Agenda
[0:07]
Interviews for Boards and Commissions
[3:58]
1. CALL TO ORDER – John B. Lewis, Chair
[5:02]
4. COMMUNITY ANNOUNCEMENT
[7:59]
5. PUBLIC COMMENT ON NON-AGENDA ITEMS
[8:27]
6. CONSENT AGENDA ITEMS
[9:43]
7. ENGINEERS
[11:12]
8. MANAGER’S REPORT
[40:17]
9. PUBLIC WORKS
[42:17]
10. SOLICITORS REPORT
[1:07:33]
11. SUPERVISORS REPORTS
[1:08:49]
12. OTHER BUSINESS
[1:08:55]
13. APPOINTMENTS/REAPPOINTMENTS TO BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS
[1:10:00]
14. ADDITIONAL PUBLIC COMMENT ON NON-AGENDA ITEMS IF NEEDED
Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[0:09]
Good evening. This is the portion of the meeting before the general meeting where we're actually performing interviews, reports and commissions.
[0:17]
And our first person, our only person is Ms. Dakota D. Matteo.
[0:23]
Demandio. Okay. Sorry about that.
[0:25]
And you're an applicant for the Citizens Traffic Commission.
[0:29]
And thank you so much for applying and volunteering in the community.
[0:33]
these are relatively straightforward ask it's a couple questions and then later there'll be a vote on that.
[0:42]
I'll ask one question one, motivated you to apply to be a member of the CIS and Traffic Commission.
[0:48]
Yeah, so I'm very passionate about pedestrian safety, specifically walkers and bikers.
[0:54]
So I'm a Chair from Philadelphia, a Chairman of a BlackRock Road, so that's kind of what got me into traffic commission.
[1:00]
just ask some questions.
[1:02]
I mentioned there is an open spot, so I'm also seeing my door and I'm struggling with
[1:06]
some like data analysis potentially.
[1:09]
I'm a background in data analysis.
[1:11]
I got a good help out.
[1:13]
So that's kind of what brought me here today.
[1:17]
Supervisor McCartney has been joining us.
[1:19]
I apologize.
[1:19]
I didn't realize he was here.
[1:21]
Yes.
[1:22]
Where was your onion?
[1:22]
Sure.
[1:25]
Thank you for applying and coming for us.
[1:28]
In terms of, you just, it sounds like you've been to some CTC meetings.
[1:32]
Yeah.
[1:33]
All right, that's good.
[1:34]
I'm wondering if, one, what you, obviously, I'm assuming it's something on Black
[1:42]
Rock Road that got you interested, if you could speak about that a little bit in your experience
[1:45]
with the CTC and then how you would use your background in data analysis and other
[1:52]
things to work with the team to do that.
[1:54]
Sure.
[1:55]
So, I guess there's probably another follow-up to the Black Rock Road, but the initial kind of thing raised was there was like a Facebook post about the canal path.
[2:06]
So, there were just concerning things in the comments section, but someone had posted, you know, how to make a, I guess, make a complaint of sorts of the traffic mission.
[2:15]
So, I'm a fan of if you complain about something, you should, you know, get your hands dirty and do it.
[2:20]
So I honestly think that the speed limit might need to be brought down because I found
[2:26]
out there's a 10 mile an hour grace period for people driving, which like 45 miles an hour
[2:32]
between a canal path and like a state mandated bike road, I think is pretty high when you
[2:38]
people walking in bike riders and it's not a state road, so it's something the township
[2:43]
could do something about I think, so kind of that's how I would like to get more involved
[2:48]
with it. I'm not sure there's scope of abilities right now. I know a lot of it's, you know,
[2:53]
through local jurisdictions. So in terms of data analysis in the meeting, they're bringing
[2:58]
up like deer strikes that they're pulling from police traffic data. They just seem to be
[3:03]
struggling with it a little. And it's something I know how to do very quickly.
[3:10]
Thank you. This was a bloody. Yeah. I knew you had been at meetings, especially, you know,
[3:17]
Thank you for knowing what to state road and what to
[3:19]
challenge your road and how we have less control over
[3:22]
some of them than the others.
[3:24]
You've had four key points that took me months to figure out
[3:27]
on citizen's traffic.
[3:28]
So thank you.
[3:29]
Thank you so much for raising your hand.
[3:32]
Thank you.
[3:32]
Supervisor Ross?
[3:34]
I don't have any questions, but thank you very much for
[3:36]
applying.
[3:36]
Thanks so much.
[3:38]
We're done shooting shortly.
[3:41]
At this time, I'm going to call the formal public meeting
[3:44]
order.
[3:58]
Just for the record, the quote before I called it order, this is where I was a grandeur mentioned
[4:03]
that you went to the number one university in the world for your masters.
[4:11]
So, that's certainly pushing good stead.
[4:15]
Yeah, and your undergrad was awesome too, so those are all fine universities.
[4:20]
With that, I will call them me to order, and we're going to begin with the pledge of allegiance.
[4:37]
Do the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with the great injustice
[4:44]
for all.
[4:51]
Okay.
[4:51]
Supervisor McCartney.
[4:52]
Here.
[4:53]
All right.
[4:54]
Present.
[4:54]
This is the supervisor, Granger, supervisor Ross, here, and supervisor Blundee.
[5:00]
I'm here.
[5:01]
Okay, with that, we've completed the roll call now on the community announcements.
[5:05]
I remind you, this portion of the agenda, residents, youth organizations may call in to
[5:09]
make a special announcement or contact the township at lmt.org to request a special announcement
[5:15]
to be added to the agenda.
[5:16]
The yardly farmers market will be at the community center at 1550 Oxford Valley Road from 10
[5:23]
on Saturday. That's this Saturday, December 21st, last chance for those
[5:29]
who gifts that you might be thinking of. There's other stuff at the farmers market,
[5:33]
but it's here at the community center. You don't want to miss it. Now on Friday,
[5:36]
a little make the town trip is going to be hosting another blood drive for the Red Cross
[5:39]
right here from 12 to 5 p.m. in the meeting room right here again. And I'm going to
[5:45]
tell you right now, I donate the last time I'm here. The cookies were solid. The music
[5:50]
was rocking. It was a 70s mix that I found very good. So if you haven't planned to donate
[5:57]
blood, you're going to want to definitely do that.
[5:59]
John, can I jump in for a second?
[6:01]
Sure.
[6:01]
Thanks. So we were asked to schedule. We've had four blood drives ready this year. This is
[6:08]
something we've been doing regularly since the endemic. The Red Cross asks us if we could
[6:13]
put on another day this day because there's such a shortage. And unlike most of our other
[6:19]
of blood drives. We have plenty of opening still. And I know it's a holiday season. It's hard
[6:23]
for people to make this kind of commitment right now. But if there's anything that anyone
[6:29]
who has time, I can tell you there's plenty of spots. 12-5, please consider making an appointment.
[6:36]
We usually sell out this time where we're not even close.
[6:40]
And along those lines, I would be one of the folks, but I donated our last drive and so I'm like
[6:45]
five days shorter, seven days short of the cycle.
[6:51]
So, you know, we're entering the holiday season.
[6:54]
I believe this year, Hanukkah and Christmas synced up.
[6:57]
So, that's all, everybody's got that same day there.
[7:00]
But what folks should be thinking about is, hey, is there something I can be doing
[7:04]
to help others that is of almost no cost to me?
[7:07]
And I get free cookies and rock and tunes.
[7:11]
So, again, make that pitch.
[7:13]
To sign up for more information, go to RedCrossBlood.org and her sponsored code LowerMakeField.
[7:20]
And if for some reason that date doesn't work for you, you can find other locations, but we'd love to have you here.
[7:25]
The Environmental Advisory Council is hosting the first Styrofoam Collection event for 2025 on Saturday, January.
[7:30]
The road, along with your clean white styrofoam, you can bring natural quirks, cleaned pill bottles with tops and batteries.
[7:37]
If you have any questions, you can check out the calendar on our website at lmt.org.
[7:42]
And remember, it's Christmas season, holiday season, you're going to have a lot of white styrofoam from all those packing things,
[7:48]
but no packing peanuts. I've been told that we can't recycle those for some reason.
[7:52]
And that completes our community announcements. At this time, we're going to invite public comment on non-agenda item.
[7:59]
So if there's an issue you're concerned about that's not on the agenda and you would like to address the board and the public,
[8:06]
you're welcome to come up to the days, just give us your name.
[8:10]
And whether you're a lower-maked resident or not.
[8:13]
And I'm not seeing anybody rushing the days, so while that's not happening, I'm going to ask,
[8:18]
do we have any callers on the line?
[8:21]
No callers.
[8:22]
All right.
[8:23]
With that, we'll move on to agenda item six.
[8:25]
This is the consent agenda items and these are non-controversal items that we'll put together.
[8:33]
If there's any member of the board that would like to remove one of the items from the consent agenda and have that dealt with specifically,
[8:41]
now is the time to ask for that. If there's any concern to the public with any of the consent agenda items, they're also welcome as well.
[8:49]
As I look around is there any just a quick question and where's the budget be approval for the budget?
[8:55]
With that.
[8:56]
That's on our manager's report.
[8:58]
Yeah.
[8:58]
Thank you.
[8:59]
I wouldn't put that in the confidant.
[9:00]
I didn't know.
[9:07]
Of course.
[9:07]
I see it.
[9:08]
I'm not seeing any desire to remove any items from the consent agenda with that.
[9:16]
I'll entertain a motion if there's one.
[9:17]
So moved. Second. All right. With that, I'll call the question. All those in favor of the consent agenda item signify by saying aye.
[9:25]
All right.
[9:26]
All right.
[9:27]
Good.
[9:29]
Those opposed opposed opposed.
[9:31]
Okay. Thank you.
[9:34]
Let the record reflect that the motion passed for one.
[9:39]
We'll move on to agenda item seven engineers report general project updates.
[9:46]
Thank you, Mr. Chair and fellow board members, our only update is that the 2024 road program is being closed out.
[9:55]
Everything else was outlined in our engineers report, and I'm happy to answer any questions that the board has.
[10:01]
Thanks.
[10:02]
Any questions?
[10:04]
I don't know if this is a question for you or a question, Derek.
[10:08]
But I know there was a question about over on quarry, like it is a road that was done
[10:15]
as part of last year, it seems to be buckling a little bit, and wondering if we have any
[10:21]
update on whether or not we can fix that.
[10:29]
Good evening supervisors.
[10:31]
Yes, we did try to see if Pico with their gas work that they're doing on women herps to
[10:39]
if they would take some responsibility of that. Of course they didn't and I can't really argue
[10:44]
with that. I don't think it's being caused by that. Any remediation work would be done solely
[10:49]
by the township on the township's time at this point. It was probably an incorrect asphalt.
[10:53]
We need a stronger asphalt mix than that intersection. It's what the engineers are telling us.
[10:58]
So we would have to replace it on our dime when that time comes.
[11:02]
Okay, not an answer. I love
[11:04]
but thank you for the answer. Yeah. Yeah.
[11:08]
With that, we'll move on to agenda item eight managers report.
[11:12]
Thank you very much for having us to share members of the board.
[11:15]
The first item on my section of the agenda is consideration of resolution 24-31, fixing tax rates
[11:24]
and special levees and adopting the 2025 budget.
[11:28]
I don't know if you want to make a motion on that or I do have some commentary on the item.
[11:32]
So Mr. Chair, I don't know how you want me to.
[11:34]
Would you like to make a motion?
[11:36]
I'll make the motion.
[11:37]
So moved.
[11:38]
Is there a second?
[11:39]
Second.
[11:40]
Okay.
[11:41]
Okay.
[11:41]
So, as the board is aware, the budget has been available for public inspection.
[11:50]
It's been available since your adoption that occurred in November, and has been available
[11:58]
again for inspection throughout, sorry, I'm sorry I was looking for something.
[12:03]
So it was made available on 1127-2024 again through today, no comments were received from the
[12:11]
general public as the board is aware we did receive a request from the Environmental Advisory Council
[12:18]
to restore their proposed 2025 funding to match their 2024 funding.
[12:27]
That was a difference of about $1,500.
[12:33]
In addition to that, there were a series of changes that minor changes that have been made
[12:41]
by staff during the course of the past month.
[12:45]
One had to do with the contracted services line item in the 400 section of the budget.
[12:53]
That expense was reduced by $7,170 to reflect the cost of the recommended proposal for
[13:02]
PADCD Strategic Management Planning Program Consulting fees, which is an agenda item after
[13:10]
this item. Again, the preliminary budget reflected the higher cost of the two finalists for those
[13:15]
for that service, but we did our recommendation is the lower of the two costs proposals.
[13:25]
There were slight reductions in both engineering and legal fees for 2025. Again, reducing each of
[13:40]
the 2024 budget so there were some savings that could be captured there. Again as I mentioned
[13:47]
we did increase the environmental advisory councils budget back to the 4,000 which again is
[13:54]
consistent with the 2024 budget for the EAC and then we were able to make a reduction also in the
[14:04]
equipment line item for IT or IT equipment, we reduce that line item by 10,000.
[14:12]
Again, that's generally an allowance line item.
[14:14]
There's no specific purchases that are contemplated, but we reduce that down.
[14:19]
Part of this exercise, just for background, was done because of the conversation that we had
[14:25]
previously about the opportunity with civic plus, which again is another agenda item moving down my
[14:33]
of the agenda, so we did revise the budget to include cost for the civic plus, which is the website portion initial term costs, but again the net change in the general fund was actually a reduction of slightly less than a thousand dollars, so very minors.
[15:00]
Actually, a slight reduction. The only other changes that were made had to do with Park and Rec Fund.
[15:08]
Line item 451, 247, which was a special events line item for the Park and Rec Fund.
[15:14]
We reduced that by $16,000, as I noted in an email to you.
[15:21]
There was money that was set aside to do sort of a community events such as the community
[15:29]
pride day that you've done in the past.
[15:33]
Even with that reduction there is still an additional $20,000 in that line item for purposes
[15:39]
of doing some sort of community events.
[15:41]
That's the decision of the of the Township and the Board of Supervisors.
[15:44]
And then the contracted services line item 451-300 was increased by the cost associated with the transition to civic rack for recreation management software.
[15:59]
So again, a net reduction of $330.
[16:03]
So just some slight tweaks that have occurred over the course of the past month, consistent with sort of the charge of direction that we got from the Board of Supervisors.
[16:12]
To see if we could accommodate the opportunity through civic rack within the confines of the plenary budget.
[16:20]
We were able to do that through these adjustments.
[16:23]
So happy to answer any questions that anyone may have.
[16:28]
I apologize for the detail going through this.
[16:30]
I just wanted to make a note of that.
[16:35]
Do you remember how many questions?
[16:37]
Yeah, I have some questions.
[16:38]
I hit the button first.
[16:40]
Damn.
[16:41]
I do.
[16:43]
I don't know that I'm startled, I don't know that I'm not excited, but I didn't realize
[16:48]
that there was strong direction from the board on Civic plus slash Civic wreck.
[16:53]
What I do remember is some conversation that they were interested in coming here, so their
[16:58]
original quote was lessened so that it came in under the vendor we were going with, but
[17:05]
we had some questions about, well what about the year after and what does it actually look
[17:09]
So, could you provide some details on that, please?
[17:13]
Sure.
[17:14]
Happy to.
[17:15]
So, again, that both quotes were in your packet.
[17:20]
So, there's two solutions.
[17:22]
The first quote, again, had to do with website.
[17:25]
The initial term cost with the implementation was 24,71150.
[17:33]
And then the annual recurring service charges after that.
[17:38]
after the initial 12-month period or 7,412 dollars annually, so those are the ongoing sort of expenses beyond implementation on the website side.
[17:53]
And then on the recreation management side, the initial term cost was 15,66937 within an annual reoccurring service charge of 3,032,000.
[18:07]
137.50 moving forward, there is language in the proposal that talks about sort of an annual increase
[18:15]
or uplift after the relationship progresses, but that's what we know at this point.
[18:25]
So, and that's, I guess the thinking is, so, 15,669.37 to 32,000 next year, and then as you
[18:34]
said upward from there, and the thinking is kind of to roll it out from Park and Recta
[18:39]
other departments in theory, additional costs associated with this moving forward.
[18:47]
So, the Park and Recta is a specific, the recreation management is a specific module that
[18:51]
they have.
[18:52]
Again, they have other solutions.
[18:56]
There's no requirement to pursue those other solutions, but there would be an opportunity
[19:00]
if the town should choose to do some moving forward.
[19:04]
But that's the whole reason, right?
[19:06]
That's that.
[19:06]
I mean, in part it was some of the direction it was that we have these disparate systems
[19:11]
to try to create a unification of those systems, create single sign-on from user, from a user perspective.
[19:18]
Civic plus with their suite of solutions does present that.
[19:21]
They are the leader in doing governmental websites throughout the country.
[19:25]
Bucks County's website is currently through Civic plus.
[19:29]
So that was really what was I think some of the discussion that occurred at the Board of Supervisors meeting and then there was some direction that was provided to eMac to look at that as sort of an objective as well.
[19:42]
They went through they did a review they spoke with civic plus they're recommending moving in the direction.
[19:49]
Again, Monica, I don't know if you want to talk specifically.
[19:53]
I mean the recreation management piece is probably the most impactful in terms of the efficiency of the work that your staff is doing.
[19:59]
I don't know if you want to comment on that again.
[20:02]
Dave, well, she's walking up here.
[20:05]
You know, we talked about the timeframe for implementation wouldn't be right away, so there's that issue.
[20:11]
And then if we can also, and I think this applies to the parking rack too, but look at, you know, if we're picking up these programs,
[20:18]
then some others that should be replaced, I would think, so some of the other spends that we have might go away.
[20:24]
Yeah, correct. So when we're talking about
[20:27]
stuff when you're spends, I mean, that's not the net cost
[20:31]
of the township because there's existing costs being incurred in those
[20:34]
areas, but I don't know if you want to talk about just workflow
[20:38]
and the efficiencies associated with the right way.
[20:40]
So I have a separate agenda, I know specifically for civic
[20:43]
law.
[20:44]
Do you want me to wait for that?
[20:45]
Sorry.
[20:46]
I mean, that's fine.
[20:49]
Yeah.
[20:50]
I can wait.
[20:51]
Well, you're welcome to stay there.
[20:52]
So again, I mean, I guess the supervisor, Blundee's point that the budget document has been adjusted to sort of reflect the ability to do that.
[21:02]
Again, you know, while there's, you know, the budget document is a planning document.
[21:09]
It doesn't necessarily obligate you to do things. Now I do realize that there's subsequent actions on the agenda that are making commitments to do certain things.
[21:18]
But the thinking was to modify the budget to accommodate it again if the desire is not to proceed on that agenda item and then again
[21:31]
There's no don't harm no foul in terms of in terms of the modifications that were made a couple of the questions and other
[21:39]
I think sure
[21:41]
They've been some some of the other items who outline has changes since since the last budget
[21:46]
It looks like there's been a reduction
[21:51]
in 412 and 414, those are fees for engineering legal fees.
[21:57]
Yeah, simple new, there's no services, essentially.
[22:00]
Each at $5,000 to reflect 2024 projected.
[22:06]
Yeah, so the engineering was reduced down to be consistent with the 2024 budget
[22:10]
and then the legal was reduced to be generally consistent with the projected spend in 2024.
[22:17]
Okay, in terms of projects that we have going on or other items, we have that may require
[22:24]
those, you know, I know, in speaking with...
[22:30]
They may be at or close to going above budget that will go into next year, et cetera, I'm thinking more of the engineer exciting not legal fees, I think you've been okay just saying.
[22:41]
So I want to make sure that we address that accordingly.
[22:46]
Yeah, so this 400, there's multiple engineering line items in your budget, some are more project-based engineering. This is just general engineering, so that was reduced.
[22:58]
that's going to be on a little bit on you to manage that
[23:02]
manage to that number.
[23:06]
And then what is what, you know,
[23:09]
$10,000 reduction in minor equipment on the IT side
[23:13]
is that related to some of the IT services that we'll be talking about later tonight.
[23:19]
I think that's not-
[23:20]
This was sort of an allowance, a general allowance that we put in
[23:24]
for just sort of incremental upgrades to
[23:27]
to equipment really, and so some of this was a guess if you will, for just to, again, have
[23:39]
some allowance in the event that things materialize or there's needs that occur over
[23:43]
the course of the year.
[23:44]
You're comfortable with that reduction.
[23:46]
I think we're fine, and again, if something significant was to materialize, then we would obviously
[23:54]
come back and have a conversation on that.
[23:55]
And I think that maybe, I don't know if it's the biggest number one, but the one that
[24:01]
I maybe didn't notice the first time around, was some significant amount of money for
[24:08]
some type of event akin to maybe a smaller version of community pride day, that we had
[24:15]
previously put on pause as we get things squared away.
[24:18]
I don't know that we had any discussion as a board as to whether or not we wanted to reinstate
[24:24]
that correct and what we would do there. So I don't know if the board but I haven't given
[24:31]
it a ton of thoughts. So I'm curious about what the board thinks about if we just
[24:34]
remove that entirely this year or if we have thoughts on what we'd actually want to do
[24:38]
this year, given where we're at. I don't just thinking about it all loud.
[24:45]
I'd be I think this year given everything we'll be looking at. I'd probably be okay removing
[24:49]
it from the budget. Do you know the number? Because I was in a way.
[24:55]
The budget was reduced by 16,000, but it still includes $20,000.
[25:00]
So I think originally it was $30,000, and Dave can correct me if I could.
[25:03]
That's all special events, so that includes veterans' day and everything else.
[25:09]
So we wouldn't, it just depends on how many of the events.
[25:13]
I think with the reduction, just based on the information that you can pay, the 2020-24 projected
[25:20]
It's been somewhere around around down, but it was around $15,000 for all of that.
[25:27]
There's still...
[25:29]
I'm sorry.
[25:30]
I don't have enough money.
[25:35]
So this year, veteran stay was just about break even.
[25:40]
That's because we didn't have community days.
[25:42]
So the people who usually support community day supported veterans day.
[25:48]
So, if we bring back community day, we'd have to really reach out for more sponsors.
[25:54]
We could look at changing the economics of community day and offering it completely differently.
[26:00]
So, of course, it's completely up to the board.
[26:02]
Do we pay any participants for the parade?
[26:06]
Yeah, few.
[26:08]
We should take a look at that.
[26:09]
Yes, I have a after-action report I can share with the board.
[26:13]
I found out, I mean, it kind of makes sense, but we pay the high school, because they have to mobilize and get their uniforms clean and stuff, and they're a key part of the parade, but I didn't realize all the logistics that go on to put it on a parade.
[26:27]
Sometimes in praise you, that are focused on a specific event.
[26:31]
Sometimes there's participants where you're like, does that make sense?
[26:37]
Yeah, that's all.
[26:38]
I thought there might have been a few of the veterans they parade.
[26:40]
They didn't make a lot of sense to me.
[26:42]
I wouldn't sure if we paid them or not.
[26:44]
And the fly over was free.
[26:46]
The fly over was...
[26:47]
The fly over was cool.
[26:49]
The fly over rock.
[26:51]
All right.
[26:53]
Other questions about Resolution 24-31?
[26:59]
So Mark, I'm sorry, Mr. Chair.
[27:06]
So initially there was, there was $50,000 that was in that line item in the plenary budget.
[27:13]
The projected spend is $14,000 in 2024.
[27:18]
So it sounds like commute.
[27:20]
We reduced the line item by 16,
[27:24]
And then there's still $34
[27:31]
,000 of resource in that line of it.
[27:34]
So probably another 15,000 if we reduced community day another 15,000 would need to be taken out.
[27:43]
Or could potentially.
[27:47]
Right.
[27:48]
So again, I don't know that there was any sort of, we're not asking this really for a commitment for community Friday today.
[27:54]
But there is resource there in the event you want to do a community event.
[27:57]
Again, the budget is a planning document not necessarily a
[28:05]
buzzable ending.
[28:07]
Thank you.
[28:08]
And can you just remind me what money is still earmarked for a partisan farm next year's budget?
[28:16]
Thank
[28:28]
you.
[28:30]
So in the fund 17, which is the 2016 bond proceeds fund, there's $700,000.
[28:38]
It's been rolled into 20 to 25 for a partisan farm.
[28:43]
And that anticipates the work that, you know, we had talked about last year, but nothing additional at this point in part because that work didn't get to happen.
[28:54]
Correct. That is essentially rolling that work forward to 225. That is correct.
[28:59]
Okay. Thank you.
[29:04]
We have a motion on the floor. And second, is there any public comment on resolution-24,
[29:09]
for a primary resolution, 24-31.
[29:13]
Is there a collar on the line with no collars and no questions?
[29:22]
I wasn't sure.
[29:23]
Since the board had an interest in reducing related
[29:27]
to the community, pride day, a lot
[29:29]
in the cell that was at 16 or 14.
[29:33]
So there was $14,000 of spend.
[29:36]
So there's still, so it was fifth, the original, sorry, the original line item was 50,000
[29:41]
preliminary budget.
[29:43]
We took 16,000 out to offset some of the cost associated with the park and wreck management
[29:48]
software that we're definitely, potentially talking about in a subsequent agenda item.
[29:53]
And then there's still on top, so 50 minus 16 is third.
[30:00]
All to between 2024, spend, and what's in that line, I know.
[30:04]
And that 2017, the four-number could still cover everything, but communities that can be
[30:09]
provided for 2020-25 that we normally do from a special events perspective.
[30:14]
If we had 15,000 remaining in community, in special events, we'd be able to cover all
[30:19]
the other events.
[30:20]
And to be honest, if we get enough sponsorship, we might not even use all of that money.
[30:25]
We should try and get all sponsorship, might think it, but I think it's always a cool.
[30:29]
Yeah. Yeah. So again, you could do that. Again, it's not, it's not impact. There's no, there's no
[30:36]
proposed millage rate change or anything on the, on the Special Purpose Park and Rectax.
[30:42]
You, you could remove it if you feel inclined to do that. Or you could leave it for the potential
[30:49]
planning, some sort of events in 2025 akin to the community pride day or something of that
[30:56]
Again, irrespective of all of that, I think Monica can speak for herself and her staff.
[31:02]
They always attempt to try to have those events all set by contributions.
[31:12]
Whatever the board's preference is, that's fine.
[31:18]
The last question before we call the question.
[31:22]
I'm not hearing any.
[31:24]
I'll call the question of all those in favor of resolution 24-31 fixing tax rates and special
[31:31]
five budget, signify by saying aye, aye, opposed, opposed, abstain, let the record reflect
[31:41]
that the budget passed for one.
[31:46]
Sounds good.
[31:47]
Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.
[31:48]
I'm members of the board.
[31:50]
The next item is I consider authorizing Township Manager to engage a consultant to perform services
[31:56]
under Pennsylvania Department of Community Economic Development Strategic Management Planning Program.
[32:00]
Again, this has been a topic of conversation at prior meetings.
[32:07]
We did receive funding from the Commonwealth to offset the cost of this effort.
[32:14]
This has been the effort that we've been talking about in terms of developing a multi-year
[32:20]
financial and operational plan.
[32:22]
You had authorized the release of a request for proposals back in December of last year.
[32:29]
They were doing, in January of this year, again, the reason for the delay in undertaking this work is we were waiting for funding from the Commonwealth Offset where at least partially offset the cost associated with the work.
[32:43]
There were five respondents to the RFP. We went through a process in which we narrowed that down to two.
[32:49]
When we submitted the grant application, it was based on the higher of the two proposals.
[32:56]
Tonight, we're prepared to recommend the lower of the two costs proposals
[33:01]
and to award, we're recommending the award of this work to strategic solutions,
[33:07]
which is a Pittsburgh based firm that has done this work throughout areas of the Commonwealth.
[33:13]
The total cost of the proposal is $64,730.
[33:20]
Our net cost, again, because 50% of that cost will be covered by the Commonwealth, is
[33:25]
$32,365, and that amount has been incorporated into the budget that you just adopted.
[33:33]
So I'm happy to answer any questions that may have, but again, the stance recommendation
[33:37]
is to engage strategic solutions.
[33:39]
So moved.
[33:40]
Second.
[33:42]
any questions, any public comment, and anyone on the phone?
[33:50]
No, what's that? I'll call the question.
[33:53]
All those invaders signify by saying aye.
[33:55]
Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.
[33:57]
Any opposed?
[33:59]
Obsteen?
[34:00]
The record reflected that the motion passed five zero.
[34:04]
Thank you very much.
[34:06]
The next item is consider authorizing the
[34:08]
The National Manager to engage an IT Manager Services provider, again, this was a service
[34:15]
that the Township Board of Supervisors had previously authorized the release of requests
[34:20]
for proposals.
[34:22]
We received eight responses to our request for proposal staff is recommending the engagement
[34:30]
of ASK technologies out of the ballot-kinwood area to, again, provide IT-managed services for the
[34:41]
township and its IT infrastructure. The cost in the proposal, the total cost monthly cost is
[34:50]
11,785, our current monthly cost is $22,089.62, so the effort did result in annualized savings
[35:06]
of a little bit shy of $124,000 or a 47% reduction in spend.
[35:15]
There are some uncertainties associated with this transition, so there may be some additional
[35:19]
transitions costs, but again, we feel comfortable that those
[35:24]
costs are not going to be material and, again, you would generate annual savings
[35:29]
moving forward by virtue of the transition. They are, again, based in
[35:33]
ballot, Kinwood serving municipalities in the suburban Philadelphia area,
[35:39]
including, I guess, their most local client would be Bristol Township.
[35:44]
So moved.
[35:46]
Second.
[35:49]
Any questions from
[35:52]
any questions from the public?
[35:54]
Public comment?
[35:57]
On the line.
[36:00]
No.
[36:00]
Okay.
[36:01]
With that, call the question all this favor.
[36:04]
Other as an attempt to manage it and engage in an IT managed service provider.
[36:08]
So you can find by saying aye.
[36:10]
All right.
[36:10]
And close.
[36:12]
Of steam.
[36:13]
Let the record reflect that it passed five zero.
[36:16]
We're going to agenda item 80.
[36:17]
So, AD is consider resolution 24-32 adopting a revised lower-make field
[36:23]
township employee handbook.
[36:25]
Again, this is an item that the township has been working on for some time.
[36:30]
That is being brought to finality.
[36:34]
The township solicitor has reviewed the document and it is before you
[36:41]
for your potential action.
[36:43]
We're happy to answer any questions that you may have.
[36:45]
So moved.
[36:46]
second.
[36:49]
Any more member questions? Just finally we finally got here. Any public comment?
[36:57]
Anyone on the phone? No. Okay.
[37:02]
With that, I'll call the question. All those in favor of
[37:04]
resolution of 24-32, signify by saying aye. Aye. Aye. And let the record up. Any opposed,
[37:13]
Okay, that the record fact that most of the past five zero and moving on to Jenna item eight e consider proposal from civic plus I know we've talked at length about this but
[37:30]
I'm happy to answer any questions that you may have, but beyond what was already said, I don't have anything else.
[37:41]
Is there a motion?
[37:42]
So moved.
[37:44]
Is there a second?
[37:51]
Okay, for purposes of discussion, I will second.
[37:57]
Is there, I know we didn't talk about the time savings in terms of process and that we talked about the last meeting,
[38:04]
but really never valued that at all in terms of its.
[38:08]
Again, it's predominantly impacting you.
[38:14]
Yes.
[38:27]
It's not in the one drive.
[38:29]
I don't know.
[38:29]
It's on the SharePoint.
[38:33]
Monica, I knew last time you talked a little bit about the value in terms of the software
[38:40]
and saving us a manual effort.
[38:41]
Ships are processing pool passes, pool passes and other stuff.
[38:47]
Have you guys had a chance to value how much the savings would be or in terms of hours or time?
[38:52]
So we were to convert 50% of our communication over to online interactions through the new software.
[38:59]
We would have a cost savings estimated around $74,000 for the year.
[39:06]
If that's 50% in the first year.
[39:08]
Okay.
[39:09]
And now would be more than the cost of the software wouldn't it?
[39:11]
By far.
[39:13]
Okay.
[39:14]
Are there any other board comments?
[39:19]
Any public comment?
[39:22]
Anyone on the line?
[39:24]
Okay.
[39:27]
With that, I'll call the question.
[39:29]
All those in favor of the proposal for civic plus signify by saying aye.
[39:36]
Aye.
[39:36]
Those opposed.
[39:38]
Aye.
[39:38]
Aye.
[39:39]
Okay.
[39:40]
I have the record reflected.
[39:41]
The motion failed.
[39:43]
With both two to three.
[39:47]
Thank you very much.
[39:53]
So that means it was approved in the budget, right?
[39:56]
But it was not approved execute.
[40:00]
There's earmarks in the budget, but not executed.
[40:02]
So we could just repeat.
[40:05]
Again, we just won't spend money.
[40:07]
I just want to make sure I understood.
[40:09]
Yeah.
[40:09]
The process.
[40:14]
Okay.
[40:15]
Moving on to Jenna.
[40:16]
I'm nine A public works.
[40:25]
I'm back.
[40:27]
All right.
[40:28]
Before the,
[40:30]
Board this evening, we have the consider acceptance of the bid in the amount of 307,263 dollars and 25 cents to T. She for contract.
[40:41]
There's ink for the traffic signal and ADA improvements at the intersection of Pine Grove and big of roads.
[40:48]
Disreminder that this product is partially funded with a PEN.green like go program grant in the amount of 305 320.
[40:55]
So moved.
[40:57]
Second.
[40:58]
So just clarify that's a net cost to the touch of about $2,000.
[41:05]
If the board remembers, we purchased this equipment already.
[41:10]
This equipment was purchased for 126,000, 9 of 480.
[41:14]
So as of right now, just construction cost is a cost of 52, about 53,000 for a construction
[41:20]
and equipment over granted.
[41:22]
So make sure we understand that.
[41:25]
Because the grant did have a 20% match so we, you know, with our match we're still over
[41:30]
about 53,000.
[41:31]
Getcha.
[41:37]
Any other board questions?
[41:40]
Any public comment?
[41:44]
Any callers?
[41:45]
No, no, no, no.
[41:45]
Okay.
[41:46]
With that, I'll call the question, all those in favor of accepting the bid in the amount of
[41:51]
370, 260,000,000, 20,000, 20,000,000, 20,000, 20,000,000, 20,000, 20,000, 20,000,
[41:54]
for contractors for tariff, external needy improvements.
[41:57]
at the intersection of Pine Grove Road and Big O Road,
[42:00]
Singapore by saying aye.
[42:02]
Aye. Aye.
[42:03]
Any opposed?
[42:05]
Any abstain at the record reflect that the motion passed by zero.
[42:10]
Thank you, supervisor.
[42:17]
Moving on to the solicitors report.
[42:20]
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
[42:22]
The Minister of Reflect that the supervisor's presence this evening
[42:25]
met in executive session immediately prior to this
[42:27]
for the supervisor's meeting to discuss litigation
[42:31]
and employment matters.
[42:34]
Maybe into item 10A in your package,
[42:38]
should be the ordinance prepared for,
[42:42]
with respect to their responsible contractors ordinance.
[42:46]
With, happy to answer any questions you may have.
[42:50]
If it is accepted, we would prepare for,
[42:54]
we prepare this in resolution form,
[42:56]
or in its form, excuse me, and prepare for advertisement.
[43:04]
So moved.
[43:06]
Second.
[43:14]
Questions?
[43:18]
General, I think I like the ordinance.
[43:23]
A couple of questions on it.
[43:25]
In terms of looking at numbers and types of projects that we
[43:35]
may have that would fall under the ordinance.
[43:38]
Have we done any evaluation in terms of how many contracts?
[43:43]
One, I want to make sure that we're all contractors that there are
[43:47]
contractors that meet all of the requirements because they are
[43:49]
extensive.
[43:50]
So I just want to make sure that there's a pool of contractors.
[43:53]
Generally, if you want to make sure that's there.
[43:55]
And then when we look at what we have coming up, generally speaking,
[44:01]
And if we know that we'll get more than the single bitter, let's say, on multiple projects
[44:07]
given what are the thresholds and what the requirements are.
[44:12]
Have we done any analysis like that?
[44:15]
We have not, again, just for benefit of the conversation,
[44:22]
and the temperature has an existing
[44:24]
RCO ordinance, which has a monetary threshold less than what is in the proposed ordinance.
[44:34]
That being said, there are some changes in terms of some of the requirements that are being placed on contractors, particularly as it relates to apprenticeship programs.
[44:43]
Derek, I don't know if you, again, I hate to pull you up here.
[45:01]
So, I don't know if you can provide any sort of context on any of that from a contractor perspective. Again, just based on your experience.
[45:09]
Yeah. Obviously, the township does utilize a number of contractors, whether they be union non-union, there are non-union contractors.
[45:20]
has had a apprenticeship programs, part of the ABC. I was trying to figure out
[45:24]
real fast of T.C. first is Union or not. I think they're member of ABC, so they
[45:28]
would kind of fall into it. A lot of the road program last year's contract was
[45:33]
out of Jersey, so they actually wouldn't comply with the RCO. It was adopted, so
[45:38]
it would, if you think there are skills and do we get respondents to the road
[45:43]
program last year that would, would comply? Yes. Okay. Yeah, General Oswald does more
[45:49]
you would comply. I think our old, or old is not there in non-union, non-premester.
[45:54]
But these are known contractors that we have a history with. And then relative to, like,
[46:01]
we're not the only township that has one of these ordinances or we, any,
[46:06]
or we any different, what's, are there anything unique about our,
[46:11]
what we're looking at versus any other townships that may, if we use anything as go by or anything like that?
[46:16]
Yeah, so there was sort of within the space, there was a,
[46:20]
a model that was used, it was a model from Westchester Burroughs, so a Chester County Burrough,
[46:28]
that was in part sort of the basis for some of the work that was done on what's proposed.
[46:34]
I will note that in that model there was, you know, because there's an applicability threshold
[46:42]
in terms of dollar amount that's currently in the draft, the current draft is reflecting $150,000,
[46:47]
So, any contract that would be above 150 ad or above 150,000 would be subject to the requirements of the ordinance.
[46:55]
The model did have that number established at 250, but that again has said the discretion of the Board of Supervisors.
[47:03]
I have no insight into. Is there any reason for the difference in numbers?
[47:10]
When we look at our projects, do we have a significant difference?
[47:13]
You have some towns in the county that are 10,000, some are 750,000, it's just one thing with the range.
[47:20]
It really runs a gambit that is correct, Jericho's correct. It runs from 10,000 to 250 plus.
[47:27]
So, again, I think that's there's some discretion on your part.
[47:32]
I don't know that of 150 to 250 in terms of impacts, going to have a tremendous impact.
[47:38]
That's sort of tough. I guess to quantify. I think we do, I don't want to say, concern,
[47:46]
but we do obviously want to make sure that we have competition in our bidding process.
[47:53]
And so that's really our main concern, if you will.
[47:58]
I think I don't know that there's a huge difference who won 15, 251 comes to executing projects
[48:04]
who would bid on what.
[48:06]
The one item that was maybe I've read too much in two
[48:09]
or had too many concerns about was,
[48:11]
there's a minimum number of years of doing
[48:14]
a specific type of work in there.
[48:17]
In one, it was five, I think another one
[48:19]
might have been three for some, but yes, I remember five.
[48:22]
I'm curious,
[48:25]
and I can't think of an example,
[48:27]
but there's always something new.
[48:28]
If there's a type of work that just is new,
[48:31]
and nobody has five years of experience,
[48:33]
or just for some reason, we're dealing a lot of contractors
[48:36]
that just don't have that, that years of experience
[48:40]
that come back but meet all the other requirements.
[48:42]
Do we have a method or a way to deal with that?
[48:45]
You've waved, you've waved, you've waved,
[48:46]
you have the discretion of waved.
[48:47]
So the order has to go to ways like we've done
[48:49]
and we have that ability.
[48:52]
And again, if it's a tip of work that one really
[48:55]
has any experience in, then you don't get any better.
[48:59]
Well, unless it's a new type of work
[49:01]
and that, you know, newly established companies that just don't meet the five years.
[49:06]
Sure.
[49:06]
I could wait for his craft.
[49:07]
OK.
[49:08]
Just want to make sure we have a way to do this.
[49:09]
The one item that Derek sort of raised, they're just posted a question on earlier that
[49:16]
I didn't, I don't know that we had a conversation about, was contracts that are obtained
[49:21]
through cooperative sort of purchasing arrangements, and whether there should be some
[49:31]
You know, working through like the keystone purchasing network, which the township has used in the past, or
[49:37]
co-stars, or other things like that. I don't know that there's any language in there that accepts those
[49:44]
Excludes them from applicability. They're really is not. So again, maybe something that
[49:50]
You want to just for the like the courts for example are specialty. Yeah, so if we have that in there for example
[49:56]
The contract that the township has been successfully using may not comply with the RCO
[50:01]
no longer, so we would have to go to market and you may get contractors that claim to have
[50:06]
the five years and may have it on the books, but they're not a specialty contractor
[50:09]
in terms of, you know, festival courts, for example, so that was something we were thinking
[50:13]
of.
[50:13]
So I just came up when you were asking a question about it's impact to our current contracts,
[50:17]
that was an example and that was sort of the context in which that came up.
[50:21]
So it's going back to the waiver and when it comes to a specialty contractor, do we have
[50:26]
the ability to issue a waiver relative to, is that our approach?
[50:30]
Yes, that is correct.
[50:33]
Can I ask, because something you just said I'm not sure if I said the response.
[50:37]
So we do use co-stars and things like co-stars frequently.
[50:42]
Would we be prohibited, or would we have to say we're bidding it?
[50:47]
And we're going to wave it if we go through co-stars and we get someone who doesn't comply.
[50:51]
Yeah, I mean, generally you're not going, I think at that point we would bring it back to you.
[50:56]
Again, you're not necessarily going through a public bid process, I don't know if that's limited to when there's a public bid.
[51:02]
I don't know if that's an exception that's not stated, but that's...
[51:06]
It's probably implied, you know.
[51:08]
I mean, so...
[51:11]
Well, the reason I'm asking is, in the times, I think it's twice.
[51:16]
I only remember two times that we've had to wave the responsible contractor ordinance.
[51:22]
it was a timing issue and I bring that up because sometimes going to co-starves is a timing
[51:28]
issue and also cost savings so I would hate to press to lose that flexibility. I wonder
[51:36]
if the next percentage in their purers that or
[51:43]
let me revisit that and I advise you on that
[51:46]
but it very well may. I believe that if it's extended in circumstances, emergencies, et cetera
[51:56]
situation. I don't want to make it sound like a bridge was falling or something. It was more like seasonal
[52:02]
timing.
[52:03]
Yeah, I mean I think generally you've done these days. You've done a road program or something.
[52:07]
It's like a tough time.
[52:11]
Is that something that we would potentially have to write into the ordinance? If that's something
[52:18]
the board wanted to or that's something we could just address on a case by case basis with motions.
[52:23]
And I guess my preference always would be to put it in.
[52:28]
So, it couldn't.
[52:29]
Yeah, from a problem.
[52:30]
The process perspective, I don't want to go off the works here. If that's the case, tonight is to advertise, and then we wanted to add a line or two related to that, the co-stars related stuff. Would we have to re-advertise?
[52:45]
Well, it hasn't been advertised yet, so.
[52:47]
No, if we voted to advertise the neck,
[52:50]
because that's what the motion is right now, right?
[52:52]
If we move forward, that's what we could get it out there.
[52:55]
And then we, if we decided to make an edit similar to what we're just talking about,
[53:01]
what do we have to re-apportize?
[53:03]
Yes.
[53:04]
I think, though, if you said, hey, I want to make this type of edit,
[53:09]
and then the advertisement.
[53:09]
That's what I was going to suggest.
[53:10]
that you can make a motion to advertise with this particular added.
[53:16]
You want to take a crack at the language?
[53:20]
Madam maternity?
[53:21]
What?
[53:22]
It's the board lunch.
[53:23]
The policy question is, contracts that are sourced through co-stars or keystone, what's that called?
[53:32]
Co-operative purchasing, organizations, keypan, keypan, keypan, keypan purchasing.
[53:36]
Yeah.
[53:37]
Who stars?
[53:38]
If that's the, if the touch of decides to go that, that is the preferred contracting method and those contracts,
[53:46]
we'll be subject to the rules of co-stars and the keystone purchasing and not necessarily the
[53:50]
responsible contract order.
[53:52]
Most of us will go to co-stars, it's for trucks stuff.
[53:55]
Yeah, it's not for us.
[53:55]
So it's not for services or stuff.
[53:58]
Yeah.
[53:59]
So tangible stuff.
[53:59]
That's why I'm like.
[54:01]
No.
[54:02]
Yeah.
[54:05]
KPN.
[54:06]
KPN did the police renovations.
[54:07]
We were looking at KPN for golf course work.
[54:10]
Co-stars did a lot of the courts, Skyler.
[54:14]
They did the best well-court for us, looking at potential co-stores for the palm
[54:19]
miners.
[54:20]
That pains out.
[54:21]
But there are sources of contracting methods through co-stores of KPN.
[54:26]
I understand, solicitors favorously writing.
[54:29]
So that could be a good sign and we might have something here.
[54:33]
Do you have something you think might work?
[54:36]
Just gathering from me you said, I don't know if there are two specific sort of exclusions
[54:41]
or exceptions would be contract sourced through co-star, keystone purchasing or other co-ops.
[54:48]
As a preferred method, you can go outside the RCL.
[54:52]
And do we want to add in about the timing issue if in fact it is a...
[54:56]
We just don't do it.
[54:58]
Just as a wait.
[55:00]
Okay.
[55:00]
Is there a better generic term rather than naming co-stars and he's don't specifically in case they change?
[55:07]
I would I co-op purchasing or General co-op purchase. Okay. General co-op. Oh, make sure
[55:15]
Now
[55:17]
That comfortable with
[55:21]
Thank you
[55:22]
I'm forgetting who was the original maker of this motion. So the fact agreeable is the second
[55:30]
We're able to sort of have a couple of heartening.
[55:34]
I didn't say, can I?
[55:35]
I know, I know, yeah.
[55:37]
Yeah, that's fine, yeah.
[55:38]
Of course, yes.
[55:39]
I think so, yeah.
[55:43]
With that, I'll call a question unless I'm not seeing anybody
[55:46]
in the public or on the phone, all those in favor of advertising,
[55:51]
the order of submitting a township's responsible contract
[55:53]
ordinance, and if I'd by saying aye.
[55:55]
All right, aye.
[55:56]
Opposed?
[55:57]
those stand?
[55:59]
I'd like to reflect the motion passed five zero.
[56:04]
Thank you.
[56:06]
Item, agenda item B is consider authorizing a
[56:10]
emergency, the zoning ordinance to be
[56:13]
providing for requirements relating to the
[56:15]
demolition of historic resources.
[56:18]
As you may recall this has been discussed before
[56:20]
that with this board before I do know that the
[56:25]
ordinance that's in your package,
[56:27]
I believe, hopefully, is the most updated version.
[56:31]
There was a request to change by your planning commission last week, specifically that, as a
[56:39]
condition, the board-consider, amending the ordinance to tie the granting of the certificate
[56:45]
of occupancy to this successful completion of any relocation or demolition of an historically
[56:52]
significant property that is under the effects of the ordinance.
[56:55]
We specifically added that in Article 1D, so that it now reads in the event that any
[57:02]
development or project is approved by the Township which may contain a historic structure,
[57:08]
which is a divine term, a certificate of occupancy for such development or project shall
[57:13]
not be issued by the Township until this successful completion of any demolition removal
[57:18]
or relocation of such historic structure that is governed by this section.
[57:29]
So that was the only change.
[57:32]
Were we waiting for comments from Bucks also?
[57:36]
We are.
[57:37]
We were waiting for this to be authorized for to be advertised.
[57:42]
Then we'll send it to Bucks County, which we can do tomorrow.
[57:45]
Send it up, put it in the portal for Bucks County Planning Commission.
[57:48]
Yes.
[57:48]
They may have comments.
[57:51]
They have a 30 day period in which to review.
[57:54]
I, you know, forgive me for not knowing the process.
[57:56]
but I thought we typically sent it to them
[57:59]
because if they do have comments,
[58:01]
that would be a second advertisement.
[58:03]
So I don't know if we want to send it to them in advance.
[58:07]
Good with whatever the board thinks is appropriate.
[58:12]
I personally, you might have a discussion a little bit
[58:16]
because I'm not ready to make a motion at all.
[58:19]
Sure, I guess I would say on that is this isn't that far
[58:23]
from other stuff that you've seen.
[58:25]
So I don't think there's likely to be anything significant for you.
[58:30]
I just thought, again, maybe we need a motion.
[58:33]
But I thought that was the process.
[58:35]
Again, whatever the board says.
[58:37]
I think it's missing some significant items in here.
[58:43]
Relative to process that the plan commission may or may not,
[58:47]
depending on their knowledge of the historic preservation,
[58:54]
I'm playing commission, no more than others. Relatives of the county where they may have some significant comments on this.
[59:02]
When I read it, it doesn't address the comments that I've had on our previously relative to what constitutes a historic structure who gets to make the call on that and how it's implemented.
[59:14]
But as an example, that's kind of vague, right?
[59:20]
As an example, this talks about the historic structures, and it starts at 1939, and any building
[59:28]
over 100 years old, eventually it's going to be all over houses, at some point, you know,
[59:33]
not today, it's not all over houses, but someday it will be 1939, I understand where that
[59:38]
from. Personally, when my professional experience going through this process has been the
[59:49]
folks that do these analyses and make these determinations are usually, you know, master's
[59:56]
HD-level folks in historic preservation and cultural resource.
[1:00:00]
This is, et cetera, that go through a very detailed evaluation per the National Historic Preservation Act requirements.
[1:00:07]
They recognize professionals. They make recommendations as to whether or not building or structure is eligible for listing on the National Register.
[1:00:15]
And then that is vetted through a state process through the State Historic Preservation Office, which is the PHMC, the Pennsylvania Historical Museum Commission.
[1:00:24]
And this doesn't mention any of that.
[1:00:28]
So I think it kind of puts the on us on our volunteers who may or may not be professionals
[1:00:36]
in the field to make those calls and to come up with those lists and to say what is historically
[1:00:42]
significant or not and that has a real impact on our residents.
[1:00:48]
Now, I like the general philosophy of this and what we're trying to accomplish, I think is great.
[1:00:57]
And the idea of tying it to a CEO, I liked it even more.
[1:01:00]
I think I was a great, great addition.
[1:01:03]
I just think personally when I think about putting restrictions on what homeowners can do with their homes,
[1:01:13]
that that should be related back to a professional
[1:01:17]
opinion of the way to do that I think is to rather than save
[1:01:24]
the 1939 or 100 years or any other year.
[1:01:28]
So if a home is or a structure is listed on the national register
[1:01:32]
because that means it's absolutely gone through a process.
[1:01:34]
It's gone through more than the process because it's actually listed
[1:01:37]
on the historic register or it's been determined eligible for
[1:01:41]
listing on the National Register by PHMC, which is a specific regulatory process that would
[1:01:47]
have to go through, then I think those homes would be ripe for this type of review.
[1:01:55]
Sort of that I think we're opening ourselves up potentially the lawsuits for folks that want
[1:02:03]
to do something with their home because it is maybe not originally not built the code, not built
[1:02:09]
modern standards, et cetera, it's whatever it may be, or there's just their personal preference,
[1:02:15]
where that starts to get sticky. And there's going to be a lot of houses in the middle,
[1:02:19]
right? I think we have two or three inch houses in the township that might meet
[1:02:22]
some of the basic requirements relative to age. So when we set up a committee that may,
[1:02:28]
some of those homes will turn over at some point and people may want to do something at some
[1:02:32]
point. So you're almost setting up another mini zone of hearing board almost to reveal all these things.
[1:02:37]
It's not that it will be that consistent or not consistent,
[1:02:42]
but that regular review will have to meet.
[1:02:44]
But I just think it gets sticky when something is not
[1:02:48]
on a list that has been vetted by some regulatory body
[1:02:53]
that is seen as being experts in the field.
[1:02:56]
Does that make sense?
[1:02:57]
Yeah, I mean, I can tell you, there was a lot of discussion
[1:03:00]
about the year and 100 and what it would mean.
[1:03:03]
And I know that the, well, I shouldn't say I know because I don't really ever know, but I believe that that was not the committee's intent, but I hear you concern and maybe that pushes us to ask the county for their feedback before we advertise, maybe that's the way to go.
[1:03:20]
I think it's part of it, and then I personally would, in order to vote for this, I would
[1:03:27]
have to see the inclusion of properties that have been deemed eligible for listing a national
[1:03:33]
register at minimum to be the starting point for this rather than just our volunteer saying
[1:03:40]
this is historic.
[1:03:41]
But there are properties that would be deemed eligible for the historic register that aren't
[1:03:47]
that maybe passed the 1939 that historical commission might not be U.S.
[1:03:56]
Well, if they are deemed eligible by the state professionals, by the National Historic Preservation Act,
[1:04:02]
National Registers are eligible, eligible if they are less than 100 years older or less than 1939,
[1:04:07]
then those are my opinion, they are still worth adding to the rest.
[1:04:12]
There won't be many of those.
[1:04:13]
They're probably aren't any, to be honest, but they're wrong.
[1:04:16]
And just to be clear, it doesn't say that people can take action on this home.
[1:04:19]
It just means that there'd be a chance to catalog and take pictures and stuff like that.
[1:04:24]
So it's not, this would not create a situation where if you were in one of those homes,
[1:04:29]
you'd suddenly be barred from those homes.
[1:04:30]
Well, they would have to go through a conditional use of approval to make certain changes.
[1:04:38]
That's correct.
[1:04:38]
That's also correct.
[1:04:39]
And that would have to go through some useful, there's potential.
[1:04:42]
I mean, you have to spend money on all that process if you're trying.
[1:04:45]
If it's tied to a sale, you might lose, you might lose the sale, you know, there's several issues with that, right?
[1:04:52]
I like what we're trying to do, but I think it devils in the details and the implementation to make sure that we're not, you know,
[1:05:02]
good intentions, certain paths, all that good stuff.
[1:05:05]
But by understanding as I wish someone from the historic commission was here, that it was not supposed to rise the level of being put on the national register,
[1:05:13]
or anything of that nature, this was really more like a grounds route, something that the
[1:05:20]
township was going to do, that it was not going to rise to that level to have to go through
[1:05:24]
all those certifications, et cetera.
[1:05:26]
No, no, it's in a certification.
[1:05:28]
Being listed on the National Register is one thing, that's a whole process, being eligible
[1:05:32]
for listing is just the review that they're talking about, but it's done by professionals
[1:05:36]
not volunteers, that this is what they do every day, and there's a specific methodology to
[1:05:42]
do that. And it's very, when you read the National Star Preservation Act, they have distinct
[1:05:47]
definitions about who is capable and able to perform those evaluations that can then go
[1:05:54]
to the ship out. Doesn't have to be listed on anything, just as to be eligible for
[1:05:58]
listing based off of the evaluations. That's two different things there.
[1:06:06]
Where I sense the board may be at this time.
[1:06:11]
Do we have a motion on this on the floor?
[1:06:13]
Now, how about we entertain the motion to authorize the solicitor to send the Plan Commission to the Plan Commission?
[1:06:23]
It's fair.
[1:06:24]
Is there anyone to have any concerns with that?
[1:06:26]
I'd make that motion.
[1:06:27]
Is there a motion?
[1:06:28]
It's a move.
[1:06:29]
It's a second.
[1:06:30]
Any questions on the motion?
[1:06:34]
Here you are.
[1:06:35]
Now, not seeing any public comment.
[1:06:37]
No one on the phone.
[1:06:39]
No one on the phone.
[1:06:40]
Okay.
[1:06:41]
Call the question.
[1:06:41]
All those paper authorized and this will assert to provide the draft amendments.
[1:06:48]
The zoning ordinance provide requirements for the demolition of historical structures.
[1:06:51]
Let's see if I would say aye.
[1:06:54]
Any opposed?
[1:06:55]
Any abstain?
[1:06:57]
With the record reflect the motion passed by zero.
[1:07:00]
General updates.
[1:07:03]
General updates are very general.
[1:07:05]
We're drafting, we're in the process of drafting easements, a couple of ordinances as you know they've mentioned in the past, anticipating a couple of lend development agreements that will be coming before us,
[1:07:19]
revising contracts for the township, working with Monica and her group and a number of others.
[1:07:26]
So we're preparing for an active 2025.
[1:07:30]
That's it. Thank you very much.
[1:07:34]
Moving on to supervisor for us. I don't have any at this time. I was, I think, the planning commission was in between the meetings.
[1:07:43]
So that was the one that we were both at. So we've already discussed that.
[1:07:47]
Supervisor Griner?
[1:07:49]
Sure. Actually, it's not on my list, but I did attend the, what I'll call this stormwater ordinance subcommittee meeting or committee meeting last week.
[1:07:58]
The group met and we had a pretty thorough review of the ordinance.
[1:08:04]
I think there were several comments that will be addressed in an updated version probably by next month.
[1:08:13]
General schedule will probably see something before the board in February timeframe.
[1:08:18]
Maybe a little sooner, but that seems all we're doing.
[1:08:23]
High level, I think we've all had input to it so there shouldn't be any surprises there, but it seems to be moving on, actually.
[1:08:30]
Let's all.
[1:08:31]
Supervisor Ross.
[1:08:33]
No reports?
[1:08:33]
Supervisor Blundie?
[1:08:35]
The only thing I want to say is if you were planning on attending golf or Trent and Mercer this month,
[1:08:41]
they have both been canceled because of conflicts with holiday season, so see you in January.
[1:08:49]
Is there any other business from any member, not seeing any, we've on to agenda item 13, the appointments, the reports, the permissions.
[1:09:06]
Make a motion to appoint Virginia Torbert to the planning commission.
[1:09:11]
Second.
[1:09:12]
Any questions?
[1:09:15]
I'll call a question.
[1:09:16]
All those favors think about by saying aye.
[1:09:18]
Hi.
[1:09:19]
Any opposed?
[1:09:21]
Any abstain?
[1:09:23]
I'm not hearing any.
[1:09:24]
Is there any other appointments or appointments for the same thing?
[1:09:28]
I don't know.
[1:09:30]
Is anyone interested in their pointing a new member to citizen traffic?
[1:09:35]
Who's the liaison?
[1:09:36]
That would be.
[1:09:38]
That would differ.
[1:09:40]
Don't get a less than well.
[1:09:44]
I'd like to make a motion to appoint Dakota Dematio to the Citizen's Traffic
[1:09:48]
Commission.
[1:09:49]
I'll second that.
[1:09:52]
All those in favor, signify by saying aye.
[1:09:56]
Aye.
[1:09:57]
I'll let the record reflect the motion as previously.
[1:10:01]
Moving on to agenda item 14, this is an additional public comment on non-agenda items
[1:10:06]
if needed.
[1:10:07]
So, if you're sitting there thinking, hey, I'd like to talk policy question.
[1:10:14]
As your chance, not seeing any movement.
[1:10:18]
Anybody on the call any calls?
[1:10:21]
Okay.
[1:10:22]
With that, I'll move on to the January 15th adjournment.