Agenda
Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
[0:08]
Good evening. Welcome to the
[0:11]
Ant-Man Finance Committee
[0:12]
meeting. Start the meeting
[0:12]
with their introductions to my
[0:15]
left. Thank you, MR. CHAIRMAN
[0:19]
Mike Deal District 20 forward.
[0:20]
Thank you, MR. Chaired Brian
[0:22]
Maori district. 25 thank you
[0:23]
to write. Thank you, MR. Allen
[0:26]
District, 15 party set. Thank
[0:28]
you, MR. Chaired Nic Robertson
[0:30]
strict for good evening.
[0:30]
CHAIRMAN Miscarry Crystal
[0:32]
Wells District 11, far West
[0:36]
Side. Good evening. Maggie
[0:38]
Frank miscarriages streak 19
[0:41]
MR. Cahill, you so thank you.
[0:43]
MR. Chaired their Cayo
[0:45]
District. 23. All right. Thank
[0:46]
you. We have 3 proposals for
[0:51]
budget hearings. Up first is
[0:53]
propose a proposal to 44, I
[0:54]
understand all these proposals
[0:55]
are you gonna bring together
[0:58]
all at once? Yes, need to vote
[1:04]
for one the time or Proposal
[1:08]
to 44 45 46. Going all Mizzou
[1:13]
break in between them. Too
[1:14]
fat. This is a little
[1:18]
confusing, but going resent to
[1:22]
44 into 46 because required
[1:24]
public and then several a
[1:26]
scarily, there's amendment to
[1:29]
45 45? So after that, we get
[1:29]
in the that became so we have
[1:34]
the floor, sir. Thank you,
[1:34]
CHAIRMAN. Scary. And that was
[1:35]
the committee. My name is Joe
[1:36]
Bast and the executive
[1:37]
director and general counsel
[1:41]
of the Indianapolis 5 And we
[1:45]
have 3 proposals for you to
[1:47]
property tax general
[1:48]
obligations, Bonds and the
[1:49]
other is facility revenues by
[1:53]
a proposal to 44, will be an
[1:55]
issue metric wasn't there
[1:57]
district. And as for a maximum
[2:00]
out of 50 million dollars for
[2:01]
construction of a operations
[2:03]
graduating bw their current
[2:04]
site. And as JUNE, 35, South
[2:08]
West Street. And then moving
[2:09]
proposal to 46 that will be a
[2:11]
general obligation, bond
[2:13]
issuance of the consolidated
[2:16]
city taxing x amount of 12.5
[2:17]
million dollars with the
[2:17]
construction of a new impd
[2:20]
North District station and
[2:24]
then finally present to 45. I
[2:25]
would approve the issuance of
[2:27]
up to 35 million dollars of
[2:29]
facility, revenue bonds to
[2:32]
financing for and 2 parking
[2:32]
garages as well as a
[2:33]
pedestrian bridge at the
[2:39]
community. Justice campus.
[2:41]
Proposal to 44, like I said,
[2:43]
is for a operations garage the
[2:47]
current to w campus south of
[2:48]
downtown just east of the
[2:52]
river this would be maxed out
[2:55]
of 50 million dollars. Max
[2:57]
interest rate of 6.5% and a
[3:02]
term not to exceed 20 years.
[3:03]
This would allow dpw
[3:04]
consolidate a lot of disparate
[3:04]
facilities they have currently
[3:09]
on that campus streamline
[3:13]
operations and allow for
[3:13]
improved storage maintenance
[3:19]
of street. So here you see
[3:23]
their current garages many are
[3:25]
day there gathered campus. And
[3:27]
so this would allow. And this
[3:31]
new graduate streamlined lot
[3:38]
of operations operations. Have
[3:43]
issuers required to do by the
[3:45]
deals you have, which is to
[3:47]
the projected changes in levy
[3:50]
and a tax rate for the taxing
[3:51]
district here. The taxing
[3:51]
district that's there for
[3:55]
district. These are very
[3:59]
conservative projections and
[4:01]
increase in tax rate would be
[4:07]
offset because decreases other
[4:15]
taxing districts of the city.
[4:17]
Goes to 46, other general
[4:17]
obligation bond. This would
[4:19]
the single city taxing
[4:23]
district maximum out of 12.5
[4:25]
million dollars, as you to see
[4:26]
6.5%, maximum term of 20
[4:30]
years, this would be it for
[4:31]
North District police station
[4:32]
at this would be located at
[4:36]
38th and Sherman Avenue. It
[4:38]
would create need to be in the
[4:42]
space that improved space for
[4:42]
visitors and employees of the
[4:48]
game. North District. Here
[4:54]
again are we checked? Id have
[4:55]
next changes to Levy and tax
[4:56]
rate of the civil city back to
[5:05]
district. So we will be these
[5:09]
2 together. With one that
[5:12]
fight as a team and usually
[5:12]
the binding of the have the
[5:14]
city Minneapolis, our
[5:18]
financial advisors more
[5:19]
advisors, words and numbers
[5:19]
are about council we have yet
[5:20]
to reach data and ready for
[5:30]
this transaction. So obviously
[5:31]
tonight where beforehand and
[5:32]
finance, we have 2 additional
[5:32]
hearings before the Board of
[5:36]
Public Works in AUGUST and
[5:37]
SEPTEMBER. Plan to go before
[5:41]
the full council in SEPTEMBER,
[5:42]
but make approval OCTOBER and
[5:43]
pressing closing by the end of
[5:48]
the year. And answer, any
[5:51]
questions about rules? To 44
[5:56]
into 4.46, thank I'm curious
[5:57]
to what kind of bond are we in
[6:00]
right now? The whole city. Was
[6:03]
a number. You have it. Don't
[6:07]
have it up and I I any other
[6:08]
quick, any questions council
[6:10]
moves. Thank you, MISTER
[6:14]
CHAIRMAN. Apologize for
[6:17]
following CHAIRMAN Kerry's
[6:19]
question. What aside from the
[6:20]
number was a capacity that's
[6:27]
left a bond for 26. So So will
[6:28]
be different each test. Taxing
[6:33]
district. The city. We We just
[6:34]
recently for the there there
[6:38]
registered PRESIDENT You know,
[6:39]
part of we reasoned that we
[6:41]
maintain our credit ratings.
[6:43]
Is that we do next or capacity
[6:49]
that we hear him. It alleges
[6:50]
that so I can find out
[6:50]
specifically what you know,
[6:55]
how much lead we and that's
[6:55]
what But we're we're not
[6:58]
approaches that. You're to be
[6:59]
helpful how many texting used
[7:04]
to get across the county?
[7:07]
Thanks. Thank you. Any other
[7:10]
questions or counselors? You
[7:12]
know, this is a public
[7:13]
hearings as anyone from
[7:13]
audience would like to speak
[7:18]
on this. Seeing entertain a
[7:23]
motion. Moved. All those in
[7:30]
favor say Aye. The question.
[7:33]
We're going to that separately
[7:35]
to 44, sorry, to 45
[7:39]
separately. It's so good. So
[7:40]
For a clear need to do. Just
[7:48]
go down. 44 46. We did 44 46.
[7:50]
All MR. Improved now. Class
[7:58]
going to 45. All right. Listen
[8:00]
to 45 would just a little
[8:01]
revenue bond issuance accident
[8:02]
out 35 million dollars to
[8:06]
refund interim financing,
[8:06]
construction of 2 parking
[8:07]
garages. I'm thinking, this
[8:14]
campus. And history with that
[8:15]
6.5 that actually bending the
[8:18]
amendment and come before the
[8:20]
council the source and is all
[8:23]
the revenue the city.
[8:30]
So it's a part of that. The
[8:31]
cdc projects at the city
[8:34]
worked Garmin bmo to Design
[8:35]
and Finance the construction
[8:36]
of these 2 parking garages and
[8:40]
a pedestrian bridge. There is
[8:41]
one that is just for staff of
[8:43]
Erie County courts then a
[8:46]
special office building
[8:48]
garage, is a part the for the
[8:49]
public Defender, probation
[8:50]
staff and also offers a
[8:54]
painful with parking. So bill
[8:55]
that for a transfer agreement
[8:57]
was approved by public health
[9:04]
and safety back in Issued
[9:04]
competitive bidding process.
[9:07]
And Carmen was ultimately
[9:09]
selected and we're coming
[9:09]
towards the end of five-year
[9:10]
buildup for a transfer
[9:17]
agreement term. As the
[9:18]
financing team. Here is divine
[9:19]
day. Have to sit in app lists
[9:20]
as again seeing more advisors
[9:22]
is our financial advisor and
[9:25]
of those became Evans as Bond
[9:26]
Council. And we get to and
[9:32]
right after this transaction.
[9:33]
Fewer steps for this one will
[9:36]
go before the full council 2
[9:37]
and SEPTEMBER the final
[9:39]
approval for the van board in
[9:40]
OCTOBER and then pressing
[9:44]
closing end of the year. Thank
[9:45]
you. I think we have an
[9:46]
amendment to this. MR.
[9:48]
CHAIRMAN.
[9:54]
MR. CHAIRMAN, I move to amend
[9:56]
Section one, paragraph c a
[9:59]
proposal. Number 2, 45 2026?
[10:00]
By deleting the language that
[10:00]
is stricken through and adding
[10:02]
the underline language change
[10:05]
in the not to exceed initial
[10:06]
interest rate from 5.5% to
[10:10]
6.5% To read has fallen. And
[10:11]
you can see strict corrected
[10:17]
and section one, infection. I
[10:19]
vote on the amendment only
[10:20]
follows favor of the the
[10:23]
moment an amendment say aye.
[10:26]
Oppose none. All right. Any
[10:29]
questions on proposal itself.
[10:33]
Cancer k a we thank Mister
[10:35]
Chair this this question sort
[10:38]
of applies to both sets of
[10:42]
proposals here. But we have a
[10:46]
discussion last week about the
[10:49]
building authority and in
[10:50]
particular, the cjc and I and
[10:51]
I don't know that you're the
[10:52]
right person, but I don't know
[10:53]
if you know the answer. So
[10:57]
there's 2 questions here. My
[10:58]
my presumption is we is the
[11:02]
counselor dealing with this
[11:04]
where if this garage was
[11:05]
building authority building,
[11:06]
they would just they still
[11:11]
have access to. But think but
[11:12]
they would do without our vote
[11:12]
that it would just pass
[11:13]
through is that is that your
[11:15]
understanding? Don't vote on
[11:24]
their bones. Cause of that.
[11:25]
I've been firmly within. 75
[11:27]
bank have no revenue bonds,
[11:31]
which that. The buildings part
[11:36]
that and all those also gone
[11:36]
through the lessee, which
[11:38]
would be that the the other
[11:43]
question to you. Why is why is
[11:46]
the garage to the cjc? Is
[11:49]
under the bill a 40 foot, the
[11:49]
parking garages or not. You
[11:52]
have any understanding of why
[11:53]
that is the previous thing
[11:55]
mention that we heard there
[11:56]
was some agreement with Dennis
[11:58]
and operate. But I guess that
[12:00]
doesn't make any sense to me
[12:01]
because that was an operate,
[12:05]
the garage and the city County
[12:05]
goalie edits ability
[12:08]
rebuilding And why we have
[12:09]
retained ownership of the
[12:14]
garage has been part of. The
[12:15]
cjc itself. I can't speak to
[12:20]
that. I was around when they
[12:22]
were deciding, you exactly
[12:25]
this works, that the cdc was
[12:33]
lance We're going tax bonds.
[12:35]
Structure payment had to be
[12:36]
structured lease payments from
[12:38]
the city to to the building
[12:38]
authority. This is being
[12:42]
financed through. You know,
[12:43]
different a different
[12:46]
mechanism. I don't know. So
[12:52]
just just in terms you know,
[12:53]
and how they with the finance.
[12:54]
And that's, you but not sure
[12:56]
exactly. Why that was decided
[12:58]
at that time. Okay. There's
[12:59]
nothing here. That's for
[13:03]
That's as we could
[13:03]
theoretically move garages
[13:05]
under the building authority.
[13:07]
So the cjc was one. A
[13:09]
comprehensive campus cause. A
[13:11]
much behind and nothing not
[13:15]
that I could envision Doing
[13:16]
anything about But like, don't
[13:17]
know how you release break
[13:22]
apart. The parking right. Like
[13:23]
it's it's for whatever reason
[13:24]
we decided to divest of the
[13:25]
cjc. It wouldn't have the
[13:28]
value. Without the parking
[13:33]
vice versa. Read that the big
[13:36]
the bigger parking garage it's
[13:38]
connected to the rest of
[13:41]
building, which don't think is
[13:42]
owned by by the building
[13:45]
That's like privately owned
[13:51]
building. So really the only.
[13:54]
City-owned portion would be
[13:55]
it's relatively small garage
[13:59]
for the judges and All right.
[14:00]
Thank Any other question,
[14:03]
counselors? I have a question.
[14:05]
My question is a you on just
[14:11]
300. And the other. 1000 and
[14:12]
these for the general public
[14:12]
losing to use these parking
[14:20]
spots. So the public out he's
[14:20]
going right and has bases
[14:21]
space is available to general
[14:26]
public. Other spaces reserved
[14:28]
information public defender.
[14:31]
Staff and then the smaller
[14:32]
garage is is just for judicial
[14:36]
staff. I mean, right now
[14:37]
there's most of the there's
[14:39]
free this month, small area
[14:43]
for, but you can pay its
[14:45]
probably only 300 parking
[14:47]
spots. Now and brunt of the
[14:48]
parking is free. So is will be
[14:49]
charge of this is going to be
[14:57]
free for the public. I don't
[14:59]
that I know that the money
[14:59]
that we're making on private
[15:02]
office building is that in
[15:04]
word is going top of that. And
[15:07]
so I don't know. Would have to
[15:09]
leave it to the controller's
[15:10]
office. You need to speak to
[15:10]
training is an answer on pre.
[15:13]
She ate it. Any other
[15:17]
questions. Any one of general
[15:23]
public speak on to 45? Seeing
[15:25]
entertain a motion. So moved
[15:28]
if moving second. All those in
[15:34]
favor say Aye. Opposed last
[15:36]
You're off off the hot seat If
[15:37]
you would try to get some
[15:38]
answers on some of So let's go
[15:39]
to the full council. Thank
[15:44]
you. Up next is a Marion
[15:48]
County treasurer's office.
[16:21]
You have a form. It takes to
[16:22]
MR. CHAIRMAN committee, my
[16:25]
name this spiral and I am to
[16:27]
serve Marion County,
[16:30]
Treasurer. I'm joined here.
[16:31]
That's thing. But wish I the
[16:34]
fire deputy and I'm going to
[16:38]
begin with an I'm having a
[16:39]
really had today. So if you to
[16:41]
clarify or slow whatever, just
[16:47]
let me just give me side. We
[16:50]
going to present at 2027
[16:50]
budget. And I have just going
[16:55]
to jump right into The first
[16:58]
flight you will see is in for
[16:59]
a town of the 40 patients with
[17:02]
The Perry County Treasurer's
[17:03]
Office. It's the
[17:03]
administrative decision.
[17:07]
County finance division
[17:07]
division and the customer
[17:11]
service to Michigan. We are
[17:14]
very proud of some of our
[17:15]
agency staffing numbers today.
[17:19]
We have 25 fill positions with
[17:20]
2 vacancies. 4 of the 8
[17:24]
managers are female one point
[17:27]
that we are really proud of is
[17:29]
that the average tenure for
[17:31]
the office for our employees.
[17:35]
It's 7.2 years with 76% of the
[17:39]
folks there think more and
[17:43]
that ever happening at least 3
[17:49]
years. It is a where education
[17:50]
experience is very So we're
[17:51]
especially proud of that. You
[17:55]
want to keep. He said a We
[17:56]
also have focus on changing
[17:57]
with Association of India.
[17:59]
They can't make these and the
[18:02]
National Association of
[18:06]
counties, Indiana County
[18:08]
Treasurer's Association and
[18:10]
and I won't go down that every
[18:12]
minute in the U.S. Senate to
[18:17]
give feel of what chart like.
[18:17]
The pink decisions or managers
[18:21]
stay consistent yeah, happy to
[18:24]
take any questions on anything
[18:32]
I'm going throw it over Gary
[18:35]
ca internal breakdown gender
[18:36]
staffing. Also know is that
[18:36]
the employee level of the
[18:39]
management levels a little
[18:40]
different this report. We
[18:43]
we've had additional higher
[18:46]
and the bucket that hr uses.
[18:46]
They include our financial
[18:49]
analysts part of staff. So
[18:49]
when it comes to gender, we
[18:55]
have 67% female. 33% male. And
[18:56]
when it comes to management on
[18:58]
on their internal breakdowns.
[19:01]
55 45. I also like to
[19:03]
highlight our racial breakdown
[19:04]
when when it comes to
[19:06]
especially Hispanic the
[19:07]
nation. We're higher than the
[19:09]
all city county average. And
[19:12]
you can see the next column
[19:12]
where says manager by
[19:13]
ethnicity, what we're really
[19:16]
proud of is. All the 5
[19:17]
categories. We have at least
[19:18]
one manager when it comes
[19:19]
multi racial, Hispanic, Asian,
[19:24]
white black. A few numbers to
[19:28]
help you understand treasures.
[19:34]
Tough We 356,000 parcels for
[19:37]
2025. We collected in 2025.
[19:40]
About 1.8 billion dollars
[19:45]
pretty taxes and all revenues
[19:46]
we invest and the average
[19:49]
monthly balance of 466 million
[19:52]
dollars. And we distribute to
[19:53]
a 2.7 billion to about 48
[20:00]
units of When talk a little
[20:02]
bit about some and
[20:03]
improvements that we've made
[20:07]
in the treasurer's I have to
[20:08]
announce that we had to
[20:13]
performance metrics for 2020
[20:16]
set. So we're on our to been
[20:22]
for 2025. Another point that
[20:23]
very proud of this said in the
[20:27]
recently completed culture is
[20:28]
a The Marion County
[20:29]
Treasurer's Office had a score
[20:34]
of 95%, which tells me that
[20:35]
hopefully the team doing
[20:35]
something right. People are
[20:39]
enjoying working there. They
[20:39]
feel were aboard they feel
[20:42]
like they're appreciated. And
[20:48]
we're very proud After 20
[20:49]
years with the same vendor, we
[20:52]
have branched out and we are
[20:54]
going through. We have
[20:55]
completed the process we're
[20:59]
going through conversion to a
[21:02]
tax software and on stuff
[21:04]
which is with backs off. That
[21:05]
was probably that year in the
[21:09]
making. And something new and
[21:11]
different way this year. We
[21:14]
set out about 7500 courtesy
[21:16]
letters and that is for
[21:18]
letters that went out to
[21:20]
people complain cuenta their
[21:21]
fall taxes. We sent the
[21:24]
letters found in JANUARY and
[21:26]
what we were hoping we would
[21:30]
is get people to bring my so
[21:32]
it gives us more of a chance
[21:33]
to invest that they didn't get
[21:38]
the money and center. Cost
[21:39]
about 7500 use a dollar. A
[21:44]
letter as a ballpark and of
[21:48]
MARCH 31st, it received can.
[21:49]
Now some people will say,
[21:51]
well, that's money. We can't
[21:52]
any way. Yes, that's true. But
[21:56]
we got it done which is which
[22:01]
is the key point here. We
[22:02]
established as part of the new
[22:03]
fund system, a new call center
[22:07]
solution, which is made our
[22:08]
life so much easier in terms
[22:11]
of the phone providing
[22:12]
customer service and also it
[22:15]
enables us to look at metrics
[22:17]
about the calls are being
[22:18]
answered. How long it's
[22:22]
taking. Calls are dropped. The
[22:23]
important stuff to provide
[22:26]
customer service. And the
[22:33]
final I like it we still have
[22:35]
a barge that underbanked
[22:36]
population and it ring cam,
[22:39]
which means that people
[22:42]
frequently literally and I'm
[22:43]
not exaggerating acts of cash.
[22:46]
8 tax bills. It's not optimum
[22:50]
for safety. Yeah. You know,
[22:53]
this not the cat homes. So
[22:54]
what it started doing this
[22:58]
happening, a bank out in the
[22:59]
hall way to talk to these
[23:00]
people are as they are
[23:05]
standing in line for to pay
[23:06]
their property tax bill to
[23:08]
talk to them that the virtues
[23:10]
establishing a banking
[23:12]
relationship. It's just a
[23:12]
small thing. But we've seen
[23:15]
some real benefits from it.
[23:18]
When it comes to progress
[23:18]
improvement. When one thing
[23:19]
that like to highlight is and
[23:23]
a lot of time it spent in the
[23:24]
office doing this processing
[23:29]
payments. Very, very manual
[23:30]
process. But we try to process
[23:33]
as much internally as possible
[23:35]
for 2 reason. It's it's more
[23:37]
accurate and we get the money
[23:38]
deposited in our in our bank
[23:40]
quicker. So you can see 2016
[23:42]
when this when all started, we
[23:44]
had 206,000 payments that were
[23:46]
processed by a 3rd party. And
[23:49]
that's and that's down to
[23:51]
6269,000 as of as of last
[23:53]
year. They say that about
[23:57]
34,000 lot bought fees and I
[23:59]
really take my hats off to our
[24:01]
to our 3 managers are revenue
[24:03]
to cover manager customer
[24:04]
service manager and really our
[24:07]
executive assistant who we're
[24:08]
all cross train and answering
[24:11]
the phones and processing mail
[24:12]
answering email and that's
[24:15]
what what can get it done. The
[24:18]
other thing is we have new
[24:19]
cash, cow nurse. Going to be
[24:21]
new bills which cask ales.
[24:22]
Would be unable to read. So we
[24:26]
invested in new cash counters,
[24:27]
$10 bills post to roll out
[24:29]
later this year and every 2
[24:31]
years going to be new bills.
[24:32]
So that should help us
[24:36]
identify counterfeit funk's.
[24:38]
One thing that we will
[24:39]
continue to worrisome goals
[24:42]
list. Is increasing the number
[24:46]
of APRIL as part of It
[24:49]
provides convenient funds for
[24:52]
paid security efficiency. Of
[24:54]
course, we always consider the
[24:56]
environmental impact and let's
[24:58]
not kid anybody the more we
[25:00]
can save postage by using
[25:04]
paperless, it saves us money.
[25:06]
So currently we have just
[25:08]
under 35,000 and our goal for
[25:09]
2027, it's another 10%
[25:16]
increase for Another Purdy and
[25:18]
gold is to continue safe with
[25:19]
investment public funds and
[25:21]
the chart you're looking at,
[25:22]
it's really the investment
[25:25]
income that was generated last
[25:26]
year from JANUARY to DECEMBER.
[25:27]
And you'll be you'll notice
[25:28]
there's a big increase during
[25:32]
a time where property tax
[25:33]
payments or a do so they MAY
[25:37]
JUNE NOVEMBER, DECEMBER. Also
[25:39]
have the liquid rate. So the
[25:41]
majority of our funds are
[25:42]
money market account.
[25:44]
Investments accounts, liquid
[25:46]
accounts. And we have a
[25:47]
short-term portfolio between
[25:49]
60 to 65 Million. Where we
[25:54]
invest your leanne CDs,
[25:56]
agencies stretched treasuries.
[25:56]
And there's a last year there
[25:59]
was a 38 basis point
[25:59]
difference this year. That MAY
[26:00]
be a little higher. We have
[26:04]
ceded this outstanding. We
[26:04]
have the financial U.S.
[26:06]
Institutions that bid on it
[26:09]
agencies, Treasury CDs, it
[26:10]
will probably be something
[26:13]
around. 4.2 to 4.4 will be the
[26:15]
yield Arco current money
[26:17]
market yields about 3.6 osos
[26:20]
about it. 68 a basis point
[26:22]
difference when it comes to
[26:25]
and the difference. What? One
[26:26]
of the reasons why I brought
[26:30]
that up is having a
[26:31]
comprehensive short-term
[26:32]
investment strategy where we
[26:35]
invest 2 to 3 years, 2 to 3
[26:37]
years, securities. We're able
[26:38]
to get additional interest
[26:40]
income so that additional 5
[26:41]
basis points, which we're
[26:43]
probably going to have next
[26:44]
year generates 250,000
[26:49]
additional interest income. I
[26:51]
want talk a little bit of
[26:52]
something that they focused on
[26:53]
increasingly over the past
[26:56]
couple of years. And that
[27:02]
community engagement, Beach
[27:04]
positions into the community
[27:07]
outreach coordinator and we do
[27:09]
special where we are we go out
[27:10]
into the public, whether it's
[27:14]
with a partner a community
[27:15]
development corporation and
[27:17]
the county fair, you know,
[27:19]
we've worked with Martin to
[27:23]
upright into planner at We get
[27:28]
a really neat segment with e a
[27:31]
r p and what we can to its
[27:33]
target, zip codes in the areas
[27:36]
with the highest incidence of
[27:38]
tax sale. Tech sell
[27:43]
properties. And you can see on
[27:46]
this slide. Those are the top
[27:49]
5 performing as a JULY 2026.
[27:51]
This is where we would spend
[27:55]
the bulk our activity and what
[27:57]
we to us have people there
[27:59]
that can speak both English
[28:01]
and Spanish and we will do
[28:03]
what we call operate that
[28:06]
check ups. Make sure that they
[28:07]
have all of the deductions and
[28:10]
credits to which they are
[28:12]
eyeful walk through the bill
[28:19]
with Tell them about value and
[28:20]
just in general provided all
[28:24]
the information that we have.
[28:25]
The next slide gives. Our guys
[28:27]
are budget breakdown of were
[28:31]
opposing and increase of
[28:32]
318,004 for all characters. 9
[28:35]
point one percent increase. We
[28:37]
look at the character
[28:38]
breakdown for a character one.
[28:43]
It's a 10.6% increase 209,000.
[28:46]
Our staffing levels for 2027
[28:47]
opposed to be the same as in
[28:50]
2026, the increases is with
[28:50]
the 3% cost of living
[28:51]
adjustment. The stepping
[28:56]
great. Attrition, increase and
[28:58]
attrition rate and health
[29:00]
insurance increases when it
[29:02]
comes to character to do with
[29:04]
supplies, operating supplies,
[29:07]
which which used send out tax
[29:11]
bill. $575 increase. And $46
[29:11]
increase overall in character,
[29:16]
too. For a character 3. We
[29:17]
have close $108,000 increase.
[29:22]
7.3, 3%. With with
[29:23]
professional services. I say
[29:27]
there's a $61,000 increase
[29:28]
about $9,000 increase with the
[29:32]
new last a phone system and
[29:33]
10,000 in each of the
[29:34]
categories when it when it
[29:36]
comes to post its mail service
[29:39]
and thinking we continue to
[29:41]
get to post increases every
[29:42]
year. So that's the appears to
[29:43]
be something that also happen
[29:45]
in 2027 in character. For no
[29:52]
change. When it comes to
[29:53]
There's a 1.4 billion dollar
[29:57]
increase proposed. And in
[29:58]
investment income. We have 1.1
[30:04]
billion dollar increase. And
[30:04]
just the next light really
[30:09]
just shows a investment income
[30:10]
relative to the budget over
[30:14]
last 3 years and will for a
[30:14]
2027. So we've had a
[30:18]
consistent. Good, good, good
[30:20]
performances when it when it
[30:21]
comes to deals this investment
[30:29]
of art. And that's it. In a
[30:29]
nutshell, you have all of the
[30:30]
report said the fact that you
[30:33]
will also included copies of
[30:34]
the documents that we hand our
[30:41]
public This is before and
[30:43]
Thanksgiving in the Bush
[30:45]
Spanish and make sure that we
[30:49]
have any of those and We go to
[30:51]
public. Thank you for the
[30:54]
opportunity to be here the
[30:54]
seat I appreciate your
[30:57]
listening and consideration.
[30:58]
It's always an honor to come
[31:01]
before the committee I'm happy
[31:03]
to take questions. Thank you
[31:05]
your presentation. Counter
[31:12]
Cahill. Thank you, MR. Chair
[31:14]
the $7500 on letters and
[31:18]
corrected. Sooner than
[31:19]
expected. 8.7 million dollars.
[31:23]
How that? The driver on the
[31:26]
1.1 million? Investment. What
[31:27]
how much of that when we look
[31:33]
at this? Investment income,
[31:33]
what what was the net effect
[31:36]
what you somebody by moving
[31:42]
that forward? Well, I think
[31:43]
going take a swipe at answer
[31:46]
and then let by cutting the
[31:49]
body. And earlier, it's less
[31:50]
that the taxpayer is going
[31:54]
first of all, but also that
[31:55]
enables us to invest the money
[31:59]
for a longer period I do. I
[32:02]
think that was part of the 1.1
[32:07]
million Incre soar. I I can
[32:08]
tell you led to an increase in
[32:09]
our interest, our names, I
[32:10]
think it would be hard to
[32:14]
quantify it. Yeah, we get a
[32:16]
break down early. It's it's
[32:17]
it's more. I would I would say
[32:17]
that some of that with wooden
[32:22]
table probably. We we both
[32:23]
receive the payments earlier
[32:23]
and we probably receive 40% of
[32:28]
it. Before the bills went out
[32:30]
in APRIL that we would have
[32:32]
gotten in JANUARY, FEBRUARY or
[32:36]
MARCH. So it was it was it was
[32:37]
well worthy. Well, worth the
[32:38]
investment. The other thing is
[32:40]
and the calls that were coming
[32:43]
in 4th front to the office. We
[32:46]
were able to identify people
[32:50]
that that have problems, maybe
[32:50]
maybe move MAY have been
[32:51]
unaware that that day that he
[32:52]
didn't pay their property tax
[32:56]
bill. So we were able to. Deal
[32:57]
with those customers getting
[32:58]
customer service. Part of the
[33:01]
really busy period when they
[33:01]
were, they would do it had a
[33:03]
tougher time getting to the
[33:05]
office. It also helped out
[33:06]
with a payment. So the people
[33:07]
that are struggling to make
[33:08]
their payments, they were able
[33:11]
to. Contact our office and
[33:16]
that MAY have. Unable to start
[33:17]
process with the starting
[33:19]
making payments online, but we
[33:20]
so that it was easier for to
[33:24]
become I mean, just my quick
[33:26]
and dirty showed it was should
[33:27]
have this just by moving it
[33:30]
forward like a month. One
[33:34]
generated about 30,000 extra.
[33:36]
As far as items that some of
[33:38]
500 generating 30,000 doesn't
[33:43]
come that through great do so.
[33:47]
And looking you. Okay? Yeah.
[33:49]
The what? Given that what is
[33:51]
MAY be on this that what is
[33:53]
driving the 1.1 that isn't new
[33:55]
increased rates that you're
[33:58]
forecasting. The biggest thing
[34:00]
is is our our average monthly
[34:02]
balance continues to increase.
[34:02]
So as a property levy
[34:04]
increases as as late
[34:07]
increases, our average balance
[34:08]
it is as long as interest
[34:08]
rates stay stay. Precept
[34:11]
steady. I think if we get a
[34:15]
3.0, 3, 5%, interest will be
[34:17]
able to make the make. The
[34:17]
budgeted numbers running
[34:19]
higher than that right think.
[34:21]
Thank you any other questions
[34:25]
or comments, counter boots.
[34:27]
Thank you both for the
[34:28]
presentation. If you could go
[34:29]
just back one slide, please to
[34:33]
20. And looking at the
[34:35]
difference 2 questions, one.
[34:38]
The amount of interest,
[34:40]
investment earnings is
[34:41]
increasing rapidly. So why do
[34:42]
you keep the budget amount
[34:46]
fixed? And 15, one, 50? It
[34:51]
went up in. There's been when
[34:53]
when you when we look at the
[34:58]
interest rate environment. The
[34:59]
environment has changed
[35:01]
dramatically beginning of the
[35:01]
year. Our money market rates
[35:06]
were. Substantially higher and
[35:07]
they can they continue to go
[35:10]
down. So so as as the money
[35:11]
market rates have gone down,
[35:12]
which is which is the bulk of
[35:13]
rain come the short-term
[35:17]
investments have. Going you
[35:21]
know looking at our budget and
[35:22]
understanding that there's
[35:23]
there's kind of this does next
[35:25]
between short-term
[35:27]
investments, liquid
[35:28]
investments and the increase
[35:31]
in the average balance for a
[35:32]
month. So using that that that
[35:37]
kind of factored into. The
[35:38]
budget number. I say, too,
[35:40]
there's a little bit of it
[35:44]
surveyed, but you go in It's
[35:46]
difficult to what some of the
[35:47]
stuff that's going on and
[35:49]
said, what can I be? What
[35:52]
might be coming down pike? So
[35:53]
I think we have a tendency to
[35:57]
be fairly conservative. Women.
[35:59]
When making assessment
[36:03]
historically has the amount of
[36:06]
the earnings exceeding the
[36:06]
budget has steadily grown
[36:08]
historically over the years.
[36:10]
More than just this 2 year
[36:12]
history. And I I would say
[36:14]
some of these factors 2020. 25
[36:18]
1 of the big factors was the
[36:19]
timing of the book. You know,
[36:22]
the interest in the So we we
[36:24]
had a 21. We had one being
[36:25]
that that was 20 Million. That
[36:28]
was over 5%. So we're able to
[36:29]
put 2025, which really made a
[36:31]
difference interest. That's
[36:34]
it's a time where short term
[36:37]
sure. And finally due to sup
[36:39]
8, the 26 number 2 Frederick.
[36:41]
See the budget member again, I
[36:44]
I and it's it's it's it's
[36:48]
really hard to dissipate with
[36:49]
with the Fed and tariffs then
[36:51]
the and the and the inflation
[36:53]
environment. So we have to be
[36:53]
somewhat conservative and try
[36:59]
to have have a figure they are
[36:59]
able to make but not have
[37:01]
something that is
[37:05]
substantially all. Thank you.
[37:08]
Thank you. Any other questions
[37:09]
from council, anyone from the
[37:11]
audience only speak on this,
[37:14]
seeing Thank As long she is
[37:15]
very much next and counting
[37:18]
on. Are there.
[38:01]
We have the floor. Good
[38:02]
evening, MISTER Chair and
[38:05]
members of the for the record
[38:07]
I am Island and I and the
[38:09]
privilege of serving as the
[38:13]
Marion County Auditor present
[38:16]
with me tonight as my chief
[38:17]
financial Officer, Tiffany
[38:20]
Matthews and I will in that
[38:25]
they're supporting me. Here
[38:27]
tonight to present at the 2027
[38:34]
budget presentation. We often
[38:35]
see on the screen. And you
[38:41]
also to say printed copy of
[38:45]
budget presentation packet.
[38:46]
Just think we go over the for
[38:50]
you. A Marion County Auditor's
[38:53]
Office is comprised 3 areas
[38:54]
which include the accounting
[38:57]
payroll real estate tax
[38:58]
provisions. The mission of the
[39:02]
office. Marion County
[39:05]
Auditor's Office is to deliver
[39:05]
exceptional customer service
[39:08]
while providing the most
[39:09]
efficient and effective
[39:12]
support to our Mary County
[39:14]
residents, city county
[39:20]
employees and then there's.
[39:21]
Our accounting Department
[39:23]
division provides accounts
[39:23]
payable and receivable
[39:27]
functions for all agencies.
[39:29]
And ensures payment for all
[39:30]
city and county bills. The
[39:31]
division reconciles cash
[39:33]
balances and funds and also
[39:35]
issues 10. 99 ce our payroll
[39:40]
department. Is responsible for
[39:42]
processing payroll and
[39:42]
ensuring adherence to a
[39:43]
clickable legal requirements,
[39:47]
including new hiring reporting
[39:49]
obligations and we also train
[39:50]
and provide support to all
[39:55]
agencies. Agency. Time keepers
[39:57]
and those are responsible for
[39:58]
a time. Keeper is responsible
[39:59]
for just what it says. Time
[40:01]
people in every agency in
[40:03]
imax. I really I'm proud of
[40:03]
that because we did not have
[40:11]
that Our real estate and tax
[40:12]
Department, that division
[40:13]
provides customer service for
[40:14]
Marion County. Residents
[40:16]
processes all tax deductions,
[40:17]
abatements tax bill
[40:21]
corrections and refunds that
[40:22]
division and ministers all
[40:23]
noticing requirements,
[40:24]
redemptions and refunds for
[40:27]
the annual tax sale as well as
[40:29]
investigates homestead
[40:29]
deduction, fraud throughout
[40:33]
the county. The next slide you
[40:38]
see for flex. The positions
[40:39]
that we have in the auditor's
[40:44]
office. Totaling 30 33
[40:46]
positions. We have 5
[40:47]
administration positions, 7
[40:50]
payroll positions. 10 and a
[40:52]
real estate division. 11
[40:57]
physicians and accounting. We
[41:00]
have 2 openings, real estate
[41:01]
and one in accounting. So if
[41:03]
you all know someone that is
[41:03]
interesting in them and send
[41:08]
them our way. Our agency
[41:12]
staffing demographics. 27
[41:16]
women. And for me, 10 women in
[41:19]
leadership to land as well.
[41:23]
All of our employees that I've
[41:26]
mentioned. We have one
[41:29]
biracial, Ali, one of Army's
[41:32]
Hispanic, African-American, 3
[41:34]
Hispanic, 12 African-American,
[41:36]
14 Caucasian and in
[41:37]
leadership. We have one
[41:38]
Hispanic, one 4
[41:39]
African-American and 7
[41:43]
Caucasian. Far as community
[41:46]
engagement. We are in the
[41:49]
process of mailing letters.
[41:51]
And new application forms to
[41:52]
veterans currently receiving
[41:56]
deductions to inform them. Of
[41:58]
changes to disabled Bennett
[41:59]
veterans, deductions and
[42:01]
credits. The letters for
[42:02]
Veterans of going out this
[42:09]
week. Recently I had an
[42:10]
interview with the local news
[42:12]
to educate homeowners about
[42:16]
Homestead. Deduction. I don't
[42:18]
have the time. I don't know
[42:18]
when interview will be aired
[42:21]
just because the everybody's
[42:25]
been been about the in recent
[42:26]
floods that we have had. But
[42:28]
we are trying our best to
[42:33]
educate. Now, residents The
[42:34]
what we offer and Islanders
[42:37]
office. Let's talk about 2026
[42:42]
progress and improvements. So
[42:42]
the auditors office introduced
[42:46]
a new automated clearing House
[42:46]
reimbursement option for
[42:50]
employees. The initiative aims
[42:51]
to streamline the
[42:53]
reimbursement process and
[42:55]
reduce the reliance on paper
[42:58]
checks. We're transitioning
[42:58]
from paper. We the goal is to
[43:03]
become a paperless county. Our
[43:04]
a c 8 reimbursement option for
[43:05]
employees began JUNE. The 8th
[43:09]
of this year. This this is for
[43:11]
the city and county employees
[43:11]
who normally receive
[43:13]
reimbursements for like
[43:16]
conferences, meals, supplies,
[43:17]
mileage, cell phones or any,
[43:21]
you know, reimbursable items
[43:22]
and employee has been approved
[43:23]
to purchase by their agency.
[43:26]
And we're happy to report that
[43:27]
that is going well. And
[43:29]
basically what that means is
[43:30]
instead of getting a paper
[43:30]
check, they have the option to
[43:32]
have it automatically
[43:34]
deposited into they're
[43:34]
checking account or savings
[43:40]
account what have you? We're
[43:43]
using you are using budgeted
[43:46]
funds to review current Wt w 2
[43:48]
10 99 processes to ensure
[43:50]
compliance with recent changes
[43:50]
in the applicable laws and
[43:52]
regulations. So excited
[43:53]
basically to be working with
[43:58]
our contract. That legal. Tax
[43:59]
professionals on our w 2 10 99
[44:07]
process us. Goals for 2027.
[44:10]
Expand automated clearing
[44:11]
house participation by adding
[44:13]
more vendors. What does that
[44:16]
mean? Liz Ellis left. It
[44:20]
reduces check printing costs.
[44:21]
So we MAY allocate those
[44:22]
resources to other future
[44:27]
initiatives. I mentioned
[44:31]
earlier the host it. The House
[44:32]
to credit, but beginning in
[44:34]
2026, the state mandates that.
[44:40]
County auditor shall. And that
[44:41]
Homestead investigations and
[44:43]
Beal for in eligible that
[44:45]
deduction is in prior years
[44:48]
before the language said it
[44:52]
was discretionary and that I
[44:58]
want to talk about. Before the
[45:00]
next light that like the home
[45:03]
state sweet. Now that so New
[45:10]
York so in regard to ach. So
[45:12]
in the beginning of my term.
[45:16]
We were receiving complaints.
[45:16]
The vendors were not being
[45:20]
paid fast enough and then
[45:20]
there's didn't want to do
[45:21]
business with the city or the
[45:24]
county. We implemented a new
[45:26]
payment request platform that
[45:30]
allowed us to be paperless
[45:30]
also MAY paying invoices much
[45:35]
quicker. Our initial start of
[45:36]
a ch was the introduction of
[45:37]
employee reimbursement, which
[45:41]
I just mentioned. Councilor
[45:44]
Cahill. Reached out with
[45:47]
concerns. Regarding met terms
[45:49]
on payments and provided which
[45:57]
i have. A copy of of you guys
[45:58]
is so the city County Council
[45:58]
calling can that was invoiced
[46:02]
on JULY 31st. And this year
[46:06]
with a due date of AUGUST,
[46:07]
30th with net terms with
[46:07]
terms. But it was paid on
[46:13]
AUGUST. 12th. People soften
[46:19]
just before Top of largest one
[46:20]
like tell you about people,
[46:21]
Southside, what people's out
[46:22]
some people south as the
[46:22]
capabilities of setting that
[46:28]
terms. Acm and our purchasing
[46:28]
department met with their
[46:31]
legal counsel over concerns
[46:32]
that payments could not or
[46:36]
could be late. That or not
[46:40]
contracted purchase orders. We
[46:44]
must consider. All payments
[46:47]
that a 30 terms such as
[46:54]
utilities. Such as utilities
[46:55]
are not contracted purchases.
[46:59]
Rent, for example, rent
[47:00]
Invoiced at 7.15, on JULY.
[47:03]
15th is due on AUGUST. 1st. So
[47:04]
it doesn't mean that 30 days.
[47:08]
All right. So what are we
[47:10]
doing? What is the result? Be
[47:11]
honest with you. We don't have
[47:12]
the resolve, but we do have a
[47:16]
plan. So the next steps. Are
[47:17]
partnering acm and the
[47:20]
Treasurer's office to do an
[47:24]
analysis of cash flow Nick
[47:26]
terms and the frequency of a
[47:28]
ch transactions. Also, I
[47:31]
talked to staff on today.
[47:33]
Councilor Cahill about too,
[47:35]
just looking at every invoice
[47:39]
that we receive and then
[47:44]
figuring out how do we manage
[47:45]
particular invoices? And so I
[47:52]
also learned today that we can
[47:55]
also set whatever the number
[47:56]
of the default rather that 0
[47:58]
right, 20 days, right, 30
[48:02]
days. The goal of, though, for
[48:04]
offices to again, by me
[48:07]
receiving those complains from
[48:09]
vendors. It is to make sure
[48:13]
that. Vendors are paid on time
[48:14]
because also what happens is
[48:18]
sometimes. CHAIRMAN Lusk
[48:21]
Arias. We will get invoices
[48:22]
from agencies and they're
[48:28]
already. The 30 day deadline,
[48:28]
right? So it's up to my
[48:32]
office. I feel at that time.
[48:33]
To like make sure that the
[48:35]
vendors are getting as soon as
[48:40]
possible. So we don't have it
[48:42]
all figured out yet, but we
[48:43]
will definitely look into what
[48:43]
we're going to do. The
[48:48]
research to find out how we
[48:52]
can process invoices in 30 day
[48:54]
next period, right? Because I
[48:55]
understand I do understand
[48:58]
where you're coming from
[49:00]
because if a bill is the
[49:02]
statement date is JULY, the
[49:03]
31st right? But the due date
[49:07]
is AUGUST. The 30th, we
[49:10]
probably set a default. Our
[49:10]
look wages make sure that the
[49:14]
bill is not late and have it
[49:16]
pay like 5 days prior to
[49:16]
write. So guess I do
[49:18]
understand and I'm hoping that
[49:21]
I'm answering some of your
[49:25]
questions that had your email.
[49:26]
So with that being said, I'm
[49:29]
going to go ahead and continue
[49:30]
to go through the presentation
[49:33]
and then I will take any
[49:33]
questions or any comments
[49:37]
from. The council members.
[49:39]
Okay. So let's talk about 2027
[49:44]
priorities and goals. The
[49:45]
homes week. We are currently
[49:46]
conducting coasted
[49:47]
investigations. However, we
[49:48]
are limited due to our current
[49:50]
property taxing system and
[49:53]
ability to gather information.
[49:53]
Our treasure actually talked
[49:54]
about the new tech scene.
[49:58]
System that we all bought into
[50:02]
myself. The assessor and the
[50:03]
treasurer, which she talked
[50:07]
about tax off and exiled is I
[50:08]
think going to do less a world
[50:14]
of good in regard how we are,
[50:15]
you know, tracking their
[50:16]
taxes. Our taxes on multiple
[50:19]
part parcel is at once the
[50:20]
current property tax. System
[50:21]
does not have that capability.
[50:24]
So we're excited About ix off
[50:24]
using it. And even that just
[50:25]
the features that it brings
[50:28]
with it. I think it'll be good
[50:33]
for the county engaging in the
[50:35]
go. Ineligible homestay it
[50:37]
data and software providers in
[50:39]
early spring that can provide
[50:39]
data. So we're working
[50:43]
organizations that actually I
[50:45]
have Don, like Homestead,
[50:47]
sweeps before. So our goal is
[50:50]
for any monitoring software to
[50:53]
continually research current
[50:53]
deduction recipients in our
[50:55]
tax base and alert U.S. Went
[50:58]
public record data suggest the
[51:00]
property is no longer serving
[51:01]
as the principal place of
[51:03]
residence. So for the homes
[51:04]
that pretty you are supposed
[51:08]
to be living at the residence
[51:10]
and it is your responsibility
[51:11]
as homeowner's responsibility
[51:14]
to report that if they are no
[51:15]
longer residing at that
[51:19]
residence at that address.
[51:21]
Let's talk about revenue,
[51:22]
comprehensive homestead
[51:23]
deduction and the ala says the
[51:25]
net result is that we collect
[51:27]
up to 3 years of additional
[51:29]
taxes and associated
[51:30]
penalties. These collections
[51:31]
go to the auditors and
[51:35]
eligible deductions, fun, the
[51:36]
greater impact to the Texan
[51:38]
units. The net revenue crease
[51:39]
after removing the fraudulent
[51:42]
erroneous Homestead deduction
[51:46]
from the specific parcel.
[51:51]
Budget breakdown. Increase
[51:52]
just a little bit account. Our
[51:55]
county, our county general,
[51:59]
for 2026. Was 14 million,
[52:02]
346,550 were $4. It is
[52:07]
increased too 15 million,
[52:07]
107,764 dollars. Our in
[52:13]
eligible deductions. For this
[52:20]
year was $655,000. $903. This
[52:24]
year, solo wars, $662,128
[52:31]
endorsement. See one up. From
[52:33]
$155,509 to $182,096. Our
[52:37]
elected officials training
[52:38]
remain the same. Looks like I
[52:40]
probably do some traveling
[52:42]
nurse. I'm educating myself,
[52:45]
but local emergency planning
[52:46]
is in my budget. I'm not
[52:47]
really surely sure why. But
[52:49]
it's $110,000 and it remained
[52:53]
the same for next year. But a
[52:54]
breakdown for personnel
[53:01]
character. One. 2027 to a
[53:06]
about 145 $1461. But the
[53:10]
difference of $562,705 in
[53:13]
eligible deductions went down
[53:22]
this year from $572,759 to 268
[53:26]
$1985, which with the
[53:30]
difference of $303,774.
[53:35]
Totaling on for this year,
[53:37]
2 billion 814 million,
[53:43]
$814,446 with the $258,931 in
[53:44]
my notes say here, the
[53:45]
character, one budget
[53:52]
increased by. I 258,931 about
[53:56]
$31 due to increasing cola
[53:59]
union and non-union and
[53:59]
changes in health insurance.
[54:01]
So this budget funds, 33
[54:03]
full-time employees with 3%
[54:04]
cola health insurance
[54:08]
increases. And step and grade
[54:12]
increases. Character to
[54:16]
supplies. County General Fund
[54:23]
for this year. $537 and went
[54:27]
down the difference of $1113.
[54:30]
Eligible deductions and 2026
[54:31]
was 23,000 stay the same. So
[54:36]
that's the euro with the if
[54:38]
you could say a total of
[54:40]
$23,537 with a difference of
[54:43]
1000, $113. And the for that
[54:49]
difference. Is reduced
[54:49]
gasoline funding based off of
[54:50]
usage. So I'm not driving my
[54:59]
city car lot Budget breakdown
[55:03]
character, 3 I'm just going
[55:04]
share with you. I'm not going
[55:06]
to go through all the the
[55:09]
figures here, but our charge
[55:12]
facts increased by $14,112.
[55:15]
You'll see the The slide and
[55:19]
then mental health costs sunny
[55:23]
and we saw an increase to
[55:26]
$524,447 to a total of
[55:32]
9 Million. And capital for
[55:33]
last, but not least there are
[55:36]
no changes. Our in eligible
[55:39]
deductions. 23,000 for this
[55:43]
year and $23,000 for next
[55:46]
year. That is conclusion of my
[55:54]
2027. It brings me and I.
[55:59]
Available to answer ultimately
[56:01]
any questions think PRESIDENT
[56:02]
Luiz. Thank you. Thank you for
[56:05]
your presentation to sit
[56:07]
question regarding the
[56:09]
Homestead Review. Any day that
[56:12]
speaks to how often folks are
[56:13]
utilized as the ducks and that
[56:15]
should not be using
[56:24]
I think we don't have exactly
[56:28]
because. We don't have the
[56:32]
means to gather all the data
[56:35]
itself. By engaging with a
[56:36]
company that can provide the
[56:37]
software utilizes obviously
[56:43]
like dmv records. We thank
[56:47]
your dmv be in the records.
[56:50]
Any public data essentially it
[56:51]
will pull that would be can
[56:55]
determine now on a day-to-day
[56:57]
basis, we usually are able to
[56:57]
catch that as far as like
[57:01]
somebody coming. Nguyen, maybe
[57:03]
someone could say some of that
[57:04]
report. They come in and
[57:09]
they'll say we I move the year
[57:10]
ago and now I'm Alicia knows
[57:11]
me see my my home. So I need
[57:15]
to, you know, Ed or whatever
[57:16]
so than that, and that might
[57:20]
trigger an investigation are
[57:22]
So how how often if you don't
[57:23]
mind is something like that
[57:24]
happened again? Do you have
[57:27]
figure that speaks to that? So
[57:28]
let me say If you know just So
[57:30]
let me say this I can't
[57:33]
remember what year so Mary
[57:35]
County is on this week before.
[57:37]
Okay. Okay. What year was that
[57:41]
10 years ago? So with
[57:41]
purchasing the new software
[57:44]
that we have mix off. Well,
[57:46]
hopefully to help us be able
[57:48]
to catch right individuals
[57:51]
that have more than one most
[57:52]
it deduction, right? So that's
[57:52]
why in the presentation,
[57:53]
though, that I said we're
[57:57]
meeting with. Companies that
[58:02]
have done this before and that
[58:03]
an initiative. Our is our goal
[58:07]
of ours is next year to do.
[58:10]
The sweet and also have in
[58:11]
place whatever that looks
[58:14]
like. We don't know yet
[58:15]
something in place to catch
[58:19]
individuals that are that have
[58:22]
more than state deduction is
[58:23]
that makes us so we don't have
[58:24]
an answer yet, but it is on
[58:26]
our things to do list to get
[58:28]
done and the great thank you
[58:29]
so much that the nra says see
[58:30]
that data when you do have a
[58:32]
thank you that run. Thank you.
[58:35]
Counselor. Km. I think MISTER
[58:38]
Chair. Thank you addressing
[58:39]
those concerns because I you
[58:41]
know, we've talked more in the
[58:42]
past week about liquidity that
[58:44]
think we talked to my time on
[58:47]
the council and is important
[58:48]
and that cash flow and paying.
[58:52]
And I agree we should not. And
[58:53]
I'm not saying it's your fault
[58:54]
when somebody he's an invoice
[58:55]
after it was already do, we
[58:58]
shouldn't be paying invoices.
[58:59]
Late, but I also don't think
[59:00]
we should be paying early
[59:04]
because it has great cash And
[59:05]
I think this goes back to last
[59:06]
year's discussion because you
[59:07]
were talking about moving more
[59:11]
jc age and inherently that and
[59:12]
addressed. We could cut, you
[59:15]
know, another week. Plus, when
[59:15]
you don't mail a check, but
[59:17]
now you see agent. Well, if
[59:19]
you're not issuing that ac age
[59:20]
on the day that it's too well,
[59:24]
actually, they too. It's like
[59:24]
if there's a weekend or
[59:25]
whatever. But if you if you're
[59:27]
not issuing that at that time
[59:29]
and you do kind of like this,
[59:31]
then because at least in this
[59:35]
case, calling it example,
[59:36]
there was checkpoint, the mail
[59:37]
and then And then it went in
[59:40]
the mail that got cash.
[59:41]
Probably was only off by a
[59:42]
couple days. But when we see
[59:43]
age that still gets bigger.
[59:46]
And although we picked a
[59:48]
colleague example not of
[59:50]
dollar amount. My concern is
[59:54]
more like and we have a major
[59:55]
contractor looking milestone
[59:56]
or something that with check
[59:56]
as Labour's pch as a lot zeros
[59:58]
at the end and the math of
[1:00:03]
that. So my my question my
[1:00:04]
follow-up question is last
[1:00:05]
year's presentation talked
[1:00:07]
about a ch converting more to
[1:00:07]
that. You've got that is to do
[1:00:09]
this year. And you said you've
[1:00:13]
got employee reimbursement
[1:00:15]
payments that's that's great
[1:00:16]
for great things from the
[1:00:18]
employees about that process.
[1:00:20]
Better. Are there other than
[1:00:21]
that? We have anybody on a
[1:00:22]
stage today or is that still
[1:00:26]
working properly? Yeah,
[1:00:28]
absolutely. Of like a you
[1:00:29]
have. We're working to expand
[1:00:32]
the pilot, but we do have a
[1:00:33]
couple of outside of our
[1:00:35]
normal because we do a ch
[1:00:36]
outside of that. I think last
[1:00:40]
year we added, for example,
[1:00:41]
state board of accounts we
[1:00:41]
need to pay. And with this
[1:00:46]
like. Taxing unit audits, when
[1:00:47]
see those invoices, we added
[1:00:52]
those 2 ach, but this year, I
[1:00:53]
say talking with them about
[1:00:58]
the ach process. And in
[1:00:59]
talking about a pilot asked if
[1:01:00]
we would include one of their
[1:01:05]
vendors. So we did
[1:01:07]
technologies. Second one was
[1:01:08]
just added a couple of months
[1:01:11]
ago and that score pay. So
[1:01:14]
that's utilized by the the
[1:01:19]
fuel payments up They
[1:01:20]
situations where we're running
[1:01:24]
into where payments for being
[1:01:25]
and feels important for
[1:01:30]
Obviously impd I d to be able
[1:01:30]
to conduct We didn't convert
[1:01:38]
those to ach so next step
[1:01:39]
because we now have mandate.
[1:01:39]
The wearing We talked about is
[1:01:42]
next. Expanding that, but also
[1:01:46]
doing it carefully, taking
[1:01:48]
into consideration that terms
[1:01:49]
consider e considering
[1:01:55]
liquidity cash flow. We have
[1:01:59]
talked of the treasurer's
[1:02:01]
about what that might look
[1:02:02]
like. So it might not be
[1:02:04]
obviously ach every day. It
[1:02:06]
might be picky. Some certain
[1:02:11]
vendors to begin with
[1:02:13]
discussing figuring out the
[1:02:15]
frequently what that would
[1:02:16]
look like. So and then I think
[1:02:19]
with a ch 2, is that. It's an
[1:02:23]
instant are Payment. So it we
[1:02:27]
make the with the exception of
[1:02:29]
mail. I that 30. We can set
[1:02:33]
that date on on 30 right. And
[1:02:37]
we know it's not going to be
[1:02:38]
late that they received that
[1:02:42]
day so we can maximize
[1:02:43]
maximizing that 30 terms and
[1:02:44]
also make sure not paying
[1:02:46]
late. Yeah, no, that's that's
[1:02:48]
good to hear. I I hope that
[1:02:48]
and I'm glad to hear not
[1:02:49]
surprised that I'm glad to
[1:02:53]
hear the Laker fuel supplier
[1:02:54]
for that makes perfect sense.
[1:02:55]
I guess I would hope that we
[1:02:59]
would kind of the big dollars
[1:02:59]
because I realize that the
[1:03:04]
goal is to eliminate the papal
[1:03:05]
charity. But in my experience,
[1:03:10]
bang for the buck is actually
[1:03:12]
The individual payments, even
[1:03:14]
though so we MAY still be
[1:03:18]
sending of a projected to
[1:03:19]
college Buffalo, Yorkers. And
[1:03:22]
yes, a ch 2. You know,
[1:03:25]
electric company esta citizens
[1:03:26]
milestone, too. So are you
[1:03:28]
anybody gets in my opinion,
[1:03:31]
anybody 7 figures a year and
[1:03:32]
that peak hour, I look at
[1:03:35]
that. So that's that's free.
[1:03:36]
And I guess my final thing I'm
[1:03:37]
glad I want him and you are
[1:03:39]
conversations now. I think
[1:03:42]
there MAY be an opportunity
[1:03:43]
for some training with regard
[1:03:46]
to people saw and it might
[1:03:47]
address some of what you're
[1:03:50]
talking about. Where rent
[1:03:50]
doesn't but that it might be
[1:03:54]
as simple as saying for rent
[1:03:55]
put the day, the rent is due
[1:03:56]
with net 0 and then the
[1:03:59]
payment will at the So I think
[1:04:03]
I think our understanding at
[1:04:04]
the moment and that's talking
[1:04:08]
with the Rp team and my xyz,
[1:04:11]
Europe. He handles, you know,
[1:04:12]
peoples problems or issues
[1:04:16]
river. Have that we might be
[1:04:17]
able to do that on a Hope.
[1:04:18]
We're hoping we can do that on
[1:04:18]
a b#
[1:04:19]
level which which
[1:04:22]
would be helpful that way. We
[1:04:23]
know that specific specific
[1:04:27]
vendor possibly. Kind of nutty
[1:04:31]
some of those out that we can.
[1:04:32]
You know, if that is, you
[1:04:34]
know, 15 days are only giving
[1:04:35]
15 days for that. We can set
[1:04:35]
it for that specific vendor
[1:04:37]
rather than having it as of
[1:04:38]
the fall across. People saw
[1:04:42]
it. Yes, I would certainly
[1:04:43]
help at center I believe
[1:04:45]
that's how it's supposed want
[1:04:46]
to hear that. But yeah, I just
[1:04:49]
I want conclude with thanks
[1:04:50]
again for this is major
[1:04:53]
progress past year. Fishy with
[1:04:55]
thank you. Thank Council
[1:04:56]
council I just would like to
[1:04:57]
say to you that I do think
[1:05:00]
that we can get it done. I do.
[1:05:02]
And I think it's having the
[1:05:03]
conversations on like we live
[1:05:06]
in a hyper right. So I but I
[1:05:08]
do. I think that is something
[1:05:09]
that having conversations and
[1:05:10]
again, because I'd learn
[1:05:11]
myself today in regard to the
[1:05:17]
Deval, but the system and
[1:05:18]
actually, if it's a rule right
[1:05:21]
versus a law and what the
[1:05:24]
auditor has the authority, if
[1:05:25]
you will, to decide on what
[1:05:27]
that number looks like. So we
[1:05:29]
would definitely my staff and
[1:05:31]
we taking a look into it and
[1:05:32]
figure out what's best for
[1:05:34]
good government for yeah, for
[1:05:41]
the Thank Council rose. Thank
[1:05:42]
you, MR. CHAIRMAN and I agree
[1:05:43]
with you, counselor Cahill.
[1:05:44]
This is very tedious work. So
[1:05:46]
thank you. MADAM Auditor, you
[1:05:50]
have done great work. I think
[1:05:52]
the ach peace is not only
[1:05:54]
reducing fraud, thought, but
[1:05:55]
it's good for business. We
[1:05:55]
don't want to drive those
[1:05:58]
dinners. The waste we've had,
[1:05:58]
you know, the course of
[1:06:01]
several years and decades,
[1:06:05]
even as so many vendors and
[1:06:06]
other agencies and governments
[1:06:08]
go to some of these things
[1:06:09]
were losing out on great
[1:06:10]
getting work done in a timely
[1:06:11]
fashion. So I commend you for
[1:06:15]
that. And again, prioritizing
[1:06:19]
internally was huge. And it's
[1:06:20]
it is so tedious and it's a
[1:06:21]
case-by-case piece. I just
[1:06:22]
want to shout out the team. I
[1:06:24]
know it's a long day for you.
[1:06:25]
Thank you for showing up and
[1:06:26]
thank you for all the work
[1:06:26]
that you all to thank. Thank
[1:06:30]
you, MR. CHAIRMAN. Thank you.
[1:06:31]
Any other questions on the
[1:06:32]
ach? Is there a fee for the
[1:06:36]
vendor? 0? It like $2 less
[1:06:40]
than a and is less than a
[1:06:41]
dollar? Yeah, it's It's like
[1:06:43]
pennies compared to look at
[1:06:46]
absolutely a check time. Thank
[1:06:47]
you. Any other questions
[1:06:49]
counselors, anyone from the
[1:06:51]
audience seeing none. We'll
[1:06:52]
move on to the item. Thank you
[1:06:59]
very Thank you. And bringing
[1:07:06]
rules for commute. It.
[1:07:37]
Welcome. And good evening.
[1:07:38]
Okay. Operation Officers
[1:07:39]
Correction Council. So a
[1:07:45]
pretty young 25th floor. 23rd
[1:07:46]
you have all the attorneys you
[1:07:50]
don't know where we are all
[1:07:52]
right. You have the Thank you.
[1:07:53]
Times kids with their thank
[1:07:56]
your time tonight friend. If
[1:07:59]
you are in that position
[1:08:00]
council here tonight present
[1:08:01]
the proposed 2027 budget for
[1:08:02]
the Office Corporation
[1:08:05]
counsel. To increase snapshot
[1:08:09]
of our agency. We are the in
[1:08:13]
law firm of the city county
[1:08:14]
provide full comprehensive
[1:08:15]
legal services to all of our
[1:08:15]
city county agencies and
[1:08:20]
employees. There are 3 fritzl
[1:08:21]
divisions in our office. The
[1:08:22]
litigation Division, the
[1:08:23]
Counseling Division and the
[1:08:26]
office. It's a prosecutor our
[1:08:26]
office also administers the
[1:08:30]
office of Equal Opportunity.
[1:08:32]
Here's a snapshot of the occ
[1:08:33]
organizational chart, as
[1:08:34]
you'll see there, the 3
[1:08:38]
divisions are listed in led
[1:08:38]
Katie Campbell, our city
[1:08:42]
prosecutor who's here tonight
[1:08:43]
Ellen Gavitt, our chief
[1:08:43]
counsel and Kylie Keys there,
[1:08:46]
our chief litigation counsel,
[1:08:47]
our senior staff is comprised
[1:08:50]
of the first 3 rows. So it be
[1:08:51]
the Corporation Council, the
[1:08:54]
deputy corporation counsel,
[1:08:54]
the 3 section chiefs, as well
[1:08:57]
as our office administrator.
[1:08:58]
Our leadership is 80% women
[1:09:05]
and we are very proud of
[1:09:06]
Here's a bit a look at she
[1:09:07]
sees role is to look at the
[1:09:08]
divisions and what used to
[1:09:09]
vision does and what they do
[1:09:11]
to provide support to city
[1:09:14]
county. The litigation
[1:09:15]
Division manages the docket of
[1:09:16]
cases all the times. And each
[1:09:17]
time the city of Indianapolis
[1:09:18]
is listed as a defendant. That
[1:09:23]
is the case. We take up last
[1:09:24]
year, enforces on to the trend
[1:09:26]
the past several years. Seen
[1:09:27]
an uptick of cases filed
[1:09:28]
against the city county and
[1:09:30]
its employees last year, a
[1:09:33]
total of 118 cases were filed
[1:09:37]
with 114 resolve to be clear
[1:09:37]
114 leads back to cases. His
[1:09:38]
office, obviously especially
[1:09:39]
federal litigation last
[1:09:42]
several years or can several
[1:09:43]
years this year. So far, we're
[1:09:45]
at 65 cases filed against the
[1:09:49]
city with 76 resolved. This.
[1:09:50]
That is a higher number than
[1:09:50]
we were last at last year's
[1:09:54]
budget presentation, which is
[1:09:54]
potentially indicative that we
[1:09:55]
are going to have more cases
[1:09:57]
again filed against the city
[1:09:58]
county just showing the amount
[1:10:00]
work in the litigation
[1:10:02]
section. The county section
[1:10:02]
that's kind of you to view is
[1:10:05]
the in-house counsel. Each
[1:10:06]
agency is assigned their own
[1:10:07]
counseling attorney. And
[1:10:08]
that's usually the first
[1:10:09]
attorney those agencies go to
[1:10:10]
and they have a legal question
[1:10:13]
the legal advice. The council
[1:10:13]
section provides those told
[1:10:15]
city County agencies as well
[1:10:17]
as the 30 boards and
[1:10:20]
commissions. Finally the
[1:10:21]
office of see prosecutors, the
[1:10:22]
office that's responsible for
[1:10:22]
enforcing the code violations
[1:10:25]
and ordinance violations. Last
[1:10:28]
year, they filed 1128 cases
[1:10:32]
and close 1002 this year, they
[1:10:36]
filed 713 cases and close so
[1:10:41]
far close 667. Without past 6,
[1:10:47]
6, 6, o that's good as far as
[1:10:48]
agents to staffing and that's
[1:10:48]
going to be a portion and
[1:10:52]
future slides. Tonight we have
[1:10:53]
46, tough fte positions with
[1:10:56]
31 filled with 15 vacancies.
[1:10:58]
Our focus of our senior staff
[1:11:00]
since I've taken this role has
[1:11:02]
been on finding ways to
[1:11:03]
support our staff, continue to
[1:11:04]
give the attorneys and the
[1:11:05]
staff in our office a good
[1:11:08]
opportunity, good experiences.
[1:11:10]
What we retention we want and
[1:11:11]
also have resource to help
[1:11:13]
build their careers as well.
[1:11:15]
So things we do and things
[1:11:17]
that we use the budget for her
[1:11:17]
character threes to pay for
[1:11:20]
attorneys annual licenses. We
[1:11:23]
reimburse support staff are
[1:11:24]
maintaining credentials.
[1:11:25]
That's probably was obviously
[1:11:26]
seen with our paralegals. Many
[1:11:28]
of them are notary publics. We
[1:11:28]
find that very beneficial to
[1:11:29]
have in our office will pay
[1:11:31]
for them to get those
[1:11:32]
commission's every few years.
[1:11:35]
They need those something we
[1:11:36]
introduced last year and we're
[1:11:40]
going continue into 27 was
[1:11:41]
reached a tourney, a $500 bank
[1:11:42]
that they can use for their
[1:11:45]
own professional development.
[1:11:46]
As most probably know, in
[1:11:47]
order to maintain your
[1:11:47]
attorney license, you have to
[1:11:48]
do a certain amount of
[1:11:49]
continuing legal education
[1:11:51]
every year. So this helps
[1:11:52]
because most firms and other
[1:11:54]
places will pay for that
[1:11:55]
entirely. But this gives an
[1:11:56]
opportunity to find not only
[1:11:58]
programs and they have the in
[1:11:59]
their individual job bankers,
[1:12:00]
things that they will utilize
[1:12:03]
to help them professionally.
[1:12:04]
We provide each attorney with
[1:12:04]
a membership to the and well
[1:12:06]
wishes the in International
[1:12:09]
Municipal Lawyers Association.
[1:12:10]
There's also the Indiana
[1:12:11]
Municipal Lawyers Association.
[1:12:13]
They're members of that has an
[1:12:14]
annual conference that all of
[1:12:15]
our attorneys to tend to work
[1:12:17]
in network and meet with all
[1:12:18]
this will trays across
[1:12:20]
Indiana. It's a very fun
[1:12:22]
conference, they learned and
[1:12:23]
kind of learn different
[1:12:24]
strategies of all the things
[1:12:27]
that we all MAY be facing.
[1:12:29]
Finally, make sure we we've
[1:12:30]
really developed some internal
[1:12:32]
training education programs.
[1:12:34]
So the attorneys don't need to
[1:12:34]
dip into their bank. They can
[1:12:36]
just here in the office. Get
[1:12:37]
an hour Cle on a subject
[1:12:37]
matter that's relevant to
[1:12:41]
them. Looking to programmatic
[1:12:44]
and fiscal successes of 26. I
[1:12:45]
kind of put these into 3
[1:12:47]
different buckets. The first
[1:12:48]
and foremost, which is I think
[1:12:50]
the primary responsibility of
[1:12:51]
our offices, the reduction of
[1:12:52]
liability of potential
[1:12:54]
exposure of the city county.
[1:12:56]
So that is advising monitoring
[1:12:57]
compliance with state and
[1:12:59]
federal laws and regulations
[1:12:59]
past year and a half,
[1:13:02]
particularly there's been a
[1:13:03]
slew of new rules and regs and
[1:13:06]
things coming out. So we have
[1:13:07]
a symbol, a little team within
[1:13:07]
our office to kind of keep an
[1:13:08]
eye on that. What's happening
[1:13:11]
at the federal level and
[1:13:12]
what's happening in different
[1:13:13]
states, especially cities that
[1:13:13]
are similarly situated,
[1:13:17]
Indianapolis to see what's
[1:13:18]
happening in so we can quickly
[1:13:18]
advise our clients get
[1:13:20]
guidance and kind of interpret
[1:13:22]
if there's pivots, we should
[1:13:23]
suggest or recommend that also
[1:13:25]
just having were never caught
[1:13:26]
surprised by thing coming down
[1:13:28]
from the state or federal
[1:13:30]
level. We also resolve law try
[1:13:31]
to work to resolve lawsuits.
[1:13:32]
Earlier, as I mentioned, those
[1:13:35]
numbers keep going up. So
[1:13:35]
we're starting to implement a
[1:13:38]
system this past year that
[1:13:39]
helps identify what the issues
[1:13:41]
are in that lawsuit. What the
[1:13:41]
plaintiff truly is complaining
[1:13:45]
about to see if we can offer
[1:13:45]
what we can do and try to
[1:13:47]
gather that evidence quickly
[1:13:50]
and see if we can assess
[1:13:51]
liability and make informed
[1:13:52]
decision as far as settlement
[1:13:53]
goes or to go forward with the
[1:13:56]
litigation. And finally
[1:13:57]
utilizing on economic impact
[1:14:00]
options with a mindfulness of
[1:14:01]
the very tight budget for
[1:14:04]
these agencies. We started
[1:14:05]
identify again what MAY be a
[1:14:06]
plaintiff's complaint about
[1:14:07]
him other than offering money.
[1:14:09]
If it's a policy change
[1:14:09]
looking into that and working
[1:14:10]
with our agencies to see if
[1:14:12]
that solve the problem. At
[1:14:13]
that point, it was bringing
[1:14:15]
and trying to find non-medical
[1:14:19]
economic ways to solve law, to
[1:14:19]
resolve lawsuits, internal
[1:14:21]
legal education, which I've
[1:14:23]
mentioned, we really try to
[1:14:24]
milk the most out of our
[1:14:27]
character, 3 In addition to
[1:14:27]
outside lawyers taking the
[1:14:28]
cases we do that don't have
[1:14:30]
capacity to take or we're
[1:14:34]
conflicted from taking. We've
[1:14:34]
had a few of those counselors
[1:14:35]
come in and provide very
[1:14:38]
specific Cle trainings. We now
[1:14:39]
have an annual section 1983
[1:14:41]
training, which is a really
[1:14:41]
specialized area of his full
[1:14:43]
government law in federal
[1:14:44]
court. We've also done a legal
[1:14:47]
writing training to help.
[1:14:48]
Encourage and advocate for
[1:14:51]
lawyers to improve their
[1:14:52]
advocacy skills. In addition,
[1:14:54]
we have with our contracts
[1:14:56]
comes expectations that those
[1:14:57]
outside counsels well mentor
[1:14:59]
our attorneys. So well, maybe
[1:15:02]
with the outside. Those
[1:15:03]
attorneys are expected in
[1:15:04]
Turley who are monitoring them
[1:15:06]
to engage the attorneys. 10
[1:15:07]
depositions they're able to
[1:15:08]
attend attend court hearings
[1:15:09]
when they're able to attend
[1:15:11]
and even take the first stab
[1:15:12]
at writing the briefs and
[1:15:13]
things like that stink. It
[1:15:13]
feedback from attorneys who
[1:15:15]
practice in this area and it's
[1:15:19]
a mentor in that way. Finally
[1:15:19]
responding to legal needs of
[1:15:23]
city county agencies. These
[1:15:23]
are necessarily subject matter
[1:15:24]
legal, but this is how we can
[1:15:26]
better serve the city county
[1:15:26]
and how issues of questions
[1:15:29]
brought to us or help agencies
[1:15:30]
have tools they can use to
[1:15:33]
kind of saw their problems.
[1:15:34]
We're currently engaged with.
[1:15:37]
I sa to help improve our a
[1:15:38]
discovery of public records
[1:15:39]
law, our public records
[1:15:41]
processees. That's probably
[1:15:42]
question we get the public
[1:15:43]
records could comes in. How do
[1:15:46]
we get this? What we do so I
[1:15:47]
say has been incredibly
[1:15:50]
helpful on developing an
[1:15:50]
intranet where we can start
[1:15:51]
printed materials, search
[1:15:54]
terms. So in those the ios
[1:15:55]
Reverend Agencies are charged
[1:15:57]
with getting those public
[1:15:58]
records request. They got
[1:15:59]
confidence. These records are
[1:16:00]
streamlined their narrow, but
[1:16:01]
they're also comprehensive.
[1:16:02]
What the of what the request
[1:16:06]
is part problem solving urgent
[1:16:07]
legal issues. Again, that's
[1:16:08]
kind of goes back to following
[1:16:11]
the state local different
[1:16:14]
regulations and then also
[1:16:16]
piggybacking on the first sub
[1:16:18]
here during the work of the
[1:16:20]
agencies and kind of engaging.
[1:16:21]
I've been spending time with
[1:16:21]
each agency to learn what they
[1:16:22]
do. What are their legal needs
[1:16:23]
know what their legal needs
[1:16:25]
are and trying to help Bill
[1:16:28]
that Internet. That's not out
[1:16:29]
yet. But information on there
[1:16:29]
that helps the agency's kind
[1:16:33]
of. Self-help themselves
[1:16:33]
before coming to us are
[1:16:34]
helping to streamline that
[1:16:38]
question. Katie impacts always
[1:16:39]
challenging one to talk is
[1:16:41]
where the internal agency. But
[1:16:42]
and these are a few that I can
[1:16:45]
highlight are happening this
[1:16:46]
year. The opiate litigation,
[1:16:47]
which is also been which has
[1:16:49]
been going on for several
[1:16:50]
years. We have received more
[1:16:53]
of that distribution this year
[1:16:53]
wrecked a 17 million we've
[1:16:56]
received so far. We still
[1:16:57]
project 70 million coming in
[1:17:01]
from the opioid litigation.
[1:17:02]
The Kia Hyundai lawsuit that
[1:17:04]
dealt with alleged effect and
[1:17:06]
the heat days and led to break
[1:17:08]
ends and cause a lot of time
[1:17:09]
and effort be spent by the
[1:17:11]
impd on investigating those in
[1:17:13]
solving those. I'm happy to
[1:17:15]
say we are in preliminary
[1:17:17]
final settlement, but that is
[1:17:18]
truly all I can say about it
[1:17:18]
right now because the court of
[1:17:20]
the parties have agreed not to
[1:17:21]
speak further on it until we
[1:17:21]
hope reach that. But I will
[1:17:24]
say I do. Hope that his
[1:17:25]
resolve by this year by the
[1:17:28]
end of this year. We also
[1:17:30]
reviewing other class action
[1:17:31]
opportunities, things where
[1:17:32]
we've either purchase products
[1:17:34]
are had issues that again,
[1:17:35]
that we should be part of to
[1:17:35]
make sure we get in on those
[1:17:37]
early so we can maximize any
[1:17:41]
settlement funds from that.
[1:17:42]
Mitigating liability and
[1:17:46]
finally get Hammer home 100.
[1:17:47]
And the changes that that
[1:17:47]
really is something has
[1:17:48]
changed past years to develop
[1:17:49]
a team to just keep an eye on
[1:17:51]
everything going on out there.
[1:17:56]
Looking his 2027. So the
[1:17:57]
number one bullet point here,
[1:17:59]
the pride, the thing for
[1:17:59]
interim and that I care a lot
[1:18:01]
about this office. I've had a
[1:18:02]
phenomenal experience this
[1:18:03]
office and gain experience as
[1:18:05]
a litigator. That's my trade.
[1:18:06]
We are currently going through
[1:18:08]
a drought of litigation
[1:18:10]
attorneys so if you look at
[1:18:11]
the chart, we are going down.
[1:18:12]
So we've had to do a lot of
[1:18:13]
outside counsel because we
[1:18:14]
have an obligation to
[1:18:17]
represent the city county. But
[1:18:19]
so immediate things we've
[1:18:19]
taken. 26, I will say thank
[1:18:21]
you to hr with them for
[1:18:24]
working with me quickly. We
[1:18:25]
knew we had to get the
[1:18:27]
litigation specific salaries
[1:18:28]
up to competitive. We weren't
[1:18:29]
even close to even with you
[1:18:31]
know, whatever. And we the
[1:18:33]
state look at surrounding
[1:18:34]
counties and what similar
[1:18:37]
situated cities are. So we
[1:18:38]
found a good able to up those
[1:18:39]
salaries. We've got those
[1:18:42]
listed last month finally
[1:18:43]
getting bites again. So we're
[1:18:44]
optimistic that that's going
[1:18:47]
to be a helpful thing. Hr has
[1:18:49]
been really helpful, would
[1:18:49]
never lie to post our jobs
[1:18:50]
before. It's just kind on the
[1:18:53]
city county website. They've
[1:18:54]
been really proactive in
[1:18:55]
getting us into the all school
[1:18:56]
job the U.S. And to divulge a
[1:18:59]
job bank and kind of helping
[1:18:59]
spread the word that we have
[1:19:02]
these positions available.
[1:19:03]
Looking to 2027 if we're still
[1:19:07]
having this issue I've had
[1:19:08]
people in various
[1:19:09]
conversations. Guess it's
[1:19:10]
saved by conversation of start
[1:19:11]
with my personal network of
[1:19:11]
attorneys that are very
[1:19:14]
throughout different areas of
[1:19:17]
law. But working see if it
[1:19:18]
makes sense to change occ to
[1:19:19]
what I'll call it a bigger for
[1:19:22]
model. We create different
[1:19:22]
positions like convert, I
[1:19:25]
should positions to more like
[1:19:26]
Doc review based to come in
[1:19:28]
because at this point for
[1:19:28]
litigation, attorney, you have
[1:19:30]
to have 2 years of experience
[1:19:32]
before women hire you because
[1:19:33]
we are complex litigation. You
[1:19:36]
are expected to be fun when
[1:19:37]
you start on day one. So going
[1:19:39]
to federal court and do any
[1:19:40]
hearing so seen maybe that can
[1:19:44]
get and that way again, some
[1:19:45]
of straight of local school be
[1:19:47]
eligible to start for those
[1:19:48]
jobs. Start shadowing start
[1:19:49]
going to those hearings. And
[1:19:50]
they also have internal
[1:19:51]
quickly within the office
[1:19:53]
going for maybe a doctor
[1:19:55]
attorney, too. And assistant
[1:19:57]
us assistant corporation
[1:19:59]
counsel. So everything's on
[1:20:01]
the table. Continue take
[1:20:02]
advice on that. Any boyer's
[1:20:02]
out there. I've I'm always
[1:20:03]
willing to try to figure out
[1:20:06]
how we can make to to get that
[1:20:08]
staffing that back up in
[1:20:09]
litigation. The second is our
[1:20:13]
sauce. A partnership. We again
[1:20:15]
thank the council in 23
[1:20:16]
appropriate funds to have
[1:20:18]
partnership with the U.S.
[1:20:20]
Attorney's office with an
[1:20:20]
attorney that says 6 solely
[1:20:23]
focused on Marion County,
[1:20:24]
violent crime. That attorney
[1:20:26]
was such a success that the
[1:20:26]
U.S. Attorney's office
[1:20:27]
snatched him up and to come
[1:20:29]
out as assistant U.S.
[1:20:31]
Attorney. But we successes
[1:20:32]
hired a new attorney who is I
[1:20:33]
think starting in 2 weeks for
[1:20:36]
that's also position. So this
[1:20:37]
has been a very mutually
[1:20:38]
beneficial partnership with
[1:20:39]
the U.S. Attorney's Office and
[1:20:44]
plan to continue that 27
[1:20:45]
shouldn't you be one of the
[1:20:46]
things other than salary that
[1:20:47]
the attorneys who talking
[1:20:48]
about is again, all they do
[1:20:49]
like having these internal
[1:20:50]
trains. That's again,
[1:20:52]
something common to all firms
[1:20:54]
offer and of course, that Ray
[1:20:57]
General's office offers those
[1:20:58]
so should we have enough here
[1:20:59]
3 thinking about what other
[1:21:01]
arteries but trainings we can
[1:21:02]
offer them free of cost to
[1:21:04]
them to benefit their careers
[1:21:04]
and their service here. The
[1:21:09]
city County. And finally
[1:21:10]
always trying to make sure we
[1:21:10]
live work with all our small
[1:21:14]
locally owned firms here.
[1:21:16]
Strangely being this
[1:21:17]
litigation shortage. We have
[1:21:18]
certainly well white in that
[1:21:21]
on who we work with this year.
[1:21:22]
I can even a model for work
[1:21:22]
with this year after list that
[1:21:26]
this has been. Kind of a dire
[1:21:26]
situation of positive, aspect
[1:21:28]
of being able to work with the
[1:21:30]
smaller, especially women
[1:21:31]
owned or minority owned firms
[1:21:32]
who can do this work and help
[1:21:33]
us out with that. So it has
[1:21:34]
been opportunity to reach
[1:21:37]
those smaller for Now to the
[1:21:42]
numbers so overall, the
[1:21:43]
variance skipped just where we
[1:21:45]
are because most to character
[1:21:49]
stay straight year. Stay flat.
[1:21:51]
It's variance increase of
[1:21:52]
38,600. And $22. And I'll show
[1:21:56]
you where that goes. Character
[1:21:59]
Wian does increase by the
[1:22:01]
294,021. But that's all we do.
[1:22:01]
The 3% cola and the increase
[1:22:02]
of one percent for health
[1:22:05]
insurance. Character to stays
[1:22:11]
the same. Character 3, the
[1:22:13]
$38,000. $38,576. Variance is
[1:22:16]
again, specifically for we've
[1:22:17]
had to increase our character
[1:22:19]
3 for outside law firms this
[1:22:20]
year. And that covers that so
[1:22:22]
we can pay off those bills. I
[1:22:24]
should also just comment that
[1:22:26]
view every attorney is taking
[1:22:27]
the case during our litigation
[1:22:29]
shortage has been made aware
[1:22:31]
that our intent is to hire
[1:22:32]
people and bring this case is
[1:22:33]
back. And so this is something
[1:22:34]
that we do hoping 27. We start
[1:22:37]
getting more folks, bring it
[1:22:38]
back. And so then we don't
[1:22:38]
have that outside counsel
[1:22:42]
anymore. Care to 4 cup. Stay
[1:22:45]
flat. And then since we are,
[1:22:46]
in fact, a chargeback agency
[1:22:48]
that shows its pride different
[1:22:49]
many other agencies are
[1:22:51]
variants of the offset. What
[1:22:51]
other regions of other
[1:22:53]
agencies. That? I'll take any
[1:22:59]
questions. Thank for your
[1:23:00]
presentation. Looking over a
[1:23:02]
little bit. You're you're down
[1:23:06]
about 8 full-time employees
[1:23:07]
without a total of 15. There's
[1:23:09]
a few that we don't need to
[1:23:11]
fill. The divisions
[1:23:11]
functioning without those
[1:23:12]
physicians who want to keep in
[1:23:15]
case. We good candidates ease.
[1:23:16]
Particularly that every
[1:23:17]
division could use the help.
[1:23:19]
They're still part of our item
[1:23:22]
that in litigation 8 was the
[1:23:23]
starting pay for an attorney.
[1:23:28]
The higher. So varies now a
[1:23:29]
litigation attorney we have
[1:23:32]
now got up to 92. If it's a
[1:23:33]
senior attorney with although
[1:23:36]
that comes experience that we
[1:23:37]
don't generally higher from
[1:23:39]
the outside when that option
[1:23:41]
case they come super qualify
[1:23:42]
me that their career and what
[1:23:43]
it does public service that
[1:23:47]
starts at 101, that's health
[1:23:47]
care and everything. That's
[1:23:50]
right. Ok? Any questions from
[1:23:58]
the counselors? My And we're
[1:24:02]
boots. I is an attorney.
[1:24:03]
Council routes. Thank you.
[1:24:10]
Think I'm sure you've done the
[1:24:11]
math, the expense of
[1:24:11]
character, 3 expense of hiring
[1:24:16]
out. Versus. Kerry can one
[1:24:17]
expensive staffing those
[1:24:20]
positions so you don't have to
[1:24:21]
la suggest that you're going
[1:24:23]
to be saving money. Increasing
[1:24:27]
your staff. That's correct.
[1:24:30]
That's correct. I mean, we
[1:24:31]
obviously negotiate races from
[1:24:32]
here on pain with private
[1:24:35]
citizens generally pay for
[1:24:38]
items, but again, increasing
[1:24:39]
smaller for the better with
[1:24:41]
with with lower rates.
[1:24:41]
Sometimes we used to big firms
[1:24:42]
that are specialized cases
[1:24:43]
like you know, generally about
[1:24:45]
police cases and things like
[1:24:47]
that that have specialized
[1:24:48]
areas of law or constitutional
[1:24:52]
questions but overall, I mean,
[1:24:53]
you're kind of going to what
[1:24:54]
I'm hoping is the nuclear
[1:24:57]
option ever pushes the
[1:24:58]
consideration we just can't
[1:24:58]
get people. What does it look
[1:25:00]
like to convert to housing
[1:25:03]
council? Had. Social
[1:25:04]
conversation about that. I
[1:25:05]
understand that sometimes law
[1:25:08]
firms are law firms would
[1:25:09]
offer a flat rate solar much
[1:25:11]
that is have a guarantee.
[1:25:13]
Budget numbers open the and
[1:25:15]
now of we do know having This
[1:25:17]
how much discovery. So we have
[1:25:18]
recovered that model. I want
[1:25:19]
to be comfortable knowing we
[1:25:21]
had a solid rate and that's
[1:25:23]
what the person that would pay
[1:25:25]
that for that every year. And
[1:25:26]
even if they did more work,
[1:25:27]
that's what the number is. So
[1:25:27]
we have a guaranteed
[1:25:33]
budgeting. And you feel
[1:25:34]
comfortable you're going make
[1:25:36]
a dent in the vacancy rate in
[1:25:38]
the litigation attorney ranks.
[1:25:40]
We have not had bites and
[1:25:43]
months and months that we've
[1:25:45]
got 2 bytes who this week so
[1:25:46]
I'm hoping that's a sign of a
[1:25:47]
changing Tide. Great. Thank
[1:25:49]
you. Thank you. Thank you. Any
[1:25:50]
other questions councilors
[1:25:54]
seeing none. Anyone the
[1:25:55]
audience now. Thank Thank you.
[1:25:58]
See you budget review. A place
[1:26:02]
in the last was the best.
[1:26:07]
Marion County City Council. 35
[1:26:08]
minute presentation. And I
[1:26:10]
want to ask can just keep
[1:26:11]
everything go right to the
[1:26:14]
numbers that Monroe graded. Is
[1:26:20]
we make right. I think we
[1:26:20]
could I wanted that to you we
[1:26:28]
thank you. And 3 sides. A
[1:26:32]
CHAIRMAN. Scary, numbers Those
[1:26:32]
friends in the audience and
[1:26:34]
citizens feeling at home when
[1:26:35]
a storm Moreland. I'm the
[1:26:37]
chief staff and chief policy
[1:26:40]
officer for the Indy City kind
[1:26:41]
accounts. I'm here with our
[1:26:41]
chief Financial Officer,
[1:26:46]
Candice Harris. We're here to
[1:26:48]
present 2027 budget. But
[1:26:49]
before we get into the
[1:26:53]
numbers. Still a little
[1:26:55]
overview of the council
[1:26:56]
landscape as we when we refer
[1:26:58]
to the council this evening,
[1:26:59]
we're talking about 2
[1:27:00]
different aspects with
[1:27:03]
council. There of course, the
[1:27:04]
25 member body of which you
[1:27:10]
are all part of you are charge
[1:27:10]
of making local laws, of
[1:27:15]
course, adopting a budget by
[1:27:18]
zing in providing consent to
[1:27:19]
the administration their
[1:27:21]
functions. But then there's
[1:27:22]
also a second aspect of the
[1:27:23]
council and that's the office
[1:27:23]
of the council that supports
[1:27:27]
that work. We are a 12 member
[1:27:32]
staff. Who advises on policy
[1:27:34]
last week, right reads public
[1:27:34]
public policy research and
[1:27:39]
support your efforts. We
[1:27:40]
perform administrative duties,
[1:27:42]
making sure that minutes are
[1:27:42]
posted in a timely manner,
[1:27:43]
making sure that the
[1:27:44]
information is accessible to
[1:27:48]
the public. And we also work
[1:27:48]
to connect the work of the
[1:27:50]
council with constituents. We
[1:27:54]
communicate your work. And we
[1:27:57]
are here to answer questions
[1:27:58]
on a daily basis when the
[1:27:59]
public wants to know more
[1:27:59]
about what the council's up
[1:28:05]
to. So on side with this this
[1:28:10]
is a slide that that kind of
[1:28:10]
gives visual layout of the
[1:28:12]
landscape. The council's on
[1:28:17]
the far left there. And these
[1:28:19]
are all the legislative
[1:28:19]
executive and judicial are all
[1:28:21]
coequal branches of local
[1:28:24]
government. I think one main
[1:28:26]
thing I'd like take away from
[1:28:28]
the slide is the role the
[1:28:31]
voters we work for the public
[1:28:31]
and we are ultimately
[1:28:32]
accountable to to the voting
[1:28:37]
public. So these priorities
[1:28:41]
for Twenty-twenty 7. This is a
[1:28:43]
theme that I've been hearing
[1:28:43]
from other of departments and
[1:28:45]
happy to hear it and
[1:28:46]
investment people. We're
[1:28:48]
looking to provide more. A
[1:28:51]
professional development
[1:28:52]
experiences within this. All,
[1:28:54]
both for the council itself
[1:28:56]
and the that that might look
[1:28:58]
like media training,
[1:28:59]
communications training,
[1:28:59]
technology, training for the
[1:29:04]
counselors and for staff. Also
[1:29:05]
focus on technology to support
[1:29:12]
our work. We have lots of data
[1:29:12]
flowing through all
[1:29:14]
departments in in the city
[1:29:15]
government. We're looking at
[1:29:17]
ways to harness those data
[1:29:18]
points in ways that can better
[1:29:21]
inform your work so that you
[1:29:23]
are making crafting policy.
[1:29:28]
That's backed by data. Also we
[1:29:28]
believe the data can provide a
[1:29:32]
very good side. Real-time
[1:29:34]
snapshot, what's happening in
[1:29:37]
your districts? This looks you
[1:29:38]
how many police runs are
[1:29:40]
happening in your districts?
[1:29:41]
How many dog bites are
[1:29:45]
occurring in your Where are
[1:29:46]
their broken water mains are
[1:29:48]
abandoned houses your
[1:29:50]
districts. We think that it's
[1:29:53]
a very smart to try to to use
[1:29:55]
more the data that's flowing
[1:29:56]
through this, that enterprise
[1:29:59]
on a day-to-day basis to help
[1:30:00]
you get better connected with
[1:30:04]
your constituents. And then
[1:30:06]
finally, working to strengthen
[1:30:09]
our relationships state else.
[1:30:10]
We see city of Indianapolis a
[1:30:13]
major driver of growth for the
[1:30:15]
whole state of Indiana. And so
[1:30:17]
it's important that we are
[1:30:18]
staying in close alignment
[1:30:19]
with with the Indiana General
[1:30:20]
Assembly, making sure that
[1:30:24]
they all are aware of what
[1:30:25]
you're up to and that
[1:30:28]
communicating we need in order
[1:30:29]
to to serve our community
[1:30:31]
because we believe that
[1:30:32]
Indianapolis is vital for the
[1:30:37]
Overall, the state. Okay. So
[1:30:42]
this is the team. This one
[1:30:43]
went field. Winfield, Leanne
[1:30:45]
at Piers came as hear us and
[1:30:46]
you can solace. Leslie
[1:30:51]
Williams, Kim Nance, Angela he
[1:30:51]
and Sears and Fernando
[1:30:55]
Ramirez. Strickland. We have
[1:30:57]
to they can't rolls right now.
[1:30:58]
The chief communications
[1:31:00]
officer and the legislative
[1:31:03]
and policy manager. Those are
[1:31:05]
2 really important roles.
[1:31:06]
We're in the process right
[1:31:08]
now. Feeling both of those
[1:31:13]
roles and we're need to get
[1:31:16]
those positions filled as soon
[1:31:19]
as possible. And I open.
[1:31:22]
Welcome, teeny input that you
[1:31:22]
have if you know of people who
[1:31:23]
are qualified and talented,
[1:31:28]
who MAY want to join our team.
[1:31:30]
Okay, give it to campus. So
[1:31:31]
hunger could be over or is he
[1:31:31]
demographic? So as you know,
[1:31:34]
we're a small office and so
[1:31:35]
being that we are a small
[1:31:37]
office, we do have less than
[1:31:38]
10 years. So about 50% of
[1:31:39]
staff has been with the city
[1:31:44]
for over 10 years. And what
[1:31:44]
the other part of other have
[1:31:45]
over staffing little be less
[1:31:47]
than 10 years 0 to 10. So
[1:31:48]
pretty proud of that, as you
[1:31:49]
know, not cover here is our
[1:31:54]
office is majority female. And
[1:31:55]
we also have about a 70% of
[1:32:01]
our staff is a minority.
[1:32:03]
Moving on to our 2027 budget.
[1:32:04]
So the council office budget
[1:32:06]
is road to be smart. You guys
[1:32:08]
all know this year. We're
[1:32:12]
rounding out about 3.4 million
[1:32:14]
dollars, not uncommon with
[1:32:15]
80's with our agencies, that
[1:32:18]
82% of our budget does go to
[1:32:20]
people. So that is majority of
[1:32:24]
our budget. So just over to
[1:32:25]
the right, you see a
[1:32:25]
side-by-side based on previous
[1:32:29]
years from 26 to 27. Well, are
[1:32:34]
despite $86,000 it's something
[1:32:36]
that I just kind of want to
[1:32:36]
highlight, though. We are up
[1:32:40]
2.6% for 2027 over our budget
[1:32:43]
is down 3.3% to 2025, as many
[1:32:47]
of you guys remember last year
[1:32:47]
we are, but it was reduced as
[1:32:52]
a result of. We'll call it
[1:32:55]
reserves. And so the council
[1:32:56]
this following year, did not
[1:32:57]
grow by the amount that we
[1:32:59]
lost last year. So it just
[1:33:00]
might increase to cover care
[1:33:03]
to one expenses. Again, some
[1:33:03]
of the other ones in the next
[1:33:11]
slide. Moving on to just a
[1:33:14]
quick overview of each
[1:33:15]
characters care to Lanikai
[1:33:16]
said that previous slide for
[1:33:17]
about 2.8 million dollars. And
[1:33:22]
compensation for all. 25
[1:33:24]
counselors and our office,
[1:33:27]
will be office of 12 so that
[1:33:28]
this budget does pressed to
[1:33:29]
fill vacancies that door and
[1:33:31]
just mentioned. That's kind of
[1:33:34]
where we're landau for the
[1:33:37]
2027 for counselor counselors
[1:33:39]
and a council staff does get a
[1:33:42]
cola this year is at 3%.
[1:33:43]
Counselors are not eligible
[1:33:47]
for stepping As for Stephen
[1:33:48]
Grey, as you guys have heard
[1:33:50]
amendment presentations, I do
[1:33:51]
not know what that looks like
[1:33:54]
for the council at this time
[1:33:55]
as it is still very much its
[1:33:56]
infancy as hr agoa fame or
[1:33:57]
navigating what that might
[1:34:02]
look like. Moving on to
[1:34:03]
character 3 hurt or 3 budget
[1:34:07]
is about $600,000 again with
[1:34:10]
majority of a two-thirds of it
[1:34:10]
going to internal backs that
[1:34:15]
is par I it's a that is
[1:34:17]
building authority. We and as
[1:34:18]
well as a few other charges
[1:34:19]
that we have the kind of go
[1:34:23]
along with that. Rest of our
[1:34:26]
budget goes exciting things
[1:34:26]
such as does the operations
[1:34:27]
are running as city county
[1:34:30]
offices. So that's our we have
[1:34:32]
some slurred legal support
[1:34:34]
contracts for We have
[1:34:36]
advertising because all
[1:34:36]
businesses and have to get
[1:34:40]
posted software for running
[1:34:42]
out those meetings and other
[1:34:46]
essential items that we have.
[1:34:49]
For characters to 45. Again,
[1:34:50]
not not really much happening
[1:34:54]
3,000 $1 to cover day-to-day.
[1:34:55]
The to that you see for
[1:34:56]
internal charge back here
[1:34:59]
fight. What we pay because we
[1:35:01]
have an in-house attorney.
[1:35:05]
Don't utilize ccs. Heavy as
[1:35:07]
some of the other But we do
[1:35:09]
have to utilize them in time
[1:35:10]
for they do So I think we're
[1:35:14]
getting them for a that $2500
[1:35:16]
and the other $2500 for
[1:35:18]
equipment. And that's we use
[1:35:20]
for various purposes for
[1:35:22]
computers. If chairs break
[1:35:22]
various items within the
[1:35:29]
office. In essence, go ahead,
[1:35:29]
will it? I would characterize
[1:35:32]
our budget is pretty lean, but
[1:35:34]
I would say that our staff
[1:35:39]
very We will lie largely on
[1:35:40]
I-10 or a in our relationships
[1:35:41]
throughout the enterprise to
[1:35:44]
get her work done. And with
[1:35:45]
thank you taking questions.
[1:35:46]
Think presentation, as for
[1:35:51]
Mary. Share a quick question
[1:35:53]
for them. Well, these
[1:35:55]
computers in the car were a
[1:35:57]
great idea. And we were all
[1:35:58]
news and we is in best thing.
[1:35:59]
We can invest your money in.
[1:36:04]
And I think 3 people view some
[1:36:05]
sense I've heard. Other
[1:36:06]
counselor counselor Cahill
[1:36:08]
said when he opens it, he has
[1:36:09]
to wait. 45 minutes for us to
[1:36:11]
an update to be able to use
[1:36:13]
it. So what can we do with
[1:36:14]
those and get mean, at this
[1:36:17]
point, I thought was year him.
[1:36:19]
So thank you for So I have
[1:36:20]
heard that a So we we do pay
[1:36:22]
for those. So we are currently
[1:36:23]
going to have to rebid our
[1:36:27]
staff or contract. But my
[1:36:30]
understanding it was used as a
[1:36:30]
secondary noting that the
[1:36:31]
findings with down, I believe
[1:36:32]
we can do voice vote even we
[1:36:35]
do another meeting rooms. But
[1:36:35]
that was the from my
[1:36:36]
understanding the primary
[1:36:37]
reason why we have a lot of
[1:36:39]
times as we look at
[1:36:41]
potentially having to shift to
[1:36:42]
a different voting platform.
[1:36:43]
I'm hoping that will be able
[1:36:43]
to come a little bit more and
[1:36:47]
from modernized system that
[1:36:48]
maybe were able to use app on
[1:36:49]
your or you something else to
[1:36:52]
do it voting. But let's go
[1:36:54]
down to that would be able to
[1:36:56]
let those that have You are
[1:36:59]
right. They are only for full
[1:37:02]
council meetings. That was
[1:37:04]
what we had intended use those
[1:37:06]
forward to get away from the
[1:37:09]
buttons. The time I had the
[1:37:09]
concern that some people have
[1:37:11]
enough trouble with the red
[1:37:12]
and green button. So I don't
[1:37:14]
think we need to implementing
[1:37:16]
technology. So I still have
[1:37:17]
that concern. I don't think we
[1:37:20]
need to go to this computer
[1:37:21]
system buttons. I've never
[1:37:21]
seen them not work. And I've
[1:37:25]
been here for going 10 years.
[1:37:27]
So I would go school whole
[1:37:28]
technology push. And if bugs
[1:37:29]
don't work, we've got a voice.
[1:37:31]
We know roll call, vote. I
[1:37:32]
don't want raise more money on
[1:37:37]
technology. We don't use.
[1:37:46]
This. With just a quick one.
[1:37:46]
Thank you. Why do we have a
[1:37:49]
charge back from? I s a, you
[1:37:52]
know, budget. We do have a
[1:37:53]
charge brings That's under
[1:37:57]
that under care to 3. So r I s
[1:38:02]
a charge backs. It wasn't part
[1:38:03]
of the 3.81 Yeah. That's a
[1:38:08]
part creating. So part of
[1:38:09]
that, too, that as well as
[1:38:10]
like we have to pay for dark
[1:38:17]
copiers. For the exact number
[1:38:18]
for I say, I can tell you so
[1:38:21]
far are controlled is the 3.81
[1:38:22]
I did not break it down, but
[1:38:24]
the exact amount that we pay,
[1:38:27]
I say the 3.81, but I can let
[1:38:29]
you know what that say did
[1:38:31]
switched to a billing model
[1:38:31]
that you can go online. Be
[1:38:33]
more than happy to share that
[1:38:35]
Lee and every month I review
[1:38:38]
it is about a quarter lack
[1:38:40]
period to make sure that's
[1:38:40]
accurate. Since we went to
[1:38:41]
actual face charges I say,
[1:38:49]
thanks. And you know what?
[1:38:50]
Thank you, MR. CHAIRMAN, thank
[1:38:53]
you both for your
[1:38:55]
presentation. I was chatting
[1:38:56]
with the assistant and mail
[1:38:58]
and I just wanted to publicly
[1:38:59]
publicly say thank you for
[1:39:01]
creating priorities that are
[1:39:04]
tangible that we all can work
[1:39:05]
towards. And then again, thank
[1:39:06]
you for all your efforts thus
[1:39:07]
far this year because I know
[1:39:10]
we throw a lot at you for a
[1:39:11]
small team. There's 25 of us.
[1:39:12]
And so just want to publicly
[1:39:13]
say thank you for all your
[1:39:17]
efforts. Instrument. Thanking.
[1:39:18]
Yeah. Thank you all. So you do
[1:39:22]
a great job. Anything else to
[1:39:27]
see any? We are adjourned 7