Agenda
Agenda: https://hayward.legistar1.com/hayward/meetings/2026/9/4601_A_City_Council_26-09-15_Agenda.pdf
Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
[6:46]
And OK, I Okay Thank you.
[8:09]
I apologize Apologies for that.
[8:11]
We you know, technical technical difficulty as they say.
[8:18]
OK.
[8:18]
So I like to reconvene the meeting
[8:22]
And welcome everybody back We i left off at public comment bye.
[8:29]
Have two public comment cards for this
[8:31]
particular in this particular area And then, of course,
[8:37]
the other public comment will happen when I
[8:39]
get to that item on the agenda.
[8:42]
So let me kick this off with the first public comment from Mr.
[8:47]
Tom Wang Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
[9:01]
And the City Council I would like to address the issue
[9:03]
There's a mental health facility these that
[9:06]
actually help in our community.
[9:08]
There are some people that cannot take care of themselves
[9:10]
and they are facilities here in the city to help these people
[9:13]
out.
[9:14]
And they provide a very much needed quality of life for them.
[9:19]
And speaking with some of these facilities,
[9:22]
it turns out that they're underfunded
[9:24]
and they are lacking a lot of needs.
[9:27]
They want to expand and to help more people.
[9:30]
But they're being told that there's the red tape
[9:34]
and there's things that they need to do better.
[9:36]
And it's prolonging extending upgrades until for city
[9:40]
that they can help more people or get better quality
[9:43]
care for the current staff that people that they have
[9:47]
that they're helping.
[9:48]
So I asked that the city council please look into this
[9:51]
and to help these care facilities, these small care
[9:54]
facilities throughout our neighborhood, to help them out,
[9:57]
to see what You can do in funding and quality of care
[10:01]
and helping them with food and other services.
[10:05]
Most of these directors who are taking care, these people,
[10:08]
they make less than $50 a day and they're doing it out
[10:12]
of kindness or their heart because after you pay everything
[10:15]
up to you, pay your electric city, your food,
[10:17]
cost your maintenance and everything,
[10:19]
they actually make less than $50 a day.
[10:22]
So they are providing a care for our community.
[10:25]
We don't want these people will have diminished capacities
[10:28]
in our neighborhood wandering around.
[10:30]
And it's not a good thing for our community
[10:32]
or for these people.
[10:34]
So please help them with that.
[10:35]
And i know that there's an item on the ballot for this November
[10:40]
or for raising the business tax.
[10:42]
And if you do get some revenue from that
[10:45]
to see about setting aside some money to help these people out
[10:49]
because it and they still are part of our community,
[10:52]
they may have a diminished capacities,
[10:54]
but they still are somebody that we need to take care of.
[10:58]
And thank you for your time Thank you.
[11:02]
Our next speaker is Lorena Vieira
[11:23]
I know that we're here today for other stuff,
[11:27]
but I believe that if you have the information
[11:31]
or the false information from this company,
[11:34]
we have the right to revoke the approval.
[11:37]
If you see the form that I'm giving you,
[11:39]
is that docketed that the mr. Gallup provided to the CC
[11:47]
to approve some information?
[11:49]
If you go to page number three, you
[11:54]
can see that the data that this that company just was
[11:58]
from 2020 2022 is yours.
[12:01]
Let me finish.
[12:02]
Ms..
[12:03]
Vieira, are you Ms..
[12:04]
Vieira if this is about the stack center
[12:09]
if you can please wait until the end
[12:11]
when we get to that item on the agenda Well,
[12:14]
this is not in the agenda and I would
[12:16]
like to present this as you know, item
[12:21]
that we are not in San Jose.
[12:24]
We are in Hayworth.
[12:25]
And the information that the stack company provided,
[12:29]
it's says that they closed.
[12:30]
Ms. Vieira obviously, the Jackson, Mississippi
[12:34]
I know you're your the item on the stack
[12:38]
is at the end of the agenda and we will get there.
[12:40]
OK I hope you can.
[12:42]
Yes.
[12:42]
And I'll save your card.
[12:43]
Thank you OK.
[12:45]
I do not have any more public comments
[12:48]
so I will move on to city manager's comments
[12:54]
Thank you, Mayor.
[12:55]
Council First, I'd like to report about the Hayward
[12:59]
executive Airport that hosted its annual Open House
[13:02]
event on Sunday September 13, from 10 to 3.
[13:06]
The free event for families and aviation lovers drew more than
[13:10]
$50,500 visitors from Hayward and the East Bay,
[13:14]
which was record attendance The event provides opportunities See
[13:18]
a variety of aircraft firsthand, Take an airplane ride
[13:21]
to discover what flying is all about.
[13:23]
And learn more about exciting careers in aviation
[13:26]
Some of the 62 exhibitors included the Hayward Police
[13:29]
and Fire departments, S.F. Drone School and Archer Aviation,
[13:33]
representing the electric aircraft of the future.
[13:36]
So just want to give a congratulations to the Hayward
[13:38]
Executive Airport team Also on September 26th,
[13:43]
the Hayward mariachi Festival returns a vibrant celebration
[13:47]
celebration of Mexican culture.
[13:49]
The Hayward mariachi Festival is expected
[13:52]
to draw thousands of attendees from across the San Francisco
[13:55]
bay.
[13:57]
Renowned mariachi bands will showcase the genre's
[14:00]
rich heritage through stunning and regalia,
[14:02]
intricate instruments tation and soulful vocals
[14:05]
The festival will also feature a vibrant Mercado
[14:08]
with local artisans, authentic Mexican cuisine Lucha Libra
[14:12]
entertainment and interactive cultural demonstrations.
[14:15]
And the family friendly event produced
[14:16]
by the Hayward Chamber of Commerce
[14:18]
will take place at Southland Mall from 12 p.m.
[14:20]
to 6 p.m.
[14:21]
Saturday september 26th.
[14:23]
It celebrates our community's diversity and cultural richness
[14:26]
and promises to leave a lasting impression.
[14:28]
Thank you very much.
[14:30]
Thank you Yeah, I just wanted to i
[14:31]
was going to make that report at the end of the meeting,
[14:34]
but i was at the airport open house on Sunday.
[14:38]
It was packed and it was a great event.
[14:42]
And of course the weather was great,
[14:44]
but just to see all the vendors there and all the information
[14:50]
booths there about how to become a pilot, how
[14:52]
to become, you know, how to, you know,
[14:53]
get into the aviation field it was great.
[14:57]
So big kudos to the airport and the airport staff.
[15:01]
And I know our public works directors in here So
[15:04]
thank you, Mr. Mary, for that.
[15:07]
OK Moving on to the R consent calendar.
[15:16]
Oh, no Moving on to the swearing in of our new city
[15:21]
commissioners What?
[15:23]
I am going to do is before the city clerk does the swearing in,
[15:30]
I'm going to go.
[15:30]
I'm going to forego staff report on city commissions
[15:35]
and then I'll just go straight to the city
[15:37]
clerk for next steps.
[15:40]
Thank you.
[15:41]
Good evening, Mayor Council members, community members
[15:44]
And you're correct.
[15:45]
This item relates to the appointment and reappointment
[15:50]
to the Cleaning Green Commission.
[15:53]
The community services Commission.
[15:55]
The Library Commission and Personnel Commission
[15:57]
and Planning commission.
[15:59]
So I'm going to ask if our newly appointed members actually Mayor
[16:05]
before we do this, rein in, we need to take action.
[16:08]
Yes, absolutely Absolutely.
[16:10]
Of course.
[16:11]
So let me do that.
[16:12]
Yes.
[16:12]
So I'm going to forego staff report.
[16:14]
And I'll come up to council to see
[16:16]
if there's any questions regarding
[16:19]
council or commissioners.
[16:21]
Seeing none, I will close this portion
[16:25]
open it up for public comment.
[16:26]
I do not have public comment cards,
[16:29]
nor do I see anyone online.
[16:31]
So I will close public comment.
[16:33]
And I will entertain a motion to accept the current class
[16:39]
of commissioners I'll move the item moved by Mayor Pro Tem Sara
[16:45]
Second.
[16:45]
Second and by Council member for Goldstein.
[16:48]
I know you said, but I heard.
[16:50]
I heard Goldstein beat you Second
[16:52]
by Councilmember Goldstein And if there are no objections
[16:56]
it will unanimously pass Congratulations, ladies
[16:59]
and gentlemen.
[17:00]
Let's give a big round of applause.
[17:01]
Our new commissioners Madam City Clerk.
[17:10]
Take it away.
[17:11]
Thank you.
[17:12]
You, Mr. Mayor.
[17:13]
Now I'm going to invite our newly appointed members
[17:16]
and our returning members to please join me at the podium I'm
[17:32]
going to do the first one.
[17:34]
I think all around Okay.
[17:38]
That's what you want to come here ?
[17:41]
Actually I did confer to give you that.
[17:46]
Just wait for me do we have all of you here?
[17:53]
Perfect.
[17:54]
All right.
[17:55]
So I'm going to ask you to raise your right hands Okay.
[18:00]
And i'm going to ask you to repeat your full name
[18:03]
one by one.
[18:04]
And we're going to go ahead and start over here I I Oh,
[18:10]
Daisy action I asked to send Bella I did Marie snuggle I,
[18:21]
Brigit Low.
[18:22]
I Cherien Purcell I Huang Dao Hi, Phyllis sander israel Mendez
[18:33]
aI.
[18:33]
Erik Hernandez.
[18:36]
AI.
[18:36]
Victor Gomez AI.
[18:39]
Carmen Cavallari AI Vasco.
[18:41]
Iago AI bonnet.
[18:44]
Indonesia I got salmon casinos.
[18:48]
I con McRae.
[18:51]
I. Guadalupe Romero I run Charlene Engine Dapper I. Jessy
[18:57]
Gunn Okay.
[18:58]
Thank you.
[18:59]
Now I'm going to ask you to repeat after me.
[19:02]
Okay.
[19:03]
Do you solemnly swear or affirm that I will support and defend
[19:08]
the Constitution of the United states and the Constitution
[19:11]
of the state of California against all enemies,
[19:14]
foreign and domestic ?
[19:16]
Go ahead.
[19:17]
Swear Shall the United States constitutions use these ?
[19:28]
That I will bear true faith and allegiance
[19:31]
to the Constitution of the United States
[19:33]
in the constant motion of the State of California
[19:36]
Go ahead States that I take this obligation freely
[19:46]
without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion.
[19:50]
Go ahead.
[19:51]
This obligation freely, without any restrictions And that
[19:57]
I will.
[19:58]
And faithfully discharge the duties
[20:00]
upon which I'm about to enter Go ahead Thank you, Mary.
[20:08]
Laura, your hands Congratulations.
[20:11]
Welcome to the Commission's Please have a seat.
[20:18]
Thank you You know, as the newly appointed commissioners
[20:25]
find their way to their seats I just wanted to say,
[20:28]
on behalf of the council.
[20:30]
Thank you for you know, applying and going
[20:34]
through the process and, of course,
[20:36]
going through the interview process These men and women
[20:41]
are volunteers they serve on a variety different committee
[20:47]
missions and, you know, they're the ones that are, you know,
[20:52]
making decisions And in our making sure
[20:55]
that the city meets its mission and its goals
[20:59]
and its priorities.
[20:59]
So again, let's give the newly appointed commissioners,
[21:03]
a big round of applause and thank them
[21:06]
for their service Okay Our next item,
[21:27]
consent item 13 on consent.
[21:30]
OK.
[21:30]
Thanks.
[21:34]
No Okay.
[21:38]
Okay.
[21:39]
Our next item is our consent calendar
[21:43]
and a have Two cards to comment.
[21:48]
The Terry Martin There is no number on the agenda item,
[21:54]
but what I'll do is I will open up for public comment and then
[22:00]
and then will entertain a motion.
[22:02]
So let me go to the first speaker
[22:06]
is Terry Martin I believe you press the button
[22:18]
and you press the button on the.
[22:19]
There we go.
[22:20]
It's on.
[22:20]
It's on.
[22:21]
What item of the agenda.
[22:22]
Are you looking at ?
[22:24]
Pretty much the first the first initial.
[22:28]
There's a lot of issues on the consent calendar
[22:30]
but I'm going to pick out the first ones that came to mind.
[22:33]
One is the per nouveau contract item the image trend data
[22:37]
contract and the Adobe services.
[22:39]
Now combine And this represents 1.5 million.
[22:43]
And this is actually you know, all of these
[22:46]
are being routed without public discussion.
[22:49]
Okay.
[22:50]
The subject to form escape hatch from item 26 to 95 expressly,
[22:53]
you know.
[22:54]
So the contract is subject to approval by the city attorney,
[22:58]
But that means that the council is
[23:00]
voting to approve a financial cap
[23:01]
deal before the final legal terms are fully ironed out
[23:04]
or signed.
[23:05]
Granting the center manager a wide latitude
[23:07]
to finalize this contract behind closed doors.
[23:10]
You know, and so i'm looking at this and going, well,
[23:13]
there's this 5,000 500,005 year agreement with per nouveau
[23:18]
radiology and it's basically slipping in a brand specific
[23:23]
medical device on the consent calendar that avoids public
[23:27]
scrutiny over competing bids or alternative medical local
[23:31]
systems.
[23:32]
And pretty much kind of all of them sort of follow within that.
[23:36]
And that, I think, is a huge issue
[23:38]
that maybe you need to have a public discussion about.
[23:41]
Thank you Thank you.
[23:43]
Our next public speaker who wants to speak on item number 13
[23:48]
is Tom Ferrara Hello Council.
[24:04]
There And it's time for I'm speaking today as a citizen,
[24:10]
but also speaking as a labor leader with.
[24:15]
H.W. And the thing that comes to mind
[24:19]
is My union brothers, sisters union brothers and sisters.
[24:26]
This item, item 13.
[24:29]
I spoke here in December about our financial situation
[24:33]
where after balancing everything and moving general fund
[24:37]
money over, we are less than $2 million away from bankruptcy.
[24:41]
And then here we are going to spend a little over $500,000
[24:45]
for a conference room And all I could think about is the six HP
[24:51]
staffing employees that were all of them eliminated,
[24:57]
the maintenance people that were eliminated in the library,
[25:01]
library employees that really needed that,
[25:04]
especially kerby I remember the lady was speaking here.
[25:09]
She is full time She got pushed down to part time
[25:12]
She didn't know what she was going
[25:13]
to do with her and her daughter with medical benefits
[25:16]
and everything else.
[25:18]
I think about that And that's why I'm saying a union brothers
[25:22]
and sisters this could have saved some of their jobs
[25:25]
or brought them back I appreciate this.
[25:28]
Not from general fund, but still I
[25:31]
think it's the wrong time to do this kind of building project.
[25:36]
I think a few years down the road would be better and just
[25:40]
to show the public that we do care about a balanced budget
[25:43]
and moving forward.
[25:44]
So thank you for your time, for appreciate it.
[25:47]
And thank you.
[25:48]
Thank you Okay Okay.
[26:01]
Next speaker is online.
[26:03]
Is t.J. from Hayward Concerned Citizens
[26:07]
And I'm assuming this is on the agenda on the consent calendar.
[26:13]
If not, I can move on Hi.
[26:18]
Yes I am calling about item number 13.
[26:23]
Good evening, Council.
[26:24]
This is T.J. of Hayward concerned Citizens.
[26:26]
I'm speaking on behalf of myself tonight
[26:28]
on item 13 on the Consent calendar,
[26:30]
which covers the city hall second floor facility
[26:33]
improvement project, which includes a new conference
[26:37]
room and two new enclosed offices for the deputy directors
[26:42]
of Transportation and Engineering.
[26:45]
I think the timing of this is terribly
[26:46]
wrong It sends a confusing message
[26:49]
to your residents about what is considered a priority.
[26:52]
While Hayward continues to be in a budget crisis.
[26:54]
Beyond your current balanced budget Nearly a year ago,
[26:58]
the council executive team took voluntary pay cuts
[27:01]
and paused cost of living adjustments
[27:03]
as a good faith gesture of making sacrifices
[27:07]
to help balance the broken budget
[27:08]
and sustain our city services.
[27:11]
So why stop there?
[27:12]
We've already experienced the impacts
[27:15]
of layoffs, frozen positions cuts to library services using
[27:20]
our Measure C funds to help balance your budget,
[27:23]
taking back grant funding that was awarded
[27:25]
to non profits in a previous c.
[27:27]
B bGP cycle.
[27:29]
And this year's National night Out caravan
[27:33]
being canceled due to placing constraints on staff overtime.
[27:37]
The message you're sending does matter The fact
[27:40]
that this City Hall improvement project is on the consent
[27:42]
calendar means that you need to be transparent about how
[27:45]
the funds are being used for this wish list item
[27:48]
and approve the over half $1 million to be spent on it.
[27:53]
And let's be honest, there's always that part of soul
[27:55]
that this half a million is not coming out
[27:57]
of general fund money.
[27:59]
But correct me if I'm wrong, it's
[28:01]
all of our taxpayer money Measure D, for instance.
[28:05]
Measure D is the utility tax.
[28:06]
We voted in that year residents pay and the water enterprise
[28:10]
revenue comes from the bills that utility customers pay,
[28:13]
which is also from your taxpayers
[28:15]
I realize staff in any business need the proper remedies to help
[28:19]
them do their jobs on the most in the most
[28:21]
comfortable and effective way.
[28:24]
But how many years has City Hall staff
[28:26]
managed with cubicles and meeting areas
[28:28]
as they already are?
[28:30]
What I'm suggesting is to defer this for the time being.
[28:33]
I'm sure there are other more pressing public facing needs.
[28:36]
These funds can help fulfill from making that sacrifice
[28:40]
today.
[28:41]
Thank you Thank you.
[28:44]
I don't have any other cards and I don't have any other speakers.
[28:49]
So what I'd like to do is i come back to the council
[29:03]
and I'll entertain a motion.
[29:06]
I'll move the item moved by Mayor Pro Tem Sara seconded
[29:11]
by Councilmember Goldstein And if there
[29:13]
are no objections actually, can we take a roll call?
[29:19]
The council member.
[29:21]
Well, there He's back.
[29:22]
So moved by council Mayor Pro Tem Sara
[29:27]
second by Councilmember Goldstein.
[29:29]
And if there are no objections the consent calendar
[29:34]
will unanimously pass.
[29:36]
Thank you Moving on On our next item is it's an informational
[29:53]
item and item number 20 Metropolitan Transportation
[29:57]
Commission, Pavement Management technical Assistance Program,
[30:02]
P Tab 2027 Grant Award for updating the city's pays
[30:07]
pavement management Program Project number 05110.
[30:12]
There is no staff report on this,
[30:15]
and this is purely an information journal item
[30:18]
and i just wanted to open up for council
[30:21]
to see if they had any questions or comments regarding this
[30:25]
If not I will close this item and then I
[30:28]
will move on to the council reports and future referrals.
[30:37]
I just wanted to reiterate to the city manager
[30:41]
thank you very much and of course, the Director of Public
[30:45]
works for Sun Sun was a great day.
[30:49]
And, it was the C 15,000 people.
[30:54]
It's a clear demonstration that every time the city
[30:58]
puts on these kinds of events that there certainly a draw.
[31:01]
So thank you for that.
[31:04]
If there are no other oral reports
[31:08]
I will then move on to council referral
[31:12]
rules which is item number 21.
[31:17]
The City Council referral Prohibition Data Center
[31:20]
development referral from Mayor Salinas Councilmember Sara
[31:23]
and council member Andrews before her.
[31:29]
I wasn't sure who was going to kick this off
[31:33]
but before I pass it over to our Director of Public Works
[31:41]
I wanted to just to set up a little bit of context here.
[31:45]
And I'll just be real brief before I give it
[31:48]
to our development services director This meeting
[31:56]
and this referral and way.
[31:59]
Hold on This meeting.
[32:03]
And this referral comes in response to a a town hall
[32:09]
that we had last month in South Hayward
[32:14]
And it also comes in response funds
[32:17]
to a few weeks earlier than that when people began
[32:23]
to express concern regarding the stack in the industrial
[32:30]
in the industrial zone and what we're
[32:36]
going to hear tonight is a referral I also
[32:42]
want to be clear about what our goal tonight is.
[32:46]
Our goal tonight is to listen Our goal tonight is
[32:51]
to talk to staff and direct staff
[32:55]
as to what next ups are There will be no action taken tonight.
[33:02]
We're not voting on anything.
[33:04]
We're not doing any of that.
[33:07]
We are simply listening.
[33:09]
And we will be directing staff as to next steps
[33:15]
We will try to listen to everybody
[33:20]
And I can i can I'm sure I can speak for the council
[33:23]
when I say we have received your emails We have received
[33:29]
your phone calls and and we have you know, and we
[33:35]
have been listening to all of you
[33:38]
and and I hope tonight we can bring more clarity
[33:43]
and be able to direct staff as to next steps
[33:48]
and what we will be doing next So
[33:51]
with that said I wanted to pass it
[33:53]
on to our director of development services, Ms. Sarah
[33:58]
Bosa Good evening, Mayor and Council.
[34:01]
I am going to turn it over to our planning manager, Lisa
[34:04]
Schmidt, who will go through a slide presentation for you
[34:07]
tonight.
[34:08]
Thank you so much.
[34:09]
Thank you.
[34:10]
You.
[34:12]
Good evening Mayor.
[34:13]
Members of the City Council and everyone who's in here tonight,
[34:15]
welcome to our city council meeting.
[34:18]
It's really happy to see you all here I'm going to provide
[34:22]
a brief presentation related to the City Council referral,
[34:25]
outlining actions to limit or further regulate data centers
[34:29]
Data center development in Hayward so on August 12th,
[34:33]
citing significant community outcry related to the approval
[34:37]
of the Stack data center and then concerns about health
[34:40]
and environmental risks related to development of data centers
[34:42]
in general Oh Three City Council members directed staff to return
[34:50]
to the full council with options to prohibit or otherwise limit
[34:54]
data center development.
[34:55]
In addition, the referral directed at staff this council
[34:59]
Sustainability committee to prepare a report on the Economic
[35:03]
and Environmental impacts of existing data
[35:05]
centers This presentation includes a brief background
[35:09]
of data centers in Hayward, the environmental review
[35:12]
process around these facilities and current regulations related
[35:15]
to data centers in Hayward.
[35:17]
And then details three options to further regulate or limit
[35:20]
data center development Just so we're on the same page,
[35:26]
I wanted to take a moment to define data centers,
[35:28]
which have been around since at least the 1960s Okay Okay data
[35:39]
centers are buildings designed and equipped to allow for high
[35:42]
density computing equipment, such as server racks used
[35:46]
for data storage and processing, generally for offsite users.
[35:51]
These facilities require uninterrupted power supplies
[35:54]
and cooling generally they rely on the electric grid,
[35:57]
but they do have on site backup power, such as generators.
[36:01]
Functions may include onsite on demand services,
[36:05]
cloud computing, enterprise services, Internet facilities.
[36:08]
And more recently, I computing.
[36:12]
There are four data centers in Hayward
[36:14]
that fall within this definition two
[36:17]
that were constructed in the mid-aughts
[36:18]
and have been operational for over a decade.
[36:21]
A large and then two larger scale facilities one of which
[36:25]
became fully operational within the past few months.
[36:28]
And one that is currently under construction to data centers
[36:33]
are subject to environment title review
[36:35]
three Under the California Environmental Quality
[36:37]
act or secure the environmental analysis may be prepared
[36:41]
by the city or the California energy Commission,
[36:44]
depending on the energy generation
[36:46]
at the facility he outlined.
[36:47]
On the left side of this slide subject areas analyzed
[36:52]
under sequence are shown in the image on the right side
[36:55]
of the screen Numerous studies and analysis
[36:58]
are prepared in order to measure potential impacts of a project
[37:01]
based on these subject areas.
[37:03]
If any impacts are identified, the project
[37:05]
must include mitigation measures to reduce
[37:07]
those impacts to a level of less than significa
[37:10]
Under state law for example, the Stack data
[37:14]
center had 14 mitigation measures, including
[37:16]
the requirement to use 100% renewable energy
[37:19]
and to use renewable diesel for generator testing
[37:22]
to manage greenhouse gas and air quality impacts respectively
[37:26]
Additionally, the project incorporated construction
[37:29]
related mitigation measures to minimize impacts
[37:31]
to air quality biological resources, cultural resources,
[37:34]
geology, hydrology and hazardous materials In April of 2026,
[37:41]
in light of recent data center approvals and recognizing that
[37:44]
there was a need for additional oversight and guidance for staff
[37:47]
and developers around this topic the City Council adopted
[37:50]
amendments to the zoning ordinance to define data centers
[37:53]
in the Municipal Code to establish a new major
[37:56]
conditional use permit process for requiring city council
[37:59]
approval allowing data centers in two industrial subdistrict
[38:03]
subject to major conditional use permit approval and requiring
[38:07]
that all new data centers submit sustainability plans
[38:11]
and community benefits packages regardless of project or site
[38:15]
size We do not have any pending applications for data centers
[38:19]
under centers under these new regulations So the following
[38:24]
three slides outline various options explored in the staff
[38:28]
report
[38:28]
that the Council can take to strengthen or limit
[38:30]
regulations related to data centers
[38:34]
The first option maintain the status quo
[38:36]
while strengthening regulations would allow data center
[38:38]
applications to be processed under the current regulations
[38:41]
while staff actively develops updated regulations.
[38:44]
Updating and strengthening the current regulations
[38:47]
could include requirements around monitoring and reporting
[38:51]
required additional environmental studies that
[38:53]
may not be required under Ceqa and possibly
[38:56]
a decommissioning requirement, among others.
[38:59]
This process of preparing updated regulations
[39:01]
could take up to six months.
[39:03]
It would require robust community outreach
[39:05]
and would ultimately come back to the city Council for Adoption
[39:10]
Other jurisdictions that are taking this approach include San
[39:13]
Jose and los Angeles County.
[39:15]
Benefits of this option are that it would provide time for staff
[39:18]
to do analysis based on best practices in data center
[39:20]
development While the Council can approve or deny projects
[39:24]
on a case by case basis on the merits of the specific project
[39:27]
and location Drawbacks include a longer time
[39:30]
frame for implementation that the applications must continue
[39:33]
to be processed under the current regulations
[39:35]
and that the city must redirect staff
[39:38]
and resources to this effort.
[39:42]
The second option explored in this staff report
[39:44]
is to adopt an urgency moratorium
[39:46]
subject to certain findings to pause data center approvals.
[39:50]
This action would require a 4/5 vote of the City Council upon
[39:53]
adoption and could be extended up to a year.
[39:56]
A pause in data center development
[39:57]
would allow staff time to study the impacts of data centers
[40:00]
and to develop updated regulations based
[40:02]
on the impacts and best practices.
[40:04]
If this option is chosen staff can make every effort
[40:07]
to bring this report back and the related findings back
[40:10]
to the City Council by the end of October Other jurisdictions
[40:15]
that have adopted moratoria while regulations are being
[40:17]
evaluated include Oakley El monte, Baldwin Park,
[40:21]
Montebello, Gilroy.
[40:22]
Last night Others probably today There's a lot of them.
[40:26]
Benefits of this option are that it's temporary.
[40:29]
It allows staff time to analyze best
[40:31]
practices and impacts of data center development
[40:33]
and to monitor implementation of state laws related
[40:36]
to this particular use that are sitting on the governor's desk
[40:39]
right now.
[40:40]
Drawbacks to this approach are that we
[40:42]
must develop Hayward specific findings to support this urgency
[40:45]
moratorium continue to accept and process but not approve data
[40:49]
center application sites, and that the city must redirect
[40:53]
staff and resources to this effort
[40:57]
The third option explored in the staff report
[40:59]
is a permanent ban on data centers
[41:01]
This option may or may not be accompanied
[41:03]
by a moratorium similar to the amending
[41:05]
the regulations option that was detailed
[41:07]
or that I described above.
[41:09]
This process may take several months to implement,
[41:12]
since there are existing data centers that must be,
[41:15]
you know, addressed in these regulations.
[41:18]
Other Juristic tions that are banned data centers
[41:20]
include Monterey park, Coachella, Cudahy and Irwindale.
[41:24]
Benefits of this option include the ability of the City Council
[41:27]
to define the ban and any exclusions or exceptions
[41:30]
to the ban For existing data centers,
[41:32]
it would provide staff time to monitor data center
[41:35]
development in other jurisdictions
[41:37]
without having to process any new developments.
[41:40]
Drawbacks include the longer time frame
[41:42]
for employment implementation that it would create uncertainty
[41:46]
around existing data centers, which have invested heavily
[41:49]
in Hayward, that the city must continue to accept and process
[41:52]
applications until the ban is adopted
[41:56]
and that the city must redirect staff and resources
[41:58]
to this effort.
[41:59]
Further there will be a loss of potential revenue and community
[42:02]
benefits associated with new data center development
[42:08]
So following Council discussion and public comments,
[42:10]
the Council is asked to provide guidance to staff
[42:13]
on their next preferred steps.
[42:15]
And that concludes this presentation.
[42:17]
OK Thank you Anything else?
[42:20]
That's it.
[42:21]
Okay.
[42:21]
Perfect.
[42:22]
All right.
[42:22]
So before I go to council comments, what I'm going to do
[42:27]
is I do have cards here for public comment
[42:31]
before I get to that.
[42:36]
I also wanted to I'm sure folks in the outside in the
[42:43]
in the hallway I guess they know that to a there's a way,
[42:47]
there's a overflow.
[42:47]
OK, good.
[42:48]
All right Okay.
[42:51]
So just in case nobody heard of or just case some of you
[42:54]
didn't hear this, I'll say this again.
[42:56]
The public comment section provides an opportunity
[42:58]
to address the Council on items not listed
[43:02]
on the agenda or informational staff presentation items
[43:06]
The Council welcomes comments and requests
[43:09]
that speakers present their remarks in a respectful manner.
[43:14]
Within the established time limits and focus
[43:17]
on issues which directly affect the city
[43:21]
or are within the jurisdiction of the city as the Council is
[43:25]
prohibited by state law from discussing items not listed
[43:29]
on the agenda items will be taken under consideration.
[43:33]
And may be referred to staff.
[43:36]
The City Council welcomes comments including criticism
[43:40]
about the policies procedures program or services of the city
[43:44]
or of the acts or omissions of the City Council.
[43:48]
Speakers as shall not use threaten, mean,
[43:51]
profane or abusive language, which disrupt peace,
[43:55]
disturbs or otherwise impedes the orderly conduct
[43:59]
of a city of the city Council.
[44:02]
The city is committed to maintaining a workplace free
[44:06]
of unlawful harassment and is mindful that city staff
[44:11]
regularly attends council meetings Discriminatory
[44:16]
statements or conduct that is hostile or intimidating or
[44:20]
oppressive or abusive are per say to a meeting
[44:26]
and will not be tolerated.
[44:29]
So with that you know, I also just want to say that you know,
[44:35]
there's a lot of us here.
[44:37]
I know there's a lot of thought on this,
[44:40]
and I know there's a lot of feeling on this topic.
[44:43]
And if we can just we're all up here.
[44:46]
We cannot reply, but we're listening and we're listening.
[44:52]
Let's be respectful.
[44:53]
We will listen to you and then we will.
[44:57]
You know, then we will provide feedback.
[44:59]
And then we're going to direct staff.
[45:01]
But I just you know, we've had, you
[45:03]
know some of these meetings in the past.
[45:06]
And I know passions are high, but I just
[45:09]
let's i'd like for us to get through this process
[45:13]
and so that we can listen We're all taking notes.
[45:15]
And so that we can do after you do your job,
[45:19]
then we will do our job All right.
[45:21]
So with that said, I'd like to and of course, per council
[45:28]
guidelines on a referral item, public comment
[45:32]
is One minute long.
[45:33]
OK So with that said, our first speaker
[45:37]
is lorena Viera I think I already gave you
[45:47]
copies of that document that I wanted to present to rebut
[45:52]
the approval of this company If you're looking into the page
[45:56]
number three, you can see that there's that company provided
[46:00]
false information because the data is from 2020 2022
[46:05]
and is talking about all the chemicals that we get in the air
[46:08]
and also indicate that that clause says facility was
[46:15]
in Jackson is true Say as we all knows is a state company
[46:19]
also is trying to open a data center over there this morning
[46:25]
or yesterday, I made a phone call to them in my
[46:28]
in the second document,
[46:31]
Mr. To the person that provided information at the I'm sorry.
[46:44]
It says that they consulting company.
[46:47]
It's david Power an associate i made a phone call yesterday
[46:51]
and today i received a phone call from One of their members.
[46:54]
I did ask if they were involved with this company and the bus
[46:59]
The first answer was no Then I said, Are you sure?
[47:02]
Because I can work with you.
[47:04]
Ms. Vieira, your time is up.
[47:06]
I don't think so.
[47:07]
I put three cards.
[47:09]
Ms..
[47:09]
Ms..
[47:10]
Viera And somebody Ms..
[47:12]
Viera We have a stack of speakers behind you.
[47:14]
I understand, Mr. Salinas, but this is a major thing
[47:18]
If we have false information.
[47:20]
I think Mr. Fitzgerald actually your attorney can tell you
[47:24]
we can revoke the approval Please.
[47:26]
Thank you.
[47:28]
I'm sorry, but you have to let me talk,
[47:30]
because I have more to say Ms..
[47:31]
Vieira.
[47:32]
I know you do.
[47:33]
OK, then I guess you want to deal with the appeal
[47:35]
Thank you Our next speaker is first name is Marissa,
[47:40]
and then if I could have lined up in the middle of the chamber
[47:45]
here next speaker is Marissa I don't have a last name
[47:50]
then I have is a Kim Cawthorn and then Mala.
[47:57]
Mala sat there and then Jewel's many, many of our high
[48:05]
Good evening Some of you guys already know who I am
[48:10]
But on this stack center, I think
[48:14]
we need to do some regulating Keep it in line
[48:20]
as it was forced upon the city.
[48:24]
Because I guess you guys want money.
[48:25]
I don't know.
[48:27]
But you know, know if we should also ban future data centers
[48:34]
because as you could see by this turnout, nobody in Hayward
[48:39]
wants One of those.
[48:40]
And I live kind of in that area and maybe it's over there,
[48:46]
but and when it's quiet at night, all that humming,
[48:51]
I will be able to hear what that is
[48:55]
and being near the Hayward interpretive shoreline, that's
[49:00]
not a good thing either.
[49:03]
But if we're going to monitor, we
[49:05]
shouldn't be monitoring these for future.
[49:07]
And also maybe ask them to do solar Thank you.
[49:14]
Thank you.
[49:15]
Next speaker is Tim Concord And then
[49:22]
Marcelo Smith can line up next.
[49:23]
If she's here, I'm okay We need to hold them accountable.
[49:30]
Last week and x employee can you pull the microphone down
[49:35]
to your mouth?
[49:35]
There you go Last week in x employee of anthropic
[49:40]
and the heads of all the A.I. companies admitted
[49:43]
that this type of company.
[49:45]
And the data centers that are attached to them are dangerous.
[49:50]
Let's listen.
[49:52]
Let's be part of the groundswell that does work
[49:54]
toward slowing it down.
[49:57]
We can do it even if we are just too small town
[50:01]
that doesn't matter.
[50:02]
It adds up We can be the small town that
[50:06]
helps to make the dollars add up to go against this.
[50:11]
If we don't act now, it'll be too late.
[50:13]
Air is coming on a lot faster than computers.
[50:17]
We should not allow One more data center
[50:20]
to be built If there are people getting paid
[50:23]
to support data centers, seek them out and sue them
[50:27]
with what there is now.
[50:28]
Hold them accountable, make them pay extra taxes,
[50:32]
test the water and the air in which they produce cars.
[50:39]
Watch them like a mother Hawk Thank you
[50:45]
And Marla father sharon Yes.
[50:54]
OK.
[50:55]
Good evening, Mayor.
[50:56]
Council on staff.
[50:58]
My name is Marla.
[50:58]
Say they're a 40 year Hayward resident I'm here to deliver
[51:02]
a data center oversight ordinance and technical letter
[51:06]
with signatories I am also delivering a petition signed
[51:11]
by approximately 2,300 Hayward residents and with more
[51:16]
signatures still coming in, supporting the direction
[51:19]
of tonight's referral the petition asks the council
[51:22]
to protect Hayward from further hyper scale data center
[51:25]
development and to require rigorous monitoring
[51:28]
and reporting for the Y03 facility already approved
[51:33]
and under construction on Eden Landing This is the significant
[51:36]
public outcry.
[51:37]
The city manager announcement referenced.
[51:39]
It is on paper and signatures from residents across the city.
[51:43]
Thank you to Mayor Salinas Mayor pro tempore
[51:47]
syrup and council member Andrews for authoring the referral.
[51:50]
Please pass it as written with both parts and intact.
[51:53]
I also have proposed motions and a cost benefit and alternate use
[51:57]
analysis.
[51:58]
Thank you.
[51:59]
You.
[51:59]
Thank you And then jewels are many of our jewels
[52:09]
and then behind if we can cue up Tom Wong
[52:16]
and the C g Gene Buchanan Good evening.
[52:27]
This is directed to Mayor Celine as Councilmember district one
[52:34]
Roach and district Council number six serves.
[52:39]
We're in an election year.
[52:41]
I hope you do all you can to retroactively ban
[52:45]
the eden Landing Data center Thank you.
[52:49]
Thank you Marcellus Smith.
[52:58]
And then if we can have cued up, is it or is it
[53:05]
Randy rodriguez Go ahead The data
[53:12]
center is an absolute betrayal of the residents of Hayward
[53:19]
community It reeks of it reeks of illegal process
[53:31]
This is going on from the beginning.
[53:35]
It reeks that right now And it is a reflection of this city
[53:41]
council who consistently makes bad decisions
[53:46]
and by that the movie theater, the Loop
[53:53]
And I could go on and on and on.
[53:55]
And now we don't have money to run the city properly
[54:01]
We are upset that we will not we will show up.
[54:06]
We will keep showing up This needs to be banned
[54:10]
and we are willing to do whatever is
[54:13]
necessary to make that happen.
[54:15]
Thank you.
[54:16]
You.
[54:16]
Thank you The next speaker is Tom Wong.
[54:27]
But then can we have Luciano Duran and Sheila Cho line up?
[54:34]
Go ahead.
[54:35]
Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
[54:35]
And City council.
[54:36]
Thank you.
[54:37]
This data center is.
[54:39]
We shouldn't.
[54:39]
We shouldn't just ban and we should actually
[54:41]
do reverse course.
[54:42]
We should actually have them move out and shut them down.
[54:45]
This is a danger to the community.
[54:47]
There's over 22,000 square footage of e-waste
[54:51]
and it's never addressed.
[54:52]
Tell me what happens with all these chips that are outdated
[54:55]
and I and data centers They're updating their servers every 6
[54:59]
to eight months and nobody's talking about world
[55:02]
is e-waste is going and it is harmful to our community.
[55:06]
So I ask that you do more due diligence and and not
[55:11]
only banning but also putting safeguards and rails to it.
[55:15]
This takes away jobs, takes away money from our community
[55:18]
The tax dollar goes directly to the city coffers.
[55:21]
It does nothing for our community.
[55:23]
It doesn't go to the restaurant It doesn't go to our neighbors
[55:27]
It doesn't help our parks.
[55:28]
However, this funds the city's pet projects.
[55:31]
And we need to stop this there.
[55:33]
So there are better businesses that we could bring
[55:35]
into the city Thank you Janine.
[55:43]
Janine buchanan.
[55:44]
And then can we have lined up Scott Galati and Terry Martin.
[55:50]
Right.
[55:51]
Good evening.
[55:51]
My name's Jeanie Buchanan.
[55:53]
I'm a Hayward resident.
[55:54]
I want to address the other part of the initiative
[55:57]
tonight establishing ongoing monitoring and enforcement
[56:00]
framework for already approved sites like the Stack,
[56:04]
Hayward's Protect will rely entirely on this policy.
[56:09]
As you know, the original sequence study only
[56:11]
measured noise at DB, a levels.
[56:14]
It did not evaluate the low frequency db
[56:18]
C levels, which bend over barriers
[56:21]
and even penetrate residential walls.
[56:23]
For example noise from h fac chillers that run 24 seven.
[56:28]
Therefore, please mandate three items
[56:31]
in the monitoring framework.
[56:33]
One independent pre operating panel
[56:35]
db c Baseline testing at residential property lines.
[56:40]
Two Enforceable low frequency db C limits and three perimeter
[56:46]
noise monitoring results available to the public
[56:50]
without this code, enforcement will not
[56:53]
be able to protect our neighborhoods Thank you.
[56:56]
Thank you Hello.
[57:06]
Good evening.
[57:07]
Council members I'm Harold Hayward, resident and honestly
[57:10]
I'm shocked this got this far.
[57:12]
I support banning future data centers,
[57:14]
requiring real strict oversight of stock.
[57:17]
Stock is a 300,000 foot square foot and 77MW.
[57:23]
They all herald report and moved forward without city council
[57:26]
vote because it was classified as office
[57:29]
use That was a loophole.
[57:31]
A project that could affect our city's water power, air, noise
[57:35]
and shoreline should not be able to just slide through
[57:38]
as just another office building when
[57:40]
we know it's more than that I'm not anti technology.
[57:43]
I'm against residents dealing with consequences We never
[57:46]
had a real chance to approve or sign up
[57:48]
for Please ban future data centers
[57:51]
requires stock to publicly report its actual water, energy
[57:54]
use, generator pollution and noise.
[57:57]
This was a huge oversight does not happen.
[58:00]
I think Thank you for your time and then when you come up
[58:11]
we're just trying to keep track of you in the system.
[58:14]
That's fine We just need to hear your name.
[58:16]
So if you can state your name and where you're from that
[58:19]
would be great.
[58:19]
That way we can make sure we're on cue.
[58:22]
Yes My name is Luciano Duran, and i
[58:24]
live with part of my family here at Giesler Way.
[58:28]
And good evening I just want to say thanks.
[58:31]
First of all, to dear Mayor Salinas Mayor
[58:34]
Pro tempore or syrup and council member
[58:37]
andrews for listening and making this possible
[58:40]
and all the residents of Hayward and as we can see.
[58:44]
And becoming aware more and more international even nationally
[58:48]
and locally.
[58:49]
Of course, this is the issue of our time.
[58:51]
This is something we have not encountered before.
[58:55]
I would say this is something major that
[59:00]
is affecting societies and towns throughout the United States.
[59:04]
And certainly Hayward and its affect, it's affect
[59:07]
is in it affects us in ways that is hard to know yet
[59:14]
But the things that we do know are very serious.
[59:17]
It increases us radiation, a heat wise.
[59:24]
It affects everything in the environment,
[59:27]
the air the water supply not.
[59:30]
And of course, it depreciates value of property
[59:33]
nearby because it's of all the pollution that is generating
[59:37]
and the the product itself of air
[59:41]
is questionable as we have come to know.
[59:43]
Now, Mr. Duran OK.
[59:46]
But but we got it.
[59:47]
Well, thank you so much.
[59:48]
Thank you.
[59:48]
Thank you And then Sheila Cho Yeah.
[59:55]
And then can I have lined up Eric is it Nico?
[1:00:00]
Mira?
[1:00:01]
And then jeffrey Hamann and Robert Stevens OK.
[1:00:08]
Good evening.
[1:00:09]
I'm Sheila I live in Hayward and I speak for hayward residents
[1:00:13]
against we why 0387 data center bills are waiting
[1:00:17]
for the governor to sign or veto by September 30th.
[1:00:20]
3 of them directly matter here.
[1:00:22]
AB 1577 AB 2619.
[1:00:25]
AB 24, 69.
[1:00:27]
And they basically require reporting energy sound fuel
[1:00:31]
or water usages to approve to get approval for future
[1:00:35]
discretionary permit or business license,
[1:00:37]
or requiring water supply assessment for water impacted
[1:00:41]
expansions The city approve the 76.6MW facility that projects
[1:00:46]
9.5 acre feet of water per year and a peak day of almost 170 37
[1:00:52]
3,000 gallons.
[1:00:54]
So none of that has to be disclosed at the business
[1:00:57]
license stage I asked the council tonight to direct
[1:01:01]
the mayor to send a letter to support all seven bills
[1:01:05]
on the service to be have before September 30th.
[1:01:07]
And I asked every resident here to please also do the thing
[1:01:11]
and whatever.
[1:01:11]
Sacramento does, please pass tonight's referral
[1:01:14]
with the urgency ordinance and oversight
[1:01:16]
that ordinance because only Hayward can write its rules.
[1:01:19]
Thank you.
[1:01:20]
You.
[1:01:21]
Thank you Good evening.
[1:01:29]
Council members My name is Scott Galati Thank you
[1:01:31]
for having me here today.
[1:01:33]
I've worked on many data center projects
[1:01:36]
throughout the Bay Area.
[1:01:37]
I represent applicants who have a desire
[1:01:40]
to build a data center, some here in Hayward and elsewhere.
[1:01:44]
They i help them get through the California Energy Commission,
[1:01:46]
which is an extremely thorough process I understand
[1:01:49]
the potential features of data center.
[1:01:52]
I really do I would emphasize I empathize
[1:01:54]
with the people in this room that are nervous about what
[1:01:57]
data centers could cause and had I not
[1:02:00]
worked on as many data centers that I have and read
[1:02:02]
all the studies and seen all the work I might feel the same way.
[1:02:08]
California is ahead of the entire country
[1:02:11]
in adopting stringent environmental and energy
[1:02:14]
regulations that don't exist in most states.
[1:02:18]
What they don't do is make sure that many of the potential
[1:02:21]
impacts that you read in the newspaper
[1:02:23]
and that people might be talking about here,
[1:02:25]
they don't happen here in California i have worked
[1:02:30]
on 14 of the last 16 projects that went through the California
[1:02:34]
Energy commission since 2018.
[1:02:37]
Because of this regulatory environment.
[1:02:39]
All of the environmental impact reports that were prepared
[1:02:42]
for those projects found that there were no significant
[1:02:45]
impacts Oh Mr. Mr..
[1:02:53]
Galanos was paying attention.
[1:02:55]
Mr. Galloway, go right ahead.
[1:02:56]
No.
[1:02:57]
Your time is up.
[1:02:58]
Thank you.
[1:02:59]
Thank you I Terry Martin Hi.
[1:03:07]
My name is Terry Martin.
[1:03:08]
I live in San Leandro.
[1:03:09]
So what I'm going to tell you is actually
[1:03:12]
it's the diesel generators that are the problem.
[1:03:14]
So basically, what you have approved
[1:03:17]
is the equivalent of every three days during a test.
[1:03:21]
And it's the testing the week, the monthly testing of £55
[1:03:24]
of raw chemical mass into the air shed,
[1:03:27]
which is the liquid equivalent of 15 two liter of bottles
[1:03:31]
of liquid causing chemical poison Okay.
[1:03:34]
When these things start.
[1:03:35]
So basically how they get through the SEC.
[1:03:37]
And what the loophole is, is they say, oh, we're
[1:03:40]
just going to measure it, you know,
[1:03:42]
diluted these things are going to put the equivalent of that
[1:03:47]
over the neighborhood.
[1:03:48]
OK.
[1:03:48]
And it is going to poison people.
[1:03:50]
People will die if you took one of those bottles in here
[1:03:54]
and I opened it up and just aerosolized it.
[1:03:56]
Everybody in this room would be dead Everybody okay?
[1:04:02]
That's what you approved with the diesel generators.
[1:04:05]
OK.
[1:04:05]
And so basically you know inside a closed room at that volume,
[1:04:10]
you know, it's going to affect our,
[1:04:12]
you know, our kids and everything else.
[1:04:15]
And these diesel generators that's what they're putting out.
[1:04:17]
And there's nothing to stop it because it's the cold starts.
[1:04:21]
It's the equivalent of an industrial generator
[1:04:23]
of going in and saying, hey, can you get my car to pass smog?
[1:04:26]
And now times it by this industrial,
[1:04:29]
you know, these generators 28 of them, It's 100.
[1:04:32]
Just let me one one more thing.
[1:04:34]
It's a mile long thing of 18 wheelers constantly going
[1:04:38]
around the neighborhood every week.
[1:04:40]
That's interesting if that's what you're doing,
[1:04:42]
that's what you approach Again good evening, council members.
[1:04:53]
I'm Eric Nakamura at the Silicon Valley Leadership Group,
[1:04:56]
representing our regional innovation economy.
[1:04:58]
First would like to acknowledges the challenges you face
[1:05:01]
and thank you for your hard work as you consider
[1:05:04]
options around data centers.
[1:05:05]
Know the field and our members are here as a resource for you.
[1:05:08]
We urge you to look beyond prohibiting new data centers
[1:05:11]
and instead build on your recent work
[1:05:13]
to ensure responsible development done right data
[1:05:16]
centers to deliver significant tax revenues and infrastructure
[1:05:20]
upgrades without harming residents.
[1:05:22]
Quality of life Silicon Valley's leading companies
[1:05:26]
are deploying real innovative and at scale
[1:05:28]
solutions to drastically reduce water consumption
[1:05:31]
and address other key concerns.
[1:05:33]
We asked for your participation in a thoughtful dialogue
[1:05:36]
between government and your industry partners
[1:05:38]
and appreciate your work and also everyone here.
[1:05:40]
Thank you.
[1:05:40]
You.
[1:05:41]
Thank you.
[1:05:42]
Thank you Where they live.
[1:05:47]
No, I did not Did you get well?
[1:05:52]
You If you want to go ahead, tell it.
[1:05:54]
Tell us Mr. Hammond.
[1:05:57]
Harmon all along.
[1:05:58]
And if you want to tell us where you live, that'd be great.
[1:06:01]
I live in Los Gatos and I work a a lady late.
[1:06:07]
Ladies and gentlemen, Ladies and gentlemen, ladies and gentlemen.
[1:06:12]
Here.
[1:06:13]
Fine, ladies and gentlemen, please Hey, you
[1:06:16]
guys Ladies and gentlemen, ladies and gentlemen.
[1:06:20]
Listen if we're going to have outbursts like this,
[1:06:24]
I will close the meeting and we will have this discussion
[1:06:27]
amongst ourselves.
[1:06:28]
All right Please give everybody the respect
[1:06:33]
and let everyone talk I understand.
[1:06:36]
I get it.
[1:06:37]
We get it But.
[1:06:39]
But let's have everyone talk and present their point of view
[1:06:44]
and and so we can get through this.
[1:06:46]
All right There should not be a shouting match.
[1:06:50]
Shouting people down.
[1:06:52]
And just because you disagree with them.
[1:06:54]
All right?
[1:06:55]
So please we're going to respect all of you
[1:06:57]
So please respect the process.
[1:07:00]
All right Thank you.
[1:07:02]
You're good.
[1:07:02]
You're good.
[1:07:03]
Thank you Mr. Mr. Hammond Hello.
[1:07:08]
My name is Jeffrey Hammond, and I'm one of the Hayward Planning
[1:07:11]
commissioner who approved the stacked data center development.
[1:07:15]
I am a volunteer.
[1:07:16]
And I do not receive any compensation for my time
[1:07:20]
I'm here tonight to state that I stand behind all my decisions
[1:07:23]
to approve the Stacked data Center development because I
[1:07:26]
believe the data center is good for Hayward economically.
[1:07:30]
And for the future.
[1:07:31]
I believe that we have a unique opportunity here in Hayward
[1:07:34]
to use data centers to help build the infrastructure where
[1:07:37]
we need to attract future industry which will help create
[1:07:40]
good jobs here in Hayward.
[1:07:42]
I believe that much of the outrage and concern surrounding
[1:07:44]
this project is unfounded and based on misinformation.
[1:07:47]
I question.
[1:07:48]
How many people have read all the staff reports,
[1:07:50]
environmental impact reports, scope findings
[1:07:53]
or even the minutes from previous planning planning
[1:07:55]
Commission meetings?
[1:07:56]
I have read all the reports.
[1:07:58]
And I have found no reason to deny this project
[1:08:00]
or especially to ban all future data centers.
[1:08:03]
I fully support greater public outreach
[1:08:06]
and I would encourage data center developers
[1:08:08]
to offer greater transparency and public involvement Hires
[1:08:12]
a city council decision maker.
[1:08:15]
Thank you.
[1:08:15]
Thank you You guys You guys please.
[1:08:25]
All right.
[1:08:25]
And like, I said, we will I will close the chamber.
[1:08:28]
And we will have this discussion by ourselves.
[1:08:31]
All right.
[1:08:31]
So please Mr. Stevens.
[1:08:36]
Thank you.
[1:08:36]
Good evening, Mayor and council.
[1:08:37]
My name is Robert Stevens.
[1:08:39]
I am a resident of Hayward, and I am a planning commissioner.
[1:08:42]
This issue is not about the environmental impact
[1:08:44]
to data centers.
[1:08:45]
Data centers have operated successfully in Hayward since
[1:08:48]
the 1980s.
[1:08:49]
The most recent one stacks went through a sick review
[1:08:52]
at the Energy Commission and found
[1:08:53]
no substantial adverse impact.
[1:08:56]
And this is also not about the electric grid.
[1:08:58]
Has anybody read the August New York Times magazine
[1:09:01]
that talks about how close we are to the precipice of collapse
[1:09:04]
of our grid?
[1:09:05]
The data centers pay to rebuild our grid
[1:09:09]
I believe this is about the existential threat that
[1:09:11]
is said to pose to us.
[1:09:12]
A data center is the only tangible target anyone
[1:09:16]
can target.
[1:09:18]
After all, you cannot picket an algorithm But a data center is
[1:09:23]
the basic plumbing of the internet.
[1:09:25]
Without it, we have no email We have no streaming.
[1:09:28]
What aims at Netflix goes out tonight?
[1:09:31]
Finally, a data center generates revenue.
[1:09:34]
A band generates nothing, stacks alone
[1:09:36]
is going to produce almost $9 Million.
[1:09:38]
I really urge you to think diligently about this task
[1:09:42]
Thank you Our next line of speakers
[1:09:46]
is habib ba Sara, Manaf E.J. Siri.
[1:09:56]
Andrew is Kluger and AJ lopez So if you guys can just all
[1:10:04]
line up here and queue up.
[1:10:06]
Thank you.
[1:10:08]
Go ahead.
[1:10:09]
Good evening My name is Habiba, and I'm here with Kara,
[1:10:12]
the Council on American-Islamic relations.
[1:10:15]
I want to tell you who these data centers are directly
[1:10:18]
impacting when these data centers are built.
[1:10:21]
They're being built around black and brown communities
[1:10:23]
leading to a disproportionate impact on already
[1:10:27]
marginalized populations.
[1:10:29]
These developments require intense use
[1:10:32]
of resources and energy which is a direct cause
[1:10:35]
of the increase in the utility bills of our communities.
[1:10:38]
The cooling systems needed for these centers result
[1:10:41]
in an expulsion of heat.
[1:10:43]
Dramatic worsening the heat exposure in these communities.
[1:10:47]
The intense use of water in the development
[1:10:49]
also leads to these communities having a lack of access
[1:10:52]
to clean water And not only that,
[1:10:55]
these data centers are then used to conduct genocide and unleash
[1:10:58]
mass surveillance on our Palestinian brothers
[1:11:01]
and sisters.
[1:11:03]
Care directly works to support Muslim black and brown
[1:11:06]
communities And much of the work we
[1:11:08]
do is in regards to understanding our rights,
[1:11:10]
our community have a right to be first, have a right
[1:11:13]
to access to clean water, have a right
[1:11:15]
to not pay the costs of these data centers
[1:11:18]
that not only benefit them, but also the that not only do not
[1:11:21]
benefit them, but also target our communities So I urge you,
[1:11:25]
council members to put our communities first and ban
[1:11:28]
the development of these data centers.
[1:11:30]
Thank you Yeah And if i can remind if I can remind folks,
[1:11:39]
just, you know, if you can tell us your name
[1:11:41]
and where you're from, and then that would be great Let's see.
[1:11:45]
Sarah and I and I apologize.
[1:11:48]
Amina.
[1:11:48]
Amina thank you so much.
[1:11:50]
I am live six miles away right on the border
[1:11:53]
of Hayward and Union City.
[1:11:55]
Thank you for having me here.
[1:11:57]
I want to say that I work with Safe Tech International
[1:12:00]
and i've had first experience with Power Line harmonic
[1:12:02]
distortions and the same kind that are caused by data centers
[1:12:06]
and three people on our street got diabetes
[1:12:09]
And we had such horrific things.
[1:12:11]
Our appliances were blowing out We had scorch marks
[1:12:16]
where our federal Pacific incense co electric panels could
[1:12:19]
not hold the surge.
[1:12:21]
These the Bloomberg report just came out
[1:12:23]
saying that data centers within 20 miles of eight.
[1:12:26]
I hyperscale data centers are different than data
[1:12:29]
centers by the way, that low load is very different.
[1:12:32]
I need to clarify that it's going
[1:12:34]
to be such bad harmonic distortions Your appliances are
[1:12:37]
not going to need to burn out and you're
[1:12:41]
going to pay much more and rate.
[1:12:43]
But it's not clean.
[1:12:44]
It's not healthy.
[1:12:45]
There's cancer there's infertility.
[1:12:47]
I'm telling you, I can I don't know people theory
[1:12:50]
that this is not about being opposed to.
[1:12:53]
I this is about people who live directly.
[1:12:56]
So I'm asking you, please wait, wait.
[1:12:58]
This is my ask.
[1:12:59]
Sorry.
[1:13:00]
Trying to say this really, really fast.
[1:13:01]
And it's on my phone The ask is very important to flat out deny
[1:13:06]
extra power lines and i know that they're
[1:13:09]
using this additional.
[1:13:10]
But do you have to look, I work with these people.
[1:13:12]
I mean, I work in seminar and you
[1:13:14]
need to be upfront with knowing how much money will be building
[1:13:17]
exact figures, estimations, no estimations Miss Amina,
[1:13:20]
thank you.
[1:13:21]
You Thank you.
[1:13:22]
You so much.
[1:13:22]
Thank you Good evening.
[1:13:30]
My name is Isiah and I represent about 1500 Hayward resident
[1:13:32]
MDs who call Hayward home.
[1:13:34]
But make their livings and support their families
[1:13:36]
as union construction workers I don't
[1:13:39]
think that it's going to come to a point
[1:13:40]
where the city should be looking at some kind
[1:13:43]
of responsible action towards the community's concerns
[1:13:45]
by waiting on a moratorium or anything.
[1:13:47]
I think we have the power to do that now.
[1:13:49]
Unfortunately, if 45 passes this November
[1:13:52]
you're not going to have any ability
[1:13:54]
to do anything because the state's going to tell you.
[1:13:56]
It has to get built If we're looking
[1:13:58]
at the issues and the concerns of the community,
[1:14:00]
then let's put the issues on the table.
[1:14:02]
Water consumption closed loop, air cooled systems,
[1:14:05]
energy demand, ratepayer protections, infrastructure,
[1:14:07]
environmental impacts and requirements
[1:14:09]
for a skilled and trained workforce.
[1:14:10]
So we don't have YouTube.com contractors building this stuff.
[1:14:13]
San Jose has already developing a policy.
[1:14:15]
California Labor federation even put out
[1:14:17]
a statewide policy and recommendations
[1:14:19]
to do this kind of stuff.
[1:14:20]
A pause by itself does not solve anything.
[1:14:23]
If there is going to be one, use that time
[1:14:25]
to create clear rules for responsible development that
[1:14:28]
actually addresses the community's concerns regarding
[1:14:31]
ratepayer protections water, and things like that.
[1:14:33]
Thank you.
[1:14:34]
Thank you Good evening.
[1:14:41]
My name's Andreas Clover with the Alameda County Building
[1:14:44]
Construction Trades Council.
[1:14:47]
RFA elliott's actually represent the workers
[1:14:50]
that build the data centers In fact, thousands live in Hayward
[1:14:54]
and make their livelihood out of projects like this.
[1:14:57]
However, today we're here in solidarity
[1:15:00]
with many people in the room to make
[1:15:03]
sure you're establishing a responsible data center policy.
[1:15:06]
Local communities and jurisdictions
[1:15:08]
should have control over what gets built
[1:15:11]
and how it gets built. We need to make sure
[1:15:14]
that issues as addressed before issues, environmental issues
[1:15:18]
issues of water, issues of energy,
[1:15:20]
issues of community benefits and of course, issues of labor
[1:15:24]
standards to ensure that those folks that are building
[1:15:27]
these centers are from the community
[1:15:30]
and are having sustainable jobs and wages.
[1:15:32]
So we're actually in full support
[1:15:34]
of taking the time to develop a responsible data center
[1:15:38]
policy We would like to be a big part of that.
[1:15:41]
And work with you and work with many folks in the room
[1:15:43]
here to ensure that And only then once that decision
[1:15:46]
has been made, how to move forward
[1:15:48]
What do we support, then?
[1:15:49]
Thank you very much.
[1:15:50]
Thank you Mr. Lopez.
[1:15:55]
Before you start.
[1:15:56]
Let me queue up the next folks.
[1:15:59]
Can I have Jessie Gunn?
[1:16:01]
Lilith ?
[1:16:02]
Is it Seb ?
[1:16:05]
And then it jabe p Sanchez.
[1:16:11]
And then Mila OK.
[1:16:16]
Mr. Lopez Go ahead.
[1:16:20]
Thank you, Counsel I just want to say
[1:16:22]
my name is a.J. Lopez Hayward.
[1:16:24]
Resident for a long time.
[1:16:26]
Mr. Smith And she actually taught me
[1:16:27]
at Shabo Mexican-American history.
[1:16:31]
I just want to say more than anything, as a concerned father
[1:16:36]
and member of this city that i just want to see Hayward thrive.
[1:16:41]
I want to see us thrive as a community.
[1:16:44]
You all know the facts.
[1:16:45]
You've heard the facts from everybody here.
[1:16:47]
I could spout those off, but I want a future for my daughter.
[1:16:50]
I want a future for the kids of Hayward.
[1:16:52]
And that doesn't involve data centers, pollution
[1:16:54]
and environmental concerns for their health near schools.
[1:16:59]
We have other ways to get money for these schools.
[1:17:01]
There's grants We could get federal grants, things
[1:17:03]
like that.
[1:17:04]
But as a parent, I'm concerned for my child's future.
[1:17:07]
And I want her to grow up in Hayward just like I did.
[1:17:11]
And thank you all Thank you Hello.
[1:17:21]
My name is Jesse Gunn and i am the treasurer and an executive
[1:17:25]
board member for the Hayward Education Association here,
[1:17:27]
speaking on their behalf yesterday Our faculty
[1:17:31]
representative Assembly representing roughly 1,100
[1:17:33]
teachers, psychologists, counselors and nurses
[1:17:36]
in the Hayward Unified School District voted unanimously
[1:17:40]
to oppose data centers here in hayward and to call
[1:17:42]
for their ban Not a pause not a moratorium, but their ban.
[1:17:47]
This these data centers do not positively impact our community.
[1:17:51]
In fact, they directly and negatively affect
[1:17:53]
our students, our families, the people who call Hayward home,
[1:17:56]
such as myself.
[1:17:57]
Thank you so much, Counsel Thank you Hi.
[1:18:06]
My name is Lilith and I'm a student at USD
[1:18:09]
and I would like to talk about the data center
[1:18:12]
environmental impact.
[1:18:13]
It is going to impact the earth.
[1:18:14]
It is just going to use and pollute our water.
[1:18:18]
And it is going to hurt younger generations.
[1:18:20]
The children's are the children are
[1:18:22]
the one that will have to live with the impact that we leave.
[1:18:25]
So my only ask is to ban all data centers,
[1:18:28]
especially hyper scale data centers in Hayward,
[1:18:31]
and set the example.
[1:18:33]
Thank you Lady Ladies and gentlemen,
[1:18:41]
listen I appreciate the applause.
[1:18:44]
And I and the congratulatory remarks,
[1:18:47]
but can we please just let's calm it down tone it down a bit.
[1:18:52]
So that we can proceed I did want
[1:18:54]
to say I did want to highlight and call out Lilith.
[1:19:00]
Lilith, thank you for being here.
[1:19:02]
And I think this is the Fourth time, maybe
[1:19:07]
that we've seen each other in.
[1:19:09]
And I do remember you and and I do listen to you
[1:19:14]
and let me just tell you, and I know
[1:19:16]
your mom sitting next to you you have been very clear
[1:19:21]
eyed about this and you have been very articulate
[1:19:23]
about this issue.
[1:19:24]
So I just wanted to say thank you and just
[1:19:27]
recognize you for that.
[1:19:28]
So thank you for your work on this
[1:19:34]
Our next speaker is JP Sanchez.
[1:19:36]
Yes sir.
[1:19:38]
Hi, Council.
[1:19:38]
My name is JP Sanchez.
[1:19:40]
I live close to my south hayward, an educator
[1:19:41]
by industrial I stand in solidarity amongst the community
[1:19:44]
that we say no to constructing more data centers The increasing
[1:19:47]
trend of the advancement technology development
[1:19:49]
is a shame because it will never benefit the general public
[1:19:52]
How do we know that?
[1:19:52]
Look, we got one, but two.
[1:19:54]
I'm as all data centers, all of our taxpayer money
[1:19:57]
will go directly into the hands of the rich, elite, corporate
[1:19:59]
conglomerate and imperialist masters like US imperialism.
[1:20:02]
This pattern is similar to what's happening in the Global
[1:20:04]
South, such as my homeland, the Philippines The project that's
[1:20:07]
being proposed by the US Israeli Alliance Initiative, Silica.
[1:20:10]
This type of predatory development
[1:20:12]
will displace thousands of indigenous people
[1:20:14]
and create and sustainable jobs and destroy the environment.
[1:20:16]
This will happen similarly here if we
[1:20:18]
don't put a stop to these data center developments
[1:20:20]
here in our city.
[1:20:21]
So I ask you, Council, to halt these operations,
[1:20:23]
ban future tech initiatives like data centers
[1:20:25]
and listen to your constituents Thank you.
[1:20:28]
Thank you And milla, before you before you speak,
[1:20:36]
let me call on the next folks Holly, is it Edmonds and Katie?
[1:20:44]
Is it clear?
[1:20:47]
Katie clear Gregory Is it fit or fight?
[1:20:55]
Yes Shawn is it I can't pronounce the last Is it's K e v
[1:21:08]
shawn Short.
[1:21:10]
Yeah.
[1:21:10]
Is there another Shawn in the room Okay.
[1:21:13]
And then Sunny Alvarado Me go right in Hi, my name is Mila.
[1:21:23]
I was born at Saint Rose hospital
[1:21:24]
in Hayward, not in Los Gatos And I'm here
[1:21:28]
because I just want to make it very clear
[1:21:30]
that calling a data center stack is
[1:21:32]
disrespectful to our community and everything
[1:21:34]
that Hayward community stands for.
[1:21:36]
If you you don't have to listen to the applause
[1:21:39]
to know what the people of Hayward want,
[1:21:41]
and that is data centers out of Hayward.
[1:21:44]
And on that note, I do want to point out
[1:21:45]
the connection between these data centers
[1:21:48]
and facial recognition technology and surveillance
[1:21:50]
technology that is used in Israel that
[1:21:52]
is used in the Philippines, that is used
[1:21:54]
all around the world for imperialist nations
[1:21:56]
like America, to surveil citizens.
[1:21:58]
And if we allow it here we are failing our community Just
[1:22:03]
know that you work for the people of Hayward
[1:22:05]
and as our representatives we implore you
[1:22:08]
to make the correct decision.
[1:22:10]
It shouldn't take this meeting to understand and do
[1:22:12]
what is right I don't care how much money they offer.
[1:22:21]
That's it Very good.
[1:22:34]
Also, I think there was a holly.
[1:22:35]
I don't know where that person is, but I'm cutting in line.
[1:22:38]
Do you want to come up, then?
[1:22:40]
Yeah.
[1:22:40]
You're next.
[1:22:41]
Yeah, I'll go after you.
[1:22:44]
Thank you Okay.
[1:22:48]
Good evening My name is Holly Edmondson.
[1:22:51]
I am here as a resident of Hayward,
[1:22:54]
a mother of a three year old, and as a person who cares?
[1:22:57]
A person who cares about her people and our environment
[1:23:01]
And I hope you're listening.
[1:23:03]
I'm deeply concerned about the effects of data centers.
[1:23:06]
I heard from opposing sides tonight
[1:23:08]
that there are no adverse effects.
[1:23:10]
How is that even possible when they're using tons of water per
[1:23:13]
day ?
[1:23:14]
And you've heard from all the facts tonight
[1:23:17]
that were presented.
[1:23:18]
I mean, that's just to name one is about the water Sorry,
[1:23:24]
I got locked out.
[1:23:27]
I also did not hear from anybody of the opposing side
[1:23:30]
that they were Hayward residents.
[1:23:32]
Not one, not One person was a Hayward resident
[1:23:34]
from the opposing side.
[1:23:38]
I strongly urge you to stop data centers until we fully
[1:23:41]
understand the impacts.
[1:23:42]
I've heard they have been heavily researched, studied
[1:23:45]
and scrutinized here.
[1:23:46]
And these positions of power That's an honor.
[1:23:50]
Listen to these people.
[1:23:52]
Nobody in Hayward wants this I'm worried
[1:23:57]
for my three year old son Our children deserve better
[1:24:02]
Think about our future and think about our kids.
[1:24:04]
Thank you Thank you You're Katie Yes.
[1:24:14]
Katie Collier.
[1:24:15]
Hi.
[1:24:16]
Council members I'm a Hayward resident and I
[1:24:20]
was born and raised in Hayward.
[1:24:21]
My family's been here for over 100 years,
[1:24:23]
and I am obviously against data centers And I went to the town
[1:24:29]
hall meeting where it was established that the city claims
[1:24:32]
they cannot stop the current data center that's being built
[1:24:35]
at 310,000 square foot one.
[1:24:38]
And that they also didn't know who the owner of that data
[1:24:41]
center was.
[1:24:42]
So there's a lot of information that, frankly, we don't even
[1:24:46]
know yet.
[1:24:47]
But hearing what everybody has said
[1:24:49]
about the environmental impacts that particular data center
[1:24:52]
is about a mile from my father's home.
[1:24:54]
I came here today with my dad.
[1:24:56]
He's in this room today because it really
[1:24:58]
matters what happens to us here in Hayward.
[1:25:01]
We actually really care as you can see, all the folks who
[1:25:03]
are here at the very least, I want
[1:25:05]
to point out that that data center,
[1:25:07]
I think they found a loophole here in our city
[1:25:10]
and they took advantage of us.
[1:25:11]
They took advantage of all the people here.
[1:25:13]
And we need at the very least, a moratorium and absolutely a ban.
[1:25:17]
So thank you for listening to me Thank
[1:25:19]
you Hi my name is Gregory Fete.
[1:25:29]
I live up in Upper D Street, kind of at the edge of town.
[1:25:32]
And Yeah, I love Hayward and and I love the Internet
[1:25:36]
and I love all these things.
[1:25:37]
And I've seen a lot of techno logic change in a lot of it.
[1:25:42]
You just kind of get used to one step at a time
[1:25:45]
And then one day we woke up, and we
[1:25:48]
saw data center these colossal energy monsters, these water
[1:25:52]
hogs these tech overlords that we have, many of whom
[1:25:59]
live right across the bay from us
[1:26:01]
And all of a sudden it kind of all comes together.
[1:26:04]
Our data is being scraped and collected illegally.
[1:26:08]
People are being targeted.
[1:26:09]
People are living in a police state
[1:26:12]
And this has to be considered as well
[1:26:16]
as the environmental effects of the data center.
[1:26:18]
We have to consider the social effects.
[1:26:21]
The idea of using artificial intelligence
[1:26:24]
to replace human judgment and we also
[1:26:29]
have to protect our children and keep pollutants out
[1:26:33]
of the atmosphere, especially early,
[1:26:36]
when our federal government just said,
[1:26:38]
oh, you want to emit carbon into the atmosphere
[1:26:42]
no problem Hayward Mister Fine, we do different and better.
[1:26:46]
Thank you.
[1:26:47]
Thank you Hi, my name is Shaun Skeen and I'd like to make one
[1:26:58]
distinction here that I've heard over and over repeated,
[1:27:01]
but between the list of data centers that we have here
[1:27:06]
in Hayward, we have three that are legacy data centers and one
[1:27:11]
that is a hyperscale The difference being that
[1:27:17]
the hyperscale will take and consume much more resources
[1:27:21]
electricity and water, but also that it operates 100% for A.I..
[1:27:30]
And my point being is that I don't
[1:27:33]
think you can have a responsible conversation about data
[1:27:38]
The Stack data center without including the issues that
[1:27:44]
surround AI And did anybody watch the news this last week?
[1:27:50]
I think we had a whole gamut of people
[1:27:55]
that lead the industry standing up and saying,
[1:27:58]
we've got problems here.
[1:28:00]
We've got to slow down So I think
[1:28:03]
I am all for in support of banning
[1:28:06]
or at a minimum, a more a moratorium where we can
[1:28:10]
go back and review I got it.
[1:28:12]
An extension.
[1:28:13]
Thank you Appreciate it And mr. Alvarado, before you speak,
[1:28:21]
let me queue up the next group of folks.
[1:28:24]
Tom is at Wetzel marguerita.
[1:28:29]
Alanis.
[1:28:30]
Damian pray right Janine and then
[1:28:41]
who Ortega And then Robert Seats Okay go ahead.
[1:28:50]
All right.
[1:28:51]
My name is Sunny Alvarado.
[1:28:52]
I'm a Hayward resident I'm a ninth grade biology
[1:28:55]
teacher with the honor to teach in this city that I grew up in.
[1:28:59]
And right now my students, they're
[1:29:01]
learning about Enveil of species,
[1:29:03]
which our plants are animals that are introduced to an eco
[1:29:06]
system.
[1:29:07]
And they put a strain on the resources or nutrients.
[1:29:10]
And prevent the indigenous animals and plants
[1:29:13]
from growing Air data, data centers
[1:29:16]
are equivalent to invasive species.
[1:29:19]
And we use our water electricity,
[1:29:21]
which should be used by the people who live here.
[1:29:24]
And these companies are not building air centers
[1:29:26]
in their hometowns So why are they building it in ours?
[1:29:30]
Can you guys be the champions and lead us to protect our water
[1:29:35]
and electricity?
[1:29:36]
And I know you guys have made the correct decision before.
[1:29:40]
Especially as their maino.
[1:29:42]
He helped us out with the Hayward Rental Stabilization
[1:29:45]
ordinance.
[1:29:45]
Right.
[1:29:46]
So I know you guys can make the correct decisions.
[1:29:49]
Let's make the correct one on this one.
[1:29:51]
Thank you Hello My name is Tom Wetzel
[1:30:02]
and I live a few blocks from here in Hayward.
[1:30:05]
And I worked for 20 years in servant development
[1:30:07]
in Silicon Valley.
[1:30:08]
And based on that experience I don't really
[1:30:11]
understand why this huge, vast expansion of data centers, which
[1:30:17]
have all these servers and disks in them, what do they need?
[1:30:20]
All this data storage for?
[1:30:22]
Or is it for like floc surveillance camera footage
[1:30:25]
to track everybody ?
[1:30:27]
Is it for all the AI systems that
[1:30:28]
are taking away people's jobs?
[1:30:30]
I think given the environmental impact we need to have real,
[1:30:34]
you know, answers believable answers to those questions
[1:30:37]
in the previous speaker who talked about the A.I. basis
[1:30:41]
of this, expand and raised a very relevant question
[1:30:44]
And I think until we have an adequate and believable and
[1:30:47]
acceptable answer, there should be a ban Thank you Tom.
[1:31:00]
Right.
[1:31:01]
Know that your Tom How about is who is Tom?
[1:31:06]
You're Tom.
[1:31:07]
OK Marguerita Yeah.
[1:31:09]
Let's go to Marguerita Hello.
[1:31:14]
My name is Margarita.
[1:31:16]
I'm coming from Union City.
[1:31:18]
And i want to say we the people over profit
[1:31:22]
who are these data centers are actually
[1:31:23]
helping Not the hard working people living in the area.
[1:31:27]
As many of us know, having data centers
[1:31:30]
will increase all types of pollution Things
[1:31:33]
like water pollution, air pollution and land pollution.
[1:31:36]
These data centers will also increase electro magnetic field
[1:31:40]
exposure to people, which can and will cause serious health
[1:31:43]
issues and problems.
[1:31:45]
Data centers take up large amounts
[1:31:47]
of water and electricity.
[1:31:50]
This can lead to less water being available for us
[1:31:52]
to drink and higher utility bills.
[1:31:55]
Bills.
[1:31:56]
We cannot drink data, but we can drink water Higher utility bills
[1:32:01]
will cause even higher worries.
[1:32:03]
An item of food usually cost up to an hour
[1:32:05]
of labor We have to worry about the food we put on our table.
[1:32:10]
And it doesn't make sense for us to worry about how utility
[1:32:14]
bills, because of computers.
[1:32:17]
The people should decide this, not billionaires Thank you.
[1:32:21]
Please say yes.
[1:32:22]
Password four.
[1:32:23]
Put a ban on future data centers.
[1:32:25]
Comply with environmental Thank you.
[1:32:27]
Regulations.
[1:32:28]
Thank you.
[1:32:28]
Thank you Party.
[1:32:35]
Yeah OK.
[1:32:36]
And are off.
[1:32:37]
I said that correct.
[1:32:39]
Notice My name is Mary Jane and i
[1:32:41]
live near Burbank Elementary School.
[1:32:44]
I worked at a top five company on Frontier Air Models.
[1:32:47]
I was part of that team myself I quit five days ago, partially
[1:32:52]
due to data center build out Many tech workers like myself
[1:32:56]
don't even want data center buildout this fast.
[1:32:59]
We want to slow growth as well in fact, some of the top IQ
[1:33:03]
was want to slow this growth as well.
[1:33:06]
Dario Mody the CEO of Anthropic just this week
[1:33:09]
said an agent swarm could take over the internet
[1:33:13]
within 6 to 12 months of all takeover
[1:33:16]
I'm having serious conversations just this morning
[1:33:19]
with my friends about pulling money
[1:33:20]
out of online financial systems to keep my money safe
[1:33:27]
The Federal government has no desire to regulate this,
[1:33:30]
so it falls to city council such as yourself.
[1:33:32]
This is no longer a sorry science fiction
[1:33:36]
My ask is to slow down at least data centers where
[1:33:38]
the primary purpose is to train evali rate or run inference.
[1:33:44]
I know that i'll leave it there.
[1:33:46]
Actually.
[1:33:47]
Thank you.
[1:33:47]
Appreciate it I'm Robert Sites.
[1:33:57]
I've lived here for about 40 years.
[1:33:59]
I've almost 80 years old during that whole time that I've
[1:34:03]
lived in California I have had to be
[1:34:05]
very careful with two things.
[1:34:08]
My water and my energy expenditure future.
[1:34:12]
I'm on a special plan where I don't use any juice
[1:34:16]
at all between four and 9 p.m.
[1:34:19]
and I take showers that are about a minute
[1:34:25]
and yet here we are.
[1:34:26]
We're going to try and we're coming up
[1:34:29]
with the technology that requires
[1:34:30]
enormous amounts of both.
[1:34:32]
And it makes no sense It's upside down.
[1:34:36]
It's as if we have all this extra energy and all
[1:34:39]
this extra water.
[1:34:39]
Gosh, what are we going to do with it?
[1:34:41]
And that's not what's really going on.
[1:34:43]
How could people be supplying?
[1:34:45]
And that's all.
[1:34:46]
Thanks.
[1:34:46]
Thank you.
[1:34:47]
You We're we're city council.
[1:34:55]
This is Angel.
[1:34:57]
Yeah I live in Union City, but I have
[1:34:59]
been working in Hayward for the past four years.
[1:35:02]
I'm a member of the organization.
[1:35:04]
And I've been Hayward, a Filipino youth organization
[1:35:06]
which connects the impacts of U.S. policy to our homeland.
[1:35:09]
The Philippines.
[1:35:10]
We vehemently condemn the building of the Stark data
[1:35:13]
center as Filipino youth, we already know the impacts
[1:35:15]
that building data centers in Hayward
[1:35:17]
will have because these are already happening
[1:35:19]
in our homeland as we speak.
[1:35:21]
The US backed POC, silica Initiative
[1:35:23]
seeks to build more data centers and semiconductor manufactories
[1:35:26]
in the Philippines.
[1:35:27]
And it's already this place the land and water from Indigenous
[1:35:30]
peoples and impoverished farmers in the Philippines
[1:35:32]
So I hope it is not lost on us that what happens in my homeland
[1:35:36]
is reflective of what will happen to the working class
[1:35:38]
and migrant communities here in the US
[1:35:41]
But if I will be frank with you City Council, the data
[1:35:43]
centers are only scratching the surface
[1:35:45]
and banning them is the bare minimum
[1:35:47]
We recently conducted a tech tour around Hayward where
[1:35:49]
we visited the intersection on West Eighth Street and Hathaway,
[1:35:53]
where a Filipino migrant was violently detained by Ice right
[1:35:56]
here in Hayward.
[1:35:57]
Despite being a sanctuary city.
[1:35:59]
And what was present are flock cameras infamously powered
[1:36:02]
by AI.
[1:36:03]
We also know that the Sky Audio Drone Manufactory, which
[1:36:06]
is only a few blocks behind Chicago College on Industrial
[1:36:08]
Boulevard, these air powered drones
[1:36:10]
are being made right in our backyard.
[1:36:12]
And then sent to our homeland in the Philippines
[1:36:14]
The people of Hayward, especially the youth
[1:36:16]
and students, are calling on you.
[1:36:17]
City Council and the data centers and correct
[1:36:19]
the injustice From Hayward to the Philippines,
[1:36:22]
noted data centers and surveillance in our communities
[1:36:24]
Thank you And then can I get here
[1:36:34]
in the middle aisle here Can I get is it Yuri Mendoza and then
[1:36:41]
Sarah, just First name Sarah tomorrow Mimi Nguyen
[1:36:51]
and then Malcolm Is it Start us say, Yeah, I apologize And then
[1:36:59]
Crystal or crystal water, I believe.
[1:37:03]
And then hannam handed me to Tino.
[1:37:07]
To Tino.
[1:37:08]
OK.
[1:37:09]
And then yuri That's not me.
[1:37:16]
Oh, no Mendoza is there.
[1:37:19]
Mendoza?
[1:37:19]
No.
[1:37:20]
OK So, Sarah no tahoe, bro My name is Tahoe Row.
[1:37:35]
I'm a resident of Hayward sky Audio Drones
[1:37:39]
for cameras and data centers.
[1:37:41]
They're all something we have here in Hayward They're
[1:37:44]
used to kill people, suppress popular movements kidnap
[1:37:47]
community members and raise the unemployment rate.
[1:37:50]
That's what they are built for They
[1:37:52]
are all tools of fascism and imperialism and world
[1:37:56]
domination.
[1:37:56]
And is that what Hayward is supposed to be about?
[1:38:00]
Are we supposed to be the industry of fashion ism
[1:38:02]
and empire?
[1:38:04]
I don't think that's the vibes of Hayward
[1:38:06]
and what most residents here want
[1:38:09]
And speaking about, you know, bands and moratoriums
[1:38:13]
and talking about responsible air development so often
[1:38:16]
we talk about slowing down or building it out
[1:38:18]
responsibly as if air is inevitable
[1:38:21]
and we just have to get used to it But making peace with air
[1:38:25]
is giving up.
[1:38:26]
Do not make peace with air.
[1:38:29]
Destroy it and kill it Thank you.
[1:38:31]
Thank you Mimi Yeah.
[1:38:40]
Hello.
[1:38:40]
My name is Mimi Nguyen.
[1:38:42]
I'm a Hayward resident and I support a permanent ban
[1:38:45]
on AI data structures.
[1:38:46]
We can join the other districts in setting an example
[1:38:50]
and doing the right thing.
[1:38:51]
I saw the long list of cons on the slide regarding
[1:38:54]
permanent bans on data centers, but everything on that list
[1:38:58]
will be worth it to accomplish, including retroactive banning
[1:39:02]
existing data centers It will all be worth it because it will
[1:39:05]
be an investment in humans.
[1:39:07]
One of the points is loss of revenue
[1:39:09]
But if the money is coming from AI it is unethical money
[1:39:12]
and we don't want it because A.I. is inherently it
[1:39:16]
is an inherently unethical machine So we don't want it.
[1:39:21]
We don't need it.
[1:39:22]
Everyone sitting here before me are meant to represent hayward.
[1:39:25]
So please hear us when we say we want a permanent ban on aI data
[1:39:29]
centers.
[1:39:29]
Thank you.
[1:39:30]
Thank you Your hello My name is Malcolm.
[1:39:39]
I was born and raised in Hayward.
[1:39:40]
I support the ban on future data centers
[1:39:43]
It happens too often that marginalized communities bear
[1:39:45]
the brunt of environmental harm caused by corporations.
[1:39:48]
I have some quotes from a Democracy Now
[1:39:50]
article regarding Zanies Data Center in Memphis, Tennessee.
[1:39:54]
Quote We are unfortunately a cautionary tale
[1:39:56]
about what will and possibly can happen
[1:39:59]
if you don't have the right rules and guardrails in place,
[1:40:01]
says Keshawn pearson.
[1:40:03]
This is an unfair precedented, the amount of pollution
[1:40:06]
that we're being exposed to nitrogen dioxide, formaldehyde,
[1:40:09]
chemicals that we know cause cancer and quote Keyshawn
[1:40:13]
Pearson, executive director of Memphis
[1:40:15]
Community Against pollution.
[1:40:16]
We could learn from Memphis's mistakes
[1:40:18]
and prevent the acceleration of environmental damage
[1:40:21]
and set a good example for the rest of the bay.
[1:40:24]
That Hayward won't let corporations walk over us
[1:40:26]
for their shirts or short term financial gains
[1:40:29]
for an industry that could put people out
[1:40:31]
of work with their air agents and possibly poison our air
[1:40:34]
and emit low frequency sound waves Don't
[1:40:37]
let Hayward residents foot the bill People People over profit
[1:40:40]
forever.
[1:40:41]
Thank you.
[1:40:42]
Thank you Yeah.
[1:40:46]
Crystal for McChrystal, I'm a resident of Hayward.
[1:40:50]
I feel like you guys have been listening to us a lot.
[1:40:53]
All night.
[1:40:53]
So I'm gonna give you something else
[1:40:55]
to listen to That's just a brief little video of a 38 megawatt
[1:41:03]
air high Frisco data Center in other parts of the country.
[1:41:07]
We have other people in all over the nation.
[1:41:10]
That's been giving us insight of what's happening.
[1:41:13]
They're giving us warnings And we, the people of Hayward,
[1:41:16]
are listening and we're saying, no I and my children
[1:41:19]
live two miles away from that Eaton landing hyperscale data
[1:41:22]
Center That's what we're going to hear on a daily basis.
[1:41:25]
OK.
[1:41:26]
We, the people of Hayward, I'm sorry if that's
[1:41:28]
going to offend you.
[1:41:29]
We're not asking you.
[1:41:30]
We're telling you we don't want this banner
[1:41:40]
And before you before you speak give me one moment.
[1:41:44]
We have to stand here in the middle.
[1:41:47]
Claire valderrama, Wallace Claire and then Alan
[1:41:55]
Is it booster?
[1:41:58]
Booster ?
[1:41:59]
Is that what it is?
[1:42:00]
And then marcos or Marcos And then Nicolas
[1:42:10]
noonan earning asked Pacheco and then Abby Gal Olivia, Go ahead.
[1:42:21]
Good evening, Councilmember is.
[1:42:22]
My name is Hannah Saturno.
[1:42:24]
I am a proud Hayward native.
[1:42:25]
Currently residing in Oakland, California.
[1:42:27]
Like many here before you, I urge all elected officials
[1:42:30]
to reconsider its approval for the stock infrastructure that
[1:42:33]
is currently under construction in the eden Shore area.
[1:42:36]
To remind or educate everyone in this room, stocks data center
[1:42:39]
was only approved because it jumped through loopholes
[1:42:41]
proving that the company only cares
[1:42:43]
about profits rather than the people living in this community.
[1:42:47]
Despite the shiny public benefits package
[1:42:49]
that it flashed in front of the Planning Commission,
[1:42:51]
commissioners, including a possible bike path instruction,
[1:42:55]
solar water.
[1:42:56]
Solar.
[1:42:56]
Oh, sorry.
[1:42:57]
Solar panels at the city's water resource recovery facility
[1:43:00]
and temporary jobs for unionized laborers during construction.
[1:43:03]
However, it is common knowledge just how
[1:43:05]
destructive and detrimental a single data center
[1:43:07]
is for a community member, for a community As council member
[1:43:11]
Syrup said, the data center will use as much electricity
[1:43:14]
as one fifth of all the homes in Hayward.
[1:43:17]
The sudden spike in energy demand and usage
[1:43:19]
will exponentially have negative impacts
[1:43:21]
on the current future, Current and future residents
[1:43:23]
of the community.
[1:43:26]
Further the data center will require hundreds of thousands
[1:43:29]
to millions of gallons of fresh water
[1:43:30]
to cool down, which will take away
[1:43:32]
from families who need it running water
[1:43:34]
and drinking water will become a scarcity.
[1:43:36]
The data center will also be near to schools
[1:43:38]
and elementary school and a middle school run by Nami.
[1:43:42]
I know my time is up I just want to say one more thing.
[1:43:45]
The 28 diesel backup generators over at this data center
[1:43:50]
will release fine particulate matter, also known as PM 2.5,
[1:43:53]
which is strongly linked to respiratory disease, heart
[1:43:56]
disease and asthma.
[1:43:56]
Thank you.
[1:43:57]
Which will be directly impacting the students
[1:43:59]
that go to the schools.
[1:44:01]
Thank you.
[1:44:06]
And are you clear?
[1:44:08]
Yes, I'm okay.
[1:44:09]
I'm Claire, and I'm an associate professor
[1:44:11]
at the Department of Nursing at Cal State east Bay.
[1:44:13]
And I've been there for 14 years now.
[1:44:15]
There's no shortage of evidence that data centers wreak havoc
[1:44:18]
on the environment and worsen living conditions day to day.
[1:44:21]
And for future generations.
[1:44:23]
They provide infrastructure for the violations
[1:44:25]
of international humanitarian law
[1:44:28]
here in resident and alcoholics.
[1:44:30]
Went to the Philippines just earlier this year.
[1:44:32]
And he was massacred along with 18 others, including
[1:44:34]
youth and journalist.
[1:44:35]
A poet student leaders and teenagers.
[1:44:38]
Drones like the drones manufactured here in Hayward
[1:44:41]
were utilized to surveil them So we cannot separate drones
[1:44:44]
and cameras from governments and corporations that use them
[1:44:47]
to protect profit, such as the silica initiative selling
[1:44:50]
the Philippines to the U.S. data centers are the blueprint
[1:44:53]
of the war economy, relying on the exploitation of workers,
[1:44:56]
displacement of communities and militarization for so-called
[1:44:59]
advances.
[1:45:01]
There are no take backs no future apology.
[1:45:03]
Well, undo such harm.
[1:45:05]
Make no mistake, decisions you make here
[1:45:07]
will impact these very neighborhoods
[1:45:08]
you were elected to serve.
[1:45:09]
And areas around the world, as stated by others.
[1:45:12]
Ban data centers, invest in Hayward Youth and Hayward
[1:45:14]
families.
[1:45:16]
Thank you Alan.
[1:45:22]
Yes Yeah.
[1:45:23]
Yeah.
[1:45:23]
Hi, I'm Alan So regular data centers are pretty bad already.
[1:45:30]
The a.I. data centers in particular use
[1:45:32]
specialized equipment Like the most expensive part of it
[1:45:36]
is largely unusable for anything other than ML purposes, which
[1:45:40]
means things like generating missing formation
[1:45:43]
via fake images and video in identify lying or misidentifying
[1:45:47]
people and surveillance or targeting people for in warfare.
[1:45:51]
Again, mis targeting and many other things
[1:45:55]
decreasing people's critical thinking skills like these
[1:46:00]
aren't just standard data centers
[1:46:01]
that all just power the cloud.
[1:46:03]
They don't really have alternative uses.
[1:46:05]
And especially what these companies having financials
[1:46:09]
as their unit economics don't really make all that much sense.
[1:46:12]
Like they very well may become defunct.
[1:46:14]
At which point even if they're being
[1:46:16]
used for some of the less bad versions of stuff, which
[1:46:19]
are still bad, they're likely going to end up being used
[1:46:22]
for to support warfare and surveillance in the end state,
[1:46:25]
because that's the only thing that you know,
[1:46:27]
the government is the only one who could really
[1:46:29]
pay for these things.
[1:46:30]
Thank you.
[1:46:31]
Appreciate it Hi Marcos from Hayward.
[1:46:39]
The harm from data centers outweighs the positive
[1:46:41]
It's obvious to the common folk that data centers are currently
[1:46:44]
being pushed under the current administration and side
[1:46:46]
by side with AIG.
[1:46:47]
AIG or to contain ICE's data collection on citizens flux
[1:46:51]
and improve forcing of surveillance cameras.
[1:46:53]
A push towards humanoid robotics and data
[1:46:56]
centers being used in support for Israel's
[1:46:58]
military intelligence Without Harm Also
[1:47:01]
comes the environmental damage and environmental deregulation
[1:47:03]
Under this administration the risk
[1:47:05]
of stunting child education and a billionaire's goal
[1:47:09]
of cutting jobs for profits and harming the working class.
[1:47:12]
A perfect example would be my situation and how
[1:47:15]
it's harming the working class.
[1:47:16]
My colleagues in the industry.
[1:47:18]
I work for I'm a senior digital artists working
[1:47:21]
at a studio with high clientele, watching firsthand
[1:47:24]
the job reduction due to i three fourth of our production team
[1:47:27]
was laid off today.
[1:47:28]
I. I was fortunate enough to maneuver around this layoff,
[1:47:32]
but my colleagues were pleased though on the band for the data
[1:47:35]
center Thank you Good evening.
[1:47:43]
City Council Mayor and staff.
[1:47:44]
My name is Nicholas.
[1:47:45]
I am a member of Hayward's birdwatching and wildlife
[1:47:47]
community I want to first off, thank you all for providing us
[1:47:51]
all the space to come here and express our opinions today.
[1:47:55]
And I think we have a unique opportunity here today
[1:47:58]
to stand our ground against the building of or destruction
[1:48:03]
of the environment in the Bay Area.
[1:48:05]
I think environmental capital is not just athletics.
[1:48:08]
It is also a part of what create a clean air in our environment,
[1:48:12]
our beautiful place to live in.
[1:48:14]
For humans, it is very easy to destroy
[1:48:16]
and very expensive to rebuild later on.
[1:48:18]
So despite the profit data centers claim
[1:48:21]
to bring to Hayward in the long term,
[1:48:23]
there are a lot of costs that we should consider corporations.
[1:48:27]
At the end, they are interested in profit over people.
[1:48:29]
And I acknowledge that you all are facing a lot of pressure
[1:48:32]
from different companies and also administration
[1:48:36]
to fulfill their concerns.
[1:48:39]
But i want you to urge you to consider what the people here
[1:48:43]
have to say and what we think about what's going on.
[1:48:45]
Thank you Ernest.
[1:48:52]
But are you.
[1:48:54]
Are you Abigail?
[1:48:55]
Yes Yeah.
[1:48:56]
OK, I'll do Abigail, and then I'll get All right.
[1:48:58]
Is this my call or.
[1:48:59]
I want to make sure.
[1:49:01]
Do you have it in that order?
[1:49:02]
Okay, perfect.
[1:49:03]
OK.
[1:49:03]
Good evening.
[1:49:04]
My name is Abigail Oliver, and I am in environmental Health
[1:49:07]
and Safety specialist who works closely
[1:49:09]
with the CDC Bachmann, EPA and all other regulating
[1:49:13]
agencies in California.
[1:49:15]
I stand before you expressing my unwavering support
[1:49:17]
to ban large scale data centers from Hayward.
[1:49:20]
There is far too much uncertainty surrounding
[1:49:23]
the dangerous rush to construct data centers Policymakers,
[1:49:26]
Compliance officers and regulators
[1:49:28]
lack the frameworks to properly zone permit
[1:49:31]
regulate these facilities.
[1:49:33]
The systematic failure could not have been shown more clearly
[1:49:36]
through the loopholes that stocks
[1:49:37]
took to construct the Edens Landing Data Center
[1:49:40]
and set up putting standards into place.
[1:49:41]
First governing First governing bodies
[1:49:44]
are being pressured to write, review and approve regulations
[1:49:47]
after developer plans are already placed on the table.
[1:49:50]
The strain of these facilities place the local infrastructure
[1:49:56]
Yeah, the strain that these facilities
[1:49:57]
place on local infrastructure is absolutely
[1:49:59]
absurd Air data centers deplete crucial water
[1:50:02]
resources in the state that has it continuously that
[1:50:04]
has continuously suffered from drought conditions
[1:50:06]
for the past 25 years.
[1:50:08]
They also draw power away from residents who are already
[1:50:10]
paying way too much for the monopolize gas and electricity
[1:50:13]
company in the Bay Area Proponents often counter
[1:50:16]
misleading times.
[1:50:17]
OK, thank you.
[1:50:18]
So I think you do appreciate it So and then before you
[1:50:24]
before you speak, can i have the Talia that I your last name
[1:50:32]
is very long.
[1:50:33]
And then peter is it lauro Munoz and then Kenneth?
[1:50:43]
Is it C sica And then is it Kylie spears
[1:50:53]
And then Brent Huang?
[1:50:55]
Huang and oh, how I am.
[1:51:00]
I apologize.
[1:51:01]
Go ahead Mr. Pacheco.
[1:51:03]
Good evening, Ernest Pacheco.
[1:51:04]
30 plus year.
[1:51:05]
Hayward member.
[1:51:08]
I support the council passing referral,
[1:51:12]
but I want to talk about something that remind
[1:51:14]
the Council and the community.
[1:51:16]
We've been here before.
[1:51:17]
Back in 2007 to fossil fuel companies
[1:51:20]
tried to force to power plants into our community
[1:51:23]
at the time, the CC the council every elected initially
[1:51:27]
said you can't stop them.
[1:51:29]
The subject matter experts, the Sierra club,
[1:51:31]
NRDC are the groups.
[1:51:32]
Everyone said, we're not going to help you fight it.
[1:51:35]
It can't be stopped This was after the Manufacturer Energy
[1:51:39]
crisis of the millennium.
[1:51:40]
Hayworth came together, and we stopped the power plant.
[1:51:44]
What we did is we revitalize We set a state president precedent.
[1:51:47]
We revitalize the fight against natural gas power plants
[1:51:51]
in California We held the other power plant up for years.
[1:51:54]
And we forced a national precedent
[1:51:56]
of being the first power plant to have greenhouse gas emissions
[1:51:59]
built into the permit.
[1:52:00]
We got millions of dollars in mitigations which mitigation,
[1:52:03]
the seller of a failure.
[1:52:04]
That beautiful labor we have this one of the mitigations we
[1:52:07]
also in 2007 started organizing our c k, which
[1:52:12]
is now a the energy that came out
[1:52:14]
of that fight working together.
[1:52:16]
We can stop these that we can stop.
[1:52:18]
Is that these are the data centers
[1:52:20]
and we can actually set precedent that was all over
[1:52:23]
think thank you, sir, for the welcome to the council on that
[1:52:29]
Sorry And I hope you say your last name.
[1:52:33]
When you come back I got you.
[1:52:35]
I leave a little eye candy for you right here featuring
[1:52:37]
some native plants and animals that are actually
[1:52:40]
endangered along If you can speak to them,
[1:52:42]
I can report them.
[1:52:44]
Hello City officials and community assembled.
[1:52:46]
I am in deep, deep gratitude for the hard work presence
[1:52:50]
and globally represented voices from everyone
[1:52:53]
here today Thank you.
[1:52:55]
My name is Nataliya Campbell.
[1:52:56]
Piano And no, I am not born or native to this land.
[1:53:00]
Hayward has raised me and has been the only home
[1:53:02]
town I've ever had.
[1:53:04]
So you can imagine.
[1:53:05]
I'm very protective of it For 20 years.
[1:53:07]
I've given back to this land and the people here, as it has,
[1:53:11]
given to me.
[1:53:11]
And I'm sure everyone here can relate to my correct knowledge
[1:53:15]
as we live on this land, we are the stewards of this land
[1:53:19]
and waters, especially while its care is not
[1:53:22]
in the hands of its faded native folk.
[1:53:25]
Blessed be the last on people's.
[1:53:27]
I believe there is not much we owe in this world besides money
[1:53:30]
and vows.
[1:53:31]
But we owe this land its proper care.
[1:53:33]
And it is on us if we allow a dangerous house of pollution
[1:53:38]
machines to thrive in their dirty work,
[1:53:41]
we will have failed this land.
[1:53:43]
The waters, these precious animals and plants
[1:53:45]
We will have failed our communities, our children
[1:53:48]
and our future Now, I will not allow that
[1:53:51]
But the question is, will the elected stewards
[1:53:53]
of this land, of this city with the most power here,
[1:53:57]
allow this danger to powerful us all?
[1:54:00]
And we're all very curious to see how you handle our fate.
[1:54:04]
Thank you so much.
[1:54:05]
Thank you for your carefully measured consideration.
[1:54:08]
Thank you.
[1:54:09]
Blessing Good evening, Peter.
[1:54:17]
Lauren, when you also on behalf of the Bay Area
[1:54:19]
Council a civic organization based in San Francisco
[1:54:22]
So our organization has studied the issue of locally serving
[1:54:25]
datacentres and we support thoughtful regulation
[1:54:28]
on this matter.
[1:54:28]
Now, San Jose is thinking through similar issues
[1:54:31]
and provides an example for how Hayward
[1:54:33]
can take a pause to set threshold requirements for data
[1:54:36]
centers.
[1:54:37]
They're exploring a framework for uniform standards.
[1:54:40]
And they are taking community input
[1:54:42]
to set high obligations for these facilities
[1:54:45]
while preserving opportunities to leverage the 3 to $7 million
[1:54:48]
in general, fund revenue.
[1:54:49]
Each project provides Hayward is already there
[1:54:53]
You have updated your zoning rules earlier this year.
[1:54:56]
And those changes set stricter standards
[1:54:58]
for data center approval, including
[1:55:00]
including council approval of all projects
[1:55:02]
through a major conditional use permit.
[1:55:04]
And they are the first to acquire a sustainability
[1:55:06]
plan and a community benefits plan for each project.
[1:55:10]
Any pause should be thoughtfully structured,
[1:55:11]
focusing on identify long regulatory gaps to be corrected
[1:55:14]
while continuing to review applications at their earlier
[1:55:17]
stages City staff should also conduct
[1:55:19]
a fiscal analysis of data centers contribution
[1:55:22]
to the General Fund to consider all impacts to public safety,
[1:55:25]
Parks, Rec and other community expenditure Thank you.
[1:55:28]
Thank you Can I have Kenneth or do you have Kenneth up next?
[1:55:39]
Yeah.
[1:55:40]
Kenneth, please.
[1:55:40]
Yeah.
[1:55:41]
Kenneth sica.
[1:55:43]
Yeah And are you Ms..
[1:55:47]
Speirs?
[1:55:47]
OK And then I have.
[1:55:49]
Yeah.
[1:55:50]
And then your next.
[1:55:51]
Yeah.
[1:55:51]
Sorry I didn't know was up next.
[1:55:53]
Yeah.
[1:55:54]
So we as Hayward residents generally
[1:55:57]
come to you all to not only give us a little bit of grievance
[1:56:03]
when it comes to our perspective but I
[1:56:07]
would say as individuals in the community.
[1:56:10]
We generally tend to give our best understanding of what you
[1:56:17]
all would like to give to us.
[1:56:19]
Data centers don't give us what we would consider prosperity.
[1:56:29]
There's no guarantee for data centers
[1:56:31]
to actually give us when it comes to pardon me,
[1:56:41]
him at his speaking in public data centers.
[1:56:44]
Don't give us a grant on what they
[1:56:47]
can boon to the community They give us
[1:56:50]
what we can take as far as water, as far as energy as far
[1:56:55]
as the resources in land But they don't give us
[1:56:58]
a guarantee on what they can produce in regards
[1:57:01]
to what they can give us to the community They say
[1:57:04]
that we can give us time as a.
[1:57:06]
Thank you so much.
[1:57:07]
Yeah, thank you.
[1:57:08]
But we got it.
[1:57:08]
Thank you Hi, my name ABC's Kaylee.
[1:57:16]
I was raised in Hayward.
[1:57:18]
I went through the entire city school district.
[1:57:21]
I am here to ask you to stop the super crazy data
[1:57:26]
center that you guys are.
[1:57:27]
That's being built right now.
[1:57:30]
When I went to Hayward High School and I took
[1:57:33]
I had to take a government class on how the government is run.
[1:57:37]
I know that you guys are civil servants
[1:57:40]
You guys are elected by us.
[1:57:43]
You should be listening to us.
[1:57:45]
Almost everyone pretty much everyone in this room
[1:57:48]
who's a constituent who is your constituent is saying,
[1:57:51]
we don't want this.
[1:57:52]
And we are begging you and asking you.
[1:57:55]
So like, intensely to stop this, It's going to harm us
[1:58:00]
And that should be the thing you don't want because we are
[1:58:04]
you are supposed to represent us and stand for us,
[1:58:06]
not stand for the data centers, the tech, every thing
[1:58:10]
stand for us, the people of Hayward
[1:58:13]
instead of the rich guys.
[1:58:16]
Thank you.
[1:58:16]
Thank you Good evening, everyone.
[1:58:25]
My name is Brent Howe.
[1:58:26]
I am a member of local union.
[1:58:28]
I local union 595 with the IBEW and I'm a resident here
[1:58:32]
in Hayward.
[1:58:33]
I have lived here in Hayward in District One
[1:58:35]
now for the last seven years.
[1:58:37]
And I'm glad we are here today to talk about the data
[1:58:40]
center being built in Hayward I have
[1:58:42]
worked in this industry for the last decade.
[1:58:44]
And I understand both the opportunities
[1:58:46]
these projects create and the enormous amount
[1:58:48]
of infrastructure that they require
[1:58:50]
I'm also a resident and ratepayer,
[1:58:52]
and I think the questions about energy water,
[1:58:54]
infrastructure and impacts on our communities
[1:58:56]
deserve real answers I believe that this
[1:59:00]
is a great opportunity for us to establish strong standards
[1:59:03]
for data centers being built, and I
[1:59:04]
recommend that the policy is have language in there that
[1:59:07]
protect the ratepayers as well as the local communities.
[1:59:11]
If these facilities are going to be built here
[1:59:13]
we need to know what the rules are
[1:59:15]
The policies should be in place to protect
[1:59:17]
the residents the ratepayer ratepayers address
[1:59:21]
environmental and infrastructure concerns
[1:59:23]
and require skilled and trained workforce to build these highly
[1:59:25]
complex facilities.
[1:59:27]
We have an opportunity to get this right here
[1:59:28]
before moving forward.
[1:59:30]
Thank you.
[1:59:30]
Thank you.
[1:59:31]
Appreciate my last three.
[1:59:35]
My last three cards are Lucy lopez, Francisco Perez
[1:59:40]
and any Audie Gal or Eddie joe from the Sea, Lucy Lopez
[1:59:58]
Francisco Perez, and then any Yeah Good morning, everyone.
[2:00:09]
I'm sorry.
[2:00:09]
Good evening.
[2:00:10]
Sorry I think about tomorrow.
[2:00:11]
Sorry.
[2:00:12]
Good evening.
[2:00:13]
Mary Salinas Councilmembers and city manager Art and staff.
[2:00:18]
Thank you. you for hosting tonight's topic.
[2:00:21]
It is one that is all over the country
[2:00:25]
and on behalf of the Hayward Chamber of Commerce
[2:00:27]
we respectfully ask the Council and staff
[2:00:29]
to continue to research and fully about this critical issue
[2:00:32]
before moving forward with any changes
[2:00:34]
to our zoning code that would prohibit all future data center
[2:00:38]
development Most importantly, we ask
[2:00:40]
that the business community and subject matter experts
[2:00:43]
be given more time and meaningful opportunity
[2:00:46]
to participate, provide feedback, accurate information
[2:00:50]
before any significant policy direction is determined
[2:00:54]
Businesses are essential to Hayward.
[2:00:56]
They generate revenue that supports public safety
[2:00:59]
and essential city services.
[2:01:01]
They create jobs, drive investment and innovation
[2:01:05]
There's a ton of innovation being done here in Hayward
[2:01:08]
right in our new innovation corridor, industrial corridor,
[2:01:11]
I call the Innovation Quarter and contribute
[2:01:14]
to the economic growth of our community.
[2:01:16]
Their voices and expertise should
[2:01:17]
be part of this conversation Yes,
[2:01:20]
conduct a comprehensive serve and economic environment
[2:01:23]
analysis.
[2:01:23]
But I ask that you work with us to hear
[2:01:25]
from the businesses and their employees who also live here
[2:01:29]
in hayward.
[2:01:30]
Environment experts labor and utilities.
[2:01:32]
We fully recognize the concerns surrounding
[2:01:34]
energy water, infrastructure, environmental impacts and land
[2:01:38]
use and those concerns are valid.
[2:01:40]
However, there's also a ton of inaccurate information
[2:01:43]
being shared.
[2:01:44]
Those concerns deserve full, careful evaluation
[2:01:47]
but so do the potential economic benefits
[2:01:49]
and consequences of closing the door entirely
[2:01:52]
to future investments is okay.
[2:01:55]
We do.
[2:01:55]
Let us continue gathering the facts
[2:01:57]
and determine what policy is right for Hayward
[2:01:59]
Thank you very francisco My name is Francisco perez.
[2:02:09]
I've grown up in Hayward, been raised here
[2:02:11]
my entire life We have seen what these data centers have done
[2:02:14]
across the country And we are here
[2:02:15]
to reject the idea that data centers should be built here.
[2:02:18]
These data centers recklessly harvest our water resources
[2:02:21]
and our data and are used to support mass surveillance
[2:02:23]
through the flock cameras.
[2:02:24]
We have all seen go up around our city,
[2:02:26]
Hayward is not for sale to the highest tech bidders.
[2:02:28]
We will not be gaslit and told that this
[2:02:30]
is in our best economic interests
[2:02:34]
Hayward is here to reject a future.
[2:02:36]
With data centers in our neighborhoods,
[2:02:37]
and we are here to reject the dystopian A.I. centric
[2:02:41]
future that this council is attempting
[2:02:42]
to build here in this city.
[2:02:44]
Thank you Thank you Fran as much as Council Jennifer vaughan here
[2:02:55]
in Saint Rose in our community family members are still here.
[2:03:00]
I grew up seeing my neighborhood gardens going dry.
[2:03:02]
Because the state policy was put out limiting residents
[2:03:06]
own water use.
[2:03:07]
And we still hear that every so often now that I pay my own rent
[2:03:10]
for my own apartment, I'm told to minimize my electricity
[2:03:13]
and don't turn on my washer and dryer between 4:00 and 9:00
[2:03:16]
because God forbid, you know, it also is a fact that our water
[2:03:20]
and electricity bills are going up constantly.
[2:03:22]
10% last year 10% this year we Hayward
[2:03:26]
residents are limited for the sake of California
[2:03:28]
and our environment.
[2:03:29]
How is it possible that we're going
[2:03:31]
to add that we added another data center
[2:03:33]
and knowing that they are.
[2:03:36]
Exactly.
[2:03:36]
They're doing exactly the opposite of what
[2:03:38]
residents are being limited?
[2:03:41]
Please ban all data centers.
[2:03:42]
And for those existing, do not allow
[2:03:45]
them to cause more harm to Hayward
[2:03:47]
please pass that referral.
[2:03:49]
Thank you OK.
[2:03:57]
I am going to go to I have a few callers online,
[2:04:01]
so like to first call upon Maria del Carmen Yes, hi,
[2:04:07]
can you hear me ?
[2:04:08]
Yes, hi.
[2:04:10]
This is Maria Del Carmen Espinosa
[2:04:12]
and I am a parent and student advocate within Hayward Unified
[2:04:15]
School District.
[2:04:16]
And I just want to let you guys know, I mean,
[2:04:19]
you up there all of you up there in the board,
[2:04:22]
I just it's on the council.
[2:04:25]
It's a infuriating that we have all of these people pleading
[2:04:29]
with you to ban these centers and yet you're
[2:04:31]
still giving it a thought of, you know,
[2:04:35]
oh, this is postponed it No, ban it.
[2:04:37]
Appreciate it.
[2:04:38]
It my biggest fear is some of these students,
[2:04:40]
the young students, the middle schoolers the high schoolers,
[2:04:43]
they don't even want to live anymore
[2:04:46]
because they don't see a future, because of air centers,
[2:04:50]
because of air, everything is taking over So
[2:04:53]
how do you think these young students feel knowing
[2:04:57]
that they have no future?
[2:04:59]
That's how that's what they think.
[2:05:00]
They have no future So why even be alive in ten years?
[2:05:05]
And that is the fear.
[2:05:07]
So please, just ban these centers,
[2:05:10]
help hUAC, have some faith in you guys Thank you.
[2:05:15]
Thank you And next speaker is next speaker is Zoom user zoom
[2:05:25]
user Hi, I'm Suzanne Luther lifelong resident of Hayward.
[2:05:34]
First thing I want to say is that hayward prides
[2:05:38]
themself on being a green city, so I'm just going to leave that.
[2:05:41]
There But tonight, you stated at the beginning of this issue
[2:05:45]
tonight that you are only listening
[2:05:47]
So first, I ask that you not only listen,
[2:05:50]
but that you actually hear your constituents concerns requests,
[2:05:54]
demands, ears, comments input efforts
[2:05:58]
about this important issue.
[2:06:00]
It's true that California has major regulated science
[2:06:03]
in basically every industry.
[2:06:05]
California regulates everything However,
[2:06:08]
there is no enforcement there is no money to pay for enforcement
[2:06:11]
So all the regulations mean nothing I'm speaking tonight
[2:06:14]
to ask you, mayor and council, to request
[2:06:17]
that you vote on this issue.
[2:06:18]
At the next council meeting and do not
[2:06:21]
wait until after the election And I
[2:06:23]
recommend that all of you in the audience
[2:06:26]
also request that this mayor and council vote
[2:06:28]
on this at the next council meeting
[2:06:31]
and ask that they not wait until after the upcoming election.
[2:06:35]
And I'll keep you in the audience.
[2:06:36]
If councillors decide that before the election.
[2:06:39]
I suggest you take your time as you
[2:06:41]
can Siddur Whether you want the council members that
[2:06:44]
are specifically to continue making these decisions for you,
[2:06:48]
then your speaker, the next speaker is Lisa Lena Martin
[2:06:54]
Reyes Selena Martin and Reyes Hi.
[2:07:02]
Can you hear me?
[2:07:03]
Yes.
[2:07:04]
OK.
[2:07:05]
Good afternoon My name is Selena Reyes I'm a Hayward resident.
[2:07:09]
And I'm here to urge the city of Hayward
[2:07:11]
to vote in support of a data center ban in Hayward.
[2:07:14]
As our oceans hit the highest temperatures on record
[2:07:17]
while andino grows on course to be the strongest in centuries
[2:07:22]
our company profits and cheap, non-human labor
[2:07:26]
worth the accelerated extinction of humanity.
[2:07:29]
The construction and use of air data centers
[2:07:32]
will negatively impact environmental resources
[2:07:35]
to ecosystem residents of this city and our surrounding
[2:07:39]
neighbors.
[2:07:40]
We know the marshmallow on the 92
[2:07:42]
itself is helping hold up rising sea levels.
[2:07:45]
This data centers not only have lax to no regulations
[2:07:49]
and oversight, but also consume and add demand
[2:07:52]
to our water and electric infrastructure that
[2:07:55]
is needed to.
[2:07:56]
But is needed for life beings to use, not for air tech
[2:07:59]
that humanity has lived and thrived without,
[2:08:02]
with a new and normalcy, a frequent environmental disasters
[2:08:05]
that cause extremely high tides, health
[2:08:07]
hazards environmental impacts nationwide and around the globe.
[2:08:11]
We owe it to living organisms and human to limit,
[2:08:15]
maintain overconsumption that only dangerous oligarchs
[2:08:19]
and corporate politicians Thank you.
[2:08:22]
I ask our next caller is Galaxy Gallus Galaxy s 25.
[2:08:31]
Hello, my name is Eduardo.
[2:08:33]
I am a proud parent of three students
[2:08:36]
here in Hayward and a resident for the last 18 years
[2:08:41]
and i also am in favor of banning these data centers.
[2:08:46]
Shame on our city council who has
[2:08:49]
to cited cell or the health of our future and our children's I
[2:08:56]
really do urge that you vote on this ban
[2:09:00]
because you are all elected officials.
[2:09:02]
And I am very, very influential individual in this south gate
[2:09:07]
community.
[2:09:08]
As so I urge you to do what's right for our children,
[2:09:11]
and for our residents I yield my time.
[2:09:14]
Thank you AC and I may not know how to pronounce this,
[2:09:25]
but it's a very short name.
[2:09:27]
It's a h is it r r on ?
[2:09:36]
Hello?
[2:09:37]
Can you hear me?
[2:09:38]
Yes Hi.
[2:09:39]
My name's on Anna Hayward Resident Irish and Urgency
[2:09:46]
and support for Council members to write
[2:09:51]
for moratorium or ban or stronger rules or for parents.
[2:09:55]
Please publish both OK 5 to 9 million revenue studies
[2:09:59]
and show Hayward's actual share servers.
[2:10:03]
Keep only about 12% of taxable values.
[2:10:06]
After five years, he works utility users.
[2:10:09]
Tax expires in 2039 and Santa clara City data centers fund
[2:10:15]
the city only 200 K to foreign two year and property tax per
[2:10:21]
the C c's review stack has about three diesel generators
[2:10:25]
and about 129,000 gallons of diesel on site required.
[2:10:31]
Public reporting of energy, water, and generators
[2:10:34]
run hours A combined health risk assessment
[2:10:37]
with favor exchange and two annoying baseline study
[2:10:41]
and decommissioning bond.
[2:10:43]
Other cities learn on your time is up.
[2:10:49]
Thank you Thank you.
[2:10:51]
Malina Rosalba Malina Rose Silva Good evening,
[2:11:01]
Marin city Council.
[2:11:03]
I'm malina Rosalba.
[2:11:06]
I am on the board of directors of a Colony Audubon
[2:11:10]
society, a local chapter here in Alameda County.
[2:11:14]
That includes the city of Hayward
[2:11:16]
where we emphasize conservation of birds and their habitat
[2:11:22]
And we oppose that any kind of construction of data centers.
[2:11:29]
And so therefore, we support the ban on data centers
[2:11:34]
and also ask to stop construction of any current data
[2:11:40]
centers and therefore, we are speaking for our nonhuman
[2:11:45]
relatives and thus all of the Ecos system,
[2:11:48]
without which no humans would ever be able to survive.
[2:11:53]
So remember, it's also about our non-human relatives, the plants
[2:11:58]
and the animals and all our flora and fauna, including
[2:12:01]
the waters and the land and the air as well, without whom
[2:12:06]
none of us could ever be alive.
[2:12:08]
Thank you.
[2:12:09]
You.
[2:12:09]
Thank you Our next speaker is Our next speaker
[2:12:15]
is Nigel Tor is the lOSO.
[2:12:20]
Nayeli Hello.
[2:12:25]
You guys hear me?
[2:12:26]
Yes Perfect.
[2:12:28]
So I'm so I'm calling all the way from Cal poly Humboldt.
[2:12:32]
I was born and raised in California
[2:12:35]
and I, for one when I first heard the news of a data
[2:12:38]
center being built on engineering,
[2:12:41]
I was so disappointed I was resident Oak Ridge which
[2:12:46]
stands for Revolutionaries Advocating for Greener
[2:12:48]
Ecosystems Asked about college, seeing
[2:12:51]
the pride that the mayor had over there over a Styrofoam fan
[2:12:56]
was due to something.
[2:12:58]
So nice to see.
[2:13:00]
And I want our community to have pride
[2:13:03]
over just having being more environment really friendly
[2:13:07]
in the area but just seeing so many people already being
[2:13:12]
angry over a Denison or being built gave me so much pride
[2:13:16]
and hope I just hope you guys see what
[2:13:20]
these what these people are saying and take note of it
[2:13:24]
and hope you guys vote for the ban against data centers.
[2:13:28]
Thank you so much.
[2:13:29]
Thank you very much Andre van Horn Andre Van Horn going once,
[2:14:01]
going twice Mr. Van Horn.
[2:14:04]
Can I have you heard?
[2:14:05]
Yes, I can hear you.
[2:14:06]
Oh, sorry.
[2:14:07]
Thank you.
[2:14:07]
I like to fully support this data center.
[2:14:09]
We have an industrial area in this city for a reason,
[2:14:13]
and we should make use of it.
[2:14:15]
I think, the process for approving
[2:14:16]
the data center was great The city council set out
[2:14:19]
clear, obvious rules that developers could follow
[2:14:23]
and took away the veto points that we
[2:14:26]
use to sabotage housing developments, industrial work,
[2:14:29]
whatever the case may be sabotaging
[2:14:32]
these private projects and undermining a real clear process
[2:14:36]
is why we have empty lots all through the downtown.
[2:14:39]
And I would like to apply this council
[2:14:42]
for not falling for this supporting
[2:14:46]
the real budget for this city and supporting development.
[2:14:50]
We have an industrial area.
[2:14:51]
And we should use it.
[2:14:52]
Thank you Thank you.
[2:14:55]
OK, so I do not have any more cards
[2:14:59]
and there are no more callers online.
[2:15:02]
So what i'd like to do is I like to close
[2:15:05]
public comment We have one more hand that snuck in
[2:15:13]
and I will take it.
[2:15:15]
I will take it Hi, everyone.
[2:15:20]
This is my name is Mildred Vasquez.
[2:15:23]
I was born and raised in Hayward,
[2:15:24]
California I'm currently I'm on Zoom I'm a Cal Poly student
[2:15:30]
and I'm currently actually in Hayward I wanted
[2:15:34]
to be in support of the ban.
[2:15:38]
A complete ban and a pause on the current data center
[2:15:43]
As mentioned earlier our electricity bills could go up.
[2:15:47]
Noise pollution will continue to.
[2:15:49]
And I just really don't see what the point of supporting
[2:15:54]
the growth of AI will be like.
[2:15:57]
There is no reason for it.
[2:16:00]
And i just think that if our city council values
[2:16:06]
the lives of the people who voted for them
[2:16:08]
or the people who supported them,
[2:16:10]
I think that we will get what the people are asking for.
[2:16:15]
You can see I don't have to tell you
[2:16:16]
that there's a large majority of people who do not support this.
[2:16:19]
And who showed up, who take the time to come here
[2:16:22]
because they're so passionate about this,
[2:16:24]
not going through That's it Thank you.
[2:16:29]
Appreciate it.
[2:16:30]
OK So I'm going to close public comment on this item.
[2:16:36]
And what I'm going to do is I am going to take care.
[2:16:39]
Seven minute recess.
[2:16:40]
So that we can stretch your legs and maybe take a bio break.
[2:16:46]
So, Madam city Clerk, if you put seven minutes on the clock.
[2:16:49]
Thank you And yeah and And I Can I love your hair right
[2:25:40]
And if I can if I can call the Council back to the dais
[2:25:52]
If I can call the council back to the dais,
[2:25:55]
please Council member Bonior the council members from Inyo
[2:26:09]
Council members are Meno council member Bonior And Oh, okay.
[2:27:12]
OK Can I get a can I get everyone to sit down please?
[2:27:19]
Can I get everyone to sit down please Thank you Thank you OK.
[2:27:47]
I want to make sure we get we're all line and.
[2:27:52]
All righty So thank you very much for that.
[2:27:55]
And I before me, make sure All right.
[2:28:13]
Okay So let me kick this off and my remarks
[2:28:18]
are going to be very brief.
[2:28:21]
And then I'll open it up for my colleagues up here
[2:28:26]
to sort of come in and build up the framework so that, you know,
[2:28:34]
that I'm going to sort of propose
[2:28:37]
that we laid lay out and begin to direct staff
[2:28:41]
in in a direction.
[2:28:42]
So that we can.
[2:28:43]
So we can move forward.
[2:28:48]
So i heard just some observations and First of all,
[2:28:53]
I wanted to say thank you for coming out and
[2:28:56]
and thank you for for putting up with me for being
[2:29:00]
the timekeeper.
[2:29:01]
That's not an easy job, by the way Nonetheless,
[2:29:07]
I understand that, you know, there's clearly
[2:29:10]
a voice in here that is looking for an all out band for data
[2:29:16]
centers.
[2:29:17]
And I hear it.
[2:29:19]
We hear it and and I understand that there's
[2:29:25]
three other big buckets or big themes
[2:29:28]
that I am hearing that I heard this evening.
[2:29:33]
There is clear expectation of more transparency and greater
[2:29:42]
expectations around transparency.
[2:29:46]
Things like reporting reporting either you know,
[2:29:50]
monthly or annually.
[2:29:53]
The operation of the you know, the data
[2:29:59]
center but also I also heard the widening of letting people know,
[2:30:09]
right More people need to know about this.
[2:30:11]
And there's got to be greater degree of, you know,
[2:30:16]
of reaching out and making sure people know
[2:30:18]
about these kinds of projects.
[2:30:22]
The other theme I heard this evening was accountability
[2:30:27]
for data centers, things like clear rules for data
[2:30:34]
centers I heard research sponsible policy
[2:30:40]
objectives and responsible policy goals,
[2:30:45]
clear rules I heard labor standards a clear articulation
[2:30:54]
and for Labor standards.
[2:30:58]
I also heard a comment that articulated the threshold
[2:31:05]
standards when coming to the city.
[2:31:08]
What is that I also heard there was a statement.
[2:31:17]
And I. I forget who said this, but there
[2:31:21]
was a commenter that said Represent us right
[2:31:25]
And and that's part of the accountability piece, right?
[2:31:29]
Making sure that your expectations as neighborhoods,
[2:31:35]
your expectations as a city are are
[2:31:39]
included in representing the other bucket
[2:31:44]
A third bucket that I heard this evening was community benefits
[2:31:51]
and you know looking at how data centers can benefit
[2:31:58]
the community, how, you know, what our clear expectations
[2:32:03]
that if built how a data center would benefit the city.
[2:32:09]
And clearly lay in that out clearly articulate leading that.
[2:32:13]
And what does that look like and how
[2:32:17]
does that connect a building like this or an industry
[2:32:22]
like this or a company like this?
[2:32:25]
How does it benefit the city or neighborhoods?
[2:32:30]
And so there's those three those three general themes
[2:32:35]
transparency, accountability and community benefits.
[2:32:41]
And so, you know what What I would
[2:32:44]
like to do is and given the urgency and I
[2:32:47]
and clearly there's you know, there's folks here and you know
[2:32:51]
and there's a lot of folks that have been emailing me
[2:32:54]
and there's a lot of folks that have, you know, spoken with me
[2:32:59]
and talked to me about this.
[2:33:02]
And clearly, there's an urgency see, regarding this.
[2:33:07]
And, you know, and I think that's why councilmember
[2:33:10]
Andrews and Mayor Pro Tem Syra.
[2:33:12]
But I you know we put this referral together
[2:33:17]
and we brought it to the council because we do sense the urgency
[2:33:22]
and we see it.
[2:33:23]
So what I'd like to do is, given the urgency is
[2:33:27]
I'd like to see direct staff if we can, then put together
[2:33:33]
a moratorium to stop process.
[2:33:37]
Right now so that staff has the opportunity for us, for you
[2:33:42]
and for us to look at the existing policy that we have.
[2:33:49]
And then look at how we can increase the standards tighten
[2:33:57]
up the standards, edit those standards around transparency.
[2:34:02]
You know, and I'll just give you one one example
[2:34:06]
with transparency You know, the data center right now
[2:34:10]
is in the furthest part of the industrial zone
[2:34:14]
And the nearest, you know, neighborhood the Glen Eden
[2:34:18]
neighborhood, is about a mile and a half, two miles from the
[2:34:25]
from the building.
[2:34:26]
And the proxy committee, the proxies city,
[2:34:31]
although it is an industrial zone,
[2:34:33]
the proximity is about 500ft.
[2:34:36]
I believe So, you know, maybe, when
[2:34:40]
I think about the transparency piece is
[2:34:42]
that we need to widen the proximity of notification
[2:34:48]
of this particularly since only the industrial zone is zoned
[2:34:54]
for it.
[2:34:54]
So we I think with this, I think we need to look at that
[2:35:00]
So that's just one example.
[2:35:02]
And there's I have plenty more for accountability and community
[2:35:05]
benefits, but I just wanted to call that and call that out.
[2:35:08]
So what I'd like for us to would what I'd like to see
[2:35:13]
is for us to stop process right now
[2:35:19]
and come back with a with a moratorium
[2:35:23]
so that we can then proceed to evaluate the policy that we have
[2:35:28]
and see how we can edit it moving forward Because I think,
[2:35:32]
the points we heard tonight and i think the feedback we got
[2:35:36]
tonight clearly there is there's a need for that.
[2:35:40]
So I'll stop there.
[2:35:42]
There's more.
[2:35:43]
I want to talk about, but I'll stop there
[2:35:46]
and see if my colleagues have more
[2:35:49]
to say or build on that And I don't have i don't know
[2:35:54]
if you guys are hit the but okay,
[2:35:58]
Council member Emanuel okay, So go ahead Council members,
[2:36:09]
have you Mayor Thank you very much.
[2:36:12]
And thank you all for being here.
[2:36:14]
It's tremendous I did have a couple a couple of questions
[2:36:18]
for our staff and thank you for the presentation
[2:36:23]
And also in the notice states, presently we
[2:36:26]
have 7900 data centers throughout the
[2:36:32]
throughout the country.
[2:36:33]
So of the emails that I received many of them
[2:36:37]
state the data centers use up all electricity all of the water
[2:36:44]
They kill all the floor and the fauna around the data centers.
[2:36:49]
They pollute the air So I want to know,
[2:36:54]
have we looked into all at all, if any
[2:36:57]
of the communities around the 7 to 900 data centers
[2:37:02]
have actually cost that?
[2:37:05]
Well, in other words, if I am paying my
[2:37:10]
per unit bill and the data center, all of a sudden
[2:37:15]
needs extra energy will they receive the energy
[2:37:20]
and cut me off This is what the people are worried about.
[2:37:23]
They're the people are worried that they're going to use.
[2:37:27]
So much water that I will not have any water.
[2:37:30]
Has that happened?
[2:37:31]
And the Senate 7900 communities that
[2:37:34]
have a data center Ladies and gentlemen, I'm going to me.
[2:37:39]
I'm going to pause here for a second.
[2:37:42]
We've sat for about 2.5 hours.
[2:37:44]
We listened to you.
[2:37:47]
We allowed you to do your job.
[2:37:49]
You did it.
[2:37:50]
Let us have our time and let us work through this.
[2:37:54]
And the cheers and jeers I respectfully,
[2:37:57]
if you can just you know, let us do our job
[2:38:00]
and we can get through this a lot faster.
[2:38:02]
OK?
[2:38:03]
Thank you Thank you.
[2:38:04]
Yeah.
[2:38:05]
Staff has done a lot of due diligence
[2:38:06]
and we've looked at a lot of studies.
[2:38:08]
There's a lot of articles we've looked you know, primarily,
[2:38:13]
we're focused on California and the hayward
[2:38:16]
and looking at kind of the local impact
[2:38:19]
And so those are things we are looking at and have looked at.
[2:38:22]
But we have not looked at every single community
[2:38:25]
that's had a data center.
[2:38:26]
And I think depending on the direction tonight,
[2:38:28]
the staff can review do more studies
[2:38:31]
and look at other case studies.
[2:38:35]
But we haven't looked at every single community
[2:38:37]
across the country So thank you.
[2:38:38]
Thank you.
[2:38:39]
So I will be brief again.
[2:38:40]
Thank you all very much.
[2:38:42]
Two words I heard today I do agree with that email
[2:38:45]
or by the way but two words I heard today
[2:38:47]
was on slowdown and study.
[2:38:50]
And in my mind that is something that I believe we should do.
[2:38:54]
And I believe that's what a moratorium will
[2:38:56]
do If we have a moratorium that will allow the our city staff
[2:39:04]
to look into not only the three items that our mayor mentioned,
[2:39:08]
but also on the does it kill all of the animals around
[2:39:14]
and the sick kill all the flowers on
[2:39:18]
and maybe they can look into you know,
[2:39:21]
the 7900 other data centers I think
[2:39:24]
it's important for everybody to see the pros and the cons
[2:39:32]
and allow us then to receive the results of these studies.
[2:39:37]
So then we can move forward and intelligently make the decision
[2:39:44]
as to how far in advance should we go, how many do we
[2:39:50]
want And of course, the areas where they possibly
[2:39:54]
could be placed.
[2:39:55]
So a moratorium is what I would vote for today,
[2:40:00]
I would not vote for.
[2:40:01]
But I agree with a moratorium on sorts.
[2:40:04]
So thank you, Mayor, and thank you.
[2:40:05]
Sit down.
[2:40:07]
Thank you Councilmember Roach.
[2:40:10]
Thank you Yeah.
[2:40:11]
Thank you, everyone, for being here tonight.
[2:40:13]
You know, we're here because we were listening
[2:40:15]
because I think the mayor and councilmember Johnson, Mayor Pro
[2:40:18]
Tem Sara, Sara's heard that call and realize this
[2:40:21]
was such an important moment that we all
[2:40:23]
had to get together and have some discussion about this.
[2:40:26]
So I'm glad we're doing this because like you, I'm
[2:40:29]
very concerned about what's happening
[2:40:30]
around the country with these large city side size hyperscale
[2:40:34]
data centers.
[2:40:34]
They're causing havoc in some of these small communities.
[2:40:37]
And there's some real consequence choices and impact
[2:40:39]
in the communities that I am very concerned about You know,
[2:40:42]
I'm reading all the same things.
[2:40:44]
You are.
[2:40:45]
I'm trying to consult environmental experts technology
[2:40:47]
experts, other governments and how they're
[2:40:49]
doing this and trying to weigh in,
[2:40:51]
trying to find a way forward.
[2:40:52]
I am I'm also concerned about the emergence of I
[2:40:55]
I've got young kids in the city as well.
[2:40:57]
And, these are all things I think we're all concerned about.
[2:41:00]
And like all of you, this all became very important.
[2:41:03]
What in the last eight months or so.
[2:41:05]
And so what came before this?
[2:41:07]
I think we were we were going off regular land use policy
[2:41:10]
in our industrial sector.
[2:41:11]
And I don't I'm you know, I commend the Planning
[2:41:14]
Commission for following the rules that were there
[2:41:16]
at the time.
[2:41:16]
But this is now called for a bigger you know,
[2:41:19]
a bigger spotlight.
[2:41:21]
And I think we all have to rise to that occasion
[2:41:23]
and understand what, you know, what does this
[2:41:25]
mean for the future of Hayward I want
[2:41:27]
to thank the staff for creating a report that
[2:41:29]
talks about the regulations where we were before.
[2:41:31]
And where we are now.
[2:41:32]
And I want to make clear that back in May of this year,
[2:41:35]
because we heard it, because we realized
[2:41:38]
that these data for potentially something different,
[2:41:40]
we needed to look at.
[2:41:42]
We passed, we made new regulations.
[2:41:44]
Hayward is now the strictest city in the Bay Area
[2:41:47]
to bring a data center to the way it currently stands We
[2:41:49]
in order to bring a data center to here,
[2:41:51]
would you now have to come before the city council for four
[2:41:54]
major conditional use permit?
[2:41:56]
You have to provide a sustainable city
[2:41:57]
plan and the community benefits plan.
[2:41:59]
And that is tougher than any city except maybe
[2:42:01]
for San Jose, who is now putting some of these regulations
[2:42:04]
into place.
[2:42:05]
So we have heard that call And I and I but I,
[2:42:08]
I think that it is okay to move forward.
[2:42:11]
Now and to talk about.
[2:42:12]
Okay, what does that mean, a sustainability plan
[2:42:14]
or a community benefits package?
[2:42:16]
I mean, how do we answer some of the very, you know,
[2:42:18]
serious concerns about the environment
[2:42:20]
that we've heard here today?
[2:42:22]
I just want to find some of my notes.
[2:42:24]
I went back to I also think, we do
[2:42:26]
need to wait and see if the state catches up to provide us
[2:42:29]
some backstops on rate payer protections,
[2:42:31]
backstops on water use and transparency and water use.
[2:42:34]
So that data centers are large, industrial users
[2:42:37]
are very transparent with their water use.
[2:42:39]
So we can all.
[2:42:40]
So we can look at real numbers.
[2:42:41]
There's a lot of, you know a lot of numbers
[2:42:43]
thrown out today about what data center,
[2:42:45]
how much data centers really use and water.
[2:42:46]
I don't know.
[2:42:47]
I'm not an expert at that, I'd like to find that out
[2:42:50]
to know for sure because there's big numbers all
[2:42:52]
over the country.
[2:42:53]
Some of these data centers use large, large amounts of water
[2:42:55]
There's emerging technology that will make that not necessary.
[2:42:58]
Let's find that out before we make absolute decisions I also
[2:43:04]
think, you know, the rate payers absolutely
[2:43:06]
should not be footing the bill for infrastructure
[2:43:08]
that's built to bring energy to data centers.
[2:43:10]
And I absolutely want to look at that.
[2:43:12]
I absolutely want to look at the noise.
[2:43:14]
You know, what is we should be know,
[2:43:15]
we should be monitoring the noise levels
[2:43:17]
from both the diesel generators, as was mentioned,
[2:43:19]
and the H vac, you know, equipment that
[2:43:22]
is on top of these buildings.
[2:43:25]
Let's see.
[2:43:25]
And I and i also the other thing I think is true that, you know,
[2:43:28]
a lot of people said I didn't know this was happening,
[2:43:31]
you know, well, I think most of us
[2:43:32]
don't know if there's a large, you
[2:43:34]
know, a townhome project going in
[2:43:36]
or if there is a large bottling plant going
[2:43:39]
in the industrial center.
[2:43:40]
We didn't know.
[2:43:41]
I mean, I don't always know, but I
[2:43:43]
think this is now risen to a level
[2:43:45]
that I think what the community is asking which I think
[2:43:47]
is a good idea, is if a data center were
[2:43:49]
to come in the future, that that would
[2:43:51]
be potentially a citywide notification
[2:43:53]
And I think that's proper.
[2:43:55]
I'd also like to see us, you know, should we take this pause,
[2:43:58]
maybe provide town halls and get some experts to answer
[2:44:02]
these very real questions?
[2:44:03]
I think like noise was played tonight.
[2:44:05]
Like I don't know.
[2:44:06]
I mean, I've heard some of these data centers and the rest
[2:44:08]
of the country are operating 24 seven on diesel generators
[2:44:11]
because they cannot get the infrastructure to bring
[2:44:14]
in the power that this is not the case.
[2:44:15]
We have an industrial air for this purpose
[2:44:17]
that we have the infrastructure there.
[2:44:19]
So a data center here will not be including
[2:44:22]
the docks the stack center will not
[2:44:25]
be running 24 seven or diesel generators
[2:44:27]
But what the noise level is, I don't know.
[2:44:29]
Yeah.
[2:44:30]
Let's find out That is why tonight I I hear you.
[2:44:35]
I recommendation to staff is to bring back findings
[2:44:37]
for an immediate moratorium to stop any further applications
[2:44:40]
for data centers until we know for certain that we cannot
[2:44:43]
mitigate all of these concerns around water use, noise,
[2:44:47]
impact and emissions from diesel generators.
[2:44:49]
You know, I'd like to know that for sure.
[2:44:51]
And, an answer some of the questions
[2:44:53]
retroactively that i think we did do a good job of answering
[2:44:57]
with the stack center As was said,
[2:44:59]
California has some of the tightest environmental
[2:45:01]
regulations in the country that you don't see in some
[2:45:05]
of the other states And that's why you see some
[2:45:07]
of this terrible you know, impacts
[2:45:09]
that we've seen on the news.
[2:45:11]
So, you know what what the stack center had to go through
[2:45:13]
is still a million times better than what we see
[2:45:15]
in the rest of the country, even though I know there are still
[2:45:18]
concerns and so that's my recommendation on the moratorium
[2:45:22]
Sorry, I'm nervous, too, and I'm on the second item
[2:45:27]
of the referral directing the City Council the council
[2:45:31]
sustainable committee, which I serve on
[2:45:33]
to develop a report on the economic environment
[2:45:35]
impacts of existing data centers.
[2:45:37]
I support that part of the referral as well.
[2:45:39]
Thank you to my colleagues I'm supportive of the recommendation
[2:45:42]
the way it is written, and I would
[2:45:44]
like that report to include impacts on water use.
[2:45:46]
So looking at the amount of water testing the water,
[2:45:49]
because there's accusation about water sort of poisoning
[2:45:52]
the system and, you know, let's find out if that's true.
[2:45:54]
I don't you know, I'm not sure that's that's a fact.
[2:45:57]
And so let's find out if that's true
[2:46:00]
And also looking at sort of water that's
[2:46:02]
for water that's released back into the vironment
[2:46:04]
If these data centers do that, looking at the emissions
[2:46:07]
from backup generators is monitoring the average entity,
[2:46:11]
energy use of the stack data center and other data centers
[2:46:14]
and monitoring noise levels from the testing.
[2:46:17]
So when they are going to be testing the backup generators
[2:46:19]
and the noise from equipment, that's used to cool the center
[2:46:23]
and finally looking at any increase in
[2:46:26]
and repair rates that might creep into our local electricity
[2:46:29]
rates, you know, I think there's a huge mixed review on that.
[2:46:33]
That's not an absolute let's find out if that's
[2:46:34]
happening around the country.
[2:46:35]
And if that's going to be happening here.
[2:46:37]
And those are my recommendation Thank you.
[2:46:39]
Thank you.
[2:46:40]
And before I call upon Councilmember Andrews you know,
[2:46:44]
I just wanted to edit a slightly a term
[2:46:48]
we're using the building is not the stack center.
[2:46:55]
It's called the stack.
[2:46:56]
And so I just wanted to clarify that because i know we're, you
[2:47:00]
those are two different buildings, two
[2:47:01]
different projects.
[2:47:02]
Thank you Thank you, Mayor.
[2:47:06]
Thank you.
[2:47:07]
Staff for the report.
[2:47:08]
And thank you to all the residents
[2:47:11]
who came out to speak on this issue I wanted
[2:47:14]
to thank my colleagues, Mayor Pro Tem sara and Mayor Solinas
[2:47:18]
for bringing this referral with me in All three of us
[2:47:22]
have our different reasons for bringing it.
[2:47:25]
For me.
[2:47:25]
It was to have the discussion in person in person
[2:47:31]
and for residents to have a forum and to have a discussion
[2:47:36]
and for staff to provide information to the community
[2:47:39]
directly about what happened and what our options on how we move
[2:47:43]
forward I am interested in reviewing oversight ordinance
[2:47:49]
and review of aspects of a moratorium
[2:47:52]
or find out what specifically Hayward residents do not
[2:47:56]
want to see in Hayward Currently,
[2:47:59]
these applications have to come to council.
[2:48:01]
We have already put in place where
[2:48:03]
others are trying to figure out right now
[2:48:06]
But the issue is that we didn't name it
[2:48:09]
and what are the actions we were doing
[2:48:11]
and what how were we including community input
[2:48:16]
and want to also acknowledge that the major critique
[2:48:19]
at the time we received prior to strengthening our requirements
[2:48:24]
was that we did not demand more in community benefits.
[2:48:26]
That was what we heard at the time that is what the planning
[2:48:29]
commission heard at the time.
[2:48:30]
Staff in the Planning Commission responded
[2:48:33]
by increasing the amount of community benefits we have.
[2:48:37]
The most community benefits out of our project for date
[2:48:40]
A center in the Bay Area right now after that decision,
[2:48:45]
the council acted And I want to make clear the city of Hayward
[2:48:48]
currently has the most stringent requirements
[2:48:50]
as it relates to data centers.
[2:48:52]
And we but we responded based on feedback from the community
[2:48:55]
that previous items were not heard by the full city council
[2:49:00]
First, I just want to take a moment
[2:49:02]
to acknowledge our planning commissioners.
[2:49:05]
They're not just people we appointed
[2:49:07]
They have various backgrounds, including
[2:49:09]
engineering, construction and public service,
[2:49:11]
legal in other backgrounds, but also these folks who
[2:49:15]
have dedicated their lives to public service They
[2:49:18]
are organizing cleanups around your community.
[2:49:20]
They are picking up your trash.
[2:49:23]
They're ensuring that we have libraries full of books
[2:49:26]
and resources they have dedicated
[2:49:28]
their lives to this community That's just give them
[2:49:32]
some respect.
[2:49:33]
They had a difficult decision to make,
[2:49:36]
and it was based off of the law at the time.
[2:49:40]
But back to the council in our actions,
[2:49:43]
this council in previous councils
[2:49:44]
have enacted moratoria aims that benefited the city
[2:49:48]
but it still gives future councils
[2:49:50]
a direction of how to make updates when necessary.
[2:49:53]
Due to changing technology or what
[2:49:55]
the community is willing to accept in the future
[2:50:00]
I want to be clear on another reason why I wanted this forum.
[2:50:05]
I wanted to confirm that staff properly.
[2:50:07]
Notice.
[2:50:08]
But I agree that we can do more But what I will say
[2:50:14]
is I agree with our advocate.
[2:50:16]
I agree that our applicants can do more as well
[2:50:19]
to educate the community about their projects.
[2:50:21]
And they should not rely on staff
[2:50:23]
to do this work for the development community here,
[2:50:27]
it has proven itself to be business
[2:50:29]
friendly by inviting your input into our business
[2:50:32]
friendly regulations and in fact, we
[2:50:37]
hosted the Startup World Cup in our backyard at our university.
[2:50:42]
The mayor was there I was there.
[2:50:44]
We have open arms to the business community
[2:50:47]
Let's look at this as an opportunity
[2:50:50]
an opportunity for Hayward, not to be
[2:50:52]
a roadblock, but the center on how to work with the community,
[2:50:55]
on how to move forward.
[2:50:57]
A resident a resident.
[2:50:59]
I deeply respect he said to me plainly,
[2:51:02]
Just tell me how my bill won't go up So let's
[2:51:06]
look at rate prayer project protections,
[2:51:09]
rigorous oversight and reporting show how and improvements
[2:51:14]
to our infrastructure will be paid to your project Include
[2:51:19]
labor standards workforce agreements,
[2:51:21]
and other ideas that are possible.
[2:51:24]
We understand And what businesses need is predictable.
[2:51:27]
But we should also take this time
[2:51:29]
to ensure our community knows what to expect.
[2:51:33]
Thank you.
[2:51:34]
Thank you, Councilman bob O'Neill.
[2:51:37]
Thank you, Mayor First, I also want
[2:51:39]
to say thank you all for coming out tonight
[2:51:41]
and for sharing your concerns.
[2:51:42]
I heard you.
[2:51:43]
And I think you heard from my colleagues
[2:51:45]
that we all heard you, and we share your concerns
[2:51:49]
about data centers in our communities.
[2:51:51]
I know that I share many of the concerns that
[2:51:53]
were brought up tonight.
[2:51:54]
This is our community.
[2:51:55]
I was born here too.
[2:51:57]
I'm raising my family here.
[2:51:58]
My parents are here, and we must do everything
[2:52:01]
in our power to protect our community
[2:52:02]
and to protect our residents.
[2:52:04]
And I think that's the action that you're
[2:52:06]
going to see us take tonight is to really make sure
[2:52:09]
that the concern that we heard tonight
[2:52:11]
are fully studied and addressed.
[2:52:13]
And to ensure that our community is protected.
[2:52:15]
Going forward.
[2:52:16]
I think we owe it to the community
[2:52:18]
to make sure that in some sort of consolidated way.
[2:52:21]
I get that we've made updates and changes to, you know,
[2:52:24]
ordinances into regulations, but I still
[2:52:27]
think we can do more to address the feedback that we
[2:52:29]
heard tonight.
[2:52:30]
I think we need to take a deeper look at just
[2:52:32]
an overall comprehensive responsible policy
[2:52:36]
and until we have something like that in place I
[2:52:38]
stand with my colleagues and with all of you
[2:52:40]
and saying, we need to put a stop to data centers.
[2:52:42]
We need to put a pause to them.
[2:52:44]
We need to put a moratorium in place,
[2:52:46]
and we need to really make sure that we understand
[2:52:48]
the issues around the environment
[2:52:50]
that we talked about today.
[2:52:52]
Water, air and all of those other
[2:52:54]
issues the electric demands, the potential impacts
[2:52:57]
on ratepayers noise fuel.
[2:53:00]
We talked about community health issues
[2:53:02]
that need to be addressed.
[2:53:04]
We also talked about how we need to do more from a community
[2:53:07]
engagement perspective and make sure
[2:53:08]
that we're being more meaningful in how we're engaging
[2:53:11]
the community and how we might be more broad in our engagement
[2:53:14]
to make sure that the community is voice is centered in all
[2:53:17]
of all of the decisions we make around building out
[2:53:21]
this community.
[2:53:22]
And I also agree that we need to have stronger
[2:53:25]
regulatory monitoring and oversight in place
[2:53:28]
This will help us ensure that we're not negatively impacting
[2:53:31]
our community and that the concerns that we're
[2:53:33]
hearing tonight have been appropriately mitigated.
[2:53:36]
I also agree with a comment from one
[2:53:38]
of the public commenters that said,
[2:53:40]
Let's watch these data centers like a mother hawk.
[2:53:42]
I think it's our responsibility to do that.
[2:53:45]
If they've come into our community
[2:53:46]
and they've given given us these guarantees of how they're not
[2:53:49]
going to impact our community, then I
[2:53:51]
think it's our responsibility to hold
[2:53:53]
them publicly accountable for that We
[2:53:55]
should be demanding scorecards.
[2:53:56]
The public demanding more public accountable bility and making
[2:54:00]
sure that we're holding these data
[2:54:01]
centers to do and to perform in the ways
[2:54:04]
that they've committed to doing And for these reasons, like i
[2:54:08]
said, I agree with a pause on all future data centers
[2:54:11]
until we have more of a community
[2:54:13]
driven data center policy But I really want to underscore,
[2:54:17]
I want this whatever we do in this space
[2:54:20]
to be community driven.
[2:54:21]
I want the voice of our community
[2:54:23]
to be centered in whatever policy we make.
[2:54:25]
That means we need to go out.
[2:54:26]
And we need to do town halls.
[2:54:28]
We need to validate that the issues that we're looking into
[2:54:31]
are the issues that the community has.
[2:54:33]
We need to make sure that we have the right regular actions
[2:54:35]
in place and the right standards in place
[2:54:37]
to address the community's concerns And I think all of that
[2:54:40]
needs to be consolidated into a policy that comes back
[2:54:44]
in front of this council with community input.
[2:54:46]
All of you back in front of us and say,
[2:54:48]
this policy works or it doesn't work.
[2:54:50]
And then that can be the guy that we
[2:54:52]
use to determine future data center development or not
[2:54:56]
in this community.
[2:54:58]
So I want to make sure that, you know, we
[2:54:59]
set this policy with the broadest community input
[2:55:02]
possible and that it's truly shaped by the residents
[2:55:05]
of Hayward.
[2:55:05]
And until then I would like and hold
[2:55:07]
on owning data centers in Hayward.
[2:55:09]
Thank you Thank you Mayor Pro tem, sir.
[2:55:14]
Thank you, Mayor.
[2:55:15]
Just a few clarifying questions for staff.
[2:55:17]
Can you clarify the vote threshold required
[2:55:19]
to pass the moratorium?
[2:55:21]
It said 4/5 in the slide translated to a council
[2:55:23]
of seven.
[2:55:24]
What does that vote require for this council?
[2:55:29]
For this is at least six council members.
[2:55:32]
So a moratorium It requires six out of seven US
[2:55:34]
to vote in support of it when it gets brought back.
[2:55:36]
If it gets brought back, seeing that that
[2:55:38]
seems like the majority Yes.
[2:55:39]
Direction.
[2:55:40]
OK.
[2:55:40]
Thank you Did any planning commissioners or council members
[2:55:45]
sign any NDAs related to this data center or prior data
[2:55:48]
centers Can someone in planning maybe clarify that?
[2:55:50]
Because I think that some of it's gone around too.
[2:55:52]
And I just want to people's minds not that I'm aware of.
[2:55:54]
It's not the practice to sign NDAs Great.
[2:55:58]
And then maybe for the city manager
[2:56:00]
or for planning or development services,
[2:56:02]
have other developers indicated an interest in developing data
[2:56:05]
centers in Hayward, and are they of comparable megawatts
[2:56:08]
to the Stack data center Yes, we've received interests there
[2:56:14]
They're bigger than the stack.
[2:56:16]
OK.
[2:56:17]
So First, I just want to start off
[2:56:20]
by saying thank you to everyone who wrote in,
[2:56:22]
who called in is watching online and came out in person tonight
[2:56:26]
to express their thoughts and their feelings
[2:56:28]
on data centers in Hayward.
[2:56:30]
There's been a lot of conversation
[2:56:31]
in on this issue nationwide, and I
[2:56:32]
think Hayward is bound to have this conversation This
[2:56:36]
is happening just to be clear, because
[2:56:37]
of all of your organizing and your advocacy.
[2:56:39]
So I appreciate you calling this question
[2:56:41]
and making this happen What happens tonight is also not
[2:56:45]
the end of the conversation.
[2:56:46]
This is the beginning of the conversation.
[2:56:48]
I want to thank the mayor and Councilmember
[2:56:50]
andrews for co-authoring this referral with me.
[2:56:52]
And I think what's abundantly clear from all the comments
[2:56:55]
that we've received tonight is that Hayward residents do not
[2:56:57]
want data centers.
[2:56:58]
In addition to the public comment that we received
[2:57:00]
a petition was submitted with over 2000 signatures
[2:57:03]
and we've also received dozens of emails.
[2:57:04]
On top of that, people have valid concerns
[2:57:07]
and a healthy skepticism of the billion and trillion dollar
[2:57:10]
corporations that want to use our resources for their profit.
[2:57:13]
This issue has evolved rapidly over the last year.
[2:57:16]
The definition of a data center has rapidly evolved
[2:57:19]
and the impacts of those data centers some very severe,
[2:57:22]
have varied from place to place.
[2:57:24]
All of these variables have created a climate
[2:57:27]
of anger, a frustration of mistrust
[2:57:29]
and of misinformation around what's happened in Hayward.
[2:57:32]
And I think that before we even consider the idea of a data
[2:57:35]
center, we have to work as a community
[2:57:37]
and as a council to address that And so I also believe
[2:57:40]
that that starts with hitting the brakes Just this week,
[2:57:44]
we had tech CEOs telling the country that it could kill us
[2:57:47]
by 2030.
[2:57:47]
So even they're advising, we slow down
[2:57:50]
And whether that's true or just a story
[2:57:52]
to distract their investors from the fact
[2:57:54]
that their companies aren't that profitable, The uncertainty
[2:57:57]
around the cost to ratepayers energy bills,
[2:57:59]
the regional and long term environmental and health
[2:58:01]
impacts the state legislature That's coming down
[2:58:04]
the pipeline and the possibility that we're also
[2:58:06]
in a massive economic bubble that might burst any moment.
[2:58:09]
That uncertain tea is very real.
[2:58:10]
And I think as city leaders we should be cautious.
[2:58:14]
Even Texas, of all places, has implemented
[2:58:16]
a statewide moratorium and due to how many centers
[2:58:18]
they've built because they committed more
[2:58:20]
electricity than the state can actually generate So
[2:58:23]
as one of the authors of this referral,
[2:58:25]
it sounds like we're not taking a formal vote,
[2:58:27]
but rather giving direction to staff I am in support of it,
[2:58:31]
given the time needed to develop a ban
[2:58:33]
and given that there's already interest in a data center coming
[2:58:35]
to Hayward.
[2:58:36]
I'm supportive of the urgency moratorium
[2:58:37]
because that's something that we can put in place sooner rather
[2:58:40]
than later However, I still think the idea of a ban
[2:58:42]
should remain on the table and i think
[2:58:44]
when we discuss the moratorium and I
[2:58:45]
agree with one of the callers that
[2:58:47]
said, bring it back next week is not enough time for our staff.
[2:58:50]
But I think if people want accountability, bringing it back
[2:58:53]
before the election is a very reasonable request.
[2:58:55]
I'm in support of that, too.
[2:58:56]
But when we discuss the moratorium
[2:58:57]
ahead of the election.
[2:58:58]
I think we should get really get into the weeds about what
[2:59:01]
it is exactly.
[2:59:02]
We want staff to look at while we're in that moratorium period
[2:59:05]
So should that moratorium pass?
[2:59:08]
And again, it requires Six out of seven votes.
[2:59:10]
And I hope that you will all come back to make sure
[2:59:12]
that that moratorium passes.
[2:59:15]
We should have an understanding that we have marching orders
[2:59:17]
from our community I agree with many of the ideas and demands
[2:59:21]
that were presented tonight.
[2:59:22]
We must improve our monitoring, reporting and enforcement
[2:59:25]
processes.
[2:59:25]
Maybe that's something that can also be developed concurrently
[2:59:28]
in our sustainability committee, maybe the sustainability
[2:59:30]
committee might consider meeting more frequently
[2:59:32]
to help expedite that process.
[2:59:34]
I know one of the demands in the petition
[2:59:36]
was a new community advisory panel.
[2:59:39]
I like the principle of deeper community involvement,
[2:59:41]
but we also have a very robust community Services Commission
[2:59:44]
looking for a new responsibility And maybe there's
[2:59:46]
a way to work in the Community Services Commission
[2:59:48]
as part of how we assess community benefits packages.
[2:59:51]
And again, you know, these are things
[2:59:53]
that we can consider when we have the moratorium discussion
[2:59:55]
as to what we want to develop.
[2:59:56]
But I just want to kind of help get the ideas out there.
[2:59:59]
So people can start to understand
[3:00:00]
the way i'm thinking about it I also think developing
[3:00:04]
a simple policy, preventing any council member or appointed
[3:00:06]
official from signing NDAs related to development
[3:00:08]
seems reasonable.
[3:00:09]
I know San Jose is considering this.
[3:00:11]
I think the Spotlight just published a piece on this
[3:00:13]
maybe three or four days ago.
[3:00:15]
If we're elected or appointed to represent the public interest,
[3:00:17]
the public deserves to know that, you know,
[3:00:19]
we're not signing away our ability
[3:00:21]
to share what we're learning.
[3:00:24]
These new policies and practices feel necessary,
[3:00:26]
if not a little overdue.
[3:00:28]
And i want to clarify that this is not just for data centers.
[3:00:30]
I think this is common sense for public servants
[3:00:33]
and for the benefit of the community for any industry
[3:00:35]
that residents might have concerns about in the future.
[3:00:38]
So just to summarize what I've said so far,
[3:00:40]
the moratorium comes first, and then
[3:00:42]
there's work that we should be prepared to do beyond that,
[3:00:44]
while that moratorium is active And I
[3:00:46]
want to be clear that I am committed
[3:00:48]
to extending any moratoria in as long as possible should it
[3:00:51]
pass later this year until all of these new protections
[3:00:53]
and practices that we're discussing here are in place.
[3:00:55]
And we're able to review Data Review
[3:00:58]
meaningful data from our sustainability
[3:01:00]
committee, including the cumulative impact of data
[3:01:02]
centers regionally on PGE needs grid
[3:01:04]
and how it's impacting the rate payers based on our findings,
[3:01:07]
a full ban might make complete sense, which is why it remains
[3:01:10]
on the table for me and in the meantime,
[3:01:13]
I think the moratorium allows us to block new data
[3:01:15]
centers from opening sooner while we worked
[3:01:16]
to get handle on the ones that have already been approved.
[3:01:19]
While minimize the fiscal and legal liability to the city
[3:01:22]
I think that's the extent of my comments.
[3:01:24]
But I want to say thank you again
[3:01:25]
to everyone who has spoken up on this issue.
[3:01:27]
Your advocacy is why we're having this conversation today
[3:01:29]
and this is this conversation is far from over.
[3:01:31]
Thank you.
[3:01:33]
Thank you Council member Golden.
[3:01:38]
Thank you.
[3:01:40]
He really does deserve the applause.
[3:01:43]
He puts a lot of thought and effort into it,
[3:01:45]
and he does really great job articulating it.
[3:01:48]
I'm i'm going to be a little quieter
[3:01:49]
and maybe not talk on everything that you brought forward,
[3:01:54]
but let me just start off by telling you how much I
[3:01:57]
appreciate you showing up your emails,
[3:02:01]
your phone calls I really appreciate it.
[3:02:05]
In the reason that I appreciate it is we work hard all of us
[3:02:10]
live here in the city.
[3:02:12]
We have to.
[3:02:12]
That's one of the rules.
[3:02:13]
And you know, I live here, raise my family here.
[3:02:17]
We drink the water, here we breathe the air.
[3:02:21]
But that doesn't mean we know everything.
[3:02:24]
And so when you folks are coming forward and raising issues,
[3:02:29]
sometimes we know, sometimes we don't.
[3:02:31]
And there's a lot of information that's
[3:02:34]
flowing around the Internet right now.
[3:02:36]
It sounds really scary.
[3:02:39]
And I could not tell you at the beginning of that conver
[3:02:42]
sation a couple of months ago, six months ago,
[3:02:45]
or whenever it really started, I could not
[3:02:47]
tell you with certainty that any of it was real or not real.
[3:02:52]
I didn't know.
[3:02:53]
So what I'm getting at here is that we
[3:02:58]
do need to slow down, take the time to make sure
[3:03:02]
that the information that we have is accurate
[3:03:05]
and more importantly that we're articulating accurately
[3:03:09]
to you, giving you an opportunity
[3:03:10]
to hear what's going on, why we're making
[3:03:14]
these decisions that we make.
[3:03:15]
And I'm not just talking about data centers
[3:03:17]
and whatever the next thing is, is
[3:03:19]
going to happen here in Hayward because we're
[3:03:21]
right in the middle of everything.
[3:03:23]
We're the heart of the bay right?
[3:03:25]
So we owe it to you.
[3:03:27]
And we want to do that when I signed up for this to be a city
[3:03:33]
council member in fact, before that,
[3:03:35]
when I was on planning commission, openness
[3:03:38]
and transparency was something I absolutely committed to.
[3:03:42]
And so I promise you.
[3:03:43]
We are going to do that.
[3:03:45]
And so I'm in favor of a moratorium
[3:03:49]
because I believe it'll give us all time
[3:03:52]
to investigate further the things that we think we know.
[3:03:57]
Take the edge is right.
[3:03:59]
There might be things that we really don't.
[3:04:02]
And give us some time to look at that
[3:04:05]
but then also look at the things that we absolutely don't know.
[3:04:07]
A couple of speakers brought up about how I data centers are
[3:04:14]
being used for surveillance and the human impact
[3:04:17]
you know, I didn't think about that.
[3:04:18]
I'm just being honest with you.
[3:04:19]
I didn't think about that.
[3:04:21]
But we ought to we ought to be thinking
[3:04:23]
about the human impact of not just a high,
[3:04:27]
but data centers generally You know, I work in i.t.
[3:04:32]
My day job and you know, the benefit that I see
[3:04:36]
is that the younger engineers are actually
[3:04:40]
becoming more expert faster and, and so there
[3:04:45]
are some good that I see it I'm not defending anybody here.
[3:04:49]
I'm just saying I see some good but at the same time,
[3:04:54]
I don't know where the blind spots are.
[3:04:56]
And so I'm in favor of the moratorium
[3:04:58]
to give us the time to investigate
[3:05:01]
those blind spots We're also working very
[3:05:05]
closely with our state where just Slater there
[3:05:08]
are currently in the process.
[3:05:09]
I think there's 7 or 8 bills that are about to be signed
[3:05:13]
and and they range from, you know,
[3:05:16]
more monitoring and enforcement, more
[3:05:19]
transparency to the ratepayer protections really strikes
[3:05:23]
a nerve, doesn't it Right.
[3:05:25]
And we want that.
[3:05:26]
And so we are working with our with our partners in the state
[3:05:30]
legislature to make sure you get that here in our conversations,
[3:05:36]
we've been, you know, very much committed
[3:05:39]
to having more community engagement
[3:05:42]
and striving for monitoring and reporting public dashboard,
[3:05:47]
for example.
[3:05:47]
So you can see what we see And, of course, at any time,
[3:05:52]
if you're seeing stuff that we're not seeing, make us aware.
[3:05:54]
If we don't know, we don't know And that's
[3:05:58]
the value of having you participate
[3:06:00]
in this process with us.
[3:06:01]
And that's why we appreciate it.
[3:06:04]
But I do have a couple of questions.
[3:06:06]
So we're a couple metrics.
[3:06:09]
So we're brought forward that were absolutely stunning to me
[3:06:14]
the first time I heard them.
[3:06:15]
And so i did a little investigating in already
[3:06:18]
know the answer to the question, but for your benefit,
[3:06:20]
I'm going to ask the experts and they're going to tell you.
[3:06:23]
And so one of the metrics was if I heard it correctly,
[3:06:27]
was 9.7 to acre feet of water consumed daily.
[3:06:34]
Had you had you heard that one?
[3:06:36]
Anyone on staff No.
[3:06:39]
I mean, we I can give you the information on the stock
[3:06:42]
if you would like.
[3:06:44]
Yeah.
[3:06:44]
So, so the stack data center was accused
[3:06:47]
of for allegedly using over a million gallons a day of water.
[3:06:55]
Can you just comment on the total water use?
[3:06:57]
Yes So based on the study that we have that was done
[3:07:01]
in compliance with the state environmental laws,
[3:07:04]
the anticipated water use is 172,000 173,000 gallons was
[3:07:12]
for a 24 hour period, which translates to about 3 million
[3:07:16]
gallons per year compared to a standard home,
[3:07:20]
which is 300 or 400 gallons daily.
[3:07:23]
So the data centers annual water use
[3:07:25]
is equivalent to about 28 households.
[3:07:28]
Water use in a year.
[3:07:30]
Okay And that water use that you're describing,
[3:07:34]
is it only dedicated to the data center operation
[3:07:38]
or does that include, you know, toilets,
[3:07:41]
landscaping Do you know what the breakdown assume
[3:07:44]
it's everything.
[3:07:45]
Yeah Total water use.
[3:07:47]
Okay.
[3:07:47]
So I saw a metric somewhere that it was like half and half So
[3:07:52]
about half of that was for landscape mapping
[3:07:54]
and Yeah, I don't have that breakdown,
[3:07:57]
but the total use is about 3 million gallons per year.
[3:07:59]
OK.
[3:08:00]
All right.
[3:08:00]
So sorry I cut you off guard.
[3:08:02]
I thought we had that one too I beg your pardon for that The one
[3:08:07]
thing that comes up in Converse asian a couple of times
[3:08:10]
was about low frequency noise and I don't recall seeing that
[3:08:14]
in the Amanda or anywhere else.
[3:08:17]
Do you know if that has been studied
[3:08:21]
that isn't studied under secure, under noise impacts?
[3:08:24]
It's it's not analyzed.
[3:08:26]
It's not there's nothing in the checklist
[3:08:28]
about that particular frequency.
[3:08:30]
Okay.
[3:08:31]
And then One of the so that's something
[3:08:34]
that we could look into for sure.
[3:08:36]
And then one more question, and that
[3:08:38]
is around the around the energy use
[3:08:42]
there's been some concern that the huge amount of energy
[3:08:46]
that they're going to use is just going to completely pollute
[3:08:50]
our skies and so forth.
[3:08:52]
Can you can you talk about the energy record Fireman's Yeah,
[3:08:56]
there required to use 100% renewable energy OK.
[3:09:02]
And do you know approximately the percentage
[3:09:05]
is of renewable energy production?
[3:09:07]
Yeah, it's just about 77% solar and about 23% wind.
[3:09:12]
Okay.
[3:09:13]
All right Very good.
[3:09:14]
So.
[3:09:14]
So solar and wind and to our knowledge,
[3:09:18]
those things don't actually produce noxious fumes
[3:09:22]
or exhaust or no.
[3:09:26]
OK.
[3:09:26]
I'm asking the obvious question because a couple people heard
[3:09:29]
me say that and they just didn't want to believe it.
[3:09:33]
But it's required.
[3:09:35]
It's and it's in the documentation.
[3:09:37]
You can read it for yourself online
[3:09:40]
So we are going to do more and i again,
[3:09:44]
am in favor of taking the steps we need to do that.
[3:09:49]
Thank you.
[3:09:52]
Thank you.
[3:09:53]
Councilmember interested?
[3:09:54]
Oh, I just saw your name up there.
[3:09:56]
Wasn't sure.
[3:09:57]
OK.
[3:09:57]
OK So.
[3:10:01]
So I think we have you know, direction moratorium
[3:10:09]
or and then or do you want to summarize or direction.
[3:10:13]
Come back with a moratorium.
[3:10:15]
You know, I'll you know I think with what Mayor pro tem
[3:10:21]
Sara brought to us was, you know, keep a ban on the table
[3:10:29]
and but you know first a moratorium
[3:10:33]
and then as we talk about that then we can know certainly
[3:10:36]
not exclude that and not have that While we do that,
[3:10:43]
we will focus on three areas either tweaking what we have
[3:10:48]
enhancing editing or adding in the areas of change, more
[3:10:53]
transparency, higher levels of accountability and greater
[3:10:57]
community benefits And so that's what I heard.
[3:11:04]
I don't know if you heard more.
[3:11:05]
Yeah, that's correct.
[3:11:06]
So we'll come back in late October
[3:11:09]
or with a proposed emergency more tauriel urgency moratorium.
[3:11:17]
And then as mayor Pro Tem Sara said,
[3:11:20]
it would be great if at that meeting you know,
[3:11:23]
have council, provide some direction
[3:11:25]
as to what you want us to study and do during that.
[3:11:28]
In addition to obviously the some of the we've
[3:11:31]
already heard you and heard the community about monitor
[3:11:34]
and some of the stuff from existing data centers.
[3:11:36]
But try to flesh that out a little more at the meeting.
[3:11:38]
And when we come back i do think we have talked to see attorney.
[3:11:42]
I think we would like a vote would be great tonight.
[3:11:47]
Tonight on the dining direction option.
[3:11:49]
So it's obviously, it's not a just for clarity.
[3:11:52]
Sure you're not enacting a moratorium tonight
[3:11:55]
you're not this doesn't have the weight of an ordinance.
[3:11:58]
But it does provide the community and the staff,
[3:12:01]
the clear direction to move forward
[3:12:03]
with a temporary moratorium.
[3:12:05]
OK.
[3:12:05]
I'll move the item.
[3:12:06]
Okay.
[3:12:07]
So moved by Councilmember or Mayor Pro tem Sara
[3:12:12]
I'll second the item So moved by Mayor Pro Tem Sara
[3:12:17]
to come back with a moratorium with the items
[3:12:20]
that we just outlined.
[3:12:21]
And then second by Mayor Salinas.
[3:12:25]
And if there are no objections, it will unanimously pass
[3:12:30]
and congratulations.
[3:12:31]
Thank you.
[3:12:31]
Okay.
[3:12:33]
So i really miss him.
[3:12:38]
To be clear to you, support for you or Tory, ma'am.
[3:12:43]
Now, where, where, where I think we're going to be staff
[3:12:48]
has heard us, the staff, as going to respond.
[3:12:51]
And we will be working with staff moving forward.
[3:12:54]
Okay ?
[3:12:57]
OK.
[3:12:58]
I would.
[3:12:59]
OK.
[3:12:59]
If we go i'm it's not popping up for me, but I'm a yes vote Okay.
[3:13:06]
So.
[3:13:07]
All right Did you refer Yes, You got it.
[3:13:18]
OK Okay And the motion passes with Seven yeses.
[3:13:26]
OK.
[3:13:27]
Moving on to this.
[3:13:30]
Was our last item Moving on to adjournment.
[3:13:35]
Our next meeting will be October 6th, 2026 at 7 p.m..
[3:13:41]
Thank you for coming out.
[3:13:42]
Meeting adjourned For the Final Five days.
[3:16:17]
And so We had a public comment on That.
[3:17:06]
So I will say that we could have had it still be
[3:17:29]
and that's why I just great.
[3:17:48]
I thought that we decided our 33 yeah Right now i'm yeah, I
[3:18:23]
I feel like if you have a young right.