Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[0:08]
There is a September 10th at 7 o'clock PM. I'm Mayor Walter for the City of North Oaks, and I hear by call this meeting to order. Administrator Chris May have a roll call for this.
[0:18]
Yeah, we'll go ahead as well, President Fisbarne here.
[0:22]
So you're here, so.
[0:23]
Professor Harold, sir.
[0:25]
We'll go ahead.
[0:26]
Thank you.
[0:27]
And if everyone would please stand for the pledge of allegiance.
[0:32]
This is the place that the United States is there.
[0:37]
We can see the world that we're going to see as one nation
[0:40]
on the end of this whole, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:49]
The next item on the agenda is for citizen comments and we invite people from the public
[0:57]
to come to the podium and be allowed up to four minutes to say whatever they would like
[1:04]
to share.
[1:05]
Did you want to?
[1:08]
Good evening.
[1:11]
Good evening, Mayor.
[1:12]
And council members, my name is George Wellock.
[1:15]
I live at 14 Red Pine Road, and I am here to talk a little bit about what was discussed
[1:25]
last month about the public institutional zoning process that you're looking at.
[1:34]
I know that you're looking to create that format for the church and for the school, those
[1:42]
areas, and I think it's a great idea to do that. I'm not opposed to anything. I'm
[1:49]
just, I want to kind of, I think it's, you know, there's a lot of good things that
[1:53]
can happen with it, but there's concern I have in terms of what I've read, and that concern
[2:01]
is that I'm concerned about how those rules are going to be written for the PI, zoning
[2:07]
activity, all right. I am in a butter, by the way, that's why I'm here. When I was reading
[2:16]
all of the activities, I saw a lot of information about the churches, the school, community
[2:22]
uses, parking, and access, and even some things about the Met Council, which is all great.
[2:28]
All right. The one thing I didn't see in that was the indication of involving the neighbors
[2:37]
in this discussion, and so I'm here just to make a request that as you go through the process of
[2:47]
defining what this PI zoning is going to be, I know that you've kind of given or you
[2:54]
just back to give that to the planning commission, which is great. I think it's important for you to
[3:01]
put into that consideration, community involvement.
[3:06]
And I, you know, there's a lot of things that happen
[3:11]
within the CUP process that impact those people who
[3:17]
are bordering the, you know, these areas that you might want
[3:20]
to consider rezoning.
[3:22]
I think it's important to look at what's going to happen,
[3:25]
what protections are there for the neighbors.
[3:29]
And so one of the things I would like to ask is that as you do this, not just to give that
[3:36]
activity directly to the Planning Commission, but to involve some of those neighbors who are going to be
[3:45]
abutting that, you know, all of those processes, all right. Now, I would, in fact, encourage, I would volunteer for that if anybody, if that's something that you would consider.
[3:55]
So, that's the purpose for my, you know, coming here to this evening, you know, this evening is just to ask you to consider that as a, as a, as a, as a part of your process involve the neighbors in, in making, you know, at least reviewing what the planning commission comes up with and allowing them the opportunity to provide feedback before it becomes fixed and it's available for public hearing.
[4:19]
So, that's my request of you, and I hope that you'll consider that and reach out to the neighbors for that kind of involvement.
[4:31]
Thank you.
[4:32]
Thank you.
[4:32]
Thank you very much for your time.
[4:34]
Kevin, when is that on the agenda for permission?
[4:36]
Yeah.
[4:36]
I was going to say the platform for that is through public hearing.
[4:40]
We send the abutter letters.
[4:41]
He noted that's slated for this month for planning commission to review.
[4:45]
And they basically three options recommend up to the council review further or do nothing.
[4:53]
So if there's neighbor interest in the public institution, all that would be the meeting to go to.
[4:58]
So last Thursday the month that's seven o'clock.
[5:02]
This one here.
[5:05]
All right.
[5:06]
And I appreciate that.
[5:08]
Thank you so much.
[5:10]
Thank you.
[5:11]
No one questions.
[5:12]
Go ahead.
[5:13]
Thank you.
[5:15]
Is there anyone else that would like to make a comment this evening?
[5:23]
Well, hello, everyone.
[5:24]
My name is Rick Kingston.
[5:25]
I live at Five Island Road, and I'm sure all of us recognize that the elections
[5:29]
for North Oak City Council members are underway.
[5:32]
And in that regard, I have two comments.
[5:34]
The first relates to the fact that these races have always been non-partisan.
[5:38]
We don't need the division occurring in Washington to be a distraction
[5:41]
for our elected officials to do what's best for North Oak residents.
[5:45]
Secondly, candidates apparently need to be reminded that the use of NOAA directory to access
[5:50]
NOAA member private contact information, including accessing and calling member phone numbers
[5:55]
for personal gain is strictly prohibited. Not only does not only does do so violate member privacy,
[6:03]
it undermines NOAA's efforts to collect such information to use membership purposes, including
[6:08]
contacting members and emergency situations. If members see these abuses, they will be
[6:14]
and private information. My recommendation is that if a member is contacted by someone using the
[6:20]
members' private information that was shared with Noah or any other private organization for their
[6:25]
personal gain, they should hang up and report the violation to Noah or any other private
[6:30]
organization that has members' private information. Thank you. Thank you. Is there anyone else that would
[6:37]
like to make comments this evening?
[6:43]
We will go on to the next line of the agenda number five
[6:47]
approval of the agenda.
[6:50]
Do I have a motion to approve?
[6:52]
The move.
[6:54]
Any further discussion?
[6:57]
All in favor?
[6:59]
Aye.
[6:59]
Right motion carries.
[7:00]
Thank you.
[7:02]
And then the next item is the consent agenda.
[7:04]
These are items that are considered routine.
[7:06]
And can be acted upon with one vote.
[7:10]
Do I have a motion to approve?
[7:13]
So moved.
[7:14]
So we're going with
[7:19]
And any further discussion on these items
[7:23]
Great, all those in favor
[7:27]
Alright
[7:27]
Motion carries, thank you
[7:30]
And next item would be our report from Deputy Craig Leiden.
[7:37]
Welcome, and good evening.
[7:41]
Good evening, everybody. I'll have everyone had a bit holiday weekend.
[7:44]
Going to be back.
[7:47]
Interesting call that we had last month was a 13th from the Woodhill Lane area.
[7:54]
A female resident called in saying there is a female outside her home trying to gain entry to her house.
[7:58]
Squadron responded and found a mentally ill woman who was convinced that she lived there and had a very wild story on how the person inside had her keys.
[8:12]
She didn't want to go but we wrote a transport hold and had her transported to Regent's hospital to their psyche and it to be evaluated given the aid that she needed.
[8:21]
She was in the system as a mental health and requiring services, but she somehow found her way into our community.
[8:31]
But that just goes to say, even though we live in a nice safe community, it's always best interest to keep your doors locked.
[8:37]
If you don't have cameras, they're not a bad investment.
[8:40]
Just to keep yourself safe and it's on on outside.
[8:43]
And they lend themselves to assist us with the flock cameras if you're not able to see a vehicle or capture.
[8:48]
license plate cameras are great for that, and then we can always leverage the block systems
[8:53]
to investigate things further.
[8:58]
I understand some traffic data was requested.
[9:02]
There have been more traffic stops.
[9:05]
I don't have Zerger, the report management system, and I have down to a science, and I
[9:11]
haven't yet been able to have a meeting with Matt Morrison or Commander Frederick Set to figure
[9:16]
how to try to extract some of that data. But tickets, I haven't only saw one ticket for last
[9:23]
month. I wasn't able to see the speed recited. I think driving after revocation. But me personally,
[9:32]
the speeds that I've been observing out there have been from like 28 up to 42 at the highest.
[9:41]
I'm curious to see what those speed signs that we put up. If we're able to pull data off
[9:45]
those at some point, maybe get a monthly report or try to pinpoint times and speeds the
[9:52]
better interdict and slope people down, keep everybody safe.
[9:57]
Another good reminder, it's a school, and there's a new bus stop when the red lights are flashing.
[10:04]
Now that is when you're required to stop, not just when the arm is fully extended, apparently
[10:09]
it was an issue with drivers using as a loophole that the arm wasn't fully extended, so
[10:13]
pass in the bus as kids are running toward the bus. If you see the red flashing lights that
[10:18]
that is your indication to stop just the full stop arm. I will continue to try to meet with
[10:24]
Matt Martson here in the week for it closes and trying to get him to run a report for me to get
[10:29]
better data. I'm not sure.
[10:36]
I'll see if I can check on the guy who's teaching him what he knows.
[10:41]
I don't know if I'd like to use the Google group for Zerker, but if the ticket's not written,
[10:48]
I don't think there's anything part of our system that captures the speed for which they were pulled over.
[10:52]
Our radar on the dash, we would hit a capture button to show what the speed was, but that doesn't get logged anywhere.
[10:59]
And then if you issue a ticket, then it would be part of that official court document.
[11:05]
But even then in order to pull out that kind of data, it would have to find each individual ticket and then see what the speed's worth.
[11:11]
But most of my stops have been for, let's say, 37, 38.
[11:21]
And like I said, I stopped 42.
[11:22]
We definitely stopped the 42.
[11:26]
Whether tickets, the issued, or not, some variables,
[11:29]
going to anyone else on the road, pedestrians,
[11:38]
daylight,
[11:38]
lighting conditions, driving history, things of that nature,
[11:42]
is it's ultimately at the discretion of the officer to cite.
[11:46]
So driving history is considered a personal accountability at the window.
[11:51]
Those types of things influence like, I like to settle things at the lowest level possible.
[11:57]
And if I feel the contact much like with our young kids fishing, if that initial contact is going to be enough to get that individual not to do it again.
[12:06]
And then hopefully it's got one contact and not again, but with notes in the record management system and with ticket being convictions showing in their driving history
[12:16]
Use that to leverage like this person had contact in the past. This person isn't getting the message. They're a regular stop. Those types of things and tickets and stuff.
[12:27]
We have the option here to use administration tickets and state citations.
[12:31]
So, again, that would be like a next step type of thing, depending on the level of events.
[12:37]
Unless your guys are promoted to administrative tickets, but for each fence, it's a flat $60 and wouldn't necessarily go on the person's record.
[12:45]
And then, as long as they comply and pay it within 10 days at the control station, it won't go as a state citation.
[12:54]
So, that's another option that we can use to try to persuade people for that driving conduct.
[13:02]
So, kind of support of clarification.
[13:04]
Sure.
[13:04]
This month, the calls for service, I can see it.
[13:06]
And this says 21 traffic stops.
[13:08]
And underneath that, there's six ax mums.
[13:12]
So, the other 15, that's around, there's its ambiguous.
[13:15]
What, what were they?
[13:16]
Wasn't speeding?
[13:18]
Or what was it?
[13:18]
I would say primarily, like, my staff,
[13:20]
most of those, I believe, are my stops.
[13:22]
It's for speed.
[13:23]
Couple.
[13:24]
15, you issued, one ticket.
[13:28]
I believe so.
[13:29]
I mean, I think the question last month was just, we're trying to get a feel, I mean you're in the field, we're not.
[13:37]
So we need to have a little bit more, I don't know if it's data or even some of this information to see what's going on.
[13:45]
It was me that asked, is it 0 to 5, they're going over or is it 5 to 10, 10 plus?
[13:52]
Most people 05, they see me, and they slow down to 28, 29, and just that officer presence
[13:57]
is enough to slow them down.
[13:59]
The ones that don't slow down, and it initiates a stop, when it's safe for me to flip around,
[14:04]
because the bends and stuff sometimes, it's not always safe for me to try to go and hold them
[14:10]
over, because where I turn around safely, and the speeds I would have to go to catch them.
[14:14]
But there isn't speed taking place.
[14:23]
It's not acceptable, but we're trying to slow them down.
[14:25]
And it's not repeat people from when I'm observing.
[14:29]
Some of the people I take contact have told me that they're the ones
[14:33]
that sometimes call them complain about the speeding
[14:35]
and that they're so sorry.
[14:40]
But I can try and put more information into the CAD notes
[14:44]
when I make a stop so that I have something to reference
[14:46]
because they're not going to log that, at least I'll be able to present on some of that.
[14:52]
I'll talk to our public information, see what I can share, what I can't share.
[14:58]
But I just recall in maybe-
[15:00]
Karen has to help me when Deputy Burell was here. We were able to get the data of, you know, how many fell in these, you know, 0 to 10, 10 to 20. And I don't want to say it was almost by month. And maybe it was the end of your report. But I think that kind of information would be helpful to see what's happening on our streets.
[15:20]
Sure. I believe some of that fell under our traffic unit, which right now doesn't exist for
[15:27]
stopping reasons and funding, but they had a different set of practice, different set of training
[15:32]
and then was our typical traffic advocate.
[15:35]
I don't know how long ago we're talking about, like, probably four years ago at least.
[15:39]
I'm sure things have changed here, but it was helpful. So if we could go in that direction,
[15:46]
I personally don't know what the rest of the council would like to see, but I'd like to see
[15:49]
I could certainly try to capture that myself more, and then again, I don't know much about the traffic signs we put in.
[15:55]
Is that something we'd be able to?
[15:57]
I thought we could pull the data from that.
[15:59]
Yeah, you gotta pay for a subscription to do so, but it is capable of doing that, so that would be a causal direction or decision to staff.
[16:09]
That's something you're interested in.
[16:11]
What's it cost?
[16:13]
That is a great question, you call.
[16:18]
Can we bring that back next week?
[16:19]
I certainly bring it back and I don't have a faith in them.
[16:23]
Great.
[16:25]
Okay.
[16:26]
Thank you.
[16:26]
Thank you.
[16:26]
My part all started.
[16:27]
Try to capture some of that so I'd use you to access and bring you the next one.
[16:30]
Great.
[16:31]
And the woman that was over on Woodhill Lane, did she, was she just, I foot or had to
[16:38]
driven?
[16:38]
Yeah.
[16:39]
When I looked like she just walked in, she'd probably safer with the, the state of mind that
[16:46]
she was on.
[16:46]
Right.
[16:46]
I know we had a similar situation a few years ago, and the person kept driving in, and that was helpful because the LPRs would alert.
[16:56]
Just so that someone could, because she was also trying to get into one certain home.
[17:02]
And so, it's nice that the deputy did a great job at that time.
[17:08]
I know.
[17:08]
Unfortunately, we don't have a license plate to put in a license plate.
[17:12]
like, but it seems like a lot of accidents, were they, were they interior, or were they
[17:18]
imprinting like a handful of them were like a village center here, that falls in under
[17:23]
orthops as well, commercial area, and then, where else, on top, I don't know, but I can get
[17:46]
Okay, the next item is impact of its 7B, impact of plastics in our environment, and I had
[17:55]
met with Lori Bullinger and Kate Windsor recently, and found this discussion very interesting,
[18:03]
so Lori will be presenting information on plastics.
[18:08]
Thank you very much for having us on the agenda.
[18:11]
I appreciate all that Kate has been doing involved in this too, so thank you for both with
[18:18]
Northeast Metro Climate Action.
[18:21]
And I also belong to the Sierra Club and a couple of zero waste groups that have been
[18:26]
working on this for quite a while.
[18:30]
A lot of people think that plastic is really just a waste issue and if we recycle more that's
[18:35]
really going to take care of the problem, but there's really a lot more to it than just
[18:40]
it being a waste issue that, you know, recycling can address. Back in the 1980s there were
[18:47]
concerns about the amount of plastic that people were throwing in the trash and starting to see
[18:52]
plastic in the ocean and the plastic industry to combat that took over the recycling, the chasing
[19:01]
arrows recycling symbol that was just used for paper at the time and they added the resin codes
[19:07]
and started trying to had a campaign to convince people that if they threw their plastic in the
[19:14]
blue recycling bin, it could get turned into something new and that would solve the plastic
[19:19]
problem. And that campaign has been wildly successful. People do believe that and they feel
[19:26]
very comfortable about using plastic and recycling it and thinking that, you know, good things
[19:31]
are going to come from recycling plastic. But the issue is really a lot more complex than that.
[19:38]
Oh, yeah, that's good.
[19:41]
And you maybe have seen recently, there's a lot of questions.
[19:45]
People are wondering if recycling really does work,
[19:49]
should we be recycling?
[19:52]
Ramsey can, it just sent out a postcard recently
[19:56]
about this saying, oh, recycling does work.
[19:59]
You know, you can be confident if you throw it in the bin.
[20:02]
It's going to turn into something.
[20:04]
You know, it'll get recycled into a new product.
[20:06]
But, you know, when you look at aluminum and paper, cardboard, metal, those really are
[20:15]
great recycled. They reduce the need for resources. It's cheaper to recycle them than
[20:21]
to mine for the raw materials and things like that. But when it comes to plastic, it's
[20:28]
really a different issue. Plastic was never designed to be recycled. It's less than 10% has
[20:36]
been recycled in the past and it just the companies that make plastic, they don't really have
[20:43]
an incentive to make it recyclable. They use a lot of different chemicals, so it's just
[20:49]
something that's very hard to recycle. And there's recycling plastic into a new product has no
[21:06]
And doing more and more recycling is not going to have an impact on the amount of produced.
[21:13]
Next slide.
[21:17]
So there's really three problems with plastic that I can see through main problems.
[21:25]
Beyond just the waste issue of, you know, having too much plastic in trying to recycle it and trying to figure out what to do with it in the waste stream.
[21:33]
And the first one is that we make too much plastic.
[21:38]
The petrochemical companies fossil fuel, petrochemical, they're all one in the same.
[21:43]
They all have the stream from the fossil fuels all the way up to making the inputs for plastic.
[21:52]
And it's a very profitable thing right now.
[21:57]
Most of the plastic, like 98% of plastic, is made from fossil fuels.
[22:01]
And most of it is from Ethane, which is a byproduct of fracking.
[22:06]
And most of the facilities that make it are in Louisiana and Texas some are now in Pennsylvania
[22:14]
because they do fracking in Pennsylvania too.
[22:17]
But the people that are living near those facilities are really suffering because of it.
[22:21]
The cancer rate in Louisiana.
[22:23]
There is an 85-mile strip that's called Cancer Alley.
[22:27]
That has one of the highest cancer rates in the country.
[22:30]
So, where it's being produced, it really has an impact on the people who live there. And they lived there before these facilities came. So it wasn't like they moved into the neighborhood with all the facilities facilities came and joined them.
[22:49]
And 40% of plastic that's produced is for single use. So it's only used for a very short period of time and then disposed up.
[22:57]
So we really have a big problem with plastic production and the amount of plastic is just increasing more than about half the plastic that's been produced has been since the early 2000s.
[23:13]
So we are just exponentially making more and more plastic and recycling really has nothing to do with that.
[23:22]
There's the demand for plastic is not driven by the products that we need.
[23:28]
It's driven by the industry that is making money on making plastic.
[23:34]
Next slide.
[23:38]
And the second issue that I think is a big concern having to do with plastic is the
[23:44]
microplastic particles that are shed from plastic.
[23:47]
So whenever you use plastic, a little bits and pieces are
[23:51]
flaking off of it all the time. Even though you can't see it
[23:55]
Sometimes you can see it, but usually you can't see it by with the naked eye
[23:59]
But a little bit of particles like if you open a water bottle you twist off the cap
[24:04]
a little particles fall into your water bottle
[24:08]
Shaking your cereal out from that little plastic bag in your cereal. It's hard for me to eat cereal now because I just can't
[24:15]
You know, a portable series of that thinking about the particles that are getting into my cereal.
[24:25]
So, you're clothing that you wear, if it's synthetic clothing, as you walk around,
[24:30]
little bits are flaking up, you're clothing, and you wash it.
[24:35]
Quite a bit comes out in the wash and goes into our waste stream.
[24:38]
So, these little particles are getting more and more into the environment by using plastic.
[24:46]
And as far as food is concerned, a lot of there's a lot of microplastics in food that we buy at the grocery store.
[24:56]
And it could be from the packaging, but it can also be from the food processing equipment.
[25:02]
So if you have like plastic tubing or bins or conveyor belts or gloves, any food that comes in contact with that has the potential for getting the little microplastic particles in it.
[25:14]
And especially when the food is hot, so it's more likely to flake off if the food is hot or if it's really cold too.
[25:24]
And there have been studies, there was a researcher who was drinking some tea.
[25:30]
And when she started looking at her synthetic tea bag, she decided that she would do a test of how much particles were coming off her tea bag.
[25:39]
And she found that there were billions from the synthetic tea bag, billions of, like 11 billion
[25:47]
microplastic particles and 3 billion nanoparticles, which are even smaller from a synthetic
[25:54]
tea bag.
[25:56]
So we're really, you know, really getting exposed to microplastic particles in our food, in our water.
[26:03]
The more that gets into the environment, the more likely we are to be exposed to it.
[26:11]
And we've been working with the Micro-Postics Researcher from the University of Minnesota,
[26:15]
her name is Mary Kassub.
[26:18]
And she got her PhD two years ago, but she started studying, and I think it was 2017.
[26:25]
And her advisor was a PFAS person, and I was really, you know, that's really odd that
[26:31]
She has someone who, you know, a mentor who's studies PFAS and not plastic and then I found
[26:37]
out that she was the first person at the University to study microplastics.
[26:42]
So it's a really new area of study but it's really exploding.
[26:47]
There's a lot of research happening right now on all these particles where are they coming
[26:53]
from.
[26:54]
One of the things that she also studied was particles as they move through the air so she
[26:59]
it captured them falling just from the air and measured that and it's all the time little bits
[27:09]
are raining down. So she said when she has a glass of water by her bed, she thinks about
[27:15]
all those little particles in her house that are falling down into her glass of water. So
[27:20]
she still drinks her water but it's one of those things. The more you know, the more you're
[27:30]
next slide.
[27:34]
Now this is from some of the research that Mary is doing. She did a study on sports
[27:39]
bottles to see what flagged off them. And those are just two slides from some of the particles
[27:45]
that have like doffs for its bottles. And if you look at those, especially the one on the right
[27:51]
has got like some very sharp points on it and stuff. Plastic is not necessarily like little
[27:57]
around pieces. They can be very sharp particles and they're going into our body. A lot of them,
[28:05]
like we drink the weed, they go through our body out, don't drink any damage. But some
[28:10]
of these could be doing damages, they move through our body. But next slide. And microplastics
[28:22]
in our body,
[28:25]
they've tested, wherever they look on our body, they're finding microplastic
[28:29]
particles, especially when the methods are getting more established on how you can look
[28:34]
with them and make sure you're not contaminating your slides and information. And then the
[28:40]
equipment to look at smaller smaller particles, they're finding more and more and there is just
[28:45]
nowhere in the body that they look that they don't find microplastic particles. They're in
[28:51]
blood, they're circulating all around. They've crossed the blood-brain barrier. So they're finding
[28:57]
men are brain, they've crossed the gut barrier. A study was done looking at placentus and they
[29:04]
looked at 62 and they found microplastics in all 62. So babies are getting exposed to plastic
[29:12]
before they're even born and they're in babies. Like the first poop from a baby when they look at
[29:19]
that has microplastic particles in it.
[29:22]
So we're really doing an experiment on our children
[29:28]
that exposing them to these kind of particles
[29:31]
before they're even born.
[29:36]
And in Seaman long to shoot,
[29:39]
and nanoparticles, these small swans
[29:41]
are found in ourselves,
[29:45]
which I think is pretty disturbing to think
[29:47]
they're getting into our cell tissue. But that's how small they are. Next slide.
[29:57]
The third part of this, that is really, I think, very,
[30:00]
Certainly as the toxic chemicals used to make plastic, right now they have identified 16,000 different chemicals that are, you know, different companies can use for different reasons.
[30:12]
As additives to give different properties to plastic, like they might add felllates to make it soft and pliable or bisphenols to make it hard, they have colorance.
[30:27]
And the labels, if you put on plastic, some of those chemicals can reach into products.
[30:34]
So about a quarter of them right now are considered hazardous.
[30:38]
Only 11 are considered like less or non-hazardous and then 62% there's just no safety data at all.
[30:47]
So a lot of these chemicals used in plastic really are hazardous or there's unknown,
[30:53]
a non-norn hazard property from it,
[30:58]
and next slide, and these chemicals don't stay in
[31:03]
the leech out of the plastic when they come in contact with our food and drink skin if it's like
[31:12]
like a lotion or something, a certain plastic bottle, it can reach out into that lotion,
[31:17]
you put that in your skin and it can get into our body in many different ways.
[31:23]
Next slide,
[31:25]
And then the health concerns from the particles and also the chemicals in plastic.
[31:33]
As far as like the chemicals go, there are some very well-studied chemicals.
[31:38]
Like valet and dysphenols, flame retardants, PFAS, that are known to be interconnecting chemicals,
[31:45]
which means that they can change how our hormone system works and our bodies.
[31:50]
And they can have an impact at very, very small doses.
[31:53]
And they can raise the risk of reproductive problems, metabolic problems, neurodevelopmental
[32:04]
problems, and they are associated with diabetes, obesity, heart disease, premature birth,
[32:12]
and low sperm count.
[32:15]
Among other things, it's just a small snapshot of things they're worried about with
[32:20]
different disrupting chemicals, and also can raise the risk of certain types of cancer, especially
[32:25]
breast cancer, things that are more susceptible to hormones.
[32:29]
And developing fetuses are at most risk from this because of all the changes that they're
[32:34]
going through, and their bodies are expecting certain spikes in certain hormones to happen
[32:42]
at certain times, and if that doesn't happen, then it could have lifelong impact on a developing
[32:49]
baby. And the other thing that is a concern are like from the microplastic particles themselves
[32:56]
physically that they might cause inflammation, oxidative stress, or damage ourselves. So those
[33:05]
are all very concerning. Next slide. So I just wanted to share a little bit. We did a survey
[33:14]
to find out what people knew about plastic, how they felt about it, and how they were interested
[33:20]
in making changes to reduce their exposure to plastic.
[33:24]
And these were just four of the questions that we asked them.
[33:29]
And I've got the full survey of anybody interested in looking at more, but the survey found
[33:36]
like very, oh, plastic makes me feel concerned or very concerned was 93% of people.
[33:46]
As people of there are willing to pay for non-plastic, and 63% that they would be strongly
[33:53]
agreed or agreed about that, if they would ban shopping bags, plastic shopping bags, oh,
[34:01]
That was 63% the other I think is 69% and then the last question we asked him if they thought
[34:10]
restaurants should not give out things automatically like forks and napkins and condiments
[34:16]
which they a lot of times just throw right in the bag whether you needed or not and 79% thought
[34:22]
that would be something that would be restaurants should do and next slide.
[34:32]
These are things that we talked about as ideas that North Oaks could maybe consider to reduce
[34:41]
our exposure to single-use plastic.
[34:44]
I mean, it definitely doesn't solve the problem, but you know, everywhere where we can
[34:48]
reduce our exposure, reduce the need for single-use plastic would be a benefit.
[34:54]
So, things that I thought might be good for considering one would be skip the stuff, which
[35:02]
is, you know, having the restaurants not give stuff out unless people ask for it.
[35:07]
And New Jersey has passed that New York City Denver, Washington, D.C., and in Minnesota
[35:14]
St. Anthony Village is working on it right now, so they're considering it.
[35:20]
Another one would be green to go containers where restaurants would have their takeout orders in something that was recyclable or compostable.
[35:31]
And there are, let's see, oh, many outlaws, St. Paul and St. Louis Park have that and they've had that for quite a few years.
[35:41]
The next would be government purchasing of single-use plastic and styrofoam.
[35:45]
I don't know how much that would be an impact in North Oaks, but it would be good to
[35:51]
formally state that, you know, we would face out those kind of purchases, I think would
[35:57]
be beneficial.
[35:59]
Zero waste of events, it wouldn't be like a requirement.
[36:03]
I don't think it should be a requirement, but it would be something that you would help people
[36:08]
or organizations or businesses who wanted to do an event and help provide information so that
[36:14]
could be successful with their event.
[36:17]
We helped many hoffles art festival four years ago.
[36:21]
They asked for our help to make their events, zero ways.
[36:24]
And we did that for two years.
[36:26]
And now they kept that going.
[36:28]
So their whole weekend is zero ways.
[36:30]
So it can be done.
[36:32]
Where was that that you did that?
[36:34]
Many hoffles art festival.
[36:37]
And then lastly is putting a fee on plastic bags.
[36:42]
In Minnesota you can't ban plastic bags, but you can't put a fee on them, and many
[36:48]
outblows Duluth both have fees, and man Kato is working on putting a fee on, so
[36:54]
they're working on it, considering that.
[36:58]
And we also work with Eureka recycling and the zero waste coalition, they said that
[37:04]
they would, if you're interested in pursuing any of these, they would definitely, you
[37:12]
help with implementing any of these.
[37:16]
And did you also, when we had spoken before, you said Roseville, had just recently...
[37:22]
Roseville, I think I'm a misspoke on there for St.
[37:28]
Go.
[37:28]
Yeah.
[37:30]
Seeing I think right. Roseville had just done for their schools reusable utensils for their schools. That was what Roseville was doing.
[37:40]
And then, you know, if there's any questions or if you'd like to pursue any of these, we'd love to work with you. And so that's it.
[37:50]
And Laurie, do you have an idea of how many restaurants around or within North Oaks are using recyclable, you know, take out containers?
[38:01]
I don't know how many are using recyclable or compostable and for the compostable you'd want it to be certified compostable, so it really could go in a compost.
[38:12]
We have a survey that we have from Mankato that they used to talk to all their businesses
[38:21]
to find out how if there was a burden, if they had concerns about it and what they were
[38:27]
currently doing.
[38:28]
So we could definitely survey the restaurants to find out what they're currently doing and
[38:34]
if they had concerns about the impact of implementing something like this.
[38:39]
And if there was one thing that you think North Ops could do to implement that would be helpful
[38:44]
Would it most likely be the takeout containers or on that list was I think takeout containers would be
[38:52]
That'd probably be the number one thing that I think would be very helpful
[38:57]
Especially don't want any styrofoam container anymore
[39:01]
You know, there is still some restaurants who use styrofoam containers, right? So is it really about
[39:06]
And you had said in the beginning, did you say Ramsey County had just sent out a postcard?
[39:12]
Yes, they did.
[39:13]
And did you contact them?
[39:15]
About that being...
[39:17]
Is you're saying that what they sent was false?
[39:21]
Well, it's not exactly false, but it's...
[39:24]
I think it's misleading when you say don't worry.
[39:28]
Recycling is going to solve this problem.
[39:30]
You just need to recycle.
[39:31]
They said it can be turned into...
[39:35]
something, I think I've got this postcard with me tonight, but they said it can be, what
[39:41]
you put in your bin is going to get turned into something, we'll make it into something,
[39:45]
but really when you make it into something like clothing or lawn furniture or decking things
[39:52]
like that, that is going to turn into a bulky item that is going to end up in the trash.
[39:57]
You know, like, and that I also had another thing for Ramsey County that said, for bulky items, what should you do?
[40:05]
And it's, they said, try to use it as long as you can. If you can't do that, try to give it away to somebody else, like buying nothing group.
[40:14]
And if that doesn't work, then put it in the trash. So it's really these things that you turn into, you make something out of it like a pot or a piece of furniture.
[40:24]
It's next stop is going to be the trash, and more plastic we make, more and more of it's going to end up in the trash.
[40:32]
And have you done any articles like to North Oak's News or anything like that?
[40:36]
I have not.
[40:39]
I mean, I think that would be really helpful.
[40:41]
I could do that.
[40:41]
I could do that.
[40:42]
Yeah.
[40:43]
Two.
[40:44]
Yeah.
[40:44]
I could do that.
[40:45]
Any questions from anyone else here?
[40:48]
So the research you've done, have you noticed?
[40:54]
Whether or not there's somebody out there trying to come up with a product to replace plastic all together
[41:02]
Because this is nibbling around the edges
[41:04]
Right
[41:05]
But that would be so what have you yeah, I mean it's very complex. I think low hanging fruit is we start with
[41:13]
Where we don't need plastic
[41:16]
we were done the packaging for
[41:20]
A packaging and cost reduction bill that went into effect in 2023 and that is going to charge producers for their packaging method used for food and other things like that.
[41:34]
And it's going to charge them more for a stop that is not recycled or compostable or and to encourage them to not use packaging if they don't need it.
[41:45]
So we're trying to get it that direction.
[41:49]
So I think first of all, eliminate the stuff that you really don't need.
[41:53]
There's a lot of packaging that I get and everything comes in a plastic bag.
[41:57]
Eliminate all those plastic bags.
[41:59]
You really don't need them.
[42:01]
Reusable bags for shipping.
[42:03]
Some companies do that.
[42:05]
Or they use glassene bags, which are highly recyclable.
[42:09]
So there's a lot of alternatives that you can use in place with like the plastic bags.
[42:13]
When it comes to food, I think that's a little trickier but there are alternatives, blasts
[42:23]
and things like that, more reusable, where you can get, try to move away from plastic packaging
[42:30]
into something more sustainable, less toxic, but yeah, it's tricky, especially, the food stuff
[42:40]
is tricky to replace that.
[42:46]
And it's I don't want to put you on the spot, but the city we have a recycling company
[42:52]
We use do no anything about that and can you make any recommendations about how we should
[42:58]
Of evaluate their work or audit their work. Um, do you it's re erase your recovery cycling?
[43:04]
I believe those are city. I don't I think you're a risk
[43:12]
Lonnie
[43:13]
It all goes down to the plant here, I think it's St. Paul, I've been there once.
[43:20]
Okay.
[43:21]
I'm in a tour, didn't all that.
[43:22]
Yeah. I think it is Eureka recycling because I know there was like a north oak tour.
[43:28]
It's Eureka.
[43:29]
It's Eureka.
[43:30]
Yeah, Eureka.
[43:31]
They are one of the best. They're a mission-based recycling companies.
[43:35]
So they really care about making sure that their employees are treated well.
[43:40]
And they've got, you know, the conditions are as healthy as they can be, and then they've got benefits and things like that.
[43:46]
And they also are concerned about having responsible end markets,
[43:50]
because that's a big problem with recycling also.
[43:53]
Where does it end up after you, you know, you sorted all out into bales, you sell the bales, where did they end up?
[44:02]
In Minnesota,
[44:04]
well, it's very hard, another thing that we're working on with Eureka,
[44:07]
is to try to identify responsible and markets and have some, that's part of that, the EPR
[44:14]
packaging bill was to have responsible and markets. So that's still in the works on how you can
[44:19]
make sure that they're responsible, like where does it finally end up? Is it going someplace and
[44:24]
getting burned as fuel? Is it being exported to another country? I know the United States still exports
[44:32]
a significant amount of stuff that's been recycled to countries like in Southeast Asia, like
[44:38]
Malaysia, Indonesia, Cambodia, Vietnam, but they really don't have, they really don't, they
[44:45]
just can't manage all of that plastic waste ending up in their country and it's, they're burning
[44:50]
it, so they're exposed to a lot of toxic chemicals from burning it and then a lot of it also
[44:57]
is up in the environment.
[44:59]
So.
[45:00]
I think that is more on the coast that it's getting exported.
[45:06]
People feel pretty confident in Minnesota
[45:08]
we're not exporting it, but we don't have any visibility like when you sell those bales you don't
[45:14]
really have visibility to the end markets. So that would be nice for work and I'm trying to get that.
[45:19]
And I do feel comfortable that Urika is doing, you know, the most that any probably recyclers doing.
[45:25]
It's the Lee Kebany template.
[45:29]
We're going to see this on any of these topics too.
[45:31]
I don't know.
[45:32]
It sounds like it'd be easy enough to pull one of the ones that she mentioned.
[45:36]
And we know what's saying Anthony you're well.
[45:38]
Yeah.
[45:38]
I know they're going to share well.
[45:40]
So I can talk to him about it.
[45:43]
See what's all there.
[45:44]
It's all around.
[45:44]
Trying to incentivize.
[45:46]
I'm just a communication.
[45:48]
I know Eureka has a video on their website
[45:50]
that shows the whole process.
[45:52]
If anybody's interested in that.
[45:55]
And we'll be, we'll be with St. Anthony's mayor City Administrator on Monday, so we should also ask about it there.
[46:03]
Yeah, that would be great. So I think anything that we could do to raise awareness of plastic and maybe, you know, be on the recycling,
[46:11]
but some of the problems, you know, our health problems, potentially environmental problems,
[46:17]
Tomorrow we could do the better and so yeah I think it would be great to do an article to
[46:22]
North Oaks News and the stroll magazine for both of those yeah okay that's a good idea
[46:29]
Thank you very much yeah yeah well thank you you know the institutional
[46:36]
I don't know can we have yeah well I would say we bring it up is just a topic probably an
[46:42]
October you know give us a little bit of time to see what's out there and put something in front
[46:46]
I'm at the council's interested in looking at that.
[46:52]
Great.
[46:52]
Thank you again.
[46:54]
Not very informative.
[46:55]
Thank you.
[46:55]
It was very nice.
[46:57]
Next item will be 9A and this is consideration of preliminary analysis proposal for
[47:07]
city hall, no location, so and Kevin would you like to start?
[47:16]
I'm hoping everybody had a chance to look at the proposal we did do a quick memo on that that hopefully people saw here today
[47:24]
Basically it lists a number of things towards the end of the document that the city could entertain doing I think for staff sake
[47:32]
We probably want to do all of those things right now. I would say there's probably
[47:37]
two things maybe three that the council would entertain
[47:42]
I don't think there's any harm in authorizing the whole thing and waiting
[47:46]
later, like for the the proposed schedule, I think it's a little premature for that, you know, at this time, but
[47:54]
We didn't meet with our task group with no representatives, calls for representatives and and chair crommons
[48:01]
I don't know if there's any opinions from girl her mark
[48:09]
whether or not we should move forward and do well if you had specific
[48:13]
ones that you wanted to do or you just wanted to do the whole thing but make model where that, you know, specifically number four
[48:20]
or I would entertain right now?
[48:24]
Well, in my mind, we do the minimal amount
[48:28]
that we need to get a ball of prep price.
[48:32]
So we can compare it to other things
[48:34]
that are floating around out here.
[48:37]
That's kind of the most I would think.
[48:42]
So how much land do we have?
[48:44]
If the building size and then you need so much parking,
[48:48]
So, how would that fit down that piece of land and then, you know, it's enough and less
[48:54]
interior, so you can see how it'd be used, that everything would work.
[49:01]
And then I'd want to see enough, I don't know if we want to put public works, add it, but
[49:07]
maybe have possible addition kind of thing, and then you do a price per square foot, now we
[49:14]
You know, it's just a $12 million project or a $6, you know, you know, where is it?
[49:28]
Mark, do you have anything to do with it?
[49:30]
Well, it's a bomb odds.
[49:34]
That's a proposal and whether we should move forward with something like that.
[49:38]
I think this is a good idea.
[49:40]
You know, that's in the packet.
[49:43]
Of him helped us out with some of those numbers.
[49:47]
So we have a good idea.
[49:50]
Because the time is, we're quickly running out of time
[49:54]
I think we should move forward with Mods proposal, it's pretty modest, and so we have that information on cost and scope and such.
[50:09]
Then we can have a better idea for what next steps might be.
[50:14]
So are you asking otherwise?
[50:16]
Well, basically we've used this to authorize it, but you could give me discretion. I think you're going to want
[50:23]
You know, one most likely you're sketch floor plan and site plan. I don't know that I'm super strong on the artistic rendering at this point.
[50:31]
I'd probably skip that.
[50:34]
The ballpark probable cost. I think we absolutely need that. I think score the four. I would skip until we have located a site that has the potential.
[50:44]
Well, not that we haven't yet, but we haven't secured any actual site to do any sort of potential schedule.
[50:52]
So I think that was a little premature right now.
[51:01]
What do you need a motion to do those things?
[51:03]
I think a motion would be appropriate directing staff to work with mod,
[51:09]
you know, with discretion on my part, based on what I just described.
[51:16]
Well, I'll meet that motion.
[51:19]
Second.
[51:21]
For their discussion, I mean, I have related, but separate item, we have this list of questions from the whole related to a building.
[51:34]
Where are we on that?
[51:36]
We're hoping to address some of those with mods, sketches and designs.
[51:41]
So we are aware that Bill sits on our task group, so he's aware of that.
[51:46]
So we're hoping as we gather some of this information, we meet again with Steve Cheerhart
[51:51]
to explore those other options.
[51:53]
We can begin to address that list of questions that no one saw them.
[51:58]
Steve's going to give me down in parallel.
[52:01]
Yeah, I would also say, you know, so I had just, I had talked to BCI at the fire when we did
[52:10]
the big deal at the fire station.
[52:16]
And one of the people from BCI had just sent over, he had said, you know, they've done
[52:22]
different city halls and stuff, and they had just sent me, he had sent me like a drawing
[52:27]
of like a possible build.
[52:30]
And so on this passes on here too. But and he also talked about, you know, as far as no one in the city, it's fairly simple to do something like that with us because we are all built out.
[52:47]
So he said, you know, a lot of time and energy comes into when, you know, if you're going to add 2,000 more homes, you're going to do something like that, then it's a very very different process to go.
[52:59]
through where, you know, our space would stay relatively the same.
[53:10]
How did you mark this up?
[53:12]
He had, he had some things where he had put grudges onto this, because I was talking to him
[53:18]
about like office and if you had a space for like what we've been talking about with Cory.
[53:25]
And so that's where he did a mock-up of, you know, what something could look like if you were
[53:31]
to combine the two.
[53:37]
So, what are you thinking of you seeing this Kevin?
[53:41]
Yep.
[53:42]
Sorry.
[53:42]
Good.
[53:44]
No, I was just thinking, what were you giving you some discretion here?
[53:49]
And what are you about to give you some discretion?
[53:52]
What are you thinking?
[53:54]
Well, I think you would want.
[53:57]
I'm just going to go back to that.
[53:58]
You would want the concept floor plan, the site plan.
[54:02]
I would probably skip the artistic rendering kind of have one there,
[54:06]
But I feel like that's going to change over time.
[54:10]
Potentially, a lot.
[54:11]
So I'm a little hesitant to spend money on that and then do it again.
[54:15]
And again, and again, as we go forward,
[54:18]
I'd probably skip that for now.
[54:19]
Three-year think is essential for me as a know at this point.
[54:24]
Just without a secure location.
[54:27]
I think that's going to be pretty variable depending on which direction.
[54:31]
Council goals are the project goals for that matter.
[54:33]
I don't know, maybe talk to Mod about four.
[54:37]
I mean, it would help us understand, you know, what if we did have to renew stuck around
[54:45]
and what that schedule would look like.
[54:49]
There might be some value in that.
[54:51]
I was thinking more along the lines of acquisition, bonding, you know, public hearings
[54:57]
if necessary, that kind of stuff, or those are generally similar, so maybe he would
[55:03]
could cut that down and not that I think is as cost as on reason why I think the whole proposal
[55:08]
is pretty in line, but those are just my initial thoughts.
[55:15]
Well, my motion included the things you articulated the first time.
[55:22]
I'm all forgetting a timeline too, but we're not going to have this thing built and I could
[55:27]
be in it for we have to redo.
[55:30]
So do we really need to spend that money right now?
[55:33]
Right, okay. That's something I think like as we move along it probably come back and say I think we're ready for this now
[55:40]
Let's go back to mind and have him do, you know, that's got
[55:44]
Start to finish for us. I think I'm with you guys on that
[55:49]
I felt like we were a little ahead of ourselves
[55:53]
And I don't see us sort of rushing ahead of our it's not there
[55:57]
It's not the only send date. It's the date by which we have to give notice to renew, which is what early this week.
[56:04]
We should do that by November. We had planned to bring that probably October here for calls a little to consider again.
[56:12]
November at the latest because anything past that we're really pushing the envelope.
[56:18]
Maybe in China they throw the building that fast.
[56:20]
Yeah. This is more just, you know,
[56:24]
reviewing, studying. I have no intention that the city council is going to pursue any actual build before the end of this year.
[56:32]
Maybe even next year. This is just gathering of information.
[56:36]
And so my, my thought on that was I felt like maybe the architect we were soon for that.
[56:43]
And that what we needed to focus on more was our discussions with Noha to get a sense of our programming
[56:50]
need and their programming need going forward. Because we're looking at something very different
[56:55]
than we were looking at with the broker, the broker we were really sort of looking at a static
[57:00]
situation like what can we do right now. But this is this is an opportunity to get what we need
[57:07]
long term, which I'm a fan of. But I think that's a longer discussion with Noah. And I still remember
[57:14]
the whole east-track discussion, which I followed somewhat closely. And I actually thought they were
[57:19]
careful in their planning as they went along, and the neighborhood was not excited about that.
[57:26]
So, I feel like we should take some of that into account on the front end rather than.
[57:33]
So, I think I'm later on an architect, but I'm all forestarting those discussions with Nohoa
[57:39]
and starting to involve, you know, Merthuk's residents, and like, what do you want here?
[57:46]
So do you favor hiring mod?
[57:49]
No, not now.
[57:51]
But how do we have those conversations
[57:52]
if we don't have some of this information?
[57:55]
I mean, we're looking for it.
[57:56]
Well, they're looking at a set design, a certain amount of space,
[58:00]
and we can understand the cost of those just based on per square foot.
[58:04]
That's what we got from our broker.
[58:06]
They're appraisers too, so they have a great appraisal database,
[58:10]
and they can give us a general sense,
[58:12]
but at this point,
[58:13]
I think we don't know what's going in that box or how big the box is, sir.
[58:18]
We've been talking about this for almost a year.
[58:21]
We've been chicken and canned down the road and it's...
[58:26]
Well, I favor moving forward.
[58:28]
I think we need some information on what exactly better information on what we're thinking about.
[58:36]
We've been talking with Noah.
[58:37]
No, it's got two people who are board members on our committee.
[58:41]
We've been talking with them about their space needs.
[58:43]
That's probably going to evolve certainly.
[58:47]
But let's not ask what Bill, Bill,
[58:50]
do you have anything to add to this conversation?
[58:53]
Because when I saw the drawing for 400 Village Center drive,
[58:58]
I mean, that had taken into account what no one needed and what the city needed.
[59:03]
So, I'm a little bit confused about how we're needing to talk to Noah about because
[59:12]
weren't you a part of that as well?
[59:14]
Would you mind sharing that?
[59:16]
Do you see, like all of a sudden, now that space would be, have to be a lot different?
[59:23]
No, I don't think, I don't think Noah has dramatically different needs than we have today
[59:28]
in the future.
[59:29]
I mean basically we need space, you know, for staff and for meetings, I think it's very valuable for no offices and city offices to be together for the benefit of our residents and members.
[59:44]
But it's going to be, it'll be a process getting land, you know, available from NOAA for a city hall.
[59:53]
So, the more detail we can get right now on space, we have to figure out what we would do.
[1:00:00]
I'll point field, you know, that's a premier soccer pitch right now in North Oaks. So anything at all that can help us get there. I think it's worth the money. I do the study. It's my opinion.
[1:00:12]
Well, and when I had talked to BCI, they had said, like, the next step would be to meet with an architect for both Noah and the city and to give the list. And that's really, I mean, part of that work has been done from the 400 village center.
[1:00:29]
it has. It's not like you guys have been doing nothing for the last year. I've seen
[1:00:33]
all the information that's coming across my email. But in fairness, I think maybe Mark
[1:00:38]
and Grover would agree. We tried to shoehorn into 400 village center type without being able to
[1:00:44]
talk about future needs particularly for the city. Well, which is really nice if you're coming
[1:00:50]
together from one standpoint where, you know, working with someone that can help make sure that
[1:00:56]
me it's our mat. Right.
[1:01:00]
Thank you.
[1:01:04]
I think mod can help us with a program as well. If we get to that point,
[1:01:09]
it seems like we need that. But anyway, did you work directly with mod with the fire station?
[1:01:18]
That was already done at the time. All those plans were done and put in place. It was just
[1:01:25]
it was by the time I got there they were they had just bid it and we're waiting for the bids to come back.
[1:01:30]
So that was all complete.
[1:01:32]
And have you worked with him, too, Kevin?
[1:01:35]
I was there from the beginning.
[1:01:37]
So, yes.
[1:01:43]
Do you have a motion?
[1:01:45]
Yes.
[1:01:46]
So, Rover made the initial motion.
[1:01:48]
Mark seconded it.
[1:01:50]
And then we had discussion.
[1:01:52]
Can you further discussion or anything?
[1:01:54]
What are the items in the motion?
[1:01:56]
What are we?
[1:01:56]
So, it was basically giving discretion to myself,
[1:02:00]
but it was item one.
[1:02:02]
prepare the concept sketch floor plan and site plan. I would skip the rendering for now.
[1:02:09]
I would do number three and I would skip four for now.
[1:02:16]
So that is my motion.
[1:02:23]
Any further, do you have anything else from hearing bill? Anything else?
[1:02:29]
I sure you don't want to give them a little leeway for the schedule. You know, so if they talk about it, it might help.
[1:02:38]
I'm open to having that discussion with him or if you want to give a little further
[1:02:45]
discretion you could involve Mark and Grover who are on that task group, I'm fine with
[1:02:51]
that too.
[1:02:54]
So if you want to make your family a amendment, I will wait to need the Roberts rules.
[1:03:01]
Yeah, that would be fine.
[1:03:03]
I'll do that.
[1:03:04]
Just don't.
[1:03:05]
I'll accept that.
[1:03:11]
So with a border in a friendly amendment, I can't remember.
[1:03:14]
Yeah, critically, technically yes.
[1:03:16]
If you make a motion to a minute, then it should be more relevant.
[1:03:20]
In a situation like this, I think we're fine.
[1:03:22]
Let's just accept any amendment and voting on the amendment.
[1:03:26]
And no other discussion from anyone else.
[1:03:29]
Questions?
[1:03:30]
Okay. All in favor?
[1:03:32]
All right.
[1:03:33]
Opposed?
[1:03:34]
No.
[1:03:34]
Okay.
[1:03:35]
Motion carries.
[1:03:38]
Next item
[1:03:39]
would be our city council member reports
[1:03:48]
Andrew, do you want to turn it?
[1:03:51]
I don't think
[1:03:54]
you can talk to about the city hall.
[1:03:56]
Yes, absolutely.
[1:04:00]
And Sarah?
[1:04:02]
Yes.
[1:04:02]
Okay.
[1:04:02]
The Pleasant Lake Task Force met today.
[1:04:06]
When was a big update?
[1:04:08]
Our barricons, something, our consultant, Joe,
[1:04:12]
brought some heavy materials.
[1:04:15]
one being the phase two proposal in approach he would take. In addition, he also
[1:04:21]
ride one final test that is that he wants to do this October and November which
[1:04:28]
is a sediment-coring test. It's not free and I want to be very clear. I'll talk
[1:04:34]
about the sediment-coring and talking with Kevin since that meaning so it's very
[1:04:38]
fresh. That's why I didn't bring the concept of my guess we all just learned
[1:04:42]
about this at 12 o'clock.
[1:04:44]
But the sediment corn was not in the initial estimates that we had.
[1:04:51]
So I will say that the entire taskers, it was unanimous
[1:04:55]
that we would recommend it, that we do this testing
[1:04:59]
to be a thorough and especially in pleasant length,
[1:05:04]
because one of the known issues is that all G-booms
[1:05:07]
and Joe talked about how this particular task
[1:05:11]
would help him get to more the cause of those algae blooms, I think it's on the West Bank
[1:05:17]
where they're West Bay, where they're particularly very bad.
[1:05:22]
Anyhow, I have a request for this council,
[1:05:27]
because Canada and I believe it's going to
[1:05:30]
cost us an additional time K, be aware that NOAA is also going to hear this, and they're
[1:05:35]
going to take it back to their board, I believe Andrew Hawkins is going to ask NOAA to
[1:05:41]
support this college too, but in order to get moving with the testing because he needs
[1:05:47]
to do it in October. I wondered if somehow we could get authorization for that additional
[1:05:54]
dollar amount. And we believe it's going to be 10k, but instead of coming back here second
[1:06:00]
time, if it comes in a little bit more, we wanted a little discussion and we were thinking Kevin.
[1:06:06]
Yeah, so I think the current shortfall, if you will, would probably be like 20, so our portion would have been 10, but for a little bit of the safety net, I think I would recommend 20, even though we know that Noah is generally supportive of that and we'll likely do that next week, but it gives us a little bit of flexibility.
[1:06:27]
As some of the issues are, the bills aren't going to come in for a few of these to late
[1:06:32]
in the year.
[1:06:33]
So right now they're estimates, so based on the estimates I can see that the city would
[1:06:38]
have a potential 10K shortfall or 20 if we were covering it in its entirety.
[1:06:45]
But we think it's necessary, it was highly supported by Don Pereira and those on the commission
[1:06:50]
from Joe, Saint Paul regional, our players that are on their
[1:06:56]
volumil. So that's one of those things that I think we have to do it in a way
[1:07:00]
it's kind of an on a fan change order as well. But if you remember last year when we
[1:07:06]
levied for this, we didn't know any of us. We had to just kind of pick a number out of
[1:07:10]
the sky to see where we would land. I think we did a pretty good job staying
[1:07:14]
within that framework. But we need this extra piece of data so that we can
[1:07:19]
grass into next year and then for next year is also be part of the budget discussion
[1:07:25]
that council can weigh in on what they want to do or don't want to do.
[1:07:30]
We have to open with a quorum, where we cannot be found. Is there any further insight? Is it late quarters?
[1:07:40]
I mean, I have been happy to pass on. So it's in the water. They use basically a cylindrical tube in the collection mud and sand and other materials and then that's tested from there.
[1:07:54]
Kate can probably answer a lot better than I come as being an engineer, but that's why I bet that.
[1:08:01]
I think it's also tied to the, I have not a scientist. I shouldn't be even speaking, but we talked with the phosphorus levels and the release rates.
[1:08:09]
And so he's trying to go after them, and the time to do it is in that sediment in October, November.
[1:08:16]
But we don't have much runway. So that's why I think I need to ask this council where you would stand on this.
[1:08:23]
and I believe no one's going to bring this up next week too.
[1:08:27]
I mean, I am in favor and the entire task
[1:08:30]
for us is asking for support to get this done,
[1:08:33]
so that we can move on, which is the second part.
[1:08:37]
I don't want to get too much into it
[1:08:38]
because we've asked our work to make a one page.
[1:08:41]
We received the phase two proposal,
[1:08:43]
which is an important for 2027 as we budget.
[1:08:48]
And we're going to talk about that on 1921
[1:08:50]
or big budget session.
[1:08:51]
But we do have an amount where our consultant is trying to develop a link management plan.
[1:08:59]
That's where we're headed to, right?
[1:09:01]
We want to know how to type a project we should implement.
[1:09:06]
Before we do that, we have Phase 2, which is the development of the Lake Management Plan,
[1:09:13]
which she wants to hit the ground running in October, so that come late April.
[1:09:17]
That is one, this community will see a like management plan, but that cost of that is, what was it?
[1:09:25]
Where I knew I knew that.
[1:09:25]
Well, and I haven't written front of me, but we just got it today, just so it calls elsewhere.
[1:09:31]
So that collect sediment cores was five grand laboratory analysis and sediment samples was 22,000.
[1:09:38]
And then technical memorandum is for a total of 35, which is why we were floating around that 15 to 20,
[1:09:46]
that we would need based on what Noah is willing to contribute to the proposed project here
[1:09:52]
that would be completed by end of year.
[1:09:55]
You would be the end of data monitoring so that we can move into phase two.
[1:10:00]
The phase two is what we kind of infertile is coming and the total, what did he, that's me.
[1:10:07]
Total was 35,000.
[1:10:09]
Total is 35,000.
[1:10:09]
Total is 35,000, but these two.
[1:10:11]
So I didn't open phase two, yeah, I was just going to talk a little bit about what the
[1:10:16]
corning is because it's in here, but it's moisture content, both things density and organic
[1:10:22]
matter, mobile phosphorus, aluminum bound phosphorus, organic phosphorus, calcium bound phosphorus,
[1:10:28]
total and extractible iron, total and extractible aluminum, he's got it set at stations S1, S3, S12,
[1:10:36]
us 14, I don't have the map here, but it's within the pleasant link.
[1:10:46]
I mean, I can say that if the council doesn't authorize this, and then it's probably,
[1:10:54]
I'm going to go to the community foundation or something.
[1:10:56]
That's how much I believe we're on a good, we have good momentum, and everyone in the
[1:11:04]
asked or agreed, let's leave no stone unturned at this point.
[1:11:07]
If we want the correct analysis and have the best shot of making an
[1:11:12]
implementation plan, why would we not get the test done?
[1:11:16]
So if we deny this, I'll probably go to the foundation and look for
[1:11:20]
prior donors.
[1:11:23]
Is there a foundation of opportunity?
[1:11:25]
We have it set up.
[1:11:27]
We worked on that three months ago.
[1:11:29]
We have one donor, but that's still not enough.
[1:11:34]
How did it just sort of come up at this point?
[1:11:39]
Why wasn't it contemplated initially?
[1:11:44]
The sediment growing?
[1:11:47]
How should we answer this?
[1:11:49]
I mean, we meet twice a month, and this was one concept,
[1:11:59]
but even some of the testing,
[1:12:02]
he's doing additional month of testing this out there.
[1:12:05]
They're still testing it in the lake, they're pulling samples this month, but so can I say it's sort of iterative based on what he's found so far this came up as this is a further.
[1:12:18]
The more the cast that's going to be a value based on what I found.
[1:12:23]
Yes, it's like peeling back on you and obviously the more he sees out there, this was his final recommendation for a data monitoring.
[1:12:30]
Okay, and this gets us to a management plan and the spring basically, so we'll be able to start
[1:12:36]
acting on the lake at that point.
[1:12:39]
At that point, you would have basically a list of objectives, if you will, certain projects
[1:12:45]
that then cancel and no one could choose to do, probably 28, I think, by the time you get
[1:12:51]
approvals from DNR, regional, your usual, you know, partners like that, but it's a little
[1:13:00]
This is a lot of the questions you're asking,
[1:13:04]
but I think the discussion pretty much hit the nail on the head.
[1:13:10]
I mean, do you need a motion?
[1:13:11]
Yeah, basically what the motion I would like to see is to throw myself essentially to up to 20,000, I would say it, it's time what I'm seeing.
[1:13:24]
I work with Noah and the city to make sure that the sediment, coring and or assessment is performed in 2026.
[1:13:30]
So,
[1:13:35]
I'm going to, in supporting this, but I have a question about our budget, so are we
[1:13:40]
now in nine months into it for going into nine months? Are we above or beyond our
[1:13:48]
blower budget for the year? I just think it's an old question. I think it's an old question.
[1:13:54]
It's unordered financial, so I'm not going to give you the best answer that you're probably
[1:13:58]
looking for because you're looking for revenues versus expenses.
[1:14:04]
which I might have here.
[1:14:11]
And if I could just ask the question to Bill, since you're in the room from NOAA, you feel
[1:14:18]
like this is completely supported by NOAA as well and to do cost sharing.
[1:14:25]
Thank you.
[1:14:27]
Yeah.
[1:14:27]
So right now, just high level looks like 70.8 so that I'll experience this is 56.31 with
[1:14:34]
understanding that we haven't had second half to access paid either and we have four
[1:14:40]
months left of building permits so it's a little bit you know it's it's not
[1:14:47]
accurate you know but it's it's a fair evaluation of where we're sitting right now
[1:14:51]
I think we're trending like we always do we expect that we're gonna fall very close
[1:14:55]
like we always do every year where we pull this money from
[1:15:00]
It could only come from reserves. I mean, it would hit one of these lines. I think at the end of the day, be anywhere from town out of the reserve or 20 worse case scenario.
[1:15:11]
Well,
[1:15:15]
this is a visual proposal that may be we had to do some correct.
[1:15:20]
Does it seem like a completely surprised to me?
[1:15:24]
I don't recall though.
[1:15:25]
No, it was in there kind of early, but the problem was we didn't have his proposal until early of
[1:15:32]
2026.
[1:15:32]
So we had to throw an estimated number in there for 26 is a budget which we did.
[1:15:37]
It originally started at 30,000.
[1:15:39]
And we bumped that up to 50 during the budget cycle.
[1:15:43]
We sized proposals and I think March of this year.
[1:15:47]
And then had discussions with the orthodox company with the foundation that we know we're
[1:15:51]
not going to be able to do this, at least right now, in a perfect world.
[1:15:55]
And now we're at that point where we've collected enough data that we think it supports
[1:15:59]
doing the traditional sediment occurring.
[1:16:02]
It's a whole water.
[1:16:04]
There are more.
[1:16:05]
There are more.
[1:16:06]
There are on every meeting we've had.
[1:16:09]
And I want to say they did it, they did this test how many years ago, but it's now
[1:16:15]
part of that window we need to get it out of it and see if our regional water was one of,
[1:16:21]
I think it was the entity that did this.
[1:16:24]
That we thought we were just contributing to that.
[1:16:25]
That's what I was just going to do.
[1:16:27]
We've already tried, but honestly, I have to say they have committed resources and their knowledge,
[1:16:34]
And that is better than nothing as we need them at table.
[1:16:39]
I think if you saw a commitment from them, it would be on the project phase, not the study phase.
[1:16:45]
And I think it would be the same on the DNR and the Vellommel's part that they'd be more in the tune with the actual project.
[1:16:51]
I think the same could be said about the companies.
[1:16:53]
They would likely be more interested in the actual, to meet the project, not the initial study to gather the information.
[1:17:02]
What I suspect is going to happen is when we come back and eat brawl, assuming that everyone agrees to support the sufferer in
[1:17:10]
2027, and no one gets the money who is sitting against the money.
[1:17:14]
Well, end up having a few hours in the flammal ten-year plan.
[1:17:18]
I think it's going to look like that.
[1:17:19]
It's going to be a table of possible projects to combat certain issues and he's going to suggest it with high-level dollar bonds.
[1:17:29]
And that's when we're going to have to work together with these entities to go after possibly grants, depending on the item, and work with sample original water on certain line items where they can strategically, you know, work in parallel with us or same with llama. It's just going to come down to which one makes sense.
[1:17:53]
Well, I walked the lake nearly every day. It's trouble. So I moved to approve.
[1:18:00]
So we have the existing, or no, sorry, that was the last one.
[1:18:05]
Yeah. Mark, go ahead.
[1:18:07]
That was it. Just everything I've heard just in just observing it were this far into it,
[1:18:19]
continue to support it.
[1:18:21]
And pleasant like is the crown jewel of North Oaks, so definitely, it's important and thank you for all of your work on this because I know you've been deeply entrenched, and I hope that, you know, I give credit to you.
[1:18:40]
So I've been preparing to work with you.
[1:18:43]
So while it's too late, it's not going to break the day.
[1:18:46]
Do I have a second?
[1:18:48]
I would second that.
[1:18:49]
OK.
[1:18:51]
So any further discussion?
[1:18:55]
All those in favor?
[1:18:57]
I.
[1:18:58]
Motion carries.
[1:18:59]
Thank you.
[1:18:59]
Did you?
[1:19:00]
I don't know if I can hold on.
[1:19:02]
Can I have a second?
[1:19:03]
I don't know.
[1:19:04]
You can hold on.
[1:19:05]
I can't hold on.
[1:19:05]
Yeah.
[1:19:07]
I don't see any issue that you're voting on there.
[1:19:09]
OK.
[1:19:09]
Of course.
[1:19:11]
And I don't just want to come to C2, we'll probably talk more about phase two on the budget.
[1:19:17]
Yeah, because it's tied to the levee for next year.
[1:19:21]
And then the council decide what dollar proportion they want to put in.
[1:19:24]
So I'll likely send that phase two tomorrow.
[1:19:27]
Yeah, let the council see that.
[1:19:29]
What it's all about.
[1:19:30]
No, I'll do the same.
[1:19:31]
I would assume next week.
[1:19:32]
You know, they're kind of in that same cycle of building for next year.
[1:19:37]
And assuming that no one finds out their funding situation, it'll be enough for the task for us to, you know, set this in motion and not to over it.
[1:19:46]
That's why we write it to you so quickly, because I think Kevin had realized we couldn't wait till men not to over to get us.
[1:19:54]
Okay.
[1:19:55]
Thanks.
[1:19:56]
All right.
[1:19:56]
Okay. Great.
[1:19:57]
Thank you.
[1:19:57]
Mark, do you have anything to remember?
[1:19:59]
No, we're in between fireboard meetings, so.
[1:20:01]
Okay.
[1:20:01]
Great.
[1:20:02]
And I just have a reminder for North Oaks-Ramage Sale this weekend, and also Farm Fest on Sunday, so.
[1:20:10]
And we're looking for volunteers for that Farm Fest, Mark's currently going, so if anybody else is interested, let Debbie know.
[1:20:17]
Yeah, and I was able to.
[1:20:20]
So, I'm going to miss it.
[1:20:22]
Yeah, so.
[1:20:24]
Okay.
[1:20:26]
Anything else administered across that you have to report?
[1:20:29]
No, I listed a couple of this random updates there in 11A.
[1:20:37]
Yeah.
[1:20:37]
Working on an ordinance isn't stuff for planning.
[1:20:40]
We have a couple other applications with them for some soil.
[1:20:45]
We have one for a septic.
[1:20:47]
We've had a couple more septics coming in.
[1:20:50]
We'll have a compound amendment request.
[1:20:54]
So we'll have some business to deal with on October.
[1:20:57]
You said variances for our septics?
[1:21:00]
Yeah.
[1:21:00]
One's a variance.
[1:21:01]
One's a compliant request to go from septic to sewer.
[1:21:08]
Can I go back and ask a question about the speed data?
[1:21:11]
Sure.
[1:21:12]
I know that you didn't know the cost.
[1:21:14]
Yeah.
[1:21:14]
Is it one of those things we want to wait a whole month?
[1:21:17]
Or is it something we can get moving sooner?
[1:21:21]
I mean, Carl's looks moved forward on it.
[1:21:22]
We just didn't have a direct number.
[1:21:25]
You know, it's like a subscription was my understanding. I just don't recall how much it was it could have been $200.
[1:21:33]
It could have been multiple thousands of dollars right back.
[1:21:37]
That's what I was going to ask is the budget session.
[1:21:42]
I could.
[1:21:44]
It's really strictly meant for the preliminary tax levian budget and setting the TNT.
[1:21:51]
It's not that I couldn't add another item.
[1:21:53]
That's fine if council has been to do that, but if it's below a certain dollar or you just want me to do it
[1:22:00]
That's what I'm wondering if it's like
[1:22:03]
We're talking three hundred four dollars. I mean, I'm fine with you doing it. Do you have something to do that what you are?
[1:22:13]
First sign so I think you guys could just say this is it seems this even
[1:22:21]
I don't know if I wanted to sign or hear a thousand bucks, something like that, and here's my
[1:22:30]
My question is because there's a lot of times two that we get data that we don't use or we don't have someone to then pay them to make changes.
[1:22:41]
It sounds like RCSO is most interested in it, so I'd probably work with one of their staff members.
[1:22:49]
So that would be helpful for them?
[1:22:52]
Yeah, I don't know that.
[1:22:52]
We would do a ton with it because we would be turning it over to Noah and our RCSL or look at potential speed changes.
[1:23:02]
I think it does.
[1:23:03]
That's the right idea of what exactly is happening out there because, you know,
[1:23:07]
that you live and can't see everything all the time.
[1:23:10]
And those signs see everything all the time.
[1:23:13]
At those locations.
[1:23:16]
I mean, can we give you, can we authorize?
[1:23:18]
or you just find what?
[1:23:19]
I think you want to set up as a 4,000, 1,000,000,000.
[1:23:22]
What do you need?
[1:23:23]
1K?
[1:23:24]
I would honestly say probably 1,500 if it happens to be 500 a sign, which I hope it's not.
[1:23:32]
But...
[1:23:32]
I'm okay with 1,500.
[1:23:33]
Can you introduce for that?
[1:23:36]
And that would be for a year, probably.
[1:23:38]
It's probably a yearly thing.
[1:23:40]
And then we would just bake that in to budget.
[1:23:42]
So I made it to make some micro adjustments to that.
[1:23:45]
So I was first by Sarah's second Andrew, I get that right.
[1:23:52]
Yes, okay, any further discussion?
[1:23:56]
No, all those in favor.
[1:23:58]
Hi, my motion carries.
[1:23:59]
Thank you.
[1:24:01]
Any more?
[1:24:01]
You'd like us to spend money on this, Sarah.
[1:24:04]
Thank you.
[1:24:05]
Thank you.
[1:24:05]
I know.
[1:24:06]
I know.
[1:24:08]
Okay.
[1:24:09]
Bridget, too.
[1:24:10]
Have anything?
[1:24:11]
I do.
[1:24:11]
Great.
[1:24:14]
And that is it. Do I have an motion to adjourn?
[1:24:18]
Oh, second.
[1:24:19]
All right, all those in favor.
[1:24:21]
All right.
[1:24:23]
Motion.
[1:24:23]
We are adjourned.
[1:24:25]
And the next meeting that I'd just like to call attention to is our budget meeting.
[1:24:30]
And that will be the 21st of September at 6 o'clock p.m.
[1:24:35]
6.
[1:24:36]
6 o'clock.
[1:24:37]
Thanks a lot.
[1:24:37]
All right.
[1:24:38]
Thank you.
[1:24:39]
So, yeah, I better get that out of my calendar.