Agenda
Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[0:03]
Court meeting order, good afternoon, roll call, please.
[0:11]
Director Schumann here, Director Keegan, here, Vice Chair Kremlin, here.
[0:19]
Director Lizade, here, Director Santos, Director Verella, here.
[0:26]
Chair, Mr. Mayor. Aye.
[0:28]
Have all members present?
[0:32]
Thank you, Madam Clerk, we move right along then to the pledge of allegiance.
[0:35]
Let's see the Rectal Azac, please lead us.
[0:39]
Please join me in the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:42]
Applegion Allegiance.
[0:44]
May you please.
[0:46]
I'm the United States of America.
[0:48]
To the Republic of the Witch of Scales.
[0:51]
In the Foundation on the God.
[0:53]
In the Business Hall.
[0:55]
The Liberty.
[0:56]
Thank you.
[1:00]
Thank you.
[1:01]
No, it's just...
[1:05]
It's the zoom that makes us look like this.
[1:09]
Yeah.
[1:13]
All right.
[1:14]
This is a time open for public comment on any item.
[1:18]
Not on the agenda.
[1:19]
This is the time when most of the public can address us on any issue.
[1:22]
Not on the agenda this afternoon.
[1:25]
Do we have any requests to address us?
[1:27]
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
[1:28]
At this time, there are no hands raised.
[1:30]
Thank you.
[1:31]
We'll move right along then to our time certain issue.
[1:35]
I don't number 2.1, water supply, mass supply, monitoring, and assessment program update.
[1:43]
Receive and discuss information on the water supply, mass supply, monitoring, and assessment program evaluation.
[1:51]
Let's see Rick.
[1:55]
Who's Eric?
[1:56]
Okay.
[1:56]
I'm going to have Mr. Baker go ahead and introduce this one.
[2:00]
Great.
[2:00]
Thank you.
[2:01]
chair chair chair on board members. Yeah, that's all the rain. Hey, oh my gosh, I
[2:07]
can tell how happy this has been happy. This is making me and I guess I should also
[2:13]
open up that of course. I know you know and everybody knows, but you know, we're
[2:17]
going to be significant amounts of rainfall to get a set of this draft, but we'll take
[2:20]
what we can get right now. So if we have, but in terms of sprinklers off, we keep going.
[2:25]
With the current situation, the drought climate change and, you know, we're at understanding
[2:30]
We're in court of water and how we're working through all those things planning for our future now is more important than ever and that's why we appreciate your time
[2:38]
To have you receive and discuss this information on the monitoring and assessment program. This is the annual
[2:43]
Update that we give to our water supply messed plan and with that I'd like to introduce Samantha Green. Thank you. That didn't say
[2:52]
Good afternoon. I'm going to share my screen
[3:01]
on this screen, you should all see the presentation for the WARS Pine
[3:07]
Master Planes Monitoring and Assessment Program update.
[3:10]
Thank you for that introduction.
[3:13]
Chief Baker, my name is Samantha Green.
[3:16]
I'm with the WARS Pine Planning and Conservation Unit.
[3:19]
The goal of the monitoring and assessment program is not to provide a
[3:24]
recommendation or ask for any decisions from the board today.
[3:27]
What it's real goal is to provide a big picture and update for all of the projects and programs that help us implement our water supply master plan to provide a reliable water supply out through 2040.
[3:42]
And so today you're going to hear about many of the projects and programs that staff is participating in.
[3:50]
Any decisions related to those projects of programs will be incremental at the time when they're needed for those projects
[3:56]
But the goal of this is to give you that big picture, so we need to make those decisions
[4:01]
You can understand how they fit into meeting our potential lead in the future
[4:06]
And so feel free to interrupt me as I go I want if you have questions or comments
[4:12]
I want this to be as helpful and informative as possible
[4:16]
So, with that, I'll begin.
[4:32]
Well, I'd read background on the Water Supply Master Plan.
[4:35]
It was adopted by the Board in November 2019,
[4:39]
with the insurcercy sustainability strategy
[4:42]
as our three-prong approach for meeting our future needs.
[4:46]
And that three-prong approach, the first aspect of that
[4:50]
is the two secure our existing system.
[4:53]
And so that's done from early through our Capital Improvement Program,
[4:56]
projects like the side of the retrofits and our rich art.
[5:00]
A few minutes of our pipeline and our treatment plants. And then another approach to doing that is also the Delta conveyance project that can help secure the imported water conveyance system.
[5:12]
And the second problem is to meet our future demands with by expanding water conservation, stormwater capture, as well as global reuse.
[5:22]
And then the final prompt to that strategy is to optimize our system and the idea behind this is to invest in project like a tick or reservoir,
[5:31]
transfer to the pipeline, or additional recharge and over the August sub-based infrastructure recharge.
[5:37]
That can help us be more nimble under different future hydrologic conditions or regulatory conditions.
[5:43]
So, with that three-poam strategy, the real goal is to come up with meets a project that
[5:50]
help us meet our future demands.
[5:54]
And what math does is it provides an annual update and a continual evaluation so that in
[6:03]
between those five-year updates for the WARS climature plan, we're still keeping on top of
[6:08]
are we doing on implementing those products, implementing the plan, and providing heated information
[6:15]
on those projects, so that the board can make proper decisions.
[6:20]
It also provides an opportunity for the board to update implementation strategy as needed.
[6:28]
Last year, when staff came to the board with the monitoring assessment program update, one of
[6:34]
the main outcomes of that year was a new demand model.
[6:38]
And so for the war supply master plan,
[6:40]
that demand projection was created before the last drought,
[6:45]
2012, 2016 drought ended.
[6:47]
And so when we worked, we had to come up with assumptions
[6:50]
that what was going to happen was that rebound.
[6:54]
And we used assumptions based on what happened in cash drought.
[6:58]
However, what we found by 2020 is that our rebound wasn't quite
[7:03]
all the way what happened in cash strout.
[7:06]
And so we worked with our retailers
[7:08]
and collected updated water use data from them
[7:12]
as well as our independent customers.
[7:16]
And updated our drought rebound assumptions
[7:18]
and developed a new demand of projection.
[7:21]
And the main finding of that is that it's around 40,000
[7:24]
eager feet less than what was projected
[7:27]
from the water supply master plan.
[7:30]
So with this new finding, it's important then
[7:32]
to look at how will we meet those future demands,
[7:36]
even though they're potentially not going to exceed
[7:39]
his forward priorities,
[7:41]
we still have climate change to continue with
[7:43]
and regulations coming down the pipe,
[7:44]
which affects the supply side.
[7:46]
So there's still is going to be that gap.
[7:48]
And so we still need projects to build that gap
[7:50]
to meet those future demands.
[7:52]
The board asks staff to come back
[7:55]
with four main things in this map.
[7:58]
And so the first part of that is one of the first item
[8:00]
is an updated project risk assessment, so the last risk assessment
[8:04]
was completed in 2017 associated with the water supply master plan, and so this
[8:10]
updates that risk assessment.
[8:13]
The second aspect is to provide a more robust climate change evaluation, looking at how
[8:18]
climate change will impact our local and important water supplies and will be presenting on
[8:23]
that today as well, as well as continually providing the project updates as well as how projects
[8:30]
can help us hose that gap between supply and demand, and then how those projects can be mixed
[8:36]
in match.
[8:37]
So create potential project portfolios to meet those future demands.
[8:42]
And when we look at these project projects and project portfolios, one of the main things
[8:48]
we are aiming to do is meet those future demands and meet the board level of service goal.
[8:54]
And from the water supply match, we plan the board level of service goal.
[8:57]
If reliable and equal is to meet 100% of demand during non-draft years, so if it's a normal
[9:03]
year, we do not want to ask the community to have to reduce their water use.
[9:08]
However, during drought, the level of service school is to not have to ask for more than
[9:13]
a 20% water use reduction.
[9:16]
And so as we do our planning and look at how projects can help us close that gap, we consider
[9:21]
this level of service school.
[9:25]
The first part that staff looked at as far as updating our project understanding this year was redoing that risk assessment.
[9:34]
The goal of a risk assessment when you're thinking of a project press, you're thinking of risks that could help it.
[9:40]
That may cause reduced project success in terms of is it going to be completed when we meet it as well as will the benefits be provided that we expect.
[9:52]
Really, when we do a risk assessment, it's not to say, oh, this is a high risk project, so we shouldn't do it not at all.
[10:00]
In fact, the goal of the risk assessment is overall goal is to make sure that we understand where the risks are, so staff can begin to mitigate those risks and make sure that we minimize them as much as possible.
[10:12]
And so what staff did was we had a series of internal stakeholder meetings to develop our risk assessment approach, which classified six categories of risks, as well several sources underneath them.
[10:25]
And then 10 different internal units with different expertise around these projects and around
[10:30]
risk.
[10:31]
And our asset, data completed the risk assessment on all the projects.
[10:36]
And you can see the report is attached to this agenda items today with more detailed results.
[10:43]
And the graph to the left is the total risk outcome that we found.
[10:49]
But again, the goal of this risk assessment, what it really allows us to do, is help
[10:53]
It makes these risks more well known so that we can mitigate and reduce them in the future.
[11:02]
The next aspect is of our evaluation for math was to include climate change more explicitly.
[11:10]
And so we included climate change impacts on the local system as well as the imported water system.
[11:17]
And so first to discuss how we looked at climate change with the local system,
[11:21]
we worked with a professor from Santa Clara University, professor Edmauer.
[11:25]
He has an expertise, both in hydrology, as well as climate change, down scaling, and we work
[11:33]
as into down scale 10 GCMs, that DWR recommended as the good global climate model,
[11:39]
so GCMs, global climate model, we global climate model represents California climate.
[11:47]
And so he downscale those 10 GCMs to represent the potential impacts that climate change could
[11:52]
on specifically Santa Clara County.
[11:56]
And in the graph over to the right, you can see on this is the representation of those
[12:02]
down-scale GCNs on the Y-axis.
[12:05]
We have the change in precipitation and down the center is zero because GCNs are uncertain
[12:12]
whether precipitation or are going to go up is going to go up or down in contrast to temperature,
[12:17]
which is on the Y-axis, you can see zero is at the beginning because there is agreement
[12:22]
amongst all GCMs, that temperature is going to increase in the future.
[12:28]
And so what we did for our analysis is we took the range of local impacts from climate change.
[12:36]
So what you're going to see today is we looked at five different climate change scenarios.
[12:41]
Or GCMs circled at BC, D and E, those really bracket, those 10 potential climate futures.
[12:49]
And then we also look at A, which is if current hydrologic and temperature conditions continue out into the future.
[12:59]
And so we took that GCM information and that provided us local reservoir inflows,
[13:06]
potential about future evaporation, climate change impacts on demands or water use precipitation and natural groundwater recharge.
[13:16]
For imported water supply impacts, the DWR does not have the same type of deep down scale GCN data available for us to use for imported water supplies currently.
[13:31]
And so instead what we did is we took their most recent housing data from their delivery capability for 2019, that's from the Urban Water Management Plan.
[13:42]
which just had some consideration of climate change,
[13:46]
but it's an incomplete picture of climate change
[13:49]
and what regulations could do by mid-century.
[13:52]
And so what we did is we used a combination of DWR climate change studies,
[13:57]
as well as we think at his fourth data, to come up with an approximation
[14:01]
of what climate change and regulations could do to our important water supply by 245.
[14:08]
And what we found is that it would be a conservative expectation would be a decrease of approximately 25% in imported water supplies.
[14:20]
So to be careful and conservative, we chose that 25% to use across all of our climate change analysis that you will see today.
[14:30]
So we take the local impact as well as the imported water impact and climate change, and we put that into our water supply planning model, which has a 94 year model period, and it models all of our supplies are storage facilities, recharge facilities, treatment plants and conveys facilities.
[14:51]
And the goal of the model is that moves water around to meet our county-wide demands,
[14:57]
retailer demands, as well as our independent.
[15:01]
So, we ran this model looking at these five potential climate scenarios. And so, all the way over to the right is a graph that is showing one way to look at water supply liability. That's the main goal of our modeling is if and how can we meet our future water demands and meet that level of service goal.
[15:23]
And so this y-axis is the number of use of shortage on this graph, and then each far
[15:30]
along the x-axis is that one of those primates scenarios A through E.
[15:38]
And so what we're aiming to do is stay with no more than a 20% water use production.
[15:45]
And so that is translated by the colors.
[15:47]
And so the yellow is the number of years, for example, that the model found is that we would have to ask our community to reduce water use by 10%.
[15:58]
And then the orange is the number of years that the model found over the 94 years we have to ask the community to reduce by 20%.
[16:05]
And so what we're really trying to do here is stay in those yellows and oranges and find projects that can keep us out of the pinks and the reds.
[16:16]
not having more water-needs reduction calls than that 20%, and so what you're looking at here
[16:22]
is the base scenario for these five different climate features so that what I mean by base
[16:28]
case is it's our existing system plus our catalog treatment programs, so as well as our
[16:38]
conservation programs but it does not include any new projects and so our new projects are what
[16:44]
needed to close that gap to get rid of those pinks in the reds. While we looked at all of
[16:51]
this, looked at all five of these scenarios for the projects in today's presentation, we're
[16:57]
going to show you the results for the median climate change scenario. It's still a pretty severe
[17:04]
climate change scenario, but it sits in the middle between our five potential.
[17:13]
And so,
[17:13]
You can get a question far that you see on the left the base case is the same as I'm at change in REOC
[17:21]
Last slide and again on the wide
[17:24]
Years of short in hold on Sam Sam hold on just a minute. Yeah, yeah, yeah, thank you very much
[17:30]
I'm sorry to interrupt
[17:32]
I just want to make sure I read can you go back to the previous slides?
[17:39]
because the following slides has similar graphs.
[17:44]
That's one big short.
[17:45]
I'm reading these correctly.
[17:48]
So the bar charts, it's a baseline for 2045,
[17:53]
which is the condition of the baseline
[17:57]
is that we've accomplished our current goal
[18:00]
of water conservation by 2040.
[18:03]
and also completed the key capital improvement project by 2040, which includes the dams,
[18:14]
or dams, rents with it. And of course, it's the, so it has, it's, yeah, yeah.
[18:23]
So I just want to make sure that you're building those assumptions in your analysis.
[18:29]
And so if that's correct, then when I read these bars, so is it a cumulative or is it an individual?
[18:42]
So for example, under a scenario A, the yellow bar, which is 10% conservation that's four out of four, it's four number of years.
[18:57]
that would be four years out of the 94 years that's modeling and then the orange is
[19:06]
six years or is it two years? Two years? Two years? Okay. So it's one year.
[19:14]
So it's two years out of the 94 modeling period. Okay. And then in that, that's the same thing.
[19:21]
Okay. Thank you very much. So yeah. So I want to make sure I'm reading it correctly so
[19:26]
that at the following slides, how we're on the on the
[19:30]
exactly that yeah. Thank you. Yeah, I appreciate that. Thank you.
[19:38]
So this
[19:39]
is the same face case bar that was scenario C in that last slide. So that
[19:45]
moderate climate change scenario. And again, to me, our level
[19:49]
first goal, we're trying to stay in the yellow and the orange. We
[19:53]
don't want to see these pinks and reds. And so coming up here,
[19:59]
Let me look up.
[20:00]
And we're going to talk about how individual projects can help us reduce the number of years as well as the severity, so that, you know, take out the things in the red.
[20:10]
And as well as looking at project combinations. And so for individual projects, the group is here. And then project combinations.
[20:20]
The way we develop these is we combined new water supply with either storage or conveyance.
[20:29]
And one thing I want to highlight, however, in this analysis,
[20:33]
and I meant to bring it up earlier as well, so I apologize.
[20:36]
Is that the Delta conveyance project we did not have model data available,
[20:43]
and still do not have model data available,
[20:44]
It's early stages right now of project planning.
[20:48]
And so we were unable to include it in this analysis
[20:51]
unfortunately.
[20:52]
So if that is a potential new water supply,
[20:55]
that could be looked at and coupled with things
[21:00]
in this coupled with other projects that we're looking at here.
[21:04]
But first, since we did not have that available data,
[21:07]
we were unable to do that.
[21:08]
Guys, I just want to flag that for everybody.
[21:11]
And so in highlighted in green are those projects or project portfolios that help us meet our level or do achieve our level of service school.
[21:23]
And in general, with this analysis, we found that local supplies that are dropped from climate resilient help us achieve that.
[21:32]
However, this is just one look at our system and a snapshot of how we're able to meet
[21:39]
our supplies under its existing makeup with new projects.
[21:43]
It's important to also look at our storage and how our storage can be exercised because
[21:49]
exercising and using our storage capacity can really help us be nimble in future drought
[21:54]
and in future wet periods.
[21:56]
And so, looking at our total storage volume on the Y-axis, so this is the volume of storage we
[22:05]
are using, and then on this orange line from at the top here, this is our total existing
[22:14]
storage capacity we have available in our system as this today.
[22:18]
And so that is including our semi-traffic storage, our local groundwater storage and surface
[22:23]
water storage as well.
[22:27]
And so we then took our model information
[22:30]
to see how well we use that existing storage capacity,
[22:34]
considering future climate change.
[22:37]
So future impacts on hydrology and evaporation.
[22:42]
And so what you can see here this bar,
[22:44]
this is the base case again.
[22:46]
The bottom of the bar represents the minimum storage
[22:49]
found over the full 94-year period,
[22:52]
where the top of the bar is the maximum storage.
[22:55]
And then that diamond is the average storage.
[22:58]
And to help track that how projects compare
[23:02]
and for always projects compare to the base case,
[23:06]
we do have these dotted lines that will continue
[23:08]
to go out this first grouping
[23:11]
is how just individual projects can help us increase
[23:15]
our exercising our storage.
[23:17]
And then here is how project combinations
[23:20]
or portfolios of projects can help us lead that storage.
[23:25]
And what this shows is that future
[23:27]
and frequent wet years with long-dryar periods
[23:30]
do indicate that under our existing storage makeup,
[23:33]
it could be difficult to fill.
[23:36]
Podible reuse does help increase our user storage,
[23:39]
that is furthering force that's dropped resiliency.
[23:43]
However, with climate change, we expect
[23:45]
that those wet years are going to come with big flows, right?
[23:49]
and then long, dry periods in between.
[23:51]
So we really want to make sure that in those wet periods
[23:53]
where we have the conveying capacity and the put capacity
[23:57]
in our base, in our storage facilities,
[23:59]
to be able to capture those by your clothes.
[24:03]
And so what this indicated is that we could improve
[24:06]
our ability to exercise our system storage capacity
[24:09]
if we diversify the system.
[24:12]
And so on this next slide, we're going to show three
[24:16]
potential diversification options, they're just preliminary scenarios, and the board can
[24:24]
add and mix and match. The first example is the Chaco, so you can use a local reservoir
[24:33]
where to help diversify our existing system. And when you look at this box, this is our
[24:44]
account storage, and the blue is our local surface water storage, and so you could use
[24:49]
a project, a local surface water project, to help diversify for example our out of
[24:55]
source. Another option?
[25:00]
Is to diversify using other out-of-county thinking options.
[25:07]
And then a final example is using a regional surface source to help diversify.
[25:12]
But again, this can be mixed and matched to get the put and take capacities that we want and manage and balance risks and constraints as well.
[25:22]
And so this table at the bottom has summarizes the put and takes.
[25:27]
And so as an example here, semi-traffic thing, this is our existing, our existing investment
[25:34]
in the semi-traffic thing.
[25:36]
It's 350,000 acre feet.
[25:38]
And that gets tied with a 32,000 acre feet maximum foot.
[25:42]
If you diversify with any of these three examples, you're able to increase your max foot, because
[25:48]
you're adding that additional 60,000 acre feet foot, for example, for a new groundwater bank.
[25:54]
of course, if you ask that some traffic that put will come down a little bit too, but you'll
[25:58]
still get much greater put capacity than what we have in our existing system, so much bigger
[26:02]
ability to take those wet years of plies and put them into storage, same thing with those
[26:07]
speceros and the chaco. They all have different percent losses associated with them as well,
[26:16]
so what you put in storage isn't necessarily going to be what's available to you at the end
[26:20]
When you're needed in a drought, so the groundwater banks tend to have a one-time foot loss,
[26:26]
where surface reservoirs have evacoration losses, so those are continual.
[26:31]
And then they each have their own constraints that also need to be found to determine
[26:35]
how to best mix and
[26:39]
that.
[26:40]
Just a minute, Sam.
[26:42]
Yeah.
[26:43]
Sure.
[26:44]
Sam, just again, this is pretty complex.
[26:49]
You four major changes.
[26:50]
We want to make sure that I'm reading it correctly.
[26:52]
So if I look at dislikes in the previous slides,
[26:56]
this existing available storage capacity,
[26:59]
the stash line on top, that's our current existing storage.
[27:04]
This is above ground storage, below ground storage,
[27:07]
and then outside the county storage.
[27:10]
So if we add a new project, like a new county storage,
[27:20]
this line or change will be moved up and if we at a recharge pound facility in South County
[27:37]
that does not change the line at just making the existing South County groundwater basin
[27:45]
more flexible and then more capacity to store water, but this line does not change.
[27:52]
That is correct.
[27:55]
Thank you very much.
[27:56]
So that's my question.
[28:01]
Thank you.
[28:03]
And maybe say we can talk just a little bit more on if we did, you know,
[28:07]
adding a recharge partner for some of these other things.
[28:08]
But the other part that you're talking about about how much we can put into these storage facilities.
[28:12]
So maybe an additional recharge point might be able to help us to go back to the men in the
[28:18]
max.
[28:19]
Maybe I'll have to average up or do certain things in that particular area.
[28:22]
It won't raise the the the the the dash line, but it could, you know, one of the things
[28:26]
that we're looking at and why that next slide talked about how well it would end is that when
[28:30]
the sweat years come in and the water to give you timeframes getting it into the ground
[28:35]
and getting it through the ground water bank is this is kind of a point there.
[28:38]
So thank you so much, Sam.
[28:39]
So Dan, Dan that's a, that's a, that's a good, that's a good
[28:44]
point. But over always that uh, if it's our existing groundwater
[28:50]
basin, then the capacity, the fullest capacity,
[28:55]
is for inferery one number. Yeah.
[28:58]
But then um, adding reach out for reach out to each
[29:01]
parco is a普. It can get us the put and take eye options much
[29:07]
more flexible film operation perspective.
[29:10]
Right, yeah, okay.
[29:11]
Good, thank you.
[29:14]
May I ask you a question?
[29:15]
Yes, through the chair.
[29:16]
Yes, Vice-Chief.
[29:18]
Yeah, I can go back to that slide again.
[29:21]
I think it's a really interesting, illustrative slide.
[29:25]
The slide after that, if we did, oh, yes, that one.
[29:30]
If you can see, you know, what I think could be added to this is not all storage is the same
[29:40]
from a reliability point of view, you know, in general out of the county is not as good as in county.
[29:51]
So, even, let's be curious, it's not in our county, in semi-traffic, it's far away.
[30:00]
Ground alarm banks will be called. So I mean, the biggest risk, it seems to me, is looking at the scenario of no water south blowing scenario, which we're facing right now. So when we do the next iteration of this, or maybe you want to address this now, put in the fact that in the most stressful condition, we can't get to water. So in many ground alarm banks, they're all going to be in the south or east, we won't be able to get it.
[30:29]
or send my track, like we're starting to have issues now, so I think we want to take that in the
[30:35]
consideration.
[30:38]
I 100% agree with that, yes. I don't know if Cindy or Vince want to follow up with
[30:46]
any comments on that with other dates.
[30:52]
Vice Chair of this year, Deputy Operator, absolutely. There is
[30:56]
a lot of information, a designated information, and we try to try to capture all of that in our
[31:02]
consideration, and this is a living document, and I'm going to process to find information.
[31:08]
We'll definitely include more nuances of the different values of storage as well as other projects.
[31:14]
Thank you for that.
[31:15]
Well, I haven't ensured I'm calling it nuance.
[31:19]
It's kind of the issue of, you know, hey, you might have a great int, I'm trying to think of the better analogy.
[31:26]
Well, you might have a real low cost per acre foot, like we do in so much crap, but it's unreliable.
[31:32]
So, what we needed, it's just not the dollar about, it's the reliability amount that we face.
[31:42]
So, I'm gonna call that a new one. I would say that's just as important as some of the financial life.
[31:50]
And additional example, when you don't have semi-traffic or water, it's not flowing.
[31:54]
There is no market to go by water. We can't get everybody right now across the Delta.
[31:59]
So, I think there's a lot of good information in here, but I think really cautious the way you're presenting it.
[32:07]
I think it is not taking into a risk adjusted press.
[32:11]
I'd like us to both expand our outlook in the next iteration.
[32:15]
Thank you.
[32:17]
If I can...
[32:19]
I'll jump first.
[32:22]
Can you give me a minute?
[32:24]
So, yeah, so I'm listening to Director Creme, and I have a thought that perhaps this
[32:29]
would be a good addition discussion, a climate change, and the impacts on groundwater and
[32:37]
water source of blood-ground, and the general water supply capacities that we could discuss
[32:41]
in our water storage towards committee.
[32:44]
More in detail, I'll listen to even third parties, and then bring to the Board of Directors
[32:48]
what our findings would be, and solutions potential, so that's a recommendation if that's
[32:53]
be that the committee chair wants to respond to, I mean, I need that up in the board of
[33:03]
sounds good.
[33:06]
Well, then I'll make that as a recommendation.
[33:09]
Let's see, Jan, if that's one word.
[33:11]
Yeah.
[33:11]
That's very disobeyed.
[33:13]
Thank you.
[33:13]
Thank you, Chair.
[33:15]
I, yeah.
[33:15]
Dr. Verella has a good idea, but I was just going to, it's more of a comment, but then
[33:26]
probably there's a question parting, and also that the comment that Director Kremlin made
[33:34]
that it's not nuances actually pretty complex analysis.
[33:42]
And I briefly read the risk analysis report.
[33:52]
I have to admit I did not spend the adequate time
[33:55]
to study the detail.
[33:57]
But I think that's where the potential risk
[34:02]
And that director Creman talked about that's where it needs to be addressed.
[34:09]
And I think it's already addressed, it's just that in this high-level presentation, it did not come out.
[34:17]
So for the storage committee to get into the detail of that, I think it's a good suggestion.
[34:26]
I'm in a appropriate suggestion.
[34:32]
Anyone else?
[34:34]
Okay, thank you, go ahead and say thank you.
[34:37]
Thank you.
[34:41]
Conversation.
[34:42]
So this side summarizes the costs and associated with each of the projects discussed today.
[34:51]
And I wanted, and it's in twenty twenty dollars.
[34:53]
I want to flag this typical life span column.
[34:55]
I don't want it to be thought of as once we hit 50 years, 75 years.
[35:03]
So,
[35:13]
the main conclusions from this analysis is that while our existing capacity may be sufficient, especially considering the lower projected demands, diversification can really
[35:25]
may really be able to help us improve our utility of that storage, and that if we improve
[35:32]
our use of storage that it does help us meet our level of service goals as well as investing
[35:38]
in drought resilience supplies. So the next steps are to proceed back through the board
[35:45]
directors that we then integrate into our map analysis and the water climaster plan going forward.
[35:51]
I do also want to flag that there should have been a hand out available.
[35:59]
I will also be on the screen with that's what I think that's allowed.
[36:04]
Let's see, he knows.
[36:08]
So a hand out of the timeline of projects and when decisions are going to be made
[36:15]
with our best available information right now.
[36:18]
So these are the main projects that are in planning
[36:23]
or with construction schedules.
[36:26]
So that the district is participating in
[36:29]
and based on color you have the green is when it's in planning,
[36:34]
then the blue's design and the orange represents construction.
[36:37]
And then you have any agreements
[36:40]
or the rectangle all out.
[36:42]
That the board will need to consider joining.
[36:45]
And then you have funding decisions as well as final decision in that circle.
[36:50]
So final decision is the go or no go.
[36:52]
Are you going to be part of the project or not?
[36:55]
And so this is so that you can see the layout of all the projects.
[37:04]
But again, no incremental decisions here today.
[37:10]
That's ready for the question.
[37:13]
Thank you, Sam.
[37:14]
Questions?
[37:16]
Sharon, do you start?
[37:17]
Thank you, Chair.
[37:18]
And I just, I have a request that this chart that it was presented about these new projects,
[37:30]
potential, schedule and decision making.
[37:33]
I think it will be a good piece of information for the CFP committee to have a similar chart
[37:41]
for the project that we plan to be completed between 20, 20, 20, 20, 40, we keep thinking
[37:49]
it's pretty far away, but it's really not that far away. And if our future planning is based
[37:58]
on completion of this key project by 20, 40, I think there will be important pieces of information
[38:08]
for SAP, your committee to use or refer to on the ongoing basis, so that'll just as a request for me.
[38:21]
Thank you, Keegan.
[38:23]
Third, the Keegan?
[38:26]
Yes, thank you.
[38:26]
I don't have a question.
[38:27]
I just have a comment.
[38:29]
I only would like to applaud staff for such a very thorough analytical approach to these projects.
[38:40]
projects and I think it's very helpful in terms of our ability to make decisions and the
[38:48]
public's ability to weigh in on this. I mean, the material is so dense. I don't even have
[38:54]
questions yet because I really need to think a little bit more about all the information that was
[39:01]
provided but it certainly was the monumental effort and Kudos to staff for that.
[39:08]
Thank you, Derek, the Kigan next.
[39:13]
I have no other board members.
[39:15]
I do have a member of the public.
[39:16]
Okay, let's see the member of the public.
[39:19]
Miss Katcia Irvin.
[39:21]
Good afternoon, Miss Irvin.
[39:25]
Good afternoon, everybody.
[39:27]
Staff members of the board.
[39:29]
Can you hear me?
[39:30]
Yes, we can.
[39:32]
Hi.
[39:32]
I'm Katcia Irvin, and I'm a volunteer at the ER Club.
[39:35]
We have a chapter in water committee.
[39:38]
And I want to thank you for holding this special meeting today.
[39:41]
about the ongoing process of water supply planning for Santa Clara County.
[39:47]
Given that this home meeting is dedicated to this topic and there will not be a lot of speakers.
[39:51]
I hope you will be considerate and not cut anyone off right at the three minutes.
[39:57]
This is an important topic and public.
[40:00]
And should input to be duly considered?
[40:04]
We appreciate the monitoring and assessment program and the continuing
[40:08]
re-adaluation of the context for dollar waters, water supply planning in an uncertain room and the
[40:14]
glee shifting water supply context. However, there are a few topics where information and transparency
[40:21]
is not being provided, at least not in a public form. We believe the board should schedule public hearing
[40:28]
about the following three topics.
[40:31]
First, we would like to see more information provided
[40:33]
about the existing arrays and SAMLIS Resort Expansion.
[40:38]
And how much new storage will this project provide
[40:41]
for value water at the cost?
[40:43]
We pair to the storage projects in the water supply master plan.
[40:47]
Also, how much or how little does the project contribute
[40:50]
towards achieving the water supply,
[40:53]
reliability, or optimization goals of the master plan?
[40:58]
Second, we would like to see more information about the stimulus low-point project.
[41:03]
What is the status of this project?
[41:04]
Is there a final EIR, EIS, and if not, when will that be completed?
[41:09]
Has a patriarchal reservoir been finalized as the preferred alternative and is there a final
[41:14]
feasibility report?
[41:16]
Third, we would like to see more information provided about the expectation of increased
[41:21]
inputting water deliveries from the Delta in wet years.
[41:26]
It's unclear what this means.
[41:28]
This is the only water expecting more than the current maximum deliveries
[41:30]
under our CBP and SWP contracts are just getting closer to the maximum
[41:35]
amount under those contracts.
[41:37]
If the district is expecting to get more,
[41:40]
what approvals are needed such as updated contracts and water rights?
[41:45]
I would also like to highlight a few items from the staff report
[41:49]
that further indicate water supply benefits of Puchico reservoir will not be sufficient to
[41:54]
more of to extremely high cost of this project.
[41:57]
First, the staff report says that current storage facilities are unlikely to be fully utilized
[42:03]
under future climate change scenarios, which indicates that new storage that Puchico is
[42:08]
a questionable value.
[42:10]
Also, the main benefit of the Puchico project is now cited as a proving operational flexibility
[42:16]
that give then that projected 25% decrease in important water supplies, the seeds of certain and questionable.
[42:26]
Our letter also brings up the topic of evaluating environmental and social impacts of the master plan projects and considering those in decision making.
[42:34]
We hope you will consider this idea to help improve the overall outcomes of your water supply program.
[42:40]
There is much more about the master plan and the map that these are the most important thoughts we wanted to share with you today.
[42:46]
and hopes that you will request staff to bring the suggested
[42:49]
topic back to the board for public hearing.
[42:52]
At the same time, a public hearing is not the best
[42:55]
venue for a real public input.
[42:58]
And we did meet with staff.
[42:59]
We very much appreciate staff for meeting with
[43:02]
three NGO and representatives in August,
[43:05]
and making earnest efforts to respond to our questions
[43:08]
that we submitted after the meeting.
[43:10]
However, we still feel like we're at the beginning of this discussion,
[43:13]
and we suggest that value water can be in some kind of forum for stakeholders to discuss and provide more in-depth input.
[43:20]
Something like a yearly water supply public forum
[43:24]
that could include breakout rates for real discussion
[43:28]
and something like the draw summit that will take place tomorrow, which I'm looking forward to participate.
[43:34]
Thank you for giving me extra time and considering these costs.
[43:39]
Welcome. Thank you, Mr. Irving. Anyone else?
[43:47]
Yes, I have... Oshah Merz.
[43:52]
Merz Merz? Merz? Merz? Merz?
[43:53]
Yes. Good afternoon, Mr. Merz.
[43:57]
Mr. Irving. Mr. Esmerra, can you hear me okay?
[44:00]
Yes, we can hear you. We've also, by the way,
[44:03]
have received your course, Pondis and also the Ciroculture course, Pondis.
[44:10]
Yes.
[44:11]
The virtual A, you kind of wonder, you know, what's going on?
[44:13]
Yes.
[44:14]
Thank you.
[45:00]
I know the board has been meeting the decision today, but I think it's important that the board understands that these kind of high rates, high costs, projects that really are uncertain in what they may yield, and that also have very severe environmental and cultural impacts really shouldn't be hard.
[46:45]
Thank you, Ms. Miser. Anyone else?
[46:50]
Yes, Mr. Chair. We have Ms. Molly Colton?
[46:53]
Yes, good afternoon, Ms. Colton.
[46:58]
Good afternoon, chair members of the board. Can you hear me okay?
[47:00]
Yes, we can.
[47:02]
All right, wonderful.
[47:04]
So, yeah, my name is Michael.
[47:06]
I'm speaking today on behalf of Sierra Club, California.
[47:09]
Yes.
[47:09]
We understand that the Delta Convance Project is not included in this evaluation,
[47:14]
because there's insufficient information regarding operations of the project.
[47:18]
However, we'd still like to underscore concerns of valley water's capacity.
[47:23]
Earth Sierra Club comment letter that was submitted prior to this meeting, recent events
[47:28]
have shown that climate change is accelerating, and that impacts that were forecasted for the
[47:33]
latter half of the century might already be happening. According to a 2021 Delta Stewardship Council
[47:39]
final vulnerability assessment, climate change will make Delta water experts less reliable in the future
[47:45]
regardless of what are the dry years. The best available science, as well as valley waters
[47:50]
on risk assessment shows that the Delta-convance project is a costly and high-risk project,
[47:57]
that will not deliver what it promises, and therefore, for it should be renewed from the
[48:01]
water supply master plan project portfolio and favor of projects and technologies that
[48:06]
reuse, recycle, and insert local and original water supplies. Local and regional water supplies
[48:12]
are the only supplies that are truly resilient to the uncertainties of climate change in
[48:18]
These projects include expanding some water capture, waste product irrigation and recycling, and
[48:24]
synthesizing water efficiency and reducing the need of importing water from the bed.
[48:30]
I bet you won't be. We need to have a master plan that we're exusing updated methods and
[48:35]
models. It's well as the best available data and science that takes into account the effects
[48:40]
of climate change and stop investing in expensive.
[48:47]
Thank you, Ms. Colton.
[48:51]
And I have no other hands raised at this time.
[48:53]
Okay.
[48:54]
Any board members?
[48:55]
Yes.
[48:56]
Those are the centers?
[49:01]
Yes.
[49:01]
Thanks, Mr. Chair.
[49:04]
To our staff to achieve bigger and a staff.
[49:07]
I read this letter that was given by Salari Mazar,
[49:12]
and Mr. Oshad just got to speaking.
[49:15]
And I was just curious, do we have any past history information?
[49:22]
Senate, the rep is then this owners of 6,320 acres out in that area, but I'd like to try
[49:28]
to find out what was said back in the 30s when the dam was first built was the farm and
[49:35]
community at that time. Do I have any historic documentation that says they were supporting
[49:40]
in or they weren't supporting in or what was the situation? I think that historic data might
[49:45]
be helpful to enter some of the questions and give us a bigger picture. So that's just a
[49:51]
request if we can find any of that, what was said or documented during the time this was built.
[50:03]
Questioner Ken.
[50:05]
Third and relay ingstyle.
[50:12]
In the reform storage reserves, including a report of large support, do we need to take AROX?
[50:27]
How can we increment a committee?
[50:29]
I
[50:33]
don't think so, I don't think so because I think a referral of a couple of, I think a referral of the issues that we discussed today is appropriate enough.
[50:47]
I also think a referral to the CIP committee just with respect to the projects that we're talking about, also is appropriate today.
[50:57]
Yeah, so I think they're both appropriate.
[51:02]
So when we get to the end of the discussion,
[51:08]
we can talk about the directions.
[51:11]
And then we'll make those assignments.
[51:15]
But I want to see if there's any other discussion or...
[51:20]
Yeah, any other discussion members?
[51:33]
I want to say that I'm very proud of staff's analysis in the level of expertise to how we're in. It took me a long time actually.
[51:45]
to keep going back and forth, thank you, I'm trying to figure out.
[51:50]
But what I want to say is that I think this is a really big effort,
[51:57]
an important effort, that I think, Ms. Kacha Arvaran of Sierra Club's suggestion,
[52:05]
the process step, adding some, as she suggests,
[52:09]
that adding a step into our overall planning process, I think it's a good suggestion,
[52:13]
And I'd like to request a board to work through that to help to incorporate those things.
[52:20]
Thank you, Vice Chair.
[52:25]
I also want to thank staff for all the work they've done.
[52:31]
I didn't read the letter for the Bichigo Land and Cal Company, and thank you for submitting it.
[52:38]
You know, I do want to mention maybe the corporation is not informed that this project would add recreational assets,
[52:50]
because this letter talks about how the only people who've enjoyed the recreational assets have been the family.
[52:59]
And then maybe at the same time they talk about something I think we all care about relationship with the native Americans who have been in the area.
[53:11]
I'd love as we're negotiating with them.
[53:13]
How much access they've given into the native peoples before this project?
[53:19]
Maybe a list of access, easements, and a lot of it, because that's one of the claims
[53:26]
in the Arizona.
[53:27]
Love the number.
[53:28]
You know, as we weigh one landowner, the benefits, the one landowner, against many, and
[53:35]
we're always nervous at least I am of a big believer in paying people a fair price.
[53:41]
Oh, but we don't want to have drugs anymore.
[53:45]
We don't want to be in a situation where right now we're facing a scared of 2022, so I
[53:51]
need to get those questions answered when we negotiate with the scrutiny of the corporation.
[53:56]
Thank you, Vice Chair.
[53:59]
The Rooka Santos?
[54:02]
Yes.
[54:02]
Thank you, Chair.
[54:05]
To support and also assist with the Vice Chair Creman for our storage committee.
[54:12]
The question is that he just said about information that this represent which call the Salari
[54:21]
Missouri represent in this family. He's got a good point that they may not call all the information
[54:27]
that we have done at the water stores can be level with our staff. Our staff does a great job and I think
[54:33]
that's what I was looking at the historic information and the President information. But one thing further
[54:38]
I had a step up for a second when Vice Chair was talking about semi-traffic's and
[54:44]
I think we need to take the end count and maybe we guys have discussed that I came with the tail end back
[54:50]
When Gary said well, you know, there may not be water available
[54:54]
It's in my trot face that I needed okay, and I got that point, but the cost of pumping it
[55:00]
Or not have it, even though the acre foot seems to be reasonable at this time, if you take on add the pumping costs, it would not be reasonable.
[55:11]
So, these are the kind of information and education that not just saloon for this attorney firm that represent in the family is what we've got to put out an education for everybody to understand.
[55:21]
and my opinion, neither the Sierra Club said,
[55:24]
well, if this needed, well, and my opinion,
[55:26]
when I do all the research from climate change,
[55:29]
to droughts, to the Stanford scientific papers,
[55:33]
to NASA, that says, we're gonna be facing this
[55:36]
more and more and more in error condition.
[55:38]
It's never gonna change.
[55:40]
There's a vital need, we've been lucky today.
[55:44]
You know right now, it's really sad
[55:47]
because we get one rain and we've got people already say,
[55:49]
no, the drought's over.
[55:50]
You got to be kidding folks. You got to be kidding. This drought is real
[55:56]
Ground water. We're very blessed so far. We haven't hit it real hard
[56:00]
From our chair to everybody here. We're all working on recycling
[56:04]
You got to have water first before you can recycle, so we got to store it up and then we you know this too
[56:10]
And 2, 7, 27, 17. If the Pacheco was then I'll take in care of we would be having water storage right now as we speak
[56:18]
But we don't. We have 11% in Anderson. So time is everything. So that's just my opinion based on what I have learned.
[56:27]
Thank you.
[56:30]
Anybody else?
[56:31]
Director Luzot?
[56:35]
Director Keegan?
[56:37]
Yes.
[56:38]
Director Luzot?
[56:40]
Director Santas.
[56:41]
This is a good point.
[56:42]
There are either for acre feet cost numbers, gross numbers.
[56:47]
Today include everything.
[56:49]
Or is it just the cost of the war?
[56:52]
It includes everything for storage except semi-traffic is unique as, I think, director Kremlin and San Jose pointed out that if there is no exchange capacity available then there is that compacting and those costs are not included in that on the semi-traffic line.
[57:16]
Can you say that again?
[57:19]
So, semi-truck, compared to those other projects on there, semi-truck, it is unique in that
[57:25]
at South of Delta.
[57:26]
So, we rely on exchange capacity to be able to get our water out of the bank.
[57:31]
If that exchange capacity is not there, we need to do the reverse flow.
[57:35]
And that is expensive pumping and the costs of that type of project is not included in the
[57:41]
table.
[57:43]
Have we ever done the reverse loop?
[57:46]
I will defer any reverse load discussion to, no, we haven't.
[57:52]
We haven't, mostly go to the cost.
[57:58]
We have not.
[58:00]
No, the reverse fall on the state side.
[58:03]
I don't think it's ever been done.
[58:05]
And then there was a small amount of, I believe, on the federal side,
[58:09]
it was done quite a number of years ago,
[58:11]
but not necessarily for us.
[58:13]
Is that correct, Cindy?
[58:17]
That is correct.
[58:18]
So when we needed it, and the reverse loading happened, we were able to get water and elsewhere.
[58:29]
Shall we speak on that?
[58:30]
Yes, please.
[58:31]
Yeah.
[58:32]
Yeah.
[58:33]
We had never actually needed it.
[58:36]
So we almost needed it.
[58:38]
We just dropped.
[58:39]
We, in the last draft, we were going to get the water out of semi-traffic.
[58:46]
But then DWR came through told us they could do it for us.
[58:49]
We put that project on hold and we got we actually didn't get the water out of some of my traffic
[58:53]
The normal way by exchange
[58:56]
That's what I thought that's what I thought so the real life that was there was there because we were able to get it
[59:03]
It was there as questionable, but it was but we've got it
[59:07]
We did all right, thank you
[59:09]
Thank you
[59:11]
Third Kigan.
[59:16]
I'm good. Thank you. Okay. Okay, great. Well
[59:19]
Any other discussion, so I think we have pretty, I think pretty much the board agrees that we should make with specific referrals to our two leading committees so that we can
[59:37]
pursue some of the discussion, continue the discussion, pursue some of the questions, get some more data.
[59:44]
Also, we want to be able to provide a greater opportunity for not just, you know, the Sierra Club but,
[59:54]
or Ms. Missouri, but of course all of you, but also provide access for others.
[1:00:01]
Members of the other members of the public to engage with us on these serious issues will make a special effort to get the word out when these committees put it on their agendas so that folks that are really interested specifically about these issues are informed and can participate.
[1:00:24]
Generally, our discussions at committee level are a lot more open, a lot more informal,
[1:00:33]
there's greater dialogue, and there's greater opportunity to really and truly give
[1:00:39]
it take.
[1:00:41]
So I encourage those folks who are listening members of the community to get a look out and
[1:00:51]
Please come to those committee meetings because, as I mentioned, the rest of the board members generally do attend, although we don't participate, if we're not members of the committee, and also members of the public do attend.
[1:01:07]
But I want to encourage you to attend because, as I mentioned, it gives us the community greater accessibility.
[1:01:17]
we have extensive dialogue in that goes on. So it's a little easier for members of the community
[1:01:24]
to feel comfortable engaging with us on some of these very serious issues. So we'll do our best
[1:01:32]
to do a little extra to get the word out when the committees have it on their agenda.
[1:01:39]
So I think we all do agree that we'll make an assignment to send this to the Storage Committee,
[1:01:50]
to continue discussions with staff, and secondly, to assign those portions of construction-related activity and projects directly to the CRP committee for the same reason.
[1:02:08]
And I also want to thank staff for the extensive engagement.
[1:02:13]
Now, this is the kind of thing that makes value water,
[1:02:18]
makes us all proud of our organization,
[1:02:21]
where we had all units and everyone involved in the discussion
[1:02:26]
in this project.
[1:02:29]
That's the kind of thing that provides to our community,
[1:02:35]
assurances that we really serious about our commitment to our obligations to the community.
[1:02:42]
I think that's very important.
[1:02:44]
So I want to especially thanks staff for engaging as you did as partners, as internal partners.
[1:02:53]
The community is getting as money's worth and I like it when the community sees is able
[1:03:00]
to see that it's getting as money's worth.
[1:03:02]
We have tremendous staff, the community puts a lot of investment in that staff and it's
[1:03:13]
great every time that we get an opportunity to show the community that it's getting
[1:03:17]
this money's work.
[1:03:19]
So thank you for that work staff much appreciated for all of us.
[1:03:25]
unless there's nothing further than we will adjourn to 4 p.m. at our closed session in 6 p.m.
[1:03:36]
for our regular meeting on our 226 to we call the Northern Compliance for the Brown Act as currently in effect in our County District Resolution 2185.
[1:03:49]
adopted on September 28th in compliance with the provisions of our very own
[1:03:58]
Assemblyman Revers under AB361. So thank you. We'll adjourn until then.
[1:04:04]
We'll stay on adjourn until then.