Agenda
Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[0:00]
Good morning, everybody. Welcome to Board of
[0:05]
Lords.
[0:07]
We're just a Board of Directors agenda for November 14th.
[0:13]
We have co-session items that we will adjourn shortly too.
[0:18]
Look at the Board, would you please take roll.
[0:21]
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Director Bell.
[0:24]
Director Eisenberg. Director Estimera. Director Shua.
[0:29]
Dr. Keegan, Director Santos, Chair Varella.
[0:33]
We have a core present.
[0:35]
Thank you.
[0:37]
Notice that the public, the Board of Directors,
[0:39]
meets in close session in accordance with the
[0:40]
wealthy and Brown Act, following the conclusion of
[0:43]
close session discussion.
[0:44]
The Board will return the remaining items on the
[0:47]
agenda.
[0:48]
We have items 2.1, 2, 3, and 4, and 2.5.
[0:53]
And we will return at 1 PM.
[0:57]
And if there any comments from the Board members at this point, okay, we are adjourned to close session at this time.
[1:22]
Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen.
[1:25]
Welcome to the Valley Waters Board of Directors.
[1:27]
Meet in November 14.
[1:29]
The Board is now coming out of close session.
[1:33]
We have any reportable.
[1:34]
I'll come to the Council.
[1:37]
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
[1:38]
Carlos Sadean at District Council.
[1:39]
With respect to items 2.1, 2.2, 2.3 and 2.4.
[1:43]
Board of Met and Close Session, which was expected to item 2.1, there was no reportable action,
[1:48]
which was expected to item 2.2 and 2.3. Direction was given to staff, and for 2.4
[1:54]
I'll turn it back to you, Mr. Chair.
[1:56]
Thank you. Close Session, discussion on public performance of graduations, proceeding today's
[2:02]
evaluation of the CEO. The calendar will commence with the legal council and for the board
[2:09]
in the next few weeks ahead, time for meeting.
[2:13]
We will do that.
[2:14]
So time-surtine, I'm moving forward.
[2:17]
Pleasure Collegions.
[2:22]
Pleasure
[2:26]
Collegions.
[2:27]
Pleasure Collegions.
[2:28]
You can apply the universities of America
[2:29]
and to the public or those stands or nation
[2:33]
under God in this world with third,
[2:36]
and justice for all.
[2:43]
I'm sure many of you participated in many of the veterans
[2:46]
today's activities throughout the county this past weekend. And I think I did the pledge
[2:52]
at least half a dozen times over this past weekend. I'm sure you all did as well. So this
[2:57]
great land of ours is protected by our veterans. Then, and today, as we are experiencing turmoil
[3:03]
throughout our world. So, orders of the day, time open for public discussion, and any item that
[3:09]
we currently is not on today's agenda. Look at the board. Do we have anybody that wishes to address
[3:14]
support at this time?
[3:18]
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have no request at this time.
[3:22]
Very good. First item the agenda. Item 3.4 conduct a public hearing to consider adopting
[3:28]
a resolution of necessity relating to acquisition of real property interest from Michael A. Doer.
[3:35]
Hope I'm pronouncing that correctly. This necessary to complete the Coyote Creek Flood Management
[3:39]
measures project, project number 918-6407, APN number 472-31-041, real estate file numbers
[3:50]
4021-320 and 4021-406 in the San Jose District 2 area. There's an action recommended on this,
[3:59]
do we have a report on this?
[4:06]
Yeah. Good afternoon chair. Board members.
[4:09]
Would you like to speak now?
[4:10]
But why need is going to be?
[4:11]
Okay, sir.
[4:11]
I'm sorry.
[4:14]
Thank you, Chair.
[4:15]
Okay, let's go.
[4:17]
Okay.
[4:25]
I'm sorry.
[4:26]
We have a support report on this.
[4:27]
My apologies.
[4:29]
Okay.
[4:29]
So welcome.
[4:30]
Good afternoon.
[4:30]
I'm John Browl.
[4:31]
The Chair of the Valley Water Board of Directors.
[4:33]
Public hearing today is going to be the consideration of what I mentioned earlier.
[4:37]
Michael Dauer.
[4:37]
We completed the COVID-19 Creek.
[4:40]
The provide the order of business.
[4:42]
The hearing would be conducted as follows.
[4:44]
First, the board will hear the Valley Water staff providing facts that will support.
[4:47]
The findings, set forth in the resolution of necessity, the information provided staff will be
[4:52]
commemorated into and will be part of an information, the deliberations for this hearing
[4:57]
number two.
[4:58]
After the presentation.
[5:00]
The property owners will have an opportunity to address the board regarding the findings, set forth in the resolution and necessity, then the board will commence the hearing.
[5:09]
Item 3, the hearing is the time for public comment. I will call speakers in the order of speakers request where we see. Each speaker shall have three minutes to address the board regarding the matter.
[5:21]
Item 4, after public comments are received and the property owners have been afforded the opportunity to address any outstanding points made during the public comment.
[5:31]
The Board will close the public hearing item 5.
[5:34]
The Board may discuss the findings supporting the adoption of the Resolution of
[5:37]
the necessity and may direct questions to valley water staff and the property owners.
[5:43]
The item 6, finally, the Board will make a decision on whether or not to adopt the
[5:49]
Resolution of the necessity approval of this Resolution requires a 2, 3, 5 out of 7.
[5:55]
Provide speaker instruction.
[5:56]
Anyone wishing to address the Board on this particular item, please present a speaker
[5:59]
card to the clerk of the board, and speakers will be a lot of three minutes, only one speaking
[6:04]
opportunity per person, and they will be presented to the chair for the wish.
[6:09]
Valley Wetter will now open and conduct a hearing for agenda number 3.4, the proposed acquisition
[6:15]
by eminent domain, a property located at 650-650-650-163, APN number as identified 472-3104,
[6:25]
one by Michael Dowret.
[6:28]
I invite Vanieru to work through Deputy Operator Officer Watershier's design and construction
[6:34]
to commence the presentation for the Dowret property.
[6:38]
Vanier?
[6:41]
Thank you, Chair.
[6:43]
I'm going to be asking for a Maudu Tomaluru Unit Manager to help me with this presentation.
[6:49]
So I, I'm glad to have the new chair and members of the board.
[6:52]
My name is Vanieru.
[6:53]
through deputy operating officer for water sheds, sitting in for crusades, chief operating officer
[6:58]
here. In the polling slides, I'll be providing information to suppose the findings set forth
[7:02]
in the resolution of necessity for the subject property for the coyote creek flood management measures
[7:07]
project. The findings to me made at this resolution of necessity hearing would be first to establish
[7:14]
the public need for the project and then to establish that the project is designed and a manner
[7:19]
that is most compatible with the greatest public good with the least private injury.
[7:23]
Then to determine that the property is necessary for the project,
[7:27]
and lastly to establish that the offer made to the property owners was in accordance with section
[7:32]
7267.2 of the government code. Next slide please.
[7:38]
For the first finding, the public's necessity of the proposed project.
[7:42]
The project is needed to predict the property,
[7:45]
salam-hiyodecrete between Oakland Road and Old Oakland Road in Interstate 280, again floods up to the level of the 20-year flood event.
[7:54]
The other benefits of the project include habitat enhancement and reduction in long-term maintenance.
[8:00]
Next slide please.
[8:02]
On this map you can see the extent of the Khiyodecrete flood management measures project.
[8:07]
This project is part of a larger Khiyodecrete flood protection project, and in accordance with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's
[8:15]
the project was divided into two phases for implementation. The first part of which is the
[8:20]
Kaoli flag management measure project which is currently under construction and the property
[8:25]
that we are discussing today is in reach 7 of this project. Next, thank you.
[8:32]
The project is designed. The project's design is constrained by the geography of the clay.
[8:36]
The vast majority of the clay flows through private property and the private properties located
[8:40]
on both sides of the tree.
[8:44]
The project design serves the greatest public
[8:46]
geared with the least private injury.
[8:49]
We make this finding through a holistic approach to the project design, and to the
[8:54]
extent practicable with the avoidance of private structures to determine the best way possible
[8:59]
to prevent flooding while reducing erosion and reducing the long-term maintenance need.
[9:04]
The design is also intended to preserve habitat in aligned project features within the
[9:09]
existing Greek alignment.
[9:12]
The other project benefits include the ability to remove large legacy trash in debris, preserving
[9:18]
the natural Greek footprint into increased native vegetation as well as to improve the maintenance
[9:23]
access.
[9:25]
With regards to SQL compliance, as I mentioned previously, the project is part of the Federal
[9:30]
Energy Regulatory Commission Order of Compliance Projects and was determined to be exempt
[9:34]
from secret review procedure into the statutory exemptions per Seqa guidelines 15, 20, 20, 15, 269C.
[9:45]
The property acquisitions are necessary for the project. The project required an acquisition of about 33 properties and reaches 5, 6 and 7.
[9:53]
The resolution of necessity due to the impasse is the proposed for this property.
[10:00]
Please in reach seven owned by Michelle Dewar.
[10:04]
The Dewar's property is necessary for the project. The
[10:07]
progress is necessary because the applied wall and the access path to construct and the maintained
[10:12]
the flood wall are on the portion of this private property. The construction activities also require
[10:17]
that a separate portion of the property be temporarily accessible to construct the flood wall itself.
[10:24]
Once the construction is complete, the property will be returned to its intended state.
[10:30]
The Doer property location is where it's shown on this map at the Dred Arrow.
[10:36]
It's in REET 7 and it's adjacent to the William Street Park close to William Street,
[10:43]
William Street intersection with the Kairi Creek.
[10:47]
The next slide shows an area of the property itself.
[10:50]
The purple lines indicates the limits of the property and the red line is where the proposed flood wall
[10:57]
is going to be staff at work extensively with the property owners
[11:01]
to design the flood wall to so as to minimize impacts to the property.
[11:06]
And then just to orient everybody,
[11:07]
the William Street Park is just to the north of the property
[11:10]
and priority creek to the east.
[11:13]
The green areas, can we go back to one?
[11:17]
The green areas are the areas for the permanent easement,
[11:20]
going all the way to the center of the creek,
[11:22]
and then the yellow areas are just for the temporary construction
[11:24]
that's required to construct the property in access.
[11:28]
Next problem.
[11:31]
A little more information about the door property, the flood wall alignment is toward the back or the eastern side of the property and the area acquired is on the both sides of the wall.
[11:40]
The flood wall will be tying into an existing wall that runs along the knock end of the property after the wall is constructed.
[11:46]
The area will be returned to its existing use as a backyard for the property owner.
[11:51]
Government Section 7267.2 requires that an offer be made to the property owner, which was
[11:56]
no less than the fair market value, established by an approved appraisal, and such an offer
[12:01]
was made to the property owner on August the year 2023.
[12:07]
This is just an abrish version of all of the interactions and back and forth the staff
[12:11]
have had with the property owner, as you can see this has been an ongoing negotiation for
[12:16]
over a year since July 15, 2022.
[12:20]
Finally, this completes staff's presentation, and we are seeking both requesting board
[12:27]
receipts from property owner, our public, and then staff is ready to answer any questions.
[12:32]
Thank you, Chair.
[12:33]
Thank you.
[12:34]
Do you appreciate that?
[12:35]
Do we have members of the family that wish to present to the board or their representatives
[12:42]
at this time?
[12:44]
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
[12:45]
I have not received any communication that we have anybody in the board room or via
[12:52]
So there's no one here to speak on behalf on this agenda item for this family, okay?
[12:59]
So now we have open for the public comments that we have any members of the public that wish to address the board on this item.
[13:05]
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have no request at this time.
[13:08]
Okay.
[13:10]
So we have no public speakers.
[13:12]
We're going to, at this point then, we're going to close the public hearing.
[13:15]
I've been heard staff's presentation comments from the property owners which we didn't.
[13:19]
and comments from all interested members of the public, which we haven't.
[13:22]
The board will now close the public hearing for consideration of board discussions and motion.
[13:27]
Board discussion or motion?
[13:29]
Or do we have a board discussion on this?
[13:34]
Do we have a motion to approve?
[13:36]
I'll make a motion.
[13:37]
Okay.
[13:38]
Have a motion.
[13:39]
And a second.
[13:41]
Any deliberation?
[13:42]
Any comment from the board members at all?
[13:45]
Okay.
[13:46]
This is a roll call vote.
[13:47]
We're soon to the California Code of Civil Procedure Section 1245.260 and 1250.100.
[13:53]
Valleywater has six months to commence an imminent domain action by filing a complaint.
[13:58]
This concludes this agenda item. This is a roll call vote.
[14:04]
Director Val. Director Eisenberg. Hi. Director Estimera.
[14:09]
Director Shua. Yes. Director Keegan. Director Santos. Chair Borough.
[14:14]
Yes, and that passes unanimously by board vote, so that closes the discussion on item 3.5.
[14:25]
Moving to item 3.4, excuse me.
[14:28]
Moving to item 3.5.
[14:31]
This is again, this is a public hearing to consider the adoption of resolutions of necessity,
[14:37]
relating to acquisition of real property interest from Fred Wey and Susan Brenner,
[14:41]
to complete the COD Creek flood management measures project is not open.
[14:46]
Provide order of business.
[14:48]
The hearing will be conducted as follows.
[14:50]
First, the board will hear from the Valley Water staff providing facts that will support the
[14:53]
Finding Support for the resolution of necessity.
[14:57]
The information provided by staff will be incorporated into.
[15:00]
And we'll be part of and inform our deliberations for this hearing. Item 2, after the presentation, the property owners will have an opportunity to address the board, reading the findings at 4th and resolutions necessity, then the board will commence the hearing.
[15:16]
Item 3, the hearing is the time for public comment. I will call speakers in the order of speaker request received. Each speaker shall have three minutes to address the board at the starting matter.
[15:26]
At him four, after public comments are received and the property owners have been afforded an opportunity to address any outstanding points.
[15:33]
May during the public comment period, the board will close the public hearing at him five.
[15:38]
The board may discuss the finding and supporting the adoption of the resolution and necessity and may direct question to value water staff and property owners.
[15:45]
At him six, finally, the board will make a net decision on whether or not to adjourn the resolution and necessity, excuse me, whether or not to adopt the resolution and necessity.
[15:54]
approval of this
[15:59]
resolution requires a two-thirds vote. Sorry about that, folks.
[16:04]
Okay, provide speaker instruction, anyone wishing to address the board may do so by filling in a speaker card and submitted to the clerk of the board.
[16:13]
And we will raise your hand, we will collect your card, speakers will have three minutes to get their point across, and speakers are cards available from the clerk of the board.
[16:23]
At this point, Valley Water will now open the conductor hearing for agenda item 3.5.
[16:28]
The proposed acquisition by him in a domain of property located 654163, APN number
[16:33]
472-31-040, owned by the Fred Wee and Susan Brenner.
[16:39]
Do we have any members of the public at this point that wish to address the bill?
[16:47]
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
[16:48]
I have no request at this time.
[16:50]
I invite staff, I invite the Vani, the European, to be officer, what she has designed and
[16:55]
section to commence the presentation in the wee brand of property.
[17:00]
You're on.
[17:02]
Thank you, Chair.
[17:03]
Again, we're going to hear from the Deputy Operating Officer for design and construction.
[17:06]
In the following slides, I will provide information to support the finding set forward in the
[17:10]
Resolution of Necessity for the subject property for the CIOD Crete flat management measures project.
[17:17]
The findings to be made at this public hearing are first to establish that the public need for the project
[17:23]
and then to establish that the project is designed in a manner that is most compatible with the greatest public gate
[17:28]
with the least private engineering. Then to determine that the property is necessary for the project
[17:33]
and lastly to establish that the offer required by section 7267.2,
[17:38]
or the government code was made to the record owners.
[17:42]
For the first finding, the project is needed to protect property salon Kairi Kree from Odo Klin Road
[17:47]
to Interstate 280 against flood levels up to the level that occurred in February 2017,
[17:52]
which is approximately a 20-year flood event.
[17:54]
The other benefits for the project include habitat enhancement and reduced long-term maintenance.
[18:00]
The slide shows the map of the KOD Creek flood protection project.
[18:03]
The project is part of the KOD Creek flood protection project
[18:07]
and was divided into two phases for implementation.
[18:10]
The KOD Creek flood management measures project which is part of the federal order compliance project
[18:16]
for FOCP and then the FlyoD-free Friday Protection Project.
[18:22]
The subject property that we are being discussed is in reach 7.
[18:29]
The project had to be designed within the existing constraints in geography of the project.
[18:33]
Private properties look, located on both sides of the creek,
[18:36]
and the creek flows through the private property.
[18:41]
The project design serves the greatest public good with the least private injury.
[18:45]
The design team used a holistic approach to project design and why did to the maximum
[18:52]
existing possible private structures, the project also preserves habitat, minimizes disturbance
[18:59]
to native vegetation and preserves enhances and creates a aquatic habitat.
[19:05]
Other project benefits include the ability to remove legacy trash and debris, preserving natural
[19:10]
footprint and open space, and increasing native vegetation as well as improving maintenance
[19:15]
access. As far as SQL compliance, as I mentioned, the project is part of the FLCP
[19:21]
projects and was determined to be exempt for SQL. While you have a file to notice of
[19:26]
exemption, the Santa Clara Clare Office on June 29, 2020, and this acquisition is part
[19:32]
of the CIOD Crick blood management project which is included in the FLCP and continues to
[19:38]
The property acquisitions necessary for the project include about 33 properties in reaches 5, 6, and 7.
[19:47]
The resolution of necessity is due to an impact in the proposed for one of the properties, namely the threat we hear in Susanne Brunner's property.
[19:56]
a little more detail about the property itself, the flat wall.
[20:00]
All and the access plan to construct and maintain the flood wall are on the portion of this property and the construction activities also require that a separate portion of the property be temporarily be accessible to construct the flood wall itself.
[20:15]
The red arrow on this map shows the location of the property itself, just to orient the William Street property is right adjacent to this location.
[20:27]
Here's a map of the area of the property, the yellow area, the temporary construction
[20:33]
easement that is required and then the green area is the permanent easement that
[20:38]
will be acquired for the project and the red line is where the proposed flood wall is
[20:43]
going to be.
[20:43]
Staff work over a period of a year with the project team work with the property owner to accommodate
[20:50]
their needs as to minimize the impact to the property itself.
[20:54]
The flood wall itself is located on the back or the east side of the property and the portion to be acquired for access is on either side of the wall.
[21:06]
The portion of the lower terrace area that will be on the left side of the flood wall is below the top of the bank and will be filled and in full construction condition.
[21:14]
Hopefully creating better value for the property backyard.
[21:19]
After the project is completed the project will be returned to for use by the property owner.
[21:24]
Government Section 726.7 requires that the offer made to the property owner be no less than the fair market value and such an offer was made to the property owner on August 30, 2023.
[21:37]
Here is an abridged chronology of all the back and forth with the property owner. As you can see this has been going on for more than a year.
[21:43]
and to the practical extent possible, we've been accommodating the property owners needs in
[21:49]
allowing for the design of the project.
[21:53]
And with that, staff's presentation concludes.
[21:56]
And after what receives comments from the property owner and public staff is ready to answer any questions.
[22:01]
Thank you, Bonnie.
[22:02]
Do we have members from the family and representatives that wish to come and present on the
[22:07]
Resolution of the necessity of this time?
[22:11]
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
[22:11]
I have not received any notification from the property owners or a representative.
[22:15]
Okay, thank you.
[22:18]
We will now receive comments from members of the public on this item.
[22:23]
Do we have any members of the public wish to address this item?
[22:27]
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
[22:28]
I have no request at this time.
[22:31]
Okay.
[22:32]
I'm closing the public hearing.
[22:34]
Having heard staff's presentations comments from the property owners, which we did not.
[22:38]
And comments from the all interested members of the public, which we did not.
[22:41]
The board will now close the public hearing for consideration.
[22:44]
Board discussions or a motion. Do I have a motion?
[22:49]
I have a motion on a second. Any additional board discussion on the item for moving forward?
[22:56]
Okay, this is a roll call vote.
[22:58]
Clerk of the board.
[23:00]
Director Bell.
[23:01]
Director Eisenberg.
[23:03]
Yes. Director Estimera.
[23:05]
Director Shua? Yes. Director Keegan.
[23:08]
Director Santos.
[23:10]
Chair Barola.
[23:10]
Yes, again, this passes unanimously.
[23:15]
Thank you, Board.
[23:15]
Thank you for your attention on this item.
[23:18]
And staff for the presentation appreciate you very much.
[23:21]
Moving on to the agenda.
[23:23]
Item 3.6.
[23:25]
This is information and feedback from the Board only.
[23:28]
Overview the annual capital improvement program process
[23:31]
and review of the currently unfunded projects.
[23:37]
Luis Pruella.
[23:43]
Good afternoon.
[23:44]
and members of the board. My name is Lucania. I'm an assistant officer in the Office of Integrated Water Management.
[23:50]
One of the areas of my responsibilities includes the Capital Improvement Program,
[23:54]
and today I'm here to present the Capital Improvement Program Annual Process Overview
[23:59]
in addition to this year's unfunded project list.
[24:06]
So the presentation outline today will include an annual CIP5 year plan timeline,
[24:11]
the Integrated Financial Planning Schedule, and then I'll briefly cover each unfunded project
[24:16]
And then we have staff here that's available to receive your feedback and answer questions at the end of the presentation.
[24:24]
I'll also have a slide on the Safe Clean Water Program Public Hearing.
[24:27]
These are questions that we're, I'm sorry, decisions that were made back in January that are regarding the valley,
[24:35]
Amazon Lake Improvement Project.
[24:39]
And then I'll end with next steps.
[24:42]
So here you have the fiscal year 25 annual CIP five-year plan timeline and as you can see it's been divided up into four phases.
[24:49]
We are currently in the evaluation phase.
[24:52]
I want to also point out that there's key dates at the bottom of the slide for feedback and instruction from the board.
[24:59]
And then there's also...
[25:00]
So, a list of months for each particular phase in which these activities take place. So, as I mentioned, we're currently in the evaluation phase. This is where the evaluation team is looking at the fiscal year 24 initially validated projects, and I want to point out that these projects come to us, either through a master plan, asset management plan, a study, staff do condition assessments, they look at risks, they look at developing business cases, cost benefit analysis, cost impact.
[25:30]
I'm sorry, cost, impact, environmental impact and social impact.
[25:36]
Once these business cases get approved, they become the initially validated projects
[25:41]
which we're presenting today.
[25:43]
So the evaluation team also looks at previously validated on funded projects and capital
[25:47]
project plant updates.
[25:48]
And these updates are changes to the adopted CIP in regards to scope, schedule, and cost.
[25:56]
All this information is taken and is used to update our funding models, then we're using
[26:02]
the funding filters for prioritization in order to develop a preliminary CIP.
[26:08]
That moves us into our next phase.
[26:10]
The preliminary phase workshops take place between December and January, and they'll include
[26:16]
significant updates existing capital project changes, projects for removal, and these are projects that may
[26:22]
have been completed during the year.
[26:24]
In addition to the evaluation team's recommendations,
[26:27]
regarding the projects that we're presenting today.
[26:30]
So I want to emphasize we are not making recommendations
[26:33]
today.
[26:34]
We are only presenting the projects that will be evaluated.
[26:40]
The next phase is, let me point out that the meetings.
[26:44]
Ideally, we would like your feedback from the CIP,
[26:47]
December 11th, and from the board on January 9th.
[26:52]
And this is so that we can incorporate any direction that you give us or any changes into the draft
[26:57]
CIP, which will be submitted for public review and February.
[27:02]
We have a hearing in May, May 14th, to close a public hearing and also request the board adopt
[27:09]
the CIP, and then of course, we publish the CIP in June.
[27:14]
And I want to add that there's additional assessments that are done to our projects even in
[27:19]
capital delivery phase. Here we have the integrative financial planning schedule. I want to point
[27:26]
out that there's the key date here is January 9th and you'll see that there's a combined
[27:30]
presentation. We work closely with our finance team, our Safe Clean Water Team, and our asset
[27:36]
management team.
[27:39]
Here's a list of our initially validated and currently unfunded projects. This table
[27:42]
is just a high level overview. It provides the project name, the cost, the estimated total cost,
[27:48]
the phase in which the project will come in, potential funding sources, and then the funding category.
[27:54]
Now briefly, goal will reach one.
[27:57]
First project is the right-not-create rehabilitation project,
[28:00]
the estimated cost for this project is $9 million. Potential funding sources would be
[28:07]
the Safe Clean Water Fund and the Watershed Stream Storage Fund. Duration for this project is approximately
[28:12]
two to three years and it's located in Gupertino. The project limits are between festival drive to
[28:17]
of road. There is bank erosion and creek obstructions in this location. And the objectives would
[28:24]
be to execute our safe clean water project FA work, which is the sustainable creek infrastructure
[28:28]
for continued public safety.
[28:32]
And then we have the objectives of also to reduce the risk of
[28:36]
bank failures that impact adjacent properties and apply to the principles to reduce the frequency
[28:42]
of erosion occurring.
[28:45]
Some background, the winter storms in early 2023
[28:50]
caused additional bank failure.
[28:52]
There is an emergency repair project that was completed,
[28:54]
this October, to address localized spots,
[28:58]
however, this area still needs to be stabilized.
[29:01]
The benefits would be that we would continue to maintain
[29:04]
our intended level of service
[29:05]
and that we're ensuring the life of our existing
[29:08]
infrastructure functions sustainably.
[29:10]
In addition, this is important because it
[29:12]
to help us achieve our safe clean water F8KPI.
[29:16]
We have the milestones listed here by phase.
[29:19]
I'm not going to go over them just for time purposes,
[29:22]
but they're there.
[29:24]
Permanentian Health Creek Concrete Replacement Project
[29:26]
is project-desistivated to cost $21 million.
[29:29]
The funds would be our safe clean water,
[29:31]
a potential funding would be from our safe clean water fund
[29:33]
and our watershed students stewardship.
[29:36]
Duration between two to three years for this project,
[29:39]
the Permanentic Creek Project is located in Mountain View
[29:42]
and it would be the site location between part drive to Mountain View Avenue for Hail Creek.
[29:48]
The location is in both altos and it would be between Arboletta Drive to recita Avenue.
[29:54]
The objective is to replace the concrete Uframe channel for both creeks and just to ensure
[29:59]
That's our...
[30:00]
Is this the infrastructure continues to function sustainably?
[30:03]
Background on this is that the concrete channels are over 60 years old and the walls are
[30:08]
starting to deteriorate due to trees that are pressing up against the walls.
[30:14]
And we want to minimize the risk and prevent the walls from collapsing.
[30:18]
The benefits of course would be to maintain our existing infrastructure and continue our
[30:23]
intended level of service. This also would contribute to our meeting our safe clean water
[30:27]
F.A. Project KPI. And there you have the milestones according to phase.
[30:34]
This is a Skata
[30:35]
Master Plan implementation upgrades phase one project. The estimated cost is 11 million.
[30:39]
The funding would come from our water utility enterprise fund. Duration would be approximately
[30:44]
nine years. And this impacts various districts since it's our Skata system. The objectives
[30:50]
would be to upgrade our supervisory control and data acquisition system communications, communication
[30:55]
system and implement an additional backup control center for Skata.
[31:02]
This project is linked to an existing capital project.
[31:06]
It's linked to our Skata Master Plan Implementation Project and the objective for the Skata
[31:10]
Master Plan Implementation Project is to deliver a 15-year program of upgraded projects phase
[31:16]
one and phase two.
[31:17]
This project that I'm presenting here would apply to phase one, which is to address our
[31:22]
communication control center, Skata systems.
[31:26]
And then phase two would be for our water treatment plant skater upgrades.
[31:30]
The benefits would be to improve the remote control capabilities of our raw water convey
[31:35]
in system and to enhance our cybersecurity in addition to ensure the ability to deliver
[31:40]
raw water to our drinking water treatment plants and groundwater recharge facilities.
[31:46]
The planning phase would be completed through our master plan and it would be completed
[31:52]
by fiscal year 25,
[31:57]
the planning phase.
[31:58]
Our next project is the Alameda's Damary Placement and Automation Project.
[32:02]
This estimated cost is 10 million.
[32:04]
It would come from our identified potential funding would come from our water utility enterprise
[32:10]
fund.
[32:11]
Duration for this project is approximately three to four years, mislocated here in San Jose.
[32:17]
The objectives would be to routinely operate the divers and down to impound water during
[32:20]
winter seasons, it would reduce the dependence on imported water in
[32:25]
alameda spawn and are for what a loop of ponds and it would help us to
[32:29]
eliminate the need for the risk of sending personnel and heavy equipment into
[32:32]
the creek. It would also expedite flood reduction response during unexpected
[32:37]
storms. Some background here is that the flash forward down is typically installed
[32:42]
and removed once a year and normally takes about a week. This project will
[32:45]
reduce that to maybe one and a half or one to two hours. During the rainy seasons
[32:50]
valley water can not divert local water to the pond for ground water recharge.
[32:55]
So, therefore, we cannot fully utilize their annual recharge capacity of 1,100 acre
[33:00]
feet to replenish the groundwater basin.
[33:03]
The benefits would be to increase the operational flexibility of the island-medicine
[33:07]
diversion and to improve the use of our local water rights.
[33:11]
So there's financial savings to our water utility enterprise fund and rate payers.
[33:16]
And, of course, the benefits to the environment would be that we would eliminate the
[33:20]
to do water, the creek prior to sending any heavy equipment in, and there you have the milestones
[33:25]
per phase.
[33:28]
The San Jose Purifier Water Project phase one, this estimated cost is at 50 million.
[33:33]
The funding would come from our water utility enterprise fund.
[33:36]
Duration is about five to six years, it's located in San Jose adjacent to our Silicon Valley
[33:42]
advanced purification center.
[33:44]
The object, this would be to construct a direct, potable reuse demonstration facility, and
[33:50]
want to point out that staff and industry leading experts have recommended that this facility
[33:55]
be constructed to address regulatory requirements and gather critical information that will
[34:00]
help validate designs for a full-scale facility. This would also ensure treatment training
[34:05]
for our treatment training's protect public health and public outreach for acceptance of
[34:11]
this facility as a reliable and drought resilient water supply.
[34:17]
This is not linked to any
[34:18]
CIP project and, as I mentioned, the benefits would be to address regulatory requirements,
[34:25]
gather critical information that will help validate designs for a full-scale facility.
[34:29]
And there you have some milestones per phase.
[34:35]
Next project is the COD-10B Fresh Water Wetlands project.
[34:38]
The estimated cost for this project is 9 million.
[34:41]
The funding identified would be the watershed stream stewardship fund.
[34:46]
duration would be approximately three to four years and the location is in South San Jose near
[34:51]
Metcalf Road area and highway 101 and this is not related to the Metcalf study project.
[35:00]
That's in the CIP. The objectives would be to meet mitigation requirements for the multi-year
[35:05]
stream maintenance program. It would help us create seven acres of fresh water wetland, one
[35:10]
acre of upland habitat, and then 1.58 acres of channel, with inclusion of fisheries habitat
[35:16]
features.
[35:20]
Some background, basically, is that our stream maintenance program oversees the routine
[35:25]
maintenance of our streams and flood control channels. So some activities result in unavoidable
[35:29]
impacts that we must mitigate. So Valley Water has acquired. So Valley Water also has acquired
[35:39]
the sites for wetlands creation. The benefits would be to continue to serve our watershed
[35:45]
operations and maintenance needs that would provide mitigation for these impacts and then
[35:50]
with enhanced fisheries and wildlife habitat functions. It would also support watershed
[35:54]
wild restoration and enhanced other environmental projects within the area such as a coyote
[35:58]
planning, wetlands project, the coyote percolation dams, and this passage and the OSHA
[36:03]
PAN separation project.
[36:05]
And there you have the projected milestones.
[36:07]
We would need to start this project during the Safe Queen Stream Maintenance Program
[36:13]
Permitcycle, which starts in 2027.
[36:17]
The surprise and bird, did you have a comment on this slide?
[36:20]
I can wait for this.
[36:22]
Okay, fine.
[36:23]
Thank you.
[36:25]
For the SouthBab flood protection project, this is a long term project.
[36:28]
The estimated cost of $23 million, the project identified funding would be the watershed
[36:35]
stream stewardship fund, and duration is approximately five to six years, the location is
[36:39]
in San Jose.
[36:41]
I do want to point out that based on the Santa Clara County 80 percent average median income
[36:46]
standard, this proposed project site does fall within the low income community, but the area
[36:52]
does not score high enough on the California environment screen, in viral screen to be classified
[36:58]
as a disadvantaged community per-cow-epa, but, like I said, it is in the low-income community area.
[37:06]
The objective would be to improve the capacity of the South Bad Creek to contain most
[37:09]
flows during a 100-year flow event, and it would be to replace three bridges, friend and
[37:15]
drive, South White Road, and the bridge located at Lotner Drive.
[37:19]
And this would also help remove some areas from the 100-year female flood plane.
[37:24]
Some background here is that this was originally recommended for replacement in 2016 through a watershed asset management plan.
[37:33]
And there are no other other projects that would address the flooding risk along SouthBab.
[37:37]
Benefits would be that it would substantially reduce the flood risk during a 1% flow event on SouthBab Creek.
[37:43]
And it would help remove some areas from the FEMA floodplain.
[37:46]
And there you have the projected milestones by phase.
[37:51]
Finally, the Pond A4 phase 2 project, the estimated total cost for this project is 34 million,
[37:57]
the fundee, productive, identified funding would be from the watershed stream stewardship fund,
[38:02]
duration is approximately 15 years and this is located in Sunnyvale.
[38:06]
The objectives would be to restore the mud flat habitat that once existed along the base,
[38:10]
edge, enhance the Pond A4 biodiversity and continue valley water's beneficial sediment
[38:15]
we use along the base shore.
[38:19]
This is linked to a CIP project, it's linked to the Pond A4 phase 1 project and some background on this phase 1 project would be that it has access improvements for delivering stream maintenance for around sediment, creates a shallow water habitat, and the shallow water habitat will serve as a foundation for the calivases on to mass a queen's creep marsh connection projects future equitone, a cellarine construction and reducing cost.
[38:46]
So without phase two phase one alone won't yield the habitat benefits and there you see the
[38:54]
the protecting milestones which would be to restore 45 acres of shallow water habitat
[38:59]
five fiscal year 38.
[39:05]
Maybe I should I finish the final slide.
[39:07]
Sure go ahead. Absolutely. We'll hold off questions.
[39:09]
So for the Safe Clean Water Program public hearing I want to point out that there's some background
[39:12]
here that there was a hearing back in January of 24 where some key decisions were made regarding
[39:17]
the Amazon Lake Improvement Project, the cost estimates for Amazon Lake Improvement Project
[39:23]
nearly tripled,
[39:27]
and this increased the project cost and funding constraints triggered.
[39:29]
This triggered our change control process.
[39:32]
So the board decided that they decided not to construct the Amazon Lake Improvement Project
[39:38]
and instead partially fund the construction of the OASER PONS project.
[39:42]
The board modified the funding allocations for two flood control projects.
[39:46]
This is a Sunnyville Eastern West Channel and the upper penitentiary creak project.
[39:52]
The port also committed to seeking additional funding to construct both flood control projects.
[39:57]
The next steps are to close up.
[40:00]
We've got the design face for the Amid and Lake Improvement Project, and we will be recommending that the Amid and Lake Improvement Project be placed on the infant list.
[40:07]
This will come to the board on December 11, I'm sorry to the CIP Committee on December 11, and to the board on January 9.
[40:15]
And then we will be continuing to seek internal and external funding for the two flood control flood protection projects identified.
[40:24]
Next steps would be, in December, we're coming to the CIP committee to review the CIP
[40:29]
preliminary five-year plan and significant project plan updates and then in January,
[40:34]
the board will review and provide direction regarding the CIP preliminary five-year plan.
[40:38]
And this concludes my presentation.
[40:40]
Thank you, Lucie.
[40:41]
Appreciate it.
[40:42]
Do we have any members of the public that wish to address this on this side?
[40:46]
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
[40:47]
I have no requests at this time.
[40:49]
Okay.
[40:50]
Director Eisenberg.
[40:53]
Thank you, Chair.
[40:54]
And thank you so much for this extremely helpful and enlightening presentation.
[41:01]
After I had to go into those in the public, I had a very productive and my opinion successful briefing yesterday,
[41:10]
where I was educated about the current, you know, created by, I think the previous board, you know,
[41:18]
our process of evaluating what is given the greatest priority and inclusion on our CIP and what
[41:27]
is considered when moving items off the CIP. I want to say as a general matter given how quickly
[41:36]
our environmental, you know, how quickly environmental change is climate change is accelerating,
[41:43]
how quickly costs our accelerating in all sorts of areas that in my opinion I think it might
[41:51]
be helpful to re-examine those criteria but given that those are the current criteria I think
[41:58]
staff did a fantastic job of being true to existing criteria and again I hope we re-examine those
[42:04]
so I'm very grateful for your work. Now a couple of comments and questions I have is you know
[42:12]
Again, you're following by our previous criteria.
[42:17]
And, but I hope when we reconsider the criteria,
[42:20]
we can give more emphasis maybe to the following factors,
[42:24]
which I think are also important.
[42:27]
And one of them, a kind of criesonomy, is compliance.
[42:33]
So I saw that a few of the projects that were moved
[42:36]
into the unfunded list were actually mitigations
[42:40]
that we agree to in order to gain approvals to do other projects.
[42:45]
And I think that mitigations that we promised we would do
[42:49]
should never be unfunded.
[42:51]
Like, that should, as a general matter, like, and this is not to blame you.
[42:55]
Again, I want to say, I think you are very true to the existing criteria.
[42:58]
And it's the criteria that I really am taking up, you know,
[43:02]
some questions about.
[43:03]
So I think that mitigations that are part of any application that we do
[43:08]
and we promise the public, commitments you made to the environment, this needs to always be mandatory
[43:14]
and not moved the list in my opinion. And in this case, that also I think includes face.
[43:22]
You know, we have seen the challenges it causes for this. You can see like many others.
[43:27]
When we are perceived, you know, rightfully or not, and sometimes it's rightfully as being out of compliance
[43:32]
with agreements that we or others made a long time ago. And I think that happens in part
[43:38]
because we are willing to move off the front of us
[43:42]
promises we made in settlement agreements and applications.
[43:47]
So I also think that should not as a rule
[43:50]
be moved off of the front of us, but again, new criteria.
[43:55]
I also think that another focus that I really
[43:59]
haven't seen been made, but again, criteria, not
[44:02]
to have is a focus on creating good union jobs in a timely manner.
[44:11]
I know that we hear a lot, I hear a lot about how this economy actually, especially
[44:18]
from lower paid workers, is much worse than maybe we will read about in the newspaper, and
[44:25]
that jobs are becoming more and more scarce, especially workers, unionized workers.
[44:32]
and so there are a few of these projects, especially the environmental rehabilitation projects that
[44:39]
are much easier to come by regulatory approvals. That there is funding available, and putting
[44:46]
up in on that for the last coming to make, you know, that there is funding available that
[44:50]
has been had by other agencies, that would really do a lot, you know, could go a long way to
[44:56]
to create more jobs for working families.
[45:00]
And workers at this really important time, affordability here is as we all know, price of housing, et cetera. It's just through the roof. It's untenable. So job creation, I think, is a worthy goal.
[45:17]
And, you know, I guess last thing I really want to say is that, oh, another thing I think is, is it kind of makes me sad that the recycling,
[45:26]
and it's end of day would be moved off because a recycling plant is so much more important
[45:32]
than just the construction and the jobs and the, you know, it actually is a creating
[45:36]
a new source of water. And so I don't think we have really taken enough efforts, not
[45:45]
criticism of staff at all, but you know, again, a board direction. I think that, you know,
[45:50]
I would like to see the board maybe giving better direction and how to value these water
[45:56]
cycling plants, because I know that a lot of board members, not board directors, not just myself,
[46:02]
have kind of pointed out that certain benefits are not really calibrated factor down to consideration,
[46:12]
like the water creation, like the environmental advantages, and John Christians, like all these things,
[46:19]
to the extent we can really do a whole harder, maybe following other agencies, like the met,
[46:25]
Santa Barbara Orange County, maybe we looked to see what they're doing so we don't have to reinvent the wheel.
[46:29]
Maybe we could create a better instructions for staff to do this.
[46:36]
Because you've proven you are so good at doing these types of analyses.
[46:42]
And you know, I'm a numbers person, then I, you know, data person, I do have great respect for this.
[46:47]
Okay, the final thing is one point about funding.
[46:50]
I've heard said that sometimes we have been our applications have been denied for funding
[46:56]
for kind of the sustainable projects, you know, water recycling, habitat restoration projects
[47:03]
that, you know, we know have been approved by other agencies and having worked on different kinds of, you know,
[47:14]
projects that require tons of regulatory approvals, such as IPOs, and then that kind of thing
[47:20]
we're constantly working with the SEC. My experience is that often it really takes a
[47:25]
risk and not that you don't do this, but it takes a really working relationship with these that
[47:30]
usually a denial is only step one and then you modify your proposal and then you modify the
[47:37]
proposal and while that definitely takes more people power, how wonderful to be able to
[47:42]
to prove budget to create more workers here, too.
[47:46]
Create more jobs here.
[47:47]
These are really great jobs for our community members
[47:50]
and maybe to work on regulatory agency relations,
[47:55]
which is time-consuming and difficult.
[48:00]
So I wouldn't ask this current staff enough.
[48:02]
It was a little bit maybe we could approve more jobs
[48:05]
to create more jobs for our community.
[48:09]
So those are just kind of my points
[48:10]
have to do with, you know, when we are able to rethink these criteria in light of changing
[48:15]
circumstances. So, but I really appreciate this work and I'm very grateful for our meeting
[48:20]
yesterday, and I have a lot of respect for the work you do. So, thank you. Thank you, everyone.
[48:26]
Vice Chair Keegan.
[48:29]
Thank you. I have a couple of the unfounded projects that I wanted to talk
[48:33]
about versus the SMPIB upgrade phase one,
[48:37]
and that's on page 10 of the presentation.
[48:44]
So we talk about, so I have a question,
[48:48]
I guess that specific to this project,
[48:50]
but it could be applied to some of the other projects too.
[48:53]
So the idea is to upgrade aging,
[48:56]
skatea, communication systems,
[48:59]
and implemented additional backup control centers for skatea.
[49:02]
And so this provides benefits in terms of improving cyber security, improving remote control capabilities,
[49:12]
ensuring our ability to deliver raw water to drinking water treatment plants.
[49:19]
So it seems to me that this is pretty important, you know, particularly given all the cyber security threats that we're facing.
[49:28]
So my question here is are we considering potential risk for essentially something like this that's a critical asset as part of our analysis because there's a considerable risk if our skates system comes down.
[49:49]
Um, and sort of an associated question.
[49:55]
It seems to me that putting some of these things in place would...
[50:00]
It potentially reduced some operating costs, right? Like we might require less staff to be doing this work.
[50:09]
So I realize it's kind of more philosophical question, but could you expand on that?
[50:14]
No, no, it is. There's a lot being done in the planning phase. We're also looking at industry standards, researching what other agencies are doing, making sure that we're up to standard.
[50:25]
looking towards a future, making sure that we're prepared.
[50:32]
And I can actually pass this on.
[50:33]
So if you two James Bowen, who is our asset management unit manager,
[50:37]
and he's also managing the Skata Master Plan implementation program.
[50:42]
Thank you, James.
[50:44]
Thank you, Dr. Kagan for the questions.
[50:48]
Just one thing I guess I can point out as well
[50:50]
in relation to this particular upgrades phase one.
[50:53]
Moving these early implementation projects forward was a direct response to risk in the early assessment done by the consultant and the master planning efforts.
[51:05]
So risk is as risk along with just factors for reliability, upper ability, life cycle cost are definitely being factored into the work of the planning consultant in the project.
[51:16]
So, even though this is an area that has some level of risk and could provide perhaps greater efficiency and staff allocation,
[51:27]
it just still below the threshold.
[51:30]
Is that what I'm hearing?
[51:32]
If I'm understanding that the question quickly, we are also as part of the overall broad master plan implementation project itself,
[51:41]
going to be doing resource analysis once we've further defined the other projects that
[51:46]
we'll be coming through and that we'll be bringing to the CIT committee into the board.
[51:51]
Resource allocations will be looked at as we implement new technologies and look at our
[51:57]
staff capabilities, both just in terms of numbers and capabilities that would absolutely be
[52:02]
something we'd be looking for efficiency as well.
[52:05]
So that could plan to an enhanced benefit cost analysis as part of this screen
[52:11]
process. Okay, great. Thank you. And then my other is about the the Almatin Lake Improvement
[52:24]
Project. You know, I know that Almatin Lake has had a number of issues, you know, part
[52:32]
of it. We own part of it. The city of San Jose owns. I really feel like if we were perhaps
[52:40]
able to do something on our side, it might help us get the city of San Jose involved in
[52:48]
doing the improvements to bring Almadin like Park back to where it once was.
[52:54]
I think we were all sad to see earlier this fairly recently that raging waters was shutting
[53:04]
down an important recreational opportunity for residents and youth and
[53:10]
East San Jose, not just from a recreational perspective, but from a
[53:13]
perspective of being able to afford young people jobs, right? I mean
[53:19]
that's how many young people start out. My sister worked as mother
[53:24]
Hubbard the first season of Great America being open. She was in charge of
[53:28]
lost children.
[53:31]
And I've known had friends whose children have been employed by San Jose Parks Department to do those recreational
[53:39]
opportunities. So I know this isn't something that necessarily falls neatly into our criteria,
[53:48]
but again, when we look in areas that are underserved, every little thing that we can do to improve
[53:55]
quality of life for disadvantaged communities, I think, is important.
[54:02]
So I'll get off my soapbox
[54:03]
now, but this is just something that's kind of near and dear to my heart, and I think I know
[54:09]
that the elected officials in San Jose really care about this as well. So this is more a comment
[54:15]
as opposed to something requiring your response on your part. So thank you very much. Thank you.
[54:20]
Director Santos.
[54:26]
Yeah, thank you, Chair. Could you go back to PAN for a please?
[55:02]
Yeah, thank you. Nice to have clarification. Do we actually own that? The water district? So that was
[55:12]
wild line service, and then we purchased it back when John bourgeois. It was there was a coastal
[55:17]
concern.
[55:20]
Which I appreciate. I remember that's been so long ago when we did it. So when I'm
[55:32]
I'm going to pass this question on to John Bourgeois, our Deputy Operator of North
[55:36]
Officer for Watershed and Planning.
[55:41]
Yes, Director Santas, John Bourgeois, Deputy of Watershed, Stewart's of Employment and yes,
[55:47]
Valley Water did acquire that pond at the same time that Don Edwards refuge acquired
[55:51]
the other salt pond, so that's part of the salt pond restoration project, and yes, we do own
[55:57]
it, but this is something we've received grants for, and so we won't be so
[56:05]
This is a very regionally beneficial project and is very competitive in the restoration grant arena.
[56:15]
Yeah, that was my point because when we went back to Washington, Judge Mason gave us those
[56:19]
blood gates and all those good things from the Department of Interior.
[56:23]
So I was hoping that we could qualify for some time of grant funding from Fish and Game,
[56:28]
Wildlife Service, Coastal Conservancy, and I hope that the Department of Interior.
[56:32]
So, what's the odds and are we continually, I'm assuming participate trying to get that?
[56:39]
Yeah, we're going to continue to monitor, it's being the ultimate fate of that as being
[56:44]
studied as part of the Santa Mosque Colabassas Creek Reconnection Project, which is also
[56:48]
received several million dollars in grant funding and we anticipate that if and when the
[56:54]
time comes to fully breach that pond after we've done these steps, that it would be very,
[57:01]
competitive for grant funding. How about the chance of looking at shoreline type of funding?
[57:08]
That's also potential. We are looking at it as part of the larger shoreline package.
[57:14]
So the estimation is 34 million but we have hope that we can reduce that.
[57:19]
Yeah my understanding is that 34 is over 15 years and that's to bring in our stream maintenance
[57:25]
material over a long, you know, small amounts of material over a long period of time.
[57:29]
So it has multiple benefits for our agency.
[57:32]
No, I'm going to work with you and we've made some great games there.
[57:36]
But it's a lot of funding.
[57:38]
The environmental and has which are fantastic.
[57:43]
Dr. Schwier.
[57:48]
Thank you, Chair.
[57:50]
First of all, I really appreciate hearing my colleagues comment on these
[57:56]
but I'm from the project but I kind of a sense there's a probably misunderstanding that
[58:06]
these projects are not making the cut. So I apologize if I misinterpret my colleagues comment
[58:20]
And then just the contrary, this is the list of project that's making the cut that's going to go into the next step.
[58:31]
So, Luz, can you put it on the process chart?
[58:36]
So, actually, I think the process requires a staff to propose a new project to be included into the 5 year CRP planning process based on our programmatic plan,
[58:49]
based on our asset management plan and save me
[58:52]
while it cleansed a create program, whatever.
[58:55]
And then there's an initial evaluation by staff.
[59:02]
And these are the project that's making the cut based on the,
[59:07]
that's what's called the initially validated.
[59:10]
And then it's unsunded because it's not approved
[59:12]
by the board yet to be included in the five-year plan.
[59:16]
That's what it's called unsunded.
[59:18]
And then these initially validated project was unfunded.
[59:23]
We're going to the preliminary VIP analysis.
[59:27]
And then that result how we'll look at financial and the
[59:31]
human resource availability, many, many other considerations.
[59:38]
And that result will come back to the full board for discussion.
[59:44]
So, yeah, so I just, I, I want to clarify that and again, if I'm misinterpreted to what I heard, I apologize, but these are the projects that's validated and then it's the worst.
[1:00:00]
If that further evaluation took going to our process, thank you. Thank you.
[1:00:05]
Dr. Bell?
[1:00:13]
Here's what I favor, I'm just going to lead out. I favor more public input. Do the fact that we're going
[1:00:22]
to have a fiscal climate that requires us to have restraint and dealing with large
[1:00:31]
costing crease, like we saw today in the newspaper from the Lake Anderson Project, multiply
[1:00:38]
that by many projects, because this is all going to happen throughout our capital budget and
[1:00:45]
cause a probably a great deal of disruption of the project cost and schedules.
[1:00:52]
So, I think, first of all, getting a handle on that and being physically restrained and laying out what we can't pay for, and what we can't pay for.
[1:01:09]
The second thing, we should have a list of ongoing maintenance and repair and restoration projects.
[1:01:17]
So we can understand, serve our backlog or up and coming over the next 10, 20 years,
[1:01:25]
kinds of projects, we're going to have to be focused on and finding out how big that
[1:01:36]
list is, is a good thing to do.
[1:01:38]
And I think when you talk about adding projects and doing other projects, sometimes it
[1:01:44]
to forget about your projects you need to do to repair and restore and upgrade and modernize and all those kinds of things to not end up with a lot of new projects on your list, but a lot of obsolete facilities.
[1:02:04]
So I think it's very important that we understand that and deal with that.
[1:02:14]
I believe we should base our bigger projects on water supply, master plan, other kinds
[1:02:20]
of long range planning, so we can see deep into the future.
[1:02:24]
These investments are multiple decades, investments, and sometimes the benefit does not
[1:02:33]
come apparent and to lay into the future.
[1:02:37]
So I think when we look at what's the most
[1:02:40]
cost-effective for Santa Clara Valley in 2050, OK?
[1:02:50]
That's the kind of approach we should do.
[1:02:54]
Lastly, I believe that just serve my own view of things here.
[1:03:03]
If we had more smaller, quick kind of projects with fair projects, restoration projects that
[1:03:14]
our own staff can do, we don't have to go through a bid process, we can just get have a bigger
[1:03:22]
team maybe to complete those projects because it's apparent now that the year to year
[1:03:30]
cost escalations are grinding down our budget and eating up our budget.
[1:03:38]
It's not like it was five years ago, it's a big problem.
[1:03:45]
So we have to respond to that.
[1:03:46]
We have to figure out how we're going to do with that.
[1:03:49]
Those costs increase realities and how do we do with that in a fiscally restrained
[1:03:56]
proper manner.
[1:03:58]
Without just saying, oh, we're just going to pass more bonds.
[1:04:01]
We're going to raise the rates.
[1:04:03]
We're going to just gather in more money.
[1:04:05]
I think that's a very idiotic way to respond to the problem.
[1:04:11]
And we'll probably be rejected by the voters
[1:04:13]
if we ever try to do it on the ballot.
[1:04:15]
So I think at first, we have to start focusing
[1:04:18]
on how we can save money via friscally restraining
[1:04:22]
at responsible agency before we start talking about adding
[1:04:30]
taxes and fees and things like that to people that really don't like that right now.
[1:04:35]
They're not very happy about things right now with that.
[1:04:39]
So those are my comments.
[1:04:42]
Thank you.
[1:04:43]
Thank you.
[1:04:44]
Appreciate the board interaction on this and appreciate the staff's bringing this forward
[1:04:49]
to the board for consideration in our future.
[1:04:52]
These are a list of unfunded capital and proven projects that we're going to be looking
[1:04:56]
at.
[1:04:56]
and as has been recommended by board members,
[1:04:59]
perhaps we need to...
[1:05:00]
Look at the list that we currently have and make some hard decisions as to how do we prioritize
[1:05:05]
what is currently on the list to projects that we're going to be implementing and those
[1:05:10]
that are being put in front of us. As far as how we're going to fund these things, well, that's still
[1:05:15]
to be determined. That is not yet be determined. So I don't like to make pre-judgment as to what we're
[1:05:21]
doing, what we're recommending, what we're suggesting. The public will ultimately tell us what they want,
[1:05:25]
what they don't want. We always know that because we work for the public. We represent the public.
[1:05:29]
But I also appreciate the input that we're getting from our board members because we're the ones that are going to approve or disapprove
[1:05:35]
What you bring to us, but a sincerely appreciate the effort time that you put into this
[1:05:40]
You give us a lot to think about so thank you so much any other final words for board members
[1:05:46]
Okay, so we're going to move on the agenda item 3.7
[1:05:49]
Thank you. Thank you
[1:05:52]
We see the review of the rolling biennial budget effectiveness and an overview of the fiscal year of 2024
[1:05:57]
or 25, rolling by annual budget process.
[1:06:01]
Again, this is information only and feedback.
[1:06:04]
No vote required on this side.
[1:06:07]
Darren.
[1:06:08]
Oh, wait a minute, sorry.
[1:06:09]
You don't look like Darren.
[1:06:10]
Hello.
[1:06:11]
I've got for noon.
[1:06:12]
I'm in Rikke and da.
[1:06:12]
Good to see you again.
[1:06:13]
Thank you, sir.
[1:06:15]
Budget manager here at Valley Water,
[1:06:16]
a presentation for you, if the board would like to hear it.
[1:06:18]
Please.
[1:06:22]
So as I mentioned, I'm in Rikke and da.
[1:06:24]
Budget manager for Valley Water.
[1:06:25]
And I'll be providing you with the review
[1:06:27]
of the effectiveness of the rolling by annual budget.
[1:06:30]
And also with some backgrounds, staff analysis, as we begin our 30-year-over rolling by
[1:06:34]
a new budget process.
[1:06:36]
And the second part of the presentation, I'll be walking you through the actual process
[1:06:40]
itself of touch on our governance policies, the financial planning process, highlight a few
[1:06:45]
budget-related key dates, and I'll also speak to the budget themes that we're incorporating
[1:06:49]
along with the high-level review.
[1:06:52]
The inputs that we are assuming has part of the first pass and a reminder that we incorporate
[1:06:57]
the board work plan strategies that I consider as part of the budget development process,
[1:07:02]
and I'll include the presentation by going over next steps.
[1:07:07]
So I'd like to provide some context or background on value water transition to our rolling
[1:07:11]
planal budget.
[1:07:12]
In August of 2020, the board asked staff to explore planal budgeting, including its potential benefits
[1:07:17]
and drawbacks, as compared to an annual budget process.
[1:07:21]
The staff presented various options and recommended the rolling planal budget cycle to be
[1:07:27]
the board would adopt the first fiscal year
[1:07:29]
and approve the second year of the budget.
[1:07:32]
In this case, the upcoming fiscal year is updated annually
[1:07:35]
and the new second year is added as the current fiscal year ends.
[1:07:39]
The goal of the two-year budget was to improvise the alignment
[1:07:42]
of the operating budget with longer-planet horizons
[1:07:44]
of the capital permit program in a long-term forecast.
[1:07:49]
The rolling by annual budget
[1:07:50]
fulfills the government code and district that requirements
[1:07:53]
which require the annual board actions.
[1:07:56]
The California government code 65403 requires special districts that can be manually, so this is stakeholder feedback and public input for the adoption of the five year CIP.
[1:08:06]
The district bat, more specifically section 2026, requires that the board can be manually and solicited public input to adopt the budget and also the water rates.
[1:08:16]
With this in mind, the rolling by annual budget approach provided longer term strategic planning approach as compared to the annual budget cycle that we previously doing.
[1:08:26]
A lot at the same time, we're filling the annual requirements that I just mentioned to you.
[1:08:31]
That being said, there are other competitor water agencies that do employee-traditional by annual budget.
[1:08:37]
We're the board approved a 24-month appropriation and they're updated with mid-cycle updates to adjust or modify the second year of the budget.
[1:08:46]
As we all know, time definitely flies by, and just last week we had our fiscal year 25 budget
[1:08:52]
kick-off presentation to staff, and we are now in the beginning stages of the third rolling
[1:08:57]
by annual budget process, since we transition back in fiscal year 23.
[1:09:01]
The rolling by annual budget has been effective as has challenged the organization to
[1:09:04]
think strategically over a couple of years, aligned with the long-term forecast, instead of balancing
[1:09:09]
the budget for one single year.
[1:09:11]
At the same time, it provides value water with the opportunity to adjust changing budgetary
[1:09:16]
and economic conditions and an annual basis.
[1:09:20]
In May 2022, value water engagement and dependent consultants, management partners to conduct
[1:09:24]
the review and analysis of transition to a rolling-by annual budget.
[1:09:29]
The consultant's opinion was that value waters decision to move to a rolling-by annual budget
[1:09:33]
was the right solution to accomplish the objective of providing a longer range of view of
[1:09:38]
the operational needs.
[1:09:39]
A traditional two-year budget would not provide the ongoing 24-month projection to the district and that's second fiscal year of the Bionne of Budget.
[1:09:48]
Also, the benefits of preparing a budget every two years would be lost if the second year becomes stale due to change in its circumstances.
[1:09:55]
That's requiring mid-cycle adjustments.
[1:09:58]
As compared to a single budget process,
[1:10:00]
Not the following. Yes, preparing the rolling bional budget requires more work, and effort to be
[1:10:05]
for that second fiscal year. But I believe that the organizations acclimated to the cadence of
[1:10:09]
the budget cycles and realizing the synergies between the long term forecast and the CIP. Second,
[1:10:16]
the rolling bional budget increases transparency and provides more information, providing insight into
[1:10:21]
the next fiscal years, goals and objectives. And third, lastly, the operating budget is better
[1:10:27]
line with the Capital Improvement Program and we're able to capture corresponding
[1:10:31]
operating expenses that are associated with the Capital Projects and budget the
[1:10:36]
required capital funding that's required that second fiscal year.
[1:10:49]
In terms of
[1:10:49]
comparing to a rolling by annual budget research additional budget, let's make
[1:10:55]
sure that's okay. I've touched on the advantages for the most part, but just to
[1:11:01]
summarize, it is mostly aligned with the annual water rate setting process and the
[1:11:05]
in state district that involves water rate policies.
[1:11:09]
The annual budget process of the rolling
[1:11:10]
by annual budget allows value water to remain responsive
[1:11:13]
to the dynamic and budget and economic conditions.
[1:11:16]
And a traditional by annual budget could save the organization
[1:11:19]
some time, but this would only be the case
[1:11:21]
if budgetary conditions remain stable year or year.
[1:11:25]
With that in mind, staff has examined the merits
[1:11:27]
of the rolling by annual budget process
[1:11:29]
and supports the continuation of such.
[1:11:31]
As if it feels a long-term planning
[1:11:34]
while remaining responsive to the dynamic and ever-changing needs of the organization.
[1:11:42]
With that in mind, I'll transition to an overview of the fiscal year 25 rolling by annual budget process.
[1:11:48]
The district develops the by annual budget in a five-year capital improvement program to allocate public funds,
[1:11:54]
necessary to provide silicone value with safe and clean water.
[1:11:57]
The development of the budget and capital improvement program are accomplished in an open,
[1:12:01]
transparent process under the guidance of the board,
[1:12:03]
also provide an opportunity for public input.
[1:12:06]
The district's financial processes are governed by the District Act, section 13 for taxes,
[1:12:11]
section 20 for the adoption of the budget, and section 26 for the levy and collection of water charges.
[1:12:17]
In addition, state and federal laws require annual examinations of financial records,
[1:12:22]
the Board of Governance, Governance policies, executive limitations for,
[1:12:26]
guided financial management, the planning, and budgeting of and ongoing financial activities.
[1:12:30]
The district's financial processes comply with all applicable laws, regulations, and policies.
[1:12:39]
On this slide, in terms of the financial planning process, it occurs between the months
[1:12:43]
of August and June, over the past couple of months that has been working hard and updating the long-term
[1:12:48]
forecast on the CIP.
[1:12:50]
We're now in the middle of budget season.
[1:12:52]
Income January will be running three processes side by side, or in parallel.
[1:12:56]
As we maintain the budget, plan one of the production charges and the CIP in sync.
[1:13:01]
in order to make sure that we don't have any financial funding gaps.
[1:13:08]
Some keyboard review dates.
[1:13:10]
For the operating capital budget on January 23rd,
[1:13:12]
we have scheduled our budget update,
[1:13:14]
and this would be our first pass.
[1:13:16]
On March 12th, we will bring the second pass results
[1:13:18]
which will be more detail,
[1:13:20]
include an input you provide today or in the future
[1:13:23]
and any new positions that management is recommending.
[1:13:27]
Lastly, on April 24th,
[1:13:29]
we'll have our budget work study sessions,
[1:13:30]
which are very detailed and we'll review the division budgets.
[1:13:34]
On January 17th, we'll bring the preliminary groundwater charge analysis in the CIP, so that the board may see and discuss the CIP at the same time, as I've seen the right analysis that's being brought forth.
[1:13:46]
And April 11th through the 23rd, we have the public hearing schedule.
[1:13:50]
In terms of the CIP, February 27th is the draft CIP that will be brought to the board, which will then take off the 60 day review process with the local cities.
[1:13:59]
On April 11th, we have the public hearings that the CFP will begin.
[1:14:04]
Lastly, I made 14th.
[1:14:07]
We will have the board of the option.
[1:14:08]
And obviously, as we were through the budget process, we can adapt.
[1:14:11]
We have more meetings.
[1:14:12]
We have necessary.
[1:14:16]
In terms of major budget themes, we have the end of the drought.
[1:14:19]
We have increased inflation, cost affecting our capital projects.
[1:14:23]
And we may have a maybe a possible recession that may affect the development of this year's budget.
[1:14:28]
On the water utility side, we expect pressure on the water rates.
[1:14:31]
As I was just previously mentioned, due to increasing capital project costs, given the increases
[1:14:35]
inflation, we'll incorporate the anticipated water rates scenarios taking to account the
[1:14:40]
water supply master plan impact in any post drought, water used to be found assumptions.
[1:14:45]
For debt issuances, we present marine rates in our budget that are quite conservative, but further
[1:14:52]
interest rate high increase value waters financing costs for capital projects relative to
[1:14:57]
transactions that we have.
[1:15:00]
This is something that we're definitely watching pretty closely. For the watershed streams, the
[1:15:03]
stewardship fund, we will fund and prioritize projects, as many future costs exceed the financial
[1:15:08]
capacity of the fund. Additionally, we will incorporate the new unsheltered people assistance
[1:15:14]
authority, aligned with the Board of Governance Policy E6, which is the encampments of unsheltered
[1:15:19]
people. These things will be balanced while also at the same time being aware of the potential
[1:15:25]
session may affect property taxes, the primary source of funds for the primary source of revenue
[1:15:30]
for this fund.
[1:15:32]
Lastly, for the State Clean Water Fund, we will also focus on grant opportunities to help
[1:15:36]
fund projects that are affected by inflationary pressures and are currently unhold to the
[1:15:42]
record bills comment.
[1:15:43]
Valley Water is also currently considering a general obligation fund to place in the November
[1:15:49]
for 2024 ballot.
[1:15:51]
These additional funds would help fund public improvement
[1:15:54]
capital projects.
[1:15:59]
As at a place where assumptions or inputs,
[1:16:01]
the first pass budget, we are maintained funding
[1:16:03]
for the fiscal year 24 authorized positions.
[1:16:06]
The fiscal year 25 plan positions will be reviewed
[1:16:09]
with the CEO and final recommendation
[1:16:11]
will be provided to the board during our second pass
[1:16:14]
presentation.
[1:16:15]
Salaries and benefits will be based on approved labor
[1:16:17]
contracts, what does same time ensuring
[1:16:19]
that supplies and service service requests
[1:16:21]
relying with the board priorities.
[1:16:23]
And lastly, the proposed budget for capital projects
[1:16:26]
will be based on the draft of fiscal year 25
[1:16:29]
through 29 five year CIP.
[1:16:34]
In terms of the board work plan strategies,
[1:16:37]
we have the board strategies that were developed in fiscal year 24.
[1:16:41]
And this will be the basis for our first pass budget.
[1:16:44]
The second pass budget would be flight
[1:16:46]
and a new revised strategies that the board made the right.
[1:16:49]
Any new board direction before the end of January
[1:16:51]
would be incorporated as part of the second pass budget.
[1:16:57]
With that, in conclusion, our next steps will be to incorporate any
[1:17:01]
new boardwork strategies or direction provided by the board today or in the future.
[1:17:07]
We'll execute the touch point dates highlight on the slide that I previously reviewed
[1:17:11]
with you, and we thought I'm ready to answer any questions that you may have.
[1:17:15]
Thank you very much. Any board questions at this time?
[1:17:19]
We have any other comment?
[1:17:22]
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have no requests at this time.
[1:17:25]
Okay, Director Bell.
[1:17:32]
Curious why we're keeping our minds open about putting something on the ballot.
[1:17:42]
This year, next year, or 20, 26, or some other option.
[1:17:51]
And I would prefer to keep that issue open at this time till we see more information.
[1:18:02]
See, you'll calendar?
[1:18:05]
Yes, I think I could respond to that.
[1:18:07]
Right now we're just in the evaluation phase of what a potential GO bond can look like.
[1:18:12]
We are far from being able to even make a recommendation to the board.
[1:18:16]
I think we're in the very, very preliminary stages of evaluating what it could be,
[1:18:22]
what it could look like in, it would not be incorporated into this budget, obviously, because
[1:18:28]
that would be a far stretch to try to incorporate it, but we are trying to evaluate it.
[1:18:32]
And we will have more information as we go further into the evaluation for the board.
[1:18:36]
And this process is how we conducted these valid initiatives in the past, is that correct?
[1:18:41]
That's correct.
[1:18:43]
Exactly.
[1:18:44]
As we've started them in the past, we evaluate if it's practical, if we can do anything to move forward
[1:18:49]
and if so, we've been for the recommendations back to the board, but we're just getting
[1:18:54]
started with a very, very beginning stage.
[1:18:58]
Thank you, Sue.
[1:18:59]
Congratulations, Bert.
[1:19:02]
I appreciate my colleagues' comments, and I just, since I'm glad to hear that you're
[1:19:06]
just getting started, I guess I would want to just toss in there for consideration while you
[1:19:11]
do start to research this possibility, just a reminder that some of the bonds, many,
[1:19:18]
possibly most of the bonds elected by the public are set according to prop 13 real estate property tax rates.
[1:19:31]
And as we know, prop 13 is a highly regressive, literally highly regressive tax scheme.
[1:19:39]
And I guess I would just exercise caution with putting on the ballot any bond proposal that increases
[1:19:51]
the regressive nature of Prop 13, often voters are not aware of how they'll be harmed.
[1:20:00]
More greatly, that people lower income people will be harmed much more than higher income people with that framework.
[1:20:09]
So, I guess I just hope I just want to test that for consideration that we need to look out for the most vulnerable.
[1:20:16]
Thank you so much.
[1:20:18]
Thank you, Director.
[1:20:19]
So, we're that concludes item 3.7 on the agenda. Moving on to 3.8.
[1:20:24]
receive an overview of the fiscal year 2024-25 groundwater production charge and treated surface
[1:20:31]
water, raw surface water, and recycled water charges, setting process, review assumptions
[1:20:38]
of the 10-year water rate projection and state water project tax levy and provide feedback.
[1:20:45]
This also is an information item no action required and we have a report high.
[1:20:50]
Hi, good afternoon, Chevrolet members, the Board, Carmen Noreinen, Financial Planning and Revenue Manager and we have a brief presentation for you today to remind the Board, may I proceed?
[1:21:02]
Okay, thank you.
[1:21:03]
Our purpose today is to remind the Board of the groundwater production charge setting process and to obtain feedback as we look forward into the FY2425 rate setting cycle.
[1:21:14]
As you mentioned, no action today.
[1:21:16]
This is what we call a no numbers present,
[1:21:18]
Haitian, excuse me.
[1:21:20]
Topics will cover today are listed here.
[1:21:26]
The District Act has several requirements
[1:21:28]
for groundwater production charges,
[1:21:29]
including setting those charges once per year,
[1:21:33]
publishing an annual report,
[1:21:35]
it's the report on protection and augmentation
[1:21:37]
of water supplies,
[1:21:38]
finally called the pause report.
[1:21:40]
We must hold a public hearing
[1:21:42]
and Valley Water must establish groundwater benefits zones
[1:21:45]
of which we currently have for.
[1:21:49]
As defined in the District Act, groundwater charges can only cover the fourth herbicides shown
[1:21:54]
here, which include imported water facilities, imported water purchases, facilities which
[1:22:01]
will conserve or distribute water and debt.
[1:22:04]
We organize our expenditures at the project level and a project must further one of these
[1:22:08]
four purposes to be considered for the water utility.
[1:22:14]
This slide highlights the many activities that Valley Water undertakes to ensure safer
[1:22:19]
global groundwater supplies, such as improvements to our infrastructure, which are
[1:22:23]
highlighted on this map, purchasing imported water and maintaining local reservoirs.
[1:22:32]
Our surface water charge setting process is consistent with Proposition 218 for water
[1:22:37]
service charges and includes a protest procedure.
[1:22:41]
As the table shows here, we typically have zero to very few protests received from our
[1:22:46]
surface water customers,
[1:22:50]
and our groundwater charge setting process is consistent with
[1:22:54]
Proposition 26 and staff believes that the rate-setting process satisfies Prop 26 is two requirements as a non-text fee and those requirements are
[1:23:04]
One to be established at an amount no more that is no more than necessary to cover reasonable cost of the government activity
[1:23:11]
and two
[1:23:12]
That costs allocated to the pair must have a fair or reasonable relationship to the pair's burden on or benefits received from that government activity
[1:23:23]
Resolution 99-21 is the board's pricing policy, and it requires that groundwater charges are
[1:23:29]
levied within a zone for benefits received.
[1:23:32]
Our four zones are highlighted on this map to the right.
[1:23:35]
The policy is based on the pooling concept which helps maximize effective use of available
[1:23:40]
resources, and it also states that agricultural water charges, shall not be, shall not exceed
[1:23:45]
10% of our M&I, or municipal and industrial charges, and that is how our current rates
[1:23:51]
what our current rate structure follows.
[1:23:55]
Our groundwater charge setting processes highlighted here
[1:23:58]
in this flow, we begin in September,
[1:24:01]
and continue until rate adoption,
[1:24:02]
which is typically a May, and as my colleagues
[1:24:05]
highlighted before me, we're generally in sync
[1:24:07]
going throughout our three distinct processes.
[1:24:10]
So we've already begun our multi-year financial forecast.
[1:24:14]
And here we are today, as highlighted in the red box,
[1:24:17]
seeking board guidance will come back in January
[1:24:19]
with preliminary rate projections.
[1:24:23]
The pause report I mentioned before is filed in February.
[1:24:26]
That's also when we notify our well owners and surface water
[1:24:29]
customers of, um, with an notice for public hearings.
[1:24:32]
Those public hearings are held in May.
[1:24:34]
And then we come back again, you know,
[1:24:36]
excuse me, those public hearings are held in April,
[1:24:38]
and we come back again in May for rate adoption.
[1:24:41]
With an effective day of July first.
[1:24:44]
This slide demonstrates why there are different rates among our north
[1:24:47]
and South County on the left, we're highlighting infrastructure that's in North County on the right, South County, and then some of this infrastructure is shared, more infrastructure means more cost and.
[1:25:00]
Rates follow costs.
[1:25:05]
As we're looking forward to FY25 and the Rates setting cycle, we're keenly aware of impacts of inflation and a potential recession, and we're monitoring those trends.
[1:25:14]
The bottom line is that inflation will drive additional upward pressure on water rates, and we are anticipating the need to prepare various scenarios to highlight capital project prioritization or sequencing.
[1:25:27]
This
[1:25:31]
graph here highlights our district manage water use and that translates to revenue for the water utility.
[1:25:37]
It highlights prior year water use, our current year projections and future year or accurate budget and future projections.
[1:25:44]
We're also reviewing how an extended rebound from the drought would impact the water utility and rate projections.
[1:25:50]
So the blue bars on this graph indicate historical use.
[1:25:54]
We've called out the historic drought and the more recent drought there, the orange bars are current fiscal year budget of about 277,000 acre feed of water usage and then future year is shown in green and the black dotted line you see there would be a slower rebound from the drought and we're prepared to consider that as a scenario with board direction for the right setting cycle and that as you can see that flats out around 225,000 acre feet.
[1:26:24]
We also continue to work closely with our retailers to incorporate any feedback they have on water use and projections.
[1:26:34]
Our baseline, our FY-25 baseline case assumptions for now are highlighted on this slide.
[1:26:40]
I'll just cover them quickly.
[1:26:42]
Again, I mentioned the water use rebound from the recent drought.
[1:26:46]
Anderson dam, seismic retrofit is included in baseline, leveraging wifial loans.
[1:26:50]
The state water project tax we're assuming the tax will consider continue to pay for a hundred percent
[1:26:56]
The state water project costs only that does exclude the state water project portion of delta conveyance
[1:27:03]
Delta conveyance participation is included as well at 3.23 percent
[1:27:08]
We're incorporating the purified water expansion delivered via P3 with operations beginning in FY28
[1:27:14]
That's still in baseline consistency with prior years
[1:27:16]
as well as Lowes Fakera's Transfer Bethany Pipeline, which reflects up to 50,000
[1:27:22]
acre-feet of storage per prior board direction.
[1:27:25]
The Chaco Reservoir Expansion, with 35% Partner Participation, also leveraging
[1:27:30]
with the alums, is in Baseline, and I previously mentioned the agricultural
[1:27:34]
rate we're assuming it would remain at 10% of M&I.
[1:27:38]
So we're talking about the open space credit.
[1:27:40]
Is that correct?
[1:27:40]
For the agricultural rate?
[1:27:42]
Yes.
[1:27:42]
Yes.
[1:27:42]
Correct.
[1:27:43]
We would continue to leverage the open space credit.
[1:27:45]
Thank you. Yes, thank you.
[1:27:50]
So some ideas that we've had for scenarios for the board to consider. And again, we're here today asking for direction on baseline as I just went through baseline with the impacts of lower water use projections due to a slower drought rebound water use a potential impact with the successful geo on ballot measure is previously discussed or baseline with various capital project funding scenarios.
[1:28:15]
I also wanted to bring to the board's attention that we'll be back in, we're scheduled to come
[1:28:21]
back in March with a 40-year forecast for the water utility. This past March 2023, we did a 30-year
[1:28:26]
forecast. This would take it out to FY67 just to demonstrate all the big long-term activities we
[1:28:33]
have going on. The goal is to demonstrate the long-term health of the water utility in our
[1:28:39]
And once again, we would incorporate data available to us from the water supply master plan.
[1:28:46]
Capital improvement data and master plans and projects that will come out of that,
[1:28:50]
system-wide asset replacement needs, and are ongoing O&M and debt service obligations.
[1:28:58]
Okay, quickly, a schedule for the rate setting cycle for FY25.
[1:29:02]
We'll be back in January.
[1:29:04]
In February, we filed a pause report and mail out notices of public hearings to our direct customers.
[1:29:10]
In March, we are planning to bring that 40 year financial forecast review, April's a big month with several public hearings both here and in South County and then ideally we're before you in early May for rate adoption along with CIP and the biennial budget.
[1:29:27]
So like I mentioned before, we're here seeking guidance from you all for our baseline rate assumption and any scenarios the board would like to see and just general feedback as we go into the rate setting cycle.
[1:29:38]
Thank you for that very thorough report. Any comments from the board? Do I
[1:29:42]
address some board? Thank you so much for this report. Can you go back to
[1:29:48]
this slide where you talk about inputs to rate setting?
[1:29:53]
It's just one? Yeah, no worries, no rush. So was that the one?
[1:30:08]
I think we need to extend this to 60 years out, 6-0, rather than 40, and that's a little bit
[1:30:29]
because the terms of these wiffier loans are payback to 60 years in the future and it actually
[1:30:39]
might even be more than that, because I think the payback and date is set to the construction
[1:30:46]
start date, Mr. Taylor can correct me if I'm wrong. So that could be as much as 65 years or 70 years.
[1:30:55]
I think it's, I think we owe it to the rate pairs to actually see the long term impact of our choices.
[1:31:02]
For example, a couple weeks ago, without at least my knowing that this district closed on a $92 million loan,
[1:31:11]
that has a $287 million repainment obligation and that obligation is going to rest on future generations.
[1:31:18]
And I think that we need to just be more transparent about that and be as my colleague,
[1:31:27]
Dr. Bell said, you know, be more mindful about responsible choices, understanding the
[1:31:32]
impact on affordability it's going to have.
[1:31:36]
Additionally, when I look at this list, again, I guess I just want to again state for
[1:31:44]
record, you know, my question of when we're finally going to place a deadline on our inability
[1:31:51]
to get, you know, financial commitments on behalf of any partnerships with Pacheco. I find it,
[1:32:05]
you know, it is to me, my personal opinion, daughter of a bankruptcy judge, is that it is inappropriate
[1:32:12]
for us to continue to use that 35% discount given that it has been many years and we don't
[1:32:19]
have signed, you know, buy it, it's better to be transparent about what the costs are currently.
[1:32:28]
And although I was told that the project would in half end if we never gain that partnership,
[1:32:34]
maybe we need to set a deadline, you know, where if we don't have our partnership by the state,
[1:32:39]
It's just, it's just kind of as a perfectionist, type 1 on theogram.
[1:32:44]
It makes me a little nutty in my head to keep saying that.
[1:32:48]
And the other, I guess, point I would say about this too, is that,
[1:32:55]
I guess in general, I just think, and this, I think, is also a continuation of some of the ideas mentioned by Dr. Bell earlier.
[1:33:04]
I think we need to be really mindful about passing on the costs of our decisions to others.
[1:33:16]
It's, you know, without diving into the deep dive as to who pays this tax,
[1:33:21]
I just kind of feel uncomfortable having people that might be family farmers,
[1:33:28]
There might be rural families, you know, really stuck, putting the bill for decisions we
[1:33:38]
made for projects that may or may not assist them.
[1:33:43]
So that's just a general point, but overall I'm very impressed with your presentation.
[1:33:49]
I really applaud this level of transparency that enables me to make these observations,
[1:33:55]
that enables me to ask for more and I think it's really moving in the right
[1:34:01]
direction to have this. So thank you. I know I could tell that staff were
[1:34:07]
tired on this and it's really the kind of transparency I'm looking for. You know
[1:34:11]
with the transparency leads to more questions. Thank you so much for this.
[1:34:15]
Do we have any speakers on this item?
[1:34:20]
Yes, thank you Mr. Chair. We do have one
[1:34:22]
member of the public, Kasha Irvin.
[1:34:25]
And so then.
[1:34:32]
Good afternoon Board of Directors.
[1:34:36]
I wanted to say regards of baseline assumptions.
[1:34:39]
It would be prudent to have been lives on 35%
[1:34:42]
of partnership, partnership, participation, and then take out.
[1:34:47]
There's clearly a risk.
[1:34:49]
A risk, that level of participation will not be realized.
[1:34:53]
And it's better to plan for the worst to see how you can
[1:34:57]
just for this bottle of alcohol.
[1:35:01]
And regarding the scenario ideas, it's important to have a scenario with lower water use protection. For one, this is the trend in recent years, and with water conservation efforts, there's no reason to assume that locating, and also the latest population growth projections, projects, low to low population growth.
[1:35:25]
And lastly, the lower water use scenario is the risk scenario for the different impacting water sales revenues.
[1:35:35]
So it's printed to same the worst with respect to revenue and rate increases.
[1:35:41]
Thank you.
[1:35:42]
Thank you, Mr. Irvin.
[1:35:43]
Any other speakers at this point?
[1:35:47]
Yes.
[1:35:49]
Oh, I didn't see, I'm sorry.
[1:35:50]
The Director Bell.
[1:35:51]
Thank you.
[1:35:54]
I wanted to say that I think this racerating strategy should be based on our bigger discussion.
[1:36:04]
We're going to have on the last of January we were talking about, so I think.
[1:36:09]
For example, I'll just point out some things.
[1:36:12]
When we look at water use,
[1:36:17]
do we want to conserve water?
[1:36:19]
If we're going to conserve water, what's our plan to conserve water?
[1:36:23]
Can we increase the conserving of water in Santa Clara County?
[1:36:27]
Is that a priority?
[1:36:28]
We're going to put our money where our mouth is on that.
[1:36:31]
We're just going to push the issue more and conserve our water rather than have
[1:36:39]
a sort of engineering approach to providing water.
[1:36:44]
So I think that's an issue.
[1:36:46]
But I think also, when I look at the rest of this list, I don't see that as the top priority.
[1:36:54]
I wouldn't make that the top priority is water conservation.
[1:36:58]
I think population growth, the projections are important to look at.
[1:37:04]
We're not going to have the population growth we've thought of 40 years ago.
[1:37:08]
It's not going to occur.
[1:37:09]
It's not happening.
[1:37:12]
Unfortunately, everything's changed out.
[1:37:16]
Costs are living here, and the valley is going up, and I have so many people I've known
[1:37:23]
that said they can't afford to live anymore than moving out.
[1:37:30]
So it's sad to even talk about it, especially with the people that are, you know, we call
[1:37:40]
missing mental but there are people that are leaving our area. So I think that's our job
[1:37:47]
is to make it this area affordable for people. So the other thing is what is real real
[1:37:56]
idea behind building a peer-fired water program if we can't get the peer-fired water program
[1:38:08]
established in the city of San Jose where I live.
[1:38:14]
I mean, we had a plant that we completed and it was a good model, and it was done 10
[1:38:24]
years ago, and then nothing happened.
[1:38:27]
So I would like to push the start button on that and get going and have the great minds
[1:38:36]
figure out how we can finance it, how we can
[1:38:39]
move this project. We can have the city cooperation on this project. We're going to talk
[1:38:47]
to the city of San Jose this week. I think that's very important.
[1:38:54]
For me as a
[1:38:55]
San Jose person, I'm distressed that we aren't able to complete that project as quickly
[1:39:06]
And as efficiently as possible in cooperation with the State of San Jose, Santa Clara, Mopetus,
[1:39:13]
all the other tributary agencies that are part of the Santa Jose Santa Clara's sewage
[1:39:23]
treatment plan.
[1:39:25]
So I would like to see that as a top priority.
[1:39:31]
I think I've said this pretty much, I'm a broken record on this.
[1:39:35]
I hate to be it, but that's true.
[1:39:37]
I am a broken record,
[1:39:40]
and garnering support
[1:39:42]
for that project might be a little easier perhaps than we think
[1:39:48]
if we start doing that.
[1:39:50]
So the other thing that's not on there is what
[1:39:54]
happened to Delta in the San Luis Reservoir.
[1:40:02]
Project that could provide us some more water. Is that a cost effect? That's not, I don't see that here.
[1:40:10]
So I'm kind of wondering what that is. You asked for comments. That's a more like a question and a statement from it on myself.
[1:40:21]
So as a new person, I see this list here, but I don't see that.
[1:40:27]
So I'd like to have some understanding of that and I'll look at all the options everybody else has I'm going to be open to everybody else
[1:40:34]
Thoughts so
[1:40:37]
Thank you
[1:40:38]
Thank you
[1:40:39]
We have no more comments at this point on that item. We have some questions that Director Bell asked perhaps we can follow up
[1:40:44]
Directly back to him with those comments into the board
[1:40:47]
Thank you very much
[1:40:49]
Okay, we're moving on the agenda item 3.9
[1:40:52]
We see the winter preparedness briefing
[1:40:55]
information only? No action required on this side.
[1:41:07]
Good afternoon, Chair Vrella, Board of Directors. My name is Alex Anderson,
[1:41:11]
I'm the Assistant Officer for Emergency Safety and Security, and I have a
[1:41:15]
presentation if you'd like to hear it. Please. Okay, thank you.
[1:41:21]
So today's
[1:41:21]
discussion is going to cover the following topics, and each of these topics are
[1:41:25]
in alignment with our boards and policies.
[1:41:31]
Now you have in front of you the
[1:41:33]
forcast images and I do have to say that I'm a bit saddened that my colleague Brian Garcia
[1:41:38]
from the National Weather Service who is the warning coordination meteorologists is not available
[1:41:45]
today. Just found that out yesterday as they are dealing with the upcoming storms this week
[1:41:50]
and the evolving forecast. But with that he did prepare me to share the following information.
[1:41:56]
So the Climate Adaptation Center, which is part of the National Oceanic and atmospheric
[1:42:01]
administration is predicting a higher probability of above normal precipitation in our area.
[1:42:07]
Now, last year's winter storms wasn't anomaly. It was extremely wet and flooding did occur in
[1:42:12]
some areas. And usually California does not have repetitive wet seasons as such, but the current
[1:42:18]
forecast is acknowledging a likely wet season for the winter ahead. So what we're dealing with is
[1:42:23]
an El Nino, which brings warmer temperatures, and this El Nino is also bringing what appears to be
[1:42:29]
a wetter season going into the winter.
[1:42:36]
Now many of the capital projects that we
[1:42:39]
accomplish here at Valley Water,
[1:42:41]
their goal is to literally take homes
[1:42:43]
and businesses out of the floodplain.
[1:42:46]
The images in front of you are one of my favorite projects.
[1:42:49]
I'm a literally baseball coach,
[1:42:51]
so our partnership with the city of Mountain View,
[1:42:54]
where we built this detention basin for flooding,
[1:42:57]
along with building a baseball field,
[1:42:59]
was a great partnership where, you know, during the day, during normal operations, we have a
[1:43:05]
great part for the community to use, but during times of extreme storms and where permanent
[1:43:10]
take, Creek may cause flooding downstream. Water could be redirected into the detention
[1:43:16]
basin, therefore mitigating the potential flooding downstream.
[1:43:24]
Now, along with our capital
[1:43:24]
projects comes many, many hours and efforts for maintenance. What's really important is that
[1:43:32]
You know, we maintain our waterways throughout the year.
[1:43:35]
It's not something that we do just when the winter gets here.
[1:43:37]
This is done throughout the calendar season.
[1:43:40]
As you can see here, some before and after pictures,
[1:43:43]
when it comes to sediment removal, and why do we remove sediment?
[1:43:46]
So sediment that builds up into our waterways, lessons capacity.
[1:43:50]
And when you have less capacity, then the water flowing through it
[1:43:54]
doesn't flow as designed.
[1:43:56]
The example that I usually use is, if you take a bathtub and you fill it up
[1:44:00]
about three quarters away, hey, no spill and no problem there.
[1:44:03]
But if you happen to get into that bathtub,
[1:44:05]
depending on who you are, that water may overflow.
[1:44:09]
So not to say that people are sediments,
[1:44:11]
but the fact that we really want to make sure
[1:44:13]
we get all the stuff out of our waterways
[1:44:15]
so that the flows can perform as designed.
[1:44:22]
Now, along with the sediment removal
[1:44:23]
is we do a lot of vegetation management throughout the year.
[1:44:26]
If you take a look at the images of the before and after,
[1:44:29]
you can see a lot of stuff growing on the left side,
[1:44:31]
but on the right side, a lot of clear area for water to flow.
[1:44:35]
Now, a little bit different in sediment, of course,
[1:44:37]
it does just place water, but as water flows through,
[1:44:40]
and you have a lot of things getting in the way,
[1:44:42]
then the water is going to go sideways up, down, left and right.
[1:44:45]
And again, the water channels are not going to perform as designed.
[1:44:49]
So it's really important for us to get this vegetation management done,
[1:44:52]
so that again, water flows through our creeks as design.
[1:44:59]
Now, for the next section here,
[1:45:00]
Here, I'm going to hand this over to my colleague, Paola Reyes, who's going to introduce some new things that our communication team has accomplished this year going into the winter season.
[1:45:18]
Good afternoon, Chair of our Ellen Members of the Board, Paola Reyes from the Office of Communications. I am here today to share our strategies and support of our goal to reduce flood risk through public engagement.
[1:45:29]
Every year, Valley Water launches a flood awareness campaign which runs rather rainy season.
[1:45:35]
Our main message for the 2023-24 season is any time it rains that can flood, get flood ready.
[1:45:42]
This year, our campaign is promoting three main cause to action.
[1:45:46]
Know your flood risk, sign up for alerts and get sandbags.
[1:45:52]
We deliver our flood preparedness message directly to the mailboxes of the 48,000 plus homes and businesses
[1:45:59]
in the FEMA special flood hazard area or SFAHA.
[1:46:03]
In 2023-24, we are sending four pieces of direct mail,
[1:46:08]
staggered rather in the season,
[1:46:10]
and we are grateful that several cities
[1:46:11]
are sharing our message through bill inserts.
[1:46:15]
As you can see in this slide, the mailings
[1:46:17]
prominently feature our message to indicate
[1:46:21]
that the recipient lives in a flood zone
[1:46:23]
are pulling last year,
[1:46:24]
found that 48% of flood zone residents know their risk,
[1:46:27]
and we're focusing on raising awareness further as a primary motivator for preparedness.
[1:46:33]
Our multilingual maelings, which I believe you received a sample of, include our nine
[1:46:39]
flood preparedness tips as required by the community rating systems so our partner cities kind of
[1:46:44]
think credit that results in lower flood insurance premiums for our community.
[1:46:53]
This year, we're also
[1:46:54]
running a significant digital campaign with adds target to the IP addresses in devices
[1:47:01]
registered to homes in the FEMA SFAJ, there's an addition to social media ads, Google ads,
[1:47:07]
and banners, and malpayling wellness papers.
[1:47:12]
We're also focusing extensively again this year
[1:47:15]
on what our hydrologists call hotspots or areas prone to flooding. We are conducting additional
[1:47:21]
outreach these areas, which include traditional and digital advertising.
[1:47:28]
As such, our S&P teams
[1:47:29]
have hung banners at 12 intersections and hotspot areas. We want to see these when driving around
[1:47:34]
community. We also sent a package of table-tap signs and
[1:47:38]
flood preparedness resources to 60 community associations in the
[1:47:42]
hotspot areas, including mobile home parks, libraries, senior
[1:47:45]
centers, schools, recreation centers and community associations.
[1:47:50]
On the digital side, we are harnessing new technologies to target
[1:47:54]
our ads further to the hotspots. This allows us to send a special
[1:47:58]
flood awareness message to the IP addresses of all devices in the
[1:48:04]
events such as the one forecast for this area and we have triggered one of such alert today.
[1:48:12]
Again, also, we are engaging our city partners as a powerful tool for agency to split our
[1:48:17]
flood awareness messaging. As we do every year, we have shared a partner toolkit with cities,
[1:48:22]
retailers, and elected officials with links to our social media messages and offering our
[1:48:27]
co-branding opportunities for billizzers. This concludes my presentation. Thank you for your
[1:48:32]
I'm in attention, and I'll hand it over to Alex.
[1:48:35]
Thank you, Pablo.
[1:48:36]
There's a very good presentation.
[1:48:37]
Thank you, Trevor.
[1:48:38]
Really?
[1:48:46]
You too, Gordon.
[1:48:47]
Thank you.
[1:48:48]
So as we prepare to respond, so we have the work that we do throughout the year, but as we get
[1:48:53]
close to the season, as we are now, we are prepared to respond and effectively manage the flood
[1:48:58]
emergencies.
[1:48:59]
I'm going to cover a little bit about monitoring, also the emergency management aspect,
[1:49:03]
and then fuel operations.
[1:49:07]
So the flood watch tool that you see in the image to the left of you is a public tool
[1:49:11]
that's offered on our Valley Water Fledged Reddy website.
[1:49:15]
It allows for up to about 15 minutes of real-time status
[1:49:20]
of creeks and reservoirs.
[1:49:22]
There's also tools in there for rain gauges
[1:49:24]
and whatnot, a lot of good information
[1:49:26]
to be shared with the public there.
[1:49:28]
And then the other images of the different tools
[1:49:30]
that we use to actually obtain the data
[1:49:32]
from the field as far as the gauges
[1:49:35]
and also the Expand Rader radar on penitentiated water
[1:49:39]
plant rooftop. So all of these tools help all of our hydrologists staff to monitor, but
[1:49:46]
also, most importantly, provide projections that we share to our partner agencies.
[1:49:53]
Now, ballot wars and emergency management is extensive. We do have emergency operations
[1:49:57]
centers, department operations centers.
[1:50:01]
We operate under the standardized emergency management system here in California, and we do lots of training and coordination with our partner.
[1:50:10]
Adencies, most recently, we had our annual winner preparedness workshop for external Adencies on October 26.
[1:50:17]
And we were able to get over 90 registered participants to hear about valley waters operations, how we respond.
[1:50:24]
And it's a event that is received really well from those that we work with.
[1:50:32]
For field operations, there are different areas where work is to be done.
[1:50:35]
In regards to the reservoir operations, there are different times based on the status of
[1:50:40]
the reservoir levels and the incoming storms where water may be released in order to mitigate
[1:50:45]
potential flooding and uncontrolled water flow into the creeks.
[1:50:50]
We operate a watershed 247 hotline where we can receive information from the public and then
[1:50:56]
responding accordingly, where we are allowed to,
[1:50:59]
basement or property, and our easements.
[1:51:02]
We do everything that we can to do
[1:51:04]
Bucket removal when safe.
[1:51:05]
If you take a look at the picture on the left,
[1:51:08]
Lotted debris had developed next to this bridge,
[1:51:11]
and was actually causing structure concerns.
[1:51:14]
And as you can see, we were able to respond to that,
[1:51:17]
and safely remove some of that debris
[1:51:20]
so that bad things didn't occur from that.
[1:51:22]
We also had field information teams
[1:51:24]
that we spread out in different areas of hot spots,
[1:51:26]
based on where the storms are coming,
[1:51:29]
to supplement our remote monitoring from our hydrologist,
[1:51:33]
but to give eyes on and feel to see what we're seeing,
[1:51:36]
as far as water levels and finding different areas
[1:51:39]
where a response is needed and debris is building up.
[1:51:44]
And last but not least,
[1:51:45]
we are definitely in the Sandbad Business here at Valley Water.
[1:51:49]
We have five sites that we own,
[1:51:51]
but we also support an additional 19 throughout the county
[1:51:54]
in the different cities.
[1:51:55]
We have filled sandbags on our sites and for the ones throughout the county we either provide sandbags or sandbag resources which is loose sand and empty bags.
[1:52:08]
This was an extensive effort last year to meet the demand.
[1:52:12]
We are prepared and everything is stocked for this year.
[1:52:15]
So we will continue these operations as we did last year and hopes of getting the resources to the public as needed.
[1:52:24]
That concludes my presentation.
[1:52:25]
I'll take any questions.
[1:52:26]
Thank you, director Eisenberg.
[1:52:29]
Thank you so much for this presentation.
[1:52:31]
It was extremely helpful, and I think it really highlighted some of this agency's strengths.
[1:52:37]
I think for sure one of our strengths is the emergency.
[1:52:41]
Can you go back a couple slides, you know?
[1:52:46]
Well, it's okay if you can't.
[1:52:48]
Just I think our emergency response center is fantastic.
[1:52:52]
It's exceptional.
[1:52:54]
I like the other directors, the opportunity to visit it and during the time of the worst, and I think it does a really good job, and you should be rightfully proud of that.
[1:53:06]
I mean, area where I think we could do a little more, and this might be an issue of bureaucracy and falling between the cracks, and is this my department or yours, but I think an area that we could invest more in is really in prevention.
[1:53:22]
And, again, without knowing whether that's your department or someone else's, I spend a
[1:53:28]
lot of time looking at to see what the met is doing because they have this incredible
[1:53:32]
innovative, well-regarded new director, and who's doing this just really, in my opinion,
[1:53:39]
amazing stuff he's doing, and some of the things that he's doing for to mitigate harm
[1:53:47]
floods. I think our things we should look at and consider and in particular a couple of those
[1:53:52]
items include large-scale infrastructure level, stormwater capture. More than just helping to subsidize
[1:54:02]
barrels on a house by house basis, but there are means and I know that Dr. Green who's one of
[1:54:08]
our staff members in different departments engaged in a, you know, has us involved in a study
[1:54:15]
to really explore kind of larger scale infrastructure.
[1:54:18]
But in my mind, capturing that water as it comes in
[1:54:22]
before it becomes polluted by runoff,
[1:54:24]
I think it's really low-hanging fruit and a missed opportunity for us
[1:54:28]
that would, you know, one increase the water supply to, you know,
[1:54:33]
protect our communities, you know, from, you know, from
[1:54:36]
flood damage since it does actually well, with done well, it actually
[1:54:39]
captures a lot of that water. You know, and three really makes us more resilient
[1:54:44]
Because, as you pointed out, if the only thing we know about our climate right now is that it is unpredictable.
[1:54:52]
The prediction is who knows, new things that have never happened before, is pretty much the definitional part.
[1:55:01]
Second thing that I've been really impressed watching them, the math and others invest in, is removal of non-porous cover, ground cover, like cement to replace it with porous.
[1:55:15]
And sometimes that requires getting used to a different kind of street feeling or bike path feeling.
[1:55:22]
But this has been, like, a lot of success in Europe in Asia, in Middle East, you know, elsewhere.
[1:55:30]
Those are not that.
[1:55:30]
I should take a, there's not too much rain, but when it rains at storms, you know, in a lot of places.
[1:55:36]
You know, to, um, very high success rate.
[1:55:38]
And I think that is something we should be looking into since it does help protect communities from flood damage.
[1:55:45]
And I think that, that third is, um, I mentioned this before, but I've been really, really impressed
[1:55:52]
with what some East Bay and like central California counties are doing when it comes to putting
[1:55:59]
halts on developments for on riparian lands. Since I'm learning so much, I learned so much
[1:56:07]
about flood is part of the San Francisco Creek JPA, which is an ongoing flood risk, you know,
[1:56:14]
at that continues. This year's not going to be pretty for East Fellow Alto,
[1:56:17]
in Palo Alto. It's just, especially with the delay of those projects. But, you know, one
[1:56:23]
thing that they're really, that I've learned with working on the Los Aceros, JPA is the benefit
[1:56:30]
of having counties and regional authorities banned development on riparian land that often
[1:56:38]
it's that development that increases risk of harm from flooding. And just preserving that riparian
[1:56:44]
land for habitat and wild, you know, and wilderness and letting the water go down there can
[1:56:50]
really protect our communities. Now, I know we don't make those statues, but we do have
[1:56:55]
a big lobbying arm and maybe we could work a little harder partner partnering with others
[1:57:00]
to get that kind of thing past because it's in really successful, you know, for them. And I guess,
[1:57:06]
you know, the last kind of common I want to make is that while I think we're fantastic with response,
[1:57:11]
Once you're at the level of thinking about your insurance, you know, premiums, or insurance
[1:57:16]
payments, or even sandbags, you're already in trouble, you know, you're already in ideal
[1:57:23]
world, we don't have to handle the sandbags at all, because we have, you know, fewer flood
[1:57:28]
risks.
[1:57:30]
So, I guess one thing I just would promote, and I know that we all agree with this on some
[1:57:35]
is that sometimes we get afraid of moving forward because it's not perfect yet and I think we, you know, we all risk from letting the perfect be the enemy of the good enough.
[1:57:49]
And again, this probably is for a different department who would be working on these, but it's just my thoughts to consider.
[1:57:56]
But in the meantime, I really am impressed with your work and the hard work of this presentation in the articulate way you presented it.
[1:58:03]
So thank you so much.
[1:58:03]
Thank you for your free back.
[1:58:05]
Throughout your Kagan.
[1:58:07]
Thank you, and thank you, Mr. Gordon and staff,
[1:58:10]
to the presentation.
[1:58:12]
If we look at page three of the presentation,
[1:58:17]
you know, to me it says a lot.
[1:58:20]
And what it's saying is, let's wait till it comes up.
[1:58:23]
It's the one with the maps.
[1:58:27]
I think it's before that.
[1:58:29]
It's like page three.
[1:58:32]
Very close.
[1:58:36]
This is the capital one?
[1:58:39]
No, it's the maps with the forecasting, National Weather Service, and so there's the seasonal precipitation outlook, which is showing for our area above normal.
[1:58:52]
And then there's the seasonal temperature outlook and I feel like a lot of focus in the press and everything has been on the rainfall.
[1:59:00]
And I do think we've done an excellent job of preparing, you know, in terms of the work
[1:59:08]
that's been done by our stream maintenance staff, all of those things.
[1:59:15]
But it's really this.
[1:59:17]
And I think people understand it's raining, there's going to be a lot of water.
[1:59:22]
I think the seasonal temperature impacts are actually what's concerning me because it's not necessarily
[1:59:28]
that intuitive to people, like if it's warm weather and the rain isn't being stored as snow
[1:59:35]
in the Sierra Snow Pack, but it's just coming down and exacerbating the existing rain that we have
[1:59:41]
within our communities. I think that's going to be a real challenge. I think it's something that
[1:59:46]
that the community hasn't been prepared for. So I know you guys are aware of this because you're
[1:59:52]
not in at me. You know it's a concern as well. I think we're going to have to be nimble as we see.
[1:59:57]
I mean, I'm hoping we have a nice...
[2:00:00]
We went with winter, with cold weather, and we are able to store a lot of water and snow. But I definitely think
[2:00:09]
the public just isn't used to having that combination in recent years of wet weather and warm weather. So it's not helping build up the CRSO pack.
[2:00:20]
So I think messaging about that, if that comes to happen, is going to be really critical. Because, you know, it's like the first day that it rains and you see people driving.
[2:00:29]
And they're like, they've never driven and what weathered before.
[2:00:33]
Well, you know, how about four or five years after they've experienced a condition like this?
[2:00:38]
So that's just my comments.
[2:00:41]
And I appreciate that you're not the weather expert.
[2:00:44]
And I'm sorry he wasn't able to join us today.
[2:00:46]
But clearly he's concerned because he's preparing for those upcoming storms.
[2:00:49]
So thank you.
[2:00:50]
Thank you for your feedback.
[2:00:52]
Director Schwit.
[2:00:56]
Thank you.
[2:00:56]
Thank you, Jeff.
[2:00:59]
I just wanted to say thanks, staff.
[2:01:01]
for continually making progress on these hot spots that it's just every year that you see it's better or reaching and then get people to understand and all that.
[2:01:17]
Thank you very much.
[2:01:19]
Thank you.
[2:01:21]
Thank you.
[2:01:21]
Do we have any members of the public that choose to address this item today?
[2:01:25]
Thank you Mr. Chair.
[2:01:26]
I have no request at this time.
[2:01:28]
Okay.
[2:01:29]
Thank you for a very thorough report today.
[2:01:31]
appreciate it. It's interesting, watching the local news, if you've been following all the weather reports
[2:01:38]
and the weather competition from all these local stations and how they're preparing and
[2:01:43]
giving us their new stations. Very dramatic using AI and other formulas. I think KPIX is really
[2:01:49]
important to me. I'm not an endorsing anybody, but they seem to have a race going on as to who gives
[2:01:54]
the best weather report in our community. So far KPIX, I think, hasn't. So that's just my comment.
[2:01:59]
Moving on the agenda we have the consent calendar coming up item 4.1 to 4.7. This is a roll call vote
[2:02:08]
Do you want to speak now? I want to pull a couple things. Okay, direct rise
[2:02:13]
4.6 and 4.7
[2:02:15]
Pull those for discussion and separate discussion. Yeah, I can I can you know the time for me to speak about that is later
[2:02:21]
4.6 and 4.7. Okay. Yeah, so item 4.1 through 4.5
[2:02:27]
five. Actually, I wanted to pull item 4.5.
[2:02:31]
5.
[2:02:35]
Okay.
[2:02:37]
Are you pulling them all? What are you doing?
[2:02:43]
All right. 4.1 through 4.4.
[2:02:46]
A roll call vote.
[2:02:52]
That's how I missed your share.
[2:02:53]
Did I hear a motion?
[2:02:54]
Yes, I have a motion in the second.
[2:02:56]
Okay, thank you.
[2:02:57]
Miss that.
[2:02:59]
Director Bell?
[2:03:01]
Director Eisenberg?
[2:03:02]
Yes.
[2:03:02]
Directress Marra, Director Shua, yes, Director Keegan, Director Santos,
[2:03:09]
Chervoro.
[2:03:10]
Yes.
[2:03:11]
Separate item for discussion 4.5.
[2:03:15]
Accept the work as complete and direct to the clerk of the file.
[2:03:17]
The notice of completion of contract in the acceptance of the work for the lower
[2:03:20]
Pentechure Creek Improvements Project Stage 1, civil work,
[2:03:24]
milestone 1, Gordon N. Ball Incorporated, contract project number 40334005,
[2:03:29]
contract number C, 0, 6, 5, 5. This is in district 3 area. Report on this place, okay?
[2:03:41]
It doesn't look like there.
[2:03:42]
Yeah.
[2:03:43]
It doesn't.
[2:03:44]
I actually just had a comment on it.
[2:03:46]
Sure.
[2:03:47]
Okay.
[2:03:49]
I frequently pull these items.
[2:03:52]
When I noticed that the contingency has been spent up to the limit.
[2:03:58]
So I would just like to commend staff for effectively managing the contingency
[2:04:02]
and keeping it at a low level, I appreciate that.
[2:04:06]
So thank you.
[2:04:07]
OK, you want to take a step of vote on that now?
[2:04:09]
Do you want to wait to hear the others, too?
[2:04:11]
4.6, comment?
[2:04:15]
Sorry, so I'm sorry.
[2:04:17]
So I guess I, this is more kind of my OCD process question.
[2:04:24]
So it is the attachment was dated in March.
[2:04:30]
And although I know I'm going to agree with this,
[2:04:33]
I guess it would be helpful to me just to hear, you know, for the public's benefit, the
[2:04:39]
rational be kind, the, you know, the extending this, which again I'm going to agree with.
[2:04:45]
And also this is a question for the chair that I understand that this particular item required
[2:04:51]
a four-fifth vote, and that is different from other matters, other matters on the consent calendar.
[2:05:00]
And this is the first time I see that. As you know, I just devilish on the details. So it's, you know, I expect, I'm just curious how that's usually handled. Maybe that's a question for the district council, if the chair agrees.
[2:05:16]
It's not a criticism.
[2:05:17]
You want an explanation now, or is this?
[2:05:19]
If a proprio?
[2:05:20]
Yes, see, how do you have a comment on that?
[2:05:23]
For the fourth is vote, I'm going to look to Council and talk about the fourth this is okay, and then I'm trying to decide to determine the March date that.
[2:05:31]
Oh, in the, I'm, and to, I'm sorry, March 9, 2023.
[2:05:34]
Yeah, it says March, yeah, March 9, 10, 2023 is the, and on the attachments that is provided is back up for this item.
[2:05:42]
So, you know, again, I don't think this is going to be controversial.
[2:05:46]
I'm just, you know, it's, I think it's always just helpful when there's not a more current attachment,
[2:05:51]
and just to have a statement, a more current statement.
[2:05:56]
So the March 9th, 2023, I'm going to look to a chief, you know, just to make sure I'm correct,
[2:06:00]
but that's when the initial emergency was declared, and I believe that's why the attachment
[2:06:05]
continues on from that date.
[2:06:08]
Chief, you have anything else to add, and then we'll look to a council for the Fourth of
[2:06:12]
the Soul.
[2:06:14]
It is accurate.
[2:06:17]
That's not really my question, I can see that a state of March 10th and that's when it begins.
[2:06:21]
I guess I'm asking for the rationale behind that, too, if you want to listen.
[2:06:25]
You know, that's really.
[2:06:27]
Okay.
[2:06:28]
Legal counsel areas.
[2:06:31]
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
[2:06:33]
I think I can help here.
[2:06:35]
So, public contact code section 2250 is the section that authorizes local agencies to forego general
[2:06:43]
contracting requirements in the event of a declared emergency and it has different
[2:06:48]
role to pay on who to clarity emergency regular reporting, but one thing that is common is that
[2:06:53]
one emergency has been declared and action has been taken pursuant to that authority.
[2:06:58]
The board has to approve the continuation of those actions at every regular meeting thereafter
[2:07:03]
until the emergency has concluded.
[2:07:05]
So that's the rationale for continuing to do this because the work, my understanding is that
[2:07:09]
the work is not yet complete, so we have to keep the work, we have to keep requests
[2:07:12]
at the board, we authorize that action.
[2:07:17]
Is it difficult, if I may, do the chair, to put out a issue that requires a
[2:07:25]
forfist majority on the same consent calendar?
[2:07:28]
I mean, maybe that's standard.
[2:07:30]
I'm still relatively speaking new.
[2:07:33]
It is certainly, it's a matter of consistent with both this agencies prior practice
[2:07:37]
in my prior agencies' practice and my understanding is that lots of agencies do, in fact,
[2:07:42]
But those continuing things on consent, the four fifth requirement is the non-golem requirement that's in the contract and public contract code as well.
[2:07:50]
My recollections that every prior item has had the four fifths will call down.
[2:07:56]
Thanks so much.
[2:07:57]
So this slide, you?
[2:07:58]
I am one hundred percent.
[2:07:59]
That's a four point seven.
[2:08:00]
Okay, so for four point seven.
[2:08:03]
So I guess we're in my notes on this.
[2:08:06]
So I guess just in line with some issues about transparency.
[2:08:12]
I'm really only talking about number, where's five points, or just five, about, you know,
[2:08:23]
in this number five, it says that on October 30th, value at our close to 92 million
[2:08:29]
dollar loan that will have a repayment obligation of 285.7 million dollars,
[2:08:37]
In other words, 286 million and so I guess to me it would just be kind of helpful to
[2:08:49]
hear and explanation of why that was a good idea.
[2:08:57]
I guess in particular because we know that there were fixed costs associated with that
[2:09:02]
that weren't disclosed, such as $300,000 of a sunk cost of the application and those closing costs,
[2:09:11]
as well as the default provisions where failure to do the project as stated is an event of default,
[2:09:22]
and upon an event of default, the EPA, the lender, has the right to accelerate, not just this loan,
[2:09:30]
But all loans, and that is consistent with Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code, that our collateral is actually future revenues.
[2:09:41]
So if the project goes away, then the collateral goes away, and when collateral goes away under the UCC, the lender has the right to accelerate all loans.
[2:09:53]
I guess I mean, I guess I want to say something else.
[2:09:56]
I guess I want to say that I think it could be helpful to them.
[2:10:00]
Ratepayers, if we engage, especially in these trying fiscal times, it might be helpful to think
[2:10:08]
about having an experienced commercial lending, secure lending attorney, you know, a specialist,
[2:10:17]
you know, with no disrespect to our capable legal department. Sometimes specialists are called in to
[2:10:24]
really help review and as a program negotiate to the extent possible, these might not be negotiable.
[2:10:33]
At least explain that the fine print of these types of loans, I booked pretty closely detailed person at the agreement that
[2:10:45]
but Valley Watersind and these terms,
[2:10:47]
events of default are pretty concerning for me.
[2:10:51]
I mean, it makes sense from the lenders point of view,
[2:10:53]
but I don't think we want to inadvertently
[2:10:56]
put our other projects like Anderson at risk.
[2:11:00]
Upon failure to go through with the Pacheco project,
[2:11:05]
which is a very clear possibility, you know?
[2:11:10]
So I guess I really, you know, obviously,
[2:11:14]
I will give the CO time to respond, but I do hope also that the CO and maybe the any other appropriate party will consider bringing in a subject matter expert on
[2:11:27]
Commer on these secured loans because there's a lot of stuff that I think will impact a rate payers that I think we the board
[2:11:35]
Should be able to consider on a case-by-case basis, so I appreciate you considering this loss
[2:11:41]
Do you see the calendar?
[2:11:43]
Yes, I did want to assure the board that we do have a very qualified bond council, external
[2:11:48]
bond council, that has reviewed these loans and that has worked very closely.
[2:11:53]
Additionally, we will have a very detailed Q&A on this loan.
[2:11:58]
I believe there was a variety of questions that have been asked for the past week that will
[2:12:02]
respond to a lot of the director's questions and questions that have been raised today
[2:12:06]
as well over the last week and so that will be in the next, let's see your bulletin.
[2:12:10]
Thank you, just I just need to point out again that bond councils are very that's a very different law practice
[2:12:18]
Extremely different and I'm talking about secured loans under the uniform commercial code article nine and that is a very separate
[2:12:26]
That expertise and
[2:12:28]
That doesn't really overlap
[2:12:30]
so
[2:12:31]
I'm going to again state my my preference that I do think it would be helpful for our constituents
[2:12:37]
you know, and to have give more information to the board so we can consider these beforehand and appreciate your thinking about it.
[2:12:46]
So do you have a motion on item 4.5, 6 and 7? Okay, motion. Do I have a second?
[2:12:51]
Thank you. The roll call please.
[2:12:55]
Director Bell. Director Eisenberg. Yes. Director Estimara.
[2:12:59]
Director Shua. Yes. Director Keegan. Director Santas.
[2:13:04]
Yes, okay, those items all pass you anonymously moving on the agenda board of directors item 5.1
[2:13:13]
Consider the September 7th, 2023 board policy and planning committee recommendations to approve the proposed staff support to the Santa Clara Valley Water Commission and
[2:13:22]
Agriculture Water Advisory Committee with the same level that has been successful for the environmental and water resource committee
[2:13:28]
This is an action item. We have a report on this.
[2:13:32]
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
[2:13:35]
This item is brought to the board as a recommendation from the board policy and planning
[2:13:39]
committee during their September 7th meeting.
[2:13:43]
One of the tasks assigned to the board policy and planning committee is to review the effectiveness
[2:13:50]
of the board advisory committee, which are the Environmental Water Resources Committee, the
[2:13:55]
Santa Clara Valley Water Commission and the Agricultural Water Advisory Committee.
[2:14:00]
The reason they review these effectiveness is to determine the ensure that the committees are
[2:14:07]
effectively engaging in supporting the board's work in the district's mission.
[2:14:12]
So this year, the Board Policy and Planning Committee invited the 2022 or 2023 committee
[2:14:18]
chairs or vice chairs to attend a meeting and give them, give the committee some feedback
[2:14:22]
on committees assigned purposes, accomplishments, and suggested areas of improvement.
[2:14:27]
The information was collected and in your agenda member, you'll see that it was categorized
[2:14:33]
in two areas, what's working and possible improvements.
[2:14:38]
What was working was very, very clear to the committee, and that was that the staff support
[2:14:44]
of the environmental water resources committee was working well for them, the staff meets
[2:14:51]
regularly with a chair or vice chair or both of the environmental resources committee,
[2:14:57]
prior to meetings and help them.
[2:15:01]
Identify two items for each agenda. One of them is a substantial item that for the committee input and discussion that typically works with what's coming before the board and the other is just a brief more informational item for the committee to receive.
[2:15:17]
So that was working well and there were a few items for improvement.
[2:15:24]
Most of those I think the committee felt that could be addressed during these pre-meatings
[2:15:30]
with the chairs and vice-chairs of the committee because they were kind of individual improvements
[2:15:35]
for committee related things versus the bigger advisory committee, the accomplishment.
[2:15:42]
One of the other needs improvements that they identified was the need for orientation, training
[2:15:47]
for new advisory committee members, and we have done that in the past, so we staff will look
[2:15:52]
into revamping their antition to model it after value waters, water ambassador 101 program.
[2:15:58]
That was some of the feedback that we received from the committee chairs and vice-chairs.
[2:16:03]
So this item is brought before the board today for the board to approve, giving allowing staff
[2:16:09]
to provide that same support to the water commission and agricultural water advisory committee,
[2:16:15]
to help them identify those items that will hopefully provide them some more opportunity
[2:16:22]
to give the board feedback and give them some more information and for staff to work with
[2:16:27]
them to incorporate any areas of improvement that they want in upcoming agenda items.
[2:16:33]
Basically, it is just as stated in the financial section, it's less than two hours of
[2:16:39]
staff's times two to three times a year, so it's not a significant amount of time.
[2:16:42]
And with that, I stand open for the chair of the BPPC or any of the committee members are open for any questions.
[2:16:48]
Thank you very much.
[2:16:49]
Let's chair Keegan.
[2:16:51]
Thank you.
[2:16:52]
I just wanted to say given the modest increase in resources, I support this particularly in terms of the water commission.
[2:17:01]
I've long felt that there's a disconnect sometimes between the appointees to the water commission.
[2:17:08]
and they're understanding of how we operate and the things that we do and anything that we
[2:17:16]
can do to facilitate educating them so that they're able to give really meaningful feedback
[2:17:25]
to us.
[2:17:26]
They're very knowledgeable about the issues in their community.
[2:17:29]
We just want to make sure that they're able to translate those issues into the appropriate
[2:17:37]
way that works with our organization. And of course, you know, the Farm Bureau, they're an
[2:17:43]
important part of this county, particularly South County, and we want to make sure that
[2:17:48]
they can be effective with their interactions with us as well. So I'd like to make a motion
[2:17:53]
to support that. Thank you. I have a motion in a second on that. Any other discussion items of the board?
[2:17:59]
Do we have public comment on that? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have no request at this time.
[2:18:03]
Okay, action is to approve item 5.1 as suggested and recommend it by our clerk of the board.
[2:18:11]
All those in favor signify by saying aye.
[2:18:13]
Aye.
[2:18:13]
All opposed.
[2:18:15]
That measure passes unanimously as well.
[2:18:17]
Thank you.
[2:18:18]
Moving on to agenda to 5.2.
[2:18:20]
Consider the October 13th, 2023.
[2:18:23]
Water storage exploratory committees recommendation.
[2:18:26]
Concerning future topics regarding the Chaco Reservoir Expansion Project to be discussed in more detail.
[2:18:32]
This is an action item, Director Schweyer.
[2:18:39]
Thank you, Chair.
[2:18:40]
I will start just by providing some background to my colleague that why this item is on this
[2:18:49]
agenda.
[2:18:50]
And since the last fully update step provided to this board, there's a many questions because the material that's prepared was focused on costs of the project actual costs that's already spent up to date and then projected future estimated costs.
[2:19:18]
I was the, and in this schedule, that was the material that's in front of the board.
[2:19:24]
However, there are many questions by board members and also by community members, environmental
[2:19:32]
groups who participated on Zoom for that discussion.
[2:19:37]
So with that in mind, that the storage exploratory committee has some discussion, and then
[2:19:46]
we recommend to the full board to direct staff that in these futures scheduled to
[2:19:54]
correlate update for a particular reservoir project that
[2:20:00]
A list of topic be included for the Food Board to have more complete in-depth discussion.
[2:20:11]
And so the item today is intended for the Board to give direction to staff to include these in the future discussion.
[2:20:20]
The item today is not for the Board to talk about the project.
[2:20:25]
And, of course, this list of things that the committee can think of at the time when we discuss
[2:20:30]
it, there's probably other topic as the board move forward in discussion, they will just
[2:20:35]
come up or jump up and then then it's a living list and the idea is that for the committee
[2:20:43]
to support the board in the board's decision making process, that's what I always feel that
[2:20:49]
it's the committee's job, the committee's job is not to make the decision for the board
[2:20:53]
coming job is to support the board and then in the board's decision making process, particularly
[2:20:59]
for this very important and then huge investment for this organization, so that's our recommendation
[2:21:10]
and hopefully that the board will be in agreement and give staff to the direction to do so.
[2:21:16]
Thank you.
[2:21:17]
Thank you, Director.
[2:21:19]
Okay.
[2:21:19]
I have a motion.
[2:21:20]
Second, we have Ryan McCartard here.
[2:21:22]
I'm just here for questions.
[2:21:23]
Well, they've answered the question.
[2:21:24]
Do I have a second?
[2:21:25]
I'm a director, sir.
[2:21:26]
I have a motion and a second on that.
[2:21:28]
I also have the Tonya director, Estomerra.
[2:21:34]
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
[2:21:35]
I wanted to thank the committee for their recommendation.
[2:21:39]
I think it's really important for us to take a very detailed review and have a discussion
[2:21:45]
on each of these items.
[2:21:46]
So I appreciate this suggestion.
[2:21:50]
Thank you very much.
[2:21:51]
Director Eisenberg.
[2:21:55]
Thank you, Chair.
[2:21:55]
I just want to state that I first, I'm really appreciate the, you know, the chance
[2:22:02]
versus discussion and discuss it and I appreciate the words of my colleague, director,
[2:22:06]
shewap, her articulate summary of what's going on.
[2:22:11]
So I just wanted to say that I am very grateful to the clerk and others for including my
[2:22:18]
to this. So, hooray all around. I do want to point out that one of the graphics I used didn't come through
[2:22:24]
for particular person's fault, probably due to the almighty IT world. You know, and I wanted to
[2:22:32]
clarify that what was missing there is that in just as a quick summary and then I'll provide it
[2:22:39]
maybe separately to the clerk who can distribute it later. That's in those Vicaros and this is on
[2:22:46]
three of my attachment is that low-specuros, reservoir and dam is actually funded more than half
[2:22:56]
in government grants, and that it is primarily funded through free money, and the WIFI alone
[2:23:05]
and you've heard me say earlier, I've got some questions about WIFI alone in today's interest rate
[2:23:10]
climate. The wiffy alone is only something like $16 million and then divided by eight different
[2:23:17]
participating, financially participating parties. So I wanted to hold that out as an example of a
[2:23:23]
very well-funded, you know, responsibly funded project and maybe something that we can
[2:23:29]
seek to emulate in our projects. But I will provide that chart, you know, it's a pipe chart,
[2:23:36]
And again, I very grateful for this.
[2:23:39]
I don't meant for the inclusion of the items, so thanks.
[2:23:42]
Thank you, Director.
[2:23:43]
A very good suggestion.
[2:23:44]
I also support Director Schwier's comments and her breakdown of the importance of this project
[2:23:49]
and having clarity and transparency on this project.
[2:23:52]
When we speak about what we're talking about in reference to Facheco,
[2:23:56]
now and in the future, Director Bell.
[2:23:59]
I want to know what the timeline is on this project
[2:24:05]
At this point, as we stand here today, what's the timeline?
[2:24:10]
We're still going through our feasibilities on this at this point.
[2:24:12]
I don't know, we have a specific timeline at this particular time.
[2:24:16]
Yeah, I think the most recent, sorry, through the chair.
[2:24:18]
Sure, no problem.
[2:24:18]
Right.
[2:24:18]
I'm a Carter Deputy Operating Officer at Dam Safety in Capital at Liberty Division.
[2:24:23]
At the timeline that we share a few months ago, still stands.
[2:24:26]
I think that was presented in a presentation.
[2:24:28]
It's a graphic that shows the timeline.
[2:24:30]
So all of that still stands as we know today.
[2:24:32]
The timeline for these presentations and these updates are quarterly.
[2:24:35]
So we're hoping to do our next update to this board in January 2020.
[2:24:39]
So what it is,
[2:24:44]
go no go decision timeline on the project.
[2:24:49]
There really isn't a go no go decision timeline on the project.
[2:24:53]
However, there are different points where the board can weigh in on certain aspects,
[2:24:58]
such as the final EIR.
[2:25:00]
That would be a full board decision to certify that. I believe on the timeline, it's in late 2025 or 26. I can't remember off top of the head.
[2:25:11]
And there's up until the week we decide or before we decide to so general obligation bonds.
[2:25:21]
That sounds like it'd be after if that decision is next year.
[2:25:24]
Yeah, that's what it sounds like to me.
[2:25:27]
OK, thank you.
[2:25:28]
Do it to Schwann.
[2:25:32]
Thank you, Chair.
[2:25:34]
Director Bell, then that's exactly why
[2:25:37]
this committee recommended these topics for suggestions,
[2:25:41]
so that we can support the whole board to reach to that point.
[2:25:47]
Any public comment on this item?
[2:25:49]
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
[2:25:49]
Yes, I have one hand raise, Koshah Irvin.
[2:25:52]
OK, the serving?
[2:25:59]
Thank you, afternoon and again, Board of Directors.
[2:26:01]
Last time I spoke, I forgot to say I'm Hunter, but I'm with this year, I'm holding a little bit of chapter.
[2:26:09]
And thank you to the committee and the Board for scheduling these work study sessions.
[2:26:15]
I wanted to point out that the water storage at Florida Community Meeting Notes
[2:26:21]
don't correctly document what I said about the last two bullets in the list of topics.
[2:26:27]
There's a regarding partnership approach and unique requirements.
[2:26:33]
And what I said is that these topics should be prioritized
[2:26:37]
because they seem more consequential.
[2:26:41]
And then also looking under the unique requirements.
[2:26:48]
I would suggest adding the encouragement code part
[2:26:52]
under that list on that last bullet, which is discussion and review of requirements you
[2:27:01]
need to the project.
[2:27:03]
Thank you.
[2:27:04]
Thank you, Mr. Servan.
[2:27:06]
Any other comments?
[2:27:08]
We have a motion in a second, all those in favor signify by saying hello.
[2:27:15]
Oh, you want to speak.
[2:27:15]
Didn't see that.
[2:27:16]
Sorry about that.
[2:27:17]
Go ahead.
[2:27:18]
Nice chair.
[2:27:19]
So, this has maybe put in the card a little bit before the horse because we haven't had a chance to talk about Anderson yet, but considering that both projects are storage projects, I also think I don't want to limit our discussion just to the points that have been raised, if there's any areas of commonality between Anderson and this project where we could make earlier decisions that perhaps
[2:27:48]
might improve outcomes if we're to proceed with the project.
[2:27:52]
For example, unfortunately, we did not proceed with decommissioning the hydroelectric plant in advance of the project.
[2:28:04]
That's, you know, that isn't a decision that was made by our current staff, but that was a decision that was made.
[2:28:10]
And the fact that we have to comply with FERC for a pretty negligible benefit in terms of hydroelectric power actually created delays and a lot of additional expenses to the project.
[2:28:25]
So that's the kind of thing that I hope and unsure staff will be looking at as we move forward.
[2:28:31]
trying to identify where are those opportunities where we can avoid future pain, if you will,
[2:28:40]
by identifying them early.
[2:28:42]
So that's just my suggestion.
[2:28:44]
Thank you.
[2:28:44]
Thank you, Vice Chair.
[2:28:45]
Do I draw some work?
[2:28:47]
Thanks.
[2:28:48]
I want to express gratitude to Ms. Irvin's public comments.
[2:28:53]
And I do want to, particularly gratitude because I mentioned, but not clearly enough,
[2:28:59]
on page 4 of my own memo that third bullet point under unmet requirements, which I re-worded
[2:29:05]
from special circumstances, unmet requirements necessary for projects success.
[2:29:11]
I included water acquisition of water rights, you know, imported water supply and state
[2:29:15]
agreement to partial destruction of popular state park.
[2:29:19]
That popular state park is when we go.
[2:29:22]
So, and I should have clarified that better.
[2:29:24]
So I thank you very much as always for your input and clarification.
[2:29:30]
Thank you, and we're always sensitive to our parks and our parks and our, and in those particular regions,
[2:29:35]
specifically, so it's a good dialogue today by this board on this particular item.
[2:29:39]
I have a motion in a second, all those in favor, signify by saying aye.
[2:29:43]
All right, all opposed.
[2:29:45]
That motion passes.
[2:29:46]
Thank you very much, board.
[2:29:48]
Moving on, the agenda item 5.3, these are board committee reports.
[2:29:52]
I have a few here, anybody on the board choose to share on their committee or at the
[2:29:58]
Yeah
[2:30:01]
Thank you, Chair. I want to point out a piece of information under the CIP Committee's report.
[2:30:11]
So this is the last page, which is a table.
[2:30:17]
And if the board recall that there's a question raised by the board about how we're spending our construction project,
[2:30:31]
the contingency money that's approved by the board,
[2:30:34]
and then whether the percentage of the contingency amount
[2:30:39]
is needs to be reviewed or not.
[2:30:45]
So this is the upcoming data assignment.
[2:30:49]
And then so we look at historical data,
[2:30:52]
which is provided in here.
[2:30:55]
So the items were categorized as project that's already completed.
[2:31:03]
Near completion, which means civil work is complete.
[2:31:07]
And then projects like this under the three year,
[2:31:10]
how plan established and peer it.
[2:31:13]
And then there's also active construction project.
[2:31:16]
That's part of that's going on.
[2:31:18]
So as you can see, these numbers are presented here.
[2:31:22]
I do want to point out that under the active construction project, the Anderson Dam Tunnel project is not included in there.
[2:31:34]
The reason being that the Tunnel project has a contingency amount approved by the board and the monitor by the CIP company of 25%.
[2:31:44]
So if the 25% is included in there is actually making the average number pretty skewed.
[2:31:51]
So that's that's that's that's reason for the so that's why I want to point out
[2:31:56]
So these are the numbers and then if I'm sure that if four members want to have further discussion
[2:32:05]
The chair will be more likely to put it on the agenda for further discussion but today
[2:32:09]
It's just where reporting on our work product and then thanks staff for the information
[2:32:15]
We're good the other reports
[2:32:19]
Okay, just a quick update on aqua, so aqua's fall conference is coming up in Indian wells
[2:32:25]
in two weeks, running from the 27th through the 30th.
[2:32:29]
I will be there.
[2:32:30]
For those of you that are attending, please, where you're walking choose.
[2:32:34]
This campus is spread out over a mile and you're going to be doing a ton of walking, just
[2:32:39]
be prepared for that.
[2:32:40]
If you are attending, many things going on, but I'll give you a thorough report on the follow-up
[2:32:45]
of aqua.
[2:32:45]
But it's going to be a very interesting conference this year.
[2:32:49]
I can assure you of that.
[2:32:51]
Any other comments or reports on item 5.3?
[2:32:54]
Moving on, water utility enterprise, 6.1.
[2:32:58]
Discuss purposes and operations
[2:33:00]
Santa Clara Valley Water District's groundwater
[2:33:02]
recharge ponds and systems received direction
[2:33:05]
from board of directors on potentially repurposing
[2:33:08]
valley water lands used for groundwater recharge.
[2:33:11]
This is info and direction only.
[2:33:14]
Do we have a report on that?
[2:33:16]
Yes.
[2:33:17]
Dr. Nune Chair for Ella.
[2:33:18]
Members of the board.
[2:33:19]
I'm Vanessa D. L. P.
[2:33:19]
You address.
[2:33:20]
Groundwork Management Unit Manager.
[2:33:22]
I do have a presentation.
[2:33:23]
Or a few for for I can just give a short summary.
[2:33:26]
What is a board for a short summary?
[2:33:29]
Okay.
[2:33:30]
Let's listen to the report.
[2:33:34]
Okay.
[2:33:35]
So as the board is aware,
[2:33:36]
Valley Water has been mentioned groundwater in the county for nearly 100 years.
[2:33:40]
I mean, to meet the requirements of the district act.
[2:33:43]
And then more recently to meet the requirements of the Sustainable Ground Management Act or Sigma.
[2:33:50]
The reason we do this nearly half the water using the county comes from groundwater.
[2:33:54]
If we focus on South County specifically it's over 90 percent.
[2:33:59]
And natural recharge alone cannot support this level of pumping, so that's why we use local and imported surface water for managed recharge through creeks and ponds.
[2:34:07]
So, over many, many decades, we've built a very extensive recharge system.
[2:34:11]
This figure shows our ponds, or over 102 of them in 24 clusters, and it's very important
[2:34:19]
that they need to be located in the right place geologically to do their job, and our ponds
[2:34:24]
are very strategically located in areas where we have very permeable gravels and sands that
[2:34:29]
allow that surface water to infiltrate to the deep principle aquifers that are the primary ones
[2:34:33]
used.
[2:34:34]
Having enough ponds and recharge capacity helps ensure that pumping and recharge are balanced.
[2:34:40]
And this prevents return of historical problems that we've been able to overcome through a lot of work and investment,
[2:34:45]
like chronic overdraft and land subsideants.
[2:34:48]
It also helps us maximize the use of available water supplies.
[2:34:53]
So the last two droughts ended with very wet years.
[2:34:56]
Having a lot of ponds really allowed us to take full advantage of those wet years.
[2:35:00]
We have a lot of water supplies available and a place to put that. And really, that was key having those
[2:35:05]
all those ponds in terms of the quick groundwater level and storage recovery that we saw on those
[2:35:10]
drows. Our upon network also helps us maximize the use of our local surface water rights. That's
[2:35:15]
up to 227,000 acre feet of local water that we can use every year for recharge.
[2:35:23]
So there are various reasons
[2:35:24]
that our ponds can be dry. Common misconception is that that means that they're not functional
[2:35:29]
are needed, but there are good reasons. The first and foremost is that these are facilities
[2:35:33]
we need to maintain them. So we have to drive those pawns to scrape the bottom. There's
[2:35:39]
a lot of fine sediments that accumulate at the bottom and can basically clog and reduce the
[2:35:43]
retarct capacity. We also need to drive the pawns for infrastructure repair or inspection.
[2:35:51]
So just as an example, last winter, and again this winter, we'll have some pawns offline,
[2:35:55]
while we inspect the Santa Clara conduit, which supplies water to those ponds.
[2:36:00]
Of course, water supply conditions affect pond use in droughts, ponds,
[2:36:05]
off-center empty because we just don't have the water surface water can be extremely scarce.
[2:36:10]
And then on the flip side, we can have years where our groundwater basins are so healthy
[2:36:14]
that we don't need recharge and certain areas.
[2:36:18]
There can also be site-specific issues.
[2:36:20]
So as an example, late last year we took the Sun Yoke's Ponds and Campbell offline, after an investigation at an adjacent fire station revealed the presence of PFAS chemicals.
[2:36:31]
So we've resumed operation in two of the Ponds, but we have two others that remain temporarily offline, as we work to complete our due diligence out of an abundance of caution.
[2:36:44]
So, the loss of any ponds translates to decrease in recharge depending on the ponds that could be hundreds to thousands of acre feet each year and the concern with that really is that the loss adds up over time.
[2:36:58]
So, as that deficit accumulates that threatens the groundwater balance that we've been able to achieve between pumping and recharge.
[2:37:05]
And just in this example, the sunny Oats ponds that count for about 9% of the larger loss
[2:37:11]
got a recharge system capacity, which may sound like a small number, but if we start to think
[2:37:16]
about our most productive recharge system, and annual 10% deficit, you can see how that could
[2:37:22]
quickly add up.
[2:37:24]
Losing individual ponds could also impact operations, these typically operate as an interconnected
[2:37:28]
system in series and the water moves between ponds with overflow at the end.
[2:37:33]
And we also need to consider our water rights as an example of the lost gutter system alone
[2:37:39]
can tap into up to 40,000 acre feet of local water rights annually.
[2:37:43]
If we don't regularly exercise and use those rights, we risk losing those.
[2:37:48]
And then lastly, the purify water plants to use all 29 ponds in Campbell to maximize the use
[2:37:54]
of purified water that will be produced at the advanced purified water plant, so we really need
[2:37:58]
all those ponds were counting on all those ponds to recharge up to 11,200
[2:38:02]
acre feet of purified water each year.
[2:38:07]
We could certainly avoid or minimize the water supply impacts that I just talked
[2:38:11]
about with new recharge facilities, but of course, there are related challenges and
[2:38:16]
costs associated with that. First and foremost, finding suitable sites could be
[2:38:21]
very challenging, especially in North County. It's highly urban. There are
[2:38:26]
a few large, undeveloped properties available.
[2:38:29]
And again, they have to be in geologically suitable areas.
[2:38:32]
And of course, land is quite expensive.
[2:38:35]
We need to conduct extensive study of any potential sites
[2:38:38]
to make sure that they're going to work as we intend them to,
[2:38:42]
given the size of these properties that we'd be looking at those studies,
[2:38:45]
but likely cost millions of dollars, and take several years to complete.
[2:38:49]
We need to be able to connect up water source to those new facilities,
[2:38:53]
So we need either a new turnout or a stream diversion and a new stream diversions permits for those are becoming increasingly difficult to obtain so that that would be a challenge in itself
[2:39:05]
Environmental assessment planning design and construction would require significant time and resources and then we'd also need to identify funding source and comply with the surplus land act
[2:39:14]
So again, it could be done there are just challenges that we would need to overcome
[2:39:19]
So, to wrap up, ground water is really a core water supply for this county and the strong
[2:39:25]
manage recharge program that we've built up is really essential for continued ground
[2:39:30]
or sustainability, especially in the phase of climate change where we're going to see more
[2:39:33]
or severe frequent shifts between extreme drought and extreme wet years.
[2:39:39]
And the recharge system that we've built up over time works really well.
[2:39:43]
We may have some positive temporarily dry, but we really do need the ponds in the capacity
[2:39:48]
that we have to balance pumping and recharge, and also to quickly recover from droughts before the next one is.
[2:39:56]
I did also want to note, a major strategy of the water supply master plan is securing.
[2:40:00]
And so that includes our water rights and our recharged facilities. Through the water slide master plan, we're also exploring projects to expand recharged with a focus on South County in particular.
[2:40:13]
So losing your replacing ponds, existing ponds, would be challenging for the reasons noted.
[2:40:18]
It's not recommended by staff from a water supply perspective. However, in light of other potential considerations, the board may have staff seeking for direction and guidance on whether there's any interest in
[2:40:29]
exploring, repurposing the land use for groundwater charge, and without a stand-up of
[2:40:34]
the infrastructure.
[2:40:35]
I have a question for you.
[2:40:36]
How much of these on many of these properties that we have in control are actual habitats
[2:40:41]
as well?
[2:40:44]
I think the answer to that.
[2:40:45]
Do you want to tell me?
[2:40:47]
I'm going to let Captain.
[2:40:48]
Sure.
[2:40:49]
Good afternoon.
[2:40:50]
Board.
[2:40:50]
My name is Bassam Kassab.
[2:40:52]
What is the supply operations manager?
[2:40:54]
All our ponds are basically facilities for each charge.
[2:40:58]
Only one of them, which is on this property, not court or property, the small pond is a habitat.
[2:41:06]
We don't clean it, we leave it as a habitat, but the others can be clean, dredged, and are not meant as a habitat.
[2:41:13]
However, birds, turtles, do visit them as they please, but it's not a habitat.
[2:41:19]
Thank you.
[2:41:20]
Appreciate that.
[2:41:21]
Direct.
[2:41:24]
Thank you so much for this presentation, and I have some questions that are reflect really
[2:41:29]
more on criticisms of myself and the way that my brain processes information and not on any sort
[2:41:35]
of criticism of you. Just so you know, so please don't take it that way. I'm like this
[2:41:39]
is very in literal person. So, and I don't still after, after living here for 35 years, I still
[2:41:46]
don't really speak California and believe it or not, it's kind of crazy. Anyway, so, and on
[2:41:51]
slide number four. You said there is a four, yeah, I think it's four. There's like the third bullet point large bullet point is impact of purified water project planned for low scatter system.
[2:42:06]
And so my understanding is from Ms. Stroof is here is that if we do the indirect
[2:42:11]
It's potable, you purify water that we do need these places for the water to go down,
[2:42:21]
which I think I understand, are most of them that we use, they are the ponds, is that right,
[2:42:30]
the recharge ponds?
[2:42:33]
So, I mean, and when you say impact to purified water project, do you mean negative impact or
[2:42:39]
positive impact?
[2:42:40]
Yeah.
[2:42:41]
So a good question.
[2:42:42]
So yes, the purified water is planning to take water from the, from Palo Alto, pipe it down
[2:42:48]
to the Las Vegas recharge system in Campbell to be used for indirect putable reuse in that
[2:42:53]
large Las Vegas recharge ponds system.
[2:42:58]
And yes, so the idea here was that if we repurpose any of those ponds, that would have a negative
[2:43:04]
impact on the purified water project because it's depending on all of those ponds to use
[2:43:09]
the capacity that will be produced at the point.
[2:43:12]
Okay, so thank you so much, and again,
[2:43:14]
my brain processing, not anything in your book.
[2:43:17]
So, I mean, my gut feeling, you know my intuition,
[2:43:22]
my belief is that we don't want to do anything
[2:43:24]
that is going to make purified water any harder,
[2:43:27]
but it already is, because it's already so much harder.
[2:43:30]
And in fact, as Mr. of Nose,
[2:43:32]
I wish we actually had the more ponds
[2:43:35]
closer to Palo Alto, so we wouldn't have to pipe the water so far
[2:43:40]
south, which is a challenge, you know, for us, for Palo Alto, et cetera, it's
[2:43:45]
whenever you have such a big infrastructure project, you then have increased
[2:43:48]
costs over time and now the homeowners and who knows what, you know, risks.
[2:43:54]
And so, I mean, my feeling is that we just don't want to subject to risk anything
[2:43:59]
that will interfere with us making purified water possible.
[2:44:07]
So, and I do actually want to have gratitude for the chair's question about habitat.
[2:44:15]
So, you know, I don't know, maybe I can ask you if this is relevant here, you know,
[2:44:20]
I've done a lot of reading and listening to my constituents about, and you've heard me
[2:44:26]
this before about their positive relationship between habitat restoration and things like clean
[2:44:33]
water, you know, that restoring habitat can do everything from helping to clean the water
[2:44:37]
and in it, you know, to helping protect communities from flood damage, et cetera. In addition
[2:44:43]
to all those wonderful, you know, helping save our earth, the habitat restoring habitat.
[2:44:48]
So, is it something that's sometimes done to have these recharge ponds also be, while the
[2:44:58]
because I think that's...
[2:45:00]
That would be really cool. And just as a side point, the fact that this is contaminated water over here, which isn't our fault, you know, but, you know, they're all the signs, do not fish, do not eat these fish, waters, contaminated fish are contaminated. And I understand that that's from the mind, you know, adding a not our fault, but it's depressing to see us, you know, that it'd be great if we could have clean research, you know, finds places that people can't
[2:45:29]
fish without it, and maybe where families can engage in, you know, what's that we're like,
[2:45:37]
outdoor entertainment since I've been in nature. I think that would be something we could really
[2:45:43]
give to our communities, especially because low income communities in particular often lack
[2:45:48]
appropriate adequate access to wildlife in nature. So I guess that's really right, like that's kind
[2:45:54]
of my point. Are these things sometimes habitats? And if so, can we do it? To my knowledge,
[2:45:59]
just from my interaction with colleagues at other agencies,
[2:46:03]
typically recharge spreading ponds or recharge
[2:46:05]
to basins or typically active water supply facilities
[2:46:07]
because they need to be maintained.
[2:46:09]
We have to scrape them.
[2:46:10]
We have to clean them to make sure that we
[2:46:12]
don't have sediment clogging, need to be careful
[2:46:13]
about the water that goes in.
[2:46:15]
So at least to my knowledge, they're typically treated just
[2:46:19]
as water supply facilities and not mixed with habitat.
[2:46:23]
But that's something that we could look into.
[2:46:25]
Yeah, I would because, you know, where I grew up with
[2:46:28]
There's these lakes ever, there's actually more lakes in Wisconsin than in Minnesota, did you know that?
[2:46:33]
But a last getting was like, as well.
[2:46:34]
Anyway, that lakes, in my understanding, do a really good job of cleaning the water.
[2:46:40]
algae, healthy algae, not that algae.
[2:46:42]
Clean water, fish, clean water.
[2:46:46]
If you have a healthy habitat, often that will be to the most clean water.
[2:46:51]
But that goes down, but I'm not an expert in that specifically.
[2:46:55]
And I do encourage you to continue that research to really find out because that way we would be
[2:47:00]
succeeding on money many overlapping goals at once. I'm not gonna say kill two birds. It's on stone
[2:47:06]
because that's awful. I'm a vegan.
[2:47:08]
So, thank you for this. Thank you for and thank you in advance for looking into that.
[2:47:13]
Dr. Bell?
[2:47:15]
Yeah, thank you.
[2:47:17]
I have a lot of these in my district probably half of them, hurt in my district, so.
[2:47:24]
I think the public, I would describe the public is concerned about the maintenance of them so that I just want to re-emphasize that that we should properly maintain our facilities.
[2:47:39]
I am actually in favor of expanding recharge facilities.
[2:47:43]
I think we ought to be looking and exploring finding places we can do it on our lands, on lands owned by the water district,
[2:47:51]
but also there might be some opportunities to negotiate with other agencies like Santa Clara County
[2:48:02]
Parks, District or other federal state agencies, open space, county, city governments,
[2:48:14]
And I think the idea of having facilities expanded for our groundwater is a good thing.
[2:48:24]
Obviously if we do have the opportunity to do water purification programs where we use these facilities,
[2:48:36]
It's a large benefit to have more of them.
[2:48:41]
There was a question, I'll give a credit to other members.
[2:48:49]
And it's, we had a presentation earlier about, like, the baseball field in Mount View,
[2:48:56]
where when flood comes, we could put water into those kinds of,
[2:49:00]
is that groundwater recharge or is that just managing or flood?
[2:49:04]
What do you call that? Is that part of your domain or is that just flag control kind of stuff?
[2:49:12]
I believe in that case it was a detention basin, which typically those are used to temporarily
[2:49:16]
detain the water and then release it later.
[2:49:19]
It will release to the creek, right?
[2:49:22]
It got it.
[2:49:24]
It will be like for the purposes of percolation or whatever.
[2:49:29]
So, I kind of wondered about that, I think, look pretty good, I think that's a good idea.
[2:49:38]
Now, getting down to the one that causes me the most part is this sunny oak facility.
[2:49:48]
There are four ponds right in a row.
[2:49:52]
The one pawn that they showed a picture of them, maybe you can put the picture of them.
[2:49:59]
Everybody can see them.
[2:50:00]
There was a concern, that's one of the things, right there. That's why they're concerned about maintenance, by the way, people in that housing right behind us on the open ponds.
[2:50:13]
But there's one pond that's in between, it's owned by the city of Campbell, I believe, or our property, it's not owned by us but the city of Campbell, or do we own that pond.
[2:50:25]
It's between the firehouse and the firehouse training center, and there's a pond in between, and it's been determined to have pollution problems, correct, and so that pond has not been used for many long, quite a long time.
[2:50:47]
It's not actually used.
[2:50:50]
So the city camel and the fire department
[2:50:54]
would like to find some way of, I guess,
[2:50:58]
you'd have to go in and clean the site or something.
[2:51:04]
What has to be done there?
[2:51:05]
It's not being used for our purposes.
[2:51:07]
That's one of the four ponds in that area.
[2:51:12]
And this is a big problem that I get.
[2:51:15]
I'm kind of tired of talking to city council members about it, and other people because they keep asking me about that.
[2:51:23]
So what can we do about that?
[2:51:25]
Let me try to address, I think I caught all your questions there.
[2:51:27]
So yes, it's a series of four ponds and sunyokes.
[2:51:30]
Pond one is located between, like you said, the fire station.
[2:51:35]
Sunyokes firehouse and sunyokes.
[2:51:37]
Yes, and the McCormick Training Center.
[2:51:40]
So, Valleywater owns the piece of property that that pond one is located on, but it's surrounded by land that's owned by the city of Campbell, and then county fire operates the fire station and the training center on that.
[2:51:52]
We, the pond was operating all of the pond were operating last year.
[2:51:56]
We did take them offline at the end of the year once we realized, again, through this fire station investigation that they had detected PFAS in, in pond one, which is that one you're mentioned between the.
[2:52:08]
We've done testing now throughout the Las Vegas recharge system.
[2:52:13]
We have had detections of keyfasts in various ponds.
[2:52:17]
They've been low levels.
[2:52:19]
We are still working specifically related to the Sunny Oaks pond 1
[2:52:24]
with the regional board, the City of Campbell and the County Fire.
[2:52:29]
The regional board has asked County Fire to do some more investigation.
[2:52:33]
The levels that we're seeing there are not terribly high,
[2:52:36]
not nearly as high as some other fire stations, but the region board is still concerned
[2:52:40]
because they're impacted well as down great end.
[2:52:43]
So the next step is to continue working with the region board and City of Camel County
[2:52:48]
Fire to better understand what's happening at the site.
[2:52:51]
And again, that's the only reason those ponds are temporarily offline.
[2:52:54]
We made that choice just out of abundance of caution while we do that.
[2:53:06]
would be important to me to have some updates occasionally to give me reports about what's
[2:53:15]
going on with that and probably do a board committee. I don't know what committee does that
[2:53:20]
would that go to. One of the board committees would review that, correct? Update on the Sonny Oves
[2:53:28]
Pollution, I call it, whatever. They might find some other pollution there. I don't know that it was
[2:53:35]
I think what happened in that is it's been around the firehouse so long and there's been a lot of training and they use chemicals and, you know, it gets washed into the ponds and that's a bad thing, you know, we got to just, you know, accept that the two uses aren't really that compatible being next to one another, I guess.
[2:53:58]
So, we got to be very, very careful about that.
[2:54:03]
And I would like to have Mr. Chairman,
[2:54:07]
that kind of monitored, reported to a committee about the
[2:54:10]
Sunny Oaks upon Pollution issue and working with the
[2:54:14]
City Council and the fire department have some
[2:54:17]
resolution of that.
[2:54:19]
So we can kind of take care of this and say that we're
[2:54:23]
moving on it and we're working on it with them.
[2:54:25]
And I think that's important.
[2:54:28]
I would ask that that be done.
[2:54:30]
I've got to request.
[2:54:31]
Look at board.
[2:54:32]
Has that request also?
[2:54:32]
Thank you.
[2:54:36]
Vice Chair Keen.
[2:54:38]
Thank you very much.
[2:54:40]
And first, thank you staff for a very well-written staff report analysis.
[2:54:46]
It was very good.
[2:54:48]
So thanks.
[2:54:50]
Just to.
[2:54:51]
I don't have a lot of his in my districts.
[2:54:55]
and like my colleague director Belle, but I do hear from...
[2:55:00]
Distituents, and primarily they're concerned about when the pawns are empty, and they actually are unhappy because no birds, right? And so I've had, I've tried to explain it, I've had staff try to explain it, and sometimes people just want to be able to watch birds, and they're not really thinking about it being part of a system.
[2:55:19]
Are we utilizing signage on these sites for to help the public?
[2:55:26]
Because I get that someone is looking at something that's empty and water has been there before.
[2:55:32]
And they're just going to be annoyed. Why is this empty?
[2:55:36]
Why aren't they charging things in there?
[2:55:39]
Why don't I see birds?
[2:55:41]
And I know signage can be problematic because it can get knocked down or things like that.
[2:55:46]
But I do feel like if we could enhance the communication, that might be helpful to people.
[2:55:53]
Even if it's just a sign that says periodically, this area will run drive because of the following reasons.
[2:55:58]
Or just something simple that it's not that we're neglecting it, you know, that there's a method to our madness.
[2:56:04]
But again, I strongly support the idea of these groundwater recharge ponds, and even though
[2:56:14]
they cannot count them as recurring mitigation, they actually, when they are filled with
[2:56:20]
water, do provide an amenity to the community, and they do benefit plants and insects and birds.
[2:56:29]
So, I think they're a net positive, so thank you.
[2:56:36]
Okay, thank you, Director Satos.
[2:56:41]
If thank you Mr. Chair for Director Bill,
[2:56:44]
you had to talk to the Senator County Fire Department
[2:56:47]
and tell him to maintain that pond
[2:56:49]
and use it for the urban search and rescue
[2:56:51]
and water equipment and help share the cost.
[2:56:54]
So that's running a ball.
[2:56:56]
Going back to the chair,
[2:56:57]
talk about the habitat, it was a good call, John,
[2:57:00]
because even though our ponds are not set up
[2:57:02]
that they are users. All the ponds in my district, deer, coyote, I can go on and on. People
[2:57:10]
put their turtles in there to fish, we even found a surgeon in there. But I could tell you this.
[2:57:15]
It's a big fish. The number of one issue in my district is when those ponds go down or they're
[2:57:21]
got trash in them, Jennifer and I get all the phone call. People love them, they want to
[2:57:32]
clear? Do I draw some bird?
[2:57:35]
Well, it's really beautiful and so many of us agree.
[2:57:39]
So I just wanted, you know, you know, with gratitude and I just, I have a agreement and then I have a just a comment.
[2:57:46]
So my grievance that I just want to give a plus plus one to is again the benefits of the recreation benefits of the habitat,
[2:57:53]
you know, as I mentioned before, maybe exploring, I love that idea of the fire department,
[2:57:58]
exploring means of sharing cost and maybe responsibility for if possible keeping these puns
[2:58:06]
up and going year round. What a lovely thought. That's just so much benefit to the community.
[2:58:12]
Wow, it's urgent. That's crazy. And gotta come to Wisconsin and fish there and you'll
[2:58:17]
really see a lot of them. But all those are good. And I want to, I guess, because Mikhail
[2:58:24]
part was mentioned now twice today. I can tell you that's in my district. I can tell you that I would
[2:58:30]
have constituents so mad at me if I don't comment about that and hold it up as an example that
[2:58:39]
is contrary to the habitat option, the pond with fish option that we're discussing today. And among
[2:58:48]
that's constituents is an 80, five-year-old or so, you know, constituent acted in the area
[2:58:53]
and retired water engineer who drove to my house twice, you know, tries with cookies,
[2:59:01]
cookies, and very old newspaper articles to walk me through a great length, and I love spending
[2:59:08]
time with constituents. This was like two hours and this was before I was elected.
[2:59:15]
This is
[2:59:15]
in his opinion, in his professional opinion, how that project fails on a water engineering level
[2:59:23]
that there was an either way I can't give it justice. I'm not an engineer. But what I am
[2:59:29]
is a baseball mom. And my husband actually was on the board of fellow also, Little League,
[2:59:36]
and my son as a varsity player, three years running at Palo Alto, high schools, winning
[2:59:41]
Baseball team and hopefully if all goes this plan playing in the NC2A next year in college
[2:59:47]
Woohoo, and I can tell you that that McKelvie Park is not liked by
[2:59:52]
By older, you know more advanced baseball players and according to my son either by little league, so
[3:00:01]
That it's a non-functioning baseball field. In addition to being non-functioning, engineering thing, according
[3:00:09]
to this wonderful constituent. That's, I mean, I could go through many details and in part, it's too small.
[3:00:15]
It's got like the wall is really weird, hitting home runs is like not a thing. I could, you know, the spectators
[3:00:22]
are really high up and worst of all. When it does function as a pool, all of the baseball equipment and everything gets flooded.
[3:00:30]
So that's just kind of part mean to kids.
[3:00:36]
You know, your baseball part
[3:00:37]
has been intentionally flooded.
[3:00:40]
So it's just in my mind.
[3:00:41]
But I hold that out as a counter example,
[3:00:45]
as an alternative to what we're talking about here,
[3:00:48]
which is using puns as a multi-faceted recreation.
[3:00:56]
and that was what I was searching for, like, recreation, asset,
[3:01:01]
took communities of recreation, habitat.
[3:01:03]
I love that notion.
[3:01:05]
I really do.
[3:01:05]
And if it's possible, I think we would possibly get funding
[3:01:10]
for it from the, again, the president-vidence, additional funding,
[3:01:18]
newer funding for habitat restoration and for our sustainability
[3:01:23]
and, you know, Governor Newsom's emphasis on,
[3:01:27]
on, you know, we, on the restoration of ecosystems and habitat.
[3:01:33]
And so, exactly, we could get some of that money to,
[3:01:35]
I think that would really serve our constituents in a lovely way.
[3:01:39]
I want everyone to be able to fish for sturgeon.
[3:01:42]
Luckily, even on the vegan.
[3:01:45]
So thank you.
[3:01:46]
Good to see you.
[3:01:49]
Thank you, Chair.
[3:01:50]
I will be really fast.
[3:01:51]
Dr. Keegan already said it but I think it's worse repeating that I really want to come from a staff on this agenda memo
[3:02:00]
It's well written all 10 pages and then it's something that I printed out
[3:02:06]
I'm going to put it in my file next time somebody talk to me about this I'll put it out and I think I can answer all the questions
[3:02:11]
So thank you so much well written and you can see that I think it's a generating the kind of a discussion
[3:02:17]
as you have among the board members. So, good job.
[3:02:21]
Thank you, Director.
[3:02:22]
Director of Samara.
[3:02:23]
Yeah, thank you.
[3:02:24]
I don't want to be repetitive.
[3:02:26]
I wanted to thank you for the presentation, but that's
[3:02:28]
great.
[3:02:30]
It's really great when we participate and
[3:02:33]
kind of explain to the public what we do and how we do
[3:02:36]
if it's excellent.
[3:02:38]
But I agree with everything that's been said, including the fact that
[3:02:41]
these ponds provide all this space everywhere in the
[3:02:47]
that we could get more we should.
[3:02:51]
We must protect the turtle and the surgeon.
[3:02:54]
Bottom line, that's a nice question.
[3:02:58]
Thank you, that was a wonderful report.
[3:03:00]
Absolutely terrific.
[3:03:02]
Tremendous knowledge given to us this board and to the public.
[3:03:05]
Do we have anybody in the public, which is to address this item?
[3:03:09]
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
[3:03:10]
I do not have any requests at this time.
[3:03:12]
Okay.
[3:03:13]
Thank you.
[3:03:13]
Appreciate your time.
[3:03:15]
Thank you, Board.
[3:03:15]
That was really good discussion.
[3:03:17]
Very well done.
[3:03:18]
Moving on, watershed, 7.1.
[3:03:22]
This is an action item, approve amendment number two, agreement number
[3:03:26]
A4224A with REY engineers incorporated on, for an on-call
[3:03:31]
Lanservain and mapping services increasing not to be exceed fee of
[3:03:35]
$500,000 for a revised total not to exceed fee of $2 million
[3:03:40]
and extending the agreement term to June 30, 2024.
[3:03:45]
It's recommended to prove that I have a motion and a second already. Any discussion? Any
[3:03:51]
public comment? All those in favor signify by saying aye? Aye. All the posed? That
[3:03:58]
item passes. Thank you very much, Board. Moving on. Moving on to item 8.1. Approved
[3:04:04]
the fiscal year.
[3:04:07]
Okay, good.
[3:04:12]
You finally, somebody said it. I can't believe it. Approved
[3:04:15]
the fiscal year 2022-23.
[3:04:18]
Oh, gosh, okay, I'll compose myself.
[3:04:22]
Sorrow, a point one, prove the fiscal year 2022-23 safe,
[3:04:26]
clean water and natural flood protection program,
[3:04:29]
annual report with proposed project text adjustments,
[3:04:33]
authorized after submitted to the independent monitoring
[3:04:35]
committee for its review,
[3:04:37]
and update the program's change control process.
[3:04:40]
This is an action item.
[3:04:41]
Do we have a new report?
[3:04:42]
Ah, I'm just gonna let you know.
[3:04:43]
Yes, actually Jessica Collins, our business planning analysis unit manager will be presenting today.
[3:04:49]
Okay.
[3:04:50]
Welcome.
[3:04:52]
Thank you so much and good afternoon, Chair Verella and members of the board.
[3:04:56]
As mentioned, I'm Jessica Collins, business planning and analysis unit manager, and I'm pleased today.
[3:05:00]
May to be here to present the fiscal year 23 annual report. This marks the second year of the renewed sickly water program, which was approved by voters in 2020. Before we dive into the power point, though, I did want to first draw your attention to attachment 4. Attachment 4 is where you will find the proposed text adjustments to the three flood protection projects that are referenced in the memo.
[3:05:21]
And just as a brief overview for you, I did want to point out that the adjustments are very
[3:05:27]
minor for the Sunnyvale East and West Channel's Club Protection Project and the Yogis
[3:05:32]
Creek Club Protection Project, we are showing removal of some text from the project description.
[3:05:38]
It's basically removal of outdated information that was included in the original measure
[3:05:43]
that went to the voters.
[3:05:44]
So, the very simple removal there and we'll be providing updated information as always in
[3:05:48]
project satisfaction of the report, and then a minor typo is being corrected in a street
[3:05:54]
name for the upper penitentiocrete subprotection project.
[3:05:57]
So non substantive changes, but changes nonetheless, and following our process requires
[3:06:01]
board approval.
[3:06:02]
All right.
[3:06:02]
So moving on, I'm going to turn our attention back to the PowerPoint today.
[3:06:07]
We're going to go ahead and give you a brief overview of our annual report improvements,
[3:06:11]
talk about a program performance, proposed change control process improvements, and then
[3:06:16]
next steps. Here we have a brief overview of the renewed safely monitor program 6 priorities
[3:06:22]
through which we deliver 32 projects that benefit our community. During the development of the fiscal
[3:06:29]
year 23 annual report, as directed by the Board, staff addressed all of the recommendations from the
[3:06:34]
programs independent monitoring committee also known as the IMC and incorporated improvements resulting
[3:06:39]
from IMC feedback received during last year's review cycle. Over the summer we met with IMC members
[3:06:44]
who are assigned to work with staff on implementation of these recommendations, and I'm pleased
[3:06:48]
to share that the members provided very positive feedback and support of these improvements.
[3:06:54]
And I'd also like to take a moment to acknowledge that our IMC chair Jeffrey Hare is here today.
[3:06:59]
He's been waiting very patiently for this item to come before the board.
[3:07:03]
So I wanted to acknowledge his presence.
[3:07:06]
Here you'll see the updated annual project statuses.
[3:07:09]
These are one of the process improvements for report improvements for referring to.
[3:07:14]
you can see that our new status categories are active, scheduled to start, on hold, KPI
[3:07:19]
not achieved, completed and closed.
[3:07:24]
The improvements also include enhanced data presentations such as more nuanced capital
[3:07:28]
project delivery confidence levels, adding five-year status history tables, and adding
[3:07:33]
flood history and background sections to our flood protection projects.
[3:07:37]
On now briefly highlight the overall program performance for fiscal year 23.
[3:07:43]
As you can see in fiscal year 23 91% of the projects were active and 9% were scheduled
[3:07:49]
to start.
[3:07:50]
On the right, you could see a snapshot of the project statuses along with a change control
[3:07:54]
process column indicating whether adjustments or modifications were made, that's another improvement
[3:07:58]
here.
[3:08:01]
All right, moving on in fiscal year 23, the board did approve the following project modifications
[3:08:06]
which are referenced here and in detail in the annual report, as well as information provided via a link.
[3:08:14]
I'll now provide an overview of the fiscal year 23 program highlights and accomplishments.
[3:08:19]
Some of the most notable include completion of a 2300 footlong underground tunnel
[3:08:23]
for the U.S. pre-cule protection project.
[3:08:27]
Awarding nearly 1.35 million in grants and partnerships for 33 projects.
[3:08:31]
Removing 1,546 tons of trash from local waterways, removing 811 cubic yards of vegetation and nearly 15,000 cubic yards of sediment from local creeps to reduce flood risks.
[3:08:46]
And those are just a few of the accomplishments.
[3:08:49]
More is included of course in the summary chapters and projects status reports.
[3:08:54]
Next, they'll take a moment to cover the proposed improvements to our change control process, approved by the Board in 2016.
[3:08:59]
The change control process includes processes for adjustments, modifications, and decisions
[3:09:07]
to not implement a project.
[3:09:10]
The updates is shown here, and on the following slides are showing changes with strike
[3:09:15]
through for the removed text and red font for the proposed new text, and the changes are primarily
[3:09:22]
required to align the process with the renewed safety model program, including reference
[3:09:27]
referencing the correct appendices and resolution and I'll briefly scroll through so you
[3:09:34]
can get a sense of what the changes are.
[3:09:39]
Very straightforward minor updates. Finally, I
[3:09:43]
did want to note that you'll see minor updates to reflect our change in schedule which means
[3:09:49]
we're coming to the board in November instead of in September which we've done in the past and then
[3:09:56]
Also a change to remove the now defunct blue ribbing committee that
[3:10:00]
That committee was created solely to receive feedback during the development of the program before putting
[3:10:06]
on the ballot measure back in 2012. So that committee no longer exists, so we're moving reference
[3:10:12]
from this process. Finally, here you'll see, we are in November here, shown by the purple
[3:10:21]
asterix. We are presenting the annual report to the board. The next step after you approve
[3:10:26]
that will be sharing that report with the Independent Monitoring Committee.
[3:10:30]
We have our kickoff meeting with the committee, the first Wednesday and December, and
[3:10:35]
then we will be conducting our review, January through February, per the board request.
[3:10:41]
We'll be bringing back one item to the board, which will include both the IMC report as well
[3:10:46]
as the management response to that report in March.
[3:10:51]
Finally, that brings us to our board actions for today, which include approving the fiscal
[3:10:54]
your 23 annual report with text adjustments to projects, authorizing staff to submit this report
[3:11:01]
to the IMC reports review, authorizing staff to update the annual report with audited financials,
[3:11:08]
and then updating the Claim Water and Natural Fluff Protection Program to change control process.
[3:11:14]
The IMC is scheduled to receive this report again following boards approval today, and we look forward
[3:11:20]
to receiving any questions or feedback you have.
[3:11:22]
Thank you for your report.
[3:11:24]
The Red Russianberg.
[3:11:26]
Ms. Collins, thank you so much for your presentation and for this report.
[3:11:31]
Oh, and because you're at the meeting yesterday,
[3:11:32]
I thank you for that as well.
[3:11:34]
It's always a pleasure to work with you.
[3:11:36]
So this might just be a newbie question.
[3:11:39]
So forgive me if it is that.
[3:11:42]
But I'd noticed on the reports because of course details, right?
[3:11:47]
I noticed on the longer form report that on page 25,
[3:11:51]
it accounts for Chaco as scheduled to start. Is that me, is that just because that
[3:11:59]
section of the Safewater program hasn't been updated yet? I'm guessing. I can answer
[3:12:05]
that question. Wonderful. So there are different kinds of key performance indicators
[3:12:10]
in the Safewater program and the key performance indicator for Pacheco is a fun
[3:12:13]
transfer. It is not the delivery of the project as a whole. It's a transfer of
[3:12:18]
And so because that transfer is not scheduled to start until a future date, it's listed as scheduled to start.
[3:12:25]
Nevertheless, we provide full transparency in our update.
[3:12:28]
We provide information about the project to the public and the IMC.
[3:12:32]
But for the purpose of the delivery of the key performance indicator, it's marked as scheduled to start.
[3:12:37]
Okay, then I guess I just want to say that for your consideration as appropriate when you have time.
[3:12:42]
I think that I asked you to consider the items I put in my, in my
[3:12:49]
addendum memo attached to item number 5.2 on the agenda just for thoughts about updating
[3:12:57]
that, you know, that item and providing greater transparency about it, but I know that's not
[3:13:04]
the topic of today and as to today, I looked at those changes and, you know, I am very
[3:13:10]
of the detailed orientation.
[3:13:12]
I love detailed orientation.
[3:13:14]
So this is really good to see.
[3:13:16]
Detail orientation serves our communities, our constituents,
[3:13:20]
transparency is always a good thing.
[3:13:22]
So thank you for that.
[3:13:25]
Dr. Bell.
[3:13:29]
Thank you.
[3:13:30]
I read, I'm referring to the Resolution Attachment 5.
[3:13:38]
And I'm looking at page 5 of the section J.
[3:13:43]
Okay, this is the low-income senior tax exemption or the exemption, okay.
[3:13:53]
And when I read it, I was a little confused.
[3:13:55]
I thought that renters would be able to get our property owned by rental,
[3:14:04]
or there'd be some way that renters would be able to get an exemption.
[3:14:10]
And if they were low income renters, it looked in like housing.
[3:14:17]
It says property, low income owner occupied and seniors over where one person and household
[3:14:26]
is the senior over 65.
[3:14:31]
So well, first of all, low income people don't own housing units in this county or recently
[3:14:41]
purchase thousand units, okay. These are people that might have owned a house and they probably
[3:14:46]
are seniors.
[3:14:51]
So how many exemptions have been applied for and accepted?
[3:14:58]
Do we have a count of that?
[3:15:00]
Just for information purposes.
[3:15:02]
I can turn that over to see if I'm a derontaler, but just to address your first question, I believe that the reason
[3:15:10]
renters are referenced in the resolution, is they're not paying the tax because it's a parcel tax, so they don't own the parcel, they're not then required to pay the tax.
[3:15:19]
But I'll turn it over to see if I'm a derontaler.
[3:15:21]
The owner pays the tax and then passes it on to the renters. Okay, go ahead, go ahead, please.
[3:15:27]
Yes, good afternoon, Darren Taylor chief and I slot the sir. I don't have figures off the top of my head
[3:15:34]
But it is a program that is pretty broadly used. It's it's it's it's a bigger number than one would think in terms of people
[3:15:41]
I get banjo of the exemption and we can provide those numbers to you. I would love to have that
[3:15:45]
I hope the board does wants to see that too because I I would be interested in finding out how those exemptions compared to other
[3:15:54]
low-income and senior exemptions and other agencies.
[3:16:02]
Is there a way of combining the requests for exemptions?
[3:16:09]
Like, if you're living in an area in there's school taxes and water district taxes,
[3:16:15]
you can send, I guess, the assessor request for all of them and wants to just check the
[3:16:23]
boxes, or I don't know if it's that easier or not.
[3:16:29]
So that's, that's no issue for me, I think we want to make sure that anybody that
[3:16:35]
it's qualified should be allowed to get the exemption.
[3:16:41]
And we want to make sure that it close to 100% of them do, because that's what we told
[3:16:48]
everybody during the campaign that we had for this, you know, so which I participated in quite
[3:16:57]
heavily. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. We have more report. Are we moving on?
[3:17:07]
We're moving on? Actually we didn't have action items. So we are asking the Board to take a motion
[3:17:13]
to ask everybody. Yeah. We're way ahead of you. Yeah. So we have a motion. We haven't put the
[3:17:19]
on that on this?
[3:17:21]
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
[3:17:22]
I have no request at this time.
[3:17:23]
Okay.
[3:17:23]
I have a motion in a second from Santos and Mr.
[3:17:25]
Merum.
[3:17:26]
All those in favour of signify by say aye.
[3:17:29]
Any opposition?
[3:17:30]
That passes?
[3:17:32]
We're not moving on to our final item for approval.
[3:17:37]
Or actually, information.
[3:17:38]
8.2.
[3:17:40]
You see even information on the Anderson Dan seismic
[3:17:42]
Richford Project status and federal energy regulatory commission order.
[3:17:46]
Compliance Project update.
[3:17:49]
Brian. All right, good afternoon to the board. So we're going to give a presentation today on
[3:17:54]
the Anderson Dam seismic retrofit project and the FERC or compliance projects. So I really
[3:18:00]
want to take this opportunity. I know there's a lot of news and things going around about
[3:18:04]
the cost increases, but I want to take an opportunity to give an update about the progress that
[3:18:08]
we've made. It's been about a year since we've given an update like this to the board and we've made
[3:18:12]
a lot of progress. And I know that's a staff, many of whom have left the meeting, but a lot of them
[3:18:17]
still here, probably about 90% of the staff that we're in this room earlier, including this
[3:18:21]
board.
[3:18:21]
This board has had 75 different committee in board agenda items in the past year that they
[3:18:27]
have approved several work today on the Kyivini Creek Flood Protection Project, housing
[3:18:31]
things and things like that.
[3:18:32]
But I just really wanted to say thank you and all this progress is credit to a large group of
[3:18:37]
people.
[3:18:41]
Okay.
[3:18:41]
So starting off, just to clarify again, the Anderson Dam seismic retrofit project kind of
[3:18:46]
a split with the FERC order compliance project back in 2020, and it's created a suite of five
[3:18:53]
sort of new projects that total in about $400 million total in our Capital Improvement Program.
[3:18:58]
The biggest one being the Anderson Dam Tunnel Project that will create our diversion system
[3:19:03]
so that we can retrofit the dam. And some associated projects that coyote creek flood management measures
[3:19:09]
project, the coyote percolation dam replacement. And two conservation measures, measure projects,
[3:19:15]
the Cross Valley Pipeline Extension and the Coyote Creek Stream Augmentation Fish Protection
[3:19:19]
Metter.
[3:19:20]
That's also known as the Chilers Project.
[3:19:23]
So the ADSRP or Anderson Dam seismic retrofit project, as you all know, includes retrofitting
[3:19:27]
the dam embankment by removing it, replacing it with state-of-the-art embankment placement
[3:19:32]
technology, and starting to do outlet works and replacing the concrete spillway.
[3:19:37]
And I'll get a little bit more in the detail on the spillway at the end of this presentation
[3:19:41]
and what we've developed there.
[3:19:43]
And there's also conservation measures included in the ADSRP that I'll talk a little bit about as well that are developing.
[3:19:52]
Okay, so where are we at in time?
[3:19:54]
So I want to direct your attention to early 2026.
[3:19:58]
That's when we're looking to break ground.
[3:20:00]
On the construction of the Anderson dam, seismic, retrofit portion of this project. So working back from there, we're honing in on that. About two years from now, we're hoping to be awarding a construction contract to a contractor to complete that work.
[3:20:14]
And there's many things that have to happen before we get to that point. With the complete our design, which I'll talk a little bit more about, where we're 90 percent, we have environmental review that are both sequa and NEPA processes and lots of permitting work to do meantime.
[3:20:28]
And all that comes together and culminates into the time
[3:20:30]
when we can proceed with the construction of this project.
[3:20:35]
So additionally, below, we have the five FERC order compliance projects.
[3:20:39]
Now, these all need to be physically completed before we start the seismic retrofit project work as well.
[3:20:44]
And if we look in where we're at in time now, the great news here is all five of these are in construction.
[3:20:50]
The Anderson Dam Tunnel project is about 50% complete.
[3:20:54]
The activity per dam replacement project is making good progress.
[3:20:58]
They started early this year and they'll be done in 2024.
[3:21:02]
The flood management measures project, there's been lots and lots of work on that with
[3:21:06]
the unhoused.
[3:21:07]
That's gotten under construction.
[3:21:09]
They're building the flood walls, physical things are happening there as well.
[3:21:13]
The cross valley pipeline extension is nearly complete.
[3:21:15]
It's just about ready to operate and the chillers is going to start construction here soon.
[3:21:20]
So lots and lots of progress on all these fronts.
[3:21:22]
I think a year ago, we only had the tunnel
[3:21:25]
and the cross-value pipeline extension construction.
[3:21:28]
So lots of good work by all here.
[3:21:32]
OK, so a little bit on the Anderson Dam tunnel project.
[3:21:35]
Of course, you see the dam there marked with the blue icon
[3:21:38]
and the reservoir behind it.
[3:21:40]
Also, I wanted to just point out the spillway at the top
[3:21:42]
of the screen there just because I'm
[3:21:43]
going to talk about that later, just for reference.
[3:21:46]
So here's the progress we've made on the tunnel so far.
[3:21:49]
We've made quite a bit of progress on the report on the next page as well, but we just reached about 1,100 feet of tunnel excavated.
[3:21:58]
So we started that tunnel excavation back on November 9th, 2022.
[3:22:03]
So just over a year of tunneling, and we've done 1100 feet. So lots of great construction progress there.
[3:22:08]
We've completed the excavation of the drop shaft there, showing green that gets incorporated into the retrofit project.
[3:22:15]
And we've also done quite a bit of work on the diversion outlet structure.
[3:22:19]
You see there down at the bottom of the screen, marked in yellow.
[3:22:22]
That's an older photo, but I'll show some new updates to that.
[3:22:26]
And so we're about 300 feet away from reaching our lake tap portion of this tunnel where we'll
[3:22:31]
do the last 350 feet with a micro tunnel boring machine that will exit out into the reservoir
[3:22:37]
about 30 feet below the water surface.
[3:22:39]
So we're like I said about 300 feet away from that.
[3:22:42]
So we've got three hundred feet more tunnel to excavate, but we'll probably start that.
[3:22:49]
Okay, so here's some pictures here on the left.
[3:22:51]
You have the tunnel as I mentioned.
[3:22:52]
This is one thousand feet in October.
[3:22:54]
We've got a hundred more feet in the past month.
[3:22:56]
So making good progress there.
[3:22:58]
Just kind of shows you what a 24 foot wide tunnel looks like.
[3:23:01]
It's pretty big when you look at the size of those people standing in the photo there.
[3:23:06]
And all throughout the summer, and we're just wrapping up the judging.
[3:23:09]
What you see there on the right, we've excavated into the slope of the reservoir there on the left.
[3:23:14]
and underneath the water surface, but down about 30 feet deep, removing material and preparing
[3:23:20]
for where the microtonal boring machine will come out into the reservoir itself. So that's
[3:23:26]
all wrapping up here soon as we complete that dredging process and that yellow booey you see
[3:23:31]
is actually a silk curtain so that extends down to the base of the reservoir and that contains all
[3:23:37]
of the sediment that they kick up during the dredging operation keeps it in that small area of
[3:23:47]
Here's a side by side of the diversion outlet structure so you can see the photo on the left
[3:23:52]
back from November 2022 and we're performing the foundation excavations and starting to
[3:23:57]
place the material in there and then fast forward to just about two months ago and September
[3:24:02]
2023 you can see the foundation rebar and the actual structure starting to take place and actually
[3:24:08]
tomorrow that will be pouring the first wall of the structure so imagine on the left of that
[3:24:13]
structure, you see there about a 30-foot tall concrete wall, so it's very, very much taking
[3:24:19]
shape as you look at the project and it's a progress so far. Back in the back of that
[3:24:24]
photo, if you follow the tunnel out, there's work going on in the north channel, it's a bit
[3:24:27]
hard to see, but lots of grading work, and we have that north channel cut off from water with
[3:24:32]
a temporary dike that's been thrown to place, so lots of good work happening there as well on the
[3:24:37]
site. So just another quick update on the FERC order compliance projects, starting with the flood
[3:24:43]
management measures. I did talk a little bit about that already. The project is underway and that's needed to to pass the flows.
[3:24:51]
Once we complete the tunnel, the increased capacity that will be able to release,
[3:24:55]
we need to have the flood management measures in place in order to convey that water through
[3:24:59]
I highly agree, say.
[3:25:01]
The Coyote E. Perculation Dam Replacement Project, who is a picture of the new foundation, where the ladder dam will go, and that will allow us to raise and lower the dam when needed, currently with the flashboard dam system.
[3:25:15]
The water gets too high and can over-top the flashboards and that can be an unsafe condition, and we want to be able to operate this for groundwater recharge capability, it's a pretty important part of our recharge system.
[3:25:27]
And a lower right with the cross valley pipeline extension and the Chiller's projects, the two conservation
[3:25:32]
measures that we're performing now.
[3:25:34]
And the cross valley pipeline releases water into a kind of creek where you see that little
[3:25:38]
spigot, just downstream of Oderpons.
[3:25:41]
And the Chiller's releases cooled water from the coyote coming plant, just downstream of the
[3:25:46]
Anderson dam.
[3:25:47]
So those are features that we need to have in place to keep coyote creek running.
[3:25:51]
Nice look for the fish.
[3:25:55]
So here's the conservation measures that we're working on as part of the Anderson Dam
[3:26:00]
seismic retrofit projects.
[3:26:01]
So these are included in the draft EIR, our under design development and planning and
[3:26:07]
working with the permitting and regulatory agencies on these different conservation measures.
[3:26:12]
So there's been lots of progress and collaboration with agencies through our different processes
[3:26:17]
with them, the OJAPONS that's going to be re-routing of the Coyote Creek system, those
[3:26:25]
Ponds were for gravel pits and basically took out the natural creek channel so we're going to be restoring that
[3:26:32]
There are a couple different alternatives on the table there. We'll be doing sediment augmentation in this reach of coyote creek
[3:26:38]
Extending north channel to reopen that section
[3:26:41]
I'm just downstream the dam and then lots of maintenance at the live oak restoration reach, which is also a county parks facility
[3:26:49]
So the fixing up the creek in the park there.
[3:26:55]
All right.
[3:26:56]
So quickly just going through some of the milestones behind the scenes here.
[3:26:59]
This is all the paperwork, all the engineering and permitting stuff that we've been working on.
[3:27:04]
So number one, we're at our 90% design.
[3:27:06]
We submitted a partial package to FERC and DSOD early this year.
[3:27:10]
I've been reviewing that.
[3:27:11]
We've been having some deliberations with them back and forth.
[3:27:14]
And we do have to submit the remaining spillway design documents that we're working through.
[3:27:19]
There's been some recent changes to that.
[3:27:21]
but I'll go over on the last slide.
[3:27:23]
This is probably the biggest news to me that September 1st,
[3:27:26]
we released the draft environmental impact report for ADSRP,
[3:27:29]
who's a percolian effort by lots of staff,
[3:27:33]
especially on the planning side.
[3:27:35]
So, a big effort getting that out in our public comment period,
[3:27:37]
just closed last week on November 8th.
[3:27:39]
And we have a list of comments that we'll be going through
[3:27:42]
and addressing as we prepare our final EIR.
[3:27:46]
So, it's moving along pretty smoothly.
[3:27:48]
And we also got our draft petition to surrender the hydropower facility.
[3:27:53]
This is our FERC process that we need to go through in the permitting realm of things.
[3:27:57]
So that's out for public review.
[3:27:59]
I think for another few weeks.
[3:28:03]
And then once we get through that we'll submit the final petition in February of 2024
[3:28:07]
for FERC to start their need for process.
[3:28:10]
And that could take up to two years to get work authorization.
[3:28:13]
We're going to be working closely with them as much as we can to expedite that.
[3:28:17]
because that really is our critical path permitting item.
[3:28:22]
Okay, any questions on any of this stuff?
[3:28:24]
Where are we getting the cost estimate item?
[3:28:30]
Okay, so we're working on the construction cost estimate.
[3:28:33]
So just in September, we received our engineers 90%
[3:28:38]
construction cost estimate, or they're depending
[3:28:40]
on a probable cost, and we've been reviewing that
[3:28:43]
with our project team, including our consultants
[3:28:45]
that work closely with us on reviewing
[3:28:48]
from technical perspective and with their experience
[3:28:51]
with the construction projects like this, and we're also getting a third-party cost estimate
[3:28:56]
through an independent cost estimating consultant.
[3:28:59]
So we're hoping to have that in December, and at that time we can really start firming
[3:29:04]
up all the numbers that we've received so far, but we do see that this project is going
[3:29:08]
to have a significant increase, and I'll get into those factors next.
[3:29:12]
Don't have too many numbers yet, but I anticipate that we'll be doing many more presentations
[3:29:16]
on the cost increase of Anderson because it is very significant, and there are a lot
[3:29:20]
different complicated factors that will contribute to it.
[3:29:28]
So the direct cost increase drivers, one is the risk reduction measures, so we've had
[3:29:33]
some added features to protect the interim dams during construction using articulated
[3:29:38]
concrete blocks.
[3:29:39]
Basically, temporary spillways that go over the temporary embankments that will have
[3:29:45]
during construction, so that's been a feature added on, as we've been deliberating with
[3:29:49]
the dam safety regulatory agencies, and we also added a supplemental bid item to bid
[3:29:53]
on for a year of delay.
[3:29:56]
And that's just in case there's an implement
[3:29:57]
whether something out of control fit.
[3:30:00]
That the contractor can't, you know, it's an out of their control that we can basically build that cost and that contingency into the contract.
[3:30:07]
So we already have that built in in case it happens. So that's more of a contingency, but we did add that in as an extra contingency.
[3:30:16]
And then the design development, there's been pretty significant modifications to this billway, which I'll go over,
[3:30:21]
and developing the in-reservoir hall roads and how all the materials going to move around within the reservoirs and process the material to build the new embankment.
[3:30:30]
So just developing that in further detail.
[3:30:34]
One of the bigger increased factors are the material cost increases.
[3:30:37]
Some materials such as concrete and steel have almost doubled in price.
[3:30:41]
In the past two to three years on the kind of post-COVID.
[3:30:45]
Just due to the supply chain issues and other labor force issues in the economy.
[3:30:50]
So that's been a pretty major cause of the cost increase.
[3:30:53]
And then sort of related to that anticipated contractor markups.
[3:30:57]
So just the market conditions for contractors and kind of the risk they would have to take on for this project.
[3:31:04]
We're assuming that they're going to have pretty healthy markups for their overhead and general conditions and the other things that they don't bid on directly such as their profit as well.
[3:31:15]
But that's going to be a major driver in the costing increase as well.
[3:31:23]
Okay, so this is the last slide just want to get a little bit into the spillway design changes that we've seen.
[3:31:28]
this is going to be responsible for, you know, major portion of the design changes that are
[3:31:33]
contributing to the cost increase. So you can see on this lower left area, I'm sure if
[3:31:39]
my arrow is showing up, the original spillway comes out straight and ends right about here.
[3:31:44]
It's just a straight shot spillway. And just wanted to mention, the spillway isn't an operating
[3:31:49]
spillway, this is our emergency spillway, just in case the reservoir fills up as a safe way to
[3:31:54]
flow out of the reservoir, kind of like the bathtub analogy that Alex Gordon used earlier,
[3:32:01]
you know, your bathtub has a way to drain before it overflows over the top of it
[3:32:04]
under bathroom floor.
[3:32:05]
There's a hole or something like that that will take the water out safely.
[3:32:09]
So similar concept here, but what we're doing is extending this fillway down through this section
[3:32:15]
here.
[3:32:16]
So the reservoir is on the left, and we'll be extending about 800 feet through an area that's
[3:32:22]
just an online channel, just kind of like a creek that's got plants and weeds and stuff
[3:32:28]
in it like that, but we're going to be lining that with concrete all the way.
[3:32:32]
And so in order to do that, the spillway will now have a turn in it.
[3:32:36]
So you can see this vending if you look at these cross sections at these different point section
[3:32:41]
to A, B, and C, you can see you've got a kind of a bank turn through this section here.
[3:32:45]
So just extending this spillway and all the additional excavation and support of the slopes
[3:32:50]
in this area, an extra concrete that's going to be a pretty
[3:32:53]
pretty major added cost, but this will help us safely convey
[3:32:57]
emergency spills in the future, meeting the DSOD criteria
[3:33:01]
for a probable max flood, so that was just one feature
[3:33:04]
I wanted to share today,
[3:33:08]
and that's all I have.
[3:33:10]
Thank you running for that update, and through a report
[3:33:12]
forward comments, well the comments.
[3:33:17]
Thank you, Mr. Chair, I have no requests at this time.
[3:33:19]
Very good. That was information only. Ryan, thank you.
[3:33:23]
Thank you. The tours you've been giving all this past year have been absolutely phenomenal.
[3:33:27]
Director Shoya, of course.
[3:33:30]
Okay, I have a quick question.
[3:33:31]
Thank you, Chair.
[3:33:33]
So, the number that we're putting the agenda member on them.
[3:33:39]
So, I'm going to put the total part there cause I close to 1.9 billion.
[3:33:44]
That's the total part there cause.
[3:33:47]
So that's the, um, my interpretation is that it's the, um,
[3:33:52]
the, a seismic retrofit project. Correct. Plus, all the conservation measures.
[3:33:57]
Plus, all the labor design and committee. That's the total project cost.
[3:34:02]
That's correct. It does not include the FOCT project. So it's a, yeah, those are the
[3:34:06]
separate, I just wanted to clarify, yeah, the Anderson Dam, seismic retrofit project.
[3:34:10]
Yeah. Total project cost. And all these, these project kind of like related to the F,
[3:34:17]
FLCP, they're not included, but then there's one point now, it's a total project cost for the currently estimated total budget cost for the Anderson size of exactly.
[3:34:29]
Correct, yeah, we took our preliminary numbers and did put them in the CIT model to see what we would get and there was one point.
[3:34:36]
Yeah, okay, thank you.
[3:34:36]
Thank you very much, thank you again Ryan.
[3:34:40]
Moving on, your agenda, external affairs, nothing chief executive officer, CEO report.
[3:34:46]
Yes, get evening a good afternoon, late afternoon,
[3:34:50]
whichever element is in the lower.
[3:34:51]
Just in the interest of time,
[3:34:53]
I'm just going to point to the fact that you do have
[3:34:55]
two reports, the community benefits,
[3:34:57]
quarterly update as well as in watersheds.
[3:35:24]
Thank you, Mr. Chair, yes. I have two requests from Director Bell. The first one is to provide regular updates to the board.
[3:35:29]
or a board committee on a Sunny Oaks Proculation Ponds rehabilitation and to work with the City
[3:35:36]
of Campbell and Santa Clara County Fire on a Resolution to the Proculation Ponds.
[3:35:44]
And then the second request is to provide direct about with the number of low-income senior
[3:35:49]
exemption participants and consider comparing our program to other low-income and senior
[3:35:55]
extension programs provided by other agencies.
[3:35:59]
Thank you very much, and with that, we are adjourned.
[3:36:04]
Thank you.
[3:36:04]
Moving on to 9 a.m. on this Friday special joint meeting with
[3:36:08]
City of San Jose in November 1723, Santa Clara Valley Water District Headquarters
[3:36:13]
building 5700.
[3:36:15]
We are adjourned.
[3:36:16]
Thank you.