Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[0:00]
Okay, we're going to, excuse me, call the meeting to order for the Advisory Screening Committee for City Attorney Tuesday, November 17, 2026.
[0:14]
Ms. Jones. Mr. Clayton.
[0:17]
Mr. Cranky. Mr. Sterling.
[0:20]
Ms. Sivisma. Mr. Ubersayer.
[0:24]
Chair Smith.
[0:26]
No further record that Chairman Smith's absence is excused to a family medical matter.
[0:34]
And do the pledge of allegiance
[0:38]
to the flag of the United States of America and to the public for
[0:44]
which it says, one nation under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for
[0:52]
our right.
[0:56]
And then observe microphone etiquette by turning that off during.
[1:00]
And then look at the little sign.
[1:03]
Okay, so the first thing we have is approval of the agenda.
[1:06]
And I believe that the city clerk will be asking us
[1:10]
to remove item number three as an action item since Mr.
[1:15]
and Felder as apparently with John his consideration.
[1:19]
That's correct.
[1:21]
Okay.
[1:21]
That's what's wrong.
[1:23]
So is there a motion to approve the agenda as amended?
[1:28]
So moved.
[1:29]
So second.
[1:30]
Second.
[1:31]
Who've been seconded?
[1:33]
All in favor.
[1:35]
Hi.
[1:36]
Hi.
[1:36]
You know, require a roll call for that.
[1:38]
No.
[1:38]
Okay.
[1:41]
Next is approval of approval of the minutes.
[1:44]
I had one comment on them.
[1:48]
It did say we had a discussion at the first meeting, which of course we did, but we also
[1:55]
had a very specific discussion about the conversation that I had with County Attorney
[2:00]
Bob Schilinger, who offered to volunteer and come and give the committee a presentation on
[2:06]
lack of the Florida Association of County attorneys and what they do and my understanding was
[2:13]
the committee was receptive to it and now the Bridget has provided us with some information on that
[2:18]
but I think it should still be in the record that we had that specific discussion and I think the
[2:25]
imitation should go out so that would be my suggestion for the minutes I would concur.
[2:33]
Okay. I mean, we do action minutes here. So we don't we don't transcribe or take notes on what's discussed during discussion items understood. So could we could we add it since I think it was the understanding collected understanding of the board that we would make that invitation.
[2:52]
I could add it in this motion to approve. Yeah, I mean, be sure. Okay.
[2:59]
All right. So there's motion, proven and seconded.
[3:04]
Well, do we have a first?
[3:08]
All right.
[3:09]
I'll make a motion to approve.
[3:11]
I can second.
[3:12]
Move.
[3:13]
And second.
[3:13]
Sorry.
[3:13]
A little out of practice at this turn.
[3:15]
All in favor.
[3:18]
Aye.
[3:19]
Any opposed?
[3:21]
Okay.
[3:22]
Minutes are approved with the notation.
[3:26]
All right.
[3:27]
And the first item on the agenda is an action item which is number two.
[3:33]
And I am as sitting chair going to make a ruling based on the city attorneys opinion that the item is out of order, and I would like to read into the record why because I am certainly no parliamentarian, but there was some significant communication with the clerk and with the city attorneys office, I think it's important that it's in the record.
[4:00]
So, and also, Mayor Kaufman, who's here today, had submitted some specific questions to the city of turning, and she answered those in detail as well.
[4:15]
So, basically what she said was, what prohibits another election while the officers are filled, and she said, the committee elected as chair and vice chair on October 20, both accepted and both are serving.
[4:29]
Section 2, 283 of the City Code, which is the enabling legislation for this committee as I understand it, requires a committee to elect a chair and a vice chair annually.
[4:40]
It doesn't use the word shout.
[4:42]
Neither the code nor the committee is establishing resolution addresses another election while the offices are filled, a term of office or removal, where they are silent robber rules and order governments.
[4:56]
Under Robert's rules, a completed election cannot be...
[5:00]
Reconcited or resented, once the person elected has accepted, and she cited the Roberts specific rules.
[5:08]
She does say that she agrees with the mayor that the 2023 amendment to this enabling code sets a minimum, not a maximum,
[5:17]
and she went on to say the committee may hold an election to fill a vacancy at any time. The amendment does not, however, authorize a new election
[5:27]
while both officers' offices are filled.
[5:32]
She went on to say, what are the officers' terms
[5:33]
and how could an officer be removed
[5:35]
and she'd refer to the same section 2283
[5:39]
that provides for annual elections,
[5:41]
and neither the code nor the resolution says more
[5:43]
about officers' terms,
[5:45]
a body that wants different officers
[5:47]
must remove the sitting officers by a separate motion.
[5:51]
It cannot simply hold another election.
[5:54]
She went on to cite the pertinent provisions of Robert's rules of order.
[5:59]
The vote required depends on how the term is defined.
[6:03]
She wanted to find that either way, she said removal requires notice.
[6:09]
Chair Smith cannot attend today's meeting because of his wife's surgery in Miami.
[6:14]
If the committee were to consider removing him, he would need notice of that motion and the opportunity to be present.
[6:23]
I think this is the first time I've been in a committee where I've ruled something out of order,
[6:29]
but that's my ruling as chair for those reasons based on the city attorney's opinion.
[6:38]
That's me.
[6:40]
Mr. Cranky.
[6:43]
I think you did very well without being a parliamentarian actually.
[6:49]
While I don't believe it is required to have a reason for placing an item on the agenda.
[6:54]
I kind of feel, you know, because we all live here, I would like to express why.
[7:02]
First, it's not about me, I do not wish the chair seat, in fact, if anybody is thinking about nominating me, you can pass that to another.
[7:11]
This comes from, in a perfect world, we would have convened this committee, they would have convened this committee after the election of District 4 Commissioner.
[7:21]
For me, out of respect for now, Commissioner Compton, and her appointee Ashley, we are fully
[7:30]
seated with Commissioner Compton's appointee here.
[7:34]
And I'm even further removed from the Roberts rules than you would be, Mr. Clintonick.
[7:41]
But I think it's a fair and practical observation to consider Commissioner Compton and her
[7:49]
pointy to be here when we see chair and vice chair positions. And that is the sole purpose
[7:55]
for doing this. I do not seek or want the chair position. And your right, Mary and
[8:02]
Downs did in fact state that there is a minimum but not a maximum. And given that there
[8:07]
is not a maximum. And this is not an agenda item to remove either your Mr. Smith. This is
[8:14]
simply a re-election now fully seated with Commissioner Compton and the constituents of district
[8:19]
for who put her there.
[8:22]
I would like to proceed with that, and I will appeal to your ruling if someone would
[8:28]
second that and we proceed with the vote for election.
[8:36]
I'll second the appeal.
[8:37]
Okay, so I guess the question is shall the decision of the chair be sustained?
[8:44]
Mr. Cranky said, yes, who second it?
[8:47]
Actually, actually second it.
[8:52]
I don't really have a lot to say. I think we should I think we should call it a law
[8:56]
I believe any time you're on a committee if you're just going to have elections all the time. It's it's going to be
[9:03]
more
[9:04]
annoying than helpful. I'm on this committee to focus on the substance of what's happening
[9:09]
I don't think a person who's presiding over the meeting has any more power than anybody else sitting here
[9:14]
They don't I mean they are simply they are simply running the meeting
[9:18]
I think to just decide we want to have elections more frequently doesn't really make a lot
[9:24]
of sense.
[9:25]
I think it's very fair that if Ashley or anybody else on this board feels that any of us
[9:33]
are not doing their job, then I think you should move to under the proper procedures to
[9:41]
remove them.
[9:42]
And that would be totally fair.
[9:44]
I think that would make a lot of sense.
[9:49]
I actually don't disagree with much of what you said, and this isn't about removing anyone for not performing.
[9:55]
This is about that for me, and this is my agenda item, so I can speak for me.
[10:00]
This is about the constituents, in district four, who voted for a commissioner, who subsequently appointed someone to this panel, who should have the opportunity, at least to nominate, and vote for chair and vice chair. I'm not suggesting anybody hasn't done their job. In fact, on the contrary, I would never state that. And that's what it's about for me.
[10:21]
Is there a way to get to become this?
[10:27]
I am sympathetic to the Democratic argument.
[10:31]
I actually was, my preferred candidate for the chair was you,
[10:36]
because I thought it represented the electorate's decision
[10:40]
city wide at that time.
[10:42]
However, I am curious to hear basically
[10:45]
at this juncture what the procedural mechanism
[10:48]
and the vehicle is to allow a new election, because based upon the email that I received,
[10:56]
it's been recited mostly by the attorney, it seems that unless there was a recall that
[11:03]
the procedural mechanism doesn't exist at this time, unless somebody could explain to me how
[11:09]
to re-litigate that action item from the last meeting. It seems if the procedural mechanism doesn't
[11:18]
exist and frankly don't have that wide of an applicant pull right now.
[11:25]
Related getting this issue might not really be fruitful for the future of binding candidates and holding meetings.
[11:37]
That seems to make sense and also, you know, if we're going to participate in something that is very out of the ordinary like this,
[11:46]
I think it would be more than fair for Chairman Smith to be here and to be able to participate.
[11:55]
I feel bad that Tracy's life is, you know, of course having the medical emergency that she is,
[12:02]
obviously Sean needs to be there and not here.
[12:05]
But that makes it even worse that we're going to seem, you know, we're having this discussion,
[12:12]
This action item when we really need to be focusing on the business of what we're doing, especially finding candidates and how to do that when he's not here.
[12:24]
So is there any other discussion on the appeal of the chairs ruling that the matter was out of order?
[12:37]
I actually had two questions, because I am also not a parliamentarian, but I did review the
[12:43]
Robert tools of order, and I had questions about under section 2, 2, 8, 4, what meeting
[12:48]
procedures has this screening committee formally adopted, and does that establish a resolution
[12:55]
addressing the officers terms or removal, and then given the exact text of section 2, 2, 8,
[13:02]
three, what authority governs removal or replacement of the officers and what vote and notice
[13:08]
would be required? Those are my two primary questions.
[13:13]
Okay, so I'm going to defer to the clerk on some of those questions. I'm going to look back.
[13:17]
I printed some of the city attorney's emails I don't have. I don't have all of them because
[13:26]
she did address that specifically,
[13:33]
and let me just say
[13:37]
amount of clerk, why don't you go ahead?
[13:40]
I don't have her email right in front of me, but I think to answer your question, we do
[13:47]
not have a guiding principle around officers, you know, there's nothing in our code that talks
[13:55]
about what happens once the chair is a site?
[14:00]
We do have the adoption of robber's rules of order.
[14:03]
Yes, of course.
[14:04]
I do know the one section, the attorney referenced in terms of removal, well, actually, the
[14:12]
first part, she's talking about rescinding or amending something previously determined, which
[14:19]
is actually not this agenda item.
[14:20]
This agenda item is calling for a new election.
[14:23]
So, I don't know that what she's referenced in there is relative, and then the only other thing that I had noticed on this removal of office for officers under 62 16, this is talking about elected officers of a permanent society, and this board would be rolled more under special committee rules or small board.
[14:53]
So what I'm seeing that she's referencing, it doesn't quite hit what is happening.
[15:00]
You know what you've put on the agenda.
[15:05]
Okay.
[15:06]
Although I am sympathetic to Ashley and Spencer's argument that she is newly on the committee, I think in that same vein, Sean is not here.
[15:18]
And this discussion is kind of in my mind, not appropriate right now.
[15:24]
If you want to have the discussion, it should be had when there's a full committee here.
[15:29]
And I really agree with Richard that we really need to focus on the issue at hand and try and move this forward because we don't have a lot of options in front of us and need to start figuring it that out quickly.
[15:45]
Thank you.
[15:46]
Thank you.
[15:47]
Yes.
[15:47]
Special.
[15:49]
So, best intended plans, I did not when we, when I placed the agenda item and again, specifically
[15:57]
out of respect for the election in District 4 and for Ashley in the Democratic process, right?
[16:03]
I was not aware that Sean would not be here today, so that sort of came after, but I am actually
[16:11]
sympathetic to your point.
[16:14]
with that dynamic, it does change things, and perhaps there's a way to be more fair, because, again, I'm not advocating for myself, I'm advocating for district force, commissioners, appointment here, on the matter.
[16:28]
I have touched on something which seems to be a lack of clarity on is this appropriate, when seating a new appointee, and maybe that's something that maybe in the future can be worked out if this happens again.
[16:43]
If I'm not mistaken, but I'm open to suggestions on how to handle this in Sean's absence.
[16:49]
Well, I have one.
[16:52]
Since apparently we can continue to, at least at a gender this, we should deny the appeal.
[17:02]
And if you would like to bring it up again, then we can bring it up again.
[17:09]
But I would feel same as Erica and Spencer said, pretty poorly to have this discussion
[17:18]
and even doing this without Mr. Smith here.
[17:21]
I just, I think it's plain wrong.
[17:24]
But in any event, do you have any other?
[17:26]
Yeah, I'm not suggesting we have a vote.
[17:29]
And I understand the position that Mr. Smith is not here.
[17:31]
My question was, what is the procedure?
[17:34]
Because I think Spencer just clarified, we don't have clarity on that.
[17:37]
And so, I think having an understanding, I think this discussion is appropriate, and-
[17:42]
Sorry, you mean about an election?
[17:45]
You stated at the beginning when you were citing Ms. Down's email that it wouldn't be
[17:50]
proper to have another election because there would first need to be a removal.
[17:53]
There would need to be an absence of that officer to have a second election.
[17:56]
My question was specific to what authority governs removal or replacement of the officers
[18:02]
and I haven't heard that.
[18:03]
And I think that that information would help guide us on whether this should be tabled,
[18:08]
whether it should be denied, whether it should be read up in a different way.
[18:11]
It seems like a very procedural issue that needs clarification before we can move forward.
[18:18]
Well, I know there are certain there are definitely procedures for removing officers
[18:26]
moving members from any board.
[18:29]
I think what we need to do today is vote on this.
[18:34]
we're spending half an hour on something where if we want to have another election we
[18:38]
can have another election one chance here because what happens now today is that if the
[18:46]
as I understand it and correct me if I'm wrong, Gary, if Mr.
[18:56]
Cranky's appeal is sustained
[18:59]
and the challenge to my ruling is sustained,
[19:06]
then we are supposed to have another election right now.
[19:10]
That wouldn't necessarily be true.
[19:12]
That just means this stays on the agenda.
[19:14]
So other motions could come forward to postpone it.
[19:18]
You wouldn't have to, all that would happen
[19:21]
is your ruling would be overturned.
[19:24]
Okay, let me make sure I'm reading her email correctly.
[19:30]
just give me a minute here. So let's see. So I specifically asked her, what happens if this
[19:37]
ruling comes up? Because this is the first, this is the first for me to be honest. So we had the,
[19:44]
we had the appeal vote, we had a motion, okay? It's debatable, it passes by a majority vote.
[19:50]
Nobody makes a motion or it fails. The officers, the officers, they are. If it passes, conduct,
[19:57]
the election. Take nominations for children.
[20:00]
Mayor, then vote, a majority of the votes cast, elex, and repeat for the vice chair. So what the city attorney
[20:09]
is opining is that we conduct that new election now, and when we would be doing that without Mr. Smith.
[20:16]
Well, I think she's assuming that that's what you would want to do, but you guys decide what you want to do.
[20:21]
So what's on the table right now is a motion to appeal your decision. If that passes, all that means,
[20:29]
is that this item goes forward on the agenda.
[20:33]
Now, then anything else can happen.
[20:36]
So, like I said, somebody can make a motion to postpone.
[20:38]
Someone can make a motion to go forward with the election.
[20:42]
All that's happening right now is you guys
[20:44]
are debating whether this item should even arise.
[20:48]
We're all right.
[20:49]
All right.
[20:49]
So, one would call the question.
[20:53]
I mean, I'm going to hold off on calling the question for another.
[20:57]
Oh, I'm sorry.
[20:58]
I'm sorry.
[21:00]
I'm going to I'm actually going to try to make this easier because now you understand my intent or at least I hope you do.
[21:07]
I would just ask since this is open debate and actually this is for you because I'm sorry this whole thing was for you or your commissioner rather.
[21:15]
Is it important for you to nominate and vote on a chair and vice chair position?
[21:21]
I think it's important for me to fulfill Commissioner Compton's wishes and I think that
[21:28]
every part of that committee involves that and so I think my vote on the chair and vice
[21:33]
chair would be important. However, as Mr. Sterling and Mr. Clinton both pointed out, my main
[21:38]
goal here is to help this committee find acceptable candidates for the City Attorney position.
[21:48]
Thank you. Anyone else have any other discussion before we call the question?
[21:52]
Should we call the question please?
[21:56]
Okay, so this is a motion to overrule the chairs
[22:00]
Rolling Miss Jones
[22:08]
Mr. Cranky.
[22:12]
I'm sorry, yes would be for my appeal to uphold the appeal.
[22:16]
Yes.
[22:18]
Miss Sterling.
[22:19]
Now.
[22:20]
Miss Abesma.
[22:21]
Yes.
[22:22]
Mr. Ubershare.
[22:26]
Chair Clinton.
[22:26]
No.
[22:27]
Okay, so that's a tie and the tie would go to the motion fields.
[22:32]
Now that we have that bit of fun business out of the way and thank you all, sorry, thank
[22:39]
you all for the for the insightful comments and yeah for having a fun review the last
[22:48]
day or so of Robert's rules, which I can tell you if you are having trouble sleeping, just
[23:03]
Next item, we don't have any other action items, then.
[23:07]
We have reports, so I don't know that we have any reports, except for, do we have anything?
[23:17]
I know that you had provided the FACA outline to us by email.
[23:22]
Yes, Mr. Chair.
[23:24]
The only reports we have is, as I briefed everyone yesterday, Mr. Eschenfelder, with
[23:31]
through his application, he was our fully qualified applicant.
[23:35]
We did have a second applicant, Mr. Williams.
[23:39]
That was emailed to you all I believe about two weeks ago.
[23:42]
He does have Florida government experience.
[23:47]
There was a question posed in an email to me about what determined
[23:52]
if someone was qualified or unqualified.
[23:57]
Direction from the commission was that we should provide you
[24:00]
those that were qualified and that included significant, at least practicing law for seven years
[24:07]
and significant local or governmental experience and Florida Bart. The two applicants we have
[24:16]
that have been placed as unqualified were provided to you with information if you'd like to review them.
[24:21]
One is an attorney with bankruptcy and real estate experience, no governmental experience at all.
[24:32]
So he was deemed unqualified. The other is a military attorney with some federal experience, but no local government experience and that's why he was deemed unqualified.
[24:44]
I just wanted to at this point tell you all how I came to that decision if at any point in time
[24:51]
I provide you with the matrix that has all the names you may always request their resume and things my job is to
[25:00]
I want to have one request on the Matrix. I don't know about anybody else, but I cannot read four point
[25:06]
type. It is tiny. I can make it big. Can you please? Yes, I can make it bigger. I even had my assistant
[25:12]
try to reform it. I have it here and I have my glasses on so I can get close to reading it. It'd be a challenge
[25:19]
at first, although I do know I didn't know what's on there. I was trying to make it so it shows on a screen, but I can
[25:25]
I definitely make it bigger.
[25:27]
I promise.
[25:28]
I just like the opportunity to give you a hard time.
[25:33]
I figure if I can't have fun at any of this stuff anymore,
[25:35]
I'm going to retire, which anyway.
[25:38]
One of the concerns that I did discuss with Vice Mayor Lee
[25:44]
is that I believe that at least heat would
[25:49]
like to see all the applicants that apply.
[25:53]
So I mean, I would mind seeing them either.
[25:55]
I mean, who knows, someone maybe has, you know,
[25:59]
doesn't have seven years of experience but has five,
[26:02]
but it's really significant, you know, you never know.
[26:06]
So I think it would be great for us to see everybody.
[26:11]
So that is why everyone has included on the spreadsheet.
[26:14]
If you would like their full entire package
[26:16]
from the application that includes the resume,
[26:18]
I can also include those too.
[26:20]
Sure.
[26:21]
Yeah, oh, and I have one other suggestion
[26:23]
before I forget, you know, I'm 63, if I don't look at these thoughts out, they kind of just go away.
[26:29]
Sorry, that come out. I thought it was inside work.
[26:35]
One thing I would like you to change on or a suggested change is, it seems like something simple, but
[26:52]
The attorneys have their work emails that are on their Florida bar, you know, you can
[27:01]
pull up the Florida bar website and find them easily.
[27:04]
That is also included with the materials that we get, of course, to show that they're an
[27:10]
active member of the Florida bar.
[27:13]
I can tell you that I did email one of these candidates, basically as an introduction and invitation
[27:20]
to a discussion,
[27:25]
and unfortunately, it wasn't super happy that it went to his work email
[27:29]
because he hadn't talked to his people yet.
[27:34]
And you know what I said was, I apologize and said, listen, I'm sorry, you know, I didn't
[27:39]
see that on the top of the application, there was not one on your resume, but it was on the
[27:48]
you know, preferred, you know, preferred email only or or something, something like that.
[27:55]
Does that make sense?
[27:56]
Yes.
[27:57]
I can definitely work to figure out that most of the time because many of them have litigation
[28:05]
or city attorney status, their personally emails are private and PII, so I try not to email them out.
[28:12]
So I will definitely find a way to exchange those with you all and ensure that we continue to follow
[28:18]
Thank you.
[28:19]
I mean, there was no problem.
[28:21]
There was just kind of a concern.
[28:27]
And while we're kind of getting before public comment, I do want to say, I did
[28:34]
have the opportunity to speak to Mr. Aston Felder, who withdrew.
[28:39]
This week or whatever he withdrew, I think, sponsored you, spoke to him and the Tyler
[28:45]
also.
[28:46]
And frankly, I was really sorry to see that he withdrew because I couldn't believe that we had some, but that good of an applicant.
[28:57]
I mean, he was exceptionally qualified, exceptionally experienced, exceptionally well-spoken.
[29:05]
It was very, you know, was a very nice, really, really nice conversation.
[29:11]
Maybe he's watching the meetings.
[29:12]
I'm going to reconsider.
[29:14]
I'm going to change his mind.
[29:16]
Oh no, who knows?
[29:19]
But yeah, I know he and apparently he and his wife really enjoyed Key West.
[29:23]
He might have had a little sticker shock on the price of real estate.
[29:31]
But any of it.
[29:32]
So any other reports that we have?
[29:36]
I just want to say I also had a good conversation with Mr.
[29:40]
So, he did express, I think, at the end of the conversation, a little bit of the housing is what
[29:48]
housing is in a key west, and so it's expensive.
[29:51]
So, not sure if that's the reason why he withdrew his application.
[29:55]
But I liked the answers that he provided as experiences for...
[30:00]
Good. I just want to tell the other members that I did think it was important that when I provided
[30:07]
him questions or hypotheticals, I did like that he centered, basically the commissions response as a
[30:18]
democratic body rather than their own policy decisions, his own policy preferences. And so I think
[30:26]
He just took a lot of experience of professionals
[30:29]
and from this 25 plus years of service
[30:32]
in a city attorney work, or other wife.
[30:37]
So if we could find another applicant like that,
[30:39]
I think that would be great.
[30:40]
Yeah, somebody of that understands how to work
[30:42]
between departments, I mean,
[30:43]
having talk, talking to another attorney
[30:46]
who is really conversant in comp plans
[30:50]
and how they relate to LDRs with handling
[30:56]
a myriad of different litigation matters that irrespective of this particular
[31:00]
candidates that is the type of person that we are looking for someone that
[31:04]
has significant experience and contract work and everything that goes into
[31:11]
it into a city and especially when you have one one sometimes you know some
[31:14]
departments don't don't agree and you can only advise the commission you know
[31:18]
what the legal opinion is and the departments are going to do what they're
[31:22]
But in that vein, you know, I guess I can use this under, you know, our our common is my suggestion would be, you know, if we can make that suggestion to the city commission would be to go out at 250,000 instead of 200, because I think to get someone of the caliber that we are that we are looking for to ask them to come in to this job.
[31:52]
And probably take a 50% pay cut if they have this type of experience and come in to probably at least double or triple the cost of living.
[32:02]
I think it would make sense and probably hopefully be attractive for other, you know, for other applicants.
[32:10]
But with that said, do we have public?
[32:12]
We do.
[32:13]
We do.
[32:13]
We have actually mayor Kaufman and then Leon Moere.
[32:27]
Mr. Mayor.
[32:29]
I'm going to go back to bed, but I do have to set the timer.
[32:35]
I'm sure the chair will give him extra time.
[32:37]
Every time he's talking, all the time.
[32:41]
And then just turn on the mic.
[32:44]
Yeah, I forgot.
[32:46]
Sam Kaufman, 1300 White Street.
[32:48]
Thank you, members of the committee.
[32:50]
Madam Clerk.
[32:52]
Madam HR Director.
[32:54]
Mr. Moyer.
[32:55]
Thank you.
[32:55]
good to see you. He's a big crowd here in the audience, right? But in any case, I wasn't planning
[33:02]
on speaking, but I did receive a phone call late this afternoon from a friend, a school board
[33:09]
member, Darren Haran. And when he had heard about the withdrawal from the candidate, he wanted
[33:14]
to be sure that I knew, and that this committee knew that what his thoughts were, and it aligns with
[33:23]
what I had proposed in previous years,
[33:26]
and that is to reach out to Vernon's emboldening.
[33:28]
Derrick Smith's in particular,
[33:30]
Mr. Ferran said he had spoken with Derrick Smith,
[33:33]
he's spoken with administration in the school district.
[33:36]
He thinks it would be a great fit.
[33:37]
I think it would be a great fit.
[33:39]
I think it would be a good choice to look at.
[33:42]
Something to look at.
[33:44]
His hourly rate is less than half of our current city attorney.
[33:48]
He knows everyone in the county.
[33:50]
He's worked in our county for 25 plus years.
[33:53]
He's board certified and he can be in-house, not every day, but every week, and that's a lot more than we have now.
[34:01]
And so we have to take into consideration what our options are.
[34:04]
We need somebody who understands an area of state critical concern.
[34:10]
He understands an area of state critical concern.
[34:12]
To Mr. Clinton's point, he knows the LDRs, you know, understands how that works,
[34:16]
especially in relation to Monarch County and how our city would operate.
[34:20]
So that's one thing I wanted to ask you to look at.
[34:24]
Maybe broaden the scope if we don't get applicants
[34:27]
for in-house positions, maybe looking at a firm
[34:30]
that can fulfill not only the work of the city attorney,
[34:36]
but also perhaps take on litigation as well,
[34:38]
or take on other matters that could save the city's taxpayer
[34:44]
dollars in a long run.
[34:46]
If you look at our monthly expenditures for our city legal department, maybe you should look at that.
[34:52]
I think it's in the $40-50,000 month range if there's a firm that could take that on in total.
[34:58]
Maybe that's a good deal for the city.
[35:00]
Something to look at. And also Mr. Smith, who had applied previously for the position that should be noted. And when he spoke to us last year, I believe it was, he said he would take it as an opportunity to mentor Kendall Hardin.
[35:15]
And that's what I think some of my colleagues on the city commission is really looking for. Someone to mentor her, be more available to staff, it's something we don't have enough of.
[35:24]
Lastly, Bob Schillinger or county attorney did make the presentation I believe twice before to the previous committee on the same subject matter, and it would be great if you looked at the Florida Association of County attorneys and their program because that would help with this process in a great way.
[35:43]
At least maybe they could also help generate some additional applicants. We'll see.
[35:47]
Anyway, that's my three minutes. I really appreciate the time.
[35:49]
You don't know how bad. I wanted to cut you off.
[35:54]
I'm just kidding.
[35:55]
As a policy, I give everyone an extra minute.
[35:57]
And for more, probably, it has seen that before.
[35:59]
Thank you.
[36:00]
If I, like I said, if I can't have fun up here, I quit.
[36:03]
Thank you.
[36:04]
Thank you.
[36:05]
The buzzer.
[36:11]
Good afternoon.
[36:13]
Is it acting chair or vice chair or?
[36:16]
Just chair.
[36:17]
Richard's fine.
[36:18]
Board members, staff visitors, I'm Leon Moyer.
[36:21]
And I just left the city commission meeting that started at nine this morning and now I'm missing out over there just for this meeting here because I want you if you have a device there and want to look up the municode.
[36:33]
If you typed in section two, hyphen 281, it's division two, uniform procedures for advisory boards.
[36:43]
And it says this division shell be designated as a uniform procedure for cities advisory boards and screening committees, including those boards designated as commissions, then section two, hyphen 282, appointment.
[37:00]
All persons who desire to serve on an advisory board shall be city residents, except is provided for the Board of Trustees for the retirement funds that have a separate section.
[37:10]
All requirements for members who serve on a screening committee shall be established by the resolution of the city commission creating such a committee.
[37:21]
The city commission is required by this ordinance to establish requirements.
[37:25]
and I could not find a resolution where they did that.
[37:29]
So I think you're all unlawfully composed.
[37:32]
Not your fault.
[37:34]
Not that you can probably talk.
[37:35]
We can talk to the city commissioners about this,
[37:38]
but because there should be requirements to be on the board here,
[37:43]
and that's to be established by a resolution.
[37:47]
No member of the city commission can serve.
[37:50]
All such persons shall submit a resume
[37:53]
to the appointing member of the City Commission is part of their application.
[37:58]
I don't know if you all submitted resumes or not, but I don't think they're following
[38:03]
this code here. This isn't the first time I've had issues with the City of Key West,
[38:07]
not following their own ordinances and rules and regulations. It's nothing personal here with
[38:12]
you all. All directly appointed advisory and screening board members serve with the pleasure
[38:17]
they're pointing city commissioner and you don't derive any property rights and
[38:23]
core and procedures 50% plus one regular meetings you're supposed to determine
[38:28]
your meeting schedule annually and meetings are supposed to be published in a
[38:32]
newspaper a general circle in the city at least five days before or advanced of
[38:39]
the meeting and also and you can have special and regular meetings and you may
[38:45]
set them at a future meeting date.
[38:47]
And if you get too many absences, you get kicked off
[38:50]
and special meetings and open meetings
[38:52]
and conflict of interest, it's very interesting to read all this.
[38:57]
But also, I have some questions about your minutes.
[39:00]
I don't think what occurred in the October 20th meeting
[39:04]
was exactly lawful because I can't see that all the members
[39:10]
were voting and nobody recused themselves.
[39:13]
So, if you don't recuse yourself, you're required to vote.
[39:17]
You can't just say nothing, and it doesn't record all of you in the minutes.
[39:22]
So, anyway, have fun.
[39:25]
Thank you.
[39:25]
Thank you.
[39:26]
Thank you, sir.
[39:29]
Okay, well, we had public comment.
[39:32]
We've already had some committee member comment.
[39:37]
Would anyone like to have some additional committee member comment?
[39:42]
actually. Yeah, I had a couple questions and maybe as far as can address this, but I was wondering
[39:47]
because of some of the points that Mr. Kaufman brought up and the rest of the board has brought
[39:52]
up is about who we're looking at and their experience. So, you know, what are we defining as
[40:00]
Sorry, just lost my please in my notes. Related fields and substantial. And so I understand that city and government work is important. But as Mr. Clinton, I've reported that, knowing LDRs and having civil litigation experience is also important. So we're looking at, you know, is it just the city government or are we also looking at private attorneys? And it's kind of a two-part question.
[40:21]
And the second part of the that I question my comment is, where are we advertising this?
[40:26]
Have we gotten the Florida Bar section listservs for those?
[40:30]
Because I've talked to, you know, I've done enough state work to have lots of friends throughout
[40:34]
the state and city and county attorneys were not even aware that this position was available.
[40:41]
And so to me that says we're not getting the message out wide enough and perhaps Mr.
[40:46]
and fact I can help us with that, but I'm also very interested in pushing those lists
[40:51]
serves because that's free of charge. And we can use that and that's where a lot
[40:56]
of people are getting that information to know about this. And I did know at the
[41:00]
recent City Commission meeting Ms. Downs announced that it had been published in the
[41:06]
Florida Bar Journal. And I don't know if that was Ms. Spoken, but I would assume that
[41:12]
you would advertise in the fort of our news and not the fort of our journal, the journal tends
[41:17]
to be a more academic, and the fort of our news has a whole section of legal advertisements.
[41:24]
So those are my two big-
[41:26]
I think you may have, I don't know, Bridget, did you provide, actually, with one of the initial
[41:33]
emails that you had sent out of where and how exactly you were advertising this, and you
[41:38]
I'm just bringing this up to speed on what we're in and how it goes.
[41:43]
I think it was the floor to our online type things and the journal.
[41:47]
Any of you have any of you?
[41:49]
Sure, Mr. Chairman.
[41:51]
So, yes, one of the first emails which is at the very bottom of all the ones that I forward
[41:54]
to G yesterday and today does list all the places we advertise.
[42:00]
Ms. Ivy Jones also asked me to look at the state government site.
[42:05]
I cannot advertise a city job on the state government site
[42:09]
and I did give a little update to that,
[42:11]
but I wanted to make sure I, you know,
[42:13]
that I did look into that today.
[42:14]
Well, prior, and that's why we were
[42:16]
unable to advertise there.
[42:17]
We do advertise on, we advertise,
[42:22]
I believe it's seven different places.
[42:25]
And based on how the advertisement went,
[42:28]
we are first meeting, I was advertising that before that week.
[42:32]
so they most of them because some of them only advertise a month are showing up more this month
[42:38]
and they are live. We are getting hits back through our online portal of where the
[42:44]
advertisements came from and most of them are most of our app institutions actually came through indeed
[42:50]
and they were through other pulled sources and we are advertising on our LinkedIn and things like
[42:57]
as well. But I can pull all of the names that I actually advertise. I don't remember them off the
[43:04]
top of my head and email them to you just so you know as well. Thank you. And I'm happy if you all
[43:09]
know of any other sites that it doesn't look like I'm advertising on. You are more than welcome to email
[43:14]
me and I can figure out what the cost is and how I get access. Some of them are restricted because
[43:20]
they have to use the city attorney to get access to them.
[43:24]
But I'm working with Ms. Downs and staff to do that.
[43:31]
Sure chair.
[43:33]
What do the advertisements actually say?
[43:37]
Does it list what experience we need?
[43:39]
Does it list what salary range?
[43:43]
Because I'm wondering if we actually provided the salary and what you're suggesting
[43:48]
if we'd get some more applicants based on that.
[43:54]
So currently the job is listed as 200,000.
[43:57]
I just pulled up the advertisement when he mentioned that,
[44:00]
because there was discussion.
[44:02]
The commission voted for it to be at 200,000.
[44:05]
We had requested 235 plus.
[44:08]
So it is 200,000 plus based on qualifications and experience.
[44:13]
The job description focuses specifically on the skills needed.
[44:17]
It talks about the LDRs labor and our minimum requirements, which were the discussion items,
[44:26]
the Commission collaboratively worked on to give us the total number of years of service, fields of work,
[44:37]
and then board or county certified preferred.
[44:42]
It is not required.
[44:43]
But originally they had wanted that required, but we knew that preferred would get us more applicants because that process can take up to five years.
[44:51]
Right.
[44:54]
That's just a buzzer.
[44:56]
Um, as the non attorney here, but one who is engaged.
[45:00]
Many, I thought from the beginning, this was a low salary for this job. What I compared to the Chief Assistant,
[45:08]
who is at 225, I have to concur with Richard, I think, and Mr. Etch and Felder did, in fact,
[45:17]
speak of the salary being really tough to endure. To his point, he said his wife is trying to find
[45:24]
way to look at houses and it is an issue, especially for an outsider. Is it conceivable that
[45:31]
we could increase that? I think we would get more candidates, just my thought.
[45:38]
I can put a request. I believe I have to put a resolution. At the December commission meeting
[45:46]
to raise it. Okay, just to change it. Just to change it. Just play and we spot can we sponsor the
[45:51]
right. I mean, this wasn't noticed. I don't think there's a
[45:54]
problem with making a motion, I don't know that legal is going to be able to put together a
[45:59]
resolution for you though, but we can certainly send the minutes along with the request
[46:06]
to increase.
[46:07]
Or you can talk to your appointing authorities, you know,
[46:14]
Sherry Jones speaking.
[46:17]
As far as the salary of my opinion is, we, we who have worked and government work some
[46:27]
of us many years know that I don't, government service work, that's pretty, pretty up
[46:35]
there for a reasonable, it seems to be, in my opinion, it seems like a reasonable request
[46:44]
$200,000 a year. However, to get more applicants, I would have to concur rate. If you put that
[46:53]
request into raise the salary, you'll maybe get more applicants.
[47:03]
And my opinion, $200,000 is way too low. So, that's what I want to say.
[47:09]
I'm going to make a motion that we make a suggestion to the commission that we raise it to $250,000.
[47:17]
Second. Okay, we have third motion seconded and thirded. Is there any discussion on this motion any further discussion?
[47:28]
If not, should we call the roll on a you can do all in favor. All right. I was going to say on a non really action
[47:34]
I don't know that we should do that, but all in favor.
[47:41]
Okay, the motion to suggest the city commission offer a much more reasonable
[47:46]
salary would go forward.
[47:49]
Now, let me ask, I need to ask a question about just some materials and making sure
[47:56]
that I'm complying with the complying with all the things that I need to comply with.
[48:02]
So I would like actually to have the benefit of the document that I created, which I thought
[48:07]
was an outline of the qualifications, but obviously I didn't want to just email actually
[48:12]
and say, hey, by the way, here's what I distributed at the initial meeting, could we distribute
[48:18]
that to her?
[48:19]
I just want to make sure it was disclosed and out there, and we don't have any sun-chime.
[48:23]
I have that, I'll forward it, too.
[48:25]
And if I could just comment on that, I read it after the meeting, and that was quite the...
[48:30]
If we could find someone that meets all of those qualifications, I would be fantastic.
[48:37]
It was a fantastic summary.
[48:38]
Well, thank you. I mean, I think that is, it's a goal. So hopefully, hopefully we can get there.
[48:47]
I'm sorry. What I didn't write down in that motion, you didn't have a figure, right? You just want them to consider a greater amount.
[48:53]
250. Oh, 250. Okay. I apologize for that.
[48:57]
What all do?
[48:58]
I characterized it as a much more reasonable salary. I think when I was talking about it.
[49:04]
What I'll do after this meeting is right to the commission.
[49:06]
So if someone wants to sponsor it based on your, we wouldn't necessarily need a resolution from you to do that.
[49:12]
Okay. I'm saying. Yeah.
[49:14]
Okay. Well, I guess they have one now.
[49:17]
So any other, any other comments?
[49:20]
I just have one.
[49:23]
With regards to not instead of, but perhaps in the interim, are we considering outside council firms or individuals in the interim?
[49:34]
Mr. Kaufman or a constituent via Mr. Kaufman, Mr. Smith from Vernas. I don't know
[49:40]
these firms, but there have been others out there.
[49:46]
Can the commission consider outside
[49:48]
firms an independent council while we conduct this or is that something that they have to
[49:55]
decide?
[49:58]
I think the other dimension can...
[50:00]
Do whatever they want, they get out of somebody, walk into Richard's office, probably tomorrow.
[50:08]
And I don't even know that and maybe carry you can direct us here. If somebody applies, obviously the application and the matrix is going to come to us.
[50:22]
but if we have, you know, if there's an outstanding applicant, I would imagine that could go.
[50:28]
I meant independent counsel, not an employee, though.
[50:32]
So I meant in an unemployed fashion, outside counsel as a firm or independent contractor,
[50:39]
not actually applying for it.
[50:41]
Oh, that's what we have now, right?
[50:45]
If I could comment on that, I just, I feel like we need to move
[50:52]
process forward of finding someone that's going to sit under this roof and be the city attorney.
[51:01]
I get it if we don't find someone going and figuring out if there's another firm. But for now,
[51:07]
especially with Kendall being out, we have Mayan here. She's been in the thick of it for several
[51:14]
a year now, I think. By bringing in another firm without Kendall here and all the chaos going on,
[51:20]
I just don't think that's the greatest idea.
[51:24]
So let me ask a question because actually I should know this and I don't.
[51:28]
Is it the will of the city commission that it is someone who permanently resides and this
[51:34]
I'm in.
[51:34]
I imagine it's in the application about relocation, that's up to that.
[51:38]
The desire of the commission, they want someone living here in in-house.
[51:42]
I would say that's what they've expressed the past couple city commission meeting, yes.
[51:47]
and just prior to establishing this committee, yeah.
[51:51]
Got it, okay.
[51:53]
If I could just add the, when we sat up here
[51:57]
with as the last sitting city attorney
[52:00]
selection committee, choosing Mayan was only,
[52:04]
because we didn't have applicants and we needed somebody.
[52:08]
So, it was an interim.
[52:09]
I think her contract was 12 months or 18 months,
[52:13]
something like that, so that's the only reason
[52:16]
and that we chose her firm.
[52:20]
Okay, that's actually really helpful.
[52:23]
So to benefit us,
[52:26]
I don't think any of us were part of that committee.
[52:29]
What do you think was the issue that there weren't qualified applicants?
[52:36]
Were there qualified applicants that was it a money issue?
[52:40]
Was it a, I can't move to key west issue?
[52:43]
Because I can tell you, my brothers are generally in the
[52:46]
to be retired, but he's not now, but when they would, when they would have to hire a new
[52:53]
surgeon. I mean, that was a tough process. I mean, you got to find a board certified
[52:58]
general and vascular surgeon. You know, they're not coming down for an hour. You're going
[53:02]
to bring them and their family down for a weekend. And you're putting them up in a hotel
[53:06]
and when, you know, a spouse gets out and gets out of the car and says, where's the closest
[53:12]
shopping mall, you know, you're going to have a bunch of money
[53:16]
spent over the weekend for nothing, right?
[53:18]
So do you do your recollect what, you know, what the issue was?
[53:22]
Was it money?
[53:23]
Was it housing?
[53:24]
The job?
[53:24]
If I recall correctly, we had more applicants than we have now.
[53:31]
But their qualifications weren't.
[53:34]
There was no one that was really standing out that, you know,
[53:37]
we would say that this person is going to be, you know,
[53:41]
city of attorney. So that's, I think, me and if I'm recalling correctly, then put in an application,
[53:50]
maybe, and she has done this job before in this manner. So it's kind of just a temporary solution
[53:58]
until we found someone that really met your summary of qualifications that we were looking for.
[54:07]
Thank you.
[54:09]
All right, is there any other comment?
[54:11]
It's a great deal.
[54:12]
Just one.
[54:13]
I wasn't here last year, but as part of my two diligence, I did ask for last year's applicant list.
[54:22]
And we did have Erica's correct.
[54:25]
We had much more than we have right now, which is why I don't need to do a commercial or something
[54:30]
and make it seem like a fun job and a better salary.
[54:33]
There was one that Michael Funiel, who applied last year, he was the Senior Assistant City Attorney for Clearwater.
[54:44]
Subsequent to not getting moved forward last year, because man down was put forward.
[54:50]
He is now the City Attorney for North Point Florida at a $25,000 base salary.
[54:55]
I wasn't here, I don't know why he wasn't put forward.
[54:58]
I suppose someone deemed him not...
[55:00]
Qualifying. Now she may remember. But she's right. We got quite a few more last year than we have right now at this point.
[55:08]
I want to say, and God, there's been so much that has happened in my past year. But there was a little bit of background issues.
[55:16]
Correct for two of them that we thought that they're.
[55:24]
Mr. Chairman, there were, there were background Mr. Fionio did not have any problems at that point and I'm not exactly sure why he, he may have been the one that may have gone forward, but at that point in time, it was decided that a contract was better than just one applicant to look at for interviews and hopes that he would, I believe that we would get more applicants and continue and the advisory board was discontinued when we signed the contract.
[55:54]
for 12 to 18 months with Aaron Downs and using Mayan as our interim city attorney to do to the fact
[56:01]
that some of our app, we did get a lot quite a few more applicants and qualified, but he did
[56:07]
come in fully qualified at that point.
[56:12]
Thank you. Do any other comments?
[56:16]
Another wasle, entertainment motion to adjourn.
[56:20]
Oh, second that.
[56:22]
Anyone want to go?
[56:23]
Well, I'm going to consider that emotion.
[56:24]
Oh, second that.
[56:27]
Oh, okay.
[56:27]
That was a hearing aids for a reason.
[56:29]
All in favor, aye.
[56:31]
Motion adjourned.
[56:32]
I don't have a govel, but there you go.