Agenda
Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[17:33]
Good afternoon, everybody, and welcome to the Santa Clara Valley Water Board of Directors Meeting.
[17:39]
You call this meeting to order? I do. We take the roll call, please.
[17:46]
Directors Estimera, Shueha, Keegan, Kremlin, Lazad, Santas, Sherberella.
[17:56]
Okay, this is a board of directors meeting in closed session.
[18:00]
We have two items, closed session conference with legal counsel,
[18:03]
conference with real property negotiators.
[18:07]
Two point two closed session conference with labor negotiators.
[18:11]
So, at this point, we're going to adjourn to closed session.
[23:45]
Meeting to the, not to the closed session meeting, and so welcome to the Santa Clara Valley Water Board of Directors Meeting.
[23:51]
Coming out of closed session, district council, do we have a report?
[23:59]
With regards to closed session, conference with legal council, conference with real property negotiators, item number 2.1.
[24:06]
The Board has provided direction and authority to staff to receive with the sale on the terms and described by the Board.
[24:12]
That's it, thanks.
[24:13]
Thank you very much.
[24:14]
So the chair and item 2.2 senior assistant district council Brian and Hopper with all board members being present direction was given to staff nothing more to report.
[24:25]
Thank you appreciate the report.
[24:27]
Would they click on the board and Michelle can please lead us in the pledge of allegiance.
[24:55]
Welcome everyone.
[24:57]
And orders of the day they'll be a change.
[25:00]
In the consent calendar, item 3.1 will be continued, to another board meeting.
[25:10]
Chair.
[25:12]
If I could respond to that, we will be continuing the item.
[25:16]
If Saeed could come up and explain the rationale for the continuance of the item.
[25:27]
Hello, my name is Aida Seni, and in the last couple of weeks the staff from the
[25:37]
Stream Maintenance Program they have been in contact with the core and U.S.
[25:40]
Fish and Wildlife Services regarding the permit for this project, maybe I should mention
[25:45]
that this project is being permitted under the Stream Maintenance Program and in recent
[25:52]
conversation with the staff from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Services, they have mentioned
[25:58]
that, I mean, they verbally mentioned that they have prepared the concurrence with the
[26:05]
project and they're going to be preparing the little concurrence within the next couple
[26:09]
of days and would be sending it to the core and we are planning to, or we're expecting
[26:14]
to get the permit from the core by the end of the next week.
[26:19]
We've been in the contact with the lowest better and the informed them, you know, of the issue
[26:26]
and we are on board to as soon as we get the project awarded the proceed with the work.
[26:33]
Thank you for that update.
[26:38]
Now's the time for public comment on any item that is not on the agenda.
[26:42]
We have any sheets and I'm really okay moving forward, item 2.6 on the agenda recognition of the
[26:48]
2017 Employee Recognition Awardees.
[26:53]
Good evening board. My name is Salam Beckham, the Supervising Program Administrator for the Diversity and Inclusion Program.
[26:59]
Here at the district which also includes our annual Employee Recognition Program.
[27:05]
Recognition programs at our district are an expression of gratitude towards the employees who work so hard to keep the water flowing in Santa Clara County.
[27:14]
Research indicates that organizational culture that values employee recognition creates an
[27:21]
environment of high satisfaction and productivity. After this year's employee recognition
[27:25]
program in June, I sent out a survey to all employees where we once again ask the question
[27:31]
whether or not they agreed with the statement that the district is a great place to work.
[27:35]
As compared to the results of the same question a bit over a year ago, the percentage of
[27:40]
employees who agree with that statement has increased 16 percentage points to 78%.
[27:46]
Of the roughly 800 employees of the district, 23 winners were chosen this year to receive
[27:51]
an employee recognition award.
[27:53]
We had over 160 nominations diverging from the past selection process in an effort to remove
[28:00]
bias whether actual or perceived.
[28:02]
This year's committee of 12 staff volunteers reviewed every single application and every single
[28:08]
application had been scrubbed of all identifying information.
[28:12]
We are pleased with the results that have been hailed as recognizing many of the unsung heroes
[28:17]
at the district.
[28:19]
And with that, I'd like to introduce you to all of the winners of this year's awards.
[28:22]
What I'll do is I'll read a short statement about each of them that's paraphrased from their
[28:28]
longer nomination and I'll ask the winners who are here with us to stand at the end of the
[28:37]
recognizing them.
[28:40]
So about further ado, in the first category of teamwork,
[28:43]
we have Nancy Pan, who's from Water Utility,
[28:46]
who won for genuinely, genuinely caring
[28:49]
and supporting the district's mission,
[28:51]
particularly when it comes to emergency repair
[28:54]
and needs coordination.
[28:56]
We have Karen Coppett, also from Water Utilities,
[28:59]
who is an upbeat caring water conservation team member
[29:02]
and who models the district's values daily.
[29:05]
Karen comes to work energetic and optimistic
[29:07]
every day. And this creates a positive working environment. Theo Hippel, who's moved to Canada
[29:14]
recently, so he's no longer at the district, but he received his word before he left. He served
[29:18]
in the Watershed's Division and was always available to answer questions and engage in discussions
[29:23]
on the bigger picture in order to create an more efficiency and data input and databases of the district.
[29:30]
Jennifer Schmidt, who's also from Water Utility, takes the initiative in supporting the imported
[29:36]
water unit by continually anticipating needs and completing tasks before she's even asked
[29:41]
to do them.
[29:43]
The next category is continual improvement.
[29:46]
First we have Randy Barrens from Water Utility, who won the award for training himself
[29:51]
to become a groundwater modeler and investigating ways to enhance and improve the model of
[29:56]
the district.
[29:56]
He does his work with passion and scientific.
[30:01]
Humanity. Linda Arlach, from Water Utility as well, for being detail-oriented, precise, and thorough,
[30:08]
her methodical and neat approach to every task is exemplary and truly praiseworthy.
[30:15]
Jack McKinney, from administration, has used his knowledge skills and abilities to assist
[30:20]
with assessment and determination of personnel fall risks throughout the district's operation
[30:25]
and has fabricated and installed many fall protection solutions throughout the district.
[30:31]
Mark C. Lowe's from Watershed has implemented continual improvement activities
[30:35]
to the Guadalupe River and Mercury total maximum daily load project.
[30:40]
Mark worked to vastly improve all aspects of the Guadalupe River and Mercury,
[30:44]
TMDL data acquisition, data management and reporting program over the last year.
[30:50]
Our third category is accountability, where we have quite an layout from water sheds for working on a multitude of projects concurrently and serving as key technical support for a variety of district programs.
[31:02]
He takes on every task that comes his way and never refuses to undertake tasks even if they are very undesirable.
[31:11]
Artigoreshi from Water Utility is a big supporter of documentation and processes which help
[31:16]
to produce high quality work. He doesn't pass the buck along and if he makes a mistake,
[31:21]
he owns up to it. Gina Adriano from external affairs who proactively volunteer to take
[31:27]
on more significant roles and media relations and other communications tasks. She has done an
[31:32]
outstanding job representing the district, especially in Spanish language interviews over
[31:37]
past few months, including during the recent flood emergency.
[31:41]
Shirley Co. from administration for her work on Octa
[31:44]
as the district's identity management system of choice.
[31:48]
Shirley went to work with an aggressive implementation plan.
[31:51]
To date, Shirley has made over 40 applications work with Octa,
[31:55]
and the district staff has used Octa over 15,000 times.
[32:00]
Integrity.
[32:01]
Our first award went to Tony and Dawg,
[32:03]
who's moved on to the city of Milpitas,
[32:05]
But he won for integrity for managing the district's inspection and rehabilitation of large diameter pipeline programs.
[32:12]
He got ahead of many of his problems by thinking about a solution in the context of doing what's right for the community.
[32:19]
John Luna from Water Utility for his work as a resident constructor, Shen Inspector, who is tireless at his work,
[32:26]
always available to lend a hand or provide input and never above performing menial tasks that need to be done.
[32:32]
Home Cutler, from administration, for her strong sense of values and ethics, she is thoughtful,
[32:38]
fair, honest, and trustworthy in all areas of work.
[32:41]
She works very hard to produce quality product, and in the most if cost-effective way, benefiting
[32:47]
the district and all parties involved.
[32:50]
Tracy Hemeter, from water utilities, for being the epitome of a public servant, working tirelessly
[32:56]
to ensure future water supply reliability in the Santa Clara County.
[32:59]
She does this not for recognition but because she genuinely cares about the district's
[33:04]
mission serving the public and protecting local water supplies.
[33:09]
Service excellence, Nigel Bullock from Water Utility for his work as a resident inspector
[33:13]
on the Wolf Road recycled water facilities project.
[33:17]
His com but firm demeanor works well not only with district staff but also other agency
[33:21]
representatives in the public.
[33:24]
Brandon pumps from Water Utility for his work on the Floridation Project.
[33:27]
Brandon mentored and provided valuable guidance to an assistant engineer recognizing her strong capabilities.
[33:34]
Brandon has continually given her opportunities to develop herself professionally and has empowered her to take on more responsibilities.
[33:42]
Marty Grimes from external affairs, who responds to whatever call media call comes in on any topic.
[33:49]
He doesn't just find the subject matter expert and expect them to handle the request that gets up to speed on the issue,
[33:54]
help develop message points and prep staff in advance of interviews.
[33:59]
Ross Bull, from Water Utility, who takes pride in care in what he does.
[34:04]
His 25 plus years of experience and operations have given him a keen eye for what works and what
[34:09]
doesn't.
[34:10]
He passes that information on to less experience operators so they don't make mistakes and work
[34:14]
efficiently.
[34:16]
And then our last category is Excellence in Management and Supervision, where the first
[34:24]
utility for providing direction without hovering or micromanaging, providing clear direction
[34:29]
that is easy to follow, and creating the leadership and strategy for his unit with the
[34:33]
input of his team where appropriate. He is helpful and patient, yet holds himself and his
[34:37]
team accountable. Michelle Meredith from Kirk of the Board, for mentoring her staff to become
[34:43]
better employees of the district and challenging them to hold themselves accountable and
[34:47]
a manner that shows she cares about their success. And finally Vanessa D. LePadre for
[34:53]
emphasizing the importance of training and encouraging staff to enroll in programs and webinars
[34:57]
that help them grow. She also
[35:00]
So strongly encourages cross-training and knowledge transfer for smooth transitions to minimize the impact on the district.
[35:07]
Now, I'd like all of the employee recognition award winners from 2017 to stand, and I ask the board to officially recognize them by adopting this resolution.
[35:28]
Thank you. The fine example of leadership amongst your peers, congratulations to all the recipients.
[35:35]
And so we have a adopt the resolution.
[35:38]
The motion in a second.
[35:40]
This is a roll call vote.
[35:43]
Directors Estimera, Shwea, Keegan,
[35:47]
Brennan, Lezott, Santas, Chairboro.
[35:51]
Yes, absolutely.
[35:53]
Again, congratulations.
[35:55]
Well done.
[35:57]
Next on the agenda is the consent calendar.
[36:02]
I have a motion in a second.
[36:04]
All those signified by saying aye.
[36:07]
Any objection?
[36:09]
I do want to call out one item 3.3 to an individual that manages to come to these meetings regularly.
[36:18]
And that's Mr. Doug Muirhead, congratulations.
[36:21]
Serving and taking the time to serve on the appointment that you will do a fine job.
[36:26]
Thank you very much.
[36:27]
Mr. Chair, we have a roll call for the consent calendar for item 3.3.
[36:31]
There's a resolution of appreciation for Mark comments.
[36:33]
Very good.
[36:34]
Director Zestimera, Shwaya Keegan, Kremlin, Lizad, Santas, Chereverella.
[36:45]
Thank you all again.
[36:49]
Moving on to Board of Directors, Corporal One Board Committee reports,
[36:57]
Director Shwell.
[36:58]
Thank you, Chair.
[37:00]
I provided a memo about capital improvement program committees, July 10th meeting summary.
[37:12]
The important thing is for it's a committee continues to work on the funding issues for the
[37:20]
Watershed Capital Project, includes full protection project and stream source your capital project.
[37:27]
And I believe this is something that's really important.
[37:30]
The committee is working on so if board members have input for us,
[37:36]
I would definitely welcome your input and if you can submit your input to Ms. Michelle Marades.
[37:47]
We will greatly appreciate that because I do believe this is something that's really
[37:51]
really important.
[37:54]
The committee also looked at the people's of upgrade assessment study, which is actually on
[38:00]
today's agenda later on on the administration, the committee took in unanimously action
[38:09]
to support staff's recommendation and make that recommendation to the whole board.
[38:16]
That's my report.
[38:20]
Dr. Kiggen, did you want to comment on
[38:25]
one of the areas we did have a meeting yesterday
[38:27]
the board policy and planning, and one of the areas that we talked about was Creek maintenance
[38:33]
along the Coyote Creek, and what the two, two, three board members, Director Kigan,
[38:40]
Director Shwale myself, are absolutely adamant about getting started on this as quickly as
[38:46]
possible.
[38:47]
We have the opportunity to have a discussion about bringing NGOs in, of all interiors, such
[38:52]
as the San Jose Corps, and other groups that could come in and help the district.
[38:56]
We need to implement it.
[38:58]
It's been five months now since the flooding along the creek.
[39:00]
The debris is there and it's an iceort to not just the people that live within that area,
[39:06]
but to the entire area of San Jose.
[39:08]
So it is our role and is our responsibility to implement this as quickly as possible
[39:13]
and get those creaks cleaned and looking good.
[39:17]
Yes, I have a speaker for Dr. Kigan.
[39:20]
Thank you.
[39:21]
Thank you for your introductory comments, Chair Barrella.
[39:24]
Just to follow up, I think that we had a very spirited discussion at our meeting yesterday.
[39:31]
Part of the discussion hinged on the fact that the public expects that we will be able to find joint solutions,
[39:41]
whether it's with other property owners slash public agencies like the City of San Jose,
[39:46]
as well as how we can work with the regulatory agencies that guide our work.
[39:53]
public judges thus by results not by efforts and so we want to be able to achieve.
[40:00]
I believe a result that the community can be proud of, and that we'll meet their expectations and needs.
[40:07]
I just did also wanted to add that I believe the first meeting in August is when we will be forming our
[40:15]
co-IRD Creek ad hoc committee. And my understanding is at that time, there will be a brief status update by staff on some of the actions taken today.
[40:25]
Thank you.
[40:28]
Thank you chair, yeah, first of all, thank for your comment and Director Keegan's comment.
[40:35]
I think both of you summarize our meeting yesterday very well.
[40:38]
I just want to ask that I will still pull by the real memo.
[40:43]
Just so that every thing that's being discussed at the committee, there's a record we can go back to.
[40:49]
So the next four meeting, you will see.
[40:52]
Thank you, Director Swede, Director Santos.
[40:55]
Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair.
[40:57]
I appreciate your leadership and this board getting 22 million dollars allocated for that project no matter what.
[41:03]
Like Barbara just got through saying, we're going to have this ad hoc committee.
[41:07]
So I would support what you're saying.
[41:09]
I'm sure Rails does too.
[41:10]
I see you to get this thing moving on.
[41:12]
Peanut up with the volunteers or whatever we've got to do.
[41:15]
This will help our committee.
[41:16]
You can go faster.
[41:17]
So appreciate the comments and the support.
[41:20]
Thank you.
[41:21]
So that is the end of the committee reports on item 4.1, what are utilities enterprise, item 5.1,
[41:29]
resolution for the Proposition 1 funding application for the Pacheco Reservoir Expansion Project.
[41:37]
Good afternoon. Thank you. Good evening, Chair Verella, members of the Board,
[41:41]
Jerry D. L. P. Adria, Acting Deputy for the Warsupply Division. And the item in front of the
[41:45]
board tonight is for you to consider adopting a resolution for the Pacheco Reservoir Expansion Project.
[41:50]
it's a requirement of the prop one funding.
[41:53]
The packet of course includes a draft resolution,
[41:55]
and we use the template from the California Water Commission
[41:58]
as the template for that draft resolution.
[42:01]
I also wanted to note that there's a supplemental agenda memo
[42:04]
for this item that we wanted to give an update on CEQA
[42:07]
and the deadlines for CEQA.
[42:09]
And in order to meet those deadlines
[42:10]
for the prop one funding application,
[42:12]
we've initiated that process.
[42:14]
We're working on the initial study,
[42:15]
as well as a notice of preparation.
[42:18]
The plan is to file those with the state
[42:19]
Most likely the first week of August, I think, August 3rd is what we're targeting, and of
[42:23]
course, including those in our application to the state by August 14th.
[42:27]
And so what that staff is available to answer any questions.
[42:30]
Dr. Criman?
[42:34]
I approve this.
[42:34]
Staff recommendation.
[42:36]
I have a motion in a second, then a conversation discussion, all those in favor
[42:40]
sign up.
[42:41]
It's a roll call.
[42:43]
Director of Zester Mera, Shwaya, Keegan, Rimmant, Lesot, Santos, Chair Barrel.
[42:51]
Yes.
[42:52]
that concludes item 5.1. Moving on, 5.2, resolution adopted, an updated fee schedule for
[42:59]
Administrating District Well-Premets and Inspections.
[43:05]
Mr. Burrell, our Chair of Burrell and Board members, I'm Mike Deffy, I'm Wells and
[43:10]
Water Measurement Manager.
[43:12]
This evening, I'm here to recommend a adoption of a resolution which updates are existing
[43:17]
fee schedule for our Well-Premitting Program. These are fees that the district charges for issuing
[43:23]
well permits and making inspections to ensure that permitted work is completed in accordance
[43:28]
with the district and state of California well standards.
[43:31]
The proposed fee schedule is on page 3 of attachment 4, lots of attachments on this one.
[43:37]
I wanted to point out at this time that this time around that the proposed resolution
[43:41]
includes authority for the chief executive office or to enter into agreements with other
[43:46]
public agencies for a mutual waiver of like kind permit fees.
[43:50]
In other words, the waiver of fees that are typically charged should be administrative or undertaken to ensure compliance with an agency's regulations and guidelines.
[44:00]
This provision was added to establish consistency between our permit fee resolution and the permit fee resolution associated with the existing water resources protection ordinance.
[44:11]
I don't have anything else to present if you have any questions.
[44:13]
The answer to the questions, comments from the board.
[44:17]
Have a motion.
[44:17]
Do I have a second?
[44:19]
Have a motion in a second.
[44:20]
And a discussion.
[44:22]
This is roll call vote.
[44:25]
Director Zesmer.
[44:27]
Choya.
[44:28]
Keegan.
[44:30]
Bremen.
[44:31]
Zot.
[44:33]
Santos.
[44:34]
Chair Barrow.
[44:35]
Yes.
[44:36]
It concludes item 5.2.
[44:38]
Moving on.
[44:39]
5.3.
[44:41]
Amendment number 5.
[44:42]
to agreement number A3676A with URS Corporation for Design Services for a not to exceed
[44:50]
fee of 6,000, 1,165. Resulting in total not to exceed fee of 17,385,900.
[45:01]
For the Anderson Dam's seismic retrofit project.
[45:05]
Good evening, Chair Verala, and Members of the Board, Hamang Desai Engineering Manager for the
[45:10]
Dam Safety Program Unit. The item before you, for consideration, is an amendment to the
[45:16]
Design Service's agreement with the URS for the Anderson Dam seismic retrofit project.
[45:22]
Based on the new findings in July, June, July of last year, the concept which was developed
[45:28]
in 2013 for the project has been substantially modified.
[45:32]
The staff had presented the modified version in the December 2016 meeting.
[45:39]
The staff has been negotiating the additional scope of work with the consultant for the
[45:43]
last four months and based on that, those negotiations and additional amount of 6 million
[45:50]
will be required to complete the design.
[45:53]
Additionally, the term of agreement will also be need to be extended to 2020, and with that, I'm open to any questions for you.
[46:01]
Any questions from the Board? Director Lissat?
[46:05]
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
[46:08]
I'm looking at the staff report and on page 6 of 7, there's table 2, and it says a DSO-D fee of $820,000.
[46:20]
Is that a inspection fees?
[46:23]
Those are the fees which are required for the modification of the permit for the project and those are paid in installments.
[46:32]
So the next installment is for the 30% design.
[46:34]
What do you see there?
[46:36]
All right.
[46:36]
So there wouldn't have been anything earlier.
[46:38]
Thank you.
[46:42]
Director Kigan.
[46:44]
Thank you.
[46:46]
I know that the reports vary through and I know that you mentioned this in the report.
[46:51]
But I do feel it's worth restating publicly because I think there's some confusion sometimes with members of the public that do wonder, you know, why, why is the engineering efforts increasing?
[47:10]
And really, it's because when we're dealing with something as sensitive as a dam, when we have regulators like DSOD and Burke that are involved with it,
[47:20]
We really need to do quite a bit in terms of preliminary investigations so that we actually have enough information
[47:29]
to develop the final scope of the project.
[47:32]
So you came before us at June 28, 2016 and reported that we were going to need to do some additional work.
[47:41]
You also came back at the December 13th Board meeting and describe the modified project,
[47:46]
project, which requires the replacement of most of the existing dam, which is a huge amount
[47:52]
of work with an embankment that would address all the project deficiencies and meet modern
[47:56]
dam, safety, and performance standards.
[47:59]
So that was information that we didn't have when we initially started on this project.
[48:04]
So again, your staff report was very thorough and included that, but I just wanted to mention,
[48:10]
I think, again, it's difficult for the public sometimes to understand these things.
[48:14]
And we need to meet the highest level of modern dam safety and performance standards, not just because DSOD and FERC are requiring it of us,
[48:29]
but because it's the prudent and safe thing to do.
[48:32]
Thank you.
[48:33]
Thank you.
[48:36]
I just want to add, in addition to the meetings that staff provided,
[48:43]
additional information, the meetings that Director Keegan mentioned.
[48:48]
Steph also brought the amendment proposal to the CIP committee.
[48:55]
I think this is July, not June, but May.
[48:59]
The May CIP committee meeting.
[49:02]
And as a committee member, focus, it's review on the contract compliance
[49:08]
part of the existing consultant agreement, and then are satisfied with consultants' performance.
[49:21]
So I just wanted to add that piece of information for public to know, and I'd like to
[49:27]
make a motion to approve staff recommendation.
[49:31]
Okay.
[49:31]
Have a motion in a second, any other discussion before the vote?
[49:35]
All those in favor signify by saying aye.
[49:38]
Aye.
[49:39]
All opposed.
[49:40]
That's it.
[49:41]
That's it.
[49:45]
Moving on to item 5.4.
[49:47]
Audit for the water utility enterprise funds for the fiscal year ended June 30th.
[49:51]
2016.
[49:55]
Good evening, Chair Verilla.
[49:55]
Members of the board.
[49:57]
Darren Taylor.
[49:57]
Chief Financial Officer.
[49:59]
Item 5.4.
[50:00]
For as the audit of the Water Utility Enterprise Funds for a fiscal year ended June 30, 2016, and this
[50:06]
is an audit that we've been doing for about 10 years now. The idea is to have a second
[50:12]
pair of eyes. Take a look at how we allocate costs and revenues between our two zones
[50:17]
of benefit in the Water Utility, the zone W2 in North County and zone W5 in South County.
[50:26]
The
[50:27]
revenues and costs are allocated fairly and equitably, and that there were no findings and the staff recommendation is for the board to accept the audit report.
[50:37]
Any comments or questions at this point?
[50:40]
Director, there's up.
[50:42]
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
[50:43]
There are no one page 10 of attachment one and it's a section that says budgetary basis discussion.
[50:55]
So, I have questions on the second and third little bullet points there.
[51:06]
And this might be why you say that cost allocations are different.
[51:10]
Did I direct you to the right place?
[51:12]
I'm with you now.
[51:13]
You're with me now.
[51:16]
So, the fourth bullet point down says the administration in general expenses make up 11% of the total
[51:23]
revenue is for North County, and 33% for the South County.
[51:28]
So is that the allocation or is that the actual expenses and why would South
[51:33]
County be so high?
[51:37]
We're talking about the General Administrative Costs that are cost centered for the
[51:43]
Water Utility.
[51:45]
In other words, it's not burdened, it's not overhead, but it's General Administrative Costs.
[51:48]
like meter reading, finance, rate setting, studies that we do.
[51:56]
And so, because of the fact that the North County is so much bigger, it's, you know,
[52:03]
95, 90 percent of the total water utility, the South County is much smaller, those administrative
[52:08]
costs end up being a little bit larger proportion for the South County, especially things like
[52:15]
meter reading and billing because there are most of the wells that we have of the 5,000 wells in the county.
[52:23]
Most of them are down in the South County, so the costs mostly are allocated to the South County for those particular activities.
[52:30]
And that's what's going to drive that disparity.
[52:33]
And then the final bullet there says just as the revenues and the expenses results in a 17 million dollar loss from operations.
[52:49]
So is that a paper loss? Is that a real loss? Is that a loss we have to deal with?
[52:55]
It's the fourth bullet in that team.
[53:00]
So that's an operating loss.
[53:04]
What happens below that line in the financial statement are things like property tax revenues
[53:10]
that's where they show it in the statement of revenues expenses.
[53:14]
And so your bottom line, the truly bottom line, is not a loss.
[53:19]
It's a positive.
[53:21]
Because of, but
[53:27]
it's showing revenues, 15 million operating expenses, it's 70, is that?
[53:34]
Oh, that's just operating.
[53:36]
Yeah, so these balances out.
[53:38]
Yeah, what that bullet is referring to is an operating income before line items like property tax revenues,
[53:47]
investment income, rental income, and things like that.
[53:49]
So, it's when you add those things in, your bottom line is a positive, not a negative.
[53:55]
I just, the reason I pointed out was, I think when you have things like that in the public document,
[54:03]
it looks like, oh my God, we're running a $70 million operating loss and what are we doing?
[54:08]
So, I wanted to have your able explanation of that on the record. Thank you.
[54:14]
Thank you, Director. Director.
[54:17]
Yeah, thank you chair question for you, Aaron on page 16 of 72, which is page 12 of the audit under capital assets the last line
[54:32]
$1.3 million, this is the last of all the bullet points on that page where it says
[54:44]
I'm not sure where the Ellamita dam is.
[54:49]
The great question.
[54:50]
I believe that's a typo.
[54:51]
It should be all madem.
[54:52]
All madem.
[54:53]
So are you telling me the auditors signed off on a bad report here?
[54:57]
Well, in here.
[54:59]
Is that all madem?
[55:00]
May be, may be, spell check wasn't run on that particular part, so it should be on my end.
[55:05]
What other mistakes aren't here?
[55:08]
Okay. Wow. Yes. Okay. Next question. The drought reserve that we've voted on.
[55:15]
Where would that be? Is that under the other reserves?
[55:23]
That would be on.
[55:24]
You know, that could be the statement of changes. You know what I'm talking about, right?
[55:28]
I know what you're talking about. I don't see it.
[55:31]
Yeah, it's it's in here to give me a moment. I can probably find it. Well on page 15, which is page 19 of 72
[55:42]
When we looked at our restricted funds
[55:46]
Okay, would it be that you would think that would be a separate line item?
[55:52]
Well, it's it's most likely going to be
[55:55]
In the unrestricted
[55:58]
What's restricted?
[56:03]
I just don't see it. I remember we voted on having a
[56:10]
So we think about it, for FY16, I think we added it in FY17.
[56:15]
This is the year and FY16.
[56:17]
We added it in FY17.
[56:18]
We increased it in FY18.
[56:20]
So we're not going to see it in FY16.
[56:22]
It's a time limit.
[56:23]
Next year.
[56:23]
Next year.
[56:24]
When's the last time we've changed our auditors?
[56:27]
Is it a matter of good practice?
[56:29]
This year is the fifth year of using our external auditors.
[56:33]
We're going to be changing them for next year.
[56:37]
Maybe I'll have a better spell checker.
[56:40]
Thank you.
[56:43]
Thank you.
[56:43]
Director for pointing that out.
[56:45]
That is a very interesting point.
[56:47]
Any other comments?
[56:50]
Have a motion?
[56:50]
Do I have a second?
[56:52]
Motion in a second?
[56:53]
All those.
[56:55]
All those of the favor, signify by say nine?
[56:57]
All opposed?
[56:59]
That passes unanimously.
[57:01]
Thank you very much.
[57:02]
Item 5.5.
[57:05]
Standard on call consultant agreement with Kennedy
[57:07]
Thanks, consultants for pipeline engineering analysis and rehabilitation services for not to exceed
[57:15]
fee of $5 million.
[57:19]
Good evening, Mr. Bell, and members of the Board.
[57:21]
Christopher Hakes, assistant officer for the Water until the capital division.
[57:25]
Board recommendation is for, I guess, staff recommendation is for approval of the on-collar
[57:29]
agreement for pipeline engineering services for a term of five years and I'm not to exceed
[57:34]
about $5 million.
[57:36]
Staff is present to answer any questions that you may have.
[57:42]
I have a motion in a second, I have a motion in a second, I also have discussion director Schweyer.
[57:51]
It's a question, my question is 5.5, 5.6, what's the difference between these two?
[57:59]
So, 5.5 is mainly aimed at our capital for designing and contracting support services,
[58:04]
with just a little bit of analysis and inspection where it's 5.6 is more for our, I guess,
[58:11]
our condition assessment with a little bit of design services.
[58:15]
So, it's really should go 5.6 than 5.5 because the,
[58:19]
the second agreement that we're going to look at is actually for the condition assessment
[58:23]
and rehabilitation services where we are developing our acoustic cyber optic monitoring database
[58:30]
for a wire breaks, so they're linked, but they're kind of too
[58:35]
have to, or one thing. Thank you. Thank you for your explanation. I
[58:40]
should cannot tell that from the agenda memorandum. Yeah, they were going to be
[58:44]
going more clear. Yeah, it was a lot of exactly the same paragraph in
[58:49]
both agenda memorandum. Thank you.
[58:53]
So I took a look at them.
[58:55]
Well, my comments are a little bit similar to
[59:00]
I'm director Shua's when I was reading board
[59:04]
memorandum and then read the attached agreement.
[59:10]
It was not clear to me what staff was anticipating
[59:15]
the task orders would be.
[59:18]
And from your explanation, I'm assuming
[59:22]
that this is more a case of Kennedy Janks, augmenting staff work in terms of preparing design plans and things of that nature.
[59:33]
That is correct.
[59:34]
Yes, I see, Emmanuel Maudin also.
[59:38]
Okay, and then the other item is a more narrowly focused technical analysis in terms of the monitoring of the wire breakage and things of that nature.
[59:51]
So just a recommendation, a little more detail, I think, would have been good.
[1:00:00]
I have no other speakers, so I have a motion in a second. All those that favour signify by saying aye. Aye. All the pose that item carries unanimously. Next item in the agenda is item 5.6. Standard on call consultant agreement with pure technologies United States incorporated for engineering and analysis services for large diameter pipelines for not to exceed fee of $2 million.
[1:00:29]
have a motion on a second.
[1:00:31]
Any discussion?
[1:00:33]
All those in favor signify by saying aye?
[1:00:38]
I'd like to kick in.
[1:00:39]
Thank you.
[1:00:41]
For my colleague's director, Creman, and Director Estamara,
[1:00:45]
when we went down and visited the
[1:00:53]
Poseidon desalination plant,
[1:00:55]
we had the opportunity to talk with the organization there
[1:00:59]
about some of the things that they were doing.
[1:01:01]
And they actually were doing something similar to what we're moving forward with now.
[1:01:08]
So I think that this is a really great investment of money.
[1:01:11]
This is going to provide us with important information that will help us avoid having a catastrophic
[1:01:19]
kind of failure.
[1:01:20]
We'll have warning things in place that will help us avoid that.
[1:01:24]
So this is a great step, and I am very happy to support the motion.
[1:01:27]
Thank you.
[1:01:28]
Thank you.
[1:01:28]
continuing on with the vote. All those in favor signify by saying aye. All opposed that I
[1:01:34]
do carries unanimously. Moving on, item six watersheds, six point one, stream maintenance
[1:01:41]
program reporting for fiscal year 17.
[1:01:48]
Good evening, Chair Verella and members of the board.
[1:01:51]
I'm Sue Tippett. I'm the deputy officer for watersheds operations and maintenance. This item
[1:01:56]
to receive a report and discuss and provide feedback to staff on the stream maintenance program.
[1:02:04]
The stream maintenance program begins began on June 15th and runs through October 15th.
[1:02:09]
This year we have over 500 projects which we will be putting into two separate notices of proposed work
[1:02:15]
to the regulatory agencies for review because of the rate number of sites and work.
[1:02:22]
We recommend that it's regular status report, be taught to the board.
[1:02:28]
This will provide you with timely information as to what is going on.
[1:02:32]
This is the second report, and this item, the first one, was provided in Nonagenda a couple weeks ago.
[1:02:38]
And as a, with your discussion, we'd like to hear any additional information that you'd like to see on the report.
[1:02:45]
The frequency of the report, if every board meeting is appropriate.
[1:02:48]
And if you'd like more pictures, less pictures, whatever you'd like to see.
[1:02:54]
So moving into the stream maintenance reports that's in the or the agenda item.
[1:03:00]
The district leaves submitted 285 stream maintenance items in its first notice of proposed work.
[1:03:07]
The regulatory agencies had 45 days to review those as of June 30th.
[1:03:11]
The agencies had approved 239 of those.
[1:03:14]
And the rate and remaining of them were pending approvals from the core and U.S.
[1:03:18]
Kishan Wildlife.
[1:03:20]
There were no further approvals during this reporting period.
[1:03:23]
However, I will report that as of July 20th,
[1:03:25]
we did receive verbal approval from U.S.
[1:03:28]
U.S. Kishan Wildlife Service for 11 projects,
[1:03:30]
the core of verbally approved all remaining items,
[1:03:34]
except for one site at Stephen's Creek at Crittenden.
[1:03:38]
And this includes the Type-Gate Project and the L.C.M.
[1:03:41]
a strong drain, which were the small capital projects that have been presented to you.
[1:03:47]
We are expecting the written response from the four in the service end of this week early
[1:03:54]
next week.
[1:03:56]
We also submitted the second notice of proposed work, which was an additional 17 stream maintenance
[1:04:02]
item, and the agencies have until August 6th to complete their review and provide approvals
[1:04:09]
for that. As of July 20th, we not heard from most of the agencies but we did hear from the
[1:04:16]
core, they had approved the 12 of them that were under their jurisdiction and issued a letter
[1:04:21]
of consultation to the NIMPS in US Fish and Wildlife Service for another 14.
[1:04:27]
So looking at the report itself, we've included a listing there of the projects that were
[1:04:32]
ongoing or completed during this period and some pictures of the work that's occurring.
[1:04:38]
On the second page, we have this, the work that our vegetation management unit is conducting.
[1:04:45]
The first chart there includes the mitigation site maintenance and this is work that's
[1:04:51]
done largely read abatement of existing re-vegetation sites and mitigation sites.
[1:04:56]
and our work on our IPNP, which is then based.
[1:05:00]
This is the plan removal program. Each report here will have a different kind of layout of the work
[1:05:09]
that's done, the first report showed a lot of the work in the coyote watershed, and this report shows
[1:05:18]
that the bulk of the work and the water utility, and that was largely weight abatement done at our
[1:05:23]
or utility sites, kindly on-meters canal and the sledge ponds in particular.
[1:05:28]
And then the second chart there shows the work that's done for the, that's largely
[1:05:34]
along our maintenance roads.
[1:05:35]
This is weed abatement and upland herbicide application.
[1:05:38]
This is work that's done, like I said, on the maintenance roads, along fence lines, along
[1:05:42]
our trails.
[1:05:43]
And then this is during this reporting period, that was part of, part of, of acreage, most
[1:05:49]
that was within the Guadalupe water shed, along Guadalupe River and Creek, and Monclero
[1:05:55]
Alamides creeks.
[1:05:58]
Work that's not shown in this chart that you may have an interest in hearing about is
[1:06:03]
our minor maintenance work.
[1:06:06]
This is a Fends Repair of Fish Latter, some trash and debris and contaminants.
[1:06:11]
But in particular, one of the items under that minor maintenance is the work that we did
[1:06:16]
on County Creek.
[1:06:17]
I'm sure you're interested in, and that is we did 10 trash and debris on tree removal sites for a total of 720 yards of debris removal.
[1:06:28]
So with that, if there's anything you'd like to comment on or provide.
[1:06:33]
Mr. Vizor, are we doing the public notification on their sort of the media and through the social media as to progress and pending projects?
[1:06:44]
sites that we see here, or we know to find the public of this.
[1:06:47]
Yes, from the major projects, relatively major, we do provide
[1:06:50]
that outreach to the community in the neighborhood.
[1:06:54]
Within the neighborhood of the district, very good.
[1:06:57]
Thank you.
[1:06:59]
This is an action item.
[1:07:00]
I have no board comments.
[1:07:01]
So do I have a motion?
[1:07:11]
Just information, a bigger part.
[1:07:14]
It's an on.
[1:07:16]
Item 6.2, report the fits received and the word construction
[1:07:21]
contact to organic construction company in the sum of $2,647,777 dollars.
[1:07:29]
The construction of the Alcumino storm drain erosion report repair project number 6208401.
[1:07:37]
We have a report.
[1:07:40]
Good evening, Chair Erella.
[1:07:41]
Members of the board.
[1:07:42]
I'm Roger Narsim.
[1:07:44]
You're doing a huge manager.
[1:07:45]
The watershed design and construction unit.
[1:07:47]
I'm also acting for knock one today.
[1:07:49]
and this item 6.2 for board's consideration is for the approval of construction of
[1:07:56]
Elcombinous Tombrane, a repair project in CDA Santa Clara, and just want to bring attention
[1:08:04]
to the board that the CDA of Santa Clara is supporting this project, and with that I'm
[1:08:09]
available for any questions.
[1:08:13]
Have a motion in the second comment from Director Kigan?
[1:08:16]
I have a question, we only had one bitter on this project, so did we do any outreach to see why there was, you know, only one person that's kind of odd.
[1:08:30]
On June 6th, we had six prime contractors as a private meeting. It was mandatory meeting.
[1:08:37]
So, we give five weeks for the bidding process, we open the bid on July 12th, and we called the contractors the day before the opening, and they said they're all busy, you're not for five weeks, so there was only one bid at that time.
[1:08:52]
So, it was close to the engineers' estimates, so it seems like we got a pretty good bid.
[1:08:57]
Very close to that, thank you.
[1:08:59]
I have a motion in a second.
[1:09:02]
All those in favour, signify by say 9, I, all opposed, that measure carries unanimously.
[1:09:09]
Thank you.
[1:09:10]
Thank you.
[1:09:11]
Moving on to item 7, external affairs.
[1:09:13]
And we have no reports.
[1:09:16]
Chief Executive Officer, number 8, 8.1.
[1:09:21]
Yes.
[1:09:21]
Thank you, Chair.
[1:09:22]
Now, we're going to come up to our interim CEO.
[1:09:24]
We do have report from Monteggrimes on this section 1126 feasibility study.
[1:09:32]
Good news, actually.
[1:09:34]
Yes, good evening, chair umbrella members of the board.
[1:09:37]
This morning, we posted a press release announcing the cavity creak feasibility study with the
[1:09:42]
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, the press release resulted in a KGO radio interview with
[1:09:46]
and Congressional Representative Zodlopkin and Rokana
[1:09:51]
advocated for this action leading to the partnership.
[1:09:55]
This feasibility study will look at the engineering
[1:09:58]
economic and environmental aspects of a potter.
[1:10:00]
A possible flood protection project on coyote Creek to establish what's called a federal interest. Before we can get funding from the federal government for a flood protection project, we must establish a federal interest. That happens if the study finds the project's benefits outweigh the costs.
[1:10:15]
And what's unique about this situation is that we will be doing the feasibility study, and the Army Corps will be providing technical assistance.
[1:10:22]
And once the study is completed, then we'll be able to pursue having Congress authorize the project for consideration.
[1:10:32]
Thank you very much.
[1:10:34]
And you have another report.
[1:10:36]
Marty, on Asian Recycle Water Day.
[1:10:38]
Right.
[1:10:39]
I'd like to report on the Asian Community Day at the Silicon Valley Advanced Water Pupurcation Center that happened on July 15.
[1:10:46]
It was the first time we had such an event at the facility.
[1:10:50]
250 people attended, which succeeded our goal of 200.
[1:10:55]
It featured tours of the facility, educational water-based lessons, and activities for children,
[1:11:02]
informational tables on groundwater management, conservation, and the Dr. Creek Program,
[1:11:06]
and taste tests of the Purified Water.
[1:11:08]
Vice Chair Richard Santos, and Dr. Niceway, welcome the public for their scheduled tours,
[1:11:14]
and Dr. Sway was interviewed by a Chinese newspaper reporter.
[1:11:17]
Our preliminary review of the support cards that we collected at that event
[1:11:20]
shows that the public marked the event very positively
[1:11:25]
with what on the water samples and the event itself.
[1:11:28]
And this morning, we received a thank you letter
[1:11:30]
from U.I.K., a Japanese-American Community Service Agency
[1:11:33]
for Seniors, which had brought 40 people to the event.
[1:11:39]
We'll be writing up this event in our E-News
[1:11:41]
monthly newsletter.
[1:11:43]
And just to note, this is the second event
[1:11:45]
that we've held at this nature, less summer,
[1:11:48]
We had the Latino tour day in partnership with
[1:11:50]
Somos Mere May Fair, a nonprofit that serves families in East San Jose.
[1:11:55]
And we will continue our outreach efforts with tours at the Peer Vacation Center and the Speaker's Bureau program.
[1:12:02]
Thank you for those reports.
[1:12:03]
We have additional...
[1:12:04]
Thank you, Marty.
[1:12:04]
There are a few more.
[1:12:06]
Yeah, Garth Hall, acting chief for what a utility has some water fixed milestones.
[1:12:10]
He'd like to report on.
[1:12:12]
Good evening, Board members.
[1:12:14]
So in that context, as announced by Norma Camacho, on July 25,
[1:12:20]
There were two closely linked important milestones for that particular project, the Department
[1:12:26]
of Water Resources issued a notice of termination for the water fix after certifying the
[1:12:32]
EIR for the project and approving that project as it preferred alternative under the
[1:12:37]
secret act. Also, associated with that DWR adopted secret findings, a statement of overwriting
[1:12:46]
considerations and adopted a mitigation monitoring and reporting program for the project.
[1:12:52]
So that critical milestone certifies that the environmental analysis of the waterfix
[1:12:56]
complies with secret on the on the state side and can now move the project step closer towards
[1:13:03]
construction. On the federal side, reclamation has not yet adopted the EIS, which is the counterpart
[1:13:10]
the Secret document. Nor has it issued its record of decision and has not yet announced
[1:13:16]
a date in which it will do so. Also, since we are talking about June 21, that partner
[1:13:23]
watery sources filed with a court, Sacramento Superior Court, a validation action, which
[1:13:30]
would affirm the department's authority to, among other things, issue revenue bonds to finance
[1:13:36]
the planning, design, construction, and other capital costs of the Waterfix project.
[1:13:44]
DWO believes a validation action is necessary to provide assurances to the financial
[1:13:49]
community for the sale of the Waterfix revenue bonds.
[1:13:54]
Thank you.
[1:13:58]
And current errands has reported on the Cochrane Line Bell.
[1:14:02]
It even means to have all the members of the board just a very quick update on the Cochrane
[1:14:06]
line valve, remember we had incident with that valve, over a
[1:14:09]
momental day weekend and in May, it's a precaution we've been
[1:14:12]
operating at reduced flows to that pipeline, we crossed
[1:14:15]
all the pipelines since that time, waiting for the SBA to come
[1:14:18]
back online, the space now back online delivering water to
[1:14:21]
the valley, so we're scheduling repairs. So beginning this
[1:14:24]
weekend, we'll be switching, they're rink and auto, and
[1:14:27]
potential plant to 100% south of the aqua duck water,
[1:14:35]
and
[1:14:35]
that from current supply through the costality tube for a collateral only, that allows
[1:14:41]
to shut down the costality pipeline and begin to be watering that Saturday morning.
[1:14:47]
Our goal is Monday morning, we'll be ready to enter the pipeline, do inspection, remove
[1:14:51]
the valve, put in the school piece, and hopefully depending on anything you find that needs
[1:14:57]
repair and they difficult these putting it all back again.
[1:15:00]
Further, by the end of next week, we should have the prostate pipeline back in operation and restored
[1:15:05]
flows back from San Luis Reservoir in Anderson. I just want to give that update. That would be all occurring next week.
[1:15:13]
Thank you for that update.
[1:15:16]
And when last update from Vincent Jen, our acting chief on community and McKelvie Park project.
[1:15:23]
Good evening, Chair Berlin, board members. I want to disclose the board that on the McKelvie Park detention
[1:15:31]
We received two public complaints last week regarding the construction.
[1:15:38]
One complaint was due to work exceeding the construction time into the evening.
[1:15:45]
We have since our staff at Warcha have worked with the contractor to come up with a plan to prevent future
[1:15:51]
problems of work exceeding the time limit.
[1:15:53]
The second item unrelated was a noise complaint for another resident, the resident requested
[1:15:59]
that our contractor resequence refazed the work and moved the construction to another location
[1:16:04]
while the resident relocated to temporary accommodations.
[1:16:08]
Unfortunately, this work is on the critical path and will affect schedule for resequence
[1:16:14]
and there will also be cost impacts, so we were not able to accommodate that request.
[1:16:17]
But watershed staff is working on researching sound barriers potentially that could be used in the future that may minimize noise in the future, so that is a research effort with construction.
[1:16:31]
Thank you, Mr. Jim.
[1:16:32]
Thank you, and that concludes our report.
[1:16:36]
Thank you, appreciate that. Moving on to administration.
[1:16:38]
9.1, adopt plans and specialifications, and authorize and advise us for bids for the board
[1:16:45]
rule.
[1:16:46]
Outer visual modernization on behalf of Mr. and Director Satos, we appreciate this.
[1:16:53]
Thank you.
[1:16:53]
Shall we have a really board of members?
[1:16:56]
The Department of Administration will be making three items today, and typically we're
[1:17:00]
always the quiet people, so we're excited to be making, well, we think our three important
[1:17:05]
things that really affect a district government.
[1:17:08]
I think the most important thing on the item tonight regarding the audiovisual program
[1:17:12]
is that this room is really the face of a district government and it has a lot of unique
[1:17:21]
features that typically you don't find in other boardrooms that really have made the importance
[1:17:28]
of visiting other communities and evaluating both their technology as well as the layout
[1:17:36]
important for tonight's presentation. I know I've designed to other city council
[1:17:42]
chambers and other communities and I think the most important thing that we've
[1:17:46]
tried to really be sensitive to is that this building in this room in particular
[1:17:51]
the technology has to really meet the needs of two parties, both the board members who
[1:17:58]
are looking in one direction and the audience that are looking in another direction.
[1:18:03]
And we're trying to make sure that the technology that we're going to be hopefully acquiring
[1:18:08]
doesn't interfere with the functioning of the meeting itself when you look at the
[1:18:13]
mark microphones and the obstruction used and just the overall sense of trying to operate
[1:18:20]
the technology.
[1:18:21]
It's extremely awkward and we're hoping to really make some substantial improvements.
[1:18:26]
Probably the most important thing we want to emphasize tonight, while there is some minor
[1:18:31]
cost reductions with upgrading the system due to the age and the
[1:18:36]
operability in placing some of the parts and keeping this thing
[1:18:40]
functioning. Primarily the biggest benefit of the system that we're
[1:18:45]
going to be talking tonight really is to promote transparency and
[1:18:49]
provide effective communication to the general public. This building and
[1:18:52]
this room in particular is the face of the district and it's important
[1:18:57]
with people come in to make a presentation, but the technology does not obstruct communication,
[1:19:04]
as well as to be able to provide an effective format to receive it if you can't come here
[1:19:10]
and you're reviewing it at home on your internet. So with that, I'm going to turn over the
[1:19:15]
presentation to our IT director, Ashu Dekar.
[1:19:25]
Good evening, chair Verella and members of the board.
[1:19:27]
My name is Ashti Kikar, Deputy Operating Officer Information Technology.
[1:19:32]
Today, we are requesting the board to adopt the plans and specifications and authorize staff to advertise the boardroom AV modernization project as for the notice to bidders.
[1:19:43]
And we are also requesting the board to authorize designated engineer to issue a din does as necessary.
[1:19:51]
Just Susan gave a great introduction, but I just wanted to say a few words about this project as well.
[1:19:57]
We have spent considerable amount of time in this.
[1:20:00]
Signing the new system and making sure that we will meet the needs of the board and various commuting meetings that are held in this room.
[1:20:08]
We have done stakeholder reviews spoken to several users about their experiences using the current system.
[1:20:15]
We have also done several site visits to organizations such as City of Morgan Hill, Mountain View and Fremont to gain from their experiences in deploying similar systems.
[1:20:26]
So we have taken a lot of feedback from the IT directors as well as the installers of the systems that these respective organizations.
[1:20:36]
The district and the public will benefit from the completion of this project in several different ways.
[1:20:43]
The project is a comprehensive technology refresh of our audio visual equipment.
[1:20:48]
I think the current system is almost 17 years old.
[1:20:52]
It's an analog system and is not supported by any support and maintenance contract.
[1:20:59]
The new system will be built ground up on the latest HD standards and will be reliable and fully supported by a maintenance contract.
[1:21:07]
So when I say latest HD standards, we are also looking forward.
[1:21:12]
So when 4K technology becomes something of commodity, right now 4K digital systems
[1:21:21]
cost much more, but if and when that becomes a commodity, this system will be able to use
[1:21:28]
that leverage that technology as well for HD standards.
[1:21:33]
The new digital projection system will provide a better viewing experience with bright and
[1:21:38]
crisp presentations, and new hypocardoid mics will improve the speaker audio quality by making
[1:21:44]
sure that the speaker is always within the audio pattern of the speaker.
[1:21:49]
So I think that's going to be a great improvement because we've heard several complaints regarding the
[1:21:55]
audio quality of the system.
[1:21:58]
We're also providing the board to choose from two options.
[1:22:02]
Susan mentioned about improving upon the desk clutter that you currently have.
[1:22:09]
So we're going to give you two options to choose from.
[1:22:11]
One is we were able to set up demos of these large panels and the second option would be
[1:22:18]
access monitors where we will cut your dies and make space for
[1:22:23]
recess monitors and both options will be priced by the
[1:22:27]
bidders and we will give the board the option to choose which option
[1:22:32]
they want to go with. We plan to bring that item to the CIP
[1:22:36]
adult committee meeting on September 11th and a full review by board on
[1:22:41]
September 26th. There's one clarification I'd like to
[1:22:47]
on upon the word negotiation stated in the memo.
[1:22:51]
Our intent is not to negotiate pricing once the bids are received and open.
[1:22:56]
The staff anticipates completing the bid review by September 6 and
[1:23:00]
bring the option pricing for review by the CIP ad hoc committee on 11 September
[1:23:06]
and a full review by the board on September 26.
[1:23:11]
The project will also improve accessibility and ADA compliance.
[1:23:15]
The new lectern can be configured for variable heights and will allow, you know, low profile monitor on the lectern.
[1:23:24]
So, you know, people with handicapped needs will also be able to use this lectern because of the variable heights.
[1:23:31]
And the system will be very to implement e-boarding if the board chooses to do so.
[1:23:36]
Several e-boarding options and programs are now available in the market.
[1:23:40]
And we will work on the new equipment and can integrate with our current agenda management system.
[1:23:48]
I kind of talked a little bit about the project deliverables.
[1:23:54]
And going back into the history of the project on 10, 28, 2014,
[1:24:00]
the Board took no action on approval of public hearing on the Engineers report.
[1:24:05]
On 38, 2016, the Board approved the design approach.
[1:24:08]
And on 524, 2016, the board adopted a resolution by conducting the public hearing on the engineer's report.
[1:24:17]
The total estimated cost of the project is around $800,000, with equipment cost being about $750,000 and labor about $70,000.
[1:24:29]
The funding for this project has been budgeted in the FI-18 Information Technology Fund.
[1:24:34]
And the next steps include, you know, a ward of construction in September of 2017, construction
[1:24:42]
begins January 2018,
[1:24:47]
and the anticipated project completion is March of 2018.
[1:24:51]
With that, I'm available to answer any questions.
[1:24:54]
Director Lizard.
[1:24:55]
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
[1:24:56]
should you say this whole
[1:25:00]
Program is coming to the CIP ad hoc to delve deeper.
[1:25:06]
Yeah, we are going to bring the bid pricing. Once the bids are opened on September 6th.
[1:25:11]
We will have the CIP ad hoc committee review the option pricing and the bids so that they can give us direction.
[1:25:21]
So, I'm curious, is to why e-boding is a future ad on?
[1:25:27]
We're going through all of this upgrading, getting new mics, new TVs, you're going to be
[1:25:33]
maybe cutting up the dias, why would we do the e-voting now and have them bid on that?
[1:25:41]
We were waiting on the direction of the board.
[1:25:43]
We wanted to give you that option, but we haven't, you know, we need to ask you that question.
[1:25:49]
But would you like to implement e-voting right now or not?
[1:25:52]
When are you going to ask us?
[1:25:54]
I'm asking them now.
[1:25:56]
I'm in favor of it.
[1:25:57]
Definitely include that as part of the project.
[1:25:59]
I'm in favor.
[1:26:02]
Director Santos?
[1:26:04]
Yes.
[1:26:04]
Thank you, Chair.
[1:26:05]
First of all, Chair.
[1:26:06]
Thank you for pushing on this.
[1:26:09]
We appreciate it very much.
[1:26:10]
I'm not going to sit here and talk about all the concerns because there is no complaint.
[1:26:16]
There is no complaints because communication is the key.
[1:26:19]
And I thank Susan for listening.
[1:26:21]
And she thank you for calling me and ask us
[1:26:23]
on my think of what the sheriff probably
[1:26:26]
looned to and saw my.
[1:26:27]
We do need board input so we can sit down and give you
[1:26:30]
some individual input that we have through experiences
[1:26:34]
where we've been other places and so on.
[1:26:36]
And I know you have some too.
[1:26:38]
I appreciate that concern.
[1:26:39]
So we need to take our time because this system
[1:26:41]
has outdated has gone.
[1:26:43]
And yes, I get very frustrated, but I appreciate the calls
[1:26:46]
of support, but at this time.
[1:26:47]
and I won't go through all that stuff.
[1:26:49]
It just got to move on, but I would hope that whatever things like, you know, we'll take
[1:26:54]
these down, we can view and so on, but to be more efficient, we got to do the outreach.
[1:26:58]
So again, we're on the right track, I'll look forward to it, so we can review all this and
[1:27:02]
get our individual input, and then have a nice finished product.
[1:27:06]
But I'd like also, if you can, can we see a finished product of something like a drawn or
[1:27:10]
something of how it would look and so on?
[1:27:12]
That might be helpful, but hearing, you know, I just wouldn't have my hearing test and
[1:27:15]
bad but I could take this thing in a minute. I can hear a pin drop in here and it don't
[1:27:20]
work at the time. But anyway you all be trying and I know it's going to be good, so thank you.
[1:27:26]
Thank you. It's Rachel Keegan.
[1:27:30]
Thank you. Well one really basic suggestion is that we have the plugs for our iPads so we don't
[1:27:37]
have to cart them back and forth. I realize that doesn't sound important but it's something
[1:27:41]
that annoys me, and another thing is that I want to echo director Luzaud in terms of the
[1:27:52]
automated voting system. And a big part of my reason is that I am monitor social media
[1:27:59]
like next door and people's comments on Facebook. I even get copied sometimes on posts to
[1:28:06]
at Yahoo groups, and some of the kinds of questions that folks come up with is, well, how
[1:28:12]
do I find out how my elected officials voted on things? And so, yes, it's possible that
[1:28:19]
they go retroactively to an agenda and they can see how it passed, but it's not really
[1:28:25]
clear and available to them. And I think just in the interest of transparency, I mean,
[1:28:30]
And I think we all take our vote seriously, and we also take seriously the public's interest
[1:28:36]
in knowing how we voted on issues.
[1:28:39]
So anything that we can do in my mind to make that more clear and more easily available
[1:28:45]
to the public, I think is a good thing.
[1:28:47]
Thank you.
[1:28:49]
Thank you, Director.
[1:28:52]
Thank you.
[1:28:54]
Thank you, Chair.
[1:28:55]
Yeah, maybe not only, you know, small things USB plugs, but also some usable outlets which
[1:29:02]
these aren't in.
[1:29:03]
I mean, I got to think about this more and talk to my AV consultant, Paul, on this matter,
[1:29:10]
but I will sound so like a good idea.
[1:29:14]
Yeah, we have already in the design that we have incorporated several plugs and power outlets
[1:29:19]
are built into, you know, the dashboards for each of the directors.
[1:29:25]
Just to reinforce what Yeshua is saying, both the stuff like the technology for the plugs
[1:29:33]
and the use of iPads, absolutely, because the technology cannot interfere with the meeting
[1:29:39]
and even the issue of the electronic voting.
[1:29:44]
I wish what we didn't specifically call that out, because it really does impact the, I guess,
[1:29:51]
human element of how you all relate to another on the dice, and I think we want to make
[1:29:56]
sure that everybody's comfortable with how that system.
[1:30:00]
To work and the ramifications of it is, I've seen it work and I've seen it work works well. And some of the bodies have not liked it. So we probably want to have some discussion before we actually want to purchase it. We'll certainly be getting potential prices on it though.
[1:30:20]
On that note, I had a conversation with the mayor of Morgan Hill who they do have e-boding.
[1:30:26]
And he said they had some technical issues, that's a more orientation issues with the council members.
[1:30:31]
So I think for those communities, I think San Jose, believe Mountain View, Morgan Hill,
[1:30:36]
we might want to get an evaluation from those communities that are using e-boding.
[1:30:41]
But before we launch that here to determine if that's something we want to invest in and they actually want to have.
[1:30:46]
And our future director, was that?
[1:30:52]
I've used it before.
[1:30:54]
It didn't take much of an education to use it.
[1:30:57]
I'm not understanding what the issue is.
[1:31:00]
The county has had it for Eons.
[1:31:03]
I've used it there as well when I'm on committees.
[1:31:07]
And I think as far as our interaction,
[1:31:11]
I think when there's a controversial issue,
[1:31:14]
I think it's pretty clear where those who
[1:31:20]
aim to participate are going.
[1:31:22]
But I think the barber's point about on the just the mundane things
[1:31:25]
that come through, it's stuff that just flipping a switch to say,
[1:31:31]
yes or no, isn't a big deal for my perspective.
[1:31:33]
I've used it.
[1:31:35]
And I don't see it cutting down on discussion.
[1:31:38]
I don't see it cutting down on the ability
[1:31:43]
to interact in the times that I've used it.
[1:31:47]
It has not been an issue.
[1:31:49]
So you said you're going to at least come back with that
[1:31:52]
as part of a bit and I would encourage you to do that.
[1:32:00]
Thank you.
[1:32:02]
So we have an action item on this, so do I have a motion?
[1:32:06]
Motion in a second.
[1:32:08]
Discussion?
[1:32:09]
No, no, no.
[1:32:09]
those in favor, signify by say aye, aye, all opposed?
[1:32:13]
Item carries.
[1:32:15]
Next item in the agenda is nine two people soft,
[1:32:18]
upgrade assessment study, findings, and recommendations.
[1:32:22]
This next item is probably one of the more difficult items,
[1:32:25]
I think I was confronted with when I took on this position.
[1:32:30]
The district had invested a substantial amount of
[1:32:34]
Both money, human resource, and preparation, and anticipation of upgrading people's
[1:32:42]
off, which is a really robust AR enterprise system for helping cities with finance, human resources and procurement.
[1:32:55]
And a couple of things that made our assessment much more timely than other organizations
[1:33:04]
is the fact that we haven't really had the opportunity to implement some of the current
[1:33:08]
features of the old system and upgrading into the new system, knowing it was going to be
[1:33:15]
such a short shelf life because of the age of the product.
[1:33:21]
I really made this district step back and evaluate whether in fact this was the right long-term strategy.
[1:33:30]
And I think both myself, issue our IT director, Darren, Taylor, and consultation of interim director.
[1:33:41]
Really struggled about doing want to go forward or step back, reevaluate, and then come up with a recommendation tonight.
[1:33:49]
which is of course not to go with people's thought and go back and re-valuate the market to look at other opportunities.
[1:33:58]
We have tonight the presentation by the company that we use to conduct this analysis.
[1:34:06]
We're going to be able to show at the end of the evening that not only will this improve the services that the district can provide to our internal customers,
[1:34:15]
But it could be done in a substantially less cost, costly way, enhanced the user application
[1:34:25]
of the technology in ultimately ensure that we have a more robust strategy for information management
[1:34:34]
going forward.
[1:34:35]
So with that, let me turn it over to Ashim Teqan.
[1:34:39]
Good evening, Chair.
[1:34:40]
We're Ellen Members of the Board.
[1:34:42]
My name is Siddhan Shuthe Kikkar, Deputy Operating Officer Information Technology.
[1:34:47]
As per your direction, we performed a comprehensive PeopleSoft upgrade assessment study, before
[1:34:53]
negotiating a final contract with the vendor to perform the upgrade of peopleSoft.
[1:34:58]
So in that
[1:35:00]
That process we hired Plant Moran to do this study who are also currently helping City of Palo Alto go to the market and acquire an enterprise resource planning software.
[1:35:11]
So we have Adam here from Plant Moran, who's going to give you the presentation and his recommendations and findings.
[1:35:19]
Good
[1:35:25]
evening, Chair Varella, honorable members of the board.
[1:35:28]
I did want to first add, I don't know if this is representative of all your board meetings,
[1:35:32]
but I am very impressed by the efficiency of this meeting.
[1:35:36]
I'm looking right through it.
[1:35:38]
I'm with Plentym Rand, we are a large accounting consulting firm.
[1:35:43]
I have the privilege of managing a specialty practice that really works with public entities
[1:35:49]
across the country, looking at large-scale technology projects.
[1:35:53]
We're independent.
[1:35:54]
We don't sell any hardware, software, or we just provide advice on direction.
[1:35:59]
Some of the bigger projects like an ERP type system, such as this one.
[1:36:04]
We look at about 50 ERP selections every year.
[1:36:08]
Helping clients, we're very familiar with large water and wastewater operations, have worked
[1:36:14]
with the Great Lakes Water Authority, which is the Detroit system.
[1:36:17]
the Louisville system, Santa Margarita, and Orange County, Las Vegas Valley, and the
[1:36:26]
Hampton Road system in North Virginia.
[1:36:28]
So we're quite familiar with the operation.
[1:36:31]
We're also as a shoe pointed out pretty familiar with the number of clients, and we work
[1:36:38]
with here in the Bay Area, Palo Alto, Sunnyvale, Monterey County, Marin County, or a few
[1:36:44]
of our clients.
[1:36:46]
In terms of some of the key findings that we've got, we had an opportunity to go back review the
[1:36:53]
gap analysis that had been done on people's soft, look at the planning documents that
[1:36:57]
went into the plan to move forward with the upgrade on the people's soft system.
[1:37:05]
By the way, the people's soft system, I'm sure you know, is your main accounting and HR system
[1:37:10]
processes your payroll, processes all the accounting information, so forth.
[1:37:15]
That system really is really quite out of date as it stands today, so much so that the
[1:37:21]
upgrade to 9.2, which you're contemplating, really is very much like a brand-new install
[1:37:28]
of a new ERP system.
[1:37:31]
It would be pretty significant in terms of its impact on the operations it would take several
[1:37:37]
years to really make those improvements, to really get the bank for the bucket if you will.
[1:37:43]
So it would be very much like a brand new install.
[1:37:47]
The plan to do the upgrade, Walt says has been around for about three years here in
[1:37:52]
the slide.
[1:37:53]
Actually, the plan was developed in 2012, and at the time, it wasn't a bad plan.
[1:37:58]
It was based on what was known about the ERP marketplace.
[1:38:02]
Since then there have been some real advances in that marketplace, specifically everybody
[1:38:07]
heard about cloud opportunities. Well that really has been the driver over the last five or six years.
[1:38:13]
A lot of the major ERP players have gone to that and that really is a direction that they're going to.
[1:38:19]
The private sector really has jumped on to that and now it's really coming into the public sector pretty fully.
[1:38:26]
And there are some very real advantages to going with some of those, those newer technologies,
[1:38:33]
specifically, you've heard of Oracle with their fusion products, so people sought to
[1:38:37]
zone by Oracle, so they had fusion now it really is a true SaaS offering that you
[1:38:42]
can go out and procure, and we've got a number of clients that have done that.
[1:38:47]
In terms of the current state, again, we're on an old version of people's soft, it really
[1:38:52]
is no longer supportable so to stay on it on people's softer with people's soft, you
[1:38:57]
to upgrade if you want to do that. It's vulnerable to cyber threats and it's very challenging
[1:39:04]
as it stands to maintain that system. It's also expensive because it's just no longer
[1:39:12]
really an efficient system in terms of meeting your needs as it stands today. There are a number
[1:39:17]
of shadow systems, so that means there's a fair bit of rework in your transaction processing,
[1:39:23]
your financial and HR type processes and hopefully with any system that you get, you'll be able
[1:39:30]
to improve on those. We do credit your IT team really for keeping this up and running. It's been
[1:39:37]
heavily customized system, which makes it all that much more challenging to operate, but they
[1:39:42]
really have kept it up and going, even though it's a very old system and really fairly frail at this
[1:39:48]
point.
[1:39:52]
The three big options that we really looked at, one was the continued down the...
[1:40:00]
The path of upgrading people soft to 9.2. Again, it's very much like a new install. Oracle is no longer investing in the people soft product. They've stated that they will keep it alive until 2027, or at least in newer version of the 9.2 version, which gives it about a 10 year horizon from now.
[1:40:20]
Again, if you go back and think about, it's probably 18 months to do the upgrade, and then it's probably a few years after that to really make the process improvements.
[1:40:29]
You're really only going to have a handful of years of really good years to get any kind of return on investment from that product to be honest.
[1:40:39]
Oracle, again, who owns people soft, has come this talk to people in the district about another possibility, perhaps going with their cloud version.
[1:40:47]
So that's number two. We wanted to model that out and see what does that look like.
[1:40:53]
And so we did that as well.
[1:40:55]
And then number three. So if you were really a private utility, you could have ended it there.
[1:41:01]
And just said we can go and we can just procure this SaaS version.
[1:41:06]
But as a public entity, you're going to want to go out to it for a public bid for a system of this size.
[1:41:11]
I would imagine it's probably the prudent thing to do.
[1:41:13]
And so we wanted to model what's out there in the marketplace and what's the range of the cost that you would see by going out and doing that.
[1:41:21]
And they're quite a range of systems out there, some of them are cloud true SaaS offerings and some of them aren't.
[1:41:26]
And so we've got a pretty large range on that based on the systems.
[1:41:32]
Here on this slide you can see a total 10-year cost of ownership when you compare the options.
[1:41:37]
So the brown line, the second from the top, is what the people
[1:41:42]
soft upgrade would be.
[1:41:44]
Over a 10-year period, your cost would be right around $36 million.
[1:41:48]
For a total cost of ownership, internal and external costs.
[1:41:52]
That's the upgrade that's the ongoing maintenance.
[1:41:55]
Again, over a cumulative over a 10-year period.
[1:41:58]
If we look at the Oracle SAS offering,
[1:42:03]
it would be somewhere around $20 to $23 million.
[1:42:06]
So substantially less probably a $10 million savings over that 10-year period and then if you look at the full range of options of what's out there in the market
[1:42:16]
And this is based
[1:42:19]
Largely on a lot of the bids that we receive from other clients that we help when they go out to market for these type systems
[1:42:24]
So we look at other similar size organizations and what have they received recently?
[1:42:30]
It would range anywhere from that 18 to 50 million dollars depending on the specific system that you
[1:42:36]
So if you go out to the market, there's quite the range.
[1:42:39]
But certainly if you went out to the market,
[1:42:41]
we would certainly encourage Oracle and their
[1:42:43]
SES offering to be one of the bitters to
[1:42:47]
come in on this as well.
[1:42:50]
So based on that, really we've got a lower cost,
[1:42:56]
where we've got several lower cost options
[1:42:58]
than the PeopleSoft upgrade.
[1:43:00]
You'll get a longer life spend with it.
[1:43:03]
You'll be on the newer technology.
[1:43:04]
Again, the people soft is only going to be as good as the day you install it because there's no big investment plan for it going forward
[1:43:11]
It's not going to be a better product. It'll simply be maintained
[1:43:15]
So you can get better technology you can get newer technology you're going through the same kind of an
[1:43:21]
Install if you will
[1:43:23]
For potentially quite a bit less money and again as a public entity
[1:43:28]
we would think that you would want to go with a public procurement and go out to bed and really
[1:43:33]
test the market. So on a nutshell, that's what I've got questions.
[1:43:40]
First of all, thank you, Chair.
[1:43:43]
Yeah, I'd like to support the staff recommendation. I mean, with $15.6 million, I could
[1:43:49]
go do my own company and rewrite any RP from scratch. I mean, we have a thing in the private
[1:43:55]
sector, what platform does Oracle ERP run best on?
[1:43:59]
That's a question for you.
[1:44:01]
I'm sorry.
[1:44:01]
That's a question.
[1:44:02]
What platform does Oracle ERP systems run best on?
[1:44:06]
What platform does that stand?
[1:44:08]
The answer is a slide projector.
[1:44:12]
Because you never can get them work and it kills them.
[1:44:14]
Okay.
[1:44:16]
So I'm supportive of this recommendation.
[1:44:19]
Very well.
[1:44:20]
Did this out?
[1:44:21]
use a firm like yourself because it might be a couple of different systems here, you know, absolutely you'll see a couple of options
[1:44:27]
You know, everyone uses expense to find it even big companies today, you know, you can slice and dice this up
[1:44:32]
So this is good and I know we have some good staff
[1:44:36]
IT
[1:44:37]
Our new chief administrative officer or CFO
[1:44:41]
Do this because these are some scary numbers 52.000
[1:44:46]
It's a million dollars per 10-year cost of ownership.
[1:44:50]
It's crazy.
[1:44:53]
So, you're a scientist.
[1:44:55]
Like a chair?
[1:44:58]
It's been here for a long time.
[1:44:59]
Just you're like...
[1:45:00]
Just in my guess that if we did this, here, everything is already outdated and here we go again. But, you know, I'm sure that director Creminoza and this specific product more than I do. So I'll go along with that. But I just, it would Silicon Valley, it seemed like there's new adventures every day and something that comes out. It's in my own home, you know, in my time. And he said, if he's come over to their own phones and all these things, it's not even that was going on. But he spent a lot of time on those things. And then everything is changing by being another one. So I hope that's not the case here.
[1:45:30]
talking $36 million and just a few years ago, I had no longer here and we were doing $23 million.
[1:45:36]
Now we're up to $36 or $20, and then it's a big replace, so I'm going to look for the
[1:45:41]
experts and hope for us to have to lead us home because this is really costly and things
[1:45:45]
get so out of it is so fast. So we
[1:45:50]
have an action about two support staff recommendations
[1:45:55]
and moving forward on that. So I have a motion and a motion on a second.
[1:46:00]
All those in favor, signify by saying aye.
[1:46:03]
Opposed none.
[1:46:05]
That passes.
[1:46:05]
Moving forward.
[1:46:08]
On item 9.3, 2017 Information Systems Master Plan, ISMP update June 27, 2017.
[1:46:18]
Yes.
[1:46:20]
This is an information item only.
[1:46:23]
So, this kind of gives them opening, I guess, contextual remarks before we make the
[1:46:29]
technical presentation, versus per second.
[1:46:38]
The plan started in, are we doing this?
[1:46:42]
2012, okay.
[1:46:45]
In 2012, a master plan, and the point thing to remember
[1:46:52]
is that the master plan needs to be reviewed
[1:46:54]
in evaluating the context of five major factors
[1:46:57]
that affect how we do business,
[1:46:58]
how we relate to each other internally and how we develop relationships with our partners externally.
[1:47:05]
And the thing I was, I've been focusing on when we were developing the memorandum here,
[1:47:12]
is essentially five factors that are sometimes invisible when you're looking at a master plan regarding information technology
[1:47:19]
because it seems so academic and not related to the way we do business,
[1:47:25]
But some of the factors, I think, that really impact the significance of information technology
[1:47:31]
in the environment is one, the fact that we are actively as an organization, really
[1:47:38]
re-evaluating the use of how we actually interact with our personal space, as employees,
[1:47:44]
here in the district.
[1:47:45]
You know, it used to be that everybody had an office for four walls and one measured
[1:47:50]
one's status with how big it, how big an office is, and that's much of that very much
[1:47:55]
is changing in the working environment, the use of personal space and how technology interfaces
[1:48:01]
with the changing of that dynamic.
[1:48:05]
The second, the second element is that the, with advanced technology is the use of the cloud
[1:48:11]
storage and the digitization of information.
[1:48:15]
When I think that I can get everything I need off this little iPad, where I used to come into a meeting like this with a stack of books.
[1:48:27]
So the technology itself allows us to hope to work in smaller spaces to be much more robust and how we do our work compared to what we've done in the past.
[1:48:37]
The other thing regarding the district here is we are really re-evaluating the use of the campus environment in the advantages of what we call shared space and we're evaluating that as we look at how much we're going to be growing in the future years and is the best solution bigger more buildings in more fixed infrastructure.
[1:49:02]
The use of technology is very much involved and that whole discussion that we're currently having right now.
[1:49:10]
Of course, as well as the fourth factor, the sustainability of our business model, we realize as an organization.
[1:49:18]
We can't simply continue to add people.
[1:49:21]
We've got to, we have the burden of learning how to work faster, smarter, and use better tools in order to do our jobs.
[1:49:28]
And that's where this technology very much comes into play.
[1:49:31]
I think the fifth factor is the change in culture in the workplace that promotes innovation
[1:49:36]
and collaboration.
[1:49:38]
We were talking earlier today, the number of people we have in the organization that are close
[1:49:42]
to retirement, 42% of people that are working today could be, could be higher in it in
[1:49:47]
approximately 10 years.
[1:49:49]
So we're really looking at a different culture of people that are going to be coming into this
[1:49:53]
environment.
[1:49:53]
and using technology differently than we're using it today, so the importance of having a really
[1:49:59]
able to bust.
[1:50:00]
Master plan is his team. So with that, what those kind of all over the Comments, the technical presentation,
[1:50:10]
I'm sure I'm going to be looking at this specific critical infrastructure that we call information management.
[1:50:16]
That's articulated in the Miranda.
[1:50:20]
Thank you, Susan. Good evening, Chair Warella and members of the Board. Again, my name is Sadhana Shetty Kikkar,
[1:50:26]
Deputy Administrative Officer, or Deputy Operating Officer, Information Technology.
[1:50:33]
Today we are presenting you an update on the Information Systems Master Plan, which was provided
[1:50:39]
to the district in 2012, so we are coming close to five years of this plan being in place.
[1:50:45]
Helping you with the presentation today are Unit Managers, Frank Fun, Infrastructure Services,
[1:50:50]
Shirley Koo and Jill Bernard from Software Services,
[1:50:56]
Lonnie Spinn from Records and Library Services,
[1:50:59]
and Fong Liu, the Project Manager for People's Software.
[1:51:03]
agenda for today,
[1:51:05]
a quick recap of the ISMP project,
[1:51:09]
the project status overview,
[1:51:11]
completed projects through FY19,
[1:51:14]
timeline for remaining projects,
[1:51:17]
a brief project deep dive.
[1:51:19]
I know we were planning to give you an ERP update when this item was actually up on the agenda
[1:51:26]
for 627, but since it was postponed for this meeting today, you've already heard about people
[1:51:34]
soft and you have given us the direction to go out to the market.
[1:51:39]
And then another project that we want to give you a little deep dive and perspective on is the
[1:51:44]
application portfolio management.
[1:51:50]
Of the 32, so I assume he was delivered in July of 2012,
[1:51:55]
and the goals were accountable IT governance workforce efficiency,
[1:52:00]
transparent customer service, asset management, business continuity,
[1:52:04]
and proactive IT service.
[1:52:06]
32 projects identified in four areas, applications,
[1:52:11]
technical infrastructure, service delivery, and decision making.
[1:52:17]
Of the 32 project listed, 12 have been fully completed, 14 are in various stages of progress,
[1:52:24]
three are in planning and three are under evaluations.
[1:52:28]
Projects completed through FY17 are as follows.
[1:52:33]
In the applications, we have enhanced the customer's self-service application on our website.
[1:52:38]
Project include apps to provide location-based information for district projects and activities,
[1:52:45]
provide data from groundwater wells, access to integrated water resource master plan, and receive public input.
[1:52:52]
We are also working with Office of Government Affairs to launch a new website for the district.
[1:52:57]
We are asked for this project schedule.
[1:53:00]
We are looking to launch our new website in December of 2017.
[1:53:06]
IT is also played a key role in the success of the landscape re-bit program, key applications
[1:53:12]
such as the water wise, house calls, high efficiency toilet program, and commercial
[1:53:17]
wash-up programs are developed in-house in successfully implemented.
[1:53:22]
Internet portal deployment is fully complete now using the open source platform, Drupal,
[1:53:28]
and we are also going to be using the same platform for our external website as well.
[1:53:33]
So there's going to be a good, you know, inter-inter-connectivity between the internal website and the external website and staff is capable of supporting due to triple open source platform now.
[1:53:46]
They have got enough experience because they've been supporting the intranet.
[1:53:52]
categorization of all assets and the inclusion in the asset registries is complete for watershed
[1:53:57]
water utility and administration.
[1:53:59]
Asset management program tool has been deployed to analyze asset management related investments,
[1:54:06]
a custom fee and risk assessment application has now been integrated with real estate services
[1:54:11]
database and developed and deploy a mobile application to help asset inventory and site condition
[1:54:17]
assessment. And this is going to be very helpful, especially when we are in the process of upgrading
[1:54:22]
our maximal asset management software as we speak. IT has also held the fleet unit to replace
[1:54:29]
the fuel management system and integrate it with other core applications. In the service delivery
[1:54:36]
area, we have identified and implemented next-generation application development platforms for
[1:54:42]
some software such as apex, oracle, interactive reporting tools, such as OBI, EE and ESRI
[1:54:50]
cloud platform for enterprise GIS. In fact, I just came back from an asry conference and
[1:54:56]
we have contracted with ESRI, the logic.
[1:55:00]
This vendor of GIS systems to actually help us develop our enterprise GIS platform.
[1:55:07]
So, that's an exciting progress.
[1:55:10]
It is also developed in adopt a five year training plan for IT staff.
[1:55:14]
This training will help staff learn to use the latest application platform and services.
[1:55:19]
So, we are in the process of upgrading the skill sets of all our staff so that they can meet the challenges of the future
[1:55:26]
and implement new technologies in the district.
[1:55:31]
In the decision making area, we have developed a GIS master plan
[1:55:35]
that provides a roadmap to develop and implement
[1:55:37]
the comprehensive enterprise GIS portal.
[1:55:40]
At a policy level, we have developed two policies.
[1:55:43]
One is the cell phone stipend program for eligible employees
[1:55:46]
and a wireless communications policy
[1:55:48]
that sets eligibility criteria for district
[1:55:51]
issued mobile devices such as laptops, iPads, and other tablets.
[1:55:56]
Along with the ISMP defined projects, IT has also been working on other key projects for the district.
[1:56:04]
They include the replacement of the budget capital planning and the forecasting system that you all just experience.
[1:56:10]
We implemented the entire budget system within four months and we were able to successfully complete our budget for FY18.
[1:56:18]
Replacement of the water revenue collection system.
[1:56:21]
system. We are also in the process of replacing the boardroom AV system. You folks just gave
[1:56:26]
us that go ahead on that. And projects related to cybersecurity, vulnerability and risk
[1:56:32]
assessment. We did come in a close session to provide you with briefings on our security
[1:56:37]
posture.
[1:56:42]
The next slide here is essentially a timeline for completion of the remainder
[1:56:46]
of the projects. And details of these projects are in the attachments and staff are here
[1:56:52]
to answer your questions after this presentation.
[1:56:55]
Not like to ask Shirley Coo to give the presentation
[1:57:02]
for the application portfolio management system
[1:57:07]
that she's currently working on.
[1:57:10]
Shirley was the recipient of the Employee Recognition
[1:57:13]
Award.
[1:57:13]
She deployed Octa, so we thought she could
[1:57:16]
she'd come and present this project here.
[1:57:22]
Good evening, Edyn one.
[1:57:23]
My name is Shirley Coo.
[1:57:24]
and I'm in software service units.
[1:57:27]
Thank you for giving us the opportunity to share our recent work.
[1:57:30]
Software Service Unit has worked on several critical projects in the past year,
[1:57:35]
including the Masimo upgrade, three maintenance program,
[1:57:38]
and the replacement of a 25 years old water-weaponial building system.
[1:57:43]
The time it doesn't work to present them,
[1:57:45]
but what I'm going to talk to you now is a small but important project
[1:57:49]
that will help us become a more proactive IT organizations.
[1:57:53]
the application portfolio management.
[1:57:57]
With the ISNP and more recently, the business continuity project
[1:58:01]
will recognize the need to have a comprehensive and up-to-date repository
[1:58:05]
of all district software applications.
[1:58:09]
This includes not only the Enterprise Service and IT support,
[1:58:13]
but also the application owned by various business units,
[1:58:17]
such as Treasury, Dem Safety, Surrey, and Hydrology.
[1:58:22]
Additionally, we continue to see staff retire.
[1:58:25]
Important lawyers pertain to the application might be lost when they do.
[1:58:30]
Loretta such as the technical support numbers, the software version, the application
[1:58:35]
functionalities, will map, service level agreement, and dependency are all critical for
[1:58:41]
business continuity.
[1:58:43]
By having this information, responsible party can ask us what, and poor being impact when
[1:58:49]
technical change must occur.
[1:58:52]
On the last count, we have close to 100 applications.
[1:58:57]
Next, take a look at NASMO.
[1:58:58]
NASMO has recently gone through a technical upgrade.
[1:59:04]
Here is a sample diagram that the tool can generate.
[1:59:07]
It may easier to understand what support our NASMO applications.
[1:59:12]
The tool server at a bottom of the screen
[1:59:14]
are where the application and the database beside.
[1:59:17]
Next up, you can see the technologies involved.
[1:59:20]
Massimo 1 on Windows 2012 will work for 12C as the database.
[1:59:26]
Massimo served the watersheds, water utility, and administration divisions.
[1:59:31]
On the top, Massimo has a number of connections and interface to other systems such as
[1:59:37]
Filmaster, GIS, People's Law.
[1:59:41]
To see how application portfolio management can help improve planning and make faster decision,
[1:59:46]
Let's take an example.
[1:59:48]
Let's say we need to fix a security issue on Windows 2012.
[1:59:53]
We can search from the tool to see which application
[1:59:55]
are running on the top of it.
[1:59:58]
In this case, maximum may be one.
[2:00:00]
One of the 50 applications impeded. These applications may have a not a 75 integration points that will need to validate, and another 30 views of group that will need to coordinate with.
[2:00:12]
As you can see, when we look at the larger technology ecosystem, this will quickly get complicated.
[2:00:19]
Have a two like the application for full and management to capture all these languages and dependency can help us.
[2:00:27]
Number one, to improve our planning and the management of technical change, since we will have a
[2:00:33]
battle with the ability into our enterprise.
[2:00:36]
Two, easily identify application redundancy in days, three, to actively identify compliance
[2:00:43]
risks, because we can run some reports to identify all the operating system, database,
[2:00:53]
or
[2:00:54]
when stop-transitions. This will eventually help improve services and reduce resource and
[2:01:01]
cost for the district. Thank you.
[2:01:06]
Thank you.
[2:01:12]
With that, I conclude the presentation and the staff
[2:01:15]
is here to answer any questions. Thank you very much. Do we have questions from the board?
[2:01:22]
The record is not? It's not really a question. I just think this application portfolio management
[2:01:27]
And it is just brilliant, I mean, I just think of the software and the different machines
[2:01:34]
that I use and what version do I have and how many updates and I can imagine what
[2:01:39]
it's like here.
[2:01:40]
So I just think that providing the common comprehensive update understanding of all district
[2:01:46]
applications, users and dependencies is absolutely critical to this organization.
[2:01:51]
So congratulations, I think this is really something that needed to be done and it's done
[2:01:57]
Move forward.
[2:01:58]
Thank you.
[2:02:01]
Very fine.
[2:02:02]
Do you have the comments from the board?
[2:02:05]
Thank you very much for your report.
[2:02:07]
Thank you for your time.
[2:02:08]
I'll leave staff members as well.
[2:02:09]
Appreciate it.
[2:02:10]
Thank you.
[2:02:11]
Great information.
[2:02:15]
Moving on on the agenda.
[2:02:16]
Next item is Mr. Council.
[2:02:18]
I see we have no report.
[2:02:22]
A adjourned.
[2:02:23]
11.1 board members reports and announcements.
[2:02:26]
Start with Director Creman.
[2:02:34]
Thank you chair.
[2:02:37]
Let's see.
[2:02:40]
So, number one, I'd like to report about my cool shirt I got from my visit to Orville Dam, for everyone.
[2:02:51]
See the cool shirt.
[2:02:53]
And in fact, because I mentioned I actually had something called an emergency spillway burger.
[2:03:00]
Pulled pork, shredded pork, kind of like the spillway at the local brewery in Orville.
[2:03:06]
I also visited Sykes, reservoir of the project we're looking at investing a bunch of money in.
[2:03:11]
More on that later, various things for the Pacheco Project, talk to various other imported water people, etc.
[2:03:24]
There is meetings.
[2:03:24]
last week.
[2:03:30]
Since our last, for meeting my last report,
[2:03:36]
I had a few interviews with Asian T.E., the
[2:03:44]
TV station or radio station to POMOTE, the Open House event.
[2:03:49]
I wanted to thank staff for a great job on that day.
[2:03:54]
at a great turnout and good response.
[2:03:59]
I also had attended the EWRC meeting,
[2:04:06]
a metwith CEO, the CFP at CFP committee meeting,
[2:04:14]
and the Bore Policy Planning Committee meeting.
[2:04:18]
Thank you.
[2:04:19]
Director Stamera.
[2:04:23]
On top of what the T-shirt I didn't get.
[2:04:25]
Let's see. Also, we much tended to say meetings. My colleagues did. We had the CEO interviews
[2:04:40]
and met with the CEO, but with coyote community reps, the environmental advisory committee meeting, I attended.
[2:04:51]
And we had a seminar in Oakland for the for wells, the water education for Latino leaders.
[2:05:00]
Membership with different council, council, folks, and mayors from around the state.
[2:05:10]
And that's a good today.
[2:05:14]
Well done. My report is so we had a meeting with the Pacheco Ad hoc committee here at the Water District. Also, we've met in the San Luis del Temen, Dota, Water Authority Board meeting.
[2:05:26]
the director's Creman in Santos.
[2:05:29]
Also attended the government relations committee
[2:05:32]
in Chamber of Commerce of Gilroy.
[2:05:35]
At a one-on-one meeting with Mayor Steve Tate of Morgan Hill,
[2:05:40]
a special San Luis Delta Mendoza Water Meeting
[2:05:43]
on the Cal Water Fix that director Santos and I attended
[2:05:46]
and had one-on-one CEO meeting this week
[2:05:50]
and also report policy and planning committee meeting yesterday.
[2:05:54]
Also, I just wanted to know that of the 11 action items we had tonight, we had 11 votes,
[2:06:01]
7-0.
[2:06:01]
The unanimous across the board, congratulations to this board.
[2:06:06]
It's my report, Director Santos.
[2:06:09]
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
[2:06:10]
At numerous meetings, I'll just highlight a few Mr. Kerman and Sherberl to the Delta Mendoza.
[2:06:16]
Very good meeting.
[2:06:18]
It's a support there for the Checco Reservoir, I thought that was great.
[2:06:21]
We had a second helping in the California Water Festival.
[2:06:24]
Sherber on I went back and met again on the Wednesday down there in Las Banyos and very interesting.
[2:06:29]
I do want to take the time to as Marty mentioned the Asian community day.
[2:06:34]
I thought it was fantastic and I always say, you know, four star. It really was.
[2:06:38]
Each of section was good, it organized and you know, the highlight with Chinese food and
[2:06:44]
fantastic as I love it. I would save my day. But you know, it was the people there and our staff
[2:06:51]
that didn't have to sell it, they were really, they're educated, they sat there and they listened,
[2:06:56]
and I really think we're ahead of our time and we're going to get this recycling water out there.
[2:07:01]
This is the kind of message the government relations does in our communications factory.
[2:07:05]
People do, and people bought into it, because we do a good job.
[2:07:09]
So I was really impressed with that.
[2:07:10]
Then I took the time, I represented Chair Barra and myself,
[2:07:14]
that the communications and government relations set down,
[2:07:17]
in the discussed with them, how important their roles are of support and this district and
[2:07:22]
of marketing what we've got to do. We want to get ballot measures and may things that we all
[2:07:26]
talk about and we've got to do and all the stuff we have in our plate. We can't do without
[2:07:30]
communication and government nations. And they do a fantastic job. We're going to do even more so.
[2:07:35]
Thank you. Thank you, Director Director, Director of the SOT. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
[2:07:39]
attended the CIP committee at least three board meetings that met with staff about Anderson
[2:07:46]
Dam, attended the EWRC had a meeting with representatives from EA and a meeting with the
[2:07:54]
ICEO.
[2:07:55]
Thank you.
[2:07:56]
Dr. Kigan.
[2:08:00]
Thank you.
[2:08:01]
Along with board member Esther Marra, I also attended the Contra Costa Water District Public
[2:08:08]
hearings for the Los Fakaris Reservoir Expansion Project,
[2:08:15]
pretty good attendance, still
[2:08:16]
more staff than attendees, but there were members of the public that attended and asked
[2:08:21]
good questions.
[2:08:23]
I also had a meeting with some constituents who are the executive directors of Save Our Trails.
[2:08:34]
They had an interest in daylight in Las Gatos Creek and the vicinity of bird and Montgomery
[2:08:40]
in conjunction with the Google development.
[2:08:44]
I had staff with me at the meeting and I think what's being proposed could potentially
[2:08:51]
be very expensive unless Google had an interest in reconfiguring the roadway.
[2:08:58]
So we provided the Sabar Trail's members with information, but I took a neutral position.
[2:09:05]
in terms of where the board would be on this other than, you know, saying that we would
[2:09:11]
not be available to provide funds for this.
[2:09:14]
But since that time I've had discussions with various other public works professionals and
[2:09:20]
I do think that the Google development is a vastly moving train, if you will.
[2:09:26]
And so I'd like to put in a board member request that staff report back to the board in terms
[2:09:34]
of what our strategy will be in terms of dealing with the project, because I don't think
[2:09:39]
we can wait for plans to come to us because everything is moving so quickly. I think that
[2:09:44]
we need to be proactive in injecting ourselves into the discussion, just like VTAs currently
[2:09:52]
involved, we need to have a seat at the table and I think it's much easier for us to let people
[2:09:59]
no upfront particular.
[2:10:00]
Secondly, if roadways are being reconfigured if there's going to be development impacts adjacent, you know, we have a confluence of two creeks in that location. So, I don't want to be overly directive of staff, but I would like to put that in as a former board member request that the interim CEO come back and provide us with her recommendation as to what we should do.
[2:10:24]
various update meetings on the Cal Water Fix, another meeting in conjunction with Director
[2:10:32]
Santos and Director Estimera with Clarity Creek Residence, attended the Quarterly Water Retailer
[2:10:41]
Meeting yesterday and met with some employee employees that representing the emerging leaders
[2:10:50]
group attended the board policy and planning committee meeting one-on-one with Ms.
[2:10:57]
Kamacho and another Delta discussion.
[2:11:00]
Thank you.
[2:11:01]
Thank you, Director.
[2:11:02]
You're going to do it.
[2:11:06]
And with that, this meeting is adjourned.
[2:11:08]
We thank you very much to a special post session meeting at 9.30 a.m. here on July 27th of
[2:11:15]
this month.
[2:11:17]
Thank you very much.
[2:11:17]
We are adjourned.
[2:11:24]
Thank you.