Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[0:00]
Court district 227 board meeting to order and first off on the
[0:09]
roll call.
[0:12]
Pause quick.
[0:16]
Katie is absent, everybody else is here.
[0:19]
All right, the stand for the vigilations.
[0:23]
I pledge to the flag.
[0:25]
And you guys, this is where you do the Republic for which it stands, on nation, under God, in a little bit of a really injustice for all.
[0:38]
Before we go over to the approval agenda, I remind Board members to try to make sure your mics are on and speak loudly.
[0:45]
And Ed remind me too.
[0:48]
So, because Ed doesn't want to do it very well.
[0:50]
All right, approve of those general items added to this agenda under a concept items new
[0:55]
hires, the AD, the two are either Riley Urban, child care assistant for valley land, Mary
[1:06]
Claire Myron, child care assistant for valley land, and Marty Braun, Maddie, Braun, fifth
[1:14]
elementary teacher. In under policy review, we have a 507 corporate punishment and
[1:23]
prone restraint review. B is 601 curriculum and instructional goals. C is 603 curriculum
[1:33]
development. In finally under 12 discussion items, we have cell phone policy and procedure
[1:40]
review. Action items 13B. We have approved the 2026-2027 teacher
[1:48]
seniority list and see a brew of October school board meeting change to
[1:53]
Monday October 17th at 7 p.m. October 12th. Thank you.
[2:02]
All in favor. Motion approved the agenda.
[2:05]
Do you have a second?
[2:06]
Second. Any further discussion? Questions? All on favor say aye? Aye. Opposed? Motion
[2:15]
carried agenda is approved. Approval of claims and accounts, August and September.
[2:21]
Good. I will make a motion. All right, do I have a second? Second. Any other further
[2:29]
discussion.
[2:32]
All right. All of favor say aye. Opposed? Motion carried. District
[2:39]
patron time. Anybody sign up? Okay. Seeing none will move on. Report
[2:47]
school board committees.
[2:51]
Nothing. Nothing.
[2:55]
I just have a, I sent out a note
[2:58]
everyone on HFAD, they did have their grand opening and the new facility, which is in the
[3:05]
old one on them all. I always like the expression they took a Salas here and made a silk
[3:10]
per side of it because it's pretty nice compared to what it was.
[3:15]
And also we'll have discussion
[3:17]
later on the cell phone committee. So that's my reports. Student Senate. Ladies.
[3:27]
Yep.
[3:30]
I'm Lucy Allen. We're talking for student senate. We have two things that we're going to talk about.
[3:36]
The first thing is we've just been trying like adjusting to new things in student senate because we got a new leader. Nikki Lee is the new student senate leader.
[3:45]
And she's been doing well, but we're kind of just adjusting and telling her kind of what we take on as an organization.
[3:51]
And then we have 11 new members, 9 through 12. So just getting them up to date with that.
[3:56]
I'm said, but we've also been doing homecoming prep, so we've been focusing on that.
[4:00]
We've had three meetings so far to plan the homecoming, and so far we've gotten all
[4:04]
the events and themes planned, and then we just have two more meetings before homecoming
[4:08]
week to finish the final preparations.
[4:11]
All right, thank you ladies.
[4:14]
Thank you.
[4:17]
I should say any questions, but no.
[4:22]
All right.
[4:22]
It's a principle, if you guys can, thank you.
[4:27]
I want to just share that we're off to a very good start.
[4:31]
It's been a great first week and a half now.
[4:35]
I think that some of the concerns that folks had about starting
[4:40]
during the fair have people feel a lot better about it.
[4:45]
And we were able to excuse any students that were engaged in
[4:49]
competitions and things like that that we're going to the fair and I think that ultimately
[4:55]
at some point the board's going to have a decision to make about next year's calendar
[5:00]
and I think that having gone through this I feel a lot better about the possibility of
[5:06]
an early start again next year. I think that it's proven to be a good thing for our students and so
[5:12]
we have had some growing pains a little bit with the bone platform and getting people used to it.
[5:18]
I think when you register for something in sports and any activity, the same way for years and years
[5:24]
and then somebody changes it, there's a little bit of learning curve and we had a little bit of that,
[5:30]
but things went pretty darn well with that and I think we have a much better communications protocol now
[5:36]
and better tracking of important documents and things like that with the high school league and physicals and things like that through the bond program.
[5:44]
So I think that that's been a very good thing.
[5:48]
We've been off to some assessments for interventions
[5:51]
that we have in place.
[5:53]
And I've been able to meet with each of the classes.
[5:57]
I will finish that up with a couple of them tomorrow
[6:01]
and on Monday talking about some expectations
[6:05]
and things like that that we have
[6:07]
do every year, some safety meetings and things like that.
[6:10]
Later in the meeting, today we're going to be talking
[6:13]
about cell phones, and I've received a lot of questions about the dialogue that is going on,
[6:20]
and I think that one of the messages that I've been kind of put in forth is trust the process,
[6:25]
and I think that the board is probably going to make some really good decisions in regard to,
[6:36]
you know, having a well-thought-out process, that's not rushing to judgment, trying to make good
[6:41]
form decisions, however, however the board decides to go with it.
[6:47]
I think it's very healthy and I think the process will be good.
[6:53]
And I wanted to share a couple things about our achievement integration report, which we do every year,
[7:00]
and that's not usually too much of a focus.
[7:04]
But one of the things that has been beneficial is that we've had the opportunity to potentially
[7:09]
and introduce some of our students to some programming
[7:12]
that Rochester Public Schools offers.
[7:15]
And in the past, our students really didn't
[7:16]
bite on that hook.
[7:18]
This year, we do have two students that are going to be participating
[7:22]
in one of the courses that's offered
[7:24]
by Rochester Public Schools and Riverland College.
[7:28]
Yeah.
[7:30]
And that is a firefighter certification training course, and it is really, really cool. A couple of our guys that are going to be doing that, it includes a year's worth, of course, work, and also seven weekends of field work, where they're going to be over at the training center in Rochester doing what firefighters train to do, and I think this is an unbelievable opportunity.
[7:59]
and I'm super excited for our guys to be able to do something like that.
[8:05]
And then I, as Zayla and Lucy mentioned before,
[8:09]
we do have a new advisor Nikki Grover,
[8:11]
that's doing a very good job and she's kind of getting off to start.
[8:14]
The students are learning, you know, what she's looking forward
[8:17]
and she's learning a little bit about what it means
[8:20]
to be a student-centered advisor.
[8:23]
Like they said, there's a lot of turnover this year
[8:26]
11 new members and I think that those folks are all starting to figure out what how much work
[8:31]
this actually is that this is not a ceremonial position that definitely is something that that requires
[8:37]
them to be putting a lot of time and effort into it and I think it's going to be great because this is an
[8:44]
important leadership group and over the last couple of years we've involved them more and more
[8:49]
not just in event planning and things like that but we have a representative from the junior in
[8:55]
your class on our high school leadership team, which is kind of an advisory, and sometimes
[9:00]
decision making group for basic operational questions and things like that to come up
[9:04]
in the high school. And last year we, Zaley, was actually one of the junior reps last year,
[9:12]
and I think that the staff members that are on that group really appreciated having student voice,
[9:18]
and the students that were on at last year represent themselves really well. And I think that
[9:23]
Lexus Newman and Sheshaw and Felder,
[9:26]
we'll do a really good job on that this year.
[9:29]
So, that's it.
[9:31]
Thank you.
[9:33]
Shane?
[9:37]
All right, just first up, board members,
[9:39]
thanks for your efforts for our school
[9:42]
and community as school board appreciation month.
[9:47]
Just a kind of an annual update
[9:50]
our fall student conferences that we held last week
[9:53]
on Monday and Tuesday went well. We have a very good turnout with our families and gives us an opportunity
[9:59]
to get connected to our kids prior to the start of school which was on Thursday. Much like what Eric
[10:08]
had mentioned our first days have gone really well and I'm thankful for the work that our staff puts
[10:14]
in to make sure that that goes as we would like it to. Just a fifth grade teacher update, as you see
[10:21]
later on in the agenda, the approval for Maddie Braun.
[10:25]
I also would just like to thank Roy Cratt, he's stepped in and provided some stability
[10:30]
in our fifth grade classroom to get us through until we can get Maddie into the classroom.
[10:38]
Just to remind our allest drills, we're doing those.
[10:41]
You may have seen our kids walking up and down the hill.
[10:45]
That's part of it.
[10:47]
And then we'll be getting started with our first fire drill this Friday.
[10:51]
Each year I've reported on the enrollment and you can see we do have a total change, we're
[10:59]
down about 13 students from last year to this year. That's total students but by
[11:04]
cohort if we just look at the same groups we're up to. So just has to do with the number
[11:10]
of kids coming into kindergarten versus the number going to the high school for 7th grade.
[11:18]
We have not been given those yet.
[11:21]
It's later this year than in the past.
[11:23]
So we're just waiting on that.
[11:26]
And then just an update on our PLCs.
[11:28]
Our focus is going to be on our mass standards.
[11:31]
Kirsten Armstrong, Katie Mayer, our PLC leads.
[11:35]
And they went to a couple trainings last year.
[11:37]
One of them was a big math conference up in Duluth.
[11:41]
And so they've gathered some resources and some
[11:45]
Connections to help guide us as we take a look at our
[11:50]
changes to the math standards. So a lot of things going on, but I do want to emphasize it. We're off to a very good start.
[11:59]
Thank you, Jane.
[12:03]
Good evening. I also want to thank our board for the work of the commitment at the time. I'm
[12:08]
I thought I was always easy, and I feel very fortunate to have a board that's patient,
[12:14]
to understanding, you know, wants to know things and ask questions, you know, and operates
[12:20]
from a position of what's the best thing for the kids and the district and everything else.
[12:27]
So, Jeff, it was very fortunate to have you, thank you for your work.
[12:33]
It's a couple of updates.
[12:34]
Irrigation has been kind of an interesting thing this summer.
[12:39]
Long story short, we have been able to get our water supplies metered correctly after the
[12:47]
change that a city made in the spring so that we're getting charged appropriately.
[12:52]
The city has been very good about making sure we didn't overpay or not get credit for
[12:57]
that in the middle of the transition so that part is good.
[13:00]
So now we've also upgraded our systems so that we can now see them and control them all from a virtual platform.
[13:08]
In fact, I can do it all from my desk now, so we can be more surgical, I guess, and what we're going to run and win.
[13:16]
So we're not running things that maybe necessarily don't need it.
[13:19]
And now this system also monitors the weather forecast.
[13:22]
It won't irrigate. If there's 80% chance of rain, if it's actually raining, it won't irrigate. If it's scheduled to.
[13:29]
If it's been an inch of rain in the last three days, it won't irrigate and so I believe just
[13:34]
beverage you of those things, over the next few years, we'll be spending less money on irrigation.
[13:41]
So I think we've got that square away. Start a school.
[13:45]
Agreed with Eric and Shane, very, very smooth. I want to thank Eric and Shane and their staff and
[13:53]
both buildings and the kids and the parents. Everybody kind of did their part and
[13:59]
First, Dave, you know, felt like normalcy, you know, other than just kind of the excitement to come back, which is cool.
[14:05]
So it's hard to believe we're in our second week already, and it just feels like we're in a routine.
[14:11]
So thank you for everyone that's contributed to that.
[14:15]
So that's all I have at the moment.
[14:16]
I can add more commentary to things as we get further through the agenda.
[14:22]
All right, thank you.
[14:24]
All right, moving on to consent items.
[14:27]
We have the August, excuse me.
[14:33]
School board meetings, the August, 18th special meeting minutes, job postings, and the new
[14:39]
hires that I mentioned earlier in Resignations, do I have a motion to approve the consent items?
[14:45]
So move.
[14:46]
Second.
[14:47]
I have a move.
[14:49]
I'll go second.
[14:52]
Any discussion?
[14:56]
All right.
[14:56]
All in favor say aye?
[14:58]
Aye.
[14:59]
Aye.
[15:00]
Opposed? Motion carried. Policy review, MCA, legislative updates. The 501 corporate punishment on the
[15:10]
own restraint, 601 curriculum and instruction goals, and 603 curriculum development. You want to speak to that.
[15:18]
There aren't any changes to these. The policy reviews are simply if there's a statutory update or a statutory change. We don't really have control over anyway.
[15:25]
It's just good to run them through the agenda, give you chance to look at them, and then we can update our year that we've
[15:33]
You know kind of put it through our review process. So nothing here to
[15:38]
Discuss
[15:39]
Okay, we don't do any of the motion on that or just don't there's not necessarily this is just simply a review for your FYI
[15:46]
No changes were made just yeah, I mean it gets it's like
[15:52]
Approving Minnesota law really is kind of a contradictory thing because laws law
[15:55]
So, you know, this is more of a way.
[15:58]
So there were no, there were no, it says Minnesota School Board
[16:03]
Association, there weren't anything that they introduced.
[16:08]
Or, well, they gave us all the new model policies.
[16:11]
A lot of these things are just legislative reference updates
[16:14]
and changes for the most part.
[16:16]
When I say no changes, I say that because there's nothing
[16:19]
material that the intent and the functionality of the policy
[16:22]
has any different, they may have just updated a term
[16:25]
or a grammatical thing or a statutory reference.
[16:31]
Do the new ones have not yet been put together
[16:35]
or are they together on the website?
[16:39]
The ones that we've been doing all along are updated.
[16:43]
The ones that have been updated all along are on the website
[16:45]
along with the ones that have been up there previously.
[16:48]
So I go through every month and try to make sure
[16:50]
there's nothing that is critically out of date.
[16:54]
But I'm probably two thirds of the way through for most of these policy changes because most of all of them are not local.
[17:04]
Local right now for us means we have a first and a second reading if there's a change because those are our policies that we are adding meeting to.
[17:15]
All right.
[17:17]
First reading of district policies for youth for 28.
[17:21]
Employ use of social media.
[17:22]
Okay, so here's a perfect example.
[17:25]
A few years ago we put together this 148 policy,
[17:29]
well it's been probably seven or eight years now.
[17:31]
And after going through it again,
[17:33]
there's a lot of administrative procedure mixed in
[17:36]
with what traditionally would be board policy,
[17:39]
and very often those things should be kind of separated.
[17:42]
So that's really all this is pulling out the guidance
[17:46]
of here's how to do this stuff,
[17:48]
putting it into staff handbooks and leaving
[17:52]
the policy content, so it's more board policy type explanations of material.
[18:04]
All right.
[18:06]
I see no second reading of district policies, so we don't have any.
[18:09]
You'll need to approve this first.
[18:12]
First one.
[18:13]
Okay, I'm sorry.
[18:15]
Do I have a motion to approve the 428?
[18:20]
First reading.
[18:21]
First reading, second, do I have a second?
[18:25]
All right.
[18:26]
Any further discussion?
[18:27]
I'm sorry.
[18:28]
I'm missing something.
[18:30]
We have to approve the first.
[18:33]
We will have the second reading.
[18:36]
Yeah.
[18:36]
I may have missed Paul.
[18:37]
You don't need to approve the first reading.
[18:40]
It's good.
[18:40]
It's good.
[18:41]
It's good.
[18:41]
But since you had a prior, if nobody has any questions or changes,
[18:45]
now you could approve the first reading, knowing we have a second.
[18:49]
So you're right.
[18:49]
You can have the vote or not and it won't change anything.
[18:53]
The vote will have to come at the second meeting.
[18:56]
Yeah.
[18:57]
So, Moe, go ahead.
[18:58]
Any further discussion?
[19:00]
All in favor, say aye.
[19:02]
Aye.
[19:03]
Opposed?
[19:04]
Motion carried.
[19:06]
Second meeting of Justice League policies.
[19:08]
We have none, right?
[19:09]
All right.
[19:10]
The discussion items.
[19:11]
Okay, cell phone policy and review.
[19:15]
All right.
[19:16]
The meeting of your little background here.
[19:18]
I brought that issue up I guess in May and we've had some discussions since then about it and it's a nationwide concern.
[19:26]
Unfortunately, when we decided to go ahead with the committee I found out at the same time that the teachers had met for their association and met and they also had concerns about cell phones and social media.
[19:40]
So we essentially combine, and they had wanted to set up a committee, so we essentially
[19:44]
combine those.
[19:46]
And the outcome we have so far is simply this plan.
[19:51]
And, you know, we're not going into this with any ideas to what we want to change or anything
[19:55]
as much as we want to basically gather information on the impacts that, you know, say cell phones,
[20:03]
smartphones, and the social media, which of course is a big topic in the media now if you
[20:09]
notice that they're suing Facebook and all these companies and stuff. But anyway, it was quite
[20:16]
informative. We met several times. We've gathered together in the plan, here, is made up of essentially two
[20:24]
parts. The major part is actually the appendix, which has a lot of information on this issue associated
[20:31]
with it. And in particular, summary chapters from a book, the anxious generation, which is quite
[20:40]
informative. And I recommend you people want to read that. That's really an engaging thing.
[20:47]
And, you know, I'll be honest with you. This isn't just about students. I found myself reading
[20:53]
that book and going, that's me. I'm hooked. So, again, this is just a review. But,
[21:01]
And as part of that review process, there's also a calendar that we put together of actions
[21:07]
that we plan to take to engage our stakeholders, which are primarily the students, their
[21:13]
parents, teachers, the administration here at Chatfield, and provide information to them
[21:22]
about what we're seeing here and that kind of appendix on the issues that we're looking at
[21:29]
they're out there. Start the conversation. Hopefully get some people talking and reviewing those
[21:36]
issues. And Eric is going to lead a survey to students on the impact of that. And I think
[21:48]
the parents too, right? Yes. So, as you will look at that timeline, if you have questions,
[21:55]
we can get into it a little further. But the just of it is, we're going to send out a bunch of
[21:59]
information to our parents and students about this issue, and then around the first of
[22:06]
October, we're planning to send out the survey to have that completed to get some formal
[22:12]
input from our stakeholders, and based on that review it, and tentatively, because we don't
[22:19]
know if we'll be there, but we may have some recommendations for the board prior to the November
[22:26]
So that is the just of it, so I want to emphasize again.
[22:30]
And we're just looking at the issue and getting some input from everybody on that. There's no, we haven't written anything different, don't or anything like that. So any questions on that from the board.
[22:48]
All right.
[22:50]
All right. I think there's none. We'll be proceeding with that as you so in the schedule here. So all right.
[23:02]
Anything.
[23:02]
Okay, anything further on that?
[23:05]
Otherwise, we're gonna move on, action items.
[23:09]
A, certified the projected levy,
[23:12]
payable in fiscal year, 26 and 27.
[23:17]
School year, 26 and 27.
[23:19]
This we do every year in September.
[23:22]
The difficulty right now that we have
[23:23]
is the Department of Ed is not
[23:26]
gotten all of their business in line.
[23:29]
So we kind of have a draft ideas to what we're going to be looking at and I did attach that to this, and so this is a preliminary approval of the levy.
[23:42]
We do the final approval in December.
[23:44]
And at the preliminary levy it's been traditional to simply certify the maximum allowed, you know, by the state, which is pretty much common for everyone.
[23:56]
And then December, you can finalize that what I can tell you is that
[24:17]
is that the proposed
[24:20]
levy or maximum certification will create about a 3.3% increase total compared to the
[24:29]
prior year,
[24:31]
about 1% of that can be attributed to the least levy track project that we put
[24:40]
the books to get that done. So, you know, and we've, our average increase has been
[24:47]
pretty modest over the last several years. So, I think that to me is a reasonable number
[24:55]
and that's what you'll have to decide upon in December.
[25:00]
I think you have a question. So, this
[25:02]
gets approved. What does this get on the tax rules? Is that start right away in the next
[25:08]
It'll be for pay 27.
[25:14]
All right.
[25:15]
Any further questions on that?
[25:17]
We see the tax impact on that in December.
[25:21]
Different options, or no?
[25:23]
Do we know it?
[25:23]
You want to, like, as if it were a bond or an operating living?
[25:27]
Well, yeah.
[25:29]
You can.
[25:30]
Historically, have given you a summary of it.
[25:34]
But the levy is broken down into so many bits and pieces.
[25:37]
The tax impact is going to but take a little while to figure out but we could base it on like a 300,000-hour home
[25:44]
Alice could do that math force
[25:48]
Because a 3% increase in our living does not equate to a 3% increase in every individual's taxes
[25:55]
I'm a from a source. It's not it's not the same thing. No generally it's less
[26:03]
You want to you. I pursue that or
[26:05]
I'm just kind of curious just going into that because I
[26:08]
So we'll need to prove that the maximum because if come December if we don't we can't go higher
[26:14]
Correct, so we go to the maximum right away because we can always go lower correct. That's that's the logic
[26:19]
It's nice to know
[26:21]
What impact that's gonna have at say three print three percent there, right or what or what we lose or where we
[26:30]
We'll be if we go less than that or don't go to that
[26:33]
Wouldn't this when the state gets all the information that we're supposed to get you'll see
[26:38]
each of the levy sources and what they did with the prior year.
[26:41]
Some are up, some are down, and the net of all that is is a 3.3.
[26:46]
And it kind of fluctuates, you know, community ed for example, you know,
[26:49]
debt service, you know, all those different levy's, you know,
[26:52]
move a little bit, you know, compared to the prior year.
[26:55]
But I'll talk with others and see if I can get a standard residential tax impact
[27:01]
just for the FYI.
[27:05]
And you have that for priorities, assemblers, yeah, okay.
[27:12]
So we need to have emotional matters that correct.
[27:15]
So do I have a motion to certify that projected level?
[27:18]
Lovey?
[27:19]
Simult.
[27:20]
Simult.
[27:20]
Simult.
[27:21]
Maximum.
[27:22]
Maximum.
[27:22]
Maximum.
[27:23]
Maximum.
[27:23]
Maximum.
[27:23]
Maximum.
[27:25]
Maximum.
[27:27]
Maximum.
[27:34]
Maximum.
[27:35]
motion carried, proved. Approved the 2026-27 teacher seniority list. This is just another
[27:44]
annual thing that we need to do. We've gone through it very carefully internally to make
[27:50]
sure that it's all accurate because that has some implications obviously in a
[27:54]
seniority and whatnot if there's staff movements and reductions and so all is
[27:59]
line and the board can approve that so that we can post it.
[28:05]
Quick question.
[28:07]
The teachers that looked at that as well, is that I assume, yeah, I work with the teacher
[28:11]
leadership they look it over, we look it over, you know, hopefully for such eyes and then
[28:14]
gets posted in the workroom so people can kind of see whether they're at and once a while
[28:19]
is an error we just go back and fix it but we try to keep it clean every year.
[28:24]
So I have a motion to approve the 2020-26, 2020-27 teacher senior audience.
[28:32]
Second.
[28:36]
All right.
[28:36]
Any further discussion?
[28:38]
One question, since we haven't seen it, have no idea what's the purpose of us approving something that we couldn't tell you if anything was wrong?
[28:48]
any help. This is more of a, you're trusting that the administration has it accurately,
[28:55]
listed along with the senior leadership of the CTA. So they can post it.
[29:01]
I agree. Again,
[29:06]
well, are we just to cover the, you don't have to. We can, we can push it to another
[29:15]
another month if you wish it was it was in my report right I know that opportunity to review it right so
[29:23]
but we wouldn't know if something was wrong anyhow no okay trusting me that's I think we have to ask
[29:29]
those questions right yeah but we wouldn't even know to ask a question no but that isn't something that the
[29:35]
board really is obligated or you know a typical board wouldn't keep up on the specifics of a
[29:43]
you already list. That's administrative work. We show you our administrative work. You trust
[29:47]
that is accurate and you approve it so that the teachers can post it and review it.
[29:56]
All right. Any other further discussion? All in favor say.
[30:00]
Aye. Aye. Opposed? Motion carried. Approved October, school board meeting to Monday, October 12th at 7 p.m.
[30:13]
Is there something going on in that may?
[30:14]
Yeah, this is brought up because we've got a due to the weird football schedule. There's a home football game versus
[30:20]
Caledonia that night and there's some folks that might feel like they want to be there and then not here or
[30:25]
You know, so it was it was brought up to see if there was an alternate plan for that meeting and I pulled the board a little bit to see what
[30:35]
Or at least Katie and Mark I think you were in on that said, you know, we think so we'll let's try this and see if the board wants to do that.
[30:46]
All right.
[30:46]
During a motion to change the mean, Jack 12, it's so moved.
[30:51]
The second.
[30:52]
Second.
[30:54]
Can you further discussion?
[30:57]
On favor C.I.
[30:59]
Opposed?
[31:02]
Motion carried.
[31:03]
Me, Jack 12.
[31:06]
Do I have a motion for adjournment?
[31:09]
The second.
[31:12]
On favor C.I.
[31:15]
Opposed?
[31:16]
Opposed?
[31:17]
Opposed?
[31:17]
Opposed?
[31:18]
Opposed?
[31:18]
Opposed?
[31:19]
It's not a discussion.
[31:22]
I would say this is probably the quickest one we've had on time.