Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[0:54]
Council meeting for May 10, 2005, will come to order it as the first call to roll.
[0:58]
Council member Peters, Deputy Mayor of Kent, Council member Atkins, Council member Young, Council member
[1:05]
Mainchine, Council member Frey, Council member Medaffer, Council member Inzuna, Mayor Murphy.
[1:11]
Here.
[1:14]
All right, ladies and gentlemen, we'll, let me tell you the order that I think we'll go in, although it's
[1:20]
subject to everybody's availability.
[1:24]
The intention would be to go to non-agenda public comment,
[1:28]
then go to all of the matters that are on our agenda today
[1:32]
that don't have any controversy.
[1:36]
Then go probably back to the budget items that we
[1:41]
trail from yesterday, Fire and Environmental Services.
[1:45]
Then I go to the controversial matters this afternoon and finally end with the close session
[1:53]
matters that we never got to yesterday.
[1:56]
That's generally the way I intend to proceed.
[2:00]
We may have to modify that as we go along so people understand.
[2:04]
So I would hope that we could get to the fire budget this morning, but I doubt if we're going
[2:10]
get their, you know, we're going to need to take a little time and not agenda public comment
[2:16]
and other matters first.
[2:18]
So going to not agenda public comment, this is a time for people to have an opportunity
[2:25]
to discuss with the council or to tell the council, their position on issues that are within
[2:32]
the jurisdiction of the city that are not on our agenda today.
[2:35]
people are limited to three minutes per subject. We'll start with Linda Smith followed by Rick Skinner.
[2:45]
And when you're called to be on deck, I'd actually come sit in the front so that in the front
[2:50]
rows so that you can be available when your name is called. Good morning, Mr. Mayor. I'm a member of
[2:58]
the council. The first thing I want to do is apologize for my behavior in this council in the past.
[3:05]
And I also like to apologize to Mr. Mindshine because I made the vote for my comments.
[3:10]
I, a lot of things have happened, some really wonderful things have happened, but I also owe Michelle Nichols Jordan and Apology, because she's, I feel that she's as good as the head of the Department of Streets, Mr. Sierra, Michelle Nichols Jordan really works for the physically challenge, and I said that she said that she didn't know anything.
[3:35]
Mr. Jordan knows a lot, but he said she wanted no more about outdoor issues.
[3:42]
And the issues at the uptown shopping center are so deplorable that they should be addressed
[3:48]
and I'd ask Council to ask Mr. Jordan to have a cup of coffee with me if possible.
[3:54]
Because it's a disaster over there.
[3:56]
And I would also like to apologize for my behavior with San Diego Police Department.
[4:01]
In some ways, I've been more of a wealth and strength than the north end of the Mule,
[4:06]
going south when I wanted to go east and west.
[4:08]
And Mr. Mayor, I know that you were forced to talk about appropriate behavior, and I'm sorry about that.
[4:14]
But now I would like to go to a couple of issues on the budget.
[4:18]
I feel that parks and recreation needs like 48, possibly 48 hours during the summer,
[4:25]
But during the winter, if they had three or four hours a day for the kids after school and three or
[4:33]
off hours a day on Saturday, I believe that that would equal less than 40 hours a week
[4:39]
year round and the libraries I feel should be open the same numbers of hours on Saturday
[4:48]
as they are now on Sunday and it would be a little more than you were going for.
[4:54]
And, of course, I'm concerned neighborhood code compliance can be cost effective.
[5:00]
If, in addition to having a re-inspection fee, if there found to be inappropriate that she'd have the original inspection fee and penalty fees, now, if, you know, neighborhood code compliance can be cost-effective if there are fines and penalty assessments. I'm sorry, but you know, if you're doing the way with neighborhood code compliance.
[5:29]
You're doing the city of the service.
[5:32]
Now, I'd like to get into something that is very near and dear to my heart.
[5:37]
I would like District 3 to talk to Mr. Price about supported independent living, and I would
[5:44]
like the city to direct the police department to do a cost benefit analysis of supported
[5:52]
And it depends on living facilities attached to model neighborhood clubhouses.
[5:58]
May I have a second, Mr. Mayor?
[6:00]
One sentence, Mr. Smith, we've got a very, very long time today. What sentence?
[6:05]
It would be more cost effective than it is today.
[6:09]
If we had supported independent living attached to neighborhood clubhouses,
[6:14]
but it would depend on the benefit cost analysis.
[6:17]
Thank you.
[6:19]
Rick Skinner, followed by Sandy Summers.
[6:27]
Good morning, Mayor Murphy, City Council members, ladies and gentlemen, I'm Rick Skinner, and I live at 6965
[6:34]
Windows Avenue in University City.
[6:37]
I wrote the mayor and all city council members a letter regarding the specifics of this back in early 2002.
[6:43]
On November 25, 2001, I was falsely arrested by the San Diego Police Department for delaying a police officer in the performance of his duties.
[6:51]
I was charged with that misdemeanor after being handcuffed in the back of police car for over two and a half hours.
[6:58]
Because the arrest for trespassing in my residence was false in the police knew it.
[7:05]
On November 24th I was in an argument with my fiance and she called the police. There was no crime so the police left.
[7:13]
The following day our neighbor got involved to his volunteer police officer and called her boss Sergeant Nellaboth at home.
[7:19]
Sergeant Nullabov sent the police to arrest me and he advised my fiance to write a note to vacate the premises or be arrested for trespassing.
[7:28]
The police dropped the trespassing allegation with the new from the beginning was false.
[7:34]
But charged me for delaying the police officer in the performance of his duties because I was reluctant to open the door to be false to the arrested.
[7:42]
As citizens of the United States, we have the right to a fair trial.
[7:45]
We have the right to call witnesses and we have the right to present evidence.
[7:50]
In my trial, the City Attorney's Office makes sure that all of these rights were denied.
[7:56]
I know I don't have so much time, so I'm going to make a few suggestions.
[8:01]
Police officers with a personal interest in a situation ought to be excluded from the decision
[8:06]
making on an arrest, especially with their when they're at home and on vacation.
[8:10]
Some police officers have no contact with the rescued maids, in this case the two had
[8:16]
lunch shortly after the rest is a thank you.
[8:20]
It was conveyed that Sergeant Neliboff was smitten with my fiance and a bad marriage.
[8:26]
The city should consider how to fairly prosecute people alleging a false arrest, the city
[8:31]
by getting a false conviction absolves itself from liability.
[8:40]
Please think about the resources the city has to bear against the citizen that has been
[8:44]
arrested. The prosecutor in this case told the jury that I threw my fiance down the stairs.
[8:52]
Tracy Rogers, the prosecutor, made that up to prejudice the jury. There was no truth in that
[8:57]
statement to the jury. If I had pled guilty to disturbing the piece, it was offered to wave any
[9:04]
penalty except probation for pleading not guilty. I spent 14 days in jail and paid $27,000 to
[9:11]
to cover $270,000 bail, again on a misdemeanor.
[9:15]
Plitting not guilty when you're not guilty should not be a crime.
[9:20]
I ask each of you to look into this personally and admit that it could not happen to you
[9:24]
because of the power that you have.
[9:26]
You have an obligation to make sure that it doesn't happen to anyone else.
[9:30]
This is one sentence.
[9:32]
Thank you.
[9:33]
Thank you, sir.
[9:35]
The people of this great city are getting a view of what goes on and I think changes coming.
[9:39]
I want to be part of the solution and I believe that Mr. Gary is part of the solution.
[9:45]
Thank you.
[9:47]
Sandy Summers followed by no new deck.
[9:51]
Good morning, Mr. Murphy. What up, Slim?
[9:56]
This is up, San Diego. It's time to wake up.
[10:00]
Meet the future because the future is here. The record is my witness. Last week before I was so rudely interrupted
[10:06]
by the 7th District Council seat, I was explaining to the most honorable council that we will not
[10:12]
tolerate in subordination from our elected public servants under any circumstances. It is a bad idea
[10:19]
under the best of conditions and especially detrimental during times of transition like these. That being said,
[10:25]
I will follow Ms. Fry's lead, and welcome Jerry Sanders, whom we have dubbed Jackimo Jerry
[10:31]
to the race.
[10:33]
Moms and dads, boys and girls, let me tell you about Jackimo Jerry.
[10:37]
The record will show that from 1993 to 1999, while Jackimo Jerry was chief of police, he and
[10:43]
the rank and file of San Diego's finest, not only put me through the best drill and ceremony
[10:48]
money he could never buy, they led me to Hurricane Bonnie the Boot.
[10:53]
It shouldn't take a rocket scientist to figure out
[10:55]
I most likely would not have crossed her path without them.
[11:00]
I had a dream that Hurricane Bonnie and I had worked together in a past
[11:04]
incarnation when we lived in Holland.
[11:08]
I was the little Dutch boy who stuck his finger in the dark while Bonnie came
[11:11]
with the rest of the village and the town was saved.
[11:15]
For the record, any astute observer that has spent as much time in the
[11:23]
House, listening to all the mixed conversations from the men and women in blue, coming and going through the years could only draw one conclusion.
[11:32]
That would be that. If our elected officials and their appointments were as honest and willing to serve all of the people as the rank and file of the San Diego police are,
[11:43]
we would not be in the mess we are in today. Don't be fooled by the bad press they have received at times over an emotional or sensational story.
[11:51]
What happens is the police are on the front line of the comic boil that erupts in various elements of society
[11:58]
and end up holding this motion gun and the line of duty more than anyone would like, especially the bad guys.
[12:06]
The incident that I witnessed could have and should have been able to be resolved in the field by any sergeant on the beat.
[12:13]
Nine months before the unwritten, unspoken, accepted government policy, but a SWAT team action to my home
[12:20]
that killed my dog and made me an outcast amongst one-trusted friends who were shocked, frightened, and too intimidated by it all to stand up for an injustice they were not witness to.
[12:32]
I wouldn't want the cops to think I'm going soft on them, but I have been playing Cowboys and Indians with these guys
[12:37]
since longer than my dad would like to remember and i just thought they would like to try
[12:42]
wearing the white hat for a change. May the blessings be uncle sandman and i would like to invite
[12:48]
all candidates for merit to come down here to nonagenda and be seen and heard so we know who you are.
[12:55]
Excuse me Mr. Summers, can you come back to this for a moment? Mr. Summers, I want to
[13:02]
I'm sorry that the things have happened to you in the past but you have to understand that when
[13:06]
you come down here to address the council is against the law to disrupt the proceedings.
[13:11]
And I respect you, you respect you right to proceed.
[13:13]
But last week, if that were to have happened again, our office would have taken action against you.
[13:18]
So just you have perfect right to say whatever you want to say, but just remember the legal parameters for everybody is that you can't disrupt the proceedings.
[13:26]
And I say that with respect and not to not to make you more angry, but just to make sure that you are like any other citizen fully aware that you have a certain responsibility as well.
[13:36]
And I'm not trying to fight you or argue with you or in any way criticize you, but I just want
[13:41]
to make sure that you know that you have to do that as well.
[13:44]
I think the record will show that I am fully aware of my responsibilities as a citizen.
[13:49]
Thank you very much.
[13:51]
No new deck followed by Ron Bushend.
[13:54]
My name is No New deck.
[13:55]
I live within the city of San Diego.
[13:58]
I am president of wheelchair access now today.
[14:01]
For the record, I use a power
[14:10]
just a deputy city attorney
[14:14]
sitting in the attorney's seat
[14:17]
to start enforcing a mandated state of California access law.
[14:23]
Last week, during the CBBG community testimony, a portable chair was allowed to block usage
[14:31]
by persons and wheelchairs in the front of
[14:41]
the city council meeting room, BTV, remote control
[14:47]
to make a close-up view from behind on a fly as you normally show a person test flying but not the view you're showing now.
[14:58]
Showing the reserve to save you.
[15:00]
This is to show up any portable, non-disabled chairs are there now, and they see none. Thank you.
[15:09]
For the record, for the second time, city attorney, please enforce California access compliance, reference, manual, division of the state,
[15:20]
at 1-1-B-O
[15:27]
-24 California Code of Regulations and it will be found on
[15:35]
Patreon
[15:41]
.1 again that is
[15:48]
one seeding. In all assembly places where seeding is provided, there shall be spaces for persons
[15:56]
using wheelchairs and semi-ambulant persons as provided in the section. Another mandated state
[16:05]
California Code reads as formal, government code 58, the District Attorney
[16:14]
comma, the City Attorney of repeat again, the City Attorney comma, the
[16:21]
County Council, if the District Attorney does not bring an action or the
[16:27]
Attorney General may bring an action to enjoy a violation of this chapter.
[16:33]
Thank you, City Attorney, I'm like a Gary sitting in your chair of
[16:40]
your future in force.
[16:45]
Ron Bochan, followed by John Stump.
[17:05]
My name is Ron Bochan.
[17:08]
I am pleased that I have a chance to talk to Mr. McGarry today.
[17:14]
My first comment is that about five or six months ago that people voted for a new city attorney.
[17:25]
I am amazed that we retain for the first time in 30 years and honest, city, attorney.
[17:35]
We, the people, have given him a box of silver bullets in a white hat and just look what this man has done.
[17:43]
He is known reverently in a high-risk regard in coffee shops as muddy moss.
[17:51]
In all due respect, you are a giant amongst men, and for me it's a dream come true that
[17:58]
we are witnessing what we're witnessing in San Diego.
[18:02]
My first comment is, I hope that you will look deeply into the Naval Training Center, and
[18:08]
fact that they violated the Navy's rules, the government's rules, and handed over this space
[18:14]
to a Delaware corporation with an LL6LLCs, and an LLP based in Switzerland, and in
[18:23]
Minotonca, Minnesota, and in the Cayman Islands. Mike, this will be your biggest challenge
[18:29]
and your biggest victory to expose what this city willingly did, and what this city council
[18:36]
willingly did about the Naval Training Center.
[18:41]
The Naval Training Center served the American people
[18:44]
and brought through many young men that will always be young
[18:48]
and forgotten and who have never come home again after serving.
[18:53]
The Naval Training Center needs to honor today
[18:57]
the two million sailors that were there and served and gave their all.
[19:03]
I think it's your duty, Mikey, to look into this deeply and understand that you cannot have a Delaware corporation based in Switzerland and secretly running a naval training base when we don't even know who they are.
[19:19]
If you carefully look at our chair, you understand that this mayor and this city council really and grossly disobeyed our laws.
[19:29]
We have the right to know who we're dealing with. For 60 years you won't have a clue.
[19:36]
Now I know you're digging into the private placement bonds.
[19:41]
But, look deeper. This will be your biggest challenge in your biggest victory.
[19:46]
You are well on your way to becoming a legend.
[19:51]
Take the next big step and look into the Naval Training Center.
[19:54]
And look into what they're doing about redevelopment because the biggest strain on our money today
[20:00]
Is the tax increment funds that are stolen from redevelopment property that don't go to the police, or the highway, or the cops anymore?
[20:09]
Thank you, Mike.
[20:10]
John Stump, followed by Meditan and Jorge Ramirez.
[20:23]
Good morning.
[20:25]
I thought it would be finished last night, but I'm here on fire and environmental services.
[20:31]
As long as I'm here, I thought I'd like to congratulate the people of San Diego on the reduction
[20:39]
of the crime rate.
[20:42]
And yesterday, it missed a stump, suggested that I come.
[20:46]
As many of you know, Mrs. Stump is one of the most senior crisis interventionist for the
[20:53]
police department.
[20:54]
She specializes in murder and rape as a crisis interventionist for the police and fire
[21:01]
for the police department.
[21:03]
And what we need to remember is the success and reduction in crime rate
[21:10]
is the fact that we have a happy and productive population.
[21:15]
It's not the plea, it's crime, and a low crime rate is the fact that
[21:21]
our citizens are happy and productive people. It's not that the police keep them in line.
[21:29]
And congratulating the police about the crime rate is like congratulating the security
[21:38]
force and a concert about the quality of the concert.
[21:46]
We have a beautiful city and a
[21:48]
of society, the crime rate is low because we're a happy and productive society, thank you very much.
[21:59]
Meditan and Jorge Ramirez, you understand, you have three minutes total between the two of
[22:05]
you, you can share it however you wish.
[22:06]
Okay, thanks.
[22:08]
Good morning.
[22:09]
My name is Jorge Ramirez and this is...
[22:11]
You need a tan.
[22:12]
And we're representing the Sanio, 2000 Sanio County Fair and we would like to invite everyone
[22:17]
to the fair this year.
[22:19]
The theme for this year is called Cinema Summer, and it starts on the 10th of June and it ends on July 4th.
[22:27]
And yes, I'm going to go ahead and talk about the grandstand line-ups that we have.
[22:33]
Some of the line-ups that we have are CZ Top, Kelly Clarkson, Derry Hall, and John Oats, Lee Greenwood, Caratop, and Plus Others.
[22:43]
For Sundays are called Yadela Famila, it is designed for the Latinos here in the Sanio County.
[22:51]
And the grandstand line of them, we have for those days, are those to canes that Tejwana, Belinda, Bailey, Lupio Rivera, and so on.
[23:00]
And we also offer a variety of events such as horse shows, dog agility days, bicycle dirt jumping, monster trucks, construction dervines, and so on.
[23:11]
I'm going to go ahead and, oh yeah, the hours from Senate to Thursday, it's from 10 to 10 PM Friday and Saturday.
[23:21]
It's from 10 to 11 PM and the only day that we're open is on Mondays.
[23:27]
It's July the 4th because it's in the Penn State.
[23:30]
We're going to have a big fireworks celebration and, uh, yeah, go ahead.
[23:35]
As you know, opening day is June 10 and we're really excited for the fair this year.
[23:38]
I'm opening days actually dollar days, so if you go to any San Diego County
[23:42]
Rouse in the county, you can get into the fair for a dollar and enjoy all the
[23:46]
festivities there.
[23:47]
We're really encouraging value this summer and so for families, friends, we
[23:51]
encourage value pack and value pack is actually $42 with an $80 value, you get
[23:56]
forward mission tickets, a parking pass, drink coupons, ride coupons as well.
[24:00]
There are many other places you can discounts such as IKEA, Rouse,
[24:03]
a $2 discount on your admission ticket. You can also buy tickets at the San Diego Box office
[24:09]
or online a ticket master. Normal admission is $11 for adults for senior 62 and over. It
[24:16]
is $6 and for kids is $5. We just really encourage you as leaders to wrote this to your
[24:22]
community. We are going to hand out envelopes with the grandstand fires as well as two complimentary
[24:27]
mission tickets. We really want to see you guys at the fair this year. The San Diego County
[24:32]
there's actually the fifth largest in the nation.
[24:34]
And so we're really excited for it this year,
[24:35]
and hope you guys will be excited with us.
[24:37]
So thank you very much for your time.
[24:38]
Thank you.
[24:42]
All right, thank you.
[24:43]
You can hand that to the clerk.
[24:47]
Mel Shapiro followed by Jarvis Ross.
[25:00]
When the council discussed the proposed new library a couple of weeks ago, there was CCDC staff here named Mr.
[25:11]
And I have this on take in telling you that downtown tax increment can only be used downtown.
[25:18]
That's a quote from Mr. releasey.
[25:20]
Of course, it isn't true.
[25:23]
You, the council, have voted CCDC money for city heights.
[25:28]
You voted for Barrier Logan.
[25:31]
And if we look at today's redevelopment agenda, you can see that you're going to vote.
[25:38]
North Bay redevelopment taxes, property taxes for an area which is outside the project area and that's for infrastructure outside of the project area.
[25:55]
I also have a city attorney opinion saying tax and commitment can be used outside the project area.
[26:01]
Then why did Mr. Alicee of CCDC give you this misinformation?
[26:08]
It did because the Chairman of CCDC has bossed against the gain financially from
[26:13]
his company's multi-million dollar architectural contract for the new library.
[26:19]
I'm speaking of the Chairman of CCDC who is also the Chairman of Tucker Sadler, Mr.
[26:25]
House Adler, who has been fined by the Ethics Commission for illegal votes, having to do
[26:33]
with a library, and for failing to list his true finances on his disclosure statement.
[26:40]
In fact, more recently, last month, another staff member, Mr. Oltzbrook, was fined by the Ethics
[26:48]
Commission for Conflicts of Interest.
[26:51]
What gives CCDC the right to lobby the council for the financial benefit of their chairman?
[26:59]
That's an open question.
[27:01]
Conflicts of interest abound there on the board and on the staff.
[27:07]
As a result of this, we get an organized misinformation campaign aimed at you the city council.
[27:14]
What's the result?
[27:17]
Campaign results and downtown keeping old-layer funds. I don't think you'll see any budget cuts for
[27:25]
CCDC in fact, you'll see more money for CCDC, but while they're keeping their money, the rest of the city gets layoffs,
[27:36]
cuts and parks, cuts and libraries, cuts and rec centers.
[27:41]
and fee increases for the residents of San Diego so that downtown developers and hotel
[27:48]
owners can prosper. You've already given John Wars and Vailant Burnham 26 downtown
[27:54]
blocks on a stadium. I think that's enough. Thank you.
[28:00]
Jarvis Ross, fellow by Mohamed Abdullah.
[28:07]
Jarvis Ross, Point Loma, Mayor Murphy and Council members. This past weekend we celebrate
[28:13]
of V.E. Day, commemorating the 60th anniversary of the end of the war in Europe.
[28:19]
In the city of Khan France in 2001, I visited the Peace Museum, which contains many artifacts
[28:26]
of World War II. Among them are four posters by the American Illustrator, Norman Rockwell,
[28:33]
depicting the four freedoms that our country stands for. The one that especially comes to mind
[28:39]
that this time on Tuesday mornings is that one of the ordinary citizens standing up addressing
[28:45]
the town meeting. It is titled, Freedom of Speech.
[28:51]
At this time I want to express my appreciation to Council members, Actons, Fry, and Young,
[28:57]
for from the very start defending this precious freedom in the form of non-agenda public
[29:02]
from further assault. On that occasion, the assault was not from the Axis Powers. The flawed
[29:10]
argument was that it delayed parties who had marketed items on the agenda. This did not
[29:17]
take into consideration the flawed and frustrating process for the private citizen trying to
[29:24]
get their concerns stocketed. Nine agenda public comment is the only way that many public
[29:30]
concerns can be aired in a timely manner.
[29:34]
My thanks to the large number of the public for pricing the rest of this council of
[29:41]
their displeasure to the proposed change, such that the council then unanimously tabled
[29:47]
any change.
[29:49]
Please remove it from the table and deposit it in the circular file.
[29:55]
On another matter, I want to recognize that city manager you will following.
[30:00]
My remarks of yesterday had apprised me that he had already recommended a 5% pay cut in the upper levels of management.
[30:10]
I applaud his recognizing the need to share the pain of this city's financial status. The public can now only await the timely overturning of the infamous drop program. Thank you.
[30:25]
Will Hamid Abdullah, followed by Whitney Karnish?
[30:40]
In the name of Allah, most gracious, most merciful, all praise is due to Allah, the Lord of the universe.
[30:45]
I bear witness, there is no God, but Allah, and I bear witness, there Muhammad is the messenger of Allah and the seal of the prophets.
[30:52]
The Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, said that the greatest jihad is to speak the truth and the presence of a tyrannical government or leader.
[30:59]
Government Insiders says Bush authorized 911 attacks. Stanley Hilton was a senior adviser to Senator Bob Dole and has personally known runs failed and willful wits for decades.
[31:10]
This courageous man has risked his professional reputation and possibly his life to get this information out to people.
[31:17]
The Bush hunter unmasked. This 911 was all planned. This was a government ordered operation.
[31:23]
Bush personally signed the order, he personally authorized the attacks, he is guilty of
[31:29]
treason and mass murder, Stanley Hilton attorney for Planes. If you are interested in joining
[31:35]
the suit, please send a letter to Stanley Hilton telling him who you are, how to get in touch
[31:40]
with you and clearly explaining in detail how you were personally victimized by the events
[31:45]
of September 11, 2001 and or post 9-11 repression and or the wars in Afghanistan and or
[31:52]
right. For those considering joining the suit who are concerned about their privacy, it is possible
[31:58]
to join the suit as a John or Jane Doe plaintiff. In such an instance, your identity would
[32:04]
remain confidential and anonymous until trial. Letters from perspective, plaintiff should
[32:09]
be male to Stanley G. Hilton, PO box 27575, San Francisco, California, 94127. And as being
[32:19]
heard in the United States District Court, Northern and District of California, taxpayers
[32:24]
of the United States of case number, CIV-0303927SI, America United States, George Bush,
[32:37]
Dick Chaining, George Tenet, Robert Mueller, Condolese Rice, John Ashcroft, are all
[32:46]
defendants in this complaint. I would ask that the city council, since you all
[32:51]
swore to uphold and defend the Constitution against enemy's foreign and
[32:55]
and domestic, try to be on alert for possibly San Diego being used as an as the
[33:03]
next so called target of terrorists, which we know was actually wage by the U.S.
[33:09]
government on its own people, and then blamed on the Muslims."
[33:20]
Whitney Cornish, followed by Carl DeMio.
[33:34]
My name is Whitney Cornish, and this morning I am here to speak on behalf of the citizens
[33:38]
in support of homeless people.
[33:41]
By now, you are probably familiar with some of the criticisms, many coalitions, such as ours
[33:47]
have for the illegal lodging laws here in San Diego.
[33:50]
Our coalition is concerned about the welfare and humane treatment of all homeless individuals.
[33:58]
However, today, I would like to focus on the subdivision of homeless who suffer from a mental illness
[34:05]
and the effects the illegal lodging law has on them in particular.
[34:10]
According to the National Coalition for Homelessness 20 to 25% of adult homeless individuals at any given time
[34:18]
have some form of severe and persistent mental illness.
[34:23]
Mental disorders prevent people from carrying out essential aspects of daily life, but according
[34:29]
to the federal task force on homelessness and severe mental illness, only approximately
[34:35]
6% of homeless persons with mental illnesses need to be institutionalized.
[34:40]
Most can live in the community with the appropriate support of housing options.
[34:45]
Unfortunately, there are not enough community-based treatment services, nor enough appropriate
[34:51]
affordable housing to accommodate the number of people disabled by mental disorders
[34:56]
in San Diego, creating a disproportionate number of mental
[35:00]
The ill individuals among the homeless population. Now I'd like to address the impact the illegal
[35:06]
lodging ordinance has on this community. We consulted with local psychiatrists and they told
[35:12]
us there is not one single, mental illness that is not negatively impacted by sleep deprivation.
[35:20]
In other words, when the police roused a homeless person out of sleep and threatened them with
[35:26]
illegal lodging ticket or imprisonment in order to get them to move on, they may be causing harm
[35:32]
beyond the irritability you and I might feel if we don't get enough sleep.
[35:37]
If this is the case, the illegal lodging law is more than unfair or inconvenient.
[35:43]
It's cruel and inhumane.
[35:46]
We must consider the impact these actions are having on people who don't have the emotional
[35:50]
resources or the mental capacity to combat their effects.
[35:54]
Menel illnesses don't discriminate, anyone can be a victim, and as long as it remains illegal
[36:02]
to exterminate those individuals who don't function, quote unquote, normally, then society
[36:08]
is responsible for making sure that these people have their basic human needs met, because
[36:14]
that's what they are, people, and humans, thank you for your time.
[36:19]
Carl Demio, followed by Lillian Zavvy.
[36:30]
Auditual Mayor members of Council last week we appeared before you and the people of San
[36:35]
Diego to submit the financial recovery plan prepared by my organization.
[36:41]
This plan breaks down our city's financial crisis and do three recovery steps.
[36:45]
Step one, restoring public trust.
[36:49]
Step two, enacting a people's financial recovery ordinance to instill budget discipline for
[36:54]
next five years. In doing so, balancing the budget, paying off our pension debt, and any additional
[37:02]
revenues would go into an infrastructure fund to rebuild San Diego. And step three is to provide
[37:07]
our public with an insurance policy that this financial crisis will never afflict our community
[37:13]
again by making accountability changes in our city's charter to strengthen integrity in our city's
[37:21]
management.
[37:23]
For the past 18 months, just like last week, we have appeared before you offering
[37:28]
ideas and sounding the call to action. And yet the mayor and the council have delayed,
[37:34]
costing our community, I believe, valuable time in getting down to the people's business
[37:39]
of restoring our city's fiscal health and safeguarding the quality of life in our community.
[37:46]
Today I ask you to look at the financial recovery plan, read it and give us your ideas on how to improve it.
[37:55]
Because the time for action is now.
[37:59]
If this mayor and this council don't take immediate action and at least consider some of these ideas on your own accord,
[38:06]
then we will be forced the people take matters under our own hand by collecting signatures and going to the ballot box.
[38:12]
You all know that that is a three to six months process and that under our city rules we might have to wait until June of 2006 before we offer the people an opportunity to take back control of their city government to impose the sort of spending discipline that city hall will not impose upon itself.
[38:32]
So I implore you. You are our duly elected representatives on this council.
[38:38]
For 18 months you have not considered our ideas.
[38:42]
Please consider these ideas because time is of the essence.
[38:48]
I know you may not agree with all ideas in the financial recovery package.
[38:51]
Step forward and bring forth a better idea.
[38:55]
On June 6, we will file this initiative with the City Attorney in the City Clerk.
[39:00]
We will begin the process and by July 1, we will collect signatures.
[39:04]
So, please, by June 6, give us your ideas.
[39:07]
Specifically, I would ask the city manager to look at the financial assumptions that we use,
[39:12]
your five-year forecast, and let us know if anything's changed since you've published
[39:15]
your five-year forecast, because once this goes to the people, this city government would
[39:20]
have to live under that five-year forecast.
[39:22]
And the city attorney, this ordinance authorizes certain legal steps to be taken to renegotiate
[39:28]
pension benefits.
[39:29]
We would like your input on the best route, the best language that you would feel comfortable with for that initiative.
[39:35]
Thank you, and let's begin the process of restoring our city's fiscal health.
[40:00]
In 2003, councilwoman Donna Frey put forth a resolution asking the authorities of Yent High City, San Diego's sister city in China, to stop torturing and killing Falun Gong practitioners.
[40:16]
Mayor Murphy has so far blocked this resolution. To read the public awareness, San Diego Falun Gong practitioners have been coming here to tell real stories of violent persecution.
[40:29]
Today I want to tell another kind of real stories how the Chinese people oppose this
[40:37]
persecution.
[40:39]
Story one, in a sociology class in an elementary school, a teacher was teaching about
[40:46]
the history of Buddhism.
[40:49]
She told the students, Buddhism is an other dark teaching, why because it teaches people
[40:56]
to be benevolent.
[40:58]
One student then asked, teacher, what about Falun Gong?
[41:04]
The teacher said, Falun Gong is not a religion, but it's a righteous teaching.
[41:11]
Why?
[41:11]
Because it advocates truth, benevolence, forbearance.
[41:17]
It teaches practitioners to be good people and helps to upgrade morality in a society.
[41:25]
Another student asked, teacher, why the television said a Falun Gong is a court.
[41:32]
The teacher said, it is a lie to not be mislead by lie.
[41:37]
The incidence of self-immolation in Tiananmen Square is staged by the bad people.
[41:45]
You should all remember Falun Gong is a good teaching and the Falun Gong practitioners are all good people.
[41:52]
Story 2. A practitioner was detained by a police when her family came to visit her, a female
[42:02]
guard tried to take advantage of her little boy by asking him cheeky questions. Why
[42:09]
is your mother jailed? Practicing Falun Gong should good people or bad people be jailed?
[42:16]
people, then it's found good or bad. Good, you are bad. The boys clearly
[42:24]
unsearched, dragged the heart of everyone around, even the female guard was brought to tears.
[42:31]
Dear Mayor, those Chinese officers from the Chinese consulate will not tell you
[42:38]
these stories. The persecution is against people's will, and will not last long.
[42:44]
We hope this stories will make you to place yourself wisely and be remembered as a good people.
[42:54]
Please do not please do one last thing as our mayor and help the good people in our sister city.
[43:03]
Thank you.
[43:05]
That concludes not agenda public comment.
[43:08]
We'll go next to the items on our agenda that appear not to be controversial if Council members want to discuss them.
[43:15]
We'll at least trail them till we get through the non-controversial ones.
[43:20]
We'll first convene as the housing authority.
[43:24]
The item first item is approval of the minutes of the meeting of April 19.
[43:27]
Is there a motion?
[43:30]
For a second, please vote.
[43:35]
Call the roll pass the 7-0 with districts to an eight excused item 2 on the housing authority agenda our actions regarding university can in reuse plan
[43:47]
Anybody want to report on that?
[43:49]
Is there a motion
[43:51]
Please vote on housing authority item 2
[43:55]
Call the roll pass the 7-0 with districts to an eight excused
[44:01]
item three on the housing authority agenda or actions regarding the proposed revisions
[44:06]
to the first time home buyer program.
[44:09]
Second, and you're on it, can I just make a quick comment on that?
[44:12]
Yes, does anybody want to report comment, Ms.
[44:16]
Second.
[44:17]
Thank you, Your Honor.
[44:19]
I just wanted to say two things, I appreciate the flexibility of the Housing Commission
[44:23]
because of the circumstances and affordability issues on housing.
[44:28]
you have continued to adjust this program to try to meet the needs of potential first-time
[44:34]
home buyers in two ways. And I think it's important to public hear this one. You've increased
[44:39]
the amount of the loan for the silent seconds that citizens can take advantage of. And secondly,
[44:45]
in terms of condo conversion programs, something we've been trying to continually monitor,
[44:50]
you have made it possible for people to seek assistance for units not in the site that's being
[44:58]
converted but in other parts of the
[45:00]
So, I just want to acknowledge and say thank you for the flexibility in trying to keep track of what we can do with this program.
[45:10]
Then please vote on housing authority item 3, call the roll, pass the 7-0 with districts 2 and 8 excused.
[45:18]
Housing authority item 4, action regarding the loan increase in subordination for island village apartments, anybody want to report on that.
[45:28]
All right, then please vote on housing authority item 4, call the roll, pass the 70 with districts to an eight excused.
[45:40]
Will adjourn as the housing authority and convenes the redevelopment agency.
[45:45]
The first item is approval of the minutes of the regular meetings from March 1, March 15.
[45:52]
Is there a motion? Please vote on the minutes.
[45:56]
Call the roll, pass the 7-0 at District 2 and 8, excuse, redevelopment, agency item 2 are actions regarding the Washington Street improvements.
[46:10]
We do have one speaker, Mr. Stump, you hear?
[46:21]
Mr. Stump put in a slip in favor and opposed.
[46:25]
You still need to get three minutes, Mr. Stump. You can't put in two slips and get six minutes and what work.
[46:31]
But I understand your your position is this you have you both is I just wanted to make a comment on these transfers
[46:38]
back and forth between
[46:41]
redevelopment areas and this is a minor transfer and I'm not opposed to the idea of transferring for a good purpose
[46:48]
Here's the point we made a great transfer and we appreciate it in city heights
[46:56]
What happens though in these transfers is that
[47:03]
At a certain point, you transfer a considerable amount of money from, let's say, downtown,
[47:12]
there should be a participation of the persons who you transfer money and you create housing in a different redevelopment area.
[47:25]
At a certain point, those persons are supposed to participate on the project area committees in those redevelopment areas.
[47:34]
And I wonder whether or not they should be able to vote on the project area committee.
[47:42]
Okay, so you know what I'm talking about?
[47:45]
So let's say we've built all this housing in a different area.
[47:52]
So we built 300, we take money out of downtown and we built housing in a different area like city heights and 300 units.
[48:06]
I think that at a certain point those people that live in that housing should be able to participate in the pack downtown.
[48:16]
Okay? That's just my comment. Then that was relating to this transfer. Thank you.
[48:23]
All right. Is there, uh, then anybody want to report on redeveloping item two?
[48:28]
Is there a motion? Is there a second? Please vote on item two.
[48:35]
Call the roll. Passes seven zero with districts two and eight excused.
[48:42]
redevelopment agency item three are is action regarding the park boulevard and harbour drive the
[48:48]
desktion bridge project authorization apply for federal transportation enhancements funding from
[48:55]
sandbag and I want to report to this one okay if you want to discuss it let's trail it
[49:07]
item four on the redevelopment agency agenda are actions regarding the balbo theater proposed memorandum
[49:13]
understanding with the Valbo Theater Foundation, anybody want to report?
[49:19]
Kate Porter was here just to really answer questions, where's Kate Porter?
[49:24]
Did you wish to say something?
[49:26]
Okay.
[49:29]
Thank you very much for the opportunity.
[49:32]
Mayor Murphy and City Council people.
[49:34]
We simply want to acknowledge the work of Councilman Zooket and Chief of Staff
[49:41]
on Mollon, Director of Philanthropy for the City of San Diego, Daniel Weinberg, and CCDC
[49:48]
Chairman Hellsadler, Senior Project Manager Eli Sanchez, for their efforts in bringing today's
[49:56]
project to you for your approval.
[49:59]
The Balbo Theatre Family.
[50:00]
Today should would like to recognize the donors to the Wonder Morton Organ Project, which are reading about several of whom are here with us today.
[50:12]
Paulian, L. E. Schneider.
[50:14]
Are here?
[50:15]
I want to show you a raise your hand.
[50:16]
Yes, would you please?
[50:18]
Victor and Jane,
[50:19]
Atenstein,
[50:20]
Dr. Kenneth Campos,
[50:22]
Dr. Bill Bailey,
[50:23]
and there are others on our board of directors.
[50:25]
I serve as the President of the
[50:27]
Ball Boath Theatre Foundation,
[50:29]
and with me today,
[50:30]
our Jan Manos,
[50:31]
who is the former chairman of the board.
[50:35]
Gary Stimple,
[50:36]
John Eric,
[50:38]
Dr. Bill Bailey,
[50:39]
and Claire Anderson, a fine advisor for us all.
[50:43]
We wish to thank all the current and future supporters to the project and the many future projects that will provide the resources to enhance and nurture the historic Balboa Theatre as a cultural center in San Diego for Arts and Education. Thank you.
[51:00]
And let me just thank the donors also on behalf of the city. Thank you for your generosity.
[51:12]
Okay, I believe we had a motion a second. So please vote on redevelopment agency item 4,
[51:20]
call the roll, pass the 7-0 with districts to an eight excused. We'll go on to redevelopment
[51:28]
agency item 5, which are also actions on the Balboath Theater. This is for the seismic
[51:33]
retrofit phase, request a bid, a horton-placer redevelopment district, anybody want to
[51:38]
report in that?
[51:41]
So, the motion is in a second,
[51:48]
please vote, call the roll, passes 7-0, which districts
[51:54]
to an eight excuse, will then adjourn as the redevelopment agency and reconvene as a city
[52:04]
Council to deal with the Companion item, which is 332, 33, City Council item 332 is the Companion
[52:17]
item to redevelopment agency item 5. Again, an action regarding authorizing the Center
[52:23]
City Development Corporation to expend tax increment funds for the purpose of the seismic
[52:28]
retrofit phase of the rehabilitation of the historical
[52:32]
bauble of theater.
[52:34]
Anybody want to report in that?
[52:37]
Not, we have a motion in a second, please vote.
[52:40]
Call the roll, pass the 70 with two and eight absent.
[52:46]
So, thank all of you that have been down here on that item.
[52:50]
You're free to stick around all morning if you'd like.
[52:54]
There's a lot of other fun things on,
[52:56]
but if you need to, if you need to,
[52:58]
You know, with your lives, that's okay.
[53:01]
We're going to go back then to the read of, excuse me,
[53:05]
to council item 330, which is the companion
[53:08]
to redevelopment agency item 2,
[53:10]
the actions regarding the Washington Street improvements
[53:12]
in the street segment.
[53:16]
There's a motion in a second, please vote,
[53:20]
call the roll, pass the 70 with districts 2 and 8,
[53:24]
excuse
[53:28]
item,
[53:33]
council item 331,
[53:34]
are the actions regarding the rancho incantada public facilities financing plan and facilities
[53:39]
benefit assessment for fiscal year 2006.
[53:44]
Anybody want to report?
[53:45]
You're on it.
[53:46]
Could I.
[53:46]
My staff.
[53:48]
I'm going to strike my staff to have a couple of questions answered, so if we can maybe just have
[53:51]
a trail maybe just to this month through before the lunch hour.
[53:55]
Okay.
[53:56]
I get my questions answered.
[53:57]
All right.
[53:57]
We'll trail item 331 then
[54:09]
we'll go next to council item 334 actions regarding the
[54:13]
60th Street right away vacation.
[54:17]
We have a motion in a second.
[54:20]
Ricardo White Eagle was here, raise your hand.
[54:24]
You deserve here, based answer questions.
[54:27]
All right, we have a motion in a second, then,
[54:30]
to approve Item 334, please vote.
[54:33]
Call the roll, pass the 7-0.
[54:35]
It districts 2 and 8 excused.
[54:43]
Item S501, or the actions regarding the Rancho
[54:46]
program of maintenance assessment district.
[54:49]
Anybody want to report on that?
[54:54]
Let me before I call him Mr. Manchai.
[54:56]
Let me just first of all call him the city clerk to reason.
[55:00]
Read the results of the Rancho Bernard O'Ballet.
[55:04]
Yes, honorable Mayor and City Council, the election has been conducted according to assessment proceedings.
[55:09]
The ballots in favor exceed the ballots in opposition with a majority vote in favor and the proposed increase to the annual assessment and to incorporate new areas for maintenance has passed.
[55:21]
We have certified the results which are now submitted to the City Council.
[55:24]
All right, Mr. Maintain, I believe the motion is to approve the fiscal year 2006 budget
[55:32]
for the Rancho Guerrero Maintenance District to confirm the assessments, approve the assessment
[55:37]
and engineers report and district map, and order the proposed maintenance and or services
[55:42]
for the Rancho Guerrero Maintenance Assistance District in accordance with the assessment
[55:45]
engineers report. That's what you're going to say.
[55:47]
That is correct.
[55:50]
We are reading from the same page. So yes, that would be my motion and honor.
[55:54]
Thank you for prompting me with that all right that would be my motion
[55:57]
There's motion a second please vote an item S501
[56:03]
Call the roll pass the 7-0 with districts to an eight excuse
[57:05]
Well, let's go first to item 333. It's the action regarding the special hearing of the fiscal year 2006 social services program funding.
[57:13]
Is that ready to go?
[57:15]
Yes, it is.
[57:16]
It is ready to go.
[57:19]
Anybody want to report on that?
[57:23]
If not, is there a motion?
[57:27]
Please vote on item 333.
[57:31]
We're Friday. Do you want to ask questions on this?
[57:33]
Nope.
[57:39]
Please vote.
[57:39]
Call the roll, pass the 7-0 with district 2 and 8 excuse at
[58:04]
this point take a break.
[58:10]
I need to consult with staff on the other CDBG items to see if we're ready to go or not.
[58:16]
When we come back, my intention would be to go to the Fire Department budget.
[58:22]
If you could get everybody over here after the short break,
[58:27]
we'll do the CDBT items if we can.
[58:29]
We'll have to trail them to the afternoon.
[58:31]
And then we'll go to the Fire Department budget.
[58:37]
And we'll take a five minute break.
[1:07:35]
In the back of order, it has to be called roll.
[1:07:37]
Council member Peters.
[1:07:40]
Deputy Mayor of the Council member Atkins. Council member Young. Council member Mainchine. Council member
[1:07:47]
Fry. Council member Medaffer. Council member Inzuna. Mayor Murphy.
[1:07:52]
Here. The plan at this point is to trail until this afternoon, S500, S502, S503 and S504.
[1:08:07]
as well as redevelopment, agency item three, in a minute we're going to go to the fire department budget,
[1:08:14]
but I understand Mr. Manchine, since you can fairly quickly deal with the,
[1:08:20]
the wrench-wake in time and manner.
[1:08:23]
Thank you, Your Honor.
[1:08:24]
My understanding is that the proposed assessments have been reduced because the developer has agreed
[1:08:30]
to make the improvements themselves. Is that correct? Mr. Manager?
[1:08:37]
I just correct, sir.
[1:08:39]
Okay, and I want to make sure from both the City Manager and the City Attorney that those agreements
[1:08:47]
have been properly entered into and it's binding. I want to make sure those improvements occur.
[1:08:53]
So I just want confirmation from both of you that.
[1:08:56]
You have my confirmation from a non-legal administrative point of view.
[1:09:00]
we believe we've met our fiduciary spot to build okay. And then to the city attorney.
[1:09:05]
Thank you Mr. Meachon. I don't know the status of the agreements at present but I can assure you we
[1:09:09]
won't sign off on the unless we're satisfied that they're correct.
[1:09:14]
Okay. That was my that was my concern. I want to make sure these you know this this project is
[1:09:19]
going to have a significant although the project itself is not in my district it's going to have a
[1:09:23]
significant impact on my on my district and so and and as you know I had opposed the project.
[1:09:29]
So I just want to make sure that these improvements occur, and that was, so I appreciate Mayor,
[1:09:36]
you allowing me to have that discussion.
[1:09:39]
Okay.
[1:09:40]
Mr. Daffer, do you have a motion?
[1:09:41]
Yeah.
[1:09:41]
With that, Mr. Manchains, questions being satisfied, I'll sum of the item.
[1:09:45]
Sir, second.
[1:09:47]
Please vote then on item 331 actions regarding the rancho and cantada public facilities.
[1:09:54]
financing plan and facilities benefit assessment for fiscal year 2006.
[1:10:00]
Call the roll, pass the 7-0 with districts 2 and 8 excused.
[1:10:06]
All right, well we'll try to get done this morning as we had two matters trailing from yesterday.
[1:10:14]
They were the fire department budget and the environmental services department budget. I'm not sure we can get both of them done this morning, but we can at least try to get through the fire department budget.
[1:10:25]
And so I'd call on the City Manager.
[1:10:28]
Thank you, Your Honor.
[1:10:29]
As you stated, we have the Fire Department, San Diego Fire Rescue to present and
[1:10:33]
System Chief Tracy Jarmor, who's going to leave the presentation.
[1:10:39]
Thank you.
[1:10:40]
On the System Chief Tracy Jarmor, I'm presenting on behalf of Fire Chief Jack Bowman and
[1:10:45]
Fire Rescue Department supporting me today in the presentation as a
[1:10:49]
of Fire Chief John John Dole and Chet Chu.
[1:10:53]
Chief Bowman is currently attending a conference where he was recognized last year as Fire
[1:10:57]
Chief for the Year for the Nation.
[1:10:59]
This commitment was made six months ago, and he's presenting on the status of the National
[1:11:04]
Urban Search and Rescue Team.
[1:11:07]
First I'd like to thank the Mayor, City Council, City Manager, and the other city departments
[1:11:12]
for their support of public safety as the highest priority during these difficult budget
[1:11:17]
times.
[1:11:18]
It's probably just as well Chief Bowman is not here today to make this presentation.
[1:11:23]
He came to San Diego with the intent to improve our overall service delivery, and so far
[1:11:28]
we have only been able to address our basic replacement needs.
[1:11:31]
Both Chief Bowman and Lamont Yulavassavadi, Facts on Honest in this presentation, and although
[1:11:36]
we appreciate the additional funding the city manager has been able to provide for our department,
[1:11:41]
we do not fill, we are fully funded under this proposed budget to maintain the current level
[1:11:46]
service and address all of our MOU requirements. We feel we're short about $3.2 million.
[1:11:52]
Do the limited time allotment? I will skip through some of the presentations spend time highlighting
[1:11:56]
specific areas.
[1:12:00]
Our budget has been increased by $8 million from $149.5 million to $158 million.
[1:12:06]
Primarily in personnel expenses. There's also been a reduction in non-personnel expenses
[1:12:11]
primarily due to a 3.8 million reduction in equipment outlay funding.
[1:12:17]
The change in positions is to formalize the helicopter program, open, station 47 of
[1:12:22]
in Pacific Highlands Ranch for the final four months of the year, and there's a reduction
[1:12:28]
in 4.4 positions.
[1:12:33]
Exponatures by Category would like you to note the 144 million personnel expenses.
[1:12:38]
91% of our total budget is in person now, typically other fire departments spend about 80%
[1:12:45]
of their budget on person now.
[1:12:47]
This situation currently leaves us very little to address supply services in our equipment
[1:12:52]
needs.
[1:12:54]
The equipment outlay number of 3.8 million, 2.8 million of that is existing lease purchase
[1:13:00]
payments and sales tax.
[1:13:01]
We actually only have $645,000 in discretionary funds for emergency medical equipment, rescue
[1:13:10]
lifeguard and fire equipment.
[1:13:13]
It also covers station furnishings, appliances, support vehicles, and equipment for the
[1:13:18]
mechanics that's less than half of it percent.
[1:13:21]
In fiscal years 2001, 2002, 2003, and 2005, our discretionary outlet was over $1 million.
[1:13:29]
But despite of all of this, we've actually managed to accomplish quite a bit, and it's
[1:13:34]
thanks to the continued support of Mayor Murphy in this council.
[1:13:37]
We acquired our own helicopter program.
[1:13:40]
After one's out there saving lies every day, and even as we were here, the seeds of the
[1:13:44]
Police Department budget, it was out saving lives last night.
[1:13:47]
We recognize the contribution of our corporate sponsors, the Center City Development
[1:13:51]
Corporation, the Community Development Block Grants, and helping us to replace 7 brush
[1:13:57]
engines, purchase three quantum apparatus, replace two additional latter trucks, equipped
[1:14:03]
with apartment operations center and establish community emergency response teams in our
[1:14:08]
community.
[1:14:10]
We've completed the accreditation application process and a peer review team will be out
[1:14:14]
here in July and San Diego to finalize the assessment.
[1:14:18]
The initial review indicates our department, as far from being accredited and potentially
[1:14:23]
22 additional stations would be required to provide the appropriate level of coverage.
[1:14:28]
We've completed the zero-based management review of the department and highlighted a number
[1:14:32]
of areas needing significant improvements, facilities, apparatus replacement and deferred
[1:14:37]
maintenance to name a few.
[1:14:40]
We're in the process of finalizing construction on several replacement facilities, Lincoln
[1:14:44]
Parks, Sanucidro, Delsero, and the South Pacific Beach Lifeguard Tower.
[1:14:49]
And during the winter storms the department took a number of successful emergency rescues.
[1:14:56]
The significant changes in our FY2006 proposed.
[1:15:00]
Budget, the majority of the increases in salaries, benefits, and retirement contributions. A new fire station is estimated to open in Pacific Highlands Ranch in March 2006.
[1:15:11]
Non-discretionary funding was added to help address our underground storage tanks problems, utilities, rent, and deal with insurance.
[1:15:20]
The department was reduced by four positions, three dispatchers and an additional clerical position.
[1:15:26]
Under Chief Bowman's direction, we took the initiative to look at the efficiency of a 12-hour shift versus an eight-hour shift in our 911 dispatch center.
[1:15:35]
We ran a pilot program and officially adopted a 12-hour shift in FY 2005.
[1:15:41]
The staffing levels required for a 12-hour shift are less than required to staff an eight-hour shift and lead to the change and staffing level.
[1:15:48]
We had hoped to utilize these positions to replace the four cleric.
[1:15:52]
We have lost over the last several budget years.
[1:15:56]
Unfortunately, in light of the reduction of force situation,
[1:15:58]
we've given these positions up as well as an additional clerical assistant to.
[1:16:05]
The 10 positions for the helicopter program have been added to our base budget.
[1:16:10]
This includes three pilots, mechanics, pre-cheese, paramedics and a program manager.
[1:16:16]
We've had a reduction in our information technology budget.
[1:16:19]
And this may have a significant impact.
[1:16:22]
The Department's Computer Replacement Program was eliminated,
[1:16:25]
and we'll handle that on a case-by-case basis.
[1:16:28]
Our challenge will be in the labor reductions
[1:16:30]
for troubleshooting computer problems,
[1:16:32]
and most importantly, for maintaining the road routing files
[1:16:35]
for the 911 computer-rated dispatch systems
[1:16:38]
for both police and that database needs to stay current.
[1:16:42]
And the one-time funding sources from CCDC and CDVG
[1:16:46]
We're eliminated from our budget for the six service level impacts with the response
[1:16:53]
times we'll continue to degrade with all the added growth and traffic without additional
[1:16:57]
fire stations and resources significant gap areas have been identified in our emergency
[1:17:03]
response coverage our highest priority is mission valley we hope for a temporary fire station
[1:17:08]
in the FY 2006 budget but it's not funded at this time our response resources are still inadequate
[1:17:15]
to handle a significant event similar to the Cedar Fire.
[1:17:19]
The Interstate Bank Building, High-Rice Fire,
[1:17:21]
and Los Angeles required 300 firefighters in the first hour.
[1:17:25]
We have only 254 firefighters on duty every day
[1:17:28]
to cover the entire city.
[1:17:31]
Our aging lifeguard and fire fleet continue
[1:17:33]
to require replacement.
[1:17:36]
The third maintenance continues to be an issue.
[1:17:38]
We have 10 and a half million and required maintenance,
[1:17:41]
which is problematic for the living conditions
[1:17:43]
of our firefighters and our lifeguards.
[1:17:45]
Our brush management program is understaffed to meet the needs of the public and the position
[1:17:49]
for the community emergency response team program managers not funded in this proposed budget.
[1:17:57]
The Department only has training funds to maintain certifications and specialized positions.
[1:18:02]
For paramedics emergency medical technicians has a dysmaterial specialist.
[1:18:06]
There are no funds in our budget for basic training efforts, such as fighting wild-land
[1:18:11]
dealers with a high-rise collapsed earthquakes or supervisory and personnel training such
[1:18:16]
as Equal Employment Opportunity, harassment prevention, supervisory skills for our captains,
[1:18:22]
lifeguards, sergeants, lieutenant and our battalion chiefs.
[1:18:26]
Problem behavior of the fire stations or lifeguards facilities leads to claims and expenses
[1:18:30]
if they're not addressed through the training process.
[1:18:33]
We have a young workforce and problems continued to surface.
[1:18:36]
So, lifeguard boat dock is underwater.
[1:18:40]
The vessels are currently being docked over the Driscoll's Marina and boats of already
[1:18:45]
experienced theft of equipment and some vandalism.
[1:18:49]
Old Mission Beach still experienced problems in coverage in that area we've had two
[1:18:54]
drownings and they'll be continued reductions in administrative support staff, impacts
[1:18:59]
our ability to address the responsive, be responsive to the needs of the public as well as
[1:19:03]
to counsel.
[1:19:07]
Minimum of Lee, the proposed FY2006 budget, the 6.3 million underfunded from the Gulf
[1:19:13]
set by the PSNNS committee in March 2005.
[1:19:19]
To maintain the existing service levels of Lithium, you requirements we would need an additional
[1:19:23]
3.2 million.
[1:19:25]
The Lifeguard Botox Red Tagged Underwater needs replacement that would be a million.
[1:19:30]
Mission Valley Temporary Station continues to be one of our highest priorities.
[1:19:34]
The fire engine lease program, which is critical for our fleet, there's no question there's
[1:19:38]
an expense to doing this program, but it locks in a replacement program and establishes
[1:19:43]
a known cost to eliminate our aging fleet.
[1:19:46]
Over 43% of our engine fleet is older than 12 years old, that's the national standard for
[1:19:52]
replacement.
[1:19:53]
21% of our engines are over 20 years old.
[1:19:56]
The least kids expire in July.
[1:20:00]
Only had the best of final offers and needed to make a decision on whether we can move forward, and this is currently not funded.
[1:20:07]
The health and wellness programs at top priority for Chief Bowman. This is to maintain the health and safety of our firefighters, and in the nine short months, this programs already saved lives.
[1:20:18]
We've created a cultural shift within our department, and firefighters are focusing more on fitness and nutrition.
[1:20:25]
Chief Bowman called yesterday and asked me to bring to your attention that yesterday, a 48-year-old firefighter, who was on duty, died of a heart attack in South Carolina.
[1:20:35]
This is what we hope to prevent from happening in our city.
[1:20:39]
Our goal is to market this program, countywide, to offset the cost of the program,
[1:20:43]
and other fire departments have already started to enroll.
[1:20:46]
We know workers' cost will be reduced based on implementation that we've seen in other cities,
[1:20:50]
but it's surely to quantify these savings for our program.
[1:20:55]
For our fleet, three out of our 11 trucks to require replacement to completely address the open cab issue.
[1:21:02]
Our explosive response unit that responds to our city carrying explosive devices is over 20 years old and in need of replacement.
[1:21:08]
This would be the last of our specialty apparatus.
[1:21:12]
And out of lifeguard seven rescue vessels that require replacement,
[1:21:15]
we've only been able to replace one so far.
[1:21:18]
deferred maintenance I've already touched on. The SERP program manager's critical to
[1:21:22]
keeping this program alive out in our communities. Originally, it was funded through a
[1:21:26]
grant last year, we applied for additional grant funds and have not received any, this
[1:21:31]
position is not currently funded. The two existing brush management employees, they're
[1:21:37]
inundated by the public, trying to be responsive to their needs since the Cedar Fire.
[1:21:42]
With all the rain that we've experienced, there's a lot of weeds that are growing out
[1:21:45]
Our goal is to re-establish this program back to the staffing levels following the normal
[1:21:50]
heights fire.
[1:21:51]
We realized the current physical situation and I've only requested two of the seven positions
[1:21:55]
be restored to be the demands of the public and an old mission beach like our coverage
[1:22:01]
I've touched on that.
[1:22:04]
At this point I'd like to clear up any misperceptions surrounding the fire rescue over time
[1:22:09]
budget.
[1:22:10]
The department did identify a couple of problem areas, the biggest of which was the staffing
[1:22:15]
of our medic rescue ambulances.
[1:22:18]
Those anomalies have been corrected and will not happen again.
[1:22:22]
The highest over time runner was essentially an employee working two full-time jobs.
[1:22:27]
This was to ensure the highest degree of safety and a new program fraught with risk and
[1:22:32]
was supported and authorized by a supervisor.
[1:22:35]
In fact, the city attorney's office did an investigation into our overtime, we turned over
[1:22:41]
all our records, recently this investigation was concluded, and they found that all procedures
[1:22:47]
were appropriately followed and people were paid appropriately.
[1:22:51]
The staffing issues that we're discussing are being addressed through the meeting and confer
[1:22:54]
process.
[1:22:55]
We've actually been working for the past three years toward system changes that would reduce
[1:23:00]
our overall overtime usage.
[1:23:02]
It's been a challenging meeting and confer item, and due to the leadership of a local 145
[1:23:07]
and particularly Ron Saitov, the first of these changes will be implemented July 1.
[1:23:13]
The perception that fire rescue's over times running rampant is also not true in FY 2005,
[1:23:19]
budget, are current projections are right on the predicted target.
[1:23:23]
We're 200,000 funded in overtime, and that's where we're tracking.
[1:23:28]
This is a graph of the FY-2005 over time budget, our budget was 6.6 million.
[1:23:34]
Sorry savings offset the overtime costs by 7.1 million.
[1:23:38]
1.3 million was reimbursed with a shortfall of 200,000.
[1:23:43]
Utilizing overtime means we only pay for employees when they're required versus hiring additional personnel that oftentimes
[1:23:49]
have a budgeted position to fill or replace the right on our engines or our ambulances.
[1:23:54]
We're actually working to manage our overtime spending cost effectively, and this has been
[1:23:59]
helped by the development of promotional lists that are currently filling a vacancies.
[1:24:08]
The significant issues we're facing, the citywide growth continues to be a challenge.
[1:24:12]
The growth and mission valley, the infill, mid city, university city areas.
[1:24:16]
Other areas throughout the city need to be addressed.
[1:24:19]
We estimate 22 areas are underserved in required additional stations or resources to meet the needs of the public.
[1:24:25]
This will be validated by the accreditation process to occur in July.
[1:24:30]
The delayed funding of the Phase 2 of the Fire and Life Guard facilities and improvement
[1:24:35]
projects impacted a number of these communities and ranches to move forward once we return
[1:24:39]
to the bond market.
[1:24:42]
And that concludes our presentation.
[1:24:45]
Thank you.
[1:24:46]
Thank you.
[1:24:46]
All right.
[1:24:46]
Thank you.
[1:24:49]
Ron Saitoff and Johnny Perkins asked to make an organized presentation on behalf of San Diego
[1:24:54]
firefighters, so we'll give you a maximum of 15 minutes.
[1:25:29]
Morning Honorable Mayor, Members of the City Council, Johnny Perkins, San Diego City Firefighters, Ron Statoff and I will give the presentation today. We appreciate the opportunity. We're going to come at this from three different perspectives. One is, we're going to provide you with a global view of fire rescue services where we've been at the last couple of years in terms of identifying various needs. Second, we're going to discuss specifically from the fiscal year of 2006 standpoint. The request we'd like to have you consider as you're deliberating the budget for the fire rescue department. And lastly, we're going to clear up what we
[1:25:58]
commonly referred to as fact-first fiction about a number of issues particularly dealing with
[1:26:02]
salaries and over times of the fire rescue department. Let me start out by saying fiscal year
[1:26:08]
06 is a difficult budget year. Firefighters realize that we want to personally thank the city manager
[1:26:14]
Lamott Yul, personally thank Mayor Murphy and all of you the members of the council for the tremendous
[1:26:19]
work you are doing to restore this city's financial health to restore the credit rating. We
[1:26:26]
This firefighters truly realize this is a difficult time, maybe in the history of our
[1:26:30]
city in terms of the budget challenges.
[1:26:32]
And as firefighters, the men and women who are out there daily putting their lives on
[1:26:35]
the line for your citizens, we want to thank you for that, which we're tremendously grateful.
[1:26:42]
In 2003, 2004, the public safety and neighborhood services committee, chair member, chairperson,
[1:26:48]
Council Member Brian Mainsign, put together a comprehensive program.
[1:26:52]
We want to thank Council Member Mainsign and that committee because what they really did,
[1:26:56]
They reviewed and accepted a comprehensive needs assessment and action plan for the Fire Rescue Department over 2003 and 2004.
[1:27:05]
What did that do?
[1:27:07]
PSNNS 2003 2004 identified a five-year plan with found $159 million worth of needs in the Fire Rescue Department.
[1:27:16]
Things such as deferred maintenance, equipment, fleet, response times, facilities, personnel, and training.
[1:27:23]
What that didn't include was approximately 133 million to upgrade our communications or a 911 system.
[1:27:29]
Again, we want to thank Council Member Mainschine and his committee for that work.
[1:27:34]
When Chief Olman got here, he initiated something called a accreditation process,
[1:27:38]
which was to identify the far-department needs and the things that they can improve upon.
[1:27:42]
Well, that accreditation has been completed and submitted.
[1:27:46]
It's currently under peer review.
[1:27:49]
One of the things that we found out in it,
[1:27:51]
we're going to need 22 new fire stations just to meet national standards.
[1:27:55]
And the reason that's important is that's how we attack this response time matter.
[1:28:00]
There are certain places in our city where we can't get to within six minutes or less,
[1:28:04]
which is the national standard to save someone's lives.
[1:28:07]
Fire stations will help us address those response times.
[1:28:11]
And, initially, estimates identified that in order to return a chief service level from 1979,
[1:28:19]
the fire and rescue department would have to actually add 11 engines, three trucks, and two battalions.
[1:28:25]
I want to thank Chief Goldman for his leadership and effort on the accreditation process.
[1:28:29]
We look forward to that peer review being completed and coming back to all of you for that.
[1:28:34]
What do we ask me for in fiscal year 2006?
[1:28:36]
Well, let me say number one, we want to thank Council Member Jim Adapher and the PSNNS Committee on March 2nd.
[1:28:43]
They supported four things that should be considered as you deliberate the budget in FY06.
[1:28:48]
Number one, Chief Jarman mentioned, maintain service levels 3.2 million.
[1:28:51]
One of the things in there is radios.
[1:28:53]
We're going to have some radios that are inoperable in January of 06.
[1:28:57]
That's a problem in a concern. We'd like to consider that.
[1:29:00]
The Mission Valley Fire Station, you've all probably heard about it.
[1:29:03]
It's been highly publicized the last couple of weeks.
[1:29:05]
The fact of the matter is we can't get into Mission Valley quicker than nine minutes
[1:29:09]
with no traffic.
[1:29:10]
It takes 12 if there's traffic.
[1:29:12]
We need to get there in six minutes or less.
[1:29:14]
There is no fire station in Mission Valley.
[1:29:16]
That is critical for public safety.
[1:29:19]
Fire engine lease apparatus program.
[1:29:21]
Councilmember Daffers Committee, following the Councilmember MainChions Committee, supported
[1:29:26]
a program that allows us this year to spend $220,000 to get eight new fire trucks.
[1:29:31]
We think that's real important in public safety.
[1:29:34]
Lifeguard vote dock is all you remember that winter storms create a lot of havoc on our streets our roadways
[1:29:39]
We'll actually destroy the lifeguard boat dock
[1:29:41]
So we need to start the process of replacing that because the lifeguards need a dock
[1:29:46]
That they can have their boat there so when they're ready to go on an emergency they can get out and take care of it
[1:29:50]
Today we're running a dock from someone and we're using another facility to get their fuel both of those the fuel in the dock at one place
[1:29:57]
So we need to start that process of replacing it for our lifeguards
[1:30:00]
Three other things that the committee didn't consider, but we feel as firefighters are real important as you consider this budget, no six.
[1:30:06]
Number one is the health and wellness program. Chief Jarman mentioned it a little bit. It's really preventative medicine.
[1:30:11]
And it's worth the money that you're going to spend to help identify potential cancers and other illnesses for firefighters.
[1:30:18]
We think it's a great program. It's something that we're going to continue to push and hopefully we're looking forward to moving it throughout our city.
[1:30:24]
But we really want you to give a high consideration for something that's going to be very beneficial
[1:30:28]
to our firefighters and the public.
[1:30:31]
The community urgency, emergency response team, all of you know about the Cedar fires.
[1:30:35]
We've had a number of communities.
[1:30:36]
In fact, I'm proud to say, I'm a certain graduate of myself, St. Carlos, the Fourth Academy.
[1:30:41]
Council member of Daphis currently in the Fifth Academy.
[1:30:44]
Now, Council member Mayan-China has been supportive of the groups in his community.
[1:30:47]
This is a real important program for the community to get involved and be there if we have another
[1:30:51]
God forbid another critical emergency.
[1:30:54]
So the funding we're asking for that for you to consider we believe is important in order to continue that program and reach out to our communities.
[1:31:01]
Lastly, brush management.
[1:31:02]
We need approximately $160,000.
[1:31:04]
We'd like you to consider to fund two positions, something that the mayor has been working on,
[1:31:08]
in terms of having a brush management program here in the city.
[1:31:11]
Again, as firefighters, we greatly appreciate everything you all are doing.
[1:31:15]
It means a lot to us.
[1:31:16]
Thanks for your hard work, Mr. City Manager.
[1:31:17]
Thank you.
[1:31:18]
I'd like to now turn it over to President of Local 145, Ron Statoff.
[1:31:26]
Thank you.
[1:31:28]
Your Honor.
[1:31:29]
Members of the City Council, Ron Statoff, representing San Diego City Firefighters.
[1:31:32]
I'd like to make a note that before I get into the meat of my presentation, that all
[1:31:37]
of the things that the Department has asked for in Mr. Perkins has discussed don't address
[1:31:41]
at all the population growth increase in the fact that we haven't kept up with it.
[1:31:46]
Don't address it all what we need to add in order to reduce response times back to a level that is
[1:31:51]
National Standard. This is just for us to maintain where we are and to prevent hopefully falling from even further behind.
[1:31:58]
I find it interesting in the Mission Valley Fire Station because I have a little personal affinity to that.
[1:32:02]
I was hired in 1977 and a Mission Valley Fire Station was in the CIP budget to be completed that year.
[1:32:11]
They recognized even then how necessary it was to have a Fire Station Mission Valley.
[1:32:15]
I think everybody remembers what fires road look like then and what fires road looks like now
[1:32:19]
in terms of growth and development, population, and business increases in that area.
[1:32:24]
I do want to thank the City Manager in particular.
[1:32:27]
Mr. Yule, this is the most honest budget. The most difficult budget, but one that addresses
[1:32:32]
very, very challenging problems in a fourth right way. And I think it's a significant move
[1:32:37]
in the right direction. Unfortunately, it comes at a very difficult time where there's
[1:32:40]
insufficient resources, even begin to address the city's needs, but it is certainly an important
[1:32:45]
step in the right direction, and I applaud the courageousness with which Mr. Ewell has pursued
[1:32:50]
this.
[1:32:51]
As Mr. Perkins mentioned, I want to address the misconceptions. One of them has already
[1:32:55]
been partially discussed, and that's over time. Over time is not an anomaly. Over time was
[1:33:01]
a conscious choice. This department, in order to provide service to the public, has to have
[1:33:06]
four individuals on every fire apparatus every day, seven days a week, 365 days a year.
[1:33:12]
When someone is hurt, when someone is on vacation, or holiday, someone else has to replace that individual.
[1:33:18]
When Chief Bowman arrived, he asked me a question shortly after his arrival, he said,
[1:33:22]
what is the most efficient way to replace those vacancies?
[1:33:25]
Is it to hire people to replace them or is it to pay overtime?
[1:33:29]
So the most efficient way, as much as I hate to admit it,
[1:33:32]
because that's a reduction in promotions and a reduction in union members, is to use overtime.
[1:33:36]
And the reason is very straightforward, over time cost the taxpayer less per hour than a full time employee.
[1:33:44]
In fact, the difference is about 39.67 an hour.
[1:33:47]
For a full time employee, that's a loaded cost with all benefits over time at time and a half,
[1:33:52]
36 dollars and 10 cents an hour.
[1:33:54]
So the chief made a decision not to fill vacancies on the fire department.
[1:33:58]
That's the 7.1 million that you saw on the chart chart that was utilized to offset over time cost by salary savings.
[1:34:04]
By using overtime in place of hiring those individuals, the chief saved over $700,000 in the last fiscal year alone.
[1:34:12]
By using overtime because it was cheaper than using full time employees that would have benefits and other costs.
[1:34:18]
The second thing that was mentioned is absolutely true, you hire a full time employee, they come to work every day.
[1:34:24]
Whether you need them or not, and our staffing patterns are such that we have more vacancies in the summer than we do in the winter, it varies throughout the season.
[1:34:31]
So, if you hire people to fill the vacancies for the whole year, you're going to wind up being
[1:34:36]
overstaffed at certain times of the year and still be understaffed at other times of
[1:34:40]
the year.
[1:34:40]
By using overtime, you have the flexibility to only pay for the vacancies you have and only pay
[1:34:45]
for the hours you need and not carry anybody on the books and access of that requirement.
[1:34:50]
That again is saved us $700,000 just in the salary savings.
[1:34:53]
If all of our overtime were used that way and a good portion of it is, it's closer to $1,500
[1:34:58]
and savings.
[1:35:00]
Now, the other popular misconception based on news reports and radio top show host and others is that we're the problem.
[1:35:07]
The city employees are the problem. We're the cost basis and that's why we're in the difficult strates that we face.
[1:35:13]
We'd like to mention just a few points that we think will help clarify that.
[1:35:17]
We've already covered the overtime position because of course that also was a news report that this egregious overtime was a problem.
[1:35:23]
This egregious overtime is saving the taxpayer's money and thank God the chief made the decision that he did,
[1:35:28]
which allowed us to fund other things within the department while saving the taxpayer's money and providing full service to the public.
[1:35:35]
You want to look at salary, the 10 largest cities in the state of California, as you know of which we are second, of the 10, we rank 8th.
[1:35:42]
Cost of housing and cost of living, we rank 2nd in the state of California.
[1:35:46]
Our firefighters now chief lands down mentioned yesterday, our firefighters don't live in San Diego any longer.
[1:35:51]
New firefighters live in Riverside, Temecula, and other areas outside the county because that's where they can afford to buy housing.
[1:35:57]
And then they commute into San Diego to serve the citizens of San Diego.
[1:36:01]
That's a significant change.
[1:36:03]
And it's because of the fact that housing is so expensive in this area and because our wages have not kept up even with the median of the ten largest cities in the state.
[1:36:12]
The next item that everybody loves to talk about is the retirement system.
[1:36:17]
Let's see.
[1:36:17]
Now, what are the words Cadillac goal-plated?
[1:36:20]
Regis outrageous, every adjective in the book.
[1:36:23]
You can fill up a source with the adjectives that have been used to describe our retirement system.
[1:36:29]
The truth of the matter is 3% at 50 for safety members throughout the state of California.
[1:36:33]
Cities and counties is the norm.
[1:36:35]
It is not outside normal practice.
[1:36:38]
it is not egregious, it is not different, it is in fact the norm.
[1:36:43]
Chief lands down also spoke eloquently yesterday about the problem of hiring people and having
[1:36:47]
them leave for other jurisdictions. Well that happens for a couple of reasons, pay and benefits
[1:36:51]
are among them. And to the extent that our pay and benefits are less than others, we risk being
[1:36:57]
a training ground. Unfortunately for all of us, we live in a wonderful city that people want to
[1:37:01]
serve and they're willing to take less pay and they do to serve the citizens here in San Diego.
[1:37:06]
Just comparing for one benchmark right here in the county of San Diego, the county retirement system has 3% at 50 for public safety members.
[1:37:15]
But our system here has a 90% cap. Once you reach 90% if you opt for the 350, then you are a cap. You can't earn more than that as a final compensation under retirement.
[1:37:24]
Under the county system, there is no such cap. If you work over 30 years, you get an additional 3% a year. If you work 35 years, you're going to go out at 105%.
[1:37:34]
And that number just keeps growing based on the length of time that you choose to serve above 30 years, 30 years, 3 percent, 90 percent.
[1:37:42]
Here that would be a cap. It didn't matter how long you work after that.
[1:37:45]
Your benefit doesn't go up. Under the county system it continues to go up.
[1:37:49]
The county has a 3 percent cost of living adjustment after your retire. That doesn't sound like much.
[1:37:53]
We're at two. The benefits that we have are a 2 percent cost of living. They're at three.
[1:37:58]
The actuary for the retirement system, Rick Rotter, I asked him a question, what would it cost if we were to add that benefit?
[1:38:02]
He said that unfunded liability alone for a 3% coal is $400 million.
[1:38:08]
If you wanted to add just 1% to the cost of living adjustment for your retired members, it
[1:38:13]
would cost $400 million in unfunded liability plus an annual normal cost increase on top
[1:38:19]
of that.
[1:38:20]
The county also has retiree health care benefits.
[1:38:23]
I called around the state, talked recently to the gentleman who had Sacramento firefighters,
[1:38:28]
their retiree health care benefits a thousand dollars a month, $12,000 a year.
[1:38:32]
to be used for a member and or their family.
[1:38:34]
The benefit here is for a member only, there's no coverage for a family under any circumstances
[1:38:39]
and it's under $500 a month.
[1:38:42]
The county also pays nine and a half percent of the employee's contribution towards retirement.
[1:38:47]
So about the only thing that leaves us with that might separate us from the rest of the state
[1:38:50]
is drop, although there are two other cities that have drop within the state of California.
[1:38:55]
Fresno has dropped, so does Los Angeles City.
[1:38:57]
Drop by the manager's report saves the city $15.9 million dollars and that was an estimate.
[1:39:04]
I happen to believe that estimate is low for two reasons.
[1:39:07]
One is more people are entering drop every day and every person that enters drop the
[1:39:11]
taxpayer saves money, the general fund saves money on that entry because you're no longer
[1:39:15]
accruing a retirement benefit, you're no longer making payments for that retirement benefit
[1:39:20]
and that's where the savings is generated.
[1:39:22]
There's been another change by the city council that is added to that and that is the cost
[1:39:26]
of retirement health care.
[1:39:27]
It was paid out of the retirement system when this report was done.
[1:39:31]
The council has subsequently voted to pay it out of the general fund.
[1:39:35]
What does that mean?
[1:39:35]
You have almost 1,000 employees today that are in drop.
[1:39:40]
That's 1,000 out of 11,000 total.
[1:39:42]
That 1,000 employees, the general fund, is not paying health care as a retirement benefit.
[1:39:48]
The general fund is paying, as you would, for any city employee, the flexible benefit
[1:39:53]
amount.
[1:39:54]
Had that person retired, you'd be paying retiree health care, had they been replaced with a new hire you'd be paying.
[1:40:00]
The flexible benefit cost for full-time employee. So what happens when a person moves to drop is there is no retiree health care.
[1:40:08]
It remain an active employee, remain under that health care benefit. And so those thousand people no longer are costing the general fund the health care process.
[1:40:17]
So when you finish and do a more comprehensive analysis, taking into account those changes, you will find that drop has saved additional money over and above the $15.9 million.
[1:40:28]
Lastly, firefighters for $1,000.
[1:40:31]
Thank you.
[1:40:31]
I'll give you one minute to wrap up.
[1:40:33]
Thank you, sir.
[1:40:33]
And then I'm going to cut you off.
[1:40:34]
That's fine.
[1:40:35]
Thank you very much.
[1:40:36]
I appreciate that.
[1:40:37]
Recently, the Center for Policy Initiative did a comprehensive report on city finance, tax
[1:40:42]
levels, and service levels reported, quote, the number of firefighters per thousand people,
[1:40:48]
0.69, is the lowest in San Diego among any city in California for which data are available.
[1:40:55]
San Diego provides fire protection and paramedic services with fewer firefighters at lower
[1:41:00]
cost than any other major city in the state of California.
[1:41:05]
So what does that mean?
[1:41:07]
San Diego Fire Department does more with less for less.
[1:41:12]
We appreciate your consideration.
[1:41:14]
I know this is a very difficult time.
[1:41:16]
Thank you for your time.
[1:41:17]
And
[1:41:20]
Nancy Robertson, Jeff Carr, representing MEA, the two of you are coming up with a total
[1:41:30]
six minutes or three minutes each.
[1:41:33]
I'm going to speak first for three minutes in the Mr. Carr.
[1:41:36]
Thank you.
[1:41:36]
Three minutes each.
[1:41:37]
Thank you.
[1:41:39]
Thank you, Honorable Mayor Murphy, Council members, and City Manager.
[1:41:44]
I am Nancy Roberts.
[1:41:45]
I'm the supervising labor relations representative for MEA, speaking on behalf of Judy
[1:41:51]
Italiano President of MEA, who is currently in the meeting converse session right now
[1:41:56]
with the city managers, representatives. MEA represents in the fire rescue department, the
[1:42:04]
lifeguards, fire dispatchers, administrative support staff, and other classifications and
[1:42:10]
the department. First of all, we'd like to commend and thank the department and the council
[1:42:15]
for continuing to work on the lifeguard facilities issues. We've been working on that
[1:42:22]
for many years and we're very pleased to see some progress on that and hopefully the bond
[1:42:28]
issues will be resolved. Additional progress can be made on replacing the old deteriorated
[1:42:35]
facilities and add the new ones where they are needed. And we'd like to thank you also
[1:42:40]
in the department for increasing the staffing of the North Pacific Beach area, which was
[1:42:46]
much needed to increase public safety and rescue. In regards to the wellness program, we repeat
[1:42:55]
what we stated last year when the program came online. Our concerns are that it is an extra when
[1:43:03]
We're looking at no funding for it, and that you're looking at cuts and concessions from
[1:43:10]
employees, so in our view it should not be supported by general fund dollars at this
[1:43:15]
time.
[1:43:16]
Additionally, the Department is proposing expanding the program to other fire agencies, and
[1:43:21]
if it is to be expanded with grant money, we believe it should be expanded to the lifeguards
[1:43:27]
before it's expanded to other fire agencies in the county.
[1:43:30]
In regard to the lifeguard dock, of course, we absolutely support that it is, as has been stated, it is underwater and the lifeguards have been going over to the high at hotel and the department is being charged in increased rate for the fuel, so it will certainly be a cost savings to get that repaired and get that back online.
[1:43:56]
Additionally, we support, of course, the departments proposal to replace the rescue boats
[1:44:10]
and the old mission beach lifeguard coverage in addition, and Mr. Carr is going to speak
[1:44:17]
to the dispatcher issues.
[1:44:19]
Thank you for your time and attention.
[1:44:20]
Have
[1:44:27]
a hand out.
[1:44:39]
Good morning. Jeff Carr, Senior Labor Relations Representative with MEA.
[1:44:46]
One of my jobs with MEA is representing fire dispatchers and it's one of my favorite jobs I might add.
[1:44:54]
We, as Chief Chairman mentioned, went to a process for all over a year.
[1:45:01]
Establishing one of the first 12-hour shifts in the history of the city, and we discussed that at length.
[1:45:10]
What you have before you are some speaking points and concerns that we have about the elimination of three positions for fire dispatchers that are on the books today.
[1:45:24]
The dispatchers that I represent are quite concerned about the potential for eliminating
[1:45:30]
those positions, and they are not filled at this time.
[1:45:35]
We believe that when you have the fire dispatch manager Susan Infantino and two assistant
[1:45:44]
managers at the council of the consoles doing dispatching, that that might say something about
[1:45:51]
staffing levels at fire dispatch. Now that doesn't happen all the time but it happens on occasion
[1:45:56]
in the middle of the night and it certainly speaks well to the devotion of management. But I don't
[1:46:01]
think that's the way the system should be working. And yet that happens on a somewhat regular basis.
[1:46:11]
That's a concern.
[1:46:14]
We believe also that with the amount of over time that the fire dispatcher's
[1:46:20]
you're working, that it certainly leads to morpheteague and potentially more repetitive motion
[1:46:27]
injuries. And by filling those three positions and bringing the staffing up to a full 32
[1:46:34]
positions in dispatch, that would eliminate a lot of that concern.
[1:46:43]
Certainly, the concerns
[1:46:45]
of those folks up there in dispatch is that if there were God forbid another firestorm
[1:46:51]
that having three additional positions as the current staffing model has it would certainly
[1:47:01]
be a bad for the image of the fire department, and the community certainly would not be
[1:47:08]
pleased to understand that three dispatch positions were eliminated in the budget in 2005.
[1:47:14]
I might add that part of the wellness budget, which is being proposed here today that that
[1:47:22]
be funded and we're concerned about that because it's not funded at this point that if
[1:47:28]
it were funded, certainly some of those dollars of $669,000, could be used to fill these
[1:47:36]
three positions that are currently vacant and being proposed to be eliminated.
[1:47:42]
We need to give you a one sentence wrap up.
[1:47:46]
We're also proposing potentially to if you would be interested in maintaining the or eliminating
[1:47:56]
the vacancies that we would go back to the meeting conferred table in April of next year
[1:48:00]
to discuss the re-implementation of those three positions if needed.
[1:48:04]
So we appreciate the time. Thank you very much all right, ladies and gentlemen, we're at 12 noon
[1:48:13]
We'll we'll come back at
[1:48:15]
To a clock to continue our discussion on the fire budget
[1:48:20]
For environmental services
[1:48:21]
I quite sure what to tell you, but just stop you have you what you have like a one minute
[1:48:27]
You do why there are other people slips in if you're gonna stay would just call you it's afternoon
[1:48:36]
Okay
[1:48:38]
Environmental services will probably trail the audit committee discussion, fire, audit committee,
[1:48:45]
environmental services, maybe you could just be on 15 minutes stand by or something like that.
[1:48:49]
So you have to stick around here often.
[1:50:01]
Swine, I am always
[1:52:44]
a couple of days.
[2:04:00]
Just to take the chances. So come on,
[2:04:06]
you got the same,
[2:04:09]
we're every gallon, you, but here is one night.
[2:05:00]
I'd you like to love me, and no other
[2:05:07]
like if you've got shame.
[2:11:27]
Sing much we,
[2:11:32]
for you brought a new kind of love to.
[2:11:41]
If the sandland
[2:11:46]
I'd want to see,
[2:11:51]
for you brought a new kind of love to me.
[2:12:00]
So that I'm the slave, you're the king
[2:12:05]
But still you can understand
[2:12:09]
That underneath it,
[2:12:14]
oh, and I am
[2:12:19]
over canceling
[2:12:24]
If I could hurry home, for you brought a new kind of love
[2:12:34]
Be
[2:12:39]
the slave of king, but still you can understand
[2:12:46]
And underneath it all
[2:12:58]
Where
[2:13:03]
if I
[2:13:07]
could draw it on your kind of love
[2:13:53]
The water from
[2:14:00]
the cheek
[2:14:11]
to soon come back
[2:14:14]
To me,
[2:14:32]
you say
[2:14:39]
And I'm covered by the star
[2:14:45]
It's guy above
[2:15:00]
Patiently waiting, hoping along
[2:15:09]
I am,
[2:15:13]
where
[2:15:38]
are you?
[2:15:49]
Where are you?
[2:15:50]
Musun, come back to me.
[2:18:18]
One of those
[2:18:38]
that took them to
[2:18:42]
the moon, got some away.
[2:18:46]
Just one of those that stay.
[2:19:16]
You're watching City TV 24.
[2:19:18]
You're access to City Hall.
[2:20:00]
The Community Service Center Program is bringing public services directly into the communities.
[2:20:06]
Instead of driving downtown residents and business owners can obtain many city services in a convenient location near their home or business.
[2:20:15]
Residents can obtain employment information, make city payments, obtain a minor building permit or get water conservation or recycling information.
[2:20:23]
Many of the centers are located with police storefront offices, so police officers and volunteers are available to meet with residents on safety issues.
[2:20:33]
Business owners can obtain business tax certificates and new business resource kits at any of the centers.
[2:20:40]
Each center offers services that are specific to that neighborhood.
[2:20:44]
For example, the College Rolando Center now offers district-be parking applications for the College Area.
[2:20:50]
If you plan to travel abroad, passport application services is offered at many of the centers.
[2:20:56]
Notary services are also available and can be done quickly for a nominal fee.
[2:21:01]
Meeting rooms are available to community groups at many of the centers.
[2:21:05]
Want to take care of city business on a Saturday?
[2:21:08]
The O time A semester center is open the first and third Saturday of each month.
[2:21:14]
There are 15 centers located across the city.
[2:21:18]
Call 619-668-2700 for directions to your nearest center or visit our website at sandiego.gov
[2:21:36]
And we small business owners are survivors, but how do you take that idea from mind to market?
[2:21:45]
This is the place to learn.
[2:21:50]
We have business school with happy brothers.
[2:21:54]
Together we'll learn about business from the inside out from the people who've done it.
[2:21:58]
We'll meet the men and women who are today's pioneers and why are heroes.
[2:22:01]
Their lives are the textiles.
[2:22:04]
Our classroom is the world.
[2:22:09]
Small business school is made possible by support from IBM.
[2:22:13]
We're not just for big business anymore.
[2:22:16]
At our website, discover how technology can move your business forward.
[2:22:20]
When it's your business, everything matters.
[2:22:23]
IBM.
[2:22:25]
And the United States Postal Service,
[2:22:27]
delivering the promise to America's 23 million small and growing businesses.
[2:22:31]
There's no way to the post office in your own office.
[2:22:34]
U.S.PS.com is waiting for you.
[2:22:39]
I'm Hattie Bryant.
[2:22:41]
Small Business School is a how-to program about starting running and growing a business.
[2:22:46]
And if you've had a chance to watch us every week, you've met many small business owners
[2:22:51]
who are doing fascinating things.
[2:22:53]
But this may be the most pioneering and adventure some soul we've ever introduced you to.
[2:22:59]
Sissy Harrington McGill makes healthy dog food, but she's always been up against the status quo,
[2:23:05]
so it's never been easy.
[2:23:07]
Usually in our master class, there are no gurus and no academics.
[2:23:12]
Most of our small business owners who so generously share their hardened insights and wisdom
[2:23:17]
in these master classes have very little formal education.
[2:23:21]
That's not the case with Sissy.
[2:23:22]
She has a master's degree in nutrition.
[2:23:25]
However, everything she knows about business, she's learned from experience.
[2:23:30]
So join us now in Southern California.
[2:23:32]
step into the masterclass with Sissy Harrington McGill.
[2:23:45]
Doc Food is a huge industry, but there's also room for the small business owner with big ideas and a mission.
[2:23:55]
The company is solid gold health products for pets in alcohol just a few miles east of San Diego, California.
[2:24:08]
Today, there are 45 items in the catalog, all for the purpose of keeping animals healthy.
[2:24:14]
Founders, Sissy Harrington McGill, have a master's degree in nutrition from Columbia,
[2:24:19]
and was a school teacher when she became the owner of a great day in 1958.
[2:24:26]
I have no children. My great days are my baby.
[2:24:29]
And when I have a dog that dies at a very young age, and I've taken supremely good care of him,
[2:24:36]
It must be something that I did wrong, so I want to find out why, so I don't lose the dog and another dog.
[2:24:44]
I think so. That's hot stuff. Great game was originally bred for the royalty and germany.
[2:24:50]
The American day in this to be 7 to 9. The German day in this to be 11 to 13, I'm saying how come.
[2:24:57]
Well, there are three things, there's nutrition.
[2:25:00]
There's genetics, and there's care. But we care for our much for our gains as the Germans do. The genetics are similar because we're always importing dogs. The only thing left is nutrition. So I took samples of the German dog food, and I put them in ziplock bags, cut the label off, and put them in the bags. I brought back a fawn son of the World Champion of 1974, the World Champion Great Dean, and I brought back dog food.
[2:25:31]
$3,000 worth of the German dog food and sold it quickly back in the U.S.
[2:25:35]
How did you get your first sale? Who bought your first bag of dog food?
[2:25:39]
Other great-dane breeders, other breeders of large dogs, German shepherds, iris, seders, dobermins, rotwilers.
[2:25:46]
But how did you get through these people? Did you go to shows?
[2:25:48]
Well, I don't know. I'll show you all the time.
[2:25:50]
Okay, I was showing my daines.
[2:25:52]
You're showing your daines and you just have like, you do have it in your trunk and you open the window.
[2:25:56]
Anybody want to buy something off?
[2:25:57]
No, you have papers and you know when people go to dog shows they're sitting around
[2:26:02]
at the edge and they're so bored, they'll read it to make a soup can.
[2:26:07]
So you give them fliers, okay?
[2:26:09]
And this is the product we have.
[2:26:11]
So the first dog show I was a vendor was in 1978 and I had set up there.
[2:26:19]
Well people say, oh is this the stuff you've been telling us about?
[2:26:22]
I sold everything that I had and then I had six people follow me to my garage to buy this dog food because they care about their dogs.
[2:26:31]
All right, so let me get this straight. You got the formula from the Germans. You bought it for license.
[2:26:37]
You had an American mill, make it for you.
[2:26:41]
And they shipped it to your garage?
[2:26:42]
Yep.
[2:26:44]
All right, tell me about that. You started with three tons in my garage and then eventually went up to 30 tons.
[2:26:50]
What is Captain of your cars out and everything else to make you know your business. So you start your business in your garage
[2:26:56]
Now her number one sales product is solid gold
[2:27:00]
The ingredients for this dry dog food for light no other
[2:27:04]
It's made from stone ground brown rice barley
[2:27:09]
Amaranth
[2:27:10]
Manhattan hearing organically grown black seed oil blueberries yucca catnip and hydrangea
[2:27:16]
you will find no animal fat, no poultry or poultry byproducts, no salt, and no sugar.
[2:27:23]
These are the various herbs that we put into some of our different products. For example,
[2:27:27]
here we have Hydrangea, which is a plant that helps to prevent bladder and kidney stones
[2:27:32]
from forming in you, your horse, your dog, your cat. And that's because 3 million years ago,
[2:27:39]
when the ice age covered the western hemisphere, when the ice melted,
[2:27:42]
drain the trace minerals out of the soil in certain parts of the United States from the Iraqi
[2:27:47]
mountains to the Pacific Ocean. Our soil is so dry and we also call it a dobi. Nothing
[2:27:54]
grows and it's alkali. Now the water comes through from Colorado here. Now it's so alkali
[2:28:00]
forms bladder and kidney stones particularly in cats. Now alkali hydrangea is an acid.
[2:28:11]
So it's
[2:28:12]
I just did it inside and kind of taste sweet, that's okay, that's not just because it's good doesn't it has taste bad
[2:28:18]
No, no, no, it tastes good. What does passion flower do? Can I just make sure passion flower is one of the ingredients in a farmer
[2:28:25]
Because it helps to calm the animal down
[2:28:28]
You know any horse that wins a race as tested for drugs immediately the urine and the saliva and this is considered a food
[2:28:37]
You don't have to draw the cash above.
[2:28:39]
All of the earth.
[2:28:42]
First of all, I take everything first.
[2:28:44]
Then I take everything that you take.
[2:28:46]
I take your animal.
[2:28:46]
I don't take it.
[2:28:47]
I consume it.
[2:28:49]
And then if it's okay, then my dogs get it.
[2:28:52]
And then if it's okay, friends dog get it.
[2:28:55]
Now, most of these facilities that are very large dog food companies, they have 40 dogs to test.
[2:28:59]
These are mostly beagles, because beagles don't need the interaction all the time with people.
[2:29:05]
Now, the dogs that test my products, these are house dogs.
[2:29:09]
In fact, if you can get them off the bed, you're lucky.
[2:29:11]
You know, although my dogs are not allowed on the furniture,
[2:29:14]
because they take up too much room.
[2:29:16]
And so anyway, if there's something wrong with a product,
[2:29:19]
those people will know that day.
[2:29:21]
And that's when I hear about it right away before,
[2:29:23]
because when you start burping a smell, this is all the things
[2:29:29]
that when you have a homebody dog, they know about it right away.
[2:29:34]
Sisi shifts the products in air-tight packages to ensure freshness, finding the right
[2:29:41]
ingredients and convincing foreign suppliers to sell to her in the beginning, tried her patients.
[2:29:47]
I wrote to the company, and in fact, I wrote to several companies, and I signed my name as
[2:29:52]
Harrington McGill. Sisi is a dumb name, Gertred is worse. So mother and I arrived in London and
[2:30:00]
Time and I called, Phillips used to reconfirm our appointment that I had, in fact, arrived. And the man said to me, are you a representative of solid gold? And I said, well, I am solid gold, and he counseled the appointment. Well, I couldn't understand what was going on. So I called back, and I spoke to a lady by name of Mrs. White, and she said, I'm sorry. We don't do business with women, and she hung up. Well, I think come 6,000 miles for nothing.
[2:30:28]
So, I went over during my appointed time, and I sat and she said, well, your appointment has been cancelled.
[2:30:35]
I said, I know, but I'd like to talk to Mr. Phillips. Yeah, anyway.
[2:30:39]
So, I sat there for about two hours, and I guess you figured, I wasn't going to leave.
[2:30:44]
So, he came out and told me that he was not interested in having any of his products into the United States.
[2:30:50]
So, then what did you do?
[2:30:51]
Well, I called up the veterinary clinic of Buster Lloyd Jones, of that, in Southern England, and it was canceled.
[2:31:00]
It's an exact same race that we don't do business with women.
[2:31:03]
So at that point in time, I had been writing for 44 different national dog magazines, articles on nutrition.
[2:31:10]
And I write for free, and I do this on purpose.
[2:31:12]
Number one, I don't copy right up.
[2:31:15]
So all these other dog clubs can use that in their local magazines, and so I started sending
[2:31:24]
him copies to Dr. Lloyd Jones and also Philips Hughes Company that I wasn't a stupid woman.
[2:31:31]
I have a Master's degree from Columbia University and I had a doctorate all but the dissertation
[2:31:36]
from Berkeley. So I started writing to them and after a while Philips Hughes company thought,
[2:31:44]
So maybe they should sell me their burrsiest to repel, please.
[2:31:49]
And within three years I got the award from the Philipshees Company as the most outstanding
[2:31:57]
salesman of the year.
[2:32:02]
When does it dawn on you that in order to grow this, you're going to have to walk away from
[2:32:08]
the job?
[2:32:09]
By 1976, after about two years, by 1977, I knew I couldn't do a good job teaching because I was so involved with the dog food.
[2:32:22]
So you had to do one of the other. If I couldn't do a job, that was the best I could do for somebody paying me, I shouldn't be in the job.
[2:32:30]
So I told my principal that I would be resigning.
[2:32:33]
I took all the money out of my teachers' retirement to put into this, so I could never go back to teacher.
[2:32:40]
And at that time, your single, if this doesn't make it, then I'll be a bag lady out on the street.
[2:32:49]
Is that a good technique?
[2:32:51]
Works for me.
[2:32:52]
It didn't scare you.
[2:32:55]
When did you know that it was going to be good for your dog that other people would buy a tube?
[2:33:01]
I don't remember when it started to seem to be always there.
[2:33:06]
How did you get your first pet shop to put your product in your store?
[2:33:10]
Many people that do dog shows our pet groomers or pet stores.
[2:33:14]
And they say, can I put it in my store?
[2:33:17]
And then when people call up as a response to these ads,
[2:33:20]
they say, I live in Redondo Beach, I live in Anaham.
[2:33:22]
Oh, I've got somebody there.
[2:33:24]
And then eventually you get distributors.
[2:33:26]
Now that's the way to go.
[2:33:28]
When do you think this stopped being your hobby and started being a business when I moved
[2:33:33]
out of the house in 1984?
[2:33:37]
Customers buy from all over the world and include the rich and famous rich people, their
[2:33:44]
so rich they want to live a long time, I guess, to spend their money and they want their
[2:33:48]
dogs to live a long time.
[2:33:50]
I'll tell you a quick story about Jaja Gabor.
[2:33:53]
This is many years ago.
[2:33:56]
She would call up and we would send product to her.
[2:34:00]
One lady, and I would mention a call up and she wanted to buy some of the dog food for her
[2:34:05]
dogs.
[2:34:06]
And I said, oh, I always say, how'd you care about it?
[2:34:08]
She said, Jaja, tell me.
[2:34:10]
I said, you are a friend of Jaja, she's just not at all.
[2:34:14]
Okay.
[2:34:15]
Well, I was sitting at a restaurant, and I was telling my friend that I was having
[2:34:20]
lunch with that my dog had terrible skin problems and Joshua's at the next table and she jumped
[2:34:25]
up and ran over and said you have to feed the solid gold fund in flocking. In 1994 the small
[2:34:33]
business administration named solid gold exporter of the year from California. One third of
[2:34:39]
Sissy 7.5 million dollars in sales go to Japan. Mani Rosino has been Sissy sales manager for
[2:34:47]
10 years.
[2:34:48]
And something just happened.
[2:34:49]
You just came in and said something good just happened.
[2:34:52]
What happened?
[2:34:52]
I'm very happy because I say not far to my main account in Japan and they sent me a projection
[2:34:58]
they do that every year.
[2:35:00]
They send me my presentation for these years, which is very, very, good.
[2:35:05]
The Japanese, because the dropping of the bomb in Hiroshima, don't like any chemicals, don't like anything they weaken the body.
[2:35:16]
And artificial preservatives tend to weaken the body, particularly the kidneys and the liver.
[2:35:20]
So there are very much in favor of natural products.
[2:35:26]
So if you're one of your big markets, they're our biggest count.
[2:35:31]
You sell more product, solid gold to Japan than you do in the US.
[2:35:36]
Absolutely. Many times. Many times over. How did you get your first sale in Japan?
[2:35:42]
I took an ad in Dog World magazine, and the woman wanted us to air mail a 40 pound second dog food,
[2:35:50]
which cost her $63 to send a 20 pound second dog food to Japan.
[2:35:55]
Her name is Yoko Suzuki, her name, lady, and she established this dog food company, and we're
[2:36:03]
now, if not the top, where the only natural dog food over there, I know this other dog food
[2:36:09]
is a dog food.
[2:36:10]
Is she your distributor?
[2:36:12]
She is a solid gold of Japan, and then she disseminated throughout the country, and also to
[2:36:18]
a poor to Hong Kong, to Taiwan, and various parts of New Zealand and Australia.
[2:36:28]
Even though she's enjoying success, Sissy still looks to the customer to test new ideas.
[2:36:34]
Now, I don't have to do dog shows anymore.
[2:36:37]
I have other people that do them, but I do them because I want to hear what the people say.
[2:36:42]
And I do trade shows, and they'll say to me, well, this worked out very well, and that
[2:36:46]
work worth the darn. I say, tell me why it didn't work. And you're not just going to
[2:36:51]
the pet shop, see they're going to the owners of the dog. For example, the canned dog for
[2:36:57]
the Disney event on the market yet. We had whole shipping to come in, it was too suppy. So
[2:37:02]
that didn't work out. So we had to change that around. It's constant tweaking. It's constant
[2:37:06]
testing things. And you're advertising is different. Tell me about that. Most advertising
[2:37:11]
and let you see a very attractive, they're four color, they have cute little cute sea pictures.
[2:37:16]
And you see the advertising once and never read it a second time when you see it because you've always read it the first time.
[2:37:22]
Are advertising, these are articles.
[2:37:25]
And if you take the two minutes to read the article, you'll learn something.
[2:37:29]
And people like to learn things.
[2:37:31]
So that's always been your philosophy.
[2:37:32]
But again, I'm going to say, well, I'm going to say, what's the teacher always a teacher?
[2:37:35]
right? Because now that I have an interesting headline of how to catch people's attention, the
[2:37:42]
things we do 2x2 we pay for 4x4. Now that one was 8x4, another guy young, another one
[2:37:48]
is a mind stretched by a new idea and never goes back to its original size. So you grab people's
[2:37:53]
attention by being a teacher as opposed to the flashy expensive 4x4. And if somebody disagrees
[2:38:00]
with me, I hear about it right away, and our 800 number is dog-hunt, DOG, H-U-N-D. So they call
[2:38:09]
me free, and they say, now, I don't agree with that last ad, V cause. I have to be the best
[2:38:14]
example of my own products, I said, I'm going to be 64 next month. So I have to be the best
[2:38:20]
example, I can't be overweight, I don't smoke, and I have to be a healthy looking person,
[2:38:25]
and nobody's going to believe that I have a healthy dog food. Right. Right. But let me go
[2:38:29]
to the idea of if you as a business person have been successful. Why do you think you're successful?
[2:38:36]
I think of course I work hard at it. I work a 24-hour day so to speak. When I go home at night,
[2:38:41]
I study nutrition. I have all these magazines. In my car, I have maybe 10 magazines on dog,
[2:38:49]
cat, and people nutrition. And if I have to go someplace and wait 10 minutes, I can get 10 minutes of reading.
[2:38:55]
Talk to me now about the 20 years and what have been some of the obstacles that have held
[2:39:01]
you back.
[2:39:02]
The government is the main obstacle against small businesses.
[2:39:08]
The government likes the status quo.
[2:39:12]
I'm not the status quo.
[2:39:13]
What do you mean?
[2:39:15]
The function of the FDA is quote to protect people.
[2:39:19]
They have already said I practiced witchcraft. I wasn't sure if it was a W or a B. They were calling me at the time
[2:39:26]
But they did not want any natural products into the United States in 1974
[2:39:32]
Why didn't you give up?
[2:39:37]
There are many times I wanted to. I thought if I could just die all this would be over
[2:39:42]
With the Lord wouldn't let me die. So I had to stay alive. It's your help
[2:39:46]
I have a stand live, you have to go forward.
[2:39:49]
It was that expression when I die, I want to go to heaven because I had my own business
[2:39:53]
I already been through hell.
[2:40:00]
The pet food industry is huge, but there's always room for a small business owner with big ideas and a mission.
[2:40:08]
Sissy is a perfect example of the type of entrepreneur who wants to change the world. Making money is way down on her list.
[2:40:17]
In bringing to the attention of dog lovers of the importance of nutrition, she's defined herself as preacher, teacher, champion and advocate.
[2:40:26]
It is her strong personal commitment and her individualistic style that make this business work.
[2:40:33]
She is a perpetual seeker.
[2:40:35]
She is constantly looking for new products and new ways to use products to help her dogs and
[2:40:41]
her customers and animals live longer, healthier lives.
[2:40:45]
She'll bring any idea to the marketplace that she believes will work.
[2:40:49]
And this is where she sometimes gets in trouble.
[2:40:52]
She may be up against the status quo, she may have to fight the system, but she's willing to do it.
[2:40:58]
This hasn't been easy for Sissy.
[2:41:00]
When you make a strong statement, you put yourself at risk.
[2:41:04]
She admits that many veterinarians purchase her products and recommend her products, but many don't.
[2:41:10]
The bottom line is, she's the type of entrepreneur who does not go along to get along.
[2:41:15]
If you choose this type of business, you choose a difficult way of life.
[2:41:20]
In fact, solid gold isn't a business, it is a way of life.
[2:41:25]
If you want to make the world a better place, stop selling products and start selling
[2:41:30]
your customers a better way of life.
[2:41:33]
Should you be exporting to Japan or in the other country, come to our website smallbsyschool.org
[2:41:39]
forward slash export. You'll find links to plenty of free information about starting and growing
[2:41:45]
a business through exporting.
[2:41:49]
At smallbusyschool.org, there is self help study for people who want to start a business
[2:41:54]
and for those who want to grow the business they have. From the home page, choose steps to start
[2:42:00]
or steps to grow. Next, you'll find eight steps or stages of growth. At each step, you'll find
[2:42:07]
links to more resources. Also, from the home page you can choose, learn online, for access,
[2:42:14]
to streaming video, and interactive study guides.
[2:42:22]
Sissy has a small retail shop with a home spun flavor, and also offers do-it-yourself
[2:42:28]
dog washing facilities.
[2:42:38]
What advice would you give someone who wants to start a business
[2:42:42]
our global business. Make sure there's a need for your product. Make sure your product is unique
[2:42:47]
and that it's different from other products, not so different that you're out on a limb,
[2:42:52]
but different enough the people can see the comparison between the two. Just make sure your product
[2:42:57]
is better and don't have it so out for out price that nobody can afford it. Okay, so unique,
[2:43:04]
high quality, price right, and you have the market. Solid gold is proof that a business can be
[2:43:12]
built by focusing on a niche, loving your product, and loving your customers.
[2:43:19]
So the reason you're doing business is to change the world.
[2:43:25]
Better health brings more joy.
[2:43:27]
If I can make a healthy dog, makes people happy.
[2:43:32]
When I die, I want to leave the dog world in a better place than it was when I came in.
[2:43:39]
I want to have a purpose of doing something good.
[2:43:44]
When I'm here, I want to make a difference.
[2:44:00]
For Sissy, Market Expansion has come from word of mouth.
[2:44:04]
John Wargo, our marketing advisor now tells us
[2:44:06]
about how another business owner makes word of mouth happen.
[2:44:11]
John, a couple of years ago, we studied Madison Park Reading
[2:44:14]
Cards.
[2:44:15]
And the shops sell their cards a very unique boutiques.
[2:44:19]
Now what we found out recently is guess what?
[2:44:21]
They're using more mail.
[2:44:22]
They did one for themselves, now we found out that in addition to doing her catalog and
[2:44:29]
mailing it to her database, she is now marketing other card companies products, producing
[2:44:34]
their catalogs and sending it to her old database.
[2:44:37]
They have found a customer base that is looking for unique cards by adding to the product
[2:44:43]
line, and what she's able to do is get creativity from a variety of different sources.
[2:44:48]
So now the Boteek that's looking for creative cars, okay, has got far more variety and far more creativity
[2:44:55]
So you're really adding value by getting these additional catalogs in the hands of the other
[2:45:00]
See, Judy doesn't have to make these words, right? All she's doing is selling them, right? In a database management, what she's decided is, she just developed a relationship with customers that the demand that she has identified is part of greater than she could supply.
[2:45:16]
So now what she does is she gets additional card companies to satisfy that supply. So what she does, she expands her business by not activating her catalog line,
[2:45:26]
by letting somebody else do the catalogs
[2:45:28]
but by expanding and selling her knowledge
[2:45:31]
in database management.
[2:45:33]
Absolutely great business extension
[2:45:36]
for a small business person.
[2:45:37]
We have that we ought to do, we have to leverage.
[2:45:39]
And she is leveraging her expertise,
[2:45:42]
supplementing it with additional supply
[2:45:45]
from other card companies, phenomenal opportunity.
[2:45:48]
So John, what can we really learn from Judy here?
[2:45:50]
Every small business really has to be disciplined
[2:45:53]
in address management, database management.
[2:45:56]
You need to capture the right name, the right spelling,
[2:46:00]
the right address, the right city, the right zip code,
[2:46:03]
and even the right phone number.
[2:46:05]
And any other information that they give you,
[2:46:08]
about themselves, you should find someplace in your data field
[2:46:12]
to put that information, because they're telling you something.
[2:46:15]
And whatever that is, you might be able to use
[2:46:18]
in order to customize your offer into that individual.
[2:46:21]
So Judy's pretty smart. She's brilliant. Data-based management is absolutely key for the success of most mild businesses.
[2:46:35]
Sissy is a perfect example of the type of entrepreneur who wants to change the world.
[2:46:40]
Making money is way down on her list. Do what you believe in, create value, do something good, and eventually the world will reward you for it.
[2:46:50]
We'll see you next time.
[2:46:56]
Small business was made possible by support from IBM, we're not just the big business
[2:47:01]
anymore.
[2:47:02]
At our website, discover how technology can rule your business forward when it's your
[2:47:07]
business, everything matters.
[2:47:09]
IBM, and the United States Postal Service, delivering the promise to America's 23 million
[2:47:15]
small and growing businesses, there's no way to the post office in your office, usps.com
[2:47:21]
is waiting for you.
[2:47:23]
If you want to learn more about starting running and growing a business, come to our website Small Business School.org
[2:47:30]
They're streaming video and interactive study guides.
[2:47:34]
The only way we can compete with big business is to be faster smarter and better.
[2:47:39]
We are the engine of the American economy. We create the jobs.
[2:47:44]
Business
[2:47:57]
is about big commitment. It's about sacrifice and struggle.
[2:48:01]
But we do it because we say if I don't do this, my wife won't be coming to me.
[2:48:18]
For when I first hit me, applied energy in a forward direction equals human look of motion.
[2:48:24]
What does this all mean about?
[2:48:25]
What does this all mean about?
[2:48:27]
I thought, wow, this concept might actually change the way we get from point A to point D.
[2:48:33]
I thought the guy inside and meant to take the telephone.
[2:48:39]
I give you the human foot.
[2:48:42]
Get out, get moving!
[2:48:44]
A message from the American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons.
[2:48:50]
You're watching City TV 24.
[2:48:52]
Your access to City Hall.
[2:50:21]
Attentions between the North East South are relatively contained. If no other sectional controversy is developed, the country may be able to work out its differences, but the issues related to Western expansion soon spiral beyond control.
[2:50:40]
The 1850s is, in many ways, a cold war getting hotter. A series of crises of the set finish.
[2:50:49]
Uniironically, with a conference, a compromise that proved to be bankrupt.
[2:50:55]
You had the giants of American political life.
[2:50:58]
You had Henry Clay of Kentucky, a weird Daniel Webster of Massachusetts.
[2:51:03]
John C. Calhoun, the great senator from South Carolina, engaged in debate over the future of the nation.
[2:51:12]
With that future includes slavery.
[2:51:15]
As one historian, Giovanni has pointed out, that's a concern to the south, that the land
[2:51:20]
opened to slavery remains constant, and the slave population continues to grow at the
[2:51:26]
rate of roughly 25% per 10-year period per census.
[2:51:31]
Presently, you're going to have slaves chasing a lot of way of masters, so benevolent diffusion
[2:51:37]
It was the phrase that used on one of the communications, but opening up more of the land gain from the Mexican war, the American West, too, displayed by intentions of the world.
[2:51:50]
These aging senators play Calhu and Webster, whose voices have influenced decades of legislation, dominate the first phase of the debate.
[2:52:00]
In fact, Clay offers a compromise proposal, which allowed the slave trade by the selling of African Americans in the District of Columbia that passed a stringent fugitive slave act, which addressed the concerns of some sons, which organized new territories without the mention of slavery, thus allowing the people who settled those regions to determine the future of slavery in that area.
[2:52:30]
It admitted California as a free state, adopted some of the debt that Texas had been building up ever since, the Texas Revolution in 1836.
[2:52:41]
In any event, the Congress of 1850 was supposedly an omnibus bill and had everything for everyone.
[2:52:47]
Unfortunately, it really didn't solve any problems.
[2:52:50]
After six months of impassioned debate, Clay's proposal is difficult, and a younger group of leaders enters the scene.
[2:52:57]
William Stewart of New York, who opposes the compromise, Jefferson Davis and Mississippi, representing the new
[2:53:04]
cock and south, and Stephen A. Douglas of Illinois. Stephen Douglas, a little giant, by foot
[2:53:11]
too, but he could pack a wallet. A fabulous speaker, like many of the great politicians of that day,
[2:53:18]
was a leader of a political movement called the Young Democrats. He took over the reigns of power
[2:53:25]
from Henry Clay in the Albany negotiation of the compromise of 1850.
[2:53:32]
The sudden death of President Zachary Taylor removes one major obstacle to the compromise.
[2:53:39]
That, and Douglas' decision, to break up the omnibus film into a series of separate measures
[2:53:43]
that could be considered individually, broke the deadlock.
[2:53:47]
By September, the compromise legislation is enacted into law, with the support of President Miller-Philmore.
[2:53:53]
elements of this compromise were problematical. They satisfied nobody, but they did allow the nation to go on for a while
[2:54:02]
but
[2:54:02]
crumbling crumbling
[2:54:05]
The first thing to go was the two-party system now both the weeks and the democrats were national parties
[2:54:12]
but over the issue of slavery they became sectional parties and this happened first in the weeks the weeks disintegrated
[2:54:20]
1851 to 52 to 53, they just simply cease to exist as a party because they couldn't bring their northern and southern wings together.
[2:54:30]
As a result, Democrat Franklin Pierce wins the presidency of 1852, allowing to maintain national harmony by avoiding divisive issues.
[2:54:39]
But as Western Territories once considered unfit for cultivation, begin to open up, questions of slave versus free, begin to take center stage.
[2:54:51]
Even the root of the proposed Transcontinental Railroad becomes an issue.
[2:54:55]
Until the mid-19th century, the direction of movement in this continent is from...
[2:55:00]
South for the North. It's from Mexico, North, where else is coming down Hudson's bay down the Pacific coast.
[2:55:05]
First with the gold rush in the Oregon Trail, which was relatively small migrations, compared to it's coming later.
[2:55:11]
They began to ship the little bit east west, but with the railways, the whole continent re-oriented, from the west to the east and east to the west.
[2:55:19]
It allows a whole set of resources which existed in the west to really added the national economy.
[2:55:24]
It's even a Douglas Senator from the Illinois, perhaps because he wanted the Eastern
[2:55:30]
Trauminess of a Transcontinental Railroad to be Chicago instead of St. Louis or New
[2:55:34]
Arms.
[2:55:35]
He doesn't need to get some states organized in territories for his west, but both the chaos
[2:55:40]
is a rescue aid.
[2:55:42]
And when he did, he created a great controversy, because the Southern Senators, the Southern
[2:55:50]
political elite, the southern planters, southern Democrats, said wait a minute, if Kansas is
[2:55:57]
organized as a territory, it's probably going to come in as a free state and then where
[2:56:02]
are we going to be? And of course Stephen Douglas needed the Democratic votes in order to pass
[2:56:07]
as well. And so he said to them, what can I do to get this bill passed? Because he was thinking
[2:56:13]
Organize the territory, get the pioneers out there, and get the railroad through there.
[2:56:20]
They said abolish the Missouri Compromising Line.
[2:56:26]
Throw it open to popular sovereignty.
[2:56:28]
Well, it was a hard sell in the north, but you was able to do it just barely.
[2:56:34]
Mostly with Southern votes.
[2:56:36]
So you had the Kansas Nebraska bill pass in 1854.
[2:56:39]
And not suddenly there's a community so war, that takes place in Kansas as the attempts to determine whether it's going to be a slave state or free soil.
[2:56:52]
The first shot, I guess you could say, was fired by Senator David Hutchinson of Missouri.
[2:56:59]
And he said in his Senate speech, and here I'm paraphrasing, we are going to organize the
[2:57:04]
Kansas for slavery.
[2:57:07]
And on the other side, Senator Charles Sumner, and many Massachusetts men said, we're
[2:57:13]
going to fund settlers to go in to Kansas and organize as a free state.
[2:57:20]
So the situation was polarized from the get go.
[2:57:24]
Territorial elections in the spring of 1855, in the night of storm of protest, there are
[2:57:31]
memorial ruffians who ride across from Missouri and vote in case of selections, and in the process they offer them.
[2:57:41]
You had almost an exclusively pro-slavery territorial legislature that was elected fraudulently.
[2:57:51]
So, if you were president Franklin Pierce from New Hampshire, what would you do?
[2:57:58]
Clearly, thousands of votes were fraudulent.
[2:58:01]
There was no doubt about that.
[2:58:02]
Well, he decided that he would accept the election of the fraudulent legislature rather than stir up any trouble.
[2:58:13]
He free status, decided to hold their own election,
[2:58:17]
and they established their own capital, which was at Lawrence Kansas.
[2:58:22]
So you had two governments and you also had a number of men who were organizing themselves into the mission and it was a very very unstable situation.
[2:58:34]
You have some of the most brutal guerrilla fighting in the American history.
[2:58:38]
But this is largely Nikron.
[2:58:41]
I'm able to produce the James gang, the younger gang, my trails, radios, and we'll also be Jay Hawkers in Kansas who will raid back into Missouri.
[2:58:50]
Oh man, name John Brown, goes into the homes of some prominent pro-slayer people, takes them out and similarly executes them.
[2:58:59]
Apologizing, but saying that gee, you're pro-slayer, and we can have that, and this is an absolute.
[2:59:05]
You can only fight on this level, because exercise is kind of cruelty, which is really personal.
[2:59:10]
I mean, these are people who sometimes have been neighbors who know each other, hate each other,
[2:59:14]
and I'm nowhere to find each other.
[2:59:16]
And it's the kind of thing which will devastate this kind of countryside atrocities on both sides.
[2:59:21]
Both sides will raise the black flag. They take no prisoners.
[2:59:24]
Causes become bleeding cancels.
[2:59:27]
So it's so that if you, as state's army, have to go there in an effort to try to keep the peace.
[2:59:35]
And this controversy came back to the halls of Congress, and that is when you had the debates over what to do in Kansas between Charles Sumner attacking the Southern Senator from South Carolina, and calling slavery a whore, and his attack by a representative from South Carolina President Brooks.
[3:00:00]
So if you just can imagine this kind of thing happening on an ordinary daily basis, it just really did seem like the country was falling apart.
[3:00:30]
John Fremont, who gained fame as the man who met the Oregon Trail.
[3:00:35]
Young and vicious former Wigs, like Abraham Lincoln, like Sam and Chase, like Joshua Giddings,
[3:00:42]
like Charles Sunder, joined the Republican Party because it took the economic program of the Wigs
[3:00:48]
and wedded it to anti-slavery principles when it came to slavery and the territories.
[3:00:53]
And as it turned out, Fremont did very well in a three-way race, which, if you can, in one.
[3:01:00]
And the thing about the Republican Party that most students of American history tend to forget is that it was the first party ever in American history to arise out of a purely sectional issue.
[3:01:16]
So, it was a northern party, identified with northern leaders, appealing to the northern
[3:01:21]
electorate, with no base at all in the southern party.
[3:01:26]
In the U.B. canon takes office, a financial panic strikes the country, followed by a depression
[3:01:32]
with last several years.
[3:01:34]
And in March of 1857, only two days after Buchanan's inauguration, the Supreme Court of the
[3:01:40]
United States, hands down one of the most controversial decisions in its history.
[3:01:45]
It's moving in the case of Gred Scott versus Sanford.
[3:01:50]
Gred Scott had been a slave.
[3:01:52]
He had belonged to an army physician,
[3:01:55]
who had taken Gred Scott in the course of his military service,
[3:02:00]
into territory that had been made free soil
[3:02:03]
by the Northwest Ordinance,
[3:02:05]
and by the Major Capitalists.
[3:02:09]
And on the basis of that,
[3:02:10]
when the surgeon died,
[3:02:12]
God sued him as a state for his freedom. The case took nanniers to get a Supreme Court.
[3:02:18]
The court said, first of all, that Dreads God was not a citizen thus could not sue.
[3:02:24]
And thus they threw out his suit for his freedom. However, the court went on,
[3:02:29]
which he didn't have to do, to say that slaves are property, and you can take property.
[3:02:35]
Anyplace in the country. Therefore you can't make anyplace for his sort.
[3:02:38]
was the implication and this rape forced an impious upon those who would abolish slavery or even
[3:02:47]
limited in any way.
[3:02:49]
And it was in these circumstances that in 1858 the contest for the Senator from Illinois
[3:02:58]
should occupy our attention because in that contest you had able him leaking pitted against
[3:03:05]
his old rival, Stephen Douglas.
[3:03:07]
Yeah, the Constitution, of course, during the 19th century, prescribed that senators would be chosen by state legislatures.
[3:03:15]
However, candidates for the Senate could reinforce the candidacy by appealing to the people, who, of course, elected to state legislatures.
[3:03:23]
So Lincoln and Douglas, conducted a series of debates throughout the state of Illinois, and really made Lincoln a not a household word necessarily, but a known name, in a way that nothing else probably could.
[3:03:36]
They were all day affairs with Lincoln and Douglas each talking mainly about slavery.
[3:03:44]
It was just amazing how important they were and how well attended they were and how eloquent both men were.
[3:03:52]
And if you can imagine the six foot for Lincoln standing next to the five foot to Douglas and really laying out the position of the Republican Party and the Democratic Party in these marvelous series of debates.
[3:04:06]
so everyone was reading about them. Everyone was wondering what Stephen Douglas was going to say about
[3:04:13]
the dread Scott decision. How Abraham Lincoln was going to respond with Stephen Douglas charged
[3:04:18]
Abraham Lincoln in the Republican Party with being quote unquote, nigger loving and advocating
[3:04:24]
racial amalgamation. So you had so many important issues about the country being discussed in these
[3:04:30]
elections in a very political circus-like atmosphere that was part and parcel of the election
[3:04:37]
during the 19th century.
[3:04:40]
Douglas wins the Senate seat in 1858, but beyond Illinois, the Democrats lose ground.
[3:04:46]
The party forfits its majority in the House, resulting in stormy congressional sessions during
[3:04:51]
the next two years.
[3:04:53]
The Battles in Congress, however, are soon overshadowed by a spectacular event just south
[3:04:58]
of the Capitol.
[3:05:00]
John Brown's reign among
[3:05:04]
had been prominent in allowing to making Kansas bleed. He migrated east again, collected a number of his followers. He had visions about striking a blow against slavery.
[3:05:16]
And in October of 1859, swept into Harper's Ferry and attempted to capture this little oversized tail.
[3:05:26]
A local footage to drive young Brown and a few, maybe half a dozen of his followers into a fire engine as all the arsenal lands in Harper's Ferry.
[3:05:38]
And there, they essentially trapped Brown and 13 hostages.
[3:05:43]
The rumors that reached the war department in Washington claimed that as many as
[3:05:48]
2,000 one-of-way slaves have seized control of the arsenal at Harper's Ferry.
[3:05:54]
The Secretary of War summons Colonel Robert E. Lee and Jeb Stewart, who just happened to be in the area.
[3:06:00]
They briefly told him he could have a couple of companies and were re-used, which were the only soldiers in the neighborhood.
[3:06:06]
But those raids are at times of time to our fairings.
[3:06:11]
They still enslaved us and Stuart, followed by a common deer and another real little engine, and set it behind the Marines.
[3:06:21]
It is dark when they arrive.
[3:06:23]
We surveys the situation and begins formulating the plan.
[3:06:27]
Jebs do it, we're himsari.
[3:06:30]
We'll take the fugitives a chance to surrender.
[3:06:32]
If they refuse, the Marine Commander Israel Green will take 12 men and charge the fire house where Brown and his followers are barricaded.
[3:06:41]
And at dawn the next morning, Lee watches his plans unfold.
[3:06:46]
And Jeb Stuart probably very nervous.
[3:06:49]
Waving a white flag walked up to the door.
[3:06:54]
Black and Stuart looked into the face of the carbon.
[3:06:58]
He recognized the man at the other end of that army, as John Brown, because Stewart had encountered him in Kansas in the G-56.
[3:07:08]
Stewart has him these votes. Brown immediately had predicted Chempton to bargain using the hostages.
[3:07:15]
He gave me a mile's head start and I will turn these hostages to record these instructions that no.
[3:07:22]
to every attempt at bargain, and family when he realized that Brown was not going to surrender,
[3:07:28]
to a step back from the door, and waiting for his cap.
[3:07:32]
He was with a signal to his usual brain and his valines.
[3:07:37]
The reeds charged the firehouse.
[3:07:40]
The reeds was armed only with a life-dressed sword.
[3:07:44]
He charged the man who's loading this weapon, tried to stab him,
[3:07:48]
and then, with a certain friend, he ended up using the hills of the sword.
[3:07:52]
to pummel Brown into unconsciousness.
[3:07:55]
Meanwhile, his fellow Marines had made short work of the Raiders.
[3:08:00]
So, John Brown was the Rating Harper's Fairy.
[3:08:04]
I think Lee deserves some credit for handling a hostage crisis.
[3:08:09]
He acted with decision and leadership
[3:08:11]
and not one hair of the 13 hostages was horror.
[3:08:17]
Brown finally found something he could do well.
[3:08:20]
That is he could die.
[3:08:23]
He challenged Americans then and now to consider what a just man ought to do when confronted with an unjust institution that he was slavery.
[3:08:35]
He went to his death unflinchingly and even inspired a man that they were later called Stonewall Jackson to write in his diary Brown died well.
[3:08:45]
No other single event does more than the Harper's Fairy Wave to convince white
[3:08:51]
souvenirs that they cannot live safely in the Union. It sets the stage for
[3:08:55]
a crucial presidential election. The election of 1860. The trial of John Brown for
[3:09:02]
Treeson was yet another incredibly divisive and controversial part of the
[3:09:09]
politics leading up to the A to 60 election. Now for the Republicans they were sure
[3:09:15]
that if they played the cards right, they could win in 1860 but who'd
[3:09:20]
nominate? And that is where Abraham Lincoln comes in because in 1859 he
[3:09:26]
embarked on a speech making tour. He was going to visit his son Robert at
[3:09:30]
Harvard and he was asked to speak at Cooper Union in New York City and he knew
[3:09:36]
it would have to be the speech of his life. Abraham Lincoln came into Cooper Union
[3:09:42]
This large auditorium with thousands of very high-falutans sophisticated northerners waiting to see what he could say for himself.
[3:09:52]
When Lincoln rose to speed, I was really disappointed. He was tall, tall, tall, and so angular and awesome.
[3:10:00]
Who, that I had for an instant of feeling of pity for so unganement?
[3:10:06]
Those who insist that federal control of slavery and federal territories violates the constitution,
[3:10:14]
point us to the provision which they suppose it must violates.
[3:10:19]
Your purpose then plainly stated is that you will destroy the government unless you be allowed to
[3:10:25]
through and enforce the constitution as you please.
[3:10:30]
And he blew people away with his speech.
[3:10:33]
His face lighted up as with an inward fire.
[3:10:36]
The whole man was transfigured.
[3:10:38]
I forgot his clothes, his personal appearance, and his individual peculiarities.
[3:10:43]
You will not abide the election.
[3:10:45]
I'll be Republican president.
[3:10:48]
In that supposed event you say you will destroy the Union.
[3:10:52]
And then you say, the great climb of having destroyed it will be upon us.
[3:10:59]
That is cool.
[3:11:01]
A high-women holds a pistol to my ear, and mothers through his teeth stand and deliver
[3:11:07]
Or I shall kill you, and then you will be unheard of.
[3:11:13]
Presently forgetting myself.
[3:11:15]
I was on my feet like the rest, yelling like a wild Indian cheering is a wonderful man.
[3:11:20]
Let us have faith, that white makes mighters, and in that faith, let us to the end dare to do our duty as we understand it.
[3:11:36]
So he electrified the Northern audiences and he came back to Illinois in a very good position.
[3:11:43]
Meanwhile, the Democrats were falling apart.
[3:11:46]
The party came apart in a platform fight over a flank, guaranteeing the sanctity of slavery, which Northern Democrats were not willing to support.
[3:11:58]
And others led by William Lousy, and it's a Alabama walk out of the convention.
[3:12:03]
Thus, rendering the convention incapable of nominating a candidate.
[3:12:07]
The Commission adjourned, and met as Northern Democrats and Southern Democrats, and all the
[3:12:14]
Democrats beautifully nominated in the United States, the president of the Southern Democrats,
[3:12:18]
nominated John C. Wreck and Richard Kentucky. Meanwhile, the Republicans, smelling victory,
[3:12:25]
as they surely should have, met in Chicago in May of 1860, and nominated Abraham Lincoln.
[3:12:32]
Lincoln was not the odds on favor, when he made sewer to New York was, sewer to make
[3:12:37]
was better known and made enough enemies within the Republican Party.
[3:12:42]
So that Lincoln, the one-term congressman from Illinois,
[3:12:45]
Champion of Lincoln Douglas Debates,
[3:12:48]
this sort of folkloric Lincoln, the Wales,
[3:12:50]
but are honest, Abe.
[3:12:53]
The Lincoln was very, very good about having managers.
[3:12:56]
Handled his campaign with great, great talent in skill.
[3:13:00]
Lincoln was an in Springfield,
[3:13:03]
insisting that we'll make no deals and be bound by none.
[3:13:06]
His managers were in Chicago, promising four-five people that could be Secretary of State.
[3:13:13]
In any event, Lincoln got the votes in the third ballot for which to indicate where you were.
[3:13:17]
And took the nomination.
[3:13:19]
Campaning among the major candidates is intense.
[3:13:22]
Republicans campaigned on a board for us.
[3:13:25]
Congress seemed that they would limit the expansion of service.
[3:13:28]
So we would have to live where it was, and never explained,
[3:13:32]
in the church where it's gained in the Mexican war.
[3:13:34]
Lincoln campaign for higher tariff on manufactured goods, for home-steading, giving public land in the West, free to people who go and live on it for five years.
[3:13:47]
Subsidies for railroads, to improve transportation, a broad base of economic expansion.
[3:13:53]
Their platform was incredibly repellent to most southerners.
[3:13:59]
And the issues were the same issues that had been dominating the national political culture for the whole decade of the 1850.
[3:14:06]
The issue was overslavery in the territories and what to do about it.
[3:14:11]
Douglass is more than democratic platform.
[3:14:14]
Harold did popular sovereignty.
[3:14:15]
let the people decide
[3:14:17]
Douglas also
[3:14:19]
hoping to
[3:14:20]
garner some support
[3:14:21]
as a
[3:14:22]
suggested that
[3:14:23]
the United States ought to
[3:14:25]
think about capturing Cuba
[3:14:27]
a potential extension of the slave plantations
[3:14:30]
that's
[3:14:31]
the sugar
[3:14:31]
in the Caribbean.
[3:14:33]
John C.
[3:14:33]
Breckenridge, the Southern Democratic
[3:14:35]
Canada, essentially,
[3:14:38]
He thought Cuba was a nice idea too
[3:14:40]
but mainly on the sanctities of
[3:14:42]
the slave property and the
[3:14:45]
could explain it. So the outcome was predictable in a way because Abraham Lincoln and
[3:14:52]
the Republican Party won the election comfortably in the North. One, every New England
[3:14:58]
state, many, many, many, many, many, many, many, many, many, many, many, many, many, many, many,
[3:15:00]
With the northern states and had a comfortable majority in the electoral college. However, the combined votes for the other three candidates outweighed the Republican vote, but because they split Abraham Lincoln was president in November of 1860.
[3:15:19]
And within a few weeks, the process of dissolution begins.
[3:15:25]
A process that will quickly lead to a prolonged and bloody war between two groups of Americans.
[3:15:31]
Each heir to more than a century of struggling to form a nation.
[3:15:35]
Each now convinced that it shares a no-common round with the UN.
[3:15:40]
The
[3:16:14]
Unish Nation is a 52-part American History Series.
[3:16:17]
For more information about this program and accompanying materials, call 1-800-576-2988.
[3:16:23]
Or visit us online at www.intellacom.org.
[3:16:47]
Like what?
[3:16:49]
How did I get to step in night?
[3:16:51]
Oh, good ball?
[3:16:53]
Like playground cool.
[3:16:54]
We have to park.
[3:16:56]
Well, that's the library.
[3:16:58]
Make you buy some houses.
[3:16:59]
So we can order bikes all around town.
[3:17:02]
Well, that all sounds like a lot more fun.
[3:17:04]
And a lot more fun.
[3:17:06]
And just being a TV star.
[3:17:09]
And that's why they're on TV.
[3:17:10]
We can see.
[3:17:12]
And we're more about what to do.
[3:17:24]
There is no argument about it.
[3:17:28]
There is no argument about it.
[3:17:32]
Parking recreation invites you to come out and play.
[3:17:39]
I come out to hike.
[3:17:45]
We come out to swim.
[3:17:50]
Three.
[3:17:57]
Out the shoe loops.
[3:18:05]
Come out of the hoop.
[3:18:25]
Parking recreation.
[3:18:26]
Won't you come out and play?
[3:18:27]
Today,
[3:18:33]
the 1,000 words, 1,000 pictures worth for
[3:18:40]
90% of our ocean pollution is caused by the little things we do every day.
[3:18:45]
It doesn't have to be this way.
[3:18:47]
You can make a difference.
[3:18:55]
Get the picture.
[3:18:57]
Take blue, have blue and send you again.
[3:19:04]
You're watching City TV 24.
[3:19:06]
Your access to City Hall.
[3:19:56]
We're going to protect in our community.
[3:19:58]
Our show is dedicated to the men and women.
[3:20:00]
Who protect our lives every day?
[3:20:02]
I'm your host, former police officer Andy Crossland. The city of San Diego now has a population
[3:20:07]
over 1 million people. The San Diego Police Department Communications Division is responsible for
[3:20:14]
sending police officers and other police personnel on routine and emergency calls. Have you ever
[3:20:19]
wondered what is like to work in the Police Dispatch Center? Our guests today are Karen Butler,
[3:20:24]
STPD Communications Manager and Harald O'Garola Lee Dispatcher,
[3:20:29]
Karen and Harardo, thanks for coming on the show today.
[3:20:31]
Thank you.
[3:20:32]
You know, everybody's seen at him 12, 1, 2, 1, 2, 1, 2, 11, and progress.
[3:20:37]
Karen, how did you become a Dispatcher and get involved with the police department?
[3:20:40]
I actually found out about a job that was a basic phone dispatcher position that was available in 1980 as when I started.
[3:20:48]
And I have always loved law enforcement, I had been a dispatcher for a concrete block company when I was a younger person, so I always wanted to do something in law enforcement, so it sounded like a great idea.
[3:21:01]
And I'll even do it now.
[3:21:03]
Since 1980, since for 20, almost 25 years.
[3:21:07]
And as the manager of the program, where are your responsibilities?
[3:21:11]
I basically am the liaison for the Center for the actual dispatchers who do the work,
[3:21:16]
And work with other department heads to ensure that the employees, one, get the tools that they need to keep up with the technology changes that are coming up and higher,
[3:21:30]
do all the normal manager type jobs.
[3:21:34]
And of course, interface with the chief's office to make sure that we are doing the job that the department has in mind for us.
[3:21:41]
Now, Gerardo, congratulations on your recent promotional lead dispatcher, tell me as a lead dispatcher, does that mean you get direction from care, you lead her around, or what does that mean? What do you do?
[3:21:52]
Actually, what I do is I monitor everything.
[3:21:55]
I monitor a phone room, the incoming phone calls, and I want to the 911 Center.
[3:22:01]
And I monitor the radio.
[3:22:03]
All of the frequencies that the officers use, we have eight main frequencies.
[3:22:11]
And I monitor all of them from there.
[3:22:14]
I also make sure that everybody is informed of any major incident.
[3:22:18]
What I mean by everybody is the lieutenant, especially the wash commander,
[3:22:21]
that they're informed of any pursuits coming around any officers that may have gotten heard of an act because of an accident or any
[3:22:36]
major incidents that go on throughout the city.
[3:22:40]
I do that by messaging them.
[3:22:42]
I also am responsible for making sure that all the other agencies are notified of any major incident going their way.
[3:22:50]
For example, pursued that maybe headed south towards the border, making sure that national city
[3:22:56]
places involved, notified, not necessarily involved, but the interests of this, especially
[3:23:00]
if we get into their city.
[3:23:03]
I also monitor a law enforcement frequency,
[3:23:10]
a frequency that all of us, most of the agencies
[3:23:14]
use.
[3:23:14]
I'm like a mutual leg.
[3:23:15]
I remember as a police officer, the old day was claymars and I think it's changed where you
[3:23:20]
on one frequency for tablight operations, right?
[3:23:23]
We monitor that frequency in, for example, if
[3:23:27]
Chilivist Police has a person that's coming our way,
[3:23:30]
that's the quickest way to get a hold of us is by
[3:23:32]
contacting us through that frequency letting us know
[3:23:36]
that they're coming and if they need our assistance,
[3:23:38]
or if it's just for information,
[3:23:41]
any other mutually-type situation that is needed,
[3:23:44]
we set it up through that frequency. It's much faster than calling them on the phone.
[3:23:48]
If we need to set up a patch, if we have a cover call, let's say an imperial beach, and we
[3:23:55]
have our officers that work in the South Bay, respond to that.
[3:23:58]
We can set up a patch where the officers, for the sheriff's department, and our officers can
[3:24:05]
communicate with each other, where their ad with positions are and make it easier for them
[3:24:11]
to hopefully apprehend the suspect.
[3:24:13]
Now, before we come in a lead dispatcher, how did you get into this? Did you just decide one day I'd like to work for the police department or what did you do before?
[3:24:21]
Well, I'm going back to the late 80s. I was a dispatcher for the Spring Valley dollar, and I love talking on the radio.
[3:24:30]
Now, something that I really enjoyed and so I applied after a few, a few actually took about eight months to get through and during that time I did have another job but that's what I always wanted to be in communications.
[3:24:50]
I always wanted to be a dispatcher. Actually I did think becoming a police officer at one point but after working in the center I decided I wanted to stay there.
[3:25:00]
Now, Karen, what happens when you hire a new dispatcher? Tell me about the training program. And let's say when Gerardo came on board, what processes did he go through to learn? I know you have a phone division, then you have an emergency 9-11 dispatcher division. What do the processes and what happens?
[3:25:17]
A little different than when Gerardo came on because we've had him around for a while. Is we use a new testing tool called critical, which is, it's almost like a simulated call-taking test.
[3:25:29]
So that we can actually determine the skill, and the aptitude of the applicant, basically, without having to have them sit down and do real live,
[3:25:41]
call taking, to know whether or not they're temperament is appropriate for the job if they have good problem-solving skills, anything like that.
[3:25:51]
So after they've taken the exam, and we know how well they're going to do as far as the technical side,
[3:25:57]
Then of course they put in an application we're able to give them an interview, a verbal interview, to see what their communication skills are like and how they're going to respond.
[3:26:09]
We should some questions out of them that's going to be basically how they deal with problems and we're a very tight knit area to work in.
[3:26:18]
So it really helps to know whether or not the temperament of the person is going to be a good fit.
[3:26:23]
Now what happens if you find somebody that isn't a good fit is that part of the testing process or if you hire somebody as a probationary process or what happens?
[3:26:34]
There's both of that.
[3:26:35]
The supervisors that are doing the interview will come to me and they'll say this person is going to be a good fit.
[3:26:43]
They seem like they're going to have the temperament that is going to fit into our into our com center.
[3:26:48]
Or they're going to come to me and say, even though they tested okay and their score was appropriate.
[3:26:55]
I can see that they might have had past experience at a business that showed they don't take direction well.
[3:27:01]
They don't work under the stress that our dispatchers have to work under.
[3:27:05]
In which case then we probably give them a wave and we decide that maybe dispatch is not for them.
[3:27:11]
So, once somebody comes on board, let's say, in Harado's been around for a long time,
[3:27:16]
he comes on board, what's the training process?
[3:27:18]
You just put somebody on the phone and start letting them answer calls or what happens?
[3:27:22]
It is quite extensive.
[3:27:24]
Right now, we have a two-week classroom session that is the trainer is one of our phone dispatchers
[3:27:30]
that he's excellent trainer, really good with people and is an excellent,
[3:27:37]
He's a good candidate to be able to sit down with a new person, tell him how you call
[3:27:41]
insect.
[3:27:42]
Most people don't think about that.
[3:27:44]
What the requirements are for working with the headset and then lays the foundation
[3:27:50]
for call types, you know, the crime tapes, types that we use the 10 codes and what we have
[3:27:56]
other call types that we have to be able to determine what a call is going to be put into
[3:28:01]
the computer.
[3:28:01]
All of it said that there's no confusion when it's put into a computer and shipped over the way of dispatcher.
[3:28:07]
There can't be any ambiguity as to what type of call we're actually putting out.
[3:28:10]
So you have two types of actually divisions if I understand correct.
[3:28:14]
You have someone that receives the phone calls when you call.
[3:28:17]
And I know you get, this is a standing over 4,000 calls on a daily basis.
[3:28:22]
That's a lot of calls.
[3:28:23]
So someone receives the phone call and then if it's an emergency goes to a 911 dispatcher,
[3:28:28]
What if it's a routine call like to take a report of a crime as a court like a burglary
[3:28:33]
or let's say, someone's cars parked in front of someone's house and it's been 72 hours
[3:28:37]
and they want to parking enforcement units come out, give me the station between those two.
[3:28:42]
Well, actually the differences, all of our phone dispatchers, so we're calling police 911 dispatchers,
[3:28:49]
are taking emergency calls and administrative calls is what we call them,
[3:28:54]
men calls. They're all sitting in the room and they're all equally trained. And those
[3:28:59]
employees will only receive the type of call that has the highest priority. And we have a
[3:29:06]
very sophisticated computer-rated dispatch and call distributor. Based on the telephone number that the
[3:29:13]
caller dialed, it will distribute the calls first that are 911, that are wireless. We call the
[3:29:24]
police officer line all of these lines are fed to the phone dispatchers based on what
[3:29:31]
number they dialed and so the highest priority calls of course are going to be the
[3:29:34]
911. All of them are equally trained so from one moment when Gerardo was working on
[3:29:40]
the phones he could have been taking a 911 call versus an admin call with a next call
[3:29:46]
would have been simply as you say block drive way or something like that which would
[3:29:51]
And so they take them all.
[3:29:54]
Now, Gerardo, what did we learn from the Cedar fires?
[3:29:58]
Which obviously was a devastating fire.
[3:30:00]
Senator San Diego County, the largest fires in history of California, and a lot of mutual aid in interactions.
[3:30:05]
What do we learn as far as communications with police agencies from that fire incident?
[3:30:11]
Actually, during that time, I was a lead dispatcher. I was working out a class.
[3:30:16]
And we learned a lot of mutual aid channels that we need to have available for officers being able to communicate with firefighters
[3:30:27]
and other agencies in order to better help the citizens of San Diego.
[3:30:35]
I mean, the entire county was involved in this fire, and there were some instances
[3:30:41]
where we needed to communicate quicker with other agencies or other, like the fire department.
[3:30:52]
We had to dial numbers instead, and that may have slowed some responses far as where we needed to have helped respond to.
[3:31:07]
My role at that time was after the initial emergency had occurred as when I was working as a lead dispatcher there.
[3:31:17]
And there were still a lot of communication between both the Sheriff's Department and the
[3:31:24]
Fire Department.
[3:31:26]
And they would call us at the desk, we're at the lead desk to notify the Sheriff's
[3:31:34]
Department of something, notify the Heartland Fire, notify the Sheriff's Department of
[3:31:42]
And there is some work that went into trying to alleviate or make communication quicker.
[3:31:49]
Karen, have those concerns and challenges have been solved now for any future disaster that magnitude?
[3:31:54]
Well, what are the things that Jardo, when he was speaking, and it really got to our attention,
[3:32:00]
was that we couldn't talk to our officers once they went up into the mountains?
[3:32:03]
So, they know that we need to have a lot more of the, we call those the, the cell sites.
[3:32:12]
I'm drawing the cell sites.
[3:32:14]
So the, so that the, so that the radios can work once they go into the sheriff's area, for instance.
[3:32:19]
They immediately started programming into the, the hand helps for the officers.
[3:32:24]
All of the radio frequencies that they didn't have access to at that time.
[3:32:29]
And the sheriff's department in return also started doing the same thing, making sure that they had more of our radio frequencies and even they have to come into the city.
[3:32:39]
So we do need an upgraded radio system right now.
[3:32:42]
It is basically antiquated in the big arena of things, but we need to get the funds to do that.
[3:32:51]
How's it looking for getting the funds to upgrade?
[3:32:54]
Well, they're hopeful that a bond issue will be able to be floated when we get all of the
[3:32:59]
issues with the city finances resolved.
[3:33:02]
How do you handle hearing impaired callers?
[3:33:05]
What do you do?
[3:33:07]
We have a telephone system that it's actually a computerized telephone, and within the telephone
[3:33:14]
system, if we see a call that there is no contact with the caller, the phone dispatcher
[3:33:20]
will actually activate a TDD teletype function within the electronic telephone and that
[3:33:29]
puts out a message, you've reached San Diego, please department, go ahead and if there's
[3:33:35]
no response to that then you know that it's basically somebody who's not on the line.
[3:33:40]
How many bilingual speakers do you have as this patchers?
[3:33:43]
Right now there's about 25, we actually should have 30, we have gone through periods of time of the years,
[3:33:53]
having to do more heavily recruiting from the Spanish speaking community,
[3:33:59]
and right now we're just not getting as many people to apply.
[3:34:03]
Coming up after the break, we'll learn how your calls are taken when you need help from the police.
[3:34:12]
grow up, I don't want to be a big city star.
[3:34:15]
Just like times, they'll go to our actors.
[3:34:18]
They'll go real city council people.
[3:34:20]
They're real council people.
[3:34:22]
Really? Really? They're not acting.
[3:34:24]
They're making real decisions.
[3:34:26]
Real decisions that they leave are me.
[3:34:29]
Like what?
[3:34:30]
How would I get to stay at the night?
[3:34:32]
Oh, good ball?
[3:34:34]
Like playground, could we have the park?
[3:34:37]
Wow, that's the library.
[3:34:38]
And they can buy some house safe so we can order a bike all around town.
[3:34:43]
So there are sounds like a lot more fun and a lot more fun for them.
[3:34:47]
And just being a cheap Easter.
[3:34:50]
And that's why they're on TV.
[3:34:51]
So we can see and learn more about what they're doing.
[3:34:56]
Well, from City Rock Life.
[3:35:00]
To be up, it's Lindsay and Austin. Austin, Lindsay and Austin. There is no argument about it.
[3:35:08]
The tune in to city council meetings.
[3:35:13]
Parking recreation invites you to come out and play.
[3:35:20]
I come out to hike.
[3:35:26]
We come out to swim.
[3:35:31]
Three.
[3:35:37]
Come out to show you moves.
[3:35:46]
Come out to him.
[3:36:06]
Parking recreation. Won't you come out and play today?
[3:36:09]
Back
[3:36:22]
to protect in our community, we're talking with STPD communications personnel,
[3:36:26]
Karen Butler and Lead Police Dispatcher, Gerardo Gerola.
[3:36:29]
Karen and Gerardo, thanks for coming back on the show.
[3:36:31]
Thank you.
[3:36:32]
We talked about 9-11 calls.
[3:36:34]
Now let's listen to one that occurred in the recent past.
[3:36:38]
Mission.
[3:36:39]
Thank you.
[3:36:39]
Thank you very much.
[3:36:40]
Thank you very much.
[3:36:43]
Thank you very much.
[3:36:44]
Thank you very much.
[3:36:45]
Thank you.
[3:36:47]
Thank you.
[3:36:48]
Thank you.
[3:36:49]
and there's shooting, he's got a hole in the ceiling, okay, is he robbing the banker?
[3:36:58]
You know, is he robbing the banker?
[3:36:59]
What is it?
[3:37:01]
Are you unsure?
[3:37:02]
Wait a minute.
[3:37:03]
Okay, it's okay, just stand the line with me if you're unsure.
[3:37:07]
What is happening?
[3:37:18]
What's that again?
[3:37:19]
It's going on the line?
[3:37:20]
It's not exactly that.
[3:37:21]
It's an infinite six, six, eight.
[3:37:23]
You're not looser, what's going on?
[3:37:24]
But a guy came in, and so she didn't get into the ceiling.
[3:37:27]
She went out there and looked at it.
[3:37:29]
Six, six, eight.
[3:37:30]
Okay, so thank you for the America man.
[3:37:33]
Yes.
[3:37:33]
What raises this man?
[3:37:35]
You know it's white and he's out the door.
[3:37:37]
He's out the door.
[3:37:38]
He's out the door.
[3:37:38]
He's out the door.
[3:37:38]
He's out the door.
[3:37:39]
He's out the door.
[3:37:41]
Okay.
[3:37:42]
What direction did he go out the door?
[3:37:44]
He went out.
[3:37:45]
The west door.
[3:37:46]
Okay.
[3:37:47]
Do you know a direction you went from there?
[3:37:51]
Oh, that was quite interesting.
[3:37:53]
And it sounded like the dispatcher really did a good job.
[3:37:57]
Handling that collar.
[3:37:58]
Now, Gerardo, your lead dispatcher.
[3:38:00]
You've obviously handled a lot of emergency calls in the years you've been a dispatcher.
[3:38:05]
Take us through now a typical day in the life of a police dispatcher here in San Diego.
[3:38:12]
Well, for the last, for the first 12 years that I worked there, I worked as a 911 dispatcher.
[3:38:18]
And basically, I mean, most of the days are, you come in, we come in and we'll go to a briefing
[3:38:25]
line-up session, we'll get information as far as any major incidents going on in
[3:38:31]
house. Business needs to be taken care of. And any other information that we need
[3:38:37]
to know before we hit the floor basically. From there we plug in and we stay plugged in
[3:38:44]
basically 10 hours. What do you say plugged in? Are we talking about your plugged into your
[3:38:49]
headset to your computer or what do you mean by plugged in? Right. We have we put on our
[3:38:55]
said, and we plug in into a computer basically to start taking phone calls. We have a
[3:39:03]
a phone system integrated into the computer that we're able to take the phone calls and
[3:39:09]
we have the computer-rated dispatch system there. We'll go ahead and just start taking phone calls
[3:39:15]
whether we'll take the emergency calls first as Karen had explained how that occurs.
[3:39:26]
And most days are routine, most days are call after call, I mean we'll take anywhere from
[3:39:33]
10 to 16 calls an hour depending on the information that's requested by the caller.
[3:39:39]
They might be upset, it might be a complaint, it might be an emergency, whatever it is.
[3:39:43]
And we'll do that. We'll take our regular breaks during the day and by the end of the day.
[3:39:51]
Most of us are excited to just sing down.
[3:39:55]
But most of them are routine.
[3:39:58]
On occasion we woke.
[3:40:00]
You see that a bank robbery call, or we may actually receive a few major type calls.
[3:40:09]
And, you know, that all really good is jumping. I mean, it's something exciting to most
[3:40:16]
dispatchers to get that call and be able to help that person, get all the information, start
[3:40:22]
typing into a, getting the officers are going, hopefully it kept you in the suspect.
[3:40:27]
Now, I know that you have a lot of job stress, and I'm going to ask both of you because
[3:40:32]
Karen, you run the whole program, and I was put a sum you're probably on call 247.
[3:40:39]
Yes, I am.
[3:40:40]
What do you do to handle the stress of being in charge of a large city like ours, the police
[3:40:44]
communications center?
[3:40:46]
Well, personally, I try to take care of myself.
[3:40:48]
I try to eat good, and exercise, and get out and spend time with my dog and we try to
[3:40:55]
one at the com center we try to make it as light as possible because in between calls
[3:41:00]
just like the officers need to have some downtime to recover from an incident that
[3:41:06]
might be heavy we do the same thing at the com center we allow the dispatchers to
[3:41:10]
to read and if need be even board games to try to lower the stress that's why they're on duty
[3:41:17]
right while they're on duty if no calls are coming in and they're the those brief times in the
[3:41:22]
middle of the night that is the most downtime for the employees and so when we see
[3:41:27]
employees sitting there and and they might be as a reading a book or a magazine
[3:41:31]
we're glad that they're able to get out of their their dispatcher mind so to
[3:41:37]
speak for a while.
[3:41:38]
Darardo what do you do to release stress?
[3:41:40]
I do basically the same thing. I mean I try to eat as best as I can. I try to
[3:41:47]
to exercise a little and then actually one of the things I do is if there's a call that affects
[3:41:56]
me, I try to go ahead and take it all in as much as I can at that moment and usually
[3:42:02]
it alleviates it for the rest of the day, the stress that I may have felt from that particular
[3:42:08]
call.
[3:42:09]
Let's talk about equipment, bring this up to date on now everything is computer controlled.
[3:42:14]
And sometimes I'll listen to the scanners here in the news room and I'll hear that the system is down.
[3:42:21]
What happens and how long usually will a system stay down where you can't talk to the officers in the field?
[3:42:27]
Well, if you're talking about the radio, that hopefully only is for moments, minutes at the most.
[3:42:33]
We have an antiquated radio system that's being kind of kept together with band-aids, but we have excellent technicians.
[3:42:45]
So all we have to do is call the radio shop technician and they'll come out.
[3:42:49]
And it's usually one of the transmitter sites that we're having trouble with.
[3:42:54]
And they're able to, as you say, electronically, they can call in from home,
[3:42:58]
call to the computer system and tell it you know we have this portion of the
[3:43:03]
transmitter site that's down and they can get it back online. If the
[3:43:07]
CAD goes down and of course that's where we actually physically enter information into a
[3:43:11]
computer and we use a basic screen format so you have the address telephone number
[3:43:17]
and so forth and and on that screen if the CAD goes down we actually have to go
[3:43:23]
to paper and pen. We call it falling back to cards. Back in the old days, that's how they
[3:43:29]
would form that cases and walk it over to the radio dispatcher and hand it. So I wanted
[3:43:35]
to get back, we do have the two positions. We have a phone dispatcher and a radio dispatcher
[3:43:39]
and the radio dispatcher is the one who puts the information out to the police officers. The
[3:43:44]
phone dispatcher is the one who pretty much triages the incoming call and will make sure that
[3:43:51]
color is calm down, gets the help that they need and format the incident for the officer.
[3:43:57]
Now, the officer once the call is received over the radio and I can remember the old days
[3:44:00]
riding around and grabbing the mic and answering the calls, screwing down the address and
[3:44:05]
people say, how can you read where you go? I knew the areas. The officer that's getting the call
[3:44:09]
of the radio explained how not only over the radio, but I know now the cars have computers.
[3:44:14]
Right. Is the information also appearing on a screen for them? Yes it is.
[3:44:19]
So now we're writing down the read where you're supposed to go.
[3:44:21]
Well, not unless they actually have to, but they've got MDTs and those are in the older cars, and MCTs, they actually have laptops now.
[3:44:30]
It's a computer that they keep the window flopped open, and when a call is dispatched to them, it is projected on the computer screen to them.
[3:44:39]
They also have a Thomas brother electronically in that computer, so that they can push a button and it'll show them directions in the event there, a new officer, or it's in one of those.
[3:44:49]
kind of hidden cul-de-sax in the neighborhood.
[3:44:52]
What about GPS?
[3:44:54]
GPS is something that I'm really hoping that they go to.
[3:44:58]
The AVL, I think...
[3:45:00]
So what they call it when they're able to track the officer's location, we have mapping in the
[3:45:07]
comm center and if they were to tie in the GPS from the laptop, we would be able to tell where they are.
[3:45:14]
But we're migrating into that area right now.
[3:45:18]
Now, Gerardo, I know coming up, cell phone calls will be handled by STPD rather than CHP. Tell me
[3:45:25]
what the difference is going to be and how you will handle them with the police department.
[3:45:28]
Okay, right now, as you mentioned, the hair patrol is accepting all the calls from the cell phones.
[3:45:36]
And they determine what agency needs to handle it.
[3:45:40]
In this case, when the call comes, this is determined by them that needs to be handled by us,
[3:45:46]
then they'll transfer the call to us and we'll handle the call as a regular call.
[3:45:50]
In the future, what I understand of this new system is the, when the person doubts 911 from their cell phone, the system will automatically send that call to the agency that handles that part of the county for example.
[3:46:09]
So we routed automatically, right, routed automatically.
[3:46:11]
If it's an area in the city of San Diego that the call is coming from, then it'll come
[3:46:16]
to us.
[3:46:17]
If it goes to, if it's originating in a different city, I'm understanding that it'll go to
[3:46:23]
that other communication center.
[3:46:26]
When we receive those phone calls, a lot of the times we may need help from that person,
[3:46:33]
determine whether at, sometimes people call 911, they don't know where they're at.
[3:46:39]
And the new mapping system is going to try to help us with that and actually give us a radius
[3:46:47]
say of where that person might kind of where there may be at.
[3:46:52]
So in addition to calling a cell phone, when you call the police and you need to say,
[3:46:55]
where you're at, what's happening, a location, if you even have to say there's a store nearby,
[3:47:00]
there's a car nearby, or something that the officer will know the area.
[3:47:03]
Yes, we prefer an address, that's the best way to get help to you.
[3:47:10]
If you don't have an address, we need to know maybe a hundred block, cross streets, if you can
[3:47:17]
tell us, you know, this major intersection here, and I'm, you know, several doors down north
[3:47:23]
or south or whatever direction, give us a building, a name of a business, and we will input
[3:47:30]
information so that the office has a better idea, you know, where we're going? Okay, this
[3:47:35]
is an intersection in fiscal south, you know, and there's a McDonald's maybe, and that's
[3:47:40]
what we need to sense somebody to assist that person.
[3:47:44]
Now, Cara, we're all quickly. How can the public help you do your job better?
[3:47:48]
One of the things that I would like the public to do is, since we are going to be answering
[3:47:52]
the wireless, I would appreciate it if all people who have cell phones contact their vendor,
[3:47:58]
their service provider, make sure that they're ready for wireless 911 and to make sure that
[3:48:05]
they have a telephone that has GPS in it so that we can actually get their location. In the event
[3:48:13]
that they don't have that they have to tell us where they are. It's imperative that they stay on
[3:48:19]
the telephone and give us as much information like you were mentioning. Any type of landmarks,
[3:48:24]
or locations, anything that will help us to find them.
[3:48:29]
They've got to tell us what kind of health they need.
[3:48:31]
Well, Karen and Gerardo thank you for the great job you're doing for the City of San Diego
[3:48:35]
and being on the show today.
[3:48:37]
And until next time, thanks for watching Protecting our Community 580 Crossroads.
[3:48:54]
You're watching City TV 24.
[3:48:57]
You're access to City Hall.
[4:01:54]
Councilmember Peters. Deputy Mayor Zuket. Councilmember Atkins. Councilmember Young. Councilmember Mainchine. Councilmember Fry. Councilmember Medaffer. Councilmember and Zunza. Mayor Murphy.
[4:02:08]
Here. All right. We're going to finish up with any public testimony on the fire department budget Mr. Stump.
[4:02:17]
Follow by Jarvis Ross.
[4:02:39]
Thank you, you're on our John Stum from City Heights.
[4:02:43]
I'm making comment on the fire department.
[4:02:47]
The City Heights is served by one fire station, fire station 17.
[4:02:53]
As the fire department will confirm, fire station 17 is the highest overutilized fire station in the entire county of San Diego.
[4:03:04]
It has been over-utilized for more than 20 years.
[4:03:12]
It was one of the basis for creation of the city heights redevelopment plan.
[4:03:18]
For the last almost 20 years we've continued to build housing and new facilities in city heights.
[4:03:26]
And yet every redevelopment plan and every
[4:03:30]
sequel document, city staff continues to say there's no
[4:03:34]
impact on fire service.
[4:03:38]
I, of course, put in, when I respond to them, that there's going
[4:03:41]
to be a conflagration in city heights.
[4:03:45]
We have canyons, and we're not no plan shows that we're going to build any new
[4:03:51]
fire stations or any new fire services in city heights.
[4:03:55]
You know, city heights contains one whole zip code, it's almost 7% to the city of San Diego.
[4:04:03]
Now I have an immediate solution for housing, some temporary fire equipment in city heights.
[4:04:10]
We're about to open a brand new heavy equipment garage in city heights at home and federal.
[4:04:18]
The central police garage has bays large enough for fire vehicles.
[4:04:26]
Please consider doing that.
[4:04:29]
It has some facility to do that.
[4:04:33]
And when you open the facility that you have the temporary facility at Bell Ray, you could
[4:04:43]
some of that temporary housing across the street for fire housing. Now on the second thing,
[4:04:53]
my wife and I, our house has been saved by fire persons and we consider them heroes. I want to
[4:05:00]
Say as a matter of, in all the best spirit, I am the three, under three mayors have served as the chairmen of the equal opportunity commission.
[4:05:14]
The fire department has to do a little better job on equal opportunity. Please do a better job, okay? Open it up a little bit more, thank you.
[4:05:23]
Mayor, I just wanted to respond. I'm excited that the police department, I mean the fire department of the Union and the Senate,
[4:05:33]
I mean the fire school district and myself are working to get a training facility at Lincoln High School,
[4:05:40]
that would train our future firefighters and our future MTs. So, right on target on that one.
[4:05:46]
We're working together. Thank you very much.
[4:05:49]
Jarvis Ross.
[4:05:59]
Mayor Murphy and Council members.
[4:06:01]
In my checkered past when I got out of the army, the first company I went to work for was underwriters Laboratories.
[4:06:09]
Testing as an engineering assistant testing fire protection equipment.
[4:06:14]
Back in those days we used from 25 square foot metal pans up to 100 square foot metal pans.
[4:06:21]
We had six inches of water in those pans and two inches of gasoline.
[4:06:26]
They were ignited and let burn until they were in a good hot flame.
[4:06:32]
We then went after these fires at the nose days with a range of different equipment
[4:06:38]
from dry chemical to carbon dioxide.
[4:06:42]
I was very fortunate.
[4:06:44]
The worst thing I got was blisters from perspiration on my arms and then the heat through
[4:06:50]
be as best as back in those days we were as best as jackets you wouldn't do that today.
[4:06:56]
At any rate, I have some knowledge of just a fair part of what firemen go through. I have
[4:07:04]
the greatest respect and admiration for them. So I'm very supportive of the services that
[4:07:11]
they provide to the public. I do have some questions, though. And this I'm looking at from
[4:07:18]
corporate standpoint. When I later on I worked for a corporation with 12,000 employees.
[4:07:27]
In the management area, we worked over time. I worked many Saturdays. I worked late nights
[4:07:35]
in my office. I received no overtime. I think we need to examine that in the fire department.
[4:07:44]
The people are out on the line, the fire thing, that's a different matter, that the people
[4:07:52]
who are not at risk at that point in time, I think we need to take a look at over time.
[4:07:58]
I think maybe that money may be spent better someplace else.
[4:08:02]
Maybe those people at that level need to be paid more in base salary and not arguing that.
[4:08:08]
But I think we need to look when over time for some of them amounts to more than the regular
[4:08:14]
salary. I think that's something that needs to be examined. There is another matter.
[4:08:20]
And this is a personnel one.
[4:08:24]
And that is, according to the media, Mr. Saitoff sat on
[4:08:29]
the retirement board in direct conflict of interest. He supported not only the drop program,
[4:08:35]
but inclusion of his union salary as a part of the total salary basis. This in return
[4:08:41]
for underfunding the pension plan, a horrendous mess for weak taxpayers.
[4:08:47]
In the eyes of the public taxpayers, he should be terminated from a city employment that
[4:08:54]
is up to the union with the fact that they choose to do with them.
[4:08:56]
Thank you.
[4:08:59]
That concludes all the public speaker slips I have on the fire rescue department budgets.
[4:09:04]
Go to Council of Discussion, Mr. Medaffir.
[4:09:06]
Thank you, Your Honor.
[4:09:07]
And I want to thank the people at Spoke and certainly for staff for their presentation
[4:09:14]
It's obviously a travesty that we're not funding the fire department and our public safety.
[4:09:20]
It's a levels that I think we all know in our hearts we should.
[4:09:24]
I liken it that nothing really else matters if we can't fund public safety.
[4:09:29]
And it is a shame to see it.
[4:09:31]
I want to tell the city manager how much I appreciate the work that staff put into the budget.
[4:09:41]
Anybody certainly invite the public to read, especially starting with page 43 in the executive summary,
[4:09:49]
under public safety funding requests, and what the needs are, and how revenue constrained the city is, over the years, and how it seems to do.
[4:10:00]
Speaking worse and worse, obviously there's a lot of talk today about the pension that apparently everything is going to hell on a hand basket because of the pension. I haven't really seen that in the case. I think that we're just finally hitting the block wall that this city has been avoiding for many years. We finally are starting to see some truth in budgeting and it's pretty apparent. What's in front of us is something that's been in the making for a number of years. The budget
[4:10:28]
But when they came to the Public Safety Committee in March, they talked about the need for
[4:10:38]
really $185 million, if I'm not mistaken.
[4:10:43]
The budget that we have before us today is $27 million less than that, and the budget
[4:10:50]
we have front of us today is $6.3 million less than what the PSNNS committee said we ought
[4:10:56]
to be at.
[4:10:56]
There's a number of things that bother me greatly, I'll start with the fact that there is no funding for a fire station in Mission Valley, as Speaker indicated.
[4:11:09]
Earlier they remember that fire station when they first came on the job in the 60s.
[4:11:16]
Thank you, Senator.
[4:11:18]
70's Allen make it that old then, Ron.
[4:11:20]
Okay, 77.
[4:11:22]
But it is a travesty that as we finish the DEL-SARO fire station later this summer, that we have a temporary
[4:11:31]
fire facility that we could locate on the practice facility, the old practice facility at
[4:11:38]
Qualcomm Stadium, while we build the new fire station and we can't even sadly do that.
[4:11:46]
Something is really wrong here.
[4:11:49]
The overtime has continued to be a public relations nightmare.
[4:11:54]
Chief Jarman, I appreciate you saying what you said earlier about the overtime,
[4:11:57]
but I'm going to ask you to explain it one more time clearly,
[4:12:00]
and then I'm going to ask the city attorney, if he's around,
[4:12:05]
to explain what his investigation was.
[4:12:08]
So, again, I just think it looks bad in the eyes of the public
[4:12:11]
that we're sitting up here condoning this terrible overtime thing but to hear Mr. Saito
[4:12:17]
I've explained it. It's cheaper to pay over time than otherwise. I want to have you from
[4:12:23]
the chief's office explain this whole overtime thing. Please one more time.
[4:12:28]
It is more cost effective to use overtime to fill positions for the situational staffing. That's
[4:12:33]
staffing the fire engines and the ambulance out in the fire stations. As we go from day to
[4:12:40]
people, some days I need 43 people. If I hired up to staff for the 43 people on the days
[4:12:48]
I only need 19, I'd have a bunch of people standing around with no apparatus to ride on.
[4:12:53]
So we've tried to manage the budget and do it cost effectively and just fill the positions
[4:12:58]
that we need to manage that fluctuation. The issue that has come to light was with the
[4:13:05]
risk you rig. Staffing those vehicles required a special certification. We had
[4:13:11]
Captain Paramedics on the ambulance and there's a small group of people that are
[4:13:16]
Captain Paramedics. When you have the situational staffing and you backfill behind
[4:13:21]
a Captain Paramedic, you need a Captain Paramedic to fill that position. Those
[4:13:25]
individuals are very small pool worked a lot of overtime and it drove their
[4:13:29]
salaries up. Through the meeting confer process, we're working to manage that
[4:13:34]
staffing, utilize a different method of staffing those vehicles, and that's what we're proposing
[4:13:40]
to put in place July 1st, but it's still in the meat and confer process.
[4:13:44]
All right.
[4:13:45]
So the bottom line is, would you agree then with the statement from the fire union president
[4:13:50]
that he said earlier that you already said that it has been more cost effective to have
[4:13:56]
over time?
[4:13:57]
Yes, it's more cost effective to utilize over time.
[4:14:01]
It's I still have a hard time believing it, but I guess me if I hear it enough times and now if I
[4:14:05]
the city attorney can explain what he did in his investigation with his staff and how that
[4:14:10]
will work out.
[4:14:11]
Yes, there was a great deal of publicity that I think raised a number of concerns about members
[4:14:21]
of the fire department captain level receiving what many people considered to be extraordinary
[4:14:32]
amounts in over time.
[4:14:34]
And I was very concerned about it and suspected that there was possible wrong doing associated
[4:14:40]
with it.
[4:14:41]
And we commenced in the office a very extensive investigation reviewed over 18,000 records
[4:14:50]
through our investigators and what we discovered in particular in the case of the
[4:14:57]
individual that was identified.
[4:15:00]
As having received the most in overtime, that this person was working essentially 24-7 to get our helicopter rescue and firefighting helicopter functional and operative.
[4:15:16]
And that we reviewed the time records and they imported and supported really what was an extraordinary amount of effort and work.
[4:15:25]
And I also had a chance to speak with Chief Roman who said that he was still even in spite of that concern about over time and the appearance that over time was at levels that were not acceptable to the public and I know that he is implemented and is in the process of implementing reforms to make sure that there's not a reoccurrence of that problem.
[4:15:53]
Thank you, Mr. City Attorney.
[4:15:55]
I appreciate that issue being clarified because I think that's a question that is going to continue to come up
[4:16:01]
because it is the public relations mess that it is.
[4:16:06]
It doesn't make sense to most people myself included that paying over time is actually cheaper
[4:16:13]
or saves money in the long run, but when you see the numbers spread out, they do pretty well
[4:16:19]
speak for themselves. I appreciate that.
[4:16:21]
The other issue that I was concerned about is that the budget this year, as most anything,
[4:16:28]
especially in fire places, mostly all personnel, and there's just a small increase over
[4:16:35]
last year's budget,
[4:16:39]
and really where I am extremely concerned is that we're really not spending
[4:16:43]
any money on any new equipment, or basically just making the lease payments on the equipment
[4:16:48]
that we have and the fire department continues to slide backward rather than forward this
[4:16:57]
year probably more than any other. One of the things that has been of great concern to
[4:17:03]
a lot of the public, especially after the Cedar Fire, was the fire helicopter. I read
[4:17:08]
in the budget book, it talks about how this thing costs $4.3 million and that we have
[4:17:16]
about 3.6 million identified, but you're still short, about $700,000.
[4:17:23]
Anybody, I heard, maybe $400,000, but there's somebody having ideas to what we're
[4:17:27]
going to get that money, since it's not in this budget.
[4:17:33]
If you recall, when that issue came before Council, the plan was to finance the purchase of
[4:17:39]
the helicopter over seven years, if we were not able to get financing because we didn't
[4:17:45]
have the audited financial statements done,
[4:17:48]
then there was also a cash reimbursement option.
[4:17:52]
I think that on Friday the last time I checked
[4:17:54]
with financing services was that they were still
[4:17:58]
pursuing the financing option.
[4:18:01]
Either trying to get financing through our existing contractor
[4:18:06]
without benefit of a audited financial statement,
[4:18:10]
or taking advantage of another vendor that didn't require one.
[4:18:14]
So, they still have a couple months before we accept delivery of the helicopter and at the last time, as I say, the last time I spoke to them, they were still pursuing those financing options.
[4:18:29]
And you're on a, we believe that within the next two months, we'll have a financing plan that will come back to you with options, but we feel comfortable either way, we'll have the financing available to the city.
[4:18:41]
Okay, but the fact that it's not in the budget now, if is that mean we're going to print
[4:18:45]
$400,000, $700,000 or $1,000.
[4:18:48]
And in the master sales tax, in the least purchase, the $2.8 million that's in the outlet,
[4:18:53]
there's $310,000 identified for sales tax.
[4:18:57]
It's rolled up in that figure, so that's available to us if we have the option to lease
[4:19:01]
purchase.
[4:19:02]
Okay, so it depends on how we go about purchasing, how we do the deal.
[4:19:06]
That's correct.
[4:19:07]
and you're just soon not make that decision yet as part of the budget.
[4:19:11]
Correct.
[4:19:14]
Okay.
[4:19:15]
Let me talk to something else regarding the fire helicopter.
[4:19:18]
At the PSNNS committee meeting of April 13th,
[4:19:21]
this is in the memo that I circulated in my colleagues
[4:19:23]
and to the city manager.
[4:19:27]
There was a motion by Deputy Mayor's
[4:19:28]
you kept in the second by Councillor Breckens
[4:19:31]
to refer the issue of lease renewal of the city manager
[4:19:33]
with directions to city manager report back to the committee.
[4:19:37]
Regarding an initial plan for an RFP to operate the Montgomery field site, to get a comprehensive report from the airport enterprise fund, including all revenue sources, and a cost analysis to complete the heliport.
[4:19:51]
And we also wanted as part of that cost analysis in an RFP option of relocating Fire Station 28 to Montgomery Field.
[4:20:01]
Collo-cating with the Hélaport. Again, to try to save money and to get rid of that old junkie fire station.
[4:20:10]
Also, we asked for certification or something that would show that the enterprise fund has the revenues to accept
[4:20:17]
the money from the federal grant for the Hélaport.
[4:20:20]
I realize this is going to come back to committee, but these are some budget items as well that I think we ought to
[4:20:30]
anything new that you can share with this that says that we're heading in that direction.
[4:20:38]
I checked last week on the status of the Hellaport Project. There is no news. We have paid
[4:20:47]
the matching funds, but the planning is 95% done, but I don't think they've selected a
[4:20:55]
contractor yet, and it all has something to do with the priorities in the airports enterprise
[4:21:03]
Well, I got to say this, Mr. City Manager, this city council was woefully awakened by the airport enterprise funds decision to
[4:21:16]
Determinate a
[4:21:18]
Very popular LSE
[4:21:19]
At Montgomery Field. I don't think in my time
[4:21:24]
Here's either council members chief of staff that I ever see such a one-sided
[4:21:30]
showing of audience participation. There was nobody in the audience. It's focused
[4:21:35]
in the city. Everybody to a person was quite angry with this idea of kicking
[4:21:41]
this lessee out, gives flying service. Now I'm hearing that you're having issues
[4:21:48]
and not even getting the information back from the airport enterprise fund. I'm
[4:21:53]
troubled by that. I just will say much to the city manager. I will be happy to
[4:21:59]
bring this thing back to the public safety committee, but we're here in the process of adopting a budget for a fiscal year of six, and
[4:22:06]
What I don't like doing, and this is where I get into this truth and budgeting collides with what we're supposed to be doing is it will be all happy and package everything up and send them all on their way
[4:22:16]
And then right after the appropriations ordinances adopted we find out that there's all these new things that we didn't talk or think about today
[4:22:24]
And I don't like surprises anymore than anybody else, and so I just want to make sure that for truth and budgeting that we're looking at everything that we want to do in the coming year.
[4:22:33]
I know we want to fund a fire helicopter and also know we need to have a helicopter and we need to relocate station 28.
[4:22:41]
Mr. Perkins, do you want to say anything about that?
[4:22:45]
Thank you, Mr. Medaffer.
[4:22:47]
As I understand it, there was a conversation between the Department and the airport divisions which stated due to the fact that Mr. Gibbs was going to apparently get a one year lease extension.
[4:22:56]
The money for the heliport relocation would no longer be available to the fire department to make that happen. That's number one
[4:23:04]
Second is that who said that this is the airport division staff?
[4:23:09]
Second is that there that they say yeah council members need to hear that again the
[4:23:14]
Airport division staff communicated to the fire department that due to the fact that Mr. Gibbs was going to get apparently
[4:23:21]
a one year lease extension or up to one year there would be no money available because they were
[4:23:27]
going to try to get that money if they had ended his lease and taken over the revenue stream
[4:23:32]
that there would not be any money to relocate the heliport number one number two that the airport
[4:23:38]
enterprise fund account did not have sufficient revenues to pay for the reimbursement that we would get
[4:23:45]
from the federal government, which as you know is at $1 million, reimbursable grant.
[4:23:49]
The airport division staff said we don't have the money in the airport enterprise account
[4:23:53]
to accept that grant to reimburs and in looking through the city manager's budget for
[4:23:59]
this year.
[4:24:00]
I believe the real estate assets section under airport enterprise fund indicates, as I read
[4:24:05]
it, 13 million in that account.
[4:24:08]
So I don't know what's already been in Cumberto or not, but it appears that there's some
[4:24:13]
communication going on about how much money is in the account and the impact that the Gibbs
[4:24:19]
lease hold in the future would have on on the project.
[4:24:22]
Thank you and I gotta say if Mr. Zuket was here right now he'd probably want somebody's
[4:24:26]
head on a platter because I can remember very clearly at the PSNNS committee meeting.
[4:24:32]
It was quite the affront to hear that the Gibbs lease was akin to the charge of ticket
[4:24:39]
guarantee, and now to kind of pick up on where Mr. Young was yesterday, if there's other sources
[4:24:44]
of money out there, that should be doing airport-related things, and it's not happening,
[4:24:50]
and in this case, 12, 13 million dollars, you know, I just want truth and budgeting.
[4:24:54]
I just want to... and I don't think anyone has tried to hide any...
[4:25:00]
The finances are any of the, excuse me, are any of the accounts that the city has. I apologize. I'm not familiar with where we are on that particular item. And so if you give me the time to go back, I'll come and to find out just what the actual specifics are. I'll come back and explain them. But I'm just not up to date on that particular piece. But I do want to just again re-emphasize this has not been a withholding of information in any way, shape, or form.
[4:25:28]
I don't want to suggest that it is, even though my comments might allude to that, I just simply
[4:25:32]
want to be able to check off some boxes that are outstanding, like FireHelicopter, the FireHelaport,
[4:25:38]
an issue that is at Committee PSNNS regarding the airport leases.
[4:25:43]
You know, Mistress, you can't clearly point it out during that committee meeting that the numbers
[4:25:48]
provided by the airport staff were completely misleading and erroneous, that they assume some
[4:25:55]
is it's e-c-engereges lease revenues that would
[4:25:59]
come in on some kind of a new leasing in reality when
[4:26:03]
you really looked at what they're getting today and what
[4:26:06]
they would have really been getting those numbers didn't
[4:26:08]
pan out.
[4:26:09]
And so, I just want to make sure I'm not hearing
[4:26:13]
retribution just to keep something from happening where
[4:26:16]
I believe from a public safety standpoint we need to
[4:26:18]
be building this helipore.
[4:26:21]
And it's not just for the fire department, this helipore
[4:26:22]
could be used by anybody that would utilize the airport. So, I mean, that's the important thing to
[4:26:27]
Again, give me the time to go back to find out what the facts are and I'll bring them back to this
[4:26:31]
spot.
[4:26:33]
Um, the other thing, I understand it would cost about $1.9 million to get the mission valley
[4:26:39]
fire station running.
[4:26:42]
That's correct. We estimated around 500,000 for the temporary structure if we're able
[4:26:46]
to use the Del Cero trailer, it would just be the cost of relocating it as well as
[4:26:52]
about 1.4 and operating maintenance and personnel costs.
[4:26:58]
So, if we don't do it in this budget ear, when are we going to do it?
[4:27:03]
I hope for FY07 or when we can go out to Bond and build the final
[4:27:08]
permanent station.
[4:27:09]
There's going to be blood on our hands.
[4:27:11]
If somebody from house burns down or a big apartment fire happens,
[4:27:15]
and we aren't able to get fire response.
[4:27:17]
I mean, I think we've been treading on thin ice and mission valley for a long time.
[4:27:23]
And I know how it pulls people out of station 28, it pulls them out of 17, it pulls them out of 31, all the way around that whole Mission Valley area.
[4:27:34]
And I've just really troubled, I'm going to have a tough time today, supporting anything that does not build that fire station in Mission Valley, even a temporary one.
[4:27:42]
The other thing that I want to talk about are these 50 front line engines at the committee meeting for March 2,
[4:27:52]
the committee voted unanimously to start leasing front line fire engines 50 of them over the next 14 years,
[4:28:05]
50 fire trucks. This city has not bought a new front line fire trucks since 2001. That's amazing.
[4:28:13]
They're driving things right now that are costing us more to fix than it would the lease payments for a new one.
[4:28:22]
And the whole concept behind this lease idea is you go seven years and at the end of the Senate
[4:28:26]
concludes maintenance and at the end of the seven years you send it back to the leasing company
[4:28:30]
And you're making its cost, you're zero,
[4:28:35]
and it's a perfect method for large cities to upgrade their fleets.
[4:28:41]
This city has had an aesthetic history for maintaining its fleet.
[4:28:44]
I don't know how many different types of fire trucks you guys have over at station 28 right now,
[4:28:48]
but just to inventory parts and to order parts must just be insane.
[4:28:54]
When we have an opportunity to phase out these old vehicles and save money, and we talk
[4:29:03]
about we get the Carl Demiles of the world and everybody coming down here and talking
[4:29:06]
about how to save money.
[4:29:06]
Now, there's a really easy way to save money.
[4:29:08]
You're money ahead.
[4:29:11]
And all we do is this whole roller coaster approach.
[4:29:14]
We buy a bunch of things one year, and then we don't do anything for a few years.
[4:29:19]
And then the next manufacturer comes along, and it's whole different parts.
[4:29:23]
So, in my memo, I feel at $220,000 to small amount to pay in this year's budget to begin
[4:29:31]
leasing eight fire engines.
[4:29:33]
I believe we should start that plan now.
[4:29:36]
I think we're always complaining about our deferred maintenance back a lot.
[4:29:39]
I think it's time we do something about it.
[4:29:42]
And so, I have a few things that I know, Ms. Fry, it's using the word wish list because
[4:29:47]
she's convinced that we've got cash and if we've got the cash and by golly, I'm going
[4:29:52]
right there to help you spend it. So I'm going to add some things to the list. First thing
[4:29:57]
I'm going to add to the list is, um, I got-
[4:30:00]
Really, you're on our three. Actually, I've got five priorities, but three I want to mention right now.
[4:30:08]
I suspect you're going to be able to get a second. This staff is going to have a second pre put on the list. I see them ready to type.
[4:30:14]
So once you give us your first one, get a second and then we'll put on the list.
[4:30:16]
Fire engine lease program, $220,000.
[4:30:21]
Good. Community emergency risk.
[4:30:25]
I'm sorry,
[4:30:30]
and for my council colleagues, I'm following this power point list here.
[4:30:37]
Isn't it supposed to be on the other side?
[4:30:45]
Yeah, that's the wrong side.
[4:31:01]
And the initial amount, this may differ, is the first, this year's payment.
[4:31:05]
That would get us eight brand new fire trucks delivered to the city of San Diego,
[4:31:10]
$220,000.
[4:31:11]
You can't even buy a fire truck for $220,000.
[4:31:14]
What's the new in cost, Mr.
[4:31:16]
about 350,000.
[4:31:20]
Brush management.
[4:31:22]
We even have to be adding this to the list.
[4:31:25]
This should just be a no-brainer.
[4:31:28]
160 grand.
[4:31:29]
And where are the goats?
[4:31:31]
We need goats.
[4:31:33]
That's park and wreck.
[4:31:35]
We'll be getting there.
[4:31:38]
Well, the thing I like about goats is that there's no meat and
[4:31:41]
there's no, there's none of those problems.
[4:31:46]
I mean, why don't you just, I mean, I need to be picky here.
[4:31:49]
Why should I put brush management there?
[4:31:50]
If you put funding for everything, the list will be twice as long.
[4:31:54]
Just put on the brush management.
[4:31:56]
The mayor saying funding is inherent.
[4:32:05]
The next item is something that I'm hoping from District 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 8 will grow
[4:32:15]
as much as it's grown in seven, clearly district five, and Mr. Maintain's district, the
[4:32:21]
cert program is really the RSVP of the future for the fire department. They have just proven
[4:32:27]
themselves to be an incredible asset for San Diego. As Mr. Perkins said, I'm in the cert class
[4:32:35]
right now, and this is good stuff to backfill. But when we folks, it's not when we have the
[4:32:45]
Not if we have the big fire again, it's when we need to be prepared.
[4:32:50]
Does it $11,000 is chump change compared to the lives that will be saved?
[4:32:57]
The property that will be saved, so I certainly support that.
[4:33:04]
The other item that I wanted to add to the list, and I presume I'll have a second on this
[4:33:10]
for Ms. Fry, and that is I'll use your number of Ms. Charmin of 1.4 million for the Mission
[4:33:15]
valid fire station.
[4:33:21]
I just don't see how we can go any longer. I mean, without a fire station
[4:33:27]
emission ballot. And the nice thing is, is that with the Del Cero Fire Station finishing,
[4:33:33]
we've got a fire house that where they can be put in.
[4:33:43]
I will thank you, Mr. Mention.
[4:33:46]
I will conclude that I certainly support health and wellness, I certainly support lifeguard
[4:33:51]
stock and maintaining service levels but the four items that we put up there I believe
[4:33:58]
for an otherwise absolutely disastrous budget for the fire department should be at least
[4:34:04]
baseline additions. And with that I thank you, sir.
[4:34:10]
Okay.
[4:34:12]
Mr. Fright.
[4:34:15]
Thank you. I just one of the things that we are working on and we can do relatively quickly
[4:34:20]
the fire department has already been advocating on this, which is the sequence significance thresholds
[4:34:28]
and to set those at a level that is actually objective and has, you know, response times.
[4:34:35]
And if the response times are not being met, that we would consider that a significant environmental impact.
[4:34:40]
I mean, that's how we got here. That's part of the way we are so far behind.
[4:34:45]
And so, even though I'm getting resistance, Mr. Manager, from people related to this particular
[4:34:53]
issue in planning and development services, I really think we need to look at response times.
[4:35:00]
Making sure there's a part of the significant thresholds. That's how we deal with this. We have been improving environmental impact reports. We just approved one last week and everybody approved it. I would not approve it. And I'm not taking shots at anybody. Bottom line was we've got all this growth coming in again. We are going to not have the adequate services. And if you look at the environmental impact report, what did it say? No impacts on fire or police. No impacts. You just grow. It's all free.
[4:35:30]
so you know until somebody actually says we're not going to keep improving all these
[4:35:34]
development projects we can we can sit here every year and continue to complain
[4:35:38]
about it because that's part of the problem so you know that's my my yearly
[4:35:43]
lecture you've just gotten it one of the things somebody it asked me to ask you
[4:35:49]
who pays for the fire marshal coverage during games of peck hope park is that
[4:35:55]
Is that the city do we pay for that or is that part of the city's contract with the
[4:36:01]
Padres the city page for that okay, so we cover that do we know how much that is if we're if we're paying 100% of the costs
[4:36:08]
I don't have an information. Okay, well, maybe I could direct the city manager to provide me with those costs
[4:36:15]
There seems to be at least three individuals that are and then the
[4:36:22]
The other question was last July, a new fee was created for annual business fire inspections
[4:36:27]
by Area Fire Engine companies and is this a cost recovery program and if so, how is
[4:36:32]
it going?
[4:36:33]
Are we breaking even?
[4:36:34]
Are we losing money?
[4:36:37]
Do we know?
[4:36:38]
We initiated that program this past year, we have a little difficulty getting it started.
[4:36:44]
We're working on it.
[4:36:45]
We didn't generate the amount of revenue, we thought we would this past year, but we're
[4:36:49]
being the upcoming year, we've got things in place to improve that.
[4:36:53]
Okay, so we don't know.
[4:36:55]
We're working towards it.
[4:36:56]
Okay, so maybe we could get a response on that.
[4:37:01]
The other issue is on the combustible explosive dangerous materials program.
[4:37:07]
There was a council resolution, I guess in the early 90s, which called for this to be
[4:37:17]
The question that someone is asking me one of my constituents is that the program's billing formula
[4:37:25]
from square footage to hourly was modified around 2,000 has gone from about 100% cost
[4:37:32]
recoverable to less than 15% cost recoverable.
[4:37:37]
So is that an accurate statement?
[4:37:39]
The formula did change as far as the percentage I have to go back and take a look.
[4:37:43]
Okay, well that would be helpful enough to see if that has been adjusted so that we're
[4:37:47]
charging full rates for what the services we're providing I think that's part of the problem too.
[4:37:55]
As far as the and I and I said this last night and and rather than go.
[4:38:03]
Rather than give the same speech I'll just I'll just give you the short inversion I know read the sigh of relief.
[4:38:09]
I cannot do city budgeting on a wish list. I can't do it.
[4:38:15]
It just doesn't work for me.
[4:38:18]
I tried it last year where we would add expenses on one side and then add where those revenues
[4:38:27]
were going to come from.
[4:38:29]
To sit here and wish, and to wish this and wish that I just can't budget that way.
[4:38:33]
This is a city.
[4:38:37]
So if Mr. Medaffer who was here is serious about the Mission Valley Fire Station, about
[4:38:46]
some of these vote docs, then I will find you that money and I do know, like I said,
[4:38:51]
it will take five votes, as all this will take good.
[4:38:56]
The motion that will be as part of this budget to put into this budget, not on the wish list,
[4:39:02]
But actually to add it into the budget, let me just get the numbers.
[4:39:05]
I think it was $1.4 million for the temporary mission Valley Fire Station.
[4:39:11]
That's about right.
[4:39:12]
It's $1.4 for the staffing operating maintenance cost.
[4:39:15]
I'm not sure.
[4:39:16]
I know it's less than $500,000 to relocate it with the trailer coming from Del Cero.
[4:39:21]
We'll need some funding, probably a couple hundred thousand to hook it up to the sewer, electricity, et cetera.
[4:39:27]
So about 1.6.
[4:39:28]
So $1.6 million.
[4:39:32]
Um, and then, the, um, what, what is the boat dock?
[4:39:40]
Price.
[4:39:41]
The boat dock to build it, so it can accommodate the existing fleet that the lifeguards have is about 2.6 million.
[4:39:48]
We need 1 million and FY 2006 to get the process started.
[4:39:52]
We'll have to go through the permitting process with the coastal commission.
[4:39:57]
All right.
[4:39:58]
Well, let's, let's start with this mystery.
[4:40:00]
So let's say $1.6 million for the temporary fire station, because I'm very worried about that. That's been going on for a very long time.
[4:40:11]
And that money, the $1.6 million would be a one-time CCDC from the community development, block grant money, loan money, that the agency owes to the city of San Diego.
[4:40:31]
So there's the money.
[4:40:35]
And the other thing I need to ask for you a second.
[4:40:38]
Well, we need to ask if that's CDVG eligible, let's see the key Ms. Fry, may I speak?
[4:40:47]
I was quite all day in court today, I thought maybe I could say a couple things here.
[4:40:53]
The, as a second or the motion, the thing with the Mission Valley Station,
[4:40:57]
I think that Mission Valley Station, you would want to look at all the different census tracks
[4:41:02]
that it represents in some of those census tracks or CDVG eligible,
[4:41:06]
which I think they are, then that would definitely fall under a CDBG eligibility.
[4:41:16]
Okay, we're ready to need to let the city manager respond to this.
[4:41:20]
You know,
[4:41:25]
I think everybody here would like to fund the Mission Valley Station.
[4:41:29]
And if it were, you know, CDBG eligible, then that would be a good source, but without knowing
[4:41:36]
if it's CDBG.
[4:41:37]
There's another way we do that is out knowing and without knowing what the impact is of taking CBG funds from CCDC.
[4:41:46]
It seems to me to be imprudent to just-
[4:41:51]
We're not taking money.
[4:41:53]
We're not taking money from them.
[4:41:55]
There is money that we loaned to them.
[4:41:57]
They are paying back alone.
[4:41:58]
There was no problem getting back to 40 million.
[4:42:01]
I think we can get that, you know, 1.6 million.
[4:42:08]
I thought yesterday there was an agreement that we would come back with a four report.
[4:42:13]
How the fine.
[4:42:14]
Then you can add that to it as well.
[4:42:18]
But we know and everybody knows that how that money can be used.
[4:42:24]
And we know that last year we had the opportunity because of the cedar fires.
[4:42:28]
Because I brought this up that we had the opportunity to use that money in any part of the city
[4:42:34]
for fire and police services, and that did happen and everybody knew it, and I couldn't get anybody to
[4:42:40]
Actually do anything about it. Councilman. So, yes. I should let you know, though, because you're our correct last year
[4:42:47]
CDVG funds were used by special equipment for fire, and that was a one-time
[4:42:53]
waiver by the federal government to allow us to relax those restrictions. I know. Okay, but we're in a different set of circles. I know, but it seems like I said
[4:43:02]
there's the where there's a will there's a way and and I and I understand that there's probably been some, you know, other agreements and I'll just, you know, always draw my motion, but I won't be proven wishes.
[4:43:16]
I won't do that.
[4:43:18]
I'm not suggesting that CDBG funds or transference of funds from CCDC, not be considered, but I think we'll consider it on Monday when we come forward with the report that'll be fine.
[4:43:32]
This fries with dry in the motion.
[4:43:35]
Let me just say this fry that your point is valid.
[4:43:39]
I know that we should look at other sources of money to fund some of these critical needs and we get to the we get to the issue of
[4:43:48]
CC DCC to regime money. We we can consider it at that time. I'm not saying we shouldn't do that. No, I wouldn't we just shouldn't do it today until we know what the eligibility is. I
[4:43:57]
I understand that, but I mean I've been discussing this for three years. You know, you would think by now somebody would have figured out the eligibility of what we used it last year
[4:44:07]
We didn't have any trouble finding the money last year from CCDC.
[4:44:10]
We used that.
[4:44:11]
I remember you guys had a big opress conference, so I mean it's doable, so I guess it
[4:44:18]
just bothers me a little bit when everybody sits and says, well we just don't know if we
[4:44:22]
can do that.
[4:44:22]
Yes you do, and you can't, and so all the way till Monday, that's fine.
[4:44:28]
One of the other things I can say is that's going to go back to 1.4, or you can put it.
[4:44:33]
You can wish it all you would ever be able to keep it at 1.6.
[4:44:36]
I mean, like I said, okay, 1.4.
[4:44:39]
Well, that was original.
[4:44:41]
Well, we'll be looking at 1.6.
[4:44:44]
And then the other thing is on the sequence significance thresholds.
[4:44:48]
And we can certainly bring those.
[4:44:49]
I think those will be coming forward.
[4:44:51]
I don't know if they're done at Mr. Peters Committee at L.U.
[4:44:54]
In H. I'm not sure.
[4:44:57]
The other thing is the...
[4:45:01]
And I guess we'll have to go through this with every one of them, and I'm assuming that the answer will be the same, but the amount of money that we're putting in for retirement is based on the 1.37 billion I'm assuming, and based on those calculations.
[4:45:18]
That's correct.
[4:45:19]
Okay, so this, you know, that's something we probably need to revisit to make sure that we're actually making the full payment.
[4:45:30]
So, so, again, I will not be doing the wish list.
[4:45:36]
I'm not wishing.
[4:45:37]
I'm not wishing either we do it or we don't, you know.
[4:45:42]
And I won't be supporting this today until I get those answers back.
[4:45:47]
And I do want to have that discussion.
[4:45:49]
And I still believe there's over $200 million that was loaned by our city to the redevelopment
[4:45:56]
agencies. And today, we continue to loan them money while we can't pay for our basic city
[4:46:02]
services. And what we're seeing is we're seeing more growth and development occurring
[4:46:06]
in these redevelopment areas that are sucking services out of our existing communities.
[4:46:11]
Mission Valley is completely, completely overbuilt. I don't have any parks. I have no parks.
[4:46:19]
And I have no fire station. And we still, we still send projects through and keep approving
[4:46:25]
them and then we've been moan our faith why why people are stuck in traffic and why these bad things
[4:46:30]
are happening. So we just as I said to you yesterday when you when you keep doing the same
[4:46:37]
thing over and over and expect a different result I think someone said that's insanity and it's
[4:46:43]
time to end it. So you know I appreciate the hard work you've done on this but it's just like I said
[4:46:52]
I'm just getting frustrated.
[4:46:55]
Mr. Peters.
[4:46:59]
Thank you.
[4:46:59]
All right.
[4:46:59]
First I just like to say this is the last budget we'll do this way.
[4:47:04]
So maybe that's of some consolation to Mr. Fry.
[4:47:07]
Next year the mayor will propose a budget.
[4:47:10]
The council will take it up and it's entirety and beat it up and send it back potentially.
[4:47:15]
You never know.
[4:47:16]
We may propose our own budget too.
[4:47:18]
Well, I'm just saying that that will be just going on.
[4:47:19]
Keep that in mind.
[4:47:20]
I'll be a procedure outlined in the charter so it'll be a lot different and I would just
[4:47:24]
like to say that under these circumstances that this is a huge improvement over the prior
[4:47:28]
administration, which did all this in secret and as cumbersome and as painful as it is
[4:47:35]
and maybe the wish list is to inform a word for what we do. I think it's kind of cute. It's
[4:47:43]
still pretty open given the set of circumstances we have now, which is what the city manager
[4:47:47]
proposing a budget, and I was picking away at it, so I think we should try to get through
[4:47:52]
that.
[4:47:53]
And since our last year doing it so I'm playing with doing the amendment list or wish
[4:47:58]
list or whatever I want to call it, I was going to just have a couple of points.
[4:48:03]
I just thought to, since everyone's put everything on the wish list, is that it seemed
[4:48:08]
to me what I was going to say is that for cost effectiveness, that the fire, lease and
[4:48:14]
brush management seemed like two things we were really trying for. I really like the idea
[4:48:20]
of keeping up with those leases and for me, brush management, for $160,000, is the kind
[4:48:28]
of thing that if you don't spend it, you could really regret it. So those are two things that
[4:48:32]
I'd really like to see us go for, since they're also since they're a little lower ticket items.
[4:48:37]
I think the boat dock is in embarrassment and kind of emblematic of where we are in
[4:48:44]
And I just think, you know, obviously it's a million bucks.
[4:48:49]
I'd like to see that I'm restored too,
[4:48:52]
but I sort of think that the Mission Valley Fire Station
[4:48:54]
has got to be ahead of that.
[4:48:56]
And I'd like the boat dock for my beaches.
[4:49:00]
But I just think Mission Valley would have to be ahead of it, too.
[4:49:02]
So I will not suggest the boat dock for this year.
[4:49:08]
I would like to know though about the five-year plan
[4:49:11]
and because looking beyond this, the managers proposed a new tool for us to look just beyond
[4:49:18]
the current year, but to look at five years and I want to know sort of how these issues,
[4:49:24]
funding issues are addressed to the five-year plan and whether chief you think that that is,
[4:49:30]
those issues have been addressed and maybe we could ask some of them to be taken up in the five-year
[4:49:34]
plan.
[4:49:37]
We provided some input to the five-year plan. We added some fire stations on the staffing
[4:49:41]
for that. Obviously the current funding situation, the budget situation,
[4:49:46]
challenging, to address all our needs, but we've worked together with
[4:49:49]
financial management to help city manager put that together.
[4:49:53]
I just like to suggest that we look at that and make sure that we
[4:50:00]
The reflect in the five-year plan, what it is that you want, and what you guys think you need, and so that we at least have a way to evaluate.
[4:50:08]
Obviously, we can't get there this year, but I don't think any of us expected to, but we would like to see us make progress in the coming years.
[4:50:16]
Maybe that's something we could do after this budget.
[4:50:20]
I guess the other question I had was, you know, the one of the issues about over time that I've heard is that vacations aren't managed.
[4:50:27]
And that a firefighter can take his or her vacation scheduled the day before and that that creates over time issues.
[4:50:36]
Can you address that and whether that's something you'd like to see changed?
[4:50:40]
In the past, we used to have what we called a vacation draw that mandated everybody to take a vacation.
[4:50:45]
A certain number of shifts off to help us manage throughout the year.
[4:50:49]
What we have, we don't currently do that, but something we're considering perhaps re-implementing.
[4:50:54]
But at this point in time, we capped the number of annual leave, days,
[4:51:00]
number of individuals that can take a day.
[4:51:02]
So, for like captains, only say 12 can be often any given day, or for engineers, maybe nine.
[4:51:07]
So, that capping of the annual leave allows us to manage how many people can be often any given day.
[4:51:13]
So, in effect, that's a way to manage your overtime too.
[4:51:16]
That's correct. And there are some days where we don't allow people to take time off
[4:51:20]
have to find their own trades such as Christmas, specific holidays, where there tends to be a number
[4:51:25]
of individuals that want to take the day off.
[4:51:29]
Well, I think people have gone over this and express their concern about it.
[4:51:35]
I just also want to end by thanking your department for the great job that you do.
[4:51:41]
Again, we're very fortunate to have such a talented force watching out for us as we do in
[4:51:49]
in life safety and I hope you'll express us to the chief my thanks for the work he's done
[4:51:56]
in the leadership he's shown and I appreciate the fourth right-ness of your presentation today
[4:52:01]
and I'd like to see more of it. Thank you. Thank you. I'll pass that along.
[4:52:14]
I'm just going to go ahead and
[4:52:15]
get started I guess. I think some kind of... We're currently balancing two things at one time.
[4:52:20]
You're going to go ahead and watch what you may begin. You'll understand in a minute why what I'm talking
[4:52:24]
Okay, thank you here on her and thank you by making the print bigger. I was having a little trouble if you're
[4:52:33]
Thank you Mr. Minkshan. I know I'm old now
[4:52:37]
But I appreciate it. I want to start by saying
[4:52:41]
You could see it
[4:52:43]
Would you like to borrow these
[4:52:46]
You should just be careful. One day it happens to all of us. I just want you to know
[4:52:52]
A couple of things one I I appreciate the hard work that's gone
[4:52:56]
into this budget as well.
[4:52:59]
Like our police force yesterday, our firefighters do a really good job with less than they
[4:53:04]
should get.
[4:53:05]
A couple of things, I know Mr. Stump has already left, or I wanted to say, unlike many services
[4:53:11]
in the inner city, I actually have four fire stations in my district, which, you know, we
[4:53:18]
talk about what we don't have in the inner city.
[4:53:21]
I'm fortunate to have four, and it is true.
[4:53:23]
One of them is the busiest fire station, station 17 in City Heights, and I think because
[4:53:31]
a lot of those calls that come in are for many, many, many things, maybe that the fire department
[4:53:36]
should not be called for, but you respond anyway, and that's the result of being in a community
[4:53:42]
with a lot of density, cultural differences, diversity, people call firefighters.
[4:53:49]
I also have two other fire stations on my board or one on Goldfinch and District 2, one in Golden Hill at 25th and Broadway and then, of course, downtown serves our area too.
[4:54:05]
But, you know, I agree that this mission Valley Fire Station has got to be a priority and we need to be pushing forward to get it done.
[4:54:13]
because when Mr. Stum talked about station 17, it's really all of those stations on both sides
[4:54:20]
of the canyon and the valley that were spawned because there is an adequate coverage and
[4:54:25]
mission valley so I do think it needs to be a priority.
[4:54:29]
But I want to Mr. Stum to know we have
[4:54:31]
four fire stations in my district alone and two, three actually that serve our district as well,
[4:54:38]
probably more. Those are the ones I'm familiar with, but I appreciate the fact that we have
[4:54:43]
something that may be other areas like District 5, which they had better coverage. I know that's
[4:54:49]
been a major concern of the chief, which is coverage in the northern part of the city, as well as
[4:54:54]
Mission Valley. I had a couple of questions.
[4:54:58]
Questions? One about
[4:55:00]
Your report, when you talk about inadequate resources and major emergencies, particularly notice
[4:55:05]
was center city. Is that the tall structures, the high rises? What does the fire department
[4:55:13]
do? Helicopters, one critical piece? What else do you need that you don't have?
[4:55:19]
The concern we have in the university city area, the high rises. You have the same high
[4:55:24]
rise situation you have in downtown. We have one fire station with an engine and a ladder
[4:55:28]
truck. For an effect of fire force to be on seeing early in an incident like that to help
[4:55:34]
evacuate the people. You really need four engines and several ladder trucks. The second truck
[4:55:40]
comes all the way from Kernie Mesa and to University City. So it's a problem in the University
[4:55:46]
City as well as downtown. Correct.
[4:55:50]
Okay. And for university city, what you need more, you need another
[4:55:57]
station you need we need an additional station and where would that station we're looking at
[4:56:03]
interplanned sites in the University City area trying to find the best location based on
[4:56:08]
available land and work with the developers up there to try and dress that situation. So as we
[4:56:13]
start to densify and that means high rises in various parts of our city we need to be we need to
[4:56:26]
fire services.
[4:56:29]
That's correct.
[4:56:29]
You'll need more resources with a high rise structure than you do for small residential.
[4:56:36]
Thank you.
[4:56:38]
I wanted to ask Ms. Rice started to ask this question.
[4:56:41]
In terms of providing and I should have maybe asked this yesterday about police services.
[4:56:45]
She did as well.
[4:56:47]
But she did yesterday.
[4:56:49]
In terms of providing fire marshal services at places like pet coparks,
[4:56:53]
state, the stadium. Are we prohibited because of emouse or contractual agreements we've had
[4:57:01]
with those with the stadiums and the ballpark? Are we precluded from assessing charges based
[4:57:07]
on services? At this point, you know how we all of a sudden we decided we're going to increase
[4:57:12]
fees for special events and police services. Are we because of our emouse precluded from
[4:57:23]
you maybe. That's a term that I would expect to see addressed in the contracts between the city and those parties, but it's obviously something that our office would need to take a closer look at and get back to you out.
[4:57:32]
I guess I would ask us to do that on any whether it's petcopark or or Qualcomm stadium.
[4:57:41]
I don't know if the sports arena fits into that category, but whatever large venues that we have,
[4:57:49]
I would like us to evaluate those contractual agreements to determine if we have any ability
[4:57:56]
at any point to start to get some cost recovery or reimbursement.
[4:58:01]
If we have agreements in place, I know how that happens, but at some point I think we need to look at it
[4:58:09]
And if the attorney's office can do that in conjunction with the manager review and that I think we should because we're charge and street fairs for services.
[4:58:19]
We're charging lots of people for services. We're starting on that road to cost recovery as much as we can. Why in the world would we leave out the big venues because we need the service there, but we're subsidizing and if we're going to do that, it needs to be a conscientious choice.
[4:58:37]
Thank you.
[4:58:41]
In terms of the budget, can I ask, I looked in the book, as far as the agreement we have
[4:58:48]
with rural metro, I noticed that the amount that we anticipate as revenue is the same
[4:58:54]
as last year, but I understand you don't really have accurate numbers quite yet on that,
[4:58:58]
so it's a placeholder.
[4:59:00]
That's correct.
[4:59:01]
The SDMSC board needs to meet and put forth their budget.
[4:59:06]
It's a placeholder right now and it'll be finalized prior to you finally voting on this
[4:59:11]
particular budget.
[4:59:13]
Okay.
[4:59:13]
Those numbers aren't available yet.
[4:59:14]
Now if in fact it's a little bit more or the same, what happens to that revenue?
[4:59:19]
Do you get to keep it in the fire department?
[4:59:23]
Right now when there's a revenue that's available, it's split 50, 50 between the city
[4:59:27]
San Diego and roll metro and it comes back into the fire department to enhance the service
[4:59:33]
Okay, so if that is the case before the end of the budget process
[4:59:37]
We might know and we might know if you're going to be short
[4:59:40]
Actually because if you come in at less than 900 whatever thousand it was 916 or something like that
[4:59:46]
961 if you come in less that means your budget is going to be shorter than you think if you come in more
[4:59:51]
Then you might be able to cover one of those critical needs
[4:59:55]
We don't program the revenue.
[5:00:00]
We wait until it's actually available to us before we spend it or identify what it's going to go for.
[5:00:07]
So,
[5:00:12]
okay.
[5:00:14]
Meaning they don't spend it unless it's come in.
[5:00:17]
Okay, but you will have a projection.
[5:00:20]
You should have a projection.
[5:00:23]
Well, I'm saying this is another source of potential revenue.
[5:00:26]
We may have a little bit more of that should be considered, particularly for fire services if we do better than we think.
[5:00:35]
That's correct. We set projections, but it depends on how many 911 calls we have,
[5:00:39]
how many of those are actual, travestes, projections, but they may or may not come
[5:00:45]
in higher or lower than that projection. Okay, so at the end of the fiscal year,
[5:00:49]
you compare projection to actual, like we do on everything else, so we won't know until much
[5:00:54]
later, and okay. That's correct, and then when the revenue is available, then we'll make
[5:00:58]
that decision. Okay.
[5:01:04]
And I understand, I only have two more things. I understand, Mr.
[5:01:09]
Medaffer put critical issues up on the wish list, so I don't really need to be repetitive
[5:01:15]
there. But, and I understand, Ms. Faraz comments about the wish list. However, I am
[5:01:24]
more forgetful these days than I used to be, and I want to make sure we got an ongoing list.
[5:01:29]
So if we do figure out any resources, if we have the discussion about CCDC, any of the redevelopment
[5:01:36]
areas, and we figure out whether we can, whether we have the votes or whether we decide
[5:01:42]
to get resources from elsewhere.
[5:01:44]
I want to know what the list is, so we can then discuss it.
[5:01:48]
I do want to ask before I add the last thing.
[5:01:53]
The MEA representative that was here that talked about the dispatch positions.
[5:01:57]
Was that a reorganization issue or was that you got to cut somewhere kind of like yesterday with the CSOs and you made a decision to do that because I know this is near and dear to your heart
[5:02:10]
Chief so
[5:02:11]
What was the determination that went into the three positions that were cut in fiscal year 2005 were budgeted for 32 dispatchers like we discussed we did a pilot program up in Anahine the Chief was familiar with 12-hour shifts
[5:02:26]
But the 12-hour shifts, they get every other weekend off, which we hoped would help them out
[5:02:32]
as far as sick leave the usage of vacation time.
[5:02:35]
So we piloted the program, program went well, and we adopted it.
[5:02:38]
The staffing levels you need for 12-hour shifts are different than what you need for
[5:02:42]
an eight-hour shift, it's less.
[5:02:45]
Currently we have 26 dispatchers, we need to hire three more, and that would take us up to
[5:02:49]
the 29.
[5:02:50]
So MEA is correct.
[5:02:51]
We do need to do some hiring.
[5:02:53]
the challenge is you can only put so many trainees on the floor at once. We just finished training
[5:02:59]
about three to four employees so they just cleared so we're ready to hire three more. We believe
[5:03:04]
29 is the correct staffing level. The three positions we were going to try to turn into clerical
[5:03:09]
assistant to is that we've lost some pride years. So since they were vacant and we needed to
[5:03:14]
reduce some positions, those were the positions that we cut. Okay. Do you feel adequately covered?
[5:03:22]
We believe 29 is appropriate number.
[5:03:25]
We have a goal in that we answer the 911 calls within 10 seconds, 95% of the time,
[5:03:31]
and we're still meeting that goal with the staffing levels we have.
[5:03:34]
Hiring the three additional dispatchers will help us with vacation and over time.
[5:03:41]
I think I would be interested in finding out how that goes at some point.
[5:03:44]
If that's when we get one of our regular updates from
[5:03:48]
from rescue services, foreign rescue services at PSNNS, maybe you can keep note of letting
[5:03:53]
us know how that's going, because I understand what a stressful job I've been told.
[5:03:59]
That must be whether it's fire dispatched personnel or police dispatched personnel.
[5:04:05]
Those are high, I think, potentially high stress jobs, and I want to make sure that we're
[5:04:10]
paying attention to that.
[5:04:11]
I'm sure you do too, but maybe you can keep that on your list to come back to us that
[5:04:15]
of your regular updates in terms of how the departments do and we'd be happy to bring back
[5:04:21]
an update.
[5:04:24]
Thank you very much.
[5:04:31]
All right, Mr. Young.
[5:04:32]
Just a couple of quick questions yesterday.
[5:04:34]
I had brought up the issue of police services being provided at these large venues.
[5:04:40]
I'm glad some folks were listening.
[5:04:43]
Just had a quick question.
[5:04:45]
Are there any precedents throughout the state or throughout the country that would allow
[5:04:51]
allow us to charge additional money for services like this for a fire inspection or police.
[5:05:00]
I'm not sure either fire or our city manager might be able to answer that for us.
[5:05:07]
Do you understand my question?
[5:05:08]
Some cities have an assessment fee that they charge based on probably attached to the property tax
[5:05:14]
for fire rescue emergency medical services that type of thing.
[5:05:19]
What about, say, for example, the podress have a big gain. You have to do some of those types of services.
[5:05:25]
Yeah, most cities do charge a set amount of money to have staff come in to make sure that
[5:05:33]
you're meeting all of your crowd control requirements on the fire marshal of the responsibilities
[5:05:40]
or to provide public safety through police.
[5:05:44]
And I was just saying I'm not sure if we don't get some revenue as a result of some of the
[5:05:54]
didn't want to be responsible. Okay, so there's a chance that we might charge charged some,
[5:06:01]
but there's a good chance that we're not on par with other municipalities of our size.
[5:06:06]
Right, those are all negotiated rates that we entered into with what the podraise before the
[5:06:14]
ballpark opened, and I just don't know what those rates are, so it may not be full cost recovery.
[5:06:19]
So generally though when you when you have those types of agreements how long do they last
[5:06:25]
are they? And definite can they be changed? No, they can be changed and I just don't know the conditions of those
[5:06:32]
least. So I have to come back and let you know what those least terms are. So you're going to come back for a fire and also please sure.
[5:06:39]
All right. Thank you.
[5:06:42]
Excuse me.
[5:06:44]
And I would just say on that point then I'm going to go into my questioning but you know my recommendation
[5:06:49]
would be that on whatever organization the city is contracting with that full cost for
[5:06:56]
recovery would be the objective.
[5:07:01]
That's my advice.
[5:07:04]
Secondly, now on to my question, I want to say thank you to the Fire Department. I know
[5:07:09]
a lot of work went into this. A few questions and then some comments. You reduce the average
[5:07:16]
cost for fleet repair order by over $500 and I just wanted I wanted to say first
[5:07:24]
congratulations but maybe get some explanation as to how you did that because it
[5:07:29]
may be instructive for other departments in the city
[5:07:51]
councilmember may chime can you
[5:07:52]
clarify that force I don't know what I'm not sure what page it's on but you you want
[5:08:10]
to
[5:08:12]
back to that. Well that's fine.
[5:08:17]
Secondly,
[5:08:20]
I discussed this a little bit when we were talking
[5:08:22]
about police yesterday,
[5:08:26]
but I thought this was important for the fire department as well.
[5:08:31]
When I'd shared the public safety committee and along with the committee members, we looked
[5:08:38]
And you're departing on the accomplished number of things.
[5:08:41]
We did the Public Safety Action Plan in February of four.
[5:08:44]
The comprehensive public safety needs assessment in March of four.
[5:08:48]
And then the Public Safety Funding Plan in May of O four.
[5:08:53]
To what degree have those goals from those three very significant plans been achieved?
[5:09:04]
Thank you for your support on those particular plans.
[5:09:06]
it actually set the foundation for where we are today.
[5:09:09]
We addressed about 12 million of the tier 1 items that we discussed during the time at PSNNS.
[5:09:16]
We've started with about, I believe, there's 1.9 million going towards the communication plan.
[5:09:21]
So we're making incremental steps, even though it's difficult budget times.
[5:09:25]
So I think that set the direction that we're currently headed in.
[5:09:29]
It was a good solid foundation.
[5:09:43]
I can answer your first question.
[5:09:45]
The challenge there, we actually received CCDC money last year and CDVG money.
[5:09:51]
Some of that was a million towards apparatus that was added to that account.
[5:09:56]
This year that money has been removed so that brought the cost that was associated with it.
[5:10:00]
And with that program, which brought the ratio down, that you see in the budget document.
[5:10:05]
Okay. You know, and I would just reiterate, I know the memo is coming forward from the manager, but it would be nice to get Ms. Fry's issue answered.
[5:10:15]
No one way or the other, but it would be nice to, you know, to have that information, you know, for us as we go through this. So how, when did you say the date was Monday?
[5:10:26]
Next week, Monday.
[5:10:27]
Next Monday.
[5:10:28]
And I would concur.
[5:10:29]
It would be nice to have this issue answered and resolved.
[5:10:33]
I mean, you know, we just need an answer.
[5:10:42]
Okay.
[5:10:43]
Well, I want to say thank you for the work that we've done together.
[5:10:47]
We've made some very, again, very significant strides during difficult budget times.
[5:10:51]
This is, you know, this public safety should be the city's highest priority.
[5:10:57]
I think it's reflected in this budget that even during tough times, the budget has increased
[5:11:04]
for our police and our fire, so I think that's good.
[5:11:08]
We're not all the way there yet, but as we discussed at the Public Safety Committee, there
[5:11:13]
now is a plan in place, and those items can be incrementally knocked off over, as soon
[5:11:22]
as possible.
[5:11:23]
will be great if it could all be done in one year.
[5:11:25]
I think there was a realization just because of the 20,
[5:11:28]
the 30 years of neglect that it wasn't going to get there
[5:11:32]
overnight, even frankly, even if there was a good budget year.
[5:11:38]
But as long as we're making steps in that direction,
[5:11:40]
as soon as we, now there's a plan in place,
[5:11:42]
now the needs have been identified,
[5:11:45]
and they're starting to get achieved,
[5:11:47]
and there's some pretty significant improvements in this budget.
[5:11:50]
And so I think that's good. I think that's good for the citizens.
[5:11:55]
Thank
[5:12:02]
you.
[5:12:03]
Do we have a
[5:12:05]
motion to approve some of this budget?
[5:12:09]
With the, and with the addition of the three four items being added to the wish list, there's a motion in a second.
[5:12:16]
Please let me just say that I'd like to echo Mr. Mainchains comments, so
[5:12:22]
we're doing better with the fire department.
[5:12:27]
funding, I thank to a lot of effort that was put in by the Fire Department, Firefighters Association, the PSNNS committee that went through and analyzed all this.
[5:12:41]
But there are still some significant needs that are unmet.
[5:12:45]
Everything Mr. Medafir put on the wish list of things I'd like to see funded if it was all possible.
[5:12:52]
I'm Mr. Medafron. I've been pushing this pressure management thing for a long time
[5:12:58]
and
[5:13:00]
but everything on that list is important.
[5:13:04]
So please vote on the Fire Department budget.
[5:13:06]
Call the roll. Passes 8-1 with District 6 voting now.
[5:13:11]
Okay, we'll take a five minute break and I'll let you know what we're going to do next.
[5:25:45]
All right, ladies and gentlemen, what we are going to do next is go into closed sessions and discuss meet and confirm matters involving the city's labor unions.
[5:25:55]
The other matters will trail and so we're ready to do with that and let me just hope that we be back out here by 4 o'clock.
[5:30:00]
Okay, bye.
[6:02:41]
Deputy Mayor Zuket, council member Atkins, council member Young, council member MainChine, council member Fry, council member Medaffer, council member and Zunza, Mayor Murphy.
[6:02:52]
Here.
[6:02:55]
All right. Let me ask at this point, item S502, the action regarding the special hearing, the fiscal year 2006 community development block grant program funding and S500, the action regarding the FY 2006 annual action plan.
[6:03:12]
we had trailed for Mr. and Junsu to be here.
[6:03:20]
Okay, we have a motion in the second.
[6:03:21]
Anybody want to report?
[6:03:24]
I need to one.
[6:03:25]
This is just the CDBG.
[6:03:28]
Well, let's deal with S502 first, which is just the CDBG funding.
[6:03:34]
Okay, we have a motion in the second.
[6:03:36]
And there is one speaker on this.
[6:03:42]
just that we close the public hearing on this. Mr. Chair Farrell, wherever you are, I'll
[6:03:51]
you can speak on the other item, but we'd close the public hearing on S503, S502. So we have
[6:03:57]
a motion in a second to approve it. Please vote.
[6:04:03]
Call the roll. Passes 8-0 with district 2
[6:04:16]
I don't know if anybody wants to report on that, but I know Mr. Charter, there is a person
[6:04:23]
here which is to speak.
[6:04:26]
Anybody want to report?
[6:04:28]
Nope.
[6:04:30]
Mr. Charfars, are you here?
[6:04:35]
Nope, not here.
[6:04:35]
Okay. Do we have a motion on 500?
[6:04:41]
For a second.
[6:04:43]
All right. Any further discussion?
[6:04:47]
All right. On S500, please vote.
[6:04:50]
Call the roll. Pass is 80 with district two excuse.
[6:05:01]
Okay.
[6:05:28]
All right.
[6:05:34]
This is what we'll do then. We'll take the redevelopment item 3, and then after that, we'll do Mr. Gurius 503 and S504.
[6:05:46]
We're convenes redevelopment into either one matter trailing. There were some questions in the council.
[6:05:50]
the action regarding the park boulevard and harbour drive pedestrian bridge project authorization
[6:05:55]
to apply for federal transportation enhancement funding from Sand Egg. Do we have a brief
[6:06:00]
staff report on that? Yes. William Yee Project Manager with CCDC. Thank you, Mayor Murphy
[6:06:08]
and members of the Council. Item 3 before the redevelopment agency today is we are seeking a
[6:06:14]
resolution from the agency to apply for some federal funding that Sand Egg has identified
[6:06:19]
for the Harbor Drive Pedestrian Bridge we would like to submit the project. Of course,
[6:06:26]
you may or may not know that the PUC California State PUC had a decision that required us to
[6:06:33]
provide a great separated crossing at Park Boulevard and Harbor Drive. While CCDC wasn't totally
[6:06:41]
supportive of that particular decision we have taken the opportunity in which to make a what we
[6:06:46]
think is a wonderful gateway to the downtown area along Harbor Drive. We have move forward
[6:06:52]
in that manner. It's critical that we get that intersection reopened since the intersection
[6:06:59]
has been closed for the last few years because the ballpark project. It's critical that we
[6:07:03]
reopen it in fact to get traffic circulating in that particular area to Harbor Drive and also
[6:07:08]
to the Convention Center. We have identified a construction budget shortfall, which is one of
[6:07:15]
reasons why we are pursuing some federal funds. Recently we had some good news, potentially
[6:07:21]
good news from the House of Representatives, they did airmark $1 million from the reauthorization
[6:07:29]
of the T bill, so federal funding that's been in place for a few years now. It still needs
[6:07:34]
to go to the Senate for final approval and then of course to President Bush to sign into legislation
[6:07:40]
which we are hopeful we will be able to get that one million. But it is not a guarantee so we
[6:07:45]
have pursuits and other avenues for funding.
[6:07:49]
This particular program from Sandag is called a pilot smart growth incentive program.
[6:07:55]
And really, the criteria that Sandag has established for the program really suits the bridge project.
[6:08:01]
Just a couple of the criteria are if the bridge project can be implemented in a very short amount of time, which it can.
[6:08:11]
Does the project or the area exemplify existing or emerging smart growth development and will the project be well designed and a good example of smart growth design principles, which we believe it will?
[6:08:23]
The eligible projects for the stand egg program include bicycle and pedestrian paths and bridges, pedestrian plaza, pedestrian street crossings, etc.
[6:08:34]
with a very heavy influence on transit, as you can imagine.
[6:08:39]
This particular program through Sand Egg is sponsored by T funds.
[6:08:43]
That's transportation enhancement funding, which is a different
[6:08:46]
pot of federal money's sand egg anticipates about a $17 million pot of money in the near-term,
[6:08:54]
in which public agencies in the region can pursue, and we are certainly with your approval
[6:09:01]
today of the resolution ready to go forward for that funding.
[6:09:05]
We also have some good news today.
[6:09:07]
I know in the last, when we are here in February,
[6:09:10]
getting an amendment to our design contract,
[6:09:13]
we were not able to report that we had other contributions
[6:09:16]
to the project, but today we can report that J.M.
[6:09:20]
Realty and Lanar home builders who are developing
[6:09:22]
the adjacent, what we call the D1-D2 parcel,
[6:09:26]
as a high-rise residential project, CCDC and the agency are negotiating a voter participation
[6:09:34]
agreement today. We expect to bring that forward to the redevelopment agency in mid-July for
[6:09:41]
approval. But one of the conditions of the OPA are that JMI contribute upwards of $4 million
[6:09:47]
for the bridge project. And they have tentatively agreed to do so. Hopefully with your concurrence
[6:09:53]
to lie, we can get funds from JMI shortly thereafter. We've also
[6:10:00]
This is the port of San Diego to also contribute upwards of a million dollars for the project. So we think with the combination of JMI, reality funds, port of San Diego funds and two of the different federal funding programs we can close our budget gap and get under construction by the end of this year. And that would be my staff report.
[6:10:22]
Okay, I just tell us again the total budget for the pedestrian bridge.
[6:10:27]
The total budget is 13.5 million. That includes a hard cost of just over 10 million.
[6:10:36]
And then of course, some soft engineering and designing costs of just under 3 million.
[6:10:41]
We are in the midst of our final design program efforts and our current construction cost is just over 10 million.
[6:10:48]
But as we get a little further down the road in terms of design, we will be able to refine that number and lower our contingency as well.
[6:10:56]
And for the record, I think we ought to thank those in Congress who have championed this as
[6:11:05]
Am I correct that Congresswoman Susan Davis personally led the effort to earmark $1 million
[6:11:12]
for this project.
[6:11:13]
That's correct.
[6:11:14]
Congresswoman Davis does deserve much of the credit here for really championing this particular project.
[6:11:22]
We are hopeful that with her assistance as it goes through the Senate,
[6:11:26]
here is that we will be able to get a confirmation of those funds.
[6:11:30]
All right.
[6:11:31]
I think there were some council questions on this.
[6:11:33]
So, will the first of us fry?
[6:11:37]
Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
[6:11:38]
No, no real questions.
[6:11:41]
And I certainly appreciate the work you've done on this.
[6:11:44]
I just would prefer to see the pilot smart growth project
[6:11:49]
If we are going to go out asking for money, that it, again, go into Mission Valley for traffic issues.
[6:11:59]
We sat here just to, I don't know, an hour ago and talked about that.
[6:12:04]
It takes nine minutes for the fire department to get into Mission Valley to put out fires, which is about four minutes over the average time.
[6:12:15]
All the growth has occurred in Mission Valley and it's now posing serious problems.
[6:12:25]
In other words, there's a very serious negative impact, environmental impact from the traffic issues and it affects other communities.
[6:12:35]
So, with all the respect to your project, I would like to see the money going some of these
[6:12:44]
communities that have been waiting and waiting and waiting and waiting, not just the new
[6:12:50]
developments, and not particularly just for one particular developers project.
[6:12:53]
I want to see something that is actually regional.
[6:12:56]
I don't think this is a regional project, so, again, this is not directed at you, this
[6:13:02]
It gets a little bit of a little iffy, so it's just really unfortunate that, like I said,
[6:13:08]
that Mission Valley seems to continue to suffer all downtown continues to get the grants,
[6:13:15]
the work, the engineering projects, et cetera, et cetera.
[6:13:18]
I'd like to see it for something else.
[6:13:21]
Council Member Freif, if I could add to that, there is, I think, some potential good news for
[6:13:27]
Sandags Program. The pilot smart growth incentive program actually has two parts. It's the short-term projects that
[6:13:35]
Cambly can be implemented. And then there's also a longer-term implementation program. That particular program will be funded by the
[6:13:43]
TransNet sales tax. And that's much more of a 20 to 30 to 40 year longer-term program, which I think could benefit areas like Mission Valley
[6:13:53]
And I certainly appreciate that I just don't know if someone, you know, that's waiting for, you know, emergency medical service.
[6:14:02]
Mission Valley has another 20 years to wait while we finally decide that we'll fight some money for it.
[6:14:08]
So again, no offense to you.
[6:14:10]
And I hope none has taken.
[6:14:12]
It's just the reality of this is that we talk about good planning.
[6:14:17]
We talk about transit, oriented development.
[6:14:20]
and we talk a lot but it just seems like once again these very problematic areas are
[6:14:28]
just being ignored because it's you know it's not politically sexy or popular
[6:14:32]
whatever it happens to be so I just I just want to keep getting that on the record
[6:14:37]
until because it's supposed to you know sort of when I when I look at what the criteria
[6:14:42]
was, you know, strengthening economic bases and, you know, can, can the project be implemented
[6:14:51]
in the near term?
[6:14:53]
There's, there's stuff in Mission Valley, you know, at, you know, state Route 163,
[6:14:57]
there's stuff we could do.
[6:14:58]
I'm just going to exemplify it.
[6:15:00]
Exist in your emerging smart growth development. Well, that's why everybody keeps telling me mission valley is a smart growth.
[6:15:07]
Well, the project we well designed. Well, I would hope so. I would assume that if you're going to design it, you'd design it well.
[6:15:12]
And that it would be a good example of the smart growth design principles, because right now, like I said, there's certain parts of our community that are getting everything and the older communities that are smart growth aren't getting anything.
[6:15:27]
So, just say, you know, I think if there are projects that are ready to go forward, then I think this is a wonderful opportunity to pursue some of those funds.
[6:15:41]
I'm as Peters. Thank you, Your Honor. I am actually supportive of this project. My concern is that there's a number of funding sources downtown that we have to support this.
[6:15:51]
And there are other projects in San Diego that are competing for the short-term money that don't have other sources.
[6:15:59]
And there are, in particular, we have pilot villages we designated as priorities for investment.
[6:16:05]
And I know that there's one in San Cidro, there's one in college, there's one in Elcone Boulevard, there might be one on Euclid.
[6:16:14]
And I don't know if there's a pilot village in Mission Valley or not, but, and I've got a project that I'll be applying in Bergrock.
[6:16:20]
We're doing traffic, reconfiguration, and all of those places don't have FBAs.
[6:16:26]
They don't have a port, and I don't know that you've really leaned on the port.
[6:16:32]
They don't have a CCDC redevelopment area, and it just seems to me that while I like to
[6:16:41]
say I like to see all nine two million dollar awards go to San Diego, and I don't think
[6:16:50]
this which seems to have other funding out sources available to it ahead of those of the projects.
[6:16:58]
And you know if I knew that all 17 million dollars were coming to the city and we could
[6:17:03]
spend some of it on this bridge that would be fine but I just think that there's ways to do this without
[6:17:08]
competing against ourselves and that's my concern with this. And I would like to see actually I would
[6:17:12]
like to have seen you say you had a certain amount of support but it seems to me they've been talking
[6:17:17]
about contributing this for a while. It's clearly in their interest. It's tightlands, and they
[6:17:22]
ought to be a big player in this. We have made a progress since we first met in February,
[6:17:30]
so with the news of the JMI contribution, when we come back to the redevelopment agency,
[6:17:36]
late summer, early fall, to request a bid the project for construction. We hope to have some
[6:17:47]
positive program.
[6:17:51]
Thank you.
[6:17:52]
First of all, I'm not going to hold my breath on the port on anything until this city council
[6:17:55]
starts telling its pork commissioners out of vote, which I think we ought to be doing.
[6:18:00]
We're going to continue to see this city extremely short-change that goes with this project
[6:18:05]
that goes with the North and Barker Arrow plan as well, and I think that's all another topic for another
[6:18:10]
day.
[6:18:11]
All I see is doing today, really, is supporting CCDC's request to apply for funding.
[6:18:17]
I mean, right now I just look at it as we're looking to give horse in the mouth.
[6:18:22]
There's already a million dollars earmarked in federal money, thanks to Congresswoman Davis.
[6:18:27]
I think there's a chance that we can get more T-21 money as well.
[6:18:32]
My staff has been in touch with Sandbag yesterday and today and I feel our chances are
[6:18:36]
very good over that.
[6:18:39]
And as we heard, I'd heard earlier that the 4 million from the private sector as a possibility
[6:18:44]
and I believe from what I'm hearing from my sources, it will be a possibility.
[6:18:50]
The bottom line is the PUC, not this city council, is requiring this project to be built.
[6:18:58]
We have an incredible investment with the Convention Center.
[6:19:01]
It makes complete sense to connect the Convention Center with the ballpark area, whether
[6:19:05]
you like the ballpark or not, whether you like the fact that John Morris and a few people
[6:19:09]
are building some of those blocks there, it doesn't matter, the fact that the matter
[6:19:11]
there's people of the Convention Center and there's people that need to get to patronize the
[6:19:15]
businesses of these to village and you know I think no matter what we ought to be doing here
[6:19:20]
is try to get funding especially if it comes from Washington DC and the funding that's being thought
[6:19:26]
sought through Sand Egg is part of a pilot smart growth incentive program and the federal funds
[6:19:32]
we're getting is $17 million that are being allocated to us to the region not to the city of
[6:19:41]
the ego ladies and gentlemen to the region. And so Sandag put up a competitive process
[6:19:46]
for these funds and we're not picking a project over another here. All we're simply doing
[6:19:52]
is suggesting that this wouldn't be a project. Sandag is going to ranking applicants. Sandag
[6:19:58]
will distribute the funds.
[6:20:00]
I agree with Ms. Fry, the Mission Valley certainly has traffic. Heck, I lost a vote here, not too long ago to build
[6:20:06]
a new road to help with some of that traffic. And I just see downtown experiencing an incredible
[6:20:13]
rate of residential growth and I feel it's very smart growth. And there isn't a project, application,
[6:20:20]
for Mission Valley right now, that we could even apply for this money. So I think we have to remember
[6:20:27]
we're competing against the entire region.
[6:20:30]
We should be submitting any and all projects.
[6:20:32]
If we get one for Mission Valley, I would love nothing more
[6:20:34]
than to submit a smart growth project for Mission Valley as well.
[6:20:38]
There's only $17 million dollars.
[6:20:41]
Again, we're not allocating that money.
[6:20:43]
That's up to Sandag.
[6:20:45]
We're simply allowing CCDC to apply for the funds.
[6:20:50]
And I think it's important.
[6:20:52]
And I hope we win through the competitive process.
[6:20:55]
and I don't know if there's a motion or not, but I will certainly move it, that we support
[6:21:01]
the application.
[6:21:02]
Sir, second, okay, I need to say a few words in favor too, since there are some hesitancy
[6:21:09]
about this, this is a regional project,
[6:21:16]
it is the connection with the park debate link between
[6:21:21]
in Belville Park and San Diego Bay.
[6:21:25]
When the ballpark was built, the PUC closed the railroad crossing at 8th Avenue.
[6:21:33]
That is where Park Boulevard now crosses Harbor Drive and said that we can't reopen that
[6:21:40]
crossing without the pedestrian bridge.
[6:21:44]
I wasn't crazy about that PUC decision.
[6:21:47]
We fought that decision, we tried to prevent them from making that ruling, but the compromise was, we could reopen that crossing if we built the pedestrian bridge.
[6:21:59]
That pedestrian bridge is very important to Mr. and Susan's district, because trucks now that are going through Barrio Logan would not have to go through Barrio Logan, if that crossing is open.
[6:22:08]
It's important to complete this dream that's been on the book since 1908, to have a link
[6:22:16]
between Balboa Park and San Diego Bay, a promenade that people can walk from Balboa Park
[6:22:27]
to San Diego Bay.
[6:22:28]
It connects the Convention Center to the Ball Park to everything that's going on in that area.
[6:22:33]
And so, it's a regionally significant project and, you know, I want to give about 99%
[6:22:40]
of the credit to Congressman Susan Davis, Congressman Susan Davis for having championed this,
[6:22:45]
but I mean, I've talked to her, I linked about this, she realizes the regional significance
[6:22:48]
of it too.
[6:22:51]
And there's a lot of benefit to the whole region of this particular project and I agree there's
[6:22:57]
other projects for important too, but this one is, I think, particularly important and I think
[6:23:02]
we should support it, I think Mr. Medaffer's right, it's going to go on the list, and you
[6:23:07]
guys are going to have to fight at Sandag, see if it even gets funded, and people don't
[6:23:13]
understand that Sandag representation is pretty damn important because a lot of money is
[6:23:17]
allocated there.
[6:23:19]
So, I urge you, I guess, vote.
[6:23:20]
And you're on our, if I could just say this, and I realize it's not to CCDC, but I will
[6:23:24]
say this to the City Manager, Mr. City Manager, if there is a possibility that, and I don't
[6:23:30]
know what the application deadline is, but I would love to see the city and capital engineering
[6:23:36]
department to apply for a smart growth project for Mission Valley for some of these
[6:23:40]
funds as well.
[6:23:41]
If it's possible, there is no reason why the city of San Diego will be limited to just this
[6:23:45]
one project.
[6:23:46]
Councilmember Medaffer, we expect or we've heard from San Diego that they expect to call
[6:23:51]
for make a call for projects in the next 30 to 60 days.
[6:23:55]
So that's one of the reasons why we are here today and our project is ready to go if the city
[6:23:59]
has other projects that are eligible and ready to go that I would encourage them as well.
[6:24:04]
We're competing with 18 other cities, or 17 other cities in the county.
[6:24:09]
This region is 50% and while as a board member to Sand Egg representing the city, I operate
[6:24:16]
with the utmost of fairness to all our cities at the same time, I want to make sure that
[6:24:20]
the city gets its fair share.
[6:24:22]
To me, that's close to 10 million bucks.
[6:24:27]
And Mr. Mayor, I just want to make sure that that sort of part of your amended motion.
[6:24:32]
Part of the motion to direct city manager to come back with a project that we could have the city of San Diego submit to the San Diego pilot smirkers program.
[6:24:42]
Or it's being acted on as you speak.
[6:24:44]
Or part of the motion.
[6:24:45]
For mission valley.
[6:24:46]
For mission valley.
[6:24:49]
And I support putting that information valley.
[6:24:52]
There may be other projects, however, the city that ought to be on that list.
[6:24:55]
I think that was Mr. Peter's point that there may be several things that ought to be for...
[6:25:01]
We represent 43% of the population, Mr. Daffer, and the speeders at 40% of the vote at Sandag.
[6:25:11]
So we ought to be able to do more than just this.
[6:25:15]
Okay, we have a motion, the second, please vote. Call the roll. Passes, eight, one, with, thank you for the district-wide voting.
[6:25:27]
So much for 40% of the vote at Sandag.
[6:25:36]
It's just so only Mr. Peters and Mr. Daffron, I realize this, but what really happens
[6:25:42]
at Sanding is Mr. Medaffer is 20% of the vote. Mr. Peters is 20% of the vote.
[6:25:47]
And so when I was on Sanding, Mr. Daffron, I tried to vote together as much as possible because
[6:25:51]
that 20% can't sleep together, I didn't have a lot.
[6:25:53]
I think we only voted opposite would be one time.
[6:25:55]
You're on, I just want, I don't want to be flipping about, I am a team player and I will appreciate
[6:26:00]
respect the wishes of the council. I just wanted to express my concern about competing against
[6:26:06]
ourselves when there's other funding sources available and that was mainly. I understand your point. It's it's a good point.
[6:26:17]
The we're going to go next then to
[6:26:21]
items
[6:26:24]
S503 and S504. S503 is actually regarding requesting the board of administration of the
[6:26:31]
the city employee's retirement system to comply with disclosure request made by the U.S.
[6:26:36]
Securities and Exchange Commission and the U.S. Attorney's Office and S504 are actions regarding
[6:26:42]
the acceptance of the audit committee's status report. First amendment to the agreement with
[6:26:46]
Crowl Inc. for services related to the audit of the city's comprehensive annual financial report
[6:26:51]
and new agreement with Wilkie Far and Gallagher to provide independent legal counsel to
[6:26:56]
role in the audit committee on these matters.
[6:27:00]
And so I think we're, I'm assuming we're going to have a,
[6:27:06]
do you want to go to the staff report first?
[6:27:09]
But do you want to go to the, you want to go to the waiver first?
[6:27:12]
I think the waiver would be the easier thing to do.
[6:27:17]
Mr. Peters on the waiver,
[6:27:21]
okay?
[6:27:21]
Any discussion on the on S503?
[6:27:25]
Oh, we have a,
[6:27:30]
okay.
[6:27:30]
We have a motion and a second on S503.
[6:27:34]
We have three speaker slips.
[6:27:37]
Let's see if they're here.
[6:27:38]
Carl Demio,
[6:27:42]
Bruce Henderson,
[6:27:45]
Virginia Silverman,
[6:27:58]
good afternoon.
[6:27:59]
I'm here today representing the City of San Diego Retired Employees Association, a long name
[6:28:05]
for actually a pretty large group.
[6:28:07]
We represent the City's Retired General members with over 1,000 dovespating members and that
[6:28:12]
is all classifications.
[6:28:15]
You can name including Retards City Manager.
[6:28:19]
This morning, our Association Board
[6:28:20]
voted to request the retirement board to wave
[6:28:22]
the attorney client privilege.
[6:28:24]
And we'll do that at the May meeting coming up.
[6:28:27]
Our board also has need to come and support your same request
[6:28:31]
to the retirement board.
[6:28:33]
This is not a request.
[6:28:35]
Our Association made decasually.
[6:28:38]
Many of us know people who served on the previous board.
[6:28:41]
Some are members of our association, and I personally know and respect many board previous board members and staff.
[6:28:49]
And I think we're sensitive to privacy and confidentiality rights.
[6:28:53]
However, the documents needed to involve decisions about public issues and public funds, not private matters.
[6:29:00]
And we've sadly concluded that the financial situation has become so dire because of the lack of the audit and continuing investigation that it constitutes a true emergency.
[6:29:10]
Therefore, extraordinary actions are needed to protect the retirees, the city employees,
[6:29:15]
and most important, the million and a half plus citizens and taxpayers to San Diego.
[6:29:22]
We hope that we don't ever have to make this kind of request again, but the consequences
[6:29:26]
are too serious not to do so now, and we hope that the council will make the same decision.
[6:29:32]
Thank you.
[6:29:34]
The second.
[6:29:35]
Thank you, Your Honor.
[6:29:36]
I appreciate your speed in which to dock at this item and I requested it about a week ago.
[6:29:46]
You know, I think it's pretty well known that the attorney has weighed in on this and made statements in public that this should be done.
[6:29:55]
I think you have made the statement your honor.
[6:29:58]
I appreciate your...
[6:30:00]
Coming down to speak on behalf of retirees, I did have a friend, an attorney, I might add, who emailed
[6:30:08]
me and reminded me that to waive attorney client privileges, a wady thing, and he had the attorneys
[6:30:17]
perspective, well, one attorney's perspective, I might add that, you know, why would you do that?
[6:30:23]
Why would anybody do that? I think that this council waded heavily when we decided to waive
[6:30:29]
attorney client privilege. I think that there's been a lot of discussion about this. If
[6:30:37]
I thought that there were any other way to get the necessary information that we need to conclude
[6:30:44]
a number of really critical issues, the work with KPMG are audit. If there were another way to do this,
[6:30:54]
I think that I would support that, but at this point, this is really the appropriate legal
[6:31:01]
venue in Avenue by which this council can make a statement, a resolution, which basically
[6:31:07]
says, we want you to do this.
[6:31:09]
We need you to do this so that the city can conduct business, and I appreciate the attorneys
[6:31:16]
assistance.
[6:31:16]
I appreciate the mayor docking this, and I think it's really important that they understand
[6:31:21]
we are unified in this request and we understand how serious this request is, but we need
[6:31:28]
them to take this action and with that it's already been moved and seconded. I just wanted
[6:31:34]
to say thank you for working together all of us to get this on the docket today. It's a resolution.
[6:31:42]
Obviously, this body cannot make them release information, but I can't think of a stronger
[6:31:49]
statement, at least at this point, that we need them to do this.
[6:31:57]
That's right.
[6:32:04]
Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
[6:32:07]
There were two questions I had on this.
[6:32:11]
First of all, when do you think we might be filling the vacancy for the,
[6:32:18]
I don't know when that might be coming up,
[6:32:20]
appointees and I'll make my plea again.
[6:32:23]
If you think about my nominee.
[6:32:28]
It's on our list of my camera, there's about eight boards and commissions that we need to
[6:32:34]
make appointments on in the next 30 days, so we're working on it.
[6:32:39]
Okay, well, I figured in the third time to charm.
[6:32:42]
So many.
[6:32:44]
And then the other question I have, maybe this is for the attorney.
[6:32:50]
Is there a mechanism that if the members, the appointees, do not weigh privileges, is there any action?
[6:33:00]
This council can take or can we unapoint them?
[6:33:04]
You asked me that question?
[6:33:05]
Yeah, I am.
[6:33:06]
Well, here's, first of all, you can't do anything without making a factual inquiry
[6:33:10]
and inform yourselves of the circumstances.
[6:33:12]
is the attorney-client privilege protects the important interest of allowing full disclosure
[6:33:24]
to be made by members of a board.
[6:33:28]
In the context of a public entity such as the pension plan, the attorney-client privilege
[6:33:33]
works in a substantially different way because it's a much more limited nature because
[6:33:40]
you have the competing interest to full disclosure, the brown act, and so it is not the
[6:33:45]
same thing as the private interest.
[6:33:49]
So in this particular case, the analysis that the city attorney has done is to, and the
[6:33:56]
judgment is that the information that's being sought is in the best interest of the members
[6:34:03]
of the pension system itself that it be disclosed, because that information bears upon whether
[6:34:08]
or not, there were violations of the laws that were designed to protect the interest of the
[6:34:15]
members.
[6:34:16]
Well, I guess I just want to know, is can we, as a city council, if what is the basis?
[6:34:27]
I mean, is there a way that if, if there's an interest, that's why I say, the answer is,
[6:34:33]
it depends.
[6:34:34]
So what I'm trying to, when I'm trying to amplify on is this, if there's a judgment
[6:34:38]
made, that the reason that the appointee is failing to waive the attorney client privilege,
[6:34:46]
is in order to protect the interests not of the members, but of the prior board member.
[6:34:54]
In my judgment, that would be a basis for asking that person to step aside.
[6:34:57]
I think, you know,
[6:35:00]
You can't just, because you disagree with the judgment call, ask someone to step aside or insist upon it, but if that person is in fact failing to show independence, which is the first duty of a member of the board, and by independence, I mean, independence from the prior board members.
[6:35:16]
And if that individual is not working in the best interests of the members of the pension system itself, then this council obviously has the ability to request that individual be removed from the board.
[6:35:27]
And in my judgment, that's something that you have with regard to any board, any instance in which a member of any of your boards that you have confirmed are acting inconsistent with their fundamental duties.
[6:35:43]
And in this case, the fundamental fiduciary duties, then you have an obligation or at least you have the right to request that they step aside. Thank you.
[6:35:58]
I support this resolution. I appreciate the mayor and Miss Atkins in particular for pushing this.
[6:36:06]
I wanted to make one observation the certain board members after their vote a few weeks ago.
[6:36:14]
One in particular and a letter to the editor and op-ed piece expressed the opinion publicly that
[6:36:21]
And I don't remember who it was, but whoever wrote the op-ed piece, said something to the effect of, basically if we thought this was really really needed, we would reconsider, but basically that case wasn't made to us, and specifically my recollection, I could be wrong, is that they were referring to KPMG and the audit.
[6:36:50]
That is, has the question ever been answered, does KPMG require this waiver to complete a certified audit for the city's San Diego?
[6:37:04]
And from the boards perspective, or from this board members perspective, they had never heard from KPMG.
[6:37:10]
They didn't know the answer to that question.
[6:37:12]
And so I would just throw out there that in addition to this being a strong statement and I would hope that our retirement board appointees current and future would hear our plea on this.
[6:37:29]
I do agree that they should also hear from KPMG, they've obviously heard from the United States attorney and her specific request.
[6:37:42]
But I think they also need to hear from KPMG and I don't know what KPMG's position is because I've heard different characterizations of KPMG's position.
[6:37:53]
But if KPMG's position is indeed that they need that waiver in order to get the information they need to complete the audit,
[6:38:01]
then that needs to be communicated very clearly by KPMG and not by anybody else to the retirement board.
[6:38:08]
And the retirement board should listen to that because going to Mr. Eguirri's point is to,
[6:38:15]
you know, their producer Eguirri duty, if the city fails, and without an audit, the city will continue to fail,
[6:38:24]
and ultimately may fail miserably as we go another however many months without a certified audit.
[6:38:31]
And if the retirement boards lack of a waiver is what is perpetuating that, then I would hope and expect that the retirement board members would reconsider their decision.
[6:38:43]
But I would just make the observation that I understood what this person was saying,
[6:38:50]
because I disagreed vehemently with their decision not to waive, but I understood his point.
[6:38:54]
And so, but it seems to be easily rectifiable.
[6:38:58]
So, whoever is communicating with KPMG these days,
[6:39:01]
if that could be passed along,
[6:39:03]
I think that that would be an important message
[6:39:05]
for the retirement board.
[6:39:09]
Okay, Mr. Redaffer.
[6:39:10]
Thank you. I want to echo the comments and Mr. Zeket.
[6:39:13]
I know when I chatted with KPMG a while ago,
[6:39:18]
to give me the impression that they could probably
[6:39:21]
give the city an audit without the waiver,
[6:39:25]
but I am completely convinced today that unless we have this waiver we're never going to have the clean
[6:39:33]
audit that I believe we need.
[6:39:37]
And so I support this mainly because anything that we can do to get the audit finished sooner,
[6:39:46]
the better.
[6:39:47]
I don't need to remind my colleagues but clearly it seems like I have to say this again because
[6:39:53]
the team as it gets recognized in the press city council wave the privileges a long time ago
[6:40:00]
And I really think it's important that the retirement board follows it.
[6:40:07]
Mr. Major, thank you. And to add on to what before I make my comments, I do want to see Mr.
[6:40:13]
Medaferase as a raise to good point, every single time the council has been asked to wave a privilege.
[6:40:20]
The council has done so, so I'm hopeful that the CERIS Board will follow suit.
[6:40:26]
I think it's significant that the Department of Justice and the SEC and the Audit Committee have asked for this.
[6:40:37]
They – all those groups obviously feel this is important.
[6:40:40]
I think it's a further way to show cooperation and a desire to get this situation resolved and completed in the best interest of everybody.
[6:40:53]
So I'm hopeful that this today will move that process along.
[6:40:59]
It shows, in my view, the Council's ongoing commitment to make sure that there is every
[6:41:05]
bit of cooperation from this side that there can possibly be.
[6:41:11]
And so with this request from the Department of Justice and the SEC, if for no other reason
[6:41:16]
than that, I think it should be complied with, as those organizations want it, they feel it
[6:41:22]
be helpful to getting the situation resolved, and therefore I agree.
[6:41:27]
Your Honor.
[6:41:29]
Seconds.
[6:41:30]
Just to follow up and kind of finish with what Mr. Zucat brought up.
[6:41:35]
Is it possible that as part of this resolution, we can, I mean, obviously, for them to reconsider
[6:41:41]
this or consider this, they have to put it on their docket, for discussion.
[6:41:46]
And so as part of this resolution and motion, can we direct that we request this be
[6:41:56]
documented for reconsideration and can we at that point send someone over to do KPMG in
[6:42:04]
particular?
[6:42:04]
Can we not request that of our consultants who are part of this process that they go make
[6:42:13]
case ask for reconsideration and have our resolution in hand. I mean, otherwise we're
[6:42:19]
passing a resolution and it's done, but I think we have to specifically ask them to
[6:42:24]
reconsider and put it on their pocket.
[6:42:27]
Mayor, thank you. The responsibility for our financial statements and for taking the initiative
[6:42:33]
under seaboard is upon us. And so in other words, to the extent that we initiated the some
[6:42:40]
of this council would be designated to go over, I'd be happy to assist in getting it on.
[6:42:44]
I think the next meeting is May 19, I think it's probably enough time to get it on.
[6:42:49]
But I would suggest that rather than asking KPMG to do it, that someone from the council
[6:42:55]
would be designated to go over and make the case so that we can make even a stronger case
[6:42:59]
to KPMG because I do agree, and I think the people of San Diego should know that this
[6:43:09]
know I think everyone knows I've been you know have issued some reports that haven't been completely
[6:43:13]
complementary of the council but I will tell you that the council has been as forthright
[6:43:19]
as they possibly could have been with we could say that one more time I just want to keep hearing
[6:43:23]
it sounds good. Is it music to your ears Mr. Medea for a day and we need to start hearing
[6:43:27]
you say that a little bit more. Well I that was in my that was in my second interim report and
[6:43:30]
I and I reiterate it now but I think that the council member
[6:43:34]
Actions that perhaps the best things it would be for yourself since you initiated this if it's the if it's the pleasure of the council to go over and make the case and we'd be happy to work with you in the city attorney's office to help you focus whatever arguments you felt with the most compelling.
[6:43:50]
Exactly as I'm willing to go over there to the board meeting with you without you.
[6:43:56]
As you know, I previously sent a letter to the board to the old board and armed with this resolution and if possible, I think that I know the audit committee would probably write the letter that we need.
[6:44:12]
I don't know about KPMG, even though I talked with them every other week, I'm not sure we've ever asked if they would do that, but
[6:44:29]
I'm going to point out you'll find, when you hear the status report, I think it's the
[6:44:34]
audit committee's desire and expectation to start meeting with the retirement board and
[6:44:42]
starting with the administration this week and so they were going to convey based on your
[6:44:47]
decision today, they were going to convey the fact that you've approved this resolution and then
[6:44:52]
Again, those discussions with the board members, so are the trustees, so that certainly
[6:44:57]
could be complemented with your efforts.
[6:45:00]
I think that, well, I would let me here for a few years.
[6:45:05]
Well, I just can't say I think, maybe Mr. Dalberg is a me to add when we ask him up here.
[6:45:10]
But I don't think there's any harm in the city. Turning making this request, the city manager, the mayor and council, the audit committee, and the KPMG.
[6:45:19]
If we can get everyone to do it, I don't see any reason to exclude anyone who's interested in getting the waiver from making their request.
[6:45:26]
And I think actually we should invite it so that there can be no doubt
[6:45:29]
At the retirement board of the interest of everyone in this and I like I said when we did the appointments
[6:45:37]
I I appreciate their independence. This is a call that they have to make. I don't believe it's something that we can order them to do
[6:45:43]
I believe in the independence of the retirement board from the city because
[6:45:49]
It's quite possible that they were too interconnected and at the reason we that managers plan one was approved and we got into bad practices in the first places
[6:45:58]
that the retirement board was looking out for the city and not for their
[6:46:02]
retirement board. That's why we've made them independent. We want the
[6:46:05]
retirement board to look out for the retirement board and not do what's just in
[6:46:08]
the city's interests. So we've actually strengthened that in the ballot this year.
[6:46:12]
We strengthened their independence. We want them to be independent. We need to
[6:46:15]
respect that. At the same time I think we all need to be unanimous and many in
[6:46:22]
our request that in this case they help us by waving it. So we asked their
[6:46:25]
a careful consideration of this in the exercise of their fiduciary duty to the retirement
[6:46:30]
system that this is something that they should do and that that's a request that you come from
[6:46:35]
all of us and I think there's no reason to sort out who should come to the table I think
[6:46:40]
everyone should be there making the same request and that could only help.
[6:46:47]
I think that's a good idea but I guess what we could do is I'm going to say I can say
[6:46:51]
I want to get together we can carry with us not only the resolution from the city council
[6:46:56]
Mayor and Council, we could bring a letter from the Audit Committee asking for a letter from the City Attorney asking for it.
[6:47:04]
I'll let you's already done that before, but letter from the City Manager just doing what you say.
[6:47:10]
But to deliver, you know, just go through the physical motions of, here it is.
[6:47:13]
This is where we think we should do.
[6:47:16]
And, you know, reassert the request with the new return for.
[6:47:21]
And potentially, we also would like the letter from KPMG.
[6:47:27]
I think we should include in our in your in the motion that we ask the city manager to make a request to KPMG.
[6:47:37]
Mr. Dawvers here.
[6:47:39]
Mr. Dawber.
[6:47:40]
I'm assuming that you'd be happy to submit that letter.
[6:47:43]
Is that correct?
[6:47:45]
So I made that request to the audit committee.
[6:47:47]
And so part of today will be also
[6:47:50]
sending a request to the the board that they dock at this item for reconsideration or at least
[6:47:57]
For us to attend let's direct the city manager to make that formal week like that request as part of the motion
[6:48:06]
Okay, any other discussion just a question
[6:48:11]
Is this the language just say request is the word demand and it?
[6:48:16]
I don't have a copy the resolution in front of me
[6:48:20]
Can I make a suggestion that you leave it to the mayor with some advice from the city attorney that the strongest appropriate wording?
[6:48:31]
Okay, I'll use that. The strongest appropriate wording. I'll live with that.
[6:48:37]
Okay. Thank you.
[6:48:39]
All right, please then vote on the motion.
[6:48:42]
Call the roll. It does pass unanimous.
[6:48:53]
Okay.
[6:48:56]
All right. We're going to go next to S504 then again the actions regarding the acceptance of the audit committee status report.
[6:49:04]
First amendment to the agreement with Crowlink for services related to the audit of the city's comprehensive annual financial report.
[6:49:12]
And a proposed new agreement will keep far and Gallagher to provide independent legal counsel to crawl in the audit committee on these matters.
[6:49:19]
Let me call first on the city manager.
[6:49:23]
Thank you, Your Honor. Members of the council. Before you is a status report that was received by the audit committee in particular,
[6:49:31]
I think Mr. Golfer signed it on May 6. Status report provides for you their work that's been done to date and next steps.
[6:49:41]
Also, before you, we've had some experience with the Audit Committee and the expenditure rate.
[6:49:47]
We're proposing a budget be established.
[6:49:50]
Before you as a request for a budget of not to exceed 1.75-1.75-1.75,
[6:49:58]
and to also
[6:50:00]
And as part of their request, they're asking to exercise their right to seek outside legal counsel. And I will allow Mr. Dalberg to speak to that particular issue as well. So Mr. Dalberg,
[6:50:21]
why didn't you?
[6:50:34]
So would you like me to go into sort of an overall status and sort of a summary of the letter or just talk specifically about seeking legal counsel?
[6:50:40]
I didn't hear that last question specifically just seeking a request for seeking legal counsel.
[6:50:46]
No, I think you should go through the whole report.
[6:50:50]
Your status report and then get into the legal counsel issue, which is probably the more controversial, too.
[6:50:57]
This is a time for to have a status report.
[6:50:59]
I think the public was interested in hearing the status report as well as the mayor of council.
[6:51:04]
All right. Well, thank you, Mayor Murphy, for giving us a chance to talk and thank you, Council.
[6:51:10]
And city attorney, Gary, and city manager, you all.
[6:51:15]
On Friday, we delivered a letter to city manager, you all, the basically gave a update of where we were in the process so far.
[6:51:25]
In conducting the audit committee work that we've been working on now for probably about two to three months.
[6:51:32]
Hopefully all of you have got that in front of you, there were a few attachments as well for attachments in back of the letter, which kind of were sort of highlighting some various issues that we thought were important in the letter.
[6:51:45]
Starting with the bullet points, what we have done thus far is we have, as that fourth engagement letter, we have gone through and we have looked at all the reports that have been prepared by the various entities that have been involved with the investigations so far.
[6:51:59]
That would be the first three really reports from Mr. Gary's office, and I guess now we've reviewed the fourth one as well, although not thoroughly on the fourth one, but we at least have read it.
[6:52:12]
We've also read Vincent Alkins initial report, which I think was a September 16th, 2004 report, and then the loose forward report that I don't remember the day, but that came out as well.
[6:52:23]
We have conducted a number of meetings with a KPMG, a person as well as over the phone and
[6:52:33]
I just started to stay pretty much on top of them as far as their concerns and interests
[6:52:36]
and kept them abreast of what we were doing in the investigation.
[6:52:40]
We've also had ongoing communication with the Securities and Exchange Commission.
[6:52:44]
I would say almost on a weekly basis, although maybe sometimes it's up to every other week.
[6:52:48]
We've had less interaction with the U.S. Attorney, I think that may have only been one or two situations where they've
[6:52:55]
opted to contact us on some issues.
[6:52:58]
The next point that you'll see here is that we have been pressing to get documents and be able to review them
[6:53:04]
and in certain critical records from the city attorney's office, from Vincent and Elkins, from NTI, Breakwater, and from San Diego Data Processing Center.
[6:53:14]
These are all people that we're involved thus far in the process of gathering information and sometimes doing some analytics on the information
[6:53:22]
Again, all this is pretty much in line with what we had pretty out late in our original engagement letter
[6:53:29]
Next, both point you'll see which is the last one on the first page is that we have made certain requests of the city attorney's office
[6:53:35]
and have been trying to work with them to get these requests handled
[6:53:39]
In addition to looking at the reports, the first three reports that were put forth, we wanted
[6:53:45]
to be able to see a first, a kind of a complete listing of all other issues that the city
[6:53:50]
attorney thought were pertinent so that we could be aware of the full scope of the concerns
[6:53:55]
that the city attorney's office had in these matters.
[6:53:58]
Next, we were hoping to be able to see Ashley support for the reports other than just the
[6:54:03]
exhibits that were attached and we've made a number of efforts in that regard and unfortunately
[6:54:08]
haven't been all that successful yet, but we have high hopes that we will be able to ultimately
[6:54:12]
have a chance to access and understand the methodology and procedures that the City Attorney
[6:54:17]
Office used as well as a number of other documents that they have that weren't part of the
[6:54:22]
exhibits that at least we are aware of that they have which Devon had a chance to look at them yet.
[6:54:28]
On the next page, we're sort of in the same position with V&E. If you remember our engagement letter,
[6:54:32]
we were really focusing on looking at the reports and pulling together the reports for V&E
[6:54:38]
in the city attorney. And one thing that may be as misunderstood here is the context of really
[6:54:42]
what a report is because in our early discussions with KPMG, they very much confirmed what
[6:54:48]
my understanding and Mr. Turner's understanding was all along, which is that a report that is
[6:54:52]
just a paper report with a bunch of words on it doesn't mean a whole heck of a lot. And in fact,
[6:54:57]
If you don't have detailed work papers, be-
[6:55:00]
Line that report that explained full methodologies, full documents considered, full procedures that were employed as to what information was looked at electronically and hard copy.
[6:55:11]
And then behind that, all the documents that were pulled out of those procedures, pulled into a coherent, well thought out full analysis that's a summary in the front of it, you really don't have much of anything.
[6:55:23]
And one of KPMGs complaints, since, well, the first complaint that I want to first talk to them was, is that, with Vincent and Alkins and with the City Attorney's reports, they had never seen the backup.
[6:55:35]
They'd never seen the support. They had no understanding of what the full scope of the documents were looked at.
[6:55:41]
The completeness of the investigation, which is pretty much the normal course for an auditor, as far as looking at these things.
[6:55:47]
So, the approach that we have taken is to say, great, we'll look at your reports, read them,
[6:55:53]
but now we want to get behind the report and we want to see exactly what procedures, exactly
[6:55:57]
what documents you've looked at, to be able to come to whatever conclusions you have.
[6:56:02]
So, with Vincent and Alkins right now, where we are, is that we requested towards the end of March
[6:56:07]
to be able to see all their work papers, all their processes and procedures that related to the
[6:56:17]
processes they were doing for the sort of additional work that they started in October.
[6:56:23]
They took under advice what we wanted, which was fully documented in methodologies and procedures
[6:56:29]
as I've discussed, and didn't really have that available.
[6:56:32]
So they have been working on trying to pull that together for not only really the first report,
[6:56:37]
but also for the second report as well.
[6:56:39]
And we had told them that before they issued another report, we wanted to be able to review
[6:56:46]
the work that they had done to make sure that it was complete enough that it would actually hold up
[6:56:50]
for some scrutiny, including sharing that with KPMG and the SEC, while this product was being developed,
[6:56:56]
because in fact, KPMG did hear what they do normally in these things, which is if we drop a report on
[6:57:01]
their desk and they haven't been involved in the development of it or looked at the procedures
[6:57:06]
in the process behind it, they have a tendency usually to try to reject it because they haven't
[6:57:11]
fully understood and bought into what the ultimate outcomes are in the report.
[6:57:15]
So, starting in March, we instructed Vincent and Alkins to pull these work papers together.
[6:57:21]
I guess we would have similar instructions with the City Attorney's Office, but we haven't
[6:57:24]
gotten that far as far as having a meeting to request that with them.
[6:57:28]
And then they've been in the process of trying to do this.
[6:57:31]
We went out to Vincent and Alkins's offices in Washington, D.C. about two weeks ago,
[6:57:36]
hoping that they would be a little further along honestly than they were in this process,
[6:57:40]
But we did spend a fair amount of time working with them on what the process would look like
[6:57:45]
Quite frankly they're a little handy cap because they're attorneys and attorneys don't do this stuff the way accounts do it
[6:57:51]
We are a little
[6:57:52]
Myopically focused on referencing and word paypers and things ticking and tying and binders where
[6:57:58]
You know attorneys like red wells and things to be a little Lucy and it's a little different world for them
[6:58:03]
So we're trying to move them along in that direction so that
[6:58:06]
The work product that they have will withstand the scrutiny of KPMG, and we plan on inviting the SEC to have to look at it as well, and the SEC has expressed serious concern being able to see it as well as KPMG.
[6:58:21]
Most likely, KPMG and the SEC will see most of it and probably buy off on what has been done well before a paper final report is issued, because that way will know that they're going to like the report that's going to be issued.
[6:58:34]
as opposed to taking a chance that they look at the report and don't really have much interest in it.
[6:58:40]
But so that's where we are with the need right now.
[6:58:42]
It's really working through their actual work product, the documentation, the procedures,
[6:58:47]
trying to understand what they looked at it, when they looked at it, and how they looked at it.
[6:58:53]
The next bullet point is meetings with Sears.
[6:58:55]
I've been involved with, I think, four meetings now with Sears administrators.
[6:59:00]
And what we have done is kind of present the issues that we thought were critical to move this audit along.
[6:59:07]
The first meeting I attended was with Vincent Nookins.
[6:59:11]
And we actually were meeting about a tax issue that was one of the items that are out there.
[6:59:16]
But what I quickly wanted to move into was actually getting the privilege waves.
[6:59:22]
And I really appreciate the fact that you have all approved that because we feel very strongly about that.
[6:59:27]
I did get a very long discourse from the general counsel for Sears and the folks that
[6:59:37]
of the law firm, Seltzer Kaplan, about why it was not a good thing for them to weigh
[6:59:41]
privilege.
[6:59:42]
And we've conducted three meetings since then and we're beginning to get some movement.
[6:59:46]
So I feel pretty good about that.
[6:59:48]
And we've also talked about concepts of remediation as well and one thing that I would suggest
[6:59:53]
to include in your resolution is a seaboard that they comply with that because in fact that
[7:00:00]
That's what the SEC wants. That's what KPMG wants. And seaboard is not just full compliance and giving out documents.
[7:00:07]
Seaboard is remediation. And remediation has to accompany whatever we do here as well as full cooperation.
[7:00:14]
And they need to be in that because I believe in my conversations with the SEC as this Mr. Turner, that if we don't get remediation along with full cooperation on compliance
[7:00:25]
of giving the documents that we may not get to be where we ultimately need to go and KPMG
[7:00:30]
as expressed concerns about remediation as well.
[7:00:35]
All right, lastly, or I'm sorry, the next item here is we talk briefly about the relationship
[7:00:40]
with V&E, and I guess the reason we got into this paragraph was because there seemed to be some confusion
[7:00:45]
floating around out there in the press about whether or not V&E was still employed, whether we somehow
[7:00:50]
I thought they were terminated or whatever.
[7:00:54]
Okay, I understand that there was some concern
[7:00:56]
about V&E issuing a report.
[7:01:00]
I wasn't actually aware of that until I heard about the fact
[7:01:02]
that they supposedly passed the deadline
[7:01:04]
and were missing a deadline.
[7:01:07]
All I can say is that I did circle around
[7:01:08]
with V&E, they directed me to some statements
[7:01:11]
they had made in front of the council.
[7:01:13]
I think it was an early march or late February or something.
[7:01:17]
And what they had said was that they were hoping
[7:01:19]
to get a mid-APA report out, but that if there were certain situations that kept them from
[7:01:25]
doing that, and it sounds like what they were talking about was, sir's documents not
[7:01:29]
being out there, and other things that might delay the report.
[7:01:34]
So I can tell you right now that they don't have work product sufficient enough to support
[7:01:41]
a report, and that they don't have it as far as the odd committee is concerned, I can
[7:01:46]
to bug around to you, they would not have it as far as KPMG is concerned, but we are very
[7:01:51]
interested in rolling up our sleeves and working with them so they can get to that point
[7:01:54]
so we can get this thing well along the way and hopefully close to being done.
[7:02:00]
Let's see here, independent legal counsel.
[7:02:07]
We are coming here, we actually did this two weeks ago, I had a meeting with Mr. Agari,
[7:02:12]
I also had a meeting with Mr. Yule, where we let them know that we were interested in getting
[7:02:17]
independent counsel.
[7:02:19]
We had floated the name of Wilkie Farb by them, and I actually gave Mr. Yule a copy of
[7:02:24]
a draft engagement letter at that point and said, can we get this schedule so we can talk
[7:02:29]
about this?
[7:02:30]
I would refer you back to our original engagement letter, and this is before we ever got
[7:02:38]
And we were just basically trying to do independent investigation.
[7:02:42]
But it was foreseen then that we would probably need legal help,
[7:02:45]
because we understood that there were legal issues here that were at play.
[7:02:49]
Particularly KPMG's focus in October and November of 2004 on illegal acts,
[7:02:56]
which in accounting, Karla A has very important connotations.
[7:03:01]
And in fact, could keep them from issuing the audit,
[7:03:04]
unless these things were done.
[7:03:05]
So we've foresaw that in the engagement letter initially that we might need that.
[7:03:10]
We made the request committee pass, I mean the council passed it, we got the mayor
[7:03:15]
to sign the letter, we got the city attorney to sign the letter, we got the city manager
[7:03:19]
to sign the letter.
[7:03:20]
So we thought we were okay, all right, then we actually went again at this when we were told
[7:03:26]
by KPMG that it wasn't enough for us to do the independent audit.
[7:03:30]
The KPMG in fact wanted to actually sign representation letters and become the audit committee
[7:03:34]
which is when Mr. Turner and myself came in front of you before, and then requested that.
[7:03:39]
Not because we really wanted to do it, but more because KPMG felt that was a needed position
[7:03:42]
for us to be in.
[7:03:44]
In that resolution, it was adapted.
[7:03:46]
We said that we would serve as the Audit Committee, but that we wanted to have a service
[7:03:51]
at in the context of the Servain's Oxyview of what the Audit Committee was.
[7:03:55]
We did that for specific reason, because Servain's Oxyly lays out in Section 103, that if you
[7:04:01]
needed advisers and dependent advisers, you can get them if you're the audit committee.
[7:04:05]
In fact, the board has to provide them if you're a public company, and one of those
[7:04:10]
independent advisers is of course legal counsel, and I may draw a line that it's independent
[7:04:14]
legal counsel.
[7:04:16]
It's not the general counsel of the corporation or the general counsel of the business.
[7:04:20]
It's not a party that has any vested interest in what's going on.
[7:04:23]
It is somebody that's utterly and thoroughly independent to provide that audit committee
[7:04:27]
legal counsel and that's what we're coming for in front of you today to approve that because we've reached the point
[7:04:33]
We're getting close enough now, but we've got to start drawing the line and figuring out what some of these legal issues mean in order to begin to kind of put some ribbons and bows around this thing and move it to some form book
[7:04:43]
conclusion. So, that's why we are here on that.
[7:04:49]
Let's see here. Length of time, which I know is a
[7:04:58]
and council person.
[7:05:00]
And for eyes interaction from the first meeting we had out here on this. And I can assure you that I don't think when we started in February, we had
[7:05:10]
under any understanding of exactly how complicated and how detailed this was going to be. And only after a long, long period of time, and trying to work through the myriad of issues, have we sort of begin to understand exactly how difficult this is, but in fact, the things that are probably running the time schedule to some degree are a little
[7:05:28]
of our control. There are two things that have to happen and I would refer you back to C-board
[7:05:34]
that are going to have to be going in place and we talk about them here in the letter. One
[7:05:39]
is that you've got to have full cooperation on the document production. There is no doubt that
[7:05:44]
quite a number of the documents that are being withheld by CIRS are, in fact, incredibly relevant
[7:05:50]
to the allegations that are floating around out there. Very, very much, on point, matters relating
[7:05:57]
MP2 and various things. So it's critical that those actually be made available to us so that
[7:06:05]
we can make them available to KPMG so that we can really and truly show that we had a thorough
[7:06:10]
investigation. Unfortunately, and it took a long time to figure this out, the city itself is
[7:06:15]
not actually in compliance with the subpoenas that were issued almost a year ago. And that was
[7:06:21]
not an easy story to figure out, but between talking to V&E and some people to city attorney's
[7:06:26]
office, what you have currently as a situation where the city has, in sort of, a piece
[7:06:31]
of mell form delivered a lot of production, but not a complete production to the SEC, relating
[7:06:37]
to those initial subpoenas.
[7:06:39]
And so we've been trying to work with V&E as counsel for the city, as opposed to their independent
[7:06:45]
investigation status, to try and work in some way that, in fact, the city can now become fully
[7:06:51]
compliant and produce the rest of the documents that would have been under the subpoena,
[7:06:55]
Or that is our end of this pinna and my understanding is is that I think Mr. Mako will be here later in the week
[7:07:01]
And it's going to be trying to talk with the SEC to get a full understanding of exactly what needs to be done to get that taking care of
[7:07:07]
But we've been kicking around some ideas to hopefully draw conclusion to that which may subject you all to a little bit more
[7:07:14]
Having to dig down deep and find a few more pieces of information, but unfortunately the subpoena
[7:07:21]
really didn't get shown to too many people until almost January of this year after some
[7:07:27]
problematic things and the first protocol which I really hadn't seen until a couple of weeks
[7:07:32]
ago unfortunately doesn't look a whole lot like the subpoena which was what was
[7:07:36]
issued by the city's attorney office last summer so it was easy to see that you know
[7:07:41]
the subpoena wasn't fully you could you could reply you could give documents for the
[7:07:50]
unfortunate but that's just the way it worked out. So that needs to be kind of taken care of and the
[7:07:54]
SEC is very interested in having that happen and they do think that now we are working with them and the
[7:08:00]
city is working with them to bring that to a good conclusion.
[7:08:05]
Let's see here. We've talked about
[7:08:06]
serious waving its privilege which is critical remediation plan. I'm at the bottom of our third page.
[7:08:12]
The seaboard case which the SEC direction 2 and the KPMG direction 2 basically talks about that you
[7:08:20]
You can have all the cooperation in the world but if you don't remediate the problems, you haven't gotten to where you need to be.
[7:08:26]
And although the city has taken some steps and in fact, the need to lay out some remediation plans that the city has adopted in their first report,
[7:08:35]
I could safely say the SECC and KPMG don't think the city is where it needs to be on this.
[7:08:40]
And I would also say that it's probably not the city, but it's also serious as well.
[7:08:44]
Because both have involvement in these things and both have to take a pretty serious look at the way things have been done in the past and some changes that need to be made in the future.
[7:08:54]
And to give you an idea of what we're talking about for remediation, we're talking about looking at individuals, but we're also talking about looking at the positions the individuals are in.
[7:09:02]
And then the rules or the controls or whatever that exist around the individuals doing these things.
[7:09:07]
And one of the problems in this investigation, which I didn't completely understand the totality
[7:09:12]
of until, you know, maybe a few weeks ago, was when you talk about some of these issues,
[7:09:17]
they run from almost the top to the bottom of the city government, and sometimes they run
[7:09:20]
out the sites for seers as well.
[7:09:22]
So you are looking at a whole lot of folks that are involved in a lot of different capacities
[7:09:27]
that some way or another drop the ball or didn't do something they should have been doing
[7:09:31]
that didn't get done, and that needs to be rectified, and as I explained to the serious folks
[7:09:36]
morning just putting a new board and seers doesn't get that done.
[7:09:40]
You know, they may be new people but they still could be subject to some of the same pitfalls
[7:09:44]
that some of the folks in the past may have gone through.
[7:09:47]
So that remediation plan and development needs to be done and it will be done with us leading
[7:09:52]
the way but we're going to need some help from various people in the city and seers and to
[7:09:57]
do that and hopefully the city of attorney's office and other people.
[7:10:00]
We'll focus on that because it will be a big task. But in fact, the peace meal actions that have been done thus far, unfortunately, really aren't being recognized by the SEC or KPMG as really big steps in remediation. Now, if it was all laid out and documented in the plan and we showed how various things have been done thus far and then more is going to be done, that would go a long way to putting the SEC and KPMG in a much happier spot and quite frankly, the audit committee as well.
[7:10:26]
So that's probably the biggest piece that's out there and we don't have to wait until we finish the investigation to do the remediation plan.
[7:10:36]
We can do that in concurrent fashion.
[7:10:38]
There's already a lot of information floating around out there that people know about that can begin to take actions and do things.
[7:10:46]
But we can sort of begin to develop the plan while we're doing the investigation and while we're floating pieces together.
[7:10:51]
And then hopefully that way you don't have a long time before in between when the investigations
[7:10:56]
done and the remediation plan for the most part is put into effect.
[7:11:02]
So that's sort of a status, I probably miss some things because we've been trying to run
[7:11:06]
around do a lot of things, but that's at least a brief overview of where we are today.
[7:11:14]
Mr. Peters, did you wish to say something before we call on the city attorney?
[7:11:21]
Okay.
[7:11:22]
Why don't we call on the city attorney then?
[7:11:27]
Okay.
[7:11:27]
This is all we want you either sit there right in the front row or at the chair right over there or wherever I think there'll be people that will be wanting to ask you some questions.
[7:11:45]
I think this is working.
[7:11:47]
First of all I'd like to familiarize those that might be listening.
[7:11:54]
I have been a securities trial attorney for 25 years and I'm a certified fraud examiner.
[7:12:00]
which means that I had to take and pass a very extensive test, certified fraud examiners
[7:12:07]
are brought in by CPAs to do forensic analysis when there are audit procedures that have
[7:12:15]
to be performed, such as AU Section 316, which is a fraud audit procedure, or AU Section 317,
[7:12:23]
which is an illegal acts audit procedure.
[7:12:27]
The importance here which Mr. Dalberg, I think, wanted to get to but may not have gotten to is the analysis is not an audit.
[7:12:38]
In other words, the 317 illegal acts analysis component that involves an attorney or an investigation.
[7:12:45]
It is not an audit. It's what goes beyond the audit. The 317 is lays out what happens
[7:12:54]
when there are suspected illegal acts or what is supposed to happen when there are suspected illegal
[7:13:00]
acts that could have a direct or indirect impact on a financial statement.
[7:13:08]
A, the way in which there can be an impact would be, for example, in our financial statement,
[7:13:15]
if there was a determination as we found that there was a substantial evidence of the securities laws,
[7:13:22]
full disclosure provisions of the securities laws, we're not complied with,
[7:13:26]
then the next step in the step that KPMG would analyze is what is what's called the FASB5 content liability impact.
[7:13:33]
In other words, is there a likelihood that there are investors out there who might sue us
[7:13:40]
on the bond issuances that involved the failure to disclose all facts or material misrepresentations?
[7:13:51]
And I think as time has shown, and as I have indicated before, it doesn't appear that there
[7:13:56]
is a FASB-5 impact at this time, in other words, it doesn't appear that there is a contingent
[7:14:02]
liability that needs to be accounted for in our financial statement, why?
[7:14:07]
Well, because this information has been out there for a long period of time, our last offering
[7:14:12]
was, in some time, during the mid part of 2003, you know, it's well over two years ago,
[7:14:20]
about two years ago, and normally having been a plaintiff's securities lawyer,
[7:14:29]
plaintiff's
[7:14:32]
let in the water they attack pretty quickly and we haven't seen that. So I'm not saying we're
[7:14:37]
out of the woods altogether on the FASB5 but it is in a can be a problem but at least as to
[7:14:43]
your city attorney from your city attorney's point of view after 25 years in the security
[7:14:47]
market and being a certified fraud examiner and after having examined this very carefully it
[7:14:52]
appears to me that we don't have currently a FASB5 content liability problem. The second
[7:14:58]
the way that direct.
[7:15:00]
Your indirect legal acts can have an impact on the financial statement with regard to remedial action. That is under AU Section 319, which is the internal control procedures and provisions of the auditing standards.
[7:15:13]
An entity has to maintain reliable internal controls. An internal control means attitudes and people, systems and procedures to make sure that the information internally that is developed, that can have a financial statement impact
[7:15:27]
is in fact maintained so that the financial statements can be properly classified described and disclosed.
[7:15:34]
The problem that we have is we do have a remedial problem.
[7:15:38]
I have to tell you that this council is probably the best suited and the best able to take remedial steps.
[7:15:45]
You do not have to wait and I urge you and I have urge you and I have in the most recent report and number four and numerous instances.
[7:15:53]
I've urged you to let the individuals go, buy out their contracts, do whatever we have to
[7:16:00]
do when Mr. Yulees, do a nationwide search for our new city manager who is a turnaround
[7:16:06]
specialist with a high reputation for financial veracity and create an internal system following
[7:16:14]
a use section 319 and the principal set forth there and so that we have the remedial steps
[7:16:19]
that we need and that we have the rebuilding of our internal control system.
[7:16:24]
We don't have to spend $5 million on that.
[7:16:26]
We can do that here.
[7:16:27]
This council is extremely well suited to do that if we were to put our heads together.
[7:16:33]
Now, let me go over what my concerns are.
[7:16:35]
If you notice, I did not sign off on the 1472.
[7:16:39]
I think it's a 1472 that was presented to the council.
[7:16:41]
The city attorney did not sign off.
[7:16:43]
And I do not support this in its current form.
[7:16:46]
I'm hopeful that Mr. Dalberg and myself,
[7:16:49]
Mr. Eul and others involved can sit down and negotiate something, but I am very concerned about the direction that we are being asked to take right now because I don't think your interests or the city's interests will be protected.
[7:17:02]
Let me show you something. This is from the 29 October 2004 letter from KPMG to Mayor Murphy and city manager Lamont Eul. Now I'm not in no way criticizing the mayor. I'm just simply for purposes of a record.
[7:17:19]
In this document, it provides,
[7:17:24]
this was the letter says in our correspondence, we not only
[7:17:27]
discussed relevant auditing literature, but also explicated for the city, some of the applicable
[7:17:32]
accounting principles that require the city in its financial statements to make disclosures
[7:17:38]
of any violations of financial related laws and regulations.
[7:17:43]
And close there with was the November 2004 AICPA Association of Independent Certified Public Accountants was the practice bulletin for illegal acts.
[7:18:00]
And let me see if I can zoom in a little bit closer to the illegal act you'll see if you'll notice right there illegal acts.
[7:18:06]
What this does is it expands upon a use section 317 procedures and what happens is when the auditor arrives at the conclusion in our case when you have the SEC and all the other investigations
[7:18:18]
When the auditor arrives at the point that there may be likely illegal acts, then the auditor typically confers with the general counsel in this case that would be the city attorney
[7:18:30]
With the general counsel to gain a deeper understanding of the facts and circumstances of the illegal acts,
[7:18:36]
and as this practice guide indicates goes beyond when you have a complex matter like ours
[7:18:42]
and develops that and you can, in fact, use outside counsel.
[7:18:46]
It's not necessary, but you can do that.
[7:18:49]
Now, the next document I'd like to show you is the status report
[7:18:58]
that has been provided to you last Friday, and one of the reasons I didn't sign off on this
[7:19:04]
is that I felt that there should have been more lead-up time there was an initial discussion
[7:19:09]
with Mr. Dalburg, but I felt that there should have been more careful negotiations
[7:19:12]
so that we could make sure that what we brought before you, everyone had bought in on.
[7:19:17]
Last Friday, Mr. Dalburg sent this to you, and in it, he said, also has attached, also
[7:19:27]
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants that is to be followed by independent
[7:19:31]
auditors and performing audits of the city's financial statements.
[7:19:36]
And he cited the same practice guide that had already been cited to the city in October.
[7:19:42]
So October, November, December, January, February, March, April, May.
[7:19:47]
So we already basically knew this back when I took over a city attorney and I discovered
[7:19:52]
document in doing our interim reports 1, 2, and 3, I followed the practice.
[7:20:00]
As it relates to what the city attorney is supposed to do, and one of the things that I told KPMG, and KPMG has certified
[7:20:08]
fraud examiners, is that it's unlikely that any attorney will give a definitive opinion that someone
[7:20:16]
did or did not commit a crime or in fact commit any legal act. That's not a likely thing to happen. And in fact,
[7:20:23]
certified fraud examiners are prohibited from reaching that conclusion. The appropriate method
[7:20:31]
and the appropriate expression, after there's what's called a predication. A predication
[7:20:35]
is that which initiates a suspicion of fraud or illegal acts. After a predication is discovered,
[7:20:42]
after an appropriate investigation is conducted, then if the certified fraud examiner slash attorney
[7:20:49]
It comes to the conclusion that there is an evidence of an illegal act.
[7:20:54]
The proper terminology is to say that evidence was found consistent with a finding.
[7:20:59]
But only juries or triars of fact make ultimate judgments.
[7:21:04]
And that is exactly the language that I used in interim report number two to come to the conclusion
[7:21:10]
that there was significant evidence.
[7:21:12]
For purposes of assessing financial statement impacts, which is what this is all about,
[7:21:20]
both for purposes of remedial, and as well for purposes of determining if there's a
[7:21:25]
FASP-5 content liability impact that is an impact that's going to have an impact on the numbers
[7:21:30]
on the financial statement, increasing liabilities, and in order to do that, you do not have
[7:21:35]
to have a jury verdict judgment.
[7:21:38]
You just have to have reasonableness, and so right now, as a practical matter, KPMG has in
[7:21:45]
their possession if the council were to permit this to go forward, if KPMG has in their
[7:21:50]
possession, I contend sufficient, and perhaps it needs to be supplemented somewhere, but
[7:21:56]
a lot of information, a lot of findings, a lot of legal information that would allow them
[7:22:03]
sufficiently, to sufficiently allow them to make an assessment about the disclosure of financial
[7:22:10]
statement impact.
[7:22:12]
And that's part of the problem here that some of the professionals seem to be not carefully
[7:22:19]
walking through the standards so that your interests are protected and they're doing that
[7:22:24]
at extraordinarily very high dollar charges.
[7:22:28]
You know, $900 as high as $900 in the case of Mr. Dalberg's associate, Mr. Levitt, and
[7:22:35]
the proposed outside council.
[7:22:37]
So one of the things I'm concerned about is that we not lose our focus and not be careful
[7:22:44]
about the standard that we have to approach.
[7:22:48]
Now, if I might show you, on November 23rd, and this is of the most immediate concern
[7:22:54]
to me.
[7:22:54]
On November 23rd, in a memorandum that Mr. Gerard sent to Ms. Fry, he indicated that
[7:23:03]
your request, you requested a copy of the work plan for additional investigation to be performed
[7:23:10]
by Vincent and Elkins with respect to the audit by KPMG, and close please find a copy of
[7:23:15]
the plan.
[7:23:16]
I did not include that because it was covered by privilege.
[7:23:20]
On February the 10th, and their agreement, the Crow firm said, subsequent to the issuance
[7:23:29]
of this report, that is the September 16th report issued by Vini, we understand that KPMG
[7:23:36]
has requested additional competent, evidential matter.
[7:23:38]
That's what's called an AU Section 326 standard, to sufficient competent, evidential matter.
[7:23:45]
It deemed themes necessary to complete its audit in accordance with applicable accounting, auditing, and professional standards.
[7:23:53]
We also understand that V&E has engaged, and has been engaged, to perform additional work,
[7:23:59]
it is our understanding KPMG has requested the results of the V&E investigation.
[7:24:04]
So what was happening then is, as Mr. Gerard explained to Council Member Frey, there was a work plan,
[7:24:12]
And that work plan, it was supposed to be pursued.
[7:24:16]
And then we emphasize it again.
[7:24:18]
It says, we also understand Vini has engaged,
[7:24:22]
has been engaged to perform this additional work.
[7:24:25]
It is our understanding KPMG has requested the results
[7:24:28]
of the Vini investigations.
[7:24:30]
Now, what I'm concerned about is that in the same 10,
[7:24:36]
February 2005 letter, the Crowell firm said that the city
[7:24:41]
has requested that Crowell receive review and evaluate the findings of the investigations by
[7:24:46]
Vini in the City Attorney. In other words, the council was concerned some members of the
[7:24:49]
council did not like my report, which was certainly their right, and there was a judgment made by
[7:24:55]
myself and others that the best thing to do was to call in someone like Len Turner with a high reputation.
[7:25:00]
You could weigh the V&E report, you could weigh the city attorney's report, and make a judgment one way the other about which report was credible and how we should proceed.
[7:25:10]
But now, when we get to the letter last week, let me go back and just quickly point out.
[7:25:17]
First, they said on February 12, we have also understand that V&E has been engaged to perform this additional work.
[7:25:24]
It's our understanding that KPMG has requested the results of the V&E investigations.
[7:25:29]
Then we go to last week, and it says, from the cruel firm, questions have been raised as to whether or not Vincent and Elkins work program will result in another report from that firm.
[7:25:42]
The independent daughters have not, specifically, requested.
[7:25:47]
So, in other words, they seem to now be saying the opposite, that they haven't requested the report from Vini.
[7:25:52]
So, in other words, we went from the point that KPMG wasn't happy with Vincent Nelkins.
[7:26:00]
city attorney does a report.
[7:26:02]
KPMG is retained to come back and do a report.
[7:26:04]
We bring in the new folks, the dog and Troy, Troy dogberg and the crow firm.
[7:26:12]
They're supposed to weigh the reports.
[7:26:15]
But then instead of the weighing of the reports, and let me tell you,
[7:26:17]
I've spoke to Paul Maco and Vini and they were adamant that they would have that report done by April 15th and in fact that was an outside date
[7:26:25]
I believe that they they told me that expressly they told John McNally or outside council and so now what I'm concerned about is
[7:26:35]
the
[7:26:36]
the next statement
[7:26:37]
are the what's happening is that
[7:26:41]
we're letting Vini off the hook
[7:26:43]
that Vini isn't actually going to issue a report
[7:26:46]
that they already should have issued the report, and that now the auditing or the outside
[7:26:53]
professional audit committee is stepping in and bringing in new counsel to perform the work
[7:26:59]
that V&E has been paid a ton of money to perform.
[7:27:03]
And now if we look at the April 19th letter from the Wilkie firm, which is a very fine firm,
[7:27:09]
Michael Arighong is an excellent attorney, an excellent defense attorney,
[7:27:14]
Benito Romano, former U.S. attorney of New York, some of the highest-priced New York
[7:27:21]
legal talent we could find. But unfortunately, the function that they would be performing
[7:27:27]
is the function V&E was supposed to be performing, for which we spend all that money.
[7:27:31]
And this is what they say. The city, I'm going to come back to, I'm sorry, I jumped ahead of myself there.
[7:27:42]
This is the April 19th of the scope of our engagement.
[7:27:45]
This is the scope of the engagement that the wilky firm is supposed to perform.
[7:27:51]
The scope of our engagement will include council and assistance to the audit committee,
[7:27:55]
and a connection with its independent investigation into SDCERS.
[7:27:59]
That's what V&E was supposed to do, and that's what they were supposed to,
[7:28:03]
that's what they were supposed to perform.
[7:28:04]
It will also include other matters that in the judgment of the audit committee may require
[7:28:09]
inquiry or investigation.
[7:28:10]
That's very open with no limit on what that can be.
[7:28:15]
Then, this is the part, although we are serving as Council to the audit committee, payment
[7:28:22]
of our bills is to be the responsibility of the city, no, no, no, no.
[7:28:27]
We are not, I mean, in my judgment, retaining high priced New York lawyers, not answerable
[7:28:33]
the city council that the audit committee can run up as big a bill as they want and the city council
[7:28:39]
has to pay that is not prudent and I cannot advise you to do that. I'm not saying we can't do
[7:28:44]
something to try to make this work but that would be reckless and let me just say this. The individuals
[7:28:51]
that we're talking about are not admitted. Mr. Benito Romano and Mr. Michael Ariang are not admitted
[7:28:58]
to practice law in the state of California. Many of the questions 1090 issues and others that
[7:29:05]
are before the audit committee are California legal questions. No person shall practice law
[7:29:11]
in California unless the person is an active member of the state bar and you might say,
[7:29:15]
wait a minute, this is a big national problem, these are big national firm. A Supreme Court case
[7:29:21]
Right on point, called the burn bomb case, says, quote, although we are aware of the
[7:29:31]
inner state nature of modern law practice and mindful of the reality that large firms
[7:29:35]
often conduct activities and serve clients in several states, we do not believe these facts
[7:29:42]
excuse law firms from compliance section 61, 25, and 61, 25 says that you have to be a member,
[7:29:51]
no person shall practice law in California unless the person is an active member of the state bar.
[7:29:56]
That law firm in the burn bomb case was in fact a New York firm.
[7:30:00]
And it was found to have been practicing law in the State of California. Now, here's in wrapping up, here's the other concern that I have.
[7:30:10]
In the April 19th letter, they want the city agrees to pay reimburse and demodify and hold harmless the wilky firm. So on the one hand, what's happening is the audit committee's kind of coming in and giving a little cover
[7:30:27]
For Vincent and Alkins to exit stage right, I don't know when the last time Mr. Michael was here but to sort of say it's OK for them not to give us that written opinion, they exit stage right and then the new firm is brought in, it works not for us, but for the audit committee we have to pay all the bills, but then we have to agree to indemnify the firm, which means that we have to give them, we have to pay them for any damages, and then it says the city agrees to indemnify and hold harmless.
[7:30:56]
this firm and under our rules of professional conduct rule 3,400 it says that a member shall not contract with a client
[7:31:07]
prospectively limiting the member's liability. Now, final slide.
[7:31:13]
If you look at where we are and maybe I can ask Mr.
[7:31:18]
Van Durlin and Phil go to the other. Thank you. Yes, if you look at the where we are and I'm not I'm not
[7:31:27]
I think the council because this has been a tough, tough problem, but if I can, if I can, if I can, I'll, I'll help you, Miss
[7:31:34]
Atkins.
[7:31:34]
What it says is it's got Vincent and Atkins started off with actually the first bill they had for this
[7:31:42]
was about $24,000, but we have it as a $150.
[7:31:47]
We started off as a $150 with them, and we're now at $3,743,000, and $36,000, that's $3,000,
[7:31:55]
seven hundred and forty three thousand and thirty six dollars and no final written report
[7:32:02]
KPMG now I want to say something about KPMG as you know I've been a very big defender of KPMG
[7:32:07]
Mr. Messia's informed me of something that I should have known and I apologize to the council for this
[7:32:11]
but I should have known this some time ago
[7:32:14]
KPMG
[7:32:14]
was an accountant to CPA for Orange County when Orange County got in trouble and KPMG was in fact
[7:32:24]
uh... discipline
[7:32:25]
by the state board of accountancy now that's not that i'm not trying to
[7:32:28]
tarnish k p m g's reputation but i need to tell you
[7:32:31]
that the difficulty is that if you have been if you've been
[7:32:35]
already
[7:32:36]
in difficulty with the state board of accountancy because of something like
[7:32:39]
orange county
[7:32:40]
you are very very very very cautious
[7:32:44]
very cautious
[7:32:45]
because you have your own interest to think about
[7:32:48]
if you make a mistake
[7:32:49]
and back up to the city of sandigo i'm not blaming k p m g
[7:32:52]
But I'm telling you that I wish that I would have known that earlier and I felt myself for
[7:32:57]
not.
[7:32:58]
Now the cruel firm, we started off with a $75,000 payment authorized $250 and now that
[7:33:05]
we're going to get up to a million, $750,000.
[7:33:10]
And I'll do respect to Mr. Dobrik.
[7:33:11]
I find him to be a very competent and excellent attorney.
[7:33:16]
But in terms of the work product that I've seen so far and some of his statements,
[7:33:21]
for him to say that he's going to apply audit type work paper analysis when the or that
[7:33:31]
he hasn't been provided the documentation any San Diego can go to the city attorney's
[7:33:37]
website and pull up every single document but one in which we have at the office every single
[7:33:44]
document that we cite to is included already in our report and most of them are contemporaneously
[7:33:50]
written documents and the standard under 317 is a standard that says that for purposes of assessing
[7:33:58]
whether there's sufficient evidence to analyze a potential financial statement impact
[7:34:02]
or whether there's enough information for us to say we need remedial action believe me.
[7:34:08]
There is more than overwhelming evidence in all of our reports and I will tell you that
[7:34:14]
I'm a trial lawyer, I prepared those reports as if I was going to go to trial.
[7:34:18]
most of those documents are self-authenticating or it would be easily authenticated documents
[7:34:24]
contemporaneously written documents surrendered by the individuals that were authors of them
[7:34:30]
and then the Wilkie firm who we haven't even think about this. The audit firm wants you to spend
[7:34:35]
$500,000 a down payment that will grow I guarantee you two millions and millions and millions of dollars on the Wilkie firm and they're
[7:34:44]
even here. Now, look, we've all had our differences, but I will tell you that I am fine.
[7:34:51]
It's hard as I can to look out for the best interest of the city and for your interest.
[7:34:55]
There is no way that this council can offer.
[7:35:00]
Authorize $500,000 for a law firm and not even have that law firm show up and explain what they're
[7:35:07]
going to be doing and have us completely trust Mr. Turner, Mr. Dalberg, and Mr. Levin. We do not have
[7:35:13]
a prior existing relationship with them. As I say, I find Mr. Dalberg to be a good man, but
[7:35:19]
I under no circumstances can we buy a pig and a poke like that. And so my suggestion is this.
[7:35:26]
Send us back to the negotiating table.
[7:35:30]
Mr. Yul, I respect Mr. Yul, I know he's trying to do the best.
[7:35:33]
I know he's trying to get that audit out.
[7:35:35]
He just wants to get that audit out and I respect that.
[7:35:38]
And as you may be able to tell, we have been working together much better.
[7:35:42]
And I apologize for anything I've done in the past.
[7:35:45]
But send us back to the table, make us all get back and negotiate.
[7:35:49]
Don't let them just circumvent the city attorney like this.
[7:35:52]
know but get us back there and I will promise you good faith in negotiations and bring us back
[7:35:58]
in a week or two weeks max and we'll work hard to get that attorney client privilege way
[7:36:04]
of over at the S.D. Sarah's board and we'll come back with a better plan. Thank you.
[7:36:13]
We originally had three speakers. I think I only see one left. Jarvis Ross, Bruce Henderson,
[7:36:17]
I think is gone. Phil Hart is gone, but Jarvis Ross, Mr. Reliable, still here.
[7:36:30]
I'm always reminded of several things when I come down here to City Council.
[7:36:34]
One of them goes back many years.
[7:36:37]
One of my professors said, the mine can only absorb what the seat can endure.
[7:36:45]
Anyway, I appreciate all the discussion that's taken place by Mr. Dalmer and our City Attorney.
[7:36:54]
I have to say the vision that came to mind happened back in the late 30s in New Jersey when
[7:37:03]
the Hindu Berg was about to land, and that was a picture of what I see another financial
[7:37:10]
disaster here.
[7:37:13]
The amount of money that is being spent on this whole thing, and I'm just, I'm appalled at
[7:37:23]
what I've heard from Mr. Dalburg with regard to the other firms that we've hired.
[7:37:31]
And then
[7:37:31]
when I hear other remarks, and I agree with our attorney with his presentation that we go out
[7:37:39]
and blindly hire another attorney.
[7:37:44]
I'm just speaking as a private citizen, but people who speak to
[7:37:48]
me too, because they know I come down here.
[7:37:53]
We're trying to figure out, and our city manager
[7:37:57]
has struggled, I think, to come up with a budget, and then I hear this, this is a disaster.
[7:38:05]
I don't know how many of you familiar with sinkholes. I spent some time in my youth on
[7:38:10]
my grandfather's farm, and that too far from us, all of a sudden, a road disappeared into
[7:38:16]
a sinkhole, and you could keep throwing they did. They threw a lot of stuff in that sinkhole
[7:38:22]
to keep going down and down. They finally moved the road to another location. All I can
[7:38:28]
say is please give this deep consideration where we're throwing public money, sir. There's
[7:38:36]
got to be some rationale, I think. Just asking you, please step back and consider what has
[7:38:44]
discussed here this afternoon. Thank you.
[7:38:50]
Mr. Peters.
[7:38:51]
Thank you, Your Honor. I want to say that I think we're all frustrated with how much money this is costing and how much time it's taking.
[7:39:03]
I would say to that, you know, we've really tried to be conscious of this budget and extraordinarily difficult times.
[7:39:11]
We just had an election, a prospect of a mayoral election come before us, which cost $3 million to $6 million.
[7:39:20]
I asked that we not do that.
[7:39:22]
We had a living wage proposal, which I thought was probably pretty good one at other times,
[7:39:30]
but will be $3 million on next year's budget. I asked that we not do that.
[7:39:36]
We have a dispute over the Mount Solidade Cross in my district which could go to the ballot that will cost $2 million.
[7:39:45]
And I'll ask that we don't do that.
[7:39:49]
In this case, however, this is the single most important thing that we're working on.
[7:39:53]
This audit.
[7:39:55]
And we're talking about a similar amount of money as we're talking about.
[7:40:00]
About with the council, that cross.
[7:40:04]
And it still pains me to do that, but I think we have to get through this.
[7:40:09]
We hired Vincent and Elkins to help us do an independent investigation.
[7:40:15]
I understand they've spent a lot of money. Mr. Dalberg, you know, you tell me that they have it in loose leaves, instead of in binders, or, you know,
[7:40:25]
And I hate to think that you're spending money actually telling them how to bind up their documents.
[7:40:33]
But on the other hand, if that's what the SEC needs and that's what KPMG needs, then we have to do it.
[7:40:39]
As far as KPMG is concerned, I think all of us are suspicious from time to time about whether they have an interest in giving us our order or not.
[7:40:48]
But, on the other hand, I think they're a big four accounting firm, I think they have professional ethics, and we're pretty far down the road with them, and I think we ought to, I don't, I think we looked terrible to switch auditors in mid course, and we'd have to start all over again, so I'll see you in each choice.
[7:41:05]
And we brought in, Mr. Turner, who's the Chief Accountant of the SEC, Arthur Levitt, who was the chairman of the SEC.
[7:41:17]
And we, you're, you Mr. Dober, because we thought you were the team that was best suited to tell us what KPMG needs, what the SEC needs, so that we can get past this.
[7:41:27]
I see, I just think that's the course one.
[7:41:33]
I appreciate your update about, and by the way, the original contract with Crow that we all
[7:41:42]
approved in March, the City Attorney signed, said, and I think you told us on the record
[7:41:48]
that you might hire, or Mr. Turner told us that he might want to hire outside council, and
[7:41:53]
It's very clearly in the contract.
[7:41:56]
The resolution says that you would function as the audit committee
[7:42:00]
as they do under sarbanes, Oxley.
[7:42:02]
It's very clear that outside auditors under sarbanes,
[7:42:04]
Oxley, it's expected that they may hire outside council.
[7:42:11]
So I'm not surprised by this.
[7:42:14]
I think that the people that you've suggested are qualified.
[7:42:19]
They have the kind of experience that you would need
[7:42:21]
and they're advising you as the audit committee.
[7:42:26]
Now, just so I just want to make sure that people understand,
[7:42:30]
I did look at their proposed agreement,
[7:42:35]
and I was concerned by the suggestion that we would
[7:42:38]
indemnify them, hold them harmless.
[7:42:40]
But the full, I think the full paragraph says
[7:42:45]
that that indemnity applies unless and until it were to be
[7:42:51]
torches or beyond the scope of the engagement,
[7:42:55]
so that wave or the indemnity is appropriately
[7:43:00]
limited if they're negligent or potentially wrongdoers, that doesn't apply and so that
[7:43:09]
would not be outside the bounds, I don't think.
[7:43:15]
I listen to the commentary about the written report, what the engagement refers to as an
[7:43:23]
investigation.
[7:43:24]
There is no description in the V&E engagement letter, which I also have here of a written
[7:43:30]
report.
[7:43:30]
Now we all expect a written report, and I think we deserve a written report.
[7:43:34]
What you're saying, Mr. Dalberg, is that before the written report is issued, you want
[7:43:39]
make sure that KPMG and perhaps the Securities Exchange Commission will be happy with the
[7:43:45]
written report when it's prepared.
[7:43:46]
So I have no problem with you being in Vincent and Elkins' face about how they prepare
[7:43:52]
the written report so that when we do get what we paid for, we don't have to go back
[7:43:56]
into a third report because I think we're all very frustrated that we had to do a second report.
[7:44:02]
So I want to head that off at the pass that it sounded like that's what you're working on
[7:44:06]
And I think that that's appropriate.
[7:44:10]
I want to address the notion that you're hiring Wokephar as a replacement to a replacement
[7:44:17]
counsel for Vincent and Elkins.
[7:44:19]
Can you describe if that's true?
[7:44:22]
And if not, what it is that Wokephar would be doing is different from what Vincent and
[7:44:26]
Elkins would be doing?
[7:44:29]
We are absolutely not hiring Wokephar as a replacement.
[7:44:33]
matter of fact I don't think that's technically possible because the council hired V&E to not
[7:44:39]
only be a council for the city represent you but then also in line of the independent investigation.
[7:44:47]
We are solely, solely looking to hire WELCY FAR as legal counsel to the audit committee only to the
[7:44:55]
extent that we need legal guidance on the issues that we're going to have to face to get through this.
[7:45:00]
And run it to ground. So Vini and Wookiefar have virtually nothing to do with each other, except, you know, Vini may be investigating some things that we may look to Wookiefar for some guidance and some of the things they're investigating. Just to give us legal guidance, because Mr. Levit, Mr. Turner, are not attorneys. And although I am an attorney, I'm not acting as attorney here. I'm nearly a CPA and this one. So we need desperately need the legal assistance. Okay.
[7:45:28]
And okay, so the idea is that they're going to advise you as a legal matter as in your role as the independent
[7:45:34]
Audit committee solely and no they have no role if you look at their letter. They have no relationship with a city
[7:45:40]
The letters very clear no relationship with the mayor and the council the other than we're coming to you basically to ask to pay their bill
[7:45:46]
That's it, which you we anticipated you would do two months ago when you told us you might hire outside council
[7:45:55]
And so
[7:45:57]
Do you have a, I think another issue that's been raised in the written report was whether there's a pre-existing relationship between Wilkie
[7:46:03]
Far and KPMG or Crow. Can you describe that?
[7:46:09]
Yes, as far as let's say Wilkie and KPMG, I believe that Wilkie has represented KPMG a few times on some accounting malpractice issues.
[7:46:21]
Michael Young is probably one of the foremost legal authorities in the United States on
[7:46:27]
accountants in all practice.
[7:46:28]
There's an article that he put together about doing investigations which Mr. Turner thought
[7:46:33]
would be good for us to share with you.
[7:46:35]
I can tell you that KPMG was overjoyed to hear that we were going to actually bring him
[7:46:41]
in on this matter.
[7:46:43]
He's been doing a lot of work with them.
[7:46:44]
He has worked for audit committees that they've been doing audits for and had very good
[7:46:49]
success for public companies, so they view him as probably one of the most qualified people in the whole country we could get on this situation.
[7:46:58]
Well, he's just parenthetically KPMG was overjoyed to hear that we'd asked for a waiver. KPMG was overjoyed to hear that we hired a new auditor.
[7:47:05]
KPMG was overjoyed to hear that we'd hired an interner. That was two months ago, and I'm just not sure how much further than long we are with KPMG.
[7:47:14]
Do you think that they're in a position to if we get through all this to issue an audit to sign an audit for us?
[7:47:22]
I think so, I think the one thing I can understand your frustrations with KPMG, but I will say this.
[7:47:28]
I came out of 20 years of public accounting, I just left an incident young as a partner a year ago.
[7:47:33]
And they have yet to see a thorough independent investigation that can satisfy them to the point where they can get the rep letter signed and get this thing closed out.
[7:47:42]
We have talked about illegal acts today, but there's a lot more going on than just the illegal
[7:47:47]
act.
[7:47:47]
So you've described what you're going through with Vincent Melkins, which is this work
[7:47:51]
paper behind the work kind of backup production you're doing.
[7:47:59]
Supporting work papers and documentation, that's correct.
[7:48:03]
So when you get all that together, you'll show that the KPMG, they'll say, yeah, this
[7:48:08]
is what we're looking for, then Vincent Melkins would be able to go ahead and prepare their
[7:48:11]
report.
[7:48:12]
Yes, and actually we plan to, we're not going to wait until Vini's finished, right?
[7:48:17]
In other words, once there are many issues here that are there investigating and we are interested in investigating.
[7:48:25]
Once we get a number of them fully documented and we're going to invite KPMG in and we're going to start testing the waters immediately about,
[7:48:33]
is this what you want to see? Is this where you're going? Are you happy with the efficiency of the documents that were investigated?
[7:48:38]
it, key word searches, hard drives, emails, whatever it is, it's a relevant to that particular
[7:48:44]
issue.
[7:48:45]
Okay, well I just say that you, Mr. Galer, we are looking to you to narrow this down to be very,
[7:48:51]
I mean I think, frankly, some of the things you say to us are very cryptic, they are
[7:48:54]
accountant speak, and you know what, you've earned by a remediation plan. I think you
[7:49:00]
mean we need to fire people, but I don't think you say it that way, and I think it's hard
[7:49:04]
us understand exactly what you mean by that. I wish you'd be more directive with us if
[7:49:12]
there's something you think we need to do. Let me just say, I think I have a lot of faith in
[7:49:18]
you, I have a lot of faith in Mr. Turner, I think the SEC does and I think that KPMG does.
[7:49:26]
We're really relying, I need this city, is really relying on you to help us get through this,
[7:49:31]
to take the material that Vincent and Alkins produced,
[7:49:37]
to take the material that this city attorney's produced,
[7:49:39]
and he's raised the very important questions.
[7:49:42]
And to do your independent view of view of it
[7:49:45]
and to get us through it, and I'll support this today,
[7:49:48]
and I'd make the motion to support it.
[7:49:51]
But I just want you to hear while we're here
[7:49:54]
that I've been supportive of this.
[7:49:56]
I think the audit is the most important thing
[7:49:58]
we've got going in the city because
[7:50:00]
Before we get back to the bond markets, we have to get the audit done. Before we get this SEC thing done, I think we have to get the audit done.
[7:50:09]
And I think it's really important for the city to do that. And you know, it's not this not an easy time for us in many respects.
[7:50:16]
And we really are looking to you to help us. I think the city attorney would be pleased to sit with you and go through these documents and explain why they're self authenticating.
[7:50:25]
and I hope that you'll have that discussion with him because maybe there's something that he's missing about what you're looking for.
[7:50:35]
But I think he's interested in getting this done, too.
[7:50:39]
So I'll support the motion, I move the recommendation,
[7:50:44]
but I just want you to know that we're really counting on you.
[7:50:49]
And the things that we do here will set an example for cities across the United States
[7:50:54]
And I think you know the importance of that to not just us, but to the whole country.
[7:51:03]
We have a second.
[7:51:06]
For discussion.
[7:51:09]
Seconds.
[7:51:09]
Thank you.
[7:51:11]
I hope in the future when other cities call us to ask for advice on what they should do.
[7:51:17]
We charge them.
[7:51:21]
I'm actually not kidding.
[7:51:23]
You know, if we have to write a how to get through it, manual, we should charge for it.
[7:51:30]
I have some questions,
[7:51:34]
and I thank you for sharing the numbers with me, Mr. Attorney.
[7:51:41]
You, Mr. Dalberg, mentioned a few minutes ago used the phrase as you were given your report.
[7:51:47]
We're beginning to get some movement.
[7:51:50]
I heard that comment from Mr. Yul in November of last year, because I said long ago, why are we still on board with KPMG?
[7:52:00]
And I was urged to be cautious in my comments in public, not from Mr. Yul necessarily, but you know, it was kind of the air of discussion.
[7:52:09]
We need a product, so let's be thoughtful, let's be cautious.
[7:52:15]
beginning to get some movement. I heard that from Mr. Gary two weeks into December after he came into office.
[7:52:22]
And we had a couple of meetings, Ms. Farah was at one.
[7:52:26]
I hear it from you today.
[7:52:29]
So forgive me as a council member that doesn't work on this issue every single day
[7:52:33]
because we got a lot of other issues that we're working on every single day.
[7:52:37]
all of them critical. I just want to express my general sense of frustration about
[7:52:45]
beginning to get some movement. You know, if I had known at $1.5 million that we weren't
[7:52:53]
going to have an audit, I might have, what is it? The fishing term cut bait? At that point,
[7:53:01]
and said let's go elsewhere. I mean, this is not my world. I am not a CPA and I'm not an attorney.
[7:53:10]
And I agree with Mr. Peters when he talks about some of the discussion being cryptic.
[7:53:16]
Merriot of issues, complexity.
[7:53:20]
I have questions about document production.
[7:53:26]
And I want to know, within the next seven to ten days,
[7:53:31]
Where we're working together, what the work plan is, what do we still need to produce in terms of documents?
[7:53:38]
I understand the service issue, but it sounds to me like you're saying in addition to that.
[7:53:45]
Our protocol of document production, I really don't care who's responsible.
[7:53:51]
I don't care who did or didn't do it.
[7:53:53]
I, as a Council member, want to know what do we still owe the U.S. Attorney and the SEC minus the
[7:54:01]
SERS documents, because we cannot control that today, but everything else, I want to see what we as a
[7:54:07]
city have not provided, or at least in an explanation of, well, there are these documents, we don't know if they exist.
[7:54:16]
I mean, or not, this council has got to have more information.
[7:54:21]
We, in the past, I think, in past years, didn't get the pros and cons of any particular
[7:54:27]
thing from the experts that we hired are the city staff that we've had.
[7:54:32]
And now we're getting a lot of advice from lots of experts and it's conflicting.
[7:54:38]
So, you know, I've gone from one extreme to another, I feel, and this is just my perspective.
[7:54:44]
It may not be truth as other people see it, but I need to kind of see the roadmap, even if it is complex and frustrating, I need to see a roadmap with all
[7:55:00]
These people, so Vincent and Alkins, you believe, Mr. Dalberg, that we still need to have them complete their investigation.
[7:55:10]
Absolutely. And KPMG believes that too. We checked with them because we were concerned after we read the correspondence.
[7:55:15]
So we're finishing that. We're finishing all of the work with V&E because KPMG needs it to sign off, give us our audit.
[7:55:24]
Well, actually, we're doing it because it would be so incredibly expensive for someone else to start that
[7:55:28]
investigation and start from scratch that for better or for worse, whether the NES,
[7:55:34]
it's the best way to use what they've done to try and do this much as we can out of that.
[7:55:39]
Okay. So KPMG needs it. Does the SEC request it?
[7:55:44]
They're very interested in it. Yes.
[7:55:46]
They're interested in it. Okay. Now, in terms of their completion of their investigation,
[7:55:52]
it's my recollection that they were going through emails, tapes, interviews, KPMG was participating
[7:56:00]
at one point.
[7:56:01]
This is with Vinnie.
[7:56:03]
Yes.
[7:56:04]
Vinnie, my understanding is that what KPMG was, did was in the fall, I think November, something
[7:56:09]
like that.
[7:56:10]
They agreed on a number of individuals and a number of search terms to look at some hard drives
[7:56:15]
and look at emails and so there was an understanding that, okay, you definitely need to look
[7:56:19]
at these things.
[7:56:20]
Is all that still in place and true or we still follow in that plan?
[7:56:24]
We are still trying to figure that out, okay?
[7:56:26]
We've asked if you need to document that, because it seems like they have done it, but
[7:56:31]
that was part of what we were doing in Washington, you see, is KPMG is going to want to see
[7:56:35]
that in fact, everybody that they asked for emails and hard drives didn't
[7:56:40]
fact get checked, and that all the key words searches that are done through the
[7:56:45]
electronic data were actually done properly, and we're trying to run that through
[7:56:49]
the data search firm that did that as well as the B&E folks. That's part of the procedures that KPMG is very interested in.
[7:56:58]
So as part of the contract or work plan scope of work with B&E, we're still going through that process.
[7:57:08]
At one point I understood how much further they had to go and I've now sort of lost track of that.
[7:57:14]
Is the forensic auditor we have on board under the in the contract we have a forensic auditor?
[7:57:21]
No, no.
[7:57:22]
Okay.
[7:57:22]
If I could go back.
[7:57:23]
You didn't give me that amount.
[7:57:25]
If I could go backwards because it's fair to ask why these things are taking so long and what
[7:57:31]
end the interruptions.
[7:57:33]
In step 10, while going back to when we even hired KPMG in the spring of 2004, they were
[7:57:40]
casting could we do a thorough investigation.
[7:57:45]
At the time, the city attorney's office
[7:57:46]
working with V&E, said to KPMG,
[7:57:51]
look, we're doing an investigation,
[7:57:52]
even though it's a disclosure issue.
[7:57:54]
We're doing this investigation.
[7:57:56]
It'll be done in September.
[7:57:57]
Let's wait and see if that will satisfy.
[7:57:59]
It's supposed to bring someone else in to start an investigation.
[7:58:03]
That report was issued in September in October, KPMG said,
[7:58:08]
this does not cover our need.
[7:58:10]
It doesn't cover the scope of work, and that's why you were all told, well, V&E did not
[7:58:16]
fail in delivering their work.
[7:58:18]
Go back to the scope of work that was requested.
[7:58:21]
They were asked to look at disclosure documents, what brought us to the problems we had,
[7:58:25]
and to make recommendations for resolving it.
[7:58:28]
That was the work product that they delivered.
[7:58:31]
And once that was completed, it did not satisfy KPMG, KPMG to their credit, began sending
[7:58:37]
those memos, and that's the October 29th memo that Mr. Garrier was referred to.
[7:58:43]
We met with KPMG in November, and that's about the time, actually, at the mayor actually
[7:58:49]
became involved in it, because in a September, late September discussion with KPMG, they
[7:58:55]
asked that I saw these letters. I said, no, I had not. They sent me copies. Then that's
[7:59:01]
one of the flurry of letters went back and forth. We set up a meeting with them in November.
[7:59:06]
Setdown and agreed that we needed to do a more comprehensive investigation.
[7:59:12]
We brought in outside attorneys from Houston.
[7:59:15]
We brought in.
[7:59:15]
Right now, tell me who they can.
[7:59:21]
We brought in a Chicago firm, forensic auditor.
[7:59:28]
We sat down with KPMG in November, work through a work plan which became known as Work
[7:59:35]
to KPMG said this approach is much better.
[7:59:41]
We appreciate the approach.
[7:59:43]
It's much more comprehensive.
[7:59:45]
That was the plan that V&E was working on.
[7:59:48]
Then we get a new city attorney.
[7:59:50]
We started an independent investigation
[7:59:52]
and several allegations of illegal acts.
[7:59:57]
And then KPMG is saying, well, now we need more.
[8:00:00]
Investigation. So, I mean, this thing has been just going in different directions and now where we find
[8:00:06]
their selves is suggesting that we stop all over again and then start again. I'm equally frustrated.
[8:00:13]
But I have said repeatedly, you've got to just drive through this. It's been very clear with KPMG that they wanted to
[8:00:20]
thorough investigation and they wanted an audit committee that was independent
[8:00:24]
who could receive the report, draw conclusions, and to provide for you, you know,
[8:00:31]
recommendations of how to clean up certain things, remediation, sorry to use
[8:00:35]
that word again, or any other changes to the controls. So none of this has
[8:00:39]
changed. We just keep moving backwards as opposed to just driving through getting
[8:00:43]
serious. We don't have a quorum. We're going to have to stop.
[8:00:47]
So you don't want to hear my tie right, is that what you call it?
[8:00:51]
Continue.
[8:00:52]
I hate to interrupt your tie right you.
[8:00:53]
But I just had one quick thing this to see the reason.
[8:00:57]
I was speaking.
[8:00:58]
Oh, I'm sorry.
[8:00:59]
Mr.
[8:01:00]
I will continue.
[8:01:01]
I want to continue.
[8:01:02]
I want to continue.
[8:01:02]
Can you down the path that we've been traveling?
[8:01:04]
Because I think it's really important when people ask why is it taking so long
[8:01:09]
because we are interrupting and wanting to go in different directions.
[8:01:12]
and I think it's imperative that KPMG has stated what they need it and that we just
[8:01:19]
pushed to get this done. And the longer we delay it, the longer it's going to cost, the
[8:01:25]
more obstacles we throw out. I mean, KPMG is the same entity that they were in the spring
[8:01:32]
as they were before December. And I don't know what happened because our city attorney had said
[8:01:38]
we're working well together. We need to we need to get these things done.
[8:01:42]
We brought in all as as a triumphant saying yes, let's let's get the audit committee on board.
[8:01:50]
This is what's necessary and they're just discharging the duties that we've asked of them.
[8:01:55]
But if you want to cost have this cost more or if there's a city and to delay this audit,
[8:02:02]
it would be to now shut us in this approach and start all over it.
[8:02:06]
And I believe that that's in the city's best way.
[8:02:09]
I'm going through my process because I think the council members, you know, well, I'm not suggesting that at this point.
[8:02:18]
I just want to raise the question and I have other questions, but Mr. Gary, did you want to respond to that specific thing?
[8:02:24]
I just want to say this.
[8:02:27]
If we think I think Mr. Young did it yesterday, I thought quite well.
[8:02:32]
What we need to do is to learn from our mistakes in the past and the council has had to deal with very complex issues and it's understandable.
[8:02:42]
317 illegal acts is the center of the difficulty.
[8:02:47]
So what we need to do is understand 317 we need to understand the practice guide.
[8:02:51]
Mr. Dahlberg thought 317 was significant enough to send us the practice guide for 317.
[8:02:59]
That was sent to us in October.
[8:03:00]
But my point is this, what we need to do is to bring Paul make-o-in and have Paul make-o
[8:03:08]
explain to us why his investigation isn't done yet.
[8:03:12]
Because remember, he was a municipal expert.
[8:03:15]
He had all this background and experience and the reason I put all my work here, I was
[8:03:21]
on a lot of questioning and okay go ahead if and the the mayor's back so he can control the
[8:03:26]
meeting again but I understand what you're saying I my lot of questioning I want to continue
[8:03:31]
for the moment which is we have Vincent and Elkins we have the forensic auditor from Chicago
[8:03:38]
are we still are we still working with Sussman Gottfried they were brought out to Sue they were brought
[8:03:44]
into Sue KPMG that's that was that's what they that's what they told me anyway the
[8:03:50]
Your Honor, you're in charge, okay.
[8:03:52]
The lawyer told me.
[8:03:53]
All right.
[8:03:54]
Mr. Gary, finish your comment and let Mr.
[8:03:57]
You'll overset it.
[8:03:57]
Usman Godfrey, lawyer, who was a specialist in suing accounting
[8:04:00]
from the initial reaction.
[8:04:02]
If you look at the October 28th letter,
[8:04:05]
that Paul Michael wrote to KPMG
[8:04:08]
after the October 11th letter,
[8:04:11]
it was a very scathing letter.
[8:04:13]
And that's what prompted the October 29th letter
[8:04:16]
from KPMG, suggesting that we not use the in the
[8:04:20]
back in October. We then retain God's assessment, Godfrey, and a very, very excellent
[8:04:25]
plaintiff's attorney who told me over at the Westgate that what his job was was to
[8:04:30]
look at preparing a lawsuit against KPMG. And the forensic accountant was brought in
[8:04:36]
to both assist in helping to develop a possible work plan as well as to put pressure on KPMG.
[8:04:42]
Now, that was what they told me. That's what my understanding was when I first took office.
[8:04:47]
Mr. Eul?
[8:04:48]
Then the city attorney's office misled the city manager's office and all others because
[8:04:54]
it was our understanding that they were expert in accounting as attorneys and we were
[8:04:59]
looking for...
[8:05:00]
Or, some way, to move this issue forward, to establish a work plan 2, necessary to satisfy the needs of KPMG.
[8:05:09]
So we brought Sussman Gottfried, as well as Chicago partners, to help develop who are a forensic auditors, to help develop a work plan that would meet the needs of KPMG.
[8:05:22]
And, quite frankly, we sat down with KPMG as I said in November, they were satisfied that the
[8:05:28]
scope of work was comprehensive enough that they would feel much more comfortable, but
[8:05:33]
reserved the right to wait to see the findings.
[8:05:36]
That was the path we were working down in November.
[8:05:39]
And then, as I said, after the first of the year, we started bearing into a different direction
[8:05:44]
again.
[8:05:45]
But I have set through this entire sorted chain of events, so I mean, I just, but what
[8:05:54]
path did we sort down?
[8:05:55]
That's what I understand.
[8:05:57]
Okay.
[8:05:57]
Let me set second.
[8:05:58]
Do you want to respond from both of them?
[8:06:00]
If you want any further responses, you can ask them.
[8:06:02]
Thank you.
[8:06:04]
So let me ask one more question.
[8:06:07]
Okay.
[8:06:07]
I've gone through V&E, the forensic auditor, we have our contract and what we're doing with
[8:06:14]
KPMG, where 3.1 million assessment got free, what does Hawkinsdale feel due for us and which?
[8:06:23]
You're a general disclosure counsel.
[8:06:25]
And what are they doing for us right now?
[8:06:28]
They work with me and they disclose your working group to get all of the disclosure's ready,
[8:06:36]
which we have been working on for weeks and weeks and months actually, to get them ready,
[8:06:40]
And we were very close to getting the wastewater in the water done when we found out last week
[8:06:46]
when Mr. McNally came and said that based upon his conversations with Mr. Dollberg and
[8:06:52]
what he understood from KPMG that we needed to get our own independent actuary because
[8:06:56]
the Mr. McNally's judgment, the unfunded liability, could be as high as $2 billion.
[8:07:03]
We had gotten it.
[8:07:03]
We had gotten word from Darlene from the auditor's office that it was about 1.7 because
[8:07:09]
of some of the changes at KPMG had made to the way in which we were reflecting the infinite
[8:07:15]
liability that was her judgment 1.7 and we were ready to go with that number and then
[8:07:22]
this other situation occurred where we were told that the actuary was found to be using
[8:07:27]
aggressive assumptions.
[8:07:29]
Okay, here's what I would like as we move forward and I don't know how my colleagues feel,
[8:07:36]
but I, as one council member, am really frustrated not to, on a week by week basis, understand
[8:07:44]
where we are, what the plan is, and some reasonable estimate of when we can expect certain
[8:07:51]
things. So what I would like to know is will we be able, and in some timeframe, determine what
[8:07:59]
We still need from B&E, and a approximate amount of time to get there, Mr. Dalberg.
[8:08:06]
Well, I know what we need from B&E right now.
[8:08:08]
You do.
[8:08:09]
Yes.
[8:08:09]
I mean, it's been two weeks since I've been out there, and I talked to Paul this morning, Mr.
[8:08:14]
Maco, and he assures me that they've got a lot more put together than they did, and we were
[8:08:19]
there last time, and that they would be ready for us to come out and start reviewing their
[8:08:23]
stuff, and make sure that it's tied down.
[8:08:25]
We also have a fair amount of open items we're pursuing with him tying down the procedural aspects of what they did to make sure those are all pulled together as well.
[8:08:33]
Is it possible for the council members to get an idea of what that is?
[8:08:38]
I mean, just some preliminary hears what our expectation is for.
[8:08:44]
But we are in the process of putting together a letter to the meeting, which actually we started last week, and I think that there's no reason why we couldn't share that with everyone,
[8:08:52]
which is pretty much based on when I left Washington
[8:08:56]
my understanding with Mr. Maco about what they would do,
[8:08:58]
how they would set it up and what they were responsible for.
[8:09:02]
Okay, so we'll get a copy of that.
[8:09:04]
Wait, we have an issue yet, but I understand,
[8:09:06]
but you will make sure we're copied on that.
[8:09:08]
Can we get, and I'm not sure if this is from you,
[8:09:14]
or at least you can at least advise if this list is accurate,
[8:09:18]
can we get an updated list of what is outstanding that we need to provide to the SEC in the U.S.
[8:09:26]
Attorney's Office absent the service information.
[8:09:32]
I can give you a little insight based on what I know.
[8:09:34]
I don't need to further.
[8:09:35]
I'd love your insight and then to find out when we will know what's outstanding.
[8:09:41]
Okay.
[8:09:43]
I think that what you're going to get here, rather than a list of these are the documents
[8:09:46]
or these are electronic files, as you're going to get a situation of, this is the gap
[8:09:51]
in an explanation between what the original subpoena said and what the protocol said,
[8:09:57]
and for individuals that haven't been separately subpoenaed and made such a difference.
[8:10:00]
For document productions, because some people have in the city, it's going to be sort of a gap-filling thing. What really has to happen is that all the main custodians of documents for the city have to be shown the subpoena again and basically say anything you've got that falls in line with the subpoena, you need to put together and ship off over the city attorney's office, and they need to move that on out to the SEC. The only difference may be that Mr. Mako seems to believe that they're made
[8:10:29]
to be a couple of things he can sort of narrow down the subpoena and get a written understanding.
[8:10:34]
Maybe I'm Friday here because we're trying to set up a meeting with the SEC.
[8:10:37]
So the subpoena may be narrowed slightly, but the SEC will sign it in writing so we've
[8:10:41]
got a finite document and then after that production with the SEC we should be done.
[8:10:47]
Now of course the US attorney is kind of on their own way of doing things so I'm not sure
[8:10:51]
how that works.
[8:10:52]
Well you're coming about piecemeal actions and the things that we are doing are not really
[8:10:58]
be in recognized by the SCC and KPNG for remediation, for remediation, in terms of these
[8:11:07]
things that are there that we need to get done and we need to get accomplished. I'd like
[8:11:13]
us to get some type of report, whether it's verbal, well I'd like this stuff in writing
[8:11:18]
that you've promised. I'd like to get some kind of update every other week. I just feel
[8:11:24]
like we are trying to move forward, this council thinks we take an action, and then we continue
[8:11:33]
to not get there, and I understand and believe that a big part of this is that you, again,
[8:11:43]
I said it weeks ago, I'll say it again, that you have city bureaucracy that is not getting
[8:11:50]
along with each other, and that is part of the problem.
[8:11:53]
not only a city bureaucracy but a separate legal entity that is a key aspect of so much of
[8:11:58]
what's going on here. That is a very unique situation to what this situation is.
[8:12:02]
Are you talking about service? Yes. Well, we're unified and they need to give us stuff. But I mean,
[8:12:07]
we still have a problem with a green upon a plan of action to move forward on.
[8:12:16]
You know, we were in full-scale agreement that we needed to work with Mr. Turner back in February.
[8:12:20]
And now, everybody's not on the same page there, so, you know, I understand why it's taken
[8:12:27]
us longer and why it's costed more from that little perspective and problem.
[8:12:33]
But then there is the actual real things that we need to get accomplished in order to come to
[8:12:42]
some conclusion with the investigations, to have your audit committee look this over.
[8:12:49]
But, you know, to still hear that we've got a problem with document production, we just
[8:12:55]
don't understand that.
[8:12:57]
So, so there are some things I think that we need to get some kind of actual commitment that
[8:13:04]
we are going to see movement on.
[8:13:07]
And document production is going to be one of them.
[8:13:12]
And some idea, every other week, where are we in the completion of the work that the
[8:13:19]
What is your assessment of it because, frankly, you know, yet again, some things I hear
[8:13:26]
really concern me and we're continuing to spend money on it and I am fine spending money
[8:13:32]
as I said when we brought you on board, if it gives us where we need to go.
[8:13:37]
But at some point, you know, I think we have to really determine, are we getting there?
[8:13:44]
And I need you to tell, I would hope that you would tell us at some point whether we end our relationship with KPMG.
[8:13:54]
And, you know, I understand that we don't want to start a process over, but again, had I known at 1.5 million.
[8:14:02]
You know, and maybe I've got a very naive or simplistic view of this, but, you know, we need to get there.
[8:14:11]
And if they're not going to get us there, then at some point, somebody that we are paying
[8:14:16]
good money to, well earned, I know, given all of what you're having to deal with here
[8:14:22]
in this city these days, trust me, it hurts us too.
[8:14:27]
I want to know whether we should change course.
[8:14:31]
So rather than to keep trudging through the mud as we're sink and deeper and deeper, I'm
[8:14:36]
to go a little longer and see if we can get there with KPMG. But at a certain point I'm not going to be willing to do that anymore.
[8:14:45]
If I could just say something here is that I think that reports have come out of Mr. Gary's office.
[8:14:51]
We're highly valued by KPMG because they brought up a lot of good facts and they're very supported.
[8:14:57]
The V&E report actually brought up a lot of good facts.
[8:15:00]
Okay, the KPMG was very interested in. But what KPMG will tell you today, and they've told us, is they have yet to see a fully documented investigation, where they can see what documents were looked at, what electronic emails were looked at, how they were searched, and this is a kind of thing they expect to see. There are some things that have been accomplished as far as the legality of things, you know, whether it was a city attorney's analysis or who's forwards analysis, which have actually got you pretty close to where you need to be on some of the legal acts issues.
[8:15:30]
That probably need a little bit of wrap up. There's other issues though about individual involvement in certain of these things or some of the disclosure issues that are out there at the SEC's in that need to be fully documented as well
[8:15:42]
So there's a lot of things here, but and basically what we're looking at is a way to kind of pull all these together and be in these critical because until KPMG could sit down and see a thoroughly documented analysis analytical analysis and what I'm talking about is how did you go through emails?
[8:15:57]
what documents did you look at? Who's documents did you look at? When did those documents show up? What production were they part of all that kind of stuff?
[8:16:05]
So I guess what I would like is a more regular update on where we are, you're on our end.
[8:16:12]
I'm happy to support the motion today, but I really think I need to understand on a fairly regular basis, are we really getting somewhere? Is there movement?
[8:16:26]
You know, I, I, I, I, I, I missed seconds request is really quite reasonable.
[8:16:33]
I would seem to me that you are the appropriate person to do that, that basically you should
[8:16:39]
be out here.
[8:16:39]
I would like to suggest some of the seconds that we have you out here every month on the,
[8:16:44]
you know, at the same time in June and that we just do the, we just, we just keep doing
[8:16:49]
this and that, every other week, Ms. Ackens, especially for the next, you know, a few
[8:16:55]
going to be tough, but every once a month, and that's better than what we've been doing.
[8:17:01]
So, I mean, I'd recommend that as an alternative, and I'll have Mr.
[8:17:04]
Weber, if you can around schedule that for a further update briefing in June, which would
[8:17:13]
probably be the 7th of the 14th.
[8:17:19]
Absolutely no problem.
[8:17:20]
We fully believed in that and we started and to the fact that it slipped away, I think we've
[8:17:24]
spoken to the city manager a couple times about it and for whatever reason it just didn't
[8:17:29]
seem like it was going to work. But we're more than happy to do that. Well, let me just
[8:17:32]
direct my staff and I'll Steve for like a bills out in the close session of French figure out
[8:17:39]
where we're at on that. In June we'll have the same update. We'll have Mr. Dobrik here. That's great.
[8:17:48]
Okay. And lastly, in terms of all of the people that we've hired to do things for us,
[8:17:53]
If they're going to be providing information to people, just all, I would like the council
[8:18:00]
members to be copied on this stuff, you know, in trying to keep track of everyone we've
[8:18:05]
hired for whatever reason, you know, the thing that showed up in the newspaper related
[8:18:14]
to Hawkins and Dell field and would, which talks about bankruptcy, I don't understand why
[8:18:22]
this wasn't provided to the city council. Why did I have to read about it in public? And then
[8:18:27]
inquire about it. And, you know, why was it given to anyone before the council had a chance
[8:18:32]
to see it? I don't understand that. So, whether it is V&E, Crow, KPMG, Hawkins, Delfielding
[8:18:39]
Wood, Wilkie, Sussman, Godfrey, the forensic auditor. You know, I really don't like being
[8:18:46]
put in this position, because I feel like we should be able to know this stuff,
[8:18:53]
and if we
[8:18:55]
are hiring, if this council makes a decision, and this is not directed at you, this
[8:19:00]
is not something that came from Crow, but if we are in the position where we hire people
[8:19:06]
to provide us information, I think we should be given the information before it makes its
[8:19:12]
out into the world just so we know what's going on. And so I would ask that of all the experts
[8:19:18]
that we've hired recently to keep us informed, you know, we have a lot of other duties. We
[8:19:24]
don't get to do this every single day. We have other obligations and other responsibilities.
[8:19:31]
And so to read about things in the newspaper and then have to inquire, I really don't like to
[8:19:38]
to be caught off guard like that. I'd rather have as much information as possible.
[8:19:42]
You're on a could I briefly respond? I don't know who released that document. It's a document
[8:19:49]
that I never saw and so I was taken aback when the reporters were asking about the information
[8:19:55]
and to my understanding anyway, it was only released to a limited number of people.
[8:20:01]
And yet, it still found its way and breaching attorney client privilege. But it was something that the city merely asked a question about with respect to what we can publicly say without conditioning the market, because we were going through a great deal of disclosure.
[8:20:18]
And so it was related to bankruptcy. Your general disclosure counsel said, let me check with my partner beforehand, and that memo came from his partner to him.
[8:20:29]
So, how it got into the public domain, I don't know, and again, you know, I've still yet to see the memo, but my point is this.
[8:20:39]
Each of the persons that we engage in employment contracts with, they are your, you're their client.
[8:20:50]
It's not, I mean, the City Attorney's Office manages the General Disclosure contract, the Audit Committee, they work for you.
[8:20:58]
it is nothing wrong. In fact, I would strongly recommend that you have them come before you
[8:21:05]
want to regular basis and give updates, so it's not filtered. You have direct information directly
[8:21:10]
from them, and you're aware of what's going on. You are there. I mean, they are your client.
[8:21:17]
And I prefer to have as much of this information as possible in public, which is why I think
[8:21:22]
would be good. The mayor says monthly, fine. I'd like to have it be in public because I'm not
[8:21:28]
adverse to this information being shared with the public. But when the public gets it via the
[8:21:34]
newspaper before I've even had a chance to see it, that really bothers me. You know, I have been
[8:21:40]
unrecorded as supporting disclosure, public hearings. I'd prefer to have these discussions in
[8:21:49]
So the public can know what is happening, but you know, I just want the courtesy of the opportunity to see it be made aware of it as well.
[8:21:59]
Mr. Eckens, if I could just add in, you spent $4 million as a Council on Mr. Maco, just to supplement what you're saying. Why isn't it here?
[8:22:08]
I mean, come on, you talked about getting periodic reports.
[8:22:14]
You spent $4 million in Mr. Mako, and he's disappeared.
[8:22:17]
I don't know when the last time Mr. Dobogun's the last time Mr. Mako was in San Diego.
[8:22:23]
Gosh, it could have been at the end of March, because he was out doing interviews.
[8:22:26]
End of March.
[8:22:28]
I would agree. I would like to be updated by...
[8:22:31]
He's gone.
[8:22:32]
I would like to be updated by everyone.
[8:22:34]
But what I'm saying is that because is Mr.
[8:22:36]
Mako has gone he will be here on Thursday he's coming in Wednesday night and he'll be
[8:22:41]
Thursday.
[8:22:42]
But as a practical matter Mr. Mako, you've spent four million dollars to get a report.
[8:22:49]
And now there's no report.
[8:22:50]
Mr. Gary, how is that related to the quote?
[8:22:52]
I mean, I think that's a relevant issue which is why I've asked the mayor to make sure that we're going
[8:22:57]
to get an update on what all of these people are doing on a regular basis so we don't keep track of it.
[8:23:03]
But you know my my simple question was to be given the information but it is relevant what you're doing is you're going along with sliding the hand
[8:23:11]
Missack and so mean you can you can come out and you can talk about how you want the public to be made aware of
[8:23:16]
But you're not holding the system accountable. You're letting Mr. Maco charge the city four million dollars and you're not asking for him to be here
[8:23:25]
It's just that simple you can say what ask for them to be here. I ask to get a full report this council before you go ahead
[8:23:33]
and authorize another dime, you need to have Mr. Michael Cummins explain to you in detail
[8:23:39]
where is the report.
[8:23:43]
Not we're going to continue.
[8:23:45]
We're going to spend $2 million today.
[8:23:47]
You laid off the ASO people yesterday, the community service officer yesterday, at 1.8 million.
[8:23:56]
And today, the ideas we're going to spend $2 million on a law firm, how 500,000 of
[8:24:01]
which we don't even know who they are, never met them, and we're going to let Mako off the
[8:24:05]
hook for 4 million.
[8:24:06]
That's the truth.
[8:24:07]
And you can talk all around it and you can give the impression that you're really dealing
[8:24:11]
with the issues, but that's not what you're doing.
[8:24:14]
And I don't, it's very transparent to me, that's not what you're doing.
[8:24:17]
And you're not meeting your fiduciary obligation to manage the money of this city.
[8:24:22]
And it's just that...
[8:24:23]
And Mr. Gary, you are, you are directing that at me because I ask a question about a document
[8:24:30]
that was leaked by someone that you're working with and all I ask for is to be
[8:24:34]
in the future with them. Why are you because you said because you said that you were
[8:24:39]
going to go along with. Okay. Okay. We're going to stop. We have a close session. We've
[8:24:44]
heard by ready to go. I we're going to stop this discussion. We're going to go in a close
[8:24:48]
session. I would hope it would be back out here at 7 o'clock to continue this discussion,
[8:24:52]
but I've got everybody ready for a close session on meeting confer issues that's going to take
[8:24:57]
place in the next two minutes.
[8:25:02]
And Mr. Dolper will be here.
[8:25:07]
Absolutely.
[8:25:10]
Just checking.
[8:25:12]
I don't want to interrupt now.
[9:49:00]
Here comes an order brief matter. I would clerk please, call the roll.
[9:49:07]
Councilmember Peters, Deputy Mayor Zuket, Councilmember Atkins, Councilmember Young, Councilmember
[9:49:13]
Mane Chine, Councilmember Fry, Councilmember Medaffer, Councilmember Zinsa, Mayor Murphy.
[9:49:22]
Here. To my colleagues, we need to continue the close session on meeting defer to Friday
[9:49:32]
at two so that if we have poor to deal with at that time we can do it.
[9:49:38]
So I just need that motion.
[9:49:41]
Well, less as we put that motion.
[9:49:43]
So it's a public that we're doing that.
[9:49:45]
Close session continued to 2 p.m. on Friday, May, whatever it is.
[9:49:51]
13.
[9:49:53]
Okay.
[9:49:55]
And I just have a question.
[9:49:56]
Is there also going to be a close session on Monday at nine?
[9:50:01]
That was, that was my intent. So I can click with you.
[9:50:06]
Well, yeah, I did, and and and and and I'm just trying to, you know, I had people coming to speak and I don't want to keep telling them to come and then not come and.
[9:50:16]
I would help with the draft. So I'm just trying to get some sort of.
[9:50:21]
But down of my preference would be to have close session because we're going to do that.
[9:50:27]
So that's fine. I've cancelled it. I just don't want to be canceling meetings and then find out that we're meeting Friday and Monday and I didn't have to cancel a meeting that really needs to be held.
[9:50:39]
So that's all I'm...
[9:50:41]
I think we need to meet on Monday and on Friday because I think there will be matters that will not be resolved on Friday.
[9:50:50]
Okay, please vote on the motion to continue close session to meet and confer to Friday at 2 p.m.
[9:51:01]
Call the roll.
[9:51:06]
It passes 8-0.
[9:51:11]
I don't think District 2 really meant the vote on this.
[9:51:17]
Okay.
[9:51:19]
Okay, pass the 7-0 with District 2 and 8 absent for the purpose of the continuum.
[9:51:24]
Now, I was, I just called you the order.
[9:51:27]
If you need to take another 10 minute break, whatever you want.
[9:51:31]
I know.
[9:51:31]
I got it.
[9:51:32]
I have to go do something else right now.
[9:51:34]
So tell me.
[9:51:35]
Can we just go ahead and start?
[9:51:37]
You're, you're in charge.
[9:51:38]
Okay.
[9:51:39]
I'm coming back, but I can't, I got it.
[9:51:42]
Okay.
[9:51:43]
Okay, we were up to Ms. Fry actually in terms of the questions, but can I ask the attorney
[9:51:49]
a question quickly?
[9:51:51]
Mr. Zuket was here when the motion was put on the floor, and he voted on the prior item.
[9:51:56]
He had already cast his vote.
[9:51:59]
I just wanted to make sure that given that we have voted on something in an interim, I need
[9:52:06]
you to tell me what is possible, Ms. Zuket.
[9:52:11]
My opinion is that council members who catch should be here to vote on the matter because
[9:52:14]
there's going to be continued discussion on the matter and he should be a part of the
[9:52:17]
full discussion.
[9:52:18]
Thank you.
[9:52:19]
Ms. Fry.
[9:52:21]
Thank you.
[9:52:23]
It seemed like a while ago when we were doing that.
[9:52:28]
I just got a walk in the circle.
[9:52:31]
You get tired.
[9:52:33]
I've got a quick find where my notes went to, from our last mid-Jim to City through my way,
[9:52:41]
which is not going to be a good thing because then I'm going to have to think of all up against you.
[9:52:45]
But I have a feeling that we're not going to get an audit out of KPMG.
[9:52:54]
I could be wrong, but that seems to be the sense I'm getting here.
[9:52:59]
And I don't know, maybe it's the city manager who would answer this question, who actually put together the scope of work originally for Vincent and Elkins?
[9:53:07]
Are you referring to the disclosure?
[9:53:10]
No, the actual scope of work, who put together the scope of work that whatever Vincent and Elkins was supposed to do on that wonderful first report that we received?
[9:53:20]
I believe that was done with the City Attorney's Office and Vincent in Elkins.
[9:53:26]
Before the original scope of work regarding a review of disclosure practices,
[9:53:31]
I believe that was with the City Attorney's Office.
[9:53:35]
And then V&E worked supposedly, I guess, with KPMG.
[9:53:40]
In other words, at what point?
[9:53:43]
I guess I'm just trying to understand at what point did Vincent and Elkins and KPMG
[9:53:49]
kind of figure out that they weren't doing the same thing. I mean that they somehow that
[9:53:57]
Vincent and Elkins wasn't really doing the work that KPMG thought they were going to be
[9:54:02]
doing. There was seems to be kind of a big old disconnect.
[9:54:05]
Again, that my recollection and I'll defer to the city attorney's office because it was handled
[9:54:10]
and the city attorney's office, Vincent and Elkins was hired in February of 2004 some time
[9:54:18]
their bouts to do, I mean in the scope of work as the fine was to do a complete review of
[9:54:24]
our disclosure practices to go backwards and determine, you know, how we got to the point
[9:54:30]
that we were at with the current practice and then to also provide recommendations. That
[9:54:36]
was their scope of work in general. As they progressed to go through their review, we then
[9:54:45]
KPMG had stated early on that they needed a thorough investigative report to be done prior to certifying the audit.
[9:54:55]
The city took the position that we have hired KPMG to ask me off.
[9:55:00]
Welcome to do this body of work. Could we wait until they completed their work to determine if it met with your needs as an independent audit?
[9:55:10]
This is not my understanding.
[9:55:12]
Okay, I'm just giving you.
[9:55:13]
Okay, well I understand.
[9:55:15]
My understanding was, is that KPMG would be able to do their audit once Vincent and Elkins finished their report.
[9:55:22]
I mean, that was the story I got.
[9:55:24]
So I guess, and that and that the reason we had hired KPMG is because the and why we were spending so much for KPMG is because it was one company and they were just going to focus all their time on doing the audit and that they wouldn't be able to complete their audit because they just wanted to wait for for for Vincent and I'll can put out their report. I mean, that's that was the story I got and that's not my understanding of what occurred.
[9:55:52]
They did, in fact, one, I mean, they did, in fact, one, a complete and thorough investigation
[9:55:57]
of particular facts.
[9:55:59]
The city asked them to withhold, asking for additional investigations until it was determined
[9:56:06]
if whether or not the scope of work that they were engaged and would resolve some of their
[9:56:10]
concerns.
[9:56:11]
And September, after the report was submitted, it was determined that it did not meet their
[9:56:16]
needs.
[9:56:20]
And so we gave him more money to do more stuff.
[9:56:24]
No, at that point in time, we met in that's when I said that's when I spoke with KPMJ was
[9:56:29]
made aware of the letters that we're being sent back and forth.
[9:56:34]
They sent me a copy of the letter.
[9:56:36]
We then had a flurry of letters that occurred in October, agreed to meet in November and sat
[9:56:42]
down and came up with work plan 2.
[9:56:45]
In work plan 2, I mean they made it very clear that they did say that it's your choice.
[9:56:50]
city to retain V&E or to get someone else.
[9:56:55]
The city is concerned at that point in time was to go out now and hire another investigative
[9:57:00]
law firm to start from scratch with delay this even further.
[9:57:10]
And then I just got a couple of quick questions that's late so I won't go through all of this
[9:57:16]
because I didn't want to give the money to be any of the second time anyway.
[9:57:21]
I just don't want to give the money to anyone, Council Member Bride, but the city is so far
[9:57:26]
down this path that we're going to have to just drive this thing.
[9:57:30]
No, but at some point, I mean, I've had this conversation so many times, it's like I
[9:57:34]
stayed here and I'm just feeling like I'm spinning my wheels, it's like I just don't get a
[9:57:39]
report.
[9:57:40]
We don't have a due date.
[9:57:42]
At some point you say, when you hire people, you say, we expect you to have something
[9:57:49]
by a certain date, go do it and if there's stuff you're missing fine then tell us and not
[9:57:56]
to drag it out for another 68 months and so like I said I would love to be able to tell
[9:58:01]
you that we could put a timeline together that we could stick to but I don't think even
[9:58:05]
with the audit committee I don't think that they have control over that they don't have
[9:58:09]
control over somebody has an example whether or not you can you'll get waivers or
[9:58:15]
which waived from serves or not will be a major determination as the how fast they can move.
[9:58:22]
Whether or not you get both Vincent and Alcans and the City Attorney's Office to provide
[9:58:27]
the documentation that they are requiring in order to demonstrate the KPMG that the work
[9:58:33]
was done appropriately will be another issue of concern.
[9:58:36]
That's why I've said over and over again, you know, unless everyone is serious about working
[9:58:41]
to conclusion, then it is going to take longer.
[9:58:44]
But I remind you that we have had a large number of allegations raised, both internal to the organization.
[9:58:51]
I am, people have not participated appropriately to help get the bring this tool conclusion in.
[9:58:58]
But I'm not part of that problem.
[9:58:59]
I must say I was very surprised today, you know, maybe it's just because people didn't know how to do it.
[9:59:05]
But that there was, you know, when I read your report and they said there was information, I think Council Member Ackon's brought this up.
[9:59:13]
and they knew audit committee, sitting in your fourth,
[9:59:20]
there was certain documents that still hadn't been turned over.
[9:59:24]
I was assuming, serves.
[9:59:27]
I was not assuming, see.
[9:59:32]
I mean, that was, that was not a good idea.
[9:59:34]
I speak to that for a moment because I have spoken to Mr.
[9:59:37]
Delberg about this as well.
[9:59:39]
I'm going back again to the beginning of time
[9:59:42]
When the first subpoenas were issued to the city in February 2004, the city hired Vincent
[9:59:51]
and Alkins to help represent the city.
[9:59:55]
The city attorney's office and the and Vincent and Alkins met with the SEC.
[10:00:00]
Negotiated a protocol that protocol was then used the collect documents. Up until January 2005, the assumption was, if you responded to the protocol, you responded to the subpoena. It wasn't until January when we found out about the allegation of record shredding, which I again state did not occur in the manner in which it was stated.
[10:00:24]
But it was at that point in time that I actually sent the subpoena to all employees who have emails.
[10:00:32]
That was the first time they saw the subpoena, the actual subpoena.
[10:00:35]
So the question now is whether or not people fully responded to the subpoena in its written form, or were they responding to the protocol.
[10:00:43]
I think Mr. Dalberg's concern is in making sure, once in for all, because keeping in mind we've had since then, people who have alleged that they've found boxes that were seized.
[10:00:54]
and hiding. So you've had all of this confusion going on and representation that they now
[10:01:00]
have to assure with the SEC and KPMG that know those things did not occur or they did
[10:01:06]
to verify that all the records are in fact have been submitted. I think what the audit committee
[10:01:11]
is suggesting to you is to do one final purge to make sure that we don't have to redress this
[10:01:17]
question again. Because of all of those steps along the way of thinking we were being responsive
[10:01:23]
because of the protocol being synonymous with the with the subpoena followed by
[10:01:28]
allegations of seizing documents and people were holding documents there has
[10:01:33]
been a lot of confusion and misrepresentation that is created the well got us to
[10:01:38]
this point and that's what's driving the cost that's what's keeping us from getting
[10:01:42]
these audits sounds it sounds like to me Mr. Yolz at least what Mr. Delver was
[10:01:50]
saying, this is what I'm hearing saying, is that they're still looking at the procedures
[10:01:56]
that were used by Vincent and Alkins for the first report.
[10:02:01]
I mean, well, you have to a little bit because a lot of the analysis, they did, we're
[10:02:05]
documents, they got to the protocol that they did for the first report and they're basing
[10:02:11]
some of their conclusions even now on some of that stuff.
[10:02:14]
So we have to understand that as well and figure out whether or not when they were doing
[10:02:18]
in that particular analysis, because that was really
[10:02:21]
of undisclosure stuff initially.
[10:02:23]
This, the second round, was more on this legal access,
[10:02:25]
the KPMG was concerned about.
[10:02:28]
And as it relates to the disclosure issues,
[10:02:30]
if they didn't look at the emails, for let's say,
[10:02:32]
Terry Webster is an example, OK?
[10:02:34]
And that's viewed to be a relevant individual
[10:02:36]
on the disclosure issues.
[10:02:39]
That's an issue they're going to deal with.
[10:02:40]
Now, the emails are there, they're available.
[10:02:42]
But they've got to look at those things.
[10:02:44]
And they've got to apply the proper search
[10:02:45]
terms to make sure that they're getting those documents,
[10:02:47]
probably a bad example because I think her e-mails have been pretty well improved but
[10:02:51]
somebody liked that potentially. And then as far as the issue about the law
[10:02:58]
firm that you're hiring that they did, did they work for KPMG?
[10:03:02]
They have represented, they've represented KPMG, they've represented PWC, they've
[10:03:07]
represented the IACPA, I mean they are kind of experts in accounting,
[10:03:12]
types of stuff. Do we have any, do you think we have any experts in accounting or
[10:03:16]
attorneys like that they're actually living California.
[10:03:22]
There might be some somewhere, but I think that the city already is hired quite a few
[10:03:29]
attorneys that don't live in California.
[10:03:31]
I know.
[10:03:33]
The disclosure council doesn't live in California, he's got a nice office in DC, I met him
[10:03:36]
a couple of weeks ago there, and Mr. Makewood, of course, doesn't really happen.
[10:03:40]
I mean, I mean, I'm just looking costs.
[10:03:42]
you know cost when people live in New York or live in you know wherever they live just
[10:03:46]
getting them here you know costs a whole lot of additional money in their contract
[10:03:50]
um... it i don't know it's just kind of helpful to have somebody that
[10:03:54]
that actually lives in galifornia uh... that could be these uh... gentlemen are so
[10:04:00]
good at what they do mr. Turner and mr. levitt knew them and they went through a process
[10:04:05]
of looking for top flight
[10:04:07]
attorneys bat you know and these were the eyes that they actually came upon
[10:04:13]
So anyways, I know and I I appreciate you
[10:04:17]
You know you come in I'm disappointed though that you know once you can there's you know Mr. Meiko's not here none of these other people are here. I mean, it's just you
[10:04:27]
And and maybe I guess we're not allowed to talk to KPMG. I think that's what someone said we're not supposed to talk to them
[10:04:34]
Is that right? I don't know I
[10:04:37]
My understanding is that some of you have been a direct contact. Oh, well, see I haven't been I thought we were in to I thought they were supposed to
[10:04:43]
independent from you, and not talk to you or KPMG.
[10:04:47]
I want to find out exactly what all as Bologna is about them quitting or being fired, and it's just a bunch of Bologna.
[10:04:54]
I did.
[10:04:54]
I thought it was an independent audit committee.
[10:04:58]
I mean, that was my understanding.
[10:04:59]
We are.
[10:05:00]
What is your concern about what aspect of what is not independent?
[10:05:03]
No, no, I'm just saying that, and also because of not to maintain that independence while you're doing, you know, your investigation, whatever it is you're doing, but also to avoid, you know, having individual phone calls, whatever you've built us an hour, it's cheaper to bring you here in front of everybody.
[10:05:22]
So everybody hears the same thing once, and that way there's not different sets of input coming
[10:05:29]
into you from perhaps, you know, individual council members, that's all, so that you hear from
[10:05:35]
all of us at the same time.
[10:05:36]
I mean, normally the way these kind of things work is that we're not revealing to anyone particular
[10:05:41]
person who talks to us any kind of detail findings, but we're talking about is status and procedures
[10:05:46]
and where we are in the process.
[10:05:48]
Right.
[10:05:48]
We're running up a big old bill while we're doing it individually.
[10:05:51]
So that's that's why I think that that counts remember
[10:05:54]
Actions I do was much much better
[10:05:57]
Believe me there's been many times I wanted to pick up the telephone and say well, what the heck are you doing?
[10:06:03]
Or what's going on?
[10:06:04]
No, I don't do that and the reason I don't do that is because
[10:06:09]
The the dollar amount and maybe if we don't bother you while you're trying to work and you could just come report us
[10:06:16]
We'd actually save some money
[10:06:17]
The first amendment was crawled, but what is the action?
[10:06:23]
$1.5 million additional dollars, and then an additional what?
[10:06:35]
$500,000 for Wilkie Far offer.
[10:06:41]
Okay, well, just to say no, I'm not real comfortable with Wilkie Far.
[10:06:47]
I mean they're probably real good attorneys, um, that just seems like enough a lot of money.
[10:06:52]
Um, I would like to have, um, some kind of response about, you know, kind of,
[10:06:57]
see what Vincent and Elkins is going to do, um, before we, we give you some more money.
[10:07:04]
Um, and then, and then I would feel a lot more comfortable doing that.
[10:07:11]
Thank you, Mr. Armstrong.
[10:07:12]
Thank you.
[10:07:14]
I'm the deputy deputy deputy mayor or something.
[10:07:16]
I'll throw off. I fit somewhere in the chain of command. Just a couple of things. I know it's a late. I'm not going to go into extensive comments, but a couple of things.
[10:07:27]
One is you said, and I wrote it down, we made remediation as necessary along with cooperation.
[10:07:34]
Let us know what that remediation is. And so give us some specifics that would be helpful.
[10:07:41]
don't you know it's it's difficult for us to determine kind of what you what you mean. So
[10:07:46]
you know I think you've seen based on your past practice that the council wants to cooperate
[10:07:52]
once it is doing everything that's power to get through this. So please tell us you know
[10:07:57]
Ms. Atkins and I had written it down to use the term road map. But you know if you give us a road map
[10:08:02]
it will help us instead of you know expecting that we're always going to be figuring out what it is you mean.
[10:08:07]
okay no that's absolutely no problem thank you and it wasn't until very recently
[10:08:15]
that this council learned that it was possible that the SEC felt like the city had not been
[10:08:21]
cooperating we just learned this I think like to yeah it was very recently and so let us
[10:08:30]
know immediately when there is an issue like this and also let us know who it is that either isn't
[10:08:36]
cooperating with the SEC what department it is. That's not cooperating with the SEC or the
[10:08:41]
US attorney. Whoever that is, let us know so we can take whatever actions that this
[10:08:47]
council is empowered to take. Okay, and then I noticed too, I'm a letter you wrote, I
[10:08:51]
thought it was very good. I'm your letter dated May 6. If there's anything in here that
[10:08:57]
somebody's not cooperating with you, you've asked for something and they won't turn
[10:09:01]
it over. They won't give you information. Also, let I mean, that needs to be made
[10:09:05]
public so that we is once again this council can bring whatever power we have over that individual
[10:09:13]
or organization whatever it is to make sure that you and then through you the SEC and the
[10:09:20]
attorney are getting what what they need.
[10:09:23]
Those will be part of the updates, may.
[10:09:24]
Okay.
[10:09:29]
Okay.
[10:09:30]
I will, you know, I think we're, you know, we're, this is, this is something that we're
[10:09:37]
along this path.
[10:09:38]
We have entrusted you, you and, and Mr. Levitt and Mr. Turner with, you know, great
[10:09:48]
responsibilities and have felt and everybody, once again, as much as was made of it at
[10:09:55]
the time, the mayor, the city manager, and the city attorney, I'll agree that you guys
[10:10:00]
For the best people to help this city get through this. So this is your advice and your proposal to us today. I think so I'm going to support it to show you and others that at least speaking for myself that I'm going to support this. I want to see us get through this. So I'm going to support you today, but I want to urge you significantly to help us get through this situation, get this done. This is the most critical set of issues facing us.
[10:10:30]
this city. Thank you. You're on the city attorney would like to comment and then it's back
[10:10:37]
over to you. Thank you, Council Member Atkins. One final comment before the Council votes on this
[10:10:43]
matter. On behalf of the city attorney's office, the city attorney's urge due to continue this
[10:10:49]
matter. He spoke to you earlier in detail expressing his concerns about in particular the two items
[10:10:57]
approving the First Amendment and approving the agreement for legal counsel for the audit committee.
[10:11:02]
He believes firmly that there are serious issues there that need to be addressed and that we ought to give this matter the appropriate
[10:11:09]
week to 10 days for our office to work with the audit committee to give you better scope on these issues before you vote on it.
[10:11:16]
And I wanted to urge you one last time to consider his recommendation before you vote.
[10:11:20]
Thank you.
[10:11:21]
Your honor?
[10:11:24]
I want you to continue to run the meeting because I've just walked in.
[10:11:28]
I think Mr. Delberg did you have anything you want to add?
[10:11:31]
No.
[10:11:32]
At this time.
[10:11:33]
Okay.
[10:11:33]
Thank you.
[10:11:35]
I would ask for the Council to vote.
[10:11:41]
Call the roll.
[10:11:43]
It passes five two with district four and six voting no in districts two and eight absent.
[10:11:51]
And we have one adjournment in memory.
[10:11:55]
I have two, Mr. Young and then Mr. Maintain.
[10:12:00]
Thank you.
[10:12:00]
I know that you continue to run me.
[10:12:03]
You did such a good job with on me.
[10:12:05]
It is with great sorrow that I request this meeting
[10:12:07]
to be adjourned in memory of Avis Johnson.
[10:12:10]
Avis Johnson passed away on April 9, 2005 at the age of 88.
[10:12:17]
Avis was elected to eight terms as a member of the California Senior Legislator of Legislature.
[10:12:25]
She was the first African-American elected as Senior Senior Senator of the California Senior Legislature.
[10:12:34]
She authored legislation that established a million dollar fund for Senior Citizens to purchase
[10:12:40]
dentures, eyeglasses, and here in aid.
[10:12:44]
Avis was active and effective on several senior organizations, including the Fourth District
[10:12:50]
Senior Commission, the Council for Minority Aging, Legislative Chair of AARP, President
[10:12:59]
of Gateway, United Senior Services, and Ladies and Bold and Vital Experiences Live.
[10:13:06]
Life has been rewarding as a phrase that Avis Johnson had used consistently or constantly.
[10:13:14]
She provided a sterling example of what one determined proud purpose-driven woman can
[10:13:20]
do for all citizens of San Diego and the nation.
[10:13:24]
Avis Johnson was a woman of God, mother, grandmother, mentor, or a tour, political and
[10:13:31]
the activists. She will be greatly missed and will remain in our hearts forever.
[10:13:37]
Mr. Mayson. Thank you and I would ask that the Council had
[10:13:40]
adjourned today's meeting in memory of Alice Horn. Alice died peacefully at her home
[10:13:45]
on March 28th, 2005. She was born in San Diego in 1925 grew up as a farm girl in Imperial Valley
[10:13:53]
where she graduated from El Central High School. Alice moved to the San Fernando Valley
[10:13:58]
where she worked first as a legal secretary and then as a marketing and program director for
[10:14:03]
Joy Manufacturing Company. While working for Joy Manufacturing, Alice met her beloved husband
[10:14:09]
Andre with whom she shared the last 28 years of her life. Alice and Andre moved to Pennsylvania
[10:14:14]
for a time before settling back in Rancho Bernardo. After a courageous recovery following
[10:14:19]
a cerebral hemorrhage, Alice enjoyed traveling to visit family and friends, taking hay rides,
[10:14:24]
playing golf in last year, dancing at her granddaughter's wedding. Alice is survived by her
[10:14:29]
devoted husband, Andre Horn, her son Frank, her daughter Barbara, and three grandchildren.
[10:14:35]
Her and Andre are wonderful members of the Ranchburnardo community have contributed much over the
[10:14:41]
years. Alice was a good friend of mine as his, as his, Andre just great people, and Alice will be
[10:14:54]
Mr. Maintain, this Council stands adjourned.