Agenda
Agenda: https://chino.legistar1.com/chino/meetings/2024/9/1841_A_City_Council_24-09-10_Workshop.pdf
Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[29:46]
Welcome to these September 10th special workshop. I'd like to call the Chino City Council and the
[29:52]
Success Regency to the redevelopment Agency to order. If everyone would please stand, I'm going to ask Mayor
[29:58]
Protem Constance.
[30:00]
First, I'd like to lead us to the flag salute.
[30:02]
Thank you.
[30:02]
Ladies and gentlemen, please go in, including our nation's flag. Ready, begin.
[30:06]
The pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America.
[30:11]
And to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God.
[30:15]
Invisible with liberty and justice for all.
[30:19]
Thank you very much. Please be seated.
[30:21]
And if our city clerk will please note that all council members are present.
[30:27]
First item on our agenda is always public comments, is there any one in the audience that would
[30:31]
like to address the council on any item that is not on the agenda?
[30:37]
Okay, see, no one will move on to our discussion items.
[30:40]
First item is the Professor of Development Update.
[30:43]
Going to receive and file a preserve development update, and the recommendation will be to
[30:48]
receive a presentation regarding the update.
[30:51]
I'd like to ask Chris Staff Report from our city planner, Andrea Gilbert, and our director
[30:56]
of development services, Warren Morellian.
[31:04]
Good evening, Mayor members of the City Council.
[31:07]
Tonight, staff will be providing an update on the development and infrastructure improvements
[31:11]
within the Preserve-specific plan area.
[31:13]
After staff's presentation, we'll be turning it over to representatives with Fallon Cresfarms
[31:18]
and Lewis to provide an update on their land holdings.
[31:22]
The Preserve encompasses 5,435 acres of land and was annexed into the City of Chino in 2003, with the adoption of the Preserve-specific plan.
[31:32]
The Preserve is generally located east of Euclid Avenue, south of Kimbal Avenue, with the portion of it extending on the north side of Kimbal Avenue,
[31:41]
and extends over to the southern and eastern city boundaries.
[31:45]
The specific plan provides a framework for development including a mixture of residential
[31:49]
neighborhoods, a commercial core, and a comprehensive network of trails providing connectivity
[31:55]
between the neighborhoods and open space features throughout the preserve.
[32:00]
Construction of the preserve began in 2004 with the approval of the first five neighborhoods,
[32:05]
the parkhouse, and the fire substation that is located on the north side of Kimball Avenue.
[32:10]
Development stopped in 2008 with the Great Recession, although Chino Development Corporation continued to master plan their land holdings north of Pine Avenue.
[32:20]
Today, the Chino Development Corporation land holdings are generally built out north of Pine.
[32:25]
North of Pine also includes the Bell and Crest Master Plan area, which is going to be located north of Pine Avenue and on the eastern west sides of Main Street.
[32:34]
And the Marquez property, which is located south of Bigmore Avenue on the western boundary of the residential portion of the preserve.
[32:44]
Chino preserved development corporation is now focusing on their land holding south of Pine Avenue.
[32:50]
In 2023, the preserved town center, which is located at Pine and Main Street, opened and brought a much needed commercial center to the preserve.
[32:58]
The development continues south of Pine bringing more residential development in the legacy Academy Elementary School which opened up the summer of this year.
[33:08]
Also, the planned south of Pine Avenue is the Glenny Duncan Park in Chino Community Center in County Library.
[33:13]
Not located in the preserve, but a project that will assist with improvements along Pine Avenue is the majestic Chino Heritage Industrial Project that is located at the southeast corner of Mountain and Bigmore Avenue.
[33:25]
This project was originally approved in 2021 by the Planning Commission in the City Council.
[33:31]
This project does sit below the 566 foot flood in a nationwide and requires approvals from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.
[33:38]
Majestic reality is continuing to work with the Army Corps to obtain such approvals and anticipate receiving a final approval from the Army Corps relatively soon,
[33:47]
and then they would be able to break ground on this project.
[33:51]
Public work staff will now be providing an update on all the infrastructure improvements within the preserve area.
[34:29]
Good evening Mayor and members of the city council.
[34:32]
Today will be providing high-level update on major infrastructure projects related to development and the preserve.
[34:39]
These projects are either currently under construction or are anticipated to be under construction in the future.
[34:45]
We'll start by reviewing projects located at the north end of the preserve and then move southward.
[34:51]
The photo on this slide shows the different projects we intend to cover tonight.
[35:00]
Starting with Mayoral Avenue. Mayoral Avenue is currently closed from Yuclintos, Steerman Drive in front of Chino Airport.
[35:08]
This closure allows the industrial developer, Nontario Rita, to complete the Yuclid intersection improvements.
[35:15]
They were conditioned to construct by city of Nontario. On this slide, you can see a recent drone photo taken of the Yuclid intersection and looking westward towards mayoral.
[35:28]
And you can see the alignment of the new curb on the east side of Uglid, south of Merrill as well as the new concrete pavement on the north side of the intersection.
[35:41]
The current closure is expected to end by November of this year, barring any on for scene delays.
[35:47]
So, road detour signs are set up to guide commuters and alert them that businesses,
[35:53]
Chino Airport, such as Fulls Cafe, continue to remain open during construction.
[35:59]
The developer is conditioned by Ontario to construct the south side of Merrill from
[36:04]
Utelid all the way to just west of Grove.
[36:08]
Once completed, this will provide two eastbound travel lanes on Merrill along Chino Airport
[36:12]
per the city's general plan.
[36:15]
According to the developer's projects schedule they expect to finish the south side and open it to the public by the end of this year.
[36:22]
Again, barring any unforeseen delays.
[36:24]
Have a quick question, will the south side also be concrete like the north?
[36:29]
At the intersections.
[36:31]
The approach to the intersections will be concrete as well.
[36:38]
So I wanted to also note to that, so the work on the south side of Merrill is anticipated
[36:44]
to be completed by the end of this year, but that's just the roadway improvements.
[36:48]
So the work behind the curve, so that would be like the sidewalk and the street lights,
[36:53]
that would be built in some time next year, yet to be determined.
[36:57]
By them as well. Excuse me?
[37:00]
My read-a as well.
[37:01]
My read-a as well.
[37:04]
And the developers also conditioned by Ontario to widen U-glid,
[37:08]
and install a new raised landscape median along the property frontage from Eucalyptus to Merrill.
[37:14]
The developers currently in a process of obtaining all the necessary plan approvals from
[37:19]
CalTrans and the two cities. Completion of the Eucalyptus improvements is anticipated to
[37:26]
be completed by spring of next year.
[37:32]
The next project is Kimball Avenue.
[37:35]
City, the city recently widened the north side of Kimball Avenue between
[37:39]
Rinkon Meadows and Milk Creek.
[37:42]
The project addressed the bottleneck in the westbound direction where two lanes narrowed
[37:46]
down to one lane thus improving traffic flow in the area.
[37:51]
The photo in this slide shows the newly widened road on the north side of Kimbo with
[37:55]
the view towards the west.
[37:57]
During the project, Siege staff had to coordinate with Southern California Edison to remove
[38:03]
to large, sort of excuse me, five large steel poles that were in conflict with the street
[38:09]
winding. The project is now nearly complete. The widen portion of the street has been
[38:15]
base paid, then is open to the public. The contractor will be returning in November to apply the
[38:22]
final pavement cap and striping.
[38:30]
The next couple of slides we're going to cover a bit more
[38:33]
have any improvements?
[38:36]
The first project to be covered are the big more street
[38:39]
improvements within the Fallen Crest development,
[38:42]
which is primarily the area shown on this slide
[38:46]
on the north side of time between West Preserve Loop
[38:49]
and East Preserve Loop.
[38:52]
Tripoint homes is currently constructing
[38:54]
a residential track located just west of East Preserve Loop.
[38:59]
So I don't know if my cursor works,
[39:01]
But it's essentially the area of east of that blue line that's on the photo.
[39:10]
So as part of their development, they're required to construct a big more along their property
[39:13]
front-inch, and tripod-point-home says in indicated that that segment should be completed and open
[39:18]
to the public by the end of the sear.
[39:21]
tripod-in-home is also recently received entitlements for the next phase of development in
[39:25]
fall and crests, which consists of the residential tract just east of west-preserved
[39:30]
loop.
[39:30]
So it's the area west of that blue line and once again they were conditioned to construct
[39:37]
the big more improvements along their property frontage and they anticipate those improvements
[39:42]
would be done by a summer of next year.
[39:46]
So with those two phases completed it will leave one last phase of development in valencrest
[39:53]
and that would be the community core section which is within that blue line area that you
[40:00]
On the on the picture. So according to the development agreement with Fallon Cress, the segments of Big
[40:08]
More to be finished based on the development phases. So per the DA, the Community Core section of Big
[40:17]
More Avenue wouldn't be done until that development occurs and at this point in time, it's a known when that
[40:23]
development will actually happen.
[40:25]
So for that reason, recognizing the importance of completing
[40:29]
big more between Euclid and Helman to provide an alternate route,
[40:34]
besides Kimball and Pine, the staff is in initial discussions with
[40:40]
the Fallon Crest representatives to look into the possibility of
[40:45]
amending the DA or possibly entering into a separate agreement to see if we
[40:50]
to complete those big more improvements that are going to be missing before the final phase
[40:55]
of development.
[41:01]
The other big more street improvements we wanted to cover were the ones located just east
[41:06]
of Euglid.
[41:08]
This section of Big More was widened as part of the conditions of approval for the earlier industrial
[41:13]
development located at the northeast corner.
[41:16]
The developer has completed the base-paving pavement of the street after installing the required
[41:21]
underground utilities, and the roadway is currently open to the public.
[41:25]
Final treatment rehabilitation for the segment is on hold until the developer completes the remaining sewer improvements across the Euclid to connect the new sewer to the city's existing main.
[41:36]
However, staff still needs to coordinate with the developer to address whether it's actually going to be feasible to make the sewer connection across Euclid.
[41:43]
Additionally, staff has identified quality issues with the sewer construction just east of Euclid that the developer needs to address before the street pavement can undergo its final rehabilitation.
[41:53]
What do you choose so they have in single?
[41:56]
Syncles, again?
[41:59]
It's more to do with the elevation of the sewer line and making sure that it has positive drainage
[42:07]
towards the direction that it's supposed to go.
[42:10]
We've discovered that there's an area where it would be flowing in the opposite direction, essentially.
[42:18]
So what would the fix be?
[42:21]
We're in the process of trying to identify how to one, how to fix it, whether is there a fix or do we need to
[42:28]
we excavate the road, which we don't want to do.
[42:31]
So there's an option to do a sewer lift station that they're willing to pay for.
[42:36]
But yes, Mayor and Council, we do have some settlements over the trench because of poor construction quality when it was initially constructed.
[42:49]
So, we're working with the developer and the contractor on that.
[42:54]
I was going to ask, I know you covered the improvements next to the fire department,
[43:02]
but you said that the contractor was in the comeback until November
[43:06]
to do the paving. Why is it taking so long for them to do the paving?
[43:11]
I think it's just based on their schedule.
[43:14]
They're just extremely busy at the moment.
[43:16]
I'm actually waiting for that same contractor.
[43:18]
that's going to be completing the Edison rehab in front of a yolapark. I'm still waiting for
[43:23]
a date to complete that. I know they recently did the intersection of Edison and Central,
[43:28]
but we're still waiting for them to get back to us. Let us know when they're going to do that
[43:31]
segment as well. So I think they're just extremely busy at the moment. There's probably a lot of
[43:37]
projects that they're working on at the moment.
[43:41]
Basically all of the asphalt that the Aspa plant
[43:44]
is producing, it's already committed to other projects.
[43:48]
So, first availability will be in November.
[43:51]
Similarly, we have Ramona Avenue,
[43:54]
they're not coming back until October,
[43:55]
because as far as already committed to another project.
[44:04]
Yes, Karen.
[44:07]
There's been several problems with Big Morrison
[44:09]
that's opening.
[44:10]
I would just encourage staff with this developer
[44:14]
to attain the most desirable resolution
[44:20]
for this problem for the long term for the city, I don't want to see anything but something
[44:26]
that we want in our best interest not just for us and in managing it but for our residents
[44:30]
down the diperventic road from having any overseeing closure problems.
[44:35]
Thank you.
[44:41]
Moving on the next project is Stormdrain Line I also know that's the Euclid Stormdrain.
[44:47]
The city's drainage master plan includes a construction of a Stormdrain facility along
[44:51]
you could extending from Merrill down to Prado Lake south of Pine, covering approximately
[44:57]
2.4 miles.
[44:59]
The primary purpose.
[45:00]
So the storm drain is to manage upstream flows from the Ontario area's north of Merrill. Additionally, the westernmost portion of the preserve, shown in the colored areas on the photo, will also discharge into the storm drain.
[45:14]
Designwork for the storm drain has begun and is expected to be completed by summer next year. Currently, staff is coordinating with our design engineer and public agency stakeholders to explore design alternatives for the southernmost portion of the storm drain,
[45:28]
where it will discharge into the Proto-Dam area.
[45:32]
The city will be required to obtain various permits
[45:35]
from other public agencies to allow construction
[45:37]
of the facility, so this includes
[45:39]
our required of engineers and orange county flood control district.
[45:44]
The estimated costs to complete the project
[45:46]
has risen to 77 million.
[45:49]
For this reason, staff is exploring funding options,
[45:51]
including any possible grant opportunities.
[45:54]
As only a portion of the cost for the project
[45:56]
will be covered by the Preserve Diff program.
[45:59]
Both the county and the City of Ontario have
[46:02]
tentatively agreed to a cost sharing agreement
[46:04]
with the city to help fund the project.
[46:07]
Over finalizing this agreement is contingent
[46:08]
on the city securing the necessary funds
[46:10]
to proceed with the construction.
[46:15]
And just you mentioned that the city of Ontario
[46:18]
and the county are talking about tentative cost sharing.
[46:24]
Why wouldn't, why wouldn't they just automatically do that, because of where the line is?
[46:31]
No, the agreement has been drafted, but it hasn't been executed, because they're waiting for the city to secure the funding to move forward with the construction.
[46:41]
So we would be the project lead, so we need to essentially front the money, and then they would reimburse us.
[46:45]
Okay, I understand. Thank you.
[46:47]
I have a question about the design, the new regulations on storm drain now, on not allowing contaminants and all the rest of it, the new design will it incorporate the new requirements that are coming.
[47:01]
Yes, Mayor.
[47:02]
So we've been working with engineers or consultant engineers to explore options on how to mitigate some of those regulatory compliance.
[47:11]
So we are working with the county parks on where to discharge and how we are going to maintain it and what kind of treatment that we want to employ.
[47:20]
So we are exploring several different options for those.
[47:29]
The next project is Pine Avenue Stage 3.
[47:32]
This project involves widening Pine Avenue between metal house and ring con metals to eliminate the current bottleneck,
[47:39]
where the roadway narrows to a single lane in both directions, thus improving traffic flow in the area.
[47:44]
The work will include raising the road to move it out of the flood zone and installing a permanent storm drain crossing underneath the road as part of the city's drainage master plan.
[47:55]
To elevate the road and address the loss of capacity in the flood zone behind Prado Dam,
[48:03]
The city has identified a suitable property, owned by Orange County Flood Control District,
[48:08]
off Johnson Avenue, which is the triangle-shaped yellow-hashed areas on the photo,
[48:15]
off of Johnson. Those would be the borrow site for the filter.
[48:20]
The project requires permits for multiple agencies, including Army Corps of Engineers,
[48:25]
State of California, and Orange County Flood Control District.
[48:28]
staff has submitted all necessary permit applications and expects to receive them by or before and
[48:34]
spring with a four-way permit from the Army Corps of Engineers anticipated to take the longest to obtain.
[48:42]
Improvement plans for the project have already been approved by the city, construction by Lewis,
[48:48]
of this diff-funded project is expected to start soon after permits are obtained and it goes out to bid.
[48:53]
quick question. I apologize. And forgive my ignorance here. But borrow
[49:00]
filter. What we borrow filter is that dirt we have to pay back somehow. Or
[49:05]
what does that work? So we are basically we're raising the roadway and so we
[49:12]
have to find dirt in order to accommodate the raising of that area. And when we
[49:17]
do that, because a portion of the project site is below the 566 line, we're
[49:23]
taking away capacity for flooding behind the dam.
[49:28]
So we have to offset that capacity and so what we're doing
[49:32]
is we're essentially making a whole somewhere else
[49:36]
to accommodate the fact that there won't be a whole
[49:39]
there for flooding, if that makes sense.
[49:42]
I believe the word is burrow, not burrow.
[49:46]
OK, but it's burrow.
[49:49]
It's burrow.
[49:50]
It's burrow.
[49:51]
It's burrow.
[49:52]
It's burrow.
[49:53]
I wouldn't imagine, I wouldn't imagine they'd burrow down down to dirt, they'd do burrow down.
[50:00]
Thank you very much. So, Pine Avenue is anticipated to remain open throughout the duration of construction, as the temporary road will be initially built to allow travel and both directions, without the need to close the road during construction.
[50:16]
And I will turn it over to our public work director who will cover the remaining part of the presentation.
[50:24]
All right, good evening, Mayor, and members of the council. So, next slide, I'm going to be going over what council consider as a priority.
[50:32]
for the community. So, as you can see, on Hesus's presentation, Pine Avenue has multiple
[50:39]
phases and multiple sections, and they're all identified as a separate project. So, let's
[50:46]
kind of go over Pine Avenue whitening. This is a Pine Avenue east of Euclid, an inclusive
[50:51]
intersection work. And this kind of is a just west of the phase 3 that Lewis is developing,
[50:59]
but it's a continuation to whiten all the way to uglid.
[51:04]
So this portion of Pine Avenue will be three leads in each direction.
[51:09]
And again, this raises our road above the floodplain so that they are all weather conditions.
[51:15]
And the project is approximately 65% complete.
[51:20]
And again, a lot of the roadways in this part of Chino is in floodplain.
[51:27]
So we are working with Army Corps for jurisdictional permits, and working with them also on making sure that they continue to review our plans even when
[51:40]
the federal funds are exhausted on the Army Corps side.
[51:47]
So we are going to be bringing to council a 2014 agreement so that they will continue to review the project.
[51:52]
Hey, Jen, on Pine Avenue, the way you raise it, how are you going to transfer the water from the north to the south?
[51:59]
So that's a nature covered.
[52:01]
Yeah, that'll be the line I.
[52:03]
Oh, the line I.
[52:05]
But that's you, clip, but there's another area on that.
[52:08]
Oh, yeah, that line H.
[52:10]
Yeah.
[52:11]
We have all these nomenclatures from our drainage master plan.
[52:16]
So we name them.
[52:17]
So this is the line I and line I need.
[52:19]
So does this include line H?
[52:21]
Line H is slightly to the east of the project, but this one you call it will be the
[52:29]
convenience point for line I, storm drain.
[52:35]
Yeah, so we have a lot of drainage processing on the project, so that's what makes it really
[52:40]
complex.
[52:43]
And obviously, storm drain I, alignment also impacts how we're going to be able to design
[52:48]
our world way, because Stormdrain Eye is a pretty sizeable structure, it's a 10 by 8 and two
[52:57]
of them on the road, which takes up a lot of room. So obviously there's a complexity to
[53:02]
make sure we avoid conflicts with other utilities. And we have a final environmental pending
[53:09]
nuclear relinquishment, and we've been touching base with CalTrans on that, and we just
[53:13]
an update. Unfortunately, not a good one. They're thinking that now, when
[53:18]
language management is going to be complete in December of 2025, but we're
[53:24]
continuing to push and see if they could do it any faster, but we're in
[53:27]
constant contact with health trends on that.
[53:33]
All right, and this is another
[53:34]
portion of Pine Avenue connector. This Pine Avenue connector is just west of
[53:40]
Pine Avenue, the one that you just saw. And this portion of the roadway is
[53:45]
two lanes, each direction, and portion of this road is actually in city of Chino Hills about about half a mile of them actually.
[53:54]
So we are in designers and progress, and staff just received an updated traffic in PEC analysis,
[54:01]
and we also share that with SPCT and city of Chino Hills.
[54:05]
And they appreciate the fact that we are sharing these pertinent information, so they could provide us feedback,
[54:11]
because there are partners in the project.
[54:14]
And even though we call these our projects,
[54:17]
these are regional corridors that provides
[54:20]
east-west access all the way to Norco and east-fail
[54:23]
and also portions of Ontario.
[54:26]
So it's not just our project, per se.
[54:28]
It's a regional benefit project.
[54:33]
And we are also with any other projects that we have
[54:37]
in this part of City of China.
[54:40]
we are working with environmental group to make sure that we clear all the environmental determination.
[54:47]
And we just had a meeting with CalChance today to talk about some of the requirements that they're going to be putting on.
[54:54]
So we are working diligently on making sure we cross all our keys and data our eyes.
[55:04]
You call it bridge. Again, this is a, we are, this is pending, we're linkishment of, you call it Avenue. So this is a safety improvement as we know that we had several incidences where we have to close the road during flooding and nation periods and for safety purposes. So this project removes the roadway bottleneck and provide access to pulmonary incline road.
[55:31]
And as you recall, we took the design to infrastructure committee and we are going to be designing a bridge instead of a retaining wall to secure the sites.
[55:48]
And that has a minimal impact compared to building a retaining wall and also expedites the construction period.
[55:56]
And we also provide cyclist and pedestrian access for the project,
[56:03]
compliant with all the ADA requirements, and requires Army Corps permits.
[56:10]
And some of these are actually the whole stretch of, you call it Avenue in this portion.
[56:16]
It's actually in the Army Corps property.
[56:19]
So, when we are conveying counter-trans-relinquishment, they're going to have to basically
[56:26]
relinquish, we're going to have to take on the easement portion for the roadway.
[56:33]
And design is expected to complete by fall of 2029, so approximately a year from now.
[56:40]
And final environmental pending, you can relinquishment.
[56:43]
So, as you could imagine, each year, our construction cost have outpaste the cost of a consumer price index,
[56:54]
and our estimated construction cost is approximately $94 million.
[56:59]
And we're also looking at how we're going to finance the project,
[57:03]
and perhaps with CalTrans.
[57:06]
They were hoping that they were partner with us, and also SPCTA,
[57:10]
Because again, these are regional quotas.
[57:13]
They just happen to be in city of Chino,
[57:14]
but it's not just the city of Chino Road.
[57:16]
It's a regional, regionally important corridor.
[57:22]
And as a part of environmental process,
[57:26]
we also spoke with another partner who actually
[57:30]
offered to explore a potential mitigation site in city of Chino.
[57:36]
So we are making progress in making sure we comply
[57:40]
with all the environmental clearance requirements.
[57:45]
And I believe that is our final project.
[57:49]
And I am here to answer any questions council might have.
[57:52]
On the Euclid Bridge, since part of that touches county land, isn't the county going to
[57:59]
participate also in the expense of that bridge?
[58:02]
We could certainly reach out to them, and I think that's where SPCTA comes in at their
[58:08]
SPCT is part of the county, transportation, and we will certainly reach out to any partner
[58:15]
who I would like to partner with us.
[58:17]
You know, supervisor Hagman is still hoping to have the shooting elastic down there.
[58:23]
And not only does you could have to be done with the, uh, the, uh, the, uh, the, what's that,
[58:28]
other little, uh, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no,
[58:31]
yeah, that has to be improved as well.
[58:33]
Yeah, Pomona Rincon, um, all-framp, and Armaab is part of this design.
[58:37]
Okay. So we will not just leave it hanging, we will provide access as well as the access to the county park.
[58:45]
Where that's all part of the design elements for the EFID Avenue project.
[58:56]
We just need to hit the lottery.
[58:59]
Yeah.
[58:59]
The big major hell in the lottery.
[59:02]
What's the height of the bridge you're going to be?
[59:04]
I don't know that yet. They're working on it.
[59:08]
It's going to be above, I think, 50 year flood because that's what they're designing for.
[59:12]
We couldn't really design it to 100 years because then we won't be able to create a ramp down to
[59:18]
Puma and Arvin Khan because it'll be so high, so we're designing it to a 50 year flood.
[59:25]
Will Army Corps accept that?
[59:28]
Yes, they would accept it and that's why we're designing it for 50 year because if we design it for 100 year,
[59:34]
we won't be able to provide access to Puma and Arvin Khan nor the county park.
[59:38]
Right, okay.
[59:41]
Any questions, comments?
[59:44]
just get a within-law reticut.
[59:47]
It's done, right?
[59:48]
It's done.
[59:50]
It's done.
[59:50]
It might have a question.
[59:52]
Yes, Chris.
[59:53]
A couple things.
[59:54]
Number one regarding the Euclid Bridge, a part of the design that may become in back next year,
[59:59]
hopefully.
[1:00:00]
It was mentioned the last thing we spoke about this by Council Member Kurt Burton, the design of the right, the entrance and exit of the shooting range there.
[1:00:13]
We're hoping that that one, the designs come back that, you know, that is a part of the plans.
[1:00:19]
The next thing I want to mention, you know, the American had touched on this, but in terms of the expense, you know, definitely, you know, reach out to the county, I think that's, you know,
[1:00:28]
that should have been done. But I think that, or are we in communication with other cities as well,
[1:00:34]
Eastville and every other city that this corridor would benefit?
[1:00:39]
I have had conversations with the county, Eastville and Ontario and Chino Hills and Pomona.
[1:00:46]
So we've already started those discussions. We've already started the discussion with the county.
[1:00:50]
So when we know how much and we've got the design, then we'll definitely reach out to our partners.
[1:00:55]
And if you don't mind me asking what's the feel from, from, from, from our partners, they're all supportive. Well, as we're working things through with Chino Health, but East fell supportive Ontario supportive Pomono was supportive, however, this doesn't really impact Pomona as much and that was the previous city manager, so I'll be reaching out to the new one as well.
[1:01:16]
They're emotionally supportive. We'll see if they're monetarily supportive.
[1:01:20]
I guess that was my real question. Thank you.
[1:01:23]
All right, thank you very much.
[1:01:26]
Thank you.
[1:01:26]
I want to introduce Jason Lee from Fallen Crest for update.
[1:01:35]
Thank you.
[1:01:36]
Council.
[1:01:37]
My name is Jason Lee.
[1:01:38]
I'm the representative for the Fallen Crest project.
[1:01:42]
I have a slide plan.
[1:01:49]
There you go.
[1:01:51]
Fallen Crest project is bounded by west reserve loop on the west side.
[1:01:56]
And essentially the harvest project from Lewis on the other side of east reserve loop.
[1:02:01]
north of Pine south of the school and the just with the Edison power lines you can see
[1:02:07]
coming through there. The project is laid out and entitled and developed into three phases
[1:02:13]
or four phases really. The phase that you don't see identified as the phase on the right-hand
[1:02:19]
side we call it phase zero, it's the initial phase we had at the project. It was the sole for phase
[1:02:24]
And currently, KV is under construction with.
[1:02:29]
Our original project approvals.
[1:02:31]
We obtained ERR, EIR, back in September 2015.
[1:02:35]
We had an A level approval on the entire project in October 2015.
[1:02:39]
And then in 2021, we started getting our individual mapping done.
[1:02:44]
We got our development agreement done for the first three phases, one, two, and three.
[1:02:49]
And then we started getting individual mapping done for KV.
[1:02:52]
and our future by our current buyer's tri-point.
[1:02:57]
Oh, by the way, feel free to interrupt.
[1:03:00]
I'm going to kind of go through as much as I can,
[1:03:02]
but I don't want to prohibit you from asking your questions.
[1:03:04]
What you see on here is an overview of the entire project,
[1:03:07]
including faces one, two and three,
[1:03:09]
and then East Reserve loop on the right-hand side,
[1:03:12]
with the KB project on the right there.
[1:03:15]
KB is already under construction.
[1:03:17]
Tri-point to the west of them,
[1:03:20]
With the park right above it is under construction and then we just closed with tripoint all the way on West Preserve loop on the left-hand side of the picture
[1:03:28]
That sort of L shape that goes up and above big more and wrap wraps around the Edison easement
[1:03:33]
That's under that's just been entitled as well. We've sold that to tripoint there processing their improvement plan
[1:03:38]
So what's going to happen is, you know, we'll have three phases under construction with our final phase
[1:03:43]
being the development community core right in the middle with Main Street up to the school.
[1:03:53]
So found across phase zero, we call it as the KB homes on the right-hand side. Phase one
[1:03:57]
is the tri-point piece with the portion of the seven acres of the 10 acre park total. We'll
[1:04:03]
be constructed with tri-points first phase. And that's, I think that's a pretty current
[1:04:08]
site plan that's been processed with them, showing the kind of the first parking lot.
[1:04:14]
phase two is the portion of the track one just got entitled and they're moving forward with
[1:04:19]
that should be under construction here I think in the next year or so with the development
[1:04:25]
and then what's remaining yes can you go back yeah yeah go back one more yes
[1:04:34]
west of the park yes why wouldn't she do that little part in the parking lot south of the
[1:04:41]
What is sneezing that way of doing?
[1:04:43]
What we're trying to do is build it in phases.
[1:04:46]
That section drains towards Bicomore.
[1:04:49]
Jainsewood Main Street, so we built it.
[1:04:52]
The portion that you see here drains towards East Reserve Loop,
[1:04:55]
the portion of the next phase, phase two,
[1:04:58]
drains towards West Reserve Loop.
[1:05:00]
In their interest rate and the portion in the middle, which is this, these drains towards Maine. So from an infrastructure
[1:05:06]
point of view, we're building it by phase. I think the differentiation is that the found across ownership
[1:05:12]
isn't a true developer, unlike the lowest company where they go out and act as if you build the improvements. We're a land developer.
[1:05:18]
And so what we do is we go and entitle these poor pieces, get them in development phases that make sense for our buyers to be able to develop,
[1:05:25]
get that approved with staff's ideas on how to face it from an infrastructure point of view.
[1:05:31]
Get that into our development agreement and allow our buyers then to be able to build this in a manner that makes sense.
[1:05:35]
So there's no interim conditions in this scenario. This builds it piece by piece.
[1:05:40]
It just seems like cutting that park off in the middle of the park with no parking doesn't make any sense to me.
[1:05:47]
The parking on the right hand side, you can see it, I don't know.
[1:05:50]
There's only a smidge.
[1:05:51]
Yeah, it's the portion that serves the the basketball courts and the tennis courts and then the open field play area
[1:05:58]
And then the more intense area, which is meant to and I can skip forward, but the more intense area
[1:06:04]
where the splash pad is
[1:06:08]
with splash pad is
[1:06:11]
right
[1:06:13]
The splash pad right on the northeast corner of big more main. That's where the intense area is going to be in the playgrounds going to be. That's where we're tying it into the mixed use
[1:06:21]
Okay, the mixed use area is going to be tied with that.
[1:06:26]
Okay.
[1:06:28]
So yeah, this phasing was based on infrastructure, based on reasonable size pieces for our developers to physically construct.
[1:06:36]
So it wasn't overburdening to each phase to overbuild infrastructure.
[1:06:40]
But we did want to commit to building in our first phase, building the first phases of the, of the part, the seven acres of the 10 acre park.
[1:06:54]
Phase 3 is our next phase. We're currently under design with that phase. Phase 3 has a lot
[1:07:01]
higher density up to 30 or 30 DU breakers the average. We've got about 400 lots.
[1:07:08]
I might click or not.
[1:07:18]
Staff, can you help you?
[1:07:20]
You're back.
[1:07:24]
Back.
[1:07:26]
There you go.
[1:07:27]
So phase 3 has a 441 units left. It's only on 25.
[1:07:30]
So the density is going to be significantly higher.
[1:07:34]
And we're going to have the remainder of the 3,
[1:07:36]
the 3.7 acres are made out of the 10 acre park.
[1:07:38]
We're also going to have a 1 acre town square
[1:07:41]
and we're going to have a commercial core, a commercial center
[1:07:45]
going up the milk.
[1:07:46]
And you go to the next, it's nice to slide.
[1:07:48]
So in the commercial, you see the pink squares centered
[1:07:52]
around the town square, the green town square down
[1:07:54]
in the corner,
[1:07:58]
that town square
[1:08:00]
meant to be kind of the focal point of the community center, of the community core of that area.
[1:08:05]
And what we want to do from a commercial perspective is Lewis's go ahead and go ahead and
[1:08:09]
develop the south side. And it developed a fantastic shopping center, state or brothers. And
[1:08:14]
what we didn't want to do was we didn't want to compete. What we want to do was create something
[1:08:18]
different. Our vision of this area, we've got almost 1,400 homes in just this found across
[1:08:25]
area. It's going to be higher density product. It's going to be intense. And we have a ability
[1:08:31]
to create a lot of walking capability. So what we want to do is create a dining experience.
[1:08:38]
And we call it the idea is create a destination dining. In commercial centers, it's so often
[1:08:43]
that you would go, it's not often that you would go to an apple base for dinner. You'd go the
[1:08:48]
apple base, you'd eat dinner, you'd go home. You wouldn't really hang out there or spending time
[1:08:52]
around that area.
[1:08:54]
And I think what we're trying to do is create that field with COVID, the way COVID happened.
[1:08:58]
It actually created outdoor dining.
[1:09:00]
It encouraged people to go out and have meals outside, have a more of an atmosphere,
[1:09:06]
a creative atmosphere.
[1:09:07]
And that's what we're trying to create in this area.
[1:09:09]
We would have brunch dining, afternoon, evening dining, outdoor paddios on a long
[1:09:15]
main street and create more of an atmosphere, different than your typical shopping center.
[1:09:19]
But more what we think would be more susceptible, more advantageous to these density ranges.
[1:09:26]
You have a lot more people that can walk there.
[1:09:28]
We have the Edison Trail.
[1:09:29]
We have an east-west link pedestrian link through the project.
[1:09:32]
And the idea is to get people out in the evenings.
[1:09:35]
You see so many people walking their dogs.
[1:09:37]
We've created a dog park right on the northwest corner of Big Morn main across the main park.
[1:09:42]
Create that activity where main and Big Morn is going to be the center.
[1:09:46]
In the afternoon, you're going to have the schools right above us, you're going to have kids walking back and forth through school.
[1:09:52]
You're going to have that activity going up and down across down to the lowest projects of the south of us.
[1:09:56]
We really think that the north side of Maine is really going to be an active walkable area.
[1:10:00]
And what we wanted to create that commercial center to support that. The town square was an idea that
[1:10:06]
we worked with staff on. That's an area that we, you can see the hatched area right in front of
[1:10:10]
the town square. That road can be closed. We can have food trucks. We can have farmers' markets.
[1:10:17]
Great, again, another reason for you to get out of your smaller unit and head down to these areas
[1:10:22]
and enjoy the outdoors. Outdoor dining, outdoor farmers' market, outdoor kind of these concepts that you
[1:10:29]
here. The top right hand corner is kind of a food truck concept on an open park. The other
[1:10:35]
ideas are all the outdoor dining concepts that we have in the area.
[1:10:40]
That's the next slide.
[1:10:42]
The next slide is the overall concept of the park. I talked about it. It's really kind of sliced.
[1:10:48]
It's a little bit of a triangle cut by the Edison easement. So the tip of the triangle is the north
[1:10:52]
west corner, which is where the dog park is going to be. What we've talked about with a couple different
[1:10:59]
commercial developers is a bark and brew kind of concept where it's almost an outdoor.
[1:11:06]
You can take your dog to the dog park, grab a glass of wine, like dog walk run around,
[1:11:11]
and then you can walk back to your walk back to your walk back to your units.
[1:11:17]
Across the street would be the main act of area.
[1:11:19]
We talked about that with a 10 acre park, seven acres being built in phrase one,
[1:11:24]
and the remainder being built with phase three.
[1:11:26]
All tied in with the Edison easement,
[1:11:29]
which you can see cutting through the property.
[1:11:32]
That's everything I have to talk about on the project.
[1:11:35]
I'm open to any questions.
[1:11:37]
Questions or comments?
[1:11:39]
Mark.
[1:11:40]
Well, you know, I know this is kind of late in the game.
[1:11:44]
And when they were designing this area,
[1:11:46]
not just on the fellow and Chris side, but on the other side.
[1:11:49]
I just foresee, especially on Pine Avenue,
[1:11:52]
being as busy as it is and being a trucker out and then us eventually trying to expand that out
[1:11:58]
to the 71-free way. I really think that we should have potentially looked for some sort of
[1:12:03]
bridge because to have kids continuously crossing the street there for school or residents going
[1:12:09]
back and forth across in Pine Avenue. I think you're going to generate a lot of traffic on Pine
[1:12:13]
Avenue because of the constant signal lights that are going to be stopping traffic from going east and
[1:12:17]
I think it just, that should have been something we should, we thought about, because I think this is, this is eventually going to become a problem in the future.
[1:12:27]
It's a good point.
[1:12:31]
Have you looked at anything along those lines?
[1:12:34]
No, no. I think the only thing we really focused on was making sure that we spaced out the signals far enough so that we didn't have too many intersections, but we would have a flow, an interaction and flow of traffic.
[1:12:44]
I think, you know, with ease-preserved loop and West-preserved loop, mainstream being the main, the main three intersections, that's kind of what we don't really focus on not creating any additional signals at those points.
[1:12:55]
Chris, did you have anything? Karen? Kurt? Okay, thank you.
[1:13:00]
Thank you.
[1:13:15]
Real quick, I just wanted to just pat with Louis. It's going to come up next and kind of give an idea what Louis is doing.
[1:13:21]
Not only right now, but some of the things in the future, and then text a little bit on demographics down there.
[1:13:33]
Good evening, Pat Lloyd with Lewis Plan communities.
[1:13:38]
We're pleased to be here tonight to talk a little bit about what's happened and what's to come on our presentation tonight.
[1:13:44]
I'm going to walk through a few slides, touch on some projects, things to come.
[1:13:48]
And then Randall is going to talk about demographics and maybe vision of the community and what's happening a little more excitement.
[1:14:06]
Thank you.
[1:14:10]
So we first started to preserve, it was almost 20 years ago, the first five neighborhoods
[1:14:18]
appear in the north,
[1:14:25]
first five neighborhoods were up in the north of Pine, and we completed
[1:14:29]
the Parkhouse and Founders Park and opened that up in February of 2005.
[1:14:37]
Also in the north, we worked with the Chino Valley School District in Greg Stichera was helpful
[1:14:42]
and getting the Calarot Preserve Academy School opened up with that we have a joint use
[1:14:48]
gym and a joint use library that got started. Other notable projects north of pine
[1:14:53]
I apologize for this laser pointer, it's not reflecting on that.
[1:15:00]
Is the Harvest Project that we just completed over at Hellman Avenue and Pine Avenue? Thank you.
[1:15:07]
Appreciate the assist Andrea.
[1:15:11]
The metosquare apartments, which are over on the west side, that that was actually a project that we built with western national apartment group that has 166 low and very low income affordable units.
[1:15:26]
So that helped to meet the affordable requirements, even though if you looked at the project for the outside, it's a beautiful project with a number of fair market rental units as well.
[1:15:36]
Currently in that community, Beezer Homes is developing and selling a project called Zenia, which is a townhouse project that's still selling, that's north of Pine, we have a small 26 lots that are on the west side of that.
[1:15:52]
there to be developed when the adjacent land opens up.
[1:15:57]
That's right now it's agricultural use,
[1:16:00]
so that will be open up, but a future date.
[1:16:03]
And the Edison corridor, which you can see throughout,
[1:16:07]
there are a lot of areas that we received approval with,
[1:16:09]
Edison, and they were able to get that landscape
[1:16:12]
and get trails in.
[1:16:14]
We worked with City to get that accepted and opened up.
[1:16:17]
So that's a nice amenity for the residents.
[1:16:26]
Next, as we go south of Pine, we'll go south of Pine recently, completed projects, Andrea
[1:16:35]
touched on the Town Center, Shopping Center, Anchor by State or Brothers, that's opened
[1:16:40]
up.
[1:16:40]
That's now 88% least, wrapping around it is our homecoming Phase 5 rental community, that
[1:16:49]
is I think that's essentially almost 100% least as well.
[1:16:56]
Today, on the Lewis portion of the project,
[1:16:59]
we have over almost 5,500 building permits
[1:17:02]
that have been pulled.
[1:17:04]
Lewis has a total of 8,199 units.
[1:17:08]
And then so that leaves about 2,600 units building permits remaining.
[1:17:15]
On new projects to come south of pine,
[1:17:17]
this is work, it's exciting along Main Street,
[1:17:20]
the heart of the community,
[1:17:24]
just south of Market Street,
[1:17:25]
yes, right there, Andrea, we're working on.
[1:17:28]
With the city, we've been doing
[1:17:29]
the conceptual design for the Chino Public Community Center
[1:17:33]
and Library.
[1:17:35]
So that's, and we have some right below that
[1:17:38]
is the Glen Duncan Park, which will wrap around that.
[1:17:45]
Further to the south, there's a, what we call the club on Maine, which is another private
[1:17:51]
recreational facility that will be, will build, somewhere to the Park House, North of
[1:17:55]
Pine, this will be a flagship, private recreation facility available only for the Lewis
[1:18:01]
residents, homeowners that buy in the community.
[1:18:08]
This is an image of the looking from Market Street to the south with the front of the community
[1:18:21]
That's, that would be at the corner of market and Main Street looking to the south.
[1:18:29]
Again, this is, at the, at the, at the northernmost portion, this is the library facility.
[1:18:34]
The, we're building, we're combining the library in the community center to be more efficient and to say it costs.
[1:18:39]
So, overall this, it's planned.
[1:18:42]
It's almost 43,000 square feet.
[1:18:44]
The combined building, it includes a basketball gym with wood floors.
[1:18:48]
It's got a banquet facility that could go well over 200 seats.
[1:18:53]
It's got an adjacent, we have an area adjacent to the banquet facility that goes outside
[1:18:58]
that I'll show on another slide that could be a wedding venue where we've got an event
[1:19:02]
lawn.
[1:19:04]
We have dance and aerobics rooms, programmable classrooms,
[1:19:11]
and then the city will own the library.
[1:19:14]
It'll be operated by San Bernard in a county.
[1:19:17]
And the library will be unique because it has several
[1:19:21]
what they call maker spaces.
[1:19:23]
And these are areas they're working with
[1:19:24]
Garner Hold Educational and their famous for robotics.
[1:19:30]
Maybe you've seen it Disneyland or not,
[1:19:31]
it's Barry Farm and so on.
[1:19:34]
But they're working with the county.
[1:19:37]
And as part of the maker space,
[1:19:38]
their goal would be to put some equipment inside those areas
[1:19:42]
or they can teach people about technology and how to use the equipment, whether it's digital,
[1:19:48]
3D digital printing or other technology, and this is hands-on classes where children and adults
[1:19:55]
can come in and actually learn how to use the piece of equipment.
[1:20:00]
Very excited about that, and the county has been working with them for some time, so that will be a major
[1:20:05]
amenity to the library.
[1:20:07]
This is a view from the back of the building. You can see on the left as the high ceiling
[1:20:13]
for the basketball gym, and then the other portion, this would be a grass amphitheater area,
[1:20:21]
very similar to what's outside here where you have a elevated stage, and then on the back
[1:20:27]
the building that could be concerts or movies in the park or be a really nice
[1:20:33]
amenity for the community.
[1:20:38]
This is a concept site plan for the Glenn Duncan
[1:20:42]
Park. What you see on the on the left side that's market avenue that's to the
[1:20:48]
North Main Street is along the the bottom of the map. So the community center is
[1:20:55]
right in the left corner, right there, correct?
[1:21:00]
So if you go to the, to the right,
[1:21:04]
that's where the green grass amphitheater would be.
[1:21:09]
And above that, there's open, there's open place space,
[1:21:13]
further to the north, there's pot-lot.
[1:21:17]
And then if you go further left, we have a dog park plan.
[1:21:21]
And then as you come back towards the center,
[1:21:23]
That's the event lawn where potentially somebody could have a wedding out there and set up
[1:21:28]
or other events that links very nicely into the community center, which the separate entry
[1:21:35]
for the banquet hall would be off of that eastern elevation.
[1:21:41]
Further to the south, we have a track, which that's a quarter mile, and then inside that,
[1:21:47]
we have grass areas that would be set up for open play that could be play fields.
[1:21:54]
One additional area that you can see down along Main Street between the building and the park.
[1:22:02]
We call that Arbor Walk.
[1:22:04]
And that's an expanded area.
[1:22:08]
Here's an image of what that might be.
[1:22:10]
Along Main Street where you could set up for our shows or the food farmers markets or other types of shows.
[1:22:20]
I know Jason mentioned earlier, maybe food trucks,
[1:22:22]
but this scenario or a main street,
[1:22:24]
you could actually block off the street
[1:22:25]
and have linkage between the community center,
[1:22:28]
the park and this area for community events.
[1:22:32]
Last item, this is the club on Maine,
[1:22:34]
which is our private recreational facility.
[1:22:39]
It's approximately 14,000 square feet
[1:22:41]
with another about 8,000 feet of covered area.
[1:22:45]
So this sits on little over three acres
[1:22:48]
And we'll have a pool and other amenities that go with the club on Maine.
[1:22:55]
So between all these projects along Main Street, if we just look at the Public Community
[1:23:01]
Center, the Park, the Arbor Walk, the Private Club on Maine, will be investing over $70
[1:23:07]
million in community amenities.
[1:23:10]
And most of these will be, we're working hard on the plans right now, it'll be started
[1:23:14]
within the next year.
[1:23:15]
So, we're really looking forward to that that's really going to add to the community, the sense of community and the amenities for the residents.
[1:23:27]
Also, under construction is just below the park, is a project we call independence, and those are, it's a rental duplex community right below.
[1:23:40]
And just above that to the, in the turquoise is the new Legacy Academy K through eight school that was opened up just this year.
[1:23:50]
So now we've got two K through eight schools, Calar on the north and Legacy Academy on the south.
[1:23:59]
On this diagram, you can also see that we're starting, we've just graded down to the south block three A.
[1:24:09]
You see that one?
[1:24:11]
Yes, right there.
[1:24:13]
And those, we've got several different product types,
[1:24:17]
but we'll be introducing single story homes
[1:24:20]
where we've got some lots that are low density,
[1:24:23]
low density product that we're building.
[1:24:25]
There's a quick snapshot.
[1:24:27]
True Mark homes is the builder that's
[1:24:29]
coming in and building one of those.
[1:24:31]
So there's a quick snapshot of...
[1:24:34]
Whoops.
[1:24:37]
Yes.
[1:24:38]
Just go.
[1:24:39]
Now, let's
[1:24:44]
go back to the master plan.
[1:24:46]
So Block 3A, this graded will be starting
[1:24:49]
in construction on that shortly.
[1:24:51]
Next is in the community core, what we call Block 11.
[1:24:56]
So it's down in the south, east corner, where Andrea is highlighting that.
[1:24:59]
We'll start.
[1:25:00]
We are grading on that very shortly. New projects that have been approved if we go up to the north and west. We call block one.
[1:25:09]
So that's an area of single family detached homes. It's we've got four different products. It was mostly medium density residential.
[1:25:17]
But we've got single family detached lots that go up to 5,000 square feet. So there's a mix of lots that would be the next area we go into development.
[1:25:26]
And our apartment group is working on Block 8, which is in the community core on Main Street.
[1:25:34]
The master plan has been approved for that.
[1:25:37]
And then future projects that were working on are Block 2, which is low density residential.
[1:25:46]
So we're doing some forward planning on that.
[1:25:49]
And then Block 10, which is the last big piece in the community core.
[1:25:53]
And then down the road would be the block three, which is the estate residential in the park,
[1:25:59]
and I'm on the east side.
[1:26:02]
So to wrap up, I have a video that was a drone over flight, which shows town center,
[1:26:08]
and it shows some of that land.
[1:26:11]
It's out the pine, which gives a very, here we go.
[1:26:16]
This is a view from market street looking to the north of Main Street,
[1:26:22]
toward pine.
[1:26:32]
So of note here on this, this west side, I don't know if you can make them out,
[1:26:37]
but we have some, I think they're Tesla charging stations that we've worked with or along this,
[1:26:46]
this row of the site.
[1:27:01]
You're coming into Main Street. You can see the new, the significant
[1:27:06]
monument signs that are in the entry.
[1:27:42]
You can barely make out in the, in the background,
[1:27:45]
you can see on the left side is the new K-8 school.
[1:28:02]
It really came out as nicely with these units,
[1:28:06]
where the folks can walk right over to the commercial.
[1:28:09]
Have all of these are occupied now?
[1:28:12]
I believe we're in the maybe 98% of those new units.
[1:28:17]
What are the rental ranges?
[1:28:19]
Do you know? I'll hand.
[1:28:21]
Don't know. I made a different question to Randall,
[1:28:24]
or we'll get an answer on that one.
[1:28:43]
What's the status of all of your commercial buildings are they how much that's so
[1:28:50]
right?
[1:28:50]
Right now we're at 88% of all the buildings are so we're down to some of the smaller
[1:28:57]
spaces.
[1:29:04]
I'm a corner of there you see Pinarra Brad and then Chipotle on the on the far side.
[1:29:09]
This is if you look at steps back a little bit and you can see up into the fell and
[1:29:13]
crest property across the street
[1:29:17]
and then other other land that we own for their
[1:29:20]
the best cross main street in further on out.
[1:29:24]
This is a nice perspective of the additional land
[1:29:28]
that's owned, that Lewis owns, that we're planning further.
[1:29:38]
So just in vision now, it would be coming down Main Street
[1:29:41]
right on the left there, would be the brand new community center.
[1:29:45]
Apping around, it would be the Glendonk and Park.
[1:29:49]
And then as we go further on down with the other amenities.
[1:29:53]
but you can see in the background our first phases of homecoming phases 1-4 that have been built there.
[1:30:05]
It's amazing.
[1:30:08]
I'm sorry for the length of this, but I thought it was a good perspective just to see all that property down to the south. You can see ease preserve loop has been extended on down and then you can see the area that's on the far left that's been graded and then we're preparing to grade just inside of ease preserve loop between main over to ease preserve loop. That's where block it loving is.
[1:30:39]
It kind of cool if you could overlay those block numbers on this, you know, yes. Yes.
[1:30:49]
It's amazing.
[1:30:51]
This is just wrapping up with a few still shots of the shopping center and looking out to the east.
[1:30:59]
With that I could either answer questions or I could wait till after Randall's made his presentation and we could do that.
[1:31:05]
That quick question.
[1:31:07]
How many more units do you guys have left before you guys are fully built out?
[1:31:13]
We have approximately 2,600 more building permits again as to build.
[1:31:19]
So I would put us at 8,100 and 2,500.
[1:31:30]
Okay, now I'd welcome Randall Lewis to make his presentation on the vision and demographics.
[1:31:46]
Thank you, Pat.
[1:31:48]
Good evening, Randall Lewis.
[1:31:51]
I want to thank the city for letting us do business more than 60 years in the city of Chino
[1:31:58]
And for being able to work at the preserve for more than 20 years, I think when we first
[1:32:03]
bought the property, we never dreamed it would end up being a 30 or 40 year project.
[1:32:07]
I hope it will be a 30 year project and not a 40 year project.
[1:32:10]
I want to thank the staff.
[1:32:12]
You've really been enjoyed to work with and I think together we've accomplished some great
[1:32:16]
things.
[1:32:17]
And lastly, since our house is so close to the fires and Claireman, I want to thank the public
[1:32:22]
safety people in the room in your colleagues.
[1:32:24]
I very much would appreciate it for all you do for the communities in our region.
[1:32:30]
So I'm just going to talk about some of the bit of statistics on the preserve.
[1:32:33]
We've got a lot more, I just have to say with fair housing rules,
[1:32:37]
there's a lot of stuff I can't talk about publicly.
[1:32:40]
I can share some stuff on one, but there's just some words on what you can do
[1:32:44]
or not do publicly with data about people.
[1:32:48]
And then when we give some information, you sort of some things that we've learned.
[1:32:52]
The source for this stuff is came from a couple of things.
[1:32:55]
First, we collect data from our home builders and then our renters, and we always try to summarize it.
[1:33:01]
And then we also, we do what I call focus groups.
[1:33:03]
We did one last Tuesday night at the preserve, where we had eight of our renters,
[1:33:09]
represented five households.
[1:33:10]
And we talked them over two hours, sort of, what do you like, what do you not like?
[1:33:14]
And then I took some time this last week to get prepared for this,
[1:33:17]
talking to some of the leasing people and some of the sales people,
[1:33:20]
just what are things that we've learned, what are they hearing from the customers.
[1:33:25]
So I want to say from a statistical point of view, it may not be a hundred percent accurate.
[1:33:30]
People, a lot of this is self-reported.
[1:33:32]
People don't always give the most accurate information.
[1:33:35]
But in general, what you're going to hear from me, I think it's very good information.
[1:33:39]
It's very accurate information.
[1:33:42]
I think the first thing that was interesting to us,
[1:33:45]
and we've seen this over time, is that we designed the preserve.
[1:33:48]
we were hoping it would be as this magnet for families.
[1:33:51]
We tried to say, how do you make it the most family
[1:33:53]
friendly community it could be?
[1:33:55]
And I think we accomplished that.
[1:33:57]
But having said that, only about 50% of our households
[1:34:00]
in the first sales site and the rental site
[1:34:03]
have children at home.
[1:34:05]
We've got a lot of singles, a lot of couples,
[1:34:07]
a lot of retirees, people without kids,
[1:34:10]
people with kids who moved out.
[1:34:12]
So I think the preserve is perceived as this place
[1:34:15]
where it's just families, and we have a lot of families
[1:34:18]
that's half of the households, but it's only half of the households.
[1:34:22]
And so for us going forward and as we work with your staff
[1:34:25]
and with all of you, I think we need to be
[1:34:27]
remembering on programming and also amenities
[1:34:30]
the other half of the population.
[1:34:33]
Interesting enough, one of the things we're seeing at the preserve,
[1:34:36]
and we see this in almost all of our communities,
[1:34:38]
we typically get more dogs than children, and send that here.
[1:34:43]
And then sometimes nights that people at dogs,
[1:34:44]
they create a lot of problems, but that's something that we really have to work on.
[1:34:49]
On our home buyers, we collect what is just some information from our builders.
[1:34:54]
And so we wanted to show you where they're coming from.
[1:34:57]
We do what is called the heat mail.
[1:35:00]
Showed is that by far, the biggest number of buyers are coming from the Sangirro Valley at our home buying projects, they're coming from the 60 freeway, the 10 freeway, a few from the 210, but mainly along the 60 and 10 quarter in the Sangirro Valley.
[1:35:15]
The second chunk of big group of buyers that we get are coming from
[1:35:20]
Geno itself from Eastvale, from Ontario, in Geno Hills.
[1:35:24]
And that just makes sense that they're here, and they know it's a good area,
[1:35:28]
and they want to get a house in a master plane community.
[1:35:31]
The third group of buyers that we get, and that's a pretty far down,
[1:35:35]
but it's still significant, is people in Orange County, Irvine, and some of the cities there.
[1:35:40]
And I think a lot of those people are coming to the preserve,
[1:35:43]
because they're used to the master plan living and they're saying they're going to come up here,
[1:35:48]
where there are communities, I'll inquisitive at the north, they like master plan communities.
[1:35:54]
We've learned that people who like master plan communities tend to buy their next home
[1:35:58]
in a master plan community and people who don't like them try to avoid them.
[1:36:03]
They feel there's too much control or too many homeowners association issues or other.
[1:36:08]
We also found just when we look at the heat map.
[1:36:10]
There are dozens of other cities that might have three buyers or five buyers, almost every city in 7 California.
[1:36:18]
But San Gabriel Valley, the local market, and then the Irvine area, are the big source of where our home buyers are coming.
[1:36:26]
The other thing that we studied was just the incomes of our renters.
[1:36:29]
This was interesting because we people always think about renters or who are those people and are the bad for a community.
[1:36:35]
Well, our rental income, it varies by the community we do in the product type, but for almost
[1:36:41]
all of our plans other than our one bedrooms, which lately we haven't been building any
[1:36:45]
of, is over $130,000 per household.
[1:36:49]
We're going to do some more one bedrooms that I'll drive it down, but even in our one bedrooms,
[1:36:53]
a lot of the incomes are $70,000, 90,000.
[1:36:57]
So, I just wanted to let you know that the renters are, there's a lot of shopping power in
[1:37:01]
renters and a lot of people that can contribute to the community in a lot of ways.
[1:37:07]
We found it interesting on the ages and people think on renters,
[1:37:11]
other getting out of college, then they're going to go in an apartment.
[1:37:15]
That's not who's renting our apartments in the reserve.
[1:37:18]
Our average age, we had a household's 41 years old.
[1:37:21]
It's actually about 41 and a half.
[1:37:23]
It's actually older than we would have expected.
[1:37:26]
But I think it's just part of the pricing and it's part of where people
[1:37:30]
are in Southern California, sometimes it's hard to buy a house, and people are renting
[1:37:34]
longer.
[1:37:35]
And one of the things we found that was interesting was the turnover rate, and most
[1:37:39]
apartment communities in Southern California, and really across the country, you might
[1:37:43]
have a turnover rate of 50% or 60% are turnover rate at homecoming of the preserve is about
[1:37:51]
35%.
[1:37:51]
And what that tells us is for the most part, people like where they're living, they're staying
[1:37:56]
longer than at other communities.
[1:37:57]
And I think that's going to mean they're going to get more engaged over time in the
[1:38:01]
Chino community.
[1:38:03]
When we study, we're a people going to move out, some are moving out of state unfortunately,
[1:38:09]
some are buying a house, some are going somewhere cheaper if they've lost their job or something
[1:38:13]
else.
[1:38:14]
But for the most part, our turnover is really low compared to the industry, really low compared
[1:38:19]
to other parts of the Louis Portfolio.
[1:38:22]
And I think it's really a measure that says the renters that the Chino, they like what
[1:38:27]
and they're going to stay.
[1:38:28]
So Randall, let me understand.
[1:38:30]
So other homecoming communities that you own,
[1:38:33]
you find the turnover rate and channel lower
[1:38:36]
than the other ones?
[1:38:38]
Our homecoming here is probably the lowest
[1:38:41]
that we've got are coming in general,
[1:38:45]
are lower than most of our competitors.
[1:38:48]
And I think part of every developer is going to say
[1:38:51]
they do a great job, we really do a great job.
[1:38:54]
And so we keep our people longer.
[1:38:56]
And so, I mean, we treasure our customers, and so we do everything we can to keep them happy.
[1:39:02]
So, yes, we did some surveying and just talking to people about architecture.
[1:39:08]
What is like, what do you not like?
[1:39:10]
And the things we found that most popular types of architecture are still some of our old friends.
[1:39:15]
It's the Spanish architecture, it's the Italian architecture.
[1:39:19]
And it's different groups like different kinds of architecture, but for the most part,
[1:39:24]
those are the most popular kind.
[1:39:27]
One that I'm really love is the modern farmhouse style,
[1:39:30]
which I think is very well with Chenele.
[1:39:33]
You know, in my heart broke in a couple weeks ago,
[1:39:35]
one of the projects, because they said,
[1:39:36]
does everyone love it?
[1:39:38]
And they said, no, a lot of people like it,
[1:39:40]
but not everybody likes the farmhouse style.
[1:39:43]
I guess that's why basketball Robinson's 31 flavors
[1:39:45]
is a different people like different things.
[1:39:48]
And part two, and part two, and part two, right?
[1:39:49]
Yeah, they love part two.
[1:39:52]
And then the interesting part is the contemporary
[1:39:54]
architecture and Pat's drone video was really great for me because I got to see a
[1:39:59]
view
[1:40:00]
The proposal that Preserve. I've never seen before till tonight, in the contemporary architectures, it's interesting that probably 30 or 35 percent of the customers really like the contemporary architecture,
[1:40:13]
probably a remaining 65 or 70 percent about half-hate that architecture and about half-ert depth that remaining are just indifferent to it and they care more about the floor plan or the price of the location.
[1:40:26]
And so I think the message is that the old friends are really good.
[1:40:31]
It's good that we're doing some new styles of architecture, and you can't please everybody
[1:40:36]
with Vanilla or chocolate, you need to have some variety.
[1:40:40]
We've learned that there's a lot of shopping power in there, but there's really a came-up
[1:40:44]
in our focus group, where people talk about how they spend their time.
[1:40:49]
But unfortunately, a lot of it's not going to genome.
[1:40:52]
Our residents were really happy when we opened up the state or brothers to really excited
[1:40:56]
about the restaurants that we're getting.
[1:40:58]
But when we talked to them about,
[1:40:59]
where are you doing most of your shopping?
[1:41:02]
It was a lot of mention, Chino Hills,
[1:41:04]
and a lot of mention, the East Fale.
[1:41:06]
And they didn't mention some of the older centers it was.
[1:41:09]
I thought that it was the interesting,
[1:41:10]
some of the places that they called Chino Hills
[1:41:13]
were actually in Chino.
[1:41:14]
The Chino doesn't get the credit
[1:41:16]
for some of the centers that they have.
[1:41:18]
I think that's up to us
[1:41:20]
and working with economic development.
[1:41:22]
We really need to educate our residents
[1:41:24]
and do a better job on all the shopping alternatives that exist in Chino, because I know
[1:41:29]
we want to keep as much of those shopping dollars in the communities we can.
[1:41:34]
Another thing that I think is room for improvement on the Lewis side, and I can all try to
[1:41:39]
partner with you, was that we needed to do a better job of educating our residents and just
[1:41:44]
all the great things in Chino and what a great city it is.
[1:41:48]
We heard people talking about it, but they didn't brag about it the way I would have
[1:41:53]
and that's not their fault, that's my fault and it's our marketing
[1:41:56]
teams fault, we need to do a better job of selling everything that's
[1:42:01]
great in China so they they appreciated it but we need to have they don't they don't
[1:42:05]
realize all that the city of China offers we did hear a lot of people
[1:42:10]
requesting more events and programs at the preserve they want to feel more
[1:42:15]
a part of the community I know mayor that's something that's been
[1:42:17]
important to you and I think when we get the community center open the
[1:42:21]
and don't be part of her. There would be a lot more people from outside that preserve
[1:42:25]
visiting the preserve. So we really want to make people a part of the community and have
[1:42:30]
it cook both ways. Well, our community services offer so many absolutely phenomenal programs,
[1:42:37]
but we have nowhere really to do them down there. Yeah, so your community service is great. Yeah,
[1:42:41]
and we just need to tell the story on our side to be pretty better. I think I've talked to the
[1:42:51]
residents born in volunteerism, but also in philanthropy.
[1:42:56]
And that's something I see in other cities like Claremont where I live, it's just got
[1:43:00]
more of a culture of philanthropy, because people live live there so long.
[1:43:04]
And I think that's something I want to think, how can we get more involved with our residents?
[1:43:08]
And I will put that on me and our team to think, how can we do a better job?
[1:43:12]
Quick question about your harvest community.
[1:43:16]
Do you get, I know you were not going to offer cooking classes and that kind of stuff.
[1:43:21]
How is that gone?
[1:43:22]
It's gone well.
[1:43:25]
It's not for everybody, but it's gone really well.
[1:43:29]
So I'm happy.
[1:43:31]
This is part of my presentation that there's a study that came out recently.
[1:43:37]
What are MasterFan community developers offering and what customers want and health and wellness.
[1:43:42]
almost everybody's trying to do what we're doing,
[1:43:45]
offering health and wellness.
[1:43:47]
It doesn't rank quite as high on what the home shop
[1:43:49]
is want.
[1:43:50]
They stare care about this.
[1:43:52]
They're a good floor plan,
[1:43:53]
and a good price and other stuff.
[1:43:55]
But we are so committed to healthy gene,
[1:43:57]
no one building a culture of health.
[1:44:01]
One of the things that really thrilled us during our focus group
[1:44:04]
was we said, hey, the preserve is great,
[1:44:06]
but we want to make it great, or what could we do?
[1:44:09]
And we went into about a 10 minute discussion
[1:44:10]
and they said, I wish you had an indoor basketball court.
[1:44:14]
I wish you had a life very, I wish you had places where kids could take classes.
[1:44:18]
I wish you had a place where we could hold banquets and stuff.
[1:44:22]
And our guys started smiling, saying, you've described the community center we're bringing.
[1:44:27]
We felt very happy that what we were working with your staff and the study you've done.
[1:44:32]
I think it's going to be a home run with the community.
[1:44:35]
We were so excited here.
[1:44:37]
Everyone would say, that's what they want.
[1:44:38]
And so when that opens, that's going to be fantastic.
[1:44:43]
Chino, when they're talking to the people,
[1:44:45]
Chino's perceived as a safe community, and that's a good thing.
[1:44:48]
I was personally surprised how many of the residents are putting in their own cameras
[1:44:52]
and putting in their own security stuff.
[1:44:55]
And in talking to them, we had people saying,
[1:44:57]
well, are you ever going to put in license plate?
[1:45:00]
The leaders, can you get more police patrols or something? You know, it wasn't like they were in a panic or anything. So I don't want to over-sell that. But first, there are a lot of people putting in ring cameras or other stuff. And there's just more and more. And I think that's not, you know, I think it's Southern California that's safety and security. It's just going to get more and more important in the future. Now, I just wanted to wrap up sort of the vision of the preserve from the beginning and working with mayor, you are part of it. And some of your other colleagues and all of you have been part of it,
[1:45:29]
giving us good advice.
[1:45:31]
It was to do something different.
[1:45:33]
It was to say, let's not be Eastville.
[1:45:36]
Let's not be Ontario.
[1:45:37]
Let's not even be part of what art is good about.
[1:45:40]
You know, let's do something different.
[1:45:42]
And let's put in amenities.
[1:45:44]
Let's put in trails.
[1:45:45]
Let's put in a lot of things to try to build community.
[1:45:49]
And we feel very good.
[1:45:51]
We've heard from people they like the architecture.
[1:45:53]
They like the landscape.
[1:45:55]
I mean, general, the people living in the preserve are happy.
[1:45:59]
And we feel good that the vision we've promised the city,
[1:46:02]
we think, delivered on, and it's paid off economically,
[1:46:06]
and that the preserve has been a big success,
[1:46:08]
and we're really grateful for that.
[1:46:11]
And we've had a lot of people say,
[1:46:12]
I turn down the Eastville, or I turn down other places,
[1:46:16]
I could get a bigger lot, but I'd rather be in a master plan community.
[1:46:21]
And it's not that we're better than Eastville,
[1:46:24]
we're just different than Eastville, it's not that we're better,
[1:46:27]
Ontario, which is different than that, and so I feel proud of what we've done.
[1:46:32]
It's been working with staff working with the community working with the Council
[1:46:36]
and Commission.
[1:46:37]
I think we stayed true to the vision.
[1:46:41]
Last year, I just wanted to say personal goals.
[1:46:43]
I mean, I'm so excited to see the school district here.
[1:46:46]
I mean, we have three groups we really wanted to do more within the future.
[1:46:49]
Number one is the school district.
[1:46:51]
It's such an important part of the community.
[1:46:54]
relationships that have not been as good as they could have been and we really want to work to
[1:46:58]
heal that because we just know for half of the residents that deserve the schools are
[1:47:03]
vitally important but I think with a really great school district which we have it's going to
[1:47:09]
impact a lot more than half of the residents. I think second we really want to partner even more
[1:47:14]
with community services to just take all the great things that are happening through community
[1:47:19]
services, get our residents more involved than get more feedback than they want, and just
[1:47:25]
so much of what makes Chino great, we want to make it even greater, and lastly, working
[1:47:30]
with public safety, the security thing and the safety thing, again, it's seven-color
[1:47:36]
for, and it maybe it's the United States, we need to part her more with public safety, just
[1:47:41]
to make sure our residents feel safe and comfortable.
[1:47:44]
with that, we're very proud of what we've done, we're very grateful to be here and
[1:47:49]
happy to answer any questions we can.
[1:47:51]
Well, Randall, you know, my saying since 1984 is that I wanted something for everyone.
[1:47:59]
You know, in a truly balanced community and by the time the President has built out, there
[1:48:03]
will be something for everyone and I know that's been important to me for a long,
[1:48:14]
long, long
[1:48:14]
working toward that. Yes, you know, there is going to be something for everyone there and I know we
[1:48:22]
kind of go back and forth about the residential state residential lots, but it's important to people
[1:48:29]
have options. We will have something for everybody. Something for everybody. Yeah, absolutely,
[1:48:34]
so thank you very much. Thank you. We're open for questions instead of their heart,
[1:48:38]
I don't know if there's any and how do you want to answer the no mark?
[1:48:44]
Just what's the timeline on the community centers?
[1:48:47]
We have the chance.
[1:48:48]
I don't know what our report on that.
[1:48:54]
We're very close to wrapping up the conceptual designs.
[1:48:58]
And then there's an administrative approval process that goes through.
[1:49:02]
Then we'll go to working drawings.
[1:49:04]
So probably next year, Springtime will have working drawings approved.
[1:49:08]
Then we need to work with the city on okay when's the timetable to start we've been told it could be a
[1:49:14]
12 to 16 month construction process
[1:49:17]
So we start sometime in
[1:49:18]
25 that probably gets a delivery in early
[1:49:22]
27
[1:49:24]
Did my math right but yes, we're working aggressively with the city on that
[1:49:29]
And your staff has been fantastic I mean we've done field trips. We've looked at pictures of community centers all over California
[1:49:35]
I think what we're getting collectively together is really going to be a jewel if you know.
[1:49:43]
Okay. Mr. Lewis, I'd like to thank you as well.
[1:49:46]
I think the partnership that the City of Juno has with Lewis Land and the development
[1:49:51]
is going to be a very nice master plan community down there.
[1:49:55]
There are people who have their perspectives about master plan communities.
[1:49:58]
I've never lived in one.
[1:50:00]
But my sister lives them on. And what I can tell you is, once it's developed, it's very nice, it's a very different way of living. And when I do go down there and visit people live in that area, I find them to be happy as well.
[1:50:13]
I think the source of their frustration for a long period of time was lack of amenities, and now that those amenities are coming online, I think they're happier.
[1:50:20]
I think with some of the things that Fallon Chris spoke about tonight, it will provide them for more opportunities to stay the local and their communities.
[1:50:26]
I also think a big source of their frustration has been just the catch-up phase of the infrastructure and roads that you saw tonight are going to cost over $200 billion for the city to construct and figure out moving forward in order to make the circulation down their proper.
[1:50:43]
But we will do it. We will find a way to do it with our local partners and the county and the state and find a way to fund these in advance them. We have to do it.
[1:50:51]
our residents are depending on us too because of these arterial supports and the support
[1:50:56]
that's going to provide to the region, not just Chino, as our Director of Public Works
[1:51:01]
Book tonight.
[1:51:02]
I think the last thing I saw tonight, Linda, I love to see, I like the new modern design.
[1:51:07]
I also like the Spanish architecture, so I thought that was very interesting.
[1:51:11]
But, Linda, when I look at that, I've seen a lot of maintenance.
[1:51:14]
One of the, some of the feedback that I get on a continuous basis is not just the parts
[1:51:18]
the city owned but the ones at the HOA owns there. I don't believe that we have clearly
[1:51:22]
defined how when we inspect those things to make sure that they're being properly maintained.
[1:51:26]
I've said this before. I'm a person that travels about the city and a lot of different parts
[1:51:31]
of it and I think one of the things that's going to become a challenge for us is making sure
[1:51:35]
that not just the publicly owned parts but the HOA parks and different things are properly maintained.
[1:51:40]
These are great things when they're maintained well so our residents can enjoy them but when they
[1:51:45]
become not well-maintained, or there's a lack of proper maintenance to them.
[1:51:50]
I think that's a source of frustration for people that contributes to blight instead of beauty.
[1:51:54]
So those are my comments.
[1:51:56]
And I think we share your observations about the infrastructure and the things that the customers are talking about.
[1:52:04]
We also share your concern for long term.
[1:52:06]
I mean, like a lot of companies, we are developed for that it reinvest and so I hope we will own a couple
[1:52:14]
thousand apartments and a big shopping center and we want the preserve to be good for 100 years
[1:52:19]
because we're going to be owning part of it.
[1:52:22]
I think that's your team.
[1:52:24]
We're on your team.
[1:52:25]
Yeah.
[1:52:25]
I think you know having a local stake in it is vital.
[1:52:29]
So thank you for that.
[1:52:29]
Mr. Lewis also just thank you for being such a good partner to the school district to us
[1:52:34]
for wanting to advance philanthropy in our community.
[1:52:37]
I think that's vital for legacy and you and your company's do a lot for our community
[1:52:43]
We're grateful.
[1:52:44]
So thank you.
[1:52:45]
Thank you.
[1:52:46]
Okay.
[1:52:50]
And I also like to thank all of our presenters for seeing our staff, for doing a great job
[1:52:55]
and giving us a breakdown and thank you for giving us a really good snapshot of where
[1:53:00]
we're at right now and where we're going in the very, very near future.
[1:53:05]
I do have a question and build out.
[1:53:09]
We're going to have a lot more people.
[1:53:10]
Do we have a number of what the population is going to be at billed out down there at the conclusion of all those?
[1:53:20]
But it would assume it would be somewhere between 25 and 30,000 people.
[1:53:25]
And what percentage are we at? Approximately.
[1:53:29]
I know the Lewis side where it's 60, some percent or 63 percent, I think.
[1:53:34]
would ever $5,500 out of $7,000.
[1:53:38]
And having that in mind, we have two schools down there.
[1:53:42]
What's the plan of putting another school down there?
[1:53:44]
We're going to need another school.
[1:53:47]
I appreciate the school district folks being here.
[1:53:51]
And we thought about that.
[1:53:52]
I know that Mark had brought it up meeting her to a go.
[1:53:58]
Is that in the plans to have another school?
[1:54:00]
Because we certainly.
[1:54:01]
There'll be up to the school district, and of course we would try to collaborate.
[1:54:05]
I'm not sure we will need it.
[1:54:06]
I mean, one of the things we're seeing, which, in it goes back to half our people and
[1:54:10]
of kids, we're seeing throughout the region, declining in romance per household.
[1:54:16]
And it's just that my senses right now are probably okay with this school plan.
[1:54:22]
But again, that will be the job of this school district, right?
[1:54:24]
I think we're going to be okay with the number of schools.
[1:54:28]
But I think the schools are full now.
[1:54:32]
Without felon quest and without the risk of your development, I was told that the two schools
[1:54:37]
are already ready.
[1:54:38]
You can see the color, or absolutely, I agree that they were both a capacity to set.
[1:54:44]
I think I'll let the school district either answer now, or maybe you can help them
[1:54:49]
come back.
[1:54:50]
Thank you, Randall.
[1:54:51]
But thank you for the information, and I'm with you, by the way, as far as the modern farm
[1:54:56]
house.
[1:54:57]
That's my favorite design as well.
[1:54:59]
I think it's too great.
[1:55:00]
I have a book on your heart when that sales person said that. But a lot of people like it, just not everybody.
[1:55:06]
Good, thank you very much. Any comments for you guys?
[1:55:09]
I'm no comments. I agree with the rest of the council as mentioned on here.
[1:55:15]
I think the efforts of philanthropy are amazing.
[1:55:20]
I just like the councilwoman Karen mentioned. I'm down there a lot at the preserve.
[1:55:25]
and about a year ago we had a chance to walk that side you and I and it's good to see it coming
[1:55:31]
along and I mean the residents that I speak without down there were residents that I come across
[1:55:40]
while you know leading over at some of the restaurants down there. I mean it seems like everyone's
[1:55:47]
really enjoying it and the night life there I'll tell you I went to the restaurant down there
[1:55:51]
a week and a half ago and you know in terms of you know it was mentioned earlier that
[1:55:57]
there's times where people go eat and they just go home but I think at least what I
[1:56:02]
seen that night in the parking lot you had just a lot of families hanging out and you know just
[1:56:07]
enjoying just a good time there in the parking lot so I guess that's just goes to show how many
[1:56:12]
people don't want to just eat and go home you know they want to hang out but again you guys are
[1:56:16]
making that happen. So thank you.
[1:56:21]
I just want to thank you guys for the partnership.
[1:56:26]
I especially want to thank you guys for being as responsive as you guys were when we determined that we needed that side walk there on.
[1:56:33]
I'm fine avenue and you guys went forward and built it even without the development being there.
[1:56:39]
So you guys have been a great partner and I thank you for being responsive to our residents and really catering to their needs.
[1:56:46]
But a lot of credit for that goes to Pat Loanier and all the area that the ones who actually make it happen.
[1:56:52]
Good.
[1:56:52]
I appreciate it.
[1:56:53]
Thank you.
[1:56:55]
Before I go, I just want to thank all of you for your support.
[1:56:57]
You really have a great staff for the people in planning community service everywhere in your city manager and assistant city manager.
[1:57:04]
I really do a great job.
[1:57:05]
So thank you for hiring them and letting us work with them.
[1:57:08]
Thank you.
[1:57:09]
Thank you.
[1:57:12]
Hey, Linda, is there anything more on this item?
[1:57:17]
No, Mayor.
[1:57:17]
Okay, then we will now move on to item number two City of Channel Planning Commission's Fair of Influence Commissioner.
[1:57:25]
This is to discuss some ideas that we had previously and provide direction to staff.
[1:57:32]
I'd like to ask for a staff report from our City Attorney Fred Galante.
[1:57:37]
Thank you. Good evening Mayor and members of the council and all of those present.
[1:57:41]
A little background on this item at its July 5th meeting of last year the Planning Commission responded to the C Council's request for feedback on Planning Commission composition appointment process in terms.
[1:57:58]
Specifically, the Planning Commission voted by 6 to 0 against appointing future members from the city's sphere of influence to serve on the Planning Commission in a voting capacity.
[1:58:12]
However, the Commission, by 4 to 2 vote, supported having a sphere of influence members serve on the Commission, so long as they serve in a non-voting and just advisory capacity.
[1:58:25]
They're after this Council held a workshop on April 9th of this year, and directed staff
[1:58:31]
to return with a proposed ordinance implementing the following directives.
[1:58:37]
Number one, the one sphere of influence member would be appointed from each sphere of influence
[1:58:43]
area, namely the north and the south areas, the sphere of influence member serve a term of
[1:58:52]
two years, allowing the members to remain in place until the conclusion of their term if that particular area from where the sphere of influence member lives is annexed to the city.
[1:59:10]
Number three, that the sphere of influence members serve in a voting capacity.
[1:59:17]
And finally, that the sphere of influence members should have the ability to vote on matters
[1:59:23]
or items that apply to citywide or which involve land within or in close proximity to
[1:59:31]
the sphere of influence area in which that particular member resides on matters or items
[1:59:38]
that apply citywide the member would serve as an alternate to the other member so that if one
[1:59:47]
member is absent and unavailable or otherwise unable to participate in a matter than the other
[1:59:53]
may participate in his or her place. Separately, the council considered whether to broadcast.
[2:00:00]
The Planning Commission meetings in light of staff's recommendation and the information that the viewership is relatively low for city council live meetings.
[2:00:14]
The sentiment was it would likely trend much lower for planning commission meetings. So the council directed that the Planning Commission's not be broadcast at this time, but wanted to revisit that issue in the future.
[2:00:27]
So, provided with this workshop agenda is a draft of the ordinance that implements the council's
[2:00:34]
directives and staff wanted to present this to the council to seek direction on whether to
[2:00:43]
bring back the ordinance for full adoption or make any potential changes.
[2:00:50]
One item that was discussed at the workshop is all conflict rules would apply to the sphere of influence members so that if the member has a material financial impact related to a matter or lives within proximate to propose project,
[2:01:10]
here she would have to recuse themselves, also Brown Act Quorum Rules would apply so that a majority
[2:01:16]
of the members, including the sphere of influence members, could not speak about matters that
[2:01:23]
are subject to the planning commission outside of a publicly-noticed meeting. With that, I'm happy
[2:01:28]
to answer any questions or hear whether the proposed ordinance still meets the council's desires
[2:01:37]
and answer questions.
[2:01:42]
Okay, what I would like to do is just have general discussion with every council member giving
[2:01:49]
some input on what they feel about what's been presented here this evening.
[2:01:54]
I know we had a lot to say that evening that it was discussed and sometimes you verbally talk about
[2:02:01]
some stuff and then by the time you see it and written down it's a little bit different from what
[2:02:06]
So, um, would anybody like to go first or see what I just go down the line?
[2:02:13]
Okay, Chris?
[2:02:15]
Yeah, before I make my comments and I'm sorry I stepped out
[2:02:17]
Fred over your presentation.
[2:02:19]
Can you go over that fourth issue there?
[2:02:22]
I'm regarding the members' right to vote.
[2:02:26]
If I read it correctly,
[2:02:29]
and these members would have the right to vote for
[2:02:32]
What does that say?
[2:02:34]
There's citywide issues.
[2:02:36]
Is that correct?
[2:02:38]
And anything in the sphere, you know,
[2:02:41]
pending the, you know, any, any,
[2:02:44]
forget what you call it.
[2:02:46]
Right.
[2:02:46]
So if it's something that applies citywide,
[2:02:49]
they could vote on it,
[2:02:51]
because presumably that could
[2:02:52]
spill over and impact this sphere.
[2:02:55]
If it's within this sphere,
[2:02:57]
then they could vote on the matter.
[2:02:59]
and if it's within the same type of rules that applied and noticing a project, so 300 feet from
[2:03:06]
this fear of influence area where they reside, that could likely affect this fear so those would
[2:03:14]
be areas where they could vote. When I say citywide issues, it'd be like a general plan amendment that
[2:03:21]
applies to citywide, things of that nature. So it wouldn't be like a proposed project on an
[2:03:27]
central and shave for something like that. I understand. Yeah, that would be close enough.
[2:03:37]
Yeah, I, you know, going back to some of the mayor's comments about, you know, we say it,
[2:03:42]
and then we look at it in paper, it just looks different. That's definitely the case,
[2:03:45]
and just my apologies to or to honestly towards staff because I think when I walked out that last meeting,
[2:03:51]
I just thought that that was a lot of information, a lot of back and forth, and I don't think it was very
[2:03:59]
Progressive I guess is the word I'm using but I don't know my initial thoughts mayor and towards staff and the rest of the council are I
[2:04:09]
This seems like a drastic change and again, I know we we
[2:04:15]
Glue myself right
[2:04:16]
As the staff to kind of bring this back and you know and I write it on papers just it just doesn't it seems like just too much
[2:04:25]
And if I may, I think what I'd like to propose and I know I touched on this one once before was, it just seems, it seems just easier, I think, from my perspective to, I love that we are considering having a member from the sphere of influence, you know, be a part of this, you know, the changes and things that come to the commission.
[2:04:52]
But I guess I guess there's the key for sure what I'd like to see is we have seven members right now and I
[2:05:00]
I think what would, again, make all this easier would be just opening up one of those positions to a member from the sphere of influence, whether that be the north or the south.
[2:05:11]
And, and, and, and, and, you know, when in terms of basically just opening up that position, right? And, on one of those seats up, and that still gives, you know, the, the mayor position of poverty, you know, look at these applications, anything that may come in from the sphere of influence,
[2:05:28]
communities and decide what the best options are, but just adding two more members, I mean we
[2:05:35]
barely even have enough seats for nine people up here, and I just, I don't know, which
[2:05:39]
just doesn't seem like, I don't know, which just seems like we may run into some issues
[2:05:45]
down the road with the way it's proposed, but again, I don't know, just my general thought
[2:05:51]
is, yeah, it seems easier just to open up one position, one seat to the sphere of influence
[2:05:55]
and allow them to at least submit an application and it be up to the mayor and the council is
[2:06:00]
approval to bring them on board or not. Again, those are just in general thoughts.
[2:06:08]
Perhaps if I could just ask for some clarification to your suggestion is keep it as a seven-member
[2:06:13]
body that open up one of those positions. Potentially to a sphere of influence member but not necessarily
[2:06:20]
it would be in the mayor's discretion, obviously, with a ratification of the council.
[2:06:25]
is that correct right right accepting one up or a couple applications I'm
[2:06:29]
and you ever come in and I'm just reviewing those and you know as a
[2:06:32]
council deciding what is you know what it's what you know who's most qualified
[2:06:38]
at least for at the moment and they would serve in a voting capacity that's
[2:06:43]
and I guess that would also mean voting in a in a capacity that again just
[2:06:49]
I'm adding the same voting rights as the other six members.
[2:06:56]
Okay.
[2:06:57]
Mark.
[2:06:58]
Okay.
[2:06:59]
So I'm looking at this.
[2:06:59]
This says whether it's to add one or more members of the Planning Commission to represent areas within the city's sphere of influence.
[2:07:05]
It's so should the sphere of influence be appointed to serve in a voting or advisory capacity.
[2:07:10]
I think when we discuss this, we agree we would add the one member from both sides of the sphere.
[2:07:16]
So adding two members that they would only have voting capacity if it impacted this very influence,
[2:07:24]
but not citywide.
[2:07:28]
Whether the planning commission meeting should be broadcast that I would lean towards
[2:07:31]
no because what was pointed out by the staff.
[2:07:37]
And then it says, once fear influence member should be appointed, so that yes, on the north
[2:07:43]
on the south, two years is fine with me.
[2:07:50]
And unless, of course, there are areas annexed,
[2:07:53]
then they would obviously have to give it to somebody else
[2:07:56]
that's not incorporated into the city.
[2:07:59]
So if they were in the sphere of influence,
[2:08:01]
as a voting member on the planning commission
[2:08:04]
for anything in the sphere, and then all of a sudden,
[2:08:06]
their home was incorporated into the city,
[2:08:09]
then they would have to resign
[2:08:10]
and then we'd have to get somebody else
[2:08:11]
that's in the sphere.
[2:08:14]
This fear of members serving the voting capacity, again, only if it impacts this fear of
[2:08:20]
a but not city-wide.
[2:08:24]
This fear of members should have the ability to vote on that, so I think that's it.
[2:08:29]
I think that's all that's all that's all that's been covered.
[2:08:32]
So I believe we should do that.
[2:08:33]
The two members, I believe they should have voting rights only in this fear, and I don't
[2:08:37]
believe that they should serve on matters that are city-wide because it doesn't affect
[2:08:43]
I'm at that point in the two year term as far.
[2:08:47]
Okay, Karen.
[2:08:51]
I know we don't like to talk about this, but I think this impacts just look for
[2:08:56]
specifically the most because of the sphere.
[2:08:59]
So we talked about this in our last meeting.
[2:09:01]
The reason we talked about two people was because of the north and the south
[2:09:06]
section of the sphere of influence.
[2:09:11]
I think my biggest concern in addressing Councilmember Flores' comments is it could be difficult to get people from both segments of the sphere and I don't see that the policy addresses if we can't fill it.
[2:09:23]
If we go out and actually seek to appoint somebody to or if nobody applies for it, how that will be addressed, if we decide to do two people.
[2:09:32]
The other thing is, if we made it an even number, that was the discussion in the last being was on a voting issue,
[2:09:41]
but that's not necessarily the worst thing if the motion were to die, you know, that way on the voting.
[2:09:48]
And I did talk in the past, I don't have a problem with the appointed members of this to the commission for this sphere to have
[2:09:55]
voting on matters that address that area because I think
[2:10:00]
What we're looking for is just input, although I don't. Yeah, I can make an argument for both voting and non-voting, but I don't have a problem with them voting either way.
[2:10:16]
I'm sorry Mark, what was the other thing you mentioned?
[2:10:21]
I think it's a length of term.
[2:10:23]
I think the term, yes, you know, two years we talked about should they be annexed into the location that's covered here in the policy.
[2:10:37]
think there's it for right now, my right me think a little bit more, thank you, Kurt.
[2:10:46]
I don't have any problems with two representatives from the sphere going on the commission.
[2:10:55]
I do have a question, though, for that things that are voted on within the planning commission.
[2:11:08]
If it affects this fear and those individuals are able to vote on it,
[2:11:19]
could the outcome
[2:11:21]
of that vote have effects throughout the entire city?
[2:11:29]
In other words, if they vote on an issue within a building development,
[2:11:38]
whatever decision
[2:11:39]
has made could that decision affect other areas within the city? Does that make sense?
[2:11:48]
I suppose it would really depend on the circumstances if it's a project that impacts sort
[2:11:55]
of a larger region, because of traffic, et cetera. I would think the answer to your question
[2:12:01]
is yes, but if it's sort of a smaller project that doesn't have sort of a more regional impact
[2:12:08]
and no, I don't know if that's really where your question's going.
[2:12:12]
And I think it is, I think it is, I think it is.
[2:12:15]
I,
[2:12:18]
you know, my initial thought was to get members from this
[2:12:23]
fearing an advisory capacity only and not have any voting rights,
[2:12:30]
because it's, it's the city of Chino, and it's going to affect us ultimately.
[2:12:37]
However, it doesn't affect them as well because they live in that area.
[2:12:42]
So I don't have an issue necessarily at this point in time with them having voting rights.
[2:12:52]
The two-year term, and I'm going to remove that as well.
[2:12:59]
So I think that was that, I'm here.
[2:13:02]
Okay.
[2:13:03]
I have one more comment.
[2:13:04]
Yeah, Karen.
[2:13:06]
I think I was going to recommend, Mayor, it just came to me that if nobody applies that we
[2:13:11]
don't necessarily appoint it, I just think we need a vacant, I think that's the recommendation.
[2:13:17]
I would make this happen, and really necessarily does this think it was like, hey, why make
[2:13:21]
it harder on ourselves?
[2:13:23]
And it should something come in, you know, of an issue and somebody decides they want to
[2:13:26]
become a volunteer, they can apply, we can seek to appoint them, but you could have
[2:13:32]
Either option you just leave it vacant or as Council Member Flora suggested, the mayor can simply choose from a host of applications, you invite members of this fear to apply, and ultimately the candidates that the mayor believes is our best suited, obviously ratified by the entire council gets that position.
[2:13:55]
It's just giving an opportunity the member in the sphere, but so there's that option, or you just leave it vacant if.
[2:14:04]
I think it defeats the purpose if you have people that are outside the sphere voting on the other section of the sphere to me of the original intent of the pointy.
[2:14:15]
The intent is for them to serve that area that's impacted by it.
[2:14:18]
So my recommendation would be if we don't have anybody to, you know,
[2:14:23]
is really interesting from that capacity, just to potentially leave it vacant.
[2:14:29]
Okay, when I read this,
[2:14:33]
after all the discussion that we had or when it went,
[2:14:37]
well, that's not what I was thinking at all.
[2:14:39]
So anyway, oh, I don't like that one.
[2:14:41]
So I've talked a little bit to Linda about it.
[2:14:44]
I feel it's important to have input from this sphere, so I would like a person from south and a person from the north.
[2:14:56]
But my idea was advisory.
[2:15:01]
And the positions would be opened up. People could apply, if they don't apply, then the position stays open. But for me, I'd like to hear their input. What are they concerned with and stuff? They don't currently live in the city.
[2:15:18]
So I don't think they should, if a piece of property is being discussed and its contiguous with the sphere, then I think it would be good to hear their input.
[2:15:29]
But again, not a voting member, but advisory.
[2:15:33]
I have no problems with two years.
[2:15:35]
If the area is annexed, then I think immediately
[2:15:37]
would be required to resign because the intent
[2:15:41]
is to get input from the spirit of influence.
[2:15:44]
And if they're part of the city, then that's
[2:15:46]
a different circumstance.
[2:15:48]
So for me, what's written while I
[2:15:51]
appreciate staff's efforts, try to cover everything
[2:15:54]
that was suggest, and for me, it's too complicated.
[2:15:57]
especially when it comes to a well if it's voting new city and not voting on city and you know what happens if it
[2:16:03]
annexes and stuff. I think it for me I would like it to be very simple to open it up to
[2:16:11]
people who are interested in this fear and in the north and the south.
[2:16:18]
Take the applications.
[2:16:20]
It's narrowed down to who's the most competent, or the most qualified, and then bring it to the council.
[2:16:27]
You know, I would like the input of the person who's district that sphere is in, okay.
[2:16:35]
But have an advisory capacity, not a voting capacity.
[2:16:41]
If they choose to participate, great.
[2:16:43]
If they don't want to participate, then they don't.
[2:16:45]
if they miss so many meetings and they get kicked off and we open it back up again.
[2:16:49]
I would like it to be very simple and not complicated.
[2:16:55]
So they would attend all the meetings, they would just attend the meetings where there was a
[2:16:58]
spursure.
[2:16:59]
They could attend the meetings with spursage.
[2:17:01]
If they want to come to every meeting, they could, but they would not have an input.
[2:17:04]
But they would have input if it deals with the spurs of influence.
[2:17:10]
And if they were to be annexed, we would just move to remove them before their term is up.
[2:17:17]
And then seek another person from the sphere is not annexed.
[2:17:24]
That can be discussed.
[2:17:25]
They could fill their term out.
[2:17:26]
But then again, we wouldn't have input from another area that we're contemplating annexing.
[2:17:32]
Because they're not part of that area.
[2:17:33]
Do you see what I mean?
[2:17:36]
And the intent, again, is to get advice from someone who lives in the sphere.
[2:17:40]
If they're annexed, they're no longer technically in the sphere.
[2:17:44]
they're now once it gets annexed and that's, of course, a longer procedure but then they're
[2:17:48]
part of the city. They're not a representative from this fair and any longer.
[2:17:53]
They're presumably they could apply to be full members of them.
[2:17:57]
Then they could apply on an opening when we have an opening for the planning commission.
[2:18:02]
Chris, I don't like the idea of opening up one of the seven seats because who are you going
[2:18:07]
to kick off? I'm not in favor of them.
[2:18:11]
Yeah, I guess my response to the, you know, the advisory, I, and even now, right, there
[2:18:20]
was a many times where we had a workshop about the annexations.
[2:18:22]
So we are hearing from them now, and they do show up to a lot of these meetings, right?
[2:18:28]
Residents from this, so having one particular person, I don't know if I really see any more
[2:18:39]
benefit in that than what we currently do, which is as a city right, we go out there, we also
[2:18:45]
town hall meeting and the place always gets filled. So I know even now we are hearing from them.
[2:18:51]
And I think that, I don't know in terms of simplicity, you know, it'd be just one more line to the
[2:18:58]
ordinance, right? If you're from the spirit, you have an opportunity to apply. And who would we kick off?
[2:19:04]
I don't know, and we are decision, and we'd be ratified that, but I mean definitely the less qualified, I think, would be kicked off, and if we have someone more qualified from the sphere of influence, then great, if we don't, great, you know, I think, yeah, just in quick thoughts.
[2:19:24]
And the piggyback off of what he said, I understand what everybody's saying, but like for example,
[2:19:30]
when we were looking at projects that were going to go in the sphere that we needed to annex
[2:19:36]
and the sphere of influence, the people in the community came out big and said, you know, we don't want this.
[2:19:44]
What would putting one person on their view other than what we already know?
[2:19:49]
You know, they already have the community come out and talk, but if we're not going to give them an opportunity to sit down and actually cast the vote in response to it.
[2:20:00]
The response to the people that they're going to be representing, which is the sphere of influence. Then why even have it? You know, we already have them come out during these meetings when they don't like a project that's going to be, let's say, high density in this sphere.
[2:20:19]
I mean, why have them as an advisory capacity? You just open up the meeting and they're going to show up and give you all their other statements anyway.
[2:20:26]
I mean, that was a whole purpose of opening it up to it's fear was to get their input,
[2:20:32]
not just their input, but their ability to weigh in on what goes in their neighborhood,
[2:20:37]
or what's interesting to go.
[2:20:38]
I mean, been in that circumstance before and having gone through the no-one age and all
[2:20:43]
the different things that have happened.
[2:20:46]
If you don't have a signed spokesperson, people grumble and grumble and grumble and meet
[2:20:52]
everything, but you never have like representative come forward that has a picture of what
[2:20:59]
everything's going through to get answers to the area. I ended up being that spokesperson,
[2:21:07]
not by volunteering, but getting volunteered when our area annexed. And so it fell upon my
[2:21:13]
shoulders to represent all of the landowners there and the residents to figure out what was going
[2:21:18]
between what was happening in the county and what was happening in the city, and they had a point of contact
[2:21:24]
instead of the crowd, you know, kind of mobbing the city council or the county.
[2:21:33]
And it ended up getting us annexed and we ended up with some zone changes and turned out really well.
[2:21:39]
The difficulty in just having a public hearing is everybody comes and everybody speaks and then everybody goes home.
[2:21:45]
But I think you have some people in the sphere, like Jerry, you have some people like Larry Walker.
[2:21:54]
Those folks all get together and that's where that whole protection came in and they're very well aware of everything that's being discussed in the planning commission and everything else.
[2:22:05]
And that's how they unite and get together and they all show up to the meetings.
[2:22:08]
So I think they're already well informed, they're voicing their concerns or the displeasure,
[2:22:17]
and I think we already have that, we don't need one person to sit here and tell us what
[2:22:22]
they're saying, because they're going to show up and tell us any way, but...
[2:22:24]
I only have to know what's going on, and the reason why they know it's going on is because
[2:22:28]
Jared is here, but he only represents the North.
[2:22:32]
Correct, and that's where we're looking at.
[2:22:34]
We have him here.
[2:22:36]
And that's where we're having the most of the annexation going on right now.
[2:22:39]
So I mean, will we have somebody coming in when we start annexing portions of the south, maybe,
[2:22:44]
maybe not.
[2:22:46]
But I think these folks already in the north are already very well aware.
[2:22:50]
But I think that the whole purpose of the, of why we were even considering this was because
[2:22:55]
we wanted to give my voice.
[2:22:57]
And if we're not going to give them a voting right, then we're not really giving them a voice.
[2:23:01]
which is letting one person come here regularly in that.
[2:23:05]
That's just my personal opinion.
[2:23:07]
But Mark, I was with you on that.
[2:23:09]
I was of my initial reaction to this was just an advisory
[2:23:15]
position.
[2:23:16]
Like the marriage mentioned.
[2:23:18]
But like you had mentioned, after I thought about that,
[2:23:22]
giving them an opportunity to have a voice and have
[2:23:25]
say anybody can show up and be in an advisory position from the sphere. I think we just,
[2:23:33]
it would be beneficial if we gave that person a voice, give the person a vote, as to what
[2:23:40]
what goes on within their area of the sphere. But only the sphere. Correct. Absolutely.
[2:23:47]
I agree with that. I guess that I can make an argument for voting on both ways, but it
[2:23:53]
It seems like also like the – didn't sitting on the diet some way in and without the vote,
[2:24:02]
it just seems like – like you said, Martha, this a person in the meeting giving
[2:24:05]
their opinion.
[2:24:06]
I think when if the rest of the commission recognizes that they have, you know, the ability
[2:24:10]
to cast a vote into the sphere, I think it gives them more – more skin in the game.
[2:24:15]
Take them a little bit beyond that, how about land that's contiguous with sphere, or is
[2:24:20]
it only this sphere?
[2:24:25]
I would say because before you discussed it, it would be just this fair.
[2:24:30]
Joseph, Joseph, how do you comfortable with that?
[2:24:37]
Can you come after me?
[2:24:38]
Okay.
[2:24:40]
I think it's the sphere because Chris, what does this sphere is what we're interested in?
[2:24:44]
Because I agree with the mayor's point in that these votes should come when it comes to planning from the city.
[2:24:51]
From the residents of the city, I think you will ask most residents of the city.
[2:24:54]
That's why we have a council on the commission appointed from the city.
[2:24:57]
I think what we're looking at is for information.
[2:25:02]
I guess my difficulty in just agreeing to that is that, again, if we have somebody who's really qualified from this fear, you know, I don't know, previous engineer or whatever the case may be, their value, their input may definitely be more valuable, you know, to other projects that are happening around city of, you know.
[2:25:25]
And yeah, I guess it just depends on the qualification
[2:25:29]
and just the knowledge and the experience of the individual.
[2:25:33]
But I mean, if someone who's experienced levels there
[2:25:39]
and someone who's just completely qualified,
[2:25:43]
I think it'd be beneficial to the city
[2:25:45]
to have their input projects that are happening
[2:25:48]
down south or downtown Chino, or what the case may be.
[2:25:52]
I mean, we don't know who that individual is,
[2:25:54]
but they may be like myself or yourself, Karen, who will just travel around the city.
[2:26:00]
So it's because they live in a north that doesn't mean they don't know what's happening
[2:26:03]
in the south or at the central part of the city of Chino, and again, I think that's going
[2:26:09]
to be up to the mayor and the council to find that right person, but...
[2:26:16]
Well, we'll get to this person. I think you're being outvoted so far.
[2:26:20]
that's true because when when the area annexes they would then have a right to apply
[2:26:26]
for the planning commission when an opening comes. Yeah, yeah, so that's 34 years away,
[2:26:33]
but yeah, it could be, but yeah, so I guess, yeah, right now I wouldn't, I wouldn't, I wouldn't
[2:26:40]
cast me a vote for that. Yeah, and I think the other thing too is I would say that some of the
[2:26:50]
minds of the residents that are in our sphere, because they are impacted by our services,
[2:26:55]
our rules.
[2:26:56]
They do a lot of their business, and, you know, has probably changed in the past seven
[2:27:02]
to ten years, where I think, in my perspective, and speaking with a lot of those residents,
[2:27:08]
is that they were probably happy with our growth control measures and different land use,
[2:27:20]
you know, it ordinances according to our general plan.
[2:27:24]
But now that they're experiencing the growth
[2:27:26]
of our experiencing and in this area you've touched on
[2:27:31]
with the lack of a proper, you know,
[2:27:33]
an updated general plan for this fear,
[2:27:36]
I think a lot of our residents would probably appreciate,
[2:27:39]
you know, the option of local annexation
[2:27:42]
because it's actually going to provide them
[2:27:44]
with more local control.
[2:27:45]
That's why we did it.
[2:27:46]
So I think if you asked this question 30 years ago, I think there would probably be a different
[2:27:52]
perspective on it because there wasn't the abundance of growth in this community that
[2:27:56]
there is now.
[2:27:57]
But I think now there's probably more of an interest for them to say, hey, we see that the
[2:28:02]
tide has shifted that there's probably more opportunity for us to have more destiny over
[2:28:07]
our future with annexation into local control.
[2:28:10]
So I think that's going to be an interesting perspective we can get from a resident living in
[2:28:17]
I've said this often, sometimes the north portion of the severe annexation doesn't always make
[2:28:22]
as much systemy as the core, the center core, but it always impactful to us.
[2:28:28]
It's interesting though that you made that comment because that's exactly why our area
[2:28:31]
did annexed because we wanted to have him put on what was happening in the county didn't care.
[2:28:38]
County was going to do what the county was going to do and we were adamant to try to protect
[2:28:42]
as much as we could and get a logical transition
[2:28:47]
from condominiums back to the one acre properties.
[2:28:52]
And so that's why our area annex was to have a voice
[2:28:55]
and have control.
[2:28:57]
That's presently occurring with the annexation
[2:28:58]
in the Philadelphia and East Endmare, right?
[2:29:02]
And as well as the ongoing complaints from residents
[2:29:06]
about bending in county areas
[2:29:09]
that are very dangerous injuries.
[2:29:11]
Because we don't have to come here.
[2:29:12]
Yeah, we were talking about
[2:29:14]
the death of these costumes streets in areas in populating areas.
[2:29:18]
And people's front and backyards,
[2:29:21]
they would prefer to have more, more local control over it.
[2:29:25]
So things have changed by I'm saying,
[2:29:27]
you know, it's changed in yet.
[2:29:28]
It's the same.
[2:29:29]
People want control over their destiny.
[2:29:34]
Okay, seems like we have foreign favor
[2:29:37]
of doing the two seats and voting, but only in the sphere.
[2:29:43]
I'll go ahead and go with that.
[2:29:45]
To your terms with the person, if the area annexes,
[2:29:51]
then they would, that's an item still to be totally vetted out,
[2:29:57]
but the person would either, once the annexation.
[2:30:00]
The question is complete, either then resign or see, and we ask for applications from the news sphere or the rest of the sphere, or they fill out their two-year terms.
[2:30:09]
I'd like him put on that. And if we don't get an application for one of those days open, it stays open and then we still can accept that application until someone does apply and is qualified.
[2:30:22]
You're good? Okay. Any questions, staff?
[2:30:25]
Do you want to if I just run through these so voting or non-voting? I'm hearing voting voting?
[2:30:31]
Voting sphere of influence only we're going to have two
[2:30:36]
Uns I was going to get to that on two members one from the north and one from the south presumably if a sphere area goes away because it's fully annexed
[2:30:46]
Then you need an
[2:30:47]
You only have one member left. Oh, you need to update the ordinance at that point anyway
[2:30:53]
So if they are, okay, so voting, then it's not citywide, it's only actually within this
[2:31:03]
fear, not abutting this fear within 300 feet, it actually has to be in this fear and
[2:31:08]
each member votes within their own fear area.
[2:31:13]
If one member has a conflict or they're serving it, because alternate for the other member, do
[2:31:20]
get to vote on the others fear. I don't have a problem with that. How about you guys? If through
[2:31:27]
con conflict, somebody can't attend the other sphere representative or conflict with a project
[2:31:34]
or conflict with a person?
[2:31:39]
I don't have any problem with that. I don't think it would cause it.
[2:31:43]
I don't have a problem with that. I think when we look back into the, you know, with the legislative
[2:31:47]
of the sphere influences is to do those residents.
[2:31:51]
So I don't see why we would want that person to weigh in,
[2:31:55]
but well, they can't leak.
[2:31:56]
Well, if they're voting, they can't leakly.
[2:31:59]
So the other representative would be
[2:32:02]
incumbent on him or her to represent that area for them.
[2:32:08]
But I want to start to see what I mean.
[2:32:10]
Term of two years, it automatically ends upon the annexation
[2:32:15]
at which time the removed member is welcome to apply.
[2:32:21]
They resigned and we could have a new member.
[2:32:25]
I think that answer is all my question.
[2:32:27]
That's all there is I have to.
[2:32:28]
Hey, is there any input from the audience on this issue?
[2:32:33]
Seeing none, then I guess any last comments.
[2:32:39]
Okay, then we will adjourn to our next regular meeting
[2:32:43]
that will be held on Tuesday, September 17th at 6th
[2:32:47]
with a closed session no earlier than for necessary.
[2:32:52]
And I think we missed the debate.