Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[0:02]
Okay, we can do that. Lieutenant Bell, did you want to take roll?
[0:09]
So we're beginning at 505 PM tonight.
[0:15]
Yeah, I can do that. Patricia Diller,
[0:21]
Dr. Castanas.
[0:23]
Here. Robert Duff, here. Alex White,
[0:30]
Chairman McGray.
[0:32]
Joshua Morris,
[0:38]
Caitlin Tiffany, Susan Wayne, Reverend Willey,
[0:47]
Kathy Taylor,
[0:50]
Andy Trimlett.
[0:52]
Here,
[1:00]
you want to start with a pledge of allegiance.
[1:08]
Kelly begin,
[1:12]
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, the Republic, to which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for all.
[1:32]
Okay, current business, the discussion regarding the comments and recommendations regarding section of the hiring of the next police chief for the city of Lemesa.
[1:43]
really fast tomorrow. I'm so sorry to interrupt. I just want to make the announcement that there was no public comments to read. Sorry. I just wanted that for the record.
[1:52]
Well, the point that you
[1:59]
like to start.
[2:02]
For item one, we have Tina White and Terry Black here to I believe asked the board some questions regarding the upcoming recruitment for the new police chief. So I will hand it over to them.
[2:18]
Thank you so much, Megan, and thank you to the task force for giving us space and time on your agenda this evening.
[2:27]
And we want to thank you all for the important work you've been doing over the last few months in a virtual environment, no less.
[2:34]
My firm has been retained to conduct the next police chief recruitment for you all and I'm happy to have my colleague here Tina White joining us.
[2:47]
You'll be the partner on the recruitment. So my firm specializes exclusively in local government executives.
[2:56]
We have a lot of experience with police chief recruitment and there are actually two divisions of the firm.
[3:02]
One is exclusively dedicated to executive recruiting for local government entities.
[3:09]
The other side of the firm is dedicated to police reform and performance enhancement.
[3:16]
So we are all about recruiting and trying to find you the best candidate for Lemesa, given that a lot has gone on in the last two or three years.
[3:30]
We've done a lot of research, a lot of studying, a lot of watching videos, and so we think we're as knowledgeable as we can be without being there in person and speaking with you all and
[3:43]
interacting with members of the department members of the city, as well as the community.
[3:48]
But as we begin this adventure of trying to recruit a number of qualified candidates for the city,
[3:56]
it's really important to us to know what's going to be a good fit.
[3:59]
Because what's right for one community can be a bad match for another.
[4:05]
Even if they're geographically closed, or similar in size, demographics, each community has its own unique personality and culture.
[4:16]
And so we try to get our arms around the community, around the department, around the city organization.
[4:22]
Before we develop our marketing materials and start talking to potential candidates and go out and advertise and actually recruit and is a mini call head hunting.
[4:33]
We really want to know what we should be looking for.
[4:38]
So we have two big questions for you this evening.
[4:40]
The first is, we'd like to get your feedback on what we call the ideal candidate profile.
[4:47]
So if we were to design that perfect, please chief candidate for Lemesa going forward.
[4:53]
What are the qualities and characteristics that are most important to you from your perspective?
[4:58]
And then our second question is, if you were to advise the new chief, where he or she should
[5:06]
invest their attention and energy during the first year, there are a number of priorities
[5:11]
we understand.
[5:12]
But what's on your list?
[5:14]
Where would you advise that individual, you know, you've really got to pay attention to these
[5:19]
three or four big big priorities if you want to be successful in our community?
[5:24]
So those are our two two main things and I think it's helpful if we start with the first.
[5:32]
So if you're thinking about that perfect candidate recognizing that there's no perfect perfect.
[5:37]
We haven't found the perfect person yet, but we are good at finding great matches.
[5:43]
But what characteristics,
[5:47]
qualities, you could talk about leadership style and even experience to the certain degree.
[5:52]
we're interested in hearing what's important to you.
[6:02]
Go ahead, Jim.
[6:03]
Okay, I just know that we've talked considerably about the importance of a leader that has
[6:12]
experienced as a change agent. Agent, there are going to be a number of new things coming
[6:19]
about, especially the community police oversight board is going to be new for this
[6:24]
Chief and being able to serve as a change agent and possibly have the skills necessary to bring
[6:33]
out of the system exchange.
[6:38]
I'm sorry.
[6:40]
I'm sorry.
[6:43]
And I think that's a crucial aspect, open to change willingness to bring about systemic change
[6:51]
And working with a secondary body to implement changes or proposals.
[7:03]
Real quick, Megan.
[7:05]
I just noticed that Cassie Taylor is, oh, no, a panelist.
[7:08]
I'm looking for
[7:15]
person.
[7:15]
Well, for my point of view, I'm looking for person.
[7:19]
This particularly sensitive to a city that has been under siege.
[7:23]
And what is quite upset, it's still upset.
[7:30]
About many of the factors that have taken place, it caused the difficulties that did cause what ended up happening.
[7:40]
I
[7:47]
have to see a new police chief that's interested in having the police department and the community work together in different events.
[7:56]
And just getting the public to be able to come in and learn about what the
[8:01]
amazing police permit does and also making sure the
[8:04]
amazing police department wants to reach out to the community and work with them.
[8:16]
I myself would like to like a chief who is definitely knowledgeable.
[8:22]
He or she could as long as they are willing to somehow get this community to build bridges.
[8:34]
And someone who is unfamiliar with how Lamesa has been ran and is interested in improving
[8:46]
Lamesa and the community relations with members of Lamesa who look like me.
[8:58]
Thank you.
[9:01]
Let's say for me, openness and communication, so willingness to speak with community and not just listen, but also take action based on the community input is a really important understanding the issues that have led to everything that's been going on in our city recently, I think is absolutely critical.
[9:27]
And then, you know, a willingness to look at what the police currently do that could possibly be done by other entities.
[9:37]
Like, you know, should the police be also our psychologists for the community and, you know, dealing with homeless issues and all that, or, you know, can we look at other ways to solve these problems that don't require people with guns to show up.
[9:52]
And then finally, like someone who's willing to take a hard look at why for the last three years and possibly more have a Mesa P.D. interesting black people at three times are a white people.
[10:04]
And how can we address that?
[10:13]
I am also interested in a police chief who will be staying around for more than two years.
[10:27]
So someone who's really going to commit a significant amount of time recognizing this, the change is probably going to take a little longer than two years.
[10:36]
So that can be done in two years that adventure to say it didn't get this way overnight.
[10:43]
And it's going to take some persistent consistent leadership.
[10:48]
We've gone through several police chiefs in the last 10 years.
[10:52]
And I don't think that's very healthy for a city.
[10:58]
Yeah, consistency is super important, I think the average 10 year for a police chief in California right now is about three years.
[11:08]
So yeah, it's tough, it's tough, but thank you, that's really important.
[11:18]
I would say that I echo a lot of things that my fellow task members have said, but something I would add is adding to the open-mindedness that a few have mentioned.
[11:29]
There are a lot of good evidence-based practices that I'm not sure necessarily being used by the LMPD right now and so being open to either doing the research or listening to people who have already done the research on what is working in cities that are similar to Lumesa and how we can actively implement those changes here.
[12:02]
So I just want to add, I apologize, I was trying to get Patricia in the meeting because she couldn't find the link, so I've been kind of in cognito.
[12:11]
But I kind of heard what most everyone have said. I just wanted to add a cheap that maybe has that is creative, a creative thinker and in other words, thinking of innovative ways to include diversity in the department and reach out to the community.
[12:38]
And I also think experience with kind of back or backing what Jamal said experience with collaboration and mediation because I think there's going to be the need to really work with the community and bring them on board with the department I mean we we've got to have really community oriented policing so everybody works together instead of
[13:04]
antagonistic sort of setup, and it's not, you know,
[13:09]
and us against them, it's we're all in this together.
[13:11]
We all want our community safe, and we want everybody to feel safe.
[13:15]
So I think those skills are really important,
[13:18]
mediation and collaboration.
[13:30]
Other thoughts?
[13:32]
We're talking about the ideal candidate and the characteristics
[13:35]
that make up that right now, a fantasy individual
[13:40]
Well, that we're going to go out and try and recruit it for.
[13:47]
I'm going to get into mine.
[13:49]
Please.
[13:51]
There's been sort of a leaning by some groups in and around the community towards vigilanteism,
[13:58]
and I would like to see a police chief who takes a firm stand against that.
[14:06]
I second that.
[14:14]
Okay.
[14:15]
And how?
[14:16]
Yeah, I just want one more thing.
[14:18]
If they've had experience working with some sort of oversight
[14:22]
community oversight body, that would be great.
[14:27]
It might not be a mandatory qualification,
[14:30]
but I think it's got to be up there with a qualification.
[14:35]
We really would like to see.
[14:42]
OK.
[14:47]
You've kind of touched on some of the priorities.
[14:50]
But when you're whispering in that new cheese
[14:53]
are sitting down for coffee, you know, invested in their success. We're in this together, because
[15:00]
And we're going to be partners. It's not us against them. What are you telling the new chief? What advice are you giving him or her on what they need to focus on? I mean, I think we can guess a few things, but I think there's there's some work to do. We probably are going to come up with a long list. And that's okay.
[15:22]
The one thing that I would tell the new chief that to take a look at the station is our police force and why is it that the photos from the 1950s of the mesa look like the photos from 2019 of the mesa there's been no change and if you really want to make change then your police force
[15:52]
should represent the community that it serves and it right now it hasn't and never
[15:58]
passed. And I definitely would like to see individuals of color have roles other
[16:08]
than just a police officer, you know, tenant, sergeants and whatnot. So that's what I
[16:30]
My recommendation to a police chief, especially that first year, is that there's a lot of history of things that have happened.
[16:38]
Way back from the helix incident going on through the riots, et cetera.
[16:43]
I would like him to try to address some of those issues as best that he can.
[16:52]
Because we haven't had transparency and I think that's just led to a lot of baggage,
[16:56]
And that's obviously why we've had the issues that we've had.
[17:00]
And I know there's definitely something they may not be able to disclose or say.
[17:06]
But I would like him to at least look at those things.
[17:10]
See what's happened and try to give some transparency and answers to the community.
[17:17]
And whatever way they can so that he's not like ignoring the situations that happened before.
[17:22]
and yeah we want to go forward, but we definitely would like to get some sort of answers,
[17:29]
especially to the more recent issue that came apart after the, after the riots.
[17:36]
Interesting.
[17:38]
Cyril, a lot of healing and understanding that needs to take place.
[17:42]
Definitely, I don't think we can have any of that and he's going to, I know that we definitely
[17:46]
have the investigation going on, but I think he needs to really be ready to jump in and address that
[17:54]
investigation and go forward. Could it be a sheet? Yes. Okay. Either way.
[18:06]
Okay. I would like to see a proactive
[18:11]
of portion of an implemented implementation of training.
[18:25]
I don't know if, so I'll make a police department actually, has any type of sensitivity
[18:35]
training, de-escalation, training, you know, just something that is more preventive.
[18:51]
And, you know, in, you know, stemming off any future issues or problems in the community,
[18:59]
If we could proactively tone that down by getting ahead of it, and then, you know, of course
[19:08]
recognizing those that don't respect the training aren't capitulating for one reason or another,
[19:15]
those people would be weeded out, you know, and he would be able to wreck he or she would be able to recognize
[19:22]
where there might be issues that are privately happening on the streets.
[19:29]
Yeah, I can definitely did a what Patricia said because the training is a big part, sensitivity training, if there's some type of simulation training that they could have as well.
[19:41]
I don't know that should exist with all the other types of video things that are going on, but simulation training would be good and it should be done on a regular basis.
[19:52]
it should not just be a one-time thing, it should be done regularly just to be enforced that behavior or reaction.
[20:01]
Absolutely, like ongoing, like something that's ongoing regardless of what year it is or
[20:08]
whatever, just something that's regular training, just like they train for sexual harassment or
[20:18]
anything else.
[20:22]
And I also think what I hear too is, you know, a chief that is really in touch with what's
[20:28]
going on, not just in his or her community, but in the profession and in other communities,
[20:34]
to anticipate if it's possible,
[20:39]
but you do not stay constrained to mandate a training or whatever,
[20:44]
to, you know, be nimble enough to bring in the right training so that everyone in the
[20:49]
apartment, their toolkit is deepening and expanding, consistent with the challenges that they're
[20:57]
dealing with. And as you all have indicated, it might not be a sore and officer that just
[21:03]
seems to be trained. I mean, maybe we have civilians and volunteers doing other things as
[21:08]
well, but maybe overall and more progressive. I don't know, but I'm just guessing of a more
[21:18]
I can just conversation happening in many places departments today.
[21:24]
Also, too, in regards to hiring, we should have people that actually, if we can,
[21:35]
I understand that you can only go by people who apply and they do have to qualify.
[21:39]
They have qualifying standards, but they should look to the community as a possibility.
[21:48]
And those people should represent the way that the community looks, you know, they should
[21:57]
have people of color and they should have people that live in the community and are willing
[22:05]
to, you know, let that be known to the community so that they, you know, they can have a better
[22:15]
relationship with schools and other parts of the community where people appreciate people
[22:24]
who actually live in our community.
[22:33]
I also agree with Patricia and Kathy and I really would like to see a chief that has the strength of character to really implement change because I think there's always people who resist change, whether people within the police department or outside of the police department.
[22:55]
And that's, you're really going to have to have a lot of strength of character to deal with a lot of the negative stuff that's going to come their way.
[23:09]
And you've got a persevere regardless because change is necessary and I want somebody who really can stand up and say we're moving forward.
[23:23]
One thing I would add, a couple things I would add, one, I'd like to see someone who isn't just willing to meet with leaders around the community, both in Lemesa and the greater scenario of County area, but actively, like reaches out to, you know, church leaders, and they'll open WACP San Diego, ACLU San Diego, and groups like that that, you know, I've been working on these issues and have a lot of information and good ideas to share.
[23:54]
And then on another note, one issue that I think has bothered a lot of people is that I've talked to a number of people who have seen police officers wearing a thin blue line flag on either their uniform or somewhere else.
[24:10]
And I think that, you know, a lot of people see that as a racist symbol, so I think someone who is willing to address that would be ideal.
[24:22]
And in terms of I don't want to put worse in your mouth, it in terms of reaching out to the community groups and the other stakeholders, it's not just like incident based.
[24:36]
It's a regular standard business practice, essentially.
[24:40]
Yeah, I mean, first looking at strategy and ways to reform and not just way and presenting bad to happen.
[24:48]
Thank you.
[24:53]
I personally would really like a person who is different.
[25:01]
Totally 100% print.
[25:03]
I know Mr. Duff earlier has said that he is worried that we've had so many chiefs in the
[25:09]
last decade.
[25:11]
And usually when it comes to looking for a chief there,
[25:15]
the boxes are all similar.
[25:17]
You know, they've been working in law enforcement for 28 years, so you know they're going to retire.
[25:23]
You know, so I think a little less time on the force and more perhaps experience and or education,
[25:33]
even if it's outside of law enforcement, would be a huge help.
[25:39]
You know, as opposed to somebody that's been working in law enforcement for 28 years,
[25:44]
has had these certifications, this degree in, you know, master's degree in, and master's degree in criminal
[25:52]
justice and master's degree, you know, so I just somebody just different.
[26:01]
Thank you.
[26:04]
Other thoughts?
[26:09]
I do believe that somehow in your interview process, that you need to try to determine whether this person
[26:17]
themselves personally has sensitivity towards people of color. If they don't, they're not going to
[26:28]
really understand what it is that the community is looking for. They want equality for everyone,
[26:38]
not just for a certain group and if they don't really understand that, I don't see how they're
[26:50]
going to be able to make a difference. I agree with Janet, it has to be somebody that's
[26:54]
going to stand up on their own two feet and they're willing to take on the negativity that's
[27:00]
and a calm by trying to do right by the community
[27:04]
and right by the police force.
[27:08]
I just, you know, I just know that if they don't have
[27:10]
an understanding and in-depth understanding, you know,
[27:14]
and they can, but I just think that a part
[27:19]
of the interview process should be to find out
[27:22]
if that's really truly in their heart and their mind
[27:28]
to do the right thing.
[27:35]
If I could add one more,
[27:38]
this would be like on the top of my list. Okay.
[27:42]
It would like somebody who
[27:44]
never worked for the Mason PD.
[27:48]
Meaning they're coming back from agency
[27:49]
and no one who necessarily has ties
[27:52]
who's ever worked for the Mason
[27:56]
and capacity.
[27:57]
You just might just different.
[27:59]
I know.
[28:00]
Especially.
[28:03]
Got
[28:08]
it.
[28:09]
It will be a nationwide recruitment.
[28:11]
So we are casting a very, very white net, which in today's world, I think it's a really good thing.
[28:19]
Or for that matter, at Justice, so the great thing, San Diego PD is the same thing as a Mesa PD.
[28:28]
And I don't want somebody looking for another retirement, PD.
[28:39]
Can you say a little bit more about that?
[28:41]
Well, we've had several chiefs of police come in here and she's like they come in from local, and they walk in here, and then they serve while long enough to get a retirement pay from the SPD.
[28:56]
And they're living quite well now, I'm sure.
[29:00]
But if you go down the line and look at all of our former police chiefs and it's not too far back that you have to go with.
[29:06]
I'll see that they came from another source local and retire here because it was a nice padded
[29:13]
young. We were a real quiet community before. We've grown up. This isn't Mayberry.
[29:22]
Yeah. Yeah. No, understood. Just candidly I'll ask you all that kind of walk in Tina and
[29:30]
shoes for a couple minutes. As you can imagine, it is not easy to recruit police chiefs this
[29:38]
these days. It is probably the least popular profession on the planet right now, or one of the
[29:45]
least popular. And you know, as you all are describing, it's going to take a very special
[29:52]
individual and an incredible leader who not just can come in and do a great job.
[29:59]
But here what?
[30:00]
It really has the passion and the heart and the empathy to lead a reform effort and just the overall change that is occurring and needs to occur.
[30:15]
One of the challenges we have is the cost of living in California.
[30:20]
And Lime says not the highest paid police department.
[30:24]
In fact, I think for Chiefs, if it's not the lowest in the county,
[30:28]
it's pretty close to the bottom.
[30:31]
So sometimes when we're recruiting candidates from out of state,
[30:36]
they have to be drawing down in another retirement system
[30:39]
to be able to afford to live here.
[30:42]
even in the most quote unquote affordable parts of San Diego County, you know, we are used
[30:50]
to our outrageous cost of living in California, but you know, people coming from from other
[30:57]
states, unless they're coming from a real upscale community, it's, you know, sticker shock.
[31:04]
And so it's not, it's not a shock, but it is, it's hard to do. It's hard to do. So I just put
[31:09]
the quick that out there so but what we are will be careful about is we're not
[31:16]
kind of to will screen out the candidates we think are who are retired on the job
[31:20]
who don't have the energy who don't have the interest you know who aren't sincere
[31:25]
in their commitment to be changed you know if they're looking to punch their ticket
[31:33]
and just cash in you know we can we're pretty good distinguishing those candidates out
[31:41]
And, you know, I've been in the business long enough
[31:43]
to know people that waste their time, you know, recruiting or applying for our openings
[31:54]
because I have a reputation for having pretty good instincts.
[31:58]
So hopefully, we'll sniff out those people, but I hear you.
[32:02]
And, yeah, this is a real roll-up.
[32:06]
Your sleeves kind of opportunity where somebody can make an incredible difference
[32:11]
I mean, that's the cool thing.
[32:13]
It's going to be hard and it's going to be difficult,
[32:15]
but if you're a true public servant,
[32:18]
wow, what a story you could be able to tell
[32:20]
in two, three, four, five years.
[32:23]
So to us, that's what gets us jazzed
[32:27]
and excited about talking to people.
[32:29]
Now, those types of people that we're looking for,
[32:33]
the Tina and I will be talking to,
[32:34]
they're not plentiful.
[32:37]
And, you know, they're going to look closely
[32:39]
at the department and the community and the work that you all have done to decide whether it's
[32:47]
it's a good match for them. It's a candidate's market right now. I just wanted to
[32:52]
fill a little bit of our pain, but we're taking what you're telling us to heart, but it's a different
[32:58]
market today. It was a tough market for good chiefs even before all of this unrest. It was getting
[33:06]
tough, you know, really, and starting to get really more difficult in 2015, 2016, because
[33:12]
the older baby boomers are retiring and plus in our state, in most states, they can retire
[33:18]
on the younger side. So we was getting harder before, all they got in rest. So, but we're not so
[33:36]
of marginally qualified people or we want quality, you know, we want Greg to have a range of options
[33:43]
at the end of the day of really good people. And so that's a little bit about our strategy.
[33:52]
So I know you've got a big agenda and I so appreciate your time tonight. Thank you so much.
[33:57]
Any other thoughts, questions you want to leave us with? I was just wondering if there's going to be a
[34:03]
process during the selection process, is there going to be an opportunity for maybe community
[34:08]
leaders to weigh in on the top three candidates and give input and maybe ask be able to ask
[34:14]
questions, is there going to be some kind of process set up for that? I know you're selecting
[34:20]
members from the community to be on the hiring committee, but once you get to the finalists,
[34:27]
is there going to be an opportunity for community members to weigh in? I don't know anything
[34:31]
about her and committee. We haven't discussed the back end of the process yet with the city,
[34:40]
so in COVID conditions who knows what will happen, but we haven't got that far,
[34:49]
but it's the most important part of the process for, I think, the community to let their voice
[34:57]
heard is now, the early stages of the process. So that's why we'll be doing some focus groups
[35:04]
as well as they'll be in online survey that people can fill out. So I can't answer the question
[35:11]
right now about who's going to be engaged. I will say from a recruiters perspective, the community
[35:18]
input upfront is really important. If we are successful in getting awesome candidates, they're going
[35:26]
be very, very concerned about confidentiality, because their organization, if they're smart
[35:32]
and organizations are getting smarter to this way pretty fast, if they have a sense that
[35:39]
they might lose some good talent, they're going to do everything to make our jobs really
[35:44]
hard to pry that person away.
[35:47]
And so I do have a little bit of concerns about a very, I know this isn't what you were
[35:53]
thing, but a very involved elaborate process where a lot of people are involved,
[35:59]
but which
[36:00]
is why it's so important that we talk to people at front,
[36:05]
but the city manager will hear
[36:06]
from us concerns about confidentiality. But there's a balance, right? We can reach a happy
[36:13]
medium to get to the right place, but we keep our eye on the prize. What we're trying to do for
[36:18]
and that is bringing you great options.
[36:23]
And we want to make sure that those people stay in the pool and stay interested
[36:26]
and they're not compromising their careers where they are presently.
[36:34]
So how's that for a round to answer, too?
[36:37]
Well, so your job is strictly with obtaining applicants
[36:42]
and then you're out of the picture.
[36:45]
The city takes over in terms of the process.
[36:47]
No, I'm sorry we stay with with the process all the way through. Yeah, all the way through. So I'm just I'm just thinking of, you know, a lot of times the top three candidates to come forward hit the newspaper so it's no longer confidential. It's it's, you know, it's well known.
[37:05]
And that's the point where, you know, it can be done on Zoom, but if community leaders could ask questions weigh in, give the input, it doesn't mean they'll make the selection, you know, but they can weigh in and give a written input or whatever it might take I think that's helpful as well.
[37:24]
Yeah, they're a variety of ways to do it. And we even take the input that we get from you all.
[37:30]
And others to create the interview questions. And there are several stages of the interview questions. It's not just two or three rounds.
[37:39]
It's extensive.
[37:42]
And it's a complicated decision, right? And it's a really important one. And there are a lot of areas to probe and explore, given the complexity of the role that we're asking them to take.
[37:53]
So, yeah, there are a variety of ways to do it, and I think if those, it's all great stuff.
[37:58]
And there are a variety of options, and we encourage our clients to consider all the options
[38:06]
and take time to think about it.
[38:08]
And we've got a little bit of time to get to that stage, but yes, thank you.
[38:14]
Really glad to hear that you're doing, you're planning on doing focus groups.
[38:18]
I'd love to hear more about that because I think what's, I'm going to be absolutely critical
[38:22]
to gain legitimacy in the community for the new police chief is to make sure that as many people
[38:27]
are involved from the community as possible. So this is a great group of people here, but we're
[38:32]
definitely not, you know, the entire community for me. Yeah, we thought you guys were at it.
[38:39]
Yes, so we look forward to those. I knew what ton of people were like jumping at the bit to
[38:44]
to give input on this, so. Well, encouraged everyone to complete that survey when it's
[38:51]
I'm sure the city will publicize it well and yeah, I think they're we're looking at identifying community leaders that we can bring together to have essentially round table discussions and make it meaningful.
[39:07]
You know, we really want it to be meaningful so we're not going to solve all the problems, but we can design that ideal candidate and you guys can send us off and on our adventure so.
[39:19]
Yeah. And the other thing I want to make sure I was, you know, you create a place where people feel they can speak out and they can say what they're really feeling because, you know, if your figure gets too big, it's like a community forum and people are just going to be too scared to say anything.
[39:37]
I appreciate that. And that was my concern as well because it doesn't serve the purpose that we're trying to.
[39:42]
to achieve. So yeah, thank you for that. And another reason for the surveys, people can even do it anonymously
[39:50]
and they can, you know, say as much or as little as they want. So we want as many avenues as possible
[39:58]
the people for people to have a voice. Do you have a timeframe on the survey or the focus group?
[40:05]
I think the survey will be posted, if not right before Thanksgiving, probably shortly thereafter,
[40:12]
and likely focus groups starting right after the Thanksgiving holiday.
[40:20]
Yeah, thanks.
[40:22]
I wish I could be there in person, give y'all a hug.
[40:25]
That's normally the way we do business.
[40:26]
So, I have to do virtual hugs.
[40:28]
I really appreciate the important work that you're doing.
[40:31]
And it's a good, good foundation for us to launch from.
[40:37]
Thank you so much.
[40:40]
Thank you.
[40:41]
Thank you.
[40:42]
Thanks everyone.
[40:44]
Thank you.
[40:45]
Thank you, Terri and Tina.
[40:47]
Thank you.
[40:49]
Have a good night.
[40:50]
Thank you very much.
[40:54]
All right.
[40:55]
Can anybody chance have you public comment?
[40:59]
We do not.
[41:00]
All right.
[41:02]
We can run on to.
[41:03]
I have number two.
[41:08]
Reviews and possibly approve the draft of the opinion piece for the
[41:13]
publication of the local newspaper.
[41:17]
So a group of us have been working on the draft, you received it in your packet and Patricia
[41:28]
Andy, Kathy, and myself have been working on this draft. Andy's done a great job of putting
[41:37]
And our words together in a very eloquent way.
[41:43]
I have made contact with the, with Laura Castañeda at the Union Tribune Editor's
[41:50]
desk.
[41:51]
She's very much and her word very much interested in our opinion piece and wants to see the
[41:57]
final draft once it's approved by this task force.
[42:00]
It would require that we not include all names, however, we can include Andy Trimlets and as a member representing the citizens public safety oversight task force.
[42:15]
So since Andy was the primary author of this piece we thought we'd move forward with that and if anybody has any recommendations one of the things I was thinking is the second to the last paragraph is a great way to end the piece and possibly put the last paragraph within the bylaw area with Andy's name and our task force name.
[42:43]
Just to get people information about what next steps are and maybe even put a link there to the application for the CPOB.
[42:56]
If anybody's interested.
[42:59]
But anyway, any other comments or ideas on this opinion piece?
[43:06]
Yeah, I had a couple comments just on some information that was presented in there.
[43:15]
I'll just let me pull it up so I can show it to you guys specifically if you guys have it in front of you.
[43:27]
Give me just one second.
[43:36]
Okay, so when I read it, overall, I thought it was great.
[43:41]
It's good to share this information with the public that we're putting this out.
[43:44]
This is, you know, what you guys have been looking for, and here it is, I think that's awesome.
[43:51]
One of the things that kind of peak my interest was in paragraph three, this statistics that we're in there.
[43:58]
When I saw that, I kind of just peak my curiosity and I just wanted to know a little bit more information.
[44:04]
And just based on my experience and expertise as a police officer, we arrest people from all over the county, all over the state.
[44:11]
If you come to Lemme say you commit a crime, we'll wear the police force that addresses that.
[44:17]
And I know that, you know, we arrest people from all over.
[44:22]
So I requested our rest data from July 2017 through June 2020.
[44:29]
And I looked at the rest C is by race.
[44:31]
And the rest C is race by a city of residence.
[44:37]
And so it kind of came up with some interesting facts.
[44:39]
So it's like a part of that is, so if you guys want to write it down to follow along,
[44:46]
so you haven't been in front of you, might make it a little bit easier to understand,
[44:49]
because I partially failed statistics in junior college.
[44:54]
So when I see all these percentages and everything like that, I kind of get up my heart rate
[44:57]
elevates a little bit, so if you can just follow with.
[45:00]
So between July 1st, 2017 and June 30th, 2020, we've had 9,607 total arrests. 86% of those arrests, with totals
[45:13]
out to 8,233, have city of residents information listed on the report. So when we arrest somebody,
[45:22]
what city do you live in? I live in San Diego, I live in Tonekila, and then we just put that information
[45:26]
and therefore. And then 4% of those arrests were suspects living outside of Lemesa. So it'd be
[45:33]
people living out of with listing residences outside of Lemesa. So of those 8233 arrests that we have
[45:44]
residents info on 21% and that equates to 1,715, we're black, 7% of those arrests were black
[45:59]
and residents of Lemesa, and then 14% were black and non-residents of Lemesa.
[46:15]
And then so for
[46:17]
That time period, 61% of our RESTD is reported living outside of the Mesa.
[46:25]
And in fact, 7% of RESTD is during those three years, we're black and provided a Mesa address.
[46:34]
I think it's worth noting that the, while the percent of overall RESTD is our black is accurate.
[46:38]
this statistic,
[46:43]
if you compare that statistic to our population demographics and looking
[46:47]
at the arrest stats with city of residents, it's important context given the majority of our
[46:52]
resties don't actually live in the Mesa. So if you look at, if you look at, if you were, this
[47:02]
is just speaking just from working at the city of Mesa, a lot of the people that we arrest,
[47:06]
If you're not committing domestic violence at your house and we respond there, a lot of the people that we
[47:11]
re-arrest or I would say transient criminals, not necessarily at their homeless, but that they are
[47:18]
traveling through our city, where they live in Oklahoma and San Diego, somewhere else, they're passing through
[47:23]
my area, specifically I've worked beat four. If you guys are familiar with the beat maps, I have gross
[47:29]
hospital and the mall and then a large, large residential area. We have people flowing in all day
[47:38]
going to that mall committing crimes, whether it's petty theft, vehicle break ins, shoplifting,
[47:45]
and it's also right next to one of our main trolley lines, the Grossmont Center,
[47:50]
trolley platform, where we have a lot of people coming in and out from all over the place.
[47:55]
And that's just one specific thing.
[47:57]
There are one specific area in the Mesa that I can speak specific on.
[48:00]
I've worked other areas, but that's the area I'm most familiar with.
[48:03]
Obviously there's trolley stops in different places to that kind of effect those numbers.
[48:09]
So I just wanted to share that with you guys just looking at that because
[48:14]
when I read that third paragraph, I was like, holy cow, you know, that seems like a lot.
[48:18]
But then I started really thinking about it and I was like, you know, we rest people from all over.
[48:22]
So is this information accurate based off our residents?
[48:25]
Like these are these residents that we're resting that 21%.
[48:31]
And it's actually not.
[48:33]
It's only 7% of our total arrests.
[48:38]
So that, oh, go ahead, Andy.
[48:41]
I really appreciate you looking that up.
[48:44]
That's really very, really, really appreciate it.
[48:50]
Yeah.
[48:50]
If I, if I can, I will, I got to go through the proper channels, but I thought I would be
[48:55]
something fun or not fun, but just like something kind of worthwhile sharing with you guys,
[49:01]
guys and girls, like trying to, you know, understand them. As we're trying to figure out this whole picture
[49:05]
all together. Yeah. I like to do email me, this is Megan. That information, I can go ahead and forward
[49:13]
it to the entire task course. Okay. I'll confer with our, our crime analyst and
[49:20]
She can maybe submit a memo to you and that will hopefully be sent your way.
[49:24]
Okay, perfect. Thank you.
[49:26]
Yeah.
[49:27]
Sorry.
[49:29]
That's a good idea.
[49:30]
I had to go ahead.
[49:35]
Just a little background on the data that I was using in that.
[49:40]
In the off-bed piece.
[49:43]
Dave Myers requested a while a few months ago.
[49:49]
So the arrest data and the field interview data later on, and so that data came from a slightly different date range than what you had for pre-ground close.
[50:01]
What was the date range that he had?
[50:03]
Just had a curiosity because I'm not sure if I can do it.
[50:06]
I can double check, but it's, I honestly it's like two or three months different from what you have, so not, it's not right.
[50:11]
up in crazy. Okay. But I have, I have all the data. I could share that with Megan as well.
[50:20]
Cool. So I didn't look at residents. I was curious though, the data you were looking at. What was the
[50:26]
overall, I missed the overall percentage of arrests of residents?
[50:35]
So let's see.
[50:42]
So the information of thirty nine percent, thirty nine percent were residents. And remember, so over, so like three big numbers to kind of keep in mind is this, we had nine thousand six hundred and seven total arrests between that three year period. So 86% of that we actually have information on to have this conversation.
[51:03]
So we're focusing on this 8233 because the other 14% we have no information on the look back on.
[51:14]
So but 30, let me just look at my notes here, 39% were residents of Lemesa.
[51:21]
So that tells you 60% of people that we arrested were not residents of Lemesa or possibly even transients.
[51:29]
And actually even that 14% of that's missing from 9,677 to 8,233, those could possibly be trained that the reason why we don't have that information is because they could, could largely impart B transients and we don't have, they don't have any residents information to provide.
[51:49]
They just, you know, when I rest on this person, hey, do you have a mailing address or anything that if I were to send mail to you know, do you have any address that you're willing to provide?
[51:59]
And they say no, I, you know, I just move on to the next question.
[52:04]
So that could be part of why we only have 86%.
[52:08]
But overall to answer question 39% of residents.
[52:12]
Mr. White, would you get your information?
[52:14]
I'm directed from the Mason City.
[52:16]
Yes.
[52:17]
You guys keep.
[52:20]
Sorry, from the staff that you guys keep to my knowledge, yes, this is just pouring directly from the data that we have.
[52:30]
And I would back in to say, I mean, I'm not familiar with all process, but if somebody submitted like a records request like Andy was saying, this is the, this, they'd be getting the same information from the same.
[52:42]
So my problem is, I submitted a record with a few times for Lameza PD.
[52:47]
I wanted to know when you traffic citations that were written for the past three years.
[52:54]
And this other request I submitted was for how many traffic citations for mud flaps.
[53:01]
I had to put in a second request because they gave me all the information on one sheet.
[53:08]
Okay, I forgot what it was on the top of my head.
[53:11]
Maybe like let's say let's say 33 years.
[53:14]
And the second time I asked I specifically asked again the same approach and broke it down the same way I did the first time and the vision that I got was very brief and it showed that there had been 27 citations written and the three years and only two are three were waiting for mud flaps, which I mean I mean if you know in the last time that we met we set up here
[53:44]
and we had a conversation about complaints by Lieutenant Bell and he went back to 2016 and that was
[53:54]
a second time he tried to give that data to us. And when I was shocked that 2016 shared with my
[54:03]
taskforce members, my wife and I came in to how a complaint of how a officer didn't fail to do his
[54:11]
duties when my, both my kids were almost deducted. It was a tipped adoption. And I sat down to
[54:18]
file a complaint and with the current acting police chief and there was no component. So my
[54:25]
thing is, like, some of the data that Lemase has, I don't trust. So, I mean, I think the best thing
[54:35]
do is to get it the information from the census.
[54:39]
Okay, and Jamal here you out and I can't really offer
[54:44]
anything because of anything like any opinion or commentary because that's above me, man.
[54:50]
What do you understand? Yeah, I can't say the data can be the people I always say and the data can be
[54:58]
can be screwed most certainly can. So I'm just saying the best place to go to gather information
[55:10]
I can say, however, I do know that we are under legal obligation to maintain records in a certain manner.
[55:19]
Again, that's above me.
[55:20]
I just know that we're supposed to be doing it in accordance to law.
[55:24]
But in going back to something that you brought up earlier regarding your PRAs,
[55:30]
I would prefer that to Megan and then we could possibly look into that a little bit more
[55:37]
for you to hopefully clarify something.
[55:42]
I'm out of the question, we're eventually interviewed, but I got the information.
[55:48]
Yeah, again, I've submitted several.
[55:51]
Okay.
[55:52]
You can see again, the first time I had to submit for that one particular question that I had
[55:58]
I had this too because the information that I was given was not correct at all the first time.
[56:04]
Okay.
[56:07]
Caitlin, were you trying to say something earlier?
[56:10]
Yeah, I just wanted to say that I appreciate that we can break it down by resident,
[56:15]
but I still think it's a little bit concerning since the entire county is only about 6% black.
[56:22]
So unless there's just way more people of color that are moving in and out of LaMesa than compared to the entire population of the county, I still think it's something that we should be concerned about.
[56:38]
Yeah, I think the bottom line is it really doesn't matter where they live.
[56:42]
It's an issue of possible racial profiling,
[56:46]
and whether they live in the Mesa or not.
[56:48]
The general population for the county at San Diego,
[56:51]
black population is 5.6% so it's considerably lower
[56:55]
than 21% even worse than the Lameza.
[56:59]
I mean, if you're gonna compare percentages,
[57:03]
you might wanna stick with the Lameza percentage
[57:05]
just because it's higher.
[57:08]
I really don't think that's our issue right now.
[57:11]
issue is really racial profiling. So that's kind of what that's addressing.
[57:19]
Okay. The, um, yeah, and I was just, that was just, you asked to create anything on it. And I,
[57:27]
I ripped, when I read that, that was like, that's on this book to me. And as is the police officer that works in
[57:32]
LaMesa and having actual hands-on experience, not just kind of theoretical or what I can gather from the data,
[57:38]
but actually driving a black and white arresting people,
[57:42]
that made me curious, is this what's really going on
[57:45]
or is there something more to it?
[57:49]
Again, having that hands-on experience
[57:51]
and knowing that I arrest people from all over,
[57:54]
not just residents that will make us a bit residents too,
[57:57]
but all over all of the county, all of the state,
[57:59]
people come in from out of state and I arrest them too.
[58:03]
It's just, I am the officer that is enforcing law
[58:07]
in that area, and if they break the law, they're, you know, almost police officer is going
[58:11]
to respond to that. So that was just kind of, that was just kind of the breakdown.
[58:17]
Right. That was really, really appreciate taking the time to look at that and digging into
[58:22]
that information. I mean, the more data we all have, the better off everyone's going to be.
[58:27]
So, um, I appreciate looking into that. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. No problem. I just,
[58:34]
I was going to say I agree with
[58:36]
it as well. I mean, it could be rewarded a little bit, so there's no, so there's given more clarity.
[58:42]
But when an arrest is made, the officer doesn't know whether that suspect lives in La Mesa or not,
[58:47]
so that's kind of a midpoint. But so looking at it the other way, it's the fact that
[58:56]
the way that it was written kind of made me think of the, if I was just a layperson reading it,
[59:01]
made me think of that, like we go around purely looking for
[59:05]
and arresting black people, which is not the case.
[59:08]
We go around looking for criminal activity and arrest criminals.
[59:11]
Doesn't matter what race, religion, age, color, that you are,
[59:19]
that purely fact is, we make decisions based off
[59:22]
for person's actions, just how a person dictates
[59:25]
going to a contact is going to go, I tell people all the time.
[59:28]
Look man, you're in control of this contact.
[59:29]
I'll be respectful of you. You're respectful of me by Sversa, but even like, you know, if, you know, I don't want to
[59:37]
put you handcuffs because you're acting squirrely or anything like that. Can you please just have a conversation with me?
[59:41]
You know, there's all these different things that we can do to deescalate, but bottom line is is we don't choose what the person looks like. We don't choose what the person does.
[59:50]
We only choose how we respond to it. And that is long, enforcing law.
[59:58]
And it seems like the response is
[1:00:00]
Higher proportionally for black people than it is for people. So that's just something we're trying to
[1:00:07]
alert everyone too so that you can look, because it's not, we're not saying that you're looking for this. We're saying,
[1:00:14]
maybe there's something in training practices, something that has nothing to do with you,
[1:00:20]
but something that has to do with something systemic going on that's leading to this discrepancy.
[1:00:26]
Because obviously, you are not specifically looking for this, but there is something
[1:00:31]
systemically going on, and we should try and figure it out so that it stops happening.
[1:00:37]
Right. Yeah. And you go in a criminal sociology, and it could be a number of different factors, right?
[1:00:42]
You know, just like, you know, people that start off at a disproportionate
[1:00:46]
disproportionate lower socioeconomic status and pop-up line. I mean, the list goes on and on.
[1:00:51]
people spent their live studying this, but this was just, again, I want to bring it back to my original point of just, I looked into it a little bit more to hopefully kind of shed some light on, you know, on that 21% on, you know, just that just the narrative that it was creating for the
[1:01:10]
Please permit which I know the men and women in this department of work with them. They come to my house. I'd babysat for them. I've want they want to mic all these different things. It's like I just don't want my friends to be painted in that picture if that's not true, you know, so if it's shedding a little bit more light on that statistic kind of kind of opened it up and maybe kind of open the perspective on it. Then that's then great if not then.
[1:01:40]
then it is what it is. I just kind of want to share some information that I dug into based off
[1:01:46]
curiosity from that help it. Thank you. I'd like to say one thing, obviously statistics can be
[1:01:56]
skewed anyway you want. So I would appreciate of making and share the information with us and how that
[1:02:03]
21% was derived just to make sure that everybody understands how that you got to that.
[1:02:12]
conclusion. And my other comment about the opinion piece, you can tell me if it might be more
[1:02:19]
correct or not. But in that same paragraph, could is there any way that I thought it would sound
[1:02:26]
better if you said the Lemase of PD shows African Americans account for 21% arrest instead of black
[1:02:33]
people? I just thought it would sound better. That was my opinion. And then I agreed also
[1:02:41]
with what Janet said about putting the link in at the back end so that if people would like to apply
[1:02:47]
for the CPOB that they are able to and they have a direct link to it. That's it.
[1:02:56]
Meet President, I just agree. I love Black. I don't love African-American at all.
[1:03:02]
Some people may disagree with me, but I'm Black. I'm American. I've never been an African.
[1:03:08]
And I'm planning on going, but I'm black, I'm a black American.
[1:03:14]
You know, so there's a lot of people out there that may be older than me that might feel differently,
[1:03:20]
but yeah, I always have a problem with African American because it doesn't mean American.
[1:03:26]
It means African American.
[1:03:27]
Okay.
[1:03:28]
I appreciate you telling me that because I know I'm like okay, what would sound better?
[1:03:32]
What would not?
[1:03:34]
I just would appreciate your opinion on that.
[1:03:36]
But me personally, I like, but again, I don't speak for everyone.
[1:03:42]
But I, I, I, I, I, I, yeah, Jamal, I think I'm the one that changed that I think and you may have had a different thing, initially, but you could say black black people or blacks, you know, I'm okay with that as well.
[1:04:05]
I'm aside, I was whenever people would say African Americans, I would then refer to white people as European Americans.
[1:04:12]
Like even though, you know, like my answer, there's came here like a couple hundred years ago, but so I'm not really European, but under the same standard, I would be a European American, right?
[1:04:28]
So are we moving on to item number three, are we going to.
[1:04:36]
decide whether with with a minor changes if we want to move forward because if this is our last
[1:04:46]
task force meeting then we need to make a decision about this draft and maybe have Andy
[1:04:52]
check out the statistics and make some tweaks on that paragraph and then make sure it's 750 words
[1:04:59]
It's a little fit in the op-ed page for the interview and then if maybe we should vote and
[1:05:08]
just say if we're okay with moving forward with this as a task force.
[1:05:15]
I did have a comment.
[1:05:16]
I did clarification, maybe.
[1:05:19]
Downward says, what will the community police oversight board do, and it says, make recommendations to whom?
[1:05:29]
Say the council, please deferment?
[1:05:33]
Do them,
[1:05:36]
and that's repeated again in that same paragraph further down.
[1:05:45]
I know that I too, Mr. Dough.
[1:05:47]
Maybe just suggestions?
[1:05:51]
Can we put suggestions?
[1:05:52]
I think there are recommendations that we can say there are two of the police chiefs.
[1:05:58]
Okay, yeah.
[1:05:59]
I mean, it is still right.
[1:06:01]
It is still right.
[1:06:03]
Yeah, we would be making recommendations to a variety of entities.
[1:06:09]
Maybe City Council, maybe the chief, maybe.
[1:06:12]
I didn't know.
[1:06:14]
City manager.
[1:06:19]
So, I mean, I'm sorry, the board would be making recommendations.
[1:06:23]
recommendations.
[1:06:27]
So, a hundred of the coordinates itself, the board is tasked with making recommendations
[1:06:33]
to the police chief.
[1:06:34]
This like brings us back to that recurring issue about the police department being subject
[1:06:38]
to the control of the police chief.
[1:06:41]
So, as we framed it, the city council will get a CC, there might be other people who are on
[1:06:47]
the CC line, but the recommendations are formally addressed to the police chief.
[1:06:51]
that's good to know. And that can be added so that it's clear where the recommendations go. Thanks, Caroline.
[1:07:00]
Thank you. Thanks, Bob.
[1:07:05]
Anything else that anybody felt could be added or changed?
[1:07:16]
Now, I like it, it's in late terms, it works well.
[1:07:20]
Very well written, Andy does a great job in Cathy helped weigh in so good group.
[1:07:29]
And just,
[1:07:30]
I think Susan was asking where the data came from. So we have the raw data for three years of arrest records and three years of field interviews from the Mesa PD. Dave Myers originally sent it to a professor, the arrest records to a professor at SDSU and they, I don't know who it was, but they went through and ran a bunch of reports based off of that raw data. So that's where the 21% comes from.
[1:07:58]
And then he gave me the raw data as well.
[1:08:01]
And so I went through and ran my own reports
[1:08:02]
and came up with the same answers.
[1:08:06]
So that's what those numbers came from.
[1:08:13]
But I'll share them with Megan so you can see it too.
[1:08:17]
So Megan, can we vote on this with minor changes
[1:08:22]
move forward with this?
[1:08:26]
Well, and somebody will need to make a motion
[1:08:28]
for this opinion piece to move.
[1:08:34]
I'll make a motion that we accept this with minor changes needed.
[1:08:40]
On second it.
[1:08:44]
I have this.
[1:08:45]
Taskforce member, does that evo?
[1:08:48]
Yes.
[1:08:49]
Taskforce member, trimlet, how do you vote?
[1:08:52]
Yes.
[1:08:54]
Vice Chair Castanas, how do you vote?
[1:08:56]
Yes.
[1:08:57]
Chair McGray, how do you vote?
[1:09:06]
Jamal Huddy vote? Yes, I'm sorry. Yes.
[1:09:09]
Task Force member Tiffany Huddy vote? Yes.
[1:09:14]
Task Force member Wayne Huddy vote?
[1:09:21]
You're on mute season.
[1:09:23]
Sorry. Yes.
[1:09:25]
Task Force member Taylor Huddy vote? Yes.
[1:09:29]
Task Force member Dylan Huddy vote? Yes.
[1:09:33]
Task Force member White Huddy vote?
[1:09:36]
I'll abstain. Okay.
[1:09:37]
And I believe that is everyone, so motion carries.
[1:09:49]
I want to item number three, review the Possible Approval of the Complaint of the Police's Conduct Handbook Reform.
[1:09:58]
Will I start?
[1:10:00]
So, Alex and the Kathy Susan and myself were on the subcommittee to, I sent you both the, well, in your packet was both the long form that we talked about our last meeting.
[1:10:14]
And we've come up with a short form with the actual form itself where you would file a complaint.
[1:10:23]
And wanted to get feedback from anybody in terms of information they'd like to see changed on that form,
[1:10:32]
or if there were any other additional changes on the long form, as you reviewed it.
[1:10:37]
I thought the complaint form is easier to understand a little bit user friendly, more user friendly than the one that is currently being used.
[1:10:53]
And mainly we took out a lot of jargon that might not be comprehensible to your average citizen.
[1:11:00]
So anybody has any recommendations or suggestions on this?
[1:11:12]
At this point, this information that we put together will go forward to the future community police oversight board for them to review and make additional changes and put into, you know, or submit as part of the policy working with the chief.
[1:11:32]
So, this is just work we've done as background work for them, for the board, and they will follow up in whatever you want to accept this.
[1:11:45]
I think it would be helpful if we agreed to accept this and move it forward to the board.
[1:11:55]
So this is kind of one note on the complaint form.
[1:11:59]
I think you guys did a great job with it and it reads really well and is accurate and digestible.
[1:12:07]
One thing I would flag is on the very last page and the second paragraph.
[1:12:13]
There are a couple of references to an investigation by the independent auditor.
[1:12:18]
And I think the accurate term would be an audit because the auditor will be investigating.
[1:12:26]
So I think it just should read the oversight board with the department at the audit.
[1:12:31]
I've independent auditors necessary and if the auditor conducts an audit.
[1:12:36]
Specifically, what's the sentence?
[1:12:38]
It is the second and third sentences of the second paragraph on the last page.
[1:13:00]
I'm not really seeing it. Is it under initiating an audit section? What section is it?
[1:13:08]
I'm on the complaint form, not the handbook. So it's the last page of the complaint form under what happens next.
[1:13:18]
We
[1:13:23]
need to set this again.
[1:13:25]
The oversight board will determine if an investigation by the independent auditor is necessary.
[1:13:31]
If the auditor conducts an investigation.
[1:13:34]
So if an audit by the independent auditor is necessary.
[1:13:39]
Is that what you're asking?
[1:13:40]
Exactly.
[1:13:43]
And then in the next sentence too, if the auditor conducts an audit.
[1:13:51]
Part of our plan was to make sure you fix this.
[1:13:56]
Otherwise, it looked great.
[1:13:57]
You did a really good job translating a bunch of technical language into something
[1:14:01]
after it's magical.
[1:14:04]
I just had a couple of comments after looking at this.
[1:14:08]
On that same form.
[1:14:11]
The sentence on the first paragraphs says,
[1:14:13]
I'll have to attach form in the community.
[1:14:15]
Please oversight for it and we'll miss a PD.
[1:14:18]
We'll review your complaint.
[1:14:19]
And take any necessary action.
[1:14:23]
I almost feel like we should admit the intake
[1:14:26]
any necessary action, or substitute something else
[1:14:29]
because we may, it seems to have
[1:14:32]
a further that we're actually going to proceed
[1:14:36]
with an investigation or an audit.
[1:14:39]
And we may consider the complaint to be unbounded
[1:14:43]
and really not going anywhere with it.
[1:14:47]
And so I felt like in a way that
[1:14:49]
kind of possibly misleading or maybe we should just don't admit it and not say take any necessary action and then on.
[1:15:00]
The third page. When they were talking, when it states brief description of the incident, then if you been in the parentheses, if you provide contact information, etc. I feel like that was repeated on that statement on the first statement on that page. And then also where it says, you have any of the following and it says photos videos documents. I felt like we should actually take that.
[1:15:28]
those comments out that are in the parentheses.
[1:15:33]
And on the last page where it says what happens next to insert, like,
[1:15:43]
and still the same after you've thought this forum say after completing this forum,
[1:15:47]
are representative from the Mississippi D will contact you to gather additional details, photos,
[1:15:55]
videos, documents, or other evidence that you may want to submit.
[1:16:04]
I just thought I would
[1:16:06]
would shorten up those two comments in the parentheses and put there after they submit the
[1:16:14]
This is what's actually going to happen.
[1:16:21]
Good point.
[1:16:22]
And I would say, after you submit this form rather than after you complete this form.
[1:16:28]
Okay.
[1:16:29]
After you fill out this form, which is currently what it says.
[1:16:32]
Awesome.
[1:16:32]
Correct.
[1:16:34]
Yeah.
[1:16:38]
Andy, what do you think about the idea of taking out those items in parentheses and just
[1:16:44]
including it in the what happens next section?
[1:16:54]
The reason that we put there and I think we could take it out of at least the second one because it does a little redundant.
[1:17:01]
The reason we put it under the brief description section is because if you had a series incident that you're going to be complaining about, you're going to look at these five lines and be like, that's not enough.
[1:17:14]
So we just wanted to make it clear that like this is not your only opportunity to explain what happened, like we just want to general description for the form and and they'll be a follow up after this.
[1:17:29]
So maybe take out the one under the photos and put it in the other section, but I'm willing to be overruled.
[1:17:44]
I'm not understanding what's in parenthesis that needs to be taken out.
[1:17:49]
There's there are on page three of the form, towards the end of the form.
[1:17:55]
There's a couple of questions that have the same information parenthesis.
[1:18:00]
One is when you give a brief description of the incident and the second one is, you have any of the following.
[1:18:06]
and then it repeats the same information in parentheses and Susan was recommending that we put
[1:18:15]
all of that into the what happens next so that people will understand that that's how they
[1:18:24]
can get the photos videos documents to the police department. I see. So what do you think?
[1:18:33]
I think if I were filling this out and I saw the brief description,
[1:18:40]
I would assume that it's going to go to someone to follow up.
[1:18:44]
But I don't think it's necessary. I think it could be taken out and added to what happens next.
[1:18:54]
I think Andy's point was that if there's only five lines and you have a lot to say,
[1:19:00]
you might be intimidated by the fact that how do I squeeze all of my thoughts into this
[1:19:04]
and just knowing that there will be a follow up maybe my ease, their minds about trying to
[1:19:11]
put it all down on paper. And I think that was the thinking behind it. I don't know if there's
[1:19:23]
particularly important as Andy mentioned in that particular question because there's just
[1:19:30]
not enough room to really get into too much detail and we want them to share details but it might
[1:19:36]
be better shared verbally. Well in that case I'd be with Andy then. Leave it for the first
[1:19:44]
brief description of the incident. Leave it there and then maybe take it out under something
[1:19:49]
the following. Yeah. Okay.
[1:19:55]
Any other comments or suggestions? Oh and Susan, on your first recommendation
[1:20:03]
about that first paragraph, second sentence where it says fill out the attached form in the community
[1:20:09]
please oversight board and the Lemase of Police Department will review your complaint and take any necessary
[1:20:14]
action. What if we said we'll review your complaint and make a determination about next steps
[1:20:25]
Somehow, you know, trying to get the point across it, something will happen, there will be a next step.
[1:20:33]
That may be, that may be better to say that.
[1:20:37]
A necessary action to me makes it seem to really, you're actually going to have an auditor look at it and do a full investigation,
[1:20:46]
and it may just be something like, you know, I got a traffic ticket in my mad.
[1:20:50]
And I'm not going to send that to them and take this necessary action. So I think something a little bit not so I don't know, credit, you know, just something a little bit softer, I think, in the verbiage on there.
[1:21:11]
And then I did have one other comment on the online brochure page, on the first page under the bullet points on the third bullet point.
[1:21:23]
It said to identify points of friction between officers and the community which can in turn inform the development of more effective community outreach and education.
[1:21:35]
I thought a better word may be foster the development of a more effective community outreach and education.
[1:21:43]
I,
[1:21:59]
I, I do love it. I'm anybody else have any. I, I, I definitely like that word.
[1:22:05]
Foster. This is the first paragraph. It's the, this is on the, the longer form the online brochure form.
[1:22:14]
I don't know if you printed that out, but it's online one in front of me.
[1:22:17]
Okay.
[1:22:18]
Can book on the.
[1:22:21]
So is it the first page?
[1:22:22]
It's the first page is under the section, the process of filing a complaint, and it's the third bullet day.
[1:22:30]
Okay. And Susan was saying the point that says to identify points of friction between officers in the community, which can in turn inform the development of more effective community outreach and education. She said change informed to foster the development of more effective community outreach and education.
[1:22:55]
Yeah. Foster. Yeah. I mean, it does, I mean, we use that it's used in other places. So, yeah, that makes sense.
[1:23:08]
On the second page of that document.
[1:23:12]
Towards the bottom, it says the possible findings are unless unfounded, not sustained, et cetera.
[1:23:19]
The possible findings on this document don't match the possible findings on the third document.
[1:23:23]
Oh, yes, the other document was based on the possible funding listed with the LMSAPD users.
[1:23:31]
So I think we should probably, I don't think we can change those.
[1:23:35]
Yeah, I don't think for a less an alternative,
[1:23:37]
complex resolution is something that we use in our city.
[1:23:41]
Okay, no.
[1:23:43]
Okay, so those two should be taken off of the long form.
[1:23:47]
Yeah, the LMSAPD users unfounded, exonerated, not sustained and sustained.
[1:23:55]
which that's from just reading off the other, the other document.
[1:23:58]
I found it needs to go and privilege and alternative complex messages.
[1:24:04]
Privileess and alternative, yeah.
[1:24:06]
He and E and F on that form, not A, they use A.
[1:24:12]
I found it is in there.
[1:24:14]
Okay.
[1:24:15]
Um, yeah, it's generated, not sustained, and sustained, yeah.
[1:24:21]
And we might just for, you know, to be, I don't know, on the same page is make sure that these are in the same order.
[1:24:35]
So we could list them in the same order on both pages. It doesn't matter which order just the same order.
[1:24:49]
So anything else,
[1:25:02]
you ready to vote and let the idea of moving this forward to the CPOB.
[1:25:08]
So
[1:25:12]
let's do that. I would like to make a motion.
[1:25:16]
I'll second that. Okay. I made the first and generally the second.
[1:25:23]
Fair McCray, how do you vote?
[1:25:25]
Yes.
[1:25:26]
Vice Chair Castana Sadevo.
[1:25:30]
Taskforce member does how do you vote?
[1:25:33]
Yes.
[1:25:34]
Taskforce member Trimla, how do you vote?
[1:25:37]
Yes.
[1:25:38]
Taskforce member Wayne, how do you vote?
[1:25:40]
Yes.
[1:25:40]
taskforce member Taylor, how do you vote?
[1:25:44]
Taskforce member Tiffany, how do you vote?
[1:25:47]
Yes.
[1:25:48]
Taskforce member White, how do you vote?
[1:25:53]
And then is taskforce member Dillard, how do you vote?
[1:25:56]
Yes.
[1:25:57]
Motion carries.
[1:26:06]
Was there any public comment?
[1:26:09]
There have not been any public comment for either items so far.
[1:26:12]
I'm going to go ahead and close that out and then we can start on a agenda item number four.
[1:26:19]
And then it's the review.
[1:26:21]
The hospital approved the draft.
[1:26:23]
The survey form and distribution of the draft.
[1:26:26]
Survey form.
[1:26:29]
So I see in all the corrections were made from the last meeting on this.
[1:26:33]
And I appreciate that notification on the.
[1:26:36]
The client to state.
[1:26:41]
Yeah, we we tried to incorporate as many of the changes as were.
[1:26:45]
recommended and good news is Caitlin and I have been working with a UCSD professor and we were
[1:26:57]
connected with a doctoral student PhD student at San Diego State University who is interested
[1:27:05]
in working with us to get the survey out in a manner that would provide a good survey of our
[1:27:15]
population. Yeah, so that's really important. They did offer a couple of recommendations as they
[1:27:22]
reviewed the survey and they said just to make it more user-friendly in item number one,
[1:27:30]
they recommended that we switch out the word equitably with fairly in case people don't
[1:27:39]
are comfortable with the meaning of equitable. And then in number six,
[1:27:47]
they worry that people might not understand what identity is referring to and recommended
[1:27:54]
that we put instead of identity at the end put race, religion, status, or sexual identity.
[1:28:03]
a lot. Yeah, as a line up, it's a lot. But I mean, that would, that would fill, you know, the term identity with specifics, replaced identity with specifics. So people understand what is meant by identity in that question.
[1:28:28]
I have
[1:28:33]
a comment about it.
[1:28:37]
And you've been talking to people who really do this for a living and know so much more about it than I do.
[1:28:42]
But one of the thoughts I did have is if they could identify themselves a little bit more in terms of their experiences so that you would have something along.
[1:28:53]
I have been, I have had interaction within the last 12 months with a member of the, of the database of police department, or I have not had any interaction with a member of the police department.
[1:29:10]
I somehow think that that's an important factor, but you've been talking to doctoral people who really know their, their business, and so I'm not sure it's true, but it came out to me,
[1:29:22]
that you want to know a little bit more about their experience with the department.
[1:29:27]
I mean, is an added question.
[1:29:30]
And that would have to be in the demographic data, because that's a yes, no type question,
[1:29:36]
it would have had interactions with the number one.
[1:29:38]
Have you had any personal contact with the member of the, of, of, of, of, of,
[1:29:42]
so police department within the last 12 months or or something that your experts would tell you
[1:29:49]
would be helpful in terms of how they're developing this opinion.
[1:30:00]
I think it harms anything, for sure. It just gives more data.
[1:30:06]
I think it was great. The only thing I would consider adding, and this does not make the life of
[1:30:13]
this type of station easier, but I do a lot of surveys at work, and one of the best
[1:30:20]
answer, or like some of the best, most interesting answers I get are actually from open ended questions.
[1:30:25]
Um, so, you know, just something like, um, have you had any experiences with the Lemuse
[1:30:30]
PD in the last year that you'd like to share or, you know, just something super open
[1:30:35]
and where people can kind of write a few sentences or whatever they want. Um, you know,
[1:30:40]
I feel like you can get some really interesting data that you wouldn't get from any of the
[1:30:43]
yes knows or the one two three four five.
[1:30:47]
Coffee with the cow.
[1:30:55]
Um, I'll run that by them. I know the whole idea was to
[1:30:59]
make sure people will are willing to respond and sometimes if it goes on too long.
[1:31:07]
But, you know, the other two things they've recommended is for age, the age question,
[1:31:14]
and the question do you identify as a person of color? They felt we should go with the specifics
[1:31:20]
as identified in the senses, the US senses. And I think that's a good idea because then we could track
[1:31:27]
information from the census to the various groupings of age and, you know, racial
[1:31:37]
identity, racial or ethnic identity. So I think that would be a good
[1:31:43]
change as well. I agree.
[1:31:50]
And again, we had talked about
[1:31:52]
Translating this into Spanish. I think we definitely need Spanish. Possibly Arabic.
[1:32:00]
I'm not sure. I know if it was alcohol and I'd take definitely Arabic.
[1:32:07]
But, you know, depends on,
[1:32:13]
I mean, if we, I don't know if we have a sizable population of Arabic speakers in Lemaisah, maybe we do,
[1:32:19]
and I'm just not aware of it.
[1:32:24]
but definitely Spanish, so that's something we have to look at.
[1:32:36]
Anything else?
[1:32:46]
What I'd like to do is get started on this.
[1:32:50]
Get the PhD students to get started on this work.
[1:32:56]
She's got a great advisor who's very much interested in what we're doing.
[1:33:02]
Stuart Ackens at San Diego State and I'd really like to get moving on the survey and see
[1:33:10]
Megan, maybe you can help out in terms of collecting information.
[1:33:14]
I know surveys through the city have been done via email and that might be one way of collecting data.
[1:33:22]
data. We'd also want to use a variety of data sources, including survey monkey, Facebook, Instagram,
[1:33:33]
phone, paper, but definitely emails would the city be able to assist in that endeavor to get surveys out?
[1:33:43]
I would have to ask. I'm not, I'm not sure. That's something that I don't have the authority to say,
[1:33:51]
or no one. Okay. Should we check with the city manager or who would be? Yeah, I would probably
[1:33:58]
be the city manager or assistant committee manager that you'd want to check with. Okay.
[1:34:03]
Great.
[1:34:07]
Anything else?
[1:34:13]
So with minor changes, if we can vote to move forward with this survey,
[1:34:21]
it would be great to collect this information before the board actually starts and then they can
[1:34:26]
follow up with the post survey, collecting post survey data.
[1:34:33]
So, is somebody interested in making a motion?
[1:34:36]
I do want that form.
[1:34:38]
I mean, you're going to be making some changes to this,
[1:34:42]
so we're unknown changes.
[1:34:45]
Well, the changes would be the two I mentioned in the questions,
[1:34:50]
changing equitable to fairly changing identity to more specific breakdown and then adding
[1:34:59]
the question, I have had an interaction within the last year with the Lomesa PD, yes or no,
[1:35:06]
and then give lines if they want to share a story.
[1:35:11]
And then, and then again, the demographic data connect that to census data.
[1:35:17]
I would make such motion if provided that there is somebody taking real close notes on this.
[1:35:27]
I know we don't want it to change dramatically.
[1:35:31]
Just to clarify, I think if the UCSD professor types thinks that the open-ended question
[1:35:38]
is going to add too much trouble, then I think we should skip it.
[1:35:41]
Okay, yeah, I'll run it by that and edit it on my suggestion and if it's something useful, but I think you now have some experts on board, so that's the most important.
[1:35:58]
You need to second.
[1:35:59]
I second. I second. I'll second it.
[1:36:03]
Tim McCray, how do you vote?
[1:36:06]
Vice Chair Castanas, how do you vote?
[1:36:11]
First, I share.
[1:36:13]
Vice Chair Castanas.
[1:36:15]
You made it.
[1:36:19]
You still need it.
[1:36:20]
Yes.
[1:36:21]
task course member death had evo.
[1:36:23]
Yes.
[1:36:24]
taskforce member trimmelate had evo.
[1:36:27]
Yes.
[1:36:28]
taskforce member Wayne had evo.
[1:36:31]
taskforce member Taylor had evo.
[1:36:33]
Yes.
[1:36:34]
taskforce member Tiffany had evo.
[1:36:37]
Yes.
[1:36:38]
taskforce member white had evo.
[1:36:41]
Yes.
[1:36:42]
And taskforce member dillard had evo.
[1:36:45]
Are you still on?
[1:36:46]
It's having trouble with her internet.
[1:36:47]
Okay.
[1:36:48]
Let's see.
[1:36:49]
Okay, so that looks like all of the task force members, the motion carries.
[1:36:56]
Okay, item number five,
[1:37:03]
yes, the discussion of the sample request for the proposal
[1:37:06]
over the independent police order.
[1:37:14]
So Caroline, I think you are going to give us a little overview of this information that was collected and shared with us.
[1:37:22]
Yes, so we provided two items for you relevant to this topic. We provided a
[1:37:30]
Copy of the RFP that the city of Davis used when they were recruiting their independent police auditor, and then we also put together a list of proposed minimum qualifications for the auditor based on our conversation.
[1:37:45]
Last time and based on doing some more research on the sorts of job descriptions and qualifications that other cities have utilized.
[1:37:56]
and so I'm happy to walk you through them or answer any questions.
[1:38:06]
I know there had been a
[1:38:07]
lot of discussion last time or perhaps as a city council meeting about whether the auditor needed
[1:38:12]
to be a lawyer and as you'll see we have certainly framed it in a way where a lawyer would be
[1:38:21]
qualified for the position but it's not the only potential professional route to being qualified
[1:38:27]
I had to be a police auditor.
[1:38:31]
So this been an individual auditor or auditor firm.
[1:38:41]
Ordinarily, they often come,
[1:38:44]
the individual auditor does have a small firm.
[1:38:48]
They're a boutique kind of firm,
[1:38:50]
but I think the hiring was contemplated to be an individual,
[1:38:57]
but it might be someone who comes from a certain firm
[1:39:02]
but you would be looking at the credentials of that individual and say,
[1:39:07]
you're the one, you're the one that we'll be talking to.
[1:39:10]
I see.
[1:39:19]
So in the Davis request for proposal,
[1:39:25]
they had mentioned that the position for independent auditor would report directly
[1:39:32]
to the city council with guidance from the city manager.
[1:39:36]
is that the same as it would be for our situation, would they report to the City Council with
[1:39:47]
guidance from the City Manager and is there anything in there about the CPOB receiving the
[1:39:55]
information as well or.
[1:40:00]
So the auditor serves at the pleasure of the City Council so in that
[1:40:05]
respect the the auditor is responsible to the city council. That's the body that ultimately
[1:40:15]
has the authority to, I guess, to terminate the auditor.
[1:40:25]
As for whether there's anything in
[1:40:27]
the ordinance, I don't think there's anything that formally gives the CPOB the sort of power
[1:40:35]
to terminate the auditor
[1:40:43]
and so by reports directly to that means that's the person who
[1:40:49]
contaminate them. The reports by reports I'm thinking of provides information to but actually
[1:40:57]
you're talking about report. Direct report is. Yeah I'm thinking about an employment context obviously
[1:41:02]
yet the auditor is going to be providing information to the police chief and also to the city council
[1:41:07]
also to the city manager, but from an employment perspective it's the city council and the city manager.
[1:41:15]
That makes sense. Thank you.
[1:41:24]
So yeah this is a lot of really good information and I think it will
[1:41:27]
really help the well and ultimately I guess it's the city manager that puts out the RFP
[1:41:38]
in the
[1:41:43]
manager, okay, right.
[1:41:48]
Will the city manager make a determination on this contract before the
[1:41:57]
CPOB is formed or do you have any idea of what the timeline is?
[1:42:04]
I don't think I have any insight
[1:42:05]
to share on the timing at this moment. I know, you know, as you guys do, that the process of looking
[1:42:13]
for CPOB members is ongoing and open.
[1:42:15]
But I'm not sure when exactly the IPA hiring process will get going.
[1:42:24]
Maybe that will take place after the board is formed.
[1:42:27]
I know the board will have to put together the bylaws as well.
[1:42:33]
So this is good information for them as well for the future board.
[1:42:42]
Thank you. Thank you for doing that.
[1:42:51]
Okay, I don't know if there's any other questions, but if not, Jamal, you could probably go move on to six.
[1:42:59]
Yeah.
[1:43:00]
I have one question.
[1:43:01]
If I just may say something real quick.
[1:43:03]
On the very last end of it, where it says a part of the minimum qualifications, where it says not be a resident of La Mesa,
[1:43:10]
are we given any thought on to like maybe not a resident of San Diego County, maybe kind of going outside,
[1:43:16]
like any spirit influence that that may be present in the county and then that way we kind of get a
[1:43:23]
more complete kind of independent type person. I just food for thought just kind of kind of what you guys
[1:43:29]
were thinking on that. Yeah, I'm like, I'm like, I'm an investigator would probably know what's
[1:43:38]
going on in the mix.
[1:43:41]
Sorry, you kind of broke up on that. I say that I would feel that any
[1:43:48]
if they're going to apply, they would know what's going on and let me see it.
[1:43:53]
Right. Right.
[1:43:55]
But I don't necessarily want to limit it to the point where we take away the opportunity for a really good independent auditor in San Diego County.
[1:44:08]
to not have an opportunity, if we think there is some sort of conflict, then we can address that during that process of looking at the contracts, but I don't want to eliminate it at this point early on because I mean, that might be the very best person for the job.
[1:44:29]
Yeah, I totally agree with you.
[1:44:32]
Today, like, like, preference will be given to people out.
[1:44:37]
I mean, like, you know, don't have, I mean, if you have a bunch of friends and family in
[1:44:41]
Tendiego or friends and family in the police department, I think that's, that's, that's not,
[1:44:46]
it's not really what we're looking for.
[1:44:49]
But well, because part of the minimum qualifications,
[1:44:52]
ask that, you know, the person be familiar with, like, all these different
[1:44:56]
policies and practices and acts and all that stuff that is very, very closely
[1:44:59]
married.
[1:45:00]
The law enforcement profession. In the law enforcement profession, we are somewhat of a
[1:45:26]
independent outside of any spirit or very much unlikely outside of
[1:45:35]
the spirit of influences within the San Diego County, because attorneys know each other, too,
[1:45:41]
as well, district attorney's office, whether you're in Vista, whether you're in Elcahón,
[1:45:45]
whether you're in San Diego, there's all this communication and there's again, one to two degrees
[1:45:50]
of separation. If you're looking for a lawyer or somebody or it's worded where a lawyer is going
[1:45:55]
be generally more qualified for this position,
[1:45:58]
you're kind of going to get those overlaps of influences
[1:46:02]
together where, you know, I just don't want to create it.
[1:46:06]
I just don't want to minimize the possibility of future drama
[1:46:10]
so where if there's like some type of large outcome
[1:46:13]
that is not accepted by the public or by the police
[1:46:16]
or by the CPOB, by this auditor
[1:46:19]
and there's some vague connection with the city manager
[1:46:23]
or with the new police chief or something like that,
[1:46:27]
we can kind of eliminate that on the front end
[1:46:29]
by making that clear.
[1:46:34]
I really like your idea, Alex, of saying,
[1:46:38]
must not be a resident of Lamecia or have family members
[1:46:42]
or associate associates who work for Lamecia PD
[1:46:46]
or the city of Lamecia.
[1:46:49]
Because I think we want to eliminate any bias
[1:46:53]
it might occur and I think that that's a really good idea. So we could certainly add that on
[1:47:07]
or recommend it because ultimately city manager will make the decision. Right. Right. Just bring
[1:47:15]
for discussion, just kind of sharing.
[1:47:19]
See what you guys thought on that.
[1:47:32]
Thanks very much.
[1:47:34]
Okay.
[1:47:40]
Number six.
[1:47:42]
Number six.
[1:47:43]
The discussion of the sample by us for the community police oversight board.
[1:47:51]
Well, this was another document that we provided you that should be in your packet.
[1:47:55]
And this was our list of the sorts of nuts and bolts, procedures and guidelines that need to be flushed out in a bit more detail.
[1:48:07]
And I'm happy to elaborate on any or to if you anybody had any suggestions of other sorts of procedural by log gaps that need to be filled in.
[1:48:26]
was wondering, nothing's mentioned about confidentiality training or the importance of confidentiality in this role as a board member on the CPOB.
[1:48:40]
Is that something that we would put into the bylaws?
[1:48:44]
Or I know you mentioned Brown Act compliance confidentiality training would have to go hand in hand with Brown Act.
[1:48:54]
I would think as one, but two of the most important trainings that board members would receive,
[1:48:59]
do you think that's something that should be a part of bylaws and procedures?
[1:49:06]
Yeah, I think that perhaps one way to reframe that would be to say there should be a bylaw regarding training
[1:49:16]
and that can specify that the Brown Act and other necessary statutory
[1:49:25]
provisions, well, four members will be trained in relevant statutes, including the Brown
[1:49:30]
Act and the other applicable confidentiality statutes.
[1:49:39]
Great, because I think even as the board progresses in the future, any new member coming
[1:49:45]
on would really need to get that type of training right up front, and understand like close
[1:49:53]
The session meetings, the importance of not going out and telling your friends about what happened in closed session and, you know, those sort of things are, it's really important that that it be adhered to.
[1:50:10]
Absolutely.
[1:50:14]
Anything else?
[1:50:26]
It's a real helpful outline of ideas that.
[1:50:31]
And I guess at this point, the board would look at this and add substance, you know, that this specifics and to each of these areas.
[1:50:43]
It gives them kind of an outline to work to work on.
[1:50:48]
So, thank you.
[1:50:49]
Thank you.
[1:50:49]
Thank you.
[1:50:50]
Thanks for putting this together.
[1:50:52]
All right.
[1:50:59]
Anything else?
[1:51:03]
Any.
[1:51:09]
I just wanted to say that this is, you know, since the City Council will soon be selecting the board members.
[1:51:21]
This is technically our last meeting.
[1:51:25]
And the only reason we would come together again in the future is if the board needed us to advise them on
[1:51:32]
something that we sent them, they wanted something clarified, whatever it might be, so as long
[1:51:38]
as we're willing to come back and support them in their work, then that would be the only
[1:51:46]
reason why we would come back together as a task force. But in the meantime, our work has been
[1:51:52]
done and everybody did a fabulous job, the contributions have been amazing. So I think we all need to
[1:52:01]
ourselves on the back for all the work that's been done and all the support from our legal team
[1:52:07]
in the city. We really appreciate you.
[1:52:11]
Well, I would particularly comment on any coming down to this board from way this is amended
[1:52:20]
the first meetings and really step it up the speed right up May. Janet, you've been a marvelous
[1:52:25]
I'll see you next time.
[1:52:27]
Thanks.
[1:52:36]
I think Janet frozen.
[1:52:40]
Thanks to Jamal for taking on the chair to these and leaving us lots of, it's, it's really, it's really, it's great.
[1:52:53]
Yeah, no problem. I really haven't enjoyed working with you guys and I'm excited to see what you guys are going to do next.
[1:52:59]
next set. So you definitely did a bang-up job and all of that. This is our
[1:53:04]
vitamin back and I appreciate everything that you've done and I really enjoyed
[1:53:09]
working with all of you guys.
[1:53:13]
Like, thank you everybody.
[1:53:15]
And what did you see some of you guys in person?
[1:53:18]
I do. One of these days.
[1:53:22]
Yeah, well, if you guys ever want to meet me, I work at LaMesa PD.
[1:53:35]
We'll do a ride along with you.
[1:53:39]
One of these days after we get vaccinated.
[1:53:44]
Yeah, right.
[1:53:46]
But yeah, again, I want a serious note.
[1:53:48]
If you guys don't want to come say hi.
[1:53:49]
I know I jumped to halfway through the meeting,
[1:53:51]
where I didn't get to meet you guys in person before.
[1:53:53]
I think Steven kind of might have met you guys in person.
[1:53:57]
But anyways, the guys want to meet shake hands, say hi, put a face to name in person, um, you know, I'm there Thursday Friday Saturday 6 AM 6 PM. So, no, no, that's, oh, not me, I'm traffic is not my thing, so, but I already, yeah, so, thanks.
[1:54:22]
It was great working with you guys.
[1:54:24]
It was.
[1:54:25]
Thank you everybody.
[1:54:27]
Thank you.
[1:54:27]
Thank you.
[1:54:28]
You were great.
[1:54:29]
A great group of clients.
[1:54:31]
It was really did a terrific job and it was it was a delight to work with you.
[1:54:36]
It was.
[1:54:37]
Yeah, congratulations to all of you on what you've accomplished.
[1:54:40]
It give Dale our best.
[1:54:42]
We miss him tonight.
[1:54:43]
I know.
[1:54:44]
He's in the middle of the country.
[1:54:46]
In a car with children.
[1:54:49]
Oh gosh.
[1:54:50]
So you're no more.
[1:54:55]
Bye.
[1:54:57]
Bye.
[1:54:58]
Good night.
[1:54:59]
Good night.