Community Workshop on Housing - The Route 130 Corridor

Sandwich Housing Authority, MA · More Sandwich Housing Authority, MA meetings · More Massachusetts meetings

Transcript

Download: Text · SRT
AI TRANSCRIPT

This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.

[0:01] We're coming tonight. We're going to be looking at the, this is the south sandwich community, design,
[0:08] visioning workshop. I am Ralph Atako. I'm the director of planning and economic development here
[0:15] in the town of sandwich, and along with me, I have the assistant town plan early and Drake,
[0:20] and we have our intern for the summer Caleb White here, for the town, and a very lovely administrative
[0:28] of a system moreover in the cave is not with us today,
[0:32] but cheese with us in spirit.
[0:35] So we're going to be looking at what the biggest impediment
[0:40] to development here in the town of Sanwich,
[0:43] where a very long time was our lack of infrastructure.
[0:47] So as you recall in November at Special Town Meeting,
[0:52] when the town meeting voted to place the water infrastructure
[0:56] investment fund on the ballot in May, in the planning office, we decided it was time to
[1:03] take action.
[1:05] We are taking a look at the Route 130 corridor, as many of you may recall that, for a very
[1:14] long time, that has been identified for development, both commercial and residential.
[1:24] So we reached out to the Cape College Commission for assistance to help us in looking at some
[1:33] visioning and some thoughts and some ideas on how we could force their development.
[1:39] So we were fortunate and we received a grant from the Cape College Commission to start breaking
[1:47] breaking up that 130 corridor in segments. So really, this is the first look at it, the first
[1:55] segment of it. And the first segment is housing. You know, with wastewater, with wastewater
[2:04] infrastructure, we could start looking at density. And the overall goal is to create housing,
[2:13] which people could afford, which people could live in, which people can retire to,
[2:18] but also create an environment which is conducive for economic development.
[2:24] So the goal is to look at different housing forms.
[2:29] This is, again, this is the first part of looking at the overall root 130 corridor.
[2:34] First segment is housing, and the ultimate goal is to put forward some zoning
[2:42] which would, again, force the development and with that, I want to pass it to Heather Harper
[2:48] from the Cape Cod Commission.
[2:53] Thank you, Ralph.
[2:54] And thanks to all of you for welcoming the Cape Cod Commission to the community of Sanwich
[3:00] to help us support you and your own visioning and planning process.
[3:05] I want to recognize some of my colleagues that are here tonight.
[3:07] I have sort of Sarah Poorgeff who's a community design planner and Michelle White who's a special
[3:12] Projects Coordinator. We also have another staff person, Chloe Shafer, that's working with us on this project.
[3:19] And this evening is really just the beginning and initial conversation with you in your community
[3:24] about the types of forms and the form of development that you feel you can support in a very defined area.
[3:30] And I want to reinforce what Ralph said that this really is about your long-term goals to support your local economy,
[3:38] recognizing that mixed use development with some additional housing to support local economic
[3:44] activity is the type of development that you've expressed some desire for both through your
[3:49] local comprehensive plan and some of the unvisioning work that you've done. So I want you to
[3:53] keep in mind that any of the forms that we're looking at and thinking about this evening could
[3:58] support residential development which is really the motivation behind the framework that you'll see
[4:03] this evening could also support other types of uses.
[4:07] So I want you to keep an open mind about what we're thinking about this evening.
[4:11] And I'm just going to share a few demographics with you about the community to get you
[4:15] in a mindset to think about your local economy and your housing supply.
[4:21] So about two years ago, we did a demographic and economic analysis of Cape Cod.
[4:26] And we did that analysis from the ground up looking at each and every community building up
[4:32] regional economic profile and what we found is that the town of Sanwich and the Cape across
[4:37] the board is looking and trending towards some population growth in the next between now
[4:42] in 2025. We also see some potential of an increase in employment and that looks really quite strong
[4:49] in the community of Sanwich with the potential for upwards of 5.2% increase in economic employment.
[4:57] So that's a really positive sign and it's the strongest growth in employment of any community
[5:01] on Cape Cod so it speaks really well. Keep in mind that both the economic increases in a population
[5:07] increases really rely on a functioning economy and a functioning economy includes the ability
[5:13] to afford to live there, find housing that are supported by the wages that are provided
[5:18] by jobs in your community. Of course, all of Cape Cod is one community. We also see the potential
[5:24] for an increase in households. I know if anyone, this is always a quiz question, can anybody
[5:29] give an answer as to why household growth is increasing at a rate greater than population.
[5:41] It's always a math question. It's a math question. The household size in sandwich across
[5:46] the Cape across the region across the nation is declining. So you'll always do the number
[5:51] of households or the number of householders needing a place to live is growing faster than
[5:55] population. So there's a lot of demand for your housing supply and that's something.
[5:59] I'm sure you're all very familiar with.
[6:01] So one of the things that really
[6:04] remarks the Cape economy in region is the type of housing supply that we have.
[6:09] And so this is a single family homes.
[6:11] We have a very robust supply of single family homes across Cape
[6:15] Cod.
[6:15] And you can see that in the United States about 63% of the housing units
[6:20] are delivered through single family homes.
[6:22] And Massachusetts is about 52%.
[6:25] Cod is 80% and Sandwich is 80%
[6:32] which limits the diversity of housing opportunity in your community.
[6:39] Of course, the other is 10 year, who lives there, are their renters, and their owners.
[6:43] And you can see here that in the United States about 36% of all households across the nation are renters.
[6:50] In Massachusetts, about 38% Kate Cod, 21, and Sandwich is really dominated by home ownership
[6:56] with about 15% of your housing stock being supported by renters.
[7:02] And then household size, you can see, you're about to norm for the U.S.
[7:07] So, household size is declining.
[7:12] But again, say much higher than the rest of the cake closer to the U.S. average.
[7:17] And then lastly, of course, all of this results in housing stress across the region,
[7:23] where we have householders across the region of Cape Cod that I have experienced.
[7:28] check
[7:30] Challenges with housing spending too much of their income annual income on housing. What you see here is the green bar, is the median home value for Cape Cod and each of those dots are what a householder at any one of those income levels can afford. So, across Cape Cod, even those earning well above the median income, a hard press to find home that's affordable at the median income. So, everyone's isolated, we're under water.
[8:01] And so what that results in is about 26,000 households across Cape Cod that are experiencing
[8:07] housing stress on that peak.
[8:08] It's really felt by those households, there's earning 80% of the median income or less.
[8:13] And what you see here in this last slide, that's the growth and income that we're predicting
[8:17] in the next 10 years.
[8:19] And the green bar you can see escalates up to a large number in 2025 if the trends in housing
[8:28] values continue along the same trajectory.
[8:31] We see something similar in sandwich, although I really attribute a lot of the economic
[8:36] opportunity in sandwich to a affordable housing supply that you have in your community that's
[8:42] a little different than the rest.
[8:44] So you're in striking distance here that there is a housing supply in your community that's
[8:48] affordable to those earning the median income and if you're earning about the median income,
[8:52] there's a supply that's affordable to you there as well.
[8:54] And then look you forward, this little data that I'll leave with you.
[8:59] We expect to see that that housing market to continue to grow and home values to grow in your community,
[9:05] which is down the road if we continue without addressing some of the diversity issues in our housing market
[9:10] to see continued stress in the housing marketplace.
[9:17] And so I know have the great pleasure and thank you for letting me set the stage on both economic development and housing
[9:23] to introduce Jeremy Lake, and when Ralph came to us looking for some help around the
[9:28] sandwich corridor planning process, we have been involved in this community resiliency
[9:32] by design exercise in several communities. And we thought it would be a really great opportunity
[9:37] for you all to think about community development and economic development from a visual
[9:41] form standpoint before you get into the the the uses and the zoning. And so we've teamed up
[9:48] with Union Studio who's done a really wonderful job working in four different communities across
[9:53] K-Cod, three of those four communities are now embarking on zoning reform with a lot of community
[9:59] and support, so we did the community engagement first around form and they're really taking
[10:05] the lead on the zoning piece which comes next.
[10:07] So we really give a great tribute to Union Studio and Jeremy Lake and Douglas and their team
[10:13] who've done a really nice job bringing these concepts home to us in a way that's attainable
[10:18] and accessible.
[10:18] And I'm going to start talking, but I am going to ask all of you to try and beat the town of
[10:23] Phelmouth in the number of residents that fill out the community survey.
[10:27] So at the end of this presentation, you'll see a link to a community survey.
[10:30] Phelmouth had 400 people fill out their survey.
[10:34] So you guys need at least 450, and we, excuse me, it should be fixed.
[10:39] It's been fixed.
[10:40] Thank you for that.
[10:41] Thank you for letting us know.
[10:43] So Jeremy, thanks so much.
[10:49] So, good evening everyone. I'm Jeremy Lake. It's Heather mentioned with Union Studio Architecture and Community Design.
[10:54] This is what we're hoping to cover here tonight. I wanted to give you a quick outline so you could see what was coming.
[10:58] First, I'll introduce who we are, Union Studio. Why are we here? It's good question.
[11:03] We'll mostly be talking about the notion of density and trying to demystify the sense of density.
[11:07] It's a big word that usually scares people. We're hopefully going to sort of talk you through what it means.
[11:12] And hopefully have you a little more comfortable about the issue by the end of the night.
[11:16] By doing so, we're going to be talking about what we call the missing middle.
[11:19] I'll get into that a little bit later.
[11:21] We'll have a few visual preference questions along the way.
[11:23] So try to stay awake as everyone's wrong.
[11:25] I'm going to be looking for votes and looking to see if you're still with us.
[11:28] Hopefully he'll still be with us.
[11:29] And then we'll finish.
[11:32] We'll open up for a general discussion at the end as well.
[11:36] So where are we, Union Studio?
[11:37] We were founded in 2001 with one overriding goal,
[11:40] which was to use our skills to make sure that any project we worked on
[11:43] no matter how big or small,
[11:45] made a civic contribution to the community that it was within.
[11:48] So whether we were working on a single family house or an entire new neighborhood plan,
[11:52] understanding the context, understanding the community that was already in place to make sure
[11:55] that what we did was appropriate fit in, enhance that community, did not detract from that community.
[12:02] We are community designers in addition to being architects.
[12:05] So we work at the scale of neighborhoods, both new neighborhoods, but also working a lot
[12:09] with existing communities like we're talking about here tonight.
[12:11] And so we consider that one of our real specialties.
[12:17] That often includes renovating or adaptively reusing historic structures in the community.
[12:22] We've done a number of historic revitalization efforts.
[12:24] It's important to respect the existing fabric that you have.
[12:27] Oftentimes this is the thing that makes your town feel different than any other town.
[12:31] So that's an important piece to all of this.
[12:35] And whenever we design new architecture, new communities, again,
[12:38] making sure that it resonates with that community and enhances the civic life of that place.
[12:43] Why do we need to do all of this?
[12:44] Well, the practice in general over the last 50, 60 years is sort of lost touch with the sort
[12:49] of best practices, if you will, of traditional neighborhoods and traditional towns.
[12:52] Think about the historic village center we're in here.
[12:56] We don't replicate this very well, right?
[12:58] We don't do it very well anymore, and we think there's lessons to be learned.
[13:01] There's good things about this that we could use for model moving forward.
[13:07] And looking at those principles, we can set up framework for revitalizing our streets
[13:12] and neighborhoods.
[13:14] So some principles of healthy communities, walkable and pedestrian friendly, mix of housing
[13:19] types to serve the broad needs of the community, public and private outdoor spaces, contextual
[13:23] architecture, and making sure that everyone has a connection to community resources and amenities.
[13:28] So these are just some general principles that we try to apply to all of the projects we
[13:31] do.
[13:32] But in particular, what we're here to talk about tonight is the importance of having a mix
[13:36] of uses and types as the building blocks for complete community.
[13:39] So, one of the challenges we often face, a lot of new development, it's often monoculture, right?
[13:44] A developer comes in, builds a hundred of the same thing.
[13:47] That's great if that's the thing you're looking for, but what if you're looking for something else,
[13:51] or if you start in that community, your lifestyle changes over time, your kids move out, whatever the case might be.
[13:57] You have what you can't stay within your same community unless that exact model fits your lifestyle.
[14:01] So, including, you know, a variety of options and mixes, including some commercial uses and close walking distance.
[14:06] This is best case scenario for trying to create community.
[14:11] So we are based in Providence, Rhode Island, but we've done a number of projects on the cave, and I just wanted to share a couple of those South Sandwich Village, working with Tom Salkalos, who I see here tonight.
[14:22] We worked with Tom a number of years ago to propose a potential master plan both for some of the existing carcels here, but also the town and lands that were down here.
[14:31] So again, it gives you a sense of the scope of the community design that we've sometimes worked on.
[14:35] I was also able to be a part of the sandwich marina study a number of years ago.
[14:39] This was funded a grant by mass development. We worked with mass development and the town.
[14:43] Looking particularly at the town owned parcels that were right next to the marina.
[14:47] But also coming up with a vision for some of the private leone lands in the general vicinity.
[14:52] With the goal being to somehow activate and really take advantage of the amenity that is the marina right now.
[14:56] It's sort of underutilized unless you just drive out there.
[15:00] Go for a walk, it'd be great to add a little more mix of uses, potential housing out there to really take advantage of that.
[15:06] Another recent thing, we won working with the UK Code Young Professional Group, a prototype for some, what we call the side hustle house.
[15:14] For those of you that don't know that term, I didn't know that term. I thought it was a dance, but it means to have something in addition to your primary job.
[15:21] So for millennials, this is a big deal. And so the concept here for young professionals was there could be a base cottage, but maybe there's a little modules that could be added on
[15:29] has an extra unit that you could rent out to someone or your own little home office, your own
[15:33] little workshop.
[15:35] So that really resonated with the young professionals, so we were excited to be one of the
[15:38] winners of that competition.
[15:40] And then just a few other projects that we've worked on around the Cape Heritage Sands
[15:44] down in Dennisport is a seasonal resort cottage community, which is absolutely beautiful.
[15:49] It's unfortunate that it's not a year-round community, but that's how they regulated it.
[15:53] Brewster's Landing is a recently completed 40B project out in Brewster, 40B being a mix
[15:58] of market rate in affordable housing, in sea captains row, which was recently approved in
[16:03] high NS, we're in the midst of working on the construction documents for that.
[16:06] That's going to be workforce housing, that's going to be largely rentals for a lot of
[16:09] the young professionals that work at the hospital in high NS.
[16:12] So these are a range of different projects, all of which are of this sort of middle moderate
[16:17] density that we're talking about here tonight.
[16:19] So again, we have experience with these things and we have experience on the Cape with
[16:22] these things.
[16:24] So why are we here?
[16:25] So we're here tonight specifically to begin conversations around strategies and techniques for meeting the increasing demand for housing on Cape Cod.
[16:33] Again, Heather sort of painted the picture of why this is becoming an issue and that's why I wanted to reach out and talk to you guys.
[16:39] Because it's important for us to get your input because again, we, you know, we consider ourselves experts in this general concept, but you guys are the experts of Sandwich and so helping us understand what might fit what might not fit is important for us.
[16:52] not sort of coming in and proposing something without getting some community input.
[16:59] So our process in schedule, we've been having the same conversations since May of last year.
[17:04] We started in four other communities.
[17:05] I'll get into that in a little bit, wrapped up hiatus in March of this year.
[17:09] Since then, we've really been reviewing a number of existing studies relative to Sanwich,
[17:13] so we've got a little bit of an understanding of the groundwork that's in place here.
[17:17] We're here June 17th with our first public presentation.
[17:20] And it's Heather mentioned this is the survey.
[17:21] here's a link to it that you obviously can click, but you could track that down.
[17:26] We're going to probably have that open for the next several weeks to get input, hopefully
[17:30] 450 people's worth of input, and we plan on having a second presentation, so we're going
[17:35] to take what we hear from you guys tonight, take what we learn from the visual preference
[17:38] survey, the online survey, and come back and propose some more detailed things.
[17:42] We haven't set the dates specifically, but early September, obviously, waiting until after
[17:46] the crazy summer season to reconvene and talk about those things.
[17:50] We've also been working on a couple of other issues,
[17:53] the framework for a form-based regulation,
[17:54] which is near-in-completion.
[17:55] I won't go into the great detail about that tonight,
[17:58] but the point there is really thinking about form
[18:00] as a way of delivering context appropriate solutions
[18:03] how they're sort of hinted at that.
[18:05] I can talk a little bit about that more later.
[18:08] There's going to be a Builders Roundtable
[18:09] at the One Cape, the One Cape this year
[18:12] is July 29th and 30th, so this will be a session
[18:15] to actually sit down with developers and talk
[18:17] through these issues, have them help us understand
[18:19] What seems what would be a good idea what are issues that we might have challenged who might need to address?
[18:24] And we're open to continuing to do this with additional communities. Again, we started with
[18:28] Pharma Thoreleens Eastam, then we added HANS. We were really excited to be able to talk about this here in Sandwich.
[18:33] And we're open and willing to keep going and talking about this with other communities on the Cape because it's an issue across the Cape.
[18:40] So where have we been? These are the four that I've mentioned that we've talked to in depth so far.
[18:46] In each case, they had some sort of study or reports or discussion of late about the real need for finding options for moderate density.
[18:55] As Heather mentioned, three of the four have either recently adopted or in the midst of trying to adopt zoning changes to help allow for these kinds of moderate densities.
[19:04] But we need to make sure everybody understands what that means.
[19:06] In the case of the first three East Ham or Leans in Falmouth, the study areas were essentially
[19:12] the main street areas of those communities.
[19:14] In East Ham, that's where Route 6 goes through, Main Street today is basically a Comberland
[19:18] Farms and a Lobster restaurant, but they have high hopes that they can redevelop and
[19:22] sort of create more of a center that they don't have currently.
[19:25] In our Leans, this is the historic village center, in this larger area is really where they
[19:29] currently have a lot of commercial, if they do have some higher density, like some apartments
[19:34] such that's generally in this area. In the case of Falmouth, the historic main street of Falmouth
[19:39] is over here and this is as you're sort of coming out the eastern end of that and starting to
[19:42] find yourself at Staples and some of the more auto-centric uses and they've identified that
[19:47] as an area that they would like to redevelop with mixed use with some more moderate density.
[19:52] What you can't quite make out in all of these, it's most clear in this one, is that you quite literally
[19:56] have these sort of intense commercial areas that almost immediately have single family residential
[20:01] communities right next door to them. So there's no real transition. You kind of go from a really intense
[20:06] used to really low intensity use. It's a sum of what we're here to talk about tonight, or these
[20:10] types that could be more of a transition and appropriate transition from those intensities.
[20:16] Hi, NS on the other hand was a very different context. And so this is their historic main street.
[20:21] Here's the hospital. So we were looking at the east end of hiatus. In this case, you've got an area
[20:26] that's already relatively built out with a lot of historic properties in place as well.
[20:31] So, this is really about thinking about context of appropriate infill if you wanted to add units in this area.
[20:36] How would you do it in a way that's meaningful and sliding into the little pockets that exist out there?
[20:42] So, a combination, you know, we did first presentations with those various communities, second presentations, the one cave summit we presented last year.
[20:49] And we were also fortunate we were approached by the Cave Housing Institute as part of their programming to go to four different communities to talk about the same issues.
[20:56] So you can see we've been up and down the Cape talking about this exact thing, because it is an issue that's across the board.
[21:02] But we're super excited that now we're here in Sandwich, because again, we're trying to bring this message to as many places as we can.
[21:09] So the Housing Challenge on Cape Cod, how they're basically already presented some of this information.
[21:13] So I'm going to go through this relatively quickly.
[21:15] A lot of that comes out of this report.
[21:16] They did, if you've not seen it, it's an easy read, it's a good read, projecting the tenure forecast for housing supply and demand.
[21:22] They identify as a number of challenges as she alluded to. Employment is growing, which is generally a good thing as long as you've got places to put those folks.
[21:32] So roughly 6,000 additional residents, this is across the Cape by 2025. Here on the upper Cape, that's projected about 1,600 new jobs.
[21:41] The real challenge though is that house prices are increasing at about 5% a year.
[21:46] Whereas the incomes of the owners, the people that would likely buy that housing is only going up 2% a year.
[21:51] So here we are in 2019, we already have a gap,
[21:53] but you can see how that's exponentially getting more challenging over time.
[21:57] And it's the same stories with rents,
[21:59] rents are increasing about 4% a year,
[22:01] but the incomes of those that would likely be renting them
[22:03] are only going up 1% a year.
[22:04] So we talk about an affordable housing challenge,
[22:07] and it's getting tougher and tougher as time goes by.
[22:12] And as she mentioned, 82% of homes in sandwich,
[22:15] our single family compared to more like 60% nationally,
[22:18] low rental opportunities.
[22:20] And one thing she didn't notice that the median home size
[22:21] on the Cape is increasing faster than anywhere else in the country.
[22:25] So we talk about the challenge of having a diversity of housing types, the new stuff that
[22:29] is being built on the Cape.
[22:36] We're having this mismatch of what the supply is and what the need really is.
[22:43] So the report concludes by suggesting there were a number of targets that they proposed for the various
[22:49] municipalities, but the real takeaways increased the diversity of senior housing, seniors certainly looking for new options.
[22:54] The diversity of multi-family housing and accommodate life stages through better life, through better urban design.
[23:03] But what about South Sanwich?
[23:03] Let's talk about the area that we're interested in focusing on here tonight.
[23:08] Some of the studies we looked at in that sort of background research.
[23:11] The first one was the local comp plan.
[23:13] It does date from 2009.
[23:15] It's about 10 years old at this point.
[23:17] Probably a time to maybe start thinking about a new comp plan.
[23:20] But the lessons are very telling.
[23:21] It identified a number of areas that should be the focus of growth.
[23:25] Some of those are the areas we're going to be talking about tonight, South Sandwich Village,
[23:29] Center, the Sandwich Industrial Park, and the zoning district along Route 130.
[23:34] And what it's suggested is that in these growth areas there should be higher density, higher quality,
[23:38] vertical mix of uses, including a variety of uses, but definitely including residential,
[23:44] very types and income levels.
[23:46] And the housing should predominate a preferred use, and there should be moderate density residential
[23:50] uses, especially as a transition to some of the single family around it.
[23:53] Again, that's what we're here to talk about tonight, and the point being that this isn't
[23:56] a new issue, right?
[23:57] This is ten years old at this point.
[23:59] These issues have been known about, so it's like, how do we make this a reality?
[24:04] On a related note, the housing production plan of 2010, again, the predominant type is
[24:09] expensive, single-family detached homes, limited rental housing, limited multi-family housing
[24:13] available.
[24:14] So again, you're not providing a range of housing for the range of lifestyles that exist
[24:20] out here.
[24:21] So we need a wider range of alternatives, make sure they're harmonious with the existing community and
[24:26] encourage smart growth principles that some of those principles I talked about earlier about mixing uses
[24:30] walkable pedestrian friendly.
[24:34] And lastly, we also looked at some more recent efforts by the Cape Cod Commission
[24:37] looking at this exact area.
[24:39] They actually did.
[24:40] They looked at the South Sandwich Village and came up this is scenario number three.
[24:44] They came up with a variety of scenarios that tested out.
[24:47] What if we don't do anything and just use our existing zoning and let it keep being built out as
[24:50] the gas stations and strip malls, what does that do for the town?
[24:53] What if we look at one where we do a big mixed use village?
[24:56] What does that do for the town?
[24:57] What if we look at one that's a combination of a little village center and some additional housing?
[25:01] And the takeaway was that the worst case scenario was the existing pattern.
[25:04] If we change nothing and we let it keep being gas stations and strip malls,
[25:08] worst case meaning the least cost effective.
[25:10] So the tax returns to the town trying to support that new development.
[25:14] The best case was a mixed use village, including moderate density housing.
[25:18] So again, the numbers here test out, that's really the way we should be thinking and trying to go.
[25:25] So what's the area we want to talk about here tonight?
[25:27] So the principles we're talking about here tonight are somewhat general,
[25:30] but it's always helpful to have a lens about where you think this might be going.
[25:34] And so we tried to map the various areas that we're talked about in the Complan.
[25:40] So the Route 30 corridor at 1.30 corridor, we're really talking about right from where 130 splits
[25:44] from Ketu at Road at the Industrial Park at Jansavash and Drive, really all the way down to
[25:49] say snake pound road, as being the 130 corridor if you will. But within that, there are
[25:56] very specific areas that are probably the more likely targets for the sort of thing we're
[25:59] talking about. For one, there's the town owned parcel of lands here, the southern end of the triangle,
[26:05] which obviously will have some pressures to be developed to help solve this. So that's one little
[26:10] local area we might think about.
[26:13] Certainly all of the commercial uses that currently exist
[26:16] here within the triangle area.
[26:19] The industrial park itself could certainly
[26:21] be revitalized and thought about as an opportunity
[26:23] for some mixed use, including some moderate density housing.
[26:27] And then as we go a little bit further down,
[26:29] we noticed that there was this little pocket here
[26:30] between the single family neighborhoods
[26:32] that's currently the garden center and the sand and gravel lot.
[26:36] At some point, the economics are going to tip there
[26:38] or those are no longer the best, the highest and best use
[26:41] when there's this demand for this housing.
[26:43] I could imagine it'll be a time when those are going
[26:45] to want to be repurposed and this mixed use sort of moderate
[26:48] density housing is the sort of stuff
[26:50] that might make sense there.
[26:51] And that's just my observation.
[26:53] And last but not least, there's also a limited little stretch
[26:55] down here of commercial uses at the southern end of root 30,
[26:59] which again you could see over time being revitalized,
[27:02] maybe including a little more housing.
[27:03] These are the pockets along 130 that we thought
[27:05] made sense to think about.
[27:07] So what we're not talking about is necessarily coming back into these existing single family
[27:10] neighborhoods and adding more density, what we're suggesting is there are these little
[27:14] pockets that are already have uses in them, or are potentially right for redevelopment
[27:19] that are the sorts of places that we're thinking about for this new housing.
[27:25] So again, from the Complan Sandwich Industrial Park here, South Sandwich Village Center,
[27:29] which is essentially here, and along the group 30, which again, that you get a variety
[27:32] of conditions, but there's a couple of spots along there where this may make sense.
[27:36] The certainly aligns with the zoning code is exists, so the industrial park is this flex zone.
[27:43] You know, this business district that's all of this stuff here.
[27:45] It's certainly down, at least at the southern end, there's this little limited business district down there.
[27:49] So zoning is almost aligned with this concept at the moment, not necessarily, but certainly identifies those unique pockets down in this part of town.
[27:58] And this is the, I know it's very hard to make out, but this is the wastewater treatment plan.
[28:02] Now that we've approved the funds to develop those this this circle the area is this large area
[28:07] So slightly different scale you can make up the triangle right here
[28:10] But the phase one area the areas that are going to be the first to get the the new treatment are the industrial park the triangle area
[28:17] And this is the school so again when Ralph talked about sort of unlocking the potential for development
[28:23] These are the areas that are now going to have the service that will allow for that
[28:27] There's other little pockets we pointed out this little pocket here, this little pocket there, those are in phase two.
[28:32] The single family communities that are sort of around this are in that third phase.
[28:36] But again, you can see there's going to be a lot of focus on this area, whether you want it or not,
[28:40] now that this has been unlocked, development is going to want to come.
[28:43] So the question is, what's the appropriate form of that?
[28:47] So what is this all beginning to suggest?
[28:48] Need for housing, hopefully putting it in the right place is planning for growth centers.
[28:53] It's the dreaded d-word. It's density. So again, that's what we're here to talk about tonight.
[28:57] This is what everybody's worried about, right? Density density.
[29:01] But it's all density to say, and that's the real question we need to ask ourselves.
[29:04] And can we find options for density that feel right for the South sandwich community?
[29:09] The answer is yes.
[29:11] When discussing housing, just to make sure it's clear for everyone, what do we mean by density?
[29:14] It's really a numerical thing. It's just math. If there's one unit on one acre of land, we say that's one unit per acre,
[29:20] make sense. If in that same area you had six smaller lots, six units per acre, and as you put
[29:26] more and more units on it, it gets up to 18 units per acre. So this is just the basic
[29:30] algorithm that you do when talking about density. But the reality is that can take any number
[29:34] of forms. So this was a project of ours in my town of East Greenwich, Rhode Island. It's hard to
[29:40] make out here, but you have the main street of town is right here, and you transition immediately
[29:44] back into the single family community behind it, again, sounds familiar, right? Same in
[29:48] situation, refining off and here on the Cape. This was an old auto body shop and this is
[29:55] what the town decided would be a good location for multi-family housing. The good news
[29:58] is this is not our project.
[30:03] This law allowed for 20 units to the acre. This is a three-quarter acre lot, so that means you can have 15 units on this. The way that the zoning is written with the big setbacks, let's buffer it, push it away from everybody as far as it can go. This is what the result would have been. This is what the typical development community would have come in, read the code, spit out, hit 20 units to the acre, achieving the goal that we want.
[30:23] What we've proposed instead, basically, blew this building up into a number of smaller units.
[30:28] These are cottages.
[30:29] It's a cottage court.
[30:30] So, we have the exact same number of units on the exact same amount of land.
[30:34] So, we have single, basically single family residents achieving 20 units of the acre, which
[30:39] sounds like a very high number.
[30:41] And the community loved it when we showed them this, they obviously kind of freaked out.
[30:44] And we said, well, what we want to really do is make sure that whatever we propose, look at
[30:47] the scale of the existing single family, that's what it looks like along the streets edges
[30:51] you're walking through.
[30:52] When you turn down and walk down this little cork down through the middle and you find all these cute little cottages running through here.
[30:57] So this is density that's in a form that feels appropriate to the community and is a good way again of transitioning from the commercial area down to the single family area.
[31:05] So that's really what we're talking about here tonight.
[31:08] All right, so this is where I see if you guys are still awake and with me.
[31:10] So I'm going to show you a couple of side-by-side images and I'm going to ask you which one do you think has the higher density?
[31:16] Just going to be a show of hands.
[31:17] Who thinks that the image on the right is the higher density?
[31:25] Who thinks the image on the left is the higher density?
[31:29] All right, good job.
[31:31] This is really a typical single-family house anywhere on Cape Cod.
[31:34] Generally speaking, in the communities we've been working in,
[31:37] the lot sizes are generally a quarter acre, half acre,
[31:39] which means you get two to four units to the acre.
[31:42] I will say in South Sandwich, in those residential pockets right around the areas we're talking about,
[31:46] The lot-size are typically a half of an acre up to one acre.
[31:51] So really the existing density down there is closer one to two units to the acre.
[31:55] This is a little duplex that's on Pleasant Street here in Sandwich,
[31:59] short walk away from here.
[32:01] It's on an eighth of an acre, so it comes in at 16.5 units to the acre.
[32:05] So we're talking about, you know, four to eight times more dense than this.
[32:09] But obviously if this was right next to this,
[32:11] most of us wouldn't notice that we would walk right on by and not freak out.
[32:14] that, oh my god, eight times the density, right?
[32:17] So the form is what's important here.
[32:21] So I'll about the one I just gave you
[32:22] compared to this guy down here.
[32:23] Who thinks the one on the left is still the higher density?
[32:30] One, two, a few hands.
[32:31] How about the one on the right?
[32:34] Most folks are going with the one on the right?
[32:38] The answer is technically this one,
[32:39] but the point was really that these are more or less the same.
[32:41] This one comes in at 16, this one comes in at 18.
[32:44] So while this one has five units, and this one has two units,
[32:47] that's more units, but that doesn't necessarily mean
[32:50] more density, because the reality is this is on a lot that's almost two and a half times
[32:54] as big, that's why the math works out. So just looking at even the number of units in
[32:58] the building isn't quite enough to tell you what the density actually is.
[33:02] All right, how about between these two? Who thinks the one on the left with all those mailboxes
[33:06] in front is the higher density? And he takers for the left, one, two, three. The rest
[33:14] of you aren't falling for it. You're right. The one on the right is the higher density.
[33:18] So, in this case, this little building has three units in it, this building has five units in it.
[33:23] Both of these are a type that we refer to as a manor house.
[33:26] That's one of the things I'll be talking about later.
[33:28] The point here is that even whatever the types are, don't necessarily deliver the same density.
[33:32] In this case, this one's twice as dense as this one, even though they're both manor houses.
[33:36] This manor.
[33:47] A unit is a dwelling unit.
[33:49] So,
[33:54] that's right.
[33:55] This isn't population density, this is just dwelling unit density.
[33:58] That's a good point.
[33:59] And again, a lot of this math, too, right?
[34:01] These might be really big units.
[34:02] These might be little tiny units,
[34:04] and that might be why the numbers go up and down.
[34:06] So I think the overall point is here,
[34:07] the math is a little misleading.
[34:08] When you look at the numbers, you're not sure what it means.
[34:11] We think the more important thing is to go,
[34:13] if this was down the street from your house
[34:14] without you so bad, is that freak anywhere else?
[34:16] Or is that something that maybe is reasonable
[34:18] in the right locations?
[34:20] Let's do one more, and then we'll keep going to something else.
[34:22] So now we've got these to neither of these
[34:23] is in sand, which by the way,
[34:25] but these are some good examples to show.
[34:27] Does anyone think that these two little guys
[34:29] on the right are higher density than the one on the left,
[34:35] two takers, three takers, everybody else is thinking maybe the one on the left.
[34:39] The answer is again, they're basically the same, 20 units of the acre, 22 units of the acre.
[34:44] So, again, the forms of these things can be very different. It's kind of shocking, but these are so efficient on such a small little plot of land,
[34:50] that they actually come in numerically at a very high density versus this guy, which is actually on a somewhat larger lot.
[34:56] we'll look at both of these again later.
[34:57] But again, form can be sort of surprising in terms
[35:00] of what it can deliver.
[35:02] All right, so what are some creative approaches
[35:03] to moderate density?
[35:05] Really, this missing middle concept, I mentioned that earlier.
[35:08] What do we mean by that?
[35:08] What we really mean is that there's a lot of options
[35:11] between the sort of classic detached single-family house
[35:14] and that classic multi-family building,
[35:16] or you could even think of this again
[35:17] as the commercial main street here on the cape.
[35:20] We used to build all these various housing types
[35:22] that slotted somewhere between the two
[35:24] that we've largely not been developing.
[35:25] which is why we call it the missing middle.
[35:29] These types were common in pre-1940s, walkable neighborhoods.
[35:32] You can walk around to older communities and find these everywhere.
[35:35] One of the challenges the Cape has, we don't have a lot of pre-1940s communities, right?
[35:40] It was a lot of the development on the Cape happened after World War II.
[35:43] Prior to that, it was largely a agricultural and fishing sort of villages.
[35:47] So thankfully, we found some examples, but they're few and far between on the Cape.
[35:50] But in any other communities, you know, it'd come to Providence where we are, you could
[35:53] find these things all day long.
[35:56] One of the nice things about them is they often slot in very nicely in its single family
[36:01] community.
[36:02] So this is a diagram where the white ones are single family homes, here you have three
[36:05] little townhouses in accessory dwelling unit, a little apartment building, a little stack
[36:09] flat.
[36:10] The point was in a lot of historic communities, these things just slotted right in next to
[36:13] the single family neighbors, and we didn't bat an eyelash.
[36:15] It's kind of what you find when you walk around here in the historic village center.
[36:20] Why is the missing middle missing middle missing?
[36:23] The big culprit were the zoning ordinances that were written after World War II.
[36:28] Prior to World War II, it was okay to mix and match everything up.
[36:31] There were some problems with that.
[36:32] People would build the nasty factory next to somebody's house.
[36:35] They said, let's learn from this, let's try something different.
[36:37] The idea was to pull all of the uses apart.
[36:40] And when they talked about residential, they overly simplified it into generally speaking,
[36:46] single-family detached and multifamily.
[36:48] The single-family detached was usually zone for one acre per lot.
[36:51] the multifamily might have been 20 units to the acre and there really wasn't a lot of stuff in between in most zoning ordinances.
[36:58] As a result, financing was structured that's what the people were going to build so that's what the banks financed.
[37:02] So it's been tough to really do this stuff in the time in between here.
[37:07] And generally speaking when we talk about some of these things like when I say mannerhouse, those sorts of things that generally doesn't resonate with the public, there's no real of understanding of what that means.
[37:15] So just a fire we so people are hesitant and resistant to this idea.
[37:20] So why is there renewed interest now in the missing middle?
[37:23] One of the big things is that empty nesters and young professionals,
[37:26] aka boomers and millennials, they want to live close to things.
[37:30] The American dream or the way that we live is slowly shifting, depending on the groups you're talking to. They want to be in the historic course. They want to be in these mixed use areas. Usually the land values are higher, so the units get smaller, and trying to find creative ways of fitting more people in these smaller areas is what everybody's trying to solve for.
[37:48] We're also looking for new models to help provide more affordable housing. So one of the theories here is that if you can provide more units on less land, the land value can be spread across those units, so hopefully you can bring them out in the cost.
[37:58] no magic bullet, but it's a step in the right direction.
[38:02] The industry is looking for new ways to develop or smaller increments, so prior to the last crash we had in 2008, it was an unusual for developers to take on 500 unit projects on 100 acres that will get built out over 15 years.
[38:14] But then they began to realize that the longer their sort of got their neck on the line and then finally the crash comes and your stuck halfway through a project you haven't actually recouped any of your cost yet.
[38:24] So the development industry is really saying,
[38:26] okay, you're really nice that we can do smaller and smaller projects that still deliver.
[38:29] And so there's a real interest in these kind of smaller increments sort of projects.
[38:34] And really there's been a demographic shift to right size units and communal living.
[38:37] So even though I said generally the size of the houses we're building are getting bigger and bigger,
[38:41] I think a lot of people have finally said, okay enough enough, you know, I don't need a 4,000 square foot home.
[38:46] Really my lifestyle could do something much smaller,
[38:48] especially as we transition into new life stages, right? The kids move away or,
[38:52] you know, you want to retire and you don't have as much income.
[38:55] You want to find a unit that's the third, that's the right size.
[38:57] And ever and ever bigger housing isn't the answer for that either.
[39:01] And all of those are things that these types that we're calling the missing middle can help
[39:04] can help address.
[39:07] So let's talk about the missing middle building types.
[39:09] What do we mean by building types?
[39:10] That's sort of an architects way of pretending we're sort of a scientist and trying to put
[39:14] these things in these convenient little categories.
[39:16] So there's single family homes, there's cottages.
[39:19] I think you guys know what, dueplexes and townhouses are.
[39:21] that's really saying when two houses are attached,
[39:23] that's a duplex.
[39:24] When multiples of them are attached, it's a townhouse.
[39:27] This is the lens by which we try to look at housing and see it.
[39:30] And there are also these variety of types that are sort
[39:32] of more in the multi-family vein.
[39:34] Maybe there's one unit on top of the other.
[39:36] We might call it a double-decker or a stacked flat.
[39:39] A manor house, again, I'll talk about these in more detail,
[39:41] is really a couple of units that are in a form that
[39:44] looks like a larger single-family house.
[39:46] And the walk-up is really suggesting there's a type
[39:48] where maybe there's just one central stair
[39:50] that feeds a number of units.
[39:51] So it's not quite at the scale of a typical multi-family building
[39:54] where you go in, go up the elevator, walk down the corridor,
[39:57] units on both sides, 100 units in one building.
[40:00] So these are some of the building types that we've
[40:02] observed and think could be a good option for the South
[40:05] Sandwich area.
[40:07] But let's talk about them each in a little more detail.
[40:10] So cottages, everybody knows what a cottage is.
[40:12] It's a small scale, single-family detached unit.
[40:14] Typically, one to two stories here on the Cape.
[40:17] They may be attached, so you could put two of them together
[40:19] there's a duplex, or maybe it's a string of them as townhouses, but they're typically detached.
[40:23] And the density here is really a ride by arranging them in clusters or cottage courts.
[40:28] So obviously if you put a cottage on a one acre lot, you're still not getting anywhere,
[40:31] you're not achieving density.
[40:33] The real win here is that when you, this is our dentist for a project, you know, instead
[40:37] of them all being out on the street, each with a large lot, they're clustered together with
[40:40] these little greenways between them, and suddenly you can get a lot more units in
[40:44] a smaller area, but still provide a pretty wonderful and charming place with single family
[40:47] housing.
[40:48] As a result, there was generally fall in the range of 8-15 units per acre in the examples that we found out here on the Cape.
[40:57] So just to show you a couple of examples, an older example, Chase's ocean grove down in Dennisport.
[41:03] Look at all these cottages in here, right? So we've got 55 of them in 3.5 acres, 15 units of the acre.
[41:09] This was obviously largely summer housing. Not all of us would want to live like that year round, right?
[41:13] A little bit too close for comfort.
[41:15] But this is one of the examples that we can find.
[41:17] This is not a new concept on the cave.
[41:19] Maybe the form of it's different now.
[41:21] But this is the concept of a cottage court.
[41:24] This is our Heritage Sands Project in Dennis Port.
[41:26] So again, a number of cottages now,
[41:28] they're sort of a little more neatly arranged.
[41:30] We play games of making sure that there's privacy
[41:32] between these units.
[41:33] That's the little green in front of them.
[41:35] They come in part here in the back.
[41:36] This is generally what it looks like.
[41:38] So in this case, we're at 64 units on 8 acres.
[41:40] So we're at 8 units of the acre.
[41:41] So we're basically half of what that historic example is.
[41:44] But again, eight is still forward two to four times more dense than the typical stuff that's around it.
[41:53] This one is treated with septic, believe it or not.
[41:57] So anywhere you don't see a house, there's probably septic underneath of there, right?
[42:00] But that's why it's why it's why it's seasonal, that's right.
[42:05] So unfortunately, the folks that own these are only able to use them,
[42:08] I think it's like six months of the year or something, which again, really unfortunate.
[42:11] Maybe things will change over time.
[42:14] So even though we didn't show any specific ones in sandwich of that scale, certainly the idea
[42:19] of the cottage as a unit type is nothing new, right?
[42:21] So you've got summer street, pleasant street, canary street, stage street, there's all these wonderful
[42:25] examples of cottages, there's many people that are happy with their cottage.
[42:29] They're just not arranged and arranged in these cottage courts, but even these are unfairly
[42:33] small lots, generally speaking.
[42:35] So their density is probably a little bit higher than the typical single family density.
[42:40] And there are a couple of examples. Pine growth cottages here in Sandwich. Is that cloud?
[42:45] Yeah, cloud okay, it was worried it was like there's always some regional variation.
[42:49] Oh no, that's blocked or whatever, but these are obviously little summer rentals,
[42:54] but I think this Pine Grove one I think actually just recently got converted to condos,
[42:57] so people are actually going to live here year round.
[42:59] So again, these aren't necessarily exactly what we were talking about when we were thinking about it.
[43:03] But again, there's a lot of precedent for this as a concept here on the Cape.
[43:07] So here's the next time I'm going to ask you guys for a little bit of input.
[43:10] So there's no right or wrong answer here.
[43:12] Generally, I'm going to put up two images
[43:14] and I'm just going to say which one
[43:15] feels more appropriate when we're thinking
[43:17] about South Sandwich in those little areas
[43:19] I kind of outlined in the triangle area,
[43:22] or maybe in some of those little smaller cluster
[43:24] pillage areas.
[43:25] So again, no right or wrong answer.
[43:26] I'm just going to do show of hands.
[43:28] Who thinks that the image on the left
[43:30] would be more appropriate for that area?
[43:32] Versus the one on the right.
[43:35] One, two, three, four, five, six.
[43:38] Okay? How about the image on the right, on two, three, few more, few more hands, maybe twice as many?
[43:45] Is anyone want to offer up why they thought the one on the left might be more appropriate, but raise their hand.
[43:49] Yes, ma'am,
[44:12] right, right, great, how about somebody who voted for the one on the right?
[44:18] Somebody want to offer up why they thought the one on the right might be more appropriate?
[44:23] Yes, sir.
[44:42] So what's great is really if you were to compare probably the densities of these two, they'd be very similar.
[44:46] So, really, this is generally what we've found as people very much referred to the character of the place onto which the cottages are fronting.
[44:53] I always sound interesting, you know, it's hard to make out. These are shingled homes, whereas these are siding.
[44:58] Everybody thinks everything on the Cape has to be shingled.
[45:00] Now, which is a true. So sometimes people were looking at that, but by and large people were really looking at the context between them, which is what you guys spoke to.
[45:06] So how about between these two? Who thinks that the image on the left would be more appropriate for the south-sandwich village area?
[45:17] New takers? On the left?
[45:22] Okay. How about the image on the right?
[45:24] I think the one on the right looks more appropriate for south-sandwich. Okay? It's pretty close a few more for the one on the right.
[45:29] Does this look too much like Martha's vineyard for those of you that didn't vote for it?
[45:33] Isn't that funny?
[45:34] So we talk about that, right?
[45:35] They're preserving the historic character.
[45:37] This immediately is recognizable as Martha's vineyard, right?
[45:40] Even though all it is is cottages with a little bit of gingerbread and some color on it,
[45:43] you know, there's buildings that look like this other places, but generally speaking,
[45:46] and you could speak out if it's not the case, but people didn't vote for this one
[45:49] because, well, that's Martha's vineyard or self-sale training.
[45:52] So how about the people that raise their hand for the one on the right?
[45:57] Does anybody want to share their thoughts as to why they thought that one was more
[45:59] appropriate.
[46:09] Anyone want to share thoughts? Yes, ma'am.
[46:16] It's a lot of work. It's right. Absolutely.
[46:19] Okay. Well, let's keep moving because we got plenty to get through here tonight.
[46:22] So the next one is duplexes. Again, I think most of you know what a duplex is.
[46:25] But again, in the cape, the variations we find are typically one to two stories,
[46:29] or sort of one and a half stories really more so.
[46:31] Two single-family homes attached by what we call a party wall.
[46:34] That's the building code way of thinking about it.
[46:37] The density comes in slightly higher or actually it's similar range.
[46:40] five to ten dwelling units per acre.
[46:42] So there were two examples of this I wanted to share that we found in Sandwich.
[46:45] At one end of the extreme spectrum here, this is the library over here.
[46:50] There are these two units that are attached, so this is a duplex, even though they're obviously
[46:54] quite grand, lovely units built in 1857.
[46:58] They are unacombines just over half acre of lots, so that would come in at about four units
[47:03] the acre, which isn't particularly high.
[47:05] What's funny is when you really look at it, this unit is on this lot, which is much smaller,
[47:09] And this one is on this lot, which is much larger.
[47:12] So if you did the math just based on the one on the right,
[47:14] you'd be coming in closer to eight units to the acre.
[47:16] So again, the size of the lot has a lot to do with it.
[47:18] Right, there's a lot of empty ground back here.
[47:21] That is effectively decreasing the density,
[47:23] even though the form on the street is exactly the same.
[47:26] So here's one end of the spectrum.
[47:28] At the other is this cute little one I've been showing a few times.
[47:30] Now on Pleasant Street, 1849.
[47:32] On an eighth of an acre of a lot, 16.5 units to the acre.
[47:35] So you can see it really is.
[47:36] It's the structure that each have a little side yard.
[47:38] they're some parking here off a summer street and it's nestled here quite nicely and amongst
[47:42] a bunch of single-family density, it doesn't feel a lot of place works pretty nicely.
[47:49] Duplexes can take many shape sizes and forms, these are all over the cap and some of
[47:54] our other projects elsewhere, but really just to show, you know, it might be designed to try
[47:57] to look like it's one single-family house.
[47:59] It might work really hard to make sure you understand that that's two units that just
[48:03] happen to be glued together.
[48:05] This is one from our Brewster project where we attach them by the garage wall, so it
[48:09] they still felt like two single family cottages that just happened to be attached but that
[48:14] helped to save a little bit of space there. So how about between these two extremes, all right?
[48:21] You ready for this? Who thinks the one on the left is more appropriate for South Sandwich?
[48:27] One, two, three, four, expected some more on this. Five. How about the one on the right? Who thinks the one on the right is more appropriate?
[48:35] one, two, three, four, five, six.
[48:37] Who thinks neither of these images is appropriate
[48:39] for South Sandwich?
[48:43] That's the answer we've largely been getting.
[48:45] What's interesting is the one Eastam was the one place
[48:47] where we got a lot of support for this.
[48:48] The whole trurl mid-century thing.
[48:50] They're kind of still hip to that vibe.
[48:52] Yes, sir.
[49:16] So a range of characters is appropriate.
[49:19] So I've been told that you guys need to speak
[49:21] into the microphone, which seems like it'll be
[49:22] a logistically tough, so I might just kind of reiterate
[49:24] what you're saying or at least try it to.
[49:26] So if a vast audience at home can be included, yes, ma'am.
[49:43] So aging, population, single story housing,
[49:45] is beneficial, which is the one on the right shows.
[49:46] That's great.
[49:47] So we did hear a lot about neither of these feeling about right.
[49:50] Some people think that you couldn't possibly find a Victorian.
[49:53] I'm sure we could walk around and find several Victorians,
[49:55] but people buy on large.
[49:56] Don't really think of that as being what we think of as Cape Siles today.
[50:00] This one certainly a challenge if you begin to imagine other buildings
[50:02] in close proximity, a whole wall of windows isn't great.
[50:05] When your neighbor's 10 feet away,
[50:06] unless you really like your neighbor, so a lot of considerations here.
[50:11] How about between these two images, which one feels more appropriate for South Sandwich?
[50:16] How about a show of hands for the one on the right being more appropriate?
[50:30] Well, again, what's that?
[50:34] We're talking about, we're talking about if we were going to try to put in new housing
[50:39] and we could steer the conversation about which is more appropriate for South Sandwich.
[50:44] if you could choose between one of these two and really thinking again it's tough to not
[50:48] think of it as your own need but maybe
[51:13] yes
[51:17] they are to do so I would say for this
[51:20] exercise you can assume the density is equivalent so really I'm just saying like so
[51:24] for instance maybe in the areas we're talking about there might be areas there were a
[51:28] lower density it's still more appropriate than a higher density on a sliding scale
[51:33] so these would still be a higher density than a lot of the stuff that's out there
[51:36] today and there might be places where that's more or less appropriate. So the question
[51:39] isn't really about which density is more appropriate. It's really what form, because
[51:42] what we're really talking about tonight is form. The slides I should, you know, we'll keep
[51:45] talking about that, but this comparison's earlier, the numerical density is sort of a misleading
[51:50] thing to think about. So it's really a form issue that I'm looking to get some input on.
[51:55] Yes, ma'am.
[52:12] Yep.
[52:19] Right.
[52:31] So the importance of
[52:36] potentially, so the comment was about parking, that's really what we were getting at when we showed this image. It's not to say that this building couldn't have a garage behind it.
[52:44] All the examples I showed earlier certainly had somewhere in a park because we agree everyone, their cars is a reality. It's a real need that you have out there.
[52:52] So how it's concentrated, one of the things we do find is that when you build in a mixed use manner a little more compact, certainly if you were to walk around, you know, the historic village center here, you might find that households have slightly fewer cars, maybe, you know,
[53:03] house can get away with one or two, they don't need one for everybody in the family because
[53:07] the kids can still walk to high school or they can get down to the store.
[53:10] So, that's the bigger picture, hope and wish.
[53:13] I'm not sure that would be the case in South Sanwich.
[53:14] I think you're correct.
[53:15] We would still have to address and think about parking, but yeah, right, right, maybe they'd
[53:23] rather bike for luck area.
[53:25] All right, I'm going to keep moving.
[53:26] Keep moving along here.
[53:28] All right, the next one is townhouses.
[53:29] You guys know what townhouses are.
[53:30] If you want to have the two stories on the Cape, a series that share common party walls, they
[53:35] can look like individual units, or a single larger building, I'll show you what I mean
[53:38] by that in a minute.
[53:40] So you can see the scale is slowly sliding up, so now we're up to 10 to 15 units to the
[53:43] acre.
[53:44] We found two good examples of townhouses, and you go over the tracks here in the historic
[53:49] part of town, two to four state streets.
[53:52] This is kind of a funny one, because what it really is, this is two lots.
[53:56] So this is almost like a duplex and a duplex that happened to be attached to their
[53:59] touch to do flexes. So wrap your head around that, it's really a townhouse. So you basically
[54:03] have four units that are attached to your in a row, but I thought it was kind of neat to
[54:06] see that one was actually built 15 years after the other. So I guess this guy really loved
[54:10] this one and just ran with it, right? So four units on a basically a third of an acre, so you're coming
[54:15] in at 12 units to the acre for this example here.
[54:22] I'm sure probably was the factory housing,
[54:24] but you can see it's it's right in amongst a community of cottages, single family, two flexes,
[54:28] it's all mixed in over there, which is really what's the kind of neat part of it.
[54:35] I do not know
[54:35] the square footage of this building is there are six units in here you can find six front doors
[54:40] you can see they're concentrated on when then to the slot I don't know if this is
[54:44] historically would have been another building but certainly right now it's a little bit of a parking
[54:47] pad and a little out building six units on a half of an acre so again roughly that same 13 units
[54:52] to the acre for the examples we found here
[54:59] so townhouses can come in a variety of shapes and sizes
[55:02] certainly here's one of these little gables we're trying to give away the fact that they were
[55:06] separate units. Sometimes three individual stoops, you can tell that that's three. Here's one that's
[55:11] starting to be designed so it looks kind of like a single family, even though it's got a couple
[55:14] of doors on it. So again that's that idea of trying to really be clear about the individual pieces versus
[55:18] composing it as if it's just one large building designed. So how about between these two does anyone
[55:25] feel that the image on the left would be more appropriate for self sandwich? Not necessarily how about
[55:32] on the right.
[55:35] A couple of votes. Very few votes for either. Is there something about these that
[55:38] people don't think are appropriate for South Sandwich? Quick comment. One of the left is
[55:44] dated. Interesting. Okay. One of the great, it's great. If people generally love the colors
[55:51] and how vibrant this looks, although you can tell it's in a very urban context, it's funny
[55:55] you say this one looks dated because it was built two years ago. At Middlebury College,
[56:03] middle
[56:04] But the point here is that this one obviously is composed is one large building, almost as if it was a house on steroids.
[56:11] Versus this one is very much supposed to look like a series of individual tall cottages that are attached to different ways of skinning the cat.
[56:18] Between these two is there anyone in the room that would defend the one on the left is being more appropriate?
[56:24] This is an example of one on the cape. Again, this one could be an interesting conversation about the character of what's in front of it.
[56:28] this one feels very urban, almost, you know, so I might be too urban because more or less
[56:32] right on the street, there's this one has all this lovely landscaping in front, but certainly
[56:36] this feels like 1983 or whenever it would have been built.
[56:41] Alright, let's move to some of the types that you might be less familiar with.
[56:44] The double decker is effectively a stack duplex, typically two or three stories, so the idea
[56:48] here is that the first floor is a unit, so that would be a studio apartment on the ground
[56:52] floor.
[56:53] Then you could go up these steps and get to a second unit that's just on top of it.
[56:57] So it's a variation of a duplex.
[56:58] It's really a vertical duplex instead of a side by side.
[57:01] And we find a lot of examples of these
[57:03] where maybe the ground floor is one unit,
[57:05] but you could go up a set of steps
[57:06] and you'd get into a two story,
[57:08] almost like a townhouse unit on top of it.
[57:10] So that's why there are two or three stories.
[57:12] It depends on sort of the size and scale of the unit
[57:14] that's on the top, on the top level of it.
[57:16] 10 to 15 dwelling units to the acre.
[57:18] So we're getting into pretty respectable numbers here.
[57:20] Again, with something that, if this was sitting
[57:21] in a single family neighborhood, you might not pick up
[57:23] on the fact that it wasn't a single family home.
[57:26] And the one really great example we found of this is the one I showed earlier in the comparison.
[57:30] So you have two units here, two units here, technically four units here.
[57:34] So that's eight units on about a half acre, 20 units the acre.
[57:38] If we pretended this building was the same as the other two, we'd still be at about 15 units the acre for these.
[57:43] So it's the exact same thing. This one there's a unit in the bottom, and there's a unit in the top.
[57:46] And this one looks like a little bit of a bigger house that just happens to be divided into four units.
[57:52] And in terms of finding other examples of these, certainly in Providence, where we come from there's bunches of them.
[57:56] If you go out the province town, you can actually find a lot of them.
[57:59] So here's one where there's a door here that takes you into the lower level unit, where
[58:02] you can go up a couple of stairs, you get in what is essentially a one and a half-story cottage
[58:06] on top of that unit.
[58:07] So two units in that one building.
[58:09] There's this beautiful example in Sandwich.
[58:11] This is right next to those really big duplexes I saw, or I showed earlier.
[58:15] This is technically a mixed use building.
[58:17] This is a little storefront on the bottom, so you come in here.
[58:20] There's a door here that's a stair up to the upstairs.
[58:22] I don't know if that's somebody's office or a little tiny unit.
[58:24] But the point, this is the exact principle of two things stacked right on top of each other in a form that's comfortable in a single family sort of neighborhood.
[58:32] All right, which one feels more appropriate here? Anybody taking the one on the left?
[58:37] Nope, little too tall.
[58:40] Little too urban.
[58:42] Okay.
[58:44] How about between these two?
[58:46] No one's picking the one on the left, right? This is really me just wanting to point out that if you went into Boston, back bay,
[58:51] This is basically a four-story mansion on top of a one-story studio apartment.
[58:56] This was probably the guy that worked for this guy, right?
[58:59] But this is a double-decker unit.
[59:01] They also happen to be attached in credible density, but these are really mansions that
[59:04] we're talking about.
[59:05] Talking about having a spread.
[59:08] I agree, Mike.
[59:14] Alright, so the next one we'll talk about, again, we only have two left.
[59:17] This is the Manor House, so I showed some of these earlier.
[59:19] So the idea here is that these are about two, three stories.
[59:22] Usually about four to six units per building is the sweet spot, and the idea is that
[59:26] This looks like a large single-family home.
[59:28] Maybe this one's a little bit taller than we would think about as being a single-family home.
[59:32] But again, you would potentially walk by this and not pick up on the fact that it wasn't
[59:35] just a single house that this is in fact a five unit building.
[59:39] As a result, they can come in 10 to 20 units per acre.
[59:42] So again, this is going to be pretty high densities when we look at that scale, especially when
[59:46] you're talking about an area that's used to units the acre, four units to the acre.
[59:50] This one happens to park by driving by in this little driveway and then the parking happens
[59:53] in the back to the point about parking that was raised earlier.
[59:58] So the two examples I shared earlier.
[1:00:00] 12 pleasant streets. This is three units in this building, the mailboxes, which are deceiving are really for a lot of the units that come up and down. Some are street here.
[1:00:08] But again, it looks like just a cute single family cottage. It just happens to be three units, so 10 units to the acre.
[1:00:14] And then this is the example. This is on the corner of this is the library right here. So this is right on Main Street.
[1:00:19] Five units on a quarter acre, 18 units to the acre.
[1:00:24] Again, a variety of shape sizes and forms.
[1:00:27] In some cases, purpose builds to be a multi sort of building.
[1:00:30] This is one who our firm did, where there were three doors here,
[1:00:33] one that took you in to the unit upstairs,
[1:00:35] and one for the units on either side downstairs.
[1:00:38] One of the conditions we find a lot of the old captain's homes on the
[1:00:41] Cape, somebody built their grand-date bedroom house over time,
[1:00:44] nobody needed eight bedroom houses.
[1:00:46] So we find a lot of these on the Cape that have been subdivided over time.
[1:00:49] So now maybe it's a four unit or a five unit building.
[1:00:51] That's the concept we're talking about here
[1:00:56] so side-by-side comparisons here. Does anyone how about the one on the right for being potentially a good fit in South Sandwich
[1:01:04] 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, so many most people going with the one on the right. What about the one on the left? Why not the one on the left?
[1:01:10] Does anybody want to offer up a thought?
[1:01:15] two urban
[1:01:17] two dense two tall
[1:01:19] all of the above
[1:01:21] Scales two big, okay
[1:01:24] The architectural character probably feels pretty good, right?
[1:01:28] But it scales too big.
[1:01:30] Fair enough.
[1:01:33] How about between these two?
[1:01:34] Would anyone pick the one on the left is being more appropriate for South Sanwich versus the one on the right?
[1:01:40] Everybody's voting on the right?
[1:01:43] Okay.
[1:01:43] So in this case, again, this is the captain's house that's been subdivided.
[1:01:46] This is literally what was built behind it.
[1:01:48] So they had a few units in here and a few units in here.
[1:01:50] I'm guessing this lot was converted to a multi-family zone,
[1:01:53] and this was their creative way of doing it.
[1:01:55] So this is what you see from the street.
[1:01:56] This is behind it, still a very charming little place to live.
[1:01:59] Parking's handled in this little shared court that's to the back.
[1:02:02] So it's not apparent that there's six to eight cars parked here.
[1:02:06] Last but not least, walk-ups.
[1:02:09] This is a space-guess small-scale, multi-family building.
[1:02:12] Two to three stories, four to 12 units, series of flats with shared circulation.
[1:02:17] So again, it's supposed to what I described earlier as a double-loaded corridor building.
[1:02:21] That's the architect way of saying the typical apartment where there's a hallway down the
[1:02:25] In this case, you really come in the door and there'd be one stair in the middle and you could have up to four units per floor, up to three stories, which gives you 12 units.
[1:02:34] That's what the building code allows. So this is one where the building code gives you a logical limit to why you won't find a 13 unit version of these or a 14 unit version of these.
[1:02:43] But what's great is they're very efficient, just having that little hallway that you come in and go off into the units, you can do a really nice compact form for those.
[1:02:49] This is one that we designed in Providence, Rhode Island.
[1:02:52] This one happens to be mixed use.
[1:02:54] So there were shops on the lower floor,
[1:02:56] but there were a number of units on the upper stories of those.
[1:02:59] 15 to 25 units to the acre for something like this.
[1:03:03] So what are the examples we found locally?
[1:03:05] Does anybody know the 1883 block on Jarvis Street?
[1:03:08] This building here?
[1:03:10] Brace yourselves?
[1:03:11] 66 units to the acre?
[1:03:14] Not even a fifth of an acre, 12 units in this building.
[1:03:17] So the lot is the building.
[1:03:18] That's why the math works out to be so high.
[1:03:20] In this case, the parking is handled with all the parking that's on streets that was a clever way of addressing the parking.
[1:03:26] Probably is because it was built before there was a need for parking.
[1:03:29] But again, this is a 12 unit building that fits in quite nicely in this neighborhood,
[1:03:33] especially where it is, right?
[1:03:34] It's transitioning from the commercial portion out to the more single family portion.
[1:03:38] So it's transitional, it's right in that sweet spot.
[1:03:42] This is that other example I showed earlier, the Harbor House out in the high-annis.
[1:03:46] So again, this one in this case now that it does have some accommodation for its own parking.
[1:03:49] We're still coming into about 20 units to the acre on this.
[1:03:52] And this is fairly low scale, maybe this is a little dated, it's not the most charming,
[1:03:56] it could be a little bit better. But it's delivering 22 units to the acre in a form
[1:03:59] that I don't think would be so bad if put in the right location in the community.
[1:04:05] Some other examples, new construction that we've done,
[1:04:07] certainly you could think about a lot of the historic ends that you find on the cape,
[1:04:11] switch your eyes and think of it instead of being an end of being a six unit building or a 10 unit
[1:04:15] building but something that might that might fit in quite nicely.
[1:04:19] So these are our last two comparisons.
[1:04:21] How about between these two?
[1:04:24] This is usually an interesting one.
[1:04:26] Who thinks the one on the left would be more appropriate for South Sandwich?
[1:04:32] A couple of takers.
[1:04:34] How about the one on the right?
[1:04:37] A couple of takers?
[1:04:39] A lot of people that didn't vote at all.
[1:04:41] For those not voting, why no vote?
[1:04:42] Just tired of voting or something specific about this one.
[1:04:48] Neither one feels Cape Coddy,
[1:04:55] more urban on the right.
[1:05:01] One of the left feels dated. This one's in Orleans. This one I don't know where it is. Probably Jersey.
[1:05:07] But I thought this one was actually for a building that is a little more contemporary in its own day.
[1:05:12] It has the right materiality, the right scale, in some ways it's actually kind of charming for one that's traditional.
[1:05:17] But it does come across as dated a little bit as a result.
[1:05:21] How about between these two?
[1:05:24] Is there anyone that would take the image on the right as being more appropriate for self-sandwich?
[1:05:29] What if I said specifically for the, let's say, the self-sandwich village center, the triangle area.
[1:05:36] If you were going to do some of the scale of density up there, who would pick the one on the right?
[1:05:40] One, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, how about the one on the left?
[1:05:45] Two, three, four, five, six, seven, so kind of a split vote.
[1:05:49] For those of you that pick the one on the right, what made you think that was potentially more appropriate?
[1:05:58] Mixed use feeling. Yes, man.
[1:06:11] So for more time at new options, new looks. Keep people here.
[1:06:26] So that has the mixed use vibe.
[1:06:28] How about this? Yes, man.
[1:06:48] So even little details like the paint colors can have a big difference in how you feel about the place. So again, there were no right answers for these right. We threw up two images that we knew might have something different.
[1:06:56] Maybe we knew what we were trying to get out. The garages was an obvious one trying to talk a little bit about parking scale.
[1:07:01] But even on these, again, I could see either one of these working potentially in this area.
[1:07:07] But what's interesting is the here, what sort of things sort of rise the top?
[1:07:09] The importance of mixed use, the importance of appealing to maybe younger people on the Cape,
[1:07:13] really considering that the details in the character have to be appropriate here.
[1:07:17] Yes?
[1:07:43] So the potential efficiencies of a flat roof putting the candidates are you an architect? I should sign you up. Think about the good stuff. What? You can't have flat roofs here. Because of the snow? Okay? Yeah.
[1:08:04] Yeah.
[1:08:04] So the challenge of flat roofs in a snow sort of context. I mean, I will admit that this is in Providence. So you are correct. You need to account for that. You need to accommodate for that. So whatever efficiencies you might think you might have, you might have to balance.
[1:08:18] right.
[1:08:22] Yeah, it does. Yeah,
[1:08:31] the port was a device for, that's a good point. When we're
[1:08:33] talking about walkbook, pedestrian friendly places, having a place to actually sit and meet
[1:08:37] your neighbors is a nice feature. That might be part of why this one feels a little
[1:08:40] one more urban. You could certainly do something like this in a fairly urban context as well
[1:08:44] and provide that opportunity. Okay,
[1:08:48] variety. This one looks like it's on the beach. Yeah,
[1:08:52] This one, I'm trying to remember, this is from somewhere on the Cape, this is a historic in, I can't remember if it was maybe in Pianis, I can't remember at this point.
[1:09:01] But this is on the Cape, whereas this is technically in Providence, but again I think the comments that were made were very good.
[1:09:16] Yeah, so variety is very helpful.
[1:09:18] And I will say that that was one of the interesting things, this was one where I think we had sort of a split vote.
[1:09:22] So it might suggest something within the range of these is a good thing.
[1:09:25] And some of the islands were curious to see if it will go one way or the other, that could be telling as well.
[1:09:30] So I will very much suggest that the visual preference
[1:09:32] survey that we have online, it's very much specifically
[1:09:36] focused on scale and on style.
[1:09:39] And so our hope is by throwing a whole bunch of options
[1:09:41] for those that people will look and what's
[1:09:43] initially we're able to look, especially
[1:09:44] if we have 450 people voting.
[1:09:46] That's where we can really see those trends.
[1:09:48] And we show a bunch of options or some of these.
[1:09:51] All acceptable, and when have we gone too far,
[1:09:53] that people start to drop off and they're thinking on that.
[1:09:55] So that's why that survey is particularly helpful for us.
[1:10:24] So, right, so the fact that we have a couple of different pockets within that South Sandwich
[1:10:27] study area, I think that's a very astute observation, and I think one of the things that
[1:10:32] we imagine is we continue to have this conversation that some of these things, especially
[1:10:35] at this scale, that's why I kind of tease that question a little bit, you know, if we're
[1:10:39] thinking about South Sandwich Village could something like this feel right, where something
[1:10:43] like this down further down Route 130 might be getting to be a little bit too big when it's
[1:10:48] sort of slotted to almost immediately adjacent to single family, so we may very well, again
[1:10:52] we're going to see how things keep playing out, but I think we're going to have an answer
[1:10:55] where it's not one answer for all, maybe there's a sliding scale, it's one of the benefits
[1:10:59] of talking here about six different building types, maybe some are appropriate and some are appropriate
[1:11:04] and others, so it's a great observation. Yes sir.
[1:11:29] Right, so the issue of affordability, that's exactly
[1:11:31] one of the points here. So I think really what we're trying to get out is what what would you
[1:11:34] exist in zoning promote? It's promoting continuing to build single family houses in these areas
[1:11:40] And the point of all this is that you're not going to achieve your affordable housing goals by doing the same thing.
[1:11:46] There needs to be room for some moderate density, like I said earlier, this begins to help with your affordable equation.
[1:11:53] This won't be the silver bullet that solves the affordable equation.
[1:11:56] But to your point, we need more rental options.
[1:11:58] We need different housing types available, workforce housing, right? That's a big challenge here.
[1:12:03] I keep putting it in the lens of the people that already live here.
[1:12:06] And they're transitioning to a new life stage. You're getting older.
[1:12:08] You might be looking for different options, you might want to be able a little bit closer to the variety of uses that are out there.
[1:12:14] So it's an affordability thing, it's a workforce thing, it's an options for the existing residents thing, it's all of the above.
[1:12:25] Exactly.
[1:12:26] So that's what we've heard a lot of, that's that challenge of not having many rental opportunities.
[1:12:30] So you want to stay on the K operator, you want to even more so stay probably in your literal community.
[1:12:34] And if that community's made entirely of single family homes, there's no other options for you to stay in your community and move on to a different type of housing.
[1:12:42] Yes sir.
[1:13:29] Right.
[1:15:04] Yes, some around there.
[1:15:09] Yeah. I know.
[1:15:14] One second.
[1:15:15] Dick, Dick, can you hold on one second?
[1:15:18] I guess if you're going to have some long questions, if you can, please come up to the microphone,
[1:15:25] so they could, so they could hear it because there's no way Jeremy is very good,
[1:15:29] but there's no way he can encapsulate what you're saying, Dick.
[1:15:32] So, I think you got it.
[1:15:34] I think you got it.
[1:15:38] Please, just come up to the microphone and it's on it's and that's why we have it. So again, this is this is a community conversation
[1:15:46] We wanted to I don't need to just step in here. You know we want this to to go beyond tonight and beyond
[1:15:54] Beyond this room. This is going to be played often
[1:15:57] So for people who couldn't be here we could see it so they could so they could get a good idea and really participate in the survey
[1:16:04] So again, if you can step up to the microphone so here's what I'll suggest
[1:16:07] I'm almost done and we'll have room for discussions, maybe some of these broader questions.
[1:16:12] I will try to quickly recap what you said.
[1:16:15] So I think you made the first point that there's, you know, call it 500 units, already being
[1:16:19] proposed in this area, what do we do about the character of those in light of this sort
[1:16:23] of information?
[1:16:23] Obviously the challenge is you already have your existing regulations that we should what you
[1:16:27] need to review those projects against.
[1:16:29] So I think the idea here is especially in light of the new infrastructure improvements
[1:16:33] that are coming.
[1:16:34] Some of this is about getting ahead of the developments that might be coming down the road.
[1:16:37] Defining that character or tonight we're talking a lot about the form is the important thing earlier
[1:16:42] I made the comment about the form-based codes
[1:16:44] That's one of the options for rewriting or zoning is thinking less about uses and more about the forms
[1:16:49] That's the important thing. That's kind of the point. We're trying to make tonight
[1:16:52] So in light of not having reformed zoning, it's hard to judge existing projects differently than the way they are currently done
[1:16:59] And speaking to updating local compliance the densities allowed you're right. You might want to re-review some of that thought around this
[1:17:05] That's a good good concept as well and
[1:17:07] I don't remember what the last, oh, need good jobs.
[1:17:12] Yes.
[1:17:13] So again, I'm going to try to finish up quickly.
[1:17:15] We'll open up for discussion.
[1:17:16] That's probably a good time to come up.
[1:17:17] And if I, especially if you've made a point earlier,
[1:17:19] and I sort of overly simplified what you were trying to suggest,
[1:17:22] that's a good point to revisit that as well.
[1:17:23] So let me get through my last few slides here.
[1:17:25] Very quickly.
[1:17:26] So the last concept is that kind of leads right into this is
[1:17:30] when you're talking about mixed use, the idea there is that one building
[1:17:33] or one area might have not just residential, but other uses as well.
[1:17:36] Heather alluded to this two earlier. Most of these forms that we've been talking about today,
[1:17:41] you could imagine having a ground floor that's commercial use that could be retail that could be
[1:17:44] office, whatever the case might be. That form could still look very much like a man or house or some of
[1:17:49] these things we're talking about. But in reality that's a shop down below, maybe those are offices up above.
[1:17:54] So form is the important thing. Whatever the uses are inside of these classic main street building, right?
[1:17:59] Those are clearly shop downstairs, but there's might be units, there's might be offices, we're not sure what
[1:18:03] those are. But doing something like this in the right location is what we're really trying
[1:18:06] to suggest. And, or by the way, most historic village centers, those things have changed
[1:18:11] over time. The important thing was they got the character right. And the fact that for a little
[1:18:15] while it was a shoe manufacturing facility and later it was a hip coffee joint and then
[1:18:20] it became somebody's lawyer law practice, right? The form stayed the same, the form is what
[1:18:25] we loved and it was the uses that changed over time. So forms can host the variety of uses.
[1:18:31] So, again, what we've been talking about tonight, thinking about these areas in particular, really
[1:18:36] what we just wanted to recap was, again, these are the different types we've been talking
[1:18:39] about tonight.
[1:18:39] I think we had a good conversation about maybe there are some places where some of these
[1:18:43] feel right, maybe there are some places where the others feel right, maybe all can fit in certain
[1:18:46] areas as well, but now is what I'm just going to transition into discussion.
[1:18:50] So, this is a chance to also come back and revisit any of these if there was something about
[1:18:54] the walkups that rubbed you the wrong way or cottages as just isn't quite enough, whatever
[1:18:58] you might be thinking we can circle back to those things.
[1:19:01] So I will just present next steps and then we'll say that that will be a discussion.
[1:19:05] Don't forget the visual preference survey, tell your friends, post on your social media,
[1:19:09] however you get the word out, and we'll be back in early September.
[1:19:12] So please keep an eye out.
[1:19:13] I'd love to have you guys come back so you can hopefully see how we've reflected on some
[1:19:16] of the things we've talked about tonight and certainly what we hear about in that larger
[1:19:19] survey.
[1:19:20] Form-based framework is almost done and again another plug for those of you that might be interested
[1:19:24] in the one-cap Summit July 29th and 30th.
[1:19:27] So with that, step-and-back, open conversation.
[1:19:32] So please, any questions, thoughts?
[1:19:34] You're going to have to come up to the mic.
[1:19:38] I'm not going to get scolded at a fifth time for that.
[1:19:46] Good evening.
[1:19:47] I'd just like to make the point that it seems to me
[1:19:51] that the real operative word for me is quality,
[1:19:55] the quality of the design, the quality of the construction,
[1:19:59] and the quality of life that that design and construction provides.
[1:20:03] I live the White House and back of the newplex I've lived in for over 35 years and it's a great little and and up until very recently was the owner occupied unit the other
[1:20:17] When you show was directly across the street from it.
[1:20:21] It's a very well designed constructed building that is very well into the historic center.
[1:20:27] I have never seen a duplex built today by today's affordable housing standards that looks like that duplex.
[1:20:36] The cottage style, once again, is a Greek revival authentic mid-18th century,
[1:20:44] was painstakingly restored by the former owner who replaced all the windows and did so with historically
[1:20:51] correct windows and doors, beautiful landscaping. I see very few affordable and priced, you know,
[1:20:59] cottage developments that really look like what that house looks like. So I think in going forward,
[1:21:06] it's a very big concern for people that, you know, that I think all of the designs that you've shown
[1:21:13] can work in South Sand, which is, you know, whether they be mixed use or cottage or doplex or townhouse,
[1:21:19] But I think that what frightens a lot of people
[1:21:24] off sometimes is like, what are they going to look like in 20 years?
[1:21:28] And I know that that's a concern.
[1:21:30] It very often we see shabby design, shabby construction.
[1:21:35] For me, most of the choices that you gave us,
[1:21:38] I felt down on which building would I prefer to live in.
[1:21:42] You had a slide where there was a front porch with a turret and a great
[1:21:46] and the other one was just the box that you'd
[1:21:49] in an out-up, where you may be rocking chairs on the porch or just visually that was more pleasing.
[1:21:56] And the quality of its design and construction, in my opinion, far-out way, living in a box with a little stoop, you know, in a row.
[1:22:06] So I think that, you know, going forward that we, you know, for me at any rate, I think quality is a really important issue.
[1:22:15] I think that's a great comment and the only thing I'll add is, when you think through these things, again,
[1:22:21] the existing zoning might just prescribe a density and a setback, but it might not get into character or materiality.
[1:22:28] It probably does, but it only,
[1:22:30] A very small level and so it's another thing to consider in addition to form could be that sort of character and that's where things like design guidelines might come into play, form-based codes, you can certainly embed some of that amount of information, but it's a very good point.
[1:22:42] It's important that that's how it makes it feel like it belongs in your that context and that setting. It's kind of a contextually appropriate character. So thank you.
[1:22:50] Yes sir, I'd like to tell you what the population is in this town.
[1:22:57] It's 19,331, that's the latest count, and that was done by Taylor White, and it's much
[1:23:04] lower than the projection.
[1:23:07] In fact, it's the lowest it's been for many, many years.
[1:23:10] The population's going down, do you know that?
[1:23:17] Second of all, housing for whom is the first question, and housing for what purpose
[1:23:22] second. I have a son who's a single man. He would like to rent a place for $800.
[1:23:29] And he can't find one. So think about that. If I was downsizing in my wife's, she doesn't want to.
[1:23:37] We would like to have a unit for around $300,000. What can we buy for that? Just think about it.
[1:23:43] It's a poor planning going to fit both of these. Thank you. Excellent point.
[1:23:48] And I think that speaks to that issue we talked about rising housing costs, but people's
[1:23:53] income is not going up quite as much, so that that challenge is becoming more and more
[1:23:56] of a challenge too.
[1:23:57] It's time to change that.
[1:24:09] To expound on Dave, David Dowling, I just like to make sure that we're addressing both ownership
[1:24:19] and rental, because that's really what this is about.
[1:24:22] And we have no rental units, and even when we do, they're took condominimizing.
[1:24:29] And that's a huge problem because then they become home ownership that becomes more expensive
[1:24:36] housing.
[1:24:36] So, even if people are buying that unit and condominimizing it and then turning around and
[1:24:43] renting it, it's higher, because they're cost of higher, they've got taxes to pay and
[1:24:47] everything else.
[1:24:48] So, to get that affordable rental unit, I do have a thing that we have to look at, buildings that may not look like typically cake-card buildings.
[1:25:00] Also, so much as a 35 foot high restriction.
[1:25:05] So, to get three stories, you can lose those pretty tolerance and arches and everything else unless we adapt zoning that would allow for that
[1:25:16] as a non-residential decorative decorations.
[1:25:21] So basically, I just think that when we're looking at all of these,
[1:25:25] we have to think about affordable rental units,
[1:25:28] because, again, I have two single sons
[1:25:33] that are looking for rental units on Cape Cod,
[1:25:36] they're not gonna find them.
[1:25:37] Right, I'm sorry, thank you, but you're very much.
[1:25:50] Yes,
[1:26:02] I know we heard about the housing for young people and I want to say the same thing.
[1:26:07] If there's no housing for 22 to 35 year olds here, if you're a young first responder, young nurse, young school teacher,
[1:26:15] who's absolutely nothing to live in unless you want to live in your parents' back in the basement.
[1:26:20] So we need to find some mechanism to have housing for these types of folks to keep them on the cake.
[1:26:26] The shakers didn't have any young people around and now their towns are museums.
[1:26:32] So we want to make sure that we have a future here for the young people to keep them here.
[1:26:37] Second point I'd like to make is if you go to the...
[1:26:39] You have a few of these buildings, the cottage, the duplex, the townhouse, on the other side of the railroad tracks.
[1:26:46] If that community was built in Nantucket, all of those houses would be a million dollars.
[1:26:51] If you walk, you know, maybe they're not in the same state of repair.
[1:26:55] But looking at that community over there, if we could condense that,
[1:26:58] and use those same design elements up in South Sanwich, I think it would be a perfect set.
[1:27:02] Yeah, excellent. Thank you very much.
[1:27:03] You know, and I will also say, again, I also want to make sure it's clear.
[1:27:06] Just because you suddenly start building townhouses, it doesn't solve all of the challenges, right?
[1:27:10] This is one of a multi-layered thing that needs to happen.
[1:27:13] I'm one small piece, Heather's going to solve all the other issues, her in the Cape Cod Commission, right?
[1:27:20] It is a very complex issue, but that's why it's important to talk about her, right?
[1:27:24] Yes, ma'am.
[1:27:25] So I know that you're right now, you guys are just focusing on housing.
[1:27:29] But I want to make sure that housing has something to go with it.
[1:27:34] So as far as like an excuse, capabilities, and something to draw the people to these communities
[1:27:40] and to make it an actual community and not just housing, you know, sort of like based on like the
[1:27:46] traditional neighborhood development plan. I mean we have that right here in the village and it
[1:27:51] would be really nice to see those components go into these housing development. So I guess my question for you is,
[1:28:00] like, what stage do you start implementing sort of the mixed use or are you just starting with housing or is it
[1:28:07] a comprehensive plan that starts with housing as far as the implementation, but as far as the design component everything's included in that master plan.
[1:28:17] Yeah, we are focused on the housing, and that's in part because this is an extension of this same conversation we've been having in other communities.
[1:28:25] So the mixed use piece is an important piece. I will even say that study area. Those are my circles like that's not a town to find study area.
[1:28:34] It's really, so I would say that this conversation is more about the principles and the types that might inform the housing and even potentially the mixed use.
[1:28:42] But we are not developing a specific zoning change or a specific plan for this part of town if that makes sense.
[1:28:52] So this meant to be sort of a first step slightly bigger picture before getting into those issues and even more detail.
[1:28:57] But certainly you can see from the con plan and that's that is the intention these growth centers should be mixed use
[1:29:02] They should include these things and certainly the areas. I identified typically right now have commercial uses in them
[1:29:08] So it should continue to have commercial uses in them
[1:29:12] Thanks. Yeah, thank you.
[1:29:22] Comment about mixed use. I like to just point out some history here in
[1:29:29] 2013 the Cape Cod Commission funded a market study by the Chesapeake Group
[1:29:34] The consultant looked at Cape Cod, town by town, and zip code by zip code.
[1:29:40] The Chesapeake Group's study concluded that the uppercayp in general and sandwich
[1:29:48] in particular cannot support significantly more retail space until at least 233.
[1:30:00] Okay, thank you. I get some of this too is planning for the future even if it's not here now, so not to, but it's a good point. I will also say market studies are usually outdated within the time they're printed, which is an unfortunate thing. But I think what you're speaking to that trend is still largely true. Most communities we're working in, there's not a lot of need for lots of new, not so new retail.
[1:30:22] Yeah.
[1:30:28] Kiss me.
[1:30:29] Dude, like the idea of variety in the development down the road, we've lived here
[1:30:37] 33 years and I also agree that quality is going to be paramount in the planning.
[1:30:46] But I would just say I would hope before anything is done that we have a comprehensive vision
[1:30:54] of what that whole area is going to look like, because in our experience, it's been such a
[1:31:01] piecemeal development,
[1:31:05] not quality materials that have looked a day with a few years.
[1:31:12] And I just hope that we don't follow that pattern that we, and I agree that the economic folks
[1:31:22] in town have got to be a part of this because we've got to talk about jobs if we're going
[1:31:30] to attract our young children and ours are off-cap working elsewhere if we've got to give
[1:31:37] them something to do at a decent wage that they can afford to lay up here, build it and
[1:31:46] that they will come.
[1:31:49] Absolutely, thank you.
[1:31:55] All right?
[1:31:57] Thank you.
[1:31:58] Ralph wants to make a couple of closing comments.
[1:32:01] But I certainly want to thank all of you for your incredibly thoughtful comments.
[1:32:05] I just want to remind you of something I said very early in the presentation
[1:32:08] when we looked at what the potential is for the cape and for the region.
[1:32:13] The population, the job growth.
[1:32:16] those trends positively into the future rely on a functioning economy and a functioning economy
[1:32:23] relies on a housing market that meets the needs of the community.
[1:32:27] So all of the comments that you've made tonight are really consistent with what we know we need as a region.
[1:32:32] So we've been really glad to be a part of this conversation, and we'll continue to work with Ralph.
[1:32:37] I think we can talk a little bit about the next phases of this.
[1:32:40] The next phase of this piece is to come back with you with a conceptual model of the development strategy
[1:32:46] that would include those transitional forms of housing with some mixed use development, but from there,
[1:32:51] we'll be then working with the community on planning on some regulatory reform to help
[1:32:56] zoning, to help the community meet its own vision. So this is a small part of a small project
[1:33:03] of a larger planning study. So thank you very much for your time, Ralph, do you want to say a couple
[1:33:08] things?
[1:33:12] Yeah, and I want to thank everyone for showing up and you know, as Heather stated,
[1:33:17] You know, this is the beginning, again, the local comprehensive plan is 10 years old.
[1:33:24] We would Jared be highlighted, it's something that we've all been talking about, and
[1:33:28] you know, we had to ask the question, and how come it hasn't happened yet.
[1:33:32] So we're breaking it down into smaller pieces, easier chunks, making it the final.
[1:33:38] The biggest question I get from developers was what the sandwich want.
[1:33:42] So it's easy to open up to a page in the local comprehensive plan, but we want to be a little more substantive than that.
[1:33:51] So again, this is the beginning.
[1:33:54] This is just one portion as we look at the root 130 development.
[1:33:59] This is what we do to tie it all together.
[1:34:05] So I do appreciate all of you for being a part of it.
[1:34:09] part of the beginning stages and I ask you to continue to participate, please go to the survey,
[1:34:17] take the survey and if you can't push it out to whoever you know so they could take the survey
[1:34:22] as well because you know we need to know what the town people want and what they'll accept as
[1:34:28] as the one and function. So you'll be hearing from our office early September, you know probably
[1:34:35] the second week in September, we'll be having a follow-up to this meeting, you know, have
[1:34:40] everybody go through the summer and enjoy it. And then we'll really start getting to work.
[1:34:47] You know, I appreciate it. Thank you very much and hope to see you in September.