Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
Copy of a YouTube video held by the Internet Archive.
Captions were copied from the YouTube video.
Captions were copied from the YouTube video.
[0:08]
Good evening everyone. Uh welcome to the
[0:10]
Madera City Council meeting. We have
[0:13]
tried to transfer over to a new system.
[0:15]
It is in still progress. So we are
[0:18]
working kind of like through the bugs
[0:21]
and aren't full capacity this evening.
[0:23]
So please come back to our next meeting
[0:25]
to see it the big grand opening show of
[0:27]
our new system. At this time, I would
[0:30]
like to call this meeting to order on
[0:31]
Wednesday, May 6, 2026
[0:34]
at 60:01. City Clerk Gonzalez.
[0:38]
The Madera City Council meetings are
[0:40]
open to the public. This meeting will
[0:42]
also be available for public viewing and
[0:44]
participation through Zoom. Members of
[0:46]
the public may also observe the live
[0:48]
stream meeting on the city's website at
[0:49]
www.mmadera.gov/live.
[0:53]
Members of the public may comment on
[0:54]
agenda items at the meeting or remotely
[0:56]
through an electronic meeting via phone
[0:58]
by dialing 669-9006833.
[1:01]
Enter ID 869-20188563
[1:04]
pound. Press star 9 to raise your hand
[1:06]
to comment and star six to unmute
[1:07]
yourself to speak. Comments will also be
[1:10]
accepted via email at city council
[1:11]
public commenter.gov or by regular mail
[1:14]
at 205 Westport Street, Madera,
[1:17]
California 93637. We'd like to remind
[1:19]
those in attendance that Wordley is
[1:21]
available for translation purposes.
[1:25]
>> Thank you for that. At this time, um,
[1:27]
city clerk consol will do roll call. But
[1:30]
before that, I would like to make an
[1:32]
announcement. Council member Mah will be
[1:35]
participating remotely by government
[1:37]
code 54953
[1:40]
83 due to a contagious illness. So, at
[1:43]
this time, she will be participating via
[1:46]
Zoom. Audio and video and camera should
[1:48]
be at on at all times so that we are
[1:50]
able to see her.
[1:52]
>> With that, I ask for roll call.
[1:54]
>> And if I may also add, mayor, all votes
[1:56]
will be conducted by roll call.
[1:58]
>> Thank you for that.
[1:59]
>> Mayor Gyos
[2:00]
>> here.
[2:00]
>> Mayor Prom Zachariah
[2:01]
>> here.
[2:02]
>> Council member Rodriguez here.
[2:03]
>> Council member Montes
[2:04]
>> here.
[2:05]
>> Council member Evans
[2:06]
>> here.
[2:06]
>> Council member Mahia
[2:08]
>> here.
[2:09]
>> And council member Viegas
[2:11]
>> here.
[2:12]
>> Thank you for that roll call. At this
[2:14]
time, I will be calling Pastor Alvarado
[2:17]
Jr. to do the invocation. And at this
[2:20]
time, we will also have our mayor pro
[2:22]
Tim Zachariah doing the pledge of
[2:24]
allegiance. And if everybody would
[2:26]
remain standing for um the loss of our
[2:29]
former mayor, Santos Garcia, and
[2:31]
supervisor Max Rodriguez for a moment of
[2:33]
silence, please.
[2:41]
» Lord, we come before your presence,
[2:42]
Father God. Lord, we just thank you,
[2:43]
Lord, for this evening. Ask, Father God,
[2:45]
for the wisdom, Lord. Ask for your
[2:47]
spirit to be in this place, Lord God. We
[2:48]
invite you here into this place. We ask,
[2:50]
Lord God, that let us be with the city
[2:52]
council members, Father God, and give
[2:53]
them guidance and direction. Lord, I
[2:54]
pray for the citizens of Madera, Father
[2:56]
God, as they come tonight to business,
[2:58]
Father God, that you be in the midst of
[2:59]
the business. Father God, ask you
[3:00]
continue to be with us and bless us,
[3:01]
Lord. Bless all those who are here
[3:02]
tonight, Father God. And Lord, um, we
[3:05]
are also grieving the loss of two great
[3:07]
men, Father God, that we're here to
[3:08]
serve this city well, Father God. We
[3:09]
thank you Lord for uh the time they put
[3:11]
here Father God and the impact that they
[3:13]
made in this city. And I thank you Lord
[3:14]
as continue to be with their families as
[3:16]
well. Lord be with these families.
[3:17]
Continue to be with us and bless us for
[3:19]
your honor for your glory in Jesus name.
[3:21]
Lord said
[3:22]
>> amen.
[3:23]
>> You show me this pledge. Ready? Salute.
[3:26]
>> I pledge algiance to the flag of the
[3:29]
United States of America and to the
[3:32]
republic for which it stands. One nation
[3:35]
under God, indivisible with liberty and
[3:37]
justice for all.
[3:39]
Please remain standing for a moment of
[3:41]
silence
[3:43]
for Santos Garcia and Max Rodriguez.
[4:32]
Thank you so much for standing and
[4:34]
honoring and respecting our loss to our
[4:37]
wonderful leaders that have served us
[4:38]
well in this community and in the city
[4:40]
of Madera. Thank you everyone.
[4:49]
So
[4:58]
there's no broadcast.
[5:06]
» My understanding is your sister
[5:10]
is connected to
[5:12]
my presentation.
[5:14]
Okay. Excuse me, mayor. We're going to
[5:16]
need to make a very very brief call to
[5:18]
council member Mahia. If you don't mind
[5:19]
if we take a few minutes.
[5:20]
>> Okay. We're going to take a fivem minute
[5:22]
recess trying to get Councilwoman Mahia
[5:24]
online.
[5:25]
>> Oh, it's two minutes.
[5:27]
>> Hold tight. Thank you.
[6:39]
We're back. I'll turn this over to my
[6:41]
city attorney.
[6:42]
>> Thank you, mayor. Uh, as you know, we're
[6:44]
having some challenges with our audio
[6:46]
visual. We can hear Council Member
[6:47]
Mahia, but we are unable to see her
[6:50]
under the government code. She's
[6:51]
required to be seen. She has graciously
[6:53]
agreed to step out of this meeting so we
[6:55]
can continue with the meeting. As such,
[6:57]
she will not be participating for the
[6:58]
remainder of the meeting. Thank you.
[7:01]
>> Thank you for that announcement. Uh we
[7:04]
thank her for letting us go on with
[7:06]
business and um if you have an agenda,
[7:09]
you will see proclamations that are
[7:10]
listed because of the audio visual
[7:13]
that's happening tonight. We're going to
[7:15]
postpone those until our meeting in two
[7:16]
weeks. So, please come back for all of
[7:18]
that. At this time, I'll turn it over to
[7:20]
my city clerk for public comment.
[7:23]
>> Um, we have one written public comment.
[7:25]
Mayor,
[7:27]
>> before we do that, could we actually
[7:28]
approve the agenda?
[7:29]
>> Oh, I'm sorry. I was all excited. Okay.
[7:32]
Uh, approval of the agenda. I bring it
[7:34]
to my colleagues for any questions or
[7:36]
concerns.
[7:37]
>> Madame Mayor, I would like to see if we
[7:39]
can move item F, council member reports,
[7:42]
up before public comments. And I wanted
[7:45]
to do that in order to honor uh the
[7:48]
passing of uh Mayor Sto. Garcia this
[7:51]
way. I can do that report now versus
[7:53]
doing that at the end.
[7:54]
>> Okay. Thank you for that. City clerk
[7:56]
Gonzalez.
[7:57]
>> Also, mayor, um we would also like to
[8:01]
request, as you mentioned, moving
[8:03]
presentations to continue those to the
[8:05]
May 20th meeting. Also item E1 under
[8:08]
administrative reports and E2 if we
[8:11]
could also uh continue those to the May
[8:13]
20th meeting. That is the request of
[8:15]
staff.
[8:15]
>> Thank you. I have those um
[8:19]
E1 and
[8:21]
>> E1 and two. If I could get a motion and
[8:24]
a second from my colleagues. Motion to
[8:26]
approve is written cabinet with with the
[8:29]
exception of E1, E2 and also the
[8:33]
proclamations
[8:34]
and moving the
[8:37]
section F up to behind the public
[8:40]
comment.
[8:41]
>> Is there still a second?
[8:43]
>> Second.
[8:44]
>> Okay, I have a first and a second. All
[8:46]
those in favor say I.
[8:47]
>> I. Those opposed. Motion passes
[8:50]
unanimously. Um, Councilwoman Evans, uh,
[8:53]
motion was to do F after public comment.
[8:55]
So, I'll bring it to my city clerk
[9:00]
for public comment.
[9:01]
>> Mhm.
[9:02]
>> The first 15 minutes of the meeting are
[9:03]
reserved for members of the public to
[9:05]
address the council on items which are
[9:07]
within the subject matter jurisdiction
[9:08]
of the council. Speakers shall be
[9:10]
limited to three minutes. Speakers will
[9:12]
be asked but are not required to
[9:13]
identify themselves and state the
[9:14]
subject of their comments. If the
[9:16]
subject is an item on the agenda, the
[9:18]
mayor has the option of speak of asking
[9:20]
the speaker to hold the comment until
[9:21]
that item is called. Comments on items
[9:23]
listed as public hearing on the agenda
[9:25]
should be held until the hearing is
[9:26]
opened. The council is prohibited by law
[9:29]
from taking any action on matters
[9:30]
discussed that are not on the agenda and
[9:32]
no adverse conclusions should be drawn
[9:34]
if the council does not respond to the
[9:35]
public comment at the time. At this
[9:37]
time,
[9:38]
>> thank you for that. I will open public
[9:40]
comment at this time and come up to the
[9:41]
podium if you would like to present.
[9:56]
My name is Anthony Forest here. Um, live
[9:58]
in Madera. Uh, good evening, mayor,
[10:00]
council members, city manager. Um, first
[10:03]
I want to give my condolences for the
[10:04]
loss of Mayor Garcia and Supervisor
[10:09]
Rodriguez. Um, as you may be keenly
[10:12]
aware, I'm on the June ballot for the
[10:14]
position of auditor controller for
[10:15]
Madera County. Uh, I'm here tonight
[10:18]
requesting your support for my
[10:19]
candidacy. This past March, I completed
[10:22]
my sixth year here at the at the city of
[10:24]
Madera as a financial services manager.
[10:27]
I've proven myself to be a hardworking,
[10:30]
responsible, ethical, and reliable uh
[10:33]
team member during my employment with
[10:35]
the city. I'm running for honor to
[10:37]
controller to bring honesty, integrity,
[10:40]
accountability, and transparency to
[10:42]
Madera County, to provide my knowledge,
[10:44]
skills, and abilities, and to take on
[10:47]
the additional challenge of running a
[10:48]
large-scale governmental finance
[10:50]
department.
[10:55]
In addition to the governmental
[10:56]
experience gained as a financial
[10:58]
services manager with the city, I have
[11:00]
almost 40 years experience as a
[11:02]
certified public accountant uh in
[11:04]
healthcare, real estate development,
[11:06]
agriculture,
[11:07]
tribal gaming, winery accounting,
[11:10]
residential, commercial construction,
[11:11]
and of course, governmental accounting.
[11:14]
This diverse background will serve me
[11:16]
well during my tenure as the auditor
[11:18]
controller if I'm elected. During my
[11:20]
almost 40 years of experience, I've
[11:22]
supervised by staffs as large as 30 and
[11:24]
as small as one. I have made
[11:26]
presentations to executives, council
[11:29]
members, and boards of directors. My
[11:31]
early years of experience included
[11:33]
preparing tax returns for individuals,
[11:35]
partnerships, corporations, and
[11:37]
nonprofit organizations, as well as
[11:40]
performed audits for companies in
[11:42]
multiple industries. I'm asking for your
[11:44]
support and the support of your friends,
[11:46]
family, acquaintances, and constituents.
[11:48]
Thank you for your time and
[11:49]
consideration and remember vote Anthony
[11:52]
Forest here for internal for auditor
[11:53]
control in Madera County. Thank you.
[11:55]
>> Thank you for your comment.
[12:09]
» Good afternoon. My name is Monica
[12:10]
Ramirez. I'm the executive director with
[12:12]
First Five Mera County and Family
[12:15]
Resource Center as well. And I only
[12:17]
bring you a message from some of your
[12:19]
youngest residents in the city and we've
[12:22]
been seeing a lot of work happening. Um
[12:25]
we our family resource center sits on
[12:27]
the corner of Joede and Lake. So we are
[12:30]
privy to all the action that's going on
[12:33]
and we are very happy and excited about
[12:35]
the the changes. The kids are really
[12:38]
thrilled to see all the big equipment.
[12:40]
not so much to parents that have to
[12:42]
circumvent back and forth, but we bring
[12:44]
you a big thank you card because I know
[12:47]
that it takes a lot of work for all of
[12:49]
this to happen and even though the work
[12:52]
continues on, we just want to extend
[12:54]
that and our gratitude for that hard
[12:56]
work. Thank you.
[12:57]
>> Thank you for your comment.
[12:59]
>> Thank you. Thank you.
[13:10]
Hello everybody. Um, my name is Monica
[13:13]
Bravo. I am CEO from the Latinos
[13:17]
and we are we are here last.
[13:20]
So I will try to do both of them.
[13:34]
Mera clue they are all the four members.
[13:38]
Um want to extend this space to have a
[13:42]
memory to
[13:45]
both of leaders here in Madera Max
[13:48]
Rodriguez and Santos Garcia. I would
[13:52]
like to have a moment of silence to
[13:54]
celebrate the life of portation to the
[13:58]
Madera County and the Madera city.
[14:07]
Max Rodriguez for to contribution. Max
[14:23]
Rodriguez was represented to the Madera
[14:26]
County in the district 4 in the district
[14:30]
4. He advocate for the union integration
[14:34]
and the good labor on the community at
[14:36]
the park during her period
[14:40]
his period. Thank you Max for your
[14:43]
contribution.
[14:46]
Fore
[15:06]
Santos Garcia ex mayor of the Madela
[15:09]
city was considered for the proclamation
[15:13]
inclusion in the communities of Boga for
[15:16]
the sports, culture and community events
[15:22]
and for be the pioneer in the change.
[15:27]
He was and we will be on a member active
[15:31]
of the Latinos.
[15:50]
We extend the condolences for their
[15:54]
family, friends,
[15:59]
to the invitation to continue to the
[16:01]
inclusion, the union and
[16:05]
we all together we contribute to to do a
[16:09]
better community
[16:11]
Maxim,
[16:19]
thank you so much. I'm so sorry my
[16:22]
English is like a little bit but I I t
[16:26]
my my heart. Thank you.
[16:28]
>> Thank you for your comment.
[16:32]
» Are there any other comments in the
[16:34]
chamber?
[16:36]
I see none. City clerk Gonzalez. Anyone
[16:38]
online or on Zoom?
[16:40]
We have none. Mayor, we did receive a
[16:42]
public comment um that a copy has been
[16:45]
distributed to the city council and
[16:47]
there is a copy at the podium for those
[16:49]
wishing to obtain one.
[16:50]
>> Perfect. Thank you so much for that.
[16:52]
With that, I close public comment and we
[16:54]
move on to
[16:56]
>> Excuse me.
[16:56]
>> We do have someone on.
[16:57]
>> Oh, okay. He put his hand down.
[17:01]
>> Open public comment. Back up.
[17:05]
God. Catchadorian.
[17:08]
>> Caller with the last name Kacadorian. If
[17:10]
you wish to speak,
[17:18]
please press star six to unmute
[17:20]
yourself.
[17:31]
Caller by the red.
[17:33]
Could you hear me?
[17:43]
» Are you
[17:44]
>> Could you hear me?
[17:46]
>> Are you on the line for public comment?
[17:48]
>> We can hear you on the Zoom call. I
[17:50]
don't think they can hear you in the
[17:51]
chambers. One moment, please.
[17:53]
>> Um, I typed a question actually over to
[17:57]
you guys. Um, just asking a few
[18:00]
questions on the public comments. I
[18:03]
emailed it to um the city clerk info.
[18:08]
>> Okay, one moment. Let me text uh
[18:18]
let me text and tail.
[18:20]
>> Yeah, as long as you can read it, I'm
[18:22]
fine with that.
[18:25]
» Okay, we can we can hear we can hear her
[18:28]
and I can read it.
[18:33]
Okay, here's the public comment from
[18:35]
Gabriella Catchadorian.
[18:37]
She says, "Hi, we are not able to
[18:39]
comment online. I'm reaching out
[18:40]
regarding the maintenance in the area
[18:42]
behind Parkwood Elementary. Where can we
[18:44]
locate a calendar when maintenance is
[18:46]
completed in this area, New Parkwood
[18:49]
Valencia? My next question is if there
[18:52]
are resources available for residents to
[18:54]
cover some of the medical expenses. I
[18:56]
only ask because some concerns have been
[18:59]
brought up that residents have been
[19:01]
discouraged to use the hospital because
[19:03]
they are being told there is no fee
[19:04]
wavers that Madera offers.
[19:07]
And that is the end of the public
[19:08]
comment for Miss Catadorian. Okay.
[19:10]
>> Thank you, city court Gonzalez. With
[19:12]
that, I close public comment at this
[19:13]
time and move on to council members
[19:17]
reports, announcements, future agenda
[19:19]
items. City clerk Gonzalez
[19:26]
one.
[19:29]
This portion of the meeting is is
[19:31]
reserved for the mayor and council
[19:33]
members to make brief reports on boards,
[19:34]
committees, and other public agencies
[19:36]
and at public events to request updates
[19:38]
to initiate future agenda items and to
[19:40]
take action on matters initiated under
[19:42]
this section of the agenda. Under this
[19:44]
section, the council may take action
[19:46]
only on items specifically agendaized
[19:47]
and which meet other requirements for
[19:49]
action.
[19:50]
>> Thank you for that. I'm going to go to
[19:52]
council member Rodriguez who wanted this
[19:54]
to be moved up. I'll go with you first.
[19:56]
>> Yes. Thank you, Mayor P. which I
[19:59]
appreciate that um you know obviously
[20:02]
everybody is aware of the passing of our
[20:04]
former mayor but I did want to take this
[20:06]
moment just to uh extend my deepest
[20:08]
condolences on the passing of our former
[20:11]
mayor Garcia who left us this past
[20:13]
Saturday um who devoted his entire lives
[20:16]
to service a longtime postal worker um
[20:20]
and also very active in the United Farm
[20:22]
Workers uh organization
[20:25]
um and very and as you know the the
[20:28]
Monica had commented that very devoted
[20:30]
and care deeply for the people of
[20:32]
Madera. Um you know in in getting to
[20:35]
know Santos when I first got elected um
[20:38]
it was uh it was unusual seeing this man out here just always coming to
[20:44]
the meetings in 2016 and 17 and he would
[20:48]
always praise me for comments that I
[20:50]
would make again just making comments or
[20:52]
asking questions. So he took on that
[20:54]
baton himself, took on the city council
[20:57]
in 2018 and then went on to pursue the
[21:00]
uh mayorship of which he cared very
[21:02]
deeply for the community especially for
[21:04]
those voices that were unheard. His
[21:07]
purpose was always to uplift those who
[21:09]
felt overlooked and unheard. Whether
[21:11]
delivering mail, organizing workers or
[21:13]
serving to very dest. He carried the
[21:16]
same commitment of fairness,
[21:18]
representation, and human dignity. To
[21:21]
his wife, his family, and all who loved
[21:23]
him, we offer a heartfelt condolences
[21:25]
and the loss of this truly loss to the
[21:27]
entire community. May we honor his
[21:29]
memory by continuing the work he
[21:31]
championed at building Madera where
[21:33]
every resident is seen, heard, and
[21:35]
valued. Um, aside from that, I also
[21:37]
wanted to um a heartfelt tribute to our
[21:40]
esteemed former county supervisor Max
[21:43]
Rodriguez. I think it was said earlier
[21:45]
by Monica Supervisor Rodriguez again
[21:47]
served this community for over 16 years.
[21:50]
Um, this was a loss that took place
[21:51]
within 30 days and uh really our deepest
[21:55]
uh condolences to them. Now, moving on,
[21:58]
I just wanted to share that I think that
[22:00]
was appropriate to do it while we were
[22:02]
here. Most of the time when we give
[22:03]
these reports, everybody's gone and
[22:06]
typically it's we're talking to
[22:08]
ourselves. But I wanted to make sure
[22:09]
that I if any family members, friends of
[22:11]
Santos, they know that we also have a um
[22:14]
a very we'll have a voice here in the
[22:16]
community. Um I had an opportunity to
[22:19]
attend the League of Cities leader
[22:20]
summit um that uh I was accompanied by
[22:24]
our uh council members Mahia Evans,
[22:27]
Viega, Sakariah um and our esteemed uh
[22:31]
city manager Rodriguez throughout the
[22:33]
sessions that we um attended, you know,
[22:37]
uh water uh government policy and um
[22:42]
other u important sessions. But one
[22:44]
thing that did stand out for me, this
[22:46]
was the last session that I I wanted to
[22:48]
bring to the city, see if it's something
[22:49]
they may consider is AI has advanced so
[22:51]
much that we can we could potentially
[22:54]
add a chat box to our city website. I
[22:57]
know this was a redevelop website. I
[22:59]
think a chat box is now very
[23:01]
appropriate. It's being utilized in many
[23:04]
of the uh especially workspaces that I
[23:06]
have. So, if it's something that we can
[23:08]
consider in the future, this is
[23:10]
something that I'd like to bring back up
[23:11]
if the council would agree to bring this
[23:14]
back up in a as a future suggested um uh
[23:18]
agenda item. Last but not least, I did
[23:20]
have an opportunity to attend the
[23:21]
Sanwalk Regional Policy Council retreat
[23:24]
that was held in Merced. This retreat
[23:26]
was again eight counties coming together
[23:28]
trying to see what's in the best
[23:30]
interest or what uh common uh interest
[23:33]
we have which is all transportation um
[23:36]
air quality and again housing. So with
[23:39]
that there were very a lot of important
[23:42]
um uh topics that we talked about but I
[23:44]
always the needs of our community
[23:47]
especially here in Madera and with that
[23:49]
madame mayor that's all I had. Thank you
[23:50]
for your time.
[23:51]
>> Thank you for your report. Uh, council
[23:53]
member Vieas.
[23:55]
>> Uh, thank you, mayor. I just wanted to
[23:57]
say that, yeah, I uh in 2020 when I
[24:02]
start uh uh uh running for uh city
[24:07]
council,
[24:09]
uh the first uh one of the first person
[24:11]
that I meet that was on Saria and I
[24:14]
learned a lot from him. uh he have a lot
[24:18]
of uh uh good things in mind for the
[24:23]
city
[24:25]
to to improve and and all those kind of
[24:28]
things. So, uh, I learned a lot from
[24:31]
them, from him and from Councilman
[24:33]
Rodriguez right in the beginning. And um
[24:38]
I just want to say it's a it's a it's a
[24:41]
one of the very
[24:44]
um bad loss of of somebody that that was
[24:50]
caring and have in mind that we serve to
[24:54]
people and make things better around the
[24:57]
city. Also, I was attending
[25:00]
CVS with uh with my colleagues and then
[25:05]
so I just wanted to
[25:10]
they say that first year will be
[25:12]
remembered by many people in Mexico and
[25:16]
that's my report. Thank you.
[25:17]
>> Thank you for your comment, Councilwoman
[25:19]
Evans.
[25:24]
Okay.
[25:26]
Good evening everyone. Blessings to you
[25:29]
all.
[25:32]
For me
[25:33]
it was hard to come today. Um
[25:39]
Santos and I
[25:42]
we talked all the time. We fought.
[25:46]
We didn't talk to each other. We cried.
[25:50]
We complained to each other.
[25:53]
But he was more than just a colleague to
[25:55]
me. He was more like a brother.
[25:59]
His family, Martha,
[26:03]
if I got sick, they were at the door.
[26:06]
bringing me the
[26:09]
story. Oh my gosh. Let me tell you. Um,
[26:13]
one night my son was here and
[26:17]
he needed hypodermic needles because
[26:19]
he's a diabetic. And I spoke with Santos
[26:24]
and he came over about 10:00 at night to
[26:27]
bring a box of needles to my son so that
[26:31]
he could take his insulin.
[26:34]
Everyone else spoken about how he did
[26:37]
things in the city and yes, he did. I
[26:40]
mean, it was unlike Arthur Neil. He was
[26:44]
one of the first to speak to me about
[26:46]
running for office,
[26:49]
but that was just a small part. He made
[26:52]
sure that there was food for children.
[26:56]
There was food for families. He made
[26:58]
sure that every time the door opened, he
[27:01]
was at some type of an event. Um, it was
[27:04]
at one point in time said that he should
[27:07]
go for the photo. Well,
[27:10]
One thing about it, no one can ever say
[27:13]
that he wasn't there. He wasn't our
[27:16]
mayor. He made sure that his voice was
[27:20]
heard from Sacramento all the way down
[27:22]
to Los Angeles. And anyone in here
[27:25]
that's a Dodger fan, oh my goodness,
[27:28]
heaven forbid if you rooted for someone
[27:31]
else, he would just elephant. And I
[27:34]
don't know how many of you knew that he
[27:36]
was colored right. So Martha would pack
[27:40]
his clothes because she wanted to make
[27:43]
sure that his things matched.
[27:46]
And one day I asked him, I said, "Is
[27:48]
blue your favorite color?" And he said,
[27:50]
"Is that what I have on?" I said,
[27:51]
"Yeah." And he says, "Oh, you know, I'm
[27:54]
color blind." I was like, "Okay." So
[27:56]
there are some of the the the personal
[27:58]
things that um
[28:00]
I just want to remember. Um I've been in
[28:03]
contact with his family. Um, and
[28:08]
they want everyone to know just how much
[28:12]
they so appreciate the love that this
[28:16]
city has shown to Stock. They rode
[28:18]
around town and they saw the flags that
[28:22]
were at half staff
[28:24]
and I have not talked to Martha, but the
[28:28]
daughters,
[28:30]
the sons, they're
[28:33]
everyone is devastated because he called
[28:36]
me and he was on the phone and he was
[28:39]
like, I can't stay on the phone long.
[28:41]
And I said, why? What's the matter? And
[28:42]
he says, I need a coke break. I said,
[28:44]
you don't need a coke break. And he do.
[28:47]
She says, "But I got to get this work
[28:48]
done." Martha left left a list for me. I
[28:51]
said, "Oh, you got honeydew to do." I
[28:53]
said, "Do you need me to come over and
[28:54]
help you?" I was like, "Oh, no. If you
[28:56]
come, she's going to be mad. I'm going
[28:57]
to get in trouble." I said, "Okay, we'll
[28:59]
get off the phone so that you can go do
[29:01]
your honeydew list." And that was that
[29:04]
was the type of relationship we had. It didn't matter. It didn't matter if we didn't talk for weeks because we were
[29:11]
mad together. And then he would call,
[29:14]
"Oh, Kenny, I'm sorry. I can I talk now?
[29:17]
You know, so but
[29:20]
that was
[29:22]
the loving side, the the man's side, the father's side, the brother's side of
[29:27]
him, and I I I will I will truly miss
[29:31]
him. Um, yesterday we went over to the
[29:35]
supervisor's office and they had a
[29:39]
moment of silence also for Max Rodriguez
[29:42]
yesterday. And today um I went to the
[29:49]
um celebration of life
[29:52]
for Max and
[29:56]
it was very very moving, very touching.
[29:58]
I wanted to make sure that we were
[30:00]
representing you know the city
[30:05]
because we need to be able to have
[30:06]
partnerships and we need to come
[30:08]
together. life is so short and you just
[30:12]
never know from one day to the next when
[30:16]
you may take your your last breath, you
[30:18]
know. Um,
[30:21]
I I'm not going to say that I'm just
[30:25]
overly overly religious, but one thing I
[30:28]
do believe and I do believe is that we
[30:31]
all have a number.
[30:33]
And one day,
[30:36]
God will call your name.
[30:38]
And I just pray that each and every one
[30:41]
of you who have differences will forgive
[30:44]
each other. Because in order to make it
[30:46]
into the kingdom of heaven,
[30:49]
you have to forgive. And you got to let
[30:52]
some stuff go,
[30:54]
you know. And and today I I listened to
[30:58]
um supervisor
[31:01]
and he talked about how he and Max were
[31:04]
of different parties, but on the local
[31:08]
level, it shouldn't matter because we're
[31:10]
supposed to all be here for each other.
[31:13]
And that's that's the bond that we need
[31:16]
to have as a community, be it county or
[31:20]
city. We're all one and we need to come
[31:23]
together as one. Our two went to major
[31:28]
cities. And it was so nice. There was
[31:31]
five of us that were there and the
[31:33]
camaraderie was just awesome to just be
[31:36]
able to sit with my colleagues and we
[31:38]
didn't violate the Brown Act. you
[31:39]
talking about too much other stuff other
[31:41]
than of the city. But it was just nice
[31:46]
because there's many times that I go and
[31:49]
especially with the the housing, you
[31:52]
know, it's it's only the two of us. And
[31:55]
it was nice to be able to walk into a
[31:57]
room and see people that look just like
[31:59]
me because generally the only one in
[32:03]
this room is myself and Joe.
[32:07]
And it's it's it's odd. It's very odd.
[32:11]
Um I want you to know that
[32:16]
we need to come together. I I went on
[32:19]
last Monday to Sacramento to the um
[32:22]
legislative day
[32:25]
and
[32:27]
I was there and we went from building to
[32:31]
building. We went to different
[32:33]
representatives offices.
[32:35]
The only one that made time for us and
[32:39]
no disrespect was um Assembly woman.
[32:44]
And she's here. She comes here and she
[32:46]
and some folks were just like thick
[32:48]
speech as well as um senator
[32:52]
and we need to have that type of
[32:54]
partnership
[32:56]
amongst all of us. We come in here we
[32:59]
smile but there was a song and I'm aging
[33:03]
myself years ago. It was by the
[33:05]
temptations. It's called smiling faces
[33:08]
sometimes
[33:10]
pretend to be your friend. We need to
[33:12]
get away from that.
[33:14]
We can
[33:17]
pray. We have this in God and trust. But
[33:21]
how many of us really take the time
[33:24]
to just
[33:26]
really trust each other
[33:31]
trust that love that we're supposed to
[33:34]
have as colleagues. We're supposed to
[33:37]
help as a city.
[33:40]
I thank you guys for being here tonight.
[33:43]
God bless each and every one of you and
[33:45]
I go back.
[33:46]
>> Thank you for your comment, Mayor Prom
[33:48]
Zachariah.
[33:50]
>> But uh um but well said. I mean uh the
[33:57]
experience that we've had with Santos as
[33:58]
a um just a former Guanian with us we as
[34:02]
a service club member. Um the things he
[34:05]
did for the community that's always
[34:06]
where he had his heart and it it is
[34:08]
going to be a big loss. Um, you know,
[34:11]
that same day was also a big victory
[34:13]
from Derek for the Mattown robotics. Um,
[34:16]
got to watch that and
[34:18]
worrisome as we always do every year.
[34:20]
Uh, but to it's it's a great thing for
[34:23]
the community. Um, I I would hope to
[34:25]
have them uh to come for a proclamation
[34:28]
at some point. So, I don't know put on
[34:30]
the agenda. Um, I know next meeting will
[34:33]
probably be full with the the ones that
[34:35]
were moving from this agenda, but um,
[34:37]
you know, have been here. It would be
[34:38]
nice to kind of recognize him as for all
[34:39]
the work you've done through the beer.
[34:40]
So, thank you.
[34:42]
>> Can you let everybody know what happened
[34:44]
at the end
[34:45]
>> as far the end end? Well,
[34:47]
>> um
[34:49]
>> well,
[34:50]
for the fourth
[34:51]
>> fourth time, two times in a row. Um and
[34:55]
what's what's always key to understand
[34:56]
is again to remind people this is not
[34:58]
nationals. This is this is the world
[35:00]
scale. So, they were going
[35:01]
internationally, China, Mexico, Israel,
[35:04]
um all the big big names you would
[35:06]
imagine. and Lil Madera is is the center
[35:08]
of the world when it comes to robotics.
[35:10]
So just remember that. So yeah,
[35:12]
>> that's right.
[35:13]
>> Perfect.
[35:13]
>> Yeah.
[35:16]
>> Thank you for your time, Council Member
[35:18]
Montes.
[35:19]
>> And I'll be I'll be brief and I'm sure
[35:20]
it won't be as eloquent as some of my
[35:22]
colleagues. U but I do also want to
[35:24]
express my condolences to the the
[35:26]
families of the Rodriguez and the Garcia
[35:28]
families. Um they were both leaders in
[35:30]
the community. They were both leaders in
[35:32]
the community and I'm sure it's going to
[35:33]
leave a void in a lot of people's
[35:36]
hearts. Um, and so my thoughts and
[35:38]
prayers go out to their friends, family,
[35:40]
and loved ones. And I guess I need to
[35:42]
get out more often cuz that is the end
[35:43]
of my report.
[35:45]
>> Thank you for your report. And we were
[35:47]
talking about how they did so much for
[35:49]
this community. This weekend was a
[35:51]
packed house. We had Relay for Life that
[35:54]
raised $57,000
[35:56]
just from Madera. We had Doors of Hope
[35:59]
that opened up their doors for this
[36:01]
community to come see what they're all
[36:03]
about. Uh Gong Boxing gym opened in the
[36:06]
city of Madera this weekend and Madera
[36:09]
High School Coyotes did a volleyball
[36:10]
camp for our young uh students uh K
[36:13]
through six. We also had the Madera
[36:16]
County Office of Education put on the
[36:17]
Artfest. Great event. And what was kind
[36:21]
of exciting, we had our law enforcements
[36:23]
that united for an 80 mile ride came
[36:26]
through our city for fallen law law
[36:28]
enforcement officers. That was very
[36:30]
exciting. I got to see them. Um, what
[36:33]
was exciting for me is I got to be at a
[36:35]
ribbon cutting with the governor and his
[36:37]
first partner wife that we are opening
[36:40]
up our national parks for uh free of
[36:44]
service. If students or adults want to
[36:46]
get a free pass from our Madera County
[36:48]
Library, they can do that. And their um
[36:52]
vision is in 30 years to uh acquire
[36:56]
30,000 more uh square footage of
[37:00]
parkland. So they're calling it 30 by
[37:02]
30. So going to see the governor and
[37:05]
championing parks. I'm a parks and gal
[37:07]
way back. I was very excited to be there
[37:09]
with so many other elected officials. It
[37:12]
was held at Sycamore Island in Madera
[37:14]
County. So, in our backyard, we had the
[37:16]
governor here a few weeks ago and that
[37:18]
was very um exciting for all of us. One
[37:21]
more thing I'd like to remind everyone
[37:23]
in the community is the Madera uh
[37:25]
prayers breakfast is tomorrow morning
[37:28]
and hope to see everyone there for that.
[37:31]
With that, um at this time, I will close
[37:34]
um the reports from the council and move
[37:37]
on to the next item.
[37:40]
Section A, public hearings. Item A1,
[37:42]
consideration of ordinance text
[37:44]
amendment 2026-01
[37:46]
for the amendment of chapter 3, planning
[37:49]
and zoning of the city municipal code
[37:51]
regarding a commercial color palette and
[37:52]
establishment of exterior paint color
[37:54]
standards for construction of new
[37:56]
buildings and repainting existing
[37:57]
buildings with commercial zone
[37:59]
districts.
[37:59]
>> Thank you. And that will be presented by
[38:01]
our planning director, Breick. Thank you
[38:03]
for being here tonight.
[38:11]
Good evening, mayor val council, David,
[38:14]
planning manager. This item is ordinance
[38:17]
test amendment 2026-01
[38:21]
and it's for exterior paint color and
[38:22]
exterior paint color in commercial zone
[38:26]
districts.
[38:27]
Uh what brought us here tonight? There
[38:29]
was the council's uh concern that they
[38:31]
expressed over repainting of commercial
[38:34]
structures with colors that were were
[38:37]
disruptive or distracting in our
[38:39]
established commercial zone districts.
[38:41]
And on February 18th, 2026, council
[38:44]
received a report from staff regarding
[38:46]
color pallets for new development,
[38:48]
repainting of existing structures and
[38:50]
commercial zones.
[38:53]
Per the municipal code, the the council
[38:56]
has the authority to amend zoning
[38:58]
regulations by initiating a text
[39:01]
amendment by resolution, sending that uh
[39:04]
into motion with starting with the
[39:06]
planning commission, first holding
[39:08]
public hearing, reviewing draft
[39:10]
ordinance, making a recommendation to
[39:13]
the council which is coming before you
[39:14]
tonight and the council taking action on
[39:17]
that draft ordinance.
[39:20]
Uh again getting to tonight the
[39:22]
council's concern was
[39:25]
uh maintaining the scenic beauty of our
[39:28]
community primarily commercial districts
[39:31]
and you have that authority through
[39:32]
zoning regulations in government code
[39:34]
section 65850
[39:37]
that includes regulation of paint color
[39:39]
and that is the ordinance that's before
[39:41]
you tonight. Council's direction was to
[39:44]
establish standards for commercial zone
[39:46]
districts through approved colors both
[39:49]
for new development and for repainting
[39:51]
of existing structures in commercial
[39:53]
districts with an emphasis of
[39:55]
prohibiting uh nuisance or bright colors
[39:58]
in those districts.
[40:01]
April 21st, 2026, your planning
[40:03]
commission adopted a resolution that's
[40:04]
included in your staff report resolution
[40:07]
2049. It's their review and
[40:10]
recommendation of the draft ordinance
[40:12]
and that's before you tonight and
[40:13]
they're recommending improvement.
[40:15]
The ordinance itself applies to
[40:18]
incommercial districts, new buildings,
[40:22]
additions to existing buildings,
[40:24]
reconstruction of existing buildings
[40:26]
even where it's caused by natural
[40:28]
disaster, fire or tornado. We had
[40:30]
warnings a few weeks ago. repainting of
[40:33]
existing buildings. Where it doesn't
[40:35]
apply is if for some reason there's code
[40:38]
enforcement action or vandalism or
[40:41]
graffiti, something needs to be
[40:43]
repainted. The requirement is that they
[40:44]
match their existing building as close
[40:46]
as possible. So, this doesn't
[40:48]
necessarily apply to that. Uh the color
[40:51]
selection um within commercial district
[40:55]
was that it be non-reflective, subtle,
[40:57]
and be based on neutral or gray tone
[40:59]
colors. The ordinance also specifies a
[41:02]
certain percentage 10% uh can have
[41:05]
accent or trim colors that are different
[41:09]
and it requires your ordinance requires
[41:11]
approval by the planning department. So
[41:13]
be developed a draft application that
[41:15]
needs to be submitted both for new new
[41:17]
buildings and repainting of structures.
[41:21]
There's no fee for that application.
[41:23]
It's reviewed and approved by staff. If
[41:25]
for some reason staff feels they can't
[41:28]
approve it, that decision is appealable
[41:30]
to your planning commission. The
[41:32]
planning commission's decision is
[41:33]
appealable to the city council where
[41:35]
you're the ultimate authority on that
[41:37]
decision.
[41:40]
The ordinance before you tonight amends
[41:41]
the city code and it sets a process to
[41:45]
establish the color palette. So the
[41:47]
ordinance doesn't set the color palette.
[41:49]
It says that the color palette is set by
[41:51]
resolution, but that resolution is
[41:53]
approved by the city council. So, that
[41:55]
allows you more flexible process should
[41:57]
you ever need to win the the uh
[42:00]
acceptable color palette.
[42:03]
In your staff report, the draft includes
[42:07]
a healthy list of acceptable colors and
[42:10]
trim colors. Again, that can be amended.
[42:14]
And this SQA this uh ordinance amendment
[42:17]
process is exempt from SQA under the
[42:19]
common sense exemption.
[42:22]
The next step should you approve
[42:24]
tonight's uh first reading is that we
[42:26]
schedule a second reading which goes on
[42:28]
your consent agenda. Tenatively that
[42:29]
would be May 20th 2026.
[42:33]
At that same meeting we would uh
[42:35]
agendaize a hearing for resolution to
[42:38]
set the color palette for you.
[42:42]
staff's recommendation first is a minor
[42:45]
uh edit to the draft ordinance that's
[42:48]
included in your staff report. Uh the
[42:50]
full text of that section is listed in
[42:53]
this slide and you can see where we
[42:56]
strike out and replace. It's the third
[42:59]
or fourth line from the bottom striking
[43:01]
out sign permit and inserting
[43:04]
application. That's the first part of
[43:06]
our recommendation. The second part is
[43:08]
that you then laid the full reading and
[43:10]
introduced by title uh this ordinance of
[43:13]
the city council of the city of Madera
[43:15]
determining the project is exempt from
[43:17]
SQA section 15061 B3
[43:21]
of the SQA of California quality act
[43:24]
guidelines and amending chapter 3 of
[43:26]
title 10 which defining the zoning of
[43:29]
the city municipal code regarding the
[43:31]
stereo colors and commercial zone
[43:33]
districts. That concludes my report and
[43:35]
I will try to answer any questions you
[43:38]
may have.
[43:39]
>> Thank you for that. I'll bring it back
[43:40]
to my colleagues for any questions or
[43:42]
concerns.
[43:46]
» Councilwoman Evans.
[43:47]
>> I'm trying to find another one.
[43:50]
>> Can you bring back up the the color
[43:52]
palettes, please?
[43:54]
>> Yes.
[44:00]
» Might have to look up here. She's
[44:02]
working on
[44:08]
» not on their screen.
[44:38]
Okay. I have a recommendation. This this
[44:41]
is personal, but I mean I'm looking at
[44:43]
the colors that we have here and because
[44:45]
of our city, I have a recommendation to
[44:48]
go no more than looking from 27 to 42 in reference to the city and and the
[44:58]
colors that it could possibly be. That's
[45:00]
just my um recommendation
[45:03]
27 to 42.
[45:07]
But I thank you so much for your report.
[45:09]
That was that was what I wanted to take.
[45:13]
>> So tonight's action is just the
[45:15]
ordinance and its process but we will
[45:18]
take your comment back with us and
[45:19]
include that in my presentation for
[45:22]
resolution to adopt. There's um it's a a
[45:26]
long list but if you have the
[45:29]
flexibility to direct us which you
[45:31]
expect a few adopted.
[45:34]
>> Okay. Thank you for your comment mayor
[45:35]
pro Tim Sachariah.
[45:38]
Um, and this question I know I'd asked
[45:40]
before, but like for instance, when we
[45:41]
have like downtown district that um may
[45:45]
have um a certain kind of feel to it
[45:48]
that they want to have that we still
[45:50]
have the how hard will it be in the
[45:52]
future to add or change the pallet as we
[45:55]
go? Is it simple single meeting? Is it
[45:57]
something that has to go back to public
[46:00]
or
[46:00]
>> It's a single meeting. We would schedule
[46:03]
Well, it would be two meetings because
[46:04]
you would need to direct us to get it
[46:05]
onto the agenda. We would do that. um
[46:08]
and bring u modifications for you to
[46:10]
consider.
[46:11]
>> Okay. And and as far as um like once we
[46:14]
approve is planning have any part of
[46:16]
that as well or it's just we're going to
[46:18]
do demand, right? I mean we're going to
[46:20]
dictate the colors, send it back to
[46:21]
planning. They're going to be ones to
[46:23]
kind of enforce in sense.
[46:24]
>> We'll modify the application that
[46:27]
includes the colors that are that are
[46:28]
permissible and then that would be the
[46:30]
new standard where when we apply if it's
[46:32]
in there staff can approve it. We can
[46:34]
keep moving. If it's not in there and it
[46:36]
wants to be added or you're suggesting
[46:38]
something be removed, we would need to
[46:39]
do that.
[46:40]
>> And there's no color restrictions for
[46:42]
instance for companies that have
[46:44]
specific colors to their
[46:46]
>> their personality there that would be in
[46:49]
the trim for instance, right? If I again
[46:52]
have a purple
[46:54]
business, but I can still put that on
[46:56]
the trim and that's exempted from the
[46:57]
pallet color or the trim is going to be
[47:00]
restricted to the pallet. The draft
[47:02]
ordinance says 10% of the trend and the
[47:05]
draft color palette that's included in
[47:08]
your staff report. If it's included,
[47:11]
they can they can propose 10% include
[47:14]
that color.
[47:14]
>> And and I'm just using an example like
[47:16]
McDonald's is yellow and red. So they
[47:19]
would have to be very 10% is all they're
[47:21]
going to be having on that whole
[47:23]
building or the trinities at least as
[47:25]
far as their colors. And if that's
[47:27]
staff's interpretation through that
[47:29]
process, then that could be appealed to
[47:31]
the planning commission which can be
[47:32]
appealed to you.
[47:34]
>> Thank you.
[47:34]
for your comment. I see no
[47:36]
other comments. I just would like to
[47:38]
thank staff for bringing this back with
[47:39]
this information. It was very important
[47:41]
to us. So we thank them for their time.
[47:43]
With that, I open up the public hearing.
[47:45]
Anybody in the chamber have any
[47:47]
comments?
[47:51]
» I see none. Anyone online or on Zoom?
[47:55]
>> Gotcha.
[47:57]
There's no one on Zoom.
[47:58]
>> Thank you. With that, I will close the
[48:00]
public hearing and bring it back to my
[48:03]
city attorney to wave the full reading.
[48:06]
>> Thank you. If you're inclined to approve
[48:07]
this, the motion would be wave full
[48:09]
reading and introduced by title and
[48:10]
ordinance of city council city mader
[48:12]
attorney. The project is exempt pursuit
[48:13]
to section 150613 of the California
[48:16]
environmental quality act guidelines and
[48:17]
amending chapter 3 of title 10 planning
[48:19]
and zoning of the city municipal code
[48:20]
CMC regarding exterior colors and
[48:22]
commercial zone districts as amended by
[48:24]
staff. Thank you. Thank you. Well done.
[48:26]
I will bring it back to my colleagues
[48:27]
for a motion in a second.
[48:29]
>> Motion to approve as written.
[48:31]
>> Second.
[48:31]
>> I have a motion and a second. All those
[48:33]
in favor as written or as stated?
[48:35]
>> As stated. Please forgive me. As stated.
[48:37]
>> Thank you. Motion and a second. All
[48:39]
those in favor say I.
[48:40]
>> I.
[48:41]
>> Those opposed. Motion passes
[48:43]
unanimously. Thank you for that. Great
[48:45]
report. Moving on to uh the next item.
[48:48]
City Clerk Gonzalez.
[48:50]
>> Consent calendar. Matters listed under
[48:52]
the consent calendar are considered
[48:53]
routine and will be enacted by one
[48:55]
motion and one vote. There will be no
[48:57]
separate discussion of these items. If
[48:59]
discussion is desired, a member of the
[49:00]
public or a member of the council may
[49:02]
request an item be removed from the
[49:04]
consent calendar and it will be
[49:05]
considered separately.
[49:06]
>> Thank you. So, I'll bring it to my
[49:08]
colleagues for any concerns or
[49:09]
questions.
[49:11]
I see none. I open it up for public
[49:13]
comment. Anyone in the chamber?
[49:17]
Anyone online or on Zoom? City clerk, we
[49:19]
have none. Mayor, thank you. Do I close
[49:21]
public comment and bring it back to my
[49:22]
colleagues for a motion and a second?
[49:24]
>> Move to approve consent.
[49:26]
>> I'll second.
[49:26]
>> Thank you for that. I have a motion and
[49:28]
a second. All those in favor say I.
[49:31]
>> Those opposed. Motion passes
[49:33]
unanimously. Um, next item. Item D1,
[49:37]
landscape and lighting assessment
[49:38]
district zones of benefit. Engineers
[49:40]
report an intention to levy and collect
[49:43]
annual assessment for citywide landscape
[49:44]
and lightning assess lighting assessment
[49:46]
district zones for benefit for fiscal
[49:49]
year 202627.
[49:51]
>> Thank you for that. That will be
[49:52]
presented by our admin analyst. A thank
[49:54]
you for being here tonight.
[49:58]
>> Thank you mayor and council. Um Nicole
[50:01]
Sab analyst department. I'm here tonight
[50:04]
to present the 26 27 landscape
[50:06]
maintenance system board. Wave that
[50:08]
everyone on council has been through
[50:09]
this at least once but for anybody
[50:11]
following along at home we will a little
[50:13]
bit of background. Beginning in 1991 as
[50:16]
projects were approved they were annexed
[50:18]
into the landscape maintenance district
[50:20]
or LM program. Today there are 80 active
[50:22]
zones of benefits within the city web
[50:25]
district program. Are developed prior to
[50:27]
this were not subject to this
[50:29]
assessment. Assessments are collected as
[50:30]
part of property taxes to maintain
[50:32]
common landscaped areas. Uh rates were
[50:36]
set when the zones were established as
[50:38]
was the maximum amount that may be
[50:39]
charged. To exceed or raise the maximum
[50:42]
amount, the majority of parcels in each
[50:44]
zone must vote in the affirmative. This
[50:47]
is the current map of all 80 zones you
[50:49]
see repeating around town.
[50:52]
Zone 51 is the citywide zone. not see
[50:56]
that on the map as unfortunately are one
[50:59]
right here but they all all over the
[51:02]
city.
[51:04]
Uh the history of the internet force
[51:05]
prepared on an annual basis incorporates
[51:07]
past expenses revenues and projected
[51:09]
expenses and revenues. It makes
[51:12]
recommendations uh on adjustments to
[51:14]
assessments based on data provided by
[51:16]
the finance department as finally in the
[51:18]
city's datas
[51:20]
and estimates of upcoming expenses from
[51:24]
parks and finance departments.
[51:26]
Uh changes since the last report uh the
[51:30]
city could not levy assessments
[51:46]
sounding brand.
[52:17]
I swear.
[52:31]
» Okay, back on track. Uh changing since
[52:33]
the last report, city cannot fund
[52:34]
assessments on negative fund balances
[52:36]
based on operational funds older than
[52:38]
the current fiscal year, which is fiscal
[52:40]
year 2025 26. Operational losses from
[52:44]
2024 and prior years have been removed.
[52:46]
This equates to $52,78
[52:49]
that must be covered by general fund.
[52:51]
For the current fiscal year 2526,
[52:53]
project to have an operational loss of
[52:55]
$41,922.
[52:57]
The next fiscal year, fiscal year 2627,
[53:00]
we're projecting to have an offer to a
[53:01]
loss of $63,382.
[53:05]
For fiscal year 2627, we will continue
[53:08]
to adjust assessments on a per zone
[53:10]
basis when permitted by individual zone
[53:12]
covenants. What this means in practice
[53:14]
is there will be no cost adjustments or
[53:16]
co-as. We will increase up to but no
[53:19]
higher the base threshold amount in
[53:21]
agreements as they approved. We will
[53:24]
continue to consider avenues for zone
[53:25]
consolidation. This is still a bit of an
[53:28]
up battle as zone consolidation can
[53:30]
cause assessments for many property
[53:31]
owners to increase in the short term
[53:33]
which makes success difficult.
[53:36]
Changes uh going forward as fund
[53:39]
balances in certain zones continue to
[53:40]
drop changes will be needed to minimize
[53:42]
losses. However, direction will be
[53:44]
needed as to what those changes may be.
[53:47]
Certain options have been discussed in
[53:48]
the past and here's just a quick
[53:50]
overview of some of them. Um reduction
[53:53]
in service is kind of the default first
[53:55]
action that we could do. Uh which would
[53:58]
be a reduction of service means reducing
[53:59]
either the frequency of visits to a
[54:01]
given zone, reduction in the amount of
[54:03]
time spent on site or some combination
[54:05]
of the two. Uh the pros of this would be
[54:07]
it would reduce the amount of manhour in
[54:09]
affected zones which would in theory
[54:11]
lower the amount of labor required. Uh a
[54:13]
con would be that the landscaping would
[54:15]
become overgrown and potentially lose a
[54:17]
static appeal. Uh we believe that
[54:19]
residents are generally not in favor of
[54:21]
this effect. Also an option would be
[54:23]
removal of landscaping. Uh removal of
[54:25]
landscaping involves removing either
[54:27]
shrubs, flowers or trees. Removal of
[54:29]
trees would generally not be considered
[54:31]
as part of this route. The pros are that
[54:34]
it has to reduce the time spent on
[54:36]
infected zones thereby reducing labor
[54:38]
hours required. Uh the cons are again
[54:41]
that requires upfront labor costs for
[54:43]
staff to remove and dispose under new
[54:44]
landscaping and then potential future
[54:46]
costs to replant should zone balances
[54:49]
increase in the future. And again you
[54:51]
can believe that residents are generally
[54:52]
not in favor of this time.
[54:56]
The I believe this is the last uh
[54:59]
recommendation or possibility rather
[55:01]
would be altered landscaping. Uh this
[55:03]
option involves either replacing the
[55:05]
existing plants with less labor
[55:07]
intensive alternatives such as natural
[55:08]
ground cover or installation with
[55:10]
features that require little to no
[55:12]
maintenance such as zeroscaping. The
[55:14]
pros are it has the potential to reduce
[55:16]
labor costs while also potentially
[55:18]
maintaining aesthetic appeal. But the
[55:20]
downside would be that depending on the
[55:21]
alternative landscaping chosen material
[55:24]
costs could be prohibitively uh
[55:26]
restrictive and could potentially
[55:27]
require a significant amount of labor to
[55:29]
convert into visual signs.
[55:32]
The recommendation for tonight would be
[55:33]
to approve the intern report with
[55:34]
amendments as may be requested.
[55:36]
Authorize staff to file a 10-day public
[55:39]
notice for public hearing and schedule a
[55:42]
public meeting for council session on
[55:44]
June 17th. And with that, happy to
[55:46]
answer any questions.
[55:48]
>> Thank you for that. I'll bring it back
[55:49]
to my colleagues for any questions or
[55:50]
comments. I see none. I will open it up
[55:53]
for public comment. Anyone in the
[55:55]
chamber?
[55:57]
Anyone online or on Zoom? City Clerk
[55:59]
Gonzalez. No attendees have requested to
[56:01]
speak. Mayor,
[56:02]
>> thank you. I will close public comment
[56:04]
at this time and bring it back to my
[56:06]
colleagues for adoption. I need a motion
[56:08]
and a second.
[56:09]
>> Move to adopt.
[56:13]
>> Thank you. I have a motion and a second.
[56:15]
All those in favor say I.
[56:16]
>> I.
[56:17]
>> Those opposed? Motion passes
[56:19]
unanimously. Thank you. Admin analyst
[56:22]
for your report. Moving on to the next
[56:24]
item. Item D2, Raymond Road Street
[56:27]
improvements, rebid city project R37,
[56:29]
CAMAC 5157094,
[56:32]
shoulder paving and RMR street rehab.
[56:35]
All right, presented by our senior
[56:37]
engineer, Ben Court. Great to see you
[56:39]
this evening.
[56:40]
>> Good to be here.
[56:52]
» Go ahead. Quick.
[57:04]
Almost had it there.
[57:05]
>> Almost.
[57:13]
» Sorry about that.
[57:15]
>> Mayor city council. My name is E. I'm a
[57:18]
senior civil engineer with the system
[57:20]
engineering department here in the
[57:21]
county. I'm here to make presentation
[57:24]
for contract award for the RMAN road
[57:27]
street improvements rebid for city
[57:29]
project 37 at Cmax CML is 157094
[57:35]
shoulder paving and RM rehab
[57:40]
context the the congestion mitigation
[57:43]
air quality act um funding is specific
[57:46]
only for the shoulder baby portion of
[57:48]
this project on road and the regional
[57:52]
surface transportation program RSTP
[57:54]
exchange funding is specific only for
[57:56]
the existing pavement and rehab.
[57:59]
Uh this is just Raymond Road. It extends
[58:02]
from from Kingland Avenue all the way up
[58:04]
to the northeast
[58:07]
city boundary. The northern southern
[58:09]
limits of shoulder pavement pavement
[58:11]
rehab are the same. Therefore, we
[58:12]
combine two projects. There's expected
[58:15]
cost savings by fitting both projects
[58:17]
together under one contract.
[58:20]
Two bid schedules were incorporated for
[58:22]
each funding source for tracking
[58:23]
purposes, but the award is based on the
[58:26]
sum of both schedules. This project is a
[58:28]
rebid of a project that was advertised
[58:30]
earlier this year. Due to potentially
[58:33]
ambiguous language regarding bid
[58:35]
documents, concerns were raised by
[58:37]
contractors after bail brief and city
[58:40]
council adop resolution 26-38 on March
[58:44]
28th, 2026 rejecting the bid and
[58:47]
authorized engineering public to be
[58:48]
advertised.
[58:51]
Project limits are Cleveland Avenue to
[58:53]
the city limits to the northeast.
[58:56]
The work in general consists of enlion,
[58:58]
clearing, rubbing for new shoulder
[59:00]
pading and approximately 8 foot of
[59:01]
shoulder paving on the river side of
[59:03]
rain road
[59:05]
rehab includes drying, replace type two
[59:08]
microsurfacing, surface prep and crack
[59:10]
sand and also to remove and replace all
[59:16]
map.
[59:22]
Project bing on March 25th 2026 city
[59:25]
released the revis
[59:28]
city's plan west portal and notice invar
[59:33]
tribute newspaper on March 25th and
[59:35]
again on March 28 2026
[59:38]
April 21st 2026 five bids were received
[59:42]
the bids were checked for accuracy
[59:44]
against bidding requirements delivering
[59:46]
licenses and bid curated the lowest bid
[59:50]
was war brothers general engineering
[59:52]
The local contractor is almost down the
[59:55]
road. This is a summary of the bids.
[1:00:00]
Loganz
[1:00:04]
is 1964.
[1:00:09]
It was well below the engineer's opinion
[1:00:11]
cost.
[1:00:15]
Wars Brothers General Engineering
[1:00:16]
Incorporated submitted the lowest bid of
[1:00:18]
$443,261.
[1:00:21]
They met all the bidder documentation
[1:00:23]
requirements and selected as lowest
[1:00:25]
responsive and responsible bidder
[1:00:28]
recommended allow recommending an
[1:00:30]
allowance of 10% of contract amount for
[1:00:32]
contingency resulting from unforeseen
[1:00:34]
conditions project is funded with
[1:00:37]
congested navigation and air quality
[1:00:39]
CMAC and local transportation fun
[1:00:42]
shoulder pavement only and the regional
[1:00:44]
surface transportation transation
[1:00:51]
from staff is adopt the resolution
[1:00:52]
approving the contract award for the
[1:00:54]
Raymond Road Street improvements bid
[1:00:56]
city project 37 R37 CMAX CNL5157094
[1:01:01]
shoulder paving and RMR pavement rehab
[1:01:04]
in the amount 443,261
[1:01:08]
plus contingencies to wars general
[1:01:11]
engineering incorporated and adopt a
[1:01:14]
secret class one existing facilities
[1:01:16]
cate categorical exemption Sure.
[1:01:24]
» Presentation. Any questions?
[1:01:26]
>> Thank you. Uh, senior engineer Baron
[1:01:28]
Court. I can tell you the residents are
[1:01:29]
going to be happy. I drive that road
[1:01:31]
quite often. So, woohoo. Thank you for
[1:01:33]
championing that project through. I
[1:01:35]
bring it back to my colleagues for any
[1:01:37]
questions or concerns. I see none. I
[1:01:39]
open it up for public comment.
[1:01:42]
I see none in the chamber, online, or on
[1:01:44]
Zoom. City Clair Gonzalez.
[1:01:45]
>> No attendees have requested to speak.
[1:01:47]
Mayor,
[1:01:48]
>> thank you. Do I close public comment at
[1:01:49]
this time and bring it back to my
[1:01:51]
colleagues for a motion and a second?
[1:01:53]
>> Motion to approve as written.
[1:01:54]
>> Second.
[1:01:55]
>> I have a motion and a second. Ty, you
[1:01:59]
want to
[1:02:01]
>> Mayor Pro Tim Zachariah second. All
[1:02:03]
those in favor say I.
[1:02:05]
>> I.
[1:02:06]
>> Those opposed motion passes unanimously.
[1:02:09]
Thank you for that presentation.
[1:02:10]
>> Thank you very much.
[1:02:11]
>> Moving on to the next item.
[1:02:15]
>> Um item E1 and E2. We're continuing to
[1:02:17]
the May 20th meeting. Moving on to E3,
[1:02:19]
direction regarding animal control
[1:02:20]
services agreement with the county of
[1:02:22]
Madera and consideration of establishing
[1:02:23]
a city county ad hoc committee.
[1:02:26]
>> Thank you for that. Presented by our
[1:02:27]
city manager Rodriguez.
[1:02:31]
>> Thank you very much, Mayor, members of
[1:02:32]
the council. For the record or the city
[1:02:35]
manager, the before you this evening is
[1:02:37]
to establish an ad committee at the
[1:02:39]
request of Madera County. For
[1:02:41]
background, the city and the county
[1:02:43]
entered into an agreement in 2018. Next
[1:02:46]
slide, Lisa.
[1:02:49]
» Captain. Oh, never mind. I'm sorry.
[1:02:51]
Let's don't listen to me.
[1:02:53]
>> Um, and under that agreement, the city
[1:02:55]
provides our own animal control
[1:02:57]
officers. We currently have two officers
[1:02:59]
and we provide the equipment and all the
[1:03:00]
necessary um items for those officers.
[1:03:03]
However, the animal control shelter
[1:03:05]
itself is controlled and managed by the
[1:03:08]
county. Um, so currently if the city
[1:03:11]
picks up an animal, we we take it down
[1:03:14]
to the animal control shelter. If a
[1:03:16]
community member has an animal, a stray
[1:03:18]
animal, they in 30 would take it to the
[1:03:20]
shelter. There have been some challenges
[1:03:22]
with that agreement in that the county
[1:03:24]
at times is at capacity or has indicated
[1:03:27]
or has notified the city that they u
[1:03:30]
that they do not have the ability to
[1:03:31]
take some of the animals. When that
[1:03:33]
happens, unfortunately, the animal will
[1:03:35]
stay in the neighborhood typically where
[1:03:36]
it's found. um as part of the agreement
[1:03:40]
while it's not directly uh related to
[1:03:43]
the animal control service agreement
[1:03:44]
there's a second component to that and
[1:03:46]
that second part is that the city
[1:03:48]
provides law enforcement services to
[1:03:50]
courthouse park I do want to identity
[1:03:56]
members have talked about the city has
[1:03:58]
this agreement so again this is the 2018
[1:04:00]
agreement we commonly refer to it as the
[1:04:02]
animal control agreement there's there's
[1:04:05]
a second agreement that is not part of
[1:04:06]
this and that is the tax revenue
[1:04:08]
agreement. What that agreement does is
[1:04:10]
it it outlines um how property taxes are
[1:04:14]
split between the city and the county.
[1:04:17]
It it identifies u sales tax. The city
[1:04:20]
pays 4.5% of our sales tax goes to the
[1:04:24]
county. So again, 4.5% of the city sales
[1:04:27]
tax goes to the county. Um and then it
[1:04:31]
also outlines that the city provides law
[1:04:33]
enforcement services to Parkwood.
[1:04:35]
is not in the city. It's
[1:04:36]
approximately 2,200 people, about 550
[1:04:39]
homes. And then also there is language u
[1:04:42]
that the city provides um some funding
[1:04:45]
for the library which is located in
[1:04:47]
downtown. And at the same time if um if
[1:04:50]
the water runway ever malfunctions,
[1:04:54]
there's an inner tie. So there's a large
[1:04:56]
gate valve. I believe it's an 8 inch
[1:04:58]
gate valve along Avenue 13 or Peak
[1:05:00]
Avenue. That gate valve is turned on
[1:05:02]
until the resident park would have
[1:05:04]
potable wires. That's a separate
[1:05:05]
agreement. So that agreement is not part
[1:05:08]
of this agreement. And there's a third
[1:05:09]
agreement and that third agreement
[1:05:11]
pertains to fire services. And if that
[1:05:14]
agreement spells out is that it's
[1:05:16]
nearest um nearest equipment um is going
[1:05:20]
to respond to an emergency. So if the
[1:05:21]
fire is in the county and our agent is
[1:05:24]
closer, we will respond. And likewise,
[1:05:25]
if there's a fire in the city and the
[1:05:27]
county agent is closer, they will assist
[1:05:29]
us. Um those two agreements are not part
[1:05:32]
of this agreement. And the only
[1:05:33]
agreement that the county is requesting
[1:05:34]
that we revisit would be for animal
[1:05:36]
control itself.
[1:05:39]
So for context, um going back to 2021,
[1:05:42]
the city was paying roughly $157,000.
[1:05:46]
Uh more recently in the current fiscal
[1:05:48]
year, we have paid about $191,000.
[1:05:51]
The reason it increases every year is
[1:05:53]
there is a 5% cost of living adjustment
[1:05:56]
uh built into that agreement. At the
[1:05:59]
time uh in 2018 the the price or the
[1:06:03]
cost for a law enforcement for us as far
[1:06:06]
was estimated at $60,000 per year. That
[1:06:09]
estimate does not have a cola so there
[1:06:11]
are no adjustments. So that estimate
[1:06:13]
historically stay at 60 for that one.
[1:06:15]
There's no cash exchange that's just
[1:06:17]
services or for the payment for the
[1:06:20]
shelter. There is payment we pay then so
[1:06:23]
the city pays the county.
[1:06:26]
Um, so again, the county has expressed a
[1:06:28]
desire to renew parachute, which they
[1:06:30]
have the the autonomy to make that
[1:06:34]
request and it's it's more specifically
[1:06:37]
outlined in section uh in section 7 in
[1:06:39]
the agreement. Um, so the county has
[1:06:42]
also indicated that if an agreement is
[1:06:44]
not reached between the city and the
[1:06:45]
county by the end of this fiscal year,
[1:06:48]
which is the end of June, that they
[1:06:50]
intend to to um to initiate a clause in
[1:06:54]
the agreement where they will be
[1:06:56]
providing the city 180 days to fully
[1:06:58]
terminate the agreement. Um, and then
[1:07:00]
that termination would be for animal
[1:07:03]
services and I suspect also for law
[1:07:05]
enforcement courthouse parks because
[1:07:07]
that's housed within the agreement.
[1:07:10]
With that said, there are a lot of
[1:07:12]
challenges with operating an animal
[1:07:13]
shelter as we've collectively talked
[1:07:15]
about. And um so a couple of things. Um
[1:07:20]
we our our animal vet bills which the
[1:07:22]
city pays for has uh increased over the
[1:07:24]
past couple of years which is shown on
[1:07:26]
the overhead. So two fiscal years about
[1:07:28]
$700 a year. We're we're currently at
[1:07:31]
about 25,000. We still have a couple
[1:07:33]
months to go. That is paid for out of
[1:07:34]
the general fund. The other thing to
[1:07:36]
note is that dog intakes have been
[1:07:38]
declining. It's not that we have less
[1:07:40]
dogs in the community. Rather, the
[1:07:42]
dental shelter um is declining to accept
[1:07:44]
the animals. So, you know, I I I can't
[1:07:47]
tell you yet the dog population has
[1:07:49]
increased or decreased in our community
[1:07:51]
and that's a difficult number to to seem
[1:07:53]
to quantify. However, uh the
[1:07:58]
animal shelter has indicated that they
[1:08:00]
are not accepting some of the city dogs.
[1:08:02]
Um and that and that is outlined. This
[1:08:05]
is data that we obtained directly from
[1:08:07]
the animal shelter. And so again, this
[1:08:09]
simply shows that the dog intakes in the
[1:08:10]
city is blue. They've slowly been de
[1:08:13]
creasing. And then we also have cats.
[1:08:17]
Um I should also note that that there is
[1:08:20]
a local measure being championed by some
[1:08:22]
community members um that they intend on
[1:08:26]
placing a measure on the November ballot
[1:08:28]
and that would be for quarters and sales
[1:08:30]
tax. So 0.25 25 on top of the the sales
[1:08:34]
tax that we have right now which is
[1:08:36]
8.25. So it would go to 8.5.
[1:08:38]
Um and that that course in sales tax
[1:08:42]
would would go to a group and my
[1:08:44]
understanding and reading the language
[1:08:45]
it it would uh then go to the county
[1:08:48]
sheriff to establish um animal services
[1:08:51]
countywide. Under that measure um a a
[1:08:55]
new shelter would be constructed and all
[1:08:58]
animal services would be provided
[1:09:00]
including animal control officers. Um so
[1:09:03]
um that packet was placed on your dice
[1:09:06]
this evening and again that was at the
[1:09:07]
request of one of the authors of the
[1:09:11]
measure. Um she also indicated that
[1:09:13]
there's an event this Friday at the
[1:09:15]
fairgrounds between 5 and 10 if anyone
[1:09:17]
would like information. Um I I'm not
[1:09:20]
necessarily advocating either way, but
[1:09:22]
um at her request, I did uh inform her
[1:09:25]
that I would be poisoned with this on
[1:09:26]
the agenda, and I told her that I would
[1:09:28]
notify council community. So the
[1:09:31]
recommendation this evening is that the
[1:09:33]
city council select um several council
[1:09:36]
members to sit as an ad hoc, which would
[1:09:38]
have been directly for the supervisor
[1:09:40]
members. Um at at the request of city
[1:09:44]
council, you could have staff there. Um
[1:09:46]
I'm I'm not positive if the county will
[1:09:48]
have staff there. Um but if that were
[1:09:51]
the case, I would recommend that the
[1:09:53]
chief of police and myself sit on that
[1:09:55]
at our committee or if there's anyone
[1:09:56]
from council that council would like in
[1:09:59]
terms of city staff, we would make
[1:10:00]
ourselves available. So with that, that
[1:10:02]
concludes my presentation. Thank you.
[1:10:05]
>> Thank you for that presentation. Um, I'm
[1:10:07]
just going to make a quick comment uh
[1:10:09]
from the staff report stating that uh
[1:10:13]
the county is looking to close the city
[1:10:16]
residents from having access if we don't
[1:10:18]
come to agreement. We have five
[1:10:21]
supervisors and four of them uh
[1:10:24]
represent city residents. We are county
[1:10:26]
residents as city residents as county
[1:10:29]
supervisors and council electeds. They
[1:10:31]
have two elected officials. Um, to say
[1:10:34]
that is disheartening because I'm a
[1:10:36]
county resident
[1:10:38]
>> and you're telling me just because I
[1:10:40]
live in the the city zoning area, you're
[1:10:43]
going to say I can't bring my animals
[1:10:44]
when I pay county taxes. Um, I have a
[1:10:48]
concern about that. The second thing was
[1:10:51]
um the part two of the ad hoc
[1:10:54]
city manager, tell me if I'm mistaken. I
[1:10:56]
thought some of that um for Parkwood
[1:11:00]
patrolling Parkwood was for the animal
[1:11:02]
control.
[1:11:03]
>> That's that's how it's going to be in
[1:11:05]
the tax sharing agreement.
[1:11:06]
>> Yes.
[1:11:06]
>> Which is a separate agreement which is
[1:11:08]
not subject to this agreement.
[1:11:10]
>> Okay. But it is that money still pulled
[1:11:12]
aside
[1:11:14]
for the animal shelter. Is it not? We're
[1:11:16]
patrolling Parkwood. That money is being
[1:11:19]
levied so that we have access to the
[1:11:21]
animal shelter. Is it not in the tax
[1:11:23]
sharing agreement? I I'm not too
[1:11:26]
familiar. I gone back and read the
[1:11:28]
agreements. I'm not too sure how the
[1:11:30]
figures originated.
[1:11:31]
>> Um, however, how they're prepared, how
[1:11:34]
they're drafted, I would
[1:11:37]
>> uh state that they're draft if someone
[1:11:39]
silent and that they're very distinct
[1:11:42]
from from one another.
[1:11:43]
>> Okay.
[1:11:43]
>> Now, if some of the negotiations overlap
[1:11:46]
and that overlap is not reflected within
[1:11:48]
the agreement, I can't state that with
[1:11:50]
confidence. I simply wasn't there.
[1:11:53]
So with that, I would like to be part of
[1:11:55]
that ad hoc committee myself. If any
[1:11:58]
other council member is interested on
[1:12:00]
being that um please speak forward or
[1:12:05]
>> Yeah, before I I answer that, mayor, I
[1:12:08]
did have a question regarding our cost
[1:12:10]
of living increase. Uh looks like that
[1:12:12]
5%
[1:12:14]
is not sufficient according to what
[1:12:17]
they're claiming, right? that this uh
[1:12:20]
cost of keeping animal shelter has
[1:12:22]
exceeded or at least for this city the
[1:12:25]
city's portion we're not contributing
[1:12:28]
sufficient right I mean for I think I
[1:12:31]
saw the letter that came across as 40%
[1:12:34]
um of the animals at that shelter are
[1:12:37]
coming from our city do you agree with
[1:12:39]
that statement or is there something to hold us accountable to that to state
[1:12:44]
that we have about 40% of the animals
[1:12:47]
held the animal fact there are
[1:12:48]
>> I I wouldn't have those fingers and it
[1:12:51]
would be difficult for me to speculate
[1:12:52]
and the reason I say that is there are
[1:12:54]
many animals from speaking with our
[1:12:57]
chief that that we don't take them
[1:12:59]
because our officers will make a call
[1:13:02]
and they'll indicate that that animal
[1:13:05]
and if the shelter has been accepted. So
[1:13:07]
I I I can't speak with confidence. I
[1:13:08]
know how long we are are are housed
[1:13:10]
there and where they're originating if
[1:13:12]
they're the city or they're the county
[1:13:14]
or if we're simply not taken. So uh we I I wouldn't have that data, but I think
[1:13:20]
as part of this discussion with the
[1:13:21]
county, we could flesh out some of those
[1:13:23]
details.
[1:13:24]
>> Yeah. And also just to comment on the I
[1:13:28]
think you provided something from one of
[1:13:30]
the founders of the proposed tax
[1:13:34]
measure. Is this in perpetuity or is
[1:13:36]
this something that would happen like a
[1:13:38]
certain time frame, 10 years, 20 years?
[1:13:40]
I didn't see anything on there.
[1:13:42]
>> My understanding is it's a perpetuity.
[1:13:44]
Um, and there's a couple council members
[1:13:46]
that kind of are nodding.
[1:13:47]
>> Okay.
[1:13:49]
>> I did speak with her at lane on Friday
[1:13:51]
evening and that was my understanding.
[1:13:53]
Um
[1:13:55]
now you know like any other tax measure
[1:13:58]
that takes place whether it's
[1:13:59]
transportation what have you there's
[1:14:01]
always some
[1:14:03]
representation from the uh public agency
[1:14:06]
that's also obviously the city or county
[1:14:09]
and any other city that's part of this
[1:14:11]
thing. So I didn't see that on there as
[1:14:13]
well. I mean again this is not part of
[1:14:15]
our item here but this was presented uh
[1:14:18]
in conjunction to this item here. I I
[1:14:21]
just am not ready to read this yet. I
[1:14:23]
think we have something before us with
[1:14:26]
the ad hoc. I saw I sat on the last tax
[1:14:29]
sharing and doing the capital there and
[1:14:31]
I certainly uh would agree with our
[1:14:34]
mayor is that we we do this carefully. I
[1:14:37]
mean I I I think we do pay property
[1:14:40]
taxes. We do pay other sales tax
[1:14:42]
measures that are collected by the
[1:14:44]
county. I'd like to I'd like to see
[1:14:46]
numbers that represent the claim as to
[1:14:49]
why we're not paying our fair share. And
[1:14:52]
if that's the case, then let's see it.
[1:14:54]
I' I'd like to see what that looks like
[1:14:56]
before um we commit to anything else.
[1:15:00]
So, if if you're looking for uh another
[1:15:04]
person I'd like to sit in as well. Um, I
[1:15:07]
think, uh, you know, I'm not saying I
[1:15:09]
have a relationship with the county, but
[1:15:11]
at least I've been part of these, um, ad
[1:15:14]
hocs and I'd like to really question how
[1:15:17]
we come about these numbers.
[1:15:19]
>> Thank you for that. I'd also like to
[1:15:21]
nominate Mayor Pro Tim Zachariah because
[1:15:24]
we have two veterans and we have someone
[1:15:26]
who's new, I think, needs to really see
[1:15:28]
the process and and learn from it
[1:15:30]
because we're not going to be here
[1:15:31]
forever. So, uh, Mayor Pro Tim
[1:15:34]
Zachariah, if you will accept that
[1:15:36]
nomination,
[1:15:37]
>> if if that's unavailable, I was going to
[1:15:38]
leave it to you guys. I trust in your
[1:15:40]
hands, but if you want a third, I'm more
[1:15:42]
than willing. Yeah.
[1:15:42]
>> Um, I think it I I echo you that it's very appalling to be put in a in a
[1:15:47]
rock and a hard place because either we
[1:15:49]
>> we acknowledge their demand for what's
[1:15:51]
probably going to be more money or they
[1:15:53]
shut us down. And then understanding
[1:15:55]
that uh to your point reading this,
[1:15:58]
we're going to hand five people
[1:15:59]
non-elected up to $60 million every year
[1:16:03]
for perpetuity to not just build but
[1:16:06]
essentially build their own private um
[1:16:08]
shelter. Um so it it's I think it's for
[1:16:11]
the you know good for the taxpayers to
[1:16:13]
attend that meeting and ask them why
[1:16:15]
it's in perpetuity that they're going to
[1:16:16]
be taking between five and $6 million
[1:16:19]
and then we're not included on any to
[1:16:21]
say of how that is spent. So, just
[1:16:23]
understand that it's not it's not just
[1:16:26]
that they're collecting money. It's that
[1:16:27]
these five people are going to decide
[1:16:29]
how it's built, how it's spent, and
[1:16:31]
essentially force us to use their
[1:16:33]
services because the county shuts us off
[1:16:35]
and we have no another no other choice.
[1:16:37]
So, I would encourage, you know, the
[1:16:38]
community to go out and ask those kind
[1:16:40]
of questions because when I've done so,
[1:16:42]
that that individual didn't seem to like
[1:16:44]
those kind of questions. But, um I do
[1:16:47]
have concerns with the a lot of that the
[1:16:49]
amount and the perpetuity. So, thank
[1:16:51]
you.
[1:16:52]
>> Okay. And with that, I'll motion to
[1:16:55]
>> question.
[1:16:56]
>> I just have one one question and I agree
[1:16:59]
with the with the or the candidates for
[1:17:01]
that hour. But I don't know if if I'm
[1:17:04]
getting ahead of myself, but I know this
[1:17:05]
is talked to the county, but if we are
[1:17:09]
not able to reach uh an agreement, then
[1:17:12]
um our options are to start our own
[1:17:17]
shelter. uh is that something that can
[1:17:19]
be I mean I'm not saying that's what
[1:17:20]
we're going to do but as we're in
[1:17:22]
negotiation in negotiations at the same
[1:17:25]
time sim simultaneously have a plan to
[1:17:28]
plan for this agreement to not go
[1:17:30]
forward.
[1:17:32]
>> I think it would be advisable to run
[1:17:34]
multiple parallel paths um in case we
[1:17:38]
can all come to an agreement um and and
[1:17:42]
explore options. Um I'm not sure if
[1:17:45]
there's any good options. Um but but I
[1:17:49]
think obviously the goal is is that we
[1:17:52]
improve our level of service. I think
[1:17:54]
collectively we have all heard that um
[1:17:56]
that there are voting animals in the
[1:17:58]
community. Um I I'm not too sure if any
[1:18:01]
of us are happy about that and I do
[1:18:03]
think we're constituents to to quite
[1:18:05]
frankly do a better job of how we tend
[1:18:08]
to to to spray animals.
[1:18:10]
>> Okay. Thank you for that comment. Um
[1:18:13]
Council Member Rodriguez. Uh yes, thank
[1:18:16]
you Eric Agos. Again, I would also um
[1:18:19]
ask our legal council to review the
[1:18:21]
invocation of section 70 and how that
[1:18:24]
affects and puts it puts the city at
[1:18:27]
peril when you have no access to the
[1:18:29]
animal shelter. So I'm not sure if in
[1:18:32]
fact again we're payers of service. I
[1:18:36]
understand that there's an agreement
[1:18:38]
before us, but again, this county
[1:18:39]
provides multiple services to the city
[1:18:41]
residents through property taxes and
[1:18:43]
other tax returns that we have. So, I
[1:18:46]
would ask our ego council to review
[1:18:48]
that, make sure that um you know, all
[1:18:51]
ends especially with the city are also
[1:18:53]
um we're not overlooking these these
[1:18:56]
small details that could potentially put
[1:19:00]
us in some type of litigation.
[1:19:03]
And that's the letter. So,
[1:19:04]
>> great comment.
[1:19:06]
City attorney got that. Great. Um, no
[1:19:10]
other comments. I will open it up for
[1:19:12]
public comment at this time. Anybody in
[1:19:13]
the chamber?
[1:19:16]
Anyone online or on Zoom?
[1:19:17]
>> We have no attendees requesting to
[1:19:19]
speak.
[1:19:20]
>> Thank you. I close public comment at
[1:19:21]
this time and I will make the motion for
[1:19:23]
the Havoc Committee uh for E3
[1:19:28]
to be Mayor Gyos, Council Member
[1:19:31]
Rodriguez, Mayor President Zachariah.
[1:19:34]
>> Second that. I have a motion and a
[1:19:35]
second. All those in favor say I.
[1:19:38]
>> I.
[1:19:38]
>> Those opposed. Motion passes
[1:19:40]
unanimously. Thank you for that report.
[1:19:42]
City manager Rodriguez.
[1:19:44]
Uh moving into close session. I will
[1:19:46]
turn this over to my city attorney.
[1:19:52]
» Thank you, mayor. We have one item for
[1:19:53]
close session this evening. It is called
[1:19:55]
G1 C negotiators to government code
[1:19:57]
section 5495 to 7.6. Agency designated
[1:20:01]
representatives are Rodriguez Silva and
[1:20:03]
Michael Lima. employee organizations on
[1:20:04]
Madera affiliated city employees
[1:20:06]
association police officers association
[1:20:08]
manager employment group and law
[1:20:10]
enforcement mid management employment
[1:20:11]
group.
[1:20:12]
>> Thank you for that. I open it up for
[1:20:13]
public comment. Anyone in the chamber? I
[1:20:16]
see none online or on Zoom.
[1:20:18]
>> No attendees have requested to speak.
[1:20:19]
Mayor,
[1:20:20]
>> thank you. I close public comment and we
[1:20:22]
will be moving on into close session.
[1:20:24]
Thank you for joining us this evening.
[1:20:27]
Uh we apologize for the inconvenience
[1:20:29]
and all our our mishaps, but we we'll
[1:20:31]
get it next time. Thank you so much.
[1:35:15]
That's old school soundboard right
[1:35:16]
there.
[1:35:19]
>> Sorry.
[1:35:20]
>> Okay. I think that's like a old school
[1:35:21]
soundboard.
[1:35:22]
>> Yeah.
[1:35:23]
>> Welcome back everyone. We're coming out
[1:35:25]
of close session and I'll turn this over
[1:35:26]
to our city attorney.
[1:35:27]
>> Thank you, mayor. There's no reportable
[1:35:29]
action taken a close session.
[1:35:30]
>> All right. I adjourn this meeting as of
[1:35:33]
7:36.
[1:35:36]
And we will see you Wednesday, May 20th,
[1:35:39]
26 in the same location. Have a good
[1:35:41]
evening everyone. Thank you. Happy
[1:35:42]
Mother's Day.