Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[0:00]
I'm going to go ahead and call the meeting of the zoning board of appeals to order. Can I get roll call, please?
[0:06]
Arm Bergerster.
[0:08]
President.
[0:09]
Eisenhower.
[0:09]
President.
[0:10]
Marlar.
[0:11]
President.
[0:12]
President.
[0:13]
Grant.
[0:16]
All right, item number two, approval of the agenda for March 17th, 2026. Do I have a motion?
[0:22]
I'll make motion.
[0:23]
approve the agenda.
[0:24]
I'll support.
[0:26]
All those in favor say aye.
[0:27]
Aye.
[0:27]
Aye.
[0:28]
All those opposed, aye.
[0:30]
Motion carries.
[0:31]
Item number three.
[0:32]
The approval of minutes for January 20th of 2026, do I have a motion?
[0:37]
We'll make a motion to approve the minutes for January 20th, 2026.
[0:42]
I'll support.
[0:43]
All those in favor say aye.
[0:46]
All those opposed, aye.
[0:47]
Motion carries.
[0:50]
Item number four.
[0:51]
The report from the township board representative.
[0:55]
There's nothing relevant to this crew necessarily.
[0:59]
Meeting tomorrow,
[1:02]
City Manager Fried will be presenting about their canal proposition, and that's how I'm going to term it.
[1:11]
For for Greshart's cooperation with some funding for that, it should be interesting to hear what he has to say.
[1:19]
we've received very little information up to about it up to this point, and we'll be curious to
[1:26]
hear from the citizens and their thoughts after he shares the intel. So that's about it right now.
[1:33]
All right. Thank you very much. Item number five, report from the Planning Commission Representative.
[1:38]
We did not have a meeting. Okay. We will move on to that. Item number six, public comment for items
[1:46]
not on the agenda. Is there anybody here for items that are not listed on the agenda today?
[1:51]
Seeing that nobody is raising their hand, we will go ahead and move on to item number seven
[1:55]
public hearings. Item 7-1, Class A designation 4683, Desmond Beach, Parcel, 7-4-20-220-0024-001,
[2:09]
is there an applicant that would like to present to us?
[2:14]
You can just come right up to that podium here.
[2:17]
Okay.
[2:18]
Question and class day designation as you're aware,
[2:23]
Desmond Beach area every house is on property lines.
[2:26]
So, we had to do some real horse trading
[2:29]
to re-apportion both our house and the neighbors
[2:36]
so that we're both within our property lines.
[2:40]
It's tough to do, we did it.
[2:42]
And I'm requesting a class A designation for the purposes of just no construction.
[2:48]
Just if something happens, if I could rebuild, that's the purpose of it.
[2:54]
So all you need is, okay, thank you.
[2:59]
All right, any public hearing for the comment on that?
[3:04]
Oh, I'm sorry I missed one meeting there's so much space in between there so
[3:14]
can I get a motion to open the public hearing I move to open the public here I
[3:19]
support okay all those in favor say aye aye all those opposed say nay motion
[3:26]
motion carries. Now we open the public hearing for citizen comment for this. Doesn't appear to be any for this one.
[3:39]
So we'll go ahead and get a motion to close the public hearing.
[3:43]
I move the public hearing. I have support. All those in favor say aye.
[3:47]
Aye. All those opposed say nay. Motion carries.
[3:51]
And there was no other course on that second.
[3:56]
Okay, at this point we'll open up for a board discussion.
[4:00]
Do you guys have a few minutes to look over everything?
[4:15]
So if we grant the class A designation and doesn't do anything other than preserve what
[4:20]
is already, like the right to build what is already there.
[4:22]
Correct.
[4:23]
Within the current footprint, or?
[4:25]
Yes.
[4:26]
Okay.
[4:26]
Okay.
[4:27]
I do
[4:31]
see the recommendation that if we're doing a run-over or if we're sound of the current
[4:37]
structure that we stipulate that we stick to our three-foot subbex that we try to keep
[4:43]
two in there is that kind of the thought process on this.
[4:49]
I know we've done that before.
[4:50]
Yes.
[4:53]
I do believe so.
[4:58]
That has been a stipulation that you guys have started on with some of the classes that
[5:04]
that are closer to the property line in the region.
[5:07]
Yeah, so if it's simply an addition, you know, obviously,
[5:12]
that's good, but if we were to knock down a significant part
[5:16]
of the structure to redo, yeah.
[5:18]
Right.
[5:18]
I
[5:21]
would make a motion to approve the class A designation
[5:24]
with that restriction on it.
[5:30]
I'll support all those in favor say aye.
[5:35]
Aye.
[5:36]
All those opposed say nay.
[5:37]
Okay, motion carries, reasons one through four.
[5:41]
Conditions of anything over greater than up 50%
[5:45]
requires coming back into three foot variants.
[5:54]
You're requesting three foot from both the North and South
[5:57]
property lines?
[5:59]
Yes.
[6:11]
All those in favor of that?
[6:12]
Say aye.
[6:13]
All right.
[6:14]
All those pose, nay.
[6:16]
Motion carries.
[6:21]
You are all set there.
[6:25]
Item 7-2, variance class A designation for 5336, Lake Shore Road, parcel 74-20-175-0035-0000 is an applicant here that would like to present to us.
[6:40]
My name
[6:49]
is Genome Weiss Alice Mariani. We are the owners of the property. We've lived there 14 years. It's a beautiful location.
[6:59]
on Lake Huron, have great neighbors, both sides of North and South, and it's been very
[7:05]
supportive of the community.
[7:07]
Within those 14 years, though, we decided that we had to increase our living quarters substantially
[7:14]
as a legacy for our children and grandchildren for living comfortably in that property because
[7:24]
prior to that, it was basically a cottage going 30, 40, 50 years in age, I guess different
[7:32]
parts of it were updated throughout the decades. But the point is, it's a 40-foot lot. It
[7:39]
was platted that way back in. I'm not even sure if it was the 30s or even earlier.
[7:52]
The
[7:52]
The structure was built with a four-foot setback as far back as when the original structure
[8:03]
was put there.
[8:05]
Your ordinance changes were substantially after the fact on that.
[8:11]
So every house, I believe, at least on one, depending on their configuration, one side of
[8:17]
that there are a lot is not going to be meeting the 10 foot setback.
[8:22]
Since then we've had at least two houses that were built and received the variance because they cannot meet the 10 foot setback.
[8:33]
And what we're asking for is our existence structure is grandfathered in.
[8:38]
We want to expand the house another 10 feet west which gives me 190 square feet to allow us for
[8:47]
better mobility and utilization of the remodeling space that were currently under process of doing,
[8:57]
and that setback will still remain as the original structure of 4.1 feet from the North Blotline,
[9:06]
10 feet west, 19 feet spanning from North to South. So it's about 190 square feet
[9:15]
addition that we're asking for, Eagle has already given a permit that it is
[9:23]
beyond the boundary of the high erosion zone and we know that doing this
[9:30]
particular remodeling not just what has happened but also adding the 190
[9:35]
square foot will just enhance the value of everyone's property certainly will
[9:40]
provide you more tax revenue since my taxes unfortunately will probably go
[9:45]
what? And the value of the neighborhood should increase as well. That's the case.
[9:54]
All right, thank you.
[9:59]
Can I get a motion to open the public hearing?
[10:02]
I move to open the public hearing as for all those in favor say aye.
[10:07]
Aye. All those in the public say nay. Motion carries?
[10:10]
No, ma'am.
[10:12]
Are there any public comment that would like to be set on? I'm
[10:18]
seeing none.
[10:18]
We'll go ahead and can I get a motion to close the public hearing?
[10:22]
I move to close the public hearing support.
[10:25]
All those in favor say aye.
[10:26]
Aye.
[10:27]
All those opposed say nay.
[10:29]
Motion carries.
[10:33]
Of course, my hands receive.
[10:34]
All right, that's good to know.
[10:36]
All right, we'll go ahead and give everyone a few minutes to look over everything.
[10:41]
They'll open up for board discussion.
[12:31]
Any board member have any questions, comments, concerns, anything for discussion?
[12:36]
Like
[12:44]
me, it jumped out to me. It was the request for the additional overhang, obviously.
[12:49]
That's quite an increase.
[12:54]
Is there a need for it, of any sorts, in that area?
[12:59]
Or is it just a personal preference request?
[13:05]
So, for the sixth.
[13:06]
Yeah, please have.
[13:08]
This is our building over there.
[13:11]
This
[13:13]
house did really have overhangs on it before on the gables.
[13:17]
Okay.
[13:17]
So, we're going to, we put a 16 inch overhang.
[13:20]
The sighting we had comes in 12 foot or 10 foot legs.
[13:23]
So, you guys got a lot of weather on the way.
[13:25]
I'd like to put a full panel on the sight in there, not seeming.
[13:28]
That allows me to do that, and it gives coverage for the house,
[13:31]
because now it's like a story and a half before it was just,
[13:34]
You know, really was kind of the second story, but not good.
[13:39]
You've bunker headed in there, so.
[13:41]
But 16 inch overhangs provides the coverage for that.
[13:45]
Okay, I mean, I don't, all the other houses in there,
[13:49]
they all have large overhangs on them,
[13:52]
so all the new ones.
[13:53]
Well, that includes gutters also.
[13:55]
Is that included in there?
[13:56]
That does, that's 16 inches plus the gutter.
[13:58]
Plus the gutter.
[13:59]
Yeah, okay.
[14:00]
So if everybody else has two foot plus the gutter.
[14:03]
Okay, so it's 16 inches plus the gutter, okay.
[14:06]
I'm
[14:20]
working with the graders, just kind of right here
[14:22]
that the 5p can, is that still, it's moving?
[14:31]
The overhang is set, yeah.
[14:32]
I wonder what the setback is with the other way.
[14:35]
And the gutter, because right now it says
[14:37]
that the distance would be greater than 5p.
[14:40]
So Kerry is referring to the note from the building inspector.
[14:46]
His note was saying that from building to building, if it's between two and five feet from building to building, extra fire rate and material that he used.
[14:56]
It looks like the neighbor to the north is...
[15:00]
Just over five feet on the property line, the 16-inch overhang would put them closer to two feet off of the property line. So it would still be seven feet. So they would not have to do any extra-fierated materials. Okay.
[15:33]
Any other items up for discussion?
[16:00]
I'll make a motion to approve the request for
[16:06]
six foot north side yard setback motion seven dash 2.1 right reasons one through
[16:13]
four yes please all those in favor say aye all those opposed in name motion
[16:21]
carries motion seven dash two dot two overhang variance do I have a motion on
[16:28]
that the
[16:37]
recommendation is that it doesn't exceed 16 inches including the gutter
[16:41]
I suppose
[16:44]
that's not possible for trying to do one sheet.
[16:55]
Looking at this, so it's really 20 inches then of projections from the structure.
[17:04]
I'm just trying to see,
[17:09]
Courtney, did you get a reading, what's the property line then from there?
[17:15]
So we're requesting four feet.
[17:19]
So they'd be to, they'd be closer to two feet off of the property line.
[17:24]
We don't typically count into play inches.
[17:27]
Yeah, so it would then be closer to two feet with the overhang and depending on the size of the gutters.
[17:34]
Right.
[17:37]
You know what size the gutters are?
[17:39]
Four.
[17:40]
Four.
[17:40]
Okay.
[17:41]
There's about 20 inches to them.
[17:43]
Mm-hmm.
[17:48]
Yes, that brings a closer to about two feet right off of the house.
[17:58]
There's seven feet from the other structure.
[18:16]
We'll still work with a 12 inch overhang.
[18:35]
So looking at the survey of the neighbor's house, it looks like they have a 28-inch o-ring on that side, so that would be bringing it much closer to that five feet, the building inspector had concerns of the heavy between the two and the five.
[18:53]
That's how you get the difference, right?
[18:55]
Does it want to run into here?
[18:57]
And what will run into here?
[18:58]
Does that make a difference?
[18:59]
That would be a building and a reflector question.
[19:01]
Well, because a lot of it's trying to get equipment back there, things like that, right?
[19:04]
Like if there's a fire or whatever, like trying to get things back there.
[19:08]
Well, if you look at the garages too, I mean, the garages are nowhere near five feet apart.
[19:15]
You know, yeah, a lot of them.
[19:19]
There's a lot of things that have happened over the last hundred years.
[19:24]
All right.
[19:25]
I know all these houses were going on.
[19:28]
This was going in two, three, five, so.
[19:30]
Right.
[19:32]
Right.
[19:34]
Absolutely.
[19:51]
These lots are like a nightmare to deal with.
[19:53]
This area is not quite as bad as some of the others.
[19:56]
Right.
[19:58]
I guess we didn't hear from a concerned neighbor as long as a building spectrum is okay with it, which it looks like that recommendation came through just by motion to approve the overhang.
[20:15]
I'll support.
[20:17]
Reasons one through four?
[20:18]
Yes, please.
[20:19]
Any conditions?
[20:24]
All those in favor say aye.
[20:25]
Aye. Aye. Aye. All those opposed to a nay? Motion carries. Motion 7-2.3 class a designation.
[20:35]
So we have a. Who supported that one? I didn't do that one. Motion
[20:48]
approved. Second.
[20:50]
Reasons one through four? Yes, please. Any conditions? No, sir. All those in favor say aye? Aye. Aye.
[20:57]
Aye.
[20:58]
All those opposed to a nay?
[20:59]
Motion carries.
[21:01]
Item number eight, any unfinished business?
[21:04]
None.
[21:06]
Item nine, no new business.
[21:09]
So item 10, any member updates.
[21:14]
We'll move item number 11, adjournment.
[21:16]
Can I get a motion?
[21:17]
Make a motion to adjourn?
[21:19]
No, it's a four.
[21:21]
All those in favor say aye.
[21:23]
Aye.
[21:23]
All those opposed to a nay?
[21:25]
Motion carries.
[21:27]
721.