11:00 AM - Closed Session and Regular Meeting - Sep 9th, 2025

Santa Clara Valley Water District, CA · More Santa Clara Valley Water District, CA meetings · More California meetings

Agenda

[1:37] CALL TO ORDER/ROLL CALL:
[1:57] Roll Call.
[9:07] District Counsel Report on Closed Session.
[9:34] Pledge of Allegiance/National Anthem.
[10:04] Orders of the Day.
[10:14] Time Open for Public Comment on any Item not on the Agenda.
[14:32] Adopt a Resolution Authorizing the Execution and Delivery of Corps Water Infrastructure Financing Program Master Agreements, Credit Agreements, Term Sheets and Certain Other Documents with Respect to the Water Utility, and Authorizing Certain Acts in Connection Therewith, to Obtain Loans of up to One Billion Dollars for Certain Water Enterprise Projects.
[24:01] Receive and Discuss Revisions to the Draft Water Supply Master Plan 2050 and Provide Feedback to Staff.
[1:31:53] CONSENT CALENDAR:
[1:32:24] Board Committee Reports.
[1:32:40] CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER:
[1:35:05] 25-0684 Review the Fiscal Year 2026 Board Policy Planning Calendar.

Transcript

Download: Text · SRT
AI TRANSCRIPT

This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.

[1:37] Good morning, everybody. I'm Vice Chair Richard Santos. Welcome to Santa Clara Valley Water District Board of Directors meeting. We're having a close session on regular meeting.
[1:47] We'll start at the 11 o'clock here and then we'll come back at 1 o'clock.
[1:51] Council, anything to add?
[1:53] I'll tell you, Mr. Mayor, the chair is back waiting to close session.
[1:57] With that, we'll take roll call.
[1:59] Director Ballard, Director Bell, Director Eisenberg, Director Shua, Vice Chair Santos.
[2:06] Yes, Director Verella, Chair Estimera, you have a quorum.
[2:11] Yes, thank you, Candice.
[2:12] And by the way, Director John got a new pickup.
[2:16] Rather than raving about it out there, it was real good.
[2:19] So we'll see you in about a couple hours.
[2:21] Thank you.
[7:27] All
[8:47] right.
[8:51] Good afternoon, I'll call the meeting back to order, apologies for being starting a little later. We just need to finish our work earlier.
[9:06] So I have a report on the close session.
[9:10] Thank you, Mr. Chair. Carlos Adriana, district council, respect to item 2.1, the board met in close session with all directors participating and no reportable action was taken and I'll turn it to you for the report.
[9:20] on item 2.2 Mr. Chair. Thank you.
[9:27] On item 0.2 same same thing happened, we had a discussion.
[9:31] No action was taken.
[9:33] We'll go on to pledge of allegiance.
[9:37] Let's see. Yeah.
[9:38] Approach of allegiance.
[9:39] We have an estimate.
[9:41] We'll start this sign.
[9:43] I'll write to the Rela police leaders.
[9:45] I'll give you the plan of the United States of America.
[9:50] And to be with public, for which this lands, one nation, fundamental and divisible,
[9:56] to be living in justice for all.
[10:01] We'll start this slide. Director de Rela, please, leaders.
[10:19] Thank you.
[10:24] Good to go to orders of the day,
[10:32] orders of the day. I don't have any requests.
[10:35] time open for the public comment, now's the time for any members of the public that might
[10:40] want to address us on any issue, not on the agenda. Mr. Chair, may I make a comment?
[10:47] Yes. Just to break the ice of attention, I'd like to say two words. John Buzwa.
[10:53] All right. Thank you, Vice Chair.
[11:01] And with that, I will.
[11:06] We're still wondering why most people aren't sitting on this side and we wonder what the problem is over there.
[11:13] So we'll figure out how to make it more comfortable or more efficient or better or more.
[11:20] All right, I am.
[11:24] Before we get going, I will read our.
[11:27] Now, setting board member questions and comments and time limits, I asked that we follow these
[11:33] guidelines to ensure a smooth and consistent flow for today's board meeting. Presentations and
[11:39] questions. Board members, please allow presenters to complete their presentation before asking
[11:45] questions, unless designated breaks or questions are provided. Board member questions and comments should
[11:50] be limited to three minutes. The board member at the end of their three minutes may can request
[11:56] additional two minutes from the chair. If granted by the chair, they make a
[12:00] ten year for the additional two minutes. The click of the board will serve as a
[12:03] timekeeper. And please respect the time limits.
[12:08] Public comments, I will invite public comments after the board has spoken.
[12:12] All members of the public are provided three minutes to present their comments to the board.
[12:17] Motion is in voting following the public comments. I will call for motion in the second before
[12:21] proceeding with a role called vote.
[12:24] Confidence on confidential subjects, as chair of the Board of the Valley Board of District, I would
[12:29] like to take a moment to underscore the critical responsibility that each board member has
[12:34] to uphold the confidentiality of any ongoing personnel investigations and accordance with
[12:39] our governance policies.
[12:41] Now fiduciary duty is to rate pairs of sign-and-clear accounting.
[12:46] This duty extends not only to our financial stewardship of the district, but also to ensure
[12:50] the integrity of our processes and the trust placed in us by all stakeholders, including
[12:56] employees, leadership and the community. During these investigations, we may be privy to
[13:02] extremely sensitive personal information in our official capacity as elected leaders of
[13:07] this agency. It is paramount that we respect the privacy of those involved and maintain confidentiality.
[13:17] sharing or discussing this information outside of also rights and appropriate channels could jeopardize the fairness and integrity of that process and expose the district to unnecessary legal reputation and financial risk.
[13:30] Please know that professionals with great expertise and experience are carrying out the duty and body of work with which we've entrusted it.
[13:39] I appreciate everyone that here is to our governance policies and this group's collective commitment to the governance of the district.
[13:47] If a board member begins to discuss confidential subjects, they will receive a warning and then be asked to leave if they continue.
[13:54] Code of Condem, as a reminder, as board members, we are committed to ethical, business like and lawful conduct,
[14:01] with appropriate decorum as stated in our board on the director's Code of Ethics and Condu.
[14:08] Out of order, if a board member is out of order of order more than two to three times,
[14:13] I will ask them to take a five minute break from days.
[14:16] If they've ruled out of order again, they will be asked to leave for the remainder of the meeting.
[14:21] If they do not leave voluntarily, then on the state law and value order ordinance,
[14:25] 22-03, they can be ordered to be removed.
[14:29] I really hope that we never get to that point, and that all board members will follow the code of ethics and conduct, and I'll lose it to the core.
[14:37] I follow these guidelines, we can ensure an efficient and productive meeting.
[14:41] May I have a motion to accept these guidelines?
[14:57] All right.
[14:58] Go a water infrastructure
[15:00] Asterig Remis, credit agreements, term sheets, and certain other documents of respect to the
[15:04] awardee utility, and also rising certain acts and connection they're with, to obtain loans
[15:09] up to $1 billion a certain award and enterprise projects.
[15:14] Sarah and Taylor?
[15:15] Excuse me, Chair. I just wanted to note that there were no public comments on minor in person.
[15:20] Oh, thank you. I'd like to see you, so.
[15:23] Appreciate it. Sarah?
[15:29] Good afternoon, Chair. Members of the Board. My name is Charmin and son of the Treasury and
[15:34] officer for Valley Water. With me today is the financing team. We have Mr.
[15:38] Laura's Chen from Strabbling. He is our Bond Council and CFO Daryntailer and on the
[15:44] right is Mr. Ed Song from Public Resources Advisory Group. He is our municipal
[15:49] advisor on this particular transaction.
[15:56] So I have a very brief presentation if
[15:58] it pleases a board. I will go through the presentation quickly. Thank you. Okay, so we are
[16:06] seeking your approval of a resolution to enter into the core water infrastructure financing
[16:11] program or SwiftP. The authorization will allow value water to secure up to $1 billion in low
[16:20] cost federal loans for our Dan Safety program. SwiftP is administered by the U.S. Army Corps
[16:28] of Engineers and provides federal credit assistance for Dan Safety Project. The program can fund
[16:34] up to 80% of eligible project costs with low interest rates.
[16:39] Repainment can be deferred for up to five years and spread over 35 years after construction
[16:46] completion.
[16:47] Such a long period of time is not practically available in the municipal debt markets,
[16:54] and the loans can be prepared any time without penalty.
[16:58] This is why this type of loan program is very attracted to us.
[17:04] The Master Agreement will cover multiple dam safety retrofit projects under Valley Waters Capital Program.
[17:12] The $1 billion authorization would allow Valley Waters to finance the 4 dam safety projects planning design and construction costs.
[17:21] The initial master program and now that we negotiated with the Army Corps is 653 million,
[17:28] and the first loan to fund planning and design costs for the Almedin Colero and Guadalupe dams is 112.6 million.
[17:36] The remaining authorization would fund the Capitalized Interest Estimates and also to fund the costs related to the Cayoli dam project down the road.
[17:47] Based on market conditions, should I continue?
[17:52] Okay, based on market conditions as of September 8th,
[17:55] so as of yesterday, the estimated true interest cost is now 4.7%
[18:00] so this is lower than what's shown on this slide
[18:02] because we prepared this slide about a month ago.
[18:05] So right now it's 4.7% as of yesterday's market rates
[18:09] for an average life of the loan of 35 years.
[18:12] This is the interest rate paid after accounting for all the fees
[18:16] and timing of payments. The finance charge is estimated to be 5.72% for the master program of which
[18:23] 1.13 million is estimated for the first loan. The total amount of proceeds received for the master
[18:30] program is 647 million and the total principal and interest payments is 1.7 million. For the first
[18:38] loan of 112.6 million, the total principal and interest repayment amount is estimated at 312 million.
[18:46] The estimate is savings for the entire program is 126 million and 19 million for the first loan compared to if we had to issue long-term revenue bonds in the open capital markets.
[18:59] So these estimates are based on yesterday's market conditions as I stated, and it made very depending on market conditions at the time of closing.
[19:09] Right now, we're targeting closing on October 6, but that is subject to change, pending the credit approval process of the US Army Corps and also the Office of Management and Budget at the federal level.
[19:25] So key features of this program is outlined here. They include the low cost borrowing, type to US Treasury rates, flexible financing terms and federal oversight.
[19:35] The terms will help valley water manage financial risk and ensure affordability of these critically important safety projects.
[19:46] The first is what P-Lone will provide up to 80% or 112.6 million of the planning and design costs currently estimated for El Medin-Colero and Guadalupe dams.
[20:00] That profile for valley water overall layering in the SWFP loan in the orange section. So I want to note that the blue section for the WIFI alone would now be smaller, because per the board's direction on August 26th, we are in discussions with the EPA to terminate the WIFI alone related to Pacheco. So the blue bars would be smaller after we factor that in.
[20:24] So, but the main point of this graphic is to show that using a federal program like the SwiftP loan to fund these major long-term dam safety projects will allow us to keep level debt service over the long-term and provide intergenerational equity to ensure that the cost of building these long-lasting public assets are shared fairly across the generations that will benefit from these programs.
[20:54] And this concludes my presentation and the team is here to answer any questions.
[21:00] Thank you, Shonen.
[21:01] Third person, Bert.
[21:03] Thank you.
[21:04] Can you please go back to slide page six?
[21:10] Okay.
[21:10] So you say that size of the loan is approximately 650 million.
[21:17] Yes.
[21:18] And using this example, I know that it's lower now.
[21:21] but using this example of 5.545% interest rate, is that what you mean by true interest costs?
[21:29] Yes. Okay, so interest rate. How did you get the figure 5.72 million as your finance charge?
[21:40] Yes. So if you refer to the board agenda memo, there is a section that talks about issuance costs.
[21:48] So the issuance cost we have calculated for the first loan is 1.133.
[21:54] I'm sorry, I don't need to cut you off, but you're talking right now just about closing costs.
[22:00] That's what that 5.72 million is.
[22:02] Finance charges are closing costs.
[22:04] Okay, but you didn't, where is the, where is the, oh, okay, so it's 1.85 billion.
[22:11] kind of total payment. Okay, so you're saying that on a approximately 650 million dollar loan,
[22:22] the repayment cost would be approximately three times the size of the loan. Yes.
[22:31] So I just want to make sure I have that straight. So borrow 650, we repay more than three times that.
[22:40] So really the effective interest rate is 300% when you use the time value of money.
[22:51] That was kind of a rhetorical question.
[22:53] If you borrow one dollar and you have to repay three dollars, the effective interest rate
[22:59] is 300%, which means three times the amount borrowed.
[23:03] But as you confirmed, we will have to repay three times the amount bar.
[23:11] So I want to note that for the record, that was the same as the wifio loans for Pacheco,
[23:18] and I do not believe that this is a good deal.
[23:23] I think we need to stay within the budget.
[23:26] So that I'm just staying there.
[23:27] So thank you for letting this out clearly.
[23:29] There are questions.
[23:36] I'll entertain a motion to adopt the resolution.
[23:39] That's the right thing.
[23:40] Second.
[23:41] Motion.
[23:42] Second.
[23:42] Roll.
[23:43] Director.
[23:45] Director.
[23:46] Bell.
[23:47] Director.
[23:48] Eisenberg.
[23:49] No.
[23:50] Director.
[23:50] Yes.
[23:52] Vice chair.
[23:52] Director.
[23:53] Aurora.
[23:54] I.
[23:56] Resolution passes.
[23:57] Thank you.
[24:01] We're along the 3.5.
[24:03] That's an information item.
[24:04] receive in discussed revisions to the draft water supply, massive plan, 2050, and provides
[24:10] feedback to the staff. I will point out that there's some revisions that have been made since,
[24:20] we've made some decisions that are last couple of board meetings.
[24:27] Yes, good afternoon,
[24:28] chair and members of the board. My name is Kirsten Stoob, assistant officer for the water supply
[24:33] division. At the June 10th Board meeting, we presented the draft water supply
[24:38] mass plan, 2050, and we're asked to return with the draft. So here we are based on
[24:43] the input and feedback from the board committees and public comments. We have revised
[24:48] the draft plan and I'm bringing it to you today. The presentation will go through the major
[24:53] revisions of the draft plan and include also clarification responses to common questions
[24:58] and discussion.
[25:00] And as you noted, there is a handout with revised slides. And with me to answer questions, our Jingu Vincent Jins, Nigah and Darim Taylor.
[25:14] Valley Water has a comprehensive flexible water system that is interconnected and designed to convey, store and deliver valley waterstabbers sources of water supply, including local surface water, groundwater, imported water, and recycled water.
[25:27] Our current system and sources of water supply can meet demands during wet and normal years,
[25:32] but extended droughts remain the biggest water supply challenge.
[25:37] Maintaining our existing water supply infrastructure,
[25:40] while developing new infrastructure and response to existing and emerging challenges
[25:44] is what the water supply must plan as well.
[25:51] Achieving rally water future water supply reliability requires planning ahead
[25:55] because water supply infrastructure can take decades to develop.
[26:01] Valley water supply master plan serves as a guiding document to determine the right level of
[26:05] investment to ensure water supply reliability for our county. The plan assesses future water
[26:11] supply outlook and demand protections and identifies and prioritise strategies to meet the county's
[26:17] current and future needs, and it has updated every five years to adapt to changing conditions and
[26:23] as an annual monitoring and assessment report.
[26:28] Just to recap, we previously presented three potential investments
[26:31] strategies, lower costs, local control and diversified,
[26:35] which were developed through project evaluation
[26:37] and portfolio analysis.
[26:39] These three potential strategies represent different approaches
[26:42] to water supply reliability, but each comes with trade-offs.
[26:47] On August 26, the board decided to suspend the Pacheca Reservoir
[26:50] Expansion Project, which necessitates changes
[26:53] to the local control and diverse fight strategies to replace the Pacheco project.
[27:00] Staff proposes to use the following portfolios instead. We had analyzed additional portfolios
[27:06] that would address future shortage and include them in an appendix to the water supply
[27:11] mass supply and so for now we think the lower cost stays the same. The reason the cost is lower
[27:16] now is due to an update in the pure water project cost for local control instead of Pacheco,
[27:22] We increase groundwater banking, and for diversified,
[27:25] we add the site's reservoir project instead of Pacheco.
[27:29] Changing these two portfolios will not result
[27:31] in major changes to the structure approach
[27:33] or narrative of the water supply master plan.
[27:39] Given different options, an uncertainty
[27:41] associated with future conditions and project development
[27:44] staff proposes an adaptive management approach
[27:47] to support investment decisions.
[27:50] With this framework, staff recommends prioritizing the lower
[27:53] cost portfolio, which includes pure water silicon valley delta conveyance project, BF-sisk
[27:58] dam raise, groundwater banking, and South County recharge, while continuing to plan for other
[28:04] projects and making incremental investment decisions through adaptive management, and of course
[28:09] continuing our conservation programs. Maintaining our existing infrastructure is assumed in the baseline
[28:15] and therefore remains the highest priority. And a light of the Pacheco decision, other storage
[28:21] options including local reservoir expansion and retrofit will be explored and evaluated through
[28:26] the adaptive management approach.
[28:32] Since our June update, we revised the draft plan and
[28:35] response to feedback and comments from the board committees, stakeholders in the public.
[28:40] The draft order supply mass plan was posted for 45 days for public review and five entities
[28:46] provided written comments and are listed here. The revised plan with major changes tracked
[28:52] is attached as attachment one and the response to comment is attachment two and the rest of
[28:58] this presentation will cover major changes to the plan as well as the responses to common
[29:03] questions and feedback received and I'll stop sort of midway for any questions you might have.
[29:09] That's questions.
[29:13] No questions. All right. At the June board meeting there was a lot of
[29:18] discussion about how the water supply mass fan relates to valley water policies and the board's
[29:24] One policy E2 water supply services lays out valley waters policy for water supply planning
[29:29] and management.
[29:30] This policy establishes not only valley waters level of service school, but also five
[29:35] other water supply goals and associated objectives, and it is the basis in guidance for
[29:40] the water supply mass supply and now add it to the draft plan both in the text and as an appendix.
[29:49] The main purpose of the water supply mass supply and is to identify valley waters future needs
[29:53] and develop an investment strategy to meet those needs.
[29:58] The worst flame aspect does that by...
[30:00] All right, taking available projects and program options and identifying the best investment strategies among those options, through project evaluation and portfolio analysis.
[30:10] The plan is not intended to determine project design and capacity which is done outside of the water supply and maths plan process.
[30:18] But even with adoption of the water supply and maths plan planning does not stop and annual updates are provided through the monitoring and assessment program.
[30:27] Public comments requested more information on the relationship of the water supply master plan to other plans.
[30:34] Perst date requirements, valley water also develops an urban water management plan, and a water shortage contingency plan, both are required to be updated every five years.
[30:45] The urban water management plan is also a long-range plan, so it is consistent with and informed by the water supply master plan.
[30:51] But it also includes other information and might use different imported water data
[30:56] per the states requirements.
[31:00] We plan to use the demand projection water supply strategies developed for the water supply
[31:04] mass plan 2050 for the next urban water management plan update,
[31:08] which is required to be completed by July next year, so 2026.
[31:13] And the water shortage contingency plan establishes actions and procedures for managing
[31:18] water shortages due to droughts and other emergencies, including triggers for water use reduction
[31:23] call, and these triggers are incorporated in the water supply mass plan model analysis to serve
[31:29] as a key indicator of system health and determine whether a portfolio meets the level of
[31:34] service goal.
[31:39] Several public comments related to the Bay Delta plan and proposed voluntary
[31:42] agreements and the impacts on valley water's imported water supply. If implemented, they could
[31:48] impacts to water deliveries to common customer retailers also certified as San Francisco Public Utility
[31:54] Commission as well as our own imported supplies. Currently those requirements are still under
[32:01] review and may change and so the exact impacts are not sufficiently understood but we did
[32:06] add additional discussion on the Bay Delta plan to the draft plan.
[32:15] Following the board referral from
[32:17] Back in June, a staff presented information on the potential opportunities to expand non-potable recycled water use in the county at the July 30th, recycled water committee meeting.
[32:28] The topics included the county white water reuse master plan, the current non-potable system.
[32:34] The assumption in the water supply master plan that they would be moderate growth and non-potable reuse from 17,000 to 20,000 acre feet per year.
[32:43] Regulatory requirements, and water quality, and benefits, and challenges of non-photable reuse.
[32:49] Attachment 3 to your packet provides the detailed information on these topics.
[32:55] And as discussed as the Recycle Water Committee, a joint study with the City of San Jose found that the development of potable reuse
[33:02] to add to our base water supply is more economically favorable, as opposed to further development of a supplemental water supply,
[33:10] Meaning non-portable views and the recycling purified water section of the draft and was expanded to include some of the information presented to the committee.
[33:23] I will stop in a couple slides, unless you want me to take a question.
[33:30] After the June Board meeting, we received updated costs information for pure water silicon valiant science reservoir, pure water silicon valiant costs went down slightly from 2.1 billion to 1.7 billion.
[33:41] and SIVES reservoir costs increased, which for valley water share resulted in an increase from
[33:47] 140 million to 210 million. And the updated costs are highlighted in this table, along with
[33:53] costs for other water supply projects, all are in $20, $25. Unfortunately, we failed to update
[33:59] the diesel project costs. They should be exactly the same as the pure water silicon valley.
[34:04] We did update it in the plan just not on this slide. And then for completeness, we have the storage
[34:10] projects here. We were also asked to provide more detail on project cost estimation line items.
[34:21] And we added that to the plan. So this table shows the line items for capital costs as well as the
[34:26] annual cost. And we added more information to appendix G as well. So those were the major
[34:34] changes to the plan and the next few slides will cover responses to questions and discussion from
[34:39] board committees in the public and I'll pause here for any questions then.
[34:43] There we go.
[34:45] Thank you.
[34:49] Okay.
[34:49] Thank you.
[34:50] Can you please go back to slide 12?
[34:53] Page 12?
[34:57] Yeah.
[34:59] Okay.
[35:00] We'll cover responses to questions and discussion from the Board, committees, and the public, and I'll pause here for any questions then.
[35:07] There we go. Thank you.
[35:13] Okay, thank you. Can you go back to slide 12, page 12?
[35:22] Okay, that one, and it was during you're talking about this slide that you noted that
[35:32] some group was it was it the, was it the, our board committee determined that non-potable
[35:42] use was less economically feasible than portable reuse. Who was it that made that the termination?
[35:52] It was a study that was conducted jointly with the City of San Jose sometime back.
[35:57] And when was that you said? It is in that let me find it.
[36:03] 2014, 2014, 2014. Okay, so 11 years ago a study was done and without seeing that study and looking at it,
[36:10] to really assume that this is a determinative study on the, you know, how much more expensive
[36:17] do you think imported water is now than it was 11 years ago? Well, imported water is one of almost
[36:27] affordable supplies now, $450 an acre foot and I am not sure. My question is how much more expensive
[36:32] it is now than it was then, and including cost to treat.
[36:40] Is there any, so I think that that I'm just
[36:43] going to put out there that that doesn't seem like a determinative study in any way whatsoever,
[36:49] if from what I've seen the cost of and read, the cost of imported water, including treating it,
[36:57] has risen exponentially in the past 11 years, multiple times over, which obviously is going to
[37:13] I think that if a decision is going to be made on behalf of the board about which is more financially feasible at very least, well, first of all, I don't think that is I think that's a board decision based on updated numbers.
[37:28] It was a decision in 2014.
[37:31] I mean, I can't hear the people talking over me. I'm so sorry, but I'm not sorry because I don't recall being asked to vote about a 2014 study.
[37:41] And whether it's still binding now, and I would be surprised if in 2025 without any updated numbers, my colleagues would choose to find that governing.
[37:55] So I think that it is, it is a very valid question. What really is more economically feasible and the vast majority of water districts and water authorities around us are not reaching that same conclusion,
[38:10] and which would make common sense truth given that
[38:14] because so much less to actually have non-potable
[38:20] reuse recycled water than potable.
[38:23] Additionally, it's such a strange analysis
[38:25] because in 2014, I don't think that the regulations
[38:30] even existed at they do today
[38:32] for the ways that we can now do not potable reuse,
[38:36] such as direct potable reuse.
[38:38] So in my mind, this is a valid question, which is more financially feasible, and I question those results.
[38:47] Okay, additionally, on page 14, can you go there?
[38:53] Okay, here we go. No, no, I'm sorry, go back on please.
[38:56] So there's a reference to local, seawater, desalination.
[39:00] So are you talking about potable or non-potable desalination?
[39:04] This would be potable.
[39:05] So where's the line item for non-putable decalination?
[39:10] There's no line item.
[39:12] Well, I think all the authorities in those who have
[39:16] had studied a degree that, sorry,
[39:18] man, it's just finished this question.
[39:20] Thank you very much.
[39:22] You know, a degree that non-putable decalination
[39:26] is far more viable than potable decalination
[39:29] is that something that we are going to look into?
[39:34] No, we are looking at only adding to the drinking water supply, because as you stated,
[39:41] we have a non-potable supply, which is our purple pipe system, desalination is, you know,
[39:49] a lot of energy costs, and so I'm not sure what percentage of our outdoor water supply
[40:00] It is only large commercial users, or large other landscapes, and so what percentage is that?
[40:09] I am not sure, but I know for the city of San Jose, so I think 75% of their customers are landscape customers.
[40:18] Okay, so we still don't have actually an analysis of what percentage of our water is that goes to uses that don't require portable water, we're actually using unputable water.
[40:28] So I think that that is a valid investigation too.
[40:32] So that's all.
[40:32] I mean, so I'm not really on board with this,
[40:36] but I appreciate none of that's your presentation.
[40:38] Thank you.
[40:41] Thank you, I don't have any more questions.
[40:48] Now we'll go through what are some common questions and discussion
[40:53] that we have heard.
[40:55] So we've had several questions, of course,
[40:57] about demand projection.
[40:59] The projection was developed using a scientific approach,
[41:02] benchmarked with other agencies
[41:04] and available regional planning data from EBAC, both stable and high projected demands are within the realm of historical water use.
[41:14] And an important note is that future shortage is driven more by the reduction in imported supply as opposed to demand.
[41:24] There were several public comments regarding the feasibility of future water conservation goals,
[41:29] calling them very optimistic and expressing concern
[41:33] that these goals may represent an uncertain component
[41:35] of the water supply master plan.
[41:39] The future water conservation goals
[41:40] were developed based on the analysis
[41:42] of valley waters programs and potential for future savings,
[41:45] especially from outdoor water use.
[41:47] And we agree that these goals are ambitious
[41:49] but believes they are implementable with sufficient resources.
[41:53] And our county already achieves high water use efficiency
[41:56] so they might be demand hardening in the future.
[41:58] But the adaptive management framework can help address uncertainty with future conditions including whether we will meet our conservation goals and the annual reporting will include tracking those goals and our progress towards the long term saving school.
[42:17] At the last board update, there was discussion on the need for reducing our reliance on imported water.
[42:22] Rainfall in our county could not support the growing population economy even with local storage projects, resulting in groundwater overdraft and land subsidence as this graph shows.
[42:35] Valley Water began importing water from the Delta by the state water project in 1965 and from this central valley project in 1987 to meet the needs of the county's growing population economy.
[42:48] These investments along with investments in water recycling and conservation have resulted in sustainable ground water sub basins and reliable water supplies for the county, and our groundwater has since stayed healthy.
[43:01] Currently, imported water accounts for about 40% of the county's water supply and many of our facilities are built and operated and conveying and storing and treating imported water.
[43:13] Currently, imported water is among the most affordable options for value water at $450 in acre foot.
[43:20] The cost for imported water is paid by contract amount and then use or lose fashion, so it is already part of our operation costs.
[43:28] Future investment and imported water projects as identified in the water supply mass plan is to help protect
[43:33] and better utilize value water's contractual water.
[43:37] And those costs are the ones I showed earlier in the supply and storage projects lines.
[43:41] Having a mixed local and important water supply will help minimize future water rate increases and a diversify water supply portfolio has been proven more resilient and reliable in responding to various hydrologic and supply and demand conditions.
[43:56] Would you like me to continue our answer?
[43:58] Yes, but to you.
[44:03] To help put things in perspective, this pie chart shows the availability and uses of delta water.
[44:08] Off the total 50.1 million acre feed of delta water, water and availability of water's uses, it's less than 1%.
[44:16] So the urban water management plan, the state requires agencies to demonstrate reduced reliance on the delta based on the percentage of imported water in their water supply portfolio.
[44:27] With our investment and water conservation reuse, the percentage of imported water in our water supply portfolio is decreasing and we need this requirement.
[44:35] We
[44:39] also had a discussion on storage.
[44:42] California needs water storage to manage its highly variable climate, which shifts between extreme drought and flooding.
[44:49] Climate change impacts weather patterns and has further uncertainty on future water supply timing and availability.
[44:57] So water storage in reservoirs and aquifers.
[45:01] Storge also helps us better utilize projects such as the Pure Water Project. The need for storage is demonstrated through the water supply mass final analysis, as all portfolios require a certain level of storage, depending on what other projects are in the mix.
[45:17] In general, we would need to either maintain the existing level or expand more.
[45:24] As we previously discussed, do maintain value waters level of service we will need to invest
[45:29] to address future shortages.
[45:31] Without that additional investment, value water will have a lower level of service, which
[45:35] could have an immediate and real impact on residents and businesses and, firstly, and chronically
[45:40] affect economic development in the county.
[45:43] A lower level of service could impact the quality of life of our residents, results, and
[45:48] less water for parks, trees, and creeks.
[45:51] Impact agricultural production and could result in billions of dollars of economic losses
[45:57] and potential land subsides with resulting infrastructure damages.
[46:02] That reduced service level would also negatively impact our own operations because we'll
[46:07] be working on a nice edge and in addition it would undermine our credibility and could have
[46:13] ripple effects to our retailers operations in long-range planning.
[46:17] So, value water needs to invest to maintain a reliable and resilient water system to meet the countings.
[46:25] The draft plan consists of eight chapters and seven appendices and the three appendices highlighted in red
[46:31] are new or include changes.
[46:36] Based on the board feedback and direction today, staff will finalize the plan
[46:40] and bring the final plan for the board adoption in the fall.
[46:43] Changes will be made to the final water supply mass plan 2050 to reflect the board's decision on the Pacheca project and the adaptive management framework will be used to explore other storage options including those local reservoirs.
[46:56] And this is a living document even if the plan is completed planning never stops to evaluate projects and make adjustments as needed.
[47:03] We would like the plan to be adopted so we can use it for the urban water management plan which is do very soon.
[47:11] So, the feedback for today, we would like feedback on the proposed roadmap and recommendation, which is to prioritize the lower cost portfolio and continue planning for other projects and any other revisions to the draft plan you'd like to see.
[47:27] With that, we open for questions.
[47:28] Thank you.
[47:29] Thank you.
[47:30] Thank you.
[47:32] Can you go back to page?
[47:33] Um, I think it was 18. It was the page where you talk about the cost of imported water.
[47:41] It was back. Uh, okay. This one. Okay. So based on cost is $450 and acre foot. So what is the cost of
[47:52] of per acre foot of building and maintaining and running the treatment plants per acre foot.
[48:02] I'd like to refer that to, I'm a Darren.
[48:06] I mean, this actually is probably an analysis that needs to be done.
[48:10] I'm saying that because when we look at the cost of recycled water,
[48:14] we seem to include the cost of building the treatment center,
[48:19] purification center of maintaining the purification center of maybe staff
[48:25] in the purification center, all of these infrastructure costs that are absent.
[48:31] from the cost calculations of imported water for imported water to become
[48:36] potable water, it needs to be treated by our plants, right?
[48:43] That is correct, but we are also proposing to put pure water into our treatment plants.
[48:50] I guess, well, I wish we maybe don't have to, we definitely don't have to do with non-potable,
[48:54] But let's just, what I'm asking for here is a equitable cost figure of the import
[49:04] of water.
[49:04] Does that exist yet?
[49:06] Or is that something that needs to be made?
[49:12] Good afternoon, Cheshme, members of Board of Nations Deputy Water Supply Division.
[49:17] We don't have a cost of the treatment pod broken out and attributed to import of water.
[49:23] our treatment plants typically treat
[49:27] married of sources, including local water
[49:29] and delivered to our customers.
[49:31] Our important water supply is also,
[49:33] some of it goes to our treatment plants,
[49:35] but some of it also goes to our groundwater recharge portion.
[49:38] So we haven't broken that,
[49:40] can we let it out?
[49:41] Right, I think if we're gonna actually make decisions
[49:45] or conclusions of what is more affordable
[49:47] and what is more financially feasible
[49:50] than other options,
[49:51] I think it's only rational that the math be consistent across the different categories so I am a
[50:00] So, is that something that maybe you all could consider doing, comparing apples with apples in order to the best of your ability?
[50:10] Dr. Eisenberg, I would like to look into the analysis of that, whether it's appropriate, because our children plans are primarily treating local water to deliver to our tree to water customers.
[50:19] And I believe, and I could be wrong, I look at the air and frankly, if I'm wrong, but I believe majority of our important water goes to recharge the groundwater basin.
[50:28] It would be a lot of our local water from our reservoirs.
[50:36] So I would say trying to break out and attribute that to the important water when the treatment plants are constructed to treat local water.
[50:43] additional water to attribute it be difficult and so we would look into the if it's appropriate and feasible,
[50:49] I happy to look into that question.
[50:50] Then I think we should then an alternate perspective is to only include the costs of acquiring the wastewater for recycling to the cost of acquiring the imported water.
[51:03] How much misdrew does wastewater cost to acquire on an acre for basis?
[51:09] We don't have that cost yet because we're still in negotiations with the city of San Jose.
[51:14] We do have it included for the poll all to project because there is an existing agreement that has that cost.
[51:20] What is that cost?
[51:24] Anyone remember what it is? So I know we're paying 200,000 for the option and then it.
[51:30] Okay, just the cost per acre for it.
[51:33] It's not measured that way.
[51:34] So what does Orange County pay for eco-foot?
[51:41] Where you can look into that, but.
[51:43] So that would be inaccurate, comparison.
[51:45] You know, if we're going to just compare the cost of just the imported water,
[51:51] then we should also compare that with just the cost of wastewater.
[51:55] Because how much is it costing right now to actually refurbish, you know,
[52:00] improve, repair the Rinkanada treatment center, approximately to the nearest
[52:06] billion.
[52:09] I'm not aware that number. Is it more or less a billion dollars? I mean,
[52:15] it's just a very million, something like that, and how much do we
[52:18] already spend on it? I believe, I mean, previously before this. Yeah, no 100 for the
[52:25] Rinkanada prudent project, right? Yeah, and I think that's on top of maybe five
[52:29] we already spent also trying to improve it in the family. Anyway, so I think that that want, you know,
[52:36] approximately more or less a billion dollars could go into the price, too. Thank you, those are my
[52:41] questions.
[52:44] The right to them.
[52:49] Okay, I'd like to give some input here. First of all, I think the 2014
[52:55] needs analysis is too dated for us to have any kind of relevance to that study and we should update it,
[53:03] and the fact that we've had server farms, other kinds of users that potentially could use
[53:12] the non-automal system. And we ought to rethink the opportunities that we might have.
[53:23] So I think that should be done in our process here. I would look at high water users,
[53:31] So, retrofit, in terms of retrofitting any of the high water users, and then also conservation
[53:43] of targeting our conservation to the areas that we don't target now, which I think are
[53:49] the large users.
[53:53] Groundwater recharge, I think should be looked at more seriously.
[54:01] The site's reservoir cost study or what that really is going to cost.
[54:08] We need to have some independent look at the sites reservoir project to make sure that it doesn't go out of control or beyond our means.
[54:25] like why the BSS project we're looking at some cost sharing with CalTRANS, how would that benefit the district?
[54:34] I mean, I've been talking about that for two years now.
[54:39] But I think people are working hard on that.
[54:42] There's some laws that have passed in Sacramento incentivizing water conservation, kind of of, they're looking at sort of the
[55:00] Our grid and electric vehicle tax credit system. And they're looking at doing the same thing for water, for water conservation. So when you do a project for water conservation, you get some kind of tax credit, or tax incentive.
[55:22] Okay, people are looking at that, I think that's a good incentive kind of way of approaching water conservation.
[55:32] The reason why I think that's a good way is because it's a state tax credit incentive, but it implies that the person doing the water conservation is not the water trick, it's the private property owner.
[55:49] So we can encourage private property owners to fund their retrofit projects by these kind of incentive kind of programs.
[56:03] And I think that's important.
[56:08] More or less the low cost plan is clearly.
[56:17] the choice at that point, I think the idea of doing these other studies kind of directions
[56:25] has to be part of the process.
[56:29] I think Palo Alto, I don't know, looking at that, we tried
[56:35] to make that work, but it came too expensive. You can see the numbers are very high. I like to know
[56:39] with the numbers would be if we switched to more of a state of
[56:46] a potable use and putting pipes all the way down to Campbell, like we had
[56:50] a system where we're going to put the pipes down to my district in Campbell
[56:53] and put the water and the perpons down there.
[56:59] I think possibly if they had non-potable users that we can incentivize
[57:07] And say, hey, we got some non-palvel water here.
[57:11] You guys could use it.
[57:14] Are you interested?
[57:15] And be more entrepreneurial.
[57:17] The decolonization,
[57:23] we had a watch and see if there's
[57:24] going to be any financial help or incentives
[57:29] for decolonization projects.
[57:32] And exploit that, it possible, as well, those are my comments.
[57:36] I think we can achieve some of our strategies by keeping this multi-direction approach.
[57:55] We have to do some new thinking though.
[57:57] We have to kind of reality think.
[57:59] I do support the idea of fixing all our facilities that we need to fix as part of the water supply
[58:13] master plan because we can build all these projects and things like that but we have to make sure
[58:19] that we don't have anything that's suffering from deferred maintenance or shutdowns or anything
[58:27] act out because of deferred maintenance. I think we're doing that now, but I think we ought
[58:33] to put that on the list, so we know that we have to do that over the next 10 years, at least,
[58:39] upgrade, modernize, make our systems, our pipelines, our treatment plants, all those things work
[58:47] better, and we'll get a dividend by doing that. I think that's a long-term dividend that
[58:54] Yeah, so I'm favoring that, I think the Delta conveyance project,
[59:03] if there can be some compromise,
[59:07] it would be a win for us, so I'd better continue to discuss that.
[59:11] That's going to be maybe something that we're not directly in control of, but I think we
[59:18] to continue to discuss the Delta conveyance project and continue to try to work some
[59:27] compromise so we can get the project at least expedited. I mean if we can build a quicker
[59:33] the better for us so but compromise is in terms of the Delta communities and environmental issues.
[59:41] So, thank you.
[59:43] Thank you.
[59:47] Derek Cabellar?
[59:51] I have a long list of questions and I'm probably going to go over time.
[59:55] But I'll start with just some of the easier questions.
[59:58] One of them was...
[1:00:00] The last meeting on this, we asked for more information about costs. And so it's been included. Thank you. It breaks down like here's the planning cost. Here's the construction cost.
[1:00:10] One of the things that I was also hoping to see is like the major drivers of the operating costs. Like if energy is a huge cost, just like flag it. And some of that's in the narrative. I think when you dig into the appendixes.
[1:00:23] But that's part of what I was looking for is like,
[1:00:25] what are the major cost drivers of the various projects?
[1:00:29] Like, director Bell said, like, oh gosh,
[1:00:32] there's a pipeline associated with this one
[1:00:34] that isn't necessarily readily apparent
[1:00:36] when you look at it, at least the first iteration.
[1:00:39] So that was one thing I just wanted to,
[1:00:41] hopefully maybe we'll get some more of those costs in there.
[1:00:49] On the, I guess, on page 35 and on page 53 in the draft plan, there's like fairly
[1:00:58] alarmist language.
[1:01:01] There's some red line stuff that has been added around the Bay Delta.
[1:01:06] And then the findings are like, and, you know, there's all these, what if scenarios
[1:01:11] that could happen?
[1:01:12] So I want to ask that question, what if semi-traffic doesn't pan out? We just can't find some ground
[1:01:20] water deals to be banking all our water? What if are imported via all the stuff that's going
[1:01:28] on with Bay Delta? What if those things actually happen? What does the portfolio look like then?
[1:01:36] That's why we have the Adaptive Management Approach.
[1:01:40] So even before your particular decision,
[1:01:43] we were looking at all the different options
[1:01:45] of what could fill the future shortage.
[1:01:48] And so that's why we are recommending to plan
[1:01:52] for additional projects beyond just a lower cost portfolio,
[1:01:55] so that we can pivot if we need to.
[1:01:58] So sites could be a backup to groundwater banking as well.
[1:02:03] You know, desalination could be, although, you know, when you get supply heavy, then it's not as efficient.
[1:02:12] So, so yeah, that would be something we would track on an annual basis in the monitoring and assessment program, how all these projects are doing and whether we need to recommend that we pivot.
[1:02:25] So, so what would you, if we have to pivot at that time, what would the portfolio look like?
[1:02:32] And sites, my understanding of sites, we still need a lot of combat, we would still need the DCP correct to convey that.
[1:02:40] Okay.
[1:02:41] It still needs to go. Well, it's.
[1:02:44] Okay.
[1:02:44] If I made a bit.
[1:02:46] If I was through, they don't, right?
[1:02:48] It's still sites water would move the bay as we do transfer waters, but we could also use DCP.
[1:02:54] So DCP would be an advantageous pairing with sites.
[1:03:01] Yeah, so I'm just curious, what does that portfolio look like?
[1:03:07] So we will...
[1:03:08] You have to make the decision now and say, oh my gosh, we have to pivot because we're not getting the imported water and we can't bank our water like we used to.
[1:03:16] It could look a lot of different ways and whatever the opportunities are available at that time.
[1:03:22] we will definitely be updating that appendix.
[1:03:27] And yeah, I mean, if we end up with nothing,
[1:03:30] obviously we have a problem.
[1:03:34] I talked about, I'd just like to add that
[1:03:38] if importedware is being reduced to a level of gray concern
[1:03:44] for us, it would be reduced to a level of gray concern
[1:03:47] for 27 million Californians plus millions of acres
[1:03:51] of agricultural land and economy and Southern California, Southern California, Southern California
[1:03:57] of the economy. So I mean, there would be a lot of political will to try and resolve that problem
[1:04:04] at a macro scale from which we could benefit. So it's hard to see how that would unfold now,
[1:04:11] but there'd be a lot of pieces in play.
[1:05:00] Tether us from external partners. And the potential need to really focus on those kinds of things.
[1:05:12] That's the language in here I thought was appropriate and it's scary. And we're, you know, you all plan for the what if scenario. And I'm actually an optimist. So that's a hard hat for me to put on.
[1:05:27] I also wanted to just clarify or ask, on purified water, and I understand, and I'm learning this, and thank you, you're going to be giving me a briefing on this, I think tomorrow, but the decision that the board made before I got here to move forward with the DPR as opposed to recycled water and a purple pipe network.
[1:05:52] So, purified, in terms of moving forward, we're moving forward with that, can you just say,
[1:05:57] I think you've said this before, but we're building that in a way that, again, going back
[1:06:03] to my last comment, we can continue, like, it's, can it, is it like a building, what kind
[1:06:10] of thing, like we can start, we can be adding on, as we say, oh my gosh, imported water has
[1:06:15] been impacted or we sell my traffic didn't pan out, we got to make more water, is it going
[1:06:20] And we're building it in a way that we can just kind of build more once we've figured that we've proven that we're awesome at it.
[1:06:27] Only as much as there's wastewater and there isn't enough to fill the entire need that would happen if there was no imported water.
[1:06:36] So right now we're negotiating with the city of San Jose and Santa Clara on the wastewater availability.
[1:06:42] they have asked us to model what happens with maximum expansion of the non-potable system and
[1:06:49] drought and water conservation, and they want to make sure that there is water for all of that.
[1:06:54] So we are building the largest one that we can with San Jose. So that's already the largest,
[1:07:00] and that's 24,000, which is going to be 7% of the water supply need in 2050 to go with the low demand.
[1:07:09] So 7% is non-allot doesn't sound like a lot.
[1:07:14] So then if you added wastewater from other wastewater plants, none of them have 24.
[1:07:21] They're all much smaller.
[1:07:23] And then in South County it's already all used up.
[1:07:26] So no local water supplies even if you then add diesel.
[1:07:31] We're not going to be able to make up that difference.
[1:07:36] Okay. I'll probably ask you the same question tomorrow. Okay. I'm ready. I also wanted to ask my colleagues if they might entertain the notion of considering something, including things in the plan like, you know, as I understand it, we, this are area uses like 66 gallons a day per person and we're on the low end and that's good.
[1:07:58] and we should also strive for being better. So is it appropriate? Where would we have a conversation about potentially putting some sort of goal
[1:08:06] for 2050 around per person usage? That's one thing that I wanted to raise.
[1:08:13] I also, in the project criteria in the plan, I forget what page that's on.
[1:08:19] I wanted to ask my colleagues if they would be amenable to or if it makes sense to include also a self-reliance.
[1:08:28] project criteria.
[1:08:31] And then also there's a pie chart at some point that has, you know, 50% of our water is imported, 5% is recycled, 15% is conservation, 30% is local. And if it's appropriate or if we should put that in for what we want that to be in 2050 what we ideally aspire for that pie chart to look like in 2050.
[1:08:55] So those are the three things that I was hoping we could provide direction as a board to include in the plan.
[1:09:04] And I think that or those were the major things I wanted to ask about. Thank you.
[1:09:10] Did you want me to respond to any of them? Yes. Okay. So this state does have standards for
[1:09:18] gallons per capita per day for indoor. And so by 2030 they want everyone to be at 42 gallons per
[1:09:24] our per day. As you know that we are at 69, let's ignore an outdoor and if you think about 50 to 60
[1:09:31] percent of water is being outside we kind of already meet that. So 42 we're doing quite well on that.
[1:09:41] Then the self-reliance that's kind of why we have the local strategy which is typically more expensive
[1:09:50] And all our projects would do require partnership.
[1:09:58] It is like...
[1:10:00] Taylor's pure water, we need a lot of partnership with our wastewater partners. So, yeah, I think it would be really hard to hold to a measure of self-reliance, but it's obviously up to the board and their policy discussion. I can't remember what the third one was.
[1:10:23] And just before you go there,
[1:10:27] self-reliance could be defined.
[1:10:30] I guess I think of it more as Santa Clara County.
[1:10:32] We rely on our partners, the people that we know in Santa Clara County,
[1:10:36] and even maybe regionally.
[1:10:38] I am fearful that dependence on state actors,
[1:10:44] it's so much farther out of our control.
[1:10:48] and so when I say self-reliance, I'm kind of thinking definitely Santa Clara County entities
[1:10:54] are self-included and then perhaps regional as well.
[1:11:01] On the patch, I don't really have a
[1:11:02] good answer for you. It's too difficult to predict the future and I would, you know, I would say
[1:11:10] keeping it open so that we can have the most cost-effective water supply for our community and
[1:11:17] economy would probably be prudent, but again, that is the board policy decision.
[1:11:26] There it is.
[1:11:28] Thank you chair.
[1:11:32] I have a comment for staff to consider if we can include some information in the
[1:11:48] in the process of finalizing the a lot of supply and mass supply.
[1:11:53] If not, they take time, I think it's okay to include in the annual map process.
[1:12:04] So I mentioned as a couple of times before, it's about South County recharge.
[1:12:11] I think we're very focused on for Jericho side and all that and we didn't really have
[1:12:17] much information about the South County recharge,
[1:12:20] that's an important component for South County's water supply.
[1:12:25] At this point, I'm not sure that how big is the slope,
[1:12:30] and then what's the real estate requirement,
[1:12:35] and then even if we purchase all the real estate,
[1:12:39] or it is a water coming from to put it in those recharge pumps,
[1:12:43] so that kind of information.
[1:12:45] And when we go to agriculture advisory committee, the discussion is focused on how this North
[1:12:56] County improvement in South County gets a small percentage of the overall potential
[1:13:03] future investment, which will, and then not really discussion about, this is the South County
[1:13:12] future improvement. North County has nothing to do with the outcome of the South County
[1:13:20] improvements and it will be 100%. 100% South County investment, 100% South County will pay for it.
[1:13:33] So I think it's probably down the road, but then knowing our constituents, I think the sooner
[1:13:43] we start this communication with South County and then, of course, South County has
[1:13:50] municipal and industrial and also the agriculture, it's not just completely agriculture.
[1:13:55] But then just I think this concept that South County needs improvement, needs investment too, and then it takes money to improve and invest.
[1:14:09] It's going to be a piece of work.
[1:14:11] The sooner or later it's not that, I think it's better.
[1:14:14] And then for this board we should have some more information about the future.
[1:14:25] plan for the South County also. So if, as I said, if you cannot do it, we see finalizing
[1:14:33] of the once upon a time. I just do it on the map process, I think it's okay. Yeah, so thank you.
[1:14:40] And also I want to say that stabbing the great job, so all this process is really a process.
[1:14:45] It's a, it's just not a project, it's really a process. And personally, I learned a lot from staff,
[1:14:51] have a lot of this process and I think it's time that which go ahead and they'll find a
[1:14:56] lifestyle. What a supply and that's the plan. And then start the art.
[1:15:00] Thank you. These are just a few other comments raised by my colleagues. You know, got my mind going and a couple other comments about slide 22. And this is another example of not going to get the answer right now, but I think it would be useful to actually quantify the storage needs.
[1:15:23] I mean, these are kind of, you know, general statements like, absolutely, we will need to compensate for, you know, this, we need to store what we don't have available from other sources on a renewable or ongoing basis, right?
[1:15:41] So I guess I'm asking in the future ideally near future for a quantification of what our storage needs are with consideration of the following non-exclusively.
[1:15:57] One is the demand management perspective, giving the interaction on storage needs when considering
[1:16:06] the impact of water recycling, non-potable desalination, which I guess hasn't even been
[1:16:12] looked into much at all, in conservation, you know, if we were to increase conservation, increase
[1:16:18] recycling, you know, increase alternate other sources of drinking water apart from storage,
[1:16:24] How does that actually impact the quantification of our storage needs?
[1:16:29] Additionally, I think it's essential that we also consider the climate change perspective.
[1:16:35] For example, the fact that these days water stored outside is generally speaking exposed to a much higher evaporation rate than in the past.
[1:16:47] So in some say up to 30%, so we would arguably need to constantly refresh water into a reservoir
[1:16:56] to make up for how quickly it potentially evaporates out that would go into that and also impact
[1:17:03] the feasibility of outdoor storage as a solution. I also think we need comparisons with nature
[1:17:10] basalitions, especially re-growing and conserving wildlife ecology, and in particular trees and
[1:17:17] forests. As we know, trees and forests hold water, serve as reservoirs. They hold water,
[1:17:27] and they also hold carbon. So, in every time we kill a tree, we move a tree, we are removing a source
[1:17:35] of releasing carbon into the atmosphere A. And we're also taking away the most natural and
[1:17:42] efficient reservoir we have, which is trees and forests. So that, and then finally, I think
[1:17:50] we need to also evaluate the cost perspective of nature-based and non-outdoor storage and
[1:17:57] underground storage options, especially in light of increasing, you know, that just when
[1:18:05] you see this sentence, increasing availability of carbon credits for nature-based solutions,
[1:18:11] you can look at a study on terraformation.com to see how carbon credits are being used for nature-based
[1:18:18] solution, and that is free money. Thank you.
[1:18:23] Thank you, Chair, so the reference to South County.
[1:18:27] There have been numerous discussions with the city of Morgan Hill, the city of Gilroy,
[1:18:32] the leadership in the unincorporated area of the county of Santa Clara County, which is same
[1:18:37] or teen, and also with the city of San Jose for the southern portion of San Jose.
[1:18:42] At Nazim, in reference to extending purple pipe into the region and the southern part of the region,
[1:18:49] mostly into Morgan Hill region, and also the potential for developing a what a
[1:18:56] purification facility in the South County. These discussions have been going on
[1:19:00] for 10 years, maybe even farther back, but we have no formidable plan to actually
[1:19:07] activate or we're funding these projects. So perhaps we continue if South
[1:19:12] County will be a focus, then I think it needs to be because it is a growing area
[1:19:16] exponentially and, by the way, agriculture is still very viable in South County as well.
[1:19:23] So there's multiple discussions and opportunities that we can look at in implementing
[1:19:27] more water resources in South County as well. Also, the discussions that we've had at the
[1:19:33] regional wastewater authority meetings in Gilroy, director Saptos and I,
[1:19:37] attendees along with staff, and we talk about these things. We speak about these opportunities together,
[1:19:44] But it's going to take a collaborative effort to get all these regions together and all the resources
[1:19:49] Meaning money to make this thing a reality make it happen.
[1:19:52] So, you know, we need to continue those discussions and come up with an actual plan that could work for South County.
[1:20:02] I did have one other question, and I'm going to speak for Charist Romara here, or make an attempt to.
[1:20:09] And that is that he has asked about increasing the capacity of our existing reservoirs, and the whole and the ground up at the old quarry.
[1:20:17] Is that, is it implied that we'll be looking at that or should that be included in this plan?
[1:20:23] So the Permanente Quarry we did do a study back in 2022. We hired a consultant and did a reconnaissance level study and found that there are a lot of feasibility challenges with that. And we brought it to the at the time water storage exploratory committee. So we're happy to bring it back to the water supply and demand management committee to refresh the current committee members.
[1:20:49] On the findings, I've got off that study and as I said earlier, the local reservoir we are looking at that, it will depend a lot on how they're operated in the future as to how much they can assist in a drought and we will also bring that back to the water supply and demand management, but we are thinking that will be as part of the adaptive management plan and doesn't need to hold up the water supply.
[1:21:16] Thank you.
[1:21:17] Thank you.
[1:21:18] Oh, we have a number of public speakers.
[1:21:23] Thank you.
[1:21:23] Yes.
[1:21:24] We have Ralph online.
[1:21:26] Go ahead.
[1:21:27] Yes.
[1:21:27] Good afternoon, Ralph.
[1:21:29] This is me.
[1:21:31] Ralph, Mr. Essie.
[1:21:33] I'm a farmer in the Central Valley.
[1:21:36] And I farm different counties.
[1:21:38] But I also farm into semi-tropic irrigation district.
[1:21:42] And we've grown like 2,500 acres down there, and we feel that that property is ideally
[1:21:52] situated for groundwater recharge and banking for possibly your district, and I think maybe
[1:22:02] I'm attempting to meet with your staff, and I don't really like to meet with a couple of
[1:22:07] board members also. And go over the idea that we have, before you could, more, stabilize
[1:22:15] your agreement with semi-tropic, maybe renegotiate it over a more long-term period. And
[1:22:23] this property that we have, you get back tremendous amounts of the water on it, because it
[1:22:30] is completely pipeline for blood irrigation,
[1:22:33] and it has all the distribution system
[1:22:37] to put water in the ground,
[1:22:39] and also has new wells to extract water
[1:22:42] from the ground when you want to take it out.
[1:22:45] So in the next week or two,
[1:22:47] I hope to meet with some of your staff
[1:22:49] and then maybe some of your board members
[1:22:52] and make a presentation for how you can
[1:22:56] without much infrastructure having cost
[1:23:00] for what you guys have been talking about.
[1:23:03] You could very efficiently thank much more water
[1:23:06] and semi-tropic.
[1:23:09] I don't know if you have any questions or.
[1:23:14] Thank you, Karen.
[1:23:16] I have an answer for you.
[1:23:17] No, I don't know.
[1:23:18] Would you like to go first?
[1:23:19] Go ahead, Erin.
[1:23:20] Just real quick, thank you so much
[1:23:22] for reaching out with us, Mr. Pistory.
[1:23:24] This is Erin Baker, Chief Operating Officer
[1:23:26] the water to the enterprise and I was afforded a message from you yesterday and I will be
[1:23:32] following up with you to meet with you to understand further about the opportunity that you
[1:23:37] have. Again, it's Aaron Baker and my email address is A, B, A, K, E, R at ValleyWater.org. But I will
[1:23:45] follow up with you this afternoon. I'm looking forward to hearing. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you,
[1:23:50] Ralph. Directed the virulent. Yeah. So, so, so, Ralph, perhaps another opportunity for you to meet with
[1:23:54] just a couple of board members.
[1:23:56] We meet monthly at the San Luis Delta Mendoza,
[1:23:59] Water Authority in Las Banyos.
[1:24:01] This Thursday, and of course, we meet every Thursday,
[1:24:03] once a month.
[1:24:04] So that could be an opportunity to do a live meeting.
[1:24:07] And our staff also is at those meetings as well.
[1:24:09] So that's just an idea of how we might be able to meet face to face.
[1:24:12] And listen to your proposal at that point.
[1:24:15] That'd be great.
[1:24:16] Also, Los Banners is very not too far from here.
[1:24:20] That's why I brought it up.
[1:24:21] Yeah, thank you.
[1:24:22] Good idea.
[1:24:25] what you do on the 23rd and next we have Peter Van Dyke.
[1:24:34] Good afternoon, Chair Tony and board members.
[1:24:40] There's so much to digest here. First of all, I want to talk.
[1:24:44] I would like to get together with Darren in advance because I think all these discussions that you're having regarding water should be presented to the Ag water advisory committee at our next meeting perhaps.
[1:24:55] or perhaps the December meeting, it's very important.
[1:25:00] It's involved here. So, perhaps I can talk to those folks. Aaron, I mean, Darren and Vince. So we can perhaps have a meeting, get some of this discussion on the agenda for the for our advisory committee. The other thing is 66 gallons per person. That seemed like quite a bit. You know, I mean, when I grew up on the farm, the water conservation was beaten into my head by my parents and grandparents. Because we knew farmers knew how important water was. And I doubt that I
[1:25:29] use 30 gallons a day because I'm very conservative. I think conservation, a short-term solution
[1:25:36] is to promote more conservation of possible and educate the public on conservation because,
[1:25:44] you know, I go over to people's houses and I just, I tell them, they'll be watching this
[1:25:48] and I got to tell them, turn off that water. You know, things like that. But I think for short-term
[1:25:52] solution, that's one of it. I still have a proponent of recycling waste water. And I really
[1:26:01] like the idea of biological solutions like wetlands, restoration, and perhaps reforestation
[1:26:06] of certain areas of that's even possible, but that's a long-term solution because I do
[1:26:10] know and the research proves that forest and woodlands do hold back a lot of water and
[1:26:16] it slowly. And of course the carbon sequestration factor of that is also very important.
[1:26:24] We work with that in our resource conservation district.
[1:26:29] So as far as South County is concerned,
[1:26:33] Director Varella is correct. Development is going exponential in South County. And unfortunately,
[1:26:39] some of the best areas for percolation into the groundwater basin are in Morgan Hill,
[1:26:43] north of Sam Martina. Those are rapidly being buried in concrete and asphalt and run off.
[1:26:52] Now, the other factors where folks are completing flood control projects, somehow we got to
[1:26:58] figure out how to save some of that water that's going downstream and get it into the ground
[1:27:05] in South County. flood control was to me as kind of a misnomer because flood control is just
[1:27:12] basically flood transferrants down stream in a lot of ways. I understand that you're completing the
[1:27:19] Yagus project and but that's all going to hit the Pahero Narrows and we're going to have major
[1:27:25] flooding down in the Carnadero. Those are just some of the points and I definitely would love to see
[1:27:31] some of this discussion that you folks are having brought to the Agwater community meeting at the next meeting
[1:27:36] if they could please. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Vande. I think that's it on a public comment.
[1:27:45] So to wrap this up, this is here for information only and I know I've raised before the question of storage that the storage subcommittee will
[1:27:52] I hope review and come back to us on a report so we can see what else we can put into the into this this plant proposed real man and see so feedback requested.
[1:28:11] Thank you so much, but if there's any more we're happy to hear it.
[1:28:15] Yes, yes.
[1:28:22] I've been trying to draw on mute myself.
[1:28:26] You never know if they're going to beat me to it.
[1:28:30] So I'd like to suggest the following.
[1:28:33] Because I agree with director Shua,
[1:28:35] you know, this has been in the works for a long time
[1:28:37] and it's great.
[1:28:39] I think it.
[1:28:41] I mean, staff is awesome.
[1:28:44] And this is a very good path forward.
[1:28:48] And I don't want to hold up a moving forward on it.
[1:28:52] I also am really interested in having a discussion and something for inclusion in the plan, so maybe it could
[1:29:01] around what that ideal pie chart looks like by 2050, including a per person goal,
[1:29:09] you know, maybe it mirrors the state, maybe it's better.
[1:29:11] And I think I heard you say Kirsten that it's for indoor and so maybe it can be a combination of the two and then also the inclusion of criteria around sulfur lions and so maybe if if my colleagues think that those are all good things that we should pursue in the context of our water supply master plan perhaps it's a conversation for the water supply and demand management committee because I don't know what those numbers should be.
[1:30:00] I think they should be grounded in data and rational thought for something that's achievable and or aspirational.
[1:30:08] So perhaps the direction from this body could be for the wisdom committee to have a further conversation on those three items for inclusion in the water supply.
[1:30:17] must plan.
[1:30:22] Thank you chair. To respond to director Bell's request. I agree that I think that's the
[1:30:31] proper committee to looking to if we're going to set goals 100 will be number associated with it.
[1:30:40] There needs to be that kind of level of discussion. And then I think the full board needs to have
[1:30:47] of course, a complete discussion if there's number associated with it.
[1:30:53] So my suggestion is that maybe in the finalized finalizing the master plan,
[1:31:02] you can put an order in there that we're working on on this, these areas,
[1:31:07] and then as we move forward, some description.
[1:31:12] Again, it's a process, right?
[1:31:13] So if I identify that distance, we need to work on the process or just work on it, but then
[1:31:18] to include some wording in the master plan so we can finalize it and then people know
[1:31:24] that will cannot.
[1:31:25] Is that if that's okay, I think that's.
[1:31:27] We can do that.
[1:31:29] We do have the water conservation growth and the board adopted and we can see how we can
[1:31:33] maybe translate that into a gowns per person, like I said, the state has a 32 gowns per person
[1:31:40] for indoor. And we're pretty much there at this point.
[1:31:48] Okay. And then I assume that
[1:31:50] everybody into the year will finalize it. We would hope to come back and like October
[1:31:58] because we do need to start working on the urban water management plan once the state guidelines
[1:32:03] come out and what would really like to rely on this document rather than the old document to do that.
[1:32:07] Got it. And it's the same group of people. Yes, there's only a few of them.
[1:32:12] Okay, well, on St. Faith. Okay. Thank you. Great. Well, thank you, staff. Appreciate the work.
[1:32:18] We'll move right along then 4.0, 4.1, the consent calendar.
[1:32:28] Most of the crew with a second.
[1:32:32] Okay. Let's see. We've got a resolution.
[1:32:34] Okay, Director Baller, Director Bell, Director Eisenberg, Director Schoom, Vice Chair
[1:32:43] Santas, Director Verella, Chair Estimera, I motion passes.
[1:32:49] Thank you.
[1:32:50] On the 5.1 Board, Committee Reports, Chair Tach, the ECCCCC summary.
[1:32:59] Well, this is a handout and we move down to CEO and chief reports.
[1:33:09] Yes, good afternoon.
[1:33:10] Hello, Mr. Mayor. Members of the board. We have one report today from Chief Gibson.
[1:33:14] Yes. Good afternoon.
[1:33:16] Good afternoon, Chair. Mr. Mayor, Mr. Board.
[1:33:18] You have the before you implement the one pages from the Office of Government Relations
[1:33:21] and Civic Engagement, just a couple of highlights from each.
[1:33:24] On August 19th, of course, the Board helped joint special meeting with the
[1:33:27] as a city council, a city hall, staff and both agencies provided updates on key projects,
[1:33:32] including purified water, Anderson Dan, County Creek, Public Protection Project, and the
[1:33:35] safely water program of course, all parties unanimously accepted the reports and engaged in
[1:33:40] discussions on accelerating project timelines, addressing housing and contaminants, and of course,
[1:33:44] most importantly strengthening intergovernmental coordination, meaning reaffirms the strong
[1:33:48] partnership between our two agencies and addressing shared community priorities, moving over to
[1:33:56] Center for various groups, including environmental and community organizations of school and local
[1:34:01] government representatives, the towards emphasizing importance of water reuse and
[1:34:04] enduring threats to our water supply. Staff also promoted purified water by distributing
[1:34:09] over 4,000 bottles to add 11 events has definitely a record, including a rotary club
[1:34:14] meeting intended by Director Ballard, a health fair, statewide picnic, a music festival,
[1:34:18] and Valley Water Night and the San Jose Giants, where 800 bottles were handed out. That's another
[1:34:22] record, the highest at a single event. Internally purified water was featured at the
[1:34:26] the town hall, and we served as Fresca in the headquarters cafeteria.
[1:34:31] In August, the youth commission also held its first quarterly meeting where commissioner
[1:34:34] a detest, Cumaar, was elected chair and commissioner L.U. was elected vice chair.
[1:34:39] The meeting included presentations on commission structure,
[1:34:41] member responsibilities, and branch compliance, always favorite,
[1:34:44] as well as updates on FY25 project progress.
[1:34:48] Later in the month, commissioners attended an online retreat featuring remarks
[1:34:50] from director Shua and team building activities, which foster collaboration and
[1:34:54] repression for the protective of your head, and I can listen to the report.
[1:34:57] Well, how many bottles we got left?
[1:35:00] I wanted to quickly report on, and that is today Valley Waters letter withdrawing from the Picheka Reservoir Expansion Project Water Storage Investment Program went out to the California Water Commission's Executive Director. You will all be receiving a copy of that letter.
[1:35:15] Thank you.
[1:35:19] Review the fiscal year 2026 Board Policy Planning Calendar.
[1:35:24] Thank you chair. We have no changes from last month.
[1:35:30] And see board member reports and announcements.
[1:35:36] I think we started out the right so it will start with yeah direct the bell.
[1:35:42] It's time.
[1:35:45] I've attended many meetings regarding the county measure A and they want to have a presentation to the board on that at one of our meetings.
[1:35:55] I assume it would be pretty soon.
[1:35:56] Okay. So the ballot manager. So if we could ask that that be done in there on the behalf
[1:36:07] of the County Board of Supervisors. Secondly,
[1:36:15] we learned this week that the passing of
[1:36:19] of Congressmen, Senator, Chair of the Democrat Party, John Burton.
[1:36:27] He was a person that I worked very closely with in the legislature and many other ways.
[1:36:35] He was a gruff tough, but dedicated his life to helping foster kids, and John Burton
[1:36:46] I've created a foundation when he left office and he established a foundation to support advocacy for foster children in California.
[1:36:58] And as you know, I work very closely with him on AB 12.
[1:37:03] Many of the other foster care bills that I introduced and just about two dozen, I think, of which about 18 of them passed into law.
[1:37:12] And we were advocates for foster care and improvements in California.
[1:37:21] His legacy will be as an advocate for many things, but I wanted to point out he was especially close to me on foster care.
[1:37:32] He was also a strong advocate for mental health and drug and alcohol programs.
[1:37:41] programs, especially for getting care through insurance for public employees, I'll say that.
[1:37:51] So public employees that have the need to have their health care coverage for mental health
[1:38:00] and alcohol and drug abuse, all a lot to John Burton.
[1:38:05] He was a wonderful guy, represented San Francisco, I didn't always agree with them on
[1:38:11] course because he had to advocate for his area. But John Burton was a very much of a humanist,
[1:38:21] just a very hard working legislator. He would fit right in with, I say, director Sandos in his
[1:38:30] entire because when the Senate had requirement of having a
[1:38:37] coat and tie, John Burton would come in with his Hawaiian
[1:38:42] shirt and he put a shoestring around his neck to say that was
[1:38:46] a tie. So John Burton, we love you and we're going to miss John.
[1:38:53] I'm going to miss him personally because I see him quite often and
[1:38:58] He was a real mentor and a special friend for me.
[1:39:07] Thank you, Jim.
[1:39:11] Derek, does it work?
[1:39:14] Thank you.
[1:39:16] I actually was going to mention Don Burton too as a longtime San Francisco skin.
[1:39:24] I drew a very familiar with his reputation and with the impact he had.
[1:39:32] I met him a couple of times, but mostly I was very well aware of all the good.
[1:39:36] he did with his role, and it's direct impact on the people and lives whom he impacted and
[1:39:46] chose to serve.
[1:39:48] In addition to what was said by my colleague, Director Bell, I also want to call attention
[1:39:54] to his longtime work on tenants advocacy, on due to his work.
[1:40:00] Our decades ago, you know, some of the most important protections on place for tenants in our state.
[1:40:11] And possibly in the country, you know, that, you know, protections that, as, as years past become ever more essential and crucial to protect families and lives and children who want to keep attending the same school,
[1:40:26] you know, and can't if they're evicted for arbitrary reasons, we'll mostly greed.
[1:40:32] And I think I and so many others, I mean, all of us, or a dead of gratitude to him for that,
[1:40:37] also his don't and said fast protection of the environment. He worked so hard on behalf of
[1:40:44] conservation and parks, and he really understood before there was a word for it. You know, the
[1:40:56] much foresight in protecting the most beautiful spaces, keeping them natural and native so that all
[1:41:03] people, despite economic opportunity and racial prohibitions which are so huge back then and
[1:41:12] still, you know, the legacies of which very much retained remain today, he worked so hard to make
[1:41:19] all lives equitable and improved the quality of life of all people. I also think he's such a great
[1:41:27] comeback story. When he suffered from addiction, he sought treatment and was honest and transparent
[1:41:36] about it, such a great role model and was treated and came back and I'm grateful for voters,
[1:41:43] You know, my community in San Francisco for giving him a lot of their chance. I think it's so important that we allow people, you know, who especially who's mistakes impacted themselves much more than the impacted others, you know, to grow and learn.
[1:42:00] So in my mind, I think he just really was a great hero and how fortunate and blessed we were that he lived for a magnificent 93 years. You know, that's a truly well-lived life.
[1:42:13] And that really is my comment for today. Thank you.
[1:42:18] Vice Chair.
[1:42:21] Yeah, thank you, Chair. Thank you both for those comments about the center of Burton.
[1:42:25] Well, well deserved and well earned.
[1:42:28] Also, if the staff just want to go and announce what director Verella was saying,
[1:42:33] it's time for us to tackle either a satellite or do something recycling one in the South County,
[1:42:38] Tony has said it for years and we keep on talking. It's time to move. So it was up to
[1:42:42] John and I will have the water resources. We'll find out what the folks want to do.
[1:42:46] We're going to bring it back here and then we'll decide what we're going to do.
[1:42:49] But we're not going to sit and wait anymore. It's time to move. And we've been doing this and
[1:42:53] they need to supply of water. We can't just work off the aquifer's ratio like. It's just not going to work.
[1:42:59] So instead of us passing a buck to someone else and has been to us, we'll take the actual steps and
[1:43:05] and we appreciate you guys just moving on.
[1:43:09] Is that right to the road?
[1:43:15] Yes.
[1:43:16] I should have kept going, but I was coming back this way.
[1:43:18] Go ahead and I'll come back this way.
[1:43:28] There you go.
[1:43:29] Yes, so I've had multiple meetings.
[1:43:31] I had the.
[1:43:34] Well,
[1:43:35] water education latino for latino leaders legislative briefing meeting, youth commission meeting.
[1:43:42] I set on the aqua board of directors that met with the executive director,
[1:43:47] interim executive director Marwan Calafi, talking about various issues that are affecting
[1:43:52] aqua at this particular time and juncture, value board meeting, Morgan Hill Chamber of Commerce,
[1:44:00] Valley Water also had a special meeting, but what's coming up is the Santa Clara County Farm Bureau is having their barbeque and a couple of weeks in their honoring two individuals.
[1:44:13] One is George Keala, farmer of the year award. We all know Tim Keala, who chairs in water advisory committee and also he's also the chair of the Farm Bureau.
[1:44:28] but his father, George Kiela, who started Kiela Farms,
[1:44:31] just a wonderful man, a great guy, and a good friend of mine.
[1:44:35] And there's also an award called the Linda L. Lester,
[1:44:38] friend of agriculture award.
[1:44:41] And that award is going to be presented to this guy.
[1:44:43] His name is John Varella.
[1:45:00] For that, a prestigious award, and I'm honored to accept it, the Linda L. L. L. L. L. Sir, friend of agriculture award.
[1:45:08] It's my report. All right. Thank you, Chair. Since my last report, I had a meeting with staff about San Francisco Creek. Also, I attended the San Francisco Creek JPA meeting.
[1:45:26] I attended the, our third SMP, draft EIR, public meeting, and the two special board meeting about our future, and Matt was CEO in our bi-worklay 101.
[1:45:47] Kurt Bem.
[1:45:54] All right, so we'll start with the funnest, and that was a participated in the Pride Parade with our folks, and it was really really hot, and I'm glad they had pretty rainbow umbrellas. So thank you all for including me. It was a lot of fun.
[1:46:09] A couple meetings I met with a rep from SFPUC to learn more about how they deal with stormwater,
[1:46:17] super educational, met with someone from the San Jose Conservation Corps and charter schools.
[1:46:22] It's like the ECC, it's got a lot of seas in its title, it's like the San Jose CCC to learn
[1:46:30] more about whether they're doing along the trails. Also, I had my quarterly checking with the building
[1:46:34] trades, Director Verella invited me down to the Farm Bureau, so I did that, thanks, that was
[1:46:40] a very educational and fun. And also where they announced that you would be getting the support,
[1:46:45] so well deserved, congratulations again. I attended the recycling waste reduction commission,
[1:46:52] and then also had a briefing from our staff here on flooding the certain areas of the
[1:46:58] We've got a little bit of trail flooding, and so thanks to Lisa and Eve on for spending time with me to help me understand exactly what we can and can't do along our trails when they flood.
[1:47:11] And that is it. Thanks.
[1:47:13] Thank you, and I have my usual committee meetings and one with the general council to see a board strategic planning meetings.
[1:47:22] work plan, meeting with the DCA CEO.
[1:47:31] I had, I said I had an interview with one of the newspapers
[1:47:40] in town and it's about it.
[1:47:47] So we close to me today's meeting by acknowledging that between
[1:47:53] of September 15 in October 15, Valley Water would join in celebrating Chicano and Hispanic Latino
[1:47:58] heritage month in appreciation to the culture, rich histories and contributions of immigrants
[1:48:04] and Americans, whose ancestors came from Mexico, the Caribbean, Central and South America,
[1:48:10] Spain, and Portugal. Valley Water is happy to join this nationwide celebration and continue highlighting
[1:48:15] the contributions of Chicano and Hispanic Latino communities and individuals. And secondly,
[1:48:21] we will close today's meeting in honor of Congressman and Senator John Burton, which talked
[1:48:27] about before his brother Phil Burton's biography rage for justice included a lot of the
[1:48:39] great accomplishments that both him and his brother John accomplished. And of course,
[1:48:45] John, lasted a lot longer after.