City Council Special Meeting

Brisbane, CA · · More Brisbane, CA meetings · More California meetings

Transcript

Download: Text · SRT
AI TRANSCRIPT

This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.

[6:54] Council meeting in Brisbane of October 20th, 2026. We're calling the meeting to order at 5.34pm. Would you please join me in the pledge of allegiance?
[7:06] I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands.
[7:13] One nation under God, indivisible with liberty and justice.
[7:21] We have a full House of Council members tonight, a city clerk, could we have roll call please?
[7:25] Council member Davis. Council member Kern.
[7:46] This is a continuation of a public hearing, and we welcome the public to comment or ask questions during tonight's hearing. Please fill out a form to speak candid to our city clerk. There's forms on the chairs with pens, speak in the comments, and we welcome the public to comment or ask questions during tonight's hearing. Please fill out a form to speak candid to our city clerk.
[7:59] We'll have four minutes for each topic.
[8:02] There's a timer on the screen.
[8:04] You can use for reference.
[8:05] It is extremely important for speakers to stay on topic.
[8:09] If you don't stay on topic, I have to stop you.
[8:12] If a speaker continues to ignore the rules, you'll be warned.
[8:15] You may be precluded from speaking on other items tonight.
[8:20] Staff has a proposed public hearing schedule.
[8:22] Would like to have a short discussion with Council about the meetings.
[8:25] could we put up the table on the screen please?
[8:39] So just staff want to comment on this or would you like for us to just talk about it?
[8:45] The chair there, but we were hoping you would have a conversation about it.
[8:48] Okay.
[8:49] All right, let's start with the Council Member Kern.
[8:54] Thank you so much, Madam Mayor.
[8:56] I think the schedule, the proposed schedule or the hearing schedule looks pretty good.
[9:00] I'm noting that we have a special meeting reorganization on 1210, leaving us sometime earlier
[9:08] that week on 127, 128, and 129. I suggest at this time or after this meeting that we put
[9:15] a special calendar hold on one of those dates in case we needed as a contingency to keep going.
[9:21] That's my recommendation. Could you please clarify that? I'm not sure if I followed you.
[9:26] to put a hold on which dates.
[9:30] According to the slide that's up right now, the last bill
[9:32] it says we have a special meeting reorganization on 1210. Monday of that week would be 12.
[9:39] 7, 12, 8, or 12, 9. One of those dates. I'm recommending.
[9:46] Okay. Thank you.
[9:48] I'm your program Davis.
[9:52] I'm fine with the schedule. I support council member
[9:57] current suggestions to have a placelder built in before the reorganization, the only thing
[10:05] of note I see is 1117 and 1119 are so close together, you know, that's unfortunate,
[10:15] but it seems like is there reason why staff doesn't have anything the second week of November
[10:25] Is it because Veterans Day throws things off or?
[10:31] Yes, that's part of the issue.
[10:32] The Veterans Day does make things more complicated.
[10:36] Yeah. So, I mean, I think that we-
[10:38] The ninth is on there. Sorry to interrupt.
[10:41] Oh, then- oh. Sorry. I see it. Okay. Thank you.
[10:49] Yeah, I mean, I think that's the only kind of tricky situation.
[10:55] But I think that we've adjusted the schedule to try to take care of most of that
[11:01] where possible.
[11:03] So I would be fine with the proposed schedule.
[11:11] Councilmember Lens.
[11:17] Okay, yeah.
[11:18] So I'm just curious.
[11:21] So yeah, I see the, that one week that has two meetings basically back the back
[11:27] this one day in between.
[11:28] So, why couldn't we have a meeting on the 23rd, is it because of the holiday music people celebrate that at the end of the week, at the beginning?
[11:42] Would you, would you give us the monster?
[11:45] Yes, November 17th, there's a meeting and then a hearing.
[11:53] and then on 1119 we have a record of council meeting and I don't know what's on the agenda for 1119.
[12:02] It's still a bit influx.
[12:04] We are monitoring the sessions in November for the reason we're describing tonight to not overload the council.
[12:12] So right now I don't have a specific item that I would mention that could not be moved up to 19th at this point.
[12:18] So, so I mean, what I'm saying is so we could potentially not have the meeting on the 19th.
[12:29] Potentially.
[12:32] You're talking about the council meeting. Yeah, I mean, I think it's appropriate to
[12:39] to do the one meeting a week. I think it allows us to to study and to get rested from having
[12:48] these fairly intense meetings so we're you suggesting the 23rd as also in a
[12:54] time you know I was yeah so if if we said okay let's not do the meeting on the
[12:59] 17th let's do it on the 23rd and then we could have the regular council meeting on
[13:04] the 19th I would be fine with that I don't know staff will be available if I may
[13:11] can I ask a question about that sure most moments is it possible we just can't
[13:16] stop doing business here in Brisbane because of the bail-in hearings although they're
[13:19] wildly important and I understand that. Is it possible to sandwich in a mini city council
[13:24] meeting before one of these hearings be after one of these hearings if there's business that we
[13:28] need to discuss? Of course. Yes and we would do something like that if it was a number of
[13:33] consent items that were important but didn't require significant conversation with the council.
[13:37] Great thank you for clarifying that. Is there more you had to say council member Lens?
[13:44] No, yeah, I think having the best laying in the meeting, but I, oh, it's like it's already in the calendar here, that week of 12, 10.
[13:57] So.
[13:57] Okay, council member.
[13:58] If I may one more time, Madam Mayor, the special meeting cliff that you're seeing.
[14:02] No, I'm sorry.
[14:02] Yeah, I'm sorry.
[14:04] Yeah, the additional meeting.
[14:06] And, you know, typically we, we don't have a lot on the agenda, but though sometimes we do.
[14:12] So if it's just the re-ord, then I would be okay
[14:17] with having a hearing during that week.
[14:20] I'll take that.
[14:21] Makes sense, thank you.
[14:24] OK.
[14:24] Council member O'Connell.
[14:27] I'm here to put in my time until I don't.
[14:30] So whatever you guys work for you, I'll work it out.
[14:37] So I think that the proposed schedule
[14:39] During the 17th, the 18th and the 19th in a row is ambitious at best and not the most effective use of my role as a council member doing my due diligence.
[14:54] I also take issue with us talking about two dates.
[15:00] In December being called deliberations where I see absolutely nothing on the schedule that says that we're going to talk about all the issues we've brought up in all these hearings to sit and talk about that with the public.
[15:14] Who's taking the notes? Who's putting together all the points that we might want to change in the specific plan? What date is on the schedule to go over that? We've gone over measure JJ points, but there's a lot of miscellaneous things.
[15:28] I see absolutely nothing on the schedule and I take issue with us,
[15:33] saying these are the deliberations with no final discussion of the council,
[15:38] no final input on what we're thinking of changing in a specific plan.
[15:42] So that's my two cents. I don't know if my colleagues agree,
[15:46] but I would prefer to have the 23rd,
[15:50] so we don't have three meetings in a row on that one week.
[15:54] And other than that, I would like to see the December schedule indicate a meeting that is for the discussion of compilation of items for potential change to the specific plan with public input at the same meeting.
[16:12] Yeah, you know, and if, if, you know, I like to add to that too. I mean, so we have this list of
[16:18] topics, and as you're going through the hearings, new things come up. And so I think it would be appropriate to have a meeting on the various alternatives.
[16:34] I think it would be good to have a meeting on objective design guidelines.
[16:42] The ones that we have, you know, we went over there a little bit during the one hearing,
[16:48] but it, you know, it would be great to see those renderings to be able to understand what is possible
[16:58] with the objective design standards that perhaps we might want to change that.
[17:06] So, I mean, I think we should leave things open, you know, I'm just, I had a conversation
[17:12] with the police, I mean with the fire chief today and talking about public safety and I also
[17:18] had a conversation with our city engineer in regards to public safety and I think it would be
[17:24] appropriate to having hearing on public safety too.
[17:26] I mean these are big ticket items that I think we need to have a greater discussion
[17:31] on.
[17:33] So, you know, I know that we have the schedule and we're trying to get through it in the
[17:38] timely manner that we hope we would do, but you got one shot at this.
[17:43] And so I hope that we give it the due diligence that it requires.
[17:48] Madam Mayor, just a couple of quick comments to the previous comment related to the description
[17:54] as deliberations.
[17:55] It was staffs understanding that that word included what you described from the day as
[18:00] just a moment ago, an opportunity for the council to have the robust discussions based
[18:04] on materials that we're bringing back in in a rota.
[18:07] So that was the intention there.
[18:08] The intention also wasn't to put a pin at the end of it either.
[18:11] There's no suggestion here that those are the last meetings.
[18:13] It was just taking it to a certain point, and then obviously we're going to have another
[18:17] the conversation with the council, so I just want to clear that up.
[18:19] If you've closed the public hearing on the previous dates, there is no discussion with the public input.
[18:26] You've closed the public hearing. You are in deliberations.
[18:33] You don't have a quick question about that, Madam Mayor.
[18:37] So does the council have to close the public hearing in order to have deliberations?
[18:44] No.
[18:45] Okay. There's no magic definition of
[18:51] When the Council can take public comment, what it's called when the Council talks amongst themselves about what to do with all of the comments that it's received.
[19:03] I mean, that's a signature point out.
[19:04] I think staff landed on that term in the hopes that it would capture what the Council would want to do.
[19:11] But no problem at all, if you want to call it discussion, if you want to call it deliberations, no problem at all.
[19:17] There's really no, what you call it does not indicate whether or not you can continue to take public comment and it doesn't indicate what specifically you have to do.
[19:30] Okay, I just, the reason I bring that up is because there was some confusion with the planning commission.
[19:35] And so I just want to, you know, just confirm that we don't have to close the public hearing.
[19:41] And we can continue to take public comment as we're trying to figure things out in potentially
[19:49] requiring more information.
[19:53] Correct.
[19:54] You can take public comment whenever you would like to receive public comment.
[19:58] There's a little bit of caveat on there that you can't always completely limit public comment,
[20:06] but I think you'll be fine.
[20:07] And if the goal is to be able to continue to receive public input as the council is discussing
[20:14] amongst yourselves what you have learned in the past several hearings, that is fine.
[20:20] And it does not matter whether you call it deliberations or discussion, whatever, happy to
[20:25] come up with another term that works for the council.
[20:28] So long as we have not closed public hearing.
[20:36] Again, you can really take public comment whenever you would like.
[20:42] Okay.
[20:45] All right. Any other comments from Council?
[20:51] Yes. Comment in a question regarding state of the city, which is indicated in your memo on the screen.
[20:58] I'm in at brisbandca.gov. I don't see that on the calendar. That's less than a month from now.
[21:04] It's not a planning phase.
[21:08] So it's not on the calendar intentionally.
[21:10] Okay. Thank you. I heard clearly what Council Member O'Connell and Council Member Davis wanted from the schedule. I'm so sorry. I didn't understand your comments about having an additional session about.
[21:28] I'm not sure I understand that.
[21:30] I think that when we look at December, I would agree with Council Member Lance that maybe we need to not label these and just put placeholders on them.
[21:38] because otherwise we're changing the topic titles and we don't know what we're calling
[21:43] things. So I would agree also with the suggestion that he made about adding a
[21:50] discussion of alternatives. We've not discussed that at all. So can we call this
[21:55] tentative baylands meeting? Yeah, that sounds good.
[21:58] Tender to baylands meetings. I like that. All right. Any other input on
[22:06] schedule, staff, you have direction, okay.
[22:11] I'd like to also now allow Council to bring up any general questions or comments, concerns related
[22:19] to the public hearings.
[22:21] Let's start with Council Member Lens.
[22:25] Okay.
[22:27] Stephanie, if you wouldn't mind come to the podium please.
[22:30] Thank you.
[22:35] Good evening. All right, good evening. Stephanie Shakovsky again with the balance. Good evening, Mayor. Council members. Yes. Councilmember Lance. Yes. So, the first hearing asked you a question about getting the letter from the property owner, authorizing BDI to negotiate contracts and agreement. And then at the end of the last hearing, I walked over to an action
[23:02] you know, what's the status of that letter and it sounded like you were going to be able to
[23:09] get that for tonight's meeting.
[23:12] And then I talked to my attorney, okay, that a problem once we are in DNA negotiations and
[23:23] it's an appropriate question to ask about our management agreement, but at this stage since
[23:29] we're talking about zoning and specific plan.
[23:33] He deemed it not necessary for that kind of disclosure
[23:38] or document disclosure.
[23:41] So happy to once we get to the actual DNA negotiations
[23:46] where our sign off of those documents are relevant.
[23:51] Right now you're in the specific plan
[23:53] and finalizing the EIR that is the city's documents.
[23:59] you don't need to have our permission to, you know, amend to the specific plan or make changes.
[24:08] So that was the legal description. So at the appropriate time, yes, happy to share those documents.
[24:20] Okay. I might have you come back up in a little bit. I have some other questions that those are for staff.
[24:25] Okay. All right. Thank you.
[24:27] Council Member Cron?
[24:31] Just a comment as we continue to the hearings.
[24:33] I know that Council last week,
[24:36] and tonight is working from this document here showing how we're moving through the topics.
[24:41] I've had a couple of folks from the community saying it was unclear how we were moving through these.
[24:46] And I just want to make sure that we're extra clear going forward on what very specifically we're talking about.
[24:51] And when we're talking about it, that is all.
[24:53] All right.
[24:53] Thank you.
[24:57] Mayor Pro Tem Davis.
[24:58] This is just general comments not getting into grading, okay, I don't have any general comments.
[25:08] Okay, let's see, Council Member O'Connell.
[25:12] No general comments at this time.
[25:14] Okay, I have one.
[25:17] Council had requested transcripts of the first hearing so that we could be provided those like seven days after the hearings to go over the important high points.
[25:30] so we could start thinking about those, researching, making changes, potentially towards the end,
[25:36] and we've not received those.
[25:38] Could I get a status update?
[25:48] Are you looking for a verbatim transcripts, or we'd also talked about having a summary table
[25:54] and we've been working on both of those?
[25:56] No, this was a, I believe you indicated you had something from one of our consultants
[26:02] that you showed to us and that it was so that we could be able to be able to contribute to the council as meeting notes.
[26:13] So we can continue working on that.
[26:16] It is a table that we could produce and it's being continually updated.
[26:23] So yes, we can have that for a future meeting.
[26:27] And any idea when we might receive those since now we're already in the fifth hearing?
[26:36] certainly for the next hearing we could have those available because I'm just looking at the schedule and we're
[26:42] cramming a lot into November and December and I don't know when we're going to have time to go back and study all of this
[26:47] Already working seven days a week. There's no more days in the week left.
[26:53] Okay, council member questions. Council member O'Connor?
[26:59] Still none? Well,
[27:05] was my understanding that staff had agreed to do a high level list of the issues that we're
[27:12] being brought up, but not necessarily verbatim transcript. So that's what I was going to say.
[27:20] My mistake if I characterize it, it was to be the important points that were brought up as
[27:26] potential consideration for changes in the specific plan when we get towards the very end of the schedule.
[27:34] It wasn't verbatim word for word transcript.
[27:40] Thank you.
[27:41] That's it.
[27:42] Okay.
[27:45] Councilmember Kern.
[27:47] Any other general topics?
[27:48] No questions.
[27:50] Mayor Pro Tem Davis still.
[27:52] Councilmember Lens.
[27:53] Yes.
[27:55] This is a question for the city attorney.
[28:00] So.
[28:00] Yeah.
[28:01] So at the last hearing.
[28:04] Representative from BDI.
[28:06] mentioned the desire to have entitlements.
[28:11] And so my question to you is, you know, by approving the specific plan, does that grant the
[28:20] property owner entitlements, and then if it does, can the property owner submit an application
[28:29] for a permit?
[28:33] Yeah, so the specific plan would authorize, I guess the short answer is yes, the specific plan would authorize the application for additional development, specific development project applications.
[28:50] the specific plan functions, somewhere between the general plan and a zoning code, it has all of the
[28:58] land uses and development standards that are permitted along with a discussion of infrastructure, open space,
[29:07] implementation guidelines, potential financing mechanisms. Once that is adopted, then the developer
[29:16] or a developer, because it's not specific to any one entity,
[29:22] can then apply for subdivision map for the design review
[29:29] and the specific use permit if they're applying for
[29:33] conditionally permitted use, but those types of uses,
[29:39] I mean, can't come in overnight because of the amount of infrastructure
[29:43] that's required but they would be able to take the next step towards applying for
[29:51] for development. The specific plan is a legislative document. It's not a specific entitlement
[29:58] to come in and get building.
[30:00] In permits, but it is a step towards creating that regulatory frameworks that they can apply for specific developments.
[30:09] Okay, and then just as a follow-up, do you have to have a development agreement in order to move forward with applying for permits, because of the approval of the specific plan?
[30:26] Once the specific plan is in place, that someone could apply for permits?
[30:34] Okay.
[30:35] All right.
[30:37] Thank you.
[30:40] Okay.
[30:41] So, since we have no other questions, I still have a couple.
[30:47] If we approve a specific plan, do we have the ability?
[30:52] Let's say before after a development agreement to actually amend that specific plan.
[30:57] I've heard this from the public over and over and over.
[31:00] So I'm going to ask on behalf of people contacted me.
[31:05] Yes.
[31:05] The Council can amend the specific plan.
[31:09] It's again, the city is legislative document.
[31:11] You can amend the policies and procedures in it.
[31:17] We'd have to, if you were making changes, we'd have to ask whether those changes created
[31:22] new or more severe environmental impacts compared to what was already analyzed.
[31:27] If it does, then, along with those amendments, you would have to do subsequent environmental review to comply with the sequence.
[31:36] But you can amend the plan to the way that you amend other ordinances, the zoning code, as often as you'd like.
[31:45] Once there's a development agreement, the development agreement, one of the contractual provisions in a development agreement, one of the purposes of entering into a development agreement,
[31:55] is to provide vested rights and lock-in development standards, and you can, that can be one of the things that are negotiated in the connection with a development agreement as to which standards are locked in place at the time the development agreement is executed into and which ones are applied at the time a specific development goes forward.
[32:20] But so, if there were development agreement, again, it could affect the application of subsequently
[32:29] adopted amendments, depending on how the development agreement itself is word is worded,
[32:35] but without a development agreement or without any other sort of vested rights, you can amend
[32:39] the specific plan and have that be applicable, again, as often as you'd like.
[32:44] And would that amending require public hearings at the planning commission level?
[32:51] Yes.
[32:52] Because it would be the same process because it would be amending planning regulations.
[33:01] So we would have a recommendation from the planning commission and a final action by the city council.
[33:07] Okay.
[33:08] Thank you.
[33:09] The council member lines.
[33:10] Mayor Mack, can I ask one question about your question?
[33:12] Absolutely.
[33:12] Thank you. Eric, from beginning to end, so let's just say we adopt the final specific
[33:17] plan and we want to go in and amend it as the mayor was asking. Can you just give me a
[33:20] rough estimate about how long that would take from the date that the council has the idea
[33:24] through pushing it through? Because it really would depend on the type of amendment. Small amendments
[33:29] could go quickly. It's how long it takes to notice a planning commission hearing, planning commission,
[33:36] if we're changing development intensity or uses, it requires 20 day notice before they're hearing
[33:43] then their recommendation has to be included in your notice.
[33:46] There's a 10 day notice requirement before the city council acts.
[33:51] So there's lead time for both of those things.
[33:54] But then it really would come down to staff time to prepare the amendments,
[33:59] and that depends on how straightforward or complicated the amendments are.
[34:04] And then when it got to council what would be a amendment,
[34:07] it would be an amendment to your zoning regulations.
[34:10] you'd have two readings before Council and then 30 days effective.
[34:18] It depends if we were changing the zoning ordinance that enacted, the Council,
[34:22] then that would be correct. The specific plan itself will be a resolution,
[34:29] which doesn't require a second reading.
[34:32] So we're talking 90 days.
[34:36] Roughly, it sounds like.
[34:37] Okay, thank you.
[34:40] If I may follow up on that, that would include either up zoning or down zoning, the same process.
[34:51] Yes, and you could also change, it doesn't necessarily even have to affect the density and up zoning or down zoning.
[35:01] It could be wanted to modify some of the objective design standards or change the implementation procedure.
[35:10] or some of the other requirements, any of the topics that are in the specific plan could be amended.
[35:18] Thank
[35:21] you.
[35:21] Anyone else?
[35:22] Councilmember Lens, are you done?
[35:24] Do you have more?
[35:25] I have one more question.
[35:26] Okay, go ahead.
[35:27] And so, Stephanie, if you would mind, come to podium please.
[35:37] All right.
[35:38] So, you know, Mr. JJ, one of the requirements,
[35:40] is that the city, the viscally positive, throughout every phase of the development.
[35:49] Correct. Right. And so in my mind, you know, we're in that first base, basically,
[35:55] we're in the planning phase of it. And so we're at a point right now where the city has conducted
[36:06] a lot of time and ever, in creating the documents that eventually, when we pass them by the
[36:15] entitlements that you've been asking, yet the city hasn't been reimbursed for a significant
[36:23] portion of that work. So I'm sure is to know what's the issue and how are we going to get paid?
[36:35] I'm sorry I'm not part of that team that's working on the financing but I can consult with my team and get back an answer to you on that.
[36:45] Okay, so do you think that you could establish some kind of payment schedule with staff and so that we can start to be whole?
[36:55] Yeah, can I consult with our finance chief of finance and our controller who I know are looking on all of those issues?
[37:05] Okay.
[37:05] You'll be able to get that information to staff so that we have it for our next year and I'm meeting.
[37:12] I hope so.
[37:13] Let me get back to them.
[37:15] Okay, great.
[37:15] Thank you very much.
[37:19] Okay.
[37:19] I have one on the staff reports for these meetings.
[37:23] There are links to attachments about soil testing.
[37:30] And many topics. And I would like to see these included verbatim in the staff report. I think the public and the council perhaps are missing those that those are really major information that people are not seeing because it's just whole bunch of, you could assume these are references and never see the reports, because you're reading the report and you go, oh, okay, I have it all.
[37:56] So typically and Kevin, you may not know this, but in the past, sometimes we got 100, 200, 300 pages, we got all the reports printed out, and I think the public deserves to see all those reports, not just links.
[38:14] So when you save verbatim, you want the actual report attached.
[38:17] Yes, so I don't want links at the end of a report. I think you can have the reports included in the agenda packet.
[38:26] for everyone to see.
[38:29] Councilmember Lens?
[38:31] That was my last question, Madam Mayor.
[38:34] Okay, and my last one,
[38:38] we've talked about near the end of the schedule
[38:41] and who is pulling together topics
[38:44] that might be of importance to circle back
[38:47] and discuss is anyone on staff doing that?
[38:52] I know this has been brought up probably a month ago
[38:55] saying is is anybody on staff keeping track or is it going to be incumbent
[39:00] on the council to read through whatever summaries we get and start making lists
[39:07] of these are all the important topics that we intended to revisit at the end.
[39:12] Well, that's definitely part of what staff has been doing between staff and the
[39:18] consultant team.
[39:19] We've been monitoring every meeting and making as Kevin alluded to before on
[39:25] contracts that tracks each comment and notes whether there was an answer that was provided
[39:32] to the comment that time, whether it's an informational item where information will be reported
[39:40] back to Council at a future meeting, whether Council provided direction for a change to be made
[39:46] to the specific plan or whether it was a topic where further discussion is needed to get Council
[39:53] direction about whether a change would be required. So that is something that is being tracked
[40:01] in real-time and referred back to after the meetings so that we can be working on
[40:08] those change pages and additional information and keeping a list of those topics that will
[40:17] come back. I think on the schedule that Kevin had was the deliberations but further discussion
[40:23] and direction from council so that those open topics you all can provide the direction on.
[40:30] I can weather changes or need it or not.
[40:33] I think it would be important even if you did it in two stages to try to get that out earlier
[40:38] than at the very end because it takes a lot of time to absorb that.
[40:43] I think it's asking a lot also of the public at the last minute before one of those meetings
[40:49] being referred to as deliberations to read through a tsunami of questions and possible changes.
[40:58] So if it's possible, I'd like to see maybe before we get into December that at least some
[41:06] of those are released as part of the packet to one of these upcoming hearings.
[41:12] And maybe we can schedule that into the hearing that we'll start going over those.
[41:18] Sure, yeah, it's a council's pleasure.
[41:20] We'll follow that direction.
[41:22] Okay, thank you.
[41:23] You know, Madam Mayor,
[41:24] I do have a one comment to make
[41:26] I apologize for that.
[41:28] Go ahead.
[41:29] So, you know, at our last meeting,
[41:31] we gave direction to staff to do
[41:33] the peer review of the interview study.
[41:36] And so, I did finally read
[41:38] that study that was
[41:42] paid for by the applicant.
[41:45] And so in that study, it based its study on the title 24 Part 6, which is the basic standard,
[42:00] or is in the sustainability framework, it talks about using the Tier 1 standard.
[42:06] So what I hope we can give direction to staff is that when we do the peer review,
[42:12] or if we're going to do a new study, that we'd look at applying the highest standards
[42:18] and looking at the requirement in measure JJ, which is to be energy neutral.
[42:25] And then based on the requirement in measure JJ, give us options for how we could achieve
[42:33] that, or achieving, say, like you said, Madison, maybe 80% and have in 20% from other sources
[42:45] on the grid, and that we should evaluate not just the current plan, but also say alternative
[42:53] seven, how does that particular model because that seems to be an alternative that the community
[42:58] has been bringing up. How does that kind of play into the mix as well? If that's good with
[43:07] the council giving that direction to staff for the study.
[43:12] Well, that just to clarify, that's not what the study looked at the study and exactly, I think
[43:19] you're right in pointing out that the study used energy standard or building standards that are
[43:28] less demanding than the building standards that would be required, which is part of why we've been saying that that
[43:34] reports a higher energy demand than we would actually expect to see. It's a conservative number
[43:41] because the inputs assumed a lower performing energy standard that would that would be developed,
[43:50] then we will actually require and see on the ground, but again, that study that we have commissioned
[44:01] Rainbow to do a peer review of, it was just one input to the energy model,
[44:10] it doesn't,
[44:10] I guess it, that study doesn't answer the other questions that you just asked,
[44:17] That's work that the ESA and consultant team did
[44:22] and use that study as one of their inputs to develop.
[44:27] I believe, I mean, the EIR does have information
[44:31] about energy use in different alternatives.
[44:34] We can feature that a little bit more.
[44:36] I heard the comment earlier about the desire
[44:38] to have a meeting focused specifically
[44:41] on the alternatives.
[44:42] And we can talk about some of the,
[44:46] In the ways that the energy use computers across alternatives, if that would be helpful, but it's wanted to clarify that that study that we were directed to have peer reviewed, doesn't.
[45:00] This is how we look at the final end result of, is the project energy neutral or what would you have to change to make it energy neutral?
[45:15] It's just an input in terms of how much energy would these building types that are allowed by these land uses, use, assuming that they were developed under different building code standards.
[45:30] Manager JJ has a requirement to design to be energy neutral.
[45:35] I hope that the study has that focus on that requirement,
[45:40] and looking forward to the information that comes from that study.
[45:45] Thank you.
[45:47] Anyone else? General?
[45:50] Comments?
[45:51] One more general.
[45:52] Sure, I'm so sorry.
[45:54] Eric, you're on the hot seat tonight.
[45:55] So let's say that we sit down and we get a meeting to the calendar and we start talking about alternatives, it could be three, it could be seven pick one, doesn't matter.
[46:04] What is the process and timeline? Should the council say we want to choose one of the alternatives and move forward with that?
[46:11] So if you could just lay that out in the simplest of steps, that would be great. Thank you.
[46:15] So the environmental analysis that SQL requires the study of alternatives to the project.
[46:24] So we have the project right now, the project.
[46:27] The original project that was studied in the EIR was the specific plan that the developer proposed.
[46:36] Actually, the current specific plan that staff has recommended before you is analyzed as an alternative.
[46:44] in the EIR because it wasn't the project, but the SQL requires that the EIR look at a range
[46:52] of alternatives that have the potential of reducing the severity of the project's environmental
[46:58] effects and then Council gets to deliberate and decide whether those alternatives can meet
[47:07] the project objectives and select either the project or one of the alternatives.
[47:13] And you have the environmental coverage to do that under the EIR.
[47:18] If Council were to decide to approve one of the alternatives,
[47:24] that is different than the staff recommended alternative,
[47:28] you would have to also provide us direction to amend the specific plan,
[47:34] so that it can form to that right now,
[47:38] Again, the specific plan that's before you is allows for a particular development program and has particular development standards.
[47:49] If we were to pick alternative three, which has a similar program but applies different development standards to achieve it or alternative seven, which has a reduced development program.
[48:01] We would have to amend the specific plan so that it matched those alternative.
[48:08] I guess I said a man, but that's not really correct because you haven't adopted it yet.
[48:11] But we would have to update the specific plan that was before you so that you could adopt it in a way that would implement those alternatives.
[48:20] And I'd have to confer with staff in the consultant team to get an estimate on how long that would take if you wanted to adopt an alternative and see the actual specific plan components that were different than what's currently in the specific plan.
[48:48] Thank you. It also sounds like that's probably a six-month body of work right there.
[48:55] I don't want to give you an estimate that's not based on facts or I would want to talk
[49:05] to the team a little bit before coming up with a number off the cuff.
[49:10] Yeah, it wouldn't be, it wouldn't be will bring it back to you next meeting, it might be faster
[49:14] than six months, somewhere in between there, but that gives us a lot, you know, a lot of wiggle
[49:19] room to play with.
[49:21] Great.
[49:21] So we're talking months and weeks.
[49:23] That's fair.
[49:24] Thank you.
[49:25] Can you, I'm sorry, you may have said this, but at the next meeting, could you bring back an estimate?
[49:32] Yeah, we can, we will have that discussion, sure. Thanks. Anyone else?
[49:38] Okay.
[49:42] We move on to the main event. Consideration of proposed bail-and-specific plan and related actions,
[49:48] including amendments to the Brisbane General Plan, Land Use, and Circulation Oalments,
[49:52] amendments to Title Section 17 of the Brisbane Municipal Code to establish zoning regulations
[49:58] adoption of the Bayshore Mobility Plan and certification of the final environmental impact report
[50:04] prepared for this project in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act
[50:10] you know as sequo. Tonight is a continuation of the last public hearing and we continue
[50:16] with questions on remediation and phasing. We finished all questions on the first topic.
[50:23] remediation framework and responsible agencies will continue with last week's scheduled
[50:30] topics remediation and phasing starting with number two, which is site grading, soil testing
[50:38] and clean soil design. I understand that both staff and the applicant do not have any slide presentations
[50:46] questions today and when the last public hearing on October 15th was continued, some council members
[50:56] still had questions for staff on the number two topic of site grading soil testing and clean
[51:04] soil design. So members of the public while we continue with council questions, could you please
[51:13] bill out speaker slips appropriately noting the topic that you wish to speak on members of
[51:19] the public at home as usual. Please raise your hand in Zoom to be added to a speaker card
[51:25] and hope you stay on topic and remember it's four minutes allotted for comments and questions.
[51:32] So we'll start with council questions. Call on each council member, ask you to limit it to one
[51:38] question after each of you that had a turn-on go back to the order for another round of questions.
[51:45] And city clerk, do I have all the slips from the public from the past public hearing?
[51:52] Yes, they included.
[51:53] Okay.
[52:07] Okay.
[52:08] Okay.
[52:11] I believe we did public questions the last time on topic number two, did we not?
[52:18] We did them first.
[52:19] So are these the people that spoke the last time?
[52:24] Those are the people that want to speak again.
[52:27] Again? I mean, that's something.
[52:30] Again, but some are here to speak on that topic for the first time.
[52:36] OK. All right. Starting with council questions.
[52:41] Council member O'Connell.
[52:46] I just wanted to make sure on the phasing during the remediation of the phasing.
[52:51] I know that the east side is not going to be remediated until the west side is completed.
[52:59] But tunnel road, where does that fit in, is that not to be improved or designed for traffic
[53:08] until after the west side is completed?
[53:22] There would be a new version of tunnel road when the east side has part of the east side
[53:28] development, so you can assume that there may be some repairs and maintenance of tunnel road during
[53:36] the operations while the west side is being developed but the redesigned tunnel road would
[53:42] become with the development of the east side.
[53:46] Thank you.
[53:48] Okay.
[53:50] Tell us a member current.
[53:54] I was able to sneak in my question regarding clean soil at the last meeting and I don't have
[53:58] any other questions on this topic.
[53:59] Thank you.
[54:00] All right.
[54:01] Mayor Pro Tem Davis.
[54:04] So, the proposed haul route includes the Blankin, Avenue, Slush, Channel Avenue, Intersection.
[54:11] Can staff clarify whether the city of San Francisco has approved or otherwise agreed to the use of its streets for bail-ins grading trucks?
[54:23] Well, again, there is no actual whole route being approved.
[54:28] There was a conceptual whole route analyzed in the EIR
[54:32] to give an idea of impact, but as Kevin described,
[54:37] and you can go through some of the steps again,
[54:41] that there will be a construction management plan
[54:46] that needs to be approved.
[54:47] and that has the goal is to identify first how to move soil internal to the site, potentially
[54:57] crossing the tracks either over under or at grade without needing to go around. If that's
[55:06] not possible to do in cooperation with Caltrain, then at that time the city would look to a dot
[55:15] a formal hell route plan, but that is not something that's been specifically proposed or approved.
[55:24] Again, what we see in the EIR is a conceptual route that was used to model noise and air quality impacts.
[55:33] If we were to, again, be in the worst case, seeing tracks move through those streets at those times and those volumes.
[55:47] But, again, as we talked about a little bit last week, we would expect to see a different, a different combination, different smaller number of tracks over a different period of time as we were
[56:02] Seeing the actual implementation happen.
[56:08] I guess what I'm struggling with is that none of the identified options seem to be good ones.
[56:19] They all seem to have significant challenges in which another jurisdiction we're relying on another jurisdiction to cooperate.
[56:29] And I think this is a big hang up for the public because what we're saying is we're going to figure this out later, not now.
[56:39] And I think that creates a lot of, I'm looking for the right word, but it just feels like it's kicking the can down the road.
[56:54] And the public is relying on the public to just trust that it's going to sort itself out in the best way possible.
[57:04] And I think that the public is looking for assurances that there is at least some solution on the table that works.
[57:18] And what I'm seeing is that none of them feel like they work and I understand that the intensity that we're contemplating is not likely to be the intensity that we will see.
[57:36] But I think we really need to do a better job of clarifying that in some way.
[57:45] because you, if it is a worst case scenario, you have to consider that it is possible.
[57:54] And if we're saying to the public, oh, yeah, I know that it says, you know, 600 and
[57:59] some on truck round trip truck trips today, but don't worry, it won't be that.
[58:04] And it just doesn't feel like enough.
[58:08] So, you know, I don't, it's not really a direction, well it is a little bit of a direction first off to try to like this is something that is clearly going to come back and we're going to need to work through.
[58:21] But I anticipate this needs to be clarified further for this for us to feel for me to feel comfortable with approving the specific plan.
[58:31] We got to get some solution worked out even if it's our second-third or fourth choice
[58:38] You know, of course the conveyor belt is the first choice
[58:42] But if we're gonna end up landing on our third choice and we're moving truck
[58:46] We're moving loads of dirt be a trucks. It has to be a route that
[58:52] Seems reasonable.
[58:58] Councilmember Lens. You would normally be next. Would you grant me? Oh
[59:03] Because I'd like to dive tail ready for what Mayor Pro Tempset.
[59:10] So my question would be,
[59:13] where will the trucks enter the east side of the baylands?
[59:17] Is there going to be a driveway?
[59:18] Is there going to be a road installed?
[59:20] Is it at the north end of the baylands, the south end?
[59:24] Where will the trucks exit the east side of the baylands?
[59:27] Will a new driveway or road be installed?
[59:29] will be, go south on tunnel, will trucks go north on tunnel, will they go on to baby and then
[59:35] go south, where will trucks enter the west side of the baylands to deposit dirt, will
[59:40] drive way or road be installed, will that be at the north end the south end specifically?
[59:46] Where will the trucks go at the end of the day? Are they going to be stored on the baylands?
[59:51] And where would that be? Will they be prevented from heading south and using tunnel to
[59:56] going through central Brisbane and route to another city will they go to
[1:00:00] I weigh 101, and if so using what route? North to baby south to tunnel, lagoon road, east to the highway.
[1:00:07] We had a problem with Google buses, and they were given a specific route, and they chose
[1:00:15] to just be scoff laws when they wanted to and ignore it. And then we had the challenge
[1:00:21] of trying to enforce it. And we asked our friends with BDI to help us in the enforcement, and frankly
[1:00:28] we didn't get much cooperation. I was very disappointed.
[1:00:34] So we're being asked again. Same thing.
[1:00:37] And I find it appalling. I'm being asked to approve a specific plan that just says,
[1:00:45] well, we'll figure out later. They're going to go wherever they go. Oh, over 30 years,
[1:00:49] well, it'll be a little at a time. Oh, one year it might be a whole bunch and other year it might be less.
[1:00:54] Oh, and that's a lot of dirt and dust and we've had a problem with trucks going to the
[1:01:00] quarry that are not covered with tarps.
[1:01:02] Thank you, Michelle.
[1:01:03] And who's going to enforce all of this and who's going to oversee it and who's going to pay
[1:01:08] for the oversight?
[1:01:09] And I'm being asked to approve this and I have had phone calls for two weeks from the public
[1:01:18] in Brisbane going, this is unacceptable and I have to agree.
[1:01:23] And I find it appalling that we're going to figure it out later.
[1:01:29] Don't think I can approve a plan unless I see a hall route or some sort of resolution.
[1:01:35] But we had one enterprising former council member in there.
[1:01:39] Ingrid, could you put a photo up on the screen, please?
[1:01:47] And I'll just give you a preview.
[1:01:50] Angel, can you please put up the picture?
[1:01:52] We had a former mayor and council member say, please find attached a screen shot of the BDI headquarters in parking lot.
[1:02:01] Would it be possible for a ramp to be built from their parking lot from North Tunnel Road that drops straight down into the Baylands area?
[1:02:11] Also, couple that was some sort of conveyor system to move dirt.
[1:02:15] And maybe we can have a contained system where all the truckings can find
[1:02:19] To the valance property without all the multiple issues cost a row repairs noise dirt dirt rock spillage on Brisbane streets. It's seems like no brainer
[1:02:33] To give credit that just I will go in there. Okay, I'll let you do it that email and you're gonna see the photo
[1:02:42] Hopefully
[1:02:46] Was former mayor in councilmember Karen cuts get just give me one moment. Thank you.
[1:02:56] I got it angel
[1:03:02] Yes, right. That's right. That's it below that. There you go.
[1:03:10] There it is.
[1:03:13] There's Baylands development offices.
[1:03:15] There's the parking lot to the right. If you look in the lower right hand corner, there's railroad tracks.
[1:03:22] The railroad tracks are running north in this photograph. You see them disappear under the parking lot. That's the tunnel.
[1:03:28] Tunnel number four. If you're a railroad affectionado of the Cal train system.
[1:03:36] Then you see an arrow going through the parking lot down into the Baylands property.
[1:03:42] There's a little tiny corner over there.
[1:03:45] I know the railroad has an easement, but that property is owned by Sunquest, even the easement.
[1:03:51] So it seems to me where we're trying to work with Cal train on figuring out how to get dirt above their tracks or below their tracks.
[1:03:59] They shouldn't have a problem with that corner giving up a little bit of the easement to move dirt trucks down there, what does anyone else think?
[1:04:07] Staff, any comments on this? I think it's a great idea. This wasn't hard.
[1:04:14] Just to add, there is a tunnel under that parking lot where the trains go through, so the tunnel is more than 100 years old. That would be a consideration.
[1:04:24] And you know what, I would add to that, that that tunnel continues into San Francisco.
[1:04:30] And there's a highway that goes over it every day with thousands of trucks and cars.
[1:04:36] That same tunnel every single day.
[1:04:39] It's been there a hundred years.
[1:04:41] It hasn't disappeared.
[1:04:42] And I would add that some years back there were some, I can't say verbatim what happened,
[1:04:50] but there was some work done in that tunnel.
[1:04:52] that was done by either the railroad or someone was in there. It was at least over five years ago, maybe more.
[1:05:01] They did extensive work in these tunnels to shore them up, so it might be worth investigating.
[1:05:06] Because I don't think they'd allow all those cars going on to 280 and 101 to be going over a tunnel that's 100 years old if it was unsafe.
[1:05:16] If I'm not a mayor, I just wanted to say that I believe the work you're talking about was
[1:05:23] when the electrification for culture and happened and they needed to do quite a bit of work
[1:05:28] in that tunnel to be able to put their equipment through there.
[1:05:33] I know what you're talking about where they had to hang the lines.
[1:05:37] This was prior to that.
[1:05:39] In preparation, I think.
[1:05:40] But don't know, wouldn't it be worth looking into?
[1:05:46] Absolutely.
[1:05:47] You know, I think it'd be great to know.
[1:05:50] I think the idea is a solid one.
[1:05:52] Good job, Karen Cunningham.
[1:05:53] I think it's great that you came up with this.
[1:05:55] One thing you just asked any thoughts considerations
[1:05:57] is the slage, lock, building, and property
[1:06:01] a historically protected site.
[1:06:05] Yes.
[1:06:07] Thank you.
[1:06:08] Are you implying a problem?
[1:06:11] I'm just curious.
[1:06:12] I'm not implying a problem I'm saying it should be looked into.
[1:06:15] Okay.
[1:06:17] All right.
[1:06:18] You know, I would like to have the applicant come up and address this potential option.
[1:06:26] Sure.
[1:06:26] Good evening.
[1:06:27] Mayor Mackin City Council members.
[1:06:28] Again, I'm Katie Lok Sunday with the Baylands team.
[1:06:31] I really appreciate all passion around this topic.
[1:06:34] Obviously, it's a very important one.
[1:06:36] And we want to make sure we consider all options.
[1:06:38] First, before we talk about the image on the slide, I do want to reiterate that it is our preference to avoid using trucks to move dirt over the streets.
[1:06:49] We would prefer to do the conveyor or something above the tracks at grade under the tracks, and we're happy to explore other options like this.
[1:06:58] One caveat I do want to add to this image that we have on the slide, our organization does not own that parking lot, we actually lease that property to park or vehicles there.
[1:07:10] That doesn't mean we couldn't talk to property owner about some kind of access, but again, like the Caltering option there are just going to be more conversations that need to be had around finding a feasible solution for moving the soil.
[1:07:25] and to your point earlier, Mayor Mackie, and about the specific plan of one.
[1:07:30] To have some clarification there. I completely understand where you're coming from, but it's also important to remember that the specific plan is the framework that guides the future development of the balance.
[1:07:40] But it's going to be supported by many, many other supplementary documents. We have the construction quality assurance plan. We have the soil management plan, desk control plan.
[1:07:49] We're going to have the construction management plan.
[1:07:52] They're going to be many more plans that take the specific plan as their framework and then drill
[1:07:57] down in more detail around how these things are actually going to happen.
[1:08:02] And that might mean more engineering studies, collaboration with other agencies that's
[1:08:06] going to be part of this process.
[1:08:08] And of course, that's going to be a really important part of our next steps is figuring out
[1:08:13] How do we move that soil without causing harm to the community or nuisance to the community?
[1:08:20] And the EIR also, even though to your point, Mayor Potem, Davis, that the worst case scenario
[1:08:28] you don't know for sure, what's going to happen, I do want to clarify that the EIR talks
[1:08:33] about moving 2.5 million cubic yards of soil, which is essentially moving all of the soil
[1:08:40] all at once. The likelihood of that happening is very slim. It's not really feasible for development.
[1:08:47] As I mentioned in my last presentation, we will most likely start construction with the Bayshore
[1:08:52] district and we did a little back of the envelope and that would probably be about 22% of that
[1:08:59] soil that was studied for movement in the EIR. So again, we're talking about a lot less trucks
[1:09:03] if we were to go to that worst case scenario where we have to use trucks and on top of that
[1:09:08] the EIR includes several mitigation measures to ensure that we are doing everything we can
[1:09:14] to minimize emissions, minimize noise, and coordinate with the city on how these truck routes
[1:09:20] would run.
[1:09:22] Thank you.
[1:09:22] If you would mind to stay in there, Katie, because I have a question for you because
[1:09:27] So, obviously, to do something like this, to do the conveyor belt, to go underneath, requires conversation with CalTrain.
[1:09:37] And so, since our last meeting, did you reach out to CalTrain and set up a meeting to discuss, you know, doing the soil and partnership with them?
[1:09:50] So, and if you would mind providing update.
[1:09:52] or we have ongoing discussions with Caltering about this and they're following the project closely,
[1:09:57] we're not meeting with them right now as so much of the specific plan is still in flux.
[1:10:02] Once we have a better idea of where the council is headed with the specific plan,
[1:10:07] I think we can talk to them about those next steps. And again, the specific plan sets the framework
[1:10:11] for the zoning and the allowable uses on the property, and then there will be additional plans
[1:10:16] where we will have to coordinate with other agencies like Caltering, and we of course will
[1:10:21] right away, be having discussions with them about how we coordinate on this soil movement.
[1:10:25] And they're aware of our preference to go over, under or at grade with the tracks.
[1:10:31] Yeah, and I understand the issues in regards to timing.
[1:10:36] To me, it just makes sense that having conversations sooner than later.
[1:10:41] We're waiting to the end of our process.
[1:10:44] Yeah. Where we're all asking for tighter solutions and just we'll work it out later. So I just
[1:10:55] not to give you an advice, but I just think it would be helpful. At least for me, as a council member,
[1:11:01] probably the rest of the council, if we got some kind of word from Cal train about
[1:11:07] preference preferences that they might have. Yeah, we would actually really appreciate if we could
[1:11:13] to collaborate with the city and have that discussion together, I think that might be helpful for them to hear from you all in addition to us.
[1:11:19] You know, Council Member, I'm willing to do that. We have a city council member from other cities that are on the Caltering Board.
[1:11:27] I think it's appropriate for us as elected to or together.
[1:11:33] Okay, thank you.
[1:11:33] If I could add to this staff has reached up directly to Caltering on this issue, requesting additional information.
[1:11:40] So we're waiting to hear back from their federal relations person on next steps, so staff has already taken some initiatives to get some of the information directly as well.
[1:11:50] Thank you.
[1:11:52] Can some member Kern?
[1:11:59] No question.
[1:12:02] Mayor Protoam Davis.
[1:12:05] Just remaining on this.
[1:12:07] You still might thunder because I was about to bring this up.
[1:12:10] So, but I think that in that conversation eventually to be had with Caltrain, this solution
[1:12:20] should be proposed, and I would think that if it's very amenable to it, then I would suggest
[1:12:31] that maybe you discuss with the property owner purchasing the property, because I could
[1:12:39] Do you have one would not want to lease this property for several truckloads a day, or constructing
[1:12:48] a conveyor over it?
[1:12:50] I would think it would just be easier to see if there would be willing to sell it.
[1:12:56] But I have other questions related to other parts of the subject, too, item two.
[1:13:06] Okay.
[1:13:06] Do you want to ask one of your questions?
[1:13:10] So, with grading,
[1:13:14] who is responsible for verifying that the grading is performed in accordance
[1:13:18] with the approved plans and geo-technical requirements and what documentation will the
[1:13:23] city receive during grading to demonstrate that the work is performed as designed?
[1:13:33] That is part of the building inspection process and also, I mean, the grading is inspected
[1:13:39] by both public works and then also the building staff, so there are continuous inspections
[1:13:46] and those inspections are intended to ensure that the work is compliant with the approved
[1:13:52] plans.
[1:13:57] That's what I thought you would say, we're just confirming,
[1:14:09] that's it.
[1:14:11] Well, I just assumed someone else was sharing.
[1:14:13] Okay.
[1:14:13] I thought you maybe had more part of that.
[1:14:17] Consumable lens.
[1:14:18] Yes.
[1:14:19] Thank you, Madam Mayor.
[1:14:20] So as for staff, could you explain the difference
[1:14:25] between remediation requirements,
[1:14:28] say, for office commercial, as opposed to residential?
[1:14:34] And yeah, and then how does that relate
[1:14:39] then to uses data associated with residential
[1:14:45] that might not be listed in the specific plan?
[1:14:50] but still are a part of the residential neighborhood fabric.
[1:15:00] I can get this if you want Kevin. Nice to see everyone on the council again. In terms of the cleanup standards for residential versus commercial, there are basically health risk-based numbers where it looks at the exposure of a residence, as if someone is there from childhood into adulthood.
[1:15:23] so for effectively what risk assessors considered to be a lifetime, which is basically 25 to 30 years.
[1:15:32] And then the commercial exposure looks at like a five day a week exposure.
[1:15:36] So the cleanup standards are different.
[1:15:38] But typically when you're looking at what I would call sensitive uses, which I think is maybe what you're going to count on.
[1:15:44] Well, all of them, I mean, you need living there as a sensitive.
[1:15:46] Yeah, so living there as considered sensitive use.
[1:15:49] And there's residential screening levels that look at what they call a reasonable maximum.
[1:15:53] exposure for residents, for a resident living there starting as a child and going into adulthood.
[1:16:01] And then those teams standards are typically applied if it's, let's say, a child care center
[1:16:06] or school or other sensitive type uses where you would, let's say, want to be more health protective.
[1:16:15] And then the commercial numbers look at things like a five day a week, 250 day a year exposure
[1:16:21] for 25 years is a typical commercial exposure.
[1:16:26] And so those are the cleanup levels, but in many ways a lot of the general areas are going
[1:16:33] to be covered and the covering with a cap with a very thick soil cap generally cuts off the
[1:16:38] exposure pathways to things like the metals and soil.
[1:16:42] So that the cover of the cap is protective whether it's a resident or a commercial exposure.
[1:16:51] So what's the difference I'm trying to understand like okay, you know, on the west side you have commercial development and then there's a road Main Street or maybe it's not Main Street, but yeah it is Main Street right so south of Main Street is commercial north of Main Street is residential which the difference in how each side of the street is remediated so the if there's particular hot spots.
[1:17:19] Let's say in the, there's a VOC chlorinated solvent area that's going to be excavated.
[1:17:27] So in that area, it would be excavated to meet the criterion that's relevant for that particular area.
[1:17:34] But if you're talking about like the general, overall part of the Bay of Lands, it's going to be capped.
[1:17:40] They'll both have the same type of cap that will allow for unrestricted use in terms of whether it's a residential,
[1:17:48] or a sensitive use or even a commercial use?
[1:17:51] Yes, I think.
[1:17:53] And Michelle can correct me.
[1:17:55] I'll ask you to correct me if I don't say this correctly,
[1:17:57] but I think what that means is a practical matter.
[1:18:01] My understanding is that everything on the west side
[1:18:04] will effectively be remediated to the same standard
[1:18:08] because of the treatment that Michelle is describing.
[1:18:11] The end result is going to be a consistent standard
[1:18:16] that allows for ground level, residential, and supportive uses, parks,
[1:18:23] daycares, et cetera.
[1:18:25] It's not necessarily true in every project, but here, because of the remediation techniques
[1:18:31] that Michelle was describing in the capping, everything to the west side will be at the
[1:18:37] same standard.
[1:18:40] Is that?
[1:18:41] Yeah, in terms of the socket, but there is, like, for example, I know there's been
[1:18:46] And some of the community members brought up the area where former staff or chemical operated.
[1:18:53] And that's in that little industrial area.
[1:18:56] That area upon building demolitions going to be sampled and characterized prior to any
[1:19:01] development.
[1:19:02] And so I'm just going to do a hypothetical, let's say there's some hotspot that weren't
[1:19:07] specific remediation, and that remediation would be to the cleanup standard that would
[1:19:12] either residential or commercial depending on the land use in the area, but then overall there's
[1:19:17] going to be this capping and the capping provides, let's call it uniform protective, which is
[1:19:22] what I think we refer to there. Okay, just to get clarification, so what you're saying is that
[1:19:27] everything on the west side will be remediated to the standard that is required for residential.
[1:19:37] Effectively with the cap. Yes. Okay, so could you just confirm that Stephanie at the podium, please?
[1:19:47] Yes. Michelle, let's correct, and Eric is correct.
[1:19:50] And you are correct. I can't remember. The cleanup that is proposed, which is the five foot clean fill on top across across the entire west side is protective, fully protective.
[1:20:05] and you can, and we, for both the residential and the, and the commercial. So there's no difference.
[1:20:13] I think what you're describing, Michelle was describing is that there is often a difference
[1:20:17] in the cleanup levels between residential and commercial.
[1:20:21] Our, our remediation plans, it is not because of the cap.
[1:20:25] But Michelle was describing is certain cleanups before the cap goes on, which we may be,
[1:20:32] But the clean cap, that five-foot clean cap protects, it's protective for both ground floor
[1:20:41] residential use and for commercial uses too.
[1:20:44] So there's no bottom line, there's no difference between commercial and residential on
[1:20:48] R and on the rail yard sign.
[1:20:52] No.
[1:20:52] Okay, that makes sense.
[1:20:54] Yeah.
[1:20:55] I appreciate the clarification.
[1:20:59] Okay.
[1:21:00] Council Member O'Connell.
[1:21:03] So it was stated that there's going to be a lot of, when the great actual grading and
[1:21:08] remediation is happening, there will be a lot of responsibility on the city and
[1:21:14] other environmental agencies to be testing and inspecting and watching over this.
[1:21:24] Seeing how this developer has shown, they are not meeting the city's expectations
[1:21:30] with payments of their existing services that they've been
[1:21:35] availing of the city being close to $7 million behind in payments.
[1:21:43] How will we be able to ensure that payment will be on going during this
[1:21:51] this grading and remediation and how will that be affecting how we can keep an eye on it
[1:22:02] without going out of pocket by millions and millions more.
[1:22:13] I think that's a question for the developer.
[1:22:18] Stephanie, if you can.
[1:22:39] I think that we've talked about this a lot at the Planning Commission about the associations that are formed with each chunk of development, then those associations, become responsible, they are the financial responsible tool for providing the insurance, providing the financial assurances,
[1:23:00] Serapoint, there's a, something called spima,
[1:23:04] the Serapoint Environmental Management Association.
[1:23:07] Funds are collected through the actual building owners.
[1:23:13] It's de-respected, they don't get out of this.
[1:23:16] It's in perpetuity.
[1:23:17] Funds are paid into that association,
[1:23:20] that association then pays for all of the environmental,
[1:23:25] and I'll continue to environmental commitments on the property.
[1:23:33] So that's one tool.
[1:23:35] Also, we have a lot of financial assurances that the regulators require of us to make sure
[1:23:41] that the revision gets done.
[1:23:44] Sometimes that's a bonding, or often what we've used at Schleig is insurance policies,
[1:23:50] to make sure that, you know, the payments that if there is additional, if there are additional clean-ups and needs that those are covered.
[1:23:59] So, so, there's many, many mechanisms to make sure that, yeah.
[1:24:04] So, I think this is, sorry, I don't mean interrupt.
[1:24:08] It's me.
[1:24:09] I think this might be a little different than the question that Council Member O'Connell is offering.
[1:24:15] And I think perhaps we let you off the hook a little bit here while you check with your,
[1:24:19] so that you have some time to check with your team.
[1:24:22] The city has a reimbursement agreement in place with BDI
[1:24:26] and there is a gap in the payments
[1:24:31] that the city has received pursing it to that agreement.
[1:24:35] We are in touch with BDI about that.
[1:24:40] And so I think that might have been Council Member O'Connell's question.
[1:24:45] I don't mean to step on your question, Council Member O'Connell,
[1:24:48] But my question was that in the big picture of the cities in the baby steps phase of overseeing what may get built when we're actually in the phase of what does get built or graded and how we can protect ourselves financially along with protecting ourselves for what the end product may be.
[1:25:16] How can we do that when we can't get the bills paid?
[1:25:23] Was my question and part of this is going to go into the financial responsibilities and I'm not talking about after they've sold off their piece of land or sold it to someone to or given
[1:25:38] forward their development rights. I'm talking about in the clean up in the grading portion
[1:25:44] and the infrastructure portion where the city can be assured of having the oversight
[1:25:51] and the financial wherewithal to be whole during that process.
[1:25:59] And in terms of actually installing a lot of the infrastructure as the subdivisions, subdivision
[1:26:06] maps are approved, before getting any final map, the city would require subdivision improvement
[1:26:12] agreements and payment and performance bonds and other sort of financial surety to make
[1:26:18] sure that the work was able to be performed for those those public improvements and that
[1:26:25] it was adequately covered there and then there's also just as permits are applied for the
[1:26:36] the city charges for inspections, for permit issuance fees, and that's in some ways a pay
[1:26:43] as you go service model in addition to this.
[1:26:46] That's what we have now.
[1:26:48] But we'll talk about that when we get to the finance.
[1:26:51] Thank you.
[1:26:52] And Councilmember, I did promise I would get back to you on that question.
[1:26:56] And I do know that there is some outstanding bills.
[1:26:58] I don't think any of those outstanding bills are for city staff.
[1:27:02] I think it's for outside consultants and there's some questions about whether or not.
[1:27:06] with our money we've paid.
[1:27:10] Understand.
[1:27:10] Understand.
[1:27:11] But I was just making the distinction.
[1:27:12] And we will get back to you.
[1:27:13] We'll get to that when we get to the financing.
[1:27:19] Thank you.
[1:27:20] So earlier,
[1:27:25] Mayor Protem Davis asked a question about who oversees grading and Kevin your response was that there are continuous inspections.
[1:27:32] And I would like to call on someone sitting in the audience that the Council has utilized, as a consultant, who's a former city manager, Robin Lighter, could you come to the podium?
[1:27:45] Because I think you have experience in this and you could answer the question.
[1:27:50] So continuous inspections, and anyone who doesn't know Robin, she was city manager during the Northeast Ridge development.
[1:27:56] And when we talk about continuous inspections which you were asking what assurances and how often does that happen, how did you handle that?
[1:28:07] We had the developer do a couple things. One is a deposit account, so we always had money from them and if the money stopped so did the work.
[1:28:18] But we had a really very big company with a lot of financial capacity, so I did not really have problems along that line.
[1:28:26] we also hired full-time inspectors and charged them to the developer.
[1:28:32] So how often was the property being inspected as it was graded?
[1:28:37] Was it what? Well, I don't think we did a perfect job.
[1:28:40] You know, so I think we did do the inspections. I think we could have even done a better job.
[1:28:45] So I don't want to hold us out as some perfect things. I think some things didn't get
[1:28:51] infected as well, but that you have to have really a good staff of inspectors that you
[1:29:00] hire as consultants to do the work and very often retired people are excellent for
[1:29:05] this role that retired from major cities.
[1:29:08] Thank you.
[1:29:08] Okay, so they're hired not as our regular building inspectors who go on site, but they're not,
[1:29:14] they're actually in their only job is to do that, I'm sorry, I didn't mean to speak over
[1:29:19] you.
[1:29:20] No, no, no, that's all right.
[1:29:21] Thank you very much. I appreciate it. Okay. Other questions on this topic? Do we still have
[1:29:29] I believe Mayor Prochem? You have some questions. Let's just start with you. So I had a bunch
[1:29:37] of other haul route questions and I feel like the responses are going to be along the lines of
[1:29:45] kind of, you know, we'll figure it out, we'll figure it out, we'll figure it out. I'm
[1:29:51] wondering, clearly there's been modeling done about to estimate what's going to happen,
[1:29:59] You know, with
[1:30:00] Feeling, and with emergency access and the EIR talks about all of these potential impacts that 600, some odd trucks today, or almost 700 round trips today would have.
[1:30:13] Now I understand that that's assuming worst case scenario, but again, like I said prior, that's all that we in the public have to go off of them when you look at that, it's like an immediate no.
[1:30:25] So, wondering if we can get some kind of modeling study, whatever, that analyzes what we
[1:30:33] deemed to be the realistic schedule, because I think that we need to know what is possible
[1:30:43] and to say that it's going to be potentially 20, more like 22 percent of that, well, then
[1:30:49] want to analyze what happens at 22%. How many truck trips today is that? Is emergency vehicle
[1:30:59] access impacted? How does the killing look? So that I can know, okay, well if we've really had
[1:31:08] to rely on trucks and we could have no partnership with Cal Training and we could have no conveyor belt
[1:31:14] and we could have no access through this, like parking lot.
[1:31:17] And all of these things, and it really had to be solely on trucks
[1:31:20] with the longest route possible.
[1:31:23] What then are we really looking at?
[1:31:25] Because I think that the public is not going to accept
[1:31:30] the worst case scenario.
[1:31:33] And if we're saying, hey, it won't even be that.
[1:31:35] Well, let's really analyze, well, what really could it be then?
[1:31:40] So we know, and that the public knows.
[1:31:43] So is it possible, and I don't know, you know, there are some questions that would need
[1:31:49] to be answered right to do that analysis, I imagine, but can we come up with something
[1:31:58] even if it's not incredibly accurate of, you know, we're predicting the future, but I think
[1:32:03] it's got to be a lot more accurate than are you talking about or are you talking about
[1:32:08] getting an estimation of what the truck traffic would be, would look like with the
[1:32:15] phasing that is being put into the specific plan. Is this something we could write
[1:32:21] into the specific plan as phasing that we do in the past?
[1:32:28] Potentially that's one way to do it. I'm just looking at an overall analysis. Like Katie said,
[1:32:33] you know, this is going to happen over several several years and the EIR evaluates it
[1:32:39] happening over three. So if we're going to look at a longer or two, okay, if we're going
[1:32:45] to look at it over a longer timeframe, what is it 10, 15, 20, 20, then can we just see what
[1:32:52] an analysis would be on 20? And then what we do with that information, how we put that into
[1:33:01] the Pacific planet, something else, but I just, if it's not going to be done in two years and
[1:33:07] everyone feels like that's unrealistic, then can we evaluate what it would look like if done
[1:33:12] over even in steps, if done over 10, if done over 15, if done over 20, done over 10, it looks like
[1:33:18] this, done over 15, it looks like this, done over 20, it looks like this,
[1:33:25] so you're asking for a
[1:33:29] worst case scenario. That's why I'm here. Yeah, I'm asking for different, to just look at different
[1:33:37] different options. We know what the worst is, right? The worst is two years. And everyone's saying,
[1:33:41] well, the worst is not going to happen. Well, what would the best and the medium look like?
[1:33:48] You know, Madison, you know, as you're saying this, it makes me think, okay, what does one day look like?
[1:33:57] Right? You know, how many trips would you allow in a day? And how would you do the oversight
[1:34:08] for ensuring that the routes that the trucks take are safe? Right? That then only allowing a certain amount on the bridge
[1:34:21] at a certain time. If that is the route that we go, right? I mean, I think just having an
[1:34:27] understanding of how you mitigate a day and then you apply that because we don't have a crystal
[1:34:35] ball. We don't know how long that particular phase of development is going to occur. But we
[1:34:41] know what the impacts of a day of truck hauling is going to be and how do we reduce that impact
[1:34:49] on the community to the least impactful as possible.
[1:34:55] And so I don't know, I mean, do we have something like that in our specific plan?
[1:35:00] Because I don't think I've seen anything in regards to that matter.
[1:35:06] No, that's not something that currently exists.
[1:35:08] Okay, but we could put it in that contract.
[1:35:12] Sure.
[1:35:14] So I have a couple of thoughts on this.
[1:35:15] It's a suggestion because this is the kind of thing that could be covered in the development
[1:35:23] agreement.
[1:35:24] I think the city can set the parameters of hauling and can decide exactly these kinds
[1:35:33] of questions.
[1:35:33] The hauling hours, how much has done at a time, are you going to do everything in two years
[1:35:40] or is it going to be over time?
[1:35:43] All of these kinds of things.
[1:35:45] Now, clearly, there's interest in this being sooner than later, so a suggestion would be
[1:35:51] to be working on a construction management plan or the framework of such a plan, knowing
[1:35:57] ultimately it will find its way into the DA, but this is something you want to learn about sooner
[1:36:02] than later. And it's iterative, because on the one hand, there are the questions of what if it's
[1:36:09] 10 years or 15 years, that's going to inform. But at the same time, the city can provide
[1:36:16] performance standards of what it finds agreeable should the truck routing is truck hauling
[1:36:24] come into play. It also, it doesn't change the policy direction, which is that the truck hauling is
[1:36:31] the kind of last choice. But these are the kinds of very particular terms that can be put in the
[1:36:38] we're not ready for the DA yet, but the framework of this particularly this topic can be looked
[1:36:47] at sooner or later.
[1:36:51] If I may, I'm not assured there will ever be a DA, but I know that there will be a specific
[1:36:59] plan.
[1:37:00] So I would say that this needs to be put into the specific plan and not in the DA if it's
[1:37:07] in the specific plan we need to have specific grading regulations in our general plan and
[1:37:15] our ordinances to make sure that we are not put under the gun and whether that needs to come back
[1:37:21] as an ordinance, a construction ordinance, in conjunction with the specific plan or as a separate entity.
[1:37:30] E, that should be done before we get a specific plan, because who knows if we'll ever get a DA?
[1:37:44] Council member, Mayor Potem, sorry, just to get back to the answer to my question.
[1:37:49] Is it possible to get some more multi-layered analysis of different scenarios?
[1:37:55] I think we could figure out what to do with that information later, but I just, I just think
[1:37:59] we need to analyze more than the worst case, and I know that's just what the EIR is required
[1:38:04] do you want to know what's the absolute worst case scenario and now we know that and it's terrible so
[1:38:10] can we just get some analysis of other things and I think having that information then informs
[1:38:17] what we would do we may look at the 20 year and be like oh yeah this is the only acceptable thing
[1:38:22] that works and if you can't work out a conveyor belt or whatever then this is how long this is
[1:38:27] have to take. So I think that that information really would be the core of decision-making that we
[1:38:36] would need to, you know, it would be at the core of our decision-making for how we would approach
[1:38:40] this in this specific plan or a construction, you know, some other kind of grading plan or what
[1:38:46] have you, but I think we need some more broader analysis. And I don't know who does that if we
[1:38:57] And this developer has, yep,
[1:39:04] yeah.
[1:39:05] Our engineers, BKF, have done a lot of the analysis
[1:39:08] on how much soil is needed on the west side,
[1:39:12] and they've done it by phases.
[1:39:14] So they've done how much is needed for the base shore.
[1:39:16] It's getting discussed earlier, 2022%,
[1:39:19] which is basically about 0.5 million cubic yards for base shore.
[1:39:23] But they've got numbers for each of the districts.
[1:39:26] So we can share those numbers with you.
[1:39:29] and then the math on, you know, how much soil that is and how many
[1:39:33] truckloads it is and depending upon how many work days you have and how much time,
[1:39:38] you know, depending upon your, so there's a lot of variables that go into it.
[1:39:42] So depending upon how much time you have to move this while if you, you know,
[1:39:47] if you're not hurry and you need to move it in six months, that's a certain number of truck trips.
[1:39:51] If you can do it more solely over a year period, that's less truck trips.
[1:39:56] Again, we're still talking about truck trips in the worst case scenario.
[1:39:59] But I think the phasing that we laid out for you last week in the way that we've been thinking about the projects is sort of north to south
[1:40:06] You know two to three different phases there so so you know the truck traffic is is a lot less than what the EIR as we explain the EIR looked at
[1:40:19] Moving all of the soil that's for the 670 truck loads a day came from the reality is it'll be a much smaller number if we have to use the truck
[1:40:29] again we just want to reiterate we don't want to use the trucks either we don't want to use the
[1:40:33] streets but we still have work to do and you know figuring out how best to move it across that
[1:40:40] railroad track. We'd like to keep it on our site for a lot of reasons. So you're announced
[1:40:45] it like you're what we can see analysis that you have right we'll say okay for this phase you need
[1:40:50] this much this kind of cubic yards so are you saying that the analysis has been done for the ripple
[1:40:57] effect of all that, or that would need to be done with translating a truck trips and we have
[1:41:01] the soil amount. Okay. We have not done, but to calculate, I mean that's a pretty simple basic
[1:41:07] map to calculate how many truck loads you would need over how much time to bring it across the
[1:41:12] to the site. So is that something you're offering to analyze or is there just going to give you?
[1:41:16] No, no, we can, we can provide that to staff on the phase by phase basis.
[1:41:24] Well, so when I'm hearing phase by phase, you're going to say, okay, for the base short district,
[1:41:27] this is what we think in terms of volume and time and then you'll move on to Brown House
[1:41:32] ice hill and you'll break it down that way just the way Katie broke down the sequencing.
[1:41:36] Yes, yes at the last meeting and we can do that for the soil and the soil movement and we can
[1:41:41] provide that. When? Well, I think what we can commit to is I don't know if you want to
[1:41:57] information and the data with the city staff. But we could probably put something like that
[1:42:03] together by the next media. Yeah, so if I, you know, what I'm looking for, and some of
[1:42:10] that Kevin mentioned, I'm looking for a performance standard. Right. So how do we apply a performance
[1:42:18] standard that reduces the environmental impacts right if the truck route option is what
[1:42:27] we have to do right and then also how do we produce the safety concerns right with emergency
[1:42:35] access so there's there's got to be some kind of formula that I think would be appropriate
[1:42:41] Yeah, then we could put into the specific plan, not the development agreement because to me development agreements are an agreement that you, you know, the city wants some amenities and you want some assurances.
[1:42:55] That isn't what we're talking about here. We're talking about health and safety and environmental impact.
[1:43:01] And what I'm talking about is providing city staff and the council with sort of the face of movement.
[1:43:07] What you're talking about and what Kevin is talking about is that next sort of performance standard for how the stuff has moved on city streets if it's moved on city streets
[1:43:16] If it's a separate document. Yes, yeah, I think we need that absolutely need it
[1:43:21] I hope we need it before we make decisions
[1:43:23] So hopefully, you know we can get that analysis sometime okay during this hearing process and and per area or per phase
[1:43:32] it should account for if it's so many truck trips to move this amount of soil. How many would you
[1:43:38] envision doing per day? And how would you do that with the queueing? So, yeah, what does that look like?
[1:43:45] I think, isn't that what you're asking for? Yeah, exactly. And I was, and I would say, you know,
[1:43:51] to if we're then putting some language in this specific plan, then we may say, okay, your maximum amount
[1:43:58] 100 a day, or your maximum amount is whatever. And so that we know that we have to have something
[1:44:06] some target or some limit that we can then regulate around. And I think that provides
[1:44:14] the public more comfort, even though 100 trips a day sounds terrible also, but it would say in the
[1:44:20] worst case, in the worst case scenario. But that would be instead of over two years, that would be
[1:44:27] every day for several years, many years.
[1:44:31] Who knows?
[1:44:32] So, while, you know, six, seven hundred and an intensity of two years,
[1:44:37] while at least after two years, it's over.
[1:44:39] But then you're thinking that long term,
[1:44:43] like just clogging in the streets,
[1:44:45] and while it might not be as bad,
[1:44:47] it's still much more, it's more constant and ongoing.
[1:44:51] So, but I think at least in the public could know,
[1:44:54] Okay, this is what, the floor, the maxes and,
[1:45:01] We know what to expect with that. Okay. We can get the information to city and how much we can bring back at the next meeting.
[1:45:12] Can you do it in a presentation?
[1:45:14] Yeah, that would be great. Not just like a staff report, but can you can be present?
[1:45:18] Yeah. With a map, something illustrating how you would do the queueing. If you have a staging area where you would do that to avoid backed up queueing,
[1:45:28] to envision that looking like, I think that's what everybody's asking for, isn't it?
[1:45:33] Yes.
[1:45:35] Well, you're asking for something that's very detailed and down the road.
[1:45:38] That's when I want to be careful that what we're going to be presenting is we're talking
[1:45:42] still conceptual about what we're talking about.
[1:45:44] I just need to really know Trucks a Day is my big thing, Anderson.
[1:45:49] And how many Trucks a Day and for how long?
[1:45:53] And then all the other fine details.
[1:45:54] hours of operation anticipated all those performance yes that's you know we're getting into the
[1:46:00] what in the how here I think we're going to ask we're going to put forth more of the what in the
[1:46:07] performance standard should be coming from the council right right so we just need that data so
[1:46:13] let's focus on the what I think okay thank you council member O'Connell I don't know that you really
[1:46:21] got enough to need to ask a question you did you have another question you'd like to ask
[1:46:28] because you're up no not at the moment i think i'd rather hear from the public i i almost
[1:46:35] feel we've gotten tonight especially we've gotten a little bit more into discussions than
[1:46:43] necessarily just questions and asking for the staff's input but again i i'm good for now
[1:46:50] Okay, we're almost there.
[1:46:51] Councilmember Lens?
[1:46:53] Yeah, you know, yeah, I was mentioned tonight
[1:46:58] that the developer as well as staff
[1:47:01] is not going to provide the visuals.
[1:47:05] So, you know, we talked about having visuals
[1:47:07] for the various stages of grading
[1:47:09] and how that all looks.
[1:47:11] So, we have these, you know, expectations of,
[1:47:15] well, expectations of what to expect
[1:47:17] on how it looks to us during the various stages of the remediation.
[1:47:25] So, are we going to get that next hearing?
[1:47:29] So, this is really for both developer and for staff.
[1:47:42] You want to, yeah, it's one of the railroads that you're wanting to see.
[1:47:46] Excuse me, Kevin?
[1:47:47] The railroads, the railyard cut and fill map.
[1:47:50] Um, you know, we do have that ready to do.
[1:47:53] Yeah, you know, what I'd like to see, or like maybe some AI generated, something that looks, like if you're driving on Bayshore, this is what you're going to see.
[1:48:04] If you're living at the Northeast Ridge and you're looking down upon the development, this is what you're going to see.
[1:48:12] You know, as having an understanding of of these different layers, these different levels of of grading.
[1:48:18] I mean, some of these grading requirements on the west side are going to be significantly
[1:48:27] high.
[1:48:28] And so how does that relate as you're going from the west down to the tracks?
[1:48:34] And then, you know, a comment that you had made, Council Member McConnell in regards to
[1:48:40] Caltrane.
[1:48:42] And so, is Caltrane going to be in a trot?
[1:48:44] So it's just like is really good to get that understanding of the lay of the land.
[1:48:51] Can so can we do some AI visuals that that show that or even like I don't even know even I would even
[1:48:58] take like more basic you know 10 feet whatever and then little building versus like something really
[1:49:07] But I just need to stop a graphic man.
[1:49:11] Question, question to understand, why does this need to be AI?
[1:49:14] Why cannot not just be elevation?
[1:49:16] Innovation models.
[1:49:19] I'm looking at using tools that help us as counsel and also the public to get a better understanding
[1:49:28] of what it looks like.
[1:49:30] Sometimes when you're looking at, say, a model that's just some lines.
[1:49:35] and you know, it's hard to visualize what that will look like as opposed if you see a photograph.
[1:49:42] Now granted, it's not a real photograph. It's AI-generated. But it looks, it will look fairly close to what you will expect to see once the word commences.
[1:49:54] So, are there any else there's the aesthetics chapter of the EIR has 18 photo simulations?
[1:50:05] I don't know if if those are not views that are helpful or if you had something a different tool in mind page.
[1:50:16] That's in the EIR.
[1:50:18] Okay, so what, let's see, so, I mean, we're here alive, so if you wouldn't mind providing that information tonight,
[1:50:32] and then emailing that to the council so that we then have an easy link to find it as well.
[1:50:40] Sure, and just for reference, it's the aesthetics and visual resources chapter, it's 4.5 of the EIR, and figure 4.5, 2 shows the locations of the 18 or so visual simulations and the different views.
[1:50:58] And then they do show their, they're somewhat crude.
[1:51:02] They're not, but they do show visual before and after
[1:51:08] with the development as it's created.
[1:51:11] I'm not sure that's exactly what it is you're looking for,
[1:51:14] but it would be good to know what those don't show
[1:51:17] that you're interested in so that we can figure out what to produce.
[1:51:21] Yeah, that would be helpful.
[1:51:22] Yeah, you know, perhaps you could have shown this tonight.
[1:51:27] And then I can, or would you could say, oh, that's fine, but it isn't exactly what we're looking for.
[1:51:36] A couple of things. I am requesting our, uh,
[1:51:40] Inzola, or the, uh, who's running tech. We do have that rail yard cut fill map, uh,
[1:51:46] which I was referencing, so we can show that.
[1:51:49] Another couple of suggestions would be, there are different ways of showing how the grading would work.
[1:51:56] This is one, I don't know if this is, that's not really helpful.
[1:52:02] So we're trying to work with you.
[1:52:05] I hope this isn't what you were thinking was okay.
[1:52:09] No.
[1:52:09] No.
[1:52:10] Let me finish talking, please.
[1:52:13] Sorry, we're trying to work with you.
[1:52:14] You're right.
[1:52:16] We are trying to work with you.
[1:52:17] So we could do a section drawing, which at least shows like where is the railroad, where is the final grade, where the roads that is
[1:52:30] This is too dimensional, but at least it would give you a sense of where the elevations are. And that's pretty straightforward, engineering firm could do that.
[1:52:39] If you're looking for more visuals in terms of renderings or kind of illustrative, that is something different, it's possible. So if this is the consensus of the council to have more of these visuals, we just need to know what you're looking for.
[1:52:56] are you looking for something engineering-wise such as a section drawing or are you looking for
[1:53:03] something illustrative or are you looking for both and then we can find the right people to do
[1:53:07] this.
[1:53:08] Thank you, Kevin.
[1:53:10] I think we can.
[1:53:10] The council please just have a look at the EIR pages.
[1:53:13] It's 4.5.
[1:53:15] They have, I'll show Madison since she's sitting right here.
[1:53:18] They do have existing views, and then mocked up views, they're not three-dimensional, but
[1:53:26] have them in the EIR. This would be a good place to start with our requirements before Kevin
[1:53:32] starts heading down a path, trying to do some kind of design, I think.
[1:53:38] I think part of what is difficult to envision is where we're on the edge of that west side
[1:53:45] development and how much higher is everything from the real road tracks. I can't tell anyone,
[1:53:51] I'm not sure either and I've looked at a lot of pages. It's just not clear. I don't know if it's
[1:53:56] same all the way across or if it varies is it I think 10 feet 15 20 feet I have no idea
[1:54:05] yeah madam madam when you look at the specific plan figure 6.3.11 right it shows the
[1:54:13] front frontied road and you know it's got got calmering at the same elevation it's low road it's just
[1:54:22] Sorry. It has the same elevation as the road. So if is that how it's going to be?
[1:54:30] No, we discuss this a few weeks ago and recognize that is not how it's going to be. So that would be a good example
[1:54:37] of a section drawing where we would show it's probably eight to twelve feet higher
[1:54:42] than the front of the road there. So that would be a way that this could be depicted. Again,
[1:54:48] that's a two-dimensional drawing, so that can be helpful.
[1:54:53] But again, we're looking to see what exactly are you looking for.
[1:54:56] So the reason for their request is to get a better understanding
[1:55:01] of what this development is going to look like in the various stages.
[1:55:05] It's not to have a disagreement or ask you to go out and do something
[1:55:13] that maybe is kind of a pain in the ass.
[1:55:15] Right, this is helpful for us and for the public to understand how it's going to look in the various stages and
[1:55:23] These renderings are not, you know, cutting the mustard. Right, so that's why we're asking for it
[1:55:32] Just put it out
[1:55:34] seven
[1:55:36] May I and can I can you put this slide back on if you may and I know before you grow
[1:55:43] I do want to, because I think that's how I answer some of the questions and this is what
[1:55:49] we call it, this is the amount of soil that will be, and it's color-coded.
[1:56:00] So the dark part of the grain, you can see the legend.
[1:56:05] It goes from basically zero, and that is the lightest color, meaning, so just for an example.
[1:56:15] If you look at the map, and it comes from a remote tunnel because you were very astute and noticing,
[1:56:22] as soon as you saw the drone, that the cow train plaza was right at the cow train track, and that is correct.
[1:56:28] You'll see right now the caltrain, that whole area to the north there would, all those
[1:56:37] lighter colors, those are at grade.
[1:56:40] So the caltrain track is at grade with the caltrain station, nearly at grade, it's about
[1:56:46] a foot and a half lower, but you won't be able to notice that difference once the platform
[1:56:52] goes in. So it was very, a suit observation and the answer to the question is, it is at grade
[1:57:01] at that section. But how do you put a five foot cap to cover up your hazardous waste?
[1:57:08] So in certain areas you'll see we will actually have to dig out to five feet to put the clean
[1:57:15] cap in. Okay, so everything this entire development is going to be sloped very massively going
[1:57:22] from No no no no no these are elevations this is a cut and fill so this is how much
[1:57:31] fill we're bringing in so the rail yard site right now if you can think of it as sort of
[1:57:36] a oblong bowl where it it's it's it's shallowest in the center that the dark green the dark
[1:57:45] greens is where the the the most fill has to come in it's shallowest in the center of the
[1:57:50] And then it, and then just the way it was built out, it came to grade
[1:57:55] at a long base shore there.
[1:57:57] We see the lighter colors, so it gets less screen around base shore
[1:58:01] and less screen around the counter-intracts on the whole north side.
[1:58:05] That's just how the site was sort of graded and built out over the years.
[1:58:11] So it's a great idea.
[1:58:11] And then it's great, everything will be basically at the same.
[1:58:15] Okay, so you're going to cut and fill.
[1:58:17] What are you doing with the cut?
[1:58:20] With this stuff that we're digging out, I mean it'll be tested and reused on site if it can be or it'll be removed if it's contaminated.
[1:58:30] So again, this is a constant question about base shore and you know, is it heavy-led contaminated and what not all that has been tested?
[1:58:37] There are some hotspots on the lead if it's too high to be reused, it'll be held off. That's how it works.
[1:58:44] Yeah. So, the Schleglopsite was that remediated to ground level residential standards or podium.
[1:59:02] In the north, it is.
[1:59:04] No, no, no, I'm sorry.
[1:59:07] Shleg is actually divided into two operating units, so in the Northam closer to the office building,
[1:59:15] there's no requirement for a vapor mitigation system.
[1:59:21] The heavier contaminations in the south end of the Shleg lock, and any kind of residential
[1:59:25] does have to have a vapor mitigation system in it.
[1:59:29] But podium level, podium level, meaning cannot
[1:59:33] end level.
[1:59:35] Yeah, with a vapor mitigation system.
[1:59:38] OK.
[1:59:38] So we don't have contaminated air in the garage area.
[1:59:43] Yes.
[1:59:43] OK.
[1:59:44] Yeah.
[1:59:44] In Schlake.
[1:59:45] In Schlake.
[1:59:46] But then ours is a more rigorous cleanup standard.
[1:59:51] Yeah, because we're bringing in, well, the most
[1:59:54] important thing is we don't have a groundwater plume,
[1:59:56] except for the small finger of the plume that's coming from.
[2:00:00] On to the very north end of the Bayshore.
[2:00:06] So the southern portion of flag also is to ground level residential cleanup or is that vapor level?
[2:00:16] No, that's a vapor. That's a vapor. That's that's that that area requires a vapor medication system under the buildings.
[2:00:24] Okay. Thank you. Yeah.
[2:00:28] I'm happy to talk more about this map. Yeah, no, I guess it's
[2:00:31] more interesting. Because it's a little bit of other counsel. It's just show all
[2:00:35] it's showing here. It's what we call a cut and fill. It's showing how much soil and
[2:00:39] you can see by the how dark the green is. You know, that's the 20 to 25 feet of
[2:00:44] soil that has to come up. The lighter areas. There's basically it is at gray. There's
[2:00:48] No, no need.
[2:00:49] No.
[2:00:52] It's very different colors.
[2:00:54] Yeah.
[2:00:55] I'm listening.
[2:00:57] I have a question on the light area near the tracks.
[2:01:01] Yes.
[2:01:01] It's light green.
[2:01:03] Didn't have to remove as much.
[2:01:06] What is the elevation above the tracks?
[2:01:09] What is the elevation above the tracks?
[2:01:11] No.
[2:01:11] It's at grade with the totally at grade.
[2:01:16] Well, this doesn't have the topo on it, but this is just the cut and fail showing
[2:01:19] how much fill we have to put in. But yeah, it's basically all that area that's white. It's
[2:01:25] everything sort of, do you see where Main Street is there? I'm going north.
[2:01:32] Do you see? Yeah.
[2:01:35] That's basically, that's basically at grade. Currently. Okay, so pretty much what you see now.
[2:01:44] Is what you're saying? Yes. Okay. Yeah. Thank you. That's a lot to say. Help. Yes. Can I jump in,
[2:01:50] Hopefully, so I think this might help the conversation.
[2:01:53] I had a chance to pull up the pages in the EIR
[2:01:55] that Council Member Kern referenced.
[2:01:58] I feel that they give me a very good picture
[2:02:01] of what we could expect.
[2:02:04] They're not fancy AI-generated images there,
[2:02:08] but they show a lot of massing from many different angles.
[2:02:12] And they're all views that we are all familiar with.
[2:02:15] And so as the public, I would wonder if we could take a short break,
[2:02:19] let staff have time to pull this up because we're not going to visualize that from this,
[2:02:25] but we will visualize it from the EIR material and then I think from there we can work out if there's
[2:02:32] more work to be done. As somebody who understands AI image generators to get AI to cooperate with
[2:02:43] to get something that is realistic. You have to prompt it over and over and over again and one thing that AI
[2:02:51] sucks at is scale. So you will see they can't get humans, right? Like big hands, big feet. And so I wouldn't even be able,
[2:03:00] I wouldn't even trust what it would, it would send because when you're the grading level is very specific,
[2:03:08] you're saying, okay, it's show us that five feet or 10 feet or whatever. I wouldn't trust
[2:03:13] that AI would actually render an accurate image that is taking into account that level of
[2:03:20] specificity of grading before a building. So I would trust this more and again, not as fancy,
[2:03:27] but I think it's going to give us what we're looking for in a much more accurate way. So if everyone's
[2:03:33] as a municipal, maybe we could just take a short break.
[2:03:35] I have one thing.
[2:03:37] I have one thing.
[2:03:38] I know we're throwing around some technical terms here,
[2:03:40] and then term we're throwing around as AI's now,
[2:03:43] what we're looking for.
[2:03:43] We're looking for something called augmented reality,
[2:03:47] which are what these photos are here.
[2:03:49] And so I think we should give staff an opportunity to pull these up.
[2:03:53] I think we should take a break right now.
[2:03:54] Can we have 15 minutes, a little bit of a longer break?
[2:03:58] If staff works on that, how many more questions do we have
[2:04:01] from council?
[2:04:02] Staff could be working on this while we finish up the council questions. That's the last one I have in two and then there is and then I have questions in three.
[2:04:10] Okay. How many more do you have?
[2:04:14] Zero. I have one.
[2:04:19] Because they could be working on this while we we do that.
[2:04:26] And I can't remember current. Did you have more?
[2:04:29] No more questions here.
[2:04:31] No more. And council member O'Connell. Did you have more? Okay.
[2:04:33] So, are you all right? I'm fine. Go ahead on my question, sir.
[2:04:37] Absolutely.
[2:04:38] Let you roll.
[2:04:40] In this section, it talks about soil testing.
[2:04:44] Testing's been completed for the soil.
[2:04:45] It's the form of landfill that we'll move west.
[2:04:49] And again, diving into all those attachments with the links.
[2:04:54] It's a lot there.
[2:04:57] We had seen dirt piles at one time that we're 75 feet high.
[2:05:01] I don't know what the final height of what was tested at the time testing was done.
[2:05:10] Was that testing done to all depths and all the way down to what was considered the cap on the fill operation that ceased in the 1960s?
[2:05:22] In other words, did you have soil testing through the various layers?
[2:05:27] It's because 60 to 75 feet is a lot and there was a lot of soil over how many decades
[2:05:34] that's been piled up if you could respond to that.
[2:05:42] Because you've said in here that it was all tested, we know it's safe to be moved, but that's
[2:05:50] only as good as how many depths and also we've learned from BBCag if you go over 20 feet
[2:05:57] you sometimes find something completely different.
[2:06:00] So how did they go about this?
[2:06:04] Can we pull up the presentation from last week?
[2:06:10] There's a slide that shows the soil amount testing.
[2:06:14] And we can go over that one more time.
[2:06:17] They can, and we do have our senior engineer here.
[2:06:22] It's under, oh,
[2:06:26] who's her?
[2:06:28] Yes, okay, well that's all of the mountains, but the next one I think is the one that I want to go over again.
[2:06:38] And then we can talk about all of the other soil.
[2:06:43] So again, we're correct.
[2:06:47] We, the soil import export business started almost as soon as the landfill closed in 1967.
[2:06:55] and it's been operating out there basically from 67 until 2017 so a lot of the
[2:07:06] soil that was brought in basically covered you see that existing soil cover
[2:07:09] that covered the landfill and that's anywhere from 4 feet to you know 65 feet
[2:07:17] over the side if you take in the mountains but there's a pretty thick soil cover
[2:07:21] covers the old trash layer that's all across the landfill, and that started, you know, as
[2:07:28] first says, the first cell was closed.
[2:07:31] And then continued as the second cell closed. There was a soil then, and we had a contractor who had a, there's been a series of contractors out there doing soil import exports since the first use permit was 1977.
[2:07:48] They were bringing in soil before that.
[2:07:50] I'm not sure they had to use permit from the city because I'm not sure the city existed
[2:07:53] before.
[2:07:56] In the early days of the 61, 61 is when you incorporated.
[2:08:02] Okay.
[2:08:02] 63 is when this.
[2:08:03] Well, maybe you didn't have a planning department issuing permits on this, but the earliest
[2:08:07] permit I found was 1977, and the soil, the input, and it was basically, it's a clean soil
[2:08:14] import export business. And the use permit said, you know, soil inspection should be visual,
[2:08:22] you know, you basically was kind of, as council member Ocono always likes to say, that
[2:08:28] it's a sniff test, you know, is the soil dirty, does it smell? And, you know, if you're doing
[2:08:33] an import export business, you want to make sure that what you're bringing in is something
[2:08:37] that you can turn around and sell. That was the business. So they really weren't in the
[2:08:41] business of taking in dirty soil, or they weren't supposed to be.
[2:08:44] And that was the use permit, was it was a physical examination of the clean soil.
[2:08:49] And it was pretty much, you know, soil came in and soil went out for many decades.
[2:08:56] Something happened in the 2000s where we were bringing more soil in and that was going out.
[2:09:01] I don't know exactly what was going on, but there was a lot of large construction projects,
[2:09:06] the central freeway, the central subway expansion, we took in a lot of that
[2:09:11] soil that was clean soil that was very deep. So that's a lot of what's
[2:09:15] mounted up out there over the years. In 2012, the city permit required the
[2:09:26] operator to start testing the soil. Not just the sniff test, not just the smell
[2:09:31] task, you know, not just a visual task, but actually testing the soil. That started in 2012.
[2:09:37] Are you talking about testing as it was brought in on that rock or testing after it was
[2:09:41] no, it had to be tested before it got sent. But in the truck, sometimes it was tested at the
[2:09:46] side. It was bringing it from, sometimes it was tested at the gates, but it was tested before.
[2:09:51] It could be accepted into the, how do you test soil in a truck at a gate?
[2:09:57] I don't know, but I'm sure my consulting could tell you how you do that, but it's done
[2:10:02] every day.
[2:10:05] And yeah, I'm sure it's a series of random samples that you take through the piles and
[2:10:10] double check that there's something contaminated in there.
[2:10:15] The point of this slide where we are today was that, yes, we did mount up a lot of soil through
[2:10:22] sort of the mid 2000s, the green area, so you see that line that says 210 topography, 210 is when
[2:10:38] we, the city started requiring the testing of the soil. So between the 2010 line and the
[2:10:47] That's all this total soil that we tested again because measure J.J. says, any soil you're moving from the landfill to the rail yard has to be tested.
[2:10:58] So this was because it was the top area. It was the easiest to access for testing because we had to get down there with, you know, kind of bulldozers and probes.
[2:11:07] We were basically separated the stuff that we knew was probably already clings that already
[2:11:12] been tested versus the stuff that we think is also clean and we have done some random
[2:11:18] testing of that green area and it does look pretty good but it's not as fully tested as the
[2:11:23] red area. The red area is been fully tested under a soil and we created a soil import evaluation
[2:11:33] and report that has been approved by DTSC and by the water board and reviewed by the
[2:11:39] City's Consultant EKI. And we tested, you know, I just want to round numbers up because
[2:11:45] we don't want to get to but about 2 million cubic cubic, 2 million cubic yards of soil that
[2:11:52] we tested. And that's roughly about what we think we need on the, on the really hard side.
[2:11:58] So looking at this illustration where you have the slope, it seems to me anything
[2:12:03] above 50 feet you could safely assume that was tested, but where you get on slow, how are
[2:12:08] you going to know where that is? Yeah, because we're looking at a cutaway view. So it seems
[2:12:14] like anything below 50 feet, even if it says tested soil, you're going to have to test everything
[2:12:20] below 50 feet. Yes, so the red stuff is tested and it is now geo tagged. So it can be lasered
[2:12:27] when the bulldozers come out and they will know exactly where to make these cuts and to move
[2:12:32] that clean soil, the green soil, like I said, if we need it, that will have to be tested
[2:12:39] in the future.
[2:12:40] But we have a lot of soil that we can use that's already been tested, and it's good to
[2:12:45] go.
[2:12:45] Yes, the red stuff.
[2:12:47] That's all good to go.
[2:12:49] Thank you.
[2:12:49] Thank you for that.
[2:12:51] Okay.
[2:12:53] Okay.
[2:12:53] Councilmember.
[2:12:54] I mean, sorry.
[2:12:54] Mayor Proto.
[2:12:56] Okay.
[2:12:57] So, these are more truck questions and some modifying, they're not for you. Don't worry, I'm modifying them, given the information we asked for, but I think we, and if it's already in a specific plan and I, you know, then feel free to point me in that direction, but I think these are things we need to work out and I would imagine that maybe staff is anticipating
[2:13:27] working them out in that sort of construction soil movement plan. But I would like to see
[2:13:37] language in the specific plan if possible. And we can add these in once we have more of
[2:13:44] an analysis. But I think the other questions that we need to solve for are enforceable limits that
[2:13:49] number and timing of truck trips, where truck trips can cue, where trucks can cue, how trucks
[2:13:58] are going to be dispatched to prevent cueing from blocking intersections. And we need to identify
[2:14:06] emergency routes. And also we need to know who's monitoring for compliance and what happens
[2:14:13] if limits are exceeded. So if we're going to say it's going to be 100 truck trips today and
[2:14:19] it's 120 or whatever or maybe it's reached that 100 for that day and it's okay, sorry you're done.
[2:14:26] So I think we just need and I know that we'll probably work the intention is to work all
[2:14:31] a lot of this out in the future, but I think as much as we can do now would be ideal.
[2:14:36] So if that exists already, let me know, but if it doesn't, it's something we need to kind of work
[2:14:44] some language out on, I think.
[2:14:50] And then I have one other. I have just one more I missed.
[2:14:59] kind of stuff.
[2:15:00] Report on this section, talks about groundwater management procedures, and are we not going to have
[2:15:07] a groundwater management plan before we approve this to look at.
[2:15:20] It says draft versions of the plans
[2:15:21] are included in the R-dips.
[2:15:27] Well, the R-dips are available,
[2:15:32] but this is not included in this
[2:15:35] specific plant. Right because the specific, the audits are the
[2:15:42] managed by the water control board and DTSC, it's a different regulatory scheme.
[2:15:50] Okay, but the actual management plan is not in the specific plant.
[2:16:00] Yeah, the meat, I'm sorry which management plan are we looking for?
[2:16:03] Ground water management plan.
[2:16:07] Correct, that's not part of the specific plan.
[2:16:13] Okay, seems like that should be something that we would lock into a specific plant, because
[2:16:22] if you're doing phase development, that groundwater management is going to affect every
[2:16:26] single phase as you go along.
[2:16:32] So the groundwater management plan has procedures to handle any kind of encounter groundwater
[2:16:39] during construction, let's say there's de-watering for utility installation, so it's part
[2:16:44] the environmental regulatory agencies purview to understand how the groundwater will be handled
[2:16:52] during construction. So it is regulated by the DTSC or the water board. And so there are attachments
[2:16:58] to the Arctic, which are the documents that are approved by those environmental regulatory agencies.
[2:17:05] And that's a pretty requisite before any building or grading permit would be issued. The mitigation
[2:17:14] mitigation measure hazard 1B from the mitigation monitoring plan requires a DTSC or what
[2:17:23] or quality control board approved soil and groundwater management plan that is subject
[2:17:30] to a city peer review and have that be approved by the appropriate regulatory agencies before
[2:17:38] a building or breeding permit would be issued.
[2:17:40] If I may, I think what you're talking about in the language you're using is for the actual
[2:17:52] remediation and cleanup and something that would be required on top of that once the remediation
[2:18:01] and cleanup is done, that falls on the water resources board or the DTSC.
[2:18:07] When we have a grading plan, we need to know what the water is going to do because of the grading plan.
[2:18:16] That's exactly what I'm talking about.
[2:18:19] Separately from what the mitigation for the remediation of the site would be.
[2:18:27] And I think that would be covered under the grading plan that's on top of the remediation.
[2:18:34] And I'm not sure how the city wants to respond, but I think that's the question where you're going with what happens to the surface when we're doing a grading plan where the water is going to go.
[2:18:48] Right. So let's say you have an area remediated. You're going to start construction of say housing.
[2:18:54] And that may be different, you've disturbed the natural pattern of groundwater coming off the hills off the mountain.
[2:19:04] And is there a plan that says, okay, while this is happening, it maybe has to re-channel the normal groundwater flows during the wetest part of the season.
[2:19:17] And how is that going to happen, or do you just let things flood?
[2:19:22] That, what you're describing with rainfall and surface water flow, that's storm water management
[2:19:28] and that would be covered under the storm water pollution prevention plan, the SWIP, which
[2:19:35] is also regulated by the water board and then there's procedures to have best management practices
[2:19:42] to minimize, you know, run off of sediment and other potential pollutants.
[2:19:47] And so that's all regulated under the construction general permit by the water board.
[2:19:52] Right. Now, I'm less concerned about the remediation part as much.
[2:19:55] That's not really good. That's construction. Yeah.
[2:19:58] That's just during construction over more than a half of an acre of land.
[2:20:02] You have to comply with the construction general permit.
[2:20:07] It's not a remediation thing. Okay.
[2:20:09] And then it's a different department within the water board that regulates storm water.
[2:20:13] Okay, and there's there's also a apparently
[2:20:20] PCBs identified in this area and I don't know if anyone has explored that has the waterboard looked into that
[2:20:28] It's been identified. It's it's under a county map
[2:20:32] It came up recently at a C-cag meeting that is one of the the areas former industrial site with with PCBs that are
[2:20:41] are moving around in stormwater and groundwater?
[2:20:47] Yeah, I can't speak specifically to Brisbane, but I can't speak to the Bay Area as a whole
[2:20:53] that the water board has been investigating many communities because of the sediment in storm drains
[2:20:59] that are just charging to the bay and resulting in PCB impacts to the bay.
[2:21:04] And so they've asked various cities where they've found detections of PCBs to go upstream
[2:21:10] within their storm drain system to find the sources, let's say the onland upland sources
[2:21:16] of PCBs to remediate them. So that's just the general process that various cities have been
[2:21:22] following all around the bay. Okay, well, but I'm talking specifically Brisbane was on a list
[2:21:28] of certain cities in San Mateo County. It wasn't just every city. So maybe maybe I need to contact
[2:21:36] staff with that. I mean,
[2:21:38] I mean,
[2:21:38] yes.
[2:21:43] So we,
[2:21:44] the city of Brisbane is
[2:21:46] part of a regional stormwater group
[2:21:49] with the county, and so we do have a lot of reporting
[2:21:52] that we do with the stormwater through that stormwater program,
[2:21:55] to the water board on our PCBs,
[2:21:57] or we're finding it and then having
[2:22:00] doing quite a bit of testing.
[2:22:01] So there's more information and documentation available
[2:22:03] that we can share as far as
[2:22:07] stormwater program and more specifically the PCV documents of the future meeting.
[2:22:15] And is this encompassing the bail-ance?
[2:22:19] Yeah, so it, it, it, it, it, it, it, our stormwater program covers the entirety of the city of Brisbane limits.
[2:22:27] So anything with, within our borders, whether it's developed under
[2:22:30] And obviously there's requirements for areas that have known PCBs, which is pretty much anywhere in the peninsula along the bay.
[2:22:41] And it basically establishes programs protocols for high handle PCB reduction through general programs.
[2:22:49] And then yes, there's more specific construction related permitting and oversight that would be done for large developments of over half an acre that would also encounter controls and measures for PCBs.
[2:22:59] So, has this been shared with BDI?
[2:23:04] Well, the hazard, sorry.
[2:23:10] I was also just going to point out in the hazard section of the EIR talks about that
[2:23:14] PCBs were one of the substances that were tested for and there are identified specific
[2:23:23] locations where PCBs do exceed screening criteria level.
[2:23:28] So that is part of what's been screened for and will be addressed through the remediation plan.
[2:23:38] But it is a known hazard that has already, testing has already commenced, has been identified
[2:23:45] in certain locations and it's part of what is planned to be addressed through the remediation.
[2:23:50] So it would need ongoing testing and monitoring over time.
[2:24:01] Well, the whole remediation system is going to have ongoing monitoring as we've been discussing for the last few weeks.
[2:24:11] Mayor Protem.
[2:24:13] I called my questions, so I'm, I'm good.
[2:24:16] Just to move on to the next topic or public comment.
[2:24:18] So do we have staff the,
[2:24:23] photos that you were illustrations, the staff have those ready to put up on the screen?
[2:24:29] Yes, they're ready.
[2:24:42] Did you want to just scroll through them or how
[2:24:44] what is the intention here?
[2:24:48] Scroll through that pause on each page.
[2:24:56] I'll just mention the first page just for people
[2:25:00] if they're looking at the EIR themselves shows.
[2:25:03] So these are all different views taken from different parts of Brisbane.
[2:25:06] So, the first page is a key that shows where the photo is taken in which direction is pointing,
[2:25:13] so those are the arrows and such. So, if you're wondering, you know, why are these different viewpoints chosen
[2:25:20] they're there and they're meant to be representative of different viewpoints around the city
[2:25:25] and showing both the views from important viewpoints in the city but also to highlight the different
[2:25:34] features of the proposed development from these different
[2:25:40] few points.
[2:26:02] Are people in the audience and on TV able to see the green ribbon above
[2:26:07] the photos describing what the overlook is?
[2:26:11] We will read it then.
[2:26:13] Overlook point at John McLaren Park facing southeast.
[2:26:31] I can read that.
[2:26:33] Get in Jim Street that.
[2:26:35] What does it say?
[2:26:37] Jim can you kindly zoom in?
[2:26:38] It's a little fuzzy.
[2:26:47] I don't know if I'm pronouncing right, but go in Jim Street at Wild Avenue and Visitation Valley facing South.
[2:26:59] Sorry, I need to back out real quick and then I'll go back in.
[2:27:32] So this is from candlestick point.
[2:27:44] And are these not rendering space upon the property owners submitted specific plan?
[2:27:54] not the staff prepared specific plan.
[2:27:57] It's important distinction.
[2:27:59] Thank you for clarifying that.
[2:28:01] That is correct.
[2:28:02] These renderings were prepared based on the pre-medigation version,
[2:28:06] so the 2025 version, and with some of the modifications to the number
[2:28:13] of towers and the shape and location of towers, the current version
[2:28:18] of the plan has fewer large buildings and visual impact.
[2:28:34] I would wonder then if it makes sense to take these,
[2:28:39] if we, again, knowing that things are have changed,
[2:28:43] and we've made adjustments to try to protect some of the views.
[2:28:49] I wonder if we could get similar renderings that reflect those adjustments.
[2:28:58] Like, probably this one would be the same.
[2:29:01] But some that show those larger towers.
[2:29:05] Is that possible to do just updating with where we are now?
[2:29:16] It is possible.
[2:29:17] So if that's a direction from the council, then that could be conveyed to the environmental consultant.
[2:29:26] This is the engineer.
[2:29:28] This is looking east towards the bay.
[2:29:31] One thing also that's useful with these.
[2:29:33] Although they are just kind of basic massing diagrams.
[2:29:38] They are to scale.
[2:29:39] So some of the concerns that have been raised with, you know,
[2:29:43] some of the other options is that these are scaled.
[2:29:52] This is that industrial.
[2:29:55] That's looking north going towards San Francisco.
[2:30:22] This looks like the southern part of the west side.
[2:30:56] Again, it's the southern part of the west side with the commercial buildings.
[2:31:17] So I'm assuming that these renderings factor in grading,
[2:31:24] right? This one is showing at grade on the west side. So I just want to make sure that
[2:31:34] this is really demonstrating the real scale, because while the scale of the buildings may be correct,
[2:31:39] You have to factor in the dirt that's going to be put there first so does do these images
[2:31:48] take into consideration grading?
[2:31:54] Yes, it would represent the grading, so some of the images are a little more clear in that
[2:32:00] respect than others, particularly as we look at, for example, the mound.
[2:32:08] Sorry, I'm getting notes from our environmental consultants.
[2:32:14] So yeah, so we think so, but we'd want to verify and yeah, perhaps BDI may have some more information on this as well.
[2:32:27] In terms of generating more images of the changes that have been proposed in the current version of the plan,
[2:32:37] you take about a month, give or take, and then also another thing for the council to consider as this,
[2:32:46] also been mentioned this evening would be if there are other alternatives that are of interest that should be modeled,
[2:32:52] because these are modeling what is known as the project, which is what is shown in the plan,
[2:33:02] but there are as we've discussed other EIR alternatives, which have not been modeled.
[2:33:09] So we'd want some direction in that respect too.
[2:33:17] So I guess, I'm so sorry.
[2:33:19] So I guess I would question Mayor Macken and council member Lance.
[2:33:24] That's what I was going to say.
[2:33:26] You've seen the renderings now that are in the EIR.
[2:33:31] This is a good baseline for you.
[2:33:34] This isn't what I asked for.
[2:33:37] Okay, so that's what I'm saying.
[2:33:38] This is like the good baseline.
[2:33:39] Yeah, this is really looking at buildings.
[2:33:43] I want to see what it looks like with the dirt without the buildings.
[2:33:49] That's what I want to see.
[2:33:51] And, you know, with some of the clarification that Stephanie provided, I think it was helpful,
[2:33:59] though I'd like to get a little more information in regards to what is going to be excavated,
[2:34:06] right, in order to get to the level. I mean, so we've had conversations in these hearings about,
[2:34:14] okay, the elevation next to the train tracks is going to be five feet above the tracks.
[2:34:21] And now we're understanding, no, that isn't what's going to happen, we're going to excavate
[2:34:26] down a certain level and then put five feet of required clean fill, um, that cap, right?
[2:34:36] Because the five feet is required throughout the entire west side.
[2:34:41] So then it's like, okay, well, that how much is going to be excavated throughout the property?
[2:34:46] Okay, so you're saying it's in the map.
[2:34:49] But, again, you know, I'm not, you know, this isn't my, my field of expertise, right?
[2:34:59] I'm just a council member. I'm trying to do my best. The public, you know, sometimes I know more than the council members and sometimes they know less.
[2:35:09] And so, but the more clear that we are in understanding like how these different phases look, the easier it is to then
[2:35:19] you know, to have buy it, or to then ask questions to get clarification.
[2:35:27] So, Stephanie, are there going to be any retaining walls in regards to holding back this fill
[2:35:36] as we move westward?
[2:35:42] Can I add to what you're saying?
[2:35:44] One of the other things that I've heard as a concern is, as you do this in phases, and you moved
[2:35:49] what's to stop the dirt from just blowing? What measures are you going to use? Because that
[2:35:55] corridor through Viz Valley is horrific winds a lot. And are we just going to have
[2:36:03] blowing dust storms? Once you disturb that, how are you going to contain that? And the other
[2:36:09] concerns, so it sounds like now from what we're seeing, where we thought, you know, and this is
[2:36:15] going back probably 10, 15 years we were told that there would be areas, I can remember
[2:36:22] Councilmember O'Connell gasping because we were told that on the west side near Bayshore
[2:36:28] it could be 20, 30 feet high. Do you remember that? And then that was the staff, your predecessors
[2:36:35] were telling us that. So that's kind of where we're coming from expecting to see and
[2:36:40] Now we're seeing this as this is all at grade pretty much the way we see it which then
[2:36:46] to me begs the question what about sea level rice?
[2:36:59] Yeah that was a bunch of questions.
[2:37:01] Yeah.
[2:37:05] I'm sorry.
[2:37:07] Mayor Mackins question in the second.
[2:37:09] So the remedial design and implementation plan, the R-Dip, that does contain all the soil
[2:37:18] dust, air, monitoring, that would be required for each phase of the development.
[2:37:26] And then there's additional, so the first phase, you know, there's...
[2:37:30] We'll be any residences out there, but there's still air and dust monitoring that is required.
[2:37:36] And how do you contain the dust?
[2:37:39] I think, can you just tell us?
[2:37:42] Well, yeah, I mean, it's contained by keeping, you know, keeping the, just keeping all your
[2:37:48] practices that dust is to a minimum if watering needs to be brought in to water, you know,
[2:37:53] if it's getting really dry, the water needs to come in to keep the dust down. And then
[2:37:57] There's requirements where work is stopped if wind speeds hit a certain, a certain, what's
[2:38:05] the word I'm looking for?
[2:38:06] It's velocity.
[2:38:07] Thank you.
[2:38:08] But you're talking about, if you're moving it, I'm talking about, it's another day in the
[2:38:13] country.
[2:38:14] And the wind is 40 miles an hour and you've cut into some of the dirt and that's what it's
[2:38:22] just loosed dirt, what's to stop it from blowing and you're talking lots of dirt.
[2:38:27] you're not talking a small area you throw a tarp over. Yeah. And again, there are dust management
[2:38:35] protocols that are in the our dip remedial plan. And then I see a what you do. So you it has to
[2:38:43] be watered down to make sure that it doesn't get flown in a doesn't fly away or needs to be covered.
[2:38:50] And how do you do that on a weekend when no one's working on it? Well, you would you would do it
[2:38:55] you like the work side on Friday. But you don't always know the wind's going to kick up. So do
[2:39:01] we have the residents calling your cell phone and saying hey, you need to get out there and water
[2:39:07] the dirt down and you're talking significant amount of water for acres. You're not talking just
[2:39:15] in a couple acres. Yeah. You could be talking 300, 400 acres. Yes. You're prepared to water that?
[2:39:21] Well, I don't know if it's 3,400 acres at a time, again, but we've talked about last week
[2:39:27] was a phased development program.
[2:39:29] So most of the site out there now is covered with vegetation, so there's not a dirt issue.
[2:39:36] But the phasing, yeah, I mean, it's a very good question, and it's also, you know, all
[2:39:44] managed in the soil and dust management plan in the R-Dip.
[2:39:49] And you can use non-potable water, a non-potable water for the construction phase.
[2:39:54] It was the dust mitigation,
[2:39:58] probably not.
[2:39:58] We have existing water out at the, out at the rail yard site from SFPUC, and that's probably
[2:40:05] what we will be using for the construction and remediation phase.
[2:40:10] Yeah.
[2:40:11] Okay.
[2:40:12] And sea level rise.
[2:40:14] It is all designed to incorporate not only the whole raising of the site is to get us out
[2:40:18] 100-year flood zone. That's why the site has to be raised.
[2:40:23] Well, but you're talking pretty much what we see is what it's going to be.
[2:40:27] Now, you're saying, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.
[2:40:29] Yeah, it's going to be filled in. What I showed you, remember I talked about how the whole site
[2:40:33] is sort of like a shallow bowl. So if you look at that slide again, that cut, I'd provide it is,
[2:40:40] you'll see most of the fill is in the center that needs to go in this. And that's where when
[2:40:45] You've heard this 2030 feet, I think the maximum is 25 feet that needs to go into those
[2:40:50] low-lying areas to bring it up to gray.
[2:40:52] Okay, but what about the east side where the water's going to come from the bay?
[2:40:58] You mean for sea level rise?
[2:41:02] It's all been, that's all been engineered into those numbers that you're seeing there.
[2:41:07] This hundred-year flood and the sea level rise has all been engineered into those final
[2:41:12] elevation numbers that you've seen. And I think we talked about this at the first hearing on
[2:41:19] C-level rise. I just have to say I'm not clear on that at all. Okay, okay, because even
[2:41:25] even count trends is concerned about highway 101. And that's really your only natural barrier
[2:41:32] and so what if it goes over the highway? Yeah. Well, I mean that's a tough question. We can't take
[2:41:38] of 101 and you know I mean obviously if the 101 goes under water we have bigger problems
[2:41:46] than okay but the 101 is not in our specific plan okay Mayor Franklin but but if you
[2:41:57] want we can I mean maybe the city staff or we can have our senior engineers come back and
[2:42:02] discuss the level rise again but I thought that we went over that pretty thoroughly in the first
[2:42:06] on sea level rise and how our engineered plants incorporate both the
[2:42:12] hundred year flood and sea level rise and the most recent documentaries on
[2:42:17] and the Arctic and all those timelines just keep getting compressed up
[2:42:22] closer and closer. Yeah and we're we're complying with the latest and greatest
[2:42:27] from the state on what we need to how we need to build the site. This was also discussed
[2:42:34] at the BBCag meeting by Alice Karpinski at the water board who oversaw our C-level rise.
[2:42:44] Analysis and our C-level rise plans. She approved all of those.
[2:42:48] So that was discussed at the BBCag and discussed at the first hearing.
[2:42:52] But if there's no more information you need, we're happy to provide it, or the city's essay consultant can also provide that information.
[2:43:00] would be nice to know what sea level rise projections you're using. Yeah, we're
[2:43:07] using the latest. I think the latest would be probably what someone made a week
[2:43:13] ago. So it's working progress. Yes. And I don't really want to speak at a
[2:43:20] term, but I believe our plan also would require if if they if they are updated
[2:43:24] again, then we would have to comply with the new rules. That's kind of how it's
[2:43:28] But right now, our current plan, the plans that are in front of you, are consistent with the most recent at 2024 guidance for sea level rise in the Bay Area.
[2:43:41] I beg your pardon.
[2:43:47] 6.6.
[2:43:51] 6.6 feet of high sea level rise that's been predicted by the waterboard.
[2:43:55] That our project is engineered and designed around.
[2:43:59] Okay.
[2:44:00] Thank you.
[2:44:01] Madam, if I could just keep stuff in either just for a second.
[2:44:05] So yeah, so thank you for the visuals that you provided that went into the ER showing the
[2:44:14] buildings.
[2:44:14] But yeah, if we can get some visuals with just the grading, because I have a question,
[2:44:20] you know, that's going to be at the next topic, which is, yeah, which I'll ask later,
[2:44:28] identifying that the west side needs to comply with the OU SM and OU-2 requirements in order to get permits.
[2:44:39] So is there one question in here?
[2:44:42] There is.
[2:44:43] No, no, no.
[2:44:44] Well, so it might be two.
[2:44:47] So in regards to what I'd like to see some visuals of just the, just the, the grading.
[2:44:54] and that's the finished grade, you know, we've, yes, and then.
[2:45:00] You know, having a, you know, a visual from tunnel, I'm assuming that tunnel is going to continue to be open to the public throughout all phases of construction.
[2:45:12] Maybe there might be, you know, a requirement to close it.
[2:45:16] Yeah, when certain times upgraded, but I think besides that, I believe you're correct.
[2:45:21] okay so then yes my question is so that you know if you're on bishore and you're heading north
[2:45:32] you just pass godly be canyon parkway to your right there's a steep drop off I mean it
[2:45:41] It's House Hill.
[2:45:44] So the cut through itself.
[2:45:45] Yeah.
[2:45:45] That's what you're looking at.
[2:45:46] So as you're heading north, right, the grade, you know, is minimized.
[2:45:54] But you know, it's still very, very high there.
[2:45:58] So you mean?
[2:45:59] Yeah.
[2:46:00] Yeah.
[2:46:00] So are you expecting the fill to be at grade of Bishore?
[2:46:08] I think if you check them, I know you don't like them.
[2:46:10] Green blow up map I gave you. Yeah, I think that is one of the areas that is designed to come up about 20 at 25 feet
[2:46:19] Okay, so so there's still gonna be
[2:46:23] some distance. There's still gonna be a draw-off
[2:46:38] There was in one of those
[2:46:41] Visuals and the aesthetics chapter. There was one that shows if you're going on guard or you're going on
[2:46:46] Baseboard Boulevard just pass Guadalupe Canyon you have ice house hill on your right
[2:46:50] you see sermons to go to the north in that exact area where you're talking about, it's sort
[2:46:54] of like a cliff. There was a rendering that showed you'll basically see a building. So we're not,
[2:47:00] like that's on an area where you're not bringing the grade all the way up there, you're going to have
[2:47:06] a building there. And so when we talk about the finished grades, that's why stuff needs to
[2:47:12] this this bowl analogy to help you understand that it's not that everything is going to be
[2:47:19] at the same level as like the current base or boulevard we're talking about leveling out the site
[2:47:24] as it is to make sure we don't you know there's pockets and things right now and we need it to be
[2:47:29] flat to start development and so that's what she's describing with these areas where you have to
[2:47:34] excavate soil bring in soil and get the site to a place where it's both has the clean cap and
[2:47:41] raised for the hundred year flood. Yeah, and I apologize for, you know, not to, you know, I guess
[2:47:48] reading, you could stay up there, please. If you could am finished. So, you know, not looking
[2:47:54] at renderings in the EIR that perhaps indicate this. But if you're just now north of bodily
[2:48:05] became your parkway, you're right, there was a rendering and had the building, but you know,
[2:48:09] there's a building there, they're still quite a drop off.
[2:48:14] It's a very expansive view down to the train tracks.
[2:48:21] And so that's what I'd like to understand.
[2:48:24] It's like, OK, how here's Bishore, I guess
[2:48:30] is going to be the grade.
[2:48:32] And then how does that slope all the way down to?
[2:48:38] Yes, the Caltering Tracks, and how does that go north say to where the roundhouse is located?
[2:48:47] You know, I'd just like to get a visual of that type of grading, and then are we going to have a retaining wall?
[2:48:53] Because that to me seems like a lot, but I'm not an engineer, I don't.
[2:48:58] No, an engineer is not here tonight either.
[2:49:01] Okay.
[2:49:01] So BKF is not here, but I think I think I have a better understanding of what you're trying to do.
[2:49:06] Yeah, yeah, I think you can visualize it with that green blob map. I gave you, but but
[2:49:13] we also can provide you cross sections and maybe it's easier. So we don't spend a lot of hearing
[2:49:19] as long as it's to give it to staff to show the cross sections for the various sections,
[2:49:25] so that you can if you can read a cross section and it'll show you the elevation. I think what you're
[2:49:31] looking for and I think it's Katie pointed out, you're looking for more what's it look like when the
[2:49:36] I think the EIR visuals are probably the best.
[2:49:40] Yeah, not when they're there, but just the lady.
[2:49:43] I wanted to see what, I want to see how the table set.
[2:49:47] Just the dirt, no buildings.
[2:49:49] Just the dirt goto building.
[2:49:51] Okay, we're going to take a 10 minute break.
[2:49:53] Please come back.
[2:49:54] Thank you.
[3:05:33] Okay, we're back again. We're still on the second topic, site greeting, soil testing and clean soil design.
[3:05:42] Madam Mayor, do we need to extend the meeting? Oh yes, we do. Thank you for that.
[3:05:47] Need a motion to extend the meeting. We'll say an hour.
[3:05:52] I'll make the motion. Okay. Second. All in favor? Aye.
[3:05:57] If anyone opposed? No.
[3:05:59] Sound flies when you haven't.
[3:06:00] Okay.
[3:06:03] We have public comments.
[3:06:06] I'm going to read the names so that you know when you're in the queue.
[3:06:12] It's going to be Chris Evers, Robin Lider, Michelle Salmon,
[3:06:18] Karen is gone.
[3:06:19] Linda Salmon, Paul Buscal, Bart Pinto, Pintoha.
[3:06:25] Thank you, Bart, for the phonetic spelling.
[3:06:28] Chris, you're up.
[3:06:36] Okay, I'm here to ask you not to allow trucks on our streets as you have been doing a lot.
[3:06:43] Could you just just speak up a little bit?
[3:06:45] I feel like I am.
[3:06:46] We want to make sure everybody at home can do it.
[3:06:48] Okay, so I'm here to ask you to not allow the trucks on our streets.
[3:06:52] And it sounds like you've already figured out that that's a bad idea.
[3:06:55] I would point out that the developer has known forever that this is going to be a problem.
[3:07:00] and it's unfortunate that they have not moved forward in any way to attempt to engineer a solution.
[3:07:08] I also am disturbed by the fact that the non-real hall route is included and is used as the model.
[3:07:18] If in fact we already knew that wasn't a whole route that includes the Blankin segment, which is prohibits trucks.
[3:07:30] That's in the document. So, when I, as an ordinary person, look at the document and you show me a sign that's a diagram that says hall route, I think you mean that that's the hall route.
[3:07:46] And if there's another hall route that they're going to use, then I would really love to
[3:07:51] see it.
[3:07:53] It's great that Karen came up with his idea.
[3:07:56] It's ridiculous that this idea came from a citizen, and not from somebody working for the
[3:08:03] developer or an engineer.
[3:08:11] So, you know, the city attorney is telling us, don't worry that it says that this is the, you know, we're going to put trucks here, we're going to fix this all up later.
[3:08:20] If we agree the plan is impossible, we need a new plan.
[3:08:24] I do not want this council to grant permission for something that is disastrous in the hope that that permission can later be reconsidered, rescinded or modified.
[3:08:33] And the EIR, the specific plan, should be reflect facts, not with full thinking.
[3:08:41] Thank you.
[3:08:42] Okay.
[3:08:45] Robin, you're up.
[3:08:52] I guess I'd just like to start by saying that 2.2 million yards of dirt, which is enormous,
[3:08:59] and it's almost three years.
[3:09:01] It's 34 months of hauling, is a project under sequa.
[3:09:07] And what that means to me is that it needs to be described.
[3:09:11] This is the only chance you as a council or the public has to be able to determine the environmental impacts of that.
[3:09:20] And that means you have to show a route and you have to analyze it.
[3:09:24] So I don't want to get away from the fact that if it's decided later than it deprives you and the community of knowing the environmental impacts of the whole route.
[3:09:36] I'm also concerned that I have been asking for what the route is and then tonight I
[3:09:42] find out that I think the riot is a lesterative rather than the route, but so I think
[3:09:47] we'd all like to know what exactly the route is and the worst case scenario I just want
[3:09:55] to say apparently was given to whoever did the IAR by the developer so it somebody thought
[3:10:03] sometimes that that actually was what they were going to do. If it's going to change then it
[3:10:10] needs to be changed in the project description and in the ER and be analyzed. But what I came
[3:10:17] here tonight to do, if I have any time left, I do, is Cliff said at the end of his thing he said
[3:10:22] last time, well I guess we just have to, I think you said, suck it out. And I would just like to
[3:10:34] It turns out, if you think about it, that the developer owns all the land, even the land
[3:10:40] under the railroad is owned by the developer.
[3:10:43] The railroad only has an easement over it, and I found sections in the California Public Utilities
[3:10:53] Code and in case law that says, somebody who owns the adjoining land has a right to a private
[3:11:00] crossing.
[3:11:01] Now, I'm not saying I know exactly what that means.
[3:11:04] I've just said, you'll never have a stronger candidate in your whole life than this developer
[3:11:09] to get you across over that rail track since they own both sides of the adjoining lands.
[3:11:17] I want to say it could be, it can bear belt, it could be an overcrossing, it could even
[3:11:21] be an undercrossing, especially since I don't know if the mayor knew this, they're doing
[3:11:26] a whole new drainage system under the rail yard for the development.
[3:11:32] So they're also doing an underground development.
[3:11:35] So I think that might be a good thing to check out.
[3:11:39] What I do know for sure is that you shouldn't be able to come
[3:11:42] before this community, or I think the council and say,
[3:11:46] well, it's infeasible, but no we have an applied.
[3:11:50] No we haven't done any engineering plans.
[3:11:53] No we haven't asked anybody, but it seems like they don't
[3:11:56] want to do this. I think the city needs to insist that they go to the California Public Utilities
[3:12:03] Commission and the JPB, or whatever it's called, and apply. Send in the documents. If it's
[3:12:13] non-feasible, then we would know. But right now, I don't think they have the right to claim that
[3:12:19] unless they have done their due diligence and proved to you in this community that it's not
[3:12:25] feasible. I thank you.
[3:12:31] Michelle Salman. I've so many notes tonight and they're kind of all over
[3:12:35] the place but one of the things I do want to say is that it was a kind of a surprise to find out
[3:12:40] that the truck calling route in the EIR was basically a fantasy and it made me very concerned because
[3:12:49] I've had many complaints about the draft EIR not matching the specific plan and I wonder how many other
[3:12:55] things are in the draft EIR that is a fantasy that isn't based on what we're actually planning
[3:13:03] to do. And I think that's a really big concern. The other part of thing, one of the things
[3:13:10] I want to say is that we're talking about, oh, we're good to go with the soil. We've tested
[3:13:14] it. We've tested it. I brought up at the last meeting. That soil is maybe, I don't know,
[3:13:20] what else is contaminated with? But I do know it is extremely contaminated with jugbotic
[3:13:25] grass seed, which is an invasive species that will just take over, wherever you put that dirt,
[3:13:30] it's going to sprout with pompous grass, most people know it asks, but it's a jubbada grass,
[3:13:35] and it is an invasive species in the state of California.
[3:13:39] You saw what it did to the coastline and all the erosion it caused.
[3:13:43] You saw what it's done in different places on San Bernard Mountain, that was higher areas
[3:13:48] now covered with it.
[3:13:50] Where do you think the seeds go?
[3:13:51] And they stay in the seed bank.
[3:13:53] So, when you're testing the soil, I want you to test for that too, and I would also like to make sure that they do soil testing where the Lazarus field site was, I noticed on that little diagram, I had a little red box that was kind of not included, and then soil testing along the whole Bayshore corridor and the one-on-one corridor for lead testing, as well as all other contaminants, but lead is particularly harmful for children.
[3:14:21] And it stays there for a long time.
[3:14:26] And they talked about, you know, no sensitive use versus employees for when it comes to the cleanup.
[3:14:32] Well, VWR was so toxic after years of what they did there,
[3:14:39] that they did not take a single employee with them when they left town and moved to Southern California.
[3:14:45] Even though employees volunteered to go and pay their own way and everything they took no one
[3:14:52] Why you have to ask yourself why they took no one and
[3:14:57] I've heard several people tell me oh
[3:15:00] Well, my so-and-so work there in the CAD cancer. So, you know, it's a concern that we really do need to make sure that everything is cleaned up to a certain level.
[3:15:11] Five feet of clean fill. What about plants, trees on the west side? Are they going to go right?
[3:15:18] Oh, Papa's grass is going to go right through that five feet down to the toxins.
[3:15:24] So I just, I'm really appreciated in the council's questions.
[3:15:27] Tonight has been a very interesting discussion, and one of the things that you might like
[3:15:32] Cliff is doing a 3D printing of the whole bailouts that would give you more of an accurate idea
[3:15:40] of scale. And it's much more reliable than AI image. Kind of like the kind of diagram is that
[3:15:47] architects used to building now we have this amazing new tool to use. So, um, and the six foot
[3:15:55] six sea level rise by 2100, I think we're going to see that a lot sooner, and this winter will
[3:16:03] be a good view of that. Thank you so much. Okay. Linda Salman is Linda Online? I don't see her here?
[3:16:19] I don't see her in the attendees at this time. Okay. He was trying to be online that I don't know.
[3:16:23] Okay, so we'll hold that aside. Paul, the scale.
[3:16:37] Paul, the scale of respect and resistance.
[3:16:42] Well, I really liked what Rob and I had to say.
[3:16:47] And thank you for that, Rob.
[3:16:49] That could be very helpful information for all parties involved.
[3:16:55] And with that said,
[3:16:59] There's also another possibility of keeping the material on site on the property and that's by using
[3:17:10] Erdum cars on the rail and there are contractors that can bring in their cars and
[3:17:19] electric locomotives to use the existing switching tracks, which I believe on the east side
[3:17:28] you'd probably have to extend the tracks to come off the main, countering corridor, just
[3:17:36] like zero point, or go from state lumber does now.
[3:17:41] They have a, they come off the main corridor, and
[3:17:47] Air dumps would be very helpful because on the west side, the spur tracks extend pretty far down into the baylands.
[3:17:55] Already,
[3:17:59] and an air dump holds like 50 cubic yards.
[3:18:04] So that's like two and a half double trucks of semi's, 20 yards that they all.
[3:18:14] So two and a half times.
[3:18:16] So if it was like 650 truck trips a day,
[3:18:21] we could do like 260 rail cars a day,
[3:18:26] however many they bring in.
[3:18:28] If it's half of that or a quarter of that and fill them up
[3:18:32] And then run them like they do now, the gravel companies, that's what they handle, whether
[3:18:39] it's aggregate, they're running up and down, Caltrain tracks all day with box cars sometimes
[3:18:46] in between the Caltrain.
[3:18:49] So that could be a good possibility.
[3:18:51] I know that any of the things you're doing regarding handling the way that is going to have
[3:18:58] it's cost and hauling it by trucks is the cheapest it's handled one time it's dropped off
[3:19:04] and they do it again so I get that but this job is going to be done right and unfortunately
[3:19:15] there's still provision in the contract that could be approved that says mitigation measures will
[3:19:26] on one feasible. So we should really be looking at what in this project is going to be feasible
[3:19:33] of growth in there. But with that said,
[3:19:41] the contractor, the developers, they need to work
[3:19:45] together, like you guys did. I owe you Cliff and Apology for saying that you were responsible
[3:19:51] will for not want to deal with the city and then you know I wouldn't take the fact that
[3:19:57] you said you didn't say it well I understand what happened and I was frustrated to think
[3:20:04] that for all this time we haven't been working with these agencies for five years so that's
[3:20:10] why I was frustrated so sorry for that but with that said the developers they came up with
[3:20:18] The plan with the city of San Francisco to do the Bolta model and a western entrance to the
[3:20:25] Cal Train Station, four different plans.
[3:20:28] That was done in 2015.
[3:20:31] It's going to expire in 2030.
[3:20:34] It has a 15 year limit.
[3:20:38] What is that cost?
[3:20:39] And what is that going to cost is to try to have to come up with.
[3:20:42] And then the candlestick plan.
[3:20:45] So yeah, we have had a whole bunch of stuff come up.
[3:20:47] And a whole bunch of stuff that was an obligation that should have been done that hasn't
[3:20:51] been done.
[3:20:53] So, yeah, it's time to sew down and we'll look at this.
[3:20:56] We'll take time.
[3:20:57] Let's move that Aussie.
[3:20:59] We'll talk about that.
[3:21:02] Such that we can do now.
[3:21:03] Thank you.
[3:21:04] Okay.
[3:21:05] That's the problem.
[3:21:05] I should understand.
[3:21:10] This is the first time I've heard that suggestion, which I don't know why we haven't
[3:21:17] thought about that because that's the infrastructures right there. So, has that been analyzed
[3:21:24] at all at any point in time as an option and then dismissed because I would think that that
[3:21:32] might also make sense to just use the rail itself if possible and I don't know if that's a
[3:21:41] question for you, BDI, or if it's for staff of staff knows, but I mean, I would think that
[3:21:50] that would be a point to bring up to Caltering unless that's already been brought up and
[3:21:56] dispelred for whatever reason.
[3:22:01] Does anyone know?
[3:22:10] Yeah, I think it would be up for a BDI to have any conversation with Caltering about using the
[3:22:15] So yes, Council member Davis, I think we've had extensive discussions with CalTram about
[3:22:27] like I said, getting over under.
[3:22:30] Around the track. We do have a DE agreement with them that does say that they will not hinder our development, and they will cooperate with us, and it goes both ways. We're supposed to cooperate if they need to use the track and access, and we worked very collaboratively with them when they were doing their electrification.
[3:22:48] But their biggest concern is safety for their passengers. So whatever we do, yeah, that is the first question.
[3:22:56] We did talk to them about using the track,
[3:23:02] loading it up on them, and yeah, the answer was no.
[3:23:08] Because the track is used because of the additional headways now
[3:23:12] that they've added more trains since they electrify.
[3:23:17] They just don't have, they would not consider using the track for that.
[3:23:24] And they were very, they were very adamant about that proposal.
[3:23:29] But yes, we've talked to them about, you know,
[3:23:33] every way we could get over and around.
[3:23:35] We're still working, talking to them, you know,
[3:23:39] about the adgrade crossing, which we think is the most sensible.
[3:23:44] But still, public safety is their biggest concern.
[3:23:47] And, you know, so we'd have to, we'd have to work through that.
[3:23:50] That is our first choice, and I think
[3:23:56] from using the existing rail, they claim
[3:24:01] that they don't allow that at all,
[3:24:03] although we do see specific union using it sometimes
[3:24:06] for movement of goods, but it's very limited.
[3:24:11] And I think that's a grandfathered in contract.
[3:24:14] So yeah.
[3:24:14] That's where I was going to go next.
[3:24:16] Yes.
[3:24:17] If existing exists, it seems to be.
[3:24:19] you've seen them. Yeah, so I've seen them too. And that's I brought it up to them. That
[3:24:23] we waited a minute. I've seen actually, you know, Pacific Union using your track and they're like,
[3:24:27] yeah, it's very limited and it's sort of a grandfathered in. Because Pacific Union, I believe,
[3:24:33] maybe owned it before. They sold it to. They owned that particular easement. So they're,
[3:24:40] they're sort of grandfathered in. But yes, I did bring that up to them.
[3:24:42] This is a follow-up question with that.
[3:24:46] So if you had a spur line, both sides track and you had rail cars lined up and you spent
[3:24:55] the daytime loading the rail cars and don't believe that the commute train runs in the
[3:25:00] middle of the night, you could run that spur right on to the main track onto the spur
[3:25:05] on the other side and you wouldn't be impeding a commuter train.
[3:25:10] Have you investigated that?
[3:25:12] I don't think there's spurs on both sides. I think there's only so you might have to install one and install a rail spher but over three years
[3:25:19] That caused it. Doing that is pretty effective compared to a bunch of trucks. Yeah, all of this great ideas
[3:25:28] And we love the creativity in the thinking and yeah, again, it's we still have to work this through with with Caltering.
[3:25:39] I just wanted to clarify a little bit 7 Pacific on the railroad right away and then Union Pacific got it and my husband was a Union Pacific railroad engineer and drove freight on that line as the South City in his later years.
[3:25:59] Yeah. So they do allow freight on that line. And that's a deal through Union Pacific.
[3:26:08] Yeah. Not Pacific Union, but I'm sorry. That's my dyslexia at this hour.
[3:26:14] Yeah. But they do hazardous waste trains, ammunition trains.
[3:26:21] No, I've seen it. Rock and grade trains.
[3:26:23] they do it all on those lines. And so one would assume that that would be a place to start
[3:26:31] because they have the ultimate right away and shared track with...
[3:26:36] Oh, start hearing.
[3:26:38] Union Pacific.
[3:26:40] Yeah, yeah.
[3:26:41] And they're in that business to make money.
[3:26:43] So, yes.
[3:26:46] That's a good point.
[3:26:47] So are you saying Terry that they could then just contract with Union Pacific and Union Pacific is already grandfathered in?
[3:26:57] So you become a client of Union Pacific instead of having your own deal with Caltering and you just bypass them and go through potentially.
[3:27:06] Who ever would like to say that my husband was afraid engineer on that line. Yeah
[3:27:12] That's smart
[3:27:13] Yeah, that spur is only on one side, so they're still an issue of getting it across the track to them to the Baylands, but that's that's another rich
[3:27:22] That's that yeah, that's the act is for yeah
[3:27:27] Yeah, great ideas
[3:27:30] Okay
[3:27:31] Don't on that all right
[3:27:36] Wait,
[3:27:39] Paul, you got, you got one minute because you've already talked and there's someone back here waiting.
[3:27:44] We want to be fair.
[3:27:46] I just want to, I'd like to sit the record straight.
[3:27:48] That's all.
[3:27:49] If we hear a minute, that's it.
[3:27:50] If we're trying to accomplish something here, there are spurs on both sides of the Caltering tracks.
[3:27:57] Golden State lumber.
[3:28:00] And if the dumps wanted to, they could reactivate your spur through there.
[3:28:05] that the rails are already there, both sides of the country already have spurs, that come off.
[3:28:12] So if you're not sure, say so, but to say there's only a smell on one side is not
[3:28:19] helping the cause.
[3:28:22] Okay, so thank you for the clarification.
[3:28:27] Madam, I think there's a raise hand for Linda Salman, I think she's online now.
[3:28:32] Okay, so I'm gonna speak for her. She sent me a text because she's not technically savvy to do this
[3:28:41] Can't figure out how to talk on this soon, but if you could for me insist that the current property owner
[3:28:47] This is from Linda salmon property owner wanting approval of a general plan immediately began to reimburse the city of Brisbane
[3:28:54] the seven million we have already spent before this on this project before we go any further.
[3:29:01] San Mateo County in the state would love to bankrupt our city and build all over us as they
[3:29:07] had originally planned before mom found the general plan and gathered the town's women together
[3:29:12] at Byron Jensen's to decide to become a city and save ourselves the bay and the mountain.
[3:29:21] And can you add how the city now is, and Park and REC are cutting benefits and raising costs
[3:29:29] for seniors and children for lack of funds, unfair that Tom Tech is trying to bankrupt
[3:29:35] us.
[3:29:36] That's all.
[3:29:37] Thank you.
[3:29:40] Bart, Pantoha.
[3:29:44] Thank you.
[3:29:45] Thank you.
[3:29:47] Thank you.
[3:29:48] Thank you.
[3:29:48] Yeah, the phonetic thing, so I have four children.
[3:29:51] and they've all graduated high school.
[3:29:53] So we had a betting pool and at what point you all went to the same high school that the name would be, you know, said correctly.
[3:30:00] I think by the fourth one they're really, really close. So I, whenever I speak, I do that phonetically because it's, yeah, it's not a very common name.
[3:30:07] Thank you, takes practice. Yeah, yeah, it's, and you did a great job. So appreciate that.
[3:30:13] So I am Bart Panto, I'm the business manager, secretary of charge of the building trades council in San Mateo County. Nice to meet you all, council members, council Mayor Pro Tem.
[3:30:23] The building trades, though, the council represents about 20 construction union trades, approximately
[3:30:31] 13,000 working people in and around San Mateo County, well, in San Mateo County,
[3:30:35] ends those who reside in San Mateo County, as well as a few that reside here in Brisbane.
[3:30:40] We have had a longstanding commitment with BDI to utilize highly skilled trades people with
[3:30:46] building construction trades.
[3:30:47] We are the most, our building trade union workers.
[3:30:51] We're the most current in innovative technology of today's construction.
[3:30:56] We prioritize safety not only for each other on the job,
[3:30:59] but as stewards of our environment, we want a clean and safe environment for all.
[3:31:04] The building trade's council is devoted to finalizing work force standards for the development of the BDI
[3:31:08] and look forward to an inclusive work force agreement that will be available to all traditional construction unions,
[3:31:13] to utilize for the work on this project, including workforce compliance, safety, and dedicated
[3:31:21] employment of our working members. And pathways to careers through various apprenticeship programs.
[3:31:28] So ultimately, to really put it simply, we're looking forward to this project at some point,
[3:31:35] maybe, hopefully coming to fruition. For us, construction work, whether it's a shovel in the dirt,
[3:31:41] You know, the remediation and the cleaning, the foundation work, the vertical work, the linear work, whether it's plumbing, electrical, waterways, drainage.
[3:31:49] Our members are ready to get to work. We're excited to have the opportunity. And really, what I see in this development that this size is the potential, the potential to grow careers in our industries.
[3:32:04] I'm going to retire at some point. You know, a lot of our working members in a retire and we want to build a foundation.
[3:32:11] training for our, you know, our apprentices, if you will, to come through and do that, you know,
[3:32:17] have a career like we did. And to this month, I'll have 30 years as a union member. I know I don't
[3:32:22] look that old. For kids graduate at high school, ready. Three of them are married. So this is, again,
[3:32:31] it sounds like you got a lot to sort out. I've been, you know, listening, I went to a few planning
[3:32:34] miss, committee meetings, you know, in this meeting a lot of really good questions are being asked
[3:32:39] and I'm looking forward again.
[3:32:41] For us, we're happy to build it,
[3:32:44] however you want to build it,
[3:32:45] wherever you want to build it,
[3:32:46] and how high, how wide, or how short,
[3:32:49] whatever, we're going to do it.
[3:32:51] So, and we're excited to do so.
[3:32:52] So, thank you for the time.
[3:32:54] All right, do we have any other slips
[3:32:57] that I don't have, angry?
[3:33:00] We have a raise 10 from Roland the Brunt.
[3:33:02] Okay, go ahead.
[3:33:09] Roland, go ahead.
[3:33:11] Yeah.
[3:33:12] Yeah, I'm out of May.
[3:33:13] Thank you.
[3:33:15] So, the first thing we regard to crossing the tribes, well, Calthrain has got a precedent
[3:33:21] right now, because they are rebuilding the Guadalupe River Bridge, just north of Stamian.
[3:33:30] And the crews, which are Calthrain crews working on the bridge reconstruction, are crossing
[3:33:36] the tracks.
[3:33:37] It's actually a unit-specific track, only once.
[3:33:40] Now, with regards to train movements, I'm not sure it's exacting back and forth between
[3:33:47] the Eastern and the website, such a good idea, but anyway, that discussion about all
[3:33:53] the ongoing dirt with trains is taking place right now with the Baltic Extension of the
[3:34:01] New York New York old yachts of the Santa Clara Station in San Jose, so you can follow how that's
[3:34:09] But the last command I'd like to make very briefly is about the answer that you got earlier,
[3:34:15] which we got to re-request in the transcripts, and I believe you were told one week.
[3:34:21] Our quite frankly, that's an acceptable.
[3:34:24] I have the transcript right in front of me.
[3:34:27] I will forward it to you at the conclusion of the meeting.
[3:34:31] And moving forward, I think it would help both the council and members of the public.
[3:34:39] If Brisbane could introduce a policy that mandates that staff posts the transcript
[3:34:46] at the same time as they post the video on the website.
[3:34:50] And last but not least, I'm about to request that the legislature
[3:34:56] to introduce legislation that mandates these for all public agencies in the state of California.
[3:35:03] Thank you.
[3:35:04] Okay.
[3:35:05] Any others city clerk?
[3:35:10] You know, Madam Mayor, if I could just make a request to roll in to that example that you
[3:35:16] stated, can you email a link to the city council that that information please?
[3:35:28] I have no further hands.
[3:35:29] Okay.
[3:35:32] We still have 28 minutes. We're moving on to topic number three sequencing remediation
[3:35:40] and development council questions. Starting with council member Lens.
[3:35:50] All right. So, okay, I'm page. I'm going off of the staff report from last week.
[3:35:59] So as I'm paid to six of 14,
[3:36:03] the second paragraph, it says that the BNLN's development will not commence until after they approve remediation and full closure activities are completed and then on page 8
[3:36:21] it states state approved remediation for OU SM and OU two must be certified complete before construction permits are issued west of Caltrane.
[3:36:31] So,
[3:36:33] based upon what it says in the staff report and tell me if I got this right, the entire
[3:36:40] west side basically needs to be remediated and certified remediated by the Reglaratory
[3:36:47] Agency's prior to any development occurring on the west side.
[3:37:03] Yes, that's correct.
[3:37:05] Great.
[3:37:06] Thank you.
[3:37:11] Council Member O'Connell?
[3:37:15] I have no questions at this moment.
[3:37:18] Council Member Kern.
[3:37:21] Thank you, Madam Mayor.
[3:37:22] Katie, this one's for you.
[3:37:25] So in the last meeting, this could be a short coming in my notes, but we were talking about something.
[3:37:30] The sequencing with regards to the infrastructure, so this is open space, roads in the general infrastructure.
[3:37:35] And I think you said that the Bay Short District would take you 10 years to complete that infrastructure.
[3:37:41] That's not where my question is. My question is for the following areas, or the districts.
[3:37:48] So I think you said that the roundhouse district, ice how district, ice how district, and the sustainability district would take an additional 10 years.
[3:37:57] Is it all three of those?
[3:37:58] Um, close, not quite. So the sustainability district is, we call it the sustainability district.
[3:38:05] I think for ease of grouping these different uses together, however, the sustainability district
[3:38:09] isn't going to move as its own independent development district, the same way like roundhouse
[3:38:14] and things like that are. So there's pieces of the sustainability sustainability district that will
[3:38:19] move with the Bay Short District. So for example, the utility scale battery storage facility,
[3:38:25] that would move with the base shore district and potentially some of the water infrastructure as well.
[3:38:35] And then you are correct that all that is expected to take 10 years.
[3:38:40] And then for roundhouse and ice house hill, the expectation is that we could move those sort of in tandem.
[3:38:46] Some commercial and ice house hill, some residential and roundhouse, and build those up together.
[3:38:52] and so that would take an additional 10 years for those last two districts on the west side.
[3:38:57] Donna, thank you for that clarification.
[3:39:00] Mayor Pro Tom Davis.
[3:39:03] I asked this question on the BBCag meeting, but I think it's important to ask
[3:39:08] here as well. So the developer proposes building homes on the west side of the site before
[3:39:16] landfill closure and remediation are complete. Meaning if future residents could live a
[3:39:21] in to an active room mediation site. Is this a common approach and what specific measures would
[3:39:28] protect residents from exposure to airborne contaminants and other particulates of concern during
[3:39:34] remediation and how will those protections be monitored and forced while people are living nearby?
[3:39:49] So this type of scenario is not unusual. So the the various remediation plans,
[3:39:55] the R-dips that were discussed for O-U-S-M and O-U-2 contain air monitoring plans,
[3:40:03] perimeter air monitoring plans.
[3:40:04] And so there would be monitoring done at the perimeter of the landfill active remediation
[3:40:11] area to assess protection of potential pollutants that could be leaving the site and moving
[3:40:18] towards the developed residential areas.
[3:40:27] Okay, so I looked at some drafts in the specific plan,
[3:40:33] and the final, and what concerned me was this.
[3:40:39] Everything in orange in the final was removed,
[3:40:43] regarding phasing, everything in orange.
[3:40:48] And so
[3:40:52] the real kicker for me is the infrastructure roadways,
[3:40:56] pedestrian, micromobility, facilities, water, wastewater,
[3:41:01] drainage are all on the right.
[3:41:04] What are the consequences if this isn't followed?
[3:41:08] Do we have built-in consequences?
[3:41:11] What happens?
[3:41:12] Can somebody tell me?
[3:41:23] Can totally see exactly what it is.
[3:41:25] You're holding up, but the specific plan does have broad
[3:41:28] phasing requirements.
[3:41:30] I believe that the more specific and relationships were intended to be defined through the
[3:41:40] development agreement.
[3:41:41] But since that's moving more slowly, we would recommend that we add specific phasing requirements
[3:41:48] to the specific plan before you take action on it so that it is in place at the time you
[3:41:56] take action on the specific plan.
[3:41:57] Well, in this is an implementation, all of this, and so it just seems to me if what is being proposed, that has to be in place, isn't followed, it stops, and that's the consequence.
[3:42:12] Or maybe that, you know, because a, an admonition of, well, we're going to kind of take care of it soon is not enough, it needs to be bulletproof.
[3:42:22] If this is what we're approving, this is what we expect as performance guidelines period.
[3:42:28] That's an agreement, that's a specific plan.
[3:42:32] And again, the specific plan is not in agreement.
[3:42:35] It's not a contract.
[3:42:36] It's a regulatory document that you are adopting.
[3:42:40] So it is appropriate to include performance standards that the city wants to see and, in fact, require.
[3:42:47] And it is, I would say, it's common to say that before you get the certificate of occupancy
[3:42:55] for the 400th unit, you have to have delivered X amount of park space, or those types
[3:43:03] of relationships are very common, and because there's not going to be a concurrent development
[3:43:11] agreement, we 100% agree that the specific plan should have those types of relationships
[3:43:17] to add it to it. So to confirm you'll bring back draft language for us. Yes, that's great.
[3:43:23] I mean, thank you. Okay. Thank you.
[3:43:28] So Council Member O'Connell, you've indicated that you don't have
[3:43:32] questions on this. So we're cycling back to Mayor Protem Davis. No more questions on this section.
[3:43:38] Okay. And Council Member Lens?
[3:43:42] Yes. So on page 9 of 14 of last week's planet or Council packet, this is that the development
[3:43:51] agreement will set detailed timing for open space infrastructure, roadway, remediation,
[3:43:56] and landfill closure, milestones, relative to building permits and certificates of occupancy.
[3:44:02] If the council so choose, choose, could we put that in the specific plan, instead of relying on the development agreement to set these standards?
[3:44:15] Yes, that's the same as what we just said to them.
[3:44:19] I just want to get clarification because this is what it says here and it's an actual role on the same page.
[3:44:25] Sure. Thank you for that.
[3:44:28] All right.
[3:44:30] Councilmember O'Connell, you had no more questions unless you've changed your mind.
[3:44:34] Councilmember Kirk?
[3:44:36] Thank you.
[3:44:38] I'm looking at EIR Volume 1 of 5, page 3-111.
[3:44:47] As we're talking through this, I'm hearing about construction and development taking place from the very north end of the property towards the south end of the property.
[3:44:56] But I'm just curious here. It says that following site
[3:45:00] Preparation and demolition of existing buildings grading will be undertaken from south to north, the opposite direction. And I'm just curious, I'm not a construction expert. Why is that?
[3:45:17] Again, it's page 3-111 of volume 1 of the EIR.
[3:45:22] I would actually, I would look to the applicant to explain the specific staging and construction strategy. They'll do a better job of it than I will. Thank you.
[3:45:39] I believe that's a typo.
[3:45:40] Oh, well, wasn't you going to explain that?
[3:45:43] I'm going to explain that.
[3:45:44] I would explain that.
[3:45:45] But there may have been an early, earlier plan
[3:45:47] of going from South to North that may be
[3:45:50] in where it came from, but it's clearly out of date.
[3:45:55] OK.
[3:45:55] The plan is north to south.
[3:45:57] Got it.
[3:45:57] Thank you.
[3:45:59] And we'll add that to the list of a number of clean up items
[3:46:04] and things that have been identified.
[3:46:06] So we'll add that to our, or rather, list.
[3:46:08] Thank you.
[3:46:08] Thank you.
[3:46:09] I have no further questions on this section, so we go back to Council Member Lens.
[3:46:15] Yeah, I'd say one question to Stephanie from my mind, please.
[3:46:22] You think I'm picking on you?
[3:46:25] So, you know, we've been talking about, you know, the regulates where agencies overseeing
[3:46:32] the remediation requirements and then having inspectors to make sure that everything is going
[3:46:37] to plan, but, you know, there's also the need to have skilled workers to do the war properly.
[3:46:45] And so, tonight, last week, you know, it talked, you know, folks came to the podium,
[3:46:52] got a letter from the building trades, you know, talking about having skilled workers
[3:46:58] to assure that the work is done, you know, as planned, right?
[3:47:04] And so I want you to tell me, like, how, how can you assure that we're going to get skilled workers working at the site?
[3:47:15] To me, it just seems like you would need workers to go through some kind of apprenticeship program.
[3:47:20] So, if you wouldn't mind explaining that, please.
[3:47:22] Yeah,
[3:47:26] and geosynthekos are expert who've been on the site for 20 years, and I assume we'll
[3:47:32] be bidding out the remediation work, but they've done hundreds of these sites before,
[3:47:38] so typically, as the lead remediation contractor for the project, they subcontract out
[3:47:49] to all the contractors. And of course, everybody that's hired has to have a certain amount
[3:47:54] of training and hazardous waste, what they call has wap or 40-hour certification, anybody
[3:48:03] who needs to be on the site has to have that training. So they go through their sub-contracting
[3:48:09] process that is very clear about who they can hire and who the training that those people
[3:48:16] need to be on site, so it's a fairly rigorous subcontracting process that the remedial contractors
[3:48:24] go through.
[3:48:25] Okay, so what you're saying is that all of these folks would go through some kind of apprenticeship
[3:48:29] program to get the certification to do that.
[3:48:33] I'm not sure if it's always an apprenticeship program, but they have to have the certification.
[3:48:37] Yes.
[3:48:39] They have to have the workers have to have the certification.
[3:48:42] There's also qualified license here on site who has to have more training than the workers but the workers have to have a minimum of a 40-hour has wiper.
[3:48:54] Okay, and then so I'm just curious.
[3:48:59] This is a security curiosity question.
[3:49:02] Are you working through some kind of project labor agreement with the trades?
[3:49:08] Yes, we have an existing letter of intent with the building trades and with the
[3:49:13] carpenters that we entered into in roughly shortly after we submitted our application
[3:49:20] for this project in 2005.
[3:49:23] We have a 2006 letter of intent that a PLA will be put in place prior to after we hire
[3:49:30] a general contractor and prior to pulling a building permit.
[3:49:33] That's what the ROI currently states.
[3:49:36] Okay, so you have an existing one then a letter of intent. Yeah, the letter of intent says there will be a PLA in place
[3:49:44] Once we have a general contractor in place and
[3:49:49] Prior to building pulling a building permit. That's our agreement with the trade union and the carpenters
[3:49:55] Okay, yep, all right. Thank you. Mm-hmm.
[3:49:59] Council member Kurt
[3:50:01] No further questions. All right
[3:50:04] Council member Lens, do you have more?
[3:50:05] That was the last for that section.
[3:50:08] That's okay.
[3:50:08] And if I may.
[3:50:12] So I am looking at the original specific plan.
[3:50:20] And on the same page that counts that Mayor Macken brought up
[3:50:24] with the phasing sequence,
[3:50:29] we have is still listed as 2,200 units
[3:50:33] instead of having the range, and in the first two sequences of phasing as the developer has said they'll do one and two that would give them all of their housing and would probably
[3:50:49] would it trigger the infrastructure on the east side at that point?
[3:51:20] Which infrastructure, as we talked about last week,
[3:51:26] that the completion of the 50% is tied to the Geneva Avenue Bridge,
[3:51:36] which, but most of the west side infrastructure, most of the west side development is tied to the west side infrastructure.
[3:51:46] And then we would expect to see the east side infrastructure follow, so just one
[3:51:51] make sure that I-
[3:51:52] So when you say 50% of the build-out, do you mean, because the first two phases are
[3:52:06] specifically for very little commercial and mostly the homes.
[3:52:11] So we're committing to the homes before Geneva Avenue needs to be built in the phasing.
[3:52:21] And when does the wastewater kick in?
[3:52:27] I know that was in the last week, but refreshed my mouth.
[3:52:30] Maria, if you can.
[3:52:35] Is it 50% of the entire square footage or just the homes?
[3:52:45] I'm not sure, with the, I have to look it up with the exact trigger as for you.
[3:52:48] Okay, get back to me. Thank you.
[3:52:53] You don't remember? Yeah.
[3:52:55] You know, I had, I had, I actually had this question in topic 6, but since you brought it up and now council member Mac, I mean, I'll, I'll, I'll, I'll just bring it up as well. So in the, the, the specific plan that
[3:53:12] is on the city's website, in regards to table 9.2.1, in regards to phases and districts,
[3:53:21] it's very general, it's not a lot of meat to the bones and a draft, there was a lot.
[3:53:31] And so I think it would be helpful to bring that back to the next meeting and show that
[3:53:39] on our, you know, check that on the screen for the next meeting, so that we can get an understanding
[3:53:47] of what the floor is and then build from that.
[3:53:53] Is that what Mayor Macken was just showing in orange?
[3:53:56] Something different?
[3:53:57] Yeah, that's what it is.
[3:53:58] And so I just wanted to clarify that, you know, it's, it's hard to read from, you know,
[3:54:04] up some favors and I think for our next meeting having it on the screen and going through it,
[3:54:11] I think would be helpful not only for us but for the public.
[3:54:18] Okay, last call on this
[3:54:21] section before we go to public comment. Anything else? I see none. All right,
[3:54:32] slips I have. I'm going to read the names first. I have Robin Liner, Linda Salmon,
[3:54:38] Michelle Salmon, okay, skip Michelle, Nils,
[3:54:45] Delender, do I have the name right? Okay, so first Robin?
[3:54:57] Thank you for this opportunity. I want to say this is not an ordinary construction project and I think some of the council brought this
[3:55:07] topic up as well. It's an enormous industrial scale earth-moving operation. I've never in my life
[3:55:16] than anything of 2.25 million tons of yards of dirt being moved. It's enormous. The concern
[3:55:26] is not simply how much dirt is being moved, but how much soil is exposed at one time,
[3:55:32] how frequently it will be disturbed, how much dust it will generate. Every track traveling
[3:55:36] under an unpaid road can generate dust. Every load of soil being dumped can release dust.
[3:55:45] Every acre exposed and uncovered.
[3:55:48] Yet the EIR does an interesting thing.
[3:55:51] It explains that fugitive dust, that gets dispersed,
[3:55:55] either in a stockpile or offload of a truck or when you unload it,
[3:56:00] is not to be included.
[3:56:02] Instead, simply the best practices will be observed.
[3:56:07] Now, how do we know that the best practices are sufficient for an
[3:56:11] operation of this magnitude. At this particular location, one we know is one of the
[3:56:16] windiest in the area. I think we need a quantitative estimate of how much dust is
[3:56:23] going to be generated by excavation, loading, unloading of trucks. How much loose soil
[3:56:31] will be exposed at one time? How high will the stockpels get to be? How what will happen in
[3:56:37] winds, and how much water and whose water will be necessary to maintain dust control.
[3:56:45] These are not minor details to be worked out after approval.
[3:56:50] These determine what the environmental impacts will be to those around us who then breathe
[3:56:56] this air.
[3:56:58] My concern is that the EIR does not adequately evaluate the site specific fugitive dust and
[3:57:05] impacts of 2.25 million cubic yards of soil. In fact, the Bay Area Air Quality District
[3:57:13] recognizes that Earth-moving, unpaved roads and bulk handling have distinct sources
[3:57:19] of fugitive dust. Yet the EIR relies on a standard construction control while not providing
[3:57:28] In any analysis, a fuse you disdesk from such a large site.
[3:57:33] I believe there should be mitigation measures for independent inspectors, paid by the developer
[3:57:39] with the authority to express, inspect operations, review truck records, require corrective
[3:57:46] actions, and stop work when necessary, and monitor results and violations should be made
[3:57:53] available to the public.
[3:57:55] We're not just talking about some dirt excavated at a construction site or brought in for foundations.
[3:58:03] We're talking about a vast million cubic yards of soil.
[3:58:09] Thousands and thousands of trucks.
[3:58:11] I'm asking that we simply get the facts.
[3:58:14] That we quantify what the potential best admissions will be for such a large,
[3:58:20] a measurable amount of soil being moved and provide independent enforcement before this work begins.
[3:58:30] Thank you very much.
[3:58:33] Michelle, come on back then.
[3:58:37] What Robin said is really true, and I reported the dust fugitive dust from that side so many times I can't even count.
[3:58:45] And I wanted to go back to what Robin said earlier about inspectors.
[3:58:49] We had apparently inspectors for the Northeastern Ridge development.
[3:58:54] But obviously they did not properly and fully inspect the Northeastern Ridge development,
[3:59:00] or there would not have been extensive building defects that caused the HOA a fortune
[3:59:08] to repair and cause several people who lived there to actually lose their homes.
[3:59:14] and the homeowner's associations sued Brookfield, a big $6 billion company, and Brookfield turned around and sued their subcontractors and actually made money on getting sued.
[3:59:29] Yeah, that's the truth.
[3:59:31] And so when we talk about inspections and making sure that we're doing everything right, we really need to find inspectors that are completely agnostic
[3:59:42] and really are doing the will of the people to make sure that things are safe.
[3:59:48] Because it didn't actually work the way it was supposed to at the Northeast Ridge.
[3:59:52] And neither did a lot of the other medications and things that were agreed upon.
[3:59:57] And so here we are faced with even a much more serious...
[4:00:00] The situation, then that was, and I still think that, you know, the northeast ridges at risk for certain things like it was both on cut and fill. So it could slide.
[4:00:13] And it would be terrible to make this same mistake over again.
[4:00:18] And the fugitive does, it came off that site during the years where they were piling that dirt and moving it around and bringing in dirt from hunters point and everything else.
[4:00:27] The diagram that you showed wasn't quite the full story, because the dust pile, the dirt got up to over 85 feet
[4:00:35] before the then-sitting council finally did something about it and made them bring it back down to
[4:00:41] below what their permit level was. And that dirt got moved around and some of it got put in the quarry
[4:00:46] and got shuffled everywhere. So it really is important to test it, including for invasive species,
[4:00:53] because we also had an incident with Star Thistle that was brought in on the incident with that dirt that fortunately we spotted in a got caught right away before it's spread that's also a very
[4:01:06] nauseous weed that's wiped out tons of California grazing land. And so it really is not just a simple, we're going to, you know,
[4:01:15] move dirt. It is really dangerous thing that we're about to embark on and we need every medication measure we can. Thank you.
[4:01:23] Michelle may I ask, are you going to have questions for Linda? No. Okay. Thank you. That was a one time favor I'm never doing it again. Okay. I'm gonna need a motion to extend the hearing by ten minutes.
[4:01:37] I'll make the motion to extend the meeting ten minutes. Second. All in favor?
[4:01:43] I had one opposed? No. Okay, Nells.
[4:01:57] Hello, Mayor, Vice Mayor, Council members, and CSTF.
[4:02:00] My name is Nells Land and I'm a representative of Carbarders Local 2017 of San Mateo County.
[4:02:05] We support the Baylands Project because it brings the type of development that significantly
[4:02:11] economic opportunity for our community. This project would create hundreds of quality
[4:02:16] construction jobs for working class men and women throughout the Bay Area.
[4:02:19] Our members are eager to be part of this building, this project, and contributing to the success.
[4:02:27] We go on the PLA, we have provided Bill and Trance Council with example of a successful
[4:02:32] tri-party agreement and a waiting for their response.
[4:02:36] We remain committed to working collaboratively with all parties to move forward with this process.
[4:02:40] We look forward to continuing the work together for the port end of the project.
[4:02:45] and carries the city to keep the bail-ass development moving forward.
[4:02:51] Thank you for your time, consideration.
[4:02:52] Thank you.
[4:02:55] So, I have a question related to that for Stephanie.
[4:03:00] You said you have a letter of intent.
[4:03:03] Does that go across all the traits?
[4:03:06] Or just certain unions?
[4:03:13] The letter of intent in 2005 was all the building traits.
[4:03:17] And in 2005 included the Carpinders, the Carpinders have spun off from the building
[4:03:23] trade councils, so we have a separate L.O.I. now with basically mirrors the original
[4:03:30] L.O.I. that we signed with the building trades in 2006.
[4:03:35] Okay, thank you.
[4:03:37] All right, Ingrid, anyone online?
[4:03:43] have heraries from the Roland.
[4:03:46] Roland, go ahead.
[4:03:50] Yes, thank you.
[4:03:51] So very briefly to a call on the comment that the Michelle made and going back to
[4:03:56] the crossing I mentioned of Catherine crossing the tracks.
[4:04:00] About a month ago, my train got stuck for 10 minutes because they had dropped
[4:04:05] debris on the track.
[4:04:07] And while I was waiting, the entire train filled up the Cementos.
[4:04:12] And I will send you a record of the incident.
[4:04:15] So it's a serious issue and I think we need to find other ways to cross this track because
[4:04:21] down there.
[4:04:22] This is just not working for us.
[4:04:24] Thank you.
[4:04:25] Okay.
[4:04:26] Anyone else?
[4:04:27] Online?
[4:04:30] No, Madam Mayor.
[4:04:32] That being said.
[4:04:34] Thank you everyone for joining us.
[4:04:36] Can I get a first and second to continue the public hearing to Monday, October 26th, 26th,
[4:04:42] 26 at 530 p.m.
[4:04:45] Some mode.
[4:04:46] And a second.
[4:04:48] Second.
[4:04:49] All in favor.
[4:04:50] I have anyone opposed?
[4:04:52] No.
[4:04:53] Motion carries this meeting as adjourned at 9.33 p.m.
[4:04:58] Thank you.