Cambria Town, NY meeting

Cambria Town, NY · More Cambria Town, NY meetings · More New York meetings

Transcript

Download: Text · SRT ·
AI TRANSCRIPT

This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.

[0:00] All for
[0:17] coming tonight. Would you please join me in our pledge to pray.
[0:26] The budget agency to the parade, put the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, in which it is all with liberty and justice for all.
[0:54] I'm just a kid, Mr. President. I can't tell you this, but I'm 100 people outside.
[1:04] Okay, I would like to clerk to read the established rules, okay, I won't do that.
[1:15] I'm going to ask the clerk to read the established rules and procedures for Tana Cambria Board
[1:20] Meeting.
[1:21] Adopted January 3, 1980.
[1:37] Well, let's try to get a microphone against it, right?
[1:41] Oh, look here, here, but he has to hear.
[1:43] That's relax.
[1:44] We're going to work on it.
[1:45] This will be the one.
[1:47] Yes, please.
[1:57] Oh, I got a scotch tape.
[2:12] I would like to ask the clerk to read the established rules of procedure for town board meetings
[2:19] about the January 3rd, 1980.
[2:23] Number one matters to be discussed must be on the agenda.
[2:27] Number two supervisor may permit additional matters to be discussed after all matters on
[2:31] the agenda have been active on.
[2:33] Number three, the supervisor may set aside the agenda to permit those in the audience
[2:38] to address the board.
[2:40] Number four, no member of the public shall engage in any demonstration, booing, hand
[2:44] clapping, or otherwise disrupt the formality of the town board meetings.
[2:49] Number five, no member of the public shall be permitted to address the town board unless
[2:53] recognized by the supervisor.
[2:55] In no event may any such person speak on one occasion for more than five minutes.
[3:00] Number six, any person speaking to the town board with the consent of the supervisor
[3:05] shall address his or her remarks to the town board, not to other members of the audience.
[3:11] Number seven, any person recognized bless you by the supervisor shall give his name
[3:16] and the nature of his business briefly.
[3:18] Number eight, no person has the right to demand an answer to a specific question from a member
[3:23] of the board.
[3:24] All such questions shall be directed to the supervisor who may answer them himself bless you or refer
[3:29] questions to the town attorney or to a town board member of his choice.
[3:34] I'm sorry, can I ask a question?
[3:36] Yes.
[3:37] A lot of those say about the supercure.
[3:42] When we get to that, we'll have an explanation for the meeting.
[3:46] Okay?
[3:47] He's not here at this point.
[3:52] At this time, our town attorney, a plant, would like to speak.
[4:00] There are a lot of people here.
[4:02] A lot of... I'm sure there's a lot of...
[4:04] No, he wanted questions.
[4:06] This obviously is not really a place or a set up for a back and forth,
[4:11] so I would like to go line by line through what's being proposed,
[4:16] provide an explanation or rationale for the change,
[4:19] and just to give more background information on this project in general,
[4:23] before we open the public hearing.
[4:26] So this is really regard to the first local law
[4:34] that is on the agenda, the E-code Law.
[4:40] So on E-code, what this was was about two years ago
[4:45] in mid-2023, the town of Canberra decided
[4:50] to retain general code services
[4:54] to do a codification of its various laws.
[4:58] up until that point, the town's laws are passed sort of piecemeal, half passively, local
[5:07] laws, ordinances, they aren't really organized. So, Cane re-decided to codify them, basically
[5:16] putting them in an organized and slightly repeated form, which is what most municipalities
[5:35] I've got to read, so I'll do the best I can to raise your hand I'll try to do the best I can, but I'm going to try to read to you to try to read from the actual document.
[5:47] So backing up, 2023, the prior administration, the prior
[5:51] town attorney, the town planner decided to undertake this project
[5:56] of codifying the town's various laws, ordinances, local laws.
[6:02] So that is easier for everyone to research, to find a point of law.
[6:08] Because without the codification, what you're left is you're left
[6:11] to try to go to the website or the books, and there are plenty,
[6:15] Each ordinance, each local law had its own animal.
[6:21] It was very cumbersome, and this is, again,
[6:25] to simplify the way you can access the laws that govern the town.
[6:31] So what ECO does is they have a legal team,
[6:34] they have a team that this is what they do.
[6:37] No, you're good.
[6:38] All right.
[6:39] This is what they do.
[6:40] They go through the town's history of laws.
[6:43] us, they organize them as they're organizing them, they're organizing them alphabetically,
[6:48] which makes sense.
[6:50] So start with animals, you go down to zone.
[6:52] So again, even that is a simple little stuff to do.
[6:56] So as they're filtering through, they are taking the sections and ordinances, the sections
[7:02] and local laws, and they're converting them to the town code.
[7:05] So they're re-signing chapter numbers, they're re-signing section numbers, they're organizing.
[7:10] As they are organizing the substantive parts of the law, the meat of the law, they are flagging
[7:17] for the town, areas that are either inconsistent, outdated, or could need revision for a number
[7:24] of reasons.
[7:25] So they perform this codification, and again they generate this list of flag items.
[7:33] They close these flag items to the town for consideration.
[7:37] The flag items were then at that point again in 2023, disseminated to the town attorney,
[7:43] to the town planner, the building department, the highway department, whoever would have
[7:46] the expertise to weigh in on what we should do, and on a consensus was made decision.
[7:53] We basically just at the end of last year, going into the beginning of this year, got through
[8:00] the process of formalizing all the decisions.
[8:03] So every issue that was flagged was either said no that's fine, we're going to leave it the way it is.
[8:09] Or if we have to make a choice because something is outdated, we choose at that point which way to go.
[8:16] The list of changes, so the list of changes is under Schedule A.
[8:21] So there are two aspects to the local law.
[8:24] One is to establish the town code, that's Article 1, the adoption of the code.
[8:27] that's basically just to adopt this format posted on lines and Tamra had the book.
[8:35] It's in a book if you want to still read a book but it's online, go online,
[8:39] it's a bunch easier. When you go to E-code, you'll see every town basically in New York State,
[8:45] it's on E-code. The second part is the schedule. Those are changes to the text of the ordinances,
[8:54] the taxes, the tax to the laws, those have to be incorporated, because we're passing
[8:59] a local law, those are changes that would be incorporated in this local law, and I'm
[9:05] going to go through each and every line item of the schedule A, so go understand why we're
[9:11] making that change, or what is even changing if anything.
[9:16] There are three main goals that the ECODE team tried to impress upon the town and three
[9:26] goals that were pursued by the town when considering these changes.
[9:29] One was to remove any mention of a set fee in these ordinances because the fees change
[9:38] over time.
[9:39] The town board has the authority to alter these fees.
[9:42] So they'll alter a fee, let's say you have an ordinance passed in 1975, it lists a fee from 1975.
[9:49] The town board might have passed the resolution, changing the fee several times since then.
[9:54] But if you go back to the law books, you've got the old ordinance.
[9:57] So a lot of the changes were to remove the set fee.
[10:01] So they're going forward.
[10:02] or any citation to a fee in the E code in the town code will refer to the town's
[10:10] the clerk's fee schedule and if you go online it should have a paper link so you can
[10:15] literally just click on it and see what 2025 or going forward with the fee schedule is
[10:20] so you'll always have an up-to-date idea you want it to say well this says it's 50 dollars
[10:25] here that was in 1980 I better call the clerk and see what it is you know 2025 so it's
[10:31] to remove those step fees, make it easier for people to understand what I would make extra
[10:35] phone calls. The second goal of ECODE was to remove internal citations. This zoning
[10:45] ordinance in particular was full of internal citations, citations, two different parts
[10:52] of itself, so that if you wanted an answer you would go, you would see this section, it
[10:57] would point you to this other section, you have to flip to that section, you have to read
[11:01] that, go back to the original section, the goal to remove the internal citations was to
[11:07] take out the reference to the other section and literally just print what you find on
[11:13] that page right there in the section. So it's designed to make it easier to read. The third
[11:20] Third was because a lot of these areas of law had, you know, there's enforcement mechanisms
[11:28] and penalties, and there were haphazardly sort of ad hoc put in the place over the years.
[11:34] There really is a wide variety of penalties.
[11:38] They're sort of all over the board and condensing and recodifying modernization in New York
[11:45] state basically, the modern municipalities have siloed a lot of these violations into
[11:51] basically two categories. One, your misdemeanor or your violation level. The state law sort
[11:57] of dictates what the max violation level offenses in terms of fine incarceration, et cetera.
[12:02] And misdemeanor, same thing, fine incarceration level. Depending on when the original law was
[12:10] pass there, you could be in the middle of both.
[12:13] So essentially what the code was trying to do
[12:16] was to standardize these penalties
[12:19] so that they made more sense.
[12:21] And you'll see examples of this as I go through.
[12:24] I can tell what issues were hot button issues in the year
[12:27] that the law was passed based on how high the penalties were.
[12:31] I think time has tamped down some of the temperatures there.
[12:36] But those are the three things you're
[12:37] going to hear a lot of, the hard.
[12:38] Getting rid of the internal citations and removing the set fees and standardizing penalties.
[12:46] So I will literally just want to, I don't know if you have counties of schedule A, starting
[12:50] at the top of schedule A, the first change.
[12:53] So now we are actually talking about changes to the law itself, not just the process by
[12:59] what it's codified.
[13:01] So Chapter 56, animals, there are two changes here.
[13:04] The animals, this is a local law from 2010, so it was passed in 2010.
[13:12] The first change, 565B, changes the fee from $18 to $21 wide, because since 20 times the
[13:18] state added a $3 fee that was enacted since 2010, we are providing them for the corporate
[13:25] debt of $3 fee.
[13:27] And since that time, $10 late fee was added if you are late time renewing your dog license.
[13:31] So that's incorporated in to this code since it's passed since 2010, chapter 63.
[13:40] So battery energy storage systems used to be housed under the zoning ordinance because
[13:46] the zoning ordinance was the closest thing that the town had to a compiled list of subjects.
[13:52] A lot went into the zoning ordinance.
[13:54] What this code is going is sort of breaking that out into its own chapter.
[13:58] So, what used to be sections in the zoning ordinance is now given its own chapter, chapter 63,
[14:03] the battery energy storage systems, section 63-12, there, you see the amendment there.
[14:09] That is to change the internal reference because in the zoning ordinance, it refers to a section of the zoning ordinance.
[14:17] Now that this has a new home in the code in chapter 63, it's changed to refer to in the code where you would find this, the penalty.
[14:26] So it literally is changing from a reference to the code, to reference to, you know, chapter 288 zoning section 288-125.
[14:35] That's where it's going to be in the code. This is a lot easier to explain if you're looking at it.
[14:39] But again, this change just directs you to where this section is now going to be in the code.
[14:45] Chapter 70, this is a building construction and fire prevention.
[14:49] This is a section 70-11A, so that everyone is following along.
[14:53] This is a codification of a local law that was passed in 2023.
[14:59] So this...
[15:00] Here has been on the books in the town of Cambridge for two years. The reason why it was changed in 2023 was because just before the talent implemented this, the New York State Building and Flair Code made these changes. So, with the codification of the local law in 2023, building, construction, flair, prevention, the code sections are now going to be broken down to chapter 70 instead of just shoehorned into the zoning ordinance, so that they're easier to identify if you have a building
[15:29] question you would have said to me, the change that's being implemented here is in the
[15:35] local law, the three areas where an inspection of a public area is required, so you have the
[15:45] assembly area, you have the schools and colleges, and then you have the all other non-residential
[15:49] occupancies. In the 2023 local law, it says at least once, and it gives a range up to 12
[15:56] months. In the law, it says up to 12 months for section 2, it says up to 12 months and
[16:02] for section 3, it says up to 36 months. The only change here is that the town is deciding
[16:08] we're going to set it to the max. We're just going to say 12 months, 12 months, 36 months
[16:13] because it had a range before. They're just picking 12, 12, 36 so that it's clear. As if you
[16:19] just look at the local law, it could be anywhere up to 12 months, 12 months, 36. So it's just
[16:25] It was codifying and cementing what the actual requirement is for a law that's been on the votes for two years.
[16:35] Chapter 102 flood damage prevention.
[16:37] This is a local law from 2028.
[16:39] At the time it was passed in 2028, there was a set fee.
[16:43] 2008.
[16:45] 2008.
[16:46] 2008.
[16:47] It was a $500 permit fee.
[16:49] What they're doing is you're removing that permit fee and you're just referring to the town clerk species.
[16:54] You're going to hear that a lot. We're removing a fee from 17 years ago and we're disreferring to the clerk.
[17:01] That was a lot of money back in 2008. I can't imagine what it is now.
[17:05] Chapter 109, freshwater wetlands. This is an interesting one because when the town implemented its freshwater wetlands protection code,
[17:15] It included a note from the DEC in the actual text that was enacted, and the note was instructions
[17:25] on how to go about the decision of making exceptions, additions, and modifications to the
[17:31] provision of the act.
[17:33] That was a note.
[17:34] It's like essentially staged directions.
[17:37] So they put the staged directions in the body of the bill.
[17:40] this just eliminates that help because it literally is an instruction to the
[17:45] town board and how to go about thinking about baking an exception when the
[17:50] case comes to it and it refers to the department's guidance from August 6th
[17:55] 1976 so it's completely unnecessary it was stage direction so they're taking
[18:00] it out because it's just confusing because it's that's direct to the town not
[18:04] of the reader. Chapter 116, games of chance. This was a 1981 ordinance that used to refer
[18:12] to the New York State Racing Wadering Board that no longer exists. They've updated their
[18:16] names to the New York State Gaming Commission. This amends that by updating the name.
[18:21] Chapter 127, mobile homes, mobile home partners. This was a 1975 ordinance. And I would imagine
[18:30] that in 1975 there were a lot of issues in the towns about mobile phone
[18:33] parks because they set some pretty high penalties. But Section 127-7V we're
[18:40] again removing the set license fee and just providing it as a fee set by board.
[18:47] 127-22A that updates the citation because they refer to it as the
[18:51] fire prevention ordinance. Right now that's been updated to the New York
[18:56] even for employer prevention and building. So again, it's just updating what it's referring
[19:01] to. Section 127, this is reducing the penalties for a violation of this section. That in 1975,
[19:13] if you have violated this section, the law allows for up to a $250 fine or incarceration for six months
[19:21] are both, that's one of these areas where the penalty sort of falls in between the violation
[19:27] level and the misdemeanor level, the New York State modern ordinances want to try to
[19:35] style one into the other. This is in the middle, so basically the town is deciding to reduce
[19:39] that potential penalty down to the violation level, which penalties for violations in New
[19:51] to the violation. Again, it was passed in 1975. Maybe it was a bigger deal back then but not
[19:58] so much anymore. Chapter 135, the noise ordinance. This was a 2010 local law and basically what they're
[20:07] doing is they had to choose between where to set this. This is one of these, there are penalties
[20:14] that were sort of not really in one or the other. They are assigning this sort as the violation level
[20:20] versus the misdemeanor level.
[20:22] So they're amending the penalties,
[20:25] the maximum penalty to be $250 fine
[20:29] or 15 days in jail versus the other decision was,
[20:31] we make this $1,000 fine or a year in jail.
[20:33] They decided to go on the violation side,
[20:35] so they're making it clear in the noise ordinance.
[20:40] Chapter 142, notification of defects.
[20:43] That's a 1991 local law that gave the town five,
[20:47] they gave the town highway superintendent five days
[21:02] The state law is now ten days, so they're emending it to conform to the state law, which is going for five days, ten days, and notice, that would mean it's not much to bring many people, but they're revising that for five days, the ten days, so that it, again, matches the state law.
[21:21] So the property maintenance code is such a 2013 local law, it was revised down to, you know, the violation level because this is another one that didn't really fit into either category.
[21:34] So it added the 15-day potential incarceration to the five.
[21:42] So again, the choice between $250,000 or $1,000 a year, property maintenance is, you know, it's not a misdemeanor level according to the town, so they're sending it at the violation.
[21:55] Chapter 1 has 73, the recreational vehicles, the parks camping grounds. This is a 1972 ordinance.
[22:01] The first change to 173.5 days to remove the set feed, again, in the set feed.
[22:08] And this was another one where the penalties were in between the two levels, so the town
[22:14] is amending to standardize this to the violation level, so you can violate the Rex Parking Camping
[22:21] Grounds section of the law.
[22:23] It's going to be $250 max times the days in jail, and that's revising it from $50 fine
[22:29] and 30 days in jail, which was the law, which was the law's test in 1992.
[22:34] Chapter 1, any one of the sewers in swoosh disposal.
[22:37] That's an 1985 ordinance.
[22:40] This is the first section to revise.
[22:43] It's going to make an internal citation manageable.
[22:49] This area is given a new section.
[22:51] It's referring to a new section in the code, so that literally is just to make it not
[22:57] referred to the old ordinance because we're going for the ordinance code. 1815S is
[23:03] again to update the New York State plumbing code which in 1985 perhaps they
[23:07] referred to it that way but we're updating it again here to the New York State
[23:11] plant fire pension building code section 181 that's again we we are taking here
[23:19] that we are going to land in the misdemeanor level here for violations of the
[23:24] sewer backflow, if you do a lot of damage with a sewer violation, so the town is amending
[23:32] to have a $1,000 fine in one year of tax incarceration, because this was one of these areas where
[23:37] it sort of fell in between, and then the last one there, section 181, 12, you were just
[23:43] removing the set fees again because for a frame to the town's fee schedule.
[23:49] So chapter 188, Solanar Two Systems, this is another area like the building co that used
[23:54] to be in the zoning ordinance, it's been broken out seven zone chapter. And again, like
[24:01] the battery energy storage system, its penalties are no longer referring to the zoning ordinance,
[24:06] it's referring to the new section of the zoning code, which is going to list one set of
[24:13] consistent penalties. So again, it's just pointing you to where the penalty section is going
[24:18] to be. Chapter 195, solid waste, the dumping section. It's a 1991 local law, a dumping must
[24:27] have been a big problem because the original law had this as a misdemeanor, so it's a thousand
[24:34] dollar fine in a year in jail. The town is lowering those maximum penalties down to the violation
[24:40] are 250 and 15. Article 2, this is an interesting one.
[24:46] 195, they aren't just the first one, it's meant to make the internal citations consistent
[24:54] again. We're referring to different parts of the code now and not to the ordinance.
[24:59] And they're reducing the, they're making, they're signing a violation level for the violation
[25:04] of the first section. So A there, B is the more serious violation. They are actually
[25:10] studying that at the misdemeanor level, the 1991 code set this as maximum six
[25:16] months in jail and up to a million dollar fine. The town is taking it down to a
[25:21] misdemeanor level and it's saying maximum of a year and a maximum of a thousand
[25:25] dollar fine. So that was again one of our trying to standardize some of these
[25:30] penalties. Chapter 224 on taxation. It's a 1985 local law. They have in
[25:39] In 1995, the state changed its real property tax law so that instead of 24 months, you had
[25:48] to wait for Title of S that went down to 12 so that the town's amending its law which
[25:52] is intended to mirror the real property tax law so we're going to 24 months to 12 again
[25:58] to match the New York State law which is a theme here.
[26:00] In 224-16 again this is an updated name here we've considered referring to the state board
[26:08] We're actually telling which modern agency we're referring to, which is the Commissioner
[26:12] of Taxation and Finance against the economic nature change.
[26:17] Chapter 231, the town owned property that's in 1981 ordinance.
[26:21] Again, they're just amending this to set it at the violation level.
[26:26] It was 250 and 30.
[26:28] So it was previously in between the two levels.
[26:32] Here, they're reducing the penalties, maximum penalties, down to 250 and 15 days a gallon.
[26:38] I mean, these are sentencing guidelines for a judge.
[26:43] So this just gives the judge a maximum range.
[26:46] So when a judge is considering, if you violated the town
[26:49] on property statute, and you were convicted,
[26:53] the judge has up to this range for either per penalty.
[26:56] So that's what we're talking about.
[27:00] Chapter 244, it was a traffic.
[27:02] This is a 1990 ordinance.
[27:04] This one has to do with the citations of the penalties for winter parking.
[27:11] Here where you're simply revising to point to this section of the vehicle and traffic law that dictates what the penalties are to make you clear that this is a vehicle and traffic infraction.
[27:21] And just so everyone knows, all vehicle and traffic infractions in the state of New York except for paperwork type tickets are either.
[27:29] their violations so that it's worth a dollar fine, 15 days in jail, that's how the state
[27:34] treats every violation of vehicle and traffic property maintenance, etc.
[27:41] Chapter 264 of the water ordinance, this is a 2018 ordinance, the first, the first change
[27:49] is again to remove those selfies, the second change is to change 30 days to one year because
[27:57] Because this was, again, one of these areas where the penalties didn't match the current
[28:03] long.
[28:03] So it went from $1,000 fine, 30 days in jail, to $1,000 fine, and one year in jail.
[28:10] And the reason why it makes a difference is because when you go from a violation to a misdemeanor,
[28:15] a violation of maximum is 15 days in jail, it's not considered an encroachment on liberty to
[28:23] the extent that you're entitled to a lawyer.
[28:25] So it makes a difference of how you set things because if you set something to a misdemeanor
[28:29] and you're cited in court, you're entitled to an attorney because the penalties are,
[28:33] it's a misdemeanor to the crime, everything else is violation of the law.
[28:37] So it really is important to try to make these consistent.
[28:40] And again, as you can see, we're sort of going back in time and sort of rearranging these things
[28:44] that are a bit all over the map.
[28:47] Chapter 271, win energy systems, again, like the battery energy storage systems before,
[28:52] or this is again just residing to where the penalty section is going to land in the code.
[29:03] Chapter 278, that is a amendment again for moves, set fees.
[29:09] And I think this is why everybody's here.
[29:12] We're getting to the zoning section.
[29:15] I'm going to go slow, so if you can't hear me here, raise your hand.
[29:20] And I'm going to be delivered here in the best I can to explain what's happening and
[29:30] why personally, as an attorney, I like E-code because it makes my job easier, it makes
[29:41] it easier to find things, it makes it easier to cross-reference things, the zoning ordinance
[29:48] in Canberra is difficult. It is large. It is funness.
[30:00] Sarah Lee refers you around. So it puts you on a chase to find an answer. It doesn't need, that does not need to be. So I'm going to go through, I'll go through these codes. A lot of them are designed to make this easier. And I hope that I'm going to try to explain why. So the first one might as well be that we might as well just get right here because this is why I'm assuming 95% of us are here.
[30:27] There is a proposed definition change to 8200, the definition of a farm in the definition
[30:39] section of the zoning ordinance is being revised from five acres to seven acres.
[30:46] Why? Because the definition itself refers to a section of agon markets law that says not
[30:56] less than seven. So this was flagged as an equal for an internal inconsistent. So we have
[31:06] a front part of the definition says five and the back part if you go to the law it's
[31:12] citing says not less than seven. So the equal says just revise it so that it's consistent
[31:19] which is what is proposed. But I think there's a lot of confusion as to the import of this particular definition.
[31:29] And I'm going to try to explain this in a way. I'm going to try to explain this in a way that it makes sense because it doesn't, it's going to be hard to explain because it doesn't really make sense.
[31:47] You're not going to disrupt this meeting.
[31:49] I agree.
[31:51] You're not going to disrupt me.
[31:52] I don't think that there should be a definition of a farm in here because it's irrelevant
[31:57] and how it's going to want to be.
[32:01] Yes, but the definition of farm in this ordinance is meaningless.
[32:08] So the definition of farm is in the definition section.
[32:11] definition of farm. The word farm as a term does not appear in any of the actual land use
[32:18] sections of the ordinance. So if you go to the agriculture and you look at the permitted uses,
[32:25] it doesn't say farm. It says agricultural activity. It says animal husbandry. It says
[32:32] This is a sort of culture, it says, agritories, because those are what is defined in the order.
[32:40] And just to give you, there is a reason why farm is here.
[32:43] I don't think it's a good reason, because it just confuses people.
[32:48] But I want to say this, new fame does not have a definition of farm.
[32:52] There are farms and new fame.
[32:56] There are a definition, the definition of farm.
[32:58] The right to farm.
[33:00] Condor plate definition.
[33:03] The definition of farm varies from town to town to town to town, but only one municipality
[33:12] that I know of actually uses farm as a land use provision.
[33:16] That's a town of Wilson.
[33:17] Why did it do that?
[33:18] That's up to them.
[33:19] But the top lot board, the town of Royalton, Newfayne, Summersett, they don't use farm because
[33:25] as far as a blanket term, which is why it's here in this definition, because this definition
[33:33] here refers to the agricultural assessment. The agon market section that this refers to
[33:41] has to deal with how you qualify for an agon salesman. The ability to be taxed as a farm.
[33:47] It says seven acres and $10,000 in sales, or if you have less than seven acres, $50,000 in
[33:53] sales but it's about an agricultural tax exemption. It's not about land use. We don't use and
[34:01] again I say we, everybody but Wilson, we don't use farm as a land use in terms of because it's
[34:09] too broad. So we split it down into agricultural activity which has a don't specific definition and
[34:15] animal husbandry, all in specific definition,
[34:19] horticulture, all in specific definitions,
[34:22] and agritourism.
[34:24] So if you were to just strike the farm definition
[34:27] out of the ordinance, nothing would change.
[34:29] If you were to leave it at five acres,
[34:31] nothing would change.
[34:32] If you were to set it at a million acres,
[34:34] nothing would change, because the ag exemption
[34:37] that is referring to is set by state law.
[34:41] There's nothing that the town could ever do.
[34:46] Okay, we're going to start sending people out the door.
[34:49] I can tell you right now, we're going to start sending you out that the town of Cambria
[35:00] has no intent of having this change be substantive in any way.
[35:06] It wasn't an internal citation, prior, if you have five acres and you grow crops, you
[35:17] are permitted to do so because you're engaging in agriculture activity.
[35:22] If you have one acre and you are growing crops, you are engaging in agriculture activity.
[35:28] The only one that has any kind of a size aspect to it is animal husbandry because if you've
[35:34] got less than five acres than you need a special permit because the town needs to make
[35:38] sure you're able to keep the animals safely, humanly, and away from the neighbors, and
[35:43] that's the only one.
[35:44] So agriculture right tip doesn't matter how big you are.
[35:48] Portic culture doesn't matter.
[35:51] And if you can animals do the only one, you can get a special permit for it if you're reasonable.
[35:55] If you want to raise chickens on one, then I don't want acres to be okay with it.
[36:00] But the thrust of this is just to correct this internal
[36:07] inconsistency because it says five and then it points to a lot of it since seven.
[36:12] This isn't a question, this isn't a band in four people.
[36:17] I've given my opinion on it.
[36:20] I'm just telling you why the change was flagged and what the rationale was.
[36:37] I don't want to talk over you but your question is landed I can hear it so I don't want
[36:45] to be rude but there's a lot going to laugh so 28200 we're moving we're changing
[36:54] automobile laundry to car wash because it just makes sense. I don't know it. I don't know.
[37:00] It's almost funny that automobile laundry is in there. Section 305 about keeping transient
[37:08] rumors and borders. They're getting rid of that because that was an attempted reference at seasonal
[37:15] farm health and that's again governed by agonmarkets. Whether you have the right to do that or not,
[37:21] I'm going to be going to my egg in America to say, you know, it's sort of superfluous.
[37:25] That's what everyone knows.
[37:26] That's what the town intended to by transient rumors and borders.
[37:30] Playhouses, toolhouses and garden houses are deleted because it's unnecessary.
[37:35] These are not structures that require a building permit.
[37:39] So you don't need permission.
[37:41] You don't need to be told that you can put a playground up.
[37:44] So the problem is when you list things that you don't need, a building permit for, that
[37:51] our structures that the town has been in is going to need to consider accessory structures.
[37:56] If you make a list, the implication is that you're excluding everything else.
[38:02] So rather than having a list of three, it is deleting it because you don't need to be
[38:07] set out.
[38:08] We don't want to give anyone the impression that the only other structures you can have
[38:11] are the playhouse, the two-house gardeners.
[38:14] Same?
[38:16] Same.
[38:18] We haven't even opened the public hearing yet, but it's going to try to get through it.
[38:20] That's right.
[38:22] So 400 and 406, that's, again, the residential
[38:28] analog of the district changes we just, we just went through.
[38:31] Section 280, 401J, the agatorism section.
[38:38] That's, this is one of these cases where we are literally just
[38:41] putting the text of that provision into the section instead
[38:46] of referring you to another section.
[38:48] So instead of pointing you to where to go,
[38:50] we're just going to print this paragraph for you so you can just read it right there.
[38:55] Same thing with section 288-500.
[38:58] In the medium density residential use district, it lists the permitted structures, and then
[39:05] it gets to a point where it says, and everything else that's considered permitted under these
[39:08] two sections.
[39:09] Well, rather than make someone flip back to the previous two sections there, we're literally
[39:13] just putting it here in writing.
[39:16] It's not adding a new permitted use, it's just saving you the time to go in back to the 400 section and the 300 section.
[39:23] Same thing with section 288-600, they are literally just saying these are your specific permitted uses rather than making you go back to the previous two.
[39:33] So again, they're not expanding or contracting any permitted uses, they are simply saving you the flipping through the three pages.
[39:41] and it's an obvious change to someone who reads the ordinance and has to.
[39:47] It's time to ask, well, the next one, section 288700, same thing.
[39:54] Instead of referring to other sections for permitted use, it's going to set them out here
[39:59] so that you don't have to keep going back and forth.
[40:03] Section 288701, now we're flipping and we're setting out these specific prohibited uses
[40:11] This law is not changing what is a prohibited use in this district, it's simply saying instead of making you go back to see what the other prohibited use is where it's going to put it right here.
[40:29] Section 288-103 all the way at the bottom after all the way down to line, the wholesale business is again just to remove the set fee.
[40:38] and this is a new one. This is a new, this is a problem with the first new edition and maybe the only new edition that's in this.
[40:46] They're adding a new section to 288-101-D, which when someone goes to sell their house, the building department is going to now have to notify the future owner in writing within 30 days.
[41:04] that this property has a special use permit attached to it.
[41:09] It's got conditions on it.
[41:11] Heads up in case you want to continue this and renew it.
[41:14] Because otherwise, if no one tells you,
[41:16] you might not know that your property has a special permit.
[41:19] So it's a simple send a notification to that person,
[41:23] let them know there might be some property
[41:25] that's got a land use associated with it
[41:26] in case they want to continue it.
[41:28] Or in case they don't know the conditions
[41:30] that are on a special permit.
[41:32] They might realize they have a special permit
[41:33] They may not know what the conditions are because they weren't part of the process.
[41:37] The lawyers are poor.
[41:40] I'd rather know than have to get a lawyer, I'd rather not pay, but teach their own, I guess.
[41:48] To weigh 288-1109, actually, I think it's simple.
[41:58] So, the next one, the 11-Away, this is an artifact of the
[42:06] disappear zoning ordinance that needs to go. When they were talking about permanent
[42:11] off-street auto storage parking, they had, if you go into the ordinance to find a list
[42:17] of everything seevable, hypothetical, set up you could have, businesses broken out, and
[42:23] And each one had its own parameters.
[42:25] So if you had a warehouse, you had to have this many parking spaces and it had to be in this
[42:30] orientation.
[42:32] And it was three pages long.
[42:34] And if you happen to want to open up that kind of building, and you're to lot, maybe
[42:39] isn't going to be conducive to that particular arrangement and you're going to be in a problem.
[42:44] So what we're doing here is eliminating those specific parameters and just giving more
[42:49] discretion to the planning board to look at your property and help figure out a
[42:54] parking space orientation that makes sense rather than trying to shoehorn people
[42:58] into what at some point someone thought was appropriate for each little break-out
[43:06] either business or public place because there was a lot in there.
[43:15] Same thing in
[43:15] 1109. They're removing those specific parameters and just giving the
[43:21] planning board more freedom to take a look at your actual parcel and try to make a plan
[43:26] for parking and offloading and standing areas that make sense rather than constraining
[43:31] them.
[43:32] So the town basically has general parking rules and general off loading rules and they're
[43:36] just referring to those instead of the specific, denumerated, present requirements which could
[43:46] be hamstring to somebody in reality.
[43:51] Section 2A1113V, again, is removing a specific fee.
[43:58] 1126.4 is deleting that penalties and remedies section
[44:03] because the patent records penalties
[44:05] had their own penalties for some reason.
[44:07] They were sort of their own, because again,
[44:09] it was passed in its own piece of legislation.
[44:11] So they're just eliminating that and making it consistent
[44:14] with the rest of the zoning penalties and sending it as its own consistent catch-all, so what they're trying to do here is instead of having six or seven different types of penalties, just having one condensed penalty section in a touring people there, and we'll get there in a minute as another one of these ones that bears an explanation.
[44:36] So, this is the big one right here, 288-1129-M4.
[44:48] The present zoning ordinance has an enforcement section that sets forth a civil penalty structure,
[44:57] which authorizes the bill.
[45:00] Building inspector to issue civil penalties for violations that they are alleging are at correct. And they are permitted to withhold moving forward on a building permit or a zoning application until those civil penalties are paid. I have a huge problem with that because you have judgmentary and executioner in the same person.
[45:31] So it needs to change, it needs to change.
[45:38] This enforcement mechanism is in addition to the state, the New York State town law enforcement mechanism.
[45:47] So the New York State town law has its own list of penalties for zoning violations.
[45:55] so I'm losing battery. I'm going to do the best I can. My battery is dead.
[46:04] So New
[46:11] York State
[46:22] Tau-Law has its own basic default violation penalties enforcement mechanisms. The
[46:30] town is able to add on to it which it did here with a civil penalty structure. What
[46:37] this is proposing is to get rid of the civil penalty structure and literally just copy
[46:43] and paste the New York State Tau-Law 268 penalties and enforcement mechanisms to just make
[46:49] that clear that that's the only penalties that the town has for zoning.
[46:56] It's already on the books, it's in the New York State law, but right now we have the civil
[47:01] penalty structure that needs to go and everyone knows it needs to go.
[47:06] The building department knows it needs to go, which is why they've never issued a civil penalty
[47:12] because they recognize that's problematic.
[47:14] And I have never recommended one in my prosecutions presumed because it's problematic.
[47:19] It needs to go.
[47:22] I don't know when it came into being, but it has no purpose anymore.
[47:27] So this section is eliminating that civil panelist framework and literally cutting and pasting
[47:33] the New York state town law and panelist in there, which, again, are already on the books.
[47:40] And you were cited.
[47:40] And what are those?
[47:42] They are, if it breaks down, the fines into offenses.
[47:49] So you have first offense, second offense, third offense.
[47:54] And it sets a max penalty for each and a max incarceration
[47:57] for each and barely for one second.
[48:02] I'm going to get my longer explainer out.
[48:08] So anytime
[48:12] there was a zoning, I'll
[48:15] trying to cut to the chase.
[48:16] Any time there was a zoning enforcement mechanism
[48:19] in the zoning ordinance, it's being changed
[48:21] with the state lives, because it's just giving an idea.
[48:24] A special permit section had its own penalties
[48:26] and enforcements.
[48:27] Those were, you know, fines, $500,000 or $1,500,000,
[48:32] et cetera.
[48:34] They're making every penalty just setting it
[48:37] at the state town law level.
[48:40] And hopefully I have the whole thing in here.
[48:45] So
[48:50] it's going to stay, it's going to stay, the civil penalty part in the law is the
[48:58] same figure that the state uses, the state uses, it's a fine that's issued by a judge.
[49:03] So you're looking at $350 for the first fine, then it's a period of years, you get a second
[49:10] fine, third fine.
[49:11] It goes up to $1,000 maximum for persistent violence.
[49:15] So what you're doing in addition is you're adding on the incarceration, the incarceration provisions that are already in the state law as well.
[49:26] So what this amendments to this section are trying to do is make people aware of what the law is so they understand.
[49:34] If you don't know that there's a state law that dictates what the max penalties are, because it's not explicitly in the ordinance.
[49:41] I guess if you're going to decide how badly you want to violate the zoning ordinance, if you don't know what the penalties are, it's not really fair.
[49:52] And additionally, there's a civil penalty framework that is dubious at best and needs to go.
[49:57] So what we're basically doing is just making what is already law in black and white writing.
[50:03] So everyone can see the intersection and stripping out that civil penalty framework.
[50:08] And that's again across the board because there are different penalties in different areas.
[50:13] There's special permit violations where one set of penalties they're just making in all the same.
[50:18] It's all the state law. You're trying to make a consistent throughout the ordinance.
[50:22] So that means it's the same for all the different towns then because they all have to be regulated in the state law.
[50:27] but town is free