Agenda
Agenda: https://brisbaneca.api.civicclerk.com/v1/Meetings/GetMeetingFileStream(fileId=12710,plainText=false)
Full agenda packet (agenda plus every staff report and attachment): https://brisbaneca.api.civicclerk.com/v1/Meetings/GetMeetingFileStream(fileId=12711,plainText=false)
Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[9:24]
The Brisbane Special Meeting of October 26, 2026, calling the meeting to order at 537, would you join me in
[9:59]
the
[10:00]
members attending remotely.
[10:02]
Sit clerk, could we have roll call, please?
[10:04]
Council member Davis?
[10:06]
Council member Lance?
[10:07]
Yes.
[10:07]
Council member O'Connell?
[10:08]
Here.
[10:09]
And Mayor Neckon.
[10:11]
Can I get a first and second to adopt the agenda as a stance?
[10:14]
Some of.
[10:15]
Second.
[10:16]
All in favor?
[10:17]
All right.
[10:17]
Anyone opposed?
[10:21]
All right.
[10:23]
Some of you have heard this before, but we're going to repeat it again.
[10:27]
We welcome the public to comment or ask questions during tonight's hearing.
[10:31]
please fill out a form to speak and hand to our city clerk. It forms on a lot of the chairs.
[10:37]
Speakers will have four minutes for each topic. There's a timer on the screen. You can use
[10:41]
for reference. It's extremely important for speakers to stay on topic. If you don't stay on
[10:47]
topic, I will have to stop you. If a speaker continues to ignore the rules, you'll be warned
[10:52]
and may be precluded from speaking on any other items tonight. So let's start filling out those
[11:01]
And to start tonight's meeting, this is Council's opportunity to bring up any general questions or concerns related to these hearings, and I'm told that our city attorney has comments to make on some correspondence to start this.
[11:21]
I don't have any affirmative comments to make, but I'm certainly happy to respond to questions from the Council.
[11:26]
All right, thank you. Then we'll start with Council's opportunity to bring up questions and comments starting with Mayor Pro Tem Davis.
[11:34]
It's
[11:38]
to confirm we're on land use restrictions and enforcement.
[11:41]
We're on just general comments.
[11:43]
General comments.
[11:44]
Sorry, sorry, sorry.
[11:45]
No, I don't.
[11:46]
Okay.
[11:47]
Council member O'Connell.
[11:51]
In response to some of the questions about budgeting last year.
[11:56]
Not budgeting, but costs last week.
[12:01]
We did get a letter in response from the Baylands.
[12:05]
and does staff have any comments on that letter?
[12:14]
Through the chair, I think we're happy to take questions.
[12:16]
I don't have any specific comments at this time,
[12:18]
but if the council has questions related to it,
[12:20]
happy to answer them.
[12:21]
Okay.
[12:24]
I'll put it in another way.
[12:26]
Does staff feel that the applicant's response to
[12:33]
to the situation of the money owed is reasonable?
[12:47]
We don't agree with many of the characterizations in the letter.
[12:51]
we understand the reason it was written attorneys from my office are in touch with attorneys
[12:59]
from BDI on the outstanding balance,
[13:05]
but no, we certainly don't agree with many of the
[13:07]
characterizations of the letter.
[13:09]
Thank you.
[13:10]
No further questions.
[13:12]
Okay.
[13:12]
You can't smell reliance.
[13:15]
Yes.
[13:16]
Thank you, Madam Mayor.
[13:17]
Stephanie, if you wouldn't mind coming to the vote, please.
[13:20]
If you speak up in the name of the vote, please.
[13:24]
Thanks Michelle.
[13:27]
Anything?
[13:28]
Yes.
[13:28]
Some members.
[13:29]
Stephanie, she comes from the Baylands.
[13:30]
Nice, Stephanie.
[13:32]
Yeah, thank you for sending letter this afternoon.
[13:37]
So Raymond couldn't make tonight's meeting.
[13:40]
He's the person who signed the letter.
[13:41]
He's our controller.
[13:42]
Control.
[13:44]
Okay.
[13:45]
So, you know, in the letter A acknowledges that, you know, that there is an agreement in which BDI, you know,
[13:55]
reimburse a city for a cost that it has incurred.
[14:00]
Okay, so there's no questioning about that.
[14:04]
So, you know, also in the document, it talks about that you've requested copies of
[14:12]
And boys, it isn't supporting documentation related to EIR preparation and associated technical
[14:19]
studies.
[14:19]
And I believe that we've given you everything that has come to us and that you've requested.
[14:25]
So, are you still still still feel that you're missing things?
[14:29]
Council member, let's I'm not personally part of the finance team.
[14:33]
So, you know, I asked them to write that letter and in response to your questions last week.
[14:40]
So, I do know that, you know, unfortunately attorneys are talking, and I think that we will get to a solution, and, you know, that makes everybody whole.
[14:54]
That's the goal.
[14:56]
All right. No, that's good.
[14:59]
Yeah.
[15:00]
This is the, you know, also note that you appreciate the city's patience as BDI works through past invoices and consultant contracts.
[15:08]
So, and then it says, you know, we will continue working with the city to gather the necessary documentation to bring this issue to a close, which is, you know, what you're saying.
[15:20]
So, I'm assuming that coming to a close means that BDI reimburse the city in a whole, you know,
[15:31]
fully reimburses the city for the the work that it's conducted on behalf of creating this
[15:37]
city plan and the EIR documents. Is that a correct statement or assumption I should say?
[15:46]
Again, I think the attorneys are talking the finance team is talking to the city and yeah, I think
[15:55]
I'm going to hopefully work out all of the questions and concerns and the
[16:04]
invoices will be paid.
[16:08]
I have some other questions but if other council members would like to ask questions.
[16:12]
I would just like a clarification on this as well.
[16:15]
So city manager Dennis, could you verify?
[16:18]
Have we sent them all the documentation that has been requested?
[16:22]
And I'm referencing there have been a series of emails starting all year through 2026 about requests for documents.
[16:31]
So we're familiar on the council that there has been requests.
[16:35]
But it's been all year and we're still not seeing these invoices resolved.
[16:39]
So I don't understand the hold up.
[16:41]
Thank you.
[16:41]
Staff has transmitted materials to BDI on more than one occasion in the last 18 months or so.
[16:48]
There were some documents that we did find a little bit later in that search, but we believe at this point we have completed that assignment in space.
[17:00]
All right,
[17:03]
I just I guess I have to comment I think it's really important that if we are moving along on a project one of the biggest projects that Brisbane has ever seen.
[17:17]
the implication of your wanting us as a partner to move this along and it to be an important
[17:24]
part of Brisbane that we can both be proud of includes financial assurances and this is not
[17:29]
looking good and I'm sure if you heard from our residents about this it would not vote well.
[17:38]
So I would really like to see some questions clear this up
[17:43]
because it's been a whole year of talking about documents.
[17:47]
And it's we're getting to the later stages of this project
[17:51]
that needs to be dealt with.
[17:52]
It's a lot of money and it keeps increasing as you know.
[17:57]
So that's just my two cents.
[17:59]
Council Member Lens?
[18:04]
Yes, Stephanie.
[18:05]
I mean,
[18:08]
you know, I would like to approve the specific plan
[18:12]
in the EIR. I like to see the site remediated. I want to build the housing. Right? That's really
[18:19]
important.
[18:21]
But to create these documents, the city has invested a lot of money and time.
[18:27]
And part of the agreement is being reimbursed.
[18:33]
There's been enough time for you to evaluate and
[18:36]
start paying us in some kind of payment program that I hope that you can work with staff on.
[18:44]
So,
[18:49]
I mean, I would like to see some kind of payment plan established by our next meeting
[18:54]
so that then you can give us an update and say, okay, yeah, we've worked out some things,
[18:59]
and this is what we're doing, going months without any payments is not acceptable.
[19:08]
Thank you.
[19:09]
Well, I would just add to that that even a payment program at this point we've had 10 months.
[19:16]
That's been a payment program.
[19:19]
I'd like to see the balance paid because there's going to be more consultants and fees incurred.
[19:25]
And what is really important I think to our community is seeing that there's a financial stability behind this whole project that it's not going to fall onto us.
[19:36]
that's something that we have heard over and over
[19:39]
and over from our constituents.
[19:41]
What happens if they don't remediate?
[19:43]
What if they start and stop?
[19:45]
Do they have the resources to really follow through?
[19:49]
And this isn't a very good reassurance.
[19:54]
So I would strongly suggest we try to clear this up
[19:57]
and expedite it.
[19:58]
Thank you.
[20:03]
Staff, one was the last time we received
[20:04]
payment of any kind from BDI.
[20:09]
I think it was, let me get the note, July, I think it was July 15, July 15, but it was
[20:20]
towards the outstanding amount.
[20:22]
And what was that value?
[20:24]
At the time,
[20:27]
the amount owed was about $6 million they believe and the payment was $1.4.
[20:36]
And how much have they incurred since that time?
[20:39]
Currently,
[20:41]
the amount the total amount allowed is 7.2.
[20:45]
No, but how, okay, so they incurred.
[20:47]
So the balance was 6 and then it went down.
[20:51]
Try to figure out how much is?
[20:52]
Approximately 800,000.
[20:55]
That's the delta.
[20:57]
Okay, thank you.
[21:00]
All right.
[21:01]
Any other general questions comments from the council?
[21:09]
And do we want to review the hearing schedule, anyone?
[21:20]
Or we've had a lot of correspondence from City Clerk on that.
[21:24]
If we had any major discussion, we could do that tonight
[21:27]
or if everyone's kind of in the loop and satisfied with where we're headed on that.
[21:33]
Why do we cancel the second of December?
[21:37]
I know we had the 9th, 10th of December, 10th of November, 10th of February, as a play
[21:44]
soldier, and I forgot that I have a conflict that day, so I know that that's the reason
[21:47]
why the 9th.
[21:49]
But I think we had the first in the second house.
[21:51]
How's the member of Connell had a conflict?
[21:57]
I'm the vice chair of the roundtable, and that will be my last meeting for them, and
[22:04]
No, I'm not the chair anymore of the technical work in groups, but if needed, I could skip that.
[22:19]
Didn't we have like the second and the third, which is really odd, so I thought to me that was an either or one of those days, right?
[22:28]
So we're planning to first
[22:30]
See you at the third, then.
[22:32]
Because you're not available on the second Wednesday. Okay.
[22:37]
Okay. That's it.
[22:40]
Tonight, on the agenda consideration of proposed bail-and-specific plan and related actions, including amendments to the
[22:47]
Brisbane General Plan, land use and circulation elements, amendments to Title Section 17 of the
[22:53]
Brisbane Municipal Code, to establish zoning regulations, adoption of the Bayshore Mobility Plan, and
[22:59]
certification of the final environmental impact report prepared for this project in accordance
[23:05]
with the California Environmental Quality Act, also known as Sequa. Tonight, we will continue
[23:12]
our public hearing and continue with questions on remediation and phasing. Let's start
[23:19]
the meeting. I believe staff has a slide presentation.
[23:23]
Yes, thank you.
[23:34]
So thank you Mayor Mack and members of the Council. As mentioned, this
[23:38]
As the sixth of the series of this public hearing reviewing the Bayland specific plan and final
[23:44]
environmental impact report, next slide, please.
[23:50]
As mentioned, tonight's topic is the phasing and remediation, a measure JJ topics 3A, 3C,
[23:59]
3D, 3F, and 3K, this is a continuation of this topic started two meetings ago.
[24:06]
Next, please.
[24:10]
In just a little bit of housekeeping, we just address this, or the council just addressed
[24:14]
us a few moments ago, this is the proposed upcoming hearing schedule, and then we've
[24:21]
assigned the tentative topics based on the order of how they've been proposed, understanding
[24:27]
really we've got dates assigned, and then the topics would slot in as they are ready.
[24:34]
So tonight we continue with the remediation, the following topic coming up next would be
[24:41]
water infrastructure and then in a subsequent meeting would be both the financing revenue
[24:47]
positive analysis as well as the public financing mechanisms.
[24:53]
Then from that point out we just have November 23rd, December 3rd and either December 7th
[24:59]
or 8th, just as Baylands tentative meetings, so those are open depending on either how the topics get covered in these first meetings and or if there are additional topics or proposed by the Council for further discussion.
[25:22]
Next, please.
[25:25]
And then also in response to requests for council, we've developed a, this is, I'd say it's a prototype for a comments and responses tracker.
[25:35]
We've tried a few different tools to basically what we want to do is track the comments and the questions from both the council members and the public and then also have responses.
[25:47]
and indicate who made the responses and and and basically be able to just track the different
[25:54]
comments through. So this first document that was distributed to Council, it's also
[25:59]
available to the public. I believe there's printouts of this. This covers the first three
[26:04]
meetings. So it's not up to date entirely, but we took the first three meetings and did a series
[26:11]
of it's kind of combination of manual bookkeeping and kind of data crunching and then also
[26:19]
putting it through AI in terms of creating something that's digestible and groups comments
[26:27]
by council member comments versus public comments. They're generally in the order received,
[26:33]
but they are in those grouping so you can track for each topic, what were the questions and
[26:38]
from Council, what came from the public. Also the responses, it's a combination of what was
[26:47]
responded to in the meeting, but also subsequently where there were additional information
[26:53]
that staff were able to add into the tracker. Those are in there as well. So this is meant
[27:00]
to be a tracker for questions and comments that have come up. General responses, and then ultimately
[27:08]
this could also be used to determine which things need further basically to come back for further
[27:14]
discussion, what are items that are relatively straightforward that could be put in red line,
[27:20]
for example, into another review plan. What have you, but first we wanted to just develop the
[27:27]
tool, see if this met the desires of the council members for tracking purposes and get any kind
[27:35]
input. If this is working, you can give us any kind of comments and then we can proceed with the
[27:40]
remaining meetings that have occurred. Kevin, thank you very much. It's just really extremely
[27:46]
valuable and that's what we need because as we accumulate all these hearings and a lot of detail,
[27:52]
it's really hard to track and I'm always trying to take notes but still it's challenging and this
[27:58]
I, I saw what you sent to us. It's really well done. I appreciate that. It's a big effort and, and it's really badly needed. So thank you.
[28:08]
Anyone else?
[28:10]
No, I just, I'm, I love the way that you organized it.
[28:14]
You took questions that were really long, at least mine were and made them very succinct.
[28:19]
So I'll just say the Clark Conway, his name has an E at the end.
[28:25]
So we should add that and it's just one typo that I saw
[28:30]
Yeah, there may be some of those so we'll want to correct those and
[28:35]
Anyway, we can clear that up, but some of it comes from
[28:41]
Hearing it's a transcription. Yeah, so and so I would say it's this has been lightly reviewed, but
[28:48]
Those are the kind of typos. We're certainly would appreciate getting that kind of editing. Thank you
[28:55]
And I believe the applicant may have a presentation tonight.
[29:00]
Sorry, we do have more slides.
[29:02]
I'm sorry.
[29:04]
So I would say that was kind of the housekeeping.
[29:06]
And then now we'll get into.
[29:08]
These next slides are follow-ups to generally these are trying to respond to
[29:14]
questions and direction that were in the last council meeting.
[29:19]
So they relate to.
[29:22]
Primarily phasing but then phasing as it relates to grading.
[29:25]
in such. So next slide, please.
[29:31]
So the May 2020 specific plan, which we're looking at, includes
[29:36]
a very high level division of phasing, with basically phase one, West Baylands, phase two,
[29:43]
East Baylands. Staff would recommend adding more specific phasing requirements. This is something
[29:49]
I think the council has articulated and we would certainly agree. The requirements can be
[29:58]
a specific plan and can be...
[30:00]
The adopted prior to any development agreement. Next, please.
[30:08]
So this is basically showing how this would look. So first thing I'll say, this is a lot
[30:15]
of things on the screen. These documents can come back, particularly in the meeting where
[30:21]
we're talking about. This is just to show the structure of the tables, and then we'll
[30:27]
the next round of slides will go into E cell of the stable so that we don't have the
[30:32]
squid. So this is me. Yeah, no, we don't expect. And then like I said, we'll have printouts
[30:39]
of this. I'd say this is still a work in progress. So by the time we talk about the financing
[30:46]
and such later in November, we'll have this to a place that it's ready to be printed out
[30:54]
But the idea is that it has the different columns for the district that opens based basically the pieces of infrastructure and then how do those get phased in relation to the development.
[31:09]
So the next slides we'll walk through each of the districts and provide the highlights of how different infrastructure components could be phased with development.
[31:20]
Just as a reminder, there's the five districts, the base shore, the roundhouse isil sustainability, and the campus east, and staff recommends each district includes specific phasing requirements.
[31:35]
Next, please.
[31:38]
Starting with the base shore district as a reminder, this would include, this would be the first phase, presumably with 980 dwelling units and up to 900,000 square feet of commercial.
[31:51]
next please.
[31:57]
And for this one I'll walk through each of these. This could take a while if I
[32:02]
do this on every single one I'm happy to do that, but this particular district I think is a good
[32:08]
illustration of how the timing of the infrastructure components go in relation to development that's
[32:16]
coming out of the ground. So starting with Sunnydale Park, which is the little park at the very
[32:21]
North End, or the very, I guess, of the Northeast, that would be built prior to final certificate
[32:29]
of occupancy for the adjacent block A1, so those go concurrently so that park would need
[32:37]
to be finished by the time people are moving into the housing in block A1.
[32:43]
Next you go to Baylands Park, and this would be in phases, because Baylands Park is very long,
[32:50]
And if you remember on the map, it's basically three blocks long.
[32:55]
So with each phase of development with the certificate of occupancy, that corresponding
[33:01]
piece of the park would need to be completed so that it's there for the people when they
[33:06]
move in.
[33:07]
The CalStrain Station Plaza would need to be completed prior to certificate of occupancy
[33:13]
for the first commercial building adjacent on blocks A11 and H12.
[33:19]
And then more globally, the wet and dryer utilities and the roadways, pedestrian improvements,
[33:25]
and micro mobility facilities would be completed, blocked by block, as specified in connection
[33:31]
with the subdivision map and public improvement agreements.
[33:35]
So these would go again concurrently with either the development or would proceed as needed,
[33:41]
particularly for extending the utilities in advance of the development.
[33:44]
It can happen before you move on. I have a question for you.
[33:47]
Sure. So, the Caltering Station Plaza aren't their homes in that area, at that there was
[33:54]
some higher dense housing. We could go to Angel, if you could go to the prior,
[34:07]
so that would be...
[34:09]
Oh, Eric is going to chime in, sir.
[34:10]
Oh, since you can see the Caltering Plaza is flanked by blocks A11 and 12, and that's the
[34:18]
density commercials, the commercial ones. Okay, I just wanted to confirm. Okay, thank you.
[34:23]
Sure.
[34:25]
So if we go past the slide to the next slide,
[34:30]
and then this, I would say, is another
[34:32]
work on progress, don't squint. What we're trying to do is put the map and the timing together
[34:38]
in a way, particularly for those visually oriented to try to match exactly that kind of thing.
[34:45]
What is exactly next at the Caltering Plaza and when do those come in during the timing
[34:51]
So, we can work on this graphic, the fonts are way too small, but the idea is to try to create a visual timeline, essentially, of matching the map to the timing of these different improvements.
[35:06]
Excuse me. May I ask a question?
[35:09]
Yes.
[35:09]
On your previous comment, you said, tied with public improvement agreements.
[35:15]
Would those agreements be in the specific plan, or are those agreements going to be more of a developer agreement or something else?
[35:28]
Yeah, so those were intended to refer to the types of agreements that go along with a subdivision map.
[35:35]
So when a first step in the process would be to have a tentative map approved, the tentative map would be approved with conditions,
[35:43]
which spell out the specific timing for the delivery of that infrastructure and then before
[35:48]
the final map can be approved, there would be a public improvement agreement or subdivision
[35:53]
improvement agreement that provides both the technical specifications for that infrastructure
[36:00]
as well as security to make sure that it's installed. And that would be entered into
[36:06]
you, the developer and the city using forms that public works, maintains, and would
[36:18]
help define the specific infrastructure and the security for providing that would be required
[36:24]
before a final map could be recorded.
[36:26]
Great.
[36:27]
Thank you.
[36:27]
I appreciate the answer.
[36:31]
Okay.
[36:31]
My report time.
[36:32]
She has a question.
[36:33]
So, because this is so small, you'll have to just be my eyes, but where it says 8, 8, 8, 8, 8, 6, is that little white box?
[36:46]
Does that say the amount of units that are in those sections, it'd be good to know if you
[36:52]
back to the last slide where it shows like prior to A1 or A2A3, like it'd be good to know
[37:05]
what those blocks equate to in terms of units. If you have an understanding, okay, after
[37:11]
the first 100 units this, after. Yeah, and you can equate there. There is a block by block
[37:18]
breakdown in the specific plan for each of the districts that we're going through.
[37:24]
It's in chapter two.
[37:27]
This district that we're looking at, it's table.
[37:30]
2.5.2 on page 2, 18, and then there's a corresponding table for each of the districts that has exactly the information that you're looking for.
[37:42]
But roughly, yeah, so that was part of the thinking as we were pairing up both the geography and the number of units that would equate to how much open space was being provided.
[37:55]
go back for a second. I want to see what's connected with the A13 and A. Oh, we've just
[38:02]
not gotten there yet.
[38:05]
A13 is three hundred and ten. Yeah, but I was just curious, like, what? Is there
[38:12]
anything tied to those? A13 and A14 now. So, for example, that other than utilities, so there are
[38:23]
for all blocks, the wet and dry utilities,
[38:25]
the roadways, the pedestrian improvements,
[38:28]
micro mobility facilities, those are all,
[38:30]
that's kind of universal.
[38:33]
In this case, and with the teeny tiny little,
[38:36]
these are great. First of all, I think, yes,
[38:38]
we can put the unit numbers on each block.
[38:40]
I think that's a great idea, and, again,
[38:43]
for if we can make something that's visual
[38:45]
and understandable in a way that
[38:49]
shows those numbers, the teeny tiny little white ones,
[38:52]
correspond to the park that's associated with that piece of development. So, for example,
[38:58]
A2 has a little teeny tiny 2A next to it, and that refers to the 2A circle next door with
[39:05]
the park. So, it's meant to sort of talk about a lot of different things happening all at once
[39:11]
in a way that's graphic, but that makes sense that those are associated with, because those
[39:18]
correspond with that block. But I think, I mean, essentially, correct me if I'm wrong,
[39:24]
they could prioritize a 13 and a 14 and build 620 units before delivering any park space
[39:33]
or any of all they would have to do is utilities and infrastructure and they could prioritize
[39:37]
doing all that first, which is the bulk of the units before we would see anything.
[39:47]
That's helpful feedback and I think that can inform, as we continue work on this phasing plan,
[39:54]
if that would be a concern, is if you have a lot of new higher density units coming in
[40:01]
without the amenities to serve those units, you'd want to build in some safeguards into your phasing plan.
[40:07]
Thank you.
[40:07]
And then just for the public sake, because they're not seeing what I'm seeing, A1 is 100 units,
[40:13]
A2 is 50 units, A3 is 40 units, A4 is 60 units, A5 is 60 units, A6 is 60 units, A7 is 60 units, A7 the units, A9 is 60 units, and A13 and A14 are each 310 units.
[40:44]
We can move to the next slide if there's no further comments.
[40:47]
and, again, yeah, point well taken and we can add those unit counts to these future diagrams.
[40:56]
I'll go through the next districts a little more quickly, just because I think you kind
[41:00]
of see the concept.
[41:01]
We can stop for specific questions, but I won't necessarily read through the entire thing,
[41:07]
but Rantos District comes next, that's 1220 units or up to 1220 with 200,000 square feet
[41:14]
commercial. Next please. So we see Bayland's Park coming in in phases prior to
[41:23]
certificate vacancy for those adjacent blocks. The roundhouse park and that's
[41:29]
that's a larger park is prior to certificate vacancy for again the residential
[41:35]
phases around it. Blocks B1, B2, B3, B4, 6, 7, 10 and 11. The ecological park
[41:43]
South, sorry, North the Main Street would be prior to final strength of occupancy for
[41:49]
blocks B-10 and 11, which are next to it.
[41:53]
And then we get into the more global Geneva Avenue west of the Caltering right away would
[42:00]
be completed on a block by block basis, again, as specified in connection with the subdivision
[42:05]
map and public improvement agreements, same with wet and dry utilities and the roadway
[42:10]
pedestrian improvements.
[42:17]
Another law. Okay, so looking at this, because I've turned the page
[42:22]
down the specific plan, so I'm seeing the breakdown for these areas too. And obviously what stands
[42:29]
out is B-14, which is the mid-density residential that represents 600 units out of the 1200 and
[42:36]
20 that this area consists of. And that's not seeming to be tied to anything as it pertains to your
[42:44]
last slide, so I know I already said this, but just like calling it out for a council to be aware of and for staff to note that I think that this representing half the units without being tied to much of anything is an area of opportunity for us to look at.
[43:03]
Thank you. Next slide in this one, we can again, the idea and this is a work in progress I'd say is to try to marry the.
[43:16]
the numbers to the phasing to something graphical, so that we can follow, but we'll work on font sizes and this is really meant to be printed more than anything.
[43:28]
Next, if we go to the, oops, we lost our title on this next.
[43:33]
Oh, there it is. I sealed district. Ice house hill district is 3.4 million square feet of commercial.
[43:39]
So, at this point, we are on the other side of Main Street, so no residential development in this area.
[43:47]
If you go to the next slide, please.
[43:51]
A lot of exciting infrastructure and components, the ecological park with community fields.
[43:58]
Ecological park would be completed in phases prior to the final certificate of occupancy for those blocks C1 and C2 and C4 and C5.
[44:08]
So, again, those are the uses that are on each side of that part of the ecological park.
[44:17]
Then we get into the series of the community fields, the West Royal Trail, the Ice House, Hill Habitat.
[44:24]
Those are all coming prior to final certificate of occupancy for the 1,000 first Baylands Dwelling Unit.
[44:32]
So this is a little different. It's less related to the adjacent development. Right next to it, it's now tied to a threshold related to the progress of the residential development.
[44:44]
Yeah, and I think that that is in part responsive to the comment that Council Member Davis, you are starting to bring up is that if those higher density blocks were developed, that would contribute and trigger the development of these large
[45:00]
Mr. Parks, sooner, but that doesn't take away from the point that you raised about wanting other things tied to that potentially, but this is one place where that factors in for sure.
[45:12]
This is really helpful. Thank you.
[45:16]
And then again, the same with Main Street, went through a utilities roadways, same with the other phases as all come blocked by block, as specified in the various agreements.
[45:28]
Kevin, I have a question for you, so what you're laying out for us is just for reference
[45:37]
to give us kind of a basic framework and that it's the council's pleasure to work with
[45:44]
you all to, you know, maybe refine the traders and, okay, I see you, not in your head.
[45:51]
All right, thank you.
[45:52]
Yeah, this is a framework and it's in draft mode, so it's been kind of going back and forth and yeah, so these kinds of comments and feedback are helpful and we can, you know, take note and keep refining and then have something ready to show the council at a later date, but with this, I think these initial comments are helpful for helping us find two things at this point.
[46:22]
If we move down, skip the few slides to the, there we go, sustainability district.
[46:31]
Now, this one has essential infrastructure and renewable energy facilities, including the solar storage systems,
[46:38]
the water recycling and storm water management facilities, and the open space features, such as the Lagoon Park, and the Baylands Preserve Park.
[46:48]
Next, please.
[46:52]
So, then we have a few triggers here, the Bay Trail and Visitation Creek, would be proposed to be required prior to certificate of occupancy for 1.25 million square feet of commercial uses in the East Campus District, and I'm trying to think of a kind of a way, an example that's close to what would that mean.
[47:17]
That's a little more than, so previously I worked at the city of Berlin game, the Meta campus or the Facebook campus there in Berlin game is 775,000 square feet.
[47:30]
So this would be not quite twice as much, but that's when the betrayal of visitation Creek would be required.
[47:37]
The valence preserve would be required prior to the first 1 million square feet, Lagoon Park and Lagoon Road realignment, the same water recycling facility has a different threshold.
[47:51]
That's one sufficient effluent is generated from development, which is estimated to be about 20% of full build out.
[47:59]
We'll talk more about that, and it's been an item of a lot of interest in our when we do get to the water topics in the next meeting or thereabouts.
[48:10]
Same with the water storage capacity, it's when required by the California Water Services Company, but as we say that's evolving, so we will continue to discuss that.
[48:24]
And then now skip this one, it's more kind of maps and colors and stuff, but last but not least is the campus east district with 2.5 million square feet of commercial plus the parks in open space.
[48:39]
And if you go to the next slide, please, all of these are completed on the block by block basis as specified, so that includes the tunnel avenue improvements at the realigned lagoon road.
[48:53]
includes Lagoon Road, Sierra Point Parkway,
[48:56]
Visitation Creek Road, the Wet and Dry Utilities
[48:59]
and the Pedestrian Improvements and Utilities
[49:02]
and Micromobility Facilities.
[49:09]
So again, this is a framework we're working on it.
[49:11]
Receiving comments and we'll come back with more specificity.
[49:15]
We'll also be some kind of more global phasing requirements
[49:19]
that apply to all of the phases.
[49:22]
And we don't have that on these slides, but that will come back as well.
[49:25]
I'd like to ask a question, so the B13 and 14, because those are the taller, more
[49:33]
dense housing, are those the affordable units?
[49:39]
Who we know?
[49:40]
We don't know the answer to that.
[49:42]
We could find out unless.
[49:44]
Do we know where the affordable, the BDIU had talked about working with non-profit developers,
[49:52]
so I'm curious where that would be in this map?
[49:56]
Do we know?
[50:00]
I do not, but we, oh, sorry, go ahead. My apologies.
[50:06]
Specifically, Madam Mayor, we don't have a final decision on that.
[50:10]
But what we have been discussing is, I can't see the numbers on this either.
[50:17]
But it's the, a way that I'm in roadhouse.
[50:20]
I mean, roundhouse now, okay.
[50:22]
I think we are talking for the Affordable Peace at the B14 piece of that at the B14 site along the river track for the Affordable Housing.
[50:35]
And then in the base or district, if
[50:43]
you can flip back to that just quickly,
[50:48]
yeah.
[50:49]
No, it's the A1 right on Sunnydale there.
[50:54]
So it's close to the, close to the counter-instation, and A1.
[51:00]
Though I'm in the, it's the block in the North West corner,
[51:06]
and that we have been discussing
[51:07]
about, the first affordable, and it would ideally be a senior affordable building on that side.
[51:18]
And I bring that up because the public waiting with faded breath all through the peninsula
[51:26]
is waiting for the affordable component.
[51:29]
And I was a little bit depressed peering that the B-14 were not going to be on the front end.
[51:40]
Since Mayor Prochem Davis had noted that those were not tied to any phasing.
[51:46]
So they're probably the latter part of the development.
[51:48]
Is that correct?
[51:50]
No.
[51:50]
The basure district would be, as we talked about in theory, the first, and that, and that first affordable unit would be sized to make the 15% inclusionary requirement, so it would be about a hundred and ten hundred and twenty unit, potentially senior affordable, potentially senior, and then roundhouse has its own affordable 15% component.
[52:19]
and that's where we're looking at the B14 and that would be in the second.
[52:23]
The second tranche of development. Okay, so the second tranche. Yeah, but the first tranche is
[52:30]
Is this piece here on the? Thank you for that. If I may. Yes, please.
[52:37]
And this is directed towards staff. I know there was some concern with H.C.D. in the past about senior
[52:49]
housing, not meeting the requirement of low income housing because otherwise every city would
[52:55]
just building senior housing. So is that a consideration?
[53:02]
Well, independent living senior housing does meet the definition. There are issues.
[53:08]
If it's an assisted living facility or a medical facility where people
[53:13]
congregate care facility, where people are living in things that don't meet the census
[53:17]
definition of a dwelling unit, that doesn't count towards greener production,
[53:22]
but independent senior housing definitely counts.
[53:27]
Okay, thank you.
[53:32]
Do you have more Kevin?
[53:34]
I do, yeah.
[53:35]
So hopefully these last ones, if we can scroll down to slide 24, please.
[53:43]
Here we go.
[53:44]
So we've talked a lot about soil movement.
[53:46]
So how does that work with phasing?
[53:49]
Now, reading the EIR, there's the big total number of the amount of soil that's being moved.
[53:55]
It's about two and a half million cubic yards thereabouts.
[53:58]
And it does describe the total amount of time that would take in the total number of trucks.
[54:07]
EIRs are there to identify the impacts, the cumulative impacts.
[54:14]
It's what's in that analysis doesn't necessarily describe the timing of how all of the soil would be moved.
[54:23]
So this is attempting kind of a back of the envelope, but we've been according to a BDI on the kind of phasing and how much soil would be moved at different times.
[54:35]
So, the base or district would start with about a little over 500,000 cubic yards and that is, let me, sorry.
[54:48]
For just looking at percentages, that's about 22% of the total.
[54:52]
So, that's just where we start off with.
[54:55]
The round town district would come later, so, you know, we don't know exactly how much later,
[55:01]
but it's not going to be concurrent with base or district.
[55:07]
So a few months years, what have you down the road,
[55:12]
would be the next phase of development
[55:13]
and that would be a 133,000 50 cubic yards,
[55:18]
which would be about a third of the total.
[55:21]
And then the most earth-moving would be with the Isle.
[55:25]
Isle House Hill District, which is 44% of the total,
[55:29]
that over a million's cubic yards.
[55:35]
If we go in the next slide, please.
[55:38]
And then in terms of regulating, so there's just for starters, the general plan policy 189,
[55:45]
and the Brisbane Municipal Code Limit, the construction truck traffic from Monday to Friday,
[55:50]
70, and to 7 p.m. That's just the base from where we start, that's in the code, but next slide, please.
[55:57]
There are some mitigation measures in the EIR, particularly program EIR mitigation measure
[56:04]
for N-N-12 and nobody can see this so we're going to go the next slide which has hopefully
[56:12]
bigger type that we can read a little better and this is verbatim out of the EIR I thought
[56:18]
it was important given the interest so it's all here and it basically says and I will read
[56:26]
if unless somebody stops me, but in conjunction with all construction permits, site-specific development and infrastructure project, subject to the city of Brisbane approval,
[56:36]
shall develop submit for city review and approval and implement construction management plans,
[56:41]
the specifying measures that would reduce impacts on motor vehicle, bicycle, pedestrian, and transit circulation.
[56:47]
The construction management plan shall include, but not necessarily be limited to the following,
[56:52]
First, location of construction staging areas from materials, equipment, and vehicles.
[56:58]
Next, notification procedures for adjacent property owners and public safety personnel,
[57:02]
regarding when major deliveries, detours, and lanes, lane closures occur.
[57:08]
And then next slide, please.
[57:11]
Identification of hall routes for movement of construction vehicles that would minimize impacts on the
[57:16]
color, vehicular, and pedestrian traffic, circulation at safety, provision for monitoring
[57:21]
surface streets used for haul routes so that they, any damage or debris is attributable
[57:26]
to the haul routes can be identified and corrected by the project applicant.
[57:31]
Also, provisions for removal of trash generated by construction activity and the process
[57:36]
for responding to and tracking complaints pertaining to construction activity,
[57:46]
including
[57:47]
This is a requirement, so this is enforceable, it's one of, it's not the only EIR mitigation
[57:55]
measure related to construction management plans, but this is the one that speaks most
[57:59]
directly to the soil hauling.
[58:03]
We will emphasize, again, for the record that the preferred option is to not have
[58:09]
on city streets and both the EDI as well as the city of pursuing, talking with, with respect
[58:19]
of authorities to try to arrange something other than that.
[58:23]
But should it come to that and in fact, in any circumstance whether streets are used or not,
[58:30]
these construction management EIR mitigation measures are requirement,
[58:37]
that's the end of the
[58:38]
slides now.
[58:39]
So, thank you for your patience and I do know
[58:42]
BDI does have additional slides but happy to take questions at this point.
[58:47]
Okay, let's let's before we go to the next presentation.
[58:52]
Okay, presentation.
[58:53]
Any council questions?
[58:55]
Council member O'Connell?
[58:57]
Can't.
[58:58]
Questions for Kevin?
[59:01]
I have a, my question is around page three of the,
[59:08]
staff report and I'm not sure if this is the time to discuss that it is on it's under
[59:17]
phasing and remediation would that would now be the time to discuss that go ahead
[59:24]
sure okay so in this it states that in your staff report it states that the
[59:36]
remediation was
[59:41]
given approval in 2025, January 16th, 2025 and must be completed within 10 years at
[59:50]
per regional water quality board.
[59:56]
And so my question would be, can we?
[1:00:00]
We tie that date that's produced by the regional water quality board into something with the specific plan, so that that cleanup is completed and put in penalties if it's, or I'm not sure what we could do, if that complete remediation, and that's for both sites, both the east and the west side.
[1:00:24]
per the staff report. So that's within 10 years of the remediation being completed.
[1:00:33]
Per regional water quality board and from what I understand that the applicant had
[1:00:40]
proposed with their phasing and how quickly they would get to things that doesn't sound
[1:00:47]
like it's within their timeframe that's prescribed by regional water quality board.
[1:00:52]
So, I'm not sure if staff has any recommendations and can come back with them to us on how we can find out what the ramifications of them not completing that within the ten years for both sites being remediated.
[1:01:09]
and we should clarify that the staff report is not fully developed. On that point, it's the
[1:01:18]
trigger is 10 years following the removal of the last bit of the stockpile dirt from the east side.
[1:01:26]
So it's not 10 years from approval of the plan. It's 10 years from when the stockpile is removed.
[1:01:35]
So it's much further out than I think is suggested by that phrase that you just read.
[1:01:42]
We talked about the timing a little bit last week, and this is contrary to the reason why I'm bringing it up.
[1:01:50]
And so the discussion last week was reflective of what the water board requires the staff report.
[1:01:59]
doesn't capture it quite correctly, but so it is a longer time horizon that we can mimic
[1:02:09]
that time horizon from the waterboard in the specific planet, I think that.
[1:02:14]
So what you're saying is that the regional water quality board did not put a ten year completion
[1:02:22]
date on this?
[1:02:23]
10 years, but 10 years from after the soil is removed, not 10 years from the approval.
[1:02:32]
So, the 10-year clock, there will be a 10-year clock ticking at some point, but it hasn't
[1:02:38]
started and will it start until all that the soil has been removed?
[1:02:42]
So, I would request we put some sort of trigger in that that happens sooner than later,
[1:02:49]
but I think that's something staff would need to work on.
[1:02:52]
Thank you.
[1:02:54]
Can't remember length. Yeah, thank you madam mayor.
[1:03:02]
This is this is questions regarding the slides only. Yes, and so Kevin, you know that last or one of the last visual that you showed did it have the sustainability
[1:03:17]
District and any of the east side. No, what this was trying to show is where's the soil going to so these were all the west side districts
[1:03:27]
that would be receiving the soil,
[1:03:29]
because all the soil is going from the east to the west
[1:03:32]
so it's two and a half million cubic yards.
[1:03:35]
There is going to be soil movement within the east side
[1:03:39]
so that was not shown on that graphic.
[1:03:41]
This was really just meant to show
[1:03:43]
what's being transferred from one side to the other.
[1:03:46]
Okay, just being transferred.
[1:03:48]
Okay.
[1:03:50]
Yeah, I do ask some questions in regards to removing,
[1:03:55]
but I guess we'll address that
[1:03:57]
another time tonight. Okay. Mayor Proto? So I have phasing questions, but they're not
[1:04:05]
about the slides which I just wait. Yeah, maybe when we get into them. Any other questions
[1:04:10]
on slides for Kevin? No. Okay. Kevin or you're all done? All done. Thank you. All right. Thank
[1:04:19]
you. That was very interesting.
[1:04:24]
Applicant, I'm told you may have a presentation for us.
[1:04:35]
Yes, it's
[1:04:35]
Actually, not a full presentation.
[1:04:40]
It's a slide that we created from the Request and Council
[1:04:46]
last week to try to show how the grading across the site
[1:04:52]
looks because the green blob cut and fill map
[1:04:57]
got a two-star review.
[1:05:00]
So I'm going to do it.
[1:05:01]
Two is being generous.
[1:05:02]
Oh, come on.
[1:05:03]
I'm being generous, but it's like two greens.
[1:05:07]
look identical in order the biggest ones. Okay, we're going to try with this one. Next, this
[1:05:13]
is the soil movement, which Kevin already covered, but just want to emphasize again, our
[1:05:20]
preference is to move the soil from east to west within our property boundaries. I think
[1:05:25]
everybody knows what the constraints on are and that, and we will be working hard to overcome
[1:05:30]
those constraints.
[1:05:35]
The next slide. Okay. Hopefully, I love this.
[1:05:43]
You know, I had a feeling that it's going to look like this. Like it was going to
[1:05:46]
make a mesa on the east side. No, it's not. So this is on the west side. Let me
[1:05:52]
let me orient you if you need it. We are standing. You are looking south at
[1:05:59]
Ice house hill, that's ice house hill though, you're looking to the, to the right is
[1:06:03]
Bayshore Boulevard and we actually captured the escarpment that comes down to Bayshore.
[1:06:09]
Do you see the cut there that we all know and then Council Member Lens as you, as we all
[1:06:15]
know as you drive north on Bayshore shortly after that escarpment, that's actually where, you
[1:06:22]
know the mountain got blown out to put Bayshore in, that's why that's so steep there.
[1:06:26]
as you move south, then there's this huge drop-off, and you're asking, are we raising the
[1:06:32]
property? No. So, where you see here are the finished elevations, as they are, so, but
[1:06:42]
as you travel, as you continue north, you do recall that the site does start to slope up because
[1:06:52]
when you're at industrial way, you're at grade.
[1:06:55]
Industrial way is at Bayshore.
[1:06:58]
But it is kind of steep down in the southern part of the site.
[1:07:03]
And what you're looking at now is the finished grades.
[1:07:09]
And then the existing grade is the red dotted line there.
[1:07:13]
So all of that area between the red line
[1:07:16]
and the finished grade will be fill.
[1:07:18]
and that's anywhere from 0 to about 20 feet on the site.
[1:07:25]
So you're looking at industrial way and then commercial building.
[1:07:30]
Building, and then the park, the linear park that runs through, that's ecological park.
[1:07:35]
And that's it finished grade and then more commercial and then that's what we call the frontage road that'll run all the way up
[1:07:45]
very close to the railroad track. And the railroad track, as you can see, the track is sort of already grade and these are all.
[1:07:59]
You know, and that's, that's the, the countering track runs that at great almost through the entire site.
[1:08:12]
So, yeah, so as I tried to describe last week, the site is sort of like a shallow bowl and it's mostly, you know,
[1:08:25]
then deeper in the middle, that's where a lot of the fill comes in.
[1:08:28]
So you hear numbers like, oh, we have to bring in 25 feet of fill and get, you know, people get confused,
[1:08:32]
are you talking about, you know, 25 feet or 30 feet? No, it's bringing in to fill the
[1:08:37]
side up so that it'll be relatively, you know, I don't want to say level because there
[1:08:44]
is about a, I would say, over the entire run from the base of, from the base of the hill
[1:08:49]
to the counter-instation is about 20 feet of, of great difference over the site, but you
[1:08:56]
wouldn't, you wouldn't even be able to notice it when you're out there. And because we have
[1:08:59]
enough area. We're not finding any retaining walls anywhere. So, because we have enough land
[1:09:06]
area, the basically the slopes will be kind of just kneaded down and to knead the
[1:09:15]
grade. So, that's any questions. Is this helpful? Yeah, no. Okay. That's at least four
[1:09:25]
I have stars. Yes. Thank you. And the fact that you got it to us that fast. I mean,
[1:09:31]
probably better than I expected. Yeah. This is really helpful. I think not just for us,
[1:09:36]
but for the public as well to be able to see to have some kind of concept. And also I think when
[1:09:42]
you consider the grading right in your mind. Yeah. I have one concept, but to actually see the dash
[1:09:48]
line, which is where we currently are and exactly where it's going, not, not, yeah, it's
[1:09:56]
not 7. And you're saying anywhere from zero to 20 feet, then 20 feet at the thickest end.
[1:10:01]
Man, ask a question. Yes. When you're saying, uh, existing grade 15 feet or 69 feet,
[1:10:09]
is that mean sea level? Yes, that's sea level. Thank you. So that that that's 169 feet,
[1:10:16]
The Bubsi level, the train is 15 feet above sea level.
[1:10:21]
So, I am confused when you have the train at 15 feet above sea level, and then the roadway is
[1:10:33]
6.7.
[1:10:34]
Is much, it's a couple of people.
[1:10:38]
But it's listed at 16.7.
[1:10:43]
But it's above sea level.
[1:10:45]
But it's below the tracks.
[1:10:49]
That's a little bit of an artifact that that 15 feet is actually at the.
[1:10:55]
It's at the treat.
[1:10:57]
It's at the track, not at the base.
[1:11:01]
So it's a typo or a grapho, I guess.
[1:11:05]
That arrow should be pointing to the base of the, where the track is.
[1:11:09]
So you see how the track, where the track is.
[1:11:10]
It still shows the roadway higher than the train tracks and that's not what the graphic shows.
[1:11:30]
Well, if that is, yeah, yeah, yeah, let me see.
[1:11:34]
I thought we have this straight now, but yeah.
[1:11:37]
Anyway, it's close.
[1:11:40]
The road and the railroad track are only a couple of feet difference.
[1:11:44]
And actually, like sort of the current grade.
[1:11:48]
So we are bringing that road up a little bit in this section.
[1:11:53]
So is it true, sorry, is it true that the line,
[1:11:58]
the dark line with the figures is accurate,
[1:12:02]
and then the illustration is just to show what sits on top
[1:12:06]
of those lines, but the relationship is shown by the flat line,
[1:12:11]
The depth that we're seeing is just, it's just kind of a cartoon.
[1:12:15]
It doesn't mean that the train is actually higher than the cars.
[1:12:18]
Am I reading that correctly, Stephanie?
[1:12:20]
Yes.
[1:12:21]
Thank you.
[1:12:23]
Hold on.
[1:12:24]
Train track is at 15 feet.
[1:12:26]
Yes.
[1:12:27]
That's from the engineer.
[1:12:31]
So...
[1:12:31]
The car's got to be a bad track track.
[1:12:34]
Well, yeah.
[1:12:36]
I mean, 15 feet.
[1:12:37]
That's the building.
[1:12:37]
everything else stepped up except for the except for the park because that's
[1:12:42]
ecological park it's also going to be serving as a bioswales so it does have to
[1:12:47]
be a little bit lower and that's great in lower yeah thank you
[1:12:55]
any other council questions are we getting more of more
[1:13:01]
And stations like this, more white.
[1:13:06]
Why did you call it a list?
[1:13:07]
Do you give your presentation or is this?
[1:13:08]
Yes, this is all I had tonight was,
[1:13:10]
but I wanted to get back to you on the issues
[1:13:13]
that were raised last week.
[1:13:15]
So, Councillor Bradelens, thank you.
[1:13:16]
So, all right, so, thank you for doing this.
[1:13:20]
Hopefully, you can also provide the east side as well.
[1:13:25]
That way we do have some east side ones already.
[1:13:27]
And mostly covering the visitation park in the Goon Park.
[1:13:34]
Those are in the specific plan, but if you want...
[1:13:37]
Yeah, I think it would be helpful when that red layer is removed,
[1:13:43]
and then you have the green layer,
[1:13:45]
and then you're just looking at the southern portion of the east side.
[1:13:50]
You have to be pretty much a grade,
[1:13:52]
because that's where the water is flowing,
[1:13:54]
and then you have this mound of dirt,
[1:13:56]
And so that's what I was saying, and it looked like the Mesa that I think in my head is going to be on the east side.
[1:14:02]
But you're right, yeah, obviously this is the west side.
[1:14:05]
But if we could have a summer visual with the same types of dotted lines, I think it would be helpful.
[1:14:12]
So in regards to this though,
[1:14:15]
so we have this existing grade 15 at 15 feet, right?
[1:14:22]
It's a countering track for the countering tracks.
[1:14:24]
So then in order to have the five feet of the cap,
[1:14:29]
you'll excavate, five feet down, or certain depth.
[1:14:33]
On our property, not on the countering property.
[1:14:36]
But yes.
[1:14:37]
OK, so that's the point.
[1:14:38]
And what's the, yeah, what's the countering easement?
[1:14:41]
The one, so on and on and on.
[1:14:43]
And the width there.
[1:14:44]
Oh, it varies on the site.
[1:14:46]
We actually just sold easements to the countering for their electrification.
[1:14:53]
So they have a pretty large easement through the, you can see the electrical poles there.
[1:15:00]
Okay. So, if we can keep that visual up, please.
[1:15:10]
Thank you. So, okay. So, as far as the cow train easement, no remediation will occur in the cow train easement, it sounds like.
[1:15:22]
No, not, we're not remediating other people's problems. I'm just, I'm just asking the question.
[1:15:27]
and I decide to slow her all on the same day here.
[1:15:30]
I'm going to need to be defensive.
[1:15:32]
So I was just clarifying that, yeah.
[1:15:34]
Okay, okay, so no remediation.
[1:15:36]
You're not responsible for their property.
[1:15:39]
I think they're responsible for party.
[1:15:40]
Okay, so then looking at this slide here,
[1:15:45]
the frontage road is the property line.
[1:15:50]
I'd have to get back to you on that.
[1:15:52]
I don't know, there's probably some easement
[1:15:55]
between French 8-grade and the Keltrain, but in it varies across the site, so.
[1:16:03]
All right, so then is there a question?
[1:16:05]
Just a favor looking at yeah, the French 8-grade in 16.7, which is 1.7 above the
[1:16:12]
Keltrain line so then in order to have the 5-foot cap you have to excavate some and
[1:16:20]
and I'll hold that.
[1:16:23]
Can't do it.
[1:16:24]
If we have to or reuse it on site, that's the, that's what's in the remediation plan.
[1:16:31]
Okay.
[1:16:33]
And, and so that would occur until you get to a certain height, where then the, the five-foot cap would be above it.
[1:16:41]
I'll have it.
[1:16:43]
Okay.
[1:16:43]
Yeah.
[1:16:44]
All right.
[1:16:45]
I asked about the question.
[1:16:46]
But I'll only ask the one at a time.
[1:16:49]
Okay.
[1:16:49]
Any other questions on the slide?
[1:16:53]
Thank you.
[1:16:54]
Very helpful.
[1:16:55]
Could you send us this to the staff habit?
[1:16:59]
Thank you.
[1:17:00]
I think distribution and the council would be good.
[1:17:03]
All right.
[1:17:05]
Moving along.
[1:17:09]
Last public hearing.
[1:17:10]
We finished.
[1:17:11]
Topic one remediation framework and responsible agencies.
[1:17:14]
Topic two site grading soil testing and clean soil design.
[1:17:18]
Third topic sequencing remediation and development and please I understand a lot of these are squishy they overlap that that's just going to be inherent in it.
[1:17:31]
Now we'll move on to the remaining scheduled topics under remediation and phasing that brings up topic four land use restrictions and enforcement reminder to the public.
[1:17:43]
please fill out speaker slips, noting the topic you wish to speak on. Members of the public at home, please raise your hand in Zoom to be added to a speaker card.
[1:17:53]
So we'll start with council questions on number four topic land use restrictions and enforcement. I'll again call on each council member.
[1:18:02]
Please limit it to one question after each of you's had a turn. I'll go back through for another round of questions.
[1:18:09]
And City Clerk, do I have all those speaker slips from the past public hearing?
[1:18:16]
You have a couple more for me.
[1:18:20]
Thank you.
[1:18:22]
Okay.
[1:18:24]
Mayor Pro Tem Davis, you're up first.
[1:18:26]
Great.
[1:18:28]
I'll just preface this by saying some of the questions I'm going to ask tonight.
[1:18:32]
I already know the answers too, and this is really because I know that
[1:18:36]
these have either come up in public common already or in written correspondence or just general
[1:18:43]
questions I've heard in the community. So I think it's really important for these to be on record
[1:18:48]
and to be addressed for the public sake. So here goes my first question. When individual
[1:18:56]
parcels are sold or developed, what provisions will ensure that homeowners and businesses
[1:19:02]
do not inadvertently inherit open-ended environmental maintenance obligations that are originally
[1:19:08]
the developer's responsibility and which obligations remain with the developer, which attached to
[1:19:16]
the property and which are funded through an association or another long-term management entity.
[1:19:29]
And if you want to come back to me on the, I know some of this really depends on financing and districts and all that, but just try your best.
[1:19:45]
Can I, can I just jump in and say under California disclosure law with those, everything that you read, not, let me rephrase that, would those be an obligation of a homeowner in selling a property to disclose to a potential buyer?
[1:20:03]
under California law?
[1:20:06]
Well, I think there's, there's a few different, we get closer to the microphone, a few different
[1:20:11]
layers that we're talking about because if there's, it really depends on where in the remediation
[1:20:18]
process we are, the regulatory agencies are ensuring that the owner of the property, whether
[1:20:27]
the current owner or a future developer is responsible for funding and implementing the cleanup
[1:20:34]
measures that the wrap and the audit requires. Once those have been implemented and the specific
[1:20:42]
plan requires those to be implemented in connection with the development before that development
[1:20:50]
is able to be occupied, then the ongoing compliance with the main use
[1:20:56]
governance and restrictions about what you can do on the property, the
[1:21:01]
monitoring, the maintenance and repairs that would become the owner's
[1:21:07]
association responsibility. There has been discussed in some of the other
[1:21:12]
meetings that ultimately there will be one or more owner's associations that are
[1:21:17]
responsible for the ongoing reporting and, again, prepare, maintenance, upkeep of the conditions.
[1:21:28]
And so ultimately, it will continue to run with the land initially, you know, kind of property on a developer
[1:21:37]
and then future owners will continue to be responsible for that.
[1:21:42]
Thank you.
[1:21:44]
Council Member O'Connell.
[1:21:53]
I worked in hazardous material a long time ago. Back then, California
[1:21:59]
had cradle to grave.
[1:22:02]
Someone who's responsible for the pollution or the entitled landowner
[1:22:09]
has a responsibility forever for that pollution. Does that stop once the state has certified
[1:22:18]
through the water quality board or the air quality board that it is
[1:22:24]
remediated and then it switches to the L&M.
[1:22:30]
I mean, there's the depends, again, what sort of question we're looking for. The responsibility for doing the cleanup for complying with the O&M runs with the property owner, if there's been unanticipated issue and you're looking for liability, then it becomes a different matter of investigation to put together the liability chain for
[1:22:59]
which could involve former property owners and sources, but that's that they wouldn't automatically
[1:23:06]
have responsibility for ongoing maintenance just under like the standard regulatory procedures.
[1:23:13]
Right, thank you.
[1:23:16]
Councilmember Lance?
[1:23:17]
Yeah, thank you.
[1:23:22]
So Stephanie, if you went mind,
[1:23:28]
thank you again for the visual.
[1:23:31]
You know, I'm still looking though for some that choose the final grades without all the fancy stuff.
[1:23:41]
You know, and the reason I ask for that is because I want to know how the water drains.
[1:23:46]
And we already have drainage issues.
[1:23:50]
Yeah, right.
[1:23:51]
And you know, at the site.
[1:23:52]
And so.
[1:23:54]
Okay.
[1:23:55]
Yeah.
[1:23:55]
So I mean, I believe we do have a drainage map in the infrastructure plan.
[1:24:00]
But let me talk about that so I'm just yeah because I'm just curious you know, like how these these various grades, you know, impact
[1:24:09]
The flow of water, right, and then you have two sides
[1:24:15]
Sorry, I'm kidding. So if from the side coach. Yeah, so I mean
[1:24:22]
You know, we get some greater clarity there and then also
[1:24:27]
Um, with that, to understand, how does that impact or the existing property owners?
[1:24:35]
Like, you, like you said, we're not responsible for mediating cow trains and land, right?
[1:24:41]
But there is, I would think of responsibility if you're doing this various grading and then that impacts, say, the tank farm or cow, you know, the, the lumber yard or ecology.
[1:24:56]
Yeah, or the pump station, you know, things like that.
[1:24:59]
We can bring you back the drainage map to show you, yeah, we can, I can assure you
[1:25:03]
we're not impacting any of our neighbors with our storm drainage
[1:25:07]
or with our, um, just with our park program.
[1:25:13]
But yeah, all right.
[1:25:14]
Can't you remember?
[1:25:14]
Yeah.
[1:25:14]
I'm sorry.
[1:25:14]
I'm sorry.
[1:25:16]
Can't you remember?
[1:25:19]
That would be great.
[1:25:20]
Thank you.
[1:25:22]
Also, this is kind of backtracking a little bit.
[1:25:24]
consultant from E.K.I. Michelle King is also online. I'm not sure we've found her in the
[1:25:30]
panless if there. Yes, so she could also speak to some of the topic that we've been discussing
[1:25:41]
here. Yeah, I mean, well, I think the city attorney kind of captured it, but with respect to
[1:25:47]
to grave is that in the eyes of the regulatory agencies, the developer would still be a responsible
[1:25:55]
party, even though the ongoing operations and maintenance may be performed by others, but
[1:26:02]
if there was some, I don't know, catastrophic problem, something new found, some change,
[1:26:08]
they could always look back to the developer if needed.
[1:26:22]
If you'd like to move to the next question,
[1:26:23]
Yeah, I'm okay with the staff coming back with that's okay. I have a question that comes back from a
[1:26:35]
staff report and in that staff report it talks about
[1:26:40]
scenario where the cap would be disturbed and
[1:26:44]
That just kind of intrigued me. So it's kind of a two-part question do all of the underground mechanical systems go into a vault
[1:26:53]
so as to be accessible, but not degrade prematurely from corrosion due to chemical contaminants.
[1:27:02]
And what would a scenario be where the cap would end up being disturbed?
[1:27:12]
Michelle, are you able to answer these two questions?
[1:27:18]
Yes.
[1:27:20]
So the cap, there's a couple of things. The utilities will be run in clean utility corridors,
[1:27:25]
So, they will be within clean fill with demarcation fabrics separating the clean fill from let's call it the dirty soil, the contaminated soil.
[1:27:38]
So, in general, like utility repairs and things like that should not be happening in the dirty dirt.
[1:27:46]
And the level of contaminants are out there,
[1:27:50]
are not such that they would increase the corrosion,
[1:27:52]
even if it were in contact with, you know,
[1:27:56]
the infrastructure, it's just normal sole corrosivity.
[1:27:59]
There's nothing about the impact
[1:28:01]
that saw that would increase corrosivity.
[1:28:04]
Underneath the building slabs,
[1:28:05]
there could be some utilities that are not necessarily running,
[1:28:10]
clean fill, and I maybe Stephanie or someone from
[1:28:13]
to speak to this more specifically. But sometimes, you know, a building slab does need to be
[1:28:22]
changed, modified if there's, you know, modifications to utilities or damage to a utility.
[1:28:29]
I think we talked at one of the prior meetings about, let's say, an earthquake situation.
[1:28:35]
Sometimes, you know, there's just damage that needs to be repaired. So those would be the types of things
[1:28:40]
the cap would be breached. So if I could ask you then following up on what you're saying
[1:28:45]
on the east side where there's less soil being left, are you talking about utilities just
[1:28:56]
5 feet underground? So the east side with the land those a little bit different because there was
[1:29:02]
the description I think was in the last meeting or maybe the meeting before I can't remember where
[1:29:08]
there was that geosynthetic clay liner, the special cap that was going to be put in place in
[1:29:16]
the situation of the land. I thought all of those what utilities will be above that cap and so there
[1:29:22]
will be basically a layer, a protective layer on top of the cap and then you kind of clean so I'll
[1:29:30]
but the cap drainage and sloping of that low permeability cover will be designed such
[1:29:38]
that all the wet utilities would be above that liner. Okay, thank you very much.
[1:29:47]
All right, back to questions, Councilmember Lens. Yeah, I want to just piggyback on the last
[1:29:53]
question that you had met a mayor in regards to the utility, so Michelle.
[1:30:00]
It sounds like there would be these clear, I guess utility corridors, maybe you said it was a different name, but you know, how are those, like, clearly marked.
[1:30:13]
So that everyone, you know, especially, you know, PG&E or others, public works, they know that okay, here, this is where all the utilities are buried, and this is kind of like a clean zone and you stay within that so that you do not disturb.
[1:30:31]
the cap? Yeah, well, there will be asvilts, you know, that will be made that will
[1:30:38]
show where all the utilities are. And before PG&E goes into do any work, for example, using PG&E on
[1:30:45]
its lines, they typically will pot hole and make sure they're in the right spot, because they don't,
[1:30:50]
I mean, they don't want to dig not in their where their line is, right? They want to locate and be
[1:30:55]
doing their work within the line.
[1:30:57]
And the utility corridor themselves will be
[1:31:00]
inclusive of all the utilities.
[1:31:02]
And like I said, there's going to be a demarcation
[1:31:04]
fabric on either side and the bottom of the corridors.
[1:31:10]
So yeah.
[1:31:10]
So what's the utility's are between the beneath the roadways?
[1:31:16]
OK, so what's the width of those corridors?
[1:31:20]
I mean, you know, you don't want PG and I
[1:31:21]
just kind of digging around, OK, did we find it or not?
[1:31:24]
It'd be great if it was like, okay, we know here's this master plan, and we just follow this. Obviously, you
[1:31:31]
know, you want to test, but you should have a pretty good understanding. I would think that where these
[1:31:36]
quarters located. Yeah, it'll all be surveyed. And typically, your clean utility quarters will go
[1:31:43]
a couple feet beyond the width of the pipe to make sure that the workers can actually work within the
[1:31:51]
corridors. So it's not like the utility will end and then three inches later is the edge
[1:31:56]
of the clean corridor.
[1:32:00]
Okay, okay, so there will be maps that will identify these corridors.
[1:32:06]
Okay. Yeah, and there will be surveyed, too.
[1:32:10]
Okay, all right, thank you.
[1:32:13]
Mayor, pro-tom Davis.
[1:32:18]
So we're building requires vapor mitigation or another engineered control to protect
[1:32:25]
occupants, is there an explicit requirement that the system be installed, tested, and incorporated
[1:32:32]
into a long-term maintenance program?
[1:32:42]
What made you get this?
[1:32:43]
Yeah, I can say Michelle, do you want to start a thanks?
[1:32:47]
Yeah.
[1:32:48]
So any type of engineered system, like a vapor mitigation system, would always have a long-term
[1:32:56]
operations, monitoring, and maintenance plan, even if it's a passive system, it would have
[1:33:02]
such maintenance plan. And how often would somebody be servicing that or monitoring that?
[1:33:12]
It honestly depends on the type of system. Okay. So, yeah, I mean, if it's an active system,
[1:33:18]
there's often auto notifications, if it checks off. For some reason, like if there's a power
[1:33:24]
There will be an auto notification if it's a passive system, it'll depend on what's defined in the operations monitoring maintenance plan.
[1:33:31]
But a minimum of once a year to check on a passive system.
[1:33:36]
In that same vein, I apologize for taking another, for asking a follow-up question, but let's say that it requires on electricity.
[1:33:46]
It requires electricity, and there is a power outage, and I know that there's going to be battery storage on the site.
[1:33:51]
and all that good stuff, but how, you know, we don't know what's ahead of us and we've seen
[1:33:58]
several cities in our country that have not had power for quite a few days, if not a week.
[1:34:11]
How quickly does that become a problem for a system like this in terms of impacting occupants
[1:34:19]
health? Is it something that could be off for several days and there would be no impact? Or is this
[1:34:26]
something that would need to, you know, after a day or two without being on, you would see some health
[1:34:31]
of X? You would be, we highly unlikely that you'd see health of X because the exposures are all based
[1:34:39]
long-term risks and long-term exposures. So when calculating those risk-based screening levels
[1:34:48]
those let's call them the action levels or the cleanup levels that would trigger the
[1:34:53]
need for even installing events they're based on a you know, basically a 25 to 30 year
[1:35:01]
exposure. So if it's off for a few days or even a week someone wouldn't get sick as a result
[1:35:07]
of that, because of the levels that are out here, they're not that high.
[1:35:12]
That's what I expect you to say, but it's just important to have very good for the record.
[1:35:20]
Okay.
[1:35:21]
Council member.
[1:35:22]
Will Como?
[1:35:23]
I'm sorry.
[1:35:23]
Mayor Mackin.
[1:35:23]
We do have that slide available for Council members.
[1:35:27]
Let's go.
[1:35:28]
If
[1:35:37]
there's a way to zoom out on the left side there, Angel.
[1:35:40]
Thank you.
[1:35:53]
I believe this is a little older map that we actually are pulling from our sea level rise
[1:35:57]
work, but it did show based on what you were saying, Councilmember Lance, it did show flow of water.
[1:36:03]
So I wanted to at least get that up, but this isn't sufficient we can find something else for you.
[1:36:08]
Yeah, no. Yeah, it would be better to get something that's more detailed and you know maybe you know I'm missing it in the specific plan.
[1:36:20]
So or in the EIR, how it's identified,
[1:36:24]
but yeah we can get that.
[1:36:26]
If I may on this slide, it shows the water flows in yellow, I'm assuming our mustard or whatever that color is.
[1:36:37]
And it does show going right through Golden State lumber, the water flow through their property.
[1:36:48]
So that would be something that the applicant or the developer at the time would need
[1:36:55]
to control that flow so it doesn't flow through another person's property, wouldn't that be the case?
[1:37:05]
Or might that be the case?
[1:37:09]
Yeah, that's accurate.
[1:37:15]
Thank you.
[1:37:16]
Anything else comes over less on this slide?
[1:37:20]
No.
[1:37:21]
Okay.
[1:37:21]
It's a fun old question, isn't
[1:37:26]
it?
[1:37:26]
I'm going to backtrack, sorry.
[1:37:30]
We were given numbers on how much cubic yards we're going to be moved for phase 1, 2, and 3, and 1, 2, 3. How much soil does that leave on the east side?
[1:37:55]
These are rough numbers. Rough numbers.
[1:37:57]
Okay, so I believe roughly we've got about 7 million cubic yards of soil stockpiled on the landfill.
[1:38:08]
We're going to be moving about, again, don't pin me down to this, to 2.5 million to
[1:38:15]
these.
[1:38:16]
So that leaves 4.5 to 5 million cubic yards that'll be on the landfill that'll be used to,
[1:38:23]
you know.
[1:38:25]
Spread out.
[1:38:25]
Thank you.
[1:38:27]
And this is a two-parter because I can't just wait until the next round.
[1:38:31]
So, with the phasing, when the time clock doesn't start until they've removed the dirt from the east side for the 10-year regional water quality board timing,
[1:38:48]
what are they going to do with that other 5, 4.5 million cubic yards of dirt to make that clock start ticking?
[1:39:05]
You don't need to tell me now, we can get that from the applicant later, but if they've got to remove all seven before the clock starts ticking that puts a very weird timing on when that clock starts ticking and we can get that landfill closed.
[1:39:23]
Thank you.
[1:39:25]
Okay. I have a question that was sent to me by a resident who said that way back we go
[1:39:37]
into the 1960s probably, a city ordinance on tipping fees and inquired whether or not
[1:39:44]
tipping fees would apply to moving these truck loads of dirt.
[1:39:52]
Did I catch everybody off
[1:39:53]
guard? Was it the term? You want me to define the term for you? I had the other winners
[1:39:58]
So the question we all looking at each other to see if we've got an answer for you.
[1:40:01]
I didn't have an answer, so I'm asking it.
[1:40:04]
Back in the day, we did charge a recycling fee for truck loads coming into the site.
[1:40:13]
Yes, exactly.
[1:40:15]
It's movement into a landfill.
[1:40:18]
Any kind of clean fill, dirty fill, you name it.
[1:40:21]
You bring a truck in, you paid it to tip it.
[1:40:34]
I think we stopped getting that when we told him they couldn't bring any more dirt in.
[1:40:39]
Well, the landfill was closed essentially.
[1:40:43]
Well, not the landfill, but the dirt pile.
[1:40:46]
The dirt pile.
[1:40:47]
They couldn't bring any more in, and that's when those fees sort of stopped, I think.
[1:40:51]
But I'm sure there's still something that's going on with the soil processing that's going
[1:40:57]
on that there's probably some sort of thing going on there still, but I don't know.
[1:41:03]
and at the quarry, quite frankly.
[1:41:07]
Yeah, but the quarry isn't us.
[1:41:09]
That's true.
[1:41:10]
In the county, right?
[1:41:13]
Mars, if you'd like to speak to this, please.
[1:41:25]
Hi, folks, can you be okay?
[1:41:28]
All right, perfect.
[1:41:29]
So, yes, we actually have an intermaster fee schedule.
[1:41:32]
We currently do have a grading permit
[1:41:35]
and a truck hauling fee that we charge for grading permits.
[1:41:40]
And the ongoing on-site recycling is currently being
[1:41:46]
invoiced and paid for by the, by the use of the intermutes
[1:41:51]
is out there as we speak on a button by monthly basis.
[1:41:54]
And we do have quite a record of the history of that.
[1:41:58]
So, happy to share that in more detail in the future.
[1:42:00]
But yes, we are collecting those as far as it being subject to this development.
[1:42:05]
There is a potential, you know, as it is now, it would be subject to these fees.
[1:42:10]
as part of our massage schedule.
[1:42:14]
So that was an affirmative,
[1:42:19]
correct?
[1:42:20]
Yes, correct.
[1:42:22]
We've been assessing fees on a bi-monthly basis,
[1:42:26]
and unless something were to be included in the development agreement,
[1:42:31]
we would be assessing the fees as part of our normal permitting process.
[1:42:36]
And so there's not confusion of terms.
[1:42:39]
what the public work director just described, although it is an impact fee and it is something
[1:42:45]
that is applicable to it needs a little bit different than it. Tipping fee, like when you're
[1:42:50]
literally in a pain to use and dump in a landfill situation, so the answer yes there are
[1:43:01]
impact fees that apply as a little bit different than yes we are charging pursuant to the
[1:43:07]
tipping fee that used to apply when it was an operative landfill.
[1:43:13]
Thanks for your clarification. That's correct.
[1:43:16]
It would probably also make a difference.
[1:43:19]
I would assume whether they were moving it just within their own site,
[1:43:24]
whether we could charge a fee if they didn't go on to a public roadway.
[1:43:28]
It might make a difference too.
[1:43:30]
Right. And part of I think part of the original ordinance was
[1:43:34]
also just we talked about it before.
[1:43:37]
wear and tear on the road with all the trucks coming and going. So that's I think part of the
[1:43:43]
genesis where this came from. Thank you. All right. Another round here, Mayor Protem Davis,
[1:43:51]
you have no more questions on this. Councilmember Lens, you have more questions on this.
[1:43:56]
I do. I'm going to pick back on another of your questions, Madam Mayor.
[1:44:01]
So, Eric, you said that, I guess that ordinance or the sipping fee apply to when the landfill was in an operative, operative condition,
[1:44:15]
and so you're talking about like when they were bringing garbage, or is it just when is it operative just when any truck is coming to the site even after the landfill was closed?
[1:44:28]
We don't, we don't, we don't need to look into what the specific ordinance says.
[1:44:32]
And we don't, I don't know all of the details of the way the city's tipping fee ordinance
[1:44:36]
was structured.
[1:44:37]
So I, we'll have to look that up to take it back to you on that.
[1:44:41]
And then, if I may, I want to piggyback on your question is, is it, you, you, you kind
[1:44:46]
of gave Eric, you know, a free pass, you let him off the hook, he's like, he was going to
[1:44:51]
ask.
[1:44:51]
Answer your question unless it was, I'll get back to you.
[1:44:56]
So, in regards to Edge.
[1:45:00]
Regaining that 10-year requirement.
[1:45:04]
Well, I was asking for him to get back to me. I didn't expect him to have an answer. Unless he...
[1:45:09]
Yeah, I thought you were going to have an answer and I wasn't sure if.
[1:45:15]
Well, so I was going to have the discussion with the applicant for how they plan on doing it.
[1:45:23]
But I think also to clarify, that starts the 10-year clock to...
[1:45:29]
for a final closure and completion, as we were discussing last week too, to the extent there are facilities being developed in the interim on the east side, those would also trigger cleanup and closure related to the areas where those facilities were being installed.
[1:45:52]
So if there were batteries or other uses that were being developed on the east side, that would trigger earlier cleanup enclosure, even if the final closure of everything, the clock hadn't started ticking, that doesn't mean that no cleanup or closure would have yet occurred.
[1:46:12]
So in some ways it also relates to the specific triggers for development milestones on the east side.
[1:46:21]
Okay, no, thank you for that.
[1:46:26]
All right, um, your pro-tube, you came up with Sory, I can go ahead.
[1:46:31]
Sorry, I know that the applicant showed a drainage slide and then we showed a drainage
[1:46:37]
slide.
[1:46:40]
Can you just, can we look at those real again real quick?
[1:47:01]
So this is showing the water moving towards the bay,
[1:47:11]
and then the next thing we see
[1:47:12]
the next one.
[1:47:19]
Yeah, this is not the right one. I
[1:47:29]
think the only map we showed Madison was the first one.
[1:47:33]
Okay, I just wanted to make sure because I thought it seemed like it was a contradiction.
[1:47:39]
One was going, one map was showing water draining. One way and the other map was showing water draining the other way and I wanted to clarify which way is it actually going.
[1:47:49]
Okay, thanks for clearing up that confusion.
[1:47:52]
Water has a mind of its own, it goes where it wants to go, and where you don't want it to go.
[1:47:58]
Right, like a cat.
[1:47:59]
Council member of the call?
[1:48:01]
I have no further questions.
[1:48:03]
Okay.
[1:48:05]
I have no further questions in this section.
[1:48:07]
Council member Lens, do you have questions in this section still?
[1:48:11]
Yeah, I just want to just get clarification.
[1:48:14]
So, it appears that on the west side and maybe on the east side, we haven't really talked about the east side, but I hope that we can get more clarity in regards to grading on the east side.
[1:48:33]
Yeah, maybe later in this section.
[1:48:36]
So, removing some of the soil maybe is can, you know, toxic, maybe it's not.
[1:48:45]
So, is there a plan for that, moving the soil on the west side that needs to be excavated
[1:48:55]
and then have the clean cap put on top?
[1:49:08]
Michelle, if you're available, that would be helpful. Thank you. Yeah. Yeah. So, the
[1:49:16]
remedial action plan that was approved a few years ago by the Waterboard and DTSC,
[1:49:24]
which remedial action plans to find the overall remedy, and then the remedial design
[1:49:29]
implementation plans, the R-Dips, are more specific in terms of the remediation that
[1:49:34]
occur and even in the case of the industrial way buildings, includes additional investigations
[1:49:39]
that would be performed to termine if remediation needs to happen.
[1:49:45]
Prior to bringing the import from the east side over to the west side.
[1:49:51]
Yeah, I'm talking about excavating on the west side and then moving that somewhere.
[1:49:55]
So is there a it would be potentially some of it may go off site and some of it may be just
[1:50:06]
reconciledated on site like thinking about that nice graphic that Stephanie showed that near the
[1:50:12]
bottom part when you're still within the what's called it in the dirty dirt it could move
[1:50:17]
around and then capped with the clean soil.
[1:50:20]
Okay, and then those trucks, there's a, you know, because I mean, that is one thing if you're
[1:50:26]
moving clean, there's dust particles, it's another if you're moving, you know, potentially
[1:50:31]
contaminated soil, that, that, that, that, that dust, you don't want into the atmosphere.
[1:50:39]
So, is there a different type of truck and process?
[1:50:43]
Now, I mean, overall, again, the R-dips will spell out the dust control measures that would
[1:50:49]
be taken, the perimeter air monitoring that would be performed.
[1:50:53]
So basically, the mitigation measures, whether it's contaminated or dirty, the bottom line
[1:50:58]
is as you don't want visible dust leaving the site, whether it's clean or dirty.
[1:51:04]
So, I'm sorry, I'm just trying to understand as there a different process for contaminated dirty soil as opposed to clean soil.
[1:51:18]
Generally, I mean, in truth, generally not.
[1:51:20]
I mean, trucks typically are covered, whether it's cleaned or dirty dirt.
[1:51:26]
The dirty dirt trucks should be decontaminated, certainly prior to like going onto a city street.
[1:51:33]
But again, typically, any construction site
[1:51:37]
you don't want to have track out from the site.
[1:51:40]
So as a practical matter, the measures, mitigation measures
[1:51:44]
tend to be very similar, whether it's cleaned or dirty dirt.
[1:51:48]
The biggest difference is that air monitoring.
[1:51:51]
Yeah.
[1:51:52]
OK, thank you for that, but that wasn't very satisfying.
[1:51:56]
All right.
[1:51:57]
Do you have any other questions?
[1:51:59]
That is it.
[1:52:00]
Public comments.
[1:52:02]
I'm going to read who the names are so you know in advance where you're at in the queue.
[1:52:08]
First I have Linda Salman, Michelle Salman, Paul Buscal, Robin Lighter, Linda, you're on.
[1:52:25]
I have so many questions.
[1:52:27]
One of my largest questions continues to be.
[1:52:32]
From the Bay Cag meeting, when they said that the clay caps were, the clay was all coming from the Bayland soil.
[1:52:41]
And I'm still figuring out, how do you clean the soil to make it to a clean cake clay cap when it comes from toxic dirt?
[1:52:52]
I'm still trying to figure that out. I don't think we have figured out how to do that.
[1:52:56]
So I have a lot of questions about that, a lot of questions about a lot of things.
[1:53:04]
I guess I'll save my financial stuff till the next number five.
[1:53:09]
But then it just seems to me that all of this is kind of still kind of up in the air that there's no real plan.
[1:53:17]
It's like, well maybe we'll work it out, we're working it out, we're figuring it out.
[1:53:21]
We don't really have the answers yet.
[1:53:23]
It makes me very, very uneasy for any kind of a specific plan when so much is unspecified.
[1:53:33]
And that has to, like, the land restrictions, who's going to be ultimately liable when things go wrong.
[1:53:41]
And I still don't think I've got an answer to that.
[1:53:44]
I mean, maybe some of you have asked some of this, and you say, well, it's going to be maybe the owners of the proper owners
[1:53:50]
and the cleanup after they bought the land, what happens then, who's in charge, who's ultimately
[1:53:57]
liable. I still don't have an answer. So I would appreciate one. Thank you.
[1:54:08]
I'm going to go back to
[1:54:09]
a squishy subject that we sort of covered earlier. Where are we going to put over one million cubic
[1:54:18]
yards of dirt in the ice house hill district.
[1:54:25]
I don't see where that's going to go.
[1:54:28]
That's a million cubic yards of dirt in the ice house hill district.
[1:54:33]
That's 44% of the total amount of dirt that they're going to be moving.
[1:54:38]
So that's of a concern and I'm still concerned about the
[1:54:44]
Besides the potential toxins in the dirt, which we've been assured that it's clean, I consider
[1:54:50]
Jabata grass seed bank in the dirt to be a real problem, especially since it's going into
[1:54:58]
an area that's ecologically sensitive.
[1:55:01]
Jabata grass is also known as pompous grass covers, much of the dirt mounts and much
[1:55:07]
with the Baylands now and it really needs to be eradicated and gone before we move that dirt and further
[1:55:16]
spread it.
[1:55:17]
And that's a real problem for me and I guess the other thing that I'm really concerned about
[1:55:21]
is on land use restrictions and enforcements, I'm still very disturbed from when I heard
[1:55:27]
last week where we, the city or whoever, hired inspectors to oversee the northeast-rich development.
[1:55:35]
And then there was spectacular failure in that with the amount of construction defects
[1:55:46]
that occurred and, you know, frog ponds that frogs could live in because they power
[1:55:52]
washed them every week. And a lot of other things that were in all of the development agreements
[1:55:59]
and the HCP agreements and they have not been kept and leaving it up to the homeowner's
[1:56:06]
association with no oversight from the city has allowed us to not fulfill the obligations
[1:56:13]
of the HCP and the development agreement in that we've had at least two of the mega
[1:56:20]
mansions add on to their houses by enclosing their courtyards, which was against the CCNRs
[1:56:28]
against what was in the development agreement and yet it got passed by the city, got approved
[1:56:32]
by the homeowner's association and then passed by our own city planning department unwittingly.
[1:56:39]
And I think that that's a real concern because that's a that was a planned development where
[1:56:44]
the water flow of all things was particularly designed specifically for the way that the
[1:56:50]
that area is cut and fill. It's not on native rock or soil. Much of it is cut and fill.
[1:56:57]
And so, not following the plans of the development, not maintaining the development agreement and the structure has a potential for that whole thing to slide, and certainly did not fulfill the obligations that were in that were supposed to go with the land, the CCNRs and all of that type of thing.
[1:57:22]
And so it concerns me that those are the mechanisms that we're going to use again, and I hope we don't spectacularly fail again, because the stakes are a lot higher now.
[1:57:34]
So I'd really like to see that tightened up, and I'd like to see some really serious oversight, and not just things like CC and ours, or that type of stuff, so thank you.
[1:57:55]
Well, let's get all Brisbane residents in. Thank you Adam Mayer and Council.
[1:58:01]
So two things. One, I haven't seen any mention about the Kinder Morgan Pipeline.
[1:58:11]
That's failed. I know one time, about 40 years ago, because unlike what Michelle King said about
[1:58:22]
corridors for utilities being in a clean corridor that can't
[1:58:27]
work in pipelines and very aggressive soil and erosion corrosion and other
[1:58:33]
things that happen through that pipeline. So I'd like to know what the plan is
[1:58:37]
for that pipeline especially because a waterfront park would be probably built on
[1:58:44]
on top of that area.
[1:58:49]
Good thing I'd like to know, possibly, from so long as we talk about, she talked about
[1:58:57]
losing contaminant on site.
[1:59:02]
The railroad site, specifically.
[1:59:08]
So like Lynn is best as they would put that underneath the roadway and they wouldn't have
[1:59:12]
a utility corridor there.
[1:59:13]
So nobody would ever dig up that roadway to have any impact with the contamination.
[1:59:23]
But she also mentioned that there will be a contaminant that would be trucked off site.
[1:59:31]
And I was curious because if we can lose contaminant on site, I put it underneath the roadway,
[1:59:38]
Why couldn't we haul the stuff that needs to go to a
[1:59:43]
Halsight, which created a grave, there's
[1:59:47]
Responsibilities hauling it
[1:59:50]
For a lot of reasons couldn't we put it on the old landfill site
[1:59:54]
And just dump the surplus on the old unregulated landfill and then cap that
[2:00:00]
So, years ago when I mentioned that, it was said that that wasn't allowed through the regulatory agencies, but if we could lose it on site on the railroad side, why couldn't we just throw it on the other side?
[2:00:15]
and then we wouldn't have to be hauling contaminants to wherever it goes somewhere I don't know
[2:00:23]
in the value or wherever they send it. So that's the things about remediation but
[2:00:34]
when we talk about responsibility as far as our financial obligation and who's going to be
[2:00:47]
that would secure that there's money available for when something does happen.
[2:00:54]
So I'm curious about that.
[2:00:56]
Thank you.
[2:01:00]
Robin Liner.
[2:01:08]
I got this again, but I'm back here with the hall wrap for you guys.
[2:01:12]
I want to say that I appreciate the staff's work, but I still don't know where the hall wrap goes.
[2:01:18]
And I just want to say if it doesn't go into San Francisco, then the only way I know it can go is back and forth over the Brisbane Bridge.
[2:01:25]
And, well, I think it's valid to say perhaps if the grading allows the grading could be done in faces,
[2:01:33]
though the EIR does not comply with letting us see if that in fact could be done.
[2:01:38]
It's still 640 trucks, maybe for a shorter period of time, but it's still 640 trucks.
[2:01:45]
And the safety of that is what I concerned about.
[2:01:48]
If you're going to have queuing as the EIR says on the bridge, that means idling of trucks
[2:01:54]
on the bridge.
[2:01:56]
It means when they get to the intersection of Bayshore and Tunnel, they're going to
[2:02:02]
make a right hand turn.
[2:02:03]
How many trucks can make slow moving right hand turns out of that intersection during that
[2:02:10]
light?
[2:02:11]
How many trucks at the stop sign of Lgunway will it take how much time does it take for them
[2:02:17]
stop and then begin again. So you're looking for what they call a traffic micro simulation.
[2:02:23]
How is it actually going to work? And I think we all deserve to know how it's actually going
[2:02:28]
to work. The EIR says it has a significant adverse impact on emergency access. I think that
[2:02:37]
needs to be resolved. I don't think we should wait for a plan. I think we should know how we
[2:02:43]
resolve that. The sweep of the turns going into the hall route are also going to stop traffic
[2:02:51]
as it precedes northerly on Bayshore Boulevard because the right-hand lane is going to be used
[2:02:57]
for the trucks to go into the hall route. And lastly, the EIR says that pedestrian, bicycle,
[2:03:04]
and transit safety is at risk with this plan. And these are things that these are significant
[2:03:11]
adverse impacts that I know we all want to ensure that any hall route is safe.
[2:03:17]
Thank you.
[2:03:19]
Okay, those are all the questions I have on this topic.
[2:03:23]
Any other city clerk looks like you have one.
[2:03:32]
Susan Brandon.
[2:03:36]
Oh, there you are. Okay, you're here.
[2:03:42]
I have a couple of questions.
[2:03:45]
One is, I think you had said last week that you would have an answer on when the city
[2:03:52]
would be reimbursed for this next meeting and I mean being that you're talking about over
[2:04:00]
a billion dollar remediation project I really find it distressing that you know we can't
[2:04:09]
even talk about a seven million dollar reimbursement to the city after ten months and
[2:04:16]
I just wonder if what happens, I mean, this is kind of goes into the financials, but if a developer decides to declare bankruptcy and then the occupants of the bail hands or the homeowners associations are left holding the bag and I guess there would be a bond that you would get so that you cannot place if you're proceeding with the project.
[2:04:45]
But if you decide to go bankrupt and then if the homeowners can't possibly meet the kind of financials that would be required for this whole remediation, huge, huge undertaking, then it would go back to the state and when the state then sue the city of Brisbane, I don't know, but it's a possibility.
[2:05:11]
And then my other question is, it was kind of what Michelle had said about the dirty dirt.
[2:05:19]
She called it not being necessarily distinguished from the clean dirt.
[2:05:26]
I read an environmental, an EIR study that said that when the bail-ons was classified as a brown field,
[2:05:41]
It was just a few points lower than a super fun site.
[2:05:47]
So, I don't consider that just like a little dirty dirt dirt.
[2:05:52]
I consider that something to be taken very seriously
[2:05:55]
and for those truckloads to not be handled in the same way
[2:05:59]
that clean dirt would be handled.
[2:06:03]
Thank you.
[2:06:04]
Okay, thank you.
[2:06:06]
Any other city clerk? Anyone online?
[2:06:10]
not a mare. Yes. Given that our meetings have historically gone until 930 this
[2:06:16]
would represent about the halfway point. Sure. And I think for all of our
[2:06:20]
sake we we would do well with a break. I think we've been taking them kind of
[2:06:25]
almost like two thirds of the way through and we run out of steam and so if you
[2:06:31]
wouldn't mind I would say at least a 10 to 15 minute break at this point.
[2:06:38]
I think that's
[2:06:39]
one one question one hands raise okay let's do that question first go ahead I
[2:07:06]
believe they have technical difficulties right now Samsung guest
[2:07:13]
whoever's logged in
[2:07:14]
a Samsung guest you need to unmute yourself
[2:07:23]
okay I don't think they'll have to come
[2:07:27]
back after the break. Let's take a break now.
[2:07:29]
Thank you.
[2:07:29]
Fifth.
[2:07:30]
10 minutes, please.
[2:25:12]
So we have the online participant able to ask that last question. We can give that a go before we close this topic out.
[2:25:22]
I believe this is Ms. Clara Johnson. If you could just press star 6 to unmute
[2:25:32]
and mute and I'm trying.
[2:25:35]
We can hear you, sir.
[2:25:39]
Thank you.
[2:25:40]
I appreciate your patience.
[2:25:43]
It's always an adventure, right, with technology.
[2:25:49]
Maggo ahead.
[2:25:50]
Please, too.
[2:25:51]
My first comment is about communication.
[2:25:54]
I think there's been a lot of great communication tonight there.
[2:25:58]
We are involved in this vast enterprise.
[2:26:00]
It is a complex and dynamic one.
[2:26:02]
It has so many aspects and competing goals and interests.
[2:26:05]
the details seem nearly infinite. There is an economic pressure, a political pressure, an environmental
[2:26:11]
pressure. It seems to me to have led to confusion. In a prior meeting one of the city's consultants
[2:26:16]
asked the city council whether they wanted to have one or more of the alternatives other than
[2:26:21]
a specific planned model. The city council did not respond. In order to move forward, you need more
[2:26:28]
information on the alternatives. The question needs to be answered. You may have wanted to delay
[2:26:34]
doing the modeling for comparison, I urge you to tell them what you want now.
[2:26:40]
I urge your consultants and the staff to provide you what they believe you need to know and not
[2:26:45]
wait until you ask for it. If they know or strongly suspect that the project is a risk of going
[2:26:51]
off the rails and ways that could be corrected if everyone would just speak up. The truck
[2:26:58]
that has been determined to be not viable as a design, and the new suggested method of moving to via the rail line and spurs may actually work.
[2:27:10]
Why not talk about other issues that may be virtually impossible, like parts of the phasing, or keeping the tunnel avenue open all the time to protect the business,
[2:27:20]
Or from this evening's meeting, the possibility that things may not occur until 20 years later because of the need to finish the excavation before you can start the remediation process.
[2:27:38]
They, excuse me, the obstacles needed to be faced now before reality becomes more complex and pressing.
[2:27:46]
The developer asks for more flexibility and they need to be more flexible themselves.
[2:27:53]
The city is responsible by requiring that critical issues be resolved within the specific
[2:27:59]
plan rather than later.
[2:28:01]
The consultants and the staff need to provide more guidance in support of the city council's
[2:28:05]
goals.
[2:28:06]
The lack of nurturing guidance was absent in the process with the planning commission and it impacted
[2:28:12]
the outcome.
[2:28:16]
There's one moment, please.
[2:28:20]
Everyone is working very hard and is highly stressful.
[2:28:25]
The city council is using its voice to get to where they believe the project must be to serve the interest of Brisbane and its people and the landed occupiers.
[2:28:34]
I hope they can more clearly declare what they need from the staff, the consultants, and the developer to get there.
[2:28:42]
Thank you for your patience and for your attention.
[2:28:45]
And I had a second comment relating to the OU to remediation.
[2:28:53]
When you, the proposed remedy includes, thanks you've heard before, over worth repeating,
[2:29:01]
capping of it contaminated soil with a durable cover of a minimum of five feet of a clean
[2:29:06]
soil or installation of hard-skate, I know that there was a comment earlier that perhaps
[2:29:14]
you could try that being a 10 feet and they stuck with 5 feet and I wanted to ask why that
[2:29:21]
was, excavated impact, it's sort of where a durable cover cannot be placed and either
[2:29:29]
consolidating the impact it excavated in a location at the site under a protective cutter
[2:29:36]
or safely disposing of it's off-site is the next part of the turf hose remedy.
[2:29:42]
Excavating VOC impacted soil and disclosing it at office site is another part of it.
[2:29:48]
Treating groundwater and soil to break down the VOC in petroleum-related contaminants.
[2:29:54]
Another, and testing soil vapor prior to building construction and insulation of the vapor.
[2:30:00]
For mitigation systems were needed. I think wherever there is vapor underneath the building, there
[2:30:07]
also needs to be monitoring on the inside of the building. Enforcing land use restriction and ongoing
[2:30:14]
monitoring and maintenance of the protective cover is groundwater and any vapor mitigation systems
[2:30:20]
that are installed are yet another part of it. And supporting BDI's decision to maintain
[2:30:25]
financial assurance mechanisms to guarantee the ongoing monitoring and maintenance
[2:30:32]
revolutions. Looking at the waterboards way of organizing things, I think you will need a bond
[2:30:40]
for each area, like a bond for OU-2, a bond for the landfill, a bond for OUSM.
[2:30:49]
You're getting in finance and that's a different section. Can we just hold you on that for now?
[2:30:58]
I think we're running over time now.
[2:31:06]
Okay, thank you.
[2:31:07]
Okay, thank you for your patience and for assisting in the technological issues.
[2:31:12]
Thanks so very much.
[2:31:13]
Thank you, Claire.
[2:31:16]
All right.
[2:31:17]
Topic number five city liability and financial risk.
[2:31:23]
First up, we have Mayor Protem Davis.
[2:31:29]
Suppose a major repair to the landfill cap or a mediation system becomes necessary decades
[2:31:36]
from now.
[2:31:37]
And their response will entity no longer has sufficient funds.
[2:31:41]
What legal and financial mechanisms will ensure the work is completed.
[2:31:55]
Let's see, if we could start at Michelle, if you're still here, start with you.
[2:32:06]
Yes, I'm still here.
[2:32:07]
So, as actually the last commenter pointed out that there are the agencies require financial assurance mechanisms to be put in place, and so the ongoing long-term monitoring that will be performed will assess whether repairs or modifications are needed.
[2:32:27]
the remedy of the future and then the long-term management organizations with the backing of the financial assurance mechanisms should cover the costs of anticipated repairs for the future.
[2:32:44]
Okay.
[2:32:48]
Consmemblements.
[2:32:50]
All right.
[2:32:52]
So Michelle, I'm going to kind of continue with that.
[2:32:56]
So trying to understand what's the process for applying appropriate funding mechanisms for the monitoring maintenance.
[2:33:06]
of the cap and perpetuity.
[2:33:09]
So it would be great if there was like a model
[2:33:14]
that we could just look at and say,
[2:33:17]
okay, yeah, if there are issues,
[2:33:20]
here's how you do the insurance, here's how you create,
[2:33:24]
I don't know, like some kind of fund that can be tapped into.
[2:33:33]
So yeah, and then just kind of a,
[2:33:36]
to our question, could there be a post remediation security
[2:33:41]
positive approved by the City Council prior to
[2:33:45]
festive land rights?
[2:33:47]
So yeah, be with my name.
[2:33:49]
I'm just going to speak to the former, but not the
[2:33:51]
latter.
[2:33:51]
OK, so the former, the first question really is, how
[2:33:56]
are those cost estimates calculated?
[2:33:58]
And so the DTSC has guidance on finding
[2:34:03]
with insurance and doing cost estimates.
[2:34:06]
And so you're supposed to look at
[2:34:08]
reasonably anticipated future costs
[2:34:10]
for typically over a 30-year period with the idea
[2:34:14]
that those costs are often looked at
[2:34:17]
in the present worth manner.
[2:34:20]
So that once you get beyond 30 years
[2:34:22]
because you're discounting,
[2:34:25]
I don't know how much you know about economics
[2:34:27]
in present or thing.
[2:34:29]
So, but you're bringing those future dollars
[2:34:31]
to current dollars so they get discounted. And so once you get beyond 30 years there's not that much
[2:34:36]
of a difference. So usually when the amount of money to be set aside for financial assurance,
[2:34:42]
it's calculated based on a 30-year estimate.
[2:34:47]
Okay and so if there was say money that was set aside
[2:34:53]
that could be in some kind of, you know, investment that's making money and if you didn't need to
[2:35:00]
happen to it, that that money would grow. So are there are you aware of any jurisdictions that
[2:35:09]
have something similar to that? Well, it's not always money that's set aside sometimes it's
[2:35:14]
a bond that's put in place. So there's different financial insurance mechanisms that are
[2:35:20]
allowed. And so that would be worked out with the regulatory agencies. But the present worth accounts
[2:35:28]
for like if you were to set aside the money, the whole present-worth calculation accounts for
[2:35:34]
the growth anticipated growth that the money would have if it were that type of situation.
[2:35:40]
Okay, thank you.
[2:35:43]
Council member O'Connell.
[2:35:46]
So would this normally, through the regulatory agencies, be something that would become part of the
[2:35:53]
as association fees and their responsibility to maintain, or would that reside with the agency,
[2:36:05]
the entity that was funding the original cleanup?
[2:36:11]
So the financial assurance mechanisms are basically just to make sure that there's,
[2:36:18]
Let's call it funds available, but in terms of management of the ongoing, let's say, monitoring
[2:36:26]
requirements and things like that, I think the idea that has been presented for the
[2:36:30]
Baylands is to have like a site-specific environmental management association that would be
[2:36:36]
the ones that would be managing it over the long term.
[2:36:39]
So it's sort of an organization with a whole thing like out at Sierra Point.
[2:36:44]
So it would be paid for and owned, so to speak, by the current tenants or landowners.
[2:36:53]
I can't speak to that. I maybe Stephanie could answer if the idea is that it's free funded in some way.
[2:37:00]
I don't know.
[2:37:02]
And that might be something, and this is to staff, that we'd be looking at with issuing building permits or would that be something
[2:37:12]
would look at in the specific plan.
[2:37:19]
Well, yeah, we would be looking as the remediation is completed.
[2:37:27]
And there's an operations and maintenance plan.
[2:37:30]
And that's when you kind of figure out what's able to be covered by environmental insurance, what you're bonding for, a lot of those structured structures are determined as you get further into the clean up process by the different regulatory agencies.
[2:37:49]
But that wouldn't be something that this body, the city, would be constructing.
[2:37:57]
This would be something that the developer or developers would be constructing.
[2:38:05]
Correct.
[2:38:06]
They need to develop our developers, ultimately need to be able to demonstrate that
[2:38:11]
There's the financial wherewithal to continue to implement and comply with the operations and
[2:38:19]
maintenance obligations, but yeah, it's not something that the city has to develop for
[2:38:23]
them or regulate, they're reporting that to the other jurisdictional agencies that are
[2:38:30]
monitoring the queen.
[2:38:30]
And is that something that we would could put into a
[2:38:39]
process for getting additional building permits
[2:38:43]
that that had been secured before or certificate certificates of occupancy? Is that something
[2:38:53]
how we would regulate whether that step had been carried out before we move on to the next phase
[2:39:01]
or the next block or however they're sectioning it? Yes, that's correct and that's consistent with
[2:39:09]
of the Planning Commission's recommendations too to add that additional clarification in with
[2:39:16]
the specific plan to make it clear that as the cleanup was being completed and the reporting
[2:39:23]
was being done, that those be simultaneously shared with reporting agencies and the city and
[2:39:31]
that if they were falling behind or not completing individual steps, that would then create a barrier
[2:39:39]
for getting additional development permits, they would not continue with the development
[2:39:44]
if those criteria weren't being met.
[2:39:48]
Okay.
[2:39:49]
I have a follow-up to that, but I'll wait because it's a little bit off-track, so.
[2:39:55]
So, my question is a little hard to explain, but earlier we looked at water runoff maps,
[2:40:04]
and the concern I have is for the other Baylands property owners, and since this is being
[2:40:11]
developed in different phases,
[2:40:15]
I just, I can't tell, you show me where the water is going,
[2:40:19]
but during construction, if something is a little bit higher than another, is there a plan
[2:40:24]
to direct the water run off during each phase and the concern that I have here is that I don't
[2:40:31]
know if you're putting in all the storm drains because it sounds like the infrastructure
[2:40:36]
is going in with phases. So when you change the way the water runs as I said earlier,
[2:40:42]
water will find its way, unless you're directing it, it's going to find a path and the impact
[2:40:49]
to the city here, financial risk are the existing property owners, because we have Golden State
[2:40:55]
is definitely a major business in Brisbane, and kindergarten, and then there's also
[2:41:02]
ecology.
[2:41:04]
So have you brought in?
[2:41:05]
This is a question for BDI.
[2:41:07]
Have you brought in the other adjacent property owners and discussed with them what your plans
[2:41:12]
are and listened to their concerns?
[2:41:14]
Because I'm not sure that I've seen what your plan is for the phases and how you're going to direct water.
[2:41:20]
We haven't seen that, but have you notified those other property owners and talked with them?
[2:41:25]
How to dialogue?
[2:41:26]
Show them what you're planning on doing?
[2:41:36]
I think the direct answer is not formally, but we do have good relationships with all of the
[2:41:44]
joining property owners and companies and, you know, they're all very supportive of the project.
[2:41:51]
I think the concerns that you're raising really are regard to stormwater during construction
[2:41:56]
periods. Those would all be managed through the stormwater management plan for construction sites.
[2:42:03]
So, you know, it's not legal and not kosher to flood your labor's property while you're doing
[2:42:10]
construction sites, so all of that is managed through the stormwater management plans that would be in place as construction starts, but in terms of sitting down with them and reviewing the plans, we've not had a formal discussion with them, but they are all supportive of the project.
[2:42:28]
We've not had any concerns raised by any of the existing property owners.
[2:42:35]
So are we going to see any of those plants this storm order management plants the city will yeah at the time of development when we you know when we when we actually you know come in with a building you know
[2:42:48]
Actually we want to do this to blocks it'll come the city will come and have to approve the storm order management plan and and you know about 15 other plans
[2:42:58]
That'll go with that with that building or that grading or building permit
[2:43:03]
Yeah, I say we'll say all the stormwater management plans.
[2:43:07]
Yeah, I think the concern is if this is phased in and you could start construction and do a portion and then maybe stop.
[2:43:14]
And are these plans contingency short term construction plans?
[2:43:18]
And then if you don't do anything for 10 years, what happens for all that water?
[2:43:24]
Yeah, that would still have to be managing the stormwater management plan whether or not you stopped construction.
[2:43:30]
I mean, you're still under that, the jurisdiction of that storm order management plan, which,
[2:43:35]
again, is under the, well, depending on the size of the property, the city would be informed
[2:43:40]
on all the storm order management, but they're actually managed by the regional water quality
[2:43:43]
control board.
[2:43:46]
Okay, yeah.
[2:43:47]
All right.
[2:43:47]
Thank you.
[2:43:48]
Yes.
[2:43:49]
And to that point, the EIR and mitigation measures do require that the city get copies of all of the
[2:43:57]
what are plans that are submitted as they are approved and have evidence that there are all
[2:44:03]
approved plans in place before issuing construction permits. So, the process that there's
[2:44:09]
one step that adds on to the process, but that's definitely just described. Okay, thank you, Eric.
[2:44:18]
Well, I'm here. I also just address council member O'Connor's question about how the financing
[2:44:26]
of the long term, first the cleanup and the long-term maintenance happens because I think
[2:44:32]
you have an, you know, kind of an excellent example right here at zero point. So the cleanup
[2:44:38]
was done, the landfill was closed by the developer, the master developer at the time, the
[2:44:47]
site itself used tax increment to fund most of that cleanup money,
[2:44:55]
recalls your point was
[2:44:56]
in a redevelopment area, and tax increment was the tool you.
[2:45:01]
So, it was a public, basically a publicly funded cleanup. Then, as each of the parcels were sold, each building owner, or land owner, is required to participate in something called the Sierra Point Environmental Management Association, or FEMA.
[2:45:20]
And you pay quarterly dues, as a member of that, and those dues go to the quarterly inspections that have to be done on the landfill.
[2:45:30]
They pay for the environmental consultant to go do all of those quarterly inspections, submit all those reports to the water board,
[2:45:39]
that pays for a pollution liability insurance, in case anything goes wrong with the cap or
[2:45:46]
you know, in the other tort reliability,
[2:45:51]
and that spima was put in place in 1998, and it's been,
[2:45:54]
you know, running very successfully, you know, for the last 27 years.
[2:46:02]
But that is the model that we would be looking at for the bailouts too.
[2:46:07]
Thank you.
[2:46:09]
Council Member O'Connell, you're next. Did you want to partly off with what you just heard and you said you had another question? Maybe this is a good time.
[2:46:18]
I do have another question.
[2:46:26]
So, I'm assuming that operations and management are going to be different for the different sections, and they're going to be doing,
[2:46:35]
since they're planning to do it in phases of 1, 2, 3, 4 on the west side.
[2:46:47]
What if developer 1, who must have the O&M financing process approved by the State Regulatory Agency,
[2:46:58]
It hasn't completed that to satisfaction.
[2:47:04]
Developer 2 might not even be related to developer 1.
[2:47:10]
Now cannot get building permits if we're holding it up for that.
[2:47:15]
Is that something that legal would need to get involved in because how could we not
[2:47:22]
allow developer to choose development to move forward if development developer one is not
[2:47:31]
completed their financial responsibilities.
[2:47:36]
Well, if the site depends on how the site is regulated, if the specifically and requires
[2:47:41]
it to be done in in phases and in earlier phases haven't been satisfied then it becomes
[2:47:50]
you know that subsequent like the successor and interest it becomes their risk and they
[2:47:57]
would need to I'm sure negotiate with before they acquired the property ways to mitigate
[2:48:05]
that risk either step in right surferances the things we're going to be complete as a practical
[2:48:11]
matter. I mean, a lot of times when there are requirements that are outside of a future
[2:48:17]
phase developers control, they will wait, they won't start until they're sure that
[2:48:24]
the last phase has been complete. So they're not taking on risk and starting something
[2:48:32]
that they can't get occupancy permits for or something like that.
[2:48:36]
But, and I'm going to go on a limb here and ask a second question.
[2:48:45]
The specific plan says that the entire west side needs to be remediated before the first building permit is issued for building on the west side.
[2:48:56]
So the whole site would need to be remediated first, correct?
[2:49:01]
I don't think that the specific plan does say that.
[2:49:07]
I thought we talked about that the last minute and I thought that that was in the specific plan that the entire west side would be
[2:49:16]
mediated before the first building permit on the west side.
[2:49:22]
I think this was a little bit confusing at the last meeting.
[2:49:27]
I agree.
[2:49:28]
And just to weigh in, I mean typically the way it works is that the remediation plans talk about the phasing
[2:49:37]
of the cleanup, and so what normally happens, and I'll use, I don't know if you're familiar with the
[2:49:43]
Brooklyn Basin development, over in Oakland, but that's one where there's an overarching cleanup
[2:49:49]
plan, and then the different phases would get approval that it's been remediated prior to construction
[2:49:57]
on the given phase, but technically it's not that the whole west side would have to be cleaned up.
[2:50:04]
I know that's what was stated last week, but as a practical matter, the agency would approve
[2:50:11]
of each phase as it gets cleaned up.
[2:50:16]
Okay, well, I have to disagree because in our staff report page six of eight last week,
[2:50:23]
it says state approved remediation for OUSM and OU2 must be certified complete before construction
[2:50:30]
permission permits our issued west of Caltering.
[2:50:40]
So maybe our staff report is incorrect.
[2:50:43]
And I'm sorry to call you out. But if that's the case, I'm working on wrong information.
[2:50:54]
I could just speak to what's done on a practical matter.
[2:50:57]
Other developments with Brooklyn Basin being an example of phased approvals.
[2:51:12]
Let's see. We have Mayor Protem Davis.
[2:51:22]
The specific plan references financial assurances for long-term operation, maintenance, and monitoring.
[2:51:35]
What specific financial instruments will be required?
[2:51:39]
Who determines their amount?
[2:51:41]
And how will the amount be calculated to cover actual anticipated costs of maintaining the landfill cap,
[2:51:49]
the Chate Management, landfill gas controls,
[2:51:52]
groundwater monitoring, and other remedy components.
[2:51:56]
And I know a lot of these questions are very similar.
[2:52:02]
And they probably all have similar answers.
[2:52:07]
But I think it's just important to ask these very similar
[2:52:11]
of questions with these key differences for the public sake.
[2:52:30]
Did you want to get it or do you want me to? I'm not sure. It turns out a lot of it is similar to what you answered before Michelle. Maybe you can repeat it and then we can tease out what some of the differences are that.
[2:52:42]
I'm not. I'm not quite kept the nuance either, but the idea is that typically before entering into an operations and maintenance agreement with the regulatory agencies, there's a requirement to do this 30 year projected cost estimate.
[2:52:59]
So, if you think about the landfill, just using the landfill as your example, then the annual costs of operating the leachate collection system,
[2:53:09]
the landfill gas collection system, maintaining the cap and cover system, and so forth, would all be included in those and the reporting that would be required to be included in that 30 year estimate.
[2:53:21]
Can I? Is it okay to ask a really brief follow-up? Um, so is that adjusted periodically to reflect inflation or changing
[2:53:31]
site conditions or actual cost of repairs that have already occurred? Um, or the costs that we know more clearly as things.
[2:53:43]
Develop over time. The financial assurance mechanism itself as far as I know is not those estimates are
[2:53:50]
I'm not adjusted but I could be wrong, I just am not aware.
[2:53:56]
Okay, thank you.
[2:53:59]
Okay.
[2:54:00]
I don't have another question on this section, so we'll go back to, let's see, Council Member O'Connell.
[2:54:10]
Oh, I'm sorry, I missed Council Member Lens.
[2:54:12]
I don't have any more questions at the moment.
[2:54:14]
Sorry, you're next.
[2:54:15]
No worries.
[2:54:16]
All right, so I'm going to ask the question that Michelle didn't feel comfortable.
[2:54:22]
responding to. And that is could there be a post remediation security
[2:54:28]
positive food by the city council prior to Vestig land rights?
[2:54:40]
Vestig rights are required at a couple of different points in the process.
[2:54:44]
It could be through development agreement, through application for a Vestig
[2:54:48]
tentative map, otherwise under the common wall Vestig rights donor crew until
[2:54:53]
after building permits have been acquired and construction has begun, you have to incur
[2:54:59]
liabilities in reliance on a validly issued permit to accrue your vested rights.
[2:55:06]
If you are negotiating a development agreement, you can, whatever the parties are able to agree
[2:55:12]
to in terms of terms to get those early vested rights, you're free to negotiate for,
[2:55:19]
But otherwise, if we're waiting for the common law bested rights, it will be much, much further down the line in the process and a lot more of the regulatory work and remediation work will have been undertaken at that point.
[2:55:34]
So the reason why I'm asking the question is that when you take out insurance, you know homeowners medical, there's usually a deductible and depending upon how much you invest in your insurance policy determines how much the deductible is.
[2:55:53]
So if you put in the bare minimum, there's going to be a large deductible.
[2:55:58]
And so if we're placing that burden on home under association, that's a large nut that if there was something to go wrong as opposed to if you put down deposit and that was invested that then that money would be there to be able to use in case there was
[2:56:34]
So, I don't know, I mean, again, it sounds like you can require that, I guess it would be
[2:56:41]
something you wouldn't negotiate, you couldn't as a requirement, I guess what I'm getting
[2:56:45]
at.
[2:56:49]
I think it's something, and what is it that we want to require?
[2:56:53]
So, again, having some kind of fund that then could accumulate over time that the property
[2:57:01]
owners invest in, they put money in it and it builds over time so kind of like your insurance
[2:57:07]
policy where you would then pay that deductible. That's where that money would have come from.
[2:57:13]
So it's all coming from the group as opposed to say a handful of homeowners and then
[2:57:24]
having that be a significant burden to them because obviously no one wants to foreclose on anyone who
[2:57:30]
I can't pay the repairs.
[2:57:36]
Sure, we can think a little bit more about a structure that's responsive to what you're suggesting.
[2:57:43]
We'll talk about that as stuff.
[2:57:45]
Okay, great.
[2:57:46]
I appreciate that, thank you.
[2:57:50]
So other people have asked my questions, but I'm going to dovetail on what you said.
[2:57:53]
I would have the same concern with property changing hands and someone coming in
[2:58:00]
several new property owners and things are falling back on the HOA and they say we just don't
[2:58:06]
have the money. That has happened before in Brisbane with HOA's where they needed significant
[2:58:11]
repairs and they said we just don't have the money. So I think that that's probably based on
[2:58:17]
experience a wise thing to consider and that's I'm sure part of where it came from.
[2:58:23]
use that. Yeah, okay. We're back to let's see, Mayor Potembevis.
[2:58:33]
So this is one that the
[2:58:35]
public has asked and that I've heard from the public so asking this for asking this so
[2:58:45]
that it's part of the public record. Is there any circumstance in which the city could be
[2:58:51]
expected to pay for repairs or assume responsibility for the site because the responsible
[2:58:57]
party or property owners cannot meet the costs.
[2:59:08]
The structure is to keep it all on privately and the city wouldn't have an ownership interest,
[2:59:13]
the city wouldn't have a direct responsibility or obligation to perform repairs or step-in
[2:59:21]
or provide, you know, financing up itself.
[2:59:25]
Thank you.
[2:59:26]
I have one other question in the section.
[2:59:29]
Thank you.
[2:59:30]
Council member O'Connell.
[2:59:34]
I'm good for now.
[2:59:35]
Okay.
[2:59:36]
Council member Lance.
[2:59:39]
I think I'm good for now.
[2:59:40]
Okay.
[2:59:40]
Back to you, Mayor Proton.
[2:59:43]
So a couple of weeks ago, O'Sack,
[2:59:45]
sent us a list of suggestions, regarding remediation and long-term monitoring,
[2:59:56]
and I'm curious if the city attorney can clarify.
[3:00:00]
By whether these recommendations protect the city within its existing authority, or risk creating liability for the city, because we want to ensure that the city does not inadvertently assume responsibility for long term, environmental oversight that properly belongs to responsible parties and regulatory agencies.
[3:00:28]
Yeah, so the formulation that you just said, I think, is correct in the most protective approach for the city, is that the jurisdictional regulatory agencies with authority over the cleanup are the appropriate bodies to define how much cleanup is required, what mechanisms or necessary to be satisfied, and that the city, I think,
[3:00:57]
benefits from being one step removed from making those decisions and making any representations
[3:01:04]
or warranties about the final work, however, the aspect that OSEC highlighted and I think
[3:01:13]
it's consistent with what the Planning Commission said, making sure that all reporting and efforts
[3:01:20]
to comply with those regulatory agencies are made available to the city so that the city
[3:01:26]
can continue to be aware of it, to continue to peer review and comment to the agencies
[3:01:33]
as appropriate as was done as the audit and wrap or being created and using the city's
[3:01:41]
regulatory authority to withhold permits if the remediation hasn't been completed to the
[3:01:55]
It's a appropriate regulatory measures for the city to take in ways that the city can be involved
[3:02:00]
as a partner in the process without exposing itself to additional risks or liability.
[3:02:08]
Thank you so much for that thorough response.
[3:02:11]
All right, we're on to public comments, so I'm going to read you the sequence of names.
[3:02:16]
We have Linda Salman, then Michelle Salman, Paul Buscal,
[3:02:20]
Emmett Cunningham, Charles Spencer, Robin Lider, Susan Branding.
[3:02:26]
So Linda, up first, so do we need to do we need to extend the meeting?
[3:02:32]
Oh yes, we do.
[3:02:33]
Can we have a motion to extend the meeting for an hour, please?
[3:02:36]
Summer.
[3:02:37]
Second.
[3:02:38]
All in favor?
[3:02:39]
Aye.
[3:02:39]
Anyone opposed?
[3:02:41]
Mootings extended to 930.
[3:02:44]
Thank you.
[3:02:45]
cross-lambal call.
[3:02:48]
Why this new equipment is really hard to hear people.
[3:02:52]
It's really difficult.
[3:02:56]
I was surprised to see the letter that they sent the day after,
[3:02:59]
in terms of the money that they owe us
[3:03:01]
and why they're not paying it.
[3:03:04]
It really causes me to question their reliability
[3:03:09]
in terms of, this is sequest in terms of asking for these permits
[3:03:15]
and things like that.
[3:03:17]
They're complaining that they've already spent $13 million
[3:03:21]
to reimburse us, and $7 million is just too much.
[3:03:27]
They want all kinds of stuff from us.
[3:03:29]
My question is, who's going to go bankrupt first?
[3:03:31]
Them or us?
[3:03:33]
It seems like there's a plot to make us go bankrupt
[3:03:36]
so that what the state then becomes in charge of everything
[3:03:41]
and building on our mountain, doing whatever they want,
[3:03:45]
they're going to make Brisbane disappear, but the whole thing just doesn't make a lot of
[3:03:51]
sense to me. They say, well, the costs that were estimated in 2022 were much more now
[3:04:01]
than they were. We've seen what has happened to prices in the last four years. I mean, so we're
[3:04:07]
about estimating amounts that are going to be liable for in 20 years, 10 years?
[3:04:16]
It's anybody's guess, the same, what has to be only this amount.
[3:04:19]
They're only going to be responsible for that.
[3:04:23]
Who's going to be responsible?
[3:04:25]
We're going to end up being the ones who are responsible or the state will take it over and
[3:04:31]
disappear, brisping.
[3:04:33]
This does not sound like a good plan to me.
[3:04:37]
So, as these issues are separate, they're going on about, from the projects required to be
[3:04:42]
physical, physically responsive to the city and blah, blah, blah.
[3:04:49]
I'm sorry, it's really not acceptable to me at all, and I know that Jeremy said it wasn't
[3:04:54]
acceptable to the staff either, to this reply.
[3:04:58]
So, to me, if we're going to do anything going forward with these people, they have to
[3:05:03]
responsible and start reimbursing us.
[3:05:06]
We already have a problem with Park and Rec and for things with the seniors, for stuff with
[3:05:13]
the kids about, well, we don't have enough money to, we have to increase the price of the
[3:05:19]
senior lunches.
[3:05:19]
We don't have enough staff to have the senior sunrise room open, all we have to have the kids
[3:05:27]
things pay for their own sewer because we can't afford it, you know, all these things
[3:05:32]
are changing in terms of the management of the city. So the city is crying poor mouth
[3:05:38]
and they're saying, oh well, it's the city's fault because their estimate was wrong.
[3:05:44]
I'm sorry, this is not going to work in terms of blaming us for them not being able to do
[3:05:57]
quite frankly, they're the way they're talking, we haven't heard about their finances,
[3:06:01]
but getting bonds from the state to do all the building and things like that,
[3:06:04]
and not even being responsible themselves. We're going to end up with the same situation
[3:06:09]
that we had in the Northeast Ridge of making all these agreements and things like that,
[3:06:14]
and then the thing is sold to other people, and nothing gets done correctly. This is not viable
[3:06:21]
this way. So somebody has to step up and be serious about if you're really going to do the development,
[3:06:29]
then commit to it, ensure it and make sure that it's going to happen for the less next 30 years.
[3:06:38]
Michelle?
[3:06:43]
This is a really complex issue and I'm really glad that the city is taking a lot of time with it.
[3:06:48]
When we talked about what infrastructure and cost to the city and risks,
[3:06:54]
I have questions about when we still be required to repair streets and infrastructure, et cetera,
[3:07:03]
if there was failure there, sort of like how the streets at the Northeast ridden got dedicated to the city of Brisbane and now we're responsible for any repairs on those city streets.
[3:07:14]
And is it going to be similar to that or will all the infrastructure still be covered by the development agreements and that type of thing?
[3:07:25]
And I also wonder about the type of fire equipment that we're going to need to be able to...
[3:07:30]
Safely have 22 story buildings or however high they plan to have buildings. It is a complex set of plans and in, you know, the city's been called the task by the state for dragging our feet.
[3:07:51]
But we haven't been really the ones who've been dragging our feet.
[3:07:55]
Greg Villkin in November of 2018 promised they would just get right on getting the specific
[3:08:01]
plan done and even sent a letter to the council that way.
[3:08:06]
And the first specific plan that we actually got from the valence development ink was not
[3:08:13]
until 2023, end of 2023, something like that.
[3:08:18]
And it was not a viable plan.
[3:08:21]
And so it was returned, and this isn't a viable plan.
[3:08:24]
And then the next one was the end of 2025.
[3:08:28]
And that's a long time.
[3:08:29]
And I read those plans as part of my duties with OSEC.
[3:08:34]
And I brought up several times that this specific plan
[3:08:37]
that was put forth did not match the program EIR,
[3:08:42]
or the specific plan EIR, and that was a concern, and we're feeling that now that what the
[3:08:50]
specific plan laid out as the map of where they wanted what didn't really match the draft EIR,
[3:09:00]
and to me that was a big concern, and I did bring it up several times, it's definitely this doesn't
[3:09:05]
to Katie and they're like, well this is our specific plan and that's the
[3:09:11]
cities draft the IR. Well I'm sorry but the two are should be together and it's
[3:09:18]
all being paid by the developer and so that was a real disconnect for me and I'm
[3:09:23]
seeing that disconnect as I listen to these hearings and sort of timing issues and
[3:09:28]
what's going to be where and concerns about the risks that the city is going to
[3:09:33]
take. Because once measure JJ passed, I knew there was going to be housing on the bail-ance,
[3:09:39]
then I just wanted to make darn sure it was the safest housing we could possibly have on such
[3:09:45]
a dangerous site. And I still feel that way. And so keep up to good work. And let's work
[3:09:52]
towards getting this done, but getting it done right without bankrupting our city or making people ill.
[3:09:58]
Thank you.
[3:09:59]
Paul,
[3:10:08]
after Paul, B. Emmett.
[3:10:12]
Thank you.
[3:10:13]
Could you remind me where I should be as far as discussing something right now?
[3:10:19]
We are in city liability and financial risk.
[3:10:22]
I thought so.
[3:10:24]
I just wanted to make sure if I go off topic, just stop me.
[3:10:28]
So, for city liability and risks, you know, the 25% open space puts us in a liability.
[3:10:38]
As much as I would like to see 25% open space on the Baylands, park,
[3:10:45]
or wherever it is, open space just means public property.
[3:10:51]
So we are going to be responsible for the cap that's been compromised or anything else that goes on on our 25% of the open space because it's now public property.
[3:11:05]
So in that sense, that puts us at risk.
[3:11:10]
Something that puts us at risk is not having any mention of a public works corporation yard or how we're going to support public works throughout.
[3:11:21]
Not only this project, but the lifetime of the bailiards.
[3:11:28]
I haven't seen anything mentioned regarding public works.
[3:11:32]
So, as far as finances go, what's up with that, how's that going to get funded?
[3:11:40]
You talk about the fire department and a police substation,
[3:11:46]
and I mean a fire station
[3:11:49]
and a police substation, but normally it's in a public works.
[3:11:54]
So,
[3:11:57]
yeah, that's, you know, and I'm going to get off topic.
[3:12:05]
It goes back to S. not collaborating with San Francisco, and I wrongfully accused council member
[3:12:12]
lunches, so when they said he didn't want to meet, but it was said, and it was said amongst
[3:12:17]
the council and I believe staff to some degree at the time.
[3:12:25]
But with that said, there's a while I really go and I mean nothing's been done with this
[3:12:31]
first off site that's supposed to be built before anything happening in Brisbane.
[3:12:36]
Now we've got the candlestick site going on on the other side and the interchange and
[3:12:42]
the multi-modal station and all these things that we're talked about and the plan that was
[3:12:47]
picking up within 2015 that's going to expire in 2030 which I mentioned.
[3:12:53]
I mean, those are our abilities to us. This won't look at this Bay Area as a San Francisco development
[3:13:00]
and a Brisbane development and not a regional development. We won't have a grocery store come in here
[3:13:07]
because they say Brisbane does have the population to support a grocery store but
[3:13:12]
We should be looking at these things as a regional need because this is a desert, this whole quadrant of this part of the peninsula is a desert to some degree.
[3:13:26]
So there's no mention in trying to come up with the plan that's going to be viable.
[3:13:32]
and to phase this play and development and not have a connection
[3:13:38]
to 101 or to the train stations until the second phase of the development puts us at risk.
[3:13:47]
So, you know, all the slage lock traffic is going to come down, be sure.
[3:13:51]
All that first development phase is all going to come down, be sure.
[3:13:54]
No connection going over to 101.
[3:13:57]
That puts us at a financial...
[3:14:01]
It just really puts us in a bind, so see, I will not have topic, but I appreciate your time and thank you.
[3:14:08]
Okay.
[3:14:16]
I plan to just talk about a couple things tonight, and I plan to talk about a couple things tonight, but do the various wonderful presentations by staff and Stephanie.
[3:14:26]
My list is grown unfortunately.
[3:14:31]
Sorry about that.
[3:14:34]
I can.
[3:14:36]
I'm going to go into all of them.
[3:14:38]
The challenge here, when you've had certain problems in town where people have actually
[3:14:43]
built, home changes to their home and run out of money.
[3:14:48]
What happens if the bail-ins developer or one of the bail-ins developers runs out of money
[3:14:52]
in the middle of their project?
[3:14:55]
Do we have any kind of assurances that this will, that the project can commence?
[3:15:00]
And not have the city get stuck on it.
[3:15:05]
Is there some kind of financial mechanism to protect us, basically?
[3:15:09]
And I'm not asking for a specific thing, just basically a general way to protect ourselves from that.
[3:15:14]
And once again, this comes back to some of the things that have been mentioned in a general sense.
[3:15:20]
Many of the discussions so far about changing topics, many of the discussions so far about, have been about expected maintenance,
[3:15:26]
What about catastrophic problems, who's financially responsible for those?
[3:15:32]
We're talking about a very large, complex system, and I don't think anybody's actually
[3:15:37]
built one like this before, so there's obviously a lot of risk, which is why everybody's
[3:15:43]
so nervous, moving on.
[3:15:50]
Moving down, a comment earlier from one of you, I can't remember, I think it was Terry,
[3:15:56]
I had this already, but she was talking about it.
[3:16:00]
One of the projects that I've seen as a software engineer
[3:16:03]
have been broken up into things that can go in parallel.
[3:16:06]
Everything I've seen in this project is all serial.
[3:16:09]
One thing, next thing, next thing.
[3:16:11]
It's like a bunch of train cars.
[3:16:13]
How come these things aren't parallelized?
[3:16:16]
Where one thing opens up three different projects
[3:16:19]
that can be run at the same time.
[3:16:22]
I'm sorry, sorry.
[3:16:23]
It's taking off of your question.
[3:16:24]
It was there beforehand, but it's a generalization of your point that you are making.
[3:16:31]
Let's see where I'm going backward here trying to cut out these back in.
[3:16:34]
A comment earlier on Ice House Hill.
[3:16:37]
There was not going to be any retaining wall or barrier around Ice House Hill.
[3:16:40]
Ice House Hill happened on that side with a road next to it.
[3:16:44]
It is going to have the same problems that Ice House Hill has on Bayshore.
[3:16:47]
There's rocks coming down Ice House Hill all the time.
[3:16:49]
If you've been out there, I think Cliff runs out there periodically.
[3:16:52]
likely I'd used to bike out there all the time.
[3:16:55]
I used to avoid it because I used to go around as far away from that hill as possible because
[3:16:59]
rocks would come down and some of them are 3 and 500 pounds.
[3:17:03]
They could do some damage.
[3:17:04]
I think we need something there to protect that.
[3:17:08]
Yeah, I'm squishy, rocks aren't.
[3:17:12]
One of the comments earlier was about the significance of the 101,000 first unit being built.
[3:17:18]
I don't understand the significance of that.
[3:17:20]
It seems like the real hurdle here is 51% of the homes being built or homes and commercial so that we can actually enable the Geneva why what was the big focus on
[3:17:30]
1,000 1,000 1,000 first home, it didn't get it, apologize, I'm trying to get you fast here and go through this stuff.
[3:17:38]
So movement, we talked about this over and over again, I'd like to hear that there's a possibility of a conveyor belt above the train tracks is probably not viable
[3:17:49]
because Caltrain is going to complain, have up below.
[3:17:58]
Where was it? There was another one about that.
[3:18:05]
There was a comment about drainage going to and from the example that Stephanie put up
[3:18:10]
showed water running directly down towards Caltrain.
[3:18:15]
And Cliff was bringing this up and Mayor Mackin was bringing this up separately.
[3:18:19]
As trying to work with our owners of these properties,
[3:18:24]
Do we need to include a review with Caltraine about the water and the drainage going down towards Caltraine to make sure that we're protecting Caltraine from any problems that they might be having as well?
[3:18:34]
There are another customer or another peer that we're working with, apologize. I'm going over. I'll stop now. Thanks.
[3:18:42]
You got five more.
[3:18:44]
Charles Spencer?
[3:18:52]
Good evening. My name is Charles Spencer. I'm a Brisbane President.
[3:18:55]
And my questions are comments concerned, the reimbursement agreement.
[3:19:01]
During the October 20th, 2026 Baylands meeting Councilwoman O'Connell mentioned in a
[3:19:08]
approximate $7 billion balance due from Baylands.
[3:19:11]
I won't repeat most of the comments that have already been made tonight, but I have three questions.
[3:19:15]
The first is where can we get a signed copy of this agreement so we can read and see what the content is contained.
[3:19:22]
Well, second question, because the bail-ans is past due on their payment, other funds have
[3:19:29]
been used to pay the expenses incurred by bail-ans.
[3:19:33]
What expenses, what funds were used to pay those expenses?
[3:19:36]
And my last question, because the bail-ans is past due, in that agreement, is there a clause
[3:19:43]
for legal action and is there a clause to suspend all negotiations until a balance is paid?
[3:19:49]
Thank you. I have some questions. I'll give them to the,
[3:19:56]
uh, Robin Wider.
[3:20:06]
Something came up last meeting, and I would hope that it would be finalized this meeting, but it guess it wasn't.
[3:20:14]
A grading plan showed that we saw today shows us from above what things look like.
[3:20:20]
However,
[3:20:23]
a cross section does something else. It gives you a side view of the land.
[3:20:27]
It tells you what exists today, what will be excavated, what will be filled, the field will be placed and how the proposed elevations will connect to the surrounding properties.
[3:20:37]
I would ask that for anybody who wants to really understand the grading as I would like to, I don't understand why.
[3:20:44]
I know it was asked by the council last time that we couldn't get the developer or the engineer to give us cross sections so we could really see.
[3:20:52]
And this is particularly true because what we've shown tonight is an easier part, if one could actually say there's an easier part of the Baylands.
[3:21:02]
So my concern is as the elevation changes, what happens to Bashar sanitary district and their car-level pumping station,
[3:21:11]
mortgage, kinden, and the tank farm. Golden State lumber, lagoon, intersection, all of those
[3:21:20]
say in the ER that they're going to flood. And basher sanitary district really did a very
[3:21:27]
good job with their comments. They said that they thought they needed to be a master, storm
[3:21:33]
drainage basin plan from the uphill of where the Levinson property is through the brick
[3:21:43]
arch sewer onto the baylands and then connecting all of it so we could see that how it all
[3:21:49]
works. The EIR replied that that wasn't necessary and I would to urge the council that I think
[3:21:55]
it is very necessary. I kind of make the suggestion that if you think of a walking shower and now
[3:22:03]
change it to a bathtub. Okay, you've created higher elevations on the side. So instead, if you
[3:22:10]
think of the tank farmers, an example, right now it kind of ponds and goes down the driveway.
[3:22:16]
But if you raise it around the corners, like a bathtub, the water's going to stay in kindergarten,
[3:22:23]
and it's going to create a different thing than being able to drain off.
[3:22:28]
Even, Emma.
[3:22:30]
Analysis in the area does the storm water increase, and if it doesn't increase, then it says that the existing
[3:22:40]
net properties may have to be modified by undertaking by others. And I'm not sure who those others mean.
[3:22:55]
I guess
[3:22:57]
responsible for every low-lying existing property. But I do think they are responsible for
[3:23:04]
consulting with those other existing property owners and that that needs to be part of what's
[3:23:10]
presented to the city. And the reason I say that is, is if you allow them to grade and put the
[3:23:17]
dirt where it is now, those businesses will come to the city afterwards complaining about what has
[3:23:24]
done to their property and their access in the same way that the base or sanitary district
[3:23:31]
does.
[3:23:32]
We need to know that how the drainage will work during construction once the developer raises
[3:23:38]
the first building pad and installs permanent roads and storm roads.
[3:23:43]
Those elevations will then affect every bit of the rest of the property.
[3:23:48]
And like unlike almost any infrastructure you're ever going to do, drainage is basically
[3:23:54]
when it's good, it's gravity fat. So if you get it wrong, then you have pump stations everywhere
[3:24:01]
because you got it wrong. I happen to think that the developer should bring cross-sections
[3:24:08]
so we can more accurately define what the impacts are. And I hope that you will follow through
[3:24:14]
on that so we can ensure that the drainage is properly done from the beginning. I thank you.
[3:24:22]
Susan Branden?
[3:24:33]
Well, just basically, I would love to know if there's ever been a large scale project.
[3:24:41]
Not necessarily as big as this, but that this developer has undertaken,
[3:24:49]
or I'd also like to know what other projects this developer has undertaken.
[3:24:55]
Because then I'd feel a lot more comfortable with putting my trust with this developer.
[3:25:06]
Also, I think that when Eric had said about how Brisbane could become,
[3:25:14]
can jump in and become a kind of partner with, I guess, the developer.
[3:25:25]
I think that this whole chain of command is the state, the waterboard and San Mateo County.
[3:25:36]
And I think that, you know, my fear is that if let's say a developer winds up declaring bankruptcy,
[3:25:50]
and then the financial responsibility goes to the property owners of the bailance.
[3:26:02]
And it would just be an enormous, I mean, unless there's some kind of fund established
[3:26:07]
or some protection for them, I mean, by and large, I don't think that they would assume
[3:26:13]
responsibility for that level of care that this whole undertaking involves.
[3:26:24]
And then I think that, too, as I said before, the developer gets a bond, I think, from
[3:26:33]
the state, with an agreement that they'll pay it back in a certain amount of time, but if
[3:26:39]
the developer is out of the picture, if they declare bankruptcy or whatever happens, then
[3:26:46]
It does become the responsibility of the homeowners and renters or occupants.
[3:26:54]
And I just can't see that they're going to step up and assume that kind of liability.
[3:27:01]
And then I think the state would turn around and sue the city of Brisbane.
[3:27:04]
I really think that that's where the, you know, that this would end up in the worst case scenario
[3:27:11]
and that really frightens me.
[3:27:12]
And I just want to make one correction before when I was talking about the, I didn't mean the EIR,
[3:27:18]
where it had said that Brisbane was just a couple of points below a super fun site when that was
[3:27:25]
determined. It was the EPA, the Environmental Protection Agency. And I mean it's really, really,
[3:27:33]
very, it's not a light matter to move that level of soil and it would involve more expense.
[3:27:40]
And I think it's something that has to really be written in to any agreement before toxic soil is moved.
[3:27:49]
Thank you.
[3:27:52]
Claire Johnson, online.
[3:28:05]
Hello.
[3:28:06]
You're there.
[3:28:07]
Go ahead.
[3:28:09]
I'm sorry, but I didn't have my hand up.
[3:28:13]
I appreciate it.
[3:28:15]
I just had that.
[3:28:17]
That's sorry.
[3:28:18]
You wanted to continue the financial discussion?
[3:28:21]
Right.
[3:28:21]
I'm sorry, I wanted to kind of make it clear if my understanding is clear of it that it would be better to have the waterboard hold the bond and I say bond because that's the only kind of financial assurance that I can think of and I really wanted you to know that
[3:28:49]
But there's a high degree of certainty that they would, they being the water ward would extend
[3:29:01]
the bond.
[3:29:04]
In other words, require about for another 30 years, and it was even implied that if it needed
[3:29:11]
to be 90 years, that might be possible, and that is not something Brisbane could do, and
[3:29:18]
And I think that the discussions you've had tonight about the regulators and their relation
[3:29:24]
to the financial assurances makes it the best course of action is to go through them.
[3:29:34]
And as I think I said recently before, the way they organize things you want to have
[3:29:48]
and they would probably have separate links.
[3:29:52]
It wasn't certain that you could get a 90 year extension from the landfill,
[3:29:57]
but it mentioned that it's possible.
[3:30:00]
With the OU2. That was one thing I wanted to tell you.
[3:30:07]
Thank you, Claire. Thank you. Those are all the slips I have, so we would proceed into topic number 6.
[3:30:21]
Faising, specific plan, chapter 9, two different development phases.
[3:30:28]
Starting with Consmember O'Connell.
[3:30:37]
I don't have any questions at this moment, ready.
[3:30:41]
Okay.
[3:30:42]
You want me to circle back to you?
[3:30:43]
Sure.
[3:30:44]
Okay.
[3:30:45]
Then let's go to Mayor Protem Davis.
[3:30:48]
I have one for this section so far.
[3:30:51]
The specific plan differs important details regarding the timing of remediation, landfill closure, infrastructure, and development, to the development agreement.
[3:31:02]
Given that we cannot assume an agreement will ultimately be executed, it would be nice if staff could draft some language for everything that can be legally incorporated into the specific plan now.
[3:31:14]
And I know this is just, this is a comment you hear from me all the time, but I'm just bringing it up in every place where I think there might be a
[3:31:22]
little bit of work to do so if we could just
[3:31:25]
evaluate and see how we might
[3:31:28]
be able to get some language that would be great.
[3:31:32]
Yeah, the point I'll take in and then a lot of what Kevin presented at the beginning of the meeting
[3:31:38]
He's intended to address the gap in phasing requirements by a deferred development agreement in particular that could be other topics as well.
[3:31:50]
And we'll continue to think about those bad as console continues to ask question and discusses if we provide feedback on that phasing and how to fill that gap that will be helpful for staff as well.
[3:32:00]
I appreciate all the work you guys have been doing.
[3:32:04]
Councilmember Lens, I don't have any questions left, which is it, we talked about it, at least my questions got answered at the beginning.
[3:32:14]
Okay, Councilmember O'Connell, circling back to you.
[3:32:25]
I'm not really prepared to talk about the phasing sequence because my expectations of the phasing and sequencing were predicated on
[3:32:41]
information that I'm now told is incorrect. And so I think some of my questions in that regard are going to be
[3:32:53]
predicated and not quite in the proper way because of that
[3:33:01]
misunderstanding on my part. Okay. So I just have one question and
[3:33:07]
I can interpret this, but I'd rather staff could clarify it.
[3:33:14]
It says it talks about the development allocation process section 9.3.2 governs block level allocation of dwelling units and commercial square footage over the approximately 20 year buildout.
[3:33:30]
So, that, here's the key phrase, so that development in one part of a district does not
[3:33:36]
prematurely consume the district's capacity.
[3:33:43]
I can interpret that different ways.
[3:33:45]
Could you tell me what that is meant?
[3:33:49]
Yeah, so the development standards in the different districts are a little bit flexible.
[3:33:56]
I think they allow for if you were to build at the ultimate ceiling to fill all of the space.
[3:34:09]
It would exceed the program that's allowed under the specific plan.
[3:34:13]
So the development allocation process is a way to make sure that it's being evenly distributed as the project develops in phases.
[3:34:23]
so that earlier phases don't basically use up all the development capacity and leave empty space to come later in future phases.
[3:34:35]
It's a way for the city to continue to monitor and ensure that the growth is balanced and distributed
[3:34:44]
and throughout all of the different districts that are allocated development in the specific plan.
[3:34:50]
So what we saw earlier just then to clarify where we saw the different developments with housing numbers,
[3:34:58]
which we couldn't read, but we know the numbers are there.
[3:35:01]
Is that what you're talking about?
[3:35:02]
So yes, things prescribed rather than left up to a developer to decide what's going.
[3:35:10]
When those numbers that are distributed by any block in district are
[3:35:18]
are able to be a little bit flexible, it's not a, there is some room for to develop at the
[3:35:26]
densities that are permitted within the development standards that would, you know, shift
[3:35:31]
between blocks a little bit, and that's part of what the development allocation process
[3:35:35]
is trying to help solve for to you to make sure that it doesn't shift too much, and so
[3:35:40]
that there's not adequate development capacity left on those other other blocks within
[3:35:45]
those districts.
[3:35:46]
and does it also balance between the commercial and the residential since measure JJ says that
[3:35:52]
there needs to be a financial viability for the city, so we're not just dealing with residences.
[3:36:00]
So that actually will continue to talk about that when we talk about fiscal positivity,
[3:36:06]
but that's not required in the specific parent currently.
[3:36:12]
No. Okay. Thank you. Very much. All right. Um, back again, any council member questions starting council member Lens, um, you said maybe unless you're going to ask, uh, are you good? All right. So, okay. So, um,
[3:36:32]
Michelle, I want to just get clarification. So in the staff report from, I guess, two weeks ago, right on page six.
[3:36:44]
And we addressed it at the last hearing,
[3:36:49]
and the response from staff and in here any response from you that contradicted it,
[3:36:59]
said the state approved remediation for OU, SM and OU2 must be certified complete before construction permit or issued west of Caltrane.
[3:37:07]
And so it sounded like your response this evening was, this isn't typically done, and therefore maybe there might be some confusion.
[3:37:18]
But that doesn't mean that we could have the requirement that the west side be completed prior to issuing the contract.
[3:37:31]
So, I'll jump in first because I was one that made the statement and it was misleading and could be characterized as a mistake.
[3:37:41]
My understanding of the question was that sentence mentions each block, east of Caltrain, and I thought we're also talking about each block west.
[3:37:51]
So, what the specific plan says is that the remediation occurs in phases and that the development can't occur until that particular part that block or what have you would be remediated.
[3:38:06]
It was not meant to imply, and I can see how the way the staff report was written, that the entire west side would have to be remediated before that first block can occur.
[3:38:16]
What my understanding was was that the maybe I looked at it a little too
[3:38:23]
literally is that you would need to remediate a building site and go through
[3:38:27]
that remediation certified before construction permits would be issued for that
[3:38:35]
particular block. It wasn't meant to imply that you needed all three of those
[3:38:39]
districts to be remediated.
[3:38:41]
In the specific plan, the way it's drafted now, at least does say that fees 1 will progress in stages as site remediation and grading activities are completed, which is more consistent with the way that Michelle described it and that we were showing that the phasing earlier, that the intention wasn't to have mass remediation at once before anything occurs.
[3:39:08]
But to require completion, as you go within the development areas and those development areas,
[3:39:16]
do need to be fully remediated before they can be occupied, but that's, I think, a little bit different
[3:39:22]
than the way the question was for you.
[3:39:24]
So the way that it was understood when we were responding last week.
[3:39:28]
Okay, so then you're saying then that this one, I'm clear, so though before occupancy occurs
[3:39:35]
on the west side, remediation of the entire west side needs to happen?
[3:39:41]
No, that's okay.
[3:39:43]
Remediation of the area that's been developed has to be complete for that area of the occupied,
[3:39:49]
but not that the entire west side needs to be remediated before anything is occupied.
[3:39:54]
All right, could that be a requirement of the, that the council would put into this specific plan?
[3:40:02]
The requirement to remediate everything at once.
[3:40:05]
Yes, before occupancy occurs, is residential occupancy, doesn't mean a commercial occupancy of a residential occupancy.
[3:40:14]
Because it would be concerned if that would be feasible to accomplish that level of remediation over that much area without allowing any development to be occupied first.
[3:40:28]
as a commercial could occur I'm just yeah I don't know what you're saying okay if I
[3:40:37]
may yes I'd like to follow up on that what you're saying a block and I'm I'm looking
[3:40:43]
at where you have A1 through A10 in the OU1 can that entire site or are you talking
[3:40:58]
about just A1 has to be remediated before you can issue a building permit for A1.
[3:41:06]
Yeah.
[3:41:06]
I don't think the intention is, for example, the entire B-shore district, even to be remediated
[3:41:12]
all at once, it would, it would more targeted, it'll be, it'll be defined better as the
[3:41:19]
remediation plans are finalized in connection with the tentative maps, but the intention
[3:41:24]
is not to, it's to be a little bit more granular. Yes. It just, it just seems very awkward
[3:41:34]
to me to grade and remediate A1 and then do A2 and A4. I mean, they're going to need to put
[3:41:46]
infrastructure, they're going to need to put in streets, and I would be more inclined to
[3:41:55]
expect the entire section to be remediated before we allow building on that section.
[3:42:05]
So if it's the base shore district gets remediated before we allow building on the base shore
[3:42:12]
section. I think that's the normal progression of things, but that might be getting into discussion.
[3:42:22]
Okay. Let's see. Mayor Pochem Davis, that's my last question for this section. Okay.
[3:42:33]
I have no other questions for this section, so we go back.
[3:42:38]
Not good. You're good. I'm going to go ahead.
[3:42:41]
Okay.
[3:42:44]
Public comments, questions. In this section, we will have Michelle, Paul,
[3:42:52]
Emmett, Robin,
[3:42:58]
and Linda Salman.
[3:43:05]
Actually, Linda, you're, I'm sorry, Linda was first. I got one of them.
[3:43:08]
Go first this time. I'm already up here. Okay. You go first and she'll go second.
[3:43:16]
I have to question and will the regulators still be regulating 30 years from now?
[3:43:23]
Look what has happened to just the last two years with environmental and regulatory rollbacks
[3:43:29]
in this country.
[3:43:31]
I am really concerned about that and look how fast environmental decline is happening with climate
[3:43:38]
change and sea level rise.
[3:43:39]
It's accelerated dramatically in the last few years, and with the long-facing, I think we need to be really realistic to do the remediation as soon as possible.
[3:43:53]
This long-facing, it's going to be hard to estimate the cost, it's going to be hard to estimate whether we will still have regulatory agencies willing to do it.
[3:44:02]
I'm also really concerned about the grouping of low-income housing units.
[3:44:08]
I have to question, are we creating future getters by not integrating low-income housing with moderate income housing and regular housing?
[3:44:18]
I mean, look what happened when they built Geneva towers.
[3:44:21]
What a tragedy that ended up being.
[3:44:24]
And I feel like building these tall low-income housing towers right next to the railroad tracks is recreating
[3:44:31]
the same nightmare and not allowing people to integrate in old Brisbane, you have, you know,
[3:44:38]
poor people living next to the unpopular people and it's integrated, but right now we're
[3:44:42]
setting it up where a low income housing is over there and then these people are over here.
[3:44:50]
And we're setting up a scenario where we will have differences and basically a ghetto and
[3:44:56]
that's a really big concern for me.
[3:44:59]
and then
[3:45:00]
Mary, I'm glad you brought up the point because I was writing my notes right as you were doing it.
[3:45:04]
How will residents in phase one react or in each phase react to what happens in the next phase?
[3:45:11]
New residents will not be happy and it will devalue the whole area.
[3:45:15]
And I think not remediating an entire district before beginning, before allowing residency or people.
[3:45:27]
Um, puts all the residents at risk, that puts all of that group at risk because when you are doing remediation, you are stirring up the stuff, and that means the exposure corridors are open, and that means people who are living there will be exposed, and we don't know how how that will work, and we don't even know that the regulatory agencies will be around long enough to regulate.
[3:45:57]
certain climate, changes, and both political and physical. So I do recommend each section, each
[3:46:05]
district, you do the whole remediation before you allow occupancy. I don't see how you can do it
[3:46:14]
safely otherwise and make sure that it's done correctly. Thank you for your diligence.
[3:46:21]
Linda, you're on.
[3:46:31]
Okay, that kind of only leads me with one particular area.
[3:46:35]
I think I know whether it was Michelle King or whoever was talking about this, dismissing
[3:46:43]
about exposure, saying, well, you know what we're talking about caps and ruptures and things
[3:46:47]
like that, and she was saying, well, it's only long-term exposure, like 25 to 30 years
[3:46:53]
that's a problem, you know, when I said about clay caps.
[3:46:58]
And so that, something about the, this is why we had discussed this in the planning commission in 1990, whatever it was when we did the general plan.
[3:47:13]
And it seems to me that we have a problem with what kind of housing.
[3:47:20]
So, we're talking now about housing with caps, with families, kids playing on toxic soil that are supposed to be
[3:47:28]
capped and so on and so forth. Whereas when we talked about housing, we were talking about dwelling units,
[3:47:37]
apartments for workers in the area that weren't going to stay for a long time.
[3:47:43]
It was like transitory. They're there because they're working on in the buildings that they're working on.
[3:47:48]
in other words like rental units and not homeowners and things like that.
[3:47:53]
So a lot of stuff has already changed when it comes to long-term exposure, we're talking
[3:48:00]
now about kids and people being there for 30 years and oh well then it's problem, but
[3:48:07]
right now we don't have to worry about it or something of that nature.
[3:48:11]
To me that's a whole long problem when it comes to long-term mediation and stewardship
[3:48:17]
and monitoring. So to check these things, you know, once a year like, make sure that there's no
[3:48:24]
leakage, if there's no problem, and then we could fix it. And then well, then if there's an earthquake,
[3:48:29]
then we have another problem or if there's sudden sea rise and flood, then we have another problem,
[3:48:34]
but it's like, meantime, we've got kids in a clay cap that now is supposed to be clay from the toxic soil.
[3:48:43]
I mean, the only clay that's really around here in Brisbane is gray wacky,
[3:48:46]
as you know, and grey wacky is a crystalline clay that holds water and when it gets full of water,
[3:48:54]
it slumps landslide. So I'm not quite sure what kind of clay cap they're envisioning,
[3:49:02]
that's still bothers me. And above is me that we're not concerned except we're saying,
[3:49:09]
or the toxins are only going to affect them for long term exposure, 25 to 30 years.
[3:49:16]
So, what happens at the end of 30 years when all of these kids are sick?
[3:49:24]
Paul Buske?
[3:49:33]
Thank you.
[3:49:35]
So, I'm just going to reiterate what I talked about earlier regarding the remediation,
[3:49:43]
and I'd like to know if it's possible to be able to just take what they were going to
[3:49:48]
hallway and put it on the other side of the old landfill side and then cap it.
[3:49:53]
And then, you know, like what they've done at Schleslach, I believe that whole site has to be
[3:50:00]
remediated before it started, and I know they're working towards that, and that supposedly
[3:50:10]
he's going to be the first development in the Bayland is a Schleslach site,
[3:50:17]
but with that
[3:50:18]
I never understood why we had to look at the whole balance.
[3:50:26]
Instead of the parcels that were now discussing the west side,
[3:50:34]
now we're talking about one specific site.
[3:50:37]
We're not talking about the whole balance.
[3:50:41]
And to that point, the feasibility clause that goes within the project also has a clause
[3:50:50]
that it allows for mitigation measures to be done when feasible.
[3:50:56]
And I mentioned this at one of the past meetings, we should be focusing on what's feasible
[3:51:02]
in the billions and putting all this time and energy and all the things that we're working
[3:51:10]
towards to try to make this plan viable, but safe, and unique,
[3:51:22]
what's viable out there,
[3:51:24]
and what's going to be feasible, you know, that whole cleanup out there alone could not
[3:51:32]
make this project feasible, possibly.
[3:51:35]
So can we focus on what's feasible?
[3:51:40]
Thank you.
[3:51:42]
Emma, honey him? Emma, we love. Okay, Robin Larder.
[3:51:57]
Since the phasing plan wasn't really
[3:52:00]
in here before I'm hoping that at the next meeting, I wasn't really prepared for the
[3:52:04]
phasing nor do I know what those things showed. So I would hope at the next meeting that
[3:52:09]
you would allow us to discuss the phasing since really I only saw those things tonight.
[3:52:15]
And the second is just in the side, I don't know anything but I would like a somebody
[3:52:19]
could check it out. I heard that the regional agencies take a bond from the developer, but
[3:52:25]
it's a bond of last resort. So somebody said never get...
[3:52:30]
For yourself in between that bond, always be secondary to the bond that they have to post. So I would suggest
[3:52:38]
if you're going to make somebody else responsible, let them be responsible after the bond that
[3:52:43]
has to be posted by the developer with the agency, get tapped, before you put somebody in between
[3:52:50]
if I'm making myself clear.
[3:52:54]
So currently the developer has to put up a primary bond with
[3:52:59]
regional agencies is my understanding. Okay, but it's a bond if there's nobody else on the hook.
[3:53:07]
So if you put the homeowners on the hook, their bond their money gets taken first and the developer is secondary.
[3:53:16]
So I just want to see if we can find out if that's true or not. I don't know that it is so that we don't let them get off the hook by putting somebody else in front.
[3:53:27]
Thank you.
[3:53:32]
That's it. On this topic.
[3:53:35]
Madam Mayor, yes, given that we have two topics left and like 10 minutes, I just wanted to
[3:53:40]
get a status check if we could about kind of how many questions maybe the council has.
[3:53:45]
I don't have anything and numbers under number seven because this was all asked earlier.
[3:53:52]
All the questions I had for this were asked by other council members earlier. And then as it pertains
[3:53:56]
to the Planning Commission, sort of section,
[3:54:00]
I only have one question.
[3:54:03]
So if similarly Council members only have a few questions
[3:54:06]
we might be able to just really wrap up this topic
[3:54:10]
so we can proceed to water.
[3:54:12]
But if not, it would be good to know.
[3:54:14]
Have an idea of how much more questions
[3:54:17]
the Council has leading into the next meeting.
[3:54:20]
I will say that I have more questions under the next topic
[3:54:24]
than I have for the others.
[3:54:27]
So I have quite a bit.
[3:54:28]
Councilmember Lens.
[3:54:33]
I don't have that many questions.
[3:54:36]
There are some things that Robin brought up
[3:54:40]
that I wanted to just highlight against
[3:54:42]
that they were super important.
[3:54:46]
Councilmember O'Connell?
[3:54:50]
I think we should let Councilmember Lens follow up
[3:54:53]
on his questions that have been raised by public comment.
[3:54:57]
And wrap up the meeting.
[3:55:01]
My tendency is to call it an evening, because I have quite a few questions, and then we still
[3:55:06]
have public comments.
[3:55:09]
We're already so far into this.
[3:55:12]
We're too close to 930.
[3:55:15]
So I think I would just go for a adjournment.
[3:55:19]
Do you all agree?
[3:55:22]
Yeah.
[3:55:22]
You know what? Thank you for just let me just say that piece about what Robin brought up and which I
[3:55:28]
just wanted to thank her you know so much for what she said you know in regards to the master trainage
[3:55:36]
basin plan. I mean we try and do our best to articulate but I just I'm just very thankful that she's an advisor for us and that
[3:55:50]
And when we come back next week that we can perhaps have that, at least a discussion about it,
[3:56:00]
showing the cross sections, understanding the plume that's coming from SlageLog and then
[3:56:07]
to show how that master drainage plan impacts the master infrastructure plan.
[3:56:13]
So thank you for that.
[3:56:15]
Okay, a clarifying question for your wrap up just so we can prepare our consults and
[3:56:20]
team to answer your questions. Do you anticipate that we will cover water topics at the next meeting?
[3:56:26]
I would anticipate with input from my colleagues we will certainly start that topic in the next
[3:56:32]
public hearing, but we'll continue the last two topics we have, which are long-term remediation
[3:56:38]
Mediation Stewardship and Monitoring, also the Planning Commission recommendation, remediation
[3:56:44]
reporting and enforcement.
[3:56:48]
Those are topics number seven and eight.
[3:56:52]
Did I go too fast on that?
[3:56:56]
Okay, that being said. Thank you everyone. Have we had the action please? Oh, I mean, sorry. I got to read it.
[3:57:04]
First of all, can I get a first and second to continue the public hearing to Monday, November 9th,
[3:57:09]
twenty twenty six at five thirty p.m.
[3:57:13]
Some move, second.
[3:57:15]
All in favor?
[3:57:15]
Hi.
[3:57:16]
Anyone opposed?
[3:57:18]
Meeting is adjourned at nine twenty four.
[3:57:21]
Thank you.