Owosso, MI meeting

Owosso, MI · More Owosso, MI meetings · More Michigan meetings

Transcript

Download: Text · SRT ·
AI TRANSCRIPT

This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.

[0:02] Good evening, we're going to start the meeting tonight with the opening prayer led by Pastor Bill Moll,
[0:08] free Methodist Church, Pastor.
[0:12] Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Yes, great. We take this moment,
[0:18] Almighty God, King of Heaven, and Maker of Earth, and each person, to recognize that we need
[0:26] wisdom from on high, for every decision, for everything that we discuss in this time, whether
[0:34] it's the leaders or those in our community, we're so thankful, Lord, that you've created
[0:39] the apostle community in each one in it, and may there be justice for all as business
[0:45] is conducted. Lord, we ask for your help now. In Jesus' name, amen.
[0:51] In that statement, take it faster.
[0:54] All the pledges of the allegiance will be led by our mayor,
[0:58] pro-Tem Jerry Haver.
[1:00] I pledge allegiance to the Black and United States of America
[1:05] and to the Republic for which it stands.
[1:08] One nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice
[1:13] for all.
[1:16] This brings us to the roll call, Madam Clerk, when you are ready.
[1:18] here.
[1:20] Mayor Ties.
[1:21] Here.
[1:22] Pro-10 Haver.
[1:23] Here.
[1:23] Councilmember Fier.
[1:24] Here.
[1:25] Luddington.
[1:25] Here.
[1:26] Olsen.
[1:27] Here.
[1:27] Asma.
[1:28] Here.
[1:28] Always.
[1:29] Here.
[1:30] Thank you, Madam Clerk.
[1:31] This brings us to the approval of the agenda in which we have one addition, I believe, item
[1:38] number.
[1:41] Yes.
[1:43] Okay.
[1:44] We have two things.
[1:45] One, in addition to the consent agenda item number 12, contract authorization public safety and car camera change over and the other changes there is not a city manager's report tonight.
[2:01] It's usually the first meeting of the month.
[2:04] I make a motion to prove the agenda with the agenda and minus the city manager report.
[2:09] All right, so far, I have a motion to support.
[2:12] All those in favor, please say aye.
[2:14] Aye, aye.
[2:15] All opposed to the same, the approval agenda is approved with the changes.
[2:22] This was just to the approval of minutes of the regular meeting of September 8th, 2026.
[2:30] I have a motion to support, all those in favor, please say aye.
[2:35] All opposed to the same.
[2:37] meeting the minutes of the regular meeting of September the 8th, 2026 are approved.
[2:43] This brings us to proclamations and special presentations in which we have none tonight.
[2:48] This brings us to public hearings in which we have one ordinance amendment unpaid parking violations.
[2:54] And we will start off with our chief.
[2:58] Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
[3:00] The front of the council tonight is update to Section 3354 for requests for formal parking
[3:07] citations under any section of this chapter.
[3:09] Shall the issue remain unpained in the excess of 30 days for vehicle bearing the same plate?
[3:14] The vehicle may be removed many, many other parts of the place I told you.
[3:20] Background out of this was the front of council about 15 months ago back in front of you today.
[3:26] last week I did have a conference called along with my co-workers with
[3:31] passport which is our contract parking services and our rep that we talked to
[3:36] we were talked we talked about this several times over the last 12 months we are
[3:41] the only municipality or entity that she is wearing that work that does not have
[3:47] something on the back end for people we don't have so towing boot or
[3:56] collections. Majority is up to them. They don't have percentages, but she did quantify it by saying she doesn't have access to all the cities that need to be in a very large company that do cities from large cities all over the country to cities much more than us.
[4:12] That's her question.
[4:13] Hello. Questions from the council to the chief? If you have any.
[4:18] Well, to your point about the options that could be available to us, at the hearing we'd be provided with the cost for the boot option or towing option like it's just towing.
[4:32] Just towing those questions I need to let them be as close as I could be sure to.
[4:36] I think, okay.
[4:37] Any
[4:41] other questions?
[4:43] My question would be, are they going to be more consistent in forcing the parking?
[4:47] because right now it seems that it's very inconsistent.
[4:51] I'm not following you.
[4:54] Well, I mean, I see people parking past the limits all the time downtown,
[4:59] and only a select few get ticketed.
[5:02] All right, he's not working seven days or five days a week.
[5:05] He's limited time that he works, but we will try and work that more.
[5:08] Well, I get that he's not working seven days a week, and it's almost every day I could drive through downtown
[5:15] and show you vehicles that weren't ticketed while other ones were.
[5:21] I'm against the tone only because the park enforcement is not consistent across the board.
[5:28] If you can have your example, I can review it.
[5:32] Come out with me tomorrow, I'll show you all kinds of examples through downtown.
[5:39] The whole point is that you've got to have some type of enforcement, no matter what.
[5:49] Okay. So if we get to three people, go walk in the streets and enforcing, and there's no way to enforce violations.
[6:01] What's the good of having three people walk around and give the tickets? That's the bottom line.
[6:09] I get that there has to be some sort of enforcement, but if it's not consistent, then it looks like you're targeting certain people.
[6:16] Well, let's, we can make a consistent, let's make a consistent before we worry about
[6:22] tone certain people's vehicles.
[6:25] Well, let's, let's put it this way, you've got four times, so if you're going to get
[6:32] the ticket at four times three, three days a page ticket, I think that's pretty darn lenient,
[6:38] lenient.
[6:38] I'm not saying it's not lenient.
[6:40] Yeah, I, I mean, you usually have went up there to take it with it.
[6:44] I'd be like that's taken, taken it down the street.
[6:46] We got a guy that's going around think that we hire that's discouraged because people
[6:53] think he's a joke because we don't enforce anything.
[7:01] So there's, there's one of the problems right there.
[7:05] And he's not working now or how long now hasn't he been out there working?
[7:09] I was not working just sporadically.
[7:12] He was off for a while for me, so we could have, we could put more time into ticketing
[7:19] and enforcing the law, that's what the basically the council person is talking about, correct?
[7:30] So I don't think this is a long term thing, but taking down the street, we take it down the street 15 months.
[7:38] 15 months and Councilwoman Osmer was mentioning, what's the number again?
[7:46] 15,000?
[7:47] Yeah, 15,000.
[7:49] So we need to do something.
[7:51] We need to act.
[7:52] If we need to act and say, hey, Chief, you heard Councilman Owens, we need more people out there patrolling it.
[8:02] then we've got to get with our city staff and say hey this is what we need but to me
[8:08] I think we need to make a they get going on and make this happen I'm tired of 15
[8:13] months now we're going to wait what another three four months five months
[8:16] approved that we're doing a better job I don't think we need to do that but I'm
[8:23] just one vote there's six other people here now I can vote against against me
[8:28] He's fine, it's not going to hurt my feelings,
[8:30] I'm still going to go home and go to sleep tonight.
[8:32] Tell me too.
[8:33] Then I'm too many meetings where I got hurt feelings.
[8:36] I wouldn't be here.
[8:38] Just voice in my opinion, that's OK.
[8:40] Well, Mayor, I wanted to add on to that
[8:42] because I think I hear what council member Owen's saying.
[8:46] But I do want to give the caveat of even if certain people
[8:50] feel as though they're being targeted,
[8:52] they're still getting a ticket because they're doing something
[8:54] wrong.
[8:55] So even if they feel like they're being targeted
[8:57] it specifically. And like Jane Doe over there had didn't get a ticket. They're still
[9:04] parking against an ordinance. Like they're still not following the law even if they feel
[9:07] as though they're being targeted. That's the thing for me is all of us comes down to
[9:12] are you following the law or aren't you? And you're not.
[9:15] So can I ask, are objective with the ticketing? Is it to make every space pay for itself
[9:23] All day like during those the working hours because we wanted to turn workers from parking in shoppers spaces
[9:32] You know what do you mean like? What's the objective? I don't the objective is to follow a lot?
[9:37] Well, no, I understand. Yeah, I'm saying objective is to keep the closer
[9:41] In front of store fronts available for customer use
[9:44] And people could just pay to park there all day long if the goal was just to collect revenue for the city or for downtown or for the DDA
[9:52] Okay, we would want those spots to be paid for every hour, right, presumably even if it was by the same person.
[9:58] Yeah, we're not getting paid money.
[9:59] This the meters or the meters that that's a bygone era right now.
[10:04] The area is is that you have X amount of hours to park in a certain spot and then you got to move.
[10:09] So so you're just not parking there and maybe I work or there and there for eight hours and not making that.
[10:16] That's about available for the next customer of one that might get there and only spend an hour.
[10:20] Right. So we're doing it for the purpose of flow. That's right. Okay. So what about the customers that show up and
[10:26] Like they have a meeting in the in the together in the room inside the deli and their group is there
[10:32] It's been the whanness club is there for two or three hours and that we won't be there two to three hours
[10:37] What you won't be there, but other groups have well
[10:42] Then there's others lots of have longer periods. You might have to have a little bit of walk, but if they're all full of employees cars
[10:50] Now you're telling the customers they can't come in and there's always an option.
[10:53] Well, on me at this part of the NCG lot and walk, I mean, there was an
[10:57] park at the NCG lot and walk to the north side of downtown.
[11:00] There's always an option because there's always a negative, there's always a
[11:04] problem. Yes. In the past, I have gone to a salon downtown and some of the
[11:11] processes take longer than two hours, but there was an arrangement, I believe.
[11:17] I don't know how long ago it was, but were they were able to give a parking pass or something?
[11:26] If they knew you were going to have a longer surface.
[11:29] Well, the lot right behind it is four hours, which is plenty of time.
[11:34] This came up numerous times since I've been here.
[11:36] Yeah, the salon has to come in.
[11:55] I'm going to open
[12:00] the public here.
[12:02] Well, we're having so much fun.
[12:04] Let's hear from them.
[12:05] Is there any more council comments?
[12:09] I'm done.
[12:09] I don't know what you might be doing.
[12:11] That's okay.
[12:12] I enjoyed it.
[12:14] Thank you.
[12:15] I think this is unfortunate that we have to take it to the soil, but it's something
[12:20] it needs to be done.
[12:21] If you get a park intake, you pay it.
[12:23] I mean, I don't.
[12:23] I agree.
[12:24] So if you're not going to pay it, then there's consequences.
[12:27] There's a way from the paint online, correct?
[12:30] They don't have to walk in with 15 bucks.
[12:32] Okay, good.
[12:33] I just want to make sure that there's an archwood on the citation.
[12:38] Perfect.
[12:39] That makes me feel a lot better.
[12:41] So with that it's the public's turn which you'll have one opportunity of the three
[12:48] minutes duration during each public hearing and the comments made during the
[12:52] public hearing shall be revelant to the subject for which the public
[12:56] hearings are held. When recognized please come to the podium, give your name and
[13:00] address and direct your comments to the mayor. Is there anyone at this time that
[13:05] I would like to make a public comment.
[13:07] Yes, Mr. Klein?
[13:13] My client will force you to have her drive.
[13:16] As I mentioned two weeks ago,
[13:17] I did this for six years for the city.
[13:21] It wasn't about parking tickets,
[13:22] but it was about impounding cars.
[13:26] And you're going to open up a whole can of worms
[13:27] that you guys have not discussed yet.
[13:30] And this is the night to do it.
[13:33] This is where you need to discuss it,
[13:35] because I know what's going to happen,
[13:36] because I dealt with it for six years.
[13:39] First one is going to be,
[13:41] you talked about waving $15,000 worth of tickets.
[13:46] Is the list of the people
[13:49] that got the $15,000 worth of tickets we weighed?
[13:53] Where the FOIA is that list available
[13:56] or I could walk into the Warsaw Police Department
[13:59] and return in a FOIA,
[14:01] and they will give me the list of the people
[14:03] that you weigh $15,000 worth of tickets on.
[14:05] and if you won't do it, tell me why tonight.
[14:11] What towing company are you gonna use?
[14:13] Are you going to use the one you're contracted with right now?
[14:16] As I mentioned two weeks ago,
[14:18] you had a candidate for city council
[14:19] who you are contracted with at this time.
[14:23] Are you going to use them or are you gonna use somebody else?
[14:28] It would be great if you'd wait until the new council comes on
[14:32] because they're the ones that are gonna have to deal with it.
[14:37] I look, you guys keep talking about the downtown district parking.
[14:41] What you don't mention are the four major entries into the city of Olasso, and it says
[14:48] no overnight parking between 3 a.m. and 6 a.m.
[14:53] What are you going to do about those people that are on the streets every night?
[15:00] Who's going to collect the money? Let's say, for example, Jerry Hayber got his car impounded on Friday night for unpaid parking tickets. Not to pick on you. I could have, you could have mentioned any other name, but you got your car impounded. It's Saturday. City Hall is not open on Saturday. How does Jerry Hayber, if he doesn't have a smartphone, he doesn't have internet. How does he get his car back the next day or on Sunday? How does he get it back?
[15:29] Where does he pay his tickets at? Is the towing company going to collect the money and then turn it into the city?
[15:35] How are the people going to get their car back?
[15:42] And is there going to be any type of profit in this for the city? Is there going to be any kind of a
[15:48] $5 paperwork fee, a $10 paperwork fee, anything like that?
[15:54] But you really you keep discussing downtown district?
[15:59] What about citywide?
[16:01] Because there's a citywide ordinance from three to six.
[16:05] And it does help.
[16:06] I mean, I'm against this, totally against this.
[16:09] What you guys are trying to do, towing the car,
[16:12] taking the car, just slap the ticket on them.
[16:15] Or the boot, the boot is a great idea.
[16:18] Let's say, for example, a hot shot business owner
[16:20] in the downtown district.
[16:22] But I think I know who one of the people is
[16:24] that gets a lot of tickets.
[16:25] You know how embarrassed that would be
[16:27] If they were to come out and leave and there's a big ol' yellow boot on their car, that'd be pretty embarrassing.
[16:33] Thank you.
[16:36] For the comments.
[16:40] Yes sir.
[16:48] Kill Humphrey 1202, South Chipman.
[16:50] So Mary, I appreciate what you guys are trying to do and I appreciate all your comments.
[16:54] I've been downtown talking to the businesses and I've gotten both sides of this story.
[16:59] The business owners are complaining that they don't have enough space to part for their
[17:03] whole time.
[17:03] I've gotten that from two or three different people and business owners are
[17:07] complaining that the parking spots in front of them are just full all the
[17:13] time. So I've heard both sides of it. I guess the only thing I can say if
[17:19] we're going to give tickets I am completely in favor of they have to mean
[17:23] something. If you're going to break the law you got to pay the fine and if they're
[17:27] not going to collect the fines then there has to be some kind of penalty. Now I
[17:33] I haven't been around long enough to know if that's the right answer or the wrong answer.
[17:37] I do know that that's what I'm getting from the business owners that I've talked to.
[17:40] Thank you.
[17:41] Thank you.
[17:44] For the comments.
[17:51] Seeing none, I'll bring it back to the city council for any comments.
[17:56] I'll give one more thing.
[17:58] So I can echo some of the works downtown, but also shops that was downtown or talks to other downtown visitors owners.
[18:05] There are definitely spots where there's the chief issue of there's not enough spots for customers
[18:10] So like right on north Washington just part of the main street. There's never enough spots there
[18:14] And so people who sit there and don't move
[18:18] Absolutely a problem, but I I will agree I have heard from some business owners that they don't know where to park, but I think that's more of a
[18:26] Education problem because I park in a lot and walk to my office
[18:31] And if that lot's full, I can park in the problem lot.
[18:34] And if that lot's full, I can park in the armory lot.
[18:36] So there are options.
[18:38] But I have also communicated with people in that area.
[18:42] And it's a complicated issue for sure.
[18:44] But we have no teeth behind our current policy.
[18:48] And so this gives us that.
[18:50] Thank you.
[18:54] If you want to comment the second time, Mr. Klein brought up
[18:59] Impalming cars and having a problem with with it and it's six years of experience
[19:05] What's your feel on that?
[19:08] I can
[19:09] I was not here when Mike did that was you know all plus years ago
[19:14] But he would use our contract like the service and as far as
[19:19] Once the tickets are paid online, we would be notified and then release would be done
[19:23] It's a very simple process. Yep. I mean you can pay right in your phone
[19:30] So can you walk us through, let's say somebody gets ticket Friday, think it back to the
[19:36] vehicle.
[19:38] It's not there.
[19:42] Well, prior to that, they are given four letters or sent to the house, 30 days after
[19:45] the fourth.
[19:46] Okay.
[19:47] It just happens, let's say, in Mr. Klein's example, you get your fourth ticket, right?
[19:54] 30 years later, it can be towed, it can be towed that day, but it can be towed and it just
[19:59] That would be a Friday, we saw it.
[20:01] Well, just be random.
[20:02] You come out of your car's gone.
[20:04] And this is after you have not paid four tickets
[20:09] in 30 days after that.
[20:10] That's right.
[20:14] So, they should know that their car has been towed, right?
[20:19] I mean, I'm just trying to figure it would like
[20:22] what process as you come out of your car's gone.
[20:24] And it's like, oh shoot, I'd never paid those tickets.
[20:26] or oh my god somebody's filming car.
[20:29] It happens. Our officers are free.
[20:31] They can think of that out pretty quick.
[20:33] They will know about the car's impound
[20:35] and it gets around pretty quick.
[20:36] Right, okay.
[20:37] Prior to that, they'll receive a letter
[20:39] and if this passes tonight,
[20:41] we will add another sentence
[20:43] to our letter that sent out
[20:44] upon the fourth citation,
[20:47] the vehicle may be towed.
[20:48] Right.
[20:48] So they'll have four letters in their inbox
[20:51] in the US mail.
[20:53] Right. So the intent is to get them
[20:54] to pay the ticket, not to tow the car.
[20:57] Like we're giving every opportunity
[20:58] for these people to pay for their tickets.
[21:01] There's a appeal process that I feel they can take it
[21:03] to the district court.
[21:04] So all that's been set up.
[21:05] Perfect.
[21:06] And it's all explained to them in great detail.
[21:09] Right.
[21:09] They received the first section.
[21:10] Sure.
[21:11] So let's say they gave toad.
[21:14] First call is to the police department or city hall?
[21:18] Is it saying the letter?
[21:20] No, we don't tell people how.
[21:21] It's six o'clock at night and City Hall is closed. Who do they go pay to get their car back?
[21:27] They can pay on their phone.
[21:28] But how would they know? I mean, they can scan it, they can go on to the portal.
[21:35] They're getting four letters and then...
[21:38] Are they getting four letters or are they towable as of the fourth ticket?
[21:42] No, they're getting four letters after each citation after 30 days. That's right, they're
[21:46] giving a letter. So after the fourth letter, you can maybe tow it.
[21:52] And all they have to do is they could pay online and then the vehicle will be released
[21:55] and they can contact the record service and we would notify them and they could pay
[21:59] the fee to that.
[22:01] So they'd pay the towing fee plus the four unpaid parking tickets in order to get their
[22:06] car back?
[22:07] Correct.
[22:07] And then the tickets first.
[22:09] You have to pay the tickets first.
[22:10] Okay.
[22:12] So is it?
[22:13] I've recently discovered that the mail, that even to send a letter with Inno also, first
[22:18] and now has to go to Grand Rapids and be sorted and then come back to O'ahu.
[22:24] We don't think we don't send out the letters that the company does passport.
[22:27] Great. I guess I'm just saying that there's a delay now, even within our own town.
[22:33] So how soon after the fourth ticket would they be eligible to be towed?
[22:39] 30th day from the ticket.
[22:41] 30th day from the last from the fourth ticket.
[22:43] The letters mail on the 31st day of the next business day, whichever one is next.
[22:47] but they did get the ticket on their cars.
[22:49] The ticket has been there on their car for 30 days now.
[22:52] They're fourth tickets.
[22:53] The fourth ticket has been on their car.
[22:55] And now they have one month to basically come up
[22:59] with to pay at least one of the tickets.
[23:01] Okay, I just wanted to make sure that I'm not missing
[23:05] the fourth for the trees here because I get your points.
[23:08] Like if you were to go out and like imagine parents,
[23:12] let's say, and their kids get the tickets
[23:15] and the kids throw away the tickets and the parents don't know that there are
[23:19] four tickets because this is not until they've been hiding mail since the beginning of time.
[23:24] It wouldn't be the first time a kid intercepted the mail.
[23:28] Oh, they're going to steal a mail too.
[23:30] Well, they're going to collect, they're going to call the police department for the car stolen
[23:34] and then they're going to say, oh, your car is stolen and your president found it because of unpaid tickets.
[23:39] There you go.
[23:40] Do you know roughly, I'm assuming you've gotten ballpark figures on what the actual
[23:44] the compound cost will be, or the towing cost or whatever, because without that information.
[23:49] There's the storage fee, so everyone's going to be different.
[23:52] But we do have a contract with this company, so have they provided us with those numbers?
[23:57] We have a contract and what, I don't know the amount on top of my head, but yes.
[24:01] Well, we have those numbers at the hearing, or the public.
[24:06] This is it, I'm sorry, will we have those numbers at any point?
[24:10] No, we won't.
[24:11] We approve them.
[24:13] We approve that contract.
[24:14] Okay, perfect.
[24:16] We're in year two or three.
[24:17] Yeah, but I guess when the other thing are after like an accident or something like that,
[24:22] or because somebody's been pulled over for a DOI,
[24:26] like that frequency is much less than what could potentially be happening here.
[24:29] So like the rate and like I don't want it to turn into a situation where we approved a rate
[24:35] that potentially seemed like it was going to happen and frequently to a limited number of people
[24:40] and therefore justified to, suddenly now, how many tickets does the $15,000 amount to actual tickets?
[24:47] I can't remember. From your last report, how many tickets?
[24:51] I have no idea.
[24:55] 30 tickets, right?
[24:56] Yeah, I mean, it's a math for about $30 dollars, right?
[24:59] You know, my point is for your tickets, you've got four tickets, you've got 30 days for tickets,
[25:05] through your math that way, 30 times four, so many days. You know, I mean, how much,
[25:11] How much more do you want to give and and and it's a toe is a toe
[25:17] Entropy penalty. Okay. I know you're thinking all of a sudden all of these are going to get
[25:22] 300 cars are going to be towing. That's not going to be the case
[25:25] It's going to be hopefully it gets around that we do toe
[25:29] And hopefully people start doing detours the behavior
[25:34] Hopefully that happens because right now when I good faith didn't work
[25:39] Well, kind of one of the things that we also just to be clear, we also didn't make a decision because we didn't have data and we were right at the precipice of getting a new system.
[25:48] The data that we had, the data that we had, it's that we're the only city that doesn't do it.
[25:55] No, I'm back then.
[25:57] Back then.
[25:57] The idea is that somehow we deferred or kicked the can and I don't think we did it.
[26:02] I think we did for a reason because we didn't have data and we were right about to start a new system.
[26:06] We disagree on that way, okay. Yeah, we had plenty of data from other cities
[26:14] Okay, and we we did it for other reasons, I think so we're back 15 months later with faith in work
[26:21] Yeah, okay, now it's time to do what you're supposed to be doing pay your tickets and you won't be told
[26:28] Yeah, I guess don't you don't you want to know though like? Oh, I have very voted for right, you know, yeah, who is it told?
[26:39] I'm happy with it, so it's not me that I'm worried about it, like people that don't.
[26:46] I hate to say this, but I absolutely agree with Mike under Mr. Klein on this one that I think
[26:53] a boot would be more embarrassing than a toe.
[26:56] Did you, yeah, I'm assuming you guys looked into the cost of a boot compared to a toe?
[27:01] No?
[27:02] No.
[27:02] I think the conversation I had with the chief was, is that the majority of the of the municipalities are towing.
[27:12] And we would have to have it in each vehicle with every day, it's very, it's not a usual friendly system.
[27:21] It's not like you just, we'd have to buy, I don't know how much they cost, towing is more efficient, it's easier on our staff.
[27:27] Yeah, it's way more costly to the community who's already strapped for cash for your tickets.
[27:35] I get that.
[27:36] I'm just.
[27:37] I'm never too much.
[27:38] At least in my opinion.
[27:40] I'm always in mind for your tickets, you know, so then you don't have any issues.
[27:47] A couple of other things.
[27:48] You've got four strikes in your out-for-feet sake, if it was one, you're different.
[27:54] Four times and out.
[27:56] I'm not, I don't have a lot of compassion when you don't pay your tickets.
[28:01] So the towing will come back before council for the next contract period.
[28:06] So there'll be future council voting on that, yeah.
[28:12] My question is the list public, I believe we did publish it the last time around.
[28:19] Am I right about that?
[28:20] People that had outseaning tickets.
[28:23] I don't remember.
[28:24] We did not.
[28:24] This is the boy at the boy a question. Yeah, I thought I don't remember names being on the list. No. Okay. No, they just can't volunteer at least in the middle of their weekend meeting.
[28:35] All we had was $1 a month. We did. There was no. Okay. We don't have individuality. If we did for it, it's not allowed to release personal names like that. We have to forget them. Okay. So it's just a dollar. Okay. We don't we don't have that list. It's not something that we compile.
[28:48] Okay.
[28:52] The question about the three to six PM, my thing is, is that it's not saying we don't, we're
[28:58] just addressing downtown.
[29:00] This is addressing everything.
[29:01] This is addressing the three to six.
[29:03] It's parking tickets.
[29:04] It's parking tickets.
[29:05] It's a period no matter where it's at, no matter if it's downtown, three to six, it's parking
[29:10] violations.
[29:11] You get a ticket.
[29:12] That's one of four.
[29:18] It's probably worth also speaking to the fact that it would be ridiculous to not vote
[29:22] on something because somebody has chosen to run for counsel, like that's neither here nor there,
[29:28] like if you want a truly unbiased thing, then we would keep moving forward without concern for
[29:36] who has chosen to run for sitting counsel because that is an undecided thing and it will be by the
[29:41] time this is already decided. So that's what I would say. There's no conflict of interest there.
[29:48] I would say that there's no conflict of interest because no one on here owns the towing company.
[29:55] And there is no guarantee that the person who owns the towing company is going to be on council.
[30:00] We're benefit from any sort of change in policy. So that's my point on that. That's good point.
[30:07] For the comments, it's singing anything deserves. I make a motion to approve the ordinance amendment for unpaid parking violations. Support. Emotion support. This be a roll call, both Madam Clerk, when you're ready. Council member fear. Yes. Bolson.
[30:29] Yes. Osmer. Yes. Rotem. Haver. Yes. Council member Owens. No.
[30:37] Loddington?
[30:38] Yes.
[30:39] Mayor Tyne?
[30:40] Yes.
[30:41] The motion for the ordinance amendment is approved.
[30:46] This brings us to our first and second comments, in which each person is going to address the city council.
[30:51] There will be a one opportunity up to one opportunity, four minutes duration during the first occasion,
[30:57] and one opportunity up to three minutes during the last occasion.
[31:04] When recognized, please come to the podium, give your name and address, and direct your comments to the mayor.
[31:09] Is anyone wishing to address the council at this time?
[31:20] Just on Harrington and 515 North Washington Street, we had a really great weekend with the historical tour, had a lot of people come out, we had about 250 people, so thanks to everybody who came out, including the mayor and the city manager.
[31:31] I'm hoping to have a lot more events at the Gold House, Halloween events, Christmas events.
[31:36] We're having an event this weekend for Meet the Candidates.
[31:39] It's Sunday from 12 to 2, so I hope to see people out there.
[31:43] Thanks.
[31:43] Thank you.
[31:44] Appreciate that.
[31:46] Further comments?
[31:49] Mr. Client.
[31:58] By Client.
[31:59] A tool for Stratford Drive.
[32:00] Regardless of what the gentleman just said behind me, I just wondered if he, if maybe you
[32:05] given the opportunity to say has he contacted everybody running for City Council, or did he
[32:10] just come here and expect everybody to, you know, like, how I see three, four candidates
[32:17] running, you know, that are in your May, I think five, like how all the other candidates
[32:21] are going to find out about this meeting.
[32:23] Um,
[32:27] in regards to the downtown parking, because you guys pressed so hard about that, on my
[32:32] phone which I can produce at any given time, I've seen city-owned vehicles parked in no parking zones.
[32:42] And when I approached those city employees about why he parked in a no parking zone,
[32:47] said I went in to get a new pair of shoes. So our city employees are driving city vehicles on the
[32:55] clock. If they're spotted parking in no parking zones, are they eligible to for the tickets?
[33:04] Even though they're driving the city's vehicle and I can produce the photos on my phone.
[33:11] So I just want to know are they going to be exempt from getting parking tickets or not?
[33:19] Just so you know too, if you start impounding cars, you have to turn over private property
[33:26] that's inside the car, baby seats, medication, you can't keep that stuff.
[33:32] So if you start impounding cars and whoever you are, whoever you guys decide to start
[33:37] to own those vehicles, they have to turn over private property.
[33:43] In fact, you wouldn't have said, people needed their Bible for Sunday church.
[33:47] We had to give it to them.
[33:48] We had to go down and we had to give it to them.
[33:50] So they're entitled to their private property.
[33:52] You cannot hold their private property.
[33:55] Thank you.
[33:55] Thank you.
[33:57] Oh, I mean, I didn't use all my three minutes.
[34:00] Mayor.
[34:01] Yes.
[34:01] You did not answer one of my questions last week, but the tree's still in the river behind the
[34:07] old YWCA.
[34:08] That question was never answered.
[34:10] I will approach the director of the library on that for
[34:22] the comments.
[34:31] Seeing none, I'll bring back the council for comments.
[34:38] Okay, so I
[34:47] guess there's only one question Mr. Klein had that regarding, and I think I know that I'm not going to answer what chief, and I can't, I can't go, I'm not going to go into the personal.
[35:03] things like did they stop the by-shoes or anything, but let's say that a city vehicle DPW, whatever city vehicle, stops as using a spot that's a non-parking spot.
[35:17] Yes. Okay.
[35:18] A vehicle would be sometimes to wonder if it's parking or any other violation.
[35:22] Okay. That's the answer. All right. Thank you.
[35:25] I'm not just parking in, but I'm moving the driver.
[35:29] Any vehicle, yes.
[35:31] Okay, thank you.
[35:35] Okay, this brings us to the consent agenda.
[35:41] Make
[35:45] a motion to approve the consent amendment for it.
[35:48] A motion of support, this be a roll call,
[35:50] both amendments, or when you are ready.
[35:52] Councilmember Osmer?
[35:53] Yes.
[35:55] Owen?
[35:55] Yes.
[35:56] Yes.
[35:56] Pro-10, Haider.
[35:58] Yes.
[35:59] Council Member Olson.
[36:00] Yes.
[36:01] Luttington.
[36:02] Yes.
[36:02] Beer.
[36:03] Yes.
[36:04] Mayor Types.
[36:05] Yes.
[36:05] The Conson agenda is approved.
[36:07] This brings us to items of business in which we have two tonight.
[36:10] The first being SATA commitment.
[36:12] And I'll start it off with the city manager.
[36:15] Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
[36:18] The SATA boards.
[36:19] I'm sorry, SATA's physically here runs with the state.
[36:23] So it's October 1st through September 30th.
[36:28] So right about this time of year we are asked by SATA to approve or acknowledge their requested commitment for their next fiscal year, which is October to next September.
[36:43] This year that commitment will not exceed $123,000, $123,586 and 75 cents.
[36:54] That is estimated to be about $12,712,800 more than we will collect.
[37:05] This happened to us last year, a little over $8,000, so that number is growing.
[37:10] The good news is that we have just under $90,000 left in our opioid settlement fund and
[37:17] And before former finance director Barrett left,
[37:21] last year he did do some research with that fund
[37:25] and the folks who arranged the settlement
[37:28] to make sure that public transportation, in this case,
[37:33] SATA would be an eligible expense for that.
[37:36] And it is.
[37:37] So rather than plug that potential $12,000 gap
[37:43] with general fund dollars, we still
[37:45] We'll have a cushion to the tune about 90 grand in the opioid fund.
[37:49] So that is our plan.
[37:51] You will see and approve the final amount which comes later next year.
[37:58] But this is just the commitment amount and we always remind council that there is an overage now from our commitment to what we collect.
[38:08] So our plan is to plug that gap with the opioid fund.
[38:13] Thank you, City Manager.
[38:15] Questions from the council?
[38:18] Or a motion?
[38:19] I want to make a motion to go through it.
[38:21] It's part.
[38:22] Motion of support.
[38:23] This would be a roll call vote.
[38:24] Madam Clerk, when you're ready.
[38:26] Councilmember Luttington?
[38:28] Yes.
[38:29] Owens?
[38:30] Yes.
[38:31] Proton Haver?
[38:32] No.
[38:33] Councilmember Fear?
[38:34] Yes.
[38:35] Osmer?
[38:35] Yes.
[38:36] Olsen?
[38:37] Yes.
[38:38] Mayor Tyne?
[38:38] Yes.
[38:39] That said, a commitment is approved.
[38:41] This brings us to items of business number two, contract approvals,
[38:46] Wellington Electric Inc., which I'd be looking for a motion to abstain.
[38:51] Councilman Luttington from the items of business regarding contract approvals.
[38:55] I have a motion to kick him out, just having that same support.
[39:00] I have a motion to support this if you roll call, both.
[39:03] Madam Clerk, when you're ready.
[39:04] Councilmember Owens.
[39:06] Yes.
[39:06] Yes.
[39:07] Bowlson?
[39:07] Yes.
[39:08] You're out.
[39:08] Brooks M. Haver?
[39:10] Yes.
[39:11] Councilmember Asmer?
[39:12] Yes.
[39:13] Fear?
[39:14] Yes.
[39:15] Mayor Tyge?
[39:16] Yes.
[39:17] Motion to abstain.
[39:18] Councilman Luttington is approved.
[39:20] Take your left.
[39:21] Exactly.
[39:22] We'll do it.
[39:25] All right.
[39:27] I'd like to approve the contact amount for Luttington Electric.
[39:31] You may.
[39:32] I have a motion support.
[39:33] Does it be a roll call vote?
[39:35] Madam Clerk, when you're ready.
[39:36] Yes.
[39:36] Probe 10.
[39:37] Haber?
[39:38] Yes.
[39:39] Council Member Owens?
[39:41] Yes.
[39:46] Olsen?
[39:47] Yes.
[39:47] Beer?
[39:48] Yes.
[39:49] Asmer?
[39:50] Yes.
[39:50] Mayor Tally?
[39:51] Yes.
[39:52] The contractor approves when they can't electric ink.
[39:54] He's approved.
[39:56] And the councilman may return.
[39:59] Hello.
[40:03] Back to work.
[40:13] This brings us now to the second citizen comments in which you'll have one opportunity up to
[40:18] It's three minutes duration during public comments at this time.
[40:23] Is there anyone that would like to approach the council?
[40:31] Yes, sir?
[40:39] Gil Humphries, 1202, South Jettman, dumb question, and I apologize for asking.
[40:44] The SATA commitment, the difference between what we collect and
[40:49] what we are paying, is there one number one, why?
[40:54] And number two, is there a long-term solution to that?
[40:58] And there might be an hypothesis if it's dumb question,
[41:01] but that was on my mind when I heard that.
[41:04] Well, first of all, there's no dumb questions
[41:06] and we'll get to that question.
[41:08] Any other comments?
[41:21] My name is Jeff Turner.
[41:22] I live to all four, all put avenue on the corner
[41:27] of Oldwood and Comstock Street.
[41:30] There's people that park on the road every night
[41:32] from three to six a.m.
[41:34] Now, if you guys aren't like to say,
[41:35] If you guys are just going to throw the tickets out, what's the sense of giving them a ticket?
[41:39] They need to have tickets on them because they're parking right where the fire hydrant
[41:44] is.
[41:45] And for one, you can't, I mean, what if my house is to burn?
[41:48] How could they, if the fire truck get in there?
[41:50] I know that one of the guys told me that they'd break the windows, but it just doesn't make
[41:54] no sense why they're doing that.
[41:56] And somebody's got to, and another thing is, I was told that we only have two officers
[42:02] per shift in a while, so why do we only have two
[42:05] officers. This place, I mean, well, I was big enough to have three or four officers at one time. I would think, but you
[42:15] know, I don't understand why there's only two officers because then they because then they say that they got enough time to write out tickets, but I don't know who it is from three to six a.m.
[42:27] because, like I said, I live right on that corner.
[42:30] I've lived there for 30 years and it seems like people
[42:34] are misusing that corner a lot and they park on the road.
[42:38] I mean, on their yards and they're not supposed.
[42:40] There's an ordinance about parking on the yard too.
[42:42] You're not supposed to be parking on your yard.
[42:45] And I just wonder why are these people still doing that?
[42:50] Well, the rest of your answer in a minute here.
[42:52] All right, thanks, Jeff.
[42:56] Other comments?
[43:00] Seeing none, don't bring it back to the council.
[43:02] I'll address the questions that came up to begin with the first of all, the difference
[43:15] question on the SATA, the City Manager can address that, please.
[43:20] The SATA knowledge for the City of Alaska is approved at a third of a million, so 0.33333.
[43:27] That is adjusted because of the heavy rollback that we've been encountering every year since I've been here really.
[43:36] So the actual transportation milled rate for 2027 is reduced to 0.3185.
[43:44] That brings in $110,000, $110,792, based on a calculation of taking the previous years net
[43:57] taxable value. When I mean net taxable value, I mean our overall taxable value
[44:02] minus the tax capture for the DDA, our brownfield funds, and I think we're
[44:10] starting to involve the two pilots that we have now, the payments of
[44:17] little taxes that we have approved. The two active ones are with Washington
[44:21] Park development that's very new and the other one was with Old Lincoln School.
[44:25] Well, that one's been active since I've been here.
[44:28] But most of that capture is from the brown fields and the active brown fields and the
[44:35] DDA.
[44:36] So when you reduce that, our net tax availability, 2027, assuming that the estimated consumer
[44:43] price index for next year holds at 2.5, is 347 million, 854,000.
[44:51] So, we can do a quick calculation with the current one-third mill reduced by the acquired
[44:58] rollback for Heather.
[45:00] That's how we come up with our estimated revenue at 110, $7.92. The calculations for SATA are done based on SATA's total budget assigned to a formula based on, partially based on the right share. Okay, so if this formula was not, if this is all in your packet, if this formula was not adopted, the city of Alasso would pay substantially more than our $123,000.
[45:29] dollar max and so this is a calculation that said it does even though most of the
[45:36] rides for their service happen in OASO in that makes sense right because OASO
[45:40] is the largest community by a few factors when you compare us to the next
[45:45] lowest community. So that serves the townships that serves
[45:49] the land, Corona, Perry, not all of these townships and villages are participating
[45:56] members, though, okay? So we are, the non-participating members don't subsidize their residents'
[46:03] rights here, and our representative on SATA can correct me any time along this path.
[46:09] But I've been here eight years, and it is confusing, but Mary Rice has been doing this
[46:14] a long time, the director, and she's a wealth of knowledge with how this is calculated,
[46:20] and it is advantageous for a WASO, but with headly rollbacks and the fact that we have about
[46:27] a little over 5% of our taxable value wrapped up in tax incentives and the DDA's tax capture,
[46:36] you know, our full amount based on that third of a mill reduced by headly is not really applied
[46:41] because we have this economic development arm that has been working in the city for quite a long
[46:46] So, in a nutshell, that's how we get to that $110,000.
[46:51] Keep in mind, last year, in the year before, I believe,
[46:55] maybe last year was the only year that they get that ceiling.
[46:58] Sad as the ceiling.
[47:00] And said, we need the maximum amount you committed to.
[47:02] Every other year I've been here, it's been a last.
[47:05] Is the system perfect? No.
[47:07] And it's kind of confusing to me, but it's how sad it works it out.
[47:12] And again, it's very much advantageous to the city
[47:16] that they calculated this way.
[47:19] No, thank you.
[47:21] I'll add in.
[47:21] It's also advantageous for Corona,
[47:23] so those are the two that are using it the most.
[47:27] And if people are really curious,
[47:28] you can come to a saturday meeting
[47:29] and ask the director about it.
[47:30] It's open to the public.
[47:32] But once you're next saturday meeting,
[47:34] oh, is it it?
[47:36] It was just last night.
[47:37] The second Tuesday.
[47:38] Second Tuesday.
[47:39] Second Tuesday.
[47:40] And it's held on...
[47:42] At six o'clock at the SATA office out on Delaney.
[47:48] It costs money to have transportation and this is an important thing for a while so because we are a large chunk of the users.
[47:59] Previous year we had 19,063 calls per ride.
[48:04] 19,000.
[48:06] It's a lot.
[48:07] I think that question was getting more, could we anticipate the shortfall and prevent it, but the eight years that I've been on council, I think it's just been the last two that there was a shortfall or over just some years, so it's just a...
[48:24] The first year over, you're right, that first year was $1200 and that came out of the general fund and then we were able to use the opioid fund for the 8,000 shortfall last year.
[48:35] So there is a cushion for a little while, and we can go on doing this for quite some time, but council made it clear, I believe this council made it clear that this is very important service for the city of Oaso, and so you are willing to, you are willing to pick up the slack, and if it wasn't for that rollback, you know, we might go to get there.
[48:55] Struggles of being a city in Michigan.
[48:59] for sure.
[49:02] Okay, thank you for that. So Chief Oakwood Comstock just been up here a few
[49:09] times I think on that issue. Can you give us a low down on the cars park there three
[49:14] to six and I will advise them to do some enforcement.
[49:19] Chief is going to advise to do enforcement.
[49:24] Won't be the first time, right, Jeff?
[49:31] Yeah, I know keep complaining, it might get, you know, look, you know, every time it gets a little better.
[49:43] Okay.
[49:46] The only other question I had is, is it true that we do, it's just two officers on the night shift, is that what it is to keep?
[49:54] Depending upon these operations and sports schedule, yes, there's always two on, sometimes more.
[50:00] sometimes more. Okay.
[50:06] Which we could double our force, but we can't. So with the economics
[50:11] I'm sorry.
[50:14] Okay, with that, I said okay.
[50:18] Oh, comments. Yes. I had a question. I noticed the, I'm just
[50:26] wondering if you can give me an update on where we're at with the commercial,
[50:31] vacant property registration discussions. And I noticed that the vacant property
[50:38] Your registration line was removed from the monthly building report, so I was wondering about that.
[50:48] The monthly building report includes existing vacant structure enforcement, but that's residential and that was covered at the previous meeting.
[50:57] I'll have to talk with Tony to see why it was taken out, I'll leave it in.
[51:04] But right now the ordinance draft is still being considered by the DDA, the EV committee.
[51:10] I don't know if it's out of the EB committee yet, but the DDA made it clear that they wanted until October to render their opinion.
[51:20] So if that comes and goes, then the DDA knows that Council will have to proceed with considering that without them.
[51:29] Thank you.
[51:32] You sure can.
[51:33] I want to talk about the holiday life that we're supposed to be on all the time.
[51:41] because funny enough, this was like one thing that this whole all seven of us were in complete consensus on was that
[51:47] illuminating downtown was a good safety measure, it added charm, it added everything.
[51:52] At the time, there was no need to make a motion to keep them on
[51:56] because it made the statement that it's as simple as telling DPW that just not to turn them off.
[52:02] They've since been turned off, and I think my concern is, one, residents have sort of
[52:09] noticing it, and complaining this mother and son that ride their bike downtown have started
[52:14] plugging them back in, in the hopes that that would turn them back on, which I think is
[52:18] a sweet effort, but moreover, I have heard I've asked Nathan, Nathan, I've asked you why, and
[52:26] you had a few reasons why you thought that they had been turned off.
[52:30] And I've spoken to Lizzie, who was the reason why you said that they were turned off and she had totally different reasons.
[52:38] So I just want to, I think I'm getting, I feel like I'm getting a run around when trying to address it and figure out why we can't have charming white lights on our trees that are already on.
[52:51] It's such a light lift.
[52:52] I just don't understand why this is such a major mountain to get over when we all were in agreement that this would be
[53:01] Charming and sweet and nice and light and safety and all the good things about a well-lit downtown creates foot traffic
[53:08] Creates all the good things that we want in our community. So why is this such I'll take I'll take the first on this city manager
[53:17] And I could probably get Councilman Wellington maybe involved with a conversation as well.
[53:25] I don't think there's anything that DDA, Main Street, wants a lights off, number one.
[53:32] Okay, that's number one.
[53:33] So that's new.
[53:34] They don't, as always, as not about they want them off, it's basically, I think there's different
[53:43] electrical for the regular lighting, the post lighting wherever you call those and there's
[53:48] another electrical service for the plugs that you plug in these lights, so there's two different
[53:56] entities. One for the light poles, one for the lights. Okay, so the one for the light, the lights,
[54:02] the light, the plug-in lights. Right. Okay, that line I think services also the downtown market.
[54:11] Great. Okay. And there are some type of issue with that line that sort of circuits that.
[54:18] So, if you want to get involved and speak a little bit on that, I'd appreciate it.
[54:23] Yes, that is shorting out with the lights and the poles. So, the lights on the poles are on
[54:29] and the Christmas lights are on. The lights on the poles. So, I think we need to specify what
[54:35] lights we're talking about. Okay, yeah, no, no. Let's calm down. Let's calm our holiday lights.
[54:39] The whole holiday lights for now, for all intents and purposes, holiday lights.
[54:43] The infrastructure is basically, it needs a lot of updating its port, just having a Christmas
[54:48] lights on.
[54:49] Okay.
[54:51] What?
[54:51] And we cannot isolate where the market is, and keep those on, and turn off the lights.
[54:58] We can't alternate them.
[55:01] No.
[55:02] Not with the way the system is now.
[55:04] So the whole grid is on, or the whole grid is off.
[55:08] and like all the plugs are on or all the plugs are off that's it basically. Well
[55:12] there's five different time plugs on downtown but the whole behind fortune
[55:17] house all but on the firestone is on one circuit that's shorting out with the
[55:26] lights. When the farmer's market is trying to use the lights or the same plugs it
[55:33] Okay, why are the plugs, why are they on during the day, why are the lights on during the day, and therefore causing an opportunity for them to be over working the plugs.
[55:45] Because there's a lot of issues with the electric.
[55:51] If you mentioned something about how somebody has to come in on Saturday morning and flip the breaker.
[55:56] But like if they're not going through and unplugging things and why would flipping a breaker make a difference because it would still be overloaded.
[56:03] unless they were manually lightening the load on that breaker.
[56:08] Like, some of it just doesn't make any sense to me.
[56:12] I can walk through you with you downtown sometimes.
[56:14] Yes, I mean, we'll, I think here, if I'm just going to really get down to it,
[56:19] sometimes I feel like the objective with problem solving is to reach the dead end
[56:25] in which we can throw our hands up a mirror and say, oh, well, I can't fix it.
[56:28] Whereas to me, I feel like if the goal is to create a charming downtown
[56:33] and this is one of the ways we can do it, then maybe we hit the problem, and now how do we solve around the problem?
[56:38] And maybe it leads us in a different direction, but I think that the pertinent finding really frustrating is that I know that we all agree that it would be more charming.
[56:48] So why is the exercise not then how do we solve the problem, where we're running into the problem?
[56:54] Obviously, there's a way for us to have holiday lights on, on all the trees. We know this.
[56:59] It's poll lights are on and half the holiday lights are on.
[57:01] At 11 o'clock tonight half the holiday lights go off,
[57:04] but the other ones don't, because they're on,
[57:07] because poll lights are on for.
[57:08] So what does it take to fix this?
[57:11] What does it take, like in the big picture,
[57:13] like how do we make our town behave like a normal town
[57:17] that can have lights?
[57:19] We pull it out.
[57:19] Right, like there's gotta be a 2026 solution
[57:24] that other municipalities are being able to pull in
[57:26] to deal with like aging on old wiring.
[57:29] I mean, I even suggested to Lizzie that I was like,
[57:32] well, maybe I'll just use my city council project money
[57:35] to pursue older lights on the trees
[57:36] because we really can never have lights.
[57:39] To me, the goal is to make a lit downtown.
[57:43] However, we get there.
[57:44] So that means we have to go with solar
[57:45] because we're never gonna fix the wiring.
[57:50] I mean, it feels like that's problematic.
[57:52] I think Lizzie got many blocks fixed a couple of years ago with a lot of lights.
[58:00] I mean, that was ARPA money, but she kind of inherited it, but we also went with the
[58:04] most expensive light poles that we could possibly have come up with, so we can never continue
[58:08] it.
[58:09] But that same kind of great speed on that, everything.
[58:12] Yeah.
[58:12] There's no other halfway measure.
[58:15] I guess it's.
[58:16] I'm sorry.
[58:17] I'm just frustrated because I just feel like it's like, when you talk, when you talk about
[58:22] about the goal, it feels like how quickly can we reach the end of the conversation and
[58:28] get our hands up in the air and it makes me crazy.
[58:32] I just feel like this is your field.
[58:37] So this is a great opportunity for you to maybe offer up some suggestions of maybe anything
[58:42] that we can do directions we could go or like this is anybody does anybody have anything
[58:49] the contribute of just an idea, like I mean.
[58:52] Well, you got to know the situation.
[58:54] You got to know the problem that you have to solve.
[58:57] And that is.
[58:57] OK, and I think probably Carl and the city knows
[59:01] what probably they have to do to make it right.
[59:06] And I would say that if I'm going to guess,
[59:09] you're talking, you could talking a lot of money.
[59:13] I think the thing that they think that would satisfy
[59:15] like a councilwoman Olson, is if we actually came up with a proposal and say, you know,
[59:23] this is $1.5 million to get the Christmas lights working because you laugh, you actually laugh
[59:29] and I don't think. No, no, no, I mean, I wouldn't like that proposal. I would, you're hoping,
[59:34] you're hoping and even solar is going to, you're talking, you're always talking money and set
[59:39] the, really the right way to go. You don't know. So you have to, you have to do, you do diligence
[59:44] in your homework and you know come up with option 1, option 2 solar come up with quotes
[59:50] because I want all the lights that Lizzie got and the by side lines and this and that
[59:58] I like the old town to have new ones.
[1:00:00] But I need another $1.8 million dollars to replace the rest of them. I can only imagine what this electrical quote would be to make it right. So when you plug something in, all the lights work on both your Christmas lights and both the, the call those chancellor lights or whatever they're called. So the chairman, chairman, chairman lights working and new. So I think you just need, you need to have a plan. You are right. A plan.
[1:00:29] Again, it's great.
[1:00:31] What I have found, and this is an example,
[1:00:34] a concrete example of what I think happens,
[1:00:38] I have not gotten the same answer twice
[1:00:41] from what for the why.
[1:00:43] I've been getting that on-house people
[1:00:45] were plugging in TVs apparently down there by frontier,
[1:00:48] and that we couldn't stop from doing that,
[1:00:50] so we shut off the grid.
[1:00:51] I have gotten that there's faulty wiring.
[1:00:54] I have gotten that it pops a breaker.
[1:00:56] I have gotten, like, every time I talk to whoever I think is the point person on who can
[1:01:02] explain to me why it's not happening, the source reason for why it's not happening changes.
[1:01:08] So it's really impossible to make a plan when you're basing it off of one person who
[1:01:13] should know the answer, what their assessment is, and then you talk to the next person who
[1:01:18] should know the answer, and they have a totally different reason why the lights got turned
[1:01:21] off or why they can't stay on.
[1:01:23] So for me, I'm more like, as a counsel person, it's really hard to govern and to try
[1:01:32] to come up with a plan and steward and all of those things when every time that you think
[1:01:37] that you've like, oh, I think I have an answer for that.
[1:01:39] And they're like, no, no, that wasn't the issue to start with.
[1:01:41] So it gets a goal.
[1:01:42] Just know it's not simple, if it's not a simple quick answer, basically even when I said about
[1:01:47] getting a quote, getting a plan and so forth, usually you get an engineering firm involved just
[1:01:53] to get them to come up with the engineering plan so you can quote the darn thing, you're
[1:02:00] talking tens of thousands of dollars just to have that done before you even get a quote.
[1:02:05] Done.
[1:02:05] I can't go to Carl and say, Carl, you know, specify everything that needs to be done on
[1:02:11] this poor electrical system that you said that needs a lot of repair.
[1:02:14] I can't.
[1:02:15] I don't think Carl wants to do that.
[1:02:17] Probably you go to an engineering firm, I don't know, I'll just push back or something
[1:02:21] and say, hey, I need a study done on the electrical grid here, what needs to be done, and then come up and then go out and get proposals.
[1:02:31] That alone, just like coming up with design for a water plant, just to get a design and a quote, how much?
[1:02:42] a lot. Yeah. A lot much. Basically. It's like 6% of a
[1:02:47] of a 6% of 100 million. So you got 6 million dollars there.
[1:02:52] Yeah, so you're so just that's for a quote you don't have a you don't have a
[1:02:57] anything on infrastructure done. That's the same thing on your electrical.
[1:03:01] It's not easy. It's not a quick fix and it's all about money.
[1:03:06] But wouldn't you appreciate transparency and when when it came up the first time not being like,
[1:03:11] Oh, yep easy peasy and then having them just get turned off. I don't know what I don't know what was said to you
[1:03:19] No, you were there
[1:03:20] We talked about it here. I just met her leaving the lights on just matter of leaving the light up
[1:03:24] Yeah, but I didn't know there was electrical issues
[1:03:26] But at some point that turned off it could have come back and been like hey, this seemed like it was important
[1:03:31] You guys used to know it's not actually you know a feasible option for us
[1:03:36] I just, today it's the lights, but this could be literally any issue.
[1:03:40] And as soon as it becomes like a, like a, if you don't notice it and bring it up,
[1:03:45] then it's not going to be brought to you.
[1:03:47] Like that is a scary situation to be in.
[1:03:50] Today it's lights, not scary.
[1:03:52] Okay, fine, but it could be something else.
[1:03:54] It could have been bike lanes.
[1:03:56] It could have been, you know, whatever could have been something to do with public safety.
[1:03:58] And it's like, as a council, that was something that I remember leaving the meeting,
[1:04:03] being like, this is amazing. We all were in consensus. So it stood out to me because it
[1:04:09] felt like, oh, wow, this is one area that we all agree. So that's the reason why it's
[1:04:13] never going right now.
[1:04:15] We did agree. We did. So I just don't think we're all or naive that we thought that, well,
[1:04:19] the electrical grid was fine and could handle it. We didn't know.
[1:04:23] Yeah, but we know now.
[1:04:25] We know now.
[1:04:26] They're on the whole holiday season.
[1:04:27] Right.
[1:04:28] So it sounds like the problem is when the lights out in the market at the same time. Is that
[1:04:33] what the real problem is. I know there's a lot of issues because I think there were
[1:04:42] several issues and the castle park and there was something put in for market use there.
[1:04:53] As far as I know the market has been good for long for quite a while. I put a bunch of plugs
[1:04:57] in the control box underneath it. Over at the castle. Yeah because they put in something new because I
[1:05:02] I think they were having the same problems there, where the light poles would only support holiday lights and nothing else that you would need for the larger markets.
[1:05:13] So they did put an electrical solution in there, those poles that are locked.
[1:05:18] So I'm wondering, could we do something like that for the market portion and leave the holiday lights on the?
[1:05:27] No, there's no way to separate any of that.
[1:05:32] They won't be on for holidays.
[1:05:35] Yes, it will be on for holidays.
[1:05:38] They will be because the market will be over in October.
[1:05:44] So the idea, so it's market or lights during the summer.
[1:05:50] Is it that easy?
[1:05:52] No.
[1:05:53] Okay, can you explain then?
[1:05:55] So it's an anchor expectation.
[1:05:56] Half the lights will be on.
[1:05:57] If you want half the lights on and half the lights off at night,
[1:06:00] probably not.
[1:06:01] You probably want them all on or all off, right?
[1:06:03] Well, I'm ideally all on.
[1:06:07] I'll take half on.
[1:06:09] You'd have to leave Christmas lights on all nights
[1:06:12] that I haven't gone off at 11 o'clock.
[1:06:15] You have to be on till.
[1:06:16] Well, that's not a problem.
[1:06:17] I thought there was a plan.
[1:06:20] That's the problem.
[1:06:23] That's the problem.
[1:06:24] with the wire. Is that they are on all the time?
[1:06:28] If the lights are on, the pole lights are on.
[1:06:32] Those are shorted out wires touching each other on the ground.
[1:06:39] That doesn't sound... Maybe I'm missing them. You're saying that they're on? It's the lights are on.
[1:06:44] The pole light is on the holiday lights on. That's too long.
[1:06:49] Jeremiah might want to be part of this conversation because he's one that controls the lights up.
[1:06:54] He gets with me about issues and I'm telling you the issues that I know of.
[1:07:01] Yeah, I need to check to Jeremiah.
[1:07:03] Jeremiah.
[1:07:07] Fort Chase is in charge of the DPW.
[1:07:11] Yeah, I mean, I don't know.
[1:07:12] I guess I just would look to know what the actual like if they're the greater minds that know how to solve the problem.
[1:07:20] Here is a solution.
[1:07:21] People are using the plugs at night.
[1:07:24] GFI's go bad.
[1:07:25] It just becomes a lot of expense.
[1:07:27] I mean, people are using the plugs at night, to me, Kevin, I could be wrong, but that
[1:07:32] feels like a patrol issue.
[1:07:33] Like, if you see somebody that's watching TV, it's plugged into a lamp post.
[1:07:37] It's your phone's.
[1:07:39] There's no TV's.
[1:07:39] It's your phone's.
[1:07:40] Okay, but that minimal draw, then.
[1:07:43] I mean, that's...
[1:07:43] It happens all over the country.
[1:07:45] Yeah.
[1:07:46] I've done it.
[1:07:48] Yeah, I mean...
[1:07:50] I don't see how that's...
[1:07:52] I don't know.
[1:07:54] Okay.
[1:07:57] I guess that's...
[1:08:01] How is this solution?
[1:08:02] I just wanted to, I would like more transparency moving forward even when I'm not on council into the new one
[1:08:08] It would be nice if the platitudes that are given as
[1:08:12] Sal for an issue are actually real and stick and if they're not real that it's brought back to the state a
[1:08:19] Here's a new here's the new problem that we didn't see
[1:08:22] We were trying to work on pollution or do you guys want not to give?
[1:08:25] Do you know where you're going to move on?
[1:08:28] Well, I'd like to be something for the new council as well because it's going to be something
[1:08:32] to me that this entire 25-minute conversation or longer that we've had, unknown, clear
[1:08:41] and crystal about the situation that we have, but I do know this, that if we want to
[1:08:51] take a look at it and happy professional come up with exactly what has to be done to make
[1:08:59] it so everything works it works correctly and it's not a band-aid okay that takes a professional
[1:09:09] group to come in and do that and it's going to cost money it's going to have to be approved
[1:09:13] by the council to have that done and that's the first step that I have right now all I can
[1:09:20] and see is that we're just going to keep on bandating it until it happens.
[1:09:23] That's all I can, how life accessible is in here.
[1:09:28] Is that how you feel, Carl?
[1:09:30] Mm-hmm.
[1:09:32] So we'd have to take that as a, okay, this is what we want, as a line item in the budget
[1:09:40] to have a engineering study and quotation on a couple options, maybe a solar, maybe whatever,
[1:09:46] and then the council make a decision.
[1:09:48] And if we have the money to do it because we can come up with that doesn't mean we're gonna have the money to do it
[1:09:54] Right, of course, of course, and I'm not even saying that we would have made the decision at the time
[1:09:59] It's more just like knowing and not being
[1:10:03] You you love these questions that hold kick and stand out in the room. I feel like that was like this has been like a situation where
[1:10:10] It's like say what you would what will move the conversation along instead of sitting with the hard truth
[1:10:16] which maybe is that we can't have a charming downtown.
[1:10:20] With the light, we can't cultivate that environment
[1:10:23] without finding another solution.
[1:10:26] And maybe at that point, we would have explored more options.
[1:10:28] And it would have been like, let's invest our time and money here.
[1:10:32] Right.
[1:10:32] Yeah, instead of being frustrated and having residents get frustrated.
[1:10:35] I still think something that the next sponsor should look into
[1:10:39] at least we'd have a game come up with a game plan,
[1:10:43] which we don't have a game plan.
[1:10:45] Right.
[1:10:45] So we could we could we could start the
[1:10:51] powders and might like have finished before the election.
[1:10:55] Yeah.
[1:10:56] Yeah.
[1:11:00] Okay.
[1:11:03] Yeah.
[1:11:06] So a couple of announcements from the VDA Main Street.
[1:11:14] That's right here we would like you to do a take at the survey and share your ideas for the future.
[1:11:23] So going to the website EDA Mainstree, hit this.
[1:11:29] We'd like to have your ideas for your ideas for the future for the city downtown.
[1:11:36] down. So Lizzie, director, she's wanting all the ideas she can get in our board as well.
[1:11:47] And October 2nd and 3rd, we're going to do another fall cleanup. It's Friday, Saturday,
[1:11:53] 8 a.m., shift to 10 a.m., to 12 shift. Friday and Saturday, the 2nd and 3rd. We meet right
[1:11:59] down here in the city hall in the basement. So looking for all the volunteers who can clean
[1:12:06] up the city and do a little pickup of litter and leaves and all that kind of stuff and make
[1:12:14] the downtown as pretty as we can.
[1:12:18] Bram, this just caught my eye, but here's the camera quick.
[1:12:23] This council, and that banner right there's-
[1:12:30] That one's mine.
[1:12:31] Yes.
[1:12:31] there's better luck. This here was put here for actually council person also.
[1:12:39] Yeah, I was just wondering why we're not putting it up again because everybody loved it.
[1:12:43] It's the fall bunting we had up. I don't think last year but the year before.
[1:12:48] I don't know. Any reason?
[1:12:52] So we haven't trouble with any sort of wind would start tangling it up.
[1:12:57] T.P.W. spent a lot of time doing it. Lizzie had a discussion with Councilwoman Olson about why today.
[1:13:05] Exactly. I suggested we put links on it, but she said that it was not worth the effort.
[1:13:11] So I'm taking them back.
[1:13:13] Okay.
[1:13:14] Anybody need ginormous buntings for fall?
[1:13:16] Uh-huh.
[1:13:17] I know. I offered her to the high school and the middle school and the elementary school.
[1:13:20] So I think I'm going to work the school racket again and see if they want them.
[1:13:23] Because it was, you know, obviously, okay, a big volunteer effort.
[1:13:27] That's not a miscaraposition on the conversation, you know?
[1:13:32] No, I wasn't going to talk today.
[1:13:34] She said, we can't put it on City Hall, but if there's any other place in the downtown, she's all ears.
[1:13:40] Only if I'm willing to do 100% of the work.
[1:13:43] And it's okay. I mean, I understood the conversation. I was on the conversation.
[1:13:47] I was not. The message was they don't go back on City Hall.
[1:13:50] Okay, that's what they were built for.
[1:13:52] I saw them on the ground and I was questioning it because they received a lot of attention
[1:13:58] that in support.
[1:14:00] I don't know that I've seen anybody comment that much and anything as far as downtown
[1:14:07] looking before, so that's disappointing.
[1:14:10] Okay.
[1:14:11] Yep.
[1:14:12] For the comments, seeing none, the next meeting is Monday, October 5th, and with that
[1:14:22] the motion to close and the motion to close.
[1:14:24] Support.
[1:14:25] Thank you.
[1:14:26] Thank you very much.
[1:14:28] Thank you.
[1:14:29] All those in favor please say aye.
[1:14:30] Aye.
[1:14:31] All those are saying we are adjourned.