Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
[0:34]
I
[2:58]
What?
[3:03]
Well, good morning everyone,
[3:04]
and welcome to City Council Chambers.
[3:06]
We are glad to have you here today.
[3:08]
Good morning, city Council.
[3:09]
Good morning, Ms. Prime. We're ready to go.
[3:11]
Yes, sir. Good morning everyone,
[3:13]
and welcome to the presentation
[3:15]
of the Mayor's proclamations.
[3:17]
We begin this morning with a Pledge of Allegiance led
[3:20]
by Imperial Border Squad, desert Inferno Squad,
[3:23]
at the invitation of city representative
[3:25]
Deanna Malona Rocha.
[3:27]
We have Greg Trujillo and Jaime Vial
[4:11]
Republic for which extends nation
[4:15]
individual liberty justice for
[4:51]
Right?
[4:52]
Alright, ready? Big smiles. And 1, 2, 3.
[5:18]
That brings us to the proclamations,
[5:20]
and the first proclamation is Sunbelt Association annual
[5:23]
Tony the Tiger Sunbelt football game.
[5:26]
All right.
[5:37]
Good morning everyone. Representative Nino.
[5:39]
Thank you, mayor. It's gonna be a great proclamation,
[5:47]
proclamation for the city of El Paso, Texas.
[5:51]
Whereas Assemble Association has served as guide
[5:55]
to enhancing the lives of the citizens
[5:56]
of El Paso for 92 years.
[5:59]
And the Tony the Tiger Sun Ball,
[6:01]
is known throughout the country as one
[6:04]
of hospitality professionalism, fun and excitement.
[6:08]
And whereas the annual Tony, the Tiger Sun Ball, has grown
[6:11]
to be the largest single sporting event in the city, as well
[6:15]
as one of the top entertainment values while showcasing the
[6:19]
city on CBS on a national television audience for 57 years.
[6:24]
And whereas the Tony, the Tiger Sun Ball
[6:27]
with Duke Blue Devils versus the Arizona State Sun Devils
[6:30]
as participants in this year,
[6:32]
annual contest at noon on Wednesday, December 31st,
[6:37]
continues to showcase the city
[6:38]
of El Paso on a national stage, outstanding football teams,
[6:42]
their fans, families
[6:44]
and supporters right here in the Sun City.
[6:47]
And whereas the Tony the Tiger Sun Ball sponsors
[6:50]
by Kellogg's Samba, executive director Bernie Olivas,
[6:54]
the Sobel President, Tamara GSKi and Board of Directors,
[6:58]
and the Sobel Queen
[6:59]
and court work to make this a football game that is embraced
[7:03]
by the citizens of El Paso as their own
[7:06]
and reserves as a great backdrop to the city, the people,
[7:10]
and the culture of El Paso, Texas.
[7:12]
Now therefore, be it proclaimed by the mayor
[7:15]
and the council of the city of El Paso, Texas, that the week
[7:18]
of December 28th shall be known as Tony the Tiger.
[7:23]
Sandal week, congratulations.
[7:25]
Signed by the Mayor Renard Johnson.
[7:32]
Good morning. Good morning,
[7:33]
Bernie. Good morning.
[7:34]
Uh, Bernie Oli, executive
[7:36]
for the Sun Bowl Mayor City Council,
[7:38]
and everybody, thank you very much for that proclamation.
[7:40]
We really, we really appreciate it.
[7:42]
And I just want to reiterate why the sun
[7:44]
exists to begin with.
[7:46]
Three main reasons that the Sun Bowl exists.
[7:48]
Number one is to give the citizens
[7:50]
of El Paso a quality event If anybody's ever gone
[7:54]
to the Sun Bowl, I think it's a
[7:55]
pretty neat event for the city.
[7:56]
Number two, to give El Paso some
[7:59]
positive national attention.
[8:01]
And for 57 consecutive years, CBS does nothing
[8:04]
for four hours, does nothing
[8:06]
but sing the praises of our city nationwide.
[8:09]
And third of all, most importantly, is the economic impact
[8:13]
that the Sambul brings to the city of El Paso
[8:15]
and surrounding area up to $25 million in one week.
[8:19]
That our, that our visitors, that, that follow their teams,
[8:22]
they come in, they stay in our hotels,
[8:24]
they eat at our restaurants, they shop at our stores.
[8:26]
And those are the three main reasons that the symbol exists
[8:30]
for 92 years.
[8:32]
So we're extremely happy, again, to put this, uh,
[8:35]
put this on, uh, behind me.
[8:37]
It brought some very important people associated
[8:39]
with the Sam, our president, Tamara Kowski, our queen,
[8:42]
Caroline Mann, and our lady in waiting, Janna East Milan.
[8:46]
And I'd like for our president to maybe say a couple
[8:48]
of words about the matchup that we have
[8:50]
and how great a game it's gonna be.
[8:52]
Absolutely. Good morning. Good
[8:55]
Morning. Thank you, Bernie.
[8:56]
We are so excited.
[8:58]
We are gonna have a tremendous,
[8:59]
tremendous game as you all know.
[9:01]
We have the Arizona State Sun Devils facing off against the
[9:05]
Duke Blue Devils.
[9:06]
Um, both teams have eight wins.
[9:09]
Uh, Arizona State was in the playoffs last year,
[9:12]
and Duke pulled up an upset, uh,
[9:16]
win over Virginia Yeah.
[9:18]
To get the a CC Championship.
[9:20]
So it's gonna be an amazing matchup.
[9:22]
We appreciate city council's support of this event.
[9:25]
It's huge. Excuse me,
[9:27]
what differentiates the Sun Bowl from other bowls?
[9:30]
It's, people are in the stands, it's in the enthusiasm
[9:33]
of El Paso that we showcase each and every year.
[9:36]
So we look forward to seeing you all there.
[9:39]
Very good. Good morning. Hi
[9:43]
Everyone. My name's
[9:44]
Caroline Mann. I'm this year's Sun Queen.
[9:46]
I'm so honored to be here this morning.
[9:47]
Thank you so much for having us.
[9:49]
And I just wanted to, on behalf of the Sunbelt Association
[9:52]
and my lady in waiting, Janice say thank you to the city
[9:55]
of El Paso for all they do for the Sunbelt Association,
[9:58]
and we love having it in El Paso. Alright,
[10:01]
Fantastic.
[10:05]
Hi everyone, my name's Janice
[10:07]
and I just wanna thank all you all for, um, you know,
[10:10]
supporting us and endlessly
[10:12]
and, you know, with Caroline leading our court,
[10:14]
we are super excited to be a part of the Symbol Association
[10:17]
and we're excited to see everyone.
[10:18]
December 31st.
[10:22]
Tony, you got anything to say?
[10:28]
Thank you very much for, for this, you know,
[10:30]
for this proclamation, for this honor.
[10:32]
And I hope to see you all at the game.
[10:34]
Uh, like I said, we have tickets for all of you.
[10:36]
Uh, I should have brought 'em and I forgot 'em on my desk.
[10:39]
Wow. But anyway, you're all invited, invited right
[10:42]
to the game, and I'll make sure you all get your
[10:43]
tickets, uh, for the game.
[10:45]
And, uh, I hopefully the weather is gonna be the way it has
[10:49]
been for the last few months.
[10:50]
We've had tremendous weather. Yeah.
[10:51]
We also have a couple of gifts
[10:52]
for you if you, uh, indulge us.
[10:54]
We'd like to pass out some things. Sure,
[10:56]
Sure. Thank you.
[10:57]
And Bernie, again, thank you guys for all
[10:59]
that you do and, and, uh, putting El Paso on the map
[11:02]
and getting us recognized nationally
[11:04]
and for the, the tremendous amount of economic development
[11:07]
that the Sunbelt does create for our region.
[11:09]
But Bernie, I do want you to talk about all the volunteers
[11:11]
that it takes to put this event on and,
[11:14]
and all the people that stand behind you.
[11:16]
I, I know Wayne Thornton's here
[11:17]
and he's behind the camera this time,
[11:18]
but tell me about all the volunteers
[11:20]
and the great people that work with you. Yeah,
[11:22]
And Wayne is, is a past
[11:23]
bridge of the assembled association.
[11:24]
But, you know, there's only seven full-time employees at
[11:26]
Assemble to put on the 16 events
[11:28]
that we put out throughout the year.
[11:30]
We could not survive if we had 700 volunteers
[11:35]
that help us put all assembled events together, 700
[11:39]
volunteers free of, you know, free of pay.
[11:42]
We don't pay 'em. But they're,
[11:44]
they all have the same passion for El Paso that we do.
[11:47]
And that's why they do it.
[11:48]
They don't do it for us, they don't do it for some,
[11:50]
they don't, don't do it for anybody but for the city.
[11:53]
So thank you for, for allowing me
[11:55]
to recognize the volunteers.
[11:56]
700 of 'em begin the year.
[11:58]
We got about 400 of 'em already working the football game.
[12:01]
Uh, right now. There's a ton of them,
[12:03]
you know, getting the field ready.
[12:04]
That field will be transformed from the UTEP field
[12:07]
to the Tony of the Tiger Sun Bowl field, one
[12:09]
of the best logos in football.
[12:12]
And all my colleagues at the other bowls,
[12:15]
they tell me the same thing.
[12:17]
Boys, you guys killed it with that logo.
[12:18]
Yeah. Which reminds me a great big thanks
[12:22]
to Kellogg's themselves.
[12:24]
You know, without them we wouldn't be able to be doing this.
[12:26]
Uh, they've been tremendous sponsors
[12:28]
and we've had tremendous sponsors all the way from Wells
[12:31]
Fargo in 86 all the way through, through WestStar, I mean,
[12:35]
through, uh, uh, Wells Fargo and Northwest.
[12:38]
And, uh, uh, of course, you know, brute
[12:41]
and, uh, Vitalis from, uh, you know, Helena, Troy,
[12:44]
and of course Hyundai was our title sponsor for nine years.
[12:47]
And now Kellogg's has been going on for six years
[12:49]
and hope we can keep 'em for a longer time.
[12:51]
But even if they don't, they have been a tremendous sponsor.
[12:54]
Like I said, they love El Paso as well.
[12:56]
So we'll see what happens.
[12:57]
Thank you, mayor. Thank you City Council.
[12:59]
Congratulations you guys. Congratulations.
[13:05]
We Have some t-shirts and some hats
[13:08]
and they're different sizes.
[13:09]
So we'll hand one out
[13:11]
and you all can exchange, get the right
[13:14]
sizes. I call you up for
[13:18]
The picture. Okay.
[13:19]
You wanna go up and shake the hands?
[13:22]
Yeah, you wanna go up and shake the hand?
[13:58]
Should I ask you to go
[13:59]
to the Yes.
[14:34]
I'm gonna use the ladder. I called Tony Mr.
[14:37]
Tiger on person basis.
[14:42]
I was like, Mr. Tiger. Mr. Tiger. Mrs. Tiger.
[14:46]
Formal a cutie.
[18:03]
Two three, mayor, can I get you in there?
[18:38]
And the next proclamation is Desert Inferno,
[18:41]
Imperial Border Squad D.
[18:43]
Okay. Representative Rocha,
[18:47]
Thank you. They have
[18:48]
a dramatic entrance
[19:10]
As you wish.
[19:25]
Good morning. Good morning, good morning,
[19:27]
representative Rocha.
[19:29]
Thank you. And since this is our last meeting of the year,
[19:33]
I just wanna, um, really thank all of council
[19:37]
for all your amazing proclamations this year.
[19:40]
Uh, we've attended them, we've celebrated them,
[19:43]
all the organizations, everybody that we have out here, um,
[19:47]
that supports citizens within the city,
[19:50]
within the county, within the region.
[19:52]
So thank you all for having such,
[19:53]
doing such a great job this year.
[19:55]
But this group right here is, uh,
[20:00]
does really amazing work.
[20:02]
And so I wanna be able to read this proclamation so
[20:05]
that you all understand how impactful
[20:07]
this group really is within, within our region.
[20:12]
Whereas the Imperial Border squad, an affiliate
[20:15]
of Storm Trooper Ranch
[20:17]
and Desert Inferno Squad, an affiliate of the Star Garrison
[20:21]
of the 501st Legion, bring joy to Star Wars fans
[20:26]
of all ages through costuming, community engagement,
[20:30]
and charit charitable appearances.
[20:33]
And whereas the Storm Trooper Ranch was established in 2018,
[20:38]
and De Desert Inferno Squad was established in 2020
[20:42]
with the mission to uphold the call to be
[20:45]
bad guys doing good by working harmoniously
[20:50]
with partner groups such as Rebel Legion, Mandalorian,
[20:53]
Mercks Droid Builders within the area for the betterment
[20:58]
of the community and local charities.
[21:01]
And whereas the Imperial Border squad has volunteered
[21:04]
countless hours at events that bring happiness
[21:08]
and hope to children and children at heart,
[21:11]
including appearances at the El Paso Children's Hospital,
[21:15]
the Make-A-Wish Foundation,
[21:17]
and other Community centered celebrations.
[21:21]
And whereas the group's commitment to uplifting spirits
[21:25]
by sharing their passion for Star Wars
[21:27]
with character portrayals
[21:30]
and inclusive programming has made them a beloved presence
[21:34]
at events throughout the western deserts of Texas.
[21:38]
And whereas the Imperial Border Squad not only fosters
[21:41]
community connection through shared fandom,
[21:45]
but also serves as a model for volunteerism, creativity,
[21:50]
and compassion for all.
[21:53]
Now therefore, be it proclaimed by the Mayor
[21:55]
and council of the city of El Paso,
[21:57]
that the Imperial Border Squad
[21:59]
and Desert Inferno Squad be formally recognized
[22:04]
for their outstanding contributions to the cultural
[22:07]
and social fabric of community.
[22:10]
And their continued efforts to bring light
[22:13]
and imagination to residents of all ages
[22:17]
to December 16th, 2025 shall be known
[22:21]
as Desert Inferno Imperial Border Squad Day.
[22:25]
Signed by the Honorable Mayor Renard Johnson.
[22:34]
Good morning, guys. Morning. Good morning.
[22:37]
The floor is yours.
[22:39]
Good morning. My name's Jaime Viva, I'm
[22:42]
behind me are members of the Imperial Border Squad
[22:45]
and five oh first, um, Garrison Legion that you spoke of.
[22:50]
It's a tremendous opportunity to be here.
[22:52]
It's a reward we never thought dream or imagine.
[22:56]
And when we talk about dreams
[22:57]
and imagination, you see behind me,
[22:59]
that's all we think about all day is what nerdy things,
[23:02]
what geeky things we're gonna do,
[23:04]
what cool costume someone has.
[23:06]
How did you make this? How did you make that?
[23:08]
But that's exactly the enthusiasm we take everywhere we go.
[23:14]
But by the time we leave here, I, I want, I hope
[23:16]
that you have, that you remember us with two words
[23:19]
or by two words, but
[23:20]
before I get there,
[23:21]
I'm gonna tell you a little bit about us.
[23:24]
What started out with one person, then the second person,
[23:29]
then the third person grew into three clubs in El Paso?
[23:34]
It's odd, the state of Texas, because we've become so big
[23:37]
and such a community driven program, if you will,
[23:41]
support group unspoken of we are a charity.
[23:44]
We cannot accept rewards or donations. So this is all us.
[23:48]
This is time away from work.
[23:49]
This is time away from our families.
[23:51]
This is financial, what we do, all for the smiles,
[23:54]
everything you all experienced this morning.
[23:56]
Taking pictures is exactly what we look forward
[23:59]
to every time we go to the hospitals.
[24:02]
Make a Wish, we visit a terminal, terminal, kids at home,
[24:06]
orphanages, social, uh, media, community events,
[24:10]
epilepsy walks, Alzheimer's walks.
[24:13]
It's endless what we do here.
[24:15]
And this is the biggest reward we ask for
[24:17]
when we go to someone's event.
[24:20]
The the joke is, all we want is a room to change it,
[24:24]
a bathroom, hopefully, and water.
[24:27]
So to get this recognition is priceless.
[24:30]
It's something that we never would've
[24:32]
dreamed of or imagined.
[24:34]
So I leave it at that what started out as three individuals
[24:36]
with a dream has turned into a family of over 90.
[24:41]
So when you think of Star Wars, El Paso
[24:44]
and the rest of Texas, when they think of Star Wars El Paso,
[24:47]
I hope that you remember family and community
[24:51]
because that's exactly what we are.
[24:53]
Wow. Fantastic.
[25:00]
On behalf of both of the groups up here, I also wanted
[25:02]
to extend a thank you to the entire city council
[25:05]
and the mayor especially to, to Ms. Rocha
[25:07]
for bestowing this honor upon us.
[25:09]
Like he said, we didn't expect or, or
[25:11]
or ever think that this was gonna happen.
[25:14]
We got into this just to get back to the city
[25:16]
and to do it maybe in a different way,
[25:18]
a little bit fun way, having a cosplay.
[25:20]
But it was, it was a love that we have that we share
[25:21]
with the community, but then we found out we can do some
[25:24]
charitable things and bring attention
[25:25]
to some important things in the city.
[25:27]
So I wanted to thank not only Jaime,
[25:29]
'cause it was his brainchild that kind of started it.
[25:31]
And then he brought me in
[25:32]
and he, he was kind enough to let me go crazy with it.
[25:35]
And this is kind of the result.
[25:37]
And so I'm very appreciative.
[25:39]
But I also wanna thank Eric Dick, uh, storm Trooper Ranch.
[25:41]
He's the founder of that. He trusted us
[25:44]
to do something a little different than
[25:45]
what everybody else was doing in his, his group.
[25:48]
And he has let us just kind of write it out
[25:50]
and we really appreciate his support for that.
[25:52]
But I also wanna thank all members past
[25:54]
and present for their time, their contributions, um,
[25:58]
for coming in and, and,
[25:59]
and doing all the things they do for the city.
[26:02]
And, you know, you have to be a person
[26:04]
that's willing to give up your time.
[26:05]
And that's not always an easy ask.
[26:07]
So the fact that they're willing to do that,
[26:09]
I'm very appreciative and I can't leave out my wife.
[26:11]
I know she's hiding somewhere in here,
[26:13]
but I couldn't have done that without her.
[26:16]
Uh, she's the one that, uh, got me the first costume
[26:19]
and kind of started us on this path.
[26:21]
So it's kind of her fault in a way.
[26:24]
But I just want to thank you
[26:25]
and everybody in the city of El Paso for being
[26:27]
so kind and accepting of us.
[26:29]
And we're hoping to do more with the city and,
[26:31]
and continue to grow
[26:32]
and give back in whatever way we can possible.
[26:35]
Wow,
[26:40]
Those passed Representative, um, Fierro,
[26:44]
Thank you so much, mayor.
[26:45]
You know, thank you all for being here and, and, and the joy
[26:48]
and the smiles that you bring to this room
[26:50]
and to the, the our the fellow council members.
[26:53]
I cannot thank you enough. This is exciting.
[26:56]
I do have a question for representative, um, Maldonado.
[26:59]
Is there a reason you gave me Yoda?
[27:04]
Thank you, mayor.
[27:06]
He little, was that Yoda or was that Gro gu? It's gro.
[27:10]
Was it Gro? See,
[27:13]
Does that mean it's even smaller?
[27:18]
So it's a double burn. Thank you,
[27:21]
Representative Rocha.
[27:23]
And not on purpose, by the way. Rep Firo. So sorry. Staff.
[27:26]
Oh my gosh. Embarrassing.
[27:29]
No, I just wanted to thank you all and,
[27:31]
and just really quick thank you for everything that you do.
[27:33]
I came across this group, uh,
[27:35]
doing the human trafficking walk earlier this year,
[27:40]
and it was amazing to have you all out there
[27:42]
and see you out there, uh, with the participants
[27:45]
and just really engaging with everybody.
[27:47]
Then come to find out everything that you do.
[27:50]
You know, those that are attached to, um, the,
[27:53]
the orphanages and the children's hospitals
[27:56]
and Make-A-Wish Foundation.
[27:58]
They all know what you all do for,
[28:00]
for those kids in the community that includes the parents
[28:03]
and all the support that, that these, um,
[28:06]
that these children receive.
[28:07]
So I just wanted to thank you.
[28:09]
But I do have to say I've known Greg since, gosh,
[28:14]
for a really long time.
[28:16]
And we didn't know, we didn't know it at the time,
[28:18]
but Catherine Longoria, she's, oh, there she is.
[28:22]
Yes, she, oh, Catherine, sorry, sorry,
[28:25]
sorry. Catherine's over
[28:26]
There.
[28:28]
Oh, there she is. Okay. So, so, um, anyways, we were at,
[28:32]
we were at, uh, a location earlier this week
[28:35]
and come to find out
[28:37]
that we were talking about the same person.
[28:40]
And I won't go into how we,
[28:43]
how I didn't know him by his name.
[28:45]
But other than that, I'll just say
[28:47]
that we've known each other for a long time.
[28:49]
He played baseball with my brother for many, many years.
[28:54]
And, uh, his brother has, has been a friend
[28:57]
of mine I would like to thank for many years as well.
[28:59]
So it's good to see you. It really is great to see you.
[29:03]
Thank you for and we'll be back, yeah. Small
[29:05]
World circle. Yes,
[29:06]
absolutely. So thank you all for everything you do.
[29:09]
I really appreciate it.
[29:11]
And, and what a treat, Greg and,
[29:12]
and Jaime, you guys have delivered for this community.
[29:15]
Thank you for uplifting El Paso
[29:17]
and the entire Borderland community and all that you do.
[29:20]
And we feel the passion from each and every one of you.
[29:23]
You know, earlier you were telling me some
[29:25]
of the costumes were made with 3D printing and,
[29:27]
and the hours that it takes to, to get to where they're at.
[29:30]
And, and, and we can't thank you guys enough.
[29:33]
And it's amazing that you started with three
[29:35]
and it's grown to where it is today
[29:37]
and you guys are throughout Texas
[29:38]
and doing the things that you're doing.
[29:40]
But I would like to, you know,
[29:42]
and we'll never forget the family and community.
[29:44]
I mean, you said it best and we won't forget that,
[29:47]
but for those that can speak, maybe they can come by
[29:50]
and introduce themselves and those that can't can still, I
[29:53]
I'll introduce the ones in the helmet
[29:54]
and then I'll let the others that don't have a helmet on.
[29:56]
Okay. And we have Sonya, she's one of our jaws here.
[29:59]
She's very enthusiastic, very hyper diaper.
[30:02]
Um, we have Reagan, he's one of our five vaers.
[30:07]
We have, uh, Zandra, she is, uh, captain Fasman
[30:10]
and also a gunner and a, um, mall.
[30:14]
And then we have Ed Brown, he's our bailin
[30:16]
and also one of our other Vaers.
[30:18]
Um, and then we have, I'll let
[30:22]
David Svo.
[30:23]
I'm Captain Han Solo, and I'm just in it for the money.
[30:28]
Morning everybody. I'm Liz Velez.
[30:30]
I cosplay as a Ray Skywalker.
[30:33]
So yeah. And we could go on and on.
[30:35]
All these people have costumes here and we have Aiden.
[30:38]
He's also, he will never show his face.
[30:40]
He's very serious in his character.
[30:41]
I've known him four years now
[30:43]
and I still haven't seen his face.
[30:46]
It's very frustrating.
[30:47]
Um, and then we have all our friends back here
[30:49]
that are also participants
[30:51]
and they don't have their costumes all the day,
[30:52]
but they came out to support and they took time off work
[30:54]
to just come out and hang out with us.
[30:56]
Wow. We're very appreciative of them.
[30:58]
This is our second family, really, honestly,
[31:00]
we hang out on our own.
[31:01]
We're gonna have a big party next week for Christmas
[31:03]
because we like hanging out with each other despite the fact
[31:05]
that we're cosplay.
[31:06]
We still like each other outside of that.
[31:08]
And the one thing I also wanted,
[31:09]
like you said, family community.
[31:11]
The one thing that I, I think
[31:12]
that's amazing about this group,
[31:13]
we have political ideologies
[31:15]
from both ends of the spectrums.
[31:16]
Religious ideologists from both end of the spectrums,
[31:18]
but somehow in the middle, none of that matters
[31:21]
because it's all about community and family.
[31:22]
And we put all that aside and we come together as a group
[31:26]
and remember that you have to be a decent person to come out
[31:28]
to do this and that we should just care about each other
[31:31]
and not worry about all that other noise.
[31:33]
Absolutely. Well said. Thank you guys. Congratulations.
[31:39]
Oh, yes, we're gonna,
[31:54]
I am not gonna run bail
[32:08]
on it's covering.
[32:10]
We're framing it for him for Oh, good. Excellent.
[35:36]
Yes. Can you take more over there?
[35:39]
I'm just waiting for the rest.
[35:43]
Okay, Ms. Brian, The next proclamation is Judy
[35:46]
Marie Ram d
[35:49]
Mayor, keeping in, in Represent
[35:52]
The theme of, uh, family and community.
[35:54]
I ask, um, oh, there they come.
[35:56]
You know, we all have friends, family, neighbors, some
[36:00]
of 'em sit on the council with us.
[36:02]
Oh, she's gone, um, who are in the restaurant bar
[36:07]
or tasting room industry.
[36:09]
And but when we look at the industry at itself,
[36:12]
there's almost 40,000 people that are employed
[36:15]
through the industry.
[36:17]
And millions and millions of dollars are
[36:18]
that are directed back to our economy.
[36:21]
So this is a great honor that I get to read this,
[36:25]
whereas the city of El Paso is proud
[36:26]
to recognize individuals
[36:28]
and organizations who have demonstrated
[36:31]
explanatory leadership, dedication, respect
[36:34]
to the residents of our community.
[36:36]
And whereas Darden Restaurant's Diamond Club status is an
[36:41]
honor awarded annually
[36:42]
to the general manager across the nation
[36:45]
who exhibits strong leadership,
[36:47]
top financial performance in the previous fiscal year.
[36:51]
Whereas Judy Marie Remo, general manager
[36:55]
of Ruth's Chris Steakhouse in El Paso has earned this
[36:59]
prestigious award, uh, the doctrine
[37:02]
restaurant Diamond Club status,
[37:04]
and for her unwavering devotion
[37:07]
to service this past, uh, fiscal year.
[37:09]
Whereas Judy Marie Remo is one of four among four Mayor,
[37:14]
uh, Ruth Chris, general managers in North America to,
[37:17]
to be acknowledged with this award.
[37:19]
Whereas to quote Ruth Chris's president,
[37:22]
Judy Marie leads a dedicated team
[37:24]
that is passionate about our food, taking care of our guests
[37:28]
and their community, ultimately making El Paso Ruth's Chris,
[37:32]
a warm and welcoming place to work and to dine.
[37:35]
Whereas the Ruth Chris team, which is includes front
[37:39]
of the house, back of the house positions, is a reflection
[37:42]
of the welcoming culture that defines El Paso hospitality,
[37:47]
showcasing the high standards of care, community spirit
[37:51]
to our residents and business consistently uphold it now,
[37:55]
therefore be, be it proclaimed by the mayor
[37:57]
and council of the city of El Paso
[38:00]
that December 16th, 2025 shall be known as Judy Marie Remo
[38:05]
and Ruth Chris' Day. Thank you so
[38:07]
Much, Both signed
[38:12]
by the honorable Mr. Bernard Johnson's mayor.
[38:15]
Ah,
[38:17]
Well good morning.
[38:18]
Good morning. Thank you.
[38:20]
Um, I, I heard my name and that's very flattering,
[38:24]
but as like any leader would share, um, it's,
[38:28]
it's not really us.
[38:29]
It's all these individuals behind me.
[38:32]
And this is Ruth Chris, team 9 1 5.
[38:37]
So I'm really excited to have them support not just me,
[38:40]
but also the city for those that don't know about us.
[38:43]
Um, in August 16th, 2016, um,
[38:47]
Ruth Chris Steakhouse opened their doors,
[38:50]
the red double French doors here at the fountains of Farah.
[38:53]
Um, our restaurant was established originally in New
[38:57]
Orleans, Louisiana, and,
[38:59]
but we opened our doors here in El Paso, Texas.
[39:01]
Our, our vision is to be the most beloved steakhouse here,
[39:05]
um, in the state of Texas.
[39:07]
We actually have over five locations in the state of Texas
[39:10]
of Ruth Kris Steakhouse.
[39:12]
But as our team vision, we wanted people to know
[39:15]
who 9 1 5 is.
[39:17]
When you think of Texas, um, you know,
[39:20]
I'm a little guilty sometimes when you think of Texas,
[39:22]
you might think of Dallas, Austin, or Houston,
[39:26]
but some people forget about Team 9 1 5 El Paso.
[39:30]
And my team, as well as my vision is
[39:33]
to make sure people know that El Paso is here.
[39:36]
It is an incredible city, it is a growing city,
[39:40]
and we want people to know that you can come pass
[39:43]
through El Paso
[39:44]
or come visit us here at, um, El Paso,
[39:47]
the fountains of Farrah.
[39:48]
So I'm super excited, um, that we're here
[39:51]
and we're here to stay and we're here to grow.
[39:54]
Uh, for those, um, that have not joined us
[39:56]
before, I want you to know that white linens do not,
[40:00]
do not let it scare you.
[40:02]
We are here to serve you from, from the northeast
[40:07]
to horizon to con we want you to, um, come check us out.
[40:12]
And here our sizzling plates, um, that I, that is our, one
[40:16]
of our competitive advantages is to be fine dining
[40:19]
that's approachable.
[40:20]
And we thank the community of El Paso
[40:24]
who has supported us since 2016.
[40:27]
I know I see some familiar faces, um, in front of me,
[40:32]
but also a lot of familiar faces in the community.
[40:34]
And we just wanna say thank you on behalf
[40:37]
of my executive chef, a Don DeLillo, my manager,
[40:41]
Joan, my other manager.
[40:43]
Fernie, we just wanna say thank you so much
[40:45]
for continuing to support us.
[40:47]
We understand that El Paso has an incredible amount of, um,
[40:52]
numbers of options of beautiful, amazing restaurants,
[40:56]
and we are just happy to just be one of your selections.
[40:59]
So we appreciate that.
[41:00]
I do wanna take the time just to say
[41:02]
and introduce to, um, my team here.
[41:05]
I do have Nadiem.
[41:06]
He's part of our private sales coordinator.
[41:09]
Christian is actually one of our servers.
[41:11]
Diana is one of my key employees
[41:13]
that also have serve you as well.
[41:15]
And then we have Marlene who makes all your cocktails.
[41:17]
So just ask her, um, Alfredo runs all your food.
[41:22]
Matthew right behind me also runs your food.
[41:25]
Augustine, if you love the bread pudding
[41:27]
or creme brulee, he is your go-to individual.
[41:31]
Um, right behind him is Caleb Castillo.
[41:35]
He also prepares all your happy birthday
[41:38]
celebration, special occasions.
[41:40]
And then of course, Fernie here, one of my managers as well
[41:43]
as our traveling coach who opened Puerto Rico
[41:46]
and Rochester, Minnesota with me.
[41:49]
And then Joan Ruan, um, also one of my, uh,
[41:53]
right hand, um, managers.
[41:54]
So on behalf of Team El Paso, thank you for continuing
[41:58]
to support us and I look forward
[42:00]
to seeing you all tonight at Happy Hour.
[42:05]
Representative Liman.
[42:09]
Thank you, mayor. Representative Fierro, always,
[42:14]
whenever there is a discussion, will ask me.
[42:16]
Were you there? Were you there in the past when
[42:19]
things have been signed?
[42:21]
I was there when you opened in 2016
[42:23]
as a city representative.
[42:25]
Awesome. And it was a fabulous event.
[42:27]
We got to see the, uh, mayor when he sliced
[42:31]
that first steak that came out,
[42:33]
it was just a wonderful event.
[42:36]
And so I can tell you that special events in my life,
[42:40]
my birthday are anniversary, are always spent at Ruth Chris.
[42:45]
So thank you for the excellent service
[42:47]
that you provide to this community.
[42:49]
Thank you. I appreciate we know
[42:51]
your favorite table, by the way,
[42:54]
And the mayors too. Yes.
[42:55]
Oh yes. In
[42:57]
The corner tables next To mine. Exactly.
[42:58]
Representative Chavez,
[43:00]
Thank you Mayor.
[43:01]
And I had the pleasure of meeting you just earlier this day,
[43:04]
um, this morning.
[43:06]
And of course I've seen you at the restaurant before,
[43:09]
but I just wanna congratulate you.
[43:11]
I have a very special place in my heart
[43:12]
for people in the hospitality industry.
[43:14]
I know this is an extremely busy month for all of you.
[43:17]
So we thank you for taking the time out of making your,
[43:20]
your bread pudding and everything else this morning,
[43:22]
which I know you're probably in a hurry to get back
[43:24]
to doing, uh, but we will be there to enjoy it.
[43:27]
And congratulations
[43:28]
and please give a shout out to everybody
[43:30]
that's working in the restaurant. Awesome.
[43:32]
Thank you. Appreciate
[43:33]
It. Yeah. And, and a
[43:34]
big congratulations to you guys on the,
[43:36]
the Diamond, uh, award that you received.
[43:39]
But I do wanna talk a little bit about your founder in
[43:41]
1965 in New Orleans.
[43:43]
Uh, when Ruth, uh, uh, Tel founded, uh, Ruth Chris,
[43:48]
she was a single mother who mortgaged her home
[43:51]
to buy a small steakhouse called Chris Steakhouse.
[43:56]
And after it burned down, she decided she wanted
[43:59]
to reopen another restaurant
[44:01]
and she renamed the Steakhouse Ruth Chris.
[44:05]
So, and now you have over a hundred locations under the
[44:07]
Darden umbrella.
[44:09]
And for you to have put El Paso on the map like you've
[44:12]
done, is incredible.
[44:14]
So you are in the top
[44:16]
of all the Ruth Chris's in the country.
[44:19]
Tough forest, sir. Oh, she's what? It's
[44:22]
Top four outta six. Top
[44:23]
Four, yeah.
[44:25]
Beating all Florida and being, well,
[44:27]
We gotta get to number one.
[44:28]
Okay. We're top four. We gotta get to
[44:29]
Number some work to be done. Yeah,
[44:31]
There's some work to be done.
[44:34]
We gotta get to number one,
[44:35]
but that is incredible to be number four in the Ruth Chris,
[44:39]
uh, franchisees throughout not only the US
[44:42]
but internationally as well.
[44:43]
So a big congratulations to you guys
[44:45]
and remember the follow the sizzle
[44:48]
and be the Ruth of your restaurant.
[44:50]
How's that? There you go. Thank you. Congratulations.
[44:52]
You guys
[45:21]
Up, you, you
[47:37]
And the final proclamation this morning is Lata Patia
[47:40]
75th year anniversary.
[47:44]
Good morning everyone. Representative Limon.
[47:47]
Good morning. Good morning mayor.
[47:51]
So we're going to continue, um,
[47:54]
with wonderful food from our city.
[47:57]
This is a proclamation from the city of El Paso.
[48:00]
Whereas La Patia Inc first opened its doors on
[48:04]
September 20th, 1950, originally
[48:08]
as a corn mill tortilla
[48:11]
and tamal factory in Isleta, Texas by Marcellino
[48:15]
and Felipa Galvan.
[48:17]
And whereas in 1970, the Galvan family sold Lata Patia
[48:22]
to a partnership which included Gus Rawles,
[48:26]
Ted Rawless, and former El Paso Mayor Ray Alazar.
[48:31]
And whereas in March, 1979,
[48:34]
local political trailblazer, Alicia Rosen Kranz Chacon,
[48:39]
a lifelong resident of Isleta,
[48:42]
purchased Lata Patia in partnership with Edward Alvarez.
[48:47]
And whereas in 1994,
[48:50]
Alicia r Chacon sold the business to her sister
[48:54]
Esther Rosenkranz, who along with her sister,
[48:57]
birthed them on si vice preserved the authenticity
[49:01]
and warmth that defined Laia over decades.
[49:06]
And whereas in 2020 Lada Am Rosen Kranz daughter
[49:11]
of Esther Rosen Kranz inherited the business as well
[49:15]
as her mother's spirit
[49:17]
and devotion to continuing the success
[49:20]
of the family enterprise.
[49:23]
And whereas Lata Patia signature stone mill ground corn
[49:27]
for tortillas and tamales, as well
[49:30]
as traditionally prepared ingredients such as Nx, Tamal,
[49:34]
and Stone Mill Ground, Chile, Colorado continue
[49:38]
to be its distinguished hallmark and source of pride
[49:42]
and wears in recognition
[49:44]
and gratitude to its employees for their passion, devotion,
[49:48]
and service to traditionally crafted Mexican food products,
[49:53]
which are renowned throughout the El Paso community,
[49:56]
and wears in deep appreciation to its individual customers,
[50:01]
businesses, and institutions whose loyal Patronist has
[50:05]
supported and sustained the continued growth
[50:08]
of Lata Batia Inc for the last 75 years.
[50:12]
Now therefore be it proclaimed by the Mayor
[50:15]
and council of the city of El Paso,
[50:17]
that this will be Lata Patia 75 year anniversary
[50:22]
day signed by the Honorable Mayor Renard Johnson.
[50:27]
Thank you. Thank you. Good morning.
[50:31]
Good morning. Thank you, mayor. Thank you City Council.
[50:34]
It's an honor to be here, uh, with our community.
[50:37]
It's, um, a great privilege to be able to,
[50:40]
to run the business with my cousin Karl La Vice.
[50:43]
And we, we keep the family tradition alive every day.
[50:46]
It's in our heart and our blood and we love our community.
[50:50]
We love what we do, and we're so grateful for our loyal, uh,
[50:55]
customers and our heart, uh, felt thanks
[50:58]
and gratitude to our, to the heart of our members,
[51:01]
the people who work at La Patia.
[51:04]
And so we have with us two, two people who are part
[51:07]
of the heart of Laia who have been there since 1988,
[51:11]
I think even before them.
[51:13]
No
[51:32]
Good morning to everyone.
[51:34]
As Laura mentioned, it is a privilege to be here, especially
[51:37]
because we're celebrating, uh, this family owned business
[51:41]
that, um, has done nothing but bring joy to its community.
[51:45]
Uh, we're so thankful to the community
[51:47]
that has supported us throughout all of these years.
[51:49]
I think the generations that ran this business
[51:52]
before us would, would be proud
[51:55]
because, uh, not one recipe has been changed.
[51:58]
You know, that true. When we think of our business,
[52:01]
we think tradition that is a word that defines us.
[52:04]
Nothing changes, but the year, but our food tastes the same.
[52:08]
And that pride that, that we have in the products
[52:12]
that we make, um, really all of our gratitude is
[52:17]
to our employees, 26 of whom are represented by
[52:22]
Norma and Walter here today.
[52:25]
Um, they take such a,
[52:27]
a pride in every little aspect of what they do.
[52:30]
Uh, this, they, we wish all the employees could have come,
[52:34]
they would've been proud to,
[52:36]
but somebody's gotta be making the tamales right now,
[52:39]
especially at this time of year.
[52:41]
And so, you know, I don't know Norm,
[52:50]
Oh,
[53:08]
Walter
[53:13]
Eno
[53:39]
Mayor, um, just, uh, a short story.
[53:43]
Um, so as a good friend of Alicia Chacos,
[53:47]
who originally owned it, when she was appointed
[53:51]
as the Small Business Administration director
[53:55]
by Jimmy Carter, that's when the, the Lata Patia was sold
[53:58]
to Lara's mother Esther.
[54:02]
And when Laura was in college, I remember a conversation,
[54:07]
um, Alicia Esther and George McCall
[54:11]
and I were sitting there and George turned around
[54:15]
and looked at Esther
[54:16]
and said, when is Laura going to learn
[54:20]
the business of La Patia?
[54:22]
She was in college. There were plans, there were things
[54:25]
that she was going to do and how life changes.
[54:30]
And she came forth
[54:31]
and has inherited the business, a long standing business,
[54:36]
a long standing business.
[54:37]
I thought Ruth Chris, 2016 and going strong.
[54:41]
But this is since September 20th, 1950.
[54:46]
And there are stories in the community
[54:49]
how Isleta students would go to Laia at lunch
[54:53]
and order atal and a tortilla, and that was their lunch.
[54:58]
And so, so many of the kids, well adults now amongst us, um,
[55:02]
that that share that story.
[55:04]
And so just so that you will know that tamales that
[55:08]
we all receive from destination El Paso are from Latia.
[55:12]
Ah, so that when you eat those, you'll understand.
[55:16]
And that also was a collaboration that started oh,
[55:21]
back when I was on council and referred them to Laia
[55:24]
and said, these are literally the best in the valley.
[55:29]
And so there's another story, mayor, that when, um,
[55:32]
representative Paul Moreno was at the State House,
[55:36]
that there was a Christmas event,
[55:38]
and it was also perfectly organized
[55:42]
that they knew the flight
[55:43]
that Southwest Airlines would take in the morning.
[55:46]
They delivered the tamales hot, they were put on the plane,
[55:51]
they were taken and delivered to Austin.
[55:53]
And Paul Moreno would distribute tamales
[55:55]
at the, at the capitol.
[55:57]
Wow. So this is their, this is their story.
[56:00]
And when you think of tortillas,
[56:02]
and they don't just make tortillas for the restaurant,
[56:06]
they make tortillas for the industry, for restaurants.
[56:09]
And perhaps you could share a few of them if you can.
[56:13]
I don't know that you can, but if you can,
[56:15]
I I think they would be proud too.
[56:17]
Okay. Then we, Uh, you know,
[56:18]
we support their success, of course.
[56:20]
Uh, and, uh, we've been, uh, we've had a longstanding, uh,
[56:24]
agreement with Chico Tacos, for example.
[56:26]
Uh, so when Walter wakes up every morning at three o'clock
[56:30]
to begin the tortilla production with his team,
[56:33]
we distribute daily, um, we have a driver
[56:36]
that goes out continuously to Chico Tacos
[56:38]
to give them the product that they need
[56:40]
to make their famous rolled tacos, which I love.
[56:44]
And we have other taquerias, um,
[56:47]
and other businesses in town.
[56:48]
And our tortilla is special
[56:50]
because ours is made specifically for frying.
[56:54]
And so it fries really nice and crispy
[56:56]
and uh, that's, that's one of the things that we're known
[56:59]
for, apart from our delicious tamales.
[57:02]
Well, now that we're hungry, well
[57:06]
what an incredible, you know, everyone has a story,
[57:09]
but your story is, is certainly incredible
[57:11]
and congratulations to LADA
[57:14]
and the entire team on being locally owned
[57:17]
for over 75 years.
[57:19]
That is hard to do.
[57:22]
I mean, not many businesses last that long.
[57:24]
And you guys, you mentioned it earlier,
[57:26]
you've been a neighborhood favorite for many, many,
[57:28]
many years and you've created so many memories for
[57:32]
so many people in the El Paso Borderland region
[57:34]
and we can't thank you enough.
[57:36]
So we're just getting to 75.
[57:39]
There's gonna be more success coming out
[57:41]
of La la Tap's restaurant and we're gonna continue to grow.
[57:44]
So thank you guys for all that you do
[57:46]
for El Paso and for this region.
[57:48]
And your story is incredible.
[57:49]
But we've gotta get to another 75 years. Yes.
[57:52]
All congratulations guys. Thank you.
[58:27]
And then we'll
[58:39]
I get you to come right there, please.
[58:43]
Right there. Perfect. That looks great. Alright. Ready?
[58:46]
Big smiles. Ready?
[58:48]
1, 2, 3, 19, 1.
[58:53]
Ready? 1, 2, 3. One more. One more.
[59:00]
1, 2, 3.
[59:20]
Counsel, we have about three minutes until roll call.
[59:40]
You're fine.
[1:02:00]
Next one. Your witness. Witness.
[1:02:02]
Okay, Ms. Friend, I think we're ready to go.
[1:02:05]
Yes, mayor. Good morning. This is a meeting
[1:02:06]
of the El Paso City Council for Tuesday,
[1:02:08]
December 16th, 2025.
[1:02:10]
Mayor Johnson is present
[1:02:12]
and presiding in council chambers, along
[1:02:13]
with Representative Acevedo, representative Malona Rocha,
[1:02:17]
representative reco alternate mayor Prom Firo
[1:02:20]
Representative, Limon Representative Canales.
[1:02:24]
It is 10:00 AM Will everyone please silence your electronic
[1:02:27]
devices so as not to disturb the meeting
[1:02:30]
and rise for the invocation delivered by El Paso Police,
[1:02:33]
senior chaplain David Mayfield.
[1:02:38]
Good morning. Good morning Mayor Council,
[1:02:43]
if you would allow me some leeway.
[1:02:47]
It's been a tough week in a season
[1:02:52]
that is almost universally acknowledge
[1:02:57]
to be a season of peace of brotherhood.
[1:03:03]
That peace has been shattered from
[1:03:09]
Bondi Beach in Australia all the way to Brown University.
[1:03:12]
Basically in our own backyard.
[1:03:18]
A piece shattered by people so filled with
[1:03:24]
animus, with hatred that
[1:03:28]
the only way they could express themselves was through
[1:03:32]
violence against innocent people.
[1:03:38]
I would ask before I deliver the invocation
[1:03:42]
that those present join me in a moment
[1:03:44]
of silence in remembrance, particularly for those
[1:03:49]
at Brown University,
[1:03:50]
but for all victims
[1:03:52]
of senseless violence around the world.
[1:03:59]
Let us contemplate peace.
[1:04:30]
Thank you. And now those who are are of a mind,
[1:04:35]
join me as I pray.
[1:04:41]
Holy one. We come together today with grateful hearts
[1:04:44]
for the privilege of serving this community
[1:04:47]
as we gather in this season.
[1:04:50]
When many observe holidays of light, hope
[1:04:53]
and renewal, we pause to honor the rich diversity
[1:04:57]
that shapes our city.
[1:05:00]
May the spirit of compassion found in these celebrations
[1:05:04]
guide our thoughts and actions.
[1:05:08]
Grant to these leaders the wisdom to listen deeply,
[1:05:12]
the patience to understand one another
[1:05:15]
and the courage to choose what is right over what is easy.
[1:05:22]
Help them embody servant leadership, placing the wellbeing
[1:05:27]
of neighbors above personal gain, seeking solutions
[1:05:31]
that uplift the most vulnerable
[1:05:34]
and stewarding resources with integrity.
[1:05:39]
We ask your blessing on every conversation, every decision
[1:05:44]
and every moment of deliberation.
[1:05:48]
May cooperation rise above division,
[1:05:51]
respect temper disagreement,
[1:05:54]
and a shared commitment to the common good.
[1:05:57]
Lead the way forward. Strengthen
[1:06:02]
all who serve elected officials, staff
[1:06:06]
and citizens alike, so
[1:06:08]
that together we may build a community marked by justice,
[1:06:13]
safety, and opportunity for all.
[1:06:18]
We pray this in the name of the Father,
[1:06:20]
the Son, and the Holy Spirit.
[1:06:22]
Amen. Thank you
[1:06:25]
Chaplain Mayfield. Thank you.
[1:06:26]
That was well
[1:06:27]
done Ms. Prime.
[1:06:31]
Yes Mayor. That brings us to
[1:06:34]
public comment on consent agenda and regular agenda items.
[1:06:39]
This morning we have Ms. Turner that signed up
[1:06:41]
to speak on item number 20 of the consent agenda.
[1:06:47]
And item 20 is the award
[1:06:49]
of solicitation 2026 dash 0 0 6 vehicle Washington,
[1:06:53]
sun City Echo Wash LLC.
[1:06:55]
Good morning Ms. Turner. You have three minutes.
[1:06:57]
Good morning. Good, good morning.
[1:06:58]
Before I get started on this, I'd like to issue a challenge.
[1:07:02]
If you're somebody from California between here
[1:07:04]
and New York City, I can guarantee you one thing,
[1:07:08]
the best Mexican food can be found here in El Paso, Texas.
[1:07:12]
And I can guarantee you that there's not anybody in Austin,
[1:07:17]
San Antonio, Dallas
[1:07:19]
or Houston, they can do a better burrito than
[1:07:22]
this hillbilly from Kentucky.
[1:07:25]
Now on
[1:07:27]
to item twenty a hundred seventy eight point
[1:07:32]
18% increase.
[1:07:33]
And I can guarantee you you didn't double the number
[1:07:37]
of police vehicles.
[1:07:41]
So somebody's got to explain this.
[1:07:44]
Somebody has to explain this.
[1:07:47]
You went from an initial $198,000 contract to
[1:07:54]
550,800.
[1:07:57]
So what are we washing?
[1:08:02]
There's nobody here. Okay.
[1:08:04]
Can you have somebody get to me
[1:08:06]
and explain to me why this has gone up?
[1:08:10]
'cause I know you didn't buy vehicles
[1:08:11]
for the police department to justify this.
[1:08:18]
Y'all are allowed to talk. You know that Right?
[1:08:21]
Under local government codes,
[1:08:23]
you can provide a factual answer
[1:08:24]
and you can provide, tell them to do something.
[1:08:32]
So that's my concern.
[1:08:36]
178 point 18% increase.
[1:08:40]
And I know you haven't bought
[1:08:42]
enough vehicles to justify that. Alright, thank you
[1:08:47]
Ms. Turner also signed up for item 38.
[1:08:49]
And this is discussion
[1:08:50]
and action to direct El Paso water utilities to schedule
[1:08:53]
and conduct eight city council district community meetings
[1:08:56]
regarding their proposed budget and rate increase.
[1:09:00]
Let me point out to you that one,
[1:09:03]
the PSB board doesn't represent, represent all El Paso ones.
[1:09:07]
There is not a single elderly person sitting on that board
[1:09:11]
who lives on a fixed income
[1:09:13]
who can put in that view.
[1:09:17]
Apparently PSB doesn't care.
[1:09:20]
And since you all do the appointing, you don't care.
[1:09:24]
So I'm gonna ask you that you change that.
[1:09:27]
The next thing I'm gonna point out is yes,
[1:09:30]
we need these meetings
[1:09:31]
because let me explain something to you.
[1:09:34]
I used in the last 14 months, I never broke two CCF
[1:09:39]
for water, but I got charged for five CCF to replace
[1:09:43]
and I got paid charged for five CCF for sewer.
[1:09:49]
I don't mind paying for what I use,
[1:09:52]
but I object to paying for what I'm not.
[1:09:55]
I'm not gonna pay for something that I'm not using.
[1:09:58]
And this is what's happening.
[1:10:00]
This is what's happening with via PSB.
[1:10:05]
Uh, these are, this is outrageous.
[1:10:10]
They seldom talk to the people. They seldom listen.
[1:10:15]
Communication is more than just talking. It is listening.
[1:10:19]
And they don't listen. They don't care.
[1:10:21]
And my God, I'm gonna see you got the water,
[1:10:26]
electric and gas probably gonna see
[1:10:30]
50% increase in our utility costs.
[1:10:35]
How are people supposed
[1:10:37]
who live on a fixed income supposed to survive?
[1:10:41]
Okay, I want y'all to think about that.
[1:10:44]
I want you to think about adding somebody who will represent
[1:10:47]
the disabled, not only the disabled community,
[1:10:50]
but the elderly community
[1:10:52]
and those living on the fixed income on the PSB board.
[1:10:55]
That voice has to be there
[1:10:57]
and that is your all's responsibility
[1:11:00]
to make it happen. Thank you.
[1:11:01]
Thank you Ms. Turner. And Ms. Turner signed up
[1:11:03]
for item 48, and this is discussion
[1:11:06]
and action on a resolution authorizing the city manager
[1:11:08]
to execute a first amendment to
[1:11:10]
that certain three 80 economic development program agreement
[1:11:13]
between the state of El Paso and Mills Plaza Properties.
[1:11:19]
Sorry, I forgot about
[1:11:20]
that one. You said 48?
[1:11:25]
Yes, ma'am. That the three 80? Yes.
[1:11:30]
Oh, I totally object to any three 80 agreement.
[1:11:33]
You constantly give out our tax dollars
[1:11:36]
and we get nothing in return.
[1:11:40]
You turn around
[1:11:41]
and tell us that, oh, we're going
[1:11:44]
to charge you x dollars a month just to drive on the roads.
[1:11:48]
Uh, and what it comes down to is,
[1:11:53]
what I see is you serve the city council of El Paso,
[1:11:57]
Texas does not serve all El Paso citizens.
[1:12:00]
You serve about 200 people.
[1:12:03]
We have billionaires
[1:12:04]
who get our tax money, they don't need it.
[1:12:06]
We have multimillionaires
[1:12:08]
who get our tax dollars, they don't need it.
[1:12:11]
And then you turn around and charge us extra
[1:12:15]
for things we've already paid for. Thank you.
[1:12:18]
Thank you Ms. Hernia, Mayor and counsel.
[1:12:20]
On item number 20, uh, the increase for the vehicle wash,
[1:12:24]
we went from a quantity of 500 vehicles to 900 vehicles.
[1:12:29]
In addition, they did add, um, an option for hand washing
[1:12:33]
for certain specialty vehicles as well.
[1:12:36]
So from 500 vehicles to 900 to 900. Okay, thank you.
[1:12:40]
All right, Ms. Brown, believe that
[1:12:41]
brings us to call to the public.
[1:12:43]
Yes. Mayor, that brings us to call to the public.
[1:12:46]
And the El Paso City Council is local government body
[1:12:49]
charged with serving the citizens.
[1:12:50]
And the meetings must be focused on the meeting of charge.
[1:12:52]
The city council meetings are public meetings under the
[1:12:55]
Texas Open Meetings Act.
[1:12:56]
Public comment is an accommodation
[1:12:58]
and not a requirement of city council.
[1:13:00]
All persons and attendance are expected
[1:13:01]
to displace civility in the quorum that is respectful
[1:13:04]
to other persons without the use of insulting, profane,
[1:13:06]
threatening, or abusive language.
[1:13:08]
Public comment will not be used for personal attacks,
[1:13:10]
nor may any member of the public use this form
[1:13:12]
for political statements or campaigning.
[1:13:14]
Please note that during call to the public,
[1:13:16]
the city council may not deliberate
[1:13:17]
or decide any subject that is not on the agenda.
[1:13:19]
However, council may propose
[1:13:20]
that a topic brought forth be posted on a future agenda.
[1:13:25]
This morning we have eight members of the public
[1:13:27]
that signed up to speak.
[1:13:28]
The first person is Elizabeth Crawford. Ms.
[1:13:31]
Crawford's topic is Bethlehem and choosing life.
[1:13:34]
Good morning, Ms. Crawford Star six, please.
[1:13:40]
Ms. Crawford
[1:13:42]
Star six to unmute your telephone.
[1:13:45]
Thank you, ma'am. Good morning. Good morning. Three minutes.
[1:13:47]
Thank you. Good morning. In the Hebrew scripture,
[1:13:50]
centuries before the advent of Jesus,
[1:13:52]
the prophet Micah Penn's words
[1:13:54]
of scripture inspired by the Holy Spirit.
[1:13:56]
But thou bethlehem, thou thou belittle
[1:13:59]
among the thousands of Judah.
[1:14:00]
Yet out of de shall he come forth unto me, that is
[1:14:03]
to be ruler in Israel, who's going forth has been from
[1:14:06]
of old, from everlasting.
[1:14:08]
In mid-November, our world focused on the International
[1:14:11]
Climate Conference held in Belen, Brazil.
[1:14:14]
In 2001 to three, I had the privilege of living
[1:14:16]
and serving in that city of Belan,
[1:14:19]
teaching English at Amazon Valley Academy
[1:14:21]
and helping a little with my roommate's
[1:14:22]
ministry to the street children.
[1:14:24]
The word in Spanish, Navida and Portuguese is Al.
[1:14:28]
Al is a time when many Brazilian people remember an event
[1:14:30]
that took place centuries ago.
[1:14:32]
In, in Lan is Portuguese for Bethlehem.
[1:14:36]
My roommate Lynn from Great Britain worked
[1:14:38]
for almost 20 years with Brazil street children.
[1:14:41]
She told me one day, you know,
[1:14:42]
these kids think Jesus was actually born here.
[1:14:45]
We laugh because it's cute,
[1:14:47]
but in many ways that lesson is profound.
[1:14:49]
The incarnation God with us, the Christ child,
[1:14:52]
he knows the suffering of mankind
[1:14:55]
that is deeply meaningful in a place such
[1:14:57]
as the Lang Brazil, where there's unspeakably deep
[1:14:59]
suffering, kids often born to parents who don't want them
[1:15:02]
conceived in the wild party atmosphere that permeates much
[1:15:05]
of the culture, throwaway kids suffering
[1:15:08]
generation after generation.
[1:15:10]
In our nation, we also have countless throwaway kids.
[1:15:14]
Just a different method.
[1:15:15]
The majority of people use to throw, throw kids away.
[1:15:20]
The abortion industry is exploding in New Mexico
[1:15:23]
and the culture is suffering.
[1:15:25]
I was in shock the first time I went to Albuquerque,
[1:15:27]
as you know, it's a rough, dangerous city.
[1:15:29]
And New Mexico Pres upon young ladies from El Paso
[1:15:32]
among other ways via abortion pills we're very relieved
[1:15:36]
that now Texans, as of December 1st, are being encouraged
[1:15:39]
to file lawsuits against those shipping abortion pills into
[1:15:42]
Texas to sue those responsible for the sending
[1:15:45]
of those abortion bills.
[1:15:47]
We know these are very tough times financially for all
[1:15:49]
of us, and worries about finances drives many couples
[1:15:52]
to abort, but there's absolutely no reason to do this.
[1:15:55]
El Paso is full of pro-lifers who would be thrilled,
[1:15:58]
so honored to help couples struggling
[1:16:01]
with unplanned pregnancies and raising their kids.
[1:16:04]
A beautiful name given to Jesus is Emmanuel.
[1:16:07]
God with us, for those who know Christ the Savior,
[1:16:09]
he has promised to be with his children
[1:16:11]
and care for them along all the journey of life, the days
[1:16:14]
of rejoicing and the days of hardship.
[1:16:17]
Emmanuel God with us.
[1:16:19]
And she shall bring forth a son
[1:16:21]
and now shall call his name Jesus.
[1:16:24]
They shall call his name Emmanuel,
[1:16:26]
which being interpreted is God with us.
[1:16:29]
Thank you and hope you have a very good advent season.
[1:16:32]
And Avida, thank you.
[1:16:34]
Thank you, thank you. The next speaker is Gloria Kran.
[1:16:42]
And for, for her comment, she will be speaking in Spanish.
[1:16:45]
If you wanna follow along with simultaneous translation,
[1:16:48]
please scan the QR code on the screen.
[1:16:53]
Yes. Good. Good morning. Good morning, ma'am. You have
[1:16:55]
But please, um, I would like to speak
[1:16:57]
to Mayor Johnson, please.
[1:16:58]
There, there is a reason that I'm here if he,
[1:17:03]
I can wait or
[1:17:06]
He's, he's returning to the day.
[1:17:07]
Yes, ma'am.
[1:17:09]
Uh, thank you.
[1:17:18]
Good morning. Good morning. My name is Gloria Koran.
[1:17:22]
I am a widow and I live on a fixed income.
[1:17:26]
This, this happened in 1996.
[1:17:30]
My sister, Luca Maria
[1:17:32]
and I, uh, As the city
[1:17:37]
for a loan for house repairs.
[1:17:40]
Um, the loan was accepted, the repairs were made
[1:17:45]
and the payments began from that time
[1:17:50]
to this time, it's been 29 years
[1:17:56]
until, until a supervisor Ellizabeth
[1:18:01]
called me and she said, um,
[1:18:05]
with the city, we have no way of proving anything.
[1:18:10]
We don't know if you pay, if you did not pay,
[1:18:14]
how much were you paying?
[1:18:16]
Do you remember? She asked me,
[1:18:18]
do you remember how much you were paying?
[1:18:20]
And I said, ma'am, my sister Lu was the one
[1:18:24]
that was making the payments,
[1:18:26]
but she, she added, I think that you still owe us the money.
[1:18:31]
So I'm gonna open another account. Yeah.
[1:18:34]
And, uh, since you owe us the money, your house has to be
[1:18:39]
assured with insurance.
[1:18:42]
So she did, and she demanded the insurance.
[1:18:46]
From there, we started looking for an insurance,
[1:18:50]
but there was no way here in El Paso that no insurance
[1:18:55]
would ensure that he
[1:18:58]
lock roof, nobody.
[1:19:01]
So she just kept quiet and she opened the account
[1:19:05]
and I'm still paying for the roof
[1:19:08]
and the house doesn't have a roof.
[1:19:11]
And that is the reason that I've been asking for help
[1:19:14]
for almost years now.
[1:19:16]
Um, finally the city,
[1:19:21]
the city introduced me to the manager,
[1:19:25]
the grant manager, um, Rick,
[1:19:30]
he was the, uh, the city, uh, he was supposed
[1:19:33]
to or okay.
[1:19:35]
He asked me for, for what, what was the problem?
[1:19:38]
I explained it to him. He was the grant manager compliance.
[1:19:43]
And he asked me, what is the problem? So I explained it.
[1:19:46]
He took all the information
[1:19:47]
and he said, we are gonna do your roof.
[1:19:50]
Um, my assistant will be going to your house
[1:19:53]
and he's gonna tell you
[1:19:55]
to move whatever the instructions were.
[1:19:58]
And he did. His, his assistant was in my house four
[1:20:03]
or five times and he did.
[1:20:05]
And I waited and I just waited for my turn
[1:20:10]
for more than 20 months.
[1:20:13]
And it was a lie. A lie.
[1:20:16]
And then another city manager, he also suggested you.
[1:20:20]
Thank you, ma'am. You've reached the three minute limit.
[1:20:22]
Mr. Johnson, please, I ask you
[1:20:25]
once again, thank you, maam.
[1:20:26]
In the name of God, please give me one appointment.
[1:20:30]
Yes, thank you. Before, but please Mr. Johnson. Thank you.
[1:20:33]
Okay, thank you. Does not even The
[1:20:35]
Next speaker is Claudia Contrera Siller.
[1:20:39]
And her topic is Christmas.
[1:20:41]
She will be followed by Ron Cuomo. Good morning.
[1:20:45]
Good morning. Good morning. Merry Christmas everybody.
[1:20:47]
Emmanuel God with us.
[1:20:49]
Um, I'm hosting a painting party, a Christmas painting party
[1:20:53]
to back the blue cats
[1:20:55]
and dogs of the city fighting animal cruelty.
[1:20:58]
Uh, there's a time for everything.
[1:21:00]
A time to fight animal cruelty, and a time to celebrate
[1:21:03]
and honor the people that are doing the hard work.
[1:21:06]
And I got two confirmations from officers also.
[1:21:10]
Animal services is going at 11.
[1:21:12]
They're taking a kitten, doing a presentation,
[1:21:15]
educational presentation.
[1:21:17]
They're also taking a backdrop
[1:21:19]
and sunny the mast from animal services.
[1:21:22]
I wanna wish a merry Christmas to everybody,
[1:21:25]
especially the ones that work outside in the weather
[1:21:29]
and during the weather and all law
[1:21:30]
enforcement, uh, agencies.
[1:21:34]
Uh, I'm very thankful, uh, to be a part of El Paso.
[1:21:37]
I really love advocating for the cats.
[1:21:40]
The reason I'm always here is to either advocate
[1:21:44]
for the cats against animal cruelty or to back the blue.
[1:21:48]
Those are my two priorities.
[1:21:49]
Also, I wanna, uh, thank Ms. Mack
[1:21:52]
because she hired a perfect, uh, person for the job
[1:21:56]
that has experience for the director position.
[1:22:00]
And, uh, I wanna invite her to, to the Christmas party,
[1:22:05]
to spend time with us and get to know the community.
[1:22:08]
This painting party is very special.
[1:22:10]
The community helped me prepared it, uh,
[1:22:14]
because they believe in the mission
[1:22:15]
to pitch the animal cruelty unit number
[1:22:19]
9 1 5 2 1 2 0 8 0 0.
[1:22:22]
They're doing an excellent job, just like animal services.
[1:22:26]
And since I'm an, I'm an animal advocate,
[1:22:29]
I cannot leave without saying
[1:22:31]
that more animals are being killed.
[1:22:33]
I sent an email about Fiero Street.
[1:22:36]
Four cats were murdered, sat Sunday,
[1:22:39]
and I think a dog, I'm not sure the person called me.
[1:22:41]
She was very worried.
[1:22:44]
Also, everybody knows about the black cat that was stolen
[1:22:49]
from a cat colony.
[1:22:51]
Uh, what I did, it's, I exposed the person
[1:22:54]
that it has been lying.
[1:22:56]
Saying she works with animal services is not true.
[1:22:59]
Saying she's with a rescue is not true.
[1:23:02]
And, um, the cat, uh, I most likely appear dead.
[1:23:07]
And I wanna read what she has on her Facebook.
[1:23:10]
Demons don't cry.
[1:23:12]
I become, I became a monster
[1:23:13]
because I didn't want to cry anymore.
[1:23:16]
I cried until my tears ran out and, and,
[1:23:18]
and I dried up inside.
[1:23:20]
I became one of them a demon. Okay?
[1:23:23]
A lot of people can think that she's referring
[1:23:25]
to herself, but it's not true.
[1:23:27]
She posted a cat just like the one
[1:23:29]
that was killed and stolen.
[1:23:32]
And this is referring to a Satanic ritual. Okay?
[1:23:35]
This is psychological, um, against me.
[1:23:39]
So I wanna ask,
[1:23:40]
when are the leaders gonna start fighting animal cruelty
[1:23:43]
against cats, please.
[1:23:45]
Thank you.
[1:23:47]
The next speaker is Ron Cuomo.
[1:23:49]
His topic is exercising his
[1:23:51]
constitutional rights to the Rescue.
[1:23:53]
1983 Animal Services. He'll be followed by Malik Tarik.
[1:23:57]
Mahmud,
[1:24:03]
Good morning. Morning,
[1:24:05]
Morning. Morning.
[1:24:08]
Uh, ladies
[1:24:09]
and gentlemen, you know, I I I send you a lot of stuff.
[1:24:13]
I do. Do you look at it? Do you read it?
[1:24:16]
I mean, my god, that's probably a 20th of what I receive.
[1:24:22]
It's, it's, it, it picks apart Haas,
[1:24:27]
it picks apart best friends.
[1:24:29]
It picks apart Austin pets alive.
[1:24:32]
Other cities picks apart El Paso.
[1:24:38]
What are we doing? Okay, we, we've,
[1:24:43]
I've just learned, we've hired a new director.
[1:24:46]
I hope this one's actually qualified.
[1:24:49]
I hope this one is not affiliated with best friends.
[1:24:52]
Austin Pets alive
[1:24:54]
and does not support the ha sheltering plan.
[1:24:57]
46,405 less strays were picked up in the
[1:25:01]
first four years of house.
[1:25:04]
Where did they go? How many of those dogs got killed?
[1:25:08]
How many times the rescues have
[1:25:10]
to pick up puppies under 10 weeks old, half eaten
[1:25:13]
because the strays, the person
[1:25:18]
that's in charge of the shelter, the people
[1:25:21]
that have been in charge of the shelter
[1:25:22]
for the last five years need to be removed.
[1:25:26]
They're not qualified.
[1:25:28]
And I'm speaking, let, let me just bring this up. Okay.
[1:25:33]
You guys did a positive meeting.
[1:25:35]
This positive meeting, did it come up with a, a fix
[1:25:38]
for your, your toxic work environment?
[1:25:42]
We read actual statements.
[1:25:45]
Why wasn't that brought up and fixed
[1:25:48]
before it got to the point it's at now?
[1:25:50]
Because a protected one didn't like it.
[1:25:54]
Okay, so here, let's do this again.
[1:25:58]
Who in here has done adoptions at the city
[1:26:00]
of El Paso at animal Services?
[1:26:04]
Who here has done rescue at the shelter?
[1:26:09]
How about transport?
[1:26:11]
How about the first person who was a volunteer
[1:26:14]
that was authorized to work with behavioral dogs
[1:26:19]
Who Put out more strays
[1:26:24]
across the country,
[1:26:29]
Animal services, what they put out every month
[1:26:34]
and what I was transporting out to the group I was dealing
[1:26:36]
with and I gave you a solution and I guarantee it.
[1:26:40]
Nothing was done because nothing's ever done that.
[1:26:44]
Other people suggest we, I I,
[1:26:48]
I really don't know who the director is,
[1:26:52]
but we got a new year coming up.
[1:26:54]
We'd like to hear from all of you that Haas is gone.
[1:26:58]
Best friends is band Austin Petalite is band,
[1:27:02]
and Paula Powell has absolutely nothing to do with the city
[1:27:05]
of El Paso when it comes to animal services.
[1:27:08]
Thank you, Mr. Cuomo.
[1:27:10]
The next speaker is Malik Tariq Maud topic is
[1:27:14]
regarding a press release
[1:27:16]
to condemn the terrorist attack in Australia.
[1:27:19]
Good morning. I respect respected mayor,
[1:27:23]
respected council members,
[1:27:25]
and my beautiful audience,
[1:27:31]
peace and blessings of God be with you all.
[1:27:35]
I'm Maik Maud Imam
[1:27:38]
and missionary of Amia Muslim community,
[1:27:43]
and I'm here to present some important words
[1:27:47]
of his holiness.
[1:27:49]
Raza Ahmad, the supreme head of the worldwide
[1:27:54]
AMIA Muslim community, utter right
[1:27:58]
after the terrorist attack
[1:28:02]
against the innocent, innocent members
[1:28:05]
of Jewish community in Australia.
[1:28:08]
So I start His Holiness says,
[1:28:14]
on behalf of the Amiya Muslim community worldwide,
[1:28:19]
I condemn in the strongest terms, the heinous
[1:28:23]
terrorist attack targeting innocent members
[1:28:27]
of the Jewish community in Australia.
[1:28:31]
Nothing can ever justify such acts of violence.
[1:28:37]
Islam upholds the absolute sanctity of human life
[1:28:42]
and declares that the killing of one innocent person
[1:28:46]
is tantamount to killing all of humanity.
[1:28:50]
Acts of terrorism and hatred are
[1:28:54]
therefore completely contrary
[1:28:56]
to the true teachings of Islam.
[1:29:00]
As Muslims, our faith requires us to show love,
[1:29:05]
compassion, and grace to the people, people
[1:29:08]
of all faiths and beliefs.
[1:29:12]
Our heartfelt sympathies are with all those
[1:29:17]
affected by this tragedy.
[1:29:19]
And we pray for the swift recovery of those
[1:29:23]
who have been injured.
[1:29:26]
Thank you, mayor. God bless you. Thank
[1:29:28]
You, sir.
[1:29:29]
Thank you. The next speaker is Patricia Osmond. Ms.
[1:29:32]
Osmond's topic is transparency.
[1:29:33]
First amendment, civil rights of citizens,
[1:29:35]
and none influence of donors
[1:29:37]
and vendors on elected officials.
[1:29:38]
Good morning, ma'am.
[1:29:41]
Good morning, Mr. Canales.
[1:29:43]
As a citizen, I'm gonna come up here
[1:29:45]
and say I was wrong yesterday on that number in regards
[1:29:48]
to the gallons in the percentages.
[1:29:51]
But this is a thing is that as a citizen
[1:29:53]
and somebody who expects, um,
[1:29:58]
my political representatives to,
[1:30:02]
uh, also admit when they're wrong,
[1:30:05]
I have no problem doing so.
[1:30:07]
So I hope y'all can do the same.
[1:30:09]
Uh, and I'm gonna kinda wing some of this because Mr.
[1:30:13]
Fierro, I mentioned Ms.
[1:30:15]
Gloria Carou yesterday,
[1:30:19]
and I was here when she came
[1:30:22]
before Oscar Lisa in this counts in some of the members
[1:30:26]
of this council before asking for assistance.
[1:30:29]
I was here when she was shuffled away
[1:30:31]
by Ms. Mack when she was a deputy city manager.
[1:30:35]
And she had spoken to
[1:30:37]
who she was mentioning Rick, that she forgets.
[1:30:40]
His name is Rick Thoreau. He was not the head of the grants.
[1:30:43]
Rick Thoreau actually went to my house once before too,
[1:30:46]
because of the scams that happened in the Community
[1:30:49]
and Human Development Department.
[1:30:51]
Okay. So I think in fact the, the contract,
[1:30:55]
'cause I did go in, uh, I, I took, uh, me and Ms.
[1:31:00]
Kran had met over a year ago, uh,
[1:31:03]
because she wanted more help.
[1:31:04]
And people, it, it's sad
[1:31:06]
because citizens know that I come here
[1:31:08]
and I don't like to come here,
[1:31:10]
but it's more often than not when I'm out in public,
[1:31:14]
I get somebody to thank me for speaking out.
[1:31:17]
And that's sad. I don't take that as a compliment.
[1:31:21]
I take that as a sad state of our city affairs.
[1:31:26]
But she told me her story when we're sitting at Denny's
[1:31:30]
and quite frankly, the city having her sign
[1:31:32]
that other contract, that's not only a breach,
[1:31:35]
but it was illegal.
[1:31:36]
It was coercion. Okay?
[1:31:39]
And I think it's something that Ken Paxon should look into,
[1:31:43]
should look into the practices
[1:31:45]
because he is looking into El Paso and the transparency.
[1:31:47]
And that's another thing on top of everything else.
[1:31:50]
And the other documents that I have shown,
[1:31:51]
because you know what?
[1:31:53]
Regardless of our city attorney trying not
[1:31:55]
to let people have the foil documents they request,
[1:32:00]
there are huge issues in our city government.
[1:32:04]
And quite frankly, we do need to look behind the curtain.
[1:32:07]
And you all are the curtain up here on the diocese.
[1:32:10]
You are the curtain and everybody behind.
[1:32:12]
And what is going on in the back of the house needs
[1:32:15]
to be addressed
[1:32:16]
because there are huge problems within our city.
[1:32:23]
It is citizens.
[1:32:26]
Now you all need to realize it is not let's do
[1:32:30]
what we used to do on a federal level.
[1:32:32]
We are seeing the corruption going on.
[1:32:34]
And I, like I tell everybody, it starts local.
[1:32:37]
They didn't get there, but they started locally
[1:32:42]
and that's where they ended up. Thank you,
[1:32:43]
Ms. Osmond. You've reached the
[1:32:44]
three minutes.
[1:32:45]
The next speaker is Eddie Chavez, Jr.
[1:32:49]
He'll be followed by Lisa Turner. Mr.
[1:32:52]
Chavez's topic is utility rates.
[1:32:56]
Good morning, sir. You have three minutes.
[1:32:58]
Good morning, Ms. Chavez.
[1:33:00]
Good morning, city Council. Good morning.
[1:33:01]
Yesterday I was at, uh, the county, uh, meeting
[1:33:06]
appealing for the people that live out there in p prior
[1:33:10]
East Montana Vista that don't have water
[1:33:13]
or sure, it's like a third war out there.
[1:33:16]
There's a lady that has,
[1:33:18]
she came out on the Texas Tribu Tribune
[1:33:21]
where she is taking water out of the, uh,
[1:33:23]
atmosphere to get water.
[1:33:26]
That's how desperate those people are.
[1:33:28]
There was a, I was, um, look, go, uh,
[1:33:34]
uh, scrolling through my, um, uh,
[1:33:38]
Facebook, uh, no, Google.
[1:33:40]
And I found that there was a program back in June,
[1:33:43]
I think it was June 8th, 2023 for the Montana Vista.
[1:33:47]
It was named Montana Vista Water Insured Development.
[1:33:53]
And this was for the colonials,
[1:33:55]
which is what I'm talking about.
[1:33:56]
There's people there that I know
[1:33:58]
that have lived there 20 years, don't have water
[1:34:01]
or sew, which is bad for the environment also.
[1:34:05]
Now, when I talked to the, the commissioner out there, um,
[1:34:09]
in the county, she said that, uh,
[1:34:13]
they're already on phase two.
[1:34:15]
Well, I investigated on it. Yeah.
[1:34:17]
Phase one was where they're building, uh, a development for,
[1:34:21]
I think it's like 6,000 houses they're gonna make on,
[1:34:23]
on South West part of,
[1:34:27]
uh, Montana Vista.
[1:34:29]
And that's being paid by the developer.
[1:34:32]
So that's nothing to do with the $31 million
[1:34:34]
that it was allocated by the state.
[1:34:37]
And, uh, Tommy Gonzalez was part of it.
[1:34:41]
And, uh, everybody seems to be like, uh,
[1:34:45]
hush hush on the, not even moving on.
[1:34:46]
These poor people that are staying over there,
[1:34:48]
the people don't wanna come out
[1:34:50]
because they, lot of 'em don't speak English.
[1:34:52]
And a lot of 'em gotta work during the week,
[1:34:53]
so they don't have time to come way out
[1:34:54]
here to the county building.
[1:34:56]
They should make a county building over there where the,
[1:34:58]
the, uh, the constituents are
[1:35:01]
where they can show up and complain.
[1:35:05]
But, uh, I'm the only one talking for all these people.
[1:35:08]
'cause I feel bad for 'em. I'm only visiting there
[1:35:10]
'cause I moved out there 'cause I sold my house.
[1:35:12]
But I'm, I'm planning to go back to Northeast,
[1:35:15]
but I don't know the, the things I see out here, I want
[1:35:20]
to go and represent them.
[1:35:22]
I'm gonna run against John Lina now back when he was out.
[1:35:26]
But, uh, the way the Northeast people treated Sam Morgan
[1:35:29]
and don't appreciate it, that's what, uh, knocked me out.
[1:35:34]
But I'm gonna try to do it again.
[1:35:35]
I come back with you guys, see how it feels being on
[1:35:38]
that side over there with you guys
[1:35:39]
through this port hole that you guys go through.
[1:35:41]
Thank you. Have Merry Christmas. All
[1:35:43]
Right. Happy holidays. Thank
[1:35:44]
yous.
[1:35:45]
The final speaker is Lisa Turner. Ms.
[1:35:48]
Turner's topic is diverting the income from general fund
[1:35:50]
and imposing fees on Al pe.
[1:35:52]
Ones, ones
[1:35:54]
Again. Good morning. Good
[1:35:55]
morning, mayor.
[1:35:57]
You know, I'm, I'm at home laying down, recovering,
[1:36:02]
and, uh, I see this article in the, uh,
[1:36:08]
El Paso matters about Representative Corino.
[1:36:11]
And, you know, we're wanting to charge everybody
[1:36:14]
who drives a monthly fee.
[1:36:17]
And I'm thinking, now, wait a minute.
[1:36:20]
We give tax dollars to Paul Foster.
[1:36:23]
We give tax dollars to the hunts.
[1:36:26]
We support all the downtown businesses with TURs.
[1:36:30]
We do all of this.
[1:36:32]
And then you wanna turn around
[1:36:33]
and charge the hardworking El Paso,
[1:36:35]
who's actually just trying to put food on the table, money
[1:36:40]
to drive on blasted roads.
[1:36:43]
Now, explain to me, I wanted somebody,
[1:36:47]
please explain to me why a billionaire
[1:36:51]
needs our tax dollars.
[1:36:54]
They have more than enough money for their own projects.
[1:36:57]
So why do we have to kick our dollars in?
[1:37:01]
That is money that can solve problems in this city
[1:37:06]
that can solve the problems
[1:37:08]
that you've been wanting to solve.
[1:37:10]
Roads, parks, increased pay for your employees
[1:37:15]
so they're not, you know, having
[1:37:18]
to work three jobs while working this one.
[1:37:23]
Why? All that money's being captured by the people
[1:37:27]
who don't pay taxes for decades.
[1:37:32]
For decades, the homeowner in this town has always paid
[1:37:37]
about 75% of the property tax
[1:37:41]
and businesses 25.
[1:37:45]
It's time that the burden is equalized
[1:37:47]
and this is how you do it.
[1:37:49]
No more. Three eighty's.
[1:37:52]
You want a three 80, you want money, then you're gonna have
[1:37:55]
to pay us twice the amount.
[1:37:58]
And then you can write that you make a donation
[1:38:00]
for twice the amount, then you can take it off your taxes.
[1:38:04]
But we can't afford to subsidize billionaires
[1:38:07]
and multimillionaires in this city anymore.
[1:38:11]
I mean, you've got to understand that I'm sitting here
[1:38:13]
and I'm looking at it and I says, well, you know what, Lisa,
[1:38:19]
the City Council of El Paso,
[1:38:20]
Texas has always represented about 200 people in this city
[1:38:24]
and forgot about the hundreds of thousands left.
[1:38:29]
You look at the homeowners, you look at the rest of us,
[1:38:34]
and you reach into our pocket and you take our money,
[1:38:37]
and then you give it to people who've already got money
[1:38:40]
who can already fund their projects out of their own pocket.
[1:38:44]
That is what you call capitalism.
[1:38:46]
What you're doing now is called communism.
[1:38:50]
Now, if we're a capitalist,
[1:38:52]
then they can fund their own project.
[1:38:55]
Thank you, Ms. Turner. That concludes call
[1:38:58]
to the public counsel per the rules of order.
[1:39:00]
No use of personal cellular devices
[1:39:02]
nor personal communication should take place on the day
[1:39:04]
as while the meeting is in session.
[1:39:06]
Once you obtain the floor from the mayor, you will have up
[1:39:08]
to 10 minutes for debate
[1:39:09]
and may speak twice per debatable motion.
[1:39:12]
Please speak into the microphone
[1:39:14]
and refrain from side conversations at the day
[1:39:16]
as when the meeting is in session.
[1:39:18]
For those of you joining us virtually,
[1:39:19]
please make sure your microphones are muted
[1:39:21]
to reduce any background noise.
[1:39:23]
That brings us to the consent agenda.
[1:39:25]
All matters listed under the consent agenda will be
[1:39:28]
considered by city council to be routine
[1:39:29]
and will be enacted by one motion
[1:39:31]
unless separate discussion is requested
[1:39:32]
by council members prior to the vote.
[1:39:34]
Members of the audience may ask questions
[1:39:36]
regarding items on the consent agenda,
[1:39:38]
when the vote has been taken, if an item has been approved,
[1:39:41]
has not been called out for separate
[1:39:42]
discussion, the item has been approved.
[1:39:43]
Council may, however, reconsider any item at any
[1:39:46]
time during the meeting. Mayor po Tim.
[1:39:49]
Thank you Ms. Pine. I make a motion
[1:39:51]
to approve the consent agenda with the following revisions.
[1:39:54]
Page three. Item five, move
[1:39:55]
to the regular agenda per myself, representative Chavez,
[1:39:58]
page four, item 14, delete per representative canez.
[1:40:03]
Page five, item 19, move
[1:40:06]
to the regular agenda per representative Acevedo.
[1:40:09]
Page eight, item 21, delete per real estate division.
[1:40:14]
And that was item 18.
[1:40:17]
Move to the regular per representative.
[1:40:19]
Page nine, item 19. Oh, I'm sorry, 19. Thank you ma'am.
[1:40:23]
Say that again. Page five, item 19, move
[1:40:28]
to the regular agenda per representative Acevedo.
[1:40:31]
The last one was page eight, item 21,
[1:40:33]
delete per real estate division.
[1:40:38]
Representative Limo,
[1:40:40]
I'd like to Mayor, I'd like to request, uh, to move
[1:40:44]
to the regular agenda item number six, please as well.
[1:40:48]
Okay, thank you.
[1:40:55]
Is there a second on the consent agenda? All right.
[1:40:57]
And I believe we have public comment. Ms. Brian?
[1:40:59]
Yes, mayor, we have Ms.
[1:41:01]
Osmond that signed up to speak on item four.
[1:41:03]
These are the so solid waste liens
[1:41:10]
Come Up. I'm gonna try
[1:41:11]
to speak about it.
[1:41:13]
Uh, so y'all approved a program that Mr.
[1:41:16]
Uh, representative Nino had placed, uh, to get volunteers
[1:41:21]
to clean up what city employees are supposed to clean up.
[1:41:25]
So you want residents to, uh, make sure
[1:41:29]
less employee hours.
[1:41:32]
But again, I will implore you to try
[1:41:35]
to do a volunteer program so that residents homes,
[1:41:42]
some of these people, whether it's elderly, disabled,
[1:41:45]
what have you, do a program in your area,
[1:41:50]
set up some volunteers.
[1:41:51]
If you're gonna throw some money at saving El Paso
[1:41:56]
City tax dollars, by having residents do that,
[1:42:01]
you're gonna kick in $1,500 to them, which, uh,
[1:42:05]
is far less than what city employees doing
[1:42:09]
that work would receive.
[1:42:11]
But if you're gonna do that, I would say
[1:42:15]
actually help your constituents,
[1:42:17]
not just make yourself look good
[1:42:20]
and, uh, do a volunteer program.
[1:42:22]
Each of your offices could set something up
[1:42:26]
for constituents in your area so that they don't have
[1:42:29]
to do these liens because there's liens in district two.
[1:42:32]
There's liens in several of these districts around the city,
[1:42:37]
and it's really upsetting that y'all will
[1:42:42]
do a program, make yourselves look good, throw in
[1:42:47]
that $1,500 for the volunteers to save
[1:42:52]
city tax dollars
[1:42:54]
because the, that, that money is just saving employee hours.
[1:42:58]
But you won't do the same thing so
[1:43:01]
that constituents aren't stuck with these liens.
[1:43:05]
$350, whatever.
[1:43:07]
Do you understand that's those same monies
[1:43:11]
that you're putting to save employee hours
[1:43:15]
you won't put to help residents avoid these liens.
[1:43:21]
I find that, I don't know, rather interesting,
[1:43:27]
interesting, appalling one of the two,
[1:43:30]
but it doesn't make you look good.
[1:43:33]
It, it, it really doesn't
[1:43:35]
because in one, you're saving employee hours
[1:43:38]
and that throwing out, yeah,
[1:43:41]
that $1,500 from your discretionary fund,
[1:43:45]
which is just donate donated dollars,
[1:43:50]
but you won't do the same so
[1:43:53]
that constituents don't get these $350 liens and such.
[1:43:59]
And I'm saying, hey, look, some
[1:44:01]
of those are probably corporate properties real,
[1:44:04]
you know, fine.
[1:44:06]
But some of those are also people in the area
[1:44:10]
that can't afford it.
[1:44:14]
Ms. Brian believe, uh, Ms.
[1:44:16]
Osmond also signed up for item number 23.
[1:44:18]
Oh, that's Okay. Item 23.
[1:44:22]
Sorry, I didn't realize it was on the consent.
[1:44:25]
No. Item 23 is an introduction. Okay.
[1:44:28]
Okay. Um, and I know typically you don't, we're we're,
[1:44:32]
We're not Taking a, we don't begun introduction.
[1:44:33]
Yeah. But if I could just, uh, Mr.
[1:44:36]
Vedo, just so if you're aware in district two, Ms.
[1:44:40]
Oman, we're not on that item, ma. Okay.
[1:44:42]
We're we're still on the consent agenda. All thank
[1:44:44]
Yeah. My, my fault.
[1:44:45]
Okay.
[1:44:46]
There's a motion in the second, uh, with the revisions
[1:44:50]
of moving items.
[1:44:52]
Number five, number six and number 19.
[1:44:54]
That's correct, mayor. Okay. Any further discussion?
[1:44:59]
All right, Ms. Prime call for the vote.
[1:45:00]
Yes, sir. And it also includes the deletion
[1:45:03]
of item 21 and 14.
[1:45:05]
Yes. On that motion call for the vote
[1:45:13]
and the voting session and that motion passes unanimously.
[1:45:17]
Alright. Would you like to work
[1:45:18]
through the items that were moved to regular?
[1:45:19]
Yeah. Let's go to item number five. Yes sir.
[1:45:22]
Item number five is a resolution
[1:45:23]
that the city manager designee be authorized
[1:45:25]
to take all necessary actions
[1:45:27]
to dissolve the El Paso Public Improvement District number
[1:45:30]
one Thunder Canyon District.
[1:45:34]
Good morning, mayor and council. Margarita Marin.
[1:45:36]
Deputy CFO Comp controller.
[1:45:39]
Representative Chavez,
[1:45:42]
Can we see the presentation first please?
[1:45:44]
Sure. Thank you.
[1:45:47]
Okay. This is a presentation
[1:45:52]
of the Public Improvement District number one, uh,
[1:45:55]
the Thunder Canyon, as we call it.
[1:45:57]
And I understand why Ms.
[1:45:58]
Chaz pulled from the consent agenda
[1:46:00]
because it is actually a very beautiful story about the
[1:46:05]
community coming together, working in partnership
[1:46:07]
with a non-profit organization
[1:46:10]
and the city, the local government to,
[1:46:12]
to preserve this land.
[1:46:15]
The strategic alignment for this is Goal six
[1:46:18]
set the standard for some governance
[1:46:20]
and physical management.
[1:46:28]
So I'll walk you through, through the story of the pit.
[1:46:31]
Um, everything started in 2004 when some
[1:46:35]
of the residents observed
[1:46:36]
that there was a developer working in the area
[1:46:39]
with the intention to, to build something in this area.
[1:46:42]
So the developer reach out to the,
[1:46:49]
To the, to the, uh, Frontera Land Alliance.
[1:46:53]
And in order to preserve this, this land,
[1:46:56]
and together they reach out to the city wanting
[1:46:58]
to see if there was something that could be done.
[1:47:01]
So then in 2006, um, the, the owners
[1:47:06]
of the area, they filed a petition to for the city council
[1:47:10]
to consider creating a pit under the authority given
[1:47:14]
through the Chapter 3 72 of the local government code.
[1:47:19]
Then six months after, in January of 2007, the city council,
[1:47:23]
um, created a resolution
[1:47:26]
to actually create this, the district.
[1:47:28]
And then furthermore, in April of 2007,
[1:47:31]
the city council finally adopted an ordinance to pass this,
[1:47:35]
um, service and assessment plan to vy the taxes
[1:47:38]
for this, for the, for the area.
[1:47:41]
May, 2007, um, the city signed a conservation easement
[1:47:45]
with the Frontier Line Alliance
[1:47:47]
to preserve the open space in perpetuity.
[1:47:50]
And then in the same month, in order to acquire the land,
[1:47:53]
the city issue, um,
[1:47:55]
special assessment revenue bond in the amount of $400,000.
[1:47:59]
And that in conjunction with the donation of some
[1:48:03]
of the residents in the area, they came together to to,
[1:48:07]
to the acquisition of the land that was donated to the city.
[1:48:11]
So since then, in 2008, annually, the city came back
[1:48:15]
to the city council, did a review
[1:48:17]
and evaluation of the annual, assess the annual assessment
[1:48:20]
to make sure that it was still appropriate
[1:48:23]
to cover the payment of the bond.
[1:48:24]
During those 12 years, the city, uh, found
[1:48:27]
that the assessment was appropriate
[1:48:29]
and no changes were made.
[1:48:31]
Lastly, um, in August of 2020,
[1:48:34]
we did the final payment for the bond.
[1:48:39]
And, um, after that, no assessment
[1:48:42]
or taxes has been levied on any residence of this area.
[1:48:46]
And it was a win situation for everybody
[1:48:48]
because the city got to acquire this land
[1:48:51]
with no expenditures related to the maintenance of the land.
[1:48:55]
And then the owners got to save this beautiful space
[1:48:58]
and preserve it in perpetuity.
[1:49:01]
So today is more of a formality to legally close this pit
[1:49:05]
because financially we did everything that needed to be done
[1:49:08]
to extinguish the debt.
[1:49:10]
All payments has been made.
[1:49:11]
There's no funds available anymore.
[1:49:13]
So financially this fund actually has been
[1:49:16]
closed since 2020.
[1:49:17]
And today we're just here again as a formality to close it.
[1:49:21]
And that concludes the presentation. Any questions?
[1:49:24]
Okay, representative
[1:49:25]
Chavez, is there a motion to approve this?
[1:49:26]
Motion to approve? Second. Okay. Representative Chavez.
[1:49:29]
Thank you Mayor. And I'd like to,
[1:49:31]
to read a statement and to the record.
[1:49:32]
Thank you, margarita for the presentation today.
[1:49:35]
Thunder Canyon exists today
[1:49:37]
because neighbors in district one chose community over
[1:49:41]
convenience and preservation over development.
[1:49:44]
Nearly 20 years ago, when this aroyo on the west side
[1:49:48]
of the Franklin Mountains was at risk of being developed,
[1:49:52]
residents came together with a shared goal,
[1:49:55]
protect open space
[1:49:57]
and preserve the natural character of their neighborhood
[1:50:00]
for future generations.
[1:50:02]
Rather than asking the broader city to shoulder the cost,
[1:50:05]
approximately 90 neighboring households voluntarily agreed
[1:50:11]
to tax themselves through the creation
[1:50:14]
of a public improvement district.
[1:50:15]
Number one, that decision allowed the city
[1:50:19]
to purchase the land upfront, secure the canyon
[1:50:23]
as open space,
[1:50:24]
and repay the cost over time, using assessments paid
[1:50:29]
directly by those residents.
[1:50:32]
This was a deliberate place-based effort rooted in
[1:50:35]
stewardship and civic responsibility.
[1:50:38]
Those neighbors understood the value of open space,
[1:50:42]
flood control, wildlife habitat,
[1:50:45]
and quality of life, not just for themselves,
[1:50:49]
but for the entire community because of their commitment.
[1:50:53]
Thunder Canyon is protected today
[1:50:56]
and remains a natural area
[1:50:58]
that residents across El Paso can enjoy.
[1:51:01]
That protection is not temporary.
[1:51:04]
A conservation easement was established to ensure
[1:51:07]
that the property will be retained forever as open space.
[1:51:11]
It is a lasting safeguard that reflects the intent
[1:51:15]
of the neighbors who came together to save Thunder Canyon
[1:51:19]
and guarantees that their investment will continue
[1:51:23]
to benefit future generations.
[1:51:26]
I applaud their efforts
[1:51:27]
because throughout the time that they were making payments,
[1:51:31]
it is my understanding that none
[1:51:33]
of them defaulted on those payments.
[1:51:34]
So they gave their word to the city that they would commit
[1:51:38]
to preserving Thunder Canyon,
[1:51:40]
and that is exactly what they did.
[1:51:42]
The neighbors, uh, of Upper Hills, uh,
[1:51:44]
neighborhood Association, I commend them for that.
[1:51:47]
I also wanna read into a, the record,
[1:51:49]
a statement from the executive director
[1:51:52]
of Front Land Alliance,
[1:51:53]
who was very much involved in this effort.
[1:51:55]
And you can find videos
[1:51:57]
of when this effort initiated on YouTube,
[1:51:59]
which I did myself.
[1:52:01]
And Janae's statement reads the following,
[1:52:03]
thunder Canyon PID concept was new
[1:52:06]
to the Frontera Land Alliance in 2006.
[1:52:09]
It turned out to be a very effective instrument
[1:52:12]
to conserve important open space lands within neighborhoods,
[1:52:17]
and was a testament to how dedicated the neighbors were
[1:52:21]
to the conservation of the Thunder Canyon Arroyo
[1:52:24]
and all the habitat and wildlife it protects.
[1:52:27]
The PID paired with a conservation easement proved
[1:52:30]
to be a great way to conserve neighborhood lands
[1:52:33]
for the community, for flood control and water recharge,
[1:52:37]
and while providing the public access
[1:52:39]
to natural open spaces, end quote.
[1:52:42]
So, uh, mayor and council and everybody here
[1:52:45]
and listening online, uh, this PID is a testament to
[1:52:49]
what can happen when our community comes together
[1:52:52]
with our local city government to really create quality
[1:52:55]
of life spaces for all of us to enjoy.
[1:52:58]
Um, uh, this PIDI think was, its first of its kind
[1:53:02]
and is unique because there are, in my understanding, uh,
[1:53:05]
just one other one
[1:53:06]
that exists currently within our community.
[1:53:09]
So, uh, I commend again,
[1:53:11]
the efforts from Upper Hills Neighborhood Association,
[1:53:13]
from the Land Alliance City staff,
[1:53:16]
and everybody who worked on this project,
[1:53:18]
and I appreciate your presentation today.
[1:53:20]
Margarita, thank, thank you so much. Thank you
[1:53:22]
So much. Congratulations.
[1:53:23]
Thank
[1:53:24]
You. Thank
[1:53:25]
You. Yeah. Congratulations
[1:53:26]
everyone.
[1:53:26]
Alright, there's a motion and a second on this item. Ms.
[1:53:29]
Brian. Item number five.
[1:53:30]
Yes, sir. The motion was made by Mayor Prote Chavez,
[1:53:33]
seconded by Representative Nino to approve item five on
[1:53:36]
that motion call for the vote
[1:53:48]
in the voting session.
[1:53:50]
And that motion passes unanimously.
[1:53:52]
Okay. Let's take item number six.
[1:53:53]
Item six is a resolution
[1:53:55]
that the city manager designee be authorized
[1:53:57]
to sign an overhead electrical easement granting an easement
[1:54:00]
to the El Paso Electric Company to provide electrical power
[1:54:03]
to property owned by the city
[1:54:04]
of El Paso within the municipal limits of the city.
[1:54:08]
Mayor, Make a motion to approve this sign. Okay.
[1:54:10]
Second. Alright, Joaquin. Morning,
[1:54:12]
Mayor. Councilman,
[1:54:13]
Representative Lemore. I'm
[1:54:14]
Sorry, I, I don't think we Joaquin.
[1:54:16]
Thank you. I don't think we need a,
[1:54:17]
a presentation necessarily.
[1:54:19]
I'd just like to know the location, the exact location.
[1:54:22]
This is at the City's Traffic Management Center over off
[1:54:25]
of San Paulo.
[1:54:28]
Thank you. Thank you, mayor. All right.
[1:54:32]
Thank you. Walk all.
[1:54:33]
There's a motion and a second to approve Item number six.
[1:54:37]
Yes, sir. The motion was made by Representative Limon,
[1:54:39]
seconded by Representative Canez
[1:54:41]
to approve the resolution on item six.
[1:54:43]
On that motion call for the vote
[1:54:50]
and the voting session.
[1:54:52]
And that motion passes unanimously.
[1:54:54]
All right. The stick item number 19.
[1:54:57]
Yes, sir. Item number 19 is the award
[1:55:00]
of solicitation 2025 dash 0 0 3 1 R,
[1:55:04]
real Estate Appraisal Services Airport
[1:55:07]
to the following suppliers, number one C-B-R-E-E,
[1:55:11]
number two, Steve R Greg, DBA, Greg, risk Management,
[1:55:15]
LLC number three, Lawry Property Advisors, LLC
[1:55:18]
and number four, Wilkinson, Pendergrass and Associates.
[1:55:22]
Representative Vado.
[1:55:25]
Thank you Mayor. I was looking at the backup for this item
[1:55:29]
and was kinda seeing, seeing
[1:55:34]
that there's, sorry I lost my
[1:55:38]
place in the agenda.
[1:55:42]
Um, I, I was kinda seeing how there were several
[1:55:47]
companies that were, um, selected on this.
[1:55:51]
So has this have, have we had appraisal services before
[1:55:54]
and we're re redoing it?
[1:55:56]
Or is this the first time that we're actually doing it?
[1:55:58]
Good morning, Krista Bus
[1:55:59]
with purchasing and strategic sourcing.
[1:56:01]
So the city does have, um, other, um, that's
[1:56:05]
what I thought appraisal services with
[1:56:06]
like the real estate division.
[1:56:08]
Um, this is the first one directly just for the airport.
[1:56:11]
And what was the reasoning for that?
[1:56:14]
Um, I'll go ahead and defer that to the department.
[1:56:16]
Okay.
[1:56:23]
Good morning. Debbie Olivas with the airport.
[1:56:25]
So it is necessary for us to have a contract at the airport.
[1:56:28]
We have over 400 leases that we, um, oversee
[1:56:32]
and so we need the services, uh, to reappraise, um,
[1:56:37]
the, the land.
[1:56:39]
And so we do it every 10 years for some of our leases.
[1:56:45]
For some, but not for all, For most, yes.
[1:56:48]
Okay. 'cause I, I've kind
[1:56:50]
of been hearing it's been a little complicated with
[1:56:54]
some rents going up
[1:56:55]
and communication issues and stuff like that.
[1:56:58]
So I'm trying to understand if this was holding that up
[1:57:02]
or how do you feel this is gonna
[1:57:04]
make that work more efficient?
[1:57:06]
No, so right now we've been using the contract under, uh,
[1:57:10]
the real estate division
[1:57:12]
and CID so we have a process in place Right now,
[1:57:15]
it has delayed a little bit
[1:57:17]
because we have to request permission from those departments
[1:57:21]
to use their contracts,
[1:57:22]
but it's only about two weeks that we've seen a delay.
[1:57:27]
Okay. And so the two week delay
[1:57:33]
using the appraisal services that we already have
[1:57:37]
and getting your own is going to eliminate two weeks
[1:57:40]
and it's just gonna be easier or
[1:57:42]
Well, yes. 'cause now we'll
[1:57:43]
have a contract in place
[1:57:45]
and so what we'll do is what we'll rotate
[1:57:48]
between the different, um, vendors
[1:57:51]
and so we'll have 'em on call.
[1:57:53]
We'll just request, um, a quote from them and move forward.
[1:57:57]
It's just a lot of money when we're kind of already using
[1:58:01]
when we already have services in place.
[1:58:03]
Right. So I'm trying to understand a little bit more,
[1:58:06]
and I'm not getting the clarity that I need. It's
[1:58:08]
Actually the same. So we
[1:58:09]
have the major contract that we've had
[1:58:11]
and as you know, we are working through over the next couple
[1:58:15]
of years looking at our entire inventory of property.
[1:58:17]
And so really the amount of property
[1:58:19]
that we are having going through appraisals is much higher
[1:58:21]
than we would've had historically.
[1:58:23]
And so I think this is allowing
[1:58:25]
that the real estate division has the capacity it needs on
[1:58:27]
the contracts that it has in place,
[1:58:29]
but also this is allowing us to utilize other companies
[1:58:33]
to be able to make sure that we can do the appraisals
[1:58:35]
to be able to renew the leases,
[1:58:37]
which is a requirement for the airport.
[1:58:39]
They're still, I mean, if you're looking at the, the cost
[1:58:41]
of those appraisals, those are comparable, you know,
[1:58:44]
until the contracts that we have, it just allows for us
[1:58:47]
to have on call more companies
[1:58:49]
that can get this done quicker so that we can move
[1:58:51]
through those leasing processes.
[1:58:53]
Okay. And then the, each appraisal is gonna be $1,800
[1:58:58]
to $15,000.
[1:59:00]
Is that gonna be based on who you call
[1:59:02]
or is that just a general thing
[1:59:04]
that all four companies will have
[1:59:07]
It? It's based on
[1:59:08]
the actual property.
[1:59:09]
Okay, so it's based on property and Yes.
[1:59:11]
Then each one will charge you. Yes.
[1:59:14]
And then I guess on the,
[1:59:16]
when this was listed out on the following suppliers,
[1:59:19]
I think it was just listed out based on the score sheet
[1:59:21]
that was there and not necessarily in order of
[1:59:26]
who got, um, first, second, third, and fourth.
[1:59:30]
Was there reason for that? No. No.
[1:59:33]
Yes. So the, the ones that we're awarding,
[1:59:36]
they were all in the same range.
[1:59:38]
So, um, because it's on a rotating basis
[1:59:41]
and we have a, a scale that we're using, it doesn't,
[1:59:47]
it wouldn't make a difference in the order
[1:59:48]
that we're providing them to you here.
[1:59:51]
Oh, 'cause of the way you're gonna
[1:59:52]
utilize the services. Yes.
[1:59:54]
Yeah. So they'll be on a rotating basis, um,
[1:59:57]
that way it's fair for all of them.
[1:59:59]
And were the two El Paso ones Wilkinson
[2:00:02]
and Steve, Greg, um, part of by El Paso?
[2:00:08]
Uh, so, so
[2:00:12]
because for all of our airport solicitations,
[2:00:16]
we include federal, uh, provisions, we're not able
[2:00:19]
to include higher El Paso first into
[2:00:22]
these, uh, solicitations.
[2:00:23]
Okay. So that had nothing to do with No. Okay. Alright.
[2:00:27]
Thank you.
[2:00:29]
Okay. Yeah, it's, is there a, is there a second?
[2:00:31]
Art Representative? Canales.
[2:00:33]
Thank you Mayor. I think one other important thing
[2:00:35]
to point out and that's that the, uh, the contracts
[2:00:40]
that we have through for appraisal services through, uh,
[2:00:43]
the, the real estate division are funded
[2:00:45]
with the general fund, is that correct?
[2:00:46]
This is airport enterprise funds.
[2:00:48]
And so, uh, this is
[2:00:51]
theoretically leave capacity on the general fund, uh,
[2:00:54]
funded contract and, and,
[2:00:56]
and instead utilize airport enterprise funds for the,
[2:00:58]
the contract at the airport.
[2:01:00]
Airport always paid.
[2:01:01]
So we always charge back to the appropriate funding code.
[2:01:04]
So if it's some metro or airport utilize a real estate,
[2:01:08]
we, we do that alignment
[2:01:09]
Back to Right. But it does
[2:01:10]
use up the capacity on the contract
[2:01:13]
that is at real estate.
[2:01:16]
Okay. Um, yeah, for that reason, I think it's, uh,
[2:01:19]
it's a good thing for the airport to have its own
[2:01:22]
contract if the capacity is going to be, uh, fairly high
[2:01:26]
or if, if the, the utilization is going to be fairly high
[2:01:28]
and you're not burdening the other contract. Thank you.
[2:01:31]
Alright. Any further discussion on this item?
[2:01:36]
Alright, hearing none Ms. Prime call for the vote? Yes,
[2:01:38]
Sir. The motion was made by
[2:01:39]
Representative Limon, seconded
[2:01:41]
by alternate Mayor Proto Piero
[2:01:42]
to award the solicitation on item 19.
[2:01:45]
On that motion call for the vote
[2:01:53]
and the voting session and that motion passes unanimously.
[2:01:58]
Ms. Brian, I believe that brings us to the first readings.
[2:02:01]
Yes, sir. That brings us to the first
[2:02:02]
reading of ordinances.
[2:02:03]
These are items 22 to 24.
[2:02:06]
Is there a motion to mayor?
[2:02:08]
Make a motion to move, um,
[2:02:10]
on the reading of the first ordinances?
[2:02:11]
Is there a second? All right. And Ms.
[2:02:13]
Prime, I believe we have public comment on item number 23.
[2:02:17]
That's correct. We have Ms.
[2:02:18]
Osmond that signed up to speak on the introduction
[2:02:21]
of an ordinance amending Title 18 building
[2:02:23]
and construction, outdoor lighting code
[2:02:25]
of city owned facilities.
[2:02:30]
I just wanna make sure that, uh, my representative
[2:02:33]
ro is aware honestly, this lighting code, Hey,
[2:02:38]
like anybody that's gone to San Diego, been
[2:02:43]
to the Hillcrest area, other areas across the US
[2:02:47]
little arches kind of looks cute,
[2:02:51]
but history for El Paso is, we've done this
[2:02:55]
before, past city councils
[2:02:58]
and city government has wasted tax dollars
[2:03:01]
in the same way before.
[2:03:03]
And proof on how long it really lasts
[2:03:07]
is in district two.
[2:03:09]
You could pull it up on Google Maps, Coron
[2:03:12]
of Travis and Cambridge.
[2:03:17]
The foundation posts are still there at least on one side
[2:03:21]
because they're used to be one of these arches
[2:03:24]
in that neighborhood as well.
[2:03:26]
Not everybody knows the history of El Paso as well as I do.
[2:03:30]
Um, but then again,
[2:03:35]
not everybody's family's been here from the
[2:03:37]
foundation of this city.
[2:03:39]
So, um, it, it's, look,
[2:03:45]
it looks cute in current place, the one in five points,
[2:03:52]
especially where it's gonna be put.
[2:03:54]
I think it's a total waste of funds.
[2:04:01]
And I understand, um, our city wants to try a turn.
[2:04:05]
The what, what anybody who knows the area
[2:04:09]
actually calls it Bohemian block.
[2:04:11]
You know, Vinnies is at Dewey's.
[2:04:14]
You know, Christina started the whole thing with Vinnies,
[2:04:20]
but trying to turn that whole area
[2:04:23]
to relieve the issues that Kern place was having
[2:04:27]
with the Cincinnati area hasn't done good
[2:04:30]
for our area either.
[2:04:34]
Um, in highlighting it with that arch
[2:04:37]
and wasted tax dollars, again,
[2:04:41]
honestly, I think our city needs
[2:04:42]
Teamwork and belonging.
[2:04:44]
Charlotte, though only four years old
[2:04:47]
had a remarkable spirit.
[2:04:49]
Her parents have shared so many of her, sorry.
[2:04:52]
Her parents have shared that she made it her mission
[2:04:55]
to ensure that everyone around her knew what love was.
[2:05:00]
She would probably, she would probably say Al is for love
[2:05:04]
and will make a heart shape with her hands.
[2:05:08]
A simple yet powerful reminder that the kindness
[2:05:11]
and joy she brought into every space.
[2:05:14]
This item is deeply important
[2:05:16]
because in El Paso, we are all family.
[2:05:19]
Sebastian, Sr. And Stephanie, their parents who are here
[2:05:22]
with us today, have shared so many loving memories
[2:05:26]
of the children with me.
[2:05:27]
And it was important to ensure that Sebastian
[2:05:29]
and Charlotte's memory and the love that they represented
[2:05:33]
continues to live on, not just in our hearts,
[2:05:35]
but in a place where children play, families gather
[2:05:38]
and our community is built.
[2:05:41]
I want to sincerely thank the neighbors
[2:05:43]
and the community members and now all of El Paso
[2:05:46]
for coming together, who stood alongside with his family,
[2:05:50]
including Mr. Carl Jackson, who is also here with us today,
[2:05:53]
and his wife Karen, for their support
[2:05:57]
and ex exemplifying
[2:05:58]
what it truly means to care for one another.
[2:06:01]
I want to also thank Sebastian Senior for her service
[2:06:04]
and for the strength and grace that he
[2:06:06]
and Stephanie continue to show us.
[2:06:10]
Renaming This park is more than an act of remembrance.
[2:06:12]
It's a reflection of who we are as a city.
[2:06:15]
Once again, the city of El Paso stands together as family
[2:06:19]
and remain here to support the Trotter family today.
[2:06:22]
And always counsel I respectfully ask for.