Agenda
Agenda: https://brisbaneca.api.civicclerk.com/v1/Meetings/GetMeetingFileStream(fileId=12720,plainText=false)
Full agenda packet (agenda plus every staff report and attachment): https://brisbaneca.api.civicclerk.com/v1/Meetings/GetMeetingFileStream(fileId=12729,plainText=false)
Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[10:18]
Good evening and welcome to the City Council meeting November 11, 2026, I'm calling meeting to order at 6 30 8 p.m. Sorry for the delay. Would you please join me in the pledge of allegiance?
[10:36]
to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation
[10:43]
under God in the civil with liberty and justice for all.
[10:53]
No city council members are attending remotely city clerk.
[10:56]
Can we have a roll call, please council member Davis here council member Kern here council member
[11:03]
Lens here council member O'Connor here and Mayor Mackin here we move on to adoption of
[11:10]
agenda. I don't believe we have a report out of closed session yet. So could I get a
[11:16]
first and second to adopt the agenda as it stands, please?
[11:19]
Some move to second. A second, length. All in favor? I.
[11:24]
I. Anyone opposed? No. Motion's carried. Our next item is something we look forward to.
[11:32]
It's awards and presentations. Today we have the volunteer, the year and the youth
[11:37]
volunteer of the year recognition and I'm going to read a Proclamation. This is a Proclamation
[11:45]
of the City Council City of Brisbane recognizing Dolores Gomez for her volunteer service
[11:52]
to the City of Brisbane.
[11:57]
Whereas Dolores has demonstrated a lifelong commitment to the
[12:00]
City of Brisbane through her dedication to preserving the community's history, strengthening
[12:05]
civic connections, and generously sharing her time, talents, and knowledge with generations
[12:11]
of residents. And whereas having made Brisbane her home in 1941, Dolores developed
[12:17]
the deep and enduring connection to the community, and he has spent over five decades helping
[12:22]
to preserve the stories, memories, and heritage that define Brisbane. Whereas Dolores began
[12:29]
her career with the Brisbane Library in 1966 and served the community for 27 years, eventually
[12:38]
becoming branch manager and helping transform the library into a welcoming center of learning,
[12:45]
connection and community life. And whereas in 1972, she organized the friends of the Brisbane
[12:51]
Library and organization that continues to support library programs and services and enriched
[12:57]
lives of Brisbane residents today. And whereas Dolores and her dear friend Dorothy Radoff
[13:03]
established the Brisbane History Collection in 1973, collecting photographs, documents, and
[13:10]
stories from longtime residents creating and lasting foundation for preserving Brisbane's unique
[13:18]
history. And whereas through her historical research writings, social media posts, community presentations,
[13:25]
history nights and co-authorship of history of America, Brisbane, California, Dolores has
[13:33]
educated and inspired residents while ensuring that Brisbane's rich heritage is preserved
[13:39]
for future generations. And whereas Dolores is widely regarded as Brisbane's historian,
[13:46]
guardian of local history, and a living treasure whose kindness, wisdom, mentorship, and storytelling
[13:53]
have touched countless lives throughout the community.
[13:58]
And whereas Dolores embodies the spirit of volunteerism through her unwavering dedication
[14:04]
to community service, historical preservation, and the sharing of knowledge, leaving a lasting
[14:11]
legacy that will benefit Brisbane residents for generations to come.
[14:16]
And now therefore be it resolved that after a lifetime of service to the city of Brisbane,
[14:22]
We take this opportunity to express our deepest gratitude and appreciation to the
[14:28]
Laura's Gomez for her extraordinary commitment to preserving our community's history and
[14:34]
enriching the lives of others through her generosity, wisdom, and dedication.
[14:40]
Congratulations to Laura's Gomez on being named the 2026 Volunteer of the Year.
[14:49]
This deserves a big round of applause.
[15:12]
The laws, would you consider coming up to the microphones so people at home can hear what you have to say?
[15:22]
I'm sorry to drag you up here, but we like to hear what you have to say. And I don't want to hear a mention.
[15:29]
I loved every minute that I worked at the library. I enjoyed it so much. And of course I had a wonderful staff, Michelle's here tonight.
[15:39]
I was glad to see her here, yeah, so anyway, you know what I wanted to mention, my husband,
[15:49]
Johnny, a lot of people didn't know him, but a lot of people did, after he got out of the Navy
[15:55]
in WWE 2, then we got married, and then they started building all these houses down in the lower part
[16:09]
of the peninsula. So I says, oh, let's, let's quickly have me look at the house so we can maybe
[16:16]
buy a house. He says, no, he says, I'm not leaving Brisbane. I'm staying right here and I'm going
[16:23]
out feet first and he did.
[16:28]
So thank you, everybody. I appreciate it. Thank you, Dolores. Would you,
[16:34]
would you, would you honor us with photograph? We're going to drag you back up here. We have a
[16:40]
Here we're going to present to you.
[16:42]
Sure.
[16:43]
Oh.
[16:45]
Okay.
[16:54]
Give me a hug.
[16:57]
We're going to be back here.
[16:58]
We want you to be in front.
[17:01]
If we could turn you around.
[17:03]
Turn around.
[17:04]
Turn around.
[17:05]
There she needs.
[17:07]
There you go.
[17:07]
To hang.
[17:10]
There we go.
[17:13]
There we
[17:21]
go.
[17:21]
Thank you.
[17:22]
One.
[17:28]
Okay.
[17:50]
You want to help her back to the chair if you put it on the panel?
[17:54]
She can keep that up.
[18:01]
to Laura's. Thank you. You're really an inspiration to all of us. We should all be so lucky
[18:08]
to have your wisdom and your age all at the same time.
[18:14]
And next we have a proclamation. We have
[18:16]
another honoree. It's the proclamation of the City Council, the City Brisbane, recognizing
[18:23]
Oveny, Ru, Ru-Hun, in my, I don't know if I'm saying I'm terrible on names, Ru-Hun.
[18:32]
Rajun, okay. They give me a phonetical spelling and it's not even right.
[18:38]
Okay, as the youth volunteer the year for 2026. Whereas Oveny has demonstrated exceptional leadership, service,
[18:48]
and dedication to the Brisbane community through years of volunteerism and civic engagement.
[18:54]
And whereas, as a six-year member of Brisbane's Youth Advisory Committee,
[18:58]
and a student trustee for the Jefferson Union High School District,
[19:02]
off me has served as a strong voice for youth and has worked to improve opportunities for students
[19:07]
and residents alike. Whereas, off me has generously given her time to support Brisbane traditions
[19:14]
and community events, including day in the park, Fest Full of Lights, the mothers of Brisbane
[19:20]
Diwali Celebration, the garden show team nights and school events that foster community
[19:26]
connection, and whereas she has shown a special commitment to bridging generations by assisting
[19:33]
seniors with technology, participating in age-friendly initiatives, supporting neighbors and
[19:40]
helping create meaningful connections between youth and older adults and whereas
[19:45]
Obney has further strengthened the community through tutoring local youth, promoting mental
[19:52]
health awareness, participating in environmental stewardship projects, and serving as a positive
[19:58]
role model for her peers. And whereas Obney exemplifies the spirit of volunteerism through
[20:06]
her compassion, reliability, leadership, and commitment to serving others, and now therefore
[20:13]
be it resolved that the City Council of the City of Brisbane proudly recognizes
[20:19]
Omni for her outstanding service to the community and congratulates her on being named
[20:25]
the 2026 youth volunteer of the year, this fifth day of November 2026.
[20:33]
Would
[20:45]
you like to say a couple words?
[20:53]
Yeah, so I moved to Brisbane when I was in kindergarten,
[20:57]
which means that I went through six years of BES and three years of living.
[21:01]
And now I'm on my fourth year in high school at Oceana.
[21:04]
And honestly, Brisbane is probably the best place I could ever think to grow up.
[21:10]
The community that we have in Brisbane just surrounds me every year.
[21:13]
Even now when I don't go to school here, I'm still so interconnected
[21:16]
and that's something that I really love.
[21:18]
I love going out and just seeing familiar faces,
[21:21]
and that's one of my favorite parts about volunteering.
[21:24]
I have so much more that I would love to do,
[21:26]
and I have so much more time to do it,
[21:28]
so I can't wait for what's ahead. Thank you.
[21:35]
We have a proclamation for you,
[21:37]
and I'm just going to say that if you wish you had more time,
[21:41]
the rest of you never saw the number of activities she's involved in.
[21:46]
I had four pages of activities
[21:49]
that she's involved in. I don't think there's enough hours in the day, but if you want to
[21:54]
stretch it out with some more, we will all absolutely honor you because you really
[22:00]
give so much of yourself. And I think we won the lottery rather than you're being happy
[22:05]
you're in Brisbane. We're happy you're here. We're lucky. We've benefit from you.
[22:10]
Thank you so much.
[22:40]
All right. We move on to the San Francisco Peninsula, San Mateo County, Silicon Valley Convention and Visitors Bureau presentation.
[22:52]
And I'm going to again get trapped on pronouncing names. John, would you kindly step to the podium? Tell me how to pronounce your last name.
[23:01]
Okay. I would not have thought that. Okay. Thank you very much. You are the President and CEO at the San Francisco Peninsula. We welcome you and look forward to your message.
[23:13]
Well, thank you Mayor Mackin. Members of City Council City Manager Dennis and City staff.
[23:21]
It is a pleasure for us to come before you this evening and give you a quick update.
[23:26]
It's been about two years since we last paid a visit here when we formed our district.
[23:32]
And joining me tonight is Laura Irbina, who is the Director of Sales at the Double Tree Brisbane.
[23:39]
Carol Self from our staff, who is a North County resident,
[23:43]
Nova Maldonato, who is our Chief Advocacy Officer, and a gentleman who is quite well known here, I see tonight, Chris Callow, General Manager of the Double Tree Brisbane.
[23:55]
And who brought his son Maxwell for a civics course 101. This is hands-on learning.
[24:03]
And it is our pleasure tonight to share with you our strategic plan that our Board of Directors
[24:13]
recently ratified and we've been making the rounds to all of the city councils and it's
[24:19]
a pleasure for us to be here in Brisbane tonight. Next slide, please.
[24:26]
So we just want to talk
[24:27]
a little bit about our work and the partnership we have with seven mile house when we talk
[24:35]
about Brisbane gets a lot of impressions. Recently seven mile house through some joint
[24:42]
effort of ours was featured on NBC Bay area. That link got over 2 million hits and it's
[24:57]
On the next slide, please, the fun continues as we amplify that message in Instagram and through
[25:07]
our social media channels.
[25:09]
There is a link to the entire interview we won't play that tonight, but just an example
[25:15]
of how we help what the appetite for visitors to come stay in our hotels using the restaurants
[25:24]
and retail and what our cities have to offer throughout.
[25:30]
We can advance this slide, please.
[25:36]
Just a quick refresher our organization formed in 1971 when our first honor eight tonight
[25:43]
was getting things going with the library, putting things in historical context formed
[25:49]
by San Mateo County hotel years.
[25:51]
We also operate the Office of Film Commission, manage the county's farm-to-table program as fresh as it gets.
[26:01]
And in 2022, we, for marketing purposes, rebranded, referring to the destination as the San Francisco Peninsula.
[26:11]
We came before you to launch our tours in marketing district and here tonight to talk about our strategic plan.
[26:17]
next slide please.
[26:22]
A recent accomplishment was to stand up in advisory board and the names you'll
[26:27]
see on this list are quite prominent throughout our community from the pillars of education,
[26:34]
business, government, hospitality, labor, environment, attractions, parks and wreck venues and
[26:42]
community at large and we're very proud that Chris has taken the time to serve on our advisory
[26:49]
Council representing the city of Brisbane and his hotel, the double tree.
[26:56]
Next slide, please.
[26:58]
Our Board of Directors,
[27:02]
my bosses, if you will, a conglomeration of hotel owners,
[27:08]
general managers, and some key attractions related businesses such as San Francisco International
[27:16]
airport, the Historical Association, a couple of restaurant tours, the rental car industry,
[27:27]
and those who may not be hoteliers but are vested in the tourism economy in our beautiful
[27:36]
San Mateo County.
[27:38]
So now the strategic plan falls on three pillars.
[27:42]
Next slide, please.
[27:44]
The first is to support asset destination development.
[27:50]
And there's three points here.
[27:54]
Advocate for significant upgrades to the San Mateo County Events Center.
[27:59]
There is a conversation underway with the county,
[28:02]
and we have participated in the dialogue with our consultants on how that asset could be improved
[28:09]
to drive more hotel stay room nights. Part in parcel with that, it could be linked to the
[28:17]
event center or separate, but there is a big appetite for tournament grade sports facilities.
[28:28]
And we feel that that could be developed somewhere in our county to further drive room
[28:35]
nights.
[28:36]
The team sports, a lot of it is youth sports, tends to meet on weekends and that's when
[28:42]
the corporate traveler isn't here, so that would be a nice shoulder market to fill our
[28:51]
hotels.
[28:51]
And to support all of our cities, we have now started down the path of developing a tourism
[28:59]
master plan.
[29:00]
So as each of our cities, contemplate investments and infrastructure,
[29:08]
we don't want to end
[29:09]
up with 18 swimming pools and no soccer fields in exaggeration, but that's the point.
[29:14]
On the next slide, please, the second pillar is to continue to build organizational excellence.
[29:24]
Increase the awareness and appreciation and support of the Peninsula's visitor economy.
[29:31]
Engage the advisory board to serve as community ambassadors and continue to build organization, culture and impact.
[29:43]
I got ahead of one slide in my apologies.
[29:50]
Let me go back one.
[29:53]
You think after 14 times I'd have this right.
[29:57]
I'm sorry, we can advance the slide.
[30:01]
Analyze the opportunity to develop an annual destination event that would ultimately be synonymous with the San Francisco Peninsula brand.
[30:11]
This year we had sponsored, most recently, the top of the Hill Festival and neighboring
[30:20]
daily city, investing in our communities.
[30:24]
We stood up the whiskey of the world festival that was in Half Moon Bay, and the fire
[30:32]
food festival that was at the coyote point park, it's our endeavor to create a
[30:43]
namesake festival that would be synonymous with the county i.e. our
[30:49]
bottle rock and it takes years maybe a decade to develop this but we took the
[30:57]
up in 2026. We are coming back in January with a county-wide restaurant week, a 10-day program
[31:06]
of dying around the county, which will also include Brisbane restaurants, and you can communicate
[31:14]
with people through food, and we feel that touching their palate, bringing them to a food festival,
[31:21]
having entertainment has potential to generate room nights. Advocate completion of the
[31:29]
500-mile Bay Trail. We have this tremendous asset along the Bay Front with just a few miles
[31:38]
missing here and there and some improvements that some communities could make. So we feel that's a
[31:47]
real distinction of something we have to offer that not every destination can offer.
[31:54]
And work with communities throughout the peninsula to encourage nightlife and music.
[32:01]
And we have reworked our website, made it very AI-friendly chatbot-friendly when folks
[32:09]
to search now, they rarely go to your site,
[32:13]
but your site is referenced in the AI's answer to your question.
[32:19]
So we've become the collection point for events happening
[32:24]
throughout the county, and we feel that all of that
[32:28]
could generate an extra room night, we'll go to the show
[32:32]
and state of the night, for example.
[32:35]
And then the next slide please, the last slide I already shared with you, but it's to continue to amplify our message and talk to the community and participate in events like the progress some in our end visit our city councils and tell the world what we're doing.
[32:57]
Next slide, please.
[33:04]
The flavors of the peninsula, as I mentioned, coming back January 21 through 31, the restaurants
[33:11]
in the county told us that's when they need business after the holiday low folks tend to
[33:18]
stay home.
[33:19]
We're going to try to get them out and then bringing back heritage, fire, whiskeys of the
[33:25]
world and some of our other community sponsored events.
[33:31]
Next slide, please.
[33:32]
For 2027, we'll also be launching a series of short movies, 10-minute episodes, profiling,
[33:44]
peninsula people.
[33:46]
And one is a restaurant tour.
[33:51]
One is a farmer, grows with sobby in half moon bay, and touching north, south,
[34:01]
coastside, bayside, Vanessa from seven mile houses featured in one of the episodes.
[34:07]
and that will premiere in a sort of movie Academy Awards kind of event.
[34:16]
It's done around the Academy Awards time, it'll be at the Guild Theater in Menlo Park.
[34:22]
And with that we appreciate your time and attention and lovely to visit your city.
[34:29]
I'll be back here tomorrow for the leadership council that's meeting actually in this
[34:37]
room and back next week again to talk about tourism to future leaders.
[34:43]
But we are here if you have any questions and any answers we can provide.
[34:48]
We'd be more in glad to do it.
[34:52]
Sorry, I would first take this opportunity to thank you for putting the peninsula on the
[34:57]
map.
[34:58]
I remember decades ago and that was not the case and that's a credit to both your staff,
[35:03]
the businesses who have that interest.
[35:05]
And you've really done that, and in addition, I mean, the publication that you put together
[35:11]
is something I actually look forward to looking at because it's so nicely done.
[35:17]
It can't help, but have someone intrigued about all the flavor of every single different
[35:23]
city in the peninsula.
[35:26]
And since you're involved in the movie aspect of the peninsula, I would just make my own
[35:31]
personal suggestion that some day you compile a list of all the famous films for decades
[35:37]
that have utilized peninsula locations and that would be an interesting map to produce
[35:44]
or feature in your magazine for people who are affectionados of some of those films to go visit
[35:51]
those actual sites because we have some interesting ones and television shows as well.
[35:56]
I know residents here can tell you about the TV shows where they came through Brisbane.
[36:02]
So, thank you for that.
[36:03]
But I'd like to open up for comments from our council colleagues here, so Mayor Protem Davis.
[36:10]
Well, John, I just want to congratulate you on your many years of service and I know that
[36:17]
you'll be retiring shortly.
[36:20]
And so, just really wanted to take a moment to thank you for all the work that you've
[36:24]
over the years. And also, I don't know if you already stacked with people to
[36:32]
feature, but there's some really interesting businesses in Crocker Park that are
[36:38]
intimately connected with restaurants across the Bay Area and across the
[36:47]
world, even AC Calderoni, they make so many white label drinks for our places that you
[36:56]
wouldn't, like they make stuff for Trader Joe's and they make stuff for Alameda sort of
[37:03]
company. They make just millions of gallons of product for restaurants all across the
[37:12]
area. And so they would be an incredible company to future. And so is literary. I don't
[37:18]
know if you're familiar with the literary, but they import Italian products, and also
[37:25]
is a great one-to-feature.
[37:30]
It's just like a business that you could showcase that have their fingers and so many other businesses that are kind of like the behind the scenes people.
[37:41]
So just a thought if you're looking for maybe to tell a story about a business that may not be as obvious, they're kind of like those hidden gems that have this big influence.
[37:51]
So anyway, thank you for all that you've done.
[37:55]
And I know that you guys were really involved
[37:57]
and stuff with the World Cup.
[38:00]
And so we thank you for all of your efforts
[38:02]
and wishing you all the best in your next chapter.
[38:06]
Well, thank you so much.
[38:07]
And thank you for the acknowledgement
[38:08]
and the great suggestions we'll definitely follow up.
[38:12]
Bye, Ray.
[38:13]
Is sponsoring code the paper?
[38:14]
Wait, where's the code?
[38:16]
Oh, yes, yes.
[38:18]
They're very generous, company.
[38:21]
Thank you so much for coming by today, really appreciate the presentation and the hard work Chris good to see you.
[38:29]
Thanks for going.
[38:30]
I just want to thank you guys for all the work that you've done.
[38:34]
I think having the foresight of looking at doing a master plan around tourism is a really really solid approach for long-term economic vitality.
[38:45]
And to the mayor's point, Steve McQueen was once in for Spain here doing the bullet chase.
[38:51]
So yes, that happened here.
[38:53]
So thanks again, guys.
[38:54]
Good to see you all.
[38:56]
Councilmember Lance.
[38:59]
John, how you doing?
[39:00]
Thank you so much for the presentation.
[39:04]
And just for your years of dedication to the county and wanting to connect all of us.
[39:10]
Sometimes you get wrapped up in your own little bubble, especially right now for us with the
[39:16]
bail-ins. But when you see your presentation, you realize that no, we are very much connected.
[39:22]
And when we connect as a county, we are much all better off for that. It also, this is a really
[39:30]
good reminder that there are resources out there for us to tap into. And we just have to make
[39:38]
initiative to do it. And so I appreciate you coming and, you know, knocking on our door
[39:45]
because we really should open it up wider than what we have had in the past and see where
[39:51]
we can expand the partnerships. So, thank you so much and all the best for your time.
[39:59]
Council Member O'Connell.
[40:04]
Thank you for coming and the great presentation and bringing your
[40:07]
board along with you. So thank you so much.
[40:13]
Thank you. And and best wishes. Don't ever be a stranger.
[40:17]
I definitely will be in the area and you'll see me around promise and Mayor Mackin. We do have a map
[40:26]
we'll leave behind literally a map of the peninsula that is framed. So we'll have that for you to decide
[40:35]
wherever you want it. Thank you very much appreciate that and thank you all for joining us tonight as well
[40:41]
and taking the time to come to our meeting. I appreciate that. Thank you. Thank you for your
[40:45]
collective leadership. Thank you.
[40:50]
All right. We'll feel pressured to stay. Yep.
[40:55]
Move on to item D Countywide Transportation Plan update from the San Mateo County Transportation Authority.
[41:02]
and I see a familiar face in Jeff Laycap from C.C.C.C.C.C, which is City County Association,
[41:09]
a government of San Mateo County for anyone who doesn't know the acronym.
[41:14]
Thank you for joining us, Jeff.
[41:15]
Thank you, Mayor, and good evening. Council members staff and members of the public.
[41:21]
I don't know how I could follow two great presentations, but I'll give it my best shot.
[41:24]
I'm Jeff McCamp from C-Cag.
[41:26]
I'm here tonight to give an update on the San Mateo
[41:29]
Countywide Transportation Plan.
[41:31]
This is a joint effort between C-Cag
[41:33]
and the San Mateo County Transportation Authority.
[41:36]
And for those who are unfamiliar,
[41:38]
C-Cag serves as the County Transportation Agency
[41:40]
for the County serving, I have putting together
[41:43]
a lot of the County White policies for transportation,
[41:46]
while our partners at the TA primarily
[41:48]
manage the measure A and W sales tax funds.
[41:51]
Next slide.
[41:55]
So tonight I'll cover the CTP process and update.
[41:58]
We'll look at the vision goals and framework, followed by the drag project list,
[42:03]
the drag programs and initiatives for the CTP and next steps. Next slide.
[42:10]
Next slide.
[42:13]
And so what is the purpose of the CTP?
[42:14]
The CTP creates a vision for the future of transportation,
[42:18]
San Mateo County.
[42:19]
Think of it as our highest level of transportation policy framework for the county.
[42:23]
It sets C-Cag and the TA's priorities and guides decision making and finally it informs planning, funding and delivering of local and regional transportation improvements.
[42:34]
Next slide.
[42:36]
So we kicked off this effort last winter.
[42:39]
We went to every city's transportation committee or to a council when there was no committee.
[42:45]
We went to your complete street safety committee last year.
[42:49]
And through those outreach efforts, we asked what the needs are today and what is missing
[42:54]
in the world of transportation.
[42:57]
Since then, we've drafted the vision goals and project lists with local jurisdictions.
[43:02]
And now we're back on the road to every city council for feedback on the draft vision
[43:06]
and goals and priority projects.
[43:08]
And the draft plan is scheduled to be released early 2027 with final adoption in spring of 2027.
[43:15]
Next slide.
[43:19]
And so through the various presentations and kind of our literature review of previous County
[43:27]
White efforts and community-based organization interviews, we really sought input through
[43:32]
the first round of outreach to really validate the existing travel trends observed in the
[43:37]
data on the transportation needs and challenges on community transportation priorities for the
[43:44]
next decade and on our graph CTP goals.
[43:47]
Next slide.
[43:52]
And this slide here really reflects what we've heard from community members.
[43:57]
The biggest things we heard were more safety and comfortable improvements, more frequent
[44:02]
transit, more highway one in El Caminoviola improvements, really looking to close network gaps,
[44:10]
really meaning the last pieces that would reduce barriers to access.
[44:14]
And also, you know, there was also, you know, a lot of love for the electrification of
[44:22]
Caltering.
[44:23]
And really, other things included e-bikes and more support for school trips and non-none work trips,
[44:30]
as well.
[44:32]
Next slide.
[44:35]
And so tonight we're looking for your feedback on the visioning goals.
[44:39]
If those resonate with you.
[44:41]
If the list of local projects for Brisbane is the right mix of the local projects, and if
[44:46]
the also looking for the mix of county-wide programs, addresses your key transportation
[44:52]
concerns, and finally anything that's missing that you're not seeing this update that
[44:56]
the CTP should address.
[44:58]
Next slide.
[45:03]
Next slide.
[45:06]
And so here's a draft vision statement. The San Mateo CTP in vision and county where residents, workers and visitors can travel safely, reliably, and with convenient choices across all modes.
[45:18]
People easily connect to daily needs via streets, trails, transit service, and highways that are resilient and endure for generations.
[45:28]
Next slide.
[45:31]
And so, as part of this update, we came down to four goals, we really wanted these goals to be
[45:37]
be able to be easily measured and more achievable over the life of this plan.
[45:43]
And so, we're looking to, as part of the CTP, to reduce how much people need to drive each day,
[45:49]
enhance resilience and comfort of our streets, trails and transit stops, move people faster and more reliably,
[45:56]
and make streets safer and prevent serious crashes.
[45:59]
It's like,
[46:05]
and so as part of this update, we wanted, the project team wanted to come up with a unified equity definition for the county.
[46:16]
Because there's been so many different agencies have different equity definitions.
[46:19]
We really wanted to come up with a unified definition.
[46:22]
And so really, this, this, this equity definition we've developed as part of the CTP is simplified.
[46:27]
it's based on four different variables income, race, vehicle ownership, and rental cost burden.
[46:34]
And with this new update, 49% of the households are now covered within the county, and that's
[46:39]
up to 21% from the previous definition. And really we'll be looking to use this layer or this data set
[46:46]
as part of our funding methodologies and our equity based funding. Next slide.
[46:55]
Next slide.
[46:56]
And so the CTP normally is used to identify regionally significant projects, and by that,
[47:03]
if it meets any of these following criteria, if it expands the real big capacity,
[47:10]
if it's expanding real network or if the project is over $250 million.
[47:16]
And so next slide. And so because of that kind of criteria, a lot of the other smaller projects
[47:24]
from our jurisdictions are not captured that way, but what we do have is the programmatic funding
[47:30]
categories, which are various buckets that cover smaller transportation efforts that are
[47:36]
not regionally significant. And so most projects that local jurisdictions deliver fall into
[47:40]
these categories, and so some examples include TDM, multi-modal, and petted bike.
[47:46]
Next slide.
[47:50]
And so the reason why we're generating this project list is if we want to get a
[47:53]
understanding of the local priorities. And so because that, regionally significant list is very short,
[47:59]
we ask every city for its top five local transportation priorities. And by having these lists
[48:05]
from all of our jurisdictions, it'll help seek ag in the TA, find resources to help move those projects
[48:10]
forward and deliver them. And also, as another reason why we're generating this list is because
[48:18]
As part of the regional transportation long-range plan developed by the Metropolitan Transportation Commission,
[48:25]
we'll be able to have this list ready when they need it sometime next year.
[48:29]
Next slide.
[48:33]
So, in working with your staff, we have the top five priority projects,
[48:41]
and this is not ranked, this isn't in no particular order.
[48:44]
But starting off with the Bayshore Boulevard Mobility and bus staff improvements,
[48:47]
The Sierra Point Parkway Transportation Fruits, the Geneva Avenue Bacial Boulevard Intersection
[48:54]
to U.S. 101 Candlestick Point Interchange, Valley Drive, Crocker Park, Multimortal
[48:59]
and Trail Connectivity Improvements, Visitation Avenue Downtown Revitalization and Multimortal
[49:05]
Improvements.
[49:07]
And a additional region-legestificant project is the U.S. 101 Sierra Point Parkway
[49:13]
change reconstruction of the LaGuinway extension.
[49:18]
Next slide.
[49:20]
And so aside from the capital projects, we also have some initiatives as part of the
[49:25]
CTP. The top row is kind of our established initiatives such as our County of
[49:30]
White Safety Forces School Program, our Transportation Demand Management, and on the
[49:34]
bottom row is kind of the emerging initiatives that we heard out of the first
[49:39]
on of outreach.
[49:41]
So looking at a autonomous vehicle integration,
[49:45]
e-bikes, and bike share, green streets,
[49:47]
and employment resilience, and mobility for older adults.
[49:52]
Next slide,
[49:55]
and I'll go forward one side.
[49:59]
Next slide.
[50:01]
So we have a website kind of with all the different project lists
[50:05]
from all jurisdictions.
[50:06]
We'll be continuing our focus groups
[50:08]
and CBO engagement throughout the end of the year.
[50:11]
We'll continue touring the road show
[50:13]
to our city councils, to the city councils, also to the end of the year, and we're expecting
[50:19]
the public draft for the CTP early 2027. I will go back. If we could go back one slide to have the
[50:26]
list of questions, these are the feedback that team is looking for on these four areas, and so
[50:33]
that concludes my presentation. I'm available for any questions and however, Mayor, you want to take
[50:39]
the feedback on this?
[50:41]
Okay, I think if you could hold in place,
[50:44]
their Jeff and will go through everybody
[50:46]
on the council, I get all kinds of input to you all the time.
[50:50]
So I'm gonna give them the floor.
[50:53]
And thank you very much for the comprehensive presentation
[50:56]
and appreciate that.
[50:58]
All right, let's start with council member O'Connell.
[51:08]
I really appreciate the presentation that you gave to us tonight.
[51:14]
I don't think that I'm really prepared to make comments on what your proposal is and what the
[51:24]
other county, what other cities are looking at, but I'm sure that our staff did a really good
[51:28]
job of talking to you about what those priorities were. Yeah, but so thank you. Okay.
[51:36]
Council Member Cran. Thank you so much for coming tonight. Thank you for the presentation.
[51:41]
I think you hit the mark with the vision and the goals of safety, faster, and resilient.
[51:50]
Those really resonate with me, so job well done.
[51:52]
Thank you.
[51:54]
Councilmember Lance?
[51:56]
Yeah, thank you, Madam Mayor.
[51:58]
Jeff, thank you for the presentation.
[52:00]
There was one slide that you had to give a criteria.
[52:05]
If we could go back to that slide, please.
[52:11]
Back one more.
[52:13]
Back yeah, it was the what you had to
[52:17]
Yeah, I'd say a lot of one more maybe.
[52:21]
Forward one.
[52:23]
Anyway, I thought that one of the criteria said it was 250 million.
[52:30]
So, that's the minimum to be listed on the list as a individually listed as a stand alone project listing on the CTP project list.
[52:42]
Okay. Okay. And then I noticed on the list of items for Brisbane, the Geneva Avenue extension was not listed. It talked about the interchange.
[52:52]
But didn't address the bailing at the Geneva Avenue extension,
[53:01]
so was it just not submitted or not downstairs?
[53:07]
We might want to have our director of public works, Moss, clarify what you put on the list.
[53:13]
Sure.
[53:14]
Angel, if you can go back to the project list, select this.
[53:22]
there, uh, perfect. So, um, so the way that, um, we phrase number three and we can work on the
[53:29]
wording as, um, and update the straft for the intention of number three was the look at
[53:33]
Geneva, Geneva having extension, um, as part of that. So it's really looking at the entirety of
[53:39]
Geneva Avenue extension all the way to the Kendall Siggie interchange. That was the, um, attempt
[53:44]
there so we can, wordsmith that a little bit better, make it a little bit more clear. Okay, great. Thank
[53:48]
for the clarification, Maws.
[53:52]
You know, I'm curious, something like the Geneva Accention.
[53:57]
And you're looking at this, US 101 interchange.
[54:02]
We're right there on the border.
[54:05]
So are there any limitations for partnering
[54:09]
with other jurisdictions outside of San Mateo County?
[54:14]
Certainly, I think, like you said, the proximity to the border with San Francisco, there's
[54:20]
opportunities to collaborate on kind of, you know, what there could be some opportunities
[54:25]
there.
[54:26]
Okay, so that wouldn't be an obstacle to potentially be opportunity.
[54:34]
Okay.
[54:35]
All right.
[54:35]
Thank you very much.
[54:37]
Mayor Pro Tom Davis.
[54:38]
I think served giving some more insight on the Geneva Avenue extension.
[54:43]
Obviously we're very interested in seeing that to fruition for a variety of reasons.
[54:48]
But yeah, I mean I think these priorities are great and glad that you've worked with staff to kind of highlight some projects that are important here.
[54:56]
I would say that something that we see coming up a lot over the last couple of years of safety.
[55:01]
So I would say that that's something that's just really on a lot of people's minds.
[55:07]
pedestrian safety and safety for those who bike, many people are biking and then, you know,
[55:15]
getting on public transit. So that's something that we hear a lot. So I'm glad that safety is
[55:21]
part of your set of priorities.
[55:26]
And I wasn't going to ask a question, but I'm going to have to
[55:37]
second entry and egress point for Sierra Point
[55:45]
because I saw Lagoonway 101 interchange
[55:49]
and I wasn't really clear on what that meant because I don't think of the exit as an
[55:54]
interchange and maybe that was incorporating the on-ramp northward from Sierra Point.
[56:00]
But we've never had that egress other than utilizing Sierra Point Parkway.
[56:06]
Our intent was to incorporate that and I think we can work on this list and make it a little bit more clear
[56:12]
I'll double all work with Jeff and the team to make sure that's incorporated. Okay, thank you very much, of course
[56:18]
I think
[56:19]
You've you've dazzled us with this and I really do appreciate you have no idea how much hard work these people do behind the scenes
[56:25]
And it was an effort to come out here tonight and present so I really appreciate that and this man's going to every council
[56:31]
So he's got Jack jet lag already and thank you so much
[56:35]
We're honoring us tonight.
[56:37]
Thank you for having us.
[56:38]
Thank you.
[56:40]
All right.
[56:40]
We move on to oral communications number one.
[56:44]
We welcome speakers providing public comment, but please be advised this is a limited
[56:49]
public forum.
[56:50]
It's therefore important for speakers to stay on topic whether speaking to a particular agenda
[56:55]
item or speaking during general public comment.
[56:58]
On topic matters are those that are within the subject matter jurisdiction of the city.
[57:03]
speakers, whether during oral communications or on agenda items will have two minutes.
[57:09]
Following these rules helps ensure the city council can get to all the items on the agenda,
[57:13]
including hearing public comment on the items.
[57:17]
If a speaker fails to follow these rules, they're disrupting the meeting and will be warned.
[57:21]
If a speaker continues to ignore the rules or is otherwise disruptive, their opportunity
[57:26]
to speak will be ended and they may be precluded from speaking on any other items tonight.
[57:32]
City Clerk is there a member of the public wishing to make public comment on any item that is not on the agenda.
[57:42]
No, Madam Mayor.
[57:44]
And anyone in the audience, I see no hands, no slips.
[57:49]
Okay, then we are moving on to the consent calendar.
[57:55]
Tonight the consent calendar consists of items E through N.
[58:00]
And we are removing, I am told, consent calendar item F as in Frank.
[58:09]
And Madam Mayor, because I am a member of the Lions Club, and I know this is an approved
[58:15]
coup sponsor ship.
[58:16]
I wouldn't want anyone to think that I was voting in my interest, so if we can just pull
[58:23]
that one to the side, I'll step outside and then come on back after Council approves item
[58:29]
Okay, so City Attorney, would you rather us do that one first?
[58:35]
It does a matter you could just whatever works for the mayor and for council member once you do not need to step outside and so on consent you can just not vote on the item.
[58:44]
Okay.
[58:45]
Are we removing F because we need to discuss it or removing F to come back the later time?
[58:50]
It's coming back at a later time.
[58:53]
All right, so then I'll make a motion to approve item.
[58:59]
E-G-H-I-J-L-M-M-N.
[59:05]
Second.
[59:09]
Did we really get everything in there?
[59:11]
You kind of threw me a curve because I had it written down.
[59:14]
E-G-J-L-M-N.
[59:21]
Okay.
[59:23]
And I have a motion and a second. All in favor.
[59:26]
Hi.
[59:26]
Anyone opposed? No.
[59:28]
And then we need approval, a motion for item K.
[59:32]
I'll make a motion to approve item K.
[59:34]
And a second.
[59:35]
Second.
[59:36]
All in favor.
[59:37]
All right.
[59:38]
And we have Councilmember Lens abstaining.
[59:44]
All right.
[59:45]
Motion's carry.
[59:50]
We now go to a public hearing.
[59:52]
This is item O, consider adoption of an interim ordinance
[59:56]
to extend a moratorium on data centers and provide
[59:59]
direct.
[1:00:00]
On updated data center, definition, staff report, please?
[1:00:13]
We're going to start.
[1:00:21]
The Canadian community development director and I, or tag taming,
[1:00:26]
we just realized we didn't realize he was starting the tag.
[1:00:30]
Also, there are two portions for the item. Do we have the advice?
[1:00:36]
Okay. There are two sort of sections of this item tonight for the council.
[1:00:42]
One is, if you'll recall, extending the stop is recommending that you extend the urgency
[1:00:49]
ordinance that you put into place previously, you would extend it tonight, you would take
[1:00:54]
the first extension, which we'll walk through with you.
[1:00:57]
Separate from that, that's the action that you'll take tonight, if you accept our recommendation
[1:01:02]
and that requires a four-fist vote, separate from that, stop it like to talk to you about
[1:01:08]
the definition of data centers that stop as developed
[1:01:11]
and we'd like to get your feedback on that
[1:01:13]
so that we can come back to you in the future
[1:01:16]
with some additional options based on that definition.
[1:01:22]
Next slide, please.
[1:01:25]
So yes, so those are the two actions
[1:01:27]
and we can move to the next slide, please.
[1:01:31]
Just to provide some background,
[1:01:33]
particularly if people haven't been following this,
[1:01:36]
the planning issues subcommittee first had discussions
[1:01:40]
about data centers back in July and August of this year. Then in September there was a
[1:01:46]
Council update with direction from the Council to prepare a moratorium with an urgency ordinance.
[1:01:52]
The urgency ordinance was brought to the City Council October 1st and that would expire on
[1:01:59]
November 15th unless there's an extension which is before you tonight. And then beyond that there's a number
[1:02:08]
steps but tonight should there be an extension then that would bring you to September 20th
[1:02:16]
of 2027 so that's a longer extension than the one that we have right now. Next week.
[1:02:25]
So, yeah, as mentioned the moratorium extension so this current one would be 10 months and 15 days
[1:02:31]
is kind of a funny number but that's how the state law works with you've got the 45 days
[1:02:35]
and you've got 15 days.
[1:02:37]
You can even do another year beyond that, but hopefully we can bring you something that
[1:02:42]
you can act on before that.
[1:02:44]
Some of the things we're working on since October 1st is looking at just how it would fit whether
[1:02:50]
you allow, don't allow, conditionally allow, all of the different options, how would that fit
[1:02:55]
with your code, what do you need to do in any circumstance?
[1:02:59]
So we're looking at those different regulations and we'll come back to you for those policy
[1:03:04]
discussions. Tonight should there be an extension. There is no change to the prohibition.
[1:03:11]
So right now they are prohibited per the moratorium and would be with the extension. Next
[1:03:17]
please. So the current definition, Brisbane, get some kudos for having a definition at all,
[1:03:24]
a lot of cities don't. So I think a lot of cities have been caught by surprise. Data centers
[1:03:30]
really change a lot. But they have been around. So this definition reflects what I think was
[1:03:38]
the state of the art of data centers a decade ago or so things that are quite up to date.
[1:03:45]
This is describing a business, not a land use. It's really kind of talking more about the
[1:03:51]
storage, not about the processing. It doesn't get into the infrastructure which is really
[1:03:56]
becoming an important consideration with the new versions, and then we do want to kind of figure
[1:04:02]
out where do you, how do you differentiate an office server room, which comes with lots of
[1:04:08]
different uses versus a data center. And part of this is to have less ambiguity. So again,
[1:04:15]
whether you allow prohibit conditional what have you. We don't want ambiguity, which could cause
[1:04:21]
problems in the future. Next, please.
[1:04:27]
So, there is state law, so that gives us something to start with, should we want to.
[1:04:32]
And, for example, San Francisco has used this state law.
[1:04:36]
It reads that a facility or a part of a facility that houses computing infrastructure, including graphics and such or processing units,
[1:04:44]
servers, storage devices, networking equipment, and associated power and cooling systems for the primary purpose of processing,
[1:04:51]
storing or distributing electronic data and that covers a lot of things and then there's
[1:04:57]
different statewide tiers depending on type 1 as has the most power usage down to type 2
[1:05:04]
and type 3. Again the purpose of having the definition and particularly having one that's
[1:05:11]
really detailed and precise is for example if you're not going to allow them you want to define
[1:05:17]
what you're not allowing or if you're going to allow something, you need to define that
[1:05:22]
too.
[1:05:23]
So we don't want to presuppose any policy decision from the council, no matter what
[1:05:28]
you do, you're going to want to have a good definition.
[1:05:30]
Next, please.
[1:05:33]
What have other jurisdictions done?
[1:05:36]
So in San Mateo County, Redwood City is the only one that has a definition.
[1:05:41]
So again, Brisbane is out front.
[1:05:44]
State of California as we mentioned does have that basic definition, so that's kind of off the shelf ready to go.
[1:05:51]
San Francisco has used that.
[1:05:53]
Oakland has a little more detail to it.
[1:05:57]
So to San Jose.
[1:05:59]
And then Monterey Park is an example, although that's Southern California.
[1:06:04]
It's not in our region here.
[1:06:05]
That is an example of a jurisdiction that has prohibited them outright,
[1:06:09]
But has separately defined the accessory server rooms so that they are careful to kind of restrict what they don't want, but also recognize that there are certain versions of data servers that go with with other industrial and commercial uses.
[1:06:32]
So what we would recommend, and this is up for discussion, is you start with that state definition.
[1:06:38]
That's something that's been thought out and offers you a kind of base.
[1:06:44]
But then you can look at, we do want to think about existing facilities that might be converted
[1:06:51]
and make sure you're kind of not having something happen that you're not anticipating by an existing building
[1:06:58]
becoming something that you didn't think it was going to become, and then we would recommend
[1:07:05]
clarification on those accessory server rooms so that you're not necessarily creating
[1:07:12]
restrictions for the types of businesses that do need some sort of smaller scale data
[1:07:18]
processing, but not on the scale of a full-fledged data center.
[1:07:24]
and then also you know again where we're needing to be very thorough for all purposes we would
[1:07:30]
We want to also have a companion definition of what a facility is. So, if we're talking about facilities, it may seem all obvious, but the ambiguity is where you could get into trouble in the future. Next, please.
[1:07:47]
So, some of the questions, again, we're not asking on the policy discussion, whether to allow them or not, that will come soon.
[1:07:56]
What we are looking for is just some feedback on what kinds of things we would want to include
[1:08:01]
in a definition.
[1:08:02]
Should we be getting into more detail about supporting infrastructure, so we just be relying
[1:08:08]
on the state wording, which talks about things such as associated power and cooling systems.
[1:08:14]
There's a lot of different options and it could be pick and choose.
[1:08:18]
You can look at some of the definitions that we've provided from the other jurisdictions
[1:08:21]
and maybe certain elements of those stick out as things that you like, and then any other
[1:08:29]
comments you would have just, you know, we're a little ahead in terms of the extension of
[1:08:34]
the moratorium is one action, but we'd like to be kind of a step ahead and be thinking what
[1:08:39]
we wanted to next. Next, please.
[1:08:43]
So what were those next steps B tonight is focused primarily
[1:08:47]
on extending the moratorium and then giving us some definition on the direction of the definition
[1:08:53]
that we can come back to at a future date. We will come back at a future date for that policy
[1:08:59]
direction and that's where the Council will provide direction regarding whether to prohibit,
[1:09:05]
whether to allow as a conditional use, allow subject to development and performance standards,
[1:09:10]
what have you. Then as this is an ordinance, whatever is decided, we'll go to planning commission
[1:09:16]
first so that we'll look at the first the first look at the ordinance we do want the policy
[1:09:24]
direction from council before going planning commission so what the planning commission
[1:09:28]
sees will reflect direction from the council on what they want to see in the ordinance
[1:09:33]
planning commission away the recommendation that then comes back to the city council next
[1:09:39]
please. So again, to ready to reiterate, sorry, the city attorneys direction first is to consider
[1:09:51]
the adoption of the interim urgency ordinance extending the moratorium on new data centers
[1:09:56]
for 10 months and 15 days and then subsequently provide us more informal direction on an updated
[1:10:05]
definition of data center that we can start mulling over and coming back to you at a future
[1:10:11]
date and to the blank mission.
[1:10:14]
With that, if there's any questions.
[1:10:16]
Before we go into questions, I just wanted to call attention to what we're doing tonight
[1:10:23]
in that there may be some people either at home watching this or later on who will watch
[1:10:28]
it in that they may not understand what's going on with the moratorium.
[1:10:33]
There are two zones currently in Brisbane, M1 manufacturing district, and T.C. 2, Southeast
[1:10:43]
Bacial Trade Commercial District that use a generic data center, no-manclature as being
[1:10:53]
allowed.
[1:10:54]
And with the moratorium, this moratorium going in place, I'm going to read the exact words.
[1:11:00]
The Citing Construction Conversion and or Operation of any new data center is prohibited in every zoning district of the city, including the two where it's getting allowed.
[1:11:13]
The moratorium would prevent that. The filing acceptance, processing or approval of any permit application for any land use entitlement to site, construct, convert and or operate any data center in the city is also prohibited.
[1:11:29]
So, it is not a ban. It's a moratorium, but it effectively ceases any incarnation or thought of a data center at this time for 10 months and 15 days by virtue of approval of this extension.
[1:11:45]
That being said, let's take some counsel questions, starting with Mayor Protem Davis, and thank you for the presentation.
[1:11:52]
So, if I'm understanding one is direction, one thing you're asking for us is direction.
[1:11:58]
The other thing is for a motion, does that motion need to have this
[1:12:02]
September 20th, 2027 date in it or you just say we're extending it?
[1:12:07]
How do you want that framed?
[1:12:08]
Sure, the motion could just be to extend.
[1:12:13]
Let me actually get to you.
[1:12:15]
It would be to adopt an interim urgency ordinance extending the
[1:12:23]
Thanks.
[1:12:27]
Did you have other questions?
[1:12:30]
Councilmember O'Connell?
[1:12:34]
I do have other questions, but why don't we get that part out of play and extend the
[1:12:43]
moratorium?
[1:12:45]
I would make a motion to extend the moratorium, and then we can go back to the definition.
[1:12:49]
So we know we're talking about two separate things.
[1:12:52]
It's a public hearing, so we have to go through a public hearing, so at this point we're
[1:12:56]
Just in council question, so to staff, so to staff on the size and you're looking for
[1:13:08]
definition of for later what we'd come back with and one of the guidelines is you
[1:13:21]
megawatts, whether it's over 25 megawatts for between two and 25 or under two.
[1:13:32]
What,
[1:13:35]
when you're saying the size of the facility, is that what the power consumption
[1:13:43]
is, the computing power, how would you describe that to me or the public?
[1:13:53]
Yes, so, I mean, size is really two aspects to this, but when we're talking about type 1, type 2, type 3,
[1:14:01]
size tier is that is the power consumption.
[1:14:06]
And my, my period, over, you know, that I don't know.
[1:14:12]
Continuous period that it's drawing 25 megawatts? I think at one.
[1:14:24]
I would need to follow up on that.
[1:14:30]
But what it's trying to do with the three tiers is basically
[1:14:35]
classify small medium and large in terms of power consumption. A community may say,
[1:14:41]
we're okay with one that's relatively small drawing, not a lot of power, but we don't want
[1:14:48]
the really big ones. You may have another community say, we don't want any of this at all. So
[1:14:53]
it's kind of more of a performance standard, but we can come back with more of a
[1:15:00]
Information on exactly what the megawatt draws are and is at one period, is at, you know, how does that work?
[1:15:08]
Yeah, I just call me ignorant. I just don't know what that means, size on the ground.
[1:15:16]
Well, let's see other aspect we could look at, if that's in, I think a lot of people are interested. How big are these actually square footage, why?
[1:15:25]
So, although this is talking about size tiers, it's based on power draws, we could also,
[1:15:32]
if this is something the council is interested in looking at, you know, how does that reflect
[1:15:38]
on the ground in terms of, you know, type 1 is 10,000 servers or more, how big is the server,
[1:15:46]
how big, you know, what kind of footprint are we talking about? And we're happy to provide that kind
[1:15:51]
information if that's something that Council would want to know more about.
[1:15:55]
Thank you. If I may Kevin, I did find some information about what the definition is related to
[1:16:01]
the megawatt. It represents the facility's instantaneous maximum power draw, not a cumulative
[1:16:06]
total over 24 hours or a year or any of the period. Thank you. How much it's drawing right then?
[1:16:15]
Great. Thank you. And I would caution the power draw for servers does not include
[1:16:21]
cooling units,
[1:16:24]
which could be quite a bit more.
[1:16:27]
Great, thank you.
[1:16:30]
Council member Kern.
[1:16:34]
Thank you, Madam Mayor.
[1:16:40]
Kevin, don't work on this.
[1:16:42]
Just sharing a thought here.
[1:16:43]
I know we're talking about megawatts and we're might use that as a unit of measurement.
[1:16:47]
In terms of computer hardware, and I'm not a hardware expert right now my partners in
[1:16:51]
home laughing that I'm talking about this like guaranteed us.
[1:16:54]
But it's my understanding that when you've got servers and you want to change up the
[1:16:57]
to increase the power, you just simply open the closet door, change out the hardware, and move
[1:17:02]
forward.
[1:17:03]
So I'm just curious when we start talking about the size and we're on the threshold between
[1:17:07]
the sizes.
[1:17:08]
Seems like that's going to be a sort of a hard thing to measure, and I'm not asking you to
[1:17:13]
work on it.
[1:17:13]
I'm just saying it's where my thinking is going.
[1:17:17]
But in terms of actual questions, I'm pretty happy with the recommended definitions that
[1:17:23]
have come forth tonight.
[1:17:24]
They're pretty comprehensive.
[1:17:25]
the one thing I didn't see in there is about the backups. So right now, data centers use
[1:17:33]
diesel generators a lot of the time, can we potentially require that they use some sort of
[1:17:39]
battery backup system that is not diesel or we're not storing fuel, we're not burning it, that's
[1:17:45]
just sort of thing, just thinking out loud regarding the backup piece, it's just something maybe
[1:17:51]
we can incorporate. So my question is can that be incorporated? That is all.
[1:17:58]
Yeah, so that would be the kind of thing in a definition that's, you know, probably more likely
[1:18:02]
if you were to allow it in some sort of way, then we would want to start providing those types
[1:18:07]
of details in the definition if they're not could be allowed, then you're probably don't need all that.
[1:18:14]
So we can pursue that as needed as things evolve. Great. Thank you so much.
[1:18:21]
Council Member Lance. Thank you, Mayor. Thank you for the presentation, Kevin, and the slide.
[1:18:28]
So that was very helpful.
[1:18:32]
You know, in regards to the process, so the Council will
[1:18:36]
produce extending the moratorium gives some direction to you, but I guess it then it goes to the
[1:18:50]
and in their public hearings, and then provide feedback
[1:18:55]
or recommendation to the council
[1:18:57]
and then the council will have its hearings
[1:18:58]
within that time period from now and until September 20th,
[1:19:05]
or 2027.
[1:19:08]
Sort of, so ultimately, if the council wishes
[1:19:15]
you would revise your zoning code to either,
[1:19:19]
whatever the council wishes,
[1:19:20]
prohibit data centers allow them with the conditional use permit, allow them with the conditional
[1:19:25]
use permit and regulations, whatever you decide to do, those changes with the living
[1:19:30]
your zoning code. And so anytime you make a change your zoning code, as you likely know,
[1:19:35]
it goes to the ordinance, the draft ordinance, goes to the planning commission first for the
[1:19:41]
planning commission to consider it and then make a recommendation to the city council. And so what
[1:19:46]
thing that suggests is, because this is really a policy issue for the council, sometimes
[1:19:54]
if it's just a zoning code amendment that's sort of a basic amendment, we might start
[1:19:58]
with the planning commission, but because this is a bigger policy issue, we're starting
[1:20:02]
with the council, we'd like to get direction from the council as to what you would like to
[1:20:06]
do.
[1:20:07]
We will then draft those changes into your ordinance, into an ordinance, take it to the planning
[1:20:15]
commission to consider a planning commission will make a recommendation, and it will come back to the council for a final decision.
[1:20:22]
And here's to the second part of your question about the timing on, we would certainly start working on it.
[1:20:29]
When we get direction from the council, we will come back to you for further direction before we even start drafting any revisions to your ordinance.
[1:20:39]
And certainly we would aim to be finished by the exploration of this extension and if we were not,
[1:20:46]
we would come back and ask the council if you would like to extend for a second time
[1:20:50]
and that time you can extend for 12 months.
[1:20:52]
Up to 12 months.
[1:20:54]
Up to 12.
[1:20:54]
Okay.
[1:20:55]
Okay.
[1:20:56]
So right now this extension is for nine months.
[1:21:00]
10 months.
[1:21:01]
Thank you.
[1:21:01]
So the initial couple of months.
[1:21:04]
Or is it an additional 12 months?
[1:21:05]
The first extension is for 10 months 15 days, combined with the 45 we've already done, it makes a year.
[1:21:13]
And then the second extension would be for another year.
[1:21:16]
Got it.
[1:21:20]
Yeah, that's it for now.
[1:21:22]
Okay.
[1:21:23]
All right.
[1:21:23]
I have a couple different things.
[1:21:26]
In terms of that big question about megawatts and megawatts are big power.
[1:21:32]
And what you showed, I believe which was San Francisco, those are all big facilities, all I think all three of theirs.
[1:21:42]
I would encourage staff to work with Westside Energy. They're very curious about what we're doing, but I would also talk to them to get an idea of what type of power demands.
[1:22:01]
Utilize their knowledge of what would be required sustained on a 24-hour basis because again,
[1:22:08]
is that 50 megawatts, 25 megawatts, just for the servers or for all the HVAC and everything else to operate it.
[1:22:18]
And in terms of how much power is used,
[1:22:24]
I think this is something that perhaps we should consider.
[1:22:30]
It for permitting it might require an annual verification, what's to stop someone from setting up a bunch of service and saying this is all we're doing and then just expanding and expanding.
[1:22:41]
And the one slide that you showed that said something about the addition of servers to a related business was to stop someone from saying, well, the business is kind of computing and we're just going to keep expanding it.
[1:22:57]
So I think that language we've got to think ahead of how someone may try to get around things
[1:23:04]
and keep expanding without our knowing it. So I don't know if that's possible. I would
[1:23:10]
require an annual energy audit which could come under our sustainability practices and that could
[1:23:18]
be verified by their energy provider, which might be Westlight or they might, if they're big enough,
[1:23:23]
they go direct and by power from power plants.
[1:23:28]
I would also encourage looking at square footage and number
[1:23:34]
of servers that we ask, how many servers are you using?
[1:23:39]
So if we do an annual inspection, we see.
[1:23:43]
Are you adding to this without telling us what are the water
[1:23:47]
requirements?
[1:23:49]
And as for the diesel generators, that's standard state of California
[1:23:53]
that they have to have them.
[1:23:54]
And then they periodically, like once a month, I think, unless that's changed, they have
[1:23:59]
to run those.
[1:24:01]
And after being in the county building in Redwood City, where they ran among top of the building
[1:24:05]
and almost killed us in the meeting on the ground floor, because the diesel fumes were horrendous,
[1:24:11]
really, really bad.
[1:24:13]
As for a battery backup, Council Member Kern, I asked that question once of West Light
[1:24:20]
Staff.
[1:24:20]
They said there isn't a battery on Earth big enough if the power goes out to sustain a data
[1:24:26]
center for hours and hours.
[1:24:30]
So they might be able to sustain some of them, but it's not going to happen for a whole
[1:24:36]
facility.
[1:24:37]
That's, that's everyone's asking that same question, but they've not resolved that.
[1:24:41]
And it's also very difficult to get batteries right now.
[1:24:44]
everything's under tariffs, supply chain shortages, you name it, this feels a little like discussion
[1:24:52]
to me. Well, he's asking for criteria and I'm giving him some criteria that I would like
[1:24:59]
staff to investigate.
[1:25:03]
And is it okay? In terms of, again, trying to iron out what you would
[1:25:12]
may become back to us on. I think, also, looking at some other states, there's a lot going
[1:25:21]
on just tons of legislation. I don't know if you've looked at that.
[1:25:29]
Yes, so we can, and so, for example, Loudon County, Virginia, is sort of data-centered
[1:25:36]
central, so we can learn a lot from them and they've, you know, kind of been early adopters
[1:25:42]
and also early regulators, and so yeah, we can certainly expand beyond the scope of Sam
[1:25:49]
Toe County in the Bay Area, and generally learn best practices for wherever we can find them.
[1:25:56]
Okay, all right, so this is a public hearing and we're going to open the public hearing.
[1:26:03]
Do we have anyone wishing to do public comment?
[1:26:08]
have a hands raised with Lisa Barbosa and it is Michelle Salman. Michelle, come on up.
[1:26:16]
And it felt I slipped sorry, honey.
[1:26:18]
That's all right, I see you.
[1:26:20]
We know who you are. Yeah, Michelle Salman.
[1:26:23]
I would just really like to compliment the staff.
[1:26:25]
That was really excellent.
[1:26:28]
Good definitions, I felt much better about moving forward with what we're doing.
[1:26:34]
And I'm really, really glad that we are doing this.
[1:26:36]
And so I support the moratorium.
[1:26:39]
I support having the best definitions that we can
[1:26:42]
and protecting the community in every way that we can
[1:26:46]
without hobbling all the businesses.
[1:26:49]
So thank you for a great.
[1:26:51]
The definitions and everything that is really excellent,
[1:26:54]
I much better.
[1:26:55]
Second, thank you.
[1:26:57]
That's it.
[1:26:59]
Anyone else, city clerk?
[1:27:01]
Anyone online?
[1:27:06]
Lisa, go ahead.
[1:27:08]
Lisa, go ahead.
[1:27:10]
Hi there, my name's Lisa Barbosa. I'm on the Executive Committee for the
[1:27:15]
Eloma Creative Chapter of the Sierra Club and in a former life I'm a
[1:27:19]
trade mechanical and electrical engineer. I'm urging you to extend the
[1:27:24]
moratorium for not just 10 months and 15 days but for an additional year. I want
[1:27:30]
you to be aware that a 25 megawatt power consumption data center is going to
[1:27:37]
about 85 million BTUs per hour into the atmosphere, with these things we're doing are
[1:27:45]
creating heat islands and they've been recording temperatures of up to four degrees
[1:27:51]
Celsius in the neighborhood. The other consideration at these things to create
[1:27:57]
infrasound, which is a sound that is far lower than the realm of human hearing,
[1:28:04]
which is around 20 hertz.
[1:28:06]
This infosound affects humans, it also affects animals.
[1:28:11]
I also want to talk about the transmission lines
[1:28:13]
who pays for them, typically it'll end up being
[1:28:16]
a ratepayers, so we're passing that on to the ratepayers.
[1:28:21]
Also, in order to keep these things
[1:28:23]
with an availability of 99.99%
[1:28:27]
which is expressed as a sub-O availability.
[1:28:30]
Now only gas generators, but also diesel generator
[1:28:33]
it will be required and these will contribute to greenhouse gases, so with all of that, and
[1:28:39]
not to mention the pernicious social effects, currently which are unknown, we urge you to
[1:28:47]
extend a moratorium and thank you so much for the time and thank you so much for your consideration.
[1:28:54]
Thank you. Do we have someone else, City Clerk? No, Madam Mary. All right. Anyone else here? No.
[1:29:03]
Okay, can I have a motion to close the public hearing?
[1:29:07]
Some moved.
[1:29:07]
Second.
[1:29:08]
All in favor?
[1:29:09]
Hi.
[1:29:10]
Anyone opposed?
[1:29:11]
No.
[1:29:11]
Council discussion.
[1:29:13]
Let us start with Council Member Lens.
[1:29:18]
Kevin, if you want.
[1:29:21]
The definitions.
[1:29:22]
As you said that San Francisco adopted the state one and then Oakland is kind of like the
[1:29:29]
one, but add some additional options. This kind of curious, you know, the last speaker
[1:29:38]
talked about the 25 megawatt facility. Could 25 megawatt facilities be built in Oakland
[1:29:48]
in San Francisco?
[1:29:54]
Those are the three classes are the smallest, which is not to say
[1:29:59]
you're small.
[1:30:00]
That those would probably be more likely in an urban environment. There may not be a lot of locations where
[1:30:09]
enough land would be available for that. But perhaps in one of the industrial districts, there
[1:30:18]
could be consideration of something relatively large footprint. They can be multi-story as well.
[1:30:25]
So I'm in a more of an setting,
[1:30:29]
yeah, you may be able to find sites that can accommodate
[1:30:32]
something in the tier 3s.
[1:30:35]
Okay, and then if the city did just an all out ban
[1:30:42]
with that jeopardized some of the businesses
[1:30:48]
that are currently in Brazil, I know it's for future,
[1:30:52]
but businesses such as some of the current
[1:30:55]
businesses, would it prohibit current types of businesses in Brisbane from setting up
[1:31:02]
shop in our city?
[1:31:06]
We would want to maybe have a better understanding of whether a current
[1:31:11]
business would fit that definition and would that then make them non-conforming. So part of
[1:31:19]
it is working out that definition to decide what are you defining. That may be why we get some
[1:31:25]
local variations, and maybe Oakland was wanting to allow a certain type of business and
[1:31:34]
work their definition around that, but also to one of the speaker's points you don't want
[1:31:41]
to kind of accidentally, maybe this is where we're going with this accidentally, prohibit
[1:31:47]
something that you didn't intend to prohibit, but then it falls within a definition.
[1:31:53]
And so I think particularly if the definition is more specific and more detailed, you're less likely to kind of get somebody swept into something that's more ambiguous.
[1:32:06]
But that can be something that staff can consider in their analysis is existing businesses and how they fit in.
[1:32:13]
Okay. No, thank you for that. Yeah, you know, I, I, I just don't have, I feel like I don't have the knowledge right to make a clear
[1:32:23]
kind of position on what should be the definition. I feel like I would need more information.
[1:32:32]
I mean, I'm all in favor of doing the moratorium. And then having staff come back with, say,
[1:32:39]
some examples in town, maybe in the Central Park, where you have to help define what we would
[1:32:48]
and what we would not.
[1:32:52]
Councilmember Kirk?
[1:32:57]
Can I make a motion at this time?
[1:33:00]
Yes.
[1:33:01]
I think we've closed the hearing, correct?
[1:33:02]
You can make a motion, but we still have discussion.
[1:33:06]
Oh, I'm with Councilmember O'Connell.
[1:33:08]
I think I would like to make a motion here to adopt the interim urgency ordinance.
[1:33:13]
16, the temporary moratorium on new data centers for 10 months and 15 days.
[1:33:17]
for suit government code section six five eight five eight second. Okay, so we have a motion on the table.
[1:33:25]
Can we pause that for the rest of the discussion? No, you have to call right because there's a second.
[1:33:39]
If we call.
[1:33:41]
If we vote on this, it means we can still discuss the language that's going forward. Correct. The rest of it. Correct.
[1:33:50]
That is correct. Yes, I mean these are two separate issues and on the second issue we're only giving you're only getting the staff direction and I I may have a fix for council member Lens if you to you should just I would suggest you call the vote on this item.
[1:34:08]
Okay, this fine. Just want to make sure we're doing this procedurally correct. All right. We have a motion on the table on a second all in favor.
[1:34:15]
Hi.
[1:34:17]
Anyone opposed?
[1:34:18]
No.
[1:34:18]
Motion carries.
[1:34:20]
So, Council Member Kern, did you have discussion?
[1:34:23]
No further items for discussion.
[1:34:25]
All right.
[1:34:26]
Council Member O'Connell?
[1:34:29]
Well, I do think that Oakland has, I appreciate the accessory service rooms, definition that goes in there.
[1:34:43]
And that it, the necessary server rooms incidental to the principle use are allowed.
[1:34:54]
But again, I think that's something that probably needs a little more research, but all in all I would be in favor of the staff coming forward with a permanent complete ban on instead of an emergency moratorium.
[1:35:12]
the language to have a complete ban as long as necessary server rooms that are
[1:35:21]
incidental to the primary use are allowed within businesses, but that's in the
[1:35:27]
future. Okay, may I approach him, Davis? So it looks like the recommended
[1:35:33]
definition of data center has that built-in. That staff is proposing plus
[1:35:40]
clarifying facility. I think what staff has here is great. I'm not interested in clarifying
[1:35:46]
megawatts and all that because I really just think we need to do a ban. I'm not trying to figure
[1:35:50]
out a way to let anyone open any kind of data center of any kind. So I would think you would start
[1:36:00]
doing that if you wanted to attract a data center of some level and I feel that our space and
[1:36:06]
has been already attracts all kinds of businesses that we want to have and so I don't see
[1:36:15]
any reason to try to attract the data center of any size and I don't hear from our community
[1:36:20]
that they want to data center of any size. So I think making sure that somebody like a place
[1:36:26]
like City Hall that has a little AV room, right, of course, that wouldn't fall into a definition
[1:36:32]
of what we would consider a data center. So clearing that up, staff has a good definition
[1:36:36]
here. And I think just moving forward with a full band, it would be interesting to know when you
[1:36:43]
come bring that analysis. If there's anyone currently that would fall outside this definition
[1:36:51]
and then, you know, we could talk about that more deeply. Maybe they could be grandfathered in on
[1:36:56]
some level. But I think that's for future discussion, but I'm I'm I'm in favor of just defining it and
[1:37:05]
getting it. So. Madam Mayor, if Kevin correct me if I'm wrong, if if we were to if the council were to pass it or provide a definition and it was worth to pass it some point.
[1:37:18]
Any use that's currently in town would be not conforming it does they don't have to change anything. So I just wanted to.
[1:37:24]
Yeah, they just can't expand. So just want to make that point.
[1:37:28]
Okay. I'm a little bit.
[1:37:30]
More pragmatic, in that I see things that at a point in time, like our current definition here, of data centers, that that was okay then, and 10 years, 20 years down the road, you go, what were they thinking, this doesn't make sense anymore.
[1:37:47]
I would rather not ban something that may turn out to not encompass a whole warehouse in the future
[1:37:55]
because the technology that they're talking about changing in 5 to 10 years will make all the giant warehouse data centers obsolete, completely obsolete,
[1:38:07]
and they say that the people that are building them right now are going to have buyers remorse or developers remorse.
[1:38:14]
So, I would, instead of banning, I would prefer that we define what we allow, period,
[1:38:22]
and we don't have to call it a data center.
[1:38:24]
We could call it server room, we could call it business computing center, but state what
[1:38:31]
we allow and not ban.
[1:38:33]
That allows us in the future if we want to amend it, change the definitions, we do that.
[1:38:42]
But, and I, that may need some of you uncomfortable.
[1:38:45]
I'm not in favor of big data centers at all.
[1:38:48]
They're, they're energy hogs, they pollute, the noise,
[1:38:51]
the, everything that we've heard.
[1:38:55]
But I also don't want to lock us into something
[1:38:59]
that we go, we didn't really have a good grasp on it yet.
[1:39:03]
And it will effectively do the same thing.
[1:39:06]
If we just say, this is all that we allow.
[1:39:08]
And we state where it is.
[1:39:11]
And then it would take someone coming to us saying,
[1:39:14]
well, I have this new technology,
[1:39:16]
and this is what it is.
[1:39:17]
And we could still say no,
[1:39:19]
but it allows us a little bit more flexibility,
[1:39:22]
because technology is changing leaps and bounds.
[1:39:27]
So that's my two cents.
[1:39:31]
Sam, you can add something.
[1:39:33]
Oh, I'm sorry.
[1:39:34]
Cuts a member, sir.
[1:39:35]
This question is for Jeremy Dennis,
[1:39:37]
city manager, and Sam's up.
[1:39:38]
Where's city attorney?
[1:39:41]
you're welcome. Is it unusual for a municipality to put an annual review on its calendar of its
[1:39:50]
data center policies and zoning?
[1:39:58]
I don't know that these data center policies have been being for more than a year.
[1:40:05]
Would it be considered unusual?
[1:40:11]
No, I mean, the Council certainly, the Council could say let's review this.
[1:40:15]
what's adopted now in review this in a year. I would suspect that particularly with this area
[1:40:20]
in part because of the reasons that the mayor just laid out that technology is evolving,
[1:40:25]
that that might make good sense. Thank you. I have some follow-up question. Are we
[1:40:31]
if we did a ban? Are we locked in? I mean, it seems like a council could make a decision at any time
[1:40:37]
to revise the definition as we're doing right now because we already have defined what
[1:40:42]
data center is now we're revising the definition. That's right. I would think at any time you could revise the
[1:40:47]
definition based on the current information you have, then trying to make something in anticipation
[1:40:53]
of what might happen in the future, you could just do something now that covers your circumstances now.
[1:40:59]
And then in the future, when you realize what you need to revise, you revise it then? Yes, that's right.
[1:41:05]
It would be the same. It would be a similar process to what we're describing now. It would be a
[1:41:12]
go to that planning commission with an ordinance to review and make a recommendation and come back
[1:41:17]
to the council for consideration and adoption.
[1:41:21]
Council Member Lens, you had something?
[1:41:23]
Yeah, Sammy, you said you had a recommendation or suggestion?
[1:41:32]
Well, it seems like the council may have worked it out, so thanks.
[1:41:40]
So does the staff have direction, you're going to come back to us with some other proposals.
[1:41:45]
We're not really voting on anything tonight.
[1:41:48]
We've already voted on the extension of the ordinance for 10 months and 15 days.
[1:41:55]
I think we, I'm working at Kevin here.
[1:41:59]
I think we have what we need.
[1:42:01]
I think we have what we need for what we would recommend the next step to be.
[1:42:05]
And the next step would be that we would come back to the council and get direction from you.
[1:42:10]
We're guarding whether you would like to band data centers entirely.
[1:42:14]
And if that's the council's wishes, we can short circuit this process, no pun intended.
[1:42:20]
So I think we have to have plenty of direction for that if that if you agree.
[1:42:25]
I think we've got what we need.
[1:42:26]
Yep, thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
[1:42:30]
Moving on to new business, consider adoption of a resolution for claiming a local
[1:42:35]
emergency related to the 2026-27 El Nino season for preparedness and planning purposes staff report
[1:42:43]
please.
[1:42:49]
Thank you Mayor Mackin and members of the council. We wanted to bring this item forward
[1:42:53]
for I think some obvious reasons but to state some of the factors. First of all the city has
[1:43:00]
in the past in recent past had significant damage from storms and this could happen again as it
[1:43:08]
on. Secondly, the county of San Mateo just declared their own local emergency and we believe
[1:43:15]
that that makes sense to put these protections in place. So if in the future we need to
[1:43:20]
take some action or get some money back from the state where the feds this would be the vehicle
[1:43:24]
for that. And further request of Council Member Lens, we also wanted to provide a brief update
[1:43:33]
tonight on our storm preparedness, and Maz will take it from here.
[1:43:41]
Thank you, Jeremy. Just one slide.
[1:43:46]
So thank you tonight. Tonight I'm just going to
[1:43:49]
provide a little bit of a recap of what we've been doing as the city with respect to
[1:43:55]
preparation for the upcoming winter storm season. And much of this is part of our annual
[1:44:03]
We're also focusing on some of our more vulnerable infrastructure, making sure we're prepared
[1:44:07]
to respond to the potential of significant storm events.
[1:44:11]
On the drainage and flood prevention, our maintenance crews have been actively cleaning catch
[1:44:15]
basins, drainage dishes, and other stormwater infrastructure throughout the city.
[1:44:19]
We're also monitoring our seasonal creeks, particularly where they intersect with roadways
[1:44:24]
for debris accumulation that could obstruct drainage flows, and this work is well underway
[1:44:30]
and we'll continue throughout the winter. We're about 75% was the guess approximately of how far
[1:44:37]
we've gone through our areas of concern. Another area that we've been working on is our
[1:44:46]
sandbag operations. Earlier this fall we had had a successful community sandbag filling event
[1:44:52]
as well as some of our staff that joined DELP out. We produced about 2,100 sandbags at that time,
[1:44:58]
those bags should be
[1:45:00]
We're available at City Hall Parking Logis, outside of this room. For about a month, for about the last month, I'm
[1:45:06]
residents have been picking them up and we've been replenishing them as necessary. Staff will continue
[1:45:11]
fulfilling Sandbags as needed and we also will welcome additional volunteer help in the future to
[1:45:19]
to fill more Sandbags if there's a desire to do that. Our equipment and operational readiness are
[1:45:25]
that I'm working through equipment inspections, which includes servicing all of our
[1:45:32]
publications and lift stations as well as our vehicles and hand tools, and also continuously
[1:45:39]
checking fuel supplies and backup power capabilities, making sure the backup
[1:45:43]
generators that we have are topped off, making sure that vehicles are kept charged and
[1:45:51]
and full gas tanks full, just so that if there's an event, we're ready to go.
[1:45:57]
We're also taking steps to protect some of our vulnerable city facilities, this includes
[1:46:03]
some of the pump stations and our corporation yard, we've strategically positioned
[1:46:07]
position sandbags, so that staff can go out there and place them around some of that critical
[1:46:12]
infrastructure like the Valley Drive Livestation and other locations.
[1:46:20]
Also, I want to touch a little bit on our Marina and some of the King-type preparedness as well as for preparedness.
[1:46:30]
We've been prepared for the King-Tides by planning to proactively close some of the low-lying parking areas.
[1:46:36]
We have some of the spots are prone to flooding.
[1:46:40]
So those when the King-Tides are starting to come up, our staff will go out and actually plan to close them in advance
[1:46:47]
of that water backing up, and there's ample parking on the higher level areas, so it wouldn't
[1:46:54]
be an impact there. The other consideration is the potential for power disruptions, given some
[1:47:02]
of our aging electrical infrastructures that were continuous continuing to upgrade, and when these
[1:47:08]
out of it is a curve, some of them are a lot of it is impacted by some of the rising tides, so
[1:47:14]
We're going to staff and we'll work to relocate effective voters, particularly our
[1:47:18]
little boards, to slips with available power when possible.
[1:47:22]
We also do have portable solar powered battery backups that are available for small charging
[1:47:30]
of small devices, so that's available at our marine offices for folks for some of those
[1:47:35]
essential devices.
[1:47:37]
And then I also want to touch a little bit on our regional emergency coordination in the
[1:47:41]
to coordinating with San Mateo County Emergency Management and our neighboring jurisdictions,
[1:47:48]
which are a sense of any major Christian different ideas and folks have been
[1:47:53]
very involved in. We've, there's also been some conversations amongst the public
[1:47:57]
work structures from across the county. We've recently met to share our preparation strategies
[1:48:03]
and updated our contact information, really to help establish better coordination and opportunities
[1:48:09]
for resource sharing during those major events and just in closing I want to encourage residents
[1:48:16]
to report drainage concerns through the city's My Brisbane Service request platform as well as
[1:48:25]
looking for potential opportunities for volunteering efforts such as Sandbag, Filling, and of course
[1:48:32]
to sign up for SMC Alert if you have not already done so I really do want to I also want to take
[1:48:37]
this moment to recognize our maintenance crews,
[1:48:40]
bring to staff and city staff as a whole
[1:48:42]
that are working behind the scenes to prepare our community.
[1:48:46]
This concludes my update.
[1:48:48]
I'm happy to answer any questions.
[1:48:50]
Is this a fun time to be a community development director?
[1:48:54]
I'm sorry, I'm public work director.
[1:48:55]
It is a fun time to be a community development director.
[1:49:03]
You know, I went through the 223 storms as well and in a different jurisdiction and I worked with my predecessor here as well.
[1:49:14]
It is interesting.
[1:49:16]
I will say that from a public works perspective, we are obviously all little heightened in our concerns.
[1:49:26]
But it's, I would say another day of the office.
[1:49:30]
Okay.
[1:49:32]
Good answer.
[1:49:34]
All right.
[1:49:35]
Council questions starting with Council Member Kern.
[1:49:40]
Thank you so much, Madam Mayor.
[1:49:41]
I only have one question.
[1:49:43]
I do sit on the emergency preparedness subcommittee with Mayor Protem Davis.
[1:49:48]
I feel like we have been given a ton of information.
[1:49:50]
I appreciate everything that you've shared so far.
[1:49:52]
I'm just tons of it.
[1:49:54]
My question is about mutual aid and the months of November and December.
[1:49:58]
I know that we look at the holidays as a special time for our staff and their families.
[1:50:04]
I know it's a tough scheduling time too.
[1:50:07]
I'm assuming that the other jurisdictions in which we have the mutual aid agreements are going through something similar.
[1:50:12]
How do we work our way through that?
[1:50:16]
That's a good point.
[1:50:18]
I mean, as first responders and emergency situations, there is opportunities for us to call
[1:50:27]
folks and even when they're on vacation at times.
[1:50:31]
A lot of other, the San Mateo County did something that was interesting, they're not
[1:50:36]
the most popular, but they actually have held off on a proving anytime off requests completely.
[1:50:44]
for us in Brisbane and some of the other jurisdictions that we have that I've talked to, we are
[1:50:49]
looking very closely to make sure that we don't minimize our staffing capabilities by overloading
[1:50:56]
on vacations and time-off requests but it's a balance trying to make sure that people also have
[1:51:01]
the opportunities to spend time with their families. One other thing that Brisbane is doing is
[1:51:06]
usually we have one off-call person during the weekends. We've decided during this, you know, during
[1:51:11]
forecasted times that we would up that to two, just to have that additional ability to
[1:51:18]
call somebody into an emergency.
[1:51:21]
Great, thank you, Moss.
[1:51:23]
That's my only question.
[1:51:24]
All right.
[1:51:25]
Thank you.
[1:51:27]
Councilmember Lens.
[1:51:28]
Yeah.
[1:51:28]
Thank you, Madam Mayor.
[1:51:31]
Thank you, Moss, for that very thorough analysis of where we are and how we're preparing.
[1:51:38]
Yeah, so I serve on the, I'm a representative for the emergency services council and county level and so they provided their update on El Nino preparedness.
[1:51:52]
You know, it's interesting that some El Nino's have a lower than average precipitation is kind of a trip.
[1:52:00]
you just think, okay, you know, it's supposed to be super heavy, but sometimes it doesn't.
[1:52:08]
You know, you talk about during the holidays, Frank. So the king tides are going to be during
[1:52:16]
Thanksgiving and Christmas. So I'm glad that you're restricting parking that lower area next to the
[1:52:27]
theoclub.
[1:52:30]
So, couple things. So, one of the things that we did after that big storm to get volunteers involved was to adopt a drain. So, maybe that is part of the volunteer program that you've initiated.
[1:52:46]
Yes, thank you. I forgot to mention that but if folks are interested, please reach out to us for continuing to adopt a train as well.
[1:52:54]
All right, and then I think it's the 14th and the 15th of November where we have the green bins that people can use to reduce their their loads around their homes.
[1:53:11]
With tree branches and things like that that could cause problems in a big storm.
[1:53:17]
I'm sure we're promoting that.
[1:53:19]
Yes, that's that's still on our on our list.
[1:53:23]
Whether dependent.
[1:53:24]
Got it. Okay, great. Thank you so much.
[1:53:28]
That's it. Okay.
[1:53:31]
Um, their program Davis.
[1:53:34]
Um,
[1:53:35]
As council member current mentioned, I'm on the emergency preparedness subcommittee.
[1:53:40]
This is something that the subcommittee asked to talk to us about.
[1:53:44]
So I'm really excited to see your presentation tonight.
[1:53:52]
One thing that did come up in the subcommittee was having more people on call when we know there's going to be a storm.
[1:53:59]
So I really like that you've taken that recommendation to her.
[1:54:03]
It's something you were already contemplating even before I was suggested by me.
[1:54:07]
But I think that will be a really big help.
[1:54:11]
So otherwise, no questions we talk so much about this already at the subcommittee level,
[1:54:17]
but excited that we're letting the public know how seriously we take this and the work that we're
[1:54:23]
doing to prepare. Okay. Council member O'Connell?
[1:54:32]
I don't really have any questions. I want to say that
[1:54:34]
I am really appreciative of all the hard work that goes into being prepared and then reacting when it
[1:54:43]
happens. I was out of town when the last big storm came and my house was under construction
[1:54:50]
at the time and so we had and I never saw it but I had mud run through my basement which
[1:54:59]
I've never seen before and through the garage but I had a construction on site to take
[1:55:07]
of it, which was wonderful.
[1:55:10]
So I'm hoping that this year, while I'm out of town again,
[1:55:16]
we don't have the same problems, and we get the drier El Niña.
[1:55:21]
But I know that the city will be taking good care of us.
[1:55:24]
Thank you.
[1:55:26]
Thank you for all the info.
[1:55:28]
And thank you to my two colleagues on the subcommittee
[1:55:30]
for doing such a comprehensive job.
[1:55:33]
I do have one question.
[1:55:34]
goes back to Loma Prieta and roads were closed, nobody knew whether to shut off gas,
[1:55:43]
meters, nobody knew what to do about this or that. And a lot of what I looked up for
[1:55:50]
the city says, go to my Brisbane or call this number and during Loma Prieta we had no
[1:55:57]
service. So I would just strongly request and suggest can we provide some other
[1:56:06]
direction to our residents if a hillside's going if there's someone trying to
[1:56:11]
turn off gas that shouldn't and no one can call. Who do they go to? Do they
[1:56:17]
go to the fire station? Do they go to City Hall? Where's the command center? Who do
[1:56:22]
They talk to because they're not going to know who to talk to and I think we need to establish
[1:56:28]
some sort of chain of command in a physical sense in case there's absolutely no phone
[1:56:34]
service and no computers.
[1:56:36]
Where do you go?
[1:56:37]
Do you go to City Hall?
[1:56:39]
If we could work on that, I would also say that we would encourage people if there is an emergency
[1:56:47]
to call 911 as well, so that's part of the emergency response.
[1:56:51]
If you can get on a phone, just working.
[1:56:55]
I'm speaking to the lawyer.
[1:56:56]
I'm speaking to the lawyer.
[1:56:58]
I would just like to add that we also have a mobile command center that has audio equipment as well as our police and fire.
[1:57:08]
So that's another option.
[1:57:09]
I mean, first response can actually go out and can this the streets and neighborhoods and share messages that way as well.
[1:57:16]
If it really came down to a situation where
[1:57:20]
communications for now.
[1:57:22]
And I would just add a suggestion brought up by our city manager, who said he would really
[1:57:27]
like to see the certs reactivated because one of the bonuses of that was having someone
[1:57:33]
who took a designated block or group of streets and in an emergency you didn't even have
[1:57:38]
to ask them.
[1:57:40]
They go out there and they knew what to do and they'd ask people who looked frantic, how can
[1:57:44]
I help you?
[1:57:46]
And I think that was a great suggestion, Jeremy.
[1:57:48]
Well, thank you. I think that actually may have come from you and others, but it's certainly
[1:57:52]
something that we were working on in my previous capacity in other city. And I know the emergency
[1:57:57]
preparedness some committees excited about the opportunity to get more volunteers, particularly
[1:58:01]
through a circuit program. So we'll engage with our friends at the Fire Department. And this will take
[1:58:06]
a little time. It does take time to build these things up. Sometimes you have holes in it. But I'm sure
[1:58:12]
that the residents of Brisbane would like to participate in the program. So do we have any public
[1:58:17]
comments? Yes. And then I'll give you my slip-a-after because I wrote a
[1:58:22]
minute slide. Okay. I was feeling pretty good about some of the
[1:58:27]
preparations and I did give suggestions. But then I talked with Walt
[1:58:33]
Peters today for like an hour and a half and now I'm gonna have nightmares.
[1:58:38]
Because he brought up a lot of vulnerabilities and things that I wasn't really
[1:58:41]
thinking about such as where our public work facility is, which is in a very low-lying area
[1:58:49]
and could get inundated with a lot of water. And also, our firehouse is also in a low-lying
[1:58:56]
area next to the creek that feeds the lagoon and where all the water runoff comes basically
[1:59:05]
right there. And so those are high-vonirability areas. We have the type of soil we have on
[1:59:14]
the mountain is very susceptible to soil saturation. It's a clay lava salt. It gets salt up to
[1:59:20]
three times it's weight and water and slides as we've seen so many times. And it's hard to determine
[1:59:26]
where it's going to slide when it's going to slide the Saturday before the big slide in
[1:59:35]
1982.
[1:59:35]
My sister and I went hiking up straight up the hill in the habitat above San Mattel Lane
[1:59:42]
and our footsteps going up the hill were filled with water, filled with water every step
[1:59:48]
because the soil was so saturated so you kind of knew it was going to go and it did but it's
[1:59:55]
to predict where and then that's one of the things that Walter.
[2:00:00]
So today was maybe we can get some USGS monitors, at least we had an early warning if it's starting
[2:00:07]
to go. It would send out on the alarm and alert people. I think that it's really important
[2:00:14]
for us to prepare as much as we can. The certain ideas could, but I was in the first search,
[2:00:20]
and it took a lot of training to get up to speed. You were supposed to have CPR training and
[2:00:27]
turn off gas and look, it was a lot and I don't know that we have enough time because it's going
[2:00:32]
to be upon us in a couple of weeks and we have three big events in November, December, and January
[2:00:39]
with high-level ties that we've probably never seen in our lifetimes because of the Kelvin wave,
[2:00:47]
the dramatically increased temperature of the water which expands the water which makes the
[2:00:51]
even higher. I think one of the things that we can do really effectively is give citizen instructions,
[2:01:00]
citizen individual emergency instructions prepare your kit, get your flashlights ready,
[2:01:06]
this is real, it's gonna happen and I actually went and got sandbags for the first time in my life
[2:01:11]
and kind of put it around the front of our house, but individual preparation I think is really
[2:01:17]
important in individual instructions, like believe it or not, people don't realize they shouldn't drive through deep water, duh, you know, I learned that but not everybody knows that and I think it's not going to be that deep, I can go, but no you can't and you might get stuck and that's not good.
[2:01:34]
So I don't know what we can do except be very vigilant.
[2:01:37]
I don't, I think, with our public work facilities being such a low-lying area, we want to
[2:01:44]
stash some of our command center stuff on higher ground and really be prepared because the
[2:01:51]
old Bayshore low-lying, that's all land fill, all we have to old county road.
[2:01:57]
So we will be, I am really concerned about this winter, I really am more than I ever
[2:02:02]
have been.
[2:02:03]
So, thank you.
[2:02:04]
And thanks to the CDC staff for all the work you are doing to get prepared.
[2:02:08]
It's monumental and I have my rake for my drain.
[2:02:14]
Mary,
[2:02:22]
good evening, just a few suggestions for consideration.
[2:02:27]
If the rains are as bad as everyone says they're going to be with the city, consider purchasing
[2:02:36]
of portable sun pumps for folks that need them throughout town. That would help, especially
[2:02:43]
if you're getting water in your house, you know, bailing it out with pots or going to cut
[2:02:49]
it. But you can buy those sun pumps pretty. They're not that expensive and have those on hand
[2:02:55]
for those folks that need it. In addition, maybe we could utilize the blast and the star to have
[2:03:05]
Maybe that top 10 things to look for or to be aware of during the storms and where to go
[2:03:11]
and where to get some help and kind of run it between now and February.
[2:03:18]
So it's just in our face so we don't panic because you don't want panic on your hands.
[2:03:25]
Okay.
[2:03:25]
Thank you.
[2:03:26]
All right.
[2:03:28]
Anyone else here?
[2:03:29]
Anyone online?
[2:03:30]
city clerk? No more hands raised met a mirror. Can I make a comment? Sure.
[2:03:37]
This was actually one thing we discussed heavily at the emergency preparedness
[2:03:41]
subcommittee but was that like ongoing social media campaign and our other
[2:03:48]
channels in which we reach people like the star and like the blast and just having
[2:03:54]
those tips as Mary suggested just constantly, you know, being fed to the public so that
[2:04:01]
it was top of mind. So that is something from a communications standpoint we discussed.
[2:04:05]
And the other thing that we discussed and I don't know that I saw it in this report was
[2:04:08]
the city has identified trees that are very vulnerable to falling in a storm.
[2:04:15]
And so we talked about, you know, getting our resources together to get those trees that we know
[2:04:21]
could be it could pose a threat in high winds and take care of those now, but also just encouraging
[2:04:29]
as part of like that social media outreach, encouraging people to evaluate the trees that
[2:04:33]
are on their property. And just encouraging them, hey, before things get really stormy,
[2:04:43]
now's your chance to prioritize getting some of those dead trees off your property. Now before
[2:04:50]
they take out power lines or follow someone's car so on and so forth. So trees was another
[2:04:56]
aspect that we had discussed.
[2:05:01]
I'm going to add something to what you said because probably
[2:05:04]
I think it was 2006 and we had a lot of rainfall and high winds in the month of January as we
[2:05:11]
often do and we used to have a 50-foot tall black occasion in the backyard with a trunk of about
[2:05:20]
Multiple trunks, 40 inches or more. Huge, huge street. Always had been pruned out. Every other year,
[2:05:28]
Davy Tree came in, thinned it out, was beautiful. They said, that'll just secure it. It started
[2:05:34]
uprooting out of the ground and spinning around, like a top in the wind. And I will hand it to
[2:05:40]
public works. They showed up and the police department. I never even had a chance to call them.
[2:05:47]
So somebody did, or the neighbors, or they were going around town, came and put red tape around
[2:05:52]
the house and said, you got to get out of here. And did that all within about 10 minutes of this
[2:05:57]
starting? And so trees, I think, are very important, especially certain species, no matter how well
[2:06:05]
they're trimmed, it can happen. Those shallow roots, eucalyptus, what is it? Eucalyptus, redwood,
[2:06:11]
and black acacia are three of the worst.
[2:06:15]
So Michelle, you had something to add on trees, please.
[2:06:20]
Yeah, trees also help lessen the impact
[2:06:25]
of the heavy rain and gives a chance for the water
[2:06:30]
to absorb more into the soil.
[2:06:32]
So tree health is really important
[2:06:34]
and I don't want people to get overzealous
[2:06:37]
and think, I'm just going to protect myself
[2:06:40]
because you will actually make the problem worse by doing that.
[2:06:45]
So it's a slippery slope.
[2:06:47]
But you really want to be careful with your trees
[2:06:51]
that you take a care of them and assess them properly
[2:06:54]
and lighten them up or canopy loads
[2:06:57]
so the tree doesn't go over.
[2:07:00]
Black occasions are kind of notorious for that.
[2:07:03]
But other trees are not.
[2:07:06]
And they actually help slow down the water
[2:07:10]
And that's going to be a real problem this year as the water not being slowed down.
[2:07:15]
And that was really part of what made the landslides in Alan Buckeye so devastating is because we had lost the canopy from the 2008 fire.
[2:07:26]
And so there was no stopping it.
[2:07:30]
And that it wasn't mother nature. It was an act of vandalism with long-term consequences.
[2:07:37]
So I really cautioned people to not overdo it with the pruning.
[2:07:41]
Okay. Thank you for that, Michelle.
[2:07:43]
We're at council discussion, starting with council member O'Connell.
[2:07:51]
I'd make it recommended to accept the city, the fiscal, are the, let me read the motion.
[2:08:03]
I've been advised I need to read these motions by the city attorney so allow me to read it
[2:08:10]
Would be to get a first and second to adopt a resolution proclaiming a local emergency related to the
[2:08:15]
twenty twenty six twenty seven El Nino season for preparedness and planning purposes
[2:08:21]
Some of the second.
[2:08:24]
I have not even given comment yet.
[2:08:26]
Oh well.
[2:08:28]
That's last time why I said we hadn't finished comment.
[2:08:31]
Okay, well we haven't finished comment. Okay. Council member current, please. Thank you so much.
[2:08:37]
Ma's is so modest. So Council member Davis and I sat through the emergency preparedness.
[2:08:43]
You skipped over some important stuff, Ma's that you guys are doing.
[2:08:47]
So it's important to point out that all of our police enforcement vehicles, including the motorcycles,
[2:08:53]
have been equipped with the high-low emergency siren. You hear that high-low siren,
[2:08:58]
get to your front door and listen to what they're telling you to do that is critically important.
[2:09:04]
Number two, our city manager, Jeremy, is going to be looking at procuring hotel space for staff that may potentially need to stay here during emergencies that don't live in Brisbane.
[2:09:18]
So he's taking on that responsibility.
[2:09:21]
Our office of economic vitality director, Mitch Bull, is looking at securing refrigeration for
[2:09:27]
people who have chemotherapy drugs or insulin to keep that stuff safe, staff is working
[2:09:33]
their butts off on this.
[2:09:34]
Most people don't know this, but we have three new-ish or brand new electric pickup trucks.
[2:09:41]
We have two GMCs and one-forward lightning.
[2:09:43]
These can power small villages, these can power stop lights, it's amazing what these can
[2:09:48]
do.
[2:09:48]
These can be a cell phone charging center.
[2:09:52]
They can power some pumps. It's amazing. So that's we've got that.
[2:09:56]
I think it's important also to point out that we do take a hard look at
[2:10:01]
San Mateo County alerts and I talked to people across this town on a repeated basis.
[2:10:06]
Now like I'm signed up. I'm signed up only one in 10 people in the city of
[2:10:12]
Brisbane is signed up for SMC alerts. That's how you're going to learn about
[2:10:16]
numbers is the situation. And you're like, well, what should this standard be? Well,
[2:10:20]
Portola Valley is at one in three. So we're way behind in our S&C alerts. So people,
[2:10:25]
that's one of the biggest steps that you can take is to sign up for those. So that's my piece.
[2:10:30]
Thank you, Mayor, for allowing me to comment on all of that. I'm glad we allowed you to comment.
[2:10:34]
That was comprehensive and really informative. And hey, Brisbane, get in gear, sign up for
[2:10:40]
those San Mateo County alerts. That's, you could save your life or your property or both.
[2:10:46]
All right, any other council discussion comments?
[2:10:50]
No. Okay.
[2:10:52]
There was a motion and a second.
[2:10:55]
All in favor.
[2:10:56]
Hi.
[2:10:57]
Anyone opposed?
[2:10:58]
No.
[2:10:59]
Motion carries.
[2:11:01]
Thank you.
[2:11:02]
Everyone for your input on that.
[2:11:05]
We move on to item Q.
[2:11:06]
This is acceptance of the physics.
[2:11:07]
We need to extend the meeting.
[2:11:10]
No.
[2:11:12]
No.
[2:11:13]
We didn't start at five thirty.
[2:11:18]
I'm in a different world.
[2:11:21]
That's okay.
[2:11:23]
No problem.
[2:11:24]
Always good to have someone watching.
[2:11:27]
Item 2 acceptance of the fiscal year 202425 audit report.
[2:11:31]
Could we have a staff report, please?
[2:11:35]
Thank you, Madam Mayor.
[2:11:36]
Members of the City Council.
[2:11:37]
My name is Jimmy Fortress and I'm the interim finance director.
[2:11:40]
I've been here a few weeks now.
[2:11:41]
and was brought on by the City Manager to help out in this time of transition for the finance department.
[2:11:48]
I expect to be here a few months and then once you hire a new finance director,
[2:11:54]
BMI way and hopefully helped you out a little bit in my time here.
[2:11:59]
Tonight we have the third audit that you are receiving in the last 10 months.
[2:12:05]
And that's a monumental effort by City staff to get caught up on previous late audits
[2:12:10]
And I also want to introduce Grace Dan, who is our auditor, and can answer any questions you have about the audit process or the audit results.
[2:12:21]
She's with Mays and Associates and has been involved in the last three audits as well, so I'm going even further back, I believe.
[2:12:27]
So I'm going to do a quick presentation to talk to you about the status of this audit and the results and answer any questions you may have.
[2:12:36]
So, this is the review for the audit year completed June 30 of 2025.
[2:12:43]
The last two were for 24 and the one before that was for 23, so 3 and 10 months, next
[2:12:50]
light please.
[2:12:53]
And this should be very familiar to you.
[2:12:55]
This is audits are required by law and they help provide a complete audited and standardized
[2:13:04]
picture of the city's financial condition and operating results. The primary purpose of the
[2:13:10]
audit is forced to communicate with a financial world how we're really doing. And so this is
[2:13:19]
authorized and required by the government accounting standards board. And so that audit is conducted
[2:13:25]
within the realm of those standards. It is also required by the California government code.
[2:13:30]
And then as you are well aware, it is required for any debt service, credit ratings that we need, and I'll talk a little bit about that here soon.
[2:13:42]
All financial reporting in this manner, whether you were the state of California, which has been late eight years in a row or so on their audits,
[2:13:50]
or the city of Brisbane, all follow the same standards and the same requirements on how they write their documents.
[2:13:55]
and the introductory portion is the part in which the auditor tells the, let's say a board
[2:14:02]
whether or not we are a compliance. And this audit has been deemed materially, the auditors
[2:14:09]
have determined that the financial statements present fairly in all material aspects and the
[2:14:14]
respected financial position of the city and the financial statements were operating conformity
[2:14:19]
with the generally accepted accounting principles.
[2:14:22]
That does not say that you are a well functioning financial city.
[2:14:27]
It says basically that you are presented the documents and the financial documents and statements in accordance with the government accounting standards.
[2:14:39]
The second section is the financial which has the analysis and the amounts of dollars.
[2:14:44]
That's the dollars and cents and the funds and then the last section is the statistical which gives you some background about items of interest that could be top tax sales tax generators or major businesses or major schools within the area.
[2:15:00]
That contribute to your financial position.
[2:15:04]
Okay. Please. Next slide.
[2:15:07]
The fiscal year in 2025 financial results, the general fund balancing increased by 3.4 million to 24.7.4
[2:15:15]
As revenue increased by 3.2 million to 38.6 primarily because of increases in sales tax and property taxes.
[2:15:22]
That's very typical.
[2:15:23]
And then expenses decreased by 2.4 million to 32.1 primarily due to some backing out of some federal grants and items like that.
[2:15:33]
This is a snapshot on June 30 of 2025.
[2:15:38]
And so you're showing yourself to the financial community that you are growing economy
[2:15:44]
and that your fund balance of revenues are increasing, which is a good sign.
[2:15:49]
Next slide please.
[2:15:53]
In the previous audits, we have received a memorandum of an internal control, and even though
[2:16:01]
you have a audit that conforms to gap, government accounting principles, there are some
[2:16:08]
issues that are identified in that memorandum of internal control that you should be well aware of.
[2:16:12]
They were included in the 24 audit and also the 23 audit, and although there have been
[2:16:17]
some improvements in those areas.
[2:16:19]
The fact remains that this audit is late and that memo on and
[2:16:23]
internal control explains some of those reasons why most notably
[2:16:27]
bank reconciliation items of internal control that didn't
[2:16:32]
compromise the city's care taking of the finances.
[2:16:38]
It just was late reporting which hurts the credibility of the
[2:16:44]
organization as we all know.
[2:16:45]
So it matters because these internal controls give you a very clear guideline about what you're doing wrong and what you need to do.
[2:16:54]
And so once you're aware of that, you are responsible for making those changes and in the MRI C shows the management's response to those claims.
[2:17:05]
Next slide.
[2:17:08]
Really, to me, the most important part of the MRI is the control environment that tone at the top.
[2:17:14]
Does the organization have the willingness the culture to do finance properly?
[2:17:20]
And I do believe that is the case.
[2:17:22]
I do believe that some of the changes that have been made will increase that transparency
[2:17:26]
and increase that credibility, but that is really what we're looking for as to make sure
[2:17:31]
that the auditors and the financial world believe that we are stewards of tax dollars in a very
[2:17:37]
good way. It also looks at risk assessment because sometimes you do have risk involved
[2:17:43]
and the things that you have to do to avoid that risk may be far exceeding the cost of
[2:17:48]
the risk and then also control activities, information and communication and we'll talk a little
[2:17:53]
about information communication and also monitoring. So those are the five areas they look at
[2:17:59]
and we'll talk a little bit about some of the areas that we need to work on. Next slide please.
[2:18:06]
The memorandum has schedule of material weaknesses, schedule of significant deficiencies and
[2:18:12]
of other matters. Next slide please.
[2:18:18]
And the findings I want to do point out, as I said,
[2:18:20]
it does not change that we did have a clean audit opinion, but these are repeated comments,
[2:18:26]
audit preparation timelines. There are three audits that have been late. Review of bank
[2:18:32]
reconciliations, journal entries, those have been behind those have been late as well. And then
[2:18:36]
one other area that is very simple to correct is that there have been times when payroll,
[2:18:44]
adjustments or other financial adjustments have been made without signed personal action forms.
[2:18:50]
That's a big no no, you need to have that documentation before you make those changes.
[2:18:55]
So we do that now, highly confident that that will be corrected for future audit cycles.
[2:19:01]
And the next audit that you have coming up for the completion of fiscal year 26 will see significant improvement if not elimination of all these issues.
[2:19:10]
Next slide please.
[2:19:12]
The single audit, I can save you this slide, we, Brisbane was not required to conduct a single
[2:19:20]
audit because they did not have a million dollars in federal expenditures.
[2:19:24]
You may have a single audit in fiscal year 26, we're still waiting to determine if that
[2:19:28]
has been exceeded, but no single audit this year.
[2:19:32]
Okay, next slide please.
[2:19:35]
Okay, next steps and the 2026 audit process, once we complete and you accept this report,
[2:19:41]
We will really start going towards completing the fiscal year 26 audit, but the 25 audit is
[2:19:49]
important because we will now be able to engage standard importers to see if we can get
[2:19:55]
our credit rating back.
[2:19:56]
We've already had a few discussions with them and will increase those discussions next week
[2:20:00]
assuming you accept this report and that will put you on good footing as you stand with your
[2:20:11]
refinance your bonds or anything like that, your much better shape than you are now, which is your
[2:20:17]
no shape to enter that market. So that will be something we'll be reporting back very shortly,
[2:20:23]
once we know what standard of course feels about the credit rating of Brisbane after this audit.
[2:20:29]
So anyway, the fiscal or 26 audit for June 30th ending of this year is underway and once we're
[2:20:37]
completed and accepted of this, we expect that audit to be returning to you in March of
[2:20:42]
2027.
[2:20:43]
That will still be late, but it will be a much better condition, it will be much closer to
[2:20:48]
the deadline, and that will put you in place for the fiscal year 2027 audits, which should
[2:20:56]
be on time, and should have all things corrected and highly confident that will be the case.
[2:21:01]
I think they're well on their way now.
[2:21:03]
I do want to compliment the finance department, especially completing four audits and 12 months
[2:21:09]
is nothing I've ever heard of or seen in my career and it's a monumental effort but
[2:21:14]
one that was necessary and showed a high level of commitment to those in the finance department
[2:21:19]
to do this.
[2:21:21]
So they should be proud that they were able to get caught up but obviously not thrilled that
[2:21:25]
they got behind.
[2:21:27]
But fiscal 2027, fiscal 2027 should get you back on track.
[2:21:32]
Next slide, please.
[2:21:34]
That concludes my report. I'm happy to answer any questions you have about the audit, and as I said,
[2:21:38]
I say, Grace saying from May's is here to answer anything about the process, but we would have to answer your questions.
[2:21:44]
Thank you.
[2:21:45]
Thank you very much, and I'd like to extend a welcome to you. We're glad to have you on board. We need your help, and it's appreciated.
[2:21:53]
So anyone that doesn't know Jimmy, thank you for joining us.
[2:21:59]
Let's start Council questions with Council Member O'Conne.
[2:22:08]
I just want to say I'm really thankful that we've gotten back on board and that I'm
[2:22:14]
very happy with your concise and optimistic for the future projections on how our financial
[2:22:25]
department is doing. So thank you. But no questions.
[2:22:29]
Okay.
[2:22:30]
May your program date?
[2:22:34]
No questions. I just thank you for acknowledging what was accomplished in the time. I don't think
[2:22:43]
people understand quite of what I heard earlier in effort. It was and how we really all rallied around
[2:22:50]
providing the resources to ensure that we were able to get this done quickly. And thank you for coming on board
[2:22:58]
help us because we needed some new leadership in the department. So I appreciate that. So you're
[2:23:06]
expecting that this is then 2025 to 2025. Six would be completed by March 2027. That is correct.
[2:23:13]
And you anticipate that you'll be here through the finish of that? It's possible. Okay. I'm semi-retired.
[2:23:20]
So I'm, I bet I'll be here as long as I need it.
[2:23:24]
And do you say that you're keeping him as long as we can?
[2:23:27]
And would you say that provided that the council accepts the audit report
[2:23:33]
and you get started that that is a standard amount of time to complete by March
[2:23:44]
2027, since the fiscal year closed June 30th, would you say that that's kind of a fair amount of time to do the prior year audit?
[2:23:56]
It is and actually the standard is 180 days after the close of the fiscal year.
[2:24:01]
So if you get that 25 audit done and approved, you're already started on the 26 audit.
[2:24:06]
I'm confident they'll be back or I'll be back and March to finalize that.
[2:24:11]
And when do you anticipate, it talked to staff and they thought that by the end of the year,
[2:24:16]
Standard and Pores would be able to issue a rating in your conversations with them,
[2:24:20]
do you still feel like that's doable?
[2:24:23]
I do.
[2:24:24]
It doesn't take a long time once you identify the analyst who gave to the way you're rating,
[2:24:29]
you can work with them directly and it goes pretty fast.
[2:24:31]
So you would say that before the end of the year, we would expect a rating of some kind.
[2:24:35]
Yes.
[2:24:36]
Thank you.
[2:24:38]
Council Member Kern.
[2:24:40]
Thank you so much, Jimmy, really fantastic job on this.
[2:24:44]
Thank you so much.
[2:24:45]
This was delivered in such a concise and proper manner.
[2:24:48]
I really appreciate it.
[2:24:50]
I am going to piggyback on Mayor Protem's question.
[2:24:55]
We are wrapping up the first week in November.
[2:24:58]
We've got the Thanksgiving holiday, Christmas, New Year's, all the good stuff.
[2:25:04]
You really honestly believe we're going to have a rating
[2:25:07]
in the five weeks that remain in this year. Other than the New York Stock Exchange, the financial
[2:25:16]
market does not care about holidays.
[2:25:21]
Jimmy, that wasn't my question, but okay. I am struggling
[2:25:26]
to believe we're going to have a rating in the next five weeks. So that's a heck of a challenge
[2:25:31]
and it sounds like you're up to it. So good luck with that. Also, the material deficiencies
[2:25:38]
and weaknesses in this audit and by the way I've only been on council for 23 months and I've
[2:25:43]
been through now four audits in 23 months here. But the material deficiencies in weakness are
[2:25:48]
exactly the same in this audit as they were the prior audits. I know you just called that out here
[2:25:52]
but I'll be interested to see how we're moving forward to make sure that gets wrapped up and I
[2:25:57]
expecting the next audit based upon what you just said to look much cleaner. So thank you so much. Thank you.
[2:26:07]
Hi, Jimmy. Logan. Yeah. I appreciate our time yesterday and it was great to meet you in person and you answered my questions very, very thoroughly. So a lot of the questions that I'll ask tonight, I already asked you, but I think it's important to do that for the public.
[2:26:30]
So,
[2:26:34]
in your staff report, you talk about the ending fund balance of 27.4 million, but most of
[2:26:42]
that is restricted, right, I guess, which leaves a small amount of 3.2 million that's unrestricted.
[2:26:51]
Did I get that, right?
[2:26:53]
Yeah, it's restricted by council policy.
[2:26:55]
So, Council, if you can always consider adjusting their policy, but the excess amount that is not restricted by a policy is that 2 million, I believe that you said or
[2:27:06]
3.2, 3.2 million, yes.
[2:27:08]
Yeah, and then money that's owed to the city.
[2:27:11]
Where does that reside?
[2:27:14]
It depends on where it's expended, and so if you have a debt in one fund, it'll it'll show up there.
[2:27:22]
So if you have a specific, you know, a question about deaths over to the city,
[2:27:28]
like I could tell you were a dad.
[2:27:30]
Yeah, you know, that would be great.
[2:27:34]
You know, we have a developer that is a significant amount of money.
[2:27:38]
Where in the audit can we find that money?
[2:27:43]
You can find that, it's a proprietary fund that I can get you the page number if you'd like,
[2:27:49]
but that's going to show up in basically what has happened
[2:27:51]
since that developer hasn't paid that work has been done so you'll see a negative
[2:27:56]
fund balance because of that money is owed to the city so it's it is incorporated
[2:28:01]
there and I can give you the page number if you want to see it. Yeah you know that would be great.
[2:28:06]
Or page 254 of the packet. 146 okay thank you. 146 is the audited itself so we have just
[2:28:15]
It's also $2.54, $3.22.
[2:28:21]
Okay.
[2:28:24]
So
[2:28:27]
when we've gone through our budget process,
[2:28:34]
you know, we identified the projected deficit
[2:28:36]
and then by the end of the year we come out in the black
[2:28:40]
and we've had a string of years that just showed that.
[2:28:46]
2025 was one of those years.
[2:28:51]
And so that money that's owed,
[2:28:53]
it's showing up in that ending fund balanceset.
[2:28:59]
In the proprietary funds, it does not show up in the general fund.
[2:29:02]
It does not show up in the general fund.
[2:29:06]
So my question to you is,
[2:29:09]
if you have that money owed,
[2:29:12]
Is the city running a deficit because it's owed the money or is it does it show up as an asset that the city anticipates will be paid?
[2:29:21]
It should show up as an accountable or a payable to the city and what happens is
[2:29:27]
The funds for the purpose of the act for our they're torn apart
[2:29:31]
But when we invest it we co-mingle it so we invest in life and some other entities and all that money goes into that pot
[2:29:38]
so that seven million that is owed to the city will have to be covered by some other cash
[2:29:44]
that otherwise could have been invested so not only are you owed the money you're actually
[2:29:48]
losing on investment opportunity because you should have that money in your pocket so there is
[2:29:54]
a secondary kind of penalty you're paying for not having that money got it got it okay that
[2:30:00]
We would go into the general fund. We would go access to it. Not directly. The money most likely is being covered by
[2:30:09]
general fund cash. Because that's where we have a lot of cash. We have 27 million dollars in cash just sitting. It's going to cover some debts in some areas.
[2:30:17]
And normally that would be returned to the general fund with interest. So, because of lost interest opportunity. That's typically what would happen.
[2:30:26]
Okay.
[2:30:30]
So
[2:30:32]
we've been racking up these costs for the B lines. But we don't see the bills.
[2:30:42]
And so is that because the spending authority that we give the staff is higher than the proposals?
[2:30:49]
And therefore the staff has the authority to sign those agreements.
[2:30:53]
And I tell him this curious about that.
[2:30:59]
Is that okay?
[2:30:59]
Well, there is a signed agreement,
[2:31:01]
my understanding between the developer and the city for work.
[2:31:07]
And so that work is performed.
[2:31:09]
And normally, in a situation,
[2:31:11]
the developer would make it a deposit.
[2:31:14]
And then that work would be charged against that deposit.
[2:31:16]
For some point in history, that's not occurring.
[2:31:20]
Yeah, so I don't think it's a matter of spending a theory.
[2:31:24]
I think it's a contractual obligation that, you know, has been
[2:31:27]
interfered into and has gone off the rails a little bit.
[2:31:31]
Okay, thank you for for that.
[2:31:35]
All right, this is the only questions I have at this time out of
[2:31:38]
the mirror. Okay.
[2:31:39]
So I'm going to dovetail a little bit off of Council Member Lens.
[2:31:44]
When I look at page 1116, it's a statement of net position.
[2:31:50]
If I look at other non-current assets, does that include the 7.6 million that the Bayland's developer owes the city? Is it in that figure?
[2:32:01]
You said page 116.
[2:32:05]
Of the packet or the app for?
[2:32:07]
Sorry, of the packet.
[2:32:09]
Okay, I only have one.
[2:32:09]
116 of 32, which is on the report, it says page 8.
[2:32:19]
Oh, okay, I got you. No, no, that would not because this is that this is government. Why statement of
[2:32:27]
Not position
[2:32:29]
Okay, so it's not included in. Oh, I'm sorry of these non-current assets.
[2:32:42]
No, I don't believe so. No, it would be in the proprietary funds, which is page
[2:32:49]
They go in, which would you say one
[2:32:52]
46 one. Thank you.
[2:32:58]
Here we go. Okay, so
[2:32:59]
I got two page numbers going here so
[2:33:05]
so page I'll get you the page number I'm almost there sorry it's not 146
[2:33:10]
146 is page 38
[2:33:17]
Jimmy 146 of 322 it's of the total packet oh I got you okay
[2:33:27]
that wasn't the right page number I'm sorry okay I'm looking at one page page 146 of the
[2:33:46]
It's 254 of your packet.
[2:33:50]
I don't want a page 252 of 322.
[2:33:54]
There we go.
[2:33:57]
222.
[2:34:00]
And tell me again where it is.
[2:34:03]
Okay, it's on page ups.
[2:34:07]
252 of 322.
[2:34:09]
Okay.
[2:34:10]
All right, sorry.
[2:34:10]
I got it now.
[2:34:11]
And if you look at developer deposit funds.
[2:34:13]
Yes.
[2:34:14]
That call on there with the big negative $7.3 million.
[2:34:17]
That's where it's at.
[2:34:18]
That's it. Okay. That's helpful. Thank you very much. Sorry about the page. Okay. Also, let's see here on page. Okay, 137 and I'll give you the other alternate page is 29 shows the utility fund utility agency is losing 1.5 million after you add in the depreciation back in.
[2:34:53]
why is this
[2:34:58]
okay I'm on page 29 137 of 32 and you are asking about under the first
[2:35:05]
fund column utility okay we showed depreciation 640 thousand and then the operating
[2:35:12]
income loss is 2.1 so if we add the depreciation back in it's still there's an
[2:35:19]
operational loss of about 1.5 million that's correct do we know why you're spending
[2:35:24]
more than you're taking in. And do we know why? Because your rates aren't keeping up with your
[2:35:29]
cost. Okay. And so, parlaying on the question about our bond rating, S&P when they
[2:35:37]
took away our bond rating said that our utilities were not operating in the black. So how do we
[2:35:44]
get the bond rating back when we're operating in a deficit? You'll get the bond rating back
[2:35:49]
for the general fund. You will not get the bond rating back for the utility fund. Okay. All right.
[2:35:54]
Thank you for that clarification and then on pay we can add a ask a follow-up question
[2:36:00]
based on sure the pathway to restoring a bond rating on that on the enterprise fund is
[2:36:09]
to increase rates or cut cost.
[2:36:13]
Right and as a reminder the city staff is already big on preparations related to the next
[2:36:22]
great study that will be bringing back to council twenty twenty eight
[2:36:30]
in my next question
[2:36:31]
can I ask one more question after that I'm so sorry thank you so much Jeremy for the
[2:36:35]
clarification on the rates study are since the rates are passed through we do not
[2:36:40]
mark those up those are passed through rates are we not always going to be in the red because
[2:36:46]
we're always going to be following a rate increase we're never going to be caught up it's almost
[2:36:52]
possible. Or am I a minor confused? Well, I was actually going to turn to Mars. Maybe you
[2:36:58]
can help a little bit with this one.
[2:37:04]
I think, I mean, when we do the race city, that's what
[2:37:07]
we're going to take a closer look at is, you know, the capital funding that we're going to be
[2:37:12]
looking at, the death service that we're covering. So I think the long term is what is the goal,
[2:37:20]
what is, what is the funding level that we're trying to get to and setting those race appropriately
[2:37:25]
for that. So we've made, I mean, there is a potential where the race would be
[2:37:30]
At where there would be higher so that we would catch up, and that's part of the rate
[2:37:35]
city of determined what that appropriate rate would look like to get us to that point where
[2:37:39]
we're in any better situation. So we could give that rating back. Thank you.
[2:37:47]
So on page 118 of 32 or your page 10, we have all the governmental activities and every single
[2:37:58]
one increased with the exception and maybe Moz will need to answer this with the exception
[2:38:04]
of public works and it dropped by 2 million. Why did public works decrease?
[2:38:10]
I don't think I know. I believe that was stormy related grant money.
[2:38:15]
So it's back down.
[2:38:18]
Okay.
[2:38:18]
And then on page 120, let me give you the alternate.
[2:38:28]
120, which is page 12,
[2:38:33]
the marina fund expenses increased by 401,000, was that dockstredging?
[2:38:40]
What was that attributed to? Do we know?
[2:38:46]
It was some of it was related to the dredging design and some of it was some of the electoral costs that we've undertaken to bring the power record.
[2:38:55]
Okay, and then Maz, you mentioned the capital projects fund, and it's showing a large deficit.
[2:39:08]
And I think it, from my notes, it's negative by about 14 million.
[2:39:15]
How do we get that on track? What do we do with that?
[2:39:20]
I actually had I have to take a look at the numbers to see how how that's being presented and whether that's is that enterprise funds or general
[2:39:31]
It's hard to track it in the report because there's there's different areas you can look, but there's no breakdown of it to see
[2:39:41]
Yeah, I can unfortunately I won't be able to answer that unless we look at the breakdowns and more detail
[2:39:46]
Okay,
[2:39:48]
and let me see if there's another one here
[2:40:00]
157, 157, let me find it.
[2:40:08]
157, which is page 49,
[2:40:15]
okay. In 2013, the general fund loan,
[2:40:19]
850,000 to the capital improvement fund. Why is this still showing outstanding?
[2:40:35]
Well, there was another, if you read further a little bit, fiscal year 2018, they approved another
[2:40:41]
advanced from the general fund to the capital of Prumet Fund,
[2:40:44]
it was issued for the following year.
[2:40:46]
So it might be the terms of that repayment is why it's required
[2:40:49]
to be listed, but I'd have to dive deeper into that.
[2:40:51]
Okay, and I'm not trying to put you on the spot.
[2:40:53]
Anything you can answer is helpful, but just some of these things
[2:40:57]
beg to question.
[2:40:58]
Okay, that's all I have.
[2:41:00]
Thank you very much.
[2:41:01]
Do we have questions from the public?
[2:41:05]
Anybody?
[2:41:08]
Nobody on line, madam.
[2:41:11]
Anybody here?
[2:41:12]
No, going once going twice counsel discussion. You know I have a couple more questions sure go ahead
[2:41:18]
So I don't know if this is Virginia or for grace
[2:41:22]
page three of three
[2:41:25]
so
[2:41:30]
At the bottom nine yeah page nine it says unusual or infrequent items so with the
[2:41:39]
The debt that has accumulated from BDI not paying the city with that be listed under unusual or infrequent items.
[2:41:52]
If very well could be, yes.
[2:41:55]
And what will happen is when we go through the next audit, the auditors will look at things, the last just questions,
[2:42:01]
and we may be determined that that needs to be pointed out as an unusual situation.
[2:42:05]
And I think so, because in the paragraph, it talks about governments are required to display
[2:42:13]
the inflows and outflows related to each unusual or infrequent item.
[2:42:19]
And so if you were to then display that, where would you display it so that the public would
[2:42:25]
understand where it is?
[2:42:29]
Well, anything that affects your economy, there's sections in here and there's actually
[2:42:35]
a couple places it could be placed, but given the large amount, I would recommend that it be
[2:42:40]
included going forward. And with the plan is, so that way when the investors look or the
[2:42:47]
bond market looks and sees why we have a $7 million debt, they know that we have a plan for it.
[2:42:51]
So that would be something I would highly recommend it for Spain does.
[2:42:54]
Okay, thank you for that.
[2:43:06]
Okay, so then on page 311, so under bank reconciliation,
[2:43:13]
So
[2:43:16]
the recommendation is that the city staff should make the preparation review of monthly bank
[2:43:21]
reconciliations a priority. So it sounds like that wasn't always done, but you're
[2:43:31]
providing that now as a monthly
[2:43:37]
yeah we've conducted numerous bank reconciliations since I've been here and I know they were
[2:43:43]
behind it by quite a few. Okay, so then I'm curious, when someone knows you money, that's
[2:43:51]
not in your bank account and you're spending this money. How does that all kind of line
[2:43:57]
up in your bank reconciliation? Well, the bank reconciliation is just a monthly check-in
[2:44:03]
to make sure that you've accounted for everything. It doesn't really describe what's going
[2:44:07]
on or how it's going on. It just shows that when you get your bank statement that your
[2:44:11]
financials internally they line up so kind of like you're checking account every month maybe you just make sure you know
[2:44:16]
Every dollar lines up, but it doesn't explain exactly how you spent or why you spent it. Yeah, sometimes though when you send it
[2:44:23]
Check to someone and then they don't cash it and you're trying to reconcile and
[2:44:28]
That should be noted that you have a receivable that you're waiting on and that that's included in the financial state
[2:44:33]
But if it's categorized correctly
[2:44:36]
Okay, thank you
[2:44:37]
Thank you, sir
[2:44:39]
All right.
[2:44:40]
That's it for this.
[2:44:40]
In an else last minute.
[2:44:42]
Postments.
[2:44:43]
Okay.
[2:44:46]
So can I get a first and second to accept the fiscal year 2425 audit reports?
[2:44:54]
Submoved.
[2:44:54]
Submoved.
[2:44:56]
All in favor?
[2:44:58]
S-S-S-S-S-S-S-S-S-S-S-S
[2:45:00]
I was talking the same thing. We were called for public comment earlier, you're just supposed to guess in here.
[2:45:09]
Do you want to allow another public comment?
[2:45:16]
Okay, I did call for public comment and there was no one responded, but come on
[2:45:27]
up.
[2:45:29]
And that's why I'm here.
[2:45:33]
So I was glad to see 2025 audit at financials.
[2:45:39]
But, and I commend the staff for getting four years of financials done in ten months,
[2:45:48]
but that should have never happened. Never happened. This is why we are a mess
[2:45:55]
because of these financials not getting filed on time. Bank reconciliation, journal entries,
[2:46:04]
This accruals are all fundamentals.
[2:46:10]
They are fundamentals.
[2:46:12]
I can tell you in the public sector, if that didn't happen, we would be fired.
[2:46:22]
This is terrible.
[2:46:24]
We need to get our act together.
[2:46:29]
You should all be aware of significant deficiencies and material weaknesses.
[2:46:35]
That is like the F word, it's awful.
[2:46:42]
We need to stay on top of these financials.
[2:46:45]
You guys should be getting a monthly report.
[2:46:48]
Is the bank record, this is what I would ask for, is the bank record done or the financial
[2:46:53]
is done.
[2:46:54]
You need to know that.
[2:46:56]
Do you know what the cash balance was at the end of September of 26?
[2:47:02]
Any of you?
[2:47:04]
Has that even been published?
[2:47:06]
It should be if you got the bank racks all reconciled.
[2:47:10]
You should know that.
[2:47:13]
And then while I get all this stuff is a lot of work,
[2:47:19]
But then you commend everybody.
[2:47:21]
You thank them for a job well done.
[2:47:25]
And in the cover letter attached to the financials,
[2:47:30]
we would also like to thank the city council
[2:47:32]
for their continued support in interest in maintaining
[2:47:35]
the highest professional standards in the planning
[2:47:37]
and management of the city's finances.
[2:47:40]
Our financials are a mess.
[2:47:43]
We need to get those.
[2:47:44]
You guys don't even know where to look.
[2:47:47]
The question you asked about the 7.3 million that the developer has ran up and they still
[2:47:56]
OS, that column needs to be relabeled because we don't know who the developer is.
[2:48:05]
It just says developer, deposit funds, big deficit in 25 of 7.3 million.
[2:48:12]
What is it today?
[2:48:14]
Can you tell me that?
[2:48:15]
Is it out the same?
[2:48:18]
Have we received any funds?
[2:48:20]
Yes.
[2:48:21]
They've paid. How much have they paid?
[2:48:24]
They've paid in a crude.
[2:48:26]
Pardon me?
[2:48:27]
They've paid in a crude.
[2:48:29]
I want what how much cash that they give us.
[2:48:31]
I don't care about the accrual.
[2:48:33]
We didn't get the money if it's a crude.
[2:48:36]
The last payment from BDI was approximately 1.2 million.
[2:48:40]
Yeah. So we've lost a ton of interest income on this cash. This is, it's unacceptable.
[2:48:48]
It really is.
[2:48:55]
That's it. Thank you.
[2:48:57]
Thank you, Mary.
[2:49:01]
Again, can I get a first and second to accept the fiscal year 20, 24, 20, 25 audit reports?
[2:49:09]
I make a motion.
[2:49:10]
second. All in favor. Hi. Hi. Anyone opposed? No.
[2:49:18]
Next we have item R receive a monthly financial
[2:49:21]
and investment report. Staff report please.
[2:49:27]
Hello again.
[2:49:31]
Someone piggybacking on some of
[2:49:33]
the deficiencies found in the the financial reporting and such a minute I got here as a city manager
[2:49:39]
asking me to start producing monthly reports, which has been done at times, but in consistent
[2:49:46]
over the previous period.
[2:49:48]
So we got you a report for this month, and there's two reports here.
[2:49:52]
There's the investment, and then there's the financial, I'll caveat the financial by saying
[2:49:57]
that there's really nothing here for you to digest because we're at the beginning of the fiscal
[2:50:01]
year.
[2:50:01]
We receive really no revenues from property tax or sales tax, but as part of financial reporting,
[2:50:07]
you should be letting you know that every month.
[2:50:09]
And so this is a baseline of what will be bringing to you.
[2:50:13]
And we'll also be giving you some analysis
[2:50:14]
of sales tax, property taxes, the major revenues.
[2:50:18]
So you know what's going on.
[2:50:19]
And that'll be included in a monthly report.
[2:50:21]
But I do admit this first version
[2:50:23]
is not the standard I'd like to see you get to,
[2:50:27]
but it's a start.
[2:50:29]
The second is the monthly investment report,
[2:50:31]
which is a little more informative.
[2:50:34]
It did write a review of September
[2:50:36]
or talking about the status of some of your investments
[2:50:38]
and how you're performing. And so you have that information as well. So that coupled with the monthly report,
[2:50:45]
should get you on a good track of foundation for making transparent financial information available.
[2:50:52]
And then what I do recommend is also doing quarterly reports where you have these on consent every month,
[2:50:58]
but every quarter, then you do a discussion just like we just had over the audited statements about what's going on.
[2:51:03]
why is this why is that and that's good practice that's best practices so by the time I
[2:51:09]
right off into the sunset I hope to have you set up with the system that you you can use and
[2:51:15]
be helpful to the residents in yourself so I'm happy to answer any questions about the budget
[2:51:18]
report and the the investment report that concludes my presentation thank you council member or
[2:51:24]
April, Tim Davis. No questions. And Councilmember O'Connell? No questions. Thank you for the clarity.
[2:51:34]
Okay. Councilmember Kern.
[2:51:37]
Thank you again, Jimmy. It feels like we're getting back on track here. I was excited to see the report.
[2:51:41]
But as you, as you stated, it's not that informative this early in the in the fiscal year.
[2:51:46]
Can you just remind me again when we see the influx of the property taxes again?
[2:51:50]
with things twice a year we see it. When is that? I believe I'm a little out of touch, but I think it's December and April.
[2:51:56]
Thank you. Okay. Thank you.
[2:52:01]
And councilmember Lance?
[2:52:07]
I don't think my question is really the budget report related, but I did want to ask you this question, Jimmy.
[2:52:12]
And I do appreciate how you've dove into our finances and wanting to administer best practices.
[2:52:26]
We need to do that and yeah we need to do that.
[2:52:30]
Right, right, the ship.
[2:52:34]
I want to know how, you know, okay,
[2:52:38]
a couple of weeks ago, the amount
[2:52:41]
that VDIO does for $7 million. And a week later, it was $7.2 and now it's at $7.4.6. Is that $7.6? And I just, I want to
[2:53:04]
You know, obviously we're going to be dealing with it on Monday, BDI might be watching this meeting.
[2:53:10]
I hope that they make a payment to the city of Brisbane for the money that they owe us.
[2:53:16]
But we need to have greater transparency in how we award contracts, I think.
[2:53:22]
And I do have a second question for you.
[2:53:25]
So, I believe that the authority to spend from staff is about $200,000, okay, city manager.
[2:53:34]
Okay, so if there's a company A, they have a proposal of $150,000, city manager has authority to sign off on that.
[2:53:46]
If company A comes back with a different project in its $150,000,
[2:53:53]
Is that considered 300,000 or is that just another 150 and you sign up on that?
[2:54:02]
Let's see the short answer. It depends. I don't know if you want to add to it.
[2:54:08]
It really does and if it's what you're looking for is really blatant circumvision.
[2:54:16]
So if you have a contract for $199,000 and then two months later for similar work,
[2:54:22]
you get another one for 100 grand, you got a problem.
[2:54:26]
Typically, though, if it's a different project,
[2:54:28]
different work, just because it goes to the same vendor,
[2:54:31]
wouldn't violate your purchasing policy.
[2:54:34]
So, but there's gray area there, right?
[2:54:36]
I'd certainly agree with you there.
[2:54:37]
Okay, yeah, I just think that you know,
[2:54:39]
is having greater transparency in that area,
[2:54:42]
especially with this accumulation of staggering debt
[2:54:47]
from a developer who wants us to approve
[2:54:52]
their specific plan based upon the world that we've done in order for them to get that approval.
[2:54:59]
I think it's warranted, so thank you.
[2:55:02]
I think perhaps and maybe that's getting into discussion a little bit,
[2:55:10]
but besides actual contracts,
[2:55:12]
I think there's ongoing staff time, there's legal time.
[2:55:18]
There's a lot of other things that are going into the additional because we're in the hearings and we're putting a lot of
[2:55:30]
resource
[2:55:31]
into moving these hearings forward. There is extra cost that is coming in on every meeting and every day while they're working on things for us to try to process the request.
[2:55:49]
I get that.
[2:55:51]
And you know, we had just, when you go from 770 into an hour seven point six and
[2:56:00]
I'm out of about a few weeks, that's six hundred thousand dollars.
[2:56:03]
That's not chump change.
[2:56:06]
And we need to have pressure in the gas emissions.
[2:56:10]
And when they're good build.
[2:56:11]
Absolutely.
[2:56:12]
And I don't think there's any reason why we can't have that be day-lighted so that we understand
[2:56:18]
and how our own personal finances are impacted by that, because they are.
[2:56:26]
Jimmy,
[2:56:29]
conventional aging spreadsheet, 30, 60, 90, 120, 180, could we please have that maybe
[2:56:39]
for our public hearing on Monday related to the money's owed by BDI. So it's very clear what's
[2:56:47]
past do and how far past do those expenses are for reimbursement to the city.
[2:56:56]
The information is there, how I can extract it, I'm not sure, but it's an expectation
[2:57:03]
that we should be able to make.
[2:57:05]
Well, I'm assuming you've applied payments to invoices.
[2:57:10]
So remaining outstanding invoices by invoice date to the developer, we should be able
[2:57:16]
to line that up to see,
[2:57:20]
is there anything current or are they all past
[2:57:24]
too? But I would like to have that document prepared for that Monday meeting.
[2:57:29]
Could you provide that? I can't guarantee that I can.
[2:57:33]
Would you try? I can try. Okay. And I can get you something of value,
[2:57:38]
but that's probably a lot of data. And again, I'm not fully confident in the system.
[2:57:43]
able to do that but I'll look into it and I'll get you some answer. Okay, and if you can't get it
[2:57:49]
before Monday, could you just try to expedite that for us? Sure. It would be extremely valuable,
[2:57:55]
I think. Okay.
[2:57:59]
Any public comments?
[2:58:02]
Chris.
[2:58:12]
It's a little difficult to conceive that
[2:58:17]
this debt has been growing over years and no report has been made to the city council about this.
[2:58:25]
It's also difficult to understand how it is that we treated BDI differently from any of the
[2:58:32]
other relationships that we have similar to this.
[2:58:36]
Why, for they not expected to provide the money up front, how did that happen, is the question
[2:58:43]
that I have.
[2:58:52]
It's bewildering quite frankly that so much is but I choose the word
[2:58:57]
suppressed implies intention and I'm hoping there was no intention to mislead or
[2:59:04]
misrepresent the situation to city council but it's certainly a question in my mind.
[2:59:11]
Anyone else? Yes, Mary.
[2:59:21]
In addition to the analysis that you are
[2:59:25]
questioning that a mayor about going back and trying to understand all the details underlying
[2:59:31]
the 7.0 point, whatever it is 7.6 million, you should also calculate the interesting
[2:59:36]
income lost and ask them to pay that. It's concerning that these guys aren't paying and we are
[2:59:45]
headed toward signing a huge agreement, the specific plan. I mean, I don't trust them. They
[2:59:54]
haven't paid. They haven't paid much. I would be really worried about that.
[3:00:00]
In fact, I think the past city manager Robin Leider mentioned, we should just get a huge upfront from them.
[3:00:11]
We're not going to do any work until you pay your debt and give us a prepaid, right?
[3:00:19]
I mean, they want the specific plan signed, right? We need them to pay their bills.
[3:00:26]
This is a fact of this I don't know how this has gotten past you guys. I do not this is just mind-boggling
[3:00:37]
And not just you, I mean you guys, it's us. We're pretty that lives here in Brisbane. We're getting screwed by these guys
[3:00:45]
It should be should not accept that and we should
[3:00:48]
You know
[3:00:49]
demand that going forward, you're going to have to give us an upfront payment, that keeps
[3:00:57]
our financial solid.
[3:01:00]
That's 7.6 million.
[3:01:03]
It's gone.
[3:01:05]
It's not in our bank account.
[3:01:06]
We need a back.
[3:01:09]
Also, I forgot to mention, our financials, the audit report still says,
[3:01:19]
We have a five-year and ten-year plan.
[3:01:24]
We do not. I asked that before.
[3:01:27]
We don't have a consolidated plan.
[3:01:30]
The monthly financials that we're pulling together,
[3:01:35]
they're not consolidated.
[3:01:37]
There's three different sheets, three different PNLs.
[3:01:41]
You guys need to see it on a consolidated basis.
[3:01:45]
You need to see the revenue coming in.
[3:01:49]
And you need to see the expenses going out.
[3:01:53]
You need to understand why certain expenses went up,
[3:01:56]
why certain expenses go down.
[3:01:58]
Numbers, you know, they're nice,
[3:02:01]
but you don't have the variance explanation with it.
[3:02:05]
You need that.
[3:02:08]
So there's still work that need to be done.
[3:02:11]
I have a question for a guest, Jimmy.
[3:02:14]
on the P&L, you have the budget and actual, the report, that's in the agenda.
[3:02:24]
I don't know if it's your to date or if it's month to date, that's not labeled.
[3:02:33]
I would be happy to be with you offline.
[3:02:36]
I don't know if that makes a difference for everybody.
[3:02:37]
Well, I'm not in a position to answer that question and I'm not used to
[3:02:42]
This exchange so I'm not prepared. Okay
[3:02:47]
Okay, okay, so that I mean that's just something to look for anyway. Thanks
[3:02:58]
Right 930 where we're in the current we're going to need a I'm sorry Chris. We're gonna need a motion. Motion to extend 15 minutes. Second
[3:03:08]
All in favor. Hi anyone opposed no go ahead
[3:03:12]
Okay. Thank you. Where in that report that you were presented tonight that is supposed to show you what the current situation is?
[3:03:20]
Where do you see the debt that we have with BDI on that report? How does that report help you understand that?
[3:03:28]
It is listed.
[3:03:30]
It is listed.
[3:03:32]
And it is clearly identified what it is.
[3:03:35]
The two page report.
[3:03:38]
Clearly listed. It shows. Yes.
[3:03:42]
Terry, she's speaking to the budget report, not the audit.
[3:03:50]
The rash balances and investments.
[3:03:52]
There's the negative 73-665-661.
[3:03:58]
Do you know what that is?
[3:04:00]
If you didn't know about this, would you know what it is from that report?
[3:04:05]
Okay.
[3:04:07]
Any other comments from the Public City Clerk?
[3:04:13]
So, I would, no, okay, so Jimmy,
[3:04:18]
President Suggestion from Mary Rogers,
[3:04:21]
if you can produce an aging, could you potentially work
[3:04:25]
on the interest loss that we've had over the duration
[3:04:31]
of these monies being allocated and not reimbursed?
[3:04:35]
That's possible, yes?
[3:04:37]
Okay, I would appreciate that as well.
[3:04:38]
All right, so that being said, can we get a first and second to receive the monthly financial
[3:04:46]
investment report for September 2026?
[3:04:50]
So moved, second.
[3:04:51]
All in favor?
[3:04:52]
Aye.
[3:04:53]
When opposed?
[3:04:55]
Next item on our agenda.
[3:04:57]
City managers reports, the updates and upcoming activities.
[3:05:01]
Thank you.
[3:05:01]
I will focus on upcoming activities.
[3:05:08]
November 7th from 9 to 10, 30, Council Member Kern is holding his autumn office hours in the
[3:05:14]
believe the sunrise room. Yes. The POW flag flown in U.S. flags on visitation for veterans
[3:05:21]
day 11, 11 will be flown at November 11, 2026 at 730. I'll ask you, excuse me, the flag will be
[3:05:31]
out there from 730 a.m. to 730 p.m. Public Works will be putting the flags out. The state of the
[3:05:36]
City is delivered by the mayor. We'll be held in this room November 18th, 2026 at 530 and
[3:05:44]
the reminder will be close for Thanksgiving. Thank you.
[3:05:49]
Mayor Council matters proposed city council meeting schedule 2026 and 27.
[3:05:58]
We have a staff report. Is this a discussion?
[3:06:02]
What's the matter may I'm just going to have angel post the schedule up?
[3:06:09]
We have all of Bayland's hearings already in your outlook calendars.
[3:06:15]
We did want to propose December 7th because the mayor and city council wanted to meet before the re-org.
[3:06:24]
So that's going to be an additional meeting that I'm going to add to your calendar as well.
[3:06:29]
Is this a firm meeting date or just tentative because the paper I have shows tentative?
[3:06:34]
Well, all the meetings you wanted to call be a lens tentative meetings so they're all
[3:06:39]
technically tucked to. But after that would be the re-org special meeting on December
[3:06:46]
10th, and then the proposed cancellation December 17th.
[3:06:50]
Okay, so there's no action on this. And then following would be just a schedule for 2027.
[3:06:58]
If you scroll down and that would be just your first meeting starting January 7th.
[3:07:02]
okay.
[3:07:05]
Madam, I have a question. Sure. So the November 23 meeting is tentative.
[3:07:14]
I brought
[3:07:14]
up public safety as an item for Council to discuss. I don't know as I guess that is tonight
[3:07:21]
where you would say Council do we want to put that into the November 23 tentative meeting slot.
[3:07:30]
I don't know, how do we add things if we want to add them?
[3:07:37]
Isn't it the case that during the public hearing we can... we're discussing the schedule, so that's just why I brought it up?
[3:07:53]
Just looking at how this item was agendized, I think it would make more sense to discuss if you're interested in adding additional discussion on the bail-ins.
[3:08:01]
The project, I think it would make more sense to discuss that the upcoming bail-ins hearing, which I keep getting the day-long is Monday.
[3:08:09]
Okay, that makes sense because this isn't an action item and we would be giving action. Okay, perfect. Thank you. That's probably what you were getting at right. Yes, okay.
[3:08:20]
Okay, anyone else? Scouts related? No.
[3:08:26]
Future agenda items. Is there any future agenda items being proposed? I have one. I would like staff to bring back a
[3:08:36]
a cost for what a traffic study on B-shore might be as it pertains to us being able to advance the B-A-V-A planning.
[3:08:51]
I realize that in prior meetings we have, well, actually the report from Good City has referenced a study that took place in 2015, which estimates the traffic on B-shore.
[3:09:05]
and that study is obviously more than 10 years old and I think in our discussions we have
[3:09:14]
really talked about what is possible or not possible given the amount of traffic on
[3:09:21]
Bayshore and because that information is not updated I don't think that we as a council
[3:09:27]
or the subcommittee really has the information needed to evaluate what are truly viable uses for
[3:09:38]
that site if they include commercial. And I understand that the subcommittee didn't move forward
[3:09:46]
with the other traffic study. And so I think this kind of study gives us really important information
[3:09:54]
for us to be getting advancing those conversations. So I don't want to get into that. I just
[3:09:59]
that's the reason why I'm asking. So maybe at a future meeting and of course another council
[3:10:05]
member has to support this but in a future council meeting you could bring back what the cost might be
[3:10:09]
and the council can talk about whether this study makes sense to pursue.
[3:10:18]
Okay. Anyone else? Yeah, I'll piggyback on that to have it be agendas. And then I do have
[3:10:26]
something that, so I was talking with Council Member Kern about forming a Bailey and
[3:10:34]
transportation ad hoc. And I don't know if that's, is that the place that you, that we
[3:10:39]
talk about that under future agenda items? Or do we bring that back on the ninth and on the
[3:10:47]
okay if we could put that then on the nine so we can talk about that. Anyone else?
[3:10:55]
Okay I'm going to bring up something and it has nothing to do with you.
[3:11:00]
Mayor Proke. We have designated places for political science during election cycles
[3:11:09]
and the area across from the gazebo this year.
[3:11:14]
I have no words to describe, I would like to consider amending our ordinance about posting
[3:11:23]
a political science to put a limitation on how many individual signs can be posted.
[3:11:29]
Candidate or measure because this year this was out of control and it was beyond an
[3:11:37]
sore and stretching all the way around the curve. Would anyone else
[3:11:41]
like to support that? Yes. And my signs were I had to and they were
[3:11:45]
stolen. I understand. And so it's much easier also to keep track.
[3:11:51]
Ingrid has to keep track of what is allowable or not allowable and I would
[3:11:56]
assume as in the past where people had used to be one or two signs and now it's
[3:12:01]
five six. I counted eight from one person. Exactly. What any you would support this? So could we please
[3:12:08]
consider tightening up that order? We're happy to. We're just doing a little side. We are doing a little sidebar here
[3:12:14]
talking about it in between the two of us. We don't know what we can do vis-à-vis limiting the number of
[3:12:19]
signs. There's a first amendment set of issues too, but we'll come back with something for you. Okay,
[3:12:24]
thank you. We appreciate it. All right. Any no more future agenda items? We're down to counting
[3:12:30]
Why do assignments subcommittee reports who'd like to start?
[3:12:35]
I do not have any.
[3:12:37]
I had an airport land use committee meeting.
[3:12:44]
And we discussed some of the changes in specific plans.
[3:12:50]
Downtown specific plans for different cities that they're changing.
[3:12:55]
That we've already heard and they're changing them.
[3:12:57]
And nothing exciting, just usual business.
[3:13:03]
Okay, Mayor Pocha, nothing for me.
[3:13:06]
Council Member Kerr.
[3:13:07]
Thank you so much, Madam Mayor.
[3:13:09]
I'm happy to announce on October 23rd.
[3:13:11]
I attended the ribbon cutting in Pasca Daryl
[3:13:14]
for the County Library's new hybrid bookmobile.
[3:13:18]
Why is this important?
[3:13:19]
Not only is it an amazing new bookmobile,
[3:13:22]
but it runs on batteries so there isn't a generator
[3:13:25]
spewing out exhaust gases when the kids are trying to look at books. So it's an amazingly quiet
[3:13:31]
and clean experience for the kids now so that you'll see that driving around it's going to come
[3:13:35]
to Brisbane. I forgot which date but we'll get that out. Thanks. So we extended the meeting by 15 minutes.
[3:13:42]
We needed another extension to get the motion to extend. Let's say 10 minutes and it won't be 10.
[3:13:49]
So moved.
[3:13:51]
How's second?
[3:13:52]
All in favor.
[3:13:53]
Hi.
[3:13:54]
Anyone opposed?
[3:13:56]
Anyone else report?
[3:13:59]
Okay.
[3:14:00]
Prepare yourself.
[3:14:01]
I haven't made a report for a while.
[3:14:03]
Westlight energy.
[3:14:04]
We had a board retreat.
[3:14:06]
This was on the 22nd.
[3:14:08]
Went way late in the evening.
[3:14:10]
I got a home after midnight.
[3:14:12]
This was about energy business in general.
[3:14:16]
the number of community choice, energy consortiums in California, it's really growing, it used
[3:14:22]
to be along the coast only and now it's starting to go into the Central Valley, which is a big
[3:14:28]
departure. There's now 36% of California counties have community choice consortiums. We were
[3:14:36]
advised about procuring renewal of energy contracts in the future. May result put your brakes on
[3:14:43]
doubling of cost because everybody with data centers is going after electricity and you might
[3:14:50]
say well let's just get more clean power going and here's the problem and I bet you could
[3:14:57]
will give me the answer in advance.
[3:15:00]
The delays in getting new projects up and running are due to tariffs, partially and also, PG&E delays, right,
[3:15:11]
connection and distribution. And we were advised that PG&E is also renewing some of their contracts
[3:15:18]
and they prioritize their allowed by law to prioritize connecting their own projects above everyone
[3:15:26]
So there's great lobbying being done by the clean energy
[3:15:30]
consortiums in Sacramento hoping with changes going on from
[3:15:35]
the selection that there will be some new guidelines.
[3:15:39]
And that will maybe in the future not be allowed.
[3:15:44]
Again, Terry, thank you, supply chain shortages tariffs.
[3:15:48]
In terms of power because everyone asks this, you know,
[3:15:51]
What about wind?
[3:15:52]
Wind is now extremely rare because the current administration is anti-win.
[3:15:57]
Geothermal takes eons to develop, although it's a good source.
[3:16:01]
The emphasis is still on solar and yet supply change sort of just same problem there.
[3:16:09]
So the emphasis right now with Westlight and every energy consortium community based is trying
[3:16:17]
keep it affordable and sustainable and it's going to be challenging because a lot of contracts
[3:16:24]
have been in place for 10 years and they're off and 10 or 15 year contracts they have to get renewed.
[3:16:31]
C.K. had a meeting on eighth and this is a short report because you already heard from Jeff
[3:16:36]
tonight. We had a report from Taltrain. They continued to increase ridership. The fairs they said
[3:16:43]
are still not adequate to fund operations.
[3:16:45]
They cited that they have 77 miles and 31 stations across 20 communities to maintain.
[3:16:53]
And that really is challenging.
[3:16:55]
The electrification for your edification is now in its second year.
[3:17:00]
At grade crossings are still presenting a safety hazard, and I was horrified to learn.
[3:17:06]
They had a big problem with cars turning on to tracks.
[3:17:10]
I thought it was just people, but it's cars.
[3:17:13]
But what they did is they installed what are called delineators.
[3:17:17]
I'm sure if Moss was here, he would know that what that is, and they've had no incidents
[3:17:21]
since.
[3:17:22]
There are 10 at-grade crossings on the Cal Train system that in the future are going to have
[3:17:28]
to be dealt with.
[3:17:29]
Those are very expensive to remedy.
[3:17:32]
So you've already heard about the San Mateo Countywide Transportation Plan update.
[3:17:37]
And if you can catch it, that list is submitted to A-Bag to determine feasibility for funding.
[3:17:44]
It's really important.
[3:17:45]
That's all I have in a report.
[3:17:49]
And Parkside 2 is on this list and we've had no meetings because of the number of bail-ance meetings that we're having.
[3:17:56]
And also trying to, we're still trying to find out what funding is left over from the Good City's contract.
[3:18:04]
And we still don't have an answer.
[3:18:06]
Because you guessed about that last time, Mayor Pro Tem.
[3:18:10]
City Clerk, do we have any written communication?
[3:18:13]
Yes.
[3:18:14]
So written communication was received from Chiang, the request for reconsideration or approval
[3:18:19]
of amendment to reimbursement, residents of Sierra Point Mobile Home Park and residents
[3:18:24]
of Brisbane, California, concerns regarding traffic and community impacts associated with Amazon
[3:18:29]
on Bashar Boulevard.
[3:18:31]
Moors regarding the upcoming event, notice, 16th annual 5K Turkey Trout for Charity, and
[3:18:37]
law regarding Mayma and electronics about the war notice.
[3:18:44]
Okay, thank you, oral communications number two.
[3:18:48]
Do we have any members of the public wishing to make public comment?
[3:18:52]
Michelle.
[3:18:56]
There is a lot of tough conversations, and especially about the finances and the situation
[3:19:02]
that we ended up being so far behind in our financial statements, and I feel really sad about
[3:19:10]
that and really unhappy about that, especially since we have brilliant new staff that are taking
[3:19:18]
the heat for what has happened well before their tenure. And I just want to commend them for
[3:19:31]
and getting us back on track and a little horrified that they inherited this blind side and
[3:19:40]
I just I have a really hard time with it and I'm so sorry that this is happening for
[3:19:47]
and then and everybody's taking a heat for something that has been going on for quite a while apparently.
[3:19:53]
So I just want to thank the current staff and tell you how much is a citizen of Brisbane.
[3:19:58]
I appreciate the honesty and candor of the staff that we have now and the transparency that we are going forward with and this council for
[3:20:09]
absorbing that and taking it to heart and working on a solution. It's really serious what has happened.
[3:20:18]
It's heartbreaking, but we're going to get past it and we're going to be better for it. So thank you.
[3:20:25]
Any other public comments?
[3:20:26]
No
[3:20:31]
Hazards, Madam Mayor.
[3:20:33]
Okay, this meeting is adjourned at 9.48 p.m. Thank you.
[3:20:37]
Do we need to announce that we are adjourning into back into our closed session?
[3:20:48]
No, but it's not required, but sure.