Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
[0:00]
Let's
[0:12]
do all together. All right. Um, good
[0:15]
evening everyone. I'll call to order a
[0:17]
special meeting of the Salem School
[0:19]
Committee of July 7th, 2026 at 6 p.m.
[0:22]
This meeting is taking place in person
[0:23]
at 29 Highland Avenue, room 227 in
[0:25]
Salem. In person is the primary method
[0:28]
of public access to this meeting. Um if
[0:31]
technologically feasible, you can access
[0:33]
via Salem Access TV or remotely using
[0:35]
the Zoom link posted in the meeting
[0:37]
agenda. The only item on our agenda for
[0:39]
this evening is interview with our
[0:40]
superintendent finalist, Jorge Allen. Um
[0:44]
we will begin with uh allowing uh you to
[0:48]
uh offer a two to three minute opening
[0:49]
statement if you like. There'll be a
[0:51]
series of questions from the committee
[0:52]
members. Uh committee members that wish
[0:55]
to ask a follow-up question to any of
[0:57]
the questions that were asked, please
[0:59]
raise your hand. Uh and I'll call on
[1:00]
folks. Um and then we'll move on to the
[1:02]
next questions and then at the
[1:04]
conclusion of the questions, uh you'll
[1:06]
have an opportunity for another two to
[1:08]
three minute closing statement if you'd
[1:09]
like.
[1:10]
» All right.
[1:10]
» Thank you.
[1:11]
» Okay.
[1:14]
Well, uh with that, the floor is yours.
[1:17]
» Thank you. Uh good evening. Uh thank you
[1:20]
uh for the opportunity to be here. Um I
[1:23]
would like to start by saying what
[1:25]
really excites me about Salem. Um what
[1:28]
really excites me about Salem is
[1:30]
basically who the community is. The um
[1:34]
having almost um for more than 40% of
[1:38]
families and students to be uh Hispanic.
[1:41]
Um having one in every six um students
[1:45]
roughly to be English learners. Uh those
[1:47]
are the things that really excite me but
[1:50]
especially the fact that this is a
[1:52]
community that is very intentional and
[1:54]
deliberate in communicating their sense
[1:56]
of belonging to um all these members. Um
[2:02]
and the most important thing is that the
[2:03]
multiculturalism and the multilingualism
[2:06]
of this community is not being seen as a
[2:10]
challenge to be managed but instead as
[2:12]
an asset that enriches the community and
[2:15]
should also enrich educational
[2:17]
experience of the students. Um,
[2:20]
personally as a immigrant myself, as a
[2:23]
first generation college educated in my
[2:26]
family, as a descendant or uh descendant
[2:29]
Westinians that actually built the
[2:31]
Panama Canal, um, I feel connected with
[2:34]
this community and I feel that the I
[2:38]
don't see way I don't see Salem as a
[2:42]
basically a district, but I see the
[2:44]
families that represent also my family
[2:47]
as well. uh also because of the fact of
[2:50]
me having to raise uh three
[2:51]
African-American uh boys in in this uh
[2:54]
community and having to navigate this
[2:57]
the school system as a parent in a
[2:59]
language and a culture that was not
[3:01]
actually my first that has given me a
[3:04]
perspective that is not just imagine or
[3:07]
learned from a book but actually lived
[3:09]
um in every day of my experience as a as
[3:13]
a parent. Two things that I would like
[3:16]
to highlight tonight and hopefully
[3:18]
you'll be able to see that through line
[3:21]
is one I truly feel and believe that
[3:25]
Salem is not at the beginning of
[3:27]
something. It's actually in the midst of
[3:30]
uh extraordinary things that are
[3:32]
happening. When I came to the site visit
[3:36]
uh a couple a few weeks ago, I I was
[3:38]
able to see um from the early early
[3:43]
childhood center how the adults were
[3:46]
excited about kids getting dirty in the
[3:49]
community garden. I was able to see uh
[3:53]
the dual language school be very proud
[3:56]
about the um the teachers that they have
[3:58]
brought from Brazil, from the Dominican
[4:00]
Republic and Spain. Uh then I was able
[4:03]
to experience and and have a
[4:06]
conversation with the a middle school
[4:07]
principal that's actually very excited
[4:09]
about the possibility that next year
[4:11]
they will be um the start of a dual
[4:14]
language program at the at their school.
[4:17]
And then also in um in my meeting with
[4:20]
high school students when I asked them
[4:23]
what what is one aspect of the Salem
[4:25]
High School uh experience that they feel
[4:28]
really proud that they will be able to
[4:30]
brag about and the answers I got were
[4:33]
two that really were very telling. One
[4:37]
one of the students mentioned that they
[4:38]
were really proud of the special
[4:40]
education program.
[4:43]
This has been my first time in my
[4:44]
educator life that actually students
[4:47]
will actually highlight the education
[4:49]
special education program as a highlight
[4:52]
of their educational experience.
[4:54]
The second thing that also uh was shared
[4:57]
by the students when I met with them was
[5:00]
that they were really proud and really
[5:02]
excited about the design of the high
[5:05]
school that allows them to to experience
[5:09]
uh career and technology education
[5:11]
opportunities and pathways in addition
[5:14]
to the uh regular high school
[5:16]
curriculum. So those are the things that
[5:19]
I describe by extraordinary. Those are
[5:21]
the things that really make Salem for me
[5:24]
a exciting place to be able to join um
[5:27]
as an educator. The second thing I would
[5:30]
like to um highlight that my second
[5:32]
through line is and it will hopefully
[5:35]
will make more sense later is the
[5:38]
concept of um locally rooted and
[5:42]
globally ready. I I feel and I believe
[5:46]
that all and every single Salem public
[5:49]
school student deserves uh access to the
[5:52]
core curriculum and also they deserve to
[5:55]
really learn about their language, about
[5:57]
the culture and about their local
[5:59]
community and those things and those
[6:02]
elements should make them ready for um
[6:06]
basically be ready globally for career
[6:09]
or any post-secary uh opportunities that
[6:12]
they might want to pursue.
[6:14]
So um those were my two uh through lines
[6:17]
today and hopefully that will capture my
[6:19]
vision and again I'm thank you for the
[6:21]
opportunity um as I'm really honored to
[6:23]
be here with with you today.
[6:28]
» Thank you Mr. Allen. Um so our first
[6:30]
question
[6:32]
equity often requires difficult choices.
[6:34]
How do you approach decisions about
[6:36]
allocating resources, opportunities, and
[6:39]
supports across students, schools, and
[6:41]
programs when needs exceed available
[6:44]
resources?
[6:46]
» Yeah, I think for me the first operating
[6:49]
definition is to keep in mind that
[6:51]
equity doesn't mean equal distribution
[6:53]
of assets. So equity is not asking for
[6:57]
every single school, every single
[6:58]
student to have the same thing. is
[7:01]
actually is asking us to be mindful
[7:04]
about how distribution of assets is u
[7:08]
providing equal opportunity of uh access
[7:11]
to opportunities.
[7:13]
So um
[7:15]
there's always this dilemma that is that
[7:18]
we're bound to face that needs always
[7:22]
going to surpass resources.
[7:25]
The question that I will have as a
[7:28]
superintendent that actually has
[7:30]
dictated my um my career is to always
[7:34]
ask the question like what are the
[7:38]
students or families that will be
[7:40]
impacted by any budget decision.
[7:44]
especially keeping in mind that we want
[7:45]
to u protect the families that are more
[7:48]
vulnerable that the families that have
[7:51]
been uh under reppresented or the the
[7:55]
students have not been achieving
[7:57]
educationally as their peers. So um with
[8:02]
those decisions with those principles in
[8:04]
mind it's important to communicate those
[8:07]
values when um having budget
[8:10]
considerations and conversations. I
[8:13]
would like to offer an example. Um,
[8:17]
as a department head in a in a world
[8:19]
language program, I had to make the
[8:21]
decision about uh increasing the class
[8:24]
size of the honors classes to be able to
[8:28]
to have enough staffing to support the
[8:31]
um the college prep courses offered in
[8:33]
my department. That was not a popular
[8:36]
decision. That was not a decision that
[8:38]
is in a way counterintuitive.
[8:41]
But the principle, the driving principle
[8:43]
for that is that those students that are
[8:46]
labeled as college prep versus honors,
[8:49]
those are the students that in a world
[8:50]
language program are the ones that are
[8:52]
more vulnerable. They are the ones that
[8:54]
don't see themselves as language
[8:56]
learners and those are the ones that
[8:58]
will benefit from having a smaller class
[9:01]
size in which that will um provide more
[9:04]
access to the teachers.
[9:06]
um those kind of decisions are the ones
[9:09]
that I that I use when I look at
[9:12]
budgetary uh considerations
[9:15]
and um and what is more important is to
[9:19]
keep in mind what will be the effect or
[9:21]
the impact of those. So I was trying to
[9:24]
protect the students that our program
[9:26]
needed to um highly support and the
[9:30]
students that were actually were
[9:31]
underrepresented academically.
[9:34]
Um but the most important thing is that
[9:36]
that decision was owned by me. That
[9:38]
decision was understood by the
[9:40]
department and I did not pass that um
[9:43]
the negativity that came with the
[9:45]
decision and spread to the rest of the
[9:47]
staff. So um in in the end the driving
[9:52]
decision is about the impact. A budget
[9:55]
document becomes a document of values
[9:58]
and statements. And it's not just a list
[10:01]
of cuts and expenses, but actually it
[10:04]
should show what a district, what a
[10:07]
program or a school values.
[10:13]
» Thank you. Uh follow-up questions from
[10:15]
committee members.
[10:23]
Member Cornell.
[10:24]
» Thank you. Um I'm wondering if you can
[10:28]
uh develop a little bit how you would
[10:32]
use what metrics you would use to sort
[10:35]
of assess how we allocate
[10:39]
our resources equitably. Um you know
[10:42]
this is a concern for us going forward
[10:43]
and equity is our guiding light in this
[10:47]
district. So, how would you think about
[10:49]
being data informed at the same time
[10:50]
that we're, you know,
[10:53]
um being human about the way that that
[10:56]
we approach our high needs population?
[10:58]
So, just like what sort of metrics and
[11:00]
data would you be looking for to make
[11:02]
sure that we're appropriating uh our
[11:05]
finances um to the to the kids who need
[11:08]
it the most?
[11:10]
» Yeah, I think um a key element for that
[11:12]
analysis has to be disagregating the
[11:14]
data. We have to understand um what is
[11:17]
the um the level of achievement not
[11:20]
necessarily as a district as a whole but
[11:22]
actually being able to be more nuanced
[11:25]
and be able to understand um are we
[11:28]
actually closing the gaps between the
[11:30]
different student subgroups. And then we
[11:32]
had to be a I will have to understand
[11:35]
basically what is that connection
[11:37]
between the uh prepundance of the those
[11:41]
subgroups where are they mostly located
[11:43]
or likely to be situated in the district
[11:46]
operationally and also in um in the
[11:49]
academic programming. So um I think the
[11:53]
metrics for me that um that I basically
[11:57]
drive when I understand district
[11:59]
decisions, it has to come to the dis the
[12:01]
segregated data and understanding what
[12:03]
are the programs that actually
[12:04]
supporting those particular groups that
[12:08]
are trailing the mainstream or trailing
[12:11]
the average of the district and what
[12:13]
where are the programs that actually are
[12:15]
helping to close that gap and to
[12:18]
accelerate learning. And so in an
[12:21]
environment which one is considering
[12:23]
either right sizing or sunsetting
[12:26]
programs that is kind of the metric that
[12:28]
I will be looking for the educational
[12:30]
outcomes for the particular groups that
[12:32]
we're interested in protecting.
[12:35]
» Thank you.
[12:42]
» All right. No further follow-ups on that
[12:44]
point. Member Cornell.
[12:47]
» We have the next question.
[12:49]
Uh the next question is uh Salem has
[12:52]
worked hard to build a culture of high
[12:53]
expectations for all students while also
[12:56]
offering strong college and career
[12:58]
pathways. How would you ensure students
[13:00]
experience a coherent educational
[13:02]
journey from elementary through high
[13:05]
school and graduate prepared graduates
[13:08]
prepared for co success in college
[13:10]
career and life? I'm sorry and graduate
[13:12]
prepared for co success in college
[13:14]
career and life.
[13:15]
» Yeah. Um thank you for the question. For
[13:18]
me the uh key term with that question is
[13:21]
coherence. And by coherence I mean that
[13:25]
when I think about a kindergarten
[13:28]
student who might be starting in the
[13:29]
fall in the and Sarah Parker Raman
[13:33]
school for example and when I think
[13:34]
about high school sale high school
[13:37]
student uh are they experiencing
[13:40]
educationally an alignment of um or
[13:44]
opportunities or are we just a district
[13:48]
that is basically a conglomerate of
[13:50]
disperate um experience. experiences
[13:53]
under the same name of uh Salem public
[13:56]
schools. So it is important that um I
[14:00]
see the coherency reflected by what
[14:03]
Selma has done with the uh portrait of
[14:06]
the graduate and the question for me
[14:08]
will be how is that portrait of the
[14:10]
graduate reflected in all vert
[14:13]
vertically in all the levels. Um, one
[14:17]
should be able to see that unfolding and
[14:21]
unpacking of those um, characteristic of
[14:24]
the posture of the graduate like
[14:25]
critical thinking, creative problem
[14:27]
solving, collaboration, communication,
[14:31]
self-awareness and cultural competence
[14:34]
from the early stages from um,
[14:37]
kindergarten, elementary and middle
[14:40]
school and so forth. It should not start
[14:43]
at ninth grade. which actually should
[14:45]
start in our levels. And um this
[14:49]
alignment of experiences
[14:51]
um is important to be able to provide
[14:55]
students with access to the core
[14:57]
curriculum and high standards. And also
[14:59]
going back to what I say about being
[15:01]
able to um experience a enrich locally
[15:06]
um informed educational uh curriculum
[15:10]
and also to prepare them for the global
[15:13]
economy and all the um future readiness
[15:15]
that we're asking students to be ready.
[15:17]
So going back to the question, I mean I
[15:20]
think the the key thing is coherence and
[15:23]
what we should be able to see that
[15:25]
elements of that coherence throughout
[15:27]
vertically in all the levels
[15:36]
follow-up questions.
[15:41]
» I'm just gonna say yes every time.
[15:43]
» Okay. Member Cornell. Um, so just to
[15:46]
drill down a little bit more on that,
[15:48]
I'm wondering if you could talk about
[15:50]
how you will work with teachers to
[15:56]
assess whether or not we we are being
[15:59]
coherent, right? Um, with our
[16:01]
expectations and our follow through um
[16:04]
and also ensuring high standards while
[16:07]
we're doing that. And I think that also
[16:08]
goes back to our the first question
[16:10]
about our um you know about equity and
[16:14]
making sure that our most marginalized
[16:15]
students are getting the most having
[16:17]
those h how you assess that and how you
[16:19]
work with teachers to kind of make sure
[16:21]
we're on track.
[16:23]
» Yeah, I think you know definitely um
[16:25]
with the educational data that we have
[16:28]
that is to ensure that um that the
[16:32]
educational programming is actually
[16:33]
yielding the resource that we're looking
[16:35]
for. For example, here um in Salem um
[16:39]
you know it's it's remarkable the growth
[16:42]
that we have seen with former English
[16:44]
learners. Uh personally um in my current
[16:47]
district I I participated in um in tried
[16:51]
to introduce datainformed
[16:54]
uh meetings regarding uh English
[16:56]
learners uh in the sense of you know a
[16:59]
kind of a variation of multi-ter systems
[17:02]
of support in which we're using data to
[17:04]
inform our educational moves and
[17:06]
instructional practices.
[17:09]
um is not too much about remediation a
[17:13]
mindset of remediation but it's a
[17:15]
mindset of what do we need to provide at
[17:18]
the student at the right time uh at the
[17:20]
right moment um so that the data inform
[17:26]
instructional decisions is something
[17:28]
that I will be looking as a
[17:29]
superintendent and hopefully in um in
[17:32]
different spaces there will be evidence
[17:35]
that educators we are using that not as
[17:38]
the only solution or the only aspect but
[17:42]
that is actually partially informing our
[17:45]
decision aside from understanding the uh
[17:48]
context of the different students. So I
[17:50]
think um going back to data on and
[17:53]
seeing every year how we closing those
[17:56]
gaps. For example, Salem has done
[17:59]
remarkable in um their student growth.
[18:02]
You know, even though that our prof our
[18:05]
achievement um levels have not caught up
[18:07]
yet, we know that research shows that
[18:10]
sustained
[18:12]
um increase in growth will actually pay
[18:15]
off or show off with achievement. So um
[18:19]
to your question about how we'll ensure
[18:21]
that that is happening in classrooms and
[18:24]
in schools. I think by having by
[18:27]
listening and observing conversations in
[18:29]
which educators are using data to inform
[18:33]
their conversations.
[18:43]
» Um member bias you have the next
[18:44]
question. Can we get prepared first?
[18:49]
» Hello. So, I'm going to be asking my
[18:52]
question in Spanish and I just want to
[18:53]
thank the interpreter here for helping
[18:55]
us tonight.
[18:57]
Let me know when you guys are ready.
[19:04]
Okay.
[19:08]
Okay.
[19:12]
andific.
[19:42]
Army
[19:59]
parame
[20:16]
experience.
[20:26]
Um,
[20:34]
collabor. Fore
[21:02]
being inch.
[21:21]
Um,
[21:22]
in closing, I would like to say this in
[21:24]
English for everyone to have access to
[21:26]
it. I think the goal is for Salem to be
[21:30]
a district where everyone feels that
[21:32]
they belong.
[21:35]
Gracias.
[21:36]
» Gracias.
[21:44]
» Any follow-ups?
[21:48]
No.
[21:51]
Um, member Hoffman,
[21:59]
» Tell us about your experience supporting
[22:01]
students who face significant barriers
[22:03]
to success, including students from
[22:05]
marginalized communities and those at
[22:07]
risk of disengagement. How would you
[22:10]
ensure Salem's systems identify needs
[22:14]
early and provide effective support?
[22:18]
Early
[22:20]
identification
[22:22]
is the name of the game is the most
[22:26]
important aspect for me. Um
[22:30]
in one of my previous um districts or
[22:34]
actually schools
[22:36]
um educators had access to a system that
[22:38]
via email any educator in the team could
[22:42]
actually communicate with the entire
[22:43]
group when there was any uh reason for
[22:47]
concern.
[22:48]
Uh it didn't have to be a crisis. It
[22:50]
just was just a concern. Um for example,
[22:53]
in my case as a language um educator, if
[22:56]
I had a concern about a particular
[22:58]
student, I will just email the group of
[23:01]
adults. Um this is what I'm seeing. This
[23:04]
is I'm wondering and likely the
[23:06]
counselor which as as a part of that
[23:08]
group will reach out to me. I will try
[23:10]
to understand better what I have seen or
[23:13]
heard from the student or uh regarding
[23:16]
the student performance and then they
[23:18]
may share with me a little more context
[23:20]
so I can understand um what is the
[23:23]
reality of the student and what could be
[23:25]
the factors um in playing into that.
[23:28]
That system might seem really small but
[23:31]
it's something that I had taken
[23:32]
throughout my career in the sense that a
[23:36]
concern we should not let a concern
[23:38]
become a crisis and sometimes we
[23:41]
formalize
[23:43]
alert systems. Um yes they are designed
[23:47]
to capture those moments but if we could
[23:50]
also normalize more frequent more less
[23:54]
formal in a way kind of informal way or
[23:57]
letting other adults in the group on the
[24:00]
team kind of know we will be able to
[24:02]
kind of close that gap between a concern
[24:05]
and a crisis. I think that when a
[24:08]
student disengages in multiple
[24:10]
disciplines, we have missed the mark. We
[24:14]
should try to respond early and try to
[24:17]
um access and and um provide that
[24:20]
support from the early stages.
[24:33]
» Member Cornell.
[24:36]
Thank you. I'm wondering um if you could
[24:39]
talk about how you will work with
[24:43]
teachers, you know, the people who are
[24:44]
really on the ground to ensure that
[24:48]
we're not leaving students behind. Sort
[24:50]
of what is your leadership look like in
[24:52]
that regard? Um or how do you expect to
[24:55]
engage with teachers to kind of make
[24:56]
sure that everybody is prioritizing the
[24:59]
same things?
[25:01]
» Yeah. Um I mean obviously I mean there
[25:03]
are there are structures in schools like
[25:06]
um student student support and teams um
[25:09]
data meetings also um at the building
[25:12]
level that might bring up some of those
[25:15]
conversations.
[25:16]
Um personally currently in my district
[25:19]
what we are working in what we call
[25:21]
relationship mapping which is basically
[25:23]
just a tool in which we are trying to
[25:25]
account for every student making sure
[25:29]
that they have at least a trusted adult.
[25:32]
is not too much on the student
[25:34]
perception of having an adult but
[25:36]
actually matching the stu the adult or
[25:40]
the teacher perception or of how they
[25:43]
connect with a particular student. So
[25:46]
we're trying to in that way kind of
[25:48]
survey the landscape identify where we
[25:51]
had gaps identify the students that have
[25:53]
not been quote unquote claimed by any
[25:56]
adult and then act as okay let's
[25:59]
understand who can be that trusted
[26:01]
adult. um so that so that the student is
[26:04]
connected. A lot of times those uh gaps
[26:07]
or holes in my current practice they
[26:10]
happen to be new students, new transfer
[26:12]
students that are new to the community.
[26:15]
But also it kind of when we look at the
[26:18]
aggregate data in those that that kind
[26:20]
of practice it tell us a little bit
[26:22]
about our practices and our about
[26:25]
internal biases regarding why students
[26:29]
need connections and why students don't
[26:31]
need connections. So that is a very uh
[26:35]
it's a small tool that's a daily
[26:37]
practice but that is how currently we're
[26:40]
trying to remind our staff members of
[26:43]
the important of connections and
[26:45]
hopefully those connections will allow
[26:47]
us to have those identification as I
[26:49]
mentioned in my previous question and
[26:52]
then also be able to tackle a concern
[26:54]
before it becomes a crisis.
[27:05]
Okay. Um, next question is mine. Um,
[27:11]
Dr. Allen, school districts across
[27:12]
Massachusetts face significant fiscal
[27:15]
challenges. Tell us about your approach
[27:17]
to budgeting and resource allocation and
[27:19]
share an example of how you've navigated
[27:22]
a period of financial constraint.
[27:25]
Yeah, as I mentioned, I mean, uh, budget
[27:27]
is a value statement document. Um,
[27:32]
in my experience, you know, um, as a
[27:35]
department head, as a district director,
[27:39]
um, I had an a situation in which, um,
[27:42]
because of FD reductions, we had to look
[27:45]
at, um, you know, cuts in the, uh, high
[27:49]
school programming.
[27:51]
um the cuts could have impacted the
[27:54]
Chinese language program uh in my
[27:57]
particular setting. Um, two of the key
[28:01]
drivers going back to what I mentioned
[28:04]
at the beginning about looking at
[28:06]
budget, looking at finances, looking at
[28:08]
impact from an equity lens was to
[28:11]
appreciate the fact that our middle
[28:14]
schools offer Spanish and French.
[28:17]
Whereas um the only exposure or access
[28:20]
to Chinese was actually at the high
[28:22]
school level.
[28:24]
the Chinese lang language program in
[28:26]
this particular district actually
[28:28]
represent was a statement of value
[28:30]
because it it represented a significant
[28:33]
portion of the demographic of the
[28:36]
community. So that was one equity
[28:39]
consideration.
[28:40]
The second equity consideration was that
[28:43]
for students that have not found success
[28:47]
in French or Spanish at the middle
[28:48]
school, uh having access to a different
[28:51]
language, uh a very different language
[28:54]
from the Romans languages of French and
[28:55]
Spanish actually offer an opportunity to
[28:59]
try again to reset and not lose that
[29:02]
confidence of them becoming um language
[29:05]
learners.
[29:07]
Um the importance of small programs at
[29:11]
the high school for example is that they
[29:13]
tend to only have one teacher. So the
[29:15]
students actually were um exposed or uh
[29:20]
actually working with one educator for
[29:21]
four years. So it created a level of
[29:24]
safety that we were not being able to
[29:26]
provide with the larger uh language
[29:29]
programs. Again this is a decision that
[29:32]
was not popular is not intuitive. Um and
[29:37]
it's um it's the kind of decisions that
[29:40]
one has to make and one has to own and
[29:43]
be able to also absorb the negativity
[29:45]
that will come that may come with the
[29:47]
decision and not pass it to the the rest
[29:51]
of the team or the rest of the staff
[29:53]
because I believe that that's part of
[29:54]
the being a servant leader to also be
[29:58]
able to understand that there will be a
[30:00]
price to be paid by decisions that had
[30:02]
to be made but as long as one is
[30:04]
transparent about what is the guiding
[30:05]
principle in this case the two equity
[30:08]
considerations
[30:10]
um at least there's an understanding
[30:13]
even though that people might not agree
[30:15]
about the the execution of the plan when
[30:18]
when I scale out envisioning what
[30:20]
happens at the district level it's kind
[30:22]
of the same being led by the same
[30:25]
principles uh understanding what will be
[30:28]
the impact of the cut or the budget
[30:31]
change depending on the um the
[30:34]
challenges of the budget and to ask
[30:37]
ourselves about are there other ways to
[30:40]
protect those vulnerable students and
[30:42]
and families. Are there other services
[30:44]
that comparable to that uh and it's not
[30:46]
just an exercise of balancing numbers um
[30:51]
even though that that's is you know
[30:53]
obviously going to be present in those
[30:55]
discussions.
[31:00]
» Stop.
[31:02]
» Thank you. Um
[31:04]
I I had two quick questions actually.
[31:06]
The first question was so the the
[31:08]
example that you provided with the
[31:09]
Chinese language program. Were you able
[31:11]
to keep that program or did you have to
[31:14]
no longer have that program in the
[31:15]
district?
[31:16]
» Yeah. So the specifics is that the there
[31:18]
were some retirements happening in in in
[31:21]
Spanish and also they we had a teacher
[31:23]
that could actually teach both languages
[31:26]
French and Spanish. So we were able to
[31:28]
kind of like swing that person to
[31:30]
support the not refilling the uh or
[31:34]
replacing retirements in the Spanish
[31:36]
program to be able to have enough FTEEs
[31:38]
to be able to maintain the Chinese
[31:40]
language teacher at that moment. So
[31:43]
obviously by doing that class sizes
[31:45]
increased you know this uh expectation
[31:48]
like why you doing this I mean these are
[31:50]
the most of our students are in Spanish
[31:52]
and French they are now being served by
[31:55]
these decisions but there was the equity
[31:57]
consideration that I mentioned in my
[31:59]
answer about this is the only space
[32:01]
where a significant number of families
[32:04]
see reflected and also it's important
[32:08]
because otherwise we will be narrowing
[32:10]
the language options for students that
[32:13]
may not have seen success at at the
[32:14]
middle school level.
[32:16]
» Thank you for closing that loop for me.
[32:18]
» Um and then just a question about the
[32:21]
the budget communication in in general.
[32:24]
Um you know it happens every year,
[32:26]
right? We all know what's coming and so
[32:28]
I'm curious as to what your your
[32:31]
philosophy is with communication of the
[32:33]
budget to you know the different groups
[32:35]
that we have. So staff um families
[32:39]
students even sometimes like how is that
[32:42]
all communi or what's your philosophy of
[32:44]
communicating that out and working with
[32:45]
the other groups? Yeah, I think it comes
[32:48]
back to what I have said in in some of
[32:50]
the answers uh before
[32:53]
just remind the community about the
[32:55]
guiding principles. I mean they are
[32:57]
budget drivers you know the you know
[32:59]
that actually are f more financial in
[33:02]
nature but also they should be a
[33:04]
reminder to the community about the
[33:06]
guiding principles so that when we start
[33:10]
um having discussions
[33:12]
the preemptively we have the we have
[33:14]
shared with the community and with the
[33:15]
stakeholders what will be the equity
[33:17]
consideration that we'll be using for
[33:20]
those decisions. Um I mean budgets um I
[33:24]
would assume if it's similar to my
[33:26]
previous districts I mean they basically
[33:29]
start early in the fall. I mean when we
[33:31]
start looking at at those um anticipated
[33:35]
um sizes of revenues um we might
[33:38]
anticipate any shortfall from the very
[33:40]
beginning. We start asking programmatic
[33:42]
questions at the at the academic council
[33:45]
level we call it which is basically all
[33:47]
the department heads and principals and
[33:49]
directors. And then the equity question
[33:51]
will be always the the equity probe that
[33:54]
those conversations will be um will be
[33:58]
used is who are these who are the
[34:01]
families and students that will be
[34:02]
impacted? how uh can we protect them and
[34:06]
are other uh alternatives where students
[34:09]
can still have access to the same
[34:11]
educational outcomes that we wanted to
[34:13]
provide for these other programs. the I
[34:16]
think with with um staff I think given
[34:20]
the declining enrollment that we're
[34:22]
having across the state and even in a
[34:24]
way the country I mean that's a it's a
[34:26]
reality that communities are facing we
[34:29]
have to be also be cognizant of the
[34:31]
impact that immigration enforcement is
[34:33]
having in in a number of our communities
[34:35]
because it's impacting our enrollment so
[34:38]
I think the more that we let people
[34:40]
preemptively know what are the factors
[34:43]
that are going to be at Okay.
[34:46]
Is not going to alleviate the discomfort
[34:49]
and the frustration but at least will
[34:53]
allow people to see transparently what
[34:57]
was the framework and the thinking
[34:58]
behind the decisions.
[35:02]
» Thank you.
[35:05]
» Any further follow-ups? Member Cornell.
[35:10]
As a body, we really value our
[35:12]
relationships with our collective
[35:13]
bargaining units and uh you know, the
[35:16]
Salem Teachers Union is the biggest
[35:17]
collective bargaining unit and is is the
[35:19]
one most impacted when we have uh budget
[35:21]
deficits. And we rely on the the
[35:25]
superintendent to be that bridge between
[35:27]
the Salem teachers union and the school
[35:29]
committee both in the buildup to the
[35:31]
budget process and and um and in the
[35:34]
negotiation process as well which is
[35:37]
dependent on budgets obviously but um so
[35:40]
that as you know is an important job of
[35:42]
school committee of the um the
[35:44]
superintendent. So, I'm I'm wondering
[35:46]
how how you'll negotiate that role of of
[35:53]
um you know, being that liaison between
[35:56]
us and and the the school commit or the
[35:59]
um the teachers union uh preparing them
[36:03]
for uh potential deficits, you know, how
[36:07]
do you see that relationship evolving as
[36:09]
you as you get into the job?
[36:12]
Yeah, that's a great question and I I
[36:15]
have to admit that in my experience I
[36:17]
have not seen the perfect way to do it.
[36:22]
I mean I just want to be honest about
[36:23]
that. I think it's always uh hope that
[36:26]
there will be some kind of um
[36:30]
anticipated communication that will uh
[36:33]
avoid that sense of shock and
[36:36]
frustration that comes and at the same
[36:38]
time the um
[36:42]
the sometimes the details of knowing
[36:44]
exactly how a reduction will impact a
[36:48]
specific employees or in specific number
[36:51]
of FDs is always uh a tricky uh act to
[36:55]
navigate. I will say that bringing back
[36:58]
everything I have said, I mean I will I
[37:00]
will assume that Salem compared to other
[37:03]
districts will have routine
[37:05]
conversations with leadership. I I I am
[37:08]
currently part of those leadership um
[37:11]
you know once a month every you know
[37:13]
twice a month uh communications and
[37:15]
engagement and one of the guiding
[37:18]
principle is let's try to avoid
[37:20]
surprises
[37:22]
uh let's try to at least as much as we
[37:24]
can you know giving our different roles
[37:27]
um to be able to kind of give a heads up
[37:30]
and and try to also be open to um
[37:36]
to different perspectives. I think what
[37:39]
I would I would hope if it's possible to
[37:42]
bring is a space and a time where uh
[37:46]
decisions have not been made and
[37:48]
decisions can actually um entertain
[37:52]
multiple perspectives because budget can
[37:54]
give you a sense of where the gaps are
[37:57]
but the stories and perspectives are the
[37:59]
ones that actually will inform you about
[38:02]
the impact. So on the one hand as I'm
[38:04]
holding the kind of the primordia
[38:07]
principle for me of understanding the
[38:10]
impact and making sure that the impact
[38:11]
is not falling on the most vulnerable to
[38:14]
really of be able to understand that
[38:16]
impact uh requires engagement with uh
[38:20]
the teach association with other um you
[38:23]
know uh units of the um the collective
[38:26]
bargaining agreement uh because those
[38:29]
are the stories that really inform what
[38:31]
just the numbers are kind of like
[38:33]
leading us to to focus on
[38:43]
member Miranda.
[38:48]
» How do you balance supporting principles
[38:51]
and school leaders with holding them
[38:53]
accountable when student outcomes,
[38:55]
school climate, or equity goals are not
[38:57]
being consistently met?
[39:00]
» Thank you for the question. Uh I would
[39:03]
like to start by saying that I don't see
[39:06]
um support and accountability as
[39:09]
mutually exclusive you know
[39:11]
propositions.
[39:13]
I actually see them as basically the two
[39:16]
halves of one situation.
[39:19]
Um
[39:21]
it is not fair to hold any any educator
[39:24]
accountable for um goals that we have
[39:29]
not spend the time explaining
[39:32]
and providing resources and coaching um
[39:35]
the educators to be able to execute that
[39:37]
plan when adults you know basically um
[39:42]
adults are just grownup students. So the
[39:44]
same thing that that we face sometimes
[39:47]
in the classroom in be able to kind of
[39:49]
manage um changes it also happens with
[39:53]
adults. When adults tend to face or tend
[39:57]
to react in a reactive way, an
[39:59]
oppositional way is we have to be able
[40:02]
to slow down and appreciate and assess
[40:06]
if this is coming because of fear of not
[40:09]
knowing how to do it
[40:12]
and fear that if I don't know how to do
[40:15]
it, would I be fired? Would I lose my
[40:17]
job? Would I lose my standing? So it's
[40:20]
important that in the coaching of of
[40:23]
every um leader the superintendent is
[40:28]
getting close to that building leader or
[40:31]
that department leader or program leader
[40:33]
to uh to ensure that that leader
[40:36]
understands what the goal is about. that
[40:40]
that leader develops um a sense of what
[40:43]
kind of resources they might have to
[40:46]
provide to their staff in order for the
[40:48]
goal to be accomplished and that they
[40:51]
have time to believe in the goal. Uh
[40:55]
personally I you know bring it to the
[40:58]
educator level to to the educator level.
[41:02]
I had um a situation with a couple of
[41:04]
educators in which um I feel that we
[41:09]
provided coaching and support and
[41:10]
resources for extended period of time
[41:14]
and the educators were not able to uh
[41:16]
meet those goals. Um it was not
[41:20]
necessarily a lack of uh skills was not
[41:23]
really a lack of resources. It came down
[41:26]
to be a mismatch between
[41:30]
the district beliefs and the personal
[41:32]
beliefs of the educators.
[41:34]
Do I continue providing the coaching?
[41:38]
The uh the educators then came to the
[41:40]
point that they realized that it was not
[41:42]
going to be a match between what they
[41:45]
believe and there was no way they could
[41:46]
they could access the district goals. So
[41:49]
they in both cases they decided to uh
[41:51]
separate themselves from the from the
[41:53]
positions.
[41:54]
Um that's not really a failure of
[41:57]
accountability. It's actually
[41:59]
accountability h providing a little
[42:02]
dignity to allow professionals to come
[42:04]
to that realization when there's no way
[42:08]
that they can give up their personal
[42:11]
beliefs in order to align them with the
[42:13]
district beliefs. Um I I view that those
[42:17]
cases as exceptions rather than the
[42:19]
rules because educators normally come to
[42:22]
education because they really want to
[42:24]
make a difference in in students and
[42:26]
families.
[42:27]
Um so I think the same kind of um
[42:31]
pattern kind of works for a
[42:33]
superintendent working with building
[42:34]
levels building uh leaders in the sense
[42:37]
of ensuring that when a building leader
[42:42]
is not meeting the the standard is not
[42:45]
achieving the goal is not a question of
[42:48]
what's wrong with the leader but it's
[42:50]
actually an introspective question for a
[42:52]
superintendent to ask what why am I or
[42:55]
what are we not providing the leader
[42:57]
leader as far as coaching and support
[42:59]
for them to continue with that growth.
[43:02]
And I think it's important that uh
[43:05]
building leaders at the same time as a
[43:07]
superintendent, we have the patience and
[43:09]
the willingness to go through that
[43:11]
journey to go through that process and
[43:14]
and that we can provide some grace to
[43:16]
each other in that in that journey. Um,
[43:20]
and that it basically because that's the
[43:23]
same kind of modeling I would like for
[43:25]
them to share with their staff when
[43:27]
they're coaching classroom teachers as
[43:28]
well.
[43:39]
» Thank you. I really appreciated
[43:41]
appreciated that sentiment about um
[43:44]
you know looking at yourself you know as
[43:46]
a as the leader um and saying what am I
[43:48]
you know how how what am I not providing
[43:51]
you know doing doing a little personal
[43:53]
reflection that's um important in
[43:55]
leadership so um just to piggyback on
[43:58]
that I'm wondering what role or h how I
[44:04]
may not be saying this correctly because
[44:06]
I'm not a teacher but it's sort of how
[44:09]
how um
[44:11]
professional development
[44:14]
can be used to help to support teachers,
[44:17]
which is what it's for. But like how do
[44:19]
you view professional development um
[44:23]
as a you know as a tool to help give
[44:25]
give um our educators the support that
[44:28]
they need? What would your approach be
[44:30]
to professional development?
[44:31]
» Thank you. I appreciate the question. Um
[44:36]
I have maybe a little individual
[44:39]
perspective on this. I I believe the
[44:41]
professional development
[44:43]
at its best is when is more about
[44:46]
coaching and the the reason why I use
[44:48]
that those those terms in a distinctive
[44:51]
way is that sometimes professional
[44:53]
development sounds to educators as a one
[44:56]
shot check a box. Here we go. We taught
[44:59]
it. You should do it. And the same
[45:03]
analogy and extension of what I'm saying
[45:04]
like adults were just like grown-up
[45:06]
students is that there there's a
[45:09]
learning curve and the question is when
[45:11]
I'm learning the new skill in order for
[45:14]
the new task or goal that has been set
[45:18]
for the district or for the school
[45:21]
am I being able to share my my failures
[45:26]
and my small successes with someone? Am
[45:29]
I able to get feedback, timely feedback
[45:33]
so I can know how to improve? And so I
[45:36]
think for me professional development
[45:39]
that is really uh most effective is the
[45:42]
one that resembles coaching. So it's
[45:44]
like a sustained relationship
[45:48]
um throughout the the um learning the
[45:51]
new learning that educators are being
[45:53]
asked to to acquire rather than just one
[45:57]
presentation. an afterchool one or two
[46:00]
hour session.
[46:09]
» Uh, next question is member stop.
[46:12]
» Thank you. Salem has a strong foundation
[46:16]
and an ambitious future including a
[46:19]
transformative high school project that
[46:21]
will impact the community for
[46:23]
generations. What should Salem schools
[46:25]
look like 10 years from now? And how can
[46:27]
the superintendent ensure that long-term
[46:29]
investments remain educationally sound,
[46:32]
fiscally responsible, and responsive to
[46:34]
community needs?
[46:36]
» Yeah, thank you. Um
[46:41]
the buildings and infrastructures that
[46:44]
those are the easy part. I think the the
[46:47]
real um core of the enterprise is
[46:52]
actually the program and the vision
[46:54]
inside the building. Um it's important
[46:57]
that our capital investments or
[47:00]
infrastructure investments are a
[47:02]
reflection of our educational vision,
[47:06]
not the other way around.
[47:08]
Um it's important that that we find ways
[47:13]
to include the key um comm school
[47:17]
community me uh members who are
[47:20]
basically the educators and students not
[47:24]
just in the planning phase um but also
[47:27]
in the implementation phase so that our
[47:30]
initiatives have um
[47:33]
vibrancy and currency as we implement
[47:38]
Um my job is to ensure that a for
[47:43]
example in the case of the um future
[47:45]
high school that the uh future the
[47:48]
future high school maintains the uh
[47:51]
educational programming that Salem
[47:53]
values and that is actually is a place
[47:56]
where there's a ocean of opportunities
[47:58]
for students.
[48:00]
Um it is important that the three
[48:04]
elements that I heard from the students
[48:05]
when I met with them that they love
[48:07]
about Sale High are preserved and
[48:10]
actually uh better resource the regular
[48:14]
high school programming
[48:16]
their uh vocational pathways
[48:19]
uh and also something that I I learned
[48:21]
in talking to the high school principal
[48:23]
is about your robust uh early college u
[48:26]
programming as well. So um it's
[48:30]
important to keep that currency that we
[48:34]
are always asking ourselves if these
[48:36]
investments are the um in in service
[48:41]
with educational vision and that um we
[48:44]
constantly find ways to for any capital
[48:48]
improvement to actually reflect those
[48:50]
educational goals and visions that we we
[48:52]
have set for the for the community.
[49:03]
and we're stopp
[49:04]
Thank you. Um I would love to unpack a
[49:06]
little more if you don't mind the
[49:08]
response about educators and students
[49:10]
need to be involved in not just the
[49:11]
implementation but the the planning
[49:13]
process and the um you know the the
[49:16]
before we get to the end part. How do
[49:18]
you envision that happening or what has
[49:20]
worked for you in the past with making
[49:22]
sure those voices are heard?
[49:24]
» Right.
[49:26]
um
[49:29]
in any new construction. I mean I'm I'm
[49:31]
focusing on the on the building of the
[49:33]
new high school. I anticipate that with
[49:35]
rising costs with uh unanticipated
[49:39]
challenges that the construction may
[49:41]
face that we have not been able to to um
[49:45]
protect or forecast with the finances
[49:47]
that there will be decisions that will
[49:48]
have to be made. So I think it's
[49:49]
important with educators and students
[49:52]
that uh the superintendent creates a
[49:54]
list of the non-negotiables of the most
[49:57]
haves and the other a second list of the
[50:02]
in case we need to cut something because
[50:04]
of rising costs or any external
[50:06]
challenges that we could live without.
[50:09]
If the educational programming is one,
[50:12]
let's say that uh fosters maker spaces
[50:16]
and and innovation or and spaces where
[50:19]
students can actually integrate a lot of
[50:21]
the STEM um knowledge and and um create
[50:26]
projects. I mean, do we have those wide
[50:29]
open spaces to allow that more agnostic
[50:32]
spaces opposed to just um subject bound
[50:36]
spaces? And I think in in creating those
[50:39]
master lists of the we're going to try
[50:42]
to protect this at all cost and these
[50:45]
are the ones that if needed that
[50:48]
students and educators have been part of
[50:50]
that of those conversations because I
[50:52]
think the last thing that we want is to
[50:54]
have a final product that the the school
[50:57]
community did not feel that their voices
[51:01]
were represented or honored uh through
[51:03]
the project.
[51:13]
member Cornell.
[51:16]
» So, we've
[51:18]
we've had a lot to think about with
[51:20]
regard to infrastructure in the past few
[51:22]
years, as I'm sure you probably know.
[51:24]
So, we, you know, we've consolidated
[51:26]
middle schools, we've consolidated
[51:28]
schools, um we've moved some some two
[51:32]
programs into another school. Uh so
[51:35]
going forward, we have a lot to think
[51:36]
about. I think particularly around preK.
[51:39]
Um even though our enrollment numbers
[51:40]
are are good, we're in good shape
[51:43]
relative to other districts. You know,
[51:44]
we still need to think about that um
[51:46]
birth rate cliff, you know, going
[51:48]
forward. So thinking about buildings is,
[51:52]
I don't think something that any of us
[51:54]
love to think about, but it's something
[51:55]
we really have to think about. So um I'd
[51:58]
love to know
[52:00]
it. It is a day one job. is really
[52:03]
thinking about the infrastructure. So,
[52:05]
I'd like to know um kind of what your
[52:09]
approach would be to to really thinking
[52:12]
about what's in our portfolio of
[52:13]
buildings um and how we how do we how do
[52:16]
we utilize them? You spoke to it a
[52:17]
little bit um but there's also like
[52:20]
there's a lot of practicality to it, you
[52:23]
know. So, I'm just wondering kind of
[52:24]
like how you would jump in and and start
[52:27]
thinking about literal buildings, you
[52:30]
know?
[52:32]
That's a great question and I I'm not
[52:34]
sure if I'll be able to answer the
[52:35]
question because of not knowing more the
[52:37]
specifics.
[52:39]
Um,
[52:44]
» There's a good chance I didn't ask it
[52:45]
very well. So,
[52:46]
» No, no, no, no, no. I guess it's just is
[52:48]
it's a reflection more of my lack of
[52:51]
understand my lack of knowledge already
[52:54]
of the um details and nuances that you
[52:57]
might expecting the superintendent to
[53:00]
kind of know at this point. Um
[53:04]
» So
[53:06]
» My question may be
[53:07]
» How how are you going to get into it
[53:11]
because we won't expect you to know on
[53:12]
the first day but kind of like how are
[53:14]
you going to jump into this and try to
[53:15]
tackle it? Ah, okay.
[53:19]
Uh, in my experience, building
[53:22]
conversations have always been um a
[53:25]
multi-year, very long conversations. And
[53:28]
I think it's important for a um a public
[53:32]
school system to have an uh a vision of
[53:37]
not necessarily the decay of buildings
[53:40]
where but we start getting the warning
[53:42]
signs that the infrastructure is might
[53:45]
not be yielding a safe or uh educational
[53:50]
educationally
[53:51]
conducive environment.
[53:54]
and and I in my experience that at at
[53:58]
the first signs of those things that's
[53:59]
when we I guess our partner this time
[54:02]
will partner with the mayor to try to
[54:04]
understand what are the um the city's um
[54:08]
list of priorities and how where will
[54:11]
that stack up in their punchline of
[54:14]
projects and things that they have to to
[54:16]
um assess.
[54:19]
Um for example in my current community
[54:22]
there has been a lot of conversations
[54:23]
about AC because of given the extreme
[54:27]
weather that we have been experiencing
[54:29]
and which is based on science is not
[54:32]
it's not going to get any better anytime
[54:34]
soon. Um those conversations are also
[54:38]
multi-year conversations. So I think as
[54:42]
a superintendent the first thing one
[54:44]
should do is to visit the sites and
[54:46]
spend time in the sites.
[54:50]
um really get to um walk the building
[54:54]
from the principal perspective to
[54:57]
understand where those um
[55:01]
infrastructure niches are are already
[55:04]
showing signs of distress and then um be
[55:09]
able to start understanding the economic
[55:13]
and financial relationship between the
[55:14]
schools and the city to be able to
[55:16]
understand where will they fall in the
[55:18]
list of either repairs or replacement or
[55:22]
new project if needed. So I my short
[55:26]
answer to the question at this point I
[55:28]
will say the superintendent needs to
[55:30]
spend a lot of time visiting the sites
[55:32]
and really stand spending time with the
[55:33]
principles to understand what is
[55:36]
happening in those schools.
[55:41]
» Other follow-ups on that question? Uh I
[55:44]
just have a a quick one. So you you
[55:46]
talked about we talked about the future
[55:49]
perspective of capital facilities and
[55:51]
buildings, but so zooming out 10 years
[55:54]
down the road, um what does the district
[55:56]
look like from an achievement
[55:58]
perspective or a culture perspective to
[56:00]
your mind?
[56:01]
Yeah, I think 10 years from now, I would
[56:05]
like to see Salem
[56:08]
be a place where we have definitely
[56:11]
moved the needle regarding achievement
[56:14]
uh according to state benchmarks with
[56:16]
MCCAST proficiency and so forth. I will
[56:20]
I will vision a district that is
[56:23]
actually graduating students that have a
[56:27]
strong
[56:30]
threeprong approach. They have a solid
[56:33]
high school a regular high school
[56:35]
curriculum exposure. they have a a
[56:38]
vibrant exposure to vocational uh and
[56:42]
technical uh pathways and also uh
[56:45]
students that have been able if they so
[56:48]
wish to uh access early college
[56:51]
opportunities.
[56:53]
I would like to see a district like
[56:57]
Salem really embracing their assets
[57:00]
being multicultural and multilingual
[57:04]
in the sense of um equipping the
[57:06]
students to be ready globally and by
[57:09]
that I mean that every Salem student to
[57:13]
graduate being proficient in at least
[57:16]
two languages.
[57:19]
um we have a robust Spanish um program
[57:22]
and we have a a dual language program
[57:25]
and I think that there's uh a lot of
[57:27]
promise in those practices and I would
[57:29]
like to see how that could extend
[57:32]
vertically on both ways. I mean even I
[57:34]
would like to understand more about the
[57:36]
prek opportunities in dual language if
[57:39]
if we don't offer them yet and what how
[57:41]
would that look like if we sustain the
[57:43]
growth in secondary. I would like to see
[57:46]
a student that feels that sale prepare
[57:49]
them to be effective contributors in
[57:54]
anywhere around the globe because of in
[57:58]
sale they experience diversity. They
[58:00]
understand uh different stories that
[58:03]
this community holds and and that the
[58:06]
educational preparation have given them
[58:09]
the tools to be effective in in our
[58:12]
economy.
[58:19]
Member Miranda,
[58:23]
» Describe a time when feedback from
[58:26]
families, staff, or community members
[58:29]
caused you to rethink your initial
[58:31]
approach to an issue. How did you
[58:33]
communicate your decision? And what did
[58:35]
the experience teach you about
[58:37]
leadership?
[58:40]
Yeah, I think that um
[58:43]
I'm going to offer an example because I
[58:46]
think that trust um needs to be earned
[58:50]
or demonstrated, not just described. Um
[58:54]
when I started in my in one of my
[58:56]
previous um districts,
[58:58]
um the the world language program was
[59:01]
undergoing a uh changing at the middle
[59:04]
school level. Um there was actually has
[59:08]
there was a consolidation from three
[59:10]
languages to just one language. Um and
[59:13]
then I was kind of thrown into this uh
[59:16]
environment uh when I was hired. Um the
[59:21]
the language that was chosen for the
[59:22]
middle school was Spanish. So the
[59:24]
community was um kind of upset when they
[59:28]
saw me, a black Hispanic coming as a
[59:30]
world language department head. they um
[59:32]
in their minds they were connecting the
[59:34]
dots that okay they want to institute
[59:37]
only Spanish and they bring a Hispanic
[59:40]
um educator to kind of run the program.
[59:43]
Um the feedback was like so
[59:48]
um emotional and negative that we had to
[59:52]
offer a a a evening forum to the from
[59:55]
some of the families. um in that evening
[59:57]
forum um families was expressing a lot
[1:00:00]
of frustration. Um and something that I
[1:00:04]
did said to them is that I come to
[1:00:08]
education and to this administrative
[1:00:11]
roles as a public servant that I don't
[1:00:14]
come to this role thinking I'm I'm the
[1:00:17]
expert who's going to bring solutions
[1:00:19]
that the community have not even asked
[1:00:21]
for.
[1:00:23]
um in that public service stance. I I
[1:00:26]
asked them for some grace to allow me
[1:00:28]
time to sit with the dilemma with the
[1:00:31]
feedback I was hearing from them with
[1:00:33]
the consolation that has been done at
[1:00:35]
least for one year by the time of my
[1:00:38]
arrival for me to understand what are
[1:00:40]
the forces that led to that
[1:00:43]
consolidation and and what is the impact
[1:00:46]
that that is having on families and
[1:00:48]
students. Um after
[1:00:52]
leaving being honest to that and
[1:00:54]
upholding that promise uh we were able
[1:00:57]
to reinstate French into the middle
[1:01:00]
school program. Um so then the program
[1:01:03]
was designed to have two languages
[1:01:04]
instead of just one. We I was not able
[1:01:07]
to um bring back Latin in the way
[1:01:09]
families have uh hope.
[1:01:12]
uh in order to maintain that promise, I
[1:01:15]
I I I really uh tried to keep a vibrant
[1:01:18]
Latin program at the high school. Um
[1:01:20]
that was kind of like my
[1:01:24]
evidence of holding that promise. And um
[1:01:27]
and I just communicated to um families
[1:01:32]
that while I could not
[1:01:36]
deliver over all the the expectations
[1:01:39]
that I did stay open to be humble and
[1:01:45]
listen to the perspective and understand
[1:01:47]
their perspectives and try to remediate
[1:01:49]
that as much as possible. So I think
[1:01:52]
that um I think that's an example on
[1:01:55]
when um you know when negative feedback
[1:01:59]
comes one one's way is to write is to
[1:02:03]
really sit in that place of humility and
[1:02:06]
be able to open up the conversation.
[1:02:09]
uh to be able to um not have so much
[1:02:14]
pride into a specific outcome but be
[1:02:17]
able to be humble and be able to change
[1:02:20]
course if the information the new
[1:02:22]
information that it comes to one kind of
[1:02:25]
um informs that it was basically a bad
[1:02:28]
decision at the beginning. So that's my
[1:02:31]
example of how I I try to build trust in
[1:02:34]
in challenging situations.
[1:02:44]
follow-up questions.
[1:02:46]
Member Cornell.
[1:02:49]
» So, I appreciate that uh
[1:02:54]
um noting humility and and and being
[1:02:56]
able to to reflect before reacting. Uh
[1:02:59]
that's that's um important. I'm
[1:03:01]
wondering how will you establish regular
[1:03:05]
lines of communication with different
[1:03:08]
groups whether that's families um
[1:03:11]
educators community partners kids when
[1:03:15]
there's not a crisis. of the the
[1:03:18]
everyday communicating.
[1:03:21]
» Yeah. I think that communication similar
[1:03:24]
to equity is not a um
[1:03:29]
is is really a commitment to to
[1:03:32]
structures that will allow for um
[1:03:37]
genuine engagement and as you said not
[1:03:40]
to engage when a situation is a crisis.
[1:03:44]
Um something that I learned from the um
[1:03:46]
sale high school students is that
[1:03:47]
there's a superintendent council with
[1:03:50]
students and they were describing how
[1:03:53]
even they have elementary school
[1:03:55]
students and that really uh blew my mind
[1:03:58]
because of um having the the be able to
[1:04:01]
visualize not just the typical reaching
[1:04:03]
out to high school students because
[1:04:05]
they're older mature or maybe to an
[1:04:08]
extent the middle school students but I
[1:04:09]
Salem is intentional in trying to even
[1:04:12]
include when it's developmentally
[1:04:13]
approach appropriate, you know, students
[1:04:15]
perspective on on conversations. As I
[1:04:18]
mentioned in one of my previous um
[1:04:20]
answers
[1:04:21]
um visiting with the community, visiting
[1:04:24]
not always waiting for the community to
[1:04:26]
come to the schools who actually
[1:04:29]
understanding where are the regular
[1:04:31]
points of u meetings, where are the um
[1:04:34]
regular spaces and ways that that people
[1:04:37]
communicate uh regularly and to not be a
[1:04:40]
stranger to try to to come to
[1:04:44]
I I I had a meeting with a group of um
[1:04:46]
families recently in which I told them
[1:04:49]
that I was valuing frequent
[1:04:51]
communication and not crisis
[1:04:53]
communication by sharing with the
[1:04:56]
community even if they're just nuggets
[1:04:58]
doesn't have to be a big news doesn't
[1:05:01]
have to be a resolve issue but like
[1:05:04]
welcoming um you know really welcoming
[1:05:08]
community partners as partners not as
[1:05:12]
guests you know when it's a school event
[1:05:14]
or something like that. So, um I think
[1:05:19]
that is really looking at what we have
[1:05:23]
as regular practices and making sure
[1:05:25]
that those those regular practices of
[1:05:28]
meeting with different uh constituencies
[1:05:31]
um have covered the ones especially the
[1:05:35]
ones of the communities I mentioned that
[1:05:37]
are more vulnerable and less visible. Um
[1:05:40]
in addition to that I I feel it's
[1:05:42]
important to have a portfolio of um
[1:05:46]
media not just always expect the evening
[1:05:49]
in person meeting but also to be able to
[1:05:51]
acknowledge and recognize that some
[1:05:54]
working families some um families that
[1:05:58]
are that is hard almost impossible for
[1:06:01]
them to come in per to come in person to
[1:06:04]
a evening event that they may need uh
[1:06:07]
communication that is still um virtual
[1:06:11]
uh that is still uh via email, not
[1:06:14]
bombard people with bulletins and
[1:06:16]
newsletters, but uh really find ways to
[1:06:20]
just share little nuggets so they are
[1:06:23]
hearing often and frequently and don't
[1:06:26]
have to wait for the big earth
[1:06:28]
shattering news um to hear from the
[1:06:30]
superintendent.
[1:06:35]
» Member Miranda,
[1:06:38]
» Thank you. Um, I sincerely appreciate
[1:06:41]
your interest in our district. Um, what
[1:06:44]
you've shared about your philosophy
[1:06:46]
around centering dignity when it comes
[1:06:49]
to um, in the educational experience,
[1:06:53]
not just with students, but also with
[1:06:55]
um, staff and also some of the
[1:06:59]
non-traditional educational experiences
[1:07:01]
that uh, you would bring to the table as
[1:07:04]
a leader. Um and and with that I I would
[1:07:08]
like to ask can you share the ways uh
[1:07:11]
having not held a superintendent
[1:07:12]
position before um or an assistant
[1:07:15]
superintendent position um please share
[1:07:19]
the ways that you believe that you're
[1:07:21]
ready for this role.
[1:07:23]
» Yeah. Thank you for the question. Um,
[1:07:27]
I guess I will start with um with
[1:07:30]
something that my family
[1:07:33]
um they kind of raised me in the in this
[1:07:36]
concept. Um I'm going to say in Spanish
[1:07:40]
first I'm going to translate it. But
[1:07:45]
mucho
[1:07:46]
uh one that is faithful in the small
[1:07:49]
things is also faithful in the larger
[1:07:52]
things.
[1:07:54]
um while because of role constraints I
[1:07:58]
have not have the opportunity to um be
[1:08:01]
invited to have the role of assistant
[1:08:04]
superintendent or superintendent
[1:08:06]
previously. I I think I I have a track
[1:08:09]
record that has shown what my values
[1:08:12]
are, my uh approach to leadership that
[1:08:15]
is based on relationships.
[1:08:18]
Um I had for the last four or five years
[1:08:20]
I have been part of the um at the senior
[1:08:24]
team level and I have in g because of my
[1:08:27]
role I have worked closely with the
[1:08:29]
superintendent in um in challenging
[1:08:33]
decisions because every time there's an
[1:08:36]
issue that has to do with DEI it tends
[1:08:38]
to be challenging
[1:08:40]
um those
[1:08:42]
exposures and opportunities are giving
[1:08:44]
me a deeper understanding of how a
[1:08:48]
district works. Currently, uh my current
[1:08:51]
district, while on the surface might
[1:08:53]
seem the opposite or not align with what
[1:08:57]
Salem is, is similar in size, is similar
[1:09:00]
in the student population and is similar
[1:09:03]
in comparable as in the number of
[1:09:05]
schools and that has also has given me a
[1:09:07]
sense of how to navigate the different
[1:09:10]
levels in a district um from the
[1:09:12]
superintendent lens. So um I don't
[1:09:17]
personally honestly I feel that I am the
[1:09:21]
right um candidate for this position not
[1:09:25]
because I I have all the answers because
[1:09:27]
of previous experiences but because uh I
[1:09:31]
can convey because of my track record
[1:09:34]
that I uh I I am someone who will
[1:09:37]
actually will sit with the problems will
[1:09:40]
listen carefully and we're very
[1:09:42]
thoughtful about finding solutions that
[1:09:45]
are responsive. So, it is in a way
[1:09:50]
um what I'm
[1:09:53]
what I'm hoping a district will value is
[1:09:56]
the um the how the superintendent will
[1:10:00]
present. How will the superintendent
[1:10:03]
show up? How will that will that person
[1:10:06]
be faithful to our families when no one
[1:10:10]
is seen? when the budget is tight and
[1:10:13]
when decisions have to be made. So I
[1:10:16]
think that what I may not bring all the
[1:10:20]
bells and whistles of someone or people
[1:10:23]
that have held positions very closer
[1:10:26]
quote unquote to the superintendency. I
[1:10:28]
think my live experiences as a
[1:10:31]
professional and the uh commitments and
[1:10:34]
values that I have used in all the
[1:10:36]
different levels of my career um could
[1:10:41]
be solid evidence that could hopefully
[1:10:44]
Salem could could believe in and could
[1:10:46]
trust that I will be faithful to those
[1:10:49]
commitments if I'm invited to come to
[1:10:51]
Salem.
[1:10:53]
» Thank you.
[1:10:57]
Any further follow-ups?
[1:11:00]
Member Hoffman,
[1:11:02]
» I just have a quick followup because we
[1:11:04]
were talking about DEI and inclusion.
[1:11:07]
And my question is um how how will you
[1:11:11]
show up to help the LGBTQ community uh
[1:11:14]
especially in these trying times with
[1:11:15]
the trans ban in um sports which doesn't
[1:11:18]
really affect Massachusetts but I know
[1:11:20]
there's lots of concerns with families
[1:11:23]
and how will you make how will you help
[1:11:25]
those families feel comfortable coming
[1:11:27]
and talking to you?
[1:11:30]
» Yeah, that's a great question. Um the
[1:11:34]
way that we have um shaped the work is
[1:11:37]
to make sure that
[1:11:41]
students see themselves in the
[1:11:44]
curriculum and instruction. But to your
[1:11:46]
question about how families will feel uh
[1:11:50]
comfortable approaching
[1:11:52]
me as a DIA director, as a
[1:11:54]
superintendent,
[1:11:56]
I think is is is um is based on the
[1:11:59]
actions and um and based on showing care
[1:12:05]
for the um the experiences, not
[1:12:09]
necessarily because of coming from an
[1:12:12]
intellectual lens like I understand
[1:12:15]
but coming from a commitment that um
[1:12:19]
that I I am there and I will be there um
[1:12:23]
when challenging times comes. For
[1:12:24]
example,
[1:12:26]
um we I have shown courage regarding the
[1:12:32]
the curriculum and inclusion of
[1:12:34]
representation and and also um by
[1:12:39]
connecting with other stakeholders in in
[1:12:41]
the in the town where I reside. um by
[1:12:46]
making sure
[1:12:49]
like for example at the high school um
[1:12:52]
where I work there's um there's a
[1:12:54]
display of
[1:12:57]
flags of different countries and also
[1:12:59]
there's a BLM flag and also a pride
[1:13:02]
pride flag
[1:13:04]
um in working or attending um the school
[1:13:08]
council meetings for example the the
[1:13:10]
school council in my current community
[1:13:13]
um recommended
[1:13:15]
that um those value principle flags were
[1:13:19]
not at the same level as the national
[1:13:22]
flags. As a DI director, I show my
[1:13:25]
support in those kind of recommendations
[1:13:28]
and also in advising the superintendent
[1:13:30]
of how to implement those things. So I
[1:13:34]
will maybe answer that question that I'm
[1:13:37]
not sure if I just by
[1:13:42]
just by being people will feel
[1:13:44]
comfortable. Um I don't want to fall
[1:13:47]
into that uh cliche of quoting people I
[1:13:50]
have friends and families you know
[1:13:51]
that's like so not appropriate but I I
[1:13:56]
hope that uh my actions are showing that
[1:14:01]
um that I truly believe in those values
[1:14:04]
and I truly believe that our students
[1:14:07]
should feel safe and seen in in our in
[1:14:10]
all our spaces. And the and the third
[1:14:13]
level
[1:14:14]
might be a little more
[1:14:16]
micro talking about the smaller things.
[1:14:20]
Um we have a system of reporting when
[1:14:22]
incidents happen and a lot of incidents
[1:14:25]
sadly but is the reality happens among
[1:14:28]
students and and I will say that because
[1:14:32]
I'm the the recipient of those u reports
[1:14:35]
either from students or educators
[1:14:38]
after race you know gender identity um
[1:14:42]
sexual orientation are the ones that are
[1:14:45]
second and third in the number of
[1:14:47]
incidents. I think that um
[1:14:51]
while my work tends to be a little more
[1:14:53]
behind the scenes, but people that know
[1:14:54]
the work will know that we when those
[1:14:57]
situations happen, we try to respond
[1:14:59]
timely
[1:15:01]
um and in a visible way so that the
[1:15:03]
students that were the target feel that
[1:15:06]
um that they are respected and valued.
[1:15:09]
And that is the work that I my role kind
[1:15:12]
of like asked me to kind of put in place
[1:15:15]
um for the for the welfare and support
[1:15:17]
of the LGBTQ plus um families and
[1:15:21]
students.
[1:15:27]
» Any final followup questions? Yeah,
[1:15:28]
member Cornell.
[1:15:30]
» I have a a question that that um
[1:15:35]
follows up on Veronica's question, which
[1:15:37]
is this. You know, as a new
[1:15:39]
superintendent, you'll have a new
[1:15:41]
experience of having to build
[1:15:43]
relationships with the school committee.
[1:15:45]
And so um I'm wondering how you'll go
[1:15:49]
about developing relationship with us as
[1:15:51]
a body and also individually um what
[1:15:55]
that you know what your approach will
[1:15:57]
be.
[1:15:59]
» Yeah it's a great question. Um, I don't
[1:16:01]
know if it's a local uh configuration,
[1:16:05]
but um,
[1:16:08]
in my experience, I tend to see the
[1:16:10]
superintendent interacting more with the
[1:16:12]
chair and the co-chair of the school
[1:16:14]
committee. Um, I think, you know, I have
[1:16:18]
been able to build the relationships and
[1:16:21]
I feel that even as a superintendent,
[1:16:25]
relationships are built by doing things
[1:16:27]
together. And I think that it's not the
[1:16:31]
social, you know, pleasantry exchanges,
[1:16:34]
but it's actually the moment of doing
[1:16:36]
the work is actually what brings strong
[1:16:38]
connections. Um, I, as a superintendent,
[1:16:43]
it's important to participate in school
[1:16:47]
committee subcommittees. For example, we
[1:16:49]
have one for policy and we meet with two
[1:16:53]
um
[1:16:54]
school committee members who are not the
[1:16:56]
chair or the um vice chair. So those
[1:17:00]
working groups are are opportunities for
[1:17:03]
a superintendent to kind of build that
[1:17:05]
relationship with individual school
[1:17:07]
committee members. Well, I think we'll
[1:17:09]
circle back that is really uh because of
[1:17:12]
the open meeting laws, we cannot do too
[1:17:14]
many things as a group, but it really
[1:17:17]
come from finding opportunities to work
[1:17:20]
with each uh school committee member
[1:17:22]
individually as a school committee
[1:17:24]
member or as a president in whatever
[1:17:28]
work or advocacy
[1:17:30]
um
[1:17:32]
duties or participation that they have
[1:17:34]
in the community also. So I think uh I
[1:17:37]
will close by saying just by doing
[1:17:38]
things together that's how relationships
[1:17:40]
are built.
[1:17:48]
» Okay.
[1:17:49]
» All right. Dr. Allen, a closing
[1:17:51]
statement if you'd like.
[1:17:52]
» Uh first of all, I want to thank you
[1:17:54]
all. I want to thank the school
[1:17:56]
committee for the opportunity for me to
[1:17:58]
uh spend uh now you know a full day and
[1:18:02]
then now uh this evening with um here
[1:18:05]
with Salem. Um
[1:18:08]
I came to this evening wanted to
[1:18:10]
highlight two things. Um it was one the
[1:18:16]
um that I feel that Salem is not you
[1:18:20]
know trying to restart something. I
[1:18:22]
don't feel that Salem is needs or is
[1:18:25]
looking for someone to create something
[1:18:27]
new per se. I personally believe that
[1:18:30]
that Salem will benefit from having
[1:18:33]
someone that actually will sustain the
[1:18:35]
work, will shepher the work and be um be
[1:18:39]
a humble partner and listener with uh
[1:18:42]
the initiatives that we already have to
[1:18:45]
have underway. And the um second thing I
[1:18:48]
wanted to like highlight for this
[1:18:50]
evening and coming back in the closing
[1:18:53]
is about the concept of valuing the
[1:18:57]
richness of this community
[1:19:00]
that um I'm really excited about
[1:19:03]
participating in a district that really
[1:19:05]
values that and try to incluse that
[1:19:07]
intentionally in the curriculum and in
[1:19:09]
the educational experiences of their
[1:19:11]
students because of um you know locally
[1:19:15]
rooted
[1:19:16]
which is your curriculum and your spaces
[1:19:19]
are kind of showing that and also
[1:19:21]
globally ready which I this is kind of
[1:19:24]
like the more in visioning part that
[1:19:26]
would like to sell today that I think
[1:19:29]
there's a lot of potential for Salem to
[1:19:32]
u see itself as a place where students
[1:19:35]
are developing that global competency
[1:19:38]
um I circling back to what I'm saying I
[1:19:42]
think that my my live experiences as a
[1:19:44]
immigrant myself as someone that had to
[1:19:48]
navigate the public school systems,
[1:19:50]
someone that I feel if I were to be
[1:19:53]
invited to be a superintendent to be I
[1:19:55]
would be honored to be in a district
[1:19:57]
that has taken the courage to name their
[1:20:00]
new school uh after um Sarah Perk uh
[1:20:04]
Parker Ramon um knowing the history and
[1:20:07]
the influence that has in
[1:20:09]
African-American history of the of the
[1:20:11]
area
[1:20:13]
and I think that um those elements but
[1:20:17]
and understanding um my leadership style
[1:20:20]
and the values that I will bring to the
[1:20:22]
um district. Um and most importantly
[1:20:25]
that I will be a guardian and um and uh
[1:20:32]
someone that will strengthen our equity
[1:20:34]
commitment but I mean the superendency
[1:20:37]
as well. Um
[1:20:42]
I feel really fortunate to be here in
[1:20:44]
front of you at this moment. I I
[1:20:47]
appreciate the moments like in the uh
[1:20:50]
community forum when um one of the
[1:20:53]
community members actually stood up to
[1:20:55]
the microphone, asked a question in
[1:20:58]
Spanish in a public forum. I I want to
[1:21:01]
be in a I I I want to be in a place
[1:21:05]
where that is not uh an exception. It's
[1:21:08]
actually the rule and Salem so far in my
[1:21:12]
experience has shown evidence that you
[1:21:14]
are that type of district. Um
[1:21:19]
so thank you very much for the
[1:21:20]
opportunity and I I would like to um to
[1:21:23]
thank you all for um for for the
[1:21:28]
friendship and the um hospitality that
[1:21:30]
you have offered me and I and I would
[1:21:33]
like to um wish you the best and I hope
[1:21:37]
hopefully I will be part of that that
[1:21:39]
journey moving forward. Thank you.
[1:21:42]
» Thank you.
[1:21:46]
That concludes the interview. Thank you,
[1:21:48]
Dr. Allen, for joining us this evening.
[1:21:50]
Is there a motion?
[1:21:53]
» Motion to adjurnn.
[1:21:54]
» Second.
[1:21:55]
» Motion. Well, Shirley's not here. She
[1:21:57]
can get it from the recording. Uh, under
[1:22:00]
discussion, seeing none. All in favor?
[1:22:02]
Any opposed? We're adjourned.