[1:50] Evening, everyone, and welcome

[1:50] evening, everyone, and welcome

[1:50] evening, everyone, and welcome To the january 20th meeting

[1:52] evening, everyone, and welcome To the january 20th meeting

[1:53] evening, everyone, and welcome To the january 20th meeting Of the ann arbor city council.

[1:53] to the january 20th meeting Of the ann arbor city council.

[1:53] to the january 20th meeting Of the ann arbor city council. If you're able please rise and

[1:54] of the ann arbor city council. If you're able please rise and

[1:54] of the ann arbor city council. If you're able please rise and Join us for a moment of silence

[1:57] if you're able please rise and Join us for a moment of silence

[1:57] if you're able please rise and Join us for a moment of silence Followed by the pledge

[1:58] join us for a moment of silence Followed by the pledge

[1:58] join us for a moment of silence Followed by the pledge Of allegiance

[2:11] to the united

[2:12] to the united

[2:12] to the united States of america and to the

[2:15] to the united States of america and to the

[2:15] to the united States of america and to the Republic for which it stands

[2:16] states of america and to the Republic for which it stands

[2:16] states of america and to the Republic for which it stands One nation indivisible with

[2:19] republic for which it stands One nation indivisible with

[2:19] republic for which it stands One nation indivisible with Liberty and justice for but our

[2:23] one nation indivisible with Liberty and justice for but our

[2:23] one nation indivisible with Liberty and justice for but our Clark please call the role

[2:26] liberty and justice for but our Clark please call the role

[2:26] liberty and justice for but our Clark please call the role Of council council member desh

[2:32] clark please call the role Of council council member desh

[2:33] clark please call the role Of council council member desh Here councilor harrison apsa

[2:36] of council council member desh Here councilor harrison apsa

[2:37] of council council member desh Here councilor harrison apsa Councilor watson councilor I'm

[2:41] here councilor harrison apsa Councilor watson councilor I'm

[2:41] here councilor harrison apsa Councilor watson councilor I'm Out here customer denha here

[2:42] councilor watson councilor I'm Out here customer denha here

[2:42] councilor watson councilor I'm Out here customer denha here Comes 01 here mayor taylor here

[2:45] out here customer denha here Comes 01 here mayor taylor here

[2:45] out here customer denha here Comes 01 here mayor taylor here Customer igher here strachman

[2:49] comes 01 here mayor taylor here Customer igher here strachman

[2:49] comes 01 here mayor taylor here Customer igher here strachman Here comes our brigg's here

[2:52] customer igher here strachman Here comes our brigg's here

[2:52] customer igher here strachman Here comes our brigg's here Councilor cornell apsa.

[2:52] here comes our brigg's here Councilor cornell apsa.

[2:52] here comes our brigg's here Councilor cornell apsa. >> we have a quorum if a motion

[2:55] councilor cornell apsa. >> we have a quorum if a motion

[2:56] councilor cornell apsa. >> we have a quorum if a motion Please to approve the agenda

[2:56] » we have a quorum if a motion Please to approve the agenda

[2:57] » we have a quorum if a motion Please to approve the agenda Move by councilor asking about

[2:57] please to approve the agenda Move by councilor asking about

[2:57] please to approve the agenda Move by councilor asking about Council member brigs discussion

[3:00] move by councilor asking about Council member brigs discussion

[3:00] move by councilor asking about Council member brigs discussion Of the agenda perhaps can have

[3:00] council member brigs discussion Of the agenda perhaps can have

[3:01] council member brigs discussion Of the agenda perhaps can have A motion please to move dc for

[3:04] of the agenda perhaps can have A motion please to move dc for

[3:04] of the agenda perhaps can have A motion please to move dc for Resolution to finalize the

[3:05] a motion please to move dc for Resolution to finalize the

[3:05] a motion please to move dc for Resolution to finalize the Evaluation report and then the

[3:08] resolution to finalize the Evaluation report and then the

[3:08] resolution to finalize the Evaluation report and then the Employment agreement for city

[3:09] evaluation report and then the Employment agreement for city

[3:09] evaluation report and then the Employment agreement for city Minister milton tony jr. Two

[3:09] employment agreement for city Minister milton tony jr. Two

[3:10] employment agreement for city Minister milton tony jr. Two After our closed session with

[3:12] minister milton tony jr. Two After our closed session with

[3:12] minister milton tony jr. Two After our closed session with Respect to move by council

[3:15] after our closed session with Respect to move by council

[3:15] after our closed session with Respect to move by council Member dish second by councilor

[3:19] respect to move by council Member dish second by councilor

[3:19] respect to move by council Member dish second by councilor Watson discussion of that

[3:19] member dish second by councilor Watson discussion of that

[3:19] member dish second by councilor Watson discussion of that Amendment one favor or opposed

[3:23] watson discussion of that Amendment one favor or opposed

[3:23] watson discussion of that Amendment one favor or opposed Is approved for the discussion

[3:24] amendment one favor or opposed Is approved for the discussion

[3:24] amendment one favor or opposed Is approved for the discussion Of the agenda as amended in

[3:27] is approved for the discussion Of the agenda as amended in

[3:27] is approved for the discussion Of the agenda as amended in Favor or posed.

[3:31] of the agenda as amended in Favor or posed.

[3:31] of the agenda as amended in Favor or posed. The agenda is approved to have

[3:32] favor or posed. The agenda is approved to have

[3:32] favor or posed. The agenda is approved to have Communications today from our

[3:34] the agenda is approved to have Communications today from our

[3:34] the agenda is approved to have Communications today from our City administrator know mayor I

[3:38] communications today from our City administrator know mayor I

[3:38] communications today from our City administrator know mayor I Thought you are coming in with

[3:39] city administrator know mayor I Thought you are coming in with

[3:39] city administrator know mayor I Thought you are coming in with A soundtrack for us.

[3:42] thought you are coming in with A soundtrack for us.

[3:42] thought you are coming in with A soundtrack for us. >> we believe we have the

[3:43] a soundtrack for us. >> we believe we have the

[3:43] a soundtrack for us. >> we believe we have the Pleasure of an introduction

[3:45] » we believe we have the Pleasure of an introduction

[3:45] » we believe we have the Pleasure of an introduction Today from the downtown

[3:46] pleasure of an introduction Today from the downtown

[3:46] pleasure of an introduction Today from the downtown Development authority dr mark

[3:49] today from the downtown Development authority dr mark

[3:49] today from the downtown Development authority dr mark Thompson.

[3:49] development authority dr mark Thompson.

[3:50] development authority dr mark Thompson. >> mark thompson, you have the

[3:50] thompson. >> mark thompson, you have the

[3:51] thompson. >> mark thompson, you have the Come the so is developing into

[4:00] » mark thompson, you have the Come the so is developing into

[4:00] » mark thompson, you have the Come the so is developing into Plan.

[4:00] come the so is developing into Plan.

[4:01] come the so is developing into Plan. We actually have our public

[4:01] plan. We actually have our public

[4:01] plan. We actually have our public Hearing your next council

[4:04] we actually have our public Hearing your next council

[4:04] we actually have our public Hearing your next council Meeting february 2nd.

[4:05] hearing your next council Meeting february 2nd.

[4:05] hearing your next council Meeting february 2nd. So I wanted to use tonight as

[4:08] meeting february 2nd. So I wanted to use tonight as

[4:08] meeting february 2nd. So I wanted to use tonight as An opportunity to sort of go

[4:09] so I wanted to use tonight as An opportunity to sort of go

[4:09] so I wanted to use tonight as An opportunity to sort of go Through some of the highlights

[4:12] an opportunity to sort of go Through some of the highlights

[4:12] an opportunity to sort of go Through some of the highlights Of the plan.

[4:12] through some of the highlights Of the plan.

[4:12] through some of the highlights Of the plan. You've seen most of this before

[4:13] of the plan. You've seen most of this before

[4:13] of the plan. You've seen most of this before But I thought it was worth

[4:16] you've seen most of this before But I thought it was worth

[4:16] you've seen most of this before But I thought it was worth Bringing to your attention

[4:16] but I thought it was worth Bringing to your attention

[4:17] but I thought it was worth Bringing to your attention Again tonight.

[4:17] bringing to your attention Again tonight.

[4:17] bringing to your attention Again tonight. So plenary acquirement delays

[4:20] again tonight. So plenary acquirement delays

[4:20] again tonight. So plenary acquirement delays Are required by state statute

[4:24] so plenary acquirement delays Are required by state statute

[4:24] so plenary acquirement delays Are required by state statute To have a plan.

[4:25] are required by state statute To have a plan.

[4:25] are required by state statute To have a plan. These plans are very prescribed

[4:28] to have a plan. These plans are very prescribed

[4:28] to have a plan. These plans are very prescribed And as we talk about the dda

[4:29] these plans are very prescribed And as we talk about the dda

[4:29] these plans are very prescribed And as we talk about the dda Plan where actually referring

[4:32] and as we talk about the dda Plan where actually referring

[4:32] and as we talk about the dda Plan where actually referring To two separate plans so there

[4:33] plan where actually referring To two separate plans so there

[4:33] plan where actually referring To two separate plans so there Is the development plan which

[4:36] to two separate plans so there Is the development plan which

[4:36] to two separate plans so there Is the development plan which Establishes the boundary and

[4:39] is the development plan which Establishes the boundary and

[4:39] is the development plan which Establishes the boundary and Its activities, projects and

[4:40] establishes the boundary and Its activities, projects and

[4:40] establishes the boundary and Its activities, projects and Programs and then there is the

[4:43] its activities, projects and Programs and then there is the

[4:43] its activities, projects and Programs and then there is the Tax increment finance plan

[4:44] programs and then there is the Tax increment finance plan

[4:44] programs and then there is the Tax increment finance plan Which estimates are tif revenue

[4:47] tax increment finance plan Which estimates are tif revenue

[4:47] tax increment finance plan Which estimates are tif revenue And talks about how we will use

[4:48] which estimates are tif revenue And talks about how we will use

[4:48] which estimates are tif revenue And talks about how we will use That revenue.

[4:51] and talks about how we will use That revenue.

[4:51] and talks about how we will use That revenue. >> so to start with the

[4:52] that revenue. >> so to start with the

[4:52] that revenue. >> so to start with the Development plan again the

[4:53] » so to start with the Development plan again the

[4:53] » so to start with the Development plan again the Development plan establishes

[4:55] development plan again the Development plan establishes

[4:55] development plan again the Development plan establishes Boundaries and activities and

[4:56] development plan establishes Boundaries and activities and

[4:56] development plan establishes Boundaries and activities and Really acts as kind of the da's

[4:59] boundaries and activities and Really acts as kind of the da's

[4:59] boundaries and activities and Really acts as kind of the da's Planning roadmap for the next

[5:02] really acts as kind of the da's Planning roadmap for the next

[5:02] really acts as kind of the da's Planning roadmap for the next Thirty years.

[5:03] planning roadmap for the next Thirty years.

[5:03] planning roadmap for the next Thirty years. One of the big changes that you

[5:07] thirty years. One of the big changes that you

[5:07] thirty years. One of the big changes that you Are going to see in our

[5:07] one of the big changes that you Are going to see in our

[5:08] one of the big changes that you Are going to see in our Proposed plan is a change to

[5:11] are going to see in our Proposed plan is a change to

[5:11] are going to see in our Proposed plan is a change to The dda boundary.

[5:11] proposed plan is a change to The dda boundary.

[5:11] proposed plan is a change to The dda boundary. So this is a current boundary.

[5:15] the dda boundary. So this is a current boundary.

[5:15] the dda boundary. So this is a current boundary. It is sixty seven blocks of our

[5:17] so this is a current boundary. It is sixty seven blocks of our

[5:17] so this is a current boundary. It is sixty seven blocks of our Downtown.

[5:17] it is sixty seven blocks of our Downtown.

[5:18] it is sixty seven blocks of our Downtown. We are only able to make

[5:19] downtown. We are only able to make

[5:19] downtown. We are only able to make Investments within those sixty

[5:22] we are only able to make Investments within those sixty

[5:22] we are only able to make Investments within those sixty Seven blocks.

[5:25] investments within those sixty Seven blocks.

[5:25] investments within those sixty Seven blocks. This boundary has never changed

[5:26] seven blocks. This boundary has never changed

[5:26] seven blocks. This boundary has never changed Since the day was established

[5:29] this boundary has never changed Since the day was established

[5:29] this boundary has never changed Since the day was established About forty four years ago.

[5:32] since the day was established About forty four years ago.

[5:32] since the day was established About forty four years ago. >> so we are recommending a

[5:33] about forty four years ago. >> so we are recommending a

[5:33] about forty four years ago. >> so we are recommending a Boundary expansion to the

[5:37] » so we are recommending a Boundary expansion to the

[5:37] » so we are recommending a Boundary expansion to the North.

[5:37] boundary expansion to the North.

[5:38] boundary expansion to the North. It includes nineteen blocks

[5:38] north. It includes nineteen blocks

[5:38] north. It includes nineteen blocks North of our original district.

[5:41] it includes nineteen blocks North of our original district.

[5:41] it includes nineteen blocks North of our original district. You may recall we had a work

[5:43] north of our original district. You may recall we had a work

[5:43] north of our original district. You may recall we had a work Session last april and at that

[5:46] you may recall we had a work Session last april and at that

[5:46] you may recall we had a work Session last april and at that Work session we were

[5:49] session last april and at that Work session we were

[5:49] session last april and at that Work session we were Recommending an expansion to

[5:50] work session we were Recommending an expansion to

[5:50] work session we were Recommending an expansion to Both the north and the south

[5:53] recommending an expansion to Both the north and the south

[5:53] recommending an expansion to Both the north and the south Since that time with after many

[5:54] both the north and the south Since that time with after many

[5:54] both the north and the south Since that time with after many Discussions with city

[5:57] since that time with after many Discussions with city

[5:58] since that time with after many Discussions with city Administration we refined that

[5:58] discussions with city Administration we refined that

[5:58] discussions with city Administration we refined that Recommendation to those

[6:01] administration we refined that Recommendation to those

[6:01] administration we refined that Recommendation to those Nineteen blocks you see to the

[6:02] recommendation to those Nineteen blocks you see to the

[6:02] recommendation to those Nineteen blocks you see to the North and that refinement was

[6:06] nineteen blocks you see to the North and that refinement was

[6:06] nineteen blocks you see to the North and that refinement was Based on need and really trying

[6:26] to maximize the potential for

[6:27] to maximize the potential for

[6:27] to maximize the potential for The denha to invest in

[6:28] to maximize the potential for The denha to invest in

[6:28] to maximize the potential for The denha to invest in Projects.

[6:28] the denha to invest in Projects.

[6:28] the denha to invest in Projects. So in this expansion area we

[6:29] projects. So in this expansion area we

[6:29] projects. So in this expansion area we Have about thirty eight

[6:30] so in this expansion area we Have about thirty eight

[6:30] so in this expansion area we Have about thirty eight Projects that are in those nine

[6:30] have about thirty eight Projects that are in those nine

[6:30] have about thirty eight Projects that are in those nine Within those nineteen blocks

[6:31] projects that are in those nine Within those nineteen blocks

[6:31] projects that are in those nine Within those nineteen blocks That the dda would not be able

[6:32] within those nineteen blocks That the dda would not be able

[6:32] within those nineteen blocks That the dda would not be able To invest and without this

[6:32] that the dda would not be able To invest and without this

[6:33] that the dda would not be able To invest and without this Expansion and I think it's

[6:33] to invest and without this Expansion and I think it's

[6:33] to invest and without this Expansion and I think it's Important to note that on the

[6:34] expansion and I think it's Important to note that on the

[6:34] expansion and I think it's Important to note that on the Revenue side this is not a big

[6:35] important to note that on the Revenue side this is not a big

[6:35] important to note that on the Revenue side this is not a big Impact for the dda in the short

[6:36] revenue side this is not a big Impact for the dda in the short

[6:36] revenue side this is not a big Impact for the dda in the short Term.

[6:36] impact for the dda in the short Term.

[6:36] impact for the dda in the short Term. So the first ten years of the

[6:37] term. So the first ten years of the

[6:37] term. So the first ten years of the Plan it's estimated to have

[6:41] so the first ten years of the Plan it's estimated to have

[6:41] so the first ten years of the Plan it's estimated to have About a two percent increase to

[6:42] plan it's estimated to have About a two percent increase to

[6:42] plan it's estimated to have About a two percent increase to The budget that first year.

[6:44] about a two percent increase to The budget that first year.

[6:44] about a two percent increase to The budget that first year. It's a half a percent.

[6:47] the budget that first year. It's a half a percent.

[6:48] the budget that first year. It's a half a percent. So it really this isn't about

[6:48] it's a half a percent. So it really this isn't about

[6:49] it's a half a percent. So it really this isn't about The revenue.

[6:49] so it really this isn't about The revenue.

[6:49] so it really this isn't about The revenue. This is about where is the need

[6:52] the revenue. This is about where is the need

[6:52] the revenue. This is about where is the need And where the dda can invest.

[6:56] this is about where is the need And where the dda can invest.

[6:56] this is about where is the need And where the dda can invest. >> so in the expansion area you

[7:00] and where the dda can invest. >> so in the expansion area you

[7:00] and where the dda can invest. >> so in the expansion area you Can see on the left of the

[7:01] » so in the expansion area you Can see on the left of the

[7:01] » so in the expansion area you Can see on the left of the Screen that's just showing need

[7:04] can see on the left of the Screen that's just showing need

[7:04] can see on the left of the Screen that's just showing need Over the next 30 years in

[7:05] screen that's just showing need Over the next 30 years in

[7:05] screen that's just showing need Over the next 30 years in Various categories.

[7:08] over the next 30 years in Various categories.

[7:08] over the next 30 years in Various categories. These are categories that could

[7:09] various categories. These are categories that could

[7:09] various categories. These are categories that could Contribute to on the right side

[7:12] these are categories that could Contribute to on the right side

[7:12] these are categories that could Contribute to on the right side Of the slide.

[7:16] contribute to on the right side Of the slide.

[7:16] contribute to on the right side Of the slide. Those are near term really

[7:16] of the slide. Those are near term really

[7:17] of the slide. Those are near term really Projects and when when I say

[7:19] those are near term really Projects and when when I say

[7:19] those are near term really Projects and when when I say Near term that's phase one

[7:20] projects and when when I say Near term that's phase one

[7:20] projects and when when I say Near term that's phase one Of our plan which is the first

[7:23] near term that's phase one Of our plan which is the first

[7:24] near term that's phase one Of our plan which is the first Ten years and some of the

[7:24] of our plan which is the first Ten years and some of the

[7:24] of our plan which is the first Ten years and some of the Projects that were prioritized

[7:27] ten years and some of the Projects that were prioritized

[7:28] ten years and some of the Projects that were prioritized The first 10 years include

[7:28] projects that were prioritized The first 10 years include

[7:28] projects that were prioritized The first 10 years include North main street improvements

[7:31] the first 10 years include North main street improvements

[7:31] the first 10 years include North main street improvements Seven twenty one north main

[7:31] north main street improvements Seven twenty one north main

[7:32] north main street improvements Seven twenty one north main Remediation and landscape and

[7:35] seven twenty one north main Remediation and landscape and

[7:35] seven twenty one north main Remediation and landscape and Then I'll just highlight

[7:35] remediation and landscape and Then I'll just highlight

[7:35] remediation and landscape and Then I'll just highlight Emphasizing investment on

[7:39] then I'll just highlight Emphasizing investment on

[7:39] then I'll just highlight Emphasizing investment on Projects that help make that

[7:39] emphasizing investment on Projects that help make that

[7:40] emphasizing investment on Projects that help make that Connection to the river.

[7:43] projects that help make that Connection to the river.

[7:43] projects that help make that Connection to the river. We talk about connecting our

[7:44] connection to the river. We talk about connecting our

[7:44] connection to the river. We talk about connecting our Downtown to the river and how

[7:44] we talk about connecting our Downtown to the river and how

[7:45] we talk about connecting our Downtown to the river and how Important that is and we have

[7:47] downtown to the river and how Important that is and we have

[7:47] downtown to the river and how Important that is and we have Investment dollars for projects

[7:50] important that is and we have Investment dollars for projects

[7:50] important that is and we have Investment dollars for projects Like that.

[7:50] investment dollars for projects Like that.

[7:51] investment dollars for projects Like that. So on the projects and programs

[7:54] like that. So on the projects and programs

[7:54] like that. So on the projects and programs Through multiple planning

[7:54] so on the projects and programs Through multiple planning

[7:55] so on the projects and programs Through multiple planning Efforts we identify one hundred

[7:59] through multiple planning Efforts we identify one hundred

[7:59] through multiple planning Efforts we identify one hundred And fifty projects those

[8:00] efforts we identify one hundred And fifty projects those

[8:00] efforts we identify one hundred And fifty projects those Capital projects are in the

[8:03] and fifty projects those Capital projects are in the

[8:03] and fifty projects those Capital projects are in the Plan based on categories you

[8:07] capital projects are in the Plan based on categories you

[8:07] capital projects are in the Plan based on categories you Can see the categories are up

[8:08] plan based on categories you Can see the categories are up

[8:08] plan based on categories you Can see the categories are up On the slide each project each

[8:10] can see the categories are up On the slide each project each

[8:10] can see the categories are up On the slide each project each Of the one hundred and fifty

[8:11] on the slide each project each Of the one hundred and fifty

[8:11] on the slide each project each Of the one hundred and fifty Projects was ranked through the

[8:14] of the one hundred and fifty Projects was ranked through the

[8:15] of the one hundred and fifty Projects was ranked through the City's capital improvement

[8:15] projects was ranked through the City's capital improvement

[8:15] projects was ranked through the City's capital improvement Planning strategic value

[8:18] city's capital improvement Planning strategic value

[8:18] city's capital improvement Planning strategic value Ranking process.

[8:19] planning strategic value Ranking process.

[8:19] planning strategic value Ranking process. So within each category you're

[8:22] ranking process. So within each category you're

[8:22] ranking process. So within each category you're Going to see specific projects

[8:23] so within each category you're Going to see specific projects

[8:23] so within each category you're Going to see specific projects And where they ranked.

[8:26] going to see specific projects And where they ranked.

[8:26] going to see specific projects And where they ranked. I have the placemaking category

[8:27] and where they ranked. I have the placemaking category

[8:27] and where they ranked. I have the placemaking category Highlighted because I just

[8:30] I have the placemaking category Highlighted because I just

[8:31] I have the placemaking category Highlighted because I just Wanted to point out there are

[8:31] highlighted because I just Wanted to point out there are

[8:31] highlighted because I just Wanted to point out there are Some projects that because

[8:34] wanted to point out there are Some projects that because

[8:34] wanted to point out there are Some projects that because Of urgency rose to the top and

[8:35] some projects that because Of urgency rose to the top and

[8:35] some projects that because Of urgency rose to the top and A good example of that is the

[8:38] of urgency rose to the top and A good example of that is the

[8:38] of urgency rose to the top and A good example of that is the Retractable bollard project in

[8:39] a good example of that is the Retractable bollard project in

[8:39] a good example of that is the Retractable bollard project in Our downtown there is a sense

[8:43] retractable bollard project in Our downtown there is a sense

[8:43] retractable bollard project in Our downtown there is a sense Of urgency to get that

[8:43] our downtown there is a sense Of urgency to get that

[8:43] our downtown there is a sense Of urgency to get that Underway.

[8:44] of urgency to get that Underway.

[8:44] of urgency to get that Underway. That project has been

[8:46] underway. That project has been

[8:46] underway. That project has been Prioritized and should our plan

[8:47] that project has been Prioritized and should our plan

[8:47] that project has been Prioritized and should our plan Be approved we are ready to

[8:50] prioritized and should our plan Be approved we are ready to

[8:50] prioritized and should our plan Be approved we are ready to Take the first step which is to

[8:50] be approved we are ready to Take the first step which is to

[8:51] be approved we are ready to Take the first step which is to Do some engineering feasibility

[8:53] take the first step which is to Do some engineering feasibility

[8:53] take the first step which is to Do some engineering feasibility At each of the I think it's

[8:54] do some engineering feasibility At each of the I think it's

[8:54] do some engineering feasibility At each of the I think it's Twenty one locations and then

[8:57] at each of the I think it's Twenty one locations and then

[8:58] at each of the I think it's Twenty one locations and then On the program side we have

[8:58] twenty one locations and then On the program side we have

[8:58] twenty one locations and then On the program side we have Four program categories that

[9:01] on the program side we have Four program categories that

[9:02] on the program side we have Four program categories that You will see in the plan.

[9:02] four program categories that You will see in the plan.

[9:02] four program categories that You will see in the plan. I have service maintenance

[9:05] you will see in the plan. I have service maintenance

[9:05] you will see in the plan. I have service maintenance Highlighted because service is

[9:09] I have service maintenance Highlighted because service is

[9:09] I have service maintenance Highlighted because service is An area where the dva is

[9:10] highlighted because service is An area where the dva is

[9:10] highlighted because service is An area where the dva is Looking to expand its role

[9:13] an area where the dva is Looking to expand its role

[9:13] an area where the dva is Looking to expand its role Downtown.

[9:14] looking to expand its role Downtown.

[9:14] looking to expand its role Downtown. We currently do not do service

[9:15] downtown. We currently do not do service

[9:15] downtown. We currently do not do service Should this plan be approved we

[9:18] we currently do not do service Should this plan be approved we

[9:18] we currently do not do service Should this plan be approved we Will be establishing a downtown

[9:21] should this plan be approved we Will be establishing a downtown

[9:21] should this plan be approved we Will be establishing a downtown Service team in recognition

[9:24] will be establishing a downtown Service team in recognition

[9:24] will be establishing a downtown Service team in recognition Of the urgency of getting this

[9:25] service team in recognition Of the urgency of getting this

[9:25] service team in recognition Of the urgency of getting this Team off the ground.

[9:25] of the urgency of getting this Team off the ground.

[9:26] of the urgency of getting this Team off the ground. We already issued an rfp.

[9:29] team off the ground. We already issued an rfp.

[9:29] team off the ground. We already issued an rfp. We received three proposals and

[9:32] we already issued an rfp. We received three proposals and

[9:32] we already issued an rfp. We received three proposals and Again should the plan be

[9:33] we received three proposals and Again should the plan be

[9:33] we received three proposals and Again should the plan be Approved we would be

[9:33] again should the plan be Approved we would be

[9:34] again should the plan be Approved we would be Recommending to our board block

[9:36] approved we would be Recommending to our board block

[9:36] approved we would be Recommending to our board block By block, block by block

[9:37] recommending to our board block By block, block by block

[9:37] recommending to our board block By block, block by block Operates these types

[9:40] by block, block by block Operates these types

[9:40] by block, block by block Operates these types Of programs.

[9:41] operates these types Of programs.

[9:41] operates these types Of programs. They have one hundred and

[9:41] of programs. They have one hundred and

[9:42] of programs. They have one hundred and Eighty of them throughout the

[9:42] they have one hundred and Eighty of them throughout the

[9:42] they have one hundred and Eighty of them throughout the Country.

[9:46] eighty of them throughout the Country.

[9:46] eighty of them throughout the Country. The program services that we

[9:47] country. The program services that we

[9:47] country. The program services that we Would be looking for the block

[9:50] the program services that we Would be looking for the block

[9:50] the program services that we Would be looking for the block By block team to take care

[9:51] would be looking for the block By block team to take care

[9:51] would be looking for the block By block team to take care Of really focus on cleanliness

[9:54] by block team to take care Of really focus on cleanliness

[9:54] by block team to take care Of really focus on cleanliness .

[9:54] of really focus on cleanliness .

[9:54] of really focus on cleanliness . So litter and debris removal,

[9:55] . So litter and debris removal,

[9:55] . So litter and debris removal, Landscaping, weeding, snow

[9:58] so litter and debris removal, Landscaping, weeding, snow

[9:58] so litter and debris removal, Landscaping, weeding, snow Removal in some specific areas

[9:59] landscaping, weeding, snow Removal in some specific areas

[9:59] landscaping, weeding, snow Removal in some specific areas Event barricade management,

[10:02] removal in some specific areas Event barricade management,

[10:03] removal in some specific areas Event barricade management, Holiday light installation and

[10:06] event barricade management, Holiday light installation and

[10:06] event barricade management, Holiday light installation and And a whole host of small

[10:07] holiday light installation and And a whole host of small

[10:07] holiday light installation and And a whole host of small Repairs and maintenance work.

[10:12] and a whole host of small Repairs and maintenance work.

[10:12] and a whole host of small Repairs and maintenance work. So now to switch gears, the tax

[10:13] repairs and maintenance work. So now to switch gears, the tax

[10:14] repairs and maintenance work. So now to switch gears, the tax Increment finance plan, the

[10:16] so now to switch gears, the tax Increment finance plan, the

[10:16] so now to switch gears, the tax Increment finance plan, the Main change that you're going

[10:17] increment finance plan, the Main change that you're going

[10:17] increment finance plan, the Main change that you're going To see in this new plan is we

[10:18] main change that you're going To see in this new plan is we

[10:18] main change that you're going To see in this new plan is we Are recommending a shift from

[10:21] to see in this new plan is we Are recommending a shift from

[10:21] to see in this new plan is we Are recommending a shift from The current cap model

[10:24] are recommending a shift from The current cap model

[10:24] are recommending a shift from The current cap model Of distribution to a revenue

[10:25] the current cap model Of distribution to a revenue

[10:25] the current cap model Of distribution to a revenue Share model.

[10:27] of distribution to a revenue Share model.

[10:27] of distribution to a revenue Share model. So this is our current model

[10:28] share model. So this is our current model

[10:29] share model. So this is our current model Of tif distribution.

[10:31] so this is our current model Of tif distribution.

[10:31] so this is our current model Of tif distribution. It is unique to ann arbor.

[10:32] of tif distribution. It is unique to ann arbor.

[10:32] of tif distribution. It is unique to ann arbor. We could not find a diva across

[10:36] it is unique to ann arbor. We could not find a diva across

[10:36] it is unique to ann arbor. We could not find a diva across The state that has the same

[10:36] we could not find a diva across The state that has the same

[10:36] we could not find a diva across The state that has the same Limitations at the ann arbor

[10:37] the state that has the same Limitations at the ann arbor

[10:37] the state that has the same Limitations at the ann arbor Day has.

[10:39] limitations at the ann arbor Day has.

[10:40] limitations at the ann arbor Day has. So to orient you to the graph

[10:43] day has. So to orient you to the graph

[10:43] day has. So to orient you to the graph That orange area at the bottom

[10:44] so to orient you to the graph That orange area at the bottom

[10:44] so to orient you to the graph That orange area at the bottom That reflects the base that the

[10:48] that orange area at the bottom That reflects the base that the

[10:48] that orange area at the bottom That reflects the base that the Taxing units retain here in ann

[10:49] that reflects the base that the Taxing units retain here in ann

[10:49] that reflects the base that the Taxing units retain here in ann Arbor the taxing units also

[10:52] taxing units retain here in ann Arbor the taxing units also

[10:52] taxing units retain here in ann Arbor the taxing units also Capture inflation that is not

[10:53] arbor the taxing units also Capture inflation that is not

[10:53] arbor the taxing units also Capture inflation that is not Typical.

[10:55] capture inflation that is not Typical.

[10:56] capture inflation that is not Typical. That blue area above the orange

[10:56] typical. That blue area above the orange

[10:57] typical. That blue area above the orange Is the revenue growth that is

[11:00] that blue area above the orange Is the revenue growth that is

[11:00] that blue area above the orange Is the revenue growth that is The dea capture and in in in an

[11:03] is the revenue growth that is The dea capture and in in in an

[11:04] is the revenue growth that is The dea capture and in in in an Arbors case in twenty seventeen

[11:04] the dea capture and in in in an Arbors case in twenty seventeen

[11:04] the dea capture and in in in an Arbors case in twenty seventeen There was a cap put on that

[11:07] arbors case in twenty seventeen There was a cap put on that

[11:07] arbors case in twenty seventeen There was a cap put on that Capture so the dea can only

[11:08] there was a cap put on that Capture so the dea can only

[11:08] there was a cap put on that Capture so the dea can only Grow at a rate of three point

[11:11] capture so the dea can only Grow at a rate of three point

[11:11] capture so the dea can only Grow at a rate of three point Five percent a year.

[11:12] grow at a rate of three point Five percent a year.

[11:12] grow at a rate of three point Five percent a year. Anything above that does go

[11:15] five percent a year. Anything above that does go

[11:15] five percent a year. Anything above that does go Back to the other taxing units.

[11:16] anything above that does go Back to the other taxing units.

[11:16] anything above that does go Back to the other taxing units. So what we are recommending in

[11:19] back to the other taxing units. So what we are recommending in

[11:19] back to the other taxing units. So what we are recommending in This plan is a shift to a

[11:20] so what we are recommending in This plan is a shift to a

[11:20] so what we are recommending in This plan is a shift to a Revenue share model.

[11:23] this plan is a shift to a Revenue share model.

[11:23] this plan is a shift to a Revenue share model. This is based on a revenue

[11:24] revenue share model. This is based on a revenue

[11:24] revenue share model. This is based on a revenue Share model that grand rapids

[11:26] this is based on a revenue Share model that grand rapids

[11:27] this is based on a revenue Share model that grand rapids Uses.

[11:27] share model that grand rapids Uses.

[11:27] share model that grand rapids Uses. What we would be recommending

[11:28] uses. What we would be recommending

[11:28] uses. What we would be recommending Is the denha would capture

[11:30] what we would be recommending Is the denha would capture

[11:30] what we would be recommending Is the denha would capture Seventy percent of that revenue

[11:31] is the denha would capture Seventy percent of that revenue

[11:31] is the denha would capture Seventy percent of that revenue Growth from new development and

[11:34] seventy percent of that revenue Growth from new development and

[11:34] seventy percent of that revenue Growth from new development and The taxing units would capture

[11:37] growth from new development and The taxing units would capture

[11:38] growth from new development and The taxing units would capture Thirty percent of that revenue

[11:38] the taxing units would capture Thirty percent of that revenue

[11:38] the taxing units would capture Thirty percent of that revenue Growth.

[11:39] thirty percent of that revenue Growth.

[11:39] thirty percent of that revenue Growth. Of course, along with that base

[11:42] growth. Of course, along with that base

[11:42] growth. Of course, along with that base And inflation we believe that

[11:46] of course, along with that base And inflation we believe that

[11:46] of course, along with that base And inflation we believe that With this split as downtown as

[11:49] and inflation we believe that With this split as downtown as

[11:49] and inflation we believe that With this split as downtown as Revenues grow, all taxing units

[11:49] with this split as downtown as Revenues grow, all taxing units

[11:50] with this split as downtown as Revenues grow, all taxing units Including the denha benefit

[11:53] revenues grow, all taxing units Including the denha benefit

[11:53] revenues grow, all taxing units Including the denha benefit From that growth and the reason

[11:54] including the denha benefit From that growth and the reason

[11:54] including the denha benefit From that growth and the reason That we landed on a thirty

[11:57] from that growth and the reason That we landed on a thirty

[11:57] from that growth and the reason That we landed on a thirty Seventy split is that in outfly

[12:01] that we landed on a thirty Seventy split is that in outfly

[12:01] that we landed on a thirty Seventy split is that in outfly Twenty six that amount in that

[12:05] seventy split is that in outfly Twenty six that amount in that

[12:05] seventy split is that in outfly Twenty six that amount in that Small orange triangle above

[12:08] twenty six that amount in that Small orange triangle above

[12:08] twenty six that amount in that Small orange triangle above That three point five percent

[12:09] small orange triangle above That three point five percent

[12:09] small orange triangle above That three point five percent Cap is at about twenty eight

[12:10] that three point five percent Cap is at about twenty eight

[12:10] that three point five percent Cap is at about twenty eight Percent.

[12:13] cap is at about twenty eight Percent.

[12:13] cap is at about twenty eight Percent. So nobody nobody goes backwards

[12:16] percent. So nobody nobody goes backwards

[12:17] percent. So nobody nobody goes backwards In terms of public engagement.

[12:17] so nobody nobody goes backwards In terms of public engagement.

[12:17] so nobody nobody goes backwards In terms of public engagement. The day we started work on this

[12:21] in terms of public engagement. The day we started work on this

[12:21] in terms of public engagement. The day we started work on this Plan in the summer of twenty

[12:22] the day we started work on this Plan in the summer of twenty

[12:22] the day we started work on this Plan in the summer of twenty Twenty three public engagement

[12:25] plan in the summer of twenty Twenty three public engagement

[12:25] plan in the summer of twenty Twenty three public engagement Started in earnest in twenty

[12:26] twenty three public engagement Started in earnest in twenty

[12:26] twenty three public engagement Started in earnest in twenty Twenty four and went through

[12:29] started in earnest in twenty Twenty four and went through

[12:29] started in earnest in twenty Twenty four and went through Twenty twenty five so we held a

[12:32] twenty four and went through Twenty twenty five so we held a

[12:32] twenty four and went through Twenty twenty five so we held a Number of public events, had

[12:32] twenty twenty five so we held a Number of public events, had

[12:33] twenty twenty five so we held a Number of public events, had Many many stakeholder meetings

[12:35] number of public events, had Many many stakeholder meetings

[12:36] number of public events, had Many many stakeholder meetings ,did multiple presentations to

[12:36] many many stakeholder meetings ,did multiple presentations to

[12:37] many many stakeholder meetings ,did multiple presentations to Various boards and commissions

[12:40] ,did multiple presentations to Various boards and commissions

[12:40] ,did multiple presentations to Various boards and commissions And we rounded it all out with

[12:41] various boards and commissions And we rounded it all out with

[12:41] various boards and commissions And we rounded it all out with A final open house in

[12:44] and we rounded it all out with A final open house in

[12:44] and we rounded it all out with A final open house in October of twenty twenty five

[12:45] a final open house in October of twenty twenty five

[12:45] a final open house in October of twenty twenty five This open house I will just

[12:48] october of twenty twenty five This open house I will just

[12:48] october of twenty twenty five This open house I will just Point out was after the plan

[12:49] this open house I will just Point out was after the plan

[12:49] this open house I will just Point out was after the plan Was drafted this was an open

[12:52] point out was after the plan Was drafted this was an open

[12:52] point out was after the plan Was drafted this was an open House that was meant to provide

[12:53] was drafted this was an open House that was meant to provide

[12:53] was drafted this was an open House that was meant to provide Education and for people to

[12:56] house that was meant to provide Education and for people to

[12:56] house that was meant to provide Education and for people to Learn about the plan.

[12:57] education and for people to Learn about the plan.

[12:57] education and for people to Learn about the plan. It wasn't a public input type

[13:00] learn about the plan. It wasn't a public input type

[13:00] learn about the plan. It wasn't a public input type Of engagement meeting so

[13:00] it wasn't a public input type Of engagement meeting so

[13:00] it wasn't a public input type Of engagement meeting so Information the next steps all

[13:04] of engagement meeting so Information the next steps all

[13:04] of engagement meeting so Information the next steps all Of the plan information

[13:07] information the next steps all Of the plan information

[13:07] information the next steps all Of the plan information Including all presentations,

[13:07] of the plan information Including all presentations,

[13:08] of the plan information Including all presentations, All resources live on the

[13:08] including all presentations, All resources live on the

[13:08] including all presentations, All resources live on the City's public engagement

[13:11] all resources live on the City's public engagement

[13:11] all resources live on the City's public engagement Website engaged a two all

[13:15] city's public engagement Website engaged a two all

[13:15] city's public engagement Website engaged a two all Of the dda board meeting

[13:16] website engaged a two all Of the dda board meeting

[13:16] website engaged a two all Of the dda board meeting Minutes, videos, work sessions

[13:20] of the dda board meeting Minutes, videos, work sessions

[13:20] of the dda board meeting Minutes, videos, work sessions All live on registar same as

[13:23] minutes, videos, work sessions All live on registar same as

[13:23] minutes, videos, work sessions All live on registar same as Council meetings.

[13:23] all live on registar same as Council meetings.

[13:23] all live on registar same as Council meetings. >> and then here we are at the

[13:27] council meetings. >> and then here we are at the

[13:27] council meetings. >> and then here we are at the Process as I mentioned at your

[13:28] » and then here we are at the Process as I mentioned at your

[13:28] » and then here we are at the Process as I mentioned at your Next council meeting there will

[13:30] process as I mentioned at your Next council meeting there will

[13:30] process as I mentioned at your Next council meeting there will Be a public hearing and the

[13:31] next council meeting there will Be a public hearing and the

[13:31] next council meeting there will Be a public hearing and the First reading of the ordinance

[13:31] be a public hearing and the First reading of the ordinance

[13:32] be a public hearing and the First reading of the ordinance Change.

[13:34] first reading of the ordinance Change.

[13:34] first reading of the ordinance Change. There is a 60 day period in

[13:38] change. There is a 60 day period in

[13:38] change. There is a 60 day period in Between that public hearing and

[13:39] there is a 60 day period in Between that public hearing and

[13:39] there is a 60 day period in Between that public hearing and When council could vote and

[13:39] between that public hearing and When council could vote and

[13:39] between that public hearing and When council could vote and That would bring us to your

[13:42] when council could vote and That would bring us to your

[13:43] when council could vote and That would bring us to your April 20th council meeting and

[13:46] that would bring us to your April 20th council meeting and

[13:46] that would bring us to your April 20th council meeting and I will just wrap it up by

[13:47] april 20th council meeting and I will just wrap it up by

[13:47] april 20th council meeting and I will just wrap it up by Saying that if there are any

[13:49] I will just wrap it up by Saying that if there are any

[13:49] I will just wrap it up by Saying that if there are any Council members or members

[13:50] saying that if there are any Council members or members

[13:50] saying that if there are any Council members or members Of the public who have

[13:53] council members or members Of the public who have

[13:53] council members or members Of the public who have Questions about the plan want

[13:54] of the public who have Questions about the plan want

[13:54] of the public who have Questions about the plan want To discuss certain aspects

[13:54] questions about the plan want To discuss certain aspects

[13:54] questions about the plan want To discuss certain aspects Of the plan, anything at all,

[13:58] to discuss certain aspects Of the plan, anything at all,

[13:58] to discuss certain aspects Of the plan, anything at all, Please reach out to me

[13:58] of the plan, anything at all, Please reach out to me

[13:58] of the plan, anything at all, Please reach out to me Directly.

[13:59] please reach out to me Directly.

[13:59] please reach out to me Directly. My email is m thompson at eight

[14:02] directly. My email is m thompson at eight

[14:02] directly. My email is m thompson at eight To org and my contact

[14:05] my email is m thompson at eight To org and my contact

[14:05] my email is m thompson at eight To org and my contact Information is also on the

[14:06] to org and my contact Information is also on the

[14:06] to org and my contact Information is also on the Website which is a to denha big

[14:09] information is also on the Website which is a to denha big

[14:09] information is also on the Website which is a to denha big Thank you.

[14:10] website which is a to denha big Thank you.

[14:10] website which is a to denha big Thank you. Thank you.

[14:13] thank you. Thank you.

[14:13] thank you. Thank you. >> we now call to public

[14:14] thank you. >> we now call to public

[14:14] thank you. >> we now call to public Comment reserve and public

[14:17] » we now call to public Comment reserve and public

[14:17] » we now call to public Comment reserve and public Reserve time is an opportunity

[14:18] comment reserve and public Reserve time is an opportunity

[14:18] comment reserve and public Reserve time is an opportunity For members of the public to

[14:19] reserve time is an opportunity For members of the public to

[14:19] reserve time is an opportunity For members of the public to Speak to council of the

[14:21] for members of the public to Speak to council of the

[14:21] for members of the public to Speak to council of the Community about matters

[14:22] speak to council of the Community about matters

[14:22] speak to council of the Community about matters Of municipal interest to speak

[14:23] community about matters Of municipal interest to speak

[14:23] community about matters Of municipal interest to speak At public comment reserve time

[14:25] of municipal interest to speak At public comment reserve time

[14:26] of municipal interest to speak At public comment reserve time One needs to have signed up in

[14:26] at public comment reserve time One needs to have signed up in

[14:26] at public comment reserve time One needs to have signed up in Advance by contacting city

[14:29] one needs to have signed up in Advance by contacting city

[14:29] one needs to have signed up in Advance by contacting city Clerk speakers in all instances

[14:30] advance by contacting city Clerk speakers in all instances

[14:30] advance by contacting city Clerk speakers in all instances Will have three minutes in

[14:32] clerk speakers in all instances Will have three minutes in

[14:32] clerk speakers in all instances Will have three minutes in Which to speak.

[14:33] will have three minutes in Which to speak.

[14:33] will have three minutes in Which to speak. So please pay close attention

[14:34] which to speak. So please pay close attention

[14:34] which to speak. So please pay close attention To the time our clerk or the

[14:37] so please pay close attention To the time our clerk or the

[14:37] so please pay close attention To the time our clerk or the Time clock will notify you in

[14:37] to the time our clerk or the Time clock will notify you in

[14:38] to the time our clerk or the Time clock will notify you in Thirty seconds.

[14:38] time clock will notify you in Thirty seconds.

[14:38] time clock will notify you in Thirty seconds. Our remaining and when your

[14:41] thirty seconds. Our remaining and when your

[14:41] thirty seconds. Our remaining and when your Time has expired when your time

[14:41] our remaining and when your Time has expired when your time

[14:42] our remaining and when your Time has expired when your time Has expired please conclude

[14:44] time has expired when your time Has expired please conclude

[14:44] time has expired when your time Has expired please conclude Your remarks and cede the

[14:45] has expired please conclude Your remarks and cede the

[14:45] has expired please conclude Your remarks and cede the Floor.

[14:45] your remarks and cede the Floor.

[14:45] your remarks and cede the Floor. Our first speaker today is paul

[14:46] floor. Our first speaker today is paul

[14:46] floor. Our first speaker today is paul Frohlich.

[14:50] our first speaker today is paul Frohlich.

[14:50] our first speaker today is paul Frohlich. Good evening mr. Taylor and

[14:51] frohlich. Good evening mr. Taylor and

[14:51] frohlich. Good evening mr. Taylor and Council members.

[14:54] good evening mr. Taylor and Council members.

[14:54] good evening mr. Taylor and Council members. I'm paul for all.

[14:55] council members. I'm paul for all.

[14:55] council members. I'm paul for all. I'm the priest at st. Andrews

[14:58] I'm paul for all. I'm the priest at st. Andrews

[14:58] I'm paul for all. I'm the priest at st. Andrews Episcopal church on the corner

[14:59] I'm the priest at st. Andrews Episcopal church on the corner

[14:59] I'm the priest at st. Andrews Episcopal church on the corner Of catherine street and north

[15:00] episcopal church on the corner Of catherine street and north

[15:00] episcopal church on the corner Of catherine street and north Division and I'd like to speak

[15:02] of catherine street and north Division and I'd like to speak

[15:02] of catherine street and north Division and I'd like to speak To see a for the banning

[15:06] division and I'd like to speak To see a for the banning

[15:06] division and I'd like to speak To see a for the banning Parking on on catherine and I'm

[15:10] to see a for the banning Parking on on catherine and I'm

[15:10] to see a for the banning Parking on on catherine and I'm Happy to be accompanied today

[15:13] parking on on catherine and I'm Happy to be accompanied today

[15:13] parking on on catherine and I'm Happy to be accompanied today By sarabande who's on our

[15:14] happy to be accompanied today By sarabande who's on our

[15:14] happy to be accompanied today By sarabande who's on our Governing board.

[15:15] by sarabande who's on our Governing board.

[15:15] by sarabande who's on our Governing board. I want to begin by saying

[15:17] governing board. I want to begin by saying

[15:17] governing board. I want to begin by saying Clearly that we support the

[15:18] I want to begin by saying Clearly that we support the

[15:18] I want to begin by saying Clearly that we support the City's goals as safer streets

[15:19] clearly that we support the City's goals as safer streets

[15:19] clearly that we support the City's goals as safer streets Expanded biking structure and a

[15:22] city's goals as safer streets Expanded biking structure and a

[15:22] city's goals as safer streets Expanded biking structure and a Transfer transportation system

[15:22] expanded biking structure and a Transfer transportation system

[15:22] expanded biking structure and a Transfer transportation system That serves people well in a

[15:26] transfer transportation system That serves people well in a

[15:26] transfer transportation system That serves people well in a Variety of ways.

[15:26] that serves people well in a Variety of ways.

[15:27] that serves people well in a Variety of ways. We are not opposed to bike

[15:29] variety of ways. We are not opposed to bike

[15:29] variety of ways. We are not opposed to bike Lanes and we share the values

[15:30] we are not opposed to bike Lanes and we share the values

[15:30] we are not opposed to bike Lanes and we share the values That animate this proposal.

[15:31] lanes and we share the values That animate this proposal.

[15:31] lanes and we share the values That animate this proposal. We do however want to raise two

[15:34] that animate this proposal. We do however want to raise two

[15:34] that animate this proposal. We do however want to raise two Specific concerns.

[15:34] we do however want to raise two Specific concerns.

[15:35] we do however want to raise two Specific concerns. First, while st. Andrews is

[15:38] specific concerns. First, while st. Andrews is

[15:38] specific concerns. First, while st. Andrews is Blessed with a small parking

[15:38] first, while st. Andrews is Blessed with a small parking

[15:39] first, while st. Andrews is Blessed with a small parking Lot that works well for most

[15:39] blessed with a small parking Lot that works well for most

[15:39] blessed with a small parking Lot that works well for most Of our weekday programs and

[15:41] lot that works well for most Of our weekday programs and

[15:41] lot that works well for most Of our weekday programs and Provides accessible parking for

[15:45] of our weekday programs and Provides accessible parking for

[15:45] of our weekday programs and Provides accessible parking for Prisoners with mobility

[15:45] provides accessible parking for Prisoners with mobility

[15:45] provides accessible parking for Prisoners with mobility Challenges on sunday mornings

[15:46] prisoners with mobility Challenges on sunday mornings

[15:46] prisoners with mobility Challenges on sunday mornings The elimination of all on

[15:49] challenges on sunday mornings The elimination of all on

[15:49] challenges on sunday mornings The elimination of all on Street parking on catherine

[15:49] the elimination of all on Street parking on catherine

[15:50] the elimination of all on Street parking on catherine Street would significantly

[15:50] street parking on catherine Street would significantly

[15:50] street parking on catherine Street would significantly Affect four large sunday

[15:53] street would significantly Affect four large sunday

[15:53] street would significantly Affect four large sunday Services.

[15:53] affect four large sunday Services.

[15:53] affect four large sunday Services. Our principal sunday service at

[15:54] services. Our principal sunday service at

[15:54] services. Our principal sunday service at 10:00 p.m. Regularly draws

[15:57] our principal sunday service at 10:00 p.m. Regularly draws

[15:57] our principal sunday service at 10:00 p.m. Regularly draws Between two hundred twenty five

[15:57] 10:00 p.m. Regularly draws Between two hundred twenty five

[15:58] 10:00 p.m. Regularly draws Between two hundred twenty five And two hundred fifty people

[15:59] between two hundred twenty five And two hundred fifty people

[16:00] between two hundred twenty five And two hundred fifty people And major services such as

[16:00] and two hundred fifty people And major services such as

[16:00] and two hundred fifty people And major services such as Christmas eve bring nearly 500

[16:01] and major services such as Christmas eve bring nearly 500

[16:01] and major services such as Christmas eve bring nearly 500 People to our campus during

[16:04] christmas eve bring nearly 500 People to our campus during

[16:04] christmas eve bring nearly 500 People to our campus during Those limited windows on st.

[16:07] people to our campus during Those limited windows on st.

[16:08] people to our campus during Those limited windows on st. Parking is essential.

[16:08] those limited windows on st. Parking is essential.

[16:08] those limited windows on st. Parking is essential. We would ask whether the design

[16:09] parking is essential. We would ask whether the design

[16:09] parking is essential. We would ask whether the design Could be reworked to allow

[16:12] we would ask whether the design Could be reworked to allow

[16:12] we would ask whether the design Could be reworked to allow Parking during specific times

[16:13] could be reworked to allow Parking during specific times

[16:13] could be reworked to allow Parking during specific times Such as sunday mornings are

[16:16] parking during specific times Such as sunday mornings are

[16:16] parking during specific times Such as sunday mornings are Major church holidays when bike

[16:17] such as sunday mornings are Major church holidays when bike

[16:17] such as sunday mornings are Major church holidays when bike Traffic is likely to be quite

[16:20] major church holidays when bike Traffic is likely to be quite

[16:20] major church holidays when bike Traffic is likely to be quite Light this kind of time limited

[16:21] traffic is likely to be quite Light this kind of time limited

[16:21] traffic is likely to be quite Light this kind of time limited Or shared use solution would go

[16:24] light this kind of time limited Or shared use solution would go

[16:24] light this kind of time limited Or shared use solution would go A long way towards addressing

[16:25] or shared use solution would go A long way towards addressing

[16:25] or shared use solution would go A long way towards addressing Our concerns while still

[16:25] a long way towards addressing Our concerns while still

[16:25] a long way towards addressing Our concerns while still Supporting the city's broader

[16:28] our concerns while still Supporting the city's broader

[16:28] our concerns while still Supporting the city's broader Transportation goals.

[16:28] supporting the city's broader Transportation goals.

[16:28] supporting the city's broader Transportation goals. Our second concern is

[16:49] a

[16:49] a Construction phase and this is

[16:50] a Construction phase and this is

[16:50] a Construction phase and this is Especially important for us.

[16:50] construction phase and this is Especially important for us.

[16:51] construction phase and this is Especially important for us. St. Andrews has operated a

[16:51] especially important for us. St. Andrews has operated a

[16:51] especially important for us. St. Andrews has operated a Breakfast program for the past

[16:52] st. Andrews has operated a Breakfast program for the past

[16:52] st. Andrews has operated a Breakfast program for the past Forty three years serving

[16:52] breakfast program for the past Forty three years serving

[16:53] breakfast program for the past Forty three years serving Breakfast seven days a week 365

[16:53] forty three years serving Breakfast seven days a week 365

[16:53] forty three years serving Breakfast seven days a week 365 Days a year to members of our

[16:54] breakfast seven days a week 365 Days a year to members of our

[16:54] breakfast seven days a week 365 Days a year to members of our Community who are hungry.

[16:55] days a year to members of our Community who are hungry.

[16:55] days a year to members of our Community who are hungry. Many of our guests are

[16:55] community who are hungry. Many of our guests are

[16:55] community who are hungry. Many of our guests are Experiencing homelessness or

[16:56] many of our guests are Experiencing homelessness or

[16:56] many of our guests are Experiencing homelessness or Struggling with addiction or

[16:57] experiencing homelessness or Struggling with addiction or

[16:57] experiencing homelessness or Struggling with addiction or Mental health challenges.

[16:57] struggling with addiction or Mental health challenges.

[16:57] struggling with addiction or Mental health challenges. This ministry depends entirely

[16:58] mental health challenges. This ministry depends entirely

[16:58] mental health challenges. This ministry depends entirely On the 15 or so volunteers who

[16:59] this ministry depends entirely On the 15 or so volunteers who

[16:59] this ministry depends entirely On the 15 or so volunteers who Need reliable, predictable

[16:59] on the 15 or so volunteers who Need reliable, predictable

[16:59] on the 15 or so volunteers who Need reliable, predictable Access to our parking lot.

[17:00] need reliable, predictable Access to our parking lot.

[17:00] need reliable, predictable Access to our parking lot. Every morning they arrive at

[17:01] access to our parking lot. Every morning they arrive at

[17:01] access to our parking lot. Every morning they arrive at Six a.m. To begin preparing the

[17:02] every morning they arrive at Six a.m. To begin preparing the

[17:03] every morning they arrive at Six a.m. To begin preparing the Meal asking them to hunt for

[17:03] six a.m. To begin preparing the Meal asking them to hunt for

[17:03] six a.m. To begin preparing the Meal asking them to hunt for Parking or use a parking garage

[17:07] meal asking them to hunt for Parking or use a parking garage

[17:07] meal asking them to hunt for Parking or use a parking garage And walk would be a significant

[17:07] parking or use a parking garage And walk would be a significant

[17:08] parking or use a parking garage And walk would be a significant Challenge, especially given the

[17:10] and walk would be a significant Challenge, especially given the

[17:10] and walk would be a significant Challenge, especially given the Age of some of our dedicated

[17:11] challenge, especially given the Age of some of our dedicated

[17:11] challenge, especially given the Age of some of our dedicated Volunteers.

[17:14] age of some of our dedicated Volunteers.

[17:14] age of some of our dedicated Volunteers. Any disruption to our lot

[17:15] volunteers. Any disruption to our lot

[17:15] volunteers. Any disruption to our lot Access during construction

[17:15] any disruption to our lot Access during construction

[17:15] any disruption to our lot Access during construction Whether for volunteers

[17:18] access during construction Whether for volunteers

[17:18] access during construction Whether for volunteers Deliveries or food service

[17:19] whether for volunteers Deliveries or food service

[17:19] whether for volunteers Deliveries or food service Would directly threaten our

[17:21] deliveries or food service Would directly threaten our

[17:21] deliveries or food service Would directly threaten our Ability to operate this

[17:21] would directly threaten our Ability to operate this

[17:22] would directly threaten our Ability to operate this Program.

[17:22] ability to operate this Program.

[17:22] ability to operate this Program. We also host a variety

[17:25] program. We also host a variety

[17:25] program. We also host a variety Of weekday worship services and

[17:26] we also host a variety Of weekday worship services and

[17:26] we also host a variety Of weekday worship services and Other community programs that

[17:27] of weekday worship services and Other community programs that

[17:27] of weekday worship services and Other community programs that Require consistent access.

[17:29] other community programs that Require consistent access.

[17:29] other community programs that Require consistent access. We respectfully ask the city to

[17:33] require consistent access. We respectfully ask the city to

[17:33] require consistent access. We respectfully ask the city to Ensure a clear and reliable

[17:34] we respectfully ask the city to Ensure a clear and reliable

[17:34] we respectfully ask the city to Ensure a clear and reliable Construction mitigation plan

[17:37] ensure a clear and reliable Construction mitigation plan

[17:37] ensure a clear and reliable Construction mitigation plan That guarantees our access to

[17:38] construction mitigation plan That guarantees our access to

[17:38] construction mitigation plan That guarantees our access to Our lot throughout the project

[17:41] that guarantees our access to Our lot throughout the project

[17:41] that guarantees our access to Our lot throughout the project And to work directly with us in

[17:42] our lot throughout the project And to work directly with us in

[17:42] our lot throughout the project And to work directly with us in Advance so that the needs

[17:42] and to work directly with us in Advance so that the needs

[17:42] and to work directly with us in Advance so that the needs Of this long standing outreach

[17:44] advance so that the needs Of this long standing outreach

[17:44] advance so that the needs Of this long standing outreach Ministry are fully understood

[17:45] of this long standing outreach Ministry are fully understood

[17:45] of this long standing outreach Ministry are fully understood And protected.

[17:45] ministry are fully understood And protected.

[17:45] ministry are fully understood And protected. St. Andrews has served and

[17:48] and protected. St. Andrews has served and

[17:48] and protected. St. Andrews has served and Harbor for nearly two centuries

[17:49] st. Andrews has served and Harbor for nearly two centuries

[17:49] st. Andrews has served and Harbor for nearly two centuries And our breakfast program has

[17:52] harbor for nearly two centuries And our breakfast program has

[17:52] harbor for nearly two centuries And our breakfast program has Been part of this city's social

[17:53] and our breakfast program has Been part of this city's social

[17:53] and our breakfast program has Been part of this city's social Safety net for over four

[17:53] been part of this city's social Safety net for over four

[17:54] been part of this city's social Safety net for over four Decades.

[17:54] safety net for over four Decades.

[17:54] safety net for over four Decades. >> we want to be constructive

[17:56] decades. >> we want to be constructive

[17:57] decades. >> we want to be constructive Partners and over that that is

[18:01] » we want to be constructive Partners and over that that is

[18:01] » we want to be constructive Partners and over that that is The time.

[18:01] partners and over that that is The time.

[18:01] partners and over that that is The time. >> but if you're if you're

[18:02] the time. >> but if you're if you're

[18:02] the time. >> but if you're if you're Wrapping up you can wrap up.

[18:03] » but if you're if you're Wrapping up you can wrap up.

[18:03] » but if you're if you're Wrapping up you can wrap up. We want to be constructive

[18:04] wrapping up you can wrap up. We want to be constructive

[18:04] wrapping up you can wrap up. We want to be constructive Partners and in a solution that

[18:05] we want to be constructive Partners and in a solution that

[18:05] we want to be constructive Partners and in a solution that Supports us while also

[18:08] partners and in a solution that Supports us while also

[18:08] partners and in a solution that Supports us while also Preserving access for worship

[18:08] supports us while also Preserving access for worship

[18:08] supports us while also Preserving access for worship Volunteers and vulnerable

[18:09] preserving access for worship Volunteers and vulnerable

[18:09] preserving access for worship Volunteers and vulnerable People.

[18:11] volunteers and vulnerable People.

[18:11] volunteers and vulnerable People. >> thank you for your time and

[18:12] people. >> thank you for your time and

[18:12] people. >> thank you for your time and Consideration.

[18:13] » thank you for your time and Consideration.

[18:13] » thank you for your time and Consideration. Thank you.

[18:14] consideration. Thank you.

[18:14] consideration. Thank you. Our next speaker is choukri

[18:22] .

[18:22] . >> good evening I my name is

[18:23] . >> good evening I my name is

[18:23] . >> good evening I my name is Chuck rheem.

[18:26] » good evening I my name is Chuck rheem.

[18:26] » good evening I my name is Chuck rheem. I live on pacard street.

[18:27] chuck rheem. I live on pacard street.

[18:27] chuck rheem. I live on pacard street. I'm running for city council in

[18:28] I live on pacard street. I'm running for city council in

[18:28] I live on pacard street. I'm running for city council in The third ward.

[18:30] I'm running for city council in The third ward.

[18:30] I'm running for city council in The third ward. The proposed comprehensive land

[18:31] the third ward. The proposed comprehensive land

[18:31] the third ward. The proposed comprehensive land Use plan is a disaster for

[18:34] the proposed comprehensive land Use plan is a disaster for

[18:34] the proposed comprehensive land Use plan is a disaster for Trees in ann arbor for the

[18:37] use plan is a disaster for Trees in ann arbor for the

[18:37] use plan is a disaster for Trees in ann arbor for the Character of ann arbor nothing

[18:38] trees in ann arbor for the Character of ann arbor nothing

[18:38] trees in ann arbor for the Character of ann arbor nothing Is done clp to incentivize

[18:42] character of ann arbor nothing Is done clp to incentivize

[18:42] character of ann arbor nothing Is done clp to incentivize Keeping trees on plots that are

[18:46] is done clp to incentivize Keeping trees on plots that are

[18:46] is done clp to incentivize Keeping trees on plots that are Being bulldozed and a lot that

[18:46] keeping trees on plots that are Being bulldozed and a lot that

[18:46] keeping trees on plots that are Being bulldozed and a lot that Is going to be redeveloped.

[18:49] being bulldozed and a lot that Is going to be redeveloped.

[18:49] being bulldozed and a lot that Is going to be redeveloped. >> you can have the trees

[18:50] is going to be redeveloped. >> you can have the trees

[18:50] is going to be redeveloped. >> you can have the trees Bulldozed flat and trucked out

[18:52] » you can have the trees Bulldozed flat and trucked out

[18:52] » you can have the trees Bulldozed flat and trucked out .

[18:52] bulldozed flat and trucked out .

[18:52] bulldozed flat and trucked out . City planning staff offered new

[18:53] . City planning staff offered new

[18:53] . City planning staff offered new Protection for trees and they

[18:57] city planning staff offered new Protection for trees and they

[18:57] city planning staff offered new Protection for trees and they Were turned down by city

[18:57] protection for trees and they Were turned down by city

[18:58] protection for trees and they Were turned down by city Council.

[19:00] were turned down by city Council.

[19:00] were turned down by city Council. City council will sacrifice the

[19:01] council. City council will sacrifice the

[19:01] council. City council will sacrifice the Trees in order to get more

[19:04] city council will sacrifice the Trees in order to get more

[19:04] city council will sacrifice the Trees in order to get more Housing units and that nearly

[19:05] trees in order to get more Housing units and that nearly

[19:05] trees in order to get more Housing units and that nearly In ann arbor rises to the level

[19:08] housing units and that nearly In ann arbor rises to the level

[19:08] housing units and that nearly In ann arbor rises to the level Of scandal.

[19:08] in ann arbor rises to the level Of scandal.

[19:08] in ann arbor rises to the level Of scandal. >> trees have many critical

[19:11] of scandal. >> trees have many critical

[19:11] of scandal. >> trees have many critical Functions and valuable

[19:12] » trees have many critical Functions and valuable

[19:12] » trees have many critical Functions and valuable Functions beyond just beauty on

[19:15] functions and valuable Functions beyond just beauty on

[19:15] functions and valuable Functions beyond just beauty on Property slated for development

[19:16] functions beyond just beauty on Property slated for development

[19:16] functions beyond just beauty on Property slated for development We must protect or replace any

[19:17] property slated for development We must protect or replace any

[19:17] property slated for development We must protect or replace any Non invasive tree that is more

[19:21] we must protect or replace any Non invasive tree that is more

[19:21] we must protect or replace any Non invasive tree that is more Than six inches thick.

[19:21] non invasive tree that is more Than six inches thick.

[19:21] non invasive tree that is more Than six inches thick. This is the standard in most

[19:23] than six inches thick. This is the standard in most

[19:23] than six inches thick. This is the standard in most U.s. Cities who care about

[19:24] this is the standard in most U.s. Cities who care about

[19:24] this is the standard in most U.s. Cities who care about Trees.

[19:24] u.s. Cities who care about Trees.

[19:24] u.s. Cities who care about Trees. There has to be a cost for

[19:27] trees. There has to be a cost for

[19:27] trees. There has to be a cost for Cutting down the middle sized

[19:28] there has to be a cost for Cutting down the middle sized

[19:28] there has to be a cost for Cutting down the middle sized Trees, cutting down all these

[19:31] cutting down the middle sized Trees, cutting down all these

[19:31] cutting down the middle sized Trees, cutting down all these Mid-sized trees without

[19:32] trees, cutting down all these Mid-sized trees without

[19:32] trees, cutting down all these Mid-sized trees without Mitigation would truly ruin the

[19:34] mid-sized trees without Mitigation would truly ruin the

[19:35] mid-sized trees without Mitigation would truly ruin the Character of ann arbor and

[19:35] mitigation would truly ruin the Character of ann arbor and

[19:35] mitigation would truly ruin the Character of ann arbor and Would guarantee that a city

[19:38] character of ann arbor and Would guarantee that a city

[19:39] character of ann arbor and Would guarantee that a city Council who would do such a

[19:39] would guarantee that a city Council who would do such a

[19:39] would guarantee that a city Council who would do such a Thing would be voted out

[19:42] council who would do such a Thing would be voted out

[19:42] council who would do such a Thing would be voted out Of office in august.

[19:46] thing would be voted out Of office in august.

[19:46] thing would be voted out Of office in august. Regular voters think that

[19:47] of office in august. Regular voters think that

[19:47] of office in august. Regular voters think that Growth for the sake of growth

[19:50] regular voters think that Growth for the sake of growth

[19:50] regular voters think that Growth for the sake of growth Is down.

[19:51] growth for the sake of growth Is down.

[19:51] growth for the sake of growth Is down. Middle-sized trees are the

[19:51] is down. Middle-sized trees are the

[19:52] is down. Middle-sized trees are the Landmark trees of the future.

[19:55] middle-sized trees are the Landmark trees of the future.

[19:55] middle-sized trees are the Landmark trees of the future. Canopy collapse is incremental

[19:58] landmark trees of the future. Canopy collapse is incremental

[19:58] landmark trees of the future. Canopy collapse is incremental .

[19:58] canopy collapse is incremental .

[19:58] canopy collapse is incremental . >> our voters will be amazed

[19:59] . >> our voters will be amazed

[20:00] . >> our voters will be amazed And disgusted that this city

[20:02] » our voters will be amazed And disgusted that this city

[20:02] » our voters will be amazed And disgusted that this city Council has not protected trees

[20:03] and disgusted that this city Council has not protected trees

[20:03] and disgusted that this city Council has not protected trees As our city is densified.

[20:07] council has not protected trees As our city is densified.

[20:07] council has not protected trees As our city is densified. Also this plan will raise taxes

[20:09] as our city is densified. Also this plan will raise taxes

[20:10] as our city is densified. Also this plan will raise taxes Significantly with no benefit

[20:10] also this plan will raise taxes Significantly with no benefit

[20:10] also this plan will raise taxes Significantly with no benefit For current residents.

[20:14] significantly with no benefit For current residents.

[20:14] significantly with no benefit For current residents. City council cares about

[20:14] for current residents. City council cares about

[20:14] for current residents. City council cares about Developers and people who might

[20:15] city council cares about Developers and people who might

[20:15] city council cares about Developers and people who might Live here in the future.

[20:18] developers and people who might Live here in the future.

[20:18] developers and people who might Live here in the future. I favor density greater density

[20:21] live here in the future. I favor density greater density

[20:22] live here in the future. I favor density greater density But we need smarter design that

[20:22] I favor density greater density But we need smarter design that

[20:22] I favor density greater density But we need smarter design that Takes trees into account

[20:25] but we need smarter design that Takes trees into account

[20:25] but we need smarter design that Takes trees into account Existing trees.

[20:26] takes trees into account Existing trees.

[20:26] takes trees into account Existing trees. >> my job is to find candidates

[20:29] existing trees. >> my job is to find candidates

[20:29] existing trees. >> my job is to find candidates To try to save ann arbor from

[20:30] » my job is to find candidates To try to save ann arbor from

[20:30] » my job is to find candidates To try to save ann arbor from This proposed degradation.

[20:34] to try to save ann arbor from This proposed degradation.

[20:34] to try to save ann arbor from This proposed degradation. I include ward three in this I

[20:35] this proposed degradation. I include ward three in this I

[20:35] this proposed degradation. I include ward three in this I Am old and male and I would

[20:38] I include ward three in this I Am old and male and I would

[20:38] I include ward three in this I Am old and male and I would Like someone who is better than

[20:39] am old and male and I would Like someone who is better than

[20:39] am old and male and I would Like someone who is better than Me protecting ann arbor and who

[20:42] like someone who is better than Me protecting ann arbor and who

[20:42] like someone who is better than Me protecting ann arbor and who Can win candidates who support

[20:43] me protecting ann arbor and who Can win candidates who support

[20:43] me protecting ann arbor and who Can win candidates who support The club can easily defeat

[20:46] can win candidates who support The club can easily defeat

[20:46] can win candidates who support The club can easily defeat Candidates who support the clp

[20:50] the club can easily defeat Candidates who support the clp

[20:50] the club can easily defeat Candidates who support the clp Can be easily defeated by

[20:51] candidates who support the clp Can be easily defeated by

[20:51] candidates who support the clp Can be easily defeated by People who love this town.

[20:54] can be easily defeated by People who love this town.

[20:54] can be easily defeated by People who love this town. But we need to move fast to

[20:55] people who love this town. But we need to move fast to

[20:55] people who love this town. But we need to move fast to Remember nominating petitions

[20:55] but we need to move fast to Remember nominating petitions

[20:56] but we need to move fast to Remember nominating petitions Have to be done and turned in

[20:58] remember nominating petitions Have to be done and turned in

[20:58] remember nominating petitions Have to be done and turned in During april.

[20:59] have to be done and turned in During april.

[20:59] have to be done and turned in During april. >> please check chuck ream save

[21:01] during april. >> please check chuck ream save

[21:01] during april. >> please check chuck ream save Tree city one word chuck save

[21:05] » please check chuck ream save Tree city one word chuck save

[21:05] » please check chuck ream save Tree city one word chuck save Tree city dot com get the facts

[21:08] tree city one word chuck save Tree city dot com get the facts

[21:08] tree city one word chuck save Tree city dot com get the facts We will fight back now or our

[21:09] tree city dot com get the facts We will fight back now or our

[21:10] tree city dot com get the facts We will fight back now or our City will be degraded.

[21:10] we will fight back now or our City will be degraded.

[21:10] we will fight back now or our City will be degraded. Our magic will be monetized.

[21:13] city will be degraded. Our magic will be monetized.

[21:13] city will be degraded. Our magic will be monetized. I want greater density but we

[21:17] our magic will be monetized. I want greater density but we

[21:17] our magic will be monetized. I want greater density but we Must grow in aaberg without

[21:18] I want greater density but we Must grow in aaberg without

[21:18] I want greater density but we Must grow in aaberg without Cutting it down.

[21:18] must grow in aaberg without Cutting it down.

[21:18] must grow in aaberg without Cutting it down. Chuck rheem save tree city

[21:21] cutting it down. Chuck rheem save tree city

[21:21] cutting it down. Chuck rheem save tree city Thank you.

[21:21] chuck rheem save tree city Thank you.

[21:22] chuck rheem save tree city Thank you. >> thank you.

[21:24] thank you. >> thank you.

[21:24] thank you. >> thank you. >> our next speaker is alex

[21:25] » thank you. >> our next speaker is alex

[21:25] » thank you. >> our next speaker is alex Lowe.

[21:28] » our next speaker is alex Lowe.

[21:28] » our next speaker is alex Lowe. Mayor alex lowe is joining us

[21:29] lowe. Mayor alex lowe is joining us

[21:29] lowe. Mayor alex lowe is joining us On zoome alex lowe a star to

[21:33] mayor alex lowe is joining us On zoome alex lowe a star to

[21:33] mayor alex lowe is joining us On zoome alex lowe a star to Amuse yourself perhaps in

[21:38] on zoome alex lowe a star to Amuse yourself perhaps in

[21:38] on zoome alex lowe a star to Amuse yourself perhaps in Evening six months to 57

[21:41] amuse yourself perhaps in Evening six months to 57

[21:41] amuse yourself perhaps in Evening six months to 57 Percent of voters voted to sell

[21:42] evening six months to 57 Percent of voters voted to sell

[21:42] evening six months to 57 Percent of voters voted to sell To the city of los misuses

[21:46] percent of voters voted to sell To the city of los misuses

[21:46] percent of voters voted to sell To the city of los misuses Downtown surface parking should

[21:49] to the city of los misuses Downtown surface parking should

[21:49] to the city of los misuses Downtown surface parking should The end of a district like this

[21:50] downtown surface parking should The end of a district like this

[21:50] downtown surface parking should The end of a district like this Occurred just by clear

[21:53] the end of a district like this Occurred just by clear

[21:54] the end of a district like this Occurred just by clear Violations of michigan campaign

[21:54] occurred just by clear Violations of michigan campaign

[21:54] occurred just by clear Violations of michigan campaign Finance, the small but

[21:58] violations of michigan campaign Finance, the small but

[21:58] violations of michigan campaign Finance, the small but Well-funded group that

[21:58] finance, the small but Well-funded group that

[21:58] finance, the small but Well-funded group that Significantly outspent the

[22:02] well-funded group that Significantly outspent the

[22:02] well-funded group that Significantly outspent the Grand total of four cash donors

[22:03] significantly outspent the Grand total of four cash donors

[22:03] significantly outspent the Grand total of four cash donors Who donated the official vote

[22:05] grand total of four cash donors Who donated the official vote

[22:06] grand total of four cash donors Who donated the official vote No campaign yet in the six

[22:06] who donated the official vote No campaign yet in the six

[22:06] who donated the official vote No campaign yet in the six Months since there does not

[22:10] no campaign yet in the six Months since there does not

[22:10] no campaign yet in the six Months since there does not Seem to have been much action

[22:10] months since there does not Seem to have been much action

[22:10] months since there does not Seem to have been much action On this from the city.

[22:13] seem to have been much action On this from the city.

[22:13] seem to have been much action On this from the city. >> now is the time city council

[22:14] on this from the city. >> now is the time city council

[22:14] on this from the city. >> now is the time city council To implement the will of the

[22:17] » now is the time city council To implement the will of the

[22:18] » now is the time city council To implement the will of the Voters.

[22:18] to implement the will of the Voters.

[22:18] to implement the will of the Voters. Now is the time to make our

[22:19] voters. Now is the time to make our

[22:19] voters. Now is the time to make our Library so much better.

[22:21] now is the time to make our Library so much better.

[22:21] now is the time to make our Library so much better. Please city council direct

[22:25] library so much better. Please city council direct

[22:25] library so much better. Please city council direct Administrator tony that this is

[22:26] please city council direct Administrator tony that this is

[22:26] please city council direct Administrator tony that this is A high priority that should be

[22:29] administrator tony that this is A high priority that should be

[22:29] administrator tony that this is A high priority that should be Completed within this fiscal

[22:30] a high priority that should be Completed within this fiscal

[22:30] a high priority that should be Completed within this fiscal Year on a separate point

[22:34] completed within this fiscal Year on a separate point

[22:34] completed within this fiscal Year on a separate point Related to cfr, I'd like to

[22:38] year on a separate point Related to cfr, I'd like to

[22:38] year on a separate point Related to cfr, I'd like to Point out that the twenty to

[22:38] related to cfr, I'd like to Point out that the twenty to

[22:39] related to cfr, I'd like to Point out that the twenty to Thirty three and sixty five bus

[22:41] point out that the twenty to Thirty three and sixty five bus

[22:41] point out that the twenty to Thirty three and sixty five bus Lines stop directly in front

[22:44] thirty three and sixty five bus Lines stop directly in front

[22:44] thirty three and sixty five bus Lines stop directly in front Of st. Andrew's episcopal

[22:45] lines stop directly in front Of st. Andrew's episcopal

[22:45] lines stop directly in front Of st. Andrew's episcopal Church and that the church

[22:45] of st. Andrew's episcopal Church and that the church

[22:46] of st. Andrew's episcopal Church and that the church Provides precisely zero

[22:48] church and that the church Provides precisely zero

[22:49] church and that the church Provides precisely zero Covered by parking spots.

[22:49] provides precisely zero Covered by parking spots.

[22:49] provides precisely zero Covered by parking spots. >> I would love to to see st.

[22:53] covered by parking spots. >> I would love to to see st.

[22:53] covered by parking spots. >> I would love to to see st. Andrew's providing bike parking

[22:55] » I would love to to see st. Andrew's providing bike parking

[22:56] » I would love to to see st. Andrew's providing bike parking And working with the right to

[22:56] andrew's providing bike parking And working with the right to

[22:57] andrew's providing bike parking And working with the right to To offer better sunday service

[23:00] and working with the right to To offer better sunday service

[23:00] and working with the right to To offer better sunday service On our busses if they truly

[23:04] to offer better sunday service On our busses if they truly

[23:04] to offer better sunday service On our busses if they truly Believe that the city needs to

[23:07] on our busses if they truly Believe that the city needs to

[23:07] on our busses if they truly Believe that the city needs to Protect god's green earth.

[23:08] believe that the city needs to Protect god's green earth.

[23:08] believe that the city needs to Protect god's green earth. >> thank you.

[23:10] protect god's green earth. >> thank you.

[23:10] protect god's green earth. >> thank you. >> thank you.

[23:11] » thank you. >> thank you.

[23:11] » thank you. >> thank you. Our next speaker is kathy

[23:12] » thank you. Our next speaker is kathy

[23:12] » thank you. Our next speaker is kathy Griswold

[23:18] rather than ask

[23:19] rather than ask Council to do something or talk

[23:23] rather than ask Council to do something or talk

[23:23] rather than ask Council to do something or talk About policies in the budget, I

[23:27] council to do something or talk About policies in the budget, I

[23:27] council to do something or talk About policies in the budget, I Want to start by reading some

[23:27] about policies in the budget, I Want to start by reading some

[23:28] about policies in the budget, I Want to start by reading some Staff comments in an effort to

[23:31] want to start by reading some Staff comments in an effort to

[23:31] want to start by reading some Staff comments in an effort to Fix it ticket and this ticket

[23:35] staff comments in an effort to Fix it ticket and this ticket

[23:35] staff comments in an effort to Fix it ticket and this ticket Is something that I put in in

[23:36] fix it ticket and this ticket Is something that I put in in

[23:36] fix it ticket and this ticket Is something that I put in in Mid december.

[23:38] is something that I put in in Mid december.

[23:39] is something that I put in in Mid december. It is regarding maiden lane

[23:42] mid december. It is regarding maiden lane

[23:42] mid december. It is regarding maiden lane Just south of broadway where

[23:43] it is regarding maiden lane Just south of broadway where

[23:43] it is regarding maiden lane Just south of broadway where There is no sidewalk.

[23:46] just south of broadway where There is no sidewalk.

[23:46] just south of broadway where There is no sidewalk. It's an auto repair business

[23:47] there is no sidewalk. It's an auto repair business

[23:47] there is no sidewalk. It's an auto repair business And it's heavily trafficked by

[23:51] it's an auto repair business And it's heavily trafficked by

[23:51] it's an auto repair business And it's heavily trafficked by Pedestrians as well as vehicles

[23:55] and it's heavily trafficked by Pedestrians as well as vehicles

[23:55] and it's heavily trafficked by Pedestrians as well as vehicles And pedestrians are having to

[23:58] pedestrians as well as vehicles And pedestrians are having to

[23:58] pedestrians as well as vehicles And pedestrians are having to Walk off to the curb into a

[23:59] and pedestrians are having to Walk off to the curb into a

[23:59] and pedestrians are having to Walk off to the curb into a Busy traffic lane because

[24:03] walk off to the curb into a Busy traffic lane because

[24:03] walk off to the curb into a Busy traffic lane because There's no sidewalk there and

[24:05] busy traffic lane because There's no sidewalk there and

[24:05] busy traffic lane because There's no sidewalk there and Cars are parking not only right

[24:06] there's no sidewalk there and Cars are parking not only right

[24:06] there's no sidewalk there and Cars are parking not only right Up to the curb but today when I

[24:10] cars are parking not only right Up to the curb but today when I

[24:10] cars are parking not only right Up to the curb but today when I Went by they were parking about

[24:10] up to the curb but today when I Went by they were parking about

[24:11] up to the curb but today when I Went by they were parking about Six inches beyond the curb.

[24:13] went by they were parking about Six inches beyond the curb.

[24:14] went by they were parking about Six inches beyond the curb. You couldn't tell where the

[24:14] six inches beyond the curb. You couldn't tell where the

[24:14] six inches beyond the curb. You couldn't tell where the Curb really was because of all

[24:15] you couldn't tell where the Curb really was because of all

[24:15] you couldn't tell where the Curb really was because of all The snow.

[24:17] curb really was because of all The snow.

[24:18] curb really was because of all The snow. So in december of december

[24:18] the snow. So in december of december

[24:19] the snow. So in december of december Twenty first I put in a ticket

[24:22] so in december of december Twenty first I put in a ticket

[24:22] so in december of december Twenty first I put in a ticket To say remove vehicles parked

[24:25] twenty first I put in a ticket To say remove vehicles parked

[24:25] twenty first I put in a ticket To say remove vehicles parked The public right of way in

[24:26] to say remove vehicles parked The public right of way in

[24:26] to say remove vehicles parked The public right of way in Violation of city code blah

[24:27] the public right of way in Violation of city code blah

[24:27] the public right of way in Violation of city code blah Blah and long term construct

[24:29] violation of city code blah Blah and long term construct

[24:29] violation of city code blah Blah and long term construct The sidewalk that you should

[24:33] blah and long term construct The sidewalk that you should

[24:33] blah and long term construct The sidewalk that you should Have incorporated into the

[24:33] the sidewalk that you should Have incorporated into the

[24:33] the sidewalk that you should Have incorporated into the Approval when you put in a new

[24:37] have incorporated into the Approval when you put in a new

[24:37] have incorporated into the Approval when you put in a new Development across the street.

[24:40] approval when you put in a new Development across the street.

[24:41] approval when you put in a new Development across the street. I want also say that I will

[24:44] development across the street. I want also say that I will

[24:44] development across the street. I want also say that I will Take every opportunity and

[24:45] I want also say that I will Take every opportunity and

[24:45] I want also say that I will Take every opportunity and Every legal path that I can to

[24:51] take every opportunity and Every legal path that I can to

[24:51] take every opportunity and Every legal path that I can to Get this sidewalk in.

[24:55] every legal path that I can to Get this sidewalk in.

[24:55] every legal path that I can to Get this sidewalk in. There is absolutely no excuse

[24:56] get this sidewalk in. There is absolutely no excuse

[24:56] get this sidewalk in. There is absolutely no excuse For not having what what that

[25:01] there is absolutely no excuse For not having what what that

[25:01] there is absolutely no excuse For not having what what that Is.

[25:04] for not having what what that Is.

[25:05] for not having what what that Is. The staff said that they are

[25:05] is. The staff said that they are

[25:06] is. The staff said that they are Going to prioritize this need

[25:09] the staff said that they are Going to prioritize this need

[25:09] the staff said that they are Going to prioritize this need To address it based on overall

[25:10] going to prioritize this need To address it based on overall

[25:10] going to prioritize this need To address it based on overall Available ability of city

[25:13] to address it based on overall Available ability of city

[25:13] to address it based on overall Available ability of city Resources.

[25:13] available ability of city Resources.

[25:13] available ability of city Resources. It is this council responsible

[25:16] resources. It is this council responsible

[25:17] resources. It is this council responsible To provide staff with the

[25:17] it is this council responsible To provide staff with the

[25:17] it is this council responsible To provide staff with the Training, with the knowledge

[25:18] to provide staff with the Training, with the knowledge

[25:18] to provide staff with the Training, with the knowledge And the funding to do their job

[25:21] training, with the knowledge And the funding to do their job

[25:21] training, with the knowledge And the funding to do their job And they haven't done that.

[25:25] and the funding to do their job And they haven't done that.

[25:25] and the funding to do their job And they haven't done that. I have taken some criticism for

[25:25] and they haven't done that. I have taken some criticism for

[25:26] and they haven't done that. I have taken some criticism for Filing a complaint against

[25:28] I have taken some criticism for Filing a complaint against

[25:29] I have taken some criticism for Filing a complaint against Staff.

[25:29] filing a complaint against Staff.

[25:29] filing a complaint against Staff. I can tell you I have two more

[25:30] staff. I can tell you I have two more

[25:30] staff. I can tell you I have two more In the works right now.

[25:32] I can tell you I have two more In the works right now.

[25:32] I can tell you I have two more In the works right now. It is council's responsibility

[25:33] in the works right now. It is council's responsibility

[25:33] in the works right now. It is council's responsibility To make sure that staff know

[25:36] it is council's responsibility To make sure that staff know

[25:36] it is council's responsibility To make sure that staff know What they're doing.

[25:37] to make sure that staff know What they're doing.

[25:37] to make sure that staff know What they're doing. Ok, so what do they recommend?

[25:40] what they're doing. Ok, so what do they recommend?

[25:40] what they're doing. Ok, so what do they recommend? Time is short because funding

[25:41] ok, so what do they recommend? Time is short because funding

[25:41] ok, so what do they recommend? Time is short because funding To fill sidewalk gaps is

[25:41] time is short because funding To fill sidewalk gaps is

[25:41] time is short because funding To fill sidewalk gaps is Limited.

[25:44] to fill sidewalk gaps is Limited.

[25:44] to fill sidewalk gaps is Limited. The city uses a prioritization

[25:45] limited. The city uses a prioritization

[25:45] limited. The city uses a prioritization System to help determine where

[25:47] the city uses a prioritization System to help determine where

[25:47] the city uses a prioritization System to help determine where The funding goes.

[25:52] system to help determine where The funding goes.

[25:52] system to help determine where The funding goes. They're proposing that in two

[25:53] the funding goes. They're proposing that in two

[25:53] the funding goes. They're proposing that in two Twenty twenty nine they're

[25:55] they're proposing that in two Twenty twenty nine they're

[25:55] they're proposing that in two Twenty twenty nine they're Going to take care of this

[25:56] twenty twenty nine they're Going to take care of this

[25:56] twenty twenty nine they're Going to take care of this Sidewalk need.

[25:56] going to take care of this Sidewalk need.

[25:56] going to take care of this Sidewalk need. Well I went and talked to the

[25:59] sidewalk need. Well I went and talked to the

[25:59] sidewalk need. Well I went and talked to the Owner again today.

[26:00] well I went and talked to the Owner again today.

[26:00] well I went and talked to the Owner again today. He is willing to actually give

[26:03] owner again today. He is willing to actually give

[26:03] owner again today. He is willing to actually give Some land if need be because it

[26:04] he is willing to actually give Some land if need be because it

[26:04] he is willing to actually give Some land if need be because it Is so critical and he said

[26:07] some land if need be because it Is so critical and he said

[26:07] some land if need be because it Is so critical and he said Close calls all the time.

[26:07] is so critical and he said Close calls all the time.

[26:08] is so critical and he said Close calls all the time. So tomorrow morning I'm going

[26:08] close calls all the time. So tomorrow morning I'm going

[26:08] close calls all the time. So tomorrow morning I'm going To talk to the detroit media

[26:11] so tomorrow morning I'm going To talk to the detroit media

[26:12] so tomorrow morning I'm going To talk to the detroit media Because if you can't do it

[26:12] to talk to the detroit media Because if you can't do it

[26:12] to talk to the detroit media Because if you can't do it Because it's the right thing to

[26:13] because if you can't do it Because it's the right thing to

[26:13] because if you can't do it Because it's the right thing to Do, maybe you'll do it because

[26:16] because it's the right thing to Do, maybe you'll do it because

[26:16] because it's the right thing to Do, maybe you'll do it because Of media pressure.

[26:16] do, maybe you'll do it because Of media pressure.

[26:16] do, maybe you'll do it because Of media pressure. >> thank you.

[26:17] of media pressure. >> thank you.

[26:17] of media pressure. >> thank you. Thank you.

[26:21] » thank you. Thank you.

[26:21] » thank you. Thank you. >> are there communications

[26:22] thank you. >> are there communications

[26:22] thank you. >> are there communications Today from council house

[26:27] » are there communications Today from council house

[26:27] » are there communications Today from council house Council member adam?

[26:31] today from council house Council member adam?

[26:31] today from council house Council member adam? Thank you.

[26:31] council member adam? Thank you.

[26:32] council member adam? Thank you. Mayor taylor.

[26:35] thank you. Mayor taylor.

[26:35] thank you. Mayor taylor. Today, one day after mlk day

[26:36] mayor taylor. Today, one day after mlk day

[26:36] mayor taylor. Today, one day after mlk day Marks the one year anniversary

[26:40] today, one day after mlk day Marks the one year anniversary

[26:40] today, one day after mlk day Marks the one year anniversary Of a oh of a republican

[26:43] marks the one year anniversary Of a oh of a republican

[26:43] marks the one year anniversary Of a oh of a republican Trifecta taking control of our

[26:47] of a oh of a republican Trifecta taking control of our

[26:47] of a oh of a republican Trifecta taking control of our Federal government one year

[26:48] trifecta taking control of our Federal government one year

[26:48] trifecta taking control of our Federal government one year Later groceries costs more.

[26:50] federal government one year Later groceries costs more.

[26:50] federal government one year Later groceries costs more. Rents are still rising.

[26:51] later groceries costs more. Rents are still rising.

[26:51] later groceries costs more. Rents are still rising. Housing is not more

[27:11] abundant.

[27:12] abundant. Health care, child care and

[27:12] abundant. Health care, child care and Education costs are stretching

[27:13] health care, child care and Education costs are stretching

[27:13] health care, child care and Education costs are stretching Family budgets thinner.

[27:14] education costs are stretching Family budgets thinner.

[27:14] education costs are stretching Family budgets thinner. People are working just as hard

[27:14] family budgets thinner. People are working just as hard

[27:15] family budgets thinner. People are working just as hard Or harder but their paychecks

[27:15] people are working just as hard Or harder but their paychecks

[27:15] people are working just as hard Or harder but their paychecks Aren't growing and they're

[27:16] or harder but their paychecks Aren't growing and they're

[27:16] or harder but their paychecks Aren't growing and they're Still falling behind.

[27:16] aren't growing and they're Still falling behind.

[27:16] aren't growing and they're Still falling behind. One year later we have fewer

[27:17] still falling behind. One year later we have fewer

[27:17] still falling behind. One year later we have fewer Rights and freedoms.

[27:18] one year later we have fewer Rights and freedoms.

[27:18] one year later we have fewer Rights and freedoms. The federal government has

[27:18] rights and freedoms. The federal government has

[27:18] rights and freedoms. The federal government has Militarized our streets and

[27:19] the federal government has Militarized our streets and

[27:19] the federal government has Militarized our streets and Turned on its people.

[27:20] militarized our streets and Turned on its people.

[27:20] militarized our streets and Turned on its people. This is most evident today in

[27:20] turned on its people. This is most evident today in

[27:20] turned on its people. This is most evident today in Minnesota where citizens and

[27:21] this is most evident today in Minnesota where citizens and

[27:21] this is most evident today in Minnesota where citizens and Non-citizens are like are being

[27:22] minnesota where citizens and Non-citizens are like are being

[27:22] minnesota where citizens and Non-citizens are like are being Rounded up and even murdered by

[27:22] non-citizens are like are being Rounded up and even murdered by

[27:23] non-citizens are like are being Rounded up and even murdered by Armed masked federal agents.

[27:23] rounded up and even murdered by Armed masked federal agents.

[27:23] rounded up and even murdered by Armed masked federal agents. We are on the brink of war in

[27:24] armed masked federal agents. We are on the brink of war in

[27:24] armed masked federal agents. We are on the brink of war in Several parts of the world,

[27:25] we are on the brink of war in Several parts of the world,

[27:25] we are on the brink of war in Several parts of the world, Including with some of our

[27:25] several parts of the world, Including with some of our

[27:25] several parts of the world, Including with some of our Oldest friends and allies in

[27:26] including with some of our Oldest friends and allies in

[27:26] including with some of our Oldest friends and allies in Europe and an american

[27:27] oldest friends and allies in Europe and an american

[27:27] oldest friends and allies in Europe and an american President is threatening to

[27:29] europe and an american President is threatening to

[27:29] europe and an american President is threatening to Cancel our free and fair

[27:29] president is threatening to Cancel our free and fair

[27:29] president is threatening to Cancel our free and fair Elections.

[27:30] cancel our free and fair Elections.

[27:30] cancel our free and fair Elections. This is not the american dream

[27:33] elections. This is not the american dream

[27:33] elections. This is not the american dream That we were promised.

[27:33] this is not the american dream That we were promised.

[27:33] this is not the american dream That we were promised. This is not the america that

[27:34] that we were promised. This is not the america that

[27:34] that we were promised. This is not the america that Thousands have fought and died

[27:37] this is not the america that Thousands have fought and died

[27:37] this is not the america that Thousands have fought and died For and we deserve and must

[27:38] thousands have fought and died For and we deserve and must

[27:38] thousands have fought and died For and we deserve and must Continue to fight for better at

[27:41] for and we deserve and must Continue to fight for better at

[27:41] for and we deserve and must Continue to fight for better at This moment local communities

[27:42] continue to fight for better at This moment local communities

[27:42] continue to fight for better at This moment local communities Are stepping cities across the

[27:45] this moment local communities Are stepping cities across the

[27:45] this moment local communities Are stepping cities across the Country including our own are

[27:45] are stepping cities across the Country including our own are

[27:45] are stepping cities across the Country including our own are Becoming a last line of defense

[27:49] country including our own are Becoming a last line of defense

[27:49] country including our own are Becoming a last line of defense For our people fighting to

[27:49] becoming a last line of defense For our people fighting to

[27:49] becoming a last line of defense For our people fighting to Protect civil and human rights

[27:52] for our people fighting to Protect civil and human rights

[27:52] for our people fighting to Protect civil and human rights ,working to create more

[27:53] protect civil and human rights ,working to create more

[27:53] protect civil and human rights ,working to create more Housing and lower costs,

[27:53] ,working to create more Housing and lower costs,

[27:54] ,working to create more Housing and lower costs, Investing in real public safety

[27:56] housing and lower costs, Investing in real public safety

[27:57] housing and lower costs, Investing in real public safety That serves rather than targets

[27:57] investing in real public safety That serves rather than targets

[27:57] investing in real public safety That serves rather than targets Our people and trying to

[28:00] that serves rather than targets Our people and trying to

[28:00] that serves rather than targets Our people and trying to Strengthen our social safety

[28:01] our people and trying to Strengthen our social safety

[28:01] our people and trying to Strengthen our social safety Net to ensure that people

[28:01] strengthen our social safety Net to ensure that people

[28:01] strengthen our social safety Net to ensure that people Aren't left to fend for

[28:03] net to ensure that people Aren't left to fend for

[28:04] net to ensure that people Aren't left to fend for Themselves while the republican

[28:04] aren't left to fend for Themselves while the republican

[28:04] aren't left to fend for Themselves while the republican While republican controlled

[28:07] themselves while the republican While republican controlled

[28:07] themselves while the republican While republican controlled Washington thrives in creating

[28:08] while republican controlled Washington thrives in creating

[28:08] while republican controlled Washington thrives in creating Chaos and fear, democratic

[28:09] washington thrives in creating Chaos and fear, democratic

[28:09] washington thrives in creating Chaos and fear, democratic Controlled cities like ours are

[28:12] chaos and fear, democratic Controlled cities like ours are

[28:12] chaos and fear, democratic Controlled cities like ours are Working to improve lives and

[28:12] controlled cities like ours are Working to improve lives and

[28:13] controlled cities like ours are Working to improve lives and Lower costs that said, it is

[28:16] working to improve lives and Lower costs that said, it is

[28:16] working to improve lives and Lower costs that said, it is Important to remember that

[28:16] lower costs that said, it is Important to remember that

[28:17] lower costs that said, it is Important to remember that Progress rarely comes from just

[28:17] important to remember that Progress rarely comes from just

[28:17] important to remember that Progress rarely comes from just One person at the top or often

[28:20] progress rarely comes from just One person at the top or often

[28:20] progress rarely comes from just One person at the top or often Not even from government at all

[28:23] one person at the top or often Not even from government at all

[28:23] one person at the top or often Not even from government at all .

[28:23] not even from government at all .

[28:23] not even from government at all . It comes from people showing up

[28:24] . It comes from people showing up

[28:24] . It comes from people showing up For one another, neighbors

[28:25] it comes from people showing up For one another, neighbors

[28:25] it comes from people showing up For one another, neighbors Helping neighbors, communities

[28:27] for one another, neighbors Helping neighbors, communities

[28:27] for one another, neighbors Helping neighbors, communities Choosing solidarity over

[28:27] helping neighbors, communities Choosing solidarity over

[28:27] helping neighbors, communities Choosing solidarity over Division, hope over fear and

[28:28] choosing solidarity over Division, hope over fear and

[28:28] choosing solidarity over Division, hope over fear and Choosing to protect one

[28:31] division, hope over fear and Choosing to protect one

[28:31] division, hope over fear and Choosing to protect one Another.

[28:31] choosing to protect one Another.

[28:31] choosing to protect one Another. So finally I say all of this

[28:34] another. So finally I say all of this

[28:34] another. So finally I say all of this Tonight to call on our

[28:35] so finally I say all of this Tonight to call on our

[28:35] so finally I say all of this Tonight to call on our Community to keep using your

[28:36] tonight to call on our Community to keep using your

[28:36] tonight to call on our Community to keep using your Voices and your privilege to

[28:39] community to keep using your Voices and your privilege to

[28:39] community to keep using your Voices and your privilege to Defend those that are being

[28:39] voices and your privilege to Defend those that are being

[28:39] voices and your privilege to Defend those that are being Silenced and targeted to

[28:40] defend those that are being Silenced and targeted to

[28:40] defend those that are being Silenced and targeted to Continue resisting tyranny and

[28:43] silenced and targeted to Continue resisting tyranny and

[28:43] silenced and targeted to Continue resisting tyranny and Fighting back against

[28:43] continue resisting tyranny and Fighting back against

[28:43] continue resisting tyranny and Fighting back against Oppression and to ask that as

[28:46] fighting back against Oppression and to ask that as

[28:46] fighting back against Oppression and to ask that as We on this side of the table

[28:47] oppression and to ask that as We on this side of the table

[28:47] oppression and to ask that as We on this side of the table Continue working to strengthen

[28:48] we on this side of the table Continue working to strengthen

[28:48] we on this side of the table Continue working to strengthen Our local policies and

[28:50] continue working to strengthen Our local policies and

[28:51] continue working to strengthen Our local policies and Protections for all of our

[28:51] our local policies and Protections for all of our

[28:51] our local policies and Protections for all of our Residents to please keep

[28:52] protections for all of our Residents to please keep

[28:52] protections for all of our Residents to please keep Pushing and our county and our

[28:55] residents to please keep Pushing and our county and our

[28:55] residents to please keep Pushing and our county and our State but most especially our

[28:56] pushing and our county and our State but most especially our

[28:56] pushing and our county and our State but most especially our Federal government to do and be

[28:59] state but most especially our Federal government to do and be

[28:59] state but most especially our Federal government to do and be Better.

[28:59] federal government to do and be Better.

[29:00] federal government to do and be Better. >> thank you, trackman.

[29:04] better. >> thank you, trackman.

[29:05] better. >> thank you, trackman. Thank you, mr. Mayor.

[29:05] » thank you, trackman. Thank you, mr. Mayor.

[29:05] » thank you, trackman. Thank you, mr. Mayor. This is somewhat not news if

[29:06] thank you, mr. Mayor. This is somewhat not news if

[29:06] thank you, mr. Mayor. This is somewhat not news if You read my newsletter but I

[29:09] this is somewhat not news if You read my newsletter but I

[29:09] this is somewhat not news if You read my newsletter but I Still wanted to let my

[29:10] you read my newsletter but I Still wanted to let my

[29:10] you read my newsletter but I Still wanted to let my Lleagues in the public know

[29:10] still wanted to let my Lleagues in the public know

[29:11] still wanted to let my Lleagues in the public know That I will not be running for

[29:13] lleagues in the public know That I will not be running for

[29:13] lleagues in the public know That I will not be running for Reelection when my term ends in

[29:14] that I will not be running for Reelection when my term ends in

[29:14] that I will not be running for Reelection when my term ends in November.

[29:16] reelection when my term ends in November.

[29:16] reelection when my term ends in November. It's been a real privilege to

[29:17] november. It's been a real privilege to

[29:17] november. It's been a real privilege to Serve and harbor first on the

[29:20] it's been a real privilege to Serve and harbor first on the

[29:20] it's been a real privilege to Serve and harbor first on the Library board and now on city

[29:20] serve and harbor first on the Library board and now on city

[29:21] serve and harbor first on the Library board and now on city Council and I'm really grateful

[29:23] library board and now on city Council and I'm really grateful

[29:23] library board and now on city Council and I'm really grateful For the trust that residents

[29:24] council and I'm really grateful For the trust that residents

[29:24] council and I'm really grateful For the trust that residents Have placed in me and the

[29:25] for the trust that residents Have placed in me and the

[29:25] for the trust that residents Have placed in me and the Chance to work with so many

[29:27] have placed in me and the Chance to work with so many

[29:28] have placed in me and the Chance to work with so many Thoughtful people along the

[29:28] chance to work with so many Thoughtful people along the

[29:28] chance to work with so many Thoughtful people along the Way.

[29:28] thoughtful people along the Way.

[29:28] thoughtful people along the Way. Of course I spent a lot of time

[29:29] way. Of course I spent a lot of time

[29:30] way. Of course I spent a lot of time Weighing this decision.

[29:31] of course I spent a lot of time Weighing this decision.

[29:31] of course I spent a lot of time Weighing this decision. I came into public service

[29:32] weighing this decision. I came into public service

[29:32] weighing this decision. I came into public service Because I care about the city,

[29:35] I came into public service Because I care about the city,

[29:35] I came into public service Because I care about the city, Wanted to help improve it,

[29:35] because I care about the city, Wanted to help improve it,

[29:35] because I care about the city, Wanted to help improve it, Enjoy helping my neighbors not

[29:36] wanted to help improve it, Enjoy helping my neighbors not

[29:36] wanted to help improve it, Enjoy helping my neighbors not Because I ever actually

[29:39] enjoy helping my neighbors not Because I ever actually

[29:39] enjoy helping my neighbors not Because I ever actually Imagined a long political

[29:40] because I ever actually Imagined a long political

[29:40] because I ever actually Imagined a long political Career and over time I've

[29:42] imagined a long political Career and over time I've

[29:43] imagined a long political Career and over time I've Learned, you know, their real

[29:43] career and over time I've Learned, you know, their real

[29:44] career and over time I've Learned, you know, their real Personal and family tradeoffs

[29:44] learned, you know, their real Personal and family tradeoffs

[29:44] learned, you know, their real Personal and family tradeoffs And public service surprised

[29:46] personal and family tradeoffs And public service surprised

[29:47] personal and family tradeoffs And public service surprised Price and for me this feels

[29:47] and public service surprised Price and for me this feels

[29:47] and public service surprised Price and for me this feels Like the right moment to step

[29:48] price and for me this feels Like the right moment to step

[29:48] price and for me this feels Like the right moment to step Aside and create space for new

[29:50] like the right moment to step Aside and create space for new

[29:51] like the right moment to step Aside and create space for new Leadership and continue

[29:51] aside and create space for new Leadership and continue

[29:51] aside and create space for new Leadership and continue Contributing to ann and other

[29:54] leadership and continue Contributing to ann and other

[29:54] leadership and continue Contributing to ann and other Ways.

[29:54] contributing to ann and other Ways.

[29:54] contributing to ann and other Ways. Of course there's still plenty

[29:55] ways. Of course there's still plenty

[29:55] ways. Of course there's still plenty Of work harder in the next ten

[29:58] of course there's still plenty Of work harder in the next ten

[29:58] of course there's still plenty Of work harder in the next ten Months around housing and

[29:59] of work harder in the next ten Months around housing and

[29:59] of work harder in the next ten Months around housing and Making this a safer community

[30:02] months around housing and Making this a safer community

[30:02] months around housing and Making this a safer community To get around fighting against

[30:02] making this a safer community To get around fighting against

[30:03] making this a safer community To get around fighting against The terrible policies of the

[30:05] to get around fighting against The terrible policies of the

[30:06] to get around fighting against The terrible policies of the Federal government.

[30:06] the terrible policies of the Federal government.

[30:06] the terrible policies of the Federal government. And I look forward to wrapping

[30:07] federal government. And I look forward to wrapping

[30:07] federal government. And I look forward to wrapping My term up with all of you.

[30:09] and I look forward to wrapping My term up with all of you.

[30:10] and I look forward to wrapping My term up with all of you. >> thank you dallas.

[30:10] my term up with all of you. >> thank you dallas.

[30:10] my term up with all of you. >> thank you dallas. No ire oh I'm sorry conserver

[30:20] .

[30:21] .

[30:21] . Thanks for making me teary

[30:25] . Thanks for making me teary

[30:25] . Thanks for making me teary Before going to see something I

[30:26] thanks for making me teary Before going to see something I

[30:26] thanks for making me teary Before going to see something I Don't understand the sentiments

[30:28] before going to see something I Don't understand the sentiments

[30:28] before going to see something I Don't understand the sentiments I found public service to be a

[30:29] don't understand the sentiments I found public service to be a

[30:29] don't understand the sentiments I found public service to be a Really good feel good

[30:29] I found public service to be a Really good feel good

[30:30] I found public service to be a Really good feel good Experience.

[30:32] really good feel good Experience.

[30:32] really good feel good Experience. >> no, no I'm back to my

[30:33] experience. >> no, no I'm back to my

[30:33] experience. >> no, no I'm back to my Personal life at all.

[30:36] » no, no I'm back to my Personal life at all.

[30:36] » no, no I'm back to my Personal life at all. I thank you to council member

[30:40] personal life at all. I thank you to council member

[30:41] personal life at all. I thank you to council member Denha for those comments.

[30:44] I thank you to council member Denha for those comments.

[30:44] I thank you to council member Denha for those comments. I concur with everything you

[30:45] denha for those comments. I concur with everything you

[30:45] denha for those comments. I concur with everything you Said and encourage our

[30:48] I concur with everything you Said and encourage our

[30:48] I concur with everything you Said and encourage our Community to do the same and I

[30:49] said and encourage our Community to do the same and I

[30:49] said and encourage our Community to do the same and I Just wanted to thank the chief

[30:51] community to do the same and I Just wanted to thank the chief

[30:51] community to do the same and I Just wanted to thank the chief Anderson for working to pull

[30:52] just wanted to thank the chief Anderson for working to pull

[30:52] just wanted to thank the chief Anderson for working to pull Together the town hall working

[30:55] anderson for working to pull Together the town hall working

[30:55] anderson for working to pull Together the town hall working With the denver public schools

[30:56] together the town hall working With the denver public schools

[30:56] together the town hall working With the denver public schools This friday at haisla

[30:59] with the denver public schools This friday at haisla

[30:59] with the denver public schools This friday at haisla Elementary school for that

[30:59] this friday at haisla Elementary school for that

[30:59] this friday at haisla Elementary school for that Community there was a threat

[31:00] elementary school for that Community there was a threat

[31:00] elementary school for that Community there was a threat That was that occurred last

[31:03] community there was a threat That was that occurred last

[31:03] community there was a threat That was that occurred last Friday and I know that that has

[31:04] that was that occurred last Friday and I know that that has

[31:04] that was that occurred last Friday and I know that that has Instilled a fair amount of fear

[31:07] friday and I know that that has Instilled a fair amount of fear

[31:08] friday and I know that that has Instilled a fair amount of fear And concern within the school

[31:08] instilled a fair amount of fear And concern within the school

[31:08] instilled a fair amount of fear And concern within the school Community there and I'm glad

[31:11] and concern within the school Community there and I'm glad

[31:11] and concern within the school Community there and I'm glad That we're going to have the

[31:12] community there and I'm glad That we're going to have the

[31:12] community there and I'm glad That we're going to have the Opportunity to be able to to

[31:14] that we're going to have the Opportunity to be able to to

[31:14] that we're going to have the Opportunity to be able to to Discuss sort of safety

[31:15] opportunity to be able to to Discuss sort of safety

[31:15] opportunity to be able to to Discuss sort of safety Protocols and mental health and

[31:18] discuss sort of safety Protocols and mental health and

[31:18] discuss sort of safety Protocols and mental health and And and next steps further just

[31:22] protocols and mental health and And and next steps further just

[31:22] protocols and mental health and And and next steps further just For the communication from

[31:23] and and next steps further just For the communication from

[31:23] and and next steps further just For the communication from Council

[31:29] on

[31:37] for my part just

[31:38] for my part just Very briefly following up on,

[31:40] for my part just Very briefly following up on,

[31:40] for my part just Very briefly following up on, You know, the comments of mayor

[31:41] very briefly following up on, You know, the comments of mayor

[31:41] very briefly following up on, You know, the comments of mayor Pratima denha you know that I

[31:44] you know, the comments of mayor Pratima denha you know that I

[31:44] you know, the comments of mayor Pratima denha you know that I Believe is a sentiment shared

[31:45] pratima denha you know that I Believe is a sentiment shared

[31:45] pratima denha you know that I Believe is a sentiment shared By I really everyone at this

[31:49] believe is a sentiment shared By I really everyone at this

[31:49] believe is a sentiment shared By I really everyone at this Table we live in unprecedented

[31:49] by I really everyone at this Table we live in unprecedented

[31:49] by I really everyone at this Table we live in unprecedented Times.

[31:52] table we live in unprecedented Times.

[31:52] table we live in unprecedented Times. Our federal government is

[31:53] times. Our federal government is

[31:53] times. Our federal government is Operationalizing law

[31:55] our federal government is Operationalizing law

[31:55] our federal government is Operationalizing law Enforcement against community

[31:56] operationalizing law Enforcement against community

[31:56] operationalizing law Enforcement against community Members and it is it is

[31:59] enforcement against community Members and it is it is

[31:59] enforcement against community Members and it is it is Entirely unacceptable.

[32:00] members and it is it is Entirely unacceptable.

[32:00] members and it is it is Entirely unacceptable. We as a municipal organization

[32:04] entirely unacceptable. We as a municipal organization

[32:04] entirely unacceptable. We as a municipal organization Have taken steps with in our

[32:08] we as a municipal organization Have taken steps with in our

[32:08] we as a municipal organization Have taken steps with in our Own sphere of control already

[32:11] have taken steps with in our Own sphere of control already

[32:11] have taken steps with in our Own sphere of control already In 2017 to make clear where we

[32:15] own sphere of control already In 2017 to make clear where we

[32:15] own sphere of control already In 2017 to make clear where we Will you know, that we will act

[32:16] in 2017 to make clear where we Will you know, that we will act

[32:16] in 2017 to make clear where we Will you know, that we will act In accordance with law and that

[32:19] will you know, that we will act In accordance with law and that

[32:20] will you know, that we will act In accordance with law and that We will not voluntarily

[32:20] in accordance with law and that We will not voluntarily

[32:20] in accordance with law and that We will not voluntarily Cooperate as as the federal

[32:23] we will not voluntarily Cooperate as as the federal

[32:24] we will not voluntarily Cooperate as as the federal Government is operationalized

[32:24] cooperate as as the federal Government is operationalized

[32:24] cooperate as as the federal Government is operationalized Weaponized against members

[32:25] government is operationalized Weaponized against members

[32:25] government is operationalized Weaponized against members Of the community.

[32:26] weaponized against members Of the community.

[32:26] weaponized against members Of the community. We also know that we are

[32:27] of the community. We also know that we are

[32:27] of the community. We also know that we are Receiving communication from

[32:30] we also know that we are Receiving communication from

[32:30] we also know that we are Receiving communication from From many community members who

[32:31] receiving communication from From many community members who

[32:31] receiving communication from From many community members who Ask us to reflect upon what

[32:34] from many community members who Ask us to reflect upon what

[32:34] from many community members who Ask us to reflect upon what We've what we start and see if

[32:35] ask us to reflect upon what We've what we start and see if

[32:35] ask us to reflect upon what We've what we start and see if We can do more and that's

[32:36] we've what we start and see if We can do more and that's

[32:36] we've what we start and see if We can do more and that's Exactly what we're doing.

[32:39] we can do more and that's Exactly what we're doing.

[32:39] we can do more and that's Exactly what we're doing. It is a process that requires

[32:40] exactly what we're doing. It is a process that requires

[32:40] exactly what we're doing. It is a process that requires Deliberation.

[32:40] it is a process that requires Deliberation.

[32:40] it is a process that requires Deliberation. Council members many of us are

[32:43] deliberation. Council members many of us are

[32:43] deliberation. Council members many of us are Working on this carefully and

[32:43] council members many of us are Working on this carefully and

[32:44] council members many of us are Working on this carefully and You'll hear more about that

[32:46] working on this carefully and You'll hear more about that

[32:46] working on this carefully and You'll hear more about that Later.

[32:46] you'll hear more about that Later.

[32:47] you'll hear more about that Later. But I just wanted to let

[32:47] later. But I just wanted to let

[32:48] later. But I just wanted to let Members of the public know that

[32:49] but I just wanted to let Members of the public know that

[32:49] but I just wanted to let Members of the public know that That we hear you and that we we

[32:53] members of the public know that That we hear you and that we we

[32:53] members of the public know that That we hear you and that we we Will respond and we'll respond

[32:54] that we hear you and that we we Will respond and we'll respond

[32:54] that we hear you and that we we Will respond and we'll respond In a way that I believe

[32:57] will respond and we'll respond In a way that I believe

[32:57] will respond and we'll respond In a way that I believe Reflects, you know, our

[33:01] in a way that I believe Reflects, you know, our

[33:01] in a way that I believe Reflects, you know, our Honoring of the rule of law and

[33:02] reflects, you know, our Honoring of the rule of law and

[33:02] reflects, you know, our Honoring of the rule of law and Our honoring of the great

[33:04] honoring of the rule of law and Our honoring of the great

[33:04] honoring of the rule of law and Our honoring of the great Crucial values at stake.

[33:08] our honoring of the great Crucial values at stake.

[33:08] our honoring of the great Crucial values at stake. I like to read comfrey request

[33:09] crucial values at stake. I like to read comfrey request

[33:09] crucial values at stake. I like to read comfrey request Confirmation of the following

[33:11] I like to read comfrey request Confirmation of the following

[33:11] I like to read comfrey request Confirmation of the following Statement that were presented

[33:12] confirmation of the following Statement that were presented

[33:12] confirmation of the following Statement that were presented At this to the city council on

[33:13] statement that were presented At this to the city council on

[33:13] statement that were presented At this to the city council on January five twenty twenty six

[33:15] at this to the city council on January five twenty twenty six

[33:15] at this to the city council on January five twenty twenty six To the board of review

[33:16] january five twenty twenty six To the board of review

[33:16] january five twenty twenty six To the board of review Elizabeth martin can have a

[33:17] to the board of review Elizabeth martin can have a

[33:17] to the board of review Elizabeth martin can have a Motion please move by council

[33:19] elizabeth martin can have a Motion please move by council

[33:20] elizabeth martin can have a Motion please move by council Member.

[33:20] motion please move by council Member.

[33:20] motion please move by council Member. They're seconded by council

[33:21] member. They're seconded by council

[33:21] member. They're seconded by council Member malik discussion please

[33:26] they're seconded by council Member malik discussion please

[33:26] they're seconded by council Member malik discussion please On favorite post is approved

[33:36] we

[33:37] we

[33:37] we Now have the force the consent

[33:38] we Now have the force the consent

[33:38] we Now have the force the consent Agenda may have a motion please

[33:38] now have the force the consent Agenda may have a motion please

[33:38] now have the force the consent Agenda may have a motion please To approve the consent agenda

[33:40] agenda may have a motion please To approve the consent agenda

[33:41] agenda may have a motion please To approve the consent agenda Move by council member decision

[33:41] to approve the consent agenda Move by council member decision

[33:41] to approve the consent agenda Move by council member decision By councilor garcia had one

[33:42] move by council member decision By councilor garcia had one

[33:42] move by council member decision By councilor garcia had one Discussion of the consent

[33:45] by councilor garcia had one Discussion of the consent

[33:45] by councilor garcia had one Discussion of the consent Agenda council member brigs.

[33:49] discussion of the consent Agenda council member brigs.

[33:49] discussion of the consent Agenda council member brigs. I wanted to make a comment on c

[33:53] agenda council member brigs. I wanted to make a comment on c

[33:53] agenda council member brigs. I wanted to make a comment on c Four and c eight unless anybody

[33:57] I wanted to make a comment on c Four and c eight unless anybody

[33:57] I wanted to make a comment on c Four and c eight unless anybody Was planning to pull either

[33:58] four and c eight unless anybody Was planning to pull either

[33:58] four and c eight unless anybody Was planning to pull either Of them so I'll just make a

[34:00] was planning to pull either Of them so I'll just make a

[34:00] was planning to pull either Of them so I'll just make a Comment on it at this point I

[34:04] of them so I'll just make a Comment on it at this point I

[34:04] of them so I'll just make a Comment on it at this point I Just wanted to share my

[34:05] comment on it at this point I Just wanted to share my

[34:05] comment on it at this point I Just wanted to share my Gratitude for city

[34:08] just wanted to share my Gratitude for city

[34:08] just wanted to share my Gratitude for city Administrator and city staff

[34:08] gratitude for city Administrator and city staff

[34:08] gratitude for city Administrator and city staff For bringing forward a

[34:09] administrator and city staff For bringing forward a

[34:09] administrator and city staff For bringing forward a Recommendation to add two full

[34:10] for bringing forward a Recommendation to add two full

[34:10] for bringing forward a Recommendation to add two full Time employees to the

[34:12] recommendation to add two full Time employees to the

[34:12] recommendation to add two full Time employees to the Transportation unit.

[34:12] time employees to the Transportation unit.

[34:12] time employees to the Transportation unit. I think this is going to be a

[34:13] transportation unit. I think this is going to be a

[34:13] transportation unit. I think this is going to be a Wonderful addition.

[34:15] I think this is going to be a Wonderful addition.

[34:15] I think this is going to be a Wonderful addition. They are an overly taxed unit

[34:16] wonderful addition. They are an overly taxed unit

[34:16] wonderful addition. They are an overly taxed unit And they've had a lot on their

[34:19] they are an overly taxed unit And they've had a lot on their

[34:19] they are an overly taxed unit And they've had a lot on their Plate and I think this will

[34:20] and they've had a lot on their Plate and I think this will

[34:20] and they've had a lot on their Plate and I think this will Allow some of our engineers to

[34:23] plate and I think this will Allow some of our engineers to

[34:23] plate and I think this will Allow some of our engineers to Be able to devote more of their

[34:24] allow some of our engineers to Be able to devote more of their

[34:24] allow some of our engineers to Be able to devote more of their Time to to higher priorities on

[34:26] be able to devote more of their Time to to higher priorities on

[34:26] be able to devote more of their Time to to higher priorities on Their list and have folks or

[34:32] time to to higher priorities on Their list and have folks or

[34:33] time to to higher priorities on Their list and have folks or More you know, folks focused on

[34:33] their list and have folks or More you know, folks focused on

[34:34] their list and have folks or More you know, folks focused on Signs and signals where we

[34:36] more you know, folks focused on Signs and signals where we

[34:36] more you know, folks focused on Signs and signals where we Would need additional attention

[34:37] signs and signals where we Would need additional attention

[34:37] signs and signals where we Would need additional attention As well.

[34:37] would need additional attention As well.

[34:37] would need additional attention As well. >> so thank you further

[34:40] as well. >> so thank you further

[34:40] as well. >> so thank you further Discussion on the consent

[34:40] » so thank you further Discussion on the consent

[34:41] » so thank you further Discussion on the consent Agenda, councilor malik, this

[34:43] discussion on the consent Agenda, councilor malik, this

[34:43] discussion on the consent Agenda, councilor malik, this I'd first like to express my

[34:44] agenda, councilor malik, this I'd first like to express my

[34:45] agenda, councilor malik, this I'd first like to express my Excitement about a fourteen a

[34:48] I'd first like to express my Excitement about a fourteen a

[34:48] I'd first like to express my Excitement about a fourteen a Resolution to approve an

[34:52] excitement about a fourteen a Resolution to approve an

[34:52] excitement about a fourteen a Resolution to approve an Agreement for additional

[34:52] resolution to approve an Agreement for additional

[34:52] resolution to approve an Agreement for additional Household electronics, take

[34:53] agreement for additional Household electronics, take

[34:53] agreement for additional Household electronics, take Back events.

[34:55] household electronics, take Back events.

[34:55] household electronics, take Back events. >> I fielded numerous inquiries

[34:56] back events. >> I fielded numerous inquiries

[34:56] back events. >> I fielded numerous inquiries From residents interested in

[35:00] » I fielded numerous inquiries From residents interested in

[35:00] » I fielded numerous inquiries From residents interested in Past events, take back events

[35:00] from residents interested in Past events, take back events

[35:01] from residents interested in Past events, take back events But for a variety of reasons

[35:03] past events, take back events But for a variety of reasons

[35:04] past events, take back events But for a variety of reasons Whether the events are full or

[35:04] but for a variety of reasons Whether the events are full or

[35:05] but for a variety of reasons Whether the events are full or Scheduling conflicts they

[35:05] whether the events are full or Scheduling conflicts they

[35:05] whether the events are full or Scheduling conflicts they Haven't been able to attend.

[35:08] scheduling conflicts they Haven't been able to attend.

[35:08] scheduling conflicts they Haven't been able to attend. So I'm excited to support this

[35:09] haven't been able to attend. So I'm excited to support this

[35:09] haven't been able to attend. So I'm excited to support this Item for more take back events

[35:09] so I'm excited to support this Item for more take back events

[35:10] so I'm excited to support this Item for more take back events In the future at increased

[35:12] item for more take back events In the future at increased

[35:12] item for more take back events In the future at increased Frequencies and I would also

[35:13] in the future at increased Frequencies and I would also

[35:13] in the future at increased Frequencies and I would also Like to pull k4 for discussion

[35:15] frequencies and I would also Like to pull k4 for discussion

[35:16] frequencies and I would also Like to pull k4 for discussion Like councilor redish.

[35:23] like to pull k4 for discussion Like councilor redish.

[35:23] like to pull k4 for discussion Like councilor redish. >> I just wanted to express my

[35:24] like councilor redish. >> I just wanted to express my

[35:24] like councilor redish. >> I just wanted to express my Enthusiasm about 16 which is

[35:26] » I just wanted to express my Enthusiasm about 16 which is

[35:26] » I just wanted to express my Enthusiasm about 16 which is The grant agreement between the

[35:30] enthusiasm about 16 which is The grant agreement between the

[35:30] enthusiasm about 16 which is The grant agreement between the Office of sustainability and

[35:31] the grant agreement between the Office of sustainability and

[35:31] the grant agreement between the Office of sustainability and Innovation and the ann arbor

[35:31] office of sustainability and Innovation and the ann arbor

[35:31] office of sustainability and Innovation and the ann arbor Housing commission.

[35:34] innovation and the ann arbor Housing commission.

[35:34] innovation and the ann arbor Housing commission. It's an agreement that allows

[35:35] housing commission. It's an agreement that allows

[35:35] housing commission. It's an agreement that allows Us to support sustainable and

[35:38] it's an agreement that allows Us to support sustainable and

[35:39] it's an agreement that allows Us to support sustainable and Affordable housing at three

[35:42] us to support sustainable and Affordable housing at three

[35:43] us to support sustainable and Affordable housing at three Hundred and fifty s fifth in

[35:43] affordable housing at three Hundred and fifty s fifth in

[35:43] affordable housing at three Hundred and fifty s fifth in The amount of a million dollars

[35:46] hundred and fifty s fifth in The amount of a million dollars

[35:46] hundred and fifty s fifth in The amount of a million dollars And I am excited to see one

[35:47] the amount of a million dollars And I am excited to see one

[35:47] the amount of a million dollars And I am excited to see one More instance in the ongoing

[35:50] and I am excited to see one More instance in the ongoing

[35:50] and I am excited to see one More instance in the ongoing Collaboration between these two

[35:51] more instance in the ongoing Collaboration between these two

[35:51] more instance in the ongoing Collaboration between these two Units they lead the city's work

[35:54] collaboration between these two Units they lead the city's work

[35:54] collaboration between these two Units they lead the city's work Towards decarbonization and the

[35:55] units they lead the city's work Towards decarbonization and the

[35:55] units they lead the city's work Towards decarbonization and the Creation of income eligible

[35:55] towards decarbonization and the Creation of income eligible

[35:56] towards decarbonization and the Creation of income eligible Affordable housing.

[35:58] creation of income eligible Affordable housing.

[35:58] creation of income eligible Affordable housing. Those are two strong priorities

[36:02] affordable housing. Those are two strong priorities

[36:02] affordable housing. Those are two strong priorities Of our residents and this

[36:02] those are two strong priorities Of our residents and this

[36:03] those are two strong priorities Of our residents and this Council every member of which

[36:06] of our residents and this Council every member of which

[36:06] of our residents and this Council every member of which Loves ann arbor I'd like to say

[36:07] council every member of which Loves ann arbor I'd like to say

[36:07] council every member of which Loves ann arbor I'd like to say And I want to note that these

[36:10] loves ann arbor I'd like to say And I want to note that these

[36:10] loves ann arbor I'd like to say And I want to note that these Two units have been

[36:10] and I want to note that these Two units have been

[36:10] and I want to note that these Two units have been Collaborating since the

[36:11] two units have been Collaborating since the

[36:11] two units have been Collaborating since the Inception of the isi in twenty

[36:14] collaborating since the Inception of the isi in twenty

[36:14] collaborating since the Inception of the isi in twenty Eighteen they've co-written

[36:14] inception of the isi in twenty Eighteen they've co-written

[36:14] inception of the isi in twenty Eighteen they've co-written Grants supported each other in

[36:18] eighteen they've co-written Grants supported each other in

[36:18] eighteen they've co-written Grants supported each other in Design work and technical

[36:19] grants supported each other in Design work and technical

[36:19] grants supported each other in Design work and technical Analysis and community

[36:19] design work and technical Analysis and community

[36:20] design work and technical Analysis and community Engagement and on several

[36:22] analysis and community Engagement and on several

[36:22] analysis and community Engagement and on several Occasions shared funding for

[36:23] engagement and on several Occasions shared funding for

[36:23] engagement and on several Occasions shared funding for Affordable projects.

[36:25] occasions shared funding for Affordable projects.

[36:25] occasions shared funding for Affordable projects. And this is just a great way

[36:26] affordable projects. And this is just a great way

[36:26] affordable projects. And this is just a great way For city units to work together

[36:29] and this is just a great way For city units to work together

[36:30] and this is just a great way For city units to work together And I'm thrilled to see this

[36:30] for city units to work together And I'm thrilled to see this

[36:30] for city units to work together And I'm thrilled to see this Further discussion.

[36:34] and I'm thrilled to see this Further discussion.

[36:34] and I'm thrilled to see this Further discussion. >> councilor ackmann, I'd like

[36:37] further discussion. >> councilor ackmann, I'd like

[36:37] further discussion. >> councilor ackmann, I'd like To draw people's attention to

[36:38] » councilor ackmann, I'd like To draw people's attention to

[36:38] » councilor ackmann, I'd like To draw people's attention to See a seventeen this relates to

[36:41] to draw people's attention to See a seventeen this relates to

[36:41] to draw people's attention to See a seventeen this relates to Council member we're going to

[36:42] see a seventeen this relates to Council member we're going to

[36:42] see a seventeen this relates to Council member we're going to That's going to be pulled.

[36:43] council member we're going to That's going to be pulled.

[36:43] council member we're going to That's going to be pulled. >> oh it is.

[36:43] that's going to be pulled. >> oh it is.

[36:43] that's going to be pulled. >> oh it is. I didn't hear that.

[36:44] » oh it is. I didn't hear that.

[36:44] » oh it is. I didn't hear that. Sorry.

[36:45] I didn't hear that. Sorry.

[36:46] I didn't hear that. Sorry. That's all right.

[36:46] sorry. That's all right.

[36:46] sorry. That's all right. Now can you pull it?

[36:50] that's all right. Now can you pull it?

[36:50] that's all right. Now can you pull it? >> sorry I'd like to pull

[36:51] now can you pull it? >> sorry I'd like to pull

[36:51] now can you pull it? >> sorry I'd like to pull Seventeen.

[36:53] » sorry I'd like to pull Seventeen.

[36:53] » sorry I'd like to pull Seventeen. >> awesome.

[36:54] seventeen. >> awesome.

[36:54] seventeen. >> awesome. You're the best.

[36:54] » awesome. You're the best.

[36:54] » awesome. You're the best. Thank you.

[37:00] you're the best. Thank you.

[37:00] you're the best. Thank you. >> sorry for the discussion.

[37:01] thank you. >> sorry for the discussion.

[37:01] thank you. >> sorry for the discussion. The concept of gender all in

[37:05] » sorry for the discussion. The concept of gender all in

[37:05] » sorry for the discussion. The concept of gender all in Favor of the concept the gender

[37:05] the concept of gender all in Favor of the concept the gender

[37:05] the concept of gender all in Favor of the concept the gender With the exception see a force

[37:06] favor of the concept the gender With the exception see a force

[37:06] favor of the concept the gender With the exception see a force Here seventeen opposed we can

[37:09] with the exception see a force Here seventeen opposed we can

[37:09] with the exception see a force Here seventeen opposed we can Set the gender with the

[37:09] here seventeen opposed we can Set the gender with the

[37:09] here seventeen opposed we can Set the gender with the Exception we see a four and say

[37:13] set the gender with the Exception we see a four and say

[37:13] set the gender with the Exception we see a four and say Seventeen is approved with ten

[37:14] exception we see a four and say Seventeen is approved with ten

[37:14] exception we see a four and say Seventeen is approved with ten Council members present all

[37:15] seventeen is approved with ten Council members present all

[37:15] seventeen is approved with ten Council members present all Vote in the

[37:34] affirmative thus

[37:34] affirmative thus Satisfying the eight vote

[37:35] affirmative thus Satisfying the eight vote

[37:35] affirmative thus Satisfying the eight vote Requirement with respect to

[37:35] satisfying the eight vote Requirement with respect to

[37:35] satisfying the eight vote Requirement with respect to Eight eight a twelve thirteen

[37:36] requirement with respect to Eight eight a twelve thirteen

[37:36] requirement with respect to Eight eight a twelve thirteen Fourteen fifteen and see a

[37:37] eight eight a twelve thirteen Fourteen fifteen and see a

[37:37] eight eight a twelve thirteen Fourteen fifteen and see a Sixteen s.a four resolution to

[37:38] fourteen fifteen and see a Sixteen s.a four resolution to

[37:38] fourteen fifteen and see a Sixteen s.a four resolution to Prohibit on street parking on

[37:39] sixteen s.a four resolution to Prohibit on street parking on

[37:39] sixteen s.a four resolution to Prohibit on street parking on The north side of catherine

[37:40] prohibit on street parking on The north side of catherine

[37:40] prohibit on street parking on The north side of catherine Street from north division

[37:40] the north side of catherine Street from north division

[37:41] the north side of catherine Street from north division Street to north engl street

[37:41] street from north division Street to north engl street

[37:41] street from north division Street to north engl street Move by council member malik

[37:42] street to north engl street Move by council member malik

[37:42] street to north engl street Move by council member malik Seconded by council member for

[37:43] move by council member malik Seconded by council member for

[37:43] move by council member malik Seconded by council member for Denha discussion please of k

[37:43] seconded by council member for Denha discussion please of k

[37:43] seconded by council member for Denha discussion please of k For council member malik.

[37:44] denha discussion please of k For council member malik.

[37:44] denha discussion please of k For council member malik. Thank you mayor.

[37:45] for council member malik. Thank you mayor.

[37:45] for council member malik. Thank you mayor. So tonight's resolution c four

[37:45] thank you mayor. So tonight's resolution c four

[37:45] thank you mayor. So tonight's resolution c four Is about prohibiting on street

[37:46] so tonight's resolution c four Is about prohibiting on street

[37:46] so tonight's resolution c four Is about prohibiting on street Parking on catherine street

[37:47] is about prohibiting on street Parking on catherine street

[37:47] is about prohibiting on street Parking on catherine street Between north division street

[37:50] parking on catherine street Between north division street

[37:50] parking on catherine street Between north division street And north engl street in

[37:53] between north division street And north engl street in

[37:53] between north division street And north engl street in Advance of a proposed protected

[37:54] and north engl street in Advance of a proposed protected

[37:54] and north engl street in Advance of a proposed protected Bike lane project this stretch

[37:58] advance of a proposed protected Bike lane project this stretch

[37:58] advance of a proposed protected Bike lane project this stretch Of catherine street is

[37:58] bike lane project this stretch Of catherine street is

[37:58] bike lane project this stretch Of catherine street is Currently a one way quiet

[38:01] of catherine street is Currently a one way quiet

[38:01] of catherine street is Currently a one way quiet Residential street that already

[38:02] currently a one way quiet Residential street that already

[38:02] currently a one way quiet Residential street that already Includes a conventional bike

[38:03] residential street that already Includes a conventional bike

[38:03] residential street that already Includes a conventional bike Lane with painted lines and

[38:06] includes a conventional bike Lane with painted lines and

[38:06] includes a conventional bike Lane with painted lines and This is also a dense housing

[38:07] lane with painted lines and This is also a dense housing

[38:07] lane with painted lines and This is also a dense housing Area that has few alternatives

[38:10] this is also a dense housing Area that has few alternatives

[38:10] this is also a dense housing Area that has few alternatives To parking on the street as

[38:11] area that has few alternatives To parking on the street as

[38:11] area that has few alternatives To parking on the street as Evidenced by the nearly thirty

[38:13] to parking on the street as Evidenced by the nearly thirty

[38:13] to parking on the street as Evidenced by the nearly thirty Four parking spots up for

[38:14] evidenced by the nearly thirty Four parking spots up for

[38:14] evidenced by the nearly thirty Four parking spots up for Elimination tonight being used

[38:17] four parking spots up for Elimination tonight being used

[38:17] four parking spots up for Elimination tonight being used More often than not because

[38:17] elimination tonight being used More often than not because

[38:18] elimination tonight being used More often than not because Of these reasons I do not

[38:21] more often than not because Of these reasons I do not

[38:21] more often than not because Of these reasons I do not Believe this location to be an

[38:22] of these reasons I do not Believe this location to be an

[38:22] of these reasons I do not Believe this location to be an Appropriate use of time or

[38:24] believe this location to be an Appropriate use of time or

[38:24] believe this location to be an Appropriate use of time or Reserves resources for such a

[38:24] appropriate use of time or Reserves resources for such a

[38:24] appropriate use of time or Reserves resources for such a Project whether they be quick

[38:25] reserves resources for such a Project whether they be quick

[38:25] reserves resources for such a Project whether they be quick Build or conventional and will

[38:28] project whether they be quick Build or conventional and will

[38:28] project whether they be quick Build or conventional and will Therefore be voting no on this

[38:29] build or conventional and will Therefore be voting no on this

[38:29] build or conventional and will Therefore be voting no on this Item tonight further discussion

[38:32] therefore be voting no on this Item tonight further discussion

[38:32] therefore be voting no on this Item tonight further discussion Of cifor for council member

[38:36] item tonight further discussion Of cifor for council member

[38:36] item tonight further discussion Of cifor for council member Watson.

[38:39] of cifor for council member Watson.

[38:39] of cifor for council member Watson. This resolution is necessary

[38:44] watson. This resolution is necessary

[38:44] watson. This resolution is necessary Because of the use of the

[38:45] this resolution is necessary Because of the use of the

[38:45] this resolution is necessary Because of the use of the Council allocated budget budget

[38:47] because of the use of the Council allocated budget budget

[38:47] because of the use of the Council allocated budget budget Amendment provision zero

[38:47] council allocated budget budget Amendment provision zero

[38:48] council allocated budget budget Amendment provision zero Funding.

[38:48] amendment provision zero Funding.

[38:48] amendment provision zero Funding. >> I understand staff's

[38:51] funding. >> I understand staff's

[38:51] funding. >> I understand staff's Reasoning behind the shovel

[38:51] » I understand staff's Reasoning behind the shovel

[38:51] » I understand staff's Reasoning behind the shovel Ready proposal and the

[38:52] reasoning behind the shovel Ready proposal and the

[38:52] reasoning behind the shovel Ready proposal and the Importance by connectivity to

[38:55] ready proposal and the Importance by connectivity to

[38:55] ready proposal and the Importance by connectivity to The hospital.

[38:55] importance by connectivity to The hospital.

[38:56] importance by connectivity to The hospital. >> so I'd like to be clear that

[38:57] the hospital. >> so I'd like to be clear that

[38:57] the hospital. >> so I'd like to be clear that The reason I won't be

[38:59] » so I'd like to be clear that The reason I won't be

[38:59] » so I'd like to be clear that The reason I won't be Supporting this resolution is

[39:00] the reason I won't be Supporting this resolution is

[39:00] the reason I won't be Supporting this resolution is That I would like to see the

[39:01] supporting this resolution is That I would like to see the

[39:01] supporting this resolution is That I would like to see the Vision zero amendment money

[39:02] that I would like to see the Vision zero amendment money

[39:02] that I would like to see the Vision zero amendment money Spread among a few vision zero

[39:03] vision zero amendment money Spread among a few vision zero

[39:03] vision zero amendment money Spread among a few vision zero Projects rather than only one

[39:06] spread among a few vision zero Projects rather than only one

[39:06] spread among a few vision zero Projects rather than only one In ward two alone.

[39:06] projects rather than only one In ward two alone.

[39:07] projects rather than only one In ward two alone. I have had constituents reach

[39:07] in ward two alone. I have had constituents reach

[39:07] in ward two alone. I have had constituents reach Out about pedestrian crossings

[39:10] I have had constituents reach Out about pedestrian crossings

[39:10] I have had constituents reach Out about pedestrian crossings On plymouth road and the

[39:11] out about pedestrian crossings On plymouth road and the

[39:11] out about pedestrian crossings On plymouth road and the Glazier a green intersection

[39:13] on plymouth road and the Glazier a green intersection

[39:14] on plymouth road and the Glazier a green intersection Where we have seen multiple

[39:14] glazier a green intersection Where we have seen multiple

[39:14] glazier a green intersection Where we have seen multiple Serious pedestrian vehicle

[39:15] where we have seen multiple Serious pedestrian vehicle

[39:15] where we have seen multiple Serious pedestrian vehicle Accidents during my tenure on

[39:16] serious pedestrian vehicle Accidents during my tenure on

[39:16] serious pedestrian vehicle Accidents during my tenure on Council there are many similar

[39:18] accidents during my tenure on Council there are many similar

[39:18] accidents during my tenure on Council there are many similar Locations across the city so

[39:19] council there are many similar Locations across the city so

[39:19] council there are many similar Locations across the city so Even if the allocated 500000

[39:22] locations across the city so Even if the allocated 500000

[39:22] locations across the city so Even if the allocated 500000 Couldn't be used for these

[39:22] even if the allocated 500000 Couldn't be used for these

[39:23] even if the allocated 500000 Couldn't be used for these Specific areas I just mentioned

[39:25] couldn't be used for these Specific areas I just mentioned

[39:25] couldn't be used for these Specific areas I just mentioned I would still support using the

[39:26] specific areas I just mentioned I would still support using the

[39:26] specific areas I just mentioned I would still support using the Funds from multiple locations

[39:26] I would still support using the Funds from multiple locations

[39:27] I would still support using the Funds from multiple locations In the city rather than than

[39:29] funds from multiple locations In the city rather than than

[39:29] funds from multiple locations In the city rather than than This one bikeway.

[39:30] in the city rather than than This one bikeway.

[39:30] in the city rather than than This one bikeway. For this reason I will join my

[39:33] this one bikeway. For this reason I will join my

[39:33] this one bikeway. For this reason I will join my Word two colleagues in voting

[39:34] for this reason I will join my Word two colleagues in voting

[39:34] for this reason I will join my Word two colleagues in voting No on this item in hopes that

[39:35] word two colleagues in voting No on this item in hopes that

[39:35] word two colleagues in voting No on this item in hopes that The funding can be used for

[39:37] no on this item in hopes that The funding can be used for

[39:38] no on this item in hopes that The funding can be used for Other projects supporting our

[39:38] the funding can be used for Other projects supporting our

[39:38] the funding can be used for Other projects supporting our Vision zero pedestrian and non

[39:39] other projects supporting our Vision zero pedestrian and non

[39:39] other projects supporting our Vision zero pedestrian and non Motorized infrastructure

[39:41] vision zero pedestrian and non Motorized infrastructure

[39:41] vision zero pedestrian and non Motorized infrastructure Improvements further discussion

[39:42] motorized infrastructure Improvements further discussion

[39:42] motorized infrastructure Improvements further discussion Council member breaks thanks.

[39:47] improvements further discussion Council member breaks thanks.

[39:47] improvements further discussion Council member breaks thanks. >> I was hoping that this this

[39:51] council member breaks thanks. >> I was hoping that this this

[39:51] council member breaks thanks. >> I was hoping that this this Is not what I was going to ask

[39:52] » I was hoping that this this Is not what I was going to ask

[39:52] » I was hoping that this this Is not what I was going to ask But given comments I was if

[39:55] is not what I was going to ask But given comments I was if

[39:55] is not what I was going to ask But given comments I was if Staff might be present to be

[39:56] but given comments I was if Staff might be present to be

[39:56] but given comments I was if Staff might be present to be Able to speak a little bit to

[39:57] staff might be present to be Able to speak a little bit to

[39:57] staff might be present to be Able to speak a little bit to This project and how this rose

[39:58] able to speak a little bit to This project and how this rose

[39:58] able to speak a little bit to This project and how this rose In the ranking and we received

[40:02] this project and how this rose In the ranking and we received

[40:02] this project and how this rose In the ranking and we received Some communications around that

[40:03] in the ranking and we received Some communications around that

[40:03] in the ranking and we received Some communications around that But that would be helpful.

[40:06] some communications around that But that would be helpful.

[40:06] some communications around that But that would be helpful. >> we have staff members on zom

[40:14] .

[40:14] . >> yeah and specifically if you

[40:15] . >> yeah and specifically if you

[40:15] . >> yeah and specifically if you Could talk about the

[40:15] » yeah and specifically if you Could talk about the

[40:16] » yeah and specifically if you Could talk about the Prioritization and in the

[40:18] could talk about the Prioritization and in the

[40:18] could talk about the Prioritization and in the Downtown dda circulation study

[40:19] prioritization and in the Downtown dda circulation study

[40:19] prioritization and in the Downtown dda circulation study And some of those other

[40:21] downtown dda circulation study And some of those other

[40:22] downtown dda circulation study And some of those other Elements that would be helpful

[40:25] and some of those other Elements that would be helpful

[40:25] and some of those other Elements that would be helpful .

[40:25] elements that would be helpful .

[40:25] elements that would be helpful . Oh yes.

[40:26] . Oh yes.

[40:26] . Oh yes. So as I remember brigs not adam

[40:29] oh yes. So as I remember brigs not adam

[40:29] oh yes. So as I remember brigs not adam A few items that relate to the

[40:30] so as I remember brigs not adam A few items that relate to the

[40:30] so as I remember brigs not adam A few items that relate to the Privatization of this project I

[40:35] a few items that relate to the Privatization of this project I

[40:35] a few items that relate to the Privatization of this project I One frankly pretty important

[40:36] privatization of this project I One frankly pretty important

[40:36] privatization of this project I One frankly pretty important One is I think as was noted

[40:39] one frankly pretty important One is I think as was noted

[40:39] one frankly pretty important One is I think as was noted Earlier discussion is that it

[40:40] one is I think as was noted Earlier discussion is that it

[40:40] one is I think as was noted Earlier discussion is that it Is a shovel ready project.

[40:41] earlier discussion is that it Is a shovel ready project.

[40:41] earlier discussion is that it Is a shovel ready project. >> there are there are a

[40:44] is a shovel ready project. >> there are there are a

[40:44] is a shovel ready project. >> there are there are a Limited number of those that

[40:44] » there are there are a Limited number of those that

[40:44] » there are there are a Limited number of those that Also need to other goals in

[40:48] limited number of those that Also need to other goals in

[40:48] limited number of those that Also need to other goals in Terms of road shift to you

[40:51] also need to other goals in Terms of road shift to you

[40:51] also need to other goals in Terms of road shift to you Know, to bicycle pedestrian

[40:52] terms of road shift to you Know, to bicycle pedestrian

[40:52] terms of road shift to you Know, to bicycle pedestrian Transit usage and that also

[40:55] know, to bicycle pedestrian Transit usage and that also

[40:55] know, to bicycle pedestrian Transit usage and that also Promotes safety goals.

[40:55] transit usage and that also Promotes safety goals.

[40:55] transit usage and that also Promotes safety goals. So so that kind of the

[41:02] promotes safety goals. So so that kind of the

[41:02] promotes safety goals. So so that kind of the Prioritization focused on those

[41:03] so so that kind of the Prioritization focused on those

[41:03] so so that kind of the Prioritization focused on those Facets.

[41:06] prioritization focused on those Facets.

[41:06] prioritization focused on those Facets. Thanks know just to know that

[41:10] facets. Thanks know just to know that

[41:10] facets. Thanks know just to know that This was the top ranked

[41:11] thanks know just to know that This was the top ranked

[41:11] thanks know just to know that This was the top ranked Project, a bicycle project, the

[41:13] this was the top ranked Project, a bicycle project, the

[41:14] this was the top ranked Project, a bicycle project, the Circulation study I questions

[41:17] project, a bicycle project, the Circulation study I questions

[41:17] project, a bicycle project, the Circulation study I questions Have come up around sort of the

[41:18] circulation study I questions Have come up around sort of the

[41:18] circulation study I questions Have come up around sort of the Parking and also we've heard

[41:19] have come up around sort of the Parking and also we've heard

[41:19] have come up around sort of the Parking and also we've heard Some public comment on that.

[41:20] parking and also we've heard Some public comment on that.

[41:20] parking and also we've heard Some public comment on that. I think that that you know, we

[41:22] some public comment on that. I think that that you know, we

[41:22] some public comment on that. I think that that you know, we Heard from an important

[41:23] I think that that you know, we Heard from an important

[41:23] I think that that you know, we Heard from an important Downtown stakeholder if staff

[41:25] heard from an important Downtown stakeholder if staff

[41:26] heard from an important Downtown stakeholder if staff Might be able to talk at all

[41:29] downtown stakeholder if staff Might be able to talk at all

[41:30] downtown stakeholder if staff Might be able to talk at all About any of the conversations

[41:30] might be able to talk at all About any of the conversations

[41:30] might be able to talk at all About any of the conversations They might have had with

[41:31] about any of the conversations They might have had with

[41:31] about any of the conversations They might have had with Stakeholders or opportunities

[41:34] they might have had with Stakeholders or opportunities

[41:34] they might have had with Stakeholders or opportunities That might exist with partner

[41:37] stakeholders or opportunities That might exist with partner

[41:37] stakeholders or opportunities That might exist with partner Institutions for special

[41:38] that might exist with partner Institutions for special

[41:38] that might exist with partner Institutions for special Events, I'm thinking

[41:38] institutions for special Events, I'm thinking

[41:39] institutions for special Events, I'm thinking Particularly maybe a

[41:41] events, I'm thinking Particularly maybe a

[41:41] events, I'm thinking Particularly maybe a Partnership with our public

[41:42] particularly maybe a Partnership with our public

[41:42] particularly maybe a Partnership with our public Schools with a large parking

[41:43] partnership with our public Schools with a large parking

[41:43] partnership with our public Schools with a large parking Lot across the street that

[41:43] schools with a large parking Lot across the street that

[41:44] schools with a large parking Lot across the street that Might be able to be used on on

[41:46] lot across the street that Might be able to be used on on

[41:46] lot across the street that Might be able to be used on on Sundays and major holidays to

[41:49] might be able to be used on on Sundays and major holidays to

[41:49] might be able to be used on on Sundays and major holidays to Accommodate, you know, large

[41:50] sundays and major holidays to Accommodate, you know, large

[41:50] sundays and major holidays to Accommodate, you know, large Parking events that are that

[41:53] accommodate, you know, large Parking events that are that

[41:53] accommodate, you know, large Parking events that are that Are necessary and in times when

[41:54] parking events that are that Are necessary and in times when

[41:54] parking events that are that Are necessary and in times when Those facilities are not used

[41:56] are necessary and in times when Those facilities are not used

[41:56] are necessary and in times when Those facilities are not used And those are certainly

[42:00] those facilities are not used And those are certainly

[42:00] those facilities are not used And those are certainly Suggestions on staff have not

[42:01] and those are certainly Suggestions on staff have not

[42:01] and those are certainly Suggestions on staff have not Had extended discussions along

[42:02] suggestions on staff have not Had extended discussions along

[42:02] suggestions on staff have not Had extended discussions along Those lines but in terms of you

[42:09] had extended discussions along Those lines but in terms of you

[42:09] had extended discussions along Those lines but in terms of you Know, we're certainly open to

[42:10] those lines but in terms of you Know, we're certainly open to

[42:10] those lines but in terms of you Know, we're certainly open to Some creative problem-solving

[42:13] know, we're certainly open to Some creative problem-solving

[42:13] know, we're certainly open to Some creative problem-solving As well as the question of the

[42:17] some creative problem-solving As well as the question of the

[42:17] some creative problem-solving As well as the question of the Construction impact.

[42:20] as well as the question of the Construction impact.

[42:21] as well as the question of the Construction impact. There will be several

[42:21] construction impact. There will be several

[42:21] construction impact. There will be several Construction projects in and

[42:22] there will be several Construction projects in and

[42:22] there will be several Construction projects in and Around this area.

[42:24] construction projects in and Around this area.

[42:25] construction projects in and Around this area. This project we expect to be

[42:25] around this area. This project we expect to be

[42:26] around this area. This project we expect to be Pretty limited in terms of the

[42:29] this project we expect to be Pretty limited in terms of the

[42:29] this project we expect to be Pretty limited in terms of the Construction impact but there

[42:29] pretty limited in terms of the Construction impact but there

[42:30] pretty limited in terms of the Construction impact but there Will be capital projects to the

[42:30] construction impact but there Will be capital projects to the

[42:30] construction impact but there Will be capital projects to the East at kingery and ingles and

[42:36] will be capital projects to the East at kingery and ingles and

[42:36] will be capital projects to the East at kingery and ingles and Then also closer to the

[42:37] east at kingery and ingles and Then also closer to the

[42:37] east at kingery and ingles and Then also closer to the Hospital glen and catherine

[42:39] then also closer to the Hospital glen and catherine

[42:40] then also closer to the Hospital glen and catherine That we expect to have a or

[42:43] hospital glen and catherine That we expect to have a or

[42:44] hospital glen and catherine That we expect to have a or More localized direct impact in

[42:44] that we expect to have a or More localized direct impact in

[42:44] that we expect to have a or More localized direct impact in Those areas but will certainly

[42:48] more localized direct impact in Those areas but will certainly

[42:48] more localized direct impact in Those areas but will certainly Impact the nearby street such

[42:48] those areas but will certainly Impact the nearby street such

[42:49] those areas but will certainly Impact the nearby street such As the further extensive this

[42:51] impact the nearby street such As the further extensive this

[42:51] impact the nearby street such As the further extensive this Bike extension.

[42:52] as the further extensive this Bike extension.

[42:52] as the further extensive this Bike extension. So that being said, I don't

[42:55] bike extension. So that being said, I don't

[42:55] bike extension. So that being said, I don't Believe there would be any

[42:59] so that being said, I don't Believe there would be any

[42:59] so that being said, I don't Believe there would be any Issue with maintaining access

[43:00] believe there would be any Issue with maintaining access

[43:00] believe there would be any Issue with maintaining access To the various private parcels

[43:03] issue with maintaining access To the various private parcels

[43:03] issue with maintaining access To the various private parcels To andrew's church included the

[43:08] to the various private parcels To andrew's church included the

[43:08] to the various private parcels To andrew's church included the Discussion you just wanted to

[43:12] to andrew's church included the Discussion you just wanted to

[43:12] to andrew's church included the Discussion you just wanted to Your second go around.

[43:13] discussion you just wanted to Your second go around.

[43:13] discussion you just wanted to Your second go around. Yeah, I figured that time was

[43:16] your second go around. Yeah, I figured that time was

[43:16] your second go around. Yeah, I figured that time was Probably out with that.

[43:17] yeah, I figured that time was Probably out with that.

[43:17] yeah, I figured that time was Probably out with that. So I just wanted to also

[43:17] probably out with that. So I just wanted to also

[43:18] probably out with that. So I just wanted to also Articulate that this did go

[43:20] so I just wanted to also Articulate that this did go

[43:20] so I just wanted to also Articulate that this did go Through transportation

[43:20] articulate that this did go Through transportation

[43:21] articulate that this did go Through transportation Commission and received a

[43:21] through transportation Commission and received a

[43:21] through transportation Commission and received a Recommendation of approval from

[43:24] commission and received a Recommendation of approval from

[43:24] commission and received a Recommendation of approval from Transportation commission.

[43:24] recommendation of approval from Transportation commission.

[43:24] recommendation of approval from Transportation commission. I do recognize council member

[43:25] transportation commission. I do recognize council member

[43:25] transportation commission. I do recognize council member Malik's concerns around, you

[43:28] I do recognize council member Malik's concerns around, you

[43:28] I do recognize council member Malik's concerns around, you Know, facilities that are

[43:29] malik's concerns around, you Know, facilities that are

[43:29] malik's concerns around, you Know, facilities that are Existing there.

[43:29] know, facilities that are Existing there.

[43:29] know, facilities that are Existing there. I think what we're trying to do

[43:30] existing there. I think what we're trying to do

[43:30] existing there. I think what we're trying to do Is create a network within our

[43:32] I think what we're trying to do Is create a network within our

[43:32] I think what we're trying to do Is create a network within our Community that is connected and

[43:35] is create a network within our Community that is connected and

[43:35] is create a network within our Community that is connected and Has a higher standard of of

[43:36] community that is connected and Has a higher standard of of

[43:36] community that is connected and Has a higher standard of of Protection and that requires,

[43:40] has a higher standard of of Protection and that requires,

[43:40] has a higher standard of of Protection and that requires, You know, connectivity across

[43:43] protection and that requires, You know, connectivity across

[43:43] protection and that requires, You know, connectivity across Facilities of similar types so

[43:44] you know, connectivity across Facilities of similar types so

[43:44] you know, connectivity across Facilities of similar types so That that that it really works

[43:47] facilities of similar types so That that that it really works

[43:47] facilities of similar types so That that that it really works For folks obviously there are

[43:51] that that that it really works For folks obviously there are

[43:51] that that that it really works For folks obviously there are Tradeoffs in terms of our

[43:52] for folks obviously there are Tradeoffs in terms of our

[43:52] for folks obviously there are Tradeoffs in terms of our Public spaces and how we use

[43:52] tradeoffs in terms of our Public spaces and how we use

[43:53] tradeoffs in terms of our Public spaces and how we use Them and living in our downtown

[43:55] public spaces and how we use Them and living in our downtown

[43:55] public spaces and how we use Them and living in our downtown Is is sometimes as a challenge

[43:59] them and living in our downtown Is is sometimes as a challenge

[43:59] them and living in our downtown Is is sometimes as a challenge Further discussion will call

[44:02] is is sometimes as a challenge Further discussion will call

[44:02] is is sometimes as a challenge Further discussion will call Please starting with council

[44:03] further discussion will call Please starting with council

[44:03] further discussion will call Please starting with council Member I'm sorry councilor

[44:06] please starting with council Member I'm sorry councilor

[44:07] please starting with council Member I'm sorry councilor Denha council member denha yes

[44:14] member I'm sorry councilor Denha council member denha yes

[44:14] member I'm sorry councilor Denha council member denha yes .

[44:14] denha council member denha yes .

[44:14] denha council member denha yes . Garside 01 yes.

[44:15] . Garside 01 yes.

[44:15] . Garside 01 yes. Mayor taylor yes.

[44:18] garside 01 yes. Mayor taylor yes.

[44:18] garside 01 yes. Mayor taylor yes. Councilor er yes.

[44:19] mayor taylor yes. Councilor er yes.

[44:19] mayor taylor yes. Councilor er yes. Councilor ackmann yes.

[44:19] councilor er yes. Councilor ackmann yes.

[44:22] councilor er yes. Councilor ackmann yes. Councilor briggs yes.

[44:22] councilor ackmann yes. Councilor briggs yes.

[44:22] councilor ackmann yes. Councilor briggs yes. Councilor cornell absent

[44:26] councilor briggs yes. Councilor cornell absent

[44:26] councilor briggs yes. Councilor cornell absent Councilor dish.

[44:26] councilor cornell absent Councilor dish.

[44:26] councilor cornell absent Councilor dish. Yes cos we're harrison yes.

[44:30] councilor dish. Yes cos we're harrison yes.

[44:30] councilor dish. Yes cos we're harrison yes. Comes from our watson no

[44:31] yes cos we're harrison yes. Comes from our watson no

[44:31] yes cos we're harrison yes. Comes from our watson no Councilor malik no motion

[44:32] comes from our watson no Councilor malik no motion

[44:32] comes from our watson no Councilor malik no motion Carries see a seventeen

[44:37] councilor malik no motion Carries see a seventeen

[44:37] councilor malik no motion Carries see a seventeen Resolution to approve a

[44:40] carries see a seventeen Resolution to approve a

[44:40] carries see a seventeen Resolution to approve a Retainer agreement with waitz

[44:41] resolution to approve a Retainer agreement with waitz

[44:41] resolution to approve a Retainer agreement with waitz Luxembourg pc and the

[44:42] retainer agreement with waitz Luxembourg pc and the

[44:42] retainer agreement with waitz Luxembourg pc and the Sandburg's law firm for legal

[44:45] luxembourg pc and the Sandburg's law firm for legal

[44:45] luxembourg pc and the Sandburg's law firm for legal Services to support the city's

[44:45] sandburg's law firm for legal Services to support the city's

[44:46] sandburg's law firm for legal Services to support the city's Participation as a named

[44:48] services to support the city's Participation as a named

[44:48] services to support the city's Participation as a named Plaintiff in a class action

[44:49] participation as a named Plaintiff in a class action

[44:49] participation as a named Plaintiff in a class action Antitrust litigation regarding

[44:52] plaintiff in a class action Antitrust litigation regarding

[44:52] plaintiff in a class action Antitrust litigation regarding Fire truck pricing sort of in

[44:53] antitrust litigation regarding Fire truck pricing sort of in

[44:53] antitrust litigation regarding Fire truck pricing sort of in Our v oshkosh corporation at oh

[44:56] fire truck pricing sort of in Our v oshkosh corporation at oh

[44:56] fire truck pricing sort of in Our v oshkosh corporation at oh Move by council member ackmann

[44:57] our v oshkosh corporation at oh Move by council member ackmann

[44:57] our v oshkosh corporation at oh Move by council member ackmann Seconded by council member

[44:59] move by council member ackmann Seconded by council member

[44:59] move by council member ackmann Seconded by council member Mallik discussion please fca 17

[45:00] seconded by council member Mallik discussion please fca 17

[45:00] seconded by council member Mallik discussion please fca 17 Per prior practice for prior

[45:03] mallik discussion please fca 17 Per prior practice for prior

[45:03] mallik discussion please fca 17 Per prior practice for prior Practice.

[45:04] per prior practice for prior Practice.

[45:04] per prior practice for prior Practice. I'd like to ask counsel for

[45:07] practice. I'd like to ask counsel for

[45:07] practice. I'd like to ask counsel for Your acquiescence in my

[45:08] I'd like to ask counsel for Your acquiescence in my

[45:08] I'd like to ask counsel for Your acquiescence in my Standing down as folks know

[45:08] your acquiescence in my Standing down as folks know

[45:09] your acquiescence in my Standing down as folks know When there is a financial

[45:11] standing down as folks know When there is a financial

[45:11] standing down as folks know When there is a financial Conflict or potential financial

[45:15] when there is a financial Conflict or potential financial

[45:15] when there is a financial Conflict or potential financial Conflict the council rules and

[45:16] conflict or potential financial Conflict the council rules and

[45:16] conflict or potential financial Conflict the council rules and Permit a recusal.

[45:19] conflict the council rules and Permit a recusal.

[45:19] conflict the council rules and Permit a recusal. It is one of the limited cases

[45:20] permit a recusal. It is one of the limited cases

[45:20] permit a recusal. It is one of the limited cases In which a recusal is

[45:21] it is one of the limited cases In which a recusal is

[45:21] it is one of the limited cases In which a recusal is Permitted.

[45:21] in which a recusal is Permitted.

[45:21] in which a recusal is Permitted. I am an sam bernstein law firm

[45:23] permitted. I am an sam bernstein law firm

[45:23] permitted. I am an sam bernstein law firm Is for me an occasional client

[45:26] I am an sam bernstein law firm Is for me an occasional client

[45:26] I am an sam bernstein law firm Is for me an occasional client And so request counsel's

[45:27] is for me an occasional client And so request counsel's

[45:27] is for me an occasional client And so request counsel's Acquiescence in my standing

[45:28] and so request counsel's Acquiescence in my standing

[45:28] and so request counsel's Acquiescence in my standing Down move by counsel member

[45:31] acquiescence in my standing Down move by counsel member

[45:31] acquiescence in my standing Down move by counsel member Actions taken by counsel member

[45:31] down move by counsel member Actions taken by counsel member

[45:31] down move by counsel member Actions taken by counsel member Brigg's discussion on favor

[45:34] actions taken by counsel member Brigg's discussion on favor

[45:34] actions taken by counsel member Brigg's discussion on favor Posed I'm out

[45:45] with that.

[45:45] with that. >> is there continued

[45:46] with that. >> is there continued

[45:46] with that. >> is there continued Discussion of 617 council

[45:48] » is there continued Discussion of 617 council

[45:48] » is there continued Discussion of 617 council Member?

[45:49] discussion of 617 council Member?

[45:49] discussion of 617 council Member? >> yeah I was wanting to make

[45:52] member? >> yeah I was wanting to make

[45:52] member? >> yeah I was wanting to make Comment on it before I knew

[45:53] » yeah I was wanting to make Comment on it before I knew

[45:53] » yeah I was wanting to make Comment on it before I knew That the mayor needed to recuse

[45:54] comment on it before I knew That the mayor needed to recuse

[45:54] comment on it before I knew That the mayor needed to recuse Himself.

[45:56] that the mayor needed to recuse Himself.

[45:56] that the mayor needed to recuse Himself. So this relates to ann arbor

[45:57] himself. So this relates to ann arbor

[45:57] himself. So this relates to ann arbor Participate as a plaintiff in a

[46:01] so this relates to ann arbor Participate as a plaintiff in a

[46:01] so this relates to ann arbor Participate as a plaintiff in a Class action antitrust lawsuit

[46:02] participate as a plaintiff in a Class action antitrust lawsuit

[46:02] participate as a plaintiff in a Class action antitrust lawsuit Related to fire truck pricing

[46:04] class action antitrust lawsuit Related to fire truck pricing

[46:04] class action antitrust lawsuit Related to fire truck pricing And I'm very excited about this

[46:05] related to fire truck pricing And I'm very excited about this

[46:05] related to fire truck pricing And I'm very excited about this Because you might remember I

[46:09] and I'm very excited about this Because you might remember I

[46:09] and I'm very excited about this Because you might remember I Think it was last early last

[46:10] because you might remember I Think it was last early last

[46:10] because you might remember I Think it was last early last Year we voted for money for a

[46:13] think it was last early last Year we voted for money for a

[46:13] think it was last early last Year we voted for money for a New fire trucks and at that

[46:17] year we voted for money for a New fire trucks and at that

[46:17] year we voted for money for a New fire trucks and at that Time when you looked at the

[46:18] new fire trucks and at that Time when you looked at the

[46:18] new fire trucks and at that Time when you looked at the Cost that was estimated for the

[46:21] time when you looked at the Cost that was estimated for the

[46:21] time when you looked at the Cost that was estimated for the New trucks compared to the last

[46:22] cost that was estimated for the New trucks compared to the last

[46:22] cost that was estimated for the New trucks compared to the last Time that we purchased these

[46:22] new trucks compared to the last Time that we purchased these

[46:22] new trucks compared to the last Time that we purchased these Trucks, it was I believe in the

[46:24] time that we purchased these Trucks, it was I believe in the

[46:24] time that we purchased these Trucks, it was I believe in the Technical terms that our fire

[46:25] trucks, it was I believe in the Technical terms that our fire

[46:25] trucks, it was I believe in the Technical terms that our fire Chief used completely bonkers

[46:28] technical terms that our fire Chief used completely bonkers

[46:29] technical terms that our fire Chief used completely bonkers And and but he also said that

[46:32] chief used completely bonkers And and but he also said that

[46:32] chief used completely bonkers And and but he also said that It was consistent with what

[46:33] and and but he also said that It was consistent with what

[46:33] and and but he also said that It was consistent with what Other communities were seeing,

[46:36] it was consistent with what Other communities were seeing,

[46:36] it was consistent with what Other communities were seeing, There was a lag in supply, etc.

[46:37] other communities were seeing, There was a lag in supply, etc.

[46:37] other communities were seeing, There was a lag in supply, etc. Etc. So this she came to my

[46:40] there was a lag in supply, etc. Etc. So this she came to my

[46:40] there was a lag in supply, etc. Etc. So this she came to my Attention when I raised

[46:40] etc. So this she came to my Attention when I raised

[46:41] etc. So this she came to my Attention when I raised Concerns about the steep

[46:41] attention when I raised Concerns about the steep

[46:41] attention when I raised Concerns about the steep Increase a resident reached out

[46:44] concerns about the steep Increase a resident reached out

[46:44] concerns about the steep Increase a resident reached out And had found that other

[46:44] increase a resident reached out And had found that other

[46:44] increase a resident reached out And had found that other Communities had filed similar

[46:47] and had found that other Communities had filed similar

[46:48] and had found that other Communities had filed similar Lawsuits.

[46:48] communities had filed similar Lawsuits.

[46:48] communities had filed similar Lawsuits. I shared that with city

[46:48] lawsuits. I shared that with city

[46:49] lawsuits. I shared that with city Attorney's office and fire

[46:51] I shared that with city Attorney's office and fire

[46:52] I shared that with city Attorney's office and fire Chief and that prompted further

[46:52] attorney's office and fire Chief and that prompted further

[46:52] attorney's office and fire Chief and that prompted further Review.

[46:53] chief and that prompted further Review.

[46:53] chief and that prompted further Review. So it's just it's nice to see

[46:56] review. So it's just it's nice to see

[46:56] review. So it's just it's nice to see This come back around and I

[46:57] so it's just it's nice to see This come back around and I

[46:57] so it's just it's nice to see This come back around and I Hope that that we get a fair

[46:59] this come back around and I Hope that that we get a fair

[46:59] this come back around and I Hope that that we get a fair Price for our equipment out

[47:00] hope that that we get a fair Price for our equipment out

[47:00] hope that that we get a fair Price for our equipment out Of this.

[47:00] price for our equipment out Of this.

[47:00] price for our equipment out Of this. Thanks.

[47:03] of this. Thanks.

[47:03] of this. Thanks. Thank you for the discussion.

[47:07] thanks. Thank you for the discussion.

[47:07] thanks. Thank you for the discussion. >> all those in favor oppose it

[47:10] thank you for the discussion. >> all those in favor oppose it

[47:10] thank you for the discussion. >> all those in favor oppose it Approved.

[47:11] » all those in favor oppose it Approved.

[47:11] » all those in favor oppose it Approved. Mr mayor, you may return.

[47:18] approved. Mr mayor, you may return.

[47:18] approved. Mr mayor, you may return. We now come to a set of public

[47:19] mr mayor, you may return. We now come to a set of public

[47:19] mr mayor, you may return. We now come to a set of public Hearings public hearings are

[47:22] we now come to a set of public Hearings public hearings are

[47:22] we now come to a set of public Hearings public hearings are Opportunities for members

[47:22] hearings public hearings are Opportunities for members

[47:22] hearings public hearings are Opportunities for members Of the public to speak to

[47:23] opportunities for members Of the public to speak to

[47:23] opportunities for members Of the public to speak to Council and the community about

[47:26] of the public to speak to Council and the community about

[47:26] of the public to speak to Council and the community about The specific subject matter

[47:26] council and the community about The specific subject matter

[47:26] council and the community about The specific subject matter Of the public hearing to speak

[47:27] the specific subject matter Of the public hearing to speak

[47:27] the specific subject matter Of the public hearing to speak At a public hearing one need

[47:29] of the public hearing to speak At a public hearing one need

[47:29] of the public hearing to speak At a public hearing one need Not have signed up in advance

[47:30] at a public hearing one need Not have signed up in advance

[47:30] at a public hearing one need Not have signed up in advance But your speech must relate to

[47:33] not have signed up in advance But your speech must relate to

[47:33] not have signed up in advance But your speech must relate to The specific subject matter

[47:34] but your speech must relate to The specific subject matter

[47:34] but your speech must relate to The specific subject matter Of the public hearing that is

[47:34] the specific subject matter Of the public hearing that is

[47:35] the specific subject matter Of the public hearing that is To say

[47:54] a specific item on the

[47:55] a specific item on the

[47:55] a specific item on the Agenda to which the public

[47:55] a specific item on the Agenda to which the public Hearing relates speakers in all

[47:56] agenda to which the public Hearing relates speakers in all

[47:56] agenda to which the public Hearing relates speakers in all Instances will have three

[47:57] hearing relates speakers in all Instances will have three

[47:57] hearing relates speakers in all Instances will have three Minutes in which to speak so

[47:57] instances will have three Minutes in which to speak so

[47:58] instances will have three Minutes in which to speak so Please pay close attention to

[47:58] minutes in which to speak so Please pay close attention to

[47:58] minutes in which to speak so Please pay close attention to The time our clerk or the time

[47:59] please pay close attention to The time our clerk or the time

[47:59] please pay close attention to The time our clerk or the time Clock will notify you when 30

[48:00] the time our clerk or the time Clock will notify you when 30

[48:00] the time our clerk or the time Clock will notify you when 30 Seconds are remaining and when

[48:00] clock will notify you when 30 Seconds are remaining and when

[48:00] clock will notify you when 30 Seconds are remaining and when Your time has expired when your

[48:01] seconds are remaining and when Your time has expired when your

[48:01] seconds are remaining and when Your time has expired when your Time has expired, please

[48:02] your time has expired when your Time has expired, please

[48:02] your time has expired when your Time has expired, please Conclude your remarks and cede

[48:02] time has expired, please Conclude your remarks and cede

[48:03] time has expired, please Conclude your remarks and cede The floor public hearing no to

[48:03] conclude your remarks and cede The floor public hearing no to

[48:03] conclude your remarks and cede The floor public hearing no to Resolution to approve a

[48:04] the floor public hearing no to Resolution to approve a

[48:04] the floor public hearing no to Resolution to approve a Transformational brownfield for

[48:05] resolution to approve a Transformational brownfield for

[48:05] resolution to approve a Transformational brownfield for Three fifty fifth s fifth

[48:05] transformational brownfield for Three fifty fifth s fifth

[48:05] transformational brownfield for Three fifty fifth s fifth Avenue.

[48:06] three fifty fifth s fifth Avenue.

[48:06] three fifty fifth s fifth Avenue. >> is there anyone in house who

[48:06] avenue. >> is there anyone in house who

[48:06] avenue. >> is there anyone in house who Would like to speak at this

[48:07] » is there anyone in house who Would like to speak at this

[48:07] » is there anyone in house who Would like to speak at this Public hearing

[48:14] ?

[48:15] ?

[48:15] ? Is there anyone online who

[48:16] ? Is there anyone online who

[48:16] ? Is there anyone online who Would like to speak at this

[48:16] is there anyone online who Would like to speak at this

[48:16] is there anyone online who Would like to speak at this Public hearing?

[48:22] would like to speak at this Public hearing?

[48:22] would like to speak at this Public hearing? I don't see anyone online for

[48:23] public hearing? I don't see anyone online for

[48:23] public hearing? I don't see anyone online for This hearing.

[48:29] I don't see anyone online for This hearing.

[48:29] I don't see anyone online for This hearing. The floor still open but I

[48:33] this hearing. The floor still open but I

[48:33] this hearing. The floor still open but I Wasn't sure if

[48:40] I'm not here to

[48:44] I'm not here to

[48:44] I'm not here to Have a public hearing.

[48:45] I'm not here to Have a public hearing.

[48:45] I'm not here to Have a public hearing. I was struck for the agenda

[48:46] have a public hearing. I was struck for the agenda

[48:46] have a public hearing. I was struck for the agenda Item to property owners.

[48:48] I was struck for the agenda Item to property owners.

[48:48] I was struck for the agenda Item to property owners. So let me make sure I'm in the

[48:52] item to property owners. So let me make sure I'm in the

[48:52] item to property owners. So let me make sure I'm in the Right place.

[48:53] so let me make sure I'm in the Right place.

[48:53] so let me make sure I'm in the Right place. I appreciate your patience here

[49:03] .

[49:03] . I'm going to speak to both

[49:04] . I'm going to speak to both

[49:04] . I'm going to speak to both Brownfield's tonight because I

[49:05] I'm going to speak to both Brownfield's tonight because I

[49:05] I'm going to speak to both Brownfield's tonight because I Was on the brownfield's review

[49:07] brownfield's tonight because I Was on the brownfield's review

[49:07] brownfield's tonight because I Was on the brownfield's review Committee which doesn't exist

[49:08] was on the brownfield's review Committee which doesn't exist

[49:08] was on the brownfield's review Committee which doesn't exist Anymore.

[49:08] committee which doesn't exist Anymore.

[49:08] committee which doesn't exist Anymore. They're actually the brownfield

[49:09] anymore. They're actually the brownfield

[49:09] anymore. They're actually the brownfield Review board and I don't think

[49:11] they're actually the brownfield Review board and I don't think

[49:12] they're actually the brownfield Review board and I don't think There's too much complaint

[49:12] review board and I don't think There's too much complaint

[49:12] review board and I don't think There's too much complaint About the way that this project

[49:15] there's too much complaint About the way that this project

[49:15] there's too much complaint About the way that this project On three fifty s fifth the

[49:16] about the way that this project On three fifty s fifth the

[49:16] about the way that this project On three fifty s fifth the Willerton would fit the

[49:19] on three fifty s fifth the Willerton would fit the

[49:20] on three fifty s fifth the Willerton would fit the Requirement that were laid on

[49:20] willerton would fit the Requirement that were laid on

[49:20] willerton would fit the Requirement that were laid on In our brownfield policy that

[49:23] requirement that were laid on In our brownfield policy that

[49:23] requirement that were laid on In our brownfield policy that Was adopted by this body in

[49:24] in our brownfield policy that Was adopted by this body in

[49:24] in our brownfield policy that Was adopted by this body in Twenty nineteen and I think we

[49:27] was adopted by this body in Twenty nineteen and I think we

[49:27] was adopted by this body in Twenty nineteen and I think we All know that this project is

[49:28] twenty nineteen and I think we All know that this project is

[49:28] twenty nineteen and I think we All know that this project is Going to be very important for

[49:29] all know that this project is Going to be very important for

[49:29] all know that this project is Going to be very important for The city and that it clearly

[49:31] going to be very important for The city and that it clearly

[49:31] going to be very important for The city and that it clearly Falls within the guidelines

[49:31] the city and that it clearly Falls within the guidelines

[49:32] the city and that it clearly Falls within the guidelines Of providing affordable

[49:34] falls within the guidelines Of providing affordable

[49:34] falls within the guidelines Of providing affordable Housing.

[49:35] of providing affordable Housing.

[49:35] of providing affordable Housing. The project itself and the

[49:35] housing. The project itself and the

[49:35] housing. The project itself and the Project developer itself and

[49:38] the project itself and the Project developer itself and

[49:38] the project itself and the Project developer itself and Our housing commission and

[49:39] project developer itself and Our housing commission and

[49:39] project developer itself and Our housing commission and Working with their partners

[49:39] our housing commission and Working with their partners

[49:40] our housing commission and Working with their partners Providing affordable housing

[49:42] working with their partners Providing affordable housing

[49:42] working with their partners Providing affordable housing Until this even though the

[49:43] providing affordable housing Until this even though the

[49:43] providing affordable housing Until this even though the Environmental aspect this

[49:46] until this even though the Environmental aspect this

[49:46] until this even though the Environmental aspect this Project is relatively small

[49:47] environmental aspect this Project is relatively small

[49:47] environmental aspect this Project is relatively small Because the site has already

[49:47] project is relatively small Because the site has already

[49:48] project is relatively small Because the site has already Been partially remediated, I

[49:50] because the site has already Been partially remediated, I

[49:50] because the site has already Been partially remediated, I Think it's I think it's

[49:50] been partially remediated, I Think it's I think it's

[49:50] been partially remediated, I Think it's I think it's Appropriate that this

[49:53] think it's I think it's Appropriate that this

[49:53] think it's I think it's Appropriate that this Brownfield recovery is given in

[49:54] appropriate that this Brownfield recovery is given in

[49:54] appropriate that this Brownfield recovery is given in This case.

[49:54] brownfield recovery is given in This case.

[49:54] brownfield recovery is given in This case. Thank you.

[49:55] this case. Thank you.

[49:55] this case. Thank you. Thank.

[49:57] thank you. Thank.

[49:57] thank you. Thank. Is there anyone else in house

[49:58] thank. Is there anyone else in house

[49:58] thank. Is there anyone else in house Or online who'd like to speak

[50:01] is there anyone else in house Or online who'd like to speak

[50:01] is there anyone else in house Or online who'd like to speak At this public hearing

[50:19] ?

[50:19] ? >> alex lowe, do you have a

[50:20] ? >> alex lowe, do you have a

[50:21] ? >> alex lowe, do you have a Comment?

[50:23] » alex lowe, do you have a Comment?

[50:23] » alex lowe, do you have a Comment? I understand so I'm just when

[50:27] comment? I understand so I'm just when

[50:27] comment? I understand so I'm just when To say that I'm really glad

[50:28] I understand so I'm just when To say that I'm really glad

[50:28] I understand so I'm just when To say that I'm really glad Said to see this moving forward

[50:31] to say that I'm really glad Said to see this moving forward

[50:31] to say that I'm really glad Said to see this moving forward And being done at legalize

[50:34] said to see this moving forward And being done at legalize

[50:34] said to see this moving forward And being done at legalize Through proper process.

[50:35] and being done at legalize Through proper process.

[50:35] and being done at legalize Through proper process. >> thank you.

[50:37] through proper process. >> thank you.

[50:38] through proper process. >> thank you. Thank you.

[50:41] » thank you. Thank you.

[50:42] » thank you. Thank you. Er I don't see any other

[50:42] thank you. Er I don't see any other

[50:43] thank you. Er I don't see any other Callers with their hands up

[50:43] er I don't see any other Callers with their hands up

[50:43] er I don't see any other Callers with their hands up Online see no one public

[50:53] callers with their hands up Online see no one public

[50:53] callers with their hands up Online see no one public Hearing is closed public carry

[50:54] online see no one public Hearing is closed public carry

[50:54] online see no one public Hearing is closed public carry Number three resolution to

[50:56] hearing is closed public carry Number three resolution to

[50:56] hearing is closed public carry Number three resolution to Approve a brownfield plan for

[50:57] number three resolution to Approve a brownfield plan for

[50:57] number three resolution to Approve a brownfield plan for The arber.

[50:58] approve a brownfield plan for The arber.

[50:58] approve a brownfield plan for The arber. S project is there anyone in

[51:01] the arber. S project is there anyone in

[51:01] the arber. S project is there anyone in House would like to speak at

[51:01] s project is there anyone in House would like to speak at

[51:02] s project is there anyone in House would like to speak at This public hearing?

[51:07] house would like to speak at This public hearing?

[51:08] house would like to speak at This public hearing? >> tom wheeler, the proponents

[51:12] this public hearing? >> tom wheeler, the proponents

[51:12] this public hearing? >> tom wheeler, the proponents Of this project led by mayor

[51:15] » tom wheeler, the proponents Of this project led by mayor

[51:15] » tom wheeler, the proponents Of this project led by mayor Taylor calvet supposed virtues

[51:16] of this project led by mayor Taylor calvet supposed virtues

[51:16] of this project led by mayor Taylor calvet supposed virtues They don't tell you where the

[51:19] taylor calvet supposed virtues They don't tell you where the

[51:19] taylor calvet supposed virtues They don't tell you where the Public money is coming from and

[51:20] they don't tell you where the Public money is coming from and

[51:20] they don't tell you where the Public money is coming from and It's a whole lot of money.

[51:21] public money is coming from and It's a whole lot of money.

[51:21] public money is coming from and It's a whole lot of money. Three hundred and twenty nine

[51:24] it's a whole lot of money. Three hundred and twenty nine

[51:24] it's a whole lot of money. Three hundred and twenty nine Million dollars.

[51:24] three hundred and twenty nine Million dollars.

[51:24] three hundred and twenty nine Million dollars. The plan would take funds from

[51:25] million dollars. The plan would take funds from

[51:25] million dollars. The plan would take funds from Every city county schools,

[51:28] the plan would take funds from Every city county schools,

[51:28] the plan would take funds from Every city county schools, Transportation, community

[51:28] every city county schools, Transportation, community

[51:29] every city county schools, Transportation, community College and library fund the

[51:32] transportation, community College and library fund the

[51:32] transportation, community College and library fund the Tax dollars support for the

[51:33] college and library fund the Tax dollars support for the

[51:33] college and library fund the Tax dollars support for the Next 30 years.

[51:35] tax dollars support for the Next 30 years.

[51:35] tax dollars support for the Next 30 years. Here's where it comes from ann

[51:36] next 30 years. Here's where it comes from ann

[51:36] next 30 years. Here's where it comes from ann Arbor public schools one

[51:37] here's where it comes from ann Arbor public schools one

[51:37] here's where it comes from ann Arbor public schools one Hundred and thirty five dollars

[51:39] arbor public schools one Hundred and thirty five dollars

[51:40] arbor public schools one Hundred and thirty five dollars Million city of ann arbor

[51:40] hundred and thirty five dollars Million city of ann arbor

[51:40] hundred and thirty five dollars Million city of ann arbor Eighty point five dollars

[51:41] million city of ann arbor Eighty point five dollars

[51:41] million city of ann arbor Eighty point five dollars Billion from police via streets

[51:43] eighty point five dollars Billion from police via streets

[51:43] eighty point five dollars Billion from police via streets Planning courts employee

[51:44] billion from police via streets Planning courts employee

[51:44] billion from police via streets Planning courts employee Benefits refuse collection

[51:46] planning courts employee Benefits refuse collection

[51:47] planning courts employee Benefits refuse collection Parks maintenance repairs parks

[51:47] benefits refuse collection Parks maintenance repairs parks

[51:47] benefits refuse collection Parks maintenance repairs parks Acquisition sidewalks even

[51:48] parks maintenance repairs parks Acquisition sidewalks even

[51:48] parks maintenance repairs parks Acquisition sidewalks even Affordable housing and climate

[51:51] acquisition sidewalks even Affordable housing and climate

[51:51] acquisition sidewalks even Affordable housing and climate Action.

[51:51] affordable housing and climate Action.

[51:52] affordable housing and climate Action. Yes five point one million each

[51:55] action. Yes five point one million each

[51:55] action. Yes five point one million each From affordable housing and

[51:55] yes five point one million each From affordable housing and

[51:55] yes five point one million each From affordable housing and Climate action at twenty two

[51:59] from affordable housing and Climate action at twenty two

[51:59] from affordable housing and Climate action at twenty two Million ann arbor district

[51:59] climate action at twenty two Million ann arbor district

[52:00] climate action at twenty two Million ann arbor district Library nine point three

[52:00] million ann arbor district Library nine point three

[52:00] million ann arbor district Library nine point three Million washtenaw community

[52:03] library nine point three Million washtenaw community

[52:03] library nine point three Million washtenaw community College seventeen point one

[52:04] million washtenaw community College seventeen point one

[52:04] million washtenaw community College seventeen point one Million washtenaw county thirty

[52:07] college seventeen point one Million washtenaw county thirty

[52:07] college seventeen point one Million washtenaw county thirty Eight point five million from

[52:07] million washtenaw county thirty Eight point five million from

[52:08] million washtenaw county thirty Eight point five million from General operations county parks

[52:11] eight point five million from General operations county parks

[52:11] eight point five million from General operations county parks Emergency communications here

[52:11] general operations county parks Emergency communications here

[52:12] general operations county parks Emergency communications here Including metropolitan

[52:12] emergency communications here Including metropolitan

[52:12] emergency communications here Including metropolitan Authority veterans relief

[52:15] including metropolitan Authority veterans relief

[52:15] including metropolitan Authority veterans relief Roads, mental health and public

[52:16] authority veterans relief Roads, mental health and public

[52:16] authority veterans relief Roads, mental health and public Safety senior citizens programs

[52:18] roads, mental health and public Safety senior citizens programs

[52:18] roads, mental health and public Safety senior citizens programs And conservation watchdog

[52:19] safety senior citizens programs And conservation watchdog

[52:19] safety senior citizens programs And conservation watchdog Intermediate school district

[52:22] and conservation watchdog Intermediate school district

[52:22] and conservation watchdog Intermediate school district Operating in special ed twenty

[52:22] intermediate school district Operating in special ed twenty

[52:23] intermediate school district Operating in special ed twenty Six point seven million that

[52:26] operating in special ed twenty Six point seven million that

[52:26] operating in special ed twenty Six point seven million that Captured revenue will go to the

[52:27] six point seven million that Captured revenue will go to the

[52:27] six point seven million that Captured revenue will go to the Developer to cover a major

[52:30] captured revenue will go to the Developer to cover a major

[52:30] captured revenue will go to the Developer to cover a major Portion of its costs to build

[52:31] developer to cover a major Portion of its costs to build

[52:31] developer to cover a major Portion of its costs to build Arber s mayor taylor has

[52:33] portion of its costs to build Arber s mayor taylor has

[52:33] portion of its costs to build Arber s mayor taylor has Repeatedly said and the

[52:34] arber s mayor taylor has Repeatedly said and the

[52:34] arber s mayor taylor has Repeatedly said and the Resolution to adopt the

[52:34] repeatedly said and the Resolution to adopt the

[52:34] repeatedly said and the Resolution to adopt the Brownfield plan states that

[52:37] resolution to adopt the Brownfield plan states that

[52:37] resolution to adopt the Brownfield plan states that These taxes would not exist but

[52:38] brownfield plan states that These taxes would not exist but

[52:38] brownfield plan states that These taxes would not exist but For the project absolutely

[52:41] these taxes would not exist but For the project absolutely

[52:41] these taxes would not exist but For the project absolutely Nonsense.

[52:41] for the project absolutely Nonsense.

[52:41] for the project absolutely Nonsense. The only way that that property

[52:42] nonsense. The only way that that property

[52:42] nonsense. The only way that that property Won't produce substantial new

[52:45] the only way that that property Won't produce substantial new

[52:45] the only way that that property Won't produce substantial new Taxes is if no project is

[52:46] won't produce substantial new Taxes is if no project is

[52:46] won't produce substantial new Taxes is if no project is Produced in that property that

[52:49] taxes is if no project is Produced in that property that

[52:49] taxes is if no project is Produced in that property that Isn't isn't going to happen.

[52:50] produced in that property that Isn't isn't going to happen.

[52:50] produced in that property that Isn't isn't going to happen. The developer here paid about

[52:51] isn't isn't going to happen. The developer here paid about

[52:51] isn't isn't going to happen. The developer here paid about Thirty million to park to

[52:53] the developer here paid about Thirty million to park to

[52:53] the developer here paid about Thirty million to park to Purchase two of the parcels.

[52:54] thirty million to park to Purchase two of the parcels.

[52:54] thirty million to park to Purchase two of the parcels. It certainly thought that the

[52:55] purchase two of the parcels. It certainly thought that the

[52:55] purchase two of the parcels. It certainly thought that the Property is valuable for

[52:57] it certainly thought that the Property is valuable for

[52:57] it certainly thought that the Property is valuable for Development if this developer

[52:58] property is valuable for Development if this developer

[52:58] property is valuable for Development if this developer Can't figure out how to put

[52:59] development if this developer Can't figure out how to put

[52:59] development if this developer Can't figure out how to put Together a viable project on

[53:01] can't figure out how to put Together a viable project on

[53:02] can't figure out how to put Together a viable project on The site without asking for

[53:02] together a viable project on The site without asking for

[53:02] together a viable project on The site without asking for Government handouts of a third

[53:03] the site without asking for Government handouts of a third

[53:03] the site without asking for Government handouts of a third Of a billion that's its

[53:05] government handouts of a third Of a billion that's its

[53:05] government handouts of a third Of a billion that's its Business problem not the

[53:06] of a billion that's its Business problem not the

[53:06] of a billion that's its Business problem not the Taxpayers problem.

[53:09] business problem not the Taxpayers problem.

[53:09] business problem not the Taxpayers problem. Another developer, another

[53:10] taxpayers problem. Another developer, another

[53:10] taxpayers problem. Another developer, another Project will come along one

[53:10] another developer, another Project will come along one

[53:11] another developer, another Project will come along one That might generate even more

[53:13] project will come along one That might generate even more

[53:13] project will come along one That might generate even more Tax revenue than this one.

[53:14] that might generate even more Tax revenue than this one.

[53:14] that might generate even more Tax revenue than this one. And without asking for any

[53:17] tax revenue than this one. And without asking for any

[53:17] tax revenue than this one. And without asking for any Public subsidy, what drives

[53:18] and without asking for any Public subsidy, what drives

[53:18] and without asking for any Public subsidy, what drives This intense support for the

[53:21] public subsidy, what drives This intense support for the

[53:21] public subsidy, what drives This intense support for the Project from the mayor and some

[53:22] this intense support for the Project from the mayor and some

[53:22] this intense support for the Project from the mayor and some Council members on the surface

[53:22] project from the mayor and some Council members on the surface

[53:22] project from the mayor and some Council members on the surface It's a desire for more

[53:24] council members on the surface It's a desire for more

[53:24] council members on the surface It's a desire for more Affordable housing.

[53:25] it's a desire for more Affordable housing.

[53:25] it's a desire for more Affordable housing. The claim is that the project

[53:26] affordable housing. The claim is that the project

[53:26] affordable housing. The claim is that the project Will include about two hundred

[53:28] the claim is that the project Will include about two hundred

[53:28] the claim is that the project Will include about two hundred Units three hundred twenty nine

[53:29] will include about two hundred Units three hundred twenty nine

[53:29] will include about two hundred Units three hundred twenty nine Million dollars for two hundred

[53:30] units three hundred twenty nine Million dollars for two hundred

[53:30] units three hundred twenty nine Million dollars for two hundred Units that's one point six four

[53:33] million dollars for two hundred Units that's one point six four

[53:33] million dollars for two hundred Units that's one point six four Or five million per unit.

[53:33] units that's one point six four Or five million per unit.

[53:33] units that's one point six four Or five million per unit. Not a good deal for a city if

[53:36] or five million per unit. Not a good deal for a city if

[53:36] or five million per unit. Not a good deal for a city if For any reason the units cannot

[53:37] not a good deal for a city if For any reason the units cannot

[53:37] not a good deal for a city if For any reason the units cannot Be built the developer can

[53:41] for any reason the units cannot Be built the developer can

[53:41] for any reason the units cannot Be built the developer can Satisfy any affordable housing

[53:44] be built the developer can Satisfy any affordable housing

[53:44] be built the developer can Satisfy any affordable housing Obligation by making a payment

[53:45] satisfy any affordable housing Obligation by making a payment

[53:45] satisfy any affordable housing Obligation by making a payment Of nineteen dollars million

[53:47] obligation by making a payment Of nineteen dollars million

[53:47] obligation by making a payment Of nineteen dollars million Promised to pay nineteen

[53:48] of nineteen dollars million Promised to pay nineteen

[53:48] of nineteen dollars million Promised to pay nineteen Dollars million to get a three

[53:48] promised to pay nineteen Dollars million to get a three

[53:48] promised to pay nineteen Dollars million to get a three Hundred and twenty nine million

[53:51] dollars million to get a three Hundred and twenty nine million

[53:51] dollars million to get a three Hundred and twenty nine million Dollar subsidy for the

[53:52] hundred and twenty nine million Dollar subsidy for the

[53:52] hundred and twenty nine million Dollar subsidy for the Taxpayers a great deal for the

[53:53] dollar subsidy for the Taxpayers a great deal for the

[53:53] dollar subsidy for the Taxpayers a great deal for the Developer.

[53:55] taxpayers a great deal for the Developer.

[53:55] taxpayers a great deal for the Developer. Thank you

[54:06] .

[54:06] . If I didn't know better I would

[54:07] . If I didn't know better I would

[54:07] . If I didn't know better I would Claim the prior speaker thought

[54:10] if I didn't know better I would Claim the prior speaker thought

[54:10] if I didn't know better I would Claim the prior speaker thought That there's no such thing as a

[54:11] claim the prior speaker thought That there's no such thing as a

[54:11] claim the prior speaker thought That there's no such thing as a Free lunch.

[54:14] that there's no such thing as a Free lunch.

[54:14] that there's no such thing as a Free lunch. Speaking of conflict

[54:15] free lunch. Speaking of conflict

[54:15] free lunch. Speaking of conflict Of interest I'd seen the video

[54:18] speaking of conflict Of interest I'd seen the video

[54:18] speaking of conflict Of interest I'd seen the video Of mr. Hoffman the development

[54:18] of interest I'd seen the video Of mr. Hoffman the development

[54:19] of interest I'd seen the video Of mr. Hoffman the development Of this property at a meeting

[54:22] of mr. Hoffman the development Of this property at a meeting

[54:22] of mr. Hoffman the development Of this property at a meeting Announce at a meeting of his

[54:23] of this property at a meeting Announce at a meeting of his

[54:23] of this property at a meeting Announce at a meeting of his Investors that he in effect had

[54:26] announce at a meeting of his Investors that he in effect had

[54:26] announce at a meeting of his Investors that he in effect had Arranged for city funds to

[54:28] investors that he in effect had Arranged for city funds to

[54:28] investors that he in effect had Arranged for city funds to Ensure that his investors get

[54:29] arranged for city funds to Ensure that his investors get

[54:29] arranged for city funds to Ensure that his investors get Their desired financial return

[54:33] ensure that his investors get Their desired financial return

[54:33] ensure that his investors get Their desired financial return .

[54:33] their desired financial return .

[54:33] their desired financial return . Apparently he thinks he's got

[54:34] . Apparently he thinks he's got

[54:34] . Apparently he thinks he's got Such a good skill at this he's

[54:36] apparently he thinks he's got Such a good skill at this he's

[54:36] apparently he thinks he's got Such a good skill at this he's Made his video copyrighted so

[54:37] such a good skill at this he's Made his video copyrighted so

[54:37] such a good skill at this he's Made his video copyrighted so Nobody else could come and use

[54:40] made his video copyrighted so Nobody else could come and use

[54:40] made his video copyrighted so Nobody else could come and use His technique to get money out

[54:41] nobody else could come and use His technique to get money out

[54:41] nobody else could come and use His technique to get money out Of the city.

[54:42] his technique to get money out Of the city.

[54:42] his technique to get money out Of the city. I've also seen a list of eight

[54:44] of the city. I've also seen a list of eight

[54:45] of the city. I've also seen a list of eight Of you who have taken money

[54:48] I've also seen a list of eight Of you who have taken money

[54:48] I've also seen a list of eight Of you who have taken money From mr. Hoffman and his wife.

[54:52] of you who have taken money From mr. Hoffman and his wife.

[54:52] of you who have taken money From mr. Hoffman and his wife. Let's see at the low end john

[54:53] from mr. Hoffman and his wife. Let's see at the low end john

[54:53] from mr. Hoffman and his wife. Let's see at the low end john Cornell taken a thousand gen er

[54:56] let's see at the low end john Cornell taken a thousand gen er

[54:56] let's see at the low end john Cornell taken a thousand gen er Taken two thousand three

[54:59] cornell taken a thousand gen er Taken two thousand three

[54:59] cornell taken a thousand gen er Taken two thousand three Hundred and fifty dollars.

[55:00] taken two thousand three Hundred and fifty dollars.

[55:00] taken two thousand three Hundred and fifty dollars. Erica briggs from my ward has

[55:04] hundred and fifty dollars. Erica briggs from my ward has

[55:04] hundred and fifty dollars. Erica briggs from my ward has Taken two hundred two thousand

[55:04] erica briggs from my ward has Taken two hundred two thousand

[55:05] erica briggs from my ward has Taken two hundred two thousand Seven hundred seventy five

[55:08] taken two hundred two thousand Seven hundred seventy five

[55:08] taken two hundred two thousand Seven hundred seventy five Dollars.

[55:08] seven hundred seventy five Dollars.

[55:08] seven hundred seventy five Dollars. Cynthia harrison's taken two

[55:11] dollars. Cynthia harrison's taken two

[55:11] dollars. Cynthia harrison's taken two Thousand fifty.

[55:14] cynthia harrison's taken two Thousand fifty.

[55:15] cynthia harrison's taken two Thousand fifty. Mr malik you've taken fifteen

[55:15] thousand fifty. Mr malik you've taken fifteen

[55:15] thousand fifty. Mr malik you've taken fifteen Hundred dollars from mr.

[55:16] mr malik you've taken fifteen Hundred dollars from mr.

[55:16] mr malik you've taken fifteen Hundred dollars from mr. Hoffman and his wife mr. Denha

[55:19] hundred dollars from mr. Hoffman and his wife mr. Denha

[55:19] hundred dollars from mr. Hoffman and his wife mr. Denha You've taken four thousand

[55:21] hoffman and his wife mr. Denha You've taken four thousand

[55:21] hoffman and his wife mr. Denha You've taken four thousand Dollars from mr. Hoffman that

[55:22] you've taken four thousand Dollars from mr. Hoffman that

[55:22] you've taken four thousand Dollars from mr. Hoffman that His wife and mayor taylor you

[55:25] dollars from mr. Hoffman that His wife and mayor taylor you

[55:25] dollars from mr. Hoffman that His wife and mayor taylor you Were the winner at six thousand

[55:26] his wife and mayor taylor you Were the winner at six thousand

[55:27] his wife and mayor taylor you Were the winner at six thousand Dollars.

[55:29] were the winner at six thousand Dollars.

[55:29] were the winner at six thousand Dollars. Oh are we going to see the

[55:31] dollars. Oh are we going to see the

[55:31] dollars. Oh are we going to see the Eight of you recuse yourselves

[55:33] oh are we going to see the Eight of you recuse yourselves

[55:33] oh are we going to see the Eight of you recuse yourselves Or are you going to take this

[55:34] eight of you recuse yourselves Or are you going to take this

[55:34] eight of you recuse yourselves Or are you going to take this Man's money and then come vote

[55:38] or are you going to take this Man's money and then come vote

[55:38] or are you going to take this Man's money and then come vote To give him lots of city money

[55:41] man's money and then come vote To give him lots of city money

[55:41] man's money and then come vote To give him lots of city money ?

[55:42] to give him lots of city money ?

[55:42] to give him lots of city money ? Tax increment financing is

[55:42] ? Tax increment financing is

[55:42] ? Tax increment financing is Always wrong because what it

[55:43] tax increment financing is Always wrong because what it

[55:43] tax increment financing is Always wrong because what it Does is it takes money that

[55:45] always wrong because what it Does is it takes money that

[55:45] always wrong because what it Does is it takes money that Would otherwise go through the

[55:46] does is it takes money that Would otherwise go through the

[55:46] does is it takes money that Would otherwise go through the Public budgeting process and it

[55:49] would otherwise go through the Public budgeting process and it

[55:49] would otherwise go through the Public budgeting process and it Pre it pre budgeted pre spent

[55:50] public budgeting process and it Pre it pre budgeted pre spent

[55:50] public budgeting process and it Pre it pre budgeted pre spent It so it can't receive public

[55:53] pre it pre budgeted pre spent It so it can't receive public

[55:53] pre it pre budgeted pre spent It so it can't receive public Scrutiny and doesn't go through

[55:53] it so it can't receive public Scrutiny and doesn't go through

[55:53] it so it can't receive public Scrutiny and doesn't go through The normal regular order budget

[55:57] scrutiny and doesn't go through The normal regular order budget

[55:57] scrutiny and doesn't go through The normal regular order budget Process.

[55:57] the normal regular order budget Process.

[55:57] the normal regular order budget Process. In this particular case the tax

[56:00] process. In this particular case the tax

[56:01] process. In this particular case the tax Increment financing is being

[56:01] in this particular case the tax Increment financing is being

[56:01] in this particular case the tax Increment financing is being Used to to enrich a certain

[56:04] increment financing is being Used to to enrich a certain

[56:04] increment financing is being Used to to enrich a certain Subset of investors in the

[56:08] used to to enrich a certain Subset of investors in the

[56:08] used to to enrich a certain Subset of investors in the City.

[56:08] subset of investors in the City.

[56:08] subset of investors in the City. >> it amounts to a transfer

[56:09] city. >> it amounts to a transfer

[56:09] city. >> it amounts to a transfer Of money from lower income

[56:13] » it amounts to a transfer Of money from lower income

[56:13] » it amounts to a transfer Of money from lower income People to higher income people

[56:15] of money from lower income People to higher income people

[56:16] of money from lower income People to higher income people .

[56:16] people to higher income people .

[56:16] people to higher income people . That's because it's going to

[56:16] . That's because it's going to

[56:17] . That's because it's going to Take money that would otherwise

[56:17] that's because it's going to Take money that would otherwise

[56:17] that's because it's going to Take money that would otherwise Go fund all the things the

[56:20] take money that would otherwise Go fund all the things the

[56:20] take money that would otherwise Go fund all the things the Prior speaker mentioned and

[56:20] go fund all the things the Prior speaker mentioned and

[56:20] go fund all the things the Prior speaker mentioned and Instead build a capital asset

[56:24] prior speaker mentioned and Instead build a capital asset

[56:24] prior speaker mentioned and Instead build a capital asset For the use of this investment

[56:27] instead build a capital asset For the use of this investment

[56:27] instead build a capital asset For the use of this investment Group without them having to

[56:28] for the use of this investment Group without them having to

[56:28] for the use of this investment Group without them having to Pay anything for it.

[56:30] group without them having to Pay anything for it.

[56:31] group without them having to Pay anything for it. If the investment can't stand

[56:35] pay anything for it. If the investment can't stand

[56:35] pay anything for it. If the investment can't stand On its own, it's a value

[56:35] if the investment can't stand On its own, it's a value

[56:36] if the investment can't stand On its own, it's a value Destroyer and shouldn't be

[56:39] on its own, it's a value Destroyer and shouldn't be

[56:39] on its own, it's a value Destroyer and shouldn't be Made.

[56:39] destroyer and shouldn't be Made.

[56:39] destroyer and shouldn't be Made. Another note the point of t.s.

[56:43] made. Another note the point of t.s.

[56:43] made. Another note the point of t.s. One zoning is to enable the

[56:46] another note the point of t.s. One zoning is to enable the

[56:46] another note the point of t.s. One zoning is to enable the Transit corridor.

[56:47] one zoning is to enable the Transit corridor.

[56:47] one zoning is to enable the Transit corridor. Zoning is to reduce the use

[56:48] transit corridor. Zoning is to reduce the use

[56:48] transit corridor. Zoning is to reduce the use Of cars.

[56:50] zoning is to reduce the use Of cars.

[56:50] zoning is to reduce the use Of cars. This project was designated to

[56:51] of cars. This project was designated to

[56:51] of cars. This project was designated to Taxi one zoning project but

[56:54] this project was designated to Taxi one zoning project but

[56:54] this project was designated to Taxi one zoning project but We're going to build a car park

[56:55] taxi one zoning project but We're going to build a car park

[56:55] taxi one zoning project but We're going to build a car park For them a parking garage.

[56:58] we're going to build a car park For them a parking garage.

[56:58] we're going to build a car park For them a parking garage. Doesn't that defeat the whole

[56:59] for them a parking garage. Doesn't that defeat the whole

[56:59] for them a parking garage. Doesn't that defeat the whole Purpose of one zoning?

[57:02] doesn't that defeat the whole Purpose of one zoning?

[57:02] doesn't that defeat the whole Purpose of one zoning? I mean it sounds like you're

[57:03] purpose of one zoning? I mean it sounds like you're

[57:03] purpose of one zoning? I mean it sounds like you're Acknowledging that one zoning

[57:06] I mean it sounds like you're Acknowledging that one zoning

[57:06] I mean it sounds like you're Acknowledging that one zoning Is just a joke as a method

[57:07] acknowledging that one zoning Is just a joke as a method

[57:07] acknowledging that one zoning Is just a joke as a method Of getting cars off the road.

[57:10] is just a joke as a method Of getting cars off the road.

[57:10] is just a joke as a method Of getting cars off the road. >> thank you.

[57:11] of getting cars off the road. >> thank you.

[57:11] of getting cars off the road. >> thank you. Thank you

[57:28] .

[57:28] . Jeffrey helpmann has mobilized

[57:29] . Jeffrey helpmann has mobilized

[57:29] . Jeffrey helpmann has mobilized The mayor, the administrator

[57:32] jeffrey helpmann has mobilized The mayor, the administrator

[57:32] jeffrey helpmann has mobilized The mayor, the administrator And several staff members to

[57:33] the mayor, the administrator And several staff members to

[57:33] the mayor, the administrator And several staff members to Urge to approve this.

[57:36] and several staff members to Urge to approve this.

[57:36] and several staff members to Urge to approve this. His fanciful project called

[57:39] urge to approve this. His fanciful project called

[57:40] urge to approve this. His fanciful project called Arber s the latest ploy is to

[57:41] his fanciful project called Arber s the latest ploy is to

[57:41] his fanciful project called Arber s the latest ploy is to Separate out one part the

[57:44] arber s the latest ploy is to Separate out one part the

[57:45] arber s the latest ploy is to Separate out one part the Granting of a huge brownfield's

[57:48] separate out one part the Granting of a huge brownfield's

[57:48] separate out one part the Granting of a huge brownfield's Subsidy from the building

[57:48] granting of a huge brownfield's Subsidy from the building

[57:48] granting of a huge brownfield's Subsidy from the building Of the three city owned parking

[57:52] subsidy from the building Of the three city owned parking

[57:52] subsidy from the building Of the three city owned parking Structures.

[57:52] of the three city owned parking Structures.

[57:52] of the three city owned parking Structures. >> they would be bought with

[57:53] structures. >> they would be bought with

[57:53] structures. >> they would be bought with Bonds committing the city and

[57:55] » they would be bought with Bonds committing the city and

[57:56] » they would be bought with Bonds committing the city and Its taxpayers to as much

[58:16] as a

[58:16] as a Third of a billion dollars in

[58:17] as a Third of a billion dollars in

[58:17] as a Third of a billion dollars in Debt and interest.

[58:18] third of a billion dollars in Debt and interest.

[58:18] third of a billion dollars in Debt and interest. >> tonight's brownfield's

[58:18] debt and interest. >> tonight's brownfield's

[58:18] debt and interest. >> tonight's brownfield's Subsidy does not stand alone.

[58:19] » tonight's brownfield's Subsidy does not stand alone.

[58:19] » tonight's brownfield's Subsidy does not stand alone. Those parking structures are an

[58:20] subsidy does not stand alone. Those parking structures are an

[58:21] subsidy does not stand alone. Those parking structures are an Integral part of our arber.

[58:21] those parking structures are an Integral part of our arber.

[58:21] those parking structures are an Integral part of our arber. S your concern.

[58:22] integral part of our arber. S your concern.

[58:22] integral part of our arber. S your concern. Your consultant has said the

[58:23] s your concern. Your consultant has said the

[58:23] s your concern. Your consultant has said the Project could not succeed

[58:23] your consultant has said the Project could not succeed

[58:23] your consultant has said the Project could not succeed Without massive subsidization.

[58:24] project could not succeed Without massive subsidization.

[58:24] project could not succeed Without massive subsidization. >> tonight's proposal a

[58:25] without massive subsidization. >> tonight's proposal a

[58:25] without massive subsidization. >> tonight's proposal a Proposed leaf is itself

[58:27] » tonight's proposal a Proposed leaf is itself

[58:27] » tonight's proposal a Proposed leaf is itself Unprecedented city brownfield

[58:30] proposed leaf is itself Unprecedented city brownfield

[58:30] proposed leaf is itself Unprecedented city brownfield Policy requires the tif shell

[58:31] unprecedented city brownfield Policy requires the tif shell

[58:31] unprecedented city brownfield Policy requires the tif shell It's acce and shall not exceed

[58:35] policy requires the tif shell It's acce and shall not exceed

[58:35] policy requires the tif shell It's acce and shall not exceed 20 percent of overall project

[58:38] it's acce and shall not exceed 20 percent of overall project

[58:38] it's acce and shall not exceed 20 percent of overall project Investment.

[58:39] 20 percent of overall project Investment.

[58:39] 20 percent of overall project Investment. >> that policy does not include

[58:43] investment. >> that policy does not include

[58:43] investment. >> that policy does not include Any exceptions for jefferey in

[58:44] » that policy does not include Any exceptions for jefferey in

[58:44] » that policy does not include Any exceptions for jefferey in Particular or for major

[58:46] any exceptions for jefferey in Particular or for major

[58:47] any exceptions for jefferey in Particular or for major Campaign donors in general.

[58:47] particular or for major Campaign donors in general.

[58:47] particular or for major Campaign donors in general. Yet this proposal would entail

[58:50] campaign donors in general. Yet this proposal would entail

[58:50] campaign donors in general. Yet this proposal would entail And reimbursements as high as

[58:51] yet this proposal would entail And reimbursements as high as

[58:51] yet this proposal would entail And reimbursements as high as 90 two percent of the

[58:55] and reimbursements as high as 90 two percent of the

[58:56] and reimbursements as high as 90 two percent of the Investment for 30 years and

[58:59] 90 two percent of the Investment for 30 years and

[58:59] 90 two percent of the Investment for 30 years and Arber s would not pay taxes to

[59:02] investment for 30 years and Arber s would not pay taxes to

[59:02] investment for 30 years and Arber s would not pay taxes to A long list of worthy causes

[59:06] arber s would not pay taxes to A long list of worthy causes

[59:06] arber s would not pay taxes to A long list of worthy causes From the city to the

[59:07] a long list of worthy causes From the city to the

[59:07] a long list of worthy causes From the city to the Sustainability fund that you've

[59:10] from the city to the Sustainability fund that you've

[59:10] from the city to the Sustainability fund that you've Always already heard the list

[59:11] sustainability fund that you've Always already heard the list

[59:11] sustainability fund that you've Always already heard the list The rest of us pay these taxes

[59:14] always already heard the list The rest of us pay these taxes

[59:14] always already heard the list The rest of us pay these taxes Every year but jeffrey would

[59:15] the rest of us pay these taxes Every year but jeffrey would

[59:15] the rest of us pay these taxes Every year but jeffrey would Not voters will be wondering

[59:19] every year but jeffrey would Not voters will be wondering

[59:19] every year but jeffrey would Not voters will be wondering Why arbor south will be risky

[59:23] not voters will be wondering Why arbor south will be risky

[59:23] not voters will be wondering Why arbor south will be risky Even with massive subsidies it

[59:27] why arbor south will be risky Even with massive subsidies it

[59:27] why arbor south will be risky Even with massive subsidies it Would be built on a desolate

[59:30] even with massive subsidies it Would be built on a desolate

[59:30] even with massive subsidies it Would be built on a desolate Concrete island surrounded on

[59:30] would be built on a desolate Concrete island surrounded on

[59:30] would be built on a desolate Concrete island surrounded on Two sides by a very busy noisy

[59:34] concrete island surrounded on Two sides by a very busy noisy

[59:34] concrete island surrounded on Two sides by a very busy noisy Roads and nothing else to which

[59:38] two sides by a very busy noisy Roads and nothing else to which

[59:38] two sides by a very busy noisy Roads and nothing else to which Podesta potential residents

[59:41] roads and nothing else to which Podesta potential residents

[59:41] roads and nothing else to which Podesta potential residents Would want to walk who dreams

[59:44] podesta potential residents Would want to walk who dreams

[59:45] podesta potential residents Would want to walk who dreams Of living let alone raising

[59:45] would want to walk who dreams Of living let alone raising

[59:45] would want to walk who dreams Of living let alone raising Children on such a site far

[59:49] of living let alone raising Children on such a site far

[59:49] of living let alone raising Children on such a site far More likely to succeed is the

[59:53] children on such a site far More likely to succeed is the

[59:53] children on such a site far More likely to succeed is the Briarwood development.

[59:53] more likely to succeed is the Briarwood development.

[59:53] more likely to succeed is the Briarwood development. It is a new apartment building.

[59:57] briarwood development. It is a new apartment building.

[59:57] briarwood development. It is a new apartment building. It's large new apartment

[1:00:00] it is a new apartment building. It's large new apartment

[1:00:00] it is a new apartment building. It's large new apartment Building is a one minute walk

[1:00:01] it's large new apartment Building is a one minute walk

[1:00:01] it's large new apartment Building is a one minute walk To a new supermarket walk to

[1:00:07] building is a one minute walk To a new supermarket walk to

[1:00:07] building is a one minute walk To a new supermarket walk to The mall soon, both will be

[1:00:09] to a new supermarket walk to The mall soon, both will be

[1:00:10] to a new supermarket walk to The mall soon, both will be Actually paying property taxes

[1:00:13] the mall soon, both will be Actually paying property taxes

[1:00:13] the mall soon, both will be Actually paying property taxes Later housing on the site could

[1:00:14] actually paying property taxes Later housing on the site could

[1:00:14] actually paying property taxes Later housing on the site could Build on these successes if the

[1:00:18] later housing on the site could Build on these successes if the

[1:00:18] later housing on the site could Build on these successes if the City would encourage at

[1:00:18] build on these successes if the City would encourage at

[1:00:19] build on these successes if the City would encourage at Briarwood not south has the

[1:00:22] city would encourage at Briarwood not south has the

[1:00:22] city would encourage at Briarwood not south has the Makings of a second downtown

[1:00:25] briarwood not south has the Makings of a second downtown

[1:00:25] briarwood not south has the Makings of a second downtown That is walkable mixed-use and

[1:00:29] makings of a second downtown That is walkable mixed-use and

[1:00:29] makings of a second downtown That is walkable mixed-use and Even taxpaying.

[1:00:30] that is walkable mixed-use and Even taxpaying.

[1:00:30] that is walkable mixed-use and Even taxpaying. >> thank you

[1:00:40] .

[1:00:41] .

[1:00:41] . >> hi my name is dan rubinstein

[1:00:44] . >> hi my name is dan rubinstein

[1:00:44] . >> hi my name is dan rubinstein .

[1:00:45] » hi my name is dan rubinstein .

[1:00:45] » hi my name is dan rubinstein . I'm just going to echo some

[1:00:46] . I'm just going to echo some

[1:00:46] . I'm just going to echo some Of the comments that you've

[1:00:46] I'm just going to echo some Of the comments that you've

[1:00:46] I'm just going to echo some Of the comments that you've Already heard.

[1:00:48] of the comments that you've Already heard.

[1:00:48] of the comments that you've Already heard. This obviously is a huge

[1:00:49] already heard. This obviously is a huge

[1:00:49] already heard. This obviously is a huge Expenditure for the city the

[1:00:52] this obviously is a huge Expenditure for the city the

[1:00:52] this obviously is a huge Expenditure for the city the Largest tif ever by far yet I

[1:00:56] expenditure for the city the Largest tif ever by far yet I

[1:00:56] expenditure for the city the Largest tif ever by far yet I Want to speak a little bit

[1:00:56] largest tif ever by far yet I Want to speak a little bit

[1:00:57] largest tif ever by far yet I Want to speak a little bit About the process in erica

[1:01:00] want to speak a little bit About the process in erica

[1:01:00] want to speak a little bit About the process in erica Brigg's recent newsletter.

[1:01:00] about the process in erica Brigg's recent newsletter.

[1:01:00] about the process in erica Brigg's recent newsletter. I'm quoting her she says on

[1:01:01] brigg's recent newsletter. I'm quoting her she says on

[1:01:01] brigg's recent newsletter. I'm quoting her she says on Thursday today's tuesday on

[1:01:04] I'm quoting her she says on Thursday today's tuesday on

[1:01:04] I'm quoting her she says on Thursday today's tuesday on Thursday a revised brownfield

[1:01:05] thursday today's tuesday on Thursday a revised brownfield

[1:01:05] thursday today's tuesday on Thursday a revised brownfield Plan was placed on the council

[1:01:08] thursday a revised brownfield Plan was placed on the council

[1:01:08] thursday a revised brownfield Plan was placed on the council Agenda fundamentally altering

[1:01:09] plan was placed on the council Agenda fundamentally altering

[1:01:09] plan was placed on the council Agenda fundamentally altering The proposal.

[1:01:11] agenda fundamentally altering The proposal.

[1:01:11] agenda fundamentally altering The proposal. But many of the details remain

[1:01:12] the proposal. But many of the details remain

[1:01:12] the proposal. But many of the details remain Unclear.

[1:01:12] but many of the details remain Unclear.

[1:01:12] but many of the details remain Unclear. The plan is not accompanied by

[1:01:15] unclear. The plan is not accompanied by

[1:01:15] unclear. The plan is not accompanied by A public private development

[1:01:18] the plan is not accompanied by A public private development

[1:01:19] the plan is not accompanied by A public private development Agreement or any other

[1:01:19] a public private development Agreement or any other

[1:01:19] a public private development Agreement or any other Agreements that would bind the

[1:01:20] agreement or any other Agreements that would bind the

[1:01:20] agreement or any other Agreements that would bind the Developer to the previous

[1:01:22] agreements that would bind the Developer to the previous

[1:01:23] agreements that would bind the Developer to the previous Commitments made in the

[1:01:23] developer to the previous Commitments made in the

[1:01:23] developer to the previous Commitments made in the Negotiated ppa.

[1:01:27] commitments made in the Negotiated ppa.

[1:01:27] commitments made in the Negotiated ppa. >> this public hearing is

[1:01:28] negotiated ppa. >> this public hearing is

[1:01:28] negotiated ppa. >> this public hearing is Supposed to represent

[1:01:28] » this public hearing is Supposed to represent

[1:01:28] » this public hearing is Supposed to represent Sufficient public engagement on

[1:01:31] supposed to represent Sufficient public engagement on

[1:01:31] supposed to represent Sufficient public engagement on This new revised plan.

[1:01:32] sufficient public engagement on This new revised plan.

[1:01:32] sufficient public engagement on This new revised plan. Few citizens would have any

[1:01:34] this new revised plan. Few citizens would have any

[1:01:34] this new revised plan. Few citizens would have any Awareness that this new plan

[1:01:35] few citizens would have any Awareness that this new plan

[1:01:35] few citizens would have any Awareness that this new plan Even exists.

[1:01:35] awareness that this new plan Even exists.

[1:01:36] awareness that this new plan Even exists. Fewer would have the

[1:01:38] even exists. Fewer would have the

[1:01:38] even exists. Fewer would have the Opportunity to read and

[1:01:38] fewer would have the Opportunity to read and

[1:01:39] fewer would have the Opportunity to read and Understand it and even fewer

[1:01:39] opportunity to read and Understand it and even fewer

[1:01:39] opportunity to read and Understand it and even fewer Would be able to on such such

[1:01:42] understand it and even fewer Would be able to on such such

[1:01:42] understand it and even fewer Would be able to on such such Short notice arrange their

[1:01:43] would be able to on such such Short notice arrange their

[1:01:43] would be able to on such such Short notice arrange their Personal schedules and venture

[1:01:46] short notice arrange their Personal schedules and venture

[1:01:46] short notice arrange their Personal schedules and venture Out in the frigid weather to

[1:01:47] personal schedules and venture Out in the frigid weather to

[1:01:47] personal schedules and venture Out in the frigid weather to Come here tonight.

[1:01:47] out in the frigid weather to Come here tonight.

[1:01:47] out in the frigid weather to Come here tonight. This is not transparency.

[1:01:49] come here tonight. This is not transparency.

[1:01:49] come here tonight. This is not transparency. >> this is not a genuine

[1:01:50] this is not transparency. >> this is not a genuine

[1:01:50] this is not transparency. >> this is not a genuine Discussion.

[1:01:53] » this is not a genuine Discussion.

[1:01:53] » this is not a genuine Discussion. The hearing is put on the same

[1:01:54] discussion. The hearing is put on the same

[1:01:54] discussion. The hearing is put on the same Agenda as the vote which might

[1:01:57] the hearing is put on the same Agenda as the vote which might

[1:01:57] the hearing is put on the same Agenda as the vote which might Occur just an hour later if

[1:02:01] agenda as the vote which might Occur just an hour later if

[1:02:01] agenda as the vote which might Occur just an hour later if Council members have already

[1:02:02] occur just an hour later if Council members have already

[1:02:02] occur just an hour later if Council members have already Firmly made up their minds

[1:02:02] council members have already Firmly made up their minds

[1:02:02] council members have already Firmly made up their minds What's the point of a public

[1:02:04] firmly made up their minds What's the point of a public

[1:02:05] firmly made up their minds What's the point of a public Hearing?

[1:02:05] what's the point of a public Hearing?

[1:02:05] what's the point of a public Hearing? If not, they will have

[1:02:06] hearing? If not, they will have

[1:02:06] hearing? If not, they will have Virtually no time to take into

[1:02:08] if not, they will have Virtually no time to take into

[1:02:09] if not, they will have Virtually no time to take into Consideration the input from

[1:02:09] virtually no time to take into Consideration the input from

[1:02:09] virtually no time to take into Consideration the input from The public which has been very

[1:02:12] consideration the input from The public which has been very

[1:02:12] consideration the input from The public which has been very Factual and very strong.

[1:02:13] the public which has been very Factual and very strong.

[1:02:13] the public which has been very Factual and very strong. We're discussing among

[1:02:14] factual and very strong. We're discussing among

[1:02:14] factual and very strong. We're discussing among Themselves the second issue.

[1:02:18] we're discussing among Themselves the second issue.

[1:02:19] we're discussing among Themselves the second issue. >> I just want to echo some

[1:02:19] themselves the second issue. >> I just want to echo some

[1:02:20] themselves the second issue. >> I just want to echo some Of the things that have already

[1:02:20] » I just want to echo some Of the things that have already

[1:02:20] » I just want to echo some Of the things that have already Been said.

[1:02:22] of the things that have already Been said.

[1:02:22] of the things that have already Been said. Councilwoman briggs goes on to

[1:02:23] been said. Councilwoman briggs goes on to

[1:02:23] been said. Councilwoman briggs goes on to Say in her newsletter the staff

[1:02:24] councilwoman briggs goes on to Say in her newsletter the staff

[1:02:24] councilwoman briggs goes on to Say in her newsletter the staff Report acknowledges that the

[1:02:26] say in her newsletter the staff Report acknowledges that the

[1:02:26] say in her newsletter the staff Report acknowledges that the Brownfield plan does not meet

[1:02:27] report acknowledges that the Brownfield plan does not meet

[1:02:27] report acknowledges that the Brownfield plan does not meet The city's brownfield policy

[1:02:30] brownfield plan does not meet The city's brownfield policy

[1:02:30] brownfield plan does not meet The city's brownfield policy But the staff nevertheless

[1:02:30] the city's brownfield policy But the staff nevertheless

[1:02:31] the city's brownfield policy But the staff nevertheless Recommends it.

[1:02:31] but the staff nevertheless Recommends it.

[1:02:31] but the staff nevertheless Recommends it. We've heard some ways that it

[1:02:34] recommends it. We've heard some ways that it

[1:02:34] recommends it. We've heard some ways that it Does not meet the policy.

[1:02:35] we've heard some ways that it Does not meet the policy.

[1:02:35] we've heard some ways that it Does not meet the policy. One is that the requirement for

[1:02:38] does not meet the policy. One is that the requirement for

[1:02:38] does not meet the policy. One is that the requirement for 15 percent of the units to be

[1:02:39] one is that the requirement for 15 percent of the units to be

[1:02:39] one is that the requirement for 15 percent of the units to be Affordable was removed

[1:02:39] 15 percent of the units to be Affordable was removed

[1:02:39] 15 percent of the units to be Affordable was removed Inexplicably and no guarantee

[1:02:41] affordable was removed Inexplicably and no guarantee

[1:02:41] affordable was removed Inexplicably and no guarantee That 150 to 200 units

[1:02:42] inexplicably and no guarantee That 150 to 200 units

[1:02:42] inexplicably and no guarantee That 150 to 200 units Of affordable housing will even

[1:02:45] that 150 to 200 units Of affordable housing will even

[1:02:45] that 150 to 200 units Of affordable housing will even Occur.

[1:02:45] of affordable housing will even Occur.

[1:02:45] of affordable housing will even Occur. The main reason we're spending

[1:02:46] occur. The main reason we're spending

[1:02:46] occur. The main reason we're spending Over three million dollars in

[1:02:47] the main reason we're spending Over three million dollars in

[1:02:47] the main reason we're spending Over three million dollars in Tif is to get that.

[1:02:49] over three million dollars in Tif is to get that.

[1:02:50] over three million dollars in Tif is to get that. Also the policy limits the

[1:02:53] tif is to get that. Also the policy limits the

[1:02:53] tif is to get that. Also the policy limits the Amount of tax increment which

[1:02:54] also the policy limits the Amount of tax increment which

[1:02:54] also the policy limits the Amount of tax increment which Could be which could be

[1:02:54] amount of tax increment which Could be which could be

[1:02:55] amount of tax increment which Could be which could be Reimbursed to the developer to

[1:02:55] could be which could be Reimbursed to the developer to

[1:02:55] could be which could be Reimbursed to the developer to 20 percent of the private

[1:02:57] reimbursed to the developer to 20 percent of the private

[1:02:57] reimbursed to the developer to 20 percent of the private Investment and has already been

[1:02:58] 20 percent of the private Investment and has already been

[1:02:58] 20 percent of the private Investment and has already been Discussed here that

[1:03:01] investment and has already been Discussed here that

[1:03:01] investment and has already been Discussed here that Reimbursement goes up to the

[1:03:02] discussed here that Reimbursement goes up to the

[1:03:02] discussed here that Reimbursement goes up to the Figures we we calculate is

[1:03:02] reimbursement goes up to the Figures we we calculate is

[1:03:03] reimbursement goes up to the Figures we we calculate is Eighty one percent but it's far

[1:03:05] figures we we calculate is Eighty one percent but it's far

[1:03:06] figures we we calculate is Eighty one percent but it's far Exceeding 20 percent.

[1:03:06] eighty one percent but it's far Exceeding 20 percent.

[1:03:06] eighty one percent but it's far Exceeding 20 percent. However you crunch the numbers

[1:03:08] exceeding 20 percent. However you crunch the numbers

[1:03:09] exceeding 20 percent. However you crunch the numbers The city staff acknowledge

[1:03:09] however you crunch the numbers The city staff acknowledge

[1:03:09] however you crunch the numbers The city staff acknowledge There are many things, some

[1:03:13] the city staff acknowledge There are many things, some

[1:03:13] the city staff acknowledge There are many things, some Of them major, that have yet to

[1:03:14] there are many things, some Of them major, that have yet to

[1:03:14] there are many things, some Of them major, that have yet to Be resolved.

[1:03:14] of them major, that have yet to Be resolved.

[1:03:15] of them major, that have yet to Be resolved. So the question becomes what is

[1:03:16] be resolved. So the question becomes what is

[1:03:16] be resolved. So the question becomes what is The rush to approve this

[1:03:17] so the question becomes what is The rush to approve this

[1:03:17] so the question becomes what is The rush to approve this Brownfield financing plan

[1:03:18] the rush to approve this Brownfield financing plan

[1:03:18] the rush to approve this Brownfield financing plan Before the details of the

[1:03:20] brownfield financing plan Before the details of the

[1:03:21] brownfield financing plan Before the details of the Project that it would finance

[1:03:21] before the details of the Project that it would finance

[1:03:21] before the details of the Project that it would finance Haven't have been resolved?

[1:03:24] project that it would finance Haven't have been resolved?

[1:03:24] project that it would finance Haven't have been resolved? Tonight's vote should be

[1:03:25] haven't have been resolved? Tonight's vote should be

[1:03:25] haven't have been resolved? Tonight's vote should be Canceled and or postponed.

[1:03:25] tonight's vote should be Canceled and or postponed.

[1:03:26] tonight's vote should be Canceled and or postponed. This should be continued to

[1:03:28] canceled and or postponed. This should be continued to

[1:03:28] canceled and or postponed. This should be continued to Another date and the public

[1:03:29] this should be continued to Another date and the public

[1:03:29] this should be continued to Another date and the public Should be informed that written

[1:03:30] another date and the public Should be informed that written

[1:03:30] another date and the public Should be informed that written Submissions to council and

[1:03:32] should be informed that written Submissions to council and

[1:03:32] should be informed that written Submissions to council and Staff are welcome.

[1:03:33] submissions to council and Staff are welcome.

[1:03:33] submissions to council and Staff are welcome. >> thank you.

[1:03:33] staff are welcome. >> thank you.

[1:03:33] staff are welcome. >> thank you. Thank you.

[1:03:39] » thank you. Thank you.

[1:03:40] » thank you. Thank you. Hey there.

[1:03:40] thank you. Hey there.

[1:03:40] thank you. Hey there. Intervenor hamshari to see that

[1:03:44] hey there. Intervenor hamshari to see that

[1:03:44] hey there. Intervenor hamshari to see that Councilwoman hackman's going to

[1:03:47] intervenor hamshari to see that Councilwoman hackman's going to

[1:03:47] intervenor hamshari to see that Councilwoman hackman's going to Leave us because she's the only

[1:03:48] councilwoman hackman's going to Leave us because she's the only

[1:03:48] councilwoman hackman's going to Leave us because she's the only Person who ever responds to my

[1:03:49] leave us because she's the only Person who ever responds to my

[1:03:49] leave us because she's the only Person who ever responds to my Emails ever and I appreciate

[1:03:52] person who ever responds to my Emails ever and I appreciate

[1:03:52] person who ever responds to my Emails ever and I appreciate That.

[1:03:52] emails ever and I appreciate That.

[1:03:52] emails ever and I appreciate That. I really do.

[1:03:53] that. I really do.

[1:03:53] that. I really do. I mean it means a lot, you know

[1:03:55] I really do. I mean it means a lot, you know

[1:03:55] I really do. I mean it means a lot, you know And you know, just like I'll

[1:03:58] I mean it means a lot, you know And you know, just like I'll

[1:03:58] I mean it means a lot, you know And you know, just like I'll Get to it here.

[1:03:59] and you know, just like I'll Get to it here.

[1:03:59] and you know, just like I'll Get to it here. But I got to be honest like if

[1:04:00] get to it here. But I got to be honest like if

[1:04:00] get to it here. But I got to be honest like if If if you feel like you're in

[1:04:02] but I got to be honest like if If if you feel like you're in

[1:04:03] but I got to be honest like if If if you feel like you're in Pushed out and you're not

[1:04:03] if if you feel like you're in Pushed out and you're not

[1:04:03] if if you feel like you're in Pushed out and you're not Wanted that's a badge of honor

[1:04:04] pushed out and you're not Wanted that's a badge of honor

[1:04:04] pushed out and you're not Wanted that's a badge of honor From this crowd.

[1:04:06] wanted that's a badge of honor From this crowd.

[1:04:06] wanted that's a badge of honor From this crowd. So I was like I said I was on I

[1:04:08] from this crowd. So I was like I said I was on I

[1:04:08] from this crowd. So I was like I said I was on I Helped write and draft this

[1:04:08] so I was like I said I was on I Helped write and draft this

[1:04:08] so I was like I said I was on I Helped write and draft this Brownfield's policy and they

[1:04:11] helped write and draft this Brownfield's policy and they

[1:04:11] helped write and draft this Brownfield's policy and they Mostly all helped pass it and

[1:04:11] brownfield's policy and they Mostly all helped pass it and

[1:04:12] brownfield's policy and they Mostly all helped pass it and We had policies for a lot

[1:04:14] mostly all helped pass it and We had policies for a lot

[1:04:14] mostly all helped pass it and We had policies for a lot Of reasons here in the city.

[1:04:15] we had policies for a lot Of reasons here in the city.

[1:04:15] we had policies for a lot Of reasons here in the city. Of course we have a policy

[1:04:16] of reasons here in the city. Of course we have a policy

[1:04:16] of reasons here in the city. Of course we have a policy Agenda committee if you're on

[1:04:16] of course we have a policy Agenda committee if you're on

[1:04:17] of course we have a policy Agenda committee if you're on That committee you believe in

[1:04:18] agenda committee if you're on That committee you believe in

[1:04:18] agenda committee if you're on That committee you believe in What you do, then you know the

[1:04:19] that committee you believe in What you do, then you know the

[1:04:19] that committee you believe in What you do, then you know the Policies are important.

[1:04:21] what you do, then you know the Policies are important.

[1:04:21] what you do, then you know the Policies are important. We have a general fund reserve

[1:04:22] policies are important. We have a general fund reserve

[1:04:22] policies are important. We have a general fund reserve Policy that it can't go below a

[1:04:23] we have a general fund reserve Policy that it can't go below a

[1:04:23] we have a general fund reserve Policy that it can't go below a Certain limit.

[1:04:25] policy that it can't go below a Certain limit.

[1:04:25] policy that it can't go below a Certain limit. We have a binding limits to

[1:04:26] certain limit. We have a binding limits to

[1:04:26] certain limit. We have a binding limits to Legal debt limit that the full

[1:04:27] we have a binding limits to Legal debt limit that the full

[1:04:27] we have a binding limits to Legal debt limit that the full Faith and credit of the nra

[1:04:30] legal debt limit that the full Faith and credit of the nra

[1:04:30] legal debt limit that the full Faith and credit of the nra People can be on the hook for.

[1:04:30] faith and credit of the nra People can be on the hook for.

[1:04:31] faith and credit of the nra People can be on the hook for. We have public hearing one was

[1:04:33] people can be on the hook for. We have public hearing one was

[1:04:33] people can be on the hook for. We have public hearing one was Going to talk about streetscape

[1:04:34] we have public hearing one was Going to talk about streetscape

[1:04:34] we have public hearing one was Going to talk about streetscape Improvement policies where any

[1:04:37] going to talk about streetscape Improvement policies where any

[1:04:37] going to talk about streetscape Improvement policies where any Time we dig up the

[1:04:37] improvement policies where any Time we dig up the

[1:04:38] improvement policies where any Time we dig up the Infrastructure we do our proper

[1:04:40] time we dig up the Infrastructure we do our proper

[1:04:40] time we dig up the Infrastructure we do our proper Zanjeer improvements on top

[1:04:41] infrastructure we do our proper Zanjeer improvements on top

[1:04:41] infrastructure we do our proper Zanjeer improvements on top Of policy that we stick to.

[1:04:42] zanjeer improvements on top Of policy that we stick to.

[1:04:42] zanjeer improvements on top Of policy that we stick to. But for some reason this policy

[1:04:44] of policy that we stick to. But for some reason this policy

[1:04:44] of policy that we stick to. But for some reason this policy This brownfield policy isn't is

[1:04:45] but for some reason this policy This brownfield policy isn't is

[1:04:45] but for some reason this policy This brownfield policy isn't is It doing it for you here?

[1:04:46] this brownfield policy isn't is It doing it for you here?

[1:04:46] this brownfield policy isn't is It doing it for you here? You don't seem to want to stick

[1:04:48] it doing it for you here? You don't seem to want to stick

[1:04:48] it doing it for you here? You don't seem to want to stick To this one and it's a very

[1:04:49] you don't seem to want to stick To this one and it's a very

[1:04:49] you don't seem to want to stick To this one and it's a very Important one and setting aside

[1:04:52] to this one and it's a very Important one and setting aside

[1:04:52] to this one and it's a very Important one and setting aside All the things I'm sure others

[1:04:52] important one and setting aside All the things I'm sure others

[1:04:52] important one and setting aside All the things I'm sure others Are going to say about the

[1:04:53] all the things I'm sure others Are going to say about the

[1:04:53] all the things I'm sure others Are going to say about the Shirking of your fiduciary

[1:04:55] are going to say about the Shirking of your fiduciary

[1:04:55] are going to say about the Shirking of your fiduciary Responsibilities, the horrible

[1:04:56] shirking of your fiduciary Responsibilities, the horrible

[1:04:56] shirking of your fiduciary Responsibilities, the horrible Optics, the way that that brown

[1:04:59] responsibilities, the horrible Optics, the way that that brown

[1:04:59] responsibilities, the horrible Optics, the way that that brown Field plan leans heavily on the

[1:05:00] optics, the way that that brown Field plan leans heavily on the

[1:05:00] optics, the way that that brown Field plan leans heavily on the State three bids it was

[1:05:01] field plan leans heavily on the State three bids it was

[1:05:01] field plan leans heavily on the State three bids it was Created one hundred thirty nine

[1:05:04] state three bids it was Created one hundred thirty nine

[1:05:04] state three bids it was Created one hundred thirty nine Parcels in the state street

[1:05:04] created one hundred thirty nine Parcels in the state street

[1:05:05] created one hundred thirty nine Parcels in the state street Bids zone went out for a vote.

[1:05:08] parcels in the state street Bids zone went out for a vote.

[1:05:08] parcels in the state street Bids zone went out for a vote. There were thirty six people

[1:05:09] bids zone went out for a vote. There were thirty six people

[1:05:09] bids zone went out for a vote. There were thirty six people Replied and voted in favor but

[1:05:11] there were thirty six people Replied and voted in favor but

[1:05:12] there were thirty six people Replied and voted in favor but In twenty six of those votes

[1:05:12] replied and voted in favor but In twenty six of those votes

[1:05:12] replied and voted in favor but In twenty six of those votes Were jeff hartmans votes.

[1:05:13] in twenty six of those votes Were jeff hartmans votes.

[1:05:13] in twenty six of those votes Were jeff hartmans votes. So it shows you that real

[1:05:16] were jeff hartmans votes. So it shows you that real

[1:05:16] were jeff hartmans votes. So it shows you that real Estate capital buys you some

[1:05:17] so it shows you that real Estate capital buys you some

[1:05:17] so it shows you that real Estate capital buys you some Some clout in this city.

[1:05:19] estate capital buys you some Some clout in this city.

[1:05:19] estate capital buys you some Some clout in this city. So this policy has is a shell

[1:05:22] some clout in this city. So this policy has is a shell

[1:05:23] some clout in this city. So this policy has is a shell Enact type policy and it speaks

[1:05:26] so this policy has is a shell Enact type policy and it speaks

[1:05:26] so this policy has is a shell Enact type policy and it speaks Generally to the environmental

[1:05:27] enact type policy and it speaks Generally to the environmental

[1:05:27] enact type policy and it speaks Generally to the environmental Issues.

[1:05:28] generally to the environmental Issues.

[1:05:28] generally to the environmental Issues. It doesn't say anything about

[1:05:30] issues. It doesn't say anything about

[1:05:31] issues. It doesn't say anything about Buying twelve million dollars

[1:05:31] it doesn't say anything about Buying twelve million dollars

[1:05:31] it doesn't say anything about Buying twelve million dollars For some parking lots.

[1:05:32] buying twelve million dollars For some parking lots.

[1:05:32] buying twelve million dollars For some parking lots. Yeah, we're going to have to

[1:05:33] for some parking lots. Yeah, we're going to have to

[1:05:33] for some parking lots. Yeah, we're going to have to Own and operate in perpetuity

[1:05:35] yeah, we're going to have to Own and operate in perpetuity

[1:05:35] yeah, we're going to have to Own and operate in perpetuity Or the two hundred million

[1:05:36] own and operate in perpetuity Or the two hundred million

[1:05:36] own and operate in perpetuity Or the two hundred million We're putting up not the

[1:05:37] or the two hundred million We're putting up not the

[1:05:37] or the two hundred million We're putting up not the Project for the affordable

[1:05:37] we're putting up not the Project for the affordable

[1:05:38] we're putting up not the Project for the affordable Housing component.

[1:05:39] project for the affordable Housing component.

[1:05:39] project for the affordable Housing component. Twenty nineteen we had twelve

[1:05:40] housing component. Twenty nineteen we had twelve

[1:05:40] housing component. Twenty nineteen we had twelve Projects combined that are

[1:05:43] twenty nineteen we had twelve Projects combined that are

[1:05:43] twenty nineteen we had twelve Projects combined that are Asking for less than this in

[1:05:44] projects combined that are Asking for less than this in

[1:05:44] projects combined that are Asking for less than this in The city I'm now I'm going to

[1:05:47] asking for less than this in The city I'm now I'm going to

[1:05:47] asking for less than this in The city I'm now I'm going to Read right from the policy

[1:05:48] the city I'm now I'm going to Read right from the policy

[1:05:48] the city I'm now I'm going to Read right from the policy Document in case you haven't

[1:05:50] read right from the policy Document in case you haven't

[1:05:51] read right from the policy Document in case you haven't The overall benefits include

[1:05:51] document in case you haven't The overall benefits include

[1:05:51] document in case you haven't The overall benefits include Mitigation, public health

[1:05:54] the overall benefits include Mitigation, public health

[1:05:54] the overall benefits include Mitigation, public health Threats, blight removal and

[1:05:55] mitigation, public health Threats, blight removal and

[1:05:55] mitigation, public health Threats, blight removal and Either one of those is

[1:05:58] threats, blight removal and Either one of those is

[1:05:58] threats, blight removal and Either one of those is Happening here the city's

[1:05:59] either one of those is Happening here the city's

[1:05:59] either one of those is Happening here the city's Priority and utilizing

[1:05:59] happening here the city's Priority and utilizing

[1:05:59] happening here the city's Priority and utilizing Brownfield is environmental

[1:06:02] priority and utilizing Brownfield is environmental

[1:06:02] priority and utilizing Brownfield is environmental Remediation and protection

[1:06:03] brownfield is environmental Remediation and protection

[1:06:03] brownfield is environmental Remediation and protection Of public health and safety.

[1:06:06] remediation and protection Of public health and safety.

[1:06:06] remediation and protection Of public health and safety. Additional public benefit needs

[1:06:06] of public health and safety. Additional public benefit needs

[1:06:06] of public health and safety. Additional public benefit needs To be provided provisioning

[1:06:10] additional public benefit needs To be provided provisioning

[1:06:10] additional public benefit needs To be provided provisioning Of affordable housing by the

[1:06:10] to be provided provisioning Of affordable housing by the

[1:06:11] to be provided provisioning Of affordable housing by the Project, not the city public

[1:06:14] of affordable housing by the Project, not the city public

[1:06:15] of affordable housing by the Project, not the city public Infrastructure improvements not

[1:06:17] project, not the city public Infrastructure improvements not

[1:06:17] project, not the city public Infrastructure improvements not Otherwise required to support

[1:06:18] infrastructure improvements not Otherwise required to support

[1:06:18] infrastructure improvements not Otherwise required to support The development.

[1:06:21] otherwise required to support The development.

[1:06:21] otherwise required to support The development. This is all for the development

[1:06:22] the development. This is all for the development

[1:06:22] the development. This is all for the development These parking structures.

[1:06:25] this is all for the development These parking structures.

[1:06:25] this is all for the development These parking structures. The city has increased its

[1:06:26] these parking structures. The city has increased its

[1:06:26] these parking structures. The city has increased its Scrutiny of the need to approve

[1:06:28] the city has increased its Scrutiny of the need to approve

[1:06:29] the city has increased its Scrutiny of the need to approve Tef for brownfield projects.

[1:06:29] scrutiny of the need to approve Tef for brownfield projects.

[1:06:29] scrutiny of the need to approve Tef for brownfield projects. There's only so much tax

[1:06:33] tef for brownfield projects. There's only so much tax

[1:06:33] tef for brownfield projects. There's only so much tax Deferral we can take its

[1:06:36] there's only so much tax Deferral we can take its

[1:06:37] there's only so much tax Deferral we can take its Imperative therefore avoiding

[1:06:37] deferral we can take its Imperative therefore avoiding

[1:06:37] deferral we can take its Imperative therefore avoiding Excessive returns and

[1:06:40] imperative therefore avoiding Excessive returns and

[1:06:40] imperative therefore avoiding Excessive returns and Safeguarding public funds.

[1:06:41] excessive returns and Safeguarding public funds.

[1:06:41] excessive returns and Safeguarding public funds. >> critical

[1:06:48] you must have a

[1:06:49] you must have a Public purpose.

[1:06:51] you must have a Public purpose.

[1:06:51] you must have a Public purpose. Thank you

[1:06:59] .

[1:06:59] . Is there anyone else in house

[1:07:00] . Is there anyone else in house

[1:07:00] . Is there anyone else in house Who would like to speak this

[1:07:01] is there anyone else in house Who would like to speak this

[1:07:01] is there anyone else in house Who would like to speak this Public hearing?

[1:07:06] who would like to speak this Public hearing?

[1:07:06] who would like to speak this Public hearing? Good evening from the

[1:07:07] public hearing? Good evening from the

[1:07:07] public hearing? Good evening from the Discussion here a little bit

[1:07:09] good evening from the Discussion here a little bit

[1:07:10] good evening from the Discussion here a little bit Moundsville center I'm ceo of a

[1:07:10] discussion here a little bit Moundsville center I'm ceo of a

[1:07:10] discussion here a little bit Moundsville center I'm ceo of a No spark and I'm here tonight

[1:07:13] moundsville center I'm ceo of a No spark and I'm here tonight

[1:07:13] moundsville center I'm ceo of a No spark and I'm here tonight Representing our organization

[1:07:13] no spark and I'm here tonight Representing our organization

[1:07:14] no spark and I'm here tonight Representing our organization And a coalition of public,

[1:07:14] representing our organization And a coalition of public,

[1:07:14] representing our organization And a coalition of public, Private and academic leaders

[1:07:17] and a coalition of public, Private and academic leaders

[1:07:17] and a coalition of public, Private and academic leaders That we work with daily.

[1:07:18] private and academic leaders That we work with daily.

[1:07:18] private and academic leaders That we work with daily. So I'm here in support of the

[1:07:19] that we work with daily. So I'm here in support of the

[1:07:19] that we work with daily. So I'm here in support of the Irs project and spark our

[1:07:21] so I'm here in support of the Irs project and spark our

[1:07:21] so I'm here in support of the Irs project and spark our Mission is centered on smart

[1:07:22] irs project and spark our Mission is centered on smart

[1:07:22] irs project and spark our Mission is centered on smart Economic growth and service

[1:07:25] mission is centered on smart Economic growth and service

[1:07:25] mission is centered on smart Economic growth and service Prosperity for all.

[1:07:25] economic growth and service Prosperity for all.

[1:07:25] economic growth and service Prosperity for all. Our board recently expanded

[1:07:26] prosperity for all. Our board recently expanded

[1:07:26] prosperity for all. Our board recently expanded That mission to include quality

[1:07:29] our board recently expanded That mission to include quality

[1:07:29] our board recently expanded That mission to include quality Of place recognizing economic

[1:07:30] that mission to include quality Of place recognizing economic

[1:07:30] that mission to include quality Of place recognizing economic Growth and community well-being

[1:07:31] of place recognizing economic Growth and community well-being

[1:07:31] of place recognizing economic Growth and community well-being Are inseparable simply put and

[1:07:32] growth and community well-being Are inseparable simply put and

[1:07:33] growth and community well-being Are inseparable simply put and Our future depends on where

[1:07:33] are inseparable simply put and Our future depends on where

[1:07:33] are inseparable simply put and Our future depends on where People on whether people can

[1:07:37] our future depends on where People on whether people can

[1:07:37] our future depends on where People on whether people can Afford to live here especially

[1:07:40] people on whether people can Afford to live here especially

[1:07:40] people on whether people can Afford to live here especially Near where they work.

[1:07:41] afford to live here especially Near where they work.

[1:07:41] afford to live here especially Near where they work. Housing supply has not kept

[1:07:41] near where they work. Housing supply has not kept

[1:07:42] near where they work. Housing supply has not kept Pace with demand as we all know

[1:07:44] housing supply has not kept Pace with demand as we all know

[1:07:44] housing supply has not kept Pace with demand as we all know ,prices continue to rise,

[1:07:45] pace with demand as we all know ,prices continue to rise,

[1:07:45] pace with demand as we all know ,prices continue to rise, Putting young professionals and

[1:07:45] ,prices continue to rise, Putting young professionals and

[1:07:46] ,prices continue to rise, Putting young professionals and Long term residents farther

[1:07:46] putting young professionals and Long term residents farther

[1:07:46] putting young professionals and Long term residents farther From opportunity and our

[1:07:48] long term residents farther From opportunity and our

[1:07:49] long term residents farther From opportunity and our Addresses that gap by adding

[1:07:49] from opportunity and our Addresses that gap by adding

[1:07:49] from opportunity and our Addresses that gap by adding Meaningful housing in a

[1:07:50] addresses that gap by adding Meaningful housing in a

[1:07:50] addresses that gap by adding Meaningful housing in a Location it makes sense this

[1:07:53] meaningful housing in a Location it makes sense this

[1:07:53] meaningful housing in a Location it makes sense this Project matters because of who

[1:07:54] location it makes sense this Project matters because of who

[1:07:54] location it makes sense this Project matters because of who It serves.

[1:07:54] project matters because of who It serves.

[1:07:54] project matters because of who It serves. The proposed housing is

[1:07:56] it serves. The proposed housing is

[1:07:56] it serves. The proposed housing is Designed for people earlier in

[1:07:57] the proposed housing is Designed for people earlier in

[1:07:57] the proposed housing is Designed for people earlier in Their career for the workers

[1:08:00] designed for people earlier in Their career for the workers

[1:08:00] designed for people earlier in Their career for the workers Are local employers are

[1:08:01] their career for the workers Are local employers are

[1:08:01] their career for the workers Are local employers are Fighting to recruit today our

[1:08:01] are local employers are Fighting to recruit today our

[1:08:01] are local employers are Fighting to recruit today our Lack of options for this

[1:08:04] fighting to recruit today our Lack of options for this

[1:08:05] fighting to recruit today our Lack of options for this Demographic is a real

[1:08:05] lack of options for this Demographic is a real

[1:08:05] lack of options for this Demographic is a real Constraint on our economic

[1:08:06] demographic is a real Constraint on our economic

[1:08:06] demographic is a real Constraint on our economic Competitiveness.

[1:08:06] constraint on our economic Competitiveness.

[1:08:06] constraint on our economic Competitiveness. It's also a clear community

[1:08:09] competitiveness. It's also a clear community

[1:08:09] competitiveness. It's also a clear community Benefit in the design.

[1:08:09] it's also a clear community Benefit in the design.

[1:08:09] it's also a clear community Benefit in the design. Irs transforms a major gateway

[1:08:12] benefit in the design. Irs transforms a major gateway

[1:08:12] benefit in the design. Irs transforms a major gateway Along state street to ninety

[1:08:13] irs transforms a major gateway Along state street to ninety

[1:08:13] irs transforms a major gateway Along state street to ninety Four first impressions matter

[1:08:13] along state street to ninety Four first impressions matter

[1:08:14] along state street to ninety Four first impressions matter And this project creates a

[1:08:16] four first impressions matter And this project creates a

[1:08:17] four first impressions matter And this project creates a Vibrant mixed use environment

[1:08:17] and this project creates a Vibrant mixed use environment

[1:08:17] and this project creates a Vibrant mixed use environment For the thousands who enter our

[1:08:18] vibrant mixed use environment For the thousands who enter our

[1:08:18] vibrant mixed use environment For the thousands who enter our City

[1:08:37] every day because they

[1:08:38] every day because they

[1:08:38] every day because they Don't work here or they don't

[1:08:39] every day because they Don't work here or they don't

[1:08:39] every day because they Don't work here or they don't Live here from a fiscal

[1:08:39] don't work here or they don't Live here from a fiscal

[1:08:39] don't work here or they don't Live here from a fiscal Standpoint increased tax

[1:08:40] live here from a fiscal Standpoint increased tax

[1:08:40] live here from a fiscal Standpoint increased tax Revenue is directed and

[1:08:40] standpoint increased tax Revenue is directed and

[1:08:41] standpoint increased tax Revenue is directed and Supports structure parking and

[1:08:41] revenue is directed and Supports structure parking and

[1:08:41] revenue is directed and Supports structure parking and Sewer infrastructure

[1:08:42] supports structure parking and Sewer infrastructure

[1:08:42] supports structure parking and Sewer infrastructure Improvements and transportation

[1:08:42] sewer infrastructure Improvements and transportation

[1:08:43] sewer infrastructure Improvements and transportation Investments that reduce car

[1:08:43] improvements and transportation Investments that reduce car

[1:08:43] improvements and transportation Investments that reduce car Dependency while maintaining

[1:08:44] investments that reduce car Dependency while maintaining

[1:08:44] investments that reduce car Dependency while maintaining Realistic access.

[1:08:44] dependency while maintaining Realistic access.

[1:08:44] dependency while maintaining Realistic access. Public private partnerships

[1:08:45] realistic access. Public private partnerships

[1:08:45] realistic access. Public private partnerships Like this are the norm in

[1:08:46] public private partnerships Like this are the norm in

[1:08:46] public private partnerships Like this are the norm in Growing cities.

[1:08:46] like this are the norm in Growing cities.

[1:08:46] like this are the norm in Growing cities. Without them, projects often

[1:08:47] growing cities. Without them, projects often

[1:08:47] growing cities. Without them, projects often Don't pencil out given today's

[1:08:48] without them, projects often Don't pencil out given today's

[1:08:48] without them, projects often Don't pencil out given today's Construction and financing

[1:08:48] don't pencil out given today's Construction and financing

[1:08:48] don't pencil out given today's Construction and financing Costs, this partnership allows

[1:08:49] construction and financing Costs, this partnership allows

[1:08:49] construction and financing Costs, this partnership allows Us to build the density that we

[1:08:50] costs, this partnership allows Us to build the density that we

[1:08:50] costs, this partnership allows Us to build the density that we Need.

[1:08:50] us to build the density that we Need.

[1:08:50] us to build the density that we Need. Tommasini straightforward

[1:08:51] need. Tommasini straightforward

[1:08:51] need. Tommasini straightforward Research council approve the

[1:08:51] tommasini straightforward Research council approve the

[1:08:51] tommasini straightforward Research council approve the Brownfield plan.

[1:08:52] research council approve the Brownfield plan.

[1:08:52] research council approve the Brownfield plan. The smart investment

[1:08:52] brownfield plan. The smart investment

[1:08:53] brownfield plan. The smart investment Strengthens our tax base and

[1:08:53] the smart investment Strengthens our tax base and

[1:08:53] the smart investment Strengthens our tax base and Supports the kind of inclusive

[1:08:54] strengthens our tax base and Supports the kind of inclusive

[1:08:54] strengthens our tax base and Supports the kind of inclusive Growth that we need.

[1:08:54] supports the kind of inclusive Growth that we need.

[1:08:55] supports the kind of inclusive Growth that we need. >> thank you.

[1:08:55] growth that we need. >> thank you.

[1:08:55] growth that we need. >> thank you. Thank you

[1:09:01] .

[1:09:02] . Good evening.

[1:09:05] . Good evening.

[1:09:05] . Good evening. And thinking about this project

[1:09:09] good evening. And thinking about this project

[1:09:09] good evening. And thinking about this project I actually looked up a term

[1:09:10] and thinking about this project I actually looked up a term

[1:09:10] and thinking about this project I actually looked up a term Opportunity cost the loss

[1:09:14] I actually looked up a term Opportunity cost the loss

[1:09:14] I actually looked up a term Opportunity cost the loss Of potential gain from other

[1:09:14] opportunity cost the loss Of potential gain from other

[1:09:15] opportunity cost the loss Of potential gain from other Alternatives when one

[1:09:18] of potential gain from other Alternatives when one

[1:09:18] of potential gain from other Alternatives when one Alternative is chosen.

[1:09:18] alternatives when one Alternative is chosen.

[1:09:18] alternatives when one Alternative is chosen. We've heard a lot about the

[1:09:22] alternative is chosen. We've heard a lot about the

[1:09:22] alternative is chosen. We've heard a lot about the Financial implications but it's

[1:09:22] we've heard a lot about the Financial implications but it's

[1:09:22] we've heard a lot about the Financial implications but it's Really more than just a

[1:09:23] financial implications but it's Really more than just a

[1:09:23] financial implications but it's Really more than just a Financial implications.

[1:09:26] really more than just a Financial implications.

[1:09:26] really more than just a Financial implications. It's also the amount of staff

[1:09:27] financial implications. It's also the amount of staff

[1:09:27] financial implications. It's also the amount of staff Time that has been spent trying

[1:09:31] it's also the amount of staff Time that has been spent trying

[1:09:31] it's also the amount of staff Time that has been spent trying To make this work and other

[1:09:34] time that has been spent trying To make this work and other

[1:09:34] time that has been spent trying To make this work and other Alternatives we haven't

[1:09:34] to make this work and other Alternatives we haven't

[1:09:35] to make this work and other Alternatives we haven't Considered.

[1:09:37] alternatives we haven't Considered.

[1:09:38] alternatives we haven't Considered. Maybe we should look at a

[1:09:38] considered. Maybe we should look at a

[1:09:39] considered. Maybe we should look at a Sports illustrated type

[1:09:41] maybe we should look at a Sports illustrated type

[1:09:41] maybe we should look at a Sports illustrated type Development while it wasn't

[1:09:42] sports illustrated type Development while it wasn't

[1:09:42] sports illustrated type Development while it wasn't Popular it might actually be a

[1:09:46] development while it wasn't Popular it might actually be a

[1:09:46] development while it wasn't Popular it might actually be a Better alternative based on

[1:09:47] popular it might actually be a Better alternative based on

[1:09:47] popular it might actually be a Better alternative based on Some metrics.

[1:09:49] better alternative based on Some metrics.

[1:09:50] better alternative based on Some metrics. So anyway, let's look at what

[1:09:51] some metrics. So anyway, let's look at what

[1:09:51] some metrics. So anyway, let's look at what We're missing in terms

[1:09:54] so anyway, let's look at what We're missing in terms

[1:09:54] so anyway, let's look at what We're missing in terms Of pedestrian safety because I

[1:09:55] we're missing in terms Of pedestrian safety because I

[1:09:55] we're missing in terms Of pedestrian safety because I Always have to talk about that

[1:09:57] of pedestrian safety because I Always have to talk about that

[1:09:57] of pedestrian safety because I Always have to talk about that We don't have funding for

[1:09:58] always have to talk about that We don't have funding for

[1:09:58] always have to talk about that We don't have funding for Streetlights.

[1:10:01] we don't have funding for Streetlights.

[1:10:01] we don't have funding for Streetlights. We don't have money to put in

[1:10:02] streetlights. We don't have money to put in

[1:10:02] streetlights. We don't have money to put in Sidewalks but we have time to

[1:10:05] we don't have money to put in Sidewalks but we have time to

[1:10:05] we don't have money to put in Sidewalks but we have time to Spend hundreds and hundreds

[1:10:05] sidewalks but we have time to Spend hundreds and hundreds

[1:10:06] sidewalks but we have time to Spend hundreds and hundreds Of hours to try to make this

[1:10:09] spend hundreds and hundreds Of hours to try to make this

[1:10:09] spend hundreds and hundreds Of hours to try to make this Work.

[1:10:09] of hours to try to make this Work.

[1:10:10] of hours to try to make this Work. >> thank you.

[1:10:12] work. >> thank you.

[1:10:12] work. >> thank you. Thank you

[1:10:23] , tim rhodes.

[1:10:23] , tim rhodes. I live on 440 south first

[1:10:24] , tim rhodes. I live on 440 south first

[1:10:24] , tim rhodes. I live on 440 south first Street.

[1:10:26] I live on 440 south first Street.

[1:10:26] I live on 440 south first Street. I'm here to speak against this

[1:10:27] street. I'm here to speak against this

[1:10:27] street. I'm here to speak against this Plan.

[1:10:27] I'm here to speak against this Plan.

[1:10:27] I'm here to speak against this Plan. I believe that we should simply

[1:10:30] plan. I believe that we should simply

[1:10:30] plan. I believe that we should simply Wait for another development

[1:10:31] I believe that we should simply Wait for another development

[1:10:31] I believe that we should simply Wait for another development That will pay taxes.

[1:10:34] wait for another development That will pay taxes.

[1:10:34] wait for another development That will pay taxes. Many developments are taking

[1:10:35] that will pay taxes. Many developments are taking

[1:10:35] that will pay taxes. Many developments are taking Care of their parking.

[1:10:38] many developments are taking Care of their parking.

[1:10:38] many developments are taking Care of their parking. Harland is a great example.

[1:10:39] care of their parking. Harland is a great example.

[1:10:39] care of their parking. Harland is a great example. Several projects downtown they

[1:10:42] harland is a great example. Several projects downtown they

[1:10:42] harland is a great example. Several projects downtown they Take care of their own parking

[1:10:43] several projects downtown they Take care of their own parking

[1:10:43] several projects downtown they Take care of their own parking And they would they don't need

[1:10:45] take care of their own parking And they would they don't need

[1:10:45] take care of their own parking And they would they don't need It if we're using a whole

[1:10:46] and they would they don't need It if we're using a whole

[1:10:46] and they would they don't need It if we're using a whole Boatload of money for this and

[1:10:49] it if we're using a whole Boatload of money for this and

[1:10:49] it if we're using a whole Boatload of money for this and It's just not a good use of our

[1:10:53] boatload of money for this and It's just not a good use of our

[1:10:53] boatload of money for this and It's just not a good use of our Money, we're not getting enough

[1:10:54] it's just not a good use of our Money, we're not getting enough

[1:10:54] it's just not a good use of our Money, we're not getting enough Value for this.

[1:10:54] money, we're not getting enough Value for this.

[1:10:54] money, we're not getting enough Value for this. It's just a bad bad plan.

[1:10:57] value for this. It's just a bad bad plan.

[1:10:57] value for this. It's just a bad bad plan. So I would urge you all to not

[1:11:01] it's just a bad bad plan. So I would urge you all to not

[1:11:01] it's just a bad bad plan. So I would urge you all to not Not pursue this.

[1:11:01] so I would urge you all to not Not pursue this.

[1:11:01] so I would urge you all to not Not pursue this. Thank you so much.

[1:11:02] not pursue this. Thank you so much.

[1:11:02] not pursue this. Thank you so much. Thank you.

[1:11:08] thank you so much. Thank you.

[1:11:08] thank you so much. Thank you. Is there anyone else in house

[1:11:09] thank you. Is there anyone else in house

[1:11:09] thank you. Is there anyone else in house Would like to speak at this

[1:11:12] is there anyone else in house Would like to speak at this

[1:11:12] is there anyone else in house Would like to speak at this Public hearing?

[1:11:15] would like to speak at this Public hearing?

[1:11:15] would like to speak at this Public hearing? >> charles rheem I am just so

[1:11:16] public hearing? >> charles rheem I am just so

[1:11:16] public hearing? >> charles rheem I am just so Stunned that this can be called

[1:11:20] » charles rheem I am just so Stunned that this can be called

[1:11:20] » charles rheem I am just so Stunned that this can be called The brown field plan instead

[1:11:20] stunned that this can be called The brown field plan instead

[1:11:20] stunned that this can be called The brown field plan instead Of a parking plan if the

[1:11:23] the brown field plan instead Of a parking plan if the

[1:11:23] the brown field plan instead Of a parking plan if the Citizens of our neighbor found

[1:11:24] of a parking plan if the Citizens of our neighbor found

[1:11:24] of a parking plan if the Citizens of our neighbor found Out you were going to spend a

[1:11:27] citizens of our neighbor found Out you were going to spend a

[1:11:28] citizens of our neighbor found Out you were going to spend a Third of a billion of their tax

[1:11:30] out you were going to spend a Third of a billion of their tax

[1:11:30] out you were going to spend a Third of a billion of their tax To give to a developer to do

[1:11:31] third of a billion of their tax To give to a developer to do

[1:11:31] third of a billion of their tax To give to a developer to do This, they would gasp and they

[1:11:34] to give to a developer to do This, they would gasp and they

[1:11:34] to give to a developer to do This, they would gasp and they Will show how they feel in the

[1:11:35] this, they would gasp and they Will show how they feel in the

[1:11:35] this, they would gasp and they Will show how they feel in the Next election.

[1:11:38] will show how they feel in the Next election.

[1:11:38] will show how they feel in the Next election. I think you probably are

[1:11:39] next election. I think you probably are

[1:11:39] next election. I think you probably are Familiar with ypsilanti and the

[1:11:41] I think you probably are Familiar with ypsilanti and the

[1:11:41] I think you probably are Familiar with ypsilanti and the Water street project that they

[1:11:42] familiar with ypsilanti and the Water street project that they

[1:11:42] familiar with ypsilanti and the Water street project that they Got involved in.

[1:11:42] water street project that they Got involved in.

[1:11:42] water street project that they Got involved in. It was a sure thing it was

[1:11:45] got involved in. It was a sure thing it was

[1:11:45] got involved in. It was a sure thing it was Going to do fine.

[1:11:46] it was a sure thing it was Going to do fine.

[1:11:46] it was a sure thing it was Going to do fine. They were going to make a lot

[1:11:47] going to do fine. They were going to make a lot

[1:11:47] going to do fine. They were going to make a lot Of money and it completely

[1:11:50] they were going to make a lot Of money and it completely

[1:11:50] they were going to make a lot Of money and it completely Collapsed.

[1:11:50] of money and it completely Collapsed.

[1:11:50] of money and it completely Collapsed. If we have a big collapse

[1:11:53] collapsed. If we have a big collapse

[1:11:53] collapsed. If we have a big collapse That'll do it anyway.

[1:11:54] if we have a big collapse That'll do it anyway.

[1:11:54] if we have a big collapse That'll do it anyway. They were underwater for I

[1:11:57] that'll do it anyway. They were underwater for I

[1:11:57] that'll do it anyway. They were underwater for I Think more than a decade really

[1:11:58] they were underwater for I Think more than a decade really

[1:11:58] they were underwater for I Think more than a decade really In a desperate situation in

[1:12:01] think more than a decade really In a desperate situation in

[1:12:01] think more than a decade really In a desperate situation in Ypsilanti to finance their city

[1:12:02] in a desperate situation in Ypsilanti to finance their city

[1:12:02] in a desperate situation in Ypsilanti to finance their city Because they put public money

[1:12:03] ypsilanti to finance their city Because they put public money

[1:12:03] ypsilanti to finance their city Because they put public money Taxpayers money into some

[1:12:05] because they put public money Taxpayers money into some

[1:12:05] because they put public money Taxpayers money into some Project and it failed utterly

[1:12:06] taxpayers money into some Project and it failed utterly

[1:12:06] taxpayers money into some Project and it failed utterly And I hope that's not repeated

[1:12:09] project and it failed utterly And I hope that's not repeated

[1:12:09] project and it failed utterly And I hope that's not repeated Here in ann arbor.

[1:12:10] and I hope that's not repeated Here in ann arbor.

[1:12:10] and I hope that's not repeated Here in ann arbor. Thank you

[1:12:24] .

[1:12:24] . Thank you, mayor taylor and

[1:12:25] . Thank you, mayor taylor and

[1:12:25] . Thank you, mayor taylor and Control ken garber.

[1:12:28] thank you, mayor taylor and Control ken garber.

[1:12:28] thank you, mayor taylor and Control ken garber. Second word I actually agree

[1:12:29] control ken garber. Second word I actually agree

[1:12:29] control ken garber. Second word I actually agree With mr. Sancerre and spark

[1:12:30] second word I actually agree With mr. Sancerre and spark

[1:12:30] second word I actually agree With mr. Sancerre and spark That there are a lot

[1:12:32] with mr. Sancerre and spark That there are a lot

[1:12:32] with mr. Sancerre and spark That there are a lot Of benefits to this project

[1:12:33] that there are a lot Of benefits to this project

[1:12:33] that there are a lot Of benefits to this project That's undeniable but the

[1:12:35] of benefits to this project That's undeniable but the

[1:12:35] of benefits to this project That's undeniable but the Parking projections are all

[1:12:36] that's undeniable but the Parking projections are all

[1:12:36] that's undeniable but the Parking projections are all Wrong.

[1:12:36] parking projections are all Wrong.

[1:12:36] parking projections are all Wrong. Crawford joint consultant pfm

[1:12:40] wrong. Crawford joint consultant pfm

[1:12:40] wrong. Crawford joint consultant pfm Use the urban land land

[1:12:43] crawford joint consultant pfm Use the urban land land

[1:12:43] crawford joint consultant pfm Use the urban land land Institute shared parking second

[1:12:44] use the urban land land Institute shared parking second

[1:12:44] use the urban land land Institute shared parking second Edition model to set the

[1:12:46] institute shared parking second Edition model to set the

[1:12:46] institute shared parking second Edition model to set the Parking demand for the office

[1:12:47] edition model to set the Parking demand for the office

[1:12:47] edition model to set the Parking demand for the office Component at one thousand four

[1:12:48] parking demand for the office Component at one thousand four

[1:12:48] parking demand for the office Component at one thousand four Hundred forty seven spaces.

[1:12:51] component at one thousand four Hundred forty seven spaces.

[1:12:51] component at one thousand four Hundred forty seven spaces. Those are the two buildings

[1:12:52] hundred forty seven spaces. Those are the two buildings

[1:12:52] hundred forty seven spaces. Those are the two buildings Seven seven seven and seven

[1:12:55] those are the two buildings Seven seven seven and seven

[1:12:55] those are the two buildings Seven seven seven and seven Eighty nine eisenhauer and now

[1:12:55] seven seven seven and seven Eighty nine eisenhauer and now

[1:12:55] seven seven seven and seven Eighty nine eisenhauer and now Have one thousand four hundred

[1:12:56] eighty nine eisenhauer and now Have one thousand four hundred

[1:12:56] eighty nine eisenhauer and now Have one thousand four hundred Ninety six spaces available

[1:12:59] have one thousand four hundred Ninety six spaces available

[1:12:59] have one thousand four hundred Ninety six spaces available Roughly the same.

[1:12:59] ninety six spaces available Roughly the same.

[1:12:59] ninety six spaces available Roughly the same. But the model does not consider

[1:13:02] roughly the same. But the model does not consider

[1:13:02] roughly the same. But the model does not consider The transit corridor or remote

[1:13:03] but the model does not consider The transit corridor or remote

[1:13:03] but the model does not consider The transit corridor or remote Work trends.

[1:13:04] the transit corridor or remote Work trends.

[1:13:04] the transit corridor or remote Work trends. Last year I walk the site on

[1:13:07] work trends. Last year I walk the site on

[1:13:07] work trends. Last year I walk the site on Two separate days and didn't

[1:13:08] last year I walk the site on Two separate days and didn't

[1:13:08] last year I walk the site on Two separate days and didn't Exact count at 10:00 piaf's

[1:13:10] two separate days and didn't Exact count at 10:00 piaf's

[1:13:10] two separate days and didn't Exact count at 10:00 piaf's Hour of peak demand on friday

[1:13:14] exact count at 10:00 piaf's Hour of peak demand on friday

[1:13:14] exact count at 10:00 piaf's Hour of peak demand on friday June 13th there were one

[1:13:15] hour of peak demand on friday June 13th there were one

[1:13:15] hour of peak demand on friday June 13th there were one Hundred and sixty seven parked

[1:13:16] june 13th there were one Hundred and sixty seven parked

[1:13:16] june 13th there were one Hundred and sixty seven parked Vehicles in the surface and the

[1:13:18] hundred and sixty seven parked Vehicles in the surface and the

[1:13:19] hundred and sixty seven parked Vehicles in the surface and the Parking deck a sea of empty

[1:13:19] vehicles in the surface and the Parking deck a sea of empty

[1:13:20] vehicles in the surface and the Parking deck a sea of empty Parking on tuesday november 4th

[1:13:22] parking deck a sea of empty Parking on tuesday november 4th

[1:13:22] parking deck a sea of empty Parking on tuesday november 4th Midweek there were still only

[1:13:25] parking on tuesday november 4th Midweek there were still only

[1:13:25] parking on tuesday november 4th Midweek there were still only Three hundred and forty nine

[1:13:26] midweek there were still only Three hundred and forty nine

[1:13:26] midweek there were still only Three hundred and forty nine Vehicles less than one quarter

[1:13:27] three hundred and forty nine Vehicles less than one quarter

[1:13:27] three hundred and forty nine Vehicles less than one quarter Capacity.

[1:13:29] vehicles less than one quarter Capacity.

[1:13:30] vehicles less than one quarter Capacity. >> so pfm apparently is

[1:13:30] capacity. >> so pfm apparently is

[1:13:30] capacity. >> so pfm apparently is Overestimating peak office

[1:13:31] » so pfm apparently is Overestimating peak office

[1:13:31] » so pfm apparently is Overestimating peak office Parking demand by up to a

[1:13:34] overestimating peak office Parking demand by up to a

[1:13:34] overestimating peak office Parking demand by up to a Thousand vehicles.

[1:13:34] parking demand by up to a Thousand vehicles.

[1:13:34] parking demand by up to a Thousand vehicles. In fact, brownfield plan

[1:13:37] thousand vehicles. In fact, brownfield plan

[1:13:37] thousand vehicles. In fact, brownfield plan Includes matthew schmidt's

[1:13:37] in fact, brownfield plan Includes matthew schmidt's

[1:13:38] in fact, brownfield plan Includes matthew schmidt's Affidavit and photos of the

[1:13:41] includes matthew schmidt's Affidavit and photos of the

[1:13:41] includes matthew schmidt's Affidavit and photos of the Blocked off and most of the

[1:13:42] affidavit and photos of the Blocked off and most of the

[1:13:42] affidavit and photos of the Blocked off and most of the Unused parking deck which is

[1:13:44] blocked off and most of the Unused parking deck which is

[1:13:45] blocked off and most of the Unused parking deck which is Meant to show the functional

[1:13:45] unused parking deck which is Meant to show the functional

[1:13:46] unused parking deck which is Meant to show the functional Obsolescence which is true that

[1:13:49] meant to show the functional Obsolescence which is true that

[1:13:49] meant to show the functional Obsolescence which is true that Parking on the site is

[1:13:50] obsolescence which is true that Parking on the site is

[1:13:50] obsolescence which is true that Parking on the site is Functionally obsolete.

[1:13:52] parking on the site is Functionally obsolete.

[1:13:52] parking on the site is Functionally obsolete. So why are we reproducing those

[1:13:53] functionally obsolete. So why are we reproducing those

[1:13:53] functionally obsolete. So why are we reproducing those Numbers in arber s so s will be

[1:13:58] so why are we reproducing those Numbers in arber s so s will be

[1:13:58] so why are we reproducing those Numbers in arber s so s will be Vastly over parked with two

[1:14:02] numbers in arber s so s will be Vastly over parked with two

[1:14:02] numbers in arber s so s will be Vastly over parked with two Thousand six hundred plus

[1:14:02] vastly over parked with two Thousand six hundred plus

[1:14:03] vastly over parked with two Thousand six hundred plus Spaces.

[1:14:05] thousand six hundred plus Spaces.

[1:14:06] thousand six hundred plus Spaces. This means that the low zero

[1:14:07] spaces. This means that the low zero

[1:14:07] spaces. This means that the low zero Point six six parking space per

[1:14:09] this means that the low zero Point six six parking space per

[1:14:09] this means that the low zero Point six six parking space per Unit ratio which oxford cites

[1:14:10] point six six parking space per Unit ratio which oxford cites

[1:14:10] point six six parking space per Unit ratio which oxford cites Is wrong the unused office

[1:14:14] unit ratio which oxford cites Is wrong the unused office

[1:14:14] unit ratio which oxford cites Is wrong the unused office Spaces make the actual ratio

[1:14:15] is wrong the unused office Spaces make the actual ratio

[1:14:15] is wrong the unused office Spaces make the actual ratio More like one point five spaces

[1:14:18] spaces make the actual ratio More like one point five spaces

[1:14:18] spaces make the actual ratio More like one point five spaces Per housing unit which is not a

[1:14:21] more like one point five spaces Per housing unit which is not a

[1:14:21] more like one point five spaces Per housing unit which is not a Responsible transit oriented

[1:14:21] per housing unit which is not a Responsible transit oriented

[1:14:21] per housing unit which is not a Responsible transit oriented Development.

[1:14:25] responsible transit oriented Development.

[1:14:25] responsible transit oriented Development. >> so the developer or the city

[1:14:29] development. >> so the developer or the city

[1:14:29] development. >> so the developer or the city Or both will be paying for a

[1:14:30] » so the developer or the city Or both will be paying for a

[1:14:30] » so the developer or the city Or both will be paying for a Lot of useless parking

[1:14:32] or both will be paying for a Lot of useless parking

[1:14:32] or both will be paying for a Lot of useless parking Structure spaces either through

[1:14:32] lot of useless parking Structure spaces either through

[1:14:33] lot of useless parking Structure spaces either through Tife or directly through to

[1:14:36] structure spaces either through Tife or directly through to

[1:14:36] structure spaces either through Tife or directly through to Payment and city issued bonds.

[1:14:40] tife or directly through to Payment and city issued bonds.

[1:14:40] tife or directly through to Payment and city issued bonds. A couple of speakers had

[1:14:41] payment and city issued bonds. A couple of speakers had

[1:14:41] payment and city issued bonds. A couple of speakers had Mentioned how the project

[1:14:41] a couple of speakers had Mentioned how the project

[1:14:41] a couple of speakers had Mentioned how the project Violates the city's brownfield

[1:14:44] mentioned how the project Violates the city's brownfield

[1:14:44] mentioned how the project Violates the city's brownfield Policy for non environmental

[1:14:47] violates the city's brownfield Policy for non environmental

[1:14:48] violates the city's brownfield Policy for non environmental Costs.

[1:14:48] policy for non environmental Costs.

[1:14:48] policy for non environmental Costs. One that wasn't mentioned was

[1:14:49] costs. One that wasn't mentioned was

[1:14:49] costs. One that wasn't mentioned was Interest.

[1:14:52] one that wasn't mentioned was Interest.

[1:14:52] one that wasn't mentioned was Interest. The policy prohibits interest

[1:14:53] interest. The policy prohibits interest

[1:14:53] interest. The policy prohibits interest Payments for non environmental

[1:14:55] the policy prohibits interest Payments for non environmental

[1:14:55] the policy prohibits interest Payments for non environmental Costs.

[1:14:59] payments for non environmental Costs.

[1:14:59] payments for non environmental Costs. I admit that spreadsheets on

[1:15:00] costs. I admit that spreadsheets on

[1:15:00] costs. I admit that spreadsheets on This project are hard to hard

[1:15:03] I admit that spreadsheets on This project are hard to hard

[1:15:03] I admit that spreadsheets on This project are hard to hard For me to read and so I can't

[1:15:04] this project are hard to hard For me to read and so I can't

[1:15:04] this project are hard to hard For me to read and so I can't Be sure of this but the way I

[1:15:06] for me to read and so I can't Be sure of this but the way I

[1:15:07] for me to read and so I can't Be sure of this but the way I Make it out the combined total

[1:15:10] be sure of this but the way I Make it out the combined total

[1:15:10] be sure of this but the way I Make it out the combined total Interest and non reimbursable

[1:15:10] make it out the combined total Interest and non reimbursable

[1:15:11] make it out the combined total Interest and non reimbursable Expenses to be paid again

[1:15:14] interest and non reimbursable Expenses to be paid again

[1:15:14] interest and non reimbursable Expenses to be paid again Against the city's policy seem

[1:15:15] expenses to be paid again Against the city's policy seem

[1:15:15] expenses to be paid again Against the city's policy seem To be one hundred and thirty

[1:15:15] against the city's policy seem To be one hundred and thirty

[1:15:15] against the city's policy seem To be one hundred and thirty Eight million dollars over the

[1:15:18] to be one hundred and thirty Eight million dollars over the

[1:15:18] to be one hundred and thirty Eight million dollars over the Thirty years of the plan.

[1:15:19] eight million dollars over the Thirty years of the plan.

[1:15:19] eight million dollars over the Thirty years of the plan. I know mr. Bolt from the county

[1:15:22] thirty years of the plan. I know mr. Bolt from the county

[1:15:22] thirty years of the plan. I know mr. Bolt from the county Is here.

[1:15:22] I know mr. Bolt from the county Is here.

[1:15:23] I know mr. Bolt from the county Is here. He can set me straight on this

[1:15:23] is here. He can set me straight on this

[1:15:24] is here. He can set me straight on this But if that's true that's an

[1:15:25] he can set me straight on this But if that's true that's an

[1:15:25] he can set me straight on this But if that's true that's an Astonishing number given that

[1:15:26] but if that's true that's an Astonishing number given that

[1:15:26] but if that's true that's an Astonishing number given that It goes against that interest

[1:15:29] astonishing number given that It goes against that interest

[1:15:29] astonishing number given that It goes against that interest If not allowed under the city

[1:15:30] it goes against that interest If not allowed under the city

[1:15:30] it goes against that interest If not allowed under the city Policy or recommended.

[1:15:30] if not allowed under the city Policy or recommended.

[1:15:31] if not allowed under the city Policy or recommended. >> thank you.

[1:15:33] policy or recommended. >> thank you.

[1:15:33] policy or recommended. >> thank you. >> thank you

[1:15:41] .

[1:15:41] . So anyone else in the house

[1:15:42] . So anyone else in the house

[1:15:42] . So anyone else in the house Would like to speak at this

[1:15:44] so anyone else in the house Would like to speak at this

[1:15:44] so anyone else in the house Would like to speak at this Public hearing.

[1:15:47] would like to speak at this Public hearing.

[1:15:47] would like to speak at this Public hearing. Hi, I'm bill smith.

[1:15:48] public hearing. Hi, I'm bill smith.

[1:15:48] public hearing. Hi, I'm bill smith. The city resident I never

[1:15:51] hi, I'm bill smith. The city resident I never

[1:15:52] hi, I'm bill smith. The city resident I never Expected never coming here

[1:15:55] the city resident I never Expected never coming here

[1:15:56] the city resident I never Expected never coming here Today.

[1:15:56] expected never coming here Today.

[1:15:56] expected never coming here Today. I did not expect to have an

[1:15:58] today. I did not expect to have an

[1:15:58] today. I did not expect to have an Speak on this because I am not

[1:15:59] I did not expect to have an Speak on this because I am not

[1:15:59] I did not expect to have an Speak on this because I am not Particularly well versed on the

[1:16:03] speak on this because I am not Particularly well versed on the

[1:16:03] speak on this because I am not Particularly well versed on the Issue.

[1:16:03] particularly well versed on the Issue.

[1:16:03] particularly well versed on the Issue. I've heard a little bit about

[1:16:04] issue. I've heard a little bit about

[1:16:04] issue. I've heard a little bit about It.

[1:16:04] I've heard a little bit about It.

[1:16:04] I've heard a little bit about It. I couldn't imagine that it was

[1:16:06] it. I couldn't imagine that it was

[1:16:06] it. I couldn't imagine that it was Even half as bad as I've heard

[1:16:10] I couldn't imagine that it was Even half as bad as I've heard

[1:16:10] I couldn't imagine that it was Even half as bad as I've heard Is my understanding was I mean

[1:16:11] even half as bad as I've heard Is my understanding was I mean

[1:16:11] even half as bad as I've heard Is my understanding was I mean It looks atrocious.

[1:16:13] is my understanding was I mean It looks atrocious.

[1:16:13] is my understanding was I mean It looks atrocious. It looks like a from the

[1:16:14] it looks atrocious. It looks like a from the

[1:16:14] it looks atrocious. It looks like a from the Information I heard which I

[1:16:17] it looks like a from the Information I heard which I

[1:16:18] it looks like a from the Information I heard which I Don't I don't know that's

[1:16:18] information I heard which I Don't I don't know that's

[1:16:18] information I heard which I Don't I don't know that's Correct.

[1:16:18] don't I don't know that's Correct.

[1:16:19] don't I don't know that's Correct. But this is a shameless

[1:16:24] correct. But this is a shameless

[1:16:24] correct. But this is a shameless Giveaway but I don't I truly

[1:16:28] but this is a shameless Giveaway but I don't I truly

[1:16:28] but this is a shameless Giveaway but I don't I truly Acknowledge I have one sided

[1:16:29] giveaway but I don't I truly Acknowledge I have one sided

[1:16:29] giveaway but I don't I truly Acknowledge I have one sided Information there could be

[1:16:32] acknowledge I have one sided Information there could be

[1:16:33] acknowledge I have one sided Information there could be There very well could be very

[1:16:33] information there could be There very well could be very

[1:16:33] information there could be There very well could be very Good reasons for this.

[1:16:36] there very well could be very Good reasons for this.

[1:16:36] there very well could be very Good reasons for this. But you know, sitting there are

[1:16:37] good reasons for this. But you know, sitting there are

[1:16:38] good reasons for this. But you know, sitting there are A few things occur to me.

[1:16:39] but you know, sitting there are A few things occur to me.

[1:16:39] but you know, sitting there are A few things occur to me. One is that this is not some

[1:16:40] a few things occur to me. One is that this is not some

[1:16:41] a few things occur to me. One is that this is not some Kind of a home run that's going

[1:16:44] one is that this is not some Kind of a home run that's going

[1:16:44] one is that this is not some Kind of a home run that's going To be fantastic for the city

[1:16:47] kind of a home run that's going To be fantastic for the city

[1:16:47] kind of a home run that's going To be fantastic for the city And we better act now.

[1:16:48] to be fantastic for the city And we better act now.

[1:16:48] to be fantastic for the city And we better act now. >> we better act tonight on

[1:16:51] and we better act now. >> we better act tonight on

[1:16:51] and we better act now. >> we better act tonight on This and so from that

[1:16:56] » we better act tonight on This and so from that

[1:16:56] » we better act tonight on This and so from that Standpoint I can't imagine

[1:16:56] this and so from that Standpoint I can't imagine

[1:16:57] this and so from that Standpoint I can't imagine Voting yes as always to well,

[1:17:01] standpoint I can't imagine Voting yes as always to well,

[1:17:01] standpoint I can't imagine Voting yes as always to well, You know, getting some I mean

[1:17:06] voting yes as always to well, You know, getting some I mean

[1:17:06] voting yes as always to well, You know, getting some I mean There might be consensus here

[1:17:07] you know, getting some I mean There might be consensus here

[1:17:07] you know, getting some I mean There might be consensus here But I'm sure in the city there

[1:17:10] there might be consensus here But I'm sure in the city there

[1:17:10] there might be consensus here But I'm sure in the city there Would not be consensus because

[1:17:12] but I'm sure in the city there Would not be consensus because

[1:17:12] but I'm sure in the city there Would not be consensus because The optics are really bad and I

[1:17:16] would not be consensus because The optics are really bad and I

[1:17:16] would not be consensus because The optics are really bad and I Mean if half of what I've heard

[1:17:21] the optics are really bad and I Mean if half of what I've heard

[1:17:21] the optics are really bad and I Mean if half of what I've heard Is true, well then I keep

[1:17:25] mean if half of what I've heard Is true, well then I keep

[1:17:25] mean if half of what I've heard Is true, well then I keep Alluding to, you know, bad or

[1:17:28] is true, well then I keep Alluding to, you know, bad or

[1:17:28] is true, well then I keep Alluding to, you know, bad or Not bad facts.

[1:17:29] alluding to, you know, bad or Not bad facts.

[1:17:29] alluding to, you know, bad or Not bad facts. My facts might be great but I

[1:17:30] not bad facts. My facts might be great but I

[1:17:30] not bad facts. My facts might be great but I Don't know I'm not I'm not any

[1:17:33] my facts might be great but I Don't know I'm not I'm not any

[1:17:33] my facts might be great but I Don't know I'm not I'm not any Kind of a subject matter expert

[1:17:33] don't know I'm not I'm not any Kind of a subject matter expert

[1:17:34] don't know I'm not I'm not any Kind of a subject matter expert But I know the optics are bad.

[1:17:36] kind of a subject matter expert But I know the optics are bad.

[1:17:36] kind of a subject matter expert But I know the optics are bad. I know that this is not it.

[1:17:41] but I know the optics are bad. I know that this is not it.

[1:17:41] but I know the optics are bad. I know that this is not it. Well, I'll just repeat myself

[1:17:44] I know that this is not it. Well, I'll just repeat myself

[1:17:44] I know that this is not it. Well, I'll just repeat myself Here.

[1:17:44] well, I'll just repeat myself Here.

[1:17:44] well, I'll just repeat myself Here. This is not some kind of a home

[1:17:45] here. This is not some kind of a home

[1:17:45] here. This is not some kind of a home Run that you've got to do it

[1:17:46] this is not some kind of a home Run that you've got to do it

[1:17:46] this is not some kind of a home Run that you've got to do it Tonight or or this opportunity

[1:17:48] run that you've got to do it Tonight or or this opportunity

[1:17:48] run that you've got to do it Tonight or or this opportunity Leaves somebody suggested that

[1:17:52] tonight or or this opportunity Leaves somebody suggested that

[1:17:52] tonight or or this opportunity Leaves somebody suggested that There are other options out

[1:17:52] leaves somebody suggested that There are other options out

[1:17:53] leaves somebody suggested that There are other options out There that could be explored

[1:17:55] there are other options out There that could be explored

[1:17:55] there are other options out There that could be explored And

[1:18:02] there are I mean I'm not

[1:18:03] there are I mean I'm not

[1:18:03] there are I mean I'm not Going to suggest that, you

[1:18:07] there are I mean I'm not Going to suggest that, you

[1:18:07] there are I mean I'm not Going to suggest that, you Know, that people are but

[1:18:08] going to suggest that, you Know, that people are but

[1:18:08] going to suggest that, you Know, that people are but Anyone here bought for a couple

[1:18:10] know, that people are but Anyone here bought for a couple

[1:18:10] know, that people are but Anyone here bought for a couple Of thousand dollars but I will

[1:18:14] anyone here bought for a couple Of thousand dollars but I will

[1:18:14] anyone here bought for a couple Of thousand dollars but I will Say that you can't vote yes on

[1:18:18] of thousand dollars but I will Say that you can't vote yes on

[1:18:18] of thousand dollars but I will Say that you can't vote yes on This tonight and say well,

[1:18:21] say that you can't vote yes on This tonight and say well,

[1:18:21] say that you can't vote yes on This tonight and say well, We're doing it for we're doing

[1:18:25] this tonight and say well, We're doing it for we're doing

[1:18:25] this tonight and say well, We're doing it for we're doing This we didn't know about the

[1:18:26] we're doing it for we're doing This we didn't know about the

[1:18:26] we're doing it for we're doing This we didn't know about the The potential downside we

[1:18:29] this we didn't know about the The potential downside we

[1:18:29] this we didn't know about the The potential downside we Didn't know about we didn't

[1:18:30] the potential downside we Didn't know about we didn't

[1:18:30] the potential downside we Didn't know about we didn't Know that this could be a

[1:18:33] didn't know about we didn't Know that this could be a

[1:18:33] didn't know about we didn't Know that this could be a Really bad deal.

[1:18:33] know that this could be a Really bad deal.

[1:18:34] know that this could be a Really bad deal. I mean that seems like a very

[1:18:34] really bad deal. I mean that seems like a very

[1:18:35] really bad deal. I mean that seems like a very Clear option to me.

[1:18:36] I mean that seems like a very Clear option to me.

[1:18:36] I mean that seems like a very Clear option to me. This could be atrocious and

[1:18:37] clear option to me. This could be atrocious and

[1:18:37] clear option to me. This could be atrocious and Then you'll say well we didn't

[1:18:38] this could be atrocious and Then you'll say well we didn't

[1:18:38] this could be atrocious and Then you'll say well we didn't Know we had to vote on it.

[1:18:41] then you'll say well we didn't Know we had to vote on it.

[1:18:42] then you'll say well we didn't Know we had to vote on it. You don't have to vote on it

[1:18:42] know we had to vote on it. You don't have to vote on it

[1:18:43] know we had to vote on it. You don't have to vote on it Tonight and

[1:19:02] you can see some

[1:19:02] you can see some Other options and I hope you

[1:19:04] you can see some Other options and I hope you

[1:19:04] you can see some Other options and I hope you Do.

[1:19:04] other options and I hope you Do.

[1:19:04] other options and I hope you Do. Thank you.

[1:19:04] do. Thank you.

[1:19:04] do. Thank you. Oh wow.

[1:19:05] thank you. Oh wow.

[1:19:05] thank you. Oh wow. Evening everyone.

[1:19:06] oh wow. Evening everyone.

[1:19:06] oh wow. Evening everyone. My name is rebecca award one

[1:19:07] evening everyone. My name is rebecca award one

[1:19:07] evening everyone. My name is rebecca award one And I'm running for city

[1:19:08] my name is rebecca award one And I'm running for city

[1:19:08] my name is rebecca award one And I'm running for city Council.

[1:19:09] and I'm running for city Council.

[1:19:09] and I'm running for city Council. I want to thank dharma's I

[1:19:10] council. I want to thank dharma's I

[1:19:10] council. I want to thank dharma's I Appreciate your email response

[1:19:10] I want to thank dharma's I Appreciate your email response

[1:19:10] I want to thank dharma's I Appreciate your email response Is I think everyone hates to be

[1:19:11] appreciate your email response Is I think everyone hates to be

[1:19:11] appreciate your email response Is I think everyone hates to be Ghosted in in terms of this

[1:19:12] is I think everyone hates to be Ghosted in in terms of this

[1:19:12] is I think everyone hates to be Ghosted in in terms of this Particular development.

[1:19:15] ghosted in in terms of this Particular development.

[1:19:15] ghosted in in terms of this Particular development. Jeff hoffman and I really got

[1:19:16] particular development. Jeff hoffman and I really got

[1:19:16] particular development. Jeff hoffman and I really got Along well ten years ago

[1:19:19] jeff hoffman and I really got Along well ten years ago

[1:19:19] jeff hoffman and I really got Along well ten years ago Because we both agreed on

[1:19:20] along well ten years ago Because we both agreed on

[1:19:20] along well ten years ago Because we both agreed on Mural's downtown and public art

[1:19:23] because we both agreed on Mural's downtown and public art

[1:19:23] because we both agreed on Mural's downtown and public art .

[1:19:23] mural's downtown and public art .

[1:19:23] mural's downtown and public art . But you know, I'm not taking

[1:19:24] . But you know, I'm not taking

[1:19:24] . But you know, I'm not taking Any donations for my campaign

[1:19:27] but you know, I'm not taking Any donations for my campaign

[1:19:27] but you know, I'm not taking Any donations for my campaign Not a single dollar because

[1:19:28] any donations for my campaign Not a single dollar because

[1:19:28] any donations for my campaign Not a single dollar because People are a little paranoid

[1:19:31] not a single dollar because People are a little paranoid

[1:19:32] not a single dollar because People are a little paranoid With government right now.

[1:19:32] people are a little paranoid With government right now.

[1:19:32] people are a little paranoid With government right now. It's really hard for them to

[1:19:33] with government right now. It's really hard for them to

[1:19:33] with government right now. It's really hard for them to Trust government.

[1:19:35] it's really hard for them to Trust government.

[1:19:35] it's really hard for them to Trust government. So whether or not you have any

[1:19:38] trust government. So whether or not you have any

[1:19:38] trust government. So whether or not you have any Influence by this donor again

[1:19:39] so whether or not you have any Influence by this donor again

[1:19:39] so whether or not you have any Influence by this donor again To the other speakers it is

[1:19:43] influence by this donor again To the other speakers it is

[1:19:43] influence by this donor again To the other speakers it is Something that should be

[1:19:46] to the other speakers it is Something that should be

[1:19:46] to the other speakers it is Something that should be Proceeded very thoughtfully to

[1:19:47] something that should be Proceeded very thoughtfully to

[1:19:47] something that should be Proceeded very thoughtfully to Not besmirch your good

[1:19:50] proceeded very thoughtfully to Not besmirch your good

[1:19:51] proceeded very thoughtfully to Not besmirch your good Character and to be above

[1:19:51] not besmirch your good Character and to be above

[1:19:51] not besmirch your good Character and to be above Reproach.

[1:19:54] character and to be above Reproach.

[1:19:54] character and to be above Reproach. I will tell you that sometimes

[1:19:55] reproach. I will tell you that sometimes

[1:19:55] reproach. I will tell you that sometimes We fall short of considering

[1:19:58] I will tell you that sometimes We fall short of considering

[1:19:58] I will tell you that sometimes We fall short of considering The social cohesion with some

[1:19:59] we fall short of considering The social cohesion with some

[1:19:59] we fall short of considering The social cohesion with some Of these projects.

[1:20:02] the social cohesion with some Of these projects.

[1:20:02] the social cohesion with some Of these projects. I work with people in the

[1:20:03] of these projects. I work with people in the

[1:20:03] of these projects. I work with people in the Service industry.

[1:20:04] I work with people in the Service industry.

[1:20:04] I work with people in the Service industry. I work with environmental

[1:20:06] service industry. I work with environmental

[1:20:06] service industry. I work with environmental Services people that clean our

[1:20:07] I work with environmental Services people that clean our

[1:20:07] I work with environmental Services people that clean our Hospital.

[1:20:07] services people that clean our Hospital.

[1:20:07] services people that clean our Hospital. I work with nurses, I know nail

[1:20:11] hospital. I work with nurses, I know nail

[1:20:11] hospital. I work with nurses, I know nail Techs.

[1:20:11] I work with nurses, I know nail Techs.

[1:20:11] I work with nurses, I know nail Techs. I know a lot of people that

[1:20:14] techs. I know a lot of people that

[1:20:14] techs. I know a lot of people that They don't want to live here

[1:20:15] I know a lot of people that They don't want to live here

[1:20:15] I know a lot of people that They don't want to live here Because they have more

[1:20:18] they don't want to live here Because they have more

[1:20:18] they don't want to live here Because they have more Affordable options in the

[1:20:19] because they have more Affordable options in the

[1:20:19] because they have more Affordable options in the Surrounding villages.

[1:20:21] affordable options in the Surrounding villages.

[1:20:21] affordable options in the Surrounding villages. For example, velvel saleen

[1:20:26] surrounding villages. For example, velvel saleen

[1:20:26] surrounding villages. For example, velvel saleen Daxter I myself lived in daxter

[1:20:27] for example, velvel saleen Daxter I myself lived in daxter

[1:20:27] for example, velvel saleen Daxter I myself lived in daxter For time because I needed to

[1:20:30] daxter I myself lived in daxter For time because I needed to

[1:20:31] daxter I myself lived in daxter For time because I needed to Save money years ago but having

[1:20:33] for time because I needed to Save money years ago but having

[1:20:33] for time because I needed to Save money years ago but having Someone to pay that type

[1:20:37] save money years ago but having Someone to pay that type

[1:20:37] save money years ago but having Someone to pay that type Of money that is going to be

[1:20:38] someone to pay that type Of money that is going to be

[1:20:38] someone to pay that type Of money that is going to be Charged I don't care if it's an

[1:20:39] of money that is going to be Charged I don't care if it's an

[1:20:39] of money that is going to be Charged I don't care if it's an Affordable housing unit or

[1:20:41] charged I don't care if it's an Affordable housing unit or

[1:20:41] charged I don't care if it's an Affordable housing unit or Market rate in that area near a

[1:20:42] affordable housing unit or Market rate in that area near a

[1:20:43] affordable housing unit or Market rate in that area near a Highway to me seems fairly

[1:20:46] market rate in that area near a Highway to me seems fairly

[1:20:46] market rate in that area near a Highway to me seems fairly Disrespectful and I don't think

[1:20:49] highway to me seems fairly Disrespectful and I don't think

[1:20:49] highway to me seems fairly Disrespectful and I don't think That this will be successful

[1:20:50] disrespectful and I don't think That this will be successful

[1:20:50] disrespectful and I don't think That this will be successful But this is my opinion.

[1:20:51] that this will be successful But this is my opinion.

[1:20:51] that this will be successful But this is my opinion. It's not about my opinion.

[1:20:54] but this is my opinion. It's not about my opinion.

[1:20:54] but this is my opinion. It's not about my opinion. I will tell you this if people

[1:20:56] it's not about my opinion. I will tell you this if people

[1:20:56] it's not about my opinion. I will tell you this if people Vote the way they're talking to

[1:20:57] I will tell you this if people Vote the way they're talking to

[1:20:57] I will tell you this if people Vote the way they're talking to Me at doors, I will win a

[1:20:58] vote the way they're talking to Me at doors, I will win a

[1:20:58] vote the way they're talking to Me at doors, I will win a Landslide because people are

[1:21:01] me at doors, I will win a Landslide because people are

[1:21:02] me at doors, I will win a Landslide because people are Not happy.

[1:21:02] landslide because people are Not happy.

[1:21:02] landslide because people are Not happy. They feel very upset about

[1:21:04] not happy. They feel very upset about

[1:21:04] not happy. They feel very upset about Wasted money including you

[1:21:05] they feel very upset about Wasted money including you

[1:21:05] they feel very upset about Wasted money including you Know, the the howard lazarus

[1:21:08] wasted money including you Know, the the howard lazarus

[1:21:08] wasted money including you Know, the the howard lazarus People I can't believe you

[1:21:09] know, the the howard lazarus People I can't believe you

[1:21:09] know, the the howard lazarus People I can't believe you Know, we gave him this.

[1:21:10] people I can't believe you Know, we gave him this.

[1:21:10] people I can't believe you Know, we gave him this. So you've got to be really

[1:21:12] know, we gave him this. So you've got to be really

[1:21:12] know, we gave him this. So you've got to be really Careful here about how you're

[1:21:13] so you've got to be really Careful here about how you're

[1:21:13] so you've got to be really Careful here about how you're Spending the city's money

[1:21:14] careful here about how you're Spending the city's money

[1:21:14] careful here about how you're Spending the city's money Because more people are paying

[1:21:17] spending the city's money Because more people are paying

[1:21:17] spending the city's money Because more people are paying Attention.

[1:21:17] because more people are paying Attention.

[1:21:17] because more people are paying Attention. But again, all of this aside

[1:21:20] attention. But again, all of this aside

[1:21:20] attention. But again, all of this aside From my understanding this

[1:21:21] but again, all of this aside From my understanding this

[1:21:21] but again, all of this aside From my understanding this Brownfield review this doesn't

[1:21:24] from my understanding this Brownfield review this doesn't

[1:21:24] from my understanding this Brownfield review this doesn't Meet criteria period.

[1:21:24] brownfield review this doesn't Meet criteria period.

[1:21:24] brownfield review this doesn't Meet criteria period. >> full stop.

[1:21:25] meet criteria period. >> full stop.

[1:21:25] meet criteria period. >> full stop. Thank you.

[1:21:26] » full stop. Thank you.

[1:21:27] » full stop. Thank you. >> thank you

[1:21:37] .

[1:21:38] .

[1:21:38] . Is there anyone online who like

[1:21:39] . Is there anyone online who like To speak this public forum

[1:21:42] is there anyone online who like To speak this public forum

[1:21:42] is there anyone online who like To speak this public forum Where we have people online?

[1:21:45] to speak this public forum Where we have people online?

[1:21:45] to speak this public forum Where we have people online? Luis vasquez, do you have a

[1:21:46] where we have people online? Luis vasquez, do you have a

[1:21:47] where we have people online? Luis vasquez, do you have a Comment have statistics

[1:21:47] luis vasquez, do you have a Comment have statistics

[1:21:47] luis vasquez, do you have a Comment have statistics Yourself?

[1:21:52] comment have statistics Yourself?

[1:21:52] comment have statistics Yourself? Yes.

[1:21:52] yourself? Yes.

[1:21:52] yourself? Yes. Greetings.

[1:21:53] yes. Greetings.

[1:21:53] yes. Greetings. Luis vasquez berten drive in

[1:21:56] greetings. Luis vasquez berten drive in

[1:21:56] greetings. Luis vasquez berten drive in Upper lower town I'm not

[1:22:00] luis vasquez berten drive in Upper lower town I'm not

[1:22:00] luis vasquez berten drive in Upper lower town I'm not Strongly in favor or opposition

[1:22:03] upper lower town I'm not Strongly in favor or opposition

[1:22:04] upper lower town I'm not Strongly in favor or opposition To this resolution tonight but

[1:22:07] strongly in favor or opposition To this resolution tonight but

[1:22:07] strongly in favor or opposition To this resolution tonight but If it were me sitting there in

[1:22:11] to this resolution tonight but If it were me sitting there in

[1:22:11] to this resolution tonight but If it were me sitting there in The council seats I would be

[1:22:12] if it were me sitting there in The council seats I would be

[1:22:12] if it were me sitting there in The council seats I would be Taking a look at trying to

[1:22:15] the council seats I would be Taking a look at trying to

[1:22:15] the council seats I would be Taking a look at trying to Convince oxford to decrease the

[1:22:23] taking a look at trying to Convince oxford to decrease the

[1:22:23] taking a look at trying to Convince oxford to decrease the Number of parking spaces and

[1:22:27] convince oxford to decrease the Number of parking spaces and

[1:22:27] convince oxford to decrease the Number of parking spaces and Increasing at the same time the

[1:22:28] number of parking spaces and Increasing at the same time the

[1:22:28] number of parking spaces and Increasing at the same time the Number of affordable housing

[1:22:32] increasing at the same time the Number of affordable housing

[1:22:32] increasing at the same time the Number of affordable housing Units that would be built in

[1:22:35] number of affordable housing Units that would be built in

[1:22:35] number of affordable housing Units that would be built in This kind of project.

[1:22:39] units that would be built in This kind of project.

[1:22:39] units that would be built in This kind of project. The other point I wanted to

[1:22:40] this kind of project. The other point I wanted to

[1:22:40] this kind of project. The other point I wanted to Make to the folks who spoke

[1:22:47] the other point I wanted to Make to the folks who spoke

[1:22:47] the other point I wanted to Make to the folks who spoke Earlier, some of whom were

[1:22:49] make to the folks who spoke Earlier, some of whom were

[1:22:49] make to the folks who spoke Earlier, some of whom were Unidentified I hey, you know, a

[1:22:54] earlier, some of whom were Unidentified I hey, you know, a

[1:22:54] earlier, some of whom were Unidentified I hey, you know, a Lot of you guys were I mean

[1:22:57] unidentified I hey, you know, a Lot of you guys were I mean

[1:22:57] unidentified I hey, you know, a Lot of you guys were I mean You're really upset with a city

[1:23:01] lot of you guys were I mean You're really upset with a city

[1:23:01] lot of you guys were I mean You're really upset with a city Potentially you know, you know,

[1:23:05] you're really upset with a city Potentially you know, you know,

[1:23:05] you're really upset with a city Potentially you know, you know, Losing money.

[1:23:05] potentially you know, you know, Losing money.

[1:23:05] potentially you know, you know, Losing money. Well, a lot of you were had no

[1:23:10] losing money. Well, a lot of you were had no

[1:23:10] losing money. Well, a lot of you were had no Problem with the city losing

[1:23:13] well, a lot of you were had no Problem with the city losing

[1:23:14] well, a lot of you were had no Problem with the city losing Ten of millions of dollars

[1:23:17] problem with the city losing Ten of millions of dollars

[1:23:17] problem with the city losing Ten of millions of dollars Of revenue for the library.

[1:23:21] ten of millions of dollars Of revenue for the library.

[1:23:21] ten of millions of dollars Of revenue for the library. So take a good look in the

[1:23:22] of revenue for the library. So take a good look in the

[1:23:22] of revenue for the library. So take a good look in the Mirror before you claim any

[1:23:26] so take a good look in the Mirror before you claim any

[1:23:26] so take a good look in the Mirror before you claim any Kind of corruption, especially

[1:23:29] mirror before you claim any Kind of corruption, especially

[1:23:29] mirror before you claim any Kind of corruption, especially Somebody like mr. Weed who you

[1:23:33] kind of corruption, especially Somebody like mr. Weed who you

[1:23:33] kind of corruption, especially Somebody like mr. Weed who you Know has has a bad habit

[1:23:34] somebody like mr. Weed who you Know has has a bad habit

[1:23:34] somebody like mr. Weed who you Know has has a bad habit Of trying the pockets of people

[1:23:37] know has has a bad habit Of trying the pockets of people

[1:23:37] know has has a bad habit Of trying the pockets of people Of the people, sir.

[1:23:41] of trying the pockets of people Of the people, sir.

[1:23:41] of trying the pockets of people Of the people, sir. >> no, sir.

[1:23:42] of the people, sir. >> no, sir.

[1:23:42] of the people, sir. >> no, sir. Thank you.

[1:23:42] » no, sir. Thank you.

[1:23:42] » no, sir. Thank you. Yeah, thank you.

[1:23:43] thank you. Yeah, thank you.

[1:23:43] thank you. Yeah, thank you. Good night.

[1:23:43] yeah, thank you. Good night.

[1:23:52] alex, you have a comment one

[1:23:55] alex, you have a comment one

[1:23:55] alex, you have a comment one Evening again this time unlike

[1:23:59] alex, you have a comment one Evening again this time unlike

[1:23:59] alex, you have a comment one Evening again this time unlike Some of the other speakers, I'm

[1:24:00] evening again this time unlike Some of the other speakers, I'm

[1:24:00] evening again this time unlike Some of the other speakers, I'm Not wearing my tinfoil hat

[1:24:01] some of the other speakers, I'm Not wearing my tinfoil hat

[1:24:01] some of the other speakers, I'm Not wearing my tinfoil hat Tonight.

[1:24:03] not wearing my tinfoil hat Tonight.

[1:24:03] not wearing my tinfoil hat Tonight. I have not called any council

[1:24:04] tonight. I have not called any council

[1:24:04] tonight. I have not called any council Members the sieber and I also

[1:24:06] I have not called any council Members the sieber and I also

[1:24:06] I have not called any council Members the sieber and I also Think that smearing council

[1:24:07] members the sieber and I also Think that smearing council

[1:24:07] members the sieber and I also Think that smearing council Members who have already voted

[1:24:08] think that smearing council Members who have already voted

[1:24:08] think that smearing council Members who have already voted Against us multiple times

[1:24:10] members who have already voted Against us multiple times

[1:24:11] members who have already voted Against us multiple times During a fairly coherent rant

[1:24:14] against us multiple times During a fairly coherent rant

[1:24:14] against us multiple times During a fairly coherent rant Against this plan is a move

[1:24:15] during a fairly coherent rant Against this plan is a move

[1:24:15] during a fairly coherent rant Against this plan is a move That does not show one to be at

[1:24:19] against this plan is a move That does not show one to be at

[1:24:19] against this plan is a move That does not show one to be at All invested in observable

[1:24:19] that does not show one to be at All invested in observable

[1:24:20] that does not show one to be at All invested in observable Reality.

[1:24:22] all invested in observable Reality.

[1:24:22] all invested in observable Reality. >> I'm grateful to city council

[1:24:23] reality. >> I'm grateful to city council

[1:24:23] reality. >> I'm grateful to city council For listening to some of the

[1:24:26] » I'm grateful to city council For listening to some of the

[1:24:26] » I'm grateful to city council For listening to some of the Feedback and at least working

[1:24:26] for listening to some of the Feedback and at least working

[1:24:27] for listening to some of the Feedback and at least working On something different than the

[1:24:29] feedback and at least working On something different than the

[1:24:29] feedback and at least working On something different than the Dreadful proposal that was up

[1:24:30] on something different than the Dreadful proposal that was up

[1:24:30] on something different than the Dreadful proposal that was up Before previous before council

[1:24:33] dreadful proposal that was up Before previous before council

[1:24:34] dreadful proposal that was up Before previous before council In previous meetings, however,

[1:24:37] before previous before council In previous meetings, however,

[1:24:37] before previous before council In previous meetings, however, In the words of kddi enngonia

[1:24:38] in previous meetings, however, In the words of kddi enngonia

[1:24:38] in previous meetings, however, In the words of kddi enngonia That's worse.

[1:24:38] in the words of kddi enngonia That's worse.

[1:24:39] in the words of kddi enngonia That's worse. Do you see how that's worse?

[1:24:42] that's worse. Do you see how that's worse?

[1:24:42] that's worse. Do you see how that's worse? Right.

[1:24:42] do you see how that's worse? Right.

[1:24:42] do you see how that's worse? Right. The city has somehow managed to

[1:24:45] right. The city has somehow managed to

[1:24:46] right. The city has somehow managed to Take an idea that many who so

[1:24:46] the city has somehow managed to Take an idea that many who so

[1:24:46] the city has somehow managed to Take an idea that many who so Strongly advocate from more and

[1:24:49] take an idea that many who so Strongly advocate from more and

[1:24:49] take an idea that many who so Strongly advocate from more and Better how saying oppose and

[1:24:52] strongly advocate from more and Better how saying oppose and

[1:24:52] strongly advocate from more and Better how saying oppose and Make it even worse and I'm not

[1:24:53] better how saying oppose and Make it even worse and I'm not

[1:24:53] better how saying oppose and Make it even worse and I'm not Talking about the the build

[1:24:56] make it even worse and I'm not Talking about the the build

[1:24:56] make it even worse and I'm not Talking about the the build Absolutely nothing anywhere

[1:24:57] talking about the the build Absolutely nothing anywhere

[1:24:57] talking about the the build Absolutely nothing anywhere Near anyone group.

[1:25:00] absolutely nothing anywhere Near anyone group.

[1:25:01] absolutely nothing anywhere Near anyone group. I'm talking about people like

[1:25:01] near anyone group. I'm talking about people like

[1:25:01] near anyone group. I'm talking about people like Me who out there have

[1:25:03] I'm talking about people like Me who out there have

[1:25:04] I'm talking about people like Me who out there have Outspokenly supported more

[1:25:04] me who out there have Outspokenly supported more

[1:25:04] me who out there have Outspokenly supported more Housing on a very consistent

[1:25:08] outspokenly supported more Housing on a very consistent

[1:25:08] outspokenly supported more Housing on a very consistent Basis.

[1:25:08] housing on a very consistent Basis.

[1:25:09] housing on a very consistent Basis. I want more housing.

[1:25:09] basis. I want more housing.

[1:25:09] basis. I want more housing. I want more housing on the

[1:25:12] I want more housing. I want more housing on the

[1:25:12] I want more housing. I want more housing on the Location of of of itself.

[1:25:15] I want more housing on the Location of of of itself.

[1:25:15] I want more housing on the Location of of of itself. >> I believe that attached to

[1:25:16] location of of of itself. >> I believe that attached to

[1:25:16] location of of of itself. >> I believe that attached to This is harmful to the city.

[1:25:19] » I believe that attached to This is harmful to the city.

[1:25:19] » I believe that attached to This is harmful to the city. >> mr. Garber and I agree on

[1:25:23] this is harmful to the city. >> mr. Garber and I agree on

[1:25:24] this is harmful to the city. >> mr. Garber and I agree on Pretty much everything that he

[1:25:24] » mr. Garber and I agree on Pretty much everything that he

[1:25:24] » mr. Garber and I agree on Pretty much everything that he Said tonight so I won't repeat

[1:25:26] pretty much everything that he Said tonight so I won't repeat

[1:25:26] pretty much everything that he Said tonight so I won't repeat His words.

[1:25:27] said tonight so I won't repeat His words.

[1:25:27] said tonight so I won't repeat His words. One thing he did miss is that

[1:25:28] his words. One thing he did miss is that

[1:25:28] his words. One thing he did miss is that The gas service to the location

[1:25:31] one thing he did miss is that The gas service to the location

[1:25:31] one thing he did miss is that The gas service to the location Appears to be for only thirty

[1:25:32] the gas service to the location Appears to be for only thirty

[1:25:32] the gas service to the location Appears to be for only thirty Condos.

[1:25:34] appears to be for only thirty Condos.

[1:25:35] appears to be for only thirty Condos. While I'm not opposed to using

[1:25:39] condos. While I'm not opposed to using

[1:25:39] condos. While I'm not opposed to using Gas for heating given the

[1:25:39] while I'm not opposed to using Gas for heating given the

[1:25:39] while I'm not opposed to using Gas for heating given the Technology available to us and

[1:25:43] gas for heating given the Technology available to us and

[1:25:43] gas for heating given the Technology available to us and Our and our plan is this the

[1:25:46] technology available to us and Our and our plan is this the

[1:25:46] technology available to us and Our and our plan is this the Saving of thirty hundreds for

[1:25:47] our and our plan is this the Saving of thirty hundreds for

[1:25:47] our and our plan is this the Saving of thirty hundreds for Gas implies of the gas hookups

[1:25:51] saving of thirty hundreds for Gas implies of the gas hookups

[1:25:51] saving of thirty hundreds for Gas implies of the gas hookups Are not actually necessary for

[1:25:52] gas implies of the gas hookups Are not actually necessary for

[1:25:52] gas implies of the gas hookups Are not actually necessary for This development but rather

[1:25:55] are not actually necessary for This development but rather

[1:25:55] are not actually necessary for This development but rather Going to be used for dangerous

[1:25:56] this development but rather Going to be used for dangerous

[1:25:56] this development but rather Going to be used for dangerous And unnecessary things such as

[1:25:59] going to be used for dangerous And unnecessary things such as

[1:25:59] going to be used for dangerous And unnecessary things such as Gas stoves and gas fireplaces

[1:26:01] and unnecessary things such as Gas stoves and gas fireplaces

[1:26:02] and unnecessary things such as Gas stoves and gas fireplaces As a as such I think that that

[1:26:06] gas stoves and gas fireplaces As a as such I think that that

[1:26:06] gas stoves and gas fireplaces As a as such I think that that This once again if we're all

[1:26:10] as a as such I think that that This once again if we're all

[1:26:10] as a as such I think that that This once again if we're all Going to move forward on this

[1:26:11] this once again if we're all Going to move forward on this

[1:26:11] this once again if we're all Going to move forward on this It needs to to go back to

[1:26:14] going to move forward on this It needs to to go back to

[1:26:14] going to move forward on this It needs to to go back to Square one.

[1:26:18] it needs to to go back to Square one.

[1:26:18] it needs to to go back to Square one. >> this doesn't this clearly

[1:26:18] square one. >> this doesn't this clearly

[1:26:19] square one. >> this doesn't this clearly Does not need to be a gas that

[1:26:22] » this doesn't this clearly Does not need to be a gas that

[1:26:22] » this doesn't this clearly Does not need to be a gas that It does not need to have gas

[1:26:25] does not need to be a gas that It does not need to have gas

[1:26:25] does not need to be a gas that It does not need to have gas Hookups.

[1:26:26] it does not need to have gas Hookups.

[1:26:26] it does not need to have gas Hookups. >> it can be all electric 30

[1:26:30] hookups. >> it can be all electric 30

[1:26:30] hookups. >> it can be all electric 30 Seconds too much parking and

[1:26:33] » it can be all electric 30 Seconds too much parking and

[1:26:34] » it can be all electric 30 Seconds too much parking and Which and we're still

[1:26:34] seconds too much parking and Which and we're still

[1:26:34] seconds too much parking and Which and we're still Prioritizing parking of busses

[1:26:37] which and we're still Prioritizing parking of busses

[1:26:37] which and we're still Prioritizing parking of busses Over bicycle that bicycles over

[1:26:41] prioritizing parking of busses Over bicycle that bicycles over

[1:26:41] prioritizing parking of busses Over bicycle that bicycles over People walking safely and that

[1:26:45] over bicycle that bicycles over People walking safely and that

[1:26:45] over bicycle that bicycles over People walking safely and that Is just not acceptable.

[1:26:46] people walking safely and that Is just not acceptable.

[1:26:46] people walking safely and that Is just not acceptable. >> thank you.

[1:26:46] is just not acceptable. >> thank you.

[1:26:46] is just not acceptable. >> thank you. Thank you

[1:26:55] , mayor.

[1:26:56] , mayor.

[1:26:56] , mayor. >> don't have any other callers

[1:26:57] , mayor. >> don't have any other callers

[1:26:57] , mayor. >> don't have any other callers On line for this hearing

[1:27:07] see.

[1:27:07] see. >> no in this public hearing is

[1:27:11] see. >> no in this public hearing is

[1:27:11] see. >> no in this public hearing is Closed.

[1:27:12] » no in this public hearing is Closed.

[1:27:12] » no in this public hearing is Closed. >> we now have before us the

[1:27:12] closed. >> we now have before us the

[1:27:12] closed. >> we now have before us the Meeting minutes of january five

[1:27:16] » we now have before us the Meeting minutes of january five

[1:27:16] » we now have before us the Meeting minutes of january five Twenty twenty six my motion

[1:27:17] meeting minutes of january five Twenty twenty six my motion

[1:27:17] meeting minutes of january five Twenty twenty six my motion Please to approve these minutes

[1:27:20] twenty twenty six my motion Please to approve these minutes

[1:27:20] twenty twenty six my motion Please to approve these minutes Of by council member watson say

[1:27:21] please to approve these minutes Of by council member watson say

[1:27:21] please to approve these minutes Of by council member watson say Goodbye council member dish

[1:27:21] of by council member watson say Goodbye council member dish

[1:27:21] of by council member watson say Goodbye council member dish Discussion of the minutes all

[1:27:23] goodbye council member dish Discussion of the minutes all

[1:27:23] goodbye council member dish Discussion of the minutes all In favor opposed the minutes

[1:27:27] discussion of the minutes all In favor opposed the minutes

[1:27:27] discussion of the minutes all In favor opposed the minutes Are approved c want an audience

[1:27:28] in favor opposed the minutes Are approved c want an audience

[1:27:28] in favor opposed the minutes Are approved c want an audience To amend chapter fifty five

[1:27:31] are approved c want an audience To amend chapter fifty five

[1:27:31] are approved c want an audience To amend chapter fifty five Unified development code of

[1:27:32] to amend chapter fifty five Unified development code of

[1:27:32] to amend chapter fifty five Unified development code of Title five bicycle and vehicle

[1:27:34] unified development code of Title five bicycle and vehicle

[1:27:34] unified development code of Title five bicycle and vehicle Parking move by council member

[1:27:38] title five bicycle and vehicle Parking move by council member

[1:27:38] title five bicycle and vehicle Parking move by council member Are seconded by council member

[1:27:39] parking move by council member Are seconded by council member

[1:27:39] parking move by council member Are seconded by council member Malik discussion please of c1

[1:27:42] are seconded by council member Malik discussion please of c1

[1:27:42] are seconded by council member Malik discussion please of c1 Council british so planning

[1:27:49] malik discussion please of c1 Council british so planning

[1:27:49] malik discussion please of c1 Council british so planning Staff was working on some

[1:27:50] council british so planning Staff was working on some

[1:27:50] council british so planning Staff was working on some Improvements to the city's

[1:27:50] staff was working on some Improvements to the city's

[1:27:50] staff was working on some Improvements to the city's Bicycle parking requirements to

[1:27:53] improvements to the city's Bicycle parking requirements to

[1:27:53] improvements to the city's Bicycle parking requirements to Enhance the usability design

[1:27:54] bicycle parking requirements to Enhance the usability design

[1:27:54] bicycle parking requirements to Enhance the usability design And accessible city of bicycle

[1:27:57] enhance the usability design And accessible city of bicycle

[1:27:57] enhance the usability design And accessible city of bicycle Parking spaces.

[1:27:58] and accessible city of bicycle Parking spaces.

[1:27:58] and accessible city of bicycle Parking spaces. And they also noted an

[1:27:59] parking spaces. And they also noted an

[1:27:59] parking spaces. And they also noted an Opportunity to simplify

[1:28:01] and they also noted an Opportunity to simplify

[1:28:01] and they also noted an Opportunity to simplify Required parking tables which

[1:28:02] opportunity to simplify Required parking tables which

[1:28:02] opportunity to simplify Required parking tables which Have gotten confusing and I

[1:28:06] required parking tables which Have gotten confusing and I

[1:28:06] required parking tables which Have gotten confusing and I Think we're never really

[1:28:07] have gotten confusing and I Think we're never really

[1:28:07] have gotten confusing and I Think we're never really Touched up since we eliminated

[1:28:09] think we're never really Touched up since we eliminated

[1:28:09] think we're never really Touched up since we eliminated Mandatory parking minimums.

[1:28:09] touched up since we eliminated Mandatory parking minimums.

[1:28:10] touched up since we eliminated Mandatory parking minimums. >> so there's no I want to

[1:28:11] mandatory parking minimums. >> so there's no I want to

[1:28:11] mandatory parking minimums. >> so there's no I want to Clarify make sure it's clear

[1:28:13] » so there's no I want to Clarify make sure it's clear

[1:28:14] » so there's no I want to Clarify make sure it's clear That there's no change to the

[1:28:14] clarify make sure it's clear That there's no change to the

[1:28:14] clarify make sure it's clear That there's no change to the Substance of the vehicle

[1:28:17] that there's no change to the Substance of the vehicle

[1:28:17] that there's no change to the Substance of the vehicle Parking requirements and there

[1:28:18] substance of the vehicle Parking requirements and there

[1:28:18] substance of the vehicle Parking requirements and there Are a lot of excellent changes

[1:28:21] parking requirements and there Are a lot of excellent changes

[1:28:21] parking requirements and there Are a lot of excellent changes To the bicycle parking

[1:28:21] are a lot of excellent changes To the bicycle parking

[1:28:22] are a lot of excellent changes To the bicycle parking Requirements which include

[1:28:25] to the bicycle parking Requirements which include

[1:28:25] to the bicycle parking Requirements which include Things like centering the bike

[1:28:25] requirements which include Things like centering the bike

[1:28:26] requirements which include Things like centering the bike Parking in the space so that

[1:28:29] things like centering the bike Parking in the space so that

[1:28:29] things like centering the bike Parking in the space so that Both ends of the parking are

[1:28:30] parking in the space so that Both ends of the parking are

[1:28:30] parking in the space so that Both ends of the parking are Usable.

[1:28:30] both ends of the parking are Usable.

[1:28:30] both ends of the parking are Usable. >> it is the level of detail

[1:28:32] usable. >> it is the level of detail

[1:28:32] usable. >> it is the level of detail That I will not go into for

[1:28:33] » it is the level of detail That I will not go into for

[1:28:33] » it is the level of detail That I will not go into for Once but be assured that your

[1:28:37] that I will not go into for Once but be assured that your

[1:28:37] that I will not go into for Once but be assured that your Favorite nerd's on planning

[1:28:40] once but be assured that your Favorite nerd's on planning

[1:28:40] once but be assured that your Favorite nerd's on planning Have made it better bicycle

[1:28:44] favorite nerd's on planning Have made it better bicycle

[1:28:44] favorite nerd's on planning Have made it better bicycle Parking better and so I hope

[1:28:45] have made it better bicycle Parking better and so I hope

[1:28:45] have made it better bicycle Parking better and so I hope That you will pass this along

[1:28:47] parking better and so I hope That you will pass this along

[1:28:47] parking better and so I hope That you will pass this along To second reading for the

[1:28:48] that you will pass this along To second reading for the

[1:28:48] that you will pass this along To second reading for the Discussion welfare all opposed

[1:28:56] to second reading for the Discussion welfare all opposed

[1:28:56] to second reading for the Discussion welfare all opposed It is approved said to an

[1:28:57] discussion welfare all opposed It is approved said to an

[1:28:57] discussion welfare all opposed It is approved said to an Audience to end chapter five

[1:29:00] it is approved said to an Audience to end chapter five

[1:29:00] it is approved said to an Audience to end chapter five 284 of chapter fifty five

[1:29:00] audience to end chapter five 284 of chapter fifty five

[1:29:00] audience to end chapter five 284 of chapter fifty five Unified developing code of

[1:29:03] 284 of chapter fifty five Unified developing code of

[1:29:04] 284 of chapter fifty five Unified developing code of Title five move by council

[1:29:04] unified developing code of Title five move by council

[1:29:04] unified developing code of Title five move by council Member disick

[1:29:25] advisory council

[1:29:25] advisory council Ragazzi edwyn discussion please

[1:29:26] advisory council Ragazzi edwyn discussion please

[1:29:26] advisory council Ragazzi edwyn discussion please Of c two council british.

[1:29:27] ragazzi edwyn discussion please Of c two council british.

[1:29:27] ragazzi edwyn discussion please Of c two council british. >> this also a first reading is

[1:29:28] of c two council british. >> this also a first reading is

[1:29:28] of c two council british. >> this also a first reading is The long awaited signage for

[1:29:29] » this also a first reading is The long awaited signage for

[1:29:29] » this also a first reading is The long awaited signage for Community participation

[1:29:29] the long awaited signage for Community participation

[1:29:29] the long awaited signage for Community participation Meetings.

[1:29:30] community participation Meetings.

[1:29:30] community participation Meetings. So as you know as part of our

[1:29:31] meetings. So as you know as part of our

[1:29:31] meetings. So as you know as part of our Implementation of the the new

[1:29:32] so as you know as part of our Implementation of the the new

[1:29:32] so as you know as part of our Implementation of the the new Approach to development memo

[1:29:32] implementation of the the new Approach to development memo

[1:29:33] implementation of the the new Approach to development memo That is now actually an antique

[1:29:33] approach to development memo That is now actually an antique

[1:29:34] approach to development memo That is now actually an antique Really by the standards of this

[1:29:34] that is now actually an antique Really by the standards of this

[1:29:34] that is now actually an antique Really by the standards of this Body it's like four or five

[1:29:35] really by the standards of this Body it's like four or five

[1:29:35] really by the standards of this Body it's like four or five Years old.

[1:29:37] body it's like four or five Years old.

[1:29:37] body it's like four or five Years old. There are fewer projects that

[1:29:41] years old. There are fewer projects that

[1:29:41] years old. There are fewer projects that Require a public hearing and so

[1:29:44] there are fewer projects that Require a public hearing and so

[1:29:44] there are fewer projects that Require a public hearing and so To ensure that there is that

[1:29:45] require a public hearing and so To ensure that there is that

[1:29:45] require a public hearing and so To ensure that there is that The public really knows about

[1:29:49] to ensure that there is that The public really knows about

[1:29:50] to ensure that there is that The public really knows about Projects that do have a public

[1:29:53] the public really knows about Projects that do have a public

[1:29:53] the public really knows about Projects that do have a public Hearing by city planning

[1:29:53] projects that do have a public Hearing by city planning

[1:29:54] projects that do have a public Hearing by city planning Commission and those that do

[1:29:57] hearing by city planning Commission and those that do

[1:29:57] hearing by city planning Commission and those that do Not.

[1:29:57] commission and those that do Not.

[1:29:57] commission and those that do Not. We're going to have big signs.

[1:30:01] not. We're going to have big signs.

[1:30:01] not. We're going to have big signs. They're going to be fabulous,

[1:30:04] we're going to have big signs. They're going to be fabulous,

[1:30:04] we're going to have big signs. They're going to be fabulous, Big and fabulous on site.

[1:30:08] they're going to be fabulous, Big and fabulous on site.

[1:30:08] they're going to be fabulous, Big and fabulous on site. So on site for projects that

[1:30:09] big and fabulous on site. So on site for projects that

[1:30:09] big and fabulous on site. So on site for projects that Require hearing at planning

[1:30:12] so on site for projects that Require hearing at planning

[1:30:12] so on site for projects that Require hearing at planning Commission and projects that

[1:30:16] require hearing at planning Commission and projects that

[1:30:16] require hearing at planning Commission and projects that Require site plan approval but

[1:30:16] commission and projects that Require site plan approval but

[1:30:16] commission and projects that Require site plan approval but No hearing at planning

[1:30:17] require site plan approval but No hearing at planning

[1:30:17] require site plan approval but No hearing at planning Commission and these signs will

[1:30:20] no hearing at planning Commission and these signs will

[1:30:20] no hearing at planning Commission and these signs will Tell you when the community

[1:30:21] commission and these signs will Tell you when the community

[1:30:21] commission and these signs will Tell you when the community Meeting is and it will also

[1:30:23] tell you when the community Meeting is and it will also

[1:30:23] tell you when the community Meeting is and it will also Tell you who the development

[1:30:24] meeting is and it will also Tell you who the development

[1:30:24] meeting is and it will also Tell you who the development Developer is.

[1:30:25] tell you who the development Developer is.

[1:30:25] tell you who the development Developer is. It will let you get in touch

[1:30:27] developer is. It will let you get in touch

[1:30:27] developer is. It will let you get in touch With the city.

[1:30:28] it will let you get in touch With the city.

[1:30:28] it will let you get in touch With the city. It's going to be great because

[1:30:29] with the city. It's going to be great because

[1:30:29] with the city. It's going to be great because People see things they see

[1:30:30] it's going to be great because People see things they see

[1:30:31] it's going to be great because People see things they see Sometimes holes they see

[1:30:31] people see things they see Sometimes holes they see

[1:30:31] people see things they see Sometimes holes they see Sometimes stacks of floors and

[1:30:35] sometimes holes they see Sometimes stacks of floors and

[1:30:35] sometimes holes they see Sometimes stacks of floors and They wonder oh what's happening

[1:30:36] sometimes stacks of floors and They wonder oh what's happening

[1:30:36] sometimes stacks of floors and They wonder oh what's happening Here and can I say something

[1:30:39] they wonder oh what's happening Here and can I say something

[1:30:39] they wonder oh what's happening Here and can I say something About it?

[1:30:39] here and can I say something About it?

[1:30:40] here and can I say something About it? And the these signs will give

[1:30:40] about it? And the these signs will give

[1:30:40] about it? And the these signs will give Them the answer in the prompt.

[1:30:43] and the these signs will give Them the answer in the prompt.

[1:30:43] and the these signs will give Them the answer in the prompt. >> so again, I urge you to pass

[1:30:44] them the answer in the prompt. >> so again, I urge you to pass

[1:30:45] them the answer in the prompt. >> so again, I urge you to pass This along.

[1:30:47] » so again, I urge you to pass This along.

[1:30:47] » so again, I urge you to pass This along. >> the second reading for the

[1:30:48] this along. >> the second reading for the

[1:30:48] this along. >> the second reading for the Discussion council member

[1:30:48] » the second reading for the Discussion council member

[1:30:48] » the second reading for the Discussion council member Breeks I just like to think

[1:30:54] discussion council member Breeks I just like to think

[1:30:54] discussion council member Breeks I just like to think Planning staff and planning

[1:30:55] breeks I just like to think Planning staff and planning

[1:30:55] breeks I just like to think Planning staff and planning Planning commission sending

[1:30:58] planning staff and planning Planning commission sending

[1:30:58] planning staff and planning Planning commission sending This along.

[1:30:58] planning commission sending This along.

[1:30:58] planning commission sending This along. I've reached out to council

[1:30:59] this along. I've reached out to council

[1:30:59] this along. I've reached out to council Member some months ago and said

[1:31:02] I've reached out to council Member some months ago and said

[1:31:02] I've reached out to council Member some months ago and said I have an idea and she said

[1:31:03] member some months ago and said I have an idea and she said

[1:31:03] member some months ago and said I have an idea and she said We're way ahead of you so this

[1:31:05] I have an idea and she said We're way ahead of you so this

[1:31:05] I have an idea and she said We're way ahead of you so this Is great and because council

[1:31:06] we're way ahead of you so this Is great and because council

[1:31:06] we're way ahead of you so this Is great and because council Members apparently kind of had

[1:31:09] is great and because council Members apparently kind of had

[1:31:09] is great and because council Members apparently kind of had A characterize my child nicely

[1:31:13] members apparently kind of had A characterize my child nicely

[1:31:13] members apparently kind of had A characterize my child nicely In a public setting dorky kids

[1:31:19] a characterize my child nicely In a public setting dorky kids

[1:31:19] a characterize my child nicely In a public setting dorky kids When we travel my child, you

[1:31:20] in a public setting dorky kids When we travel my child, you

[1:31:20] in a public setting dorky kids When we travel my child, you Know, points out these signs in

[1:31:23] when we travel my child, you Know, points out these signs in

[1:31:23] when we travel my child, you Know, points out these signs in Other communities says hey, why

[1:31:24] know, points out these signs in Other communities says hey, why

[1:31:24] know, points out these signs in Other communities says hey, why Don't we have this in our

[1:31:24] other communities says hey, why Don't we have this in our

[1:31:24] other communities says hey, why Don't we have this in our Community?

[1:31:25] don't we have this in our Community?

[1:31:25] don't we have this in our Community? And I think it's one of these

[1:31:27] community? And I think it's one of these

[1:31:27] community? And I think it's one of these Pieces where if you want to

[1:31:28] and I think it's one of these Pieces where if you want to

[1:31:28] and I think it's one of these Pieces where if you want to Communicate to folks about

[1:31:31] pieces where if you want to Communicate to folks about

[1:31:31] pieces where if you want to Communicate to folks about What's happening in their

[1:31:31] communicate to folks about What's happening in their

[1:31:32] communicate to folks about What's happening in their Neighborhood, the easiest way

[1:31:32] what's happening in their Neighborhood, the easiest way

[1:31:32] what's happening in their Neighborhood, the easiest way To reach them is just simply

[1:31:34] neighborhood, the easiest way To reach them is just simply

[1:31:34] neighborhood, the easiest way To reach them is just simply Posting a sign on that that

[1:31:35] to reach them is just simply Posting a sign on that that

[1:31:35] to reach them is just simply Posting a sign on that that Spot and letting them know that

[1:31:38] posting a sign on that that Spot and letting them know that

[1:31:39] posting a sign on that that Spot and letting them know that A development is anticipated

[1:31:39] spot and letting them know that A development is anticipated

[1:31:39] spot and letting them know that A development is anticipated And when the public meetings

[1:31:42] a development is anticipated And when the public meetings

[1:31:42] a development is anticipated And when the public meetings Are going to be and it's a

[1:31:43] and when the public meetings Are going to be and it's a

[1:31:43] and when the public meetings Are going to be and it's a Great way for us to be able to

[1:31:45] are going to be and it's a Great way for us to be able to

[1:31:45] are going to be and it's a Great way for us to be able to Communicate effectively with

[1:31:46] great way for us to be able to Communicate effectively with

[1:31:46] great way for us to be able to Communicate effectively with Our residents and let them know

[1:31:49] communicate effectively with Our residents and let them know

[1:31:50] communicate effectively with Our residents and let them know That we really do appreciate

[1:31:50] our residents and let them know That we really do appreciate

[1:31:50] our residents and let them know That we really do appreciate And value their input in the

[1:31:51] that we really do appreciate And value their input in the

[1:31:51] that we really do appreciate And value their input in the Process for the discussion well

[1:31:58] and value their input in the Process for the discussion well

[1:31:58] and value their input in the Process for the discussion well In favor or opposed it is

[1:32:02] process for the discussion well In favor or opposed it is

[1:32:02] process for the discussion well In favor or opposed it is Approved c three an audience to

[1:32:03] in favor or opposed it is Approved c three an audience to

[1:32:03] in favor or opposed it is Approved c three an audience to Amend chapter fifty five zoning

[1:32:03] approved c three an audience to Amend chapter fifty five zoning

[1:32:04] approved c three an audience to Amend chapter fifty five zoning Rezoning point one five acres

[1:32:06] amend chapter fifty five zoning Rezoning point one five acres

[1:32:07] amend chapter fifty five zoning Rezoning point one five acres Shampooed plan unit development

[1:32:07] rezoning point one five acres Shampooed plan unit development

[1:32:07] rezoning point one five acres Shampooed plan unit development District two are c multifamily

[1:32:10] shampooed plan unit development District two are c multifamily

[1:32:10] shampooed plan unit development District two are c multifamily District 715 717 east huron

[1:32:14] district two are c multifamily District 715 717 east huron

[1:32:14] district two are c multifamily District 715 717 east huron Street rezoning 715 770 east

[1:32:18] district 715 717 east huron Street rezoning 715 770 east

[1:32:18] district 715 717 east huron Street rezoning 715 770 east Here on street move by council

[1:32:19] street rezoning 715 770 east Here on street move by council

[1:32:19] street rezoning 715 770 east Here on street move by council Member second by council denha

[1:32:22] here on street move by council Member second by council denha

[1:32:22] here on street move by council Member second by council denha Discussion please of c three on

[1:32:25] member second by council denha Discussion please of c three on

[1:32:25] member second by council denha Discussion please of c three on Favor paused it is approved for

[1:32:33] discussion please of c three on Favor paused it is approved for

[1:32:33] discussion please of c three on Favor paused it is approved for An ordinance to amend section

[1:32:38] favor paused it is approved for An ordinance to amend section

[1:32:38] favor paused it is approved for An ordinance to amend section Part of me.

[1:32:38] an ordinance to amend section Part of me.

[1:32:38] an ordinance to amend section Part of me. >> thank you cifor an ordinance

[1:32:41] part of me. >> thank you cifor an ordinance

[1:32:41] part of me. >> thank you cifor an ordinance To amend section eight five

[1:32:42] » thank you cifor an ordinance To amend section eight five

[1:32:42] » thank you cifor an ordinance To amend section eight five Three to of chapter one zero

[1:32:45] to amend section eight five Three to of chapter one zero

[1:32:45] to amend section eight five Three to of chapter one zero Five housing code of title

[1:32:46] three to of chapter one zero Five housing code of title

[1:32:46] three to of chapter one zero Five housing code of title Eight building regulations

[1:32:47] five housing code of title Eight building regulations

[1:32:47] five housing code of title Eight building regulations Of the code the sea

[1:32:49] eight building regulations Of the code the sea

[1:32:50] eight building regulations Of the code the sea Of narborough move by council

[1:32:50] of the code the sea Of narborough move by council

[1:32:50] of the code the sea Of narborough move by council Member denha second by council

[1:32:51] of narborough move by council Member denha second by council

[1:32:51] of narborough move by council Member denha second by council Member harrison discussion

[1:32:52] member denha second by council Member harrison discussion

[1:32:52] member denha second by council Member harrison discussion Please a c for council member

[1:32:53] member harrison discussion Please a c for council member

[1:32:53] member harrison discussion Please a c for council member Denha thank you mayor taylor

[1:32:57] please a c for council member Denha thank you mayor taylor

[1:32:57] please a c for council member Denha thank you mayor taylor Tonight I am incredible.

[1:32:57] denha thank you mayor taylor Tonight I am incredible.

[1:32:57] denha thank you mayor taylor Tonight I am incredible. I am incredibly happy to

[1:33:00] tonight I am incredible. I am incredibly happy to

[1:33:00] tonight I am incredible. I am incredibly happy to Introduce this ordinance

[1:33:01] I am incredibly happy to Introduce this ordinance

[1:33:01] I am incredibly happy to Introduce this ordinance Amendment to create rent

[1:33:02] introduce this ordinance Amendment to create rent

[1:33:02] introduce this ordinance Amendment to create rent Transparency in ann arbor and

[1:33:04] amendment to create rent Transparency in ann arbor and

[1:33:04] amendment to create rent Transparency in ann arbor and To ban mandatory tenancy fees

[1:33:05] transparency in ann arbor and To ban mandatory tenancy fees

[1:33:05] transparency in ann arbor and To ban mandatory tenancy fees Require clear disclosure of any

[1:33:08] to ban mandatory tenancy fees Require clear disclosure of any

[1:33:08] to ban mandatory tenancy fees Require clear disclosure of any Potential optional fees and

[1:33:08] require clear disclosure of any Potential optional fees and

[1:33:08] require clear disclosure of any Potential optional fees and Finish the job that started

[1:33:11] potential optional fees and Finish the job that started

[1:33:11] potential optional fees and Finish the job that started Last year when we eliminated

[1:33:12] finish the job that started Last year when we eliminated

[1:33:12] finish the job that started Last year when we eliminated Predatory pre tenancy junk

[1:33:15] last year when we eliminated Predatory pre tenancy junk

[1:33:15] last year when we eliminated Predatory pre tenancy junk Fees.

[1:33:16] predatory pre tenancy junk Fees.

[1:33:16] predatory pre tenancy junk Fees. As we consider this rent

[1:33:16] fees. As we consider this rent

[1:33:16] fees. As we consider this rent Transparency ordinance this

[1:33:17] as we consider this rent Transparency ordinance this

[1:33:17] as we consider this rent Transparency ordinance this Evening I also want to be very

[1:33:20] transparency ordinance this Evening I also want to be very

[1:33:20] transparency ordinance this Evening I also want to be very Transparent about what it does

[1:33:21] evening I also want to be very Transparent about what it does

[1:33:21] evening I also want to be very Transparent about what it does Not do this ordinance

[1:33:23] transparent about what it does Not do this ordinance

[1:33:23] transparent about what it does Not do this ordinance Unfortunately will not likely

[1:33:24] not do this ordinance Unfortunately will not likely

[1:33:24] not do this ordinance Unfortunately will not likely Lower the actual monthly costs

[1:33:26] unfortunately will not likely Lower the actual monthly costs

[1:33:26] unfortunately will not likely Lower the actual monthly costs For most tenants.

[1:33:27] lower the actual monthly costs For most tenants.

[1:33:27] lower the actual monthly costs For most tenants. As we know, state law continues

[1:33:28] for most tenants. As we know, state law continues

[1:33:28] for most tenants. As we know, state law continues To operate with us from taking

[1:33:31] as we know, state law continues To operate with us from taking

[1:33:31] as we know, state law continues To operate with us from taking Any action that could amount to

[1:33:32] to operate with us from taking Any action that could amount to

[1:33:32] to operate with us from taking Any action that could amount to Rent control.

[1:33:32] any action that could amount to Rent control.

[1:33:32] any action that could amount to Rent control. So in fact enacting this

[1:33:34] rent control. So in fact enacting this

[1:33:34] rent control. So in fact enacting this Ordinance may even initially

[1:33:35] so in fact enacting this Ordinance may even initially

[1:33:35] so in fact enacting this Ordinance may even initially Appear to increase the base

[1:33:36] ordinance may even initially Appear to increase the base

[1:33:36] ordinance may even initially Appear to increase the base Cost of rent as landlords shift

[1:33:39] appear to increase the base Cost of rent as landlords shift

[1:33:39] appear to increase the base Cost of rent as landlords shift Their pricing models from a

[1:33:39] cost of rent as landlords shift Their pricing models from a

[1:33:40] cost of rent as landlords shift Their pricing models from a Less transparent fee based

[1:33:42] their pricing models from a Less transparent fee based

[1:33:42] their pricing models from a Less transparent fee based Structure and shift to those

[1:33:43] less transparent fee based Structure and shift to those

[1:33:43] less transparent fee based Structure and shift to those Rental costs into the

[1:33:44] structure and shift to those Rental costs into the

[1:33:44] structure and shift to those Rental costs into the Advertised monthly based cost

[1:33:47] rental costs into the Advertised monthly based cost

[1:33:47] rental costs into the Advertised monthly based cost Of rent.

[1:33:47] advertised monthly based cost Of rent.

[1:33:47] advertised monthly based cost Of rent. What this ordinance will do is

[1:33:48] of rent. What this ordinance will do is

[1:33:48] of rent. What this ordinance will do is Empower tenants and prospective

[1:33:51] what this ordinance will do is Empower tenants and prospective

[1:33:51] what this ordinance will do is Empower tenants and prospective Tenants throughout in arber to

[1:33:52] empower tenants and prospective Tenants throughout in arber to

[1:33:52] empower tenants and prospective Tenants throughout in arber to Shop apples to apples in the

[1:33:54] tenants throughout in arber to Shop apples to apples in the

[1:33:54] tenants throughout in arber to Shop apples to apples in the Rental housing market with full

[1:33:55] shop apples to apples in the Rental housing market with full

[1:33:55] shop apples to apples in the Rental housing market with full Knowledge of what their

[1:33:56] rental housing market with full Knowledge of what their

[1:33:56] rental housing market with full Knowledge of what their Prospective monthly housing

[1:33:57] knowledge of what their Prospective monthly housing

[1:33:57] knowledge of what their Prospective monthly housing Costs will be allowing them to

[1:33:58] prospective monthly housing Costs will be allowing them to

[1:33:58] prospective monthly housing Costs will be allowing them to Plan for expenses and budget

[1:33:59] costs will be allowing them to Plan for expenses and budget

[1:33:59] costs will be allowing them to Plan for expenses and budget Responsibly without being

[1:34:02] plan for expenses and budget Responsibly without being

[1:34:02] plan for expenses and budget Responsibly without being Surprised by hidden, mandatory

[1:34:02] responsibly without being Surprised by hidden, mandatory

[1:34:03] responsibly without being Surprised by hidden, mandatory And often monthly fees that

[1:34:07] surprised by hidden, mandatory And often monthly fees that

[1:34:07] surprised by hidden, mandatory And often monthly fees that Should have been factored into

[1:34:07] and often monthly fees that Should have been factored into

[1:34:07] and often monthly fees that Should have been factored into The costs of their rent to

[1:34:08] should have been factored into The costs of their rent to

[1:34:08] should have been factored into The costs of their rent to Begin with, when a property

[1:34:10] the costs of their rent to Begin with, when a property

[1:34:10] the costs of their rent to Begin with, when a property Manager advertises that the

[1:34:11] begin with, when a property Manager advertises that the

[1:34:11] begin with, when a property Manager advertises that the Costs of rent for a unit is one

[1:34:14] manager advertises that the Costs of rent for a unit is one

[1:34:14] manager advertises that the Costs of rent for a unit is one Thousand dollars a month, it

[1:34:14] costs of rent for a unit is one Thousand dollars a month, it

[1:34:14] costs of rent for a unit is one Thousand dollars a month, it Should cost one thousand

[1:34:15] thousand dollars a month, it Should cost one thousand

[1:34:15] thousand dollars a month, it Should cost one thousand Dollars a month.

[1:34:17] should cost one thousand Dollars a month.

[1:34:17] should cost one thousand Dollars a month. A prospective tenant should not

[1:34:18] dollars a month. A prospective tenant should not

[1:34:18] dollars a month. A prospective tenant should not Show up to sign a lease and

[1:34:19] a prospective tenant should not Show up to sign a lease and

[1:34:19] a prospective tenant should not Show up to sign a lease and Learn that on top of their

[1:34:20] show up to sign a lease and Learn that on top of their

[1:34:20] show up to sign a lease and Learn that on top of their Monthly rent.

[1:34:21] learn that on top of their Monthly rent.

[1:34:21] learn that on top of their Monthly rent. They will also be expected to

[1:34:22] monthly rent. They will also be expected to

[1:34:22] monthly rent. They will also be expected to Pay often hundreds of dollars

[1:34:22] they will also be expected to Pay often hundreds of dollars

[1:34:23] they will also be expected to Pay often hundreds of dollars In unavoidable, previously

[1:34:25] pay often hundreds of dollars In unavoidable, previously

[1:34:25] pay often hundreds of dollars In unavoidable, previously Undisclosed and undisclosed

[1:34:29] in unavoidable, previously Undisclosed and undisclosed

[1:34:29] in unavoidable, previously Undisclosed and undisclosed Fees dramatically increasing

[1:34:29] undisclosed and undisclosed Fees dramatically increasing

[1:34:29] undisclosed and undisclosed Fees dramatically increasing Their monthly housing costs.

[1:34:32] fees dramatically increasing Their monthly housing costs.

[1:34:33] fees dramatically increasing Their monthly housing costs. To fix this, this ordinance

[1:34:34] their monthly housing costs. To fix this, this ordinance

[1:34:34] their monthly housing costs. To fix this, this ordinance Will prohibit landlords from

[1:34:34] to fix this, this ordinance Will prohibit landlords from

[1:34:34] to fix this, this ordinance Will prohibit landlords from Charging any mandatory fee.

[1:34:36] will prohibit landlords from Charging any mandatory fee.

[1:34:36] will prohibit landlords from Charging any mandatory fee. Those costs should be billed as

[1:34:37] charging any mandatory fee. Those costs should be billed as

[1:34:37] charging any mandatory fee. Those costs should be billed as What they are rent and in order

[1:34:40] those costs should be billed as What they are rent and in order

[1:34:40] those costs should be billed as What they are rent and in order To ensure that the rent costs

[1:34:41] what they are rent and in order To ensure that the rent costs

[1:34:41] what they are rent and in order To ensure that the rent costs Are not unnecessarily impacted

[1:34:43] to ensure that the rent costs Are not unnecessarily impacted

[1:34:44] to ensure that the rent costs Are not unnecessarily impacted By eliminating fees for

[1:34:44] are not unnecessarily impacted By eliminating fees for

[1:34:44] are not unnecessarily impacted By eliminating fees for Services and benefits that only

[1:34:45] by eliminating fees for Services and benefits that only

[1:34:45] by eliminating fees for Services and benefits that only Some tenants are receiving, it

[1:34:48] services and benefits that only Some tenants are receiving, it

[1:34:48] services and benefits that only Some tenants are receiving, it Will continue to allow optional

[1:34:49] some tenants are receiving, it Will continue to allow optional

[1:34:49] some tenants are receiving, it Will continue to allow optional Tenancy fees.

[1:34:49] will continue to allow optional Tenancy fees.

[1:34:49] will continue to allow optional Tenancy fees. These are fees that a tenant

[1:34:52] tenancy fees. These are fees that a tenant

[1:34:52] tenancy fees. These are fees that a tenant Can choose to pay by opting

[1:34:53] these are fees that a tenant Can choose to pay by opting

[1:34:53] these are fees that a tenant Can choose to pay by opting Into specific services taking

[1:34:55] can choose to pay by opting Into specific services taking

[1:34:55] can choose to pay by opting Into specific services taking Specific actions or failing to

[1:34:56] into specific services taking Specific actions or failing to

[1:34:56] into specific services taking Specific actions or failing to Complete an obligation set

[1:34:57] specific actions or failing to Complete an obligation set

[1:34:57] specific actions or failing to Complete an obligation set Forth in their lease that

[1:34:59] complete an obligation set Forth in their lease that

[1:35:00] complete an obligation set Forth in their lease that Resulted in actual cost to the

[1:35:00] forth in their lease that Resulted in actual cost to the

[1:35:01] forth in their lease that Resulted in actual cost to the Property owner.

[1:35:01] resulted in actual cost to the Property owner.

[1:35:01] resulted in actual cost to the Property owner. So think of things like parking

[1:35:03] property owner. So think of things like parking

[1:35:03] property owner. So think of things like parking Fees when a parking spot is not

[1:35:04] so think of things like parking Fees when a parking spot is not

[1:35:04] so think of things like parking Fees when a parking spot is not Provided to every tenant pet

[1:35:07] fees when a parking spot is not Provided to every tenant pet

[1:35:07] fees when a parking spot is not Provided to every tenant pet Fees or incurring fees and

[1:35:07] provided to every tenant pet Fees or incurring fees and

[1:35:08] provided to every tenant pet Fees or incurring fees and Fines that have been paid by a

[1:35:08] fees or incurring fees and Fines that have been paid by a

[1:35:08] fees or incurring fees and Fines that have been paid by a Landlord.

[1:35:11] fines that have been paid by a Landlord.

[1:35:11] fines that have been paid by a Landlord. It also allows properties to

[1:35:12] landlord. It also allows properties to

[1:35:12] landlord. It also allows properties to Continue to provide and charge

[1:35:12] it also allows properties to Continue to provide and charge

[1:35:12] it also allows properties to Continue to provide and charge For utility usage and if passed

[1:35:15] continue to provide and charge For utility usage and if passed

[1:35:15] continue to provide and charge For utility usage and if passed Tonight this ordinance will not

[1:35:19] for utility usage and if passed Tonight this ordinance will not

[1:35:19] for utility usage and if passed Tonight this ordinance will not Is not set to take effect until

[1:35:19] tonight this ordinance will not Is not set to take effect until

[1:35:20] tonight this ordinance will not Is not set to take effect until August.

[1:35:20] is not set to take effect until August.

[1:35:20] is not set to take effect until August. That was intentional to ensure

[1:35:22] august. That was intentional to ensure

[1:35:23] august. That was intentional to ensure That landlords have the time

[1:35:23] that was intentional to ensure That landlords have the time

[1:35:23] that was intentional to ensure That landlords have the time And opportunity to update their

[1:35:24] that landlords have the time And opportunity to update their

[1:35:24] that landlords have the time And opportunity to update their Leases and change pricing

[1:35:27] and opportunity to update their Leases and change pricing

[1:35:27] and opportunity to update their Leases and change pricing Structures without immediately

[1:35:27] leases and change pricing Structures without immediately

[1:35:27] leases and change pricing Structures without immediately Falling into noncompliance and

[1:35:31] structures without immediately Falling into noncompliance and

[1:35:31] structures without immediately Falling into noncompliance and To allow us to address ongoing

[1:35:31] falling into noncompliance and To allow us to address ongoing

[1:35:32] falling into noncompliance and To allow us to address ongoing Code enforcement needs in our

[1:35:32] to allow us to address ongoing Code enforcement needs in our

[1:35:32] to allow us to address ongoing Code enforcement needs in our Next budget cycle prior to

[1:35:34] code enforcement needs in our Next budget cycle prior to

[1:35:34] code enforcement needs in our Next budget cycle prior to Adding to that need.

[1:35:35] next budget cycle prior to Adding to that need.

[1:35:35] next budget cycle prior to Adding to that need. Finally, I just want to briefly

[1:35:38] adding to that need. Finally, I just want to briefly

[1:35:38] adding to that need. Finally, I just want to briefly Thank a number of people for

[1:35:39] finally, I just want to briefly Thank a number of people for

[1:35:39] finally, I just want to briefly Thank a number of people for Their contributions to this

[1:35:39] thank a number of people for Their contributions to this

[1:35:39] thank a number of people for Their contributions to this Legislation specifically

[1:35:41] their contributions to this Legislation specifically

[1:35:42] their contributions to this Legislation specifically Renters commission colleague,

[1:35:42] legislation specifically Renters commission colleague,

[1:35:42] legislation specifically Renters commission colleague, Council member harrison, our

[1:35:43] renters commission colleague, Council member harrison, our

[1:35:43] renters commission colleague, Council member harrison, our City attorneys and staff

[1:35:45] council member harrison, our City attorneys and staff

[1:35:46] council member harrison, our City attorneys and staff Particularly attorneys riiser

[1:35:46] city attorneys and staff Particularly attorneys riiser

[1:35:46] city attorneys and staff Particularly attorneys riiser And richard's members of the

[1:35:47] particularly attorneys riiser And richard's members of the

[1:35:47] particularly attorneys riiser And richard's members of the Renters commission,

[1:35:50] and richard's members of the Renters commission,

[1:35:50] and richard's members of the Renters commission, Particularly gail rosen who has

[1:35:51] renters commission, Particularly gail rosen who has

[1:35:51] renters commission, Particularly gail rosen who has Contributed significantly to

[1:35:51] particularly gail rosen who has Contributed significantly to

[1:35:51] particularly gail rosen who has Contributed significantly to Developing this ordinance and

[1:35:53] contributed significantly to Developing this ordinance and

[1:35:53] contributed significantly to Developing this ordinance and Relying on her experience as an

[1:35:54] developing this ordinance and Relying on her experience as an

[1:35:54] developing this ordinance and Relying on her experience as an Attorney and advocate for

[1:35:55] relying on her experience as an Attorney and advocate for

[1:35:55] relying on her experience as an Attorney and advocate for Student tenants, members of the

[1:35:57] attorney and advocate for Student tenants, members of the

[1:35:57] attorney and advocate for Student tenants, members of the Tenants union.

[1:35:58] student tenants, members of the Tenants union.

[1:35:58] student tenants, members of the Tenants union. And even though we didn't

[1:36:01] tenants union. And even though we didn't

[1:36:01] tenants union. And even though we didn't Ultimately align on everything,

[1:36:02] and even though we didn't Ultimately align on everything,

[1:36:02] and even though we didn't Ultimately align on everything, Several property managers and

[1:36:05] ultimately align on everything, Several property managers and

[1:36:05] ultimately align on everything, Several property managers and Landlords who engaged with this

[1:36:06] several property managers and Landlords who engaged with this

[1:36:06] several property managers and Landlords who engaged with this Ordinance language in good

[1:36:06] landlords who engaged with this Ordinance language in good

[1:36:06] landlords who engaged with this Ordinance language in good Faith contributed ideas and

[1:36:09] ordinance language in good Faith contributed ideas and

[1:36:09] ordinance language in good Faith contributed ideas and Improved it through their

[1:36:10] faith contributed ideas and Improved it through their

[1:36:10] faith contributed ideas and Improved it through their Suggestions and input so thank

[1:36:12] improved it through their Suggestions and input so thank

[1:36:12] improved it through their Suggestions and input so thank You to everyone who has brought

[1:36:13] suggestions and input so thank You to everyone who has brought

[1:36:13] suggestions and input so thank You to everyone who has brought Us here today and I hope that

[1:36:14] you to everyone who has brought Us here today and I hope that

[1:36:14] you to everyone who has brought Us here today and I hope that You will support this and move

[1:36:14] us here today and I hope that You will support this and move

[1:36:15] us here today and I hope that You will support this and move It forward a second reading

[1:36:16] you will support this and move It forward a second reading

[1:36:16] you will support this and move It forward a second reading Council member harrison.

[1:36:17] it forward a second reading Council member harrison.

[1:36:17] it forward a second reading Council member harrison. >> thank you, mayor.

[1:36:20] council member harrison. >> thank you, mayor.

[1:36:20] council member harrison. >> thank you, mayor. >> housing in the city is

[1:36:21] » thank you, mayor. >> housing in the city is

[1:36:21] » thank you, mayor. >> housing in the city is Expensive enough without

[1:36:22] » housing in the city is Expensive enough without

[1:36:22] » housing in the city is Expensive enough without Surprises but for many renters

[1:36:25] expensive enough without Surprises but for many renters

[1:36:25] expensive enough without Surprises but for many renters Especially first time renters

[1:36:25] surprises but for many renters Especially first time renters

[1:36:25] surprises but for many renters Especially first time renters And people are new to the city

[1:36:28] especially first time renters And people are new to the city

[1:36:28] especially first time renters And people are new to the city Of ann arbor, the real cost

[1:36:29] and people are new to the city Of ann arbor, the real cost

[1:36:29] and people are new to the city Of ann arbor, the real cost Does not show up until it's too

[1:36:32] of ann arbor, the real cost Does not show up until it's too

[1:36:32] of ann arbor, the real cost Does not show up until it's too Late.

[1:36:32] does not show up until it's too Late.

[1:36:32] does not show up until it's too Late. What I hear again and again is

[1:36:35] late. What I hear again and again is

[1:36:35] late. What I hear again and again is That people don't know the true

[1:36:36] what I hear again and again is That people don't know the true

[1:36:36] what I hear again and again is That people don't know the true Cost of what they owe each

[1:36:36] that people don't know the true Cost of what they owe each

[1:36:37] that people don't know the true Cost of what they owe each Month until after they have

[1:36:39] cost of what they owe each Month until after they have

[1:36:39] cost of what they owe each Month until after they have Committed they see an

[1:36:40] month until after they have Committed they see an

[1:36:40] month until after they have Committed they see an Advertised rent and assume

[1:36:43] committed they see an Advertised rent and assume

[1:36:43] committed they see an Advertised rent and assume That's it.

[1:36:43] advertised rent and assume That's it.

[1:36:43] advertised rent and assume That's it. Then come the add on required

[1:36:44] that's it. Then come the add on required

[1:36:45] that's it. Then come the add on required Charges unclear utility

[1:36:47] then come the add on required Charges unclear utility

[1:36:47] then come the add on required Charges unclear utility Structures, fee fees disclosed

[1:36:51] charges unclear utility Structures, fee fees disclosed

[1:36:51] charges unclear utility Structures, fee fees disclosed Late or buried in lease.

[1:36:52] structures, fee fees disclosed Late or buried in lease.

[1:36:52] structures, fee fees disclosed Late or buried in lease. Most people don't know how to

[1:36:55] late or buried in lease. Most people don't know how to

[1:36:55] late or buried in lease. Most people don't know how to Read line by line by the time

[1:36:56] most people don't know how to Read line by line by the time

[1:36:56] most people don't know how to Read line by line by the time Renters discover they've

[1:36:59] read line by line by the time Renters discover they've

[1:36:59] read line by line by the time Renters discover they've Already paid money or signed

[1:37:00] renters discover they've Already paid money or signed

[1:37:00] renters discover they've Already paid money or signed Paperwork and backing out isn't

[1:37:02] already paid money or signed Paperwork and backing out isn't

[1:37:02] already paid money or signed Paperwork and backing out isn't Really an option.

[1:37:03] paperwork and backing out isn't Really an option.

[1:37:03] paperwork and backing out isn't Really an option. >> think about choosing a

[1:37:04] really an option. >> think about choosing a

[1:37:04] really an option. >> think about choosing a Restaurant.

[1:37:06] » think about choosing a Restaurant.

[1:37:06] » think about choosing a Restaurant. >> most people would be

[1:37:07] restaurant. >> most people would be

[1:37:07] restaurant. >> most people would be Reluctant to sit down if the

[1:37:08] » most people would be Reluctant to sit down if the

[1:37:08] » most people would be Reluctant to sit down if the Menu didn't list prices.

[1:37:10] reluctant to sit down if the Menu didn't list prices.

[1:37:10] reluctant to sit down if the Menu didn't list prices. You wouldn't want to order

[1:37:11] menu didn't list prices. You wouldn't want to order

[1:37:11] menu didn't list prices. You wouldn't want to order Dinner expecting to pay fifty

[1:37:14] you wouldn't want to order Dinner expecting to pay fifty

[1:37:14] you wouldn't want to order Dinner expecting to pay fifty Dollars and get a bill for five

[1:37:15] dinner expecting to pay fifty Dollars and get a bill for five

[1:37:15] dinner expecting to pay fifty Dollars and get a bill for five Hundred but that's effective.

[1:37:18] dollars and get a bill for five Hundred but that's effective.

[1:37:18] dollars and get a bill for five Hundred but that's effective. >> what happens to some renters

[1:37:19] hundred but that's effective. >> what happens to some renters

[1:37:19] hundred but that's effective. >> what happens to some renters Here?

[1:37:19] » what happens to some renters Here?

[1:37:20] » what happens to some renters Here? This ordinance does one thing

[1:37:22] here? This ordinance does one thing

[1:37:23] here? This ordinance does one thing It requires the full cost

[1:37:23] this ordinance does one thing It requires the full cost

[1:37:23] this ordinance does one thing It requires the full cost Of rent to be shown up front in

[1:37:26] it requires the full cost Of rent to be shown up front in

[1:37:26] it requires the full cost Of rent to be shown up front in The ad on the first page of the

[1:37:27] of rent to be shown up front in The ad on the first page of the

[1:37:27] of rent to be shown up front in The ad on the first page of the Lease no surprises, no fine

[1:37:31] the ad on the first page of the Lease no surprises, no fine

[1:37:31] the ad on the first page of the Lease no surprises, no fine Print.

[1:37:31] lease no surprises, no fine Print.

[1:37:31] lease no surprises, no fine Print. It also provides clarity for

[1:37:32] print. It also provides clarity for

[1:37:32] print. It also provides clarity for Landlords by defining what

[1:37:35] it also provides clarity for Landlords by defining what

[1:37:35] it also provides clarity for Landlords by defining what Belongs in rent, what can be

[1:37:36] landlords by defining what Belongs in rent, what can be

[1:37:36] landlords by defining what Belongs in rent, what can be Optional and what must be

[1:37:39] belongs in rent, what can be Optional and what must be

[1:37:39] belongs in rent, what can be Optional and what must be Disclosed as utilities.

[1:37:39] optional and what must be Disclosed as utilities.

[1:37:39] optional and what must be Disclosed as utilities. >> that kind of clarity

[1:37:42] disclosed as utilities. >> that kind of clarity

[1:37:42] disclosed as utilities. >> that kind of clarity Protects everyone and reduces

[1:37:43] » that kind of clarity Protects everyone and reduces

[1:37:43] » that kind of clarity Protects everyone and reduces Disputes before they start

[1:37:46] protects everyone and reduces Disputes before they start

[1:37:46] protects everyone and reduces Disputes before they start Housing is too fundamental and

[1:37:47] disputes before they start Housing is too fundamental and

[1:37:47] disputes before they start Housing is too fundamental and Too costly for people to be

[1:37:48] housing is too fundamental and Too costly for people to be

[1:37:48] housing is too fundamental and Too costly for people to be Guessing.

[1:37:49] too costly for people to be Guessing.

[1:37:49] too costly for people to be Guessing. This ordinance doesn't regulate

[1:37:50] guessing. This ordinance doesn't regulate

[1:37:50] guessing. This ordinance doesn't regulate Rent and it doesn't prohibit

[1:37:54] this ordinance doesn't regulate Rent and it doesn't prohibit

[1:37:54] this ordinance doesn't regulate Rent and it doesn't prohibit Legitimate fees.

[1:37:54] rent and it doesn't prohibit Legitimate fees.

[1:37:55] rent and it doesn't prohibit Legitimate fees. It simply requires honesty and

[1:37:57] legitimate fees. It simply requires honesty and

[1:37:57] legitimate fees. It simply requires honesty and Visibility so renters can make

[1:37:58] it simply requires honesty and Visibility so renters can make

[1:37:58] it simply requires honesty and Visibility so renters can make Informed decisions before they

[1:38:01] visibility so renters can make Informed decisions before they

[1:38:01] visibility so renters can make Informed decisions before they Commit.

[1:38:01] informed decisions before they Commit.

[1:38:02] informed decisions before they Commit. >> I'm really proud to

[1:38:02] commit. >> I'm really proud to

[1:38:02] commit. >> I'm really proud to Co-sponsor that's why I am

[1:38:06] » I'm really proud to Co-sponsor that's why I am

[1:38:06] » I'm really proud to Co-sponsor that's why I am Proud to co-sponsor this

[1:38:06] co-sponsor that's why I am Proud to co-sponsor this

[1:38:07] co-sponsor that's why I am Proud to co-sponsor this Ordinance and I want to thank

[1:38:07] proud to co-sponsor this Ordinance and I want to thank

[1:38:07] proud to co-sponsor this Ordinance and I want to thank Council member denha for

[1:38:09] ordinance and I want to thank Council member denha for

[1:38:09] ordinance and I want to thank Council member denha for Leading this effort.

[1:38:10] council member denha for Leading this effort.

[1:38:10] council member denha for Leading this effort. >> thank you.

[1:38:10] leading this effort. >> thank you.

[1:38:10] leading this effort. >> thank you. Further discussion councilor

[1:38:15] » thank you. Further discussion councilor

[1:38:15] » thank you. Further discussion councilor Watson.

[1:38:16] further discussion councilor Watson.

[1:38:16] further discussion councilor Watson. I appreciate the hard work on

[1:38:20] watson. I appreciate the hard work on

[1:38:20] watson. I appreciate the hard work on On this ordinance from council

[1:38:23] I appreciate the hard work on On this ordinance from council

[1:38:23] I appreciate the hard work on On this ordinance from council Members and from community and

[1:38:24] on this ordinance from council Members and from community and

[1:38:24] on this ordinance from council Members and from community and I I've experienced some

[1:38:27] members and from community and I I've experienced some

[1:38:27] members and from community and I I've experienced some Of these same situations, you

[1:38:30] I I've experienced some Of these same situations, you

[1:38:31] I I've experienced some Of these same situations, you Know, going to somewhere

[1:38:31] of these same situations, you Know, going to somewhere

[1:38:31] of these same situations, you Know, going to somewhere Touring an apartment and seeing

[1:38:32] know, going to somewhere Touring an apartment and seeing

[1:38:32] know, going to somewhere Touring an apartment and seeing That they had amended a

[1:38:35] touring an apartment and seeing That they had amended a

[1:38:35] touring an apartment and seeing That they had amended a Mandatory trash fee and a

[1:38:36] that they had amended a Mandatory trash fee and a

[1:38:36] that they had amended a Mandatory trash fee and a Parking fee and then sooner or

[1:38:38] mandatory trash fee and a Parking fee and then sooner or

[1:38:38] mandatory trash fee and a Parking fee and then sooner or Later you're looking at two or

[1:38:39] parking fee and then sooner or Later you're looking at two or

[1:38:39] parking fee and then sooner or Later you're looking at two or Three hundred dollars more than

[1:38:41] later you're looking at two or Three hundred dollars more than

[1:38:42] later you're looking at two or Three hundred dollars more than The posted rent and actually

[1:38:42] three hundred dollars more than The posted rent and actually

[1:38:42] three hundred dollars more than The posted rent and actually That led me to walking away

[1:38:45] the posted rent and actually That led me to walking away

[1:38:45] the posted rent and actually That led me to walking away From a few places because it

[1:38:46] that led me to walking away From a few places because it

[1:38:46] that led me to walking away From a few places because it Just pushed it outside of my

[1:38:47] from a few places because it Just pushed it outside of my

[1:38:47] from a few places because it Just pushed it outside of my Budget at the time.

[1:38:50] just pushed it outside of my Budget at the time.

[1:38:50] just pushed it outside of my Budget at the time. So I'd like to I'm proud to

[1:38:53] budget at the time. So I'd like to I'm proud to

[1:38:53] budget at the time. So I'd like to I'm proud to Support this today and I'd also

[1:38:53] so I'd like to I'm proud to Support this today and I'd also

[1:38:54] so I'd like to I'm proud to Support this today and I'd also Like to be added as a

[1:38:54] support this today and I'd also Like to be added as a

[1:38:54] support this today and I'd also Like to be added as a Co-sponsor councilor bogucki

[1:38:57] like to be added as a Co-sponsor councilor bogucki

[1:38:57] like to be added as a Co-sponsor councilor bogucki Had one thank you.

[1:38:57] co-sponsor councilor bogucki Had one thank you.

[1:38:58] co-sponsor councilor bogucki Had one thank you. >> I just also want to thank

[1:39:01] had one thank you. >> I just also want to thank

[1:39:01] had one thank you. >> I just also want to thank Council member for denha

[1:39:02] » I just also want to thank Council member for denha

[1:39:02] » I just also want to thank Council member for denha Council members harrison all

[1:39:04] council member for denha Council members harrison all

[1:39:05] council member for denha Council members harrison all The individuals that helped to

[1:39:07] council members harrison all The individuals that helped to

[1:39:08] council members harrison all The individuals that helped to Contribute to this ordinance.

[1:39:08] the individuals that helped to Contribute to this ordinance.

[1:39:08] the individuals that helped to Contribute to this ordinance. I think it's so important for

[1:39:09] contribute to this ordinance. I think it's so important for

[1:39:09] contribute to this ordinance. I think it's so important for Economic equity and when we

[1:39:12] I think it's so important for Economic equity and when we

[1:39:12] I think it's so important for Economic equity and when we Think about making our city

[1:39:13] economic equity and when we Think about making our city

[1:39:13] economic equity and when we Think about making our city More affordable we have to

[1:39:14] think about making our city More affordable we have to

[1:39:14] think about making our city More affordable we have to Tackle it from numerous vantage

[1:39:16] more affordable we have to Tackle it from numerous vantage

[1:39:16] more affordable we have to Tackle it from numerous vantage Points and I think this is

[1:39:17] tackle it from numerous vantage Points and I think this is

[1:39:17] tackle it from numerous vantage Points and I think this is Really important.

[1:39:20] points and I think this is Really important.

[1:39:20] points and I think this is Really important. So thank you and proud to be a

[1:39:21] really important. So thank you and proud to be a

[1:39:21] really important. So thank you and proud to be a Part of it, proud to be a

[1:39:22] so thank you and proud to be a Part of it, proud to be a

[1:39:22] so thank you and proud to be a Part of it, proud to be a Sponsor.

[1:39:23] part of it, proud to be a Sponsor.

[1:39:24] part of it, proud to be a Sponsor. >> thank you for council member

[1:39:25] sponsor. >> thank you for council member

[1:39:25] sponsor. >> thank you for council member Brigs

[1:39:45] just wanted to thank the

[1:39:46] just wanted to thank the Sponsors co-sponsors for

[1:39:46] just wanted to thank the Sponsors co-sponsors for Bringing this forward and to

[1:39:47] sponsors co-sponsors for Bringing this forward and to

[1:39:47] sponsors co-sponsors for Bringing this forward and to The renters commission for

[1:39:48] bringing this forward and to The renters commission for

[1:39:48] bringing this forward and to The renters commission for Their work on it as well and

[1:39:48] the renters commission for Their work on it as well and

[1:39:48] the renters commission for Their work on it as well and Asked to be added as a

[1:39:49] their work on it as well and Asked to be added as a

[1:39:49] their work on it as well and Asked to be added as a Co-sponsor council member ihr

[1:39:50] asked to be added as a Co-sponsor council member ihr

[1:39:50] asked to be added as a Co-sponsor council member ihr Dedeaux what council member

[1:39:50] co-sponsor council member ihr Dedeaux what council member

[1:39:50] co-sponsor council member ihr Dedeaux what council member Brigg said thank you.

[1:39:51] dedeaux what council member Brigg said thank you.

[1:39:51] dedeaux what council member Brigg said thank you. >> further discussion.

[1:39:52] brigg said thank you. >> further discussion.

[1:39:52] brigg said thank you. >> further discussion. >> well since we all have nice

[1:39:52] » further discussion. >> well since we all have nice

[1:39:52] » further discussion. >> well since we all have nice Things to say about this, I'm

[1:39:53] » well since we all have nice Things to say about this, I'm

[1:39:53] » well since we all have nice Things to say about this, I'm Going to add some I would I too

[1:39:54] things to say about this, I'm Going to add some I would I too

[1:39:54] things to say about this, I'm Going to add some I would I too Would like to thank the renters

[1:39:55] going to add some I would I too Would like to thank the renters

[1:39:55] going to add some I would I too Would like to thank the renters Commission and council members

[1:39:55] would like to thank the renters Commission and council members

[1:39:55] would like to thank the renters Commission and council members For denha and harrison for

[1:39:56] commission and council members For denha and harrison for

[1:39:56] commission and council members For denha and harrison for Their great good work on this

[1:39:57] for denha and harrison for Their great good work on this

[1:39:57] for denha and harrison for Their great good work on this Topic.

[1:39:57] their great good work on this Topic.

[1:39:57] their great good work on this Topic. We all know that the the power

[1:39:58] topic. We all know that the the power

[1:39:58] topic. We all know that the the power Relationship between the

[1:39:58] we all know that the the power Relationship between the

[1:39:58] we all know that the the power Relationship between the Information relationship

[1:39:59] relationship between the Information relationship

[1:39:59] relationship between the Information relationship Between landlords and tenants

[1:40:02] information relationship Between landlords and tenants

[1:40:02] information relationship Between landlords and tenants And prospective tenants is

[1:40:03] between landlords and tenants And prospective tenants is

[1:40:03] between landlords and tenants And prospective tenants is Asymmetric and we are working

[1:40:06] and prospective tenants is Asymmetric and we are working

[1:40:06] and prospective tenants is Asymmetric and we are working Hard to to provide some balance

[1:40:09] asymmetric and we are working Hard to to provide some balance

[1:40:09] asymmetric and we are working Hard to to provide some balance .

[1:40:09] hard to to provide some balance .

[1:40:09] hard to to provide some balance . The ordinance as drafted will

[1:40:10] . The ordinance as drafted will

[1:40:10] . The ordinance as drafted will Do just that.

[1:40:10] the ordinance as drafted will Do just that.

[1:40:10] the ordinance as drafted will Do just that. It will make clear to tenants

[1:40:13] do just that. It will make clear to tenants

[1:40:13] do just that. It will make clear to tenants What charges they are going to

[1:40:14] it will make clear to tenants What charges they are going to

[1:40:14] it will make clear to tenants What charges they are going to Be obligated to pay, enabling

[1:40:17] what charges they are going to Be obligated to pay, enabling

[1:40:17] what charges they are going to Be obligated to pay, enabling Them to make choices about

[1:40:18] be obligated to pay, enabling Them to make choices about

[1:40:18] be obligated to pay, enabling Them to make choices about Where they live, where they are

[1:40:21] them to make choices about Where they live, where they are

[1:40:21] them to make choices about Where they live, where they are Living and giving them some

[1:40:22] where they live, where they are Living and giving them some

[1:40:22] where they live, where they are Living and giving them some More control in a economic

[1:40:25] living and giving them some More control in a economic

[1:40:25] living and giving them some More control in a economic Relationship where they are an

[1:40:29] more control in a economic Relationship where they are an

[1:40:29] more control in a economic Relationship where they are an Inherent disadvantage.

[1:40:29] relationship where they are an Inherent disadvantage.

[1:40:29] relationship where they are an Inherent disadvantage. I'm excited to be part of it

[1:40:30] inherent disadvantage. I'm excited to be part of it

[1:40:30] inherent disadvantage. I'm excited to be part of it And glad that we're moving it

[1:40:32] I'm excited to be part of it And glad that we're moving it

[1:40:32] I'm excited to be part of it And glad that we're moving it All forward.

[1:40:33] and glad that we're moving it All forward.

[1:40:33] and glad that we're moving it All forward. >> so thanks.

[1:40:36] all forward. >> so thanks.

[1:40:36] all forward. >> so thanks. Further discussion on favor

[1:40:37] » so thanks. Further discussion on favor

[1:40:37] » so thanks. Further discussion on favor Aleppo opposed is approved dc

[1:40:40] further discussion on favor Aleppo opposed is approved dc

[1:40:41] further discussion on favor Aleppo opposed is approved dc One resolution to reappoint

[1:40:44] aleppo opposed is approved dc One resolution to reappoint

[1:40:44] aleppo opposed is approved dc One resolution to reappoint Maia curtis to the board

[1:40:48] one resolution to reappoint Maia curtis to the board

[1:40:48] one resolution to reappoint Maia curtis to the board Of review as a non registered

[1:40:49] maia curtis to the board Of review as a non registered

[1:40:49] maia curtis to the board Of review as a non registered Elector move by council member

[1:40:52] of review as a non registered Elector move by council member

[1:40:52] of review as a non registered Elector move by council member Cornell seconded by council

[1:40:53] elector move by council member Cornell seconded by council

[1:40:53] elector move by council member Cornell seconded by council Member watson discussion please

[1:40:54] cornell seconded by council Member watson discussion please

[1:40:54] cornell seconded by council Member watson discussion please Of dc one on favor or opposed

[1:40:59] member watson discussion please Of dc one on favor or opposed

[1:40:59] member watson discussion please Of dc one on favor or opposed Its approved yes a seven with

[1:41:12] of dc one on favor or opposed Its approved yes a seven with

[1:41:12] of dc one on favor or opposed Its approved yes a seven with 11 council members present

[1:41:12] its approved yes a seven with 11 council members present

[1:41:13] its approved yes a seven with 11 council members present Albany the affirmative thus

[1:41:13] 11 council members present Albany the affirmative thus

[1:41:13] 11 council members present Albany the affirmative thus Satisfying the eight vote

[1:41:15] albany the affirmative thus Satisfying the eight vote

[1:41:15] albany the affirmative thus Satisfying the eight vote Requirement pardon me seven

[1:41:16] satisfying the eight vote Requirement pardon me seven

[1:41:16] satisfying the eight vote Requirement pardon me seven Vote requirement cast member

[1:41:19] requirement pardon me seven Vote requirement cast member

[1:41:19] requirement pardon me seven Vote requirement cast member Of denha question of order.

[1:41:23] vote requirement cast member Of denha question of order.

[1:41:23] vote requirement cast member Of denha question of order. Thank you mr. Mayor.

[1:41:24] of denha question of order. Thank you mr. Mayor.

[1:41:24] of denha question of order. Thank you mr. Mayor. My apologies as I forgot in my

[1:41:27] thank you mr. Mayor. My apologies as I forgot in my

[1:41:27] thank you mr. Mayor. My apologies as I forgot in my Excitement that we had a very

[1:41:28] my apologies as I forgot in my Excitement that we had a very

[1:41:28] my apologies as I forgot in my Excitement that we had a very Minor amendment to tweak a

[1:41:30] excitement that we had a very Minor amendment to tweak a

[1:41:31] excitement that we had a very Minor amendment to tweak a Couple of words in this.

[1:41:31] minor amendment to tweak a Couple of words in this.

[1:41:31] minor amendment to tweak a Couple of words in this. So I would ask for

[1:41:35] couple of words in this. So I would ask for

[1:41:35] couple of words in this. So I would ask for Reconsideration of c four

[1:41:36] so I would ask for Reconsideration of c four

[1:41:36] so I would ask for Reconsideration of c four Procedurally a reconsideration

[1:41:38] reconsideration of c four Procedurally a reconsideration

[1:41:38] reconsideration of c four Procedurally a reconsideration Of c for you are on the on the

[1:41:39] procedurally a reconsideration Of c for you are on the on the

[1:41:39] procedurally a reconsideration Of c for you are on the on the Winning side of the matter and

[1:41:40] of c for you are on the on the Winning side of the matter and

[1:41:40] of c for you are on the on the Winning side of the matter and So is there do we need a second

[1:41:44] winning side of the matter and So is there do we need a second

[1:41:44] winning side of the matter and So is there do we need a second On that motion or is that just

[1:41:46] so is there do we need a second On that motion or is that just

[1:41:46] so is there do we need a second On that motion or is that just Sure.

[1:41:46] on that motion or is that just Sure.

[1:41:46] on that motion or is that just Sure. >> is there a second on that

[1:41:47] sure. >> is there a second on that

[1:41:47] sure. >> is there a second on that Motion council member breaks

[1:41:48] » is there a second on that Motion council member breaks

[1:41:48] » is there a second on that Motion council member breaks Thank you.

[1:41:48] motion council member breaks Thank you.

[1:41:49] motion council member breaks Thank you. Discussion of the

[1:41:49] thank you. Discussion of the

[1:41:49] thank you. Discussion of the Reconsideration all in favor or

[1:41:51] discussion of the Reconsideration all in favor or

[1:41:51] discussion of the Reconsideration all in favor or Oppose the reconsideration is

[1:41:51] reconsideration all in favor or Oppose the reconsideration is

[1:41:52] reconsideration all in favor or Oppose the reconsideration is Approved.

[1:41:55] oppose the reconsideration is Approved.

[1:41:55] oppose the reconsideration is Approved. We are reconsidering c for an

[1:41:56] approved. We are reconsidering c for an

[1:41:56] approved. We are reconsidering c for an Audience to amend section eight

[1:41:59] we are reconsidering c for an Audience to amend section eight

[1:41:59] we are reconsidering c for an Audience to amend section eight Five three two of chapter one

[1:42:00] audience to amend section eight Five three two of chapter one

[1:42:00] audience to amend section eight Five three two of chapter one Zero five housing code of title

[1:42:03] five three two of chapter one Zero five housing code of title

[1:42:03] five three two of chapter one Zero five housing code of title Eight building regulations

[1:42:04] zero five housing code of title Eight building regulations

[1:42:04] zero five housing code of title Eight building regulations Of the code of the city of ann

[1:42:05] eight building regulations Of the code of the city of ann

[1:42:05] eight building regulations Of the code of the city of ann Arbor move by council member

[1:42:05] of the code of the city of ann Arbor move by council member

[1:42:05] of the code of the city of ann Arbor move by council member Denha second by council member

[1:42:06] arbor move by council member Denha second by council member

[1:42:06] arbor move by council member Denha second by council member Harrison discussion please of c

[1:42:07] denha second by council member Harrison discussion please of c

[1:42:07] denha second by council member Harrison discussion please of c For council member of denha.

[1:42:10] harrison discussion please of c For council member of denha.

[1:42:10] harrison discussion please of c For council member of denha. Thank you mr. Mayor and I will

[1:42:11] for council member of denha. Thank you mr. Mayor and I will

[1:42:11] for council member of denha. Thank you mr. Mayor and I will Ask the clerk to forward on the

[1:42:14] thank you mr. Mayor and I will Ask the clerk to forward on the

[1:42:14] thank you mr. Mayor and I will Ask the clerk to forward on the Amendment as well.

[1:42:15] ask the clerk to forward on the Amendment as well.

[1:42:15] ask the clerk to forward on the Amendment as well. But this is a pretty minor

[1:42:18] amendment as well. But this is a pretty minor

[1:42:18] amendment as well. But this is a pretty minor Tweak to the utility charge

[1:42:21] but this is a pretty minor Tweak to the utility charge

[1:42:21] but this is a pretty minor Tweak to the utility charge Section which changes the

[1:42:22] tweak to the utility charge Section which changes the

[1:42:22] tweak to the utility charge Section which changes the Language you one capitalized a

[1:42:26] section which changes the Language you one capitalized a

[1:42:26] section which changes the Language you one capitalized a Solid waste to ensure that we

[1:42:27] language you one capitalized a Solid waste to ensure that we

[1:42:27] language you one capitalized a Solid waste to ensure that we Are talking about solid waste

[1:42:30] solid waste to ensure that we Are talking about solid waste

[1:42:31] solid waste to ensure that we Are talking about solid waste As provided by by the

[1:42:31] are talking about solid waste As provided by by the

[1:42:31] are talking about solid waste As provided by by the Department and then clarified

[1:42:35] as provided by by the Department and then clarified

[1:42:35] as provided by by the Department and then clarified That that is defined as in

[1:42:35] department and then clarified That that is defined as in

[1:42:35] department and then clarified That that is defined as in Chapter twenty six of existing

[1:42:38] that that is defined as in Chapter twenty six of existing

[1:42:39] that that is defined as in Chapter twenty six of existing Code .

[1:42:39] chapter twenty six of existing Code .

[1:42:39] chapter twenty six of existing Code . This is to create clarification

[1:42:42] code . This is to create clarification

[1:42:42] code . This is to create clarification Around the fact that this isn't

[1:42:43] this is to create clarification Around the fact that this isn't

[1:42:43] this is to create clarification Around the fact that this isn't Just any type of waste that

[1:42:46] around the fact that this isn't Just any type of waste that

[1:42:46] around the fact that this isn't Just any type of waste that That may be on the property but

[1:42:47] just any type of waste that That may be on the property but

[1:42:47] just any type of waste that That may be on the property but Rather those actual services

[1:42:47] that may be on the property but Rather those actual services

[1:42:47] that may be on the property but Rather those actual services That are provided.

[1:42:49] rather those actual services That are provided.

[1:42:50] rather those actual services That are provided. And so once that is circulated

[1:42:53] that are provided. And so once that is circulated

[1:42:53] that are provided. And so once that is circulated I would move to amend its is

[1:42:56] and so once that is circulated I would move to amend its is

[1:42:57] and so once that is circulated I would move to amend its is There a second seconded by

[1:42:57] I would move to amend its is There a second seconded by

[1:42:57] I would move to amend its is There a second seconded by Council member harrison the

[1:43:00] there a second seconded by Council member harrison the

[1:43:01] there a second seconded by Council member harrison the Friendly to the body friendly

[1:43:01] council member harrison the Friendly to the body friendly

[1:43:01] council member harrison the Friendly to the body friendly The body for the discussion the

[1:43:05] friendly to the body friendly The body for the discussion the

[1:43:05] friendly to the body friendly The body for the discussion the Main motion as amended?

[1:43:06] the body for the discussion the Main motion as amended?

[1:43:06] the body for the discussion the Main motion as amended? I still think it's a good idea

[1:43:10] main motion as amended? I still think it's a good idea

[1:43:10] main motion as amended? I still think it's a good idea For the discussion on favor no

[1:43:14] I still think it's a good idea For the discussion on favor no

[1:43:14] I still think it's a good idea For the discussion on favor no Opposed is approved.

[1:43:17] for the discussion on favor no Opposed is approved.

[1:43:18] for the discussion on favor no Opposed is approved. Thank you.

[1:43:18] opposed is approved. Thank you.

[1:43:18] opposed is approved. Thank you. Thank you dc to resolution

[1:43:21] thank you. Thank you dc to resolution

[1:43:21] thank you. Thank you dc to resolution Revised twenty twenty six

[1:43:22] thank you dc to resolution Revised twenty twenty six

[1:43:22] thank you dc to resolution Revised twenty twenty six Council calendar move by

[1:43:23] revised twenty twenty six Council calendar move by

[1:43:23] revised twenty twenty six Council calendar move by Council member for watson

[1:43:26] council calendar move by Council member for watson

[1:43:26] council calendar move by Council member for watson Taking my children because he

[1:43:27] council member for watson Taking my children because he

[1:43:27] council member for watson Taking my children because he Had one discussion please of dc

[1:43:27] taking my children because he Had one discussion please of dc

[1:43:28] taking my children because he Had one discussion please of dc Two in favor or opposed is

[1:43:32] had one discussion please of dc Two in favor or opposed is

[1:43:32] had one discussion please of dc Two in favor or opposed is Approved three resolution to

[1:43:37] two in favor or opposed is Approved three resolution to

[1:43:37] two in favor or opposed is Approved three resolution to Approve a brownfield plan for

[1:43:38] approved three resolution to Approve a brownfield plan for

[1:43:38] approved three resolution to Approve a brownfield plan for The aaba s project move a

[1:43:40] approve a brownfield plan for The aaba s project move a

[1:43:40] approve a brownfield plan for The aaba s project move a Council member denha seconded

[1:43:44] the aaba s project move a Council member denha seconded

[1:43:44] the aaba s project move a Council member denha seconded By council member mallik

[1:43:44] council member denha seconded By council member mallik

[1:43:44] council member denha seconded By council member mallik Discussion please of dc three

[1:43:45] by council member mallik Discussion please of dc three

[1:43:46] by council member mallik Discussion please of dc three Councilor quinnell

[1:43:53] .

[1:43:54] .

[1:43:54] . >> I'd like to move for

[1:43:55] . >> I'd like to move for

[1:43:55] . >> I'd like to move for Postponement of this agenda

[1:43:55] » I'd like to move for Postponement of this agenda

[1:43:55] » I'd like to move for Postponement of this agenda Item second by council member

[1:43:58] postponement of this agenda Item second by council member

[1:43:58] postponement of this agenda Item second by council member Brigg's discussion please

[1:43:59] item second by council member Brigg's discussion please

[1:43:59] item second by council member Brigg's discussion please Of the postponement quinnell to

[1:44:02] brigg's discussion please Of the postponement quinnell to

[1:44:02] brigg's discussion please Of the postponement quinnell to A date to the next meeting

[1:44:06] of the postponement quinnell to A date to the next meeting

[1:44:06] of the postponement quinnell to A date to the next meeting Second by councilor kernell

[1:44:06] a date to the next meeting Second by councilor kernell

[1:44:07] a date to the next meeting Second by councilor kernell Sorry.

[1:44:10] second by councilor kernell Sorry.

[1:44:10] second by councilor kernell Sorry. >> thank you kazmir cornelio

[1:44:11] sorry. >> thank you kazmir cornelio

[1:44:11] sorry. >> thank you kazmir cornelio The floor on the postponement

[1:44:11] » thank you kazmir cornelio The floor on the postponement

[1:44:12] » thank you kazmir cornelio The floor on the postponement Thank you.

[1:44:14] the floor on the postponement Thank you.

[1:44:14] the floor on the postponement Thank you. I think a lot of the first

[1:44:15] thank you. I think a lot of the first

[1:44:15] thank you. I think a lot of the first Of all I apologize for being

[1:44:18] I think a lot of the first Of all I apologize for being

[1:44:18] I think a lot of the first Of all I apologize for being Late.

[1:44:18] of all I apologize for being Late.

[1:44:18] of all I apologize for being Late. I was at a sixth grade choir

[1:44:19] late. I was at a sixth grade choir

[1:44:19] late. I was at a sixth grade choir Concert cheering on my daughter

[1:44:21] I was at a sixth grade choir Concert cheering on my daughter

[1:44:22] I was at a sixth grade choir Concert cheering on my daughter .

[1:44:22] concert cheering on my daughter .

[1:44:22] concert cheering on my daughter . I think the timing of this when

[1:44:23] . I think the timing of this when

[1:44:23] . I think the timing of this when It came to council, the lack

[1:44:25] I think the timing of this when It came to council, the lack

[1:44:25] I think the timing of this when It came to council, the lack Of time that we've had to

[1:44:28] it came to council, the lack Of time that we've had to

[1:44:29] it came to council, the lack Of time that we've had to Review the materials and the

[1:44:29] of time that we've had to Review the materials and the

[1:44:29] of time that we've had to Review the materials and the Pretty substantive changes to

[1:44:30] review the materials and the Pretty substantive changes to

[1:44:30] review the materials and the Pretty substantive changes to The original proposal created a

[1:44:33] pretty substantive changes to The original proposal created a

[1:44:33] pretty substantive changes to The original proposal created a Lot of questions for myself at

[1:44:37] the original proposal created a Lot of questions for myself at

[1:44:37] the original proposal created a Lot of questions for myself at Least and I'm sure for four

[1:44:38] lot of questions for myself at Least and I'm sure for four

[1:44:38] lot of questions for myself at Least and I'm sure for four Other colleagues and having

[1:44:38] least and I'm sure for four Other colleagues and having

[1:44:38] least and I'm sure for four Other colleagues and having Additional time to to consider

[1:44:41] other colleagues and having Additional time to to consider

[1:44:41] other colleagues and having Additional time to to consider It and ask those questions

[1:44:42] additional time to to consider It and ask those questions

[1:44:42] additional time to to consider It and ask those questions Of both staff and the developer

[1:44:45] it and ask those questions Of both staff and the developer

[1:44:45] it and ask those questions Of both staff and the developer Is advisable for their

[1:44:46] of both staff and the developer Is advisable for their

[1:44:46] of both staff and the developer Is advisable for their Discussion of the postponement

[1:44:56] .

[1:44:56] . >> councilor?

[1:45:00] . >> councilor?

[1:45:00] . >> councilor? I guess I would say in support

[1:45:01] » councilor? I guess I would say in support

[1:45:01] » councilor? I guess I would say in support Of that so the removal of the

[1:45:03] I guess I would say in support Of that so the removal of the

[1:45:03] I guess I would say in support Of that so the removal of the Ppa I think fundamentally

[1:45:04] of that so the removal of the Ppa I think fundamentally

[1:45:04] of that so the removal of the Ppa I think fundamentally Changes what this is and there

[1:45:08] ppa I think fundamentally Changes what this is and there

[1:45:08] ppa I think fundamentally Changes what this is and there Were quite a few references I

[1:45:09] changes what this is and there Were quite a few references I

[1:45:09] changes what this is and there Were quite a few references I Feel like in the materials to

[1:45:12] were quite a few references I Feel like in the materials to

[1:45:12] were quite a few references I Feel like in the materials to Some kind of an agreement

[1:45:15] feel like in the materials to Some kind of an agreement

[1:45:15] feel like in the materials to Some kind of an agreement Between the city and the

[1:45:16] some kind of an agreement Between the city and the

[1:45:16] some kind of an agreement Between the city and the Developer possibly but without

[1:45:19] between the city and the Developer possibly but without

[1:45:19] between the city and the Developer possibly but without Details and also details about

[1:45:20] developer possibly but without Details and also details about

[1:45:20] developer possibly but without Details and also details about The agreement with the housing

[1:45:20] details and also details about The agreement with the housing

[1:45:21] details and also details about The agreement with the housing Commission doesn't seem like we

[1:45:23] the agreement with the housing Commission doesn't seem like we

[1:45:24] the agreement with the housing Commission doesn't seem like we Have it in front of us.

[1:45:24] commission doesn't seem like we Have it in front of us.

[1:45:24] commission doesn't seem like we Have it in front of us. So those seem like you know,

[1:45:25] have it in front of us. So those seem like you know,

[1:45:25] have it in front of us. So those seem like you know, Since our staff is kind

[1:45:27] so those seem like you know, Since our staff is kind

[1:45:27] so those seem like you know, Since our staff is kind Of pointing to them and the

[1:45:28] since our staff is kind Of pointing to them and the

[1:45:28] since our staff is kind Of pointing to them and the Report is public but if it's

[1:45:31] of pointing to them and the Report is public but if it's

[1:45:31] of pointing to them and the Report is public but if it's Tied to agreements that no

[1:45:31] report is public but if it's Tied to agreements that no

[1:45:32] report is public but if it's Tied to agreements that no Longer exist, I'm just kind

[1:45:32] tied to agreements that no Longer exist, I'm just kind

[1:45:32] tied to agreements that no Longer exist, I'm just kind Of struggling to understand

[1:45:34] longer exist, I'm just kind Of struggling to understand

[1:45:34] longer exist, I'm just kind Of struggling to understand What the urgency of considering

[1:45:35] of struggling to understand What the urgency of considering

[1:45:35] of struggling to understand What the urgency of considering This tonight is

[1:45:42] .

[1:45:42] . Yeah, I concur.

[1:45:43] . Yeah, I concur.

[1:45:43] . Yeah, I concur. I mean we've been contemplating

[1:45:44] yeah, I concur. I mean we've been contemplating

[1:45:44] yeah, I concur. I mean we've been contemplating This project in one one

[1:45:46] I mean we've been contemplating This project in one one

[1:45:46] I mean we've been contemplating This project in one one Particular form for a couple

[1:45:47] this project in one one Particular form for a couple

[1:45:47] this project in one one Particular form for a couple Of years now and with less than

[1:45:50] particular form for a couple Of years now and with less than

[1:45:50] particular form for a couple Of years now and with less than Two weeks notice, the

[1:45:50] of years now and with less than Two weeks notice, the

[1:45:50] of years now and with less than Two weeks notice, the Fundamental structure

[1:45:53] two weeks notice, the Fundamental structure

[1:45:53] two weeks notice, the Fundamental structure Of everything has shifted and

[1:45:54] fundamental structure Of everything has shifted and

[1:45:54] fundamental structure Of everything has shifted and We don't have any accompanying

[1:45:54] of everything has shifted and We don't have any accompanying

[1:45:55] of everything has shifted and We don't have any accompanying Agreements but since we have a

[1:45:57] we don't have any accompanying Agreements but since we have a

[1:45:58] we don't have any accompanying Agreements but since we have a Moment right now, I think I'd

[1:46:02] agreements but since we have a Moment right now, I think I'd

[1:46:02] agreements but since we have a Moment right now, I think I'd Like to ask if possible maybe

[1:46:05] moment right now, I think I'd Like to ask if possible maybe

[1:46:05] moment right now, I think I'd Like to ask if possible maybe This will help others in terms

[1:46:08] like to ask if possible maybe This will help others in terms

[1:46:08] like to ask if possible maybe This will help others in terms Of their thinking around around

[1:46:09] this will help others in terms Of their thinking around around

[1:46:09] this will help others in terms Of their thinking around around This matter as well.

[1:46:09] of their thinking around around This matter as well.

[1:46:09] of their thinking around around This matter as well. You we had some we spent a

[1:46:13] this matter as well. You we had some we spent a

[1:46:13] this matter as well. You we had some we spent a Great deal of effort developing

[1:46:16] you we had some we spent a Great deal of effort developing

[1:46:16] you we had some we spent a Great deal of effort developing And contracted for that to

[1:46:20] great deal of effort developing And contracted for that to

[1:46:20] great deal of effort developing And contracted for that to Negotiate a number of elements

[1:46:21] and contracted for that to Negotiate a number of elements

[1:46:21] and contracted for that to Negotiate a number of elements That were agreed upon by by

[1:46:24] negotiate a number of elements That were agreed upon by by

[1:46:24] negotiate a number of elements That were agreed upon by by Both parties and we're told

[1:46:29] that were agreed upon by by Both parties and we're told

[1:46:29] that were agreed upon by by Both parties and we're told That these are coming

[1:46:29] both parties and we're told That these are coming

[1:46:29] both parties and we're told That these are coming Forthcoming and other

[1:46:30] that these are coming Forthcoming and other

[1:46:30] that these are coming Forthcoming and other Agreements.

[1:46:32] forthcoming and other Agreements.

[1:46:32] forthcoming and other Agreements. But again, we don't have those

[1:46:33] agreements. But again, we don't have those

[1:46:33] agreements. But again, we don't have those In front of us tonight.

[1:46:34] but again, we don't have those In front of us tonight.

[1:46:34] but again, we don't have those In front of us tonight. So I'd like to ask if possible

[1:46:36] in front of us tonight. So I'd like to ask if possible

[1:46:37] in front of us tonight. So I'd like to ask if possible If if somebody from the

[1:46:37] so I'd like to ask if possible If if somebody from the

[1:46:37] so I'd like to ask if possible If if somebody from the Development team could come up

[1:46:38] if if somebody from the Development team could come up

[1:46:38] if if somebody from the Development team could come up And I'd like to ask you and I'm

[1:46:40] development team could come up And I'd like to ask you and I'm

[1:46:40] development team could come up And I'd like to ask you and I'm Hoping the answer is yes and is

[1:46:43] and I'd like to ask you and I'm Hoping the answer is yes and is

[1:46:44] and I'd like to ask you and I'm Hoping the answer is yes and is Already negotiated agreements

[1:46:44] hoping the answer is yes and is Already negotiated agreements

[1:46:44] hoping the answer is yes and is Already negotiated agreements But kind of what the status is

[1:46:47] already negotiated agreements But kind of what the status is

[1:46:48] already negotiated agreements But kind of what the status is In terms of if you're

[1:46:48] but kind of what the status is In terms of if you're

[1:46:48] but kind of what the status is In terms of if you're Anticipating this being in

[1:46:49] in terms of if you're Anticipating this being in

[1:46:49] in terms of if you're Anticipating this being in Forthcoming development

[1:46:49] anticipating this being in Forthcoming development

[1:46:50] anticipating this being in Forthcoming development Agreements

[1:46:57] , this is from your

[1:46:58] , this is from your

[1:46:58] , this is from your Perspective confirming this

[1:47:01] , this is from your Perspective confirming this

[1:47:01] , this is from your Perspective confirming this Germane to the moment it is.

[1:47:02] perspective confirming this Germane to the moment it is.

[1:47:02] perspective confirming this Germane to the moment it is. Thank you.

[1:47:03] germane to the moment it is. Thank you.

[1:47:03] germane to the moment it is. Thank you. I mean from my perspective it

[1:47:06] thank you. I mean from my perspective it

[1:47:06] thank you. I mean from my perspective it Is not understood.

[1:47:06] I mean from my perspective it Is not understood.

[1:47:06] I mean from my perspective it Is not understood. >> yeah.

[1:47:07] is not understood. >> yeah.

[1:47:07] is not understood. >> yeah. Jeremiah thomas chief operating

[1:47:08] » yeah. Jeremiah thomas chief operating

[1:47:09] » yeah. Jeremiah thomas chief operating Officer crawford so I apologize

[1:47:12] jeremiah thomas chief operating Officer crawford so I apologize

[1:47:12] jeremiah thomas chief operating Officer crawford so I apologize .

[1:47:12] officer crawford so I apologize .

[1:47:13] officer crawford so I apologize . >> council member, could you

[1:47:13] . >> council member, could you

[1:47:14] . >> council member, could you Clarify your question?

[1:47:14] » council member, could you Clarify your question?

[1:47:14] » council member, could you Clarify your question? Yeah.

[1:47:14] clarify your question? Yeah.

[1:47:14] clarify your question? Yeah. So I'm happy to go through a

[1:47:17] yeah. So I'm happy to go through a

[1:47:17] yeah. So I'm happy to go through a List of of items that were

[1:47:18] so I'm happy to go through a List of of items that were

[1:47:18] so I'm happy to go through a List of of items that were Previously negotiated within

[1:47:20] list of of items that were Previously negotiated within

[1:47:21] list of of items that were Previously negotiated within The p.a..

[1:47:21] previously negotiated within The p.a..

[1:47:21] previously negotiated within The p.a.. Sure.

[1:47:21] the p.a.. Sure.

[1:47:21] the p.a.. Sure. And you know, my assumption

[1:47:22] sure. And you know, my assumption

[1:47:22] sure. And you know, my assumption Would be that therefore come in

[1:47:25] and you know, my assumption Would be that therefore come in

[1:47:25] and you know, my assumption Would be that therefore come in And agreed upon within the next

[1:47:26] would be that therefore come in And agreed upon within the next

[1:47:26] would be that therefore come in And agreed upon within the next Development agreements but I

[1:47:29] and agreed upon within the next Development agreements but I

[1:47:29] and agreed upon within the next Development agreements but I Just wanted to see if they were

[1:47:30] development agreements but I Just wanted to see if they were

[1:47:30] development agreements but I Just wanted to see if they were Going to you could easily say

[1:47:32] just wanted to see if they were Going to you could easily say

[1:47:32] just wanted to see if they were Going to you could easily say Yes or no.

[1:47:33] going to you could easily say Yes or no.

[1:47:33] going to you could easily say Yes or no. So the boardwalk bike lanes are

[1:47:36] yes or no. So the boardwalk bike lanes are

[1:47:36] yes or no. So the boardwalk bike lanes are Those going to be are those are

[1:47:40] so the boardwalk bike lanes are Those going to be are those are

[1:47:40] so the boardwalk bike lanes are Those going to be are those are Those something that the those

[1:47:40] those going to be are those are Those something that the those

[1:47:41] those going to be are those are Those something that the those Will be included in the

[1:47:41] those something that the those Will be included in the

[1:47:41] those something that the those Will be included in the Project?

[1:47:41] will be included in the Project?

[1:47:42] will be included in the Project? Ok and what about the south

[1:47:44] project? Ok and what about the south

[1:47:44] project? Ok and what about the south State street intersection with

[1:47:45] ok and what about the south State street intersection with

[1:47:45] ok and what about the south State street intersection with The whether or not there's

[1:47:52] state street intersection with The whether or not there's

[1:47:52] state street intersection with The whether or not there's Going to be a traffic study?

[1:47:53] the whether or not there's Going to be a traffic study?

[1:47:53] the whether or not there's Going to be a traffic study? >> we're awaiting feedback from

[1:47:53] going to be a traffic study? >> we're awaiting feedback from

[1:47:54] going to be a traffic study? >> we're awaiting feedback from City engineering on that point.

[1:47:56] » we're awaiting feedback from City engineering on that point.

[1:47:56] » we're awaiting feedback from City engineering on that point. >> but is the contribution

[1:47:57] city engineering on that point. >> but is the contribution

[1:47:57] city engineering on that point. >> but is the contribution Something that the department

[1:48:00] » but is the contribution Something that the department

[1:48:00] » but is the contribution Something that the department Team is still comfortable with

[1:48:00] something that the department Team is still comfortable with

[1:48:01] something that the department Team is still comfortable with Contributing?

[1:48:01] team is still comfortable with Contributing?

[1:48:01] team is still comfortable with Contributing? >> I think the contribution was

[1:48:04] contributing? >> I think the contribution was

[1:48:04] contributing? >> I think the contribution was Part of an agreement that was

[1:48:05] » I think the contribution was Part of an agreement that was

[1:48:05] » I think the contribution was Part of an agreement that was Comprehensive between the city

[1:48:08] part of an agreement that was Comprehensive between the city

[1:48:08] part of an agreement that was Comprehensive between the city And the developer and we're

[1:48:09] comprehensive between the city And the developer and we're

[1:48:09] comprehensive between the city And the developer and we're Looking forward to additional

[1:48:09] and the developer and we're Looking forward to additional

[1:48:09] and the developer and we're Looking forward to additional Collaboration on the point.

[1:48:12] looking forward to additional Collaboration on the point.

[1:48:12] looking forward to additional Collaboration on the point. So that's a yes.

[1:48:13] collaboration on the point. So that's a yes.

[1:48:13] collaboration on the point. So that's a yes. We're looking forward to

[1:48:14] so that's a yes. We're looking forward to

[1:48:14] so that's a yes. We're looking forward to Additional collaboration on the

[1:48:15] we're looking forward to Additional collaboration on the

[1:48:15] we're looking forward to Additional collaboration on the Point.

[1:48:15] additional collaboration on the Point.

[1:48:16] additional collaboration on the Point. >> and what about the enhanced

[1:48:16] point. >> and what about the enhanced

[1:48:16] point. >> and what about the enhanced Atay bus shelters that will be

[1:48:19] » and what about the enhanced Atay bus shelters that will be

[1:48:20] » and what about the enhanced Atay bus shelters that will be Included ok and what about the

[1:48:23] atay bus shelters that will be Included ok and what about the

[1:48:23] atay bus shelters that will be Included ok and what about the Space for a future bus rapid

[1:48:24] included ok and what about the Space for a future bus rapid

[1:48:24] included ok and what about the Space for a future bus rapid Transit station that will be

[1:48:27] space for a future bus rapid Transit station that will be

[1:48:27] space for a future bus rapid Transit station that will be Allocated.

[1:48:27] transit station that will be Allocated.

[1:48:28] transit station that will be Allocated. Yes ok wonderful.

[1:48:31] allocated. Yes ok wonderful.

[1:48:31] allocated. Yes ok wonderful. And with regards to the energy

[1:48:32] yes ok wonderful. And with regards to the energy

[1:48:32] yes ok wonderful. And with regards to the energy Efficiency as twenty one energy

[1:48:35] and with regards to the energy Efficiency as twenty one energy

[1:48:35] and with regards to the energy Efficiency as twenty one energy Code is that something that

[1:48:36] efficiency as twenty one energy Code is that something that

[1:48:36] efficiency as twenty one energy Code is that something that You're planning on a meeting in

[1:48:37] code is that something that You're planning on a meeting in

[1:48:37] code is that something that You're planning on a meeting in The building?

[1:48:39] you're planning on a meeting in The building?

[1:48:39] you're planning on a meeting in The building? I don't understand the context

[1:48:42] the building? I don't understand the context

[1:48:42] the building? I don't understand the context The question I'm not the

[1:48:43] I don't understand the context The question I'm not the

[1:48:43] I don't understand the context The question I'm not the Engineering expert in the

[1:48:43] the question I'm not the Engineering expert in the

[1:48:43] the question I'm not the Engineering expert in the Project but yeah so previously

[1:48:46] engineering expert in the Project but yeah so previously

[1:48:47] engineering expert in the Project but yeah so previously There there was a commitment to

[1:48:47] project but yeah so previously There there was a commitment to

[1:48:48] project but yeah so previously There there was a commitment to Meet the 2021 energy

[1:48:51] there there was a commitment to Meet the 2021 energy

[1:48:51] there there was a commitment to Meet the 2021 energy Code in terms of energy

[1:48:51] meet the 2021 energy Code in terms of energy

[1:48:51] meet the 2021 energy Code in terms of energy Efficiency that was yes.

[1:48:54] code in terms of energy Efficiency that was yes.

[1:48:54] code in terms of energy Efficiency that was yes. That's still included.

[1:48:55] efficiency that was yes. That's still included.

[1:48:55] efficiency that was yes. That's still included. Wonderful.

[1:48:55] that's still included. Wonderful.

[1:48:55] that's still included. Wonderful. That's great to hear.

[1:48:58] wonderful. That's great to hear.

[1:48:58] wonderful. That's great to hear. And in terms

[1:48:58] that's great to hear. And in terms

[1:48:59] that's great to hear. And in terms Of electrification, will the

[1:49:02] and in terms Of electrification, will the

[1:49:02] and in terms Of electrification, will the The thousand units be fully

[1:49:03] of electrification, will the The thousand units be fully

[1:49:03] of electrification, will the The thousand units be fully Electric for rental units will

[1:49:05] the thousand units be fully Electric for rental units will

[1:49:06] the thousand units be fully Electric for rental units will Be fully electrified and the

[1:49:06] electric for rental units will Be fully electrified and the

[1:49:06] electric for rental units will Be fully electrified and the Intent is for any for sale

[1:49:09] be fully electrified and the Intent is for any for sale

[1:49:09] be fully electrified and the Intent is for any for sale Units to be at the discretion

[1:49:10] intent is for any for sale Units to be at the discretion

[1:49:10] intent is for any for sale Units to be at the discretion Of the purchaser outstanding.

[1:49:13] units to be at the discretion Of the purchaser outstanding.

[1:49:13] units to be at the discretion Of the purchaser outstanding. And what about providing

[1:49:14] of the purchaser outstanding. And what about providing

[1:49:14] of the purchaser outstanding. And what about providing Easement on geothermal,

[1:49:14] and what about providing Easement on geothermal,

[1:49:14] and what about providing Easement on geothermal, Geothermal that will not be

[1:49:17] easement on geothermal, Geothermal that will not be

[1:49:17] easement on geothermal, Geothermal that will not be Included?

[1:49:18] geothermal that will not be Included?

[1:49:18] geothermal that will not be Included? Ok, although that was agreed

[1:49:20] included? Ok, although that was agreed

[1:49:21] included? Ok, although that was agreed Upon previously ok and with

[1:49:24] ok, although that was agreed Upon previously ok and with

[1:49:24] ok, although that was agreed Upon previously ok and with Water conservation are you is a

[1:49:28] upon previously ok and with Water conservation are you is a

[1:49:28] upon previously ok and with Water conservation are you is a Project still planning on using

[1:49:29] water conservation are you is a Project still planning on using

[1:49:29] water conservation are you is a Project still planning on using It meeting sort of water

[1:49:32] project still planning on using It meeting sort of water

[1:49:32] project still planning on using It meeting sort of water Conservation in terms

[1:49:33] it meeting sort of water Conservation in terms

[1:49:33] it meeting sort of water Conservation in terms Of drought tolerant landscaping

[1:49:35] conservation in terms Of drought tolerant landscaping

[1:49:35] conservation in terms Of drought tolerant landscaping ,epa water sense plumbing

[1:49:36] of drought tolerant landscaping ,epa water sense plumbing

[1:49:36] of drought tolerant landscaping ,epa water sense plumbing Fixtures.

[1:49:36] ,epa water sense plumbing Fixtures.

[1:49:36] ,epa water sense plumbing Fixtures. Yes standing in with regards to

[1:49:39] fixtures. Yes standing in with regards to

[1:49:40] fixtures. Yes standing in with regards to Construction materials are the

[1:49:40] yes standing in with regards to Construction materials are the

[1:49:40] yes standing in with regards to Construction materials are the Primary structural remained you

[1:49:43] construction materials are the Primary structural remained you

[1:49:43] construction materials are the Primary structural remained you Still planning on using wood

[1:49:44] primary structural remained you Still planning on using wood

[1:49:44] primary structural remained you Still planning on using wood For reduced invited carbon ?

[1:49:47] still planning on using wood For reduced invited carbon ?

[1:49:47] still planning on using wood For reduced invited carbon ? >> yes.

[1:49:47] for reduced invited carbon ? >> yes.

[1:49:48] for reduced invited carbon ? >> yes. Great

[1:50:08] thanks for sharing with

[1:50:09] thanks for sharing with

[1:50:09] thanks for sharing with Me and answering these

[1:50:10] thanks for sharing with Me and answering these

[1:50:10] thanks for sharing with Me and answering these Questions.

[1:50:10] me and answering these Questions.

[1:50:10] me and answering these Questions. Sure.

[1:50:10] questions. Sure.

[1:50:10] questions. Sure. And then in terms of your

[1:50:11] sure. And then in terms of your

[1:50:11] sure. And then in terms of your Future phases, is the plan

[1:50:12] and then in terms of your Future phases, is the plan

[1:50:12] and then in terms of your Future phases, is the plan Still continuing to incorporate

[1:50:12] future phases, is the plan Still continuing to incorporate

[1:50:12] future phases, is the plan Still continuing to incorporate Sustainability features into

[1:50:13] still continuing to incorporate Sustainability features into

[1:50:13] still continuing to incorporate Sustainability features into Into future phases?

[1:50:14] sustainability features into Into future phases?

[1:50:14] sustainability features into Into future phases? >> yeah, the core of that plan

[1:50:15] into future phases? >> yeah, the core of that plan

[1:50:15] into future phases? >> yeah, the core of that plan Remains unchanged.

[1:50:15] » yeah, the core of that plan Remains unchanged.

[1:50:16] » yeah, the core of that plan Remains unchanged. >> ok, I'm glad to hear that

[1:50:16] remains unchanged. >> ok, I'm glad to hear that

[1:50:16] remains unchanged. >> ok, I'm glad to hear that These will be forthcoming.

[1:50:17] » ok, I'm glad to hear that These will be forthcoming.

[1:50:17] » ok, I'm glad to hear that These will be forthcoming. I want to know since we don't

[1:50:18] these will be forthcoming. I want to know since we don't

[1:50:18] these will be forthcoming. I want to know since we don't Have these in front of us

[1:50:18] I want to know since we don't Have these in front of us

[1:50:18] I want to know since we don't Have these in front of us Tonight it's it's difficult to

[1:50:19] have these in front of us Tonight it's it's difficult to

[1:50:19] have these in front of us Tonight it's it's difficult to Know whether or not that's

[1:50:20] tonight it's it's difficult to Know whether or not that's

[1:50:20] tonight it's it's difficult to Know whether or not that's Something we can count on.

[1:50:20] know whether or not that's Something we can count on.

[1:50:21] know whether or not that's Something we can count on. But I'm glad to hear your

[1:50:21] something we can count on. But I'm glad to hear your

[1:50:22] something we can count on. But I'm glad to hear your Assurances that those those

[1:50:22] but I'm glad to hear your Assurances that those those

[1:50:22] but I'm glad to hear your Assurances that those those Will be a part of the the

[1:50:23] assurances that those those Will be a part of the the

[1:50:23] assurances that those those Will be a part of the the Future agreement.

[1:50:25] will be a part of the the Future agreement.

[1:50:25] will be a part of the the Future agreement. >> those are all of my

[1:50:26] future agreement. >> those are all of my

[1:50:26] future agreement. >> those are all of my Questions for you right now.

[1:50:27] » those are all of my Questions for you right now.

[1:50:27] » those are all of my Questions for you right now. Thank you.

[1:50:27] questions for you right now. Thank you.

[1:50:27] questions for you right now. Thank you. Thanks.

[1:50:29] thank you. Thanks.

[1:50:29] thank you. Thanks. >> councilor dish, thanks for

[1:50:33] thanks. >> councilor dish, thanks for

[1:50:33] thanks. >> councilor dish, thanks for Asking that series

[1:50:33] » councilor dish, thanks for Asking that series

[1:50:33] » councilor dish, thanks for Asking that series Of questions.

[1:50:33] asking that series Of questions.

[1:50:34] asking that series Of questions. Those were all the things that

[1:50:36] of questions. Those were all the things that

[1:50:37] of questions. Those were all the things that As they were neither they it

[1:50:40] those were all the things that As they were neither they it

[1:50:40] those were all the things that As they were neither they it Might not have been clear that

[1:50:41] as they were neither they it Might not have been clear that

[1:50:41] as they were neither they it Might not have been clear that They were in the side plan and

[1:50:44] might not have been clear that They were in the side plan and

[1:50:44] might not have been clear that They were in the side plan and They were not included in this

[1:50:45] they were in the side plan and They were not included in this

[1:50:45] they were in the side plan and They were not included in this I plan narrative.

[1:50:45] they were not included in this I plan narrative.

[1:50:45] they were not included in this I plan narrative. So there was some question

[1:50:46] I plan narrative. So there was some question

[1:50:46] I plan narrative. So there was some question About whether they would carry

[1:50:48] so there was some question About whether they would carry

[1:50:48] so there was some question About whether they would carry Over.

[1:50:48] about whether they would carry Over.

[1:50:49] about whether they would carry Over. >> so you've gotten yes.

[1:50:49] over. >> so you've gotten yes.

[1:50:49] over. >> so you've gotten yes. Is on all those carryovers we

[1:50:52] » so you've gotten yes. Is on all those carryovers we

[1:50:52] » so you've gotten yes. Is on all those carryovers we Know that the site plan is

[1:50:53] is on all those carryovers we Know that the site plan is

[1:50:53] is on all those carryovers we Know that the site plan is Carrying over.

[1:50:53] know that the site plan is Carrying over.

[1:50:54] know that the site plan is Carrying over. We know that the site plan

[1:50:55] carrying over. We know that the site plan

[1:50:55] carrying over. We know that the site plan Anything identified in the site

[1:50:56] we know that the site plan Anything identified in the site

[1:50:56] we know that the site plan Anything identified in the site Plan narrative is carrying

[1:50:57] anything identified in the site Plan narrative is carrying

[1:50:57] anything identified in the site Plan narrative is carrying Over.

[1:50:57] plan narrative is carrying Over.

[1:50:57] plan narrative is carrying Over. >> we know that the the

[1:51:00] over. >> we know that the the

[1:51:00] over. >> we know that the the Agreement with the and our

[1:51:04] » we know that the the Agreement with the and our

[1:51:04] » we know that the the Agreement with the and our Housing commission was a piece

[1:51:07] agreement with the and our Housing commission was a piece

[1:51:07] agreement with the and our Housing commission was a piece Of the public private

[1:51:08] housing commission was a piece Of the public private

[1:51:08] housing commission was a piece Of the public private Development agreement.

[1:51:11] of the public private Development agreement.

[1:51:11] of the public private Development agreement. It seems as though that based

[1:51:15] development agreement. It seems as though that based

[1:51:15] development agreement. It seems as though that based If I'm understanding correctly

[1:51:16] it seems as though that based If I'm understanding correctly

[1:51:16] it seems as though that based If I'm understanding correctly All of the provisions of that

[1:51:19] if I'm understanding correctly All of the provisions of that

[1:51:19] if I'm understanding correctly All of the provisions of that Agreement are going to carry

[1:51:19] all of the provisions of that Agreement are going to carry

[1:51:20] all of the provisions of that Agreement are going to carry Over it will require a new

[1:51:23] agreement are going to carry Over it will require a new

[1:51:23] agreement are going to carry Over it will require a new Agreement because the ppa is

[1:51:27] over it will require a new Agreement because the ppa is

[1:51:27] over it will require a new Agreement because the ppa is Gone.

[1:51:28] agreement because the ppa is Gone.

[1:51:28] agreement because the ppa is Gone. But all of the provisions in

[1:51:28] gone. But all of the provisions in

[1:51:29] gone. But all of the provisions in That agreement are going to

[1:51:29] but all of the provisions in That agreement are going to

[1:51:29] but all of the provisions in That agreement are going to Carry over.

[1:51:30] that agreement are going to Carry over.

[1:51:31] that agreement are going to Carry over. And in a moment I will ask

[1:51:32] carry over. And in a moment I will ask

[1:51:32] carry over. And in a moment I will ask Jennifer hall to explain where

[1:51:35] and in a moment I will ask Jennifer hall to explain where

[1:51:35] and in a moment I will ask Jennifer hall to explain where She thinks and I just want to

[1:51:39] jennifer hall to explain where She thinks and I just want to

[1:51:39] jennifer hall to explain where She thinks and I just want to Say so.

[1:51:42] she thinks and I just want to Say so.

[1:51:42] she thinks and I just want to Say so. So the major change the

[1:51:46] say so. So the major change the

[1:51:46] say so. So the major change the Substantive change that we have

[1:51:47] so the major change the Substantive change that we have

[1:51:47] so the major change the Substantive change that we have Before us is simply that there

[1:51:51] substantive change that we have Before us is simply that there

[1:51:51] substantive change that we have Before us is simply that there Is no ppa.

[1:51:51] before us is simply that there Is no ppa.

[1:51:51] before us is simply that there Is no ppa. >> there is no implication

[1:51:54] is no ppa. >> there is no implication

[1:51:54] is no ppa. >> there is no implication Of city.

[1:51:55] » there is no implication Of city.

[1:51:55] » there is no implication Of city. >> the city will no longer be

[1:51:58] of city. >> the city will no longer be

[1:51:58] of city. >> the city will no longer be Purchasing the parking tickets

[1:51:59] » the city will no longer be Purchasing the parking tickets

[1:51:59] » the city will no longer be Purchasing the parking tickets So that's so the risks

[1:52:03] purchasing the parking tickets So that's so the risks

[1:52:03] purchasing the parking tickets So that's so the risks Associated with that the

[1:52:05] so that's so the risks Associated with that the

[1:52:05] so that's so the risks Associated with that the Financial participation in that

[1:52:06] associated with that the Financial participation in that

[1:52:06] associated with that the Financial participation in that Way is out.

[1:52:13] financial participation in that Way is out.

[1:52:13] financial participation in that Way is out. That's what we that's the major

[1:52:13] way is out. That's what we that's the major

[1:52:14] way is out. That's what we that's the major Substantive change is how do

[1:52:16] that's what we that's the major Substantive change is how do

[1:52:17] that's what we that's the major Substantive change is how do You mind your understanding and

[1:52:17] substantive change is how do You mind your understanding and

[1:52:17] substantive change is how do You mind your understanding and Then I know I'm done for this

[1:52:18] you mind your understanding and Then I know I'm done for this

[1:52:19] you mind your understanding and Then I know I'm done for this Round the housing commission

[1:52:26] then I know I'm done for this Round the housing commission

[1:52:26] then I know I'm done for this Round the housing commission Has a development agreement

[1:52:27] round the housing commission Has a development agreement

[1:52:27] round the housing commission Has a development agreement Between us and the development

[1:52:30] has a development agreement Between us and the development

[1:52:30] has a development agreement Between us and the development Team and we've recently

[1:52:31] between us and the development Team and we've recently

[1:52:31] between us and the development Team and we've recently Finalized back and forth

[1:52:35] team and we've recently Finalized back and forth

[1:52:35] team and we've recently Finalized back and forth Between our attorney, their

[1:52:36] finalized back and forth Between our attorney, their

[1:52:36] finalized back and forth Between our attorney, their Attorney, our staff, their

[1:52:36] between our attorney, their Attorney, our staff, their

[1:52:36] between our attorney, their Attorney, our staff, their Staff.

[1:52:39] attorney, our staff, their Staff.

[1:52:39] attorney, our staff, their Staff. Our board has to approve it

[1:52:40] staff. Our board has to approve it

[1:52:40] staff. Our board has to approve it Still we don't have a meeting

[1:52:40] our board has to approve it Still we don't have a meeting

[1:52:40] our board has to approve it Still we don't have a meeting Till tomorrow night which I

[1:52:43] still we don't have a meeting Till tomorrow night which I

[1:52:43] still we don't have a meeting Till tomorrow night which I Don't know if we have a quorum

[1:52:44] till tomorrow night which I Don't know if we have a quorum

[1:52:44] till tomorrow night which I Don't know if we have a quorum So I can't say it's approved.

[1:52:47] don't know if we have a quorum So I can't say it's approved.

[1:52:47] don't know if we have a quorum So I can't say it's approved. But from your staff and

[1:52:48] so I can't say it's approved. But from your staff and

[1:52:48] so I can't say it's approved. But from your staff and Attorney level that has all

[1:52:50] but from your staff and Attorney level that has all

[1:52:50] but from your staff and Attorney level that has all Been negotiated I can't think

[1:52:53] attorney level that has all Been negotiated I can't think

[1:52:54] attorney level that has all Been negotiated I can't think Of anything that has changed

[1:52:54] been negotiated I can't think Of anything that has changed

[1:52:54] been negotiated I can't think Of anything that has changed From the commitments that were

[1:52:58] of anything that has changed From the commitments that were

[1:52:58] of anything that has changed From the commitments that were Made in the council memo.

[1:53:02] from the commitments that were Made in the council memo.

[1:53:02] from the commitments that were Made in the council memo. The number of units parking

[1:53:03] made in the council memo. The number of units parking

[1:53:03] made in the council memo. The number of units parking Parking passes, geothermal

[1:53:06] the number of units parking Parking passes, geothermal

[1:53:06] the number of units parking Parking passes, geothermal Electric building I know I'm

[1:53:09] parking passes, geothermal Electric building I know I'm

[1:53:09] parking passes, geothermal Electric building I know I'm Missing some things but I can't

[1:53:10] electric building I know I'm Missing some things but I can't

[1:53:10] electric building I know I'm Missing some things but I can't Think of anything that has

[1:53:13] missing some things but I can't Think of anything that has

[1:53:13] missing some things but I can't Think of anything that has Changed related to that except

[1:53:14] think of anything that has Changed related to that except

[1:53:14] think of anything that has Changed related to that except For in the ppa with the city

[1:53:21] changed related to that except For in the ppa with the city

[1:53:21] changed related to that except For in the ppa with the city There were some there were some

[1:53:21] for in the ppa with the city There were some there were some

[1:53:22] for in the ppa with the city There were some there were some Language in there that needed

[1:53:25] there were some there were some Language in there that needed

[1:53:25] there were some there were some Language in there that needed To be decided.

[1:53:25] language in there that needed To be decided.

[1:53:25] language in there that needed To be decided. What document the city would

[1:53:29] to be decided. What document the city would

[1:53:29] to be decided. What document the city would Have to include that language

[1:53:30] what document the city would Have to include that language

[1:53:30] what document the city would Have to include that language In because it's more of a

[1:53:33] have to include that language In because it's more of a

[1:53:33] have to include that language In because it's more of a Enforcement arm of the city,

[1:53:33] in because it's more of a Enforcement arm of the city,

[1:53:34] in because it's more of a Enforcement arm of the city, Not something that the housing

[1:53:37] enforcement arm of the city, Not something that the housing

[1:53:37] enforcement arm of the city, Not something that the housing Commission enforces and I don't

[1:53:37] not something that the housing Commission enforces and I don't

[1:53:38] not something that the housing Commission enforces and I don't Know where that is going to

[1:53:38] commission enforces and I don't Know where that is going to

[1:53:38] commission enforces and I don't Know where that is going to Land.

[1:53:40] know where that is going to Land.

[1:53:40] know where that is going to Land. Probably the development

[1:53:41] land. Probably the development

[1:53:41] land. Probably the development Agreement.

[1:53:43] probably the development Agreement.

[1:53:43] probably the development Agreement. >> thank you, councilor.

[1:53:50] agreement. >> thank you, councilor.

[1:53:50] agreement. >> thank you, councilor. Well, so I guess we're still on

[1:53:54] » thank you, councilor. Well, so I guess we're still on

[1:53:54] » thank you, councilor. Well, so I guess we're still on The bus on the postponement and

[1:53:57] well, so I guess we're still on The bus on the postponement and

[1:53:57] well, so I guess we're still on The bus on the postponement and It does it seems like to me it

[1:54:01] the bus on the postponement and It does it seems like to me it

[1:54:01] the bus on the postponement and It does it seems like to me it Seems like we're kind of back

[1:54:02] it does it seems like to me it Seems like we're kind of back

[1:54:02] it does it seems like to me it Seems like we're kind of back In the discussion of it.

[1:54:05] seems like we're kind of back In the discussion of it.

[1:54:05] seems like we're kind of back In the discussion of it. >> if I had you know I guess it

[1:54:06] in the discussion of it. >> if I had you know I guess it

[1:54:06] in the discussion of it. >> if I had you know I guess it Was in my I guess preference to

[1:54:12] » if I had you know I guess it Was in my I guess preference to

[1:54:12] » if I had you know I guess it Was in my I guess preference to Have a little bit of a

[1:54:13] was in my I guess preference to Have a little bit of a

[1:54:13] was in my I guess preference to Have a little bit of a Discussion to hear from staff

[1:54:14] have a little bit of a Discussion to hear from staff

[1:54:14] have a little bit of a Discussion to hear from staff And then at that point if there

[1:54:16] discussion to hear from staff And then at that point if there

[1:54:17] discussion to hear from staff And then at that point if there Was still outstanding issues to

[1:54:17] and then at that point if there Was still outstanding issues to

[1:54:17] and then at that point if there Was still outstanding issues to Go to, then consider the

[1:54:20] was still outstanding issues to Go to, then consider the

[1:54:21] was still outstanding issues to Go to, then consider the Postponement.

[1:54:21] go to, then consider the Postponement.

[1:54:21] go to, then consider the Postponement. >> but I guess as we're

[1:54:22] postponement. >> but I guess as we're

[1:54:22] postponement. >> but I guess as we're Considering the postponement

[1:54:22] » but I guess as we're Considering the postponement

[1:54:22] » but I guess as we're Considering the postponement Now I'm in favor of it.

[1:54:27] considering the postponement Now I'm in favor of it.

[1:54:27] considering the postponement Now I'm in favor of it. >> but but I do wish we had had

[1:54:28] now I'm in favor of it. >> but but I do wish we had had

[1:54:28] now I'm in favor of it. >> but but I do wish we had had Maybe a chance to discuss the

[1:54:31] » but but I do wish we had had Maybe a chance to discuss the

[1:54:31] » but but I do wish we had had Maybe a chance to discuss the Main motion first before the

[1:54:32] maybe a chance to discuss the Main motion first before the

[1:54:32] maybe a chance to discuss the Main motion first before the Post on councilor.

[1:54:37] main motion first before the Post on councilor.

[1:54:38] main motion first before the Post on councilor. >> yeah, I don't think I'll be

[1:54:41] post on councilor. >> yeah, I don't think I'll be

[1:54:41] post on councilor. >> yeah, I don't think I'll be Supporting postponement myself.

[1:54:42] » yeah, I don't think I'll be Supporting postponement myself.

[1:54:42] » yeah, I don't think I'll be Supporting postponement myself. >> I mean I think, um for my

[1:54:45] supporting postponement myself. >> I mean I think, um for my

[1:54:45] supporting postponement myself. >> I mean I think, um for my Part I asked my questions, you

[1:54:50] » I mean I think, um for my Part I asked my questions, you

[1:54:50] » I mean I think, um for my Part I asked my questions, you Know, ahead of time I know this

[1:54:50] part I asked my questions, you Know, ahead of time I know this

[1:54:51] part I asked my questions, you Know, ahead of time I know this Came on a little later but I'm

[1:54:53] know, ahead of time I know this Came on a little later but I'm

[1:54:53] know, ahead of time I know this Came on a little later but I'm Prepared to vote on it tonight.

[1:54:56] came on a little later but I'm Prepared to vote on it tonight.

[1:54:56] came on a little later but I'm Prepared to vote on it tonight. I think as council member

[1:54:57] prepared to vote on it tonight. I think as council member

[1:54:57] prepared to vote on it tonight. I think as council member Watson said, we can have a

[1:54:58] I think as council member Watson said, we can have a

[1:54:58] I think as council member Watson said, we can have a Discussion and we can get

[1:55:01] watson said, we can have a Discussion and we can get

[1:55:01] watson said, we can have a Discussion and we can get Questions answered if need be

[1:55:04] discussion and we can get Questions answered if need be

[1:55:04] discussion and we can get Questions answered if need be And if folks are comfortable

[1:55:07] questions answered if need be And if folks are comfortable

[1:55:07] questions answered if need be And if folks are comfortable Voting, they're comfortable

[1:55:08] and if folks are comfortable Voting, they're comfortable

[1:55:08] and if folks are comfortable Voting, they're comfortable Voting and if they're not, then

[1:55:09] voting, they're comfortable Voting and if they're not, then

[1:55:09] voting, they're comfortable Voting and if they're not, then I guess the vote is no thanks.

[1:55:12] voting and if they're not, then I guess the vote is no thanks.

[1:55:12] voting and if they're not, then I guess the vote is no thanks. >> councilor denha.

[1:55:15] I guess the vote is no thanks. >> councilor denha.

[1:55:15] I guess the vote is no thanks. >> councilor denha. Yeah, very briefly, I'm going

[1:55:16] » councilor denha. Yeah, very briefly, I'm going

[1:55:16] » councilor denha. Yeah, very briefly, I'm going To say I think based on the

[1:55:19] yeah, very briefly, I'm going To say I think based on the

[1:55:19] yeah, very briefly, I'm going To say I think based on the Questions that I had and have

[1:55:20] to say I think based on the Questions that I had and have

[1:55:20] to say I think based on the Questions that I had and have Been answered, even additional

[1:55:24] questions that I had and have Been answered, even additional

[1:55:24] questions that I had and have Been answered, even additional Questions that were just asked

[1:55:24] been answered, even additional Questions that were just asked

[1:55:24] been answered, even additional Questions that were just asked And answered, I would be

[1:55:27] questions that were just asked And answered, I would be

[1:55:27] questions that were just asked And answered, I would be Comfortable voting on this

[1:55:28] and answered, I would be Comfortable voting on this

[1:55:28] and answered, I would be Comfortable voting on this Tonight but I will support

[1:55:30] comfortable voting on this Tonight but I will support

[1:55:30] comfortable voting on this Tonight but I will support Postponement out of deference

[1:55:31] tonight but I will support Postponement out of deference

[1:55:31] tonight but I will support Postponement out of deference To my colleagues who feel that

[1:55:34] postponement out of deference To my colleagues who feel that

[1:55:35] postponement out of deference To my colleagues who feel that They need more time to

[1:55:35] to my colleagues who feel that They need more time to

[1:55:35] to my colleagues who feel that They need more time to Understand this.

[1:55:36] they need more time to Understand this.

[1:55:36] they need more time to Understand this. So that's just where I'm going

[1:55:37] understand this. So that's just where I'm going

[1:55:37] understand this. So that's just where I'm going To land on this.

[1:55:40] so that's just where I'm going To land on this.

[1:55:41] so that's just where I'm going To land on this. >> councilor eckmann sorry.

[1:55:48] to land on this. >> councilor eckmann sorry.

[1:55:48] to land on this. >> councilor eckmann sorry. I understand that the main

[1:55:49] » councilor eckmann sorry. I understand that the main

[1:55:49] » councilor eckmann sorry. I understand that the main Primary difference between the

[1:55:52] I understand that the main Primary difference between the

[1:55:52] I understand that the main Primary difference between the Ppa that we were considering

[1:55:53] primary difference between the Ppa that we were considering

[1:55:53] primary difference between the Ppa that we were considering Before and what's on the table

[1:55:54] ppa that we were considering Before and what's on the table

[1:55:54] ppa that we were considering Before and what's on the table Now is the city, you know,

[1:55:57] before and what's on the table Now is the city, you know,

[1:55:57] before and what's on the table Now is the city, you know, Financing the parking garages

[1:55:58] now is the city, you know, Financing the parking garages

[1:55:58] now is the city, you know, Financing the parking garages Which it would ultimately own.

[1:56:01] financing the parking garages Which it would ultimately own.

[1:56:01] financing the parking garages Which it would ultimately own. And to be honest, I appreciate

[1:56:02] which it would ultimately own. And to be honest, I appreciate

[1:56:02] which it would ultimately own. And to be honest, I appreciate That that's not part of this

[1:56:02] and to be honest, I appreciate That that's not part of this

[1:56:02] and to be honest, I appreciate That that's not part of this Discussion anymore.

[1:56:04] that that's not part of this Discussion anymore.

[1:56:04] that that's not part of this Discussion anymore. >> be that as it may, what

[1:56:05] discussion anymore. >> be that as it may, what

[1:56:06] discussion anymore. >> be that as it may, what We're being asked to do is to

[1:56:07] » be that as it may, what We're being asked to do is to

[1:56:07] » be that as it may, what We're being asked to do is to Basically overlook one of the

[1:56:08] we're being asked to do is to Basically overlook one of the

[1:56:08] we're being asked to do is to Basically overlook one of the Major criteria is that we have

[1:56:12] basically overlook one of the Major criteria is that we have

[1:56:12] basically overlook one of the Major criteria is that we have An brownfield's review policy

[1:56:15] major criteria is that we have An brownfield's review policy

[1:56:15] major criteria is that we have An brownfield's review policy Which is this twenty percent

[1:56:16] an brownfield's review policy Which is this twenty percent

[1:56:16] an brownfield's review policy Which is this twenty percent Of overall project investment

[1:56:17] which is this twenty percent Of overall project investment

[1:56:17] which is this twenty percent Of overall project investment And the staff report you know,

[1:56:20] of overall project investment And the staff report you know,

[1:56:20] of overall project investment And the staff report you know, I feel like we're not we and

[1:56:23] and the staff report you know, I feel like we're not we and

[1:56:23] and the staff report you know, I feel like we're not we and The public are not given enough

[1:56:24] I feel like we're not we and The public are not given enough

[1:56:24] I feel like we're not we and The public are not given enough Information.

[1:56:25] the public are not given enough Information.

[1:56:25] the public are not given enough Information. What it says is that the

[1:56:27] information. What it says is that the

[1:56:27] information. What it says is that the Standard is intended to ensure

[1:56:27] what it says is that the Standard is intended to ensure

[1:56:28] what it says is that the Standard is intended to ensure A reasonable balance between

[1:56:31] standard is intended to ensure A reasonable balance between

[1:56:31] standard is intended to ensure A reasonable balance between Private investment and public

[1:56:31] a reasonable balance between Private investment and public

[1:56:32] a reasonable balance between Private investment and public Contribution and has been an

[1:56:32] private investment and public Contribution and has been an

[1:56:32] private investment and public Contribution and has been an Effective benchmark for prior

[1:56:35] contribution and has been an Effective benchmark for prior

[1:56:35] contribution and has been an Effective benchmark for prior Brownfield projects.

[1:56:35] effective benchmark for prior Brownfield projects.

[1:56:35] effective benchmark for prior Brownfield projects. This project, however, has been

[1:56:39] brownfield projects. This project, however, has been

[1:56:39] brownfield projects. This project, however, has been Contemplated as a public

[1:56:39] this project, however, has been Contemplated as a public

[1:56:39] this project, however, has been Contemplated as a public Private partnership involving

[1:56:40] contemplated as a public Private partnership involving

[1:56:40] contemplated as a public Private partnership involving Substantial city investment.

[1:56:43] private partnership involving Substantial city investment.

[1:56:43] private partnership involving Substantial city investment. Although the ultimate extent

[1:56:43] substantial city investment. Although the ultimate extent

[1:56:44] substantial city investment. Although the ultimate extent Of city participation has not

[1:56:44] although the ultimate extent Of city participation has not

[1:56:44] although the ultimate extent Of city participation has not Yet been determined.

[1:56:47] of city participation has not Yet been determined.

[1:56:47] of city participation has not Yet been determined. >> what know

[1:56:53] councilor radish

[1:56:54] councilor radish

[1:56:54] councilor radish May I please ask mr giant to

[1:56:58] councilor radish May I please ask mr giant to

[1:56:58] councilor radish May I please ask mr giant to Help clarify on the questions

[1:56:59] may I please ask mr giant to Help clarify on the questions

[1:56:59] may I please ask mr giant to Help clarify on the questions That are being raised about

[1:57:02] help clarify on the questions That are being raised about

[1:57:02] help clarify on the questions That are being raised about Potential guidelines being

[1:57:06] that are being raised about Potential guidelines being

[1:57:06] that are being raised about Potential guidelines being Observed or not observed and

[1:57:06] potential guidelines being Observed or not observed and

[1:57:07] potential guidelines being Observed or not observed and Clarify the sentence that was

[1:57:07] observed or not observed and Clarify the sentence that was

[1:57:07] observed or not observed and Clarify the sentence that was Just read during the twenty

[1:57:10] clarify the sentence that was Just read during the twenty

[1:57:10] clarify the sentence that was Just read during the twenty Percent threshold there were

[1:57:14] just read during the twenty Percent threshold there were

[1:57:14] just read during the twenty Percent threshold there were Actually two there's the twenty

[1:57:15] percent threshold there were Actually two there's the twenty

[1:57:15] percent threshold there were Actually two there's the twenty Percent threshold just

[1:57:18] actually two there's the twenty Percent threshold just

[1:57:18] actually two there's the twenty Percent threshold just Mentioned there was something

[1:57:19] percent threshold just Mentioned there was something

[1:57:19] percent threshold just Mentioned there was something About reimbursing interest that

[1:57:22] mentioned there was something About reimbursing interest that

[1:57:22] mentioned there was something About reimbursing interest that Was raised earlier.

[1:57:22] about reimbursing interest that Was raised earlier.

[1:57:23] about reimbursing interest that Was raised earlier. I didn't understand the

[1:57:25] was raised earlier. I didn't understand the

[1:57:25] was raised earlier. I didn't understand the Objection so ordered and then

[1:57:26] I didn't understand the Objection so ordered and then

[1:57:26] I didn't understand the Objection so ordered and then There's a just a question about

[1:57:26] objection so ordered and then There's a just a question about

[1:57:27] objection so ordered and then There's a just a question about What that sentence in the

[1:57:29] there's a just a question about What that sentence in the

[1:57:30] there's a just a question about What that sentence in the Report meant that was just read

[1:57:30] what that sentence in the Report meant that was just read

[1:57:30] what that sentence in the Report meant that was just read Ok so the first criteria is

[1:57:33] report meant that was just read Ok so the first criteria is

[1:57:33] report meant that was just read Ok so the first criteria is That the amount of tife that

[1:57:34] ok so the first criteria is That the amount of tife that

[1:57:34] ok so the first criteria is That the amount of tife that Goes into the project of the

[1:57:37] that the amount of tife that Goes into the project of the

[1:57:37] that the amount of tife that Goes into the project of the Support of the project

[1:57:37] goes into the project of the Support of the project

[1:57:38] goes into the project of the Support of the project Shouldn't exceed twenty percent

[1:57:38] support of the project Shouldn't exceed twenty percent

[1:57:38] support of the project Shouldn't exceed twenty percent Of the overall project.

[1:57:39] shouldn't exceed twenty percent Of the overall project.

[1:57:39] shouldn't exceed twenty percent Of the overall project. >> um yeah.

[1:57:41] of the overall project. >> um yeah.

[1:57:41] of the overall project. >> um yeah. And the first staff report it

[1:57:42] » um yeah. And the first staff report it

[1:57:42] » um yeah. And the first staff report it Says unique public private

[1:57:44] and the first staff report it Says unique public private

[1:57:45] and the first staff report it Says unique public private Partnership city's

[1:57:45] says unique public private Partnership city's

[1:57:45] says unique public private Partnership city's Participation is unique.

[1:57:48] partnership city's Participation is unique.

[1:57:48] partnership city's Participation is unique. The project is unique.

[1:57:49] participation is unique. The project is unique.

[1:57:49] participation is unique. The project is unique. I would definitely stand by

[1:57:49] the project is unique. I would definitely stand by

[1:57:50] the project is unique. I would definitely stand by That.

[1:57:50] I would definitely stand by That.

[1:57:50] I would definitely stand by That. It certainly is that part that

[1:57:55] that. It certainly is that part that

[1:57:55] that. It certainly is that part that Policy was written in twenty

[1:57:56] it certainly is that part that Policy was written in twenty

[1:57:56] it certainly is that part that Policy was written in twenty Nineteen when interest rates

[1:57:56] policy was written in twenty Nineteen when interest rates

[1:57:57] policy was written in twenty Nineteen when interest rates Were zero different building

[1:57:59] nineteen when interest rates Were zero different building

[1:57:59] nineteen when interest rates Were zero different building Climate, different housing

[1:58:03] were zero different building Climate, different housing

[1:58:03] were zero different building Climate, different housing Market, different council,

[1:58:04] climate, different housing Market, different council,

[1:58:04] climate, different housing Market, different council, Different demand, different

[1:58:07] market, different council, Different demand, different

[1:58:07] market, different council, Different demand, different Cost structure materials.

[1:58:11] different demand, different Cost structure materials.

[1:58:11] different demand, different Cost structure materials. We're getting a certain type

[1:58:12] cost structure materials. We're getting a certain type

[1:58:12] cost structure materials. We're getting a certain type Of project here.

[1:58:15] we're getting a certain type Of project here.

[1:58:15] we're getting a certain type Of project here. It's something that I think

[1:58:16] of project here. It's something that I think

[1:58:16] of project here. It's something that I think I've articulated to all of you.

[1:58:19] it's something that I think I've articulated to all of you.

[1:58:20] it's something that I think I've articulated to all of you. Is that like revising that

[1:58:20] I've articulated to all of you. Is that like revising that

[1:58:20] I've articulated to all of you. Is that like revising that Policy something that is

[1:58:21] is that like revising that Policy something that is

[1:58:21] is that like revising that Policy something that is Definitely on our work plan for

[1:58:23] policy something that is Definitely on our work plan for

[1:58:23] policy something that is Definitely on our work plan for This year because we realized

[1:58:23] definitely on our work plan for This year because we realized

[1:58:23] definitely on our work plan for This year because we realized That when you have kind of a

[1:58:24] this year because we realized That when you have kind of a

[1:58:24] this year because we realized That when you have kind of a Static policy in a dynamic

[1:58:27] that when you have kind of a Static policy in a dynamic

[1:58:27] that when you have kind of a Static policy in a dynamic Environment it's not

[1:58:27] static policy in a dynamic Environment it's not

[1:58:27] static policy in a dynamic Environment it's not Necessarily a great fit.

[1:58:30] environment it's not Necessarily a great fit.

[1:58:30] environment it's not Necessarily a great fit. >> I don't want to say that

[1:58:31] necessarily a great fit. >> I don't want to say that

[1:58:31] necessarily a great fit. >> I don't want to say that This you that it meets the

[1:58:34] » I don't want to say that This you that it meets the

[1:58:35] » I don't want to say that This you that it meets the Criteria.

[1:58:35] this you that it meets the Criteria.

[1:58:35] this you that it meets the Criteria. I don't wanna contort myself

[1:58:36] criteria. I don't wanna contort myself

[1:58:36] criteria. I don't wanna contort myself Into saying that it doesn't but

[1:58:38] I don't wanna contort myself Into saying that it doesn't but

[1:58:38] I don't wanna contort myself Into saying that it doesn't but It is a unique project.

[1:58:39] into saying that it doesn't but It is a unique project.

[1:58:39] into saying that it doesn't but It is a unique project. It's 17 acres of what is now

[1:58:40] it is a unique project. It's 17 acres of what is now

[1:58:40] it is a unique project. It's 17 acres of what is now Pavement converting it into

[1:58:42] it's 17 acres of what is now Pavement converting it into

[1:58:42] it's 17 acres of what is now Pavement converting it into Essentially all of the

[1:58:42] pavement converting it into Essentially all of the

[1:58:42] pavement converting it into Essentially all of the Infrastructure parking included

[1:58:43] essentially all of the Infrastructure parking included

[1:58:43] essentially all of the Infrastructure parking included That being about six blocks

[1:58:46] infrastructure parking included That being about six blocks

[1:58:46] infrastructure parking included That being about six blocks Of a downtown.

[1:58:46] that being about six blocks Of a downtown.

[1:58:46] that being about six blocks Of a downtown. So it's not like apples and

[1:58:50] of a downtown. So it's not like apples and

[1:58:50] of a downtown. So it's not like apples and Oranges.

[1:58:50] so it's not like apples and Oranges.

[1:58:50] so it's not like apples and Oranges. It's like apples and lasana

[1:58:51] oranges. It's like apples and lasana

[1:58:51] oranges. It's like apples and lasana Just it's just not a not not

[1:58:54] it's like apples and lasana Just it's just not a not not

[1:58:54] it's like apples and lasana Just it's just not a not not Not not a good fit.

[1:58:54] just it's just not a not not Not not a good fit.

[1:58:55] just it's just not a not not Not not a good fit. So I'm revising our policy to

[1:58:58] not not a good fit. So I'm revising our policy to

[1:58:58] not not a good fit. So I'm revising our policy to Be a little more dynamic in

[1:58:58] so I'm revising our policy to Be a little more dynamic in

[1:58:58] so I'm revising our policy to Be a little more dynamic in Terms of what kind of project

[1:59:01] be a little more dynamic in Terms of what kind of project

[1:59:01] be a little more dynamic in Terms of what kind of project We're seeing in preserving the

[1:59:02] terms of what kind of project We're seeing in preserving the

[1:59:02] terms of what kind of project We're seeing in preserving the Same benefits.

[1:59:02] we're seeing in preserving the Same benefits.

[1:59:02] we're seeing in preserving the Same benefits. Make sure rossler as possible

[1:59:04] same benefits. Make sure rossler as possible

[1:59:04] same benefits. Make sure rossler as possible Being a little bit more attuned

[1:59:05] make sure rossler as possible Being a little bit more attuned

[1:59:05] make sure rossler as possible Being a little bit more attuned To like what a dynamic changing

[1:59:06] being a little bit more attuned To like what a dynamic changing

[1:59:06] being a little bit more attuned To like what a dynamic changing Environment looks like is

[1:59:08] to like what a dynamic changing Environment looks like is

[1:59:08] to like what a dynamic changing Environment looks like is Something that we want to do

[1:59:09] environment looks like is Something that we want to do

[1:59:09] environment looks like is Something that we want to do The interest so in the policy

[1:59:13] something that we want to do The interest so in the policy

[1:59:13] something that we want to do The interest so in the policy It says we're not to collect

[1:59:16] the interest so in the policy It says we're not to collect

[1:59:16] the interest so in the policy It says we're not to collect Interest even though it is a

[1:59:17] it says we're not to collect Interest even though it is a

[1:59:17] it says we're not to collect Interest even though it is a Negligible cost.

[1:59:17] interest even though it is a Negligible cost.

[1:59:18] interest even though it is a Negligible cost. Yeah, correct.

[1:59:20] negligible cost. Yeah, correct.

[1:59:20] negligible cost. Yeah, correct. I would say that the one thing

[1:59:21] yeah, correct. I would say that the one thing

[1:59:22] yeah, correct. I would say that the one thing That having not having a ppa

[1:59:25] I would say that the one thing That having not having a ppa

[1:59:25] I would say that the one thing That having not having a ppa Does to the project is that

[1:59:25] that having not having a ppa Does to the project is that

[1:59:26] that having not having a ppa Does to the project is that Makes the project a lot more

[1:59:26] does to the project is that Makes the project a lot more

[1:59:26] does to the project is that Makes the project a lot more Expensive.

[1:59:27] makes the project a lot more Expensive.

[1:59:28] makes the project a lot more Expensive. The ppa the way that we would

[1:59:29] expensive. The ppa the way that we would

[1:59:29] expensive. The ppa the way that we would Have bonded for the project

[1:59:32] the ppa the way that we would Have bonded for the project

[1:59:32] the ppa the way that we would Have bonded for the project Municipal bonding, our

[1:59:33] have bonded for the project Municipal bonding, our

[1:59:33] have bonded for the project Municipal bonding, our Excellent bond rating was we

[1:59:36] municipal bonding, our Excellent bond rating was we

[1:59:36] municipal bonding, our Excellent bond rating was we Did that for a reason interest

[1:59:37] excellent bond rating was we Did that for a reason interest

[1:59:37] excellent bond rating was we Did that for a reason interest Rates for the city were quite

[1:59:40] did that for a reason interest Rates for the city were quite

[1:59:40] did that for a reason interest Rates for the city were quite Low.

[1:59:40] rates for the city were quite Low.

[1:59:40] rates for the city were quite Low. So if we don't do that it makes

[1:59:44] low. So if we don't do that it makes

[1:59:44] low. So if we don't do that it makes The project more expensive.

[1:59:45] so if we don't do that it makes The project more expensive.

[1:59:45] so if we don't do that it makes The project more expensive. And so when we say ok, these

[1:59:48] the project more expensive. And so when we say ok, these

[1:59:48] the project more expensive. And so when we say ok, these Are eligible costs and the

[1:59:48] and so when we say ok, these Are eligible costs and the

[1:59:48] and so when we say ok, these Are eligible costs and the Brownfield plan we know we need

[1:59:49] are eligible costs and the Brownfield plan we know we need

[1:59:49] are eligible costs and the Brownfield plan we know we need This brownfield plan to address

[1:59:51] brownfield plan we know we need This brownfield plan to address

[1:59:51] brownfield plan we know we need This brownfield plan to address The gap in the project but we

[1:59:52] this brownfield plan to address The gap in the project but we

[1:59:52] this brownfield plan to address The gap in the project but we Say yes, but we're going to

[1:59:55] the gap in the project but we Say yes, but we're going to

[1:59:55] the gap in the project but we Say yes, but we're going to Remove one of the big eligible

[1:59:56] say yes, but we're going to Remove one of the big eligible

[1:59:56] say yes, but we're going to Remove one of the big eligible Items that can help pay for the

[1:59:57] remove one of the big eligible Items that can help pay for the

[1:59:57] remove one of the big eligible Items that can help pay for the Project like that's saying it's

[1:59:59] items that can help pay for the Project like that's saying it's

[1:59:59] items that can help pay for the Project like that's saying it's Just going to make the project

[1:59:59] project like that's saying it's Just going to make the project

[2:00:00] project like that's saying it's Just going to make the project Harder to do I mean it's a

[2:00:04] just going to make the project Harder to do I mean it's a

[2:00:04] just going to make the project Harder to do I mean it's a Policy decision is this kind

[2:00:05] harder to do I mean it's a Policy decision is this kind

[2:00:05] harder to do I mean it's a Policy decision is this kind Of project we would like to see

[2:00:06] policy decision is this kind Of project we would like to see

[2:00:06] policy decision is this kind Of project we would like to see A think that it checks a lot

[2:00:08] of project we would like to see A think that it checks a lot

[2:00:09] of project we would like to see A think that it checks a lot Of boxes and obviously that

[2:00:29] is

[2:00:29] is Perfect but it's something that

[2:00:30] is Perfect but it's something that

[2:00:30] is Perfect but it's something that Like if we want this project to

[2:00:30] perfect but it's something that Like if we want this project to

[2:00:31] perfect but it's something that Like if we want this project to Pencil out capturing interest

[2:00:31] like if we want this project to Pencil out capturing interest

[2:00:31] like if we want this project to Pencil out capturing interest Is something that is required

[2:00:32] pencil out capturing interest Is something that is required

[2:00:32] pencil out capturing interest Is something that is required For it to do that.

[2:00:32] is something that is required For it to do that.

[2:00:33] is something that is required For it to do that. Councilor, just one point

[2:00:33] for it to do that. Councilor, just one point

[2:00:33] for it to do that. Councilor, just one point Of clarification.

[2:00:34] councilor, just one point Of clarification.

[2:00:34] councilor, just one point Of clarification. So you were talking about the

[2:00:34] of clarification. So you were talking about the

[2:00:35] of clarification. So you were talking about the City's policy was written in

[2:00:35] so you were talking about the City's policy was written in

[2:00:35] so you were talking about the City's policy was written in Twenty nineteen and their state

[2:00:36] city's policy was written in Twenty nineteen and their state

[2:00:36] city's policy was written in Twenty nineteen and their state Guidelines where interest is

[2:00:37] twenty nineteen and their state Guidelines where interest is

[2:00:37] twenty nineteen and their state Guidelines where interest is Reimbursable under state

[2:00:37] guidelines where interest is Reimbursable under state

[2:00:37] guidelines where interest is Reimbursable under state Guidelines for the city's

[2:00:38] reimbursable under state Guidelines for the city's

[2:00:38] reimbursable under state Guidelines for the city's Policy was written to be more

[2:00:39] guidelines for the city's Policy was written to be more

[2:00:39] guidelines for the city's Policy was written to be more Strict than that.

[2:00:39] policy was written to be more Strict than that.

[2:00:39] policy was written to be more Strict than that. Also the city's policy was

[2:00:40] strict than that. Also the city's policy was

[2:00:40] strict than that. Also the city's policy was Written to have some strict,

[2:00:42] also the city's policy was Written to have some strict,

[2:00:42] also the city's policy was Written to have some strict, You know, sort of static

[2:00:43] written to have some strict, You know, sort of static

[2:00:43] written to have some strict, You know, sort of static Guidelines around ratios

[2:00:45] you know, sort of static Guidelines around ratios

[2:00:46] you know, sort of static Guidelines around ratios Of investment which so we are

[2:00:46] guidelines around ratios Of investment which so we are

[2:00:46] guidelines around ratios Of investment which so we are Not talking about violating the

[2:00:47] of investment which so we are Not talking about violating the

[2:00:47] of investment which so we are Not talking about violating the State's brownfield law.

[2:00:50] not talking about violating the State's brownfield law.

[2:00:50] not talking about violating the State's brownfield law. We're talking about well how

[2:00:51] state's brownfield law. We're talking about well how

[2:00:51] state's brownfield law. We're talking about well how Would you put it?

[2:00:52] we're talking about well how Would you put it?

[2:00:52] we're talking about well how Would you put it? >> well, I think it's really

[2:00:56] would you put it? >> well, I think it's really

[2:00:56] would you put it? >> well, I think it's really Commendable that we have a

[2:00:57] » well, I think it's really Commendable that we have a

[2:00:57] » well, I think it's really Commendable that we have a Brand and certain policies and

[2:01:00] commendable that we have a Brand and certain policies and

[2:01:00] commendable that we have a Brand and certain policies and Things that we really, you

[2:01:01] brand and certain policies and Things that we really, you

[2:01:01] brand and certain policies and Things that we really, you Know, promote to the rest

[2:01:01] things that we really, you Know, promote to the rest

[2:01:02] things that we really, you Know, promote to the rest Of the world that make no

[2:01:02] know, promote to the rest Of the world that make no

[2:01:02] know, promote to the rest Of the world that make no Special our brownfield policy

[2:01:04] of the world that make no Special our brownfield policy

[2:01:04] of the world that make no Special our brownfield policy Reflects that.

[2:01:04] special our brownfield policy Reflects that.

[2:01:05] special our brownfield policy Reflects that. I mean in terms of like

[2:01:05] reflects that. I mean in terms of like

[2:01:05] reflects that. I mean in terms of like Requiring it for affordable

[2:01:08] I mean in terms of like Requiring it for affordable

[2:01:08] I mean in terms of like Requiring it for affordable Housing requirements for

[2:01:11] requiring it for affordable Housing requirements for

[2:01:12] requiring it for affordable Housing requirements for Sustainable features

[2:01:12] housing requirements for Sustainable features

[2:01:12] housing requirements for Sustainable features Of remediating above and beyond

[2:01:13] sustainable features Of remediating above and beyond

[2:01:13] sustainable features Of remediating above and beyond What is required.

[2:01:16] of remediating above and beyond What is required.

[2:01:16] of remediating above and beyond What is required. Those are those are good

[2:01:17] what is required. Those are those are good

[2:01:17] what is required. Those are those are good Things.

[2:01:17] those are those are good Things.

[2:01:17] those are those are good Things. We're allowed to have stricter

[2:01:18] things. We're allowed to have stricter

[2:01:18] things. We're allowed to have stricter Standards in the state.

[2:01:19] we're allowed to have stricter Standards in the state.

[2:01:19] we're allowed to have stricter Standards in the state. We can't have less strict our

[2:01:20] standards in the state. We can't have less strict our

[2:01:20] standards in the state. We can't have less strict our Brownfield policies a little

[2:01:20] we can't have less strict our Brownfield policies a little

[2:01:21] we can't have less strict our Brownfield policies a little Bit stricter than the state

[2:01:23] brownfield policies a little Bit stricter than the state

[2:01:23] brownfield policies a little Bit stricter than the state Requires and that is I think

[2:01:27] bit stricter than the state Requires and that is I think

[2:01:27] bit stricter than the state Requires and that is I think That's what you're getting at

[2:01:28] requires and that is I think That's what you're getting at

[2:01:28] requires and that is I think That's what you're getting at Is that you were certainly not

[2:01:30] that's what you're getting at Is that you were certainly not

[2:01:31] that's what you're getting at Is that you were certainly not Going against with state laws

[2:01:31] is that you were certainly not Going against with state laws

[2:01:31] is that you were certainly not Going against with state laws As we just have a little bit

[2:01:32] going against with state laws As we just have a little bit

[2:01:32] going against with state laws As we just have a little bit Higher standards than what

[2:01:33] as we just have a little bit Higher standards than what

[2:01:33] as we just have a little bit Higher standards than what State law requires further

[2:01:38] higher standards than what State law requires further

[2:01:38] higher standards than what State law requires further Discussion council member

[2:01:39] state law requires further Discussion council member

[2:01:39] state law requires further Discussion council member Kernell, I think they're going

[2:01:42] discussion council member Kernell, I think they're going

[2:01:43] discussion council member Kernell, I think they're going To need you to stop me if this

[2:01:46] kernell, I think they're going To need you to stop me if this

[2:01:46] kernell, I think they're going To need you to stop me if this Is not allowed in this section

[2:01:47] to need you to stop me if this Is not allowed in this section

[2:01:47] to need you to stop me if this Is not allowed in this section Of our conversation because

[2:01:53] is not allowed in this section Of our conversation because

[2:01:53] is not allowed in this section Of our conversation because Of the change in the ppa and

[2:01:54] of our conversation because Of the change in the ppa and

[2:01:54] of our conversation because Of the change in the ppa and Not having aside from the

[2:01:57] of the change in the ppa and Not having aside from the

[2:01:58] of the change in the ppa and Not having aside from the Brownfield the tif tables which

[2:01:58] not having aside from the Brownfield the tif tables which

[2:01:58] not having aside from the Brownfield the tif tables which We know can be amended in front

[2:02:02] brownfield the tif tables which We know can be amended in front

[2:02:02] brownfield the tif tables which We know can be amended in front Of us, do we have a firm

[2:02:05] we know can be amended in front Of us, do we have a firm

[2:02:05] we know can be amended in front Of us, do we have a firm Assurance the city staff have a

[2:02:06] of us, do we have a firm Assurance the city staff have a

[2:02:06] of us, do we have a firm Assurance the city staff have a Firm insurance that all three x

[2:02:08] assurance the city staff have a Firm insurance that all three x

[2:02:08] assurance the city staff have a Firm insurance that all three x Will remain priority number one

[2:02:09] firm insurance that all three x Will remain priority number one

[2:02:09] firm insurance that all three x Will remain priority number one And will not require any public

[2:02:11] will remain priority number one And will not require any public

[2:02:11] will remain priority number one And will not require any public Participation?

[2:02:15] and will not require any public Participation?

[2:02:15] and will not require any public Participation? No, I think the plan and

[2:02:19] participation? No, I think the plan and

[2:02:19] participation? No, I think the plan and Of itself is public

[2:02:19] no, I think the plan and Of itself is public

[2:02:20] no, I think the plan and Of itself is public Participation.

[2:02:20] of itself is public Participation.

[2:02:20] of itself is public Participation. It's the taxes that are

[2:02:23] participation. It's the taxes that are

[2:02:23] participation. It's the taxes that are Generated by the project that

[2:02:24] it's the taxes that are Generated by the project that

[2:02:24] it's the taxes that are Generated by the project that Are going to pay for something.

[2:02:25] generated by the project that Are going to pay for something.

[2:02:25] generated by the project that Are going to pay for something. So I think that certainly

[2:02:25] are going to pay for something. So I think that certainly

[2:02:25] are going to pay for something. So I think that certainly Constitutes that also passing

[2:02:27] so I think that certainly Constitutes that also passing

[2:02:28] so I think that certainly Constitutes that also passing This doesn't get the project

[2:02:31] constitutes that also passing This doesn't get the project

[2:02:32] constitutes that also passing This doesn't get the project Started.

[2:02:32] this doesn't get the project Started.

[2:02:32] this doesn't get the project Started. This is a step in the process.

[2:02:33] started. This is a step in the process.

[2:02:33] started. This is a step in the process. It is a vital step in the

[2:02:36] this is a step in the process. It is a vital step in the

[2:02:36] this is a step in the process. It is a vital step in the Process.

[2:02:36] it is a vital step in the Process.

[2:02:36] it is a vital step in the Process. But is it is it is a step in

[2:02:37] process. But is it is it is a step in

[2:02:37] process. But is it is it is a step in The process there.

[2:02:38] but is it is it is a step in The process there.

[2:02:38] but is it is it is a step in The process there. This does not make the project

[2:02:42] the process there. This does not make the project

[2:02:42] the process there. This does not make the project Feasible automatically.

[2:02:43] this does not make the project Feasible automatically.

[2:02:43] this does not make the project Feasible automatically. It is very feasible that like

[2:02:47] feasible automatically. It is very feasible that like

[2:02:47] feasible automatically. It is very feasible that like We will we will continue to

[2:02:47] it is very feasible that like We will we will continue to

[2:02:47] it is very feasible that like We will we will continue to Work with the developer as long

[2:02:50] we will we will continue to Work with the developer as long

[2:02:50] we will we will continue to Work with the developer as long As they're willing to do that

[2:02:51] work with the developer as long As they're willing to do that

[2:02:51] work with the developer as long As they're willing to do that To put together a deal

[2:02:52] as they're willing to do that To put together a deal

[2:02:52] as they're willing to do that To put together a deal Structure that makes sense.

[2:02:53] to put together a deal Structure that makes sense.

[2:02:53] to put together a deal Structure that makes sense. There's there's still a

[2:02:54] structure that makes sense. There's there's still a

[2:02:54] structure that makes sense. There's there's still a Financial gap.

[2:02:54] there's there's still a Financial gap.

[2:02:55] there's there's still a Financial gap. I told you ten months ago when

[2:02:57] financial gap. I told you ten months ago when

[2:02:58] financial gap. I told you ten months ago when I started that this was the

[2:02:58] I told you ten months ago when I started that this was the

[2:02:58] I told you ten months ago when I started that this was the Most well vetted project I had

[2:02:59] I started that this was the Most well vetted project I had

[2:02:59] I started that this was the Most well vetted project I had Ever seen.

[2:02:59] most well vetted project I had Ever seen.

[2:02:59] most well vetted project I had Ever seen. That was ten months ago.

[2:03:02] ever seen. That was ten months ago.

[2:03:02] ever seen. That was ten months ago. There's been some vetting since

[2:03:02] that was ten months ago. There's been some vetting since

[2:03:02] that was ten months ago. There's been some vetting since Then.

[2:03:03] there's been some vetting since Then.

[2:03:03] there's been some vetting since Then. So stand by that we know that

[2:03:06] then. So stand by that we know that

[2:03:06] then. So stand by that we know that To make this project feasible

[2:03:09] so stand by that we know that To make this project feasible

[2:03:09] so stand by that we know that To make this project feasible It is going to require some

[2:03:10] to make this project feasible It is going to require some

[2:03:10] to make this project feasible It is going to require some Level of public participation.

[2:03:12] it is going to require some Level of public participation.

[2:03:12] it is going to require some Level of public participation. Exactly.

[2:03:13] level of public participation. Exactly.

[2:03:13] level of public participation. Exactly. That fuel mixture looks like is

[2:03:14] exactly. That fuel mixture looks like is

[2:03:14] exactly. That fuel mixture looks like is Still being determined.

[2:03:16] that fuel mixture looks like is Still being determined.

[2:03:17] that fuel mixture looks like is Still being determined. But for it to be this far down

[2:03:17] still being determined. But for it to be this far down

[2:03:18] still being determined. But for it to be this far down To the process for eighteen

[2:03:18] but for it to be this far down To the process for eighteen

[2:03:18] but for it to be this far down To the process for eighteen Months in the process and not

[2:03:19] to the process for eighteen Months in the process and not

[2:03:19] to the process for eighteen Months in the process and not Have an assurance that the city

[2:03:21] months in the process and not Have an assurance that the city

[2:03:21] months in the process and not Have an assurance that the city Council is behind it is

[2:03:21] have an assurance that the city Council is behind it is

[2:03:22] have an assurance that the city Council is behind it is Something the gets to a point

[2:03:25] council is behind it is Something the gets to a point

[2:03:25] council is behind it is Something the gets to a point Where somebody mentioned staff

[2:03:25] something the gets to a point Where somebody mentioned staff

[2:03:26] something the gets to a point Where somebody mentioned staff Time the developers we just we

[2:03:29] where somebody mentioned staff Time the developers we just we

[2:03:29] where somebody mentioned staff Time the developers we just we Need we need to know if there's

[2:03:30] time the developers we just we Need we need to know if there's

[2:03:30] time the developers we just we Need we need to know if there's A reason to continue to pursue

[2:03:30] need we need to know if there's A reason to continue to pursue

[2:03:30] need we need to know if there's A reason to continue to pursue It though.

[2:03:31] a reason to continue to pursue It though.

[2:03:32] a reason to continue to pursue It though. >> yeah.

[2:03:32] it though. >> yeah.

[2:03:32] it though. >> yeah. Thank you.

[2:03:32] » yeah. Thank you.

[2:03:33] » yeah. Thank you. I appreciate that I I think

[2:03:33] thank you. I appreciate that I I think

[2:03:33] thank you. I appreciate that I I think Given the amount time spent on

[2:03:36] I appreciate that I I think Given the amount time spent on

[2:03:36] I appreciate that I I think Given the amount time spent on That and the fact that this

[2:03:37] given the amount time spent on That and the fact that this

[2:03:37] given the amount time spent on That and the fact that this Isn't going to materialize

[2:03:37] that and the fact that this Isn't going to materialize

[2:03:37] that and the fact that this Isn't going to materialize Tomorrow is argument enough to

[2:03:40] isn't going to materialize Tomorrow is argument enough to

[2:03:40] isn't going to materialize Tomorrow is argument enough to Wait to see what the city

[2:03:40] tomorrow is argument enough to Wait to see what the city

[2:03:41] tomorrow is argument enough to Wait to see what the city Attorney's office might come

[2:03:41] wait to see what the city Attorney's office might come

[2:03:41] wait to see what the city Attorney's office might come Back to us with in two weeks.

[2:03:44] attorney's office might come Back to us with in two weeks.

[2:03:44] attorney's office might come Back to us with in two weeks. >> it's that just doesn't feel

[2:03:45] back to us with in two weeks. >> it's that just doesn't feel

[2:03:45] back to us with in two weeks. >> it's that just doesn't feel Like a long postponement to me

[2:03:46] » it's that just doesn't feel Like a long postponement to me

[2:03:46] » it's that just doesn't feel Like a long postponement to me .

[2:03:47] like a long postponement to me .

[2:03:47] like a long postponement to me . >> councilor briggs.

[2:03:47] . >> councilor briggs.

[2:03:47] . >> councilor briggs. Yeah, and I I appreciate the

[2:03:51] » councilor briggs. Yeah, and I I appreciate the

[2:03:51] » councilor briggs. Yeah, and I I appreciate the Assurances from the development

[2:03:54] yeah, and I I appreciate the Assurances from the development

[2:03:54] yeah, and I I appreciate the Assurances from the development Team about what what's going to

[2:03:55] assurances from the development Team about what what's going to

[2:03:55] assurances from the development Team about what what's going to Be coming.

[2:03:56] team about what what's going to Be coming.

[2:03:56] team about what what's going to Be coming. I would hope that you if we do

[2:03:59] be coming. I would hope that you if we do

[2:03:59] be coming. I would hope that you if we do Support their support for

[2:03:59] I would hope that you if we do Support their support for

[2:04:00] I would hope that you if we do Support their support for Postponement tonight that when

[2:04:00] support their support for Postponement tonight that when

[2:04:00] support their support for Postponement tonight that when When comes back that we'll

[2:04:03] postponement tonight that when When comes back that we'll

[2:04:03] postponement tonight that when When comes back that we'll We'll have those those legal

[2:04:04] when comes back that we'll We'll have those those legal

[2:04:04] when comes back that we'll We'll have those those legal Agreements in front of us so

[2:04:04] we'll have those those legal Agreements in front of us so

[2:04:04] we'll have those those legal Agreements in front of us so That those you it's not just a

[2:04:07] agreements in front of us so That those you it's not just a

[2:04:07] agreements in front of us so That those you it's not just a Pinky promise.

[2:04:07] that those you it's not just a Pinky promise.

[2:04:08] that those you it's not just a Pinky promise. It's something more more

[2:04:08] pinky promise. It's something more more

[2:04:08] pinky promise. It's something more more Concrete.

[2:04:10] it's something more more Concrete.

[2:04:10] it's something more more Concrete. But I do want to ask you a

[2:04:12] concrete. But I do want to ask you a

[2:04:12] concrete. But I do want to ask you a Question around something that

[2:04:14] but I do want to ask you a Question around something that

[2:04:14] but I do want to ask you a Question around something that I don't think could be done in

[2:04:15] question around something that I don't think could be done in

[2:04:15] question around something that I don't think could be done in The next two weeks is remains

[2:04:18] I don't think could be done in The next two weeks is remains

[2:04:18] I don't think could be done in The next two weeks is remains One of my concerns.

[2:04:18] the next two weeks is remains One of my concerns.

[2:04:18] the next two weeks is remains One of my concerns. But it could be and that's that

[2:04:22] one of my concerns. But it could be and that's that

[2:04:22] one of my concerns. But it could be and that's that You know, in brownfield plan

[2:04:25] but it could be and that's that You know, in brownfield plan

[2:04:25] but it could be and that's that You know, in brownfield plan And in the past we've we've we

[2:04:28] you know, in brownfield plan And in the past we've we've we

[2:04:29] you know, in brownfield plan And in the past we've we've we Referenced the pfm study and

[2:04:33] and in the past we've we've we Referenced the pfm study and

[2:04:33] and in the past we've we've we Referenced the pfm study and That has been used just a month

[2:04:33] referenced the pfm study and That has been used just a month

[2:04:34] referenced the pfm study and That has been used just a month And a half ago two months ago

[2:04:36] that has been used just a month And a half ago two months ago

[2:04:37] that has been used just a month And a half ago two months ago We were told that the only way

[2:04:37] and a half ago two months ago We were told that the only way

[2:04:37] and a half ago two months ago We were told that the only way That this project would move

[2:04:38] we were told that the only way That this project would move

[2:04:38] we were told that the only way That this project would move Forward was if the city wanted

[2:04:40] that this project would move Forward was if the city wanted

[2:04:40] that this project would move Forward was if the city wanted And you know, purchased,

[2:04:40] forward was if the city wanted And you know, purchased,

[2:04:41] forward was if the city wanted And you know, purchased, Maintained and operated these

[2:04:44] and you know, purchased, Maintained and operated these

[2:04:44] and you know, purchased, Maintained and operated these Parking structure two months

[2:04:45] maintained and operated these Parking structure two months

[2:04:45] maintained and operated these Parking structure two months Later we're told that this

[2:04:45] parking structure two months Later we're told that this

[2:04:45] parking structure two months Later we're told that this Project is financially

[2:04:48] later we're told that this Project is financially

[2:04:48] later we're told that this Project is financially Feasible.

[2:04:48] project is financially Feasible.

[2:04:48] project is financially Feasible. But all we need to do is

[2:04:50] feasible. But all we need to do is

[2:04:51] feasible. But all we need to do is Potentially is is you know,

[2:04:51] but all we need to do is Potentially is is you know,

[2:04:52] but all we need to do is Potentially is is you know, This large brownfield but we

[2:04:55] potentially is is you know, This large brownfield but we

[2:04:55] potentially is is you know, This large brownfield but we Have a you know, we have a

[2:04:58] this large brownfield but we Have a you know, we have a

[2:04:59] this large brownfield but we Have a you know, we have a Letter from the developer from

[2:04:59] have a you know, we have a Letter from the developer from

[2:05:00] have a you know, we have a Letter from the developer from September that you know, speaks

[2:05:03] letter from the developer from September that you know, speaks

[2:05:03] letter from the developer from September that you know, speaks To says exactly that that you

[2:05:07] september that you know, speaks To says exactly that that you

[2:05:07] september that you know, speaks To says exactly that that you Know, you analyze the project

[2:05:08] to says exactly that that you Know, you analyze the project

[2:05:08] to says exactly that that you Know, you analyze the project And determined that city would

[2:05:08] know, you analyze the project And determined that city would

[2:05:09] know, you analyze the project And determined that city would Need to own the parking garages

[2:05:11] and determined that city would Need to own the parking garages

[2:05:11] and determined that city would Need to own the parking garages In order to make the project a

[2:05:12] need to own the parking garages In order to make the project a

[2:05:12] need to own the parking garages In order to make the project a Reality.

[2:05:12] in order to make the project a Reality.

[2:05:12] in order to make the project a Reality. And so we continue to reference

[2:05:14] reality. And so we continue to reference

[2:05:14] reality. And so we continue to reference This pfm study in terms in the

[2:05:15] and so we continue to reference This pfm study in terms in the

[2:05:15] and so we continue to reference This pfm study in terms in the Brownfield plan about the

[2:05:18] this pfm study in terms in the Brownfield plan about the

[2:05:18] this pfm study in terms in the Brownfield plan about the Financial feasibility and the

[2:05:19] brownfield plan about the Financial feasibility and the

[2:05:19] brownfield plan about the Financial feasibility and the Need for the city to actually

[2:05:19] financial feasibility and the Need for the city to actually

[2:05:20] financial feasibility and the Need for the city to actually Participate in this.

[2:05:22] need for the city to actually Participate in this.

[2:05:22] need for the city to actually Participate in this. And yet it doesn't seem to be a

[2:05:23] participate in this. And yet it doesn't seem to be a

[2:05:23] participate in this. And yet it doesn't seem to be a Strong financial guide for the

[2:05:24] and yet it doesn't seem to be a Strong financial guide for the

[2:05:24] and yet it doesn't seem to be a Strong financial guide for the City anymore considering the

[2:05:26] strong financial guide for the City anymore considering the

[2:05:26] strong financial guide for the City anymore considering the Structural changes.

[2:05:27] city anymore considering the Structural changes.

[2:05:27] city anymore considering the Structural changes. So if you can maybe speak more

[2:05:30] structural changes. So if you can maybe speak more

[2:05:30] structural changes. So if you can maybe speak more To you know, how are we

[2:05:31] so if you can maybe speak more To you know, how are we

[2:05:31] so if you can maybe speak more To you know, how are we Referencing those documents in

[2:05:31] to you know, how are we Referencing those documents in

[2:05:32] to you know, how are we Referencing those documents in That analysis?

[2:05:34] referencing those documents in That analysis?

[2:05:34] referencing those documents in That analysis? >> how does that inform where

[2:05:35] that analysis? >> how does that inform where

[2:05:35] that analysis? >> how does that inform where We're at today considering the

[2:05:35] » how does that inform where We're at today considering the

[2:05:36] » how does that inform where We're at today considering the Structural changes?

[2:05:37] we're at today considering the Structural changes?

[2:05:37] we're at today considering the Structural changes? Sure.

[2:05:37] structural changes? Sure.

[2:05:38] structural changes? Sure. So we had engaged pfm again our

[2:05:42] sure. So we had engaged pfm again our

[2:05:42] sure. So we had engaged pfm again our Consultant, not their

[2:05:43] so we had engaged pfm again our Consultant, not their

[2:05:43] so we had engaged pfm again our Consultant, not their Consultant.

[2:05:43] consultant, not their Consultant.

[2:05:43] consultant, not their Consultant. So we're paying them for the

[2:05:44] consultant. So we're paying them for the

[2:05:44] consultant. So we're paying them for the Good advice that they're giving

[2:05:45] so we're paying them for the Good advice that they're giving

[2:05:45] so we're paying them for the Good advice that they're giving Us I guess probably 14 months

[2:05:49] good advice that they're giving Us I guess probably 14 months

[2:05:49] good advice that they're giving Us I guess probably 14 months To go at this point to say how

[2:05:50] us I guess probably 14 months To go at this point to say how

[2:05:50] us I guess probably 14 months To go at this point to say how Would the city's participation

[2:05:51] to go at this point to say how Would the city's participation

[2:05:51] to go at this point to say how Would the city's participation In this project make the most

[2:05:53] would the city's participation In this project make the most

[2:05:53] would the city's participation In this project make the most Sense?

[2:05:54] in this project make the most Sense?

[2:05:54] in this project make the most Sense? And like I said before, our

[2:05:54] sense? And like I said before, our

[2:05:55] sense? And like I said before, our Excellent bond rating tax

[2:05:57] and like I said before, our Excellent bond rating tax

[2:05:57] and like I said before, our Excellent bond rating tax Exempt municipal bond is was a

[2:05:58] excellent bond rating tax Exempt municipal bond is was a

[2:05:58] excellent bond rating tax Exempt municipal bond is was a Way to make that, you know, say

[2:06:02] exempt municipal bond is was a Way to make that, you know, say

[2:06:02] exempt municipal bond is was a Way to make that, you know, say Pencil out so over the course

[2:06:05] way to make that, you know, say Pencil out so over the course

[2:06:05] way to make that, you know, say Pencil out so over the course Of that time interest rates

[2:06:06] pencil out so over the course Of that time interest rates

[2:06:06] pencil out so over the course Of that time interest rates Have dropped a bit.

[2:06:09] of that time interest rates Have dropped a bit.

[2:06:09] of that time interest rates Have dropped a bit. We have more clarity on

[2:06:10] have dropped a bit. We have more clarity on

[2:06:10] have dropped a bit. We have more clarity on Construction prices.

[2:06:13] we have more clarity on Construction prices.

[2:06:13] we have more clarity on Construction prices. The gap that existed at the

[2:06:14] construction prices. The gap that existed at the

[2:06:14] construction prices. The gap that existed at the Beginning is smaller than the

[2:06:17] the gap that existed at the Beginning is smaller than the

[2:06:17] the gap that existed at the Beginning is smaller than the Gap that would exist today but

[2:06:20] beginning is smaller than the Gap that would exist today but

[2:06:20] beginning is smaller than the Gap that would exist today but There exists a gap today like

[2:06:21] gap that would exist today but There exists a gap today like

[2:06:21] gap that would exist today but There exists a gap today like It is circumstances change

[2:06:24] there exists a gap today like It is circumstances change

[2:06:24] there exists a gap today like It is circumstances change Because of long.

[2:06:25] it is circumstances change Because of long.

[2:06:25] it is circumstances change Because of long. This is a phase project with a

[2:06:28] because of long. This is a phase project with a

[2:06:28] because of long. This is a phase project with a Lot of moving parts.

[2:06:29] this is a phase project with a Lot of moving parts.

[2:06:29] this is a phase project with a Lot of moving parts. The gap has gone down a little

[2:06:31] lot of moving parts. The gap has gone down a little

[2:06:31] lot of moving parts. The gap has gone down a little Bit but there's still a gap I

[2:06:32] the gap has gone down a little Bit but there's still a gap I

[2:06:32] the gap has gone down a little Bit but there's still a gap I Think that we could reengage

[2:06:35] bit but there's still a gap I Think that we could reengage

[2:06:36] bit but there's still a gap I Think that we could reengage Pfm have them look at it again

[2:06:36] think that we could reengage Pfm have them look at it again

[2:06:36] think that we could reengage Pfm have them look at it again But it's going to tell us what

[2:06:39] pfm have them look at it again But it's going to tell us what

[2:06:39] pfm have them look at it again But it's going to tell us what We kind of already know if we

[2:06:40] but it's going to tell us what We kind of already know if we

[2:06:40] but it's going to tell us what We kind of already know if we Do it if they do this privately

[2:06:43] we kind of already know if we Do it if they do this privately

[2:06:43] we kind of already know if we Do it if they do this privately It's more expensive than if we

[2:06:44] do it if they do this privately It's more expensive than if we

[2:06:44] do it if they do this privately It's more expensive than if we Were to do it the way that that

[2:06:45] it's more expensive than if we Were to do it the way that that

[2:06:45] it's more expensive than if we Were to do it the way that that Was set up in the ppa.

[2:06:51] were to do it the way that that Was set up in the ppa.

[2:06:51] were to do it the way that that Was set up in the ppa. So I think that the value

[2:06:52] was set up in the ppa. So I think that the value

[2:06:52] was set up in the ppa. So I think that the value Of that would be it would be

[2:06:53] so I think that the value Of that would be it would be

[2:06:53] so I think that the value Of that would be it would be Limited.

[2:06:53] of that would be it would be Limited.

[2:06:53] of that would be it would be Limited. It's just intuitively going to

[2:06:55] limited. It's just intuitively going to

[2:06:55] limited. It's just intuitively going to Have a higher interest rate

[2:06:56] it's just intuitively going to Have a higher interest rate

[2:06:56] it's just intuitively going to Have a higher interest rate Because it's financed

[2:06:57] have a higher interest rate Because it's financed

[2:06:57] have a higher interest rate Because it's financed Privately.

[2:06:57] because it's financed Privately.

[2:06:57] because it's financed Privately. I'm sure I'm getting at what

[2:06:59] privately. I'm sure I'm getting at what

[2:06:59] privately. I'm sure I'm getting at what Your what your question is but

[2:07:00] I'm sure I'm getting at what Your what your question is but

[2:07:00] I'm sure I'm getting at what Your what your question is but That's the truth of the matter

[2:07:06] your what your question is but That's the truth of the matter

[2:07:06] your what your question is but That's the truth of the matter To some degree you are I think

[2:07:07] that's the truth of the matter To some degree you are I think

[2:07:07] that's the truth of the matter To some degree you are I think That you we paid for, you know,

[2:07:11] to some degree you are I think That you we paid for, you know,

[2:07:11] to some degree you are I think That you we paid for, you know, Study to look at this in a

[2:07:12] that you we paid for, you know, Study to look at this in a

[2:07:12] that you we paid for, you know, Study to look at this in a Financial calculation for us

[2:07:15] study to look at this in a Financial calculation for us

[2:07:15] study to look at this in a Financial calculation for us That was to give us assurances

[2:07:18] financial calculation for us That was to give us assurances

[2:07:18] financial calculation for us That was to give us assurances Around the need for city

[2:07:19] that was to give us assurances Around the need for city

[2:07:19] that was to give us assurances Around the need for city Participation in this and the

[2:07:22] around the need for city Participation in this and the

[2:07:22] around the need for city Participation in this and the Type of city participation that

[2:07:23] participation in this and the Type of city participation that

[2:07:23] participation in this and the Type of city participation that Was needed and within the

[2:07:24] type of city participation that Was needed and within the

[2:07:24] type of city participation that Was needed and within the Course of two months that type

[2:07:26] was needed and within the Course of two months that type

[2:07:26] was needed and within the Course of two months that type Of participation has shifted

[2:07:26] course of two months that type Of participation has shifted

[2:07:27] course of two months that type Of participation has shifted Really fundamentally in terms

[2:07:27] of participation has shifted Really fundamentally in terms

[2:07:27] of participation has shifted Really fundamentally in terms Of what we've been told is a

[2:07:30] really fundamentally in terms Of what we've been told is a

[2:07:30] really fundamentally in terms Of what we've been told is a Necessity.

[2:07:30] of what we've been told is a Necessity.

[2:07:30] of what we've been told is a Necessity. And so, you know, I think I've

[2:07:34] necessity. And so, you know, I think I've

[2:07:34] necessity. And so, you know, I think I've Just left with some doubt

[2:07:34] and so, you know, I think I've Just left with some doubt

[2:07:35] and so, you know, I think I've Just left with some doubt Around the utility of that

[2:07:36] just left with some doubt Around the utility of that

[2:07:37] just left with some doubt Around the utility of that Study there.

[2:07:40] around the utility of that Study there.

[2:07:40] around the utility of that Study there. Yeah, I think the the the way

[2:07:42] study there. Yeah, I think the the the way

[2:07:42] study there. Yeah, I think the the the way That the ppa was set up, it

[2:07:45] yeah, I think the the the way That the ppa was set up, it

[2:07:45] yeah, I think the the the way That the ppa was set up, it Says the city will participate

[2:07:46] that the ppa was set up, it Says the city will participate

[2:07:46] that the ppa was set up, it Says the city will participate In this way, this way.

[2:07:46] says the city will participate In this way, this way.

[2:07:46] says the city will participate In this way, this way. But there are so many other

[2:07:48] in this way, this way. But there are so many other

[2:07:49] in this way, this way. But there are so many other Things that responsibility the

[2:07:49] but there are so many other Things that responsibility the

[2:07:49] but there are so many other Things that responsibility the Vast responsibilities of the

[2:07:50] things that responsibility the Vast responsibilities of the

[2:07:50] things that responsibility the Vast responsibilities of the Developer and it kind of became

[2:07:52] vast responsibilities of the Developer and it kind of became

[2:07:52] vast responsibilities of the Developer and it kind of became Clear that that was just wasn't

[2:07:53] developer and it kind of became Clear that that was just wasn't

[2:07:53] developer and it kind of became Clear that that was just wasn't That wasn't the optimal keep

[2:07:55] clear that that was just wasn't That wasn't the optimal keep

[2:07:56] clear that that was just wasn't That wasn't the optimal keep Saying fuel mixture but with

[2:07:56] that wasn't the optimal keep Saying fuel mixture but with

[2:07:56] that wasn't the optimal keep Saying fuel mixture but with The right set of you roles,

[2:08:00] saying fuel mixture but with The right set of you roles,

[2:08:00] saying fuel mixture but with The right set of you roles, Responsibilities, risks and we

[2:08:00] the right set of you roles, Responsibilities, risks and we

[2:08:00] the right set of you roles, Responsibilities, risks and we Need to reevaluate it a little

[2:08:04] responsibilities, risks and we Need to reevaluate it a little

[2:08:04] responsibilities, risks and we Need to reevaluate it a little Bit now like I said, the

[2:08:05] need to reevaluate it a little Bit now like I said, the

[2:08:05] need to reevaluate it a little Bit now like I said, the Brownfield is a step in the

[2:08:08] bit now like I said, the Brownfield is a step in the

[2:08:08] bit now like I said, the Brownfield is a step in the Process.

[2:08:08] brownfield is a step in the Process.

[2:08:08] brownfield is a step in the Process. It is not the end of the

[2:08:09] process. It is not the end of the

[2:08:09] process. It is not the end of the Process.

[2:08:09] it is not the end of the Process.

[2:08:09] it is not the end of the Process. I don't know that we would want

[2:08:12] process. I don't know that we would want

[2:08:12] process. I don't know that we would want To build a swiss watch kind

[2:08:13] I don't know that we would want To build a swiss watch kind

[2:08:13] I don't know that we would want To build a swiss watch kind Of in the same way that we did

[2:08:15] to build a swiss watch kind Of in the same way that we did

[2:08:15] to build a swiss watch kind Of in the same way that we did With a ppa that that took a lot

[2:08:16] of in the same way that we did With a ppa that that took a lot

[2:08:17] of in the same way that we did With a ppa that that took a lot Of time and resources before we

[2:08:20] with a ppa that that took a lot Of time and resources before we

[2:08:20] with a ppa that that took a lot Of time and resources before we At least knew that there is

[2:08:20] of time and resources before we At least knew that there is

[2:08:20] of time and resources before we At least knew that there is Enough support to warrant

[2:08:21] at least knew that there is Enough support to warrant

[2:08:21] at least knew that there is Enough support to warrant Moving forward.

[2:08:23] enough support to warrant Moving forward.

[2:08:24] enough support to warrant Moving forward. And I don't want to come up

[2:08:24] moving forward. And I don't want to come up

[2:08:25] moving forward. And I don't want to come up Here and say that we have every

[2:08:27] and I don't want to come up Here and say that we have every

[2:08:27] and I don't want to come up Here and say that we have every Single answer to every single

[2:08:28] here and say that we have every Single answer to every single

[2:08:28] here and say that we have every Single answer to every single Question.

[2:08:28] single answer to every single Question.

[2:08:29] single answer to every single Question. I think that there's just some

[2:08:29] question. I think that there's just some

[2:08:29] question. I think that there's just some Things that are, you know,

[2:08:31] I think that there's just some Things that are, you know,

[2:08:31] I think that there's just some Things that are, you know, Unknowable until we're getting

[2:08:32] things that are, you know, Unknowable until we're getting

[2:08:32] things that are, you know, Unknowable until we're getting Quotes on prices and getting

[2:08:35] unknowable until we're getting Quotes on prices and getting

[2:08:35] unknowable until we're getting Quotes on prices and getting Quotes from banks on interest

[2:08:36] quotes on prices and getting Quotes from banks on interest

[2:08:36] quotes on prices and getting Quotes from banks on interest Rates, on loans and all that

[2:08:37] quotes from banks on interest Rates, on loans and all that

[2:08:37] quotes from banks on interest Rates, on loans and all that Stuff.

[2:08:38] rates, on loans and all that Stuff.

[2:08:39] rates, on loans and all that Stuff. But this gives us city team

[2:08:43] stuff. But this gives us city team

[2:08:43] stuff. But this gives us city team Development team bandwidth

[2:08:43] but this gives us city team Development team bandwidth

[2:08:43] but this gives us city team Development team bandwidth Oxygen to continue pursuing a

[2:08:46] development team bandwidth Oxygen to continue pursuing a

[2:08:46] development team bandwidth Oxygen to continue pursuing a Deal

[2:08:52] .

[2:08:53] .

[2:08:53] . For my part I'm going to be

[2:08:54] . For my part I'm going to be

[2:08:54] . For my part I'm going to be Voting against the postponement

[2:08:56] for my part I'm going to be Voting against the postponement

[2:08:56] for my part I'm going to be Voting against the postponement Of I think that the change from

[2:09:01] voting against the postponement Of I think that the change from

[2:09:01] voting against the postponement Of I think that the change from The fundamental change is now

[2:09:01] of I think that the change from The fundamental change is now

[2:09:02] of I think that the change from The fundamental change is now The absence of the there are

[2:09:05] the fundamental change is now The absence of the there are

[2:09:05] the fundamental change is now The absence of the there are Other changes there but they

[2:09:06] the absence of the there are Other changes there but they

[2:09:06] the absence of the there are Other changes there but they Are from my perspective

[2:09:09] other changes there but they Are from my perspective

[2:09:09] other changes there but they Are from my perspective Incremental the absence of the

[2:09:10] are from my perspective Incremental the absence of the

[2:09:10] are from my perspective Incremental the absence of the Ppa well with the existing with

[2:09:12] incremental the absence of the Ppa well with the existing with

[2:09:13] incremental the absence of the Ppa well with the existing with The ppa the city already had a

[2:09:16] ppa well with the existing with The ppa the city already had a

[2:09:16] ppa well with the existing with The ppa the city already had a A very low risk that had been I

[2:09:17] the ppa the city already had a A very low risk that had been I

[2:09:17] the ppa the city already had a A very low risk that had been I Think to my satisfaction firmly

[2:09:20] a very low risk that had been I Think to my satisfaction firmly

[2:09:20] a very low risk that had been I Think to my satisfaction firmly Established absent the ppa the

[2:09:21] think to my satisfaction firmly Established absent the ppa the

[2:09:21] think to my satisfaction firmly Established absent the ppa the City continues the city's risk

[2:09:24] established absent the ppa the City continues the city's risk

[2:09:24] established absent the ppa the City continues the city's risk Drops to infinitesimal.

[2:09:28] city continues the city's risk Drops to infinitesimal.

[2:09:28] city continues the city's risk Drops to infinitesimal. The point here from my

[2:09:28] drops to infinitesimal. The point here from my

[2:09:29] drops to infinitesimal. The point here from my Perspective is that the

[2:09:31] the point here from my Perspective is that the

[2:09:32] the point here from my Perspective is that the Investment infrastructure set

[2:09:36] perspective is that the Investment infrastructure set

[2:09:36] perspective is that the Investment infrastructure set That will be addressed by a

[2:09:39] investment infrastructure set That will be addressed by a

[2:09:40] investment infrastructure set That will be addressed by a Fully realized brownfield plan

[2:09:40] that will be addressed by a Fully realized brownfield plan

[2:09:40] that will be addressed by a Fully realized brownfield plan Is either identical to or rymes

[2:09:44] fully realized brownfield plan Is either identical to or rymes

[2:09:44] fully realized brownfield plan Is either identical to or rymes Extremely, extremely closely to

[2:09:47] is either identical to or rymes Extremely, extremely closely to

[2:09:47] is either identical to or rymes Extremely, extremely closely to The plan and the discussion

[2:09:48] extremely, extremely closely to The plan and the discussion

[2:09:48] extremely, extremely closely to The plan and the discussion Which has been existing at this

[2:09:51] the plan and the discussion Which has been existing at this

[2:09:51] the plan and the discussion Which has been existing at this Table and in the public and in

[2:09:55] which has been existing at this Table and in the public and in

[2:09:55] which has been existing at this Table and in the public and in Throughout with staff and with

[2:09:55] table and in the public and in Throughout with staff and with

[2:09:56] table and in the public and in Throughout with staff and with The team and with our legal

[2:09:59] throughout with staff and with The team and with our legal

[2:09:59] throughout with staff and with The team and with our legal Advisers for months now to I

[2:10:02] the team and with our legal Advisers for months now to I

[2:10:02] the team and with our legal Advisers for months now to I The the fact that there

[2:10:06] advisers for months now to I The the fact that there

[2:10:06] advisers for months now to I The the fact that there Continue to be you know, some

[2:10:07] the the fact that there Continue to be you know, some

[2:10:07] the the fact that there Continue to be you know, some Agreements that need to be

[2:10:10] continue to be you know, some Agreements that need to be

[2:10:10] continue to be you know, some Agreements that need to be Drafted, some agreements that

[2:10:11] agreements that need to be Drafted, some agreements that

[2:10:11] agreements that need to be Drafted, some agreements that Need to be approved.

[2:10:14] drafted, some agreements that Need to be approved.

[2:10:14] drafted, some agreements that Need to be approved. >> this is how multiphase six

[2:10:17] need to be approved. >> this is how multiphase six

[2:10:17] need to be approved. >> this is how multiphase six Block sized projects work in my

[2:10:21] » this is how multiphase six Block sized projects work in my

[2:10:21] » this is how multiphase six Block sized projects work in my View this has had a adequate

[2:10:25] block sized projects work in my View this has had a adequate

[2:10:25] block sized projects work in my View this has had a adequate Discussion to get us to this

[2:10:26] view this has had a adequate Discussion to get us to this

[2:10:26] view this has had a adequate Discussion to get us to this Point.

[2:10:26] discussion to get us to this Point.

[2:10:26] discussion to get us to this Point. There will be adequate

[2:10:29] point. There will be adequate

[2:10:29] point. There will be adequate Discussion will continue as

[2:10:29] there will be adequate Discussion will continue as

[2:10:30] there will be adequate Discussion will continue as Other

[2:10:50] issues come before before

[2:10:51] issues come before before

[2:10:51] issues come before before The body and will we'll deal

[2:10:52] issues come before before The body and will we'll deal

[2:10:52] issues come before before The body and will we'll deal With them at that time.

[2:10:52] the body and will we'll deal With them at that time.

[2:10:52] the body and will we'll deal With them at that time. So I'm ok voting vonne as is

[2:10:53] with them at that time. So I'm ok voting vonne as is

[2:10:54] with them at that time. So I'm ok voting vonne as is Today further discussion

[2:10:54] so I'm ok voting vonne as is Today further discussion

[2:10:55] so I'm ok voting vonne as is Today further discussion Roll-call vote please starting

[2:10:56] today further discussion Roll-call vote please starting

[2:10:56] today further discussion Roll-call vote please starting With council member denha I'm

[2:10:57] roll-call vote please starting With council member denha I'm

[2:10:57] roll-call vote please starting With council member denha I'm Sorry.

[2:10:57] with council member denha I'm Sorry.

[2:10:57] with council member denha I'm Sorry. Thank you.

[2:10:58] sorry. Thank you.

[2:10:58] sorry. Thank you. On the postwoman council member

[2:10:59] thank you. On the postwoman council member

[2:10:59] thank you. On the postwoman council member Denha yes countermarch 01 yes

[2:11:02] on the postwoman council member Denha yes countermarch 01 yes

[2:11:02] on the postwoman council member Denha yes countermarch 01 yes Mayor taylor no customer ire no

[2:11:03] denha yes countermarch 01 yes Mayor taylor no customer ire no

[2:11:03] denha yes countermarch 01 yes Mayor taylor no customer ire no Customer akman yes.

[2:11:07] mayor taylor no customer ire no Customer akman yes.

[2:11:07] mayor taylor no customer ire no Customer akman yes. Customer brigs yes.

[2:11:08] customer akman yes. Customer brigs yes.

[2:11:08] customer akman yes. Customer brigs yes. Customer kornel yes.

[2:11:08] customer brigs yes. Customer kornel yes.

[2:11:08] customer brigs yes. Customer kornel yes. Customer no councilor harrison

[2:11:11] customer kornel yes. Customer no councilor harrison

[2:11:11] customer kornel yes. Customer no councilor harrison No councilor watson yes

[2:11:14] customer no councilor harrison No councilor watson yes

[2:11:14] customer no councilor harrison No councilor watson yes Councilor malik yes.

[2:11:15] no councilor watson yes Councilor malik yes.

[2:11:15] no councilor watson yes Councilor malik yes. >> motion carries the motion is

[2:11:18] councilor malik yes. >> motion carries the motion is

[2:11:19] councilor malik yes. >> motion carries the motion is Postponed d.

[2:11:19] » motion carries the motion is Postponed d.

[2:11:19] » motion carries the motion is Postponed d. S to resolution to approve a

[2:11:23] postponed d. S to resolution to approve a

[2:11:23] postponed d. S to resolution to approve a Transformational brownfield

[2:11:23] s to resolution to approve a Transformational brownfield

[2:11:23] s to resolution to approve a Transformational brownfield Plan for three fifty s fifth

[2:11:25] transformational brownfield Plan for three fifty s fifth

[2:11:25] transformational brownfield Plan for three fifty s fifth Avenue move by council member

[2:11:26] plan for three fifty s fifth Avenue move by council member

[2:11:26] plan for three fifty s fifth Avenue move by council member Denha second by council no dis

[2:11:29] avenue move by council member Denha second by council no dis

[2:11:30] avenue move by council member Denha second by council no dis Discussion please of dc two

[2:11:30] denha second by council no dis Discussion please of dc two

[2:11:30] denha second by council no dis Discussion please of dc two Council o is our staff

[2:11:34] discussion please of dc two Council o is our staff

[2:11:34] discussion please of dc two Council o is our staff Introduction.

[2:11:34] council o is our staff Introduction.

[2:11:34] council o is our staff Introduction. Thank you

[2:11:44] everyone of joginder

[2:11:48] everyone of joginder

[2:11:49] everyone of joginder Economic development.

[2:11:52] everyone of joginder Economic development.

[2:11:52] everyone of joginder Economic development. So this is related to the three

[2:11:53] economic development. So this is related to the three

[2:11:53] economic development. So this is related to the three Fifty s fifth avenue affordable

[2:11:56] so this is related to the three Fifty s fifth avenue affordable

[2:11:57] so this is related to the three Fifty s fifth avenue affordable Housing project three and

[2:11:57] fifty s fifth avenue affordable Housing project three and

[2:11:57] fifty s fifth avenue affordable Housing project three and Thirty units twenty storeys

[2:11:58] housing project three and Thirty units twenty storeys

[2:11:58] housing project three and Thirty units twenty storeys Downtown this item has been for

[2:12:01] thirty units twenty storeys Downtown this item has been for

[2:12:01] thirty units twenty storeys Downtown this item has been for You all in various capacities a

[2:12:04] downtown this item has been for You all in various capacities a

[2:12:05] downtown this item has been for You all in various capacities a Couple of times joined by

[2:12:05] you all in various capacities a Couple of times joined by

[2:12:05] you all in various capacities a Couple of times joined by Members of the development team

[2:12:08] couple of times joined by Members of the development team

[2:12:08] couple of times joined by Members of the development team .

[2:12:08] members of the development team .

[2:12:08] members of the development team . We've been patiently waiting

[2:12:09] . We've been patiently waiting

[2:12:09] . We've been patiently waiting Back there working with them

[2:12:12] we've been patiently waiting Back there working with them

[2:12:12] we've been patiently waiting Back there working with them For a while on this project.

[2:12:13] back there working with them For a while on this project.

[2:12:13] back there working with them For a while on this project. It precedes me by a lot.

[2:12:16] for a while on this project. It precedes me by a lot.

[2:12:16] for a while on this project. It precedes me by a lot. I understand that this has a

[2:12:16] it precedes me by a lot. I understand that this has a

[2:12:17] it precedes me by a lot. I understand that this has a Long history to one of the

[2:12:20] I understand that this has a Long history to one of the

[2:12:20] I understand that this has a Long history to one of the Tools that we're using in this

[2:12:20] long history to one of the Tools that we're using in this

[2:12:20] long history to one of the Tools that we're using in this Very complicated capital stack

[2:12:23] tools that we're using in this Very complicated capital stack

[2:12:23] tools that we're using in this Very complicated capital stack Is called a transformational

[2:12:24] very complicated capital stack Is called a transformational

[2:12:24] very complicated capital stack Is called a transformational Brownfield.

[2:12:24] is called a transformational Brownfield.

[2:12:25] is called a transformational Brownfield. I I wanted to give you guys

[2:12:27] brownfield. I I wanted to give you guys

[2:12:27] brownfield. I I wanted to give you guys Just a very brief overview

[2:12:28] I I wanted to give you guys Just a very brief overview

[2:12:28] I I wanted to give you guys Just a very brief overview Of what it was you're way too

[2:12:31] just a very brief overview Of what it was you're way too

[2:12:31] just a very brief overview Of what it was you're way too Familiar with regular

[2:12:34] of what it was you're way too Familiar with regular

[2:12:35] of what it was you're way too Familiar with regular Brownfield plans by this point.

[2:12:35] familiar with regular Brownfield plans by this point.

[2:12:35] familiar with regular Brownfield plans by this point. We know they captured our

[2:12:36] brownfield plans by this point. We know they captured our

[2:12:36] brownfield plans by this point. We know they captured our Property tax new property taxes

[2:12:40] we know they captured our Property tax new property taxes

[2:12:40] we know they captured our Property tax new property taxes That would not exist.

[2:12:40] property tax new property taxes That would not exist.

[2:12:40] property tax new property taxes That would not exist. But for the project I'm

[2:12:43] that would not exist. But for the project I'm

[2:12:43] that would not exist. But for the project I'm Transformational brownfields

[2:12:44] but for the project I'm Transformational brownfields

[2:12:44] but for the project I'm Transformational brownfields Are a little bit different in

[2:12:44] transformational brownfields Are a little bit different in

[2:12:45] transformational brownfields Are a little bit different in That they capture several other

[2:12:47] are a little bit different in That they capture several other

[2:12:47] are a little bit different in That they capture several other State taxes emphasis on state

[2:12:51] that they capture several other State taxes emphasis on state

[2:12:51] that they capture several other State taxes emphasis on state These aren't local taxes.

[2:12:51] state taxes emphasis on state These aren't local taxes.

[2:12:52] state taxes emphasis on state These aren't local taxes. These are only state taxes and

[2:12:54] these aren't local taxes. These are only state taxes and

[2:12:54] these aren't local taxes. These are only state taxes and They are still incremental.

[2:12:55] these are only state taxes and They are still incremental.

[2:12:55] these are only state taxes and They are still incremental. So taxes that would not exist

[2:12:56] they are still incremental. So taxes that would not exist

[2:12:56] they are still incremental. So taxes that would not exist But for the project.

[2:12:58] so taxes that would not exist But for the project.

[2:12:58] so taxes that would not exist But for the project. So what does a transformational

[2:12:59] but for the project. So what does a transformational

[2:12:59] but for the project. So what does a transformational Brownfield project for a site

[2:13:02] so what does a transformational Brownfield project for a site

[2:13:02] so what does a transformational Brownfield project for a site To be eligible it needs to meet

[2:13:03] brownfield project for a site To be eligible it needs to meet

[2:13:03] brownfield project for a site To be eligible it needs to meet The same criteria as a normal

[2:13:04] to be eligible it needs to meet The same criteria as a normal

[2:13:04] to be eligible it needs to meet The same criteria as a normal Brownfield project.

[2:13:06] the same criteria as a normal Brownfield project.

[2:13:06] the same criteria as a normal Brownfield project. There are some additional ones

[2:13:07] brownfield project. There are some additional ones

[2:13:07] brownfield project. There are some additional ones That must be a mixed use

[2:13:07] there are some additional ones That must be a mixed use

[2:13:07] there are some additional ones That must be a mixed use Project that drives population

[2:13:10] that must be a mixed use Project that drives population

[2:13:10] that must be a mixed use Project that drives population Growth, commercial activity and

[2:13:10] project that drives population Growth, commercial activity and

[2:13:11] project that drives population Growth, commercial activity and Employment growth.

[2:13:14] growth, commercial activity and Employment growth.

[2:13:14] growth, commercial activity and Employment growth. Environmental remediation is

[2:13:14] employment growth. Environmental remediation is

[2:13:14] employment growth. Environmental remediation is Still a component of it but

[2:13:17] environmental remediation is Still a component of it but

[2:13:17] environmental remediation is Still a component of it but Economic development is kind

[2:13:17] still a component of it but Economic development is kind

[2:13:18] still a component of it but Economic development is kind Of the thrust of it more than

[2:13:21] economic development is kind Of the thrust of it more than

[2:13:21] economic development is kind Of the thrust of it more than More than just cleaning up the

[2:13:22] of the thrust of it more than More than just cleaning up the

[2:13:22] of the thrust of it more than More than just cleaning up the Site.

[2:13:22] more than just cleaning up the Site.

[2:13:22] more than just cleaning up the Site. So the difference is there are

[2:13:25] site. So the difference is there are

[2:13:25] site. So the difference is there are Taxes that can be captured both

[2:13:26] so the difference is there are Taxes that can be captured both

[2:13:26] so the difference is there are Taxes that can be captured both During construction and after

[2:13:29] taxes that can be captured both During construction and after

[2:13:29] taxes that can be captured both During construction and after The completion of the projects.

[2:13:30] during construction and after The completion of the projects.

[2:13:30] during construction and after The completion of the projects. So all along it's property tax

[2:13:33] the completion of the projects. So all along it's property tax

[2:13:33] the completion of the projects. So all along it's property tax Caps are like a normal

[2:13:34] so all along it's property tax Caps are like a normal

[2:13:34] so all along it's property tax Caps are like a normal Brownfield plan during

[2:13:36] caps are like a normal Brownfield plan during

[2:13:36] caps are like a normal Brownfield plan during Construction we can capture

[2:13:36] brownfield plan during Construction we can capture

[2:13:37] brownfield plan during Construction we can capture Construction related income tax

[2:13:37] construction we can capture Construction related income tax

[2:13:37] construction we can capture Construction related income tax So folks working on the project

[2:13:40] construction related income tax So folks working on the project

[2:13:40] construction related income tax So folks working on the project The income tax so they would be

[2:13:41] so folks working on the project The income tax so they would be

[2:13:41] so folks working on the project The income tax so they would be Earning we can capture

[2:13:44] the income tax so they would be Earning we can capture

[2:13:44] the income tax so they would be Earning we can capture Construction related sales and

[2:13:45] earning we can capture Construction related sales and

[2:13:45] earning we can capture Construction related sales and Use taxes so building materials

[2:13:48] construction related sales and Use taxes so building materials

[2:13:48] construction related sales and Use taxes so building materials Sales tax on those and then

[2:13:52] use taxes so building materials Sales tax on those and then

[2:13:52] use taxes so building materials Sales tax on those and then After completion so three fifty

[2:13:53] sales tax on those and then After completion so three fifty

[2:13:53] sales tax on those and then After completion so three fifty S is fully occupied.

[2:13:55] after completion so three fifty S is fully occupied.

[2:13:55] after completion so three fifty S is fully occupied. Let's just pretend that there's

[2:13:56] s is fully occupied. Let's just pretend that there's

[2:13:56] s is fully occupied. Let's just pretend that there's Like a market on the first

[2:13:59] let's just pretend that there's Like a market on the first

[2:13:59] let's just pretend that there's Like a market on the first Floor we can capture income tax

[2:14:03] like a market on the first Floor we can capture income tax

[2:14:03] like a market on the first Floor we can capture income tax From residents that live in the

[2:14:04] floor we can capture income tax From residents that live in the

[2:14:04] floor we can capture income tax From residents that live in the Building.

[2:14:07] from residents that live in the Building.

[2:14:07] from residents that live in the Building. We can capture sales taxes from

[2:14:11] building. We can capture sales taxes from

[2:14:11] building. We can capture sales taxes from That first for commercial use

[2:14:11] we can capture sales taxes from That first for commercial use

[2:14:12] we can capture sales taxes from That first for commercial use Or whatever commercial use it

[2:14:12] that first for commercial use Or whatever commercial use it

[2:14:12] that first for commercial use Or whatever commercial use it Is.

[2:14:12] or whatever commercial use it Is.

[2:14:13] or whatever commercial use it Is. Those are those capturable and

[2:14:14] is. Those are those capturable and

[2:14:14] is. Those are those capturable and Then we can capture fifty

[2:14:15] those are those capturable and Then we can capture fifty

[2:14:15] those are those capturable and Then we can capture fifty Percent withholding tax.

[2:14:18] then we can capture fifty Percent withholding tax.

[2:14:18] then we can capture fifty Percent withholding tax. So essentially like the

[2:14:19] percent withholding tax. So essentially like the

[2:14:19] percent withholding tax. So essentially like the Employees at the ground floor

[2:14:20] so essentially like the Employees at the ground floor

[2:14:20] so essentially like the Employees at the ground floor Retailer making that that's

[2:14:22] employees at the ground floor Retailer making that that's

[2:14:22] employees at the ground floor Retailer making that that's Capturable to so it's it's the

[2:14:23] retailer making that that's Capturable to so it's it's the

[2:14:23] retailer making that that's Capturable to so it's it's the Same idea.

[2:14:26] capturable to so it's it's the Same idea.

[2:14:26] capturable to so it's it's the Same idea. It's still the incremental tax

[2:14:27] same idea. It's still the incremental tax

[2:14:27] same idea. It's still the incremental tax Increases just applies to a

[2:14:27] it's still the incremental tax Increases just applies to a

[2:14:28] it's still the incremental tax Increases just applies to a Whole basket of state taxes

[2:14:28] increases just applies to a Whole basket of state taxes

[2:14:28] increases just applies to a Whole basket of state taxes That usually wouldn't be it

[2:14:30] whole basket of state taxes That usually wouldn't be it

[2:14:30] whole basket of state taxes That usually wouldn't be it Wouldn't be capturable.

[2:14:31] that usually wouldn't be it Wouldn't be capturable.

[2:14:31] that usually wouldn't be it Wouldn't be capturable. It's a tool for this project.

[2:14:35] wouldn't be capturable. It's a tool for this project.

[2:14:35] wouldn't be capturable. It's a tool for this project. You're approved a pilot

[2:14:35] it's a tool for this project. You're approved a pilot

[2:14:35] it's a tool for this project. You're approved a pilot Agreement I believe in december

[2:14:38] you're approved a pilot Agreement I believe in december

[2:14:38] you're approved a pilot Agreement I believe in december .

[2:14:38] agreement I believe in december .

[2:14:38] agreement I believe in december . So the housing component

[2:14:39] . So the housing component

[2:14:39] . So the housing component Of this is you know, for all

[2:14:39] so the housing component Of this is you know, for all

[2:14:40] so the housing component Of this is you know, for all Intents and purposes tax

[2:14:42] of this is you know, for all Intents and purposes tax

[2:14:42] of this is you know, for all Intents and purposes tax Exempt.

[2:14:43] intents and purposes tax Exempt.

[2:14:43] intents and purposes tax Exempt. So the only tife that it would

[2:14:44] exempt. So the only tife that it would

[2:14:44] exempt. So the only tife that it would Generate would be from the

[2:14:45] so the only tife that it would Generate would be from the

[2:14:46] so the only tife that it would Generate would be from the Ground floor retail which is

[2:14:46] generate would be from the Ground floor retail which is

[2:14:46] generate would be from the Ground floor retail which is Just one floor and a 20 storey

[2:14:50] ground floor retail which is Just one floor and a 20 storey

[2:14:50] ground floor retail which is Just one floor and a 20 storey Building.

[2:14:50] just one floor and a 20 storey Building.

[2:14:50] just one floor and a 20 storey Building. It doesn't equate to a whole

[2:14:51] building. It doesn't equate to a whole

[2:14:51] building. It doesn't equate to a whole Lot of a lot of money.

[2:14:53] it doesn't equate to a whole Lot of a lot of money.

[2:14:53] it doesn't equate to a whole Lot of a lot of money. So being able to leverage these

[2:14:54] lot of a lot of money. So being able to leverage these

[2:14:54] lot of a lot of money. So being able to leverage these Other sources of funds is the

[2:14:55] so being able to leverage these Other sources of funds is the

[2:14:55] so being able to leverage these Other sources of funds is the Excellent way to help put

[2:14:58] other sources of funds is the Excellent way to help put

[2:14:58] other sources of funds is the Excellent way to help put Together that complicated

[2:14:58] excellent way to help put Together that complicated

[2:14:58] excellent way to help put Together that complicated Capital stack.

[2:14:59] together that complicated Capital stack.

[2:14:59] together that complicated Capital stack. Now you might be thinking hey,

[2:15:02] capital stack. Now you might be thinking hey,

[2:15:02] capital stack. Now you might be thinking hey, We should use on all of our

[2:15:05] now you might be thinking hey, We should use on all of our

[2:15:05] now you might be thinking hey, We should use on all of our Projects that would be great

[2:15:06] we should use on all of our Projects that would be great

[2:15:06] we should use on all of our Projects that would be great But there are unfortunately

[2:15:06] projects that would be great But there are unfortunately

[2:15:07] projects that would be great But there are unfortunately Some limitations.

[2:15:09] but there are unfortunately Some limitations.

[2:15:09] but there are unfortunately Some limitations. Mdc only approves a handful

[2:15:10] some limitations. Mdc only approves a handful

[2:15:10] some limitations. Mdc only approves a handful Of these every single year and

[2:15:13] mdc only approves a handful Of these every single year and

[2:15:14] mdc only approves a handful Of these every single year and They are subject to geographic

[2:15:14] of these every single year and They are subject to geographic

[2:15:14] of these every single year and They are subject to geographic And city size distribution.

[2:15:17] they are subject to geographic And city size distribution.

[2:15:17] they are subject to geographic And city size distribution. Um, so like only certain ones

[2:15:21] and city size distribution. Um, so like only certain ones

[2:15:21] and city size distribution. Um, so like only certain ones In our area and only certain

[2:15:21] um, so like only certain ones In our area and only certain

[2:15:21] um, so like only certain ones In our area and only certain Ones for cities of our size for

[2:15:25] in our area and only certain Ones for cities of our size for

[2:15:25] in our area and only certain Ones for cities of our size for Preference in ann arbor the

[2:15:25] ones for cities of our size for Preference in ann arbor the

[2:15:25] ones for cities of our size for Preference in ann arbor the Project needs to be at least

[2:15:29] preference in ann arbor the Project needs to be at least

[2:15:29] preference in ann arbor the Project needs to be at least Seventy five million dollars if

[2:15:30] project needs to be at least Seventy five million dollars if

[2:15:30] project needs to be at least Seventy five million dollars if They were doing it in detroit

[2:15:32] seventy five million dollars if They were doing it in detroit

[2:15:32] seventy five million dollars if They were doing it in detroit They would need to be five

[2:15:33] they were doing it in detroit They would need to be five

[2:15:33] they were doing it in detroit They would need to be five Hundred million dollars to to

[2:15:34] they would need to be five Hundred million dollars to to

[2:15:34] they would need to be five Hundred million dollars to to Qualify for this.

[2:15:36] hundred million dollars to to Qualify for this.

[2:15:36] hundred million dollars to to Qualify for this. So it's not a tool that we can

[2:15:37] qualify for this. So it's not a tool that we can

[2:15:37] qualify for this. So it's not a tool that we can Use frequently.

[2:15:38] so it's not a tool that we can Use frequently.

[2:15:38] so it's not a tool that we can Use frequently. It does exist.

[2:15:40] use frequently. It does exist.

[2:15:40] use frequently. It does exist. There are probably some other

[2:15:41] it does exist. There are probably some other

[2:15:41] it does exist. There are probably some other Ones you know that may come

[2:15:44] there are probably some other Ones you know that may come

[2:15:44] there are probably some other Ones you know that may come Down the pipeline that might be

[2:15:45] ones you know that may come Down the pipeline that might be

[2:15:45] ones you know that may come Down the pipeline that might be A good fit for this but it's

[2:15:46] down the pipeline that might be A good fit for this but it's

[2:15:46] down the pipeline that might be A good fit for this but it's Just a good tool that can

[2:15:48] a good fit for this but it's Just a good tool that can

[2:15:48] a good fit for this but it's Just a good tool that can Really help with some of these

[2:15:49] just a good tool that can Really help with some of these

[2:15:49] just a good tool that can Really help with some of these More challenging projects to

[2:15:50] really help with some of these More challenging projects to

[2:15:50] really help with some of these More challenging projects to Help close financial gaps.

[2:15:51] more challenging projects to Help close financial gaps.

[2:15:52] more challenging projects to Help close financial gaps. Um, the development team is

[2:15:53] help close financial gaps. Um, the development team is

[2:15:53] help close financial gaps. Um, the development team is Here.

[2:15:55] um, the development team is Here.

[2:15:55] um, the development team is Here. >> john hall is here and we

[2:15:56] here. >> john hall is here and we

[2:15:57] here. >> john hall is here and we Would be happy to answer any

[2:15:57] » john hall is here and we Would be happy to answer any

[2:15:57] » john hall is here and we Would be happy to answer any Of the questions that you have

[2:15:58] would be happy to answer any Of the questions that you have

[2:15:58] would be happy to answer any Of the questions that you have About thank you.

[2:16:00] of the questions that you have About thank you.

[2:16:00] of the questions that you have About thank you. Thank you for the discussion.

[2:16:05] about thank you. Thank you for the discussion.

[2:16:05] about thank you. Thank you for the discussion. Kasavubu.

[2:16:09] thank you for the discussion. Kasavubu.

[2:16:09] thank you for the discussion. Kasavubu. I just can't wait to vote yes

[2:16:10] kasavubu. I just can't wait to vote yes

[2:16:11] kasavubu. I just can't wait to vote yes On this tonight.

[2:16:11] I just can't wait to vote yes On this tonight.

[2:16:11] I just can't wait to vote yes On this tonight. I can think of no better

[2:16:14] on this tonight. I can think of no better

[2:16:14] on this tonight. I can think of no better Project to be our first

[2:16:14] I can think of no better Project to be our first

[2:16:14] I can think of no better Project to be our first Transformational brownfield

[2:16:15] project to be our first Transformational brownfield

[2:16:15] project to be our first Transformational brownfield Project welfare oppose it is

[2:16:25] transformational brownfield Project welfare oppose it is

[2:16:25] transformational brownfield Project welfare oppose it is Approved.

[2:16:27] project welfare oppose it is Approved.

[2:16:27] project welfare oppose it is Approved. >> do we have the sorry

[2:16:34] approved. >> do we have the sorry

[2:16:34] approved. >> do we have the sorry Resolution authorizing

[2:16:35] » do we have the sorry Resolution authorizing

[2:16:35] » do we have the sorry Resolution authorizing Publication of notice of intent

[2:16:35] resolution authorizing Publication of notice of intent

[2:16:36] resolution authorizing Publication of notice of intent To issue capital improvement

[2:16:38] publication of notice of intent To issue capital improvement

[2:16:39] publication of notice of intent To issue capital improvement Bonds to fund a portion of the

[2:16:39] to issue capital improvement Bonds to fund a portion of the

[2:16:40] to issue capital improvement Bonds to fund a portion of the Development of 350 south fifth

[2:16:42] bonds to fund a portion of the Development of 350 south fifth

[2:16:42] bonds to fund a portion of the Development of 350 south fifth Avenue as affordable housing

[2:16:42] development of 350 south fifth Avenue as affordable housing

[2:16:43] development of 350 south fifth Avenue as affordable housing Not housing not to exceed

[2:16:45] avenue as affordable housing Not housing not to exceed

[2:16:46] avenue as affordable housing Not housing not to exceed Thirty five million dollars

[2:16:46] not housing not to exceed Thirty five million dollars

[2:16:46] not housing not to exceed Thirty five million dollars Move by catherine burn now in

[2:16:50] thirty five million dollars Move by catherine burn now in

[2:16:50] thirty five million dollars Move by catherine burn now in Councilman had one discussion

[2:16:50] move by catherine burn now in Councilman had one discussion

[2:16:51] move by catherine burn now in Councilman had one discussion Piece of dc three on paper

[2:16:54] councilman had one discussion Piece of dc three on paper

[2:16:54] councilman had one discussion Piece of dc three on paper Opposed to the roll call so it

[2:16:57] piece of dc three on paper Opposed to the roll call so it

[2:16:57] piece of dc three on paper Opposed to the roll call so it Says thank you my apologies

[2:17:01] opposed to the roll call so it Says thank you my apologies

[2:17:02] opposed to the roll call so it Says thank you my apologies Roll call vote please start at

[2:17:02] says thank you my apologies Roll call vote please start at

[2:17:03] says thank you my apologies Roll call vote please start at Count number of denha council

[2:17:03] roll call vote please start at Count number of denha council

[2:17:03] roll call vote please start at Count number of denha council Member denha yes council

[2:17:05] count number of denha council Member denha yes council

[2:17:05] count number of denha council Member denha yes council Markazi edwyn yes mayor taylor

[2:17:06] member denha yes council Markazi edwyn yes mayor taylor

[2:17:06] member denha yes council Markazi edwyn yes mayor taylor Yes councilor er yes councilor

[2:17:09] markazi edwyn yes mayor taylor Yes councilor er yes councilor

[2:17:09] markazi edwyn yes mayor taylor Yes councilor er yes councilor Ackmann yes councilor briggs

[2:17:14] yes councilor er yes councilor Ackmann yes councilor briggs

[2:17:14] yes councilor er yes councilor Ackmann yes councilor briggs Yes.

[2:17:14] ackmann yes councilor briggs Yes.

[2:17:14] ackmann yes councilor briggs Yes. Councilor cornwall yes.

[2:17:15] yes. Councilor cornwall yes.

[2:17:15] yes. Councilor cornwall yes. Councilor dish yes.

[2:17:15] councilor cornwall yes. Councilor dish yes.

[2:17:15] councilor cornwall yes. Councilor dish yes. Councilor harrison yes.

[2:17:17] councilor dish yes. Councilor harrison yes.

[2:17:17] councilor dish yes. Councilor harrison yes. Customer watson yes.

[2:17:18] councilor harrison yes. Customer watson yes.

[2:17:18] councilor harrison yes. Customer watson yes. Customer malec yes.

[2:17:21] customer watson yes. Customer malec yes.

[2:17:21] customer watson yes. Customer malec yes. >> motion carries.

[2:17:21] customer malec yes. >> motion carries.

[2:17:22] customer malec yes. >> motion carries. Do you have the pleasure of the

[2:17:23] » motion carries. Do you have the pleasure of the

[2:17:23] » motion carries. Do you have the pleasure of the Concession today?

[2:17:25] do you have the pleasure of the Concession today?

[2:17:25] do you have the pleasure of the Concession today? Yes.

[2:17:25] concession today? Yes.

[2:17:25] concession today? Yes. Mayor taylor I would like to

[2:17:26] yes. Mayor taylor I would like to

[2:17:26] yes. Mayor taylor I would like to Request a closed session under

[2:17:29] mayor taylor I would like to Request a closed session under

[2:17:29] mayor taylor I would like to Request a closed session under Um fifteen point two six eight

[2:17:30] request a closed session under Um fifteen point two six eight

[2:17:30] request a closed session under Um fifteen point two six eight Section eight one eight to

[2:17:33] um fifteen point two six eight Section eight one eight to

[2:17:33] um fifteen point two six eight Section eight one eight to Consider the personal

[2:17:34] section eight one eight to Consider the personal

[2:17:34] section eight one eight to Consider the personal Evaluation of the city

[2:17:37] consider the personal Evaluation of the city

[2:17:37] consider the personal Evaluation of the city Administrator and also under

[2:17:38] evaluation of the city Administrator and also under

[2:17:38] evaluation of the city Administrator and also under Section eight one eight for

[2:17:41] administrator and also under Section eight one eight for

[2:17:41] administrator and also under Section eight one eight for Discussion of confidential and

[2:17:42] section eight one eight for Discussion of confidential and

[2:17:42] section eight one eight for Discussion of confidential and Privileged memo provided

[2:17:45] discussion of confidential and Privileged memo provided

[2:17:45] discussion of confidential and Privileged memo provided Counsel on friday, january

[2:17:46] privileged memo provided Counsel on friday, january

[2:17:46] privileged memo provided Counsel on friday, january 16th.

[2:17:46] counsel on friday, january 16th.

[2:17:46] counsel on friday, january 16th. Thank you please to go into

[2:17:49] 16th. Thank you please to go into

[2:17:49] 16th. Thank you please to go into Closed session on that basis

[2:17:49] thank you please to go into Closed session on that basis

[2:17:50] thank you please to go into Closed session on that basis Move by councilor what else can

[2:17:52] closed session on that basis Move by councilor what else can

[2:17:52] closed session on that basis Move by councilor what else can I count on drinks discussion

[2:17:56] move by councilor what else can I count on drinks discussion

[2:17:56] move by councilor what else can I count on drinks discussion Roll-call vote please.

[2:17:56] I count on drinks discussion Roll-call vote please.

[2:17:57] I count on drinks discussion Roll-call vote please. >> starting with counts number

[2:17:57] roll-call vote please. >> starting with counts number

[2:17:57] roll-call vote please. >> starting with counts number Denha denha yes.

[2:18:00] » starting with counts number Denha denha yes.

[2:18:00] » starting with counts number Denha denha yes. Customer zero yes.

[2:18:01] denha denha yes. Customer zero yes.

[2:18:01] denha denha yes. Customer zero yes. Mayor taylor yes mariah yes.

[2:18:04] customer zero yes. Mayor taylor yes mariah yes.

[2:18:04] customer zero yes. Mayor taylor yes mariah yes. Customer yes customer brigg's

[2:18:05] mayor taylor yes mariah yes. Customer yes customer brigg's

[2:18:05] mayor taylor yes mariah yes. Customer yes customer brigg's Accounts marcano yes.

[2:18:08] customer yes customer brigg's Accounts marcano yes.

[2:18:08] customer yes customer brigg's Accounts marcano yes. Customer dish yes customer

[2:18:09] accounts marcano yes. Customer dish yes customer

[2:18:09] accounts marcano yes. Customer dish yes customer Harrison yes.

[2:18:12] customer dish yes customer Harrison yes.

[2:18:12] customer dish yes customer Harrison yes. Customer watson yes.

[2:18:12] harrison yes. Customer watson yes.

[2:18:13] harrison yes. Customer watson yes. Customer yes john kerry we're

[2:18:15] customer watson yes. Customer yes john kerry we're

[2:18:15] customer watson yes. Customer yes john kerry we're In closed session

[3:37:31] open session

[3:37:34] open session

[3:37:34] open session D.c. For resolution to finalize

[3:37:38] open session D.c. For resolution to finalize

[3:37:38] open session D.c. For resolution to finalize The evaluation report and amend

[3:37:39] d.c. For resolution to finalize The evaluation report and amend

[3:37:39] d.c. For resolution to finalize The evaluation report and amend Employment agreement for the

[3:37:40] the evaluation report and amend Employment agreement for the

[3:37:40] the evaluation report and amend Employment agreement for the City administrator milton

[3:37:42] employment agreement for the City administrator milton

[3:37:42] employment agreement for the City administrator milton Tonier jr. Move by council

[3:37:43] city administrator milton Tonier jr. Move by council

[3:37:43] city administrator milton Tonier jr. Move by council Member piracicaba, a council

[3:37:43] tonier jr. Move by council Member piracicaba, a council

[3:37:43] tonier jr. Move by council Member piracicaba, a council Member denha discussion please

[3:37:46] member piracicaba, a council Member denha discussion please

[3:37:46] member piracicaba, a council Member denha discussion please Of d.c. For council members to

[3:37:49] member denha discussion please Of d.c. For council members to

[3:37:49] member denha discussion please Of d.c. For council members to Thank you, mayor.

[3:37:50] of d.c. For council members to Thank you, mayor.

[3:37:50] of d.c. For council members to Thank you, mayor. I'd move to amend the first

[3:37:51] thank you, mayor. I'd move to amend the first

[3:37:51] thank you, mayor. I'd move to amend the first Resolved clause to read one an

[3:37:54] I'd move to amend the first Resolved clause to read one an

[3:37:54] I'd move to amend the first Resolved clause to read one an Increase of twenty thousand

[3:37:58] resolved clause to read one an Increase of twenty thousand

[3:37:58] resolved clause to read one an Increase of twenty thousand Dollars to the city

[3:37:58] increase of twenty thousand Dollars to the city

[3:37:59] increase of twenty thousand Dollars to the city Administrator's annual salary

[3:37:59] dollars to the city Administrator's annual salary

[3:37:59] dollars to the city Administrator's annual salary Retroactive to an effective may

[3:38:01] administrator's annual salary Retroactive to an effective may

[3:38:01] administrator's annual salary Retroactive to an effective may 17th 20 25 as provided in

[3:38:02] retroactive to an effective may 17th 20 25 as provided in

[3:38:02] retroactive to an effective may 17th 20 25 as provided in Section three of the employment

[3:38:05] 17th 20 25 as provided in Section three of the employment

[3:38:05] 17th 20 25 as provided in Section three of the employment Agreement and to section three

[3:38:06] section three of the employment Agreement and to section three

[3:38:06] section three of the employment Agreement and to section three Of the agreement be amended to

[3:38:09] agreement and to section three Of the agreement be amended to

[3:38:09] agreement and to section three Of the agreement be amended to Also provide a one time lump

[3:38:10] of the agreement be amended to Also provide a one time lump

[3:38:10] of the agreement be amended to Also provide a one time lump Sum payment of three percent

[3:38:12] also provide a one time lump Sum payment of three percent

[3:38:13] also provide a one time lump Sum payment of three percent Of the city administrator's

[3:38:13] sum payment of three percent Of the city administrator's

[3:38:13] sum payment of three percent Of the city administrator's Current salary which amounts to

[3:38:14] of the city administrator's Current salary which amounts to

[3:38:14] of the city administrator's Current salary which amounts to Eighty four hundred dollars

[3:38:16] current salary which amounts to Eighty four hundred dollars

[3:38:16] current salary which amounts to Eighty four hundred dollars Seconded by council member ira

[3:38:17] eighty four hundred dollars Seconded by council member ira

[3:38:17] eighty four hundred dollars Seconded by council member ira Discussion the amendment or in

[3:38:20] seconded by council member ira Discussion the amendment or in

[3:38:20] seconded by council member ira Discussion the amendment or in Favor or opposed the amendment

[3:38:23] discussion the amendment or in Favor or opposed the amendment

[3:38:24] discussion the amendment or in Favor or opposed the amendment Approved discussion in the main

[3:38:24] favor or opposed the amendment Approved discussion in the main

[3:38:24] favor or opposed the amendment Approved discussion in the main Motion as amended I guess let

[3:38:25] approved discussion in the main Motion as amended I guess let

[3:38:25] approved discussion in the main Motion as amended I guess let Me let me get this party

[3:38:27] motion as amended I guess let Me let me get this party

[3:38:28] motion as amended I guess let Me let me get this party Started this contract before us

[3:38:32] me let me get this party Started this contract before us

[3:38:32] me let me get this party Started this contract before us Comes after the evaluation

[3:38:36] started this contract before us Comes after the evaluation

[3:38:36] started this contract before us Comes after the evaluation Of our city attorney milton

[3:38:36] comes after the evaluation Of our city attorney milton

[3:38:37] comes after the evaluation Of our city attorney milton Downey jr. Administrator what

[3:38:40] of our city attorney milton Downey jr. Administrator what

[3:38:40] of our city attorney milton Downey jr. Administrator what Did I say?

[3:38:40] downey jr. Administrator what Did I say?

[3:38:40] downey jr. Administrator what Did I say? >> oh goodness.

[3:38:43] did I say? >> oh goodness.

[3:38:43] did I say? >> oh goodness. You see, that's how highly I

[3:38:44] » oh goodness. You see, that's how highly I

[3:38:44] » oh goodness. You see, that's how highly I Think of him.

[3:38:47] you see, that's how highly I Think of him.

[3:38:47] you see, that's how highly I Think of him. Our city administrator milton

[3:38:51] think of him. Our city administrator milton

[3:38:51] think of him. Our city administrator milton Downey jr. And I mean for me

[3:38:54] our city administrator milton Downey jr. And I mean for me

[3:38:55] our city administrator milton Downey jr. And I mean for me The notion of evaluating mr.

[3:38:58] downey jr. And I mean for me The notion of evaluating mr.

[3:38:58] downey jr. And I mean for me The notion of evaluating mr. Tony is somewhat like, you

[3:38:59] the notion of evaluating mr. Tony is somewhat like, you

[3:38:59] the notion of evaluating mr. Tony is somewhat like, you Know, we have we often think,

[3:39:02] tony is somewhat like, you Know, we have we often think,

[3:39:03] tony is somewhat like, you Know, we have we often think, You know, in our in our you

[3:39:06] know, we have we often think, You know, in our in our you

[3:39:06] know, we have we often think, You know, in our in our you Know, our private hearts that

[3:39:07] you know, in our in our you Know, our private hearts that

[3:39:07] you know, in our in our you Know, our private hearts that We are unworthy of the task

[3:39:08] know, our private hearts that We are unworthy of the task

[3:39:08] know, our private hearts that We are unworthy of the task Before and evaluating mr. De

[3:39:10] we are unworthy of the task Before and evaluating mr. De

[3:39:10] we are unworthy of the task Before and evaluating mr. De Hony on the work that he does

[3:39:11] before and evaluating mr. De Hony on the work that he does

[3:39:11] before and evaluating mr. De Hony on the work that he does Here at the city is one

[3:39:15] hony on the work that he does Here at the city is one

[3:39:15] hony on the work that he does Here at the city is one Of those times you know, we are

[3:39:18] here at the city is one Of those times you know, we are

[3:39:18] here at the city is one Of those times you know, we are Just so incredibly fortunate to

[3:39:19] of those times you know, we are Just so incredibly fortunate to

[3:39:19] of those times you know, we are Just so incredibly fortunate to Have the gentleman and I use

[3:39:22] just so incredibly fortunate to Have the gentleman and I use

[3:39:22] just so incredibly fortunate to Have the gentleman and I use That term in all of its senses

[3:39:25] have the gentleman and I use That term in all of its senses

[3:39:25] have the gentleman and I use That term in all of its senses Working for the city of ann

[3:39:26] that term in all of its senses Working for the city of ann

[3:39:26] that term in all of its senses Working for the city of ann Arbor, working for the

[3:39:26] working for the city of ann Arbor, working for the

[3:39:26] working for the city of ann Arbor, working for the Community of ann arbor, working

[3:39:29] arbor, working for the Community of ann arbor, working

[3:39:30] arbor, working for the Community of ann arbor, working For the employees of the

[3:39:30] community of ann arbor, working For the employees of the

[3:39:30] community of ann arbor, working For the employees of the Municipal organization with the

[3:39:33] for the employees of the Municipal organization with the

[3:39:33] for the employees of the Municipal organization with the Skill expertize character and

[3:39:37] municipal organization with the Skill expertize character and

[3:39:37] municipal organization with the Skill expertize character and Any other good thing you can

[3:39:38] skill expertize character and Any other good thing you can

[3:39:38] skill expertize character and Any other good thing you can Think of like mr. Tony, it was

[3:39:45] any other good thing you can Think of like mr. Tony, it was

[3:39:45] any other good thing you can Think of like mr. Tony, it was It was a great and glorious day

[3:39:46] think of like mr. Tony, it was It was a great and glorious day

[3:39:46] think of like mr. Tony, it was It was a great and glorious day When when he decided to come

[3:39:49] it was a great and glorious day When when he decided to come

[3:39:49] it was a great and glorious day When when he decided to come Join us we were wise to bring

[3:39:49] when when he decided to come Join us we were wise to bring

[3:39:50] when when he decided to come Join us we were wise to bring Him aboard and I just am so

[3:39:53] join us we were wise to bring Him aboard and I just am so

[3:39:53] join us we were wise to bring Him aboard and I just am so Pleased and proud of the work

[3:39:56] him aboard and I just am so Pleased and proud of the work

[3:39:56] him aboard and I just am so Pleased and proud of the work That he does for us and and

[3:39:57] pleased and proud of the work That he does for us and and

[3:39:57] pleased and proud of the work That he does for us and and Just feel blessed every day.

[3:40:01] that he does for us and and Just feel blessed every day.

[3:40:01] that he does for us and and Just feel blessed every day. So that's what I think.

[3:40:03] just feel blessed every day. So that's what I think.

[3:40:03] just feel blessed every day. So that's what I think. Thank you for the discussion.

[3:40:07] so that's what I think. Thank you for the discussion.

[3:40:07] so that's what I think. Thank you for the discussion. My year.

[3:40:15] thank you for the discussion. My year.

[3:40:15] thank you for the discussion. My year. >> I just want to chime in and

[3:40:16] my year. >> I just want to chime in and

[3:40:16] my year. >> I just want to chime in and I'll be brief but one of the

[3:40:18] » I just want to chime in and I'll be brief but one of the

[3:40:18] » I just want to chime in and I'll be brief but one of the Things that we've seen over the

[3:40:19] I'll be brief but one of the Things that we've seen over the

[3:40:19] I'll be brief but one of the Things that we've seen over the Past year is our city staff

[3:40:22] things that we've seen over the Past year is our city staff

[3:40:23] things that we've seen over the Past year is our city staff Filling out with a number

[3:40:26] past year is our city staff Filling out with a number

[3:40:26] past year is our city staff Filling out with a number Of really important new hires

[3:40:27] filling out with a number Of really important new hires

[3:40:27] filling out with a number Of really important new hires And department heads.

[3:40:30] of really important new hires And department heads.

[3:40:30] of really important new hires And department heads. These were key positions.

[3:40:34] and department heads. These were key positions.

[3:40:34] and department heads. These were key positions. Some were open for some time

[3:40:35] these were key positions. Some were open for some time

[3:40:35] these were key positions. Some were open for some time And it was really administrator

[3:40:39] some were open for some time And it was really administrator

[3:40:39] some were open for some time And it was really administrator Tony reputation among municipal

[3:40:45] and it was really administrator Tony reputation among municipal

[3:40:45] and it was really administrator Tony reputation among municipal Management in this country that

[3:40:49] tony reputation among municipal Management in this country that

[3:40:49] tony reputation among municipal Management in this country that Brought some of those folks

[3:40:50] management in this country that Brought some of those folks

[3:40:50] management in this country that Brought some of those folks Here really high level great

[3:40:51] brought some of those folks Here really high level great

[3:40:51] brought some of those folks Here really high level great New hires.

[3:40:53] here really high level great New hires.

[3:40:53] here really high level great New hires. And so thank you very much for

[3:40:54] new hires. And so thank you very much for

[3:40:55] new hires. And so thank you very much for Your work in not just, you

[3:40:58] and so thank you very much for Your work in not just, you

[3:40:58] and so thank you very much for Your work in not just, you Know, doing the work and

[3:40:59] your work in not just, you Know, doing the work and

[3:40:59] your work in not just, you Know, doing the work and Leading a staff that we have

[3:41:02] know, doing the work and Leading a staff that we have

[3:41:02] know, doing the work and Leading a staff that we have But really building it for the

[3:41:03] leading a staff that we have But really building it for the

[3:41:03] leading a staff that we have But really building it for the Future and putting very key

[3:41:06] but really building it for the Future and putting very key

[3:41:06] but really building it for the Future and putting very key People in place.

[3:41:06] future and putting very key People in place.

[3:41:06] future and putting very key People in place. And I'm excited to see this

[3:41:08] people in place. And I'm excited to see this

[3:41:08] people in place. And I'm excited to see this Leadership team gel and see

[3:41:09] and I'm excited to see this Leadership team gel and see

[3:41:09] and I'm excited to see this Leadership team gel and see Where you're going to take it

[3:41:10] leadership team gel and see Where you're going to take it

[3:41:10] leadership team gel and see Where you're going to take it In the future.

[3:41:12] where you're going to take it In the future.

[3:41:13] where you're going to take it In the future. Further discussion or favor or

[3:41:17] in the future. Further discussion or favor or

[3:41:17] in the future. Further discussion or favor or Opposed it is approved and let

[3:41:21] further discussion or favor or Opposed it is approved and let

[3:41:21] further discussion or favor or Opposed it is approved and let The record show that it's

[3:41:24] opposed it is approved and let The record show that it's

[3:41:24] opposed it is approved and let The record show that it's Unanimous we'll be council

[3:41:25] the record show that it's Unanimous we'll be council

[3:41:25] the record show that it's Unanimous we'll be council Members present.

[3:41:25] unanimous we'll be council Members present.

[3:41:26] unanimous we'll be council Members present. >> we have before us the

[3:41:28] members present. >> we have before us the

[3:41:28] members present. >> we have before us the Support of communications

[3:41:28] » we have before us the Support of communications

[3:41:28] » we have before us the Support of communications Petitions and referrals can

[3:41:29] support of communications Petitions and referrals can

[3:41:29] support of communications Petitions and referrals can Have a motion please to approve

[3:41:30] petitions and referrals can Have a motion please to approve

[3:41:30] petitions and referrals can Have a motion please to approve The clerk's support move I

[3:41:31] have a motion please to approve The clerk's support move I

[3:41:32] have a motion please to approve The clerk's support move I Can't speak spare now second by

[3:41:32] the clerk's support move I Can't speak spare now second by

[3:41:32] the clerk's support move I Can't speak spare now second by Council member denha discussion

[3:41:33] can't speak spare now second by Council member denha discussion

[3:41:33] can't speak spare now second by Council member denha discussion On favor post is approved.

[3:41:36] council member denha discussion On favor post is approved.

[3:41:36] council member denha discussion On favor post is approved. We have communications today

[3:41:37] on favor post is approved. We have communications today

[3:41:37] on favor post is approved. We have communications today For her indomitable city

[3:41:40] we have communications today For her indomitable city

[3:41:40] we have communications today For her indomitable city Attorney.

[3:41:40] for her indomitable city Attorney.

[3:41:40] for her indomitable city Attorney. No thank you ma'am.

[3:41:41] attorney. No thank you ma'am.

[3:41:41] attorney. No thank you ma'am. In the absence of public

[3:41:41] no thank you ma'am. In the absence of public

[3:41:41] no thank you ma'am. In the absence of public Comment overflow mayor a motion

[3:41:44] in the absence of public Comment overflow mayor a motion

[3:41:44] in the absence of public Comment overflow mayor a motion To adjourn please move by

[3:41:44] comment overflow mayor a motion To adjourn please move by

[3:41:44] comment overflow mayor a motion To adjourn please move by Councilman mcconnell second by

[3:41:45] to adjourn please move by Councilman mcconnell second by

[3:41:45] to adjourn please move by Councilman mcconnell second by Councilman briggs discussion on

[3:41:47] councilman mcconnell second by Councilman briggs discussion on

[3:41:47] councilman mcconnell second by Councilman briggs discussion on Favor posed.

[3:41:48] councilman briggs discussion on Favor posed.

[3:41:48] councilman briggs discussion on Favor posed. >> we're adjourned

Ann Arbor City Council Meeting 1/20/26

Agenda

Transcript