Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
These are YouTube's auto-generated captions, not a human transcript — expect occasional errors, especially with names and technical terms.
[0:47]
Heat. Heat.
[2:02]
Hey,
[2:16]
honey.
[4:47]
Heat. Heat.
[5:00]
to the limited formal meeting for the
[5:01]
Salic County, the Salic City Council. I
[5:03]
don't know what that came from.
[5:07]
That's embarrassing.
[5:10]
>> I um maybe it's because I said county
[5:12]
» I um maybe it's because I said county
[5:12]
too many times today. Um so, welcome to
[5:16]
today's meeting. We're happy uh to have
[5:19]
you here whether you are in person or
[5:21]
joining us online. Uh we hope that you
[5:24]
continue to participate in whichever
[5:25]
manner you feel the most comfortable.
[5:27]
Today we are convening a limited formal
[5:30]
meeting which means that this is not a
[5:31]
standard formal meeting. Uh on June
[5:34]
16th, 2026 we adopted an uh interim tax
[5:39]
levy an interim budget. Tonight, the
[5:42]
council needs to consider action on the
[5:44]
on the final step in the annual budget
[5:47]
process for the city final budget
[5:50]
adoption and truth and taxation hearing
[5:52]
required by state law. Um, a truth and
[5:56]
taxation hearing happens when any of the
[5:59]
following takes place. The city raises
[6:01]
property taxes, property tax
[6:04]
stabilization, and judgment levy. The
[6:07]
city is adopting a property tax increase
[6:10]
to provide 13 uh,500,000
[6:15]
of additional atalum tax revenue
[6:18]
generated by the 9.16%
[6:22]
property tax increase. Additional tax
[6:26]
revenue is required for the city
[6:28]
operations outlined in the property tax
[6:31]
impact schedule including but not
[6:34]
limited into public safety, public
[6:36]
lands, youth and family programming,
[6:40]
public utility matters matters and the
[6:42]
city vehicle fleet maintenance.
[6:46]
Although the hearing is a formal step
[6:48]
required by state
[6:50]
by the state, the council is always
[6:52]
interested in hearing from the council.
[6:54]
Feedback from the public helps the
[6:56]
council make decisions in future budgets
[6:58]
or even amendments to this year's
[7:01]
budget. If you would like additional
[7:03]
information regarding the property tax
[7:05]
assessment, please visit the South Lake
[7:07]
County Treasurers website
[7:09]
www.saltcount.govtreasurer/
[7:13]
GV/treasurer/propy
[7:16]
taxes. Now, please join us for the
[7:20]
pledge of allegiance.
[7:25]
I aliance to the flag of the United
[7:28]
States of America and to the republic
[7:31]
for which it stands. One nation under
[7:34]
God, indivisible with liberty and
[7:37]
justice for all.
[7:40]
>> Thank you. Before we continue through
[7:43]
» Thank you. Before we continue through
[7:43]
the agenda, I want to quickly go through
[7:45]
the registration information
[7:47]
and share the reasoning about how and
[7:50]
why we chair these meetings the way we
[7:51]
do. We welcome everyone regardless of
[7:54]
your opinion or your side on an issue
[7:58]
because we will have people from varying
[8:00]
positions on important issues. The
[8:02]
council goal is to make the meeting a
[8:04]
place where where people feel safe and
[8:07]
comfortable participating. This is the
[8:09]
most local level of government and is a
[8:12]
key value of ours to ensure that we have
[8:14]
created a respectful and safe
[8:15]
environment so that no one is
[8:18]
intimidated out of free participation.
[8:21]
This also allows us to ensure that the
[8:24]
meeting can continue and that we can
[8:26]
conduct the schedule city business. We
[8:29]
invite each of you to contribute to this
[8:31]
space to speak your mind and to welcome
[8:34]
others do the same. In order to create
[8:37]
this welcome welcoming and safe space,
[8:40]
we will pause the meeting at any action
[8:43]
that causes a disruption to our ability
[8:45]
to conduct the meeting or any safety
[8:48]
concern involving threats or unprotected
[8:51]
speech. If there are repeated actions or
[8:54]
comments, it may result in the rem
[8:57]
removal from the meeting. To avoid
[8:59]
intimidating others, please avoid the
[9:02]
use of threatening and discriminatory
[9:04]
language. Do not insult others based on
[9:06]
religion, ethnicity, race, color,
[9:10]
gender, sexual orientation, or physical
[9:13]
ability. Whether you agree or disagree
[9:16]
with someone's comment,
[9:18]
clapping, cheering, shouting, booing,
[9:21]
snapping, gesturing, obstructing, or
[9:24]
discouraging others from commenting is
[9:27]
not allowed.
[9:29]
Just as a reminder, council members will
[9:32]
refrain from reacting or responding to
[9:34]
allow everyone to share their opinions
[9:37]
freely. This is to keep our reactions
[9:39]
from affecting your ability to share
[9:42]
your opinion freely. If you would like
[9:44]
to follow up with any of us, please see
[9:46]
council staff in this in this room or
[9:49]
you can message in zoom uh for contact
[9:52]
information. When making your comments,
[9:54]
please address the body and know an
[9:57]
individual elected official. If you have
[9:59]
a handout for the council, please raise
[10:02]
your hand and council will assist you.
[10:05]
Um staff is available during the meeting
[10:07]
and after too. Uh so if you have
[10:09]
questions or information that you you
[10:12]
seek uh if you want the council rules
[10:15]
that are posted on the chat and that are
[10:17]
also posted outside this room. Um just
[10:21]
as a reminder uh our public comment
[10:23]
registration process. Individuals might
[10:25]
register to comment on scheduled public
[10:28]
hearing items until the hearing is
[10:30]
closed. If you're in Zoom, you need to
[10:34]
unm unmute your microphone when your
[10:37]
name is called. Each person will have
[10:39]
two minutes. If you reach the two-minute
[10:42]
mark, the host will announce time and
[10:45]
your microphone will be muted. We'll be
[10:48]
calling those uh register in the order
[10:52]
of sign up. If you need assistance in
[10:55]
the room right here, please raise your
[10:57]
hand. Staff will assist you. If you need
[11:00]
assistance when you're online, contact
[11:02]
the administrator of the meeting and
[11:04]
they will assist you. If you have
[11:06]
technical issues, staff support and zoom
[11:09]
can assist you. Uh and that's ash from
[11:12]
our staff.
[11:14]
Just if you're able if you're not able
[11:16]
to share all your comment in those two
[11:18]
minutes, um you can send us the rest of
[11:21]
the comment uh via email. You can also
[11:24]
mail it to us. Um, and the contact
[11:27]
information for that is at
[11:29]
slc.govcounsel.
[11:32]
If you have a handout, please notify the
[11:34]
council staff uh before uh you begin.
[11:37]
So, let's uh begin with the the item on
[11:40]
the agenda, which is uh the truth in
[11:42]
taxation public hearing for fiscal year
[11:45]
2026 2027.
[11:48]
Um, before we begin taking comments, I'm
[11:51]
going to turn the time to Jennifer
[11:52]
Bruno, Council Executive Director, to
[11:54]
give us a short introduction. Jen, thank
[11:57]
you, Mr. Chair. Um, as you mentioned,
[11:59]
we're having a truth and taxation
[12:01]
hearing tonight as a requirement of
[12:03]
state law based on the proposed interim
[12:06]
fiscal year 2027 budget, which includes
[12:10]
$13.5 million in additional property tax
[12:12]
revenue. Uh the property tax impact
[12:15]
schedule which lists all of the proposed
[12:18]
uses for the proposed tax increase is on
[12:20]
our council website at
[12:22]
link.slc.govslcfy27.
[12:27]
Thank you.
[12:29]
>> Thank you Jennifer. Um
[12:32]
» Thank you Jennifer. Um
[12:32]
Isaac, please start with our first
[12:33]
public comment.
[12:36]
>> Thank you Mr. Chair. We have four people
[12:37]
» Thank you Mr. Chair. We have four people
[12:37]
registered to speak to this item. The
[12:39]
first will be Brooke Brin, followed by
[12:41]
Eric Miller, and then Susanna Arguo.
[12:45]
>> Um, so
[12:49]
I bought my house 1990 on the budget.
[12:53]
Let's move on quickly to the water bills
[12:56]
and the city bills.
[12:59]
In 2005, I paid
[13:03]
26, let's see,
[13:08]
$26.50
[13:11]
in the winter time for my bill. This
[13:15]
last month year,
[13:18]
$136.
[13:20]
It's up 523%.
[13:23]
In the summertime
[13:26]
in 2025, I paid a little over $40 for my
[13:29]
water bill. This year,
[13:33]
167 plus, up 417%.
[13:39]
I paid I used 30% less water this year
[13:43]
in June, 34% less in July, and I paid
[13:48]
more for both
[13:51]
>> time
[13:55]
Thank you.
[13:58]
Just as a reminder, please uh if you
[14:00]
haven't been able to finish your comment
[14:02]
and the two minutes, please make it uh
[14:05]
you have an opportunity to share with
[14:06]
staff to make it to us. Next comment
[14:10]
>> next will be Susanna Argu followed by R.
[14:13]
» next will be Susanna Argu followed by R.
[14:13]
Scott Birdsaw and then back to Brooke
[14:16]
Bren. Susanna is here in person.
[14:19]
>> Thank you to all. My name is Susan
[14:21]
» Thank you to all. My name is Susan
[14:22]
Arillio and I'm really happy to come to
[14:25]
again to Sole City, my favorite city
[14:28]
after I visit so many states because the
[14:31]
culture, the cleanness of the city, our
[14:35]
people, our government and diversity.
[14:40]
I I can tell you increasing the property
[14:43]
taxes will not be good at all. We know
[14:47]
that the increase of everything is up.
[14:50]
everything. But if we do that, many
[14:53]
people will decline in many ways. Will
[14:56]
it be poverty so much? Probably we can
[14:59]
reach 100% poverty plus and no able to
[15:06]
you know have the education that we
[15:07]
needed because we are paying the
[15:09]
property taxes. When that happen affect
[15:12]
everybody. The people who are renting
[15:15]
the places who already at this moment
[15:19]
they are facing so much struggles by
[15:22]
myself for instance you know I have my
[15:25]
degree I should be in better position
[15:28]
but what is going on right now I cannot
[15:30]
handle the financials right now because
[15:33]
everything is expensive. You can imagine
[15:36]
how much is increase in property. So the
[15:38]
owners of the property also increase the
[15:40]
rent. So I don't think so is is good to
[15:44]
do that because everything will be
[15:46]
increased. Our city that is wonderful
[15:48]
many people coming over the world to
[15:50]
live here because they say oh here is
[15:52]
amazing because they coming and see that
[15:54]
everything they can buy it. many people
[15:56]
from California scares thousands of
[15:58]
people but I believe that the government
[16:01]
do should do something because anything
[16:04]
is not anything about money is about the
[16:07]
good living to have good society
[16:11]
to care about people because we need a
[16:14]
good government that they can start up
[16:17]
for the people who really need it. Thank
[16:19]
you.
[16:22]
Next will be R. Scott Birdsaw followed
[16:24]
by Brooke Brin. R. Scott is here in
[16:27]
person.
[16:30]
Okay. So, I'm supposed to tell you my
[16:32]
name, R. Scott Birdsaw, and I live in
[16:34]
Mapleton, so I'm being taxed here
[16:36]
without representation.
[16:39]
Um,
[16:42]
I would really like to know why. I
[16:44]
didn't even realize this this is about a
[16:46]
water allocation if that's what it is.
[16:48]
I'm just going by what I was told on my
[16:50]
tax bill or my estimated tax bill that
[16:53]
just recently came.
[16:55]
I just don't understand why anything
[16:57]
needs to increase by 12% from one year
[17:00]
to the next.
[17:02]
And if you guys have got some material
[17:05]
for me to review, maybe it makes sense.
[17:08]
But at this point,
[17:11]
the fact that I get a notice from the
[17:13]
the tax collector
[17:16]
and I don't even know exactly what
[17:19]
category, it just says Salt Lake City is
[17:22]
going up 12%.
[17:24]
And there's also a uh
[17:27]
an issue for a what does it say? A
[17:30]
judgment levy that's being created out
[17:32]
of whole cloth. I don't know what that's
[17:34]
about either. It would be nice if we
[17:37]
knew those things and then maybe we
[17:40]
could discuss them, but it sounds like a
[17:42]
decision is about to be made without me
[17:45]
knowing anything about what the decision
[17:47]
really involves.
[17:53]
» And next will be Brook Brin who is here
[17:55]
in person.
[18:00]
I'm Brooke Bren, a mother sold bread
[18:03]
maker and homeowner in Rose Park.
[18:06]
Despite my family's economic
[18:07]
desperation, I currently have $25 in my
[18:10]
bank account. I'm not here to complain
[18:12]
about the increased taxes. I'm here
[18:15]
because I feel trust has been betrayed.
[18:21]
I want to trust the city.
[18:24]
If there was a way, I would want to
[18:26]
donate.
[18:30]
But the budget betrays the city's trust
[18:32]
in three major ways.
[18:35]
Matt, uh, the most significant tax
[18:37]
increases, police,
[18:40]
uh, not tax, budget increases, the
[18:42]
increased budget feels like it's paired
[18:44]
with the increased taxes. So, uh,
[18:46]
police, mass surveillance, and the
[18:48]
justice system. We have a 5% increase to
[18:51]
the police budget, which is one of the
[18:53]
most significant sections of the city
[18:57]
budget. Uh, living in Rose Park, many of
[18:59]
my law-abiding neighbors fear the
[19:00]
police. I was confused by that for a
[19:03]
while until I realized that a lot of my
[19:04]
high school bullies are cops.
[19:09]
And then I saw that cops are about twice
[19:10]
as likely to beat their wives. I can't
[19:13]
help but wonder how many cops enjoy the
[19:15]
violence and their qualified immunity.
[19:18]
About $500,000 of that police budget
[19:21]
will increase
[19:23]
um the funding to flock cameras. Why are
[19:25]
we handing the reigns of mass
[19:26]
surveillance over to known abusers?
[19:29]
We already hear stories of cops using it
[19:31]
to stalk their exes.
[19:34]
Besides, I thought a hearing for this
[19:37]
was scheduled for September 15th.
[19:40]
Is that hearing simply theater?
[19:43]
Have you already decided?
[19:45]
There's a bunch more, but
[19:48]
please, if you're not going to allocate
[19:50]
the funds yourselves, allow people who
[19:53]
care to donate.
[19:58]
That was the final register commenter
[19:59]
for this item.
[20:10]
» Thank you all of those that made
[20:12]
comments. Uh, and I need a motion.
[20:17]
» Mr. Chair, I move that the council close
[20:18]
the public hearing and adopt an
[20:19]
ordinance approving the final tax final
[20:22]
rate of tax levy for all city funds,
[20:24]
including the library fund on all real
[20:27]
and personal property within Salt Lake
[20:29]
City, made taxable by law for fiscal
[20:31]
year 2026 27.
[20:35]
» Second.
[20:36]
>> Council member Dugan for the motion and
[20:38]
» Council member Dugan for the motion and
[20:38]
council member Petro for the second. Um,
[20:41]
is there any discussion?
[20:45]
Council member W.
[20:47]
just appreciate the people who came out
[20:49]
to speak. Um we did in the our budget
[20:53]
adoption t adopting the tenative budget
[20:56]
talked a lot about um the issues facing
[20:59]
the city, the affordability issues that
[21:01]
we're facing. Um I don't want to repeat
[21:04]
those. Um those are are part of the
[21:06]
public record from the last meeting. I
[21:07]
hope that you'll take a minute to listen
[21:09]
to them. I'm also willing to stay and
[21:12]
answer a few questions um after this
[21:14]
meeting. People have them. Thank you.
[21:18]
>> I
[21:20]
» I
[21:20]
thank you for for for your comments, uh,
[21:22]
Council Member Warden. I I do want to
[21:25]
run down, um, you know, that this and I
[21:28]
know that for the discussions, uh, to
[21:32]
the lengthy discussions this year on the
[21:34]
budget, um, they were not easy. Um, I'm
[21:37]
trying to, uh, balance the budget with
[21:40]
less revenue and increasing cost. And I
[21:43]
remember some of the facts and I was
[21:45]
trying to look at them because they were
[21:46]
so shocking. Um the the you know asphalt
[21:49]
that everybody you know is asking us all
[21:52]
the time for better streets used to cost
[21:55]
$44 a ton in 2020 and now it cost you
[21:58]
know $64 a ton right for us. Um and the
[22:02]
the the price of gas for our own
[22:05]
vehicles um has increased and the cost
[22:08]
of equipment for firefighters you know
[22:10]
went up a third. Um and then trying to
[22:15]
balance the needs of a growing city with
[22:17]
less revenue uh created a lot of
[22:21]
you know created uh constraints and and
[22:24]
uh competing uh competing needs. Um, and
[22:28]
I I do appreciate the administration and
[22:31]
and pretty much fi finding, you know,
[22:33]
$13 million in savings and and looking
[22:37]
into every single department and trying
[22:39]
to reduce the budget to see if we can
[22:42]
make it without an increase. Um, and and
[22:47]
uh, you know, it turned out to be that
[22:49]
it was not possible with with the budget
[22:52]
that we had in front of us. and and um
[22:56]
there is the impact to all of our
[22:57]
neighbors is heavy. Um and I don't think
[23:00]
anybody here took it lightly. Um and if
[23:02]
the many discussions we had in the last
[23:04]
few months, uh there are public records
[23:06]
of them. Um we we we struggle a lot in
[23:10]
trying to find consensus and find a
[23:12]
budget that makes sense. Um and uh I um
[23:16]
I appreciate the discussions and it's
[23:18]
not lost on on any of us and certainly
[23:20]
not not to me about how hard it is to
[23:23]
make ends meet uh in in this in this uh
[23:27]
time. So I wanted to end with that at
[23:30]
least for me. Um I uh I appreciate
[23:33]
everybody. I have a motion by council
[23:35]
member Dugan and a second by council
[23:37]
member Petro. All those in favor say I.
[23:39]
I.
[23:40]
>> I.
[23:41]
» I.
[23:41]
>> Any oppose? Any abstensions?
[23:45]
» Any oppose? Any abstensions?
[23:45]
Okay, this motion carries unanimously.
[23:48]
This concludes our limited formal city
[23:49]
council meeting. This meeting now is
[23:51]
adjourned.
[23:53]
>> Now is not adjourned.
[24:24]
Council close the public hearing and
[24:26]
adopt an ordinance approving the final
[24:28]
budget for Salt Lake City for fiscal
[24:30]
year 2026 2027, including the property
[24:34]
tax increase outlined in the property
[24:35]
tax impact schedule. The final budget
[24:38]
action includes a tax rate adjustment
[24:40]
exceeding the certified tax rate and
[24:43]
will release revenue funds received
[24:44]
through the tax rate increase from the
[24:47]
restricted fund created at the time of
[24:49]
the interim budget adoption.
[24:52]
>> Second. I have a motion by council
[24:54]
» Second. I have a motion by council
[24:54]
member Warden and a second by council
[24:56]
member Dugan. Is there any discussion?
[25:02]
» Going to call the question. All those in
[25:03]
favor say I.
[25:04]
>> I.
[25:04]
» I.
[25:04]
>> I.
[25:05]
» I.
[25:05]
>> Any oppose? Any abstensions?
[25:09]
» Any oppose? Any abstensions?
[25:09]
This motion carries unanimously. Sorry
[25:11]
for the confusion. This is a new
[25:13]
process. It's a new process that the
[25:15]
state has required us to do right now.
[25:17]
So I um it's my fault for not paying
[25:20]
attention. So um that motion carries
[25:23]
unanimously.
[25:25]
Uh and now uh this time is correct. This
[25:29]
concludes our limited formal city
[25:30]
council meeting. This meeting now stands
[25:32]
adjourned.