Agenda
[0:26]
1 ROLL CALL AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
[2:06]
2 COMMUNICATIONS
[3:49]
3 APPROVAL OF MEETING MINUTES
[4:49]
4 CONSENT AGENDA[Consent Boiler|B1]
[4:50]
Items 1 through 18
[5:46]
260596 Budget and Appropriation Ordinance for Departments - FYs 2026-2027 and 2027-2028
[6:52]
260596 Budget and Appropriation Ordinance for Departments - FYs 2026-2027 and 2027-2028
[6:53]
260597 Annual Salary Ordinance - FYs 2026-2027 and 2027-2028
[6:53]
260598 Administrative Code - San Francisco Self-Insurance Surety Bond Fund
[6:56]
260599 Business and Tax Regulations Code - Early Care and Education Commercial Rents Tax Baseline - FYs 2026-2027 and 2027-2028
[7:18]
260601 Funding Reallocation - Our City, Our Home Fund - Homelessness Gross Receipts Tax - Services to Address Homelessness
[7:26]
260600 Health Code - Patient Rates for Fiscal Years 2026-2027 and 2027-2028
[7:26]
260655 Administrative Codes - Weights and Measures Fees
[7:30]
260602 Neighborhood Beautification and Graffiti Clean-Up Fund Tax Designation Ceiling
[19:10]
260543 Police Code - Penalties for Prohibited Discharge of Fireworks
[20:11]
260486 Accept and Expend Grant - Retroactive - California Department of Parks and Recreation - General Fund Specified Grant - Sunset Dunes Striping and Signage Project - $200,000
[21:05]
260711 Accept and Expend Grant - Jain-Trivedi Fund - "Be The Jury" Program - $250,000
[21:33]
260713 Accept and Expend Gift - Retroactive - Epic Systems Corporation - 2025 UGM Safety Net Grant - $12,710.44
[21:33]
260714 Accept and Expend Gift - Retroactive - Epic Systems Corporation - 2025 Safety Net Gift - $115,000
[21:34]
260735 Accept and Expend Gift - Retroactive - Epic Systems Corporation - Help Low Income and At-Risk Populations - 2025 Unrestricted Gift - $37,500
[22:29]
260726 Contract Amendment - Resource Design Interiors - System Furniture - Not to Exceed $10,630,000
[22:30]
260727 Contract Amendment - Resource Design Interiors - System Furniture - Not to Exceed $17,750,000
[23:07]
260738 Accept and Expend Grant - Retroactive - State of California - Essential Access Health - Comprehensive Sexual and Reproductive Health Program - $250,000
[23:08]
260737 Accept and Expend Grant Increase - Retroactive - Centers for Disease Control and Prevention - Strengthening STD Prevention and Control for Health Departments (STD PCHD) - $15,873,392
[24:04]
260743 Emergency Declaration - Recreation and Park Department - Marina Yacht Harbor Dredging - Estimated Cost of Emergency Work Exceeds $2,500,000
[24:22]
260793 Acquisition of Real Property - $2,178,786 - Amended Loan - NTE $13,666,153 - Residential Ground Lease - ABR $100 - New Asia Housing, L.P. - Commercial Ground Lease - ABR $1 - CCDC New Asia Commercial LLC - 758 and 772 Pacific Ave - 100% Affordable Housing
[24:23]
260794 Rent Forgiveness, Month-to-Month Rent Reduction - Shew Yick Trust One, Robert Yick Exempt Assets Trust, Hon So, Inc., Hon Keung So, and Candy Mei-Yiu So - New Asia Restaurant - $1,172,500
[25:59]
7 SPECIAL ORDER 2:30 P.M. - Recognition of Commendations
[2:08:31]
260795 Lease Agreement - Retroactive - 3rd Street Youth Center and Clinic - 888 Post Street - $1 Annual Base Rent
[2:09:23]
260796 Apply for Grant - United States Department of Housing and Urban Development - Continuum of Care Program - Anticipated Revenue in Excess of $16,000,000
[2:09:51]
260797 Settlement of Unlitigated Claim - International Federation of Professional and Technical Engineers, Local 21 - $201,174 - Suspending Rule 3.25.2
[2:10:25]
260692 Initiative Ordinance - Business and Tax Regulations Code - Real Property Transfer Tax Foreclosure Exemption
[2:17:06]
260551 Resolution of Intention to Issue Bonds - Annexation of Property to Infrastructure and Revitalization Financing District No. 1 (Treasure Island)
[2:17:07]
260552 Approving Annexation Supplement - Amended and Restated Infrastructure Plan - Infrastructure and Revitalization Financing District No. 1 (Treasure Island)
[2:17:36]
260570 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - Alexander Adams Home
[2:17:55]
260571 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - Born Home
[2:18:02]
260572 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - Charles Katz Home
[2:18:05]
260573 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - Charles L. Hinkel Home
[2:18:10]
260574 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - De Urioste Home - James C. Hormel Mansion
[2:18:22]
260575 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - Duboce Triangle Greek Revival Home
[2:18:29]
260576 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - Early Haight Ashbury Farmhouse
[2:18:35]
260577 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - Elliott M. Wilson Home
[2:18:42]
260578 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - Engine Company No. 44 / Adams-Van Hoesen House
[2:18:50]
260579 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - Guerrero Street Double Stick Eastlake Home
[2:19:00]
260580 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - Henry Street Rowhouses
[2:19:06]
260581 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - Holy Innocents Church
[2:19:11]
260582 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - John J. Clark House
[2:19:18]
260583 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - Mission Congregational Church
[2:19:24]
260584 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - Phoenix Brewery
[2:19:31]
260587 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - Richard Spreckels Mansion / Buena Vista Studios
[2:19:39]
260588 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - Second Church of Christ Scientist
[2:19:46]
260589 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - Tietz-Beneke House
[2:19:53]
260590 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - William Shaughnessy Home
[2:19:59]
260681 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - Fernando Nelson Home
[2:20:04]
260682 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - Lange House
[2:20:10]
260754 Planning Code - Landmark Designation - Engine Company No. 33
[2:20:26]
260662 Mayoral Reappointment, Building Inspection Commission - Lindsey Maclise
[2:20:41]
260663 Mayoral Reappointment, Public Works Commission - Eleanor Blume
[2:20:58]
260665 Mayoral Reappointment, Board of Appeals - John Trasvina
[2:21:15]
260666 Mayoral Reappointment, Public Utilities Commission - Joshua Arce
[2:21:52]
260829 Appointment, Sanitation and Streets Commission - Kimberlee Hartwig-Schulman
[2:22:07]
260710 Hunters View HOPE SF - Street and Public Infrastructure Acceptance; Official Right-of-Way Widths and Grades
[2:23:02]
260628 Commemorative Street Name Designation - "Dr. Carlota Texidor del Portillo Way" - Bartlett Street between 21st Street and 22nd Street
[2:23:34]
260818 Declaring Intent to Initiate Undergrounding Process - Homestead Street
[2:23:52]
260621 Liquor License Transfer - 456-460 Larkin Street - Reggie and Maude’s
[2:24:33]
260697 Liquor License Issuance - 835 Larkin Street - Tenderloin Museum
[2:24:45]
260706 Liquor License Transfer - 995 Ellis Street - College Market
[2:24:46]
260752 Liquor License Transfer - 2135 Buchanan Street - Hello Mart
[2:25:19]
260667 Mayoral Reappointment, Public Utilities Commission - Kate Stacy
[2:25:43]
260769 Mayoral Appointment, Planning Commission - Mike Chen
[2:26:01]
260863 Presidential Appointment, Planning Commission - Elizabeth Macdonald
[2:26:02]
260864 Presidential Appointment, Planning Commission - Joel Koppel
[2:26:27]
9 ROLL CALL FOR INTRODUCTIONS [Roll Call Boiler|B1, B2]
[3:03:39]
10 PUBLIC COMMENT [Public Comment Boiler|B1, B2, N1]
[3:35:36]
12 FOR ADOPTION WITHOUT COMMITTEE REFERENCE[For Adoption Boiler|B1,B2]
[3:35:36]
Items 88 through 95
[3:37:05]
260850 Afghan American Heritage Month - August 2026
[3:39:18]
260851 National Fentanyl Prevention and Awareness Day - August 21, 2026
[3:41:54]
260852 South Asian American Heritage Month - July 18 through August 17, 2026
[3:47:01]
260865 Disability Pride Month - July 2026
[3:50:24]
260861 Preparation of Proponent/Opponent Ballot Arguments and Rebuttal Ballot Arguments - November 3, 2026
[3:52:44]
14 ADJOURNMENT
Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
[0:09]
. >> good afternoon welcome to
[0:13]
the july 28th 2026 regular meeting of the san francisco
[0:17]
board of supervisors. Madam clerk, please call the
[0:20]
roll. >> yes supervisor chan chan
[0:23]
present supervisor chen chen present supervisor dorsey
[0:27]
dorsey present supervisor fielder fielder present
[0:31]
supervisor mahmood mahmood presents supervisor gentleman
[0:35]
president mendham and present supervisor melgar melgar
[0:38]
present supervisor sardar sauter present supervisor
[0:42]
cheryl cheryl not present supervisor walton walton
[0:47]
present supervisor wang huang present mr. President you have
[0:53]
a quorum. >> thank you, madam clerk.
[0:54]
the san francisco. San francisco board of
[0:58]
supervisors acknowledges that we are on the unceded ancestral
[0:59]
homeland of the ramakrishna loney who are the original
[1:03]
inhabitants of the san francisco peninsula.
[1:06]
as the indigenous stewards of this land and in accordance
[1:09]
with their traditions the ramakrishna loni have never
[1:11]
ceded lost nor forgotten their responsibilities as the
[1:14]
caretakers of this place as well as for all peoples who
[1:17]
reside in their traditional territory.
[1:19]
as guests we recognize that we benefit from living and working
[1:22]
on their traditional homeland. We wish to pay our respects by
[1:25]
acknowledging the ancestors, elders and relatives of the
[1:29]
ramakrishna loni community and by affirming their
[1:30]
sovereign rights as first peoples.
[1:32]
colleagues, will you join me in reciting the pledge of
[1:34]
allegiance pledge allegiance to the united states of america
[1:40]
and to the republic for which it stands one nation
[1:46]
indivisible with liberty and justice for all.
[1:52]
>> on behalf of the board, I want to acknowledge the staff
[1:56]
at s.f. Gov tv today that is especially kaleena mendoza.
[1:59]
they record each of our meetings and make transcripts
[2:01]
available to the public online .
[2:04]
>> madam clerk, do you have any communications?
[2:05]
yes, mr. President. The board of supervisors
[2:08]
welcomes your attendance here in person in the board's
[2:11]
legislative chamber room 250 on the second floor of city hall.
[2:14]
when you can't be here, the proceedings are airing live on
[2:18]
s.f. Gov tv's local cable channel or live streaming at
[2:21]
sfo vtv talk. As of july 1st pursuant to sb
[2:24]
707 the full board is required to take remote public comment
[2:28]
during the public comment period.
[2:29]
we will prioritize those who have joined in person and then
[2:32]
hear from our remote callers. The board has also approved a
[2:36]
rule to address disorderly public comment.
[2:39]
members of the public must keep their comments germane to
[2:41]
matters within the jurisdiction of the board.
[2:43]
any comments that contain personal attacks, harassment or
[2:47]
discriminatory remarks directed to a city employee or board
[2:51]
member are outside of the scope of this body and shall be
[2:54]
redirected. Failure to immediately redirect
[2:55]
those comments will result in that individual's forfeiture
[2:58]
of remaining time and we will transition to the next speaker
[3:02]
. Please remember to address your
[3:03]
comments to the board as a whole and not to individual
[3:06]
members. To submit public comment
[3:07]
in writing send an email to bossa at safety of dawg or via
[3:11]
your postal service to the san francisco board of supervisors.
[3:15]
number one dr. Carlton be good place city hall room 244 san
[3:18]
francisco, california nine four 1 or 2.
[3:21]
to make a reasonable accommodation for a future
[3:25]
meeting under the americans with disabilities act or to
[3:27]
request language assistance please contact the clerk's
[3:32]
office at least two business days in advance by calling
[3:35]
(415) 554-5184 members. That concludes my
[3:39]
communication. >> thank you, mr. President.
[3:40]
thank you, madame clerk. All right.
[3:46]
let's go to our approval of meeting minutes.
[3:50]
>> today the board is considering approval of the
[3:53]
june 23rd board meeting minutes and the june 22nd june 24th
[3:56]
and june 25th special meeting minutes at the budget
[4:00]
and appropriations committee which constituted a quorum of
[4:01]
the board. >> can I have a motion to
[4:04]
approve the minutes as presented moved by walton
[4:07]
seconded by chan? >> madam clerk, can you please
[4:08]
call the roll? Yes on the minutes supervisor
[4:11]
walton walton I supervisor wong huang I supervisor chan chen I
[4:19]
supervisor chen chen I supervisor dorsey dorsey I
[4:23]
supervisor fielder fielder I supervisor mahmud mahmud I
[4:27]
supervisor gentleman I mendelson I supervisor melgar
[4:31]
melgar I supervisor sardar sadr I supervisor cheryl cheryl
[4:37]
either lebanese without objection the minutes will be
[4:42]
approved after public comment as presented madam clerk let's
[4:45]
go to the consent agenda please call items one through 18 items
[4:49]
one through 18 are on consent. These items are considered
[4:53]
routine if a member objects an item may be removed
[4:56]
and considered separately. >> please call the roll on the
[5:00]
consent agenda. Supervisor walton walton I
[5:04]
supervisor wong wong I supervisor chan chen I
[5:11]
supervisor chen chen I supervisor dorsey dorsey I
[5:15]
supervisor fielder fielder I supervisor mahmood mahmood I
[5:19]
supervisor gentleman hi amendment I supervisor melgar
[5:23]
melgar I supervisor sadr sadr I supervisor cheryl cheryl I
[5:30]
there are lebanese without objection the audiences are
[5:33]
finally passed and the resolutions are adopted.
[5:37]
>> let's go to unfinished business please call the budget
[5:38]
items 19 through 26 together items 19 through 26 comprise
[5:44]
the final reading of the annual budget item 19 is a budget
[5:48]
and appropriation ordinance appropriating all estimated
[5:52]
receipts and all estimated expenditures for departments of
[5:53]
the city and county of san francisco as of july 1st, 2026
[5:58]
for the fiscal year ending june 30th 2027 and 2028.
[6:02]
I don't 20 is this annual salary ordinance enumerating
[6:05]
positions in the annual budget and appropriation ordinance for
[6:09]
the fiscal year ending june 30th 2027 and 2028 know in 2021
[6:14]
is the ordinance amending the administrative code to
[6:18]
authorize the city administrator to pause, reduce
[6:19]
or return the annual contributions by the
[6:22]
departments that contract for public works to the san
[6:26]
francisco selfish self-insurance 30 bond fund
[6:31]
item 22 is an ordinance modifying the baseline funding
[6:32]
requirements for early care and education programs
[6:35]
in fiscal years 2627 and 2728 to enable the city to use the
[6:42]
interest earned from the early care and education commercial
[6:43]
rents tax for those baseline programs.
[6:48]
item 23 is an ordinance amending the health code to set
[6:49]
patient rates for services provided by the department of
[6:53]
public health for fiscal years 2627 and 2728.
[6:58]
item 24 is an ordinance amending the administrative
[7:00]
code to increase certain utility meter fees
[7:05]
and authorize the comptroller to annually justify fees for
[7:06]
weights and measures and utility meters up to the
[7:09]
maximum allowable under state law.
[7:13]
and item 25 is an ordinance temporarily suspending the cap
[7:17]
on the use of homelessness gross receipts tax revenues to
[7:20]
fund short term rental subsidies and finding that
[7:24]
temporarily allowing for increased expenditures on short
[7:25]
term rental subsidies will further the purposes of our the
[7:29]
our city our home fund. And finally item 26 is the
[7:33]
ordinance adopting the neighborhood beautification
[7:36]
and graffiti cleanup fund tax designation ceiling for tax
[7:39]
year 2026. >> chair chan thank you present
[7:43]
amendment colleagues I rise before you at a very proud
[7:48]
moment. A month ago the budget
[7:52]
and appropriations committee completed its work to bring
[7:56]
before the full board unanimously recommend it for
[8:00]
fiscal year 2627 and 2728 chu fiscal year budget and today we
[8:06]
are poised to hopefully again unanimous city approved this
[8:11]
budget something that this board supervisors has not done
[8:14]
in six years and this budget while it can certainly be
[8:18]
improved upon is something we all can be very proud of all 11
[8:23]
of us we will restore more than $28 million in cuts to vital
[8:26]
services, retain frontline jobs and safeguard more than $1.3
[8:33]
billion in reserve funds to protect against further
[8:37]
anticipated cuts from trump's administration.
[8:41]
for the past four years our work my team and I as chair of
[8:45]
the budget committee has centered on reducing wasteful
[8:49]
spending, creating our rails against corruption, saving for
[8:53]
the future by putting reasonable dollars on reserve
[8:57]
and reversing cuts affecting the most vulnerable san
[9:01]
franciscans and saving essential jobs and services.
[9:05]
I believe that together we have been successful with this work
[9:09]
this year again in collaboration with
[9:12]
mayor lurie we have accomplished a lot and thanks
[9:16]
to him and his team this year we invested eight $8 million
[9:20]
annually to replace the san francisco fire department's
[9:24]
fire trucks, all of which are more than ten years old with
[9:27]
some up to 50 years. So we funded new pfa freeze
[9:31]
uniform for every firefighter by july of this year replacing
[9:35]
all uniforms containing cancer causing chemicals of course as
[9:42]
mentioned earlier that we now put together a 1.3 billion
[9:45]
dollars in reserve to safeguard against trump's cut to health
[9:49]
care. We have ensure full funding for
[9:52]
immigration legal defense funds and immigrant resources
[9:56]
in collaboration with all members and particularly the
[10:01]
budget and appropriation committee.
[10:04]
we restore $28 million in reinvestment and those
[10:08]
include vital services to support seniors employment
[10:11]
opportunities for youth critical programing
[10:14]
and services for our lgbtq. A transgender linux and bipoc
[10:19]
communities we fully fund it free city college we also fund
[10:23]
vital hiv prevention and care services.
[10:30]
we reverse layoffs for workers that provide services at 311
[10:34]
call centers laguna honda hospital and child care
[10:38]
facilities under the human service says agency.
[10:42]
this budget showed that we can and should move forward a
[10:46]
spending plan that prioritizes support for our most vulnerable
[10:50]
communities and that we can still safeguard for our future.
[10:54]
so I am proud of the work we have accomplished together
[10:57]
and honored to have serves san francisco as your budget
[11:01]
committee chair under two different mayors two different
[11:03]
board presidents and through 18 civil rights supervisors.
[11:10]
>> and so thank you colleagues. Why are we still facing tough
[11:11]
challenges ahead? The work we have done together
[11:15]
has moved san francisco in a positive direction.
[11:18]
>> so while this is my last year shepherding the city's
[11:22]
budget as chair, please know colleagues I am here at your
[11:26]
service to assist all of you to make sure that we continue to
[11:30]
stay on this positive trajectory.
[11:33]
meanwhile though I continue to hope not just right now but
[11:38]
remaining of the year that all of us continue to stay vigilant
[11:42]
in guarding the city's fiscal health.
[11:46]
so of course I just want to thank president amendment for
[11:50]
appointing me to as budget committee chair and thank you
[11:53]
colleagues and thank you vice chair dorsey for being a vice
[11:57]
chair really throughout the year not just during the budget
[12:01]
process. So thank you colleagues for
[12:02]
your support. >> it's been an honor serving
[12:05]
you. Thank you.
[12:06]
supervisor dorsey thank you president randleman.
[12:09]
colleagues, I want to start by thanking budget chair connie
[12:13]
chan for her outstanding leadership throughout the
[12:14]
budget process as I have witnessed here in city hall for
[12:17]
many years praying prior to joining this board guiding our
[12:20]
city through challenging fiscal times is no small task.
[12:24]
chair chan has approached it for more years than just this
[12:28]
past one with professionalism, intelligence and a
[12:31]
collaborative spirit that benefited all san franciscans.
[12:34]
and as I said at the budget and finance committee two weeks
[12:35]
ago I know that some men my age might bristle at the notion of
[12:40]
having to admit they've been well mentored by someone who's
[12:43]
younger than they are. Fortunately I'm not one of
[12:47]
those men and I just want to say through the chair, connie,
[12:48]
you've been a great mentor to me as your vice chair on
[12:51]
budget. Thank you.
[12:54]
I'm also grateful to chair chan staff and especially francis
[12:57]
shea for the generous collaboration the entire office
[13:01]
brought to working with my office through the budget
[13:03]
process. Thank you all.
[13:05]
that same spirit of partnership extended to many others of
[13:06]
course I want to thank mayor lurie and his team budget
[13:10]
director sophia kettler for their collaboration every step
[13:14]
of the way. Ms. Kettler was thoughtful,
[13:17]
responsive and deeply engaged throughout these negotiations.
[13:20]
I'd also like to thank comptroller greg wagner and his
[13:21]
team but the budget and legislative analyst office
[13:25]
and every department that spent countless hours and shared
[13:29]
their expertise in answering our questions and providing the
[13:33]
information we needed to make well-informed decisions.
[13:37]
I want to thank my colleagues on the budget
[13:38]
and appropriations committee and all the colleagues on this
[13:41]
board. This was one of the most
[13:44]
collaborative budget processes I have ever observed.
[13:45]
let alone been a part of. We brought different
[13:49]
perspectives and priorities to the table of course, but we
[13:52]
approached this work with mutual respect a willingness to
[13:56]
listen and a shared commitment to finding common ground.
[13:59]
for much of that spirit I also want to give a special shout
[14:02]
out to president randleman for the spirit of cooperation that
[14:04]
you have imparted in your leadership of this board.
[14:07]
this year's budget was never going to be easy.
[14:10]
we met we entered this process facing a significant structural
[14:12]
deficit compounded by threats posed by the federal
[14:15]
government. I believe our responsibility
[14:19]
was to make decisions that put the city's finances on a more
[14:20]
sustainable path for years to come.
[14:24]
at the same time, budgets are ultimately about people
[14:27]
and throughout this process I appreciated that the committee
[14:29]
remained focused on listening to communities and responding
[14:31]
as best we could. The board's spending plan
[14:35]
reflects that effort. I think restoring
[14:38]
and protecting programs that matter deeply to san
[14:39]
franciscans while remaining mindful of our city's fiscal
[14:42]
constraints. Perhaps closest to my heart,
[14:45]
I'm proud that we found a way to stabilize funding for
[14:46]
programs that train the next generation of addiction
[14:49]
and recovery specialists and community mental health
[14:51]
counselors at a time when san francisco is making historic
[14:54]
investments in behavioral health and recovery services.
[14:58]
we also have to invest in the workforce that makes these
[15:01]
services possible many of whom are in recovery themselves
[15:05]
and who are finding real purpose in helping others.
[15:07]
I'm grateful to for the partnership of supervisor
[15:11]
sharon chen and her staff jackie prager in particular
[15:14]
in working to preserve essential community services
[15:15]
especially for the filipino community so that we share
[15:18]
in district six and 11 and beyond.
[15:21]
those organizations provide trusted cultural competence
[15:25]
support that thousands of residents rely on every year.
[15:26]
I'm proud we were able to work together to protect them.
[15:29]
finally, thanks to my team my chief of staff dominica donovan
[15:33]
who staffed me on this budget. Thanks to to madison tam, brian
[15:37]
dahl and mohana somebody from my team I'm incredibly grateful
[15:40]
for the dedicated professionals I get to work with who are part
[15:44]
of my team and I'm pleased that we're able to preserve
[15:45]
important services for older adults across our city
[15:48]
including health programs that provide services to the lgbtq
[15:53]
plus community and those of us aging with hiv.
[15:56]
these programs are lifelines for seniors and caregivers
[16:00]
alike and they deserve our continued support.
[16:01]
and finally, I truly appreciate the collegiality of all my
[16:04]
colleagues in this process. We didn't agree on everything
[16:07]
but we approached these decisions in good faith and a
[16:09]
shared commit to serving the city we love.
[16:11]
thank you all. And for these reasons I'm happy
[16:13]
to support this budget. Supervisor sauter thank you
[16:18]
president madeline. >> colleagues if we take
[16:19]
ourselves back a few months I think we all knew the original
[16:23]
budget wasn't acceptable and had too many cuts and was
[16:26]
too blunt and how it made those decisions.
[16:27]
I know we all spent countless hours since trying to get this
[16:30]
budget to a better place. Maybe not the exact perfect
[16:34]
place any of us would have liked but a much better place.
[16:38]
and in a moment when we see our federal government turning on
[16:42]
its most vulnerable and proud that the budget committee
[16:46]
and now this board stood united and looking out for the city,
[16:50]
I'm also proud that we were able to fight for and win back
[16:53]
many of the proposed cuts. In particular we advocated
[16:56]
and won back funding to save programs that serve our seniors
[16:58]
small business grants that fuel our neighborhoods and services
[17:02]
to support our immigrant population.
[17:04]
>> over the past few months we've spent a lot of time
[17:08]
listening to communities both inside these chambers and out
[17:12]
in the neighborhoods. And through that I've heard
[17:13]
loud and clear that residents want transparency from city
[17:16]
hall. They want partnership and they
[17:19]
want to see city dollars turned into results.
[17:23]
those are values that don't end today with the passage of this
[17:24]
budget in which we need to keep top of mind going forward
[17:27]
because this certainly won't be the last challenging budget
[17:30]
before us. I want to appreciate my
[17:34]
colleagues particularly on the budget committee led by chair
[17:36]
chan or vice chair dorsey. And thanks as well to my team
[17:39]
for navigating a challenging and time consuming last few
[17:43]
months particularly my chief of staff tina bell and michelle
[17:46]
andrews as well. Colleagues, I would
[17:47]
respectfully ask for your vote today so that we can pass this
[17:51]
budget. I will add only a few thank you
[17:58]
since most of the thank you's have been have been made I do
[18:00]
want to thank sophie, marie and renee all the joy in my
[18:05]
office. I do want to thank special
[18:06]
thanks to chair chan who has now done this for four years
[18:09]
and ably led processes with different boards and different
[18:13]
priorities but has done it with a unique set of skills.
[18:20]
and so thank you to you and to frances shea and to all the
[18:24]
folks in your office who got us through that.
[18:27]
to my other colleagues on the committee.
[18:29]
thank you for your participation for all of your
[18:32]
work and then I would also like to give a little shout out to
[18:36]
cheyenne chen who agreed to sit in for me on a number of of
[18:40]
those budget and appropriations committee meetings.
[18:44]
>> I hope it was a useful exercise and experience for
[18:47]
you. I appreciate your well your
[18:50]
willingness to do that for me and with that, madam clerk.
[18:55]
I actually I don't think we need to do a roll call.
[18:58]
I think we can take this same house, same call.
[19:02]
>> without objection, the ordinances are finally passed.
[19:05]
>> please call item 27. Item number 27 is an ordinance
[19:09]
amending the police code to provide penalties for the
[19:12]
prohibited discharge of fireworks including a first
[19:14]
offense with a fine not less than 125 or more than 250
[19:19]
and is second in any subsequent offenses with a fine not fine
[19:23]
not less than 250 or more than 750 or imprisonment for not
[19:28]
more than six months. >> this one we do need to do a
[19:29]
roll call on on item 27 supervisor walton walton no
[19:35]
supervisor wong wang I. Supervisor chan chin I
[19:42]
supervisor chen chen I supervisor dorsey dorsey I
[19:46]
supervisor fielder. Fielder no supervisor mahmood
[19:50]
mahmood I supervisor benjamin hi benjamin I supervisor melgar
[19:57]
melgar I supervisor sardar sardar I supervisors cheryl.
[20:01]
cheryl either nine eyes and two nose with supervisor walton
[20:06]
and fielder voting no. >> the ordinance is finally
[20:07]
passed madam clerk please call item number 28.
[20:13]
item number 28 is a resolution retroactively authorizing a
[20:17]
grant from the california department of parks
[20:18]
and recreation for the sunset dunes striping and signage
[20:21]
project in the amount of 200,000 for a grant performance
[20:25]
period starting july 1st, 2025 through june 30th 2028.
[20:30]
>> please call the roll and item 28 supervisor walton
[20:33]
walton I supervisor wong wong I supervisor chen chen I
[20:40]
supervisor chen chen I supervisor dorsey dorsey I
[20:44]
supervisor fielder fielder I supervisor mahmood mahmood I
[20:49]
supervisor maintenance hi amendment I supervisor melgar
[20:53]
melgar I supervisor solder solder I supervisor cheryl
[20:59]
cheryl either 11 days without objection the resolutions
[21:03]
adopted please call item 29 item 29 is a resolution
[21:07]
authorizing a grant in the amount of 250,000 from the jane
[21:10]
privity fund for the purpose of increasing your per diems to
[21:14]
qualifying low income through the b b the jury program from
[21:20]
august 1st 2026 through july 31st 2031 I can take this item
[21:24]
same house, same call. Without objection the
[21:28]
resolution is adopted. Please call 3332 together items
[21:32]
30 through 32 or 3 resolutions to retroactively accept
[21:34]
and expend gifts from the epic systems corporation to help low
[21:38]
income and at risk populations for the period of july 1st 2025
[21:43]
through june 30th 2026. Item 30 authorizes monetary
[21:46]
monetary gift and entitled a 2025 utmb safety net grant
[21:51]
in the amount of approximately 12.7 thousand item 31
[21:54]
authorizes a monetary gift entitled 2025 safety net gift
[21:59]
in the amount of 115,000 and item 32 authorizes a
[22:05]
monetary gift entitled 2025 unrestricted gift in the amount
[22:10]
of 37 37.5 thousand. >> same house, same call.
[22:14]
without objection the resolutions are adopted.
[22:17]
please call items 33 and 34 together items 33 and 34 two
[22:23]
resolutions approving third amendments with resource design
[22:26]
interiors for system furniture item 33 increases amount by
[22:31]
approximately 1.6 million for a total not to exceed amount of
[22:34]
approximately 10.6 million and extending the term by three
[22:37]
years for a term of nine years from september 15th 2022
[22:43]
september 14th 2029 and item 34 increases the amount by
[22:45]
approximately 8.8 million for a total not to exceed amount of
[22:50]
approximately 17.8 million and extending the term by three
[22:53]
years, three months and 17 days for a term of nine years from
[22:57]
january 1st 2021 to june 2nd. Some I mean to december 31st
[23:00]
2029 same house, same call. >> without objection the
[23:06]
resolutions are adopted. Please call 35 and 36 together
[23:08]
items 35 and 36 are two resolutions retroactively
[23:13]
authorizing the department of public health to accept
[23:16]
and expend grants in the amount of approximately 1.1 million
[23:20]
for a total grant amount of approximately 15.9 million from
[23:23]
the centers for disease control and prevention for
[23:27]
participation in program and table entitled
[23:30]
strengthening std prevention and control for health
[23:31]
departments for the period of july january 1st, 2019 to
[23:37]
february 28th 2027 and item 36 in the amount of 250,000 from
[23:44]
the state of california through essential access health for
[23:47]
participation in a program entitled comprehensive sexual
[23:51]
and reproductive health program for a term of one year from
[23:54]
april 1st, 2026 through march 31st 2027 same house, same call
[23:58]
without objection the resolutions are adopted.
[24:03]
please call 37. >> item 37 is a resolution
[24:07]
approving the recreation and parks department general
[24:08]
manager declaration of emergency for emergency
[24:11]
dredging at the san francisco marina yacht harbor estimated
[24:14]
to cost in excess of 2.5 million.
[24:17]
>> same house, same call without objection the
[24:21]
resolutions adopted. >> please call 38 and 39
[24:22]
together items 38 and 39 or 2 resolutions regarding
[24:26]
construction of affordable housing item 38 authorizes each
[24:31]
city to acquire the real property located at 758 pacific
[24:35]
avenue from new age to housing lp for approximately 2.2
[24:39]
million approving a third amend at the third amendment to the
[24:42]
loan agreement and the total amount not to exceed
[24:46]
approximately 13.7 million enter into a residential ground
[24:49]
lease for a term of 75 years in order to construct a 100%
[24:55]
affordable 175 unit multifamily rental housing development
[24:59]
affordable to low income senior households.
[25:00]
approving a commercial groundless with dc new asia
[25:03]
commercial llc to lease a portion of 772 pacific for a
[25:08]
term of 75 years to construct and operate certain commercial
[25:11]
space for community serving purposes and making appropriate
[25:15]
findings. And item 39 resolution is a
[25:18]
resolution that authorizes mou cd to partially forgive
[25:23]
approximately 1.2 million in outstanding rent obligation
[25:29]
liens and reduce the monthly base rent to 5000 per month for
[25:30]
the main remaining duration of the month to month occupancy to
[25:33]
end on september 30th 2026. >> same house, same call
[25:37]
without objection the resolutions are adopted.
[25:41]
and with that yes, madam clerk we shall go to our 2:30 p.m.
[25:45]
special order for people who are here for items later on
[25:49]
in the agenda. >> we have a lot of items under
[25:52]
our 2:30 p.m. Special order and so that could be it'll
[25:56]
definitely be more than an hour .
[26:00]
>> madam clerk please call 2:30 p.m. Special order yes our 230
[26:03]
special order is the recognition of meritorious
[26:07]
service to the city and county of san francisco.
[26:11]
>> let's start with the district ten supervisor walton
[26:14]
. Thank you.
[26:19]
president of colleagues today it is my honor to recognize
[26:23]
and celebrate someone who has dedicated an extraordinary 50
[26:27]
years of her life to the students, families
[26:31]
and communities of san francisco.
[26:32]
miss emily wade thompson. Miss wade thompson is a true
[26:45]
san francisco native and lifelong product of the san
[26:46]
francisco unified school district.
[26:49]
she attended smu as the from kindergarten through 12th grade
[26:53]
and then went on to earn her degree in elementary education
[26:58]
in from san francisco state university.
[26:59]
in her master's degree in educational leadership from
[27:02]
the university of san francisco ,she has spent her entire
[27:06]
career giving back to the various good district that
[27:10]
helped shape her over the course of 50 years with sfi
[27:13]
usd. Emily served as a teacher,
[27:16]
principal and administrator. She spent 15 years in the
[27:20]
classroom, 11 years as principal and 24 years as an
[27:24]
administrator for 30 of those years.
[27:28]
she dedicated herself to dr. George washington carver
[27:31]
elementary school first as a teacher and later as a
[27:35]
principal. She touched the lives of
[27:38]
generations of students and families.
[27:42]
>> but emily's impact extends far beyond the walls of any one
[27:46]
school. >> for 24 years she served as a
[27:49]
supervisor and director of family and community engagement
[27:53]
where she worked tirelessly to strengthen the relationships
[27:57]
between schools, families and communities.
[28:00]
she understood that we invest in families and bring
[28:04]
communities to the table. Our students are stronger
[28:08]
and our schools are stronger. She also believed deeply
[28:13]
in creating opportunities for young people to dream bigger.
[28:16]
>> she coached the only elementary school track team
[28:19]
and smu sd at the time and organized education
[28:23]
and cultural trips that allow students to experience the
[28:26]
world. Traveling from paris, france to
[28:28]
senegal, taiwan washington dc. Her commitment to service has
[28:35]
also been felt throughout our community.
[28:38]
for more than 30 years she has been a dedicated member of the
[28:42]
san francisco alliance of black school educators serving as
[28:46]
president and helping lead important initiatives such as
[28:48]
the african american reading day and scholarship programs.
[28:52]
for more than 20 years she partnered with the suu kyi
[28:55]
foundation to support attendance and student success
[28:59]
and baby bonus point schools. And she's supported 28
[29:04]
shoestrings pre-k cohort graduations.
[29:08]
through her membership and leadership with the better
[29:10]
new chapter of the national sorority of phi delta kappa
[29:13]
incorporated, she has continued to advance literacy, mentorship
[29:16]
and community engagement. And as a lifelong member of
[29:23]
first union missionary baptist church, she has remained
[29:25]
committed to uplifting families and strengthening the bonds
[29:28]
that hold our communities together.
[29:31]
>> ms.. Wade thompson your career is a
[29:35]
testament to what it means to truly serve.
[29:39]
>> you cannot simply work in our schools.
[29:40]
you help build community. You didn't simply educate
[29:44]
students. You open doors, created
[29:47]
opportunities and inspired generations of young people to
[29:50]
see what is possible for themselves.
[29:54]
50 years of service is an incredible milestone and your
[29:58]
impact can be seen in the students you taught the
[30:02]
families you supported, the educators you mentored and the
[30:05]
communities you strengthened. It is my privilege to honor you
[30:09]
today and celebrate the remarkable legacy you have
[30:13]
built right here in san francisco.
[30:14]
congratulations ms.. Wade thompson on 50 years of
[30:18]
service. We are grateful for you.
[30:21]
we celebrate you and we thank you for everything you have
[30:26]
given to our city. Enjoy your retirement.
[30:28]
>> thank. >> good afternoon.
[30:50]
okay. Good afternoon everyone.
[30:54]
and to supervisor shimon walton and to everyone that is present
[30:58]
it is dede an honor to be here to accept this.
[31:05]
I am so humbled. At this very moment.
[31:06]
I'm grateful for the 50 years that I have served in the san
[31:10]
francisco unified school district on something that I
[31:14]
know that I was called to do that I loved and I was very
[31:18]
passionate about that of being an educator.
[31:21]
I could not have made this journey without some very
[31:26]
strategic partners such as the san francisco alliance of black
[31:30]
school educators, the first union missionary baptist
[31:34]
church, the national sorority of phi to cap inc. Begin a new
[31:38]
chapter the sushi foundation the african-american
[31:44]
achievement and leadership initiative and of course my
[31:48]
family. And I do want to say to
[31:49]
supervisor shimon walton thank you for being one of those
[31:53]
african-american readers that have come into our community
[31:57]
for at least 20 years. >> I really do appreciate that
[32:02]
. >> I also wanted to say a
[32:06]
special thank you to the bayview hunters point community
[32:10]
for having built a relational trust where you allowed me to
[32:18]
work with thousands of children in that community
[32:22]
and especially the dr. George washington carver academic
[32:26]
elementary school where thousands of students have come
[32:29]
through that door. And I'm hoping in some way that
[32:31]
I nurtured their genius. I would like to leave you with
[32:37]
a call to action. >> please do not forget those
[32:42]
african-american children that I've worked so hard with
[32:46]
and that are still there. If you know that you can help
[32:50]
them and you know what you know and you know how to educate
[32:54]
them, please do so. Once again, thank you.
[32:57]
supervisor sherman walton. >> and thank you for everyone
[33:01]
who's present here today. I really do appreciate it.
[33:24]
to go over
[34:02]
add all right districts. >> 11.
[34:26]
supervisor chen. >> may I have mr. Simon
[34:34]
tanner's come up to the podium ?
[34:57]
>> tolley it's my great honor to recognize to recognize roxy
[35:01]
for center chu district 11 institution.
[35:05]
as they celebrate their 50th anniversary in this august roxy
[35:11]
it's more than a neighborhood market.
[35:12]
>> it's a story of immigration's perseverance
[35:15]
family and american dream. And then in the 1970s, simon
[35:22]
tanner's and his family one of ten siblings immigrated from
[35:26]
jordan in search of better futures.
[35:30]
like so many immigrants, family who have helped build san
[35:33]
francisco, simon began by working long hours in a local
[35:38]
supermarket alongside his uncle through work, determination
[35:41]
and sacrifices. He and his brother peter
[35:45]
realized that their dream of opening roxy for center on san
[35:48]
jose avenue in 1975 over the past five decades.
[35:53]
roxy has become woven into the fabric of district 11 when a
[35:58]
larger grocery store like the safeway closed for the evening.
[36:01]
roxy stayed open serving neighbors, workers, family,
[36:08]
anyone who was needing a warm milk of friends or a friendly
[36:12]
face. >> they carefully selected part
[36:13]
out that reflected diversity of our community making everyone
[36:17]
feel welcome. Roxy has also been a gathering
[36:21]
place for a generation of young people.
[36:25]
they have proudly sponsored a local ethic effort like day
[36:28]
programs including city college football, riot and high school
[36:32]
teams, road and high school sports team and balboa
[36:35]
buccaneers found proudly known as many as roxy sports.
[36:40]
>> they were filled with trophies and team photos tell
[36:44]
the story of business that has always invested in its
[36:47]
community. Their generosity extends far
[36:51]
beyond the store. Rosie has donated food to
[36:52]
countless community drives, participated in neighborhood
[36:58]
celebrations such as the 4th of july parade and regularly
[36:59]
catered community meeting and public safety event.
[37:06]
>> today simon's nephew make proudly carry on the family's
[37:11]
legacy as a father of three wonderful children.
[37:15]
he represents the next generation of an immigrant's
[37:19]
family whose tot work continues to strengthen our city.
[37:22]
>> his story reminds us that san francisco and america is
[37:26]
built by family who arrives with hope wartime tirelessly
[37:30]
give back to their community and create opportunity for the
[37:34]
next generations. >> it is also fitting that roxy
[37:38]
has become a favorite spot for dedicated officers after
[37:42]
ingleside police stations and our firefighters as they
[37:46]
say something special that say something special about the
[37:47]
welcoming spirits and quality of the roxy has offered to for
[37:54]
the last 50 years. Roxy food center is not simply
[37:58]
a successful small business industrial ivan.
[37:59]
it's also a symbol of american dream a beloved pillar
[38:05]
in district 11 and also one of the many immigrants successful
[38:06]
story that makes san francisco the extraordinary the
[38:10]
extraordinary city that it is today.
[38:13]
>> congratulations on 50 incredible years.
[38:16]
we thank you simon make and the entire ten years family for
[38:20]
your unwavering commitment to our neighborhood and we look
[38:24]
forward to celebrating many more milestone together.
[38:27]
>> congratulation. Thank you.
[38:35]
>> good afternoon, everyone. My name is simon tanase.
[38:39]
I I'm really honored and privileged to receive this
[38:46]
recognition on behalf of my roxy family.
[38:51]
my nephew mick and his brother in law mike.
[38:58]
his wife sienna and mike's wives my hero and their family.
[39:05]
I'd also like to recognize my brother peter to thank him for
[39:10]
all the hard work and his wife beth mercy and over there
[39:14]
and we are honored to be part of the mission terrorists
[39:20]
neighborhood for the last 51 years.
[39:26]
and it is been a privilege and a blessing to be part of
[39:30]
that neighborhood that the customer is the neighbors, the
[39:35]
mission terrorists association led by david hooper and his
[39:39]
wife lisa here in a big part of the roxy success and you know I
[39:50]
like to think also of ingleside police station for all the
[39:54]
protection they gave us over the years.
[39:57]
all the schools in the area there are countless including
[40:00]
city college. We have been blessed.
[40:04]
and thank you so much supervisor chen for bringing us
[40:08]
to this point here. Thank you so much.
[40:12]
>> thank you everyone. Have a good afternoon.
[40:21]
>> okay, so here you can use the
[41:07]
one district one supervisor chan.
[41:33]
>> thank you. Cousin random and I first want
[41:37]
to thank supervisor dorsey for really like just say the
[41:41]
resolution celebrating the afghan-american heritage month
[41:45]
and that I'm so honored to co-sponsor.
[41:48]
>> but I also want to thank supervisors dorsey's a mohandas
[41:51]
peabody for organizing all of us and I'm so humble through
[41:56]
this ability that we together can honor the next generation
[42:04]
and our young and also all afghan-american leaders in the
[42:08]
community and through the recognition.
[42:09]
>> so thank you so much for your work.
[42:11]
it is my privilege and honor today that I get to honor rabbi
[42:19]
maha didi who is a native san franciscans and whose
[42:23]
profession and personal commitment reflect his deep
[42:28]
dedication to our city and our communities.
[42:31]
rabbi has remained devoted to the continued growth
[42:35]
and success of our city that he proudly calls home.
[42:39]
>> his commitment to san francisco is reflected not only
[42:43]
in his professional achievements but also in his
[42:47]
dedication to supporting the people, businesses
[42:50]
and communities that contribute to our city's vibrant
[42:54]
characters. >> through his work as an
[42:56]
attorney, entrepreneur and community member, robbie
[42:59]
continues to embody the spirit of service, leadership
[43:04]
and civic pride that defines san francisco.
[43:07]
>> robbie is a labor and employment attorney with
[43:11]
nearly a decade of legal shakespearean.
[43:14]
and he currently serves as an associate attorney at ogletree
[43:19]
deakins where he focuses exclusively on litigation
[43:23]
and representing employers in complex workplace matters.
[43:29]
robbie earned his bachelor of arts in political science from
[43:34]
chapman university and his juris doctor from ohio naughton
[43:38]
university. >> pettit college of law.
[43:41]
beyond his legal practice robbie has is a partner with
[43:46]
prickly and natural hydration company powered by prickly
[43:50]
pear. >> charisse water he has helped
[43:54]
grow the brand from an emerging start up into a nationally
[43:57]
recognized company that is carrying more than 3000 retail
[44:02]
locations across the united states.
[44:06]
demonstrating his passion for supporting local
[44:10]
entrepreneurship and contributing to san
[44:11]
francisco's thriving business community community service has
[44:17]
also been an important part of his life for the past 22 years.
[44:20]
he has participated in relay for life organizing fundraising
[44:24]
effort in honor of a close family friend who lost his
[44:27]
battle with cancer. He also volunteers as a mentor
[44:32]
for golden gate universe at his mock trial competitions helping
[44:36]
aspiring attorneys strengthen their advocacy and courtroom
[44:40]
skills. In addition, he volunteers at
[44:44]
his local mosque supporting community outreach initiatives,
[44:47]
youth mentorship programs, charitable efforts and service
[44:51]
project to assist families throughout the bay area.
[44:55]
>> so clearly he does not sleep through his legal career.
[44:58]
>> entrepreneurial efforts and lifelong connection to san
[45:03]
francisco robbie continues to contribute his skills,
[45:07]
leadership and passion to the city and communities that have
[45:10]
shaped him. >> and I'm so proud and so
[45:14]
humble to recognize his contribution here today and the
[45:18]
floor. >> thank you so much.
[45:19]
thank you. President mando man board of
[45:22]
supervisors and a special thanks again to you.
[45:23]
supervisor connie chen for this incredible honor.
[45:26]
I'm truly humbled and grateful to receive the commendation
[45:32]
from district one. I remember being a kid looking
[45:33]
up at the tall buildings in the city and thinking to myself
[45:38]
that one day you know I want to be in one of those buildings
[45:42]
doing something that matters. San francisco lit that fire
[45:46]
in me. It gave me something to reach
[45:48]
for and it inspired me to dream big.
[45:52]
and to be standing here today recognized by this incredible
[45:53]
community is something I will carry for the rest of my life.
[45:57]
>> as a labor and employment attorney at ogletree deakins
[46:01]
I've had the privilege dedicating nearly a decade of
[46:04]
my life of my career to advocacy and problem solving,
[46:08]
helping organizations of all sizes navigate complex
[46:12]
challenges. Every day I get to do work I
[46:16]
love right here in the city I love.
[46:19]
that combination is something I never take for granted.
[46:22]
and beyond the courtroom I've been fortunate enough to
[46:24]
channel my entrepreneurial spirit into a better for you
[46:31]
beverage company that makes natural hydration drinks from
[46:34]
real fruit instead of artificial ingredients.
[46:37]
>> and we have them here in many stores here in our very
[46:43]
own san francisco. And it all started with that
[46:46]
same hustle, creativity and determination to the city
[46:49]
instilled in all of us. And at the end of the day
[46:53]
everything comes back to san francisco.
[46:56]
whether it's the law to entrepreneurship or simply
[46:58]
showing up for the people around me, the city is what
[47:01]
drives me. The people, the neighborhoods,
[47:04]
the businesses, the culture. >> there's a heartbeat here
[47:08]
like nowhere else and I feel it every single day.
[47:09]
I'm so proud to be part of this community and lift each other
[47:12]
up and never stop striving to make the city better for
[47:15]
everyone else. >> I want to thank my family
[47:19]
especially my wife who thinks I work too much.
[47:22]
my colleagues and everyone else who has supported me along the
[47:24]
way. I promise to keep working hard
[47:26]
to keep serving this incredible city and to keep making san
[47:29]
francisco proud. >> thank you so much.
[47:55]
>> let's take one more. Let's take one district two
[48:15]
supervisor cheryl. Thank you president mantel min
[48:20]
and colleagues, thank you all for joining for afghan-american
[48:23]
heritage month this month. I am extremely grateful
[48:28]
and honored to commend zarina yousafzai from the union square
[48:35]
alliance. Zarina thank you so much for
[48:36]
being here and more importantly thank you for being you know
[48:40]
zarina was born and raised in fremont, the afghan
[48:43]
immigrant parents who instilled in her a strong commitment to
[48:46]
education, hard work and community service.
[48:50]
she carried those values with her to uc irvine where she
[48:51]
earned her degree in political science in 2018.
[48:54]
and since 2019 sareen has built her career here in san
[48:57]
francisco at the union square alliance where she now serves
[49:01]
as finance and human resources supervisor overseeing the
[49:04]
organization's financial human resources and administrative
[49:08]
operations. In this role she has
[49:09]
demonstrated remarkable leadership and resilience
[49:12]
in fields where women and women of color remain
[49:15]
underrepresented. Zarina also plays an important
[49:19]
role in advancing the union square alliance's mission to
[49:21]
support san francisco's downtown recovery.
[49:24]
she has helped manage grant funding from the office of
[49:27]
economic and workforce development delivering public
[49:29]
activations concert series safety initiatives
[49:32]
and community programing. >> this work has been
[49:35]
instrumental in revitalizing union square, bringing
[49:36]
residents workers visitors back to the area and revitalizing
[49:39]
san francisco as a whole. But beyond her professional
[49:43]
accomplishments, serena is deeply committed to uplifting
[49:47]
her community. She volunteers at al sabeel
[49:50]
masjid nurul islam mosque on jones street where she assists
[49:54]
afghan families and she mentors young women in their
[49:58]
educational and career pursuits.
[49:59]
>> zarina, thank you for all that you have contributed to
[50:02]
san francisco and the community.
[50:03]
>> your story reflects the broader contributions that
[50:06]
african americans have made to san francisco.
[50:09]
contributions rooted in service perseverance and a dedication
[50:14]
to uplifting others. Today we recognize you for your
[50:18]
leadership, your professional excellence and most of all your
[50:21]
commitment to this community. Zarina congratulations and the
[50:23]
floor is yours. Thank.
[50:31]
>> thank you so much. Thank you, supervisor cheryl.
[50:32]
it means a lot to me and thank you to the board of supervisors
[50:36]
for this commendation. In honor of afghan-american
[50:40]
heritage month it is truly an honor to be here today.
[50:43]
I also want to extend a special thank you to manas abidi for
[50:47]
recommending me for this recognition.
[50:48]
I'm grateful our paths cross while serving this incredible
[50:51]
city. Your commitment to uplifting
[50:55]
our afghan community inspires me deeply and I'm honored to
[50:59]
stand here today because of your support.
[51:00]
>> my afghan community is the core of who I am.
[51:04]
I was born and raised in fremont.
[51:07]
as mentioned by supervisor cheryl.
[51:10]
known to many as little kabul where thousands of afghans
[51:14]
including my parents found refuge in the 1980s.
[51:15]
I carry that history with me every day.
[51:18]
it reminds me of the resilience our community has shown
[51:22]
and motivates me to serve especially our youth and our
[51:26]
young afghan women who deserve to see what is possible.
[51:29]
>> my parents inspire me every day.
[51:33]
>> their sacrifice, strength and belief in education
[51:37]
and hard work are the foundation of everything I do.
[51:38]
I would not be standing here without them.
[51:41]
like so many children of immigrants, I am here because
[51:46]
of the opportunities they work so hard to create and I believe
[51:49]
it is our responsibility to inspire the next generation
[51:54]
through education, civic engagement and community
[51:56]
involvement. >> being recognized in the city
[52:00]
I love means so much. San francisco is a huge part of
[52:04]
my story. I am proud to work for the
[52:05]
union square alliance and contribute to its mission
[52:08]
alongside an incredible team that has provided me with
[52:12]
countless opportunities and countless opportunities to
[52:16]
grow both personally and professionally.
[52:17]
growing up san francisco was always a place I dreamed of
[52:21]
being and I'm grateful to now serve and give back to this
[52:24]
city. They say if you love what you
[52:25]
do you never work a day in your life.
[52:28]
and that's exactly how it feels.
[52:31]
this commendation is not a purchase, a personal honor.
[52:33]
it's a recognition of the african american community our
[52:36]
history, our contributions and our future.
[52:40]
it celebrates those who came before us and those who will
[52:41]
come after us. I did I did not take this
[52:45]
commendation lately I am deeply grateful to be commended during
[52:51]
a month that celebrates african americans and their
[52:52]
contributions to the city and county of san francisco.
[52:54]
>> thank you
[53:26]
. >> district three supervisor
[53:28]
sauter thank you president gentlemen.
[53:31]
colleagues today I'm happy to introduce sara for rosie
[53:35]
in honor of afghan-american heritage month.
[53:36]
sara please come up and join us .
[53:41]
sara for rosie is an immigration lawyer at the san
[53:46]
francisco office of fragment. Ray bernsen and lowy llp
[53:49]
located in district three. Her journey in san francisco
[53:53]
started at usf law school in 2017 where she obtained her
[54:00]
j.d. In 2020 and for the past nine years sara has witnessed
[54:04]
firsthand san francisco's vibrant culture entrepreneurial
[54:07]
spirit and deep rooted immigrant heritage.
[54:08]
>> through her work she actively protects
[54:12]
and strengthens these attributes every day by helping
[54:16]
immigrants build their future here in san francisco.
[54:17]
>> she is ensuring that our city continues to be a hub for
[54:20]
innovation and genomic growth. Her work also enriches san
[54:24]
francisco's cultural fabric by helping individuals
[54:27]
and families build new lives, establish lasting roots
[54:31]
and contribute their unique perspectives, traditions
[54:35]
and talents. As a bilingual attorney fluent
[54:38]
in english and farsi, sara brings a valuable cultural
[54:42]
perspective to her practice representing the immeasurable
[54:43]
contribution ins and resilience of african americans in the
[54:47]
legal profession and beyond. Her involvement and leadership
[54:51]
in celebrating afghan-american heritage is a reflection of her
[54:56]
belief in promoting the stories of those who chose to call this
[55:00]
city home. And as we honor sara's work
[55:03]
and prepare to celebrate afghan-american heritage month
[55:07]
in august, this is a moment to recommit to the work of making
[55:10]
sure our city is a place that welcomes and protects
[55:14]
immigrants, values their contributions and recognizes
[55:17]
the vital role they play in shaping our city's future.
[55:21]
so sara, thank you again for being an inspiring
[55:25]
representative of the african american community and for
[55:29]
helping san francisco be a stronger and more inclusive
[55:32]
city. >> and I now welcome you to
[55:33]
share a few words. Thank you.
[55:34]
supervisor san. >> good afternoon everyone.
[55:44]
>> I am deeply honored and grateful to receive this
[55:45]
recognition from the city and county of san francisco.
[55:49]
I would like to begin by extending my sincere thanks to
[55:53]
board president madeline. The members of the board of
[55:59]
supervisors and especially supervisor sauter and menard's
[56:03]
anybody for this incredible recognition.
[56:06]
>> thank you for your leadership, your service to the
[56:10]
city and your commitment to celebrating the diverse
[56:13]
communities that make san francisco such a special place.
[56:17]
I would also like to acknowledge how meaningful this
[56:21]
moment is because it comes as the board prepares to pass a
[56:25]
resolution today recognizing august as afghan-american
[56:28]
heritage month. As an afghan-american woman
[56:32]
receiving this recognition at a time when our community's
[56:36]
contributions, stories and history are being formally
[56:40]
recognized by the city of san francisco makes us honor even
[56:44]
more profound it serves as a reminder of how far our
[56:48]
community has come and the countless individuals whose
[56:53]
resilience, perseverance and service have helped shape
[56:57]
the city we all call home. For the past nine years san
[57:00]
francisco has been my home. It is where I attended the
[57:04]
university of san francisco where I built my career where I
[57:08]
found community lifelong friendships and where I have
[57:11]
grown both personally and professionally.
[57:14]
this city welcomes me, challenges me and inspires me
[57:18]
to give back in ways that I never imagined.
[57:20]
today I have the privilege of serving as an immigration
[57:24]
attorney. Every day I work alongside
[57:27]
individuals and families who are pursuing new futures.
[57:31]
excuse me new beginnings seeking opportunity
[57:35]
and building their futures in this country.
[57:38]
through that work I am constantly reminded of the
[57:39]
determination and hope that immigrants bring to our
[57:43]
communities. As the daughter of immigrants
[57:46]
and as someone whose own life has been shaped by those
[57:49]
values, it is an honor to help others navigate their own
[57:53]
journeys and contribute to the fabric of this city and country
[57:56]
. >> I would like to recognize my
[57:58]
partner bregman who is here today.
[58:01]
thank you rachel for your mentorship and support.
[58:04]
I am grateful to work alongside such dedicated and talented
[58:08]
professionals and this recognition is not mine alone.
[58:11]
to my parents thank you for your sacrifices, perseverance
[58:16]
and unwavering belief in the power of education, hard work
[58:19]
and service. Everything I have accomplished
[58:20]
stands on the foundation you built for me.
[58:24]
to my mom especially thank you for being my greatest supporter
[58:28]
and constant source of strength .
[58:31]
and to my husband thank you for your unwavering support,
[58:35]
encouragement, love and partnership.
[58:36]
I am so grateful to share this moment with you and our
[58:40]
daughter. Lastly, I would like to close
[58:43]
with an afghan proverb. >> excuse my farsi.
[58:50]
cataract. Cataract jamychal.
[58:53]
one got a tattoo on me shot. This means drop by drop of
[58:58]
river cross into the sea. To me this reflects the spirit
[59:02]
of san francisco. Every act of service, every
[59:06]
opportunity extended to another person and every contribution
[59:10]
to our community may seem small on its own but together they
[59:14]
create something extraordinary. Thank you again for this
[59:18]
incredible honor. It is a privilege to call san
[59:22]
francisco my home and I am deeply grateful to be
[59:23]
recognized by the city that has given me so much.
[59:26]
>> thank you
[1:00:29]
. >> all right.
[1:00:37]
>> district four supervisor wong.
[1:00:44]
>> good afternoon, colleagues. May have park and rec.
[1:00:47]
>> come join us up here. Hello.
[1:00:51]
>> good afternoon, colleagues. In celebration of park
[1:00:56]
and recreation month. I'm pleased to honor the
[1:00:59]
dedicated employees of the san francisco recreation and park
[1:01:03]
department whose hard work makes our parks and open spaces
[1:01:07]
some of the greatest assets in our city.
[1:01:08]
district four is home to some of the city's most iconic parks
[1:01:11]
and open spaces. Whether it's children playing
[1:01:14]
at a neighborhood playground, families gathering for a
[1:01:18]
picnic. Athletes competing on our ball
[1:01:19]
fields or residents simply enjoying the outdoors.
[1:01:22]
these spaces enrich our daily lives.
[1:01:25]
none of this would be possible without the hardworking park
[1:01:27]
recreation and park employees who care for them every single
[1:01:31]
day. I'd like to recognize several
[1:01:34]
members of the rec and park department who have joined us
[1:01:36]
today. There's general manager sarah
[1:01:38]
medland and policy and public affairs manager jack avery.
[1:01:41]
>> thank you for your leadership and everything you
[1:01:43]
do for our city. >> today I'm honored to
[1:01:45]
recognize two outstanding members of the department nick
[1:01:49]
borgerson and park service member and brandon o'keefe.
[1:01:56]
>> gardner captain. Nick serves as the park
[1:02:04]
services manager for service area for overseeing more than a
[1:02:08]
thousand acres of parkland across nearly all of district
[1:02:10]
four. For more than 14 years he has
[1:02:11]
led gardening and custodial teams working closely with
[1:02:15]
residents support countless community events and ensured
[1:02:19]
our parks and rec facilities remain in outstanding
[1:02:22]
condition. His leadership has been
[1:02:22]
instrumental in successfully managing our parks through four
[1:02:27]
stern grove festival seasons including the challenging years
[1:02:30]
following the severe winter storms and in maintaining
[1:02:34]
premier athletic fields throughout the district while
[1:02:35]
helping deliver the new stern grove playground.
[1:02:41]
brennan serves as the gardener captain for the stern grove
[1:02:42]
complex caring for stern grove pine lake park.
[1:02:47]
parkside square. Mcalpin park, carlson park
[1:02:50]
and several surrounding neighborhood parks.
[1:02:53]
during his nearly 12 years with the department, he has advanced
[1:02:55]
from apprentice gardener to gardener captain bringing
[1:02:58]
remarkable skill and pride to every park he has served.
[1:03:01]
one of his proudest achievements was leading the
[1:03:05]
landscape restoration of sterling grove's east meadow
[1:03:08]
following the devastating winter storms helping restore
[1:03:10]
his beloved community's space for concerts, weddings, picnics
[1:03:17]
and countless neighborhood gatherings.
[1:03:18]
while we're recognizing nick and brennan today they
[1:03:21]
represent the hundreds of dedicated recreation and park
[1:03:25]
employees who work behind the scenes every day from gardeners
[1:03:29]
and custodians to maintenance crews, recreation leaders
[1:03:32]
and supervisors. Your dedication keeps our parks
[1:03:33]
beautiful. Our facilities welcoming
[1:03:36]
and our neighborhoods thriving on behalf of the residents of
[1:03:40]
district four, thank you for everything you and your team do
[1:03:42]
to serve our communities. Now would like to give you a
[1:03:45]
floor to say a few things. Thank you and thank you to the
[1:03:51]
board for the recognition and the honor of which I'm
[1:03:55]
really proud. On behalf of my team both
[1:03:58]
gardening and custodial to accept it's it's really quite
[1:04:03]
an honor. As parks services manager I'm
[1:04:06]
incredibly thankful for the fantastic and committed staff
[1:04:10]
we have over in district four. Together we manage as you
[1:04:15]
mentioned 11 parks and complex sports complexes just within
[1:04:19]
district four. I have to pause and say one of
[1:04:21]
the one of the great joys I have with and working with
[1:04:25]
parks is the amazing team that I work with towards the the
[1:04:29]
beneficial maintenance of all of those unique parks
[1:04:34]
in district four and throughout the city.
[1:04:36]
if you think about it, each park is is a very unique little
[1:04:40]
gem and so unique are the communities that surround each
[1:04:44]
each park so each one is vastly different from the next and so
[1:04:47]
the parks there serve those local communities and it's just
[1:04:51]
nice to be part of that whole process to provide some oxygen
[1:04:56]
to you know, this this this area that can seem a little bit
[1:05:02]
9 to 5 for for a lot of folks. So just a I also wanted to
[1:05:10]
mention that our sfr pd team devalues its role in working
[1:05:14]
towards the maintenance here aspects and that's in providing
[1:05:18]
beautiful active spaces for our diverse community.
[1:05:22]
thank you for recognizing the hard work and efforts of our
[1:05:26]
humble team. >> appreciate it.
[1:05:43]
even though you get district five supervisor mahmood.
[1:06:11]
>> colleagues today it is my honor during an african
[1:06:16]
american heritage month for the upcoming month of august to
[1:06:20]
recognize william husseini, the assistant u.s. Attorney whose
[1:06:23]
career has been defined by extorting very commitment to
[1:06:27]
public service and to protecting our communities a
[1:06:30]
courageous alum has spent the past 13 years as a federal
[1:06:41]
prosecutor since returning home to the bay area in 2022.
[1:06:44]
she has served in the northern district of california where
[1:06:47]
she worked on corporate fraud matters, violent crime and drug
[1:06:51]
trafficking cases affecting neighborhoods within san
[1:06:52]
francisco including the tenderloin.
[1:06:55]
>> she was born in kabul, afghanistan and came to fremont
[1:06:59]
as a child after her family immigrated to the united states
[1:07:02]
. Like so many afghan families
[1:07:03]
who made their east bay their home, they became part of
[1:07:07]
fremont's vibrant afghan american community helping
[1:07:11]
build the neighborhood while creating opportunities for the
[1:07:12]
next generation. >> she went on to earn both her
[1:07:16]
undergraduate degree and law degree from uc berkeley for
[1:07:19]
clerking for a federal judge in miami at both the district
[1:07:23]
court and 11th circuit court of appeals.
[1:07:26]
although she had the opportunity to remain
[1:07:27]
in private practice, elam chose a career in public service.
[1:07:31]
she joined the u.s. Attorney's office in miami.
[1:07:34]
prosecuting cases and violence involving violent crime, child
[1:07:38]
exploitation, fraud, civil rights, public corruption
[1:07:41]
and drug trafficking. In 2022 she returned to the bay
[1:07:45]
area to continue that work here at home.
[1:07:46]
>> her recent jury trials in san francisco involve the
[1:07:49]
human trafficking of a young minor and a murder for hire
[1:07:52]
prosecution representing some of the most difficult cases.
[1:07:55]
>> our justice system is called upon to handle.
[1:07:59]
>> throughout her career, elam has approached this work with
[1:08:01]
conviction and responsibility rooted in protecting
[1:08:03]
and serving our most vulnerable communities.
[1:08:07]
>> she has worked to protect victims, uphold the rule of law
[1:08:11]
and help keep our communities safe.
[1:08:12]
>> this is especially meaningful to recognize.
[1:08:16]
elam during a fine american heritage month because this
[1:08:17]
month of august gives us the opportunity to celebrate the
[1:08:20]
generations of afghan americans who have strengthened our city
[1:08:24]
and our country through our public service.
[1:08:27]
entrepreneurship, education and community leadership.
[1:08:28]
>> holmes career reflects that legacy and stands as an example
[1:08:32]
of what is possible for young african americans growing up
[1:08:35]
here in the bay area. >> recently I also learned that
[1:08:39]
elam is the cousin of author charlotte for any who's work
[1:08:42]
many millions of readers may know to afghan's history and to
[1:08:46]
the resilience of its people through the book kite runner.
[1:08:50]
my as you may not know but one of the last memories I have of
[1:08:54]
my grandmother was watching the kite runner when it was playing
[1:08:57]
on broadway in new york and it's a memory I will
[1:09:01]
cherish for the many years now that she has passed.
[1:09:04]
>> so hamm, thank you for your service to the people of san
[1:09:06]
francisco and for representing the very best of our
[1:09:08]
afghan-american community. >> the floor is yours.
[1:09:18]
>> thank you. President amendment board
[1:09:19]
supervisor and a special thank you to supervisor mahmood.
[1:09:23]
I'm incredibly grateful for this recognition and my afghan
[1:09:26]
heritage is a big part of who I am.
[1:09:27]
my family immigrated to fremont when I was ten years old.
[1:09:31]
my earliest memory as a child or from growing up
[1:09:35]
in afghanistan and my first memories of immigrating to this
[1:09:38]
country involve how warmly the community in fremont welcomed
[1:09:41]
my family. And it's not just the community
[1:09:44]
in fremont but the bay area in general and that became my
[1:09:48]
home. >> and it is a beautiful place
[1:09:49]
to live especially as an immigrant.
[1:09:53]
>> I'm thankful for the community we have built.
[1:09:54]
a big part of why I chose a career in public service is to
[1:09:57]
serve the people who welcomed me and my family to this
[1:10:01]
country. I've had the privilege of
[1:10:04]
working with law enforcement partners and officials to make
[1:10:07]
the tenderloin a safer a safer place to live and work.
[1:10:11]
I want to thank all those partners for the work we've
[1:10:13]
done together and also have special note thank you to
[1:10:16]
mahnaz abadi for her tireless efforts in working to bring
[1:10:19]
people together for the betterment of our community.
[1:10:23]
on a personal level I want to dedicate this to my mom who is
[1:10:26]
here today. Mom, I'm amazed by your
[1:10:27]
sacrifices and grateful for your support.
[1:10:31]
you are the smartest and strongest person that I
[1:10:34]
know. And finally as a mom myself, I
[1:10:35]
want to call out my beautiful children zane and perry.
[1:10:38]
I love you both. Thank you again.
[1:10:41]
>> I really appreciate this opportunity and district six
[1:11:10]
supervisor dorsey thank you president mandelbaum.
[1:11:14]
colleagues, it is my distinct honor to recognize an
[1:11:18]
exceptional public servant whose life and career embody
[1:11:20]
the very best of san francisco's values resilience,
[1:11:26]
opportunity, integrity and an unwavering commitment to
[1:11:27]
serving others. I'm proud to honor joseph as
[1:11:30]
the mayor lurie's assistant chief for public safety joseph
[1:11:41]
joseph story begins like so many great san franciscans
[1:11:42]
stories do with a family seeking refuge and finding a
[1:11:46]
home. In the early 1980s his family
[1:11:49]
arrived in san francisco as afghan refugees seeking safety,
[1:11:53]
stability and the opportunity to build a better future.
[1:11:57]
they settled near silver avenue and sweeney street in a
[1:12:00]
community that welcomed them with compassion and hope.
[1:12:02]
>> joseph says that san francisco gave his family
[1:12:05]
everything opportunity, security and a future and he
[1:12:09]
has spent his career admirably repaying that gift through a
[1:12:12]
lifetime dedicated to protecting and serving the
[1:12:16]
people of this city. That calling led him to the san
[1:12:19]
francisco police department where he broke new ground as
[1:12:22]
the first afghan police officer promoted to the rank of
[1:12:24]
sergeant and was a speedy colleague of mine for a time.
[1:12:27]
over the course of his distinguished career he served
[1:12:30]
honorably and well in the mission southern tenderloin
[1:12:34]
and northern police districts earning the respect of
[1:12:35]
colleagues and communities alike.
[1:12:38]
joseph understood that true public safety isn't achieved
[1:12:42]
solely by enforcing the law but by earning trust and building
[1:12:45]
meaningful relationships with the community he was sworn to
[1:12:47]
protect. He worked tirelessly to
[1:12:50]
strengthen partnerships between law enforcement and our diverse
[1:12:53]
communities approaching every interaction with fairness,
[1:12:57]
empathy and with respect. When medical challenges brought
[1:13:01]
his police career to an unexpected close, joseph
[1:13:02]
continued his commitment to service in the private sector
[1:13:06]
with the san francisco 49 ers organization.
[1:13:08]
and when the opportunity arose once again to serve the city
[1:13:12]
and county of san francisco, he answered that call without
[1:13:15]
hesitation. Today as assistant chief for
[1:13:16]
public safety and mayor lurie's administration he continues to
[1:13:20]
advance initiatives that strengthen public safety
[1:13:24]
and foster collaboration across our city.
[1:13:27]
what makes joseph's career so truly remarkable isn't simply
[1:13:31]
the positions he has held but the values that have guided him
[1:13:32]
through every chapter of his service.
[1:13:35]
humility, integrity, compassion and an enduring belief that
[1:13:39]
public safety is both a privilege and a responsibility
[1:13:42]
. Joseph, on behalf of the san
[1:13:43]
francisco board of supervisors and the people of san
[1:13:47]
francisco, thank you for your decades of service, your
[1:13:50]
principled leadership and your unwavering commitment to our
[1:13:51]
city's diverse communities. As we prepare to celebrate
[1:13:54]
afghan-american heritage month in a few days, it is our
[1:13:58]
privilege to recognize you for your contributions and to
[1:14:02]
express our gratitude for all that you do and all that you
[1:14:05]
have done for the city we love. >> congratulations.
[1:14:15]
and I have to leave. But before you speak,
[1:14:23]
supervisor mahmood yosef yosef ,you have made one the most
[1:14:34]
profound impacts in my career and the first two years of
[1:14:38]
office. >> I remember that weekend
[1:14:42]
in september where there was an increase in youth violence
[1:14:46]
in the tenderloin. And you and I had a call
[1:14:50]
and you said let's go on a walk.
[1:14:53]
and we walked down leavenworth and it was like walking down
[1:15:00]
history memory lane because every block you told me the
[1:15:04]
story of who was there, how long they've been there
[1:15:09]
different demographics, different races.
[1:15:12]
every block was a different community, a different
[1:15:17]
challenge and a different element of hope.
[1:15:18]
and I remember when we got I think to leavenworth and eddie
[1:15:23]
a group of 20 kids runs up there weren't kids anymore but
[1:15:27]
probably young, young early 20s and they run up to you.
[1:15:30]
I don't think you'd seen them in years.
[1:15:34]
and one of them says uncle yosef, I just got a job.
[1:15:35]
>> and you showed me how these were people that you knew as
[1:15:42]
kids from your days in community policing.
[1:15:46]
and I don't know what lesson you were trying to teach me
[1:15:50]
that day but I came away with like 50 lessons.
[1:15:55]
>> and it showed me the power of community policing, the
[1:15:56]
profound relationships you formed with the neighborhood
[1:16:03]
and that on that day four years prior and the impact that that
[1:16:07]
has had for years and years to come and that impact I think
[1:16:14]
has led to permanently shaping a future for this neighborhood
[1:16:19]
where for the first time in years we're investing
[1:16:26]
in community policing again in the tenderloin for the first
[1:16:29]
time in years we're taking a focus on the youth and actually
[1:16:30]
elevating their stories because of you we are now creating the
[1:16:37]
first youth violence prevention program which I see squalor as
[1:16:41]
guys are behind you. >> we want to rise with the
[1:16:48]
united players and and it just shows how one person namely you
[1:17:03]
can make a huge difference. And mayor lurie picking you was
[1:17:08]
one of your best choices for the neighborhood band like it
[1:17:13]
was like if you were not in this position the tenderloin
[1:17:16]
would not be in the recovery that it's in today.
[1:17:19]
and I have permanently learned so much from you that I will
[1:17:27]
never forget. We have many years to go but I
[1:17:30]
I'm so grateful for being able to partner with you and for
[1:17:34]
teaching me so much on how to turn this neighborhood around.
[1:17:36]
and really excited and really great choice.
[1:17:39]
I'm really bummed it wasn't mine.
[1:17:40]
so big. >> congrats yosef.
[1:17:43]
thank you so much for sharing that comment.
[1:17:49]
yosef I should acknowledge that your boss mayor lurie has
[1:17:54]
entered the chamber. >> mayor larry if you would
[1:17:55]
like to say anything please come up.
[1:17:58]
>> okay. Supervisor mahmood that was
[1:18:01]
really poignant and I appreciate it and he deserves
[1:18:05]
every single word of it. I just wanted to stop by
[1:18:12]
and say I've known what do I call you mr. Izzy yosef for a
[1:18:17]
very long time now. His brother and his sister are
[1:18:21]
here who are dear friends. And when you go into jobs like
[1:18:25]
this you want people that are going to go all in with you.
[1:18:33]
and this is a tough position that you're in challenging one
[1:18:39]
you and and stephen betts and you all have just gone all
[1:18:43]
in with your your soul and your heart.
[1:18:47]
and and I talk to you at midnight.
[1:18:51]
I talk to you at 6 a.m.. You are always on and you care
[1:18:54]
so deeply about this city. You care deeply about the t l
[1:18:58]
but you care deeply about every single part of this city.
[1:19:02]
you want our youth to have opportunities and you're
[1:19:06]
fighting for it every day in this position.
[1:19:07]
and you come from the law enforcement side but your heart
[1:19:11]
is in the community building side which I think is so
[1:19:15]
incredibly unique. And we need more of that
[1:19:19]
in this city. And so it's I'm so grateful to
[1:19:23]
the supervisors for honoring I know yosef azeem.
[1:19:26]
he's a dear friend. But I'm glad that the whole
[1:19:30]
city gets to see a true champion of san francisco doing
[1:19:37]
the work every single day. Your two children, your wife,
[1:19:41]
your brother, your sister, your parents I know are incredibly
[1:19:45]
proud of you as am I. >> so thanks for all your work
[1:19:49]
on behalf of the city and county of san francisco.
[1:19:59]
>> all right. Thank you.
[1:20:00]
the presidency president, mandolin and board.
[1:20:03]
I'm truly grateful. I also want to thank
[1:20:07]
mayor lurie or chief of public safety steven betts, my
[1:20:11]
counterpart and the guy that truly puts in all the work with
[1:20:14]
me. My teammates across our city
[1:20:15]
departments chieftain chrisman sheriff miyamoto, chief
[1:20:19]
clinical lieutenant dave gough you know you guys are working
[1:20:22]
with us every single day making things happen.
[1:20:26]
and I can't thank you enough. Most importantly, you know my
[1:20:30]
family, my wife nicole, my kids luciano joseph jr.
[1:20:33]
and my brother tarek azeem. Dina and my mom and my uncle
[1:20:37]
tony for always supporting me. I always have big dreams, big
[1:20:41]
goals and they've never told me I can't do them.
[1:20:44]
>> they always say go harder, go bigger.
[1:20:46]
and even when I do go you've got to go even harder next time
[1:20:48]
. So they're never it's never
[1:20:49]
enough. You got to keep going.
[1:20:50]
so I generally thank you for for for doing that and really
[1:20:53]
the commute organizations I mean you got howard we got
[1:20:57]
rudy, we got the squad, we got vip united players.
[1:21:00]
I mean it's been over close to 15 years.
[1:21:01]
I've been working with these guys day in and day out
[1:21:04]
and just like the mayor said, I'm on the phone with howard at
[1:21:07]
four in the morning, six in the morning with these guys.
[1:21:09]
answer the call. They show up.
[1:21:11]
it's really not me doing the work.
[1:21:12]
it's honestly them doing the work and I'm just the guy
[1:21:14]
that's conveying the messaging .
[1:21:15]
so thank you all. This is really your award, not
[1:21:16]
mine. So thank you.
[1:21:19]
sincerely. You know, our family's journey
[1:21:23]
began about 40 years ago when my parents arrived as refugees
[1:21:26]
with nothing but hope. And my mother taught me that no
[1:21:30]
matter how hard life gets, you always take care of your
[1:21:33]
community and in return your community will take care of you
[1:21:36]
. And why I say that was because
[1:21:37]
she as a mother of three children my father had some
[1:21:41]
severe health mental health issues and she never gave up on
[1:21:45]
him. She continued to care for him
[1:21:48]
and you know she would still help other people.
[1:21:52]
and I would always say mom, you're struggling but you're
[1:21:53]
helping other people. And she would always say you
[1:21:56]
have to keep helping people. And that lesson just stuck with
[1:22:00]
me. Know I didn't understand it but
[1:22:01]
I saw it and that's why it's kind of ingrained in me now
[1:22:04]
and I just do it naturally because I watched her do it.
[1:22:06]
>> and you know, I hope she's proud.
[1:22:07]
I hope you're proud, mom. They are able to see this
[1:22:10]
today. >> this is really about you
[1:22:11]
know, not I again but I could tell you guys you know, I get a
[1:22:15]
little emotional even talking about the san francisco police
[1:22:17]
uniform was the greatest honor of my life.
[1:22:21]
the way it ended wasn't on my terms of course, because of
[1:22:22]
some health issues. But being able to come back
[1:22:25]
in this role is so special for me and just to be able to work
[1:22:30]
with these people again and do what I do from the bottom of my
[1:22:32]
heart there's nothing great on this road.
[1:22:33]
I mean when this ends I've accomplished my mission
[1:22:37]
in life. >> I'm happy to be here, happy
[1:22:40]
to do what I could with you guys.
[1:22:43]
you know, again, I can't thank you guys enough.
[1:22:47]
supervisor dorsey, you're the best.
[1:22:48]
I appreciate you very much. A great partner.
[1:22:50]
>> I can't do this without a group like this and one of us
[1:22:55]
you're doing phenomenal work. So again, thank you from the
[1:22:58]
bottom my heart. >> thank you to see the whole
[1:23:33]
family well take of her twin. Okay.
[1:24:11]
got it. Let's take some
[1:25:34]
. >> and next up, district seven
[1:25:38]
supervisor melgar. >> thank you, president
[1:25:41]
colleagues, it is great. >> on with a great honor that
[1:25:46]
disability pride month we will be presenting a special
[1:25:49]
commendation to the pomeroy recreation and rehabilitation
[1:25:53]
center. >> if you could come up please
[1:26:00]
. >> you too, david.
[1:26:01]
well, I located on the outer edge of san francisco a
[1:26:07]
district seven. The pomeroy center has served
[1:26:08]
at san francisco's disability community for more than 70
[1:26:14]
years. Next year will mark the
[1:26:15]
center's 75th anniversary. >> and it is it's probably
[1:26:23]
lesser known than the pomeroy center but it is actually owned
[1:26:27]
by the city and the land is through the public utilities
[1:26:28]
commission. The pomeroy center was founded
[1:26:31]
by janet pomeroy in 1952 at a time when many individuals with
[1:26:38]
disabilities were excluded from society and community life
[1:26:42]
and often institutionalized. >> in founding the center,
[1:26:47]
janet pomeroy aimed to meet community needs for programs
[1:26:51]
that serve children adults with disabilities seniors.
[1:26:55]
the center's mission is to provide recreation ational
[1:26:58]
vocational educational opportunities for people with
[1:27:03]
disabilities through programs and services that encourage
[1:27:04]
self-expression, promote personal achievement and growth
[1:27:08]
and lead to greater independence.
[1:27:11]
today the center's programs and services support nearly
[1:27:15]
2000 people every week. Some of pomeroy center's
[1:27:19]
impactful programs include the afterschool program for
[1:27:23]
children with disabilities who attend s.f. School throughout
[1:27:27]
the day offering a safe, active ,engaging place to learn to
[1:27:31]
play, to hold relationship ups. The residential program which
[1:27:36]
provides adults with disabilities with safe, stable
[1:27:39]
housing and individualized support.
[1:27:40]
>> the aquatics program a pool and swimming program that
[1:27:43]
serves both the disability community and the broader
[1:27:48]
community. Particularly children
[1:27:51]
and seniors. And the employment services
[1:27:54]
program which provides job training and placement services
[1:27:58]
to people with disabilities. >> we celebrate the pomeroy
[1:28:02]
center for this disability pride month because its work is
[1:28:06]
about uplifting and honoring the history, the experiences,
[1:28:10]
the achievements of the disability rights movement
[1:28:13]
and of the disability community.
[1:28:17]
disability looks very different for everyone.
[1:28:20]
>> for people experiencing disability it is a very diverse
[1:28:25]
thing. This month is a chance for us
[1:28:29]
to celebrate those in the community and also to recognize
[1:28:32]
the challenges folks in this community face still.
[1:28:36]
>> the primary center is a deeply admirable example of how
[1:28:40]
an organization working to support individuals with
[1:28:44]
disabilities can grow and thrive and help people
[1:28:48]
connect with others. I also want to note how
[1:28:49]
impressed I am with the staff at the pomeroy center who truly
[1:28:53]
serve with purpose, with love, with deep respect for the
[1:29:00]
mission of the center. They are a large part of why
[1:29:01]
this space is so warm and welcoming.
[1:29:04]
families feel truly connected to the center and that is only
[1:29:08]
possible because of the intention ality of the
[1:29:12]
relationships that get built here.
[1:29:13]
I want to celebrate the pomeroy center for its more than 70
[1:29:18]
years of dedicated service to and in collaboration with the
[1:29:23]
san francisco's disability community as well as the city
[1:29:27]
at large. With that I would like to
[1:29:28]
present jillian mueller, director of development
[1:29:32]
and communicate and david drew pinsky, ceo and jj kin who will
[1:29:39]
speak to us about the experience in the pomeroy
[1:29:44]
center. And I want to recognize their
[1:29:45]
service, their dedication and their care for the
[1:29:48]
community in san francisco. >> all right.
[1:29:57]
good afternoon, president vandeman and members of the
[1:30:01]
board of supervisors on behalf of the pomeroy center.
[1:30:04]
thank you for recognizing our organization during disability
[1:30:06]
pride month. >> we are especially grateful
[1:30:09]
to supervisor melgar who has been an incredible advocate
[1:30:12]
and friend to pomeroy throughout the years and we are
[1:30:16]
incredibly honored to be here today.
[1:30:17]
>> this recognition is important because it reflects
[1:30:21]
something really extraordinary .
[1:30:24]
history has not always been kind to the disability
[1:30:26]
community whose members have often been excluded, ignored
[1:30:29]
and hidden from public life. >> this commendation shows that
[1:30:33]
the board of supervisors sees values and celebrates this
[1:30:38]
community and recognizes the contributions that they make
[1:30:41]
every day. >> pomeroy we create
[1:30:44]
opportunities for children and adults with developmental
[1:30:46]
disabilities to build relationships, develop life
[1:30:50]
skills, express themselves, find meaningful employment,
[1:30:54]
stay active and of course have fun.
[1:30:57]
we also provide residential services that offer safe
[1:31:01]
and supportive homes where our residents can build
[1:31:02]
independence while also maintaining connected to the
[1:31:05]
pomeroy community. >> our participants are not
[1:31:06]
only involved that pomeroy. They also volunteer throughout
[1:31:10]
the bay area. For example, one group
[1:31:13]
volunteers with the san francisco marin food bank
[1:31:14]
and delivers meals throughout the bay area sharing their time
[1:31:18]
and talents while making a meaningful difference in the
[1:31:21]
lives of others. >> our impact as supervisor
[1:31:24]
melgar said, extends to the broader public with our 92
[1:31:27]
degree saltwater pool we provide therapeutic swimming
[1:31:28]
senior programs and children's swim lessons for people of all
[1:31:32]
ages and all abilities. As we continue to grow.
[1:31:36]
we plan to expand our residential housing program so
[1:31:39]
more participants can have safe stable homes for families with
[1:31:44]
a child or a sibling with a disability.
[1:31:47]
housing can be a major source of fear and anxiety, especially
[1:31:49]
when they are uncertain about their future.
[1:31:51]
we are committed to easing that bier by creating more long term
[1:31:55]
housing opportunities so people with disabilities can remain
[1:31:57]
in san francisco and stay connected to the people and the
[1:31:59]
places they know and love. We also hope to one day open an
[1:32:04]
inclusive, inclusive of preschool and daycare on site
[1:32:07]
where children with and without disabilities ages 0 to 5 can
[1:32:10]
learn and grow together from an early age.
[1:32:13]
>> today pomeroy serves more than 2000 people each week but
[1:32:17]
our true impact is found in the small moments of competence,
[1:32:21]
connection, independence and belonging that happen here
[1:32:24]
each day. >> thank you again to the board
[1:32:26]
of supervisors for this meaningful recognition
[1:32:29]
and thank you again to supervisor melgar for your
[1:32:30]
continued partnership and support.
[1:32:32]
I would now like to turn it over to jj who's one of our
[1:32:36]
participants at pomeroy to give her words on the her experience
[1:32:38]
at pomeroy to up to noon. My name is jj.
[1:32:46]
I am proud to be a positive pet at the palmerston day dojo.
[1:32:54]
my mother met model and services go board of
[1:32:59]
supervisors for our pathway to disability pride month.
[1:33:05]
>> paul has helped me grow because partly because of
[1:33:09]
pomona I have a job at no to and I'm proud to work and be
[1:33:13]
part of my community. >> my job gives me alerts
[1:33:20]
and helps me be more independent.
[1:33:28]
>> paul might also what has also helped me make well.
[1:33:32]
wonderful friends are to to new tunes go on fun community
[1:33:40]
outings and activities I never thought I could do.
[1:33:43]
>> I feel included. I feel supported.
[1:33:47]
I feel like I belong on disability pride month moments
[1:33:55]
as people with disabilities have drapes colored and dreams
[1:34:01]
with the white support we can work, make friends, be part of
[1:34:07]
our communities and live for a myriad of lives.
[1:34:14]
>> get your ball that is a palm and board supported people like
[1:34:17]
me. It has to district nine
[1:35:23]
supervisor fielder. Thank you president management
[1:35:25]
I would like to ask on your wall zimmerman and please come
[1:35:29]
to the podium. Colleagues I'm thrilled today
[1:35:35]
to commend on your wally zimmerman who among the many
[1:35:40]
roles they play in the community is the founder
[1:35:42]
and coordinator of the people's budget coalition.
[1:35:46]
>> today after passing the budget for this fiscal year, it
[1:35:47]
is fitting to honor anna for their work bringing us all
[1:35:51]
together to protect vital services for our communities.
[1:35:54]
>> at the helm of people's budget coalition which
[1:35:57]
represents over 150 organizations citywide spanning
[1:36:01]
the spectrum of services it is nothing short of a miracle that
[1:36:05]
they've been able to build consensus among partners
[1:36:08]
and get to agreement on priorities for advocacy
[1:36:12]
and they accomplish this during an extremely challenging
[1:36:13]
deficit year when we were initially facing proposed
[1:36:17]
massive cuts to san francisco's social safety net and extensive
[1:36:21]
layoffs of city workers. Instead, due to audience
[1:36:24]
expertise on the city budget and process as they led the way
[1:36:28]
in ensuring the restoration of $28 million in cuts to
[1:36:31]
community services on year has been no stranger to city hall
[1:36:35]
budget season for the past six budget years they have been
[1:36:39]
advocating for the most vulnerable residents in our
[1:36:42]
city. They began their time as an
[1:36:43]
intern for former supervisor dean preston in the district
[1:36:46]
five office back in 2020 at age 18 and then subsequently with
[1:36:50]
the office of former supervisor ronan who was budget chair at
[1:36:54]
the time in the role of budget fellow.
[1:36:57]
>> they learn the ropes, pored over spreadsheets and built
[1:37:00]
relationships on the second floor and among stakeholders
[1:37:04]
outside the building. They have become a master of
[1:37:06]
budgets and spreadsheets while a fellow on realize the need
[1:37:12]
for a participatory budgeting process where residents and the
[1:37:14]
organization in serving them shape how our money is spent
[1:37:18]
they went to work creating the infrastructure that would
[1:37:21]
become the people's budget coalition other than the
[1:37:25]
mayor's budget office and chair chan ana knows the budget
[1:37:28]
and budget negotiations process like no other in this building
[1:37:33]
. >> but ana also knows the
[1:37:34]
community the needs for essential services and how to
[1:37:37]
bring everyone to the table to come up with a plan to protect
[1:37:40]
these vital supports provided by so many amazing community
[1:37:44]
based organizations due to their leadership and the
[1:37:48]
collective partnership of people's budget members
[1:37:49]
and negotiation with all of my colleagues and their budget
[1:37:53]
staffers, we were able to secure wraparound support for
[1:37:56]
immigrant families, job training and placement for
[1:37:59]
people especially system involved youth case management
[1:38:00]
recovering substance use treatment and supportive
[1:38:04]
services culturally responsive support for adults in the
[1:38:08]
mission mobile health care, sdi testing and overdose prevention
[1:38:12]
for sex workers trainings and job connections for older
[1:38:15]
adults and adults with disabilities.
[1:38:16]
housing support for people experiencing gender based
[1:38:20]
violence support for culture districts and commercial
[1:38:23]
corridor revitalization and so much more on you.
[1:38:27]
you should be so proud of the work you did to make all this
[1:38:29]
happen. We known as a coalition and it
[1:38:32]
takes a village but what you bring to this work is a
[1:38:35]
relentless commitment to social justice an unparalleled grasp
[1:38:39]
of city budgeting and numbers and a deep love for community.
[1:38:43]
>> thank you for your service and I look forward to seeing
[1:38:47]
you at city hall next year during budget season and to
[1:38:51]
working in partnership to protect our vital services.
[1:38:54]
>> congratulations. I also see my colleagues on the
[1:38:56]
roster. Supervisor mahmood.
[1:39:01]
>> I just wanted to thank you again for all your advocacy
[1:39:05]
over the last several months. I really appreciated you
[1:39:07]
hosting the town hall in the tenderloin and I think what it
[1:39:11]
spoke to is that you proactively brought together so
[1:39:14]
many different communities not just in the tenderloin but
[1:39:17]
across district five and elevated voices and issues
[1:39:21]
that too often are forgotten as part of budget processes.
[1:39:24]
everything from housing to tenant protections to food
[1:39:28]
security. >> and it really felt like one
[1:39:32]
of the largest town halls we have in the neighborhood.
[1:39:35]
but it spoke to giving a voice for the voiceless.
[1:39:39]
and also explaining the budget process which can be extremely
[1:39:43]
complicated. But I remember there was a
[1:39:47]
conversation about revenue and revenue and making it
[1:39:51]
really accessible for everyone there even monolingual speakers
[1:39:52]
who are in the neighborhood as well.
[1:39:55]
>> and because of that education and because of that
[1:39:59]
advocacy, I do think the budget that we have this year was able
[1:40:03]
to represent what the people needed as well.
[1:40:07]
so thank you again for your advocacy supervisor, fielder
[1:40:11]
said we would not have had the outcome had it not been for you
[1:40:14]
and your coalition. >> so thank you so much.
[1:40:15]
supervisor jen. >> thank you president.
[1:40:19]
thank you. Supervisor fielder for offering
[1:40:22]
this special commendation to angel and your work on budget
[1:40:26]
this year and during previous years as a large part how this
[1:40:30]
sport has been held accountable to our community.
[1:40:34]
so your voice, your advocacy have helped to ensure that we
[1:40:38]
don't waver and that we protect the direct essential services
[1:40:45]
that our most vulnerable populations have relied on for
[1:40:49]
decades. >> you kept people calm.
[1:40:50]
why still remaining firm and steadfast?
[1:40:54]
you should be very proud, very proud of your coalition
[1:40:58]
building and your accomplishment.
[1:41:01]
>> and I know for my district michelle levin, we are grateful
[1:41:05]
for your partnership during this budget year.
[1:41:07]
>> congratulations. >> the floor is yours.
[1:41:12]
thank you. I'm anya wallis ekman with the
[1:41:16]
s.f. People's budget coalition. It's nice to not have the timer
[1:41:20]
counting down while I speak up here.
[1:41:21]
rarely. >> I have very much grown up
[1:41:24]
in city hall. I've been here since I was 18.
[1:41:28]
my seventh budget year and this is the first time that I
[1:41:32]
exceeded the budget proud of what we all did together
[1:41:36]
because truly it took each one of you as a member of the board
[1:41:39]
of supervisors I saw each one of you fight in a way that I've
[1:41:43]
never seen before. Fighting not just for your
[1:41:47]
district or for one organization that was important
[1:41:50]
to you. Each of you fought for a
[1:41:53]
community of san francisco that desperately needed your voice
[1:41:57]
and your leadership and a country that is demolishing
[1:42:01]
people's voice and people's leadership.
[1:42:02]
>> you give working class people access to city hall
[1:42:05]
through your public comment through staying attentive to
[1:42:09]
our public comments, through welcoming us in and allowing us
[1:42:13]
to make a bunch of noise in the hallway and interrupt you
[1:42:17]
and annoy you and bother you. You let working class people
[1:42:20]
now this year more than any other that when they get
[1:42:24]
involved they can make a difference.
[1:42:28]
we've let people know through this budget process where we
[1:42:31]
saved every organization that was going to close that is not
[1:42:35]
going to happen and did not happen on july 1st and that is
[1:42:40]
because of you. So I hope that we can remember
[1:42:43]
and hold this together as the future fights come ahead as it
[1:42:47]
continues to be challenging. I hope all of us can remember
[1:42:51]
the wins this year and the lesson that it taught to
[1:42:55]
working class san francisco. When you get involved with your
[1:42:58]
city government you can make a difference.
[1:42:59]
when you get involved with the budget you can change people's
[1:43:03]
lives radically. It's a very dangerous lesson
[1:43:07]
for working class san francisco to know which is that when we
[1:43:10]
fight we win. And so we will be back of
[1:43:14]
course we'll be back every single year until the work is
[1:43:18]
done because people's budget is a broad coalition that is so
[1:43:21]
much more than just myself though I am so honored with the
[1:43:26]
leadership that they allow me to have as such a young person
[1:43:29]
who can make mistakes certainly the coalition backing me up has
[1:43:34]
given me a voice to say what many of us for many years have
[1:43:38]
been chanting outside of city hall which is that in san
[1:43:41]
francisco we can do better. We can do better than this.
[1:43:45]
we can have universal child care.
[1:43:48]
we can have universal health care.
[1:43:49]
we can get to zero on hiv. There shouldn't be any elders
[1:43:53]
out on the street. We can feed every child.
[1:43:56]
we can do all of that in more in san francisco and we can do
[1:44:00]
it most of all when we all work together.
[1:44:03]
and so I think most of all supervisor fielder it is
[1:44:07]
incredible to have you back and to have our champion back
[1:44:09]
in city hall and especially to supervisor chan as well into
[1:44:13]
every supervisor who held a town hall with us.
[1:44:16]
you are making a difference. Your changing the way that we
[1:44:19]
do city government here in san francisco and reclaiming our
[1:44:23]
role as san francisco as the leader in democracy most of
[1:44:27]
all. And I think of course my
[1:44:30]
wonderful mother a survivor of domestic violence herself who
[1:44:34]
has passed on to me just a portion of the strength that
[1:44:38]
she was blessed with and that I carry with me every single day.
[1:44:41]
so she is the reason why I'm here today and thank you
[1:44:43]
especially to supervisor fielder supervisor preston who
[1:44:46]
originally brought me into city hall and trained me in the
[1:44:51]
first place. Supervisor ronan for teaching
[1:44:54]
me the budget and to my partner d.o. For supporting me for
[1:44:57]
endless endless days. >> he knows all of your names
[1:44:58]
whether or not he wants to. >> so I appreciate all of you
[1:45:02]
and thank you. I accept this on behalf of my
[1:45:05]
coalition and on behalf of every working class person who
[1:45:09]
came to city hall and got to see a vision of what it would
[1:45:14]
be like for working class people to really control city
[1:45:16]
hall. >> thank you
[1:45:52]
. All right, colleagues, I have
[1:45:56]
to today a retiring or a retired city employee of great
[1:46:01]
excellence and then an amazing organization.
[1:46:07]
first I'm going to invite eileen lofgren to come on.
[1:46:21]
>> you can't be leaving us. >> this is outrageous, eileen.
[1:46:26]
lucky me. I am honored to present a
[1:46:30]
commendation recognizing eileen for nearly three decades of
[1:46:34]
work on some of the city's biggest public health
[1:46:37]
challenges including overdoses ,hiv, hepatitis c
[1:46:42]
and homelessness. >> if it's hard in san
[1:46:45]
francisco has to deal with it. Eileen has probably been having
[1:46:47]
to deal with it from the start of her career.
[1:46:50]
>> she has championed communities that have
[1:46:53]
historically been marginalized, stigmatized or overlooked.
[1:46:54]
at the department of public health she'd worked in the
[1:46:58]
former hiv prevention section the community health equity
[1:47:01]
and promotion branch and behavioral health services
[1:47:04]
helping strengthen the department's capacity to
[1:47:06]
provide compassionate service to people who use drugs, those
[1:47:09]
experiencing homelessness and others facing systemic
[1:47:12]
health inequities. >> as director of the office of
[1:47:16]
overdose prevention, eileen built on that previous work
[1:47:17]
and experience guiding the development and delivery of
[1:47:20]
overdose prevention programs. Before her retirement in june,
[1:47:28]
eileen served as community affairs manager where she
[1:47:29]
continued to advance hiv overdose and hep c prevention
[1:47:33]
efforts in every role. Eileen emphasized building
[1:47:36]
partnerships across neighborhoods and within the
[1:47:39]
department ensuring that public health initiatives were not
[1:47:41]
only grounded in science but also informed by the lived
[1:47:44]
experiences and needs of san francisco's most vulnerable
[1:47:47]
residents. Her ability to listen build
[1:47:48]
trust and connect with san franciscans from all
[1:47:51]
backgrounds helped shape more responsive public health
[1:47:55]
policies throughout her career. Eileen also supported the next
[1:47:59]
generation of public health leaders strengthened
[1:48:00]
collaboration across the department and helped foster a
[1:48:03]
culture centered on compassion, partnership and innovation.
[1:48:09]
with deep respect and gratitude.
[1:48:10]
we thank you, eileen, for your decades of service to the city
[1:48:14]
and county of san francisco and the floor is yours.
[1:48:17]
>> thank you. Way to make an introvert feel
[1:48:33]
comfortable. >> you guys are welcome.
[1:48:34]
anyway, thank you president mandolin and members of the
[1:48:37]
board of supervisors. I'm so deeply honored to be
[1:48:41]
recognized today for my 28 years of service at the
[1:48:44]
department of public health. But I really want to emphasize
[1:48:48]
that success is never a solo achievement.
[1:48:52]
it's a team effort and I'm incredibly grateful for the
[1:48:55]
countless colleagues city partners and community
[1:48:58]
stakeholders that I've had the privilege to collaborate with
[1:49:02]
collaborate with over the decades.
[1:49:03]
>> san francisco is my home. >> I moved here very young
[1:49:07]
and I grew up here and I've called this city home for
[1:49:10]
nearly 40 years. As a young adult I worked my
[1:49:14]
way through city college in san francisco state determined to
[1:49:17]
build a better life for myself and others.
[1:49:21]
>> I still remember this year excitement of landing my first
[1:49:25]
role with a part time non benefited position on an hiv
[1:49:29]
prevention research study. >> what began as a temporary
[1:49:34]
assignment became an incredible 28 year journey and over time
[1:49:38]
my work has expanded to include from hiv prevention to overdose
[1:49:45]
prevention and community engagement.
[1:49:46]
and my goal has always been very simple to bring people
[1:49:50]
together creating opportunities to learn, grow and build
[1:49:53]
lasting partnerships. >> historically there has been
[1:49:58]
a divide between harm reduction and recovery.
[1:50:02]
and despite my best efforts during my career to bridge that
[1:50:06]
gap, I've often found myself navigating a broader conflict.
[1:50:10]
>> this mission too was deeply personal and is deeply personal
[1:50:14]
to me. Having lost many loved ones to
[1:50:18]
overdose and having also celebrated many others who are
[1:50:22]
thriving in recovery, I know firsthand that a variety of
[1:50:26]
approaches are vital to a person's journey.
[1:50:30]
>> regrettably, the civil servants and frontline staff
[1:50:34]
who lead this vital work have increasingly become targets of
[1:50:40]
hostility both locally and nationally.
[1:50:41]
and unfortunate. I experienced that backlash
[1:50:45]
firsthand simply for championing ending these life
[1:50:49]
saving efforts. >> yet san francisco has always
[1:50:52]
been a global trailblazer and I hope our city continues to lead
[1:50:57]
by standing firm in our core values.
[1:51:01]
sending a clear message that bullying over differing
[1:51:05]
opinions has no place here. >> while my time at epa has
[1:51:09]
ended, I know I will continue to see many of you as I embrace
[1:51:15]
my next chapter as a proud lifelong resident of san
[1:51:19]
francisco. Thank you for the privilege of
[1:51:22]
serving the city allowing me to serve the city and county of
[1:51:24]
san francisco for these past 28 years.
[1:51:27]
and I know for certain that I'll see supervisor mendham
[1:51:31]
because we see each other everywhere.
[1:51:32]
>> so thank you for did you want to go back?
[1:51:57]
okay, we're going back inside. Come on.
[1:52:02]
okay. >> I just want to say thank you
[1:52:10]
. I think you see many people
[1:52:11]
from the department here, many people in our community.
[1:52:14]
I have worked with eileen for far longer than I have and yet
[1:52:16]
in my a little over a year I've quickly come to know how
[1:52:22]
incredibly special and unique you are.
[1:52:26]
and I've said this to you in terms of your grace, your
[1:52:29]
compassion, your kindness, your desire to bridge different
[1:52:34]
points of view and ultimately always to make sure we care for
[1:52:39]
the people we care for here in san francisco.
[1:52:42]
so I think the folks that work with you both at the department
[1:52:46]
and the community have seen that and we will never be able
[1:52:49]
to fill exactly the hole that you are leaving here.
[1:52:53]
and I think that's very clear that your legacy lives on.
[1:52:57]
so congratulations and we miss you and we wish you were still
[1:53:01]
with us. So but I hope you enjoy it.
[1:53:04]
>> thank you. >> let's try this again
[1:54:01]
. >> all right.
[1:54:02]
I would now like to invite the jingling cantonese opera
[1:54:06]
company to come on up. Shubin chen and anybody with
[1:54:13]
you? >> come on up.
[1:54:23]
>> there we go. Excellent.
[1:54:26]
>> all right. All right, colleagues, it is my
[1:54:31]
great honor to be presenting a commendation to the jing
[1:54:35]
in cantonese opera institute today.
[1:54:39]
for nearly three decades, jingjing has worked to preserve
[1:54:42]
the centuries old tradition of cantonese opera.
[1:54:44]
while introducing this art form to new generations
[1:54:47]
and audiences throughout san francisco and the bay area.
[1:54:50]
cantonese opera is a traditional performance art
[1:54:51]
that combines singing live orchestral music, acting
[1:54:54]
martial arts acrobatics and elaborate costumes to tell
[1:54:59]
stories drawn from history, folklore, romance and everyday
[1:55:02]
life. Although it originated in the
[1:55:06]
cantonese speaking regions of southern china, it has since
[1:55:09]
spread around the world as chinese immigrants brought
[1:55:11]
songs performances and stories abroad with them.
[1:55:14]
the first known performance of cantonese opera in america
[1:55:17]
actually occurred in san francisco when the hong tong
[1:55:21]
chinese dramatic company performed in the sansom theater
[1:55:25]
in 1852. In recognition of its cultural
[1:55:29]
significance, cantonese opera was inscribed in unesco's
[1:55:33]
representative list of intangible cultural heritage of
[1:55:36]
the intangible cultural heritage of humanity.
[1:55:39]
in 2009, despite its significance, history
[1:55:40]
and popularity within the chinese community, however,
[1:55:43]
opportunities to experience and learn about cantonese opera
[1:55:47]
are limited in the united states.
[1:55:48]
since its founding in 1997 being one of the few
[1:55:51]
organizations in northern california dedicated
[1:55:54]
specifically to presenting cantonese opera to broader
[1:55:58]
audiences has worked to ensure this tradition continues to be
[1:56:01]
performed, taught and shared with new audiences.
[1:56:05]
under the leadership of founder and music director shubin chen,
[1:56:09]
a fifth generation generation cantonese opera musician
[1:56:13]
jingjing has hosted regular performances of cantonese opera
[1:56:17]
complete with a traditional cantonese opera orchestra
[1:56:20]
elaborate embroidered costumes and headpieces martial arts
[1:56:25]
and more. Through performances at venues
[1:56:28]
such as the historic great star theater and participation
[1:56:32]
in cultural celebrations including aapi heritage month,
[1:56:35]
the institute has become an important part of san
[1:56:39]
francisco's arts and cultural landscape, drawing more than
[1:56:42]
800 audience members each year. Jingjing also hosts more
[1:56:45]
intimate salons and workshops, training and connecting not
[1:56:49]
only established performers and musicians but also members
[1:56:51]
of the community who want to learn more about cantonese
[1:56:54]
opera jang's work, however, goes beyond preservation.
[1:56:58]
part of the institute's mission is to ensure that cantonese
[1:57:01]
opera reaches new audiences evolving and growing as a
[1:57:03]
living tradition rather than remaining a relic of the past.
[1:57:06]
through bilingual performances with english subtitles,
[1:57:10]
educational programing and interactive talkback
[1:57:13]
sessions, the the institute introduces audiences of all
[1:57:16]
backgrounds to the history, artistry and cultural
[1:57:18]
significance of cantonese opera at their annual festival this
[1:57:21]
may jing brought elected officials and community leaders
[1:57:25]
from across san francisco. Many of whom were not of
[1:57:28]
chinese heritage including myself and supervisor söder on
[1:57:32]
stage to perform fragrant sacrifice one of the most
[1:57:36]
iconic songs in the cantonese opera repertoire.
[1:57:39]
>> it was a lot of fun. It was extraordinarily nerve
[1:57:43]
wracking but I think all the community participants were
[1:57:47]
grateful for the opportunity to learn more about the tradition
[1:57:50]
and an event like this can only happen because of an
[1:57:52]
organization unlike jingjing which actively works to make
[1:57:55]
cantonese opera accessible to broader audiences and to
[1:57:59]
encourage new audiences to engage with the art form.
[1:58:02]
I want to thank everyone at the jing and cantonese opera
[1:58:04]
institute for all that you do. And with that I want to in well
[1:58:09]
know I actually want to invite my colleagues to weigh in other
[1:58:13]
people want to talk. >> supervisor sauter well thank
[1:58:14]
you president gentleman for bringing this honor before us.
[1:58:17]
>> it is well-earned and deserved.
[1:58:18]
I want to appreciate your work to carry this legacy on and to
[1:58:22]
make sure that it reaches everyone.
[1:58:25]
and earlier this year when we had the chance to to
[1:58:29]
participate, it was a treasured memory that that all that will
[1:58:36]
always live on with me and I appreciate you being so patient
[1:58:40]
,supportive, kind and welcoming me into your
[1:58:41]
space. And we just had an incredible
[1:58:44]
concert there at great star theater.
[1:58:45]
so thank you for your work every single day to carry this
[1:58:48]
legacy forward. >> and supervisor chen, thank
[1:58:51]
you. Civil rights of my moment.
[1:58:56]
you know, as someone who grew up in canton, you know also
[1:58:59]
grew up in kent. Cantonese opera I, I really
[1:59:03]
want to acknowledge everyone who is sitting here actually
[1:59:06]
you know, our respected elders for continue a continuous
[1:59:11]
effort and love in preserving our culture and heritage.
[1:59:17]
>> it's this performance is really I it's a very special
[1:59:22]
way of continue to tell the chinese stories you know
[1:59:26]
whether it's history, if folktales stories romance or
[1:59:30]
loyalty. I have a seven year old she
[1:59:34]
tried it you know little kids was trying it but again I think
[1:59:41]
the vocal like the language itself it's requires a lot of
[1:59:45]
dedication and practices. It's beautiful but it's really
[1:59:49]
hard to do it. And I also want to acknowledge,
[1:59:50]
you know, this performance it's also the makeup.
[1:59:53]
it takes hours to put it on in order to see what is on the
[1:59:57]
stage and that's our chinese says it takes ten years of
[2:00:01]
practice. It's just to show you ten
[2:00:04]
minutes on the stage and seeing a lot of young people actually
[2:00:08]
it's also engaging through a ding yang's opera and it's to
[2:00:11]
me it's really warm and also feeling really grateful
[2:00:16]
and excited and seeing that our heritage is continue to be able
[2:00:19]
to carry for the next generation.
[2:00:23]
thank you so much. Well deserved.
[2:00:24]
congratulation for this well deserved accommodations.
[2:00:27]
>> thank you. All right now for the
[2:00:34]
multi-generational family that brings us cantonese opera.
[2:00:38]
>> come on up. Thank you.
[2:00:39]
good afternoon everyone. >> my name is annie chen
[2:00:43]
and I'm kaitlyn chen, our dad cuban chen will be giving his
[2:00:47]
remarks in cantonese verse and then we will be giving our
[2:00:51]
english translations
[2:04:13]
. >> first I would like to
[2:04:14]
sincerely thank president rafael mendelssohn for
[2:04:18]
initiating this commendation and thank you to the san
[2:04:19]
francisco board of supervisors for recognizing and supporting
[2:04:23]
singing cantonese opera institute.
[2:04:26]
>> today's honor does not belong to me alone.
[2:04:29]
it belongs to the entire singing family our apprentices,
[2:04:33]
opera friends, students, volunteers.
[2:04:37]
donors. Sponsors.
[2:04:38]
community partners. Youth participant arts
[2:04:41]
and everyone who has supported and believed in us throughout
[2:04:43]
the past 29 years. Today is especially meaningful
[2:04:46]
to me because three generations of our cantonese opera family
[2:04:50]
are gathered here together my father, my wife and our
[2:04:57]
children. >> I would also like to take
[2:04:58]
this opportunity to say something to my father.
[2:05:02]
dad thank you. It was my father together with
[2:05:06]
my grandfather who introduced me to the world of cantonese
[2:05:09]
opera. >> what they passed on to me
[2:05:12]
was much more than just music. They pass on a passion and a
[2:05:17]
responsibility and a mission to me that is the true meaning of
[2:05:21]
intangible cultural heritage. On this occasion we hope to
[2:05:27]
share a chapter of cantonese operas history that many people
[2:05:31]
even here in san francisco may not know.
[2:05:35]
for many early chinese immigrants including the
[2:05:38]
railroad workers and laborers who helped build the american
[2:05:42]
west counties opera performances were an important
[2:05:43]
way to learn about current events and stay connected to
[2:05:47]
news from home. >> in many ways cantor's opera
[2:05:50]
served as one of the earliest forms of community media for
[2:05:54]
san francisco's chinese community.
[2:05:55]
>> this history is not only the story of county's opera it is
[2:06:01]
also part of san francisco story.
[2:06:02]
>> today's recognition gives us even greater confidence
[2:06:05]
and determination to continue our work whether in preserving
[2:06:09]
the art of cantor's opera or expanding education
[2:06:12]
and outreach to younger audience audiences.
[2:06:13]
>> finally, I would like to once again thank president
[2:06:17]
rafael mendelssohn, the board of supervisors and everyone
[2:06:23]
here today. >> thank you.
[2:06:38]
all right, come on over here. All right, everybody.
[2:07:21]
all right. >> oh
[2:08:00]
,okay. And that takes us back to item
[2:08:09]
40. And can I have a motion to
[2:08:13]
excuse supervisor walton from the remainder of the meeting?
[2:08:16]
moved by jen, seconded by fielder.
[2:08:17]
we can take that without objection.
[2:08:20]
supervisor walton is excused for the remainder of the
[2:08:24]
meeting. >> madam clerk, please call
[2:08:25]
item number 40. Yes.
[2:08:28]
item number 40 is a resolution retroactively authorizing the
[2:08:32]
lease with third street youth center and clinic for the
[2:08:35]
second and third floors of the property located at 888 post
[2:08:37]
street for a two year term commencing on july 1st, 2026
[2:08:41]
for an annual base rent of $1 and making appropriate
[2:08:44]
findings. >> please call the roll in this
[2:08:47]
item and item 40. >> supervisor wong wong I
[2:08:51]
supervisor chan chan. I supervisor chen chen I.
[2:08:58]
supervisor dorsey dorsey supervisor fielder fielder I
[2:09:02]
supervisor mahmood mahmood I sober supervisor randleman hi
[2:09:06]
amanda man I supervisor melgar melgar I supervisor sardar
[2:09:13]
sardar I supervisor cheryl cheryl either too nice or
[2:09:18]
without objection the resolution is adopted please
[2:09:21]
call item 41 item number 41 is a resolution approving the 2026
[2:09:28]
grant application for the united states department of
[2:09:29]
housing and urban development continuum of care program with
[2:09:33]
anticipated revenue to the city in excess of 16 million
[2:09:36]
and fulfilling the board of supervisors review and approval
[2:09:39]
process we can take this same house same call without
[2:09:43]
objection the resolutions adopted please call items 42
[2:09:47]
and 43 together items 42 and 43 or 2 resolution suspending
[2:09:52]
board rule 3.20 5.2 which requires an affirmative vote of
[2:09:56]
eight members and approving settlement of unlit guilty
[2:09:58]
claims involving an unfair practice charge arising from
[2:10:01]
employment disputes. Item 42 approve the settlement
[2:10:04]
with the international federation of technical
[2:10:07]
engineers local 21 for approximately 201,009 and 43
[2:10:12]
approves a settlement with the service employees international
[2:10:15]
union local 10 to 1 for approximately 181,000.
[2:10:18]
>> same house, same call. Without objection the
[2:10:22]
resolutions are adopted. Please call item 44.
[2:10:25]
item number 44 is a motion ordering submitted to the
[2:10:29]
voters at an election to be held on november 3rd, 2026 an
[2:10:32]
ordinance amending the business and tax regulations code to
[2:10:37]
beginning march 1st 2027 eliminate the real property
[2:10:41]
transfer tax foreclosure exemption for the transfer of
[2:10:42]
all properties other than the transfer of residential
[2:10:46]
and mixed use properties with few fewer than five residential
[2:10:50]
units and to make other nonstop substantive clarifications to
[2:10:54]
the real property transfer tax and increasing the city's
[2:10:58]
appropriations limit by the amount of real property
[2:11:01]
transfer tax collected for four years from november 3rd, 2026.
[2:11:05]
>> supervisor mahmood thank you president colleagues.
[2:11:09]
this measure gives san francisco this before you today
[2:11:12]
voters the opportunity to decide whether a transfer tax
[2:11:15]
code should reflect the ways to today's commercial real estate
[2:11:19]
market operates rather than the market that existed decades ago
[2:11:23]
. Before I go further, I want to
[2:11:24]
thank the many partners who made this ballot measure
[2:11:27]
possible our drafting city attorneys carroll report
[2:11:31]
and scott reiber our partners at de la la ten ski and maggie
[2:11:35]
mattson, whose work was central to getting this measure to
[2:11:39]
where it is today. In the mayor's office ned segal
[2:11:41]
and ali bondi comptroller wagner and grace and spencer
[2:11:44]
for their rigorous analysis and assessor recorder joaquin
[2:11:48]
torres and his team for the data that grounds this
[2:11:52]
conversation. >> I want to thank mayor lurie
[2:11:53]
as well for initiating this measure together and many
[2:11:56]
co-sponsors of the board. Supervisors dorsey melgar, chen
[2:12:00]
wong walton and randleman for standing behind this measure
[2:12:04]
and the growing list of organizations including seiu 10
[2:12:07]
to 1, seiu 2015 teamsters and a growing list of organizations
[2:12:11]
for sponsoring this measure as well.
[2:12:14]
>> I also want to acknowledge the amendment we adopted
[2:12:18]
in committee which guarantees that if this measure and any
[2:12:21]
other measure addressing the transfer tax both passed
[2:12:22]
in november both will go into effect.
[2:12:26]
>> this measure also comes at a critical moment for the city's
[2:12:30]
finances. San francisco is confronting a
[2:12:33]
serious budget crisis one that has forced difficult trade offs
[2:12:37]
across city departments and services.
[2:12:38]
>> it is entirely reasonable to ask whether our tax code is
[2:12:42]
capturing revenue. It was always meant to capture
[2:12:45]
not creating a new tax but closing a gap that has grown
[2:12:49]
substantially as the market has changed.
[2:12:50]
>> historically the foreclosure exemption was primarily used
[2:12:53]
in traditional lender foreclosures where a bank took
[2:12:57]
title and transfer tax was generally paid later when the
[2:13:00]
lender sold the property. The assessor recorder's data
[2:13:04]
shows that pattern has shifted dramatically between fiscal
[2:13:05]
years 2223 to 24 and fiscal year 2025 to 26.
[2:13:11]
more than half of exemption claims involve properties
[2:13:15]
valued over $10 million compared to just 4 to 5% in the
[2:13:19]
preceding 15 years. Sophisticated investors
[2:13:22]
structuring transactions to take advantage of an exemption
[2:13:23]
that was never designed with them in mind.
[2:13:28]
during that same three year period transactions involving
[2:13:30]
income producing and investment oriented properties account for
[2:13:33]
more than $450 million in transfer taxes that
[2:13:36]
otherwise would have been generated compared with roughly
[2:13:39]
50 million over the prior 15 years combined.
[2:13:42]
>> the comptroller's estimate office estimates that this
[2:13:46]
measure would increase our real property transfer tax revenues
[2:13:47]
by an average of 100 to $150 million annually over the next
[2:13:52]
five years. Meaningful revenue we cannot
[2:13:56]
afford to leave on the table. Though the comptroller was
[2:13:57]
candid that it will be unpredictable and cyclical tied
[2:14:01]
to foreclosure activity and real estate conditions.
[2:14:04]
>> importantly, this proposal does not eliminate the
[2:14:06]
exemption for homeowners or small residential properties.
[2:14:09]
it remains in place for single family homes, smaller
[2:14:12]
multifamily properties with fewer than five units
[2:14:13]
and qualifying small mixed use properties.
[2:14:16]
the measure ask only whether a larger commercial investment
[2:14:20]
property transfer should continue to receive the same
[2:14:21]
treatment under today's market conditions.
[2:14:24]
>> ultimately a policy question about whether the tax code is
[2:14:28]
operating as originally intended or whether it should
[2:14:31]
be updated in light of how dramatically the marketplace
[2:14:35]
has changed. Colleagues, I'm asking to send
[2:14:36]
this to the voters so that they can decide for themselves
[2:14:39]
whether that this is the moment to close that gap.
[2:14:42]
supervisor cheryl thank you president mandel and I'm going
[2:14:47]
to be supportive of this but it's not without reservation.
[2:14:53]
>> right now we're in a situation where a huge number
[2:14:57]
of things are contributing to a very high cost of construction
[2:14:59]
for housing, a very high cost of transaction for downtown
[2:15:03]
office buildings that we desperately need to be sold
[2:15:07]
and rehabilitated and and reinvigorated.
[2:15:09]
and this will be a slight slight added cost, not a huge
[2:15:14]
one. And so I would urge us to be
[2:15:17]
aware that this measure looks to provide balance and gives us
[2:15:22]
more optionality as we look forward to levers like the
[2:15:26]
broader transfer taxes that might be blocking especially
[2:15:32]
certain housing construction. And so I would encourage us as
[2:15:33]
we look forward past november should this pass at the ballot
[2:15:37]
to not think of this as a new source of revenue to allow us
[2:15:44]
to possibly spend more on things but as a way to give us
[2:15:49]
the flexibility to potentially consider lowering a transfer
[2:15:53]
tax that would allow us to build more housing that we
[2:15:56]
desperately need. I think the conversation around
[2:16:00]
the housing trust fund is incredibly important because it
[2:16:01]
has us as a city saying we value affordable housing
[2:16:06]
and we're willing to put our money there.
[2:16:08]
similarly on this side I think we need to look forward and say
[2:16:12]
hey, where we're addressing a gap, a loophole if you will,
[2:16:18]
in in the tax code with this we're going to fill that gap.
[2:16:20]
but at the same time it gives us flexibility to maybe lower
[2:16:23]
transfer taxes blocking the production of other housing.
[2:16:27]
so I with reservations I will be supporting this but I would
[2:16:31]
urge us to remember that the original intent behind this was
[2:16:34]
not to create a new stream of income in a vacuum but was
[2:16:38]
intended to balance out the potential reduction of other
[2:16:42]
income streams in order to incentivize more housing
[2:16:45]
production that will help san franciscans overall.
[2:16:47]
thank you. >> okay.
[2:16:52]
and with that I think we can take this item.
[2:16:56]
so same house, same call. >> without objection the motion
[2:17:01]
is approved. >> madam clerk, please call
[2:17:04]
items 45 and 46 together. >> items 45 and 46 are two
[2:17:10]
resolutions regarding the treasure island infrastructure
[2:17:11]
and revitalize ation financing district.
[2:17:15]
item 45 is the resolution of intention to issue bonds as a
[2:17:18]
result of an annexation of property and 46 is a resolution
[2:17:22]
approving annexation supplement to the amended and restated
[2:17:26]
infrastructure findings infrastructure financing plan.
[2:17:29]
>> let's take these items same house same call without
[2:17:33]
objection the resolutions are adopted and please call items
[2:17:38]
47 through 68 together items 47 through 68 are 22 ordinances
[2:17:45]
amending the planning code to designate various properties as
[2:17:48]
landmarks and making the appropriate findings.
[2:17:50]
item 47 designates the alexander adams home located at
[2:17:55]
1450 masonic avenue. >> item 48 designates a born
[2:18:00]
home located at 99 davis adero street.
[2:18:03]
item 49 designates a charles cat's home located at 1200
[2:18:06]
delores street. Item 50 designates the charles
[2:18:09]
l hinkle home located at 740 castro street.
[2:18:13]
item 51 designates a day eurostat eur euros d home james
[2:18:20]
c hormel mansion located at 181 buena vista avenue east.
[2:18:23]
item 52 designates the double triangle greek revival home
[2:18:27]
located at 2173 15th street. Item 54 designates the early
[2:18:34]
haight ashbury farmhouse located at 11 piedmont street.
[2:18:38]
item 54 designates elliott and wilson home located at 1335
[2:18:43]
guerrero street. Item 55 designates engine
[2:18:46]
company number 44 adams van house house located at 3816
[2:18:52]
22nd street. Item 56 designate guerrero
[2:18:55]
street double stick eastlake home located at 1415 1417 grove
[2:19:02]
street. Item 57 designates a henry
[2:19:03]
street rowhouses located at 190 121 97 henry street.
[2:19:09]
item 58 designates a holy innocents church located at 455
[2:19:13]
fair oak street. Item 59 designates the john j.
[2:19:17]
clark house located at 210 douglas street.
[2:19:21]
item 60 designates a mission congregational church located
[2:19:26]
at 3689 19th street. Item 61 designates the phenix
[2:19:30]
brewery located at 552 no east street.
[2:19:34]
item 62 designates the richard spreckels mansion buena vista
[2:19:37]
studios located at 737 bueno vista avenue west.
[2:19:42]
item 63 designates the second church of christ scientist
[2:19:46]
located at 651 dolores street. Item 64 designates its anarchy
[2:19:52]
house located at 657 cannery street.
[2:19:57]
item 65 designates a william shaughnessy home located at 394
[2:20:01]
fair oak street. Item 66 designates a fernando
[2:20:05]
nelson home located at 701 castro.
[2:20:08]
item 67 designate solange house located at 199 coral street.
[2:20:14]
and finally item 68 designates engine company number 33
[2:20:19]
located at 117 broad street all right, let's take these items.
[2:20:24]
same house, same call. Without objection, the
[2:20:25]
ordinances are passed on first reading please call item 69.
[2:20:28]
>> item 69 is a motion approving the mayor's
[2:20:32]
nomination for the appointment of lindsay mcaleese to the
[2:20:35]
building inspection commission term ending july 1st, 2028.
[2:20:39]
>> same house, same call. >> without objection the motion
[2:20:43]
is approved. Please call item 70 item 70 is
[2:20:46]
a motion approving the mayor's nomination for the
[2:20:47]
reappointment of eleanor elinor bloom to the public works
[2:20:50]
commission. Term ending july second 2030.
[2:20:54]
>> same house, same call. Without objection the motion is
[2:20:58]
approved. Please call item 71.
[2:21:01]
>> item 71 is a motion approving the mayoral
[2:21:05]
nomination for the reappointment of john trice
[2:21:06]
trustee now to the board of appeals term ending july 1st,
[2:21:09]
2013. >> same house, same call
[2:21:12]
without objection the motion is approved.
[2:21:17]
>> please call item 72. Item 72 is a motion approving
[2:21:21]
the mayor's nomination for the reappointment of justice joshua
[2:21:24]
rsa to the public utilities commission term ending august
[2:21:28]
first, 2013. >> same house, same call.
[2:21:32]
without objection the motion is approved.
[2:21:35]
please call item 73. >> item 73 is a motion
[2:21:38]
approving the president of the board of supervisors rafael
[2:21:40]
mendelssohn's nomination for the reappointment of robin
[2:21:43]
covello to the board of appeals term ending july 1st, 2013.
[2:21:46]
>> same house, same call. >> without objection the motion
[2:21:50]
is approved. Please call 74.
[2:21:54]
>> item 74 is a motion reappointing kimberly hartwig
[2:21:57]
shulman term ending july 1st, 2030 to the sanitation
[2:22:01]
and streets commission. >> same house, same call.
[2:22:04]
without objection, the motion is approved.
[2:22:05]
let's go to our committee reports.
[2:22:08]
>> please call item 75. I'll first start with item 75
[2:22:12]
through 77 were considered by the land use and transportation
[2:22:15]
committee on july 27th and forwarded to the board as
[2:22:18]
committee reports item 75 it was recommended as amended with
[2:22:23]
the same title. It is an ordinance accepting
[2:22:24]
irrevocable offers of public infrastructure associated with
[2:22:28]
the hunter's view hope s.f. Project phase two dedicated
[2:22:31]
and said public improvements for public use dedicating them
[2:22:34]
for public street and roadway purposes excepting for city
[2:22:38]
maintenance and liability purposes.
[2:22:39]
establishing an official street grade sideways sidewalk list
[2:22:43]
and public right away with accepting an offer dedication
[2:22:46]
for phase two easements delegating authority to accept
[2:22:51]
the phase three public infrastructure affirming the
[2:22:53]
school determination and making the appropriate findings same
[2:22:56]
house same call without objection the ordinance is
[2:22:59]
passed on first reading please call 76 item 76 was recommended
[2:23:07]
as amended with a new title. It is a resolution adding the
[2:23:11]
commemorative street name carlotta textured or del
[2:23:12]
portico tollway on bartlett street between 21st street
[2:23:17]
and 22nd street in recognition of dr. Carlotta textured otel
[2:23:22]
del portillo's leadership in establishing the city
[2:23:23]
college of san francisco's mission campus and her legacy
[2:23:26]
as a longtime civic and educational leader.
[2:23:29]
>> same house, same call. >> without objection the
[2:23:33]
resolutions adopted please call 77 item 77 is a resolution of
[2:23:37]
intent to initiate an undergrounding process for
[2:23:41]
homestead street between 24th and 25th streets and making
[2:23:44]
findings that undergrounding at this location is a general
[2:23:48]
benefit to the public. >> same house, same call.
[2:23:51]
without objection the resolutions adopted please call
[2:23:54]
78 through 81 together. >> yes.
[2:23:57]
item 78 through 30 through 81 were considered by the public
[2:23:59]
safety neighborhood services committee on july 23rd and were
[2:24:03]
forwarded to the board as committee reports they comprise
[2:24:06]
four resolutions determining the public convenience or
[2:24:10]
necessity of various liquor licenses and requesting that
[2:24:13]
alcoholic beverage control impose conditions on the
[2:24:16]
issuance of these licenses. Item 78 is a person to person
[2:24:21]
permits to persons transfer of a type 48 on sell general
[2:24:22]
public premises beer, wine and distilled spirits liquor
[2:24:26]
license to out of sight productions doing businesses
[2:24:29]
ranging in models located at 456 to 460 larkin street.
[2:24:35]
item 79 is a types 64 on sell general theater liquor license
[2:24:39]
to uptown tenderloin doing business as tenderloin museum
[2:24:43]
located at 835 larkin street. Item 80 what is a person to
[2:24:48]
person premise to permits transfer of a type 21 off sell
[2:24:51]
general beer wine and distilled spirits liquor license to
[2:24:55]
missing liquor doing business as college market located at
[2:24:59]
995 elm street. And finally item 81 is a person
[2:25:03]
to permit person premise to premises transfer of a type 20
[2:25:07]
off sell beer and wine liquor license to h.j. M.w. Enterprise
[2:25:11]
doing business says hello mart located at 2135 buchanan street
[2:25:18]
. >> same house, same call.
[2:25:18]
without objection the resolutions are adopted.
[2:25:21]
>> please call item 82 items 82 through 85 were considered by
[2:25:26]
the rules committee on july 27th and were forwarded to the
[2:25:29]
board as committee reports item 82 as a motion approving the
[2:25:32]
mayor's nomination for the reappointment of kate stacy to
[2:25:36]
the public utilities commission term ending august 1st, 2013
[2:25:39]
and we can take this same house same call without objection the
[2:25:43]
motion is approved please call 83.
[2:25:47]
>> item 83 is a motion approving the mayor on
[2:25:50]
nomination for the appointment of mike chen to the planning
[2:25:52]
commission term ending june 30th 2030.
[2:25:55]
>> same house, same call. >> without objection the motion
[2:25:59]
is approved. >> please call items 84 and 85
[2:26:02]
together items 84 and 85 or 2 motion and motions approving
[2:26:09]
the president of the board of supervisor rafael mendelssohn's
[2:26:10]
nomination for appointments to the planning commission.
[2:26:14]
item 84 is for elizabeth mcdonald with the term ending
[2:26:16]
july 1st, 2030 and item 85 is for joe koppel term ending july
[2:26:22]
1st 2030. >> same house, same call.
[2:26:26]
>> without objection the motions are approved.
[2:26:29]
and madam clerk, let's go to roll call.
[2:26:33]
first up, a roll call to introduce new business today
[2:26:34]
will be supervisor wong notes here colleagues today I am
[2:26:47]
introducing a resolution to accept a $1 million in state
[2:26:50]
funding for the sunset boulevard recycled water air
[2:26:54]
station improvement project sunset boulevard has a
[2:26:58]
tremendous amount of open space running through the
[2:26:59]
neighborhood but much of it is currently dry, patchy and not
[2:27:03]
nearly as green or welcoming as it should be.
[2:27:07]
years of drought deferred maintenance and problems of the
[2:27:10]
existing irrigation system have taken a visible toll.
[2:27:14]
>> this project is an important step toward changing that.
[2:27:17]
>> the funding will help connect the irrigation system
[2:27:19]
serving approximately 60 acres of medians and roadside
[2:27:22]
greenspace to san francisco's recycled water system that will
[2:27:26]
eliminate the use of potable drinking water for irrigation
[2:27:30]
and conserve an estimated 40 million gallons of potable
[2:27:34]
water every year. This resolution will not
[2:27:38]
transform the boulevard overnight but reliable
[2:27:40]
sustainable irrigation is essential if we want to restore
[2:27:44]
the landscaping, support healthier trees and plantings
[2:27:45]
and make better use of this large public space.
[2:27:49]
I want to thank senator scott weiner for his work
[2:27:52]
in sacramento to secure the state investment.
[2:27:55]
his efforts made this funding possible and we appreciate his
[2:27:57]
partnership in delivering critical infrastructure
[2:27:59]
improvements for san francisco. I also want to thank our
[2:28:02]
partners at the department of public works for advancing this
[2:28:03]
important project. The sunset deserves the same
[2:28:07]
level of attention and investment that the city
[2:28:10]
gives to prominent public spaces elsewhere.
[2:28:12]
this is a practical, much needed investment in the
[2:28:15]
neighborhood and I respectfully ask for its support.
[2:28:18]
>> thank you. Process.
[2:28:19]
thank you. Supervisor wong.
[2:28:20]
supervisor chen. Thank you.
[2:28:22]
supervisor chen. >> thank you, madam clerk.
[2:28:29]
colleague today I'm introducing a resolution to recognize july
[2:28:33]
28th, 2026 as wool hepatitis day in san francisco.
[2:28:39]
in 2020 the world health organization declared july 28th
[2:28:44]
as wool hepatitis day to honor nobel prize winner scientist
[2:28:48]
dr. Baruch blumberg who discovered a hepatitis b virus
[2:28:55]
in san francisco. It's estimated that 15,000
[2:28:58]
residents are living with chronic hepatitis hepatitis b 1
[2:29:05]
in 12 asian pacific islander adult immigrants a
[2:29:06]
disproportionate alley affected by hepatitis b deaths by
[2:29:10]
effective vaccines. Happy happy continues to impact
[2:29:14]
our communities. It is essential to continue
[2:29:18]
providing accessible screening treatments and raise
[2:29:22]
educational awareness. This resolution recognized two
[2:29:26]
health care professionals advocates in san francisco
[2:29:30]
happy free who work tirelessly to provide accessible care
[2:29:33]
community education and who advocate for state legislation
[2:29:37]
mandating primary care physician to offer screenings
[2:29:40]
to individuals at risk. But most importantly it urges
[2:29:45]
health care providers to continue providing prevent it
[2:29:48]
preventative hepatitis screening, accessible care
[2:29:51]
and to continue educational outreach to ensure our
[2:29:53]
communities are healthy. >> I would like to thank my
[2:29:56]
colleagues supervisor chen fielder, madam wong and walton
[2:30:00]
for your early co-sponsorship. >> next colleagues I would like
[2:30:04]
to introduce another resolution urging khizr to drop his
[2:30:10]
terrible three contract demands.
[2:30:11]
>> this comes as a follow up to the hearing that we held at
[2:30:15]
last week's committee of the whole.
[2:30:18]
we heard from clinicians and experts about problematic
[2:30:22]
contract demands that have the possibility of negatively
[2:30:26]
impacting the quality of care that patients receive due to a
[2:30:29]
potential for layoffs of staff clinicians increased it
[2:30:33]
outsourcing of care and referral of larger number
[2:30:37]
of patients onto artificial intelligence therapy platforms.
[2:30:40]
I have serious concerns about the use of ai or machine
[2:30:45]
learning for clinical treatment and clinical triage.
[2:30:49]
as I said during the hearing I'm not against technology but
[2:30:52]
without meaningful data and evidence that emerging
[2:30:53]
technologies ready for the kind of work that is allegedly being
[2:30:57]
employed whit through kaiser. We rise putting patients
[2:31:00]
in harm's way ai and other machine learning emerging
[2:31:04]
technologies are not obligated to patient care or wellness.
[2:31:08]
they do not take hippocratic oath.
[2:31:12]
if someone is seeking out a health care provider to inquire
[2:31:16]
about behavioral health treatments they deserve at
[2:31:17]
minimum to be assessed by a licensed clinicians on intake.
[2:31:21]
>> this resolutions urged kaiser to drop its terrible
[2:31:26]
three contract limits and requests that day come to
[2:31:30]
the bargaining table in good faith.
[2:31:31]
and what intentions of upholding the highest quality
[2:31:35]
standards of care as possible. Thank you to my colleague
[2:31:38]
supervisor walton chan fielder for their early co-sponsorship
[2:31:42]
and the rice I submitted. >> thank you.
[2:31:43]
thank you. Supervisor chen supervisor
[2:31:46]
dorsey. Thank you.
[2:31:47]
supervisor fielder. Thank you madam clerk please be
[2:31:51]
referred to me after my colleagues the writer bill gars
[2:31:55]
in memoriam. >> supervisor mahmud colleagues
[2:32:01]
as part of our continuing effort to address food
[2:32:02]
insecurity I am submitting a letter of inquiry today to the
[2:32:06]
city administrator and the director of real estate to
[2:32:09]
learn more about san francisco's municipal property
[2:32:10]
portfolio and how it can be used to support future
[2:32:14]
investments in food security. From what I've heard from
[2:32:17]
residents in district five accessing affordable, healthy
[2:32:20]
groceries is an issue in many of our neighborhoods
[2:32:21]
and grocery stores closing and tariffs affecting the costs
[2:32:25]
of goods. That is a problem that will
[2:32:26]
only get worse and make san francisco harder and harder to
[2:32:29]
live in for those whose incomes can't keep pace with rising
[2:32:32]
costs, the city has some data on its real estate but this
[2:32:37]
information isn't easily accessible or compiled in a way
[2:32:40]
to help leaders and community partners plan for potential new
[2:32:43]
food distribution and retail uses the ask in this letter is
[2:32:47]
for a complete inventory of city owned property including
[2:32:49]
vacant parcels, underutilized buildings and ground floor
[2:32:52]
commercial spaces in city owned buildings the neighborhood or
[2:32:55]
supervisory district in which each property is located the
[2:32:59]
approximate size of each person in each building and where
[2:33:02]
available and existing use designation occupancy status or
[2:33:07]
known constraints for each property.
[2:33:08]
I hope the results of this otherwise can be helpful to the
[2:33:10]
rest of my colleagues as well as we consider the city's role
[2:33:14]
in our neighborhoods just like the budget we approved earlier
[2:33:15]
today. How the city uses its real
[2:33:18]
estate is a moral document and should be an honest
[2:33:19]
expression of our values. This is the first step towards
[2:33:23]
achieving that. >> the rest I submit.
[2:33:26]
thank you supervisor. Mr. President.
[2:33:29]
>> thank you, madam clerk. I have a hearing request, an
[2:33:34]
ordinance and three in memoriam.
[2:33:39]
first I calling for a hearing on the progress of the city's
[2:33:43]
ongoing efforts to address drug markets and open air drug
[2:33:44]
scenes across san francisco. In may 2023, the city
[2:33:47]
established the drug market agency coordination center
[2:33:50]
demak to improve coordination of the city's response to open
[2:33:54]
air drug markets. Since that time residents
[2:33:55]
and visitors alike report improvements in street
[2:33:58]
conditions especially downtown. However, drug scenes have
[2:34:01]
persisted in historically challenged neighborhoods at
[2:34:05]
levels of activity that are unacceptable and new areas have
[2:34:09]
emerged as hubs of drug related activity notably including the
[2:34:13]
areas around the bart plazas at 16th and 24th streets.
[2:34:16]
recognizing the deterioration of conditions in the mission,
[2:34:18]
the administration in june the beginning of june initiated a
[2:34:21]
90 day period of focused enforcement and other
[2:34:25]
activities to try to turn the tide.
[2:34:26]
at this hearing I am interested in better understanding
[2:34:30]
and also giving the public a better opportunity to
[2:34:33]
understand the efforts that have been made to reduce street
[2:34:37]
level drug activity citywide and the more recent specific
[2:34:41]
efforts focused on the mission. In short, what has worked?
[2:34:45]
what hasn't and where are we going from here?
[2:34:46]
I look forward to hearing from the mayor's office, the police
[2:34:50]
department, the district attorney, the department of
[2:34:51]
public health, the office of economic and workforce
[2:34:53]
development and bart and I want to thank supervisor jackie
[2:34:57]
fielder and supervisor matt dorsey for their co-sponsorship
[2:35:01]
of this hearing request. >> secondly, earlier this year
[2:35:08]
the board passed an ordinance submitted for consideration by
[2:35:12]
the proposition e commission streamlining task force.
[2:35:13]
you will remember that you may remember this I hope you
[2:35:16]
remember this. The task force's mandate was to
[2:35:18]
identify opportunities to modify, consolidate or
[2:35:21]
eliminate public bodies to improve the administration of
[2:35:24]
city government while preserving meaningful
[2:35:25]
opportunity for public engagement.
[2:35:28]
among other changes, the ordinance established more
[2:35:32]
standardized structures and membership guidelines
[2:35:33]
across commissions to improve transparency and consistency
[2:35:36]
in how these bodies operate. >> the task force's ordinance
[2:35:39]
established term limits for most of our city's oversight
[2:35:43]
bodies. However, the members recognized
[2:35:46]
that term limits might not be necessary or desirable for all
[2:35:50]
bodies. One such body was the rent
[2:35:51]
board. The members of the task force
[2:35:55]
recommended preserving the rent board's current structure with
[2:35:58]
no term limits. The ordinance was introduced
[2:35:59]
and passed however inadvertently omitted an
[2:36:02]
exception to give effect to that direction.
[2:36:06]
the legislation I'm introducing corrects this and restores the
[2:36:09]
rent board term limit provision to its original form which is
[2:36:12]
consistent with what the task force recommended.
[2:36:13]
I want to thank mitchell omer berg, executive director of the
[2:36:17]
affordable housing alliance. Meg heisler, policy director
[2:36:21]
for san francisco communities against displacement.
[2:36:24]
and polly marshall, a founding member of the affordable
[2:36:26]
housing alliance and 35 year veteran of the rent board for
[2:36:28]
identifying and working with mae skelly in my office on this
[2:36:32]
issue. I also want to thank and new
[2:36:35]
and the apartment association for their feedback.
[2:36:37]
and finally I want to thank our deputy city attorney brad russi
[2:36:39]
for his work drafting the legislation.
[2:36:45]
>> the first memoriam I have is for jerry fuller.
[2:36:48]
I'm asking that we adjourn today's meeting in memory of
[2:36:52]
jerry who died of jerry gerald allen fuller who died on july
[2:36:56]
14th at the age of 76. He was born in illinois on
[2:37:00]
september 30th, 1949 and spent his early years in des plaines,
[2:37:04]
a suburb of chicago before his family moved to nearby mount
[2:37:08]
prospect. When he was 11 he graduated
[2:37:11]
high school there in 1967. A lifelong friend once said
[2:37:15]
that they were the only progressive minded people
[2:37:16]
in that conservative suburb and growing up in that
[2:37:20]
environment sparked jerry's lifelong political activism.
[2:37:23]
in high school he studied french unlike most students.
[2:37:26]
true, he learned to truly c truly learn to speak it
[2:37:28]
fluently. And after spending a semester
[2:37:31]
at the sorbonne he fell in love with paris where he would
[2:37:34]
return to spend many of his birthdays.
[2:37:35]
jerry was known for his intelligence and boundless
[2:37:39]
curiosity. He attended the university of
[2:37:40]
wisconsin in the late 1960s and early 70s studying
[2:37:42]
political history. During the height of the
[2:37:46]
vietnam war protests when the streets around were literally
[2:37:47]
on fire. After completing his
[2:37:50]
undergraduate studies, jerry moved to washington, d.c. To
[2:37:53]
pursue a master's degree in international relations at
[2:37:55]
george washington university. Later transferring to american
[2:37:58]
university living in georgetown in the mid to late 70s was
[2:38:02]
jerry's first time living in a city with a visible openly gay
[2:38:05]
community and culture and d.c. Would remain one of his
[2:38:08]
favorite cities along with san francisco and of course paris.
[2:38:12]
in 1980 moved by the community's response to the
[2:38:13]
assassination of harvey milk, jerry relocated to san
[2:38:17]
francisco. He got a job at kaiser where he
[2:38:19]
helped develop one of the first outreach programs for people
[2:38:21]
living with hiv. During these years he suffered
[2:38:24]
the loss of many dear friends losses that only reinforced his
[2:38:28]
commitment to political and community activism.
[2:38:31]
he worked at kaiser for more than 20 years before retiring
[2:38:34]
in his early 50s due to attendant injury.
[2:38:35]
in retirement he discovered a passion for photography taking
[2:38:38]
classes at city college. >> however, politics remained
[2:38:40]
his first love. He served on the board of the
[2:38:43]
alice b toklas lgbtq democratic club in the early to mid 2000s
[2:38:47]
which is how I met him as a young gay aspiring politico.
[2:38:51]
he remained active with lgbtq rights organizations and was a
[2:38:54]
dedicated volunteer at the frame line at frame one
[2:38:58]
in every city he lived at every job and school.
[2:39:02]
jerry formed deep lasting friendships in addition to his
[2:39:06]
intelligence passion for helping others love of art
[2:39:07]
and literature and sense of humor.
[2:39:09]
it was this gift of friendship that defined jerry fuller.
[2:39:10]
he left behind a world full of best friends rest in peace
[2:39:14]
and power. Jerry fuller.
[2:39:17]
may your memory be a blessing. I am also asking that we
[2:39:21]
adjourn today's meeting in memory of jeremiah.
[2:39:24]
jerry francis halsey. A civic, environmental
[2:39:26]
and educational leader who died on july 17th at the age of 87.
[2:39:30]
>> he was born on january 15th, 1939 in boston and moved to the
[2:39:37]
bay area to earn his juris doctor from the university of
[2:39:38]
california berkeley school of law.
[2:39:40]
after earning a bachelor of arts in english literature from
[2:39:44]
boston college and our master of arts in industrial and labor
[2:39:45]
relations from cornell university after graduating he
[2:39:48]
served in the united states army from 1963 to 1969
[2:39:52]
and following his military service he began a
[2:39:55]
distinguished legal career that spanned more than five decades.
[2:39:58]
after being admitted to the california bar in 1966, he
[2:40:01]
served as a deputy district attorney for contra costa
[2:40:05]
county and as a staff attorney with the u.s. Securities
[2:40:06]
and exchange commission. He went on to co-found the
[2:40:10]
offices of halsey and johnson in san francisco in 1970 where
[2:40:13]
he specialized in california energy and labor law even after
[2:40:17]
leaving his full time roles in public service, however,
[2:40:20]
halsey remained committed to serving the public.
[2:40:21]
over the years he held a number of leadership positions
[2:40:25]
in various civic and educational organizations,
[2:40:27]
including his 20 year tenure as a trustee of the california
[2:40:29]
construction industry labor management cooperation trust.
[2:40:32]
beginning in 2006, he also served on the california
[2:40:35]
transportation commission where he was vice chairman the
[2:40:38]
california economic development commission, the california
[2:40:39]
state coastal conservancy and the university of
[2:40:42]
california board of regents. He was deeply involved
[2:40:45]
in democratic party politics playing key roles in the
[2:40:47]
campaigns of governors edmund g.
[2:40:50]
brown jr gray davis and gavin newsom and fundraising for
[2:40:53]
democratic candidates at the national level including
[2:40:54]
presidents jimmy carter, bill clinton, barack obama and joe
[2:40:57]
biden. Halsey's catholic faith was a
[2:41:00]
guiding force throughout his life shaping the way he
[2:41:04]
approached his work, relationships and service to
[2:41:05]
others. Guided by the church's
[2:41:08]
teachings, he consistently sought opportunities to care
[2:41:11]
for those around him and help those in need.
[2:41:12]
he was known for being a whether enthusiast and for his
[2:41:16]
love of books and eclectic art. Many remember him as an
[2:41:19]
institution at the institution of sam's grill.
[2:41:20]
additionally, while he eventually embraced the san
[2:41:24]
francisco 40 niners and california golden bears he
[2:41:26]
never lost his boston accent or his loyalty to the boston red
[2:41:28]
sox and boston bruins. Our condolences go out to his
[2:41:31]
sons jeremy and sean, his stepson charlie johnson and the
[2:41:35]
many extended family members friends, colleagues and and
[2:41:38]
clients who loved him. Rest in peace, jeremiah halsey.
[2:41:42]
may your memory be a blessing. And finally I'm asking that we
[2:41:46]
adjourn today's meeting in memory of sidney alan
[2:41:49]
johnston who died far, far too young.
[2:41:53]
on june 26th, 2026 at the age of 40 she grew up in marin
[2:41:56]
county, received both her undergraduate degree and mba
[2:42:00]
from the university of the university of san francisco,
[2:42:04]
said it was named for her grandmother who along with her
[2:42:05]
grandfather gus bought john's grill in 1969 and turned it
[2:42:08]
into the landmark restaurant it is today.
[2:42:12]
cydney often worked behind the bar at john's grill and was
[2:42:15]
known for her warmth, quick wit and her genuine interest
[2:42:19]
in each and every customer. Her gift for connecting with
[2:42:20]
others led her to a career in hospitality.
[2:42:23]
although she later moved to greece, san francisco remained
[2:42:27]
an important part of her life. She continued to stay connected
[2:42:28]
to john's grill and collaborated on projects
[2:42:31]
with her brother including the john ellis block party and the
[2:42:34]
hello local podcast. Friends and family remember
[2:42:36]
sadness as event as adventurous, joyful giving
[2:42:38]
and devoted to her family. She is survived by her parents
[2:42:43]
john and athena constantine. Her brother john constant jr.
[2:42:46]
and his fiancee lindsay her nieces athena and leah.
[2:42:50]
and many beloved cousins. We want to send our profound
[2:42:54]
and deep condolences to the family.
[2:42:57]
rest in peace and power sad now.
[2:42:58]
may your memory be a blessing. >> and the rest I submit.
[2:43:01]
thank you, mr. President. Supervisor melgar.
[2:43:07]
thank you. I'd like to be added to the
[2:43:08]
in memoriam for as a constant please.
[2:43:12]
colleagues today I'm also submitting an in memoriam along
[2:43:16]
with my colleague supervisor fielder and supervisor walton
[2:43:23]
in honor of my dear friend dr. Estella reyes garcia whose
[2:43:27]
life's work has transformed the health and well-being of
[2:43:31]
generations of san franciscans. Dr. Estella reyes garcia was a
[2:43:35]
partner at the a sister, a leader, a chicana and activist
[2:43:42]
,a psychologist, a mentor, a jokester and so many other
[2:43:46]
things to so many people. She carried warmth and humor
[2:43:50]
alongside deep wisdom and she was tough.
[2:43:53]
she understood that healing did not happen only in a clinical
[2:43:57]
office. Healing happened
[2:43:58]
in relationships with family community land ancestors
[2:44:02]
ceremony, any language, music movement and collective
[2:44:07]
struggle. Throughout her life and career,
[2:44:10]
dr. Garcia worked to improve the mental, emotional,
[2:44:14]
spiritual and communal well-being of chicano, latino
[2:44:18]
indigenous and across all communities in san francisco.
[2:44:23]
she is known for her approximately 35 years at
[2:44:29]
instituto familia de la raza including 15 years as its
[2:44:33]
executive director and leader. Her story is one of
[2:44:37]
perseverance, service and an unwavering commitment to
[2:44:41]
uplifting our chicano, latino and indigenous communities.
[2:44:45]
from her childhood working alongside her mother
[2:44:46]
and siblings in california's central valley to earning
[2:44:49]
degrees from city college of san francisco, uc santa cruz,
[2:44:52]
uc berkeley and a doctorate from ucsf's langley porter
[2:44:56]
institute dr. Garcia has never forgotten where she comes from
[2:45:00]
and who she serves. Under her leadership, instituto
[2:45:04]
has become a model for culturally responsive care
[2:45:08]
providing vital services that recognize that true wellness is
[2:45:12]
an emotional spiritual, cultural and social.
[2:45:16]
throughout her work, countless individuals and families have
[2:45:21]
found support, dignity and hope a defining feature of dr.
[2:45:25]
garcia's work with her conviction that meaningful
[2:45:28]
healing must recognize the cultural and spiritual lives of
[2:45:32]
the people seeking support. Under her leadership ifr
[2:45:35]
brought together clinical services family support, youth
[2:45:39]
development prevention, peer support, community organizing,
[2:45:43]
traditional practices in different forms of healing.
[2:45:47]
darker garcia describes healing as a continuum that included
[2:45:51]
prevention, treatment, emotional wellness, spiritual
[2:45:54]
wellness and behavioral health. She emphasized that no single
[2:45:58]
practice professional, disciplined or healing
[2:46:02]
tradition was enough on its own.
[2:46:03]
people and communities need many medicines and those can
[2:46:06]
include therapy but they also can include healing circles
[2:46:13]
ceremony prayer allthat is dance art music movement
[2:46:17]
storytelling laughter food family participation elder
[2:46:21]
guidance community gatherings and connection to the
[2:46:25]
ancestors. >> her philosophy rejected the
[2:46:29]
idea that professional mental health treatment had to be
[2:46:31]
separated from wants culture and spiritual practice.
[2:46:34]
she understood that such a separation often reflected a
[2:46:38]
system that had historic dismissed indigenous knowledge
[2:46:42]
and treated western clinical models as the only legitimate
[2:46:46]
form of care. Dr. Garcia instead affirmed
[2:46:49]
that ancestral knowledge and community traditions had
[2:46:54]
always sustained our people. She worked to create spaces
[2:46:58]
in which clinical practice and traditional ways of healing
[2:47:02]
could exist together strengthening each other.
[2:47:05]
one of dr. Garcia's many important contributions is san
[2:47:09]
francisco with her advocacy for both indigenous residents from
[2:47:12]
mexico, central america and further south as well as
[2:47:16]
her support in bridge building with the american indian
[2:47:17]
community. Many indigenous immigrants to
[2:47:21]
san francisco encountered health, housing, immigration,
[2:47:24]
education and social service systems that were just not
[2:47:28]
prepared to recognize their languages, their cultures,
[2:47:30]
histories, migration experiences.
[2:47:33]
indigenous residents were often grouped broadly into latino
[2:47:37]
categories making their distinct identities and needs
[2:47:40]
invisible. Dr. Garcia understood that this
[2:47:45]
invisibility was not simply admin and an administrative
[2:47:48]
problem excuse me but it was part of a longer history of
[2:47:53]
colonization and cultural erasure.
[2:47:56]
the indigenous health and wellness initiative began
[2:48:00]
through association mab in response to the needs of san
[2:48:04]
francisco's yoga tech and mayan community and dr. Garcia's
[2:48:08]
advocacy helped secure dedicated funding for
[2:48:11]
indigenous communities. Under her leadership, ifr
[2:48:15]
initiated and supported many programs and efforts that
[2:48:16]
continue to this day to serve indigenous people from across
[2:48:20]
latin america with greater attention to mental health,
[2:48:23]
cultural identity, migration and trauma.
[2:48:28]
>> dr. Garcia also played a formative role in the
[2:48:31]
development of the road map to peace, a community initiative
[2:48:35]
created in response to violence affecting young latino
[2:48:39]
residents. Following the loss of several
[2:48:43]
young people in 24, the 2014 community organizations
[2:48:46]
and leaders began meeting to develop according needed
[2:48:50]
response. Dr. Garcia made clear that the
[2:48:51]
community could not remain inactive while young people
[2:48:55]
were being lost. She understood that violence as
[2:48:59]
connected to deep deeper conditions trauma,
[2:49:02]
disconnection, institutional racism, poverty, neighborhood
[2:49:06]
displacement, involvement in juvenile and legal
[2:49:10]
and criminal legal systems, limited economic opportunities
[2:49:14]
and the loss of cultural identity and belonging wrote
[2:49:19]
roadmap to peace brought together the community
[2:49:20]
and providing combined coordinated services youth
[2:49:23]
leadership, healing family support, community engagement
[2:49:27]
and alternatives to involvement in the juvenile and criminal
[2:49:30]
justice system. Dr. Estella garcia legacy can
[2:49:34]
be found in the clinicians she mentored.
[2:49:37]
the organization she strengthens the coalition.
[2:49:41]
she helped build the ceremonies and healing circles she
[2:49:45]
supported. The young people many young
[2:49:48]
people given another path and the families who
[2:49:50]
encountered services that recognize their full humanity.
[2:49:53]
it can also be found in the continued practice she left
[2:49:57]
with all of us. The practice of la quinta
[2:50:01]
guerra my heart goes out to her spouse robin san miguel thank
[2:50:05]
you estella for your lifelong commitment to healing our
[2:50:08]
communities. I also want to thank especially
[2:50:13]
julius huberty and tracy brown for their collaboration and in
[2:50:17]
preparing this in memoriam. San francisco is a better,
[2:50:21]
healthier and more compassionate city because of
[2:50:22]
dr. Estelle garcia. The doctor is the latter as
[2:50:26]
garcia and mr. President. Madam clerk, I would like to
[2:50:32]
turn this over to supervisor fielder to share a few remarks
[2:50:36]
and then be referred for introductions.
[2:50:37]
>> thank you. >> thank you so much supervisor
[2:50:41]
melgar for leading this in memoriam.
[2:50:44]
I would like to add a few brief remarks on behalf of myself
[2:50:48]
and district nine to honor the life and legacy of dr. Stella
[2:50:49]
rae as garcia who played such a pivotal role in the mission
[2:50:53]
district. Throughout her decades of
[2:50:56]
leadership and work for social change including over 35 years
[2:51:00]
at instituto familia de la raza 15 of those at the helm.
[2:51:04]
dr. Garcia was a beloved mentor and visionary, especially
[2:51:07]
visible in the countless women leaders who grew up in her
[2:51:11]
orbit and who are now outspoken changemakers in our city.
[2:51:14]
dr. Garcia left her mark in advocating for
[2:51:18]
and implementing public policy and mental health hiv services
[2:51:22]
and social services to improve access and promote healthy
[2:51:23]
communities particularly for the latino immigrant community.
[2:51:27]
the mission district will miss her dearly but remember her
[2:51:31]
legacy which lives on in ifr and so many of our leaders.
[2:51:35]
I offer my deepest condolences to her lifelong partner robert
[2:51:38]
and son miguel, their daughter and nieces mikayla, ana
[2:51:42]
and esperanza, their grandchildren and their
[2:51:43]
extended community looks like supervisor chen also.
[2:51:51]
>> thank you person. Don't mind.
[2:51:55]
thank you. Thank you supervisor malkia for
[2:51:56]
giving us the opportunity to recognize the many
[2:51:59]
contributions that dr. Garcia blasted our community with.
[2:52:02]
not only did she help build ifr into what is today but she had
[2:52:06]
a direct impact and influence over the wellness and safety of
[2:52:10]
so many families in our neighborhoods.
[2:52:13]
her innovation, grit and love for community will be
[2:52:14]
remembered for generations. I'm also sending my love to our
[2:52:19]
family. Thank you for sharing her with
[2:52:22]
our city. May her memory be a blessing.
[2:52:24]
>> thank you. >> thank you.
[2:52:28]
and supervise your melgar. You wanted to finish your roll
[2:52:33]
call for introductions. Thank you, madam clerk.
[2:52:37]
today I am introducing a hearing request along with
[2:52:40]
supervisors dorsey chen chan and fielder for a joint meeting
[2:52:45]
between the commission on the status of women and the board
[2:52:49]
of supervisors public safety and neighborhood services
[2:52:53]
committee. The staffing needs policies
[2:52:55]
and procedures for responding to and addressing reports of
[2:52:57]
sexual assault. >> last march we held a hearing
[2:53:01]
on the severe understaffed understaffing and policies for
[2:53:05]
the san francisco police department's special victims
[2:53:08]
unit. >> the hearing illuminated the
[2:53:09]
critical consequences of an understaffed team tasked with
[2:53:13]
some of the most egregious cases of sexual assault
[2:53:17]
domestic violence, human trafficking and the toll that
[2:53:21]
it takes on overworked investigators.
[2:53:25]
while staffing remained difficult to address, there was
[2:53:28]
still a commitment and immediate steps that were
[2:53:30]
taken after the hearing to alleviate the strains of the
[2:53:33]
special victims unit into strengthened protocols.
[2:53:36]
there has been some progress but we still have a long way to
[2:53:40]
go. >> last week the san francisco
[2:53:43]
standard reported on how difficult it remains to
[2:53:44]
navigate the process even when a survivor follows all the
[2:53:48]
steps, collects evidence and even has a suspect match.
[2:53:54]
it demonstrates that there is a culture that prevails where
[2:53:56]
sexual assault is not provided the same level of urgency
[2:53:59]
and sensitivity which leads to survive.
[2:54:03]
survivors refraining from reporting or speaking up when
[2:54:06]
there is a sexual assault. San francisco's rape case
[2:54:10]
clearance rate has dropped significantly to the point
[2:54:14]
where there are we are at half the national rate with only 14%
[2:54:20]
of rapes cleared. If we want survivors to feel
[2:54:24]
safe coming forward, it is up to us to show how we will be
[2:54:28]
held accountable to serving them with dignity and a sense
[2:54:32]
of urgency. The commission on the status of
[2:54:33]
women also discussed this issue last week so that is why I am
[2:54:37]
calling the joint hearing with our public safety
[2:54:40]
and neighborhood services committee today.
[2:54:41]
we want this hearing to focus on next steps for improving the
[2:54:44]
outcomes and the handling of sexual assault reports.
[2:54:47]
this is about collaboration and bringing together resources
[2:54:51]
so we can center survivors and make improvements.
[2:54:55]
I want to thank the mayor's office the victim and witness
[2:54:59]
services, the office of sexual harassment and assault response
[2:55:02]
and prevention. Sharp the san francisco police
[2:55:03]
department the department of the status of women and the
[2:55:07]
mayor's office for their willingness both
[2:55:11]
in collaboration and thank you to chair dorsey of the public
[2:55:15]
safety neighborhood services committee for your partnership.
[2:55:19]
the rest I submit thank you supervisor or supervisor sauter
[2:55:23]
colleagues. >> housing continues to be the
[2:55:26]
defining crisis of our day. Rents are crushing the very
[2:55:30]
people who make this city run and are keeping out countless
[2:55:34]
members of the next generation who want to live their san
[2:55:37]
francisco dream. We need to respond to this
[2:55:41]
emergency by both building more homes and supporting existing
[2:55:45]
tenants, keeping renters in their homes and ensuring
[2:55:46]
these homes are affordable and in good condition.
[2:55:49]
>> must absolutely be part of our response to the housing
[2:55:53]
crisis. So today I'm introducing three
[2:55:56]
items which respond to the increasing pressure that
[2:56:00]
renters find themselves under in today's hot housing market.
[2:56:03]
>> first I'm introducing a drafting request to update
[2:56:07]
and strengthen san francisco's elevator ordinance.
[2:56:11]
>> and before I tell you what the legislation is, I want to
[2:56:13]
tell you why I'm doing this. It's because of the tenants at
[2:56:16]
845 california that I have met over this past year almost 100
[2:56:20]
of my constituents, different agents, different backgrounds,
[2:56:24]
all who have had to bond together out of necessity
[2:56:27]
because their elevators have been broken nearly nonstop.
[2:56:31]
an elevator outage might seem like an abstract problem until
[2:56:36]
you hear directly from the people it hurts.
[2:56:39]
so this summer I visited f45, california and met the people
[2:56:43]
impacted by this. I met an amazing 94 year old
[2:56:46]
woman who has contributed decades of her life to san
[2:56:50]
francisco but is now isolated from the city she loves.
[2:56:53]
I met a man who suffered cardiac arrest in his apartment
[2:56:58]
and when the paramedics arrived he had to walk himself down
[2:57:01]
many flights of stairs because the elevator was broken.
[2:57:05]
I met a woman who told me how she struggles to carry her dog
[2:57:08]
in one hand and groceries in the other as she traverses
[2:57:11]
the steep stairs. >> I met neighbor after
[2:57:13]
neighbor who shared that they now go out less because of the
[2:57:17]
elevator outages and skipping seeing friends, limiting
[2:57:21]
groceries and putting off doctor appointments or even
[2:57:24]
surgeries because of the uncertainty.
[2:57:27]
and I saw that eight flights of winding narrow, disjointed
[2:57:28]
stairs stand between them and their normal lives
[2:57:31]
and activities in san francisco .
[2:57:35]
despite nearly 30 formal building complaints repeated
[2:57:38]
outreach from my office and tenant complaints, the
[2:57:39]
property owner has been evasive and noncommittal in their
[2:57:43]
responsibility to fix the elevators.
[2:57:46]
they constantly play a cat and mouse game in making
[2:57:47]
temporary fixes to evade building inspections and forced
[2:57:50]
tenants to wade through endless mazes of phone trees to try
[2:57:54]
and reach a real human being. >> and while these elevators
[2:57:58]
stop broken month after month, this landlord has been
[2:58:01]
marketing a 400 square foot studio in the very same
[2:58:05]
building for $4,200 a month. And the listing even promised a
[2:58:10]
quote elevator for effortless access.
[2:58:13]
>> after I toured the building. I was left dismayed and angry.
[2:58:17]
the property owner clearly needs to answer for their own
[2:58:21]
neglect but our city can do more to our current elevator
[2:58:25]
ordinance is light on specifics and gives bad actors far too
[2:58:29]
much leeway when an elevator doesn't actually reliably serve
[2:58:33]
tenants. >> so today's drafting request
[2:58:34]
will ask that the city attorney work to update san francisco's
[2:58:38]
elevator ordinance in a number of ways, including requiring
[2:58:42]
that property owners have a responsibility to maintain all
[2:58:46]
elevators as fast as operable at all times and setting a
[2:58:53]
clear deadline for repairs to be completed.
[2:58:54]
requiring that relocation options be provided by property
[2:58:58]
owners to certain populations that need accommodations for
[2:59:01]
outages longer than 24 hours. Requiring that more notices
[2:59:08]
and electronic communications be posted and sent immediately
[2:59:11]
for all outages including translation for city supported
[2:59:13]
languages. >> we will also examine fees
[2:59:17]
and enforcement schedules for building violations related to
[2:59:20]
elevator outages and clarify remedies and anti retaliation
[2:59:24]
protections available to tenants when their access to
[2:59:28]
their homes is limited is limited by elevator outages.
[2:59:31]
>> I believe that a working elevator in an apartment is not
[2:59:35]
an amenity or a luxury. It is a core housing service.
[2:59:39]
and so this legislation says simply if you profit from a
[2:59:43]
building you're responsible for keeping it livable.
[2:59:46]
>> next I'm introducing a budget and legislative
[2:59:50]
analyst's request to consider improvements for san francisco
[2:59:54]
whose policy regarding banked rent increases banked rent is
[2:59:58]
the practice of a landlord skipping an annual allowable
[3:00:01]
rent increase and instead saving or banking the unused
[3:00:06]
percentage. And under today's policy
[3:00:07]
landlords have the option to add this bank rent increase at
[3:00:11]
a future date to the same tenant with no limits.
[3:00:14]
this can lead to a large rent increase in future years that
[3:00:18]
can be hard to expect or absorb all at once.
[3:00:21]
in today's hot market we're seeing bank rent use as a tool
[3:00:25]
to push tenants out with large increases rent increases that
[3:00:29]
are untenable. This is especially concerning
[3:00:32]
around the sale of new buildings which was the case at
[3:00:35]
1120. Jackson in my district where a
[3:00:38]
92 year old and her neighbors are fighting evictions here.
[3:00:42]
banks rent was first used as an incentive for the building as
[3:00:46]
it was marketed having a 224% rental upside achievable
[3:00:49]
through unit turnover and then bankrupt bank banked rent was
[3:00:57]
weaponized to bring sudden rent increases that no tenant could
[3:01:01]
absorb overnight. I believe there are guardrails
[3:01:05]
that we should consider which will help us avoid these
[3:01:08]
scenarios. Every other city that allows
[3:01:12]
bank rent has guardrails every single one except san
[3:01:16]
francisco. And we have literally been
[3:01:19]
called the wild west of rent banking because of this.
[3:01:23]
>> so our bill a report will look at limits and protections
[3:01:25]
that other cities have enacted and consider how they might
[3:01:28]
impact san francisco tenants, property owners and the overall
[3:01:32]
rental market. >> finally I am introducing
[3:01:35]
hearing requests on the topic of rental scams a practice that
[3:01:39]
is becoming more sophisticated and deceptive in this brutal
[3:01:43]
rental market. San franciscans searching for
[3:01:47]
housing are increasingly targeted by rental scams
[3:01:50]
listing listings for apartments that simply don't exist.
[3:01:54]
scammers posing as landlords or property managers as requests
[3:01:59]
for deposits or first month's rent before reviewing
[3:02:01]
and fraudulent subletting schemes that exploit the city's
[3:02:06]
competitive rental market. These scams disproportionately
[3:02:10]
hit renters with the least room for financial loss students new
[3:02:12]
arrivals, low income tenants and immigrants navigating an
[3:02:15]
unfamiliar housing search process for the first time.
[3:02:18]
>> so our hearing will examine the scope of this problem
[3:02:22]
in san francisco. What protections currently
[3:02:25]
exist and what more are the city can do to warn people
[3:02:26]
before money changes hands? A special thanks to chief
[3:02:30]
assistant treasurer amanda freed for her work in elevating
[3:02:33]
this issue and her office's commitment to consumer
[3:02:37]
protections in a brutal housing market.
[3:02:41]
>> we need to step up how our city protects renters and long
[3:02:45]
time tenants. My message to those seeking to
[3:02:48]
exploit today is competitive market is clear.
[3:02:52]
if you own a building, keep the elevator running.
[3:02:56]
if you're going to raise the rent, don't spring years of
[3:02:59]
increases on someone overnight. And if you're advertising an
[3:03:02]
apartment it should actually exist.
[3:03:03]
so I look forward to turning this work into legislation
[3:03:07]
in the months ahead to better protect san francisco renters.
[3:03:10]
I want to thank michelle andrews for my team for her
[3:03:14]
work on all of these items and for approaching both the
[3:03:15]
human stories and legislative side with care
[3:03:18]
and consideration. I also want to thank city
[3:03:22]
attorneys including brad rossi, megan ryan and rob coppola for
[3:03:23]
their partnership on these items and the rest.
[3:03:26]
>> I submit. >> thank you.
[3:03:30]
supervisor supervisor cheryl smith thank you.
[3:03:34]
scene no other names on the roster mr. President.
[3:03:37]
>> that concludes roll call for introduction.
[3:03:38]
let's go to public comment. >> all right.
[3:03:41]
at this time the board of supervisors welcomes your
[3:03:43]
general public comment. In person speakers will be
[3:03:45]
prioritized so please line up on the right hand side of the
[3:03:49]
chamber. Those joining us remotely
[3:03:52]
superstar three now to line up in the remote queue.
[3:03:53]
during general public comment you may speak to the approval
[3:03:56]
of the june 23rd board meeting minutes.
[3:04:00]
the june 22nd june 24th and june 2nd june 25th.
[3:04:03]
budget and appropriation committee minutes.
[3:04:06]
items 88 through 95 the items under the for adoption without
[3:04:10]
committee reference calendar and any other general matters
[3:04:12]
that are not on today's agenda but must be within the board's
[3:04:15]
subject matter jurisdiction. >> all other agenda content
[3:04:18]
will have been reported out to the board by an appropriate
[3:04:21]
committee where the public comment requirement occurred.
[3:04:23]
as I indicated at the beginning of the meeting, the board has
[3:04:27]
also approved a rule to address disorderly public comment.
[3:04:30]
members of the public must keep their comments germane to
[3:04:32]
matters within the jurisdiction of the board.
[3:04:35]
any comments that contain personal attacks, harassment or
[3:04:38]
discriminatory remarks directed to a city employee or board
[3:04:42]
member outside the scope of this body and shall be
[3:04:43]
redirected? Failure to immediately redirect
[3:04:46]
your comments will result in your forfeiture of remaining
[3:04:50]
time and we will transition to the next speaker.
[3:04:53]
also please remember to address your comments to the board as a
[3:04:54]
whole and not to individual members.
[3:04:56]
>> first person. Good evening supervisors.
[3:05:01]
my name is amelia. District nine speaking in my
[3:05:03]
individual capacity in the last two weeks I have walked over 23
[3:05:07]
miles across our city across our system of care.
[3:05:11]
the crisis centers, shelters, rehabs, drop in centers, food
[3:05:12]
distribution sites, supportive housing sites.
[3:05:16]
I had to tell them they may be witnessing the removal of peer
[3:05:20]
counselors from the street crisis response team from
[3:05:21]
frontline workers to directors. No one that I spoke to had
[3:05:24]
heard it anywhere else. They count on the non-uniformed
[3:05:28]
peer support backed by our traditional first responders
[3:05:31]
when they call 911 for their people.
[3:05:33]
our people. One person on foot in door to
[3:05:37]
door during off hours should not be the communication
[3:05:38]
strategy for a policy change of this consequence within a
[3:05:41]
city's administration focused on coordination, accountability
[3:05:45]
and outcomes. Some of the sentiments of those
[3:05:48]
conversations are already public record.
[3:05:49]
in the 70 letters you have all received in your board packets
[3:05:53]
from the last two weeks alone if we really are to break the
[3:05:56]
cycle, let's start with telling the truth out loud to your
[3:06:00]
constituents your health care and social service workers.
[3:06:03]
>> first responders want this. The answer is in your inbox.
[3:06:07]
I want to be able to solve programmatic issues at the
[3:06:08]
programmatic level while looking to you for macro level
[3:06:11]
direction. But I ask right now why would
[3:06:15]
we forfeit funded high quality care that has mechanisms for
[3:06:19]
federal and state reimbursement?
[3:06:19]
in this budget climate. Please sign a letter to the
[3:06:23]
mayors support the mayor's office to support us regarding
[3:06:26]
a thorough review before recess.
[3:06:29]
I am here as a resource whether we are to do the right thing
[3:06:31]
right now or whether we'll have to someday rebuild the
[3:06:34]
demolition of a once successful collaboration.
[3:06:38]
now effective. Now effective august 14th.
[3:06:42]
>> thank you. Thank you for your comments.
[3:06:44]
>> next speaker. >> good morning president
[3:06:51]
mandell men, members of the board of supervisors and my
[3:06:53]
fellow san franciscans. My name is eva seligman and I
[3:06:56]
am honored to serve as a legislative intern
[3:07:00]
and supervisor dorsey's office. I am also a proud native of san
[3:07:04]
franciscan. >> currently I study at boston
[3:07:05]
university frederic party school of global studies where
[3:07:08]
I study international relations and history.
[3:07:11]
>> it is my privilege to stand before you today to introduce a
[3:07:15]
resolution that I helped authored establishing a
[3:07:16]
fentanyl awareness and remembrance day in the city
[3:07:20]
and county of san francisco. >> for the past four years
[3:07:23]
supervisor dorsey has been a leading voice in advancing a
[3:07:27]
recovery first approach to the drug crisis in our city an
[3:07:31]
approach that prioritizes treatment, rehabilitation,
[3:07:36]
prevention and public safety. This resolution builds upon
[3:07:39]
that important work by recognizing the profound impact
[3:07:40]
fentanyl has had on our communities and honoring the
[3:07:44]
lives we have lost. Funnel has fundamentally
[3:07:48]
changed the landscape of the overdose crisis in san
[3:07:51]
francisco. It is more potent, more
[3:07:52]
dangerous and more unpredictable all than previous
[3:07:55]
substances and it has left families, neighborhoods
[3:07:59]
and communities across our city devastated.
[3:08:00]
>> behind every number and every statistic there is a
[3:08:03]
person there is a loved one a neighbor, a friend, a family
[3:08:08]
member, a son, a daughter, a valued member of this
[3:08:12]
community. >> this resolution creates an
[3:08:15]
opportunity to honor those individuals, support those who
[3:08:19]
continue to grieve and raise awareness about the ongoing
[3:08:20]
dangers of fentanyl. Fentanyl awareness
[3:08:23]
and remembrance day is not only about looking back
[3:08:27]
and remembering those we have lost.
[3:08:28]
it is also about looking forward with greater awareness,
[3:08:31]
stronger prevention efforts and a renewed commitment to
[3:08:35]
pursuing solution that saves lives.
[3:08:36]
>> san francisco has always been a city that confronts
[3:08:40]
difficult challenges with compassion and courage
[3:08:43]
and action. >> by recognizing this day we
[3:08:44]
affirm our commitment to supporting those impacted by
[3:08:48]
the crisis. I respectfully ask for you to
[3:08:51]
support this resolution. Thank you very much.
[3:08:52]
thank you for your comments. >> speakers good afternoon
[3:09:02]
president man woman members of the board.
[3:09:06]
>> my name is mahoney seabury and I have the privilege of
[3:09:10]
serving as a legislative aide to supervisor matt dorsey.
[3:09:11]
>> I'm deeply honored to stand before you not only as a member
[3:09:14]
of a staff but as a proud afghan-american speaking on
[3:09:18]
behalf of item 88 recognizing august as afghan-american
[3:09:21]
heritage month. >> this resolution represents
[3:09:25]
something I have never imagined that I would see growing up to
[3:09:28]
stand in this chambers as an afghan-american serving the
[3:09:30]
people of san francisco and representing a resolution
[3:09:33]
recognizing my own community is both humbling and deeply
[3:09:37]
meaningful. It is a reminder that
[3:09:38]
representation matters and that every community deserves to see
[3:09:41]
its story reflected in the institutions that serve them.
[3:09:45]
this resolution also represents the continuation of a journey
[3:09:49]
that began here in this chamber back in 2023.
[3:09:52]
I had the privilege of drafting san francisco's first
[3:09:56]
afghan-american heritage resolution and at the time I
[3:10:00]
hope that it would become more than a proclamation I hoped it
[3:10:04]
would become a tradition one that ensured future generations
[3:10:05]
of african americans would not only see their heritage
[3:10:08]
recognized but their contribution asians celebrated.
[3:10:12]
>> today I am incredibly proud to say that that vision has
[3:10:16]
grown beyond san francisco. Earlier this year in march, the
[3:10:17]
state of california officially recognized afghan-american
[3:10:21]
heritage month building upon the momentum that began began
[3:10:24]
here at the board of supervisors.
[3:10:27]
>> it is a powerful reminder that meaningful change often
[3:10:31]
begins at the local level. This year also marks another
[3:10:35]
historic first for the first time in conjunction with afghan
[3:10:38]
american heritage month, the board of supervisors is
[3:10:40]
recognizing afghan americans for their extraordinary service
[3:10:43]
to our city and our state. These honorees are more than
[3:10:48]
accomplished professionals. They are examples of african
[3:10:49]
americans that have contributed to california for decades
[3:10:52]
quietly serving, quietly leading and giving back.
[3:10:55]
>> this is why this resolution matters.
[3:10:58]
I want to personally thank supervisor matt dorsey for his
[3:11:00]
unwavering support and for championing this resolution
[3:11:03]
and I thank each of you for recognizing the extraordinary
[3:11:07]
contribution. >> thank you for your comments
[3:11:09]
. >> next speaker.
[3:11:17]
>> good afternoon supervisors. I am richard knee, a journalist
[3:11:21]
and former member of the sunshine ordinance task force.
[3:11:24]
I'm speaking on behalf of the society of professional
[3:11:28]
journalists northern california chapter and the pacific media
[3:11:30]
workers guild. >> news guild cwa local three
[3:11:34]
9521. >> at least one of you has
[3:11:35]
expressed a desire to fill the task force with members who
[3:11:40]
take a so-called pragmatic approach toward sunshine law
[3:11:43]
compliance delaying appointment of those who have already
[3:11:47]
applied and in some cases been vetted by spca and the league
[3:11:51]
of women voters is anything but pragmatic.
[3:11:55]
>> you are forcing the task force to go on hiatus causing
[3:11:59]
build up of a backlog of sunshine related complaints
[3:12:02]
and delaying redress for those who have filed them.
[3:12:06]
it is not the task force's job to be more friendly or more
[3:12:09]
adversarial towards city officials and agencies.
[3:12:13]
the task force's job is to encourage and monitor sunshine
[3:12:17]
law compliance without fear or favor.
[3:12:21]
>> at least one of you argues that the volume of record
[3:12:25]
requests makes it difficult for city officials and agencies to
[3:12:28]
do their job. >> sunshine law compliance is
[3:12:33]
part and parcel of that job. >> but rather than make sure
[3:12:37]
that those officials and agencies have sufficient
[3:12:38]
staffing and resources to meet record requests, some of you
[3:12:45]
want instead to blame the requesters for exercising their
[3:12:48]
right to know about city policies and actions and their
[3:12:52]
bases. A tactic straight out of the
[3:12:53]
author authority tarion playbook is a wrongheaded
[3:12:56]
approach that will enable backroom dealing and force
[3:13:00]
sunshine complainants to go to court which will cost the city
[3:13:04]
potentially millions every year .
[3:13:07]
>> that is anything but pragmatic.
[3:13:11]
thank you for your comments. Next speaker.
[3:13:19]
hello city council and nice to see you jackie.
[3:13:22]
my name is dee henry and I'm here to discuss something
[3:13:24]
that's not on the agenda today but stick with me.
[3:13:26]
>> it will all relate. I want to advocate for a
[3:13:30]
historically shafted bird. >> I was once like you, jackie
[3:13:34]
thinking of them as rats of the skies.
[3:13:37]
I saw dirty scoundrels feeding the dirty birds and it almost
[3:13:41]
brought me to tears to say that I spat on them.
[3:13:42]
>> I've heard them called mudguards black plague birds
[3:13:46]
target practice ice chubby doves dog toys government spies
[3:13:53]
,alien spies hoochie mamas scaly rats monk jumbos concrete
[3:13:57]
chicken guzzlers and in some cases as the covid pandemics
[3:14:03]
patient zero. I would like to offer a moment
[3:14:05]
of silence for uttering those words.
[3:14:08]
but it all changed when I moved to san fran.
[3:14:11]
I was gazing out at the beautiful sunset over the bay
[3:14:12]
as I cut my toenails and a big bang almost made me chop off my
[3:14:19]
toe. I went out to the balcony
[3:14:20]
and heard a faint cuckoo and saw I would become my best
[3:14:23]
friend and lover. >> little kenny I realized that
[3:14:29]
these are cuddly, chunky, curious and totally cuckoo for
[3:14:33]
cocoa puffs creatures and this city has declared war on them.
[3:14:38]
>> and I'm here to make a stand .
[3:14:40]
look around. There's spikes on windows.
[3:14:44]
nets on doorways and the covert pigeon hunting syndicate known
[3:14:48]
as the parrots. >> I've spent long nights
[3:14:49]
weeping in the fetal position due to this city's atrocities
[3:14:53]
towards pages. >> so here are my demands.
[3:14:56]
>> cuckoo. Here we go, jackie.
[3:15:00]
okay, everyone. Pigeons on three.
[3:15:02]
one, two, three. Pigeons.
[3:15:04]
>> thank you. >> thank you for your comments.
[3:15:09]
next speaker. >> good afternoon.
[3:15:16]
my name is yahia buzzard. I'm here today with care the
[3:15:19]
council on american-islamic relations and we support the
[3:15:22]
resolution recognizing south asian american heritage month
[3:15:24]
in san francisco. >> for generations south asian
[3:15:27]
americans have shaped the fabric of san francisco through
[3:15:31]
their contributions to the city's culture economy, public
[3:15:35]
service and civic life. >> the south asian american
[3:15:38]
community is incredibly diverse encompassing muslim dalit sick
[3:15:43]
tamil bengali napoli, indo caribbean and many other
[3:15:48]
communities whose histories and contributions deserve to be
[3:15:51]
recognized and celebrated. Recognizing south asian
[3:15:55]
american heritage month uplifts many stories, identities
[3:15:59]
and contributions especially at a time when south asians
[3:16:03]
continue to face discrimination ,hate and erasure.
[3:16:07]
>> we are grateful to supervisor mahmood
[3:16:10]
and commissioner kudarat, continues chaudhry for their
[3:16:13]
leadership on this resolution. We respectfully urge the board
[3:16:17]
to unanimously support the resolution and to continue
[3:16:21]
celebrating the invaluable contributions of south
[3:16:22]
asian-americans in san francisco.
[3:16:25]
>> thank you. Thank you for your comments.
[3:16:28]
>> next speaker I abhor this colonial u.s. Government of
[3:16:36]
white christian nationalistic primacy of coerced cisgender
[3:16:40]
living and heterosexuality of capitalism policing, slavery,
[3:16:44]
genocide, eco side eugenics all of it but only focusing on that
[3:16:48]
dream my humanity until I feel my bone dry of its marrow.
[3:16:51]
I'm aspiring to root more in what makes being human
[3:16:53]
worthwhile. As corny as it sounds, love is
[3:16:56]
what makes this fight worth fighting.
[3:16:59]
love of my soulmate our kitties love of love of saying join
[3:17:02]
others and helping others find their joyful moments seeing an
[3:17:04]
uplifting and protecting the humanity of every other person
[3:17:07]
to everyone feeling like they're about to buckle under
[3:17:11]
the state sponsored domestic terror.
[3:17:12]
>> don't give up. >> I won't give up and I hope
[3:17:15]
you don't either. Related.
[3:17:18]
what will be the point of human supervisors if a mayor or city
[3:17:22]
attorney can just use a.I. To generate legislation?
[3:17:23]
will we get district a.I. Chat bots to address our concerns
[3:17:27]
instead of five or so humans staffing each district office?
[3:17:29]
the mayor has open had open eyes ceo sam altman on his
[3:17:34]
transition team. Just this month it was
[3:17:35]
announced that our state of california is expanding access
[3:17:37]
across state government through an anthropic a.I. Partnership.
[3:17:41]
every government concession to a.I. Replacing the human heart,
[3:17:45]
intelligence and discretion is a concession to inhumanity
[3:17:46]
literally. And let me tell you san
[3:17:49]
francisco and california they're making massive
[3:17:50]
concessions. >> if there's one thing people
[3:17:53]
of san francisco should know by now, it's that our mayor does
[3:17:55]
not support any new taxes nor restrictions on big tech
[3:17:57]
corporations and real estate. We just saw that when the
[3:18:01]
mayor dennis supports a proposed tax to encourage
[3:18:04]
filling empty grocery stores, empty grocery store fronts
[3:18:06]
and not supporting a resolution supporting a state's bill
[3:18:09]
against surveillance pricing. >> we have a no new taxes on
[3:18:12]
the rich mayor and a techno fascist billionaire political
[3:18:14]
movement has paved its way into city hall paid its way into
[3:18:16]
city hall transforming san francisco into a red city and a
[3:18:20]
blue state red not due to communism or socialism but red
[3:18:23]
due to our mayor's alignment with the trump administration's
[3:18:26]
agenda. The mayor's approach to
[3:18:27]
governing is that of a ceo capitalist and tyrannical
[3:18:30]
and stealing stability and life itself from the homeless, poor
[3:18:32]
and marginalized. >> thank you for your comments.
[3:18:35]
next speaker barra supervisors and mayor office of san
[3:18:46]
francisco. The title of today is any
[3:18:49]
statically terrifying. Let it be known I'm the
[3:18:51]
guardian of the title of miss chinatown or san francisco 2018
[3:18:57]
and miss popular miss chinese international 2019.
[3:19:00]
in february of 2019 maggie wong came home with the title of
[3:19:03]
miss popularity of miss chinese international.
[3:19:06]
despite the fact everyone bet against her by june of 20 19 I
[3:19:12]
had a change of heart. >> a grudge to me is an act of
[3:19:17]
nothing more intriguing poising hoping the other person will
[3:19:21]
die. Let bygones be bygones.
[3:19:24]
to celebrate my new view I bought my auntie a new iphone.
[3:19:28]
>> two months later I drove maggie to meet my auntie.
[3:19:32]
>> auntie. Where is my iphone?
[3:19:36]
it was a tongue in cheek response that ms. Chinatown is
[3:19:40]
here it's by my side and here to stay.
[3:19:42]
>> she took it the wrong way. She thought I was going comedy.
[3:19:45]
iphone. >> and hand it to maggie.
[3:19:49]
instead of paying maggie a greeting, she bolted up the
[3:19:52]
stairs and locked herself in a bathroom.
[3:19:56]
she cried hysterically uncontrollably and she would
[3:20:00]
not open the door until I leave.
[3:20:01]
that ends my journey to the title owner of miss popularity
[3:20:04]
of miss chinese international. Some of you say oh my god that
[3:20:11]
is horrible. >> what why done to your
[3:20:12]
auntie? It is true at certain angle
[3:20:15]
maggie could be terrifying. >> which brings me I would
[3:20:19]
prefer not to talk about my destination but my journey.
[3:20:25]
>> for me doing something as difficult and hard I don't look
[3:20:29]
at challenge. >> I look at hope.
[3:20:34]
if the chance for me to clinch a no point zero one chance of
[3:20:37]
success I would take it because my mom named me lock soo nung
[3:20:41]
means ability and what do I need to do?
[3:20:44]
>> thank you. Thank you for your comments.
[3:20:46]
next speaker. Good evening supervisors.
[3:20:54]
happy disability pride month. This is elijah logan, director
[3:20:59]
of the office on disability and accessibility and while I
[3:21:03]
would love to just talk about all the great work our office
[3:21:06]
and our departments are doing around excessive ability
[3:21:11]
including expanding language access for the deaf and hard of
[3:21:15]
hearing community including best practices for small
[3:21:19]
businesses in partnership with the office of small business
[3:21:22]
including some of our great capital efforts there are
[3:21:23]
moving forward. I would not be doing justice
[3:21:26]
this disability pride month if I did not talk about my friend
[3:21:31]
alice wong who has before you a year ago and who lives on
[3:21:34]
in our memory. And so in honor of alice I will
[3:21:38]
just read one of her greatest hits.
[3:21:41]
disabled people have always existed whether the word
[3:21:45]
disability is used or not. To me disability is not a
[3:21:49]
monolith nor is it a clear cut binary or disabled.
[3:21:56]
of disabled and non-disabled. Disability is mutable and ever
[3:22:01]
evolving. Disability is both apparent
[3:22:04]
and not apparent. Disability is pain.
[3:22:05]
struggle, brilliance, abundance and joy.
[3:22:09]
disability is socio political, cultural and biological.
[3:22:15]
being visible and claiming a disabled identity brings risks
[3:22:19]
as much as it brings pride. I am so proud of the work our
[3:22:23]
city is doing and continuing to do in the space of disability
[3:22:27]
rights and accessibility. Thank you for your leadership
[3:22:30]
and support. >> thank you for your comments.
[3:22:31]
next speaker president. Man woman.
[3:22:42]
board of supervisors my name is richard chastity peterson.
[3:22:49]
I want to talk briefly about artificial intelligence and I
[3:22:51]
think that was brought up briefly and I think katy, one
[3:22:56]
of the items 86 or something I've been involved
[3:23:00]
in artificial intelligence since the 1960s believe it or
[3:23:04]
not at tufts university city. >> I then went to college at
[3:23:12]
in boston with some of the greatest teachers and at least
[3:23:16]
in new england I came to san francisco and have continued
[3:23:23]
artificial intelligence work with both clients and some of
[3:23:27]
my own personal work. I've developed certain game
[3:23:32]
boards and things that actually assist in many of the concepts
[3:23:38]
of artificial intelligence. I want to warn against using
[3:23:43]
artificial intelligence as a automatic means to enforcement
[3:23:50]
of many of your governmental regulations.
[3:23:53]
and this goes not only to the city but to the state as my
[3:24:00]
trials with the state board state bar show that some tracks
[3:24:08]
when already set are put in motion by simple oversights
[3:24:13]
once they're in motion there is rarely anything that you can do
[3:24:18]
except under extraordinary circumstances.
[3:24:23]
the other thing is the algorithm is basically and if
[3:24:29]
then type of an algorithm all algorithms are it.
[3:24:34]
>> then when you get into generative development then you
[3:24:38]
get into real trouble because you are allowing other humans
[3:24:41]
to introduce the algorithms that change your mind.
[3:24:46]
>> thank you. Thank you for your comments.
[3:24:47]
>> next speaker
[3:25:23]
. >> okay.
[3:25:24]
good afternoon. I'm jessica persico.
[3:25:28]
my written comments focus on transparency, accountability
[3:25:31]
and accessibility. You can read them right here.
[3:25:35]
okay. I also want to thank
[3:25:43]
mayor lurie for attending today.
[3:25:44]
I hope you can attend this monday's health commission
[3:25:47]
meeting at 4 p.m. At room four await the september board
[3:25:51]
meetings and stay for public comments before signing budgets
[3:25:55]
and other matters most urgent. Daniel lauria I urge you if
[3:26:02]
you're watching to not sign one file number 251003 expanding
[3:26:08]
drug free housing in ways that may add cost risk evictions for
[3:26:15]
people in recovering and those with mental health conditions.
[3:26:18]
and worsen our existing housing and health care system because
[3:26:23]
we know that there's an accessibility crisis.
[3:26:26]
>> number two file number 250630 the clean up code that
[3:26:32]
removes reporting labeled obsolete and including that for
[3:26:40]
hunters point shipyard oversight.
[3:26:41]
>> residents rely on these to protect our environment and to
[3:26:48]
keep them protected. I also ask that this board
[3:26:52]
and anybody watching to work with me to get our federal
[3:26:57]
medicaid payments back by addressing fraud waste
[3:27:03]
and abuse. Contact me at gov dot this the
[3:27:07]
game.com. Please verify and adopt gov dot
[3:27:11]
dis gamescom as a public resource to anyone watching
[3:27:15]
this with the means. Please consider a bridge grant
[3:27:19]
for services affected by medicaid budget cuts such as ss
[3:27:24]
z s of age and ucsf. >> I also like to thank you for
[3:27:28]
your comments. Next speaker mr. President w o
[3:27:34]
duffy. I just recently added a new
[3:27:38]
supervisor district that I've lived in for about a month
[3:27:42]
and a half. I lived in chinatown now in a
[3:27:43]
private hotel and sro hotel private, unsubsidized and the
[3:27:50]
people there were living in very close quarters to each
[3:27:54]
other and I just couldn't I was just so impressed the security
[3:27:58]
and there was no problem with security in the building.
[3:28:00]
I'm just so impressed with my neighbors their tenacity for
[3:28:04]
life. This is a building, by the way
[3:28:05]
no elevator. It's a flight and a half up
[3:28:09]
from the street and then this floor above that is another
[3:28:13]
flight and a lot of seniors just lugging stuff up those
[3:28:16]
stairs every day and lugging it back down.
[3:28:17]
I just was very impressed by them.
[3:28:20]
I think it's a really good thing that someone here the
[3:28:24]
board is leaning towards realizing that yes, we need
[3:28:27]
more housing but we also have to protect, preserve and and
[3:28:31]
defend the quality of life that we have for the housing that we
[3:28:34]
already have. I'm very impressed by that
[3:28:36]
today. And you know, I changed my
[3:28:39]
speech that I'm going to make sometimes I change it five
[3:28:42]
times I'm sitting back there and I just like to thank you
[3:28:47]
all for your service and I know that you're going to be able to
[3:28:48]
play in the field of the lord and I.
[3:28:51]
I hope you are observing things and thinking and have a moment
[3:28:55]
to contemplate. >> thank you for your comments.
[3:28:58]
>> seeing no other individuals here in person we will be going
[3:29:02]
to our remote line if you have not already done so please
[3:29:04]
press star three to remote to line up remotely.
[3:29:07]
again personal attacks harassment or discriminatory
[3:29:10]
remarks directed to a city employee or board member are
[3:29:13]
outside the scope of this body and shall be redirected.
[3:29:15]
failure to immediately redirect those comments will result
[3:29:18]
in the individual's forfeiture of remaining time and we will
[3:29:22]
transition to the next speaker. Let's hear from our first
[3:29:25]
caller by a demand. The bulk of beach and I call
[3:29:33]
all the people of serbia I oppose upcoming heritage month
[3:29:37]
resolution because they are like kosovo and these goals
[3:29:44]
with all three be very bad saints go to america vote for
[3:29:52]
your loving your envy the victory moving from karate
[3:29:56]
and all will have more important report in the and and
[3:30:03]
all sorts of grocery store you got to you had to live grocery
[3:30:07]
store rock out board and things about time that you bought the
[3:30:12]
building but your no minutes bob that all right let's go to
[3:30:18]
our next caller. >> hello supervisors my name is
[3:30:29]
will hayworth, a resident of district nine and I'm calling
[3:30:30]
because I'm a complainant in a pending sunshine ordinance task
[3:30:34]
force complaint and the deadline for processing it
[3:30:40]
under the existing task force handling procedures was july
[3:30:44]
17th. The board can't meet right now
[3:30:47]
because nine of the task or seats are vacant and cannot
[3:30:48]
walk. We can be sure.
[3:30:51]
walton published statement explains how this happened
[3:30:52]
which is that the city attorney advised only on june 26th that
[3:30:55]
the task force was to look at the new rule.
[3:30:58]
no one designed this outcome. I got that.
[3:30:59]
but I want to note in response to the idea of expanding the
[3:31:02]
search for applicants which is a worthy goal of the existing
[3:31:05]
odd things for are filled by nominations from the society,
[3:31:10]
professional journalists and the league women voters
[3:31:11]
pennington departure in june for those four seats the pool
[3:31:14]
is fixed by ordinance outreach cannot change it.
[3:31:17]
acting on them right now would restore quorum and allow the
[3:31:21]
remaining five seats to be determined at the board's
[3:31:25]
pleasure in the future. The comments are from the
[3:31:27]
society professional very publicly that at least one
[3:31:30]
member of this board considers the sunshine ordinance
[3:31:33]
burdensome and prefer commissioners the more
[3:31:34]
pragmatic to use section 67 not 30 assigns those nominations to
[3:31:37]
outside organizations precisely so that the watchdog's
[3:31:41]
composition does not track any official appetite type of
[3:31:42]
oversight. On july 10th the ethics
[3:31:44]
commission returned a matter concerning the mayor's office
[3:31:46]
to a body that cannot begin to receive it.
[3:31:48]
I attributed to no one but every week this body save stark
[3:31:51]
makes that harder to explain. I ask that you please calendar
[3:31:54]
the full organization nominated reappointment to the sunshine
[3:31:56]
ordinance task force no later than the 1st september rules
[3:31:59]
committee meeting and sooner at a special meeting is convened.
[3:32:02]
>> thank you. Thank you for your comments.
[3:32:03]
next speaker good afternoon. My name is lynn rivas.
[3:32:12]
>> I'm dr. Lynn rivers. I'm the executive director for
[3:32:16]
the california association of mental health iran
[3:32:20]
organizations relying solely on emergency department personnel
[3:32:23]
while eliminating peer specialists would compromise
[3:32:28]
san francisco's crisis response efficiency.
[3:32:32]
it'll increase criminal justice involvement and unnecessarily
[3:32:36]
inflate health care costs based on the research, san francisco
[3:32:40]
should retain peer specialists and community mobile units for
[3:32:44]
the following key reasons one here live bill outreach
[3:32:47]
prevents hospitalization and manage its acute crisis
[3:32:50]
in its early two tiers improve the escalation and strengthen
[3:32:58]
crisis intervention. Three community mobile crisis
[3:33:01]
units directly reduce arrests and criminalization and for
[3:33:08]
relying solely on emergency department departments
[3:33:12]
increases costs and system strain.
[3:33:13]
thank you very much. >> thank you for your comments.
[3:33:17]
next caller. >> hi there.
[3:33:24]
>> I'm lynch north north beach resident.
[3:33:27]
san francisco sunshine ordinance begins with the
[3:33:29]
simple principle that government exists to conduct
[3:33:32]
the people's business and that the people don't give
[3:33:35]
government the right to decide what we should know.
[3:33:38]
>> today city hall seems to be saying why violate the sunshine
[3:33:42]
ordinance when you can simply eliminate the people who
[3:33:46]
enforce it? >> recently so-called
[3:33:47]
streamlining changes the changed the rules for
[3:33:49]
commission appointments streamlining what bureaucracy
[3:33:53]
or accountability. >> now nine of the 11 members
[3:33:57]
of the sunshine ordinance task force have been forced off the
[3:34:00]
commission because their re appointments have been left to
[3:34:02]
expire by you. >> and the timing couldn't be
[3:34:05]
more convenient. You remember that october phone
[3:34:09]
call between mayor lurie and then donald trump when the
[3:34:12]
public asked for public records of it?
[3:34:13]
>> the mayor's office refused. >> the sunshine task force
[3:34:16]
found that we that refusal violated our transparency laws
[3:34:20]
and their next step should have been to finish that case.
[3:34:24]
instead the task force itself disappeared.
[3:34:27]
>> that's quite the magic trick.
[3:34:28]
but it didn't go away because the public lost interest.
[3:34:31]
but because the referees had been escorted off the field.
[3:34:35]
>> and this isn't really about one phone call.
[3:34:36]
it's about whether oversight itself survives.
[3:34:39]
the sunshine task force is lying in a coma because of your
[3:34:43]
politics and that means it can be revived by your political
[3:34:47]
will. >> your constituents as always
[3:34:48]
are watching reappointing the voting members restore the task
[3:34:51]
force and prove that in san francisco sunshine isn't
[3:34:55]
something that politicians can quietly switch off like p, g
[3:34:59]
and e. >> remember when the washington
[3:35:00]
post had some political will back in 2017 and warned us that
[3:35:05]
democracy dies in darkness? >> well, between this and the
[3:35:09]
deplorable shade act I had to sit through last week your
[3:35:12]
constituents are watching and feeling mighty left out
[3:35:15]
in the cold these days. So please do the right thing by
[3:35:19]
the folks who elected by elected you and let the
[3:35:20]
sunshine back in. >> thank you for your comments.
[3:35:27]
I believe that ends are a remote call in line.
[3:35:29]
mr. President. >> all right.
[3:35:32]
public comment is now closed. Madam clerk, please call the
[3:35:36]
for adoption without committee reference agenda items 88
[3:35:39]
through 95 together items 88 through 95 were introduced for
[3:35:42]
adoption without committee reference a unanimous vote is
[3:35:45]
required for adoption of a resolution on first appearance
[3:35:48]
any supervisor may require resolution on first appearance
[3:35:51]
to go to committee. >> supervisor mahmood like to
[3:35:55]
sever item number 90. >> right.
[3:35:58]
uh supervisor dorsey I'd like to sever item 88 and 89
[3:36:07]
supervisor melgar 93 please. And I would like to sever 94
[3:36:19]
and so madam clerk, could you call the roll on the remaining
[3:36:21]
balance of the items? >> yes on items 9192 and 95.
[3:36:26]
>> supervisor wong wong absent supervisor chan chin I
[3:36:33]
supervisor chin chin I supervisor dorsey dorsey I
[3:36:40]
supervisor fielder fielder I supervisor mahmood mahmood I
[3:36:44]
supervisor randleman hi randleman I supervisor melgar
[3:36:48]
melgar I supervisor sadr sutter I supervisor cheryl cheryl I
[3:36:56]
there are nine eyes without objection the resolutions are
[3:36:59]
adopted and the motion is approved please call item 88
[3:37:04]
item number 88 is a resolution declaring the month of august
[3:37:10]
2026 is afghan-american heritage month in the city
[3:37:11]
and county of san francisco raza dorsey thank you president
[3:37:14]
madam and colleagues today I am proud to ask you to support
[3:37:19]
this resolution declaring august as afghan-american
[3:37:22]
heritage month for the city and county of san francisco.
[3:37:25]
san francisco has always been defined by those who came here
[3:37:28]
seeking opportunity, freedom and the chance to build a
[3:37:30]
better future. The african-america community
[3:37:33]
embodies that enduring spirit as we've heard in much of
[3:37:34]
today's meeting today african-americans,
[3:37:37]
african-americans helped shape every corner of san francisco
[3:37:41]
as physicians attorneys, educators, engineers,
[3:37:45]
entrepreneurs, artists, public servants and members of our
[3:37:49]
armed forces and community leaders.
[3:37:50]
this resolution is an opportunity to recognize not
[3:37:54]
only those remarkable achievements but also the
[3:37:57]
resilience, perseverance and generosity that define the
[3:38:01]
afghan american experience. It affirms that their story is
[3:38:02]
an essential part of san francisco's story.
[3:38:05]
I would also like to recognize someone from my own office who
[3:38:08]
has been instrumental in making this recognition possible.
[3:38:10]
my legislative aide muhammad somebody who worked tirelessly
[3:38:13]
to elevate african-american heritage month into one of the
[3:38:17]
city's signature cultural celebrations.
[3:38:20]
through her vision, leadership and unwavering dedication
[3:38:21]
and what has been a local celebration has grown into an
[3:38:25]
annual tradition that now brings together leaders from
[3:38:29]
across california to honor the extraordinary accomplishments
[3:38:32]
of the african-american community.
[3:38:33]
monis thank you for your leadership, your dedication to
[3:38:36]
public service and for ensuring that history, culture
[3:38:39]
and achievements of the african-american community are
[3:38:40]
recognized and celebrated in our city.
[3:38:44]
because of your work, san francisco has become a leader
[3:38:47]
in honoring afghan-american heritage month and our city is
[3:38:48]
stronger and richer for it. To the african-american
[3:38:52]
community, thank you for your resilience, your service, your
[3:38:55]
leadership and your countless contributions to the city
[3:38:58]
and county of san francisco. We're proud to celebrate your
[3:39:00]
achievements today and we look forward to continuing this
[3:39:03]
tradition for years to come. >> thank you, madam clerk.
[3:39:06]
is this the same house we have ?
[3:39:10]
yes. All right.
[3:39:11]
let's take this same house, same call without objection,
[3:39:13]
the resolution is adopted. >> please call item 89.
[3:39:17]
>> item 89 is a resolution recognizing august 21st 21st,
[3:39:21]
2026 as national and all prevention and awareness day to
[3:39:25]
honor the lives impacted by the overdose crisis support
[3:39:28]
families and communities affected by substance use
[3:39:32]
disorders. Recognize frontline responders
[3:39:33]
and service providers and reaffirm the city's
[3:39:37]
commitment to prevention, treatment and recovery.
[3:39:40]
>> and public safety supervisor dorsey thank you president
[3:39:43]
and one colleagues. This resolution recognizes
[3:39:44]
august 21st as fentanyl prevention and awareness day
[3:39:48]
in san francisco. This resolution is about
[3:39:51]
remembrance, awareness and action because the numbers
[3:39:54]
behind the crisis remain staggering.
[3:39:55]
fentanyl is as much as 50 times more potent than heroin and a
[3:39:59]
dose of as little as two milligrams is fatal for most
[3:40:03]
most people. According to the cdc, more than
[3:40:06]
70% of accidental overdose deaths nationwide in 2024
[3:40:09]
involved fentanyl. >> here in san francisco, more
[3:40:13]
than the more than 3000 people we've lost to fentanyl related
[3:40:17]
overdoses since 2020 has made this the deadliest public
[3:40:20]
health emergency in our city since the darkest days of the
[3:40:23]
aids crisis. In august we will remember
[3:40:27]
those lost stand with grieving families and recommit ourselves
[3:40:30]
to prevention, treatment and long term recovery as well.
[3:40:31]
we must recognize and honor the health care workers and first
[3:40:35]
responders, peer counselors and community organizations
[3:40:38]
doing lifesaving work in this realm every day.
[3:40:41]
I want to recognize my legislative intern eva
[3:40:42]
seligmann, who we heard from earlier who her research
[3:40:46]
and drafting made this resolution possible.
[3:40:49]
eva, thank you for your hard work and commitment to public
[3:40:50]
service. Finally, colleagues, I would
[3:40:53]
invite you and all members of the public to attend the fifth
[3:40:56]
annual international overdose awareness sunset vigil.
[3:41:00]
a light for every life on sunday august 30th at 7 p.m. On
[3:41:03]
the steps of city hall. There we will honor the lives
[3:41:07]
of those lost and stand with families and individuals
[3:41:08]
in recovery whose voices remain at the center of this work.
[3:41:12]
thank you to gina mcdonald and the other moms who have
[3:41:15]
held this vigil for the past five years and for their
[3:41:17]
continued fight for recovery. >> madam clerk, please call the
[3:41:22]
roll on this item on item 89. Supervisor wong wang I
[3:41:25]
supervisor chan chen I supervisor chen chen I
[3:41:32]
supervisor dorsey dorsey I supervisor fielder filter I
[3:41:36]
supervisor mahmud mahmud I supervise our management I
[3:41:41]
mandolin I supervisor melgar melgar I supervisor sada sadr I
[3:41:45]
supervisors cheryl cheryl either tonight without
[3:41:49]
objection the resolution is adopted please call item 90.
[3:41:55]
item 90 is a resolution declaring july 18th through
[3:42:01]
august 17th 2026 a south asian american heritage month in the
[3:42:03]
city and county of san francisco and affirming the
[3:42:06]
cultural, religious and linguistic richness within
[3:42:09]
the south asian community and recognizing this pluralism
[3:42:13]
as a source a source of strength that contributes to
[3:42:17]
san francisco's identity as an open, inclusive and forward
[3:42:18]
looking city. >> supervisor mahmood thank you
[3:42:21]
colleagues and thank you to everyone joining us today
[3:42:25]
in the audience as we recognize july 18th through august 17th
[3:42:28]
2026 a south asian american heritage month in the city
[3:42:33]
and county of san francisco deeply honored to have had the
[3:42:36]
opportunity to introduce this resolution recognizing the many
[3:42:39]
contributions of south asian american communities that have
[3:42:41]
helped shape san francisco into diverse, dynamic and inclusive
[3:42:44]
city that we are today as someone of pakistani heritage,
[3:42:48]
this recognition carries personal meaning and it's a
[3:42:52]
reminder that our city is strongest when every
[3:42:53]
community's history, culture and contributions are seen
[3:42:56]
valued and celebrated. South asian identity
[3:42:59]
encompasses a vast and diverse group of communities including
[3:43:03]
afghanistan, bangladesh, bhutan, india, maldives, nepal,
[3:43:07]
pakistan and sri lanka. Within that diversity are
[3:43:11]
countless languages faiths, cultures and traditions
[3:43:14]
and lived experiences that enrich our city.
[3:43:16]
>> south asians have been a part of san francisco's story
[3:43:20]
for generations from entrepreneurs and small
[3:43:22]
business owners to health care workers, educators, engineers,
[3:43:24]
artists and public servants. South asian americans have
[3:43:28]
contributed to nearly every aspect of civic life in our
[3:43:31]
city. This month is an opportunity to
[3:43:34]
recognize the resilience of this community our history
[3:43:37]
in this country includes moments of exclusion,
[3:43:39]
discrimination and injustice from restrictive immigration
[3:43:43]
laws to the rise of islamophobia.
[3:43:44]
anti-sikh discrimination, discrimination, anti-hindu
[3:43:47]
discrimination and xenophobia that have impacted communities
[3:43:51]
across south asia's many identities.
[3:43:55]
but our history is also one of perseverance, solidarity and an
[3:43:56]
organizing south asian communities have stood
[3:44:00]
alongside other communities fighting for immigrant rights,
[3:44:03]
workers rights, gender equity, lgbt high plus inclusion,
[3:44:07]
racial justice and a more equitable future for all.
[3:44:10]
this recognition is particularly meaningful because
[3:44:14]
the dates of south asian american heritage month
[3:44:15]
coincide with several significant moments in south
[3:44:18]
asian history including independence days and other
[3:44:19]
milestones that represent both the complexity of our shared
[3:44:23]
histories and the enduring ties of south asian communities
[3:44:26]
around the world. For many south asian families
[3:44:30]
these histories are deeply personal and they represent
[3:44:31]
stories of migration, sacrifice and resilience but also
[3:44:34]
opportunity a story that many san franciscans I know share as
[3:44:39]
they seek a better life for themselves and their families.
[3:44:43]
san francisco has always been a city shaped by immigrants
[3:44:46]
and by communities who bring their experiences, cultures
[3:44:49]
and hopes for the future. Recognizing south asian
[3:44:51]
american heritage month is a reflection of our city's values
[3:44:54]
that inclusion is not just about welcoming people into our
[3:44:57]
communities but honoring their contributions.
[3:45:00]
I want to thank the members of the south asian community
[3:45:02]
advocates, cultural organizations, small business
[3:45:05]
owners and residents who continue to strengthen our city
[3:45:06]
every day. Today we celebrate the richness
[3:45:09]
of the south asian community in san francisco and reaffirm
[3:45:13]
our commitment to building a city where every person
[3:45:14]
regardless of where they come from, what language they speak
[3:45:17]
or traditions they carry knows that they belong.
[3:45:21]
I respectfully ask your colleagues for your support on
[3:45:22]
this resolution. >> supervisor dorsey thank you
[3:45:25]
president randleman. Thank you supervisor mahmood
[3:45:29]
for introducing this resolution to celebrate the country
[3:45:32]
and contributions of the south asian community to our city.
[3:45:35]
know one of my favorite things about serving people in a city
[3:45:39]
as diverse as ours is that we are all strongly encouraged to
[3:45:43]
crash the party for one another's cultural
[3:45:44]
celebrations. And that includes one of my
[3:45:47]
absolute favorites holi the festival of colors which we
[3:45:50]
hosted in my district at the east cut crossing a couple of
[3:45:51]
years ago with brightly colored chalk powder.
[3:45:55]
I still can't get out of much of the clothing that I wore
[3:45:58]
that day and we celebrated earlier this year that the
[3:46:00]
sales force tower projection last year to honor south asian
[3:46:05]
heritage month I recognized sima sri, a constituent of mine
[3:46:10]
who was just an incredible civic and cultural leader
[3:46:13]
in the south asian community. I wanted to take the
[3:46:14]
opportunity to express my appreciation again for all the
[3:46:18]
work that she has done to uplift and celebrate the
[3:46:21]
community. She has helped activate public
[3:46:22]
spaces for cultural celebrations and supported
[3:46:25]
south asian artists and entrepreneurs and used her
[3:46:29]
talents to build connections, equity and visibility.
[3:46:32]
she unfortunately could not be here today to give public
[3:46:33]
comment as much as I know she wanted to but I did want to
[3:46:37]
give her credit and to her and people like her for
[3:46:41]
dedicating themselves so generously to sharing their
[3:46:43]
culture and celebrating our diversity.
[3:46:44]
so thank you, sima and thank you supervisor bhagwan all
[3:46:50]
right. I think we can take that.
[3:46:51]
yeah, I think we can take the same house same call without
[3:46:55]
objection the resolution is adopted.
[3:46:57]
>> please call item 93. Item 93 the resolution
[3:47:04]
recognizing july 2026 as disability pride month in the
[3:47:05]
city and county of san francisco.
[3:47:08]
>> supervisor melgar thank you president colleagues july is
[3:47:12]
disability pride month and I wanted to make sure to
[3:47:13]
acknowledge some of the accomplishments that our city
[3:47:16]
is leading on in light of the egregious setbacks by this
[3:47:20]
federal administration. >> I want to make a special
[3:47:24]
shout shout out to eli gallatin from the office of disability
[3:47:27]
and accessibility and their team this july today and is
[3:47:31]
working closely with the mayor's office, city
[3:47:35]
departments, community partners a welcomed in the support of
[3:47:39]
the national association of the deaf biennial conference
[3:47:43]
in preparation for thousands of deaf attendees we strengthen
[3:47:47]
language access throughout the city, expanded asl availability
[3:47:51]
at city at city events and coordinated with
[3:47:55]
departments to improve communication access in public
[3:47:56]
facing services. They also hosted the california
[3:48:00]
commission on disability access for a regional meeting at this
[3:48:04]
disability cultural center. Odeh worked closely with the
[3:48:08]
office of small business on the beyond the front door
[3:48:11]
initiative which helps businesses improve physical
[3:48:15]
accessibility for residents and visitors during mayor loury
[3:48:18]
and first lady proud us one city day the agency created a
[3:48:22]
fully accessible event that honored the legacy of the 1977
[3:48:28]
section five before sit ins protesters dennis billups
[3:48:33]
and debbie kaplan along with disability cultural center
[3:48:34]
co-director emily bates shared reflections that meaningfully
[3:48:38]
connected the history of the disability rights movement with
[3:48:42]
a work underway today in partnership with the
[3:48:46]
economic support and self-sufficiency s.f. Mta
[3:48:49]
and the disability cultural center they held a five for
[3:48:53]
walking rolling tour staff resource tables provided onsite
[3:48:57]
cal fresh and medical support and showcase sfa j's mobile
[3:49:01]
benefits center demonstrating the cross apartment cross
[3:49:05]
apartment collaboration looks like an action we celebrated
[3:49:08]
the one year anniversary anniversary of the disability
[3:49:12]
cultural centers accessible community center space
[3:49:16]
and heard directly from residents about its growing
[3:49:19]
impact. >> together these
[3:49:20]
accomplishments reflect san francisco's commitment to going
[3:49:24]
beyond ada requirements to explore ending access to
[3:49:29]
services and ensuring people with disabilities can fully
[3:49:32]
participate in the civic life of our city as we recognize
[3:49:36]
july 2026 as disability pride month we reaffirm our
[3:49:40]
commitment to accessibility equity in continuing the
[3:49:45]
collaborative work our combined teams have advanced over the
[3:49:46]
past year. It is my hope that as we
[3:49:49]
approach next year's milestone that we will also take this
[3:49:52]
opportunity to expand our support for people with
[3:49:56]
disabilities further elevate visibility of our heroes like
[3:49:59]
judi human and alex wong. Wouldn't it be incredible if we
[3:50:03]
finally saw a statue of judy human to mark the location
[3:50:09]
in u.n. Plaza where the five live four sit ins took place
[3:50:10]
with happiness ability pride month.
[3:50:17]
>> thank you supervisor mugar let's take this item same
[3:50:20]
house, same call without objection the resolutions
[3:50:21]
adopted and madam clerk please call item 94.
[3:50:25]
>> item 94 is a motion authorized in preparation of
[3:50:28]
written proponent and opponent valid arguments and rebuttal
[3:50:32]
valid arguments for submittal to the voters for the november
[3:50:35]
3rd, 2026 consolidated general election.
[3:50:39]
>> all right and I believe that you have some proposed
[3:50:42]
amendments to this resolution for us that have been
[3:50:46]
circulated. >> yes, they have been
[3:50:47]
circulated. The amendments to the motion
[3:50:49]
being proposed is to designate supervisor chin to write the
[3:50:53]
proponent argument for the charter amendment on municipal
[3:50:55]
finance corporation and public bank designate supervisor
[3:50:58]
amendment to write the proponent argument for the
[3:51:02]
charter amendment on department board commission and advisory
[3:51:05]
body updates designate supervisor melgar to write the
[3:51:09]
proponent argument for the charter amendment on the
[3:51:11]
housing trust fund designate supervisor mahmood to write the
[3:51:13]
proponent argument for the initiative ordinance on real
[3:51:17]
estate real property transfer tax foreclosure exemption
[3:51:21]
designate supervisor walton to write the opponent argument for
[3:51:25]
the charter amendment on extending city administrator
[3:51:28]
duties and changes to city contracting designate
[3:51:29]
supervisor walton to also write the proponent opponent argument
[3:51:33]
for the charter amendment on changes to executive branch
[3:51:37]
management and designate supervisor walton to also write
[3:51:41]
the opponent argument for the charter amendment on changes to
[3:51:44]
ballot measure process and designate supervisor melgar
[3:51:48]
to write the opponent argument for the initiative ordinance on
[3:51:51]
allowing private vehicles on the great highway in the sunset
[3:51:53]
dunes the remainder of the opponent argument section will
[3:51:59]
be stricken for all of the ones that the supervisors had no
[3:52:03]
interest in writing and making other clarifying and conforming
[3:52:07]
changes. >> all right.
[3:52:08]
can I have a motion to make the amendments that have been
[3:52:11]
described by the clerk moved by chen seconded by mahmud?
[3:52:17]
>> can we take that without objection?
[3:52:18]
without objection. The motion is approved and then
[3:52:21]
can we take the amended item? Same house, same call without
[3:52:26]
objection the motion a motion motion no motion is approved.
[3:52:37]
all right, madam clerk, do we have any imperative agenda
[3:52:44]
items? >> we have no imperative agenda
[3:52:47]
items and you please read the in memoriam.
[3:52:48]
>> yes. Today's meeting will be
[3:52:52]
adjourned in memory of the following beloved individuals
[3:52:56]
on behalf of president mandolin for the late mr. Gerald allen
[3:53:00]
fuller and on behalf of supervisors mandolin and melgar
[3:53:04]
for the late miss sidner ella ellen constant and on behalf of
[3:53:08]
president mandolin for the late mr. Jeremiah halsey and on
[3:53:16]
behalf of supervisor melgar for the late dr. Estella garcia.
[3:53:20]
and I think that brings us to the end of our agenda, madam
[3:53:21]
clerk, do we have any further business before us today?
[3:53:25]
that concludes our business for today.
[3:53:26]
thank you. >> we are adjourned