Agenda
We think we found an agenda here: https://oakland.legistar1.com/oakland/meetings/2026/7/9560_A___Concurrent_Meeting_of_the_Oakland_Redevelopment_Successor_Agency_and_the_City_Council_26-07-21__Agenda.pdf
Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
[7:25]
Good afternoon.
[7:29]
Good afternoon. And welcome to
[7:32]
the rule. The City Council
[7:35]
today, JULY 21st, the time
[7:36]
just 3.37 in this meeting show
[7:41]
come to order. The 4 I call
[7:42]
roll. I would like to give
[7:43]
instructions on how to submit
[7:45]
a speaker card to 4 items on
[7:47]
this agenda. If you're here in
[7:48]
person and participating and
[7:50]
would like to submit a speaker
[7:51]
card police not as a part in
[7:52]
turning into a Clark
[7:54]
representative either before
[7:56]
the item is called in to
[7:57]
record or late in the 2 hours
[7:58]
after the meeting began again,
[8:03]
the meeting began at 3.37 So
[8:07]
on lies because cards are of
[8:09]
all cards. Mission do 24 hours
[8:10]
before the meeting began. So
[8:12]
that has closed once again. If
[8:13]
you would like to speak to an
[8:14]
item on agenda again, thought
[8:17]
a speaker card turning into a
[8:18]
Clark representative either
[8:19]
before the item is called in
[8:22]
to record or 2 hours after
[8:24]
this meeting began, whichever
[8:24]
comes first with that. I will
[8:29]
now call roll. On role Council
[8:32]
member Brown is excused.
[8:36]
Councilmember Fife is excused.
[8:36]
Councilmember Guy, Crescent
[8:39]
Councilmember Houston, here.
[8:45]
Councilmember longer. Wang.
[8:49]
And Councilmember Chandran.
[8:51]
PRESIDENT. We have 5 members
[8:55]
present for skews 3 excuse
[8:56]
with that with I move on to
[8:59]
the first item sheremet 100,
[9:01]
you have any announcements.
[9:05]
Thank you. Yes, I have 2 quick
[9:06]
announcements because we are
[9:10]
in a very tight situation. We
[9:11]
will be with only 5 members
[9:12]
present. We will be reducing
[9:14]
speaker time to one minute. We
[9:16]
will all. There's also a
[9:17]
request from the
[9:21]
administration to pull item
[9:22]
5.1, which will be the first
[9:22]
on consent calendar. Thank
[9:26]
you. Thank you for that. So
[9:27]
with item, threes
[9:31]
modifications to the agenda,
[9:32]
assuming the council chair
[9:32]
just know that that is there
[9:35]
additional? Any other
[9:39]
modifications Okay. That now
[9:40]
moves through the agenda. Item
[9:43]
number 4 is consideration of
[9:43]
public hearings are no public
[9:45]
hearings on this agenda today.
[9:49]
We will now move to non
[9:51]
consent items. 5 so item 5.1 I
[9:53]
will read the item into
[9:56]
record. It is adopt one of the
[9:58]
following pieces of
[9:58]
legislation want a resolution
[9:59]
accepting the police
[10:01]
commission selection panel
[10:02]
slate of 2 commissioners,
[10:06]
Ricardo Garcia, Costa and
[10:07]
Johnny hears to serve on the
[10:09]
Oakland Police. Police
[10:10]
commission or it was Lucian
[10:11]
rejecting the police
[10:14]
commission selection panel,
[10:15]
slate of 2 commissioners,
[10:16]
Ricardo Garcia, Costa in
[10:19]
Johnny here to serve on the
[10:21]
Oakland Police Commission. I
[10:23]
do have 3 speakers for this
[10:24]
item. Thank to administration.
[10:29]
Go ahead. Good afternoon
[10:30]
Council. We're asking that the
[10:32]
item is withdrawn from the
[10:34]
agenda. The selection panel
[10:34]
hasn't had the opportunity to
[10:35]
consider the background checks
[10:37]
prior to submission to
[10:38]
council. And we would like to
[10:40]
note that the city charter
[10:41]
provides that if the city
[10:42]
council does not accept or
[10:44]
reject the slate within 60
[10:45]
days after take after
[10:47]
completion of the background
[10:49]
checks and submission by the
[10:51]
selection panel are designated
[10:54]
replacement shall be deemed
[10:55]
appointed. However, the
[10:56]
Oakland City Municipal Code
[10:58]
requires that the appointing
[11:00]
authority here. The selection
[11:01]
panel considers the background
[11:02]
checks prior 2 submission to
[11:04]
the council. And that has not
[11:06]
happened as such. The
[11:07]
background check process has
[11:10]
not yet been completed in
[11:11]
recommendation is not properly
[11:13]
before the council at this
[11:14]
time in there for the 60 day
[11:18]
time period cannot starter.
[11:19]
Thank MADAM Clerk. I know we
[11:20]
still have to read in public
[11:22]
comment even though the item
[11:23]
this poll do want to make sure
[11:24]
all the t's are crossed and
[11:26]
the I's are dotted before
[11:28]
voting on anything. So please
[11:28]
read in the public we'll do
[11:31]
thank you for that sheremet
[11:32]
100. So I will read in the
[11:34]
speakers for those who are
[11:35]
here in person. Please step up
[11:35]
to the podium. When I call
[11:36]
your name, please restate your
[11:40]
name for the record. If you
[11:41]
are participating online,
[11:43]
please raise your hand so I
[11:43]
can easily identify you. We
[11:45]
will take those who are in
[11:45]
person first followed by those
[11:48]
who are online. I have Blair
[11:51]
Beekman, gender in of Allah.
[11:55]
Welcome to in one minute the a
[11:58]
lot of time at this time.
[11:58]
Something is going on. It's
[12:03]
not right. 45 people apply to
[12:05]
be on the police commission.
[12:09]
One of those was Omar Pharma.
[12:09]
Off 10 were selected from the
[12:14]
45. Off, although was not
[12:16]
selected by any selection.
[12:18]
Panel member off Alma has been
[12:19]
on this on the police
[12:21]
commission. He's been on the
[12:23]
commission that deals with
[12:26]
Measure x. He has been on the
[12:28]
task force full re-imagining
[12:29]
policing. He has been a part
[12:34]
of the veterans. Issues. He's
[12:34]
been a part of the board
[12:38]
Security Committee. Pharma has
[12:39]
been a relevant participant.
[12:44]
He helped to develop the law
[12:46]
false alarm system with rep
[12:49]
Councilmember Kaplan. And
[12:52]
nobody saw to put him. As one
[12:55]
of the 10 candidates. That
[12:57]
black man is being targeted.
[13:02]
He's being top. Thank you for
[13:04]
your It's all we will now move
[13:05]
to the zone speakers. I have
[13:06]
Blair Beekman please unmute
[13:12]
yourself and you MAY begin.
[13:13]
Big Ben. Really nice words
[13:15]
from the previous public
[13:16]
commenter shoppers. An
[13:18]
interesting point of view. I
[13:19]
also think there's a point of
[13:22]
view that you're trying to
[13:25]
allow the one of the previous
[13:26]
candidates who supposed to be
[13:27]
a part of the future of the
[13:30]
police review process. You're
[13:32]
giving him another chance.
[13:33]
Omar, not so much. But this
[13:36]
other you are. These are both
[13:37]
people who are supposed to be
[13:40]
there. That administration did
[13:41]
not want, but you're still
[13:42]
trying now anyway, it's going
[13:46]
to more time now. Thank you
[13:47]
that you're trying. It's
[13:48]
really important that we try
[13:51]
tried to make clear that
[13:52]
community. Is that a really
[13:54]
important role in creating
[13:54]
good police review commission
[13:58]
in the past 10 years? We don't
[13:59]
I don't want to ruin that. I
[14:01]
don't want to. And then and in
[14:02]
most regions that people
[14:02]
tinkering with it, it sounds
[14:04]
like when they maybe shouldn't
[14:06]
be. So thank you. Sounds like
[14:08]
you are trying to address and
[14:11]
good luck. You can. And Thank
[14:13]
you for your comments. The
[14:16]
next speaker I I do not see
[14:17]
their hand raise in the queue,
[14:17]
but I do see another name. Let
[14:20]
me see if they. What name did
[14:21]
you sign up to speak for what
[14:26]
item? Hello? Yes. Can you hear
[14:27]
speak into resolution about
[14:30]
Riccardo Tisci a casa? Did you
[14:32]
sign up? I'm sorry. Go ahead.
[14:33]
Your My name is Judy Straw
[14:37]
year apologize. We don't have
[14:39]
a speaker card for you for
[14:40]
this item. So that concludes
[14:42]
our public commenters for this
[14:45]
item. Thank you. And there's
[14:46]
no action needed and he's been
[14:47]
withdrawn so we can move to
[14:48]
the next. I thank you so much
[14:55]
for that. So apologize.
[14:56]
Highland Terrier to chair to
[14:58]
the body. If we would need
[15:00]
vote on the action to withdraw
[15:04]
this item. Okay. Okay. I will
[15:05]
make the motion to withdraw
[15:05]
this item on the request of
[15:12]
the city administration. There
[15:13]
was a motion by much on trans
[15:15]
seconded by councilor be
[15:16]
Houston to remove withdraw
[15:22]
item. 5.1 on role. Council
[15:23]
member Brown excuse
[15:25]
Councilmember Fife excuse,
[15:31]
Councilmember Gallo. Houston
[15:36]
Long I. Sheremet, Andre, I
[15:38]
item number 5.1 withdrawn with
[15:42]
5 ayes, 3 excuse that now
[15:43]
takes us to item 5 point to
[15:45]
one moments. Bear with me
[15:46]
while reading this lengthy
[15:52]
title. Item, s 5.2 is adopt a
[15:53]
resolution authorizing the
[15:56]
city administrator to award
[15:57]
contracts to one Grand Prix
[15:59]
for ink in the amount not to
[16:01]
exceed 1 million, $400,000 to
[16:03]
provide collision repair and
[16:05]
body shops services for light
[16:08]
vehicles for a three-year term
[16:10]
SEPTEMBER. First 2026 to since
[16:13]
SEPTEMBER. First 2029 in 2
[16:13]
one-year options to renew in
[16:17]
response to the rfq 2 quality
[16:18]
body in vendor in the amount
[16:21]
not to exceed 1 million,
[16:22]
$50,000 to provide collision
[16:23]
repair and body shop services
[16:27]
for light vehicles for a
[16:29]
three-year term in 2 one-year
[16:29]
options to renew in response
[16:33]
to the Rfq 3 Falcon collision
[16:34]
repair eek in the amount not
[16:37]
to exceed $525,000 to provide
[16:39]
collision repair and body shop
[16:40]
services for light vehicles
[16:44]
for a three-year term and 2
[16:45]
one-year options to renew in
[16:46]
response to the Rfq for
[16:48]
Mueller are brothers body shop
[16:52]
any amount not to exceed?
[16:53]
$525,000 to provide collision
[16:56]
repair a body shop services
[16:58]
for light vehicles for a
[16:59]
three-year term and 2 one-year
[17:00]
options to renew a response to
[17:03]
the Rfq 5 Mola brother's body
[17:04]
shop in the amount not to
[17:07]
exceed 1 million, 750,000
[17:08]
dollars to provide collision
[17:10]
repair and body shop services
[17:11]
for him heavy vehicles for 8
[17:15]
the year term. And 2 one-year
[17:17]
options to renew in response.
[17:19]
The rfq Malkin collision
[17:21]
repair eec in the amount not
[17:24]
to exceed 1 million, 750,000
[17:25]
dollars to provide collision
[17:27]
repair shop services for heavy
[17:29]
vehicles for a three-year
[17:31]
term. And 2 one-year options
[17:32]
to renew in response to the
[17:37]
Rfq 7 making findings under
[17:37]
Oakland Municipal Code.
[17:43]
Section 2.0 4.0 5, 0 2.0 4.0
[17:44]
5, 1, and waiting for their
[17:47]
formal advertising in bidding
[17:48]
requirements. To the extent
[17:49]
necessary and adapting
[17:50]
appropriate California
[17:51]
Environmental Quality Act
[17:52]
findings. And I have 2
[17:56]
speakers for this item.
[17:57]
Figures thank you, MR. Be how
[17:58]
many minutes do you require
[18:04]
approximately? 3 minutes?
[18:08]
Thank you. Please. Go ahead.
[18:10]
Thank Richard. Better is the
[18:10]
assistant director bureau
[18:11]
maintenance, internal services
[18:14]
of Oakland Public works. I'm
[18:15]
here before you with contract
[18:18]
for collision repair brought
[18:20]
this before the Public Works
[18:22]
Committee previously, it's
[18:23]
approximately 7 million
[18:25]
dollars. He's exactly
[18:26]
7 million dollars contract
[18:26]
capacity in total for 3 years
[18:29]
with 2 one-year extensions.
[18:31]
The original proposal was to
[18:36]
make multiple awards to the 6
[18:36]
vendors noted during the
[18:41]
discussion of Public Works
[18:42]
Committee. There are some
[18:44]
concerns raised by council
[18:46]
members related to having more
[18:49]
Oakland based businesses
[18:52]
involved in that rfp. So
[18:52]
there's a resolution attached
[18:56]
to this agenda report that's
[18:58]
recommending award 2 quality
[18:59]
body and fender only Oakland
[19:03]
base body shop on this agenda
[19:04]
report. We do have some new
[19:05]
information. I thought it was
[19:08]
important to share with
[19:09]
counsel Councilmember Houston.
[19:11]
As we looked into the matter.
[19:12]
I'm not sure if your questions
[19:16]
were answered by purchasing,
[19:17]
but as we research with
[19:19]
quality body and fender, we
[19:20]
discovered that there are
[19:21]
smaller body shop. They're
[19:22]
only able to take one job at a
[19:26]
time from the city of Oakland.
[19:28]
So we've currently got 25
[19:29]
vehicles in accident repair
[19:32]
status. 23 of those are opd.
[19:33]
If we only award to quality
[19:35]
body has proposed in the other
[19:37]
resolution, it will slow down
[19:38]
the body repairs that were
[19:41]
able to perform. And also it's
[19:42]
been brought to my attention.
[19:44]
We have 280,000 an outstanding
[19:46]
invoices to Mueller are
[19:48]
brothers, which I'm not sure
[19:50]
if we have contract capacity
[19:51]
to pay all of those invoices.
[19:52]
Plus the work that's currently
[19:55]
at their shop. So there's a
[19:57]
better more information now
[19:58]
than we had at Public Works
[19:59]
Committee. And with that, I'm
[20:00]
available to take your
[20:04]
questions. Thank you.
[20:05]
Councilmember Houston, we are
[20:09]
fixing your mike situation.
[20:11]
But if you if but the club
[20:19]
will unmute you race. Through
[20:25]
chair. I have a a real issue.
[20:26]
But this and I understand you
[20:27]
get your research about
[20:30]
quality body. What about
[20:31]
Pacific collision in de 7 in
[20:32]
turmoil. Auto body, Dana have
[20:32]
out in the audience right now.
[20:38]
The problem that I have. I can
[20:40]
take that. The problem I have
[20:42]
is with this is not with you
[20:43]
is with the situation soon.
[20:46]
When I into office, it was
[20:47]
always waving the small local
[20:50]
business. Urgent emergency
[20:52]
right? So when you dealing
[20:54]
with body fender, this is not
[20:56]
mechanics because I understand
[20:58]
what councilmember guy always
[20:58]
speaks about. We have all
[21:01]
these cars in. This in the
[21:03]
yard. It's not being fix. So
[21:08]
this remove that. This is body
[21:10]
and fender. This is not some
[21:11]
high-tech right? And through
[21:13]
chair, I'd like to ask the
[21:15]
city attorney a question about
[21:18]
when they have to when we get
[21:22]
a contract from the we can't
[21:24]
use small local small local
[21:25]
business participation. Is
[21:32]
that true or not? Through the
[21:33]
chair to councilmember
[21:35]
Houston? We can. I can. We can
[21:35]
get back to you on the
[21:39]
specific item. One. It's that
[21:45]
it's the same same one would
[21:46]
get us of I go with so soggy.
[21:47]
Be the answer. Answer is we
[21:51]
cannot find instead of.
[21:52]
Answers that we can at. And
[21:54]
I'm not talking over you. City
[21:55]
attorneys just that we cannot
[21:56]
use to small local business
[21:56]
when it comes to that. This is
[22:01]
not something that's we urge
[22:02]
it matter or we have to go out
[22:06]
to a specialty is not. We have
[22:10]
in ways. District district. We
[22:11]
have many body shops well as
[22:13]
dish. We have many body shops
[22:14]
in my we probably have the
[22:16]
most by the shops Oakland.
[22:21]
Then the whole Alameda County
[22:21]
have a problem with spending
[22:22]
7 million dollars outside of
[22:22]
the city of Oakland. So with
[22:25]
this quality with this quality
[22:27]
you said is small. But I can
[22:34]
have we're smart guy.
[22:37]
Terrible. I do body because he
[22:39]
wasn't even notified it. He's
[22:42]
a vendor in ways District
[22:43]
wasn't even notified. They
[22:43]
said that he had to go online
[22:47]
or something like that. This
[22:48]
is request for qualification
[22:49]
is that cannot go you here all
[22:50]
day. Coming up here, real
[22:51]
quick and ask and I haven't
[22:53]
come up to the chair when we
[22:54]
move to public speakers going
[23:00]
on. So my issue is this. We've
[23:01]
got to stop Russian. All these
[23:02]
these projects outside of our
[23:04]
city because when I look at
[23:06]
this, I see here that and a
[23:09]
light duty. It was 10
[23:11]
companies that we reached out
[23:12]
to 5 was out of the city of
[23:15]
Oakland. If I was in the city
[23:17]
of Oakland on the heavy duty,
[23:26]
I see teen. There were. 3. 7
[23:28]
is 7 outside 3 inside the city
[23:30]
of Oakland. Right? That was
[23:33]
requested qualification. I
[23:34]
have a problem with this some
[23:35]
other issues is coming on and
[23:38]
does not have to do with you
[23:40]
that we keep going outside of
[23:42]
the city of Oakland to give up
[23:44]
this work. And I got and I
[23:45]
understand it now woke up in
[23:46]
the middle of the night. I
[23:47]
woke up and I was like, why is
[23:49]
it so easy for people to give?
[23:52]
Contracts out of my city?
[23:55]
Because they don't live here.
[24:01]
And I Watching him move. So
[24:03]
don't want this to go through.
[24:04]
I want this to be redone where
[24:08]
we go out Companies not
[24:10]
companies like Pacific
[24:11]
Collision. All the body shops
[24:12]
in our city and keep the
[24:15]
7 million dollars in our city
[24:16]
because I'm not going city law
[24:16]
got it now. I've got it now.
[24:21]
So thank you really quickly.
[24:22]
Councilmember Houston, your 3
[24:27]
minutes are a minute. Ok?
[24:32]
Sorry, okay. Thank you.
[24:33]
Because I did my research on
[24:36]
that one, too. You know, I
[24:38]
know how many minutes that guy
[24:38]
we had a fight when I first
[24:39]
got in office about my
[24:45]
minutes. But not for right.
[24:46]
What are we going to do about
[24:46]
this council members? We're
[24:48]
going to take the 7 million
[24:49]
dollars out and give it to
[24:50]
others when we can keep it
[24:51]
inside our own city. What are
[24:55]
we going to do? Ask you I
[24:56]
don't want this to go out to
[24:57]
know other body and vendors.
[25:00]
This is not some tank. This is
[25:01]
body offender, right? So I
[25:03]
want to keep it here, Want
[25:07]
enough business to be? He
[25:08]
wasn't even reached out. He's
[25:09]
qualified to s l b e said it
[25:11]
wasn't even notify 4 and he
[25:16]
was he was. Had a serious
[25:20]
situation. A car crashed into
[25:24]
his business. Stopped his
[25:30]
business. Now he's back up.
[25:31]
Why we final $4,000 for some
[25:34]
find out about that, too. And
[25:36]
he had the encampments in his
[25:37]
area which was harming his
[25:38]
business. Now it's time to be
[25:42]
able embrace him. And brace
[25:42]
these companies. That's what I
[25:46]
want to do. And almost and 10
[25:48]
toes down for the company's in
[25:50]
Oakland, a small local
[25:51]
businesses, Latino, my black
[25:52]
brothers and sisters. That's
[25:55]
where I'm standing on. You'll
[25:55]
the floor and I want to see
[25:56]
what my council members had to
[25:58]
say about this. Is that a
[26:02]
motion accounts under 2? Hold
[26:05]
this. To dispense of this item
[26:05]
and ask public works to come
[26:07]
back with other
[26:08]
recommendations or yes, that's
[26:12]
the motion. Okay to the
[26:12]
parliamentarian. What is the
[26:14]
right up to the city
[26:15]
administrator place? Thank
[26:17]
you. I just want to clear what
[26:19]
clarify one thing that right
[26:21]
now the public works is
[26:21]
bringing back the proposal
[26:26]
that was approved by the
[26:27]
committee, which was to limit
[26:33]
approval to the local. The
[26:33]
local company called quality
[26:36]
body and Fender. So that is
[26:38]
the proposal in front of you.
[26:41]
I did want to also encourage
[26:43]
you to consider adding item 5
[26:45]
the Mueller brothers contract
[26:49]
because we do owe them money.
[26:50]
And then the remainder of that
[26:54]
money. Public works would come
[26:57]
back and do another proposal
[27:00]
based on further outreach to
[27:02]
local businesses because of
[27:02]
his knee will come back to
[27:03]
that. I just want to clarify
[27:06]
in the packet, the
[27:06]
supplemental legislation. Does
[27:09]
have what's be reflected from
[27:11]
the committee. So all of these
[27:12]
other companies except for the
[27:14]
one that's from Oakland,
[27:15]
quality body and Fender has
[27:18]
been removed. If we vote on
[27:19]
this item and we can take into
[27:21]
consideration if we want that
[27:24]
back. One of the non Oakland
[27:25]
companies, because the money
[27:28]
comes under long, the number.
[27:30]
Thank you. And yeah, I just
[27:34]
wanted to support my
[27:35]
councilmember fellow
[27:36]
Councilmember Houston's
[27:37]
comments. I think for me the
[27:39]
concern is who gets the
[27:40]
invitation, you know, in the
[27:43]
first place right? The fact
[27:45]
that we have if you go down
[27:47]
International Boulevard, many,
[27:49]
many auto body shops. Now I've
[27:51]
learned that a number of them
[27:54]
actually have the city's fl b
[27:55]
e certification and they did
[27:58]
not get the invitation that
[27:59]
that is concerning. I think
[28:01]
something that I would just
[28:03]
agree that we need to. We need
[28:04]
to do better and we need to
[28:06]
make sure that the small and
[28:09]
local businesses if you know,
[28:10]
of course we want, we want to
[28:10]
make sure they can do the job.
[28:14]
But what people don't get
[28:16]
invitation right. That
[28:17]
automatically puts them at a
[28:19]
disadvantage to not even
[28:20]
respond to the rfq in the
[28:20]
first place. And that's not
[28:25]
right. Just a point of
[28:28]
clarification for the city
[28:30]
administration for Mueller are
[28:32]
brothers. Is it item 4, 5, are
[28:35]
just for that. I think you
[28:37]
could do it. Just item 5. Just
[28:42]
with item 5. And then 1, 1,
[28:44]
other clarification in terms
[28:48]
of who gets the invitations pw
[28:50]
is not. I will be working with
[28:52]
purchasing, which is the
[28:53]
entity in the city that puts
[28:54]
out the rfp. So it's pw its
[28:56]
purchasing. And I'm happy to
[28:58]
be working with them in
[28:59]
concert with the council
[29:01]
members to be sure that we
[29:02]
have the appropriate list.
[29:03]
Thank you. Okay. Thank you.
[29:07]
Keep count on So my
[29:09]
understanding is we're voting
[29:13]
on the amended resolution as
[29:14]
amended by Councilmember
[29:14]
Houston and the rest of the
[29:17]
committee to just go with the
[29:18]
local vendor because if we
[29:20]
don't do that, we will not be
[29:22]
able to repair any of our
[29:23]
vehicles until the until after
[29:26]
recess. I think this is
[29:26]
reasonable to just go with the
[29:28]
local vendors that we can, you
[29:29]
know, limp through the recess
[29:33]
and then public works will
[29:34]
bring us bring us back. But I
[29:35]
would also like to make a
[29:42]
motion to add in item 5. Thank
[29:43]
you for MADAM Chair. If I can
[29:47]
make one clarification both
[29:48]
the committee's recommendation
[29:48]
and the original item or
[29:51]
before the spot. The for your
[29:53]
full consideration just
[29:55]
clarify. So you can. You can
[29:57]
also consider the original.
[29:59]
Has proposed I would like to
[30:00]
go go with the item as amended
[30:01]
by councilmember he's
[30:04]
committee and add an item 5.
[30:05]
Thank you. Councilmember
[30:12]
Houston. Yes, understand a
[30:12]
chance to what you're doing. A
[30:16]
cast member on her is panned
[30:17]
individual from Mueller's so
[30:18]
they can get paid correct
[30:19]
their company. How much of
[30:22]
through chair, how much of the
[30:26]
old not to the chair. 280,000
[30:27]
okay, outstanding invoices and
[30:28]
potential work that has not
[30:28]
been invoiced yet. That's
[30:29]
currently in their shop. And
[30:32]
how much is that? Don't have
[30:34]
that information give you
[30:35]
estimate. Not at the assistant
[30:38]
director level. Okay. So
[30:42]
they're in San Leandro. Yes.
[30:44]
Okay. Through I researched and
[30:46]
San Leandro. So accept that.
[30:49]
Given Mueller that money and
[30:51]
the cars. It's already in
[30:53]
there that we committed to
[30:54]
makes no sense to pull
[30:54]
something, agree with that.
[30:57]
But moving forward, I'm not
[30:59]
agree with that and that other
[31:00]
none of that So accept that
[31:01]
this move it like you said a
[31:06]
cast member on. Thank you.
[31:07]
Council member would like to
[31:14]
second that motion amendment.
[31:15]
Before move to public comment.
[31:17]
I have a clarifying question.
[31:18]
So I'm in full support of
[31:21]
moving forward with the
[31:22]
contract with one Oakland
[31:24]
company on this list, quality
[31:25]
body in fender and adding and
[31:26]
Mueller are brothers because
[31:28]
they have an outstanding
[31:31]
amount owed. What is the
[31:34]
approximate practices? The
[31:35]
city administrator of looking
[31:38]
into other Oakland vendors. I
[31:39]
will be working with
[31:40]
purchasing over the recess
[31:41]
that we can bring it back.
[31:43]
Hopefully on the first or
[31:46]
second meeting. Thank you.
[31:48]
MADAM Clerk, we can move to
[31:50]
public. Thank you so much. As
[31:51]
i call your name, please
[31:52]
approach the podium. If you're
[31:55]
here in person, if you're
[31:56]
online, please raise your hand
[31:57]
so I can easily identify you
[31:58]
will start with those who are
[32:01]
in person visits out on the
[32:01]
Bala and she's in Blair
[32:07]
Beekman. In any order you MAY
[32:09]
postpone if your person and I
[32:10]
called running in apologies.
[32:20]
If I mispronounced names. Hi,
[32:21]
my name's in it's good to see
[32:22]
council members. Want to see
[32:27]
you guys. And I run. But he's
[32:30]
an open lot over. 36 years and
[32:35]
I to come up labor. And are so
[32:36]
I have knowledge he's going to
[32:37]
him to take the intonation,
[32:42]
prove it. And I reached and
[32:45]
know that the city has auto
[32:46]
repair program. So if you knew
[32:54]
it, private too. So a lot. I
[32:55]
really appreciate of you. Did
[32:57]
it. You know, consideration
[33:00]
lauding told one of my shop,
[33:01]
too, put up a put 8 in the
[33:03]
city on a cruise program.
[33:06]
Thank you very much.
[33:12]
Councilmember Houston.
[33:12]
Apologize. MADAM Clerk, I
[33:13]
think Council Houston's Mike
[33:15]
is the only one that I can't
[33:17]
tap on right there. Go to
[33:18]
chair. Want to know if you
[33:20]
have anything else to say
[33:21]
because I would like for you
[33:24]
to share with just real
[33:26]
briefly about the condition
[33:27]
that your company was in and
[33:28]
the condition the things that
[33:32]
it had to indoor. With
[33:33]
business. And then that
[33:36]
accident that happened where
[33:37]
that car rammed it to go shut
[33:39]
you down and you open company
[33:40]
did been here for how many
[33:42]
years 30. Think you over to
[33:44]
over 36 years. You hear
[33:46]
audience. Do you hear that?
[33:51]
36, shouldn't. We? Supporting
[33:53]
our businesses that was here
[33:54]
in the good and bad times of
[33:55]
Oakland, California, where we
[34:01]
live. Most of us. So. Go a to
[34:04]
b. I know Clinton. My
[34:19]
hometown. On 2 years of all.
[34:22]
So one of ladies, young Navy.
[34:28]
Some of all of thing. And I
[34:33]
have a very hard time. I last
[34:34]
2 years over 16 and Donna
[34:39]
Gross income. I have a more
[34:41]
than 32 workers not always to
[34:45]
the use of 14. And we had we
[34:46]
tried to put out the permits
[34:49]
to local n. Or so city down
[34:53]
action line. And I talked to
[35:01]
and there. I almost crossed
[35:01]
And if taking other permitted
[35:04]
to And then I have a from
[35:09]
Open. There's still I rent
[35:14]
power line for some Every
[35:19]
month I pay for over $2000.
[35:20]
I'm losing money for even
[35:24]
year. If I keep team going
[35:25]
like these I met, I MAY have
[35:29]
to close down all regions. I
[35:30]
have taken the key continues.
[35:34]
Money. And to So I have one
[35:41]
now 40 people from Thank chair
[35:42]
some say this to the audience
[35:42]
and taught of people is this
[35:46]
it 2, you can sit down now. Do
[35:46]
we want to treat up Oakland
[35:48]
businesses like that? No, we
[35:55]
do not. 36 years in the game
[35:56]
support and hiring our folks
[35:57]
and he had to suffer like
[35:59]
this. We need embrace
[36:01]
businesses so they stay and do
[36:02]
not leave. Let me share this
[36:04]
with everybody. I bought it
[36:06]
now. It takes me some time to
[36:12]
get it. When I got I got it.
[36:13]
And I'm about to fight for my
[36:14]
folks. And let me share this
[36:16]
with you. In closing my
[36:16]
cousin. Daryl Kerry used to
[36:20]
say this. And I remember used
[36:22]
to say to me all the time. He
[36:26]
said if you not mad now. When
[36:27]
you get mad and I'm mad
[36:28]
because I'm with my for my
[36:33]
folks. Think. Thank you. And
[36:36]
if I MAY acknowledging the
[36:37]
presence of Councilmember
[36:39]
Brown who is now participating
[36:41]
remotely for all 6, thank you.
[36:42]
Thank you. And we have one
[36:44]
more speaker for this item or
[36:47]
do if we can pause to allow
[36:49]
the parliamentarian to ask a
[36:49]
necessary questions of council
[36:53]
member Brown. Before she is
[36:57]
allowed to proceed remotely.
[36:59]
Pursuant to the ground at
[37:00]
participating remotely under
[37:04]
the just cause basis requires
[37:04]
the member participating
[37:05]
remotely to disclose whether
[37:06]
there is anyone in the room
[37:07]
with them. That is 18 years or
[37:11]
older. No, there's not. Thank
[37:19]
you. Thank you for that. And
[37:22]
our last speaker apologies. Is
[37:25]
Blair beat men. You've you.
[37:26]
Did you manage your soap and
[37:26]
begin your comments for item s
[37:34]
by 0.2? I apologize. Lost know
[37:39]
that. Just just for just for
[37:41]
the council members reference,
[37:42]
even though we have
[37:44]
councilmember Brown online, we
[37:45]
need 5 members present at the
[37:49]
diocese for If any
[37:51]
councilmembers need to take a
[37:52]
break, we can call a short
[37:57]
Just letting a thank you.
[37:58]
They're beating. You MAY be
[38:01]
resume your comments. Thank
[38:02]
you. Well, thank you. Blair
[38:04]
Beekman. I don't have any
[38:04]
public comment. I passed for
[38:06]
this item so that can help but
[38:08]
things right now. Thank you.
[38:09]
Thank you so much, Blair and
[38:12]
that closure costs public.
[38:15]
Commenters for item that 5.2,
[38:17]
thank Believes is a motion a
[38:19]
second. Thank you so much. On
[38:21]
this item, we have a motion by
[38:22]
Councilmember Houston,
[38:24]
seconded by Councilmember
[38:27]
Unger to approve item 5.2 as
[38:29]
amended approving committee's
[38:29]
recommendations from the JULY
[38:33]
14th. Committee meeting of
[38:36]
noting that we're keeping
[38:37]
contract quality body and
[38:41]
fenders only and the
[38:43]
additional amendment added
[38:43]
today in Council of the
[38:46]
Mueller Brother's body. Part 5
[38:50]
of this, a title it. And with
[38:51]
that motion on role for this
[38:53]
item as amended council member
[39:01]
Brown. As a Councilmember Fife
[39:02]
is excuse councilmember Gile.
[39:08]
I. Councilmember Houston. I
[39:09]
councilmember Unger
[39:11]
Councilmember Wang, chair
[39:13]
Ramachandran. I item number 5
[39:14]
is approved as amended with 6
[39:18]
ayes to excused. And we are
[39:22]
now going to move to item s
[39:29]
5.3, the appropriating
[39:29]
allocating 50 million dollars
[39:31]
of proceeds of the sale of the
[39:32]
city of Oakland and divided
[39:33]
50% interest in the Coliseum
[39:37]
complex of California. Public
[39:38]
employees, retirement systems
[39:39]
for a discretionary payment of
[39:43]
the city's unfunded accrued
[39:46]
liability. For Retirement
[39:47]
benefits. And there are quite
[39:50]
a few speakers for this item.
[39:51]
And MADAM Clerk, we do need an
[39:54]
urgency finding under the sun.
[39:54]
Yes, miles from we see that
[39:57]
does appear to provide the
[39:58]
basis. Thank you. I will make
[40:04]
the agency finding so staff
[40:06]
will make holidays. They will
[40:07]
request agency finding and
[40:11]
then vote on it. Thank you to
[40:12]
Terre 100 Johnson, director of
[40:13]
finance. The urgency for this
[40:14]
item is should the city agreed
[40:16]
before council's returns from
[40:17]
its recess and conclude the
[40:21]
sale but of its transaction ac
[40:23]
for the sale, the Coliseum,
[40:24]
this city would be who to
[40:26]
present to transmit the
[40:27]
funding immediately to
[40:29]
California public employees,
[40:31]
retirement system to maximize
[40:33]
the savings in long term costs
[40:37]
from the copper system by
[40:38]
accruing appropriate returns
[40:40]
in the Calpers system from the
[40:42]
supplementary investment. I
[40:44]
should note that this
[40:46]
particular item was included
[40:47]
in the fiscal impact. Summary
[40:47]
of your ordinance approving
[40:50]
the Coliseum sale on the
[40:52]
advice of attorney. Pull it
[40:53]
apart separately. Just that we
[40:54]
have clear directive and
[40:57]
advice on this item. But this
[40:57]
was the intent anticipated use
[41:01]
of the sale proceeds. I will
[41:01]
also note that the item
[41:06]
itself. Does not include any
[41:09]
allocation of the city savings
[41:10]
in ongoing cost from the
[41:13]
operating costs of the
[41:14]
coliseum gpa. Nor does it
[41:16]
preclude a particular costs on
[41:17]
the revenue sharing agreement.
[41:18]
That is also a component of
[41:20]
that item. This is simply on
[41:24]
the sale of the arena. I would
[41:24]
have happy to answer any
[41:25]
questions. And again, the
[41:28]
urgency for the item is to get
[41:29]
it to purse immediately so
[41:30]
that it can begin Turner
[41:31]
return and maximize the city's
[41:32]
long-term savings. Thank you
[41:35]
for that urges. We need a
[41:35]
motion that we can Conroe for
[41:36]
the agency. Now, I will make
[41:37]
the motion. Is there a second?
[41:41]
I got And there was a motion
[41:44]
by much 100 seconded by
[41:46]
Councilmember Unger to approve
[41:47]
the urgency stated on Record
[41:51]
Council member Brown.
[41:58]
Councilmember Plant. Fyfe is
[42:00]
excuse Councilmember Gallo. I
[42:00]
Councilmember Houston. I
[42:05]
councilmember I and chair
[42:07]
Ramachandran. I item number
[42:10]
skews me the urgency finding
[42:11]
for item s 5.3 was approved
[42:16]
with 6 ayes to excuse thank
[42:19]
Now we can move council under
[42:24]
comment. Okay. Thank So I will
[42:29]
start with a quick question.
[42:30]
How much pension liabilities
[42:34]
does the city have right now?
[42:35]
The city has over 2 billion
[42:36]
dollars in liabilities, not
[42:37]
attached to the Calpers
[42:39]
system. Thank you. And a quick
[42:40]
follow-up question by asked
[42:43]
paying 50 million of it.
[42:44]
What's the benefit to the city
[42:47]
of starting pay this down as
[42:48]
the city begins to pay down
[42:50]
process, we achieve savings
[42:51]
and I would liken this to
[42:52]
paying down the bill on a high
[42:54]
interest credit card. The
[42:58]
sooner you make a payment, the
[42:59]
lower your over the payment to
[43:00]
make overtime is you'll accrue
[43:01]
the savings on your future
[43:02]
bill, because your minimum
[43:03]
payments will be less. This
[43:04]
will provide future ongoing
[43:06]
savings. The city and future
[43:08]
fiscal years. Thank you,
[43:10]
colleagues. Any questions.
[43:12]
Okay. We can move to public
[43:13]
speakers. Thank you so much.
[43:14]
As I call your name if you're
[43:17]
here in chambers, please
[43:18]
approach the podium in any
[43:20]
order and state your name for
[43:20]
the record. If you're
[43:21]
participating online, please
[43:22]
raise your hand. We will take
[43:25]
those who are in person first,
[43:30]
David Peters player, men.
[43:33]
Dominique Riley, to Lani.
[43:36]
There are Jon Santos, Jon
[43:41]
Jones, the 3rd asada, Bala and
[43:41]
Jeanne Hazard in any order
[43:42]
again, if I called your name
[43:43]
and I mispronounced name. I
[43:46]
apologize in advance. But if
[43:47]
you are participating in
[43:49]
person and you want to speak
[43:51]
to item s 5.3, please approach
[43:54]
the podium. If not, we will go
[43:55]
to those who are online. But
[43:56]
if I called your name and you
[43:57]
signed up for this item. Thank
[44:12]
you.
[44:14]
Good afternoon,
[44:19]
everybody. My name is John
[44:20]
Santos on Bay Area resident
[44:21]
for 71 years and an Oakland
[44:26]
resident for the last 36. If
[44:27]
we citizens workers and
[44:28]
artisan Oakland have come to
[44:29]
understand anything at all.
[44:30]
It's that the arts are not
[44:34]
only a replaceable, but I
[44:35]
absolutely and urgently
[44:37]
necessary for our sanity. And
[44:41]
for our very survival.
[44:41]
Nothing's more important,
[44:42]
effective and powerful lesson
[44:45]
generator of unity and love in
[44:48]
our efforts to confront the
[44:48]
absurd and open hostility of
[44:49]
the federal government towards
[44:50]
people of color across the
[44:54]
nation and the globe. The arts
[44:56]
must be a priority if we have
[44:57]
any hope of Oakland continuing
[44:58]
to rise and represent real
[45:01]
justice and solidarity among
[45:02]
working class communities both
[45:05]
locally and internationally
[45:06]
wholeheartedly supporting the
[45:06]
arts is the most logical
[45:08]
investment you can make.
[45:13]
You'll be generating jobs,
[45:13]
revenue, wide-ranging
[45:14]
collaboration, civic Pride,
[45:16]
Great Beauty and real hope.
[45:18]
Police said a glowing example
[45:20]
and do the right thing by
[45:23]
designee. I time crisis. Thank
[45:27]
you so much for your comments.
[45:28]
If I called your name, I have
[45:29]
Mississauga Jon Jones that
[45:32]
urging hazard I'm Jon Jones.
[45:34]
The 3rd is waiving his
[45:35]
opportunity to speak at this
[45:42]
time for Adam by 0.3 Okay. I'm
[45:47]
going to take. This time to
[45:50]
make a statement. We had a
[45:52]
public safety committee
[45:55]
meeting and somebody video, my
[45:57]
participation in that meeting.
[46:01]
And they the video. Was
[46:02]
misrepresenting what actually
[46:05]
happened. It made it seem like
[46:09]
Councilmember Wang. Was
[46:14]
victimizing me. Councilmember
[46:15]
Wang hit every white to
[46:18]
request me. To stop disrupting
[46:19]
the meeting. She did nothing
[46:23]
wrong. The video is being
[46:24]
shown as of Councilmember
[46:26]
long. Was attacking his old
[46:29]
Black lady. That is not the
[46:35]
case at all. If I'm a victim.
[46:36]
I know how to defend myself. I
[46:38]
don't need no video out. They
[46:39]
circulate an trying to help
[46:41]
me. This was an effort to but
[46:43]
it was not anything that she
[46:51]
did wrong. Apologies,
[46:56]
business. Think MISTER Has or
[46:57]
you want to speak to item 5.3,
[47:03]
if not, we will move MR.
[47:05]
Hazzard are you speaking to
[47:10]
item 3? I ok, thank One moment
[47:11]
why we're having technical
[47:13]
issues online that will go to
[47:13]
it's a hazard is now speaking
[47:23]
to item 5. Thank you. I'm glad
[47:25]
that this first phase, the
[47:29]
Coliseum. Has been completed.
[47:32]
But we have a long way to go.
[47:34]
This. Is that going to happen
[47:38]
overnight? As hoopla would
[47:41]
have us to really. It's going
[47:45]
to be a long process. Breaking
[47:47]
ground ribbon. Catty. Shovel
[47:52]
in the ground. My guesstimate
[47:55]
is only guess um. Maybe 10
[48:01]
years. Before we see anything.
[48:05]
So I would only caution Going
[48:10]
forward. That's ain't going
[48:14]
happen. Just like that. Took a
[48:14]
long time to get where we are
[48:18]
is going to it. Take a long
[48:18]
time to get where we're
[48:28]
supposed to be. Apologies.
[48:31]
MISTER Has a juror time is at
[48:32]
well now need it moved to the
[48:37]
zone. Speakers. If I called
[48:39]
name and you are here online,
[48:40]
please raise your hand so I
[48:43]
can easily identify you. Blair
[48:43]
Beekman, you're on muted. You
[48:48]
you to begin. I thank you.
[48:48]
Blair, big front, very brave
[48:53]
words from a all Thank you
[48:58]
very much. I wanted to comment
[49:02]
I'm interested in how isn't
[49:04]
the Oakland Arena deal? A part
[49:07]
of the a's county Part of the
[49:09]
sale. Where is Oakland is the
[49:12]
stadium's part of the sale?
[49:15]
How is that? The negotiation
[49:16]
process going Alameda County
[49:18]
and Can we count on them to
[49:19]
come through with this plan? A
[49:21]
retirement plan for the
[49:21]
Oakland community? I really
[49:25]
hope you can. We're working on
[49:26]
tax Lee and forgiveness, ideas
[49:27]
that I think can be a good
[49:29]
negotiating tool with Alameda
[49:31]
County towards best practices
[49:32]
for everyone. Good luck and
[49:36]
those efforts good luck we
[49:38]
address retirement plans, it's
[49:40]
really this is a really
[49:41]
important item for open. We
[49:42]
can't. And our retirement
[49:42]
plans for Oakland City
[49:43]
workers. Can we take a cut in
[49:45]
pay 50 bucks a month
[49:49]
translates to 600. Thank you
[49:56]
for your I. Hello if you
[49:57]
signed up to speak for an item
[49:58]
under 5.3, can you state your
[50:05]
name? On any day? Bpd in
[50:06]
yearly. Thank you, MR. P's,
[50:07]
you MAY begin your time. Thank
[50:13]
you very much. I want to
[50:16]
remind this council of the
[50:18]
work fire town says I believe
[50:25]
in 2014 council passed. As
[50:26]
part of a consolidate
[50:28]
consolidate House, the
[50:30]
resolution that directed that
[50:34]
net gain of the city's did
[50:35]
city sure the gain from this
[50:35]
property and other similar
[50:36]
properties would go to the
[50:38]
Affordable Housing trust.
[50:41]
Clearly the 2014 council was
[50:42]
much more cognizant and
[50:45]
willing to direct money to
[50:46]
affordable housing. So I think
[50:47]
now we have a lot of people
[50:49]
that talk about what they're
[50:50]
going to do for affordable
[50:51]
housing when the opportunity
[50:54]
comes actually direct these
[50:55]
50 million dollars to the
[50:57]
Affordable Housing Trust Fund
[50:58]
as designated by prior counsel
[51:02]
council drop the ball. And so
[51:03]
it's very unfortunate that we
[51:05]
say what we were going to
[51:06]
about homelessness and
[51:07]
affordable housing when the
[51:08]
money is actually there. We
[51:09]
decide to stay in house we're
[51:12]
at. Thank you for your
[51:16]
comments. I a all names have
[51:17]
been called for this item, but
[51:18]
if I MAY through the chair,
[51:21]
the air is some technical
[51:22]
issues. The live streaming
[51:23]
right now. So I don't think
[51:24]
that is accessible. So we just
[51:27]
need to make that known for
[51:28]
the public that our online
[51:29]
streaming is currently having
[51:30]
technical issues and we're
[51:44]
trying to get that up.
[51:46]
So if
[51:47]
you search Kate, have my
[51:48]
apologies. If you Kate have
[51:50]
online, it's live. But link on
[51:52]
the Web site is not accurate,
[51:53]
but it is currently streaming
[51:53]
live. You just have to lock
[51:54]
onto it. So just knowing that
[51:58]
the So again, that closure
[51:59]
speakers for this item, 5
[52:04]
point 3. Thank you. I will
[52:04]
entertain a motion to move the
[52:08]
item.
[52:15]
Second, Thank you for that. I
[52:16]
do. We got believe we got a
[52:17]
second from Councilmember
[52:19]
Gallo. So there was a motion
[52:22]
by Councilmember Unger,
[52:22]
seconded by Councilmember
[52:25]
guile to approve item. S 5.3
[52:29]
And as is on role. Council
[52:33]
member Brown. 5, his excuse
[52:36]
COUNCILMAN Guy. I
[52:38]
Councilmember Houston. I
[52:43]
councilmember anger. I Wang
[52:44]
thank you. Missus Can I say
[52:48]
that? Okay. And chair
[52:52]
Ramachandran I item s 0.5, 5.3
[52:54]
was approved with 6 ayes and
[53:00]
to excused. That now takes us
[53:01]
to item to the consent
[53:07]
calendar. I will read in the
[53:09]
short titles to the consent
[53:10]
calendar item. 6.1 is
[53:12]
approved. The draft minutes
[53:15]
for the committee meeting on
[53:16]
7/7/2026 item 6.2 declaration
[53:18]
of a local emergency due to
[53:20]
aids item. 6.3, a declaration
[53:23]
of a medical cannabis health
[53:24]
emergency item, 6.4
[53:25]
declaration of a local
[53:27]
emergency of homelessness.
[53:31]
Item 6.5, League of California
[53:33]
Cities 2026 annual conference
[53:37]
in Expo reimbursement item.
[53:38]
6.6 Congressional Black
[53:40]
Caucus, 2026 legislative
[53:44]
conference reimbursement.
[53:50]
Item, 6.7 Is the consolidation
[53:50]
of the city of Oakland's
[53:51]
NOVEMBER. 3rd, general
[53:52]
municipal election. This
[53:56]
ordinance is proved on final
[54:02]
passage item. 6.8 amendment to
[54:04]
the ordinance. Number 1, 2, 1,
[54:06]
8, 7, the salary ordinance for
[54:08]
the bear. Various
[54:09]
classifications. And this
[54:10]
item, this ordinance was
[54:14]
approved on final passage.
[54:15]
Item, 6.9 amendment to the
[54:16]
ordinance. Number 1, 2, 1, 8,
[54:21]
7, Salary for the council
[54:22]
members, city attorney and the
[54:26]
city auditor. This ordinance
[54:28]
is approved on final passage
[54:32]
item. 6.10 It is the sale of
[54:35]
the 3.19 Chester Street. This
[54:38]
ordinance will be approved on
[54:42]
final passage item. 6.11 for
[54:42]
me. The city of Oakland,
[54:45]
Sanctuary City policy. This
[54:46]
ordinance to will be if
[54:47]
approved on final passage
[54:55]
item. 6.12 This is the 2026
[54:56]
municipal Planning Code
[54:57]
amendments. This ordinance
[54:58]
will be approved on final
[55:05]
passage. Item. 6.13, a
[55:09]
resolution in support of ab 15
[55:13]
88 item. 6.14 consists of 2
[55:14]
pieces of legislation in this
[55:16]
is the final contract map.
[55:18]
Number 8, 6, 9, 7, a
[55:21]
subdivision map in final track
[55:24]
map Subdivision map on parcel
[55:26]
10 item 6.15, is the Bay Area,
[55:30]
urban areas, Security
[55:32]
Initiative 2025 to 2030 m o
[55:38]
you. Item 6.16 district, 6
[55:39]
appointment to the Cannabis
[55:43]
Regulatory Commission item
[55:45]
6.17 point minutes to the
[55:49]
state advisory board item 6.18
[55:51]
is a reappointment to
[55:51]
children's initiative.
[55:55]
Citizens Oversight Commission.
[55:56]
Item 6.19 is an appointment to
[55:59]
the Cultural Affairs
[56:01]
Commission item 6.20
[56:03]
appointment to the privacy
[56:06]
Advisory Commission item 6.0
[56:07]
21, a resolution in support of
[56:11]
sb 954. Item, 6.0 22 amendment
[56:12]
to the Cultural Affairs
[56:14]
Commission enabling ordinance.
[56:16]
This ordinance is approved
[56:17]
introduction. Final passage
[56:20]
would be SEPTEMBER. 15th item
[56:21]
6.23 Encampment management and
[56:27]
abatement re shuns. Item. 6.0
[56:28]
24 Ray Mueller versus the city
[56:34]
of Oakland. Item s 6.0 25
[56:37]
Second Amendment to Coliseum
[56:40]
complex and sale agreement.
[56:43]
This ordinance is a proved on
[56:49]
final passage. Item s 6.0 25
[56:51]
the grant funds for the
[56:52]
Oakland fun for the purpose of
[56:56]
the technology audit. This
[57:02]
item item s 0.6 To 7 the
[57:04]
fiscal year. 25 through 28
[57:06]
citywide strategic plan. One
[57:09]
yr update item 6.0 28 the
[57:12]
parking operations contract
[57:16]
extension item. 6.0 29 is the
[57:16]
reimbursement resolution,
[57:18]
general obligation, but bonds.
[57:24]
Item 6 point 3, 0 professional
[57:25]
services agreement with that.
[57:27]
We very until Ted, we'll ll
[57:28]
for llp for Forensic Audit
[57:33]
Services. Item. 6.0 31 is the
[57:34]
ac transit Fruitvale Avenue.
[57:35]
Corporate co-operative
[57:39]
agreements. Item s 6.0 32
[57:42]
municipal facility, energy
[57:45]
Assessment, Professional
[57:47]
Services agreement item 6.0 33
[57:50]
is $750,000 Bay Area. Air
[57:50]
Quality Management District
[57:58]
Grant. Item s 6.0 34 the
[57:58]
Broadway streetscape
[57:59]
improvement Construction
[58:05]
contract award. Item s 6.0 35
[58:07]
is re ap 2 point oh, hit funds
[58:08]
for the west. Oakland Uvm
[58:14]
pilot. Item s 6.0 36, the
[58:16]
city's response to the 2025
[58:16]
2026. Alameda County Civil
[58:21]
Grand Jury report. Item s 6.0
[58:22]
37 is the professional
[58:23]
services contract amendment
[58:25]
with the alta Planning and
[58:25]
Design Eac for the 7th Street
[58:33]
Connection Project. Item s
[58:36]
6.38 2 pieces of legislation
[58:38]
and it is the charter 8 tax
[58:44]
and sale authorization. Item s
[58:46]
6.0 39 seminary point bit and
[58:48]
went forgiveness. This consist
[58:50]
of 2 pieces of legislation.
[58:54]
The first is approved and the
[58:57]
second piece the ordinance is
[58:58]
being approved on
[58:59]
introduction. Final passage
[59:04]
will be 7 SEPTEMBER 15th. Item
[59:05]
s 6.40 professional services
[59:09]
agreement with the raw Dough
[59:10]
Co for signage and wayfinding
[59:16]
services. Item. 6.0 41 is
[59:17]
acceptance and appropriation
[59:18]
of workforce development funds
[59:22]
for the fiscal year. 26 to 27.
[59:25]
Item. 6.0 42, this is a
[59:25]
construction resource center
[59:31]
grant agreement for him.
[59:32]
Prestige Program, Support
[59:34]
Services item. 6.0 43 is
[59:40]
continuum of cater program.
[59:43]
Item s 6.0 44 is the old cap
[59:44]
2026 s of c s bg of
[59:48]
resolution. Item s 6.0 45 is
[59:55]
Oakland. 4 elderly and
[59:56]
disabled program measure be
[1:00:01]
fines for the 26 27. Item. S
[1:00:03]
6.0 46 is the opd surveillance
[1:00:03]
technology. 2025 annual
[1:00:09]
reports. Item s 6.0 47 is
[1:00:10]
operational agreement between
[1:00:12]
the city of Oakland and
[1:00:14]
Alameda County, a period from
[1:00:14]
ratification through DECEMBER
[1:00:21]
31st. 2030, 5. 6.0 48 is the
[1:00:22]
apricot 2026 and a report in
[1:00:28]
amendment used policy. Item. S
[1:00:29]
6.0 49 is the contract would
[1:00:33]
buy research group for
[1:00:33]
training in capacity, building
[1:00:39]
services. Item. S 6.50 is the
[1:00:42]
opd fiscal year. 24 25 Edward
[1:00:43]
Bryant Memorial Justice
[1:00:50]
Assistance Grants. Item s 6.0
[1:00:51]
51 is the opd r a s h
[1:00:51]
helicopter maintenance
[1:00:56]
contract. Item. S 6.0 52 was
[1:00:57]
you between the city of
[1:00:58]
Oakland, California Highway
[1:01:07]
Patrol. Item s 6.0 53 is the
[1:01:08]
grand performance material
[1:01:08]
which will need and urgency
[1:01:11]
find. You read into record. If
[1:01:13]
staff is available to state.
[1:01:16]
The urgency up. One moment,
[1:01:19]
Councilmember. I'm sorry,
[1:01:23]
which which one is This is
[1:01:23]
item s 6.0 53 the Grand Vera
[1:01:32]
Wang Councilmember Wang.
[1:01:32]
There's needs to be an urgency
[1:01:33]
finding as item was added to
[1:01:37]
the agenda that the 3 day.
[1:01:38]
Excuse I was not following.
[1:01:41]
Can you repeat the sigh item s
[1:01:42]
6.0 53, the grand performance
[1:01:44]
mural. This item was added to
[1:01:45]
the agenda at the three-day so
[1:01:48]
that we need to be an urgency.
[1:01:51]
Oh, yes, I did my colleagues
[1:01:52]
thank you clerk. But the
[1:01:53]
reason we need and urgency
[1:01:54]
finding is we have a set of
[1:01:57]
artist and muralist who are
[1:01:57]
interested in restoring the
[1:01:59]
grant performance Purell in
[1:02:02]
District 2 and they need to
[1:02:02]
meet. They would like to do
[1:02:07]
this in OCTOBER, SEPTEMBER
[1:02:08]
They need to do it before the
[1:02:08]
winter time. And when the race
[1:02:09]
season hit. So this is might
[1:02:11]
be the urgency finding. Thank
[1:02:12]
you. I hope my colleagues
[1:02:25]
agree to this. Okay. And that
[1:02:25]
was motion by council member
[1:02:26]
was seconded by COUNCILMAN
[1:02:27]
Houston to approve that
[1:02:28]
urgency, finance as stated on
[1:02:29]
the record Council member
[1:02:34]
Brown. Thank you.
[1:02:35]
Councilmember vices by Kuz
[1:02:39]
excuse Councilmember Gallo. I.
[1:02:39]
Councilmember Houston, I
[1:02:40]
councilmember under
[1:02:42]
councilmember along eye and
[1:02:46]
share Ramachandran. I or just
[1:02:47]
finding was approved with 6
[1:02:50]
ayes to excuse item s 6.5 3
[1:02:55]
now move to the last consent
[1:02:56]
item. S 6.5 for the contract
[1:02:59]
agreement for James the year
[1:03:01]
as the Oakland Police chief.
[1:03:04]
And this also will need and
[1:03:05]
urgency finding from staff. I
[1:03:05]
see them approaching. Thank
[1:03:09]
you so much. Good afternoon.
[1:03:10]
Council PRESIDENT Ordered the
[1:03:11]
tube stuff. Never really. Yes.
[1:03:12]
We're requesting emergency
[1:03:15]
funding for a 6.5, 4 for this
[1:03:17]
item to be on the JULY.
[1:03:18]
Today's agenda to ensure the
[1:03:19]
city promptly execute an
[1:03:19]
employment agreement with
[1:03:22]
Chief James Beere following
[1:03:23]
his appointment as chief of
[1:03:24]
police prior to the City
[1:03:29]
Council summer recess. Time
[1:03:30]
the proposed agreement will
[1:03:30]
allow the city to move forward
[1:03:31]
with the terms of the Chiefs,
[1:03:32]
employment and compensation
[1:03:33]
and support the city's ongoing
[1:03:34]
public safety priorities.
[1:03:38]
Thank you for consideration.
[1:03:40]
And that was a motion by
[1:03:42]
Councilmember Gallo, seconded
[1:03:43]
by Councilmember Houston to
[1:03:43]
approve the urgency finding
[1:03:45]
stated on Record Council
[1:03:50]
member Brown. Councilmember
[1:03:53]
Fife is excuse Councilmember
[1:03:54]
Gallo. I councilmember
[1:03:57]
Houston, I councilmember I
[1:04:00]
long I and share Ramachandran.
[1:04:03]
I the urgency finding for item
[1:04:04]
6.5, 4 was approved with 6
[1:04:09]
ayes into excused. And that
[1:04:10]
concludes the reading of the
[1:04:11]
consent items on this agenda.
[1:04:12]
We have quite a few speakers
[1:04:15]
for this item. Thank you. I
[1:04:18]
will first call the mayor's
[1:04:19]
office to make to requested
[1:04:23]
amendments. Good afternoon.
[1:04:24]
Again, pressed toward of seats
[1:04:27]
that they were really the
[1:04:27]
mayor's office like to request
[1:04:30]
a minor amendment to item 6.1
[1:04:32]
9 appointment to the Cultural
[1:04:33]
Affairs Commission. We would
[1:04:36]
like to make a end result line
[1:04:39]
for Nia j Cups to the existing
[1:04:41]
language is Jacobs to serve a
[1:04:42]
three-year term on the
[1:04:44]
Cultural Affairs Commission
[1:04:46]
beginning JULY first 2026 and
[1:04:49]
ending SEPTEMBER 30th 2029.
[1:04:50]
We'd like to change that to
[1:04:53]
me. A j Cups to serve a
[1:04:55]
three-year term on the
[1:04:57]
Cultural Affairs Commission
[1:04:58]
beginning OCTOBER. First 2025
[1:04:58]
and the ending SEPTEMBER 30th
[1:05:05]
2028. Will vote on them
[1:05:08]
together. We will the
[1:05:10]
amendment and and your Second
[1:05:12]
Amendment. Thank Councilmember
[1:05:14]
from runs in the second. One
[1:05:16]
is item 6.2, 0, appointments
[1:05:19]
to the Privacy Advisory
[1:05:21]
Commission. Another minor
[1:05:24]
Amendment. Ronald Busby lane
[1:05:25]
for changing is robust. Be
[1:05:26]
replacing the Beacon seat
[1:05:28]
previously held by Heather
[1:05:30]
Patterson. Ronald is actually
[1:05:31]
replacing the big can seat
[1:05:32]
previously held by Sean
[1:05:35]
Everhart. And so the language
[1:05:36]
is robust, be replacing the
[1:05:36]
vacancy previously held by
[1:05:42]
Sean number. Thank And I will
[1:05:44]
second, but do have to go to
[1:05:44]
public comment. And
[1:05:45]
councilmember comments comes
[1:05:50]
Denver. If I'd like register
[1:05:55]
at no vote item. 6.40, please.
[1:06:00]
Thank you. Councilmember
[1:06:02]
Houston, I like to the chair.
[1:06:02]
I want to make sure that
[1:06:08]
amendment. Has 6.2, 8 was at
[1:06:09]
it because I didn't hear it
[1:06:09]
because member in your
[1:06:11]
committee. I didn't like the
[1:06:14]
three-year to 2 year the month
[1:06:16]
to month. That's added into
[1:06:18]
that. Yes, I will. I will
[1:06:20]
clarify. So in Finance
[1:06:20]
committee, we heard the item
[1:06:25]
regarding the parking operator
[1:06:26]
contract extension is Director
[1:06:31]
Johnson here actually to just?
[1:06:32]
Referenced the changes briefly
[1:06:34]
that we made from committee
[1:06:35]
that we're going adopt today
[1:06:37]
if passes. Thank you. Brent
[1:06:41]
Johnson to the chair, the
[1:06:44]
revised language only extends
[1:06:44]
the contracts for the garages
[1:06:47]
to the end of the calendar
[1:06:48]
year. And the staff report
[1:06:49]
supple report provides the
[1:06:51]
additional information that
[1:06:53]
was requested by the
[1:06:55]
committee. And there will also
[1:06:56]
be an informational report
[1:06:57]
that were provided to the
[1:06:59]
Finance too. Second. And that
[1:06:59]
has already been scheduled
[1:07:02]
pools. Thank you. And I just
[1:07:03]
for the record, I want to
[1:07:08]
clarify that. There most of us
[1:07:10]
and not all of us and finance
[1:07:11]
committee when this item was
[1:07:11]
discussed, had some deep
[1:07:16]
reservations about. The
[1:07:16]
performance of these
[1:07:20]
contracts. And we welcome the
[1:07:20]
initiatives that the finance
[1:07:21]
Department is trying to put
[1:07:24]
forward to improve performance
[1:07:26]
of our existing parking
[1:07:28]
garages not only in collecting
[1:07:29]
revenue, which is certainly a
[1:07:31]
problem, but also safety,
[1:07:32]
accessibility, ours that are
[1:07:33]
they're available open to the
[1:07:34]
public. So there are a number
[1:07:35]
of questions that we did bring
[1:07:37]
up in committee that when the
[1:07:41]
informational report about a
[1:07:41]
planned overhaul of our
[1:07:43]
parking garage system comes
[1:07:45]
up. I look forward to hearing
[1:07:46]
in SEPTEMBER the consummate
[1:07:48]
Houston, and through the chair
[1:07:49]
at thank you for your
[1:07:51]
leadership. Seeing that right.
[1:07:55]
And that Texas company. Texas
[1:07:58]
Company. So thank you.
[1:08:07]
Appreciate. Councilor Wang.
[1:08:08]
Yes, thank you. I will also
[1:08:11]
just log a no vote for item.
[1:08:15]
6.4, 0 as well. Thank you.
[1:08:17]
Thank you. And week counts
[1:08:19]
Houston. Just one was can we
[1:08:20]
speak on a couple of these
[1:08:22]
items or do we want the public
[1:08:24]
to speak? Because I wanted you
[1:08:25]
can speak. Yeah. Just wanted
[1:08:29]
to speak on the sanctuary city
[1:08:32]
piece I want thank council
[1:08:33]
member Gallo and I want to
[1:08:34]
thank council member Wayne for
[1:08:36]
accepting my amendments. And
[1:08:39]
as I always say, that my mom
[1:08:39]
is black. My father's that he
[1:08:43]
know. And I was always wonder
[1:08:47]
since 1986, you know, when my
[1:08:48]
Latino side of my family was
[1:08:49]
being represented for 40
[1:08:52]
years. I had to go home and
[1:08:56]
see my friends passed away and
[1:08:58]
I and we ever a part of this
[1:09:01]
say 2 area refuge city. And I
[1:09:02]
want to just share a couple
[1:09:05]
things that I wrote Down. Let
[1:09:06]
me pull that up. Real quick
[1:09:08]
should have been ready, but I
[1:09:22]
was not. And I apologize. In
[1:09:23]
1986. Oakland was first
[1:09:24]
declared as a saint. You are
[1:09:28]
refuge city 1986. 1983. Just
[1:09:30]
remember 1983 National
[1:09:31]
Journal. We for Oakland as
[1:09:35]
what the crime capital crime
[1:09:36]
capital, revolutionary leader
[1:09:42]
Huey p Newton was killed. 1989
[1:09:42]
seen bunch of my friends died
[1:09:49]
in 18. 89 and then 92. Dorn.
[1:09:50]
Per per capita homicides in
[1:10:00]
1982. Record. 175 homicides.
[1:10:00]
And many of them were my
[1:10:01]
friends, my classmates, people
[1:10:06]
that I knew my cousin.
[1:10:11]
Appreciate. You accept MR.
[1:10:17]
Revisions of bringing in. A
[1:10:19]
refuge and a sanctuary for my
[1:10:22]
black residents right? Because
[1:10:25]
we were left out for so long
[1:10:25]
so long in this historic, 40
[1:10:27]
years, 40 years. We weren't a
[1:10:30]
part of a bit now. We're part
[1:10:31]
of it. So now we've got to put
[1:10:33]
money to that right? So I'm
[1:10:34]
saying is thank you
[1:10:37]
councilmember way. Thank you.
[1:10:39]
Councilmember Gallo think Sept
[1:10:41]
in that because I feel that 40
[1:10:42]
years of us being left out of
[1:10:43]
my other side of my family be
[1:10:47]
left out was. Was hurtful for
[1:10:49]
what I had to go through. What
[1:10:49]
my family, many of people
[1:10:50]
that's out here in audience
[1:10:51]
right now, seen it. So thank
[1:10:55]
you so much on that one. And
[1:10:57]
then the last one I like to
[1:10:58]
speak on. Thank you. Thank
[1:11:04]
you. To last one was. You
[1:11:06]
know, I spoke on that one. So
[1:11:07]
let it go. Thank you so much.
[1:11:09]
Appreciate it. Thank you.
[1:11:13]
Council under long. Since
[1:11:16]
we're talking about the
[1:11:17]
sanctuary city policy. And of
[1:11:19]
course, I want to also thank
[1:11:21]
you, Councilmember Houston,
[1:11:23]
because truly a true city of
[1:11:26]
refuge must acknowledge both
[1:11:27]
the contributions of the black
[1:11:31]
community as well as a lot of
[1:11:33]
the ways that the black
[1:11:34]
community has been
[1:11:35]
disinvestment has been subject
[1:11:39]
to systemic discrimination and
[1:11:41]
and block from opportunities.
[1:11:44]
And so it is only just to add
[1:11:45]
those amendments that that you
[1:11:48]
added. So thank you. I also
[1:11:49]
want it's just think because
[1:11:50]
this body for supporting the
[1:11:52]
sanctuary city policy. Want to
[1:11:56]
thank the faith in action
[1:11:57]
community that really pushed
[1:11:59]
us and has been the primary
[1:12:01]
advocate for this piece of
[1:12:03]
legislation. I also want to
[1:12:04]
thank council member Gallo for
[1:12:07]
his partnership as well as for
[1:12:08]
being the legislator for much
[1:12:08]
of the proceeding
[1:12:09]
sanctuary-city policies that
[1:12:11]
lead to this day. So thank
[1:12:23]
you, everyone. Thank you.
[1:12:27]
MADAM Last comment that today
[1:12:31]
promise you, to it. 6.2, 3
[1:12:34]
encampment abatement
[1:12:35]
management team operation that
[1:12:39]
was supposed to not consent
[1:12:42]
bring that back in us. Okay.
[1:12:43]
That it was it went to consent
[1:12:46]
bring it back because I need
[1:12:46]
on my council members to hear
[1:12:47]
doesn't need Jenkins two-year.
[1:12:50]
He's not here. And the
[1:12:52]
brownie, Erin and I 5 to hear
[1:12:52]
that some a brain that back
[1:12:55]
because that was supposed to
[1:12:56]
be on. Not consenting Amari
[1:12:58]
was due to rep present. It.
[1:12:59]
And that was this one right
[1:13:01]
here. Office of Homeless
[1:13:03]
Solutions. It was supposed to
[1:13:04]
be brought up in a small
[1:13:04]
mistake, but I will bring it
[1:13:07]
back. So everyone can see
[1:13:08]
what's going on encampment
[1:13:12]
abatement policy. Thank you,
[1:13:13]
councilmember MADAM Clerk, we
[1:13:16]
can read in the speakers.
[1:13:17]
Thank you so much. Council
[1:13:19]
reason. Thank you. Chair
[1:13:21]
Ramachandran as I call your
[1:13:22]
name. Please approach the
[1:13:24]
podium. Any order in please re
[1:13:25]
state your name for the record
[1:13:27]
when you approach the podium,
[1:13:28]
if you're participating online
[1:13:29]
and I call your name, please
[1:13:30]
raise your hand so I can
[1:13:31]
easily identify you. Please.
[1:13:35]
Again, note that the speaker
[1:13:36]
time was reduced to one minute
[1:13:39]
due quorum issues. So if you
[1:13:41]
signed up for multiple items,
[1:13:43]
it'll be the max with one
[1:13:45]
minute starting. So we have
[1:13:48]
Jennifer Inlay Dan Damien
[1:13:52]
Rennie. We're man, David
[1:13:58]
Peters add to Stacey. Jyoti
[1:14:09]
Singh. Ronnie's 10. Coast by
[1:14:14]
Vanessa long. Betty Robinson,
[1:14:19]
Tony Mo. Samantha Wise, James
[1:14:24]
Wood, Robert. Medley. But boy,
[1:14:28]
I think sorry, Ole John
[1:14:35]
Santos, Jon Jones, that 3rd.
[1:14:36]
Giselle Bahar us out all of
[1:14:41]
Allah. Daniel Galvin is Alice
[1:14:47]
Stephenson Stevens. That Tosh
[1:14:51]
a year spring bit. Jamal, true
[1:14:58]
love. He and the gyms.
[1:14:59]
Charlotte, I know, you know,
[1:15:03]
skews me. Por algo ms
[1:15:08]
Arlington. Tongue. Well,
[1:15:10]
Allison Wall, Jennifer at
[1:15:14]
Wood, Ted Russell, Alana. Lip
[1:15:21]
set. And Jeanne Hazard Ajay
[1:15:23]
Kay Flowers, Carissa Gauthier
[1:15:33]
is. Armando g. And Laura
[1:15:35]
Watts. In any order, please
[1:15:35]
state your name in the record.
[1:15:36]
And if you getting time cws
[1:15:39]
also state that. Good
[1:15:41]
afternoon, John shows that
[1:15:42]
there. Good evening. MADAM
[1:15:45]
City clerk up to the chair of
[1:15:46]
the records on zones of 3rd. I
[1:15:47]
want to begin by thanking the
[1:15:47]
city clerk's office. Your team
[1:15:51]
is so amazing. You're so
[1:15:52]
professional, courteous coming
[1:15:53]
here. I don't know what I'm
[1:15:54]
the one at the time, but Shell
[1:15:57]
hit me out. So I appreciate
[1:16:00]
saw I don't real quickly item.
[1:16:00]
6.40, not 6.4, 9. I support
[1:16:05]
bright research group. 6.11, a
[1:16:08]
sanctuary city won. I support
[1:16:11]
that one wholeheartedly. Thank
[1:16:12]
councilmembers Councilmember
[1:16:13]
Gallo in Councilmember. He was
[1:16:13]
that and I want to say is I'm
[1:16:15]
going to raise east Open. The
[1:16:15]
thing I love the most about
[1:16:18]
the towns of diversity. Right?
[1:16:19]
So we it's important that we
[1:16:22]
don't get caught up in how the
[1:16:23]
system was separate because
[1:16:25]
we're not enemies. We got do a
[1:16:26]
better job identifying how the
[1:16:26]
system pits one against
[1:16:30]
another. Now with that man
[1:16:31]
said item, number 6, 0.2, 5,
[1:16:35]
the Coliseum. I want to start
[1:16:36]
by thanking cities everyone
[1:16:37]
who played a role in this hour
[1:16:41]
a lot when of this. I want to
[1:16:41]
thank all the council members
[1:16:42]
because right now we've got to
[1:16:43]
be real is a lot of hate and
[1:16:45]
going right now. It's a lot of
[1:16:47]
people who hate the city of
[1:16:48]
Oakland and I'm glad you are
[1:16:50]
wise enough to see through
[1:16:52]
that. It's one thing to
[1:16:53]
disagree on a proposal.
[1:16:55]
Everyone have a right to their
[1:16:56]
opinion. But when it's coming
[1:16:57]
from people who seemingly
[1:16:59]
celebrate whenever there's a
[1:17:00]
tragedy or challenge in the
[1:17:02]
city of Oakland that represent
[1:17:05]
the spirit of Oakland. Any
[1:17:06]
time there are people who
[1:17:09]
openly speaking a matter.
[1:17:10]
That's misogynistic,
[1:17:11]
homophobic and transphobic.
[1:17:11]
That does not represent the
[1:17:15]
values of the city of Oakland.
[1:17:16]
And quite frankly, all respect
[1:17:17]
know about who can come in
[1:17:19]
here and but they were put man
[1:17:20]
the face behind what they got
[1:17:21]
to say because we've got to
[1:17:24]
see it here. Do business.
[1:17:25]
We've been doing this for a
[1:17:27]
long time Matt, what they want
[1:17:29]
to for folks MAY not
[1:17:31]
understand my involvement with
[1:17:31]
the Coliseum goes back to
[1:17:35]
where I deal with in my 30's.
[1:17:35]
I mean, glasses. I was 35
[1:17:36]
pounds lighter. I didn't have
[1:17:40]
any great. I was working on
[1:17:42]
the minimal ways. I was making
[1:17:42]
$10 an hour working at the
[1:17:43]
Burger. King are used to be at
[1:17:44]
13th and Broadway. And I heard
[1:17:48]
about Coliseum City. That's
[1:17:50]
someone who born a race here
[1:17:51]
in left sports. I got involved
[1:17:51]
in a meeting with the
[1:17:55]
developers. And then when it
[1:17:55]
got to a point to where it was
[1:17:57]
clear that the writers want to
[1:17:57]
move, there was an effort led
[1:17:58]
by Ronnie Lott. And that's
[1:18:01]
where I'm it. My brother Ray
[1:18:02]
bought it and we met with
[1:18:04]
council member Gallo. It was
[1:18:05]
the effort. So by the Raiders
[1:18:08]
that didn't work out. So then
[1:18:10]
the next step was to sue the
[1:18:11]
nfl. So again, with the
[1:18:13]
support of Councilmember
[1:18:15]
Gallo, you was always there
[1:18:17]
with us. Former city attorney
[1:18:18]
Barbara Parker. There was
[1:18:20]
effort to sue the nfl for
[1:18:21]
violating the relocation
[1:18:24]
policy. So I want people to
[1:18:24]
understand that this didn't
[1:18:26]
just happen out of nowhere.
[1:18:29]
There was 6 entities and 2020
[1:18:30]
who vie for opportunity to
[1:18:33]
enter the dna with the city of
[1:18:34]
Oakland, nuns habit the closed
[1:18:34]
doors. Then today I want to
[1:18:37]
curb people. All this happened
[1:18:38]
during a pandemic. All these
[1:18:39]
meetings are recorded. So
[1:18:42]
there's no excuse people to
[1:18:44]
keep spreading lies and
[1:18:45]
misinformation. We love open.
[1:18:46]
If you don't love hope and get
[1:18:46]
the h#
[1:18:47]
up out of here
[1:19:00]
because I'm here. Good
[1:19:01]
afternoon Council. My name is
[1:19:03]
Doctor Betty Robinson. Harris,
[1:19:05]
I'm here as an educator to
[1:19:09]
support culture arts. I was
[1:19:11]
deeply dismayed to learn that
[1:19:12]
Oakland arts funding had good
[1:19:16]
at it. And the cold to affairs
[1:19:17]
during a rough and
[1:19:19]
contribution was eliminated at
[1:19:25]
the end of 2024, what shame.
[1:19:26]
Research is adamantly clear
[1:19:28]
about the developing brain,
[1:19:30]
the healthy brain and how the
[1:19:32]
hill in brain is positively
[1:19:37]
influenced by the arts. The
[1:19:38]
Coliseum sale presents a rare
[1:19:40]
opportunity to secure a
[1:19:45]
permanent funding source. As a
[1:19:46]
resident over 40 years, I was
[1:19:47]
present at the open and that
[1:19:49]
the Alice along the Art Center
[1:19:54]
Performing Arts 1982. I have
[1:19:55]
personally visited that
[1:19:59]
building weekly to date.
[1:20:01]
Oakland is a has a natural
[1:20:05]
reputation as the art magnon.
[1:20:07]
I apologize. Bitty your time
[1:20:07]
is up. Thank you so much for
[1:20:12]
your comments next. Speaker.
[1:20:15]
Good afternoon. My name is
[1:20:15]
James Wood Faith Action East
[1:20:18]
Bay. And I'm here today to
[1:20:23]
celebrate. I'm anticipating a
[1:20:23]
vote to Spain, they do a
[1:20:26]
devoted sanctuary city. But
[1:20:27]
I'm here to say that this is a
[1:20:30]
day that all of us should be
[1:20:31]
proud to call. City of Oakland
[1:20:34]
are home. And in this I turn
[1:20:38]
and grateful to the. Tenacious
[1:20:39]
leadership of council member
[1:20:42]
guy over all these years. For
[1:20:43]
the leadership and direction
[1:20:46]
and power of cast member and
[1:20:46]
to thank council member
[1:20:48]
Houston for opening all of our
[1:20:50]
eyes to the need of a
[1:20:51]
sanctuary city and the
[1:20:53]
broadest possible sense. I am
[1:20:54]
proud to be open. I am proud
[1:20:55]
that you are representing us
[1:20:56]
Oakland and thank you for your
[1:21:01]
vote today. Thank you so much
[1:21:07]
for your comments. Hi, I'm
[1:21:08]
Miller was from a policy
[1:21:09]
manager at the non-profit Save
[1:21:10]
the Bay where a regional
[1:21:11]
organization protecting and
[1:21:12]
restoring campuses that. I
[1:21:16]
work right across the street
[1:21:17]
where offices and we're really
[1:21:19]
happy to see 6.2 one on the
[1:21:20]
consent agenda. That's the
[1:21:23]
resolutions Port of sb 954.
[1:21:25]
We're super that it made it
[1:21:25]
this far. And we really urge
[1:21:28]
your support today. The
[1:21:29]
purpose of this is in support
[1:21:31]
of a clean-up bill in the
[1:21:33]
state legislature. And that
[1:21:36]
bill is in response to a
[1:21:38]
really devastating bit in a
[1:21:39]
trailer bill that was passed
[1:21:42]
last year. That essentially
[1:21:44]
removed advanced manufacturing
[1:21:45]
projects from the sequel
[1:21:48]
process, meaning that if you
[1:21:50]
are to build a battery
[1:21:53]
recycling facility or a data
[1:21:55]
center or other refinery here
[1:21:56]
in our Bay area. You no longer
[1:21:59]
have to go through the secret
[1:22:01]
process. Those are obviously
[1:22:03]
projects that are known for
[1:22:04]
causing environmental
[1:22:04]
contamination and public
[1:22:06]
health impacts. The sequel
[1:22:07]
process is what people used to
[1:22:11]
understand thank you for your
[1:22:12]
comments. Your time is up
[1:22:21]
next. Speaker. Thank you. Good
[1:22:23]
afternoon Council. My name is
[1:22:24]
Alana Litz said I'm a district
[1:22:25]
one resident and a member of
[1:22:27]
the Cultural Affairs
[1:22:28]
Commission speaking on behalf
[1:22:30]
of a few of other of fellow
[1:22:31]
commissioners who couldn't be
[1:22:32]
here, including our Vice
[1:22:35]
chair. I want to congratulate
[1:22:35]
you on getting to this point
[1:22:38]
of the cell sale of the
[1:22:39]
Coliseum. Undoubtedly it will
[1:22:43]
benefit the whole city. And
[1:22:44]
we're in support and in
[1:22:44]
support of a vote for the sale
[1:22:45]
agreement and wanted to ask
[1:22:49]
that the council invest the
[1:22:51]
new 6% ticket revenue share
[1:22:52]
from the sale into the arts,
[1:22:54]
cultural and creative economy
[1:22:55]
and doing so would repair
[1:22:57]
years of disinvestment. Like
[1:22:58]
you heard earlier, our budget
[1:23:00]
is effectively 0 now for
[1:23:03]
making grants. This is not a
[1:23:05]
novel idea. Other cities from
[1:23:05]
Columbus to Portland to
[1:23:09]
Seattle at a ticket fee to
[1:23:09]
support the cultural
[1:23:10]
infrastructure that makes the
[1:23:11]
city's desirable to begin
[1:23:14]
with. And I emailed you all a
[1:23:15]
report yesterday about the
[1:23:16]
benefit that investing in the
[1:23:17]
creative economy has on the
[1:23:20]
overall economy. And would
[1:23:21]
allow us to bring back
[1:23:22]
programs like the cultural
[1:23:23]
strategist and government
[1:23:37]
programs support.
[1:23:37]
Good
[1:23:39]
afternoon. My name is Roberto
[1:23:40]
Am the former cultural affairs
[1:23:41]
manager for the city of
[1:23:42]
Oakland. I was in that
[1:23:46]
position for 7 years and
[1:23:48]
experienced the highs and lows
[1:23:50]
around budgets. And one thing
[1:23:52]
that didn't go away is a
[1:23:54]
dynamic alum and of our
[1:23:55]
culture community. And they've
[1:23:57]
been here in front of you any
[1:24:00]
time to talk about value.
[1:24:01]
Here's an opportunity for you
[1:24:05]
to remedy that. Patter. Bad
[1:24:09]
pattern of a broken record of
[1:24:10]
and actually invest in finding
[1:24:11]
a dedicated revenue stream for
[1:24:14]
your cultural community, this
[1:24:15]
money that could potentially
[1:24:20]
come out of this a sales
[1:24:23]
agreement a way for him. What
[1:24:27]
our culture community brings
[1:24:28]
to us to affirm that we are
[1:24:30]
city of belonging and artists
[1:24:36]
belong here and come from. You
[1:24:41]
validate us. Not be.
[1:24:42]
Apologies, MR. Bo Diddley
[1:24:43]
thank you so much for your
[1:24:44]
comments. Hope you're enjoying
[1:24:45]
your attack. Next speaker.
[1:24:52]
Please. Hello. My name is to
[1:24:54]
seeing. I directed dance
[1:24:55]
company called it a dance and
[1:24:56]
drum. I'm a resident of
[1:25:00]
district 5. And I'm also on
[1:25:01]
the Cultural Affairs
[1:25:01]
Commission. I'm here speaking
[1:25:05]
on my own behalf, the sale of
[1:25:07]
the Coliseum is an incredible
[1:25:07]
opportunity to restore local
[1:25:10]
arts and culture funding with
[1:25:11]
that ticket revenue stream and
[1:25:14]
without burdening taxpayers
[1:25:14]
investing this revenue stream
[1:25:17]
in artist makes good business
[1:25:18]
sense. Artists are small
[1:25:19]
businesses like myself and we
[1:25:22]
bring business to the city as
[1:25:23]
a place that takes immense
[1:25:27]
pride in Oakland, Rees talent.
[1:25:28]
We must walk that talk and
[1:25:29]
invest in the arts sector
[1:25:30]
which makes Oakland the
[1:25:32]
culturally rich place that it
[1:25:34]
is. We need this ticket
[1:25:36]
revenue to support artists,
[1:25:38]
grants, arts in schools,
[1:25:38]
cultural strategist in
[1:25:41]
government and more. And we've
[1:25:42]
been defending defunding the
[1:25:43]
arts in Oakland for years. And
[1:25:46]
now we have the opportunity to
[1:25:47]
enhance the lives of all of
[1:25:48]
our residents by investing
[1:25:50]
this ticket ticket revenue
[1:25:51]
back and to the arts. Thank
[1:25:53]
you so much. Thank you for
[1:26:01]
comments. Good afternoon.
[1:26:03]
Council members. My name is
[1:26:03]
phony Stratton. I'm the
[1:26:04]
executive director of Oakland
[1:26:05]
and a fellow for California
[1:26:08]
for the Arts. I want to speak
[1:26:11]
to item 6.2, 5, as you
[1:26:12]
consider the future allocation
[1:26:13]
of the city's new 6% ticket
[1:26:16]
revenue from the Coliseum. I
[1:26:16]
urge you to make a dedicated
[1:26:18]
investment in the Artis
[1:26:19]
cultural workers and
[1:26:21]
organizations that make
[1:26:24]
Oakland Oakland, I know to
[1:26:25]
make incredibly hard difficult
[1:26:26]
budget decisions and I
[1:26:27]
appreciate all the work you've
[1:26:29]
done to improve our city's
[1:26:30]
finances and arts and culture
[1:26:32]
was extremely impacted by
[1:26:34]
that. Currently, the budget is
[1:26:36]
only $300,000. More or less 0%
[1:26:40]
of the total budget. That
[1:26:42]
matters because culture powers
[1:26:44]
Oakland, it defines our town's
[1:26:45]
identity. It drives our
[1:26:46]
economy by supporting local
[1:26:48]
businesses, attracting
[1:26:50]
visitors improves our
[1:26:53]
wellbeing and mental health
[1:26:53]
and its treatments. The public
[1:26:55]
safety by making neighborhoods
[1:26:57]
safer, safer. This is a chance
[1:26:58]
to create a sustainable
[1:26:59]
funding source for the culture
[1:27:00]
and infrastructure that powers
[1:27:01]
our city. Thank you. Thank you
[1:27:08]
so much for your comments.
[1:27:09]
Good afternoon Council. Name
[1:27:10]
is Todd Russell on a home and
[1:27:14]
district one and temescal and
[1:27:15]
today's vote and the cost him
[1:27:18]
sail. His historic and one of
[1:27:19]
the most important things we
[1:27:20]
can do even though you're not
[1:27:22]
deciding allocation today is
[1:27:23]
to dedicate the full 6% to
[1:27:26]
arts and culture. As you've
[1:27:28]
heard, the Cultural Affairs
[1:27:28]
division has been starved for
[1:27:32]
decades. The funding peak was
[1:27:36]
actually in 1992 when it was
[1:27:37]
1.6 million dollars. That's
[1:27:38]
nearly 4 million dollars today
[1:27:41]
in 2 days funds consider
[1:27:44]
inflation General fund
[1:27:45]
contributions was zeroed out
[1:27:48]
since the end of 2024. And my
[1:27:49]
main point here is that the
[1:27:51]
arts are not a luxury line
[1:27:52]
item in the budget that
[1:27:56]
contribute to public safety
[1:27:57]
neighborhood vitality, the
[1:27:58]
education of children, youth
[1:28:02]
and adults. And I would just
[1:28:03]
want to point out a recent
[1:28:04]
national port that was
[1:28:05]
released just last week some
[1:28:07]
new data are to national arts
[1:28:08]
researcher. And it found that
[1:28:13]
public investment, the arts.
[1:28:14]
Thank you for your comments to
[1:28:20]
next speaker. My name is
[1:28:21]
Charlotte. I live in district
[1:28:27]
be on at 2.3 Before you head
[1:28:29]
up our I want to hear. But in
[1:28:31]
a couple of things at
[1:28:33]
encampment, closure is a
[1:28:34]
euphemism. What actually is is
[1:28:36]
it's a sweep is an eviction
[1:28:36]
that might seem like
[1:28:37]
semantics. But I think that
[1:28:40]
makes a difference if you
[1:28:41]
actually go to sweep and talk
[1:28:42]
to the city administrators,
[1:28:42]
talk to opd, they know that
[1:28:45]
it's a dirty job. They know
[1:28:46]
that people might lose their
[1:28:47]
rv's, their home, their
[1:28:48]
documents, the medication that
[1:28:50]
might lose contact with loved
[1:28:50]
ones. They might come home
[1:28:51]
from work and find the
[1:28:54]
everything they own is gone.
[1:28:55]
They also are very clear the
[1:28:56]
same officials on the fact
[1:28:58]
that where people go next.
[1:28:59]
What they do next is not their
[1:28:59]
problem, not their job to
[1:29:00]
worry about that. I don't
[1:29:02]
think they would dispute that
[1:29:03]
the people being swept are
[1:29:05]
clear on all this. And they're
[1:29:07]
all so clear on wherever they
[1:29:08]
go next. It's not going to
[1:29:09]
perturbed businesses per term
[1:29:10]
House neighbors. It's going to
[1:29:12]
be to survive. So when you
[1:29:13]
hear this report, I hope you
[1:29:14]
really, really drill down on.
[1:29:15]
How much does this cost could
[1:29:18]
be done with that money? Why
[1:29:19]
are there so many bank? It
[1:29:20]
lots and vacant buildings in
[1:29:21]
Oakland and why is the rents
[1:29:22]
so high? Thank you for your
[1:29:30]
comments. Hi, my name is
[1:29:33]
Allison My doctor is in opera
[1:29:34]
performance and I love living
[1:29:34]
in a town where my
[1:29:38]
representatives also a singer.
[1:29:39]
Oakland has so many artists to
[1:29:40]
be proud of and the revenue
[1:29:41]
percentage from the Coliseum
[1:29:42]
complex can provide sustained
[1:29:44]
support for Oakland's creative
[1:29:45]
powerhouse and will create
[1:29:46]
opportunities for the next
[1:29:47]
generation of artists right
[1:29:51]
here in our town. Other cities
[1:29:52]
already do this. It's not a
[1:29:53]
novel idea. So let's refill
[1:29:55]
the artistic cup of our
[1:29:57]
community keeping that revenue
[1:29:59]
here with our artists who are
[1:30:00]
making music and and art and
[1:30:03]
dance and all types of cars.
[1:30:04]
Here in specially, especially
[1:30:04]
in light of the recent cuts
[1:30:05]
have been made. Thank you very
[1:30:14]
much. Thank you. Good
[1:30:15]
afternoon. My name is Daniel
[1:30:19]
Galvin is Oakland resident and
[1:30:19]
your list. And I'm here to say
[1:30:22]
thank Thank you. And thank you
[1:30:24]
most especially to Charlene
[1:30:27]
Wang in giving us the go ahead
[1:30:28]
to do the restoration of this
[1:30:31]
beautiful mural painted over
[1:30:33]
40 years ago, the Graham
[1:30:34]
performance mural. They gave
[1:30:35]
us opportunity now to move
[1:30:38]
forward. It's been funded
[1:30:41]
publicly. There's been no city
[1:30:42]
money foundation. Money likely
[1:30:43]
yes zone about family fun.
[1:30:49]
Gave money in the and the a
[1:30:53]
reward. So $100,000 was raised
[1:30:54]
by the people by the community
[1:30:56]
in helping get this nearly
[1:30:57]
restored. And I'm very
[1:31:01]
thankful your support. And
[1:31:02]
with all going nowhere as we
[1:31:03]
are now lower first will be
[1:31:05]
the restoration beginning
[1:31:07]
performance. And that's that's
[1:31:08]
at the 5.80, freeway
[1:31:10]
underneath the Grand Avenue.
[1:31:12]
And of course, the boulevard.
[1:31:12]
And we'll see you up there and
[1:31:16]
give the home. Thank you.
[1:31:17]
Thank you for your comments in
[1:31:23]
you next. Speaker. I'll be
[1:31:27]
interpreting for quitting.
[1:32:29]
Good afternoon Council
[1:32:30]
members, my name is according
[1:32:31]
Gomez and I'm a leader with
[1:32:33]
faith in Action, East Bay. I
[1:32:35]
urge you to pass the City of
[1:32:35]
Refuge ordinance on second
[1:32:39]
reading and make it law into
[1:32:40]
Oakland. This ordinance
[1:32:40]
matters because it does more
[1:32:43]
than repeat. Values. It
[1:32:45]
codifies them in the Oakland
[1:32:49]
Municipal Code replacing prior
[1:32:51]
scattered resolutions with one
[1:32:52]
enforceable chapter that
[1:32:52]
clearly picked Texas, civil
[1:32:55]
and human rights of Oakland
[1:32:57]
residents. It says city
[1:32:58]
services and not contingent on
[1:33:00]
citizenship status and it bars
[1:33:02]
city employees from using city
[1:33:04]
money, resources or personnel
[1:33:06]
to enforce federal civil
[1:33:07]
immigration law. That means
[1:33:08]
families can go to school. Sea
[1:33:10]
kelp report harm and
[1:33:12]
participate in civic life
[1:33:14]
without fear. A law that
[1:33:15]
builds trust improves public
[1:33:17]
safety and strengthens the
[1:33:29]
whole community. Thank you.
[1:33:30]
Elsa Stevens with Faith in
[1:33:34]
action item 6.11, letting your
[1:33:37]
tourist or student visa lapses
[1:33:37]
equal to letting your parking
[1:33:40]
meter run out. Ice dogs don't
[1:33:42]
care about, you know, humid
[1:33:44]
ration status. Ice is jailed
[1:33:46]
Native Americans for the crime
[1:33:49]
of looking or sounding forint.
[1:33:50]
Their new targets are Syrians
[1:33:55]
and Haitians. Ignorant
[1:33:56]
white-supremacist have no clue
[1:33:58]
of what a Syrian or Haitian
[1:34:00]
looks or sounds like. We must
[1:34:02]
prepare for a new wave of
[1:34:03]
kidnappings of our family
[1:34:06]
members, friends and neighbors
[1:34:09]
over 6 65,000 people rot in
[1:34:12]
American concentration camps
[1:34:13]
today for the crime of not
[1:34:16]
looking Aerion. Many die
[1:34:17]
there. Please enact the
[1:34:26]
ordinance. Good afternoon
[1:34:28]
Council members. My name is
[1:34:29]
not the dna to speaking on
[1:34:33]
items as 6.0 2, 5, I serve as
[1:34:35]
Co executive director of
[1:34:35]
emerging Arts professionals
[1:34:36]
representing a network of more
[1:34:39]
than 3,000 artists. Arts
[1:34:40]
administrators, teaching
[1:34:41]
artists and cultural workers
[1:34:43]
in the Bay area, many of whom
[1:34:44]
live in work in Oakland, such
[1:34:46]
as myself District. One. I
[1:34:47]
urge you to approve the
[1:34:49]
Coliseum deal and dedicate the
[1:34:50]
city 6% ticket revenue share
[1:34:51]
to rebuilding Oakland's arts
[1:34:54]
and culture sector. There's a
[1:34:55]
limited public investments
[1:34:57]
have destabilized Oakland's
[1:34:57]
arts ecosystem organizations
[1:35:00]
have reduced programming
[1:35:00]
artists and cultural workers
[1:35:02]
are leaving the field getting
[1:35:06]
really hard to stay here
[1:35:06]
organizations are going
[1:35:09]
through reserves and many are
[1:35:11]
struggling to sustain
[1:35:12]
institutions that make
[1:35:14]
Oakland, vibrant, creative
[1:35:15]
city without dedicated
[1:35:16]
funding. We risk losing an
[1:35:17]
essential part of Oakland,
[1:35:20]
identity and economy. Police
[1:35:21]
seize this opportunity to
[1:35:22]
build a sustainable future for
[1:35:22]
Oakland, art and culture
[1:35:23]
sector. Thank you so much.
[1:35:29]
Thank you for your comments.
[1:35:29]
Good Evening. Council member.
[1:35:33]
My name is most leader faith.
[1:35:35]
Actually, also, I union
[1:35:37]
electrician. I just want
[1:35:38]
remind everybody the purpose
[1:35:39]
ice is less about immigration
[1:35:41]
and more about getting citizen
[1:35:43]
accustomed to living in a
[1:35:46]
police state. I all of Oakland
[1:35:48]
just take a stand against
[1:35:51]
atrocities because my own son.
[1:35:56]
Young black man. That left
[1:35:56]
work just looking for a meal,
[1:35:59]
a suckling Chinese meal was
[1:36:00]
stopped by ice, demanding his
[1:36:03]
first get. He was terrified.
[1:36:05]
Are going to take a stand
[1:36:08]
against Organ is watch that
[1:36:10]
rain come because nobody in
[1:36:12]
here safe. The young black man
[1:36:12]
born and raised in a bay area
[1:36:14]
was stopped by ice. What's
[1:36:14]
going to stop and to stop
[1:36:17]
anybody else? You know, it's
[1:36:17]
like how do we defend
[1:36:21]
ourselves against that? So,
[1:36:21]
you know, protect brown,
[1:36:23]
protect black people. The
[1:36:24]
tech, all people Oakland,
[1:36:25]
thank you. Thank you for your
[1:36:34]
calm. Council members. My name
[1:36:36]
is j k Fowler. I'm a resident
[1:36:37]
of deep 3 and here is part of
[1:36:39]
the Oakland Arts and culture
[1:36:40]
community representing the
[1:36:40]
Matic bookshop them at Preston
[1:36:42]
Bay Area Book Festival. To
[1:36:44]
urge you to allocate the full
[1:36:45]
6% Coliseum. Ticket revenue
[1:36:48]
shared arts and culture. We
[1:36:49]
have a new recurring public
[1:36:50]
revenue source in front of us
[1:36:50]
and it's far from abstract.
[1:36:54]
Its people in seats at the
[1:36:55]
arena and stadium generating
[1:36:55]
dollars that can be directed
[1:36:59]
into creative infrastructure
[1:37:00]
that makes Oakland a place.
[1:37:02]
People want to live visit and
[1:37:04]
root for arts and culture
[1:37:05]
brings tens of millions of
[1:37:06]
dollars to our city in direct
[1:37:09]
and indirect. Spend.
[1:37:10]
Conclusions. Cultural affairs
[1:37:11]
division has been cut to the
[1:37:15]
bone. Court grants to artists,
[1:37:15]
organizations, festivals and
[1:37:16]
youth programs have been
[1:37:17]
stripped away. We're surviving
[1:37:19]
and ingenuity and exhaustion,
[1:37:20]
not on the level of support a
[1:37:21]
city of this cultural
[1:37:22]
magnitude deserves. Dedicating
[1:37:27]
the 6%. To arts and culture is
[1:37:29]
a smart self to see investment
[1:37:29]
and stabilizes cultural
[1:37:30]
organization supports arts in
[1:37:31]
schools and youth program
[1:37:32]
strengthens downtown in
[1:37:33]
neighborhood quarters and
[1:37:34]
keeps Oakland's creative
[1:37:37]
workers in. Thank you so much
[1:37:44]
for your comments. I excuse
[1:37:47]
me. I was going to speak on 4
[1:37:47]
items and I'm not sure what
[1:37:53]
that means. Time policies. Can
[1:37:53]
you please take your name for
[1:37:54]
the record? Yes. Of the
[1:37:56]
Knesset. Long. Okay. You get a
[1:37:57]
total 3 minutes. 3 minutes,
[1:38:02]
ok? Thank you so much. Thank
[1:38:03]
you for this opportunity.
[1:38:04]
Speak my name is Vanessa Wang
[1:38:05]
and the chair of the Cultural
[1:38:09]
Affairs. Commission for
[1:38:13]
another Minute and one. I
[1:38:16]
wanted to speak in support of
[1:38:18]
6.19 The appointment of Jacobs
[1:38:19]
to the Cultural Affairs
[1:38:20]
Commission. We have long
[1:38:23]
sought someone who has the
[1:38:24]
knowledge, bandwidth and
[1:38:24]
commitment to sit on both of
[1:38:25]
the commission and the public
[1:38:28]
are advisory committee. And so
[1:38:31]
we have that in and so I look
[1:38:32]
forward to working with her
[1:38:35]
with your support. Also want
[1:38:41]
to thank you for hopefully
[1:38:42]
supporting 6.22 The and a
[1:38:43]
slight change in our enabling
[1:38:45]
ordinance to the commission to
[1:38:47]
allow as a body to elect our
[1:38:49]
chair as most other
[1:38:50]
commissions do. And this is in
[1:38:52]
line with what the mayor
[1:38:55]
desires. So thank you for
[1:39:00]
that. I have often spoke to
[1:39:01]
about the heart and soul of
[1:39:04]
Oakland and the importance of
[1:39:07]
our cultural life in this city
[1:39:08]
and so I I also know that you
[1:39:11]
have very important duties
[1:39:16]
around the budget. And so I do
[1:39:18]
want to share with you that
[1:39:20]
there was a 2024 national
[1:39:21]
study from the School of
[1:39:21]
Public and Environmental
[1:39:23]
Affairs at the University of
[1:39:25]
Indiana that found that this
[1:39:29]
is a nationwide study, the
[1:39:31]
arts and creative Industries
[1:39:33]
comprise 4.4% of us gdp. And
[1:39:36]
that is greater than the
[1:39:37]
percentage of construction in
[1:39:38]
this country greater than
[1:39:39]
transportation in this country
[1:39:44]
and greater and agriculture.
[1:39:46]
With 3 different and
[1:39:47]
analytical models. They've
[1:39:49]
shown that the growth in the
[1:39:51]
arts sector positively impacts
[1:39:53]
the growth of the overall
[1:39:55]
economy. Not just our sector
[1:39:59]
and then also the arts sector.
[1:40:00]
Economy is resilient. The
[1:40:02]
share of the economy derived
[1:40:05]
from the arts sector has been
[1:40:06]
consistent consistently in a
[1:40:09]
range between 4 and 5% of gdp
[1:40:14]
since 2001. And that time span
[1:40:17]
includes 3 recessions. So I do
[1:40:21]
want you to take the idea of
[1:40:24]
the potential of using that 6%
[1:40:25]
from the ticket sales from the
[1:40:29]
arena stadium very seriously.
[1:40:30]
Not just as an investment in
[1:40:31]
the cultural sector, but also
[1:40:35]
in the entire city. And and I
[1:40:36]
want to also thank you very
[1:40:39]
much for 6.11 council members,
[1:40:43]
Gallo, Houston, long for the
[1:40:46]
push to renew less as a city
[1:40:47]
of refuge. When we're seeing
[1:40:48]
people in this nation and
[1:40:49]
virtually being executed
[1:40:51]
without due process,
[1:40:52]
accompanied by threats from
[1:40:55]
our highest offices. And so I
[1:40:56]
thank you for your courage in
[1:40:59]
standing for what's right and
[1:41:00]
also that's also about the
[1:41:01]
culture of all of our
[1:41:12]
community. Good afternoon
[1:41:12]
council members. My name is
[1:41:13]
Jun Atwood representing myself
[1:41:16]
personally, speaking on 6 0.2
[1:41:19]
5. I live in district one. I'm
[1:41:21]
an arts professional who's
[1:41:22]
worked in arts grant making in
[1:41:23]
San Francisco, Pittsburgh and
[1:41:25]
cities across Massachusetts.
[1:41:27]
Oakland is the only city where
[1:41:28]
lived in work that is not
[1:41:29]
currently making direct public
[1:41:31]
investment through art and
[1:41:31]
culture Grantmaking. And I'd
[1:41:35]
love to see that change. I
[1:41:35]
respectively respectfully
[1:41:38]
asking the council earmarked
[1:41:38]
to 6% gross ticket revenue
[1:41:39]
from arena and stadium for
[1:41:41]
arts and culture Oakland
[1:41:42]
because the arts are essential
[1:41:46]
to Oakland's future public
[1:41:47]
investment in the arts pays
[1:41:47]
dividends in returns. As a
[1:41:48]
grant maker, I've seen how
[1:41:52]
direct public arts funding. It
[1:41:53]
leverages private investment.
[1:41:55]
We're creating local jobs and
[1:41:56]
economic activity. Also
[1:41:57]
students with access to
[1:41:59]
community arts and music
[1:42:00]
programs are 5 times less
[1:42:04]
likely to drop out of schools.
[1:42:06]
Oakland's artists and cultural
[1:42:07]
organizations are already
[1:42:08]
doing the work that face
[1:42:09]
capacity limitations from
[1:42:10]
covid debt, recovery, federal
[1:42:11]
and state funding cuts and
[1:42:15]
rising inflation costs. Is at
[1:42:16]
what your time is up. Thank
[1:42:23]
you so much, Nick Speaker.
[1:42:24]
Good afternoon council
[1:42:27]
members. My name is Kani said
[1:42:28]
with U.S. And Arts and Culture
[1:42:28]
advocate culture Bear and
[1:42:29]
community organizer. I'm
[1:42:30]
speaking on Six-point-five
[1:42:31]
because Oakland's cultural
[1:42:33]
ecosystem is at a breaking
[1:42:35]
point years of disinvestment
[1:42:36]
culminated in the total
[1:42:38]
elimination of general fund
[1:42:39]
grant dollars for arts and
[1:42:40]
culture and leaving the
[1:42:41]
community space is an artist
[1:42:41]
who pull the city together on
[1:42:44]
life support. As my colleague
[1:42:46]
stated Culture ii is the
[1:42:47]
culture isn't a luxury. It's
[1:42:48]
our identity, our resilience
[1:42:49]
and the heartbeat of our youth
[1:42:51]
education, approving the
[1:42:52]
Coliseum deal gives us
[1:42:52]
historic opportunity to
[1:42:55]
protect this ecosystem by
[1:42:57]
dedicating a 6% ticket revenue
[1:42:59]
share. We create a
[1:43:00]
self-sustaining streamer live
[1:43:01]
entertainment directly,
[1:43:02]
reinvest in local culture
[1:43:02]
makers and makes sense that if
[1:43:04]
you enjoy the pie, you pay
[1:43:06]
your bakers reinvesting. This
[1:43:08]
revenue will stabilize
[1:43:09]
neighborhood anchors like
[1:43:10]
Destiny Arts Center at
[1:43:10]
Eastside Arts Alliance and
[1:43:11]
Keep Oakland a vibrant,
[1:43:12]
creative powerhouse. Please
[1:43:14]
vote. Yes. Thank you. Thank
[1:43:14]
you for your comments next.
[1:43:20]
Speaker. Hi, my Name's Dan
[1:43:22]
Kalb. I'm here representing a
[1:43:23]
broad coalition of
[1:43:23]
environmental Bible, justice
[1:43:27]
and labor organizations
[1:43:27]
supporting agenda item. 6.2 1.
[1:43:28]
Thank you. Councilmember Wang
[1:43:31]
for bringing this forward.
[1:43:31]
This is to support a Bill sb
[1:43:33]
954, that is working to
[1:43:36]
protect impacted communities
[1:43:37]
from over industrial expansion
[1:43:40]
and make sure that we don't at
[1:43:41]
every particular units from
[1:43:42]
being polluted even more than
[1:43:42]
they already are. I'm just
[1:43:43]
going to read a bunch of the
[1:43:45]
organization supporting this
[1:43:47]
bill. Clean Water, Action
[1:43:49]
communities for a better
[1:43:49]
environment. Save the Bay a
[1:43:51]
pan actions. Sierra Club,
[1:43:53]
California, Alameda Labor
[1:43:54]
Council, California Nurses
[1:43:55]
Association, state Building
[1:43:55]
and Construction Trades
[1:43:57]
Council Green Lighting
[1:43:59]
Institute west Open
[1:44:00]
Environmental Indicators,
[1:44:00]
Project Blue Green Alliance
[1:44:01]
Center for Environmental
[1:44:03]
Health, Urban Habitat, 3.50,
[1:44:05]
Bay Area, conservation voters,
[1:44:07]
the spay United Auto Workers
[1:44:09]
region 6 planning conservation
[1:44:11]
patiently can more than 100
[1:44:12]
other organizations. Thank you
[1:44:14]
for supporting sb 3954. Thank
[1:44:15]
you for your comments next.
[1:44:24]
Speaker. Good afternoon.
[1:44:25]
Council members. My name is
[1:44:27]
Arlington, leader with a
[1:44:31]
connection Bay. I'm here. That
[1:44:32]
matter of fact that we just
[1:44:35]
urge you. To pass the city
[1:44:39]
refuge ordinance. It's not
[1:44:39]
just for me. It's not just for
[1:44:44]
you. It's for the people. The
[1:44:46]
people put you in power in the
[1:44:47]
trust to with his knowledge.
[1:44:47]
And when you make to step
[1:44:48]
forward and you opened up this
[1:44:52]
door, you really you're not
[1:44:54]
following your leading the
[1:44:57]
people down a path to trolls.
[1:45:00]
And I asked I urge you again,
[1:45:01]
please continue to push
[1:45:02]
forward because there are
[1:45:03]
other shootings. Watch an and
[1:45:08]
growing with you and we a team
[1:45:10]
you guys have shown teamwork
[1:45:10]
to come together to bring this
[1:45:14]
for a second viewing so that
[1:45:17]
he can so that he can beat a
[1:45:19]
Ford plant to sate people can
[1:45:20]
go to school. People can stay
[1:45:21]
in the home. They don't have
[1:45:24]
to be scared to come out.
[1:45:25]
Continue to do the work that
[1:45:35]
you're doing for the people.
[1:45:40]
I'm at a mile and before it
[1:45:41]
begins speaking, I do want to
[1:45:43]
disclose that I'm a volunteer
[1:45:44]
with Jamie Joyce's
[1:45:45]
congressional campaign, but
[1:45:46]
I'm coming here as a private
[1:45:48]
citizen and these are my own
[1:45:49]
opinions. I'm working
[1:45:50]
filmmaker. I'm a working
[1:45:51]
artist and I would highly
[1:45:53]
support whole allocation of
[1:45:58]
the 6% gross into funding and
[1:46:00]
grant funding. I really would
[1:46:02]
like to thank you for the tax
[1:46:03]
incentives that you all have
[1:46:06]
worked hard to fund. And if we
[1:46:08]
have additional grants towards
[1:46:10]
filmmaking in Oakland, we can
[1:46:12]
bring a lot more production
[1:46:13]
here. We can fund more
[1:46:14]
production and that is job
[1:46:17]
creation. And that is more
[1:46:18]
business and more eyes on arts
[1:46:22]
in Oakland and I think very
[1:46:23]
important. I think there's a
[1:46:26]
there's a big opportunity here
[1:46:29]
to make Oakland in the East
[1:46:31]
Bay into kind of film hub in
[1:46:32]
in California and that this
[1:46:33]
could help support that in
[1:46:35]
addition to supporting youth
[1:46:36]
programs and lots of other
[1:46:42]
amazing things. Thank you.
[1:46:47]
Madeline. Stacey. Start
[1:46:49]
talking. Thank you. We
[1:46:51]
previously received a vacant
[1:46:54]
report from keeping Alexander.
[1:46:56]
There are about 5 parcels of
[1:46:56]
viable open public land where
[1:46:59]
our unhoused neighbors would
[1:47:00]
be able to exist without fear
[1:47:02]
or threat being swept where
[1:47:04]
water electricity could be
[1:47:05]
provided. Medical teams and
[1:47:06]
other outreach and housing
[1:47:10]
navigators can find them. We
[1:47:11]
don't want to Canton for
[1:47:12]
businesses and schools and
[1:47:13]
churches. Okay. Since zones
[1:47:15]
map being developed. All
[1:47:17]
right, that we must give our
[1:47:20]
neighbors somewhere to go.
[1:47:21]
What do we need to do to make
[1:47:24]
this land ready and available?
[1:47:25]
It's viable. It MAY cost a
[1:47:27]
little money, but we cannot
[1:47:29]
keep spending money on sweeps
[1:47:30]
without having some place for
[1:47:33]
people to go. Because when
[1:47:34]
someone earnings and shoulder
[1:47:36]
the cost is not disappear,
[1:47:36]
it's just the most expensive
[1:47:37]
and least effective parts of
[1:47:39]
the public system. Police
[1:47:41]
department's emergency rooms,
[1:47:43]
shelters, correctional
[1:47:45]
facilities, sweep operations,
[1:47:48]
become the fault response. The
[1:47:49]
system's absorb the cost would
[1:47:50]
not exist up. Housing were
[1:47:53]
provided. And right now we're
[1:47:55]
not even asking for housing
[1:47:55]
just land. Let's please make
[1:47:58]
these parcels available. Year
[1:48:00]
to date of the 78 encampment
[1:48:02]
management and abatement team
[1:48:03]
operations. There are 59 full
[1:48:06]
closures by partial closures.
[1:48:08]
64 Sunday 82% of their
[1:48:11]
operations. This costs money.
[1:48:11]
And to be clear, a closure is
[1:48:14]
the sweep. That's what the
[1:48:17]
city now calls abatement. Bait
[1:48:22]
asbestos, not people. Because
[1:48:22]
of the certain cities
[1:48:23]
currently do is continue sweep
[1:48:24]
away any community they've
[1:48:26]
built away from the resources
[1:48:28]
from their foundation from
[1:48:29]
there live in vehicles each
[1:48:30]
week to it's one's mental
[1:48:32]
health steals and trash is
[1:48:33]
most of their possessions and
[1:48:34]
makes it so navigators and
[1:48:35]
advocates cannot find them to
[1:48:36]
connect them to resources.
[1:48:39]
Each sweep the harm. And even
[1:48:45]
results in death. People are
[1:48:46]
dying as a result of sweeps is
[1:48:48]
not hyperbole. This is really
[1:48:49]
happening to our neighbors.
[1:48:51]
Our community members, Oakland
[1:48:57]
residents. We need to do
[1:48:57]
better. Invest in solutions,
[1:49:04]
not sweeps. This 6.46, lprs
[1:49:05]
provide indiscriminate,
[1:49:06]
retrospective location, data.
[1:49:06]
Any person with no
[1:49:08]
intermediary on demand. That's
[1:49:12]
a search without a warrant.
[1:49:13]
Capability to track and Folsom
[1:49:14]
to sensitive locations, such
[1:49:15]
immigration hospital, hospice
[1:49:16]
churches, Planned Parenthood.
[1:49:18]
Their lover's House, etc. It's
[1:49:19]
a violation of the 4th
[1:49:23]
Amendment to me that goes for
[1:49:24]
drone footage to and celebrate
[1:49:25]
will be used extra
[1:49:27]
judiciously. It will in the
[1:49:28]
report actually agenda. But
[1:49:29]
the original contract is
[1:49:29]
discussed in addition to
[1:49:30]
warrant it states that will be
[1:49:31]
used to search mobile devices
[1:49:34]
by authorized possess ERs with
[1:49:35]
their permission and consent.
[1:49:36]
We know how the consent is
[1:49:39]
often up. Taint all of the
[1:49:40]
state is sensitive and does
[1:49:43]
not prevent Crime Stoppers.
[1:49:44]
Surveillance state skews me
[1:49:45]
stop the surveillance state.
[1:49:46]
Cancel the contracts. Now.
[1:49:54]
Thank you. Armando speaking on
[1:50:00]
the encampment policy. Your
[1:50:01]
report says the site and
[1:50:02]
promotes health and wellness
[1:50:03]
and access to interim and
[1:50:05]
permanent housing. But that's
[1:50:07]
not true. Your most recent
[1:50:08]
again policy does nothing to
[1:50:09]
increase shelter housing,
[1:50:11]
permanent housing or health
[1:50:12]
care delivery. To the
[1:50:13]
contrary, you've been closing
[1:50:15]
hundreds of shelter, pets just
[1:50:16]
publishing a list of lands
[1:50:19]
doesn't provide housing. There
[1:50:19]
are people in some of that
[1:50:20]
land right now providing
[1:50:21]
housing for themselves. Are
[1:50:21]
you going to keep sweeping
[1:50:25]
than confiscating 10? Some
[1:50:26]
vehicles making wide swaths of
[1:50:27]
the city inaccessible to a
[1:50:30]
certain class of people
[1:50:31]
banishing seclude ing and
[1:50:32]
dispossessed and then does not
[1:50:33]
promote health and safety.
[1:50:35]
Your report gives lip service
[1:50:37]
to equity. But a recent uc
[1:50:38]
Berkeley study found that
[1:50:40]
since grants pass you've been
[1:50:40]
pushing encampments deeper
[1:50:41]
into black and brown,
[1:50:43]
low-income neighborhoods.
[1:50:46]
Contradicting your stated
[1:50:47]
equity goals, Black and
[1:50:47]
indigenous people are
[1:50:48]
represented in the unhoused
[1:50:49]
population double what they
[1:50:50]
are in the general population.
[1:50:52]
Don't talk about racial
[1:50:53]
equity. Why you're subjecting
[1:50:55]
them to stay violence. Thank
[1:51:00]
you for your comments. Hello.
[1:51:04]
My name is spring cows. I am
[1:51:05]
4th generation. Oakland
[1:51:06]
resident. My kids are also 5th
[1:51:07]
generation district. One
[1:51:12]
voters. Proudly support the
[1:51:13]
sanctuary ordinance. I'm a
[1:51:13]
descendant of stolen Africans
[1:51:17]
and European immigrants and
[1:51:17]
ice targets. People who look
[1:51:18]
like me, people who look like
[1:51:20]
my family members, people who
[1:51:21]
look like my neighbors and my
[1:51:26]
community. Do not support this
[1:51:27]
war against immigrants. It is
[1:51:30]
nothing but racial terrorism
[1:51:32]
from slavery to mass
[1:51:33]
incarceration to mass
[1:51:37]
deportation. We do not need
[1:51:37]
scares Oakland resources that
[1:51:40]
already far too sports sparse
[1:51:43]
going to a colluding with ice.
[1:51:45]
We don't need Oakland
[1:51:46]
residents and community
[1:51:48]
members living in Terre afraid
[1:51:49]
to shop, afraid to live afraid
[1:51:50]
to take their kids to school,
[1:51:52]
afraid to patronize their
[1:51:54]
business is afraid to it. Go
[1:51:58]
out walks. We need the support
[1:52:00]
of the council members and to
[1:52:01]
stay 10 toes down for the
[1:52:03]
community and support this or
[1:52:10]
thank you for your comments.
[1:52:11]
Hello Council. Marcher love
[1:52:14]
here I am the founder Perry
[1:52:15]
Farrell night. I like to
[1:52:17]
knowledge Merrily City,
[1:52:18]
administrative sg Lake,
[1:52:21]
PRESIDENT Jenkins Sandra for
[1:52:22]
the leadership moving this
[1:52:26]
historic deal forward.
[1:52:27]
Congratulations to the African
[1:52:28]
American sports and the time a
[1:52:28]
group on being one step closer
[1:52:31]
to owning the kind of same
[1:52:32]
complex where regard to the 6%
[1:52:35]
of annual gross ticket sales
[1:52:37]
that was earmarked for
[1:52:38]
community benefits. I believe
[1:52:39]
that those funds should go
[1:52:41]
towards our in culture. More
[1:52:44]
specifically a portion going
[1:52:45]
towards making movies right
[1:52:46]
here in Oakland, Oakland is to
[1:52:49]
be a town of art and culture.
[1:52:51]
It needs use the number one
[1:52:54]
distribution of it. And that's
[1:52:56]
film and I'm happy to share
[1:52:58]
ideas. What PRESIDENT Jenkins
[1:52:59]
and council member Brown
[1:53:00]
Riverside any of you that will
[1:53:03]
ultimately hear me out. We
[1:53:04]
need to be making the movies.
[1:53:06]
If we want people to be
[1:53:07]
visiting Oakland, the
[1:53:09]
influence the film. And I play
[1:53:10]
everybody come here. Barry
[1:53:19]
Field. Thank you for comments.
[1:53:22]
All right. My name is Chris
[1:53:24]
McCAnn with the Embarcadero
[1:53:25]
Neighborhood Association.
[1:53:29]
Recently the city a cleanup in
[1:53:30]
the part. They did an
[1:53:31]
excellent job tons and tons of
[1:53:36]
garbage was removed. And they
[1:53:36]
were smart about planning
[1:53:39]
follow-up. Clean up after
[1:53:44]
this. So that. It wasn't going
[1:53:44]
to be the same story. It's
[1:53:46]
been over the past 5 years has
[1:53:47]
chased people out from one
[1:53:50]
place to another. They need
[1:53:52]
something permanent and it's
[1:53:53]
not what they're getting when
[1:53:56]
they're chased around. Without
[1:53:58]
enforcement when there's a
[1:54:00]
cleanup without enforcement,
[1:54:03]
it just happens again and
[1:54:05]
again. A ton of garbage was
[1:54:06]
removed. Its now piled up.
[1:54:08]
It's now being sorted through
[1:54:10]
and being spread all around
[1:54:13]
the neighborhood. We have a
[1:54:13]
school in our neighborhood
[1:54:17]
that's really important. And
[1:54:18]
right now that's being
[1:54:19]
occupied by people living on
[1:54:22]
the railroad tracks. Thank you
[1:54:23]
for your comments. Your time
[1:54:39]
is that. Next? Speaker?
[1:54:40]
Gallo,
[1:54:43]
you always talk about it's not
[1:54:44]
what you say. It's what you
[1:54:49]
do. How long is it going to
[1:54:51]
take you fix it? The coach,
[1:54:55]
Fred, feel it. But you could
[1:55:01]
emergency legislation. Vo Co 2
[1:55:02]
Look how long it's taken for
[1:55:05]
this black. Coach will fit in
[1:55:12]
your district. Thank you.
[1:55:12]
Councilmember Houston for
[1:55:16]
bringing to the attention.
[1:55:16]
Historical reference related
[1:55:17]
to black folks in this town
[1:55:27]
which, you know, guy Ryan got
[1:55:28]
excuse. She's only been on the
[1:55:31]
council for short time. And
[1:55:33]
that's no real excuse. So what
[1:55:34]
are you going to do about
[1:55:39]
fentanyl? The most deadly,
[1:55:42]
albeit on the street. You want
[1:55:45]
to talk about. A public health
[1:55:47]
crisis for cannabis. Did you
[1:55:51]
know cannabis is illegal? And
[1:55:53]
they got cafe so you can get
[1:55:57]
smoke in the back. So when you
[1:56:04]
got to deal with now. You
[1:56:08]
know, Jala so hypocritical.
[1:56:11]
And you give these and lever
[1:56:16]
Speeches. They're known haul
[1:56:19]
with me. They don't hold with
[1:56:23]
a lot of people in this town.
[1:56:24]
But because you sit where you
[1:56:25]
sit, you think you could give
[1:56:26]
us a bunch of c#
[1:56:28]
. Well,
[1:56:29]
know, bring it to your
[1:56:38]
attention. Stop a guy You know
[1:56:39]
how long black folks have been
[1:56:41]
set for it. And what
[1:56:42]
councilmember Houston said
[1:56:45]
about the heat. Crime capital
[1:56:48]
of the world. We ran parallel
[1:56:53]
with the spelling out too. And
[1:56:53]
that police chief came over
[1:56:59]
here. Thank you. Stay with us.
[1:56:59]
You do that. We'll see the
[1:57:02]
rest of people every time it
[1:57:04]
comes to black folks, you
[1:57:13]
don't step up to the plate.
[1:57:13]
And then when I tried to
[1:57:14]
confront walk out of respect
[1:57:17]
in there, I don't have time.
[1:57:20]
City attorney. It's that city
[1:57:21]
attorney told City attorney be
[1:57:28]
lying to you, too. When y'all
[1:57:31]
to it. The transaction and use
[1:57:35]
tax. By inserting say And
[1:57:43]
address that in open Thank you
[1:57:43]
for your comments. Your time
[1:57:52]
is up. Related to the police
[1:57:57]
chief. I do not support the
[1:57:59]
process. The selection of the
[1:58:00]
chief, the last process. We
[1:58:02]
got to see every candidate we
[1:58:04]
got to hear from every
[1:58:06]
candidate. We didn't have that
[1:58:08]
same process. I don't know who
[1:58:08]
else was out I don't want
[1:58:10]
somebody else. I do not
[1:58:13]
support this process of not
[1:58:15]
knowing the other candidates.
[1:58:17]
You have an item on here
[1:58:19]
that's grant funding from from
[1:58:21]
the Department of Homeland
[1:58:23]
Security. It never went to
[1:58:25]
committee. You don't know what
[1:58:27]
Homeland Security grant money
[1:58:28]
requires you to do related to
[1:58:32]
people here and authorize. But
[1:58:33]
you rubber stamping it. You
[1:58:34]
really care about your
[1:58:34]
sanctuary city status. I don't
[1:58:38]
think so. Related to parking.
[1:58:42]
How does the open ice rink
[1:58:43]
validate free parking? You've
[1:58:44]
never counted fall. How free
[1:58:47]
parking goes on over there?
[1:58:48]
You have on the agenda. A
[1:58:52]
forensic audit to be done. You
[1:58:54]
do identify what but a friend
[1:58:55]
forensic audit is done to
[1:58:58]
uncover evidence full up legal
[1:59:03]
proceedings, fraud and also
[1:59:04]
meant asset misappropriation
[1:59:05]
in committee. You didn't
[1:59:06]
discuss what this forensic
[1:59:09]
audit is about. You have a
[1:59:13]
grant 20350 dislocated
[1:59:13]
workers. Know what that means,
[1:59:15]
dislocated workers, but I do
[1:59:17]
know African-Americans, a 10%
[1:59:18]
of the unemployed in this
[1:59:19]
city. Everybody else is close
[1:59:21]
to full percent. Housing.
[1:59:23]
That's another one hud
[1:59:26]
housing. You don't have any
[1:59:33]
information on who's on House.
[1:59:34]
Open House and authority
[1:59:34]
identified this 5,000 people
[1:59:35]
in their waiting list for
[1:59:38]
House. You have an item
[1:59:42]
antipoverty grant. The county
[1:59:45]
says you have 1000 Funny
[1:59:47]
people who all identified is
[1:59:51]
below poverty. And you only
[1:59:53]
get 1.3 million dollars. How
[1:59:53]
you're going to decide who
[1:59:56]
gets the money. Will it be?
[1:59:57]
Some citizens would be
[2:00:00]
noncitizens. I don't know.
[2:00:02]
Sanctuary City, sanctuary
[2:00:07]
city. 42 to 46% of people.
[2:00:09]
Will in this country on all of
[2:00:10]
the rise here because they
[2:00:11]
have expired visas. You
[2:00:16]
protecting them? Is you
[2:00:17]
protecting them as well?
[2:00:23]
That's 42 to 46%. Sanctuary
[2:00:25]
city background checks and you
[2:00:28]
want to echo usd not have any
[2:00:29]
background checks. Rick wife
[2:00:30]
of volunteers to protect
[2:00:34]
unauthorized people. You have
[2:00:37]
ending increase of salary of
[2:00:40]
council members, city attorney
[2:00:41]
and city on on the agenda
[2:00:42]
today, you can refuse to take
[2:00:47]
a pay raise. These people
[2:00:47]
don't they don't read the
[2:00:48]
agenda to say something else
[2:00:50]
on want to talk about.
[2:00:51]
Situation is a lot of stuff
[2:00:52]
and you need to be talking
[2:00:52]
about people in audience.
[2:01:00]
Okay. Yes. Thank you so much.
[2:01:01]
Mississauga on a summit called
[2:01:03]
for those who are
[2:01:03]
participating via zoom or in
[2:01:04]
person. If I called your name
[2:01:05]
here in person and you have an
[2:01:07]
approach, the podium et please
[2:01:08]
approach the podium. Otherwise
[2:01:11]
we will move to zoom speakers.
[2:01:12]
With that. We will go to our
[2:01:14]
zoom speakers. We have up
[2:01:15]
Thurs Blair Beekman. Your
[2:01:21]
community MAY begin. All right
[2:01:22]
with band. I can place items
[2:01:23]
on consent. I wanted to speak
[2:01:26]
try to get to them Probably
[2:01:27]
help, though, just speak to
[2:01:29]
for us to item 6.4, 6,
[2:01:31]
surveillance technology
[2:01:33]
ordinance you're having having
[2:01:35]
items of mail pr things being
[2:01:37]
brought back to public safety
[2:01:41]
committee either SEPTEMBER,
[2:01:43]
OCTOBER, NOVEMBER. I think it
[2:01:44]
shows that there's a serious
[2:01:45]
problem going on with
[2:01:47]
accountability about pr issue
[2:01:48]
and that, you know, for as
[2:01:52]
much as you put off signing
[2:01:54]
the contract for what I could
[2:01:54]
guess is some actual good
[2:01:58]
reasons for the community. You
[2:01:59]
can't be accountable here in
[2:02:00]
JULY and you've had to push
[2:02:03]
this off until late fall. I
[2:02:04]
think that signals a problem.
[2:02:08]
And I think you guys it's a
[2:02:09]
council person's really have
[2:02:12]
to work to create an acessible
[2:02:13]
understandable informational
[2:02:14]
process. Why you guys are not
[2:02:15]
signing the contract and why
[2:02:17]
you have it. If you have at
[2:02:18]
this point, why did you wait
[2:02:21]
so long to and what does that?
[2:02:22]
What are the benefits of
[2:02:24]
compared to signing the
[2:02:26]
contract immediately and then
[2:02:26]
working through our problems
[2:02:28]
that way is Alameda County is
[2:02:31]
done. They're going to the
[2:02:33]
same rfp process. You guys at
[2:02:34]
this time for a future alpr
[2:02:36]
vendor yet they signed the
[2:02:39]
contract to go through it You
[2:02:40]
guys never to lawsuits. Now
[2:02:43]
you more long. One of all I
[2:02:44]
left vulnerable. Those sort of
[2:02:44]
questions. Can you make clear
[2:02:46]
to the public? What are the
[2:02:47]
advantages of putting all
[2:02:48]
signed the contract? Please
[2:02:49]
work on that. Please make it
[2:02:53]
clear to the public without
[2:02:54]
all said to try to go back to
[2:02:58]
remainder of the item. 6.7
[2:03:00]
Consolidation of the municipal
[2:03:03]
election. I'm not in of city
[2:03:04]
government having some sort of
[2:03:06]
say that they don't have to
[2:03:09]
say what's on the agenda items
[2:03:10]
voting time. The eu. There's
[2:03:11]
legal ways that that is, but
[2:03:13]
it doesn't make anything and
[2:03:14]
more clear. Just give you guys
[2:03:15]
superiority and not. It's not
[2:03:18]
a good system. 6.8 6.9 or
[2:03:21]
celery ordinance, things to
[2:03:22]
try to offer to try to clarify
[2:03:27]
what I said if city workers
[2:03:29]
take a $50 cut in pay each
[2:03:35]
month, $600 a year, 4, 202
[2:03:36]
known for 200,000 workers or
[2:03:40]
what is it yet? 20,000 for the
[2:03:41]
city that work for the city?
[2:03:42]
However, the numbers is a
[2:03:44]
20,000 sorry, whatever. That
[2:03:46]
number is that works out to
[2:03:49]
about 2 million dollars in
[2:03:51]
savings. Just a small pay cut
[2:03:52]
or year. And that allows you
[2:03:55]
to continue the retirement
[2:03:57]
fund. Things and health
[2:03:59]
benefit things. I think that's
[2:04:00]
the more important goal and
[2:04:00]
it's worth taking a big guy
[2:04:03]
but couldn't pay a month. It
[2:04:03]
just creates a better morale.
[2:04:06]
I think for people and there's
[2:04:07]
so many items. I want to talk
[2:04:10]
to thank you for the sanctuary
[2:04:12]
city things and working on
[2:04:12]
that cure weighing can the
[2:04:13]
other council person and I
[2:04:17]
hope they can work on the the
[2:04:17]
street issues what is that the
[2:04:20]
street? Thank you so much for
[2:04:24]
your comments can we are on
[2:04:25]
the consent calendar if you
[2:04:28]
signed up to speak for the
[2:04:30]
consent calendar, today's
[2:04:30]
agenda, can you state the name
[2:04:34]
that you signed up for? All
[2:04:36]
right. No response from low
[2:04:37]
can. We will go to the next
[2:04:42]
speaker you are a muted if you
[2:04:44]
signed up on today's agenda
[2:04:45]
for the consent calendar, what
[2:04:49]
name did you sign up for? 6
[2:04:52]
dot to 5 underwent knee. It
[2:04:56]
should be Kareem Ahmed.
[2:04:56]
Kareem. Unfortunately, I do
[2:05:01]
not have a speaker card. It
[2:05:02]
is. I are a new did. You can
[2:05:08]
go ahead give your comments.
[2:05:11]
Are. My name's Curry. Mohammed
[2:05:12]
Aman original founder of the
[2:05:13]
African American Sports and
[2:05:14]
Entertainment Group speaking
[2:05:16]
in my individual capacity
[2:05:21]
regarding item 6 dot to 5 on
[2:05:22]
Monday, JULY 20th, co-founder
[2:05:23]
and complain to Brian Dickson
[2:05:26]
and I submitted a formal
[2:05:27]
written notices concerning one
[2:05:30]
result. Questions about the
[2:05:31]
relationship among the
[2:05:32]
African-American sports
[2:05:34]
entertainment group Acg Land
[2:05:34]
and Oakland acquisition
[2:05:36]
company, including the
[2:05:37]
authority for advancing the
[2:05:40]
Coliseum transaction to these
[2:05:41]
entities. These matters are
[2:05:43]
connected to a pending
[2:05:44]
arbitration and related
[2:05:45]
Alameda County Superior Court
[2:05:47]
action. We are not asking the
[2:05:47]
council to decide the merits
[2:05:50]
on those disputes and we're
[2:05:52]
not opposing responsible
[2:05:54]
redevelopment within the city
[2:05:56]
of Oakland. We respectfully
[2:05:57]
ask the City Council to Paul
[2:05:58]
and continue the item as 6.
[2:06:01]
That to 5 before authorizing
[2:06:03]
are completing reversible cell
[2:06:03]
transfer recording are
[2:06:09]
closing. Thank you for your
[2:06:10]
comments. I will give will can
[2:06:16]
why believe is David Peters?
[2:06:17]
If you are and you didn't hear
[2:06:18]
me, you can unmute yourself
[2:06:25]
and you can begin. We will go
[2:06:29]
to Jen if you signed up to
[2:06:31]
speak for an agenda item on
[2:06:31]
the consent calendar, can you
[2:06:32]
state the name that you signed
[2:06:37]
up for? Iht under Jennifer
[2:06:38]
Findlay? Thank you so much.
[2:06:46]
Begin. Thank Yeah, 50 some
[2:06:47]
items on that. The content
[2:06:51]
calendar is a lot. I wanted to
[2:06:53]
talk mainly about intersection
[2:06:55]
of that of the sanctuary city
[2:06:59]
ordinance. The you can't beat
[2:06:59]
a beat policy which is
[2:07:01]
ridiculous, offensive name and
[2:07:05]
gop surveillance Tech report.
[2:07:08]
Let's start with supposedly
[2:07:12]
urgent contract from roughly
[2:07:13]
Shangri. That is still not
[2:07:15]
been executed. What's up with
[2:07:16]
that eye had questions? Blair
[2:07:17]
become covered some pretty
[2:07:19]
well. Thank you for that.
[2:07:23]
Regarding the tech
[2:07:23]
surveillance report. First
[2:07:26]
question is why opd still not
[2:07:29]
treating on gps that would
[2:07:30]
help response time close to
[2:07:33]
being shipped out in some I
[2:07:35]
saw last week's opd stats.
[2:07:36]
Crime continues to go down
[2:07:37]
across the board. They seem to
[2:07:42]
be doing well. Senate. With
[2:07:44]
their staffing right to say I
[2:07:45]
oppose the encampment
[2:07:46]
abatement policy, which
[2:07:47]
targets the same people who
[2:07:50]
are being targeted by ice who
[2:07:51]
might unknowingly be sleeping
[2:07:55]
reflect camera. I'm happy to
[2:07:55]
see the new ordinance. But
[2:07:56]
does the city of refuge apply
[2:07:59]
to our unhoused neighbors? How
[2:08:02]
does that overlap with ap? Yes
[2:08:04]
vote flock is the polar
[2:08:07]
opposite 2. Yes. Vote on a
[2:08:10]
sanctuary city. The Flock ceo
[2:08:10]
later this morning
[2:08:11]
specifically said the company
[2:08:13]
has no opinion on immigration.
[2:08:14]
And if the states want to,
[2:08:17]
they can use it for that. It's
[2:08:18]
about so much more than
[2:08:20]
immigration up with It's so
[2:08:22]
much risk in the past. This
[2:08:24]
reason that in the past 13
[2:08:29]
months people people is nearly
[2:08:29]
60 municipalities cancel
[2:08:33]
contracts ascent. But I heard
[2:08:34]
morning, many are more
[2:08:35]
deflating. Should kick cameras
[2:08:36]
down there trying to get
[2:08:39]
contracts canceled. They say
[2:08:41]
that they're not going to
[2:08:41]
access the debt, to think they
[2:08:42]
can access the data. That
[2:08:43]
might be what they say. But
[2:08:44]
when you've got to believe
[2:08:46]
them 2, it only means they
[2:08:47]
can't access to it yet or if
[2:08:50]
they're going to get hat some
[2:08:53]
of them don't even a cat. Ben
[2:08:57]
Jordan, a great work on this.
[2:08:59]
And she many cameras that
[2:09:00]
actually require, you know,
[2:09:02]
lock in for the public to
[2:09:05]
access including baby think
[2:09:09]
sporting at playgrounds and
[2:09:11]
these were available to the
[2:09:12]
public live stream to stream
[2:09:13]
later like they're watching
[2:09:16]
Netflix. I don't want these
[2:09:17]
cameras, which it me or my
[2:09:24]
neighbors there was also
[2:09:25]
instance Sir Lee being
[2:09:27]
prosecuted for in Texas for a,
[2:09:31]
quote, Self managed abortion.
[2:09:32]
Because they were found Cs.
[2:09:36]
This network of flock cameras.
[2:09:38]
We don't talk about stories
[2:09:39]
harmed the police They flock
[2:09:40]
mistakes. The driver stopped.
[2:09:46]
It Thank you for your comments
[2:09:47]
next. Speaker here, West
[2:09:48]
Oakland, Cultural Affairs,
[2:09:48]
Action plan or is this David
[2:09:52]
Peters? That is and thank you
[2:09:54]
for giving me the unmute
[2:09:54]
button because the weather
[2:09:55]
going up to about a 2 time. So
[2:09:56]
thank you. Hear me. Fine. Yes,
[2:09:59]
we can. You MAY begin. Thank
[2:10:00]
you. My name is David Peters.
[2:10:03]
I am the founder and executive
[2:10:04]
director of the West Oakland
[2:10:08]
Cultural Action Network. And I
[2:10:09]
have been going to before I go
[2:10:13]
down that path. I heard
[2:10:15]
earlier speaker talk about in
[2:10:16]
can't and common abatement
[2:10:19]
program in the context of
[2:10:22]
racial equity. It's the racial
[2:10:23]
equity analysis is around the
[2:10:25]
ink, an encampment abatement
[2:10:25]
program and so many other
[2:10:28]
programs is missing lacking in
[2:10:31]
this council has yet to direct
[2:10:33]
and appropriate, fair and
[2:10:34]
equitable racial equity
[2:10:37]
announces for anything.
[2:10:39]
Because if you fail to analyze
[2:10:42]
the impact on my neighborhood
[2:10:45]
and other black and brown flat
[2:10:46]
land neighborhood from the
[2:10:49]
keep a thin by folks who are
[2:10:50]
claiming public territory as
[2:10:52]
their private property, isn't
[2:10:57]
Isn't it? The belief that
[2:10:59]
black neighborhood, black
[2:11:01]
businesses, black babies,
[2:11:02]
black voters and black
[2:11:05]
residents not deserve to live
[2:11:06]
in an environment free from
[2:11:08]
the encampment that are out of
[2:11:09]
control that have become new
[2:11:10]
physical of litter and in
[2:11:13]
other kind problem behaviors
[2:11:14]
because it's not encampment.
[2:11:17]
It is the behaviors we are
[2:11:18]
doing a great disservice to
[2:11:20]
our historic neighborhoods and
[2:11:21]
I need I need the people who
[2:11:22]
come in here and talk like
[2:11:26]
that to assess their impact
[2:11:28]
and the role they play in
[2:11:29]
Pushkin poor black people from
[2:11:29]
shelter to street because
[2:11:31]
y'all get it right now. What
[2:11:35]
about that? But I'm going to
[2:11:36]
coliseum longer any place to
[2:11:39]
my grandparents. House. Every
[2:11:40]
time I go in that place, I
[2:11:43]
think I'm a grandma because
[2:11:44]
that put that college team is
[2:11:45]
so much of our history and
[2:11:47]
culture, whether it was the
[2:11:50]
soul patrol. The fog landed at
[2:11:50]
the mother or nothing. Mandela
[2:11:55]
coming here on his tore that
[2:11:55]
that complex has meant so much
[2:11:56]
for the history and culture.
[2:11:58]
This town. We cannot begin to
[2:12:02]
forget for get how much of
[2:12:05]
that culture and what
[2:12:06]
influence us in that in that
[2:12:07]
city and how much of our
[2:12:11]
history as well. We must have.
[2:12:12]
A museum not just to the
[2:12:15]
people who played at the
[2:12:20]
Coliseum, so many a great
[2:12:21]
oaklanders passes sports
[2:12:22]
fields, including Bill Russell
[2:12:23]
and Frank Robinson who were
[2:12:25]
respectively. The first black
[2:12:26]
manager in the nba, first
[2:12:27]
black coach nba and first
[2:12:29]
black manager in Major League
[2:12:30]
Baseball. Both want to
[2:12:32]
teammates and climbs high
[2:12:33]
school. You would not know
[2:12:36]
that are many other things. If
[2:12:37]
Black Liberation walking tour
[2:12:39]
had not been funded, people
[2:12:39]
all over the world have been
[2:12:42]
on this tour. It's nasty.
[2:12:43]
Recognize it attracts people
[2:12:45]
to come here. We must
[2:12:47]
continue. We must dedicate
[2:12:49]
funding dedicated stream of
[2:12:50]
funding to our arts and
[2:12:51]
culture community because
[2:12:54]
Oakland is known for one
[2:12:57]
unique thing. Our history and
[2:12:58]
our culture, our unparalleled
[2:12:59]
and a whole bunch. We all came
[2:13:01]
move here. Cause us. Thank you
[2:13:02]
for your comments, David
[2:13:03]
Peters, that concludes your
[2:13:04]
public comment. Speakers for
[2:13:13]
item 6. Thank you. I will pass
[2:13:16]
it to city administrator like
[2:13:17]
thank you very much on the
[2:13:19]
administration is requesting
[2:13:23]
that item 6.4, 0, the
[2:13:24]
professional services
[2:13:24]
agreement with her at a
[2:13:28]
company for signage and
[2:13:29]
wayfinding services. The
[2:13:30]
continued until the next
[2:13:35]
meeting. SEPTEMBER 15th. Thank
[2:13:39]
you colleagues any questions
[2:13:40]
count. Some member, Gallo and
[2:13:49]
Houston. And that was a motion
[2:13:51]
by Councilmember Gallo,
[2:13:52]
seconded by Councilmember
[2:13:53]
Houston to approve the consent
[2:13:55]
count, little calendar as
[2:14:03]
amended on roll. And things
[2:14:04]
comes another one. Yes. Thank
[2:14:06]
you so much chair. Appreciate
[2:14:08]
it. I did want to address a
[2:14:10]
cup for more items in the
[2:14:11]
agenda first fall on 6 points
[2:14:15]
or 6.2, 1. Thank you, Dan Cow.
[2:14:16]
First of all, for your service
[2:14:18]
to the city, especially a
[2:14:19]
leader in environment and in
[2:14:23]
on the environment. Thanks for
[2:14:24]
bringing to my attention as
[2:14:26]
well as council member Brown
[2:14:29]
Detention sb 954. I just hope
[2:14:30]
that we can continue your
[2:14:32]
legacy of environmental
[2:14:35]
activism here in the city of
[2:14:36]
Oakland. I also wanted to do a
[2:14:40]
shout out Braxton gotten or i
[2:14:41]
seen the audience as look
[2:14:45]
forward to your expertise on
[2:14:46]
the Privacy Advisory
[2:14:50]
Commission. The other item, I
[2:14:51]
want to dress a very quickly
[2:14:53]
6.2 5. I know that we are not
[2:14:55]
making a decision around how
[2:14:56]
the revenue for the Coliseum
[2:14:59]
sales going today. But
[2:15:00]
considering the voices in the
[2:15:04]
audience. I did want to just
[2:15:04]
logs some support for a
[2:15:05]
portion of the revenue going
[2:15:07]
to arts and culture,
[2:15:10]
especially when I think about
[2:15:11]
this vision that we have
[2:15:12]
around the coliseum minute
[2:15:14]
positioning to be calm,
[2:15:16]
Oakland, to be a music city,
[2:15:21]
right? I think about Austin,
[2:15:22]
Texas, Nashville and these
[2:15:23]
other music City's what
[2:15:25]
they've done. Well is to bring
[2:15:29]
up homegrown talent. Right?
[2:15:32]
And so I also think this is a
[2:15:33]
smart economic development
[2:15:34]
decision that is going to bear
[2:15:38]
out return on investment. And,
[2:15:39]
you know, we've had to park
[2:15:41]
Kalani come through city of
[2:15:42]
Oakland. I'd like to see more
[2:15:44]
of that homegrown talent make
[2:15:46]
it onto, you know, and urging
[2:15:51]
a soft stage. Finally, I just
[2:15:54]
want to address a 6.4 6. This
[2:15:56]
is the infirm at the
[2:15:59]
technology. Opd reports. First
[2:16:02]
of all, there was some
[2:16:03]
misinformation just look, I
[2:16:05]
think should have worthwhile
[2:16:06]
debates about flock. I also
[2:16:09]
think there's been some
[2:16:09]
misinformation posted around
[2:16:14]
how there was a deliberate
[2:16:15]
intention around item sub This
[2:16:17]
was the alpr item that was
[2:16:19]
truly there. Isn't it? Opd
[2:16:20]
came to me because they
[2:16:22]
realize there is a legal issue
[2:16:26]
with how it was posted. And so
[2:16:26]
it would have been an issue
[2:16:28]
for us to adopt it. So to be
[2:16:30]
clear, we are not adopting
[2:16:32]
anything related to the alp
[2:16:34]
ours today that was stricken
[2:16:35]
from the record and taken
[2:16:38]
down. And I just think that
[2:16:39]
when we have these debates,
[2:16:42]
let's at least grounded in the
[2:16:43]
facts. And finally, since I
[2:16:46]
was unable to address
[2:16:48]
Mississauga before sense, it
[2:16:49]
wasn't actually part of this.
[2:16:50]
I I really want to thank you.
[2:16:53]
You didn't have to do that for
[2:16:56]
me. So so thank you. And I
[2:16:56]
think the thing about this
[2:17:00]
asada is that. You and I have
[2:17:01]
had my we've had our
[2:17:06]
disagreements at times. But I
[2:17:07]
really think this is not a
[2:17:08]
first of all. You do war
[2:17:13]
reading, on these items than
[2:17:15]
anybody. Anybody on the city
[2:17:15]
council, you really do. And
[2:17:18]
you actually see it on the
[2:17:20]
school board meetings, the
[2:17:21]
county beatings, you are more.
[2:17:23]
Well, you are reading every
[2:17:25]
single piece and I actually
[2:17:26]
think people need to do a
[2:17:28]
documentary about your life.
[2:17:32]
Your life story truly. Because
[2:17:34]
and where you came from New
[2:17:35]
Orleans and just your history
[2:17:37]
and how you came to come to
[2:17:39]
Oakland, all your
[2:17:40]
contributions. And I think for
[2:17:45]
me, you know, I actually want
[2:17:46]
your voice to your perspective
[2:17:47]
to ring through. Clearly when
[2:17:51]
it comes to public safety.
[2:17:51]
Unfortunately, I also have an
[2:17:52]
obligation even when I agree
[2:17:56]
with your point of view you
[2:17:57]
know, just maintain order,
[2:17:58]
even one. I think your
[2:18:01]
perspective is incredibly
[2:18:02]
important. But let's chat
[2:18:03]
afterwards and again, thank
[2:18:05]
you. You really didn't have to
[2:18:05]
do that for me. So I I just
[2:18:15]
appreciate you. Thank you.
[2:18:17]
Councilmember Long and thank
[2:18:19]
you. Missus councilmember.
[2:18:23]
He's ok, we have a motion and
[2:18:25]
a second. Thank you once
[2:18:25]
again, so much for that. So we
[2:18:26]
have a motion by COUNCILMAN
[2:18:29]
The guile seconded by
[2:18:30]
Councilmember Houston to
[2:18:32]
approve the consent counter as
[2:18:33]
amended on role Council member
[2:18:38]
Brown. Thank you.
[2:18:39]
Councilmember Fife is excuse
[2:18:40]
Councilmember Gallo. I
[2:18:42]
Councilmember Houston. I I
[2:18:50]
Wang. And chair Ramachandran.
[2:18:51]
Item number 6. The consent
[2:18:52]
counter is approved as amended
[2:18:55]
with 6 ayes and to excused.
[2:19:06]
That now takes us to. That.
[2:19:08]
Now takes us to the item. 7
[2:19:09]
counsel counsel
[2:19:09]
acknowledgements and
[2:19:14]
announcements. Okay.
[2:19:15]
Colleagues, any announcements?
[2:19:17]
Well, there was a public
[2:19:18]
speaker who started to mention
[2:19:19]
this event, which I will
[2:19:23]
gladly highlight right now on
[2:19:24]
that Thursday, JULY 30th right
[2:19:28]
here in council chambers. My
[2:19:29]
office is working with Bay
[2:19:34]
Area, Phil Knight, 2 to screen
[2:19:35]
2 amazing local made films.
[2:19:37]
That will be a panel
[2:19:38]
discussion after the event
[2:19:40]
which I will not great. Thank
[2:19:41]
you to Jim. Not true. Love for
[2:19:42]
being here today and for
[2:19:48]
putting on this event. And
[2:19:50]
bringing speakers who are
[2:19:51]
fantastic film makers as well
[2:19:51]
as the executive director of
[2:19:54]
the San Francisco Film
[2:19:55]
Commission. It is a free event
[2:19:56]
sign-up online. We hope to see
[2:19:58]
you next Thursday at 06:00pm
[2:20:03]
at Council Chambers any other
[2:20:07]
announcements, if not. Well in
[2:20:10]
please do consider attending
[2:20:11]
the Laurel Street Fest on
[2:20:12]
Saturday, AUGUST 8th. It's
[2:20:17]
going to be beautiful. And the
[2:20:18]
performances really, really,
[2:20:19]
really amazing time again.
[2:20:23]
Another free festival and if
[2:20:25]
there are no other
[2:20:26]
announcements or adjournment
[2:20:31]
we will move to open farm.
[2:20:33]
Thank you so much. We are now
[2:20:33]
open as I call your name.
[2:20:35]
Please approach the podium in
[2:20:37]
any order state. Your name for
[2:20:38]
record. If you're
[2:20:39]
participating in a line and
[2:20:39]
you would like speak once I
[2:20:40]
call your name, you can make
[2:20:41]
your hand as well. So I can
[2:20:42]
easily identify you will start
[2:20:44]
with those in person. Jennifer
[2:20:53]
Findlay. Renay. David Peters.
[2:20:53]
Natalie, near Jon Jones. The
[2:20:55]
3rd Mississauga on the Bala
[2:20:58]
Lambertville Retana. Windy
[2:21:01]
blooming marked the cruel
[2:21:05]
Tracey tallest Williams
[2:21:12]
Alexander Ridge, Windy. Martha
[2:21:16]
Kohl ants, Madeline, Stacey.
[2:21:17]
And Jeanne hazards in any
[2:21:22]
order, MR. Hazzard. I was in
[2:21:27]
court on JUNE. 25 2026 related
[2:21:29]
to the transaction and use tax
[2:21:35]
a special election. APRIL 15.
[2:21:43]
This city after 4. 378 days.
[2:21:43]
Vow to The only thing they
[2:21:48]
found since MAY 19. To dismiss
[2:21:51]
my case. The court sustained
[2:21:54]
it. Without lead to a man on
[2:21:57]
preparing. The opening before
[2:22:01]
the appeals court, which I was
[2:22:01]
already prepared for MAY 19th
[2:22:05]
2025. But what's interesting
[2:22:10]
with all of this. 2 documents,
[2:22:15]
a draft. And the proposed
[2:22:15]
ordinance. There's no
[2:22:19]
introduction. For what the
[2:22:19]
council approved on JANUARY
[2:22:27]
9th. Thank you for your
[2:22:36]
comments. Your time is up. I
[2:22:38]
chair records zones. The 3rd
[2:22:39]
want to say a few things. I
[2:22:39]
appreciate the comments made
[2:22:43]
by Councilmember Houston. I
[2:22:44]
think its important to review
[2:22:46]
all the contracts right? And
[2:22:47]
look at how many times they'll
[2:22:49]
slip requirements been weight.
[2:22:51]
Know there's a tendency to do
[2:22:52]
so. And I do believe that we
[2:22:54]
be local support, locals much
[2:22:54]
as possible. Another thing I
[2:22:56]
want to share, that's very
[2:22:58]
important with all the vacant
[2:22:59]
and abandoned buildings and
[2:23:02]
parcels of land. We got here
[2:23:04]
when I was walking now
[2:23:05]
international for the brt. I
[2:23:06]
notice that first of all, a
[2:23:07]
lot of these buildings are not
[2:23:08]
even people from this country.
[2:23:10]
30's. So the merchant some
[2:23:11]
time because that's the
[2:23:12]
challenge for the owner to
[2:23:13]
transmit the mission to the
[2:23:15]
merchant. My point is as a
[2:23:16]
city, we should be in the
[2:23:16]
business of acquiring assets
[2:23:18]
as much as possible because we
[2:23:19]
don't know when the next
[2:23:22]
pandemic. Mike, her, we see
[2:23:23]
what happened with the parcel
[2:23:24]
83rd MacArthur High was sold.
[2:23:25]
So I would encourage you all
[2:23:29]
to do that work. Let's connect
[2:23:30]
with the county assessor.
[2:23:31]
Lsu's eminent domain for
[2:23:32]
properties that are owned by
[2:23:33]
people who are doing nothing
[2:23:35]
with it. So thank you. Thank
[2:23:37]
you for your comments. Want
[2:23:40]
to? Thank MISS Candace, I'm
[2:23:43]
gonna MISS You. I'm gonna MISS
[2:23:48]
You so much. We always ability
[2:23:50]
to put people in groups. And I
[2:23:54]
have put. People into the
[2:23:57]
groups that I understand. The
[2:23:59]
people are in this country 3
[2:24:03]
groups. The indigenous people,
[2:24:07]
the original people. The
[2:24:09]
people who immigrated to this
[2:24:11]
country and the 3rd group as
[2:24:12]
the people who came here
[2:24:15]
against their will. The
[2:24:18]
enslaved people better known
[2:24:19]
as African-Americans. That's
[2:24:20]
the group I'm talking about.
[2:24:24]
Every time I come here. We not
[2:24:26]
the same as those of the 2
[2:24:29]
groups. We have a lot of
[2:24:29]
things that are not in place
[2:24:34]
for us. In terms of jobs,
[2:24:36]
housing in terms of education.
[2:24:38]
Appreciate what you did. That
[2:24:40]
resolution but then identifies
[2:24:42]
the issues of African
[2:24:43]
Americans in this city. We
[2:24:44]
have no action plan. To deal
[2:24:50]
with those. Apologies.
[2:24:51]
Mississauga you times that
[2:24:56]
next Speaker. Thank you.
[2:24:58]
Hello. My name Dana, I'm a
[2:25:01]
psychotherapist at Children's
[2:25:02]
Hospital. Oakland all sewn up
[2:25:02]
the union member. And I'm here
[2:25:05]
to talk about measure Measure
[2:25:06]
c. But before I get to that, I
[2:25:08]
want to extend some thank yous
[2:25:09]
for a spot to for coming out
[2:25:10]
to support us on JULY 9th,
[2:25:12]
action there. And for the
[2:25:14]
hospital second vote, we want
[2:25:17]
to think Mayor Lee, who
[2:25:18]
somehow found it in a way to
[2:25:21]
persuade Nicholas Home Co to
[2:25:23]
have a conversation with ice
[2:25:25]
meeting. Labor as you MAY
[2:25:26]
know, Measure c has Isaac
[2:25:28]
about 20% for the hospital. 5%
[2:25:29]
of which we are supposed to
[2:25:30]
have some say. So with respect
[2:25:34]
to how spent until Nichols
[2:25:37]
home would have nothing to do
[2:25:37]
with us. Making one making up
[2:25:40]
one excuse or another. Now
[2:25:42]
then cut to the chase. Were
[2:25:42]
here to ask you to do
[2:25:45]
something because we think
[2:25:45]
that the hospice misusing
[2:25:47]
measure c money, how do we
[2:25:51]
know it looks like they're
[2:25:52]
taking care open residents
[2:25:52]
only cameras. It over to the
[2:25:54]
city health care. And we also
[2:25:56]
think that they're taking jobs
[2:26:01]
that we do. Thank you for your
[2:26:06]
comments next. Speaker. Hello,
[2:26:07]
my name is Tracy. Tell us
[2:26:10]
clinical life and scientists
[2:26:12]
at Tall Children's Hospital,
[2:26:13]
Oakland and I just want been
[2:26:15]
working there for about a good
[2:26:17]
10 years. And we recently
[2:26:18]
received a letter saying
[2:26:21]
services will be moved out to
[2:26:21]
China Basin, which is over on
[2:26:24]
the east, the West Bay so that
[2:26:26]
we are getting services cut
[2:26:31]
in. There are several things
[2:26:33]
that are detrimental for
[2:26:33]
children at Children's
[2:26:36]
Hospital. So one being blood
[2:26:36]
cultures, that blood cultures
[2:26:39]
are moved out. It we've had a
[2:26:42]
case or scenario where the
[2:26:43]
black culture turn positive in
[2:26:46]
less than 6 hours. Pretty
[2:26:48]
common for rapid for different
[2:26:49]
type of organisms. But if it
[2:26:52]
turns positive and is in route
[2:26:53]
to being set up over there, we
[2:26:55]
could lose at least 6 to 8
[2:26:56]
hours. And that's really
[2:26:57]
detrimental for children
[2:27:00]
because, you know, there a
[2:27:01]
really sensitive population.
[2:27:02]
And this patient just happened
[2:27:05]
to be oncology patient. So we
[2:27:06]
would actually lose the
[2:27:09]
ability to for accessibility.
[2:27:10]
Thank you for your comments.
[2:27:16]
Tracy. Next speaker. Hi, my
[2:27:18]
name is Wendy Blum Unama rn
[2:27:19]
and I've been in Oakland
[2:27:21]
Children's Hospital for last
[2:27:23]
39 years since the affiliation
[2:27:24]
with ucsf that started 11
[2:27:26]
years ago. We have seen a
[2:27:27]
steady decline and services
[2:27:30]
offered in Oakland, ucsf
[2:27:31]
receives funds from Alameda
[2:27:33]
County's Measure c that
[2:27:34]
funding should be used for the
[2:27:34]
hospital services provided in
[2:27:38]
the Oakland Campus. We want
[2:27:38]
transparency and
[2:27:39]
accountability for those
[2:27:40]
funds. Please listen to the
[2:27:43]
staff in the trenches and
[2:27:44]
don't follow for ucsf. Spotty
[2:27:47]
power point presentations. We
[2:27:48]
do not want to see the for the
[2:27:48]
loss of certain needed
[2:27:50]
services for the families in
[2:27:52]
Oakland. We've already seen
[2:27:54]
our bone marrow, the bulk of
[2:27:55]
our bone marrow transplant
[2:27:55]
program is moved to Mission
[2:27:59]
Bay in San Francisco. We're
[2:28:01]
seeing the shift of college e
[2:28:04]
services as well as complex
[2:28:05]
cardiac surgeries. Our single
[2:28:07]
cell program is world renowned
[2:28:08]
to the longtime guidance of
[2:28:09]
our position. Now, doesn't
[2:28:10]
cheat. And we have really have
[2:28:12]
fears that medical hits will
[2:28:13]
cut those programs for the
[2:28:15]
adults as well as that
[2:28:16]
children services. So please
[2:28:24]
help us keep care in Oakland.
[2:28:25]
My name is Martha Cool. And
[2:28:27]
I've been in our ins for 45
[2:28:28]
years of those years. I worked
[2:28:30]
40 years at Oakland,
[2:28:32]
Children's caring for sick,
[2:28:33]
the sick and injured kids and
[2:28:35]
specialize in care of kids
[2:28:37]
with cancer. I retired but
[2:28:37]
remain active in our community
[2:28:41]
for health care. Right. When
[2:28:42]
ucsf Health first affiliated
[2:28:44]
Cho and 14 uc promised so
[2:28:46]
much. But you can't trust
[2:28:49]
them. We have all witnessed a
[2:28:50]
diminishing level of services
[2:28:51]
and care over time with the
[2:28:53]
transfer specialties across
[2:28:56]
the bay. Not only that they
[2:28:58]
unilaterally cut our contracts
[2:28:59]
and transferred us into a
[2:29:00]
substandard contract that they
[2:29:03]
don't even honor. More
[2:29:05]
importantly, though, this has
[2:29:07]
caused harm to many workers
[2:29:07]
and families and working
[2:29:08]
conditions have deteriorated.
[2:29:12]
Morale is very low. More
[2:29:13]
importantly, good working
[2:29:15]
conditions are always the
[2:29:16]
foundation that makes it
[2:29:17]
possible to give great patient
[2:29:19]
care without this patients MAY
[2:29:20]
be at risk and all try to give
[2:29:22]
even if we all try to do the
[2:29:23]
best, they must be held to
[2:29:27]
account. Thank you so much for
[2:29:33]
your comments next. Speaker.
[2:29:34]
Good afternoon, everybody. I'm
[2:29:37]
ridge. I want to give a simple
[2:29:40]
introduction about who I am.
[2:29:41]
I'm a 14 year-old I live and
[2:29:43]
also brought there and I am
[2:29:46]
interning with close regroup.
[2:29:49]
I'm shattered Isaac right
[2:29:51]
here. You guys, many of you
[2:29:53]
MAY be familiar with my
[2:29:54]
grandmother, Jane Garcia.
[2:29:54]
She's the ceo of a clinic at
[2:30:00]
nasa. Jim, by that same spirit
[2:30:01]
of community service. I'm
[2:30:01]
deeply involved in local
[2:30:04]
advocate advocacy at my school
[2:30:05]
District, West Contra Costa
[2:30:08]
Unified School District. I
[2:30:09]
would like to thank you,
[2:30:10]
MISTER Gallo, giving mine in
[2:30:14]
the street. Thank you your
[2:30:23]
comments. Next Mylan, Stacy,
[2:30:24]
today, we had quite a packed
[2:30:26]
agenda in terms of the consent
[2:30:28]
items. There usually is a
[2:30:28]
packed agenda, but I've
[2:30:31]
noticed a trend in the past
[2:30:33]
few months that every city
[2:30:34]
council committee and every
[2:30:35]
concurrent City council
[2:30:36]
meeting has made the public
[2:30:40]
comment cut down to one minute
[2:30:42]
or as it's now essentially
[2:30:43]
defaulted. And we all expect
[2:30:45]
only have one minute. And I
[2:30:46]
just like you to think about
[2:30:50]
and consider how public isn't
[2:30:51]
really fully able to give a
[2:30:53]
voice to everything you want
[2:30:53]
to, especially with the
[2:30:54]
consent items where we had a
[2:30:56]
maximum of 3 minutes when many
[2:30:57]
of us wanted to comment on a
[2:31:00]
handful of the items, it's
[2:31:01]
just simply not enough time
[2:31:02]
for public input actually be
[2:31:05]
heard inconsiderate. Thank you
[2:31:06]
for your comments next.
[2:31:11]
Speaker. The little Damian or
[2:31:12]
first of all, thank you very
[2:31:16]
much for the grant performance
[2:31:17]
year-old. One of those things
[2:31:21]
that. Always is a route that
[2:31:22]
you always rude to me back in
[2:31:23]
the city. Whenever I would
[2:31:25]
come back home from traveling
[2:31:26]
or whatever, very few of the
[2:31:27]
lake and then being able to
[2:31:31]
see that that And then as far
[2:31:35]
the Coliseum, I think it be
[2:31:37]
very interesting if city was
[2:31:38]
able to during this break to
[2:31:42]
take a look at. The other big
[2:31:43]
projects that we wanted to
[2:31:46]
accomplish. Didn't happen and
[2:31:49]
really identify where the city
[2:31:52]
fell apart and try to get
[2:31:53]
started and get infrastructure
[2:31:53]
right, like MR. Hazzard said
[2:31:55]
he's going to be a while
[2:31:56]
before everything gets going.
[2:31:57]
But it be great if the city
[2:31:58]
could have some things in
[2:32:00]
place. And on note, also
[2:32:01]
thinking about the idea music
[2:32:05]
City. It can also you can
[2:32:06]
operate from the top down. But
[2:32:07]
I think there's also some
[2:32:08]
foundation made get put in
[2:32:09]
place that we don't have to
[2:32:09]
wait for that 6% to start
[2:32:11]
rolling Thanks. Thank you for
[2:32:16]
your comments. All names have
[2:32:17]
been called. If you signed up
[2:32:18]
to speak in your in person,
[2:32:21]
please approach the podium. If
[2:32:22]
not, we will go to Speakers
[2:32:23]
blare become in your community
[2:32:28]
MAY begin. Thank you. Really
[2:32:29]
awesome words play a big win
[2:32:30]
here. Really awesome words
[2:32:32]
that you guys have over 15
[2:32:33]
made it over efficient the
[2:32:36]
public comment time. I work on
[2:32:38]
that and come back in the fall
[2:32:39]
with a better plan. Thank you
[2:32:42]
for a person's words. I also
[2:32:43]
want to comment. It's a
[2:32:44]
sideshow issues that I hope
[2:32:45]
that council person wearing an
[2:32:50]
a Houston again get together
[2:32:51]
on council person. Houston
[2:32:53]
some interesting ideas on
[2:32:56]
sideshow. Things. I hope that
[2:32:57]
can be a work. I'm really
[2:32:58]
hopeful. I heard how the movie
[2:32:59]
business can be of help to
[2:33:01]
Oakland. I think every
[2:33:01]
practice. Good check
[2:33:02]
accountability for the
[2:33:03]
upcoming downtown development
[2:33:05]
projects. That would be really
[2:33:08]
helpful and just give people
[2:33:09]
good reminders that best
[2:33:10]
practices simply makes people
[2:33:11]
feel good with technology and
[2:33:13]
good luck. And those efforts.
[2:33:14]
And finally, our council
[2:33:17]
person wearing you had a good
[2:33:19]
meeting today and that's a
[2:33:21]
really important goal with
[2:33:22]
tech accountability that we
[2:33:24]
learn to be more clear, honest
[2:33:25]
and straight forward with each
[2:33:25]
other in our conversations.
[2:33:28]
And I don't think you. Thank
[2:33:29]
you for your comments. If I
[2:33:31]
called your name and you are
[2:33:32]
on zoom action, please raise
[2:33:34]
your hand if not all names
[2:33:36]
have been called for Open
[2:33:39]
forum. Thank you so much.
[2:33:40]
Before council members we
[2:33:41]
Sorry, my apologies. I do see
[2:33:43]
one of speakers raised their
[2:33:44]
hand, I believe is David
[2:33:45]
Peters. You eat yourself and
[2:33:48]
begin. Thank you. MADAM Clerk,
[2:33:51]
this is David Peters of West
[2:33:54]
Oakland. It is that fine day
[2:33:55]
and was the open right now? I
[2:33:58]
hope you are fined as much joy
[2:33:58]
in this beautiful find JULY
[2:34:02]
afternoon. As I am over here,
[2:34:05]
optimistic. I think that for
[2:34:08]
the first time in a while, I
[2:34:08]
think that we're pulling
[2:34:09]
together play in the right
[2:34:12]
direction. You know, we've see
[2:34:14]
some significant outside
[2:34:16]
investment at the Coliseum
[2:34:17]
property in a deal it by 4
[2:34:19]
brothers from the from the
[2:34:20]
town. We continue to make
[2:34:26]
strides in public safety the
[2:34:28]
our budget, cliff that we seem
[2:34:29]
to almost humble over last
[2:34:31]
year, perhaps as bad for. I
[2:34:32]
want to remind everybody
[2:34:33]
everything accomplished
[2:34:35]
through the culture spirit in
[2:34:36]
this town come out on the
[2:34:37]
black liberation walking
[2:34:39]
toward this Saturday, AUGUST
[2:34:43]
whatever it is. And again, the
[2:34:44]
of JULY, whatever it is, the
[2:34:46]
last will be on AUGUST. 15th.
[2:34:52]
Its ceo down. Thank you for
[2:34:52]
your comments. That concludes
[2:34:54]
our open speakers. Thank you.
[2:34:55]
Before we lose clam city
[2:35:00]
clerk, please go ahead. Thank
[2:35:03]
Just as the council its rating
[2:35:03]
on as ida said, this is
[2:35:06]
Candice Evans last meeting
[2:35:07]
with this is she is moving on
[2:35:08]
and I just want to thank her
[2:35:10]
for her great work, a good
[2:35:12]
service. We say many great
[2:35:14]
people moved through the city
[2:35:14]
clerk's office and she is once
[2:35:17]
I just want to thank her today
[2:35:18]
for her service and just we
[2:35:19]
share the best. She who's on
[2:35:28]
to do great things. Thank you
[2:35:29]
so much. Musk and this wishing
[2:35:31]
you the very best in your
[2:35:34]
future endeavors. This is this
[2:35:35]
is often a thankless and
[2:35:35]
hijack that declare say they
[2:35:39]
just read in, you know, in one
[2:35:42]
single breath, 55 items
[2:35:43]
consent. Plus, several others
[2:35:45]
in this meeting and you help
[2:35:46]
from these meeting smoothly
[2:35:46]
everyone who works in the
[2:35:50]
clerk's office says incredibly
[2:35:51]
important work for
[2:35:52]
transparency and access year
[2:35:54]
in Oakland and getting our
[2:35:55]
agendas clear and moving
[2:36:03]
forward. So thank you come
[2:36:08]
summer. His Due to change is
[2:36:13]
hard for me. Change is hard
[2:36:14]
you believe in and I'm used to
[2:36:18]
you You steal Muzak. I hate
[2:36:20]
change, but wish you the best,
[2:36:23]
you know, and I'm used abuse
[2:36:24]
everyone dry with somebody go
[2:36:25]
over. Just used everyone. I'm
[2:36:30]
used to structure. So you're
[2:36:31]
congratulate you, but you mess
[2:36:33]
it a structural what just
[2:36:34]
structure here. So appreciate
[2:36:38]
it. I love Thank you. Thank
[2:36:41]
you. Enjoy recess, everyone or
[2:36:42]
else he'll be here working.
[2:36:43]
But this meeting is adjourned.
[2:36:58]
See you in SEPTEMBER.