This meeting has a video, but ChampDS only streams it inside its own player, so we can't play it here. Watch it on ChampDS's page for this meeting.
Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
[0:12]
Excellent.
[0:13]
All right, good evening and welcome to the
regular meeting of the Cortland Hudson
[0:16]
Board of Trustees. I'm Mayor Brian Pugh.
Please join me in the Pledge of
[0:19]
Please join me in the Pledge of
Allegiance.
[0:19]
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the
United States of
[0:25]
America. And to the Republic for which it
stands,
[0:29]
one nation under God, indivisible,
[0:33]
with liberty and justice for all.
[0:36]
All right, now we proceed
[0:40]
to our approval of
[0:43]
vouchers.
[0:45]
General fund, $394,132.30.
[0:52]
Water fund, $357,979.80.
[0:57]
Sewer fund, $25,038.16.
[1:02]
Capital fund, $145,837.38.
[1:08]
And the trust fund, $11,750. Do I have a
motion? So moved.
[1:13]
Second.
[1:14]
Motion by Trustee Simon, second by Trustee
Nicholson. All in favor?
[1:18]
Aye.
[1:18]
Okay, very good. Now we proceed to our
feature presentation,
[1:24]
a presentation of certificates of
recognition from the New York Conference
[1:32]
of Mayors to John Spada in recognition of
25 years of service and to John
[1:39]
Nikitopoulos in recognition of 40 years of
service. Oh yeah, there he is.
[1:47]
All right, now I would like to invite the
board to come Come join me in
[1:54]
presenting the— So again,
[1:56]
the first one is for John from our Water
Department.
[2:01]
He is continuing a family tradition of
service to our village.
[2:08]
So I want to, on behalf of the board,
[2:11]
extend our deep thanks to him for his
service and look forward to years of
[2:19]
continued work for our village. Thank you,
John.
[2:24]
Thank you.
[2:31]
And Chief Nikitopoulos, a true lifetime
dedicated to our village.
[2:39]
Thank you. Down here, and we'll just have
everyone stand over here.
[2:47]
Yeah, members of the family, come on down
if you want to stand up.
[2:51]
Join members of the board.
[3:11]
Yeah, right. Ready, everyone? Perfect.
Okay.
[3:18]
All right, and for the folks that were
here for
[3:25]
that presentation, you want to stay,
[3:30]
you're welcome to stay.
[3:34]
You want to take this opportunity to
leave,
[3:40]
please do so. Okay, great. Great.
[3:45]
Okay, now we have 3 public hearings of the
evening.
[3:53]
The first will be on Local Law Number 10
of, uh,
[4:00]
Draft Local Law Number 10 of 2026 to amend
Chapter
[4:08]
230, Zoning, of the Village Code to update
[4:14]
provisions related to domestic animals and
farm
[4:21]
animals. Do I have a motion?
[4:25]
So moved.
[4:27]
So moved.
[4:27]
Second.
[4:28]
Motion by Trustee Simon, second by Trustee
Nicholson. Discussion?
[4:32]
Yes, Mayor, if I could, I just wanted to
make a couple of quick comments.
[4:38]
I want to say first and foremost that the
Village Board of Trustees has worked hard
[4:43]
on Local Law Introductory Number 10,
[4:46]
the purpose of which is to amend our
zoning provisions on domestic animals and
[4:52]
zoning provisions on domestic animals and
farm
[4:52]
animals. If anyone had told us one year
ago that in 2026 we would be spending
[4:57]
substantial amount of time on this topic,
we would likely not have believed them.
[5:03]
But things change, and events cause that
change to occur.
[5:07]
So a number of developments in the village
made it clear that our existing zoning
[5:13]
provisions regarding animals and fowl were
insufficient.
[5:17]
With the help of our manager, our village
attorney, our planner and engineer,
[5:22]
this Board of Trustees has made a sincere
effort to craft legislative language to
[5:28]
address the inadequacies of our existing
code. Is it perfect? Of course not.
[5:34]
Are we finished? Also, of course not.
[5:36]
The great congressional giant John
Dingell, 59 years and 21 days in the U.S.
[5:42]
House of Representatives would regularly
say, often when I was in the room, quote,
[5:47]
nothing is agreed to until everything is
agreed to, so you guys need to go to work.
[5:53]
That was good advice when it was told to
us by Chairman Dingell,
[5:58]
and it's good advice today.
[6:00]
As we've seen in recent weeks,
[6:02]
there is a significant divide within the
community on a number of issues related to
[6:08]
the current draft of Local Law
Introductory Number 10.
[6:12]
The job of the Board of Trustees in the
weeks ahead is to continue to work hard on
[6:18]
this bill, but to do so in a way that
bridges that divide.
[6:22]
That's hard work, and it must be done
seriously and without distractions that
[6:27]
seriously and without distractions that
would
[6:27]
tend to divert this board from its main
mission of finishing its work in an able
[6:33]
manner. Some have said that as we go
forward with our work,
[6:37]
That I should recuse myself from further
involvement in the drafting of Local Law
[6:43]
Introductory Number 10.
[6:45]
They say I should do so because I live
next door to a family that now lives next
[6:50]
door to a flock of racing pigeons. I
appreciate suggestions that I recuse
[6:56]
appreciate suggestions that I recuse
myself.
[6:56]
In fact, before a single letter was ever
written or any other communication on that
[7:02]
issue, I raised that question myself back
in May when we first began considering
[7:08]
these issues. I was told then by our
village attorney, Mr.
[7:12]
Subban at the time, that it was not
necessary for me to do so.
[7:16]
However, I did subsequently recuse myself
from a zoning board advice of counsel
[7:22]
session, again relying on our village
attorney who felt it was appropriate in
[7:27]
attorney who felt it was appropriate in
that
[7:28]
instance since the zoning board was
dealing with a specific interpretation of
[7:33]
dealing with a specific interpretation of
the
[7:33]
zoning code impacting 2 homes.
[7:36]
I was grateful for his guidance and, of
course, did so recuse myself.
[7:40]
Soon after this hearing date was
established and we received specific
[7:45]
established and we received specific
questions on
[7:46]
recusal, I have been guided by our very
capable village attorney to my right, Ms.
[7:52]
Dixon. She advised me that anytime I feel
I cannot be objective as we go forward,
[7:58]
I should recuse myself.
[7:59]
Today, I feel as objective as I've always
been on the issues surrounding Local Law
[8:05]
Introductory Number 10.
[8:07]
My goal in this and other legislative
endeavors on the part of our board is to
[8:12]
endeavors on the part of our board is to
get
[8:13]
to where House Speaker Tip O'Neill always
advised us to be, quote,
[8:17]
the most good for the most people. In
other words, I'm trying to be helpful
[8:23]
other words, I'm trying to be helpful
here.
[8:23]
When I see a problem or one is presented
to me,
[8:26]
I don't measure the distance of that
problem from my house.
[8:31]
I just try to find a solution.
[8:33]
That's how I approached all of our work
here in Croton since I joined the board.
[8:38]
And this is not a unique trait of mine. I
believe all of my colleagues do the same.
[8:44]
That's what this job is all about.
[8:47]
I never want to look at a neighbor who
feels distressed by a village law or
[8:52]
feels distressed by a village law or
problem
[8:52]
or even a legislative draft and say,
sorry, I can't help you.
[8:57]
You live too close to me.
[8:59]
On the other hand, as I said a moment ago,
[9:02]
this work is too important to be put at
risk by any distractions.
[9:06]
And most importantly,
[9:08]
I have great faith in the talent and
abilities of my 4 colleagues,
[9:12]
assisted by the manager, by our planner,
by our engineer, and our attorney,
[9:18]
to devise a final version of Local Law
Introductory Number 10 that meets Speaker
[9:23]
O'Neill's standard. Quote, the most good
for the most people.
[9:28]
And I believe they share my view that our
obligation is to solve the problem and
[9:33]
that doing nothing in this instance is not
a good option for Croton.
[9:38]
So to remove any potential distractions as
this board goes forward,
[9:43]
I will recuse myself from any further
involvement with Local Law Introductory
[9:49]
involvement with Local Law Introductory
Number
[9:49]
10. I wish you all the best as this
hearing and any subsequent action on this
[9:54]
measure proceeds. I thank everyone for
coming out tonight and sharing your
[10:00]
coming out tonight and sharing your
thoughts
[10:00]
with the board. And now, until this
specific hearing is concluded,
[10:05]
I will relinquish my seat on this board
and happily join the people. Thank you.
[10:11]
Thank you. And before we proceed to the
public hearing, uh, Manager,
[10:15]
do you have any background information
you'd like to present? For sure.
[10:21]
How far back do you want me to start?
[10:23]
Anything that you think is relevant.
[10:25]
No, thank you, Mayor.
[10:27]
Um, so, um, as Trustee Simon kind of gave
a brief synopsis on the law,
[10:32]
I'll just say that, um, you know,
[10:34]
the board has had numerous discussions on
this law.
[10:37]
Um, much of the information is included in
the backup Uh,
[10:41]
documentation that is available on the
village website as part of the agenda.
[10:47]
Um, for those who are interested,
[10:49]
we have received comments from our
Waterfront Advisory Committee,
[10:54]
we have received comments from our Village
Planning Board,
[10:58]
we have received comments from the
Westchester County Planning Board.
[11:02]
All that information is available on the
village website.
[11:06]
Um, you know, this is just, as was said, a
public hearing.
[11:10]
Um, you know, the board Can, after they've
heard comments from the public,
[11:16]
can choose to close the public hearing or
leave it open.
[11:19]
There's no requirement that it be voted on
this evening.
[11:23]
You know, if the board wants to take the
feedback that it's received both through
[11:29]
email and through the public commentary to
come and go back to a work session,
[11:34]
get further guidance from our attorney,
[11:37]
those are all options that you have
available. You know, to do so.
[11:42]
You know, I think that is—
[11:44]
Manager, thank you. I, I just want to make
sure I understood.
[11:49]
So Deputy Mayor Simon has recused himself
from—
[11:54]
Yes, correct.
[11:56]
Going forward from considering the law and
any revisions from that will come from
[12:02]
your hearing.
[12:04]
Okay.
[12:05]
Thank you. And I just want to say that I'm
grateful for all the residents who came
[12:11]
out tonight. I'm sure you're here for
various reasons,
[12:15]
but I'm grateful that you're all here.
[12:18]
And I'm grateful for the people who
submitted letters concerning Local Law 10,
[12:24]
the proposed law, that is, including ways
that it can be more clear.
[12:29]
I really respect the amount of engagement
the community has shown around this law,
[12:36]
and it will only help us strengthen it and
make it better. So thank you.
[12:41]
Well said. And out of respect for that
engagement and those contributions,
[12:47]
we will not be voting on this law tonight.
[12:50]
We will be taking it back for a work
session for further review to be informed
[12:55]
session for further review to be informed
by
[12:56]
the comments from our respective, you
know, formal referral bodies,
[13:00]
but also from what we hear tonight and
over the preceding and coming days via
[13:06]
over the preceding and coming days via
email.
[13:06]
Okay. All in favor? Aye. All right, the
floor is open.
[13:10]
Everyone has— please state your name,
address. You have up to 5 minutes to
[13:16]
address. You have up to 5 minutes to
speak.
[13:16]
And just to clarify, this is the public
hearing for the law. So the—
[13:22]
Yeah.
[13:22]
Yes.
[13:22]
There will be 3 public— well, 2 more
public hearings,
[13:25]
then public comment on agenda items,
[13:27]
then public comment on non-agenda items
towards the end of the meeting.
[13:31]
So don't start that clock.
[13:33]
Okay.
[13:33]
Debbie Braddock, 23 Young Avenue.
[13:36]
Um, to me, this became quite confusing
about someone having, um,
[13:42]
I believe it was pigeons,
[13:44]
and my husband's father had homing pigeons
for years and lived in Croton.
[13:51]
It wasn't a problem, you know, it just—
[13:55]
life happens.
[13:55]
I personally feel that it would be
detrimental not to have that,
[14:01]
not to continue that legacy for someone
else,
[14:04]
and to be concerned about people who might
want to have chickens.
[14:10]
Because if we say birds, we could then
move to chickens.
[14:13]
Are we going to say a specific number?
[14:16]
I think we need to gracefully meet again
and discuss what this is going to do to
[14:21]
someone who bought a house and has a hobby
and wants—
[14:25]
and I do not know this person, but I want
them to have every opportunity we had.
[14:30]
Thank you.
[14:31]
Thank you.
[14:32]
Thank you.
[14:45]
Uh, thank you to the mayor, trustees,
[14:47]
and manager for considering protecting our
neighbors and village by banning pigeons
[14:51]
without grandfathering,
[14:53]
as many municipalities have done in the
face of residential flock operations.
[14:57]
The facts and documented impact show the
greater good this ban would bring to our
[15:01]
community and the village-wide risks of
not taking swift action.
[15:04]
I'm among 7 of the 8 closest households on
the same block as the pigeon operation at
[15:09]
148 Old Post Road North And that's
excluding the member of the Board of
[15:13]
excluding the member of the Board of
Trustees,
[15:13]
uh, who have expressed support urging an
immediate pigeon ban with no
[15:17]
grandfathering. I'm uniquely able to
provide details of our lived experiences
[15:21]
provide details of our lived experiences
of the
[15:22]
havoc caused by this flock on our property
and our quality of life.
[15:25]
This board has reviewed some of the visual
evidence shared by our neighborhood,
[15:29]
like the examples of pigeons on the board
over here that perch for upwards of a
[15:34]
couple hours on our roofs, gutters, garden
beds, and other outdoor spaces.
[15:38]
It is unreasonable to allow dozens of kept
pigeons, or any neighbor's animal,
[15:42]
to occupy other people's properties.
[15:44]
They cohabitate on neighbors' properties,
causing health, safety, quality of life,
[15:48]
and financial impacts, which include
defecation on our houses, cars, lawns,
[15:52]
driveways, patios, and furniture. A
predator killed bird that fell on our
[15:56]
predator killed bird that fell on our
property.
[15:57]
Noise disturbances from the large flock
routinely wake us up at 4 AM.
[16:00]
Very low flight path that first runs
directly over our property at peak outdoor
[16:05]
times, with pigeons shedding debris,
feathers, particles, and poop overhead.
[16:09]
A diminished ability to use our outdoor
spaces due to the mess and constant
[16:13]
spaces due to the mess and constant
repeated
[16:13]
flights. Village officials have been told
that the majority of the pigeons in the
[16:18]
condo are young. It takes just 20 days for
eggs to hatch and about another month for
[16:22]
pigeons to become fully grown. By 6
months, they begin reproducing.
[16:26]
As shown here on the board, in low-end
controlled breeding,
[16:29]
a flock of 24 pigeons can easily multiply
to 120 in just 1 year,
[16:32]
according to the NIH and other reports.
[16:34]
It's easy to see how quickly this becomes
impossible to manage and regulate and how
[16:39]
the nuisance exponentially grows.
[16:41]
A flock of pigeons, 24 pigeons poop about
1,000 times a day.
[16:44]
On the low end, that's 50 to 75 times an
hour as they fly overhead or remain
[16:48]
hour as they fly overhead or remain
perched
[16:48]
on neighboring homes and properties.
[16:50]
Their droppings are corrosive and cause
damage to homes and cars.
[16:54]
A flock of 100 pigeons produces 4,800
pounds of poop per year.
[16:57]
More exposure and higher quantities means
higher risk of infectious diseases and a
[17:02]
greater nuisance to neighbors.
[17:03]
Free from these impacts is the flock
operator who does not live in that home,
[17:07]
yet constructed this massive pigeon condo
along his elderly neighbor's property line
[17:12]
backing up to their vegetable garden.
[17:14]
Well-established property line trees have
also been removed or disturbed,
[17:18]
increasing flight lines and sight lines.
[17:20]
It's not feasible for the village to
regulate or accurately count this pigeon
[17:24]
operation, which can be swiftly relocated
or released like has occurred over this
[17:29]
past week. This board is also aware of
instances of code and rule circumvention
[17:33]
instances of code and rule circumvention
at
[17:33]
148, which leaves future compliance in
doubt.
[17:35]
There is not enough space or distance from
neighbors for this type of operation,
[17:40]
and there's no realistic way to prevent
these animals from congregating on and
[17:44]
damaging neighboring properties. Our block
is not unique in Croton.
[17:47]
Much of our village is comprised of small
lots and closely built homes.
[17:51]
Everyone should be able to enjoy their own
homes without worrying that neighbors'
[17:56]
animals will be treating their houses or
lawns like toilets.
[17:59]
There— these are some of the same reasons
why other municipalities in Westchester,
[18:03]
The City of Chicago and beyond do not
permit pigeons in residential areas.
[18:07]
This board is aware of the range of
binding state and federal case law that,
[18:11]
for good reason, supports an immediate
municipal ban with no grandfathering.
[18:15]
A wide sampling of verified residents in
neighborhoods across the village agree
[18:20]
neighborhoods across the village agree
that
[18:20]
Croton should not become a beacon for
pigeon flock operations.
[18:23]
They cite already budding ecological
concerns about the pigeons found or
[18:27]
photographed this summer around the
village.
[18:30]
Pigeons are large, non-migratory,
[18:31]
and do not behave as our native songbirds
or backyard chickens do.
[18:35]
Homing pigeons attract more invasive wild
pigeons and doves,
[18:38]
which they're known to mate with, to our
neighborhood,
[18:41]
pushing out songbirds that we've enjoyed
over the years.
[18:44]
As a resident biologist recently shared
with the board,
[18:47]
there is a real concern that wider
biodiversity in Croton's neighborhoods and
[18:51]
biodiversity in Croton's neighborhoods and
parks
[18:51]
could continue to dwindle as the pigeon
population grows and crowds out other
[18:56]
species. Beyond that, pigeons attract
rats, other pests,
[18:59]
and predators to neighborhoods.
[19:00]
They pose health risks, especially to
those who are immunocompromised,
[19:04]
to senior citizens, and to children,
including histoplasmosis, cryptococcosis,
[19:08]
psittacosis, salmonellosis, and bird
mites.
[19:11]
Dogs and cats are particularly susceptible
to cryptococcosis,
[19:14]
a fungus that is found in bird droppings,
notably in pigeons.
[19:17]
These are the primary reasons I am not
alone in urging you to act tonight on the
[19:21]
board's previously stated consensus intent
to adopt a pigeon ban without
[19:25]
grandfathering to protect neighbors, pets,
properties and our environment.
[19:29]
Thank you.
[19:30]
Thank you. Thank you.
[19:31]
Hi, good evening. Can everyone hear me?
[19:38]
Yes.
[19:39]
Um, good evening, members of the board,
Mayor Pugh.
[19:43]
My name is Erica Loudon Corwin,
[19:45]
and I live at the dead end of Penfield
Avenue in the house where I grew up.
[19:51]
I'm speaking tonight because I,
[19:54]
I have some concerns and questions
regarding the establishment of Erasing
[19:59]
regarding the establishment of Erasing
pigeon
[20:00]
loft on Old Post Road. I'd like to just
point out that pigeons are not fowl.
[20:06]
By the way, what is the definition of
fowl? No, not all birds are considered
[20:12]
fowl? No, not all birds are considered
fowl.
[20:12]
While bird applies to any feathered,
warm-blooded vertebrate,
[20:17]
the entire scientific class Avis,
[20:20]
fowl is a much narrower term used in both
biology and the law.
[20:24]
In simple terms, all fowl are birds, but
not all birds are fowl.
[20:29]
Biologically, the term fowl refers almost
exclusively to 2 specific orders of birds:
[20:36]
Galliformes, landfowl, heavy-bodied
ground-feeding birds such as chickens,
[20:42]
ground-feeding birds such as chickens,
turkeys,
[20:42]
pheasants, quails, grouse, and peacocks.
[20:46]
And Seraforms, waterfowl, like swimming
birds such as ducks, geese, and swans.
[20:52]
Because pigeons are often not defined as
fowl in standard municipal dictionaries,
[20:58]
towns often regulate them under general
public nuisance ordinances like noise,
[21:04]
public nuisance ordinances like noise,
odor,
[21:05]
property damage, acid waste, livestock or
animal limits,
[21:09]
Or specific building codes for outdoor
structures and lofts rather than just bird
[21:15]
laws alone. While pigeon racing may have a
rich tradition,
[21:20]
it belongs really on expansive
agricultural land or designated urban
[21:25]
agricultural land or designated urban
rooftop
[21:26]
facilities. I don't think—
[21:28]
I think we all know it doesn't belong
jammed into single-family suburban
[21:33]
neighborhoods where the footprint directly
impacts adjacent homeowners.
[21:39]
Often pigeon racing enthusiasts view their
birds as highly trained athletes and
[21:45]
become completely blind to the reality of
the nuisance they create.
[21:50]
The hobby has deep roots in dense urban
environments like rooftop coops in the
[21:57]
environments like rooftop coops in the
Bronx
[21:57]
or Manhattan, or expansive rural areas
like upstate New York,
[22:02]
but it translates terribly to small lot
suburban neighborhoods.
[22:07]
I also have some questions that I think
would be helpful.
[22:11]
Why did this homeowner specifically choose
a house that wouldn't be a good fit for
[22:18]
racing pigeons? Why did this homeowner
target Croton?
[22:22]
Why should other residents have to allow
his racing pigeons to disrupt and
[22:28]
his racing pigeons to disrupt and
vandalize
[22:28]
their property with dropping and corrosive
pigeon poop?
[22:33]
What does he have to prevent reproduction?
Is he eating the eggs?
[22:38]
Is he selling the eggs? Does he pay taxes
on betting when he's racing the pigeons?
[22:44]
How are the pigeons tagged?
[22:46]
How does a pigeon qualify to receive a
band on their leg?
[22:51]
I just think those are some questions that
would be helpful to know.
[22:56]
Thank you so much.
[22:57]
Thank you.
[22:58]
Hi, good evening. My name is Nicole
Shapiro.
[23:01]
Um, my husband and I live diagonally
across the street from Tony,
[23:05]
and therefore we have a pretty good
perspective on whether Tony's pigeons are
[23:09]
creating a problem for the neighborhood.
They are not.
[23:12]
With Tony's permission, we looked at the
coop ourselves.
[23:16]
The coop is clean and well-maintained.
[23:18]
It is set well back from the neighboring
property lines and is a substantial
[23:22]
distance from other houses. The birds were
quietly cooing.
[23:26]
There was no offensive smell.
[23:27]
We saw no rats, no droppings outside the
coop,
[23:30]
nothing that struck us struck us as dirty
or unsanitary.
[23:33]
What we saw bore very little resemblance
to the picture painted by many of the
[23:38]
allegations being used to justify a ban.
These are not feral street pigeons.
[23:43]
They're tagged racing pigeons.
[23:44]
They're individually identifiable,
[23:46]
domesticated birds that are bred and
trained to return to their home loft.
[23:51]
Our understanding is also that Tony has
had the birds vaccinated.
[23:54]
In other words, this is a managed flock of
birds being cared for by an owner.
[23:59]
Where's the evidence that Tony's pigeons
have caused a rat problem?
[24:03]
Where's the evidence that anyone has
incurred pest control expenses because of
[24:08]
incurred pest control expenses because of
these
[24:08]
birds? Where's the evidence of a fire
hazard?
[24:10]
Has anyone contracted any illness
associated with the pigeons?
[24:14]
Has testing revealed dangerous airborne
pathogens?
[24:17]
Is there evidence of damage to neighboring
property from these particular birds?
[24:22]
We are not aware of any such evidence.
[24:24]
There's obviously a difference between
something that theoretically could happen
[24:29]
something that theoretically could happen
and
[24:29]
something that is actually happening.
[24:31]
We don't think Croton should prohibit an
activity throughout the entire village
[24:36]
based primarily on hypothetical and
generally unwarranted concerns.
[24:40]
If the concern is that improperly stored
pigeon food might attract rodents,
[24:44]
require pigeon food to be stored in
sealed, rodent-resistant containers.
[24:48]
If a coop becomes unsanitary, require the
owner to clean it.
[24:52]
If there's an offensive odor, regulate it.
[24:54]
If the village believes coops should be a
dis— a certain distance from property,
[24:59]
from property lines or neighboring homes
establish a reasonable setback.
[25:03]
These are sensible regulations.
[25:05]
What we do not understand is why the
solution needs to be a complete ban.
[25:09]
There's also the issue of fundamental
fairness to Tony.
[25:13]
Our understanding is that Tony
specifically checked with the village
[25:17]
specifically checked with the village
before
[25:17]
purchasing his house to make sure he would
be able to keep his pigeons.
[25:21]
He subsequently constructed the coop with
the village approval.
[25:25]
and its compliance with applicable
building requirements.
[25:28]
He relied on what he was told and spent
money building to, uh, to build the coop.
[25:33]
It's difficult to see how it is fair for
the village to tell a resident that
[25:37]
something is permitted,
[25:39]
allow him to rely on the representation
and make an investment,
[25:42]
and then change the law after the fact
specifically to prohibit what he was told
[25:47]
specifically to prohibit what he was told
he
[25:47]
could do. There are potentially serious
legal issues associated with this as well.
[25:52]
Given that Tony was already keeping the
birds, consulted with the village,
[25:56]
and constructed his coop with village
approval,
[25:59]
it seems obvious that an attempt to force
him to eliminate the existing use could
[26:04]
result in litigation.
[26:05]
That means Croton taxpayers could end up
paying for attorneys to defend a lawsuit
[26:10]
over a clean pigeon coop that could have
been avoided by simply adopting reasonable
[26:15]
regulations or grandfathering an existing
use.
[26:18]
There's a straightforward compromise
available here.
[26:21]
If the village believes pigeon keeping
needs additional regulation,
[26:25]
establish reasonable limits on the number
of birds, establish setbacks,
[26:29]
require the birds to be properly housed,
[26:31]
require feed to be kept in
rodent-resistant containers,
[26:34]
require the coop to be maintained in a
clean and sanitary condition,
[26:38]
address unreasonable odor or noise.
[26:40]
The village could even require the pigeons
to be banded or otherwise identifiable.
[26:45]
if it believes that the— that that would
be useful,
[26:48]
then enforce those rules when someone
actually violates them.
[26:52]
That approach would address virtually
every legitimate concern that has been
[26:56]
every legitimate concern that has been
raised
[26:57]
without prohibiting responsible pigeon
keeping.
[26:59]
If the board ultimately decides that it
does not want new pigeon coops in Croton,
[27:04]
we believe Tony's existing coop and flock
should unquestionably be grandfathered.
[27:09]
We respectfully ask the board not to enact
a blanket prohibition on keeping pigeons.
[27:14]
If reasonable regulations are needed,
adopt them.
[27:17]
If an actual nuisance develops, address
it.
[27:19]
But please do not impose a village-wide
ban based on problems that,
[27:23]
as far as we can see, have not actually
occurred.
[27:26]
And if the board nevertheless decides to
prohibit new pigeon keeping,
[27:30]
at an absolute minimum,
[27:31]
Tony's existing village-approved coop and
flock should be grandfathered. Thank you.
[27:36]
Thank you.
[27:44]
Hi, my name is Andrea Fury. I live at 14
Morningside.
[27:48]
I don't have that much to add to what
Nicole just said. She was so thorough.
[27:54]
But I would like to bring up one aspect of
this whole story that we haven't really
[28:00]
talked about, and that is the importance
of pets in people's lives today.
[28:05]
My daughter is working at the VA hospital
in Washington, D.C.
[28:09]
as a clinical psychologist.
[28:11]
And she told me just a couple of nights
ago that one of the biggest issues that
[28:17]
ago that one of the biggest issues that
they
[28:17]
are facing is that for a lot of these
veterans,
[28:21]
their closest companion is their pet. It's
their animal.
[28:25]
In this case, as has been ascertained,
these are Tony's pets.
[28:29]
So it's not just an issue of outlawing
birds that fly around like, like wild
[28:35]
birds that fly around like, like wild
birds.
[28:35]
These are his pets. I also would like to
add that I did hear a lot of what if,
[28:41]
what if, what if. Um, I don't think that
really stands,
[28:45]
but mostly I would like to thank the board
for extending this conversation and, uh,
[28:51]
not voting on it tonight. Thank you very
much. Thank you.
[28:55]
Hello, uh, my name is Jean Clearfield, and
I was raised in the same town where my—
[29:01]
the same house where my father grew up and
where my grandmother still lives,
[29:07]
90 Truesdale Drive. And I would like to
speak as someone who hosts Project
[29:12]
FeederWatch, a citizen science project
created by Cornell Ornithology Lab.
[29:17]
And I routinely work in my job with many
birds, especially mourning doves,
[29:23]
which are biologically almost identical to
pigeons.
[29:26]
I would like to say that I've heard a lot
about infectious diseases,
[29:31]
and I want to say from an ornithological
point of view that pigeons do not pose a
[29:37]
unique threat of illness compared to any
other species of bird.
[29:42]
Okay, we are not dealing with, as you may
have heard them called, unfortunately,
[29:48]
like rats of the sky.
[29:49]
That is an unfortunate situation in which,
of course, pigeons,
[29:54]
as we associate them with cities and
metropolitan areas, are essentially—
[29:59]
they were released en masse before, and
they were kept as pets,
[30:04]
and now basically are sequestered to
eating garbage in cities.
[30:08]
So that is not up to— that's not integral
in the nature of pigeons.
[30:13]
And when they are kept, they are just as
clean, just as safe, as any other pet.
[30:19]
Okay, so I would really like to quench
this rumor that pigeons are somehow
[30:24]
this rumor that pigeons are somehow
dirtier
[30:25]
or more, you know, illness-producing than
any other bird,
[30:29]
any other pet that we have.
[30:31]
Okay, all these concerns,
[30:33]
all these illnesses that we're hearing
named are not unique to pigeons.
[30:38]
I would also like to say that, you know,
it really does generally seem that,
[30:43]
you know, we live in the natural world.
[30:46]
And if you were worried about
biodiversity,
[30:49]
reducing the amount of songbirds in this
town,
[30:53]
reducing the amount of species of birds in
this town— I'm an avid bird watcher,
[30:58]
and all I'm going to say is that I think
it's kind of interesting that that
[31:04]
it's kind of interesting that that
interest
[31:04]
has not popped up at any other time.
[31:07]
So I think if you're interested in things
like biodiversity,
[31:11]
interested in things like reducing
illness, interested in things like you
[31:17]
illness, interested in things like you
know,
[31:17]
helping the immunocompromised.
[31:19]
I wish that would— that concern would
emerge at other moments as well,
[31:24]
as someone who is genuinely concerned
about those topics and expresses my
[31:30]
about those topics and expresses my
concern
[31:30]
for biodiversity, for the natural world in
my work and in everything that I do.
[31:36]
And I'm generally concerned that something
which seems to be inconvenient to very
[31:42]
few people is now going to limit the
freedoms of the town which,
[31:46]
which I've come to love and which I know
that, that many, many birds have,
[31:52]
have come to love. So, so thank you so
much, and, uh, I hope you vote, um,
[31:57]
much, and, uh, I hope you vote, um,
nicely.
[31:58]
Thank you.
[31:59]
Thank you.
[31:59]
Good evening, how are you?
[32:05]
My name is Elio. I'm the president of New
Rochelle Pigeon Club.
[32:09]
Tony's a member, he's the newest, youngest
member of that club.
[32:13]
Our club was established in 1943.
[32:15]
So, you know, like through the years, you
know, like we have so many people,
[32:20]
you know, like doctors, businessmen,
lawyers, you name it.
[32:25]
Currently our club has 32 members and
they're all spread out through
[32:29]
they're all spread out through
Westchester.
[32:31]
Some of them are Greenwich, Connecticut
also, Rye.
[32:34]
So, you know, like that somebody make a
comment about one-family house coops,
[32:38]
you know, like that doesn't exist. I live
in one-family house.
[32:43]
And I have a coop over there.
[32:44]
My neighbor loves the pigeons and all
that.
[32:47]
I've been raising pigeons since I was
probably 5, 6 years old, as I can
[32:51]
probably 5, 6 years old, as I can
remember.
[32:52]
And another thing that I want, you know,
like to, you know,
[32:56]
agree with the lady is that about the
disease, you know,
[33:00]
like we take care of our pigeons like we
take care of our babies.
[33:04]
My daughter tells me,
[33:05]
you treat your pigeons as your babies and
you treat ours as your pigeons, you know.
[33:09]
So, you know, like Also, you know, like my
son is in a spectrum and it's like, uh,
[33:13]
he's a relaxing thing, I would say.
[33:15]
You know, like when he gets tantrums, you
know,
[33:18]
like the only thing I can chill him off is
bring him to the pigeon coop and relax
[33:22]
with him over there for an hour or 2.
[33:25]
If that would pose any, uh, danger or any,
you know, disease for him,
[33:28]
I would never bring him over there. So,
you know, like it's not in, uh,
[33:32]
you know, like it's not in, uh,
questioning.
[33:33]
Uh, I mean, you know,
[33:34]
like somebody wanted to know about how we
tag them and all that,
[33:38]
the eggs and all that.
[33:39]
And it's a very simple process, you know,
[33:41]
like they can go to Benzin Live and see
how we tag the pigeons, you know,
[33:45]
like they have the band, they have the
chip.
[33:48]
We have expensive equipment that we trace
pigeons and all that.
[33:51]
And also, you know, like there is a way
that, you know,
[33:54]
like we separate the boys from girls, I
would say, you know,
[33:58]
like after the breeding season.
[33:59]
And there's no eggs or anything in the
coop that we eat or we break or whatever
[34:04]
coop that we eat or we break or whatever
we
[34:04]
do with them. Another thing is that, you
know,
[34:06]
like we take care of them about the
diseases, you know, like right Today, you
[34:11]
diseases, you know, like right Today, you
know,
[34:11]
like I order a very expensive testing kit
that I want to send to Texas by certified,
[34:16]
you know, like, and, you know, mail to
check for any disease that might have.
[34:20]
You know, I check the droppings, I check
everything.
[34:23]
You know, like we are vets basically, the
pigeon flyers, they are vets.
[34:27]
You know, like all the flyers that are in
our club, you know,
[34:30]
like I'm the youngest one and they made me
the president just because, you know,
[34:35]
like there are a lot of old people and
they don't know how to deal with You know,
[34:39]
like the the clocking system and the
computers and all that.
[34:42]
By the way, I'm the director of IT
department for the city of Peekskill.
[34:47]
So that's why I'm the president.
[34:50]
They they made me over there to to to take
care of all this kind of stuff.
[34:54]
But you know, like we have generations of
people over there.
[34:57]
Like the guy is eighty years old and he's
telling me his grandfather had pigeons.
[35:02]
So you know, like it's it's a lovely
tradition.
[35:05]
You know, like and it's a hobby that.
[35:07]
I guess, you know, it's like a horse race,
you know.
[35:10]
I don't know, you know, like, I love my
pigeons, and pigeons are keeping me alive,
[35:14]
to be honest with you guys, with what I'm
going through in my house.
[35:18]
So, you know, like, it's— I'm sorry.
[35:20]
It's okay.
[35:27]
And there's no rats. Another thing is
about the mice and all that stuff, you
[35:31]
about the mice and all that stuff, you
know.
[35:31]
Keep in mind, if one mice enter in the
coop, the pigeons are gone.
[35:34]
He's going to kill all of them.
[35:36]
They're all going to be dead.
[35:37]
So there's no, you know, like no way rats
would be in that coop.
[35:41]
Or, you know, like if they attract rats,
you know,
[35:44]
like we take care of them in many ways.
[35:47]
But, you know, like there's—
[35:49]
what can I say, guys? You know, like we
take care of— we love our pigeons.
[35:54]
We love our hobby, you know, like and all
that, you know,
[35:57]
like we don't want anybody to, you know,
like lose its pleasure in life or,
[36:02]
you know, hobbies because of somebody
else.
[36:04]
I don't know what it is, whatever it is,
but as I say, you know, like, we, we,
[36:09]
we have the pigeons here as part of our
life. We have in our blood.
[36:14]
Like many people have, like, other
hobbies, you know, like pigeons are our
[36:19]
hobbies, you know, like pigeons are our
life.
[36:19]
I mean, anybody has any question, you
know, like how we test them and
[36:24]
know, like how we test them and
everything,
[36:25]
I can go through all of that.
[36:27]
But I assure you guys that there is
nothing cleaner than a pigeon coop in a
[36:33]
nothing cleaner than a pigeon coop in a
pigeon
[36:34]
fancier's yard.
[36:36]
I've been having pigeons in my house for
probably 11 years right now,
[36:42]
when I moved over there.
[36:44]
And the only complaint I got, it's, uh,
[36:47]
it was this old guy named Anthony That,
uh,
[36:51]
why do you lock your pigeon in wintertime?
[36:55]
Because he liked to see the pigeon flying
every single day.
[36:59]
And the reason why we lock them in
wintertime is because of the hawks.
[37:02]
We don't want our pigeon to get hit by
hawks during the winter because hawks tend
[37:06]
hawks during the winter because hawks tend
to
[37:07]
hit the pigeons, you know, like when the,
the leaves of the, the trees—
[37:10]
Time has expired, sir.
[37:11]
I'm sorry?
[37:12]
Time has expired, sir. All right, I'm
sorry. Thank you, guys.
[37:23]
Good evening. I'm Jennifer Pauley.
[37:25]
I live at 146 Old Post Road North, right
next door to Tony,
[37:29]
and I've lived there with my husband Andy
Simmons for over 20 years.
[37:34]
And before I say anything else,
[37:36]
I just want to thank all of you for being
on the board,
[37:39]
for your commitment to public service and
the public good,
[37:43]
and appreciate your having this discussion
today.
[37:47]
I would like to add, too, that I am home
most of the time. I work from home.
[37:52]
I usually am not going into the office.
[37:54]
I garden, and we have 2 dogs, and my
husband is a senior citizen.
[37:59]
Sorry, I had to put that in.
[38:01]
He's gonna kill me.
[38:02]
But in any case, both of us are outside in
our yard a lot,
[38:06]
and we are very aware of what goes on in
the neighborhood.
[38:10]
And I rarely see Tony's pigeons.
[38:12]
I think his coop is closer to my property
than to anybody else's,
[38:17]
but I rarely see them unless I walk near
the coop,
[38:20]
which is where they seem to spend the vast
majority of their time.
[38:25]
When I have seen them flying,
[38:27]
they do a few swoops over our house and a
couple of others,
[38:31]
and then they return to their coop. Their
sound is a very muted, gentle cooing.
[38:36]
Tony keeps the coop very clean. There's no
odor coming from it.
[38:41]
And as a cursory look at public health
literature will confirm,
[38:45]
there is no public health hazard from
domestic pigeons.
[38:49]
There's certainly no more risk from them
than from wild birds flying all over
[38:54]
Croton. Have these pigeons ever pooped on
my patio? Maybe.
[38:59]
Have they ever sat on top of my house?
Perhaps.
[39:02]
But so has every other bird in Croton.
[39:04]
It's important to note too, as Tony has
told me,
[39:08]
that he received village approval before
he built his coop.
[39:12]
And Tony doesn't live in his house
full-time because he is renovating it,
[39:17]
but he will be moving into the house and
living there full-time with the pigeons.
[39:23]
He has followed all the rules. He got all
the necessary permits. He built the coop.
[39:29]
He moved his pigeons in.
[39:30]
To tell him now that his approximately 20
pigeons have to go is outrageously unfair
[39:36]
and unjust. I know other neighbors have
complained to the board about the pigeons.
[39:42]
We've heard some tonight.
[39:44]
They have also called the police multiple
times to report that the pigeons are
[39:49]
flying over their house.
[39:51]
Somebody, I don't know who,
[39:53]
even called the fire department once
claiming that the coop was on fire.
[39:58]
Every time one of these calls is made, as
you know,
[40:01]
it requires that the police or
firefighters come to the house to
[40:06]
firefighters come to the house to
investigate.
[40:07]
Is this really the best use of our taxes,
[40:09]
to send first responders into the middle
of a dispute between neighbors,
[40:14]
taking them away from real emergencies?
[40:17]
If you support this ban,
[40:19]
please consider that you will be aligning
yourself with a campaign of harassment
[40:24]
against Tony, who is a new Croton
resident.
[40:27]
I also have to say, I find it hypocritical
to consider a ban on pigeons when we
[40:33]
still allow gas-powered leaf blowers.
[40:36]
As we know, gas-powered leaf blowers are
so loud they can damage hearing.
[40:41]
In our house, we have to spend the best
weather months of the year with all the
[40:46]
windows shut tight so that we don't have
to listen as,
[40:50]
as much to the daily roar of leaf blowers.
[40:53]
Gas-powered leaf blowers spew carcinogens
and toxic emissions into the air.
[40:58]
This is a well-documented fact.
[41:00]
They kill beneficial insects and they
destroy pollinator habitats.
[41:05]
And people wonder all the time— I see it
on Facebook— where are all the bees?
[41:10]
Where are all the fireflies? Where are all
the butterflies?
[41:15]
And yet we allow gas-powered leaf blowers,
but we're considering banning pigeons.
[41:20]
I'll remind you that pigeons, unlike leaf
blowers, don't cause cancer,
[41:25]
they don't destroy the environment, and
they don't ruin your hearing.
[41:30]
I think we as a community need to focus
more on issues of real importance and
[41:35]
more on issues of real importance and
worry
[41:36]
less about people's pets. Thank you for
the chance to speak.
[41:40]
And thank you for your service to the
community. It's truly appreciated.
[41:45]
Thank you. Good evening. Jim Miller, 18
Wolf Road.
[41:50]
I've followed the discussions the previous
weeks about this quite a bit.
[41:57]
Read the pretext for this statue of
concerns about health related to bird
[42:04]
droppings, related to seed that is used to
feed the birds, attracting rodents,
[42:11]
and other health-related concerns that
have been caused by apparently We have one
[42:19]
pigeon coop in the village, 20 pigeons.
[42:23]
And what really struck me today is I
walked out my front door,
[42:28]
and I have a couple of birdseed feeders
hanging from my tree.
[42:34]
And as I walked out, there was a flock of
perhaps 100 starlings on my front lawn.
[42:42]
Nothing unusual. It's fall migration this
time of year.
[42:47]
I'm sorry?
[42:48]
Also, the feed is there for them to eat,
and they come.
[42:52]
And when I startled them, they flew across
the street,
[42:56]
half of them landing on my neighbor's
roof,
[42:59]
the other half landing in the tree next to
their house.
[43:03]
And the other thing that I noticed was,
[43:06]
not only have I attracted these birds that
are going to be pooping all over the
[43:12]
place and causing disease, But also I've
attracted rodents.
[43:17]
I, I saw squirrels running all over the
place.
[43:21]
And, uh, what, what I wonder is,
[43:24]
have we considered banning bird feeders in
Croton?
[43:28]
Because whatever dangers you feel arise
from a pigeon coop,
[43:34]
the same dangers arise from bird feeders.
[43:38]
And I'm here to say, like, well,
[43:41]
maybe first you came for Tony's pigeon
coop.
[43:45]
Next, you may come for my bird feeders.
Please don't. Thank you.
[43:51]
Thank you. Thank you. Excuse me.
[43:54]
Um, Gary Eisinger, Cleveland Drive.
[43:57]
Uh, good evening, members of the board and
neighbors.
[44:00]
I wanted to take these few minutes to talk
about NIMBYism.
[44:04]
It's been quite a few years now that many
of us in the village have been attacked
[44:10]
with this word. We went from being
neighbors to being NIMBYists,
[44:14]
the word utilized against us,
[44:16]
slandering us with implications of our
utter horridness as human beings.
[44:21]
While allowing ADUs on the smallest lots
in Croton,
[44:25]
built right up to and looming over
longstanding property setback
[44:29]
longstanding property setback
requirements,
[44:30]
you shot us NIMBYists down, favoring, it
seems,
[44:34]
the shadows taking away gardens and
hard-earned little slices of paradise.
[44:39]
With absolutely zero neighbor input
allowed.
[44:42]
With Lot A, our neighbors on Wayne Street
brought up the obstructed views they would
[44:48]
have from this 5-plus-story structure,
[44:50]
and those neighbors were also written off
as nimbyists,
[44:54]
obstructionists in the Hochul to Harkham
to Pugh slam dunk to take away neighbors'
[45:00]
right to voice grievances on the impact
your progress and your preferred changes
[45:05]
your progress and your preferred changes
to
[45:06]
the village impact our daily lives.
[45:08]
With 425 Riverside, we have neighbors—
dare we label them NIMBYs as well—
[45:13]
who have grave concerns of a slope
collapse in their own literal backyards.
[45:18]
At Gottwald Circle, an unnecessary
elongation of the xeriscape garden curbs
[45:23]
elongation of the xeriscape garden curbs
were
[45:24]
designed such that parking spots were
removed from in front of these neighbors'
[45:29]
houses, impacting their businesses and
daily life.
[45:33]
In this case, a redesign could have
pleased all sides,
[45:36]
but our mayor and deputy mayor,
[45:39]
with less concern for other neighbors'
backyards or street front in this case,
[45:44]
ignored their pleas.
[45:45]
And with Kathy Hochul's Let Them Build
package,
[45:49]
we have exempted large-scale projects like
425 Riverside and soon the Green Growler
[45:54]
building from SEQR, which enabled public
input into projects that quite literally
[46:00]
impact our backyards, our front yards, and
our quality of life.
[46:04]
So now we come to the subject of this
diatribe: our own Deputy Mayor's backyard.
[46:10]
It seems to have now gotten personal.
[46:13]
I mean, absolutely no one likes bird shit
in their backyard,
[46:17]
and since we are now holding a public
hearing on what ostensibly boils down to
[46:22]
hearing on what ostensibly boils down to
where
[46:23]
we draw the line on pigeon shit in what
seems to be the wrong neighbor's backyard.
[46:28]
And by wrong neighbor,
[46:30]
I find it quite amusing that it is
Croton's own godfather of anti-NIMBYism
[46:35]
Croton's own godfather of anti-NIMBYism
who now
[46:35]
apparently having reached his own
come-to-NIMBY moment.
[46:39]
So now that you've had this epiphany that
our backyards can really matter to us,
[46:45]
would you please consider joining the
voice of community Uh, excuse me,
[46:50]
the voice of Croton Community Group.
[46:52]
Um, and with our community group behind
you,
[46:55]
we can help you fight the power of Hochul
to Harkham to Pugh and reclaim the joy and
[47:01]
dignity of your little slice of paradise
we call the backyard.
[47:06]
And on a more serious side regarding the
chickens,
[47:09]
I really think your proposed setbacks are
way too big.
[47:13]
So odd that you champion a 10-foot setback
for an 800-square-foot ADU but ask for 5
[47:19]
times that for a 60-square-foot chicken
coop?
[47:22]
Please make that difference make sense to
me in the coming weeks. Thank you.
[47:27]
Thank you.
[47:28]
Hello, my name is Doug Simmons.
[47:33]
I live on Finney Farm Road.
[47:37]
And I'm here to advocate for my neighbor
[47:44]
Tony and his pigeons and doves.
[47:50]
Tony is a good neighbor.
[47:51]
He's a nice guy.
[47:53]
When you talk to him, as I have on a
number of occasions, I've gotten to know
[47:57]
number of occasions, I've gotten to know
him,
[47:57]
you realize you're in the presence of a
gentleman.
[48:01]
Please know that he's suffering from this
proposed legislation.
[48:05]
I think you saw some emotion tonight from
one of his, I guess,
[48:09]
colleagues.
[48:10]
I didn't, I didn't know that gentleman.
[48:11]
Tony's fearful. He's not a guy looking to
fight City Hall.
[48:16]
You know, he, he, uh, he doesn't have a
lawyer at ready.
[48:20]
This is, uh, this is, uh, really caught
him, uh, unexpected.
[48:25]
Um, he moved here because he sensed a
loving and tolerant community,
[48:30]
and he's been treated so poorly. It's
really shameful.
[48:35]
I understand the May 29th petition,
[48:37]
which has 41 signatures was circulated
among parents at the school bus stop in
[48:43]
among parents at the school bus stop in
front
[48:44]
of my home. It's directly across from
Jennifer and Andy's and Antoni's.
[48:49]
No one knocked on my door and asked me to
sign.
[48:54]
I had no idea this petition even existed
until a few weeks ago.
[48:58]
The petition is alarmist in tone and out
of touch with reality.
[49:03]
Let me address 2 specific objections.
[49:05]
Pigeons, coops, excrement, and feed
attract rats and other pests.
[49:11]
These create health issues and costly
control burdens.
[49:15]
This was obviously written before we got
to know— before I got to know Tony,
[49:22]
and it's a gross exaggeration.
[49:24]
Tony's coop is immaculate,
[49:26]
and anyone with a bird feeder knows that
seed has to be properly stored or rats
[49:33]
seed has to be properly stored or rats
will
[49:33]
become a problem. 2, 2 of the 6.
[49:36]
I'll only do the 2 of this petition, May
29th petition.
[49:41]
Sizable coops— it's not that big, by the
way—
[49:44]
sizable coops are known to be a fire
hazard.
[49:49]
This is an irresponsible allegation,
[49:51]
and our fire department was indeed
summoned to Tony's home with the report
[49:55]
summoned to Tony's home with the report
that the
[49:56]
coop was on fire. There was indeed a smoke
condition.
[49:59]
And it came from a barbecue grill in the
yard behind Tony's home.
[50:04]
Our volunteer firefighters showed up for
no reason.
[50:07]
Along the same lines,
[50:09]
I also understand that the police have
been called in response to complaints that
[50:14]
Tony's birds have been defecating on their
property. Seriously?
[50:19]
Another call was made to a local business
to remove a dead pigeon from a yard.
[50:24]
I'm not sure which one.
[50:26]
Was it Tony's? His pets are banded with
identification.
[50:31]
Imagine if a deceased dog or cat wearing a
collar had been discarded without
[50:36]
attempting to reach the owner.
[50:39]
No one attempted to get in touch with Tony
about that bird.
[50:43]
This is harassment. This is abusive. It
really has to stop.
[50:47]
It's like picking on a newcomer.
[50:50]
Circumstances have changed since the
circulation of the May 29th petition.
[50:55]
The coop is built. His beloved birds are
acclimated to their new home.
[51:01]
It takes a while for pigeons to get
settled into a home, and they,
[51:05]
they will fly around. They're homing
pigeons.
[51:09]
They gotta figure out where their home is.
[51:12]
It's another reason why it'd be really
cruel to uproot them again.
[51:16]
Other neighbors like myself and friends on
Old Post Road have come to admire Tony's
[51:22]
doves.
[51:24]
These neighbors include Andy and Jennifer,
who live across the street.
[51:26]
They're the closest—I measured by my
footsteps—they're the closest to the coop.
[51:32]
Their bird is the closest neighbor. Their
home is the closest neighbor to the coop.
[51:37]
They love the birds.
[51:38]
I love the birds.
[51:41]
A new petition started on August 21st,
just a few weeks ago.
[51:45]
It's since been circulated. It says here
190.
[51:48]
196 signatures, but since I wrote this, I
think it's gone over to 200.
[51:52]
That quick, that many people rallied to
this petition.
[51:56]
And that includes my immediate neighbors
in 3 households to the south of me on Old
[52:01]
Post Road.
[52:01]
The new petition is rational and fair,
[52:06]
and it concludes that we ask the board—
[52:11]
the petition— and I ask the board to
reject a ban grandfather existing
[52:18]
keepers, and protect the rights of
responsible pet owners in Croton.
[52:24]
Thank you for this opportunity.
[52:27]
Good evening, Pete Panzica, 110 Old Post
Road.
[52:33]
Um, I'm sure Tony's a nice guy.
[52:35]
I don't know him, but I would not be happy
if this statute which allowed Tony to
[52:39]
enter neighborhood under this pretext of
owning pigeons were allowed to stand,
[52:43]
because you need to put yourselves in the
neighbor's shoes.
[52:47]
And I know there's some neighbors who
testified tonight that the pigeons don't
[52:51]
bother them, but those pictures don't lie.
[52:55]
There are birds on the house. I'm sure
there's poop in the house.
[52:58]
Your windows are open.
[52:59]
I'm sure there's cooing, and that becomes
annoying after a while.
[53:03]
Dogs are legal, but if a dog went into
your front lawn and tore up the neighbor's
[53:08]
flowers, they would call the police.
[53:10]
If dog was incessantly barking all night,
you would call the police.
[53:14]
And if a dog was pooping on your lawn, you
would call the police.
[53:18]
I just wish that the neighbors who are
inconvenienced by this would be given that
[53:23]
same consideration because they're—
[53:25]
this is their lived experience and they
are suffering from this.
[53:29]
And if it was me and somebody moved next
to me because this law was in place,
[53:34]
I would be very unhappy. I can understand
chickens.
[53:37]
They are contained in a, in an area. They
don't fly around.
[53:41]
Bird feeders, you're inviting the birds to
your property.
[53:44]
I am a physician. Toxoplasmosis and
histoplasmosis are real
[53:50]
diseases that people do get. So I've seen
it.
[53:54]
Please, Sarah, Sarah, please,
conversation.
[53:58]
I mean, the comment came to me.
[54:01]
So Um, so that's all I really have to say.
[54:05]
Um, I would not, you know, and I love
animals, but if animals are an annoyance,
[54:10]
they shouldn't allow to be annoying, you
know, people in the town of Croton.
[54:14]
Thank you.
[54:15]
Thank you. Thank you.
[54:21]
Thank you.
[54:22]
Good evening, I'm Carrie Andrews, 20
Hunter Street here in Croton.
[54:29]
And I just think this is an issue looking
for a problem.
[54:34]
And I really support Tony being able to
have his pigeons.
[54:40]
The thing is, pigeons are already here.
[54:44]
I keep eBird accounts, which is, you know,
[54:48]
I track the birds that are in my backyard
almost daily and elsewhere.
[54:55]
Thank you.
[54:56]
And I've had pigeons, they're called rock
pigeons, feral pigeons.
[55:02]
I've had them for years now. They're in
Croton, they're here.
[55:06]
So I don't think that that is such an
issue that they have, that the pigeons,
[55:12]
you know, that are confined, it's only 20
of them.
[55:16]
It seems like a reasonable thing to have.
[55:19]
And in terms of the illness caused, I'm a
PA, retired PA.
[55:23]
And I used to park in the Bronx in a
garage that was so full of pigeons that
[55:29]
feathers were everywhere, poop was
everywhere.
[55:32]
And I would get out and I would— I was
actually a little nervous about it,
[55:38]
to be quite honest, when I first started
parking there.
[55:42]
But by the own admission of the review of
the records with the— that—
[55:47]
Brian Healy presented, the risk of those
illnesses,
[55:51]
psittacosis and toxoplasmosis and all of
those, is extremely rare.
[55:56]
And so I don't really think it is a health
hazard.
[55:59]
And I just think that it's really,
[56:02]
really unfair for this person who has
gotten a permit,
[56:06]
moved here because he thought he could
have his pigeons,
[56:10]
and then all of a sudden we're like
pulling the wool from under him.
[56:15]
Thank you.
[56:15]
you know, the rug from under him.
[56:18]
I don't think it's quite the hazard that
is being presented,
[56:22]
and I really think he ought to be able to
allow— and we shouldn't have this ban.
[56:27]
It seems like it's something that came up
after a situation came up that I don't
[56:32]
really think is well thought out. Thank
you.
[56:35]
Thank you. Good evening, everyone. I'm
Tony. Uh, you all know me.
[56:42]
Thank you so much for your support.
[56:45]
So I heard a lot of concerns tonight and a
lot of support,
[56:51]
and I really appreciate for all your
support.
[56:57]
Uh, the concerns they have that if I
wanted to get eggs and eat eggs,
[57:01]
that I would keep chickens so I don't have
to keep pigeons because they have way
[57:06]
smaller eggs. And the other con—
[57:08]
the other Their concern is that every
single bird contains same disease if they
[57:14]
single bird contains same disease if they
get
[57:14]
it. So on Croton, we have 380 different
species birds.
[57:18]
None of them have been vaccinated.
[57:22]
None of them have been treated.
[57:23]
None of them have been cleaned. Mine are
every single day.
[57:27]
Their water has been cleaned every single
day.
[57:30]
I don't leave the same can on the same day
for 2, 3 days. I cleaned it.
[57:35]
I feed them only for what they need to
eat. I don't leave feed on the feeder.
[57:40]
I don't. I, I wanted—
[57:42]
I love them.
[57:42]
I don't want to risk killing none of them.
[57:46]
As per mites and rats, um, as my president
of the club, our club, mentioned it,
[57:54]
um, if a single mice or rat gets in my
coop for them is like a poison.
[58:00]
In 24 hours, they would die.
[58:03]
So that is my first concern,
[58:06]
to keep them clean and not allow any
single rats or rats coming in there.
[58:13]
Al, Nora, and Stacy, they've been to my
coop. They've seen it, how I keep it.
[58:21]
I have everything secured.
[58:23]
There is no way they could get mice or
rats in there.
[58:27]
So that about that concern, mice and rats,
that, that, that just can't happen.
[58:32]
And the other thing is, oh, on Croton you
guys been having pigeons forever.
[58:38]
My question is, how many people got sick
from them?
[58:41]
Because for what I heard, none of them
got.
[58:44]
So if that's all your concerns, you had
that concern here a while ago,
[58:49]
and I don't understand Why police haven't
been called for any wild pigeons or doves,
[58:55]
which they fly every single day in my
house,
[58:58]
and they've been flying before I brought
the pigeons on my house.
[59:03]
I have pictures and videos way before I
brought them because I knew this was
[59:08]
brought them because I knew this was
coming.
[59:09]
So doves been here, they flying on top of
my roof,
[59:12]
the neighbor's roof, anybody's roof,
[59:15]
and different birds are flying there.
[59:18]
They're pooping all over.
[59:19]
Is that the same poop or is that, that's a
different poop?
[59:23]
So I'm, I'm so, I'm so— yeah, it's so
confusing.
[59:27]
And then, uh, there was another question,
[59:30]
another concern which I can't actually
remember exactly,
[59:33]
but have they flied on the people's
houses?
[59:36]
Yes, they have. Have I mentioned it here
the first time I was here that they could
[59:42]
be flying the first week they come out of
the coop, the young, young ones?
[59:48]
Yes, they do, because they're afraid from
predators.
[59:51]
Their wings are not strong enough to fly
up in the air.
[59:55]
So what they do, they fly around the
houses to scan the property, get used to
[1:00:01]
houses to scan the property, get used to
it,
[1:00:01]
to the, to the area. Then they won't be
doing that anymore.
[1:00:06]
Well, I heard they ripped a neighbor's
cushions.
[1:00:09]
They don't, they don't have that strength.
They both seen the feeder plastic bag.
[1:00:15]
I have it on the coop. with the pigeons.
[1:00:18]
If they, they had that strength, that bag
would have been ripped a long time ago.
[1:00:24]
So the cushions, I'm guessing it's way
stronger than a plastic bag is.
[1:00:29]
So if these ones are all the concerns, and
if there is any other concerns,
[1:00:34]
I would be more than happy to answer.
That's all I had. Thank you. Good evening.
[1:00:40]
Ed Riley from Truesdale Drive.
[1:00:42]
When I heard the gentleman speak last
week, I was very sympathetic.
[1:00:47]
It may, may still be. I'm not sure.
[1:00:50]
Croton's had serious problems with pigeons
in the past.
[1:00:54]
I grew up on Van Wyck Street down here.
Spent 21 years there.
[1:00:58]
And pigeons populated the entire Riverside
Avenue, Brook Street area,
[1:01:03]
the train tracks, you know, the train
station.
[1:01:06]
And then as changes were made in the
Village, they migrated up.
[1:01:11]
And they hung around 2-story and 3-story
buildings. They created an incredible
[1:01:17]
buildings. They created an incredible
mess.
[1:01:17]
As a matter of fact,
[1:01:19]
my neighbors used to hire us to get with
pellet guns and BB guns to shoot them off
[1:01:25]
their drains because you'd have this
phosphorescent white streak down the sides
[1:01:30]
phosphorescent white streak down the sides
of
[1:01:30]
these houses. And they were dirty and they
were filthy. They were an unwanted pest.
[1:01:36]
I don't know how Croton got rid of them,
but Croton did get rid of them.
[1:01:42]
Now, if these pigeons— and,
[1:01:44]
and I'm surprised the board didn't ask the
gentleman from New Rochelle,
[1:01:49]
or the last gentleman, a lot of questions.
[1:01:52]
Hopefully he'll do that in, um, in work
session.
[1:01:55]
You know, on this pigeon issue,
[1:01:58]
I thought that maybe these pigeons go with
the urbanization of Croton.
[1:02:03]
You know, you need— if Croton's going to
be an urban environment with a lot of
[1:02:08]
apartment houses, maybe you need the
pigeons and the squirrels and the, you
[1:02:14]
pigeons and the squirrels and the, you
know,
[1:02:14]
feeding things in the park.
[1:02:16]
I think what people are afraid of is if
you want a, um, a, a visual, uh,
[1:02:22]
in-your-face representation of what pigeon
mania could look like if these pigeons
[1:02:27]
are not controlled is if you go to
Tuckahoe Road and Central Avenue,
[1:02:32]
there's a Dunkin' Donuts there. It used to
be a bank.
[1:02:36]
It's right next to the, uh— Tuckahoe Road
Post Office.
[1:02:40]
If you look at the pigeons and the crap
and the filth in that whole corner, and,
[1:02:46]
and it comes from the fact that people
feed those pigeons.
[1:02:50]
They attract those pigeons to that area.
[1:02:53]
Now, if these pigeons are well-trained
pigeons— actually, World War I, a pigeon,
[1:02:59]
a passenger pigeon for New York Division
got a Medal of Honor because he helped
[1:03:05]
got a Medal of Honor because he helped
save
[1:03:05]
this Lost Battalion.
[1:03:06]
Now, if his pigeons are so well trained
that they don't bother your neighbor—
[1:03:12]
that's always a big violation.
[1:03:14]
If your pigeons on a regular basis bother
your neighbors and create filth in your
[1:03:20]
neighbor's house, you are violating
neighborliness.
[1:03:24]
And then if you have a complaint against
that neighbor,
[1:03:28]
the first thing is not to go to the
Village Board or the Police Department,
[1:03:33]
it's to go to your neighbor and confront
them about that.
[1:03:38]
But if these pigeons are so well trained
that they go—
[1:03:41]
they can go to the Ringling Brothers show
and after, you know,
[1:03:46]
1 or 2 errant trips to the neighbor's
house,
[1:03:49]
they will always return and they're
numbered.
[1:03:52]
Remember, you regulate the number of
chickens in somebody's yard.
[1:03:57]
You don't allow chickens to go in somebody
else's yard and you regulate the number.
[1:04:03]
If this gentleman— I have great sympathy
for Because it's—
[1:04:07]
maybe we ought to call in Marlon Brando
here as a witness.
[1:04:12]
But if, um, if he, if he can regulate the
number, he has bans on everyone, uh,
[1:04:17]
they will not bother the neighbors' houses
and poop all over their houses, uh,
[1:04:23]
they're not like wild birds, they are like
starlings, um, that, that's great.
[1:04:29]
But it should be, um, grandfathered.
[1:04:31]
Thank you.
[1:04:32]
Because I find it hard to believe that,
you know, like in every household,
[1:04:37]
a couple of pigeons get together and say,
hey, you know,
[1:04:40]
let's go over the wall and set up shop,
you know,
[1:04:44]
down the street or someplace like that.
[1:04:46]
But if that's the case, if these can be
controlled, they're so well disciplined,
[1:04:51]
etc., I think you should grandfather this
gentleman because he could come in here
[1:04:56]
and ask permission to have these.
Remember, we've had this problem before.
[1:05:01]
And I don't know whether they're fish or
fowl, but remember the geese problem?
[1:05:06]
Everybody used to love geese, right? Now
everybody hates geese. Why?
[1:05:10]
Because they poop all over the place.
[1:05:12]
That's what pigeons do if they're not
regimented.
[1:05:15]
Now maybe he has a regiment that's well
regulated. God bless him.
[1:05:20]
But you missed your chance,
[1:05:21]
and hopefully you'll do this in a work
session where you can ask back and forth,
[1:05:26]
or people can submit questions to you. And
you can get the full story.
[1:05:31]
Your pigeons will never escape.
[1:05:33]
If you leave town, you'll take every one
of them with you, etc.
[1:05:37]
But in the dark past of Croton's
industrial era,
[1:05:40]
we had thousands and thousands of pigeons,
and they were a plague. Thank you.
[1:05:45]
Thank you. Thank you.
[1:05:46]
Hello, Matt Angelini, Cleveland Drive.
[1:05:52]
Thank you, uh, for everybody on the board
for hearing us all out tonight.
[1:05:57]
It's really impressive that you've let
everybody take up all of your time.
[1:06:02]
I just have 2 quick things to add.
[1:06:05]
Uh, one on the public health issue that
we've heard so much about tonight.
[1:06:10]
I think it's interesting to add in some
data to the argument when we're talking
[1:06:15]
about Cryptococcus and other diseases that
are spread by pigeons.
[1:06:19]
The CDC cites the per capita rate on those
diseases as something like 1 in 100,000
[1:06:25]
cases. And then when you're talking about
New York State and something like Lyme
[1:06:30]
disease, you're talking about 200 times
that rate, something like 200 per 100,000.
[1:06:36]
So I think if we're talking about public
health as being one of the reasons for
[1:06:41]
putting this local law into effect,
[1:06:44]
and we're not also comparing the effects
of deer on the village of Croton,
[1:06:49]
then we're not really passing the purple
face test there when it comes to public
[1:06:54]
health. And the second thing that I wanted
to address, um,
[1:06:58]
I think one other commenter addressed it
tonight, but changing the setbacks on
[1:07:03]
tonight, but changing the setbacks on
fowl,
[1:07:03]
uh, coops and homes from 15 feet to 50
feet is a massive change to the village,
[1:07:09]
and I believe would ban most of R-9 and
R-5 from being able to put a coop anywhere
[1:07:14]
on their property. And I think that that's
something that a lot of chicken owners in
[1:07:20]
Croton would be against as well. So again,
thank you for your time. I appreciate it.
[1:07:26]
Thank you.
[1:07:30]
Hi, Nora Odland, Van Wyck Street.
[1:07:32]
You guys have heard a lot from me on this,
so I'm gonna just keep it brief.
[1:07:37]
And I just wanted to refute one point that
I heard brought up here,
[1:07:41]
which was about dogs you know,
[1:07:43]
if there was a dog that was constantly
going into a neighbor's yard, you know,
[1:07:48]
you would do something about it.
[1:07:50]
You probably would, but the thing that I
don't think you would do is ban dogs
[1:07:55]
village-wide. And that's where my
particular— I have been organizing around
[1:08:00]
particular— I have been organizing around
this,
[1:08:00]
but my particular issue with this is that
I do feel that a ban is a really,
[1:08:05]
really big reaction to something that
Probably doesn't.
[1:08:08]
You know, like now if somebody else wanted
to ever keep pigeons,
[1:08:13]
we're never going to allow that because of
a neighbor dispute.
[1:08:17]
And whether that's fair or like, I don't
know,
[1:08:20]
that's just where I have an issue with it.
So I wanted to add that into the record.
[1:08:25]
And everyone really spoke really
eloquently.
[1:08:28]
I thank you all for listening to this and
all of your service about this.
[1:08:33]
So thanks so much.
[1:08:34]
Thank you. Good evening, everyone.
[1:08:37]
Nigel Rovella, 167 North Riverside.
[1:08:41]
I am one of the, uh, neighbors, uh,
[1:08:45]
within the 7 closest to, uh, this pigeon
coop.
[1:08:51]
I have sent the Board of Trustees
pictures,
[1:08:54]
and I think there was one video, um, of
the change in my property,
[1:08:59]
um, from these pigeons.
[1:09:03]
The moment that I guess they, they were
put in,
[1:09:06]
I started noticing poop going up my steps.
[1:09:09]
So now when I walk up my steps,
[1:09:11]
I have to carry my dog so she doesn't step
on the poop,
[1:09:14]
so then I have to clean her paws when I go
inside the house.
[1:09:19]
I had a pigeon on top of my car. I had
poop near my car.
[1:09:22]
Now I can't park my car underneath the
tree.
[1:09:25]
Trees in front of my house because I have
some pigeons in my trees.
[1:09:30]
One day my dog came out and ran towards
one of my flower beds because there were 2
[1:09:35]
pigeons there that did not scatter once my
dog got there about a foot away from
[1:09:41]
eating them. Why didn't the pigeons move?
[1:09:43]
Now, many people have said, well, we've
always had pigeons,
[1:09:47]
these could be wild pigeons.
[1:09:49]
Yeah, for sure. But you know what?
[1:09:51]
I've lived there for many years. I've
never seen pigeons in my trees.
[1:09:56]
They've never been in my flower beds.
[1:09:57]
They've never been on top of my car.
[1:09:59]
There's never been pigeon poop going up my
steps, on my driveway, on my deck.
[1:10:05]
I walk on Wolf Street 3 times, sometimes 2
to 3 times a day with my dog.
[1:10:12]
I've never seen so many pigeons on the
pole lines on Wolf Street,
[1:10:15]
on people's rooftops.
[1:10:17]
So there is a change.
[1:10:18]
There's absolutely a change,
[1:10:20]
and that is something that we need to
consider While making this
[1:10:24]
decision, yes, it's only one coop right
now.
[1:10:27]
But if we pass this law and it's
unregulated, and as the gentleman said
[1:10:32]
unregulated, and as the gentleman said
earlier,
[1:10:33]
where we don't have something in place to
ensure that the amount of pigeons that are
[1:10:38]
allowed to be in a property don't expand,
[1:10:41]
that's that can create a very big problem
with the pigeon population,
[1:10:46]
just like chickens.
[1:10:47]
they can overpopulate if we're not
regulating them, right?
[1:10:51]
So there's also the questions of, oh,
we're saying a lot of what-ifs.
[1:10:56]
Well, when we're making decisions, we have
to use what-if,
[1:10:59]
and we have to use scenarios of worst case
to best case.
[1:11:03]
Because if you don't take into account
those what-ifs, what are you going to do?
[1:11:08]
Wait to ban something after something
actually happens?
[1:11:12]
So if there's a possibility, a 1% chance
of somebody being able to get Sick,
[1:11:17]
or 1% chance of just damage to your
property, or in the nuisance because of
[1:11:22]
property, or in the nuisance because of
noise,
[1:11:22]
right? I do hear the cooling noise at 5
o'clock in the morning for quite a long
[1:11:27]
period of time.
[1:11:30]
It's disturbing.
[1:11:31]
So, um, as I said before, I've sent
videos, I've sent images,
[1:11:36]
so there is proof in a visual aspect.
[1:11:39]
There's many people here that are
sympathetic.
[1:11:42]
I'm sympathetic to our new neighbor.
[1:11:44]
I haven't met him, haven't gone to his
house, he hasn't come to my house.
[1:11:48]
He also didn't do that prior to building
his coop and informing all of us, hey,
[1:11:53]
what do you guys think if I'm doing this?
[1:11:55]
I don't know, if I were somebody that was
building something to, let's say,
[1:12:00]
house ducks, I'm going to ask my
neighbors, hey,
[1:12:03]
what do you think if I start doing this?
[1:12:05]
I need to take into consideration what my
neighborhood is going to think about.
[1:12:10]
Many things get done in neighborhoods and
different cities and towns and villages
[1:12:15]
without taking into consideration what the
other might think. We can't be selfish.
[1:12:20]
I can't sit here and be selfish about what
another neighbor is trying to do with
[1:12:25]
pigeons, with chickens, with crocodiles,
or whatever, right?
[1:12:29]
But I can only be adamant about what's
happening in my property right now,
[1:12:33]
and I can only be sympathetic to what's
happening in other another neighbor's
[1:12:38]
property. And I'm also here speaking,
[1:12:40]
also thinking in the broad aspect of what
might happen within our village and
[1:12:45]
surrounding villages if this pigeon
situation gets out of control.
[1:12:49]
So there's a what-if for you.
[1:12:52]
There are other villages and towns in
Westchester County and in the surrounding
[1:12:56]
counties and in other states that have
passed a ban.
[1:12:59]
Why did they do that?
[1:13:01]
There had to be something behind it.
[1:13:04]
So I ask that you take into consideration
all of the pros and all of the cons and
[1:13:09]
all of the information that the public and
the neighbors have given to make a wise
[1:13:14]
decision. I've doubted while I was sitting
here and listening to everybody and all
[1:13:20]
the new information that I received about
me asking you to please put this ban in,
[1:13:25]
but it's been reinforced for me to ask you
to put this ban in and not grandfather
[1:13:31]
this situation. And I'm not asking this
because of anger that I have to walk in
[1:13:36]
because of anger that I have to walk in
and
[1:13:36]
go up my steps with pigeon poop on there.
[1:13:39]
I'm asking you because of concern in the
greater view of the village. Thank you.
[1:13:44]
Thank you.
[1:13:45]
Thank you.
[1:13:59]
Does anyone wish to comment on Local Law
Number 10?
[1:14:01]
Mayor, I'll just note for the record that
we received a
[1:14:06]
number of written comments which are
posted to the
[1:14:10]
agenda.
[1:14:10]
Okay. All right. Well, with that, uh,
[1:14:13]
do I have a motion to close the public
hearing?
[1:14:16]
So moved.
[1:14:18]
Motion by Trustee Nochtaler, second by
Trustee, uh, Slippen. All in favor?
[1:14:24]
Aye. Aye.
[1:14:25]
All right, we proceed to our second, uh,
[1:14:28]
public hearing of the evening concerning
Local Law Number 11 of 2026 to amend
[1:14:33]
Chapter 204. I'll give folks who want to
leave this opportunity to head out now.
[1:14:39]
Actually, we don't have a date for the
work
[1:14:43]
session where we're going to discuss this
yet,
[1:14:47]
do we?
[1:14:48]
No.
[1:14:51]
Hopefully sometime in October. Okay. Yeah.
[1:14:53]
Well, so, quick clarification.
[1:14:55]
If we do make revisions in the work
session to Local Law 10,
[1:14:59]
can we reopen the public hearing?
[1:15:01]
Yes. You have to notice a new one.
[1:15:04]
Yeah, correct.
[1:15:05]
Do we close it? We just, we just closed
it. Oh, okay. Sorry. You made the motion.
[1:15:10]
I know. I was just so excited to be able
to make the motion.
[1:15:13]
Substantive changes, then you really need
to have another public hearing.
[1:15:17]
Okay.
[1:15:18]
But I do think it was clear to everybody
that what are
[1:15:24]
the next steps we were going to do,
[1:15:27]
which is why otherwise we would have left
it open,
[1:15:32]
I guess. Yeah. Okay.
[1:15:40]
For those that are leaving,
[1:15:47]
please proceed on your way
[1:15:53]
out.
[1:15:54]
Please leave.
[1:15:56]
If you're staying, please regain your
seat.
[1:16:02]
All right, do I have a motion to, uh,
[1:16:08]
on opening a public hearing on Local Law
Number
[1:16:16]
11 of 2026?
[1:16:17]
So moved.
[1:16:19]
Do I have a second?
[1:16:21]
Second.
[1:16:23]
Motion by Trustee Nicholson, second by
Trustee Slippen. Discussion?
[1:16:31]
Give a brief—
[1:16:31]
Yeah, yeah.
[1:16:33]
So the Village Board had discussed this
local law at a public— at a work session.
[1:16:39]
I believe that was in July.
[1:16:41]
This is a change in the law related to the
Senior Citizen Rental Income Exemption
[1:16:48]
and the Disabled Person Rental Income
Exemption program.
[1:16:52]
It applies to properties that are already
covered under the Emergency Tenant
[1:16:58]
Protection Act. So in the village,
[1:17:01]
there are 5 properties that are covered
under that program.
[1:17:05]
And though the existing village code
already has a provision, it's Chapter
[1:17:11]
already has a provision, it's Chapter
204-30B,
[1:17:12]
that provides for the automatic adjustment
of the limits based on the action of the
[1:17:18]
state legislature. So this is really just
housekeeping item to, um, update our, uh,
[1:17:25]
code so that if people do look at it, they
know what the actual limits are.
[1:17:30]
Sorry.
[1:17:31]
Yep. Very good.
[1:17:33]
Thank you.
[1:17:33]
Thank you.
[1:17:34]
All in favor?
[1:17:35]
Aye.
[1:17:37]
All right, uh, the public hearing on Local
Law Number
[1:17:43]
11 of 2026 is open. Anyone wishing to
speak,
[1:17:48]
this is your opportunity.
[1:17:51]
Okay, seeing no one wishing to speak,
[1:17:55]
do I have a motion to close the public
hearing?
[1:18:01]
So moved.
[1:18:02]
Uh, motion by Trustee Nicholson. Do I have
a second?
[1:18:05]
Second.
[1:18:07]
Uh, second by Trustee Simon. All in favor?
[1:18:09]
Aye.
[1:18:09]
Aye.
[1:18:15]
Whereas the New York State budget for
2026-2027 included legislation that
[1:18:19]
2026-2027 included legislation that
increased
[1:18:19]
the income limits for the Senior Citizen
Rental Income Exemption and Disabled
[1:18:24]
Persons Rental Income Exemption programs
from $50,000 to $75,000,
[1:18:27]
and whereas these changes were discussed
at a work session held on July 22nd, 2026,
[1:18:32]
and whereas Local Law Introductory Number
11 of 2026 has been drafted to increase
[1:18:36]
the statutory limits in the Village Code,
[1:18:38]
and whereas the public hearing was opened
and closed on September 2nd, 2026,
[1:18:42]
Now therefore be it resolved that the
Village Board of Trustees hereby adopts
[1:18:46]
Village Board of Trustees hereby adopts
Local
[1:18:47]
Law Introductory Number 11 of 2026 to
amend Chapter 204, Taxation,
[1:18:50]
of the Village Code to update the limits
for the Senior Citizen Rental Income
[1:18:54]
Exemption and Disabled Persons Rental
Income Exemption programs,
[1:18:58]
which upon adoption becomes Local Law
Number 10 of 2026.
[1:19:01]
Do I have a motion? So moved.
[1:19:05]
Second.
[1:19:06]
Motion by Trustee Simon, second by Trustee
Nicholson. Discussion?
[1:19:11]
Just a point that, you know, when we
talked about this at the work session,
[1:19:15]
I think we asked the question of any— if
any renters has taken advantage of this,
[1:19:20]
um, and the answer was no. So I think with
the, um, change— is that right?
[1:19:24]
No, there are— we do have— there's,
there's, I believe,
[1:19:28]
2 people from Barry Manor that, that have
taken— that, that are,
[1:19:31]
that are currently receiving it. Yeah,
qualifying or receiving. Correct. Yeah.
[1:19:36]
Okay, I just want to, you know, this is a
significant increase, so, um, there,
[1:19:40]
there may be more people that are
eligible.
[1:19:42]
So just getting the word out that this is
something that people can take advantage
[1:19:47]
of, um, would be great.
[1:19:48]
And should we adopt it, I think we likely
will,
[1:19:51]
we'll start with the seniors meeting on
Friday and brief them on that.
[1:19:55]
And hopefully if there are folks that can
make this applicable to them, great.
[1:20:00]
If not, if they can be telling some of
their friends Yeah,
[1:20:04]
I think we had discussed at the work
session, it's a,
[1:20:07]
it's a relatively small number.
[1:20:09]
I, I forget, I think it's about 130 units
total that are covered.
[1:20:13]
So it's, it's feasible to just send a
mailing directly to those.
[1:20:17]
That'd be great.
[1:20:18]
Yeah, to those people. So yeah, we'll
just, we'll pull something together.
[1:20:21]
There's probably stuff on online on the
state website that we can,
[1:20:25]
that we could send.
[1:20:26]
That'd be great. Very good.
[1:20:27]
Yep.
[1:20:29]
Further discussion? All in favor?
[1:20:32]
Aye.
[1:20:33]
Fantastic. Thank you.
[1:20:34]
All right, we proceed to Local Law, uh,
[1:20:37]
Intro Number 12 of 2026 to amend Chapter
197, Streets and Sidewalks, uh,
[1:20:42]
to update the list of sidewalks exempt
from the duty to clear or make safe.
[1:20:47]
Do I have a motion?
[1:20:49]
So moved.
[1:20:51]
Second.
[1:20:52]
Uh, Motion by Trustee Nocktally, second by
Trustee Simon.
[1:20:56]
That's fine.
[1:20:56]
Discussion?
[1:20:58]
So, um, this local law came out of a work
session that was held in June where we
[1:21:04]
discussed, uh, the impacts and the, uh,
requested, uh,
[1:21:08]
changes from the winter of 2025-2026,
right?
[1:21:12]
So, uh, we had multiple large snowstorms
Right, which taxed our DPW.
[1:21:17]
And, uh, you know, after meeting with them
to do a recap of the,
[1:21:22]
of the winter season, we went through the
sidewalk list that, um, you know,
[1:21:28]
the list of sidewalks that are maintained
by the DPW.
[1:21:32]
And so we made a number of adjustments,
um, or recommended a number of
[1:21:38]
um, or recommended a number of
adjustments,
[1:21:39]
made a number of adjustments for those
areas that, that we could.
[1:21:44]
Um, and in this law specifically, what we
are looking to do is, um,
[1:21:49]
remove a portion of the sidewalk on Old
Post Road South, basically across—
[1:21:55]
I'm sorry, Rachel, can you scroll up to
the— up? Yeah, sorry. Yeah, thank you.
[1:22:01]
So we're looking to remove a section of
the sidewalk, um,
[1:22:06]
on Old Post Road South as well as the tiny
section of sidewalk on Radnor from the
[1:22:12]
law. The sidewalk on Radnor is adjacent to
village-owned property,
[1:22:18]
so we have to maintain that regardless, so
it doesn't need to be listed in the law.
[1:22:24]
And then there are 2 parcels on Old Post
Road South that, you know,
[1:22:30]
front onto Old Post Road South,
[1:22:32]
and so there's no reason why the village
needs to be clearing those sidewalks.
[1:22:38]
Um, you know, most homeowners in the
village are responsible for,
[1:22:43]
for clearing their own sidewalks.
[1:22:46]
So, um, so we're asking to have the law
amended to address that.
[1:22:51]
And then secondly, if you want to scroll
to the next picture there, on Farrington,
[1:22:58]
there's 2 areas. Um, uh, one,
[1:23:00]
the southern side of Farrington involves
the property that is part of the Faribank
[1:23:06]
affordable condominiums at the end of Bank
Street.
[1:23:10]
There's no access from that property onto
the sidewalk on Farrington,
[1:23:16]
and it's a similar story for the homes
that have Palmer addresses that back down
[1:23:22]
onto Farrington. So at the last board
meeting—
[1:23:26]
this graphic is not updated from the last
board meeting, from the last work session—
[1:23:33]
Um, but the board did agree to extend, um,
[1:23:36]
the area that DPW will be responsible for
to include those 2 houses on Palmer.
[1:23:42]
And the law that's part of the backup
tonight reflects those, those changes.
[1:23:48]
Thank you.
[1:23:50]
Great, thank you.
[1:23:50]
Thank you. Okay, all in favor of the
public hearing?
[1:23:56]
Aye. All right.
[1:23:59]
The floor is open on Local Law 12 of 2026.
Hi.
[1:24:04]
Hi, Dave from Farrington Road.
[1:24:07]
My question is more so on the southern
side,
[1:24:11]
because the northern side has a wall.
[1:24:15]
But in the, in the winter, I understand
clearing.
[1:24:20]
But in the summer, after things have grown
weeds, ivy, sometimes poison ivy,
[1:24:27]
and you want to walk your dogs up and down
the street?
[1:24:33]
Is that also included in this bill?
[1:24:37]
Because it basically overgrows the
sidewalk. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
[1:24:45]
So this law only covers snow and ice
removal.
[1:24:49]
So during the other times of the year,
[1:24:52]
the property owners are still responsible
for maintaining vegetation.
[1:25:01]
So— And if that is not happening, how
would a resident who's experiencing an
[1:25:05]
would a resident who's experiencing an
issue—
[1:25:06]
what's the course of action for that
person?
[1:25:08]
Contact the engineering department and
code enforcement will inspect it.
[1:25:12]
Thank you.
[1:25:13]
Yep.
[1:25:16]
All right. Anyone else wishing to comment
on Local Law 12-2026?
[1:25:20]
All right, seeing no one else wishing to
comment, uh,
[1:25:24]
do I have a motion to close the public
hearing?
[1:25:27]
So moved.
[1:25:29]
Second.
[1:25:30]
Motion by Trustee Nicholson, second by
Trustee Simon. All in favor?
[1:25:34]
Aye.
[1:25:35]
Okay, whereas the Village Code requires
that property owners clear their sidewalks
[1:25:39]
of snow and ice within 12 hours after the
end of a snow event,
[1:25:42]
And whereas the Village Code also provides
an exemption for certain areas where
[1:25:46]
geographical limitations put an undue
burden on the property owner.
[1:25:50]
And whereas following the winter of
2025-2026,
[1:25:52]
the Village Manager and Department of
Public Works reviewed the list of existing
[1:25:56]
exemptions and requests for new exemptions
and developed proposed changes.
[1:26:00]
And whereas these changes were discussed
at a work session held on June 24th, 2026.
[1:26:04]
And whereas Local Law Introductory Number
12 of 2026 has been drafted to reflect
[1:26:09]
these changes. And whereas a public
hearing was opened and closed on September
[1:26:13]
hearing was opened and closed on September
2nd,
[1:26:13]
2026, now therefore be it resolved that
the Village Board of Trustees hereby
[1:26:17]
the Village Board of Trustees hereby
adopts
[1:26:17]
Local Law Introductory Number 12 of 2026
to amend Chapter 197,
[1:26:20]
Streets and Sidewalks,
[1:26:22]
of the Village Code to update the list of
sidewalks exempt from the duty to clear or
[1:26:26]
make safe, which upon adoption becomes
Local Law Number 11 of 2026.
[1:26:30]
Do I have a motion?
[1:26:32]
So moved. Second.
[1:26:35]
Motion by Trustee Nicholson, second by
Trustee Simon. Discussion?
[1:26:41]
All right, all in favor? Aye.
[1:26:44]
All right, we proceed to responses to
questions submitted via email.
[1:26:50]
No questions, Mayor.
[1:26:51]
All right, very good. We proceed to public
comment on agenda items.
[1:26:57]
Anyone wishing to comment on any agenda
item, this is your opportunity.
[1:27:02]
Ed Riley from Truesdale Drive.
[1:27:05]
First comment is that in spite of my
pleas, you cannot read your agenda.
[1:27:10]
We can see your maps sometimes, most of
the time, but we can't read your agenda.
[1:27:17]
And you need either new screens or you
need larger typeface.
[1:27:22]
So you can talk about something, show it
up here, and nobody can read it.
[1:27:27]
Thank you.
[1:27:28]
Except maybe I sit in here. Just a general
comment.
[1:27:31]
Um, you know, after I— in terms of pigeons
or anything else, dogs, whatever, bats,
[1:27:37]
whatever you keep, whatever kind of pet
you keep,
[1:27:40]
listening to the last gentleman speak, if,
if I had a neighbor who let his dog,
[1:27:46]
you name the pet, wander into my yard and
mess up my yard on a repeated basis,
[1:27:51]
so it's filth and inconvenient for me just
to walk into my door,
[1:27:56]
I would be over at my neighbor's house
apologizing profusely the next day.
[1:28:01]
And some of the people on this board have
done this for me.
[1:28:05]
I would be right there the next day
apologizing, you know, my birds, my dog,
[1:28:10]
what can I do? Now, maybe you have a crazy
dog,
[1:28:14]
and so once every 3 months the dog gets
out and does the same thing,
[1:28:18]
eats your daisies. But if that happens
like 2 or 3, 4 times,
[1:28:23]
it's time to deal with it with the dog.
[1:28:25]
And maybe it's time the village starts
issuing some summonses, you know?
[1:28:30]
Right.
[1:28:31]
So, so if that's the case that's
happening, if I were the pigeon owner,
[1:28:37]
happening, if I were the pigeon owner,
one,
[1:28:37]
when you talk to him and sympathetically,
yeah,
[1:28:41]
I know your father was in his business,
[1:28:44]
get your ass over the neighbor's house and
start apologizing to your neighbor.
[1:28:50]
That's the first thing, the rule of
neighborliness.
[1:28:54]
So, and I think you should take that into
consideration.
[1:28:58]
My stance, I'm very sympathetic with the
gentleman.
[1:29:02]
He's got a history of doing these things,
raising.
[1:29:06]
But if he can't guarantee, you know, he
can't, you know,
[1:29:11]
reach minimum standards of not polluting
the area, you know, he's got a problem.
[1:29:17]
Maybe he ought to go in a different sport
or sell his pigeons.
[1:29:22]
Um, you know, that's tough love, I guess.
I'd like to comment on item 3.
[1:29:27]
The, the firemen in Ash— volunteer
firemen— I just can't say enough about
[1:29:33]
firemen— I just can't say enough about
them.
[1:29:34]
You really need better medals and campaign
ribbons and whatever it is for them.
[1:29:40]
Um, the number of events that they respond
to in a year,
[1:29:44]
given by some of the awards you've given
these first responders in the past.
[1:29:50]
It's just mind-boggling.
[1:29:52]
That's why people don't join stuff
because, oh,
[1:29:56]
I got to go to a meeting once a month.
[1:29:59]
These guys go out there like 30 times a
month.
[1:30:02]
So my hat's off to Spada and everybody in
this fire department, past and present.
[1:30:09]
They're really heroic people and really
self-sacrificing people.
[1:30:14]
And it goes for their family.
[1:30:16]
Because they get ripped away from family
events with their children.
[1:30:21]
And so it's a— it's like being in the
service. It's really a sacrifice.
[1:30:27]
And my hat's off to them.
[1:30:29]
So the— I want my— I was attracted to
Resolution B, Item 2, Emergency Health
[1:30:35]
Resolution B, Item 2, Emergency Health
Plan,
[1:30:35]
which brings us back to some of the
commentary on national and state level.
[1:30:41]
We know that the national health plan for
the state of New York and the federal
[1:30:47]
government under the CDC, National
Institutes of Health,
[1:30:52]
and so forth was a disaster with COVID And
thankfully, for the most part,
[1:30:58]
this village did not implement draconian
measures when this health crisis came up.
[1:31:04]
But there was some really outlandish crap,
[1:31:07]
and a lot of vendors and businesses
catered to their worst customers who are
[1:31:13]
catered to their worst customers who are
afraid
[1:31:14]
of dirt any day. They're still wearing
masks for that matter.
[1:31:19]
So, and the terrible,
[1:31:20]
the terrible health advice from the
highest health department authorities in
[1:31:26]
highest health department authorities in
the
[1:31:26]
state of New York to kill 13,000 to 15,000
people in our nursing homes.
[1:31:32]
When, by the way, 50% of the nursing home
in this state today can't pass a federal
[1:31:39]
or state inspection.
[1:31:40]
And they forced those people to stay in
those nursing homes, away from their—
[1:31:46]
and died without their friends and
relatives.
[1:31:50]
And then denied where it came from,
censored everybody,
[1:31:54]
and then prevented them from using drugs
that could have, if administered early,
[1:32:00]
could have prevented serious illness.
COVID complications for those individuals.
[1:32:07]
What a disgraceful history.
[1:32:09]
So that's the atmosphere of distrust that
you're proposing for health emergency
[1:32:15]
plans, and please keep that in mind. Thank
you. Thank you. Thank you.
[1:32:20]
Does anyone else wish to comment on any
agenda items?
[1:32:25]
All right, seeing no one else wishing to
comment,
[1:32:28]
we proceed to the report from the village
manager.
[1:32:32]
Okay, thank you, Mayor. Okay, so, uh, just
some quick updates on things.
[1:32:40]
The DPW today was working on Old Post Road
South.
[1:32:44]
This is going to be the start of what I
hope will be a nice beautification
[1:32:52]
project in the Upper Village.
[1:32:55]
They replaced the stamped concrete,
[1:32:58]
which is more colloquially known as the
fake brick,
[1:33:03]
in the Upper Village between Maple Street
street and the entrance to the
[1:33:10]
Merwin Oak parking lot. So it had crumbled
over time.
[1:33:16]
And so this is the first in basically a
maintenance project.
[1:33:22]
So they had no sooner gotten the final
stamp done than the skies opened
[1:33:29]
up. And, you know, thanks to Scott and his
crew for getting everything
[1:33:36]
covered quickly.
[1:33:37]
The tarp.
[1:33:38]
Yeah, and get— and getting it, getting it
done. So they did it.
[1:33:43]
They did a great job today, as, as usual.
[1:33:46]
Um, also, I wanted to thank, um, give a
really big thank you to, um, Ben Ling, um,
[1:33:53]
who is a Croton resident and a grad
student.
[1:33:56]
And he has been, uh, volunteering with the
engineering department all summer,
[1:34:02]
basically, to help, uh, digitize a lot of
their old plans as part of the, you know,
[1:34:08]
renovation and reorganization of that
office.
[1:34:12]
It was thought to try to get as much of
the records as we could digitized and then
[1:34:18]
hopefully save on some of the space.
[1:34:21]
And so there is a closet full of maps and
plans from, you know,
[1:34:26]
eons ago that have just been kept in paper
format.
[1:34:30]
And so, you know, we have now digitized
all of, all of those, hundreds of them.
[1:34:36]
And so, you know, now we'll be deciding if
we need to keep the originals or if we
[1:34:42]
can now dispose of those,
[1:34:44]
or maybe there might be some that the
Historical Society may want or something
[1:34:50]
Historical Society may want or something
like
[1:34:50]
that. But just— Ben was a big help. His
last day was last Thursday.
[1:34:55]
before school started again.
[1:34:57]
And so just really wanted to thank him for
all his efforts this summer.
[1:35:03]
And then speaking of the engineering
office,
[1:35:06]
they will be closed to the public on
Friday.
[1:35:10]
We'll send out an email tomorrow just
letting everyone know,
[1:35:14]
as the office staff is going to be moving
from their current office to the new
[1:35:20]
section of the office that has been
renovated this summer.
[1:35:25]
So they're going to be moving on Friday,
[1:35:28]
and then they'll reopen Tuesday in their
new spot,
[1:35:32]
and then DPW is going to start work on
the—
[1:35:35]
their old spot that they're in right now.
[1:35:38]
Um, Monday we're closed for the Labor Day
holiday,
[1:35:42]
as I'm sure most people will know.
[1:35:44]
Garbage pickup will be a day late for
those who normally get it on Monday,
[1:35:50]
and our summer office hours are coming to
an end this Friday.
[1:35:55]
We will be back to our regular 8:30 to
4:00 Monday through Friday next week.
[1:36:01]
So let's see, I'm sure the mayor and/or
Trustee Simon will have more to say about
[1:36:07]
New York Forward and their reports, but we
do have a meeting tomorrow night,
[1:36:13]
so hopefully people will be able to come.
[1:36:16]
Also, the Farrington Steps, I'm sure, will
be talked about,
[1:36:20]
but they are now reopened. after a nice
ribbon cutting yesterday— or sorry,
[1:36:26]
ribbon cutting yesterday— or sorry,
Monday.
[1:36:27]
Our retaining wall out around this—
[1:36:29]
around the municipal building on Brook
Street and Old Post Road North,
[1:36:35]
they're going— our contractor is going to
start work on that project hopefully next
[1:36:41]
week, weather permitting.
[1:36:43]
As anyone who has walked around the
building knows,
[1:36:47]
there are some areas that are in need of
some attention.
[1:36:51]
Some of the plaster has fallen off, you
know,
[1:36:55]
so we're going to get those repairs done
and have the wall repainted.
[1:37:00]
Yeah, so just based on where they're
working and the time of day,
[1:37:05]
there may be some temporary sidewalk
closures, so just be cognizant of that.
[1:37:11]
And then I wrote this on the top.
[1:37:13]
I don't know if I— we issued 4 leaf blower
violations between—
[1:37:18]
from the last meeting until yesterday.
[1:37:21]
Yesterday, the ban, the seasonal ban, is
over as of yesterday.
[1:37:26]
So those would be the— those 4 are the
last that were issued.
[1:37:31]
So I will— I'll have a final report at the
next meeting of exactly how many
[1:37:36]
violations there were and what the outcome
of those were. And that is it.
[1:37:42]
Thank you.
[1:37:43]
Any questions?
[1:37:44]
Thank you.
[1:37:45]
Thank you, Manager.
[1:37:46]
You're welcome.
[1:37:47]
All right, we proceed to the consent
agenda.
[1:37:51]
Do I have a motion on the consent agenda?
[1:37:54]
So moved.
[1:37:55]
Second.
[1:37:56]
Motion by Trustee Simon, second by Trustee
Nicholson. Discussion?
[1:38:01]
Manager, since it was brought up in the
public comment,
[1:38:05]
would you like to briefly summarize at a
very high level some of the changes to
[1:38:12]
the Village's emergency health plan?
[1:38:14]
Sure. So the plan was last updated in
2023.
[1:38:18]
Since that time, there has been some
revised guidance specifically from the CDC
[1:38:24]
about how infectious diseases and
communicable diseases should be handled.
[1:38:31]
So there is a redlined version that is on
the website as part of the agenda so that
[1:38:37]
if there are people at home who are
interested, you can look and see.
[1:38:43]
But it generally updates some of the
language that's in here.
[1:38:48]
In 2023, we were just exiting the
pandemic, right?
[1:38:52]
I mean, it was pretty much coming to an
end at that point.
[1:38:57]
But there was some language here, right?
[1:39:00]
Like, you know, in the planning
assumptions, which is on page 5,
[1:39:05]
it talks about the current coronavirus
pandemic.
[1:39:09]
So we were just— we just changed a lot of
the language to reflect the fact that,
[1:39:16]
you know, there was a pandemic in 2020
and, you know,
[1:39:20]
some of the guidance has changed.
[1:39:23]
There were also— the plan is specific to
the village, right?
[1:39:28]
So each municipality has to have a plan
that's specific to them.
[1:39:33]
So we have titles that are identified as
essential.
[1:39:37]
Those, those specific employees have tasks
that are assigned to them.
[1:39:43]
So as the needs of the village change in
terms of staffing and what goes on, we—
[1:39:50]
the plan should be updated accordingly.
[1:39:53]
So, you know, for example,
[1:39:55]
the Treasurer's Office no longer has
senior account clerks.
[1:40:00]
They have new people in different titles,
so that's been updated to reflect that.
[1:40:07]
You know, just things that have changed in
the past 3 years that are new—
[1:40:17]
And Manager, I presume the employees have
been involved in the development of these
[1:40:22]
updates?
[1:40:22]
Yeah, so I work with the Village Clerk on
these updates as our human resources
[1:40:28]
contact, and then we are required by law
to share the proposed changes with our
[1:40:33]
unions. And, you know, the Teamsters wrote
back and said thank you,
[1:40:38]
they didn't have any concerns.
[1:40:40]
Um, I did not receive a response from the
Police Association.
[1:40:45]
Um, so, but, you know, we're just, we're
just required to notify them.
[1:40:50]
We don't have to, um, we don't have to do
anything further than that.
[1:40:55]
So, um, so that's been done.
[1:40:57]
Great. Thank you. Manager, um,
[1:40:59]
I know you had a very good explanation for
8, uh, item number 7.
[1:41:05]
The authorizing village manager to execute
an amendment to the license
[1:41:12]
agreement with the county for the running
of electrical wires over
[1:41:18]
village property. So I thought the, the
public might—
[1:41:22]
Sure.
[1:41:23]
Appreciate— Yeah, so the reason for that—
[1:41:27]
so the county came to us last year and
asked if we would be willing to entertain
[1:41:32]
allowing them to have Con Edison run an
electrical wire across our— the well
[1:41:38]
electrical wire across our— the well
fields,
[1:41:38]
um, to the caretaker's house in Croton
Gorge Park.
[1:41:42]
Um, you know, we have electrical poles
that are in the well fields, right,
[1:41:47]
to power the different things that we have
down there.
[1:41:51]
Um, it did require the addition of one new
pole, uh,
[1:41:55]
to basically bridge the area between our
property and the county property,
[1:42:00]
which the Yeah, the county had— they paid
to have it put up at their expense.
[1:42:05]
Um, and in agreement for allowing this,
the county assumed, uh,
[1:42:10]
50% responsibility for any future, uh,
costs associated with our private poles.
[1:42:16]
Um, so if there were— a tree came down and
damaged the pole,
[1:42:20]
or if it needed to be replaced for
whatever reason,
[1:42:23]
the county would now split those costs
with us.
[1:42:27]
Um, so I mean, the board already approved
the license agreement in 2025.
[1:42:32]
Um, the term of the agreement ends
September 30th of this year.
[1:42:36]
The county is asking for a 3-month
extension just to find—
[1:42:41]
they haven't been able to finalize the
paperwork, so they're, you know,
[1:42:46]
they need a couple more months to do that.
[1:42:49]
Thank you.
[1:42:50]
Yep. Further discussion? All in favor?
[1:42:58]
Aye.
[1:42:59]
All right, we proceed to proposed
resolutions.
[1:43:02]
First resolution is in the proposal for a
revised capital—
[1:43:07]
a revision to the capital plan for
'26-'31.
[1:43:10]
Thank you, Mayor. Whereas the Village
Board of Trustees adopted the 2026-2031
[1:43:15]
capital budget plan on April 22nd, 2026,
[1:43:17]
And whereas since that time it has been
necessary to add additional funding for
[1:43:22]
necessary to add additional funding for
the
[1:43:22]
Half Moon Bay Bridge and Brook Street
draining—
[1:43:25]
drainage project to the capital plan.
[1:43:27]
And whereas the revised capital plan
reduces the debt issuance for this current
[1:43:32]
fiscal year by $420,520, a 9% decrease.
[1:43:34]
And whereas this decrease has been made
possible due to an additional $1,715,000
[1:43:39]
possible due to an additional $1,715,000
in
[1:43:39]
grant funding for various projects.
[1:43:41]
Now therefore, be it resolved that the
Village Board of Trustees adopts the
[1:43:46]
Village Board of Trustees adopts the
revised
[1:43:46]
capital budget plan for the years 2026
through 2031.
[1:43:50]
Do I have a motion?
[1:43:53]
So moved.
[1:43:54]
Second.
[1:43:55]
Motion by Trustee Nicholson,
[1:43:58]
second by Trustee Simon. Discussion?
[1:44:02]
All in favor?
[1:44:03]
Good news. It's always good when it goes
in that direction.
[1:44:07]
Yeah, it's always good to have it.
[1:44:08]
Happy to reconsider any budget anytime we
get new revenues
[1:44:13]
there. Very good. Now the next few ones
won't be as easy.
[1:44:17]
No, unfortunately not.
[1:44:19]
Any more money coming?
[1:44:21]
No, we just, we have to readopt the
bottom.
[1:44:25]
This is a greatest hits, you know, kind of
thing.
[1:44:28]
So, um, just bear with me on this. I, I
think they did.
[1:44:34]
You did? Yep. So I'm only,
[1:44:36]
as long as the attorney agrees to this,
um,
[1:44:41]
I'm only going to read the abstract.
[1:44:44]
Thank you.
[1:44:45]
Okay, and then—
[1:44:46]
It isn't necessary because this is just a
readopting and a revision based upon,
[1:44:51]
and you can explain it.
[1:44:52]
Yeah, do the whole air conditioning one.
That was always my favorite.
[1:44:56]
So I think we've been here long enough
already.
[1:44:59]
Okay, um, so Resolution 210, a resolution
authorizing,
[1:45:03]
subject to permissive referendum,
[1:45:05]
the upgrade of the air conditioning system
in the Department of Public Works garage
[1:45:10]
for the Village of Croton-on-Hudson,
Westchester County, New York,
[1:45:14]
at a maximum estimated cost of $117,875,
[1:45:17]
and authorizing the issuance of $117,875
serial bonds of said village to pay the
[1:45:22]
cost thereof.
[1:45:23]
Do I have a motion? So moved.
[1:45:26]
Second.
[1:45:27]
Motion by Trustee Simon, second by Trustee
Nicholson. So we have to do a roll call.
[1:45:32]
Yep.
[1:45:32]
Votes for these. So Trustee Slippen.
[1:45:34]
Aye.
[1:45:34]
Trustee Knacktaler?
[1:45:35]
Aye.
[1:45:35]
Trustee Nicholson?
[1:45:36]
Aye.
[1:45:37]
Trustee Simon?
[1:45:37]
Aye.
[1:45:38]
Mayor Fio?
[1:45:38]
Aye.
[1:45:41]
Resolution 211, a resolution authorizing,
subject to permissive referendum,
[1:45:47]
the Brook Street Drainage Project in and
for the Village of Croton-on-Hudson,
[1:45:52]
Westchester County, New York, at a maximum
estimated cost of $1,519,525,
[1:45:57]
and authorizing the issuance of $1,519,525
serial bonds of said village to pay the
[1:46:03]
costs thereof.
[1:46:04]
May I have a motion? So moved.
[1:46:07]
Second.
[1:46:07]
Motion by Trustee Simon, second by Trustee
Nicholson.
[1:46:12]
Trustee Sullivan?
[1:46:12]
Aye.
[1:46:13]
Trustee Nochteller?
[1:46:13]
Aye.
[1:46:14]
Trustee Nicholson?
[1:46:15]
Aye.
[1:46:15]
Trustee Simon?
[1:46:16]
Aye.
[1:46:16]
Mayor Pio?
[1:46:17]
Aye.
[1:46:18]
Resolution 212, a resolution authorizing,
subject to permissive referendum,
[1:46:23]
the issuance of $92,250 bonds of the
Village of Cortlandt-on-the-Hudson,
[1:46:26]
Westchester County, New York,
[1:46:28]
to pay the cost of the purchase of a
command car replacement for the fire
[1:46:32]
command car replacement for the fire
department
[1:46:33]
in Enforced Village.
[1:46:34]
Do I have a motion? So moved.
[1:46:37]
Second.
[1:46:38]
Motion by Trustee Simon, second by Trustee
Nicholson.
[1:46:40]
Trustee Slobin?
[1:46:42]
Aye.
[1:46:42]
Trustee Knoktoller?
[1:46:43]
Aye.
[1:46:43]
Trustee Nicholson?
[1:46:44]
Aye.
[1:46:44]
Trustee Simon?
[1:46:45]
Aye.
[1:46:45]
Mayor Pugh?
[1:46:46]
Aye.
[1:46:46]
Bond Resolution 213, a resolution
authorizing, subject to permissive
[1:46:51]
authorizing, subject to permissive
referendum,
[1:46:52]
the purchase of police communication and
tech equipment for the Village of
[1:46:57]
Croton-on-Hudson, Westchester County, New
York,
[1:47:00]
and a maximum estimated cost of $512—
sorry, $712,623,
[1:47:04]
and authorizing the issuance of $712,623
serial bonds of said village to pay the
[1:47:09]
cost thereof.
[1:47:10]
Do I have a motion?
[1:47:12]
So moved.
[1:47:14]
Second.
[1:47:15]
Motion by Trustee Nicholson, second by
Trustee Simon. Discussion?
[1:47:19]
Or rather, uh, Vote. Yeah, let's go.
[1:47:22]
Trustee Sullivan?
[1:47:23]
Aye.
[1:47:23]
Trustee Nochtaler?
[1:47:24]
Aye.
[1:47:24]
Trustee Nicholson?
[1:47:25]
Aye.
[1:47:25]
Trustee Simon?
[1:47:26]
Aye.
[1:47:26]
Mayor Pugh?
[1:47:27]
Aye.
[1:47:27]
Bond Resolution 214, a resolution
authorizing, subject to permissive
[1:47:32]
authorizing, subject to permissive
referendum,
[1:47:32]
improvements to fire stations in and for
the Village of Cortlandt Hudson,
[1:47:37]
Westchester County, New York, at a maximum
estimated cost of $558,113,
[1:47:42]
and authorizing the issuance of $558,113
serial bonds of said village to pay the
[1:47:47]
cost thereof.
[1:47:48]
Do I have a motion? So moved.
[1:47:51]
Second.
[1:47:51]
Motion by Trustee Simon, second by Trustee
Nicholson.
[1:47:54]
Trustee Slippen?
[1:47:55]
Aye.
[1:47:56]
Trustee Nachdahl?
[1:47:56]
Aye.
[1:47:56]
Trustee Nicholson?
[1:47:57]
Aye.
[1:47:57]
Trustee Simon?
[1:47:58]
Aye.
[1:47:59]
Mary Pio?
[1:47:59]
Aye.
[1:47:59]
Bond Resolution 215, a resolution
authorizing, subject to permissive
[1:48:04]
authorizing, subject to permissive
referendum,
[1:48:04]
the issuance of $128,125 bonds of the
Village of Cortlandt Hudson,
[1:48:09]
Westchester County, New York,
[1:48:11]
to pay the cost of the reconstruction of
the Farrington Road steps Do I have a
[1:48:16]
motion?
[1:48:16]
So moved.
[1:48:17]
Second.
[1:48:18]
Motion by Trustee Nicholson, second by
Trustee Simon.
[1:48:21]
Trustee Slippin?
[1:48:23]
Aye.
[1:48:23]
Trustee Nochteller?
[1:48:24]
Aye.
[1:48:24]
Trustee Nicholson?
[1:48:25]
Aye.
[1:48:25]
Trustee Simon?
[1:48:26]
Aye.
[1:48:26]
Mayor Pugh?
[1:48:27]
Aye.
[1:48:27]
Bond Resolution 216, a resolution
authorizing, subject to permissive
[1:48:31]
authorizing, subject to permissive
referendum,
[1:48:32]
the purchase of a firefighting vehicle,
equipment,
[1:48:35]
and apparatus for the Village of
Cortlandt, Hudson, Westchester County, New
[1:48:40]
Cortlandt, Hudson, Westchester County, New
York,
[1:48:40]
at a maximum estimated cost of $219,350
and authorizing the issuance of $219,350
[1:48:45]
serial bonds of said village to pay the
cost thereof.
[1:48:48]
Do I have a motion?
[1:48:50]
So moved. Second.
[1:48:52]
Motion by Trustee Simon, second by Trustee
Nicholson.
[1:48:55]
Trustee Slubin?
[1:48:57]
Aye.
[1:48:58]
Trustee Knoktaler?
[1:48:59]
Aye.
[1:48:59]
Trustee Nicholson?
[1:49:00]
Aye. Trustee Simon? Aye.
[1:49:01]
Mayor Piehl?
[1:49:02]
Aye.
[1:49:04]
Upon Resolution 217, a resolution
authorizing, subject to permissive
[1:49:08]
authorizing, subject to permissive
referendum,
[1:49:08]
municipal building improvements for the
engineering department office for the
[1:49:12]
Village of Cortlandt-Hudson, Westchester
County, New York,
[1:49:15]
at a maximum estimated cost of $84,050,
[1:49:17]
and authorizing the issuance of $84,050
serial bonds of said village to pay the
[1:49:21]
serial bonds of said village to pay the
cost
[1:49:21]
thereof.
[1:49:21]
Do I have a motion?
[1:49:23]
So moved.
[1:49:24]
Second. Motion by Trustee Nicholson,
second by Trustee Simon.
[1:49:29]
Trustee Slippen?
[1:49:30]
Aye.
[1:49:31]
Trustee Nochteller?
[1:49:31]
Aye.
[1:49:32]
Trustee Nicholson?
[1:49:32]
Aye.
[1:49:33]
Trustee Simon?
[1:49:33]
Aye.
[1:49:34]
Mayor Pugh?
[1:49:34]
Aye.
[1:49:36]
Bond Resolution 218, a resolution
authorizing, subject to permissive
[1:49:40]
authorizing, subject to permissive
referendum,
[1:49:41]
improvements to park security in and for
the Village of Cortlandt-Hudson,
[1:49:45]
Westchester County, New York, at a maximum
estimated cost of $101,250,
[1:49:49]
and authorizing the issuance of $51,250
serial bonds of said village to pay part
[1:49:54]
serial bonds of said village to pay part
of
[1:49:54]
the cost thereof.
[1:49:55]
Do I have a motion?
[1:49:57]
So moved. Second.
[1:50:01]
Motion by Trustee Nicholson, second by
Trustee Simon.
[1:50:04]
Trustee Slibban?
[1:50:05]
Aye.
[1:50:05]
Trustee Knackteller?
[1:50:05]
Aye.
[1:50:06]
Trustee Nicholson?
[1:50:06]
Aye.
[1:50:07]
Trustee Simon?
[1:50:07]
Aye.
[1:50:08]
Mayor Pio?
[1:50:08]
Aye.
[1:50:10]
On Resolution 219, a resolution
authorizing, subject to permissive
[1:50:13]
authorizing, subject to permissive
referendum,
[1:50:14]
the purchase of Department of Public Works
equipment for the Village of
[1:50:18]
Cortlandt-Hudson, Westchester County, New
York,
[1:50:21]
at a maximum estimated cost of $492,000,
[1:50:23]
and authorizing the issuance of $492,000
serial bonds of said village to pay the
[1:50:27]
cost thereof.
[1:50:29]
Do I have a motion? So moved.
[1:50:30]
Second.
[1:50:32]
Motion by Trustee Nicholson, second by
Trustee Simon.
[1:50:35]
Trustee Slibban?
[1:50:36]
Aye.
[1:50:37]
Trustee Knopfeller?
[1:50:37]
Aye.
[1:50:38]
Trustee Nicholson?
[1:50:38]
Aye.
[1:50:39]
Trustee Simon?
[1:50:40]
Aye.
[1:50:40]
Mayor Pugh?
[1:50:41]
Aye.
[1:50:41]
On Resolution 220, a resolution
authorizing, subject to permissive
[1:50:45]
authorizing, subject to permissive
referendum,
[1:50:46]
the reconstruction of roads throughout and
in and for the village of
[1:50:50]
Cornell-on-Hudson, Westchester County, New
York,
[1:50:53]
at a maximum estimated cost of $857,500,
[1:50:55]
and authorizing the issuance of $857,500
serial bonds of said village to pay the
[1:51:00]
cost thereof.
[1:51:01]
Do I have a motion?
[1:51:02]
So moved.
[1:51:04]
Second.
[1:51:04]
Motion by Trustee Nicholson, second by
Trustee Simon.
[1:51:07]
Trustee Slippen?
[1:51:09]
Aye.
[1:51:09]
Trustee Knacktaler?
[1:51:10]
Aye.
[1:51:10]
Trustee Nicholson?
[1:51:11]
Aye.
[1:51:11]
Trustee Simon?
[1:51:12]
Aye.
[1:51:12]
Mayor Piehl?
[1:51:13]
Aye.
[1:51:13]
Bond Resolution 221, a resolution
authorizing, subject to permissive
[1:51:17]
authorizing, subject to permissive
referendum,
[1:51:18]
construction of sidewalk improvements at
Municipal Place and South Riverside,
[1:51:23]
and pedestrian and safety improvements in
and for the Village of Cortlandt Hudson,
[1:51:28]
Westchester County, New York, at a maximum
estimated cost of $779,246,
[1:51:32]
and authorizing the issuance of $779,246
serial bonds of said village to pay the
[1:51:37]
cost thereof.
[1:51:38]
Do I have a motion?
[1:51:40]
So moved.
[1:51:40]
Second? Motion by Trustee Nicholson,
second by Trustee Simon. Trustee Slubin?
[1:51:45]
Aye.
[1:51:46]
Trustee Knacktaler?
[1:51:47]
Aye.
[1:51:47]
Trustee Nicholson?
[1:51:48]
Aye.
[1:51:48]
Trustee Simon?
[1:51:49]
Aye.
[1:51:49]
Mayor Pugh?
[1:51:50]
Aye.
[1:51:50]
Last one, Bond Resolution 222, a
resolution authorizing,
[1:51:54]
subject to permissive referendum,
[1:51:56]
construction of traffic safety
improvements in and for the Village of
[1:52:00]
Cortlandt-on-Hudson, Westchester County,
New York,
[1:52:03]
at a maximum estimated cost of $138,375,
[1:52:05]
and authorizing the issuance of $138,375
serial bonds of said village to pay the
[1:52:10]
cost thereof.
[1:52:11]
Do I have a motion?
[1:52:12]
So moved.
[1:52:13]
Second?
[1:52:15]
Motion by, uh, Trustee Nicholson, second
by Trustee Simon.
[1:52:18]
Trustee Slippin?
[1:52:19]
Aye.
[1:52:19]
Trustee Knacktaler?
[1:52:20]
Aye.
[1:52:20]
Trustee Nicholson?
[1:52:21]
Aye.
[1:52:21]
Trustee Simon?
[1:52:22]
Aye.
[1:52:23]
Mayor Pugh?
[1:52:23]
Aye.
[1:52:24]
Okay, moving right along.
[1:52:26]
All right, uh, next is Resolution C
concerning, uh, a bid award.
[1:52:33]
Whereas the Village issued an invitation
to bid on July 23rd,
[1:52:36]
2026 for maintenance services on the
Village's various HVAC equipment,
[1:52:40]
and whereas 3 bids were submitted by the
deadline of August 13th, 2026,
[1:52:43]
whereas the lowest bid received was from
HVAC Now, Inc.
[1:52:46]
of Poughkeepsie, New York, in the amount
of $49,375, whereas Frank Balbi,
[1:52:50]
Superintendent of Public Works, has
recommended moving forward with the low
[1:52:53]
recommended moving forward with the low
bidder.
[1:52:54]
Now therefore be it resolved that the
Village Manager is hereby authorized to
[1:52:57]
Village Manager is hereby authorized to
award
[1:52:58]
bid number 8 of 2026 to HVAC Now, Inc.
[1:53:00]
of Poughkeepsie, New York, in the amount
of $49,375.
[1:53:02]
Do I have a motion?
[1:53:06]
So moved. Second.
[1:53:08]
Motion by Trustee Nicholson, second by
Trustee Simon.
[1:53:12]
Oh, we're not doing the— No, this is not
discussion.
[1:53:16]
Discussion. Regular order.
[1:53:18]
We're not doing the roll call anymore.
[1:53:20]
No.
[1:53:20]
Well, I appreciate the superintendent, you
know,
[1:53:23]
working hard to get a range of bids and—
[1:53:26]
There was a range, yes.
[1:53:27]
Yeah.
[1:53:28]
Yeah.
[1:53:28]
It was an incredible range.
[1:53:30]
It's just, you wonder, you know, about
some of the higher ones.
[1:53:33]
Yeah.
[1:53:35]
It is what it is. We got the right one.
[1:53:36]
Yeah, this is a, this is a good example.
[1:53:40]
This is a service that we haven't really
had to bid before, but in recent years,
[1:53:46]
as the cost of things have continued to
increase and the state has not taken any
[1:53:53]
action to increase the bid limits in the
law,
[1:53:56]
things that used to cost $25,000 or
$30,000 and we didn't have to bid are now
[1:54:03]
costing $40,000 or $50,000 and now are
subject to bidding.
[1:54:08]
So it's just more work for us, more bids
that we have to do, unfortunately,
[1:54:14]
because of what the law is. So.
[1:54:16]
I remember raising the bid thresholds was
an ICOM legislative
[1:54:22]
priority over a decade ago. They're still
where they were.
[1:54:28]
Yeah.
[1:54:28]
Yep.
[1:54:31]
Okay, all in favor?
[1:54:32]
Aye.
[1:54:32]
Aye.
[1:54:33]
Whereas the village issued an invitation
to bid on August 6th,
[1:54:37]
2026 for the annual street resurfacing
program,
[1:54:39]
and whereas 6 bids were submitted by the
deadline of August 27th, 2026,
[1:54:43]
whereas the lowest bid received was from
Louis Rinaldi Inc.
[1:54:47]
of Ossining, New York in the amount of
$790,900, whereas Frank Balbi,
[1:54:50]
Superintendent of Public Works, has
recommended moving forward with the low
[1:54:55]
recommended moving forward with the low
bidder.
[1:54:55]
Now therefore be it resolved that the
Village Manager is hereby authorized to
[1:54:59]
Village Manager is hereby authorized to
award
[1:55:00]
bid number 9 of 2026 to Louis Rinaldi,
Inc.
[1:55:02]
of Ossining, New York, in the amount of
$790,900.
[1:55:05]
Do I have a motion?
[1:55:07]
So moved. Second.
[1:55:08]
Motion by Trustee Nicholson, second by
Trustee Simon. Discussion?
[1:55:12]
Well, Mayor, it's, uh, I,
[1:55:13]
I think it's nice when the lowest bidder
is also the one that you've worked with in
[1:55:18]
the past and has a great reputation,
[1:55:20]
so Glad we'll be able to do some more of
that this year.
[1:55:23]
So we will have, um,
[1:55:24]
probably by the next meeting we'll have a
list of the areas that are being repaved.
[1:55:30]
So, um, you know, due to the board's
support for infrastructure improvements in
[1:55:36]
support for infrastructure improvements in
the
[1:55:37]
capital budget, uh, you know, we received—
[1:55:40]
we were able to include many more streets
than we have in the past.
[1:55:45]
So Um, you know, I think there'll be a lot
of areas that will see some attention
[1:55:51]
this year.
[1:55:52]
That's great.
[1:55:52]
Yep.
[1:55:53]
What's the time frame?
[1:55:55]
Uh, later this fall. I don't, I don't know
what the exact time frame is.
[1:55:59]
Um, you know, it's going to depend on what
other areas they are working in as well.
[1:56:03]
So, but we'll, like I said,
[1:56:05]
by the next meeting we should have an idea
of what the schedule is and what the
[1:56:09]
streets are.
[1:56:10]
Great. Yep.
[1:56:11]
Thank you.
[1:56:13]
Very good. Okay, all in favor?
[1:56:15]
Aye.
[1:56:16]
All right, we proceed to public comment on
non-agenda items.
[1:56:22]
Anyone wishing to comment on anything,
this is your opportunity.
[1:56:28]
Please state your name and address. 5
minutes a person.
[1:56:34]
Hi, Dave from Farrington Road.
[1:56:37]
I just want to say that this is number 10
for me in non-agenda.
[1:56:42]
Comments. Here we go again. Rabbit season.
[1:56:45]
Duck season?
[1:56:46]
No. Pollution season. Unnecessary hearing
damage season.
[1:56:51]
Clouds of unburned fossil fuels into my
open windows season.
[1:56:55]
I was going to give you another study and
more science about how toxic gas leaf
[1:57:01]
blowers are, but I think the case has been
made.
[1:57:05]
Like I said last time, Over and over and
for years.
[1:57:09]
So instead, just read the Sinai letter you
got last week. Mount Sinai.
[1:57:16]
This is not a popularity contest.
[1:57:19]
It's real people's health and well-being.
[1:57:22]
We are losing the war on cancer and
ignorance is the
[1:57:27]
main culprit.
[1:57:29]
Please stop poisoning us.
[1:57:32]
Bring us in line with other Westchester
and New Jersey towns that care about their
[1:57:37]
citizens' health.
[1:57:39]
Irvington, Larchmont, Mamaroneck, White
Plains,
[1:57:43]
and since I first came to talk to you last
year,
[1:57:46]
Dobbs Ferry and Rye have passed full-year
ordinances.
[1:57:50]
In New Jersey, there's Maplewood and
Montclair.
[1:57:53]
There's big towns, there's small towns.
[1:57:56]
Croton is No, has fallen behind.
[1:57:59]
You remember the bad air quality from last
month's wildfires?
[1:58:05]
That's PM2.5. That's nitrogen dioxide.
[1:58:09]
That's carbon monoxide, which mixes with
sunlight to create ground-level ozone.
[1:58:14]
And the village sends air quality warning
emails to residents.
[1:58:19]
But does the village put out warning
emails about dangerous air quality and
[1:58:23]
literally deafening sound levels?
[1:58:25]
No.
[1:58:26]
while gasoline-powered leaf blowers are
allowed?
[1:58:29]
Because it's the same stuff.
[1:58:32]
This is an easy fix, but you have to value
public health.
[1:58:37]
So do you?
[1:58:39]
It's time for a change. Thanks.
[1:58:41]
Thank you.
[1:58:58]
Ed Riley from Truesdale Drive.
[1:59:00]
Just to make a comment on some issues
which I don't think are critical issues,
[1:59:06]
but I think they're brought up here again
and again every week,
[1:59:11]
is if a person's making an argument You
don't have to use hyperbole,
[1:59:16]
especially in the environmental area where
so much of the hyperbole has proven
[1:59:22]
false. Just take the electricity plans,
[1:59:25]
the alternate electricity plans for New
York,
[1:59:28]
for Westchester County and New York State.
[1:59:31]
So I recommend all speakers when they
talk, address the point.
[1:59:36]
I can't sleep at night, I can't hear,
whatever it is. As opposed to hyperbole.
[1:59:42]
You know, the whole world's going to end
if this doesn't happen.
[1:59:46]
Perhaps some of the trustees would address
this before I get to my principal topic.
[1:59:53]
It's up to them. One, I think the assist—
that the village manager—
[1:59:58]
I don't know who he does— has doing these
jobs now,
[2:00:01]
but if he doesn't have an assistant now or
somebody who's doing the job without the
[2:00:07]
title He's like one of these Indian,
Indian gods with 8 hands, right?
[2:00:13]
Hats off to him for that.
[2:00:14]
Item 2, item number 7 on page 2 brings up
a licensing agreement about electrical
[2:00:20]
wires. The original proposal for power
lines,
[2:00:24]
not the ones that went down the center of
the river. All right.
[2:00:28]
We could talk about that.
[2:00:30]
But the one that was supposed to go down
by the railroad tracks and cross Croton
[2:00:36]
Point, maybe we'd get an update on that.
[2:00:39]
You know, maybe I missed something, but I
haven't heard about it lately.
[2:00:45]
Hopefully it went the way of a Hudson
River walkway from New York City in the
[2:00:50]
River walkway from New York City in the
Bronx
[2:00:51]
to Poughkeepsie, hopefully.
[2:00:53]
And when, when you're dealing with street
repaving,
[2:00:57]
this village has done an excellent job.
[2:00:59]
with repaving and potholes get fixed
really quick.
[2:01:03]
I wish you would share your intelligence
and your knowledge and your drive with the
[2:01:09]
state of New York, which sucks at this.
[2:01:12]
They could have fixed from the Croton
Bridge to Hawthorne Circle.
[2:01:17]
He stopped halfway. It must have been
somebody's assembly district that ended
[2:01:23]
somebody's assembly district that ended
there.
[2:01:23]
And 129 is a trip. I ought to charge the
state for the alignment on my car.
[2:01:29]
Right.
[2:01:29]
Which goes out every 3 years because the
state can't fix roads.
[2:01:34]
The basic— one of the basic functions of
state government.
[2:01:39]
And then on tax receipts, you transferred
tax assessments to the town of Cortland.
[2:01:45]
I would love to know what the actual—
[2:01:48]
what actually happened in terms of income
to the village and the number of taxes
[2:01:54]
that went up by how much and how much went
down.
[2:01:57]
and whether it came out the way people
thought it would.
[2:02:01]
Now I'd like to address the most serious
issue.
[2:02:05]
We have had a boycott on an individual
basis of CVS,
[2:02:09]
which is a terrible corporation.
[2:02:11]
Nice people work here, but their
corporation is the worst. They really
[2:02:17]
corporation is the worst. They really
suck.
[2:02:17]
And they've had a series of terrible CEOs.
[2:02:20]
They fired the one that started selling
abortion drugs.
[2:02:24]
and advocated a threat to the United
States and then ran her company into the
[2:02:30]
ground. They fired her. Now she's running
for political office where she belongs.
[2:02:36]
And I'll give to your clerk what this
RU-46, this plethora of mailing RU-46,
[2:02:42]
stockpiling it, giving it to anybody,
[2:02:45]
especially state physicians from New York
who are protected by the state government,
[2:02:51]
give it to everybody out of state.
[2:02:54]
So this is a case in North Carolina where
they went to Virginia and these 2 young
[2:03:00]
people got RU-486, aborted their
31-week-old child into a toilet bowl,
[2:03:05]
and if it wasn't for another older person
calling 911, This 31-week-old child,
[2:03:11]
that's a 95% survival when you're born at
31 weeks. The child would be dead today.
[2:03:17]
It also says something to our ethics
education.
[2:03:21]
The other item, which I promise you, which
is the history,
[2:03:25]
the European history of RU-486,
[2:03:27]
it is as ugly and as destructive and as
manipulative and as lying And we don't
[2:03:33]
manipulative and as lying And we don't
give
[2:03:34]
a crap about women, as it has happened in
the United States.
[2:03:38]
I gave you the one on Clinton adopting—
are you—
[2:03:42]
how he did it politically in the United
States. And I can give you some examples.
[2:03:48]
I have personal experience with this about
where their test sites was.
[2:03:53]
Like, one of them was in Dobbs Ferry.
[2:03:56]
So I'll read this to you next time, but
I'll give it to you for your review now.
[2:04:02]
Thank you.
[2:04:10]
Thank you.
[2:04:18]
Thank you.
[2:04:33]
All right, uh, public comment continues.
Does anyone else wish to comment?
[2:04:38]
Seeing no one else wishing to comment, we
proceed to reports.
[2:04:43]
Trustee Slippen.
[2:04:44]
Thank you. Um, I just want to start by
thanking all of the residents that came
[2:04:49]
thanking all of the residents that came
out
[2:04:50]
to speak tonight. It is so great to see a
full room of people.
[2:04:54]
Um, I'm glad that we are going to be able
to have another conversation,
[2:04:59]
a further conversation regarding Local Law
10, because—
[2:05:03]
and I'm just glad that we're going to be
able to have some further conversation
[2:05:08]
about it. And because I still have a lot
of questions about where we are with what
[2:05:14]
we're doing and how we're going to deal
with enforcement.
[2:05:18]
and, um, what that's all going to look
like. But mainly, thank you.
[2:05:23]
It's, you know, the last week of summer,
and a lot of people came out, um,
[2:05:28]
and a lot of people have written to us
also.
[2:05:31]
Uh, you know, this is one of those topics
where we— I—
[2:05:35]
it's not many topics where we get as much
in, you know, um,
[2:05:39]
commentary from residents as we did on
this.
[2:05:42]
Um, so thank you to everyone, everyone who
came out tonight.
[2:05:46]
Um, Thank you to Dave from Farrington for
his persistence.
[2:05:51]
Um, what is the timing for waiting for—
[2:05:53]
we're waiting to get something back still
from the— see,
[2:05:57]
can you remind me where we are?
[2:05:59]
We've referred something to the CAC, it's
coming back to us. What's happening?
[2:06:05]
Where are we?
[2:06:06]
We basically— we did refer— we referred a
memo with some information to the CAC.
[2:06:11]
Okay, they have been working on that, as
far as I'm aware.
[2:06:15]
You know, one of the things the board did
ask was for them to respond back with an
[2:06:20]
estimated timeline. Okay. Right. You have
not received that back.
[2:06:24]
So could we just follow up? Because I am—
I am—
[2:06:27]
Well, they, they, they, like most of the
other committees,
[2:06:30]
took off the month of August. So their
schedule—
[2:06:33]
But it feels like it's been— this has been
a while, right? When did we refer it?
[2:06:38]
It's a good amount of time.
[2:06:40]
Yeah, maybe a couple months, maybe. It's
been maybe a couple months.
[2:06:43]
But I mean, I guess just even if there's
some type of update about a timeline for
[2:06:46]
when we think we're going to hear from
them, that would be great.
[2:06:49]
Yep.
[2:06:49]
I do sort of question the number of
summonses that are being written.
[2:06:55]
I mean, I know that we're out of the quiet
period or whatever you call it.
[2:07:00]
But it's hard for me to believe there are
only 4 since the last meeting because I
[2:07:07]
hear a lot of gas leaf blowers.
[2:07:09]
So I'm, you know, interested to keep that
ball moving down the field.
[2:07:15]
I just want to say welcome back to all the
students. Schools opened this week.
[2:07:21]
Congrats on opening day to our colleagues
on the school board.
[2:07:25]
I was disappointed that I could not be at
the Farrington Steps ribbon cutting.
[2:07:31]
I'm sure my colleagues who were there
We'll talk about that, but you know,
[2:07:37]
half the kids in the village, maybe more.
[2:07:40]
I think it's more than half the kids in
the village do not get a bus to school
[2:07:47]
the village do not get a bus to school
after
[2:07:47]
they leave CET. My children were included
in that.
[2:07:51]
So the more safe pathways to school we can
have for the students, the better.
[2:07:57]
And those steps look fabulous. So thank
you to the DPW.
[2:08:01]
I know we've been asking a lot of the DPW.
[2:08:04]
Always, but especially lately, which leads
me to my next item,
[2:08:09]
which is the incredible art installation
that is now completed at the Riverwalk.
[2:08:15]
I can't— it's a harmonic— what's the name?
[2:08:19]
Harmonic Landing.
[2:08:20]
Harmonic Landing. It's amazing.
[2:08:22]
It's a piece of really impressive art that
has that is—
[2:08:26]
was with a little bit of financial support
from the village, basically gifted to us.
[2:08:33]
Um, you know, the DPW did a tremendous
amount of work.
[2:08:37]
Um, Bruce Allend was at the Arts and
Humanities Committee meeting last night,
[2:08:43]
just kind of giving that committee an
update on what's happening.
[2:08:48]
Lots of photos, lots of interest from
people.
[2:08:51]
Arts and Humanities is going to work on a
ceremony to open it, dedicate it,
[2:08:57]
get the word out about it. It's just
spectacular.
[2:09:01]
Good.
[2:09:01]
I'm so thrilled that Croton now has this
piece of art.
[2:09:05]
So thank you to everyone who made that
happen.
[2:09:09]
And especially Bruce couldn't say enough
about the DPW and how amazing they were to
[2:09:15]
work with, which really just is across the
board.
[2:09:19]
Everything DPW touches, it's just really
magic.
[2:09:22]
So, but this is another great example of
that.
[2:09:26]
And then finally, the manager and I and
the chief of police and the chair of PAC
[2:09:32]
have spent some time working on getting an
RFP, getting a committee,
[2:09:37]
a company that's going to do the police
survey.
[2:09:40]
And that project is really moving along.
We got a lot of proposals.
[2:09:46]
We did some interviews this week.
[2:09:48]
It seems like sometime next week we're
going to be able to narrow it down.
[2:09:54]
You know, another department in the
village that does unbelievable work for us
[2:10:00]
village that does unbelievable work for us
is
[2:10:00]
the police department,
[2:10:01]
and I am anxious to get that study so that
we can make sure that we're we understand
[2:10:08]
how the department is working better, we
can be addressing what they need from us,
[2:10:14]
um, and how, you know, how that's all
going to look.
[2:10:18]
So I'm excited for that work to begin.
[2:10:21]
Um, it takes a long time to go through the
proposals and do the interviews, and, um,
[2:10:27]
Carolyn Whiting, the chair of the Police
Advisory Committee, is just,
[2:10:32]
just doing so much tremendous work there.
So I would like to thank her.
[2:10:38]
And then also just mention that the PAC is
going to be doing another community
[2:10:44]
survey that we've been working on.
[2:10:46]
I think it's going to be rolled out
sometime in October.
[2:10:50]
October.
[2:10:51]
So I'm looking forward to that.
[2:10:52]
It's all— all of this is kind of related,
[2:10:54]
but there's a lot of good work happening
there.
[2:10:57]
So thank you to all the people who are
involved with making that happen.
[2:11:00]
And then I just wondered what the update
on the website is.
[2:11:05]
It was supposed to launch yesterday.
[2:11:07]
Okay, I wasn't sure. That was what I
thought you said.
[2:11:09]
Yes, it did not launch yesterday.
[2:11:12]
There's just a couple more things that we
need to do.
[2:11:15]
So I'm just looking forward to our new
website. I think it will be fantastic.
[2:11:20]
That's the new date.
[2:11:22]
Thank you.
[2:11:24]
I am done, sorry. Because you mentioned
the police study,
[2:11:29]
thank you for your work on that.
[2:11:32]
What is the process, or, you know, kind of
timeline for bringing—
[2:11:38]
what's the process for bringing it to the
Board of Trustees?
[2:11:43]
Is it the study that is going— you
mentioned you're already interviewing.
[2:11:50]
This is just for the— to do— it's so—
[2:11:53]
This is to select the consultant, right?
So we did an RFP. Okay.
[2:11:58]
And Um, we got a number of responses, 12
or 13 responses.
[2:12:02]
Um, you know, I put together a small
working group of myself, the chief,
[2:12:08]
the lieutenant, uh, Carolyn Whiting, the
chair of the PAC,
[2:12:12]
and Trustee Slippen as the PAC liaison.
[2:12:15]
Yep.
[2:12:16]
And we— everybody in the group reviewed
all the proposals that we received.
[2:12:21]
Uh, we met to go over them.
[2:12:23]
We came up with, uh, consensus on the, the
top 3 that we wanted to interview.
[2:12:28]
So we've done those interviews now this
week.
[2:12:31]
We're going to meet next week to see if we
have a consensus on what our
[2:12:35]
recommendation would be.
[2:12:37]
And then at that point,
[2:12:39]
I think we would bring it back to the full
board for discussion and consideration.
[2:12:44]
Okay. And that would include what it is
we're looking to study?
[2:12:48]
Yeah, well, that— I mean, that's in the
Sorry, that's in the, um,
[2:12:53]
that was in the RFP, right? So it's just,
it's a staffing study.
[2:12:58]
So we're looking to analyze and evaluate
the current staffing structure of the
[2:13:03]
department, whether we have too many, too
few, just right.
[2:13:08]
Okay, you know, are they assigned
correctly to the right divisions?
[2:13:12]
You know, all that sort of stuff.
[2:13:15]
And especially in light of things like the
population of the village changing,
[2:13:19]
the addition of body cams, things like
that that might impact the—
[2:13:22]
is the number we have correct now?
[2:13:24]
And Carolyn has actually been really great
about making sure to ask these questions.
[2:13:29]
We're not just asking about currently
what's happening and the current number we
[2:13:33]
have, but in the future, we can't predict
exactly what's going to happen.
[2:13:37]
But as we look forward, how will—
[2:13:38]
how can we use the information we gather
to make sure that we continue to serve the
[2:13:43]
needs of— that the police department
continues to serve the,
[2:13:46]
the changing needs of the village.
[2:13:48]
That's great.
[2:13:48]
Yeah, and, um, they're also going to look
at civilians as well,
[2:13:53]
not just sworn officers,
[2:13:55]
seeing whether or not there might be an
opportunity to bring in a civilian
[2:14:00]
opportunity to bring in a civilian
employee
[2:14:01]
who may be able to take some of the—
[2:14:04]
Right.
[2:14:05]
Non-essential—
[2:14:06]
Administrative tasks.
[2:14:06]
The administrative, yeah.
[2:14:08]
And then that way that frees up an officer
to do other officer
[2:14:12]
things. Yeah. So, okay. Thank you. Yep.
[2:14:17]
Okay. Well, on August 25th,
[2:14:19]
as a member of the Waterfront Advisory
Committee meeting,
[2:14:24]
I attended the August 25th meeting with
Deputy Mayor Simon.
[2:14:29]
We reviewed the major Metro-North Railroad
project for consistency with our local
[2:14:35]
waterfront revitalization program
policies.
[2:14:39]
And at my request, which was supported by
the board and Manager Healy,
[2:14:45]
for more comprehensive information— thank
you, Manager,
[2:14:49]
for getting Metro North representatives to
come and present at the WAC,
[2:14:55]
which I know was, I guess, a first.
[2:14:58]
So I don't know, it might— it could be, I
guess. I don't know.
[2:15:03]
First, I guess, is you, manager.
[2:15:05]
Yes, probably the first person in the last
6 years.
[2:15:08]
Yeah, it's amazing that, you know, that
you got someone's attention, actually.
[2:15:14]
Yeah, no, that's great because they came,
uh,
[2:15:17]
the WAC had very good questions for them,
and, you know,
[2:15:21]
they answered what they could, um, and
they're coming back for the second, uh,
[2:15:27]
round of questions. So You know, we—
[2:15:30]
it's not like we know we can't stop this
project.
[2:15:33]
We all want reliable, you know, train
service,
[2:15:37]
but it's just providing more complete
information so that the WAC could make
[2:15:43]
determinations against the policies.
[2:15:45]
And it also adds more transparency to the
public on what it is that they're doing.
[2:15:51]
For example, we learned at the WAC that
when we knew the project will replace the
[2:15:57]
existing signal system with a
high-capacity capacity vital cab signaling
[2:16:03]
high-capacity capacity vital cab signaling
system.
[2:16:03]
The work will span from Croton-on-Hudson
to Poughkeepsie within active rail
[2:16:09]
to Poughkeepsie within active rail
corridor
[2:16:10]
adjacent to the Croton and Hudson Rivers.
[2:16:13]
Visually, it— the project will introduce
new fencing and new structures,
[2:16:18]
some of them up to 25 feet tall.
[2:16:20]
And we're trying to understand how many,
where, you know,
[2:16:25]
because we have to answer questions on the
WAC,
[2:16:28]
like how will this project affect
sightlines?
[2:16:31]
And also, there'll be some in-water
construction to place platform footings.
[2:16:37]
So we know that, you know,
[2:16:39]
residents fish and children play in the
fields along the riverfront.
[2:16:44]
So, you know, we're just trying to get
more information.
[2:16:48]
So, and, and they've been pretty
forthcoming. coming. So appreciate that.
[2:16:54]
On Wednesday, August 26th, I was informed,
like the rest of the board,
[2:16:59]
that a senior member of our community was
crossing the street,
[2:17:04]
and just a few feet from making it to the
curb, she was struck by a bicyclist.
[2:17:10]
It was, you know, an accident,
[2:17:12]
but unfortunately she was taken to the
hospital and had staples in her head and I
[2:17:18]
think, well, manager,
[2:17:19]
I know I've noticed like an increase in
the bicycle safety videos that are out,
[2:17:25]
which I think are great.
[2:17:27]
But I know, you know, I welcome the
opportunity to elevate safety, you know,
[2:17:33]
discussions and, you know, education with
kids.
[2:17:36]
And, you know, I know there'll be like a
bike ped committee meeting.
[2:17:41]
Um, And I'm sure you're going to discuss
that.
[2:17:45]
But I, I think the more we can do—
[2:17:47]
I think Trustee Nicholson had a good idea
with maybe, you know,
[2:17:52]
exploring whether one of our hardworking
detectives or police chiefs, I don't know,
[2:17:58]
could come and talk to kids about bike
safety.
[2:18:02]
But anyway, I just welcome more, you know,
more we could do around that.
[2:18:07]
Can can only help. On August 28th,
[2:18:10]
I attended the annual Croton Seniors Club
barbecue at Senosqua Park,
[2:18:15]
which was so well attended. There must
have been 80 people there.
[2:18:20]
It was a gorgeous day.
[2:18:21]
Special thank you to John McKeon and Bob
Anderson for their senior club leadership,
[2:18:27]
Joanna Straub from our rec department and
her fabulous planning,
[2:18:32]
and to our DPW barbecue chefs, Raz, Bobby,
and John.
[2:18:36]
The food was, you know, I know funded by
the seniors club, but it was, it was,
[2:18:42]
it was, yeah, it was a great afternoon.
[2:18:45]
And then on September 1st, I attended the
May—
[2:18:48]
with the mayor and Trustee Nicholson and
the manager,
[2:18:52]
the reopening of the Farrington Steps. So
I know that work was a long time coming.
[2:18:58]
Coming. It was just really well done and
beautifully done.
[2:19:03]
And I know DPW is looking forward to
continuing the rest of the job.
[2:19:08]
And also the neighbors were really
supportive and kind while the work was
[2:19:13]
supportive and kind while the work was
taking
[2:19:14]
place. I know, like, I'm sure there were
some, you know, pains, but they were,
[2:19:19]
they were great. And then last,
[2:19:22]
just because the public interest around
425 South Riverside on the planning board,
[2:19:28]
I just Wanted to say that this application
will not be on the next planning board
[2:19:34]
meeting agenda, September 8th.
[2:19:36]
Um, the meeting after September 8th is
September 22nd.
[2:19:40]
So anyway, for those folks interested in
that subject or application, um, you know,
[2:19:46]
the next meeting after the 8th is the
22nd.
[2:19:50]
Don't know if it will be on then, but just
wanted to share that.
[2:19:54]
Thanks.
[2:19:55]
Thank you.
[2:19:55]
I'll just— if I can just add on to that,
um,
[2:19:58]
anyone who's interested in that,
[2:20:00]
just sign up for the planning board
agendas on the website and you'll—
[2:20:04]
That's a good idea.
[2:20:05]
Yeah, you'll get notified if it is on.
[2:20:07]
Yeah.
[2:20:07]
Yeah. Okay.
[2:20:08]
Thank you. There have been no submissions
received since, uh,
[2:20:12]
we had our initial planning board meeting.
[2:20:15]
Yeah.
[2:20:16]
Yeah. Okay. Thank you.
[2:20:17]
Um, so I just want to note that the fall
recreation programming is up and available
[2:20:23]
registration. And I also want to just
highlight the fact that we are offering 3
[2:20:29]
programs for teens. So from 5th to 8th
grade, there is a— Well done,
[2:20:35]
Trustee Nicholson. You've been fighting
this for a while.
[2:20:39]
That's a first.
[2:20:40]
And very well done to—
[2:20:41]
Working collaboratively.
[2:20:43]
Working collaboratively with the
organization. I'm impressed. Thank you.
[2:20:48]
Will my 13-year-old attend one of these?
[2:20:50]
My kids missed out, but I'm glad it's
there.
[2:20:53]
Up for debate, but it was very, very nice
to see.
[2:20:56]
You know, this is the first teen
programming that, you know, trip-wise,
[2:21:01]
they're going to be going to a couple
different destinations,
[2:21:05]
which is really exciting, including the
movies.
[2:21:08]
So really exciting for that age group to
kind of get out of Croton and see the
[2:21:14]
world, which is, which is really exciting.
[2:21:17]
Lorraine Hansberry Coalition will be
hosting a discussion display of materials
[2:21:22]
hosting a discussion display of materials
at
[2:21:22]
the library. So more to come on that and
the exact dates,
[2:21:26]
but it's in the next couple of weeks.
[2:21:29]
I just want to reiterate my appreciation
for the folks that came out this evening
[2:21:34]
for Local Law 10. I, you know,
[2:21:36]
I'm surprised more folks are not talking
about chickens because I think there are
[2:21:42]
more chicken coops in this village, um,
[2:21:44]
that could be impacted by the passage of
this proposed law. So— As it's written
[2:21:50]
this proposed law. So— As it's written
now.
[2:21:50]
As it's written currently.
[2:21:52]
So, um, as we dive in, um, at our work
session,
[2:21:56]
I would like to talk about that a little
bit further.
[2:22:00]
Um, also, we've gotten some emails
regarding domestic caged animals inside
[2:22:06]
regarding domestic caged animals inside
people's
[2:22:06]
houses. So people are confused about the
language there.
[2:22:11]
So there's some more to dig into with
Local Law 10 than just the pigeon issue.
[2:22:17]
So I just wanted to highlight those
things.
[2:22:21]
Many thanks to the DPW with the Farrington
steps.
[2:22:24]
And, you know, it's really wonderful to
see.
[2:22:28]
And then just a quick update,
[2:22:30]
we are working on the FAQ around the
cameras in the village.
[2:22:35]
So that is pending, but, um, the village
manager is working diligently on that.
[2:22:41]
Um, and we hope to have that out soon.
[2:22:44]
Great. Oh, nice going on the teens.
[2:22:47]
Um, I'd like to offer, uh,
[2:22:48]
the FDR Museum and Library because if I
could take the seniors and the teens there
[2:22:54]
in the same year, I think that would be—
that would be an accomplishment.
[2:22:58]
So let's just—
[2:22:59]
Multi-generational.
[2:23:01]
Yeah, let them, let them.
[2:23:02]
I can't guarantee my own team.
[2:23:03]
Plenty, plenty of stuff there for the
young people.
[2:23:07]
Anyway, just taking us back to where we
began this evening,
[2:23:11]
I just want to say a couple more words
about Chief Nikotopoulos and John Spada.
[2:23:17]
And just when you think of— and
congratulate them— 40 years for Chief
[2:23:22]
congratulate them— 40 years for Chief
Nikotopoulos.
[2:23:23]
When you think about the changes in
policing,
[2:23:26]
whether it's computer technology or
investigative techniques,
[2:23:30]
And if you take this all the way back to
1986, DNA as a use of investigations,
[2:23:36]
that was really at its infancy. Increased
diversity.
[2:23:40]
What hasn't changed in those 40 years is
John Nikotopoulos.
[2:23:44]
You know, we've had the consistency and
leadership of him all these years as kind
[2:23:50]
leadership of him all these years as kind
of
[2:23:50]
a hometown hero. So I'm just kind of just
so grateful that he's been with us for 4
[2:23:56]
decades. And also John Spada for 25 years.
[2:23:59]
When you look at the complexity of what it
takes, you know, we—
[2:24:03]
most people think the water comes from the
faucet, but it doesn't.
[2:24:08]
And the treatment that has to go in there,
[2:24:11]
and particularly the federal and state
regulatory requirements that have changed
[2:24:17]
regulatory requirements that have changed
so
[2:24:17]
drastically over the last 25 years,
whether it's PFAS or lead and copper,
[2:24:22]
whether it's PFAS or lead and copper,
arsenic,
[2:24:22]
cryptosporidium, you name it.
[2:24:25]
And on top of the Homeland Security
requirements that we've had to use to
[2:24:30]
requirements that we've had to use to
protect
[2:24:30]
our water supplies coincidentally in the
same 25 years that John has been here.
[2:24:36]
So I just wanted to thank both of them for
their incredible service.
[2:24:41]
Let's see, tomorrow night we hope to fill
this room again with our New York Forward
[2:24:47]
Forum. New York Forward, for those of you
out there,
[2:24:50]
is a 4.5 million-dollar program that helps
you reimagine different sections of your
[2:24:56]
commercial areas, retail areas,
[2:24:59]
whether it be streetscapes or improved
transportation corridors or just helping
[2:25:04]
transportation corridors or just helping
our
[2:25:04]
local business folks, you know, to do a
better job with capital.
[2:25:09]
So we're going to talk about some ideas
that have been developed through our
[2:25:14]
planner, through our our departmental
teams here,
[2:25:18]
through some of our board members here,
[2:25:21]
and particularly Trustee Nackteller's had
some great ideas that have been
[2:25:26]
forthcoming in the last couple of weeks on
New York Forward.
[2:25:30]
So we'll have a chance to talk all of
those through and get some good public
[2:25:36]
feedback on what some of those are, as
well as some good ideas from the public.
[2:25:41]
But in addition to that,
[2:25:43]
we're very gratified that that Mayor
Marjorie Hsu from Sleepy Hollow is going
[2:25:48]
Marjorie Hsu from Sleepy Hollow is going
to
[2:25:49]
join us for our whole, our entire meeting.
[2:25:52]
When it's a competitive state program like
New York Forward,
[2:25:56]
you want to take a close look at those who
have been successful in getting the grant
[2:26:02]
previously in your region, and that's
definitely Sleepy Hollow.
[2:26:06]
So Mayor Hsu will be coming in to talk
about what Sleepy Hollow initially was
[2:26:12]
about what Sleepy Hollow initially was
trying
[2:26:12]
to accomplish with their New York Forward,
[2:26:15]
how it's gone since they actually won the
$4.5 million 4 years ago,
[2:26:20]
and what it's been like working with New
York State in implementing that.
[2:26:25]
So hopefully we can get some good
inspiration from,
[2:26:29]
from her experience that will go into our,
our approach and our application,
[2:26:34]
which probably is going to due sometime in
January.
[2:26:38]
Earlier, actually last week,
[2:26:40]
the manager and I attended the Fire
Council and got a good update on what all
[2:26:45]
Council and got a good update on what all
the,
[2:26:46]
all the 3 houses are up to.
[2:26:48]
Very specifically for calendar updates, I
just want everyone to circle Sunday,
[2:26:53]
October 4th. That's Fire Fair.
[2:26:55]
The theme for Fire Fair this year is
Charge into Fire Safety.
[2:27:00]
Safe charging is a superpower,
[2:27:02]
emphasizing the safe charging habits for
all the different devices that are powered
[2:27:08]
by lithium-ion batteries, such as our
telephones, our tablets, our laptops,
[2:27:13]
our bicycles, our scooters, power tools, a
lot of toys.
[2:27:17]
So you're going to have a lot of good
lessons.
[2:27:20]
So Fire Fair every year is just great for
families and kids and everyone involved.
[2:27:26]
Back to the WAC meeting for a second,
[2:27:29]
I did want to thank Trustee Nackteller for
the innovation,
[2:27:33]
and she's described it in full, but it was
an innovative approach.
[2:27:38]
And I've been on the WAC now for almost 6
years.
[2:27:41]
It's the first time we actually brought in
someone from the outside to try to
[2:27:47]
enlighten us, and they didn't quite get
there, but we invited them to come back.
[2:27:52]
So, you know, they had some information,
but they owe us— They owe us.
[2:27:57]
They are willing to return.
[2:27:59]
They owe— and they should because they owe
us some more information.
[2:28:04]
So I was very grateful for that session.
[2:28:07]
And in addition, in that WAC meeting, we
also had under consideration,
[2:28:12]
which we'll see at a subsequent board
meeting here,
[2:28:16]
the draft laws that we've put together
with the help of our planner,
[2:28:20]
Valerie Manastra. And I should mention, by
the way, Valerie, of course,
[2:28:26]
will be part of our New York Forward
meeting tomorrow night.
[2:28:30]
But on the WAC meeting,
[2:28:31]
Valerie and our attorneys have put
together draft legislation to buttress and
[2:28:37]
enhance our planning approach in light of
some of the changes that have been brought
[2:28:43]
about by the SEQR reforms that came out of
the state legislature and the governor.
[2:28:49]
So we'll—
[2:28:49]
The planning board will be taking up the
site development Part of the enhancement
[2:28:54]
site development Part of the enhancement
at
[2:28:55]
their meeting on the 8th.
[2:28:56]
Very good. Perfect. Perfect to know.
[2:28:59]
That's part of the zoning code, so the
planning board will be talking about that.
[2:29:05]
Absolutely. Perfectly stated.
[2:29:07]
Another calendar item,
[2:29:08]
just because we haven't had a chance to
talk about it much this year,
[2:29:13]
but our annual Rotary car show is Sunday,
September 27th, from 11 to 3.
[2:29:18]
So circle the calendars for that.
[2:29:21]
Rotary is hard at work on that,
[2:29:23]
getting getting the great cars and the
sponsors and the food trucks and all that.
[2:29:29]
So hopefully the weather helps and
participates and cooperates.
[2:29:34]
And so we'll have a great afternoon that
Sunday.
[2:29:37]
Let's see, Trustee Slippen mentioned the
start of the school year.
[2:29:42]
I just wanted to thank the manager and DPW
and police and everyone involved in
[2:29:47]
improving the approach that we have on
safety for the Maple and Wells
[2:29:52]
safety for the Maple and Wells
intersection.
[2:29:53]
We're going to get an RRFB there, rapid
reflecting flashing beacon,
[2:29:58]
which really puts the teeth into our
crosswalks. It's coming soon.
[2:30:03]
You know, the manager is working very
effectively with our state partners.
[2:30:08]
But until we get that, which hopefully, as
I say will be very soon.
[2:30:13]
We have temporarily there one of our
police speed lights so that people that
[2:30:19]
police speed lights so that people that
are
[2:30:19]
coming to the crosswalk will understand,
you know, how fast they're going.
[2:30:24]
But we've also put up one of the
temporary—
[2:30:27]
you'll see it in the middle of the
crosswalk, just someone standing there,
[2:30:33]
cardboard person standing there saying,
yield to pedestrians.
[2:30:37]
So anything that we can do.
[2:30:39]
to strengthen that crosswalk until we get
the RFP is very much appreciated.
[2:30:45]
So I think it was great that we had all of
this— these improvements,
[2:30:49]
temporary improvements in place on the
first day of school.
[2:30:54]
And last but not least,
[2:30:55]
on our housing preference for first
responders and medical personnel,
[2:31:00]
not only is it, I think, a triumph of good
policy,
[2:31:04]
but it's also been a triumph of good
communications because the article—
[2:31:09]
articles in the entire New York region
have been focusing on that.
[2:31:14]
If you just put in Croton-on-Hudson
housing preference for first responders
[2:31:19]
housing preference for first responders
and
[2:31:20]
medical personnel, you'll see that way,
way to our north,
[2:31:24]
our press release was picked up and run.
[2:31:27]
So I think we're getting appropriate
recognition for that.
[2:31:31]
And hopefully, you know, others will we'll
consider it as well.
[2:31:35]
But I think it just, it just goes to show,
you know,
[2:31:39]
what the good results we can get when we
make sure to tell our own story in our own
[2:31:45]
way. That's it. Thank you. All right, very
good.
[2:31:49]
I think most of the major points have been
covered.
[2:31:52]
I do want to note our 9/11 ceremony next
week will be done jointly with our
[2:31:58]
neighboring communities.
[2:32:00]
Buchanan is the formal host, but of
course, physically,
[2:32:04]
it will be in our village at our 9/11
Memorial. That's Friday at 4:00.
[2:32:09]
And if it is, in the event of rain, it
will be relocated to the Harmon Firehouse.
[2:32:14]
But hopefully, those that are available
can come and join us and remember the 25th
[2:32:20]
anniversary, which is kind of remarkable
to think about.
[2:32:24]
Yes.
[2:32:27]
I also want to, uh, congratulate, uh,
[2:32:30]
3 individuals on their exciting new
adventures in public service.
[2:32:34]
Uh, I will be appointing Kai Sheng, with
the consent of—
[2:32:39]
advice and consent of the Village Board.
[2:32:42]
I will be appointing Kai Sheng, um, excuse
me, uh, and Anne Rizzoli,
[2:32:47]
and to the Village— to the VEB, Visual
Environment Board.
[2:32:51]
And then also Gabriella Mirabelli.
[2:32:53]
to the planning board as a planning board
alternate. Wonderful. All right.
[2:32:59]
So do I have a motion?
[2:33:00]
So moved.
[2:33:01]
I have a second. Motion by Trustee Simon,
second by Trustee Nicholson. All in favor?
[2:33:09]
Aye. All right. And that— before we motion
to close,
[2:33:14]
I'd like to have a brief moment of silence
for Rhoda Stevens,
[2:33:19]
who served our village for many, many,
[2:33:22]
many years on the Zoning Board of Appeals
from 1982 to 2017,
[2:33:28]
serving as chair from 2015 to 2017, and
was also one of our—
[2:33:33]
is also part of the Westchester County
Senior Hall of Fame.
[2:33:39]
Hopefully we all have opportunities to
serve our community as she did. Thank you.
[2:33:46]
Do I have a motion to close?
[2:33:48]
Mayor, before we close, could I just add
one thing about the, uh, 9/11 ceremony?
[2:33:52]
Yes.
[2:33:52]
Um, for— we'll have 3, uh, new names from
village residents who passed away from,
[2:33:59]
uh, 9/11 disease be recognized at this
year's ceremony.
[2:34:03]
So, um, you know, we, uh,
[2:34:05]
we'll have the new plaques put on the
monument down there.
[2:34:09]
So fortunately, we are still losing people
as a result of that day.
[2:34:14]
So just wanted to highlight that.
[2:34:17]
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Madam
Chair. All in favor? Aye.
[2:34:21]
I, I don't think you actually got the
motion. I— yeah.
[2:34:24]
So moved. Second. Motion by Trustee Simon,
second by Trustee Nicholson.
[2:34:28]
All in favor? Aye. Aye. Thank you.