Water Supply and Demand Management Committee Regular Meeting - Jan 27th, 2025

Santa Clara Valley Water District, CA · More Santa Clara Valley Water District, CA meetings · More California meetings

Transcript

Download: Text · SRT
AI TRANSCRIPT

This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.

[1:51] Good morning, everyone. And thank you for coming and attending. And we'll call them in to order for the Santa Clara Valley of Water District, applying the man management committee.
[2:03] And Stephanie, please take roll call, please. Yes. Director Santos. Yep.
[2:09] Dr. Shewak, here, and Director Ballard, here. Thank you, you have a quorum.
[2:13] Thank you all. We just talked about, we've got through the football playoffs, and so it's going to be a very interesting anyway.
[2:23] With that time open to public comment on any item not on the agenda.
[2:27] So I got to raise your hand. Go through Stephanie would be glad to have your comments.
[2:32] We do have the comments by zero club culture urban here the hand-out
[2:40] Any public comment again? There's culture. Go right ahead.
[2:46] Welcome, culture.
[2:50] Good morning, valley water directors and staff. Can you hear me?
[2:56] Yes
[2:58] I
[2:58] Wanted to elevate a couple of topics that others have recently brought forward at public meetings
[3:05] And encourage this committee to request these items be added to your work plan.
[3:11] One item is the concern about accelerating proliferation of data centers and the water resources they require.
[3:20] There were two speakers on this topic at the last board meeting.
[3:24] This could be very problematic for water supply and water supply planning.
[3:28] when question is whether the water demand projection is taking this into account.
[3:36] And then the other item is grass ground water de-watering for below ground construction.
[3:45] I can't remember which meeting that was,
[3:47] but staff said they made some EIR comments about the impacts of de-watering,
[3:54] related to art and high speed rail in, you know, in the dirt on station area. And with
[4:04] all this below ground construction happening in areas with high water table, it seems
[4:09] like a steady session would be useful to start understanding the magnitude of this activity
[4:16] and the impacts and to discuss ideas for how to take advantage of this possible water supply.
[4:24] And, you know, how to address any issues that might happen.
[4:29] So, I hope that, you know, Valley Water will be proactive,
[4:34] and look at these two issues before, you know, it's too late.
[4:39] And then also, I just wanted to apologize that I have a commitment
[4:44] at 11 a.m. so I may not be able to make a public comment
[4:49] about the Pacheco update, that I do hope that you and staff will consider my comments,
[4:56] which mainly point to small inconsistencies.
[5:00] This is in the staff report that should be corrected. Thank you. Thank you, coach. We have your material that you sent us. We have it here. And we'll make note of what you said. So thank you. Anyone else?
[5:15] Next we have approval of the minutes.
[5:18] Can you change us anything nice make motion to approve meeting minutes? Okay, there's a second by the director of shadow baller all of favor. I all oppose that carries. Thank you
[5:35] Next we have the election of the chair and vice chair and we'll do them together and let me just start up by saying that I've been here a couple years as chair, but I'm very honored and I'd like to see as change to get our new people involved
[5:48] So with that, I'll make a motion to support
[5:51] nice you if we're chair and if I share
[5:53] with the child of Bellon.
[5:55] Do I have a second?
[5:58] Do you want it?
[6:00] Sure.
[6:02] Well, thank you.
[6:03] All of favor?
[6:04] That passes.
[6:06] Tonight, it's in your ball game and welcome.
[6:10] Thank you.
[6:11] Thank you for your thoughts and yeah,
[6:13] I have to do my
[6:19] job on to a managed this community.
[6:22] Okay. Well, move on to item 4.2.
[6:28] It's a very long title.
[6:31] Receive an update and discuss the BFCs,
[6:34] Cudam Race and Residual Expansion Project.
[6:37] Recommend to the Board to execute the first amended
[6:42] and re-stated activity agreement
[6:45] and approve the sin Luis Dautam and Dota
[6:48] water authorities execution of the management and cost share agreement with the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation.
[6:57] Also, recommend to the board to increase the value water storage capacity up to 60,600 acre feet,
[7:06] and recommend to the board to authorize up to 2,5,57,636 dollars to convert value up to.
[7:17] to cover value of the sheer of project planning costs through February 2026.
[7:25] It's Vincent.
[7:26] Jeff Schwartz, thank you. I'd like to say that this has been a long and
[7:33] long and dry not negotiations with the Bureau of Reclamation working through the San Luis del
[7:38] tomato water authority to reach a major milestone for this project. I'd like to turn the floor
[7:44] to send you off for a short presentation overview of some of the major elements of the agreement
[7:51] caution agreement as well as activity agreement.
[7:54] All right. Good morning committee members, Cindy Gaugh, in Puerto water manager.
[8:01] Glad to be here today to present on this item. At the last time this committee met back
[8:06] in November, I gave an update on the project and we just finished negotiations of key components
[8:11] of the management and cost share agreement. Since then, a lot has happened, which have resulted
[8:20] in these four, I can't advance the slide here, which here we go, which have resulted
[8:30] in these four recommendations. So to provide a little more context, the management and cost
[8:36] agreement is between the San Luis Delta Mendoza Water Authority and the U.S. Bureau of
[8:41] Reclamation.
[8:42] Valley Water does not actually sign that agreement.
[8:46] What we would execute is the activity agreement between the San Luis Delta Mendoza Water
[8:50] Authority and the participants.
[8:53] So the Cossure Management Agreement establishes the benefits and overall obligations of this
[8:59] project and the activity agreement allocates those benefits and obligations to the participants
[9:06] through the San Luis and Delta Modoto Water Authority.
[9:10] Over the past couple of months, we successfully completed negotiation of the activity agreement,
[9:16] and on January 9th, the Authority Board approved execution of both agreements.
[9:21] So our first two recommendations are that the Board Execute the activity agreement,
[10:00] One of the participating agencies. And the last recommendation is to provide additional funding to cover the planning costs over the next year.
[10:09] These next slides are background slides and additional detail to help support the recommendations. I'll try to move through them fairly quickly. The primary reason why we're interested in this project is because our water supply master plan team has projected a shortage in our ability to meet our level of service in 2050.
[10:26] This slide summarizes those projections for four potential future scenarios.
[10:32] The team identified three possible portfolios of projects that could fill the shortage in the
[10:36] system.
[10:37] The project is in two of the three.
[10:39] The point being that it's an important project that could help meet our level of service in the
[10:43] pace of climate change.
[10:45] And they have to add a qualifier that these portfolios are subject to change given that
[10:49] these projects are all in their planning stages.
[10:51] And some projects that may not be in these portfolios now could potentially be added in the future.
[10:59] The project is to enlarge San Luis Reservoir by 130,000 acre feet. San Luis Reservoir is an integral part of the state water project and the central valley project.
[11:11] And all the infrastructure needed to move the water to the reservoir and add the reservoir into our county is already in place and operational, which makes this project, you know.
[11:21] it gives it a huge advantage over others we're looking at.
[11:29] The project will move forward
[11:30] in tandem with the safety of dams project, which is focused on seismically retrofitting that
[11:35] existing dam by raising it 10 feet and building stabilizing stabilizing berms. The system project
[11:44] would raise the dam an additional 10 feet. Funding and project benefits will be split between
[11:51] the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, which will take 30% of the storage to do what they want with
[11:56] it and 70% of the storage will be used by the participants to put and take our water within
[12:03] certain constraints.
[12:06] So at the last meaning of this committee, I presented key provisions of the Management Agreement
[12:11] and I'll quickly review those here, the agreement allows for the storage of our CBP and
[12:19] to VP contract allocation and other supplies like transfer supplies, we can currently store
[12:24] those supplies in the existing San Luis reservoir, but there may not be space or that water
[12:30] could spill if the reservoir fills. Under the project, we have allocated space for us supplies
[12:36] and there is no spilling, which actually is a huge benefit. The project, the agreement also
[12:43] provides for the allocation of surplus water
[12:46] that may be made available by the project.
[12:51] This water would be available currently
[12:52] to us under our existing CBP and SWP contracts,
[12:56] but we typically don't have any space to store it.
[13:00] So this new storage will capture that water
[13:03] and make it available to the participants.
[13:06] Non-CVP water is reliably stored.
[13:10] can be reliably stored in this expanded space. CBP water has less reliability and I'll get into that
[13:20] in the next slide. There will be an exemption from the Public Health and Safety
[13:24] Calculation for non-CVP water supplies and what that means is that in critical years when there is
[13:31] a public health and safety need will have more opportunity for having additional supplies to meet
[13:37] those needs. And finally, there's an option to lease or market our storage capacity to offset costs.
[13:46] So, there are some risks. Reclamation has taken the position that they can access our stored
[13:53] CVP water in our share. Basically, they can take that water and give it to senior water-right
[13:59] holders, refuges, or other M&I contractors that have a public health and safety need when there is
[14:05] sufficient other CVP supplies to provide to meet those needs.
[14:11] Now we've analyzed this and believe that risk can be mitigated by prioritizing the storage
[14:17] of our state water project supplies and other non- CVP supplies.
[14:22] There's another risk associated with shared group governance with other project participants
[14:28] and non-participants that are members of the San Luis Delta Mendoza Water Authority board.
[14:32] We've negotiated some terms in the activity agreement to help mitigate this risk and we'll continue to refine the governance structure.
[14:44] And finally, some of the risks are, you know, there are some risk mitigation due to off ramping that is incorporated into this management agreement.
[14:54] So the authority, the sandwich that's made out of water authority, can back out of the...
[15:00] In two years from now, so we have two years to really solidify our decision.
[15:08] So moving on to the activity agreement.
[15:12] We've negotiated terms that make it very clear that the
[15:16] San Luis Delta Mendoza Water Authority is participating on behalf of the participants and the benefits
[15:21] of the project will flow through the authority to the participants in proportion to the
[15:28] project participation level that that includes storage and the surplus water supply.
[15:35] The San Luis Delta Mendoza San Luis Delta Mendoza water authority board approval will be needed for
[15:43] the project budgets amendments to the activity agreement and agreement approval of other
[15:48] agreements as well as litigation decisions. But we've negotiated some provisions in the
[15:54] activity agreement that provide for an assignment of the rights, obligations and interests to a new
[16:09] GPA comprise of the participants.
[16:12] So we negotiate terms that provide for the assignment of these rights, obligations and
[16:16] interests of the San Luis Delta Mendoza Water Authority to a new GPA comprise only of the
[16:23] And that would take place with the approval of participants that would comprise 90% of the participation level.
[16:33] Most decisions related to the project will require approval of participants comprising 85% of the participation level.
[16:41] And what that means is that no decisions can be made without value water support.
[16:47] Given that we are the largest project participant at 66% of the project.
[16:52] All right.
[16:59] So, with that, I guess I'll pause and see if there are any questions.
[17:06] Questions from committee members? No. Okay.
[17:12] I have a quick question.
[17:15] So the slides are 92 page United, or page night of the PowerPoint slides, the top
[17:27] Reclamation may access storage, CBPW, and they're still in jails.
[17:31] So we said by prioritizing storage of SWP supplies, we can probably mitigate this potential
[17:38] risk.
[17:39] So exactly what do we mean to mean that we don't if we have to be one available. We won't
[17:47] store it in the
[17:49] civil and stressful. If CVP water becomes available in the wetter years and we don't have any other place to store it
[17:56] We will store it in this this expanded space
[18:00] What we would want to do is take it out of that space prior to a drought
[18:05] So we would want to move it to potentially semi-traffic or maybe a local reservoir before
[18:11] before a drought occurs or maybe during the first year of a drought before the bureau would have the opportunity of the first year of drought if you wouldn't know the job at coming next year
[18:22] That's that's true, but we would prioritize putting non-CVP water in so if there are other places to store the CVP water
[18:31] we would probably try to prioritize those opportunities and the other question is, is there a
[18:39] time limit for 20 water in this space to, we can say that we have good weather and then
[18:49] fully utilize these space that we contracted under and we have favorable weather for many
[18:57] maybe here's the one that can just be there.
[19:00] There's no time limit.
[19:01] There's no time limit.
[19:04] There is a, I was just about to say that.
[19:06] There is a, a small loss associated with storage
[19:10] in the surface reservoir.
[19:12] And there's still discussion on going
[19:13] as to what that loss might be.
[19:16] But no more than 10% in here.
[19:19] I guess it's not that small.
[19:21] But the idea is, you know, if you have some losses,
[19:24] They're typically, they're often is opportunities to refill, right?
[19:30] So you just top it off with any additional water we may not need immediately to keep that full.
[19:37] Or we can move the storage to another location.
[19:41] But yet, that storage, there's no limitation to how long we can put water.
[19:46] Okay, yeah.
[19:48] Okay, thank you.
[19:49] I do want to just clarify in terms of reclamation, accessing stored water during droughts, but that means is if we have CBP water.
[20:00] Take it without paying us. So that's kind of for for reclamation, what they like in terms of, you know, it was big negotiation, this whole thing, but that I just want to make that clear, they have the ability to take water if it's CBP water and you haven't taken delivery yet. So for us, we're just going to manage around that.
[20:26] Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, okay. Thank you. That's yeah.
[20:31] All right. Okay. We'll continue. Okay.
[20:36] So moving on.
[20:41] One of our recommendations is to increase our participation level by a small amount.
[20:45] And this is due to the withdrawal of Chaco water district, which was the smallest participant in among the seven agencies.
[20:54] This table shows the participating agencies.
[20:59] The Chaco Water District was at less than a percent participation level.
[21:05] The proposal is to fill the gap by distributing their share to the remaining participants
[21:10] in proportion to their participation levels.
[21:14] And that would increase our storage capacity from 60,000 to 60,398.
[21:20] All the participants would be going to their boards to seek approval for this increase.
[21:26] And there is a chance that some of them may not want to increase in which case there would be a gap that our agency could take on just to fill the gap and keep the project going.
[21:41] The total cost of the project is 1 billion, 45 million, which is broken down as shown in this table.
[21:47] The share of those costs that are allocated to the participants is $731 million.
[21:55] Valley water share would range between $482 million and $487 million depending upon how
[22:04] the particular water district's vacancy is distributed, how much of that we want to take on.
[22:10] However, that range is so small that really all of these options have the same impact on our rates.
[22:17] So, the estimated rate impact in North County Zone 7, Zone W2, M&I, is a ramp up to an additional
[22:27] $227 per acre foot or $7.81 per month per household by fiscal year 34.
[22:41] So, Zuring in on what we get for that cost, our preliminary modeling is showing that the project
[22:47] provides a significant water supply benefit to us.
[22:52] If we assume that some isotropic continues with its current capabilities and magnitude
[22:59] at 60,000 acre feet of storage, the project would reduce our shortages by 66% over a six-year drought.
[23:07] It can also increase the cost-effectiveness of projects like purified water projects and the Delta
[23:13] and veins project that produce water in white years,
[23:16] because now we'll have some extra space
[23:18] to capture surplus waters instead of losing it.
[23:23] There's also some synergy with groundwater banking
[23:25] in that groundwater banks typically have a lot of limitations
[23:29] on the rate of water and the timing of water
[23:32] that can be sent down to for storage,
[23:35] as well as the way the water can come back to us.
[23:39] The system project can capture large gulps of water
[23:43] when the water's available, and then we can meter the delivery down to the groundwater banks
[23:48] at a rate that they can absorb, and the system project can also serve as another tool to
[23:54] help us get the water back through exchange.
[24:01] The participants have contributed about four and a half million dollars to this project to date.
[24:06] Valley Water Share has been 1.69 million to date.
[24:11] This funding is coming to an end, and reclamation is requesting that participants provide
[24:16] another 3.25 million to cover costs for the planning, design, and permitting activities
[24:23] through February of 2026. Our share of that funding would range from 2 million, 45,000 to
[24:30] 2,000, and 57,000 depending on how much of the Pacheco water district's vacated space we take on.
[24:39] We expect a larger funding request in early 2026 of 13.2 million dollars
[24:46] To get us to the final participation decision in early 2027, and that would take on the form of a financing commitment, commitment to finance the construction of the project.
[25:00] This schedule shows those decision points, the two interim funding, decision points, and the final decision in early 2027. Over the next two years, we'll be negotiating a number of add-on agreements, including a spend plan, coordination agreement, and the operations and maintenance agreement, then negotiations are expected to begin on these agreements very soon.
[25:26] And over the next year and a half or so, we're going to develop the financing structure and refine the governance approach.
[25:34] And as you can see from this schedule, construction is expected to begin soon after the final financing decision in early 2027.
[25:43] And the project is anticipated to be completed.
[25:47] The construction is anticipated to be completed by 2032.
[25:51] And that ends my presentation. If there are any questions, I'd be happy to answer them.
[25:58] Okay. Questions from community members?
[26:04] Go ahead.
[26:10] When I was reading through the briefing materials, and thank you, this was great.
[26:17] And maybe you said this and I was distracted, but there was mentioned made of the 152 improvements and co-benefits
[26:25] stuff like that. I was just wondering if you or someone could talk a little bit more about that
[26:30] aspect of the project and just the opportunities there and and what we've been doing or maybe
[26:38] it's just too early to understand you know what are what are the what are those co-benefits. How are
[26:43] we sourcing those you know it's community involved those kinds of questions. I can answer a little bit
[26:50] I'd also like to know if Chuck Gardner can hear us
[26:53] and is on the line.
[26:56] Okay, I can start off and just say that the state rep 152,
[27:02] the raising of that section of the highway
[27:05] is basically half of the project cost.
[27:08] But there is larger public benefits
[27:10] and that section needs to be upgraded
[27:14] to meet seismic standards.
[27:16] So staff and the authority have been seeking funding opportunities to offset our costs.
[27:25] I think with respect to the more details we're going to outreach and planning,
[27:30] I would like to turn that over to Chuck Gardner, who is our consultant
[27:34] who's working on the project management for this project.
[27:38] Chuck, are you available to speak?
[27:41] I am. Can you hear me?
[27:43] Yes, we can hear you. Thank you. Thank you for joining us. You're welcome. Glad to be here.
[27:50] Yes, we're just getting started engaging with Cal Frans on the rays of Highway 152.
[27:57] So we understand that that's a very busy highway that connects the Central Valley to the coast there.
[28:05] And so we know there's a lot of public interest in how that traffic
[28:11] is going to be managed when the highway is actually being raised.
[28:17] So currently, the biggest focus that we have
[28:21] is working on a traffic study that we're presenting
[28:24] to a call-trans to determine what's the best way to manage traffic
[28:28] while that project is into construction.
[28:31] But that's in the very early stages of engagement
[28:35] with Californians. S&D was just saying, one of the primary benefits of the rays of the project
[28:41] will be to improve the, improve the project to current seismic standards. And concurrent with
[28:50] that, we recognize that this represents almost half of the project cost and some in addition to
[28:56] this rays grant that we apply for later this month. In fact, it's due on the 30th, we'll have
[29:04] raise grant submitted, but there are other funding opportunities that are out there that we're looking at.
[29:10] In addition to beginning to look at value engineering efforts to try to reduce the cost,
[30:00] Most of it is necessary to raise the highway. And seeing if there's more efficient ways to deliver those materials such as using the highway 152 hall route and other routes inside the reservoir that might be available to us.
[30:16] So again, a lot of details still to be developed with respect to that project, but it is getting a significant amount of our attention at the moment.
[30:37] I'll ask a follow-up question to this highway 152 relocation or racing hudder. My early understanding
[30:48] is that the Buer's project for seismic stability of the dam itself does not require any work.
[31:01] two highway 152. That is the work is required because of the another 10 feet of
[31:09] lazy. So, okay.
[31:14] So, be aware that there's not any responsibility for the stretch of the
[31:20] highway, even though that I think both of them Chuck mentioned, some mentioned about
[31:26] a seismic stability of the existing condition.
[31:32] So, can the sculpture have any responsibility for that?
[31:37] I think I'll turn that over to Chuck.
[31:42] Caltrance was just recently made aware that there was a fault line that ran through
[31:50] how we'd 152 almost right through the center of it as a matter of fact.
[31:53] So, they have been made aware of it, and we are looking to see if there would be funds available through
[32:00] Caltrans or some other source to address that seismic issue.
[32:06] That is, overall, the expansion portion of the project is the responsibility of reclamation.
[32:16] however, the authority is taking lead on this highway 152 raised portion of the project.
[32:25] Yeah, that's a sense because of the authorities need so that it's required for the highway 152.
[32:38] Yeah, but just eventually our culture and its benefit, if a third is doing the whole thing
[32:45] then culture is benefiting of getting a structural way, a structural way, a better highway.
[32:56] But yeah, I know all of you are still a lot of work to be talked and all that.
[33:01] I just don't understand that, yeah.
[33:05] Another question is on the, and thank you, Mr. Gardner. Thank you very much. It's on the page 15 of the PowerPoint slides.
[33:15] It's just at 60,000 acre fee storage in Assumines,
[33:20] that some economic continuous project reduces shortage
[33:23] by 66,000 over a six year chart.
[33:28] Can you explain a little bit more about reduce shortage
[33:31] by 66% of what is that really mean?
[33:36] Yeah, sure.
[33:37] And I think I'll turn that over to Catherine to respond to that.
[33:44] Sure, so it was part of the project modeling, we are modeled, you know, the current system without the project just kind of as is.
[33:57] And we have a certain amount of shortage during the drought where we're not meeting our, you know, level of demand.
[34:06] And we do another run with the project in place and we see that the amount of shortage is reduced by 66% so I don't have the exact numbers in that it's just looking at it with and without the project what is our shortage during that.
[34:24] that early 90s drought from, I think, what is it, 1988 through, like, the 19th, in 1987 through
[34:33] 1991 or 92. So this goes back to your full quadrant, planning scenario to that shortage. So the
[34:43] shortage becomes smaller, 66% smaller, 66% in planning for a 60 year drought. Yes. And for that specific
[34:52] six years of job. Okay. Okay, good. Thank you. Thank you very much.
[34:59] I don't have any-
[35:00] The support of recommendations, but we do have a comment. All of you here responsible for us getting sources of water. I really appreciate it. I want to sing a lot, you know, Vincent and of course, Cindy, of course chief Baker, and before her mom, Joan, but you guys are really helping build that relationship up there and the Delta, Madonna, and I really believe this is a great asset for Senator County to always have a source of water. So I really appreciate the work and the relationships
[35:29] that we're built starting from June all the way up today. It's a lot better and we get a
[35:34] long, a lot better but I really appreciate the legal advice in the contracts. That's why
[35:39] it's so important to have you guys at the table because that's the stuff that we really don't pick up
[35:44] all the time and one mistake can lead us to the political situation so I really appreciate the work
[35:51] Thank you. Thank you.
[35:54] Okay. Okay.
[35:58] And I'm going to ask are there any of the comments on this item?
[36:05] Thank you, Chair. I have no physical cards. It looks like there is one online Arthur Keller.
[36:10] Okay. Mr. Keller, go ahead.
[36:13] Good morning, how are you?
[36:15] Anyway, what is like the hood of an earthquake affecting these projects?
[36:25] So the question is, how is the earth going affecting this project? Is that right? Yes.
[36:33] The project is going to improve the seismic stability of the debt. Well, it's going to be.
[36:42] The project will be constructed in tandem with the safety of dams project.
[36:46] will improve the seismic resilience, resiliency of San Luis Reservoir, and then the raising of 152
[36:53] will also improve the safety of that highway with respect to seismic risks as well.
[37:02] And what is the risk of the way we're proposing the semi-traffic continue? What is the risk of
[37:07] in a six-year drought being able to continue to draw water for the semi-traffic reserve?
[37:14] That is a very good question, and we believe that semi-traffic will continue to be viable.
[37:25] Now the exact level of service and the parameters associated with inconsistencies associated
[37:34] with putting the water in and taking the water out in the face of the sustainable groundwater
[37:39] Management Act Sigma is that's still being developed, right?
[37:44] So there are conversations ongoing about the GSPs,
[37:49] the groundwater sustainability plans,
[37:51] and actions that the GSAs, the groundwater sustainability
[37:58] agencies, including semi-traffic, will take in the event
[38:03] of a drought.
[38:04] So those are being developed, and there's
[38:06] I'm going with the state board.
[38:10] Thank you.
[38:10] One other question is, how do we...
[38:13] There's a potential of the operation.
[38:15] That's what the most mainly water goes in the...
[38:18] It evaporates away.
[38:19] How do you...
[38:20] What can we do to mitigate water evaporation from the lake?
[38:28] Well, we are...
[38:30] There's a conversation that will be had among the participants at the Bureau
[38:36] and the Department of Water Resources to identify what
[38:38] appropriate evaporation rate is. The currently are some kind of placeholder numbers in there,
[38:46] one percent a month, but we think that's high. So we're going to look at what an actual
[38:51] evaporation rate is, and then one of the aspects that we would want to engage in is looking at the
[39:00] opportunity to top off the reservoir, when there is surplus flows, or move the surface storage into
[39:06] groundwater banks to minimize the losses. But there, you know, no option is perfect. And you
[39:15] have to try and coordinate all of your options. They all have pluses and minuses. And you
[39:20] try and coordinate all of our options in the way that optimizes our water supply reliability.
[39:26] Yeah. The lake is used for recreational purposes. How do we, what are risk of water pollution
[39:32] for the recognition of purposes.
[39:36] I'm afraid I don't think we can capture that.
[39:41] The lake is used for recreational purposes.
[39:45] Now, what a risk of water pollution for the recreational purposes.
[39:50] You mean the damned raising?
[39:52] No, no, no.
[39:53] The lake will have the damage.
[39:55] The recreational existing recreation activities.
[39:58] the record.
[40:03] So, is the question, is the recreation activities going to cause pollution in the lake?
[40:10] Yes, and what are the risk of recation activities costing pollution in the future?
[40:15] Yeah. I was just going to say, I don't know that we know what the actual pollution levels are. I don't think that there's very much anything to really be worried about.
[40:27] And whatever they are now is like what would be in the future,
[40:31] the project is not going to change the recreational use
[40:33] that's like it.
[40:34] Right, so we're not looking to, but just for reference,
[40:37] there are watershed sanitaries who are surveys
[40:40] and other things that they do as this water does end up
[40:43] to the drinking water treatment plants and other things like that.
[40:45] So they understand the amount of pollution
[40:48] that may occur from incidental recreational use
[40:52] and understand the treatment technologies
[40:55] and everything else that we have on our facilities, make sure that the water is always exceeding
[41:01] drinking water standards. That being said, there's also, you know, for recreational purposes,
[41:06] or as part of these sanitary servers, they have surveys, they have various things that they look
[41:11] at to try to make sure that they're inspecting boats at various times, understanding where things
[41:14] are looking at. Some of the other things that kind of go along or pair along with these is not
[41:19] so much pollution, but also clog up muscles or other types of muscles or other programs
[41:24] that we're looking at to make sure that recreation from pollution and from possible transfer
[41:32] of non-need of bullets or other things like that are all part of something that the state water
[41:37] project and the center of other project looks at and is developing mitigation strategies
[41:41] for. Yeah. Yeah. And it's a we have all of our reservoirs have some more issues that you just have to
[41:50] lift. They they call existence. You have to basically manage to the best up to the best ability.
[41:58] If it's up to us, we'll just block everything. Nobody can enter our property then life will be so simple.
[42:04] But it does, it's a, a recreation opportunity. It's also important thing for the community.
[42:13] So, okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Kepler.
[42:18] Thank you very much. Okay.
[42:21] We have motion and second-on in favor say aye.
[42:24] Aye. Yeah. Okay.
[42:26] Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Cindy.
[42:33] Okay, the next item is item
[42:46] 4.3 update on valley waters collaboration with water retailers on the water supply and demand management and
[42:57] mentors of landlord engagement.
[43:00] Good morning committee.
[43:02] Here's some sort of assistant officer
[43:03] for the water supply division.
[43:04] I'll turn this over to Ashley Shannon.
[43:07] Good morning.
[43:09] Thank you for having me.
[43:11] Ashley Shannon Senior Water Conservation Specialists
[43:13] in our water supply planning and conservation unit.
[43:16] I'll mention I'll be presenting on how we collaborate
[43:19] with our local retailers and then what we're doing
[43:22] to provide our services to
[43:24] renders engage with landlords, all right.
[43:30] So value-waters partners with local partnerships
[43:33] with our local retailers, plays a really crucial role
[43:36] in achieving our water conservation goals,
[43:38] 10,000 acre feet by 4040 and now 126,000 acre feet by 2050.
[43:45] By working really closely with our retailers,
[43:49] we can leverage resources, coordinate funding for rebate programs,
[43:52] and ensure consistent messaging for the public,
[43:55] especially during a drought.
[43:57] And so, you know, with the 13 major water retailers
[43:59] in our county that helps serve this,
[44:02] that, you know, 200 million people
[44:03] that live within the county, we can achieve these goals.
[44:06] And so, what I'll go through is the kind of various aspects
[44:10] that we do, including cautionary agreements,
[44:12] outreach collaboration, committee engagement, and reporting.
[44:19] So to the increased participation in RBBA programs,
[44:22] and to encourage conservation through our through advanced metering infrastructure, which is AMI.
[44:29] We value water is entered into cost sharing agreements with a number of the water retailers in our county.
[44:36] We have six current. We had seven, but one of them ended at the end of our cost sharing agreement with Puportino,
[44:42] ended at the end of 2024. But we've got agreements with Gowroy, Stimo Pidesh,
[44:48] Morgan Hill, Stimo Palo Alto, and Phenose Municipal Water in various forms.
[44:54] Currently, our kosher agreements include many of our programs. This is our landscape rebate
[45:01] The cost sharing contributions vary by water retailer. So far, I'll ask if you'd be a big program, for example, cost sharing adds an additional $1,000 to $3,000, depending on where you are in the county for single family and $10,000 to $35,000 for commercial institutional and multi-family properties.
[45:20] In addition, this is finding that in our lower grads package, AMI is in a really important
[45:25] tool for reaching our water conservation goals.
[45:29] And Valley Water provides cost sharing on implementing AMI in different service areas and
[45:35] also helps fund water use reports, which provide custom water consumption information
[45:43] to participants.
[45:44] As of July, 2024, we have kosher agreements with three different agencies for AMI, and this is the city of Morgan Hill, city of Milpitas and city of Palo Alto.
[45:56] We are also in process of creating kosher agreement with the city of Mountain View for approximately 19,000 AMI meters.
[46:10] Rally Waters Office of Communications works really closely with our water retailers to cross from our programs in multiple languages that are in mainly in English Spanish Mandarin and Vietnamese.
[46:23] And our multi-lingual advertising campaigns target these diverse populations through digital and social media platforms.
[46:30] And during fiscal year 24 we worked with various cities to contribute creative materials to remote water conservation programs and our rebate programs.
[46:43] We offer partners, we offer partner toolkit for our water conservation campaigns for our retailers can promote that.
[46:50] Featuring ads, digital banners, animation and suggested messaging.
[46:54] We've also co-branded our materials so that our retailers can use those on their own platforms as well.
[47:06] And then for that sort of collaboration, we offer community engagement.
[47:13] So to collaborate and coordinate with these water retailers, we facilitate quarterly water retailer meetings and several corresponding subcommittees.
[47:21] So, through the water conservation and communication retailer subcommending specifically,
[47:27] our staff works with our retailers to promote our water conservation programs, develop
[47:33] consistent messaging and drought messaging, focuses on local and state regulations, reporting
[47:39] requirements, and just to build in our agency relationships.
[47:44] Through our water conservation subcommittee, we are facilitating an ad hoc working group.
[47:50] to help our retailers navigate the urban water use
[47:53] objective calculation.
[47:55] So everyone right now is trying to figure those out.
[47:58] And so we're helping to facilitate
[47:59] so that everyone's on the same team
[48:03] and understand how to do that reporting.
[48:06] So this is also stated with the states recently adopted
[48:08] water use efficiency regulations
[48:10] that making conservation a California way of life framework.
[48:15] In addition to working with our retailers
[48:17] through the committees in October, Valley Water and Bosca, the Bay Area Water Supplying Conservation Agency,
[48:25] we successfully hosted an all-day workshop to equipped agencies with the knowledge and the tools
[48:30] that necessary to understand and comply with the state's water use regulations.
[48:36] The workshop was a success during nearly 70 attendees from over 40 different agencies throughout the
[48:45] agency perspectives and enterprise while sharing newly created guidance resource developed
[48:52] through a partnership between Valley Water and Bosca.
[48:58] The new regulations will assist Valley Water in meeting our long-term goals.
[49:05] And then through reporting, we also work closely with our water retailers to provide them
[49:09] with conservation participation data and receive data from demand forecast modeling.
[50:00] To all the different retailers in our county, we've also developed an economic metric based
[50:08] water demand model, bill with the data and support of value waters, water retailers and
[50:14] cities to support its water planning and investment decision. So this model is built using
[50:20] statistical relationships among historical data sets, such as water use economic data and
[50:26] development data in climate data as well.
[50:32] And then to move on to our engagement with
[50:34] renters and landlords, this is something that this committee has discussed often
[50:40] that the need for this collaboration. But to expand the program accessibility, we have
[50:45] value water has updated our landscape, we program requirements, and our long due to landscape
[50:49] rate water. We've had eligibility criteria to now allow renters to apply and receive the
[50:56] debate directly with Britain consent from their landlord or the property owner.
[51:02] Rangers who participate in our Landscape Library Program are also eligible for our Landscape
[51:07] Maintenance Consultation Program, which is a one-to-one-half-hour on-site consultation
[51:12] with the Landscape Professional, which tips on how to maintain their Landscape to improve
[51:19] the longevity of that program and really to ensure that we are protecting our investments
[51:24] in these landscape rebate programs.
[51:27] Our waterways outdoor survey program is also beneficial to homeowners and renters responsible
[51:33] for maintaining their home landscape.
[51:35] So during the survey, a trained irrigation professional will evaluate their system, provide
[51:42] recommendations, flagging efficiencies, and then also give them tips on eligibility for rebate
[51:48] program participation.
[51:49] And
[51:55] then value order, we also have an online shopping cart that offers properties in Santa
[52:00] Claire County free, including renters, free water conservation devices.
[52:05] So anyone can use this site to request low flow shower heads, sinkerators, shower timers,
[52:13] DIY kits, and it's all available on our website at watersavings.org, to help reduce
[52:19] cost and water usage. And then lastly, in collaboration with PG&E's Energy Savings Assistance
[52:27] Program, Valley Water Conducted 2 pilots addressing weeks, delivering equity-based water
[52:34] conservation measures to low-income households across that of Claire County. So the Lika
[52:39] Assessment and Pilot and Repair Pilot offered visual indoor and outdoor Lika assessment
[52:45] along with repairs and replacements of leaky aerators and irrigation equipment.
[52:52] The toilet assessment and retrofit pilot focused on identifying repairing toilet leaks,
[52:56] as well as replacing inefficient toilet models to 1.6 gallon per plus your higher.
[53:03] So together, these pilots served 214 low-income households, which included 29-brinter occupied homes.
[53:12] And with that, open for questions.
[53:20] Thank you, Ashley.
[53:21] There's just no community members.
[53:24] Well, thank you, Chair.
[53:25] Ask the comment.
[53:27] This is here about our February summit.
[53:30] Oh, yes.
[53:31] So, um, value water is hosting a landscape.
[53:34] Our annual landscape summit.
[53:35] It's on February 27.
[53:38] Um, we posted every year.
[53:41] It's for landscape professionals.
[53:42] And also those working in Jason too, landscaping, we get a lot of involvement from the various agencies or cities in the county as well as well as outside sources.
[53:52] And it's just kind of focuses on new and innovative topics that we're hoping that landscape was well adopted and take with them out into the.
[54:03] It's it came about from our landscape committee.
[54:07] I'll cherish you and I serve on the last gave the committee and this come a long ways and does a great job.
[54:14] When I hear well I go to other committees.
[54:17] They seem not everybody but they always seem to say we need more publicity.
[54:20] I'm always up because I guess because we just get only information.
[54:24] But I know we've got to keep on with our residents because we're going to be facing these droughts again.
[54:29] Right now everybody's kind of happy things are kind of fussing on everything's working.
[54:34] When the cost is going to go up and water is going to be scarce, and again to the last game of committee, you guys just do a really fine job.
[54:42] Thank you.
[54:45] Question clear.
[54:49] New be here.
[54:50] I'll keep saying that for I think I get a year.
[54:54] How long you get to say they are new be.
[54:57] Is there a place where we can see the that out?
[55:00] But is there more of a report or a comprehensive place where we can just be like, okay, we're doing all these great things.
[55:08] We have partnerships with these various cities. You know, what is the result? What are we seeing as the uptake? Is it, does it vary across city?
[55:19] Are the, you know, can we, and this also goes to on the audit committee doing an audit around conservation and just getting a better understanding of like,
[55:26] Well, it works. What's what's getting people to actually do this stuff.
[55:32] I'd love to see the number. Like I'd love to see the numbers. Yeah.
[55:35] Through the chair if I could.
[55:37] Uh, me too, Richard. I'm the manager of the water supply planning and conservation unit.
[55:41] Uh, we actually do have a web page. There is a tab on there with reports.
[55:47] That's where we keep like our strategic plan that we recently completed a few years ago.
[55:51] we have our annual reports which does talk about what is the participation in the various programs
[55:57] things like that. So we do have that available. And then we provide reports on a regular basis
[56:02] at this committee as well. Yeah, it's actually on your work plan to hear our annual update of how we're
[56:09] doing towards our water conservation goals.
[56:23] Okay. This is another action item. I'm going to ask for
[56:29] public comment related to a staff's presentation.
[56:35] Thank you chair. I have no physical cards and there are no hands raised online.
[56:39] Okay. Thank you. Thank you for the information.
[56:43] Okay. And we'll move on to the next item, which is the last of the characters.
[56:49] Thank you.
[56:50] I then 4.4 update on Laos Laquerra's Reservoir Expansion Project.
[56:55] I recommend to the Board to ratify the resolution of the Laos Laquerra's Reservoir Joint
[57:02] Power Authority to terminate the joint exercise of power's agreement and dissolved the
[57:09] authority.
[57:10] Thank you, Teresh.
[57:11] Thank you.
[57:12] Thank you.
[57:12] Thank you.
[57:12] Thank you.
[57:19] Thank you.
[57:20] Thank you.
[57:20] So good morning, I'm Kathryn Moher, a senior engineer in the imported water unit.
[57:25] I have a very brief item for you today on the most of the Careous Reservoir Expansion Project.
[57:29] It's so brief that there's actually no presentation.
[57:32] Looks like they're showing the Chaco Reservoir presentation on the screen.
[57:37] So Ron, Ron presentation, it's just me talking today.
[57:43] So on January 8th, the most of the Careous Expansion Joint Powers Authority or JPA adopted a resolution
[57:50] to terminate the project and to dissolve the Louis Vicaros JPA. As the committee is aware,
[57:56] this action follows is decision by the Contra Costa Water District board in November to
[58:02] withdraw their support from the project. A copy of the resolution that the JPA approved on January 8th
[58:08] has been included in the agenda packet. The resolution directs the JPA staff to proceed with the
[58:18] to the member agencies at the end of the dissolution process.
[58:22] JPA staff are estimating that there would be about $10 million of unspent funds that would be returned
[58:29] and split amongst the number of agencies.
[58:31] Value water is expected to get about 14% of whatever the remaining funds are,
[58:38] so potentially around 1.4 million depending on how much is actually left at the end of this.
[58:44] The resolution also specifies that at some point in the future one of the member agencies
[58:48] which is to use the facility designs that the JPA funded as part of this project that they would
[58:55] reimburse the other members for their contributions to that facility's design.
[59:03] So at any point
[59:04] time, if Contracost Water District or another agency wants to go back and revive the project,
[59:09] there would be some reimbursement of the funds spent towards those design.
[59:17] So the JPA agreement specifies that 75% of the JPA member agency boards need to ratify the
[59:23] resolution to dissolve the JPA in order for the resolution to take effect.
[59:29] There are eight JPA members, so 75% would be six out of the eight members.
[59:35] So at this time, all the other members are taking this resolution back to their board
[59:40] for ratification and we're going to be bringing this to the committee today and then hopefully
[59:46] to the board on the February 25th Board meeting and we are recommending right now that the staff
[59:53] or that the committee make a recommendation to the board to ratify the JPA's resolution to dissolve.
[1:00:00] For the board to give a resolution. How many of the most important is that, you know, I was able to participate in that, uh,
[1:00:08] local council group. And we had some good relationships, met a lot of good folks and so on, so we never know.
[1:00:13] What may come around for the Pacheco or other things, and our staff always maintain the good relationship.
[1:00:21] Real knowledgeable people. And then, of course, lessons learned.
[1:00:24] We're talking about Cisco and everything else how
[1:00:28] It's easy to dissolve partners, but how do you keep partners? And so we want to make sure we do that
[1:00:33] But to our staff and of course, I was called our Joe, but his Katherine and Vince cuz we drive up together
[1:00:39] I know he's chatting and there was kept me on top of all the all the issues not really appreciate
[1:00:45] Besides going to McDonald's and buying me one video
[1:00:47] But that was a really good end of that would be my recommendation. Thank you
[1:00:56] Are there any public comment?
[1:01:00] Want this?
[1:01:02] Uh, thank you.
[1:01:03] Share.
[1:01:05] There are no hands online, but I do believe we'd have a,
[1:01:09] Oh, no, I'm sorry.
[1:01:11] No, no public comment at this point.
[1:01:13] That's for the next one.
[1:01:14] Thank you.
[1:01:15] Okay.
[1:01:16] Okay.
[1:01:17] Um, then, uh, we have a motion is second on the favor say I.
[1:01:23] Okay.
[1:01:23] I'm sorry. I don't think I got the second. Was there a faller? Thank you. Yeah.
[1:01:33] Okay. Thank you. I almost say thank you, Joe. He conditioned me. I'm sure your mom is so proud of you.
[1:01:47] Okay. Moving on to item 4.5. Receive an informational update on the
[1:01:54] to check out the Reservoir Expansion Project.
[1:01:58] Yes, good morning, Chair and committee.
[1:02:00] I'm Ryan McCartard, Deputy Operating Officer
[1:02:02] of the Dam Safety and Capital Delivery Division.
[1:02:04] So we have an update today on the particular Reservoir Expansion
[1:02:07] Project, a pretty lengthy agenda memo with a lot of description
[1:02:10] on what's going on.
[1:02:12] And there's also a presentation that Julianne O'Brien will give.
[1:02:15] And this time we also included an FAQ
[1:02:16] of kind of a compilation of some of the questions
[1:02:19] that have been asked in the past year or two
[1:02:21] and just kind of putting those all in one place
[1:02:23] to document our responses on this.
[1:02:25] You've got a really nice complement from Sierra Club, I bought your FAQ, so I guess.
[1:02:31] Yeah, let's make it. We're trying our best. All right, I'll hand it over to Julianne.
[1:02:36] Good morning, Julianne. Good morning, Julianne, I'm Julianne O'Brien,
[1:02:42] Engineering, Unit Manager, overseen the project project project.
[1:02:46] So today's another informational update, and it's a more general project update,
[1:02:51] compared to some of our more specific updates
[1:02:55] that we've had recently.
[1:02:58] Just kind of as a reminder,
[1:03:01] in October of 23, the committee came up
[1:03:03] with a list of potential projects to kind of guide
[1:03:05] our updates moving forward.
[1:03:08] We then took that to the board the following month.
[1:03:12] Then the next update was on the project operations
[1:03:16] and benefits that was late 23 or late 2024.
[1:03:20] We've followed that with discussion and review of project costs in spring of 24 and then the discussion and review of requirements unique to the project in late summer early fall of 2024 and as Ryan mentioned we've got that list of FAQs that we put together from those different presentations just to kind of have it one spot to reference.
[1:03:46] Some of the future topics that are still in the list, because these get brought up, frequently
[1:03:50] we just want to remind everyone that they are still coming.
[1:03:53] The next one is actually going to be the discussion review of current partnership approach
[1:03:57] and the board directed partnership percentages.
[1:04:01] We've got a few updates and some strategy changes that we want to bring up to the board
[1:04:07] and so that'll be the next one.
[1:04:09] And then, other ones on the list, that we, so the camera, the connection between the project and the 2025 water supply master plan is portfolio recommendation, the projects environmental impact and mitigation measures and then any additional topics that the board or committee may bring up.
[1:04:30] So project updates, since the last major overall update,
[1:04:36] geotechnical investigations, as the committee may remember back in May 2023,
[1:04:42] the investigations were stopped due to the court order, requiring additional
[1:04:48] sequence analysis. That took the form of a initial study mitigating negligent
[1:04:54] negative declaration that was released to the public in June of 2024.
[1:05:00] Decision happened in August of 2024 and October we had the notice of preparation and we are in the process of finalizing that document and we anticipate releasing that hopefully next month.
[1:05:15] And then as far as environmental phase, in June of 21, PG&E let us know that there was going to be some additional transmission line improvements needed to just part of the project.
[1:05:29] And it actually took us a little while to determine exactly what that requirement was going to be.
[1:05:36] And so we now know it's two additional miles.
[1:05:37] In September of 23, Army Corps was finally identified as the Federal Lead Neapolete and then as part of that discussion and them taking that lead,
[1:05:54] they just requested that we separate our environmental impact statement from the recirculated draft EIR for the larger project.
[1:06:01] Initially we had planned on doing a joint document.
[1:06:04] And so we took that request under advisement we had some internal discussions and figuring out pros and cons of both approaches and then this passive timber we decided that that was the best approach for this project.
[1:06:20] mainly due to the page limitations for the NEPA document.
[1:06:24] So this will allow us to have a fully robust
[1:06:27] SQL document to address everything we need to with SQL
[1:06:30] and then we can reference that in the NEPA document.
[1:06:34] Additionally, we realized that we were gonna have
[1:06:37] to do some additional modeling required
[1:06:39] because of the statewide model updates,
[1:06:42] moving from calcium 2 to calcium 3.
[1:06:45] And so we're going,
[1:06:46] that's gonna extend the environmental phase as well
[1:06:48] while we update our models accordingly.
[1:06:54] And so the impacts to the geotechnical work
[1:06:58] and the environmental phase as resulted in approximately
[1:07:02] 18-month delay to the project.
[1:07:05] And so that's what this document or the slide shows.
[1:07:08] It's just the changes to the phase dates.
[1:07:14] And so even though it says construction start
[1:07:17] is 1-1-20-29, that's not necessarily
[1:07:19] the start of actual construction, that's just the start of the construction phase.
[1:07:23] And so there's going to be some pre-construction activities still occurring after that part.
[1:07:33] These slides, I'm not going to spend a whole lot of time on them because there's just a lot of information,
[1:07:38] but basically that 18-month schedule delay that I showed on the previous one is now detailed
[1:07:47] out in some of the specific activities during, that are, is going to occur during those phases.
[1:07:53] And so the main, you know, we are here in January, 2025, we're working on the updated project
[1:08:00] description and then developing the draft, which are really draft EIR, as well as continuing to
[1:08:07] move the design level geo tech EIR along and the design simultaneously.
[1:08:23] Okay, current project efforts.
[1:08:25] As I mentioned, we're continuing to progress towards a 60% design.
[1:08:29] We did receive an interim 60% design package earlier this month
[1:08:33] for the items that are not dependent on the geotechnical
[1:08:37] investigation results, the rest of the 60% design is kind of on hold until we get that
[1:08:44] investigation, those investigations completed. We are continuing to coordinate with PG&E on the
[1:08:50] new transmission line. We have completed the facility study report with PG&E and moved on to the
[1:08:59] I, which I'm in our connection agreement and we've received that draft and we're reviewing
[1:09:05] that right now and we are compiling our comments. We anticipate getting those back to PG&E
[1:10:01] So, upcoming milestones, as I mentioned, we're expecting to have the draft geotech EIR completed in February 2025, and so that will then go out for public comment.
[1:10:14] We will then incorporate any comments, address those, and with the goal of having the final EIR certified and permits in hand, I August, and then resuming the geotechnical investigations in September.
[1:10:29] We would then look to complete the geotechnical investigations next June and then the 60% design would be completed September 2026.
[1:10:45] Any questions?
[1:10:49] Thank you for the report. Questions on how many member?
[1:10:56] Okay.
[1:10:59] Okay.
[1:11:00] Yeah.
[1:11:01] Let me see.
[1:11:06] All has this question now that
[1:11:09] at the last page of the PowerPoint slides.
[1:11:12] It says certified geotech.
[1:11:15] EIR slash permits.
[1:11:17] So my question is that.
[1:11:19] What kind of permits work?
[1:11:21] Sorry, sorry.
[1:11:22] The main floor that you'll turn, they're cool.
[1:11:24] So we will need a liquid streambed alteration agreement, and then we actually have a meeting to later today to discuss what other permits are needed.
[1:11:34] But I know we're planning on talking about the 401 versus 404, 602, and then the valley habitat plan because that work, this work will be covered at the valley habitat plan.
[1:11:45] So, it's a reduced scale, but it's the same problem.
[1:11:54] So, I think that we will still need some of those permits for the boring themselves.
[1:12:03] And I will be able to provide additional detail when we take this item to commit the full board.
[1:12:10] Okay, I'll be here.
[1:12:11] And so related question is that we still need to get property owners agreement to get on their property to date whatever big size the the whole is.
[1:12:29] So for the real technical for and we have the property access that we need already.
[1:12:34] So this is, yeah, we had condemnation efforts and so we have to have to access.
[1:12:47] We don't need to go through this again. So the, we already have to write,
[1:12:53] how was the EIR is adopted by the board and on the permanence of fire, then we're meeting
[1:13:00] our requirement for the geotentical investigation.
[1:13:06] So that we have property access right now.
[1:13:08] We may need a time only extension for one of the properties based on the time that was stipulated in that initial agreement.
[1:13:15] However, the work that was included in that initial agreement has not changed,
[1:13:19] and so it's just a matter of asking for additional time on that.
[1:13:23] And we are in the process of coordinating that.
[1:13:25] Okay. Okay. Yeah. Okay. Good. I thought we could need to go through that process again. So we didn't. We shouldn't. Okay. Yeah. Okay. Then, uh, uh, as we'll public comment first and then go back to the head to four permits.
[1:13:41] First of all, we have. Thank you, chair. There's one public person public comment. Okay. So Mr Doug Peterson.
[1:13:53] Dear committee members, my name is Doug Peterson, and I am here today to speak about the
[1:13:58] decision making process for the Pacheco Reservoir Expansion Project.
[1:14:03] I am troubled by recent suggestions that the board should set an arbitrary date in the
[1:14:09] near future to consider terminating the project.
[1:14:12] I believe that our deliberations should be allowed to run their natural course.
[1:14:16] Specifically, I believe that the passage of Proposition I, in 2014, obligates Valley Water to honor the will of California voters and give the project a reasonable opportunity to succeed.
[1:14:31] Proposition I was a carefully crafted water bond that passed out of the California legislature with extraordinary bipartisan support.
[1:14:40] Not a single state senator opposed it and the vote in the assembly was 77 to 2.
[1:14:47] The proposition has something in it for everybody and earned the endorsement of Governor
[1:14:52] Jerry Brown, Senator Diane Feinstein, Senator Barbara Boxer, the California Democratic
[1:14:57] Party, California Republic.
[1:15:00] The California Audubon, the Delta Countess Commission, California Chamber of Commerce, the Silicon Valley Leadership Group, Natural Resources Defense Council, California League of Conservation Voters, and the Association of California Water Agents.
[1:15:18] Most importantly, the $7 billion buy measure was approved by 67% California voters and included a major provision that's $2.7 billion would be earmarked for desperately needed water storage projects.
[1:15:36] The Jacob was one of eight major projects selected to receive a portion of the water storage funding and remains eligible for a $504 million grant through the water storage investment program.
[1:15:47] Two of those eight projects have now been terminated, including the nearby Losfakeros expansion project.
[1:15:56] If a project like Pacheco was to come to fruition, the water agency must navigate a complex lab,
[1:16:03] laborant of obstacles. Each of which has a valid public purpose.
[1:16:08] As the agency struggles to reconcile its future water needs, with others genuine concerns.
[1:16:13] takes considerable time to plan and vet these kinds of large infrastructure projects, and that is as it should be.
[1:16:22] If the well of California voters is to be respected, agencies like valley water that were chosen to build new water storage facilities need to show political courage and persevere.
[1:16:33] It has been argued that we should abandon Pacheco and favor of other solutions, but striking
[1:16:39] the balance between different water supply strategies was accomplished when proposition
[1:16:43] one was crafted.
[1:16:45] And considerable state funds have been made available for the kinds of strategies favored
[1:16:52] by Pacheco's detractors.
[1:16:54] Water districts like ours are the only public agencies that can deliver on proposition
[1:16:59] one's mandate to increase our state's water storage capacity. We applied for the water storage grant money.
[1:17:07] A half a billion dollars was awarded to us, and we need to follow through on what we started.
[1:17:13] The day may come when we are forced to decide that Pachakos is not in the best interest of
[1:17:18] Salot, Cland, Santa Clara Valley residents, but that day is far off. Even if it costs money to
[1:17:26] continue pursuing the project, our deliberate
[1:17:29] process needs to continue innovative.
[1:17:33] Thank you.
[1:17:35] Thank you very much for that comment.
[1:17:37] Thank you.
[1:17:40] Questions, comments from coming.
[1:17:43] Just a second.
[1:17:44] Are there anyone on the Zoom?
[1:17:47] Thank you, Chair.
[1:17:48] There are no hands on Zoom.
[1:17:50] And also want to recognize
[1:17:54] are in from the Sierra Club, subbedded comments, I think yesterday about this item.
[1:18:04] Comments from coming in members, Director Santos?
[1:18:07] Yeah, thank you, Chairman. Mr. Petersen, I always appreciate you taking the time as you
[1:18:11] have numerous times, because you educate yourself continually to help all of us have a
[1:18:16] better future.
[1:18:17] I don't know what's wrong with people when you were about costs all that time. Sure, we all do
[1:18:22] But what do you do if you don't have water?
[1:18:25] Well, what if you do if you fail you face the LA fires. I've been there and when that source is not there
[1:18:33] It's unbelievable 12,000 homes
[1:18:35] 15,000 firefighters we can go on and on, but the damage control will go on forever
[1:18:40] That's a costable never absorb. It'll go on and on
[1:18:44] So it takes one of the biggest issues in California, there's always been we don't have enough
[1:18:49] damps and some of the ones that we have need maintenance in issues.
[1:18:54] Thank goodness we have 10 and now this one are staff doing a great job to make we just
[1:18:59] had a meeting a couple of days ago to show how we're continuing our maintenance program to
[1:19:04] make sure we have a reliable source for firefighting, for drinking, for the environment
[1:19:09] and reduce flooding.
[1:19:10] It's just common sense. I don't know why we keep on arguing because I got mine and I keep on repeating it
[1:19:18] I want to see the great grandchildren have water and not kill each other over COVID-19
[1:19:23] Let alone lack of water. So thank you for taking the time because every time a civilian comes in and says this
[1:19:29] It just helps educate everybody. I appreciate it and I hope you are there listening when I'm gone
[1:19:35] Don't call me and say you don't have water
[1:19:43] Thank you for the great presentation, and I was particularly, I liked the look back on the summary of some of the questions that have been asked in the past that helped me as again.
[1:20:00] Graphs that show Chesbro compared to Chaco. And it says, I guess it was referring to a this graph was shown previously, and someone was like, what does this mean? And so I read your response to this, and I still am like, well wait, what does this mean? So can you just explain maybe a little more?
[1:20:18] Yeah, right, and you want to take that one?
[1:20:20] Yeah, I can explain that one a little bit more. So yeah, the question was asked, we presented this slide.
[1:20:26] comparing the Chesbro reservoir storage with the expanded particular reservoir storage with the Chesbro line shown below just to show kind of the magnitude of the amount of storage and water we'd have available with the expanded particular reservoir.
[1:20:41] The question was asked, I think there was kind of a misunderstanding of what we were presenting and so we were trying to clarify what we were trying to present with this graphic.
[1:20:51] I don't know how I'll explain it, but without reading through our response more carefully,
[1:20:58] but did you have like a specific question on?
[1:21:02] I guess my takeaway was that it's essentially showing, you know, Chesbro's showing these
[1:21:09] seasonal fluctuations, and it's just, it's just greater volume of the jaco helps move stuff out.
[1:21:14] Like, that's, that's, that's just it.
[1:21:16] Yeah, that's, that's pretty much it. And so Tesbro's kind of of one of our typical reservoirs. They don't all operate like this Anderson's kind of one of the exceptions. You know, we try to keep storage in there when it's, you know, there's no restriction on it. But yes, it is, is showing that, you know, the most of our reservoirs fill and then almost completely empty year in and year out. So it's a kind of a cyclical thing. Just based on the amount of storage they can have and they're constantly releasing water to the, the creeps that they serve. So this is comparing the more magnitude of the Chaco would.
[1:21:46] would, you know, keep it full longer so there would be basically a reserve of water at most times
[1:21:51] in there.
[1:21:57] I couldn't do as a Santos when I was on a roll, I forgot, but when I thank Brian, I mean,
[1:22:03] Brian, my partner, because he's always educating people on, you know, when you've got a river
[1:22:08] button, he's staffed, and all you've taken care of the 10 dams we have, you're taking on
[1:22:13] this plus Anderson, it's a hell of a challenge right now.
[1:22:16] And I really appreciate all the work you guys are doing, because you're trying to, trying
[1:22:20] do is making sure we have a source for the rest of our lives and it's hard work. I think
[1:22:26] enough, a few people screwed in as you include the CIA and FBI probably, but as you're doing a
[1:22:33] great job and I really appreciate it. Thank you.
[1:22:39] Okay,
[1:22:42] I think I'm going to give you some suggestions
[1:22:47] on the future topics that Steph asks us that right now we have three topics that was originally
[1:22:59] developed. That was the whole idea for the whole board to take its time to really look into
[1:23:05] the complexity of FUXAM, a Jacobo, and then how to set the spying earlier that it's not going to
[1:23:14] we're not going to operate a jico, that's where we operate our existing care as
[1:23:19] before, since it's a different operating mode, so it's the board developed a list
[1:23:26] of issues, some technical, some dollars, some political to take our time to go through these
[1:23:34] topics one at a time. And we're still right now, it's listed on the page three of the
[1:23:42] for slides, there are still three topics that were haven't done it yet.
[1:23:49] My suggestion is that for the next topic, discussion with this committee in the full
[1:23:59] board, I would move the discussion of connection between Project and 2020, if I want to
[1:24:07] most of the plans for the recommendation.
[1:24:11] I think, I think it's to me that's a more critical
[1:24:19] item to understand before we talked about cost sharing or environmental impacts and mitigation.
[1:24:28] And only environmental impacts and mitigation are not important. They're critical in order
[1:24:33] However, it just seems like the timing is not right yet where we can go to the board talk about
[1:24:41] environmental impacts and mitigation, but it just seems that we're in the middle of the study study of that.
[1:24:48] It's going to just be a very preliminary or partial information.
[1:24:53] So I think until we have a better grasp of the mitigation.
[1:24:58] and
[1:25:00] Just went to the board, and I long ago presenting this that four quadrant was a six year job, job planning, and then the three portfolios, right, the diversified portfolio, the lease cost, and then local control.
[1:25:17] I think it will be interesting for, not interesting, it will be important for everybody to understand that the role of particular reservoir plays in these three portfolios.
[1:25:36] So what I'm thinking is that in theory that these three portfolios will all accomplish
[1:25:47] the job planning for what the amount, one of the supply master plan is looking at, and
[1:25:56] the reason that, particularly seeing, I think two of them, two of them, and then not all three.
[1:26:04] So there must be a different role of Pacheco project in our overall planning for the,
[1:26:12] both for the future 2025. So I'm not sure I explain myself clearly, but
[1:26:20] I think that if we focus on Pacheco, that to me will be a good understanding for all of us,
[1:26:30] including myself that knowing that Pacheco can play this kind of a role to make the future planning
[1:26:39] a more whatever flexible or whatever. So that would be my suggestion.
[1:26:49] Yeah, no, absolutely. You know, I was kind of in my own head debating, you know, which one should
[1:26:55] come first and we'll coordinate with the waters by master plenty, most of them are sitting in this room.
[1:26:59] So they're her first hand and see where we stand
[1:27:02] and if the times right to do that.
[1:27:05] I think it could be, but I think we do also want to,
[1:27:07] maybe we can even combine the presentation
[1:27:09] and share some of the partnership concepts
[1:27:11] that we're doing.
[1:27:12] Yeah, that was a very, very valuable moment
[1:27:14] because they do tie in to how the operations modeling looks
[1:27:17] and how it would affect the water supply master plan.
[1:27:20] So we can kind of, you know,
[1:27:21] how to let them and see how we can best address that.
[1:27:23] Yeah, that's presentation.
[1:27:24] Okay.
[1:27:25] Okay, good.
[1:27:26] I don't know if you have any comments that staff is asking us for input.
[1:27:33] And also staff is seeing additional topics as requested by the board and committee,
[1:27:38] particularly for their provider.
[1:27:40] That's is a, you were not part of the whole world going through the list of topics to
[1:27:46] looking to if you have anything to add to this, you'll welcome to add anything.
[1:27:51] And also, this is not the one-time thing that's, as we move, you know, you'll probably think about something and then just keep in mind that we, we made a commitment to ourselves and then to the public that it's a huge project, a huge expenditure, we want to understand that we aspect of it, so by the time we make a decision, we know that there's decent balancing act.
[1:28:18] Yeah, this is not this is good, but they're overall. We're looking at overall picture. Yeah
[1:28:26] Since you were asking again, and I'm so typically what I do is I read through the packet and then I make a bunch of notes of all the questions that I have and
[1:28:34] I like to try to get it get them ahead of time to staff so that I'm not necessarily springing anything on folks
[1:28:39] But sometimes I just don't have time
[1:28:42] But one of the questions that I or just one of the comments that I made as I was going through the materials was
[1:28:47] just generally, and again, this is, and the new person, so these are questions that I also don't
[1:28:54] want to take a lot of committee time for because it's me learning, but since you were asking
[1:28:59] if I had any more feedback, one of the thoughts that came to mind as I was reading through some
[1:29:03] of the, you know, backtracking a bit on SQL, which is always something typically that happens
[1:29:10] for big projects, but just generally the approach of this agency towards, you know, generally
[1:29:19] the approach of the organization towards Sequoia, if we tend to do kind of a built-in suspenders
[1:29:23] approach or if it varies depending on the project, you know, just reading through this is like,
[1:29:32] okay, we got a backtrack a little bit and redo some of these pieces. And so I just, I had questions
[1:29:37] around that we anticipate that what happened is that generally our approach, that kind of stuff.
[1:29:44] Yeah. So with respect to the geotech, Nicole investigations, we typically do those under
[1:29:49] an exemption, a geotitinal investigations are almost always done in an exemption. This, in this
[1:29:56] distance be partly because of the amount of investing.
[1:30:00] And fourings and test pits that were needed. One of the property owners did file a lawsuit and it was determined that we needed to do additional
[1:30:14] sequence analysis for this case and that the exemption did not apply. And so this is a very unique situation that
[1:30:20] wouldn't ordinarily happen for our other projects.
[1:30:29] Yeah, I can elaborate just a little bit on that, so like Julian mentioned, we typically use
[1:30:34] a categorical exemption which is legal and basically the judge determined that we need
[1:30:41] an additional SQL analysis.
[1:30:43] Now, additional SQL analysis for the geotechnical investigation, we've already gone through
[1:30:47] alternatives and how to conduct investigations, for example, accessing a lot of the areas
[1:30:53] and these kind of untouched, pristine, you know, mountain sides would have required us to like cut
[1:30:59] roads and things like that to get the drill rigs to those areas. And we looked at using helicopters.
[1:31:03] And we actually did that in our phase one, investigation and used helicopters to land the material
[1:31:08] right where we need it in an equipment and perform those investigations. We also have a long list of
[1:31:13] best management practices and mitigation measures that we use during geotechnical investigations as a
[1:31:23] what goals in our mission in mind. But in this case, you know, it was challenged, and so we are
[1:31:28] doing additional SQL analysis, but this is not going to be the part for the course going forward
[1:31:33] that we don't intend for this to be our standard protocol. So we'll continue to use categorical
[1:31:39] exemptions and think carefully about the size of the investigation program and the impacts that
[1:31:44] occur.
[1:31:51] Okay. Okay, so not there are no further suggestions for the board for the for the for the staff. Yeah,
[1:32:00] for the board. Okay. So this is information, I don't only and otherwise, thank you for
[1:32:09] thank you for the statement, I know it's getting longer and longer, but then which I think it's important that we keep it
[1:32:15] just to be transparent and particularly the dollar amount that we spent since the beginning of the project so that we're not hiding, we're not hiding anything, this is good, thank you.
[1:32:35] Next item,
[1:32:40] item 4.6 review and discuss what is the supply and demand management committee
[1:32:47] work plan and approved 2025 meeting schedule.
[1:32:53] Okay, so all words work plan as it's planned right now is on the last page of this
[1:33:00] could page 155. We are in January, so these are the items that's on our agenda. On our agenda,
[1:33:11] today we did all of them. Looks like in February there's no item planned out for February's meeting.
[1:33:20] is that we don't even for the purpose of having a meeting and having a meeting. There has to be
[1:33:28] something to have access. We were going to have this in Skyrim, but then it got moved to today.
[1:33:34] So yeah, there's no item for February. Yeah. Then I was, since there's no item plan for February
[1:33:40] then we won't meet in February. Okay. And any suggestion from community members for the
[1:33:50] future months that's planned down. For example that I think Director Byler you mentioned about
[1:34:01] looking at what's the outcome in numbers of the accomplishment of water supply. A lot of
[1:34:10] conservation. So this water conservation saving model and your water conservation savings
[1:34:16] That's when we're March that will give us that kind of
[1:34:21] information. Correct.
[1:34:23] Yes, that's correct. And also the information previously requested by the Director
[1:34:27] Bell on what large water users as well as what Coach mentioned earlier.
[1:34:33] Likely, I'm most of it looked fit in the city items.
[1:35:00] Groundwater Dewatering for construction activities. So you can build those topics into us.
[1:35:11] Probably, I mean, the groundwater one is slightly different.
[1:35:15] It was talked about that, actually more than once, right? Yeah.
[1:35:21] So, but it's probably a good idea to refresh our mind about that topic.
[1:35:34] There's no, I don't think there's no new information.
[1:35:36] No, I was trying to look to see if we could, I don't know, stick it into 4.1 or 1 of the other.
[1:35:42] 4.1 is in all the way to October, but maybe we can, well, I can circle back around with
[1:35:49] and we can, if, if, if sneaky in and the four point one in October works out, okay, if not, we'll make sure we can try to figure out some of the
[1:35:59] existing information if that's enough then we can recommend adding.
[1:36:03] Absolutely. Okay. Yeah. Okay.
[1:36:10] I think any, any suggestion from community members?
[1:36:15] Yeah.
[1:36:16] Yes. Thank you. You know, listen to Vice Chair Bellerden and I listen to others that talk about, you know,
[1:36:22] We still need more publicity on certain items and keep it simple like years ago. I said, you know,
[1:36:27] set of saying 7.6% cost put down the dollar sign. So we changed some of those things with
[1:36:33] Darren and people understand it more. We need to, for example, like when we talk about dams and
[1:36:38] our reservoirs and all our maintenance, we should need to come out and information about, well, if we
[1:36:43] just relied on our aquifers for one year, we would have no water or whatever we would have.
[1:36:49] We've got to be able to show examples about why the cost are going up, and what is needed,
[1:36:55] you know, why the example, I hope the majority of us won, and you know, but check what
[1:36:59] down with it.
[1:37:00] These are all the reasons why if you don't have these things, here it can happen.
[1:37:04] We know we're going to have to cost a more important water, we try not to, we're trying to rely
[1:37:08] on all this.
[1:37:10] So we can start showing those costs and some of the things that I believe in your mentioning,
[1:37:14] I think it helps us and the public understand it a lot better.
[1:37:17] So, that helps us, that's kind of what I was referring to earlier, to connect back to the three portfolios of the,
[1:37:29] what is the plan that project or reservoir must play a specific role in, at least those two portfolios that,
[1:37:40] So it's making something better, making something worse, oh yes, but it has a role without it it's going to be this with with it is going to be this it's kind of what I was looking for also just so the
[1:37:58] public can understand it better.
[1:38:04] Yeah,
[1:38:07] yeah, this looks great and I made a comment, I think it was at the my very first board meeting. I'm not remembering, but I think it was there.
[1:38:19] Where we were approving the legislative principles for the year and I made a comment about new construction.
[1:38:26] And, you know, ordinance is going forward that will help reduce our water demand and the
[1:38:35] role also of retrofitting existing buildings.
[1:38:38] And so under 3.3 fine opportunities to ensure new development has improved water wise
[1:38:44] features, window, and land use coordination is that kind of thing included there.
[1:38:50] And I know it wasn't, it's not, I believe it's not yet a priority in the legislative principles
[1:38:58] per se to be working with local governments to do, have a model ordinance for retrofits.
[1:39:05] So I may be jumping the gun and saying, hey, let's work on this.
[1:39:09] But I'm just wondering if you can say a little bit more about where that fits into what we're
[1:39:12] doing.
[1:39:13] Yeah, definitely fits in 3.3 and it really is the model water-efficient new development
[1:39:18] ordinance. We are actively working with local governments to get that adopted. So it would be part of this update.
[1:39:26] Yeah. And so just to be clear, this is for new construction and also super interested in existing buildings and how we retrofit those.
[1:39:36] Yeah.
[1:39:39] So.
[1:39:39] window, it is really about new construction. So maybe I thought it's included.
[1:39:45] I think it's a very model. Yeah, I'm not sure if it's included, but I still think it fits there,
[1:39:54] but if the committee would prefer that we have something separate. I'm not sure who, you know, what we would
[1:40:00] Actively working on it, wait, we were actively working on it for many, for many years, but then
[1:40:07] Recently, I had a meeting with the Chair Astralera and I think Vice Chair, and I was the
[1:40:17] best of one Chair Astralera and I was a transition from me to Director Astralera.
[1:40:25] We met with all our lobbyists, not obviously, legislative consultant in Sacramento and
[1:40:33] and also local, just Santa Clarke County, that's primarily our own staff, and then one of the staff said,
[1:40:42] director, I show you this year, you're going to progress out of this, their effort in mother,
[1:40:52] mother, father, efficiency, and new development partners.
[1:40:57] So I knew, we didn't got it, we just keep working at it.
[1:41:04] And of course, all the city, they're busy just like,
[1:41:07] oh, why this year you're taking care of it, but then they have a role.
[1:41:10] So just keep working.
[1:41:13] Yeah, also our regular program updates under strategy one.
[1:41:19] And yeah, strategy one mostly.
[1:41:21] We do, I mean the landscape relay program is all about retrofitting the existing urban landscape and we had the pilot projects that Ashley mentioned, you know retrofitting multi-family buildings and things like that.
[1:41:34] So I would say it's already included in the work plan to talk about retrofits.
[1:41:43] Okay,
[1:41:46] so that will be the design and foot data, the work plan.
[1:41:51] So we won't have a meeting in February.
[1:41:56] And at this page 156 is the planned meeting date for.
[1:42:03] calendar year 2025, so our general guideline for the meeting is the fourth Monday,
[1:42:16] fourth Monday at 10 o'clock every month unless the Monday is a holiday then we will
[1:42:26] schedule that meeting according to everybody's schedule. That's listed on page 156. Do we need to
[1:42:34] approve this? Would it did the for not just for information? If you wouldn't mind it's just
[1:42:39] for approving the schedule. Approving the schedule? Yes. And it's just it that it happens on Monday.
[1:42:44] I think just one time and it's noted as a memorial day. Okay. Okay. I do all make a motion to approve
[1:42:50] this schedule. Okay. And the only favors the eye. I. Yeah. Okay. Thank you.
[1:42:58] Andrew, you have. You have something to look.
[1:43:06] Okay. Okay.
[1:43:08] Clerk to review in clarification of committee request.
[1:43:12] I think you chair. I have the minutes of November 4th, 2024 were approved.
[1:43:17] Dr. Shua is chair. And Dr. Ballard is the vice chair for this committee.
[1:43:22] The BF-SIS recommendations were approved and as were the list for caros, recommendations were approved.
[1:43:36] Pitchaco Reservoir information was received and the work plan in the 2025 meeting schedule were approved and will continue to update the work plan as needed.
[1:43:47] Yeah, thank you.
[1:43:51] Okay. Okay. Before we adjourn immediately, I have a request for Mr. Peterson.
[1:43:57] Can you give us the copy of what you just read?
[1:44:03] So that I'm thinking that we can include it as
[1:44:08] records or for meetings or something. Yeah. So thank you. That'll be great. Thank you so much.