Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
[0:14]
That's very
[0:19]
right now.
[0:34]
Yeah. Yeah.
[0:39]
[music]
[0:51]
» [music]
[0:57]
[music]
[1:02]
[music]
[1:12]
» Stay down.
[1:31]
» [music]
[1:37]
» Birthday.
[2:09]
Uh-huh.
[2:30]
Hallelujah.
[2:39]
[music]
[2:45]
[music]
[3:10]
too.
[3:12]
If you ever plan to go away
[3:19]
my way, take the highway. That's the
[3:22]
best
[3:25]
kick on
[3:33]
Chicago,000
[3:39]
miles
[3:40]
all the way.
[3:48]
» [music]
[3:51]
» Through
[3:52]
Missouri
[3:55]
looking
[4:04]
[music] for
[4:09]
you
[4:11]
the time
[4:14]
[music]
[4:15]
and you make that guy love for your
[4:21]
kids.
[4:39]
» [music]
[4:44]
[music]
[5:01]
[music]
[5:03]
» Going
[5:05]
to see
[5:07]
Missouri
[5:24]
[music]
[5:26]
time
[5:29]
when you make
[5:32]
California
[5:34]
» [music]
[5:35]
» Showcase
[5:37]
all showcase
[5:41]
showcase.
[5:45]
[music]
[6:02]
You missed it.
[6:07]
» He left.
[6:18]
I'm just going to do regular version.
[6:38]
» [music]
[6:47]
» Come here.
[6:57]
Here
[7:02]
we go. [music]
[7:42]
» [music]
[7:47]
[music]
[7:53]
[music]
[8:03]
[music]
[8:04]
» Come on.
[8:17]
» [music]
[8:51]
[music]
[8:59]
[music]
[9:08]
» Go. [music]
[9:24]
Go ahead. Thank you.
[9:35]
» [music]
[9:36]
» I show you
[9:44]
[music]
[9:54]
check.
[10:18]
Sorry.
[10:34]
Free is
[10:47]
[music]
[10:53]
ready.
[11:03]
» [music]
[11:08]
» Hallelujah.
[11:11]
[music]
[11:24]
All right.
[11:28]
There you go.
[11:38]
» [music]
[11:47]
[music]
[11:52]
[music]
[12:10]
[music]
[12:18]
» Don't get around.
[12:30]
Let's
[12:33]
do
[12:40]
» Myself
[12:58]
right there. Or you want
[13:11]
This musical.
[13:17]
[music]
[13:22]
[music]
[13:29]
Glorious.
[13:51]
[music]
[14:10]
» [music]
[14:16]
[music]
[14:21]
» Thank you.
[14:27]
» [music]
[14:33]
[music]
[14:38]
[music]
[14:55]
» Understand.
[15:16]
» [music]
[15:17]
» La.
[15:39]
[music] Heat.
[15:56]
» [music]
[16:01]
» Oh my
[16:08]
god.
[16:10]
[music]
[16:22]
» [music]
[16:38]
» Thank you. Thank you.
[16:41]
» [applause]
[16:47]
» This is our last song.
[16:48]
» Uh we're here
[16:51]
for Black Incorporated and we are
[16:54]
opening up the China Christian Jazz
[16:56]
Record.
[17:00]
[applause]
[17:05]
Hallelujah.
[17:09]
[music]
[17:16]
[music]
[17:32]
Wow.
[17:39]
[music]
[17:45]
[music]
[17:58]
» [music]
[18:03]
» Hallelujah.
[18:22]
» [music]
[18:29]
[music]
[18:37]
[music]
[18:52]
» Okay.
[18:58]
Four.
[19:04]
I'm
[19:06]
[music]
[19:12]
[music]
[19:13]
trying to say
[19:17]
[music]
[19:22]
[music]
[19:42]
» [applause]
[20:19]
» You want
[28:04]
All right, we're going to get started
[28:05]
this morning. I first I want to thank
[28:07]
Morris McCraven and friends, the jazz
[28:09]
trio that was performing inside the
[28:12]
chambers here. We'll hear a little bit
[28:13]
more about the Charlie Christian
[28:15]
International Music Festival in a few
[28:17]
minutes. But first, we are going to have
[28:20]
a invocation led by Lieutenant Steven
[28:23]
Harris, who is chaplain for the Oklahoma
[28:25]
City Fire Department, followed by the
[28:27]
pledge of allegiance led by Elise and
[28:30]
Jocelyn Ormandi, representing Scouting
[28:32]
America Troop 3055.
[28:35]
Please stand as you are able.
[28:43]
Let us pray.
[28:45]
Lord, we give praise to you today. We
[28:47]
thank you for the wonderful things
[28:49]
happening to our city with arenas and
[28:51]
stadiums and parks on the riverside.
[28:54]
Lord, we thank you for these things.
[28:56]
Lord, help us to gain wisdom and
[28:58]
understanding to help our homeless
[29:00]
people and other people in need in our
[29:02]
city in a lasting way. Lord, let our
[29:05]
city be a light to all cities, to all
[29:07]
people that we can live in safety and
[29:10]
harmony and joy regardless of our
[29:14]
ethnicity, regardless of our beliefs,
[29:17]
that this would glorify you. In your
[29:18]
name we pray. Amen.
[29:27]
Will you please join us for the pledge
[29:30]
of allegiance?
[29:34]
» I pledge aliance to the flag of the
[29:38]
United States of America and to the
[29:42]
republic for which it stands, one nation
[29:46]
under God, indivisible, with liberty and
[29:49]
justice for all.
[29:57]
Well, thank you, Lieutenant Harris, and
[29:58]
thank you, Elise and Jocelyn.
[30:02]
All right, next up, uh, well, first of
[30:04]
all, I call the meeting to order and,
[30:07]
uh, next up will be couple of
[30:09]
presentations from office of the mayor
[30:12]
and I will make my way to the front for
[30:14]
that.
[30:32]
Thank you.
[30:33]
Maybe Anita and our friends from the
[30:35]
Charlie Christian uh music festival can
[30:39]
come down.
[30:53]
All right. Well, coming up again is the
[30:55]
Charlie Christian International Music
[30:57]
Festival. And to learn a little bit more
[30:59]
about that, I'd ask the clerk to read
[31:01]
this proclamation.
[31:03]
Whereas the Black Liberated Arts Center,
[31:06]
now in its 59th year, was established to
[31:09]
showcase the cultures and contributions
[31:11]
of African-Americans
[31:13]
through fine arts and arts education.
[31:16]
And whereas for nearly six decades, the
[31:19]
Black Liberated Arts Center has worked
[31:21]
to develop the artistic talents and
[31:23]
teaching abilities of Oklahomaans,
[31:25]
bringing world-class arts experience to
[31:28]
Oklahoma City and our state.
[31:31]
And whereas the Black Liberated Arts
[31:33]
Center has produced the annual Charlie
[31:36]
Christian International Music Festival
[31:38]
for 37 years, educating and enriching
[31:41]
residents and visitors from across the
[31:43]
country and around the world. And
[31:46]
whereas Charlie Christian grew up in
[31:48]
Oklahoma City, attended Douglas High
[31:51]
School, and learned his craft in the
[31:53]
music scene of Deep Deuce. And whereas
[31:56]
Charlie Christian, Oklahoma City's own
[31:59]
guitar legend, has been postumously
[32:02]
honored with induction into the Nessie
[32:05]
Nasuhi Ertagon Jazz Hall of Fame, the
[32:09]
Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, the Downbeat
[32:11]
Hall of Fame, and the Oklahoma Hall of
[32:14]
Fame among others. And whereas in 2006,
[32:18]
the city of Oklahoma City named Charlie
[32:20]
Christian Avenue in Bricktown. And
[32:23]
whereas in partnership with the Leenda
[32:26]
Foundation and Oklahoma City University,
[32:29]
the Black Liberated Arts Center has
[32:31]
established the Charlie Christian Guitar
[32:33]
Institute,
[32:35]
Oklahoma's only institute of higher
[32:37]
learning devoted to his music. And
[32:40]
whereas the 2026 Charlie Christian
[32:42]
International Music Festival will be
[32:45]
held July 3rd through July 5th at Booker
[32:48]
T. Washington Park featuring local,
[32:50]
regional, and national performers
[32:53]
celebrating his enduring legacy. Now,
[32:56]
therefore, I, David Holt, mayor of the
[32:58]
city of Oklahoma City, do hereby
[33:00]
proclaim July 3rd through July 5th, 2026
[33:03]
to be Charlie Christian International
[33:06]
Music Festival Week in Oklahoma City.
[33:09]
» Well, thank you. Well, this has been, as
[33:11]
the proclamation stated, a tradition of
[33:13]
four decades. And uh I was just thinking
[33:16]
also how amazing it is. It's been 20
[33:18]
years since we renamed uh the Avenue in
[33:21]
Bricktown after Charlie Christian. That
[33:23]
I guess that means that's how long I've
[33:24]
known you, Anita. So, [laughter] uh so
[33:28]
welcome back to City Hall. Uh and we
[33:31]
would love to hear a few words from you
[33:33]
to uh tell us even more about the
[33:35]
Charlie Christian International uh music
[33:38]
festival.
[33:39]
» Uh this this year's festival is going to
[33:42]
be a celebration of celebrations with
[33:45]
Charlie Christian. This year marks uh
[33:49]
such
[33:50]
uh milestones of a rich his history and
[33:55]
heritage that most people don't know
[33:57]
about. And this year's festival is
[34:00]
divided into two parts. We have so many
[34:04]
celebrations. I've passed everyone up
[34:06]
here um a copy of the celebrations this
[34:11]
year and it'll be spread out over the
[34:14]
year,
[34:15]
» But we have milestones like Douglas High
[34:20]
School where Charlie Christian went to
[34:22]
school
[34:23]
135 years old this year.
[34:26]
Avery Chapel AM Church,
[34:30]
137 years old, which is a church that
[34:34]
Ralph Ellison and his family attended.
[34:39]
I didn't know that until I started
[34:41]
speaking in some of the uh churches
[34:43]
around the community, but that's it
[34:47]
needs to be noted and people need to
[34:49]
know that we've got that kind of a
[34:51]
history. Uh Dr. Finley. Gravy Finley was
[34:55]
the family physician during those times
[34:58]
and if he were alive he'd be 120 years
[35:01]
old. Charlie Christian is celebrating
[35:05]
110th birthday as a matter of fact in
[35:08]
July.
[35:09]
Uh Route 66 is being celebrated for 100
[35:14]
years. It was the musical trail and
[35:17]
Charlie Christian knew that trail well
[35:21]
and it ran from Oklahoma City to Chicago
[35:24]
on to California, New York. Everybody
[35:27]
was on Route 66, the musical trail. Uh
[35:32]
OIC, which was right here, which is
[35:35]
right here in Oklahoma City, uh Reverend
[35:38]
Dr. H. Leon Sullivan
[35:40]
uh who was a great person passed not too
[35:44]
long ago. uh he was named by uh the
[35:49]
president of the United States to be the
[35:52]
creator of business principles that
[35:57]
businesses all over the world could do
[36:00]
business with South Africa after
[36:02]
apartheid and his operations right here
[36:06]
is still in operation and now they're
[36:09]
doing literacy workshops for our uh
[36:12]
public who
[36:14]
need to learn.
[36:17]
Uh and then finally, we're presenting uh
[36:21]
America's
[36:22]
250th anniversary. That's another
[36:25]
celebration. So, we'll have these part
[36:28]
ones and parts two. We'll have visual
[36:31]
arts. We'll have music, and you heard
[36:34]
some of that fine music. Uh and, uh and
[36:40]
other things like books that are rare.
[36:43]
We have two museums, an art museum and a
[36:46]
history museum to this day. And so we're
[36:49]
in for a good ride and you are all
[36:53]
invited to come and just go to our
[36:56]
website and you'll get the information
[36:58]
that you need on the things that we'll
[37:00]
be putting forth. Part one begins now.
[37:04]
» Very good. Let's hear it for Anita and
[37:06]
her team. [applause]
[37:09]
» Oh. Oh yes.
[37:13]
Oh, I need it. That's yours. [laughter]
[37:15]
» Thank you.
[37:16]
» Thank you.
[37:23]
» All right, Jarus. Jarus, come on down.
[37:27]
» We'll meet here.
[37:29]
[applause]
[37:33]
» All right, Jarus, we'd love to learn a
[37:35]
little bit more about your service to
[37:37]
the people of Oklahoma City. And so, I'd
[37:38]
ask the clerk to read this resolution.
[37:41]
Whereas Jarus Jeff has been a city
[37:43]
employee for two years and serves as
[37:46]
digital graphic technician for the
[37:48]
public information and marketing
[37:50]
department's print shop. And whereas
[37:53]
Jerus exemplifies the city's core value
[37:55]
of service first, responding to each
[37:58]
request with exceptional
[38:00]
professionalism, accuracy, and a clear
[38:02]
commitment to helping projects succeed.
[38:05]
And whereas Jerus provides expert
[38:07]
guidance on specialty printing needs
[38:09]
with patients thoughtfulness and a
[38:11]
collaborative approach. And whereas
[38:14]
Jerus reliably accommodates urgent or
[38:17]
late notice requests without sacrificing
[38:20]
quality, making him an invaluable
[38:22]
partner to city staff. And whereas on
[38:25]
February 11, 2026, Jerus produced a 50
[38:29]
square foot banner in under two hours to
[38:31]
notify residents of a prescribed burn at
[38:34]
Martin Nature Park, enabling clear
[38:37]
public communication
[38:39]
and allowing staff to be reassigned to
[38:42]
critical fire support roles. And whereas
[38:45]
his swift action that day along with his
[38:48]
consistent excellence enhances public
[38:50]
safety, staff efficiency, and city
[38:53]
service to the community. And whereas
[38:55]
this council desires to recognize Jarus
[38:58]
Jeff for his commitment to public
[39:00]
service and the residents of Oklahoma
[39:02]
City. Now therefore, be it resolved by
[39:05]
the mayor and council of the city of
[39:07]
Oklahoma City hereby thank and commend
[39:10]
Jarus Jeff June 2026 South Oklahoma City
[39:14]
Kowanas Club employee of the month.
[39:16]
» All right. Thank you. Well, this is a
[39:18]
resolution, Jarus. So, we're going to
[39:20]
see if we can get you the votes.
[39:25]
Got a motion and a second. Please cast
[39:28]
your votes. I wish to vote I
[39:39]
passes unanimously.
[39:41]
Uh yes, [applause]
[39:43]
you are the employee of the month.
[39:48]
Well, Jarus, we'd love to hear a few
[39:50]
words from you and uh but I'll just
[39:52]
preface it by saying how grateful we are
[39:54]
for your service and that uh you lend
[39:56]
your talents to the city of OKC and
[39:58]
obviously you are wellliked. This is a
[40:01]
this is a rambunctious crowd for Tuesday
[40:03]
morning at 8:30. So, um the floor is
[40:06]
yours.
[40:07]
» Okay.
[40:08]
» Uh first I want to thank you for this
[40:10]
opportunity. Um, I'm really thankful for
[40:13]
the award and for the recognition. Um,
[40:16]
since coming to the city, I've been
[40:18]
welcomed with open arms from the staff
[40:20]
here in the city manager's office. Um,
[40:22]
been welcomed with nothing but smiles
[40:24]
and support everywhere I turn. Uh, from
[40:27]
my supervisors all the way to the staff
[40:29]
around me. It's been a really thankful
[40:31]
community that I've had up to this
[40:33]
point. And so, I'm happy to continue to
[40:35]
work and do what I can for the city and
[40:37]
thankful for everybody that shows the
[40:39]
support towards me. So, all right, let's
[40:41]
hear it for Jarus. [applause]
[40:44]
Congratulations.
[41:22]
All right. Still remaining is an
[41:24]
appointment to the Oklahoma City
[41:25]
Planning Commission. Item B.
[41:29]
Take a motion on that.
[41:36]
Got a motion in a second. Cast your
[41:37]
votes.
[41:44]
Passes unanimously. And then item C is a
[41:47]
resolution approving travel expenses for
[41:49]
me to attend the US Conference of
[41:50]
Mayor's Celebrate America meeting in
[41:53]
Philadelphia next month. Could take a
[41:55]
motion on that.
[42:00]
A motion and a second. Cast your votes.
[42:29]
Wait, wait, wait, wait.
[42:33]
» Okay.
[42:38]
All right.
[42:40]
Passes unanimously and with the
[42:41]
necessary six affirmative votes. That
[42:44]
concludes Office of the Mayor. Now we're
[42:45]
at number four. Item four, items from
[42:48]
council and we have uh five items today
[42:51]
from the judiciary committee. So I'll
[42:53]
turn it over to the chair of the
[42:54]
judiciary committee, Councilman Stone
[42:56]
Cipher, to present these items. Uh thank
[42:59]
you, your honor. On um June 2nd, the
[43:02]
judiciary committee met and it is our
[43:04]
obligation under title 11 to uh pick
[43:08]
judges on staggered terms, two-year
[43:10]
appointments, and to decide their
[43:12]
compensation. And uh we have five
[43:15]
appointments and designations that we
[43:17]
recommend today to the city council. I
[43:20]
would say the judiciary committee was
[43:22]
unanimous. Um the one thing that I'm
[43:24]
really proud of the committee, we work
[43:26]
hard to make sure that we we find judges
[43:29]
that know the law, but also that have
[43:32]
great temperament and a great degree of
[43:34]
civility because many times our citizens
[43:36]
their first experience will be with
[43:38]
those judges. And we have a great group
[43:41]
of judges. We had a judicial survey that
[43:43]
was taken in March. I encourage you to
[43:45]
take a look at it, how well our judges
[43:47]
are doing and what the public thinks of
[43:49]
our judges. And so with that, I am told
[43:52]
by Deon Martin I have to make these um
[43:55]
one at a time. So I'll start with 4A,
[43:57]
which which is a resolution appointing
[44:00]
Gunnar Brisco as municipal judge July 1,
[44:02]
2026 through June 30th, 2028. So moved.
[44:17]
Got a motion and a second. Cast your
[44:19]
votes.
[44:22]
» Passes unanimously.
[44:24]
» The next matter is item 4B, which is a
[44:27]
resolution appointing Donald Kein as
[44:30]
municipal judge July 1, 2026 through
[44:33]
June 30, 2028. So moved.
[44:38]
» [clears throat]
[44:42]
» Got a motion and a second. Cast your
[44:44]
votes.
[44:48]
» Passes unanimously.
[44:50]
» Item 4 C is a resolution designating
[44:53]
Donald Kein as presiding judge July 1,
[44:57]
2026 through June 30th, 2027.
[45:01]
So moved.
[45:06]
» A motion and a second. cast your votes.
[45:11]
» Passes unanimously.
[45:13]
» Item 4 D is a resolution designating
[45:15]
Edward Hasbrook as vice presiding judge
[45:18]
July 1, 2026 through June 30, 2027. So
[45:23]
moved.
[45:30]
Got a motion and a second. Cast your
[45:31]
votes.
[45:35]
» Passes unanimously. Item 4E is a
[45:37]
resolution appointing Christopher Kelly,
[45:40]
Lauren Mayo, and David McKenzie as
[45:43]
special judges July 1, 2026 through June
[45:47]
30, 2028. So moved.
[45:56]
A motion and a second. Cast your votes.
[45:59]
Passes unanimously.
[46:01]
Thank you and the judiciary committee
[46:03]
for all your work.
[46:04]
» Thank you.
[46:06]
[clears throat]
[46:06]
All right, item five, city manager
[46:08]
reports. Mr. City Manager.
[46:10]
» Thank you, mayor. We have several
[46:11]
reports on today. Two of the reports are
[46:14]
budget transfer reports. Um, one of them
[46:16]
you'll see is for last fiscal year.
[46:18]
Typically, we produce this at the time
[46:20]
that we're producing our financial
[46:22]
reports for the previous fiscal year.
[46:24]
Those were delayed due to the
[46:26]
implementation of the financial system,
[46:28]
which is now in place. still working
[46:29]
through some issues with that, but we do
[46:32]
have the final report which is typic
[46:34]
typically runs with that uh the final
[46:36]
transfers report that runs with that
[46:38]
financial report. So that is on for
[46:40]
today. And these transfer reports,
[46:42]
there's certain budget transfers that
[46:43]
are the the council through um policy
[46:47]
authorizes me to approve and the staff
[46:49]
to approve. This just gives you an
[46:50]
update on those. There's also a link on
[46:52]
there where you can go see all the
[46:54]
details of every report that's on there.
[46:55]
So the first report is for last fiscal
[46:58]
year. The second report is the budget
[46:59]
transfers for this fiscal year through
[47:01]
March 31st. And then we have the interim
[47:04]
financial report through April 30th. Um
[47:07]
just give a little bit of update on
[47:08]
that. We've done a couple of budget
[47:10]
amendments
[47:11]
um through this year that have allowed
[47:14]
us to increase our budget for a couple
[47:16]
of different things that we've approved.
[47:18]
Um if you look at our our revenues,
[47:21]
generally the revenues are on target.
[47:24]
with the budget amendments that we've
[47:26]
made, we've approved using some fund
[47:28]
balance to cover some of these costs,
[47:30]
some of our reserves. And if if you look
[47:33]
at this and take out the fund balance
[47:34]
that's budgeted, um on the second page
[47:37]
of that report, the um it would leave us
[47:40]
at about a $4.3 million deficit in our
[47:44]
revenues to this point in the year. Um I
[47:47]
think in total if you look at it
[47:49]
personnel expenses I mean uh our
[47:51]
expenses compared to our revenues we
[47:53]
would be about 6.2 million if you take
[47:55]
out that fund balance about $6.2 million
[47:59]
um that we have used in fun would have
[48:01]
used in fund balance for this year.
[48:03]
Coming into the end of the year with
[48:04]
some of our revenues coming in at the
[48:06]
end we believe that we're going to be
[48:08]
closer to the budget. We'll still use a
[48:10]
little bit of fund balance but we don't
[48:11]
you think we'll use that full 10.9
[48:13]
million that we budgeted so far. Uh but
[48:16]
we'll still keep monitoring that and
[48:17]
report that back to you. I do want to
[48:19]
acknowledge that one of the biggest
[48:21]
overages that we have on our expenses
[48:23]
where we're over budget is personal
[48:24]
services. If you recall when we approved
[48:27]
our contracts, we approved a stipen for
[48:29]
employees that was above what we had in
[48:30]
our reserve for that purpose. So we knew
[48:33]
we were going to use some fund balance
[48:34]
on that. That drives a portion of it.
[48:36]
Another portion of it is we're way over
[48:38]
budget on police and fire overtime.
[48:40]
We've been over a budget in that in
[48:42]
those categories for a while trying to
[48:44]
work that get that right size to get
[48:46]
those costs down, but also to get our
[48:47]
budget back up to about an equilibrium.
[48:50]
We've had a significant number of
[48:51]
vacancies in the past in police and
[48:54]
that's covered some of that and really
[48:55]
required some of that overtime. As we're
[48:57]
getting more of those positions filled,
[48:58]
we should be reducing that overtime and
[49:00]
getting that back in line. So, still
[49:02]
working on that. All in all, at the end
[49:04]
of the year, um our expectation is we'll
[49:06]
use a little bit of fund balance, but
[49:08]
it'll be a fairly small amount of fund
[49:09]
balance. I think even less than the $6
[49:11]
million that we show on this report to
[49:13]
this point. So, just wanted to give you
[49:15]
an update on that. Additionally, we do
[49:17]
have the um quarterly riverport
[49:21]
foundation report and we can get any
[49:23]
answers for you if you have questions on
[49:24]
that. We'll get answers for that. And
[49:26]
then claims and payroll is on and that
[49:28]
can be found on okc.gov. And that's all
[49:29]
the items that I have.
[49:31]
» All right. Thank you, Mr. City Manager.
[49:38]
Next up, item four, Journal of Council
[49:40]
Proceedings. We have items A and B we
[49:42]
could take with one motion.
[49:51]
» Item six. Yeah, thank you. Good catch.
[49:53]
Don't know why I said item four. All
[49:55]
right, we got a motion to second. Cast
[49:56]
your votes.
[50:00]
Passes unanimously. Uh, next up, item
[50:03]
seven, request for uncontested
[50:05]
continuences. Item 11 A and 11B, items
[50:08]
11 A and 11B are already going to be uh
[50:12]
deferred until July 7th. Mr. City
[50:15]
Manager, is there anything else?
[50:17]
» We just have three additional items on
[50:18]
today. Uh, beginning on page 23, we'll
[50:22]
strike all these items from the agenda.
[50:24]
Um, this is 11 M1. Item A, 1623 West
[50:29]
Bird Street. The owner is secured. Item
[50:31]
G, 11:35 West Wilshire Boulevard, the
[50:33]
owner has secured. And item J, 3503
[50:36]
Southwest 42nd Street, the owner has
[50:38]
secured. And that is all the items we
[50:40]
have.
[50:41]
» Okay,
[50:48]
now we're at item eight, revocable
[50:50]
permits and events. Item 8A is a
[50:53]
revocable permit with the Black
[50:54]
Liberated Arts Center for the Charlie
[50:56]
Christian Festival, previously
[50:58]
discussed, July 3rd through the 5th. in
[51:01]
Booker T. Washington Park and
[51:05]
» I believe they left before they were
[51:07]
able to come and talk about this.
[51:09]
» She said everything she would uh just so
[51:12]
you guys know because this is the first
[51:13]
time being back at the park. They were
[51:15]
at a park years ago, but they've come
[51:17]
back. They'll be playing music on
[51:18]
Friday, Saturday, and Sunday at
[51:20]
Washington Park. They'll also have the
[51:23]
same street closures that Junth does,
[51:25]
that single lane on Fourth Street,
[51:28]
Northeast 4th, and then High as well.
[51:31]
So, if you have any questions, let us
[51:33]
know.
[51:35]
» All right, Councilman Pennington.
[51:37]
» Thank you, Mayor. Just want to say um a
[51:39]
big thank you to Anita Arnold and to
[51:41]
Garland Puit for their leadership. It's
[51:43]
a really fantastic event. I'd invite all
[51:45]
of of my fellow council members to join
[51:47]
me um at the event that on on the
[51:50]
weekend of July 3rd. Um, it's going to
[51:52]
be really great. So, thank you so much
[51:54]
and I move approval.
[52:01]
We have a motion and a second. Cast your
[52:03]
votes.
[52:09]
Passes unanimously.
[52:12]
Next up is item B. That's a revocable
[52:15]
permit with the with love project
[52:17]
foundation for Junth on the east on June
[52:20]
20th at Lincoln Park. And we have Jaden
[52:23]
Oliver and Christa Rice here.
[52:26]
» Yes. Good morning. Thank you guys for
[52:29]
allowing us to be here once again for
[52:30]
our sixth year. So on behalf of our
[52:32]
committee, thank you guys. Uh we've been
[52:35]
able to stand here many years uh before
[52:37]
and go over the history. One thing our
[52:40]
team was able to do this year is spend
[52:42]
some time diving in further into the
[52:44]
history of Junth and what happened after
[52:47]
Union General Granger uh went into
[52:50]
Texas. And we know the history doesn't
[52:52]
stop there. We got to talking about uh
[52:54]
the the uh the doctors and the black
[52:58]
entrepreneurs that settled here and
[53:00]
created our black Oklahoma towns here
[53:02]
and what that looked like for historic
[53:04]
Deep Deuce and for any OKC. Um, and what
[53:08]
we're here to share today is how that is
[53:10]
why a proven community matters. And so I
[53:13]
just want to share a few stats about
[53:14]
what we've been able to do over the last
[53:16]
5 years with Junth on the East.
[53:19]
Estimated attendance uh over the years
[53:22]
annually 15,000 attendees. Local
[53:25]
performers featured 20 plus community
[53:28]
vendors per year, 80 plus uh 15 plus
[53:32]
food trucks. Um and then uh 60 plus band
[53:35]
members. A lot of that matters
[53:37]
especially for our local artists and our
[53:39]
local performers because a lot of them
[53:41]
get to say that they shared a stage uh
[53:43]
with a Grammy nominated artist or an
[53:46]
Emmy award-winning artist. And so that
[53:48]
matters because that allows them to add
[53:49]
that to their resume which then takes
[53:51]
their career even further. Again, a
[53:53]
proven community. So this year's event
[53:56]
provides the east side uh opportunity
[53:59]
the community an opportunity to work
[54:01]
with over a 100 merchant vendors and
[54:03]
food truck vendors, local artists and
[54:05]
performers. Looking at total probably
[54:07]
over 150 people uh influence and that's
[54:10]
not just the people, it's their families
[54:12]
and their children um and so forth and
[54:14]
so on. Uh we we love that it gets to get
[54:17]
to that point. So, as we allow room for
[54:19]
growth, our kids zone will be increased
[54:21]
by 2.5%. Um, and we be we're able to
[54:24]
honor our families by providing an area
[54:26]
where education, creation, and
[54:28]
imagination can happen for our children.
[54:31]
And as we continue to build our
[54:32]
relationships in our sixth year, we are
[54:34]
partnering with the Jo Foundation to add
[54:37]
a threeon-ree basketball tournament. So,
[54:39]
I'll go ahead and let Jaden talk about
[54:41]
that.
[54:44]
» Good morning. My name is Jaden Oliver.
[54:46]
I'm the founder of the Jawler Foundation
[54:48]
and I'm honored to be here today
[54:50]
representing my family, my ancestors,
[54:52]
and my community. I'm excited to share
[54:55]
that the Jawer Foundation is partnering
[54:56]
with Junth on the East this year to host
[54:59]
the inaugural 3v3 basketball tournament.
[55:02]
In addition to the festival, we will be
[55:04]
bringing 72 kids from all over to
[55:07]
celebrate Junth. Not only will they have
[55:09]
an exceptional basketball experience
[55:11]
with competitive play, open three-point
[55:13]
contests, trophies, and giveaways, but
[55:16]
my favorite piece is that the teams will
[55:17]
be named after local black leaders who
[55:19]
have helped pave the way, impact
[55:21]
Oklahoma City, and all over the world.
[55:23]
Also, in their honor, we will be gifting
[55:26]
players all-star trading cards that will
[55:28]
tell these leaders stories, and share
[55:29]
more about their legacy. I just want to
[55:32]
thank and give love to my team, the best
[55:35]
committee in the city and um you know my
[55:38]
community for helping bring this new
[55:40]
experience to life for our kids. We also
[55:43]
want to thank the city for helping us
[55:44]
get the court in proper conditions for
[55:46]
our kids um to be able to compete to
[55:49]
enjoy be a part of their community and
[55:51]
to be supported by love. My dad always
[55:53]
says when the community works together
[55:55]
the community works and this festival
[55:56]
and this basketball tournament is truly
[55:58]
a testament to that. At the Jer
[56:00]
Foundation, we always like to share that
[56:02]
it's bigger than basketball and we want
[56:04]
to invite you all to come and witness
[56:05]
that. [clears throat] Thank you.
[56:09]
» Thank you, uh, Councilman Pennington.
[56:11]
» Thank you, Mayor. Um, and so we have
[56:13]
Friday along with threeon-ree, um,
[56:16]
tournament, which is awesome. This is
[56:17]
the first I heard of it. And the trading
[56:18]
cards sound really cool. So, can I have
[56:20]
one? Um,
[56:21]
» Yes, [laughter]
[56:22]
give that to you. Yeah, we'll have Ka
[56:24]
give it to you.
[56:25]
» There you go. Um, so, okay. So, Friday
[56:27]
we've got the 5K.
[56:28]
» Thursday. Thursday we have our panel
[56:30]
discussion at Innovation Hall.
[56:32]
» Okay. Panel discussion on Thursday.
[56:34]
Friday 5K. Saturday concert what time?
[56:37]
» Festival 11 to 4 concert doors open at
[56:40]
56 to around 10.
[56:42]
» Excellent. Well, thank you all for your
[56:44]
work. It's an amazing event and um it's
[56:47]
always so exciting to bring people to
[56:48]
the east side and and to let us see the
[56:50]
the unity and the progress that we're
[56:52]
making in our community and it's because
[56:53]
of your efforts. So, thank you so much
[56:55]
and I'm looking forward to participating
[56:57]
too. So with that, mayor, I move
[56:59]
approval.
[57:06]
» Right. We have a motion and a second.
[57:09]
Cast your votes.
[57:11]
[clears throat]
[57:14]
Passes unanimously.
[57:16]
» Awesome. Thank you guys so much.
[57:18]
Appreciate it. We invite you all to
[57:23]
» All right. Next up is item C. revocable
[57:25]
rightway use permit with Oklahoma Pride
[57:27]
Alliance to hold the Oklahoma Pride
[57:28]
Alliance downtown Pride parade on June
[57:30]
28th. And we have John Milner here.
[57:34]
Good morning. Um yeah, we're coming back
[57:36]
downtown at Scissor Park for the sixth
[57:38]
year. Um looking forward to welcoming
[57:41]
the community June 26th, 27th, 28th.
[57:43]
Festival starts 400 pm on Friday. We'll
[57:46]
have entertainment, food, vendors. Uh,
[57:49]
we've got a community resource zone on
[57:51]
Saturday, artist market Friday night,
[57:53]
and then it culminates with the downtown
[57:55]
parade on Sunday starting at 11:00 a.m.
[57:57]
Happy to answer any questions.
[58:01]
» Can you share who some of your
[58:03]
headliners are?
[58:05]
» I knew you were going to ask that. And
[58:07]
I'm the logistics guy. I know they just
[58:10]
posted.
[58:11]
» I just wanted to shout out the Drag
[58:12]
Queen because I'm such a fan and I'm so
[58:15]
amazed that y'all got them. It's so
[58:17]
exciting. And I will also add we've got
[58:18]
Oklahoma native Samantha Crane playing.
[58:21]
So that's going to be fantastic. And I
[58:22]
believe she plays Saturday night. So
[58:24]
it's going to be a good festival. Let's
[58:26]
just hope for uh cooler weather this.
[58:29]
» We will we will cross our fingers for
[58:31]
for that. [laughter] But you all are
[58:33]
always so well um organized and just
[58:36]
really appreciate um you bringing this
[58:37]
this celebration to downtown. So happy
[58:39]
to move for approval.
[58:40]
» Thank you.
[58:41]
» Councilwoman, I just want to clarify. Do
[58:43]
you mean Bob the Drag Queen RuPaul's
[58:45]
Drag Race winner is coming to Oklahoma's
[58:49]
capital? Yes,
[58:51]
» Be correct.
[58:51]
» It's huge.
[58:54]
» And I also just want to add I want to
[58:56]
thank Drew Watson in the special events
[58:57]
office. I've worked with Drew for the
[58:59]
past six years and the special events
[59:01]
office and Drew is fantastic. So, shout
[59:03]
out to Drew. Thank you.
[59:07]
» Any questions? Okay.
[59:09]
» No, we got a motion in a second.
[59:12]
cast your votes.
[59:16]
» Pass.
[59:17]
» Thank you very much.
[59:18]
» Thanks.
[59:19]
» All right. Now, we're going to recess
[59:20]
the council meeting and convene as the
[59:22]
Oklahoma City Municipal Facilities
[59:24]
Authority. Uh we have a presentation for
[59:26]
item B. Mr. City Manager.
[59:28]
» Yes. Nicole Tower is uh here with the
[59:31]
budget office to present this budget. uh
[59:33]
this the m municipal facilities budget
[59:35]
and she'll talk about this as she goes
[59:36]
through but it represents a lot of the
[59:38]
transfers a lot of the functions that we
[59:40]
have that come through the operating
[59:42]
budget so just want to acknowledge that
[59:44]
and I'll let Nicole take us through the
[59:46]
quick presentation
[59:47]
» Yeah good morning Nicole Tower office of
[59:49]
management and budget happy to be here
[59:51]
again to present the FY27 OC MFA budget
[59:56]
um so today you're going to be presented
[59:58]
with the MFA budget as well as the OCPA
[1:00:00]
budget and while those both pay play
[1:00:03]
vital roles in supporting city
[1:00:05]
operations. I like to think of the OCMFA
[1:00:08]
as an internal facing trust and the OCPA
[1:00:11]
um serves the public more outward facing
[1:00:13]
activities.
[1:00:16]
The OCMFA or Oklahoma City Municipal
[1:00:19]
Facilities Authority is a trust of the
[1:00:21]
city that provides a mechanism that
[1:00:23]
allows for multi-year contracts with
[1:00:25]
vendors such as a health insurance
[1:00:26]
providers and allows for the maintenance
[1:00:29]
of adequate reserves for such things as
[1:00:31]
workers compensation claims. At the last
[1:00:34]
council meeting, the city budget was
[1:00:36]
adopted. The MFA budget that is being
[1:00:38]
presented today, the primary source of
[1:00:40]
revenue is the city funds from that
[1:00:42]
adopted budget. We can now look at the
[1:00:44]
specifics of this budget for fiscal year
[1:00:46]
27.
[1:00:48]
So overall, the trust budget is just
[1:00:50]
over 178 million. Last year's budget was
[1:00:54]
146 million, which is an increase
[1:00:56]
year-over-year of 21%.
[1:00:59]
And you can see the various budget
[1:01:00]
functions on this slide. So this slide
[1:01:03]
groups similar functions together to
[1:01:05]
illustrate and summarize the functions
[1:01:07]
of the trust.
[1:01:09]
The first one, health insurance, is by
[1:01:10]
far the largest portion at 95 million or
[1:01:14]
53%. This comes from both the city and
[1:01:17]
its employees as they contribute to the
[1:01:19]
premiums paid for health insurance.
[1:01:21]
There are also several similar functions
[1:01:23]
to health insurance in this budget. The
[1:01:25]
city's property [clears throat] and
[1:01:27]
liability insurance is about 23 million
[1:01:29]
or 13% and workers compensation is
[1:01:32]
projected to be about 20 million or 11%.
[1:01:35]
We also pay for unemployment claims
[1:01:37]
through the OCMFA, but those are
[1:01:40]
relatively small, about 205,000.
[1:01:42]
The next largest category is information
[1:01:45]
technology. So at 15 million or 8%, this
[1:01:49]
is one of the largest areas that
[1:01:51]
utilizes the abilities for the
[1:01:52]
multi-year contracts. They use it for
[1:01:54]
such things as a city-wide computer
[1:01:56]
systems, the radio systems, E911, and
[1:01:59]
other IT related services.
[1:02:02]
The general purpose and others category
[1:02:05]
includes annual financial audits,
[1:02:07]
professional legal services, and code
[1:02:09]
enforcement related contracts.
[1:02:12]
The city also uses the OCMFA for
[1:02:14]
advanced capital funding. Those are for
[1:02:17]
GEO bonds and it helps them jumpstart
[1:02:19]
certain capital projects. So, we've set
[1:02:21]
up a revolving fund here in the OCMFA
[1:02:24]
and it allows public works to begin
[1:02:26]
design work on bond projects before the
[1:02:28]
bonds are sold. Once the bonds are sold,
[1:02:30]
the bond proceeds reimburse the trust
[1:02:33]
for those early design costs,
[1:02:35]
essentially buying back the plans. This
[1:02:38]
process helps us get projects moving
[1:02:40]
faster.
[1:02:41]
As those funds are replenished, they can
[1:02:44]
be used to kick off the next round of
[1:02:46]
projects, keeping our momentum going.
[1:02:49]
Okay.
[1:02:51]
So when we look here at the revenue,
[1:02:54]
health insurance contributions from the
[1:02:55]
city and its employees is the largest
[1:02:57]
source at 93 million or 52%.
[1:03:01]
Transfers from various funds such as the
[1:03:04]
IT or the risk management internal
[1:03:06]
service funds is the second largest at
[1:03:08]
54 million or 30%.
[1:03:11]
Fund balance is the next largest at 13
[1:03:13]
million or 7%. And finally here, there
[1:03:16]
are several miscellaneous revenue
[1:03:17]
sources that account for just over 10%
[1:03:20]
of the revenue. And this covers things
[1:03:21]
like interest.
[1:03:24]
Okay. On the expense side, payments to
[1:03:27]
other services and charges dominate at
[1:03:30]
172 million or 96%. And this makes sense
[1:03:33]
because these are things such as the
[1:03:35]
health insurance premiums and the IT
[1:03:37]
contracts.
[1:03:39]
Okay.
[1:03:41]
And with that, I'm happy to answer any
[1:03:43]
questions that you might have.
[1:03:46]
» Thanks, Nicole.
[1:03:48]
» Thank you.
[1:03:49]
» Thank you.
[1:03:51]
» Thank you. And we have a resident who
[1:03:52]
signed up on uh OCMFA item E. Uh Steve
[1:03:57]
Hunt.
[1:04:03]
All right. Steve Hunt, 6300 West Drive.
[1:04:05]
I want to give a little background on
[1:04:06]
why I'm speaking on something so
[1:04:08]
seemingly benal as a pension software
[1:04:11]
contract. Um, late last year I appeared
[1:04:13]
on the organized money uh podcast with
[1:04:15]
Dave Diane of American Prospect and Matt
[1:04:17]
Stellar talking about my time at Costco
[1:04:20]
where I saw that Costco was too large of
[1:04:23]
an entity for private equity firms to
[1:04:24]
take over. So, they were targeting their
[1:04:26]
trusted vendors one by one. And over the
[1:04:29]
year and a half that I was there, I
[1:04:30]
watched uh not just the members have a
[1:04:34]
hard time with degradation of product,
[1:04:36]
but the people that work in Oklahoma
[1:04:37]
City call center unable to get any help
[1:04:39]
because these equity firms had taken
[1:04:40]
over these vendors. Well, I'm starting
[1:04:42]
to notice the same phenomenon happening
[1:04:44]
here in the city. Um Oklahoma City can't
[1:04:47]
be targeted for leveraged buyout by KKR
[1:04:49]
or Blackstone. So, what they're doing is
[1:04:51]
they're taking over the vendors one by
[1:04:53]
one. And the one that I see today is
[1:04:55]
item E. A contract was fully executed by
[1:04:58]
the vendor on May 28th, weeks before
[1:05:01]
this body was given the opportunity to
[1:05:02]
vote on it today. The vendor is Pension
[1:05:05]
Technology Group LLC. They are owned by
[1:05:07]
Case 5 Capital Private Equity Family
[1:05:10]
Office out of Dallas Metroplex that
[1:05:12]
manages capital for anonymous high- netw
[1:05:14]
worth Dallas investors. That's Case 5
[1:05:17]
Capital. You can look them up. The
[1:05:19]
agreement hands over access to the
[1:05:21]
retirement data of 6,500 Oklahoma City
[1:05:23]
municipal employees, active members,
[1:05:25]
retirees, and beneficiaries. Buried in
[1:05:27]
the fine print is a specific clause
[1:05:30]
regarding resilient data. The provision
[1:05:33]
grants a private equitybacked firm the
[1:05:36]
right to take anonymized derivative data
[1:05:38]
from Oklahoma City employees retirement
[1:05:41]
records and exploit it commercially for
[1:05:43]
benchmarking product development and
[1:05:46]
proprietary analytics in perpetuity
[1:05:49]
completely surviving the life of this
[1:05:51]
contract. The civic architecture here is
[1:05:54]
entirely asymmetric. The city employees
[1:05:57]
whose labor built this capital have zero
[1:06:00]
rights under this contract. The OKC
[1:06:02]
employee retirement system has no
[1:06:03]
independent right to sue per the
[1:06:05]
contract. If the firm suffers a
[1:06:07]
catastrophic breach exposing the data,
[1:06:10]
which will happen, this is a 5-year
[1:06:12]
contract, and this will happen. 6,500
[1:06:14]
civil servants, their liability is
[1:06:16]
capped at 1.5 time one year's fee, a
[1:06:19]
mere $195,000. So each employee will get
[1:06:23]
30 bucks. They can go to Jimmy's Egg and
[1:06:25]
have a breakfast if their data is
[1:06:27]
stolen.
[1:06:29]
This isn't an administrative upgrade. It
[1:06:31]
is a long-term extraction mechanism. I
[1:06:33]
ask the council to table this item today
[1:06:35]
and answer one fundamental question.
[1:06:37]
» 30 seconds remain.
[1:06:38]
» Who inside the city government decided
[1:06:40]
that a Dallas private equity firm should
[1:06:42]
own the commercial rights to Oklahoma
[1:06:43]
City employee data in perpetuity? Was it
[1:06:46]
the mayor who spent nine years
[1:06:48]
compensated by a private equity interest
[1:06:50]
in a synicure at Hall Capital?
[1:06:53]
Thank you.
[1:06:56]
That concludes the residents who signed
[1:06:57]
up to speak. We can now take OS OC MFA
[1:07:00]
agenda with one motion.
[1:07:07]
Got a motion and a second. Cast your
[1:07:09]
votes.
[1:07:19]
[clears throat]
[1:07:28]
passes unanimously. Now we'll adjourn
[1:07:30]
OCMFA and convene as the Oklahoma City
[1:07:32]
Public property authority. We do have a
[1:07:34]
presentation on item F.
[1:07:35]
» Yes. Uh this is the public property
[1:07:37]
authority budget. Steve Akens is here
[1:07:40]
with the budget office and Steve will
[1:07:42]
give us an overview on the public
[1:07:44]
property budget.
[1:07:46]
» Good morning, Mayor, Council, City
[1:07:48]
Manager. Um, like the OCMFA, the the
[1:07:52]
Oklahoma City Public Pro Property
[1:07:54]
Authority is a trust where we can enter
[1:07:57]
into long-term projects and it's a
[1:08:00]
mechanism to allow for the multi-year
[1:08:02]
contracts funding to things like
[1:08:04]
fairgrounds improvements, golf courses,
[1:08:07]
maps facility, sports facilities, and
[1:08:10]
something you may have heard about
[1:08:11]
called the Continental
[1:08:14]
Coliseum, the new NBA Arena.
[1:08:17]
Uh, next slide. The revenues by source
[1:08:21]
are primarily
[1:08:23]
um
[1:08:25]
from transfers from various funds that
[1:08:28]
come into the the PPA. Golf course has
[1:08:30]
revenues. There's a little bit of fund
[1:08:33]
balance. There's transfers from hotel
[1:08:35]
motel tax and transfers from the general
[1:08:38]
fund are the sources.
[1:08:41]
expenditures by category. Capital outlay
[1:08:44]
is by far the largest piece of the PPA
[1:08:48]
and $250 million in fund balance
[1:08:52]
was transferred from MAPS to the PPA for
[1:08:57]
preliminary work on the new MBA arena.
[1:09:01]
Uh that was done back in 2025. It
[1:09:03]
carried over to the the new year. $1.8 8
[1:09:06]
million of capital construction for the
[1:09:08]
new at the turn grill and $850,000 for
[1:09:11]
the softball and bricktown improvements.
[1:09:15]
other services and charges of 31.7
[1:09:17]
millions. are things like the management
[1:09:19]
contract for ACM for the Paycom center
[1:09:23]
and the Oklahoma City Convention Center
[1:09:26]
as well as the other various activities
[1:09:28]
for the fairgrounds, golf courses, North
[1:09:30]
Canadian River maintenance and sports
[1:09:33]
facilities transfers at 17.9 million or
[1:09:37]
5% primarily golf course transfers and
[1:09:40]
transfers the excess back of the hotel
[1:09:44]
motel tax to from the PPA. It goes into
[1:09:48]
the PPA. Then we transfer the excess
[1:09:50]
back that's not needed back to the hotel
[1:09:53]
motel tax. And the other items are
[1:09:56]
personnel services, supplies, debt
[1:09:58]
services,
[1:10:00]
expenditures by function.
[1:10:03]
Um
[1:10:05]
we we did have an increase this year of
[1:10:07]
expenditures and and and it's about $181
[1:10:10]
million and that that is all primarily
[1:10:13]
due to that influx of revenue that we're
[1:10:16]
using for the preliminary work of the
[1:10:18]
new MBA arena. Um
[1:10:22]
the golf course expenditures at 27.8
[1:10:24]
million. They're primarily salaries and
[1:10:26]
wages, water, sewer, refu and
[1:10:28]
contingencies. Fairgrounds expenditures
[1:10:31]
at 25.4 million.
[1:10:33]
um debt service cost uh repairs and
[1:10:36]
maintenance and excess funds returned to
[1:10:39]
the hotel motel
[1:10:41]
uh fund. The remaining 1% are various
[1:10:44]
things like sports facilities, natural
[1:10:46]
gas, culture and recreation, business
[1:10:48]
improvement districts and other
[1:10:50]
miscellaneous activities. And that's a
[1:10:52]
recap of what the OCPA consists of. If
[1:10:56]
you have any questions, um
[1:11:00]
thank you. All right.
[1:11:02]
Thank you. Well, that concludes OCPA. We
[1:11:05]
could take uh items A through H with one
[1:11:07]
motion.
[1:11:21]
Got a motion and a second. Cast your
[1:11:22]
votes.
[1:11:26]
Passes unanimously.
[1:11:28]
All right. All right, we'll adjourn OCPA
[1:11:30]
and reconvene as the council. We're on
[1:11:32]
item nine, the consent docket, and there
[1:11:34]
is a presentation for
[1:11:38]
item AZ. Is there any other item that a
[1:11:41]
council member wishes to pull out for
[1:11:46]
separate vote? I think maybe uh
[1:11:48]
Councilman Stone Cipher, you have a
[1:11:50]
couple. What are those items again?
[1:11:51]
» It's uh item
[1:11:54]
9DM at page 18. Mhm.
[1:11:57]
» I'd ask for a separate vote on that,
[1:11:58]
please.
[1:11:59]
» Just that one.
[1:12:00]
» Well, there's one later, but it's uh
[1:12:02]
item
[1:12:05]
uh 11s.
[1:12:06]
» Oh, okay. After. Okay.
[1:12:08]
» Yeah.
[1:12:08]
» Very good. Well, uh is there any other
[1:12:10]
item that someone wishes to pull out for
[1:12:12]
a separate vote, comment, question?
[1:12:13]
» Mayor, did did you say that there's a
[1:12:16]
presentation on a?
[1:12:18]
» Yes.
[1:12:18]
» Perfect. Thank you.
[1:12:22]
» Okay. Well, if there's nothing else,
[1:12:23]
maybe we'll start with that separate
[1:12:24]
vote. Councilman Stone Cipher and you
[1:12:26]
can step out for a moment. So this would
[1:12:28]
be item DM.
[1:12:32]
We could take a motion.
[1:12:41]
Got a motion and a second. Cast your
[1:12:42]
votes.
[1:12:50]
Passes unanimously. All right. And now
[1:12:52]
we'll go back to the presentation at a
[1:12:56]
» Yes. Emma Winsky is here with um the uh
[1:13:00]
human rights commission, city human
[1:13:02]
rights commission to present this item
[1:13:04]
and the actions that we're taking today.
[1:13:07]
» Thank you. Yeah, Emma Winsky, compliance
[1:13:09]
officer for the human rights commission.
[1:13:11]
Um I'm here to talk about the plat
[1:13:13]
amendment project that um we and many
[1:13:15]
other city and external partners have
[1:13:17]
been working on.
[1:13:20]
So, a little bit of background. Um, as
[1:13:22]
many of you probably know, uh, in the
[1:13:24]
mid- 20th century, a lot of plat
[1:13:26]
documents contain racially restrictive
[1:13:28]
language. So, this prevented black,
[1:13:30]
Jewish, Asian, other groups from owning
[1:13:33]
property. Um, of course, these are
[1:13:35]
illegal and have been for many decades,
[1:13:37]
but still in Oklahoma City, many of our
[1:13:40]
plat documents still contain this
[1:13:41]
language. And so, in 2024, Governor Stit
[1:13:44]
signed a bill into law which allowed
[1:13:45]
municipalities to amend plat documents.
[1:13:48]
Um and then last year in April, you all
[1:13:50]
unanimously approved a resolution in
[1:13:52]
support of the city initiating this
[1:13:54]
process. Um starting to sort of
[1:13:56]
understand what it would take for a city
[1:13:58]
to do this instead of an individual
[1:13:59]
property owner. So we have been hard at
[1:14:02]
work in the interim.
[1:14:04]
So here are uh you know kind of some
[1:14:06]
abbreviated steps. So first of course
[1:14:09]
identifying the affected plats and this
[1:14:10]
is done [snorts] through a combination
[1:14:12]
of um like a digital review of the
[1:14:14]
online um sort of archives. We also
[1:14:17]
hosted a volunteer event this past March
[1:14:19]
and 75 people showed up which was really
[1:14:22]
um wonderful. We were thrilled to have
[1:14:24]
that much engagement. Um and it also
[1:14:26]
involved some manual uh review at the
[1:14:28]
county archives for some of those plats
[1:14:30]
where um the covenants were either filed
[1:14:32]
separately or you can't read them
[1:14:34]
because they're so old. Um then we are
[1:14:36]
sending mail notification to all
[1:14:38]
property owners who live in affected
[1:14:39]
plats notifying them of this process and
[1:14:42]
letting them know that they can come
[1:14:43]
speak at commissions and council if they
[1:14:45]
have any um concerns. Then we get
[1:14:48]
approval from the relevant commissions.
[1:14:49]
So historic preservation planning
[1:14:51]
commission. Now here we are. Step four,
[1:14:53]
approval from council hopefully. Um and
[1:14:55]
then pending that we will file the
[1:14:57]
amended plat with the county.
[1:15:01]
And so a little bit of uh a status
[1:15:03]
update. So, we estimate that there are
[1:15:05]
around 6,600 plats across Oklahoma City.
[1:15:08]
Of course, we're like a large, uh, land
[1:15:10]
area. And so, um, around 45% of those
[1:15:13]
have been reviewed to date. And again,
[1:15:15]
that volunteer event, we reviewed, um,
[1:15:18]
around 2,200 plots in two hours. So,
[1:15:20]
again, this is just like a peoplepowered
[1:15:21]
initiative. And so, we were very
[1:15:22]
grateful to the many volunteers who
[1:15:24]
showed up. And of those 3,000, um, 260
[1:15:28]
contain discriminatory language that
[1:15:30]
been confirmed, and then 20% require
[1:15:32]
further review. So again, this is kind
[1:15:34]
of an iterative process where we'll
[1:15:36]
continue to um sort of methodically move
[1:15:39]
through these plat. So overall, we're
[1:15:41]
going to estimate that 9 to 12% of the
[1:15:43]
total platin OKC contain discriminatory
[1:15:46]
language. Again, we're continuing to
[1:15:48]
review, but um that is where we're at to
[1:15:51]
date.
[1:15:53]
And um we're working on this in
[1:15:55]
partnership with um some colleagues at
[1:15:57]
OU and um one of their grad assistants
[1:16:00]
who's been a huge help has been mapping
[1:16:02]
the plat as we go along and this will be
[1:16:05]
made available. But we're just wanting
[1:16:06]
to sort sort of show the um distribution
[1:16:08]
of plats across the city um just to
[1:16:11]
represent that this isn't concentrated
[1:16:12]
in any one particular ward or area. This
[1:16:14]
is something that happened across the
[1:16:16]
city. So uh the green areas are ones
[1:16:18]
where no language was found. red where
[1:16:21]
we find that racially restrictive
[1:16:22]
language and then blue are just those
[1:16:24]
ones that need further review. So, we'll
[1:16:26]
continue to update this and we'll share
[1:16:27]
this publicly as well. We want this to
[1:16:29]
be um an opportunity for the community
[1:16:31]
to learn about this project and this
[1:16:33]
effort.
[1:16:34]
So, with that, I'm happy to answer any
[1:16:36]
questions.
[1:16:39]
» Well, first I'd like to say thank you
[1:16:41]
for the presentation. Um commend you for
[1:16:44]
your work. I also would like to express
[1:16:47]
gratitude to the residents who in pretty
[1:16:51]
significant numbers turned out to do
[1:16:53]
this work. Um, it just pulled up on the
[1:16:57]
internet uh some of that uh language and
[1:17:00]
this was even in our [clears throat]
[1:17:02]
Federal Housing Administration language
[1:17:05]
uh that it was in something called the
[1:17:07]
underwriting manual for them and it said
[1:17:10]
that quote incompatible racial groups
[1:17:12]
should not be permitted to live in the
[1:17:14]
same communities. Right. Um
[1:17:18]
that same manual recommended that
[1:17:21]
highways be a good way to separate
[1:17:23]
African-Americans from white
[1:17:25]
neighborhoods.
[1:17:26]
Right? So this was an actual
[1:17:31]
approach the government took. Right? So
[1:17:33]
it was neighborhoods and governments
[1:17:36]
that did this sort of work. And that's
[1:17:39]
why I am the first biracial black or
[1:17:42]
black person to serve on this body
[1:17:44]
outside of W seven where a majority
[1:17:46]
black population is like a majority
[1:17:49]
white population. W 2 elected me based
[1:17:52]
on the content of my character. But that
[1:17:54]
could not have happened when you had
[1:17:57]
restrictions in neighborhoods saying
[1:18:00]
that a person couldn't even live there,
[1:18:03]
right? No matter if they were a doctor
[1:18:05]
or a barista. So, this is critical work
[1:18:08]
that you all are doing. It's an
[1:18:10]
important reminder because we hear
[1:18:12]
voices today that say, "Well, maybe the
[1:18:13]
races should be separated again." Um,
[1:18:16]
and you should always remember where
[1:18:17]
those voices come from. They come from
[1:18:19]
this history, right? This history. And I
[1:18:22]
just want to thank again you and your
[1:18:24]
and the residents and again, especially
[1:18:26]
W 2 because I think they have shown
[1:18:29]
what's possible um and a different life
[1:18:32]
is possible here. So, thank you.
[1:18:37]
Thanks Emma.
[1:18:38]
» Thanks for all the hard work.
[1:18:41]
» I just want to also say thank you to
[1:18:42]
Emma. Appreciate your work and I live in
[1:18:44]
one of the affected neighborhoods. So,
[1:18:46]
um I got the notice and thought, wait,
[1:18:48]
what what's going on? So, love that this
[1:18:49]
work is happening and appreciate the
[1:18:51]
effort.
[1:18:55]
» All right. Well, that concludes uh
[1:18:57]
consent docket. We can now take the
[1:18:58]
remaining remaining items with one
[1:19:00]
motion. [clears throat]
[1:19:07]
I have a motion and a second.
[1:19:10]
Cast your votes.
[1:19:23]
Passes unanimously. Item 10 is the
[1:19:26]
concurrence docket. We could t take
[1:19:28]
items A through R with one motion.
[1:19:36]
A motion and a second. Cast your votes.
[1:19:44]
Passes unanimously.
[1:19:46]
Item 11 are items for individual
[1:19:48]
consideration. Items A and B were
[1:19:50]
already deferred, which brings us to
[1:19:51]
item C. This is an ordinance on final
[1:19:53]
hearing. is recommended for approval.
[1:19:56]
Reszoning 9525 West Hefner Road from
[1:19:59]
double A to PUD 2130. This was deferred
[1:20:02]
from June 2nd. Councilman Carter, no one
[1:20:05]
has signed up to speak.
[1:20:12]
After speaking with the applicant and
[1:20:13]
the representation, we will move for
[1:20:15]
approval.
[1:20:23]
Got a motion and a second. Cast your
[1:20:24]
votes.
[1:20:29]
Passes unanimously. Item 11D uh has a
[1:20:33]
couple of items here. The uh item two is
[1:20:35]
the ordinance on final hearing that was
[1:20:37]
recommended for approval resoning 4200
[1:20:39]
Southwest 29th from I2 and AE2 to PUD
[1:20:43]
2134 and AE2. Item one is an amendment
[1:20:46]
to the master design statement. This is
[1:20:49]
deferred from June 2nd. Uh, Councilwoman
[1:20:53]
Avers, no one has signed up to speak.
[1:21:02]
» One of these days I'll get faster with
[1:21:03]
the microphone. Um, I have confirmed
[1:21:05]
with the applicant we are going to defer
[1:21:07]
one more session to host our community
[1:21:09]
meeting, but we are moving forward.
[1:21:11]
Thank you.
[1:21:12]
» Okay. So, I'm going to defer item D for
[1:21:16]
two weeks. That would be July 7th.
[1:21:19]
» July 7th.
[1:21:21]
» Yes, sir.
[1:21:21]
» All right. Let's take that up as a
[1:21:23]
motion.
[1:21:33]
We have a motion and a second. Cast your
[1:21:36]
votes.
[1:21:41]
Item is deferred. All right. Item E is
[1:21:44]
an ordinance on final hearing. It was
[1:21:45]
recommended for approval reszoning 9810
[1:21:47]
West Memorial from PUD 986 to PUD 2138.
[1:21:53]
Uh, Councilman Carter, no one has signed
[1:21:55]
to speak.
[1:21:57]
Okay. Subject to the technical
[1:21:59]
evaluations,
[1:22:00]
then I will move for approval.
[1:22:09]
Have a motion and a second. Cast your
[1:22:10]
votes.
[1:22:15]
passes unanimously.
[1:22:18]
Uh 11F is an ordinance on final hearing
[1:22:20]
recommended for approval reszoning 5401
[1:22:23]
South Mustang Road from R1 to SPD 1799.
[1:22:29]
Uh this is deferred from April 21st and
[1:22:32]
May 5th and 19th. It is a 52% protest.
[1:22:36]
And Matt, that triggers the
[1:22:38]
supermajority requirement of seven,
[1:22:40]
correct?
[1:22:41]
» For approval and Councilwoman Avers, we
[1:22:44]
have a few people who have signed up to
[1:22:46]
speak when you are ready for that.
[1:22:48]
» Let's welcome our guests to speak.
[1:22:50]
» Okay. Um
[1:22:55]
I don't know. Do It looks like a few of
[1:22:57]
these are protests. I'm not sure who
[1:22:58]
might be here for the applicant. Usually
[1:23:00]
it's a good place to start perhaps. Uh
[1:23:03]
is that Fox.
[1:23:04]
» Yeah, maybe I might suggest we hear what
[1:23:07]
it is first before we hear the
[1:23:09]
opposition.
[1:23:12]
» Good morning. David Fox, 525 Northwest
[1:23:15]
11th Street. Uh here on behalf of the
[1:23:18]
applicant. Um this is one that we spent
[1:23:22]
a lot of time at the planning commission
[1:23:24]
level. Uh there were community meetings
[1:23:26]
that were held and I I think it's worth
[1:23:29]
pointing out that
[1:23:31]
where we're located is South Mustang
[1:23:34]
Road. Mustang Road is a state highway
[1:23:36]
and could you There we go. I think it's
[1:23:40]
this area has exploded in growth over
[1:23:42]
the last 10 years. What you would expect
[1:23:44]
to see along state highways that are
[1:23:46]
fully developed four-lane is more
[1:23:48]
intense commercial type of use. You have
[1:23:51]
this area along Mustang Road north of
[1:23:54]
59th starting to develop. You've got the
[1:23:56]
PUD 265 which is an older PUB which has
[1:23:59]
elements of commercial. You have the C1
[1:24:02]
immediately east which was a recently
[1:24:04]
approved. You have a 7-Eleven gas
[1:24:06]
station right there at the corner.
[1:24:08]
Significant commercial development is
[1:24:10]
expected to to come. So when we
[1:24:12]
originally filed this SPUD, it had lots
[1:24:14]
of different commercial uses in it. We
[1:24:16]
went and had a community meeting. It
[1:24:18]
became clear that uh there was no
[1:24:20]
element of commercial that would be
[1:24:21]
acceptable. What became clear as we
[1:24:24]
moved on was there was nothing that
[1:24:26]
would be viewed as acceptable by the
[1:24:28]
neighbors short of residential. I would
[1:24:30]
submit to you that it is very unlikely
[1:24:32]
that anybody would put their home now on
[1:24:35]
Mustang Road given that it's State
[1:24:37]
Highway, given the amount of traffic it
[1:24:38]
carries. And so the idea that this would
[1:24:40]
be developed residentially moving
[1:24:41]
forward I think is extremely unlikely.
[1:24:44]
So what we did is we came back with an
[1:24:47]
SPUD that has an 01 base. Now it's the
[1:24:51]
first 01 SPUD or PUD that I've ever been
[1:24:54]
a part of. O2 is generally what you
[1:24:57]
would expect to see. O2 is the general
[1:24:59]
office. Frankly, I was surprised to see
[1:25:01]
that we had an 01. So 01 represents the
[1:25:04]
least intensive non-residential zoning
[1:25:07]
district that we have in Oklahoma City.
[1:25:09]
And then what we did is we further
[1:25:10]
restricted it down to only allow about
[1:25:12]
six uses. So the only thing that could
[1:25:14]
really happen here is that you would
[1:25:16]
have an office development, accountant,
[1:25:19]
lawyers, things like that. And then at
[1:25:22]
the planning commission level through
[1:25:24]
commissioner Meek's work, we had imposed
[1:25:27]
upon this development. Sarah, would you
[1:25:28]
mind go to site plan perhaps the most
[1:25:31]
restrictive set of uh conditions placed
[1:25:34]
on an SPD that's an office development
[1:25:36]
that I have been a part of. All of which
[1:25:39]
were intended to make this more
[1:25:41]
compatible to the neighborhood. So,
[1:25:44]
first what you see is four different
[1:25:46]
buildings. We capped the square footage
[1:25:48]
of each individual building at 7500
[1:25:50]
square ft. We required them to all be
[1:25:52]
singlestory. Why that's significant is
[1:25:55]
of course the neighborhood under R1
[1:25:56]
regulations could have 35 ft and 2 and a
[1:25:58]
half stories. We capped these at
[1:26:00]
singlestory. We required them in the SPD
[1:26:03]
to be residential style with a pitched
[1:26:06]
roof. We further specified the pitch of
[1:26:08]
the roof to ensure that it is a
[1:26:10]
residential style pitch roof and not
[1:26:12]
something else.
[1:26:14]
We then required a masonry wall anywhere
[1:26:17]
where we are adjacent to single family
[1:26:19]
residential. Now typically masonry walls
[1:26:22]
of 8 ft in height which is what is
[1:26:24]
required here are reserved for uses
[1:26:27]
[clears throat] that may be deemed
[1:26:27]
incompatible. Now this is not
[1:26:29]
incompatible. Typically you see that
[1:26:31]
when it's multif family next to single
[1:26:34]
family or heavy intense commercial next
[1:26:36]
to single family. But here at the
[1:26:38]
request of planning commission we agreed
[1:26:40]
to an 8ft masonry wall. We further
[1:26:43]
agreed to uh increase landscaping points
[1:26:46]
within the parking areas. Significant
[1:26:49]
landscaping on the south, the west and
[1:26:52]
the north. Significant landscape buffer
[1:26:54]
along the south, the west and the north.
[1:26:59]
We agreed to limit it to no more than
[1:27:01]
four buildings.
[1:27:04]
We required public water and public
[1:27:07]
sewer. Uh we are required to double the
[1:27:11]
number of landscaping points in the
[1:27:13]
parking areas. We are required to double
[1:27:16]
the amount of landscaping points along
[1:27:18]
the northern border.
[1:27:20]
We prohibited access to 54th. What you
[1:27:23]
see before you is the original site
[1:27:24]
plan. So now we have prohibited access
[1:27:27]
off to 50 Uh Sarah, could you go to the
[1:27:28]
aerial again? My apologies
[1:27:31]
from 54th Street, which serves as that
[1:27:33]
residential street.
[1:27:35]
Um in speaking with the council woman,
[1:27:37]
we have further agreed this and this
[1:27:39]
will be an amendment to limit the number
[1:27:41]
of access points into the SPD to one off
[1:27:45]
of South Mustang Road. So all of that
[1:27:49]
along a state highway we submit makes us
[1:27:53]
a compatible development. Now one of the
[1:27:55]
things that the council and planning
[1:27:57]
commission does not um hear or consider
[1:28:00]
are covenants. I suspect you're going to
[1:28:02]
hear something about it. So I just want
[1:28:04]
to mention one brief thing about it. The
[1:28:06]
covenants that control this neighborhood
[1:28:08]
that were done before anyone bought a
[1:28:10]
home in there have a provision and that
[1:28:13]
provision is found at section 4 and it
[1:28:15]
says all lots except tracks one and two
[1:28:19]
in the tract described shall be used
[1:28:21]
solely for residential. Well, this is
[1:28:24]
within that tract one and two. So what
[1:28:26]
does that tell us? Well, it tells us
[1:28:27]
that at inception of this neighborhood,
[1:28:30]
it was anticipated that everything in
[1:28:33]
this is required to be residential
[1:28:35]
except tract one and two. So, clearly
[1:28:37]
something other than residential was
[1:28:39]
contemplated here. I think the neighbors
[1:28:42]
know that on the eve of planning
[1:28:43]
commission, they went and attempted to
[1:28:46]
modify the covenants. Now whether or not
[1:28:48]
they're lawful is another matter, but I
[1:28:50]
was handed the day of planning
[1:28:51]
commission modified covenants trying to
[1:28:53]
fix apparently a problem that they I
[1:28:55]
guess concede allows something other
[1:28:57]
than residential to go here.
[1:29:00]
So with that, I'm happy to answer any
[1:29:02]
questions. It was recommended for
[1:29:04]
approval by the planning commission and
[1:29:06]
you'll note that in the council memo
[1:29:10]
there are 11 TEES and I think
[1:29:15]
four through 11 were all added at the
[1:29:17]
time of planning commission through
[1:29:18]
negotiation with the planning commission
[1:29:21]
uh member for W 3. And again we would
[1:29:23]
propose to modify this to limit the
[1:29:26]
access to one curb cut off of Mustang.
[1:29:29]
Happy to answer any questions.
[1:29:34]
Thank you, David. I think that you've
[1:29:35]
done a great job explaining it.
[1:29:38]
» All right, then we'll start with the
[1:29:39]
folks who've signed up to speak if that
[1:29:41]
works. Uh Colin Walk.
[1:29:48]
» Good morning, council. Colin Walk, 100
[1:29:51]
North Broadway, Sweet 2900, and I
[1:29:54]
represent Thoroughbred Homeowners
[1:29:56]
Association. What I want to be clear
[1:29:58]
about is this is the rest of the story.
[1:30:00]
You just heard Mr. Box talks talk about
[1:30:03]
covenants. And while the city generally
[1:30:05]
doesn't consider covenants, and I can
[1:30:06]
appreciate that fact, what he omitted
[1:30:09]
was that where it says shall be
[1:30:11]
residential only except for lots in one
[1:30:13]
and two, it then goes on to specify that
[1:30:16]
those lots may only be developed into
[1:30:20]
retail spaces and specifically for
[1:30:23]
swine.
[1:30:24]
Right? So, this area, if you look at the
[1:30:27]
photos I've provided, still have cattle
[1:30:29]
on all of these lots. The reason why
[1:30:33]
there are 11 TES in this particular case
[1:30:36]
is they're because they're trying to fit
[1:30:38]
a round peg in a square hole. If you
[1:30:41]
will notice the development immediately
[1:30:42]
to the south, it is a high density
[1:30:45]
populated area that is adjacent to
[1:30:47]
commercial development. Our acreages are
[1:30:50]
all five acres lots because this is an
[1:30:54]
agricultural development. And unlike
[1:30:56]
most people who come and stand before
[1:30:58]
you and say, "Please, not in my
[1:31:00]
backyard. I bought into this residential
[1:31:02]
neighborhood. I didn't know that field
[1:31:03]
was going to be developed." These
[1:31:05]
individuals not only knew this was an
[1:31:08]
agricultural area because of the size of
[1:31:09]
the lots, but because of the covenants
[1:31:12]
and the restrictions that were put on
[1:31:13]
it. So consequently, to the extent that
[1:31:16]
this council does believe that this is
[1:31:18]
somehow compatible, in spite of the size
[1:31:21]
variations, in spite of the fact that
[1:31:24]
this is a private road, and if you think
[1:31:26]
that people turning off of the main
[1:31:28]
highway, the main thoroughfare in
[1:31:30]
Mustang aren't going to miss that turnin
[1:31:32]
and start utilizing my client's private
[1:31:35]
road for which they pay, you're wrong.
[1:31:37]
It's going to happen. My clients are
[1:31:39]
going to incur additional costs as this
[1:31:41]
goes on. And so consequently when we
[1:31:44]
look at this we have to say is this
[1:31:46]
compatible? This is a completely
[1:31:48]
agricultural area has always intended to
[1:31:50]
be so it has covenants in there and the
[1:31:53]
11TE are just simply examples of um the
[1:31:57]
fact that they're trying to put a round
[1:31:59]
peg in a square hole. The final thing
[1:32:00]
that I'll say is is again going back to
[1:32:02]
the covenants I'll remind the council
[1:32:04]
that while you all do not generally look
[1:32:05]
at covenants you do for the purposes of
[1:32:07]
whether or not to permit uh issue
[1:32:09]
permits for short-term rentals. And so
[1:32:11]
to the extent that the council is
[1:32:13]
willing to consider covenants for
[1:32:15]
short-term rentals but is not willing to
[1:32:17]
do so for a zoning project would lead me
[1:32:19]
to believe that's an arbitrary and
[1:32:20]
capriccious decision.
[1:32:22]
» 30 seconds remaining.
[1:32:23]
» So consequently, we would ask that you
[1:32:24]
deny this proposed spud for not being
[1:32:27]
compatible with the area it is currently
[1:32:29]
zoned in. Thank you.
[1:32:32]
» Thank you. Um item I'm sorry, June Roy.
[1:32:49]
June Roy 11, pardon me, 11749
[1:32:52]
[clears throat]
[1:32:53]
Southwest 54th Street in Thorbred Acres.
[1:32:57]
Um, [clears throat]
[1:32:59]
I'm 79 years old and I know I don't have
[1:33:01]
to tell my age, but there's a reason.
[1:33:04]
and my husband and I, I'm sorry, bought
[1:33:07]
this house 30 years ago
[1:33:10]
because of the neighborhood because it's
[1:33:15]
five acres and while our neighbors are
[1:33:18]
mostly close,
[1:33:20]
uh, it's ex exact opposite to the new
[1:33:25]
area that is built right beside us,
[1:33:28]
which has over a hundred houses on it.
[1:33:32]
And they knew when they built there that
[1:33:36]
there would be some retail at the
[1:33:39]
opening of their street.
[1:33:42]
Theirs is not a private road. They don't
[1:33:45]
pay for it. We do. And it costs a lot to
[1:33:49]
work on our road every few well every
[1:33:52]
few years. But we bought this house to
[1:33:56]
live the rest of our lives and to leave.
[1:33:59]
Sorry, my throat's all dry. and to leave
[1:34:01]
for our children.
[1:34:03]
I don't have a lot of money. What I have
[1:34:06]
to leave my children [clears throat] is
[1:34:09]
that house
[1:34:11]
and reszoning the front of it. Like I
[1:34:14]
say, it's not our backyard. It's our
[1:34:16]
front yard. It's what people see when
[1:34:19]
they come to our neighborhood. And even
[1:34:23]
though we knew in the covenants it said
[1:34:25]
there those two were exempt from that,
[1:34:29]
our understanding when we bought our
[1:34:32]
homes was that that was for the one area
[1:34:36]
they're trying to resone now to be able
[1:34:38]
to do roping things because there were
[1:34:42]
they owned originally four lots and they
[1:34:46]
wanted to be able Thank you so much.
[1:34:49]
Our
[1:35:00]
understanding that that exemption was
[1:35:02]
for them to be able to run cattle, have
[1:35:04]
roping and all that kind of events on
[1:35:08]
that. It was not so it would be built
[1:35:11]
into
[1:35:13]
really retail.
[1:35:15]
And the gentleman who originally owned
[1:35:18]
that lived there for a long time and he
[1:35:21]
never put any retail in there. It was
[1:35:25]
only used for cattle and all that.
[1:35:27]
» 30 seconds remaining.
[1:35:29]
» Pardon?
[1:35:31]
» Did somebody say ask something?
[1:35:34]
» You have
[1:35:35]
you have 30 seconds left.
[1:35:38]
» Okay. But besides that, my real concern
[1:35:41]
is the danger this would cause. You
[1:35:43]
can't get down Mustang Road during rush
[1:35:47]
hour, which is actually three or four
[1:35:49]
hours a day because it's backed up from
[1:35:52]
59th Street to 44th Street and then
[1:35:55]
after the light beyond that. It's
[1:35:57]
dangerous and several of our neighbors
[1:36:00]
have been involved in wrecks trying to
[1:36:02]
turn onto our street. It's dangerous to
[1:36:05]
reszone it. I think I'm out of time and
[1:36:08]
thank you for hearing me.
[1:36:09]
» Thank you, Mr. Ry. This is very
[1:36:11]
important to us.
[1:36:12]
» Corey Frank.
[1:36:20]
» My name is Corey Franks. I live 11500
[1:36:24]
Southwest 54th Street. My house butts up
[1:36:27]
to the property of the proposed
[1:36:30]
land that's being changed.
[1:36:32]
Um,
[1:36:34]
obviously I'm opposed to it. You know,
[1:36:37]
we people that seek out acreages kind of
[1:36:42]
like having space beside them. So,
[1:36:45]
thoroughbred acres, five acre tracks.
[1:36:48]
This this particular track that's being
[1:36:51]
proposed used to be five. The the
[1:36:55]
original owner, they passed away. Kids
[1:36:57]
seen dollar signs. They decided, hey,
[1:37:00]
let's reszone or they
[1:37:03]
broke it down to three, three and a half
[1:37:06]
acres
[1:37:08]
with the intentions of hoping to be able
[1:37:10]
to to
[1:37:12]
profit off of it for commercial land.
[1:37:15]
Um, so basically, if this is approved,
[1:37:19]
I'm going to come home to my property,
[1:37:22]
see a 8ft cement wall in my backyard.
[1:37:26]
If
[1:37:29]
I wanted to do that, I'd live in a
[1:37:30]
neighborhood. I'd live in a neighborhood
[1:37:32]
where my neighbor's house is right
[1:37:36]
beside me, 10 foot, you know, from my
[1:37:38]
property.
[1:37:40]
Um,
[1:37:41]
it, you know, if I see a lot of stuff
[1:37:45]
that if this is approved, what's to keep
[1:37:49]
somebody else from
[1:37:52]
buying three or four houses on another
[1:37:54]
street on Mustang Road, turning it
[1:37:57]
commercial.
[1:37:59]
And by the way, when
[1:38:02]
Box mentioned the commercial aspect of
[1:38:05]
Mustang Road,
[1:38:08]
85% of Mustang is already commercial
[1:38:11]
from 152 up to 10th Street.
[1:38:16]
There are multiple houses on
[1:38:19]
Mustang Road on acreages that remain.
[1:38:25]
Um and then going back to the concept
[1:38:31]
that they have proposed,
[1:38:34]
you know, 8 ft masonry wall that is what
[1:38:37]
what is that? Is that is that brick or
[1:38:40]
is that a pre-made cement wall that I'm
[1:38:42]
going to be looking at? Is that a nice
[1:38:45]
brick wall with columns, pre-cast tops?
[1:38:48]
We don't know. Also, what they haven't
[1:38:51]
put on the
[1:38:53]
» 30 seconds remaining.
[1:38:54]
» The concept is there is no retention
[1:38:57]
pond on there. The city is going to
[1:38:59]
require a large retention pond which
[1:39:02]
going to hold water and quite frankly, I
[1:39:06]
haven't seen a pretty retention pond on
[1:39:08]
any commercial development.
[1:39:11]
um they're they're hyping it up to make
[1:39:13]
it look good,
[1:39:15]
but regardless, you start adding all the
[1:39:18]
other stuff in and then go before the
[1:39:21]
city to get the plans approved, it's
[1:39:23]
going to change from what they've got.
[1:39:25]
But thank you for your time.
[1:39:27]
» Thank you, Russell Rouse.
[1:39:41]
My name is Russell Rouse. I live at
[1:39:43]
11501 Southwest 54th Street. Um,
[1:39:48]
my reason for being here is the uh
[1:39:51]
increase in non-residential properties
[1:39:55]
has increased the traffic to the point
[1:39:57]
that we have a lot of difficulty trying
[1:40:01]
to get out and into our neighborhood. We
[1:40:03]
are a not through street. It is
[1:40:06]
definitely a dead-ended property. End
[1:40:09]
result is as the street backs up with
[1:40:11]
the cars, everybody comes down the
[1:40:14]
street, sees the backed up cars, and
[1:40:16]
turns right down the down our street.
[1:40:18]
It's difficult to support a street if
[1:40:21]
you're going to have a thousand people a
[1:40:23]
day running up and down your street. Um
[1:40:26]
there are plenty of uh commercial
[1:40:30]
properties up and down Mustang that are
[1:40:32]
currently empty. There's nobody to
[1:40:36]
support them. There are no companies in
[1:40:37]
them. There are no owners in them.
[1:40:39]
There's no renters in them. There's just
[1:40:41]
buildings out the wazoo. Um we're just
[1:40:45]
having difficulty with this. Our place
[1:40:47]
is definitely res rural in nature and uh
[1:40:52]
maintain that way for a reason. But um
[1:40:56]
in this particular case, this this
[1:40:59]
really seems out of out of place. We uh
[1:41:02]
we can't leave our houses uh say 4 to
[1:41:06]
6:00 at night, 6:30. Traffic's backed up
[1:41:10]
all the way from 59th past the entrance
[1:41:12]
into our road. So, we can't go north. We
[1:41:15]
have to go south and wait in line with
[1:41:17]
everybody else that's stuck in the
[1:41:19]
backup. It's it's just the rest of the
[1:41:22]
environment does not support the amount
[1:41:24]
of individuals that we have uh moving
[1:41:27]
into the area. The end result is uh
[1:41:31]
we're trapped. We can't hardly get in.
[1:41:34]
We can't hardly get out. Um and the cost
[1:41:36]
will go up in our neighborhoods. Um we
[1:41:40]
certainly uh appreciate everybody here's
[1:41:42]
effort. Um but u there there's no doubt
[1:41:46]
the individuals on our street were under
[1:41:48]
the impression that we're in a rural
[1:41:50]
neighborhood. We we don't have city
[1:41:53]
water. We don't have uh city sewer. We
[1:41:56]
don't have anything. We support it all
[1:41:58]
ourselves. And um this excess traffic
[1:42:01]
when everybody stops and tries to bypass
[1:42:04]
the backed up road and thinks they can
[1:42:05]
come down our street um is going to
[1:42:08]
increase our costs tremendously.
[1:42:11]
Um
[1:42:12]
» 30 seconds remaining.
[1:42:13]
» Trying trying to keep this short and
[1:42:15]
sweet, but I appreciate your time. Thank
[1:42:17]
you very much.
[1:42:20]
» Thank you. Uh Carrie Barker.
[1:42:27]
» Thank you very much. Uh it's Carrie
[1:42:29]
Barker. I'm the president of the
[1:42:32]
Thoroughbred Homeowners Association. I
[1:42:35]
live at 11648 Southwest 54 Street. I
[1:42:39]
have been the president for more than 30
[1:42:41]
years. And if you've seen the speakers
[1:42:43]
prior
[1:42:44]
u to myself all are of the same caliber
[1:42:49]
that lived in that neighborhood and it
[1:42:52]
might as well be called thoroughbred
[1:42:54]
farms. Thoroughbred
[1:42:57]
is the name of what we do. That's the
[1:42:59]
nature. We have horses, we have cattle,
[1:43:02]
we have donkeys, we raise chickens. It
[1:43:05]
is a rule. We're on uh we're not on city
[1:43:08]
water. We're well and septic. That's the
[1:43:11]
sort of community it is. It's kind of
[1:43:13]
unique and that's the reason why this
[1:43:15]
sort of business right at our front door
[1:43:18]
and in one of our lots that was
[1:43:21]
protected many years ago when the
[1:43:23]
covenants was written to guard against
[1:43:26]
that. And what they failed to mention
[1:43:27]
about the covenants is the wording in
[1:43:30]
there does not permit a developer to
[1:43:33]
come in there and put four 7500 square
[1:43:37]
foot buildings and 200 parking spaces
[1:43:40]
right at our door. Our area has one
[1:43:44]
residence per lot per five acres. We
[1:43:47]
qualify as farm exemption. This is
[1:43:51]
what's unique and this takes away from
[1:43:52]
the character. You've seen this on
[1:43:55]
television where ranches have to protect
[1:43:58]
themselves from developers coming in and
[1:44:00]
changing the environment. Please try to
[1:44:04]
protect what we have developed over the
[1:44:06]
long many years. There's not many of
[1:44:09]
them left and we're proud of it. Each
[1:44:11]
one of us know the neighbors personally
[1:44:15]
and we want to keep it that way. And we
[1:44:17]
don't see why this business when it's
[1:44:19]
presented to you, what you don't see, it
[1:44:21]
looks pretty on paper, but when you put
[1:44:24]
it in practice and drive down there and
[1:44:26]
look at four huge buildings set up on
[1:44:29]
the front of that, it's going to detract
[1:44:32]
from our acreage. And we have kept it in
[1:44:34]
pristine condition. All of those houses
[1:44:36]
are occupied. We've invested our
[1:44:39]
savings, our 401s in there. That's all
[1:44:42]
we have. The owners of this that were
[1:44:45]
there previously, ironically, is a land
[1:44:48]
and cattle
[1:44:50]
company and they want to remove what we
[1:44:53]
have on there now. We keep cattle on
[1:44:55]
there. Everyone else have horses. We do
[1:44:59]
not want this change there. We're not
[1:45:01]
opposed to commercial businesses,
[1:45:03]
» But put it somewhere where it belongs.
[1:45:06]
If you read the zoning, the purpose for
[1:45:09]
zoning, this was approved residential
[1:45:11]
some 35 years ago. It's residential.
[1:45:15]
It's not commercial. And if you look at
[1:45:17]
the zoning, it says here that zoning is
[1:45:20]
the purpose. It's necessary to protect
[1:45:22]
the community health, safety, and
[1:45:26]
welfare. Please uphold that today and
[1:45:30]
reject this application.
[1:45:33]
Thank you.
[1:45:36]
Thank you. That concludes Councilwoman
[1:45:38]
Avers uh the residents who signed up to
[1:45:40]
speak.
[1:45:43]
» Councilwoman, can I ask a quick
[1:45:44]
question?
[1:45:46]
Um
[1:45:48]
and this might seem like a naive or I
[1:45:51]
just I feel very uninformed on what the
[1:45:54]
covenant piece is. And so I was
[1:45:56]
wondering if maybe Sarah or Matt could
[1:45:59]
talk to us about why we don't consider
[1:46:01]
covenants and what the purpose of them
[1:46:03]
is. then if they don't have any effect
[1:46:06]
on our zoning.
[1:46:16]
» Yeah, that's a that's a good question.
[1:46:18]
So, the covenants run with the land and
[1:46:22]
those certainly apply to um visav the
[1:46:27]
the developer and the purchaser of the
[1:46:30]
property. Traditionally,
[1:46:33]
um, as a municipality, we focus on our
[1:46:37]
ordinances and what we can consider
[1:46:40]
lawfully.
[1:46:41]
There are components that of of what may
[1:46:45]
be contained in covenants that this body
[1:46:47]
can certainly consider, but the fact of
[1:46:50]
that agreement
[1:46:52]
is that private agreement, it remains
[1:46:55]
private. Although it may be of record,
[1:46:58]
it'd be more like a mortgage or
[1:46:59]
something between between other parties,
[1:47:01]
not the city itself.
[1:47:03]
» So it it's not something that's like
[1:47:06]
who enforces it. It's just self-
[1:47:09]
enforced.
[1:47:10]
» So the private property owners could
[1:47:13]
could pursue recourse at the district
[1:47:15]
courthouse if they believe that um
[1:47:17]
» The covenant is not being
[1:47:19]
» Right. If that the covenants have been
[1:47:20]
violated.
[1:47:21]
» Gotcha. Thank you.
[1:47:24]
And then this is I'm guessing for
[1:47:26]
councilwoman because it's your award.
[1:47:28]
I'm just looking at the map. Am I
[1:47:31]
understanding that retail doesn't exist
[1:47:35]
between Southwest 44th and 59th that
[1:47:37]
it's north and south of those two
[1:47:39]
intersections? Is that about right?
[1:47:41]
» What's the question?
[1:47:44]
So on Mustang Road
[1:47:48]
between 44th
[1:47:50]
and 59th
[1:47:52]
» 44th
[1:47:53]
» Like Southwest 44th. Am I looking
[1:47:55]
» That retail does not exist?
[1:47:57]
» That's a question. That's not a
[1:47:58]
statement. Is there any retail between
[1:48:01]
Southwest 44th and Southwest 59th? I see
[1:48:04]
some south.
[1:48:07]
» Sure.
[1:48:07]
» Of 59th.
[1:48:09]
I see some north, but on here I'm not
[1:48:12]
seeing that.
[1:48:14]
» So, the the zoning exists to allow
[1:48:17]
retail. Now, we're not proposing retail.
[1:48:19]
Like, we're just office. I guess if
[1:48:22]
there's a 7-Eleven gas station north of
[1:48:24]
59th that sells things. So, I guess that
[1:48:27]
is some form of retail. But there PED265
[1:48:32]
allows
[1:48:34]
commercial development allowing retail.
[1:48:35]
There's a lot of talk of commercial
[1:48:37]
development. We do not allow any
[1:48:38]
commercial uses.
[1:48:39]
» An office.
[1:48:40]
» Office 01 office.
[1:48:44]
» And then what is the closest office to
[1:48:49]
this area? Do you have any notion of
[1:48:51]
that?
[1:48:51]
» Yeah.
[1:48:53]
I'm going to use this. So here's our
[1:48:56]
site right here across the street.
[1:48:59]
Office.
[1:49:00]
» There's office, right? Okay. I see on
[1:49:01]
there. But is that zoned or is there an
[1:49:04]
actual office there?
[1:49:05]
» Actual office. If you look at the aerial
[1:49:08]
Sarah, would you mind going back right
[1:49:11]
here?
[1:49:13]
And then north of that is commercial
[1:49:14]
zoning, but yeah, the office is there
[1:49:17]
and built. The 7 This images from 2005,
[1:49:22]
excuse me, 25. The 7-Eleven is now fully
[1:49:24]
operational. Mustang Road is developing
[1:49:26]
out. It it once was a kind of rural
[1:49:31]
area, but that has changed rapidly.
[1:49:34]
You've got multif family here. You've
[1:49:36]
got commercial zoning and development
[1:49:38]
ongoing and we're again it's I think
[1:49:40]
it's critical our spud is limited to
[1:49:43]
office only and 01
[1:49:47]
and there's a tenant for this office.
[1:49:50]
» No, not yet.
[1:49:52]
» Okay.
[1:49:53]
I I guess that's where I have some
[1:49:58]
issues is
[1:50:01]
when I think of downtown office space
[1:50:03]
right now and the vacancies and then I
[1:50:05]
just drive
[1:50:07]
almost anywhere in Oklahoma City.
[1:50:09]
Really, I could do this almost in any
[1:50:11]
city and I just see so much vacant
[1:50:15]
office space
[1:50:17]
and that always bothers me especially in
[1:50:19]
a housing crisis.
[1:50:21]
So, I don't know. That's just on my
[1:50:23]
mind. So, thank you for walking me
[1:50:24]
through that.
[1:50:25]
» So, real quick on that. Yes, the the
[1:50:26]
downtown market is having perhaps some
[1:50:30]
issues with vacancies. The suburban
[1:50:34]
market for lowscale office development.
[1:50:37]
There is always interest for that. There
[1:50:39]
there are largecale office developments
[1:50:42]
like this where you'll have 15 to 20
[1:50:44]
residential style office buildings that
[1:50:46]
are full. Um there's a very different
[1:50:49]
market in the suburban market from the
[1:50:51]
downtown market. So the question before
[1:50:53]
you is not are there tenants to fill
[1:50:55]
these spaces. Um it's do we have a use
[1:50:59]
that is compatible with all the
[1:51:00]
restrictions that have been placed upon
[1:51:02]
us.
[1:51:06]
If we if we made zoning decisions based
[1:51:08]
on do we have tenants in place uh just
[1:51:10]
about nothing get done here on Tuesdays.
[1:51:14]
» Yeah.
[1:51:16]
Okay.
[1:51:35]
Okay. I have really looked at this
[1:51:39]
application. Uh I actually happened to
[1:51:41]
be it's my first planning commission
[1:51:43]
case that I ever got to watch. um in
[1:51:46]
person because I was here for another
[1:51:48]
purpose. And so I got to meet many of
[1:51:51]
our neighbors and um hear the concern
[1:51:55]
and the um elevation of of issues. And I
[1:52:00]
also got to see our planning commission
[1:52:02]
at work and our planning commissioner
[1:52:05]
representing the concerns of the
[1:52:07]
neighbors and the balance of the
[1:52:09]
applicant and and their property rights.
[1:52:12]
And that's what I've seen really
[1:52:14]
evolving over the last several months is
[1:52:17]
that conversation and the
[1:52:20]
changes to the application. And so we're
[1:52:23]
at a point um today where it takes seven
[1:52:26]
votes
[1:52:28]
um to pass it. Um but the flip side of
[1:52:31]
that is if the um applicant feels that
[1:52:36]
their property rights are being violated
[1:52:38]
and us saying no, then they can take
[1:52:40]
that to district court and it would be
[1:52:42]
evaluated in a court environment and um
[1:52:47]
and so we have to go back to land use
[1:52:49]
compatibility. is what is being proposed
[1:52:52]
compatible and amendable to what was
[1:52:55]
scoped in the land use that was approved
[1:52:56]
by the city 30 years ago and the zoning
[1:53:00]
from the city 30 years ago was as an R1
[1:53:03]
um which actually enables more than one
[1:53:05]
house in this particular lot. It could
[1:53:08]
enable up to five houses under the
[1:53:10]
current uh zoning conditions in that
[1:53:12]
area. So what happened in planning
[1:53:14]
commission were really adding
[1:53:16]
mitigations to make an office as close
[1:53:20]
to a an impact as residential
[1:53:23]
development would be. So I heard today
[1:53:27]
the concerns about the road traffic and
[1:53:29]
I echo every concern around traffic and
[1:53:34]
congestion and throughput um in
[1:53:38]
southwest Oklahoma City. We have some
[1:53:40]
real challenges. We have had incredible
[1:53:43]
development. Um, one of the mitigations
[1:53:46]
that was negotiated with planning
[1:53:48]
commission through great feedback from
[1:53:51]
community members is, hey, we're worried
[1:53:53]
about people wearing and tearing on a
[1:53:55]
road that we're paying for out of
[1:53:56]
pocket. And so the access to this zoning
[1:54:01]
added a restriction where there's only
[1:54:03]
access from Highway 4. And um the
[1:54:06]
buildings are proposed to be built just
[1:54:09]
like a house as if the houses that were
[1:54:12]
approved there.
[1:54:14]
So the um landscaping that has been
[1:54:17]
incorporated would not be a requirement
[1:54:19]
under the HOA association or even in um
[1:54:23]
any normal residential development.
[1:54:26]
And that was done to try to support the
[1:54:31]
rural feel of the existing neighborhood
[1:54:34]
to create that green space. And um and
[1:54:38]
then the masonry wall was actually done
[1:54:40]
also to really be able to separate it
[1:54:42]
from the neighborhood so that there
[1:54:44]
would be no impact from a traffic, a
[1:54:48]
safety and security risk.
[1:54:51]
um really all of the considerations that
[1:54:53]
have been noted by our neighbors. And so
[1:54:58]
um today I'm going to make a motion for
[1:55:01]
approval
[1:55:03]
with the full understanding and support
[1:55:06]
that if you want to take this to court
[1:55:10]
tied to the PUD, that is 100% your
[1:55:13]
right. But if this council votes no
[1:55:14]
today, all of the negotiation, all of
[1:55:18]
the concessions that you've gotten from
[1:55:20]
a neighbor negotiation perspective, you
[1:55:22]
would lose and you wouldn't have any of
[1:55:24]
that navigation in place. And so today,
[1:55:28]
I'm making a motion for approval. Yes,
[1:55:30]
sir.
[1:55:31]
» We need to to make the amendment to
[1:55:34]
limit it to one curb cut first.
[1:55:36]
» Sorry.
[1:55:36]
» Thank you.
[1:55:39]
» All right. Uh the motion for the
[1:55:41]
amendment is to make it a one road
[1:55:43]
access
[1:55:44]
» One curb cut
[1:55:45]
» Off of one curb cut allowed off of
[1:55:47]
Highway 4 just like um a residential um
[1:55:52]
access point would normally be off of
[1:55:54]
Highway 4. I'm not saying just like that
[1:55:56]
in the amendment, but I'm just saying
[1:55:58]
that as a comparison because I actually
[1:55:59]
think it would probably be a double
[1:56:02]
double entrance to enable access and or
[1:56:05]
egress and ingress. Um,
[1:56:09]
this is a this is a hard one because I
[1:56:12]
totally I 100% understand, but if you
[1:56:15]
don't have
[1:56:17]
what you have negotiated in place
[1:56:20]
approved by this council, then you don't
[1:56:22]
have the guarantees of that. And if you
[1:56:24]
look at the court dockets, I think that
[1:56:27]
you, the applicant, on the flip side,
[1:56:30]
would have an an an equal argument. If
[1:56:33]
that makes sense. I'm happy to discuss
[1:56:36]
all of the things that I've gone
[1:56:37]
through, but I want you to know that all
[1:56:39]
of these protections are to make it
[1:56:41]
equivalent to a residential
[1:56:43]
neighborhood, but enable the property
[1:56:45]
owner to execute their rights as um to
[1:56:50]
have a residentialike business in that
[1:56:52]
environment. And if and I'm there are
[1:56:56]
many other people around this horseshoe
[1:56:58]
that have way more experience than me in
[1:57:01]
both law and planning. So, if I have a a
[1:57:04]
misunderstanding or a misinterpretation
[1:57:06]
of this, I would, you know, welcome your
[1:57:08]
insight. But, uh, I've really tried to
[1:57:12]
learn and understand all of the risks
[1:57:15]
and the benefits to make the best
[1:57:17]
decision for our community.
[1:57:19]
» I'll just add that
[1:57:22]
I appreciate
[1:57:25]
the work you're doing on this item,
[1:57:28]
Councilwoman. I just do. I think the
[1:57:30]
amendments, I think your planning
[1:57:32]
commissioner is doing some great work.
[1:57:34]
Um, so on that note, uh, I'll vote to
[1:57:38]
join you all on the technical evaluation
[1:57:40]
just to continue making this item as,
[1:57:44]
um, useful to the area as possible, but
[1:57:49]
I ultimately
[1:57:51]
just don't think I can go along for the
[1:57:53]
rest of the ride. But should it pass, I
[1:57:55]
at least want to make sure it's the best
[1:57:57]
possible product it can be. So I'll just
[1:57:59]
want to state that for the record.
[1:58:07]
» All right. So we want to move an
[1:58:09]
amendment
[1:58:09]
» Motion for amendment.
[1:58:13]
» And that is an amendment as previously
[1:58:17]
described or
[1:58:19]
» Um curb cut.
[1:58:20]
» Yeah. Uh access shall be limited to one
[1:58:22]
curb cut off Mustang Road.
[1:58:25]
» Okay, that's it.
[1:58:29]
All right, we got a motion and a second
[1:58:30]
for the amendment. Cast your votes.
[1:58:35]
Passes unanimously. Now we're on the uh
[1:58:38]
item as amended. Item F.
[1:58:46]
We have a motion and a second.
[1:58:49]
Cast your votes.
[1:58:54]
» 7 to two and with the necessary Seven
[1:58:57]
votes required for approval.
[1:59:00]
All right. Item G is an ordinance on
[1:59:02]
final hearing. It was recommended for
[1:59:03]
approval reszoning 2319 North Barnes
[1:59:06]
Avenue from R2C4
[1:59:09]
UD and TT to SPD 1817 UD and TT.
[1:59:15]
Councilwoman Hammond, no one to speak.
[1:59:17]
» Is the applicant here? I'm not sure I
[1:59:20]
see them. Oh, there you are. I'm just
[1:59:21]
hiding. Um, can you just kind of give us
[1:59:22]
a brief kind of overview of what this
[1:59:24]
project is?
[1:59:25]
» Yeah, absolutely. Mark Sitel, one
[1:59:27]
Sheridan Avenue with Johnson and
[1:59:28]
Associates. Uh this is a town home
[1:59:30]
project just south of Memory Serves as a
[1:59:34]
Jimmy John's off of uh Northwest 23rd
[1:59:36]
Street. And so uh what we've designed
[1:59:39]
are nine units. The front four face
[1:59:42]
barns. So the front doors, they'll have
[1:59:44]
kind of small front yards. Uh and then
[1:59:46]
the units behind will face internally.
[1:59:49]
Uh and then they will have backyards. So
[1:59:51]
it it's a bit of a an awkward site
[1:59:53]
because of its size and its depth. Um,
[1:59:55]
but uh we went to the urban design
[1:59:58]
commission. It's probably the biggest
[1:59:59]
change. The entirety of this SPUD will
[2:00:02]
have to conform to the urban design uh
[2:00:05]
guidelines and review process. Right now
[2:00:07]
only half of it does. So we've actually
[2:00:08]
brought some property essentially in uh
[2:00:11]
for review. So they recommended
[2:00:12]
approval, planning commission
[2:00:14]
recommended approval, staff generously
[2:00:16]
recommended their approval as well. Uh
[2:00:18]
and we are here today asking for your
[2:00:20]
approval.
[2:00:21]
» Thank you. Yeah, I just wanted to
[2:00:22]
highlight this. Um, this lot has been
[2:00:25]
vacant the for I don't know how long,
[2:00:27]
but definitely my whole time on council
[2:00:28]
and I know has been a concern of some of
[2:00:30]
the neighbors. So, I think it's exciting
[2:00:32]
to see some infill development on it.
[2:00:34]
And um I' I've not heard anything
[2:00:36]
negative from the neighbors and I think
[2:00:38]
it generally it's being seen as a
[2:00:39]
positive addition to the neighborhood.
[2:00:41]
So, I'm happy to move for approval.
[2:00:46]
All
[2:00:50]
right, we have a motion and a second for
[2:00:52]
item G. Cast your votes.
[2:00:58]
Passes unanimously. Item H is an
[2:01:01]
ordinance on final hearing. It was
[2:01:02]
recommended for approval resoning 1320
[2:01:05]
West Reno from SPUD1309
[2:01:08]
to SPD1821.
[2:01:12]
Councilwoman Avers has stepped away. So
[2:01:14]
maybe we will come back to that. We'll
[2:01:17]
skip H for now. Um item I is an
[2:01:21]
ordinance on final hearing establishing
[2:01:23]
45deree angle parking uh on the east
[2:01:26]
side of North College near Northwest
[2:01:28]
16th. Councilwoman Hammond.
[2:01:31]
» Yes. I will move for approval.
[2:01:39]
» Have a motion and a second. cast your
[2:01:41]
votes.
[2:01:53]
Passes unanimously. Item J is an
[2:01:55]
ordinance on final hearing establishing
[2:01:57]
reserved parking for the physically
[2:01:58]
disabled uh on College near Northwest
[2:02:01]
16th. Councilwoman Hammond,
[2:02:03]
» I will move for approval.
[2:02:08]
» Got a motion and a second. cast your
[2:02:10]
votes.
[2:02:18]
Passes unanimously. Item K is an
[2:02:20]
ordinance on final hearing establishing
[2:02:21]
reserved parking for the physically
[2:02:23]
disabled on the west side of North
[2:02:24]
Harvey near 11th. Uh Council Hammond,
[2:02:28]
» I will move for approval.
[2:02:37]
Have
[2:02:37]
» A motion and a second. Cast your votes.
[2:02:46]
passes unanimously. Item L1 is the
[2:02:49]
public hearing regarding the dilapidated
[2:02:50]
structures here listed. Amy, has anyone
[2:02:51]
signed up to speak?
[2:02:52]
» No, they haven't.
[2:02:53]
» They have not. So, we'll advance to the
[2:02:54]
resolution found at L2 to claim the
[2:02:55]
structures are dilapidated.
[2:03:04]
There's a motion in a second for L2.
[2:03:08]
cast your votes.
[2:03:15]
Passes unanimously. M1 is the public
[2:03:17]
hearing regarding the unsecured
[2:03:18]
structures here listed except for those
[2:03:19]
previously struck. Emmy, has anyone
[2:03:21]
signed up to speak?
[2:03:21]
» No, they haven't.
[2:03:22]
» They have not. And so we'll advance to
[2:03:23]
the resolution found that M2 declaring
[2:03:25]
structures are unsecured.
[2:03:33]
Motion cast your votes.
[2:03:36]
» We have a motion and a second. Cast your
[2:03:37]
votes. passes unanimously. Okay. Now,
[2:03:39]
we're going to go back to item H. I
[2:03:41]
understand Councilwoman Avers has asked
[2:03:42]
Councilman Stone to carry this item.
[2:03:44]
This is a, as previously stated, this is
[2:03:47]
for um SPD 1821 at 3020
[2:03:54]
West Reno.
[2:03:55]
» Thank you, mayor. Has anyone signed up
[2:03:57]
to speak?
[2:03:57]
» They have not.
[2:03:58]
» All right. With that, I'll go ahead and
[2:03:59]
move for its approval.
[2:04:05]
» Got a motion in a second. Cast your
[2:04:07]
votes.
[2:04:12]
passes unanimously. Item 11 in is a
[2:04:15]
public hearing regarding uh the
[2:04:17]
abandoned building here listed. Amy, has
[2:04:18]
anyone signed to speak?
[2:04:21]
» No, they haven't.
[2:04:22]
» They have not. And so we will uh advance
[2:04:24]
to the resolution found in two declaring
[2:04:25]
the building abandoned.
[2:04:32]
Have a motion and a second. Cast your
[2:04:34]
votes.
[2:04:37]
passes unanimously.
[2:04:39]
Um item 1101 is a public hearing
[2:04:43]
regarding an amendment to the fiscal
[2:04:44]
year 2026 budget. Uh Amy, has anyone
[2:04:47]
signed to speak?
[2:04:48]
» No, they haven't.
[2:04:48]
» They have not. Uh so we can advance to
[2:04:51]
O2. This is a resolution adopting uh
[2:04:54]
said amendment which I believe was
[2:04:56]
introduced at this last meeting.
[2:05:01]
So no presentation.
[2:05:04]
Got a motion and a second. Cast your
[2:05:06]
votes.
[2:05:10]
Passes unanimously.
[2:05:12]
11 P1 is the second public hearing
[2:05:15]
regarding uh the regarding amending
[2:05:18]
amending the June 17th, 2025 resolution
[2:05:20]
regarding fire expenditures. Amy, has
[2:05:22]
anyone signed to speak?
[2:05:23]
» No, they haven't.
[2:05:24]
» They have not. And so we will advance to
[2:05:25]
the resolution at P2 making such
[2:05:28]
amendment.
[2:05:33]
We have a motion in a second. Cast your
[2:05:35]
votes.
[2:05:40]
Passes unanimously. Q1 is the second
[2:05:43]
public hearing regarding fire sales tax
[2:05:45]
appropriations. Amy, has anyone sent to
[2:05:47]
speak?
[2:05:48]
» No, they haven't.
[2:05:48]
» They have not. So, we'll advance to the
[2:05:50]
resolution found at Q2 uh regarding said
[2:05:54]
fire department appropriations.
[2:05:58]
Got a motion in a second. Cast your
[2:06:00]
votes.
[2:06:04]
Passes unanimously. 11R1 is a second
[2:06:06]
public hearing regarding police sales
[2:06:08]
tax appropriations. Amy, has anyone
[2:06:10]
signed to speak?
[2:06:10]
» No, they have not.
[2:06:11]
» Not. So, we'll advance to the resolution
[2:06:13]
found at R2 regarding said police
[2:06:15]
department appropriations.
[2:06:22]
Got a motion and a second. Cast your
[2:06:24]
votes.
[2:06:31]
passes seven to one. Uh, and then item S
[2:06:34]
is a joint resolution with the Oklahoma
[2:06:36]
City Economic Development Trust
[2:06:37]
approving an allocation to the city of
[2:06:39]
Oklahoma City and an amount not to
[2:06:40]
exceed $4 million from Increment
[2:06:42]
District 2's other public development
[2:06:45]
costs. This is for the purpose of the
[2:06:46]
MAPS 3 Union Station renovation at 300
[2:06:49]
Southwest 7th. And we have a
[2:06:50]
presentation.
[2:06:51]
» Yes, Ryan Echelman is here with GSB to
[2:06:53]
give us a presentation on this project.
[2:06:56]
» Great. Good morning to you all. Uh
[2:07:00]
I'm here to talk about the uh renovation
[2:07:02]
of Union Station which is um located on
[2:07:06]
the south end of um Scissor Tale Park.
[2:07:11]
Let me advance here.
[2:07:14]
Um
[2:07:15]
there we go.
[2:07:19]
South end of Scissor Tale Park. um
[2:07:24]
built in the golden age of rail travel
[2:07:27]
in about 1930. Had a few had a about two
[2:07:30]
decades of um kind of its heyday and
[2:07:33]
then it was um habits changed and the
[2:07:38]
city changed and it kind of disappeared
[2:07:40]
into obscurity. Um, fortunately for us,
[2:07:42]
the building has been incredibly well
[2:07:44]
taken care of. Um, and is now exposed to
[2:07:46]
public view by the development of the
[2:07:48]
park after being buried uh, among
[2:07:50]
commercial development south of downtown
[2:07:53]
for many, many years. Um, you can see an
[2:07:55]
aerial of it in its abutment to the park
[2:07:58]
to the rail line and I40 to the south.
[2:08:01]
Um, as I mentioned, the building's in
[2:08:03]
really good condition. Needs a little
[2:08:05]
bit of renovation on the interior and
[2:08:06]
exterior. It's been used as an office
[2:08:08]
building by uh, Embark for many years.
[2:08:11]
Um and we're proposing to return it to
[2:08:13]
public use. Um you can see a lot of the
[2:08:16]
existing or the original infrastructure
[2:08:18]
still in the building, light fixtures,
[2:08:20]
cornice, stone work. Um and you can also
[2:08:22]
see on the right the office building
[2:08:24]
that they built inside of the uh
[2:08:26]
original uh waiting hall that will be
[2:08:28]
removed. And this is what we propose to
[2:08:30]
do is to return it to its original glory
[2:08:34]
um and to make it a public facility
[2:08:35]
again to host events, to host park
[2:08:38]
visitors, um and to make the public
[2:08:40]
portion of the building uh public again.
[2:08:43]
So this is an image of the east um
[2:08:45]
waiting hall um hosting an event. You
[2:08:48]
can see the old ticket windows. You can
[2:08:50]
see um all the original um cornis work
[2:08:53]
and light fixtures and everything that
[2:08:55]
would be restored as a part of the
[2:08:56]
renovation.
[2:08:57]
The building is made up of two portions.
[2:08:59]
The the former public portion, which
[2:09:01]
we're calling area A to the north. Um
[2:09:03]
and areas B and C are former baggage and
[2:09:06]
cargo areas. Uh those are not proposed
[2:09:09]
to be renovated as a part of this
[2:09:10]
project. Um will be focused on the north
[2:09:13]
half of the building.
[2:09:15]
You can see it consists of the two
[2:09:17]
original waiting halls, um support areas
[2:09:20]
and circulation areas, restrooms, um
[2:09:23]
meeting and office space. Uh the blue
[2:09:25]
area is proposed for renovation by this
[2:09:27]
funding, but we'd like to tackle the
[2:09:29]
alternate areas highlighted in orange so
[2:09:32]
that we really we really um complete the
[2:09:34]
renovation of the entire north portion
[2:09:37]
of the building.
[2:09:39]
Part of what makes this project
[2:09:40]
challenging is it's historic. Um it was
[2:09:43]
built in 1930 at a time when buildings
[2:09:46]
were not um did not have central air
[2:09:48]
conditioning in those systems. And we
[2:09:50]
are introducing um lots of people into
[2:09:53]
those spaces for large events. Um think
[2:09:56]
about filling those rooms on August, you
[2:09:59]
know, at three in the afternoon on
[2:10:00]
August 15th when the air conditioning
[2:10:02]
demand is at the highest. And so we are
[2:10:04]
building a Swiss watch. This is an image
[2:10:06]
on the right that shows the air
[2:10:07]
conditioning system that's going to be
[2:10:09]
integrated into the attic of the uh of
[2:10:12]
the facility to support all of that.
[2:10:14]
This has to be done invisibly so we
[2:10:16]
don't compromise any of the historical
[2:10:18]
um character of the building.
[2:10:21]
As I mentioned, large occupancy spaces
[2:10:23]
will be able to host as many as 600
[2:10:25]
people uh over 350 at tables um and a
[2:10:29]
smaller amount in the west hall which
[2:10:32]
will also function as kind of a uh
[2:10:34]
arrival and visitor center for the park
[2:10:36]
itself that the foundation will will
[2:10:38]
operate. upgrading
[2:10:40]
um upgrading all the HVAC systems,
[2:10:43]
providing new electrical service to
[2:10:45]
support not only the HVAC demands, but
[2:10:47]
also the convenience power. Um buildings
[2:10:50]
in 1930 did not have the electrical
[2:10:52]
infrastructure that we would expect
[2:10:54]
today for a modern event center.
[2:10:56]
Upgrading some plumbing. There's some
[2:10:58]
failed uh failed sewer lines under the
[2:11:01]
building that need to be replaced. And
[2:11:02]
upgrading the water service. And then as
[2:11:04]
I mentioned, lots of selective
[2:11:06]
historical renovation to lighting
[2:11:08]
windows, um interior plaster, terazzo
[2:11:11]
floors, exterior stonework, um
[2:11:14]
modernizing many of those historic
[2:11:16]
fixtures as well, some furniture for the
[2:11:18]
facility, and completing the fire
[2:11:21]
protection system to protect it in
[2:11:22]
perpetuity. need to go back really quick
[2:11:25]
um mention this project um has a little
[2:11:29]
over 12.5 million dollars in funding
[2:11:30]
from the residual revenues from MAPS 3.
[2:11:34]
This was not originally a maps 3
[2:11:36]
project, but it has been allocated those
[2:11:38]
funds. Um but we are about $4 million
[2:11:40]
short to complete uh all of the work
[2:11:42]
that I've described. So, some of the
[2:11:45]
things that would be um have to be cut
[2:11:47]
out of the project um without the
[2:11:49]
additional funding um includes the items
[2:11:52]
listed on the screen. We would have to
[2:11:54]
utilize a different mechanical system
[2:11:56]
which would use rooftop equipment or
[2:11:58]
some other things that would not be
[2:11:59]
compatible with the historic character
[2:12:01]
of the building. Um would have to forego
[2:12:03]
some of the infrastructure improvements.
[2:12:05]
Eliminate alternates. um eliminate some
[2:12:08]
of the uh AV infrastructure that would
[2:12:10]
be needed to support events um and the
[2:12:13]
like. So, this is a request to utilize
[2:12:16]
those tough funds to complete the
[2:12:17]
funding, close the funding gap, and
[2:12:20]
hopefully um with the help of Lingo
[2:12:22]
Construction, who's a construction
[2:12:23]
manager, um reintroduce this facility to
[2:12:26]
the public in a couple years. Any
[2:12:28]
questions for me?
[2:12:34]
» Thanks, Ryan. to
[2:12:38]
» All right. Well, it's exciting. So, we
[2:12:42]
can uh take up the resolution found at
[2:12:45]
item S.
[2:12:50]
Got a motion in a second.
[2:12:53]
Cast your votes.
[2:13:00]
Passes unanimously.
[2:13:02]
And then item T is a resolution
[2:13:04]
approving the Oklahoma City parks and
[2:13:06]
recreation department policy on
[2:13:07]
advertising sponsorships and donations.
[2:13:10]
And we have a presentation.
[2:13:12]
» Yes. Melinda McMillan Miller, our parks
[2:13:14]
and recreation director, will present
[2:13:16]
this new policy.
[2:13:18]
» Thank you, Mr. City Manager. Melinda
[2:13:20]
McMillan Miller, parks and recreation
[2:13:22]
director. Um, this policy is is long
[2:13:24]
time coming. We've worked on it for many
[2:13:26]
years to update and create a policy that
[2:13:29]
is very workable for our park system as
[2:13:31]
well as our public in order for us to um
[2:13:34]
continually provide enhanced maintenance
[2:13:36]
uh different types of programming. It
[2:13:38]
also follows the parks master plan that
[2:13:40]
identified multiple different
[2:13:41]
alternative funding resources that we
[2:13:43]
could tap into. Um it also follows
[2:13:46]
national recreation and park association
[2:13:48]
standards for um accreditation purposes,
[2:13:51]
something we aspire to get completed for
[2:13:52]
our city. So policy overall is just
[2:13:55]
giving us the um ability to define and
[2:13:58]
outline um what advertising is allowable
[2:14:00]
in our parks. Making sure that we
[2:14:02]
protect um the public making sure that
[2:14:05]
we enhance and protect the city's
[2:14:08]
mission and values and make sure things
[2:14:10]
are appropriate especially where
[2:14:11]
children are. Um and also give us the
[2:14:13]
opportunity to have some additional
[2:14:15]
resources to continue to maintain and
[2:14:17]
take care of our parks.
[2:14:20]
There any questions? I'm happy to answer
[2:14:22]
them.
[2:14:26]
Thank you.
[2:14:27]
» Thank you. All right, we can take up the
[2:14:28]
resolution found at item T.
[2:14:34]
» We have a motion and a second.
[2:14:38]
Cast your votes.
[2:14:46]
Passes unanimously and uh Vice Mayor
[2:14:49]
Hinkle presided.
[2:14:56]
brings us to item U1, extension of
[2:14:59]
collecting bargaining agreement with the
[2:15:01]
American Federation of State, County,
[2:15:03]
and Municipal Employees, local two or
[2:15:05]
2406.
[2:15:07]
Uh, executive session is not requested,
[2:15:09]
but city manager, do you have some
[2:15:11]
comments you'd like to make on this? V.
[2:15:13]
Uh so UNV um as Vice Mayor Hel said are
[2:15:18]
items that are just extending our
[2:15:19]
contracts as we're continuing
[2:15:21]
negotiations with our bargaining units.
[2:15:23]
You'll notice FOP is not on here. We do
[2:15:25]
now have the signed agreement with FOP.
[2:15:26]
That'll be on the next meeting. We'll
[2:15:28]
get that taken care of there. Um so we
[2:15:30]
appreciate u the collaboration and
[2:15:32]
cooperation as we're working together.
[2:15:34]
This allows us to continue the funding
[2:15:36]
or the contract as we have it right now
[2:15:38]
into next year until we get a new
[2:15:39]
contract in place.
[2:15:42]
So, we're ready for a motion on U1
[2:16:00]
and it passes 8 to zero. V1 uh extension
[2:16:06]
of the collecting bargaining agreement
[2:16:07]
with the International Association of
[2:16:09]
Firefighters Local 157. Ready for a
[2:16:13]
motion
[2:16:25]
and it passes 8 to zero.
[2:16:29]
Uh W1 is a resolution authorizing the
[2:16:33]
municipal counselor to approve the
[2:16:35]
admnification claim made by the
[2:16:37]
defendant officer in the lawsuit
[2:16:40]
Lorenzo Clerkley versus citizen of
[2:16:42]
Oklahoma City.
[2:16:44]
Executive session is not requested.
[2:16:48]
Ready for a motion.
[2:16:59]
and it passes unanimously.
[2:17:03]
Item X and Y are asking for executive
[2:17:07]
session. Do
[2:17:07]
» We need to take a motion on those?
[2:17:08]
» So, we need a motion on both of those.
[2:17:10]
Please
[2:17:11]
» Do it separately. Yeah, we'll start with
[2:17:14]
X.
[2:17:23]
It passes unanimously. And to Y
[2:17:47]
And it passes unanimously as well.
[2:17:50]
Item Z is claims recommended for denial.
[2:17:56]
Ready for a motion.
[2:18:10]
And it passes unanimously.
[2:18:12]
And item AA is claims are recommended
[2:18:15]
for approval. Ready for a motion.
[2:18:30]
And it passes. unanimously.
[2:18:34]
Item 12 is comments from council. One,
[2:18:37]
two.
[2:18:40]
» Yes. Thank you, Vice Mayor. Um, I just
[2:18:44]
wanted to say that I am I was quite
[2:18:48]
honored a week ago to march in Tokyo
[2:18:53]
Pride Parade. It was incredible. I've
[2:18:56]
already posted about this on social
[2:18:58]
media. What happened is I met someone
[2:19:01]
who does advocacy work around HIV AIDS
[2:19:05]
particularly on the idea that uh
[2:19:08]
untransmissible equals undetect or
[2:19:11]
excuse me undetectable equals
[2:19:12]
untransmissible right and so if you're
[2:19:15]
someone who's taking the proper
[2:19:17]
medications if if you're HIV positive
[2:19:19]
right which this is a reminder everyone
[2:19:23]
regardless of your sexual orientation
[2:19:26]
does not matter
[2:19:28]
pest regularly. It is you protecting
[2:19:32]
your body and protecting others. And so
[2:19:34]
anyway, I met someone and they said,
[2:19:36]
"Hey, do you want to march in the parade
[2:19:38]
with us?" And I said, "Oh, I'm sorry.
[2:19:40]
What did you just say?" So I got to
[2:19:42]
march in the parade. And while I was and
[2:19:45]
the reason why I was in Tokyo is we have
[2:19:48]
uh some OKC residents who live in W 2
[2:19:51]
and W 6 uh who are in a band I've
[2:19:53]
referenced up here previously called
[2:19:55]
Chap Pile, a metal band, uh who on the
[2:19:58]
same day that Beyonce's Renaissance
[2:20:00]
album came out a few years ago, the
[2:20:02]
music site Pitchfork said, "The two
[2:20:04]
albums you need to be listening to are
[2:20:07]
Beyonce's Renaissance and OKC's Chat
[2:20:10]
Pile."
[2:20:12]
I I mean that is incredible. That is
[2:20:16]
incredible. Especially because I met the
[2:20:18]
basis Austin when we were working at
[2:20:19]
Blockbuster Video back in 1999 to 2001,
[2:20:24]
right? When I was a closeted gay boy
[2:20:26]
wearing Abberrombie and Fitch and he was
[2:20:29]
a crust punk kid. So, you know, the fact
[2:20:31]
that that friendship has endured for a
[2:20:33]
quarter century is really special to me.
[2:20:35]
And as I was marching in the parade, I
[2:20:37]
found myself thinking about Classen
[2:20:39]
Boulevard, which is of course home to
[2:20:41]
OKC's uh historic Asian district. And as
[2:20:45]
I was thinking about Classen, I couldn't
[2:20:48]
help but remember, and I know this might
[2:20:49]
make some folk uncomfortable, but that's
[2:20:51]
okay. Um there was a former OKC mayor
[2:20:54]
who in 2001 removed the uh Pride banners
[2:20:57]
from Classen Boulevard. Um, and that was
[2:21:00]
the same year when I was 19 that I came
[2:21:02]
out to my mother, a retired RN who
[2:21:05]
actually took care of the first patient
[2:21:08]
uh here in OKC who had AIDS. Uh, at a
[2:21:11]
time when when some doctors wouldn't
[2:21:13]
even touch this young man, right? Um,
[2:21:17]
and so that was in 2001. That same year,
[2:21:20]
this city council, not us, but our
[2:21:23]
predecessors predecessors predecessors
[2:21:25]
voted 6 to3 to deny any banner permit
[2:21:30]
containing quote a political, religious,
[2:21:32]
or social advocacy message. And what was
[2:21:34]
strange about that was, and I'm having
[2:21:36]
to read from some notes here, since
[2:21:37]
1989, the city permitted groups to hang
[2:21:40]
banners from utility pole brackets,
[2:21:42]
including celebrating the Olympic, the
[2:21:44]
Oklahoma Olympic festival. So when they
[2:21:48]
removed the pride banners, the former
[2:21:50]
mayor explained that LGBTQ folk quote
[2:21:53]
have a right to behave that way if they
[2:21:56]
want to. Although some aspects of it are
[2:21:59]
illegal, quite frankly, I find it
[2:22:01]
offensive that we won't put up a
[2:22:03]
religious message, but we will put up an
[2:22:05]
irreligious message. The That's the end
[2:22:07]
of the quote. The Oklahoma editorial
[2:22:09]
board agreed and said, quote, "At least
[2:22:12]
the clan wasn't pushing a political
[2:22:14]
agenda on a sign."
[2:22:16]
End quote. So, remember, back then,
[2:22:19]
being gay was actually illegal in
[2:22:21]
Oklahoma. In fact, in most states,
[2:22:23]
punishable in Oklahoma with a 10-year
[2:22:25]
imprisonment until a 2003 US Supreme
[2:22:28]
Court decision ruled such laws
[2:22:30]
unconstitutional.
[2:22:32]
It's worth noting that during Germany's
[2:22:35]
1928 elections a 100red years ago, the
[2:22:38]
Nazis, who were the clan's white
[2:22:40]
supremacist counterparts, argued, quote,
[2:22:43]
"Anyone who even thinks of homosexual
[2:22:45]
love is our enemy. We reject anything
[2:22:49]
which emasculates our people and makes
[2:22:51]
it a play thing for our enemies, for we
[2:22:54]
know that life is a fight, and it's
[2:22:56]
madness to think that men will ever
[2:22:58]
embrace fraternally." End quote. The
[2:23:01]
Gestapo, we must remember, arrested
[2:23:03]
around 90,000 men for homosexual
[2:23:06]
activity between 1937 and 1939,
[2:23:10]
imprisoning 15,000 in concentration
[2:23:13]
camps under the infamous paragraph 175
[2:23:17]
law.
[2:23:18]
Nazi youth burned books, and those books
[2:23:22]
included Einstein's research and
[2:23:25]
transgender medical care research.
[2:23:31]
Thanks to a lawsuit from the ACLU and
[2:23:34]
former LGBT advocacy group Simron
[2:23:37]
Alliance, a judge found that the former
[2:23:40]
mayor and the council's actions were
[2:23:42]
unconstitutional.
[2:23:44]
Another note on the clan uh and the
[2:23:46]
Oklahoma's editorial board uh 25 years
[2:23:49]
ago that strikes me as silly because
[2:23:54]
that same paper in the 1920s had a
[2:23:57]
headline above the fold uh crowd knocked
[2:24:00]
cold by Ku Klux when tens of thousands
[2:24:03]
of clan members marched in downtown
[2:24:05]
Oklahoma City. We have to know our
[2:24:08]
history when we hear some of this
[2:24:09]
rhetoric today uh demonizing LGBT
[2:24:12]
people. we need to know where it comes
[2:24:14]
from.
[2:24:16]
So, as the first teacher and openly gay
[2:24:19]
person to ever serve on this council, uh
[2:24:22]
I'm honored to do the real work of Class
[2:24:25]
and Boulevard, which is with our Asian
[2:24:28]
district. It's always striking to me
[2:24:30]
people scapegoat queer people about
[2:24:31]
society's problems when the real
[2:24:33]
problems are streets that need
[2:24:36]
resurfaced, right, and sidewalks to
[2:24:38]
build. And that's why I'm excited to
[2:24:39]
steward an upcoming streetscape for the
[2:24:41]
area.
[2:24:43]
And uh similarly, we have a competitive
[2:24:47]
$975,000
[2:24:49]
federal grant that our city of OKC won,
[2:24:53]
right? And that's to uh study transit
[2:24:56]
oriented development on Classen. And
[2:24:58]
that's going to prioritize resurfacing
[2:25:01]
sidewalks, crosswalks, median and
[2:25:03]
lowincome affordable housing. Keeping in
[2:25:05]
mind that OKC's median income hovers
[2:25:08]
around $37,000 and that we're short. Too
[2:25:11]
many units for our people. This can
[2:25:13]
include mixeduse developments, bike
[2:25:15]
safety, trees, landscaping, and
[2:25:17]
architecture honoring uh our historic
[2:25:20]
Asian district and the nearby
[2:25:21]
neighborhoods. And I can't wait to march
[2:25:25]
with our Asian district who will march
[2:25:27]
for the first time in any pride parade
[2:25:30]
this year. And I'm signing up today to
[2:25:32]
do that with them. I asked them last
[2:25:33]
week. Um, a final note, Chap Pile. It is
[2:25:38]
incredible to see them in Tokyo and
[2:25:41]
Osaka. They're not rich.
[2:25:45]
They they quit their day jobs, but
[2:25:46]
they're making about the same money they
[2:25:48]
were then. They have no healthcare. We
[2:25:50]
have no benefits, right? But it is
[2:25:53]
incredible. OKC to see audiences in
[2:25:55]
Osaka and in Tokyo knowing the lyrics of
[2:26:00]
people from Oklahoma City. And to
[2:26:03]
conclude, those lyrics are often about
[2:26:07]
homelessness. They are out there
[2:26:09]
advocating,
[2:26:11]
advocating,
[2:26:13]
asking a simple question. Why? Why are
[2:26:16]
there people homeless on our streets?
[2:26:19]
We have the means. We have the
[2:26:21]
resources, they say in their lyrics. And
[2:26:24]
seeing people from across the world
[2:26:27]
knowing those lyrics and singing
[2:26:29]
alongside,
[2:26:31]
knowing they're representing us on the
[2:26:33]
world stage, that's incredible. That is
[2:26:35]
just incredible. And so I'm so proud of
[2:26:37]
this city and the people we are
[2:26:38]
producing. And uh just wanted to share
[2:26:41]
that history during Pride Month that
[2:26:43]
this council knows better. This council
[2:26:46]
does better. the city manager does
[2:26:48]
better, this mayor does better, and a
[2:26:50]
lot of us in this city know and do
[2:26:51]
better. And I just want to thank you all
[2:26:53]
this Pride Month for your uh love and
[2:26:55]
compassion. So, thank you.
[2:26:58]
» Ward four
[2:27:00]
six.
[2:27:01]
» Yes. Thank you for sharing that,
[2:27:03]
Councilman Cooper. Um yeah, I think it's
[2:27:06]
unfortunate when we sort of think, oh,
[2:27:08]
all that stuff was back then, but
[2:27:11]
recognizing that a lot of that rhetoric
[2:27:12]
continues today. um and the reasons why
[2:27:15]
we need things like pride celebrations
[2:27:17]
to to push back against it and um give
[2:27:21]
especially young people the opportunity
[2:27:23]
to um love who they are. Um I just want
[2:27:28]
to invite folks to participate if
[2:27:30]
they're um available on the 24th. I
[2:27:32]
think that's next Wednesday at noon. The
[2:27:35]
diversion hub um is having their ribbon
[2:27:38]
cutting. Um very exciting for their new
[2:27:40]
building over on Lynwood. Um, it was
[2:27:42]
supposed to be, I think, in May, but we
[2:27:45]
we had rain, really bad rain that week.
[2:27:47]
And so, um, it'll be next next Wednesday
[2:27:49]
at noon. Be a big fun celebration. Come
[2:27:52]
see their new building. It's really
[2:27:53]
beautiful. Um, and in their art, they've
[2:27:56]
been they've been in there for like a
[2:27:58]
month. I think they're ready to They're
[2:27:59]
like, "Why are we doing this now? We're
[2:28:01]
already off the ground uh uh doing all
[2:28:04]
our work, but an opportunity to
[2:28:06]
celebrate their staff and um and this
[2:28:07]
beautiful new space that um we partnered
[2:28:09]
with them on. So, hope you can join us.
[2:28:13]
» 47 48.
[2:28:16]
» I have some breaking news. I got it
[2:28:18]
about 5:30 this morning when I got my
[2:28:19]
newspaper. Um, on July 14th, next month
[2:28:24]
that it will be exactly two years before
[2:28:27]
the start of the Olympics. And LA28 just
[2:28:31]
announced that it's opening the portal
[2:28:32]
for volunteers. And that includes
[2:28:34]
volunteers in Oklahoma City that want to
[2:28:37]
participate in the Olympics. Those
[2:28:39]
events will run July 14th through the
[2:28:41]
29th. There's a great article in the
[2:28:43]
paper today by Jenny Carlson that
[2:28:45]
explains the process and the events that
[2:28:48]
we will be hosting. So, if you want to
[2:28:49]
be a volunteer, here's your chance.
[2:28:51]
Thank you.
[2:28:53]
» Thank you. Brings us to item 13, which
[2:28:56]
is citizens to be heard. As I call your
[2:28:59]
name, come up, state your name and
[2:29:00]
address, and you'll have three minutes,
[2:29:02]
and the lovely Miss Amy will let you
[2:29:04]
know when you have 30 seconds left. Uh
[2:29:07]
Dan Halber.
[2:29:18]
I'm Dan Helber. Uh 16317
[2:29:22]
Northwest or uh goodness gracious uh
[2:29:27]
Delmare Drive up in your ward board 7.
[2:29:29]
Um I'm a refugee from California. Um,
[2:29:32]
mayor, um, council members, um, I came
[2:29:35]
here three generation or three years ago
[2:29:37]
for freedom and for grandchildren, not
[2:29:40]
necessarily in that order.
[2:29:42]
Um, Benjamin Franklin wrote that, uh,
[2:29:44]
they can they that can give up essential
[2:29:47]
liberty to obtain a little temporary
[2:29:50]
safety deserve neither liberty nor
[2:29:53]
safety. Um, and I think that this
[2:29:55]
applies to the surveillance state.
[2:29:59]
Around the corner from my home in
[2:30:00]
Fairfield South neighborhood is an
[2:30:02]
unobtrusive black pole topped with a
[2:30:05]
solar panel and a camera. When I first
[2:30:08]
noticed it over a year ago, I thought,
[2:30:10]
"Oh, it's part of the system that
[2:30:11]
synchronized traffic lights to improve
[2:30:13]
the traffic flow east on 164th."
[2:30:17]
Then I learned about flock cameras. um
[2:30:20]
their item got moved to uh two weeks
[2:30:23]
from now. Okay. And the potential for
[2:30:26]
misuse. Uh Chairman Mao noted that the
[2:30:30]
people have sharp eyes. We don't need to
[2:30:33]
give big data a record exactly when I
[2:30:37]
leave for work each morning. Um feeding
[2:30:40]
that information in uh to update my
[2:30:43]
social credit score. Um, I do not
[2:30:45]
appreciate being surveiled in a
[2:30:48]
warrantless fashion. I would like that
[2:30:50]
camera and all of its friends uh taken
[2:30:54]
down. I would like OKC's contract with
[2:30:57]
Flock to to be terminated. Um, and I
[2:31:02]
would like to recommend that this
[2:31:04]
council think long and hard about
[2:31:06]
replacing that system with some sort of
[2:31:08]
flock 2.0.
[2:31:10]
Um, I'd like to thank Mr. Pennington for
[2:31:13]
coming to Mayflower. Um I will research
[2:31:16]
and remember his vote um in 28. Thank
[2:31:19]
you.
[2:31:23]
» Next is Lori Walke followed by Mari
[2:31:26]
Williams.
[2:31:33]
Good morning. I am Reverend Dr. Lorie
[2:31:34]
Walk, 5219 North Miller Place 73112, a
[2:31:38]
proud resident of W 2 and a local pastor
[2:31:41]
in the United Church of Christ. I along
[2:31:44]
with my clergy colleagues and fellow
[2:31:46]
citizens are here to urge you to not
[2:31:49]
renew Oklahoma City's contract with
[2:31:51]
Flock. When the city council first
[2:31:53]
collaborated with Flock three years ago
[2:31:56]
to install cameras along the routes that
[2:31:58]
we take to school and to church and to
[2:32:00]
urgent care and to the dentist and to
[2:32:02]
work and to the mall and to well
[2:32:04]
everywhere you probably thought it was a
[2:32:07]
sound decision and it would have been
[2:32:09]
hard to not think that it was a sound
[2:32:12]
decision to contract with Flock or any
[2:32:15]
other automated license plate reader
[2:32:17]
system. They make big promises about car
[2:32:21]
insurance, community safety, and crime
[2:32:24]
reduction. But in the last three years,
[2:32:26]
we've learned some things like how ALPRs
[2:32:29]
like Flock collect data on millions of
[2:32:32]
vehicles regardless of whether the
[2:32:34]
driver is suspected of a crime. How they
[2:32:36]
own and share that data at their
[2:32:38]
discretion. That the data from ALPRs
[2:32:42]
like Flock have led to wrongful arrests
[2:32:44]
and profiling and enabled police
[2:32:46]
officers to stalk their ex partners at a
[2:32:50]
rate that is alarming. And we also now
[2:32:52]
know that there is no substantial
[2:32:54]
evidence that ALPRs like Flock
[2:32:56]
effectively prevent crime. Indeed,
[2:32:59]
across America, local officials are
[2:33:01]
choosing to stop using these cameras
[2:33:03]
because of grounded fears of mass
[2:33:05]
surveillance and local data shared in
[2:33:07]
ways that devastate families and wider
[2:33:09]
communities and inevitably the local
[2:33:11]
economy.
[2:33:13]
It has been three years since the
[2:33:15]
council first collaborated with Flock.
[2:33:17]
And you didn't know what you didn't
[2:33:18]
know. But now you know from public
[2:33:20]
records and reports that surveillance
[2:33:23]
companies like Flock cannot be trusted.
[2:33:25]
Over 50 cities across more than 20
[2:33:27]
states have voted to deactivate, pause,
[2:33:29]
or entirely cancel their contract with
[2:33:32]
Flock because people everywhere are
[2:33:34]
asking hard questions. And it is time
[2:33:36]
for our city council to do the same. So,
[2:33:39]
as you consider whether to continue
[2:33:40]
collaborating with surveillance
[2:33:42]
companies like Flock, please know that
[2:33:45]
while you once may have thought they
[2:33:46]
were okay,
[2:33:49]
it's okay to change your mind. Show us
[2:33:55]
your courage. Leave flock behind.
[2:34:00]
Oh, it's okay.
[2:34:04]
Change your mind and you can join us.
[2:34:07]
Join us here anytime. Oh, louder
[2:34:10]
friends, it's okay to change your mind.
[2:34:16]
Show us your courage.
[2:34:19]
Leave flock behind.
[2:34:21]
Oh, it's okay to change your mind. And
[2:34:28]
you can join us. Join us here any
[2:34:32]
[singing] time.
[2:34:34]
May that be your earworm until you vote
[2:34:37]
to not renew that contract.
[2:34:43]
[applause]
[2:34:45]
» Mari Williams, followed by Stephanie
[2:34:47]
Berdine.
[2:34:52]
» My name is Mari Williams. I've lived in
[2:34:54]
the OKC metro for my entire life. I
[2:34:56]
currently reside in Ward 5. Good
[2:34:58]
morning, Mayor Holt, who's not here,
[2:35:00]
city manager Freeman, and members of the
[2:35:02]
Oklahoma City Council. This morning, I'd
[2:35:04]
like to go through some cases where
[2:35:06]
Flock and its AI cause irreparable harm
[2:35:08]
and often cost the cities using it money
[2:35:10]
for settlements. April of 2024 in
[2:35:12]
Toledo, Ohio, Flock misread the seven on
[2:35:15]
Brandon Upurch's truck as a two.
[2:35:17]
Officers drew guns. When he hesitated,
[2:35:20]
the K9 officer released the dog which
[2:35:22]
latched onto his dreadlocks, slammed his
[2:35:24]
head into the pavement, and bit his arm.
[2:35:27]
He was hospitalized in jail before
[2:35:29]
charges were dropped. Upurch lost
[2:35:31]
sensation in his finger, had to sell his
[2:35:33]
truck, was evicted, and rehomed his two
[2:35:36]
dogs out of fear. He settled his lawsuit
[2:35:38]
for $35,000.
[2:35:40]
June of 2025, JC and Carolyn Heron, plus
[2:35:44]
their three-year-old granddaughter,
[2:35:45]
Penelope, were driving in Morristown,
[2:35:47]
Tennessee. Flock confused their lovey
[2:35:49]
license plate, spelled with an O, with a
[2:35:51]
recovered stolen trucks that spelled it
[2:35:53]
with a zero. Guns were drawn.
[2:35:56]
Grandparents were handcuffed in front
[2:35:57]
handcuffed while their terrified
[2:35:59]
granddaughter cried alone in the back
[2:36:01]
seat. They were cleared only after a VIN
[2:36:03]
check. April 2021, Athetherton,
[2:36:06]
California. Flock read an H as an M.
[2:36:09]
Jason Berkell was stopped at gunpoint,
[2:36:10]
ordered to the ground, and handcuffed.
[2:36:13]
This the lawsuit settled for $45,000.
[2:36:16]
The department admitted the camera
[2:36:17]
misread the plate. July 2023, Espanola,
[2:36:20]
New Mexico. Jacqueline Gonzalez and her
[2:36:22]
12-year-old si sister were driving when
[2:36:24]
Flock flagged their Kia after reading A2
[2:36:27]
as a seven. Both were ordered out at
[2:36:30]
gunpoint and handcuffed. Yes, including
[2:36:32]
the 12-year-old little girl. Body cam
[2:36:34]
footage captured the girl pleading,
[2:36:36]
quote, "Can you call my mom?" Family
[2:36:39]
settled the lawsuit in 2025. September
[2:36:42]
2025, Bowar, Colorado. Flock cameras
[2:36:45]
tracked Christian's truck passing
[2:36:47]
through Bowar. A sergeant used that data
[2:36:49]
plus doorbell footage to falsely accuse
[2:36:52]
her of stealing a $25 package. She had
[2:36:54]
to spend days gathering her own dash cam
[2:36:56]
footage, Google location history, and
[2:36:58]
ring video to prove her innocence.
[2:37:00]
Summons voided and the officer was
[2:37:02]
disciplined. February 2026, Sherwood,
[2:37:05]
Arkansas. A mother would a mother was
[2:37:07]
driving with her young children when
[2:37:09]
Flock misread their car's plate due to a
[2:37:11]
loose loose or broken frame. Misreading
[2:37:14]
an X as a Y. Full felony stop was
[2:37:17]
conducted with guns drawn. Parents were
[2:37:19]
handcuffed in front of their kids.
[2:37:21]
Cleared only after an investigation. The
[2:37:23]
officer was ordered to receive
[2:37:25]
» Remaining.
[2:37:26]
» Thank you. was ordered to receive
[2:37:27]
additional training. And in February
[2:37:29]
2026, a Milwaukee police officer was
[2:37:32]
criminally charged after using Flock to
[2:37:34]
stalk her romantic partner, running her
[2:37:36]
plate 124 times and her ex's 55 times in
[2:37:41]
the span of two months. Please end all
[2:37:43]
contracts with Flock. Thank you.
[2:37:51]
Stephanie Berdine followed by Elizabeth
[2:37:53]
Droo.
[2:37:57]
Good morning. Stephanie Berdine, 515
[2:37:59]
Maple, Yukon, Oklahoma. I am here
[2:38:03]
because even though I'm a Yukon citizen,
[2:38:05]
I live in Canadian County and Oklahoma
[2:38:09]
City is the largest municipality in
[2:38:12]
Canadian County. And in the next few
[2:38:15]
meetings, you all are going to be voting
[2:38:18]
on some issues, PUD 21105 and 2124 that
[2:38:24]
are in Miss's district. And
[2:38:26]
unfortunately, she's left and can't hear
[2:38:28]
me. Um, but those items are going to
[2:38:32]
allow reszoning for hyperscale data
[2:38:35]
centers. Right now, you all aren't
[2:38:38]
getting any attention. Yukon is, Luther
[2:38:42]
is, Piedmont is, but the largest
[2:38:46]
data center out of all those will be in
[2:38:49]
your city limits over 300 acres and
[2:38:53]
everybody's saying that's the Yukon data
[2:38:55]
center.
[2:38:57]
Well, this meeting has been kind of
[2:38:59]
enlightening because I wasn't expecting
[2:39:01]
to hear other Canadian county residents
[2:39:05]
concerns over your all's actions that
[2:39:08]
left here quite heartbroken and unhappy.
[2:39:10]
I remember when Highway 4 was just a
[2:39:13]
two-lane road and it was rural and there
[2:39:17]
are no Mr. Cooper, for your information,
[2:39:19]
there are no things between 44th and
[2:39:22]
59th that are mostly it's mostly
[2:39:25]
residential. But anyway, back to my
[2:39:27]
subject.
[2:39:30]
This is a hypers scale data center.
[2:39:34]
Do you all really want to be responsible
[2:39:39]
to be the city west of the Mississippi
[2:39:42]
that's encouraging this? Because the
[2:39:44]
land south on Frisco Road where this
[2:39:46]
will be in your city limits, the other
[2:39:50]
data center companies, the LLC's are
[2:39:53]
buying or out purchasing land to where
[2:39:57]
there could be a thousand acres of data
[2:40:00]
center just on Frisco Road. Um, entering
[2:40:05]
from the west,
[2:40:07]
that's what people are going to see.
[2:40:09]
Data centers, not the prettiness of the
[2:40:13]
prairie and amber waves of grain, just
[2:40:16]
ugly metal, stone, concrete buildings.
[2:40:21]
And I really wish you all would consider
[2:40:25]
your all's actions to citizens
[2:40:28]
» 30 seconds
[2:40:29]
» That are that live right next to your
[2:40:32]
city limits. I know I pay as much in
[2:40:35]
sales taxes residents of Oklahoma City.
[2:40:37]
And I love this city. I am a volunteer.
[2:40:40]
I've already signed up to volunteer for
[2:40:42]
the Olympics. I give tours at the art
[2:40:44]
museum to students from all over this
[2:40:47]
state. I love Oklahoma City just as much
[2:40:50]
as I love Yukon. And I wish you all
[2:40:52]
would show your love to your neighbors.
[2:40:54]
Thank you.
[2:40:59]
Elizabeth Drew, followed by Cole McAfee.
[2:41:10]
[clears throat]
[2:41:11]
» Hello. Um, my name is Elizabeth Drew.
[2:41:14]
I'm here uh just for myself talking
[2:41:16]
against ALPRs. Uh to the counselors who
[2:41:19]
are not yet picking up what we're
[2:41:20]
putting down. First, I want you to think
[2:41:22]
about all your neighbors and all your
[2:41:24]
constituents. And I want you to think
[2:41:25]
about what your level of trust is for
[2:41:27]
them. They voted for you. You live next
[2:41:29]
to them. That you they don't have a
[2:41:31]
dossier on you. They don't pry into your
[2:41:34]
personal lives. They respect that you
[2:41:36]
deserve the same considerations they do.
[2:41:39]
And then I want you to consider why the
[2:41:40]
writers of sci-fi have long pointed to
[2:41:43]
larger agencies manipulating large
[2:41:45]
amounts of people with mass
[2:41:46]
surveillance.
[2:41:48]
Agencies which are not emotionally
[2:41:49]
driven by the duty of proximity
[2:41:52]
knowledge of each other. Locality. These
[2:41:55]
agencies are driven by the emotions of
[2:41:57]
very few individuals. Very rich
[2:41:59]
individuals basically have trust
[2:42:01]
problems. They exist because of trust
[2:42:04]
problems. How do you build trust? the
[2:42:07]
opposite of what ALPRs do. You learn
[2:42:09]
what hurts, you forgive, you find the
[2:42:11]
way. You're grateful for the experience,
[2:42:13]
and you lean into that. You see the
[2:42:16]
cycle, and you break it. Please break
[2:42:20]
this cycle brought on to us by a very
[2:42:23]
few individuals with trust issues.
[2:42:26]
When it comes up, you may have a room
[2:42:28]
full of people hired to tell you
[2:42:29]
otherwise. So, I'm saying it now. Please
[2:42:32]
at that time vote against any further
[2:42:35]
AOPR contracts. If we can hold trust in
[2:42:38]
our hearts, that's beautiful. Thank you,
[2:42:46]
[clears throat]
[2:42:46]
» Cole McAfee followed by Solless Evans.
[2:42:55]
» Hi, my name is Cole McAfee and I'm a
[2:42:56]
resident homeowner in W 6. I wanted to
[2:42:59]
talk to you today ahead of the city
[2:43:01]
contract renewal vote with the automatic
[2:43:03]
license plate reader vendor flock about
[2:43:05]
what the real impact of this invasion of
[2:43:07]
privacy looks like. Back in 2019, my job
[2:43:10]
involved increasing transparency work
[2:43:12]
around the district attorneys council
[2:43:14]
and Oklahoma district attorneys
[2:43:15]
association.
[2:43:17]
When I started attending the meetings of
[2:43:19]
the one body that is public, the
[2:43:22]
district attorneys made it clear they
[2:43:23]
did not welcome me. One of the points of
[2:43:26]
discussion in those meetings was the
[2:43:27]
launch of the uninsured vehicle
[2:43:29]
enforcement diversion program or UVED.
[2:43:32]
This program launched automatic license
[2:43:34]
plate readers on traveling trailers as
[2:43:35]
well as in fixed locations across the
[2:43:38]
state and throughout Oklahoma City in
[2:43:40]
collaboration with OG&E.
[2:43:42]
During the time I was engaged in
[2:43:43]
transparency efforts, I began to receive
[2:43:46]
UVED notices despite my vehicle being
[2:43:47]
insured.
[2:43:49]
In each of these, which I had to spend
[2:43:51]
several hours of phone tag to resolve, I
[2:43:53]
received a notice with a different photo
[2:43:55]
of me in my car, the automatic license
[2:43:58]
plate reader had captured uh along with
[2:44:01]
the threat that I either pay the UVED
[2:44:04]
program $174 or show proof of insurance.
[2:44:09]
pictures of me on my way to work,
[2:44:11]
outside of my doctor's office, near my
[2:44:13]
home, a terrifying invasion of my
[2:44:16]
privacy and capturing of my life without
[2:44:18]
any wrongdoing on my part. It only
[2:44:21]
stopped when media started a first round
[2:44:23]
of coverage on all of the wrongful
[2:44:24]
letters being sent by UVED.
[2:44:27]
That's just one example of what the
[2:44:28]
invasive nature of these tools looks
[2:44:30]
like. Your contract with Flock and the
[2:44:32]
use of automatic license plate readers
[2:44:34]
exposes all Oklahoma City residents and
[2:44:37]
people who move through our city to this
[2:44:38]
invasive cataloging of our political
[2:44:41]
beliefs, of where we travel, of our
[2:44:43]
medical conditions, of who we meet with,
[2:44:46]
of our daily lives. Gathering this
[2:44:49]
information should require at minimum a
[2:44:51]
warrant.
[2:44:54]
The mass surveillance program threatens
[2:44:56]
our collective privacy. Please do not
[2:44:59]
renew the contract with Flock or with
[2:45:01]
other automatic license plate reader
[2:45:03]
vendors. Thank you.
[2:45:10]
Solus Evans, followed by Steve Hunt.
[2:45:22]
» Good morning. Uh my name is Solus Evans.
[2:45:24]
I live at 2822 North Hudson Avenue. a
[2:45:27]
resident of W 2. Um I'm a disabled
[2:45:30]
veteran and the director of community
[2:45:32]
for freedom Oklahoma. I'm just here to
[2:45:34]
uplift what all the others have said
[2:45:36]
about ending the flock contract um and
[2:45:38]
remind you that it's a violation of our
[2:45:40]
fourth amendment uh rights and that you
[2:45:43]
all should not renew the contract and
[2:45:45]
any AAL uh PRs um in the future. So,
[2:45:49]
thank you.
[2:45:55]
» Steve Hunt, followed by William Lee.
[2:46:01]
» Is there any way we can do that 30
[2:46:02]
minute thing for real this time? No.
[2:46:04]
» No,
[2:46:05]
he accidentally said 30 minutes last
[2:46:07]
time. Um, okay. So, I'm Steve Hunt, 6300
[2:46:10]
Westby Drive. Well, there's a lot going
[2:46:11]
on today. Um, I appreciate all the folks
[2:46:14]
coming to talk about Flock and I would
[2:46:16]
certainly like to encourage them to look
[2:46:18]
at Granicus, the uh, private equity
[2:46:21]
owned firm that does Prime Gov. In 2018,
[2:46:23]
the city approved a $53,000 a year
[2:46:27]
contract with uh, Primev, who was then
[2:46:29]
in 2021 bought by a private equity firm
[2:46:32]
backed by Stratam and then purchased by
[2:46:35]
Granicus. Now, the city's contract is
[2:46:37]
$300,000, a 600% increase in the fee
[2:46:40]
that we pay them. Although it is for a
[2:46:42]
suite, it's basically the same thing.
[2:46:44]
And they're extracting a lot of data
[2:46:46]
from uh citizens. When you submit a
[2:46:48]
request to the city, it goes through
[2:46:49]
Granicus and they're using that data all
[2:46:52]
over the country. Um it's basically what
[2:46:55]
Hannah Erin talked about in Ikeman and
[2:46:57]
Jerusalem, the benality of evil. It's
[2:46:59]
easy to be against flock, the foaming at
[2:47:02]
the mouth, you know, technological pan
[2:47:05]
ponopticon, but the cumulus, I'm sorry,
[2:47:09]
the uh granica stuff is just as serious
[2:47:12]
and I'd like people to look at that.
[2:47:13]
Okay, so some of y'all remember uh back
[2:47:15]
in December, I came and spoke about the
[2:47:17]
television uh broadcast for the Thunder
[2:47:21]
and how they were possibly going to go
[2:47:23]
insolvent. They have since become
[2:47:25]
insolvent.
[2:47:26]
uh they thought that they could get all
[2:47:29]
the debt, get the uh asset, and then
[2:47:31]
sell once the insolveny approached, but
[2:47:34]
it was such a train wreck that it's now
[2:47:37]
over.
[2:47:39]
And um the reason I bring that up, the
[2:47:41]
identical corporate rot is playing out
[2:47:43]
right now on the radio side. Cumulus
[2:47:45]
radio that does the thunder broadcasts
[2:47:49]
filed for chapter 22. That's a joke
[2:47:51]
phrase for filing chapter 11 for the
[2:47:54]
second time. um they put forth a $53
[2:47:57]
million IBIDA with $65 million in debt
[2:48:01]
interest services.
[2:48:03]
So the creditors are taking over the
[2:48:07]
radio side that does the Thunder
[2:48:09]
broadcasts and they're the reason that
[2:48:11]
it exists in the first place. And y'all
[2:48:13]
might know in 2008 2009 I was here
[2:48:16]
pleading with the council to give the
[2:48:18]
broadcast rights to Perry Broadcasting
[2:48:20]
and I met with Russell Perry numerous
[2:48:22]
times about it. He was like, you know,
[2:48:24]
Steve, thanks so much for doing this.
[2:48:26]
They don't care. And they don't because
[2:48:28]
the reason is that Klay Bennett gets
[2:48:30]
paid regardless.
[2:48:31]
» 30 seconds.
[2:48:32]
» They're filing for Chapter 11. And one
[2:48:34]
reason that they've been able to remain
[2:48:36]
relevant is that they have the contract.
[2:48:38]
And Klay Bennett and Pro Basketball
[2:48:40]
LLC's gets paid regardless. So, we don't
[2:48:44]
know who's going to be owning Cumulus in
[2:48:46]
the future because their SEC filing does
[2:48:48]
not mention it. But it's time to get
[2:48:51]
serious about the Thunder and the
[2:48:54]
community that loves them and the fact
[2:48:56]
that
[2:48:58]
non-American groups and non, you know,
[2:49:01]
Oklahoma groups are running the show.
[2:49:04]
So, I just wanted to bring that up.
[2:49:05]
There's a lot uh wanted to talk about
[2:49:07]
Union Station and all that, but maybe
[2:49:10]
next time. Thanks,
[2:49:14]
» Brady Harold,
[2:49:17]
followed by Joshua Higinbot.
[2:49:28]
Hello, my name is Brady Harrell. I live
[2:49:30]
at 424 Colbrook Drive and I'm just here
[2:49:34]
to um encourage the city council to end
[2:49:38]
its flock contract like a lot of other
[2:49:40]
uh of our neighbors here today. But I
[2:49:43]
thought I'd do so by sharing a few uh
[2:49:45]
facts about uh Flock and uh uh why I
[2:49:50]
think that it would be a good idea for
[2:49:53]
us to end our uh city's relationship
[2:49:56]
with them. Uh so uh first off, it's uh
[2:50:00]
uh pretty widely accepted that uh
[2:50:02]
Oklahoma City for some time has had
[2:50:04]
around 90 or uh just above uh flock
[2:50:08]
cameras in the area. That's what we
[2:50:10]
actually saw recently at a uh flock town
[2:50:14]
hall that some of our city council
[2:50:16]
members actually had the opportunity to
[2:50:18]
speak at. But if you actually go and
[2:50:20]
check uh the number of flock cameras in
[2:50:23]
the actual metro area has increased
[2:50:25]
significantly to the point where it's
[2:50:27]
almost uh entirely blocked out on maps
[2:50:31]
if you ever actually go to check for it.
[2:50:34]
uh leaving uh in with increases in the
[2:50:37]
dozens in certain areas. Um I'd also
[2:50:41]
like to make a note about uh
[2:50:43]
specifically a type of uh camera that
[2:50:46]
has beencome uh much more recognized in
[2:50:49]
the Oklahoma metro area called the
[2:50:51]
Condor [snorts] camera. It looks a
[2:50:52]
little bit like this. It is a uh uh inc
[2:50:56]
it is an increased level of
[2:50:58]
surveillance. It has a in uh built-in
[2:51:00]
tracking technology that allows for the
[2:51:03]
camera to actually move and rotate uh
[2:51:06]
around any facility. And it usually is
[2:51:09]
seen on top of one of these large solar
[2:51:11]
panel devices that allow for them to be
[2:51:14]
uh transported to different areas with
[2:51:17]
relative ease. So they don't have to be
[2:51:19]
attached to a particular pole or
[2:51:21]
neighborhood and can just be dropped in
[2:51:24]
different areas.
[2:51:27]
block uh cameras are capable of
[2:51:29]
recording
[2:51:31]
uh up to uh 14 different uh photos and
[2:51:36]
uh videos at any given moment.
[2:51:40]
And because of that, they uh pose a
[2:51:42]
great risk to uh overexposing members of
[2:51:46]
our community uh as a privacy violation.
[2:51:51]
Not to mention the recent addition that
[2:51:53]
a lot of flock cameras have seen to
[2:51:56]
their uh equipment uh with an additional
[2:51:59]
microphone.
[2:52:00]
» 30 seconds remaining.
[2:52:01]
» Thank you. With an additional microphone
[2:52:03]
implement that uh as advertised is meant
[2:52:07]
to uh help document if perhaps a gunshot
[2:52:11]
or a cry for help is uh heard in the
[2:52:14]
area. But it could absolutely be abused
[2:52:17]
as a violation of privacy with uh people
[2:52:20]
just walking around in these areas near
[2:52:22]
these cameras being listened in on.
[2:52:26]
Uh I think that it's very unfortunate
[2:52:30]
that we've uh had a contract at all and
[2:52:33]
would encourage you to please end our
[2:52:35]
contract with the flock system. Thank
[2:52:37]
you for your time.
[2:52:40]
William Lee
[2:52:47]
going once.
[2:52:51]
Joshua Higen.
[2:53:08]
» Good morning, y'all.
[2:53:10]
My name is Josh Aken botham. I live in
[2:53:12]
the seventh ward and I'm speaking behalf
[2:53:15]
of Oklahoma's for privacy today about
[2:53:17]
the proposed renewal of the city's
[2:53:19]
contract with flock safety. Over 800
[2:53:22]
people have already signed petition
[2:53:24]
since we launched it at the end of May,
[2:53:26]
demanding Oklahoma City not renew its
[2:53:28]
contract with flock safety.
[2:53:31]
Flocks automated license plate readers
[2:53:34]
do more than capture images of vehicles.
[2:53:36]
They create a searchable database
[2:53:38]
accessible to police departments across
[2:53:40]
the nation as well as federal agencies
[2:53:42]
and any third-party Flock deems in its
[2:53:45]
interest to give access to. Flock can
[2:53:48]
and does collect and track data on which
[2:53:52]
houses of worship you visit, your
[2:53:54]
medical appointments, political events
[2:53:56]
you attend, and even which gun shows you
[2:53:59]
happen to show up at. Over time, this
[2:54:02]
can reveal deeply personal information
[2:54:03]
about people's lives, especially with
[2:54:05]
the 60-day data retention period
[2:54:07]
Oklahoma City currently has. Single
[2:54:10]
camera hit can tell a little bit about a
[2:54:13]
person, but months of records can paint
[2:54:15]
a detailed picture, their daily
[2:54:17]
routines, beliefs, relationships, and
[2:54:19]
activities. Long retention periods allow
[2:54:22]
flock to maintain a historical record
[2:54:24]
where people have traveled even when
[2:54:26]
they haven't done anything wrong. This
[2:54:28]
is why we're asking for a retention
[2:54:29]
period of no longer than 24 hours with
[2:54:31]
the permanent deletion of data unless
[2:54:34]
otherwise required by law. Oklahoma City
[2:54:37]
residents should not have their travel
[2:54:39]
history accessible to police
[2:54:40]
departments, federal agencies, and
[2:54:42]
anonymous third parties. Nor should this
[2:54:45]
system be used to create expansive watch
[2:54:47]
lists or facilitate broad surveillance
[2:54:49]
unrelated to specific criminal
[2:54:50]
investigations.
[2:54:52]
Lawful criminal investigations, as far
[2:54:54]
as I know, generally start with probable
[2:54:56]
cause. Call me oldfashioned, but driving
[2:54:58]
a car on a city street does not
[2:55:00]
constitute probable cause.
[2:55:03]
Bottom line, time and again, Flock has
[2:55:05]
misled the public and government
[2:55:07]
officials in cities across the nation.
[2:55:09]
In fact, they're so little trusted
[2:55:12]
cities like Dayton, Ohio, Evston,
[2:55:14]
Illinois, and Dayton County, Wisconsin,
[2:55:18]
that they have felt the need to put
[2:55:19]
black trash bags over those cameras to
[2:55:22]
keep people from being tracked and flock
[2:55:25]
collecting the data even after the
[2:55:27]
cities themselves ended the contracts
[2:55:29]
with the company.
[2:55:31]
Trusted city officials do not conduct
[2:55:34]
the people's business with untrustworthy
[2:55:36]
companies. For that reason, we're asking
[2:55:38]
the council to reject this contract
[2:55:40]
renewal and terminate the city's
[2:55:42]
relationship with flock safety as soon
[2:55:44]
as possible and until that contract is
[2:55:47]
terminated, place guardrails on data
[2:55:49]
retention no more than 24 hours and
[2:55:52]
strict limits on data sharing with
[2:55:54]
agencies outside of Oklahoma. Over 50
[2:55:56]
cities, as already mentioned, in over 20
[2:55:59]
states have deactivated, paused, or
[2:56:01]
entirely canceled their contracts with
[2:56:03]
lock safety. And it is time for this
[2:56:05]
council to put the interests of Oklahoma
[2:56:06]
City residents first. So, we urge you to
[2:56:09]
reject this renewal. Thank you kindly
[2:56:11]
for your time and consideration.
[2:56:24]
Excuse me. William Lee. One more time.
[2:56:26]
One more time.
[2:56:28]
Going. Going. Gone. Ronnie Kirk.
[2:56:54]
My name is Ronnie Kirk.
[2:56:57]
My address is 2328 North Missouri.
[2:57:01]
Mr. Pendleton, thank you for coming
[2:57:04]
Saturday to the event at Memorial Park.
[2:57:09]
No, everybody knows there was city
[2:57:11]
council,
[2:57:12]
but half the people and most of the
[2:57:14]
black people don't know how to use the
[2:57:17]
city council. Everybody complain, but
[2:57:20]
they won't go to the city council to
[2:57:22]
make a complaint. So I took the time to
[2:57:25]
explain them how to go about doing that
[2:57:28]
to get more to start coming.
[2:57:32]
Inside that [clears throat]
[2:57:34]
newspaper there's an article about me.
[2:57:37]
There's also an article that fly.
[2:57:42]
I've been over 50 city council meetings.
[2:57:46]
That's what's on that fly.
[2:57:49]
It's honor to me to be here
[2:57:52]
on a holiday
[2:57:55]
that I started in Oklahoma.
[2:57:58]
I started June 10, June 17, 1970.
[2:58:03]
So, I'm honored to get my roses where
[2:58:07]
I'm living instead of after I'm gone.
[2:58:11]
And I want to say thanks to Mr. Wade
[2:58:14]
Gley.
[2:58:17]
Before there was the thunders,
[2:58:20]
there was way garland police chief.
[2:58:23]
I went to Spring Lake Park Division.
[2:58:27]
Wrote him a letter.
[2:58:29]
Didn't have to call and I said, "Well,
[2:58:32]
you send some police out to play
[2:58:34]
basketball with these kids on northeast
[2:58:36]
side of town to make it a little more
[2:58:38]
community friendly and police friendly."
[2:58:42]
They showed up.
[2:58:44]
They played basketball for 4 hours. As
[2:58:48]
they shift change or they got a break,
[2:58:51]
Mr. Gar made sure they were there for 4
[2:58:54]
hours.
[2:58:56]
So, I want to say thanks to the city.
[2:58:59]
Thanks to y'all. We steady going
[2:59:01]
forward. We're not going backwards.
[2:59:04]
So, I want to say thank y'all for what
[2:59:06]
y'all doing. And let the bar know the
[2:59:09]
city is beautiful.
[2:59:11]
There's more things he got planned for
[2:59:13]
us, too. And I want to say thank y'all.
[2:59:16]
» Thank you, Mr. Kirk.
[2:59:19]
Uh, we're going to recess for executive
[2:59:21]
session. We'll be back.
[3:23:44]
And we are journed.
[3:23:46]
And we are German.