Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
This transcript looks like it may be hallucinated by the transcription model (not a real transcript of what was said) -- treat it as unreliable. This can happen when the source audio is unusually quiet, corrupted, or otherwise hard to transcribe.
[0:00]
So I'm going to start this meeting at 601. Do you mind starting the recording please?
[0:05]
Okay. Can I get a motion to accept the agenda please?
[0:10]
So move. Thanks for Nanda, is there a second?
[0:13]
It's half second. Okay. Remember we need to adjust for the snapshots. Oh, I was just going to see if we're going to move it. Okay. All right. All those in favor of the agenda please signify by saying aye.
[0:30]
Hi.
[0:31]
Hi.
[0:36]
Gave in Barbara.
[0:40]
All those opposed.
[0:43]
Staining.
[0:44]
Okay.
[0:45]
We have an agenda.
[0:47]
So we're going to start the meeting out.
[0:48]
We've invited the legislators for that represent our district here tonight.
[0:53]
And online, you can see Senator David Weeks.
[0:56]
Senator Terry Williams, representative Peter Conlin.
[0:59]
And we also have representative Alicia Malay over here.
[1:04]
So thank you all for coming, we appreciate it very much.
[1:10]
I just wanted to say that we were hoping that you could kind of give us an update of what's going on in the legislature right now,
[1:17]
and then hopefully open it up to questions.
[1:20]
That's okay with you guys.
[1:26]
It's fine.
[1:27]
This is Dave.
[1:28]
I would like to recommend that representative Peter Conland as the chair of the House Education Committee.
[1:34]
House, we read a song,
[1:39]
chair of Conland is dealing with the issue all day long while in the Senate Education Committee as one of the two committees and the Representative Conland has recently introduced some language and a mock which I think would be a great interest to the school.
[2:07]
That's fine, David, I'm happy to lead off if that would be helpful.
[2:13]
So can you hear me okay first of all?
[2:16]
Great.
[2:19]
So Peter Conland, I represent Goshen and Lester within the Art of Valley District, the chair
[2:25]
of the House Education Committee, I live in Cornwall,
[2:30]
I think it's fair to say that
[2:33]
legislature in general, certainly the House Education Committee. I think in general, we are somewhat
[2:40]
struggling to continue to work on Act 73 given the feedback we've received in many different forms
[2:50]
and ways from the redistricting task force to the Commission on the Future of Public Education into
[2:57]
thousands of comments from Vermonters between the passage of Act 73 last year and where we sit today.
[3:08]
Act 73 essentially says, let's move to a state of newer larger districts and move our funding formula from the way we do it today to the way most states do it using a foundation formula
[3:26]
in which every school district is funded based on the profile of each and every student.
[3:35]
You know, the funding formula part is complex mathematical academic and sort of behind the scenes,
[3:42]
but everybody sort of gets the concept.
[3:46]
The newer larger districts represents, you know, a very significant change in how we do things.
[3:53]
And I think it's fair to say it is very hard to get consensus on how that should be and what that should look like.
[4:04]
So the committee that I chair, the House Education Committee was basically kind of stuck talking about the higher level concepts that we're hard to talk about without having something to react to.
[4:17]
So, two weeks ago, I put on the table a map, really there for discussion purposes.
[4:25]
Mainly, however, it was done with some thought to feedback we've heard from both academic
[4:34]
researchers, the Superintendents Association, sort of for mantras in general, so it breaks
[4:42]
the state up into districts of 2 to 4,000 districts that have 2 to 4,000 students in
[4:47]
roughly, they would be all school districts, not supervisory unions so that we can have sort
[4:55]
of a uniform set of operating protocols throughout the state that's calling me it so
[5:00]
that they're all governed by statute rather than each kind of doing its own thing.
[5:07]
But not surprisingly, that creates a lot of conflict, we've got people who are concerned
[5:15]
about newer larger districts mandated by the state, changing a culture of local control.
[5:24]
Act 46 did a bit of that, but I 46 was in many ways for many people voluntary as opposed
[5:31]
to the state saying this is how it's going to be done.
[5:36]
Personally, I'm a believer that act 46 is a proven concept and perhaps it's time that the whole
[5:42]
move to that sort of newer larger district, which is why what I put forward talks about
[5:49]
27 districts across the state ranging from 2 to 4,000 students. With that, I added some
[5:57]
language sort of operationalizes it that says, these are school districts. They are not
[6:03]
supervisor unions, one board governing the newer larger district. No such thing as a non-operating
[6:10]
district, basically, every district has got the resources to provide a K-12 education,
[6:19]
whether a high school level, for example, that is an independent school, one of the
[6:24]
four historic academies, or a public school.
[6:29]
But essentially it says that, you know, school boards assigned students to how they're going
[6:37]
the educated within their district, just as it's done for the vast vast majority of
[6:43]
amongst students today, you know, sort of how that happens can be somewhat left up to
[6:50]
the local school board,
[6:54]
and, you know, so you can imagine the pushback on it, it effectively
[6:59]
eliminate sort of the parental town tuition choice program that we have, it is newer
[7:06]
larger districts, it gets rid of supervisory unions within which we have lots of
[7:12]
different delivery systems.
[7:16]
It puts, I would say, a level of fear in much of
[7:21]
over month about what a sort of born represents a larger geographic area.
[7:30]
They may not have the same investment in the smaller communities.
[7:38]
As I say, smaller communities are struggling
[7:41]
through declining enrollment, staffing and construction needs, anyway, to me a larger board overseeing
[7:51]
or a board overseeing a larger district allows sort of a more strategic way of dealing
[7:58]
with declining enrollment. Anyway, so I put that on the table. My community is essentially reacting
[8:04]
to it. I would say what I put on the table, every member of my committee has something
[8:10]
in it that they cannot get beyond. For some it is the elimination of choice as we know it.
[8:18]
For others, it's the elimination of the SU model. For others, it's a fear of what the foundation
[8:24]
formula may hold in the future, but we can't really calculate that until we know what the districts
[8:30]
are going to be. So, you know, we are, I would say, struggling, but I think the committee
[8:37]
that I chair is a microcosm of the legislature writ large and sort of struggles that
[8:45]
we're going to face to make major change. I am a believer that now is an opportunity that
[8:54]
we need to have these hard conversations, our enrollment is not growing, we've our costs are,
[9:04]
and we're reached to point where we need to make some hard decisions, but I'm not sure
[9:09]
that for monitors are ready for the level of change that is proposed to an X73 originally,
[9:16]
or that sort of I put on the table and that others that put on the table. I'll stop there, maybe
[9:21]
over to my Senate counterparts. Today they got their first look at a map of their own and operational
[9:28]
language of their own, which may be they could talk a little bit further about. But there's a
[9:32]
lot being talked about up here. That's for sure turning that into the next big step in the
[9:47]
I'll pick it up from there if you want, or Peter.
[9:53]
They will pay you up to the chair, I would say.
[9:56]
Yeah, go ahead.
[9:58]
So I just want to say that collectively, the legislature, the education committees.
[10:07]
In the end, we'll set the policy.
[10:10]
We've been taking testimony, we've been doing school tours.
[10:13]
And I'm not one, I'm only one vote in my community of six, but I'm also very interested in the people that actually do it for a living and what they need to have happen to make this successful.
[10:31]
I believe you know a lot more about your district than I do.
[10:34]
And we've been listening to them in a totally, there's some point we need to put something
[10:39]
lines on them out and I could have done that, you know, the first week of the last session.
[10:47]
It was with, you know, 73 pass. We got time period to get it and we're trying to get out in front
[10:56]
of declining student population of the half of every year. And I'm not sure how we do that.
[11:03]
So it's kind of like trying to get out of train going 90 miles an hour that we need to get this.
[11:10]
I think the foundation formula will be finalized and implemented in the 2020 night.
[11:19]
So some people say that we should just implement the foundation formula now.
[11:25]
What things happen organically?
[11:28]
I'm not sure, I'm not qualified to make that combination, so as a member of the committee, I'm
[11:35]
sitting there listening in County and when I'm asked to make a decision for a board, I'll
[11:41]
make that decision.
[11:43]
And I'm, I'm, Terry Williams, representing Rotten County from Colby.
[11:53]
Okay, thank you, Peter, and thank you, Terry.
[11:55]
This is Dave Leak's, I represent Rebellion County, but I live in Proctor.
[12:03]
What I'm going to do is just provide a perspective from my viewpoint only on where I think
[12:12]
we're going, everyone, and I'm not representing the committee and I'm not representing
[12:19]
the caucus, so where I think we're going, I think that's a superintendents or going to
[12:25]
end up being tagged with a larger geographic footprint. School principles will remain the focal
[12:32]
point for the community. But I do believe that that's superintendents will basically
[12:39]
the focus will carry back and they'll be responsible for a larger geographic area to make
[12:45]
regional decisions. So that's one point. Second, organic district thing. I think it doesn't
[12:54]
provide the speed that we need for the property tax issue, although that would be, I think
[13:04]
everyone's preference.
[13:05]
I don't think that as history would tell us that we don't have the luxury of that type
[13:13]
of multi-year runway ahead of us.
[13:17]
Bocees regions, definite possibility, but Bocees are already in legislation as I believe
[13:23]
the school boarder of the understands.
[13:25]
We're also also wrestling with a bill that Senator Baruch introduced, Senator
[13:33]
Baruch is the President of the Senate.
[13:36]
Here is a lot of weight with the chamber.
[13:40]
He introduced a spending cap bill, which is going to get a lot of mileage of the next
[13:45]
couple weeks.
[13:47]
I do want to reassure the board that political leadership and the leadership
[13:53]
the education, those who shape education policy and fiscal policy, they meet regularly and we're
[14:01]
talking at least every week, if not more frequently. And I do believe that the current
[14:07]
superintendents are really part of the overall solution here. I've re-anticized all the superintendents
[14:15]
in our region that we really want your input. It's critical to fully understanding where
[14:23]
This we're out to see me three should be going
[14:27]
One of the issues which I want to share with with the board is that
[14:32]
One of the one effort that I think is critical is it whether you're in the House Education Committee the Senate Education
[14:42]
The money committees in the House and the Senate
[14:44]
The Secretary of Education and the Governor, etc, and we have to find what the common we have to agree with the common goals
[14:52]
are we're back 73 so we find that overlapping synergy and that.
[15:00]
Conversation gets a little bit diluted. When we're talking about one particular map versus another particular map, I think we need to agree on what those goals are, and I think that will infinitely help us shape the strategy ahead.
[15:14]
There are now maybe five or six different map versions, so that's going to go a little confusing over time.
[15:23]
Perhaps on a column, introduce his a couple of weeks ago, our chair in the Senate Education.
[15:29]
Senator Suckbaum, go out from Bancin, introduce Bancin County, introduce his concept today,
[15:36]
which we're still trying to understand and such.
[15:39]
And you know what I want to leave everyone with the impression that and I think if I'm
[15:46]
sitting on a common set it already there is no consensus right now on the approach.
[15:53]
And so we're dealing with two different education committees, one in the House, one in the Senate.
[15:58]
We're dealing with the finance committees, appropriations committees, the general and the governor.
[16:03]
We're going with Secretary of Education, we've got a number of special interest groups who are weighing in.
[16:12]
And no matter how much people want to find common ground, we're not there yet.
[16:17]
And it's going to be a pretty tough slog ahead.
[16:22]
So I think the three of us are the only representatives who are online.
[16:27]
We're interested in what the board has to feed back to us on your perspective on where
[16:35]
this good goes should go, shouldn't go, etc.
[16:42]
Well, if you don't mind, I might talk a moment just a chair talk about the politics involved here.
[16:49]
The governor has said, get me maps where I won't sign the state budget.
[16:54]
And that's a pretty definitive threat, you know, you could shut down government, come July 1st, if we don't have a budget in place.
[17:07]
And we have, you know, politics at the local level where some people say, if I vote for something that I believe threatens the existence of the small town, a small schools in my area, I can't vote for it.
[17:22]
We've got people who say it's the foundation formula is going to mean my district is going to get less money
[17:30]
I can't vote for it. We've got people. So you can imagine that and meanwhile, where I feel the worst is that we are
[17:38]
holding up school districts who want to make decisions about their own future and do some long-term planning.
[17:46]
And we keep saying, you know, or they keep saying, let's wait and see what the legislature does.
[17:51]
And at a certain point, we have to say we've done what we can now you all need to move forward.
[17:59]
You know, one thing that I think we can all agree on, that we were discussing today in our committee,
[18:04]
is the critical need for the state to come up with some sort of school construction a formula.
[18:12]
And that's, you know, if there's one thing we have consensus on is probably that.
[18:18]
But as Senator Weeks said, fine, he can set us around some of the bigger issues is definitely
[18:23]
challenging.
[18:29]
Does anybody have anything they want to start with?
[18:34]
Go ahead, Brett.
[18:35]
Broadly speaking, the fact that you said who you are.
[18:38]
Oh, yeah.
[18:39]
Brett Mullen Pissford.
[18:40]
So foundation funding.
[18:43]
Broadly speaking, who does that benefit versus who does what districts that would negatively
[18:48]
impact?
[18:50]
All right, so, you know, to put bluntly, well, first of all, hopefully it would, you know,
[18:57]
everybody would have the ability to maneuver their district to accommodate it.
[19:02]
But the fact is, it levels out state funding.
[19:07]
So if you are a low per pupil spending district, you come out ahead because the idea is that, you know,
[19:20]
I would imagine that those who are spending below the state average probably do better and those who are spending above the state average probably would see their funding curtail.
[19:29]
Depending, of course, on lots of factors, what is the profile of all of the students in your new district?
[19:41]
I have a bunch more, but other people can ask first.
[19:44]
Oh, you're so sweet.
[19:46]
OK.
[19:47]
It's one else.
[19:50]
I have some feedback, but not questions.
[19:51]
I just prefer to use questions.
[19:53]
OK.
[19:55]
I have a question then since no one else seems to be asking.
[19:58]
I want to know how this works with other things that we need in this state.
[20:04]
Number one is healthcare.
[20:06]
You know that healthcare is one of the biggest costs in our district.
[20:10]
And what is being done to work on finding a way to make health care less costly in the state,
[20:18]
which would in turn reduce our budgets as well?
[20:27]
Great question. I'll be brief so the others can say something.
[20:31]
Last year we passed a few things that I have, in fact, it helped for example,
[20:36]
bring down the V-high premium increase. It was still an increase, but I've brought that
[20:43]
increase down. Basically saying that, you know, hospitals for example can no longer charge
[20:49]
exorbitant rates on prescription drugs. We have reference-based pricing being put into place.
[20:56]
I think in the next couple of years that should help as well. But the fact of the matter is
[21:03]
just like education, our demographics make reducing the actual cost of healthcare in this state
[21:10]
really challenging. As does our sort of objection, just as we don't like to close schools,
[21:21]
we also don't like to close hospitals and we are basically an over-hospital state and it is
[21:33]
or insurance pool is way out of whack for what you would want.
[21:40]
So people say, well, let's not tackle education
[21:43]
reform until we solve health care.
[21:46]
Health care is probably not solvable without some sort
[21:49]
of national change.
[21:50]
We can nibble at the edges, but we can't make a big debt.
[21:58]
Yeah, this is Dave.
[22:00]
I agree with Brooks and Colin.
[22:03]
Both Senator Williams and I are alumni of the Senate health and welfare committee, where we spent two years trying to get our head around Vermont health care challenges.
[22:17]
So I like Representative Collin and not very encouraged that we have a solution.
[22:25]
I think we're biting around the edges.
[22:27]
I think that's...
[22:30]
Prescription, caps and various initiatives are not going to drag down the overall cost of health care, which, in fact, just make sure everyone's on the same sheet of music here.
[22:45]
There are health care costs or three times out of the Reneber State New Hampshire.
[22:52]
And I do agree with Representative Colin, this is really a national issue, and in fact,
[23:00]
I would put the bulk of the issue with, we send around the National Immigration policy.
[23:11]
that we could solve many of our problems with bringing in labor from a trained skilled labor
[23:21]
from outside the U.S., but that perspective is not a share at the national level at this
[23:29]
point.
[23:30]
And I wanted to make just one comment, this again is based on one representative's experience
[23:38]
with the Health and Welfare Committee is what I call the 40-60 rule that 40 percent of
[23:45]
our monitors pay for their own health care, and then they also pay for the other 60 percent
[23:51]
of our monitors.
[23:52]
Now I know that's a very broad generalization, but it gives you the essence of the problem
[23:57]
in a nutshell, that we're a little too generous, and it's costiness, dearly, with all of the
[24:09]
demographic challenges that are up to them in a column I want.
[24:13]
So I don't think that we're going to track to solve one of the major cost drivers that's
[24:20]
affecting education costs after those very reasons, but we're trying to affect the issues
[24:28]
which are in our hands within the education community.
[24:34]
So, when I've got something to have to, we have a number of cost drivers affecting education,
[24:40]
they're also affecting everything else, and I personally have spoken to Governor Scott
[24:44]
about, you know, if you could do one thing, what we do, if you were governor, and I said,
[24:51]
fixed to a healthcare.
[24:53]
So, I know there's a bill of House 82 in right now, which is addressing that, the Green
[25:00]
Moon Careboard is, is working to bring down prescription drug prices as much as we can
[25:06]
in the state, but we are such a small insurance pool to draw from, that we're pretty much limited.
[25:12]
I mean, Blue Cross Blue Shield had a very far bankruptcy and they had to merge with Blue Cross Blue Shield and Michigan to stay solid.
[25:23]
So we have some problems. I don't think the education committee is the place you want that we're going to get a fix.
[25:30]
And I think it just diverts from the education issues that were in policy issues returning to fix that education.
[25:44]
Kevin first.
[25:46]
So I did think of the question, what's the future for CTE look like?
[25:51]
And I asked this because if I could wave a magic wand for our district, the one thing I do.
[25:58]
First thing I do anyway is make CTE opportunities available to every kid that wants one.
[26:06]
And I think that's true for at least much of the rural area in the state.
[26:11]
So I'd like to hear what the plans are. Thank you.
[26:17]
The Secretary of Education has a new, broad CTE bill that's been introduced.
[26:26]
It's a major change in our country where it's going to go.
[26:30]
But there are, there are some philosophies built into it.
[26:32]
One of which is, yes, standalone CTE centers are an important part of how we move forward.
[26:39]
But so is pushing the CTE into high schools that kind of accommodate it, especially when we talk about CTE, we're not just talking about programs that require a big garage to work on cars and tractors, but all you really need is a, you know, a CNC machine.
[27:00]
So, I think that the, I'd say that the future is probably going to include more CTE type opportunities within our high schools as they exist.
[27:14]
Not quite sure how we're going to get there.
[27:17]
But CTE remains one of the unsolved major challenges that we have moving forward within Act 73,
[27:27]
because we have to figure out how to fund it on an equitable statewide level.
[27:32]
And right now, you know, the CTE and Middlebury for example,
[27:36]
tuition is about $34,000 per FTE student.
[27:40]
Others are much cheaper.
[27:42]
They have 200 spaces for 200 kids.
[27:45]
Staffers got waiting list.
[27:47]
How do we write that ship and balance it out so that
[27:52]
you know, tuition's come down and students have more access.
[27:57]
And of course, like many things in education,
[27:59]
it comes down to time sitting on a bus.
[28:02]
A lot of kids just say, you know, I don't want to spend half my day driving back to
[28:05]
fourth to a CTE if I can get that in my home high school,
[28:11]
but then that pulls the key out of the CTE program.
[28:13]
So making all these things work is challenging,
[28:15]
but I do think that the future people seem to agree that the future
[28:20]
needs providing some technical education within the high schools as they exist, really to
[28:26]
meet student demand.
[28:31]
Yeah, I would agree completely with the Rups and Commons.
[28:34]
I think that the one issue that everyone in the Senate Education Committee agrees on is that
[28:41]
CTE is critical enhancing CTE programs as critical to Vermont for a number of reasons,
[28:48]
some of which Rups and Commons outline.
[28:53]
There are, so Representative Cohen referenced the, the waiting list for Stanford.
[29:02]
Well, the waiting list, you know, it's kind of a euphemism.
[29:05]
It's not a waiting list.
[29:06]
It's 80 students who couldn't pick up the program,
[29:09]
but they were motivated to pick up.
[29:12]
And we've got to address that.
[29:15]
There's, you know, what are they waiting for?
[29:18]
waiting for next year or the waiting for more construction, now it's stopped for expand. Are they waiting for
[29:24]
our order of value to be able to set up a satellite, CTE? In the meantime, they're not getting
[29:29]
the technical education they need to be to carry forward on the career. There's a couple of simple
[29:37]
things that in addition to everyone being supportive of CTE. There's a couple of simple things
[29:42]
that are in action, which I do think will move through legislation relatively unscathed.
[29:49]
And what is the concept as simple as common schedule between schools, common Bell schedules,
[29:58]
so that schools know.
[30:00]
It's predictable now, but they're not synergized for the benefit of the student who's going to a CTE, but also has some obligations back at their parent high school.
[30:12]
But I can't leave you with your impression that CTE is, there's not a person in the room who doesn't agree that CTE is, and you've heard the governor articulated, that need all of our support.
[30:26]
And at this state, at this time in state, it's happening.
[30:34]
It's got full score.
[30:37]
But we spent all afternoon with Secretary of Education
[30:41]
Saunders talking to us about CT.
[30:45]
She has a plan of sending out Senator Ron Hingsdale
[30:51]
has a good one right now, which we will focus on, actually right in CT statewide, she's got a good hand a lot, and those two kind of run out of the plan.
[31:04]
So that's how we're going to develop the plan.
[31:07]
It's by looking at where the school houses are.
[31:11]
I mean, we need to end up having to come up with some funding to start a regional high school with the CT center in it.
[31:20]
But that's, that's years from now, we just don't have the money, because we're still
[31:25]
on more touring on school construction.
[31:28]
But that doesn't mean that if a school district decided to merge on or own, and there's
[31:36]
a school house, it was a good shape, that could become a CTE satellite for staffer.
[31:42]
And the other thing is is trying to find the qualified actors that will leave the industry
[31:51]
to come to work for our teachers' wages when they could be making six figures.
[31:57]
You know, you gotta find somebody that's at the end of their work life cycle.
[32:02]
It's willing to come back and share ways around here she's married.
[32:07]
There's a lot of issues out there that have to be resolved to get CT, but everybody
[32:15]
agreed is that I think accident in three the governor's plan was actually grounded in CT.
[32:23]
We need workforce.
[32:24]
We need people to grow and build houses.
[32:27]
We can't people move here to do work.
[32:30]
They can't find a place to stay.
[32:32]
So it's a vicious cycle and we're all focused on trying to fix it, but we're limited to what we can do because of funding.
[32:43]
So, I'll leave it there.
[32:46]
Thank you.
[32:49]
Right, you had your hand raised?
[32:51]
Yeah, I have a question, but there's a little context, I guess, that I have to wrap into it.
[32:57]
And it just seems like, I mean if we could even go all the way back to Act 60 and all the
[33:01]
things that the state sort of done since then to try to fix education,
[33:08]
the problem has
[33:08]
consistently seems to be that what's important to districts or important to voters is drastically
[33:15]
different.
[33:15]
It's sort of a tale of the halves and the half-naughts.
[33:19]
And so for us sitting here, I mean Act 46 was flawed and that it didn't force anything,
[33:23]
But at least you could combine with like-minded groups and sort of foreign boards that had similar goals.
[33:32]
This feels like if you don't go far enough and don't sort of set up what the outcome for facilities,
[33:43]
what the supervisor units here, the district's going to look like, not supervisor unit.
[33:48]
Then you're almost maybe setting districts up for failure in some ways, right?
[33:55]
Because let's say if we pick on Peter's map, right?
[33:58]
I think that showed us merging with Rotland, right?
[34:00]
So, okay, so we merge with Rotland, let's pretend in this hypothetical scenario.
[34:04]
Okay, so does that mean that there's one high school, does that mean that there's two?
[34:09]
What does that mean for our facilities versus what is happening in Rotland?
[34:12]
And what sort of voice would, what's left of our district have in that, and if you don't dictate sort of what that's going to look like,
[34:21]
you're kind of setting us up to be in a room that's hostile because, you know, it's a new board, you've reorganized it.
[34:29]
You said, okay, you're on now one district, but you haven't said, okay, this is the plan for your facilities.
[34:34]
And honestly, cutting down on the overhead of supervisor units isn't really going to fix the problem.
[34:43]
excellent points, all of them. One of the things we struggle with is, you know, you're
[34:51]
actually right, we create new larger districts with new school boards, and then we don't
[34:57]
give them tools to make hard decisions. We've solved some problems, but we haven't, but we've
[35:05]
left the major problems in the hands of these new school boards, and as you say, are we creating
[35:10]
in a hostile room.
[35:13]
Got to balance that with people, you know, say, well, we need to have, you know, some semblance
[35:18]
of local control and if the state dictates everything.
[35:22]
So in the example that you provide sort of the merging of your district in Rutland, you
[35:28]
know, it would be up to the school board to look at the facilities and see what is the
[35:33]
best economical way to move forward, whether the smaller high schools, you know, cease to
[35:39]
exist and the larger ones absorb them. I don't know, but it's trying to find that delicate
[35:46]
balance between who makes those decisions. I am very sympathetic to what you're saying,
[35:54]
which is, you know, don't stick us with the heart choices. You guys make them. But the political
[36:02]
encouraged to do all of it ourselves up here is also perhaps lacking just because it's a
[36:11]
hostel room up here. That's what I'm trying to get past but I agree to review. I'm very
[36:21]
fearful of giving new school boards nothing but sticks which is why school construction
[36:29]
name is at least something that we might be able to offer to say, you know, as a school board,
[36:34]
if you're going to move forward with consolidation, if you took all the sort of Rutland County
[36:39]
high schools or even the Eastern Rutland County high schools and said, you know, go from
[36:45]
four to two, at least we could provide some assistance with that. But your point is very well
[36:51]
taken, I appreciate it.
[36:54]
Can I add something to that?
[36:57]
Okay.
[36:59]
So, you know, I'm looking at, I'm listening to my constituents, I'm listening to my school
[37:06]
boards, and the district, my towns, and they're like, gee, should we be planning on merging,
[37:13]
you know, what should we do?
[37:15]
Can we do that?
[37:15]
Yeah, you can do that.
[37:17]
So here's where I came up with right now, no district has forced, has been forested
[37:23]
All right. That means town still retain leverage. This strategic reality is
[37:30]
The legislature eventually adopts a statewide consolidation map. Towns that have already begun discussions, study fiscal impacts and identified preferred partners.
[37:42]
Negotiating governance structures will be in the stronger position in towns that did nothing.
[37:47]
So I guess you got to ask yourself, should we be looking for like a five-year plan?
[37:53]
You still got the time.
[37:56]
You know, what's a board plan?
[37:57]
I don't know.
[37:58]
It's a town.
[37:59]
I know my town, the three towns that were in my supervisor's district, have already voted
[38:08]
whether they would consider closing the school.
[38:11]
And the answer was yes.
[38:13]
So they see the reality on the ground that eventually we're going to have to, we don't have
[38:18]
the stupid population, we're going to have to do something.
[38:22]
So I guess I'll ask you guys a question, have you been thinking about what you're going
[38:27]
to do because you can't do that?
[38:29]
Oh yeah, we've done some things, we've reached out to other districts seeing if they were
[38:35]
interested in joining with us. And we heard crickets. It's not that it's off the table,
[38:42]
but right now we know they're not interested at this point.
[38:48]
Yeah, Brad. I got to push back on this one a little bit. So, respectively, I just
[38:54]
heard a comment 15 minutes ago that we don't know what we is important to us out of
[38:58]
Acts 73. Acts 73 was passed last year. So you guys are putting us in this awful
[39:03]
position of not being able to do anything, because there's nothing coming from the state of any substance.
[39:10]
It's all, well, we might do this, or we won't talk about this, or we've got this off ramp, or this off ramp.
[39:15]
We want to get to hear, that doesn't help us, because everyone just grabs that and says, this is why we can't do something.
[39:21]
Because we don't know what the state's going to do.
[39:24]
Okay.
[39:26]
Good, I mean, that's one of the reasons why we got pushed back on some of the ideas that we had in our own district this year,
[39:31]
when we were crafting a budget was, you can't do that until the legislature decides what
[39:37]
they're going to do.
[39:39]
But I'm hearing that we should be strategically thinking ahead.
[39:45]
So that wasn't the legislature to worry that they had to come up with the cost, what the education
[39:53]
actually it was going to be in December, and finally did that. We're a surprise as you were.
[40:02]
That's a number of nine percent. And I've always said we always should be on the same
[40:07]
budget cycle, same fiscal year, because how can you guys, you got to have your budget all before
[40:12]
a time meeting date, and we haven't even proved that. Yep, that's it.
[40:19]
So, you know, look at things that we can fix along the way too.
[40:23]
Well, it also...
[40:24]
One of the other things that I would say to you, and I know this isn't you, but when someone
[40:29]
comes out and says that they're expecting a 12% increase in property taxes this year,
[40:34]
and we haven't even looked at a budget yet. That is not helpful for our budgets.
[40:38]
When we're trying to craft one, and we craft a budget that's only a 2.92%
[40:43]
and everyone's like, no, it's 12, because that's what we heard on the news.
[40:46]
that's what Governor Scott said. That is not helpful. I've heard the same thing in my
[40:51]
town too.
[40:56]
So I think that looked what I'd keep and I think that
[40:58]
here on this earlier was, you know, there's a, there's a, there's a desire by
[41:02]
Vermont, there's to maintain Vermont choice into Vermont, voters to have control
[41:08]
over the decisions made, but they're also not willing to make decisions that are
[41:13]
difficult without someone from the top making them do it. So we can't have it
[41:18]
We're not going to make any decisions because we want the big guys to tell us what the rules
[41:22]
of the game are and then simultaneously complain or say, you know, like, we want our
[41:27]
own choices we want Vermont freedom.
[41:30]
We have to have, we have to be able to say either, we make the hard choices ourselves and we
[41:35]
do it together as a community or we wait until we're forced to make good decisions and then
[41:40]
claim that our choice and our freedoms are being imputed on, don't get both.
[41:44]
I'm going to follow up on what Amber just said, I don't think that's quite accurate though.
[41:49]
I admire the sentiment, I don't think it's accurate because we're putting the position
[41:53]
by the state where we don't have power and if we do make those decisions, they're subject
[42:00]
to change and that the voters are very leery about making changes under those circumstances.
[42:07]
It becomes a scapegoat.
[42:08]
The specific thing I'm thinking about is these ranging aging building infrastructure.
[42:15]
We have a problem, and I think importantly, in Proctor, you understand this that we have
[42:21]
a 60-year-old building that needs a lot of work.
[42:27]
We plan to ask the voters for money to do that.
[42:30]
There's a certain amount of reluctance.
[42:32]
We'll find out how much reluctance there is out there, but there's certainly a lot of resistance
[42:37]
to it, and it's part because we have an unclear future, and that unclear future resides in
[42:44]
one peculiar. So it's a very difficult problem. And you might say, well, you had 60 years
[42:51]
to take care of you deferred maintenance problems. So you're stuck with it. But that doesn't
[42:57]
help us in the moment. And since I've been on this board, this is my six year, we've been talking
[43:02]
about infrastructure and what to do and coming up with the plan and presenting it to the
[43:06]
and COVID got in the way and now, in my opinion, on pillars in the way. So it's really difficult
[43:16]
to make these local decisions that we want to make without, without, without, without having
[43:20]
the sort of damages over our head. I would just add that right now we do have the power.
[43:28]
And do we want to act and think strategically before the power is taken away from Montpelliers?
[43:36]
because any board should be looking forward and thinking ahead.
[43:41]
I think that all the boards need to anticipate understand and work towards the idea that we're going to consolidate.
[43:48]
Like whether we consolidate OV with Middlebury, OV with Rutland, we're going to consolidate.
[43:55]
And so, you know, as we have discussed, not we, I don't actually have a voting number of the board in the clerk,
[44:00]
but as the board has discussed, where we in the best position to welcome
[44:07]
students into our building versus our students having to go all the way to Rowland, you know like what
[44:16]
where the students going to want to go is where the building has been maintained upcap programs
[44:21]
are in a stable position and there's adequate teachers and adequate resources. So unless we position
[44:27]
ourselves to be that player in the game, our students aren't going to have in our building and
[44:34]
board is not going to have the leverage to welcome students in.
[44:37]
At this point, the amount of work to you on this building probably matches what of
[44:41]
Rutens does.
[44:42]
If they beat us to the punch, they upgrade their facilities, they upgrade their programs.
[44:47]
It's just going to make sense that we move our students out because they're already going to
[44:51]
be in a position to hold our students if we are not in a position to do it.
[44:56]
Well, no matter what they're going to have the more boats, right?
[45:00]
It's a bigger area. Eight square months.
[45:05]
Mr. Waldee, do you have anything you'd like to say as our student rep?
[45:11]
These are student rep, so this is Brain Waldee. These are student rep. He's a senior here at Otter Valley.
[45:18]
I suppose the main thing that I was thinking about just now once, what you said about each of access,
[45:25]
I think for a lot of kids, at least in Brandon and surrounding areas, it would be a fair bit
[45:31]
more hassle to have to strain schools.
[45:38]
I'm not briefed on all these specifics of all
[45:41]
this, so I can't really speak with any knowledge, but I do think it would be very nice to
[45:50]
a clear understanding of what's going to happen because amongst the student body there
[45:56]
are many different.
[45:59]
Basically we all think that something else is going to happen because no one has any idea
[46:03]
so a lot of kids say well we're going to have a new school building into something and
[46:08]
then the other kids are saying well no we're going to be going up to London and others say
[46:12]
we're going to go to Millbury and everyone who has a sibling in the school is just wondering
[46:18]
And what I know is going on, and they don't get it, and I think if something could happen
[46:26]
to give authority at all, it would be very pleased.
[46:34]
Thank you.
[46:36]
Thank you.
[46:37]
Thank you.
[46:37]
Thank you.
[46:37]
Thank you.
[46:38]
Thank you.
[46:38]
Thank you.
[46:38]
Thank you.
[46:38]
Thank you.
[46:42]
Thank you.
[46:43]
Thank you.
[46:50]
Thank you.
[46:51]
So this is this is this is the question. This is responding to Peter
[46:57]
There's a couple of things I'm just speaking for myself. This is my chance to say it
[47:02]
Some couple of things about your plan. I like I think that and so you've noticed that in our case
[47:09]
I think are issues on democratic and that's been harmful and I also think tuition and districts are inherently unfair
[47:16]
So eliminating those things putting everybody on the same map under the same rules. I think it's a good thing
[47:22]
So thank you for that.
[47:27]
Oh, is there second? I thought you were going to say something else. No, that was it
[47:31]
All right, okay, sorry
[47:33]
I thought he said two things and he only need to really said one okay, so I've renamed one to say some things
[47:39]
So I so thank you all for for coming today
[47:44]
And I think Senator weeks, you know kind of what I'm gonna say already
[47:47]
But one of the things that I'm happy that you guys are working on the necessary things
[47:55]
for us to have a strong educational system within Vermont, but we're working on effectively
[48:01]
the inputs to what goes into our education without really knowing what we're going to be
[48:09]
getting at the end of it.
[48:11]
And so I don't know if it's the domain of the Secretary or if it's part of the legislature
[48:18]
for us to really move forward with helping boards and helping communities decide what
[48:27]
they are supposed to be doing with this money that they're spending on students.
[48:31]
And I bring that up because our graduation rate is going down.
[48:37]
We have, as a state, we have fallen further behind in literacy.
[48:44]
Math is, it's like that everywhere, but it seems like we, as a state, could really use some help with that as well.
[48:51]
And so when you have 119 districts, some of them are not operating.
[48:55]
That's 119 different ways.
[48:57]
And then you, to approach what they want their local control in order to produce at the end of the 12th grade year.
[49:06]
Additionally, within some districts, you might still have kind of the vestiges of the pre-consolidation where the schools are still doing their own thing, and so that's a whole other set of outcomes that are being generated that are not connected to anything else.
[49:23]
And so being responsible for the students within the district and being somebody who is supposed to be stewarding the finances in a way that produces the greatest possible outcome for the students that we have.
[49:36]
have, yes, we can continue to decide what we think our students should be able to do, but
[49:43]
frequently it's kind of disconnected from the other things.
[49:47]
Like we really wanted to focus on CT and college and life preparedness, that's something
[49:52]
that may or may not be tied to what is going on at the state level.
[49:57]
And so I don't know.
[49:59]
So I guess it's not really, I guess it's kind of a question, but more than anything, it's
[50:06]
cheering on the legislature to really be, I guess,
[50:12]
to chase the outcomes too, not just the inputs.
[50:15]
Because when we're just chasing the inputs,
[50:17]
you have 119 different ways that those inputs
[50:19]
are going to be put to use.
[50:27]
I'm Leslie, the end of the new and I'm from Lester.
[50:30]
And I don't really have a question, might as well.
[50:33]
Feedback.
[50:34]
I've been out in about an out-of-sink county
[50:37]
talking to citizens and their opinions
[50:41]
our academic excellence is the priority and they did not like the two district, a supervisory union
[50:49]
that was being recommended. They prefer the 10 or 12 district mapping that we have been looking at.
[50:57]
They felt that they would lose a local control and that the government would not
[51:03]
really be listening to the citizens and taking input and respecting, you know, their individual
[51:13]
philosophies and teaching their children.
[51:17]
So I just wanted to share that over this past weekend I was out and about and that's the feedback that I received.
[51:28]
Awesome.
[51:31]
Other questions?
[51:34]
The only thing I would like to say at the end of this is that, you know, education is important,
[51:40]
and I'm glad that you guys are working on it up there. I also alluded to healthcare,
[51:44]
but I also realized that there's three other areas that I feel that the state needs to be working
[51:49]
on in tandem in order for all of this to kind of work itself out. And number one is jobs,
[51:54]
number two is infrastructure, and three is housing. And as you all know, on this side of the state,
[52:01]
we do not have an easy way to get to the interstate, you know, you've got to go over mountains
[52:05]
and hills and valleys. You know, we have half of an interstate over here on route four,
[52:11]
but how about the other half? We're not going to be able to get jobs and CTE is great and all of that,
[52:17]
but we also need those other jobs, factory jobs, things like that that we are losing hand over fist.
[52:23]
And I think in order to bring our education levels back, we're going to need to be working on all of that in tandem.
[52:30]
It's not just education. I know Governor Scott is pushing that. I like Governor Scott, but it's all of that in order to keep our kids here to keep us here in order for us to live in Vermont.
[52:44]
So I just want to leave that.
[52:46]
I'll tell you, I think that the fundamental problem from Regents down to Bennington is a stagnant economy.
[52:55]
I think what we're dealing with a lot of symptoms, and we're not addressing the fundamental problem.
[53:01]
In our region, it's the economy.
[53:04]
And I agree with you a hundred percent that Limited Access Highway, the Limited Access Roads,
[53:10]
Highways is an issue that's been ignored for what's it been now 50, 50 years
[53:18]
So I agree with you 100%
[53:22]
Thanks
[53:22]
Yes, all right guys, just pause soon
[53:24]
Sure, but bring that to one question first. I'm sorry. I'm going to bring it back and then you can go if you don't mind
[53:29]
Not only a question. Okay, I do agree with what's on the week said and what you said about jobs
[53:37]
I for one would like to stay in Vermont, but the only reason I'm really
[53:43]
questioned if I will is because of the lack of jobs, and I think that is true
[53:48]
for at least the majority of the peers I know is they all like the state, but
[53:55]
there's just not as many jobs as here as they are in other parts of the country.
[54:01]
Mr. Senator Williams, please go ahead.
[54:03]
Well, just that closing, you know, actually 73 in the end, it's all about education quality.
[54:11]
It really is.
[54:11]
That's what we have really care about.
[54:13]
That's why it gives us dessert.
[54:16]
And somehow we got to figure out how to fund it and to move on with it.
[54:22]
And I think we were doing a good job.
[54:25]
Politics always getting in the way of it.
[54:28]
And unfortunately, you know, we can only do so much from
[54:33]
where we are, and I really appreciate where you use the board and the teachers all do for our kids.
[54:40]
And you've got to do it on with what you got right now.
[54:43]
So hopefully it's a process.
[54:44]
You've got to end up with something better.
[54:47]
People will all make it make a sense of that.
[54:51]
Thank you.
[54:53]
Thank you.
[54:53]
Thank you for being here.
[54:55]
Thank you.
[54:55]
Yeah, we really appreciate you being here.
[54:56]
Thank you for taking time out of your night to do this.
[54:59]
And if you need us, contact us.
[55:03]
That it's always a pleasure to visit with your board
[55:06]
because the conversations are very frank and direct
[55:08]
and I really appreciate it.
[55:11]
All right, thank you.
[55:12]
We took root.
[55:13]
All right, well, I thank you.
[55:15]
Have a good night.
[55:17]
Right now.
[55:18]
OK.
[55:20]
6.56, I did so well in timing that.
[55:23]
OK.
[55:25]
We are about to, so we have a couple of minutes
[55:28]
Although we do have a proposed executive session at seven, we can take a few minutes of public comment if you would like to do that right now.
[55:39]
Are we going to have another opportunity?
[55:41]
After our executive session, yes, we will continue it so that you guys all have a chance to speak.
[55:46]
But is that supposed to be the first thing on the agenda?
[55:48]
and they were supposed to go after what's 730.
[55:52]
No, actually it's a legislative update underneath communications
[55:55]
appearances and staff.
[55:57]
That was the first thing.
[55:58]
So that's why that's there.
[56:00]
Oh, I just put in this today, slime.
[56:02]
No, it's been like that since it came out.
[56:12]
Does there anyone who would like to speak?
[56:15]
We'll just wait until we're late all sleep.
[56:16]
OK, all right.
[56:18]
We're just waiting.
[56:19]
We need our lawyer to come on.
[56:21]
And then she's actually on Thursday enough.
[56:23]
So then I need a motion to move into executive session at 6.58.
[56:30]
So moved.
[56:30]
Seconded.
[56:31]
Okay. We're going to move into executive. All those in favor. Sorry.
[56:36]
All right.
[56:36]
All right.
[56:38]
Perfect. All those opposed.
[56:40]
Okay. We're moving into executive session at this time.
[56:43]
It is time for public comment. So we'll open it up to you all.
[56:49]
We want to start.
[56:52]
Do you be reading the letters that were submitted?
[56:54]
It's not tonight.
[57:00]
I'll start.
[57:02]
Hi.
[57:02]
Hi.
[57:02]
I'm Caitlin Helen.
[57:04]
Is that I am writing to express concern regarding what appears to be a continued pattern
[57:09]
of an architect, public notification, and transparent communication surrounding significant district
[57:14]
discussions and potential structural changes.
[57:17]
In reviewing recent meeting minutes, several entries raised a series question about how and
[57:21]
when the public is being informed.
[57:23]
In the November 18, 2025, it was noted that there was a lack of communication with community, including questions about whether the public was being informed that changes were under consideration.
[57:36]
It was further emphasized that even small budget decisions can significantly impact public trust if the community does not receive clear and transparent communication.
[57:44]
In the November 4th, 2025 minutes reference was made to propose redistricting redistricting
[57:52]
maps expected by December 31st for further review and consideration.
[57:58]
Given the magnitude of redistricting decisions, proactive public engagement should be standard
[58:03]
practice, not in afterthought.
[58:05]
The minutes also reflect conversations regarding potential collaboration or realignment involving
[58:11]
Hory Valley, Proctor, and the Greater Rutland County Supervisor reunion.
[58:15]
These discussions include the possibility of structural changes affecting middle and high-school
[58:20]
configurations, consolidation models, and district alignment.
[58:24]
Yet it appears that much of this dialogue occurred in preliminary stages without broad
[58:29]
public awareness.
[58:30]
These are not minor administrative adjustments.
[58:33]
They involve potential redistricting, consolidation, building use changes, and long-term financial
[58:39]
planning.
[58:39]
Each of these carries significant implications for students, families, taxpayers, and community identity.
[58:46]
Transparency is not simply about complying with open meeting laws.
[58:49]
It is about actively ensuring that families and community members understand what is being explored, why it is being explored,
[58:57]
what alternatives exist and how they can meaningfully participate before decisions solidify.
[59:02]
When the public learns of major considerations, only through meeting minutes, secondary reports or fragmented updates,
[59:09]
It is understandably a road's trust.
[59:12]
I respectfully request that the Board commit to clearly communicating when major structural
[59:17]
redistricting or consolidation discussions are in exploratory stages, provide accessible
[59:23]
summaries of proposals and their potential impacts before drafting letters of interest
[59:28]
or advancing discussions, establish a consistent, proactive public engagement plan for any
[59:33]
proposal that could alter district configuration, student assignment or long-term government
[59:37]
structure. Ensure that also a substantive, inter-district discussions occur trans-parallel,
[59:45]
sleep, transparently, and warned public meetings. Rebuilding and maintaining public trust
[59:51]
requires more than technical compliance. It requires intentional openness. Our community
[59:56]
deserves to be informed participants in decisions in our
[1:00:00]
Our children's education and our town's futures. Thank you for attention to this matter. I look forward to your response and a renewed commitment to transparent and inclusive governance.
[1:00:11]
And two board members just miss what you said.
[1:00:18]
Who's next?
[1:00:20]
Although.
[1:00:22]
I sent in this letter to each of you via email, but I just wanted to make sure there's
[1:00:26]
on the right card.
[1:00:26]
I wanted to read it out loud for you.
[1:00:28]
Who's next?
[1:00:30]
I'm writing as a parent directly affected by the decision to move
[1:00:34]
Cavalry preschool program.
[1:00:35]
I'm asking for clear answers.
[1:00:37]
I'm both the process and we'll follow.
[1:00:39]
And the reasoning behind the decision.
[1:00:41]
At January 6th meeting, the board voted to relocate the preschool. Many of us were surprised by the vote.
[1:00:47]
Under Vermont open meeting law, agendas are required to be posted in advance and must give the public reasonable notice of the business that may be acted upon.
[1:00:57]
Reloading the preschool was not specifically warned in the agenda.
[1:01:00]
I would like to understand how the board determined to take the vote, complying with the requirements.
[1:01:05]
Moving a preschool program is a major decision for families and the community.
[1:01:09]
It feels like something that should be clearly identified beforehand.
[1:01:14]
On January 13th and February 3rd meetings, there was attempts to reconsider or rescind
[1:01:19]
the January 6th vote.
[1:01:21]
It appears that seven votes were treated as necessary to overturn the prior action.
[1:01:26]
I'm respectfully asking the board to explain how the number was determined.
[1:01:30]
Robert's rules of order 12th edition section 35 state that a motion to rescind may pass by
[1:01:36]
majority vote of pre-fifth previously noticed was given or by two-thirds of a vote of
[1:01:43]
those present or majority of the entire membership. These are alternatives. If a proper
[1:01:49]
notice was given for reconsideration, it seems as simple majority of those presents would have
[1:01:54]
been sufficient. In addition, the OPEU articles of agreement require two-thirds vote only in
[1:02:02]
very specific circumstances such as certain school closures. I would appreciate
[1:02:07]
clarification as to what specific authority the board relied on to require seven
[1:02:12]
votes in this situation. If 11 board members were present, two-thirds of those
[1:02:17]
present, but actually require eight votes, not seven. The board calculated based
[1:02:22]
on all 13 seats, seats, 13. I would like to know what legal authority requires
[1:02:28]
that approach beyond the procedural issues I want to speak to a broader responsibility of
[1:02:33]
the board. School board members are elected to serve as stewards of public funds protect
[1:02:40]
the quality of our children's education and strengthen the community that supports our schools.
[1:02:45]
That responsibility includes asking hard questions, carefully evaluating recommendations from
[1:02:51]
the administration and ensuring that decisions are made transparently and the best interests
[1:02:57]
of students and taxpayers.
[1:03:00]
The board works for the community, families trust that you will question assumptions, a
[1:03:05]
value-weight long-term impact, and fully examining the reasoning behind specific changes.
[1:03:11]
When a decision of this magnitude is made, particularly in a way that these families'
[1:03:15]
feelings, press, or unheard, the raises concerns about whether the stewardship role is being
[1:03:21]
fully exercised.
[1:03:22]
There are also van confusions about the underlying rationale for moving carefully.
[1:03:27]
Some explanations have focused on facilities and a lot in logistics.
[1:03:32]
Others have suggested broader enrollment for planning considerations.
[1:03:37]
If this relocation is part of a larger strategic version of grander configurations or
[1:03:42]
district restructuring, that vision should be clearly articulated and openly discussed.
[1:03:48]
the community deserves to understand not only what decisions are made but why this issue was created
[1:03:55]
significant concern and division in our community. I'm simply asking for transparency,
[1:04:00]
accountability, and assurance that both the law and the district's governing documents
[1:04:05]
were followed carefully and that the bird for fully exercise its independent oversight responsibility.
[1:04:12]
Thank you. And your name is I'm Sergeant Jean Kaufman. Thank you. Thank you.
[1:04:21]
My name is Sarah McKigan. I'm writing to express my distrust, disapproval, and frustrations with the OVU Board.
[1:04:27]
I am a young mom of a preschool and elementary age children. I grew up in Pittsburgh and graduated from out of alley.
[1:04:33]
My attention was drawn to these meetings based on the Catholic topic.
[1:04:37]
Once it was actually listed on the agenda, so I attended my first meeting after the unborn vote on one six.
[1:04:42]
At my first meeting, Berthrend began the meeting
[1:04:46]
without any introduction of herself,
[1:04:48]
blank face to monotone, that really set the stage of the tone of these meetings.
[1:04:51]
It's a new attendee.
[1:04:52]
I immediately found the air intimidating to the board,
[1:04:55]
doing the public, an air that seems to be trying to display a nearly
[1:04:59]
bully-like mood, a bit ironic as I've heard surveys
[1:05:03]
in extensive data collection on how kids in school
[1:05:06]
amongst the field amongst their peers,
[1:05:08]
bullying and safety are a common topic.
[1:05:11]
So now that I'm paying attention, I'm enlightened on how things tend to run and I'm not impressed.
[1:05:16]
These folks are delegating our tax dollars, not listening to the public to the tune of 30 million dollars.
[1:05:21]
And now it's standing a mountain amongst a small community.
[1:05:25]
It's a tough argument, since on two, three, even a select word member, was sure to point out that the turnout for standing up for the motion to keep Cavali in place was a uniquely large and there's an unusual large amount of public comment in favor of keeping at its current location.
[1:05:40]
Yet some members have such big egos. They tuned out the public comment to stick to their gender to rule it as a closed location.
[1:05:47]
After being ignored by most, I do thank those who changed their vote and heard us.
[1:05:51]
This brings me to some questions about the OVU Board decision making and some points I read in the annual report.
[1:05:58]
First, the report summary begins with OVU Board is proud to present a budget increase of 2.92% for the 2627 school year.
[1:06:08]
As we all know, raising property taxes cannot be sustained, and we did our best to pass responsible budget.
[1:06:13]
Part of this budget is the move, part of this budget, is moved to white and gray-k to the OCA,
[1:06:21]
Blaster, and Cavalry-Cree-K to Low-Through.
[1:06:24]
I point this section out and ask, why does the budget include the moves?
[1:06:28]
I thought the move was to save money, not dip into the funds included in a nearly 3% increase.
[1:06:33]
Also, how can a move be decided to happen if it needs a budget to do that, and we didn't pass the budget yet?
[1:06:41]
As I continue to read the report, I get to staffing changes headline and see that Lowthrop is anticipated to have a one-teacher reduction.
[1:06:50]
I'm curious through this side which teacher.
[1:06:54]
As I said, I attended Lowthrop and to be frank, now as a parent, I'm thus far not impressed with the school.
[1:07:00]
My son's a fourth grader, and I even homeschooled him last fall in the fear that that year would be like the previous.
[1:07:07]
I would love to see annual reviews surveys sent to parents with appropriate place to submit their opinions about classroom teachers and special teachers that allows them to be anonymous or in a fashion of strong opinion stone effect relationships.
[1:07:19]
It could just be a simple 20 question survey rating from one to five.
[1:07:23]
Confidentiality is necessary. A large problem of a small community is fear of rocking someone's boat that you need to evaluate
[1:07:30]
Professionally, but no-you'll cross paths socially. I am now in a second year of my son whose peers parent is the teacher. This is another very difficult situation, especially when there's conflict. Actually, something I think that shouldn't be allowed, teaching children in their own grade level. They do avoid having them in the same class, but the grade level as a whole is extremely difficult.
[1:07:51]
As a pattern at Lowthrop, I see laziness and impatience amongst the staffs towards students,
[1:07:57]
not all, but you're only as good as your weakest link.
[1:08:00]
I also see re-organizing teachers via changing grade levels right really, and I believe this
[1:08:05]
is a cause of a lot of disruption in teachers teaching patterns and rhythm.
[1:08:08]
Part of my frustration with cavalry moving to Lowthrop is cavalry has, who I believe is one
[1:08:13]
of the best teachers in the school, and a great consistent routine in organization.
[1:08:17]
something that little group gets an F on in my eyes and I am very worried they cannot handle
[1:08:22]
another grade class grade. They really need to get their act together before this edition. Could
[1:08:27]
it be a leadership issue? Is it a board issue? What can you do to help? So I ask again, who fires
[1:08:33]
the one teacher and who gets to pick that person? If you also in front of us with true desires to improve
[1:08:39]
our district schools, you need our opinions and we need your expertise on the process to implement.
[1:08:44]
This is not going to happen successfully with limiting public comment only at the beginning of the meeting and by acting
[1:08:50]
with pre-made decisions.
[1:08:52]
Open your eyes for the public and open your minds to what's best for each school.
[1:08:56]
They don't all need to be identical.
[1:08:58]
Don't change what's broken and turn your focus onto what is broken.
[1:09:02]
We always did several meetings now, dismantling one thing that wasn't broken.
[1:09:06]
Why did we not work on fixing real issues?
[1:09:09]
Cavalry was not an issue unless it was a disruption to the larger agenda that we have for the Cavalry building that's still not being shared
[1:09:17]
I think there's a lot of information from a higher bees not getting shared. I wasn't like none at 73 today, and I think we're starting to see the bigger picture here
[1:09:25]
I stayed in kit it's fair to avoid Nesciby, so that wonderful comment that was made at the previous milled it
[1:09:31]
Meeting about Cavalry can move because Nesciby did it well Nesciby had no pre-K and so they put it in the military school
[1:09:41]
You're worried about enrollment in health.
[1:09:44]
We didn't need to necessarily be my school's town, my town's schools.
[1:09:48]
Your actions help schools like us.
[1:09:52]
Your actions help schools like Christ the King with enrollment.
[1:09:56]
Thanks.
[1:10:00]
Anyone else?
[1:10:02]
Jennifer Brittanyham?
[1:10:04]
Good evening.
[1:10:05]
At the last meeting, over an hour public comment was given
[1:10:08]
support of keeping Cavalry preschool where it is. The town select court, voted unanimous,
[1:10:15]
unanimously, in support of keeping it where it is. Over 300 vehicle voters signed a petition
[1:10:20]
asking you to keep Cavalry where it is. And yet it feels as though none of that mattered.
[1:10:25]
If the board does not wish to listen to community members, if you do not wish to listen to
[1:10:31]
the select board, if you do not wish to listen to 300 voters, then at the very least you should listen
[1:10:36]
to your own data.
[1:10:38]
At your last meeting, you presented the fall
[1:10:40]
panorama culture survey results in grades 3 through 5,
[1:10:46]
66% of students reported feeling safe,
[1:10:49]
which means one third of our elementary students
[1:10:52]
do not feel safe at school.
[1:10:55]
65 reported a sense of belonging,
[1:10:57]
which means more than one third
[1:10:59]
to do not feel safe like they belong.
[1:11:03]
School climate was only at a 59%.
[1:11:06]
That is not a strong number. These are not numbers we should feel comfortable with.
[1:11:11]
And by grade 6 through 12 those numbers decline even further.
[1:11:17]
By only 49% feel safe only 33% feel a sense of belonging, school climate drops to 45%.
[1:11:26]
By middle on high school only one in three students feel they truly belong.
[1:11:31]
We cannot ignore that trajectory. The longing does not suddenly disappear in sixth grade.
[1:11:38]
It either grows or erodes over time, and the foundation for safety, belonging, emotional regulation, and communication begins in early childhood.
[1:11:49]
Your own survey shows the motion regulation at 50% favorable in grades 3 through 5.
[1:11:56]
That means half of our elementary students are struggling with managing their emotions.
[1:12:00]
These are skills that are built earliest in preschool settings that focus on play, relationships, and social development.
[1:12:09]
If one third of our elementary students already do not feel safe, if more than one third already do not feel they belong,
[1:12:17]
why would we weaken the very program that builds those skills at the earliest stage?
[1:12:23]
Cavalry preschool is not just a classroom, but is where children's first learn that school is safe,
[1:12:30]
adults can be trusted, that they are valued, and they belong.
[1:12:34]
If we want stronger, panorama results, five years from now, the work starts at age 3 and 4,
[1:12:41]
not in middle school, where their foundation for all of these are built.
[1:12:45]
You may choose not to listen to the community, but you should not ignore your own data.
[1:12:51]
Pre-school is prevention. Pre-school is belonging. Pre-school is infrastructure.
[1:12:57]
Please protect the Pat Cavalry preschool.
[1:13:00]
Also, understand that the board is exploring a potential middle school model,
[1:13:05]
a relocation of students and restructuring to address enrollment in engagement challenges.
[1:13:10]
It does not make sense to invest energy and restructuring grades 6 through 8 while weakening the very program that shapes children at age 3 and 4.
[1:13:22]
Thank you.
[1:13:27]
My name is Megan For air.
[1:13:29]
First, I would like to thank those on the board who voted in favor of these meetings.
[1:13:34]
Cavalry at the Cavalry location.
[1:13:37]
The fact that you are willing to listen to the families that spoke out against the move and support what is best for our Chinese learners is great.
[1:13:43]
appreciate it. I would also like to express my disappointment with those who oppose the
[1:13:48]
against statement or choose to chose not to vote. After attending the February 3rd meeting,
[1:13:54]
which had over an hour of public comment given a sport of keeping coverly where it is,
[1:14:00]
some one board member described as a wearer circumstance, where the four has been
[1:14:06]
that amount of time hearing public comment on one specific issue. Not to mention over 350 signatures
[1:14:12]
from legal voters seeking to keep happily at its current location, yet it feels as though none
[1:14:18]
of that matter, the community's voice did not matter to the board.
[1:14:22]
At the last meeting presented the Panorama Daph, within the static, it was noted that one
[1:14:28]
third of our elementary students and grades three through five do not feel safe at school,
[1:14:33]
more than they feel like they belong. Students in grades six through 12 on half, at least
[1:14:38]
One half of the students did not feel safe and nearly two-thirds felt like they did not
[1:14:42]
long.
[1:14:43]
These numbers are concerning and something that's not ignored.
[1:14:47]
The foundations are feeling safe and a sense of belonging and or the communication
[1:14:51]
and emotional skills that you get in an early childhood.
[1:14:55]
These are skills that are built and presented to our earliest learners when they enter the
[1:14:59]
school.
[1:15:00]
A system in a preschool setting. A setting that focuses on play, relationships, and social development. The program at Calvary offers all these skills and more. Why would we begin a very program that notes the skills at the earliest stages? Calvary isn't just a program. It is where children learn first learn that school is safe, adults can be trusted, they evaluate, and they belong.
[1:15:27]
Anyone else?
[1:15:31]
Are you in a position to actually answer questions?
[1:15:36]
I mean, if there's questions asked.
[1:15:38]
Potentially?
[1:15:40]
Usually not.
[1:15:40]
I mean, usually we hear from you.
[1:15:42]
Usually answer questions.
[1:15:44]
Well, first of all, I had the whole issue with anonymous letters.
[1:15:48]
You could share that.
[1:15:49]
I don't mean answers.
[1:15:50]
I just think that there needs to be clear policy
[1:15:53]
about accepting anonymous correspondence.
[1:15:56]
Sure.
[1:15:58]
So Kerry sent in a, let's talk or a reach out
[1:16:01]
that talks specifically about accepting anonymous letters
[1:16:04]
from the public. She indicated that most times most boards and things do not accept them because
[1:16:12]
they can't be, we can't be certain that they're from the community that we are serving or that,
[1:16:19]
you know, it's the same person saying 12 different things the same time. She also indicated that in
[1:16:25]
a narrow situation, you would accept anonymous letters, especially if you feel that there would be
[1:16:30]
attribution or, you know, essentially attribution, so she indicated that she wanted to know
[1:16:41]
why we had accepted those letters.
[1:16:45]
I told her, and my response to her, that I agreed with her, that nine times out of ten,
[1:16:50]
we don't accept anonymous communication because we don't know where it's coming from.
[1:16:56]
But she did hit the nail in the head when she talked about attribution and fear of retaliation.
[1:17:02]
Um, that is me we all anyone standing up. Oh, no, I understand. And also be on that
[1:17:09]
Ooh, that end of retribution. So own it. I understand. I'm just saying that those people
[1:17:17]
I think it's risky and I think that there just needs to be some real clear policy.
[1:17:21]
And you guys did put weight on those 12 anonymous. I remember wasn't you who said like,
[1:17:26]
We have 12 people who responded in the support of it and they were okay.
[1:17:32]
Have you got anybody off?
[1:17:33]
Please respect us and do not cut us off while we're talking.
[1:17:36]
Thank you.
[1:17:37]
Oh, man.
[1:17:38]
What?
[1:17:39]
It's okay.
[1:17:40]
But the point of the matter is is that, you know, either so I can see why the teachers and I did
[1:17:47]
say that you could tell some of those anonymous letters or from teachers and they don't
[1:17:51]
want to ruin their their, well, I think from the way that they talked, you could
[1:17:56]
So, but again, you know, so, but in the past we really haven't had that situation and I have said in previous meetings that if someone sends an anonymous communication and we can't tell what it's about that we, you know, here it is, but you know, I don't know where we go with that.
[1:18:13]
and I felt that people within the group that was speaking did ask to hear from the anonymous.
[1:18:20]
Well, they asked to hear all of the communications that we received and I heard the anonymous ones.
[1:18:25]
That was mentioned by the group.
[1:18:28]
I did not, I tried not to put any kind of emphasis on either one. I did try to keep it even.
[1:18:35]
I hope I did that. But I mean, you are heard. I do hear you.
[1:18:40]
And so I guess my other question now is in regard to the proposal for a different, I think
[1:18:51]
that it's being called field fields, it's labeled in the annual record as field studies at the
[1:19:03]
Calvary Library location. So what is that plan?
[1:19:09]
I mean, is that must be an administrative plan?
[1:19:11]
You go out there to generate excitement for,
[1:19:15]
if it's actually a plan, in place.
[1:19:18]
Because it doesn't really make any sense to me
[1:19:20]
to take a program, move the program to save money.
[1:19:26]
I assume it's money, I don't know anything.
[1:19:29]
But, okay, anyway, so you're moving it to a new location,
[1:19:35]
but you're going to put another program up there.
[1:19:37]
So you still have to maintain it, you still have to staff it, you still have to ensure it, I guess I just don't understand.
[1:19:46]
Is that something that's a real playout at this point? Or is it just...
[1:19:50]
I think that that's probably something they would talk about over the summer, but I don't know, that's an administrative thing for...
[1:19:56]
Yeah, I don't...
[1:19:57]
The board doesn't.
[1:20:00]
Well, I guess the bottom, you know, like the bottom line, like...
[1:20:04]
What is it? What are you saving?
[1:20:15]
I don't think we're putting a new program there, I think we want it to, I don't believe it to the program.
[1:20:21]
The goal is for the other grades to be able to access it as well.
[1:20:25]
So it's not just, it's not just available for the pre case students as it is currently.
[1:20:31]
So is there a plan or is it just an idea at this point?
[1:20:35]
It's an idea at this point, so then because we would need the feedback from the teachers and from the campus administration and the best way to utilize it.
[1:20:44]
Because as we've heard that it is really good for our students to get out and utilize the facility that's out there.
[1:20:53]
It brings opportunity for us to be able to use it in different ways.
[1:20:56]
So it would be similar to what that experiential program is already in place, it's like
[1:21:02]
but for all students.
[1:21:04]
For all students.
[1:21:07]
Interesting.
[1:21:09]
Thank you.
[1:21:12]
Any other?
[1:21:13]
Please comment.
[1:21:16]
Could I have copies of anyone's statements that are printed?
[1:21:19]
Could be really helpful for taking minutes.
[1:21:22]
All right.
[1:21:22]
Well then.
[1:21:23]
Thank you.
[1:21:24]
I would like to read my other letter.
[1:21:26]
Just no big help.
[1:21:26]
Thank you.
[1:21:27]
Thank you.
[1:21:29]
Okay.
[1:21:29]
Well, I have two board members here when I, or we're not here, when I have to keep reading.
[1:21:36]
If you'd like to get to, they're more of them, you can hand it to them and they can read it.
[1:21:40]
Well, you know, well, we're doing the rest of the meeting.
[1:21:42]
If that would be helpful.
[1:21:51]
I'm just going to, I did not read this part, but I'm crossing out.
[1:21:55]
Oh, okay.
[1:21:57]
Hopefully on the research.
[1:21:58]
No worries.
[1:22:00]
I think it was the, yeah.
[1:22:01]
They can read it.
[1:22:02]
Well, we're continuing on.
[1:22:04]
Thank you.
[1:22:04]
All right, we cannot do the 2025 Vermont snapshot review.
[1:22:11]
I'm sorry.
[1:22:12]
I'm sorry.
[1:22:13]
I'm sorry.
[1:22:14]
Go for it.
[1:22:16]
My apologies.
[1:22:17]
So I'm writing to strongly and unequivocally.
[1:22:20]
I did send this, but I don't know who has gotten it.
[1:22:24]
Okay.
[1:22:25]
I am writing to strongly and unequivocally urge the reinstatement
[1:22:28]
of the Cavalry Facebook program.
[1:22:30]
The decision to relocate the preschool age children to low for elementary is deeply concerning.
[1:22:37]
Developmentally inappropriate, logistically unsound and procedurally flawed.
[1:22:42]
Local elementary is not designed for three and four-year-old children. The building is layout, it's daily rhythms, and a student population,
[1:22:50]
or tailored to much older elementary age students.
[1:22:53]
preschoolers require a fundamentally different environment, one that prioritizes safety,
[1:22:58]
common transitions, age-appropriate facilities, and protected spaces.
[1:23:02]
Placing toddlers in the building design for much older children exposes them to unnecessary risks.
[1:23:08]
Older students, even unintentionally, can intimidate or bully much younger children.
[1:23:13]
This is not a reflection of the older students' character, but a predictable consequence of mixing vastly different developmental stages in a space never meant to support it.
[1:23:22]
Additionally, relocating preschoolers to low-thrupper will require significant financial
[1:23:28]
investment to retrofit the building to meet early childhood needs.
[1:23:32]
These costs specialize bathrooms, classroom modifications, playground adjustments, and safety
[1:23:37]
accommodations represent new and avoidable expenditures.
[1:23:41]
Reinstating the Cavalry preschool program would eliminate the need for much of this spending
[1:23:45]
and make it far better use of existing appropriate infrastructure.
[1:23:50]
Traffic and safety concerns cannot be overstated.
[1:23:52]
Introducing preschool drop-off and pick-up into low-thrups existing schedule will significantly
[1:23:58]
significantly increase congestion.
[1:24:00]
Morning and afternoon traffic will be doubled, creating delays, confusion, and safety hazards
[1:24:05]
for families, staff, and students alike.
[1:24:07]
For this reason, I formally request that the members of the school board personally witnessed
[1:24:12]
current drop-off and pick-up procedures at low-thrupp elementary before the fall of
[1:24:17]
2026 school year.
[1:24:18]
Observing these conditions firsthand is essential before adding an entirely new population of very young children and their families into an already congestive system.
[1:24:28]
There's also a critical issue of location.
[1:24:31]
Low-through is dangerously close to Route 7.
[1:24:33]
For preschool age children who are impulsive, unpredictable, and still learning basic safety awareness, this proximity presents a series and unacceptable risk.
[1:24:42]
Pre-school environments must prioritize distance from high traffic progress, not place children closer to them.
[1:24:48]
Beyond these practical concerns, the process by which the initial vote to relocate the pre-school raises series, legal and ethical issues.
[1:24:56]
The first vote to move the program occurred without proper public null notice.
[1:25:00]
Families and community members were not aware of the meeting or the decision, which appears to be a violation of the Vermont's open meeting law.
[1:25:06]
The decisions of this matter to magnitude must be made transparently with full public awareness and participation.
[1:25:14]
Additionally, I am deeply concerned by the apparent consideration of anonymous letters or comments to support of relocating the preschool program.
[1:25:25]
A anonymous submission should not be accepted or weighted in on decisions of this importance.
[1:25:30]
There is no way to verify who submitted these letters, which town they reside in, or whether they have direct connection to the district,
[1:25:37]
or a single individual may have submitted multiple responses.
[1:25:41]
Allowing the anonymous input on our mind transparency,
[1:25:45]
accountability and integrity of the decision-making process,
[1:25:48]
especially when the outcome directly affects young children and public resources.
[1:25:52]
Furthermore, Vermont law is clear regarding ethical oversight and accountability.
[1:25:57]
Vermont Act 171 requires school districts to designate and maintain access
[1:26:02]
to an ethics liaison to ensure compliance, transparency, and ethical governance.
[1:26:09]
Given the concerns surrounding process, notice, anonymous input, and decision-making,
[1:26:13]
it is imperative that the district clearly identifies ethics liaison and involve them
[1:26:18]
in reviewing the actions taken related to the preschool relocation.
[1:26:24]
Compliance with Act 171 is not optional, and ethical safeguards exist precisely to address
[1:26:29]
situations like this.
[1:26:30]
The Cavalry preschool program exists for a reason.
[1:26:33]
It means unique, developmental, emotional, and safety needs for our youngest learners.
[1:26:38]
Removing it and forcing preschoolers into an ill-suited elementary environment.
[1:26:46]
Underminds those needs, ignores foreseeable risk and disregards the voices of families
[1:26:51]
who rely on this program.
[1:26:52]
I urge the school board to take a media action to reinstate the Cavalry preschool program,
[1:26:57]
pause any relocation efforts, and sure compliance with Vermont law and recommit to transparent
[1:27:03]
lawful and child-centered decision-making. Our youngest children deserve
[1:27:06]
environmental design for that, not compromise as that place. Convenience, cost,
[1:27:11]
work's tendency above the safety and well-being.
[1:27:16]
We're going to hand that one. Can you hand that in too?
[1:27:18]
Yes, please. Amber, please. Thank you. Thank you.
[1:27:21]
Thank you. Thank you.
[1:27:22]
No problem. Thank you.
[1:27:24]
I'd like to ask you a question about, like, the way that the reach out works.
[1:27:27]
Sure. I noticed on today's, like, I know you're not going to read them,
[1:27:31]
but actually a comment that I had put,
[1:27:33]
which I submitted really late,
[1:27:35]
but it's appearing today, but I actually made it
[1:27:39]
for last meeting.
[1:27:40]
So what's like the timing to make sure you submit things
[1:27:43]
so that it appears to you guys in the correct manner.
[1:27:46]
Like so it falls into the right meeting.
[1:27:48]
And the right meeting.
[1:27:49]
So I told people last, the last meeting
[1:27:52]
that as long as it was in by three o'clock
[1:27:54]
on our meeting day, that we would get it.
[1:27:57]
My words are not in there.
[1:27:59]
Okay.
[1:28:00]
today. But so I just wonder what that works. Right, okay, but that's that's essentially
[1:28:05]
what it is. Is that I won't? Yes? When you're finished? Oh, okay. So, but that's what I don't
[1:28:12]
get them after three o'clock. So, anyone that if you send a reach out, those reach out
[1:28:17]
come to, if you send them to the board. So the reach out comes to me. That's actually
[1:28:20]
really the line. Okay. Yeah. But they only go to me. But they only go to me. They may not necessarily
[1:28:27]
be in the bar package. But Digg is previous. Yes, we give it. Yeah. I give them to Melinda. Thank you,
[1:28:34]
Pat Clark. Yeah. Yeah, but she sends out the work. If you want us, all of us to get it, I would say
[1:28:40]
the Friday before the meeting. Thank you. That's helpful. Okay. Actually, Jennifer, written hand was first,
[1:28:47]
sorry. I just want to know why, for the process, just trying to understand why today you're not
[1:28:54]
to read the letters and I did need the deadline for today for with my reach out and it wasn't
[1:29:01]
part of the packet and also it's extremely difficult trying to reach you guys individually. I know
[1:29:09]
like you guys write, oh put first initial and last name at or and you tell us that's how to do it
[1:29:16]
but like someone I tried m and f as a first name and then last name and it doesn't work.
[1:29:22]
Yeah, that's for Nanda.
[1:29:24]
So what is your name?
[1:29:25]
My name is M.Dott for Nanda.
[1:29:29]
I think that my RNA is M.Dott for Nanda.
[1:29:37]
It's because it took my personal email and then add it.
[1:29:41]
Can you guys put it on like that the main thing?
[1:29:44]
It should be just loaded in the directory.
[1:29:46]
It just says that it's supposed to be our first initial.
[1:29:48]
It does not.
[1:29:49]
I mean, because I have a complicated, okay, I just thought maybe it would just make it flow, but I'm the understitled.
[1:30:00]
We just need really easy if you guys could write your emails on the website so that we can make sure that we're putting in correctly.
[1:30:11]
And I really dislike the idea that all the reachouts funnel to you and nature.
[1:30:17]
Yeah, like I I think it should it's it's in the description. It says like to reach us
[1:30:24]
Meaning I'm thinking I'm sending this and all of you guys are receiving it
[1:30:29]
But I truly don't know
[1:30:31]
But I think that ensures that she's gonna get it to all of us that's for responsibility
[1:30:35]
That's for responsibility
[1:30:37]
So if you send it just to me and if your I don't know if anybody else has gotten what you've sent well and the other issue is I think what you may be getting at is that
[1:30:46]
When we are not together and a group, the only person who can speak for the board is myself.
[1:30:52]
So if you send an email to all of us individually, like I've seen a few of you do, they're not to answer you.
[1:30:58]
The only one who will answer is me.
[1:31:00]
That's fine.
[1:31:01]
I just want to make sure.
[1:31:02]
No, but I just want you to know that.
[1:31:03]
So if you're not getting responses from 12 other board members, it's because they're not supposed to do that.
[1:31:11]
Unless I give them specific, right, unless I give them specific reasons to talk to the board like if they go to the select board or something
[1:31:18]
I mean we have talking points for those budget or something like that. Yeah
[1:31:24]
Okay, and Terry, sorry. I didn't mean to interrupt. Do you have something else?
[1:31:27]
So I was just trying to clarify. So I don't think we had a specific process until this past week
[1:31:34]
we have not short-up the process as to how they get into the packet or how everybody gets
[1:31:40]
them prior to a meeting. So that's something that Melinda and I will talk about.
[1:31:45]
So you at the end of the week eventually everybody gets. Yeah they'll get them in there.
[1:31:52]
They should be getting them in the board packet and anything that they didn't get from the
[1:31:56]
prior one should be in the next one. Friday before. Yeah the Friday before it's one.
[1:32:01]
So when that once the agenda goes out, that's the last one that they're going to receive.
[1:32:08]
So.
[1:32:08]
So why are you not reading letters today? Isn't that the whole point?
[1:32:13]
Well, most of you already read them. I mean, I just didn't read them today because actually carefully is not on her agenda for today.
[1:32:21]
So, and I think you all, I mean, the only two that I didn't read because I read them all today,
[1:32:27]
The only two that I did not read pretty much said the same thing that you all said, so that but
[1:32:34]
Is their voice and they reached out they did know they did, but it will be in the next it'll be in the next packet
[1:32:40]
And you'll be able to read that we've seen them right. I'm not the last to not from today
[1:32:46]
Actually, I like to see in a earlier deadline. It is super hard like if we go to three and then all of a sudden it's
[1:32:52]
All right
[1:32:54]
I've been playing with the panic finally broke it like that's not really enough time
[1:32:57]
I think that's why I say Friday. Yeah, I mean I work. Well, that's fine. I mean right. That's so I'm
[1:33:03]
Something that we had that issue in the past so I we didn't really have a plan but we'll we'll make one
[1:33:09]
I mean it probably needs to be after the agenda comes out for that exact reason like what are we talking about
[1:33:13]
But but you guys don't like it to get him on the day of so certainly on a four clock
[1:33:18]
Well, so, you know, anyway, so we'll come up with a plan and make sure that we communicate to everyone as to when
[1:33:26]
The last minute that
[1:33:27]
Or members will get it might be Sunday, so that it comes out Monday. You did a day like if we got it Tuesday morning. That would be at least
[1:33:34]
Maybe semi-reasonable
[1:33:36]
We'll figure it out
[1:33:38]
It's not something I'm gonna figure out tonight. Sorry
[1:33:43]
Okay, but but yes, we will make
[1:33:45]
because I'm an board document, it's not for your judge.
[1:33:47]
Right. Yeah. Right. It's just, it's just, yeah, communication to the board.
[1:33:52]
Okay. So thank you for all of your comments. Moving on.
[1:33:58]
The 2025 Vermont snapshot review is not available yet.
[1:34:01]
So we are going to be moving that onto the next agenda.
[1:34:04]
If it finally becomes available.
[1:34:08]
Okay. Well, that's a little too late for us.
[1:34:11]
Yeah.
[1:34:12]
We have a monitoring report 2.7 compensation in benefits. Can I get someone to make a motion please?
[1:34:19]
We're in the end.
[1:34:21]
Okay, is there a second?
[1:34:23]
Natalie, does there any discussions on the monitoring report 2.7?
[1:34:29]
Is this one is about compensation in benefits?
[1:34:32]
There are teachers and staffs.
[1:34:34]
So, this one is, I like it because it's not a very long and complicated one and the documents that we produce a lot of documents on a regular basis for this specific.
[1:34:48]
So, it was easy to put this monitoring report together.
[1:34:53]
Is there anything else you want to say about it?
[1:34:56]
No.
[1:34:57]
Okay.
[1:34:58]
Any questions for Renee?
[1:35:01]
Okay.
[1:35:01]
All those in favour of approving monitoring report 2.7 compensation of benefits,
[1:35:08]
please signify by saying aye.
[1:35:10]
Aye.
[1:35:11]
Aye.
[1:35:12]
Aye.
[1:35:12]
Aye.
[1:35:15]
Any abstentions?
[1:35:17]
Okay.
[1:35:17]
Passes.
[1:35:19]
All right.
[1:35:19]
Next thing on our agenda is an open meeting law complaint.
[1:35:24]
I have.
[1:35:28]
So, in regards to the opening meeting law complaint that we received this past week, we do not feel that an open meeting law violation occurred, however, out of an abundance of caution, the board is going to cure the alleged violation anyway.
[1:35:47]
I hereby move that the board ratifies the actions taken regarding the budget on January
[1:35:54]
6, 2026, including relocating to pre-K programs and maintaining OCA as a K-36.
[1:36:04]
Can I have any of these or a second?
[1:36:07]
I'll second the motion.
[1:36:09]
Thank you, Rianan and any discussion.
[1:36:15]
Hearing none, all those in favor of the motion put forth by Natalie.
[1:36:19]
please say aye.
[1:36:23]
Where do you go?
[1:36:31]
Okay. Who's second at that motion? Was that Rihanna?
[1:36:33]
Yes it was Rihanna. It was. Yeah. Do you want to do me my leave? Well just keep your hands up
[1:36:41]
I get. I don't know why he walked out at this particular time. He made a gun. All right all those
[1:36:46]
signify by saying aye raise your hands. And those online
[1:36:54]
rean and gave.
[1:37:00]
Okay. Okay, Barbara, you
[1:37:04]
yes. So what? Okay. And you worked out right as we were voting. No, we did that already. We were, we were at the opening meeting
[1:37:17]
We were already voting.
[1:37:18]
I didn't know you were going to hear it again.
[1:37:22]
No, I'm familiar with it.
[1:37:24]
All those in the boat.
[1:37:26]
We were at the eyes.
[1:37:28]
I'm sorry.
[1:37:28]
I have currently low.
[1:37:30]
Warren, Reonon, gay, Barbara, Garrett, Leslie, Kevin, Thornton, Natalie, I did not get a fernonance. Did you, yes, you did, thank you.
[1:37:38]
Yes and Brett? No. Yes?
[1:37:40]
It is going to be a no. Okay, all right. Hold those nay.
[1:37:46]
Brett and Kevin. Okay. Any abstentions, is that 11? 10? 12?
[1:37:53]
3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, yeses, 2, no, is an equals 11.
[1:38:00]
Okay, then the eyes have it and we have cured our open meaning a lot of complaints.
[1:38:09]
Let me explain what that means.
[1:38:12]
So currently what that means is that we don't believe that we had an open meaning violation,
[1:38:19]
however, in order to move forward, we are saying that everything that we did prior
[1:38:26]
to tonight in regards to Cavali and waiting pre-schools and the K-36 configuration at
[1:38:33]
Lester is affirmed. So it means that Cavali, the pre-school will be Lester, the pre-school at
[1:38:42]
currently a waiting will be at Lester and Lester remains a K-36 school. So that our original votes
[1:38:50]
Right, right because we were at the boat was on the six is what the boat was. Yeah, it's what it's saying exactly
[1:38:56]
Confirming it. We are ratifying that. Yeah,
[1:39:01]
okay moving on monitoring report 4.44 chairs roll
[1:39:07]
Yeah, I can pull it up
[1:39:29]
I think we have been
[1:39:42]
sorry they're pulling up the chairs roll right now
[1:39:44]
Is there anything on there that needs to be changed look like you okay?
[1:39:49]
Well, we have for example tonight's agenda item too. Oh
[1:39:54]
Probably not
[1:39:57]
Okay
[1:39:59]
Excuse me can I just and yes
[1:40:01]
Are you fine with me? Oh, yes. I'm sorry. Thank you for hanging out with us. We do appreciate you
[1:40:09]
Have a good night. You know this as well. Good night. Good night.
[1:40:19]
So I cannot read that
[1:40:21]
It's even with my glasses. Oh, there we go. All right
[1:40:28]
Okay, so we'll pull that out. Yeah, okay. We'll just pull that piece out. Yeah, if that's okay with everyone
[1:40:37]
Everybody okay with that
[1:40:39]
The first is for example, then the third note. That's in that first box the far right column the far right column
[1:40:47]
examples of where we did this
[1:40:49]
We're pulling it out the third paragraph in the upper right column
[1:40:57]
So it's decided with so far. It's so for example. Okay, we're just pulling that paragraph out
[1:41:03]
Okay, I'm everybody's okay with that. I'm sorry. I didn't even look to see you guys okay with that
[1:41:09]
I'm looking over there to my left
[1:41:10]
Yes, but it seems self-explanatory language
[1:41:15]
Yeah, I think you go out. Oh, we thought I think when we did that we just
[1:41:19]
deliberations will be fair of a seam self-explanatory, so
[1:41:26]
so yes we're pulling it sure go ahead
[1:41:31]
okay all right annual district meeting planning so we will have a budget presentation at our
[1:41:38]
annual meeting and we will also have a bond proposal presentation I believe it was in your packet
[1:41:46]
The proposal that are the bond proposal that Jill duty and myself worked on a little bit more Jill than myself
[1:41:58]
Did anybody have a chance to look at it?
[1:42:08]
I'm not sure what page
[1:42:21]
The
[1:42:25]
funds. What are we talking about? No, there should be a proposal so that you guys can see it for the first time
[1:42:33]
Maybe it's not in there. I didn't see you
[1:42:38]
Okay, well, I didn't like because I just assuming we had pictures and stuff and oh, they're what yeah
[1:42:42]
There were our pictures. It's essentially a mashup of our mom for proposal and the
[1:42:50]
All right, well then this is what I'm gonna do. I'm gonna send it out to all of you
[1:42:56]
Yes
[1:42:57]
No, that's not it. No, so what I'm gonna do is I'll have Melinda send it out to you tomorrow. If you have any specific
[1:43:05]
Yuck, sir, yay, is about it. Please send them to me. Not to everybody, just send it to me so that we can make any changes.
[1:43:15]
I was going to give the presentation unless you'd like to do it.
[1:43:18]
I won't be here.
[1:43:19]
Oh, fine.
[1:43:20]
You're going to be gone.
[1:43:21]
Oh, that's where you can't go in or somewhere.
[1:43:23]
Yeah, it's hard to recognize.
[1:43:24]
Okay, okay.
[1:43:25]
So yeah, so, um, probably me.
[1:43:28]
Welcome.
[1:43:29]
All right.
[1:43:30]
So I will send out that bond proposal and the budget presentation is essentially going to be the same as it was last year.
[1:43:38]
Well, you know, just with different numbers.
[1:43:42]
All right.
[1:43:44]
As far as the middle school model and communication planning,
[1:43:47]
I went to the Brandon Selectboard meeting and the Lester Selectboard meeting the last two Monday nights.
[1:43:55]
Leslie also went to the Lester one last night as well.
[1:44:01]
I had three talking points, number one, what our budget increased was, number two that we are looking at at a bond, whether that is a bond that just makes her great again, all of her inwards.
[1:44:13]
Here, Otter Valley, or if it also includes the middle school model will be up to the community to give us feedback on what they feel they can stomach.
[1:44:22]
Although, after hearing what three of our legislators had to say, I think that it would make us look like we're doing strategic planning.
[1:44:37]
And we can do that here too.
[1:44:38]
That's the other cool thing.
[1:44:39]
I feel like if we were focused on some of those.
[1:44:42]
I'm really happy that they're talking about allowing us to be able to have CT programs on our campuses.
[1:44:51]
because it seems like we've been, our schools like Audir Valley have been prevented because
[1:44:58]
you're supposed to send.
[1:45:00]
Your students to the tech centers and I think I can't remember if it was Williams or or a week should brought it up the fact that if you send, actually, my, my, my, my comment that if you keep a student here for CTE that's one less student that's going to the tech center for CTE and I'm not necessarily I'm okay with that.
[1:45:22]
Because we're allowing more people in that district in our area.
[1:45:26]
Well, that was great.
[1:45:27]
Well, in that waiting list, at Stafford of 80 students,
[1:45:30]
now all of a sudden is much less because you haven't seen programs.
[1:45:33]
You're not spending your money on busing.
[1:45:36]
Right.
[1:45:37]
The other piece, too, is just a little good.
[1:45:41]
The other piece, too, is being it.
[1:45:43]
And I think he also mentioned that you may not need to have a gigantic,
[1:45:47]
like a huge shop available.
[1:45:51]
there are plenty of other CTE programs that you can do in a classroom. And so you might need to buy
[1:45:59]
some special equipment, but you can do it in a classroom. And so that would be something that we could
[1:46:03]
really utilize. And I think it's a good opportunity to read out kids or serious about it.
[1:46:13]
An introductory too. Oh, yeah, sure. If you don't excel here, then you can't even plot or over that
[1:46:20]
Right, no right, no more of a specialty.
[1:46:23]
We're also kids who want to wear a skill, but not necessarily going to a trade.
[1:46:26]
Like a lot of kids want to own a world, but they don't necessarily want to go to a two year world.
[1:46:31]
Right, I went to Fair Haven, and I did not go to Stafford, even though I knew I was going to be in the trades,
[1:46:37]
because I didn't want to drive 45 minutes, and I was too anxious to be in a separate location, you know.
[1:46:44]
That's just having some exposure.
[1:46:47]
Well, even if you want to do some woodworking, you know, I mean if you, you know, it doesn't mean you want to go into construction, but you can, you know, redo your own house or something like that.
[1:46:57]
I think that Mr. Clark Pack could probably, you could easily do some of that stuff because he has this year he set up the welding shop who are doing welding and they're now, he has a lot more, he has a ton of machines but woodworking.
[1:47:15]
I think if he was just allowed to, he could probably easily set up a few programs.
[1:47:21]
We just need another one of him.
[1:47:23]
Yeah.
[1:47:24]
Well, maybe not a him directly, but you know, someone who can do the things he does.
[1:47:28]
But the other ability too is to be able to draw on some of the CTE funds.
[1:47:33]
When we actually went, because Mr. Carpeck is certified.
[1:47:37]
So as a result, we should be receiving some of the CTE funds that we come along with that as well.
[1:47:44]
Okay, good. All right, well anyway, so that is I'm going in the interest of time to move the overview of all funds in the cell phone ban policy.
[1:47:55]
We're gonna kick that to the next meeting, which won't be until the middle of March. However, there is community linkage tomorrow night.
[1:48:02]
There is the Pittsburgh Select Board meeting. I cannot attend, which I don't know if you want to attend.
[1:48:09]
I'm gonna talk about the budget.
[1:48:12]
Oh, shh, shh, shh.
[1:48:13]
It's just three little, you know.
[1:48:15]
Yeah, well we have an R&E as you board meeting, otherwise I would go with you.
[1:48:19]
I have a helmet.
[1:48:19]
And face the lions then.
[1:48:23]
So, but we can talk, if you want, we can talk about what the, you know, three major, three major points to make and you can,
[1:48:30]
we should do that.
[1:48:31]
Yeah, so we'll talk in talk tomorrow.
[1:48:34]
It's calming when you have time.
[1:48:36]
Okay.
[1:48:37]
Also, this Saturday from 8 to 10 at the Brain and Transfer Station, which is actually at
[1:48:43]
Hase Palettes, Renee is going to be there waving, I was going to be there with you too,
[1:48:47]
however, my son is going to be wrestling first time competitively in Berry, so I'm going
[1:48:53]
to travel with Berry, so I won't be able to be there, but also on Saturday from 1030 to
[1:49:00]
noon is the Lester Transfer Station at their town hall, so if any of you can make it to
[1:49:05]
Dave or talk to people that'd be great.
[1:49:08]
Well, we'll have the books extra handouts of people need them.
[1:49:13]
And if they haven't received them yet,
[1:49:15]
and I'll bring you coffee if you are willing to join me.
[1:49:19]
And Saturday February 28th, which is next Saturday,
[1:49:22]
there's a Pittsburgh Transportation Transportation
[1:49:25]
and then the wedding transfer station.
[1:49:28]
So, advocacy, anything you want to talk about there.
[1:49:31]
Um, just, you know, keep yourself updated with all the information that's coming out of
[1:49:36]
the monthly.
[1:49:37]
I had, I need to go probably on the way home, listen to the, whenever testimony, um,
[1:49:43]
Secretary's Honors provided today in the Senate Ed Committee, because Senator Weeks
[1:49:46]
made it sound like it was very interesting.
[1:49:49]
Um, really good.
[1:49:50]
The CTE testimony.
[1:49:53]
Um, the other piece.
[1:49:54]
Um, so within the, uh, within the document, um, you'll see, uh, a presentation that, uh,
[1:50:00]
Senator Saunders gave to the House, Ed Committee, and one of the things that was really
[1:50:08]
happy that Senator Weeks brought it up, but also that in the presentation that she provided
[1:50:14]
to the Education Committee is really getting to the point of, we need to start with what
[1:50:20]
we are expecting.
[1:50:21]
What is educational quality actually supposed to be not just what we think it should be in
[1:50:27]
of our 119 districts, but actually what is the state expecting us to produce with our students
[1:50:33]
as they go through our systems, and so, and then the BSPAA Education Legislative Report is,
[1:50:41]
if you have all kinds of time, you can see all the different bills that are percolating up to
[1:50:46]
the legislature this year. Let's see, Superintendent, it's announcement, say thing, or anything.
[1:50:53]
The only thing, we are finally able to announce that we receive the Transcend Fellowship
[1:51:02]
and we've started meeting with Principal Ruppel, Mr. Carpac, and I have started meeting
[1:51:09]
kind of as the core group but then we are also including teachers and others as part of
[1:51:17]
our next level group and we're also going to be inviting members of the community to join
[1:51:21]
us along the way because and it's really important for us to really kind of set the future
[1:51:26]
and if we're really able to start offering CTE on our campuses, this is going to be a perfect
[1:51:32]
segue.
[1:51:34]
Yes, sir.
[1:51:34]
Is that one of the things you said you would like me to be at?
[1:51:39]
Cool.
[1:51:40]
All right.
[1:51:40]
Our annual district meeting is next Wednesday, February 25th, except for those of us will
[1:51:44]
be in Florida.
[1:51:46]
630 here at the auto rally library. New board member orientation will be Tuesday March 10th
[1:51:53]
If we have any new board members
[1:51:56]
I don't think we have anybody running that is new news. Oh, yes, yes, yes, although I did talk to her at the pre one
[1:52:05]
So yeah, so I guess we have to have that. I mean there is a writing campaign
[1:52:08]
There is okay, and then our next board meeting will be Tuesday March 17th here at 6 o'clock
[1:52:15]
where we will reorganize. So unless there's anything else anybody would like to talk about
[1:52:21]
I'm gonna let you go at 8.57 for an answer. Really. Thank you. All right move second day is a second
[1:52:30]
All those in favor? Aye. All right. All right. All right. Thank you.