Agenda
Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[0:02]
Also, it's five o'clock. So I'm going to call to order this valley-water, 40 directors meeting for August 27th, the time is 5 p.m. Could I have a roll call? Please, Madam Clerk.
[0:34]
Thank you very much.
[0:36]
Item 2.1 has been removed from the calendar.
[0:40]
Let me do this notice first.
[0:41]
The Board of Directors meets in closed sessions in accordance with the Ralphham Brown Act following
[0:45]
the conclusion of closed session discussion.
[0:47]
The Board will return for the remaining items on the regular agenda.
[0:50]
As I said, 2.1 has been removed from the agenda.
[0:53]
We're going into closed section to hear 2.2 conference with legal counsel regarding existing
[0:58]
litigation, Valley Board of District versus San Francisco Bay Regional Water Quality
[1:01]
control board, counter-cancer County Superior Court.
[1:05]
You're going into the closed session.
[1:07]
We will return at 6 p.m. Thank you very much.
[4:16]
The clock on the wall says it's 6.01.
[4:18]
So we will call the meeting back to order.
[4:20]
We'll return from closed session with that at 2.3.
[4:24]
A district council report.
[4:28]
Thank you, Madam Mayor.
[4:29]
With respect to item 2.2.
[4:32]
Duration was given to staff.
[4:34]
All board members being present, except Director Keegan.
[4:36]
Thank you.
[4:36]
Thank you very much.
[4:37]
Okay, item 2.4, please join me in this loop to our nation.
[4:42]
I pledge allegiance.
[4:57]
Thank you very much, orders of the day.
[5:00]
I see none other than I'm going to pull item 3.10 unless no one else is going to. Item 2.6, time opened for public comment on any item that in the agenda. I do not have any cards, but just so we can case anyone has something they want to say. This item is reserved for persons wishing to address the board and any matter not on this agenda. As I said, I do not have any cards for public comment. I do have one card for agenda item that I will call at that point.
[5:30]
particular time. So moving on, consent calendar items 3.1 to 3.13, and I'm going to pull
[5:37]
310. So if I could have a roll call, please. Motion is second. We have three resolutions
[5:45]
as part of that. So we need to have a roll call. You want to pull something? 3-8. All right? So
[5:52]
going to pull 3-8 and 3-10. So our motion is for all the rest and we have a resolution
[6:02]
on 3-9 so we need to still need a roll call.
[6:06]
Dr. Sermar. Dr. Swayer? Dr. Keegan? Dr. Clevver? Dr. Sandoz? Dr. Valera?
[6:16]
Chairperson was that? Yes. All right, that motion carries. So we have still item 3.8
[6:23]
Director Creme and you had a question or something? Yes. Thank you. Chairle was that just a comment.
[6:32]
You might have remembered, I'm sure you do our direction to real estate to list the beneficial
[6:37]
interest on any real estate transaction. Remember that? Yes, I do. That's not here. Yes, it appears
[6:45]
is that we've just listed the transaction as two and from the Lico estate to the Belli
[6:50]
Water District. How do we know it's not director Schweyer? Correct, you do not have that
[6:55]
information. Didn't we ask to get it? You did? Okay, I'm going to vote for this, but I do want
[7:01]
to remind again we've had this direction like 12 times. We have, we are working on it and we'll
[7:06]
have it corrected for the next time we come to the board. Okay, that was all my comment.
[7:15]
Okay,
[7:15]
in the second item, 3.8, roll call, Madam Clerk, Director, Mr. Mayor, Dr. Shua,
[7:25]
Dr. Keegan, Dr. Kevin, yes, Dr. Santas, Dr. Raleigh, and Chairperson Masat.
[7:33]
Yes, thank you. Item 310 is a resolution to recognize August 26 as Women's Equality Day,
[7:40]
And part of the reason I want the pull-less is in the staff memo, it says that in addition to our recognition of women's equality day, the association of women employees has partnered with a group entitled Pasadena 2020 to participate in the building and presentation of this year's Rose Bowl parade women's equality day float.
[8:01]
I'm assuming the association of women employees is here at the district,
[8:07]
yes, okay, well congratulations women employees of the district.
[8:11]
This is terrific. They're actually going to help build the float. Wow. I love it. I love it. And also they're getting ready for
[8:19]
They're they're going to partner with the district and other ERGs to
[8:23]
Mark the hundredth anniversary of women winning the right to vote next year and I believe I have someone who would like to speak. Let me turn this on
[8:32]
Chair Hawk
[8:34]
I
[8:34]
in T-pop.
[8:36]
I was called the mayor.
[8:37]
And you're now called the Chair and the Board of Directors.
[8:40]
Just a little bit of an update and background on this item.
[8:42]
This is the Association of Women that we have here and they've been a longstanding organization
[8:47]
with Valley Water.
[8:49]
And so they are actually tenured, they have the history and they've worked very hard throughout
[8:53]
the decades to advocate for women in particular in the workplace.
[8:58]
Recently we have the ERZ, a while, that was instilled, which also was working in partnership
[9:03]
with AWE. And specifically, this resolution was very important to both of those organizations
[9:08]
and we'll continue to work together as we advance equality for men in workplace specifically.
[9:13]
Terrific. Yeah, so that's where I wanted to pull up because I knew that we were deeply involved
[9:18]
as the, as the staff member was set. So with that, I'm going to make a motion to
[9:22]
approve adopt the resolution, recognizing August 26th 2019 as women's equality day. And thank you
[9:27]
to the Association of Women Employees in the Wow E.R.G.
[9:33]
All right, roll call, Madam Clerk.
[9:38]
Dr. Mr. Ratt.
[9:39]
Dr. Shunnan.
[9:41]
Dr. Keegan.
[9:42]
Dr. Cameron.
[9:45]
Dr. Santas.
[9:47]
Dr. Vrala.
[9:48]
And Chairperson, was absolutely.
[9:50]
Thank you very much.
[9:51]
Four point one, Darren, put it over.
[9:56]
Okay, I mean, we need to put this over because we're waiting
[9:58]
for at the auditor too.
[10:02]
We will go back to that. So 4.2. Consider adopting resolution in support of the nomination of Sarah Palma as a candidate for position of association of California Water Agency's vice president and approves the middle of member agency ballot for region 5 board members for 2020-2021. Director Estamara.
[10:27]
Thank you, Madam Chair. I just wanted to point out that Dr. Palmer is a member of the DCA board and we're very closely with her and so definitely supportive of the nomination.
[10:41]
Thank you.
[10:42]
The motion to make the second.
[10:42]
Director Verla?
[10:44]
Thank you. Yes. Thank you for the motion. I was going to make it.
[10:47]
But you need me to.
[10:47]
It also region five. She's the vice chair of the region five of aqua.
[10:52]
And I said on that board of her and also recommend her as well.
[10:55]
Okay, great. So we have tons of recommendations. Recommendations move to approve.
[11:00]
It's okay. We motion in a second and multiple seconds multiple motions. So we have a resolution we need to adapt.
[11:06]
So I believe that's a role call as well.
[11:09]
And here she is. Here who is.
[11:13]
Here she is. Here she is.
[11:16]
Can we can we ask her to come to the...
[11:18]
We'd like to say if you were. We'd just come on down. Yes, we come on down.
[11:22]
We've had two motions and two seconds, so we're going to take a vote first.
[11:26]
We might not want to take a vote.
[11:27]
We're going to take a vote.
[11:28]
It's all the P5s.
[11:29]
You know, NRL's number.
[11:31]
Notification levels.
[11:32]
OK.
[11:33]
I am Sarah Palmer.
[11:34]
I'm from seven water agency.
[11:36]
And I'm hoping to get your support for becoming vice president of aqua.
[11:42]
So you might ask, why do I want to do that?
[11:44]
Well, I've been in water for a long time.
[11:46]
Even though it's aqua, it's been mainly since I've been retired and teaching.
[11:50]
I'm a teacher, I was a teacher, I was a teacher, cancer researcher, biochemist, I did consulting
[11:59]
with Laura Blvdmore Lab on water issues and with basically developing things for teachers
[12:06]
and education.
[12:07]
I've done a lot of public speaking on the subject and water is my passion as it is for you.
[12:15]
I'm sure.
[12:15]
So, I'm hoping to get your support and also if I do get your support, I hope you talk to other agencies and other people and ask them for their support as well.
[12:28]
So, thank you for considering this.
[12:30]
Thank you, Dr. Palmer.
[12:32]
As I was saying, when you came in, we have two motions and two seconds to support you and so we're going to take a roll call.
[12:46]
Dr. Christopher, Dr. Shula, Dr. Keegan, Dr. Kevin,
[12:56]
Dr. Santas, Dr. Vrala,
[13:00]
Chairperson Azad.
[13:01]
Yes, so I just will be seeing you at aqua.
[13:04]
So congratulations on receiving our support.
[13:07]
Yes, excellent.
[13:08]
Thank you.
[13:09]
All right, moving on to item 4.3 review of fiscal year 2020 board policy planning and performance monitoring calendars.
[13:17]
Does anybody have anything they'd like to say about that?
[13:22]
I believe that the court generally has something to say about it.
[13:31]
So this is showing updates since the last time the board viewed at it and viewed it in highlight.
[13:39]
And if you have additional updates or comments, I'd be happy to take notes of them and see that it's revised.
[13:47]
It's one of the things I wanted to note is something that we've been trying very hard to do and that is to get the advisory committees plugged into their work plan a lot of the things that we're doing so that we actually use them as advisory committees and it looks like that's been propagated to the extent it can be so that's helpful and again thank you to Director Shua and to our clerk Michelle King for working so hard on this.
[14:14]
Any other comments? I think this was just for feedback and direction. So I think we're good. All right, moving on board committee reports or
[14:25]
40 of them. There are handouts for
[14:29]
DCA summary did Tony. Did you want to give us a summary?
[14:34]
Let me let me do. Thank you very quickly.
[14:39]
As I mentioned, Director Palmer's our Vice President of the Board, and thank you for coming.
[14:46]
We would have hoped for you anyway, but thank you for coming.
[14:50]
We did just have two important issues that we discussed.
[14:55]
And that was staffing.
[14:56]
We had a staffing workshop because...
[15:00]
So initially the department, I think the whole idea initially was that the DCA wasn't going to have employees, but if we went along, we realized that we really did need at least a cadre of employees, and so we went through a small workshop regarding that and had a little discussion about that.
[15:22]
And secondly,
[15:28]
we had a review of the executive director's report, which is pretty comprehensive,
[15:36]
but we're pretty happy about it because it includes a lot more information for the public to see.
[15:41]
We used to have a pretty skeletal report, but now this is a really comprehensive report,
[15:47]
includes even the departmental actions so that the public knows exactly what's going on,
[15:56]
with the project, what the department's doing, what the executive is doing and so on.
[16:04]
We're happy about that because it's very public and it's on our website and everything.
[16:08]
It's a pretty comprehensive report. And then we had the General Council report, the Treasury report,
[16:15]
And not much more, but we expect that they're going to be a lot more meetings as we get
[16:23]
a lot.
[16:24]
And hopefully the next month or two we'll find out what the proposed size of the tunnel will
[16:30]
be and so on.
[16:34]
All right.
[16:36]
So there were other summaries in here at the Richter Barona, did you have something you want
[16:44]
to say?
[16:50]
There we go.
[16:50]
I just report out in the agriculture water advisory committee.
[16:57]
So at the last meeting we had in July, the committee at that point approved a subcommittee
[17:05]
to do a feasibility on coming forward with an alternative to the open space credit
[17:12]
where agriculture purposes in Santa Clara and our region.
[17:16]
And so in the board, in our budget of adoption, anointed me with the challenge to try to
[17:27]
herd these nice folks in the Farm Bureau organization to come up with a plan.
[17:33]
So I sat down with Mr. Darren Taylor and we ran over some scenarios and came up with
[17:39]
an idea that I will be presenting to the Farm Bureau next week.
[17:45]
I did sit down with the member of their executive team, executive director, and also the president
[17:52]
of the board, and went over the scenario with them, and they approved they thought it was
[17:57]
a good idea, and so I will be presenting that to the board members and to the committee
[18:03]
in those that show up.
[18:04]
I also formed a subcommittee of an advisory group of folks in a conclusive, Farm Bureau will
[18:12]
their own group, but I did have the newest appointment to the Advisory Committee, Mr. Tim Keala,
[18:19]
who will be joining this, also have a member from the California Water Coalition, members
[18:25]
from the Open Space Authority, the Habitat Agency, Loma Prey at a Conservation District,
[18:31]
a City Council member from Morgan Hill, a City Council member from San Jose, and members
[18:36]
from Mr Assembly Member Robert Reefes' office and also Santa Clara County Ag Planning Commissioner.
[18:46]
So those would be the Advisory Committee, too.
[18:49]
The group at the Farm Bureau will form, and I will report back to this committee to
[18:55]
this board once I've learned more, and also, if they approve this, we will move it forward
[18:59]
and agendize this for discussion at the next meeting in October of the Agriculture Water Advisory
[19:04]
committee. So, that's where report? Okay, Director Kermin, I think you had yours on and I knocked
[19:12]
you off, and then Director Santos, Director. So you just shut up and there you're going to go.
[19:18]
Thank you, Chair. We had a water storage meeting today that was very productive and we voted
[19:29]
to recommend to the board that the staff in San Benito County Water District have a kind
[19:41]
of a tentative agreement between them as our super partner that's pretty we voted to recommend
[19:50]
that staff either starts negotiating that but we want to put it back to the board asks that
[19:58]
our board puts it on the agenda.
[20:00]
For the next meeting. Is that representative kind of what happened? Yes, no. Yeah. So I guess an ask is to put it on the agenda. Okay. So that'll be a agreement between us in San Bernardo County.
[20:13]
So that's an ask, I think. Yeah, I think we see something on the agenda. Okay.
[20:17]
And one other thing that Mr. Meer had showed incredible knowledge in that board meeting of some interesting and obscure, but important knowledge of semi-traffic water storage that we're going to actually bring back the discuss, very impressive Mr. Meer had.
[20:39]
And that's it for now.
[20:41]
Great, Director Santas.
[20:47]
Thank you.
[20:48]
I think you have Gary and John Lutus that it was a very informative water storage meeting
[20:52]
with all our staff.
[20:54]
A lot of questions, a lot of dialogue.
[20:56]
I'm sure it could have went on for a couple more hours.
[20:58]
But anyway, real quick, we had the homeless ad hoc committee meeting.
[21:02]
Very, very good meeting, packed house.
[21:05]
We're going to make us some recommendations.
[21:06]
It'll come to the board.
[21:07]
The next meeting will be September 30th.
[21:10]
So we're doing some due diligence right now in terms of trying to do a different approach
[21:14]
about the cleanup and how we go about it or work with the homeless and Melanie and
[21:18]
the staff and everybody did a great job and we meet with the police chief and we're going
[21:23]
to try to different approach but before we do of course we'll come to the board because
[21:26]
it's a consideration to make a presentation.
[21:28]
Then the last one was the Santa Clara County Council Operations Emergency Operations
[21:33]
Media and Chair Lizot was there with Chief Yoke and it was a very good meeting about
[21:39]
you know get ourselves prepared and ironically that's what we're doing as a board but we need to go back and also
[21:45]
I hope we put on a future board that we still got to address our security issue not just the other emergency things
[21:52]
But in that made everybody wake up in my lady at home to run
[21:56]
I was talking about it
[21:58]
She buys the bag of all the goodies which I already had, but it's good update and then then then that media had a list
[22:04]
Which is good so we double checked with this but I hope you folks out there too
[22:07]
earthquake fires are all real and we're having them again this year as always and we do a good job
[22:14]
but I'm glad that we were already tackling these issues and then she didn't even after the
[22:18]
mean he had a chance to sit down and talk about some we'd call them common sense issues of what
[22:22]
we can do now so it was really good so thanks anybody else taking a lot to that it was a really
[22:30]
excellent several presentations at the emergency council one particularly concerning the PG&E
[22:39]
of shutdowns and what we might anticipate, but we're kind of in a bubble when we're not expected to be really greatly impacted.
[22:47]
But just on the issue of security and to Director As Santos's point, I think after we had the active shooter training, I think during that meeting,
[22:57]
I asked that we have sort of like a mock board meeting where we do something about an active shooter,
[23:06]
just to, again, where are the exits, how do you get out, what's hardened, what isn't, I think we talked about hardening the lobby, so I'm hopefully hopefully that's going to come back.
[23:17]
And then the other thing, I forget what I mentioned to, I may have mentioned it to Alex, was whether or not we could have search training on site.
[23:29]
I was at the celebrate Cambrian and there was a certain representative there and they were
[23:36]
Campbell cert but I asked them if there was ways to do that so I have some information
[23:40]
if you don't I'm sure you already have it so I think it would be important to have some
[23:45]
cert just offered here as a site and so it could either be community board employees whatever
[23:54]
who wanted to get CERC trained.
[23:58]
So, Chief Yoke, did you want to say something?
[23:59]
So I want to just reaffirm that that I will work with our emergency services and security
[24:05]
manager on that requested drill exercise in the evacuation routes as well as follow-up with the
[24:12]
community emergency response team that's the the the the the CERC in regard to utilizing
[24:20]
our agency as one of their locations.
[24:28]
Thank you chair. I just want to remind the board that I have included three meeting summary in this item.
[24:37]
One is the board policy planning committee, the other two are for the two meetings of the capital improvement program, particularly for the capital improvement program that we're discussing in the middle of discussing PLA.
[24:51]
and also the prioritization criteria for this coming CRP.
[25:01]
And I try very hard to make the memo simple and to the point. So please, if you have any questions or suggestions, give it to us.
[25:15]
All right. And again, there's some additional summaries that you are seeing.
[25:20]
And the Water Commission summary report. Okay. Thank you, everyone, for your reports and updates.
[25:26]
But next item on the agenda is 4.5 approved updates to the Santa Clara Valley Water District Living Wage Policy, Michael.
[25:37]
Good evening, sir.
[25:38]
Good evening, Chair Lizot, board members.
[25:40]
This is an item to see information on living current living wage policy and recommendation of updated update to the policy.
[25:53]
As I previously reported, back in 2003, there was the policy that was adopted at that time
[26:03]
by the board, included persons doing work on behalf of the district, not be paid less
[26:10]
than a living wage, not able to afford health insurance, have reasonable time off, and
[26:15]
not be subject to lay off, merely because the district changes contracts, and also to work
[26:21]
an environment of labor peace.
[26:23]
That was confirmed again in 2008 by the board.
[26:26]
In 2011, the board amended the policy and eliminated
[26:33]
the language regarding affordable health insurance,
[26:36]
not being subject to layoff, merely because of changing
[26:40]
contract and working in an environment where there is
[26:42]
labor peace.
[26:45]
Since then, the current policy requires that persons
[26:49]
doing work on behalf of the district be paid at least a living wage and received reasonable
[26:55]
time off, but there's no language on healthcare and nothing defining the meeting of reasonable
[27:02]
time off.
[27:03]
So before you is an updated policy which includes the idea that first of all covers janitorial,
[27:12]
custodial employees and security employees.
[27:14]
Both of whom are the kind of people who have been here many years and embedded in our workforce.
[27:22]
We have stepped on those two crews that have been here as long as 20 years.
[27:29]
And, you know, through changes of various contractors.
[27:33]
So what the recommendation here is that besides the living wage, which has just been updated,
[27:41]
pursuant to the cost of living. We're proposing that anyone, any of these people who work
[27:49]
and they all do pretty much work in average of 20 hours or more a week, assigned to the
[27:56]
Valley Water and their eligible dependents be provided health insurance paid by the contractors.
[28:05]
And there's included in this policies and minimum requirements or what the medical coverage is,
[28:10]
down insurance would be what the vision coverage would be.
[28:14]
These are all parallel to what current existing valley water employees get,
[28:21]
and it requires time off 12 holidays, water valley water holidays, 12 days of sick leave,
[28:29]
and vacation time, you know, for these employees, and we did exclude, and the old policy
[28:37]
just so to point out, there were included services like pest control, office and clerical,
[28:46]
copy your maintenance, landscaping, all of whom are sporadic services and different
[28:51]
people common go, and there's no really stability to what they do.
[28:57]
It's just services as needed, so to speak.
[29:01]
So we're recommending this updated policy, as you can see, we have an estimate of $780,000
[29:13]
increase.
[29:14]
That would increase.
[29:16]
What we're saying is that it would get addressed when we negotiate, renegotiate,
[29:22]
with the contractors, you know, the cost of this and undoubtedly
[29:29]
would be some kind of past through or, you know,
[29:33]
form of a higher contract crisis for us.
[29:36]
But that's kind of the neighborhood of the cost.
[29:39]
So we're recommending board, consider adopting this new,
[29:44]
updated living wage costs.
[29:46]
OK, thank you, Michael, to Rick, Mr. Mayor.
[29:48]
Thank you, Madam Chair.
[29:49]
Yeah, I had raises because I can't, for my life for me, remember why we changed the policy.
[29:57]
But I certainly believe that we ought to have the policy.
[30:00]
This presented today, we should certainly adopt that. We continue to see stories in the news everywhere and news
[30:07]
both TV and everywhere about how tough it is to make a living here, and especially for these
[30:13]
working folks, we need to be supportive on them, treat them just like our employees, and that's
[30:17]
really what this is all about. Later on, we talk about temporary employees, same thing. So fairness
[30:24]
is what's important. Before I move this map, I just wanted to ask Michael, would we expect
[30:30]
to land scalpers? Are they really intermittent with us or because since we've got a lot of
[30:37]
land scalping out here? I don't know. We have crews that come for a few hours each week,
[30:49]
Trim during the fall when they're released, they might be here for a personal day or several
[30:54]
partial days, but that service is unlike the janitorial where there's a dedicated design
[31:00]
staff that is here for either a partial shift, regularly, or a full shift every day.
[31:08]
And we've got a separate contract for the skilled labor and that contract helping our clean up
[31:16]
are pre-cleanups, and encampments have a very mobile workforce.
[31:23]
They tend to come and go on that contractor's payroll,
[31:27]
and assigned to jobs depending on how long
[31:32]
those jobs are and how complex they are.
[31:36]
So they tend to be more temporary workers.
[31:39]
Thank you.
[31:41]
Then I'm satisfied then with the proposal.
[31:44]
so I move that we adopt that proposal.
[31:47]
Thank you, Manchir.
[31:48]
Okay, it's a motion and a second to adopt the
[31:52]
Santa Fire Valley, what a district living wage policy.
[31:56]
All those, it's just an action.
[31:58]
So all those in favor?
[32:00]
All those opposed that motion carries unanimously.
[32:03]
All right, moving on.
[32:04]
Thank you, Tony, and thank you Michael.
[32:09]
Moving on to item 5.1.
[32:13]
Receive groundwater benefits zone study preliminary
[32:15]
report and consider recommendations for updates to the groundwater benefit zone.
[32:20]
Let's see how we don't take the...
[32:24]
Vanessa first, and then that is Vanessa, isn't it?
[32:27]
I can't see that for, I'm sorry.
[32:30]
I have to look here in the TV.
[32:32]
It'll help me.
[32:33]
And then I have one speaker.
[32:35]
Go ahead.
[32:36]
Okay.
[32:36]
Good evening, chair Lizot.
[32:38]
Members of the board.
[32:39]
My name is Vanessa DeLapadra.
[32:40]
I'm the groundwater management unit manager here at the district.
[32:43]
Valley Water. I'll be providing an overview of the groundwater benefit zone study, but I want to note
[32:48]
that there is much more detail in the agenda item and attachments. And also, I mentioned that
[32:52]
I have a team of experts here to help answer any questions that the board may have on this item.
[32:58]
So the district act authorizes the board to establish zones in areas that benefit from valley
[33:03]
water activities to protect an augment water supplies. And these zones are important because groundwater
[33:07]
charges collected in these areas allow us to fund activities that ensure sustainable groundwater.
[33:12]
So the two primary zones that you're familiar with are W2 shown in blue here in North County and W5 outlined in Brown in South County.
[33:22]
So although there's no requirement to do so, it is appropriate to review the zones periodically because our activities change over time and so does our understanding of the groundwater basins.
[33:31]
So we hired Montgomery and Associates consulting firm to conduct an independent science-based study to help ensure fair and equitable charges for well users.
[33:40]
The study also helps us to address both pending and future requests for exemption from the charge zones.
[33:47]
Engaging stakeholders was a key focus throughout the study, because zone changes have the potential to impact many well users.
[33:54]
So you can see on the timeline here, it's taken us some time to get to this point, and that's because we wanted this study to be really comprehensive,
[34:00]
and we wanted to provide for stakeholder input. So before the consultant evaluated any data, we solicited input on the study approach from stakeholders and an independent technical review committee.
[34:10]
And then after the preliminary study was prepared, we again sought input from those two groups.
[34:17]
Throughout the study, we've asked stakeholders to provide relevant data and information,
[34:20]
and we considered that in bringing forth the recommendations to you this evening.
[34:27]
So, in working to identify areas that receive similar benefits from valley water activities,
[34:31]
the consultant first mapped our activities, and also the features that affect the occurrence and the movement of groundwater.
[34:39]
So, the consultant used this mapping and multiple lines of evidence to assess specific areas
[34:45]
that benefit from valley water activities.
[34:47]
The analyzed groundwater level trends for evidence of benefit from our activities, and this
[34:51]
analysis was conservative to minimize the influence of other factors like rainfall or
[34:57]
San Francisco Public Utility Commission deliveries.
[35:00]
The consultant also used groundwater results and the groundwater budget to evaluate the effect of
[35:05]
valley water activities, and they also considered data provided by our stakeholders.
[35:12]
So, based on this conference of analysis, the consultant recommends six zones compared
[35:17]
to the existing two, and the point of this is to help ensure that well users pay only
[35:21]
for those activities that benefit those areas. The technical review committee for the study found
[35:26]
the analysis to be thorough and reasonable, and they praise valley water and the consultant
[35:30]
for the comprehensive study that we took on.
[35:33]
If the consultant recommendations were adopted
[35:35]
about 90 wells, which are mostly a North County,
[35:38]
would be newly added to a zone,
[35:40]
and more than 500 wells would be removed from any zone.
[35:46]
In North County, the consultant recommends
[35:48]
three zones, which are shown here, the largest,
[35:50]
which is zone A,
[35:52]
overlies the Valley Floor Aluvium,
[35:55]
which is the geologic materials that form
[35:57]
the primary aquifers.
[36:00]
The study demonstrates that this zone A benefits
[36:03]
from the same set of comprehensive activities as existing zone W2, which is shown here in the blue outline.
[36:10]
The consultant recommends two new zones B1 and B2, which are along the foot hills,
[36:15]
and the basis for these zones is value-water treated deliveries in those areas and interconnected
[36:20]
groundwater flows. Zone B1 overlies the Santa Clara Formation, which is more geologically complex
[36:28]
and the valley floor and zone B2 overlies bedrock.
[36:35]
In South County, the consultant also recommends a change from one zone to three.
[36:40]
First, coyote valley is recommended to be a separate zone zone C shown here, and that's because
[36:45]
groundwater in this area flows north. This is part of the Santa Clara sub basin to the north.
[36:50]
This area is demonstrated to benefit from the managed recharge of local imported water.
[36:56]
The larger zone zone D, which is shown in light green,
[37:00]
overlays the Yagas sub basin, Valley Floor,
[37:02]
Lovium, and this zone is demonstrated
[37:04]
to benefit from the same set of comprehensive activities
[37:07]
as existing zone W5.
[37:10]
Zone E, which is shown in dark green,
[37:12]
overlays a Lovium in the foot-hills downstream
[37:14]
of the U.S. and Tresbro reservoirs,
[37:17]
in this area that benefits from valley water releases
[37:20]
of local surface water from those reservoirs.
[37:25]
So we conducted extensive outreach on the preliminary report and the Zones recommended by the consultants.
[37:31]
This included presentations to board committees, elected officials, and the public as well as letters to potentially affected well users.
[37:38]
We held three open houses, responded to many phone calls and emails, and met with individuals and groups of well users.
[37:48]
So we received written comments on the preliminary report from several water retailers and individuals,
[37:53]
these comments and our written responses are an attachment for of the board packet.
[37:59]
The comments from Water Retailers were very helpful in identifying areas in the preliminary
[38:03]
report where additional clarification was needed or expanded detail.
[38:08]
However, we believe the preliminary report provides compelling evidence of benefit from
[38:12]
value water activities in these areas, so the comments ultimately did not result in changes
[38:17]
to the recommended zones.
[38:21]
Most comments from individual well-users related to Zones B1 and B2, again, these are those areas along the North County Foot Hills.
[38:29]
And most of those related to comments on the complex geology and the Santa Clara formation and the lack of data within those areas.
[38:36]
And staff agrees there is very limited data within those areas, and there is uncertainty about how ground runners connected within those areas in those zones.
[38:46]
Well owners proposed to be removed from his own were generally very surprised and very appreciative.
[38:54]
So it's nice to hear some of those comments.
[38:56]
I do want to mention that after the board item was posted, we received comments from the Happy Acres Mutual Water Company.
[39:02]
They're well was previously exempted from zone W5 in 1989, but is proposed to be included in the Consultant Recommended Zone E.
[39:10]
So we would like to add those comments to the administrative record, and a copy has been provided to the clerk of the board, and I believe you have all have a comment of those
[39:19]
a copy of those comments as well.
[39:22]
So for that particular well, staff is proposing to review
[39:25]
available area, available information for this well, in the general area, and we would provide an update prior to any formal board action to change in these zones.
[39:40]
You want to speak now?
[39:43]
Thank you.
[39:45]
Just a question on this late communicator we receive from happy acres.
[39:52]
They were not inclusive in any part of the discussions that we had previously and the public
[39:57]
meetings they were notified or they never responded.
[40:00]
I just want some clarification as to why this late response when we had such a public outreach on this. It's kind of like we're not aware.
[40:09]
So our records indicate that we did send letters to this water company, several letters. I think in April and in June,
[40:15]
notifying them of the availability of the preliminary report, open houses. I'm not sure of the reason, but they did recently reach out to us with these comments.
[40:26]
Thank you.
[40:31]
Director Karen.
[40:33]
Thank you.
[40:34]
First I want to thank staff yourself.
[40:37]
Mr. Hall and Mr. Cook.
[40:39]
For all the work you did.
[40:41]
Clearly a tough one.
[40:44]
When we say attachment for the public comments,
[40:47]
I'm looking at and it looks blank the medium.
[40:49]
I reading this wrong.
[40:52]
There was a supplemental agenda item.
[40:55]
So it's provided and I'm not sure.
[40:57]
Okay, because this says four when I look on four in our little thing I don't it's it's actually blank
[41:03]
I think it's a supplemental
[41:07]
attachment one
[41:08]
Okay, it's in what two is map consultants recommended do I need to do a refresh
[41:19]
Okay, so it should be about 130 pages of comments and responses
[41:25]
Yeah, that's what I don't see but
[41:28]
It's in the second attachment, I think there's some refresh issue, but okay fine, just want to be sure also, we get our meets and bounds right this time if you recall, last time some members of the public brought up that our meets and bounds did not match what we said at the board meeting, so I don't know if we bring those back or not.
[41:50]
And so if the board directs staff to pursue zone changes at this time, we will need to prepare the
[41:56]
meets and bounds and we will be just one of the things in that because it's real detailed
[42:01]
in there and he said what we discussed in public was different than actually what we published.
[42:10]
Thank you.
[42:14]
Thank you.
[42:14]
Chief Hook.
[42:21]
Through the chair and board.
[42:22]
In response to the meets and bounds, as it relates to the progress made thus far by staff,
[42:26]
we've done preliminary report which we're presenting this evening and the boundaries that have
[42:31]
and developed a bin for illustration purposes,
[42:33]
and identification of wells in and out of the potential proposed zones.
[42:37]
Meets and bounds, however, have yet to been completed
[42:40]
or acted upon by staff.
[42:42]
We're looking for that guidance this evening
[42:44]
based on the recommendation of staff and concurrence of the board
[42:47]
and then we'll actually prepare meets and bounds
[42:50]
and would bring those back to the board.
[42:52]
So those were required very meticulous work
[42:55]
in terms of completing that action.
[43:03]
Stan did you want to say something?
[43:05]
Yeah, thank you.
[43:05]
Thank you.
[43:05]
Madam Chair.
[43:06]
With respect to the German comments, I do remember the gentleman that came before the board
[43:10]
of that particular time.
[43:12]
I don't know, maybe two or three years ago, I think maybe something like that.
[43:15]
But I think what's important in understanding is that as Chief Hawkes pointed out, the
[43:21]
maps today are for illustrative purposes.
[43:25]
They are not specific as to where the line actually lies.
[43:31]
And then what will be presented to you, assuming a board gives such a direction, is an
[43:41]
national meets and bounds, which is specific.
[43:44]
And that is what the board will be ultimately having to approve or disapproval.
[43:51]
That's all.
[43:51]
Thank you.
[43:54]
Okay.
[43:55]
Did you want to continue?
[43:57]
Yes.
[43:58]
So based on careful consideration of the preliminary report and all of the information and data that we receive from stakeholders,
[44:05]
value water staff is recommending a total of four zones.
[44:10]
So in North County, we're recommending that existing zone W2 be modified to be consistent with boundary of zone A proposed by the consultant.
[44:19]
And that's because these areas are determined to benefit from the same set of activities that rather than creating a new zone, we can modify the existing zone.
[44:26]
Zones B1 and B2 along with put hills may benefit from valley water activities, however, staff believes that additional geologic and groundwater data would be needed to fully justify charges in these zones.
[44:38]
So staff is recommending that Zones B1 and B2 not be implemented at this time.
[44:44]
If these staff recommendations are implemented, one well would be added to his own and more than 350 would be removed from Zones W2.
[44:52]
With fewer while users in the zone, the water rate in the modified zone W2 would increase
[44:57]
by an estimated $3 an acre of foot as a result.
[45:02]
And South County staff recommends that zone W5 be modified to align with the boundaries of zone D proposed by the consultant. Again, since these zones benefit from the same set of activities. Staff also recommends establishing new zones W7 and coyote valley and W8 downstream of US and Tresbro reservoirs. The boundaries of these zones would be consistent with consultant recommended zones C and E respectively, but the names would align with valley water naming convention.
[45:31]
So this would cause about 10 wells to be added to a zone and 500 to be removed. Water rates within Modified Zone W5 would increase due to a shrinking of the zone, and because well users and coyote valley would no longer contribute to recycled water programs in the Y august sub basin.
[45:48]
The estimated increase to well users and modified zone W5 is $11 an acre foot. Water rates in zone W7 and W8 would decrease since well users within these areas would no longer fund certain activities.
[46:00]
So, the estimated decrease in coyote, coyote values $15 an acre foot, and the estimated decrease in zone
[46:06]
W8 is $138 an acre foot, and it's important to note that any changes to zones don't affect the overall revenue
[46:14]
received by value water from groundwater production charges.
[46:19]
If the staff recommendation is approved, 11 wells that have pending ground exemption requests from zone would be removed from various areas within zone W2.
[46:28]
These are shown here and these well users and any others rule from a zone would no longer be subject to ground order production charges once the zones become affected
[46:38]
So staff recommends
[46:40]
Moving forward to establish the four zones described and listed here modify the zones w two and w five and new zones w seven and w eight
[46:49]
This would require preparation of the legal survey description or the meets and bounds from board consideration and adoption
[46:56]
We recommend that the zone changes the implemented in fiscal year 2021 to be effective
[47:00]
on July 1 of 2020, and this would require rate study of these newer modified zones for inclusion
[47:07]
in the fiscal year 21 protection and augmentation of water supplies report and the related
[47:13]
rate setting cycle. Staff recommends that current rates remain effective until new rates are
[47:18]
established for these new or modified zones during that FY21 rate setting process.
[47:24]
And we also recommend future review of the zones if our activities change substantially
[47:28]
if we get significant new data on the groundwater basins or if more than 15 years has passed without any review of the zones.
[47:38]
So if the board directs staff to pursue zone changes, this fall we would do the work to prepare the needs and bounds with a legal survey description.
[47:46]
We would conduct the rate study, and then we would also need to ask the board to set a public hearing.
[47:51]
That's required by the district act as part of the work to establish new zones.
[47:55]
So staff recommends that the public hearing for board adoption of newer modified zones occur in January of 2020, and again that the newer modified zones become effective
[48:05]
beginning July 1 of 2020. And with that, stand up into any questions.
[48:13]
All right. I have one public speaker.
[48:18]
Speaker, stay tuned.
[48:23]
Tom Zigderman,
[48:28]
thank you for spelling it phonetically for me.
[48:30]
Thank you. Thank you. Good evening, Chair Lizott, members of the Board. My name is Tom Zigderman.
[48:37]
I'm the Director of Water Resources and Civil Infrastructure at Stanford University.
[48:41]
Stanford continues to have questions about the zone of benefit studies, technical basis,
[48:46]
for concluding that district recharge activities benefit the far North County.
[48:51]
And we continue to question whether the study supports the legal basis for the district's groundwater fees.
[48:57]
We have had two rounds of comments and responses with staff on the technical aspects.
[49:02]
We have different opinions on the validity of the computer modeling developed in the study
[49:06]
and we have different opinions on the effect of the district's recharge activities
[49:11]
That are located in the Central County, by the way, that's about more than 10 miles away from Stanford and San Francisco Creek.
[49:19]
That are located in the Central County on the recovery of groundwater levels in the North County.
[49:24]
Both in the mid-1900s and today, relative to development of our own surface water supplies and investment in imported SFPUC water in the mid-1900s.
[49:36]
and the substantial decrease in use of groundwater that resulted from that importation.
[49:42]
We also recharge groundwater directly.
[49:45]
Stanford has invested significantly in these activities which should be recognized in the district study of the benefits of its projects.
[49:54]
So we would like to continue to meet with district staff and work out an approach that acknowledges these factors and their relatives.
[50:08]
Thank you.
[50:10]
All right, do we have any Director Estimer, you want to say something?
[50:16]
Yes, Madam Chair, I just got a quick question about the justification for removing so many well, especially
[50:22]
South County, from people who can more than go out to afford it and place it in people who
[50:32]
So, I mean, this really was a very technically focused study so the consultant was using various
[50:38]
available data and tools to really assess and look for evidence of benefit from valley
[50:43]
water activities. And based on that analysis, it does result in the recommendation to remove
[50:51]
a fair number of wells. The overwhelming majority of these are very small producers. I know
[50:56]
the number sounds very large, but I think the average pumping for these wells is on the order
[51:00]
like one and a half acre feet in comparison to the 140,000 acre feet that's
[51:07]
pumped county wide each year. But again this was strictly a technical analysis
[51:12]
and these were the results that come out of that.
[51:18]
Dr. Krimad.
[51:23]
Thank you, Chair. And it was
[51:25]
my bad for somehow I missed the supplementary stakeholder comments.
[51:32]
I mean can you
[51:33]
And I know we've resolved a couple of these.
[51:36]
Can you maybe comment on these long engineering letters, which unfortunately I haven't
[51:43]
had enough time to read through in detail, I have to go get my civil engineering degree
[51:48]
currently.
[51:51]
Would you like me to comment specifically on a Stanford comment?
[51:54]
You know, Seratoga, golf club, I think is the one that's kind of left.
[51:59]
Saratoga and maybe Stanford and it great oaks.
[52:03]
I mean, just, you know, what's the story?
[52:07]
So the Saratoga golf club was concerned about being included.
[52:12]
I believe their in zone B1.
[52:15]
So if the staff recommendation is moved forward,
[52:18]
then they would continue to be outside of his own.
[52:21]
So that's moot.
[52:23]
What about the great oaks?
[52:26]
Is that just them?
[52:30]
Yeah, yes, I didn't want to say that. I want you to get in trouble for standing like that.
[52:34]
Well, I would suggest that for the comments from Great Oaks and Stanford and Palo Alto, and of course,
[52:40]
Great Oaks and Palo Alto also supported the comments from Stanford.
[52:45]
I think it's a situation of agreeing to disagree.
[52:49]
I mean, there is a difference of opinion there, but again, we feel that there are multiple lines of evidence that were used in the study that
[52:57]
It was a scientifically sound approach, and that there's more than enough evidence and documentation
[53:05]
to continue to include these areas in his own.
[53:08]
Are there any differences, quoting Chair Lizot, Great Oaks being Great Oaks, or did they
[53:14]
attach an engineering report, right?
[53:18]
No, Great Oaks comments were just I agree.
[53:23]
Well, they did have their own specific comments.
[53:24]
because they were not from a technical consultant from there, right?
[53:28]
Thank you.
[53:30]
If I may.
[53:31]
I think it's, for me, the fact that staff has looked at some of the comments that were
[53:37]
made in some of the meetings and also letters and decided to take two zones out of what
[53:45]
the, to me, speaks to the fact that we're willing to listen and if the data isn't solid
[53:51]
or it hasn't been there long enough or it isn't, you know, just not enough to tip it.
[54:01]
We're going to say, okay, the data is not solid enough for us.
[54:06]
You've made your point and we're just going to continue and if the data changes one way,
[54:10]
the other will make a decision one way or the other.
[54:12]
So to me, that speaks of us being fair in looking at the data and, you know, making
[54:21]
decisions based on what's in front of us and not just, you know, how we feel that day.
[54:28]
So I direct your sentence.
[54:31]
Yes, though, would ask my fellow board members to, let's put this up for 30 more days.
[54:36]
We shouldn't be in a hurry and it's no disrespect to staff because Vanessa met with all
[54:41]
of us and gave you plenty of time to know and I called the guy out there from Stanford.
[54:47]
call him Kenny Rodgers. He came to our water demand meetings all the time and I think that
[54:53]
with that input we have right now 30 days ain't going to hurt anybody. We got to make a decision
[54:57]
maybe in January. I think staff done a great job.
[55:00]
I know I met with George and you and we sat down and you explained it to me. And I haven't had no phone calls. But just hearing what I'm hearing, I just think it's more healthy to give whether it be stand for greater or for 30 more days every day, get their input. And then if the decisions are the same from staff, let's go ahead and adopt it and do what we've got to do. But I would ask my fellow board members to hold off for 30 more days. That's my motion.
[55:35]
Yes. I'd like to call Darren Taylor up to the podium here to talk about, but a 30-day delay,
[55:43]
what kind of impact that would have on our rate setting process for this year, 21.
[55:50]
Sure. Thank you. Good afternoon. Good evening.
[55:54]
A 30-day delay. Well, what we plan to do as part of the FY21 rate study is prepare the rate study
[56:04]
using the old zones, and prepare the rate study using new zones.
[56:09]
So what really is what would be different for us
[56:13]
is if the board were to go down a path of something different
[56:16]
than the staff recommendation.
[56:18]
In terms of a 30 day delay, I think that that's something
[56:20]
that we can work with, and knowing that we're going to head
[56:26]
down the path of kind of doing it both ways so that ultimately
[56:29]
down the road for the FY21 rate setting process,
[56:31]
we can show the board what it looks like before
[56:34]
and what it looks like after.
[56:42]
Yeah.
[56:43]
I'd like to support director Santos, Motion,
[56:47]
you know, maybe a friendly amendment,
[56:48]
maybe to the next board meeting.
[56:51]
Here's the thing, I mean, I think these letters
[56:54]
are precursor to potential litigation,
[56:57]
and I think we know how much that cost.
[57:01]
So maybe the parties can do some sort of informal,
[57:05]
scientific science-based mediation in the meantime if there is such a thing I mean you
[57:11]
say I agree to disagree but I'm just worried that we'll be spending a couple hundred
[57:17]
thousand dollars in the litigation maybe one less try to in that period that's
[57:25]
why to try to come to some sort of narrow it down but it's hard for me to say
[57:32]
because I didn't read the letter, so it's my bad.
[57:35]
Dr. Chushu.
[57:37]
Thank you, Chair.
[57:38]
With there's a comment, I was
[57:41]
support the motion to extended three or
[57:47]
days.
[57:49]
But I'd like to remind my colleague that
[57:55]
as Vanessa said, this is a very technical study
[57:59]
And the whole idea of doing this study is to make sure that the benefits that are conveyed by our operation is paid by our owners that's receiving that benefits.
[58:14]
And the study is taking many well owners who currently paying for the pumping charges.
[58:26]
However, some of the operations and investment we do, they actually don't receive the complete benefit
[58:35]
out of those.
[58:36]
So there's these two sites, there's quite a few well owners that are paying for what they're
[58:44]
So, 30 days, if we can have additional time to work with other resolved scientific comments,
[58:55]
I'm okay with that.
[58:57]
See, you'll come at you.
[59:00]
I just wanted to get some clarification from the board when you say 30 days, is this 30 days
[59:07]
prior to the publishing of the agenda item because we have to do a 10-day posting prior to that or are you saying just because
[59:20]
If we were to go to the next board meeting on September 24th that we would have to post less than 30 days actually and
[59:28]
So that wouldn't give us the whole length of time to really have for the discussions or
[59:34]
Mediations regarding this issue
[59:36]
Well, but even if you're, even if you're posted, you could still continue to talk up until the day of the meeting.
[59:44]
So that would still, I mean, I wouldn't want to go beyond the September 24th meeting.
[59:52]
Mr. Yamamoto.
[59:53]
Two comments, madam Chair.
[59:55]
Yes.
[59:55]
First I think, I think what's important here is that.
[1:00:00]
That's important, but it's significant in its particular respect. We're talking about a major financial
[1:00:08]
issue with respect to the district. So, in that respect, I think you want to have all your information
[1:00:15]
published prior to that board meeting, so that the public has an opportunity to review what
[1:00:23]
is has been discussed in what resolution if any has been met, rather than wait until the
[1:00:31]
day of the board we need to present whatever issues are out there.
[1:00:38]
So I think I think in considering any kind of delay, you want to make sure that information
[1:00:46]
is published and posted correctly according to the District Act that our practices.
[1:00:51]
So I think that's very important.
[1:00:54]
I also, for the record, want to make sure that
[1:00:59]
and have a misdeal of Peter correctly, if I'm wrong,
[1:01:04]
but the issue with respect to Stanford is not
[1:01:09]
unresolved in staff's mind.
[1:01:13]
We have conferred with our consultants.
[1:01:16]
We have had public meetings,
[1:01:18]
and we are confident in the results that we are presenting this evening.
[1:01:24]
Now, I'm going to spell a paper if I anything I said was incorrect, please correct me now.
[1:01:28]
That's correct.
[1:01:29]
Thank you, Manager.
[1:01:32]
So, I'm not going to support the motion.
[1:01:36]
I think there's been plenty of public outreach.
[1:01:41]
I think that as I said previously, that staff has taken into consideration all comments.
[1:01:48]
And in those instances where there wasn't, you know, absolutely rock solid data or a not an enough data.
[1:01:59]
Two zones were taken out.
[1:02:02]
I think that shows that we're, you know, willing to make some changes.
[1:02:06]
I agree as the speaker from Stanford said, you know, we're just going to have to agree to disagree.
[1:02:11]
I don't know what 30 days is going to buy us. I really don't.
[1:02:14]
So I can't support the motion I think it's
[1:02:20]
just I can't but I agree with the district council
[1:02:24]
I don't know how the boat's going to go, but if it does go in favor of the delay that we have to
[1:02:32]
It may not be the last meeting in September, maybe the first meeting in October such that
[1:02:37]
Everything has to be done by 30 days so that we can post it in time for the meeting in October
[1:02:43]
So, okay, that's my comments.
[1:02:48]
What do we take of voice vote, Madam Clerk?
[1:02:57]
Okay, so what I have is that the board direct staff to hold off four additional 30 days,
[1:03:04]
which is translating to the first meeting of October 2019 to allow
[1:03:08]
the rate of Stanford Palozo and others to present concerns to staff,
[1:03:12]
and direct staff to come back in 30 days with a confirmation of continued
[1:03:16]
unchange recommendation or new recommendation reflecting changes if that's applicable.
[1:03:21]
That's what I have.
[1:03:27]
Okay, and with that we'll take a roll call.
[1:03:29]
Dr. Christopher?
[1:03:31]
Dr. Shua?
[1:03:32]
Yes.
[1:03:33]
Dr. Keegan?
[1:03:35]
Dr. Kremen?
[1:03:36]
Yes.
[1:03:37]
Dr. Santas?
[1:03:39]
Dr. Verla?
[1:03:41]
Chairperson Lizot?
[1:03:44]
Okay.
[1:03:45]
All right, thank you, Vanessa.
[1:03:46]
It's a very much go forth and negotiate for whatever.
[1:03:53]
I'd like
[1:03:55]
to thank you chair.
[1:03:59]
I just want to once again, thanks staff for a great work.
[1:04:04]
And also the process of knowing the fine everybody working together with everybody.
[1:04:09]
Thank you.
[1:04:11]
All right.
[1:04:12]
Number six, the watershed's nothing external affairs.
[1:04:18]
Yeah, just so that we're all in the same page in terms of the 30 days, I just want to make sure that we're expecting a publishing date of this item no later than 30 days from this date, hopefully for full presentation at the first meeting in October.
[1:04:39]
Thank you.
[1:04:45]
Okay.
[1:04:47]
External affairs, Adam 7.1, approve recommended positions on federal legislation, the top
[1:04:54]
position of supporting S1730 Harris.
[1:05:00]
A top of position, support an HR-323, and adopt the position of support on HR-855.
[1:05:09]
I know Rachel's here, but does anybody want to help?
[1:05:12]
I tried Rachel.
[1:05:13]
Emotion in the second. Thank you for the wonderful write-up.
[1:05:16]
Thank you for the write-up.
[1:05:17]
Thank you.
[1:05:20]
Emotion in the second. All those in favor?
[1:05:22]
All those opposed that motion carries.
[1:05:24]
And we're going to go back to item 4.1 because our Denise from tap is here.
[1:05:33]
So, good evening to the chair members of the Board, Senior Assistant District Council
[1:05:37]
Brian Hopper.
[1:05:39]
The Board's Independent Auditor, tap or national, has recommended that the Board Auditor
[1:05:43]
committee have a formal charter to guide its work.
[1:05:47]
And in the absence of a formal charter, different standards could be applied in different
[1:05:52]
cases, time could be lost, discussing what approaches to take, and there could be a loss of
[1:05:58]
public trust in the process and in any results.
[1:06:02]
Before you as attachment 1 to the board memo is a proposed board audit committee charter for
[1:06:09]
your review and approval if desired.
[1:06:11]
This was developed over the course of a number of meetings with the board audit committee
[1:06:16]
and the independent auditor, key elements of this proposed charter are listed in the board memo on pages 1 and 2, and I can go through those, I can walk through those if the board would like, but an interest of time I'll just jump ahead.
[1:06:33]
Well, this will guide the committee's work.
[1:06:36]
This is ultimately the Board's documents for the Board to approve and it's for the Board to change later on if it's subsequently dissatisfied with it.
[1:06:46]
A approval of a charter will help ensure that the Board Outer Committee is carrying out its functions and accordance with the Board's expectations and approval.
[1:06:57]
And at this point, I would invite Denise Callahan from Taper International to make any additional
[1:07:04]
comments she might wish to regarding best practices and the need for charter.
[1:07:13]
Good evening, Board Chair.
[1:07:14]
Vice Chair, Board Directors, Brian, you actually did a very good job.
[1:07:17]
I just want to highlight that the audit charter serves as key guiding principles for the
[1:07:23]
audit committee to help oversee the audit process and it eliminates any uncertainty by the
[1:07:29]
committee the board, the independent auditor, and district management in terms of how the audit process will be implemented.
[1:07:39]
Thank you. I can walk through the key elements, or I will stand prepared to answer any questions the board may have on the proposed document.
[1:07:46]
So we have a question for Director Krimant?
[1:07:48]
So, would Director Shwaya on the thing, it would be the audit committee, it's not a thing.
[1:07:57]
Director Keegan's not here, but I'd make a motion to approve this thing.
[1:08:03]
Motion.
[1:08:04]
Director Shwaya.
[1:08:08]
Thank you chair.
[1:08:10]
As Director Kremis said, I remember on the audit committee, we spent lots of times on the
[1:08:20]
the content of this charter, particularly related to the kind of authority this committee has.
[1:08:32]
One item that generated significant discussion at the committee level is item number eight.
[1:08:41]
that it says in addition to all that the BSC is given authority to conduct limited investigation
[1:08:49]
to address discrete issues.
[1:08:53]
So I will ask Brian to explain this one a little bit better to the whole board so that there
[1:09:03]
is say, come on understanding of what's because at the community level there's a lot of
[1:09:09]
discussion.
[1:09:09]
Yes, thank you, Director, and so this was requested by a majority of the committee and the full text of this section is found on page seven of the attachment.
[1:09:22]
It's an article five section five entitled limited investigations and this essentially holds that in lieu of a formal audit the committee would also have discretion to conduct or request.
[1:09:36]
Limited investigations to address discrete issues or concerns regarding very limited
[1:09:44]
universe of things, regarding concerns of fraud, waste, or violations of law or policy
[1:09:51]
at the district.
[1:09:53]
And one important distinction is that while the full board must approve the annual audit plan.
[1:10:00]
Which would include all the audits to be undertaken by the committee. The Board would not have the full board, but not have approval of the limited investigations. Those would be
[1:10:12]
President to a majority of the Board Audit Committee.
[1:10:16]
And so the proposed charter lays out the scope of what these limited investigations could
[1:10:21]
entail, and it includes a few safeguards, Denise, and maybe you wanted to address this
[1:10:28]
as well.
[1:10:29]
You would also recommend if this is perhaps a best management practice.
[1:10:33]
Just very briefly, what the limited investigation does, it allows the independent auditor
[1:10:38]
or to determine whether or not there's any merit to any potential issue related to fraud
[1:10:45]
or abuse.
[1:10:47]
And if there is merit, then the independent auditor would recommend to the audit committee
[1:10:51]
how to go forward, whether or not to outsource an independent investigator or do or outsource
[1:10:59]
to an external auditor to do a fraud audit.
[1:11:03]
And with that belaboring the point, I did just want to also highlight some of the safeguards
[1:11:08]
that we've attempted to incorporate in the language.
[1:11:11]
And this is under 5B scope.
[1:11:15]
And so this notes that the limited investigations,
[1:11:19]
they don't have to be subject to formal audit standards.
[1:11:23]
And they can only be undertaken
[1:11:24]
where their design number one to determine the existence
[1:11:29]
or non-existence of discrete facts involving
[1:11:33]
alleged fraud, waste, or violations of law or policy.
[1:11:37]
Number two, the committee has determined that an audit is not appropriate to address the concern.
[1:11:46]
And number three, the limited investigation does not address any matters covered or potentially covered by a board governance policy GP6.
[1:11:57]
And that's the board member's code of conduct.
[1:11:59]
So, in effect, the board audit committee would not have the right to conduct a limited
[1:12:03]
investigation of a fellow board member for matters that would be under the jurisdiction
[1:12:10]
of GP6.
[1:12:11]
And I don't know, Director Schwer, if you wanted to, or Director Kremlin, if you wanted to expand
[1:12:16]
on this concept.
[1:12:27]
I did have a question.
[1:12:29]
I think Denise said that this would be initiated initially by some sort of,
[1:12:38]
finding or or or indication from the independent auditor.
[1:12:43]
It can be initiated through various sources for example staff may raise
[1:12:47]
concerns. That's what I want to say.
[1:12:48]
They go to you with the potential concern, but you're not so sure about it.
[1:12:52]
So we will undertake a quick review to determine whether or not there's any merit behind the
[1:12:57]
allegation. Okay. That's that's what I want to make sure was there as well.
[1:13:02]
Okay. All right.
[1:13:04]
This is up for approval.
[1:13:09]
We have a motion.
[1:13:14]
We have a motion in the second.
[1:13:16]
All those in favor?
[1:13:17]
All those opposed?
[1:13:19]
That motion carries unanimously.
[1:13:21]
Thank you.
[1:13:22]
Brian Denise.
[1:13:23]
Thank you.
[1:13:25]
All right.
[1:13:34]
All right.
[1:13:35]
So we're now on to Chief Executive Officer,
[1:13:37]
8.1, approve it.
[1:13:38]
One time compensation adjustment to the Santa Clara Valley
[1:13:40]
Board District temporary workforce in fiscal year 2020
[1:13:44]
allow a change of authority from the Chief Administrative Office to the Chief Executive Office for Future Fiscal Year, compensation adjustments at Valley Warders Temporary Workforce.
[1:13:55]
Two recommendations.
[1:13:57]
Oh, Michael.
[1:13:58]
Chair was that board members, Michael Barrett's Labor Relations Officers.
[1:14:02]
So this is a recommendation that the Board to set, consider setting the hourly compensation of the Temporary Employees equal to the hourly compensation.
[1:14:14]
of regular employees in the classifications that in the same classifications that the temporary
[1:14:21]
workers are working in. The second part of this recommendation is to change the authority
[1:14:28]
from the chief administrative officer, which is a position that no longer exists, to the chief
[1:14:34]
executive officer for future fiscal year compensation adjustments. As part of the budget cycle,
[1:14:43]
We value water relies on temporary workers to carry out a lot of our mission, and it's
[1:14:50]
becoming increasingly difficult to attract and retain qualified temporary workers due
[1:14:56]
to the current salary structure.
[1:15:00]
As well as what's going on in the community with unemployment being so low.
[1:15:07]
So all of our temporary staffing agencies, our three staffing agencies have reported to us that the workforce wages are significantly below market rate.
[1:15:21]
And it's continuing to impact our efforts to secure an important segment of our workforce.
[1:15:29]
temporary workers are, so again, we utilize the same classifications for the regular classified
[1:15:37]
staff, as we do for the temporary workers, the regular workers are represented by the three
[1:15:45]
unions, you know, in the district of the two unions in the district, three bargaining units.
[1:15:50]
And the temporary workers are not, and so the temporary workers are not entitled to compensation
[1:15:57]
adjustments that are negotiated by the bargaining units.
[1:16:03]
So in accordance with the current work instruction, salary tables are adjusted.
[1:16:10]
The last adjustment was dated, I'm sorry, the work instruction was less changed, amended
[1:16:22]
in 2011 and in fact in the past CAAOs have approved increases but the last one was in 2008 was
[1:16:33]
the last increase when salaries were adjusted. In that time, what has resulted is a
[1:16:41]
discrepancy between what we pay a temporary worker and a regular worker in the same class
[1:16:46]
is 38.5% difference.
[1:16:50]
So just to have a table there that shows you the difference
[1:16:55]
where a associate engineer currently the temp workers,
[1:17:01]
making $41.22, the regular valley worker employees,
[1:17:06]
making $57.9.
[1:17:09]
So that's the 38.5% difference.
[1:17:12]
We've surveyed our 12 comparator agencies received 10 responses, 90 percent of those, do use the same scale for their temporary workers as their regular workers are being paid.
[1:17:28]
So the cost here would equate to about $2.2 million in fiscal year 2020.
[1:17:36]
We believe that in terms of the financial impact that while we have a budget of six million dollars for temporary workers in fiscal year 2020, it's believed that we don't usually expend the full budget and that this could be, you know,
[1:18:07]
to change the, you know, to increase as one time, at this point, adjustment for temporary
[1:18:13]
work is to be paid the same as this equivalent classification and the regular workforce
[1:18:20]
and to grant the chief executive office of the authority to consider and approve compensation
[1:18:26]
adjustments to valley water's temporary workforce as part of the budget cycle in the future.
[1:18:34]
Thank you, Michael.
[1:18:35]
Do I trust Mayor, did you want to say something?
[1:18:37]
It's thank you, Mayor Chair.
[1:18:39]
I just recently reviewed a book,
[1:18:42]
read a book about the 100-year life,
[1:18:44]
which I think is gonna be normal now in our society.
[1:18:49]
And so we have to find a way of bringing back retired employees,
[1:18:54]
not just from our organization, but in the county,
[1:18:59]
or at least in our state.
[1:19:02]
It's a two-way road, you know,
[1:19:03]
we need to be fair with people that work for us as we did before with the janitors and as we
[1:19:08]
do with our workforce but also you know for our own benefit as an organization to be able to bring
[1:19:16]
back people who have tremendous experience whether they obtained it here or elsewhere we made a lot
[1:19:23]
of investments in people and were able to get that return back for the community but we have to be fair
[1:19:29]
and we have to be able to attract people to do that.
[1:19:32]
So I think there's a good policy and the change is good
[1:19:36]
so that we can have our CEO be attendant
[1:19:38]
to make sure that we're being fair with these folks
[1:19:42]
that we attract them and that we treat them fairly.
[1:19:46]
So I think it's a good change.
[1:19:47]
And I'd move that we adopt that policy.
[1:19:51]
So motion, a second, a direct issue.
[1:19:54]
Thank you, thank you, Chair.
[1:19:55]
Yeah, I definitely support staff's recommendations.
[1:20:00]
Foundation, and this is just the right thing to do. I don't know how it's just going on for so many years.
[1:20:10]
Anyway, and I just wanted to have a clarification on recommendation B for future fiscal year, allow a change of authority from Chief CAO to CEO for future fiscal year compensation adjustments.
[1:20:24]
I want clarification from staff that this compensation adjustments, meaning that the
[1:20:34]
10-per-employee doing exactly the same job, have exactly the same classification, will
[1:20:39]
have the same compensation as the regular employee for the district.
[1:20:45]
That's what this recommendation be, means, it's not just changing authority from you.
[1:20:50]
And then, five years later, we're going to have a discrepancy of whatever percentage that we haven't adjusted for these temperament.
[1:21:02]
Yes.
[1:21:03]
Through the chair, that is the intent.
[1:21:05]
And to actually bring this back when we bring the salary adjustments on an annual basis,
[1:21:10]
that we also add the temporary temperal adjustments as well too.
[1:21:15]
Thank you.
[1:21:17]
All
[1:21:20]
right.
[1:21:21]
We have a motion in a second to approve A and B of this
[1:21:29]
compensation for temporary workforce.
[1:21:31]
Can't believe it was 30 to what you think? 32% different to 38.
[1:21:38]
That's a head shaker. All those in favor. All those opposed that motion carries unanimously.
[1:21:45]
Thank you, Michael. Okay, 2.8.2. Approved the central budget adjustment for fiscal year 2019, 2020,
[1:21:53]
to have a motion, a motion the second to approve the central budget adjustments for physical
[1:21:59]
year 2019 2020. Great report, Darren, all those in favor, all those opposed.
[1:22:08]
Is that a resolution
[1:22:10]
do we need to? No, it's just approving the budget. So all those in favor, all those opposed
[1:22:16]
that motion carries unanimously. All right. 8.3 CEO and chief reports. We do have a number
[1:22:23]
of chief reports, and so we'll start off with Chief Hock.
[1:22:26]
Good evening, Chair and Board of Directors.
[1:22:28]
We do have the draft EIS, EIR for the San Luis Low Point Improvement Project, so the U.S.
[1:22:34]
Bureau of Reclamation held public meetings on August 12th and Gilroy in August 16th in Sacramento
[1:22:40]
regarding the release of the draft EIR and EIS for the San Luis Low Point Improvement
[1:22:44]
Project.
[1:22:45]
This has been a long-standing EIR and feasibility study for over a decade.
[1:22:49]
We have worked through an MOU with the Bureau to get to this point, so it's a pretty big milestone.
[1:22:55]
So Valley Water Staff was present at both the public meetings to provide support to
[1:22:58]
Reclamation as it's being led by the Bureau.
[1:23:01]
And in answer any questions regarding Facheco Expansion of Reservoir Project,
[1:23:05]
which is the National Economic Development Alternative or the Preferred Alternative in the low point feasibility study, which is great news.
[1:23:13]
The public comment period for the draft DISER will remain open until September 24th,
[1:23:17]
forth, 2019, at which it will close and will proceed forward with the feasibility study and work
[1:23:23]
with the Bureau. So, great. Miles Stone's happening there in the public. Next, I'd like to invite
[1:23:28]
Mr. Erin Baker up to the Dias. So, effective Monday, September 9th, Erin Baker will be Deputy
[1:23:36]
Operating Officer of Raw Water Division, formerly known as Raw Water and Operations and Maintenance
[1:23:40]
Division. Erin has over 20 plus years of public agency engineering and leadership work experience
[1:23:47]
in water treatment, water supply, and flood protection.
[1:23:51]
In his capacity as DOO of raw water division, Aaron will oversee treatment plant maintenance,
[1:23:56]
raw water operations, raw water field operations, and pipeline maintenance and utility
[1:24:00]
maintenance engineering. He will have approximately 75 FTEs. He is well-suited to take on the
[1:24:06]
challenge of forthcoming in the utility, and I look forward to his tenure ship and then the
[1:24:17]
Thank you.
[1:24:18]
What you're up to, you have to say a few words.
[1:24:25]
Sure.
[1:24:26]
Honourable Board of Directors, thank you so much for the opportunity.
[1:24:30]
I am excited to take on the challenges of raw water operations, and I promise to efficiently
[1:24:37]
deliver the raw water for the county.
[1:24:40]
Perfect.
[1:24:40]
Thank you.
[1:24:41]
Thank you.
[1:24:42]
We know you'll do a good job in congratulations.
[1:24:45]
Right.
[1:24:46]
Now we, yes, we have a couple more reports from Chief Richardson on the status of our SNP.
[1:24:55]
Good evening, members of the board chair, Lizot.
[1:24:57]
I believe before you, you do have the latest stream maintenance.
[1:25:00]
Report that's dated August 10th through August 23rd. Once again, this is just a highlight of the ongoing activity that we're doing this summer.
[1:25:08]
Set a removal bank protection, in-stream habitat improvements, et cetera. Just a couple notable items.
[1:25:15]
One, we just recently completed the in-stream habitat complexity project on Las Gatos Creek on August 16th.
[1:25:22]
that's an environmental project that we put in there for the purposes of
[1:25:26]
fisheries. So that's I think a big milestone for us of completing that
[1:25:31]
project. And then I think I mentioned this briefly before, but some of our
[1:25:36]
significant set-able sediment removal activities, which are beginning soon, and
[1:25:42]
have just begun our showing test results for many of the sites indicating that
[1:25:47]
sediment will need to be disposed of at landfills instead of being delivered
[1:25:51]
upon A8. And so just to heads up that disposal costs are expected to be higher than usual.
[1:25:58]
And I think as Chief Yoke will be reporting, we've had to take some extra safety precautions
[1:26:03]
for some of our staff due to some of the constituents of concern in the soils. And that's
[1:26:08]
it for me. Thank you.
[1:26:14]
Thank you.
[1:26:14]
Is there more mercury in Pont A8 or of the other ponds of Pont 4? In all these areas, was there
[1:26:22]
more or less with them to remove the sentiment?
[1:26:25]
Well, the cons are the channels that we're currently
[1:26:29]
excavating for.
[1:26:31]
We're finding elevated levels of arsenic or nickel and PCBs
[1:26:37]
that those types of constituents and they're higher
[1:26:40]
than we're allowed to place in on date.
[1:26:43]
So we're having to haul those to landfills.
[1:26:50]
So with that, we'll go to Chief Yoke's report in regards
[1:26:53]
to some of the findings and the protective measures that are being taken.
[1:26:59]
I'm going to briefly recap some information that I will sent through Board Communications
[1:27:04]
and then provide to current status.
[1:27:07]
So to recap in preparation for several settlement removal projects at Sunnyvale East, Steven's
[1:27:12]
Greek accredited in and Guadalupe River, Trimble to Monogue Expressway locations, Valley
[1:27:18]
Water staff, collected soil samples and found some of the constituent levels were high.
[1:27:23]
enough to be of the potential concern in terms of worker exposure.
[1:27:29]
So our health and safety unit developed safety plans for worker protection and the crews
[1:27:35]
were trained and fitted with the appropriate personal protective equipment.
[1:27:41]
They that unit immediately started conducting ear monitoring and to ensure that there are no
[1:27:47]
concentrations in the air that would be of concern for both our workers as well as the public.
[1:27:52]
And, after a couple days now, of air sample results that came back, thus far, they have
[1:28:00]
indicated no airborne levels of concern for hazardous contaminants with low levels of visible
[1:28:06]
dusting observed.
[1:28:09]
Crease are deploying the best management practices when required to minimize the dust levels
[1:28:16]
and where personal protective equipment only when they're in direct contact with the contaminated soil.
[1:28:27]
And with that that concludes my report.
[1:28:30]
Thank you.
[1:28:32]
Okay, thank you very much.
[1:28:33]
And then we also have Chief Calendar reporting out on government relations.
[1:28:37]
All right.
[1:28:38]
So, actually I'll be reporting on external affairs with government relations, civic engagement and communications.
[1:28:43]
you do have a one-pager for government relations just want to highlight a few activities. Yesterday, AB 707,
[1:28:51]
Valley Water Sponsored Bill, increasing our contracting threshold from 25,000 to 50,000 did
[1:28:57]
move off the assembly floor with the unanimous vote. So it is on on this way to the governor's desk.
[1:29:03]
We've actively working with partners and stakeholders in the community to continue to support
[1:29:07]
that with the governor. So hopefully we will be able to obtain a signature, we'll continue to
[1:29:11]
be surprised as it moves forward and then on the back of the one page are just highlighting
[1:29:16]
that there have been quite a few activities and engagement efforts in the community but
[1:29:21]
just want to highlight. My favorite one of the three, not the other two, we're not important,
[1:29:26]
but we did have the decently giant scheme. All three offices were supporting the giant scheme in
[1:29:30]
different aspects. A couple of relations did have the booth that was out there visited by
[1:29:34]
thousands of folks that were at the, at the game. But in the right top hand corner, you do see
[1:29:40]
chair Lizette moving towards her first pitch which they cross the base quite successfully
[1:29:46]
look like a slider probably one of the best pitches of the night.
[1:29:53]
So and then as usual you do have to status the bills that you have taken positions on.
[1:30:00]
Moving on to the office of civic engagement, we do have the Yagis Creek groundbreaking tomorrow at Morgan Hills, so I know we will be joined by Director Vorella, as well as Congressman Lofgren.
[1:30:13]
Just this afternoon, there was an extra meeting add on, with Congressman Lofgren, which as soon as the groundbreaking is over, she's going to spend a little bit of time just to get updated on Anderson Dam and the status of Anderson Dam, so I know that the CEO, as well as Director Velas, while supporting staff will be there to provide support.
[1:30:29]
support on that meeting, so we will let you know if anything comes out of it, but it's
[1:30:33]
just going to be the ongoing efforts to make sure that she's appraised of the status
[1:30:39]
of Anderson Damage, where she has sent several letters, asking about the status of this
[1:30:44]
will be just kind of a continued touching and making sure she's kept in touch.
[1:30:50]
On the communications role, just for the office of communications, a few things, the office
[1:30:54]
of the government relations, office of civic engagement, or hosting a VIP tour actually for civic
[1:30:59]
engagement or hosting a VIP tour at the Pierification Center for Council Member Chappy Jones.
[1:31:05]
This Thursday, Council Member Jones is right now considering how he wants to basically be able
[1:31:10]
to take the lead potentially for the city of San Jose and being the lead on the recycled water
[1:31:14]
voice. So he's just exploring things. This is a tour that will be taking place with you.
[1:31:19]
He's never been on a tour there, so it was kind of the first step in moving. Well, first or second
[1:31:23]
step in moving forward to securing support.
[1:31:26]
Also, in Saturday at 31st, the Recycle Water Outreach team
[1:31:30]
will be running with two prime-themed tours
[1:31:33]
for the LGBT community.
[1:31:35]
So I'll be the first time I've done something like that.
[1:31:37]
That will be out at the plant this weekend.
[1:31:41]
And also, we have the new FY20 Grant cycles,
[1:31:44]
which are opening up for A2, which
[1:31:47]
is our water conservation grants, B3, the pollution prevention
[1:31:51]
grants and D3 the wildlife habitation grants. Those will also be opening this Friday so we'll
[1:31:57]
make sure that we provide information for a new as normal going up to the community through
[1:32:01]
next one other mechanisms so you can communicate with your constituents and that is all I have
[1:32:06]
unless there's any questions in anything I've reported.
[1:32:10]
You'll be there to welcome Chabby Jones.
[1:32:12]
Thank you. We'll make sure that we get to know. Director Barrel. Thank you.
[1:32:21]
So,
[1:32:21]
that we talked about. The NRCS grants are you talking is relates to the
[1:32:26]
Yagus or is it relates to the possible fire, yes, all of the above. Yes, so in
[1:32:34]
term, as for Yagus we're continuing to work on that we actually is submitting something
[1:32:39]
that least be for the phase one portion. For Yagus we're still exploring phase two.
[1:32:44]
Our hope is that we can maximize the dollars for Yagus we are going to try to move
[1:32:51]
as much as we possibly can in our CS will be the ones that identify how much we'll be able to obtain once we provide the information on the grant.
[1:32:59]
So it's not a direct request that we make from them, but they will identify, yes, you're eligible to receive dollars for these efforts.
[1:33:06]
So it's still in the middle of that.
[1:33:07]
As it relates to the fire protection, it does not appear that we will be able to use utilizing our CS for any funding for the fire protections in the areas that they have previously
[1:33:20]
previously, and then so in the 60s and 70s, we've explored that that's basically a closed
[1:33:26]
door.
[1:33:26]
We were looking at grants through other mechanisms, including through cow fire.
[1:33:31]
It appears that cow fire is said that they're unwilling to pay for assessments of areas
[1:33:38]
to assessments of areas in the Yagas watershed to determine which areas that they would want
[1:33:47]
I guess it'd be back for fire protection.
[1:33:50]
However, we're still looking to see if there's other grants that would be able to pay for
[1:33:55]
a Cal Fire to do that.
[1:33:56]
So, what's the grants available from the State of California available?
[1:33:59]
Well, the California...
[1:34:00]
Since the governor's pushing so much for fire suppression fire prevention, that there would
[1:34:04]
so appear to be that there'd be some grants or dollars available for the State.
[1:34:08]
So, well, the Cal Fire grants are through the State.
[1:34:11]
So, Cal Fire had initially indicated that those grants may be available through Cal Fire, but
[1:34:16]
we went to the state who makes the grancing,
[1:34:18]
who provides the grance, they said,
[1:34:21]
no, you're not eligible to utilize this grant
[1:34:23]
in order to do assessments of the areas that need to be done.
[1:34:26]
So we reached back out to the local counselors
[1:34:29]
and said, wait, you said that we'd be able to do this.
[1:34:32]
We haven't closed that door completely,
[1:34:34]
but I do believe that it's fairly close.
[1:34:37]
Thank you.
[1:34:40]
And that concludes our reports for today.
[1:34:42]
Thank you.
[1:34:43]
I want to take this opportunity to thank everyone involved
[1:34:47]
with the wonderful night at the San Jose Giants.
[1:34:49]
I mean, I think we had over 600 people
[1:34:52]
between staff and employees and in volunteers.
[1:34:57]
I particularly wanted to thank Matt Kellogg McKanford.
[1:35:00]
The two videos that we produced, the CEO and myself, one was for the employees here, and one was actually shown at the game, even though the giants didn't quite get the volume right until the very end, but it was still shown, it was still shown.
[1:35:14]
And just the staff who staffed the booths had a lot of good reports from people who attended the Rick, your entire team who was there, so it's just a big hearty thank you for me for a job well done.
[1:35:28]
It was a lot of fun for me personally, but it looked like everybody who attended was having
[1:35:32]
its horrific time as well, and I think that goes to the work that everybody did to make
[1:35:37]
that happen.
[1:35:38]
So again, thank you.
[1:35:40]
Okay, district council,
[1:35:44]
a board member reports and announcements.
[1:35:47]
I think proposed a future board member agenda items.
[1:35:50]
I think we had one by Director Kremlin that we had, Director Santos also, there's something
[1:35:57]
Let's see.
[1:35:59]
No, Gary first.
[1:36:00]
No, Gary's already said it.
[1:36:02]
We talked about a maybe as coming up with our security.
[1:36:07]
We're going to do it next month.
[1:36:10]
We're coming up later on.
[1:36:13]
We're talking about the actual security of our plans
[1:36:15]
and at this building in different properties.
[1:36:20]
I will work with District Council to schedule a closed session.
[1:36:24]
We did just recently get our completed security assessment back
[1:36:28]
for my report, that's more consultant.
[1:36:34]
Good, good, great, great.
[1:36:35]
With director Santos, you know, I think given the events
[1:36:40]
that we've seen in South County and other places,
[1:36:43]
I think we have an urgency to that.
[1:36:46]
So I mean, scheduled with in a reasonable,
[1:36:50]
you know, period of time.
[1:36:52]
Close session on that.
[1:36:57]
Clerk, review and clarification of board requests.
[1:37:03]
Okay, in addition to that, I'm there coming back, which are not requests, but I'm coming
[1:37:08]
items on the agenda.
[1:37:10]
The BMR that I have is that staff is coordinating that mock active shooter exercise replicating
[1:37:15]
an active shooter at a board meeting scenario and investigating on-site search training.
[1:37:24]
I think that was it.
[1:37:26]
Anything else?
[1:37:27]
Do you want to hear back the coming back on the future agenda?
[1:37:31]
Yeah.
[1:37:32]
Sure, one, two.
[1:37:33]
Okay.
[1:37:33]
what I have is that staff is to agenda is for discussion on the agreement between the district and
[1:37:38]
somebody to county. As was discussed at today's water storage
[1:37:42]
exploratory committee, it was director Kremlin's request.
[1:37:46]
5.1 continuing to October 10th.
[1:37:48]
It was my request who is actually a recommendation of our committee to be more formal that to put it on the agenda.
[1:37:57]
Yeah.
[1:37:59]
At five point one is continuing and then the closed question discussion on facility security.
[1:38:05]
All right.
[1:38:06]
Thank you.
[1:38:08]
All right.
[1:38:08]
So we're at the end of the meeting.
[1:38:10]
If I may, I'd like to adjourn this meeting.
[1:38:14]
This earlier we had a resolution for women's equality day and a very dear friend of mine passed away.
[1:38:20]
She was a city attorney, she was the town attorney for the City Town of Las Gattas.
[1:38:27]
She was a Superior Court judge, Mary Joe Levenger, was a mentor and adventurous friend
[1:38:36]
to everyone, but particularly she worked very, very hard for women's rights and making
[1:38:43]
sure that women had an opportunity.
[1:38:46]
She made sure that the women that she came in contact with worked at their highest level by
[1:38:54]
encouragement.
[1:38:55]
And so she passed away on Thursday after a brave battle with cancer.
[1:39:01]
So I'd like to adjourn this meeting in her honor.
[1:39:04]
And we are adjourned to September 10th at 1pm.
[1:39:07]
Thank you.