Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[0:04]
All right, well, good evening. Let's call the fire AMS, staffing, public information, meeting
[0:10]
to order. This is September 23rd. It is 6.03 p.m. Meeting will be held both in person
[0:16]
and remotely. That is the call to order. First order of business is roll call, please.
[0:23]
Supervisor Zimmerman, here. Supervisor Livingston. He is excused. He's outdone. Supervisor Leeds.
[0:30]
absent, I don't know where she is.
[0:32]
That makes two of us.
[0:34]
Supervisor Palmer?
[0:35]
Here.
[0:35]
Chairman Mike.
[0:36]
I am here.
[0:37]
Thank you very much.
[0:39]
Our item of business this evening is information session regarding the fire EMS staffing proposal
[0:45]
to be considered by town electors on Monday October 7th, 2024 at 7 p.m. in the Lynn town hall.
[0:52]
This meeting this evening is for discussion only.
[0:55]
What we will do is we will start with a short presentation to give you an overview to let
[1:00]
you know how we got to where we are today.
[1:04]
Then we will have both our current fire chief, Pete Jones speak, also John Peters, the
[1:11]
fire chief from the city of Lake Geneva.
[1:14]
We will then have some final comments and input for our presentation.
[1:19]
And after that, we will open it up to the audience for any questions or comments that you
[1:23]
may have regarding the proposal. So without further ado, I will turn it over to our
[1:29]
administrators Jim Hurley, who will begin our presentation.
[1:51]
Do you need any one? Like Chairman White said, we prepared some slides to inform you about
[1:55]
the partnership with the city of Lake Geneva and the township for the revived Fire AMS services
[2:01]
which just started this past February and to talk about how do we got to that point in
[2:07]
the Town Board came to this decision to choose that partnership and then offer some comments
[2:12]
from Chief Jones and Chief Peters.
[2:17]
Providing a broad overview of really what the goal of the partnership is in the type
[2:23]
of service that you're getting.
[2:25]
The City of Lake Geneva provides a minimum of three emergency personnel on scene to medical
[2:30]
emergencies.
[2:31]
They provide paramedic level service to the community, response times to all emergency calls
[2:39]
and less than 10 minutes, 80% of the time in non-world areas and 15 minutes in rural areas.
[2:46]
The city will continue to provide to respond to all Fire EMS calls on the North Shore,
[2:52]
and this is the most cost effective model due to the sharing of fleet and equipment
[2:57]
and administrative personnel, which really ties into the public administration,
[3:01]
associates, study that we'll get into later, and I hope you all get a chance to take a look
[3:06]
that's on our website.
[3:09]
Lynn Firey Miss staffing challenges. Lynn has long been served proudly by a
[3:14]
paid-on call volunteer Firey Miss department. In the past, we had approximately 25 to 30 members
[3:21]
at one any one time, including a members that were available during regular business hours
[3:26]
in weekends. Currently, the department has pressed six active personnel who can respond to calls
[3:33]
year round, and most members are available to a limited number of calls per service per month.
[3:40]
Linda is now receiving more calls per service, especially on the EMS side, due to an aging
[3:46]
and growing population, as well as service level expectations changing. And paid on call members
[3:52]
are unable to meet the increasing training requirements for emergency personnel, which have become
[3:57]
I'm a lot more challenging in the last several years
[4:00]
in the decade going back further.
[4:04]
The initial agreement with the city of Lake Geneva
[4:06]
for EMS staffing.
[4:08]
So our approach was to see if we can find a staffing model
[4:10]
that worked without going to 24-7.
[4:14]
And initially in 2021, we began contracting with the city
[4:17]
to provide two EMS personnel station
[4:21]
from Monday through Friday, 7-E-M to 5-P-M
[4:24]
because that's the most of our members were at work.
[4:25]
and we were experiencing the biggest challenges.
[4:28]
The partnership did result in improved response times
[4:32]
in more consistent responses
[4:33]
in terms of the level of service provided.
[4:36]
During periods of that contractual staffing coverage,
[4:39]
like you need an EMS staff
[4:41]
responded to the majority of EMS calls in 10 minutes or less.
[4:45]
However, despite those improvements,
[4:47]
we continue to experience challenges
[4:49]
outside of those contractual hours
[4:51]
in the evenings and on the weekends.
[4:55]
So what did we do?
[4:56]
The next thing we did was we hired public administration associates to conduct a study to review
[5:02]
current operations options for the town and help us with data and analysis to determine what is
[5:10]
the best model for the services that we need. So we were hired them in 2023 to conduct a comprehensive
[5:17]
study analysis, reviewing staffing vehicles apparatus needs and facilities, the study which included
[5:25]
interviews with Fire AMS members, I think we had about 14 at that time, and then we looked at
[5:31]
three different options. For one, it was maintaining the current service level,
[5:36]
two, it was creating a Lynn Fire AMS standalone model, and three, partnering with the City of
[5:43]
Lake Geneva to provide 24-7 Fire AMS coverage.
[5:49]
The partnership with the City of Lake Geneva,
[5:51]
We considered, we reviewed the response times, the quality of care, the cost options and the feedback from Lynn members, and the town board ultimately decided to, to agree to a one year agreement with the city of Lake Geneva to staff the Lynn Firehouse 247 with professional fire AMF services.
[6:13]
The partnership, again, includes the following service levels, those three emergency personnel
[6:18]
on scene to medical emergencies, paramedic level service to the community, and again, that goal
[6:23]
of 10 minutes, 80% of the time, they're better in non-world areas than 15 minutes in rural
[6:30]
areas.
[6:31]
At this time, I'll ask Chief Jones, if you could come up to the podium to talk a little bit
[6:35]
more from your experience about some of the challenges that we've had and the partners
[6:42]
partnership with the City of Lake Geneva.
[6:44]
Our biggest challenge today is having active members.
[6:48]
We've gone for a full roster.
[6:54]
And then in the last few years we've all,
[6:57]
we're all the way down to nine members.
[6:59]
And we have six active members and three of members
[7:03]
that are non-active right now on our roster.
[7:06]
With Lake Geneva's help, we've been able to answer calls.
[7:10]
For the last year, we're down to seven minutes
[7:13]
and twenty-eight seconds reaching someone's house now, averaging. So that's a
[7:19]
very close to having people at our station 24-7. The biggest
[7:24]
challenge is we're not at the station, we're all at home, so it takes us ten minutes
[7:29]
to get to the firehouse just to get out the door. So that makes a big difference
[7:34]
on saving someone's life.
[7:38]
If everything is worked out perfect so far, we've got
[7:43]
people there so anyone comes up to the door or someone there it's just so much
[7:49]
better feeling that there's someone there.
[7:54]
Thank you Chief. No, I appreciate that.
[7:56]
Thank you. We also have Lake Geneva Chief Peters. Chief Peters if you could
[8:02]
talk currently about crude staffing and how things are working so that
[8:06]
residents could be aware.
[8:10]
Good evening everyone. Chief Trump Peters, the
[8:13]
new fire department. Thank you for having me. We've had a successful relationship with
[8:20]
the townland for several years. When I started on the fire department way back when we worked
[8:26]
very often with the townland, fought fires, worked a lot with some folks in the audience
[8:32]
as well as chief Jones fighting fires. And we had worked very often with the townland.
[8:37]
And this isn't a new relationship for us at all.
[8:41]
The things that are happening with the town of Lynn,
[8:45]
what the change in staff and the lack of availability
[8:48]
with staff is a nationwide issue.
[8:51]
It's happening to all of us.
[8:53]
If you look on any, if you Google paid on call firefighters,
[9:00]
this is unfortunately a common problem
[9:02]
we're having throughout our nation.
[9:03]
So this isn't a town-a-lin issue or a city-of-LH&E issue, it's a global issue, unfortunately.
[9:13]
So this is just a thing we're trying to do to build that gap and to make it so that
[9:19]
we can respond to in a timely fashion and provide that service, unfortunately.
[9:23]
This is the next step.
[9:25]
With that being said, there was a study that was put together by the township and the city
[9:32]
we did a study as well with what that being said, these things were identified to be able
[9:38]
to meet to provide you service and to do that appropriately.
[9:44]
We currently are meeting and surpassing the study in time frame response, which I'm
[9:50]
happy to tell you that.
[9:52]
And at time frame, it was at 10 minutes and at 8 minutes, I'm a responding quicker than
[9:57]
that.
[9:57]
That's wonderful.
[9:58]
I have gotten some feedback from the tunnel in, excuse me, some residents directly that we are providing good service to them and that we've had some success stories, which is wonderful as well.
[10:12]
We provide together, just as that says, if they're stronger, we are stronger together.
[10:18]
The goal would be to continue to build that relationship and make that stronger together
[10:24]
and continue to foster that and make that better.
[10:28]
What that being said was our response times.
[10:32]
We also have increased the service to the community through paramedic, right?
[10:36]
So before it was at the Advanced DMT, we now bring the paramedic to that.
[10:42]
They also, in addition to that, if you have a fire emergency, we have somebody there, three
[10:47]
people going out the door. We know that we used to say as firefighters when we started in this
[10:53]
a fire fire doubles every minute. Now we say every 30 seconds of fire doubles. So that that's
[11:00]
important to us as well. So we get somebody to you quicker and then more folks come as we need them.
[11:10]
That's that's about it. That's all I have for you. So thank you. Thank you.
[11:16]
Thank you very
[11:17]
to chief Peters, one of the questions is for Lynn residents and members that want to
[11:21]
continue to serve. They can continue under the city of Lake Geneva. There will be that
[11:26]
opportunity to still still respond to calls. So the paid on call is still there.
[11:36]
Okay.
[11:38]
So one of the questions people of the neighbors, how much is this going to cost us? In the total
[11:43]
annual cost is $1.9 million, but one of the things to keep in mind is that our current
[11:49]
tax levy includes one and a half million borrowing for the service, which we've had
[11:54]
to cover the agreement through the end of the year. But we would be able to reduce those
[12:00]
borrowing costs if we were able to include this service in the tax levy, and then per the
[12:06]
PAA study, we have to look at the bigger picture of what were our options and what's most
[12:11]
cost effect. And the study recommended that there would be the reductions in fleet and equipment
[12:16]
and administrative personnel, especially as we get further into the agreement,
[12:21]
there's maybe some more equipment that we could share rather than buying things to soar at the
[12:25]
Lynn station alone. There could be some sharing opportunities. No additional costs for recruiting
[12:32]
hiring and training a standalone fire AMS department, which not only is it the challenge of the cost,
[12:38]
but also the time frame in retention.
[12:41]
We need to have at least, let's say, 10 people,
[12:44]
including a fire chief, and then to bring everybody up to that
[12:47]
paramedic level service that you're getting,
[12:49]
that's going to take a lot of time, and if they take a job elsewhere,
[12:52]
for a possession filled, we could very much be reduced to providing
[12:55]
with three people at the station to two,
[12:57]
which we've heard from some municipalities,
[12:59]
that's what they've had to do, which is very unfortunate.
[13:02]
Also cost avoidance for any kind of additional satellite station
[13:06]
on the north side and what you would have to provide with a standalone department.
[13:11]
And one of the things, too, is our supervisor Livingston mentioned his reduction
[13:15]
and his homeowner's insurance premiums.
[13:17]
So that's one of the things you could reach out and let's let your insurance provider know
[13:21]
that you're getting 24-7 Pyramus services, which could reduce your premium costs.
[13:27]
So just to give an example, we all know the revaluation just happened.
[13:31]
So I'm going to give you an example of what the, looking at your tax bill,
[13:35]
what the difference would be. So if your home with assess is career at a million dollars and then it's
[13:40]
moving up to $1.7 million, which is a 70% increase, which is the average that we're seeing across
[13:47]
the community, we looked at what that cost portion would be. And Lynn's portion would increase if you
[13:53]
include both our capital expenses and our firing missed staffing by 18% and the estimated annual tax
[14:00]
increase, or that $1.7 million dollar house is $489 per year, or $1.34 cents per day.
[14:10]
The town budget also does include some capital expenses that are related.
[14:15]
For one, purchasing fire mini-pumper to get better access to narrower roads and driveways,
[14:23]
fire AMS building modifications were changing the office spaces into dorms or bunk rooms for
[14:29]
or the 24-7 staffing, but also our other infrastructure, improved roads, drainage, bridges, replacing our highway bucket trucks, our storm sirens, and equipment replacement for emergency responders.
[14:43]
We're also going to have two ambulances, so we're going to have those equipped with paramedic level services.
[14:50]
So, with that said, I'll turn over to Chairman White's.
[14:54]
I think before we turn it over for questions, you know, your town board did not take this.
[15:00]
Like, this is something that we've been looking at for a number of years. As Chief Jones said, our amount of volunteers, or paid on call, our group that we had at the town of Lynn, continued to window over a number of years. We were really obligated to these people, and really wanted the existing model to work. And Chief Jones and the group attempted to try to recruit, to find other
[15:29]
people. Changing demographics, changing workloads, changing attitudes of employers, no longer
[15:38]
allow the person to be at a local company and to be able to leave a two o'clock in the afternoon
[15:43]
for a call. There used to be businesses right down the street here. They'd let their people come
[15:48]
to the fire station and go to call. That doesn't happen anymore due to a couple of things. Probably
[15:54]
work load at the employer also liability. And so with that demographics and changing lifestyles
[16:01]
have really forced this issue a bit. As Chief Peter said, it's not happening just here in the
[16:06]
Taliban. It's happening in many, many communities all over the United States and around the area.
[16:11]
If you look, you know, Fontana and Williams Bayup partnered over and while wall work, there's been
[16:16]
a partnership and a merger. It's happening all over the place. And so we didn't take it lightly.
[16:22]
We looked at the three options. One maintaining our existing model. We went back to the fire department at that time and said before we opt to make a decision on this study.
[16:35]
Can you tell us can you find a way to make this existing model work and they came back to us and they said no, they can't.
[16:42]
So at that point in time, we were left with two options.
[16:46]
Starting our own standalone fire EMS department in town of Lynn.
[16:50]
Probably take two years to implement and the cost would be much higher than a partnership.
[16:55]
Also by doing something like that, we have this wonderful area on the North Shore that's separated.
[17:01]
How do we access the North Shore and would we have to duplicate it on the North Shore?
[17:05]
So that became problematic from a financial perspective.
[17:09]
So thirdly, it was the partner.
[17:10]
Lake Geneva is strategically and geographically located in between South Shore and North Shore and so with that, you know what we're doing is using them with their resources and their staffing to staff at our building.
[17:25]
That's what we're proposing here. That's what we're doing this year. One of the things is our trucks are going to continue to be the same.
[17:32]
the equipment is going to be ours. It's the town of Lynn. When they go out of that station,
[17:37]
it's going to say town of Lynn Fire Department, staffed by the Lake Geneva people where we will
[17:42]
help share resources and get you in a more timely manner. One of the other interesting parts about
[17:49]
this, right now we're looking at $1.9 million, that staffing of three right now. Three is the minimum
[17:56]
that we can have to show up at a call, so we can't staff with two, you've got to start with three.
[18:01]
One of the beauties of it is, right now our annual call volume is about 300 calls a year
[18:06]
if I'm not mistaken.
[18:08]
Three people will get you to about 500 or 550 calls a year.
[18:12]
So we do have some wiggle room in there in the existing staffing that all of a sudden we're
[18:18]
not going to come back next year and say we've got to kick it to five people.
[18:22]
We've got to work our way up over time to get to those numbers of calls.
[18:25]
Will we get there?
[18:27]
Unfortunately, I'm sure we will do the two things, aging population number one, increased population in the township.
[18:34]
We have a lot of vacant land that's going to continue to be developed.
[18:37]
We need to provide these services to those people.
[18:40]
So I hope that gives you a better context of where it came from from the town board perspective and gives you a little bit more insight.
[18:48]
Mr. Hurlow.
[18:49]
Okay, questions? We can open it up for questions. So at this point in time, I will ask by the
[18:56]
raise of ants. If anybody has a question or comment, we can, you know, we as a group can answer.
[19:02]
We have the chiefs who are here. We also have Tim France, who is a representative from PAA,
[19:07]
public administration associates. They are the ones that did our fire EMS study for us. So he can
[19:13]
answer questions if it's directed at them. So please raise your hand and I'll try to grab
[19:19]
as quick as I can. I saw the first hand here. I would ask that you we got people remotely
[19:25]
so I would ask when you ask your question, come on up to the podium, state your name,
[19:30]
your address, your question, or your comment. Thank you. Thank you. My name is Linda Heyman. I live
[19:35]
at N2374, Noel Wood Drive in the Noel Wood subdivision on the North Shore.
[19:41]
First of all, I want to apologize for contributing to your problem. I am both a new full-time resident
[19:46]
and an aging resident as of last year. But nonetheless, regardless of our age, this is an important
[19:53]
service. Thankfully, we've never had to have calls by our police to my home, but if we did
[19:58]
have to call, I'd like to know that somebody came as quickly as possible. I have two questions,
[20:02]
mostly because I'm just uninformed. I know there's a fire station just work up here. Is that correct
[20:07]
for the town of Lynn. That's where it's located. That is then correct. So when I live in
[20:15]
Nolwood, I'm on the North Shore. If I have to call the fire department, where does that fire
[20:19]
truck come from? Presently and where will it come under this new plan?
[20:25]
So that doesn't change.
[20:27]
That is correct. So the staffing that you're looking for is additional personnel both at the city of
[20:33]
Geneva station and the Lynn station or help me understand that.
[20:37]
You bring up a great point and I don't think we explained that well enough.
[20:41]
Right now, all calls on the door shore are handled by the city of Lake Geneva from their
[20:47]
Lake Geneva fire station.
[20:49]
That will continue.
[20:52]
The staffing will be to staff our fire department location here on hillside road on the south
[21:00]
sure to handle the calls on the South Shore. Part of the agreement with the City of Lake Geneva is we will have the staff in here, but they will still continue to respond to all the calls on the North Shore. That's built into that cost that we got into the detail of it.
[21:18]
There is a cost reimbursement to them for the number of calls that they have on the North Shore as a percentage of their total calls.
[21:26]
Okay, thank you very much.
[21:28]
You're welcome.
[21:29]
Thank you.
[21:30]
So another hand over here on this side.
[21:37]
Name and address first and then comment or question, please.
[21:40]
I got 10 questions.
[21:42]
Charlie Handle, W3751 Franklin Street,
[21:46]
Fenda, retired EMS chief.
[21:50]
Just eyeball kind of cool keeping questions.
[21:54]
Staffing at.
[21:55]
That then prices are fire station here, three, with one paramedic, one or two paramedics.
[22:08]
Money for calls, where's it going?
[22:11]
You guys still build, don't we?
[22:13]
Correct.
[22:13]
So we still are recouping that, but that's recouping.
[22:16]
So offset sum to 1.9 million.
[22:19]
Yes.
[22:20]
So it's battered in.
[22:21]
Okay.
[22:23]
response time. What's national average? I thought the 15th kind of high.
[22:29]
That's what they
[22:30]
study children with our average national rate. Well, it's safe as well as kind of looking
[22:36]
for what state average. Backbooked in the day, I thought we used to roll out maximum of
[22:41]
10 minutes. They're higher at, yeah. Well, we're at the door at 7.25.
[22:48]
Okay, that's I just kind of I've seen that note and I'm 15 minutes kind of I can sit long on that if you want I you do have Kim brands on
[22:58]
Um, I think it's so safe I can ask him. Yeah, uh, Mr. Frans, if you could unmute yourself and speak to uh, Mr. Randall's question about
[23:05]
uh, state averages and uh, where those numbers come from that were in the study
[23:11]
There isn't any published state average data, but the national standard for combination
[23:17]
fire departments, which is what Lake Geneva and Tellano Lin is now, is that in urbanized
[23:28]
areas, the travel time should be less than four minutes, total response time of six minutes,
[23:32]
in urban areas, 10 minutes, and then extremely rural remote areas, 15 minutes.
[23:41]
So when we talk about averages, that's spread out over the entire township.
[23:45]
So we look at it more from a fractile perspective on those different areas,
[23:51]
rather than because some may say, well, it took 14 minutes to get to my home,
[23:56]
Not necessarily seven. Well, that's because an average takes into account half our less half our greater. So that's why we look at that fractal percentage, which right now you are less than eight minutes.
[24:11]
I believe is that 80% where you're looking at chief right now that you're meeting.
[24:19]
And that I would tell you is above average in the state because I do a lot of studies in different places and for mostly rural area that's excellent.
[24:35]
Thank you Jeff.
[24:41]
So the city employees are under, they would be under their HR, but it's depending on our rig versus if it's the city.
[24:52]
Okay, so that just isn't enough. Are we on the road for it?
[24:56]
Okay.
[24:58]
equipment ownership, the way it sounds, we're still owning it and we're getting another
[25:02]
rig coming.
[25:03]
We have a mini-pumper and any ambulance should be here so that we don't retire the
[25:08]
money.
[25:09]
We've got both rigs.
[25:10]
Right now, so we have more problems with the little.
[25:14]
Okay.
[25:15]
That's already ordered.
[25:17]
That should be here in March.
[25:21]
What a lot of guys, when I retired, we were trying to do it districts around more
[25:26]
County's any PDF or John is anybody even talked I know I talked to Jamie Dresa and he was
[25:34]
they're kind of starting to talk that way because everybody's in the same boat.
[25:41]
Yes and all the comments is let us say at the level they're not long to do that.
[25:50]
Okay so let's back burner.
[25:59]
If we could do a one year term and if that's going to be an option, that would be the best
[26:05]
not future.
[26:07]
I would not say it in their future.
[26:11]
Okay. Okay.
[26:16]
Call by 350. That's just rescue or is that that will not talk now is that that mutual aid to what what do we really roll out as?
[26:31]
We've been in F-300, but I mean, that's mutual aid. We're heading for Genoa City and that kind of stuff too, right?
[26:40]
That one.
[26:42]
Okay, districts, two ambulances, North Shore cost. We always had that contract. How much is that again?
[26:49]
So right now we don't pay anything right now so the intent was that once we had a full longer term agreement that we would come to a rate for that. So that's included in that 1.9 million.
[27:01]
Okay.
[27:02]
Just me being my background, I could see someone's got to approach the Wisconsin legislators, try getting it in the districts.
[27:16]
I don't know how you do it, but I do that.
[27:20]
Maintenance and stuff to write and cut from that, because you guys are still
[27:22]
then paid for maintenance and all that, we are, right?
[27:25]
We are. So we pay for the maintenance.
[27:29]
I had almost.
[27:31]
How much would deal can we give it to Lake Geneva.
[27:35]
And let them have our substation kind of thing out here.
[27:39]
just an option. That was thought of, but, you know, we're in the
[27:43]
infancy of this relationship. If for some reason it doesn't go well. Now you
[27:48]
gave up all your equipment. That's not a good decision to be in. Maybe down the
[27:52]
line, those would change. See, that's what I'm hoping you guys to say that done
[27:56]
deal. Okay, you know, do it this year and try finding the baby steps. Okay, thank
[28:02]
you. You're welcome. My
[28:15]
name is Andre Gibbs. I live at W4075.
[28:18]
Elgin Club Drive so I'm also on the North Shore and I think this has probably been answered but
[28:25]
I wanted to try and understand it a little bit better. A couple of questions. We had a one-year contract
[28:33]
previously and now we want to extend this longer. How long a time is there a bounded time or will it
[28:42]
just go until we decide, is it a five year contract?
[28:47]
Is it a 10 year contract?
[28:48]
How long does it, is it a permanent partnership?
[28:51]
How does it, how do we work that?
[28:53]
We're currently in a one year agreement with them for 2024.
[28:56]
Okay, for 24, 7 to be 65 coverage.
[29:00]
Okay.
[29:00]
We had previous ones where they did part time,
[29:03]
as Mr. Hurley said, 7 a.m. to 5 p.m.
[29:07]
We are still in the negotiation stage
[29:09]
with the city of Lake Geneva.
[29:11]
but we are looking at most likely a long-term agreement whether it be 15
[29:17]
year or 20 year. However, there would be an out clause on both sides should
[29:22]
something happen, but it would probably be a 24-36 month out clause because, you
[29:29]
know, on each side, there's going to take time. Legendable would have to roll back.
[29:34]
They're staffing. We'd have to roll up staffing and develop a department, so there
[29:39]
there will be an outclass and there will also be some caveats in there to renegotiate
[29:44]
if things change dramatically due to call-level volumes, development, etc.
[29:51]
That's what I was wondering if there was a, if it was a, say, 10 to 15-year contract, would
[29:55]
there be a re-negotiation so you could say, okay, you know,
[30:00]
So you could take a look at the cost and modify up or down as you needed to. Okay. So the, the, you mentioned the 489 per household, if there was a $1.7 million value on that household, is that 489 designated out in the, the tax bill or is that in addition to the tax bill that will be levied on the new values? So that would be looking at for the win portion on your tax bill.
[30:29]
So what portion of it is going towards Fire EMS staffing, if that was the value of that.
[30:34]
Okay.
[30:35]
So that's what you're asking, that the 489 is, that will be the representative number
[30:41]
more or less in the tax bill you'll see, Fire EMS 489.
[30:47]
Correct.
[30:47]
It won't be a separate item.
[30:49]
It'll be included in the Lynn portion.
[30:51]
Okay.
[30:51]
So it'll be grouped in there.
[30:53]
And one of the things to keep in mind, too, is that one year agreement, part of that's
[30:57]
already included in your tax bill.
[30:59]
So it's not like you're just jumping from $1.9 million from this year to next year because we have
[31:04]
one and a half million dollars in there. But there are some other capital expenses that we reviewed
[31:09]
that will be in the proposed budget and that including the mini-pumper, the building modifications,
[31:15]
there's some equipment for EMS services as well as other infrastructure costs. So that's where
[31:20]
that total estimate is an 18% increase for that value home year over year.
[31:26]
And that's that's the 489 number correct. So it's a little different because we're talking the total heavy versus but if you look at the 489 number, yes, that would be 18%
[31:36]
Okay, and then you use the term I was unfamiliar with it was volunteer on call. In other words, I was president at present at an accident on the North Shore.
[31:52]
And the fire came, fire trucks came, and I'm not sure if they were late Geneva, they might have been Elkhorn, but later on a bill was issued as well.
[32:04]
Does that also mean that you get a bill in addition to the part taking part of that budget within the tax?
[32:14]
So you would get our just for services, yes, that still does exist and it helps offset
[32:19]
taxes so that there's some balance there between the two.
[32:23]
So we do have fees for services based on the level of services that provide.
[32:27]
Okay.
[32:28]
So if a fire truck shows up or an or EMS, is there a, is it $500 that do we know what that
[32:35]
charge is per call?
[32:38]
We have a fee schedule that you can look at to see the numbers themselves.
[32:44]
Okay, is that a web?
[32:45]
I don't have them all in my list, they might have to say.
[32:47]
No, no, it's put up.
[32:49]
So we have a on the website or full annual fee.
[32:51]
It's on the website.
[32:52]
What they could do is on our fire emits landing page, include a link to it so that you can
[32:57]
see what those fees are.
[32:58]
Okay, so you'll get a general idea of what that would be per call.
[33:03]
Okay.
[33:03]
And keep in mind, you know, right now with or without, you know, going to this increased
[33:11]
cost, there still are those fees right now.
[33:13]
That's not going to change to go hand in hand that that's been in place already.
[33:18]
Has that has that been in place for a long time or I think a lot I was I was only surprised
[33:24]
because I had never been to I'd never been I was thought it was part of my taxes.
[33:28]
And so when I got an additional charge, I was surprised by that, and I didn't know that it was exterior of tax payments.
[33:39]
Has that existed for a while then?
[33:43]
As long as I've been here, I know that we reviewed these.
[33:46]
Probably 5% now.
[33:48]
Is it?
[33:49]
I did not know that.
[33:50]
If you think about it, we get a lot of calls and services there for people who don't live in the town of it.
[33:56]
So, therefore, you know, if we didn't have that fee, now we would all, all the taxpayers would be supplementing all the calls for the people that are from outside the taxi body itself.
[34:06]
So, we felt this was the fairest way to do it to recoup some of those costs as well.
[34:12]
Okay, just try to understand.
[34:13]
Nope, just try to explain.
[34:14]
All right, great. And then the meeting goes that is when people will come and vote on this.
[34:23]
That's right. And that will be in person only town electors, so meeting residents.
[34:28]
Well, that is our station. I'll be here.
[34:31]
Thank you very much. Thank you.
[34:36]
Anybody else? This is Tim Franz from PA. Did I just add something regarding those fees to clarify is that.
[34:44]
But the majority of those fees that are charged are for emergency medical services, which
[34:50]
are billed to health insurance, Medicare, Medicaid, whatever the particular patient has.
[34:58]
So that's standard practice in all departments.
[35:02]
When it comes to things like vehicle accidents, if there are departments that charge a fee for
[35:09]
the actual response to that at times that is also potentially something that can be passed
[35:17]
on to that person's insurance company.
[35:21]
So just wanted to clarify that.
[35:23]
Most of those fees that are charged by the department are things that are otherwise paid
[35:28]
for by insurance.
[35:31]
Thank you, Jim.
[35:33]
I think I saw a hand over here.
[35:44]
I think we all were a little shocked when we got our human assessment and we set a 70%
[35:51]
month in some cases.
[35:56]
Along with that, you're developing a substantial human sickness.
[36:02]
What do you think the mill rate doing with that volume of $7% more taxable money on our property?
[36:15]
Number one, when you have a reassessment, let's just say we're not here doing this fire in us right now.
[36:21]
Let's just say we had total taxes of $2 million last year.
[36:26]
I'm just going to use that number.
[36:29]
Total taxes were $2 million.
[36:31]
If we didn't ask for any money for FIER EMS and we didn't talk about net new construction,
[36:37]
our taxes would still be $2 million this year.
[36:41]
Because your assessment went up 50%, 60%, 70%, all it does is adjust the mill rate based
[36:49]
upon that level of taxes.
[36:51]
That doesn't mean that we got a 70% tax increase because the assessed value went up by 70%.
[36:58]
What it does is if somebody's assessed value went up by 50%, they'll share in a lesser
[37:04]
amount of taxes than they did last year.
[37:07]
If you went up by above 70%, 100%, you would pay a larger share.
[37:12]
But that $2 million is now split amongst that higher assessed valuation.
[37:18]
It doesn't give us a windfall of 70%.
[37:22]
Taxes are flat.
[37:22]
so I understand that.
[37:25]
It'll have a rich due to the
[37:30]
building that is blowing on underneath.
[37:33]
No, no, no man.
[37:36]
Yeah our net new constructions pretty minimal,
[37:39]
I think like 2025,000,
[37:41]
Greg over the year.
[37:43]
Right, that's why.
[37:46]
So, I guess,
[37:48]
I'm confused then because if you have
[37:51]
more should you get your taxes on $2 million or whatever you are, that is not whatever we
[38:02]
did last year, it's going to go up 50 percent or whatever. No, it is not. No, I just explained
[38:08]
that. Before our tax, our total assessed valuation was about $2.4 billion, $2.5 billion, the current
[38:19]
year and then it's going up to three. Now it's going up to about 3.6 billion. Your two million
[38:24]
dollars is split by that number. So in essence, the mill rate would go down and the tax amount
[38:32]
would stay the same. We got a lot going on this year because of the asking for the fire EMS money,
[38:40]
but in a normal reassessment year, other than net new construction, if all you did was your tax
[38:46]
amount that's there. It would be flat. Your taxes might go up more or they might go down because
[38:53]
if the average increases 70 percent, your house might be less than 70 percent. It might be greater
[39:00]
than 70 percent. If you nailed right at 70 percent, your taxes would be basically flat. If you're at
[39:07]
less than 70 percent, you may share in less of a tax burden. If you're greater than 70 percent,
[39:13]
you'd share any larger tax burden, but we did not receive a windfall of 70% because of the reassessment.
[39:24]
Your taxes will most likely go up approximately 18%.
[39:28]
Okay. See on that, I have another question. The one-year agreement that you have was like $1.4 million.
[39:37]
$1.5.
[39:41]
And I understand that you are looking at additional services by doing this combination.
[39:51]
Does it make any sense to prolong the one year of the event, maybe like you, if not,
[39:59]
if you said I don't know, maybe they want more, they want more, but I mean, I don't know
[40:05]
well Lake Geneva apartments with, I think there's Geneva, the town of Geneva, those people.
[40:13]
I saw all of these EMS tire apartments having the same struggles and who, I mean, in Lake
[40:21]
Geneva becoming the goal to, and you know, widening out a lot.
[40:27]
I mean, these red copen that, you know, we're not going to get the coverage we need for this.
[40:33]
The city does have a contract with the town of Geneva where they provide support similar to like what we see on the North Shore, but this is the one contract that they have with the town.
[40:44]
Is there a key for my missing anything?
[40:46]
So,
[40:52]
we provide services for the town of Geneva only about a quarter of the town of Geneva.
[40:58]
Not the whole entire town of Geneva.
[41:00]
City of Elkhorn provides the rest of the service for the town of Geneva.
[41:04]
Our contracts are based upon a amount of call for service based on that amount.
[41:09]
That's how they're charged.
[41:12]
So, that's how that works out.
[41:15]
We do not supply service to the town of Valencia.
[41:18]
And can we provide that service? Yes, we provide that service now. We continue to supply that service. So we have the ability to do that.
[41:27]
Did that answer it? Okay. Thank you.
[41:31]
So our question is.
[41:32]
I
[41:44]
have a question.
[41:46]
I have a question.
[41:47]
Okay, okay, okay, I just have a couple of questions to the players.
[41:53]
Alright, so that was two many and sometimes four is enough for a person out.
[42:08]
And I'm wondering whether or not,
[42:11]
in the firehouse? Do you go off with tree trucks? Do you take an engine?
[42:21]
Engine? Engine goes off for firecalls.
[42:24]
And the ambulance goes up on the street.
[42:29]
They take a pickup in the ambulance, so that if they only use paramedics, it all depends
[42:35]
what the call requires at the time of year.
[42:37]
But sometimes there are multiple calls where you've already depleted the personnel at one
[42:45]
very department.
[42:46]
It's going to take two or three times that long, but the next one to actually reach the
[42:53]
scene or the second scene and all that works out.
[42:55]
I'm just wondering what the bad guy personnel that might be cruising in when you get it all.
[43:05]
So how we work with that, we work with our mutual aid partners, just like we always have
[43:09]
quite frankly, just like I said earlier, we're all feeling the similar issues that the
[43:16]
tunnel then has, right?
[43:18]
So throughout our county, if you look at this, there's a lot of folks partnering together
[43:23]
and that's why it's because the challenge for the paid-on-call staff.
[43:29]
So we, we, a fire, I'll take a fire, for instance, right?
[43:33]
We use the Mavis system quite a bit for that and we, that's why we have automatic aid coming in on a fire now.
[43:39]
It's much different than it was before before one single department would be toned out for a working fire.
[43:45]
Now we have actually four departments respond just for that reason.
[43:50]
We also use change of quarters to come in and get back fill our stations and we back fill both stations automatically just for that reason.
[43:57]
Sure.
[43:58]
Does that?
[43:58]
Can I say a couple of words?
[44:01]
It hadn't been part of the discussion, I don't know how.
[44:04]
I don't know if you just want to.
[44:05]
Yeah, there are plenty of things.
[44:06]
Good question.
[44:07]
Thank you.
[44:08]
Thank you, Dale.
[44:10]
Other questions?
[44:13]
Yes, sir.
[44:23]
Mr. Chairman.
[44:24]
Alan Pollack.
[44:25]
Mr. Chairman.
[44:28]
Alan Pollack.
[44:28]
Mr. Chairman.
[44:28]
Alan Pollack.
[44:28]
Alan Pollack.
[44:29]
Mr. Chairman.
[44:30]
Mr. Chairman.
[44:31]
Mr. Chairman.
[44:34]
Mr. Chairman.
[44:36]
Mr. Chairman.
[44:37]
started with the entire department, he was on 55 years, I was on for almost 20 years,
[44:44]
so I know a little bit about what's going on on Paul for everything he's doing.
[44:49]
I mean, I read the study twice, I said, they made an estimate and they should read it,
[44:54]
and answer a lot of their questions right off the back.
[44:58]
Having said that, I'm going to
[45:00]
Is, will this be a line item on the backfill, like the garbage bill, or the dispute that we did, may I include it? Okay.
[45:10]
Q. I think you said we have six active requirements. Is it not between fire and anti-advertisement? All right, part of the DMF. How many are on the page of the roll here?
[45:25]
I mean, you were somebody else?
[45:27]
Yes.
[45:28]
Thank you.
[45:30]
Um, second.
[45:34]
I try to go along with, uh, trying, but I can see where we have to wait a little while to make it work.
[45:43]
I think in the long run, we'd be better off if we just contracted with Lake Geneva and we didn't have to pull the equipment and maintain.
[45:53]
And I think it worked better for them.
[45:58]
They have all the equipment.
[46:00]
And they can have the firepower.
[46:02]
We get some kind of recuperation for all that
[46:05]
to create any equipment or whatever.
[46:06]
I realize that's a little way down the road,
[46:09]
but that's something I like to see happen.
[46:12]
And while we're at it, I don't think
[46:14]
we're going to need the firepower anymore.
[46:16]
That's a big expense that we don't need.
[46:19]
That would help with our situations
[46:21]
as far as paying for the legislative services.
[46:26]
There's a lot of things that we've been doing all the time.
[46:28]
We've got to work outside the box.
[46:31]
There's been some of this stuff.
[46:33]
And it was a benefit.
[46:34]
Again, what we've got is by state statute,
[46:37]
it would be our required to find fire protection
[46:39]
either as well as self or contract,
[46:42]
but something to think about.
[46:44]
I know what it likes to hear.
[46:45]
We are required to provide clean protection.
[46:48]
That's about the million thought of the year.
[46:50]
so we can have the county takeover some of that.
[46:53]
That was like in a burden to the fire protection.
[46:56]
This was a fire EMS meeting, Mr. Pauli.
[46:58]
This is a fire EMS meeting, Mr. Pauli.
[47:03]
I'm sorry, but it's been fun.
[47:05]
I'm sorry, but going back to the equipment,
[47:08]
we did discuss that as we were going through negotiations
[47:11]
and we objectively and conscientiously opted
[47:17]
opted to maintain our equipment at this point in time due to it being in the
[47:22]
infancy of the relationship. That might be one thing that could change and be
[47:27]
renegotiated down the line, but we want to get to know each other as we're going
[47:32]
through and we're putting this together. I agree with that. But the thing's going to be
[47:36]
to keep in mind. I see the talk about the mini-monger. The red card should be good
[47:42]
We have five or two or three years now.
[47:44]
I'm going to find the answer than last.
[47:48]
We're going to have to do it.
[47:49]
Understand.
[47:50]
Thank you.
[47:50]
You're welcome.
[47:51]
Any
[47:55]
other questions in the audience this evening.
[48:03]
Time in ourselves pretty well.
[48:05]
I will ask I will ask one more time.
[48:08]
Are there any additional questions one last time by anybody in the audience before we stop the public comments for this evening?
[48:14]
If you have a follow-up question, yeah, please come on up.
[48:25]
I really wanted to ask the question then.
[48:30]
How long does it use that?
[48:32]
Is that an infection use for our users?
[48:40]
We've used it, I think, on one call.
[48:43]
A few guys follow, the recipe calls for the founding.
[48:46]
We've used it for one choir call.
[48:49]
It's a tool and tool back.
[48:50]
So the day we really needed, it's going to work out perfectly.
[48:56]
Is that, you know, it's just the tool that I do about it?
[49:01]
Originally,
[49:07]
in a previous study that was commissioned by the board,
[49:13]
that fireboat was looked at and put into place before I was involved,
[49:18]
but I read the study, and it was put in because of the challenges
[49:24]
which is that are in place with some of the driveways and some of the egress and ingress to some of the link.
[49:35]
What is going into play?
[49:37]
It does have a use.
[49:39]
I know I've been on first thing, but I have two players that have come to that and been very used.
[49:46]
So, at the end of the news, that's why there's been a conversation as you've heard about this many
[49:51]
popular that Mr. Bronsworth together to study, that talks about the many popular.
[49:57]
The reason behind this many popular is, again, for the interest of the issues for the
[50:03]
audience, because we have some challenges to address, for instance.
[50:07]
So, another way to accomplish that is getting a smaller vehicle to get income strived.
[50:13]
So I don't know if that's good, it has a good purpose, it's just one of those on eye-hung
[50:21]
work with a great job, you haven't had to use it as a study data, so I hope that answers
[50:27]
your question.
[50:28]
Yeah, we do use it though, so attentionally surrounding it's our current one, isn't it?
[50:34]
And having that technology on it, there, and so on our things like that, we're tied, well,
[50:41]
also. Thank you for bringing that up.
[50:45]
Thank you for the additional questions.
[50:49]
Go down
[50:57]
and we'll continue to play by a whole short. The 1.9 million sets include some
[51:04]
capital expenditures. Are those only one year and might it be reduced to about two years?
[51:11]
They're separate. So the 1.9 covers the North Shore staffing at our station plus
[51:16]
management, including our overall tax
[51:19]
lending for the upcoming year includes additional capital expenses,
[51:23]
windows being the mini-pumper, the building, and then some of the equipment.
[51:28]
But that was one of the key changes.
[51:31]
Correct. There could be other capital items, of course.
[51:35]
Oh, of course. No, no. There could be other capital one time expenses,
[51:39]
and we did speak to, there could be more opportunities as this relationship
[51:42]
continues to grow to share equipment, where we could reduce some of those capital
[51:46]
costs, but the 1.9 is really the staffing piece that we're requesting for.
[51:51]
Thank you.
[51:52]
Sure.
[51:52]
Thank you.
[51:55]
Yes, sir.
[51:57]
Come on out.
[52:05]
Speaker, N1925 sunny side.
[52:08]
I'm like Mr. Poliak.
[52:10]
I know nothing of how fire departments or even as departments work.
[52:16]
And I just want to clarify.
[52:18]
This is primarily a medical emergency response issue.
[52:23]
issue, it is not a fire fighter issue, it's not an actor.
[52:33]
No,
[52:38]
that's.
[52:39]
So this is a setting up of all hazard departments.
[52:42]
So the three folks that are in the firehouse that will be staffing the station on, this side
[52:46]
of the lake are duly and role certified to go to fires as well as emergency medical calls.
[52:54]
The
[52:57]
call there's a
[53:00]
fair job is to notify the volunteer requirement.
[53:05]
No, they will respond to the call and then the paid-on call or the part-time folks that are still in the department.
[53:11]
They
[53:16]
like to need your station and other usually in the station will come as well.
[53:20]
So typically, if there's a fire, there's no concern that there would be a lack of fire requirements.
[53:32]
I mean, that's the biggest concern that you're looking to respond.
[53:37]
But if I could be talking about earlier, if I'm talking earlier, the fear is that fire
[53:42]
doubles every 30 seconds.
[53:45]
So whether we get that as a group of water, I'm certainly going to be doing those things.
[53:49]
We want to get as many people there as we can, that's bad.
[53:54]
So, typically there are enough problems here to respond.
[53:59]
No, that why everyone in this model is starting out with three people
[54:03]
to address the issue because she's going to struggling with a data call set.
[54:08]
It was down in three people to find out.
[54:12]
What we would do is rely upon Davis Mutual Aid,
[54:16]
Fox Service, which is basically right now even before we got in the relationship
[54:21]
with Lane Geneva when Lynn would go up. It's a big fire. We don't have enough people.
[54:27]
We call them from Fontana, Williams Bay, Lake Geneva, Elkhorn, Bloomfield to come on in.
[54:34]
And we do the same thing to help those neighborhoods. We just get our initial crew there.
[54:40]
And then you have to call in reinforcement through the Mavis system.
[54:44]
So, is it good if they're just a lot less tolerant here or some of the guys to be out there
[54:50]
and all of us if it's hard to find anyone to knock on the door to bring it in.
[54:59]
Sorry.
[55:00]
So, the community in the age of the community is older and nobody wants to come and do this
[55:06]
now.
[55:10]
I think that answers my question.
[55:12]
Thank you all for your service.
[55:14]
Thank you.
[55:15]
Thank you for the questions.
[55:16]
One
[55:20]
last time, any additional questions from anybody here in the town hall audience this evening,
[55:29]
right? Then I will ask we have a couple people that are on virtually.
[55:35]
Do any of you have a question that you would like to ask today if so please raise your hand.
[55:49]
seen none. I guess I will look to our other board members anything that either
[55:54]
Maureen Zimmerman or Alex Palmer would like to add for this evening.
[56:02]
Well then I'd like to thank everybody for their attendance this evening like
[56:09]
the same Mr. Frans for this comments in but we appreciate it very much to him and
[56:14]
for the the you know program that you put together from PAA the study
[56:20]
to help us Chief Jones, Chief Peters. Thank you very much for enlightening us and everybody,
[56:26]
thank you for your comments and questions. We appreciate you being here and we look forward to
[56:32]
having all of you join us on October 7th at 7 p.m. here in the town hall. Please be advised that
[56:39]
for that meeting, if you need to be in person to be able to vote, you won't be able to vote via
[56:47]
Zoom or electronic and the voting will be limited to electors, meaning people who are registered to vote in the town of Lynn.
[57:01]
Say that one more time.
[57:02]
A photo ID would still be required to be seen as what you're voting on election day.
[57:10]
Yes.
[57:10]
Yes.
[57:12]
Yes.
[57:13]
Yes.
[57:19]
Yes.
[57:19]
Yes.
[57:24]
Yes.
[57:26]
Yes.
[57:26]
on electors have to approve the levy increase by the Department of Revenue tonight.
[57:34]
Okay, for the levy increase, it needs to go to the electors because we're exceeding the
[57:42]
allowable.
[57:44]
No, not the contract.
[57:47]
Any other questions?
[57:49]
At this point in time, I'd like to ask.
[57:51]
of
[57:55]
the home of that residence?
[57:57]
Yes.
[57:59]
We have to be a registered board.
[58:03]
So you made a decision to resign here.
[58:06]
20 days from seconds to October that you just show
[58:10]
what I mean.
[58:12]
So, all the stages required to file a contribution.
[58:20]
So, all right.
[58:22]
be nothing else to have motion to adjourn and move to adjourn. Second, follow the