Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[0:00]
Or Wednesday, August 6, as I check the date. Thank you for joining us this evening. As understandable,
[0:08]
we are in a larger facility for the item that on the agenda, later on the agenda that is
[0:13]
drawing greater attention. So we are going to be proceeding with our normal business first
[0:20]
before proceeding with that portion of the evening. I would first like to note that council had an
[0:28]
executive session immediately prior to the start of the meeting to discuss outstanding legal matters
[0:34]
and the conduct of the meeting. Next, I would like to ask everybody to rise for the Pledge of
[0:38]
Allegiance.
[1:09]
Thank you very much. At this time, understanding we have a larger group, but not
[1:14]
everybody can see. Our name placards at the table and such, you might be familiar with who everybody
[1:19]
is up here. I'm going to ask for everybody up here at the table to introduce themselves and state their
[1:26]
a role for the sake of everybody in attendance tonight.
[1:29]
So if we could start down on this part of the microphone,
[1:32]
this end of the table will work down this way
[1:35]
for everybody to make their introductions.
[1:38]
Bill Rigby, Director of Public Safety
[1:40]
and Fire Chief Middle Town Township.
[1:43]
John McMullen, Township Manager, Middle Town Township.
[1:47]
Mark Demiko, Township Solicitor.
[1:51]
Chris Stump, Council Member at large.
[1:54]
Susan Powell representing the first district.
[1:59]
Viviana Dussling representing district three and chair.
[2:03]
David Byaleck representing the fourth district.
[2:07]
Eric Chinette, good township engineer.
[2:10]
Andy Parker, township traffic engineer.
[2:17]
And that is the end of the table.
[2:19]
Okay, next item on our agenda is we begin every meeting with the
[2:24]
a public comment to allow opportunity for public to comment on items not appearing on tonight's agenda.
[2:31]
So with that in mind, I would ask anybody that has comments on items not appearing at tonight's agenda to come up to the podium.
[2:39]
And if you do have such comments to state your name and address for the record before we proceed.
[2:44]
Are there anybody with public comments on items not appearing at tonight's agenda?
[2:55]
All right, seeing none, hearing none, I will proceed with, again, if there are regular agenda here, reports.
[3:01]
Mr. McMillan, do you have a report as, sorry, as a chair, I do not have a report tonight.
[3:07]
We did not have any committee meetings, but manage a report.
[3:10]
Mr. McMillan, do you have one?
[3:11]
No, thank you, Madam Chair, nothing to report this evening.
[3:15]
Thank you very much.
[3:16]
And Mr. Chinnetka, as far as our engineers report for the month of July.
[3:19]
Hi.
[3:23]
Thank you, Council.
[3:24]
Very briefly.
[3:25]
Just one of the put out there that we have submitted the permit plans for the Lennight
[3:32]
Park Improvement Project that was done a few weeks back and that project is still scheduled
[3:39]
to be constructed or begin construction in the fall.
[3:44]
That's all I have tonight.
[3:46]
Thank you, Mr. Genetka.
[3:48]
All right.
[3:48]
Next on is we have on our agenda.
[3:50]
We have a number of items for review tonight that we workshop at our first meeting of the month.
[3:57]
The first item we have for review is a review by Council of several zoning hearing board applications.
[4:02]
The first one being application 2025-11, Mr. McMillan.
[4:07]
Yes, thank you, Madam Chair.
[4:09]
So for a reminder to Council, these do not take any action or consideration just whether or not Council would like to send representation to the zoning hearing board.
[4:20]
So
[4:28]
the first is application 2025-11, Joseph Schick of two Palmer's Lane and a residential
[4:36]
zoning district are two requested variants from the 20-foot minimum width of a side-yard
[4:43]
requirement to construct a 1,557 square foot addition, which will project to within 10
[4:49]
feet three inches of the side property line.
[4:56]
Thank you, Mr. McMollan.
[4:57]
Any concerns with this application that we see the need to send a representation to the zoning hearing?
[5:05]
I have none.
[5:07]
Thank you. I think we have consensus. We don't need to send a representation for that one.
[5:12]
The second case, application 2025-12, Mr. Norman Sutton of 351-353 Park Mount Road, Zoned-M manufacturing district,
[5:24]
Request several variances for minimum death of a rare yard of 90 feet, minimum aggregate wide width of a side yard, and a minimum width of an individual side yard of 75 feet.
[5:38]
Applicant located a 30 foot by 40 foot covered barn on the property which projects within 6 feet of the side property line and to within 54 feet of the property line.
[5:49]
The property is less than 40 or 50 feet wide and is not conforming with respect to both
[5:54]
use and dimensional requirements.
[5:56]
So the applicant is basically asking to use this discovered barn which is not conforming
[6:02]
but will require zoning relief.
[6:05]
It's an existing structure.
[6:08]
So that they're not requesting to construct it.
[6:11]
It is there when they have the property.
[6:12]
Okay.
[6:14]
Any concerns warranting senate representation?
[6:18]
No, normally I would request, if there's any input from neighbors, but since it's an existing structure, neighbors are already ready to aware of it.
[6:29]
Okay, yes, we have consensus. We don't need to send representation to the zoning hearing board.
[6:36]
The third application before this evening is application 2025-13 of 217 Harrison Road.
[6:44]
Mr. G. D. Minico seeks a variance from three sections of the zoning code for permitted
[6:53]
accessory and conditional uses in the R3 zoning district for proposed firearm safety
[6:59]
training business to be operated from a residential property.
[7:04]
A portion of the business would require client visits to the property in order for clients
[7:09]
to receive pre-purchase firearms.
[7:11]
The applicant also seeks a variance from a section of the zoning code for more than one
[7:16]
principal use on the lot.
[7:18]
Just wanted to add additional information that the applicant is not asking for any training
[7:25]
on the property.
[7:26]
The applicant is only asking for purchases at the property.
[7:33]
There was no fire arm, only fire one fire or fire arm sales but no fire arm training.
[7:39]
And in addition, the applicant has an off-site training location that does not involve ammunition
[7:48]
as it will not involve the sale of ammunition at his residential location.
[7:52]
So he's just requesting, which is part of the permanent application to the federal government
[7:57]
and the Division of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms that the applicant get approval from the local
[8:04]
in this impality. So this is the first, the zoning piece is the first step in the applicant
[8:11]
submitting an application to the federal government. I believe that we do need to have
[8:17]
representation at the zoning board for this. I concur. Mainly just to get detailed understanding
[8:24]
of storage and safety concerns for the residents. This is an R3-zoned area putting a business,
[8:30]
especially a firearm business. I'd love to get clarity around some of those pieces, so I would also
[8:34]
So recommend that we send legal representation.
[8:39]
Okay, yeah, so we have consensus on that as well, John.
[8:43]
Okay, thank you, so note it.
[8:52]
All right, so that concludes with the items we have that are up for review.
[8:56]
Next, we have items up for approval, the first of which being ordinance 871,
[9:01]
our Comcast Franchise Renewal Agreement, Mr. McMahon.
[9:04]
Yes, thank you, Madam Chair.
[9:06]
For Council's consideration this evening is ordinance 871,
[9:09]
the renewal of the Comcast Franchise Agreement.
[9:11]
If Council will recall this was introduced at a Council workshop on May 7th, at that time,
[9:20]
Council ask some questions about the existing agreement and any differences that would be involved moving forward.
[9:27]
And I share with them the main difference is the township.
[9:30]
The municipalities under the cable franchise agreement are permitted to request 5% of total gross receipts from a cable provider.
[9:44]
So Middletown historically and in its current contract is only requesting four and based on the changes to the cable industry and more opportunity for
[9:57]
streaming the township is realizing less revenue because the cable provider is
[10:03]
realizing less revenue because of other streaming opportunities. So after a
[10:08]
careful review, this application has been handled by a special solicitor,
[10:14]
Cohen law firm, Cohen law firm negotiated this agreement over the course of
[10:19]
the last six months with Comcast and I concur with the recommendation from
[10:25]
and co-in-law that the township increased to 5% as opposed to 4% and although attempts
[10:32]
were made to negotiate a five-year agreement because of the drastic, the ever-evolving
[10:40]
changes to the cable industry, Comcast would not, and it's not unique to middle-town
[10:45]
township would not deviate from a 10-year agreement. So this agreement would be for 10 years, which
[10:51]
which is the standard and negotiating with Comcast.
[10:54]
So for Council's consideration.
[10:57]
Thank you, Mr. McMillan.
[10:59]
Any questions or concerns from the council?
[11:05]
I'd like to make a motion to approve.
[11:07]
Thank you. Do I have a second?
[11:09]
Second.
[11:10]
Thank you, Miss Powell. All in favor?
[11:16]
Any opposed?
[11:18]
All right. We have four eyes. Thank you very much.
[11:20]
Motion passes.
[11:26]
Next item up for approval, Resolution 2025-11,
[11:29]
the emergency declaration for Middletown Township due to the closure of
[11:32]
Crozier Health System, Mr. McMullen? Yes, thank you, Madame Chair. If Council
[11:38]
were recall as a result of the closure of the Crozier Health System, which
[11:44]
involved closing both the Crozier Hospital and Upline and the Taylor Hospital
[11:49]
in Ridley Park, the county went into a crisis mode in terms of available, so
[11:58]
So available emergency rooms but more importantly transportation because two emergency rooms at the time closure was handling 24 of the 49 municipalities.
[12:08]
So the county themselves issued an emergency declaration to address the emergency transportation system.
[12:19]
And so multiple municipalities followed suit with the county and did the same.
[12:24]
So if you'll recall request came to middle town township on April 23rd, I'm sorry on
[12:31]
yeah on April 23rd and with the request for middle town township to enter into a emergency
[12:36]
declaration which would provide the township with expedient or and some relaxation of procurement
[12:44]
processes if that fall under emergency declarations council agreed to do so with the provision
[12:49]
and that council and the township would revisit it in 90 days.
[12:53]
So here we are at about 90 days, and so before you is consideration to either terminate
[13:01]
the emergency declaration or extend the emergency declaration.
[13:06]
That's the reason I asked our fire chief Bill Rigby to participate in this meeting this evening.
[13:11]
Chief Rigby has been in touch with the county as early as this afternoon, and the county
[13:17]
is extending their emergency declaration for 30 days and it appears that other municipalities
[13:23]
are doing the same but I'll let Chief Rigby comment on what the county and surrounding
[13:28]
municipalities are doing.
[13:31]
Thank you, John.
[13:32]
I won't speak for the surrounding communities too much but I will also contact with Dr.
[13:38]
Taylor from county council today and they are going to extend at least for 30 days to take
[13:45]
look, the units that were stood up to support the crisis just turned off on August 3rd.
[13:55]
So there have been a couple of meetings, parties like making some changes.
[14:01]
So I think they wanted to get a better look at see how things were going to go with the
[14:06]
additional units are no longer in service.
[14:09]
service. With that said my recommendation to the manager and to council is that we follow
[14:15]
the county on this one and just keep ours in place and we revisit this in 30 days.
[14:24]
But services here in the township have been enhanced and I believe we're serving on residents
[14:30]
well.
[14:30]
I was just going to ask if there were any updates to the ambulance turn time last we heard
[14:41]
in April that it was 47 minutes, something like that.
[14:47]
So there might have been an article that some of the folks have seen recently that just
[14:51]
was up. The turnaround time is now around 29 minutes versus 2021, I believe we're
[15:00]
Excuse me, a year ago, it was nine minutes. So, it's now 29 minutes. Yes, there are extended
[15:09]
wait times, which makes taking patients to our outlying hospitals sometimes a priority,
[15:17]
but yes, there is wait times, and they have increased.
[15:20]
Thank you. That is an improvement. We're heading the right direction. Just not where we need
[15:25]
to be correct. I believe it, Pat O'Connell from the county remarked about it when we were
[15:30]
first in there. It was somewhere in the area 41 minutes, but we're still a little bit longer,
[15:36]
much longer than where we were.
[15:40]
So while I can completely understand the county's view of
[15:44]
extending for 30 days, I think Middletown is in a very unique position both with our EMS situation
[15:49]
within the township as well as having riddle hospital within township and the increase in
[15:55]
in presence due to the closures.
[15:57]
I would propose that we actually extend the 60 days
[15:59]
and not just align with the 30 day council
[16:02]
or the Delaware County recommendation.
[16:06]
So my proposal would be to extend it to 60 days
[16:08]
and then revisit after 60 days.
[16:11]
Thank you, Dave.
[16:12]
Yeah, I was gonna ask about that as well
[16:14]
as far as like a longer time frame
[16:15]
because understanding, when you spoke about the units
[16:19]
being turned off, those are specific
[16:20]
that the ones that the county had added.
[16:23]
We have taken our own steps and such.
[16:25]
So they're looking at a 30-day time frame to assess, I would feel more comfortable than having a chance to further assess once they're done with, you know, that time period as well.
[16:36]
60 days sounds completely reasonable to me. Do you see any issue with that, chief?
[16:42]
No, I have no objection to that, but there obviously is quite an increased call of value at a real hospital for many more and, you know, lots of calls for public safety there.
[16:52]
not only the police are experiencing there is long way times in the ER and sometimes folks get
[17:00]
unsettled. So, yes, that's going to continue, I think, for quite a bit with us being one of two
[17:06]
hospitals. Yeah, and let's clarify, this really helps us make decisions more efficiently on behalf of
[17:12]
the township. So, I don't think it's a direct impact to any of the local facilities or anything
[17:18]
within the town, within the county, it just more, it allows us as council and leaders
[17:22]
within the township to be able to make more decisions more efficiently and effectively.
[17:30]
Agreed.
[17:31]
Any issues as far as drafting?
[17:34]
We don't need to rewrite anything as far as the...
[17:36]
So just need a motion from council this evening that they're agreeing to extend the current
[17:43]
emergency declaration by 60 days.
[17:46]
And do I have a motion?
[17:46]
So since it was my, my, what I brought up, I will make a motion to extend the emergency declaration and revisit this in 60 days.
[17:56]
Thank you, Mr. Reo. I have a second.
[17:58]
Second.
[17:59]
Thank you, Mr. Sunt. All in favor?
[18:03]
Any opposed?
[18:05]
All right. We have four eyes. So the motion passes to extend for a 60-day time period.
[18:14]
So Ms. Apologist brought to my attention for folks standing in the back.
[18:18]
We may have a lengthy meeting tonight, not that we won't possibly potentially have recess at certain points.
[18:25]
But if you want to come forward, there are open seats in a number of places, not just up front.
[18:31]
You don't have to be, you don't have to braving up front, but there are a number of open seats spread out throughout the room.
[18:37]
I just want to give an opportunity for folks to recituate themselves.
[19:10]
All right, so for folks still standing, I'm going to assume you're going to, you're braving the position.
[19:15]
You're going to have to stick it out there, or certainly you can always come up during the course in the meeting as well.
[19:21]
All right, so next item on our agenda is the preliminary land development application for Outroger industrial for the construction of the 330,000 square foot warehouse.
[19:31]
Now, before we get into this, it will begin with the presentation from the applicant upon conclusion of the presentation.
[19:38]
There will be opportunity for public comment as we do with any agenda items.
[19:44]
Given the nature of this meeting, the concerns surrounding this, and wanting to make sure we have an opportunity to cover the first, the applicant's presentation, allowing for public comment as well as counsel's opportunity to ask our questions and dialogue with the applicant.
[20:04]
We want to get through this by a reasonable hour.
[20:07]
So what we are asking is for residents at that point making public comment to try to limit public comment to three minutes from individuals.
[20:18]
We do have a time time keeper who will help indicate when you're about to reach that time frame.
[20:25]
Just so we can help make sure as many people as possible get a chance to speak and we can cover everything and get through the entire process tonight.
[20:33]
tonight. By our reasonable hour. I can see children here. We've got families, so I ask for your cooperation with that.
[20:40]
Thank you very much. So at this time, Mr. McMahon, we will turn it over to the applicant for their presentation.
[20:46]
Yes, thank you, Madam Chair. So, for Council's review, preliminary land development application from Outrigger Industrial for the construction of a 330,000 square foot warehouse located at 1408 West Baltimore Pike.
[21:00]
The application was reviewed by the Delaware County Planning Commission.
[21:04]
The Planning Commission did not recommend approval of this application.
[21:08]
The application was also reviewed by the Middletown Township Planning Commission.
[21:12]
The Middletown Township Planning Commission did not recommend approval and some reasons that
[21:18]
were shared to me by the Planning Commission solicitor for not recommending approval.
[21:25]
There were some concerns that from the planning commission members that the application was incomplete due to failure to seal their plans, pursuant to the tantric of code, a failure to present accurate lot lines.
[21:39]
They believe it was imperative that outrigger accurately present a lot line in its full form so that it may be appropriately analyzed.
[21:47]
And they are requesting or would have liked to see more of outrigger and its consultants team able to answer.
[21:55]
basic and additional questions affecting our analysis of the application, such as the number and type of tenants, the traffic, and the type of business operations.
[22:04]
So I do see this evening, the full applicant team, the applicant's attorney, Ms. Debbie Schultzki is at the podium.
[22:11]
So I turn it over to Ms. Schultzki.
[22:14]
Hi, good evening. My name is Deborah Schultzki. I'm with the law firm of Riley Viper, Holland, Colorado, here on behalf of the applicant.
[22:20]
We also have a number of representatives here this evening for the Outrigger team who
[22:24]
I'll introduce very briefly if I can find them all.
[22:29]
I have Scott Henderson and Ben Moore from Outrigger.
[22:33]
We have Chuck Olivia and John Grant from Stantec, our project engineers Nicole Klein from Bowman,
[22:39]
Traffic Consultant.
[22:40]
We have Gavin Bybuck from Liberty Environmental who I believe is hiding over there on the
[22:44]
back.
[22:44]
And we have Carl Everbot from Everbot, Acoustical Consulting, who's our sound consultant.
[22:51]
And before getting into the actual nature of the application itself, I just wanted to
[22:56]
know one issue just for purposes of the record.
[23:00]
As this council is well aware, I had submitted a correspondence to you, dated July 25th, asking
[23:07]
council to recuse itself and retain an independent reviewer, to review and decide the application.
[23:12]
I became aware of public statements that were made during the course of public meetings over the course of the last year in which we believe there were statements made that Council demonstrated a preconceived bias against the application.
[23:30]
Now we want to make sure the applicant has every opportunity.
[23:34]
Folks, all right, folks, we do want to make sure the applicant has every opportunity to get through their presentation and statements.
[23:41]
I understand the heated issue. Okay. We just want to make sure in the interest of time and make sure we cover everything we need to cover tonight.
[23:48]
Let's let them proceed without an interruption. Okay. Thank you very much.
[23:53]
Thank you. And as a result of these statements, we believe it impede my clients to process rights.
[23:58]
My understanding from your solicitor, however, is that council believes it can rule impartially on this application while we respectfully disagree.
[24:08]
At this point, I don't think we have any recourse or choice in the matter, so we are intending to proceed forward this evening without waiving that issue, obviously.
[24:17]
As I believe everybody in this room is aware, the property that is subject to this application is located as Mr. McMillan said at 1408 West Baltimore Pike.
[24:30]
It's on what's known as the Franklin Mint property, which is situated along a very major corridor of the township by highway.
[24:37]
Federal Highway, Baltimore Pike, it's located immediately across the site from the industrial
[24:45]
Wawa facility, and it's quite frankly part of the reason it was chosen was because of
[24:50]
the location and the fact that this particular zoning district allows this use by right.
[24:58]
As you know, before you as a preliminary, just a preliminary subdivision land development
[25:02]
plan.
[25:03]
We're also well aware I'm sure that there's currently an approved plan for this same
[25:08]
exact site for a last-mile distribution facility, which is still a valid plan that could
[25:13]
be built today, which is known as the frost plan.
[25:16]
We believe the plan that's before this evening is much better than that plan, especially from
[25:21]
an environmental perspective.
[25:23]
There's a number of benefits to this plan over that previously approved plan in terms of
[25:29]
conservation of environmental features. Specifically, there's a significant reduction in disturbance
[25:36]
of steep slopes under this plan. For example, the frost plan disturbed 23.31%, and the current
[25:44]
plan only disturbs 3.14%. So it's a significant reduction in the disturbance of steep slopes.
[25:52]
In addition, there's substantially less tree removal under this plan. The frost plan removed
[25:57]
to 26.21% versus this plan, which is 3.83%.
[26:03]
And in addition, there's a lot less impervious coverage
[26:07]
that's proposed as part of this plan.
[26:09]
It's a reduction of 12% from that previously approved plan.
[26:12]
So there's a number of improvements to this plan.
[26:14]
There's also less late time truck traffic,
[26:17]
and there's a number of other things
[26:19]
you'll hear through the course of the evening.
[26:21]
As Mr. McMollan indicated,
[26:23]
This is where proposed 330,000 square foot warehouse.
[26:27]
It was reduced from the original size, which was 360,000 square feet.
[26:33]
That reduction was in coordination with certain communications, with township staff,
[26:41]
regarding requests that the size be reduced.
[26:45]
We've been working very diligently with various concerns, all your concerns over the course of the last nine months.
[26:53]
This plan, as you know, has been subject to great scrutiny.
[26:57]
Probably I can say more than I've ever seen the last 25 years for a by-right land development plan.
[27:03]
Your consultants have done very thorough reviews on behalf of the township.
[27:08]
They've done a great job.
[27:09]
I believe that my client has likewise done a great job in addressing a number of the comments
[27:15]
that the consultants have raised and working with them through various communications.
[27:21]
site walk meetings, staff meetings to incorporate items into the plan, a number of which go beyond
[27:28]
what your minimum ordinance requirements are. So we appreciate all the feedback that your
[27:33]
consultants have provided. We believe that the plan as it exists today, which incorporates
[27:38]
a lesser building height at the request of Tom Kamida, a lesser reduction of the building itself,
[27:45]
we're making various improvements to your some existing erosion problems that are unrelated to
[27:50]
this particular project and don't need to be corrected by us, but we've agreed to do that.
[27:55]
We've incorporated additional Birmingham, additional landscaping.
[27:59]
We've done a lot of things to this plan that quite frankly go beyond what your ordinance
[28:04]
requires. The last set of reviews, we've we're up to four reviews now and we believe most of the
[28:13]
items, if not all of them, and those latest set of reviews are really just minor cleanup items,
[28:19]
or what I call our typical of your post-approval requirements, which would be more typical for a final plan.
[28:27]
This town typically reviews plans as a preliminary final, so that's why you get all these items because a lot of times it's reviewed concurrently.
[28:34]
We were asked to submit this only as a preliminary, which again, I know it's not typical in this municipality.
[28:41]
My experience on a number of projects with our offices that it's been reviewed concurrently, but we agree to proceed that way.
[28:49]
Again, a lot of the remaining items are related to your post-approval agreements obtaining
[28:53]
all your third-party permitting.
[28:56]
And of course, moving forward with our MBDS permit today, it's typically not even done
[29:02]
until you have your preliminary plan approval moving forward.
[29:06]
So you know, Alvarygar has been very conscientious throughout the process in trying to work with
[29:12]
the township and incorporate things to make it a better plan.
[29:15]
Again, they want to be part of the community, again, they chose this site for a few reasons
[29:19]
and that rigor will be speaking about this as well when they talk to you, but one of
[29:24]
it was because it is a bivariate use in this particular zoning district.
[29:29]
This isn't the situation where we're asking for conditional use.
[29:33]
So really the use is not an issue because it's legislatively zoned for this particular use.
[29:38]
It's already been determined to be suitable and an appropriate use for the area and the
[29:43]
character of the neighborhood.
[29:45]
So the job is counsel as well, where your job is to review whether this plan meets the
[29:51]
applicable ordinance standards set forth in your subdivision land development ordinance
[29:55]
and your zoning and under the MPC and determine whether or not
[30:00]
Plan meets those requirements. It doesn't matter whether or not you like the use, because again, the use is permitted. The courts have said that environmental concerns are not a basis to deny a use, a by-right use like this. However, again, because Outreger recognized that environmental was a big factor. We know the neighbors are concerned with that, and I understand from staff there were some questions about it. My client actually retained an air quality expert, which I don't think I've ever done on any project in 2020.
[30:29]
25 years to be able to look at some of those issues for you and address those even though
[30:35]
it's, you know, not typical at all for by right use.
[30:39]
So if the council doesn't have any questions in me, I was going to turn it over to Scott
[30:44]
Henderson.
[30:44]
He's going to tell you a little bit about Outreager, what they do, their various projects
[30:49]
and why they're interested in being in middle town township.
[31:05]
Not good evening.
[31:22]
Good evening.
[31:23]
Let me start by my say.
[31:25]
I'm going to try to keep this as condensed as I can because I know that there's a lot of people there want to speak and I want to respect that.
[31:32]
I want our consultants to be able to have their chance to present.
[31:36]
So look, I'm not going to bore people with who outrigger is.
[31:39]
I'm sure people have poured through it.
[31:41]
They know who we are. That's okay.
[31:44]
I just, again, from my perspective, I've been doing this for 25 years, developed a lot
[31:50]
of projects.
[31:51]
I've worked as a consultant.
[31:53]
I've helped some of the biggest companies in the United States with their space needs.
[31:57]
I've helped some of the smallest companies in the United States with their space needs.
[32:02]
And when you go through a development process, I think the one thing that you, as a developer,
[32:07]
you should be able to rely on is that we have codes, rules, regulations, laws, ordinances,
[32:16]
specifically set up so you remove subjectivity. Otherwise, nothing would ever get built.
[32:23]
Nothing would get done because there's just argue, argue, argue, argue, pick, pick, pick, right?
[32:26]
So that's why those are in place and the challenges for the township to say, look,
[32:32]
They're coming in, point to the consultants and say, challenge the developer so that they
[32:38]
can meet the code.
[32:39]
If they meet the code, then the obligation, technically, is to say yes, it's approved.
[32:45]
We think we have met that requirement, we think we've met that demand.
[32:50]
We think in many cases, we've gone above and beyond what is generally required in a normal
[32:55]
process.
[32:56]
So I just wanted to state that, look, our business plan and I've stated this many times
[33:02]
We are not going to be going after high-throughput logistics users for two reasons.
[33:08]
One, because that's not our business plan.
[33:10]
And two, we just physically aren't going to be set up for it.
[33:14]
There are certain things, let me just back up, in logistics real estate, like true logistics
[33:20]
real estate, there are legitimate physical attributes of a building that you need to have bar
[33:27]
non-act completion, or you want to even get a look, it's all about speed to logistics
[33:33]
users. They want to get in, they want to set up quickly speed, speed, speed, right? And
[33:38]
you need throughput to do that. So for starters, a normal logistics user, if they were to come
[33:43]
to knock on her door and say, Mr. Outrigger, we want to lease your space. What's your clear
[33:48]
height in the building? It's going to be 36. We need 40 dead in the water. Won't work.
[33:53]
Okay, 40 foot clear is generally the prerequisite for high impact logistics users to be in
[34:00]
ability.
[34:00]
36 foot clear isn't going to cut it, but we don't care because that's not what we're chasing.
[34:06]
We're going to be focusing on localized businesses.
[34:09]
There is a very antiquated supply of older buildings in Delaware County, somewhat in Chester
[34:17]
County, and certainly in the Philadelphia, that need to be replaced with new, you know, state
[34:22]
of the art facilities. And we think we can meet that demand. So we're going to be focusing on the
[34:27]
local user. The building is going to be cut. Okay. So we're going to be setting up
[34:32]
demising walls, leasing the tenants on hopefully a multi-tenant basis. And, you know, so we're
[34:38]
going to try to get up to six. But, you know, someone asked me before in the planning commission
[34:41]
meeting. It's probably going to end up being around fourish is what I would think. But that's what
[34:46]
we're doing. We're not, and I know there's a lot of questions on, oh, it's going to be a big
[34:50]
impact logistics user, and I just don't believe that we're going to be set up for that.
[34:54]
I would also note like things, and again, I'll try to explain this, because a lot of folks
[34:58]
don't know some of the nomenclature for our industry, but there's something in a warehouse
[35:02]
that's called a speed bay.
[35:04]
And a speed bay is an area of the warehouse where the column spacing is quite a bit larger,
[35:09]
and it's usually located near your door or the doors.
[35:12]
And you technically want, you know, you want minimum of 60, but logistics users want
[35:17]
a little bit bigger. The press now is to get the 70. And that allows for more maneuverability
[35:22]
in that area to get things on the trucks and out the door. We won't have that. We're
[35:28]
going to be at 60. Technology systems. I would invite you to go and look at prologists.
[35:35]
Go to prologists' website and look at their essentials program. Technology truck counts at
[35:41]
the doors. How long does it take skew inputs to get on the truck? How long does it take to
[35:46]
unload the truck to get them on the shelves. There's a lot of technology that goes in these buildings
[35:50]
that we just aren't set up for. We're not going to have it. So again, logistics users that come
[35:55]
and want to see it, do you have these types of essential set up for our program? No, dead in the water.
[36:02]
So I know there's been a lot of talk about doors on the wall. Doors on the wall don't mean trucks.
[36:08]
Doors on the wall is basically a baseline that is in our industry that we just generally use
[36:13]
to develop and build buildings.
[36:15]
The idea is just line the dock wall with doors.
[36:18]
That's it.
[36:19]
It doesn't necessarily mean trucks.
[36:22]
The building is not cross docked.
[36:25]
Okay, cross docking in real estate is you have, you know,
[36:28]
loading on both sides, right?
[36:30]
And sometimes it could be on all four sides.
[36:31]
But you have loading on both sides and it allows trucks to come in
[36:34]
and do their input, goes into the warehouse,
[36:37]
and then they generally quickly turn to go output.
[36:40]
Okay, so that's Amazon, right?
[36:42]
So in the other plan that's approved, that's what that is. It's high-intensity
[36:49]
shift work, at least to probably free shift works.
[36:53]
600 plus vans going in and out all day, all night, you know, trucks coming in. That's high throughput. That's true logistics, right?
[37:01]
This is not that
[37:04]
And I would just say again, there was someone I mentioned, you know, overall like a truck terminal. I would invite you to go
[37:09]
So look at like XVO, Pit, Ohio, Old Dominion, RL carriers and look at those facilities, right?
[37:19]
Those facilities are true truck terminals where trucks are very active and they're just going at all times.
[37:25]
We're just simply not going to have that.
[37:28]
So those are just generally some of the things I just kind of wanted to illustrate as far as, you know, whether we're logistics or not.
[37:35]
and we're just not. We're not going to be able to fulfill that, even if we wanted to.
[37:41]
Look, I'll also say, I think this is important. One of the reasons, yeah, my son asked me,
[37:47]
he's like, why do you do what you do? When I was a consultant, it was just pushing paper.
[37:52]
And I thought, you know, you kind of want to leave your thumbprint and you want to do something
[37:56]
that actually adds value, right? There's tax revenue, there's job creation,
[38:01]
You know, you get up, people get up, go to work, it's dignity, like they have, you
[38:06]
know, places to earn a paycheck, and we try to help create that.
[38:09]
We try to help businesses grow.
[38:12]
So look, I think this will probably add, I'm going to guess I'm at a couple hundred temporary
[38:16]
construction jobs, it's not nothing, and we believe somewhere in the range of about a hundred
[38:21]
permanent jobs, once it's fully leased out.
[38:26]
I think I would be remiss if I also just didn't talk about industrial buildings in proximity
[38:35]
to residential areas.
[38:37]
If you look at Delaware County, look at Brumall industrial park, look at Marketshook and
[38:43]
the new building there, look at Donald Springbroke and ask them, that's a perfect example, two
[38:48]
buildings, 260,000 square foot building and a 210,000 square foot building.
[38:53]
right next to a townhome development, right next to a residential area.
[38:58]
Brumel industrial park is 41 buildings.
[39:00]
I think the total amount of square footage is 2.1 million square feet,
[39:04]
backs right into a high density single family home area.
[39:07]
Marcus Hook, same thing, high density residential on the front side,
[39:12]
it wraps around on the side, again, very high density townhome developments,
[39:16]
older homes, okay, so it's not a typical for this type of development,
[39:21]
that just look at the areas, it's there, it's in some plain view for this to be put in.
[39:28]
It's not atypical.
[39:29]
In fact, you could say in some of the densest areas of Delaware County, Philadelphia
[39:32]
County, Bucks County, it's pretty typical, it's not unusual at all.
[39:37]
And lastly, let me just state that, and I think this is important because I've seen a lot of
[39:43]
chatter on social media about some of the struggles that the school district is having.
[39:48]
and I've heard about, you know, I've read about things like, you know, kids being in modular trailers
[39:54]
as their classroom, worrying about their taxes being raised as a result of, you know, not having,
[40:02]
you know, the funds in the school to facilitate new bodies or new kids and, you know, and obviously,
[40:08]
I know that there's some facility issues as well, right? So, you know, I just kind of wanted to touch
[40:13]
based on, you know, the taxes here.
[40:16]
I mean, there's been discussion on social media
[40:18]
about whether or not we're seeking alerta.
[40:21]
We are not.
[40:22]
We've never been, we've never sought to get alerta.
[40:25]
We're not looking at alerta now.
[40:26]
We're not going to look at alerta in the future.
[40:28]
This is, I'm supposed to point out,
[40:32]
probably want to explain what that is, that term.
[40:34]
I don't think everybody's familiar with that term.
[40:35]
Yeah, so, so, Lurda is an acronym and it's basically,
[40:39]
I can't believe the full name is escaping, but it's a program that's generally put in
[40:44]
for former industrial sites that are revitalized into new developments.
[40:51]
And then what happens is you go, you go to three different groups, you go to the county,
[40:56]
the township, and the school district, and you basically do what you're trying to get
[41:01]
as a tax evapment, and it's based on a graduated takedown of, you know, the fall over 10 years.
[41:08]
So basically what you want to say is we'll pay 10% of the full tax vote for your one and then it'll increase by 10% each year.
[41:16]
We're not doing that, right?
[41:18]
So this will be a fully assessed and taxable building year one.
[41:23]
And we've run, we went in and we did some calculations based on the county and the township and the school district.
[41:29]
And so, you know, on an annual basis the county will receive $145,000, the township will receive roughly $38,000.
[41:37]
The school district received $588,000.
[41:41]
Over 10 years, the school district will get $7.2 million.
[41:46]
But the total tax value of 9.7.
[41:49]
That's significant, especially when you have a school district that is struggling with certain items in its operations.
[41:57]
So I just wanted to state that.
[41:59]
I think it's important and it's part of the reason why we're not seeking alerta.
[42:03]
and frankly I think that in terms of the way learned is set up given the history of the site
[42:09]
being industrial that it would be a site that you know you technically could see Florida for.
[42:13]
So like I just want to I want to thank the the township you know and look I we have a fundamental
[42:21]
disagreement over you know over this issue but I want to thank the residents for being respectful
[42:27]
just like right now I appreciate it I hope that you know we've conducted ourselves in a manner that
[42:32]
But you feel the same way, even though we do have our disagreement, but that's all I have to say.
[42:37]
Thank you very much.
[42:39]
Thank you, Mr. Henderson.
[42:46]
To the next we have Stan Tech, they're going to talk to you, walk you through the plan,
[42:49]
and talk about some of the more technical issues with the plan itself.
[42:53]
And I believe Chuck and John may be splitting this portion of it.
[43:01]
Good evening, my name's Charles Alvo, OLIVO.
[43:05]
I'm with Stan Tech Consultants.
[43:07]
I will be there for 40 years at the end of next month, so I've been doing this a while.
[43:14]
The parcel is, and I just want to see,
[43:19]
okay, I thought this was supposed to, is it sound
[43:25]
asleep again?
[43:31]
I'm going to start, which, let's go back to the first one, which one?
[43:42]
I'll start with this plan because it's color coded and I think everybody could see it a
[43:46]
little better. This parcel that we're going to talk about tonight is identified as
[43:51]
the Mint parcel. We're proposing develop approximately 30.6 acres for a
[43:58]
proposed warehouse and that is in the center brown area marked C. That's the
[44:03]
area that we're talking about tonight. The site and if we look at Baltimore Pike
[44:08]
is running north to south so to the left north to the right south. The site is
[44:14]
found by Franklin station, the residential development, which is shown as B. It's in the
[44:20]
yellowish.
[44:22]
Baltimore Pike would be to the west, Office Drive, which is the signalized intersection,
[44:28]
which would be to the north, which is where the state police barracks is.
[44:34]
And then Pond's edge, the residential is to the northeast, and that's in the white space
[44:41]
there because it's not part of the property here.
[44:43]
But that's in the located in the white blank space between the colored things and then to the
[44:52]
And then open spaces to the east which is shown as a and that is all the green area to the top
[45:00]
Oppo the page.
[45:04]
Okay.
[45:07]
What is
[45:12]
it?
[45:14]
Am I doing something in there? Just trying to get to the next. The zoning for the site, that's fine. Which?
[45:23]
It's my angle. Oh, okay. The zoning for the site is zoned SU1A, which is mixed use. And the zoning is based on the entire parcel, which is 178 acres. And that includes, in the previous one,
[45:40]
all the color ones. In this one, you can see we're pointing to all the different developed areas
[45:46]
in the site, but it's based on the 178 acres that the proposed development area for outriggers is
[45:55]
approximately 30.6 acres. We're proposing a building, a one-story, a two-story warehouse building,
[46:05]
which is 330,000 square feet which is 300 by 1,100 feet with a second floor of
[46:13]
approximately 4,000 square feet of office. The parking area for this will
[46:19]
require 334 spaces which will include 14 accessible spaces and 34 compact
[46:29]
back spaces. 75 of these 334 spaces are proposed in reserve. Again, these are things that we
[46:38]
discuss with the township that they said they would like to get some more green area.
[46:43]
And so we went and proposed spaces in reserve. And what does that mean? It mean, are you
[46:51]
getting something
[46:59]
like me?
[47:12]
What it means is the perimeter parking spaces,
[47:15]
is we will design as if they're impervious.
[47:19]
So when we do the stormwater,
[47:21]
they will be designed as impervious surface.
[47:27]
So they'll all count for that.
[47:29]
However, they will not be billed at this time.
[47:31]
So we have spaces that we can 75 of the 334 on the border line
[47:37]
that we will not construct at this time.
[47:40]
But if needed, they can be constructed.
[47:42]
it. The rear yacht includes 62 trailer spaces and 63 loading area doors. The impervious
[47:53]
tabulation for this includes 330 square feet, 330,000 square feet of building, 71,954
[48:04]
square feet of concrete paving in the rear, 334, 256,000 square feet of asphalt paving,
[48:13]
and 26,489 square feet of sidewalk.
[48:18]
So when you look at the zoning for this, again, we're back to basing on 100, it has to
[48:26]
be for this zoning area, it says the minimum is 100 acres.
[48:29]
we have 178 acres. The maximum impervious for the track is 60 percent.
[48:39]
Presently, it's at 34 percent, and ours will bring it up to 44 percent.
[48:45]
So we're increasing what's proposed.
[48:48]
Everything that's built today and approved goes from 34 percent to 44,
[48:53]
but we still have allowable up to 60.
[48:55]
The maximum building surface is 20% for the whole thing.
[49:00]
Presently it's at 11.4%, and this will bring it up to 15.6%.
[49:06]
So we're still below the maximum impervious and building coverage
[49:10]
for the site, but there's still more things that must be developed.
[49:21]
This site, again, I'm going to talk about access to the site.
[49:26]
The site we have, it has one access in the center, which is just a right in, right out from
[49:33]
Balmer Pike. It's restricted because you can't get it from heading south on this. So it's only
[49:40]
if you're headed in the north direction of Balmer Pike and you get on to the site in the middle,
[49:44]
which is right in, right out. Office drive, however, is the signalized intersection and the main
[49:51]
point of access for the site. That's where all truck traffic and passenger cars will
[49:57]
come in if they're coming north or south on one more bike. They would use that light
[50:02]
to get in the site and they would go around to the back of the site for the trucks would
[50:08]
be in the back. The first driveway off of the off of the proposed drive is for the cars
[50:16]
to come around and they go to the side of the building and around to the front of the
[50:20]
So it basically keeps all the trucks at the rear and all the parking, the passenger vehicles in the front.
[50:33]
That driveway will also be signed.
[50:36]
We're proposing that there'll be no right turns allowed on to Franklin.
[50:42]
There'll be no right turns allowed onto the middle drive, and I'm sorry, but I can't see.
[50:48]
It's the sign
[50:55]
for no left turns of the trucks on painters' way.
[51:02]
And they'll also be at the top point of the trucks that, when they leave the site, they'll
[51:07]
be a second sign back there saying no trucks permitted to turn right on painters' way.
[51:13]
So we're going to enforce the with signs that the trucks cannot turn on the painters' way,
[51:19]
So they can only enter and exit from that area.
[51:27]
The reason that the driveway is where it is and it has the cross between the entrance to this site and to the get on the site,
[51:37]
you have to cross over, there's a pipeline there.
[51:40]
There's an existing pipeline that you have to cross over so you just can't make the crossing anywhere.
[51:45]
You have to try to cross where you're not adding additional fill or doing cuts at the
[51:52]
pipeline.
[51:53]
So you need to get back to the back two areas to make those crossings of the pipeline.
[51:59]
So they'll be done and we do have approval and we have to go through the approval process to show
[52:05]
them exactly how much cut and fill is being done for the pipelines at that point.
[52:13]
The rear driveway which goes out the Franklin Boulevard will be necked down and restricted and it'll be allowed for emergency vehicles only.
[52:23]
So we intend to have ballers or something else at that end to restrict access to it, but it won't be the same size of the street, we're necked it down, but we are providing a walkway across the rear which would be
[52:39]
for people to be able to use a walkway from the residential area around the back of the site and come down to painters' way and that way.
[52:53]
We're also providing access and easements so that there's supposedly a trail that's coming through the back area, and you can see it's very hard to see but the lines are turning and they're doing switchbacks so they can get up the hill.
[53:09]
We're trying to keep them as level as possible and within standards
[53:16]
So so you're going to be switch backing back and forth at a hill so that there'll be a trail through the what is the open space in the back area
[53:27]
About stormwater. I'm going to turn it over to John and he's going to talk about some stormwater for you
[53:47]
Yeah, I'm going to go a little bit out of order and
[53:49]
and get into, go over grading for the site before I get into stormwater.
[53:58]
When we get into the site, obviously from people that are familiar with the site, we've
[54:05]
got, and that's not going to point, is it?
[54:07]
We've got a number of site restrictions for the site.
[54:11]
We've got to match the Baltimore Pike rating for the center driveway entrance.
[54:16]
That's locked in.
[54:17]
we're not changing the elevation of Baltimore Pike. As Chuck had mentioned, we've got the pipeline
[54:23]
crossing. So originally with the concepts for this plan, we actually wanted to provide access
[54:29]
to the front parking lot coming off of office drive also, but as we evaluated the grading
[54:36]
of office drive versus our site, we kept having to push back, push back, push back further.
[54:42]
the location that's shown there is the original access road or road that was
[54:50]
going across the site, but that is where we are proposing to continue to cross.
[54:54]
But it's a little bit further back than we wanted, but that's what was needed in
[54:57]
order to match grades at the Sanoco pipeline crossing. We also had to match
[55:05]
grades at the end of Franklin Drive, which required a little bit of fill, a
[55:11]
a little bit of retaining walls as we've got down to that side of the street.
[55:15]
We also have existing basin, existing basin in front of our site that we have to continue
[55:20]
to provide positive drainage to.
[55:22]
So the elevation of that basin is actually pushing our site up a little bit also that we can
[55:27]
get the positive drainage to continue the flow that's getting there now.
[55:30]
We want to maintain in the future.
[55:34]
As we went through the site with our grading, there's a lot of pressure or requests to increase
[55:41]
the berms to provide the visual barriers as much as possible. We do have a graded berm and landscaping
[55:49]
along Franklin Drive which we've increased approximately 8 feet and on the opposite side
[55:56]
we've provided additional grading on that side to raise the grades approximately 6 feet along
[56:02]
office drive just to buffer our site a little bit from the north and the south sides. So it's kind of
[56:08]
The driving force on the gradient is that we're kind of surrounded by a number of features which we have to tie into.
[56:16]
The landscape plan, I just wanted to say we're continuing to coordinate with the township on landscaping.
[56:25]
We're providing abundant landscaping around the site and raising up the berms, we've worked that into the landscaping.
[56:33]
But we continue to work with the township on that to try and come up with a suitable landscaping for the site.
[56:41]
We've got landscaping along the back of the site at the trail.
[56:45]
Either side of the site, the one thing we have done is pulled off some of the landscaping around the perimeter of the building
[56:52]
and used that landscaping a little bit further as more of a buffer than an aesthetic feature since we're screening our site as much as possible.
[57:01]
So, again, just trying to work back and forth, just trying to come up with the most appropriate use of landscaping and, you know, just buffer this from residential properties as much as possible.
[57:12]
We also know it's your landscape architect about other visual barriers. We do have soundballs, which would be discussed later in this presentation.
[57:20]
We added in a six foot high wooden fence in the area that it was thought to be a critical
[57:28]
point of Vista and we continued to work as we go into final design on additional landscaping
[57:36]
and buffering to
[57:46]
go the wrong way here,
[57:54]
there we go.
[57:54]
But, lighting for the site is being done in compliance with the Township Ordnance.
[58:03]
This is a, you know, by rates plan.
[58:05]
The one thing that we have been discussing is the area in the back on the access drive.
[58:10]
That is, it's by rate, but right now that by rate means it's got 25 foot poles along
[58:15]
the back, which we're not sure if that's what we're looking for, if we're going to use that
[58:20]
back area.
[58:21]
The driver along the back, it's got multiple purposes.
[58:24]
The access drive for the truck traffic getting into the back of the site,
[58:28]
it's also the emergency access to get from residential area to the north,
[58:33]
the residential properties to the south.
[58:35]
It's also pedestrian walkway as the area east of the site is open space.
[58:43]
So we've got a pedestrian walkway to allow pedestrians from one side to the other
[58:47]
and to access that open space.
[58:49]
So we're not sure if we're putting 25-foot floodlights or streetlights back there is really
[58:56]
what we're looking for with that, you know, it's a nice, beautiful landscape to manatee
[59:00]
back there.
[59:01]
But, you know, there's discussion about possibly putting bothered lights in there, possibly
[59:05]
putting even more decorative walk lights back there, and we'll continue to work with the
[59:09]
township one.
[59:10]
You know, if we wanted to reduce the lighting requirements back there to make it a little
[59:14]
but more attractive space for more desirable space to walk in.
[59:22]
And we get into stormwater management for the site.
[59:28]
Stormwater has been designed.
[59:30]
It's a, well, the front half of the site is tributary to rocky ground,
[59:35]
which is very restrictive.
[59:36]
Ninety percent reduction rate for the stormwater ray control.
[59:40]
The rear of the site also, it's less restrictive,
[59:43]
but it still has a 50 percent reduction rate.
[59:45]
Stormwater Management is being addressed by utilizing the existing basin in the front
[59:51]
and two infiltration basins and one MRC basin to be constructed.
[59:56]
Stormer Management and Providing.
[1:00:00]
Raid control, volume control, water quality control, all in compliance with PADEP and the Township
[1:00:07]
ordinances. So, I can get into more details on that, but the crux of it is that we're working
[1:00:14]
with the Township Engineer on this. We are complying with Township requirements for
[1:00:19]
storm management and PADEP as this will eventually require an MPDS permit.
[1:00:29]
The last thing I wanted
[1:00:30]
to get into is waivers. There are a few waivers that are being requested for the project.
[1:00:37]
I don't know if you can point these out Chuck. We've kind of locked up here. There's
[1:00:42]
we basically have four sections of waivers. The first section at the north end of the site
[1:00:48]
has to do with the basin or the yet at this charge coming out of the police barracks
[1:00:53]
over there. That really has nothing to do with our development. That area
[1:00:59]
When the previous frost job was being done, it was noticed that there was heavy erosion at the location right now.
[1:01:06]
It's discharging into steep slopes. Those steep slopes are eroding. So during the frost project, we were asked to extend the pipe to the
[1:01:14]
repairing buffer down to the wetlands, discharging a flat area where it wouldn't erode. So we are
[1:01:21]
disturbing the steep slopes, very steep slopes, and the repairing cord or just extend the pipe down so it actually gets to the wetlands area.
[1:01:34]
Again, this is not something that's required for a project. It's something we included on the previous project to address an existing erosion issue.
[1:01:43]
So we're requesting waivers to address that.
[1:01:47]
The second area we have in order to construct a road at the pipeline crossing, we've got areas
[1:01:53]
in there that were disturbing steep slopes and very steep slopes.
[1:02:02]
We've pushed this road as far as we possibly could away from the steep slopes and very steep
[1:02:06]
slopes.
[1:02:07]
We've installed or planned out retaining walls along the outside of it to minimize any impacts
[1:02:13]
to the steep slopes and very steep slopes, and I think we've done everything we could
[1:02:18]
to absolutely minimize the disturbance to those steep slopes.
[1:02:22]
The one thing to keep in mind with this is in looking at it, no matter what you develop
[1:02:27]
on this site, that's the location where that road, and that road is emergency access road.
[1:02:34]
It's got the sidewall for the pedestrian access, but that's as far west as we can push this
[1:02:41]
road.
[1:02:41]
So, we're trying to minimize as much as we can what impacts we have to those steep slopes.
[1:02:47]
The third area of steep slopes is mainly, well, it's over near the toll development, but
[1:02:54]
we've got to pipe this charge coming out of our stormwater management system.
[1:02:58]
Right now, that area, if you go out there, and this is covered in our steep slopes report,
[1:03:03]
it is heavily eroded, going about four to six feet deep, if you go down there, it's definitely
[1:03:09]
the area that if we're going to do disturbance in a steep slope, that section needs to be restored.
[1:03:17]
And right now the water is washing down the steep slopes. So we're proposing is to take the
[1:03:22]
discharge coming out of our stormwater systems. Unlike what was done with the police barrack
[1:03:27]
systems, we actually want to take our stormwater down to the toe of the slope and discharge to the
[1:03:32]
wetlands where we're not going to have that future erosion problem. That's the preferred method
[1:03:39]
PADP for discharging, they require it to be at the toe of the slope where you're not
[1:03:43]
going to have that erosion.
[1:03:45]
So although it's a temporary impact to the repairing corridor and to these already
[1:03:51]
disturbs slopes, we feel that that's the best place to put this pipe discharge.
[1:03:59]
The other, I think it as far as the waiver requests as far as the disturbances, but we do
[1:04:07]
We have a waiver request in for the use of HDPE pipe versus the RCP pipe.
[1:04:12]
We see this in many municipalities that that's kind of a carryover from when HDPE pipe
[1:04:18]
I think was first coming out.
[1:04:20]
It's been accepted by Penn Dot for decades now, but it doesn't really, it hasn't really
[1:04:25]
got carried over into ordinances.
[1:04:30]
There are pros and cons to each type of pipe.
[1:04:34]
The HTTP pipe is a little bit more flexible, it has a little bit more give if there is any
[1:04:38]
sort of shift to it.
[1:04:40]
It's a more corrosion resistant, which a lot of the soils in this area are corrosive
[1:04:45]
to concrete and to steel pipe.
[1:04:49]
Some of the problems with the HTTP pipe is it doesn't, it needs more cover in the RCP pipe.
[1:04:57]
So whenever we go with the shallow or pipe or, you know, grainy requires it to be shallow,
[1:05:01]
We do go with the RCP pipe.
[1:05:05]
Another drawback to it is pipe discharge.
[1:05:09]
Often times the HDPE pipe gets placed in a stone bed.
[1:05:14]
Sometimes you get piping for the water actually flow in the stone outside the bed.
[1:05:19]
You're causing erosion there.
[1:05:21]
Our pipe discharge coming out of our basins is not HDPA.
[1:05:26]
I don't think we have any shallow pipes on this, but that's something we evaluate.
[1:05:29]
Wait, before the site, where appropriate, we're requesting to use HDPE rather than
[1:05:35]
your RCT.
[1:05:40]
I think it's about all I have on the waivers in the rest of the civil presentation.
[1:05:53]
Does council have any questions now or do you and wait till we're finished everything?
[1:05:59]
I know there are some questions.
[1:06:02]
I think we can wait until the end of the presentation and present those questions.
[1:06:06]
Okay.
[1:06:07]
Our next presenter will be Michelle Welch from RGS to talk about the EIA report.
[1:06:29]
Hi, my name is Michelle Welch, M-I-C-H-E-L-E-W-E-L-C-H. I am a project manager
[1:06:36]
and registered landscape architect at RGS Associates, formerly Black and Thomas Panzak.
[1:06:43]
I've worked on several different projects involving the Franklin men's site and
[1:06:48]
I'm Granite Parcel since 2015 in terms of planning, landscaping, lighting, and compiling
[1:06:55]
the environmental impact assessment.
[1:06:58]
And I'm very familiar with the site at its own ongoing history.
[1:07:02]
As part of the Outrigger project, RGS was responsible for compiling the environmental impact assessment
[1:07:08]
or EIA.
[1:07:10]
And the EIA is required by the Middletown Township Zoning Ordnance section 275-215.
[1:07:17]
And the EIA is basically a process used to evaluate the potential environmental and economic
[1:07:24]
consequences or benefits of a proposed project, and the goal is to assess and minimize negative
[1:07:31]
effects on the environment ensuring sustainable development.
[1:07:35]
To start, the report documents, the existing conditions that include biological resources,
[1:07:42]
businesses, physical resources, land uses, historic resources, visual, economic impacts
[1:07:50]
and benefits, utilities and community service impacts.
[1:07:55]
And then it systematically goes through each condition to report on the impact the project
[1:08:00]
has on these resources.
[1:08:03]
So the report also includes the required environmental performance standards, which the project
[1:08:09]
to must adhere to based on the township code and other regulatory authorities.
[1:08:14]
This project will be compliant with the environmental performance standards in the township code
[1:08:20]
and goes above the necessary requirements in some instances. The Outrigger project will have
[1:08:27]
a fiscally positive impact on middle town township and road street media school district as Scott was
[1:08:34]
The fiscal impact analysis is functionally the difference between the cost of providing
[1:08:42]
community services to additional residents and employees of the proposed project and
[1:08:48]
the revenue generated by taxes, fees, interests, and fines associated with the improvement of
[1:08:54]
land.
[1:08:55]
Overall, the generated revenues greatly exceed the generated expenditures of the project.
[1:09:02]
The Outrigger project has less environmental impact than the previously approved frost plan as the other consultants were saying.
[1:09:13]
For example, the Outrigger project is located mostly within the footprint of the former Franklin Mint building and parking area.
[1:09:22]
Has less and previous surface than the former approved frost project.
[1:09:27]
The Outrigger project is removing approximately 50,000 square foot of woodlands where the
[1:09:33]
former, the frost project was removing 340,000 square foot of woodlands.
[1:09:39]
And as John was saying, the frost project also has disturbed a larger percentage of steep
[1:09:45]
slopes and land adjacent to the rubber paring buffers.
[1:09:49]
Any development proposed for the site would need to disturb steep slopes and the rubber paring
[1:09:55]
buffers.
[1:09:55]
but the Outrigger plan is keeping those disturbances to an absolute minimum.
[1:10:00]
Overall, this project would be less impactful on the physical and biological resources
[1:10:05]
on site than the previously approved plan.
[1:10:08]
The EIA also systematically goes through the impacts and addresses
[1:10:13]
how the project is mitigating these impacts.
[1:10:17]
For example, the applicant is proposing to install sound barrier walls
[1:10:21]
as is recommended by the Acoustic Specialist to mitigate sound beyond what is required by code.
[1:10:28]
Our sound consultant will speak to that in more detail later on.
[1:10:33]
Other mitigation measures include landscape buffering and
[1:10:36]
Birmingham in addition to the township requirements an 8 to 10 foot high berm is being proposed
[1:10:43]
between the project site and Franklin station to the west to create a stronger buffer between the
[1:10:48]
two sites and a 4 to 6 high berm is also proposed on the east side of the building.
[1:10:56]
Plant material from the parking islands has been reallocated to the east and west of
[1:11:00]
the site to enhance the buffering and put the vegetation to better use.
[1:11:05]
The townships requests for additional pedestrian connectivity between Franklin Mint parcels
[1:11:11]
has been incorporated on the south side of the site with the proposed sidewalk which will
[1:11:17]
will also connect to potential township trails
[1:11:20]
and green open space.
[1:11:21]
There will also be a pedestrian connection
[1:11:24]
along Baltimore Pike,
[1:11:25]
incorporated into the streetscape
[1:11:27]
with additional benches.
[1:11:30]
The building height has been reduced
[1:11:32]
from 50 foot to 44 and a half foot,
[1:11:35]
and a six foot high screening fence
[1:11:37]
has been added to the rear of the building as requested.
[1:11:42]
The applicant has been adjusting the plan
[1:11:44]
and working with the townships staff diligently
[1:11:46]
to try and incorporate as many of the township directives as possible.
[1:11:51]
And the EIA has also been updated to incorporate more detailed information about mitigation measures
[1:11:57]
and controls for air quality, erosion control, and sound emissions as requested by the township consultants.
[1:12:05]
Stormwater mitigation is required and regulated by the PA DEP. Stormwater requirements are much more stringent now
[1:12:13]
that they were when the Franklin Mint was constructed, so that would be greatly improved upon.
[1:12:18]
And this layout provides the most practical balance between the development of this site,
[1:12:24]
minimization of impacts, and the preservation of the environment.
[1:12:29]
And more detailed studies are included in the EIA as exhibits and reference throughout the document.
[1:12:35]
And these include visual resource study, traffic study, and sound study.
[1:12:40]
and we have professional experts to talk to these points in further detail.
[1:12:45]
Thanks.
[1:12:56]
Nicole Klein from Bowman, our traffic consultant is going to speak to you next.
[1:13:12]
Good evening.
[1:13:12]
Again, Nicole Klein and ICOLE, K-L-I-N-E, from Bowman Consulting Traffic Engineer for the Applicant.
[1:13:21]
So I have been the traffic engineer for the development and ownership team of the Franklin Mint
[1:13:28]
since the beginning of the envisioning process for redevelopment of the multiple properties
[1:13:34]
under the umbrella of the Franklin Mint parcel. So there
[1:13:43]
has been significant planning
[1:13:48]
and discussion that has gone into the traffic infrastructure within the entirety of the Franklin
[1:13:56]
department parcel from its inception.
[1:14:01]
So back in 2018, a full master plan traffic impact study, I prepared for the Franklin
[1:14:10]
Mint as well as Ponds Edge in order to take that holistic look at traffic operations for
[1:14:18]
this area with regard to planning access points and roadway frontage improvements.
[1:14:25]
At that time, an alternative transportation plan was also developed in order to document
[1:14:31]
all the transportation benefits built into the master plan through other features, including
[1:14:38]
the sidewalks and trails, internal roadway connectivity, and connectivity to transit.
[1:14:45]
We moved forward to the Frost Development Plan.
[1:14:50]
At that time, we prepared a supplemental traffic analysis that was in 2021.
[1:14:55]
and it updated that master plan to incorporate.
[1:15:00]
The Frost Development at that time. Originally in the master plan study, this area was assumed
[1:15:08]
for an office redevelopment at 576,000 square feet. The Frost Development last-mile distribution
[1:15:16]
facility was analyzed in the supplement and as a matter of the review by the township
[1:15:24]
and PANDA at that time, the only improvements with regard to additional traffic items were
[1:15:31]
site access, modifications, and improvements, and site-frontage elements. There were no additional
[1:15:38]
off-site improvements identified for that project. So we move forward now to, you know, what we're
[1:15:45]
here to discuss, but I think that history is important, but now shifting to the currently proposed
[1:15:51]
outrigger development. So we've had many studies over the years, the most recent, as I mentioned in
[1:15:57]
2018 in a supplement in 2021, when we began the process without rigor, the Townships traffic
[1:16:03]
engineer and Township staff requested a fully updated traffic impact study. And we agreed the
[1:16:10]
applicant agreed and we proceeded. So in early 2025, we started again from scratch. And so what that
[1:16:19]
That means is in coordination with the township, 15 study intersections were identified.
[1:16:28]
We did all new traffic counts, weekday morning, weekday afternoon peak periods.
[1:16:35]
We took a fresh look at all the future traffic projections.
[1:16:40]
You can imagine what we did, you know, the counts in 2018, for example, there have been
[1:16:44]
a lot of other developments that have moved forward in the township.
[1:16:47]
not only on the Frank and Franklin Mint parcel, not only Ponds Edge, the Wawa train station,
[1:16:54]
the promenade at Granite Run, the work at Riddle Hospital. A lot of that has come a long way.
[1:17:00]
It's not all complete, but it's come a long way. So the new traffic counts we did captured all of
[1:17:05]
those changes. We updated our assumptions in terms of those developments which are approved and not
[1:17:10]
yet completed. We added that traffic into our new analysis. And of course, we added the traffic
[1:17:16]
to be generated by the proposed Outrigger Warehouse facility.
[1:17:22]
So just a couple points of comparison.
[1:17:26]
You know, the Frost development had more traffic on a daily basis than the Outrigger project.
[1:17:35]
And the Frost project had more trips that would be generated during many hours of the day than the Outrigger development.
[1:17:44]
There are some areas where the Outrigger project is more, and they are of importance.
[1:17:50]
The frost development was projected to generate 42 large truck trips a day, so that would
[1:17:56]
be 21 trucks in and 21 trucks out on a typical weekday.
[1:18:01]
For the proposed Outrigger development, we are estimating 200 total truck trips in a 24-hour
[1:18:10]
period.
[1:18:16]
Okay, folks, let's give her a chance to continue and then we'll once the presentation is complete
[1:18:22]
we'll be able to make comments and we'll also take these into consideration if you want to click.
[1:18:27]
If you want to clarify that point by all means as far as the trips versus number of trucks but we'll continue.
[1:18:33]
I will continue to explain as planned so that means 100 trucks in and 100 trucks out on a typical weekday
[1:18:41]
in that 24-hour period. Now those numbers are not made up. Those numbers are based on very specific
[1:18:51]
guidance from PennDOT on speculative warehouse projects. It's based on data collected at real operating
[1:19:00]
sites. Now we looked at those numbers in conjunction with OutRigger. It would do them no good for me to
[1:19:08]
underestimate the truck trips on our study. We certainly always have an opportunity to
[1:19:12]
adjust and explain. But in conjunction with Outrigger and as Scott explained very clearly
[1:19:19]
at the beginning of this presentation, there are very specific site elements that are going
[1:19:24]
to dictate the types of tenants. And so we are very confident that these number of trucks
[1:19:30]
are conservative, i.e. high, compared to what we anticipate based on the type of tenants
[1:19:36]
that will be able to utilize the space in this building.
[1:19:40]
But it doesn't end there and I will talk about some other measurements
[1:19:46]
or controls that will protect the township in that regard
[1:19:51]
when I finish explaining what we did in the study.
[1:19:54]
So moving forward, again, back to the study that we prepared,
[1:19:58]
all new counts, all new analysis and the investigation of the traffic impacts
[1:20:04]
from the Outrigger development at 15 study intersections surrounding the site.
[1:20:10]
Based on all of our evaluations, which were done, you know,
[1:20:14]
based on PennDOT guidelines and criteria as well as in conjunction
[1:20:18]
and under the review of the townships traffic engineer,
[1:20:22]
we assessed the vehicle delay and the change in cues that will result
[1:20:30]
from the additional trips to be generated by this project at those surrounding study intersections.
[1:20:38]
Vehicle Delay is assessed on a letter grade scale. It's known as level of service.
[1:20:44]
We give a level of service grades based on the amount of vehicle delay.
[1:20:49]
It's a level of service A, if it has extremely low delay, and the grade goes up to B, C, D, E, and F.
[1:20:57]
F is considered failing.
[1:21:00]
Level of service D as in dog or better
[1:21:03]
is the typical goal for an urban and suburban environment.
[1:21:09]
So, we know that there are traffic issues
[1:21:11]
in this area of middle town township,
[1:21:14]
and we acknowledge that.
[1:21:15]
The results of our analysis and the mandate
[1:21:18]
on these offsite intersections,
[1:21:20]
which are all under the jurisdiction of Pendot,
[1:21:23]
is that we have to mitigate
[1:21:25]
any of our specific impacts. And so we have to compare without development conditions to
[1:21:32]
with development conditions and assess how much traffic impact is specific to the development.
[1:21:38]
Based on our updated analysis findings in the report, we found no significant traffic impacts.
[1:21:50]
Yep,
[1:21:53]
all right folks. It isn't everybody's best interest that we let the applicant proceed
[1:21:58]
with their presentation uninterrupted.
[1:22:01]
All right, there will be the opportunity for public comments.
[1:22:03]
We need to keep it down and let them continue.
[1:22:05]
Thank you.
[1:22:08]
There is, there was not any significant traffic impact
[1:22:12]
based on the measure of overall intersection delay.
[1:22:17]
That's the first threshold.
[1:22:18]
We look at the intersection as a whole.
[1:22:22]
The Townships Traffic Engineer did identify
[1:22:24]
in their review letter at two study intersections.
[1:22:27]
There are some individual movements
[1:22:29]
with some added delay and some increase queuing, and we acknowledge that.
[1:22:33]
And at this point, based on the Townships Review and Pendats Review,
[1:22:37]
it has been agreed by all parties, including the applicant,
[1:22:40]
that there will be a meeting to discuss with the Township, Pendats, and the applicant
[1:22:45]
the results of the traffic study, any additional questions and next steps.
[1:22:54]
So, I do want to go back to, you know, I explained, you know,
[1:22:59]
the truck trips and provided some comparisons.
[1:23:01]
I have some additional information I want to share because there have been a lot of questions and a lot of speculations surrounding that information.
[1:23:12]
So we did include these two graphics that I am going to describe within the traffic impact study.
[1:23:18]
So these are not new.
[1:23:19]
What I'm going to focus on in these two maps are the daily truck trips.
[1:23:24]
This first map is showing existing truck volumes and this is all from pen.data.
[1:23:29]
this is not from data that we collected. This is pen.data. So what this shows, you can see about
[1:23:35]
in the middle of the map, we have a red star which indicates the outrigger site.
[1:23:41]
We look at the three major routes surrounding the site where you see the most truck traffic today
[1:23:47]
and the routes that are most desirable by the large tractor trailer trucks given their desired
[1:23:53]
destinations. So the first on the far left of this map, the upper left, is the root
[1:24:02]
to and from the site via root 1 to root 202. The top number daily trips of
[1:24:13]
1,484. That is the total number of truck trips that that root experiences on a
[1:24:21]
typical weekday in a 24-hour period. As we look to the bottom left, that covers the root
[1:24:30]
via root 452 to and from I-95. The total truck trips in that area on a daily 24-hour
[1:24:39]
basis on a typical weekday, existing truck volumes, 1,112 truck trips. And these are two
[1:24:46]
way, it's the soda on both directions. And then the final major route that we identified
[1:24:54]
would be utilizing Route 1 to travel to and from I-476. The daily truck trips on that
[1:25:02]
were particular route are 1,977.
[1:25:09]
So our second graphic, this focuses on those truck trips
[1:25:13]
that I talked about in terms of the site trip generation.
[1:25:17]
We talked about 200 daily truck trips.
[1:25:20]
100 trucks in and 100 trucks out for a total of 200 truck trips.
[1:25:26]
So if we look at those three routes,
[1:25:28]
we don't know exactly how the trucks will distribute.
[1:25:31]
But I'll cover that question in a moment.
[1:25:34]
But assuming the trucks from this site travel in a similar pattern
[1:25:38]
to the way the trucks travel in this area today,
[1:25:41]
It's a reasonable baseline assumption.
[1:25:45]
What we would have, again in that upper left is the route along, you know, taking route
[1:25:50]
one to get to and from Route 202, this site would add about 60 truck trips, total trips
[1:25:56]
both directions.
[1:25:58]
That's about a 4% increase on the existing trucks on that route today.
[1:26:02]
The lower left, that route taking 452 to and from I-95, again, about adding about 60 daily
[1:26:10]
truck trips and that is about a 5% increase in trucks versus what is on that route today.
[1:26:18]
And then the final one in the upper right, utilizing Route 1 to travel to and from I-476.
[1:26:23]
There, there is more truck demand today, so we would assume there is likely to be more
[1:26:28]
truck demand on that route for this site.
[1:26:30]
The daily truck trips from the site were estimating 80 and that's about a 4% increase over the
[1:26:37]
existing trucks.
[1:26:38]
So it is a change, it is an increase, but it is not a significant change or increase.
[1:26:45]
So I wanted to circle back to that one last topic that I alluded to.
[1:26:50]
What additional measures or controls are in place?
[1:26:54]
We recognize this is a speculative development and there are always a lot of questions surrounding
[1:27:02]
traffic in speculative industrial developments, that is not uncommon.
[1:27:06]
And there are a couple of ways that that is typically handled.
[1:27:11]
Through PennDOT, PennDOT has already stated in their review of the traffic study that
[1:27:17]
they will require a post-development study.
[1:27:20]
That is typical of PennDOT for speculative warehouse and industrial projects.
[1:27:26]
And so the applicant and their HOP permit will be held to the standard that was included in
[1:27:32]
the traffic impact study.
[1:27:33]
And through that post-development study, if it is found to be generating higher trips
[1:27:39]
than what was included in the traffic impact study, PennDOT has the ability to require
[1:27:46]
additional analysis, evaluation, and potential improvements if it is deemed required.
[1:27:59]
Folks, we need to eliminate the interruptions.
[1:28:02]
Okay, let's let the applicant continue.
[1:28:04]
You'll have the opportunity for a public comment.
[1:28:06]
We need to let them finish.
[1:28:09]
And finally, the township will also have that ability.
[1:28:14]
In the Township Traffic Engineers Review Letter, he requested that the applicant agrees to
[1:28:19]
the requirement of a post-development study.
[1:28:22]
The applicant has agreed to that.
[1:28:25]
The details of that still need to be determined, and we will work through that, and I think it
[1:28:29]
makes the most sense to work through that again collectively through the collaboration meetings
[1:28:34]
that will occur with PennDOT, but the township will also hold the ability to create a condition
[1:28:42]
to require that post-development study, so that it doesn't just have to be relied on
[1:28:47]
through the PennDOT HOP permit, we can have the same condition in place with the township
[1:28:53]
as well.
[1:28:54]
And so, it would not be fair to present a traffic impact study and then to build something that
[1:29:00]
to generate significantly more traffic.
[1:29:02]
And so those controls are important and reasonable.
[1:29:05]
And so that's my presentation,
[1:29:07]
and I'll be happy to answer questions at the end.
[1:29:09]
Thank you.
[1:29:10]
Thank you very much.
[1:29:11]
And we will let the presentation complete
[1:29:14]
the presentation before we ask questions and such.
[1:29:24]
Our next presenter will be Gavin Bybuck,
[1:29:26]
who's from Liberty Environmental.
[1:29:28]
He's gonna talk to you about the air quality
[1:29:31]
and emissions issues.
[1:29:36]
Good evening.
[1:29:36]
I'm Gavin Bebeck, B-I-E-B-U-Y-C-K.
[1:29:41]
I'm with Liberty Environmental.
[1:29:44]
I'm an air quality consultant,
[1:29:45]
have been one for 35 years.
[1:29:47]
Prior to that, I worked for Pennsylvania DEP
[1:29:49]
in the Bureau of Air Quality.
[1:29:53]
I have evaluated the project,
[1:29:57]
primarily looking at applicable.
[1:30:00]
Federal and state air quality requirements. As Michelle from RGS mentioned, the project will comply
[1:30:07]
with state and federal air quality requirements, specifically during construction,
[1:30:16]
future dust control requirements will be implemented and complied with. And in during operation,
[1:30:25]
The truck traffic will comply with the state idling requirement, which limits truck idling to five minutes in any one hour.
[1:30:37]
Signs will be placed to remind truck drivers to comply with that requirement.
[1:30:45]
The trucks will of course comply with federal tailpipe standards.
[1:30:51]
And as for as overall air quality impacts go, this project sounds like a large project when
[1:31:03]
you hear 100 trucks per day.
[1:31:06]
Big picture that is not very large compared to a truck terminal or distribution center where
[1:31:17]
you have a thousand trucks per day or more. No. And as Scott pointed out, this is not going
[1:31:27]
to be a truck terminal. This is not going to be a logistic center. This is going to
[1:31:32]
be a warehouse for local businesses so that the amount of truck traffic on site is significantly
[1:31:40]
less than the large distribution centers we're seeing in the Lehigh Valley, for example,
[1:31:45]
which are a million square foot with much larger traffic volumes.
[1:31:52]
I understand there's concern from several of the community regarding PM 2.5.
[1:31:59]
Fine particulate matter, which is one of the prime air pollutant concerns at the moment.
[1:32:06]
And I can appreciate that Delaware County has been non-attainment with the PM 2.5 standard in the past.
[1:32:14]
It has currently been re-designated as attainment, PM 2.5 levels have decreased significantly over the last 20 years by over 30%.
[1:32:25]
However, the PM 2.5 standards have also been lowered, so the expectation is that Delaware County will be reclassified as non-attainment with the PM 2.5 standard.
[1:32:38]
However, trucks and vehicle traffic are really not the problem when it comes to PM 2.5.
[1:32:46]
The problem is in large part power plants, the I-95 corridor, refineries, airports, logistics
[1:32:55]
in general, and in looking at the PM 2.5 data, the concern is really the Philadelphia I-95 area,
[1:33:05]
the level of each of your county, Montgomery County,
[1:33:08]
or quite a lot of.
[1:33:09]
We weren't going to ask questions, but the concern I think
[1:33:13]
about the air pollution is what this project is causing.
[1:33:19]
Yes.
[1:33:19]
So relitigating the past is becoming a theme in this presentation.
[1:33:23]
And can we focus on what's happening now?
[1:33:33]
Fair enough, this project, if we look at the worst case,
[1:33:38]
which are 100 trucks per day, or 200 trucks in, 100 trucks out. That is 200 in total.
[1:33:48]
If we look at that, and we look at the PM 2.5 emissions associated with that truck traffic,
[1:33:54]
it is less than 1 pound per day of PM 2.5. And I base that on other distribution centers.
[1:34:02]
I've looked at, with much larger traffic based on emissions ten years ago.
[1:34:07]
Emissions from truck traffic is considerably lower now because of ultra low sulfur diesel
[1:34:14]
and much cleaner new engines and trucks.
[1:34:18]
So, one pound per day of PM 2.5 is the projection at the most from the truck traffic at this site.
[1:34:27]
One pound per day in my world of air permitting is de minimis.
[1:34:34]
It is very, very low.
[1:34:36]
To require an air permit from Pennsylvania DEP, a source like the Wawa Berry, large boilers,
[1:34:45]
they have to emit more than 100 pounds per day.
[1:34:48]
So one pound per day is a very low emission rate.
[1:34:53]
and that's what's estimated from this site, from the truck traffic.
[1:35:01]
As I mentioned, PM 2.5 is a concern, it is going to be a concern in Delaware County when we expect the county to be re-designated as a non-intainment.
[1:35:14]
But truck traffic and traffic in general is addressed through the county planners and the states and Penn.
[1:35:23]
not in terms of what's projected for the highways, the traffic study that was done shows
[1:35:30]
that the impacts on the highway are going to be less than 5%.
[1:35:36]
So with regard to air quality, I draw the same conclusion that the air quality impacts
[1:35:45]
are not going to be significant from this project.
[1:35:48]
And
[1:35:54]
in summary, I understand your concern with a lot of truck traffic, but my experience
[1:36:02]
has been particularly in the Lehigh Valley, where we've seen distribution centers go in.
[1:36:10]
Well, Lehigh Valley used to be not an attainment for BM2.5, 10 years ago, and it is now attainment.
[1:36:17]
It now meets the standards despite the fact that we have a lot of truck traffic and a lot
[1:36:21]
of much larger distribution centers than what we're talking about here, the air pollution
[1:36:26]
levels have gone down. So I do not see an air quality or air pollution concern with
[1:36:31]
this project. Thank you. Thank you. Just checking in with our
[1:36:36]
sound tech folks, we're good to go to continue. Just to give you a heads up, with the recording,
[1:36:42]
the sound recording we have going on tonight, there will be a time, maybe within the next
[1:36:47]
No, we're actually good. Okay. We may end up having to do a recess for switching a taste,
[1:36:51]
but it sounds like we're good to go for right now. So I was checking out their sound tech folks.
[1:36:54]
Thank you.
[1:37:02]
Well, the good news is we're down to our last presenter on our end.
[1:37:10]
So our last presenter will be Carl Everbach to discuss sound.
[1:37:21]
Good evening, and thank you very much. My name is Carl Everbach, C-A-R-R-R.
[1:37:27]
last name, EV, E-R-B-A-C-H, and I am a professor of engineering at Swarthmore College,
[1:37:36]
but I'm here in my capacity as a private acoustic consultant to address issues of noise
[1:37:42]
and sound from the proposed site.
[1:37:46]
I should say that, as stated earlier, the environmental performance standards
[1:37:54]
that the township specifies determine what is allowed for sound propagation and the township's
[1:38:04]
acoustics consultant, Thornton acoustical consultants, have worked in response to my proposals
[1:38:15]
and the townships consultant agrees with the standards that are used to determine the level of the sound,
[1:38:28]
the noise barriers that are required to mitigate the sound appropriately.
[1:38:33]
What I mean by that is that the township code uses noise ordinance standards that are outmoded and have not been updated.
[1:38:43]
So the modern translation, according to the American National Standards Institute for
[1:38:49]
the outmoded active band or frequency band analysis, has been specified in a standard which
[1:38:58]
I've applied to the township's noise ordinances, and the Thornton consultants hired by the township
[1:39:06]
have agreed that the numbers that I used in that translation are correct.
[1:39:11]
So the township and its consultants and the applicant and his consultant, me, agree on the standards to be met.
[1:39:21]
We will have no trouble meeting these standards.
[1:39:23]
The two sources of noise that the residents are concerned about are, and the only sources that I believe are going to take place are noise from trucks, including backup beepers, and HVAC noise from the roof of the building.
[1:39:42]
Both of these are going to be mitigated by noise barriers.
[1:39:45]
The noise barriers at ground level are specified as 15 feet tall, which is taller than the ceiling
[1:39:51]
of this room, and they are located close to the trucks so that the propagation of the
[1:39:58]
noise from the trucks will be below the standards, agreed upon in the noise, revised noise ordinances
[1:40:06]
conditions from the township at the most sensitive or nearest residences.
[1:40:13]
Any residences farther than the closest ones will have less noise.
[1:40:20]
That's a matter of physics, it's a matter of propagation, sound propagation.
[1:40:26]
On the roof of the proposed building, there will be 10 foot high noise barriers.
[1:40:31]
They will surround two sides of the HVAC units and most definitely will reduce this noise
[1:40:41]
below the required maximum limits.
[1:40:45]
So I will say that there's absolutely no doubt on my mind and we will be sure the applicant
[1:40:52]
has specified that we will meet all the applicable noise ordinances of middle-town township in
[1:40:59]
this project.
[1:41:00]
Thank you.
[1:41:00]
Thank you so
[1:41:10]
that would conclude our presentation but our consultants obviously are all here.
[1:41:15]
I'll wait.
[1:41:17]
Our consultants are here obviously to answer the questions that you have.
[1:41:23]
Thank you very much Mr. Mischowski.
[1:41:26]
At this time, I think we'll
[1:41:35]
have the public
[1:41:40]
questions.
[1:41:41]
All right, so at this time, we'll actually move to the public comment period at which
[1:41:49]
time residents will be asked to limit their statements to three minutes.
[1:41:56]
Ms. Moreno will be keeping track of time, and again, this is in the interest of everybody
[1:42:01]
here to give everyone a chance to express concern, make statements so we can progress through
[1:42:09]
the course of the night and at a reasonable hour. At this time, just to review, we have the
[1:42:14]
podium up here. I would ask folks to come up to the podium, state their name and address
[1:42:18]
for the record before making comment. I would also ask you to keep in mind redundancies
[1:42:24]
part. I think there's a lot of shared concerns and we understand there are a lot of people concerned
[1:42:30]
about this. We don't necessarily need to hear the same concern reiterated multiple times.
[1:42:37]
So I would ask, I would ask pardon me, that's fine I'm just asking and the interest of everybody here to progress through the whole progress that you keep redundancy in mind with your statements.
[1:42:48]
Thank you.
[1:42:50]
Hi, my name is Laura Shaw. I live at 754 switchman road in media. I pay taxes. I pay a lot of taxes.
[1:43:03]
Laura, L-A-U-R-A, Shaw, S-H-A-W. You're welcome.
[1:43:10]
I want to mention, first of all, I want to apologize
[1:43:12]
for the amount of misinformation and I'm just going to say misinformation, but you all know what I
[1:43:21]
mean that you were subjected to and we all were subjected to. Secondly, I want to mention that
[1:43:27]
The 1,470 people have signed a petition telling you not to approve this warehouse and distribution
[1:43:35]
center.
[1:43:36]
I shared this petition with you months ago.
[1:43:40]
I'm sharing it again tonight because we have a number of new signatures.
[1:43:44]
And because I want to give these people a voice in the proceedings tonight.
[1:43:50]
It says we, the residents of Middletown Township, strongly oppose the Outrigger Industrial
[1:43:56]
acquisition LLC proposal to build a distribution center at 1408, West Baltimore Pike Media.
[1:44:03]
This development would have a detrimental and irreversible impact on our community.
[1:44:08]
We concur with the Delaware County Planning Commission's December 20, 2024 recommendation
[1:44:14]
to the township.
[1:44:15]
And I quote, disapproval due to code noncompliance and broad inconsistency with the overarching
[1:44:22]
parking purpose of the zoning district, as well as with the Middletown and Delaware County
[1:44:26]
comprehensive plans, end quote. And I'm adding something that I'm sure all the petitioners
[1:44:33]
would agree with, that we also concur with the Middletown Planning Commission's recommendation
[1:44:37]
against approving the Outrigger proposal. I'm going to somebody's timing me, right? So when
[1:44:43]
I get to three minutes, I will stop, but with the time I have left, I want to read some comments
[1:44:48]
from people who signed the petition so I can give them a voice at this
[1:44:52]
proceeding. The first is from Christy Freed, who lives here in Middletown. I'm
[1:44:57]
sure she pays a lot of taxes too.
[1:45:00]
F-R-E-I-D. You're welcome. The warehouse does not align with the county township or residence hopes of what this residential and retail corridor could be in the near future, and should not be built on this lot of land. This portion of Baltimore Pike is already riddled with a ton of traffic, and I cannot imagine how much worse it would be with additional semi-trucks running to and from the warehouse at all hours. The noise, light and air pollution would be out of control. There are many other choice lots available.
[1:45:29]
to build to suit that outrigger can choose that would not be in such a newly and now heavily populated residential area.
[1:45:37]
Please vote no to the warehouse project for the sake of the local residents.
[1:45:43]
C-Hong Pack, P-A-K, also of Middletown.
[1:45:48]
C-Hong, et, and I may be saying wrong. S-E-O-H-O-N-G. Is she here?
[1:45:58]
You're next.
[1:46:02]
My name is Paul Lopriato. It's P-A-U-L-O-P-R-E-I-A-T-O. A lot of letters. I live on Kyle Square,
[1:46:10]
so I'm a Middletown resident and taxpayer. You may have seen me at nearly every council meeting
[1:46:16]
and every outrigger related planning commission meeting this year. I just like to talk about what
[1:46:21]
I've seen. I've seen people show up and pack township council meetings to speak out against this
[1:46:25]
projects. I've never seen a single one in support. I've seen every single speaker at planning
[1:46:31]
commission meetings speak out against the project as well. I've heard Middletown residents
[1:46:36]
highlight valid stormwater and pipeline danger concerns, concerns for their physical safety
[1:46:43]
as we add 200, that's 200, new trucks to local streets. I heard concerns that this project no longer
[1:46:51]
fits with the current zoning requirements, and I've heard concerns that the project never
[1:46:55]
actually fit within the old zoning requirements either, all reasonable. On the other hand,
[1:47:01]
I've seen outriggers submitted incomplete application, with analysis including traffic studies
[1:47:06]
from before COVID and before Franklin Station and Ponzege. We're developed. I've seen them claim
[1:47:12]
they'll have no impact on state police operations against all basic logic. Did you know that last
[1:47:19]
Last month in Lehigh County, a township council voted down a warehouse proposal for
[1:47:23]
being, quote, incomplete and detrimental to the health, safety, and welfare of its residents.
[1:47:28]
This is reason enough to vote no in this proposal.
[1:47:32]
But I've also seen them lie in the Planning Commission presentation saying they had community
[1:47:36]
support.
[1:47:38]
I've seen them send threatening letters to the employers of people who simply spoke out
[1:47:41]
against the project.
[1:47:43]
This is the definition of bad faith, and is also reason enough to vote no on this average
[1:47:48]
proposal. They continue to hide their final plan, still unable to name a single tenant
[1:47:53]
that they'll have. Did you know a township council in central PA voted down a warehouse
[1:47:59]
with no tenants? Because it's a spec warehouse, which they mentioned a few times. It's different
[1:48:04]
than a warehouse. It's when you have no tenants lined up. That was reason why they voted
[1:48:09]
it down. And that's reason enough to vote this proposal down. The Delaware County Planning
[1:48:13]
Planning Commission recommended against this proposal, our own Planning Commission recommended
[1:48:18]
against this project, with not a single vote in favor.
[1:48:23]
Now that you've heard all these reasons, I ask you on the count to also please vote against
[1:48:27]
this proposal.
[1:48:28]
Thank you.
[1:48:39]
Hi, Katie Fulton, FUL, T-O-N, Natalie Lane, I am a resident.
[1:48:44]
I'm going to try not to add on and say the same things that have already been said.
[1:48:48]
but during the presentation we heard a lot about the previous approved plan.
[1:48:55]
There was so much focus on that but that was approved when there was not two full communities built and occupied.
[1:49:03]
It was built before there was a new apartment complex built and it was approved before two local hospitals closed their doors, increasing the volume hitting rental hospital.
[1:49:11]
So in my opinion what was approved in the past is not at all relevant.
[1:49:17]
I've been coming to these meetings for over a year now or whenever this started, but it started
[1:49:23]
at 500 plus trucks a day. Then it went down to 100 and many times we have asked, I specifically
[1:49:31]
have asked, is it 100 trucks in and out, meaning 200 trucks, or is it 100 trucks total, meaning
[1:49:37]
50 trucks in and out? And nobody would answer me while all of a sudden today now we're being
[1:49:41]
told 200 trucks. So what is the answer and who is going to police? Because again, we don't have
[1:49:48]
a tenant. So who is going to police who they lease this building to? And if they lease it to somebody
[1:49:55]
that needs more than 200 trucks a day, what happens then? Because doing a traffic study after the building
[1:50:01]
is built and the trucks are already on our roads, what does that do for us? Are they going to knock the
[1:50:07]
The building down,
[1:50:12]
the other thing it was not mentioned that so many of our intersections
[1:50:15]
are failing.
[1:50:16]
The other day I was at the intersection of Penal Road and Baltimore Pike and the ambulance
[1:50:20]
could not get through.
[1:50:22]
There was no way for them to get through and there was nowhere for people to go.
[1:50:27]
This is our health and safety of the people in this community that is at risk.
[1:50:32]
Additionally, nine minutes in 2021 and 29 minutes today.
[1:50:36]
That is also before the apartment complex has been filled.
[1:50:41]
So, again, this is our health and safety of the people that are living here, paying taxes, and all of that.
[1:50:49]
The last thing that I'll say is at the last planning commission meeting, I spent my time watching the faces of the people outrigger as people spoke.
[1:50:59]
And I watched a woman get up with tears in her eyes and talk about the health and safety of her family
[1:51:06]
and I watched the people with at-out rigor smile and smirk and laugh. And so that tells me everything that I need to know
[1:51:13]
about how much they care about our community and making it a better place for everyone to live. Thank you.
[1:51:31]
Sorry, I'm a little tall. I just want to make sure you can hear me. My name's Jonathan Long. I'm an attorney.
[1:51:36]
Many are representing a number of citizens who live in Franklin station.
[1:51:39]
They formed a 501-C4 nonprofit corporation called No Warehouse at Franklin Mint Site.
[1:51:46]
I did submit a letter to the township the other day as well as I submitted a few letters
[1:51:50]
over time.
[1:51:52]
I was asked to bring copies of that today just to make sure that it becomes part of the record.
[1:51:57]
So I do have copies here that I can distribute.
[1:52:00]
I did also bring a copy of my previous letters and our environmental reports from Dr.
[1:52:05]
depending on Dr. Howard, just to make sure those are part of the record.
[1:52:09]
I'm happy to give Debbie a copy as well.
[1:52:11]
I do have a list of my membership of the organization.
[1:52:15]
Today you are sent by Ms. Schultzky a legal brief that does a lot to try to address the arguments that we've made regarding the environmental rights amendment and arguing that basically it has no applicability here today.
[1:52:31]
I will tell you as you read that legal brief, I want you to keep in mind that for over 40 years the environmental rights amendment, despite being in our most basic rights in our Constitution, our state Constitution, sat as a basic dead letter of law for 40 years.
[1:52:52]
They would be here 40 years ago, they would be here 10, 15 years ago saying nobody applies
[1:52:57]
that, it means nothing.
[1:52:59]
But then our Supreme Court a few years ago gave it life and gave it teeth.
[1:53:05]
And over the last few years it's been getting applied in more and more locations and in more
[1:53:10]
and more situations.
[1:53:12]
So they're arguing that it doesn't apply here today, but it is the most basic right that the
[1:53:18]
The people in this room, the people in this community have a right to clean air, clean
[1:53:23]
water, and a pristine environment.
[1:53:26]
And you, as the local government, are the trustees of that right.
[1:53:32]
And so we're asking you to apply that and protect this community.
[1:53:45]
So you'll have my letter.
[1:53:46]
I'm not going to belabor it frankly, the people that went right before me hit on some of
[1:53:50]
the points I was going to hit on.
[1:53:51]
One thing that jumped out at me listening to the presentation tonight is the idea of the post-development traffic study which the woman just before me touched on, and I will say, and as your solicitor can tell you, the township has no right under Pennsylvania law to tell a developer they can make to make improvements off site.
[1:54:15]
So, for them to say that you as a township, oh, you have the right to make them do a post-development traffic study.
[1:54:22]
Well, that's all well and good, but it's dead paper.
[1:54:24]
Because you have no right as a township to tell them to go and improve intersections.
[1:54:28]
PennDOT does.
[1:54:30]
PennDOT's 10 years out on making improvements to 352 and 452 intersections.
[1:54:38]
So, I will distribute, I'm getting the hook.
[1:54:43]
I will distribute my papers.
[1:54:46]
Thank you very much for your time.
[1:54:49]
Thank you.
[1:54:56]
Mr. Penning, if we could just wait until he has finished distributing these,
[1:55:00]
I would like to feel your attention.
[1:55:23]
All right, Dr. Penning, thank you.
[1:55:25]
My name is Dr. Trevor Penning. I am a resident at 614 Hoops Lane in Franklin station and
[1:55:32]
a Middletown township taxpayer. My name is spelled P-E-N-N-I-N-G.
[1:55:44]
I am also an environmental
[1:55:46]
mental health expert and work with the non-profit No Outrigger at Franklin Mint Site. I'm also
[1:55:53]
an environmental scientist and an international authority on air pollution employed by the
[1:55:59]
University of Pennsylvania. My remarks are my own expert opinion. First, I will not be silenced
[1:56:08]
or intimidated by the Outrigger attorneys.
[1:56:20]
Second, I oppose the Outrigger development on
[1:56:23]
environmental health grounds, as documented in my letter to the council dated February 24th
[1:56:30]
and my air monitoring report dated April 25th, 2025. My comments focus on the letters sent by
[1:56:39]
the environmental engaged by Outrigger and signed by their expert, Gavin Bybook. These
[1:56:45]
letters aim to minimise the effect of air pollution on nearby residents.
[1:56:53]
They state that
[1:56:55]
federal laws will ensure compliance with violations of air pollution standards, which is to
[1:57:00]
negate any responsibility by Outrigger for the pollution that they will cause. The applicant
[1:57:07]
The applicant cites the heavy-duty diesel emissions control tailpipe standard adopted by the
[1:57:12]
Pennsylvania DEP, that requires tenants to operate heavy-duty trucks on the site after the
[1:57:19]
model year of 2024 or newer.
[1:57:23]
The applicant acknowledges that they cannot specify the types of trucks to
[1:57:28]
be used by the tenants, so there will be none compliance with this standard. The applicant states
[1:57:34]
there will be compliance with the Diesel-powered Motor Vehicle Eiffeling Act, which restricts
[1:57:39]
diesel truck idling to no more than five minutes in any 60-minute period. How can this be achieved
[1:57:45]
with 200 trucks a day? It is not possible. The applicant acknowledges that Delaware County is
[1:57:51]
none attainment with the National Air Quality Standards for Ozone. Ozone is generated by reaction
[1:57:58]
of nitrogen oxide and volatile organic compounds, both diesel exhaust emissions.
[1:58:03]
On the other hand, it is a known respiratory irritant and would exacerbate asthma, especially
[1:58:08]
in the most vulnerable, including our young children.
[1:58:13]
The applicant acknowledges that Delaware County will likely be non-compliant with the
[1:58:18]
new PM2.5N who stand of nine micrograms per cubic metre, when measurements become available.
[1:58:24]
Air quality data that I have presented the Council shows that already one third of the time
[1:58:29]
We are in the exceedance of this level. We have also documented Dr.
[1:58:46]
Penning, I just want
[1:58:47]
to give you an opportunity if you could summarise that.
[1:58:56]
I can conclude with the following outweigher concerns. Outweigher maintains that by right
[1:59:02]
they can proceed with this development. I ask, can out right outweigher, by right ignore
[1:59:09]
nor the Pennsylvania Environment Rights Amendment, can rigor, by right, ignore the effect of
[1:59:15]
local air pollution, can out-rigor by right, ignore the effects on the health of middle-town
[1:59:20]
township residents caused by diesel exhaust. I ask the Township Council to oppose this
[1:59:26]
development to be protective of public health.
[1:59:42]
My name is Michael Bondsteen. My wife and I live in a 225 south panel road, and I had
[1:59:55]
The
[1:59:58]
case against the outrigger
[2:00:00]
The plan has been made by dozens and dozens of Middletown residents, not one person spoke up in favor of it. It's been made by highly qualified experts, such as Dr. Penning and Dr. Howard. And it's been made eloquently by council for the No Warehouse Group. But this afternoon, just before four o'clock, Outreger's attorneys filed a new legal brief. It was filled with moralized and more misleading statements. And I'm calling this to your attention, not because they're all liars.
[2:00:28]
after multiple fileings and multiple hearings, we already know their liars.
[2:00:34]
What out- what Outrigger is asking is the Council approve their application,
[2:00:41]
based on a promise to comply with a list of conditions.
[2:00:47]
Why would anybody, believe Outrigger, could be trusted to do that?
[2:00:52]
The very first sentence in their new memo refers to objections as to
[2:00:57]
as certain undisclosed persons, that is, objectures, are undisclosed persons.
[2:01:04]
That's a lie. Every single person who spoke at the Planning Commission provided a name and address.
[2:01:11]
Outriggers' representatives claimed their plan had the approval of residents of a senior community across the road.
[2:01:17]
That was shown to be a lie at the next meeting, when dozens of people stood up and said,
[2:01:21]
that's not true.
[2:01:27]
Outrigger claims that their plan should be approved because you previously
[2:01:31]
proved the Frost Plan. That's probable nonsense because, as lawyers know, it suggests they
[2:01:37]
don't have to prove that their plan complies with the law. That's not true.
[2:01:43]
As regards concerns over increased air pollution, Outrigger offered no objective data to support
[2:01:49]
their claims. And it's telling that they have not presented any experts to dispute the reports
[2:01:56]
of Dr. Howard and Dr. Trevor Penning. Indeed, despite repeated demands, we still don't have
[2:02:03]
a clue as to how many trucks will be going in and out. 500 or we recognize it's too much. We'll
[2:02:10]
say it's 200. No, we'll say it's 100, whatever it takes. And if you read the multiple environmental
[2:02:16]
until impact assessments, all they're saying in vague general terms is that we will comply
[2:02:22]
with the law. That's not enough. They have to show how they're going to comply with
[2:02:26]
the law, and if you can't measure how much increase in air pollution is going to take
[2:02:34]
place because you don't know how many trucks are spewing filth, then it's meaningless.
[2:02:41]
Outrigger
[2:02:41]
Here cannot be trusted to meet conditions attached to the approval of its obviously
[2:02:47]
deficient ten more seconds.
[2:02:50]
For these reasons alone, I urge counsel not to approve Outriggers plan.
[2:03:03]
Hello.
[2:03:04]
My name is Carter Lynn.
[2:03:05]
That's C-A-R-T-E-R.
[2:03:07]
I live in P-C-A-R-T-E-R-L-N-A-I-N.
[2:03:12]
Yeah.
[2:03:13]
So I live in Ponsage.
[2:03:15]
Just wanted to point out that in addition to the new apartment complex and rid of hospital
[2:03:19]
we already have. We also have a new Hilton and a plus at
[2:03:22]
in front. So we also need to take that into consideration.
[2:03:27]
That's it. I'm going to focus on the traffic and people in
[2:03:30]
the community already know that how much traffic we experience
[2:03:33]
during rush hour and non-rush hour and even on the weekends.
[2:03:37]
And I just have some questions. Maybe I misunderstood the
[2:03:41]
presentation, what my math isn't correct, but the trip number
[2:03:45]
just doesn't really add up. They say that they have a 4%
[2:03:49]
increase in a total traffic in and out, that's like for a total number of like 1000 trips per day,
[2:03:57]
for a given route and like 1900 for I 476, but since all the truck needs to come in and out
[2:04:06]
from the warehouse, doesn't that necessary makes 200 additional trucks for route number one?
[2:04:12]
and that's 100 trucks per day right now.
[2:04:17]
So that's a 20% increase rather than 4%.
[2:04:22]
So I would suggest that the numbers
[2:04:28]
to be reviewed by a third party traffic consultant
[2:04:31]
rather than a respective party, if that's available.
[2:04:36]
But in addition, in addition to the numbers, the stats, I'm, you know, a question
[2:04:43]
out of Castile just now, I also want to point out that traffic jam is not just
[2:04:49]
the numbers game like everyone knows how traffic jam works. Like you could have
[2:04:55]
approaching a big breaking point where you have a bottleneck and then the next car
[2:05:00]
can cause you to wait in line for like the next 10, 15, 20 minutes.
[2:05:05]
So if the current traffic at rule number one is at the critical point, as if right now,
[2:05:10]
then if we're adding 200 trucks to that, it's not just,
[2:05:16]
let's just say that the presentation is correct, 4%.
[2:05:18]
That is not just 4%. That could trigger us down to more traffic, to I-95, to I-476.
[2:05:26]
It could be 30 minutes, 40 minutes, 50 minutes, more weight in line before we get to home.
[2:05:33]
So that's more than what the numbers suggest.
[2:05:37]
It's a trickling effect and it's a feeling.
[2:05:40]
So I just want to point this to everybody as already in the community, to the township committee, for consider.
[2:05:59]
My name is Xiao Chunling, I'm a resident at Ponsai H as well, I'm a father, I'm a taxpayer,
[2:06:15]
so since I'm Asian, I'm a particular interesting number, so let's go back to the air pollution
[2:06:20]
number.
[2:06:21]
So I think the gentlemen mentioned that 200 trucks per day that produce PM 25 about 1 pound on daily basis.
[2:06:32]
I think the missing part is this is every single day.
[2:06:37]
I'm planning to live here for another 5 years and years.
[2:06:41]
So what's the number total number in next 5, 10 years?
[2:06:46]
It's going to be 1000 pounds of PM 25 pollutants.
[2:06:50]
in the air, who is going to clean that hour long, our case long, and our early days
[2:06:57]
people long, who is going to do the job to clean the air.
[2:07:01]
So that's the missing part.
[2:07:03]
I would really urge the committee to vote no to this project.
[2:07:08]
And that's what I don't say.
[2:07:17]
Hello, my name is Patricia Haggerty.
[2:07:19]
That's P-A-T-R-I-C-I-A-H-A-G-G-E-R-T-Y.
[2:07:26]
I would first just like to express my concern that this project would have a very detrimental
[2:07:32]
effect on the neighboring residents in the general area and in particular on the school
[2:07:38]
that is right next to, right there on Baltimore Pike and I'm concerned for the health of
[2:07:45]
the children.
[2:07:46]
If I may, I would like to read a few more comments from the petition.
[2:07:52]
Sorry, before you do that, can you just put your address into the record, please?
[2:07:55]
Yes.
[2:07:55]
My address is 16, soldier, song, lane.
[2:08:00]
That's media, Riddlewood, Middletown Township.
[2:08:04]
Yeah, sorry.
[2:08:05]
Okay.
[2:08:07]
So, the first comment is from Ciong Pock, S-E-O-H-O-N-G-P-A-K, who says, this development
[2:08:19]
threatens to increase traffic noise pollution and disrupt the quality of life for residents.
[2:08:25]
We urge decision makers to prioritize sustainable and community-friendly alternatives that
[2:08:30]
preserve our environment and neighborhood.
[2:08:36]
Second, next comment is from Ruth Lieberwitz, R-U-T-H-L-E-I-B-O-W-I-T-Z, who says,
[2:08:46]
My husband has a lung disease and is on continual oxygen.
[2:08:50]
The air pollution issues could likely negatively impact his illness.
[2:08:57]
We've got, uh, next comment is from Michael Barber, M-I-C-H-A-E-L-B-A-R-B-E-R, who says,
[2:09:06]
we move to this area to escape the noise, pollution, and congestion of the city and all the undesirable
[2:09:11]
commercial industrial activity.
[2:09:14]
The construction of a commercial warehouse facility would destroy all the attractiveness
[2:09:18]
of living in this area.
[2:09:20]
We will most certainly relocate if the warehouse proposal is approved.
[2:09:27]
Next comment is from Rosarita Fratoni, whose R-O-S-E-R-I-T-A-F-R-A-T-O-N-I, who says,
[2:09:41]
this development profile does not fit into the media area.
[2:09:45]
It's citizens prefer environmental and ecological development.
[2:09:52]
Next comment is from Claire Bickerton, C-L-A-I-R-E-B-I-C-K-E-R-T-O-N.
[2:10:00]
This road is already horribly congested.
[2:10:03]
We should be aiming to make the area more walkable and community oriented,
[2:10:08]
not plop a warehouse down that will do nothing to serve the community.
[2:10:16]
Here's a go on. Mary Sikung, M-A-R-Y-C-Y-C-O-N, she says. As a long-term time resident,
[2:10:30]
I have become very concerned and often adversely impacted by the current traffic congestion in
[2:10:35]
this area. This distribution center would exacerbate such concerns as well as impede timely access
[2:10:41]
us to essential facilities, EG, Rital Hospital, Rocky Run Fire Department, Senior Living
[2:10:48]
Care. Further, I strongly believe that a warehouse distribution building would not be
[2:10:54]
an asset to our community which mitigates any potential tax revenue. This area has already
[2:11:00]
been overdeveloped and with high density housing. I sincerely hope that the Township Council
[2:11:06]
will have the foresight to recognize the long-term negative impact such development would
[2:11:11]
have on the lives of constituents and the environment.
[2:11:15]
Thank you very much.
[2:11:34]
Okay, name.
[2:11:49]
Sure.
[2:11:50]
No problem.
[2:11:56]
Thank you.
[2:11:58]
Okay.
[2:11:59]
Are we going to go?
[2:12:01]
Yes.
[2:12:02]
Name is Becky Barnard.
[2:12:05]
B-E-C-K-Y-B-A-R-N-A-R-D.
[2:12:09]
I live at 4.11, New Middletown Road, or Lyme Estates, the other retirement community.
[2:12:21]
Hi, guys.
[2:12:25]
I wasn't going to speak, but my big concern is about the ordinances and
[2:12:39]
regulations that outrigger claims to be an accordance with. My big concern is when were
[2:12:47]
those ordinances and regulations written and enacted? Because I'm sure they were written
[2:12:57]
way before. A lot of things have happened since, as you know. So until that ambiguity is
[2:13:05]
clarified, and there have been other ambiguities.
[2:13:11]
I would say no, no, no way. Thank you.
[2:13:26]
Hi, my name is
[2:13:27]
Yolanda Torres, Yolanda YOLANDA, Torres T-O-R-R-E-S. I live at 231 Black Hawk Court. I've lived in this
[2:13:38]
community for about 10 years. Totally love this community. Clean, beautiful, lots of greenery,
[2:13:45]
friendly people. This is all stands to be threatened right now. If this warehouse gets to be built.
[2:13:53]
There are so many points I would like to hit, but let me start first with words matter.
[2:14:00]
And if you take the statements or presentations made by this company, you will find a ton of escape
[2:14:08]
patches like necessarily, necessarily, conservatively 200 trucks. Are you kidding me? We all know it's
[2:14:20]
more than 200 trucks. They stood up here and said 200. We all know that's not true. I would love for
[2:14:29]
somebody to investigate further as to the true number. The other thing, PM 2.5, which is responsible
[2:14:38]
for multiple deaths, increase risk of strokes, increase risk of asthma, increase risk
[2:14:47]
of other pulmonary diseases. It is terrifying. Right now, our air quality is in a dangerous level,
[2:14:57]
Due to particles
[2:15:00]
Coming from Canada. Imagine particles coming from our own neighborhood. Can you imagine? Can you imagine? I have young grandchildren that visit me. Thank God they're all healthy. But could they end up developing asthma because they come to visit grandma? My husband is a pulmonary patient.
[2:15:28]
who is on multiple medications because of the air quality the past few days
[2:15:33]
I told them you're not allowed to go outside unless you wear a mask and he's
[2:15:39]
doing really well his pulmonologist thinks he's doing fabulous I think he could
[2:15:43]
do better but I can't even imagine what will happen in this warehouse gets
[2:15:50]
built here we live in a community with multiple retirement homes that have
[2:15:58]
multiple health issues. We are going to increase their risk of dying, not just
[2:16:05]
theirs, but ours too, of dying of a heart attack, of having strokes, of having
[2:16:10]
pulmonary issues, shorten all our lives. And what is the biggest contributor of
[2:16:17]
PM 2.5? Vehicles, especially trucks, gasoline, diesel, all of that, and don't
[2:16:27]
believe for a second that it's 200 trucks. That is an outright lie and we all know it.
[2:16:34]
You're not fooling anybody.
[2:16:38]
Please vote against this measure. This community needs you to protect us. Thank you.
[2:16:46]
Hi,
[2:16:53]
my name is Marianne Coyva, and I am at 132
[2:17:02]
West 7th Street in Mediaboro, but I am in the RTMSD resident and parent as well.
[2:17:11]
And frankly, this is climate change. This is exactly how it happens. I'm dealing with it in my backyard.
[2:17:18]
And also, you know, we we re after membership to the Y right over here again this year, but that is the only time that I come into middle town. I actively spend less money because I know I'm going to be sitting there at the lights.
[2:17:34]
And right now traffic is light because everybody's down the shore.
[2:17:37]
So, the traffic right now is not what is typically there as you all know.
[2:17:43]
I also do have asthma, and I take one injection, two inhalers in allergy medicine, and it's
[2:17:51]
still not well controlled.
[2:17:54]
I did not have, I was not on anything for asthma before I moved here.
[2:18:00]
I also didn't have breast cancer until I moved here.
[2:18:03]
could be other things, sure. But the air pollution and the water pollution here are just out of control as other people have already said.
[2:18:15]
I respectfully and genuinely also invite the outrigger folks to please come and sit at the intersection at 5.30 on a Wednesday after Labor Day, because that is when our kids are back in school.
[2:18:32]
That is the real traffic and try to get home from there quickly.
[2:18:38]
That is why I do not go into Middletown much if I can help it.
[2:18:43]
And respectfully earlier, it was also a few comments were made in the beginning
[2:18:49]
by that team to counsel and that they have to put this project through.
[2:18:55]
I have heard many consultants and groups say exactly the same thing in exactly the same ways.
[2:19:01]
They all say it very similarly and in minimizing language also.
[2:19:07]
Council is here for exactly this reason in each one of our towns, for exactly this, for
[2:19:13]
the interest of the people that vote you all here and get you here and keep you here.
[2:19:21]
So please, please vote no for your residents and for those of us in the area.
[2:19:28]
We live here. Outregor does not. Thank you.
[2:19:39]
My name is Leslie. L-E-S-L-I-E.
[2:19:41]
Campo, C-A-M-P-O. I live at 210 Black Hawk Court. I was not intending to speak so
[2:19:48]
I have nothing in front of me but first I want to say this is not the Lehigh Valley.
[2:19:53]
This is not Aston. This is not Brumall. This is not Marcus Huck. This is Middletown.
[2:20:05]
Welcome to Middletown. Secondly, Ms. Klein, I'm not sure if it was you, but I'm going to guess it was.
[2:20:12]
I'm remembering listening to a traffic engineer sometime between 2012 and 2015, who told us that it was a D.
[2:20:20]
I'm sorry in F, at the intersection of Route 1 and 352, Penal Road and Marin Road.
[2:20:28]
And I remember at that time people being very upset about that and saying,
[2:20:33]
why would we want to be an F? Why are we aspiring to that? And the thing is we are still an F,
[2:20:41]
but it's only because there's nothing past an F. There's no such thing as a G or a Z.
[2:20:47]
So it has gotten worse from those days in 2012, 2014, 2015. And in addition to that,
[2:20:55]
I did spend some time and I have nothing in front of me looking at your study from 2015 and comparing
[2:21:01]
it to 2025. And I am not a traffic engineer, I'm a retired fifth grade teacher. But in
[2:21:07]
reading it, the language was very different. Like, I believe it was in 2015 when they talked
[2:21:14]
about the intersections. And it was the main ones, it was Route 1, Baltimore Pike, it was
[2:21:19]
352, Barron, and Pennell. When they talked about them, they talked about them, they gave
[2:21:26]
how many cars were going in each direction but then I believe it was in the 2025 it was how many
[2:21:33]
cars total. So it was really hard to compare those numbers and again I don't have it in front
[2:21:38]
of me so I might be getting it reversed. Also the word vehicles was used in one instance but vehicles
[2:21:45]
and then it was it was stated in 2025 that it would be less vehicles but more trucks and I think
[2:21:51]
I don't know how many vehicles equal a truck, four or five, who knows?
[2:21:56]
But just so, I, I as a layperson, found it very confusing to read that data and it would
[2:22:05]
be great if it was put out in something that lay people could understand and use the same
[2:22:11]
terms in all the studies.
[2:22:12]
Don't change it from 2015 to 2018 to 21 to 25 because I really found that confusing.
[2:22:18]
That's it.
[2:22:19]
Thank you.
[2:22:19]
My
[2:22:25]
name is Andrea Beakner, B-U-E-C-H-N-E-R. I live at 204 Northbrook Drive. I've
[2:22:32]
been a Middletown Township resident for 35 years now and I've been to
[2:22:38]
several of these meetings and I've listened to the presentations and I'm
[2:22:43]
convinced more than ever that the burdens of the project of this Outrigger
[2:22:50]
project significantly outweigh the benefits.
[2:22:54]
In addition to the pollution concerns, my biggest concern is traffic and the congestion
[2:23:03]
that the 200 trucks and additional vehicles will compound the problems of an already
[2:23:14]
stressed route 1 and related arteries. I'm concerned about the pipeline and the stress
[2:23:23]
that that will take with countless numbers of vehicles going back and forth over it every
[2:23:30]
single day.
[2:23:33]
And I'm also concerned about the impedement to emergency vehicles and getting
[2:23:40]
to and from people that need their help to hospitals and you know and just serving, serving
[2:23:50]
the community. So my hope is that the Township Council will act in the best interest of
[2:23:58]
its residents that it serves and oppose this project.
[2:24:08]
And I would ask that you put your
[2:24:09]
with thumbprint on someone else's community.
[2:24:20]
Richard Shaw, 754, Switchman Road.
[2:24:24]
That's RICH, ARD, S-H-A-W.
[2:24:30]
I want to make comment on two things,
[2:24:33]
the location that's proposed and the highway situation.
[2:24:39]
You know, we all are really enamored
[2:24:42]
with our inter-life styles of having warehouses
[2:24:45]
isn't the benefits that come from them and having them close.
[2:24:51]
And I've read a bit about Outrigger online
[2:24:55]
and a person in Suzanne Paysley also provided some statistics
[2:24:59]
and just been looking at the website.
[2:25:01]
And Outrigger is a great warehouse company.
[2:25:04]
You're building a lot of warehouses.
[2:25:06]
And Mr. Hendricks, you mentioned the situation and how
[2:25:11]
when you go to some of the other locations around here,
[2:25:13]
you can see warehouses that are actually backed right up to developments and and and and dense housing.
[2:25:20]
And I think, you know, somebody said this, made comments about this.
[2:25:26]
That doesn't mean that that's the way things should be.
[2:25:29]
And that's not something that this town wants to have.
[2:25:33]
When you look at the numbers behind it, it's not something that we can tolerate.
[2:25:40]
And in terms of just looking at the Outrigger website, Outrigger lives that.
[2:25:46]
They don't have any situations that are like that on their website.
[2:25:50]
We have 16 warehouses that are highlighted.
[2:25:53]
They may have more than that, but in none of those backup to housing developments.
[2:25:59]
There are three of them, one in Houston, one in Grand Prairie, Texas, and Santa Freight Springs,
[2:26:05]
California that are fairly close, but none of them are remotely as close to
[2:26:10]
developments as this one would be. And so I just like you to think a bit
[2:26:15]
about that.
[2:26:18]
The other point has to do with the highway situation. And there are
[2:26:26]
two major roads here, there's U.S. 95 and there's, what is it, 6.4.4.4.7.6, there you go.
[2:26:42]
And you know, both of those are just a little bit over six miles from this location.
[2:26:47]
And when you look at what Altreger has been building, none of their locations are anywhere
[2:26:52]
near that far from a controlled access highway.
[2:26:58]
They're typically right on controlled access highways.
[2:27:01]
For example, the example that Mr. Henderson gave down in Aston.
[2:27:04]
I'm sorry, that wasn't an overgaure warehouse.
[2:27:06]
But warehouses are generally located close to this.
[2:27:09]
Not six miles.
[2:27:12]
And when you look at the proximity of what we have,
[2:27:16]
there was discussion about the emergency plan for ambulances
[2:27:22]
and such. This is not a place that really lends itself to having these long stringed
[2:27:28]
stringed out things before you get to the major highways where warehouses should be intended.
[2:27:34]
Outward your bill builds most of their warehouses. It's 16 only for that time.
[2:27:39]
Okay, time is still.
[2:27:49]
John Collegious, K-O-L-I-C-I-U-S,
[2:27:53]
two, one, two, south, old middle town road, middle town township, and I'm a
[2:28:00]
professional engineer. I'm a volunteer member of the Environmental Advisory
[2:28:04]
Committee. Our committee had prepared something for presentation to
[2:28:09]
council, but we were advised not to present it to council because we had never
[2:28:13]
been formally charged by council to do a review of this project, so I'm
[2:28:18]
speaking as a private citizen. And looking at a lot of the things I look to
[2:28:23]
several of the reports and so many places, different consultants use different numbers,
[2:28:28]
nothing adds up. A perfect example. Mr. Henderson, oh, this is going to be limited hours,
[2:28:34]
maybe eight, ten hour shifts, one shift today. Well, the traffic study says 200 trucks with
[2:28:41]
the AMP of 11 and a PMP of 13 trucks. Well, if it's a ten hour shift, that's averaging 20
[2:28:49]
20 trucks an hour. It's not 11 or 13. Secondly, Mr. Henderson stated, we're going to get local
[2:28:58]
businesses that are in properties that aren't supporting them right. Well, are they going to
[2:29:04]
pay higher rent to want to move? And if you can't rent it to them, who are you going to rent to?
[2:29:10]
So then in one of the reports, I saw that the managing firm doing a lot of the work without
[2:29:16]
outrigger is a real estate investment trust called Centres Industrial and right on their
[2:29:23]
website, their investment strategy, aggressively targeting investment and development opportunities
[2:29:29]
to facilitate last mile delivery through the state of the art warehouse and distribution
[2:29:34]
facilities.
[2:29:35]
Well, we're speculating, we're not going to build that here because that wouldn't fit our
[2:29:39]
profile, but certainly fits their profile.
[2:29:43]
and beyond that if you don't rent it to them are we better off with an empty
[2:29:48]
warehouse because nobody wants your building they didn't want to hear you
[2:29:53]
think there's going to be public backlash as somebody moves into your building
[2:29:56]
that they don't want to work with these tenants
[2:30:00]
Please vote against the person here.
[2:30:11]
All right, my name is Dave Caskella, D-A-V-E, A-A-S-K-E-L-A. I don't live right by this site. I live all the way over 352, just off Baron Road. But I drive this area a lot. Okay. I have, I'm 74 years old. Okay. I have COPD.
[2:30:39]
I've been over 50 years in the building and development business.
[2:30:44]
I'm educated as an architect.
[2:30:46]
I work as a senior inspector for a large engineering firm, nationwide engineering firm.
[2:30:55]
I didn't bring consultants with me today.
[2:30:59]
I didn't bring
[2:31:04]
reports with me today, but I took a few notes on my phone while I listened
[2:31:10]
to these gentlemen and ladies. And there were some things that struck me. All right.
[2:31:18]
Basically nobody mentioned Glingwood School. I have a grandson who's going to be starting there
[2:31:24]
in three weeks. I have another grandson who will be starting there in a couple of years.
[2:31:30]
All right.
[2:31:33]
It's very close to this site and things like a particular matter and
[2:31:42]
are concerned to me because I have COPD, well I don't think that necessarily your pound
[2:31:50]
a particular matter per day is going to exacerbate my COPD half a mile away, I don't think
[2:31:58]
it's going to help either.
[2:32:01]
I will say this because I've been to a lot of these things over the years.
[2:32:06]
The presentations are designed to be mind-dumming,
[2:32:13]
anybody agree?
[2:32:17]
And confusing,
[2:32:20]
so that people stop listening and they stop cogent arguments because they've
[2:32:28]
been talked over by the experts.
[2:32:31]
I will say previous unrealized plans for this site or any other site in this area are
[2:32:38]
irrelevant. Who cares what didn't get built before? It has nothing to do with this proposal.
[2:32:48]
This proposal stands very poorly on its own lack of merit.
[2:32:57]
PennDOT has number one, I don't believe
[2:33:00]
your traffic studies. I don't believe what the impact that you claim it will have minimal impact.
[2:33:07]
but Penn dot proposals for improvement of 352 and 452 have been in the works for many years,
[2:33:19]
I have gone nowhere yet, but eventually will further impact when that work is done.
[2:33:27]
The traffic in this area and 200 truck trips a day isn't going to help.
[2:33:34]
Stormwater management.
[2:33:35]
It's time.
[2:33:37]
My time is up.
[2:33:39]
Please, since everybody has recommended against this,
[2:33:44]
and the other, your own planning commissions, the county,
[2:33:48]
and everyone else has recommended against this, please do the right thing
[2:33:52]
and vote against it.
[2:34:08]
Good evening, everyone. My name is Stan Johnson,
[2:34:11]
J.O.H.N. S.O.N.
[2:34:12]
I live at 160 Kennedy Drive.
[2:34:15]
I'm very proud to be the president
[2:34:17]
of the organization known as No Warehouse at the Franklin Mint site.
[2:34:28]
I'm also the numbers guy
[2:34:29]
as you've been coming to these meetings.
[2:34:34]
One of the issues that keeps coming up is the number of
[2:34:38]
trucks and we're being asked to believe a number generated by Bowman.
[2:34:50]
On the township staff, you have
[2:34:53]
traffic engineer who has done an awful lot of work on this effort and in his
[2:34:59]
letter dated to 2725 when paragraph 4 he states very clearly the traffic
[2:35:06]
generation number should come from attachment G2 of Penn Dodd publication 282.
[2:35:13]
That results in a much higher vehicle count. I'm not a traffic engineer I can't
[2:35:20]
say what number to use, but I believe what your staff engineer says. I cannot believe
[2:35:27]
what Bowman says. And I want to close by thanking you, the members of the council that are
[2:35:33]
here tonight, for your service to our community. Your job is a difficult one. All four of you
[2:35:40]
I know are troubled by this decision. It's a difficult one. Most of you join council to have
[2:35:48]
a very positive impact on your community.
[2:35:52]
To make our town, middle-town township a better place
[2:35:55]
for your families, for our families and our neighbors, to create a positive and a constructive
[2:36:01]
legacy for you and for your families and for your town. Why else would you give so much time and energy
[2:36:09]
to council? The choice that you have to make is a complex one, and yet it's very simple. The answer
[2:36:17]
is vote no. We do not want this in our community, and I asked you, as members of council, to vote no.
[2:36:38]
Anton, KEN, T-O-N, Stucky, STU, C-K-E-Y, and I live at 143 Donovan Drive in Ponzej.
[2:36:47]
Didn't plan on speaking tonight. I'm not an engineer. I'm not a lawyer or an expert,
[2:36:52]
but I am a former advertising executive, and I know a few things about massaging messages
[2:36:57]
to server purpose. And I want to talk about a few things that I've heard in
[2:37:03]
several of these presentations that I've attended. One, regarding traffic, it's
[2:37:08]
very convenient to use generic numbers from a Penn.guidance document. I would
[2:37:13]
imagine if Outriggers as big as successful in their industry as they are, they
[2:37:18]
would have some statistics regarding traffic for their facilities, their clients
[2:37:22]
and sizes, that they could at a minimum provide a minimum and a maximum traffic
[2:37:27]
impact from their experience.
[2:37:30]
Sure, it's convenient to talk about larger numbers in a broader area and reduce the impact
[2:37:37]
of the 200 trucks specific to this location by spreading it out across the larger area
[2:37:44]
down to 476, 322 and so forth.
[2:37:48]
It is convenient to talk about minimal impact to the traffic areas without talking about the
[2:37:56]
specifics. 452 and 1 is currently 140 percent past the failure mark based off the study provided
[2:38:05]
by the outrigger team, and the addition of this facility would put it to over 150 percent past
[2:38:10]
the failure mark, and that was not mentioned. Regarding sound, it's convenient to state that the
[2:38:17]
sound report that they talk about mentions that vehicle operations are not considered as part of
[2:38:22]
compliance when large part of what their business does is bring in large
[2:38:26]
tractor trailer trucks, which make a lot of noise. They talk about mitigation,
[2:38:30]
but at night, however, as far as I'm aware, a truck makes the same amount of
[2:38:35]
noise at night as it does during the day.
[2:38:39]
Regarding air, it's convenient to
[2:38:42]
talk about the greater county and not focus on the impact to the local area,
[2:38:46]
despite local residents and experts providing data and studies that show that
[2:38:51]
that there is already noncompliance with the air quality here.
[2:38:54]
And so the gentleman at the beginning talked about your obligation to evaluate whether
[2:39:00]
this meets and complies with regulations.
[2:39:05]
As far as I understand it, traffic fails, they claim exemption from sound, they generalize
[2:39:11]
air quality without discussing immediate local impact and deferred to federal and state regulations.
[2:39:16]
Why? Because it's convenient to defer to federal and state regulations because that removes
[2:39:23]
the burden from the council to approve this, and it puts the regulation outside of the jurisdiction
[2:39:28]
of this group. That's some pretty good spin from my perspective, and I urge you guys to vote.
[2:39:35]
No, thanks.
[2:39:42]
Good evening. I'm Dr. Marilyn Howard. I'm not a resident, but I'm an expert for the
[2:39:47]
know-where-house non-profit group.
[2:39:51]
I have already submitted some comments in writing that I hope that you received on two occasions.
[2:39:57]
I'm an occupational and environmental medicine physician and I'm employed by the University of Pennsylvania, the Proman School of Medicine.
[2:40:05]
For years I've worked with, for 30 years actually, I've worked with patients to help them understand the nature of their symptoms and whether or not it's related to environmental exposures
[2:40:16]
And so I feel very qualified to assess this situation as I understand it here.
[2:40:22]
Based on my assessment of the health and safety of this proposal, I must urge you to reject
[2:40:29]
this project.
[2:40:32]
There are a number of key health issues that I just would like to summarize.
[2:40:36]
Many of them have been discussed today already.
[2:40:39]
The first one is doesn't sound much like a health concern, but it's about the number
[2:40:44]
of vehicles.
[2:40:45]
We've been talking with a number of trucks.
[2:40:47]
Cars have emissions too.
[2:40:50]
And that same calculator that everyone's talking about,
[2:40:53]
calculates 1,008 vehicles total for this size warehouse,
[2:41:00]
about 227 of them being the big trucks.
[2:41:04]
But these smaller vehicles that we aren't talking about,
[2:41:08]
many of them are also diesel.
[2:41:10]
And when you're parked at a light, waiting for the light to change,
[2:41:13]
That is called idling and when you're in that daycare center immediately adjacent, that's a big load
[2:41:20]
I don't care about the one pound per hour whatever that calculation was
[2:41:25]
Just imagine the children's noses within
[2:41:29]
2030 feet when they're outside of a lot of a long line of trucks and cars with this diesel exhaust
[2:41:36]
I don't want my child there and I don't want yours there either
[2:41:41]
The
[2:41:44]
county, the entire county is out of compliance with ozone as the National Ambient Air
[2:41:49]
Quality Standards.
[2:41:50]
And in fact, it will soon, as you heard from their expert, be out of compliance with
[2:41:54]
particulates as well.
[2:41:56]
Particulates are carcinogens largely.
[2:41:59]
In addition to their ability to cause asthma, worsen asthma, cause heart attacks.
[2:42:05]
And if someone here has a heart attack or a stroke, they have to wait 29 minutes for
[2:42:10]
the ambulance.
[2:42:11]
I'm telling you, that is not going to be a good outcome.
[2:42:15]
And then when they get to riddle hospital with a 40% increase in their volume, their
[2:42:21]
weight times are much longer than they ever have been just because of the closure of
[2:42:27]
Crosier Chester Hospital.
[2:42:29]
And so when you add that 29 to the long weight time, there is a reason why you have continued
[2:42:36]
your declaration of emergency.
[2:42:38]
And that plays exactly into this issue we're talking about here.
[2:42:44]
How can you, in good conscience, put knowing that your public is at risk from a health perspective
[2:42:52]
and issuing a declaration of emergency also agreed to increase the traffic.
[2:42:58]
This is an obligation of each of yours as trustees of the health and safety of your community.
[2:43:09]
And as a physician, I urge you all to reject this proposal just for that reason alone,
[2:43:17]
not to mention the fact that that outrigger has, you know, tried to threaten Dr. Penning
[2:43:23]
and me through our employers so that we stop testifying and that they have all these
[2:43:28]
other discrepancies that other people have raised.
[2:43:31]
I think all of those things speak to character, but I'm just speaking to health right now.
[2:43:37]
And on a health basis alone, they should not have this proposal, you should not approve
[2:43:41]
it.
[2:43:41]
My
[2:43:54]
name is Boben Desai, that's a D-E-S-A-I, 140 junction road media PA,
[2:44:06]
B-H-U, P-L-K-P-D-E-N.
[2:44:12]
So I hear everyone, you giving us three minutes, I don't remember you saying anything, any
[2:44:23]
time stipulation to them, they literally took hour and a half from start to beginning.
[2:44:30]
All those people, the study that they presented obviously are paid by them.
[2:44:35]
Just remember that note,
[2:44:39]
you need to listen to the people who elected you.
[2:44:44]
Would no for this project instead put a playground for the kids.
[2:44:51]
You have 300 new houses built in that area with a young population living.
[2:45:00]
With the little kids,
[2:45:03]
and you have a daycare open right there also. So what is the pollution
[2:45:08]
is going to do to all those little kids there? Traffic. I don't think any of these people
[2:45:16]
who presented live in a media. You need to go out in the morning and in afternoon. Traffic
[2:45:26]
from 452 route one south to the north. It takes literally 15 minutes to go one mile.
[2:45:36]
And then add this, the trucks to this traffic. And obviously you heard the truck numbers
[2:45:43]
started from 100 to 500 to 200. We don't know actually how many trucks going to be there.
[2:45:49]
So listen to the people and won't know.
[2:46:03]
Hello, I'm Julian Mihai, that's spelled I-U-L-I-A-N.
[2:46:08]
Yes, I-U-L-I-A-N.
[2:46:10]
Last name, M-I-A-A-I.
[2:46:13]
I leave at 749, switchman road.
[2:46:16]
One topic I wanted to talk about is the so-called tax benefit.
[2:46:21]
So I think as if my mental math worked well,
[2:46:25]
they call around 750,000 annual positive impact.
[2:46:31]
I think that what misses is the downside to that.
[2:46:35]
So if every single home loses value because of that,
[2:46:40]
if some of the retirement homes lose some residence,
[2:46:44]
what is that made from a lowering the tax revenue of the city in itself?
[2:46:49]
And then the other thing that doesn't mention is what are the alternatives?
[2:46:52]
So if, for example, I'm not an expert, a different type of cleaner business or if you would
[2:46:59]
to put 100 houses there, if that would be possible, well, 100 houses conservatively
[2:47:05]
with 10,000 annual tax, that's a lot more than what the so-called potential tax benefit
[2:47:12]
from this business is.
[2:47:13]
So hopefully somebody can run those numbers and if that's a factor in the decision-making,
[2:47:19]
we'll look at alternative so that it doesn't become one.
[2:47:22]
Thank you.
[2:47:29]
Hi, my name is Jason Zurwick. That's spelled J-A-S-O-N-Z-E-R-W-E-C-K. I live at 20
[2:47:37]
soldier song lane on the president of middle-town township land conservancy. It's hard to say what
[2:47:44]
hasn't already been said already. So I think the one thing that Outrigger has been consistent with
[2:47:52]
is that they haven't listened to the community.
[2:47:55]
And if they had, then community turnout
[2:47:57]
wouldn't have increased every meeting.
[2:48:02]
And I'm worried about that because as they find
[2:48:05]
a future tenant, if they aren't going to listen
[2:48:08]
to the community now, what guaranteed we have
[2:48:10]
that they'll hold themselves
[2:48:11]
and their future tenant accountable
[2:48:14]
for how our health and safety is affected.
[2:48:18]
In addition to that, I'm worried that the developers
[2:48:22]
are really kind of living in a living in the past. I mean, they're looking at old plans,
[2:48:28]
they're looking at warehouse designation that's part of an old zoning ordinance.
[2:48:35]
They're thinking about things before we were in a state of emergency, where we're having longer
[2:48:40]
wait times with the ambulances. And I think the estimates on truck turn around. Well, I mean,
[2:48:49]
And I think they're laughable on their face, but personally, I've been in product development
[2:48:55]
for the past 15 years.
[2:48:57]
I have over 40 patents to my name and a lot of the projects I do, a new product development
[2:49:04]
or warehouse automation, and you'd be amazed how fast you can empty some of these containers.
[2:49:11]
I mean, you don't need dozens of truck bays to do 200 trips a day.
[2:49:16]
and you can empty a truck in about 15 minutes.
[2:49:20]
So, while these developers might be stuck in the past,
[2:49:23]
I think that our community needs to look into the future
[2:49:27]
about, you know, what this could look like
[2:49:31]
five or 10 years from now and how we're gonna deal with it.
[2:49:49]
I'm Gwen Sides, they live at 2.19, Hunter Street.
[2:49:53]
I've been paying taxes here for Sides, SIDE, D-E-S.
[2:49:59]
I've been paying taxes here for 42 years.
[2:50:02]
I was 22 years old when we moved in.
[2:50:05]
Lots of things have happened.
[2:50:07]
The council has done a great job over the years with protecting all of us, including the people in this front row.
[2:50:17]
Before and after you get here, if you get here.
[2:50:19]
One of the things that I've seen is any of the other developments that we approve,
[2:50:27]
sitting with neighbors from Ponds Edge, I knew a kind of trim was going on there houses
[2:50:33]
before you guys approved anything. I don't even know what the building looks like.
[2:50:38]
What are we actually going to see when somebody comes to Middletown Township?
[2:50:43]
It passed the pretty bridge over the over Baltimore Pike. We knew what the terrain station was going to look like.
[2:50:51]
I said, hey, listen, they want to build 600 cars.
[2:50:56]
There's council wanted to put like 300. I said, let them build it for 600.
[2:51:00]
Hopefully it's going to work well and we're going to put people on the train and help work on this traffic problem.
[2:51:06]
So, one of the things, we all talk about 452 and 1 being an F. The issue is it's a volume
[2:51:16]
to capacity issue. You can't get 1,000 cars a minute past Glenwood school or in front
[2:51:26]
of the hospital getting on to the bypass. That's where the issues are with our traffic. It's
[2:51:31]
not at the corner. I know because I live at the corner. The loop road that was supposed
[2:51:39]
to be a great answer, oh, you're going to be able to get out of your street. So now
[2:51:45]
when the light turns red, so now when you get that gap, the loop road traffic fills the gap
[2:51:52]
and we can't get out of our street at all. So volume to capacity.
[2:52:00]
The other thing was, I sat in meetings where it was approved that we redo our comprehensive
[2:52:10]
plan.
[2:52:12]
The comprehensive plan wanted to put, okay, I wanted to put their building in the field
[2:52:20]
across the street from where you want to put your building, but the comprehensive plan
[2:52:25]
said that they were supposed to be in the complex what there used to be the
[2:52:33]
quarry where the mall was. When all the way to the State Supreme Court didn't
[2:52:38]
comply with the comprehensive plan, then you can go to the Acne today because of
[2:52:44]
it. Does this meet the comprehensive plan? I was in the audience twice when we
[2:52:51]
updated that. I don't know what the status of that is, but I do know, at me, went all the way to the
[2:52:58]
States to the top, and they said, you got to do it. You got to comply with a comprehensive plan.
[2:53:05]
So they're my only thoughts. And I thank you for doing the job that you all do for all of us.
[2:53:19]
My name is Barbara Balada, B-I-R-B-I-R-A, Balada B-I-L-O-T-T-A. I live at 275 Linus School Court.
[2:53:27]
First of all, yes, I do want to thank the board for everything.
[2:53:30]
I don't think I've been to so many township meetings that I have in these last couple
[2:53:34]
years.
[2:53:35]
I won't keep any one's time, but my question is, is why would a company spend this much
[2:53:41]
time and this much money to be somewhere where they're not wanted?
[2:53:47]
Thank you.
[2:53:54]
My name is Pamela Slinenko.
[2:53:57]
Pamela Slinenko, the last name is SLA and I NKO.
[2:54:01]
I live at 120 Riper Road. That's in Ponce. And I want to say, I settled on my home this past
[2:54:08]
November. And if I had known there was a warehouse going in, I never would have moved here. I didn't
[2:54:15]
even know about the hotel that was going in. Envy homes didn't tell us much.
[2:54:24]
I was told nothing would
[2:54:26]
ever be behind my home because of the pipeline. I think things are changing a little bit from
[2:54:31]
what I heard this evening. And I'm just going to end up with every day I do my own traffic study.
[2:54:40]
Seven days a week, all during the day and in the evening. And my study shows the congestion
[2:54:47]
is very bad and very dangerous. That's it.
[2:55:03]
I thought it was the last one. All right. My name is Ryan
[2:55:07]
again, Feldman, 525 East St. Andrews Drive,
[2:55:11]
I'm a resident at a Dupet Axis, F-E-L-D-M-A-N.
[2:55:18]
So I have 20 years of experience in real estate development
[2:55:21]
and I have a master's degree in city planning.
[2:55:25]
I do have, before I move forward,
[2:55:27]
I have a procedural point of inquiry.
[2:55:30]
Am I permitted to pose questions directly
[2:55:32]
to the applicant and their experts?
[2:55:35]
So the intent of the public comment is to make comment if you have questions, you can say where your questions are when council members have a chance to pose our questions.
[2:55:44]
So hopefully the link will be great.
[2:55:46]
We are taking all the public comments and questions.
[2:55:49]
Right. Well, since they're not available directly for questions, I guess I would implore.
[2:55:59]
Council to ask them to please confirm for the record when the baseline traffic counts were taken.
[2:56:06]
And if they were taken during the pandemic, we're adjacent to the pandemic when vehicle counts were substantially lower.
[2:56:12]
Please do ask that directly. Okay, it's my fear that these counts may be artificially low, in which case these numbers are more meaningless than we already feel.
[2:56:23]
So, as previously stated, the post-construction impact studies, they have no real enforcement
[2:56:31]
teeth.
[2:56:32]
Okay?
[2:56:33]
Once it's approved, there's no recourse from middle-town.
[2:56:38]
The horse is out of the barn.
[2:56:40]
It's over.
[2:56:41]
We're not going to go back, okay?
[2:56:43]
Now is the time to protect ourselves, all right?
[2:56:47]
So if the developer is so confident in the very small scale, the small scope and the small
[2:56:55]
scale nature of their eventual attendant. I would like counsel to please ask directly.
[2:57:00]
Would they be opposed to posting a $25 to $30 million bond? To be released, once the
[2:57:07]
tenant has been in place for several years, pending the results of independent traffic
[2:57:13]
studies, okay?
[2:57:15]
Because once they get the approval it's over. So please do ask them that.
[2:57:20]
that. Finally, I just want to speak directly to Council. Thank you for serving. We all appreciate
[2:57:27]
the work that you do. Okay. We really do.
[2:57:32]
But I just want to say I want everyone in this
[2:57:36]
room to understand. They have a really tough job because unfortunately,
[2:57:44]
they can't just
[2:57:44]
say no because we don't like it. Okay. If it came down to what we like, it's pretty
[2:57:51]
open and shut. They can't just say no. All right. It doesn't come down to our passions
[2:57:57]
of what we want. We don't want it comes down to what is allowable. Okay. So let's be
[2:58:04]
honest and truthful. If you deny this, we just might get sued. The township might get
[2:58:10]
sued because of illegal takings. That's what happens. Okay.
[2:58:18]
Okay. I just want everyone
[2:58:20]
want to realize that and I also want the Township Council to realize that if we get sued,
[2:58:27]
we're behind you.
[2:58:31]
We're behind you.
[2:58:47]
Please do what we all want. Do what is actually right
[2:58:53]
by the zoning ordinance. There's enough gray area in this running ordinance. This is not
[2:58:59]
but this is not the compliance with zoning, okay?
[2:59:03]
Have you ever seen a meeting this well-offended?
[2:59:08]
No.
[2:59:09]
So if and when we get to it, if you guys say no,
[2:59:13]
we have your back, we will remember how you guys vote, okay?
[2:59:19]
Thank you.
[2:59:29]
Sorry.
[2:59:31]
My name's Craig, C-R-A-I-G, Mutatees, M-U-E-T-T-E-R-T-I-E-S.
[2:59:40]
I live on Martin Selain, and I constantly hear amulets.
[2:59:46]
You speak into the mic, but I don't think so.
[2:59:48]
I constantly hear amulets behind my house, because of the closure of closure.
[3:00:00]
And you know, closure went down the tubes because venture capital went in, and venture capital
[3:00:12]
poisoned it. And I sat here tonight and looked at Outreger Industrial, and there are two
[3:00:20]
major partners, their investors, are Davidson, Kemper, Capital Management, and
[3:00:30]
Monarch Alternative Capital. Capital Management. You've been screwed once. I
[3:00:40]
think we're about to get screwed again. I recommend that we not okay this. We live
[3:00:50]
in a wonderful community. It takes me a week to go out route one now. I'm 77 years old.
[3:01:01]
I don't have that much more time to drive.
[3:01:12]
I'm Ted Rob or OBB 1343 West Baltimore Pike.
[3:01:20]
Page 10 of the paperwork for the meeting tonight says, unless council votes tonight,
[3:01:27]
the project will be deemed approved.
[3:01:33]
No, that would not be the case.
[3:01:34]
So it's so with this being August 6th.
[3:01:38]
That's a potential extension is offered by the applicant.
[3:01:40]
Has August 30th.
[3:01:42]
So the current deadline is August 20th.
[3:01:45]
I beg your pardon?
[3:01:46]
The current deadline is August 20th.
[3:01:49]
That's what I said.
[3:01:49]
Unless I was going to say unless
[3:01:53]
you take unless council takes action before August 20th,
[3:01:58]
the project will be deemed approved.
[3:02:02]
Please vote tonight.
[3:02:05]
The applicant wants waivers.
[3:02:07]
You are under no obligation to give waivers.
[3:02:13]
Please don't.
[3:02:16]
The project will enforce no right turn on printer's way
[3:02:20]
and no idling by posting signs.
[3:02:27]
Who will do the enforcing, Mr. Alvo?
[3:02:30]
Will you be standing there printer's way? Will the environmental expert be there
[3:02:37]
shining people for idling? Middle-town township has no police. Who is going to
[3:02:43]
do the enforcing?
[3:02:47]
Their air quality problems we've heard discussed. We don't need
[3:02:51]
more particulate matter. Please vote tonight. Thank you. You ran for this.
[3:02:59]
Congratulations on being elected.
[3:03:05]
Thank you for your service.
[3:03:17]
Right, so at this time, we have reached the end of the public comments before moving
[3:03:21]
out.
[3:03:21]
It did want to clarify the last statement as far as the August 6th versus August 20th.
[3:03:27]
The applicant has granted, and by mistake, by all means, please correct me.
[3:03:32]
The applicant has granted an extension through August 20th for action by council on this.
[3:03:39]
There was no other issue passed that, there was no extension grant to pass that.
[3:03:44]
If we don't act on it at that time, it does default to deemed approval.
[3:03:49]
Correct.
[3:03:50]
We have no extension passed August 20th.
[3:03:53]
So I just wanted to clarify that point.
[3:03:55]
At this point, I'm just trying to take a temperature here as far as need for any particular fight.
[3:04:02]
So at this point, we'll consider public comment period ended.
[3:04:06]
I would like to take a five-minute recess, so folks can maybe utilize the facilities and
[3:04:12]
such.
[3:04:13]
Before we proceed to the point where council members and such can ask our questions and
[3:04:17]
have some further dialogue before we progress, any issues with that?
[3:04:23]
So folks, at this time, we'll call 10-10.
[3:04:27]
Take a five-ish minute recess to 10-15.
[3:04:30]
Okay.
[3:04:31]
Thank you very much.
[3:04:31]
As
[3:04:55]
I say that we're missing some key folks up here, so stand by.
[3:05:15]
All right folks, welcome back.
[3:05:18]
So with the public comment period and having concluded, we're now going to go ahead
[3:05:23]
and it's the opportunity for Council to ask our questions, post-concerns, and so forth.
[3:05:31]
and to be able to dialogue a little further before we move forward.
[3:05:35]
So, I want to open it up to my colleagues up here as far as questions that they may have for the applicant.
[3:05:47]
This is a question for the traffic study.
[3:05:50]
What constitutes a value change to be significant?
[3:06:05]
So, PennDOT has very specific rules and regulations for development traffic impact
[3:06:12]
And they are related to the level of service grades that I talked about in my presentation,
[3:06:18]
and the associated vehicle delays.
[3:06:22]
So in summary, Pendants Rules are, you cannot degrade the level of service from without
[3:06:32]
development to with development conditions, so you can't drop a letter grade.
[3:06:37]
Or if you do drop a letter grade in level of service, the increase in vehicle delay
[3:06:44]
under 10 seconds does not require mitigation.
[3:06:50]
Over 10 seconds does require mitigation.
[3:06:55]
So the 46% decrease in level of service moving from B to C
[3:07:06]
At the intersection of U.S.-1 and Penal Road does not constitute a significant traffic
[3:07:11]
impact.
[3:07:12]
I would have to see the specific numbers that you are referencing, percentages are
[3:07:16]
not.
[3:07:17]
Let's look at those numbers then.
[3:07:18]
Let's do it.
[3:07:27]
Mr. Stumpall, you're looking at that just as a follow-up, Ms. Klein.
[3:07:30]
So does Penn Dott's guidance provide any guidance, if you will?
[3:07:36]
If there is no further letter grade to go, as we heard earlier, some of the intersections
[3:07:40]
are already at an F-grade.
[3:07:41]
If there is nowhere else to go, lower than that, is there any guidance that
[3:07:47]
pendop provides on whether or not that impact? How do you reassess or reevaluate
[3:07:51]
that impact? The 10-second rule would also apply to that letter rate. Thank you.
[3:07:57]
May I approach to see what you're looking at or you
[3:08:11]
can say what? Yeah, so I
[3:08:12]
can do my best to explain what we're looking at here. So there are a series of
[3:08:18]
tables within our traffic impact study that for each study intersection lay out the individual
[3:08:25]
movement level of service letter grades and the associated average vehicle delay that
[3:08:30]
goes along with that letter grade.
[3:08:32]
So through those tables, you're able to look at each intersection and see first of all existing
[3:08:37]
conditions which are based on 2025 new traffic counts.
[3:08:43]
Then we project to future without development conditions that incorporates a regional background
[3:08:50]
growth rate and committed developments in the area that are approved and not yet constructed
[3:08:56]
and occupied.
[3:08:57]
That's our baseline condition.
[3:09:00]
And then we add on to that our site traffic and that is the with development conditions.
[3:09:05]
So I'm just trying to step through what the table shows and those are the three columns.
[3:09:10]
So, PENDOT's mitigation rules for development traffic impacts that I explained apply to the
[3:09:18]
comparison of without development to with development.
[3:09:22]
Existing is just baseline.
[3:09:23]
It does not come into the comparison.
[3:09:26]
So the two columns that were required to compare are without development to with development.
[3:09:32]
So as an example, a particular movement has been circled here.
[3:09:38]
It is the westbound through movement on Route 1 at the intersection with Route 452.
[3:09:44]
And the example here, the results show in the weekday afternoon peak hour, the baseline
[3:09:51]
existing level of service for that movement is a B as in boy with an average vehicle
[3:09:57]
delay of 15.5 seconds, that's just the baseline.
[3:10:00]
With out development conditions, that movement goes to a level of service C with 21.8 seconds of average vehicle delay.
[3:10:11]
That's our baseline for pen nut mitigation rules.
[3:10:15]
Our with development level of service is still a level of service C. Right there, no mitigation required per pen nut.
[3:10:24]
Now, we still do give the average vehicle delay, it's 22.6 seconds, so the difference
[3:10:31]
in average vehicle delay from without development to with development is 0.8 seconds.
[3:10:39]
There's no level of service drop and there's a very minimal change in average vehicle delay,
[3:10:44]
per pendent rules, no mitigation improvements required.
[3:10:48]
So that's how you read the table.
[3:10:54]
struggle a little bit, and again, this is not necessarily a question, but the quantitative
[3:10:59]
pieces of it are all very relevant.
[3:11:02]
The problem for me is translating the quantitative into the qualitative, because as a 15-year resident,
[3:11:08]
I can tell you that I've never spent a minimum of 15 seconds delayed at that intersection.
[3:11:21]
Is there any way to translate those quantitative values into the qualitative impact?
[3:11:27]
I know this is an overarching study of or an overarching comment on just qualitative versus
[3:11:32]
quantitative, but is there a way to speak to the qualitative impact of those numbers?
[3:11:37]
So if you look at other movements in the intersection and the intersection as overall,
[3:11:44]
when you look at those tables, the level of service letter grades and the delays are provided
[3:11:49]
for each movement, but then there's also an overall intersection letter grade given.
[3:11:54]
The intersection of R1 and 452 is a level of service F overall in the morning and in the afternoon for all conditions.
[3:12:05]
So, and if you look at individual movements, you will see significant failures.
[3:12:10]
That is not the criteria that we have to meet with PANDOT at state road intersections.
[3:12:16]
It's the change. It's not the baseline.
[3:12:19]
Yes, understood.
[3:12:20]
How is the baseline different than the non-developed?
[3:12:23]
So you would assume or at least I assume probably incorrectly is if it's non-developed, is
[3:12:28]
that not the baseline?
[3:12:31]
Not for the mitigation rules.
[3:12:33]
It's the baseline for the traffic study.
[3:12:35]
We do counts on the street.
[3:12:37]
It's real conditions.
[3:12:38]
That's our existing conditions.
[3:12:40]
But the mitigation rules, we as a developer, the developer does not have to solve existing
[3:12:46]
problems.
[3:12:47]
It's not their responsibility, it's not being caused by them.
[3:12:51]
And that's why Penn Dodge rules are based on without development versus with development.
[3:12:57]
Thank you.
[3:12:57]
Yes.
[3:12:58]
With the mitigation rules relating to the change, the US-1452 intersection, the eastbound
[3:13:07]
at the top, for the left turn, going from without development to with development does go
[3:13:14]
from a B-A-D-O-S-C.
[3:13:15]
in the morning, but it's less than 10 seconds, so we are still not required mitigation for that particular movement.
[3:13:24]
So it has to meet both.
[3:13:26]
Correct.
[3:13:27]
First, if there's no letter grade change, you don't even look any further.
[3:13:32]
If there's a letter grade change, your developers allow to increase the delay by up to 10 seconds before the mitigation requirement comes in.
[3:13:42]
And as I mentioned during my presentation, there are some movements that, you know,
[3:13:47]
were called out in the traffic engineers' letter, and we will have to discuss those with
[3:13:51]
PennDOT.
[3:13:53]
So just building on that.
[3:13:54]
So the traffic study, and I want to put this, there were a number of questions from the
[3:13:58]
residents about the number of trucks and truck trips.
[3:14:02]
These numbers are not actual numbers.
[3:14:03]
These are the PennDOT recommendations for speculative, non-occupied warehouses.
[3:14:09]
Is that correct?
[3:14:10]
They are the PENDAQ required trip generation numbers for speculative warehouse.
[3:14:14]
Yes.
[3:14:15]
I go back to the question of Outriggers been in this business for an extended period
[3:14:20]
of time.
[3:14:21]
A warehouse of this size is that consistent with, below, above, the traffic numbers that
[3:14:27]
you're seeing in other locations, how does the PENDAQ requirement match up to Outriggers'
[3:14:35]
own real-world experience?
[3:14:36]
So, I can speak to two points, one my own experience 23 years as a traffic engineer, I've
[3:14:42]
worked on many industrial projects, including many speculative warehouse projects.
[3:14:48]
This has become, you know, a pretty common development practice, and is why, as I mentioned,
[3:14:54]
and has implemented some post study requirements.
[3:14:57]
The benefits of doing those posts are
[3:15:00]
These, as we do get real data. And PennDOT has gone out on their own and done trip generation studies on their own at sites that have been built in Pennsylvania. This guidance is based on that. So it is based on real world data and not just anywhere in the country. It was, PennDOT did a pretty extensive study within the past few years and it demonstrated that this approach is accurate to what is being built. I can speak to my conversations without rigor.
[3:15:29]
and they also have been very comfortable with the traffic numbers and they expect to stay under them.
[3:15:37]
So as it relates to public safety though, are there impacts different rules for significance?
[3:15:48]
Because the intersection in question is right next to a fire department, the Rocky Run Fire Department,
[3:15:54]
as well as right up the road from one of now two hospitals in the county.
[3:16:02]
Now that we just heard in the beginning of this meeting,
[3:16:05]
and I realized that it's the position of the applicant
[3:16:07]
that they're not responsible for that, and that's fine.
[3:16:09]
But we are responsible for that.
[3:16:11]
And so there needs to be some considerations.
[3:16:16]
I do understand the concerns when it comes to the Pendant Highway Occupancy Permit process.
[3:16:21]
the development world is regulated on a level of service and delay.
[3:16:28]
I just have a follow-up question. So you mentioned about the post-approval or I can't
[3:16:33]
remember the term, you used the post-development study? Post-development study.
[3:16:36]
In your experience, the 23 years that you mentioned, have you seen where a post-development
[3:16:40]
study has actually increased traffic and what's been the recourse in that example?
[3:16:45]
I have never had a project show traffic higher than the traffic impact study
[3:16:51]
at a level that required further study. A trip here there has happened on occasion, it was not
[3:16:57]
an industrial project, but I have not experienced a post-development study that required additional
[3:17:05]
analysis and evaluation of improvements.
[3:17:10]
So let me pose this, though. If the post-development study
[3:17:13]
did show significant impacts, what steps at that point could be taken to mitigate that, to
[3:17:22]
You know, to reflect people's concerns as far as, oh, you know, once the cap's out of the bag, once the horse is out of the barn, what could be done to adjust that?
[3:17:30]
Could you give some examples of steps that would be taken at that point, if such a, you know, such degradation took place?
[3:17:39]
I can and I would like to give the two examples as I presented, you know, there's the Pendant regulations and there could be a township condition.
[3:17:47]
On the pen dot side, they have, they hold the rights of the highway occupancy permit.
[3:17:53]
And so they have the ability to revoke a highway occupancy permit if these condition
[3:17:58]
statements are not met and carried forward.
[3:18:01]
So that is the control at the state level.
[3:18:04]
Within any condition of a post study within the township, it would be our recommendation and
[3:18:11]
I do believe your traffic engineer would agree with me, he can speak to it.
[3:18:14]
But we would want the condition to be very clear.
[3:18:18]
I have seen them done a couple of different ways tied to some level of financial commitment
[3:18:24]
should, you know, that be required or, you know, tying it back to Pendant is common,
[3:18:36]
you know, when it's all state roadways like it is in this case as well.
[3:18:40]
So kind of trying to close that loop.
[3:18:42]
So, those are the ways that I've seen it most commonly done, is that there's kind of
[3:18:47]
a vision for what improvements could make sense, given additional traffic, and so there's
[3:18:54]
some forethought put into it so that that's built into the condition.
[3:19:01]
So with such steps, though, actually improve the situation at that particular intersection
[3:19:09]
that might be at issue, or is it more a matter of collecting funds to improve safety elsewhere in the township?
[3:19:18]
Or are there steps that could be taken that would actually improve that condition that degrades?
[3:19:23]
That would typically be the way it would be focused.
[3:19:25]
And certainly, Penn dot wouldn't have the ability to collect monies and then have it applied elsewhere.
[3:19:31]
It has to speak directly to the impact.
[3:19:33]
So it would more commonly be tied to, you know, the specific impact itself versus, you know,
[3:19:40]
being broad.
[3:19:43]
And as our traffic engineer, do you have anything further to say to that as far as any
[3:19:49]
elaboration?
[3:19:50]
I would say that, as Nicole said, we are, there's going to be coordination with PennDOT.
[3:19:57]
They do have the teeth as far as the post-development study.
[3:20:02]
It is ultimately they could revoke the highway occupancy permit as sort of the, I don't
[3:20:11]
know, worst case scenario, or you know, if the improvements couldn't be made to satisfy
[3:20:15]
PennDOT, they do have that right to do that.
[3:20:19]
I don't see a lot of examples if any where that has really happened because usually something
[3:20:26]
can get worked out.
[3:20:27]
Well, as Nicole said, as well, usually the post-development study doesn't end up showing such an increase over the volumes that were in the traffic study that was done before the development was built, such that additional improvements would be required as a result of the post-development study.
[3:20:49]
So, you know, to speak to Ms. Klein's points about the trip generation that was done for
[3:20:58]
speculative warehouses, they are in their most recent traffic study.
[3:21:02]
They did do the correct procedure based on the Penn Dot requirements and it's just a
[3:21:08]
matter of what actual tenants come in here, but that's what the Penn Dot procedure is
[3:21:16]
supposed to guard against, so.
[3:21:27]
Thank you, Miss Fine.
[3:21:31]
I have a question from Mr. Alivo.
[3:21:33]
So you mentioned in your presentation,
[3:21:35]
and a couple of times we highlighted the Sonoco pipeline.
[3:21:39]
And you quoted in your statement as saying,
[3:21:41]
we have approval, but then said we need to get approval.
[3:21:45]
Have you gotten guidance variance approval from Sonoco
[3:21:51]
around making any changes or building
[3:21:54]
on top of the pipeline?
[3:22:02]
Regressively
[3:22:06]
represented from the McKee Group is not here tonight, but I thought they do
[3:22:12]
have approval to cross the pipeline.
[3:22:14]
What they want at the end is show exactly how much cut and fill is being placed in those
[3:22:21]
areas, but they have approval to cross it.
[3:22:25]
And so they do have an approval to make the crossing.
[3:22:27]
It's the final design. They do have to do some testing and everything and get that and submit that back to the
[3:22:36]
Pipeline people to get the final approval. Do you know if that approval has been submitted to our our engineers?
[3:22:44]
That I don't know
[3:22:46]
Have you
[3:22:49]
It's it's a letter it's a
[3:22:52]
It's I haven't received anything of the pipeline. I thought he had we have a
[3:22:59]
We do have a general approval easement from the pipeline.
[3:23:07]
We have the ability to cross it.
[3:23:10]
But they need to see has Chuck noted the final design for this particular project.
[3:23:17]
And that's in the works and that obviously is like any other third party permit
[3:23:20]
that would be a condition of the plan approval just like all your other third party agencies.
[3:23:26]
So, if it's been in your possession, why hasn't it not been submitted, because it's been an outstanding question from our engineers regarding that the details, the correspondence, any feedback from the Sonoco correspondence, because we haven't seen any of that.
[3:23:42]
And it's been an outstanding issue for quite some time.
[3:23:45]
I had thought that it was addressed in our last response letter to the July second response.
[3:23:52]
All
[3:24:00]
right, so in the absence, in the absence of that, we don't have, saying we have the
[3:24:05]
general approval, we don't have any detail as far as how the, what steps are going to
[3:24:12]
be taken there, what snuggle would the specifics of what snuggle would require, how the risks
[3:24:19]
to the different, the different, um, development you want to do in the right away, we don't have
[3:24:25]
have any specifics to how the risks to developing the right away would be addressed.
[3:24:31]
We can certainly provide you with the agreement that we have to date if it hasn't been.
[3:24:35]
We had thought that it was submitted to the township.
[3:24:44]
Pending that, the risks of the driveway, understand the explanation as far as why the driveway
[3:24:51]
needed to go there versus another liquid.
[3:24:56]
What has been looked at regarding the risks, as far as the repeated traffic trips and such
[3:25:03]
over the driveway. How has it been assessed the risk of the pipeline regarding the repeated
[3:25:10]
weight, the possible settling of the top soil and such there as far as with the pipeline?
[3:25:18]
Because this pipeline issue has been of grave concern in this community for years,
[3:25:23]
especially given the contents of this specific pipeline in the area. So that is of concern knowing
[3:25:31]
the details of how those risks are being mitigated and the specifics of what Sonoco is requiring.
[3:25:36]
But beyond what Sonoco is requiring, how those risks are being mitigated.
[3:25:40]
That would be with a geotechnical engineer that we would show and then show the thickness of
[3:25:48]
paving and everything and how far. Again, it depends on the depth of the pipes and how far they are
[3:25:55]
from the bottom of the base to the top of the pipes and we would ensure that that would not
[3:26:01]
Decrease of what's across there today and prove to them that the wheel loads
[3:26:09]
Will distribute enough so that it won't affect their their pipeline again
[3:26:13]
They've this isn't the first crossing that they would have in the area. So they want to see
[3:26:20]
want to see the
[3:26:23]
Type of painting and everything thickness of stone and and everything to spread the load out over the pipeline
[3:26:29]
So
[3:26:33]
this isn't the first build out over the pipeline right away as far as new construction or road going over this pipeline in our community.
[3:26:41]
That I don't that I don't know.
[3:26:47]
And it goes around one was already there when the pipeline was about so the pipeline went under wasn't a new construction on top of it.
[3:26:54]
So the other could do you know and maybe you can't speak to this but was the approval that you're speaking of and referencing from Sonoco was that referencing the old frost project approval?
[3:27:03]
or is this something specifically to this particular application?
[3:27:10]
Without, I don't know that the fine details on that, they do, there's an...
[3:27:17]
The details matter here.
[3:27:18]
I understand that, and you're asking, what we're trying to do is get the approval
[3:27:24]
of where the road can go and then we can finalize the details
[3:27:28]
because if we move the road forward or backwards
[3:27:33]
words, or I'm going to say north or south, it changes what happens to the roadway.
[3:27:40]
I completely understand that, but it's August 6th.
[3:27:43]
This application was submitted at the end of November of end of last year.
[3:27:47]
I ask you why that information has not been obtained and presented to this Council for
[3:27:52]
evaluation.
[3:27:59]
We've since confirmed that agreement was submitted with
[3:28:04]
Third submission.
[3:28:10]
Is it the agreement with the frost application or is the agreement with the outrigger application?
[3:28:18]
It's a property level agreement based on what development going in there.
[3:28:22]
Does that open?
[3:28:26]
It's for the property as agreement.
[3:28:28]
It's in the open key group.
[3:28:32]
We're crossing the easement.
[3:28:34]
We're crossing the get-crossing easement.
[3:28:35]
So, my understanding is we don't have anything from Sonoco, acknowledging this particular development.
[3:28:43]
We have it.
[3:28:44]
Please use the microphone.
[3:28:46]
I'm sorry, we have it for the property, it's for the McKeepe.
[3:28:49]
Can you provide your name and your role in position?
[3:28:54]
Ben Moore with Outrigger Industrial.
[3:28:59]
So, if you're representing Outrigger but you're speaking on behalf of the property owner.
[3:29:05]
property owner is not here, so well that so it doesn't give you the right to speak on behalf. No?
[3:29:15]
Folks, so we do have the the lady who is trying to record this, right? She needs to be able to hear what people are saying.
[3:29:23]
I appreciate the concern and the passion behind this, but she doesn't need to be able to hear what's being said. Thank you.
[3:29:31]
It was just a statement of whether or not there's an authority to speak on behalf of the property owner.
[3:29:36]
The property owner was intending to be here this evening, and while he was in route, his wife had a fall, so he couldn't make it this evening, but he has represented us to us that there is disagreement which was, as I mentioned, submitted with the third submission.
[3:29:54]
So the township does have that. We're happy to provide it to again if you can't find it.
[3:29:59]
So, I think
[3:30:00]
That submission is fine. What the professionals have asked for is specific documentation from Sonoco regarding this particular development. Right. And it's kind of this catch 22 that we're talking about in order to finalize the design of everything and work with Sonoco. We need to move forward with this process first, but that has been in the works. I know the land owner has been coordinating with Sonoco with that. And as I mentioned, it's it's certainly something like any other third party.
[3:30:29]
agency that could be a condition of approval.
[3:30:33]
I mean, it's just like your PEN-DOT or your MPDES permit.
[3:30:35]
If we don't obtain that, then we can't fill the project.
[3:30:40]
But, Michelle, skin number of times, especially at the beginning of tonight, you mentioned
[3:30:46]
the fact that this was just a preliminary land development plan submission and really
[3:30:52]
called out the fact that it wasn't being done as a preliminary slash final land development
[3:30:56]
application, as in your experience you said most of these situations are, are you prepared,
[3:31:01]
would you be prepared to submit a preliminary final land development application?
[3:31:05]
It sounds like there's a lot missing that would be required of a final.
[3:31:09]
There's a lot of details. You mentioned that a number of times, calling up the back that this
[3:31:14]
was not being allowed to proceed as a preliminary slash final.
[3:31:16]
Yeah, that wasn't my intention. I was saying we're only here for preliminary. That's what I was saying.
[3:31:20]
I made one statement earlier on that typically the Township has reviewed them concurrently as a preliminary final and my statement was made in the context of saying that your professional consultants have throughout this process been very thorough in their reviews and have mentioned a number of items that are really more typical for final, but they've captured it with our reviews. That was the only reason I was stating that.
[3:31:46]
So given that one item, it highlights to me a question that I'll throw to one of our professionals of what other potential outstanding items have not meant have not been met to your satisfaction from a, are there anything that's outstanding from an engineering professionals perspective?
[3:32:07]
Obviously, the Sonoco issue, excuse me, is one of them that we've been asking for information
[3:32:14]
since the beginning, since the very first review on this and had hoped to get some kind
[3:32:19]
of feedback from Sonoco on this particular layout because everything that we have in our
[3:32:27]
possession from the applicant is related to an agreement with McKay and Sonoco and with
[3:32:34]
exhibit showing the frost development which is not this development. So we've been asking
[3:32:39]
for that. That's one thing that I have stated in my letter I recommended be accomplished
[3:32:46]
before preliminary approval so we can make sure that that whatever impact if there is
[3:32:52]
any adverse comments from SNCCO about the crossing that that could be handled before a preliminary
[3:33:00]
approval. So that was the one recommendation I made. Another area that's been, you know,
[3:33:07]
that's in our review and it talks about the Park and Recreation and Open Space and, you
[3:33:16]
know, whether or not Township wants to take a fee in lieu of or whether the Township wants
[3:33:22]
other more specific Park and Recreation facilities, which the ordinance requires, if Council
[3:33:28]
So choose is to request that that's another area that I would say is hasn't been very developed there hasn't been a lot of conversation back and forth about what council might want to see what do you think council wants to see et cetera et cetera all along it's been well we'll just pay the fee in lieu of that's kind of the approach we're taking and as I understand it I don't know that that the town that council wants a fee in lieu of and I don't know that.
[3:33:57]
that a credit can be taken from the Franklin station development and applied towards this
[3:34:03]
development and that those are legal issues but I'm just saying there hasn't been much
[3:34:07]
development around the park and recreation issue and then another one would be the issue
[3:34:14]
of the lot having frontage on a public street or a street with access to the public and trying
[3:34:22]
trying to get established some language about access to that parcel that's being proposed
[3:34:31]
that has the access, that has a flag where a piece that touches a road, a quasi-public
[3:34:39]
road, but there is no physical access through it.
[3:34:42]
So part of what we've been asking for is an easement to allow whoever ultimately owns that
[3:34:50]
property to freely access it for whatever purpose they choose. And what we've gotten so
[3:34:55]
far is language that's very specific to certain things and not more broad, which I would
[3:35:03]
expect that you would need in order for, let's say that the parcels dedicated to the township,
[3:35:09]
the township would want to have access through the outrigger parcel to get to this parcel and have
[3:35:16]
have access for anything that the township desires to use that parcel for.
[3:35:20]
So that's another area that has been discussed since the beginning, that still hasn't really
[3:35:26]
been nailed down at this point.
[3:35:36]
If I could just respond briefly, I mean, we had thought we did address that issue with
[3:35:42]
a lot, by providing an easement, showing it on the plans.
[3:35:46]
So that was our understanding that that issue had been resolved.
[3:35:49]
regarding the fee and loo. I mean we've never been advised by the township that council wanted the open space and we've always sit all along like most of the other developments that have come before you that we would pay the fee and loo or you know get the credit which my understanding from the property owner and based on prior approval for the Franklin station that there is a credit available that that would run with the entirety of the track that may be used as a credit for this particular project again
[3:36:22]
that's a legal issue that
[3:36:24]
that between the legal people and council has the right to ask for a fee in lieu of or allow a fee in lieu of or ask for other specific park and recreation facilities or land as part of a large development like this.
[3:36:40]
And so thus far the conversations around this haven't been very specific as to what do you think the township wants.
[3:36:49]
That's what it's been more of, we're just going to pay the fee in lieu of and take a credit for things that we've built in Franklin Station.
[3:36:59]
That's been the primary, in my opinion, the primary focus of the replies related to the Park and Rack and Dedication of Land, et cetera.
[3:37:08]
And as far as the other issue goes, the easement language that we've been asking for, again, is not broad.
[3:37:14]
But it's very specific to certain, a very few uses that would be permitted within the easement.
[3:37:22]
And it does not allow general public to access vehicularily or
[3:37:28]
it's limited to emergency services access, public works, and pedestrian foot traffic.
[3:37:35]
And that's a very specific language for an easement note to be quite honest with you.
[3:37:40]
So I don't have in front of me the correspondence, but can you speak to have you have you had conversations or have you sent official questions back and not gotten the accurate responses and then felt like has there been a dialogue back and forth to address these or is it just kind of died on the vine?
[3:37:59]
There has been, the review letters have asked for this easement under the context that we
[3:38:05]
need this easement in order to make this parcel viable because it's not physically accessible
[3:38:09]
through the flag part of the lot.
[3:38:11]
The premise all along has been the easement has to allow full access for all types of activities
[3:38:19]
and uses so that whoever owns the parcel can go through that easement on Outriggers property
[3:38:25]
to get to this parcel.
[3:38:26]
The language thus far has been, that's been offered has been very specific as to not include the general public, for example, through the use of a motor vehicle.
[3:38:40]
Should the township, should this land be offered to the township, the township would likely consider using it to create a trail connection.
[3:38:49]
The only thing that that easement language thus far has allowed is emergency services, foot traffic,
[3:38:57]
by pedestrians.
[3:38:59]
And I forget the third thing, but it's not general.
[3:39:02]
It's not general public works.
[3:39:06]
Thank you.
[3:39:06]
And just to speak to the requirement.
[3:39:08]
So it was asked of John Grant.
[3:39:13]
As far as the access easement or request to provide an easement for the access drive
[3:39:19]
in the rear, the things that were put in the back there, we put the pedestrian sidewalk
[3:39:24]
going across the back so we said it would allow for pedestrian use in the back.
[3:39:28]
One of the reasons we were not permitting or residential traffic through theirs because
[3:39:33]
the road is blocked off by borrowers to prevent non-emergency vehicles from going using this
[3:39:40]
as a through road.
[3:39:42]
So opening it up to residential, vehicular traffic that doesn't go anywhere doesn't make
[3:39:48]
make sense. This is not something that we'd be opposed when we go into final design to continue
[3:39:54]
to discuss, but we've been working on this access road across the back that we want to limit
[3:40:00]
vehicular traffic to keep it from going to Franklin Boulevard, but if there's borrowers
[3:40:07]
at the back to keep trucks out of there, then it kind of complicates things.
[3:40:18]
We're trying
[3:40:18]
to 16 feet, so it's the minimum required with to get an emergency vehicle through there.
[3:40:25]
If we wanted to remove the bowels, that was requested by the township.
[3:40:29]
We thought we were appeasing the township by making those changes, so it's, again, we'll
[3:40:36]
continue to work with you on final.
[3:40:37]
We thought we were providing what you wanted there.
[3:40:39]
We provided access for public works to get back there to access the, if the trail system
[3:40:44]
is constructed, we are providing access pedestrian access along the walkway or the sidewalk there for
[3:40:50]
the residents to access it. That was asked for, and I believe that was the third review,
[3:40:57]
and we added the notes into the next submission there providing that access easement.
[3:41:02]
The notes aren't sufficient. We'll work with you on as we move into final design. Again,
[3:41:07]
we're looking for preliminary design. We didn't expect all the legal, you know, finalized documents
[3:41:13]
it's on the access easement to be completed at this time.
[3:41:18]
The point of the comment was that it's not a viable lot if the general public cannot
[3:41:24]
access the lot.
[3:41:26]
If the town should own the lot and accept it the language of that easement, outrigger
[3:41:32]
could come back later and say, well, we don't want you bringing the general public in here
[3:41:37]
through vehicles to go to a trailhead.
[3:41:41]
The point of the issue is that the easement allows the lock to be viable, therefore the
[3:41:49]
easement has to be brought enough to allow all uses possible.
[3:41:54]
And I thought that was pretty clear, but perhaps it wasn't.
[3:41:58]
And I think that's the crux of my question, which is not necessarily the granular detail
[3:42:03]
of the response, but the lack of clarity of the response between the two parties.
[3:42:08]
And that to me is the concern because you're asking us to make a decision on something that quite frankly we have parts of the information both from the Sonoco piece and these other pieces that we've just discussed.
[3:42:21]
So unless concerned with the details but more in the fact that we haven't gotten alignment between the professionals between the applicant and the township on a number of issues.
[3:42:30]
But yet we're being asked to make a decision on behalf of this application and for these
[3:42:36]
residents on missing information, not missing information, but missing information.
[3:42:42]
I mean, respectfully, we don't think it's a number of issues.
[3:42:48]
It sounds like it's two issues, one of which we thought was resolved.
[3:42:51]
This is the first I'm hearing about this this evening that there is some confusion and perhaps
[3:42:55]
it's on our end.
[3:42:58]
But in terms of the pipeline, that, again, that is a third-party agency permit, and the
[3:43:03]
township does not have the ability to hold up our plan based on those types of issues.
[3:43:24]
I have a couple of other questions.
[3:43:25]
I just want to see first if okay,
[3:43:29]
to our experts, what other outstanding issues are there?
[3:43:37]
I know there is an issue of zoning, there is an issue of a lot-line, I'm aware of.
[3:43:42]
Can we let we touch touch on those particular issues and flesh those out?
[3:43:47]
Because to your point, Mr. Olskie, it is not just two issues. It is not just two outstanding issues.
[3:44:09]
Mr. McLean, or Ms. Moreno, could one of you speak on the zoning points?
[3:44:14]
I think we need to get into this one now.
[3:44:20]
The zoning piece related to the parking. So the township during its review of the SU1A zoning district
[3:44:27]
to the applicant, the parking provisions for the overall district and with the comprehensive
[3:44:37]
zoning update, the township's opinion is that the current, the new zoning, the parking
[3:44:45]
for the related to the new zoning would apply to the lots that are not developed and are
[3:44:57]
We are still not
[3:45:00]
We're satisfied with what we received in the concept plans related to complying to the parking
[3:45:07]
requirements for the SU-1A district. So the applicant feels as though they can, they're
[3:45:13]
entitled to use the parking from the former zoning of that SU-1A, the township's opinion
[3:45:22]
and the opinion of our solicitor is that the parking falls under the new comprehensive zoning update.
[3:45:32]
So, it's the obligations of duty or the burden of the applicant to demonstrate to us that they can meet the provisions in the zoning in terms of the gross floor area in terms of other
[3:45:49]
other parcels that are undeveloped for future retail or future grocery or future office that they need to satisfy parking requirements and what's been submitted in a concept plan and a subsequent review by
[3:46:06]
We've determined that the applicant hasn't met the burden of demonstrating that they're meeting the parking under the new zoning update, which we believe is the new parking requirement.
[3:46:25]
And this is an issue that was raised for the first time after our third review of this project.
[3:46:31]
And again, this is, this is an item that the landowner through its council, Kristen Camp, has been handling.
[3:46:37]
And as I mentioned, unfortunately, he couldn't be here, but I am familiar with the letter that she submitted in response to the solicitor's letter.
[3:46:44]
And they feel very strongly and I agree that the law is on our side on this issue.
[3:46:50]
I mean, you can't pick and choose which ordinances to apply.
[3:46:53]
We're vested under the old ordinance and therefore you can't review the plan in a vacuum
[3:46:58]
and pick, you know, what you're applying this ordinance to that ordinance.
[3:47:01]
It has to be the ordinance that this plan is being reviewed under, it's a track by plan.
[3:47:07]
And we feel comfortable with our position, with Chris and Cam's position, that the parking,
[3:47:16]
as shown on the concept plan should be utilized under the old ordinance and therefore is compliant
[3:47:23]
with your old ordinance, which is what we are bound by for this particular project.
[3:47:30]
Has there been communication between our solicitor on this with Miss Camp?
[3:47:36]
Because that was his opinion differs from Miss Camp and his recommendation to us is based on that.
[3:47:42]
So there has been communication back and forth between the township and township solicitor and Miss camp on this issue.
[3:47:51]
And like I had mentioned, the review that was completed by our solicitor, his opinion is that the parking falls under the new zoning ordinance, not the old zoning ordinance.
[3:48:04]
Thank you.
[3:48:07]
There is another issue I do want to address, but before we get into that, I would ask you.
[3:48:14]
The Planning Commission has recommended us to recommend it to us not to
[3:48:18]
prove this. What do you feel are the changes or issues that you have addressed or
[3:48:24]
resolved in the time since our Planning Commission voted not to recommend a
[3:48:30]
approval? Well it's hard for me to answer that because the Planning Commission gave
[3:48:34]
absolutely no basis for the reason for their recommendation of denial. In fact I
[3:48:38]
tried to stamp up and ask them and I was hollered and booed and told us to sit
[3:48:42]
down and the meeting ended.
[3:48:44]
So I have no idea what the basis of the planning commission's recommendation to deny the
[3:48:49]
plan.
[3:48:50]
I will say I know everyone's mentioning the county also recommended.
[3:48:54]
The county review letter is the same exact review letter that they issued for the frost
[3:48:59]
project when they recommended that plan be denied, but yet the council still approved that
[3:49:03]
one.
[3:49:06]
So in the course of the meeting, the planning commission meeting, given like the questions
[3:49:10]
that were asked or-
[3:49:11]
They didn't answer any questions.
[3:49:13]
There were very few questions.
[3:49:18]
John, do you want to revisit the summary that you received that at least summarized some
[3:49:24]
of the reasons?
[3:49:25]
And we didn't receive a summary of that either, so I'd love for you to share that with
[3:49:29]
us.
[3:49:36]
And to be clear, as far as to give the planning commission credit, they are not legally
[3:49:41]
required to provide reason for their recommendation or not.
[3:49:46]
We certainly want to know, have some information to move forward on.
[3:49:52]
Right, and they are not required to provide it, legally.
[3:49:55]
We are,
[3:50:00]
I figured in the course of the planning commission meetings and such that it would have been apparent with what the issues might have been.
[3:50:11]
So in the summer that was provided reasons for the planning commission not recommending approval.
[3:50:20]
was the planning commission felt that outriggers application was incomplete due to the failure to seal their plans, pursuant to the township code and failure to present accurate lot lines.
[3:50:33]
They believe that it's imperative that outrigger accurately present the lot lines in a full form so that it may be appropriately analyzed.
[3:50:42]
To this point, some planning commission members felt that outriggering and its consultant team were unable to answer basic questions,
[3:50:48]
affecting their analysis of the application such as the number and type of
[3:50:52]
tenants, the traffic, and the type of business operations. The lack of
[3:50:56]
response from Outreger was a cause for concern. Some members were concerned
[3:51:00]
about the volume of business that would likely be conducted at the proposed
[3:51:03]
warehouse. Further, the planning commission believed that the application did not
[3:51:07]
match the purpose of the zoning district nor did it match the purpose of the
[3:51:11]
township's comprehensive plan.
[3:51:21]
And none of those comments were conveyed to us
[3:51:23]
Yes, nor were there any questions relating to those?
[3:51:27]
Do you feel in the course of the planning commission meeting that those issues were not
[3:51:31]
weren't apparent?
[3:51:33]
We did agree to do a survey, and that's actually in the works.
[3:51:37]
Even though, again, that's never been required for any other preliminary plan in this township
[3:51:43]
where we're actually a preliminary final plan.
[3:51:45]
Usually you don't seal them until the time when you go to record them.
[3:51:48]
But we agreed to do that. We told the planning commission. We would
[3:51:52]
agree to do a survey and have the plan sealed the preliminary plans. You're referencing the issue of the lot line
[3:51:58]
Parme you're and you're referencing the issue of the lot line the first issue that mr. McMollan mentioned about the plan being not sealed
[3:52:06]
So fundamentally, what does the seal mean?
[3:52:10]
What does having a plan sealed mean? What do what does that seal actually stand signify signify?
[3:52:16]
Probably better for a survey or engineer, but I mean, it's something typically that isn't done until you get to
[3:52:23]
The post final plan on an answer to the question
[3:52:26]
What does the seal signify from the actual architect or whoever's drawing up that plan? What does that seal mean?
[3:52:34]
I'm assuming it means the accuracy of the plan
[3:52:39]
Can you repeat that I didn't understand
[3:52:42]
Pardon me?
[3:52:43]
Can you repeat that?
[3:52:44]
I didn't.
[3:52:46]
Go ahead.
[3:52:51]
The engineer and he can explain.
[3:52:52]
I'm just asking what you stated.
[3:52:54]
I didn't hear what you said.
[3:52:55]
Did you say it determines the accuracy of the plan?
[3:52:58]
Yes.
[3:53:00]
So formalizes the accuracy of the plan.
[3:53:03]
Correct.
[3:53:05]
I'd like the plan is in question as far as being sealed is the subdivision plan.
[3:53:12]
and setting the proposed property lines down on the project.
[3:53:15]
Those lines have been shifting slightly here and there.
[3:53:18]
The original plan, we bumped it out.
[3:53:20]
Property line extended in other four acres
[3:53:22]
I believe in the back because we thought
[3:53:24]
we might need more area for stormwater management
[3:53:27]
as our design went on, that area moved up.
[3:53:31]
There's also easements that get established
[3:53:33]
during the design process that establish
[3:53:35]
where we have to have various utility easements,
[3:53:39]
stormwater easements.
[3:53:40]
Those all get placed on the plan.
[3:53:42]
The only plan that we did not have signatures on, I believe, was the survey plan because
[3:53:47]
the survey plan, the subdivision plan, not the land development plan, but the subdivision
[3:53:52]
plan.
[3:53:53]
It wasn't going through preliminary plan stage, we didn't have that property line set until
[3:53:59]
very late in the plan.
[3:54:00]
Now we brought on an independent survey that's doing the outbound survey of the property to
[3:54:05]
We established a toll property, the proposed outrigger property, the area for the open space in the back, but that's in progress right now, but that's the only plan that was not signed, again, was had to do with the subdivision, not the land development.
[3:54:24]
So I'll ask our professionals, do we require or request that we have sealed documents from previous applicants that have been stated that we don't request that or require, that is not a requirement for the township?
[3:54:37]
Well, the statement was never, I think it was never or doesn't typically or something
[3:54:42]
strong like that.
[3:54:43]
And that's just not accurate.
[3:54:44]
There have been other subdivisions that have gone through preliminary that have had
[3:54:48]
the professional seals on.
[3:54:50]
There's no question about that, 100%.
[3:54:52]
So in your professional opinion, what do those seals mean to you as a professional?
[3:54:58]
To me, it just indicates that the professional who's preparing to plan looked at it and agrees
[3:55:03]
to it's accuracy whether you put the stamp on the plan now or then there should be some level
[3:55:09]
of oversight. Obviously there was an issue with the existing features plan. I mean that's
[3:55:15]
undeniable. I can't smooth that over and that should have been caught. It should have been caught.
[3:55:23]
In my opinion.
[3:55:26]
And that was communicated. We did. It was affected one plan sheet which
[3:55:33]
in terms of what Eric's talking about, the sub division plan sheet, which had no impact on anything with the proposed development, there's 43 plan sheets.
[3:55:43]
Quite frankly, we wouldn't even need to create a sub division, we wouldn't do, we could do a condominium, and then this wouldn't even be an issue.
[3:55:50]
But you're not.
[3:55:51]
No, we're not.
[3:55:52]
Right, so please don't bring up hypotheticals that don't exist.
[3:55:56]
Can
[3:55:59]
we speak to the lot line issue at this point, as far as the number of acres in the
[3:56:09]
current proposal, the submission, there is an issue of the lot line.
[3:56:16]
Can we get into that?
[3:56:20]
I would defer to the Township Engineer for the to describe the lot line.
[3:56:25]
Yeah, basically the crux of the issue is that the plan that was submitted included an existing features plan that
[3:56:32]
Didn't have accurate lines on it and didn't and didn't show the entirety of a parcel which
[3:56:39]
It does did not show I'm sorry did not show the entirety of the parcel that was being subdivided. So it showed
[3:56:47]
two existing a showed part of one existing parcel another existing parcel
[3:56:54]
both of which didn't exist in the form that they were shown and in essence what was there was
[3:57:02]
one parcel that was being proposed to be subdivided into two instead of two with changing a lot lines
[3:57:09]
two parcels going to two is what you would commonly call a lot line change that's how the
[3:57:15]
plan was submitted in essence and what it really is is a two lot subdivision. I don't disagree that
[3:57:23]
the repair of the plan is not complex. It's fairly easy, very easy to make the revision.
[3:57:34]
So in fairness, I will say that as much. That has that been done. It has been done. It was
[3:57:39]
submit on July 21st, I believe. And again, this was raised after our third review. We finally had
[3:57:47]
And then opportunity to sit down and figure out what was meant by this comment because
[3:57:52]
there was a lot of back and forth through paperwork and it just didn't make any sense
[3:57:56]
to us as it turns out it was just some very minor relabeling issues that were corrected
[3:58:01]
and resummit it to the township just like we've been doing with all the other comments we've
[3:58:05]
been addressing.
[3:58:07]
Does it affect the nature of the application?
[3:58:12]
It doesn't affect the development at all.
[3:58:13]
It only really affects the amount of the open space area.
[3:58:16]
but all the area in bulk calculations are based on the entire track, so it doesn't impact
[3:58:23]
any of the area in bulk requirements or anything shown on the zoning data chart.
[3:58:31]
Doesn't this have like a little bit more on the theme of missing information, though,
[3:58:36]
when this application was submitted, there was information. It just feels rushed.
[3:58:42]
I disagree. I don't think it's been rushed at all. I feel like there's been very thorough
[3:58:47]
overviews. There's been discussions at public meetings for the last over 12 months, even
[3:58:53]
before this application was submitted. I don't agree with you that it's been rushed
[3:58:57]
at all. This is a very normal give-and-take process for any land development. As your
[3:59:02]
solicitor even indicated in the letter that's posted on the website, it's not uncommon
[3:59:07]
to get a review letter that starts at 60 pages and it gets whittled down to 50, then 40
[3:59:12]
30 and 30 and there's a lot of back and forth give and take. There's a lot of communications
[3:59:17]
that happens. There's a lot of interpretations under ordinances. It's not uncommon at all
[3:59:22]
and certainly isn't rushed.
[3:59:24]
This isn't normal because you're trying to exist in a past zoning rule so that we do have
[3:59:34]
that under consideration and I do think that it leads to like conversations of like we
[3:59:42]
keep talking about good faith around disclosure of information, rushing information, not having
[3:59:49]
complete and updated traffic studies and still in those in question.
[3:59:54]
And then the lot line issue kind of just hoping it waves away because it's a 20 minute issue
[3:59:58]
It was a 20-minute issue.
[4:00:00]
You and this is a multi-million dollar project. Why, why wasn't that done? You want to talk about good faith. My client sat down and met with the township. Probably six months before the new ordinance was adopted to share this plan. The ordinance under which the entirety of the front commitment property was built has been in place for 20 years. And then the township decides to target this property because of this plan to rezone it.
[4:00:29]
to change the use.
[4:00:34]
Wasn't it, wasn't it 2018 when the,
[4:00:37]
it's, there was an update that.
[4:00:42]
Yeah.
[4:00:43]
Tell me about it.
[4:00:44]
I asked
[4:00:53]
John McMullen a number of times,
[4:00:55]
and had to keep asking John McMullen a number of times
[4:00:57]
to send me information and the happenings of the township,
[4:01:02]
legal and otherwise.
[4:01:03]
And I constantly had to go back to him to get that information.
[4:01:15]
If I request something, I have a right to that information and you, sir, you, sir on
[4:01:21]
12-4 of last year, talk about bias, you don't belong on this committee.
[4:01:29]
Okay.
[4:01:29]
All right.
[4:01:30]
You, sir.
[4:01:31]
You, sir.
[4:01:31]
No, no, no.
[4:01:34]
No, no, no.
[4:01:35]
Okay.
[4:01:36]
them.
[4:01:37]
I'll let Viviana hear me out.
[4:01:39]
Viviana, I need you to control your
[4:01:43]
control.
[4:01:43]
Sure.
[4:01:44]
And to communicate with respect
[4:01:46]
right now.
[4:01:46]
That's fine.
[4:01:48]
You, sir, showed significant
[4:01:51]
bias on 12-4 of 24.
[4:01:55]
Significant bias.
[4:01:57]
We have Viviana, you showed bias.
[4:02:00]
This is not good faith.
[4:02:02]
If you are referring to the comments
[4:02:03]
that were quoted in that memo, those comments were us responding to people coming to us
[4:02:12]
in public comment as they have every right to it at every public meeting we have, expressing
[4:02:17]
concern, saying something like we're on the same page when it comes to them expressing concerns
[4:02:22]
about traffic and air pollution such. That is me sympathizing with concerns. It has no bearing
[4:02:27]
on your application or the merits of your application, your twisting people's words.
[4:02:34]
We have, we take an oath, we have an obligation to the health, safe, safety, and welfare of
[4:02:41]
our residents.
[4:02:42]
And they also come to some public comment, we can speak to them that is no bearing on
[4:02:46]
our ability to judge the merits of your application which have been, you've already mentioned
[4:02:53]
how many months it has been to have these type of outstanding issues still in deficiencies
[4:02:58]
and to want to get to this point you went through the planning commission meetings as well.
[4:03:02]
That will process and there are still all these deficiencies in the application.
[4:03:06]
Maybe on when we when I met with you and John what you told me was you told me two things.
[4:03:11]
The first thing you told me is that you believed that this was a commercial corridor.
[4:03:16]
Those were your words. You said that John was present. You also told me and instructed me not to bring
[4:03:21]
up Amazon in subsequent meetings. Okay? Because I didn't think they had any bearing.
[4:03:27]
The previous, the previous, the previous, the conditions have changed there. It is a previously
[4:03:34]
submitted plan. I why we are moving forward on the merits of your application. And it is a
[4:03:40]
commerce recorder, but that has nothing to do with the zoning issues. You spoke to the
[4:03:45]
condition of use that had been, wasn't there at the beginning of the heaven added in?
[4:03:50]
It's, this was not the original, the original zoning for that commercial corridor.
[4:03:57]
It is.
[4:03:57]
Yes, it's a commercial corridor.
[4:03:59]
Okay.
[4:03:59]
This is beyond that.
[4:04:01]
So you believe it is a commercial corridor?
[4:04:04]
So you're telling the residents that the zoning, yes, this is well beyond that base issue.
[4:04:14]
Okay, so maybe on Facebook, you publicly stated
[4:04:18]
that our development falls under the zoning
[4:04:22]
that we applied under.
[4:04:24]
You said it.
[4:04:27]
Show me the specifics of that.
[4:04:28]
I got it.
[4:04:29]
Because you're talking about the warehouse provision
[4:04:32]
that was added, what are you referring to?
[4:04:35]
There are social media comments or a comment
[4:04:38]
that you made where you indicated
[4:04:40]
that our project falls under the zone
[4:04:42]
that it is permissible.
[4:04:43]
So the media comments of anyone have no bearing on this debate right now.
[4:04:50]
And he's trying to show bias and to negate or my point is that has no bearing on the merits
[4:05:00]
of your application having these outstanding issues and deficiencies. Whether it's a commercial
[4:05:04]
court or not, if your application is deficient, it's deficient.
[4:05:08]
Okay, so let's work through the balance and then you can vote.
[4:05:10]
So we have tried, we've gotten to this point after this many months, our experts have
[4:05:17]
tried to communicate with you and these outstanding issues still exist.
[4:05:21]
There's definitely a strong feeling of bad faith from our experts, frustrations surrounding
[4:05:29]
the lack of communication and lack of resolution of these issues.
[4:05:32]
Okay.
[4:05:32]
Well, we respectfully disagree.
[4:05:34]
We've had a number of communications with your consultants.
[4:05:36]
And at this point, are there any further questions from members of council for the applicant?
[4:05:47]
Do your experts want to raise any issues that haven't been addressed yet?
[4:05:59]
Okay.
[4:05:59]
At this point, I'm going to ask if there is a motion regarding this application.
[4:06:02]
I move to deny the application.
[4:06:15]
So at the start of this discussion, our responsibility was stated as a simplistic overview
[4:06:23]
of just rubber stamping a checkbox that was provided by the applicant.
[4:06:30]
Unfortunately, our responsibility here is not just a rubber stamp.
[4:06:35]
It goes beyond that to balancing the rights of the applicant, the rights of the residents,
[4:06:41]
and also the alignment with our overall township master plan.
[4:06:48]
As we've heard from discussions not only here today, but also from the Planning Commission,
[4:06:53]
this application has been viewed as incomplete and I concur.
[4:06:57]
In addition, there are a number of elements that are not in line with saldo.
[4:07:05]
The applicant has had a number of opportunities to provide responses to our experts, to address
[4:07:11]
the issues.
[4:07:13]
And as I've mentioned, this application was submitted in November.
[4:07:16]
We're now here in August with still outstanding issues.
[4:07:20]
With those comments in mind, I second the vote to reject this application.
[4:07:29]
Thank
[4:07:33]
you, Mr. Vialek. All in favor of the motion to deny the application.
[4:07:39]
Any opposed,
[4:07:40]
Farnett?
[4:07:42]
I want to just have a roll call vote to clear on the record.
[4:07:46]
Thank you. Mr. Stump, your vote.
[4:07:53]
I.
[4:07:54]
I.
[4:07:55]
I.
[4:07:56]
I. Motion passes. You deny the application.
[4:08:03]
And
[4:08:20]
on to our next item of the agenda would be approval of our bill list
[4:08:26]
rather
[4:08:27]
anti-comactic for those who want to stick around for this. The next item of the agenda
[4:08:30]
is the bill list for council from the Capital Reserve Fund to Patricon-Welman-Demica
[4:08:37]
and Brown for the Trid-Lenai Road Zoning flood plan in the amount of $10,605 to
[4:08:44]
to Richardee Pearson construction for the RFP number 10,
[4:08:48]
Mint Trails, Segment 1.
[4:08:50]
Folks, if you don't mind, we just do need
[4:08:51]
to get this recorded, okay?
[4:08:53]
And they amount of $207,575 for a total
[4:08:58]
from the capital reserve of $218,180.
[4:09:04]
Folks, folks, I understand we want to congregate
[4:09:07]
and have discussions, but we've got a recording
[4:09:09]
of these events that needs to be posturized.
[4:09:13]
So if we could just hold down the conversations, please.
[4:09:16]
Thank you. I promise this part of wrap up soon.
[4:09:20]
So for total from the Capital Reserve Fund of $218,180.
[4:09:25]
From debt service fund to the Bank of New York Mellon for loan to Midtown 2019,
[4:09:37]
I was going to do the abbreviation there on the amount of $52,285.
[4:09:44]
It is the bond, that's okay.
[4:09:47]
All right, so for the bond payment of $52,285, also to the Bank of New York Mellon, bond
[4:09:54]
payment of $380,000 for a total of $432,285.
[4:10:00]
From our escrow fund to DB Enterprise Developers for the 617 Creek Road lot number three in the amount of $15,918 to Kelli engineers and
[4:10:11]
surveyors for a main engineering escrow in the amount of $9,651 to Kelli engineers and surveyors as well for the June engineering escrow in the amount of $11,405 to McCormick and Taylor for our toll, the
[4:10:25]
I told brothers Franklin Station work in the amount of $6,750 to Thomas Committ associates for the outrigger acquisition of what is that referred to
[4:10:41]
for work for work for work on the outrigger acquisition plan the amount of $5,245
[4:10:47]
also to Thomas Committ associates for the work regarding outrigger in the amount of $5,471 for a total from escrow of $54,441
[4:10:59]
From our General Fund to Aqua Auto Pay for the Township Hydrants in the amount of
[4:11:03]
$9,078 to Arthur J. Gallagher Risk Management for our 2025-2025-2026 workers comp in the
[4:11:11]
amount of $42,756 to Barbacane Thorton and Company for the 2024 Rocky Run audit in
[4:11:18]
the amount of $6,750 to GO2 tech incorporated for May 2025 IT in the amount of $5,189
[4:11:28]
dollars to Kelly engineers and surveyors for a May engineering amount of $29,871 to Kelly
[4:11:35]
engineers and surveyors for June engineering in the amount of $24,382 to Optinaker,
[4:11:42]
June recycling in the amount of $52,705 to for credit card auto pay for the credit card payments
[4:11:53]
for our trips, parts and rec trips and amount of $7,631 to United Inspection Agency for
[4:12:00]
a June Electrical Inspections and the amount of $8,166 for a total from the General Fund
[4:12:06]
of $215,730 for a grand total of $920,637.
[4:12:16]
Do I have a motion for approval of the bill?
[4:12:18]
Thank you, Ms. Powell.
[4:12:20]
Do I have a second?
[4:12:21]
Second.
[4:12:21]
Second.
[4:12:23]
Thank you, Mr. Stum.
[4:12:24]
Mr. Beallick.
[4:12:26]
All in favor?
[4:12:27]
Hi.
[4:12:29]
Any opposed?
[4:12:30]
All right.
[4:12:30]
Motion passes.
[4:12:31]
The bill is approved.
[4:12:32]
And we are adjourned for the night.
[4:12:33]
Thank you very much for coming out.
[4:12:35]
Second with us, folks.