Planning Commission Work Session

Page County, VA · · More Page County, VA meetings · More Virginia meetings

Transcript

Download: Text · SRT ·
AI TRANSCRIPT

This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.

[1:17] It's 7 o'clock. I'd like to call the work session of the Page County Planning Commission to order. If you please rise for the pledge of allegiance.
[1:35] One nation under God.
[1:53] Just a reminder tonight that if you do choose to speak, make sure that your microphone is turned on as indicated by your green or red light. And then you speak loudly directly and clearly into it. Mr. Hunter, roll call, please. Chris Adams. Sandy Davis. We the Turner. Yeah, Ken Johnson. Kathy Greg. Yes. Here. All right. Moving forward.
[2:14] We need a motion to adopt agenda as amended by staff.
[2:18] They had asked that we had the EDA subcommittee or the housing subcommittee report on of that.
[2:24] And it would be relocated after the speedway underneath the unfinished business.
[2:34] The committee is there a second?
[2:35] I'll second it.
[2:36] Motion be made and properly seconded.
[2:38] Mr. Honourable, call please.
[2:40] Mr. Turner.
[2:47] All right, moving forward adoption and new business.
[2:50] Adoption of the minutes from August 11th.
[2:51] I'll give you a quick second to note any changes that need to be made.
[2:55] Any
[3:33] changes need to be made to the minutes.
[3:37] Here and none, then I'll need a motion to adopt them as presented.
[3:45] Make a motion to adopt the minutes, last minute.
[3:48] All right, motion to be made, is there a second?
[3:50] I'll second it.
[3:51] Motion to be made and property second.
[3:52] Did Mr. Honourable, please?
[3:54] Mr. Davis.
[3:55] Yes.
[3:56] Mr. Turner.
[3:57] Mr. Johnson.
[3:58] Mr. Greg.
[3:59] Yes.
[3:59] Mr. Adams.
[4:00] Chairman Werner.
[4:01] Yes.
[4:02] All right, move forward and unfinished business.
[4:08] Mr. Hon, I think you had some comment you wanted to make sure just briefly what's in your packet we have the latest version of the draft conditions that
[4:17] Mr. Gregg and Mr. Johnson and staff worked on in the last two weeks and I'll let Mr. Gregg go over that.
[4:22] The only thing I'll comment on on that is you'll see many different colors throughout the document that's just a reflection of different people working on it.
[4:30] So, all of the, if it's not black, it's something that's been changed over time.
[4:35] If you have any questions or that, just to ask.
[4:37] The other two things, as it did to the packet, we received an email that directly you received from a citizen earlier today.
[4:46] And then I have some staff notes that we will go over to once we get to the violations section.
[4:52] That's it.
[4:56] Mr. Gregg and Mr. Johnson, which one of you wants to go through?
[4:58] The changes you all made?
[5:00] I will if you don't mind. First of all, I have to say that we spent collectively many, many hours.
[5:08] I'm aware that the results are not going to please many people, but we really, really work very hard on that.
[5:14] So thank you, Mr. Johnson. Thank you, Josh. Cassie's not here, but we all worked on that.
[5:19] So I'm going to say, if there's congratulations, they go to all of this criticism, bring them to me.
[5:26] Although we did, it wasn't a collective effort, but we tried to gain consensus on that.
[5:32] So I just, before we go through the document, I wanted to tell you what my thought process
[5:37] was in trying to tackle this.
[5:39] This is, I've been on the planning commission for six, seven years now.
[5:42] This is by far the most difficult one.
[5:44] I guess second to the SUP for industrial solar, this is really not easy.
[5:50] And had we had the benefit of professional advice or guidance, either to a sound study
[5:55] or just some conversation, it would have made it much easier.
[5:59] So when I said at the last meeting, I think it's in the minutes that it felt to me like
[6:03] the blind leading, the blind, yeah, I'm as blind as you are, I just volunteered to try and
[6:07] do the best I could, so please bear with us, okay?
[6:11] So I thought, here's my process and my method.
[6:14] I was trying to keep as much of the old SUPs as possible, because I thought they were well
[6:19] thought out and reason, especially the 2007 permit, because they came in the wake of a
[6:24] sound study in recommendations by a professional. There was a lot of two and four, and I thought
[6:28] there was a lot of good stuff in there. So number two, after keeping as much as we could,
[6:34] I thought we needed to clarify some definitions, some language, some metrics where it was necessary
[6:40] to enable better enforcement, where possible. So we hear that, you know, enforcement for
[6:46] a variety of reasons was an optimal, some of it
[6:51] had to do with the way the rules were either not defined
[6:54] or not clearly, or the language needed modifications
[6:58] or maybe we needed new metrics.
[7:00] I do want to say something about enforcement.
[7:03] I know that I see a lot of complaints from the public
[7:05] about lack of enforcement.
[7:07] There is not something that the Planning Commission,
[7:10] other than writing rules, has a direct influence on.
[7:13] That's something which is a budgetary item and that is really a board decision.
[7:19] So we can write rules which we think that staff should be able to enforce given the right
[7:26] tools or the personnel but that's not a decision we can make at the level of the planning commission.
[7:31] So beyond clarifying what was there, then we needed to modify definitions, language or metrics
[7:38] and sometimes create some, when it was necessary to do so for either public health and safety,
[7:46] trying to take into account the comments of the public and also what Mr. Don requested,
[7:52] what the applicant requested. So that was the method. So I can give you an example of all these
[7:58] three things. For instance, in number one, we kept the number of events at 32. The definition of
[8:06] events that's directly from zoning ordinance 125 for the sound mitigation
[8:12] measures we kept in there the racing seasons equal to October for the oval
[8:17] track marched in November for the motocross or dirt track we kept as is Sunday
[8:22] racing we kept as is the rain days especially the maximum of 25% which which
[8:29] amounts to eight days out of 32 lighting standard which we have to talk about
[8:35] for the moment we haven't changed that. That is to show you how much we've kept the
[8:39] old SUP. Two, when I say we needed to clarify definitions, language and metrics, for instance,
[8:46] the language regarding events, practices, we had to put some new definitions in there, and then
[8:53] we had to add new things. For instance, a schedule of events, a new definition, for instance, we chose
[9:00] to define something which is called public use training and commercial training.
[9:06] I'll tell you a little bit more about that. Some sound metrics and language,
[9:10] violation and penalties. The sound free weekend is new and the overnight
[9:14] lodging is new. So that's just to tell you how we proceed it. Okay, we took what
[9:19] we could, we tweaked some and some of it so that you know we had a we had a method.
[9:26] So looking at the document that you have in front of you, it's the 821-2026.
[9:32] So, this Josh can probably tell you it's what, the 12th or 20th or 30th versions since
[9:39] last time you saw it because we had this idea and then we had that idea and we talked
[9:43] about it and I talked about it, Ken talked about it, went through Josh, we talked about
[9:47] it with Cassie and this and that and the other that went round and round.
[9:49] So, this was finished on Friday and then some new things came in today as well.
[9:57] So, I think what you're going to see here, as I said, racing season.
[10:03] We had a hard time deciding for a season for both tracks.
[10:10] As you can see, the oval track is April 4, October.
[10:12] That's seven months.
[10:14] Motocross March to November.
[10:16] That's nine months.
[10:16] So since we couldn't really agree on one,
[10:19] we decided to keep them separate.
[10:25] There is some comment.
[10:26] I think Josh thought the term motocross track might be better
[10:30] change to dirt track.
[10:31] If you look at the 2011 permit, it's written motocross track in bracket dirt track. So we'll have to see if we want to keep that
[10:40] name as it is
[10:41] so
[10:46] Yeah, the idea of being there that there's other things that happen at the motocross
[10:51] There's other events and just what it's conventionally known as motocross and I would probably defer to the applicant to discuss that further if we
[10:59] Rechange the name of that so we kept it as that but we'd be open to calling it the dirt track or whatever you want
[11:05] It's an oval track. My point is maybe it could be the rectangular track or something like that, but whatever
[11:13] So we when we came to look at the definition of
[11:19] practice practices
[11:20] This was a big big big discussion. Not everybody had the same idea of what a practice was
[11:26] Can we back up to the race and season and talk about the two different time frames?
[11:32] Okay
[11:33] If
[11:37] you're going to be running the Dirt Track Motor Track March through November, why wouldn't
[11:42] you run the Overtrag the same time frame?
[11:44] If they're already running for one, why don't you let them run for the other?
[11:48] Because it's just adding more noise and more opportunity for events and I did not think
[11:54] that with respect of not having professional advice we could take it upon ourselves to lengthen
[12:03] the oval track season since it's the noesiest.
[12:05] But wouldn't the same noise be generated
[12:07] from the mic motor cross?
[12:09] We don't know that.
[12:12] Now, if you, I don't mind having this discussion now,
[12:16] but you'll see where it further on in the documents
[12:19] it has a bearing.
[12:20] So if you want to discuss to defer the converse, I would
[12:23] That's fine.
[12:24] We can defer it to when we actually are using it in the document.
[12:28] But basically the reason it's like that
[12:30] is we couldn't agree on which one, the shorter one
[12:33] or the longer one.
[12:39] Since we had a lot of discussion around what practice consists of, it seems to me it would
[12:45] seem to us that many times the neighbors were complaining about it and always because
[12:50] an event took place and we were told no, it's not an event, it was a practice.
[12:54] So we thought it was important to define practice and then we went through numerous situations
[13:00] of the definition of practice and how to make sure that a practice did not become an event.
[13:05] So we looked at many metrics, and I think Ken will tell you about that, but in that process we realized that we need that we had two definitions missing.
[13:17] So one of them was on the bottom of page one, public service training.
[13:21] And you can read this as how we defined it, any activity in which fire and rescue personnel emergency responders, school bus drivers, and other public safety or public service personnel use a facility track.
[13:34] Equipment to develop or improve driving skills, vehicle handling, technique, safety procedures
[13:39] or operational auditions and furtherance of their official duties.
[13:43] So we decided to separate that from practice.
[13:48] Another area which we chose to separate is what we chose to call commercial training.
[13:54] Any activity in which participants use the facilities tracks to develop or improve driving
[13:59] skills often to the public or to facility patients for a fee as part of a commercial or
[14:04] recreational program and not involving competitive vehicle activity among participants, including
[14:11] but not limited to high performance driving clinics or schools or similar programs.
[14:15] The reason we added that is we seem to recollect the applicant saying that this was a new avenue
[14:22] of business for him and we should honor that but then consider it differently than the public
[14:28] use training for the practice. So that meant that if you look on page two, H, that left
[14:37] practice tuning and testing, we used the same terminology as before, would be the use
[14:42] of the track by any vehicles other than during a motorsport event, public service training
[14:46] or commercial training, meaning it's everything else.
[14:57] just wanted to put those streets together and
[15:00] We have left blank the days and hours of use for the commercial training because we thought we should talk to the applicant about that. So, you know, at this point, it might be a good idea. So before we do that, I want to ask one question, Mr. Hahn. So the definitions you have included for public service training and the ones you have included for commercial training. Is that consistent and compliant with the current ordinance that's written when it can't be used in those type of events as a accessory? I don't think it would be inconsistent.
[15:31] but we would probably be well advised to
[15:34] and
[15:36] come in current supplemental regs for that.
[15:39] But I'll confess we did not look at the supplemental regs
[15:43] when we were doing this, it's correct.
[15:45] Yeah, because I mean, I'm not concerned in the past
[15:47] if it's been in the ordinance, that's what we followed.
[15:50] For that, when we really never rewrote the ordinance,
[15:52] when we got to the conditions.
[15:54] I just as long as this component consists of what's in there
[15:56] and it's not taken away or adding to what that's allowed to do
[16:00] than any existing definitions we tried to,
[16:02] But
[16:16] I do think, I mean, I can't do it right now,
[16:20] but
[16:36] I'm just wondering if other than it was,
[16:39] and that's great.
[16:47] Is this a good time to ask the applicant what he,
[16:50] I know he spoke about, you know, clubs and people wanting
[16:53] to come and train on the tracks at a past meeting.
[16:56] I confess that I don't remember everything he said,
[16:59] but I thought he said that was a new avenue of business,
[17:02] and we thought it should be regulated separately
[17:04] than the public service training
[17:07] or the practice for the races,
[17:09] because it's a different.
[17:12] Mr. Obama, is there either one of you want to address that?
[17:26] What is your specific question in the clarification?
[17:31] Does our definition of commercial training correspond
[17:35] to what you have talked about when you came to the podium
[17:39] in one of our previous meetings, saying that there
[17:41] was an avenue of business that you wanted to tap into?
[17:45] I think you mentioned clubs from major cities
[17:49] is aware that they are, they want to drive their sports car in the track.
[17:53] Correct.
[17:53] Yeah.
[17:54] There's requests from various car clubs and individuals that just want to come and do
[18:06] practice and testing on the track, and it's not a confined schedule, and we may get a
[18:17] call today and car clubs got an idea they like to come on the Saturday and if the Saturday
[18:26] is available they can come up and practice.
[18:30] That consists of they may come in and set up cones and set up a rental course inside the
[18:38] track and that's one form of practice for those folks.
[18:44] We get other entities that want to use the facility just to do training for their drivers
[18:56] as far as proper parking and normally when that happens it's done up in the parking lot.
[19:06] They'll set cones up and go through and have a course there and train their drivers.
[19:13] you know how to handle the vehicles and when that happens that's usually some of the
[19:21] local fire and rescue units that ask for that to be done and so practice gets into a
[19:31] lot of a lot of various things you know I have some people call me and these are individuals
[19:38] And they'll say, a daughter's working on how to drive,
[19:44] and we like to use your facility to do that when they're available.
[19:50] So we'll get that type of request.
[19:53] And those requests are really unlimited, you know,
[19:58] than what calls we do receive and get.
[20:03] I don't know if that helps you clarify.
[20:05] Can I clarify just a little bit?
[20:07] No, no, go ahead.
[20:08] So really what this draft Mr. Vaughn is doing
[20:10] is it's kind of taking what we've previously combined all and splitting it out
[20:16] in three different categories. It's the public service training. So that's your
[20:23] Fire EMS school bus and as I recall where we landed on that was that would be
[20:27] basically held. It's unlimited except it's it's held to facility hours so
[20:33] whenever the facility hours are they can be there yeah they can't be sirens on
[20:37] unless there's an actual emergency yeah so that's that's basically to keep that
[20:42] limited and then there's this commercial training which would be more tied to
[20:48] what we understood, you to say earlier several weeks ago,
[20:53] tied to schools, clubs, things like that, it's not a race, there's no race
[20:57] going on. They can use the track, I don't know, we made me to specify that they
[21:02] could use the parking a lot too if they're doing any kind of training with
[21:07] parking because right now we're kind of reserving to the whole track and the
[21:12] practice tuning and testing, and that's everything else, but really what that's
[21:16] tied to is practicing, it's the same cars that are doing the old track race or dirt track
[21:21] race. So it's practice tuning and testing for those events. And what's different about
[21:26] practice tuning and testing is, if this is, you know, approved as is, it would be limited
[21:32] to a certain number of practice tuning testing per year. So, so public service would be unlimited,
[21:38] that commercial training would have more limited hours,
[21:40] which we'd discuss, but number of commercial training
[21:44] would be unlimited.
[21:46] And then practicing testing would be limited to,
[21:49] I think, where we rested there was, basically, 32 practices.
[21:53] That's further on in the training, yeah.
[21:56] So that's conceptually what it is.
[21:58] And so I think what Ms. Greck is kind of asking you
[22:00] is, how did the definitions sound to you?
[22:04] I don't know, problem with the definition.
[22:07] Thank you.
[22:07] The only thing I'd say about commercial training and you kind of hit on it there a little
[22:12] bit, Josh, where we were mentioning facilities, tracks, I mean, technically the facility would
[22:16] include the parking lots.
[22:17] If you took the work tracks out, the facility would be covered, the parking lot would then
[22:21] be covered.
[22:23] I agree.
[22:27] Isn't that parking lot?
[22:28] Yeah.
[22:31] I would just add that much of my motivation to adding commercial training is in my research
[22:35] I found that that is an evolving and growing demand for this kind of facility.
[22:41] People are really enjoying it.
[22:42] So I wanted to make sure it was covered as an approved view so it wasn't laid out directly as an approved use in the past
[22:48] I'd wanted it to be clear that it is.
[22:52] So that was an example of adding something new that didn't exist before and also at the same time clarifying what a practice really was.
[23:02] So we are confined practicing to people practicing for an event.
[23:09] Is there any questions about any of that that we can clarify?
[23:12] Why? None of this was easy. We went through multiple versions and multiple ideas, a lot
[23:17] of research.
[23:22] Now, it was our, it is our understanding that those activities are going to be less
[23:27] noisy than the events and races themselves.
[23:31] I'll say something about that.
[23:32] Because
[23:58] it's not, at least it's not in the definition.
[24:01] I think it was in previous definitions.
[24:03] Yeah, I don't think we have anything here. I'll read it to you again. Just keep that in mind.
[24:07] Any activity in which fire and rescue personnel emergency responded school bus driver or other public safety or public service personnel use use the facility.
[24:19] Sorry, use the facility track.
[24:22] We're going to take the word track out of here as well.
[24:24] Use the facility equipment.
[24:28] The facilities equipment to develop or improve driving skills vehicle handling technique safety procedures or operational knowledge in
[24:37] furtherance of their official duties.
[24:45] But I don't think we have the no blowing science is what I'm going to show you.
[24:48] You do when you go down to number two, if you read that and then underneath noise regulations.
[25:02] So we can put a we should put an exception there under number two.
[25:08] Yeah I mean I don't I don't we were going to address that in a bit but yeah
[25:11] sure we can put an exception for that. I mean I don't see where you need to
[25:14] include public service training and commercial training underneath that
[25:17] anyway. Well it was just to have some kind of metric to measure it but you're
[25:25] saying not to include public service training. Yeah or commercial training I
[25:28] wouldn't include either one of those under I'm declared five or four. Yeah.
[25:34] Can we
[25:35] just get to that when we get to it. Page
[25:48] two practice and training, we, I don't think
[25:52] we've changed anything else.
[25:56] The Motorsports event day, there was a question about scheduled
[25:59] being there, but that's in the definition, I want 20.
[26:04] Josh, did we have a comment on that,
[26:06] but maybe, I don't think I see it anymore, but maybe that needed to be changed in the
[26:12] ordinance, where is that? Oh no, it's under e on page 1, sorry. Yeah, so I just
[26:19] want to draw your attention to something on page 1 still. Modus sports event,
[26:24] any regularly scheduled, we don't like that term regularly, that Cassie
[26:28] reminded us that that's what's in the ordinance, so that's a conflict such as
[26:32] you referred to that we'll have to discuss, because if you say it's regularly
[26:36] scheduled, what if it's not regularly scheduled, that it happens to be scheduled
[26:41] but not regularly.
[26:45] So, regularly schedule would imply it happens every week, it happens
[26:49] every month, or every January, or something. So, it does say and or advertise gathering.
[26:56] So, doesn't that kind of cover? Is there going to advertise anything, right? Yeah. So, we were
[27:01] thinking of taking the word regularly out of there when Cassie said, wait a minute, that's
[27:05] what's written in those only wordments. So, we may have to reconsider. In view of this,
[27:11] We may have to consider some of the verbiage of those only ordinances if that's appropriate.
[27:21] Sorry for the two info.
[27:24] Anything
[27:32] else under definitions that's new?
[27:34] Josh, I don't think so.
[27:59] So maybe that definition would be better in the rain day section because
[28:10] there's no conflict.
[28:11] Okay, noise regulation.
[28:13] So here,
[28:17] A1, the only change that we were proposing is to reduce the number of 88 to number of 82.
[28:24] to. We weren't quite sure how, I think that was the number proposed by Michael. We're
[28:30] quite sure how we arrived at that. And I personally think it's excessive and was suggesting
[28:38] reducing it to AD2 when it seemed like my colleagues agreed. But there's a couple of comments
[28:43] on the right hand. Josh, do you want to tackle that?
[28:47] Sure, there's a general comment just some
[29:53] of us still think that the DNL is actually the
[30:00] In our solution is the one that is fairer to everybody. It also appears to be complicated and expensive. But I do think that the board needs to be aware that it wasn't the 2007 SUP. And in taking it out, we need to be aware that we're taking something out. Yes,
[30:24] no, but I want to make sure we have this conversation, and I want it to be stated. It is the most fair. Now,
[30:30] Now, so we could consider language in here, which goes a little bit further to refer to
[30:37] the work that Mr., that my colleague, Mr. Johnson did on the DNL, we all liked it at
[30:42] the time.
[30:42] We thought it was, you know, it was great.
[30:46] And, you know, we could either cite the language, by the way, when you say Josh, it's uncertain
[30:54] certain how the 2007-2007 condition 7 is 7A, the talks about D&L.
[31:03] So there is language that we could put back in there, Mr. Johnson had proposed, you know,
[31:10] an annual noise budget text, which is what's five lines long, we could put it in here, which
[31:18] is an alternative, which is actually the best solution.
[31:22] And it's not that we want to insist on it being in here, but we want the board to see that
[31:28] That's an option. The other option is to go with what we have under one, A1, with the
[31:34] noise limits that were in the document that was given to us by the county attorney with
[31:41] a modification at 82 instead of 88. And then add it for that under number two. Why don't
[31:48] you explain how you came to that? And I think we were trying here to find how to regulate
[31:54] practices in a fair way. Do we regulate the number of cars? Do we regulate the
[32:01] day of the week? How do we not allow them to be turned into events under the
[32:06] label of a practice? And so Mr. Johnson kindly did a deep dive on that and
[32:11] maybe you want to explain to us how you arrived to this foundation
[32:18] if we look at
[32:26] that schedule. You're
[38:04] going to manage the difference in the sound levels when the
[38:07] practice in the murder sport event races that same day.
[38:14] That's not an issue because if it's a day it does
[38:20] the difference what we try to say
[38:23] is if you go over
[38:27] counts as a race day, if there's already a race day there.
[38:32] Right but you're triggering it as a violation.
[38:35] I mean I don't, the whole thing is they keep getting, have violations counted against them
[38:39] well if they choose to exceed the 71 on a race day because you consider them, consider
[38:45] to murder a sport day, technically they were in violation of the 71.
[38:48] Well, actually what it says here is a violation of this sub-barregraph shall cause that date to be counted as a more dispensed
[38:54] Meaning
[38:57] we're specifying what this particular we could change the term violation if you want. Yeah
[39:03] I don't I don't think violations the right word. I just say if you're going to say that if it exceeds that
[39:08] Expression
[39:09] No, if it just exceeds that it's considered a murder sports event. Yes. Okay. So use another language. Okay.
[39:28] So I have the
[39:30] Border of the property yield 71 decibels
[39:50] So we get back to the same problem, so then they're using practice days as an event day.
[39:58] Do you see what I'm saying?
[39:59] Then if the practice is as noisy as events, then they become event days.
[40:03] And then they're going to be in a relationship and say that.
[40:07] Well, how do we go about it? That's what we're trying to explain to you.
[40:10] How would you go about it?
[40:12] We've spent many hours trying to go around it to find a solution and the only solution.
[40:16] actually my reasoning was based on a comment that Mr. Vaughn made when he said
[40:21] that for instance the commercial training what we call now commercial training
[40:25] was gonna be less noisy than the practices because they're not racing so we
[40:30] said okay then the metric is better we're just saying that if it isn't gonna be
[40:34] noisy and it's on the same day it's not gonna they're not gonna be penalized
[40:37] because it's an event day anyhow right but if it is a practice let's say on a
[40:42] Thursday, and it says noisy as an event, then it can.
[40:48] John, can you pull up the ordinance?
[40:50] It has that, I want to look at that ADD-Dustful criteria.
[40:54] It
[41:31] says at the very end, D4, unless, if you go to the end,
[41:38] D, the
[41:42] mention of the ACE, it's about as long D4,
[41:48] unless they're specifically addressed in the use permit,
[41:50] which they are no recurrent to exceed ADD-DB.
[41:54] Always
[41:59] levels specifically address in a special use permit will take precedent over the maximum ADV.
[42:07] So basically you want to penalize them for practice is what you're doing.
[42:11] Yeah that's exactly what you're doing.
[42:16] They're only penalized for practice if the practice, if the level of noise of the practice is equal to an event.
[42:24] If
[42:30] you disagree with the number of 71, I'm sure we're not attached to it.
[42:33] What we're saying is if your practice becomes as noisy as an event, or beyond a certain
[42:40] threshold, then it becomes an event, that's all we're saying.
[42:44] Now you can disagree with the metric of 71.
[42:48] I don't have a problem that we discussed that, but we're saying that we were trying to prevent
[42:55] a practice becoming an event in terms of noise because that seems to be where the
[43:04] conversation was for a recent violation or for a recent alleged violation.
[43:09] Other ways of practice.
[43:10] The
[43:24] point is we're trying to limit noisy practices where they're racing.
[43:28] Remember the county attorney said at some point in here, I think we still have it somewhere
[43:34] that it is, they're not supposed to practice in a way that mimics racing, right?
[43:42] In that reference, he's just talking about the competitive nature of multiple cars racing against one another.
[43:49] I think we're muddy in the waters by trying to incorporate noise into the definition of motor sports events.
[43:56] But isn't that the whole issue? Isn't that where the problem lies? Isn't that the
[44:01] heart of the issue? Isn't the heart of the issue of the complaints of the neighbors?
[44:07] And the rights of the property owner? Isn't it all about the noise?
[44:11] So, all right. Who's going to enforce that 70 more?
[44:19] If there is a DNL standard adopted, then it takes that into account as well.
[44:23] But that's an a-weighted decibel.
[44:26] They're all a-weighted decibels, every metric we have in here is an a-weighted decibel.
[44:32] If we adopt the DNL standard then it just all falls under the DNL standard and this falls
[44:39] by the wayside.
[44:41] Yeah, that I agree with you.
[44:43] So it's either we have the DNL metric which we all agree is the best or we have the AD
[44:50] for motorsports event and a reduced sound level for practices in order not to
[44:57] the disguised practices, not to dissapear.
[45:04] I mean, I still come back to the enforcement issue. Is staff going to be setting out there when
[45:10] practices have been in versus any event? I mean, on the days. So I'm so glad you touched on that, because that's the subject
[45:19] to my heart. It seems like we're constantly going around in circles saying we can't put
[45:27] things in there that can't be enforced, and they can't be enforced if they're not in here,
[45:31] right? And it goes round and round and round. It's gone like that's a 20-30 years. So we know
[45:35] that if enforcement only happens about, you know, uncomplaint, you know, upon complaint,
[45:42] then staff needs to be equipped with the tools of enforcement, whether that's more people
[45:46] or more equipment. More equipment would be DNL, more people, but that's not a decision
[45:52] that we can make at this level. We don't decide on budgets to hire staff or to give staff
[45:57] more equipment. So I guess here's my point. If we don't put rules in, it's a little bit
[46:03] like saying, oh well, we're not going to put a speed limit on 81 because we can't have,
[46:09] you know, officers out there monitoring the speed limit 24 Sabbath, right? So we still need
[46:15] have rules in here. And this is why I was saying we really tried very hard to put rules
[46:20] that were fair. We're not saying it was easy. We're not saying we're right. We're trying.
[46:24] What my point is is the non-dustible difference for a few select hours of a week really worth
[46:32] all the extra headaches that it's going to cause both staff and the applicant.
[46:38] Part of the answer to that is how many hours a week now we're back to managing it by hours.
[46:44] the impact on the community we're now managing it by hours.
[46:48] As it's currently drafted, there's, I don't remember 10 or 12 hours a day where under your
[46:55] theory, 80 decibels would be authorized.
[46:59] So people would be subject to that race-weight level noise six other days a week or five
[47:06] other days a week.
[47:09] So it's just a question of how do we manage something, trying to look ahead 30 years.
[47:17] Who knows what it's going to be like in 30 years?
[47:19] Who knows what the demand for that track is going to be?
[47:23] So what we're endeavoring to do is to get away from managing it by hours.
[47:29] Because hours is too restrictive according to what Mr. Vaughn says.
[47:33] If we limit them just to two hours, then a day or whatever it is, then he said he doesn't
[47:39] have the flexibility to deal with people that just call them up, they just want to do this.
[47:44] So that's the real crux of it.
[47:47] Do we want to expose neighbors to race-weight-level noise the other five days of the week, ten
[47:52] hours a day, which is what we would do if we authorize an 80-deserville level for training,
[47:58] or do we want to manage noise at a lower level for non-raceway events. That's
[48:05] what it boils down to, I think. What that number should be? Should it not be 71? I've
[48:09] already been very plain. I don't know. And I won't know until we get some advice.
[48:16] If I meet Chairman, I'm good.
[48:53] I'll six, seven times a day. What's the alternative?
[49:04] You leave
[49:04] If we leave it all at 80, we tried that.
[49:06] OK, I want you to know that we spent.
[49:09] If we haven't spent a total of at least the total of one
[49:13] employee 40 hours a week, we've spent zero.
[49:16] We have witnesses.
[49:17] We've spent many hours going around in circle
[49:19] with all these solutions.
[49:21] And we did not find this was the most
[49:24] fear in our opinion.
[49:26] Because if not, you're back to the neighbors calling
[49:30] all the time.
[49:31] You know what?
[49:32] It was over the noise limit.
[49:33] it was loud, it was a Monday Tuesday Friday. Now I'll add something that I seem to remember
[49:38] from previous conversation and I believe this I could be wrong, but I believe the applicant
[49:43] told us that most practices, or it might have been somebody else, most practices take place
[49:48] the day before the race, right? If the race is on a Friday, it takes place on a Thursday,
[49:53] if it's on a Saturday, it takes place on the Friday, which is why we limited if you look a little bit
[49:57] further down to practice two days a week. Not the trainings, not the public use trainings,
[50:03] or the commercial training, just the practices.
[50:06] We leave them the hours they want.
[50:07] We say, no more than so many hours,
[50:09] but you can choose the hours.
[50:10] Limited to two days away,
[50:12] we put this in here for your consideration
[50:14] because we thought it was a good idea.
[50:16] Is it possible that right now we're doing some guesswork
[50:19] that the applicant might be able to answer
[50:21] as in what a feasible practice,
[50:26] how long in a day, what time of day usually happens in,
[50:30] and there could be conditions
[50:31] that he would be amenable to that would be limited to a certain number of days per week and year and still be at 80 decibels.
[50:40] Yeah, I mean the only thing I have going to comment is though when we read the sound study, a sound study was based on one car going around the track and they had points where it was hit in 80.
[50:52] And I understand your logic and makes perfect sense.
[50:56] But if the sound study is saying one track going around the track is 80 decibels at the
[51:01] proper line or at the points where it's measured, and we cut it down to 71, are we making
[51:06] an unrealistic constraint?
[51:08] Maybe so.
[51:09] Maybe so.
[51:10] But then how else are you going to prevent a pr- how are you- else are you going to prevent
[51:14] an event being disguised, I'm sorry if the word sounds a little unappealing, but dressed
[51:20] up as a practice.
[51:21] You know what I'm saying?
[51:21] It's a practice.
[51:22] It's labeled as a practice, but it's as noisy as an event.
[51:24] and then it should count, isn't it?
[51:35] Shall we leave it for now?
[51:36] That's fine.
[51:37] And move on for the sake of conversation.
[51:40] So to clarify, how are we leaving it?
[51:42] I heard two things just now.
[51:45] Now, if you look at the path top of day three,
[51:48] nonwithstanding paragraph A, the facility may.
[51:52] They may go and hire a sound acquisition
[51:54] and say, wait a minute, there's an alternative, right?
[51:59] We allow for that here.
[52:03] hate to blame for this but I'm on the one who has put a draft out and I want to make sure it's the right draft
[52:09] Is in my hearing that if we're keeping an 80 there is no purpose for two anymore because it's all 80
[52:16] Am I eliminating 80 in this draft or two in this drafts?
[52:20] Do we need I mean just tell me what to do. Let's hold this
[52:24] Okay, so the conversation because I think certain things need to be looked at in perspective
[52:28] Has
[52:31] anybody else have anything on page two or can we move on?
[52:33] We
[52:41] haven't added anything to mufflers. That was not our language, and that was there before. That was the county attorney.
[52:47] We did not add that.
[52:50] That was there. We didn't touch that. The monitoring and measuring plan is something we agreed that.
[52:56] We agreed on that at the last meeting.
[53:01] can't document 814, it was instead of the method of measurements proposed by the county
[53:05] attorney saying it's better left for the recommendations of professionals.
[53:09] We haven't changed that either.
[53:15] The next thing we've changed is I believe on page 5, am I mistaken?
[53:23] The rest is nothing we've seen all this before.
[53:28] We think that number four might be redundant with the new language of 4C5, so we took it
[53:34] out.
[53:34] In
[53:39] G, we're saying that if a professional is hired and he happens to identify any additional sound mitigations,
[53:48] they should also be implemented and maintain.
[53:52] Should that happen? We're not saying that it should, but if it does.
[53:56] So then we get to maximum event days.
[53:58] The
[54:02] only thing we changed here under A was we changed calendar year to 2 combined racing seasons,
[54:07] because we couldn't decide which one to use.
[54:09] so
[54:19] many days and they're different racing seasons.
[54:25] We added B, a weekly cap, two
[54:30] motorsports event date per calendar week. It's never been any different to my
[54:37] knowledge I've never seen more than two so we put it in there. We put in the
[54:41] noise free weekend but
[54:45] I think we had that before, right?
[54:58] Sorry I'm just reviewing
[54:59] the changes that we made. No, not because they're before. I mean I'm still kind of
[55:03] on a weekly cap of two more sport events per calendar week and then your
[55:07] requirement in the waste free weekend. Why, why don't you just allow them to have
[55:11] three?
[55:13] Because they never have more than two. They have Friday and Saturday.
[55:18] Friday Saturday Sunday chart.
[55:20] Well, shall we look at the Sundays when we get to it because we have that there as
[55:25] well.
[55:46] Somebody questioned under weather allowance days D and E. There was a measure
[55:52] of 30% I think that came from the county attorney and we was wondering how that 30% would
[55:58] be determined is that 30% of the number of events, 30% in hours, we weren't quite sure
[56:04] how that would work. But since it wasn't our language, we just thought that staff would
[56:11] have to interpret that. We did talk about that but weren't quite sure how to address it.
[56:15] If you want a picture of how we would interpret it as is, if there is a rain delay, we'd probably
[56:21] ask the operator to give us a schedule of what the events were and how far they got to that schedule.
[56:28] We wouldn't be requiring the applicant to give us that schedule in advance.
[56:33] I don't think that's reasonable. So after the event has already been rain delayed, they would give us the scheduled events.
[56:40] But the schedule events is publicly posted.
[56:43] It's always on Facebook or something.
[56:44] Well, that's the schedule of event.
[56:45] I'm talking about the, the, the, the, this, this,
[56:48] What actually happened during each individual event.
[56:50] That's how we make a determination
[56:51] of whether they had a sufficient enough day yet.
[56:54] But I'm saying, if the schedule for next weekend
[56:56] is published on Facebook, then they could,
[56:58] we know as some how many did you complete.
[57:00] Well, we only completed two of the, of the six races.
[57:03] Well, that's 33%.
[57:05] I wonder why 30% why 30.
[57:08] I don't know why.
[57:09] But that wasn't us, so we didn't go there.
[57:15] What we did add is on page six, there
[57:19] shall be a maximum of,
[57:34] that was in our language as well,
[57:35] the 30%.
[57:38] We took the maximum of eight weather allow us days
[57:41] and unfinished events, cabined for both reasons and combined.
[57:44] We took that from the two permits, because that's
[57:46] what it says now.
[57:54] We don't change anything else.
[58:09] Number six, we added the public service training
[58:13] during facility hours of operation, meaning as long as the facility is open they can come
[58:17] and train. Practice, tuning and testing and commercial training, we thought the practice
[58:25] and tuning shall be limited to two calendar days per week. Now, I don't know if we want
[58:32] to lump the commercial training in here, or if we want to have a different days for commercial
[58:42] training. I'm not sure we should have put commercial training in there.
[58:45] Any one time you can have?
[58:46] Yeah, so we might have made a mistake there. I don't think that would work.
[58:49] I would put commercial training in the public service training.
[58:52] We
[58:56] want to have special hours for that.
[58:59] They're the same. They're the same, accomplishing the exact same thing. Just two different entities
[59:04] are doing them.
[59:05] My disagree. One of them is public service. The other day it's people that are facing the
[59:09] paying the facilities to rise.
[59:14] You disagree with that. Why? We're trying to control and
[59:20] accessory use. What is the difference between public service training and commercial training
[59:28] if you take out the difference in the type of people that are using them? Well, one of it
[59:33] public service? No, take that out. Take public service. I take commercial out and look at the thing
[59:38] individually. Is it the exact same type of thing going on just two different groups of people
[59:44] using it? That's that's not the thing that I used. A commercial training in my mind would be people
[59:50] that want to learn how to be a race car driver or to wait till the fruit. Professional reasons or it's
[59:57] just fun. They want to sign up for a class.
[1:00:00] Let's come out and take this training that is available on a commercial basis. So that is probably going to be using vehicles with a much higher noise output than people practicing with an ambulance. So that was the thinking behind that. Like somebody like you have the, I don't know, the Ferrari club of Alexandria, whatever they come with 10 Ferraris and they want to, you know, go around and around the race. We felt that's that's more noisy than just a couple of, you know,
[1:00:28] share-ish deputies or whoever coming for public service. We thought it deserved different standards.
[1:01:15] So that's allowed under facility hours. Monday through Saturday, 7 to 11 Sunday, 11 to 10.
[1:01:33] So I think that now that we dig into it, you can see that it's not easy.
[1:01:38] I appreciate that you don't like what we've done or some of what we've done,
[1:01:42] but none of it was done lightly.
[1:01:48] It seems to me just so we keep moving.
[1:01:52] Number six, go ahead.
[1:01:56] If I may ask, based on the progress has
[1:02:03] been generating the last hour and the last months,
[1:02:08] I'd like to publicly pull the permit from any amendments
[1:02:12] and we'll operate as is.
[1:02:14] Thank y'all for your time and the money you spent as far as it with attorney fees.
[1:02:22] Moving forward, the EDA housing subcommittee.
[1:02:29] We met yesterday and
[1:02:45] we're so the committee.
[1:02:48] Some brains are only occurred, but it was basically meeting each other
[1:02:52] and going over what we felt like were the challenges of affordable housing in the county.
[1:02:59] And I'm
[1:03:02] going to start to meet and discuss it, looking at all the different grants maybe
[1:03:08] that we could come up with, just a basic strategic planning sort of put out there.
[1:03:18] The only thing I'd add is that the public hearing for the short-term rentals, which will
[1:03:24] be at the Larry High School, that'll be the same night that the housing study is actually
[1:03:29] presented by the contractor to the board.
[1:03:31] You
[1:03:40] now need a motion to adjourn.
[1:03:45] I move we adjourn.
[1:03:46] All right.
[1:03:47] Motion to the mains are a second.
[1:03:48] A second.
[1:03:49] All right.
[1:03:50] Motion to the mains are a second.
[1:03:50] Everybody go home.