Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
[10:33]
meeting to order. Sorry I'm a little bit
[10:35]
late. Uh
[10:38]
meetings galore, I'm telling you. Uh
[10:41]
welcome to the uh [snorts]
[10:46]
board meeting uh September the 8th. Uh,
[10:50]
welcome all elected officials and
[10:52]
invited guests. And I'm trying to see if
[10:55]
there's any elected officials. Y'all
[10:57]
help me see any.
[11:00]
I don't. Invited guest. Uh, J. Uh, Evans
[11:05]
Hart is not here. Uh, on your phones and
[11:09]
electronic advice uh devices, if you
[11:11]
would put them on silent uh so it won't
[11:14]
interrupt the meeting. And then uh I'll
[11:17]
have the marshall bring me my sheet up.
[11:23]
Thank you, buddy.
[11:29]
Mr. Jason Kathy, how are you, buddy?
[11:33]
You know, I I appreciate all the
[11:35]
encouragement that you send uh to us,
[11:37]
especially me and all the things that
[11:40]
are going on with the Fellowship of
[11:41]
Christian Athletes and uh all the
[11:44]
success. Maybe you can tell us about
[11:46]
that. So, we'll take a little bit stand
[11:49]
up to the podium and uh I'm just going
[11:51]
to tell you a little thing. I've been
[11:53]
knowing Jason for a pretty good while
[11:55]
and very active with the fellowship of
[11:57]
Christian Athletes and uh uh how long
[12:00]
how long you been serving in that
[12:01]
capacity?
[12:02]
» Year seven.
[12:03]
» Year seven missionary with sir.
[12:06]
» Yep. Uh married to Robin, got three
[12:10]
children. Uh older children, 22, 16, and
[12:13]
14. How do you keep girls or boys?
[12:16]
» Older two girls and the boys the
[12:17]
youngest. Yes, sir.
[12:19]
» Uh he loves uh ministry. He loves his
[12:23]
family. He loves playing the guitar and
[12:25]
singing. Are you going to sing for us
[12:26]
today?
[12:27]
» Not today.
[12:28]
» Not today.
[12:28]
» I think y'all got too many items on the
[12:30]
agenda.
[12:31]
» I'm telling you. Well, I'm going to get
[12:33]
everybody to stand. Open us up. Jason in
[12:35]
prayer. And also, uh
[12:40]
I guess you're doing the pledge, too.
[12:43]
Yes. Nope. The colors are he's fallen,
[12:46]
right? They're out there. Okay. Just do
[12:48]
the prayer, buddy.
[12:51]
Dear gracious heavenly father, we we
[12:53]
call on you today. Um the word
[12:55]
invocation is like we're invoking you as
[12:58]
the higher power. Lord, I do lift up all
[13:00]
of our elected officials, our public
[13:03]
servants. Lord, my mind specifically
[13:05]
goes to the book of James where you said
[13:08]
if we ask for wisdom in faith, then
[13:11]
you'll pour it out generously, Lord. So,
[13:13]
we're going to thank you in advance for
[13:15]
that wisdom today. We're we're calling
[13:17]
on you uh in the decisions that are made
[13:20]
having to do with policy and all these
[13:23]
items on the agenda and we know there's
[13:25]
debate, Lord, but at the end of the day,
[13:26]
Lord, we believe that you are sovereign
[13:28]
and that you don't make any mistakes,
[13:29]
Lord. So, we just ask that your will
[13:31]
would be done today. Uh we lift up these
[13:33]
young people today that are going to be
[13:35]
bringing forward our colors and we do
[13:37]
all this in Jesus name. Amen.
[13:39]
» Amen. Y'all remain standing. We'll have
[13:41]
the colors presented by East Paul High
[13:44]
School. Attention
[13:47]
forward carry
[13:53]
forward. March
[14:05]
color guard
[14:09]
left ace.
[14:12]
Sir, Eastporting High School is
[14:14]
requesting permission to post the
[14:15]
colors. Sir,
[14:16]
» You got it, buddy.
[14:17]
» Post.
[14:35]
Present arms.
[14:39]
Please show me the reciting the pledge
[14:41]
of allegiance.
[14:42]
I pledge algiance to the flag of the
[14:45]
United States of America and to the
[14:48]
republic for which it stands. One nation
[14:52]
under God, indivisible, with liberty and
[14:56]
justice for all.
[14:58]
Order arms.
[15:03]
Post
[15:11]
ready. Face
[15:14]
forward. March.
[15:20]
[applause] Good job, ladies.
[15:31]
Next, uh,
[15:34]
[cough and clears throat] we have the,
[15:35]
uh, adopt the the minutes from August
[15:37]
the 25th, 2026 work session and August
[15:41]
the 25th on the board meeting minutes.
[15:44]
Uh, hope you've reviewed those. So, I
[15:46]
need a motion to adopt those minutes.
[15:50]
Motion to adopt the board meeting
[15:53]
minutes of August 25,
[15:56]
2026.
[15:57]
» Miss Kaker, is there a second?
[16:00]
» Second.
[16:01]
» Is that you, Mr. Dunn?
[16:02]
» Yes, sir.
[16:03]
» Okay. Uh, all in favor of up signify by
[16:07]
uplifted hand.
[16:10]
Uh, no announcements that I know of at
[16:12]
this time. Invited guests. There's none.
[16:15]
Uh, bid awards. Uh the first one is to
[16:18]
approve the purchase to the lowest
[16:20]
responsive quote that's Tri County
[16:22]
Uplifters for the final uplifting of 20
[16:26]
police patrol vehicles in the amount of
[16:29]
$395,4460.
[16:34]
Funding for this project will be from
[16:36]
Splass.
[16:37]
Do I have a motion to approve?
[16:41]
» Motion to approve.
[16:42]
» Thank you, Mr. Dunn. Is there a second?
[16:44]
Second,
[16:45]
» Miss Galloway. All in favor signify by
[16:48]
that lifted hand.
[16:52]
[cough] Excuse me.
[16:55]
Next is to authorize Pauling County Fire
[16:58]
Rescue to uh proceed with the purchase
[17:01]
of four Ford Maverick vehicles from the
[17:05]
Hardy family Ford through the state of
[17:08]
Georgia contract for a total uh vehicle
[17:12]
purchase price of $127,360
[17:17]
uh0
[17:18]
with the remaining of the the $12,640
[17:24]
uh of the approved $140,000
[17:29]
and that's in FY2027
[17:32]
project uh allocation
[17:34]
utilized for department lettering and
[17:38]
the warning lights funding for this
[17:40]
project will be allocated from SPLS. I
[17:44]
have a call for a motion to approve.
[17:47]
» Motion to approve.
[17:49]
» Miss Kaker, is there a second?
[17:52]
Second, Mr. Snyder. All in favor signify
[17:55]
with uplifted hand.
[18:00]
[snorts]
[18:01]
At this time, we don't have any reports
[18:04]
uh from committees or departments that
[18:06]
I'm aware of. Public participation on
[18:09]
agenda items. I think we do have one and
[18:12]
that's Joel Larkin.
[18:14]
If you'll come up to the podium, Mr.
[18:17]
Larkin and state your name and
[18:21]
you know the routine don't you?
[18:24]
» Good afternoon. My name is Joel Larkin.
[18:26]
I'm with the firm Sams Larkin and Huff
[18:27]
and Marietta. I appreciate being here
[18:29]
today. I wanted to comment on two
[18:31]
things. Number one, could you add me to
[18:33]
the Maverick order?
[18:35]
» Do what?
[18:36]
» The Ford Maverick. Could you put one on
[18:37]
there for me? No,
[18:39]
» I will.
[18:40]
» Um I'm pleased to represent the
[18:43]
applicant on item nine. It's a request
[18:45]
to change the zoning conditions. Uh, and
[18:48]
I'm mainly here to respond to any
[18:50]
questions you have, particularly you,
[18:51]
Mr. Chairman, because I know you missed
[18:52]
the planning commission meeting. So, if
[18:55]
there's any more any questions that the
[18:56]
board has or any information that you
[18:59]
need, we're here ready to respond to it
[19:01]
and provide it to you. Thank you.
[19:07]
» I Are there any questions from the board
[19:10]
or comments?
[19:12]
Okay. Thank you.
[19:14]
uh
[19:17]
public participation on agenda items.
[19:20]
There are uh there's one of those I
[19:24]
don't
[19:26]
» Huh?
[19:26]
» We just
[19:34]
» Oh, that's what I was doing. Uh I
[19:37]
thought that was what I was doing. Uh
[19:41]
there's actually one uh is uh the
[19:44]
disposal of the vehicles. Uh I need a
[19:46]
motion to approve.
[19:49]
» Motion to approve.
[19:51]
» Uh Miss Galloway, is there a second?
[19:54]
» Second,
[19:55]
» Miss Kaker. All in favor signify with
[19:57]
uplifted hand.
[20:00]
Okay.
[20:02]
No old business at this time. Uh new
[20:05]
business. Uh first is uh action to adopt
[20:08]
resolution 2026-37
[20:11]
authorizing the uh submission of
[20:14]
congestion mitigation and the air
[20:17]
quality program grant uh application to
[20:21]
the Georgia Department of Transportation
[20:23]
for the purpose of the project of the
[20:25]
Cedar Crest road improvement project
[20:27]
from Harmony uh Grove Church Road to
[20:31]
Cobb County line. That's uh P I 00013700
[20:37]
0 uh located in post one and also in
[20:40]
post 4. Uh and the gold mine road which
[20:44]
is at state route 101 intersection
[20:46]
improvement project. That's the PI
[20:49]
0019801
[20:53]
located in post 2. Uh I'll call for a
[20:57]
motion.
[20:59]
» Motion to approve.
[21:01]
» Mr. are done. Is there a second?
[21:03]
» Second. [clears throat]
[21:04]
» Excuse me,
[21:05]
» Mr. Snder. All in favor signify with the
[21:08]
uplifted hand.
[21:12]
[snorts]
[21:12]
» Next is action to adopt resolution
[21:14]
2026-38
[21:17]
confirming the executive session for the
[21:19]
purpose of real estate litigation uh and
[21:22]
litigation. Uh I'll call for a motion.
[21:27]
» Motion to approve.
[21:28]
» Mr. Snyder. Is there a second? Second,
[21:31]
» Miss Galloway. All in favor signify with
[21:33]
uplifted hand.
[21:40]
» All right. Next, we'll move into the
[21:42]
Pauling County Planning uh commission
[21:44]
meeting uh which was in their
[21:47]
recommendations on August the 25th and
[21:50]
also September the 8th. The first one is
[21:54]
uh action to adopt uh ordinance 20 uh
[21:58]
26-07 text amendment amending title one
[22:02]
admin uh administration and title two
[22:06]
zoning for the unified development
[22:09]
ordinance which is a UDO for Paulen
[22:11]
County Georgia uh and for other
[22:14]
purposes. I'll call for a motion.
[22:17]
» Motion to approve.
[22:20]
» Miss Galloway. Is there a second?
[22:23]
» Second,
[22:24]
» Miss Kaker, all in favor signify with
[22:26]
uplifted hand.
[22:30]
Next is uh number eight, which is the
[22:32]
2026-01
[22:35]
TAA application by Green Leaf
[22:38]
Investments Partners, uh L130 LLC. Mark
[22:43]
uh uh Buck Anonan uh requesting a text
[22:49]
amendment to the Unified Development
[22:52]
Direct Industrial District Section
[22:55]
210-240
[22:57]
uh
[22:59]
02 permitting use to allow the following
[23:03]
usage as permitted by Wright Health and
[23:07]
Fitness uh facilities including the
[23:09]
health club, fitness center, gymnasium,
[23:12]
and the fitness uh instructor uh studio
[23:16]
uh of the UDO unified development uh
[23:19]
ordinance. Approval on this text uh
[23:22]
amendment would add the following uh
[23:25]
text. Uh do I need to read those text?
[23:29]
» Yes.
[23:31]
» Uh that's the RR the health and fitness
[23:33]
facilities including the health club
[23:36]
fitness center gymnasium and the fitness
[23:39]
and structure studio. Recommendation on
[23:42]
this was approved uh 70 to zero and I'll
[23:46]
call for a motion from the board.
[23:49]
» Motion to approve.
[23:50]
» Mr. Dunn, is there a second?
[23:52]
» Second.
[23:53]
» Miss Galloway. Uh all in favor signify
[23:57]
by the uplifted hand.
[24:05]
Next is uh number nine which is a
[24:08]
2026-06-spa
[24:13]
application for Joel L. Larkin uh Sam's
[24:16]
Larkin and Huff LLC
[24:19]
uh requesting to amend a zoning uh
[24:23]
condition number nine from prior
[24:25]
reszoning application the 2020-16-Z
[24:30]
which limits the hours of operation on
[24:33]
the property from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. Uh
[24:38]
this uh applicant uh proposed hours of
[24:43]
operations from 5:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
[24:46]
Property is located in Lin Lot 101,
[24:49]
District 1, Section 3, north side of uh
[24:54]
Ridge Road and east side of Vaughn Road.
[24:57]
That address is 4281
[25:00]
Ridge Road and it's in post three.
[25:13]
Motion to approve.
[25:15]
» I ain't calling for it yet, but I was
[25:17]
fixing to.
[25:17]
» Sorry. [laughter]
[25:20]
» Oh, that's great. Sandy, is there a
[25:22]
second? Mr.
[25:22]
» Chair, if you would just read I think
[25:25]
the stipulation recommendation
[25:27]
from the planning commission. I think if
[25:31]
I can.
[25:34]
» Okay, I'm good. Second.
[25:36]
» Okay.
[25:38]
Uh,
[25:40]
so we we had a motion from Miss Kaker.
[25:43]
Is there a second?
[25:46]
» Second.
[25:48]
» All in favor signify with uplifted head.
[25:52]
» Okay.
[25:54]
» Uh, Mr. Chair,
[25:55]
» Oh, I got to read the recommendation.
[25:57]
» You call for opposition.
[25:59]
» Call for opposition. Yeah.
[26:00]
» Did you have
[26:02]
» I don't think you called for opposition
[26:04]
on that vote.
[26:05]
I w I need to call for opposition.
[26:07]
» I believe you do. Yes.
[26:08]
» Then I will.
[26:09]
» Yes, sir. Thank you.
[26:10]
» Uh is there any opposition on the number
[26:13]
uh on this last one?
[26:15]
» Yes.
[26:17]
» Yes. You got one.
[26:21]
» Oh, voting against it.
[26:22]
» I thought you I thought I saw a hand.
[26:25]
All right. So, uh what was that? What
[26:29]
was that? Uh what was it? You wrote it
[26:31]
down. Uh the the vote is approval at 41.
[26:35]
» 41.
[26:36]
» May I ask what the motion was? I'm not
[26:38]
clear.
[26:39]
» The motion was
[26:45]
» Turn it over. The motion was to approve
[26:49]
the applicant hour of operations from
[26:52]
500 a.m. to 11 p.m.
[26:54]
» Thank you.
[26:57]
» And I think that's the same as all the
[26:59]
surrounding hours. Is that correct?
[27:03]
It's the way I understood it.
[27:04]
» I believe so.
[27:09]
[clears throat]
[27:10]
» Which one am I on?
[27:14]
Uh, next is a 2026-02
[27:17]
uh SPSA application by Hickory Creek uh
[27:22]
Homeowners Association Incorporated
[27:24]
requesting
[27:27]
a revision of the PRD planning
[27:30]
residential development site plan from
[27:32]
resoning case 2004
[27:35]
uh-15-Z.
[27:37]
The applicant uh uh uh proposed to
[27:43]
construct a small community amendment uh
[27:46]
amenity on approximately 1.63 63 acres
[27:50]
of designated green space. Property is
[27:53]
located in Lin lot 892
[27:57]
uh district 3 section three uh west side
[28:00]
of the Sandy Glenn and Horththone Drive
[28:04]
intersection and it's located in post 4
[28:07]
and there are four stipula uh five
[28:10]
stipulations actually. Uh I call for a
[28:14]
motion
[28:21]
No,
[28:21]
» I'm going to make a motion for denial.
[28:23]
» Okay. Uh, is there a second?
[28:27]
» Second.
[28:28]
» Mr. Dunn, all in favor of signify by the
[28:31]
lifted hand.
[28:33]
And I didn't say, but the the
[28:35]
recommendation from planning is on. It
[28:37]
was denial 70 to zero.
[28:40]
Uh, next is the 2026-04-C
[28:46]
[clears throat]
[28:47]
application by
[28:50]
uh Ryan uh Lawrence requesting to
[28:53]
reszone 3.15 acres from R2
[28:57]
uh suburban residential district to I1
[29:01]
which is light industrial district for
[29:03]
the construction business including a
[29:06]
proposed storage yard for lumber
[29:09]
skidsters and other industrial products.
[29:13]
Application is also requesting a
[29:16]
variance to reduce buffer along the
[29:18]
northern the north property line from
[29:21]
50t to 25 ft. Property is located in
[29:25]
land lot 1041
[29:27]
district 2 section 3 west
[29:34]
side of the Hyram Douglasville Highway
[29:36]
SR92
[29:38]
uh south of Bill Karuth Parkway. That
[29:41]
address is 3166 Hyram Douglasville uh
[29:45]
highway and that is in post three. There
[29:50]
are four stipulations on this uh project
[29:53]
and the
[29:55]
uh recommendation from planning and
[29:57]
zoning was approve approval of five to
[30:02]
zero. So I'll call for a motion.
[30:07]
» Motion to approve with all the
[30:09]
stipulations.
[30:11]
» Miss Galloway, is there a second?
[30:13]
» Second.
[30:15]
» Miss Kaker. All in favor signify with
[30:18]
uplifted hand.
[30:24]
Okay, that
[30:25]
» Mr. Chair, if I may, excuse me, I want
[30:28]
to just for clarification sake, I want
[30:30]
to go back to the previously approved
[30:33]
item number nine.
[30:36]
And I want to make sure the record is
[30:38]
clear.
[30:40]
When the chairman read this item,
[30:43]
uh, it was for the
[30:46]
reason the applicant was wanting hours
[30:49]
of operations from 5:00 a.m. to 11:00
[30:52]
p.m. That was uh what the applicant
[30:55]
requested. That's what that was the
[30:58]
motion that was approved by the board of
[31:00]
commissioners. There was a stipulation
[31:03]
from the planning commission uh which is
[31:07]
number nine which is uh that says owner
[31:10]
and developer agrees to limit store
[31:12]
hours from 5 to 10 Sunday through
[31:15]
Thursday and from 5 to 11 Friday through
[31:19]
Saturday. That particular stipulation
[31:21]
was not approved. What was approved is
[31:24]
the hours from 5 to 11 7 days a week.
[31:29]
And I just wanted to make sure that that
[31:30]
is the will and intention of the board.
[31:35]
And if that's correct, then there's no
[31:37]
reason to talk about it any further. I'm
[31:40]
getting nods around the board that
[31:41]
that's correct. Thank you.
[31:45]
» Okay. Thank you for that update. Uh
[31:48]
conclusion of regular business. We do
[31:50]
have public participation on non-aggenda
[31:52]
items and uh we have I think six uh
[31:56]
citizens that's going to talk and the
[31:58]
first one will be at the podium that
[32:01]
would be Michelle Pratner is it Prattner
[32:05]
and let me see and it's on you can tell
[32:08]
us when you come up state your name and
[32:11]
also what you're going to be speaking on
[32:14]
uh and then the next in the back in the
[32:16]
uh uh next in line will be uh uh Mr. J.
[32:22]
No. Yeah, Mr. James Bender. Where's he
[32:25]
at? And get in that uh see that there it
[32:29]
says uh on deck. You can jump right in
[32:32]
there. Okay.
[32:34]
» Okay. So, um I'm Michelle Prather. I'm
[32:37]
I'm going to be speaking on um getting
[32:40]
an ordinance changed for outdoor storage
[32:42]
units. Um, and I'm here today to ask
[32:45]
this board to re-examine one restriction
[32:48]
in our unified development
[32:50]
ordinance. The requirement that outdoor
[32:53]
storage of boats, RVs, campers, and
[32:55]
personal trailers must be tied to a
[32:58]
fully constructed steel self storage
[33:01]
facility. This rule creates an
[33:03]
unnecessary and costly barrier. It
[33:06]
forces landowners to build commercial
[33:08]
storage buildings simply to provide
[33:11]
outdoor parking per for personal
[33:13]
recreational vehicles. Many residents
[33:16]
own these vehicles but cannot keep them
[33:18]
at home because of HOA restrictions.
[33:21]
Yet, the current ordinance makes it
[33:22]
extremely difficult for private property
[33:24]
owners to help meet that need in a low
[33:27]
impact way. We can protect the county's
[33:30]
character without requiring buildings.
[33:32]
Strong visual screening, including
[33:34]
mature tree buffers and privacy fencing,
[33:38]
can keep our outdoor storage completely
[33:40]
hidden from roads and neighborhooding
[33:43]
neighborhooding properties. Heavy
[33:45]
commercial um trucks can still be
[33:48]
prohibited. The question is not whether
[33:51]
this use should be regulated. It is
[33:53]
whether um the allow only option must
[33:58]
include a storage building. I
[34:00]
respectfully urge this board to direct
[34:02]
staff to prepare a text amendment that
[34:04]
creates a clear conditional path for
[34:06]
standalone heavily screened outdoor
[34:08]
storage of personal recreational
[34:10]
vehicles on appropriately sized
[34:13]
properties. This would give reasonable
[34:15]
land owners a practical option while
[34:18]
still protecting the appearance and
[34:20]
character of our community. Thank you
[34:22]
for your time and consideration.
[34:24]
» Thank you, Michelle. Appreciate it. Uh
[34:27]
uh Mr. Bender will be next on data
[34:30]
centers and if Connie Rex straw will get
[34:32]
in the uh next in line.
[34:37]
You ready? My name is James Bender. I
[34:39]
work in the fiber optic industry
[34:40]
probably about 20 years. And I see where
[34:42]
you say there's no data center going in
[34:44]
at Cole Lake Road. The only problem I
[34:46]
have with that is I'm watching them put
[34:48]
a six pack of conduit in down Dallas
[34:51]
Highway into Dallas right by the CVS.
[34:54]
They cost between 50,000 and $100,000 a
[34:57]
mile to install. And you're telling me
[35:00]
no data centers? Nobody's doing that on
[35:03]
a maybe. I mean, that's almost a $2
[35:05]
million investment. I go further in my
[35:08]
connections. Look at the 811 dig
[35:10]
tickets. Excel constructions
[35:13]
putting in fiber optics for a data
[35:15]
center. So I mean somebody needs to
[35:18]
explain it to me. Either you're not
[35:19]
going to do it or you are going to do
[35:21]
it. You're lying to them or you're lying
[35:22]
to us. I need to know.
[35:26]
That's what I want to know cuz they're
[35:27]
not putting that in for giggles. I've
[35:30]
done this for 20 years. If they're
[35:33]
slamming that much conduit in the
[35:34]
ground, that's almost 6,000 fibers they
[35:37]
can put in there. do the same amount of
[35:39]
work as two million copper phone lines?
[35:43]
I mean, would you like to explain it to
[35:46]
me? I'd love to know.
[35:48]
» I know that Greystone's putting in fiber
[35:50]
through the whole
[35:50]
» That ain't Greystone. That's Zo.
[35:52]
» I know I'm like the back of my hand. And
[35:54]
they don't do nothing but high-end
[35:56]
massive data. CNN, Bank of America. They
[36:00]
don't offer residential service. And the
[36:02]
fact that you would just tell me
[36:03]
Greystone,
[36:05]
» Well, they work with another company.
[36:07]
They don't work with Zale. I promise you
[36:08]
that. 20 years. I mean, so the fact that
[36:12]
you just tried to pawn that off on me,
[36:14]
come on.
[36:16]
I just told you I' been doing this for
[36:18]
20 years. I've seen it. And the problem
[36:21]
you're going to have is it's not just
[36:23]
going to be them. Then some other
[36:24]
company's going to come in. T-Mobile,
[36:26]
Crown Castle, they're going to want to
[36:29]
run fiber there. You're not going to
[36:30]
have any room in the ground for your own
[36:32]
utilities. I see it every day.
[36:35]
So, I mean, I know you put a moratorium
[36:37]
on it, but that's only on new permits,
[36:40]
not old permits.
[36:42]
I mean, they're a blight. I've been to
[36:44]
them. I mean, you can get in a prison
[36:47]
easier than you can get in a data center
[36:48]
to look at it. I mean, I'm not talking
[36:51]
chain link fence. I'm talking concrete
[36:53]
walls with razor wire, their own fire
[36:56]
department, their own security force.
[36:58]
They might employ 40 people. They're not
[37:00]
going to bring jobs. They're not going
[37:02]
to bring business to the community.
[37:05]
They're just going to blight the land.
[37:07]
That's all they're going to do. And I
[37:09]
know, I've seen it. I've been there. I
[37:11]
look at them every day. And then, God
[37:14]
forbid somebody hits that fiber in the
[37:15]
ground. Then you've got the whole road
[37:18]
tore up for two or three days. It's all
[37:20]
I got to say. But I promise you this. If
[37:23]
it goes in, I'll make sure none of y'all
[37:25]
get reelected. I will petition campaign
[37:29]
for anybody against you, even if it's a
[37:31]
Democrat.
[37:32]
» Well, thank you. [applause]
[37:39]
» Uh, Miss Rexaw,
[37:42]
» I'm going to do one correction on my
[37:44]
name. My maiden name is Rake Straw.
[37:45]
Connie Raikstraw. I'm now Ellis, but
[37:47]
Connie Raikstraw Ellis. And I first off,
[37:50]
I want to wish you a good afternoon. I'm
[37:52]
not mad at anyone, but I am mad at
[37:54]
situations like many people in this
[37:56]
county and what I have to say about I'm
[37:58]
coming before you once again into the
[38:00]
rapid push to develop these data centers
[38:02]
in our county and the secrecy
[38:05]
surrounding them. The people here
[38:07]
deserve a voice and we never had a
[38:09]
voice. Never. We are the ones that live
[38:12]
here and pay the taxes that pay your
[38:14]
salaries.
[38:18]
Not big developers or corporations. They
[38:21]
don't. They don't live here. They don't
[38:22]
pay your salaries. We do. I've said it
[38:25]
before and I'll say it again. As regard
[38:27]
to AI and data centers, there are too
[38:30]
many unknowns. You do not move this
[38:33]
rapidly on something like this. And I'm
[38:35]
sure you're quite aware across this
[38:37]
nation, many counties and states are
[38:40]
putting moratoriums. They're putting
[38:42]
brakes on till they can do further
[38:44]
research and put appropriate ordinances
[38:46]
and regulations in place to protect
[38:49]
their people. That's the wise thing to
[38:51]
do here. And I also heard from a
[38:54]
developer recently that has built data
[38:57]
centers and he said he would not even
[38:59]
put a data center in Paul County. It is
[39:01]
too populated. We don't have to have one
[39:04]
in our county. If we as the people
[39:06]
decide to put one with the appropriate
[39:08]
regulations, that's one thing. But we
[39:09]
don't have to have one here. But he said
[39:11]
if he were going to build a data center,
[39:13]
he would put it the middle in the middle
[39:14]
of it. No more. At least I'm sorry, at
[39:16]
least 2 to 3,000 acres slap in the
[39:19]
middle of it surrounded by trees. You
[39:20]
know why? The trees are going to buffer
[39:22]
the noise and the pollution that's going
[39:24]
to come from these centers. We don't
[39:26]
know what we're doing to our people, our
[39:27]
environment by putting men like that
[39:29]
like this. So, I'm going to ask you two
[39:31]
things today. Number one is to extend
[39:33]
the moratorum and number two is to
[39:36]
repeal the teapot. You have that in your
[39:37]
power as a commission to back that out.
[39:43]
And before I get down from this podium,
[39:44]
there are two questions I want to ask
[39:46]
you. And you may not be able to answer
[39:47]
them in public. And I understand if you
[39:49]
can't, hopefully you can, but I would
[39:52]
like an answer to me directly via email
[39:54]
because I've asked it of you. And I'm
[39:55]
not sure about prior or current
[39:58]
permitting. But let's say we have the
[40:00]
moratorum now and when it expires, do
[40:03]
you plan to move forward with the
[40:04]
Tidwell Road and Bethl Church Road
[40:06]
project into development of a data
[40:08]
center? Is that your intention at the
[40:10]
expiration of the moratorum? Does anyone
[40:13]
want to answer that?
[40:17]
» Okay. And question number two, this
[40:20]
isn't just for the board. This is for
[40:21]
the entire room.
[40:23]
» Well, you don't address.
[40:24]
» Well, okay, but this this is this is a
[40:26]
question I want you food for thought
[40:28]
here. if we had a ballot put before us
[40:31]
or if you did or even a questionnaire as
[40:33]
a member of this county and by a raise
[40:35]
of hands you can vote yes and remember
[40:39]
raising your hand means yes would you
[40:41]
allow a data center in your backyard. I
[40:44]
want to remind you commissioners that
[40:47]
this is your county your home and your
[40:50]
lives as well. It's just not the people
[40:52]
that are up here upset. You're infecting
[40:54]
everyone in this county. And I'm asking
[40:57]
you in the name of God and the people to
[41:00]
do the right thing. Just do the right
[41:02]
thing. Thank you.
[41:03]
» We will, [applause]
[41:07]
Mr. W.
[41:10]
And the next will be Todd Panel if he
[41:13]
can come up here and sit in the uh uh
[41:15]
» I think I'm next
[41:16]
» On deck.
[41:18]
» I think he
[41:19]
» I think you have me as next,
[41:21]
» Right?
[41:22]
» Ma'am, you're you are next. You saying
[41:23]
Mr. Pal, come up. Be ready.
[41:26]
Mr. Chairman, commissioners, and staff,
[41:29]
thank you for the opportunity to speak
[41:31]
this afternoon. My name is Michelle
[41:32]
Wolvin. We keep coming month after month
[41:35]
because you work for us. And right now,
[41:37]
we feel that you're not listening. And
[41:40]
because we are hearing, the board
[41:41]
remains intent on moving the Highway 92
[41:44]
data center project forward.
[41:47]
There is no realistic way to
[41:49]
meaningfully strengthen the current
[41:50]
ordinance to protect surrounding
[41:52]
homeowners while keeping the developers
[41:54]
committed. We are told this project is
[41:57]
not going anywhere. The board wants it.
[42:00]
That's exactly why I'm here. Under the
[42:02]
teapot, data centers are effectively
[42:04]
allowed by right specifically listed
[42:07]
parcels covering roughly 995 acres. The
[42:10]
developer does not need a full reszoning
[42:13]
or special use permit.
[42:15]
These properties were effectively
[42:17]
spot-zoned. Our constitution does not
[42:20]
permit government to create special
[42:22]
privileges for a few at the expense of
[42:25]
the many.
[42:26]
Georgia law and the principles of due
[42:28]
process and equal protection under both
[42:30]
the Georgia and United States
[42:32]
Constitution reject singling out
[42:34]
discrete tracks for preferential
[42:37]
treatment.
[42:39]
Spot zoning that favors a particular
[42:41]
project without a clear relation to the
[42:43]
broader public health, safety, and
[42:46]
welfare is unconstitutional.
[42:49]
Naming specific parcels and granting
[42:52]
them a use unavailable to surrounding
[42:54]
property is precisely the special
[42:56]
treatment the Constitution forbids.
[43:00]
Neighboring owners were denied the same
[43:02]
notice and opportunity to be heard that
[43:04]
a conventional resoning requires. That's
[43:07]
a preferential treatment and it cannot
[43:09]
stand.
[43:11]
Why is it acceptable to tell homeowners
[43:13]
they can just sell out to the
[43:14]
developers?
[43:16]
That is not an answer. That is a
[43:18]
dismissal of people who built their
[43:20]
entire lives here. Families should not
[43:22]
be forced to abandon their homes and
[43:24]
neighborhoods they invested in simply so
[43:26]
a flawed project can expand.
[43:30]
Telling people their only option to sell
[43:32]
is pressure and not justice.
[43:35]
This raises a serious question about the
[43:37]
advice the board received. Our county
[43:40]
attorneys are charged with giving sound
[43:42]
legal counsel. They know the
[43:43]
consequences of advancing major land use
[43:46]
changes with limited public notice. They
[43:49]
lived through the long
[43:52]
I'm sorry.
[43:55]
They lived through the long airport
[43:56]
industrialization controversy. If the
[43:59]
county attorneys warn you this ordinance
[44:01]
would face constitutional challenge and
[44:03]
you proceeded anyway, the public
[44:06]
deserves to know why.
[44:08]
The lack of proper notice, the
[44:10]
appearance of preferential treatment,
[44:12]
and the spot zoning problems were all
[44:14]
foreseeable.
[44:15]
The board cannot claim to be studying
[44:17]
the issue while also signaling that this
[44:20]
particular project will proceed and that
[44:22]
the ordinance cannot be strengthened
[44:24]
without losing the developer. Because
[44:26]
the teapod was adopted through a process
[44:28]
that violates due process and equal pro
[44:31]
protection under the law and because it
[44:33]
functions as unconstitutional spot
[44:35]
zoning. It is not merely flawed, it's
[44:37]
invalid.
[44:39]
An ordinance that cannot withstand
[44:42]
constitutional scrutiny cannot be
[44:45]
patched into compliance. The only lawful
[44:48]
remedy is complete repeal.
[44:51]
The board has both the authority and the
[44:55]
duty to repeal it. Anything less leaves
[44:58]
in place a framework that treats some
[45:00]
owners differently and denies them the
[45:02]
process the constitution requires. We do
[45:05]
not want to live in an AI surveillance
[45:07]
state or under a digital currency
[45:08]
controlled by these facilities. Do you
[45:11]
want your do you want that for your
[45:13]
children and your grandchildren? This is
[45:15]
not a legal issue. It is a question of
[45:17]
whether we will treat our neighbors as
[45:19]
the law and the faith requires. Many of
[45:22]
you profess the Christian faith as do I.
[45:25]
Scripture is clear. Romans 13:9 tells us
[45:29]
the commandments are summed up in the
[45:31]
single rule. Love your neighbor as
[45:33]
yourself.
[45:35]
Galatians 5:14 says the entire law is
[45:38]
fulfilled in that same command. Loving
[45:40]
your neighbor means protecting the
[45:42]
homes, the peace, and the rightful
[45:44]
expectations of the families who live
[45:46]
next to these parcels, not creating
[45:48]
special rules that pressure them to sell
[45:50]
or that privilege one developer over
[45:53]
equal treatment for everyone.
[45:55]
It means refusing to sacrifice the many
[45:59]
for the preferences of the few. If we
[46:03]
truly love our neighbors, we will not
[46:05]
allow a constitutionally flawed process
[46:07]
to stand. Will this board choose to love
[46:10]
its neighbors by treating every property
[46:12]
owner equally under the law?
[46:15]
Will you protect the families who built
[46:17]
their lives here or force them to sell
[46:20]
so a favored project can expand?
[46:23]
» Will you stand for the Constitution
[46:26]
or defend special privileges for a few?
[46:29]
» Thank you.
[46:30]
» Thank you, Miss Wen. [applause]
[46:33]
Next is Miss uh Mr. Panel on data
[46:37]
centers and Richard Chappelle will be
[46:40]
next in the
[46:48]
» Good afternoon commissioners.
[46:51]
I think the last two speakers summed
[46:53]
everything up for the most part. But I
[46:56]
will tell you this, over the last three
[46:58]
or four months,
[47:00]
everything that I've dug into and
[47:02]
everything that the folks out here and
[47:04]
in the community have asked for open
[47:06]
records and sent to me without me
[47:09]
asking.
[47:12]
There's not a whole lot in the open
[47:14]
records that tell us that there's been a
[47:17]
whole lot of work and due diligence and
[47:19]
research in this event.
[47:22]
Not through the open records doesn't say
[47:24]
it. Then through conversations that I've
[47:27]
had with maybe commissioners, staff, and
[47:31]
different people,
[47:33]
private conversations that we've talked
[47:35]
about, they've talked about different
[47:37]
things. Some of them said one of them
[47:39]
one time I asked I said hey when did
[47:42]
y'all start this in January of 25 and
[47:44]
they said no started it in March. I
[47:46]
think it was March. I'm pretty sure it
[47:48]
was March. Then I was told May of 25. So
[47:54]
March to August when it was approved is
[47:57]
five months. May is three months. So,
[48:01]
not a whole lot of time and effort and
[48:04]
research. In my view, according to what
[48:07]
I've heard from some of y'all and from
[48:10]
staff and from the open records, does
[48:14]
not show a whole lot of research has
[48:17]
been done.
[48:18]
The folks in the county have brought you
[48:21]
all kind of things. And I know people
[48:22]
talk about the environment and they talk
[48:24]
about all kind of different things, but
[48:27]
they they brought you true stats, real
[48:30]
stuff. And I know there's stuff out
[48:32]
there on YouTube. I get that, but they
[48:34]
brought you great information.
[48:37]
Now, it's also been told, and I've heard
[48:40]
it, that, hey, all you had to do was
[48:44]
look in the paper. Y'all know what was
[48:46]
put in the paper. And that's not true.
[48:49]
Not for the average citizen. Not for the
[48:51]
above average citizen, not for anybody
[48:53]
would have known what you were doing and
[48:56]
where you were doing it.
[48:58]
They've also been said, some comments
[49:00]
have also been made said, hey, they
[49:03]
could have bought the property.
[49:06]
The owners of the property bought the
[49:08]
property zoned the way it was zoned
[49:10]
around the people that live there. And
[49:12]
that's what we know is that zoning. When
[49:15]
something gets reszoned, it's all about
[49:17]
the people that live around it, not
[49:19]
about the land owner. It's not. I bought
[49:23]
my place and plan to live there forever.
[49:26]
Julie and I fostered kids for a lot of
[49:29]
years, almost 17 different boys, helped
[49:33]
raise them, and adopted two, and my
[49:35]
family plans to stay on my property.
[49:39]
So, we want to talk about the facts.
[49:42]
I shouldn't have to go to bed at night.
[49:46]
These people shouldn't have to go to bed
[49:47]
at night. Nobody in our community should
[49:50]
have to go to bed at night and wonder
[49:52]
what's being done in the newspaper.
[49:55]
It shouldn't happen like that. There
[49:57]
should be reasonzoning. There should be
[49:59]
signs up. There should be a every piece
[50:02]
of property in the county should be
[50:03]
reszoned if it's going to be reszoned
[50:07]
that specific property, not go and do a
[50:11]
blanket overlay like what y'all have
[50:12]
done. And then I could get into a lot of
[50:16]
things
[50:17]
and I won't mention names,
[50:20]
but did y'all hire Brandon Bowen as an
[50:23]
attorney to work on this project?
[50:27]
Because the the emails that the open
[50:29]
record emails
[50:32]
indicate that y'all hired Brandon Bowman
[50:37]
and he went to what was called the
[50:39]
enduser
[50:41]
and made sure that he brought back the
[50:43]
information
[50:45]
to you all
[50:47]
to get you all to do what he needed
[50:50]
done. And when I look at the open
[50:53]
records, it seems as everybody, the
[50:56]
developer, the land owner, this attorney
[50:59]
from Carterville, everybody knew about
[51:01]
what was going on except for the
[51:03]
citizens.
[51:05]
And I'm going to end it with this.
[51:09]
Y'all have got to extend the moratorum
[51:13]
March 31st of next year minimum.
[51:17]
If you just let that moratorum ride and
[51:20]
January 1 comes while everybody's at
[51:23]
home and on vacation, including you all,
[51:26]
what's going to happen on January 4th?
[51:31]
You going to have a called meeting and
[51:33]
fix it? Y'all can fix this right now. My
[51:37]
family and these families in this
[51:39]
county, they all deserve you to fix it.
[51:42]
Extend the moratorum because you're
[51:44]
going to be caught in trouble if you
[51:46]
don't. Extend the morator.
[51:49]
» Thank you so much and have a great day.
[51:52]
[cheering]
[51:53]
[applause]
[51:57]
» Chappelle. [applause]
[52:05]
Good afternoon. My name is Richard
[52:07]
Chappelle. I'm a resident of Pauling
[52:09]
County. Uh I live off of Brownsville and
[52:12]
Ronald Drive, very close to where you
[52:14]
have this data center.
[52:16]
I I'm going to I understand how I sound.
[52:19]
I'm not an elected official, but I am a
[52:22]
civil servant and I'm going to speak
[52:23]
civil servant to civil servant. So, if I
[52:25]
sound all crazy, it don't take it
[52:27]
personally.
[52:29]
[sighs] These data centers, this isn't
[52:31]
the normal kind of data center. A
[52:33]
regular data center for internet, that
[52:35]
kind of thing, that's about the size of
[52:36]
an Exxon gas station. This is a hypers
[52:38]
scale data center that uses more power
[52:40]
than the entire county. And when you
[52:44]
when you have that energy, when it comes
[52:47]
from energy to electricity, you have
[52:49]
basically you have sound, you have
[52:51]
light, you have heat. And the amount
[52:53]
that that's going to generate that close
[52:55]
to people's homes, 100 foot barrier is
[52:57]
not going to stop that. You know, you're
[53:00]
already seeing in Texas and in Oregon,
[53:02]
they have brownouts, they have power
[53:04]
outages, and a brown out, I don't know
[53:07]
about you, you guys can see my salary
[53:09]
because I'm a state employee. I can't
[53:11]
afford to just continuously replace my
[53:14]
equipment or my utilities because of
[53:16]
brownouts.
[53:19]
And this this stuff that they're talking
[53:22]
about about China, it it's not competing
[53:25]
with China. These companies are
[53:26]
competing with other AI companies and
[53:29]
their profits.
[53:31]
[clears throat] As one company runs out
[53:33]
of money, it borrows money from another
[53:35]
AI company. Nvidia,
[53:37]
all of these companies. And I understand
[53:39]
that this is kind of dork level stuff,
[53:41]
but you know, this is what I specialize
[53:42]
in. This is what y'all's tax money goes
[53:44]
to make me be good at. They've got this
[53:47]
circle of like buying and selling and
[53:50]
profiting off their own product. But
[53:52]
that that circle doesn't include us. I
[53:55]
mean, this what they're doing is
[53:56]
basically Enron on a massive level. And
[53:59]
we're going to be stuck with the
[54:00]
consequences.
[54:02]
I mean, you're already seeing that with
[54:03]
some of these places that they the air
[54:05]
pollution that they're bringing in from
[54:07]
diesel, depending on how they that goes
[54:10]
in the air that doesn't just stay there.
[54:12]
That comes down in the form of acid
[54:14]
rain.
[54:15]
Pauling County is a very green county.
[54:17]
It's a county I love to live in. I can,
[54:20]
you know, I can almost be
[54:21]
self-sufficient, you know, grow my own
[54:22]
food, do what I need to do. Not going to
[54:25]
be able to do that with that kind of
[54:26]
heat, noise, acid rain, and air
[54:30]
pollution. And it's not like dropping a
[54:32]
bomb. It's not going to happen
[54:33]
immediately. It's one of these things
[54:35]
that happens over time. And you're
[54:38]
already seeing in some of these other
[54:39]
states once it comes in, there's no
[54:41]
protection for us. There's no protection
[54:43]
for the residents. You know, like this
[54:45]
gentleman who came before me said, I I
[54:48]
plan on pretty much dying in my home in
[54:50]
Paul County. It it's great. I love it
[54:51]
there. I don't want to have to live a
[54:55]
couple of feet from a data center
[54:57]
because
[54:59]
where they have it on Tidwell Road, they
[55:00]
keep trying to say it as Tidwell and 92.
[55:02]
It is the entirety of Tidwell Road. And
[55:05]
for anyone here, and I know gas is
[55:08]
expensive, but go down Tidwell Road so
[55:10]
you can just see just how large of a
[55:13]
scale that this is planning on being.
[55:15]
And I I'm not accusing you guys. I'm not
[55:18]
going to talk crazy you guys, but I
[55:19]
don't think it was explained in detail
[55:21]
like this when they pitched it. You
[55:24]
know, they probably just pitched it as,
[55:25]
oh, it's great. It's a future. It's
[55:27]
going to make all this money.
[55:29]
If it's going to make all this money, if
[55:31]
it's so great, why are the companies
[55:32]
that are pushing it, why are their CEOs
[55:35]
moving to other countries where they
[55:36]
don't have data centers? They're not
[55:38]
putting them in their backyards. They're
[55:39]
putting in hours and they're leaving
[55:42]
because they know that it's a house of
[55:44]
cards.
[55:46]
You know, I mean, they're trying to say
[55:48]
all this good stuff, but you know,
[55:50]
they're getting our power. They're
[55:52]
getting our water. And, you know, I hate
[55:54]
to quote AC/DC here, but we're getting
[55:56]
the dirty D that's done dirt cheap.
[55:59]
And I want to leave you with one thing
[56:02]
that has stuck with me my whole life
[56:05]
because I wasn't always on the right
[56:06]
side of law and technology. And it is
[56:09]
Matthew 16:23. For what profit is of a
[56:12]
man if he gains the whole world and
[56:14]
loses his own soul? Thank you.
[56:17]
[applause]
[56:22]
» Thank everyone of y'all. And uh there's
[56:25]
no executive session uh at this time. So
[56:29]
we will adjourn. But I need a motion to
[56:32]
adjourn.
[56:35]
» Motion to adjurnn. Miss Caker, is there
[56:38]
a second?
[56:39]
» Second.
[56:40]
» Mr. Snyder, all in favor signify with
[56:43]
uplifted hand.
[56:45]
» We are adjourned. Y'all have a great
[56:47]
evening.