Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[1:57]
Welcome to the new Brighton Planning Commission meeting of September 15th, 2026.
[2:03]
First order of businesses to call the roll, Vice Chair, Eric Nelson.
[2:08]
Vice Commissioner Collins.
[2:10]
Commissioner Brian.
[2:12]
Commissioner Caper.
[2:14]
Here.
[2:14]
Commissioner Turner.
[2:16]
We have a quorum.
[2:18]
I need a next item on the agenda is the approval of tonight's agenda.
[2:23]
Can I get a motion to approve the agenda?
[2:25]
I moved to Approved 9th agenda, can I get a second?
[2:30]
I second. Any discussion? Seeing none all those in favor signify by saying aye. Aye.
[2:36]
Those opposed? The agenda has been approved. Next item on our agenda is the approval of the minutes of the August 18th, 2026 meeting.
[2:46]
Any corrections, additions, deletions,
[2:52]
seeing none? Can I get a motion to accept the minutes from that August 18th meeting?
[2:59]
I moved to approve.
[3:01]
All right. Second. Any discussion? All those in favor,
[3:04]
signify by saying aye. Aye. Aye. Those opposed.
[3:08]
Minutes are approved. Report from the city council liaison.
[3:12]
We do not have one this evening.
[3:14]
So we will immediately move into the public hearing,
[3:17]
which is a conditional use permit application
[3:21]
from QT new brightening LLC to operate a car dealership
[3:25]
limited to five vehicles out of sweet six in the light and
[3:28]
for your building at 855-3rd Street Southwest. Assistant Director of Gazola. Would you take
[3:35]
us through that application? I would be happy to see if I can get this to appear correctly
[3:41]
up here for you. There we go. All right Mr. Chair, I remember the planning commission. The only item
[3:47]
before us tonight is I would say a pretty straightforward conditional use permit request. It comes
[3:52]
from a business that you're already familiar with about the same time last year. Ramadan Adam
[3:58]
And Link Drive Express came before you seeking a conditional use permit to authorize auto repair as part of their transportation business.
[4:07]
Adding auto repair to the site allowed them to fix their fleet vehicles whenever they need to do that.
[4:12]
And it'll also allow them to work on their clients cars when they received those types of requests.
[4:18]
This year they're back before you seeking authorization to do auto sales and add that to the list of services that they provide from suite number six.
[4:27]
per Mr. Adam, their primary business or former drivers who oftentimes have cars that they can no longer use.
[4:36]
So adding vehicle sales to the site is going to allow them not only to repair their clients vehicles when they receive those requests,
[4:44]
but also to sell their clients vehicles when they no longer need their vehicles or their cars.
[4:49]
By state law there must be at least five dedicated parking spaces associated with the dealer's license,
[4:54]
and they have agreed that five vehicles would be the maximum number of four sale vehicles on
[5:00]
site at any given time. So with that as your overall background, here's the site itself.
[5:06]
As you can see, it's located in the southern portion of the community here. It's just off to the
[5:12]
west of old Highway 8 and just to the north of the lakeside manufactured home park.
[5:18]
The 855 building is one of four identical light industrial buildings in this area of the city
[5:23]
And it houses a number of, I guess, different businesses, including Link Drive Express.
[5:30]
As always, I hear your arrows of the site with this first one looking to the north from 2024.
[5:36]
One looking to the east, one looking to the south, and finally one looking to the west.
[5:43]
And we can bring those up as maybe needed.
[5:46]
Looking at the applicant's site plan, you can see that sweet number six in the 85 building is really central to that particular structure.
[5:53]
and this business does have five dedicated parking spaces that would be used for this dealership
[6:00]
license off to the west of the building. They have two dedicated spaces for the business off to the
[6:06]
east of the building and then they have four parking spaces interior to this particular suite.
[6:13]
The minimum required number of parking spaces for this business is four so I would say that they do
[6:19]
have that accounted for in the dedicated spaces for the business, as well as with the shared
[6:24]
parking that's available for all of the businesses in this kind of series of buildings.
[6:30]
That said, we do want this business to thrive and succeed. So it's not a stretch to think that
[6:35]
parking could become an issue at some point in time given the layers of different uses in this particular
[6:41]
building. So you will see that concern reflected in the recommended conditions in the CUP criteria
[6:47]
as we go through them.
[6:50]
The jumping to that right now,
[6:51]
staff does find that a number of the CUP criteria can be met outright.
[6:56]
As proposed, the operation is not going to endanger the public health.
[7:00]
It's not going to impact further development of the site.
[7:03]
In one of any negative impacts on local infrastructure.
[7:06]
It's not going to unnecessarily impact natural areas.
[7:09]
The property is owned light industrial,
[7:11]
so that's one of the classifications where use cars is actually allowed under our code.
[7:15]
and there is no buffer requirement given the business's location.
[7:20]
All of the other criteria for a CUP, we believe, can be met with conditions.
[7:25]
First, this can only impact the use and enjoyment
[7:27]
to surrounding businesses in property if part...
[7:30]
So as a condition of approval, we are recommending the CUP limit the number of cars that can be foresail onsite to the five parking spaces that they have for this dealer's license.
[7:43]
We've also added two clauses that say if complaints are received on parking or on dealership traffic, that the applicant would agree to come here, reopen the CUP, allow us an opportunity to address whatever those complaints are and come up with a new framework to make sure that we are
[7:59]
addressing the identified issues.
[8:02]
Dealerships do need to attain a license to the clerk's office, so you'll see that listed
[8:07]
as condition number four.
[8:09]
Code specifically prohibits foreseal vehicles from being parked in the right of way, so we
[8:14]
have that listed as condition number five.
[8:17]
We've limited maintenance work to being inside of the building with condition number six,
[8:21]
and then finally code specifically prohibits vehicle sale businesses from doing auto-bodywork.
[8:27]
So that is a prohibition listed in condition number seven.
[8:32]
So overall we do feel that this is a use that can work well for this particular business on this site and in this location provided all of these conditions are followed.
[8:41]
So given that analysis staff is recommending approval of the conditional use permit here tonight subject to the conditions we just went over.
[8:50]
For this particular item this is a public hearing.
[8:52]
so the planning commission is asked to hold the hearing tonight to then make a recommendation for council consideration
[8:58]
both myself and the applicant are present here tonight if you do have questions
[9:02]
so with that we'll turn it over for discussion thank you
[9:08]
any questions for staff commissioners any questions you have for the staff
[9:12]
Yeah, if you got one, what is the reasoning for the provision and
[9:17]
out of body at a place that the Elsa's cars?
[9:20]
For a, it's, it's one of our primary, I guess, just requirements for any
[9:26]
business that sells automobiles within the city, and then I believe was a requirement
[9:31]
to really separate out, you know, somebody, let's say the Ford dealership, where they have
[9:37]
new cars, they have used cars, and they have a repair shop.
[9:40]
They want to do that to be separated from auto body, where you'd have junk vehicles or vehicles that clearly couldn't run and might not run for a long time.
[9:49]
You'd have to get a special approval for that. So that's a different CUP to do that type of work.
[9:58]
That makes sense.
[10:00]
You seem to be, if I had to, yes, if you were a judge in that requirement, it's really the parking of what are really junk vehicles that need major repair before they can run again.
[10:12]
I think that was the fear that I remember we had talked about in previous applications like this was, you have five or six, especially when we're along old highway, we had to get one guy that I mean, there's five or six junk or vehicle sitting there.
[10:29]
Sure.
[10:29]
It just becomes an ice arc, because you don't know how soon they're going to get in.
[10:33]
I'll soon they'll get out.
[10:34]
So that's kind of worth that.
[10:36]
Thank you.
[10:37]
Any other questions for staff?
[10:40]
No?
[10:41]
Okay.
[10:42]
At this time then I will take a motion to open the public hearing.
[10:48]
And move we open the public hearing.
[10:50]
Can I get a second?
[10:52]
All those in favor signify by saying aye.
[10:56]
the public hearing is now open at 639. Do we have anyone online?
[11:07]
We do not. And we have
[11:09]
only one gentleman, the applicant in the crowd here tonight. So, sir, did you want to come up
[11:16]
and say anything? No? Okay.
[11:25]
Okay. Seeing we have no one that wishes to speak for against,
[11:30]
uh... i will take a motion to close the public hearing
[11:33]
uh... movie close public hearing
[11:36]
can i get a second
[11:38]
all those in favor signify by saying i
[11:41]
uh... the public hearing is officially closed at six thirty nine
[11:48]
uh... okay
[11:52]
commissioners
[11:53]
anything you want to talk about concerns
[11:56]
with
[11:56]
pretty straightforward
[11:58]
i don't think there's really anything we need to be the only issue i would have
[12:01]
obviously, if they're parking becomes an issue, that's always an issue and
[12:06]
Yep, the city. So, yeah, but it's laid out in the condition, so it didn't
[12:14]
feel like we needed to be overly restrictive at this point. They believe it's going
[12:18]
to work. Yeah, that's a plan for it to work, so let's let them move forward.
[12:22]
And if it doesn't work, they've agreed to come back to the peripheral reopen and we'll
[12:26]
examine it once again. Perfect.
[12:29]
Okay, that having been said unless if there's any other discussion and seeing that I will take a motion to move this forward to the city council.
[12:39]
I move you recommend the city council approve the requested conditional use permit to authorize vehicle sales at 855 3rd Street Southwest suite number six.
[12:48]
Based on the facts and findings and conditions listed on page 1011 of the reporters may have been amended here tonight.
[12:53]
And I get a second.
[12:55]
A second.
[12:57]
Any questions? Any discussion?
[13:00]
Seeing none, all those in favor, signify by saying aye.
[13:03]
Aye.
[13:03]
Those opposed?
[13:05]
The resolution passes and it will move on to the city council.
[13:08]
So that would be on next Tuesday's agenda.
[13:11]
Next Tuesday.
[13:12]
Okay.
[13:14]
Same time.
[13:16]
I'll reach out to you and we can talk more about that.
[13:18]
Any other issues that need to come before the commission this evening?
[13:23]
Seeing none, all those in favor of a German, signify by saying aye.
[13:28]
Aye.
[13:29]
Those opposed.
[13:32]
Poor jerk.