Village of Mamaroneck Harbor Coastal Zone Management Meeting 9/16/26

Mamaroneck (village), NY · · More Mamaroneck (village), NY meetings · More New York meetings

Transcript

Download: Text · SRT ·
AI TRANSCRIPT

This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.

[0:00] All right, good evening, everyone. I'm going to make a motion to open the meeting. Is there a second?
[0:08] Second? All right. All in favor? Aye. Any break?
[0:12] So, the motion passes, and the September 16th, 2016 meeting of the Village of Imaginary Network Harbor.
[0:17] And of course, those own management and commission is now open before you get started just when I directly was attention to the fire access on my left and right in case of emergency.
[0:29] So the first order of business is the minutes, so the commission has reviewed the draft minutes for the July 15th, 2016 meeting.
[0:42] Are there any questions or comments to the minutes? Seeing not only the motion to approve the minutes for the July meeting, is there a second? Okay, all in favour?
[0:52] Great, so that motion passes in the minutes are true.
[0:57] So this evening we have one applicant item, which is consistency review for 254
[1:04] center avenue, and that's a subdivision plot and the construction of Juno Town houses following
[1:14] the demolition of the existing structure.
[1:16] So, is that compared to the step to the podium and give us a overview of the project and please introduce yourself for the commissioner at the podium?
[1:33] We didn't, my name is Robert Sikana, I'm the advocate for this project.
[1:40] So we are subdividing, because it's still not inter-tool-ups, and each load has two set-of-the-tash
[1:51] on how this we were before the planning board for the past year or so and I think we have
[2:04] we can put the zoning so there's no plans and my our engineer on site and engineer is
[2:14] here, but I'm here to hear any questions or comments or anything, because I look
[2:24] the alive, the alive, the lives, and didn't see any comments at all from the mobile.
[2:35] Typically, we'll receive an overview and we'll have a project walk through for us with the
[2:44] to be directed to the engineering clients.
[2:47] And again, just a frame, the discussion here.
[2:51] This is this our first project in a few meetings,
[2:54] at least, that's in the river flood plane.
[2:57] And so our LWRP document, which governs our considerations
[3:01] for this matter, have a number of policies
[3:04] that are on point for this type of project.
[3:06] They have all flooding risks, issues of stormwater management,
[3:11] and issues of erosion control, primarily the policies that we're most concerned about
[3:17] with a project like this.
[3:19] So, I think, you know, we've evolved it to hear the measures that have been taken to
[3:28] ensure that this project is not going to create flood hazards for the residents and neighbors.
[3:37] And we also want to discuss the stormwater management plan that's been put into effect.
[3:44] I know that there's been back and forth with the village and the planning board on the specifics of the stormwater management plan,
[3:53] but typically, you know, that's at this meeting where we sort of receive our overview of those elements of the project.
[4:02] And if there's any of that that you're equipped to speak to, that would be very helpful for us.
[4:08] Yeah, unfortunately the gap is the engineers.
[4:12] Second, he's one of some of it on documents about the storm management, the production, and the pressure.
[4:22] So,
[4:27] there is a lot of some of the impression that this is the first time in the movie.
[4:30] Yes, I was on the impression that we had that comes in the comments that the other boards.
[4:39] So, that's why we didn't come this, we weren't referring to the real comments.
[4:51] But if you have any comments, I mean, I think this is going to be one of the points that
[4:55] I would like to imagine in this video.
[5:00] Yeah, yes.
[5:01] Look, I'm not sure if we're going to have, if there's folks, look, good people have reviewed
[5:04] the file.
[5:07] I don't know if there's specific questions that felt for missionaries have come in advance to go over.
[5:13] There are items that people are, like I said, you know, we want to make sure that
[5:18] stormwater plan is adequately handling the runoff that's being created by the new structure.
[5:27] You know, and again, the engineer can walk us through that and discuss, you know, that's usually the most productive use of the commission's time, you know, again.
[5:38] Are there questions that folks wanted to raise that the came in advance with that we can give to the architect and hopefully get ahead of for the next time that we meet?
[5:50] would as to reiterate what you really said. The process is that we do review the documents,
[6:00] and we use this session to have it presented and to give the sensitivity of the location
[6:08] of the engineering aspect, which is pretty important for us to clarify questions for our comprehension,
[6:17] and then we get to rate questions, but what I would say to try and move this alliance
[6:24] that you come even more prepared next time. I noted from reading through the documents that
[6:33] it has been a long iterative process through planning. It was not clear to me there was perhaps
[6:40] a vague or open ended questions about possible variances that I was going to ask for a question
[6:46] to us as said to us to do with driveway with and linked to that. Our purview is looking at
[6:55] environmental impacts and there are civil policies that we need to find consistency to.
[7:02] I note that the soil tests are unsurprisingly not able to absorb permeability as they are in
[7:13] areas and so the engineer was designing a rather than a permeability infiltration of
[7:20] back into groundwater, which by definition is going to be too high at certain times.
[7:25] It's acting as a storage capacity.
[7:30] I wedさいch wneud, meddwl yw'n chwirwydd yw'n yw'r gwneud hewn o'r rhaedw'n ffnyd. I ffysdiw'r rhaedw gwneud yn i'n ray, ddatau wouldithol ddwythrbell. At agy o'r hynnydd, gallu ddwythrbell. Gwrs o'rroyn nhw'n ffysdiw'n afd. I ddwythrbelld, hynnyr ddwythrin, gwrs o'r rhaedw – girwysdiw'n eisiau'n i ddwythrbell.
[7:58] I ddwythrbell i ddwythrbell. I ddwythrbell, ydwythrbell, ddwythrbell, ddwythrbell. Fyd, ddwythr
[7:59] ddwyfyneth sydd ydwyfyneth ayd yn y rynneud yn ydd argymod yn ymneud wedi'n eich nysUA.
[8:17] Ys rydio os yma yw mwynneud.
[8:20] Ys rydio osar yw hyddol ysefoadigod ydewion i ffynnyfynnydd.
[8:20] Fwynneud ddwod yn fwyfynnydd.
[8:21] Shuit, defa.
[8:21] Iffydd.
[8:22] If yndr ddaedd dd хotdol ywydol ymneud.
[8:24] Ys rydio yn fysthi'n lowrng yn ffrunnyw un hyr, ydyf nychu gynnyfyr.
[8:32] a eithesiud i'n unun amgu од modu ywintu ddeodd mae'n ufydeg yn a'rwlid bod y argymd.
[8:41] Mae gael musicd, oedd yn yw yw i'r gweld ydym'r ywyd o'r yng Nghiensw 있wai.
[8:53] Mae'n ar gyfer stryd yn yna'r rwodd.
[8:56] A gallu rwyd dwy'r rydd wrth gwy'n o'r swodd, yn o'r rwyd o'r ydn i'r rwydgy Labad.
[9:02] wיitau gwyllau ddefrau, Ina i'n i fyfraenau, am ymgol i wedi i'n i'l gael i'n ei'n ddefrau, ei'n i'n ddefrau.
[9:08] Ddefrau ni rdwenn gyngenau o'r ffordd arwedd a'r mynd yr Cynast Dr Gwysio Gwysio?
[9:19] a chi, a fwyb o gwwflydd lle a trafer y ac a hymno, ei wli a hynny gyhan o chwyfodddi upi synryr, a hynny
[9:24] synryr ymthl nhwds yw'ryd yn'r gwnd�v.
[9:29] I'r gwnaud Iw'n nhw'r fwybodd.
[9:31] I wleyau, yn wthem eisiau hefodd gwyfodd gwyfodd gwyfodd gwyfodd gwyfodd gwyfodd
[9:36] a'r goodd cymraug o'r mynd ardd.
[9:38] Diabu'n syngyd yn a satyr yr una i ygaisgrwy o'n dda, oedd ykwneud.
[9:49] Yw dda'n prundrydd a'r clam maid wedi i ydyd yn ymnydd, yr Paulinau'r am yddu.
[9:54] A'r yda maelaxe'n rwyd, dipelagwydd, oedd dddev jenwys mdeobu'r.
[10:02] Yddydd'r nwy方 yddydd, oedd dddydd, oedd yw nidwysiadiddd oedd nhw.
[10:11] Eudd i ywi wedi i mdeobu'r gwydau, oedd dddydd, oedd ddddddydd, oedd dddwysiadiddddydd, oedd ddddd, oedd ddddddd.
[10:14] Cru dy'r oid community, mae ydymnool yffdo metdo a didd chi eu a eu
[10:20] syneud chi afelw fer iyodol mwy uned lo nhw ar eith couldw wedi do murderi galliw.
[10:26] O fěrbyddio meddagai o.
[10:34] A'r
[11:01] odd
[11:02] mae impulda 까 zeiy ho, sy bina Eiff ellr i'r yn dweith, survivors sa
[11:06] pagd ynilau ynir diolio ei ddech
[11:12] i'npliant a dweith ar met rthed o masdys animals rofaid
[11:26] pau hen ed ac ddr y fwynyg ythfangol yr
[11:32] Mae'r gwnaedadodd va'n'r pwata'u rydych can a'r defodd, yn i'r iawn gwnaedadodd.
[11:41] Mae'r dmydafre yn gyfrethio trwy, ac yw cdyn iawn gwnaedadodd,
[11:46] a maithio sy'n rydych chi'n cy final gyfrethio Member ddraeth i amgen i'n cystyroedd ollen o huwtodd,
[11:55] a nyl ffyd.
[11:57] Mae'r ddraeth gydaedd gyffydd, ac sy'n gyfrethio, a'r deffodd.
[12:02] Boyd o gynnwyntgyleud, a ddim o diolud bwyd o gynhydeau ym gydeu'n bodeth'u.
[12:08] Ddeodau, aad o ddim ymydd yn gynhyd o mwyn.
[12:10] Wy cywdydd un, yn ddim ydd yn din gydaed yn ddim, o ddim.
[12:13] Felly yn ymydd o fyddod, aad aad aad aad aad o ddim.
[12:18] Gydaed o ddim llwydd yn ddim, ydد i dod y fyddod ddim.
[12:19] L'odd yn hyg ywydd y fiunod, y ddim, yddim yn yddim...
[12:27] fel pdyfod cdwyfilod yng이� sue, ym yn posdyn o'r yw'r g pockets o'r ymthod o'r mynd.
[12:30] Ond o'r mwyd, yw hynneeth, hynneethau.
[12:32] Feliw hynneeth ein ddryd, co'r ddyrion, ymaeth o'r ddyrion.
[12:39] Mae'r ddyrion, ei yn ddyrionau, nthoddddd dympod.
[12:42] Feliw hynneethau nryd.
[12:45] Feudn yn ddewar i'r ddyrion.
[12:51] eu mwyn yn y diwneeth y cymneith o dwewn bod, i mwyn o'n zifatu i fydd yn eithol i mwynza.
[12:54] Mae hyn hyn y rwydu wesio'n wedi'n fod yn y mwynza.
[13:00] Mae hyn y br online, y rwy'n am trick i gyn yr dwewn y yall'n bod yji'n i'n maw dwewn.
[13:07] I'r rdoedd rwo'n gennym yddd ar o drwna.
[13:08] Anastra cael y at24mr y dwewn.
[13:13] Mae'n o'n ei'n byl y rdoedd i gynreid aedol.
[13:15] Aedol, aprop y rdoedd i eda dwewn i'r rdoedd gynreid aedol.
[13:20] oedd ymwyrs yn flyd een yn yn y'n flyd een yn y cyflyd oedd yn ied yn yn gyda Kidsliwr
[13:34] dwwy'n oedd yn flyd een yn y amgydiodol ied ywn yn defysddio yn vaithyn oedd yn rhwb phaen oedd yn jysch.
[13:38] Fwyrs i'n orm, oedd yn ywch eichol i'n yda wedi, ynn,
[13:41] mae hymde cyflyd y yd yn dnydelodled ddim oedd yn yllid yn ddwl oedd yn ydeen.
[13:44] mae zienew o bwybhydddwrefン aiatadol.
[13:46] handicap o gna ff music.
[13:49] Eint העd byddu toda mae'n o bwddwreffyd.
[13:54] Eint tewek yn plyh o indu diponedd y frodd �ofer.
[13:58] Elrondud am歡迎 o bwddo pads,
[13:59] Gatu m in cynes gallot
[13:59] sydd â容易.
[14:01] Oedd â'n yr drab oernod ydibeffer,
[14:02] a De Sm Pigad conservation,
[14:03] a dia feraw ar 2 y patriaaaa…
[14:05] Gaugh a mae nad wda'i saltsd.
[14:09] Driaduiblio y n economiyelodTellw
[14:10] o r nodolydho querio bygdwaes bydwf powiedzieć o Ogdh'r
[14:13] ag gä tayu.
[14:41] Dart. S
[14:44] ac dgefluwmdy ni'niau i'r Muhol, aw nouau tryd, bliaon a.
[14:50] �thford yn ten yna'w hynny yn dハ.
[14:52] E 61 e i'r Thinu
[14:53] oedd yr conversionau � far dari我agu, aur ynnga dwyiedy.
[14:56] Felly dde olyn, mae tw lidt gandd'ung bydd.
[15:00] Everyone, this is Kayla Kubinski with the H2M Architects and Engineers. I'm assuming you can hear me?
[15:05] Yes, thank you.
[15:05] Okay, great. All right. So, where we left off, and I think it's important for the applicant to understand
[15:13] is that the swells as currently designed don't meet the stormwater code or the design manual for New York City.
[15:23] So those will be need to be revised as outlined in our last memo, but they do currently
[15:30] at 10, you wait the 100 year 24-hour storm, but again, you know, the soil needs to be revised.
[15:39] So that's where we've left off with them. And that's been complicated.
[15:44] Oh, you know, outside of this meeting, right, this isn't the first, they're hearing of this, just making
[15:49] And I think it's also important for the applicant to make sure that the revision dates are added to the plans.
[16:00] I think tonight there might have been some confusion about the plans submitted and what needs to be reviewed.
[16:06] Yes, obviously dating, dating submission materials just helps keep the version control managed and everyone knows who have not the latest thing greatest
[16:13] So please take that into consideration as well continue to submit materials to the village.
[16:20] Okay, so we'll be able to follow the rules and dates.
[16:25] Okay, thank you.
[16:26] And I do want to raise one other issue now to reset.
[16:28] There was a question of whether or not you know again this is a bigger picture question of
[16:37] There's a question of whether or not on the sheltered river there, there's existing wetlands
[16:42] that we just need to be mindful of.
[16:44] I don't know if that's been resolved, but I wanted to flag that issue.
[16:49] If there's a termination that there is a technical village regulated wetlands adjacent
[16:55] to this piece of property, we should just know it had an ex-meeting.
[16:59] I don't know if that's been resolved yet or not.
[17:02] A has not been, I asked Mark and I think Mark Trudeau to go and take photos of the river in the vicinity of the property today, and he didn't know that the river is vegetated on both banks.
[17:18] So it's not completely, like, channelized or hardening the concrete. So there is a possibility that they're well instead.
[17:25] And I am not sure if there are wireless or if he has been ruled out in previous African materials from playing Warner, anything like that.
[17:39] So if that is the case, there might be well and both are within the Western version of the project say.
[17:48] Yeah, great. Again, that's just a flag that, you know, if there's a determination made that there's wetland and that this property is in
[17:55] the villages wetland buffer. We're going to have to have a wetland assigned his opine on the
[18:04] scope of the project and confirm that in their opinion the project has conceived and all the
[18:09] measures that have been taken to protect the riverway, both dams that wetland. And so I think that's
[18:15] for you, again, this is being recorded, check that again, keep that in mind. And again, just for
[18:25] There's a wetland, that became to be advised to engage a professional to examine that wetland
[18:33] and make sure that what you guys are contemplating and doing isn't going to harm that sensitive air.
[18:42] So the issue is that there's a sort of out of my air effects, but there's a state regulated wetland,
[18:49] where there isn't that.
[18:51] But on the village code, there's a second definition of, so there's two components to the wetland definition one is the state regulated map wetland, which doesn't exist adjacent to this parcel, and there's also a broader, more general wetland that's just basically like if there's literally, if there's land that is near water and that has wildlife that counts as wetland wildlife, then that's also wetland.
[19:19] Do you want me to provide a little background? Sure. Yes, please.
[19:24] So, the federal government are the late smart ones that are along navigable rivers and waterways.
[19:30] The state, the government, you know, you want to find version of that.
[19:37] And then the village has to purge you over one of the neither the state nor the federal government.
[19:44] So this is there are three parameters that make a well and a well and it's whether or not water accumulates on the site for a long amount of time too.
[19:59] So that's the first one, hydrology. So literally there are water there and signs of water.
[20:04] Then the second parameter is hydrophilic vegetation so are there plants there that can tolerate wet conditions and then the third parameter is hydrophilic and when you dig a hole in a wetland, the soil has certain characteristics that you can tell that water pools there and is there for a set of periods of time so those are in the definition in the in the village code.
[20:33] The second bullet point is related to the definition of a wetland according to the federal government and the state.
[20:41] So it's kind of just declining what the state and the fact is also considered to be wetlands.
[20:47] So I would recommend that a wetland scientist go to book at the base of the river and determine whether or not wetlands are there.
[20:58] and they will, if they are about inside just the little stuff.
[21:05] I'm looking, it's already, but it looks like it's too, yeah look, but we're not going to go with
[21:12] my seat, I'm going to answer the question for us here. So look, I think we're going to ask
[21:15] then you guys, connect.
[21:17] Okay, so we'll just a little search, check.
[21:20] Okay, I will, we'll, we'll, we'll.
[21:22] That's a reason, thank you for, uh, enhancing my, uh, uh,
[21:26] No, we're not.
[21:27] You've worked.
[21:28] Thank you.
[21:28] If I can just add a wetland.
[21:32] Just go back to your comment.
[21:33] From what I just learned to know,
[21:34] it is that there's a repair in buffer there.
[21:37] Because it's a digitator that's not, you know, a concrete hard wall.
[21:41] So the set and the third point is when you do speak to a wetland,
[21:44] Santa Zell Losa.
[21:45] It's for the third parameter.
[21:47] So Hydric soil is something that can be actually measured through GIS,
[21:50] as well as other tests.
[21:53] Thanks.
[21:54] the sort
[21:59] of just the question about the stormwater meeting in New York State, the requirements
[22:06] of the swells.
[22:09] I mean, Harry, Harry, who's part of the New York State, that does nominate the thing.
[22:23] Yes, this was defined in our report, so there has to be a minimum with
[22:31] And a minimum length of 100 feet. And as proposed, it's under those requirements.
[22:40] And again, this could be found in the New York State stormwater design manual.
[23:08] was selected, that's not as it's done in the case.
[23:10] There are a handful of policies here that I think do a high,
[23:13] especially with stormwater, not for erosion control,
[23:17] and also accordingly, instructions when you say not,
[23:19] but what we're supposed to explain why.
[23:22] So I really think that, you know,
[23:23] your team should go back and produce a document
[23:25] recently with a more of their own response.
[23:27] Because I don't know how, but everybody here,
[23:29] I have a more informed conversation about
[23:31] who were the pinched with an application arm.
[23:34] Sorry, I just, um, to clarify, is there, uh, will, in the post on the technical firm,
[23:41] should we follow that line, is there a state line or, it will line?
[23:46] Yeah, it will, it will state the village policy.
[23:49] The village policy.
[23:50] And then it gives you a spot to respond to it.
[23:53] You know, it.
[23:54] Okay, so we have to go with the village policy.
[23:56] Yeah, it, it spells it out pretty clearly, but everything is checked out, pickle bowl, and it's not like case here.
[24:02] The actual document is a LWOMP on the village website.
[24:11] But the policy document is uploaded on the website and is the LWOMP.
[24:20] Yeah, I think the coastal system form also lists the policies.
[24:24] I just think it's, you know, we understand that this is your first run through of this process.
[24:32] just after someone taking a look at that and thoughtfully engaged with the sources of the policy.
[24:38] So I think there's some ones that are pretty obviously relevant to the Stanford project.
[24:44] I think so in case the closer look, though.
[24:45] There are a lot of scientists who are in the heart and they are more familiar with the
[24:52] health care, but I don't think that makes sense.
[24:57] Wetland scientists will be able to open on specific policies, but not all, but as the
[25:03] applicant's responsibility to take a holistic view of that application form.
[25:08] For example, there's a question here about how you've minimized the damage to resources
[25:15] It's a pleasure for questions in here, they're pretty straightforward, my opinion.
[25:22] Please go back and take a look at them.
[25:44] Thank you.
[25:46] Great.
[25:48] Any other questions from the commissioner?
[25:49] This is very much just to thank you a little bit more, you know, and I'd be looking to understand a little bit more
[25:56] for the quality and what this, the impact is going to be, all you think would be, and the adverse effect to enable you during construction phase.
[26:06] I know you provided a lot of material in there, and one of the areas that I was looking at is that it is in a failing war, or you would have to go down again and go up and up and up.
[26:15] and access, you know, this kind of stuff.
[26:17] I'd like to understand during the period of construction.
[26:21] What does it mean to the neighbors?
[26:24] Whether you look at the background of stuff like that.
[26:27] So basically think about this one as well.
[26:29] You may not be.
[26:30] You may not be.
[26:30] You may not be.
[26:31] You may not be.
[26:34] Okay.
[26:36] And you have this one with a kind of reality check.
[26:38] You get three inches during this weekend.
[26:41] All of Washington's own water.
[26:43] So that could be an expectation for your
[26:46] So, you know, we even used to protect your investment and you weren't literally gotten out of ashes.
[26:52] So it would be taking all this likely to avoid floating coercion in situations like this, especially again.
[27:00] The finish is, you know, busy in the monitoring.
[27:02] I mean, I think we all know here, folks that live here, folks that don't live here.
[27:08] This piece of land is going to flood, right?
[27:11] And so, you know, that doesn't mean that doesn't necessarily mean one thing or the other,
[27:14] but you might love it, we get to know that we're being thoughtful about, you know, expecting the worst, you know, and that's what we're doing here.
[27:23] So there are
[27:28] any other questions or comments?
[27:32] Mm-hmm.
[27:32] It's a bunch of ambush schools, well, that, you know, it has gone through the planning to plan,
[27:39] review sometimes, because it's, it's, it's flip, so it's a relief, because they look at the nativity of exercises and all that.
[27:46] But our concern is going to very much be the water quality.
[27:54] So, I'm really suggest that you imagine the look very creatively at that,
[27:59] the swells, the run-off coefficients design of the driveways
[28:09] into efficient to use your time.
[28:12] Thanks a lot. Yeah, and I think look,
[28:16] The engineers are not here, we appreciate your time, we've done our best to flag some
[28:21] issues for you.
[28:22] Obviously, check the record, check the recording, engage with the engineering folks and
[28:28] the rest of the village and the meantime.
[28:31] And we'll commission commissioners to accept we have any questions.
[28:36] We'll make sure they get over to you guys so that you have what you need to come prepared for
[28:40] that to me.
[28:42] Thank you very much.
[28:43] Thank you.
[28:48] So with that, I think the agenda has been covered, and I'm going to make most of it to adjourn the meeting, is there a second?
[28:57] Great. All in favor?
[28:59] Great.
[29:00] So Moccasters, meeting adjourn.
[29:01] Thanks, everyone.
[29:02] Thanks, I'm Cmedi, I appreciate it.
[29:05] Have a good night.