Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
[0:05]
>> All right,
[0:06]
I've got 4:30. If everyone
[0:07]
would turn
[0:08]
on their microphone.
[0:11]
Is the recording going?
[0:12]
>> Yes.
[0:13]
>> All right, well,
[0:14]
welcome you all to the
[0:15]
Regular Finance Personnel
[0:16]
Insurance Committee meeting.
[0:19]
Today is Tuesday, August
[0:20]
11, 2026. Are we
[0:23]
in compliance
[0:24]
with the open meeting?
[0:25]
>> Yes, you are.
[0:26]
>> Thank you. Number 2, we
[0:27]
have an agenda. Someone like
[0:30]
to move.
[0:32]
>> Move to approve the
[0:33]
agenda, please.
[0:34]
>> Second.
[0:36]
>> Any changes, questions?
[0:37]
All right, so I'll put
[0:41]
into a vote to approve the
[0:44]
agenda as presented. All
[0:47]
those in favor signify
[0:49]
by saying aye.
[0:51]
>> Aye.
[0:52]
>> Opposed, same sign.
[0:53]
That passes.
[0:55]
Number 3, we have two former
[0:58]
minutes to approve. Do we do
[1:02]
those together or separately?
[1:06]
>> Do it together.
[1:08]
>> Thank you. So we have the
[1:09]
draft minutes from the July
[1:11]
14 meeting and the July 21
[1:14]
meeting to approve.
[1:15]
>> I make a motion.
[1:25]
>> Thank you. Any changes,
[1:31]
corrections, typos?
[1:39]
All those in favor
[1:41]
of approving the Draft
[1:42]
minutes from July 14 and
[1:43]
July 21, 2026 meetings
[1:45]
signify by saying aye.
[1:46]
>> Aye.
[1:48]
>> Those opposed,
[1:49]
same sign. It's passed. All
[1:53]
right, number 4, public
[1:54]
comment.
[1:56]
>> None here.
[1:58]
>> So, no public here. So, we
[2:00]
won't have any public
[2:01]
comment. Number 5,
[2:03]
communications.
[2:05]
>> No communications either.
[2:06]
>> Thank you, Stephanie. No
[2:08]
communications. We'll move
[2:09]
on to number 6, business
[2:11]
items, starting
[2:12]
with the presentation
[2:13]
of the Sauk county medical
[2:14]
Plan options by M3
[2:15]
Insurance.
[2:16]
>> Yeah, so I'll kick it
[2:18]
off ever so briefly. So M3
[2:20]
was here last month,
[2:22]
the month before,
[2:23]
presented information
[2:24]
on kind of where we were at
[2:26]
with medical plan options,
[2:27]
looking for 2027 and
[2:29]
beyond. So, I've done some
[2:30]
work with the M3 team,
[2:31]
have some more numbers,
[2:34]
information,
[2:35]
some pieces where we're at.
[2:37]
As of today,
[2:38]
nothing is finalized yet. As
[2:39]
we go
[2:40]
through the budget process,
[2:41]
Lisa and I will continue
[2:43]
to work through plan design
[2:44]
and what makes the most
[2:46]
sense. But wanted to update
[2:47]
the committee because this
[2:48]
will ultimately be coming
[2:50]
back through a resolution
[2:51]
for 2027 plans next month
[2:54]
in September. So that way
[2:55]
we're not hopefully
[2:57]
surprising you. We won't be
[2:58]
with too much here. So, I'm
[3:00]
just going
[3:01]
to get them plugged.
[3:28]
>> Technology.
[3:45]
>> Thank you.
[3:46]
>> Nice
[3:47]
to see you all again. Ryan
[3:48]
Pels with M3 Clayton
[3:49]
executive work closely with
[3:51]
Lisa and MJ. As we presented
[3:52]
last month, we kind of laid
[3:54]
out the roadmap
[3:55]
of what it looks like
[3:57]
for the county,
[4:00]
what we're doing together
[4:01]
in terms of marketing. So
[4:03]
what you have in front of you
[4:04]
is really an illustration
[4:06]
of what's up here. So, this
[4:08]
is. We'll walk
[4:10]
through the presentation
[4:11]
on the TV as well, but this
[4:13]
is the executive summary. So
[4:14]
we did receive the renewal
[4:16]
from Dean, the health
[4:17]
insurance renewal from
[4:18]
Dean, and it came out
[4:19]
at 14.9%. And if you
[4:20]
remember, for those
[4:21]
of you that were
[4:22]
in the room last month,
[4:23]
we went
[4:24]
through how you're running
[4:25]
in terms
[4:26]
of medical loss ratio, your
[4:28]
experience, the high cost
[4:30]
claimants,
[4:31]
probably not surprised based
[4:32]
on that presentation a month
[4:33]
ago.
[4:34]
Right.
[4:35]
So, 14.9 weren't super
[4:36]
excited about that. I worked
[4:37]
with Anna, went back to Dean
[4:38]
and was able to
[4:39]
at least get 1 percentage
[4:40]
point off. So that is
[4:43]
depicted
[4:44]
on this screen here. The
[4:46]
other items that we talked
[4:49]
about last month were
[4:51]
strategic planning that we've
[4:53]
been working together on
[4:54]
in terms of rounding
[4:56]
out the benefit options
[4:58]
within the county. So we've
[4:59]
always had the traditional
[5:00]
low deductible option for
[5:02]
employees and it's always
[5:04]
been the desire to add to
[5:06]
that a high deductible health
[5:08]
plan that can be paired
[5:09]
with an HSA. So, we will show
[5:11]
you what that means
[5:12]
to the district, excuse me,
[5:14]
to the county as we walk
[5:16]
through here.
[5:18]
But any questions
[5:19]
on the executive summary
[5:21]
before we dive into the high
[5:22]
deductible health plan
[5:25]
options and what that looks
[5:26]
like in terms of modeling? I
[5:29]
know this is small. I
[5:30]
apologize.
[5:33]
>> So after the meeting,
[5:35]
I didn't want
[5:36]
to give you too much
[5:37]
in advance, but
[5:38]
after the meeting,
[5:39]
this is on. Everything
[5:41]
they're going to present is a
[5:42]
link via the website. So, we
[5:43]
will send this out
[5:44]
to the committee. So, you will
[5:45]
have all this information.
[5:46]
So don't take crazy notes.
[5:47]
We'll give this to you. We
[5:48]
just didn't want
[5:49]
to get you too far
[5:50]
on the leads before we could
[5:51]
give you a high level and run
[5:52]
through it first.
[5:53]
>> Yeah.
[5:54]
And I would say there's a
[5:55]
lot of information
[5:56]
on this link that will be
[5:57]
sent out to you. So, if you
[5:58]
have any questions,
[5:59]
feel free to reach out to
[6:00]
Hannah and the team. We're
[6:01]
happy to answer that. We'll
[6:02]
summarize all the information
[6:04]
here. And as I'm going fast,
[6:05]
I apologize. We will talk
[6:08]
about quickly. The dental
[6:09]
renewal came in at plus 6%.
[6:11]
And just as a reminder,
[6:14]
that is a voluntary plan. So
[6:15]
that's no financial impact
[6:17]
to the county, but we want
[6:20]
to at least let you know it's
[6:22]
a 6%. And I would say that's
[6:24]
very common right now
[6:26]
in the dental. We
[6:27]
talked a little bit about
[6:28]
that. I think last month,
[6:29]
dental,
[6:31]
we're seeing anywhere from 8
[6:32]
to 10% increases just based
[6:33]
on marketplace and inflation,
[6:34]
etc. So the voluntary dental
[6:38]
plan came in at 6%. Your
[6:40]
vision plan all the way
[6:42]
to the right is 0%. That is
[6:44]
in rate guarantee until 2030.
[6:46]
So those lines I just wanted
[6:48]
to chat about quick
[6:49]
before we move into,
[6:51]
obviously, the high end here,
[6:53]
the medical modeling and the
[6:55]
renewal.
[6:57]
>> And if you have additional
[6:58]
questions or you want
[6:59]
additional details on the
[7:00]
dental and vision renewals,
[7:01]
there are tabs
[7:02]
at the top that you can see.
[7:04]
When you get this,
[7:05]
you can read
[7:07]
through it all. There is a
[7:08]
ton of information on there
[7:09]
about how those plans are
[7:10]
running and whatnot. So
[7:11]
that's available to you
[7:13]
to review. But we know we
[7:15]
only have a short amount
[7:16]
of time, so we want to focus
[7:17]
on the medical today.
[7:20]
Okay.
[7:22]
So, we'll just really
[7:23]
quickly jump to this tab. We
[7:24]
kind of already talked
[7:25]
about it. Initial renewal is
[7:27]
a 14.9. Ryan was able to go
[7:28]
back and get a 13.9%
[7:29]
increase. Right here
[7:31]
in this box right there, you
[7:33]
can see the calculated
[7:35]
increase. So M3,
[7:39]
our actuarial analysis, our
[7:41]
risk management team puts
[7:42]
together an actuarial
[7:43]
analysis. So, we have what
[7:45]
your prior year renewal
[7:47]
calculated
[7:48]
at that means what Dean said,
[7:49]
hey,
[7:50]
this is what they deserve
[7:52]
for an increase. So, if you'll
[7:53]
remember, you got a 9.9 last
[7:55]
year. Dean really should have
[7:57]
given you a 27.84 just
[7:58]
because
[8:00]
of how you were running,
[8:02]
how the county was running,
[8:03]
I should say. So, they gave
[8:05]
you initial rate relief.
[8:07]
Same thing this year. 32.5 is
[8:08]
actually what was warranted.
[8:09]
They came out at the 14
[8:11]
point,
[8:12]
or they gave you 17.6% of
[8:13]
rate relief is what we call
[8:14]
it. And then the recommended
[8:16]
increase was what they put
[8:18]
out with the 14.9. We have
[8:22]
now gotten it down to 13.9.
[8:24]
And then this side right here
[8:26]
is what our risk management
[8:28]
actuaries calculated. We
[8:30]
would have said based
[8:32]
on how you're running,
[8:34]
it would be a 34.45. And then
[8:35]
the rate relief we would have
[8:38]
given you was a 9.43
[8:41]
for various factors,
[8:42]
credibility, things
[8:43]
like that. But then our final
[8:44]
renewal that,
[8:46]
like our actuary team
[8:47]
Sundays was a 25. So that
[8:49]
13.9 might seem like a lot,
[8:51]
but it's actually better than
[8:54]
what M3 would have calculated
[8:56]
as well. So we felt it was
[8:58]
fair for the market.
[9:01]
Any questions on that?
[9:04]
>> I have a question.
[9:05]
I know there's a lot
[9:06]
to that,
[9:08]
but how do they come up
[9:09]
with those figures? And how
[9:10]
did you come up
[9:11]
with your figures
[9:12]
before them?
[9:13]
>> Sure.
[9:14]
Great question.
[9:15]
>> That's a lot.
[9:16]
>> Yeah, it is a lot. So, and
[9:17]
we touched on this, I think,
[9:19]
last month, too. How carriers
[9:20]
look at this and evaluate
[9:21]
specific claims. So, they're
[9:22]
going
[9:24]
to calculate that based
[9:26]
on prior experience, based
[9:28]
on current experience. And
[9:29]
they can see when we chatted
[9:31]
about high cost claims and
[9:32]
known risk. Right. They know
[9:34]
what the prognosis
[9:35]
of that is. So, there's a lot
[9:37]
of variables going forward,
[9:39]
including the fact that they
[9:41]
have a hospital here. So, we
[9:44]
chatted about that as well.
[9:45]
Sauk county is an important
[9:47]
client to them. So, they're
[9:48]
not going
[9:50]
to release a 27.84%. They
[9:51]
know it's not viable
[9:52]
for you. But when they look
[9:54]
at that prior period,
[9:55]
current period,
[9:58]
and they walk that down,
[9:59]
they will come
[10:00]
to a business adjustment,
[10:01]
which is that rate relief
[10:03]
to get to that 14.9%. So
[10:06]
there's also the look
[10:07]
at their manual rates. So, if
[10:09]
it was just that plan design,
[10:11]
that $500 deductible plan
[10:12]
design that you currently
[10:14]
have here at the county,
[10:16]
what would that be manually?
[10:17]
And they'll compare that to
[10:18]
your actual experience as
[10:20]
well. There's a lot that goes
[10:21]
in there from an actuarial
[10:22]
standpoint.
[10:24]
>> I thought I heard you say
[10:25]
that they're going back
[10:26]
at what the county has
[10:27]
in the past.
[10:29]
Correct?
[10:30]
Are they also doing
[10:32]
comparison to other counties
[10:33]
and other organizations
[10:34]
similar size or is it mostly
[10:36]
just based on what Sauk
[10:37]
county is?
[10:38]
>> No, they'll look at their
[10:40]
pool performance as well.
[10:41]
So, you're in a pool
[10:43]
at deemed powered by
[10:44]
Medica.
[10:45]
Right.
[10:46]
And how is that pool
[10:47]
performing?
[10:48]
And the larger you are and
[10:50]
the longer you are
[10:51]
with a carrier, the more
[10:52]
credibility you have.
[10:54]
So, you're a fairly large
[10:55]
district and I don't have it
[10:56]
in front of me. The actual
[10:57]
exhibit. They'll give you
[10:59]
credibility to what Lex said
[11:00]
earlier. You're not
[11:02]
necessarily 100% credible,
[11:04]
or maybe you are,
[11:05]
I can't recall. And then they
[11:07]
would hunt. Your experience
[11:10]
is what they will go
[11:11]
off of. They won't compare
[11:13]
you to anything else because
[11:15]
they know you have enough
[11:16]
lives and they can trend that
[11:18]
forward
[11:19]
to how your performance is
[11:20]
with them,
[11:21]
if that makes sense. Okay, so
[11:22]
all the way to the right.
[11:26]
Lex mentioned the 34.45, the
[11:28]
9.43 initial rate relief and
[11:29]
the 25.02. How we come up
[11:31]
with that is we have about
[11:33]
1300 clients,
[11:36]
employee benefit clients
[11:38]
with health insurance
[11:39]
within the M3 family. So
[11:41]
that's all the benchmarking
[11:42]
in our data, if you will. So
[11:45]
that's aggregated and
[11:46]
averaged out and then the
[11:48]
actuaries do their math and
[11:50]
that's how they come up
[11:52]
with that. It's not perfect,
[11:55]
but it's generally speaking
[11:57]
client your size based
[11:58]
on your geography.
[12:01]
What are we seeing overall
[12:02]
in the book of business
[12:04]
for the most current period,
[12:05]
if you will.
[12:13]
>> So, we won't go through,
[12:14]
you know, the high cost
[12:15]
claims and stuff. We did that
[12:17]
last time for those
[12:18]
of you that were here. But
[12:19]
again you'll have that
[12:21]
information that you can kind
[12:22]
of look at when we talk
[12:23]
about that. Last time we were
[12:25]
here we talked
[12:26]
about how we were going
[12:28]
to go to market the different
[12:30]
options we had. Self funding,
[12:31]
ICHRA,
[12:32]
all those fun things. We
[12:33]
determined let's just stick
[12:34]
with fully insured because
[12:36]
that's what made sense
[12:37]
for your group
[12:38]
in the county. And so we did
[12:39]
and unfortunately all
[12:41]
of the plans or all
[12:43]
of the carriers that we went
[12:44]
to market for so Group
[12:46]
Health Cooperative, GHC,
[12:47]
WPS Health Solutions, WCAGHT
[12:49]
with is Wisconsin Counties
[12:50]
Association, Group Health
[12:53]
Trust and courts,
[12:55]
they all denied. Now courts,
[12:56]
I will say they really dated
[12:58]
a lot of back and forth
[13:00]
with us. We're really diving
[13:01]
into some things. We gave
[13:03]
them a lot of, you know,
[13:04]
we had a lot
[13:06]
of conversations
[13:07]
but ultimately none
[13:08]
of the carriers were able to
[13:09]
provide more competitive
[13:10]
rates than you have than your
[13:12]
renewal would be. So that's
[13:14]
why they declined quote.
[13:16]
>> Any questions
[13:19]
on the marketing
[13:20]
at all?
[13:30]
>> All right, I know there's
[13:32]
a ton of stuff on here,
[13:35]
but we'll walk you
[13:36]
through it and then
[13:38]
like I said, you guys will
[13:39]
get this and you can review
[13:40]
it on your own. Do you want
[13:41]
to start?
[13:43]
>> Yeah, sure.
[13:44]
So the table up top here
[13:45]
shows your current HMO spend.
[13:46]
That dark blue bar. Lex will
[13:47]
scroll over that and then
[13:49]
your renewal. So total
[13:50]
premium,
[13:51]
what that 13.9% results in.
[13:53]
And then what we did was we
[13:56]
asked Dean for some alternate
[13:58]
plan options knowing that we
[14:01]
would really like to offer
[14:03]
high deductible health plan
[14:06]
that could be paired
[14:08]
with an HSA. And so this
[14:09]
shows total premium at the
[14:10]
1700 53,500 single family
[14:13]
deductible HSA option, the
[14:14]
2000, 4000 option, 357 option
[14:15]
and then the 48 option
[14:17]
in a couple,
[14:18]
just a couple pieces
[14:20]
of information here. Option
[14:22]
117 53,500. That is the
[14:24]
minimum the IRS will allow
[14:27]
for deductibles that qualify
[14:31]
for HSAs. 2000, 4000. Very
[14:39]
common plan design if you
[14:41]
will, especially if you're
[14:43]
just thinking
[14:45]
about implementing an HSA.
[14:46]
And the reason for that is
[14:48]
every year the IRS will up
[14:50]
that minimum. So last year I
[14:51]
think it was $1,700 34. They
[14:53]
always up it like $50 a
[14:56]
single, $100 a family every
[14:58]
year. That happens when we
[15:01]
have clients
[15:02]
with more minimums. The
[15:05]
employees say, why are you
[15:06]
upping my deductible? It's
[15:08]
not us, it's the IRS. So our
[15:10]
strategy is always
[15:12]
to increase that a little bit
[15:14]
to 2,000, 4,000, so we get
[15:15]
away
[15:17]
from that minimum increase
[15:19]
from the IRS. So we really
[15:20]
focused on this 2000, $4,000
[15:22]
plan with Dean, if that makes
[15:23]
sense. So go ahead, Lex.
[15:28]
>> I was just going to say,
[15:29]
this chart right here,
[15:31]
all this is,
[15:32]
is it's just a chart version
[15:33]
of what's above. So we've
[15:34]
shown a lot
[15:36]
of it multiple ways
[15:37]
for people that like
[15:38]
to see it different ways.
[15:39]
Same thing with the point
[15:41]
of service plan. Exactly what
[15:42]
Ryan talked about. You have
[15:43]
10 people on the point
[15:45]
of service plan
[15:46]
with the county. So we,
[15:48]
for the purpose of this,
[15:49]
we really won't focus much
[15:50]
on the point
[15:51]
of service plan,
[15:52]
but that will continue
[15:53]
to be offered. That's not
[15:55]
going away way. It's just
[15:56]
there's only 10 people. So
[15:57]
it's minimal spend and it's
[15:58]
minimal. We'll talk about it.
[16:02]
>> I have a question.
[16:03]
>> Yeah, go ahead.
[16:04]
>> Thank you. I couldn't
[16:05]
actually see the numbers
[16:08]
of how much we'd be spending
[16:09]
for each of those plans,
[16:11]
but is that based on the
[16:13]
people who are currently
[16:14]
enrolled?
[16:16]
>> Yep.
[16:17]
So that's current
[16:18]
elections as of today,
[16:19]
or when we sent this over,
[16:20]
that your team provided us a
[16:21]
census and we sent that over.
[16:22]
And keep in mind,
[16:23]
on this tab, we're looking
[16:24]
at the total as a whole.
[16:28]
That's not just the county
[16:29]
spend. So the county pays 88%
[16:30]
of the HMO and 83
[16:33]
of the point of service. So
[16:38]
that breakdown is a little
[16:40]
bit further
[16:41]
in the presentation,
[16:43]
but this is looking at the
[16:44]
just the total premiums as a
[16:46]
whole. And on that,
[16:47]
on this page, this total
[16:49]
renewal annual and total
[16:52]
current annual, those numbers
[16:53]
include both employee and
[16:55]
employer contributions. So
[16:59]
that's a total combined
[17:01]
blended. But we'll get
[17:02]
to the breakdown here.
[17:04]
>> Yeah.
[17:08]
>> Okay, so this screen here,
[17:10]
what we did is very
[17:12]
conservative adoption
[17:13]
of the HSA. We don't think
[17:15]
that half
[17:17]
of your staff is going
[17:18]
to elect the HSA. It's just,
[17:20]
it's a different plan design.
[17:22]
You know, it's got different
[17:24]
nuances, if you will. So we
[17:26]
like
[17:27]
to be very conservative. If
[17:28]
we do implement an HDHP,
[17:30]
what does that mean? How does
[17:32]
it look? So on the left here
[17:34]
you can see 10% adoption.
[17:36]
What does that mean?
[17:38]
To your question, before we
[17:39]
showed that minus 7.04%
[17:41]
of that 2000, 4000. That's if
[17:43]
everybody goes
[17:44]
into that plan design,
[17:46]
it's not going to happen. So
[17:48]
10%, what is the result
[17:49]
for 10%?
[17:51]
You can see basically it is
[17:52]
$110,000 savings
[17:54]
to the county. And how we
[17:56]
derived at that is the
[17:59]
premium differential that
[18:00]
minus 7.04%.
[18:03]
But then we're going
[18:04]
to give the
[18:05]
employees an incentive
[18:06]
to enroll in this. Right.
[18:08]
It's an HSA qualified plan.
[18:10]
1500 per single, 2000 per
[18:12]
family, excuse me, 3000 per
[18:14]
family would go
[18:15]
into an HSA. The county would
[18:16]
contribute that to
[18:18]
their account. When you roll
[18:19]
all that up,
[18:20]
there still is a savings of
[18:22]
$110,000 to the county.
[18:26]
>> And keep in mind,
[18:27]
this modeling
[18:28]
on this page is based off
[18:29]
of 2000, $4,000 deductible
[18:31]
plan. And the we were kind
[18:32]
of our idea
[18:35]
behind why we decided
[18:37]
to do a $1500, $3000
[18:39]
contribution to the HSA is so
[18:41]
that the HSA plan would still
[18:43]
feel like your $500,000 plan.
[18:48]
Right.
[18:50]
So your deductible minus
[18:51]
the HRA contributions would
[18:52]
be about that. So we wanted
[18:55]
to keep it equitable.
[18:56]
But that said,
[18:57]
this is not set in stone
[18:58]
like Anna said. None
[19:00]
of this is set in stone.
[19:01]
This is just what we model
[19:02]
because that's what we're
[19:04]
seeing as far as
[19:05]
benchmarking. And that's what
[19:07]
people typically do first
[19:08]
year. Again, if we decide
[19:10]
to go down this route,
[19:11]
we can talk a lot more
[19:12]
about it, but we wouldn't
[19:13]
necessarily say that every
[19:14]
single year the county would
[19:17]
give 1500, 3000. It might just
[19:19]
be a first year. You give
[19:20]
that and then, you know,
[19:22]
going forward it's a little
[19:23]
bit less to adjustment.
[19:25]
That's, that's kind
[19:26]
of the strategy that we see
[19:27]
with a good number
[19:30]
of our clients that do roll
[19:32]
out a high deductible health
[19:33]
plan option is that maybe the
[19:35]
first year to help them seed
[19:37]
their HSA a little bit more?
[19:39]
Because those people that
[19:40]
don't use the doctor,
[19:41]
they're going
[19:42]
to have a nice slush fund
[19:43]
in their HSA that rolls
[19:44]
over year after year.
[19:45]
Because remember, it's not
[19:46]
like an FSA. It's their money
[19:47]
that they get
[19:48]
to keep and that will stay
[19:49]
in that account.
[19:51]
Yeah?
[19:53]
>> So you talked
[19:54]
about that 10% adoption,
[19:56]
meaning 10% of the employees
[19:58]
might do that. Is there a
[20:00]
profile of who does that?
[20:04]
>> I don't think that's
[20:05]
perfect. But in general,
[20:07]
I think we talked
[20:08]
about this last month is,
[20:09]
you know, it's individuals.
[20:10]
It might be the younger
[20:12]
generation that doesn't go
[20:13]
to the doctor that would
[20:15]
like their premiums
[20:16]
to be lower, but also would
[20:17]
like to save
[20:18]
for retirement. It could be
[20:19]
an older person that's close
[20:21]
to retirement that wants to
[20:22]
stock some money away as
[20:23]
well. It's just a general
[20:25]
rule of thumb, working
[20:26]
with our actuaries and Dean
[20:28]
Health plan, what they see
[20:30]
when clients implement this,
[20:32]
it's about 10% just across
[20:34]
the board. I don't think
[20:36]
there's really a profile
[20:37]
there in general,
[20:39]
generally speaking.
[20:48]
>> Okay, so we modeled it
[20:50]
10%, 20%, 30%. You can see
[20:51]
the more adoption,
[20:53]
the more savings.
[20:54]
Right.
[20:55]
That just makes sense. If
[20:57]
we scroll. Actually, we want
[20:59]
to go to the next page. So
[21:00]
this is where I think it's
[21:02]
going to answer a lot more
[21:03]
questions. So the first.
[21:06]
Sorry, the first over here
[21:08]
on the left in the red,
[21:09]
that's if nobody goes,
[21:11]
right? If we have nobody
[21:12]
to take you up on the offer
[21:14]
of the high deductible health
[21:16]
plan.
[21:17]
Right.
[21:18]
We know what your numbers
[21:19]
are.
[21:20]
Okay.
[23:46]
>> I bet 10% adoption
[23:47]
level, 110,000 savings is
[23:50]
that after factoring
[23:51]
in if we were to contribute
[23:53]
to an HSA for them?
[23:54]
>> That's factoring in that
[23:56]
15, 3 HSA.
[23:57]
>> Good question.
[24:00]
>> Yeah. So then if we go
[24:02]
down here, this is more ways
[24:04]
to show you this same stuff.
[24:07]
Right.
[24:08]
It's helpful to see HMO
[24:09]
point of service down here.
[24:16]
The combined total. So
[24:17]
assuming this is where I was
[24:18]
trying to get
[24:20]
to earlier was the combined.
[24:22]
If HMO and point
[24:23]
of service had 10%,
[24:25]
you'll see the savings
[24:26]
of the 110, 20%, 221 and then
[24:28]
the 30% is 3 times 37. That
[24:32]
was a lot.
[24:45]
>> I mean that is a lot.
[24:49]
>> It's a lot. And you know,
[24:50]
we opened with this. This is
[24:52]
a work in progress. We're
[24:53]
still working with Anna and
[24:54]
team, you know,
[24:55]
to model some options out
[24:57]
for the county.
[24:58]
But this is where we are
[24:59]
today with the renewal. We
[25:00]
didn't have any bidders right
[25:02]
from our marketing events.
[25:04]
So we do have options
[25:06]
within the deemed health
[25:07]
plan. But we wanted to show
[25:08]
you your current HMO and then
[25:10]
what it would look like
[25:12]
with the HSA plan as well.
[25:16]
So we'll continue
[25:17]
to do this based on the
[25:18]
conversation you all have and
[25:19]
support the county
[25:21]
in any way we can.
[25:25]
>> Why would there be no
[25:26]
bidders? What would be the
[25:27]
reasoning
[25:28]
for the no bidders?
[25:29]
>> They're looking at your
[25:31]
most recent experience and
[25:33]
then your prior experience.
[25:34]
And so when they put that
[25:36]
through their quoting system,
[25:38]
all things equal, I think
[25:40]
Lex said this, they can't
[25:42]
produce a competitive bid.
[25:44]
So then it's very industry
[25:47]
typical that they'll just
[25:49]
decline to quote. So all
[25:52]
those carriers that Lex
[25:54]
mentioned decline to quote,
[25:56]
but they're looking at the
[25:57]
county's specific experience.
[26:02]
Yeah, they will. Yep. Once
[26:07]
that renewal comes out,
[26:09]
it's shared with them. And
[26:10]
again that's industry
[26:13]
standard as well.
[26:15]
>> Any other questions?
[26:17]
>> I guess, thoughts on the
[26:19]
high deductible health plan?
[26:21]
Do we want to talk
[26:23]
about the ALTS to the HMO,
[26:25]
not the high deductible plan?
[26:29]
>> Yeah.
[26:30]
So we gave you a bunch
[26:32]
of information about high
[26:34]
deductible health plans.
[26:35]
Now, if you guys are like,
[26:36]
you know what,
[26:37]
we don't have the appetite
[26:38]
for that right now. We do
[26:39]
have other options
[26:40]
to tweak your current plan.
[26:42]
So that current $500,000
[26:43]
plan, we do have options
[26:46]
for that. So, yeah,
[26:48]
if we went to this plan,
[26:49]
increasing the deductible
[26:51]
slightly, $750 single, $1500
[26:53]
family,
[26:55]
then that would get you to
[26:57]
about 11.62%. So that would
[27:02]
drop it a few points down.
[27:05]
And then if you went
[27:06]
to alternate two,
[27:08]
that would be a 1,000,
[27:09]
$2,000 deductible,
[27:11]
which would get you
[27:12]
to a 9.17% increase. So what
[27:15]
we wanted to also show you is
[27:17]
our benchmarking. So M3,
[27:20]
we talk a lot about edge,
[27:22]
right? So our education and
[27:23]
government entities, we
[27:24]
pulled our benchmarking just
[27:26]
for that book of business.
[27:27]
So we have 223 plans
[27:29]
in that book of business.
[27:31]
You'll notice that where
[27:33]
you're at today, that $500
[27:34]
deductible, you're beating
[27:37]
out most of our book
[27:39]
of business. Right. There's
[27:41]
16% of our Edge clients
[27:43]
that are within that $500
[27:44]
deductible. And what we
[27:46]
suggested, all those plans
[27:49]
that we suggested would still
[27:52]
be less than the most
[27:55]
popular, if you will,
[27:58]
plan offering within our
[28:00]
Edge book. So typically we're
[28:01]
seeing between 1501-2000. So
[28:05]
you would either be at with
[28:06]
that high deductible health
[28:07]
plan or below with any of
[28:09]
those options that we talked
[28:11]
about. So Sauk county will
[28:12]
still keep their amazing
[28:13]
benefits that they have
[28:15]
with the medical,
[28:17]
but we understand that
[28:18]
at some point it may not be
[28:20]
affordable to the county or
[28:21]
their employees anymore. So
[28:23]
that's a lot to think about.
[28:27]
But I wanted
[28:29]
to make sure we kind
[28:30]
of talked about that. You can
[28:32]
see current is 500. Even if
[28:34]
you jump to the 1000, you're
[28:36]
still $1300
[28:37]
below the average deductible,
[28:40]
which is 2,300.
[28:48]
>> Yeah. And we could do
[28:50]
that.
[28:52]
>> Yes, correct.
[28:53]
>> What was the minimum
[28:55]
deductible you need for the
[28:56]
high deductible health plan?
[28:58]
>> Yep.
[29:00]
>> And one thing I will say,
[29:02]
the way the high deductible
[29:05]
health plan is set up,
[29:08]
the deductible and the max
[29:10]
out of pocket are the same
[29:11]
because there's 100%
[29:13]
coinsurance in network,
[29:15]
there's 100% co insurance.
[29:16]
So that means if you picked a
[29:17]
2, 4, right.
[29:18]
Like if you went to the 2.4
[29:19]
high deductible health plan,
[29:20]
that would mean that your
[29:22]
plan today would has a
[29:24]
$1,753,500 max out
[29:28]
of pocket. Your high
[29:29]
deductible health plan max
[29:30]
out of pocket will be
[29:32]
2,000, 4,000. So you'd be
[29:33]
250 and $500 more on the max
[29:35]
out of pocket. So even if you
[29:37]
move to the 750, 1500
[29:40]
out plan, the max out
[29:42]
of pocket is a 2, 4. So it
[29:44]
would kind of keep things a
[29:46]
little bit more
[29:47]
in line if you bumped up
[29:48]
to that 750, 1500. Not saying
[29:50]
that you have to. Right. But
[29:51]
if you were going
[29:52]
to implement a 2, 4, then it
[29:54]
would, you know,
[29:56]
it would be easier to say the
[29:57]
plans work differently.
[30:01]
Right.
[30:02]
On a high deductible
[30:03]
health plan, there's no CO
[30:04]
pays,
[30:06]
you're paying everything out
[30:07]
of pocket. But if you asked
[30:08]
all little bit earlier
[30:09]
about kind
[30:10]
of what's the profile maybe
[30:12]
of somebody that uses it,
[30:13]
somebody that is using their
[30:14]
plan and maxing
[30:17]
out their plan anyway,
[30:18]
they might take you up on the
[30:20]
HSA or the high deductible
[30:21]
plan with the HSA, because
[30:22]
that HSA contribution is
[30:23]
going to pay for their,
[30:24]
their deductible,
[30:25]
but it's also their max out
[30:26]
of pocket on a high
[30:27]
deductible plan.
[30:28]
>> I was thinking more
[30:29]
of it as compared to a weight
[30:31]
scale because if you're not
[30:32]
making a lot of money,
[30:33]
people tend
[30:34]
to take the lowest deduction.
[30:37]
But there are advantages to
[30:38]
the HSAs that you can take
[30:40]
advantage of,
[30:42]
but you also kind of need to
[30:43]
have a wage where you can
[30:44]
afford
[30:45]
to pay that bill.
[30:47]
>> Yep.
[30:48]
>> I guess that's kind
[30:49]
of what I was getting at. Is
[30:50]
there any kind of breakdown
[30:52]
in those categories?
[30:54]
>> I would also say though
[30:55]
that the high deductible
[30:56]
health plan,
[30:57]
that premium is lower. So, if
[30:58]
you are savvy enough
[30:59]
to say, okay. Let's say
[31:01]
there's a delta of $50 a
[31:03]
month,
[31:05]
I don't know what it is
[31:06]
off the top of my head of
[31:07]
$50 a month, if I say, okay,
[31:08]
I'm going to put that extra
[31:10]
$50 into my HSA,
[31:11]
then I save that for the
[31:13]
rainy day when I do have a
[31:15]
claim. If, you know, plus
[31:16]
what the county contributes
[31:20]
but again,
[31:21]
it's consumerism.
[31:23]
Right.
[31:24]
So, like you have
[31:25]
to be a good consumer.
[31:26]
But keep in mind on the high
[31:28]
deductible health plan, your
[31:29]
preventive visits are covered
[31:30]
at no cost as long as they're
[31:34]
preventive. You know how that
[31:35]
goes. So make sure they're
[31:37]
coded as preventive, but that
[31:38]
annual preventive visit is
[31:40]
covered. So if that's all
[31:41]
people are going to
[31:43]
in the doctor, you know,
[31:44]
maybe an urgent care visit,
[31:46]
you can use the telehealth
[31:49]
for certain things and that
[31:50]
will help cut back
[31:53]
on costs as well. So, it's
[31:54]
education, definitely.
[31:57]
>> Yeah. And kind of asking
[31:58]
what motivates people
[31:59]
to want
[32:00]
to get what plan?
[32:02]
>> It's a great question and
[32:03]
great point. I think it does
[32:04]
come down
[32:05]
to that premium too.
[32:06]
Right.
[32:07]
So that Lex's point,
[32:08]
that HDHP is going
[32:10]
to be much cheaper. So if you
[32:11]
did save that
[32:12]
into your HSA,
[32:14]
you're no worse,
[32:15]
worse off.
[32:16]
Right.
[32:17]
I always
[32:18]
describe it this way. I feel
[32:19]
like HSA plans are like pay
[32:20]
as you go where a traditional
[32:21]
plan is a prepaid plan.
[32:23]
Right.
[32:24]
You have those co pays,
[32:25]
you can predict that,
[32:27]
what that out
[32:28]
of pocket is. But
[32:29]
for those plans,
[32:30]
they're going
[32:31]
to be much more expensive.
[32:32]
So it all depends on when,
[32:33]
how the bath shakes out.
[32:35]
>> Do you guys have a tool
[32:37]
available where the employees
[32:39]
can go in and kind
[32:41]
of do some prediction
[32:42]
against that? And the reason
[32:43]
I ask is, you know,
[32:45]
my daughter started with her
[32:46]
company and so I was really.
[32:48]
Because she's generally
[32:50]
healthy. Right. Said hey,
[32:51]
you know, tried to point
[32:53]
out the advantages for her to
[32:54]
take the high deductible plan
[32:56]
and capitalize on being able
[33:00]
to save that HSA. Because if
[33:02]
she's healthy,
[33:03]
especially if you have no,
[33:05]
she's 24 years old,
[33:07]
maybe she doesn't use it
[33:08]
for 15, 16 years. She's
[33:10]
building that nest egg that
[33:11]
has a lot of flexibility
[33:12]
for her later in life.
[33:14]
Absolutely. You know, and she
[33:15]
was getting it right and I
[33:18]
think leaning towards that.
[33:20]
Then when her package came
[33:21]
out, she was able
[33:23]
to log online and we were
[33:24]
able
[33:25]
to do some real time go.
[33:26]
Okay, so you go in
[33:27]
for your physical, you do
[33:29]
this, you do that. Let's say
[33:30]
you have an accident,
[33:31]
you got to go
[33:32]
to the emergency room,
[33:33]
you could plug that all in
[33:35]
and came back and told her
[33:37]
what her out
[33:38]
of pocket costs were going
[33:39]
to be across the board
[33:40]
on three different plans,
[33:42]
which then really kind
[33:43]
of motivated her
[33:44]
to understand, you know,
[33:46]
some of the selection options
[33:47]
she had where she wanted
[33:48]
to go.
[33:50]
>> Yeah, it sounds to me,
[33:51]
that's a decision support
[33:52]
tool that's built
[33:54]
into maybe an HRIS system.
[33:55]
Now we're going to get
[33:57]
into all of our jargon
[33:58]
over here, but that's
[33:59]
probably what that is. I
[34:00]
would tell you that we don't
[34:02]
currently have something the
[34:03]
county doesn't currently
[34:04]
have something like that.
[34:06]
It's generally probably
[34:07]
harder to do with a provider
[34:09]
owned HMO. I would say you
[34:11]
could probably do it better
[34:12]
on the pharmacy side with
[34:13]
your pharmacies because
[34:16]
that's where the biggest
[34:18]
difference is. And in the
[34:20]
self funded market that's
[34:21]
it's easier to do because you
[34:23]
have a wider array
[34:25]
of providers to access.
[34:27]
In other words, an MRI,
[34:29]
an open MRI might be $595
[34:30]
versus here in town,
[34:32]
it might be $4,200. That's
[34:33]
where the consumerism comes
[34:35]
in. But that sounds like just
[34:36]
a decision support tool
[34:38]
that's out there and they're
[34:40]
helpful, super helpful.
[34:42]
But generally speaking, no,
[34:43]
we don't have anything
[34:46]
like that. And I would say if
[34:48]
you do have medical needs,
[34:50]
you can always access your
[34:51]
EOBs and kind of figure that
[34:53]
out on your own as well. I
[34:54]
know that's not probably the
[34:55]
answer you're looking for.
[34:58]
>> No, that's like. No. I was
[34:59]
just wondering because, you
[35:00]
know, and I understand, you
[35:03]
know, Sam's concern makes a
[35:04]
lot of sense.
[35:05]
Right.
[35:06]
You don't want lower wage
[35:07]
employees taking advantage
[35:08]
of it, particularly if they
[35:10]
do have health issues. You
[35:12]
want them to get a job.
[35:13]
>> Correct.
[35:14]
Yes.
[35:15]
>> But to the other side
[35:16]
of it, you have a young
[35:18]
healthy male or female that's
[35:19]
cruising
[35:21]
along and they're not going
[35:22]
to have a medical need
[35:24]
for another 20 years. That
[35:30]
high deductible plan is
[35:32]
really a great alternative.
[35:34]
>> It is,
[35:35]
I would say too... Sorry
[35:36]
to cut you off.
[35:37]
>> As long as the HS.
[35:38]
>> I would say that was part
[35:39]
of the strategy behind how we
[35:40]
design this, right?
[35:41]
With Hannah and team is,
[35:42]
is if you think about that
[35:44]
$2000, $4000 and what that
[35:45]
seeded HSA contribution is
[35:47]
at that 1500 or $3000, it
[35:49]
still feels
[35:52]
like your current plan
[35:53]
to a certain extent. So, you
[35:55]
can anticipate that even if
[35:57]
you have the worst year
[35:58]
out there, it's going
[36:00]
to cost you that $500 out
[36:02]
of pocket or you know,
[36:04]
that thousand for a family.
[36:06]
So I mean it's not just.
[36:08]
You're right,
[36:09]
there are a lot of
[36:10]
individuals that will just
[36:11]
choose the cheapest and they
[36:13]
don't know how it works. And
[36:14]
that's a situation that we
[36:15]
don't want to be in,
[36:16]
we would want
[36:17]
to do the education up front.
[36:18]
But still having that HSA
[36:20]
contribution really does
[36:21]
support that incentive
[36:23]
to increase participation
[36:25]
in that HDHP.
[36:28]
>> We don't necessarily have
[36:29]
a support tool where they
[36:30]
could go in and say, I take
[36:32]
this, I go
[36:33]
to the doctor this many
[36:34]
times. But we do have
[36:35]
modeling that we can put
[36:37]
together that says, okay,
[36:38]
I'm a low utilizer. I go in,
[36:40]
maybe I go in for my physical
[36:43]
and I maybe have an urgent
[36:44]
care visit or an office visit
[36:47]
a year. And then we can, we
[36:48]
can show how that would look
[36:49]
or
[36:52]
like a medium utilizer.
[36:53]
Like, okay, we all go in
[36:54]
for a preventive care. We
[36:55]
maybe have one ER visit here.
[36:59]
Two office visits. I'm
[37:00]
just spitballing here. And
[37:01]
then a high utilizer,
[37:04]
I take an expensive medicine,
[37:06]
I go into the doctor.
[37:07]
>> My FSA was gone
[37:10]
by the end of January.
[37:12]
>> Yeah, exactly. So keep
[37:14]
in mind it's easy
[37:16]
on the HMO. You're gonna hit
[37:18]
your max out of pocket, you
[37:19]
know what your maximum
[37:21]
exposure is. So it's easier
[37:23]
to model that way. And then
[37:25]
we can, you know, put
[37:26]
in the, whatever the HSA
[37:28]
contributions are. So we can
[37:30]
model that. It's just not
[37:33]
able to be customized by the
[37:34]
employee that would be
[37:35]
looking at it.
[37:36]
>> Sure. No, that would be a
[37:37]
great, I think. Supplement
[37:39]
when they roll these out. So
[37:47]
employees could see. Yeah, I
[37:49]
mean that's pretty educated
[37:51]
on their choices because a
[37:52]
lot
[37:54]
of them you say you didn't
[37:56]
get through the whole world
[37:57]
insurance you got to insure
[37:58]
and their eyes glazed over.
[38:01]
I didn't understand that
[38:02]
when I went to the pharmacy
[38:03]
on HDHP that it was going
[38:04]
to cost me $300
[38:05]
for my prescription.
[38:06]
Right.
[38:08]
I mean, those are the
[38:09]
biggest challenge or changes
[38:10]
I should say. When you look,
[38:11]
think about. There's no $1
[38:13]
coverage
[38:14]
on an HSA qualified plan
[38:16]
except for preventive care.
[38:19]
That includes pharmacy. So if
[38:20]
you're on a high end
[38:21]
specialty pharmacy or
[38:24]
prescription, sometimes it's
[38:25]
beneficial because you can
[38:27]
hit that max right away.
[38:28]
Other times it might not be
[38:29]
dependent
[38:30]
on the plan design.
[38:35]
>> Any other questions?
[38:37]
>> I have a question
[38:38]
about people be allowed to
[38:40]
pick what bank or place they
[38:43]
would hold their HSA or
[38:45]
would we suggest...
[38:48]
>> That would be
[38:49]
something we work
[38:50]
with the HR team on. So it's
[38:51]
easy from the employee
[38:53]
standpoint and the county
[38:56]
in terms of payroll
[38:58]
deductions and contributions
[38:59]
from the county.
[39:03]
>> So it's just most likely
[39:04]
as one.
[39:06]
>> Yeah. There's vendors out
[39:08]
there that make it super easy
[39:10]
on the consumer and the
[39:11]
client.
[39:12]
One of the most common is
[39:13]
I don't know if you've ever
[39:14]
dealt
[39:15]
with a company called task
[39:17]
out of Madison. They offer
[39:18]
both. So, you know, so
[39:21]
from our standpoint,
[39:23]
it's a one shop stop. So I
[39:24]
don't know if that's three
[39:26]
hazards.
[39:28]
>> Today, you have FSA
[39:30]
with EVC. EVC also does HS.
[39:32]
So that would be the route we
[39:33]
would probably suggest.
[39:34]
But again,
[39:35]
we haven't gotten that far
[39:36]
with all of that. But a Task
[39:37]
does a great job. EVC does a
[39:39]
great job. They do the same
[39:41]
stuff also both randomly
[39:42]
located in Madison and
[39:44]
Middleton. So we have the two
[39:47]
largest admin administrative
[39:48]
plan offerings.
[39:56]
>> But yeah,
[39:58]
we're not holding the money.
[39:59]
It's gone
[40:01]
to a certain part.
[40:02]
>> Any question?
[40:04]
>> Okay, well,
[40:06]
thank you very much.
[40:08]
>> Thanks
[40:09]
to getting the links
[40:10]
to the data.
[40:12]
>> Okay.
[40:14]
>> Yeah. If you have any
[40:15]
questions after that,
[40:16]
let us know.
[40:24]
>> All right, we'll move on
[40:25]
to 6B. Resolution
[40:26]
to purchase vehicle for the
[40:27]
ABRC transportation program
[40:28]
and amend the 2026 budget.
[40:32]
>> All right,
[40:36]
you're good.
[40:57]
>> All right, so for those
[40:58]
of you who don't know me,
[40:59]
I'm Quinn Haas. I'm the
[41:00]
director of the ADRC. Stacey
[41:01]
is my transportation
[41:03]
supervisor for the ADRC and
[41:06]
Troy Garwood is our
[41:07]
transportation coordinator.
[41:09]
So I brought them
[41:10]
with because they know more
[41:11]
about the transportation
[41:15]
program and the resolution.
[41:16]
But as you can tell, the
[41:17]
resolution has been brought
[41:18]
to you. And basically what
[41:20]
happens is we have,
[41:22]
I guess you would say,
[41:23]
a fleet
[41:24]
of vehicles that we utilize
[41:26]
to transport individuals
[41:28]
to medical appointments.
[41:31]
They have to be 60 and
[41:32]
over or have a disability.
[41:35]
And the way that our
[41:38]
transportation department
[41:40]
works is that Stacy applies
[41:43]
for two different grants
[41:44]
every year. One is a state
[41:48]
grant, 8521, and then the
[41:50]
5310 is a federal grant that
[41:51]
is administered
[41:53]
by the state. And there are
[41:55]
reports that are done
[41:56]
quarterly. And so
[41:57]
with our grant, a lot of
[42:00]
times we are allowed any
[42:02]
money that is not spent
[42:03]
throughout the year
[42:05]
can go
[42:06]
into our dot trust fund. And
[42:08]
that DOT trust fund can't
[42:09]
have more than $80,000 in it
[42:11]
at any given time. And so we
[42:15]
have been fortunate enough
[42:17]
that with our fleet
[42:18]
of vehicles that we use,
[42:20]
we have been able to,
[42:22]
when they meet,
[42:23]
what do you call it?
[42:25]
>> The end of useful life.
[42:27]
>> End of useful life that
[42:29]
they are sent to auction.
[42:31]
So Troy just sent one
[42:32]
of our vans to auction
[42:35]
because it had more than the
[42:38]
mileage that is considered
[42:39]
useful life. And so that's
[42:41]
still at auction rate
[42:44]
for another week or so. And
[42:45]
so whatever we get
[42:48]
from that then goes back
[42:50]
into our program.
[42:53]
But basically we took that
[42:54]
one
[42:56]
to auction and we had money
[42:57]
in our DOT trust fund. And so
[42:59]
we are looking
[43:00]
at replacing that vehicle.
[43:02]
And so that's what this
[43:04]
resolution is about. Again,
[43:05]
there is no additional tax
[43:06]
levy that we're asking. The
[43:08]
money comes
[43:10]
from our grants that go into
[43:12]
our DOT trust fund and then
[43:14]
we utilize that money
[43:15]
to purchase a new vehicle.
[43:17]
Troy does all
[43:19]
of the checking into vehicles
[43:21]
that are handicap accessible
[43:23]
and getting bids. So he
[43:24]
worked on that prior and then
[43:26]
that went
[43:27]
to our ADRC board. And so
[43:29]
they were able to see which
[43:30]
vans were looked at.
[43:32]
But we typically
[43:34]
like these vans the best.
[43:35]
Our drivers
[43:37]
like these vans the best.
[43:38]
They came in the best price.
[43:39]
But again, we did look
[43:41]
at other options. We work
[43:44]
with AMJ Mobility, which
[43:46]
helps to retrofit the vehicle
[43:48]
so they that they're
[43:50]
wheelchair accessible. And I
[43:52]
don't know you have anything
[43:55]
to add because again,
[43:57]
it's not my program.
[43:58]
>> Any questions?
[44:02]
>> No. I think I was on the
[44:04]
board when we approved this
[44:07]
vehicle.
[44:12]
>> That might have been time
[44:13]
to retire.
[44:18]
>> Your useful life is...
[44:21]
>> All right.
[44:23]
>> We have a motion and a
[44:26]
second final offer. Any other
[44:28]
discussion?
[44:32]
>> I did have one question
[44:33]
and I know because it's
[44:34]
specially equipped,
[44:36]
it's probably not worthy.
[44:38]
Is there any thought process
[44:39]
to turning these vehicles
[44:41]
over possibly a year older,
[44:42]
25,000 miles sooner, get a
[44:43]
little higher resale value
[44:45]
maybe, or practical. I know,
[44:48]
that's what I'm saying.
[44:50]
Because it's special
[44:52]
equipped. I don't know if we
[44:53]
would.
[44:55]
>> And just so I understand
[44:56]
what you're asking, selling
[44:57]
them earlier so we get more
[44:59]
money out
[45:00]
of them or trading them back,
[45:02]
that would be fine. I don't
[45:03]
think it would increase what
[45:04]
we get out
[45:05]
of them as opposed
[45:06]
to how much we get out of
[45:07]
them as far as revenue and
[45:08]
use.
[45:09]
>> Yeah, that's what I was
[45:10]
curious because I know like
[45:12]
with our squads, if you know,
[45:13]
we can dump one at 50,000
[45:14]
miles versus 75,000 miles,
[45:16]
they're significant.
[45:18]
>> And anecdotally the last
[45:20]
van we sold was about the
[45:22]
same mileage and we got
[45:23]
about 14,
[45:25]
for this one is going about
[45:27]
the same pace as the other
[45:29]
one did. We may not get as
[45:31]
much just because times are a
[45:32]
little different, but
[45:34]
it's a decent,
[45:36]
it's a worthwhile suggestion.
[45:40]
But we get a lot of life out
[45:41]
of these vans and trying
[45:42]
to buy one every, I mean
[45:45]
50,000 miles honestly.
[45:47]
>> Oh, I would say I was
[45:48]
thinking five years versus
[45:49]
seven years for example. So
[45:51]
is there is there value
[45:53]
in that or not?
[45:54]
>> And it all depends
[45:55]
on if we have money in our
[45:56]
DOT trust fund because again,
[45:57]
you know, not every
[45:59]
year do we have and these
[46:00]
vehicles are obviously quite
[46:02]
expensive, especially
[46:05]
after they have
[46:07]
to be retrofitted and all
[46:08]
of that. So that would be the
[46:09]
only other thought. We don't
[46:11]
always have the funds in our
[46:13]
DOT trust fund and we utilize
[46:14]
that so that there is no tax
[46:15]
levy used in order
[46:16]
to purchase these.
[46:19]
>> Cool.
[46:21]
>> All right.
[46:22]
Well, we have a motion and
[46:23]
a second. I'll call for
[46:24]
to vote. All those in favor
[46:25]
of sending the resolution
[46:29]
to purchase vehicle for the
[46:30]
ADRC transportation program
[46:31]
and amend the 2026 budget
[46:32]
to the county board. Please
[46:35]
say aye.
[46:36]
>> Aye.
[46:38]
>> Any opposed, same sign.
[46:40]
That passed unanimously.
[46:41]
>> Thank you.
[46:42]
>> Thank you.
[46:47]
>> All right. 6C,
[46:48]
presentation quarterly
[46:49]
accounts receivable reports.
[46:52]
>> So, the four departments
[46:54]
that we look at their
[46:55]
quarterly accounts receivable
[46:56]
are attached and granted
[46:57]
assets for their second
[46:58]
quarter of the year ending
[47:00]
June 30, 2026.
[47:05]
>> 6D. Budget Update.
[47:07]
>> I just wanted to give an
[47:18]
update of where we're at
[47:19]
with the budget. July 31st
[47:20]
was our deadline
[47:22]
for the departments to get in
[47:23]
their initial budget requests
[47:26]
and then last week and this
[47:28]
week as an admin team. So
[47:30]
Lisa, Anna, myself, Tara and
[47:32]
then Louis from our MIS
[47:34]
department have been sitting
[47:35]
down with the departments
[47:37]
individually going
[47:38]
over what they submitted,
[47:41]
just talking to them
[47:42]
about it. The plan is then to
[47:44]
bring everything together and
[47:45]
see where we're at. I will
[47:48]
say we got estimates
[47:49]
from the Department of
[47:51]
Revenue last week and I ran
[47:53]
estimated numbers. There's
[47:54]
the more of the details
[47:56]
of the numbers are on my
[47:58]
accounting monthly report
[48:00]
later in the agenda.
[48:01]
But I won't get
[48:02]
into all of the
[48:04]
numbers and the figures. But
[48:07]
the preliminary estimates
[48:09]
that we're getting from the
[48:10]
Department of Revenue for net
[48:12]
new construction increases
[48:16]
are not looking great. It's
[48:17]
down from prior years. So
[48:18]
we're looking at our tax levy
[48:19]
that we are not going
[48:20]
to be able
[48:21]
to increase it very much.
[48:22]
Maybe about 490,000. Again,
[48:23]
that's an estimate. Right now
[48:24]
we don't have the final
[48:25]
numbers, so I can't say if
[48:26]
that's the final number or
[48:27]
not yet. So just looking
[48:28]
at you know, we just heard
[48:29]
from the health insurance
[48:30]
increases there the
[48:32]
department asks that are
[48:33]
coming in. We're looking
[48:35]
at what we need to put
[48:37]
together. I think we're going
[48:38]
to start brainstorming some
[48:39]
ideas and putting it all
[48:40]
together before we bring the
[48:41]
full budget presentation
[48:42]
to you. But I just wanted
[48:44]
to let you know kind
[48:45]
of where we're
[48:46]
at right now. I don't know if
[48:48]
Lisa had anything she wanted
[48:49]
to add to it.
[48:51]
>> The bad news is?
[48:54]
>> This is the shocker
[48:55]
before the sheriff came in to
[48:58]
today because I hadn't looked
[48:59]
at the bottom line yet. We
[49:00]
have no union negotiated
[49:02]
contract yet, so to speak.
[49:04]
We are $10 million over what
[49:06]
we can actually levy right
[49:08]
now. So we are going to have
[49:10]
to make some pretty hard
[49:11]
choices, folks, going
[49:14]
into this next budget cycle.
[49:15]
Because when we look at the
[49:17]
revenues that we're allowed
[49:19]
to increase, we're talking to
[49:20]
folks that haven't touched
[49:22]
their fee schedule schedules
[49:24]
in 10 years to really start
[49:25]
to look at whether or not
[49:26]
we're covering our costs.
[49:28]
But trying to push sales tax
[49:31]
and interest investment. I
[49:33]
mean, we're getting to a
[49:34]
point where there's very
[49:36]
little we can pull out
[49:37]
of that anymore. So it is
[49:40]
going to be the departments
[49:42]
really starting to look
[49:43]
at their programs, their
[49:45]
services, us figuring
[49:47]
out if we can do some tweaks
[49:48]
with the health insurance.
[49:50]
Not really where I wanted
[49:53]
to hear we were this morning,
[49:55]
but I'm optimistic that we
[49:57]
will get there. I just think
[49:59]
we're going to have to be a
[50:00]
little creative and
[50:01]
innovative.
[50:05]
>> Any other budget update
[50:07]
questions? Thank you,
[50:11]
Stephanie.
[50:12]
>> So we've got
[50:16]
6E. Presentation of County
[50:17]
Financial Report.
[50:18]
>> Okay.
[50:20]
>> And those are attached
[50:21]
in Granicus. The first page
[50:23]
just has some notable lines
[50:24]
that we pull out. Those
[50:26]
numbers all look in line
[50:27]
with where we should be
[50:28]
at this time of the year.
[50:29]
The second page summarizes
[50:30]
sales tax. And Lisa touched
[50:31]
on a little bit. The May sales
[50:32]
tax figures we got
[50:34]
at the end of July. I was a
[50:36]
little disappointed. Those
[50:39]
didn't come in very good.
[50:42]
We're still slightly ahead
[50:43]
of where we were
[50:44]
at last year, but not much.
[50:46]
So I just don't know what
[50:47]
sales tax looks like. I mean,
[50:48]
we'll see how the rest
[50:49]
of the year goes. The sales
[50:50]
tax looks like it's kind
[50:51]
of leveling off. It's been
[50:53]
increasing quite a bit every
[50:54]
year since that Covid year.
[50:57]
That threw everything
[50:58]
in wrench and everything.
[50:59]
But I don't know,
[51:00]
sales tax right now is
[51:01]
looking
[51:02]
like it's staying kind
[51:03]
of steady with what it was
[51:04]
last year. I think interest
[51:06]
rates, this isn't
[51:07]
on this page, but I think
[51:08]
interest rates too are kind
[51:10]
of leveling off, hopefully
[51:11]
staying where they're at this
[51:12]
year and not dropping.
[51:13]
Moving on
[51:15]
to pages three and four.
[51:17]
This is looking at all the
[51:18]
revenues and expenses
[51:20]
by functional areas. Not a
[51:23]
lot outstanding here.
[51:26]
Again, our grant numbers,
[51:28]
grant revenues maybe don't
[51:30]
look so great compared
[51:32]
but that's a lot of times our
[51:33]
expense expenses are coming
[51:34]
in and then we have to apply
[51:36]
for the revenue afterwards.
[51:37]
So grants do always tend
[51:38]
to grant revenue always tends
[51:39]
to lag the expenses. And I
[51:40]
know like for example, well,
[51:51]
one thing like the license
[51:52]
and permits number for the
[51:54]
health and human service area
[51:56]
that looks ahead
[51:57]
of schedule.
[51:58]
But that's me mainly due to
[51:59]
annual food licenses are due
[52:01]
June 30th. So most of that
[52:03]
food licensing money that
[52:04]
comes in into that area has
[52:05]
already come in
[52:06]
for the year. So that's why
[52:07]
that line looks a little
[52:08]
ahead of schedule. And then
[52:12]
the last two pages is kind
[52:13]
of a breakdown more
[52:14]
by the department areas. And
[52:15]
nobody was really jumping
[52:16]
out at this point
[52:18]
of the year looking unusual.
[52:21]
So did anybody have any
[52:22]
questions
[52:23]
about financials.
[52:25]
>> Number 7. Personnel
[52:29]
Insurance Department?
[52:33]
Obviously you run with.
[52:36]
>> Sounds good.
[52:38]
>> So 7A is the safety
[52:40]
report. Busy
[52:42]
with safety. I will call out
[52:43]
that our property claims year
[52:45]
to date are a little high.
[52:47]
Seen that we've had eight
[52:48]
claims this year so far and
[52:50]
last year was nine and the
[52:51]
year before was ten. So we've
[52:53]
just had some unfortunate
[52:55]
incidents. We've hit two deer
[52:56]
with the sheriff's office.
[52:58]
So that was two
[53:00]
of the claims.
[53:01]
We had a couple plow
[53:02]
trucks that were hit.
[53:04]
Our plow trucks did not
[53:05]
hit. Our plow trucks were
[53:06]
hit. I just want
[53:07]
to very specify
[53:08]
in unfortunate circumstances.
[53:10]
That was two
[53:11]
of the highways. So we just
[53:13]
had some. The deers are kind
[53:15]
of a common thing, but the
[53:16]
highway trucks getting hit is
[53:17]
not common. So that's the
[53:20]
property claims continue
[53:21]
to work through those
[53:23]
liability claims. And then
[53:25]
the workers comp is kind
[53:26]
of trending. Not that I
[53:28]
wanted to trend, but I don't
[53:29]
see anything concerning
[53:31]
related to those numbers
[53:32]
at this point. And then 7B,
[53:36]
benefits report. Similar,
[53:38]
Just kind of trending where
[53:40]
we have been previously. We
[53:42]
did have a little jump in
[53:43]
healthcare center turnover
[53:44]
which caused
[53:46]
for our overall turnover
[53:48]
to increase a little bit.
[53:49]
But we're still sitting
[53:50]
at 10% year to date. We do
[53:51]
typically see some turnover
[53:52]
kind of
[53:53]
in the summer months. Just
[53:54]
with retirements and folks
[53:57]
changing jobs. It's a good
[53:58]
time to change jobs. I always
[53:59]
said that as a recruiter
[54:00]
because kids are out
[54:01]
of school and you can kind
[54:02]
of adjust and then get back
[54:03]
into the swing of things
[54:04]
before a kid get back
[54:06]
into school. And so summer
[54:07]
turnover,
[54:08]
there's always a little bit
[54:09]
of that that happens. And 7C
[54:12]
report is the rest
[54:15]
of the department report. So
[54:16]
recruitment numbers Working
[54:17]
through three open positions
[54:18]
right now with the county
[54:20]
excluding the health care
[54:22]
center. Page two
[54:23]
of that report. We did have a
[54:25]
little bit of health care
[54:26]
center turnover,
[54:28]
although we've had, as I
[54:29]
said, we've had some good
[54:31]
hires though too recently
[54:32]
for hires last month
[54:35]
to rehire. So busy
[54:37]
with recruitment. Busy
[54:38]
with some activities
[54:40]
for the employees. Page three
[54:41]
of that report. Have not had
[54:43]
any additional security
[54:44]
breaches and investigations
[54:45]
for this year. And our goals
[54:47]
are all
[54:48]
in progress.
[54:54]
Those are the big reports.
[54:57]
So, I just like
[54:58]
to pause. 7D budget report.
[55:00]
We're right where we should
[55:01]
be a little more than halfway
[55:02]
through the year,
[55:03]
so I don't have any concerns
[55:05]
with where our budget sits. I
[55:06]
do have an open risk safety
[55:07]
coordinator under that risk
[55:08]
management insurance piece.
[55:10]
So that position is mostly
[55:12]
vacant. She's working a
[55:14]
little bit still for me,
[55:16]
so that will continue
[55:17]
to trend a little bit lower
[55:18]
through the end of the year
[55:20]
just because we're gonna have
[55:21]
a vacancy for a bit. And then
[55:23]
the last, 7E, invoices.
[55:26]
Looking for approval
[55:27]
of invoices of $4,313.68
[55:29]
for this month.
[55:32]
>> Motion to approve.
[55:34]
>> Second.
[55:35]
>> Any questions?
[55:50]
>> Okay. All those in favor
[55:51]
of paying the invoices of
[55:52]
$4,313.68 say aye.
[55:55]
>> Aye.
[55:57]
>> Any oppose,
[55:58]
same sign.
[56:01]
>> Thank you, Anna.
[56:07]
>> All right. First is my
[56:09]
monthly report. We've just
[56:10]
been obviously busy with tax
[56:11]
collection and still continue
[56:12]
to work on tax foreclosure.
[56:14]
And then budget. Our average
[56:15]
rate
[56:17]
for investments has gone
[56:20]
down this year. There are
[56:21]
some shorter term investments
[56:24]
that are going up above 4,
[56:26]
but those are more of the 13
[56:27]
week Zoids. That's really
[56:29]
something we've been trying
[56:32]
to look for the 2027 budget,
[56:34]
but I just. Unless someone
[56:35]
has a globe that they can
[56:36]
tell me what's going
[56:38]
to happen. Magical.
[56:40]
Currently we have 1,008
[56:42]
parcels that I turned
[56:45]
delinquent, which equals
[56:47]
about 1.9 million. So
[56:49]
hopefully that number goes
[56:51]
down a little bit
[56:52]
before I do. Tax certificates
[56:54]
end of this month. Those
[56:56]
delinquent notices went
[56:58]
out this morning. So we'll be
[56:59]
fielding calls
[57:00]
for the next couple days.
[57:02]
Budget report. Everything
[57:04]
looks normal. Investments are
[57:06]
on pace for this year,
[57:08]
so we should be good with
[57:09]
that. I have the investment
[57:10]
report attached. And then my
[57:15]
final thing is my invoices,
[57:18]
which is always a fun month.
[57:20]
$47,262,871.64.
[57:27]
>> Any questions for
[57:28]
Jessica? I'll take a motion.
[57:30]
>> I will make a motion to
[57:32]
approve.
[57:37]
>> I was just going to say
[57:39]
the majority going right
[57:41]
across the table.
[57:44]
>> You called that.
[57:45]
>> Second.
[57:47]
>> All in favor of paying the
[57:48]
invoices in the amount of
[57:50]
$47, 262, 871.64.
[57:51]
Please say aye.
[57:59]
>> Aye.
[58:02]
>> Thank you.
[58:10]
>> So, my accounting update
[58:11]
is attached in Granicus.
[58:14]
We've been having a busy
[58:16]
month in July. On July 30,
[58:19]
the auditors released a clean
[58:21]
audit opinion. It's on the
[58:24]
website and I believe it was
[58:25]
Lisa sent that out to the all
[58:26]
the county board members
[58:28]
but it's also
[58:29]
on the website if you need
[58:30]
to look at that for our
[58:33]
2025 audit statements or
[58:34]
financial statements,
[58:36]
we've also been working on
[58:37]
this is a newer audit
[58:38]
requirement. The state DHS
[58:40]
requires nursing homes
[58:41]
to have another audit. So
[58:42]
we've been working on that
[58:43]
with our independent auditors
[58:45]
and along with the health
[58:46]
care center employees. And
[58:48]
then we've also been working
[58:49]
on getting ready for the
[58:50]
single audit which gets
[58:52]
released in the fall. So
[58:54]
we've been working on that.
[58:55]
And budget,
[58:57]
we've been getting really
[58:59]
busy in budget. Capital
[59:00]
improvement plan committee
[59:01]
met in July. I already kind
[59:03]
of mentioned I won't go
[59:04]
through these numbers there
[59:06]
in the report,
[59:07]
but I included numbers
[59:08]
in here that you can read
[59:09]
in your free time
[59:10]
about where we're looking
[59:11]
at our levy for the this year
[59:12]
and then upcoming. We just
[59:16]
have a lot more budget
[59:17]
to work on. And then I've got
[59:19]
my other numbers on there.
[59:20]
Nothing's out
[59:22]
of the ordinary
[59:25]
for the county update. Also
[59:26]
attached is my year to date
[59:28]
budget report that those
[59:29]
numbers for the accounting
[59:30]
department are also in line
[59:31]
with where we should be
[59:32]
at this time of year. Then
[59:33]
item 9B. Reviewing the
[59:35]
accounting department's
[59:37]
invoices are I have invoices
[59:38]
attached for $7,699.
[59:45]
>> Question?
[59:48]
>> Second.
[59:53]
>> Any questions for Stephanie
[59:54]
on any of that?
[59:55]
>> Sorry, who seconded?
[1:00:01]
>> So all those in favor
[1:00:02]
of paying the monthly invoice
[1:00:03]
in the amount of $7,699.
[1:00:06]
Please signify
[1:00:07]
by saying aye.
[1:00:08]
>> Aye.
[1:00:10]
>> Opposed, same sign.
[1:00:11]
Passes as well.
[1:00:14]
>> And then we also have
[1:00:15]
approval for the county board
[1:00:16]
and committee payments
[1:00:17]
in the amount of
[1:00:18]
$16,379.28.
[1:00:22]
>> Move to approve.
[1:00:23]
>> Second.
[1:00:25]
>> All those in favor of
[1:00:26]
paying the committee
[1:00:29]
payments, signify
[1:00:31]
by saying aye?
[1:00:33]
>> Aye.
[1:00:35]
>> Opposing, same sign. All
[1:00:38]
right, number 10, our next
[1:00:40]
meeting will be September 8th
[1:00:41]
at 4:30pm. Now, we'll go into
[1:00:45]
close session.
[1:00:47]
>> I'll move
[1:00:48]
to go close session.
[1:00:50]
>> Thank you, Supervisor.
[1:00:52]
>> For the record, we have
[1:00:54]
to read that.
[1:00:56]
>> Pardon me?
[1:00:57]
>> You have to read.
[1:00:58]
>> Oh, I have
[1:00:59]
to read it first?
[1:01:00]
>> Yes.
[1:01:01]
>> Thank you.
[1:01:02]
>> Sorry about that.
[1:01:03]
>> I jumped the gun.
[1:01:04]
>> It is anticipated that the
[1:01:05]
Finance, Personnel and
[1:01:06]
Insurance Committee may enter
[1:01:07]
into closed session pursuant
[1:01:08]
to Wis. Stats. S. 19.85 (1)
[1:01:09]
(e) Deliberating or
[1:01:12]
negotiating the purchasing
[1:01:14]
of public properties,
[1:01:15]
the investing
[1:01:17]
of public funds, or
[1:01:18]
conducting other specified
[1:01:19]
public business, whenever
[1:01:21]
competitive or bargaining
[1:01:22]
reasons require a closed
[1:01:23]
session. A roll call vote
[1:01:25]
will be taken to go
[1:01:26]
into closed session and
[1:01:27]
to return to open session.
[1:01:28]
So this is on the Approval
[1:01:30]
to Purchase Property at 515
[1:01:31]
Broadway Street, Baraboo, WI
[1:01:33]
53913.
[1:01:35]
>> Move to close session.
[1:01:36]
>> Thank you. I have a
[1:01:37]
motion.
[1:01:38]
>> I'll second.
[1:01:39]
>> Thank you. And we'll do a
[1:01:43]
roll call.
[1:01:48]
>> [ CALLING ROLL ]
[1:02:10]
>> [ MEETING ADJOURN ]