Agenda
We think we found an agenda here: https://docs.google.com/gview?url=https://capmetrotx.legistar1.com/capmetrotx/meetings/2026/2/3051_A_Board_of_Directors_26-02-11_Agenda.pdf&embedded=true
Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
[0:07]
CapMetro board meeting.
[0:09]
>> Travillion: well, I
[0:10]
should say good afternoon.
[0:12]
Good afternoon, everybody.
[0:14]
And thank you all for coming
[0:16]
out to our public hearing
[0:17]
and special board meeting.
[0:19]
I will call this meeting to
[0:20]
order.
[0:23]
Today is wednesday, FEBRUARY 11th.
[0:29]
The time is 12:22.
[0:30]
With a quorum available.
[0:32]
I have to check with my
[0:33]
attorney, with a quorum
[0:34]
available, we'll start the
[0:37]
meeting at 12:22.
[0:40]
We are going to rearrange
[0:41]
our order.
[0:43]
We're going directly to
[0:45]
action items.
[0:46]
And we will go -- when we
[0:48]
finish our action item we'll
[0:51]
go back to the front and
[0:54]
then work on the rest of our
[0:55]
agent.
[0:56]
First item on our agenda,
[1:00]
and I'll read it into the --
[1:01]
I'll read it into the
[1:02]
record, approval of a
[1:04]
resolution authorizing the
[1:05]
PRESIDENT And ceo or her
[1:13]
designee to apply for the
[1:15]
capital area metropolitan
[1:16]
planning organization,
[1:18]
campo, 202008-2031 call for
[1:20]
projects, submitting both
[1:22]
CapMetro's bus stop street
[1:24]
furniture and equipment
[1:27]
program and hybrid bus fleet
[1:29]
upgrade program for campo
[1:31]
consideration and committing
[1:32]
to providing local match
[1:34]
funding from CapMetro
[1:36]
should the projects be
[1:37]
selected.
[1:38]
Anna land will make this
[1:39]
presentation for us.
[1:40]
>> absolutely.
[1:42]
Good afternoon, members of
[1:45]
the board, chair travillion,
[1:46]
president and ceo dottie
[1:46]
watkins.
[1:51]
My name is anna land and we
[1:52]
are here to seek approval
[1:54]
for the two projects that
[1:57]
chair travillion started.
[1:58]
The bus stops churn and
[1:59]
equipment program and the
[2:00]
hybrid bus fleet upgrade
[2:01]
program.
[2:03]
This was originally
[2:06]
presented on JANUARY 14th to
[2:09]
the finance audit and
[2:10]
administration committee and
[2:14]
was supposed to be on the
[2:14]
JANUARY 26th board agenda
[2:16]
that was rescheduled due to
[2:16]
weather.
[2:17]
We are seeking the
[2:19]
application for these two
[2:19]
projects.
[2:21]
Under the campo call for
[2:23]
projects, which is basically
[2:26]
a competition for federal
[2:27]
transportation funds
[2:29]
eligible follow roadways,
[2:30]
transit, multimodal
[2:32]
improvements and safety
[2:32]
enhancements.
[2:33]
There are three different
[2:34]
categories that we would
[2:35]
like to apply under, and
[2:37]
they are the service
[2:39]
transportation block grant,
[2:40]
transportation alternative
[2:41]
set aside and the carbon
[2:42]
reductions program.
[2:45]
The first project is the
[2:47]
CapMetro bus stop street
[2:48]
furniture and equipment
[2:48]
program.
[2:50]
We are seeking funds to
[2:53]
install 120 bus stop
[2:56]
shelters and 76 priority
[2:58]
transit stops.
[3:00]
It is a little over
[3:01]
8.1 million and if awarded
[3:02]
we would commit to a match
[3:05]
of approximately a little
[3:06]
over 1.6 million.
[3:08]
the second is the hybrid bus
[3:11]
fleet upgrade program.
[3:13]
This is for the purchase of
[3:14]
18 diesel electric hybrid
[3:17]
buses to replace our
[3:18]
electric fleet and it
[3:19]
supports our state of good
[3:21]
repair goals.
[3:22]
The total project cost is
[3:24]
$27 million, and if awarded
[3:27]
we commit to a local match
[3:28]
of $5.4 million.
[3:29]
And that's the end if you
[3:34]
have any questions.
[3:35]
>> Travillion: board
[3:36]
members, do we have any
[3:36]
questions?
[3:38]
Do we have any questions?
[3:40]
Have any questions?
[3:42]
Hearing none, chair will
[3:43]
entertain a motion to --
[3:45]
>> chair, before we take
[3:46]
that motion, I've been
[3:47]
informed that one of our
[3:48]
public speakers signed up to
[3:50]
speak not just on the public
[3:51]
hearing, but also on this
[3:52]
action item, so I think it
[3:53]
would make sense that we
[3:55]
hear from them before the
[3:56]
board takes a vote.
[3:59]
>> Travillion: all right.
[4:00]
Would that be MS. Joseph?
[4:01]
>> I believe so.
[4:03]
>> MS. Joseph, are you with
[4:18]
us?
[4:19]
Yes, MR. Easton.
[4:20]
What is it you want me to
[4:22]
comment on, is it the public
[4:24]
hearing or the action item?
[4:25]
I know you changed some
[4:27]
order or something, but I
[4:27]
didn't catch all that was
[4:29]
said at the beginning of the
[4:31]
meeting.
[4:31]
>> Travillion: the action
[4:33]
item.
[4:34]
>> okay.
[4:36]
Thank you, MR. Chair,
[4:37]
members, I'm zenobia joseph.
[4:40]
i just wanted to say as it
[4:45]
relate specifically to the
[4:46]
capital area metropolitan
[4:47]
planning organization, as it
[4:49]
relates to the bus stop
[4:51]
furniture, I just want you
[4:52]
to recognize -- and I
[4:53]
mentioned this in the
[4:56]
finance committee as well.
[5:01]
Specifically at 100041 st.
[5:04]
Albert the great catholic
[5:06]
church, 12100 is on metric,
[5:07]
there was a bus stop shelter
[5:09]
that was just placed there
[5:10]
within the last two weeks,
[5:12]
and also one on parmer or
[5:14]
near parmer at parmer
[5:15]
elementary, but I would just
[5:17]
remind you specifically that
[5:21]
at braker and metric there
[5:23]
is still a flat beverage for
[5:24]
route 392, and I would ask
[5:26]
you to recognize as well
[5:27]
that the trashcans as I have
[5:30]
mentioned before are being
[5:32]
removed from CapMetro's
[5:33]
bus stops, specifically
[5:35]
north plaza and rundberg.
[5:36]
And there are trashcans that
[5:42]
have been removed from 392
[5:45]
stop by [Indiscernible],
[5:46]
rotter ham and shropshire,
[5:47]
so while you are asking for
[5:49]
more amenities, the question
[5:50]
is why is it that you're
[5:52]
unilaterally allowing the
[5:57]
staff to remove those from
[5:58]
the bus stops?
[5:59]
Receiving more is not going
[6:00]
to make the system more
[6:01]
equitable.
[6:02]
I would remind you that
[6:07]
northeast of U.S. 183 the
[6:08]
system is actually
[6:09]
inequitable there.
[6:10]
I would call to your
[6:12]
attention the letter that
[6:14]
was written by sharmila
[6:15]
[Indiscernible] That said
[6:16]
50% of the enhanced stops
[6:18]
were on rundberg, which is
[6:20]
not true.
[6:22]
So I've asked MR. Palmer to
[6:23]
analyze the bus stop
[6:24]
shelters and the
[6:28]
distribution of those
[6:30]
assets, the yellow book
[6:31]
gives him his guidelines.
[6:33]
He has not done so at this
[6:34]
point, but I would remind
[6:36]
you that the pass-through
[6:38]
funds that you receive are
[6:39]
from the federal highway
[6:40]
administration and your
[6:42]
systems, as my comments are,
[6:44]
arrest in the context of the
[6:46]
civil rights act of 1964,
[6:47]
which prohibits
[6:48]
discrimination based on
[6:49]
race, color, national
[6:51]
origin, and your system is
[6:52]
inequitable as it relates to
[6:54]
the bus stop shelters and
[6:54]
amenities.
[6:55]
So I actually am against
[6:56]
that.
[6:57]
I know that travis county
[6:59]
will be looking at this item
[7:00]
tomorrow and I'm also
[7:02]
against the red line parkway
[7:03]
trail funding.
[7:05]
It's about $2 million that's
[7:07]
in the same call for
[7:07]
projects.
[7:09]
So I just would ask you to
[7:11]
take a look at the north
[7:13]
lamar area in particular and
[7:15]
to ceo dottie watkins, I
[7:16]
just want to remind you that
[7:18]
the mid block stops need to
[7:19]
be closed on lamar,
[7:27]
especially at yager where
[7:28]
MR. [Indiscernible] Was
[7:29]
killed in JULY 25.
[7:31]
Same area as MR. Norton in
[7:33]
2026 on or about
[7:34]
JANUARY 30th, he was hit and
[7:37]
then he died from his
[7:37]
injuries.
[7:39]
His service dog lived.
[7:40]
those are my comments as it
[7:42]
relates specifically to this
[7:42]
item.
[7:44]
I'm not sure whether the
[7:45]
action item.
[7:47]
I told MR. Easton the item I
[7:48]
would speak on.
[7:49]
I would ask you to be
[7:50]
transparent on why you
[7:52]
removed the summary of
[7:53]
comments so that actually
[7:56]
aligns with your minutes.
[7:58]
That is in my view
[7:58]
discrimination and I would
[7:59]
ask you to be transparent on
[8:01]
why you no longer put our
[8:02]
comments in the board
[8:02]
packet.
[8:04]
If you have any questions I
[8:05]
would gladly answer them at
[8:06]
this time and would ask for
[8:07]
guidance as it relates to
[8:08]
the public hearing.
[8:09]
>> Travillion: all right.
[8:11]
Board members, do we have
[8:12]
questions?
[8:13]
Do we have any questions?
[8:15]
All right.
[8:18]
Thank you, it MS. Joseph.
[8:20]
Also, is there anyone else
[8:22]
that would like to address
[8:23]
the board here during the
[8:24]
public comment period?
[8:25]
Anyone else that would like
[8:30]
to address the board?
[8:31]
Oh, this is the action item,
[8:32]
not public comment.
[8:35]
Let me take that back and
[8:36]
ask if there are no
[8:37]
questions, the chair will
[8:38]
entertain a motion to
[8:40]
approve action item number
[8:45]
1.
[8:46]
Okay.
[8:47]
All right.
[8:49]
It's been moved and properly
[8:51]
seconded that we approve
[8:53]
action item number 1.
[8:55]
Any further discussion?
[8:57]
Any further discussion?
[9:00]
any further discussion?
[9:02]
Hearing none, all in favor
[9:04]
of approving action item
[9:05]
number 1.
[9:06]
And I need to make sure that
[9:07]
our board members are on
[9:08]
camera.
[9:10]
I see both board members on
[9:10]
camera.
[9:13]
All in favor of approving
[9:15]
item number 1, please let it
[9:17]
be known by saying aye.
[9:19]
>> [Chorus of ayes].
[9:21]
>> Travillion: all right.
[9:24]
And so it looks like I have
[9:29]
four ayes and I will make it
[9:29]
unanimous.
[9:31]
So action item number 1 has
[9:32]
been approved.
[9:35]
Thank you.
[9:38]
Now let me go back -- we
[9:41]
called to order at 12:22.
[9:45]
Now we will move into on
[9:48]
presentation for the public
[9:49]
hearing, which should be
[9:51]
before public comments.
[9:52]
All right.
[9:55]
So let's put the
[9:55]
presentation together.
[10:01]
That will be peter braden to
[10:03]
present.
[10:05]
>> good afternoon, chair
[10:06]
travillion, PRESIDENT And
[10:07]
ceo watkins and members of
[10:08]
the board.
[10:11]
My name is peter brentton, I
[10:12]
am a senior community
[10:13]
engagement coordinator here
[10:15]
on behalf of the CapMetro
[10:17]
team working on improving
[10:18]
our fare programs.
[10:19]
I hope for your health and
[10:20]
safety you can remembered to
[10:23]
book your valentine's day
[10:23]
reservations.
[10:26]
I am here today to present
[10:29]
on who topics, the day past
[10:33]
retirement and the farebox
[10:33]
replacement.
[10:34]
>> health and safety.
[10:35]
>> yes.
[10:36]
Before we get into depth I
[10:38]
want to point out that these
[10:40]
two items, while distinct,
[10:41]
go hand in hand.
[10:45]
They're linked.
[10:46]
That perspective -- from
[10:47]
that perspective we expect
[10:47]
that customers will
[10:51]
experience this as one
[10:51]
change.
[10:52]
That's important because
[10:53]
we've been making strategic
[10:54]
steps over the past few
[10:56]
years to modernize our
[10:57]
technology, improve the
[10:58]
experience for our
[10:59]
customers, and simplify the
[11:01]
options when it comes to
[11:05]
fares.
[11:06]
Now, we'll start by talking
[11:07]
about the day pass
[11:08]
retirement and the farebox
[11:09]
replacement, however, I want
[11:11]
to provide you one piece of
[11:14]
information out of order.
[11:15]
Our fareboxes are 20 years
[11:19]
old.
[11:22]
Revenge of the sith, the
[11:24]
ipad shuffle, the first
[11:25]
video ever posted to
[11:26]
YouTube.
[11:28]
Technology has changed a lot
[11:30]
since 2025 and considering
[11:32]
the unfathomable advances in
[11:33]
technology since the time
[11:35]
our fareboxes were first
[11:38]
installed, we have been able
[11:39]
to identify and evaluate
[11:41]
options for our customers to
[11:42]
improve their experience and
[11:45]
hopefully provide them more
[11:45]
value.
[11:47]
You'll see that we're
[11:49]
talking about time based
[11:50]
versus account-based payment
[11:51]
systems on this slide, and
[11:54]
there are a lot of words.
[11:55]
What's important to note is
[11:57]
that we are currently
[11:58]
operating both of these
[12:00]
systems at once and our
[12:01]
momentum is towards
[12:02]
operating only one.
[12:05]
That is for simplicity,
[12:06]
efficiency and a better
[12:08]
experience for our
[12:10]
customers.
[12:11]
If you use a paper pass
[12:15]
today, you are using the
[12:15]
time-based system.
[12:18]
When you activate or dip the
[12:20]
paper pass, a timer starts,
[12:21]
and you are able to swipe
[12:23]
that pass as valid fare
[12:25]
media for the time that that
[12:26]
timer is active.
[12:29]
If you use a reloadable fare
[12:32]
card or the umo app, you are
[12:33]
using the account-based
[12:34]
payment system.
[12:35]
You pay per ride and you are
[12:37]
capped at certain amounts,
[12:42]
certain thresholds.
[12:44]
That paper pass, when you
[12:47]
activate it, you steadily
[12:47]
lose value.
[12:49]
I like to think of it as an
[12:50]
hour glass.
[12:51]
You can only buy a specific
[12:54]
amount of sand and you only
[12:55]
have a specific amount of
[13:00]
time to use it.
[13:01]
If you lose the pass, if you
[13:03]
get sick, if you decide I
[13:05]
would rather take an uber
[13:06]
home, you lose value.
[13:09]
However, in contrast the
[13:10]
account-based payment system
[13:13]
lets you put in only as much
[13:15]
sand as you need at one
[13:19]
time, and if you lose your
[13:21]
phone or the reloadable fare
[13:22]
card you don't lose the
[13:23]
value that you've put in so
[13:25]
long as you've registered.
[13:27]
It's recoverable.
[13:27]
Considered the benefits for
[13:29]
our customers, we've been
[13:30]
making strategic steps over
[13:32]
the past few years to
[13:34]
prepare for a full
[13:36]
transition from the
[13:37]
time-based payment system to
[13:38]
an account-based payment
[13:38]
system.
[13:40]
We are now at the point
[13:41]
where we will make a big
[13:44]
leap and retire the
[13:45]
time-based payment system
[13:47]
for all of our fixed route,
[13:50]
local and commuter services.
[13:51]
Here is a simple summary of
[13:53]
the changes we are proposing
[13:58]
to the fare structure.
[14:00]
Local and community fares
[14:02]
will see a removal of the
[14:03]
time-based products and the
[14:05]
capping of the thresholds
[14:07]
stated explicitly rather
[14:10]
than as references to the
[14:11]
time-based pass product.
[14:13]
There's also clarifications
[14:16]
made to make pickup a
[14:19]
discrete fare and state that
[14:20]
fare capping does not apply
[14:22]
to that service, codifying
[14:23]
our current practice while
[14:25]
we explore options for fare
[14:26]
capping on pickup.
[14:28]
We've also added language to
[14:29]
define the intervals for
[14:31]
fare capping with a daily
[14:34]
fare cap being assessed
[14:36]
during the service day and a
[14:38]
monthly fare cap being
[14:40]
assessed during a calendar
[14:41]
month.
[14:45]
We conducted a title six
[14:45]
fair equity analysis in
[14:46]
accordance with our fare
[14:47]
policy because we're
[14:48]
changing out the system
[14:49]
works.
[14:50]
Title vi studies are used to
[14:52]
calculate whether changes in
[14:55]
policies, programs or
[14:57]
services from organizations
[15:00]
receiving federal funding do
[15:01]
not discriminate against
[15:03]
people based on race, color
[15:04]
or national origin as
[15:08]
required by the title vi of
[15:09]
the civil right act of 1964.
[15:11]
The key findings of the
[15:13]
study we conducted showed
[15:15]
that more than 97% of all
[15:17]
trips made using the service
[15:19]
would not see a fare change,
[15:20]
with fewer than three
[15:22]
percent of all trips
[15:23]
affected.
[15:25]
These are trips made with
[15:27]
day passes, purchased with
[15:30]
cash on our buses or at
[15:31]
ticket vending machines.
[15:33]
If you are a customer that
[15:35]
currently pays with cash for
[15:37]
day passes and you ride
[15:37]
frequently, you will
[15:39]
actually benefit by
[15:41]
transitioning to the umo app
[15:43]
or the reloadable fare card
[15:44]
because you get access to
[15:47]
daily and monthly fare
[15:47]
capping.
[15:50]
We studied the impact of day
[15:51]
pass retirement on two
[15:53]
groups as part of the fair
[15:55]
equity analysis, minority
[15:56]
customers and low income
[15:57]
customers.
[15:58]
They then looked to see
[16:01]
whether those groups MAY see
[16:02]
disproportionate negative
[16:04]
impacts or if those groups
[16:06]
wouldn't receive
[16:07]
proportionate benefits.
[16:10]
When we viewing the impacts
[16:11]
to minority customers we see
[16:12]
no disparate impact.
[16:14]
The impact we do see is
[16:16]
minor with a less than two
[16:17]
percent difference in the
[16:18]
impact between minority
[16:21]
customers and non-minority
[16:22]
customers.
[16:23]
When reviewing the impacts
[16:24]
to low income customers, we
[16:26]
see no disproportionate
[16:27]
burden either.
[16:31]
The impact we do see again
[16:32]
is minor with less than two
[16:33]
percent difference in the
[16:35]
impact between low income
[16:37]
and non-low income
[16:38]
customers.
[16:38]
Okay.
[16:40]
Now I will move on to our
[16:41]
farebox replacement, but
[16:43]
before I do, I want to note
[16:44]
that this year will be the
[16:48]
20th anniversary of the
[16:50]
nintendo wii.
[16:52]
Our farris boxes --
[16:56]
>> you didn't say mtv.
[16:58]
>> our fair boxes need to be
[16:59]
replaced.
[17:01]
They are no longer party r.
[17:01]
Supported by the
[17:03]
manufacturer and a new
[17:04]
system will lower our
[17:05]
ongoing costs of good
[17:06]
repair.
[17:09]
Knowing that an account an
[17:10]
based payment system
[17:11]
improves the customer
[17:11]
experience and therefore
[17:13]
planning for the retirement
[17:16]
of the time-based payment
[17:17]
system, we made the
[17:18]
strategic decision to align
[17:20]
the farebox replacement and
[17:21]
day pass retirement.
[17:24]
Our new validaters offer
[17:25]
improved payment options
[17:27]
that allow for fare capping
[17:29]
such as the fare card and
[17:31]
recently tap to pay, though
[17:34]
tap to pay is only daily
[17:37]
fare capping.
[17:38]
There we go.
[17:40]
The new fareboxes will still
[17:42]
accept cash as payment for
[17:43]
single rides.
[17:45]
We do encourage customers
[17:49]
who pay with cash to use a a
[17:51]
reloadable fare card or the
[17:53]
umo cap that ensures they
[17:54]
will receive maximum value
[17:56]
with daily and monthly fare
[17:57]
capping.
[17:59]
At the upcoming board
[17:59]
meeting on the 23rd we
[18:01]
will be asking the board to
[18:02]
approve these fare structure
[18:03]
changes.
[18:05]
If approved, we will end all
[18:08]
purchases of day passes
[18:10]
starting MARCH 1st and
[18:11]
sales of day passes on buses
[18:16]
and tv ms, ticket vending
[18:17]
machines, in early MAY and
[18:19]
stop accepting paper parses
[18:22]
on our buses JUNE 1st.
[18:23]
Installation of the new
[18:24]
fareboxes would span roughly
[18:26]
from JUNE 1st to SEPTEMBER 1st and we
[18:29]
expect to end our paper pass
[18:30]
exchange program at the end
[18:31]
of the calendar year.
[18:33]
The exchange program is
[18:34]
still in development.
[18:36]
We expect to launch it
[18:38]
before JUNE.
[18:38]
Thank you very much.
[18:39]
I hope the information was
[18:40]
helpful.
[18:41]
Happy to answer any
[18:43]
questions you MAY have.
[18:44]
>> Travillion: board
[18:46]
members, do we have any
[18:49]
questions?
[18:50]
Yes, go ahead board member
[18:51]
vela.
[18:52]
>> Vela: thank you, chair.
[18:53]
What percentage of our
[18:54]
customers are still using
[18:56]
cash?
[18:58]
>> that is a great question.
[19:01]
I MAY lean on some of my
[19:03]
colleagues here in the room.
[19:05]
I know -- we can follow up.
[19:06]
>> Vela: great.
[19:07]
I know it's a small
[19:09]
percentage, but just out of
[19:10]
curiosity I was wondering
[19:14]
how many folks it is.
[19:15]
>> Travillion: okay.
[19:17]
Any additional questions?
[19:20]
if there's no questions,
[19:22]
additional questions?
[19:24]
Hearing none, thank you, but
[19:25]
you might want to stay close
[19:26]
because I will open up the
[19:30]
public hearing and we'll
[19:34]
take up public comments on
[19:36]
the fares item and give the
[19:36]
general public an
[19:37]
opportunity to tell us
[19:38]
whatever they want to tell
[19:38]
us.
[19:39]
>> thank you.
[19:40]
>> Travillion: so let's
[19:41]
see, I understand we have
[19:43]
one speaker who has signed
[19:44]
up in advance.
[19:46]
Let's see, can we call
[19:47]
MS. Joseph back.
[19:49]
>> MS. Joseph, did you want
[19:50]
to make additional comments
[19:59]
today?
[20:00]
>> Travillion: is she
[20:01]
still with us?
[20:06]
>> yes, I'm on the line.
[20:08]
Thank you, MR. Chair.
[20:09]
Okay.
[20:11]
Thank you, MR. Chair,
[20:12]
members.
[20:12]
I'm zenobia joseph.
[20:15]
I wanted to make my comments
[20:16]
in the context of title vi
[20:18]
of the civil rights act of
[20:19]
1964, which prohibits
[20:20]
similar education based on
[20:21]
race, color, national
[20:22]
origin.
[20:24]
I do see you have a title vi
[20:26]
fare equity analysis on page
[20:28]
nine of 86.
[20:30]
However, it is disingenuous
[20:31]
for your staff member to say
[20:32]
that fewer than three
[20:33]
percent of the trips are
[20:34]
affected.
[20:36]
Especially for people who
[20:37]
MAY take more than two trips
[20:38]
a day or twice a day.
[20:40]
I want to remind you that
[20:44]
cap remap JUNE 3rd, 2018,
[20:45]
eliminated north, east,
[20:46]
west, connectivity so
[20:47]
starting there you already
[20:48]
know that people have to
[20:50]
take more than two buses to
[20:52]
get anywhere if you are
[20:53]
northeast of U.S. 183.
[20:55]
I want you to recognize that
[20:58]
your origins and
[20:58]
destinations survey from
[21:01]
2023, there's a good article
[21:03]
in the austin monitor by
[21:05]
nina hernandez, OCTOBER 6,
[21:06]
2023, that specified that
[21:08]
african-american riders are
[21:09]
the most transit dependent
[21:11]
and it went up to 88%.
[21:14]
So the question is did you
[21:16]
actually analyze what impact
[21:17]
this would have on
[21:18]
african-americans in
[21:18]
particular?
[21:19]
And then the immigrants that
[21:22]
are northeast of U.S. 183
[21:24]
and the hispanic riders too.
[21:27]
I want to remind you that it
[21:28]
was MARCH 25, 2024, when
[21:30]
your service analysis
[21:35]
manager jennifer govea said
[21:36]
if a passenger needs three
[21:38]
vehicles to get to their
[21:38]
destination they're counted
[21:39]
three times.
[21:42]
So you are double and triple
[21:42]
counting the minority
[21:43]
population and specifically
[21:45]
she said, quote, this is
[21:47]
part of our federal funding
[21:49]
allocation and our formula
[21:51]
for receiving funds from the
[21:53]
fta, unquote, federal
[21:53]
transit, administration.
[21:57]
I do want you to recognize,
[21:57]
MR. Chair, that this does
[22:00]
have a disparate impact on
[22:01]
african-americans and low
[22:04]
income riders a
[22:04]
disproportionate burden.
[22:06]
If you are asking people to
[22:07]
pay 1 fiscal year $25 per
[22:12]
ride, that's $1.25, 250 for
[22:13]
just going on two buses
[22:15]
before they even get to
[22:15]
work, that's about five
[22:16]
dollars.
[22:17]
They have to get back,
[22:18]
that's about ten dollars
[22:20]
round trip.
[22:21]
That's more than the actual
[22:22]
commuter pass.
[22:24]
I want to remind you that
[22:25]
the commuters also ride free
[22:28]
on game days when the train
[22:29]
is too full and they can't
[22:34]
even get to the farebox on
[22:35]
the 803 metro rapid.
[22:38]
I would ask you to table
[22:40]
this item, do the analysis
[22:41]
appropriately as opposed to
[22:43]
selling the system to us as
[22:44]
though it's the best thing
[22:45]
since sliced bread.
[22:47]
I want you to recognize that
[22:48]
you already have arguments
[22:50]
between the unhoused people
[22:53]
and people who get on the
[22:55]
bus and you have the
[22:55]
20-year-olds and students
[22:57]
who have no id because you
[22:59]
haven't enforced it.
[23:00]
This is discriminatory and I
[23:01]
would ask you to recognize
[23:03]
that more needs to be done
[23:04]
to make the system equitable
[23:06]
as opposed to diminishing
[23:09]
the service and treating us
[23:10]
like second class citizens.
[23:12]
If you have any questions, I
[23:13]
would gladly answer them at
[23:15]
this time, but your analysis
[23:17]
is flawed because it does
[23:18]
not take in consideration
[23:20]
the routes that very
[23:22]
eliminated by roberta
[23:22]
gonza
[23:24]
lez, who was there when
[23:24]
she made her presentation to
[23:26]
the board, and it is time
[23:27]
for him to retire.
[23:29]
If you have any questions,
[23:30]
i'll gladly answer them at
[23:30]
this time.
[23:32]
Thank you for allowing me to
[23:32]
make my comments.
[23:33]
>> Travillion: board
[23:34]
members, do you have any
[23:35]
questions?
[23:36]
Do you have any questions?
[23:40]
Hearing none, thank you very
[23:41]
much for your presentation.
[23:43]
>> thank you, MR. Chair.
[23:44]
>> Travillion: is there
[23:45]
anyone else in the audience
[23:47]
that would like to address
[23:49]
the board?
[23:51]
Any other -- any other -- do
[23:54]
we have any calls, ed?
[23:55]
Okay.
[23:56]
So without anyone who wants
[23:59]
to make a presentation in
[24:01]
the audience, without any
[24:03]
additional calls, then I
[24:05]
will call this meeting -- I
[24:07]
will close this meeting at
[24:10]
12:46.
[24:12]
12:46.
[24:15]
Any questions or
[24:15]
observations?
[24:16]
[Pounding of gavel].
[24:17]
All right, the meeting is