10 06 2026 City Council

South Lake Tahoe, CA · · More South Lake Tahoe, CA meetings · More California meetings

Transcript

Download: Text · SRT
AI TRANSCRIPT

This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.

[23:09] Before we call this meeting to order, we will hear instruction on how the public may access Spanish interpretation.
[23:16] Thank you. The following message will repeat in Spanish.
[23:20] We are offering live interpretation into Spanish in our some platform.
[23:24] To access this Spanish channel, press the more option at the bottom of your screen, select interpretation and choose Spanish.
[23:31] If you join in the ASUS smartphone app, select your language by clicking more, or the three dots at the bottom of your screen, select the language interpretation and choose Spanish.
[23:43] Bienvenidos, estamos of rescindos interpretación en español en vivo y indirecto en la plataforma Zoom.
[23:50] Para tener acceso a la interpretación o prima la opción de moro o más al pie de su pantalla.
[23:56] Seleccione interpretación y pulse español o espanese con su formato para activar su canal.
[24:04] Si está unido se asume su teléfono inteligente, seleccione la opción de moro o más.
[24:11] Interpretation, Pulse's, Paniol, or Spanish,
[24:13] will be a form of Dota Rai Pivar, Sukanal.
[24:16] Much gracias.
[24:18] Thank you, back to you.
[24:20] Thank you.
[24:20] Recording in progress.
[24:22] We'll move on and start with our land acknowledgement.
[24:24] The city of South Lake Tahoe acknowledges the lands we occupy today
[24:27] or the lands in the home of the Washoe shoe.
[24:29] The people from here and on today is the Washoe tribe of Nevada and California.
[24:32] A sovereign nation.
[24:33] Since the beginning of time and for thousands of years before the arrival of any other people,
[24:37] the washer lived here and cared for this place. With values and intention that we can all
[24:41] learn from on behalf of the City Council, I would like to acknowledge thank and honor the Indigenous
[24:46] washer tribal communities that are the past, present and future stewards of the Lake Tahoe Basin.
[24:51] And with that, before we open for our call to order, I would like to introduce Miss Christine Malakop,
[24:57] she will be sitting in for Sergio tonight as our...
[25:00] So thank you for being here.
[25:08] Great. With that, we will call this meeting to order and move on to our pledge of allegiance.
[25:13] to the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under
[25:22] God, in the fiscal, with liberty and justice for all.
[25:29] Ms. Boyne can ship, excuse me, Ms. Carpenter, can we get a roll call?
[25:32] Yes, of course. Council Member Horton. Here, Council Member Jenkins.
[25:38] Council Member Robin. Here. Mayor Protem Roberts.
[25:41] Here. Mayor Bass. All present.
[25:43] Great. And a closed session report.
[25:46] do we have any in close session report?
[25:48] Mayor, there is no reportable action.
[25:51] All right.
[25:52] With that, we are going to move on to our proclamations.
[25:54] We have a proclamation this week for fire prevention week.
[25:58] And we are also going to have a proclamation for excuse me, because it's not on my national domestic violence awareness month.
[26:06] So we'll go ahead and start with fire prevention week.
[26:12] Chief Copen, would you accept the proclamation from the mayor, please?
[26:35] The city of South Lake Tahoe is committed to ensuring the safety and scrutiny of all those living and visiting
[26:40] South Lake Tahoe, and whereas fire remains a serious public safety concern both locally and nationally,
[26:46] and the presence of lithium ion batteries and many household devices introduce fire risk,
[26:50] and whereas most of the rechargeable electronics used in homes daily, including smartphones, tablets,
[26:55] lab-toff's power tools, e-bikes, e-scooters, antlers are powered by lithium-ion batteries,
[27:02] which if misused damage or improperly charged can overheat, start a fire, or explode.
[27:07] And whereas the National Fire Protection Association reports an increase in battery-related
[27:12] fires, underscoring the need for public education on the safe use of lithium-ion batteries
[27:16] and devices.
[27:17] And whereas the way lithium-ion batteries devices are charged can make a difference in
[27:21] helping prevent home fires, and whereas safe charging includes using the cord and charger
[27:26] that came with your device or won't approve by the manufacturer.
[27:30] Charging on a hard, flat surface, watching food, signs like devices that are very hot
[27:35] or start or swell.
[27:37] Start to swell.
[27:38] Excuse me, unplugging when fully charged and charging larger devices like e-bites outside
[27:43] and away from exits, and whereas residents are encouraged to understand that safe charging
[27:48] means making smart choices every time they plug in.
[27:51] And whereas the City of South Lake Tahoe, fire responders remain dedicated to reducing the
[27:56] clearance of fires through prevention, safety, education, and community outreach.
[28:01] And whereas the 2026 fire prevention week, the charge in to fire safety, safe charging
[28:06] is a superpower, serves to remind all residents the safe charging can help reduce the risk
[28:11] of fires and homes and communities.
[28:14] Now for the city council of the City of South Lake Tahoe does here by proclaim October 4th
[28:18] through the 10th, 2026 as Fire Prevention Week and urges all residents to learn about and practice
[28:24] safe and charging habits.
[28:26] Thank you.
[28:27] All right.
[28:27] Absolutely.
[28:28] Appreciate it.
[28:38] Yes.
[28:38] Do we have a visitor?
[28:39] Thank you.
[28:40] All
[28:47] right.
[28:51] So this will be for National Domestic Violence Awareness Month, whereas October is annually
[28:56] recognized as the National Domestic Violence Awareness Month, and whereas Live Violence
[29:00] free change that's named of this derise collective to focus more on positive growth, decrease stigma
[29:06] and increase outreach to local survivors of all forms of intimate partner violence. And whereas
[29:11] domestic violence programs in California, including vis-à-vis collective, provide a central
[29:16] life-saving service for survivors, their children, and communities. And whereas approximately
[29:21] 35% of California women and 31% of California men experience physical intimate partner violence
[29:27] and their lifetimes. And whereas California has higher rates of domestic violence experienced
[29:32] by both men and women, women compared to the national average, and whereas key excellence,
[29:38] accelerants and risk factors of intimate partner violence including financial insecurity,
[29:43] housing instability, and mental health challenges are widely experienced by South Lake
[29:47] Tahoe residents according to Barton Health's community health needs assessment. And whereas
[29:52] according to that assessment, about one and out eight people in South Lake Tahoe report physical
[29:56] intimate partner violence. And whereas the domestic violence
[30:00] The effects people of all genders, sexual orientations, ages, racial, ethnic, cultural, social, religious, and economic groups in the United States and here in California.
[30:10] And whereas domestic violence is the third leading cause of homelessness among families in the United States, and whereas domestic violence costs $8.3 billion in expenses annually,
[30:20] A combination of higher medical costs, 5.8 billion, and lost lost productivity, 2.5 billion.
[30:27] And whereas children exposed to domestic violence can experience long-term consequences, including difficult to school.
[30:33] Substance abuse, behavioral problems, and adolescents, and serious adult health problems.
[30:38] And whereas all survivors deserve access to culturally responsive programs and services to increase their safety and self-sufficiency.
[30:45] Now, therefore, the City of Council of the City of South Lake Tahoe does here by proclaim
[30:50] the month of October, 2026, as national domestic violence awareness month, and calls upon
[30:56] all citizens, community agencies, elected leaders, and businesses to increase their participation
[31:01] effort to support families, thereby helping to prevent domestic violence and strengthening
[31:05] the community and which we live.
[31:15] All
[31:27] right, we're going to move on to public communications.
[31:30] This is the public's opportunity to speak on any topic.
[31:33] Not listed on this agenda, comment shall be limited to four minutes in accordance with
[31:37] the Brown Act.
[31:38] The City Council cannot deliberate or vote on any matter raised under public communications,
[31:43] but may briefly respond to statements made or questions posed.
[31:47] And we're going to also add a statement to that, which is that we value participation
[31:51] and ask everyone to help maintain a respectful and orderly meeting.
[31:54] When speaking, please avoid repeating comments, already made, so others have time to speak.
[31:58] Please refrain, please remain polite and respectful toward all participants.
[32:02] Side conversations should be moved to the lobby, so they do not disrupt the meeting.
[32:06] So thank you.
[32:07] And with that, we'll open up public comment here in the room and Mr. Perini.
[32:14] Good afternoon, Mr. Mayor.
[32:16] Members to the council.
[32:17] New City Attorney, I imagine I haven't been introduced, but welcome, we'll be like the
[32:24] altitude and you'd like pine trees, you know, we had a official here that didn't like
[32:29] pine trees after she worked here for seven years. But anyway, it's a whole other story
[32:33] you might want to learn about. But I came here for item seven. But since I was here,
[32:39] I thought I'd come in something else, I've commented on before, then me and the honorable
[32:46] Mr. G completely disagree on completely, but you're going to have a fatal accident on either
[32:54] D Street, Tata, or Julie Lane, and it's going to happen.
[33:02] And the personal energy attorneys will line up to get a transcript of what I've been telling
[33:07] you now for the fourth time.
[33:09] You have to turn Lake Tahoe Boulevard from Viking way to Lake Tahoe Boulevard back to
[33:20] Fort Lanes.
[33:22] It is atrocious.
[33:24] People are taking side streets, side streets, Tata, D Street, Julie Lane going 40, 50 miles
[33:31] an hour through residential, and somebody's going to get killed.
[33:34] And this transcript will show that you've been made aware of it, and you will be responsible
[33:43] for it, partly, the driver will be responsible for some, but you're the deep pocket,
[33:51] and you will pay out the most, so I urge you to urge Dr. Cue to reconsider his position, and
[34:02] maybe get more engineers involved, or somebody else,
[34:06] but that street, you've got two class A bike lanes
[34:09] on each side of the street, let alone class C bike lanes
[34:14] in the street could be easily turned back into four lanes.
[34:18] But anyway, this is push on notice.
[34:21] And I hope it draws your attention.
[34:24] I know it's going to be hard to go against one
[34:26] of your department hats.
[34:27] Very esteemed, gentlemen, by the way, very honest.
[34:31] But has the wrong opinion and the wrong engineering background to make this decision.
[34:39] Thank you very much.
[34:43] Anybody else here in the room that would like to make public comment?
[34:46] Yes, just go ahead and come forward.
[34:58] Kathy Zollinger.
[35:01] I'm here to talk about bears. On Wednesday, September 30, the bear crossing leg, table,
[35:07] board from McDonald's to I-Hop was killed. This bear for a long time had been crossing their
[35:12] due to McDonald's not securing their trash. He then crossed I-Hop to who, also, for a long time,
[35:20] has not secured their trash properly. I-Hop still currently has a non-bear proof plastic trash
[35:25] right in front, why when we live in Bear Country here have commercial businesses but allowed
[35:32] to use these non-secured trash receptacles. Barely provided this council a new trash ordinance
[35:38] many months ago and no action was taken. We're begging you to institute an emergency commercial
[35:44] ordinance requiring commercial businesses to switch to Bear Proof trash receptacles. I spent
[35:51] half hour of this week, driving around, photographing various places that still have unsecured
[35:56] or open trash receptables, which is what that is in the middle.
[36:01] This is inexcusable in our town, we know better, but we're not doing better.
[36:06] Several nights after this, in a nearby area, we respond to another bear, hit by a car,
[36:12] and in a complex with trash all over the driveway.
[36:14] I also have photos, these photos are a BG center target, shopping center, 7-11 big
[36:21] datties.
[36:23] What I don't have photos of, but was very visible, burger me, heavenly village, and I
[36:29] hot.
[36:30] Please save a bear's life required these businesses to have their approved trash receptacles
[36:34] now.
[36:36] This isn't to say we don't solve problems with our locking trash cans and non-locking
[36:41] recycl bins because we do, every single day.
[36:43] dumpsters are also overfilled and not secured.
[36:47] This emergency ordinance would be something impactful that you can do quickly that will have a big impact.
[36:54] Please, if you guys don't still have a copy of it, I can...
[37:06] In the room that would like to get public comment.
[37:10] I'm gonna solder stuff.
[37:19] Melissa solder stins off like Tahoe. Good evening everyone.
[37:23] I would like to say first it is fire prevention week.
[37:27] We're honoring that which is great.
[37:30] Your statement really highlighted what our problem right now is and it is not out in the forest.
[37:35] It is indeed here in our communities with the infrastructure hardening problems that we have.
[37:40] These lithium batteries are a huge issue.
[37:42] We have had, you know, just I think it was last summer, the trash dumps truck started on fire and they had to dump it in the middle of my street.
[37:51] So it is an issue and if we had a house fire start in our community on a windy day, it would spread through our community very quickly and there is no amount of logging in the forest that is going to prevent that.
[38:05] The vast majority of fires more than 90% are started within a short distance from roadway. They are starting within our communities. They are not starting way out in the forest.
[38:16] And I really want to double down on the fact that the Forest Service is being very
[38:23] coy, as well as TRPA in their treatment of the glyphosate issue.
[38:28] We are being absolutely gaslighted with them saying that there is going to be no spraying
[38:34] in the Caldore Fire Area till 2028.
[38:37] That will absolutely be going through, they're just stalling us, holding off.
[38:42] But I want to make it clear that they are being very careful in saying the caldo or fire area.
[38:49] glyphosate is being sprayed around the basin on a regular basis all the time.
[38:55] They only have to notice for 10 days and it's just happening everywhere.
[38:59] We really really need to focus and demand that these projects cease.
[39:05] The logging is not helping and as long as we keep approving it, keep just looking the other way.
[39:09] We are never going to have funding for home and infrastructure hardening.
[39:13] And we all know that that is the main problem.
[39:15] Cal Fire knows it, our insurance companies know it,
[39:18] the Forest Service knows it, everybody knows it.
[39:21] We don't have a problem putting out a fire on a normal day
[39:24] and no study anywhere says that thinning is an effective way to stop
[39:30] a wind or climate driven fire.
[39:32] There's just nothing about it that will be effective.
[39:35] We've seen it time and time again.
[39:36] I would again like to say the trash is a huge issue. I'm not going to harp on it because you guys are here all the time, but
[39:43] We cannot allow bears to be euthanized in our community until we are
[39:48] Requiring people to do the bare minimum. We're not even doing the bare minimum. There's trash everywhere
[39:53] There are people with completely unsecured trash receptacles. The recyclables are huge huge
[40:00] Huge, huge problem. People do not use them correctly. And we just have to do better. Or we are responsible for all of it. And it's on our conscious. We have lost a dozen bears to car strikes this year. That's nearly an entire generation of cubs, just gone. And we have to do better. We're the supposedly intelligent species. We need to act like it. Thank you.
[40:28] May I just make a comment that the City Council is holding a special meeting on the 13th
[40:35] as I if I'm correct? The purpose of that is too full, but one of the most important
[40:40] purposes is to discuss the issue of use of glyphosate and I have been told that so the
[40:49] public will be invited to comment on that. The City Council will be in a position to take action
[40:54] that it thinks is appropriate on that important issue.
[40:58] So I just want to mention that for clarity.
[41:00] Thank you, Mr. Jenkins.
[41:01] Anybody else here in the room that would like to give public comments.
[41:05] Seeing none will look on Zoom.
[41:07] No hands raised on Zoom, Mayor.
[41:09] All right, we'll go ahead and bring this back to Council.
[41:11] So with that, we're going to go ahead and move onto any city commissioners that are here in the room
[41:14] that would like to give a city commission report.
[41:17] And I don't see any, Ms. Mike or excuse me, Ms. Carpenter.
[41:20] And if that's fine, I'll answer to both.
[41:22] We do have one hand raised Ms. Ballard.
[41:29] Hi everyone, Stacey Ballard.
[41:31] I just wanted to give you an update from our last meeting.
[41:34] We spoke about enhancing some art in the REC center using up some of those walls that are empty in there.
[41:45] We also talked about our annual report to your city council in the city council in November.
[41:53] So we're really looking forward to telling you about all of our successes and then we're
[42:00] also continuing to work on our five-year work plan and discussion so we would love any council
[42:07] members or any members of the public to show up at our next meeting next month and let me know
[42:13] if you have any questions. Thank you all. Thank you, Ms. Ballard.
[42:18] Mr. Ansbury, we are on Commissioner
[42:21] reports are you wishing to give a commissioner report?
[42:30] Mr.
[42:31] Ann Spary are you interested in giving a commissioner report?
[42:36] Well, we can't are you there?
[42:38] Hello? Yes. We're on commission.
[42:40] So, uh, so I'd miss the public comment. Is that what you're saying?
[42:44] Yes.
[42:45] Oh, my goodness. Okay. All right. I apologize to you.
[42:48] You can email me, uh, Mr. Asbury and I'll distribute to council after the meeting.
[42:53] Okay. Wonderful. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
[42:55] Thank you. All right. No additional commissioner reports.
[43:00] Great. All right. Without we'll go ahead and move on to our consent agenda and let's see.
[43:05] I think we do have.
[43:06] I'm requesting to pull item seven.
[43:08] Okay. So Mr. Robbins will pull item seven. Any other questions?
[43:11] Just a question on item five.
[43:13] Just a question on five.
[43:17] Mayor, I do want to note a typo on item two in the action.
[43:21] It says fiscal tier like a crying, but it's fiscal year.
[43:25] Okay.
[43:26] Thank you for the correction.
[43:27] Okay, I think we could go ahead and ask the question on five before we open public comment.
[43:32] Yes, Mr. Karimo, take them around.
[43:36] What is your spending authority?
[43:38] I couldn't recall when I was reading the report.
[43:41] Your department spending authority.
[43:45] That's very interesting question.
[43:47] Ms. Horgan, the same as any other department heads.
[43:52] I approve all invoices under 30,000.
[43:55] So up to 29,999 dollars.
[43:59] How often is that reviewed just for my understanding?
[44:03] What do you mean?
[44:04] The spending authority.
[44:07] For spending the authority has not been changed for many years.
[44:12] For many years, and I must clarify that any contract
[44:16] over 60,000 has to go to council.
[44:19] Okay, 60,000.
[44:20] In contract has to be approved over 60,000
[44:23] has to be approved by City Council and additional purchase and procurement rules are that
[44:30] any contracts over 10,000, we have to request three bills, three informal bills. Any contracts
[44:39] over $10,000, $60,000 have to be publicly bided. So we've noticed we post them on planet
[44:49] builds and as described. Okay, the staff report. Those are my only questions I just wanted to understand. Thank you.
[45:00] Members of the questions on the consent agenda before we do public comment.
[45:03] All right. See, a non-will go ahead and open the consent agenda minus item 7. Item 7 will be coming back as a full item. So, you will be, that will be coming right next.
[45:16] Perfect. Yeah, come right up Mr. Prening.
[45:24] My name is the Prening. And I wanted to add a little context of what she just said. On items that are change orders, they go over 10,000 or 15,000.
[45:37] thousand, they don't have to come back to the console. He can approve a change order for
[45:43] million bucks if he wanted to. He says he's going to go to the console to get it, but that's
[45:48] what's in your bylaws, okay? So, change orders are treated completely different than bit items
[45:54] that go over budget. And a change order is not subject to review by anybody, but by on a
[46:03] are dealing with public works, and maybe a change you're dealing with by finance.
[46:08] But change orders are completed completely different than bid orders, and I want to put
[46:14] that in.
[46:14] Thank you.
[46:20] Anybody else miss Auterson?
[46:27] Melissa Sotterson, South Lake Tahoe, first number eight, these complete streets
[46:34] projects are very expensive, weird thing, not a huge fan of the way that they have been
[46:42] implemented, I think that it takes up an incredible amount of space with really ugly landscaping.
[46:48] And it makes me feel less safe as a pedestrian.
[46:54] The ramps for our access are often flooded during the winter, or even just a simply raining day.
[47:02] So I really hope that we pay attention to those ramps, especially flooding is a huge issue.
[47:07] anywhere these complete storage programs have gone in place.
[47:13] All these outside, so number nine, we do a lot of outside consulting for things, and I
[47:19] don't really see that we get a lot of results from any of it, especially an economic development
[47:23] market analysis.
[47:26] Talking to anyone in the community is going to give you a better idea of what's going to help,
[47:30] but I can guarantee you that we're not going to be attracting new businesses here into our
[47:34] community right now. We are not doing the bare minimum to support our businesses. I really feel this is a huge issue
[47:40] Our chamber of commerce. They are not doing their job to support the businesses that we have
[47:45] We've got the Sandwich boards coming up. Those are much simpler things that we could do to support our businesses
[47:51] We're not even promoting what we have here. I don't think that bringing in new businesses to fail within a few months is really going to help us
[47:57] Especially spending a lot of money to do it
[47:59] So if you need to do an economic development figure out how to attract businesses here
[48:04] perhaps talk to the people that live in the community, talk to the businesses that we already have here.
[48:09] It's a disaster out there and we're not going to be attracting quality businesses with what we have right now.
[48:16] We really have to do better.
[48:19] Yeah, I guess that's it.
[48:21] Thank you.
[48:22] Mr. Moser.
[48:31] Good evening.
[48:32] Good evening.
[48:33] Good evening.
[48:33] Good evening.
[48:39] Good evening.
[48:40] new Pine Bowl Vard project and I'm in favor of complete streets if you complete them within
[48:49] my lifetime and which this one here I don't know about hopefully get to see it.
[48:58] First of all, it's you know TRPA, we'll you know a couple of studies they did at the corner
[49:07] Park Avenue and Highway 50 is the busiest pedestrian and vehicular traffic corner in the entire
[49:14] basin. And I've been pointing that out for years. Ever since they did this first study,
[49:20] because it's also the worst. It's the most dangerous. It's the worst physical condition,
[49:25] infrastructure, wise, pot-hole, wise, everything.
[49:32] So, you know, you can't even have, I've been asking
[49:34] for just take by Tahoe Tombs down to Cedar, or man's in here to take those few parking spaces
[49:41] out for the sake of five or six parking spaces, you know, you create, I've sent the City Council
[49:45] pictures.
[49:46] We only have four feet between the cars and winter between their the Burm and then cars parked
[49:51] and sometimes even double parked, blocking Tahoe Tombs driveway, but you have four feet
[49:56] between the left-turn lane, the center-line lane, and-and-and-and-and-and-and-and-and-and-and-and-and.
[50:00] So, cars are supposed to go through there, pedestrians are supposed to go through there, would baby carriages with skis and bicycles in the lake.
[50:10] So, you can't even take care and do the simple things here to make them safe and just do away with those five.
[50:16] I got you to do on the corner there years ago, of course, aiming pool to credit for it, parking right on the opposite corner there where you turn right to come this way.
[50:24] And we were allowing parking right up to the very corner, which was absolutely absurd.
[50:31] So, you know, I would take that out to start with and make things before you even apply for this grant and start doing a long way.
[50:38] Like I said, do the little things first.
[50:42] Also, down at the bottom, there, you know, part of it is drainage.
[50:46] You're talking about the third on the side and saving the lake and affecting the lake and everything.
[50:52] and actually you have the basins down there to collect it.
[50:56] Problem is, is in the winter the water can't get to the basins because you get down the bottom of the berms cover the drains to it.
[51:03] And I've mentioned, you know, for the last few years,
[51:06] they just take the paddle boards that are on there that just say D1 and whatever,
[51:10] but they're right at ground level.
[51:12] First, no fall, they're covered.
[51:13] You can't see them.
[51:14] The snowplows can't see them.
[51:15] Don't know where the drain is.
[51:17] So, put paddle boards up high, eight feet in the air.
[51:20] So they know where it is or lights it and they can avoid it.
[51:24] I've cleaned them out when it's small, when it's small,
[51:26] berms I've gone down and shovel them out on number of occasions.
[51:29] But when it's five, six, high berms, six, seven feet across, I ain't doing it.
[51:33] So like I said, little things, and two, you get this actually done in and built.
[51:39] But you know, get also I mentioned about getting a pledge of at least a million from the
[51:45] If you just get instead of having to wait and apply for grants and this is 10 years off from beginning completed with this process at the earliest, starting right now.
[51:57] So get a pledge of at least one million of the three and a half million at the TBID collects to use and leverage that for a bond issue.
[52:07] And you can get enough to do the whole project, and in three years, you can actually have this done instead of waiting 10 or 12 years.
[52:14] So I would do that. You know, North Shore is using their business improvement district funding, you know, for infrastructure uses and, you know,
[52:22] whole host of things, not just marketing. You know, you want to market something, you got to have a product to market, you know,
[52:33] You know, are quite angry about it, and you know, almost getting run over and it's quite unsafe.
[52:40] So, you end up creating a lot better opportunity and by using your marketing money to actually create a good product to market.
[52:48] On the number nine, yeah, this is for the agreement with the Zenis economic development, market study and business attraction strategy.
[52:59] Again, if you don't have a quality market, a quality product here, you're not going to have quality businesses and quality people wanting to set up business here and come in.
[53:12] So that's the first step.
[53:13] When Joe Irvin here took the reins and his little buddy there, we have a Feldman from Malibu, gave her $25,000.
[53:23] You know, when she was supposed to bring in a track businesses and did a brochure that which we
[53:27] supplied all of the photos for and it was just an online thing didn't even print it up.
[53:33] And, you know, I was supposed to bring people here and show them the town and we got absolutely
[53:37] nothing for our 25,000.
[53:39] She just came and sat at one meeting and sat by a side and that.
[53:44] So, you know, there you go, that's, you know, $25,000 just pissed away for nothing.
[53:48] And I suspect this, you bring in somebody from out of town, they're really not familiar with it,
[53:53] they're going to spend time, they're going to need to spend time, they familiarize themselves with the city,
[53:58] with the business climate here.
[54:00] And you know, by the time you do that, the money's pretty much used up.
[54:04] So between people here and you know, all of you sitting up there and people sitting over here,
[54:10] really should have some sort of expertise and knowledge of the town where you shouldn't run
[54:14] in order to attract businesses and also to say hello to people that could put businesses
[54:20] on a large scale and create a second and third economy here.
[54:24] But that is a priority because tourism is flaky and also free up some of the housing so
[54:30] that it can exist.
[54:31] Thank you.
[54:32] Thank you, Mr. Mosier.
[54:33] Anybody else here in the room that would like to get public comment on a consent agenda?
[54:38] Okay, seeing normal go on Zoom.
[54:44] There are no additional public comments, Mayor.
[54:46] Great.
[54:47] With that, we can bring this back to Council for a motion.
[54:49] I will make a real quick comment just on the item nine.
[54:53] I think we recognized that we definitely
[54:56] want to see a second and third economy.
[54:57] And I think that it does take.
[54:59] Um...
[55:00] We're reaching out to people that look into that, that are not from here. I think is also a good thing.
[55:06] Because they can see a perspective that we may not be seeing.
[55:09] The city has done a lot with our business concierge program, going out to survey businesses and what we've heard a lot is that there is the want for the city to be more involved in helping support businesses.
[55:20] So, yeah, I think that, again, I think our business community is rather healthy, but always can be better.
[55:26] So, with that, unless there's other comments,
[55:28] I will look for a motion on the consentage of the minus item seven.
[55:33] I'll make a motion to prove the consent calendar
[55:37] two through ten minus item seven.
[55:41] There you go.
[55:42] Is there a second?
[55:43] Great. We've got a motion in the second.
[55:45] You can vote.
[55:49] That motion unanimously carries.
[55:51] Great. With that, we're moving on to item seven.
[55:53] This is a resolution of an intent to abandon the easterly
[55:58] have a new right of way, and this was Mr. Robin, so I'll start with you.
[56:04] Okay, then we will go ahead and see the staff.
[56:13] Good evening, members of Council.
[56:15] Mohammed Karashi, better known as Dr. Q, your public works director.
[56:19] The item before you is one step of the process outlined in our city code for the abandonment
[56:27] of roadways.
[56:29] There's a sequence of steps we have to go through.
[56:31] The first is there needs to be an application along with its associated V presented to the city.
[56:39] Then staff will reach out to the appropriate departments, specifically planning, department, fire, street maintenance, police.
[56:50] And I believe those are the ones specifically listed, but we reach out to find out if they have any opinions or thoughts on the
[56:58] application, it then goes to planning commission for their assessment of how it affects the
[57:05] long range plans in the city. The next step is the one where I right now where Council
[57:10] is asked to set a hearing date for a public hearing on the actual abandonment where you would
[57:16] then presumably pass a motion if you were in favor of it and at that point the road becomes abandoned
[57:24] and that property then reverts to a non-road condition and based on our understanding of the laws
[57:34] at the moment, there are two potential outcomes to that process.
[57:39] One is that if that property, if that road was owned in fee by the city, it becomes a piece
[57:46] of property owned by the city, subject to our decision on how to dispose of it.
[57:52] The alternative, if it is an easement and not property and fee, it then reverts to the underlying property owners that are adjacent to that section of roadway, and they can decide what they want to do with it, but it becomes their property and they make the decisions.
[58:11] Typically that's going to mean from the center line of the road towards the properties that becomes theirs.
[58:16] Um, this application before you has gone through the first several steps and we are now ready to bring it to you next month.
[58:26] As a for a public hearing to have comments presented and then for you to make an appropriate decision.
[58:34] I think I will conclude the staff report there and make myself available to questions.
[58:39] Thank you, Dr. Hugh, and I'll start with Mr. Robbins.
[58:42] Sorry, I forgot to hit the button, but you know.
[58:45] Do, does the city know unambiguously if we own that section of property?
[58:53] I will answer that, sir.
[58:56] Unambiguously is a harsh standard for me to come to.
[59:00] We have reached out to the county surveyor.
[59:03] The preliminary discussions with them is they believe it is a property and fee and belongs to the city.
[59:08] But they have not given us their written determination yet, and that has not been presented to our city attorney yet for their evaluation.
[59:18] So it's reasonable for me to interpret that as a statement that we do not yet.
[59:22] We may in the future, but we do not at this time have unambiguous clarity that we own that property.
[59:27] That is correct.
[59:28] Okay, very good.
[59:30] That we actually own it.
[59:31] Okay, has there been is there a contractual obligation for what will happen to that property once we abandon it and it reverts to
[59:40] it either reverts to or is sold to some other owner?
[59:47] Let me I will answer it this way if it is property in fee
[59:52] There is no contractual obligation at the moment for the disposition of that property
[59:57] We will have a better
[1:00:00] We will have a band in the roadway. Yes, correct. But we have no plans to do anything roadway wise with that piece of land at the moment. Anyway, it is a dead end. If it is property, if it is an easement, then it automatically reverts to the underlying property owner. There is no contract or anything.
[1:00:24] So we do not then decide what happens to it is that property owners who have who acquire that would then be able to enter into
[1:00:34] contractual agreements with a third-party to sell. So there is no contractual obligation that there's some defined public good that will happen at the end of this process at this time
[1:00:47] You can just jump in real quick right here. So what happens what happens if
[1:00:53] If it is actually owned in fee by the city, what happens is the city council will need to appoint a real property negotiator.
[1:01:03] And designate the property parcel and in close session give them parameters for negotiation of the sale of that parcel in fee.
[1:01:12] And then that real property negotiator will go forward, conduct negotiations, and then that sale documentation would come back to the city council for approval.
[1:01:20] Okay, I'm going to get to that in a second. So hold that thought because that's my next topic, but the
[1:01:25] talk, the question I asked right now was, is there any agreement for what will become of this
[1:01:32] property once we either, once we abandon the easement and or sell it? We have the city and staff have
[1:01:38] not entered into any agreement. Okay. We have had discussions, but those are not agreement. So we don't
[1:01:44] We don't have any defined outcome for what will happen to that parcel.
[1:01:50] That is a fair at this time, that is a fair assessment.
[1:01:55] Perhaps.
[1:01:55] I would tell you that we have two defined outcomes that happen.
[1:01:59] We don't know what right now it's a road.
[1:02:02] The public can park there or use it for snow storage or whatever.
[1:02:06] But that's going to change and what will change into at this time is undefined.
[1:02:12] Once we either ban in the easement or relinquish ownership, next question, the one that you got, you went just a bit ahead, that's fine.
[1:02:23] Once we abandon the easement and we no longer consider it a road, right, we no longer have access to use it, but that will happen before we know what value it would have, assuming we even own it to sell it for which to sell it.
[1:02:38] We have not yet done an appraisal nor do we know how much it is valued at is that understanding correct?
[1:02:49] I think you're right, Councilmember. I think there would need to be a real property negotiator appointed and get an appraisal and then do the negotiations and work again.
[1:02:58] The market value determined so that.
[1:03:00] So I just want to summarize the current state of knowledge.
[1:03:04] And it's my questioning section. We'll get to my opinions, I'll wait for the, I'll wait for the comments for that.
[1:03:11] But right now, we are being asked to abandon the roadway and we don't know what will happen to that property.
[1:03:19] There's no guarantee that it will be used for some kind of public interest use or public benefit at use.
[1:03:26] And if not, we also don't know what value or how much how many dollars it will yield the city as a consequence of that.
[1:03:33] But once we abandon the right of way, it's abandoned and it doesn't come back and that's so so I want to make sure I understand that that is our current state of knowledge.
[1:03:44] Correct.
[1:03:45] Okay.
[1:03:45] I have a degree with the majority of that. Yes.
[1:03:48] Okay.
[1:03:49] I have more, but it'll hold for comments.
[1:03:52] Ms. Morgan.
[1:03:55] Yeah.
[1:03:55] Not as exciting as yours.
[1:03:57] Do we have an estimate of the cost of maintenance of that payment like our annual maintenance or or maybe historical maintenance.
[1:04:04] I would I would not have that at the moment because feasibly if we abandoned we no longer
[1:04:11] are responsible so there's a lot of safety and we would not be snow-plowing we would
[1:04:17] not be paving in the future we would not be doing it.
[1:04:21] Okay thank you.
[1:04:22] Mr. Jenkins.
[1:04:25] Thank you Dr. Coo.
[1:04:26] My understanding also is that once there's a determination of whether it's in fee title or it's
[1:04:34] and if the city council decided that it was going to abandon the right away, that the
[1:04:40] uses that it could be used for depends on what's in the plan, what's in the regional
[1:04:45] plan, what's in the city's general plan, and that those uses that nothing could occur unless
[1:04:50] there's consistent with the city's general plan, that is my understanding of what the law is,
[1:04:55] So it's not that they there could be a free for all is out of fear
[1:05:00] Is that a fair comment? I think it is. I would say it a little bit more specifically than that.
[1:05:08] I would say that that piece of land will become property of someone, one of the Jason property owners.
[1:05:18] It would then be considered land that is usable slash-developable by that owner, and they would
[1:05:26] the city's process of going through building development services, if necessary, also
[1:05:33] permitting from TRPA and so on, depending on what they wanted to do there.
[1:05:38] But it would be in their discretion to decide.
[1:05:40] But I think the point is that it depends on what the general plan and what the
[1:05:44] end or the regional plan says that it can be used for it couldn't be used to build
[1:05:48] something that was not consistent with the regional plan or the general plan.
[1:05:52] And I think in fact that in order to abandon it, you'd have to make a finding
[1:05:56] that it's consistent with the circulation element of the city if it wasn't historically
[1:06:02] a roadway.
[1:06:03] So that's just enough for a thought.
[1:06:05] I believe that is the action that the planning commission has already taken.
[1:06:11] Mr. Jenkins, that is correct.
[1:06:12] The actions would need to be consistent with the city's general plan, as well as the zoning
[1:06:17] and other applicable regulations.
[1:06:22] Actually, a question came to mind, did we look at, was this a part of the roadways that
[1:06:26] were given to the city by El Dorado County in 1965.
[1:06:30] It was existing then.
[1:06:31] I believe we've determined that the map underlying parcel
[1:06:35] map that provided that roadway dates back to the 1930s.
[1:06:41] So then it would seem like, because yeah,
[1:06:43] when we became a city, that gave us the right of the roadways.
[1:06:46] So I would think that it's also...
[1:06:47] That's part of the reason we contacted the county surveyer's office.
[1:06:50] They were the original folks who dealt with that
[1:06:53] would have the documents and ability to interpret those documents appropriately.
[1:07:02] Great. Thank you so much, Dr. Thiel. And with that, we're going to go ahead and open this up to
[1:07:05] public comment. This is item number seven, the resolution of intent to abandon
[1:07:11] 30 foot portion of paradise. Mr. Perini.
[1:07:18] I'm Mr. Perini. Welcome.
[1:07:23] I'm a paraphrase.
[1:07:23] somebody that described me on next door, but I've been here for decades, I've
[1:07:32] lived here for decades, I've been to meetings for decades. I've voted here for
[1:07:39] decades since 1972. I've been elected for four tenths of a decade to public
[1:07:47] office and I said a lot of time researching this and I've also researched, I'm not sure
[1:07:58] how much your attorneys familiar with the public utility code which is different than
[1:08:06] the civil code that we're talking about and I think the number on that is 1031 of the
[1:08:19] So that's the prevailing document you're looking at, you haven't looked at the utility code, yeah, I don't think.
[1:08:25] The client question hasn't looked at the utility code, which is completely different.
[1:08:31] I was a member of the Satelli Public Judicial Board, and we had fetitalism easements to most of our water tanks.
[1:08:41] Those have value, and I contacted, went beyond the surveyor's office.
[1:08:49] I contacted the El Rave County County Council's office about this issue, and I have
[1:08:55] via Brookline, and I haven't got a definitive answer yet when this was transferred to the
[1:09:09] an easement. Okay, so you own a piece of land that you're not putting out for competitive
[1:09:17] bid. And adjacent property owners have nothing to do with it, unless you're talking about
[1:09:22] the center line on an non-feet title easement. The center line has nothing to do with it
[1:09:30] on a non-feet title easement on a fee title easement. So there are three adjacent property owners
[1:09:37] one of them was forced to put in a gate to accommodate fire, a fire there if it was put
[1:09:44] in the higher than in. The Americano probably was if they ended up getting a after a bid
[1:09:52] process, which I advocate, if they ended up getting it, they would be forced should be forced
[1:09:56] put in a gate. They say they're sure that I'm parking, they acquired the problem.
[1:10:00] 308-8-181, and turn it into a time share, do you know how much parking was done? Now they're complaining
[1:10:05] about not having enough parking, and they want to get something without a bid, it is not fair, and it smells pretty bad.
[1:10:15] Thank you very much. I have more to say and a lot more information, but my form in it's here three minutes. Thank you, Mr.
[1:10:25] Anybody else here in the room that would like to give a comment?
[1:10:28] Yes, Mr. Sottersen.
[1:10:34] Mr. Sottersen, South Lake Tahoe.
[1:10:37] This one just puts a really bad taste in everybody's mouth.
[1:10:40] It's a large parcel.
[1:10:42] It's larger than your normal easement, which would be transferred.
[1:10:45] It is access, which is a huge issue.
[1:10:48] In these days of fires, we can't afford to lose access.
[1:10:53] And it's a huge issue.
[1:10:54] That area is incredibly congested already.
[1:10:57] We know that people cut through that road to get through that property.
[1:11:03] There's not a lot of ways you can get through that area.
[1:11:07] On Pioneer Trail, there's not a lot of side roads.
[1:11:09] It's not a very safe area to be walking along.
[1:11:13] I think that's, it's a really a concern just losing these parcels in general.
[1:11:18] We don't need to be further congesting things.
[1:11:21] Flooding is a huge issue in that area.
[1:11:23] So more parking is just going to increase regional flooding. So I don't know. I mean, it's very difficult to
[1:11:33] Imagine the
[1:11:34] There's a lot of
[1:11:36] Friendships and stuff that go on between the planning at department and our Chamber of Commerce and these businesses and it
[1:11:43] Is really leaves a bad taste to everybody's mouth. Nobody feels comfortable with it
[1:11:47] The way that this is happening in such a rapid pace without any warning whatsoever
[1:11:51] we don't even know whether we own the property or not is really ridiculous to me.
[1:11:58] And I just, I don't know why we keep losing access to everything.
[1:12:03] Everything is not about the tourists.
[1:12:05] Our locals need places where they can walk through to get through to cut through these congested areas.
[1:12:12] And I don't know, I know people that use that road.
[1:12:15] So I'm not sure that it belongs to them, per se.
[1:12:19] We don't need to be paving over anything else and if you do,
[1:12:22] decide to get this rid of this parcel.
[1:12:25] We should be getting something in compensation for it.
[1:12:27] We rarely get any compensation for any of this and we have lost a lot of space over the years.
[1:12:34] So thank you.
[1:12:36] Thank you.
[1:12:37] Anybody else here in the room?
[1:12:38] We'd like to give a public comment.
[1:12:40] Seeing none.
[1:12:41] We'll check on.
[1:12:42] Oh, yes, Miss McCarthy.
[1:12:50] My name is Jan McCarthy.
[1:12:51] and I have the Americana that butts up to it.
[1:12:54] And we've been trying, parking has been a problem forever.
[1:12:57] We didn't build that.
[1:12:59] We bought it in 1974 from the Cabana motel
[1:13:04] that built it as a back annex for bus groups way back
[1:13:07] in the day.
[1:13:10] I bought the four lots next to the Americana
[1:13:12] that I was turned down and everything I wanted to do
[1:13:15] by the TRPA.
[1:13:17] I wanted to build the park just to have five more parking spots
[1:13:19] out of that four lots I tried to do anything and they turned everything down and then when
[1:13:28] I sold the property because I couldn't build on it and then we were actually parking there
[1:13:34] for 40 years we've been overflow parking there I should have just left it alone because we
[1:13:41] could have still been using it today but instead I decided we should buy that so I bought it
[1:13:47] but all four lots, and the very next day that it closed as grow, the TRPA said I had to put
[1:13:54] posts in, so nobody could park there. So that's when I proposed all kinds of things to make
[1:14:01] it a park for the neighborhood, keep the grass, make it. If you don't think you know everything
[1:14:04] I do as flowers and grass. So I tried everything and then I hired an engineer 30,000 for
[1:14:13] for nothing. So I sold it all four parcels and look how quick they put up four
[1:14:19] taking tacky houses that, you know, when I was going to do was going to bring
[1:14:25] people to come to a park so I could get five more spots. It's just been this uphill
[1:14:30] road. So and we have tried to, we've looked at paradise. The paradise went under
[1:14:36] the Americana before it was built and went all the way to Pioneer. And then when
[1:14:39] And that was put in, they cut it right there.
[1:14:43] But it was a motel when it was first built.
[1:14:45] We later turned it in time, but that didn't really change anything.
[1:14:48] And they still didn't have enough parking because they built it for buses.
[1:14:52] And again, back in the day, people would jump in a car and come up here with the family.
[1:14:58] Well now, all the kids have cars.
[1:15:00] So we were for a long time telling people to go park at the casinos, but now that's costly. We just keep getting squeezed, squeezed, squeezed, and so I've asked to buy this. Now we've tried to get it for 10 years. But the Hampton has that right away, we need a fire truck to go in and turn around. But now they built the fire gate, so they don't need that anymore. So we've had our applications and come out and know where. This didn't come out and know where.
[1:15:29] I thought an application in for two years was gone through, no, you just need to talk about it.
[1:15:34] Just if you don't want to, yes.
[1:15:36] Okay.
[1:15:37] It is so, anyway, Mike deal with here with some more information.
[1:15:40] If you could let him he's on Zoom, we'd really help me.
[1:15:43] Thank you so much.
[1:15:44] Absolutely, Ms. McCarthy.
[1:15:45] Thank you.
[1:15:46] All right. If there are no other public comments in the room, we will go on Zoom.
[1:15:52] There's a couple of, there's one hand raised.
[1:15:55] Judy Johnson.
[1:16:04] Ms. Johnson and to your turn.
[1:16:07] Can you hear me out?
[1:16:09] This is Eric Johnson and Judy Johnson in my wife and we only the last three lots and two cabinets on Paradise 7 and
[1:16:25] It's been my fan is since 1940 and first of all, I just wanted to comment Emily Doritree has been very, very
[1:16:35] find as far as calling us and keeping us up to date and even always it's what's going
[1:16:40] on. I really appreciate that. We really, we do want to work with you. We're out of
[1:16:45] housing this, but so I don't know. We do a survey on our property that Jeff Turner
[1:16:54] is stood on. And she usually say, in front of time, believe me, there's some survey work.
[1:16:59] Mr. Johnson, can you turn off whatever, like turn down the volume on the device that you're watching the city council meeting from?
[1:17:12] If you can just mute the device that you're watching the meeting on and just speak through your phone.
[1:17:19] I'm going to.
[1:17:21] Okay, thank you. It's just causing some feedback and we can't not understand you.
[1:17:25] Just a minute, just a minute.
[1:17:33] Oh, and now we've lost you completely.
[1:17:43] Okay, go ahead.
[1:17:44] So, can you hear me now?
[1:17:47] I can, it's still reverberating, but just go ahead.
[1:17:49] We'll figure it out.
[1:17:51] Turn her sauce.
[1:17:53] Let me turn her.
[1:18:00] Okay, she's going to stand over there.
[1:18:02] Okay, you have about two minutes left.
[1:18:04] Just go ahead and finish.
[1:18:07] So we met with Jan a couple of times and like I said, I didn't know it was very helpful to be in this out of the day.
[1:18:16] We were kind of left out of the process.
[1:18:17] Very good.
[1:18:18] And Jan, who will, for a certain number of part and part,
[1:18:23] is the block there, which is a fence.
[1:18:26] And as you put it in the area, we didn't know this.
[1:18:29] and she had a plus and a plus and a virtual like that.
[1:18:32] And we found that, and we started practicing the school
[1:18:35] for all of a sudden, so I always want to say
[1:18:37] is that we just want to keep it in the form of work
[1:18:41] where it's going to be a plus on his,
[1:18:44] just to be able to move that in a month or a month or a month.
[1:18:47] Yeah, I'm sorry, Mr. Johnson.
[1:18:49] We are just getting too much feedback
[1:18:52] because you have multiple devices going at one time.
[1:18:54] And we are just not able to hear you at all.
[1:18:57] if you just want to yeah we just can't hear you I'm sorry if you want to submit some
[1:19:03] comments in writing yeah I'm sorry we're just unable to hear you
[1:19:12] no we're still just getting reverberation I'm sorry if you'd like to submit some written public
[1:19:21] comment you can send it to public comment at cityofslt.gov and I'll distribute after the meeting thank
[1:19:28] No additional public comments, Mayor.
[1:19:31] We'll bring this back to council and Mr. Robbins.
[1:19:35] So I noticed when I noticed this on the staff report, when I noticed on the agenda I went through the staff report here.
[1:19:42] The first thing that stood out to me was that the staff report had no indication anywhere as to why this request was being made.
[1:19:51] What is the underlying purpose that's going on here?
[1:19:53] And then I went back to read the staff report for the Planning Commission meeting.
[1:20:00] Which also had no indication whatsoever of why this request was being made. I had to go to the video to see testimony, you know, or to see public comment rather, not even testimony, but just public comment indicating that this had something to do with parking. But in nowhere in the staff reported it say why this was being made. We don't know if we own it, we don't know how much we would get in return for it. And there's no indication that the outcome of this transfer would be in the public's interest.
[1:20:29] and my concern here is that I don't have a strong emotional connection to the last 30 feet
[1:20:36] of a dead end paradise, that's sort of not the concern that I have is the specific parcel
[1:20:42] but of setting up precedent that the city is going to give away bits of itself to private
[1:20:47] for-profit enterprises with no clear understanding of what we get in return or what the
[1:20:52] people get in return.
[1:20:53] And for me, that's fundamentally problematic.
[1:20:56] I appreciate the planning commissions assessment
[1:20:59] that this doesn't impact vehicle circulation,
[1:21:02] but our responsibility isn't to vehicle circulation.
[1:21:05] It's to the stewardship of public property
[1:21:09] and public and the public trust.
[1:21:10] And this doesn't, at this time, the material
[1:21:14] as presented here doesn't have sufficient information,
[1:21:18] certainly for me to go forward with this.
[1:21:19] And I think if we're going to transfer it,
[1:21:21] need to know, especially if we're going to permanently abandon the easement, which permanently
[1:21:27] abandoned our ability to use it as snow storage or at some point in the future, or for
[1:21:31] something else, we need to know how many dollars the public will be getting an exchange for us
[1:21:36] giving this up, or if this is being turned into a park that's accessible to the public, or it's
[1:21:41] being there's some easement for there to be a pedestrian and bike cut through, or whatever
[1:21:46] the case may be, we should know the outcome of the, we should know what the process outcome is before we
[1:21:53] in dev, before we start on this and we just don't have that kind of information. And I'm not saying
[1:21:58] that I'm fundamentally against selling a piece of property that the city doesn't really need so that some
[1:22:05] business can have more parking that's not an inherent wrong thing but then we need to know what the
[1:22:09] public's getting an exchange for that. We need to know the number of dollars and we need to know that we actually
[1:22:13] own it. And if we're going to abandon an easement, then that should come with some compensation
[1:22:18] for our inability to ever use that property in the future in the way that we are able
[1:22:23] to use it now. And I don't see any of that in the staff report materials. I'm also somewhat
[1:22:31] concerned that this came up on consent. I recognize that we did ask staff to be aggressive
[1:22:38] about putting material on consent, and so I don't, I don't fault that, but my general viewpoint
[1:22:45] is that if we're giving away bits of the city that that should probably get a little
[1:22:50] more attention, you know, but in fairness, we did ask for that, so, but that is a bit of
[1:22:56] a concern for Mike.
[1:22:58] Thank you.
[1:22:59] Mr. Jenkins.
[1:23:00] Mr. Robert.
[1:23:01] Mr. Robert.
[1:23:01] If I could just clarify for you, the action that's being requested of Council tonight
[1:23:07] is not approval or denial of the abandonment.
[1:23:10] It is adopting a resolution that would set the date of a public hearing, where you would
[1:23:15] receive further public input and be able to consider the abandonment of the property.
[1:23:22] We don't have,
[1:23:24] I don't think we have enough information to assess whether or not it's worth
[1:23:29] having further meetings until we know that we own the property.
[1:23:33] we know what the property is, how can the public reasonably comment on the value exchange
[1:23:40] at hand here? If we don't know how much the parcel is worth to a potential buyer,
[1:23:45] or we don't know how much the easement abandonment is worth to a potential buyer.
[1:23:49] And I see no indication in the staff report that that information is guaranteed to be
[1:23:54] available prior to the public hearing. So how can the public provide
[1:23:58] informed input, if there's no additional information, then what's already in the staff report
[1:24:04] which is insufficient.
[1:24:06] So my concern is that this is not ripe for this assessment yet.
[1:24:11] There needs to be more homework to done before an informed decision can be made.
[1:24:15] And that includes an informed input by the public.
[1:24:18] Thank you, Mr. Rodgers, Mr. Dickens.
[1:24:20] Oh, yes.
[1:24:21] Would you like to thank Mr.
[1:24:28] Dickens?
[1:24:28] prior to the public hearing that might be helpful for the council.
[1:24:33] Absolutely, Mr. Keele. Dr. Keele, excuse me.
[1:24:35] Sure. I want to first start with according to the report prepared by a surveyer,
[1:24:43] of the portion that we're talking about abandoning.
[1:24:46] The total amount is 1435 square feet or less.
[1:24:54] That's smaller than most homes where that you could talk about.
[1:25:00] We need to keep in mind that I understand there's concerns about what could be used, what could be done
[1:25:04] with that land, but what we're talking about is 1,400 square feet. There's not a lot that can be done.
[1:25:11] In terms of process, we have gone through the process of looking at whether the city has a potential
[1:25:19] use for that, and the determination is there is no potential use for that piece of area of land. I would also submit.
[1:25:30] Whether it's in easement or in fee is, you may think it's relevant to your decision, but it is not completely relevant.
[1:25:40] The decision is, do we want to keep that as a roadway portion that is not going to be used and currently is used as on street parking?
[1:25:53] That is the purpose it's currently being used for.
[1:25:56] So, you can make a decision when the time comes, not today, again, today is only to establish
[1:26:03] a date for a public hearing where then you can have all sorts of opinions come forward
[1:26:10] from the public on whether it should be done or not.
[1:26:13] You will find that we will have more information on, hopefully, by that point, about the easement
[1:26:19] versus in fee will have more clarity, I hope, by that point.
[1:26:24] In terms of the price for it, I believe the intent here
[1:26:29] is that once it's determined that it can be bought by someone,
[1:26:33] the person wanting to buy it would be asked to do the pay
[1:26:37] for the appraisal of that land.
[1:26:39] We're not agreeing to sell it before there's an appraisal.
[1:26:43] We are only saying it becomes eligible for us to sell.
[1:26:47] After, but we have to abandon the easement at that point.
[1:26:51] If it's easement, again, that land never belonged to us.
[1:26:56] We were given permission to use it by the underlying property owner.
[1:27:00] They still keep the land.
[1:27:01] It's never going to be ours if it's easement.
[1:27:04] If it's in property and fee, you are correct.
[1:27:07] It is then city property.
[1:27:09] And we get to decide at what price we want to sell it.
[1:27:14] But once if we abandon the easement and then attempt to sell it,
[1:27:19] we will have already abandoned the easement.
[1:27:21] There's nothing to set up, there's nothing to set up, there's nothing to set up, there's
[1:27:23] nothing to set up.
[1:27:24] If it is owned in fee, if it is owned in fee, we still own it after we abandon it, it does
[1:27:30] not go away.
[1:27:31] But we all will have abandoned the, the, the, and it is, if we, you know, we might own part
[1:27:38] of it and then have an easement further beyond that, right?
[1:27:40] Is that not possible?
[1:27:42] No.
[1:27:42] Okay.
[1:27:43] That is not the situation.
[1:27:45] Look, if we were doing it in the middle of a block that could be possible.
[1:27:49] but we would never consider that option but we won't but is there a is there a fear compensation
[1:27:54] that's given to the city in exchange for abandoning the easement if it's just an easement
[1:27:59] and not owned in fee no so so I don't see how the public can have the ability to provide reasoned
[1:28:08] input without knowing if there's money at the end of this for the city in exchange for their
[1:28:15] property of which we are the stewards, so if I may, you may be confusing abandoning the
[1:28:24] right of way with easement. easement is the form of title that allows the city to utilize
[1:28:33] the property as right of way. So if the city owns it in fee title, we own the property.
[1:28:40] it's a designated right of way we would be abandoning the right of way then we would
[1:28:46] just have a piece of property owned by the city that could then be purchased by another
[1:28:51] property based on negotiation and praise all of those things. Does that mean we don't like the
[1:28:56] price that we were offered at that point we will have already abandon it though but we would
[1:29:00] re-establish the right away if we wanted to. City owned property we'd have to re-establish
[1:29:06] a right away after the fact if we if we wanted is that correct if there was a need but
[1:29:13] my understanding is that the evaluation has determined that there is not a need for that
[1:29:18] to be city right I am generally uncomfortable and I think we should all be about the prospect
[1:29:23] of setting a precedent of giving away bits of the city for reasons we know not why for
[1:29:28] for uses that have not been clearly established and for a price that we do not have an assessment
[1:29:35] much less than negotiated transfer. And apparently, at this time, for property that we don't
[1:29:41] actually know for certain that we own or not. And so that seems pretty-
[1:29:46] But see what the rest of Council has to say. Yes, Mr. Jenkins, what I have on my last
[1:29:52] next in the Miss Oregon, Mr. Jenkins.
[1:29:55] Yeah,
[1:29:59] I typically...
[1:30:00] And then typically, if there's property,
[1:30:06] will we, no, have an answer, is there a title search that's
[1:30:09] going to be done? How do we, to the point of the council member Robbins? Is there a title search
[1:30:14] that's being done? So we'll know definitively what it is we're dealing with? Is that, you know,
[1:30:22] I would tell you what we've asked from the county surveyors office would be similar to what a title
[1:30:28] would bring forward. I think it's safe to say that our counsel and preliminary discussions has
[1:30:36] also suggested that we would want to make sure to have title insurance if we were to own it
[1:30:41] and want to sell it so that it protects us in case there's any dispute later on about whether
[1:30:47] we own it. But at this point, just so everyone, maybe I'm perhaps going too far into death but this
[1:30:55] This discussion about infee versus easement comes from language in the map act and I believe
[1:31:04] if I have the date right 1974 possibly 1972 the map act was updated to say that property that is
[1:31:15] given as either easement for use of a roadway for example needs to be specific about
[1:31:22] stating if it's being given in fee as opposed to just stating easement prior to 74 though
[1:31:29] that was not in place and so there was no use of the phrase actually I'm actually glad
[1:31:35] that state law applies to something that we do and and and and and and it's not done on
[1:31:40] some regional bases that we have no control over so I'm actually glad to hear that but I was
[1:31:44] going to ask so
[1:31:50] but but I think it is important to know the status of the property I think
[1:31:53] that's important, and I think helping a business to stay in business and do better in business
[1:32:03] is a public interest issue. That's what we're talking about, economic development, economic diversity.
[1:32:09] So I, so in the concept of helping business to do business to stay in business is what we should
[1:32:16] thinking about too. So those are kind of juxtaposed, juxtaposed. Well, it's thinking of them
[1:32:23] together, juxtaposed. Whatever that is, juxtaposed. I'm never going to use that word again.
[1:32:31] But I think it's really important that we know definitively whether we own it or not. That's
[1:32:36] important. That's such a base fact. We should know it. I have no problem, I have no problem. Because
[1:32:44] There's nothing, no decision we make tonight is going to be about the disposition of it.
[1:32:49] It's simply setting a hearing and by the time that a hearing is held, we better note
[1:32:54] with certainty whether we own it or not.
[1:32:58] But that's my thought.
[1:33:00] That's my thought.
[1:33:01] I would also point out to you, part of the reason we're here today is there are certain requirements
[1:33:05] on us in terms of noticing the public hearing and having sufficient time to do that.
[1:33:10] That also doesn't mean that we can't postpone or reschedule the hearing.
[1:33:16] Should we not have the answers we need by that?
[1:33:19] Great.
[1:33:20] Thank you, Mr. Jenkins.
[1:33:21] Before again.
[1:33:22] That last part actually answered my question because I believe my conversation last week with the city attorney,
[1:33:31] Ruden, it suggested that this could be postponed if that piece of information wasn't determined.
[1:33:37] And so that answered my question.
[1:33:40] The other thing was mentioned in public communications
[1:33:43] about emergency access.
[1:33:45] And I thought I understand from the city report
[1:33:49] that the gate that it was established when Hampton
[1:33:52] in Winning establishes that emergency access
[1:33:57] and that abandoning this property doesn't adversely
[1:34:01] affect any access for fire or safety or evacuation?
[1:34:09] As I indicated earlier, we did reach out to both police and fire to ask whether there
[1:34:15] were any concerns with it.
[1:34:17] They did not say anything to us.
[1:34:19] I will certainly let Chief Keppen or Chief Robertson add onto that if they would like to.
[1:34:26] The other thing I may not have explicitly mentioned, in addition to the departmental agencies,
[1:34:32] we also did reach out to all the local utilities to make sure whether they have easements
[1:34:37] or anything in that area. And I think only one agency has an easement, and that will be that will
[1:34:44] be taken care of in the process.
[1:34:54] Do our public safety folks have any concerns about access if this property is a banning.
[1:35:00] And for evacuation or emergency access to the buildings already in the area?
[1:35:10] I didn't see this on DRK, so I don't know where that line is, so I'm going to look that up real quick.
[1:35:15] I could just, for your information, this portion that's proposed to be abandoned.
[1:35:21] It's just a dead end. It does not provide access to any other properties.
[1:35:25] And if we were to abandon it, it would not affect the ability to access that emergency gate at the hand in.
[1:35:31] Thank you.
[1:35:33] Great.
[1:35:33] Thank you, Ms. Morgan.
[1:35:34] Mr. Roberts.
[1:35:36] Yes.
[1:35:37] I appreciate Mr. Robbins' comments and his concerns and his thoroughness in reviewing
[1:35:42] this agenda item.
[1:35:45] But I also want to mirror what Mr. Jenkins said that it appears at least at this stage
[1:35:50] of most in front of us, what's being asked for us from this agenda item today.
[1:35:55] It seems like all the ducks are in a row or the opportunity to gather more of this information,
[1:36:00] And what you're very valuable, I agree, we'll be in front of us at November 3rd hearing.
[1:36:08] And if it's not, then we can address it.
[1:36:11] So I mean, I don't really understand what the confusion is, but it seems like it's, I think
[1:36:17] it makes a lot of sense at this stage, and I'm ready to make a motion.
[1:36:21] Great.
[1:36:22] Thank you Mr. Roberts.
[1:36:24] Yeah, I'm more or less agree, but what I'm hearing, I think, from Mr. Robbins, is that the
[1:36:28] that this has come forward and maybe that we look at a policy around if we are abandoning properties,
[1:36:34] that there's a different, but that's kind of a different item than what we're looking at today.
[1:36:37] Just in the way that those things get brought forward to the public could be reviewed.
[1:36:42] But as far as what's happening today, I think that again, knowing the American economy property,
[1:36:46] Ms. McCarthy, we, you know, needs parking, it seems like something that is, yeah, that is appropriate.
[1:36:53] And, and again, if, as Mr. Roberts just said, if we have issues,
[1:36:56] we still have another round to bring this back forward.
[1:37:00] So with that in less Mr. Robbins or yep, go ahead.
[1:37:04] Can you guarantee that prior to the public hearing that the public will be able to know
[1:37:10] how many dollars will be available in exchange for the property if
[1:37:19] it's an easement only
[1:37:20] then the answer is zero as I understand and if it's in feed and the amount of dollars is
[1:37:26] more than zero, but either way, can you guarantee that the public will know that an exchange
[1:37:30] for this action how many dollars the city, the public will receive an exchange for
[1:37:36] relinquishing this property to a private owner?
[1:37:41] No, I can't guarantee that because I can guarantee the appraisal can be done in the 30 days.
[1:37:46] The intent was never to do an appraisal prior to the abandonment.
[1:37:50] The appraisal was going to be contingent on whoever wanted to buy the property after they could
[1:37:55] buy it.
[1:37:56] And it seems to me that staff is clearly indicating that the public will not have adequate
[1:38:01] information at the time of a public hearing to give meaningful input if they don't know
[1:38:06] what the public benefit is, be it money or otherwise of the outcome that they're concerned.
[1:38:11] I think we would know that it would be at the market rate, which is what the appraisal will
[1:38:15] be based on.
[1:38:16] So even though we may not know that dollar figure, it's guaranteed that it's going to be
[1:38:19] at the market rate of the value of the property based on the appraisal, because I believe
[1:38:23] by law, we have to sell it at the migrant rate.
[1:38:26] So I would just note that for the abandonment hearing,
[1:38:31] it's not likely that you'll have that information,
[1:38:33] but prior to any sale of property,
[1:38:36] that would require council action,
[1:38:38] and that information would be provided.
[1:38:41] OK, unless there are other questions, comments,
[1:38:43] let's go for a motion if somebody could make one.
[1:38:48] I'll make a motion.
[1:38:49] I move that we pass a resolution of intent to abandon
[1:38:51] and the Paradise Avenue right away and set public hearing data in November 3rd, 2026.
[1:38:59] May we have a motion and question on the motion.
[1:39:02] Sure.
[1:39:03] With the understanding that by the time that the hearing is held, that we have, that we know whether or not the property is owned in fear,
[1:39:11] or not, would you agree to that?
[1:39:12] Otherwise the hearing would be continued.
[1:39:15] Would you, would that be a group?
[1:39:17] Would that be a group?
[1:39:18] As a second, I second.
[1:39:20] pass for that clerk.
[1:39:21] Dr. Keyes said that it could.
[1:39:24] Noticing it wouldn't prevent us from postponing if we don't have that information.
[1:39:30] No, no, let me tell you what I said.
[1:39:34] What I said was, would the maker of the motion agree that exactly what you said is part of the motion?
[1:39:42] Okay, well then I was seconded.
[1:39:43] No problem with that.
[1:39:44] So we got a seconded amended motion and now I think we can vote.
[1:39:56] Motion carries.
[1:39:58] Great.
[1:39:58] All right, before we move in.
[1:42:51] Good evening, Mayor Vass and Council members. My name is Jessica Wackenhatt, Lamelli, Housing Manager for the City.
[1:42:58] And today I also have John Hitchcock, the planning manager, will also be presenting with me today.
[1:43:05] We're going to be presenting on the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency or TRPA Housing Amendments and Water Quality and Mobility Fees summary.
[1:43:13] John and I will provide a summary on the amendments based on our understanding of them,
[1:43:17] but we also have Karen Fink, Long Range Planning Director from TRPA here as well.
[1:43:26] To begin, the Tahoe Libyan Housing and Community Revitalization Working Group is a TRPA stakeholder advisory group that was created in 2020 to help develop practical regional housing policies while maintaining like Tahoe's environmental protections.
[1:43:41] It operates as a formal working group of TRPA's advisory planning commission or APC which drawn service on and developed recommendations to your collaborative process and it does not itself make final regulatory decisions.
[1:43:54] There are local government seats for each jurisdiction for members are appointed by the
[1:43:59] TRPA Government Board, including two from the regional planning committee and two
[1:44:04] from the local government and housing committee seats. This includes Mayor Vass.
[1:44:09] There are up to 13 members appointed by the TRPA Executive Director to represent specified
[1:44:14] stakeholder perspectives, including public lands, de-districted housing, housing development,
[1:44:19] social services, contractors, realtors, employers, environmental organizations, and community
[1:44:27] collaborative. Individuals were also able to apply through an application to fill some of these
[1:44:33] seats.
[1:44:41] So now I'll jump into the cultivating communities, which is part of the Tahoe living
[1:44:48] working group. And so this is a multi-year project and this is phase three of the project and it's
[1:44:55] focus on making housing more accessible while maintaining and improving environmental protections
[1:44:59] as I mentioned earlier.
[1:45:00] On January 28, TRP released a notice of preparation for an environmental impacts statement or EIS to analyze the potential environmental impacts of those policy recommendations.
[1:45:12] The policy recommendations is in the packet as well for anyone to review. The policy alternatives that are in the EIS will include a no project alternative, which evaluates the potential environmental and housing cost effects of continuing under TRP's existing housing policies.
[1:45:30] without adopting any new policy amendments that are listed in that draft.
[1:45:36] The second is a housing for it alternative, which focuses on adapting to your pay policy
[1:45:41] to meet the regional housing need through a combination of incentives.
[1:45:44] Primarily focused on new workforce housing with limited strategies focused on better utilization of existing housing.
[1:45:52] And the last alternative is housing preservation alternative.
[1:45:55] This focuses on utilizing existing housing stock to meet the need of Tahoe's workforce.
[1:46:06] The public review of the draft EIS, a housing cost memorandum in proposed amendments
[1:46:11] to the regional planning code of ordinances are expected to be available later this fall.
[1:46:17] This will also include a 60-day public review period for anyone to review.
[1:46:21] The public at review will inform the final EIS in proposed amendments to be considered for adoption in 2027.
[1:46:30] pre-usual housing presentations and I'm going to go through a few definitions so that everyone
[1:46:36] understands because this may be a little bit different than other presentations that I have provided
[1:46:42] about some key terms because TRPA has also specific definitions for some of their housing terms.
[1:46:49] So the first one is affordable by design housing. This is non-deadrestricted housing that includes
[1:46:54] either multi-family rental housing with restrictions on conversion to four-scale housing
[1:47:00] for a minimum of 15 years, when it may be converted to de-districted achievable condominiums.
[1:47:08] The next is multi-family housing and a mixed income project with a required minimum amount of
[1:47:13] de-districted affordable modern or achievable housing. The next is any ADUs under 1,200 square feet.
[1:47:20] The other is innovative housing types or models aimed at creating naturally occurring affordable
[1:47:26] housing, so this includes tiny homes, community land trusts, co-housing or dormitories.
[1:47:33] And the last one is single-family homes converted into do-plexes, triplexes, or four-plexes.
[1:47:39] And all housing types utilizing bonus units would be subject to restrictions for having
[1:47:43] used as short-term rentals.
[1:47:48] Next, I will go through quickly because I know some of these are from you're all
[1:47:52] familiar with. So for affordable, it's similar to the definition that we use at the state and federal
[1:47:58] level for what's de-drestricted under 80% of the county's area median income. And for moderate income,
[1:48:05] this is de-drestricted to an income not an excess of 120% of the area median income.
[1:48:13] And achievable is another term that TRPA created. That includes single or multi-family residential
[1:48:19] development deeter-sick to be used exclusively as a residential dwelling by permanent residents who meet
[1:48:26] one or more of the following criteria. They can either have a household income not an access of
[1:48:31] 120 percent of the county's AMI or at least one household occupant works at least 30 hours per week
[1:48:40] or full-time equivalency for an employer with a business license or a tax address within the
[1:48:46] or Tahoe trekking unified school district and
[1:48:49] requires the employer's physical presence,
[1:48:53] or a resident is a retired person who has lived in a
[1:48:56] de-drestricted unit in the Tahoe Bayes
[1:48:58] for more than seven years.
[1:49:00] So as you can see, this last one's not necessarily restricted
[1:49:03] by income, but a portion of that can include it.
[1:49:08] And then the last key term all included are bonus units.
[1:49:11] So these are residential development rights that are provided
[1:49:14] by TRPA or in some cases the local jurisdictions as incentives for contributing to regional
[1:49:20] plant goals such as constructing affordable moderate and achievable housing or retiring
[1:49:26] environmentally sensitive parcels from future development.
[1:49:33] And now I'll go into the tiered
[1:49:35] structure for the different incentives that we'll apply to each of the policy and code recommendations
[1:49:41] that I'm going to move forward in the next few slides. So for Tier 1, it includes de-districted
[1:49:48] affordable and moderate income housing units, so then sentives through cost reductions
[1:49:52] and wave development fees and streamlined process.
[1:49:55] So this is where the most incentive supply tier two is a little bit less so it
[1:50:00] Includes de-districted of tubable housing units and units meeting the criteria for affordable by design that I just read through.
[1:50:10] And this includes some streamlined processes, reduced development fees, and are restricted against use as short term rentals.
[1:50:17] And the last is tier 3, so this includes all other housing types that are not included in the first two tiers, and includes unrestricted condominiums and any other detached single-family homes.
[1:50:34] Alright, so with the first policy set, it's under reduced cost and barriers for smaller housing types.
[1:50:41] So this covers three different aspects, which include development rates, development costs and fees, and the development process.
[1:50:48] So within the development rates, or the first thing I'll say also, you'll see some blue asterisk that are up here as well next to the some of the proposals.
[1:50:58] And that just really means that staff was recommending that policy as was proposed in the policy recommendation report.
[1:51:07] And so under development rights, this is to direct some of the remaining growth potential in the Bayesian to the residential bonus unit pool and allow more types of housing to qualify for bonus units.
[1:51:19] The next is to align conversion policies to scale residential development rights.
[1:51:24] So this is thinking about one development right either equals a larger single family home or one apartment unit and how this development rights can be scaled applicable to the different square footage of those housing units.
[1:51:39] And then the last one was ensuring new development contributes proportionally to alleviating the housing need.
[1:51:46] Under development cost and fees, there is fee changes to support both affordable and workforce housing.
[1:51:52] And then the last one is development process, so this is to increase thresholds for discretionary review which city staff also supported and then environmental exemptions.
[1:52:05] And now I'm going to go for some of those ones that we didn't quite support as staff.
[1:52:11] What some of our comments were on those sections.
[1:52:15] So under development rights, we wanted to update the affordable by design definition to include market rate condominiums.
[1:52:22] and include only a no VHR de-distriction rather than requiring a achievable de-distriction.
[1:52:31] As a participant in this group, I'll say that a lot of the other groups have participate, do not support this.
[1:52:41] And then there is concerns about conversion of TRP commercial floor area to only housing, which was in the regional plan.
[1:52:47] So our concern is that if TRPA takes their pot of commercial floor area that they have to
[1:52:53] distribute to the different jurisdictions that CFA as a limited resource won't be used
[1:52:59] for economic development projects.
[1:53:03] And then the last was we support any TRPA recommended housing replacement to all jurisdictions,
[1:53:12] but we want to be able to opt out if we have a policy that's equivalent or better than what
[1:53:17] RPA is proposing as well so that our own jurisdiction has some sort of control in that sense.
[1:53:24] For example, if TRPA is creating an inclusionary housing policy, we can have ours in place of whatever theirs is proposing.
[1:53:33] And then under development process, we are in support of supporting higher thresholds for discretionary review.
[1:53:40] Because a lot of the projects that we get in E-Multi family project has to go through a
[1:53:45] hearings officer with TRPA and so we would hope that they would increase that threshold
[1:53:50] from four units to a higher amount, just like we do at the city level.
[1:53:56] And then we're also in support of environmental exemptions for up to four plex from TRPA
[1:54:00] project level and environmental review, and we wanted it to align with what's happening
[1:54:05] with CEQA as well, so it creates more consistency and transparency for developers.
[1:54:13] All right, with water quality, there are improvements to help achieve the housing need.
[1:54:19] The first is development costs and fees.
[1:54:21] So this includes options other than coverage limitations and area-wide stormwater systems to
[1:54:26] treat personal level stormwater run-off.
[1:54:29] The next is to install area-wide stormwater improvements.
[1:54:33] The next is to use updated soil maps.
[1:54:36] I forget what year the current soil maps are being used for, but this could create more
[1:54:41] development potential in the region as well and thinking about different parcels and
[1:54:47] how much is allowed to be developed on each one of those parcels and then to re-evaluate
[1:54:52] the excess coverage mitigation fees.
[1:54:54] Some of our staff and comments included in support of exempting projects from
[1:55:00] Average transfer fees for projects we want to see, such as ADUs, affordable, moderate income housing, and then we're also in support of area white stormwater improvements with a caveat that they cost a lot of money and may not be able to accommodate some projects as well due to the area that the project is built in.
[1:55:22] The next section is increasing housing choice, so the first is expanding housing sites.
[1:55:28] Expand geographic scope for incentives so right now a lot of the incentives are based in town centers
[1:55:33] We have limited town centers and there's different boundaries for bonus units
[1:55:38] There's different boundaries for different incentives
[1:55:40] So we're hoping to expand some of those boundaries, especially if it's across the street someone couldn't build an ADO
[1:55:47] When someone else could
[1:55:49] for example
[1:55:50] Also allowing missing middle housing and more neighborhoods so thinking about that and
[1:55:56] and allowing encouraging housing on public or institutional lands.
[1:56:01] And then the last is to facilitate transitional support of housing.
[1:56:06] The next is building renovation or rehabilitation.
[1:56:09] So this is to support any rehab that's going on with current buildings that we do have within the city,
[1:56:15] or throughout the region.
[1:56:17] And the next is housing occupancies.
[1:56:19] So this is looking out and locking vacant housing units.
[1:56:22] Supporting a housing authority to manage
[1:56:24] de-districtions and programs, because right now there's
[1:56:27] different entities requiring de-districtions.
[1:56:31] And so, thinking about who is overseeing
[1:56:34] those different de-districtions and making
[1:56:36] ensuring that they're being set in place
[1:56:39] and that other people aren't moving into those units.
[1:56:43] And then also establishing stable sources
[1:56:45] of funding for de-districted housing.
[1:56:48] And the last is development standards
[1:56:50] in area plan process improvements and this is to allow higher density and height standards.
[1:56:59] So our staff comments were to really facilitate transitional support of housing and alignment
[1:57:04] with California state law.
[1:57:06] This is also in line with what's proposed in our housing element as well because there's
[1:57:11] been a lot of changes in allowing this type of housing and then housing occupancy, unlocking
[1:57:17] They get housing units, jurisdictions, have to fund these programs and implement them so
[1:57:21] where our district should have more control of what programs and everything are taking
[1:57:27] place.
[1:57:29] Support housing authority to manage de-dercercated programs and restrictions.
[1:57:35] And then the last is for development standards.
[1:57:38] So in line with our different area plans that have all been approved by the City Council,
[1:57:44] We want to allow higher density and height standards and we know that coverage is a limiting factor for most of these developments.
[1:57:52] It's not necessarily always the height and density.
[1:57:55] However, many of the members of this group are against allowing any units that are not redirected at all.
[1:58:05] Let's see.
[1:58:07] Yes.
[1:58:11] Or we can wait till then.
[1:58:17] would rather have seen a study session on where we could really go through this in detail.
[1:58:23] and I've expressed that thought.
[1:58:27] But as we go through, I don't want to lose anything.
[1:58:32] Okay, go ahead.
[1:58:35] But everybody for questions, if we go with one person.
[1:58:38] So if we're going to open up for questions,
[1:58:40] I'd like to kind of like to get to a stopping point a little bit.
[1:58:43] I'm sure we can find a stopping point.
[1:58:47] Well, I just want to go through.
[1:58:49] I want to give everybody the equal opportunity to ask a question.
[1:58:52] If we are going to stop now, if this is where.
[1:58:57] Yeah, how much, let's go ahead and finish and then I think we found the questions.
[1:59:01] Great. Yeah, it's just a couple more slides. Okay. So, um, one of our other big comments was
[1:59:08] talking a lot with other members of the Tahoe Living Working Group about how opposing height
[1:59:13] and dead to the increases actually works against environmental goals. Um, and then we wanted to
[1:59:19] also concentrate more housing and town centers and mixed use areas, as I said, like expanding
[1:59:24] some of those areas where they're allowed
[1:59:26] so different housing types are
[1:59:28] throughout different neighborhoods.
[1:59:31] And then also one thing that we've continuously noted
[1:59:34] is that the majority of the city is within half mile of transit.
[1:59:38] And so we want to have higher density in the city
[1:59:41] because that allows more people to use public transit
[1:59:46] and some of the other options that are being created as well.
[1:59:51] And then as far as area plan process improvements,
[1:59:53] and we spoke a lot about reducing the number of TRP meetings for approvals for area plans.
[2:00:00] So, right now, they have to go through APC, RPC and the governing board, and it also goes through
[2:00:05] here through the city for planning commission and then, as well, the city council, which is a lot
[2:00:11] of meetings, and so reducing some of that as well.
[2:00:17] And now I'll turn it over to John to talk about
[2:00:19] water quality and mobility mitigation fees.
[2:00:26] We've been meeting Mayor Bass and members of the council
[2:00:28] for the record, John Hitchcock. I just have a couple slides to talk about mitigation fees that's
[2:00:34] associated with TRPA in developing projects.
[2:00:38] The first item here is watercolumn mitigation fees.
[2:00:39] These are fees that have to be paid for any project.
[2:00:42] So you're creating any sort of new land coverage,
[2:00:45] any new project is subject to $1.86 square foot.
[2:00:48] And based on average, you know,
[2:00:51] on average, base level coverage of 1500, 2000 square feet,
[2:00:54] you'll essentially look in anywhere from 274,000 square feet
[2:00:58] of fees for putting new land coverage on the ground.
[2:01:00] There's also what TRP considers excess coverage, this is excess coverage in excess of your base allowable.
[2:01:09] Those are also subject to fees that you need to mitigate that set $8.50 square foot.
[2:01:13] There is a news nuance on that.
[2:01:15] If you're doing a project generally, that fee is based on a percentage of your construction cost.
[2:01:22] However, you choose to use any of TRP incentives such as previous payers or previous decks.
[2:01:28] You have to mitigate that fee in full 100%.
[2:01:32] And then also creating any coverage in the city right away is also subject to your communication
[2:01:36] fee and that is $8.50 a square foot.
[2:01:40] Generally, in our application process, we usually see applicants paying anywhere from 800 to
[2:01:45] 1000 square foot in fees for off-site coverage.
[2:01:48] That's the coverage to connect the property to the city right away in the city street.
[2:01:51] A mobility mitigation fees, this previously used to be called air quality mitigation fees, and was based on average daily vehicle trips.
[2:01:59] A couple years ago, TRPA chains from air quality mitigation fees, some mobility mitigation fees, which is based on vehicle miles traveled.
[2:02:07] This applies to any project, not just residential, but any project in a basin that generates additional vehicle miles traveled.
[2:02:14] And it applies to vacant parcels, existing development that's adding any sort of new
[2:02:21] development rights, whether it's commercial, whether it's tourists, or whether it's residential.
[2:02:26] And so you can have an existing development on site that chooses to add additional units
[2:02:30] of use.
[2:02:31] That will be subject to the mobility and mitigation fees.
[2:02:35] These fees are calculated based on the project and the type of use that's being proposed
[2:02:41] and it's proximity to a town center.
[2:02:45] The theory is that if your project is located in the town center,
[2:02:49] your mitigation measures should be less.
[2:02:51] However, that's not what we actually see in the real world.
[2:02:55] Currently today, for residential uses,
[2:02:57] a cost of a VMT is $213.76 per VMT generated.
[2:03:06] To give you an idea, on an average size, 2,000 square foot single-family home, an applicant
[2:03:16] probably can be looking at $8,000 to $10,000 in mitigation fees in order to construct.
[2:03:23] It's just make it very clear that VMT, mitigation fees are not restricted.
[2:03:29] Multifound projects are not subject to the mitigation fees, so affordable, moderate, and achievable.
[2:03:35] And then see here, so non-dead restrictive projects would be expected to pay these VMT mitigation fees.
[2:03:44] We did provide comments to the working group.
[2:03:47] It staff feels that the whole mitigation fee process lacks some transparency,
[2:03:52] and there seems to be some inequality in the process itself.
[2:03:56] Depending on the use type, your mitigation fee can vary.
[2:04:01] If any of you have ever had experience with TRPA's project impact assessment tool, the number of
[2:04:08] uses that are listed on that tool is very limited.
[2:04:11] And as everyone knows when you're dealing with uses, you have variability in uses, right?
[2:04:16] In commercial use, you can have a eating and drinking place, you can have a coffee shop, you
[2:04:19] can have ice cream shop.
[2:04:20] Those have different types of attractions.
[2:04:24] So that kind of affects your VNTs and our experience is that the PIA tool is not robust enough for us to figure out these mitigation tools.
[2:04:34] So we spend a lot of time actually on the phone with TRP Strat trying to figure out there's mitigation, which tends to kind of delay the whole project.
[2:04:43] And that concludes the presentation in Jennifer and I can, I'm sorry, Jessica and I can answer any questions.
[2:05:01] I wanted to draw your attention. I had this marked office, second I don't. Two page. I think it was 28,
[2:05:12] yes, 28, 29 and 30 of the report.
[2:05:15] I'll just staff what the actual report report, the policy, the policy, the policy recommend.
[2:05:23] It's the subject-blind increase housing choice, the expanding housing sites.
[2:05:29] So that's an item that's been discussed for the next strategic plan cycle for the city to investigate a residential area plan, which we do not currently have.
[2:05:42] We don't have a specific zoning plan for our residential zones.
[2:05:46] Only for our commercial mixed use highway 50 adjacent areas.
[2:05:50] We don't have a zoning plan for our residential areas.
[2:05:54] We simply inherit the TRPA zone.
[2:05:57] And I want to understand, it looks like they are proposing that
[2:06:02] localities can allow to implement dueplexes in residential areas.
[2:06:08] But if I'm reading it right, and this is my question to make sure I'm
[2:06:11] understanding this correct, that the TRPA themselves will not automatically update their
[2:06:19] residential area plans on the TRPA side to allow dueplexes. They are allowing localities
[2:06:26] to do it, but they're not going to do it on their own. So, for example, if this passes,
[2:06:33] El Dorado County out in Mayors could if they wanted to allow dueplex, you know, change zoning
[2:06:39] will allow due pecks, but it won't automatically allow due pecks on the TRPA site. Is that
[2:06:44] understanding broadly correct?
[2:06:47] Yes, broadly that is correct. The current zoning for residential areas is the Planner
[2:06:53] Statement System, which is a holdover from the 1980s. The TRPA process does allow
[2:07:01] local jurisdictions to adopt area plans for residential areas, and as part of the process,
[2:07:05] we can't propose increased densities of duplexes as-
[2:07:09] Well, we're recognizing that we exist, you know,
[2:07:14] sometimes to my frustration in a, in a community
[2:07:16] that includes not just the city, so we are impacted by the zoning.
[2:07:22] We are functionally, our residents are functionally impacted
[2:07:24] by the zoning decisions of others in our neighborhoods.
[2:07:27] How much of our region has residential area plans
[2:07:32] that would allow higher density than single families, right?
[2:07:38] That, you know, that are in that space now.
[2:07:40] And I think the answer is zero, but I want to,
[2:07:43] I want to, I'm asking you to make sure of my understanding.
[2:07:46] That's, that's a good question.
[2:07:48] Incline recently adopted an area plan for the whole county,
[2:07:52] but I haven't read it.
[2:07:54] No, I'll be honest.
[2:07:55] I know Plash of County has two.
[2:07:57] I haven't memorized incline zoning planning.
[2:07:59] Yeah, I do know in some residential areas within the city we do allow higher
[2:08:04] density, for example, the, what we call the Emma Bay Connector going out of the city, and then
[2:08:10] the couple portions of the special areas along Emma Bay Road going out towards
[2:08:14] Camperchusen, which are residential areas which we do allow higher density. So there's a
[2:08:17] president in the single family residence shows what we do allow some increased deaths.
[2:08:21] We have bits where like there's bits in Al-Tahoe that have, that have, you know, non-conforming
[2:08:27] pre-existing multifamilies, but broadly we don't generally allow it every, we allow the mushroom
[2:08:34] house McMansions, those are allowed everywhere in a residential area, but if that same building
[2:08:39] were split down the middle and had to units, that's allowed almost nowhere. It's allowed in certain
[2:08:44] areas. It's allowed in a few very few areas, but none of the other regions like the,
[2:08:53] not in the
[2:08:55] them do, and the changes here don't change that unless the counties themselves also subsequently
[2:09:03] change that.
[2:09:04] So is there an opportunity for us to give input to this process to say that maybe what the
[2:09:10] TRPA should do is change that by default, and if the counties want to undo it, and reject
[2:09:18] that, maybe they can choose areas where they disallow it, but the idea is, you know, I'm not,
[2:09:24] I don't have a lot of reason to believe that the regional counties are going to be terribly responsive to the housing crisis because they haven't been so far.
[2:09:31] So is there an opportunity in this process for us to give that kind of feedback to the TRPA?
[2:09:37] Well, definitely that's a different process for sure where you opt out instead of opt in.
[2:09:46] I do know that Tira paid, has set President where local jurisdictions can opt out of certain
[2:09:53] standards.
[2:09:54] But I think that would be something that I would probably defer to Ms. Fink if she would
[2:09:59] have any.
[2:10:00] Comments on that. Is to whether or not they're able to do that or whether or not we can lobby effectively the TRPA to adopt that as part of this draft. As part of an updated draft. Okay. So that I'll bring that back when we come back for discussion. That's something I wanted to talk about.
[2:10:17] I wanted to thank you for the announcements, Mr. Jenkins.
[2:10:25] First, I want to compliment staff for after I've located the staff comments at the end of the report. I appreciate it.
[2:10:34] work that you've done and I appreciate the work that TRPA has done in developing ideas for
[2:10:42] the region.
[2:10:46] My focus goes back to questions that I've asked in the past and no fault of yours or anyone
[2:10:53] that they I don't think they've been completely answered.
[2:10:58] But do the rules that are being proposed by TRPA apply to the region?
[2:11:05] Do the rules that the framework, does it apply to the region?
[2:11:10] The answer would be yes, that's that's their intent.
[2:11:13] And I noticed in the report that there was a, there was some analysis that allegedly,
[2:11:21] whoops, allegedly, that's a value word.
[2:11:25] That was done to identify the rena,
[2:11:29] we would call California the rena, rena needs.
[2:11:34] I was unaware that that was being done.
[2:11:38] I think those numbers are very important,
[2:11:42] respectfully, while I love our friends at the RPA and say,
[2:11:46] I don't have any faith necessarily in the numbers,
[2:11:49] Because I don't see the region stepping up and doing what is what is necessary and I would I would ask if you think it would be useful to have an independent analysis done that we are required actually to
[2:12:03] The right we are required in California to have
[2:12:07] Because the region would you agree the region needs to do it share of affordable housing not just the city of South Lake Tahoe
[2:12:15] Would you agree
[2:12:16] I would just, so this is referring to the Lake Tahoe workforce housing needs assessment.
[2:12:22] So TRPA did contract consultant, so it's B.A.E. urban economics who conducted this study.
[2:12:28] It is different than the rena, rena as was discussed in a few meetings ago.
[2:12:35] It's really thinking about the base needs split across the entire state of California.
[2:12:41] This needs assessment looks at new construction, but it also looks at substandard housing units.
[2:12:45] And so it's a different scope, but I think it's a good step in looking at what's actually happening within the Bayesian, and it compares to the jobs that are within each jurisdiction.
[2:12:58] And then there's a really good summary of each jurisdiction was asked to provide because this was part of the Tahoe living working group as well.
[2:13:05] So we reviewed it as part of that group and I believe we met with all the local jurisdictions also spoke about it as well.
[2:13:12] So it gives us summary of what each jurisdiction in the region is doing around housing.
[2:13:17] Yeah, is it not true that the state of California has said that we have met our rena
[2:13:21] numbers because of the fine work that's been done by previous councils in this council and
[2:13:26] providing affordable housing is that is that true.
[2:13:29] We are achieving some of our numbers.
[2:13:30] That's correct.
[2:13:31] Yeah, it seems like that while the state HCD is suing people who some of whom I met at
[2:13:37] cities. They're they're applauding the work that all of you and this council and previous
[2:13:43] council's done so. The other thing is when we talk about building affordable housing
[2:13:50] and you have a California state agency that's buying land and single family subdivisions
[2:13:56] that's non-sensitive lands and taking it off the tax roll and taking off the building roll.
[2:14:01] does that? Is that not really an opportunity to create additional housing? If some of those nonsense
[2:14:09] that have lands in existing residential subdivisions were made available and did the TRPF look at that
[2:14:15] as an opportunity? I hope that's not my car. I would say that, yeah, that's part of the, we've brought
[2:14:24] it up. It's one of the programs in our current housing element and proposed in our future housing
[2:14:30] element as well to work with, sorry, I'm going to do each other.
[2:14:37] It's not going to work with public entities around the like that
[2:14:40] own land to think about how we can collaborate to get some housing on some of
[2:14:44] those different public lands throughout the city. I know that it was a big topic.
[2:14:49] It's also part of the talk of living working group. That was discussed in
[2:14:51] it's one of the policy recommendations as well. Well, again, I want to
[2:14:56] you, if I may, on the staff assessment.
[2:15:00] I look to you as our professional staff to be the ones to make the recommendations that we particularly pay attention to as our professional staff, and because you're closest to the folks here.
[2:15:14] And so I have no problem with your recommendations with maybe some additions that I'll bring up when we come to the final conversations that we have.
[2:15:23] Great, thank you Mr. Jenkins, Mr. Sorghum.
[2:15:28] Yeah.
[2:15:30] Gosh, I lost. I lost to your point.
[2:15:34] There was something that I was going to write down.
[2:15:37] When we got to the end, I got lost.
[2:15:41] These note pads have real values.
[2:15:42] I know, no, actually, I put notes.
[2:15:45] But if this...
[2:15:45] I have to put down my question.
[2:15:47] Underdevelopment writes update,
[2:15:48] affordable by design definition to include
[2:15:50] market rate condominiums and include
[2:15:52] And only a no VHR deed restriction, rather than requiring an achievable deed restriction.
[2:15:59] I wondered if you could just articulate that a little bit for me, I want to make sure I understand that.
[2:16:06] So, we've been doing this for quite some time, actively engaged in TRP staff, and also in the working
[2:16:12] group, that from the C's perspective, we're looking for housing of all types.
[2:16:17] And we strongly feel that any incentives that you provide to deed restrictive units with
[2:16:22] a photo-moder that Chewbull should also apply to market
[2:16:25] rate units.
[2:16:27] And by providing those incentives, also in conjunction
[2:16:30] with our area of planning process, where we're
[2:16:34] adopting minimum density standards,
[2:16:38] trying to get higher density housing
[2:16:40] and trying to encourage a photo-body design,
[2:16:45] meaning smaller-kind of minimum units, by the fact
[2:16:48] that they cost cheaper to build, that they then
[2:16:50] become affordable to the workforce.
[2:16:52] So that's the concept that we've been working with
[2:16:55] and trying to encourage TARP-A to adapt.
[2:16:59] Yeah, and I'll just add one more thing is one thing
[2:17:02] that we've drawn a nice speak a lot about
[2:17:05] is with the TAs that we provide for 80 user multi-family
[2:17:09] units for free as part of a city council resolution.
[2:17:13] With that, we see that a lot of people don't want to put
[2:17:17] any data restrictions on those homes, that they
[2:17:20] building, but they are fine with putting the no VHRP
[2:17:23] restriction, and so we've seen them say, like, oh, we can get these
[2:17:27] bonus units from TRPA, but once they see those
[2:17:30] de-districtions, they come to us and they're like, we wait for
[2:17:33] years, and we'll say no to VHRs, and so that's what we've been
[2:17:36] advocating. Okay, that's how I thought I understood it. So thank
[2:17:41] you Ms. Wackenham, Limelli, because I did understand it. So then my
[2:17:44] The question to you is how optimistic are you about the direction of this report and whether or not more projects will be approved and whether or not this will mean more achievable housing in our city?
[2:18:02] I think depending on which codes are actually adopted by TRPA governing board and we'll see what happens once the draft EIS has released and what the study says.
[2:18:15] Um, I think with, I'll go back to the,
[2:18:29] with the three policy alternatives.
[2:18:32] I think with number two, which is a housing for alternative.
[2:18:37] Staff has been advocating for a lot of these policies since 2020.
[2:18:42] And so we're hopeful that a lot of these changes that we see daily when projects come in
[2:18:47] and what some of those barriers and challenges are to development.
[2:18:50] we hope that that could open up more possibilities in some of the
[2:18:54] parcels that we do have left or redevelopment where nothing is being
[2:18:59] done currently because of some of those restrictions.
[2:19:01] I mean, we can from from Mark's experience from service branch.
[2:19:05] I mean, we can point to a couple of housing projects in the city that we're
[2:19:10] really only feasible because of the city's art incentive program where we
[2:19:16] to use to units of use, where we've had very successful in constructing at least, I think, about 20
[2:19:25] multi-family projects. We'd give restrictions on them that they can't be used for short-term
[2:19:29] rentals, but they are rental units, and that's basically your workforce housing that you're
[2:19:33] looking for. So we think the model that we use, we think TARPA can probably expand on that,
[2:19:39] and I think by doing that we think that we can get more housing on the ground, and not just
[2:19:42] She will, but the workforce housing that we're looking for,
[2:19:45] the missing middle.
[2:19:46] That's, that answer was perfect because I think there's a lot of
[2:19:50] value in what you've turned away, like the data of what projects
[2:19:54] you've had to say, no, I'm sorry, that won't work out.
[2:19:57] And you've already, you know,
[2:20:00] But made clear to me that it's often because of the deed restriction and that there would be maybe a chance for us to get more housing if it was a VHR restriction in exchange.
[2:20:12] Thank you.
[2:20:14] Thank you.
[2:20:15] Mr. Roberts, any questions?
[2:20:17] Great.
[2:20:19] Yeah, I don't go ahead to public comment.
[2:20:21] I do just want to remind that everybody, one of the greatest things I think about this is it is a regional thing that we will see throughout the whole lake.
[2:20:29] And there was a huge amount of work put into it.
[2:20:32] Ms. Karen, I think it's here tonight from T.R.P.A.
[2:20:34] who really led the Taliban living working group from the side of T.R.P.A.
[2:20:38] So there's just been a lot of work and it will go across the region,
[2:20:41] which I think could be a positive thing for housing and tariff altogether.
[2:20:45] With that, we'll go to public comment.
[2:20:46] Thank you both. That was a great presentation.
[2:20:49] Anybody here in the room that would like to give public comment
[2:20:52] on the side of them please come forward.
[2:20:55] Okay, seeing none, I'll go to Zoom.
[2:20:57] We have a couple of hands raised.
[2:21:00] First, we have Ms. Cade Bauer.
[2:21:11] Ms. Cade Bauer, would you like to provide public comment?
[2:21:14] Apologies, I hit Cade muted on accident.
[2:21:18] Thank you, City Council.
[2:21:20] This is Heather Cade Bauer.
[2:21:22] It's all like Tahoe.
[2:21:24] I think you staff, I really like this report.
[2:21:28] I like the focus on workforce housing
[2:21:32] and the vacation rental restrictions.
[2:21:37] The one thing that struck me is the height
[2:21:39] increases to allow for more density.
[2:21:42] It's been mentioned and it's a way to increase workforce housing,
[2:21:47] which is for my understanding that midtown area plan
[2:21:50] when they increased housing or the height,
[2:21:54] it was to increase to allow for more workforce and affordable housing.
[2:21:58] But then immediately after the Midtown area plan was approved, there was a project at the
[2:22:05] Old Nell site that went before the Planning Commission and it already previously been approved
[2:22:11] for like a 27 foot allowance and with the new Midtown area plan, they used that to go to the
[2:22:19] Planning Commission to increase their height, which definitely affects several people, but they
[2:22:25] acknowledge during that planning commission meeting that those units will more than likely
[2:22:32] be vacation runals.
[2:22:35] And so I just would like to urge the council to make sure everything that you do is continue
[2:22:41] on with workforce housing needs to be our key.
[2:22:44] We need to as people that live and work here be able to afford to rent a place and we need
[2:22:51] stop allowing for high exceptions when it's obviously only going to accommodate vacation rentals.
[2:22:58] Thank you. Thank you.
[2:23:03] All right. Next we have Mr. Friedrich.
[2:23:10] Good evening.
[2:23:11] John Friedrich here. I just want to say great presentation, Jessica and John. I thought all the
[2:23:16] proposals were well-reasoned and thoughtful and certainly contribute to making housing
[2:23:22] more affordable for locals which I think the broad agreement is a top priority in our
[2:23:29] city and in looking at the TRPA alternatives in the EIS I would say a blend of
[2:23:35] housing forward and housing preservation makes sense I hope it's not just one or
[2:23:40] the other it seems like we need both and then just I thought that came to mind
[2:23:45] is with the mobility mitigation fee. I think it'll be worth exploring when residents
[2:23:51] are converted to BHR's outside of town centers and the same places that trigger mobility mitigation
[2:24:00] fees for other new developments. If there's a conversion from a second home or residents to a
[2:24:07] BHR with high occupancy that generates a lot of traffic, it seems like that ought to also
[2:24:13] be subject to higher fees to mitigate the impact of those additional auto trips that weren't there
[2:24:18] before, so that's something I was suggest, considering.
[2:24:21] Thank you.
[2:24:22] Thank you.
[2:24:24] No additional hands raised, Mayor.
[2:24:26] Great.
[2:24:26] Thank you.
[2:24:27] We'll bring it back in Mr. Jenkins.
[2:24:34] Mr. Morgan.
[2:24:35] I wanted to be sure that.
[2:24:36] Whoops.
[2:24:36] I turned my mic on first.
[2:24:39] Will the environmental impact statement that's being done
[2:24:42] by the Tahoe Regional Planets as you have an economic analysis
[2:24:46] of what their proposals mean for the economics of the region?
[2:24:51] And my interest of course is more specifically as it relates to the city of South Lake Tahoe.
[2:24:58] Are they, do these policy?
[2:25:00] These encourage economic sustainability in growth and funds for environmental protection or do they do something other than that.
[2:25:09] And that's, and not by the policy side, you know, a study or an economic development study, not by a policy side got person, although I have a certain affection for those.
[2:25:22] But by an economist who can independently evaluate the economics.
[2:25:28] Okay, so that's like one question,
[2:25:34] and the other thing is this whole, it occurred to me for a long time that the whole coverage issue was a substitute for having adequate in appropriate drainage.
[2:25:46] In fact, John Hester, to his credit, as he departs T.R.P.A., he said that regional basins could
[2:25:56] provide the drainage facilities that we've never had, is that, and that's what I think
[2:26:02] the direction that we were taking is that, is that correct, John, or somebody,
[2:26:11] I'm just
[2:26:11] getting rubbed up yourself.
[2:26:12] of the record drawn in history, so TARPA did adopt some of the standards that allow coverage
[2:26:22] exemptions or waivers of coverage for de-districted units for certain neighborhoods that
[2:26:30] have air-wide treatment that are implemented and maintained by the public agency or some sort
[2:26:39] did some sort of district.
[2:26:41] So let me ask, then thank you, that's precise question.
[2:26:46] It's now that I remember that I did read that.
[2:26:50] If there's a regional basin that is taking drainage water off,
[2:26:56] and that basin benefit does not apply to businesses that might exist in the area
[2:27:01] or residential units of all types, what is the nexus then for
[2:27:07] that we're charged under California law.
[2:27:10] What is the nexus that we have,
[2:27:13] that there are people that they're contributing drainage
[2:27:17] water this going into a basin?
[2:27:19] What, why should there be a, why should other,
[2:27:21] some people benefit and other people's not
[2:27:23] if they're in the basin or service area?
[2:27:26] Why, I don't understand it.
[2:27:29] That's a good question.
[2:27:31] I mean, I think, so, let me think about this a bit.
[2:28:03] The
[2:28:05] hand of that. Right now, we don't know that answer. My understanding is we have an RP out to try
[2:28:10] to answer, to get that answer, whether the city system can't take on that additional runoff,
[2:28:16] which then we would benefit from additional coverage waivers.
[2:28:22] Is it reasonable to assume that if we're going to design regional basins, which I am delighted
[2:28:30] with support from TRPA and from our own staff that they serve the entire area that needs
[2:28:37] to be that they be of a size and of a depth and of a quality that they can serve the
[2:28:42] entire area and not just portions of an area.
[2:28:46] That would, I was, I was, I think Kennedy janked years ago.
[2:28:50] There are cities that that actually do that and I think I've probably given or I can give
[2:28:54] you examples of cities that have their wide basins that serve everyone, where they have
[2:28:59] drainage facilities that connect to those basins, so that the streets aren't flooded and so
[2:29:04] on.
[2:29:05] But it seems to me that would be reasonable with that not be reasonable if it's technically
[2:29:12] possible to do.
[2:29:14] Yes, that would be reasonable, right?
[2:29:16] One is feasible and technical and three we have the funding to do that.
[2:29:22] Well, and the other thing, we have a number of properties that are owned by the federal
[2:29:26] government and state government inside the city limits.
[2:29:29] that would be perfect basins, it would seem to me, I'm not an engineer, don't claim to be,
[2:29:38] don't have that expertise.
[2:29:41] So therefore I can practice it without liability, I guess, I could be a public worksperson
[2:29:46] practicing without liability.
[2:29:48] But I mean, it seems to me that if we're going to design a basin, that we need to design
[2:29:52] it to serve an area and we divide the city up into areas, the extent that that's possible,
[2:29:56] where the basins could serve those areas.
[2:29:58] And then, uh, we-
[2:30:00] I always said we have lots of money, it's just how we spend it, but they're expensive, but the other, so you agree that if we could do it, that it would be a good idea. Is that fair? I'm not putting words, I don't want to put.
[2:30:13] Well, I think, you know, I think ROI treatment is a good idea, you know, seriously.
[2:30:20] The city itself, the city is broken up into watersheds and some watersheds.
[2:30:25] Some of those are actually, you know, directly connected to the lake and those are the ones
[2:30:28] that we try to focus most of our efforts on, but then we also have other watersheds that are
[2:30:33] not connected that may not, may not need not work, but, you know, from a, I mean, land use
[2:30:38] The planning was right, doesn't make sense to have airway treatment.
[2:30:41] Yes.
[2:30:41] And if that can benefit, you know, private properties,
[2:30:46] and they would get some sort of waiver coverage waivers or some of the incentives.
[2:30:51] And I think that would make sense.
[2:30:54] Mr. Jenkins, if I may, the rules may have changed a bit since we did this,
[2:30:58] but we do have a good example within the city.
[2:31:02] When we redeveloped the Harrison Avenue area,
[2:31:05] We did handle the drainage in that area within the basins that were constructed by the city and the storm water system there.
[2:31:14] And those private properties were able to benefit from that by not having to put in their own individual infiltration on each property.
[2:31:24] I believe they also are allowed a higher base allowable coverage limit, which most of those properties are already overcovered, but it does affect their requirement to mitigate that excess coverage when they go to redevelop.
[2:31:41] And we did see private investment in that area after we developed that project.
[2:31:47] So I do think we do have an example of that within the city, it's more of a commercial district example, what they're talking about here is expanding that to residential.
[2:31:58] Well, and into the city manager's point by the way, the answers that you all have given her excellent.
[2:32:05] But I think the answer is, or the question really is, should that these are examples of things that we are already doing that make a lot of sense.
[2:32:15] it's good environmentally. And I just want to be sure that there are no rules put in place by
[2:32:20] our regional friends that would discourage or otherwise prohibit us from doing what we're already doing.
[2:32:27] And if that's an assurance, then I get pretty happy. And that was the crescendo of my joy.
[2:32:38] I would deferred a misfaint, but I think I think TRP would probably prefer airway treatment
[2:32:44] than parts of my parcel, level treatment, which hasn't been proven to be very effective.
[2:32:50] Because of maintenance issues.
[2:32:51] And just last the last thing, the last question I have, something that has always troubled
[2:32:57] me when I worked here and then afterwards, and you've heard this before, when we talk
[2:33:04] about coverage, if you have enough money in this basin or in our city, you can buy coverage
[2:33:13] so that a property that would otherwise only cover a certain portion, and I can give you
[2:33:19] examples of a new construction going on. I won't name the street, but you can probably guess
[2:33:23] because it's in the case,
[2:33:26] that you can almost cover the entire parcel if you buy coverage.
[2:33:30] So it doesn't seem to me, there's any relationship between drainage and drainage and the coverage
[2:33:41] if you're covering everything without having the facilities that are treated.
[2:33:45] Is that, I don't know, maybe on wrong.
[2:33:48] Well, there's, there's the chirp he allows base level coverage and then they allow additional
[2:33:53] coverage.
[2:33:53] You can transfer in based on your, your part size.
[2:33:57] So give example, 5,000 square foot parcel, generally your base level coverage is just
[2:34:00] 30% of about 1,500 square feet, you're allowed to purchase another 300 square feet to bring
[2:34:04] in up to 1,800 square feet, and then you can get pervious exemptions for the driveway
[2:34:09] and then you can get pervious exemptions for the deck, which then zero out that.
[2:34:13] So, at the end of the day, coverage wise, you're looking up in the 2, that 2,200 square feet.
[2:34:21] Thank you.
[2:34:22] Thank you.
[2:34:23] Thanks.
[2:34:23] Mr. Robbins.
[2:34:25] Yeah.
[2:34:25] So, my, like, I, along the lines of the questions I had asked in the question section
[2:34:32] was, I think we should provide direction to staff to engage in vigorous, if not aggressive
[2:34:40] advocacy for making the density increase for residential areas based on why either mandatory
[2:34:52] preferably or opt-out at a minimum rather than something that they were required to opt-in
[2:34:58] Thank you.
[2:35:00] This goes to, I think, the very practical observation that the surrounding communities are choosing
[2:35:05] very much to not do their part. Like they could, and they have made it clear through through
[2:35:12] actions that they are choosing not to.
[2:35:16] There are no shortage of mushroom house, McIntyre
[2:35:20] McMansions, whatever you want to call them, that go up on both county areas. But none of
[2:35:28] can be dueplexes, even if it's the same structure size. And that's absurd. That's, you know,
[2:35:35] the kind of thing we want to incentivize here. And this is a small, you know, we're not a sprawling
[2:35:41] area of the way, like a spark is, or the Sacramento suburbs. So the impact on, like additional
[2:35:47] transit is not bad. And the fact that we want more people writing our transit services is the other
[2:35:55] part of it. Limiting it to just the areas that are considered town centers is just not
[2:36:01] sufficient. You know, we are building a lot of these
[2:36:06] make mansions. We, the community, you know, are building a lot of these make mansions.
[2:36:11] If you could, they could be dueplexes. There's a good shot that two rental streams would
[2:36:17] allow that same physical size structure to pencil out as being a profitable investment over
[2:36:25] a single, you know, a McMansion, that would be nothing but a vacation home.
[2:36:33] And if the regional governments have chosen not to do their part because they are interested
[2:36:39] in protecting the property values and seeing property values continue to go up for current
[2:36:45] residents.
[2:36:46] And for billionaires, particularly on the North Shore, where they like to say that the big
[2:36:56] You know, the value of this is that, yes, we have, we have on deck the action item to fix this in our town, but this applies to the whole basin of which we are a part, and our housing crisis is severely impacted by the regional governments, the regional communities, unwillingness to address the housing crisis themselves.
[2:37:20] And so I think that should be part of the direction we issue today, and I'd like to get feedback from the rest of the council as to, you know, whether or not you think that's something we should, we should provide as feedback.
[2:37:32] I don't know, I can't tell you how the TRPA's board will eventually sit with that, you know, but the least we should engage in is advocacy.
[2:37:41] If we're not willing to advocate for it ourselves, you know, for others, then we certainly can't complain when other communities don't do their part.
[2:37:48] We didn't even ask.
[2:37:51] So, thank you, Mr. Robert.
[2:37:51] Thank you, Mr. Robert.
[2:37:52] I'm not on these materials.
[2:37:54] All right.
[2:37:55] Miss Oregon?
[2:37:56] No? Okay.
[2:37:58] Mr. Roberts.
[2:38:01] No.
[2:38:02] I really appreciate this presentation as a huge amount of work and very well done.
[2:38:08] But yeah, I agree with that on, you know, advocating for the base and wide density and, you know,
[2:38:13] making sure that these changes are base and wide, almost all of them.
[2:38:17] need to be based on what we're all on the same page and I'm not sure how we're supposed
[2:38:23] to structure our motion on this, but are there any other things that we want to add into
[2:38:31] what they already have in place on this presentation?
[2:38:33] Well Mr. Robinson has brought that up on it and again I think that this is a regional approval
[2:38:40] that does spread across the entire base and I think the way that it is now right is it kind
[2:38:44] and it gives each municipality or jurisdiction the ability to add the density.
[2:38:51] But it doesn't just automatically add it and then have them have to take it away.
[2:38:55] And so that's kind of what you're considering is that we kind of change the process to where
[2:39:00] you know, it's going to go across the base.
[2:39:02] And now again, I think for the public's efficacy, the TRPA is all five counties with representatives
[2:39:08] out of both states.
[2:39:10] And so the approval, of course, is a much different than here.
[2:39:14] You know, we're one voice on that board that we need to go in and know doubt that we can we can not ask for things and advocate
[2:39:22] But yeah, it's just that I kind of want to put that out there because it's not
[2:39:26] Yes, we can go and ask and say hey, you know change the way you're doing it which is kind of just 180 from because it's in a way
[2:39:33] They already allow that it's just backwards somewhat if you know it any because because
[2:39:38] Because you can either take it away or add it to the local jurisdiction has that ability
[2:39:43] it's just but the other way around right now is how I would see you know what I'm saying
[2:39:49] because right now it's just not going to be allowed and you add it and so if you want to keep
[2:39:53] it it's not allowed you just don't add it and you still have the choice to add it so either way
[2:39:58] it's just doing it the other way around.
[2:40:00] Problems, the regional governments have made it clear that they have no interest in addressing these problems.
[2:40:06] So we should at least make it an active thing where we are enabling higher density and that's the default now.
[2:40:15] Because if we just hope that the community that the regional governments will do the right thing,
[2:40:21] I think we have ample ample evidence that that isn't going to be the case.
[2:40:25] No, I'm not a disagreement with these are in like promoting, you know, it's in a way helping promote a way for them to
[2:40:31] To get that done, and I'm not necessarily opposed, but I'm just kind of putting it out that
[2:40:36] Yeah, how the TRPA may seem like.
[2:40:38] I have an actual moment to comment, but David has ahead of me on the on the American AI.
[2:40:42] I want to come in on this discussion.
[2:40:44] So we're just looking deeper into the policy recommendations report.
[2:40:48] So in the actual policy recommendations report, it does say that it could be implemented in two ways
[2:40:53] And two different approaches. And so one is the one that you all are discussing.
[2:40:59] So the first is TRPA could mandate the change in every single residential family neighborhood.
[2:41:04] Without the need for a area plan amendment or two,
[2:41:09] it could support the local jurisdictions and amending their area plans.
[2:41:13] So both of those options are discussed in the policy report.
[2:41:16] That's on page 25.
[2:41:18] Page 25.
[2:41:21] Okay, because it had like option A and B on 29 and 30, but this is on 25.
[2:41:27] Yes, so it's under the allow missing middle housing in more neighborhoods, under expanded housing sites.
[2:41:33] Great. Thank you. Yes, Mr. Jenkins. Thank you.
[2:41:36] I have always been an advocate for local control. So I am an advocate for that. I have been
[2:41:42] throughout my entire professional career and I still remain.
[2:41:48] Having said that, this city, like, like, cities in California, are all put under the
[2:41:56] arena system.
[2:41:58] With their told, you have a regional share of needs.
[2:42:03] We are not a typical city because we are the only city in California in the Tahoe region,
[2:42:07] in a by-state compact. Thus, the California can say whatever it wants about arena which we've done well with help with a lot of parties including our governor.
[2:42:23] But it doesn't apply to the region. So I don't know how we have a region. I don't know. We're kind of getting hit kind of both ways.
[2:42:32] And I agree with local discretion and government, that's why we're here.
[2:42:40] On the other hand, maybe TRPA should be adopting something like a rena, a rena number
[2:42:48] for the region, a rena number, though, that is done collaboratively within, by the way,
[2:42:57] I like B.A., I've known them for years, I like the work they do, or they used to do that
[2:43:03] not recently.
[2:43:04] I don't know them at well, but we're kind of caught in a trap.
[2:43:10] And then previous legal advice said, well, state law doesn't apply, well, state law doesn't
[2:43:15] apply.
[2:43:15] Well, I'm still confused when state law applies and it doesn't apply.
[2:43:20] Because on a lot of issues that we deal with, and this city has never really addressed
[2:43:26] that issue despite the fact that for two years I've been asking about that when the state law
[2:43:31] apply when does it not apply or do we just pick and choose which when it applies and
[2:43:35] doesn't apply and that's why I had hoped that with with with professional counsel that we
[2:43:42] would that we would get some advice on when when the laws when they pass housing laws and say
[2:43:49] We have to do this and that is a really apply, it doesn't apply, I don't know.
[2:43:55] So I think we're caught kind of in, I'd like to see the region do more, but I think in
[2:44:00] order to do that, TRPA has to set some standards of its own and assume and do what
[2:44:05] rena does, maybe that wouldn't pass the boardbook, that I think we should be advocating
[2:44:12] for, because I think what they want us to do is absorb all the affordable housing in the
[2:44:19] And I'm not prepared to do that.
[2:44:21] They need to do their part.
[2:44:23] And I want to be sure the region does their part.
[2:44:26] And if they don't do their part, then I don't,
[2:44:32] then I, well, then there's other options
[2:44:33] that we'd have to discuss.
[2:44:35] Thank you, Mr. Jenkins.
[2:44:37] Great.
[2:44:38] Before I go on to Mr. Robbins, just to remind us here,
[2:44:40] we're looking for a motion.
[2:44:41] If we do want to provide different policy direction,
[2:44:44] which Mr. Robbins has brought up.
[2:44:46] But I think we've discussed it quite a bit.
[2:44:47] So that's where we're at is trying to figure out.
[2:44:49] We want to put a motion forward to provide any policy direction.
[2:44:53] I want it.
[2:44:54] But we're kind of saying that I think I sent a letter and said that I agree with the staff recommendations today.
[2:45:00] With some additions. Yeah, that's what I was going to say. And then maybe Mr. Robbins has a motion. I was just going to say that I agree with the staff recommendations. I think I appreciate your engagement. And I can see how this is also going to support you in your negotiations for arena, because what you guys have put together as a report and what your recommendations are for TRPA will be good faith effort.
[2:45:27] when you have to show for the housing element and for arena,
[2:45:32] you know, what you're advocating for.
[2:45:34] So I just, I see all of these things
[2:45:38] in like a package.
[2:45:40] Like it seems to me like we're moving in the right direction.
[2:45:44] And I hear the frustration,
[2:45:47] I don't know that there's anything that we're going to do about that tonight.
[2:45:51] So I suggest that we take the recommendations from the city staff
[2:45:56] And maybe I agree, add something about density in residential areas or however the councilmember
[2:46:04] Robin sees that fit.
[2:46:06] And then we should make a motion and move this forward so we can get on to the rest of the
[2:46:10] business.
[2:46:11] So yeah, it seems like we've got where there's consensus on the staff recommendations
[2:46:15] and if you want to include in the motion that we basically ask for the TRPA to consider making
[2:46:22] the density upfront, it's going to be across the base and policy, instead of the jurisdiction
[2:46:28] I've been to do it themselves, and that basically is an ask that, you know, we can bring
[2:46:33] to them and see what they have to say.
[2:46:34] It's the ask of option one in their own, like option set, so it's like they have acknowledged
[2:46:40] that as one way of doing it on page 25.
[2:46:43] I imagine they are probably going to default to not doing that, because that's going to be more
[2:46:47] palatable.
[2:46:47] But either way, I think we should advocate for that option that they have established as one of the options.
[2:46:53] The other option, the other thing I think we should advocate for in a different, in a related domain is treating
[2:47:01] VHR use in residential areas the way it is, which is a commercial use.
[2:47:06] And requiring any VHR use that is beyond so many nights per year at least as commercial use and responsible for the various set of commercial mitigation fees.
[2:47:17] that are required by any other commercial use.
[2:47:20] There is transit and travel, transit and VMTs and all the,
[2:47:27] there's a set, I don't want to list them,
[2:47:28] I'm not, I'm not intending to list them
[2:47:31] and say if it's a VHR use
[2:47:33] and this is what this property is doing,
[2:47:36] then that is a commercial use
[2:47:37] and it should pay commercial mitigation fees
[2:47:38] just like a hotel would.
[2:47:40] And so that's the other thing I think we should advocate for.
[2:47:42] I'm not disagreeing with you
[2:47:43] and I've honestly really brought this up at TRPA
[2:47:46] trying to bring it back to either a residential unit of use.
[2:47:48] How can we get a mitigation fee that could go towards transit?
[2:47:51] I'm not, I'm in full support of that,
[2:47:53] but I feel like that takes the housing effort
[2:47:55] and kind of like brings it into such a larger,
[2:47:58] not disagreeing with you, but I think we should keep the focus
[2:48:00] on what we want to direct them to go back
[2:48:03] as, you know, which, again, I do see the cross section of EHRs,
[2:48:08] but when you start to get into the mitigation
[2:48:09] and changing the full, you know, definition of residential unit
[2:48:13] of use over to commercial or a TAU, which is another theory with that. It just changed that
[2:48:19] just adds so much to kind of the, so I just don't. If we don't try to advocate for this,
[2:48:26] we are guaranteed to get nothing. Well, if we want to add it, it's just trying to point out like
[2:48:30] it's something that we always complain about. We always complain about reasons not doing their
[2:48:37] part and here's our opportunity to at least ask. So then Mr. Mayor, I'm prepared to make a motion
[2:48:42] I think I have Mr. Roberts on my list.
[2:48:44] Everyone else has discussion on the second thing.
[2:48:47] I have Mr. Roberts on my list.
[2:48:48] So, yep.
[2:48:50] Thank you.
[2:48:51] I agree that we should add in the base and wide density as to the task recommendations already.
[2:49:00] I also agree we should do with the regional rena request as well.
[2:49:04] I do have one concern on,
[2:49:06] I agree conceptually about the VHRs and treating them as commercial properties, but as far
[2:49:13] as the VMT goes, I think there needs to be, it would need to be looked at from the,
[2:49:18] if it was a, it was a five or six person long-term rental, we probably have more VMTs than
[2:49:24] what a, what a, what a, what a, what a chart would do, so it's not fair, it needs to be evaluated
[2:49:28] equally.
[2:49:30] Great.
[2:49:31] Thank you Mr. Roberts.
[2:49:32] Mr. Jenkins.
[2:49:32] I got to all my listeners. Somebody ready to make a motion. Mr. Jenkins I can put something together.
[2:49:39] Mr. Jenkins, I lost my spot. I have to look for my spot. I have to look for my spot. I know.
[2:49:44] I'm misorganized. I'm sorry. I even have to put a motion together with staff recommendations, both the additions.
[2:49:49] Well, what are we going to go?
[2:49:50] Yeah, I recommend that the City Council approve the recommendations of staff to the...
[2:50:00] TRPA regarding this matter. In addition, that I would add that I want to ensure that whatever policies
[2:50:09] are developed, there's an economic assessment done to determine the impact on the sustainability
[2:50:16] of our economy, of the economy of the region, and, of course, more importantly, the economy
[2:50:21] University.
[2:50:25] And I have no problem with what the Mayor
[2:50:30] Protem suggested that the issue of applicability of fees
[2:50:37] be evaluated. It should be evaluated by TRPA and us. So
[2:50:45] that's the motion.
[2:50:46] Well, yeah, the idea here is that VMTs are assessed on commercial operations, they are not assessed on residential operations.
[2:50:54] And that is a distinction that is made currently.
[2:50:57] If you build a five unit residential housing unit, it's not, it doesn't have to pay commercial VMT mitigation fees.
[2:51:05] If you build a five unit hotel, it does.
[2:51:09] And so that's the distinction that should be made.
[2:51:11] is that it's not that everyone pays VMT mitigation.
[2:51:17] I don't think the VMT.
[2:51:19] I don't think so far out of it.
[2:51:21] Because you start talking about a commercial use
[2:51:22] and a residential zone and what the use is.
[2:51:26] But Mr.
[2:51:27] Yeah, California.
[2:51:28] Yeah, California.
[2:51:29] Yeah,
[2:51:31] California.
[2:51:31] I don't think any of that's been there.
[2:51:34] I think we're going to reach further up.
[2:51:35] But Mr. Hitchcock, please.
[2:51:37] To clarify, so all you says is subject to VMT.
[2:51:41] the difference between VMT's associated with residential uses and VMT's associated with
[2:51:46] towards combination uses, the VMT fee for tourist combination uses is quite a bit more
[2:51:51] than what residential use paid the theory being that it creates more VMT's more traffic.
[2:51:59] So then all we're going to do in the motion and is also just that we advocate for treating
[2:52:06] via HR utilization throughout the basin, consistent with VMT as consistent with commercial
[2:52:15] VMT mitigation.
[2:52:16] You can say that was a one thing that I've advocate it for many times at TRPA is converting
[2:52:21] the definition of a VHR from an RUU, a residential unit of use to a TAU, and that's basically
[2:52:27] what accomplishes kind of what it looks like.
[2:52:29] If we did that, wouldn't that subsume, then it would automatically change to including that.
[2:52:34] I think that also means there are a lot of code change that needs to happen because I've been
[2:52:38] if I might just point of order so that we can follow the final direction of Council.
[2:52:44] I believe Mr. Jenkins made a motion but he did but I didn't know if well.
[2:52:51] So I don't know if he was finished and if you want to request that the motion be amended Mr. Jenkins
[2:52:58] could do that then we'll look for a second and then discussion.
[2:53:00] Yeah, we didn't get a second and I think I guess I should have stopped in my apologies on that, but it seemed like we
[2:53:07] You had what you wanted in it, which is the economic side and the staff recommendations, but it didn't include Mr. Robbins or the other things
[2:53:14] I'm one of my other forms of whole motion with all the other symbols
[2:53:18] What was the arena thing you wanted included though? Could you articulate that so I can put it in the motion?
[2:53:23] I think that the TRPA should establish a rena type allocation for affordable units in the basin for all jurisdictions within the basin because we are the only one, and Eldorado Canyon, I guess, in Placer County, and theory, we're the only one that has a quote, rena, we're, and TRPA should be considering if they truly want to do planning,
[2:53:53] for this matter that they establish a goals for the region. So you can narrow down the
[2:54:02] language. So here's what I'm just so that rather than we articulate the whole motion and
[2:54:08] then we give it here's the things I'm going to put in the motion just so we can get through
[2:54:11] this. I'm going to recommend page 25 option one. I'll say that nicely but it'll be that's
[2:54:17] we make it automatic for higher density.
[2:54:22] I'm going to say, and this is,
[2:54:25] provide direction to staff to advocate for the following things
[2:54:29] to the TRPA, because obviously they can't just do
[2:54:32] the TRPA stuff as much as I would prefer that.
[2:54:37] Then also to consider VA charge mitigation fees as commercial
[2:54:41] or preferably to advocate for considering VA charge
[2:54:46] as tourist accommodation units from an RAU right to consider them as T8 to consider them as requiring
[2:54:53] TAUs as commercial stuff. I mean the commercial that's why you have a TAU in a way
[2:54:58] because it's disowning but anyways.
[2:55:00] Okay, however you want to say about that. And then that the we also advocate that the theorem here established a renaut equivalent is what I'm going to say. So it's its by state, whatever, a renaut equivalence assessment for that that covers the base and wide region. Those are the things I'm going to put in the motion. Does that sound good with enough people? Okay. So I'm prepared to ask our recommendations. Plus, plus the rest of the whole thing.
[2:55:26] I move that I move that we provide policy direction to the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency,
[2:55:36] cultivating communities, conservating the Basin project, and mobility mitigation fees,
[2:55:44] that the staff that consists of the staff recommendations provided herein as per this agenda
[2:55:52] item. In addition, that we provide direction to staff for staff to vociferously advocate for
[2:56:05] mandatory housing density as outlined in on page 25 option 1, that staff advocate for
[2:56:16] including base and wide mitigation fees for VHRs, treating them as commercial, and or for requiring TAUs for VHRs, base and wide, and also that they advocate for TRPA to establish a base and wide renaequivalent assessment of housing needs.
[2:56:39] Is that adequately clear for staff?
[2:56:43] I just want to make sure staff is clear with nothing for that motion.
[2:56:47] There was one other suggestion on the table, and that was regarding the economic analysis.
[2:56:52] I don't know if you had discussed that.
[2:56:54] Well, there should be an economic analysis.
[2:56:57] There should be an economic analysis of the impact of these policies.
[2:57:01] Do they promote our sustainability?
[2:57:03] I mean, the concept is there should be an economic analysis of all policies and how they affect our ability to sustain our community and grow our economy so we can create jobs so people can be a played in the Ford house.
[2:57:19] But that's a long question.
[2:57:20] I will amend it to simply say and that they advocate for TRPA to perform an economic analysis for these policy changes.
[2:57:29] I though third.
[2:57:32] Who has a motion and a second and we can go.
[2:57:36] That was easy.
[2:57:37] That actually was easier than I thought.
[2:57:40] I hope I'm holding back.
[2:57:42] I know my mouth is disappearing here.
[2:57:50] That was an unannable question.
[2:57:52] Mr. Mayor, Mr. Mayor I do the only thing that I'm disappointed in is that
[2:57:59] a major housing policies and land use policies and not go to the Planning Commission.
[2:58:07] I think it should have gone.
[2:58:09] They are under California law.
[2:58:11] They are the only required planning.
[2:58:14] And I think it would have been helpful to us to the public.
[2:58:17] Had this discussion also had benefit of the results of the Planning Commission.
[2:58:23] Thank you so much, Mr. Jenkins.
[2:58:25] We're moving on to regular new business.
[2:58:26] This is the item 12 update on geothermal feasibility study and recreation and aquatic centers hydronics.
[2:58:32] You want a motion?
[2:58:32] No, we have a taken public comment.
[2:58:43] Good evening, Council.
[2:58:44] Mohamed Karashi, presenting this item.
[2:58:50] We had a discussion back in June.
[2:58:53] At the time we presented what we called the capital improvement plan.
[2:58:59] There were discussions about the boiler system that was needed at the Rec Center and during
[2:59:06] that discussion there was also further discussion about exploring geothermal options for
[2:59:12] providing that snow melt operation at the Rec Center as well as in a more global sense for
[2:59:19] the city.
[2:59:21] In response to that, the department took some actions over the summer, one of them was that
[2:59:27] requested RFPs to explore the feasibility of geothermal activity and it's used in South
[2:59:36] Lake Tahoe. Attached to the staff report you have the most the best value proposal that we
[2:59:44] received up the two. We received two in total. We have provided you with the one that we
[2:59:55] I want to be clear, it does not tell us exact.
[3:00:00] How to do geothermal? It tells us if it will be possible to do geothermal. There will be additional phases as outlined in the report that would be needed to get to a point where we actually are using geothermal if it turns out that is possible.
[3:00:20] In the meantime, we do still have the issue of the snow melt to deal with at the rec center.
[3:00:27] We took some action on that part as well.
[3:00:29] We have received quotes for a more traditional gas powered boiler.
[3:00:36] It will come in under 250,000 to install that and could be done potentially before we have
[3:00:44] So depending on when we get to know, the item before you is to request guidance from you
[3:00:51] on the direction you would like us to take.
[3:00:54] I have provided you three choices of emotions that you could make.
[3:00:59] I would kindly ask you to choose only one.
[3:01:02] I think I've written them such that you only need to choose one different
[3:01:05] god list of what you'd like to do, but let's talk, let's choose only one.
[3:01:10] Why don't you tell us what you think we should do that's and then then let us decide if we want to do something
[3:01:17] I want to hear from your professional judgment
[3:01:22] I wasn't prepared to have a professional judgment. I have one. I'm wondering if we're deferring to you all
[3:01:30] I agree we're not engineers, but this this is not an engineering decision. This is a financial and policy decision that I believe is in your hands
[3:01:40] Anything else, Dr. Kew?
[3:01:42] I think I will leave it and be okay with questions.
[3:01:45] I'm going to open up for questions.
[3:01:46] Ms. Morgan?
[3:01:47] If I just add to the staff support, I think operationally the staff is pretty aligned
[3:01:53] that we do believe that a snow melt system on that, especially on that walkway, walking up
[3:01:58] to the Recreation Center would vastly improve the safety of that walkway through the winter.
[3:02:06] Doing manual snow removal, we can do that absolutely.
[3:02:09] But as we all know, as we do our own driveways and walkways, that there can be ice build up that a snow melt system would assist with.
[3:02:19] So when it comes to recommendation, operationally, we do recommend that there be a snow melt system there.
[3:02:26] Personally, I think sooner, rather than later, would benefit.
[3:02:30] But, however, it's certainly up to Council if you would like for us to continue pursuing
[3:02:36] the geothermal potential that perhaps could be utilized in a future project or a different
[3:02:43] area where we do also have pedestrian activity.
[3:02:48] Ms. Ms. Mayor.
[3:02:50] Question.
[3:02:51] We, yes, so if you don't mind, just go on to go on the list for me if you don't want to.
[3:02:55] Oh, I'm sorry.
[3:02:56] It's all right.
[3:02:56] And Ms. Oregon was on the list.
[3:02:57] Yeah, we're trying to work in strategy, sorry.
[3:02:59] Are we aware of any geothermal snow melt systems
[3:03:03] already deployed in the city limits?
[3:03:07] We are not.
[3:03:08] We did reach out, I failed to mention.
[3:03:09] We did reach out to one of our contractors
[3:03:14] that we use for heating ventilation and stuff,
[3:03:18] and did request them to provide us with an option
[3:03:24] if one existed for a geothermal system and they declined because they basically said what
[3:03:31] they felt was it would be too large a device that would be needed for the purposes we were
[3:03:36] had. So at the moment there is none that we know of and we do not we don't have a specific
[3:03:43] option that we could quickly install. So so not first known help but do are we aware of geothermal
[3:03:50] systems that are being used in the city currently, is this like feasible just because other
[3:03:56] organizations or entities are using it and they've been deploying it effectively, it's been
[3:04:03] consistent. I'm not aware of anything in the region that is actually deploying it yet. I have heard
[3:04:09] there were some investigations into possible a possible city-wide system in the truck area,
[3:04:17] But that has not yet materialized and I don't know that there is a specific plan for that.
[3:04:24] Okay, I'll save the rest for comments.
[3:04:26] Great.
[3:04:26] Mr. Robinson.
[3:04:27] Mr. Jenkins.
[3:04:29] Mr. Robinson.
[3:04:31] I think, I think, would you agree,
[3:04:35] a form of a question?
[3:04:37] Would you agree that the safety issue comes first?
[3:04:40] The safety issue of making sure that people don't fall and break their neck
[3:04:44] or slip and fall and so on. So that's first, would you agree as well that the geothermal is
[3:04:52] actually, I'm excited about that idea that it might be possible in an area with geothermal.
[3:05:00] Stuff in it. And so that's whether it's applicability here, there may be applicability in other areas of the city, other venues of the city itself or even on the private side.
[3:05:15] So, but would you agree that the safety issue is first?
[3:05:18] The safety issue is very important, and that's part of the reason that the ability to have
[3:05:24] a snowmelt system was put in, or at least the underground components that would have
[3:05:31] been needed so we didn't have to tear everything up.
[3:05:32] The only thing this has nothing to do with our staff here, I just wish that that would have
[3:05:37] been part of the planning for the Recreation Center, the 62 million dollar center, that
[3:05:40] would have been part of it.
[3:05:43] Mr. Romans.
[3:05:46] So I'm just trying to see if we can get, if there's even a, you know, that the $50,000 or $47,000
[3:05:53] had the $50,000 fee is for doing a study to assess how much a system might cost to do the installation, right?
[3:06:04] I would not characterize it that way, sir.
[3:06:07] We may get something like that, but I think phase one is really exploring is geothermal, is
[3:06:12] their geothermal activity we could even tap into to use?
[3:06:18] OK, because the other option, right, is a geothermal
[3:06:21] system, is just the geothermal aspect of this type of system
[3:06:26] is using the Earth as a heat sink or a heat reservoir.
[3:06:31] You can also do heat pumps at misfiric, which
[3:06:35] is now, you know, if you're building new, you generally
[3:06:39] will not, I mean most people will, there's a good reason not to opt for regular air conditioning
[3:06:44] anymore and to only build heat pumps which provide heating and cooling using the atmosphere
[3:06:50] as the heat reservoir. Even in the winter time, you can produce a good amount of heat out of
[3:06:56] the cold outside air. The physics of that may seem odd, but it is correct.
[3:07:03] That's not,
[3:07:03] I mean, that is potentially another option from a physics standpoint, but the systems that
[3:07:10] are being referenced in the proposal are all, are all, are all, are all, are all, are
[3:07:13] geothermal.
[3:07:14] Is there a reason that geothermal rather than an atmospheric heat pump is preferred for sort
[3:07:19] of snowmalt operations rather than an atmospheric heat pump?
[3:07:24] And should we be expanding that consideration to be a little more body?
[3:07:29] But the goal here is for energy reduction, rather than using natural gas, and to use electricity
[3:07:36] and heat transfer systems, right, that can allow us to save energy.
[3:07:44] So, and use electricity rather than burning things.
[3:07:46] So, is there a reason we should not consider atmospheric heat pumps?
[3:07:52] I'm going to say there is, and I'm going to ask Mrs. Carpenter to see if Ricky is on the zoom meeting
[3:07:58] raising his hand, wishing to speak, and I will ask him to respond to that question because I believe
[3:08:04] that may be the basis for what we want.
[3:08:06] Yeah, you have Mr. Riddle on. Chris, I'll take you back to my next slide.
[3:08:10] Ricky, could you please speak to that last question?
[3:08:14] Yeah, absolutely. So just for clarity sake, you know, the existing Greg Center was designed
[3:08:19] with atmospheric heat pumps as the primary heat source for the condition space within the building.
[3:08:25] So we have a, that's, that's the entire heat recovery system.
[3:08:29] So there's atmospheric heat pumps in, in addition to heat recovery units.
[3:08:35] The, the primary justification for the recommendation towards this gas fired boiler is,
[3:08:45] since, you know, you mentioned that this was not included in the original conceptual design,
[3:08:50] or the full permanent design, we actually are at a limiting factor of the electricity that's available as well as the gas.
[3:09:05] So, prior to making this recommendation, we evaluated this concurrently with Southwest Gas to ensure that the existing gas meter assembly was capable of utilizing this.
[3:09:16] I will state that the gas-fired boiler is one of high efficiency and, you know, I understand
[3:09:24] that there's different, you know, principles and ways to approach this from an economic standpoint.
[3:09:31] Gas-fired boiler is typically easier or not easier.
[3:09:36] It's less expensive of an installation and a less expensive operating cost.
[3:09:41] granted you don't get the technical carbon reductions that you're looking for in some type of
[3:09:45] atmospheric heat pump.
[3:09:47] I will say that the space consideration will also come into effect to install a gas or an
[3:09:53] atmospheric electric-based heat pump to be able to source the enough energy to run this.
[3:10:00] Now, melt assembly would require the construction of an additional mechanical yard, as well as all of the associated designs that go into that.
[3:10:11] You know, another thing to take into consideration is given that the exterior ambient temperatures drop below 40 degrees fairly regularly here.
[3:10:20] the atmosphere of key pumps actually have internal heating coils to keep the coils themselves
[3:10:25] from freezing over. So there's a lot of the mechanical advantage of a gas-fired boiler
[3:10:31] is really applicable given that we're putting this in a, you know, we're trying to make it fit
[3:10:38] for the safety being first and foremost. We really were trying to become, we're trying to be creative
[3:10:45] and present what we felt was the best fiscally responsible option you know clearly
[3:10:51] happy to go in the different direction if it's absolutely necessary.
[3:10:56] Well I think I think it's pretty clear that certainly the upfront costs of a fossil fuel system
[3:11:04] is going to be lower than the upfront costs of a heat pump of any kind and the idea is that
[3:11:13] atmospheric heat pump is typically cheaper in upfront costs than a geothermal, but if I guess
[3:11:20] the idea here is that for snow melt, the total heat amount needed, the number of watts
[3:11:27] of heat that we're, you know, watts of heat are going to be so much higher than conditioning
[3:11:31] the air in a building that it's just not efficient to do that with an atmospheric system
[3:11:37] Hence, the need for a geothermal system
[3:11:39] so you have your temperature reservoir is in a more stable temperature
[3:11:44] so you don't have to move as much air as you do water through
[3:11:48] or cool it through the geore reservoir.
[3:11:52] But that raises the next question,
[3:11:54] which is the comment was that it's cheaper to operate,
[3:11:57] I guess that's cheaper to operate at what gas price.
[3:12:03] And that's at current gas prices.
[3:12:05] And I guess a follow-up question,
[3:12:06] And I suppose this would this be then a question for the study to answer would be how what
[3:12:13] factor change in gas prices would actually be needed for a crossover in straight up cost
[3:12:19] benefits like if gas doubled then does this become cheaper if gas goes up 50% does this
[3:12:24] become cheaper or does gas have to be 34 or 5x you know what is the cost of gas that would
[3:12:30] have to be, for gas to now actually be more expensive to operate in order to do a cost
[3:12:37] only comparison, and that would be ignoring the carbon reduction benefits, which I think
[3:12:43] are sufficient reason to spend a little more anyway, but to understand how much difference
[3:12:49] like what cost are we, does that carbon reduction come at? We would have to know the operating
[3:12:55] cost relative to the carbon emissions from natural gas and at what price of natural gas that
[3:13:07] is.
[3:13:08] Are those the kind of things of the study would assess for the $50,000.
[3:13:12] I do not believe that would be a phase one assessment.
[3:13:16] That would come in one of the later phases when we start looking at specific sites that may
[3:13:21] have an opportunity to use and then we would begin to look at designing those systems that's
[3:13:27] when we would do that analysis of feasibility at a particular site and then then I agree
[3:13:35] at that stage we would ask for the cost comparison of alternative modes as well because I think
[3:13:40] we have responsibility to the public to understand like I want I would like to see us not use
[3:13:47] carbon emissions for energy usage full stop,
[3:13:51] but I think the public has a right to know
[3:13:52] at what cost that is coming.
[3:13:54] And so that would be answered in a later study,
[3:13:57] not in this initial study.
[3:13:58] I do not believe state, I don't believe
[3:14:00] what they are proposing in phase one would get us to a point.
[3:14:03] We couldn't make that comparison
[3:14:05] because we would not still not know
[3:14:07] sort of how big a system we're talking about yet locations.
[3:14:12] But once we get to a point where we're starting to assess
[3:14:15] feasibility of locations, and kind of the what that unit will then do.
[3:14:21] You need more unit specifics in order to make that assessment.
[3:14:24] And then in the meantime, if we choose to go this path, the pass would be just snowblown
[3:14:29] and salted and whatever as anything else.
[3:14:32] Is that the, that would be the plan?
[3:14:33] Do you mean if we don't do the boiler?
[3:14:35] Correct.
[3:14:36] If we don't do the boiler, it's traditional snow removal technique.
[3:14:39] It's entirely, until we decide on either later doing geothermal or doing the boiler,
[3:14:45] It's not that nothing's going to get plowed in the meantime and you're just going to wade through feet of snow.
[3:14:51] We have the ability to clear the sidewalks for now.
[3:14:55] We do have that ability. Again, this is, this is, do this or no sidewalks.
[3:15:00] Yes, that is not what we're saying, but what we are saying is there's an opportunity to get that system in now versus waiting a year or two to put it in later.
[3:15:10] Thank you. Thank you Mr. Robin. So a few questions for me. So the hydronics that are in the concrete that were done as part of the initial project are just in the front or we talking that it wraps all of the concrete, you know, when you walk out of the back.
[3:15:24] How do we know how many square feet we're talking about on how much is covered in hydronics?
[3:15:31] I've heard of Ricky on that.
[3:15:33] Okay. Yeah, absolutely. So it was evaluated to do a full coverage that was determined at the time
[3:15:42] to be too expensive even in the prep work as well as leading back into the overarching utility capacity
[3:15:54] available given the design. So what has been installed and prepared is the service delivery
[3:16:00] yard. There's a concrete apron on the kind of wrapping around the side that leads into
[3:16:06] the commercial kitchen as well as in front of the trash enclosure. And then from the primary
[3:16:12] parking lot there is a six foot wide pathway that goes directly down the middle of the primary
[3:16:19] walking path to the front door, it was really the minimum amount that was felt capable
[3:16:30] of achieving the safety goals and concerns that we had, as it's mentioned in the staff
[3:16:37] report, especially considering the senior nutrition programs as well as the hours of operation,
[3:16:42] The intent was to be able to provide at least a clear pathway of a reasonable with which is how six foot was ended up being defined as well as the service delivery yard.
[3:16:57] Those are also the service delivery yard stays relatively shaded and has roof run off.
[3:17:03] though there is, you know, a valuation of gut or assembly
[3:17:07] being installed has a heavy amount of shading
[3:17:11] with very minimal sunlight.
[3:17:15] Front access path as some of you may or may not have seen
[3:17:19] did experience some pretty severe icing over.
[3:17:23] Just given the design of the Rex Center itself
[3:17:28] and the water has ice dams have formed, so the snowmout will assist in the reduction of the
[3:17:38] overarching ice sheets that will be generated there. And in addition to that, the
[3:17:46] salting of colored concrete leads to fairly excessive spalling, so there was an intention of
[3:17:54] increasing the longevity of nearly improved walkway.
[3:18:00] Great.
[3:18:01] So yeah, so that's somewhat of answers to my second question,
[3:18:04] because I have somewhat questioned the $250,000 cost
[3:18:07] of the boiler just because our replacement cost
[3:18:10] and the Padma area is closer to a million dollars.
[3:18:14] But it's also because the square footage is so much smaller.
[3:18:18] We're talking about a really pretty small space for what's
[3:18:22] covered by hydraulics. The second question, you know, looking at, in the way that the feasibility
[3:18:28] study breaks down, and I think you've said this as phase one, really just informs us, you know,
[3:18:34] are we going to be able to, to store energy because at the level of store, you know, heating a
[3:18:40] sidewalk where we're really trying to only get to 40 and 41 degrees Fahrenheit on the sidewalk
[3:18:44] to melt the snow as it falls. You know, we're not talking about having to go very deep into the earth
[3:18:50] to do that, right?
[3:18:51] And so, but it would have also feasibility
[3:18:54] that it would advise us, if you do go deep,
[3:18:57] you are gonna get to over 100 degrees Fahrenheit
[3:19:00] at this amount of drilling at this amount of feet.
[3:19:03] That's really what we're talking about
[3:19:04] in the first phase of this.
[3:19:05] Is that correct?
[3:19:06] I think I would agree with that.
[3:19:08] I would also point out that the company that has proposed
[3:19:12] is also focused on networks of energy networks.
[3:19:17] So they are looking at an entire area,
[3:19:20] not not a specific location and they're going to assess whether we have the opportunity for
[3:19:27] eventually developing a network for the city. I won't go so far as to say that would be the
[3:19:35] first thing we're going to get. We would build up to it because anytime I talk city wide you
[3:19:41] should be thinking 10s, 20, 30s, millions of dollars kind of thing and we don't have those kinds
[3:19:47] resources at the moment, but it is something we could incrementally build up to.
[3:19:51] Definitely.
[3:19:52] And so, you know, even if we go forward and do this on putting in the boiler if we do the feasibility.
[3:20:00] And we're forward to five to let's call this boiler replacement time 20 years. The, the manifold for the hydronics, you know, most likely could tie into that city network if we had it developed, saving, you know, whatever.
[3:20:13] The natural gas cost at Padma are unreal. We've had years, you know, it's highs $160,000, just for the heavenly village. And so, and we'll all we know about gas is it's going to go more and more and it's something that we should reduce as our goals.
[3:20:29] Clearly, state we want to do. So I'll leave it at that for right now for my questions before we go to public comment and come back for discussion unless Mr. Roberts
[3:20:36] You know, okay. Thank you, Dr. Q.
[3:20:38] With that we'll go ahead and open this item to public comment for anybody that's here in the room that would like to get public comment.
[3:20:44] Ms. Otterston.
[3:20:50] All right, Melissa Otterston, South Lake Tahoe.
[3:20:53] I think again, the rec center we're going back to how every step of this has just been a disappointment.
[3:21:01] heat pumps atmospheric heat pumps were the goal from the beginning if not
[3:21:06] geothermal the fact that we are even considering natural gas at this stage we
[3:21:11] are nowhere close to meeting our goals for net zero we're not even we're
[3:21:17] going backwards. I don't understand why we live in a snow country and we still
[3:21:22] have people that seem opposed to shoveling sidewalks. I think our best bet here
[3:21:28] would be to build a covered walkway over the sidewalk that has solar panels on it, provides
[3:21:34] you some electricity, you're not going to have snow falling off onto the sidewalk, then
[3:21:38] you don't have to shovel it as much, I mean it's all really simple things, all of this
[3:21:42] should have been done from the beginning when the price on the rec center started going
[3:21:46] up, it should have been scaled back. We shouldn't have ridiculous walkways that go around
[3:21:51] the top that maybe five people will use. We live in an outdoor paradise, we never needed
[3:21:57] this rexenter in the first place. It was always intended to be more a community style center.
[3:22:03] I just cannot fathom using natural gas at this stage when there are so many other options.
[3:22:10] And this particular thing, if it was such a vital thing to get this ice melted, it should have
[3:22:15] been done from the first from the beginning. Geothermal is incredibly important.
[3:22:22] We know that we have hot springs on the North Shore, we know that we are so grounded by
[3:22:25] springs all over the place, not sure what we have available here, but we really do need to get that and
[3:22:32] we were very lucky with our public works before. A news was great and he did a lot of research and I am
[3:22:41] pretty tired of these presentations being done in such a mocking tone with a lack of information
[3:22:49] available to us. I believe that we have been working on some of these issues for nearly a decade now
[3:22:56] and the information is available. Perhaps people when they come on to staff and are hired to do
[3:23:02] such a vital important job and we have had some of these projects in the works for so very long
[3:23:10] research should have been done and some of this history should have been taken into account.
[3:23:16] I know personalities are a thing here, but I really am insulted by the lack of effort that
[3:23:24] is made to take these projects seriously.
[3:23:27] These are very big projects, and we have to ask for traffic calming measures.
[3:23:31] We've asked for heat pumps.
[3:23:32] We've asked for solar panels, and we're not getting anywhere.
[3:23:35] It's always deferred to someone else.
[3:23:37] We need to do more information, and this has been on the works for a long time.
[3:23:41] atmosphere, key pumps, or geothermal, natural gas has no place in our future, and solar panels
[3:23:47] over walkways stop pretending like we can't cover things to prevent ice.
[3:23:52] Thank you.
[3:23:53] Thank you, Ms. Auterson.
[3:23:54] Any other members in the room that would like to give public comments, Mr. Mozier?
[3:24:10] Good evening.
[3:24:11] At Mozier, South Lake Tahoe.
[3:24:14] Yeah, I mean, it would be nice, too, as Ms. Auterson pointed out about, you know, drawbacks
[3:24:20] natural gas. But, you know, at this point for expediency, I think that is probably the best option
[3:24:28] for now, because you haven't done any exploratory and there is nothing in the region,
[3:24:35] even a immediate region here on a geothermal level. So, you don't know if that possibility,
[3:24:42] how far you'll have to go to get to get your needs, whereas you do know, you know, with a gas
[3:24:48] for right now exactly what you're going to need and produce and you know I drill the well
[3:24:56] up outside of Calistoga through volcanic rock.
[3:25:00] And how did I get the bits done? And they were wearing out about every 12 feet. And found the guy in San Rosa that actually did the bits for the guys.
[3:25:08] There's up in Geiserville, PG&E plant up there. And so he was coding the bits for me. And actually got to go up to there with him. I asked him if I could go up with him when he was dropping some bits off. And so I'm more to it than you think.
[3:25:28] And costs, and so like I said, there's no background information, there isn't anything to
[3:25:36] go on.
[3:25:37] It's all exploratory to start with and you could be several years off.
[3:25:41] So I like her idea of covering it, putting a cover, maybe have to put sides on it in the
[3:25:47] winter.
[3:25:48] So it doesn't blow onto it, you can have a roof, but if that's all you have, snow blows
[3:25:54] under it. So, you know, that is a possibility also. You could just put, you know, some nice panels up on the side or something and and four winter, but, you know, other than that, you know, I would go with the gas boiler for now.
[3:26:06] That seems to be the most feasible immediate solution and then take it from there and figure out which one to do in the future what your path is going to be.
[3:26:15] Thank you.
[3:26:16] Thank you Mr. Moser.
[3:26:19] Anybody else in the public seeing none here, we will look to Zoom.
[3:26:22] You know, go ahead and call Ms. Kate Bauer.
[3:26:29] I see the council. Thanks for listening to me again.
[3:26:31] I do agree with Ms. Sartarsher.
[3:26:34] I'm like, come on now. Why can't we just cover the sidewalks?
[3:26:39] Then it creates an area where we don't have to spend
[3:26:43] fossil fuels and all this other crap to keep the sidewalks.
[3:26:48] I oversaw several projects of the college.
[3:26:51] and the college has several heated sidewalks.
[3:26:54] And it is nice.
[3:26:56] It helps them.
[3:26:56] And no staff, it helps lower costs from having
[3:27:00] to do manual stout to removal.
[3:27:02] But it also increases our carbon footprint.
[3:27:06] So something like the Sarsh from proposed
[3:27:10] of putting just put a lid over the sidewalks.
[3:27:17] And then floor panels are big.
[3:27:19] Thank you.
[3:27:20] Thank you.
[3:27:22] No additional public comment today.
[3:27:24] Great.
[3:27:24] We'll bring it back to Council.
[3:27:26] And I'm actually going to open this one up because this geothermal issue is really something that I've championed and really want to see come forward.
[3:27:33] And is a little, this is now the third time we have gotten Council to approve this.
[3:27:38] Going all the way back almost a year and a half to two years ago, unanimous support.
[3:27:43] A year ago about, or maybe even less than that, unanimous support.
[3:27:47] And the reason is, because again, it is feasibility and it is exploratory, but it is something
[3:27:53] transformational in so many things, in our transportation, potential energy production, I was
[3:28:00] a major advocate to heat and use geothermal for the pool at the Rexiners, and it got shot down,
[3:28:06] and many other things through that process. That, again, the public was very involved in,
[3:28:10] and we did have a limited budget, and that is a factor here. But the reality is there are so many
[3:28:16] examples world wide of geothermal being used throughout communities and
[3:28:20] and planning. And when we look at the cost of things like the snow removal on
[3:28:24] our bike path just along Highway 50 and incorporating geothermal as we build
[3:28:28] into the future into all of our pavement and into what we're doing. Is there a
[3:28:33] huge cost? Sure, but when you look at the savings and then the carbon offset the
[3:28:38] public safety improvement, it goes on and on and on and if we can show it and
[3:28:43] actually be the leaders of doing the feasibility,
[3:28:45] you can gain the attention of calterans
[3:28:47] and get them to do a small pilot project
[3:28:49] in the middle lane of our highway
[3:28:51] that would get rid of the burn that we put dump trucks
[3:28:53] on highway 50 that continue to burn more carbon,
[3:28:57] do more harm to our pavement and create a huge public safety
[3:29:01] risk in the middle of our town that could be handled
[3:29:04] by geothermal, but we do somewhat need to show
[3:29:07] and we have an opportunity here to show the feasibility
[3:29:11] and that it is possible.
[3:29:12] So we know we're next to Reno and you know that area is one of the most active geothermal places on planet earth.
[3:29:20] We are definitely within a pocket of the real ability to find out and I think we will find out that we can do it.
[3:29:28] And then yes, this isn't going to show us what it's going to cost.
[3:29:31] Site by site, it's going to be specific to do we want to go deep well, do we want to do just very shallow well because all we're trying to do is heat some pavement.
[3:29:39] Those are things that we will find out once we know if the feasibility is possible to even take that next step.
[3:29:46] And that's what this initial study is about, is finding out the next step.
[3:29:51] As far as putting in the boiler, I generally do agree that we should not create more natural gas burn.
[3:30:00] Planning, appliances all call it in the city. But at the same point, we have the hydraulics installed. We need to keep safety at the most of what we're doing.
[3:30:11] The hydraulics are there. It's not a huge amount of money, and it's not a huge amount of natural gas, because we're not talking about a huge amount of square footage that we're heating.
[3:30:21] And for that, I think it's worth with the people that use the Rec Center, which is our community.
[3:30:26] but I think it's worth to have the safest environment we can there.
[3:30:30] So I would stand on the side of approving that but I also very much want to see us for the third time say yes go out and do feasibility four geothermal for the city for the future of planning in the city.
[3:30:42] So that's where I'll leave it and I'll go to Ms. Horton.
[3:30:45] So I agree actually I'm looking at motion number three which I think is where you're headed.
[3:30:50] But I just want to mention a couple of things why I feel this way one we already have the governor preemptively
[3:30:55] calling a state of emergency for a super convenient, which means we could potentially have some real snow impacts this year.
[3:31:03] I like the idea of an expedited timeline on this because we already do have the infrastructure there in order to get this up and running for public safety.
[3:31:15] And I just, it's a multi-generational
[3:31:20] Brex Center, I am there in the middle of the day,
[3:31:23] which tends to be when older people are also there.
[3:31:28] And when Mr. Riddle mentioned also the employee entrance
[3:31:32] and the senior nutrition coming in,
[3:31:36] shaded area that could potentially be icy.
[3:31:40] I worry about workplace safety.
[3:31:42] And, honestly, going back to nursing school, the leading cause of trauma in our country always has been and probably always will be falls.
[3:31:53] It's a leading cause of traumatic brain injuries, spinal cord injuries, and hip fractures.
[3:31:58] And, unfortunately, we've learned over the last several years that if an older adult has a fall with a hip fracture,
[3:32:07] They are likely, well, there's a 20% chance that they will die within that year.
[3:32:13] It's a really shocking information for those of us who care for patients in the hospital.
[3:32:19] We take care of them after they break their hips.
[3:32:23] We send them to surgery.
[3:32:24] We fix them up.
[3:32:24] We send them to rehabs, but the reality is that 20% of those people won't live the rest
[3:32:30] of the year.
[3:32:31] So I feel really strongly about whatever we can do to make our facilities safe and prevent
[3:32:37] falls is something that we should consider and we have the ability to do this.
[3:32:42] So I think we should look at geothermal.
[3:32:45] My dad was an architect, he had geothermal on his property and so I was really familiar with it.
[3:32:50] If when it broke down, it was always comical because there weren't a lot of people to do
[3:32:54] the service of it and hopefully what we'll find in the feasibility study is that if we employ
[3:33:00] this technology that we also have services around us if there are issues that we can quickly
[3:33:07] identify the issue and repair it because I remember that. But yeah, I would put forward a motion
[3:33:13] for three, but I'm sure there's more comments. I don't see any hands on my list, so I don't see any hands on my list,
[3:33:19] so I don't know the right or anything. All right, I go ahead and go ahead and let's go ahead and let's
[3:33:22] go. I'll hit the button. I just didn't want to go. I've been going first to bunch, so I'm
[3:33:28] to everyone as their transfers.
[3:33:32] Yeah, I remember when the final authorization for the bonds for building the REC center
[3:33:37] came, and I spoke about what I thought were a lot of missed opportunities,
[3:33:44] that two councils
[3:33:44] have got three councils ago now, at least three councils ago, possibly more, I'm trying
[3:33:51] to count in my head here.
[3:33:53] But quite a few councils have got lost opportunities to do what I would have thought would
[3:33:57] and really clever things such as using the waste heat
[3:34:01] from the refrigeration, from the ice rink,
[3:34:05] to use that heat to heat the swimming pool, right?
[3:34:08] That would be the kind of not just about installing
[3:34:11] geothermal, but about being outright innovative
[3:34:14] in terms of being efficient with these kinds of systems.
[3:34:20] Because if you've ever put your hand on,
[3:34:22] if ever put your hand to the backside of an air conditioner,
[3:34:25] it gets very hot, because it's pumping the heat out
[3:34:27] your house, there are opportunities to use that waste heat instead of pumping it into the atmosphere
[3:34:32] to pump it into our swimming pool.
[3:34:34] We lost out over and over again on some of these opportunities to be inventive.
[3:34:41] I don't think we should lose out on opportunities here to investigate at least to properly
[3:34:46] assess the cost of geothermal.
[3:34:48] I was a supportive of this in the beginning.
[3:34:51] My frustration is that I think is relevant here is that, you know, this should have been part of the initial design work on this.
[3:35:01] And that should have been part of the design build rather than the design bid build process for the building.
[3:35:08] You know, these are all things that should have been done better, you know, six years ago, seven years ago.
[3:35:14] But the best time to fix a problem if you can't do it in the past is now.
[3:35:19] So I think we should at least go forward to the city. I do think that there is a, you know, there is some good points in that, you know,
[3:35:27] Is there an option to just build a, you know, a perugula or something like that to build a cover with solar panels that can do
[3:35:33] that can handle snow loads if we incline, like that should be a consideration also one of the reasons that's not as good is you get a lot of wind
[3:35:42] Driven snow and you know, it's not going to be completely enclosed so that
[3:35:46] You know, Tahoe is known for its winds, especially in the winter time, so this is, but I think that should be
[3:35:53] Something that we at least have can show the public
[3:35:56] that we consider that option also, that may be a very simple
[3:36:00] use case as well, that we have some solar covered walkway
[3:36:04] that should be in the consideration mix as well.
[3:36:07] I don't think we should buy a gas boiler at this time
[3:36:13] without having properly done a consideration of more environmentally friendly alternatives
[3:36:18] and properly understood what the costs assessments are.
[3:36:22] It's almost certainly going to cost more upfront,
[3:36:24] but we don't know how much more.
[3:36:26] And I think 50 grand, not nothing to me,
[3:36:28] but not a huge amount in the life of the city
[3:36:32] to properly have that to meet the commitments
[3:36:36] that this council has made in terms of carbon reduction.
[3:36:39] So I'm happy to go ahead with the recommended option number,
[3:36:46] whichever one is the one to do the study.
[3:36:49] I forget which one.
[3:36:52] But okay, let me real quickly go to Mr. Jenkins.
[3:36:56] Mr. Jenkins.
[3:36:57] No, I wasn't going to make a motion.
[3:36:59] I'm saying that it's my position.
[3:37:01] I wasn't trying to cut everyone off.
[3:37:04] First, I think we should do what it's safest first.
[3:37:08] And if that is a cover, I thought that was an interesting idea.
[3:37:13] If it's a cover or if it's a boiler, whatever is safest, we do first.
[3:37:17] because somebody falling on their and breaking their neck or dying with their elderly and maybe it's myself, I don't know, we fall.
[3:37:28] That cost will be far in excess of whatever we invest.
[3:37:33] The second thing is I'm excited about the idea of geothermal.
[3:37:37] I'm excited not just at this site, but I think that something the basin should be looking at on a base of my bases.
[3:37:45] They should be helping us examine the potential for that.
[3:37:49] And I would hope that our representatives would be doing that.
[3:37:54] So I'd like that idea about the cover if that's reasonable and feasible and safest,
[3:38:01] but we have to do what is safest because that's what we're supposed to do.
[3:38:07] And so I guess I'm in favor of option three as Ms. Morgan said.
[3:38:11] Yeah, no, I did great and I had just a point out on Mr. Robin's fact. I think that it is I hear you I want to examine it but for the safety side like Mr. Jenkins is talking about it will happen now and I think if we go back to the drawing board we could end up in March before we get to cover so that's why I'm more in favor of
[3:38:29] Yeah, they can deploy the boiler basically right now. So I hear you I would we had for that boiler right now.
[3:38:37] Well, yeah, but if we go to design on a walkway, because I mean, it's going to have to be architecturally
[3:38:42] designed and it's going to have to fit into the buildings, you know, aesthetics. And so you're
[3:38:46] going to end up with, like, you wouldn't end up with any safety standard for this winner, which we
[3:38:51] very well deal with, like a very big winner. So to me, I agree with you on fundamentally, but we don't
[3:38:57] have the time to have the building, you know, have the building basically have snowmelt for this,
[3:39:03] This one, you wouldn't have a, you wouldn't have a cover, and I'll defer to Dr. Mr.
[3:39:08] Yes, excuse me, Dr. Q.
[3:39:10] But I wouldn't think we could get to a cover before.
[3:39:13] Mr. Bass, I was just going to ask, I don't, I don't know the answer to this question,
[3:39:18] whether a cover of that walkway had been evaluated in the past during the design of the project
[3:39:24] or later date, I don't know if Mr. Riddle or Dr. Q would have any information that might help you with that.
[3:39:31] I don't know if Mr. Riddle is still on the call, but he may be most familiar with those details.
[3:39:37] He's on. He's unmuted. Go ahead, Ricky.
[3:39:40] Yeah, absolutely.
[3:39:42] You know, a covered walkway, quite frankly, was not evaluated.
[3:39:49] You're correct in your intuition. It wouldn't be deployable this year.
[3:39:53] You know, quite frankly, it's going to be difficult to get the boiler deployed in time
[3:39:59] as is that.
[3:40:00] Your cue mentioned, you know, it depends on when the snow comes. You know, the beauty is that we already have the engineered assemblies. And, you know, essentially, it's, it's some final touches on design to be able to get something implemented.
[3:40:15] To go through the design efforts of a covered walkway with the snow load is not an impossible feat.
[3:40:22] But it is one that is going to be tremendously more expensive than what is proposed right now.
[3:40:31] Given the size of the walkway, I can't just put a six foot wide cover down the middle of the walkway.
[3:40:38] I would have to cover the entire width of the walkway, most likely.
[3:40:44] And I think there would be a lot of thought and effort that would need to go into something
[3:40:50] like that.
[3:40:51] It's definitely not impossible.
[3:40:54] But at this point in time has not been evaluated and nothing more than the hydronic
[3:41:04] ready assembly was evaluated for implementation aside from a larger hydronic scope that was
[3:41:12] reduced based on financial restrictions during the implementation of the construction.
[3:41:19] Thank you Mr. Rittle.
[3:41:20] All right, so I think we're ready for, well, I don't know. I mean, I think I see consensus
[3:41:24] for number three. I mean, if you would like more comments, that's fine, but we think we do have
[3:41:29] consensus and let's get in the way.
[3:41:32] The proposal is we're going to buy a natural gas powered boiler and also then investigate
[3:41:42] investigate and pay for a study on geothermal, the potential outcome of which is that we would
[3:41:49] then rip out, we would rip out that boiler and replace it with a geothermal heat pump.
[3:41:57] The geothermal is a broader kind of city-wide effort to look at whether there is a feasibility
[3:42:05] to use it and where it might make the most sense to do that.
[3:42:09] it may be a bike path. It may be future fire station. It may be the
[3:42:15] microwave for a low-level officer to do that at the
[3:42:18] rexenter by having installed in natural gas.
[3:42:23] Boy, there's the hydronics are there. So they're the
[3:42:25] hydronics are there. So they're the hydronics are there. So they're the
[3:42:26] hydronics are there. So they're the hydronics. So that's why it's a pretty
[3:42:30] low cost and it's such a small amount of square footage that it really
[3:42:34] is does not burn most likely that much gas because we're not talking
[3:42:38] about a huge amount of square footage area.
[3:42:40] What I was saying is later in time,
[3:42:43] if we have this network that's envisioned
[3:42:44] and the boiler goes out, at that point,
[3:42:47] you would be able to use the manifold
[3:42:49] onto geothermal 20 years down the road
[3:42:51] and then you don't have a boiler replacement cost
[3:42:53] and you don't have any more natural gas costs.
[3:42:56] But that's, yeah, the feasibility of geothermal
[3:43:00] is kind of our first step.
[3:43:02] And again, we approve this twice and the third time is now,
[3:43:05] but this is with an RFP back.
[3:43:07] What's great about this time is we actually have some data back from a company that will perform this feasibility and give us stuff.
[3:43:13] So we're going to, so option three has us installing more fossil fuels at the rec center.
[3:43:18] I don't, there may be three votes for it, but I wouldn't support that.
[3:43:22] I think we can spend one winter snow blowing it and putting down salt for one winter until we find out if we can put geothermal at the rec center and where else we could put it at.
[3:43:34] that seems to be the option that meets the commitments we've made for environmental sustainability.
[3:43:41] Saying, forget it, we're going to burn natural, burn more natural gas, which we already do for
[3:43:45] the pool heating, and we're going to do that for the outside as well, and this option would for
[3:43:50] close any further geothermal for a generation, or for at least a generation for the rec center.
[3:43:58] How does that meet our environmental commitments to the public?
[3:44:02] you know, I actually totally hear that. I think I also heard that if we were, I
[3:44:07] seen in snow plowing that that will decrease the length that that pavement will
[3:44:15] last like it will stand on for a hundred years. We can decide. I guess we just don't
[3:44:20] know whether or not to do geothermal or put in a boiler and we can make that
[3:44:25] decision next year having now known whether or not geothermal would work.
[3:44:29] Yeah, I feel like I hope I don't regret saying this, but I don't believe it's realistic to assume
[3:44:36] that geothermal would even go in next year at the Rec Center. That is okay. I do not interpret
[3:44:43] the proposal we have in the steps we would have to do to happen that quickly. So I would look at
[3:44:48] that. I think three years would be up would be maybe realistic, maybe a little on the optimistic
[3:44:55] outside still, knowing how design processes work.
[3:45:00] I certainly don't believe we would be in a position to do it next year.
[3:45:04] Okay, but not 20 years, which is how long, how long is a boiler last? 20, 30 years?
[3:45:13] Okay.
[3:45:14] They ought to last longer than that if they're new.
[3:45:17] For me, it's like I, I could Scott, I was here with the Padma boilers, and I really been on this beating
[3:45:22] this drum for a while on the Geothermal Conversions. Why for this, to me, at least, I,
[3:45:27] It's such a small area, and the public safety benefit for the people coming and going is huge, and if we end up, you know, I just feel like I know how snow removal happens
[3:45:38] But we would end up contracting it out. But if you have a huge storm, the service is not going to happen during the storm
[3:45:43] People are still wanting to come into the rec center. That's the most used time is going to be the middle of a storm
[3:45:48] Because people need to get out of their house and recreate. So to me I think it again as much as I'm like such an advocate on the geothermal side
[3:45:55] And I don't see this as stopping geothermal by any means.
[3:45:58] I think we're making the move to elevate geothermal,
[3:46:01] get the first feasibility done.
[3:46:04] And then we start to incorporate that.
[3:46:05] Fire Station 3 is definitely one that's coming.
[3:46:08] There will be other projects and then it in public works.
[3:46:12] The feasibility that the counter-ins can look at.
[3:46:15] Four Padma, actually.
[3:46:16] This is also something.
[3:46:18] This feasibility study will cover an informed Padma.
[3:46:21] Do they want to spend a million bucks
[3:46:22] and 120 to 160 grand a year in natural gas,
[3:46:27] or because their boilers are up to replacement
[3:46:29] basically right now as well.
[3:46:31] So this feasibility can do a lot for the time.
[3:46:33] And I just keep thinking that that's where
[3:46:36] you see senior nutrition exists now in the
[3:46:40] SREC Center and Mr. Riddle just clearly articulated
[3:46:43] that the food and staff are coming in from a shaded area
[3:46:48] on an apron to the side of the facility
[3:46:50] that has the capability for this.
[3:46:56] I'm just, I have a hard one for that. This is a hard one for
[3:46:59] me because I agree 100% on the environmental impacts and that we should, you know, weigh public
[3:47:07] safety and the safety of seniors with our environmental goals and initiatives. In this case,
[3:47:15] I feel like going forward with the boilers makes sense in the evaluation in a step towards the evaluation of other measures and actually love the heat pump idea, but it looks like geothermal would be the direction for this, so I support both.
[3:47:35] And I'll just put one more comment on it. One thing too is if geothermal does get realized and we have the network to connect to in its 10 years and we want to connect them and sell the boilers to use boiler.
[3:47:44] That's absolutely something that could happen 10 years down the road when we're like, hey, we want to quit paying that natural gas bill
[3:47:50] Let's connect it. Can you sell a used boiler or is that a feasible thing?
[3:47:53] That's like selling a used car
[3:47:56] I am not the person to answer that question. I can answer for sure everything is for sale and I'm not answering the question at the moment
[3:48:04] Ricky, do you want to try to answer that question?
[3:48:08] You can sell a used boiler, what would occur in that instance and what we have done on other facilities?
[3:48:16] We would most likely repurpose it for a boiler of a similar size that is older at a different facility.
[3:48:22] Okay.
[3:48:24] All right.
[3:48:24] Anybody able to like to thank you, Dr. Cue?
[3:48:27] Motion.
[3:48:28] Motion.
[3:48:28] I'd like to pass a motion directing staff to execute an agreement for a geothermal feasibility study and
[3:48:34] cure and install a gas powered boiler for the hydronic system at the multi-generational recreation and aquatic center.
[3:48:41] Second.
[3:48:43] We got a motion in a second and we can vote.
[3:48:49] That motion carries.
[3:48:51] Great.
[3:48:51] Okay, with that we will take a small break.
[3:48:54] Come back at 9.15.
[3:49:09] Okay, we are going to call this meeting back to order.
[3:49:11] We are on item number 13.
[3:49:14] This is the wave first reading and introduction of an ordinance.
[3:49:17] submitting South Lake Tahoe City Code Title VI Chapter 6.4 of our sign and advertising structures.
[3:49:23] Article 3, General provisions, Section 6.4, 080, Mr. Hitchcock.
[3:49:32] Good evening again, Mayor Bass and Council members for the Reckon John Hitchcock.
[3:49:36] I'm the item before you is consideration amendment of Title VI, Chapter 6.4,
[3:49:41] Article 3, Section 6.4, Point Oedo, which just has to do with signs and activities,
[3:49:47] 9 Procuring Permits, as the Council may recall, on November 4th of last year, I'm
[3:49:53] staff presented the current status of Sino and its two Council members, which primarily
[3:49:57] focused on portable signage, a-frame.
[3:50:01] And the ordinance has currently written allows port of signage on Fridays and on weekends and on holidays
[3:50:06] from 8 to 5pm. At that meeting on November 4th, council member Robbins made a motion which was
[3:50:15] second by council member Roberts directing staff to bring back amendments to the council of consideration
[3:50:21] to ensure echo access to signage for all local businesses. And also as it means to promote economic
[3:50:27] activity in the city of South Lake Tahoe.
[3:50:30] In drafting our ordinances, our proposed ordinances
[3:50:33] staff did meet with the City Council at Hock Committee,
[3:50:36] and Councilman Robbins, and Councilman Mayor Bass,
[3:50:39] and also representatives of the Tahoe Chamber
[3:50:41] and Seltah, Restaurant Association.
[3:50:44] Some of the feedback received from that Hock Committee
[3:50:46] was requiring the use of high quality materials
[3:50:50] and regulating colors of temporary signage,
[3:50:53] are discussions with the stakeholders.
[3:50:57] Their focus was primarily on portable signs,
[3:51:01] and what we heard back from them is they wanted to
[3:51:04] ensure that there was equal access to all businesses
[3:51:05] to portable signage to current ordinance today
[3:51:08] only allows one per parcel.
[3:51:11] Based on that feedback, staff did draft ordinance
[3:51:14] for your consideration that includes the following elements.
[3:51:18] Allow portable signage, a frames to display Monday through Friday,
[3:51:22] AEM to 10 p.m., the increase in time is to accommodate businesses that may stay open later.
[3:51:30] Limits sign-copy-size to six feet per side, this is kind of the average size sign frames
[3:51:39] and we did a research. Also, limit height of those sandwich boards, a frames to four feet.
[3:51:46] Also, delete banners as an option since all businesses as even businesses within a business complex
[3:51:52] would qualify, staff is concerned with potential visual clutter that
[3:51:58] damage would create by putting them up on buildings, and also include language
[3:52:03] addresses, materials, colors, and sign maintenance. We didn't include in
[3:52:08] your staff packet on pages 473, 474 of your packet includes some examples of
[3:52:16] frames that staff would consider these as appropriate type of a frames for the tile basin.
[3:52:25] We also did research the cost of a frames and they range from $130 for plastic a frames
[3:52:31] all the way up to about $600 for metal a frames and custom a frames.
[3:52:36] Staff did include plastic as an option to ensure that signage can be obtained for reasonable
[3:52:41] cost.
[3:52:42] But also at the same time, I was also limiting the color options to Ertone and darker hue colors.
[3:52:49] The pose line was just shown on page one toe, your agenda packet, and then that concludes my presentation, and I can answer any questions.
[3:52:58] Thank you.
[3:52:59] Thank you so much, Mr. Hitchcock.
[3:53:01] Mr. Jenkins.
[3:53:03] Mr. Hitchcock, thank you very much.
[3:53:04] And my question is this, and your view is what you're proposing environmentally sound
[3:53:11] and business friendly.
[3:53:13] I believe it is, sir.
[3:53:15] Thank you.
[3:53:16] Thank you.
[3:53:17] Any other questions before we go to public comment?
[3:53:20] I'll just go Mr. Roberts.
[3:53:24] So I think it's great that there are given e-glacces, like one for business, instead of one
[3:53:28] for parcel.
[3:53:29] But what are some of the challenges that do you think about?
[3:53:33] for some, like, take where cold water brewery is.
[3:53:38] You know, there's several businesses in that small area.
[3:53:41] All of them can't put a sandwich board out front.
[3:53:44] It's just gonna, it's not gonna look good.
[3:53:46] It's gonna be too much.
[3:53:48] There's not enough room to put that many signs out.
[3:53:50] Has there been any options discussed about how to address that
[3:53:54] and give them opportunities as well?
[3:53:56] I think from the kind of public perspective, I think we have to also do some outreach to business owners.
[3:54:07] I had the discussion on them and how they can put out portable signage while still ensuring that we don't create additional visual clutter.
[3:54:16] And some businesses, I think they may personally have to within their own association, probably maybe rotate signage in order that everyone has their opportunity to put out sign.
[3:54:25] within the limited space of the hair, that could be an option.
[3:54:32] Yeah, I mean, I guess the amount of space available will limit some
[3:54:34] of the opportunities.
[3:54:38] Okay.
[3:54:38] Thank you, Mr. Roberts.
[3:54:40] Mr. Robbins.
[3:54:42] On page six of the staff report, you've got like a graphic of four
[3:54:45] signs.
[3:54:46] And you mentioned the plastic ones are cheapest at a hundred
[3:54:48] something dollars.
[3:54:50] How much roughly are the other three?
[3:54:52] So how much roughly are the other three that you have picture here?
[3:54:57] Well, I think it's specific the spive cost for those.
[3:55:00] Signs, I looked up at a bunch of different signs today, and they range from 130 to 600. It just depends on how elaborate the sign is. And if you go with a custom, custom design, then it gets very expensive, particularly metal ones.
[3:55:14] I have more for comments, but.
[3:55:18] All right. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
[3:55:18] Thank you.
[3:55:19] I'm going to go ahead and open the item for public comment. Item number 13. Yes, Mr. Moser.
[3:55:34] Yeah, the big thing with this big problem with it as if it everything else is enforcement.
[3:55:42] You know, years ago when they changed and made the new laws and stuff there, there was on
[3:55:47] Skewer on the coffee place that was just off of Skewer on there.
[3:55:51] You know, and they're putting their sign right in Skewer on Boulevard.
[3:55:54] You know, and it was like eight feet, you know, the edge outside of the parking space
[3:55:59] And in the screen on the street there and stuff when we were supposed to be sidewalks and just weekends.
[3:56:06] And we even had two council members living up the hill from there coming down every day passing it and never did anything about it.
[3:56:13] And a couple other business people I talked to and everything and was mentioned and one even said,
[3:56:19] Ed, why don't you mention that sign on ski run? I said, I mentioned it to people that drive by it council members.
[3:56:25] So, you know, that is a problem, I mean, you know, when you master enforcement of VHRs and E scooters and E bike channel, maybe you can, you know, allow this.
[3:56:37] It's just one more thing that, you know, you have to enforce and I don't think you, you know, you really don't have the time or the manpower or anything to enforce it.
[3:56:44] You know, Mr. Roberts made the point, if, you know, by cold brewery there and that little shopping center, I mean, you know, people driving down the road aren't going to see if they have in front of their shop there, a little sign or anything that's, you know, it's worth a mouth, you know, for your business or you pull in there and see it or see the sign for the business, you might want to look and maybe consider more of, you know, people being allowed to put signs in their windows of the business that, you know, aren't, you know,
[3:57:14] you know, that are attracted somewhat, you know, and a little more artful oriented and stuff
[3:57:19] that to catch people's eye or something. So I would look, you know, when you had even the
[3:57:24] front of your building there, when you were doing the construction there, it was the best and
[3:57:27] had that mural out there, you know, that was tremendous. You know, so I would look more, you
[3:57:35] know, more in the line of actual artwork, you know, if you go by, by CVS there in the state
[3:57:41] line corridor and the casino corridor there and there's the business is there and
[3:57:46] type two or something and another one and you know they put you know sandwich boards
[3:57:50] right out in the middle of the sidewalk that's like this wide and sandwich boards of this
[3:57:54] wide and on a weekend people are having to squeeze through and turn sideways just to pass through
[3:57:59] there and it's like you know they just have no laws or no regulations and that's what you get
[3:58:04] and what you end up with. So yeah I would look at you know limiting
[3:58:10] But also, whatever you do, and decide on if you're going to allow more of them enforcement,
[3:58:17] you know, is really the key otherwise it just gets, it gets ugly and, you know, you just
[3:58:22] end up with another roadside attraction is what we've become.
[3:58:25] Thank you.
[3:58:27] Thank you Mr. Mayor.
[3:58:28] Yes, Mr. Sauterson.
[3:58:34] Mr. Sauterson.
[3:58:36] This is a huge thing for our businesses and I think we've gone over this quite a few times that,
[3:58:42] COVID. It worked really well. A lot of our businesses are set very far back from the road and we are a tourist community and sandwich
[3:58:50] boards are very, very common in nearly every single tourist community. If you go to the coastal city is like Fort Bragg area, Glass Beach.
[3:58:59] That's how everything is done. I do think that it needs to be done thoughtfully. There are clearly some places where they're not appropriate for space reasons, but that's easily mitigated.
[3:59:12] We definitely can work with the businesses and be patient while we find places to set them.
[3:59:18] We really don't want to see limited our businesses.
[3:59:20] I don't like banners, though, should not be allowed with sandwich boards or beautiful.
[3:59:25] I wish that we could stick to maybe some kind of wood production.
[3:59:29] You know, some kind of standardized template that people can use to kind of keep them a little nicer.
[3:59:36] Sometimes they're pretty ugly, very bulky, it can be done really beautifully though, and I really
[3:59:43] think that it would be a huge boom to our businesses, more than doing these economic
[3:59:47] studies and stuff we really need to be helping our businesses survive here, and this is a huge
[3:59:52] huge thing for them. I know people don't like them, but I walk everywhere in this town,
[3:59:57] and even walking around, it's really hard to see.
[4:00:00] Our businesses from the road. So it really would make a huge difference. Consider some kind of thoughtful templates, though.
[4:00:07] I know that we did some signs for the barely league and they were very heavy plastic with like metal inserts in them.
[4:00:15] So they don't blow away. They're really solid and look nice. And they're like $300.
[4:00:20] So I mean, it can be done well and not very expensive, but please approve this. I think we've tried multiple times now. Thanks.
[4:00:29] Anybody else here in the public that would like to get public comments saying none will go to Zoom?
[4:00:34] No, none's in there.
[4:00:36] Okay.
[4:00:36] We will go ahead and bring it back to council.
[4:00:39] I can open this up a little bit and I was on the subcommittee.
[4:00:41] I think we worked on the subcommittee through this ordinance.
[4:00:44] We listened to the public and yes, so much boards is what the business is really want.
[4:00:49] And I think we've done good work on this ordinance.
[4:00:51] I also think this is an issue that continuously should be worked on.
[4:00:55] I think a lot can be done even in the city looking at like artful signs and providing, you know, even grants for property owners and businesses that want to make great art signs that fit into the community.
[4:01:06] But again, I think that's all for later and something this should just always be a working issue the same thing for kind of faded signs and how can we get people to improve some of the signs along Highway 50.
[4:01:16] But for me tonight, I think we've done work on this ordinance and ready to move forward with the first reading.
[4:01:22] So I know Mr. Robbins, you have some comments.
[4:01:28] The operative word here that I introduced staff to apparently is Schlach.
[4:01:36] Schlach?
[4:01:37] Schlach?
[4:01:37] No, Schlach.
[4:01:38] Because sometimes the word he need is just Giddish.
[4:01:41] And that's all there is to it.
[4:01:44] And so Schlach means that which is kind of junky and ugly.
[4:01:48] And on and on poetically, it means what it sounds like.
[4:01:52] And the challenge I have is, I respect that the business is want to have their signs out more during more time.
[4:02:00] And I'm fine with that. If in exchange, we have better looking signs, less shlocky signs.
[4:02:08] And that we don't have a plastic, chency, you know, trashy looking signs to that end.
[4:02:15] One of the things I think that the amendment does well is give examples, at least in three examples,
[4:02:21] of what better looking signs are, but one of the things I think that got missed in the process
[4:02:27] was that I think we should probably not be using plastics as a material for those signs.
[4:02:34] I think I'm fine with expanding sign hours and having more of the signs from more of the businesses,
[4:02:41] but they should in exchange for that expansion, the rest of the community should get better
[4:02:47] better looking environment, and that means signs that are either not made of plastic or
[4:02:52] don't look like they're made out of plastic, of this injection molded, blown plastic.
[4:02:57] And that would be the upper left option on page six of the report.
[4:03:01] It's better that it's black, because the ones that are using now are bleached white, and
[4:03:05] they look like PVC pipes, they really look bad.
[4:03:09] Black is better, but I think we're giving a lot to the businesses here to have a lot more
[4:03:15] signs that they want, I think we should make an amendment to the item to include a clause that
[4:03:23] says in terms of the materials requirements that say prohibit sandwich boards that are made
[4:03:33] of or appear to be made of predominantly plastic materials.
[4:03:37] Otherwise, I think if you're looking at like the upper right, the other options, the wood
[4:03:41] talk for once. All those are fairly nice. And I'm fine with that. The other thing I suggest,
[4:03:47] and I brought this up from Monday staff meeting was that I think we should come back to this
[4:03:52] in about a year to see how it worked out and request that staff return this issue after a summer's
[4:04:01] worth with enough time for amendments to be made over the course of a winter. And we can evaluate
[4:04:08] And to put that on the planning agenda whatever now, I don't need a specific data or anything,
[4:04:13] but you know, so that we come back and see, do we have problems with 10 signs all clustered
[4:04:18] together at the turn-in for a, at the driveway entrance for a shopping plaza?
[4:04:23] Is that something we need to come back and address, or is this, is this actually a problem or not?
[4:04:27] Thank you, Mr. Robbins, Mr. Jenkins.
[4:04:35] First of all, I want to compliment the committee working with constituents and the business community
[4:04:41] to come up with ways to make our businesses help our businesses to better survive and
[4:04:49] advertise themselves.
[4:04:50] Secondly, I think I'm no expert on science, but I always thought that plastic science
[4:04:58] or water proof.
[4:05:00] I guess if you use the right plastic. But I like the idea. In fact, I had written down here, maybe what you do is adopt the ordinance as it is, but with a sunset provision. And says, and say in a year, that unless the council reenacts it, that the ordinance goes away, and that gives you the ability to evaluate the effectiveness of the current ordinance.
[4:05:27] And to make changes what you might think or need it.
[4:05:32] And also it tells the business community that we want to work with them,
[4:05:37] but we don't want a lot, what was a shocky, but we don't want a lot of shocky signs.
[4:05:43] And so I trust the work of the committee, the work that's been done,
[4:05:49] and maybe with a sunset provision that Council then will have to re-enact
[4:05:55] in the future based upon experience.
[4:05:58] That's all.
[4:05:58] Thank you, Mr. Jenkins.
[4:05:59] Mr. Morgan.
[4:06:01] So echoing all the comments.
[4:06:03] I, my only comment to the signs.
[4:06:09] The examples that we have are all lovely,
[4:06:12] and I actually think the black plastic looks fine.
[4:06:15] My only issue with enforcing,
[4:06:23] I think
[4:06:25] If businesses already have some of the other signs, I don't want to place a financial burden
[4:06:30] on them in order to meet this new standard if that sign already exists.
[4:06:36] I think encouraging these signs or suggesting that when their sign is at end of use that
[4:06:46] they replace it with this option.
[4:06:48] I just feel like right now everything is expensive and asking people to toss their signs,
[4:06:53] which may be plastic and then they're just getting thrown in the trash in order to replace
[4:06:59] them with a sign that meets the ordinance.
[4:07:04] I would just, I would prefer if the language suggested that when those signs are at end
[4:07:10] of use, they replace it with something that meets the ordinance, just an idea, and then
[4:07:16] I like this sunset idea or that this ordinance gets revisited, you know, at a certain time that we choose to see how it went, to get feedback from the residents, but then also from the businesses and make sure that it's meeting the needs of both.
[4:07:36] Thank you so much. Mr. Roberts was there in the comments from you.
[4:07:42] I just wanted to say I kind of disagree with that about having them used the old signs.
[4:07:47] Because for one, as you mentioned, it's going to be even harder to enforce.
[4:07:52] And it opens it up to more views where, I mean, how are we going to know when they had the sign purchased, you know.
[4:07:59] And the whole objective of this is to improve the sites on our city streets and our city businesses, so I don't think we should allow that, but I do think I like the sunset clause idea.
[4:08:12] Okay.
[4:08:13] It seems like there's agreement on the sunset clause.
[4:08:16] The sunset clause, just to clarify, I mean if we put that in, then it kind of makes it automatically expire.
[4:08:22] If we just say that we have to revisit it to possibly make amendments then it kind of makes the committee not have to be in a hurry up
[4:08:30] To bring it back if you follow what I mean
[4:08:35] I understand your point
[4:08:37] I think the Sunset clause puts the pressure on everybody
[4:08:40] Yeah, that that whatever is done has to be something that's viewed positively by the business community
[4:08:46] By the city council by the public and that's the only reason that that was suggested
[4:08:51] If it had to be reviewed in a time certain, I guess to some degree would, I think the pressure
[4:09:01] is really on if there's a sunset provision, a most laws never go away.
[4:09:06] They just keep piling up as we know from Sacramento,
[4:09:11] and so I think either is good.
[4:09:16] I like the idea that we're trying to work with the business community to make them ensure
[4:09:21] that they are sustainable, that they are profitable, that they hire people, and that this
[4:09:25] is an opportunity to do that in a non-shelucky way.
[4:09:30] So would we, as a council, think that the sunset, or just the bringing this back in a year,
[4:09:35] if we do this side sunset, do you think setting it out like 18 months that way, it comes back
[4:09:39] in a year, it gives us subcommittee time to work on it to bring back in order.
[4:09:42] Yeah, I was thinking that if it was by Indy, you know, December next year or January, the following
[4:09:48] here that that that would give enough time to evaluate performance and I'll ask the city manager
[4:09:54] here.
[4:09:55] I think sure I think you know if the first reading of the sort.
[4:10:00] All right, we're going to move on to the next meeting. The next meeting is approved tonight. There will be a second reading on November 3rd. So kind of puts us pretty close to a year from then we'll cover full summer and we'll be able to bring some information back to council.
[4:10:17] I'm sitting in a year and a month, definitely be by the end of the 18 months we've been plenty of time.
[4:10:23] I'm not fine at all.
[4:10:24] You have committee meetings and then the drafts were fine.
[4:10:27] It's been between a year and 18 months is when appropriate.
[4:10:30] I think that we would be able to bring it back.
[4:10:32] I'd say shoot for 18 months only because it gives again.
[4:10:34] The committee can meet.
[4:10:35] There's got to be an order to instruct.
[4:10:36] It's got to the first and second and all that.
[4:10:39] My big issue is I'm indifferent.
[4:10:42] I mean that in the genuine sense, not the facetious sense about it.
[4:10:45] having it be an issue or having it be come back, you know, for review or having it be a sunset
[4:10:50] preserve. You both are equally fine for me, 12 to 18 months, whatever, that's also fine.
[4:10:57] The bigger issue for me is we are opening hundreds of new businesses to have a frame signs
[4:11:03] that would not have had them legally under the current ordinance.
[4:11:08] And so a bunch of people are going to buy new signs, a whole bunch of people I would anticipate
[4:11:12] will buy new signs. I would like that not to be crappy looking plastic. And the only way to do that
[4:11:21] is to put that into the ordinance, which is says, you know, and I'm sorry, that's that's an amendment
[4:11:26] we could make. And I did review with Sergio de Arco, assuming I'll be covered it, that would not be considered
[4:11:36] manifest material change. That would be sufficiently minor that we could do it here and now.
[4:11:39] So I have language in mind for that amendment if there's consensus on prohibiting plastic materials.
[4:11:47] They can use the cheapest wood option.
[4:11:50] You can use reclaimed wood, which actually look even cooler and be homemade and be nice.
[4:11:55] But like the cheap A-frame, the cheap plastic injection molded stuff.
[4:12:00] If we have dozens and dozens of new signs of that along Highway 50, we will have shot ourselves.
[4:12:04] Those are not crappy looking.
[4:12:06] Shlocky looking.
[4:12:07] Shlocky looking.
[4:12:08] Shlocky looking.
[4:12:08] So, can I ask a question on that language that I would assume would be part of the motion?
[4:12:14] The images that we have that include molded black sign, your sig, are you wanting language
[4:12:25] that prohibit all plastic signs or was that sign accepted?
[4:12:31] And what I would say is, no, no, so what I would say in the language is that I would amend,
[4:12:38] specifically, I would amend section F lowercase, Roman numeral 2, and then add a VI subsection
[4:12:47] lowercase 6 to say, and excludes, I would like to just say, exclude Schlock, that would be,
[4:12:54] but that's not an enforceable language, much as I would prefer, to exclude signs that have the
[4:12:59] appearance of being made predominantly of plastic.
[4:13:03] Which would allow you to have something that is plastic, but looks just like wood, which
[4:13:08] is probably a thing, but that should not look like it's made of plastic.
[4:13:13] So on VI, where it says sandwich boards, Saudi constructed of high quality materials and
[4:13:18] color shall be limited to darker earth tone hues, and must be maintaining good repair.
[4:13:23] And so I would say, and shall not have the appearance of being made out of plastic.
[4:13:27] I think we maybe a simpler suggestion is just to say constructed of high-quality, non-plastic materials.
[4:13:36] Yeah.
[4:13:37] I'm slightly more restrictive than what I'm saying, which I'm also fine with.
[4:13:41] But yeah.
[4:13:42] And then the other thing is we wanted to say that that's only going to be for new businesses.
[4:13:46] Signs that already exist can be used, which gets very difficult to enforce.
[4:13:51] So we're just going to say everybody that has a plastic sign in to throw it away.
[4:13:54] They can't use it anymore.
[4:13:55] or sell it on Facebook.
[4:13:57] I mean, that's, I have a little bit.
[4:13:58] I'm worried about just throwing it up.
[4:14:00] You're throwing away a lot of plastic at that point.
[4:14:03] And I'm putting a burden on a business investment for people.
[4:14:06] I'm a market place to restaurants in Reno.
[4:14:08] Yeah, but I mean, I'm off with tons of plastic.
[4:14:09] I think you can do it in a new, like any new sign that is purchased,
[4:14:15] which I know is a very difficult thing to enforce.
[4:14:18] It's not like, but I just, I have a hard time saying that I want all my
[4:14:22] the businesses that currently own a frame science
[4:14:24] to have to throw them away.
[4:14:26] I have a real-
[4:14:26] No idea, we are giving something up,
[4:14:29] which is-
[4:14:30] No, these are not signs that require a permit,
[4:14:32] so we do not have an inventory of the existing.
[4:14:36] And I think we're giving up a lot more signs
[4:14:39] on a lot more days, which they did not have.
[4:14:41] I just think about the amount of plastic thrown away,
[4:14:43] just in that one motion.
[4:14:45] That's my only thing is like, I just don't.
[4:14:47] And so, I mean, I hear you,
[4:14:49] and I do want to see quality signs,
[4:14:50] And I do agree that some of those don't look the greatest.
[4:14:54] I just, when I think about how many plastic science currently exist and they're all going
[4:14:57] to need to be thrown away, that to me.
[4:15:00] My concern is the functional reality, which is that if we say plastic signs are okay, everyone's
[4:15:05] going to do the cheapest option, which is the rational decision for every business is to choose
[4:15:11] the lowest cost thing that benefits themselves to the most.
[4:15:14] I could support the idea that a new business that's going to get in a, and a sign should
[4:15:18] go into this higher quality, but I do not support every business needs to throw away their sign
[4:15:22] and buy a new one. I just can't get behind that, because I, you know, how hard it is in business.
[4:15:27] it's like, I just feel like those are things that our business community is not going to support.
[4:15:32] I don't know.
[4:15:33] Those personal signs are like, you know, $900.
[4:15:36] They're not, they're not, they're not.
[4:15:37] They're not, they're not.
[4:15:38] That's a new sign we're asking for is going to be through your 400.
[4:15:41] So you're throwing away your $100 investment to be estimated 400.
[4:15:44] But it's the throwing away also.
[4:15:46] This is going to put more plastic in our landfills and that's a big reason.
[4:15:51] If they're still usable, if they're still of a decent quality, it's just to throw them out just because
[4:15:58] That's where I'm going to say I don't want them to look different.
[4:16:00] disagree with you, but how do we execute that?
[4:16:04] So there's a way, but it's a kind of really non-inforcible in a sense, to just say that
[4:16:08] look, any new business or new sign purchase should follow these standards or shall.
[4:16:13] You could put shall, but I don't think that we're going to call them non-conforming, because
[4:16:20] it just says a new purchase, right?
[4:16:22] We don't need to put non-conforming language, so I think that's one way to do that.
[4:16:26] and not have a, and I can head draft language for that if.
[4:16:31] If that's a motion.
[4:16:33] That'll be my, I'm never say I'm not willing to compromise.
[4:16:37] I do have some other folks.
[4:16:38] Mr. Jenkins, would you like to comment one?
[4:16:41] No, Mr. Roberts?
[4:16:42] No.
[4:16:43] Okay.
[4:16:43] Go for the motion.
[4:16:44] Mr. Roberts.
[4:16:45] All right.
[4:16:46] Let's see if I can swing this.
[4:16:50] I motion to wave first reading and introduce by title only
[4:16:54] and ordinance amending South Lake Tahoe City Code Title 6 chapter 6.40 signs and advertising
[4:17:02] structures article 3 general provisions sections 6.40.080 signs and activities not requiring
[4:17:10] permits to expand the timeframe in which a portable sign may be displayed and refer second reading
[4:17:17] and adoptions the November 3rd, 2026 meeting and to amend
[4:17:26] Section 6.40.080, Subsection F, Subsection I.I. Subsection B, Subsection.
[4:17:46] Where's the, sorry, where's the, I just want to point out, I'm sorry, but it looks like the the numbering is a little different.
[4:17:53] on the, I got through that hole! The ordinance lists the section that you're
[4:18:05] referring to at, you know, one at a time, one at a time please, as section I, and you,
[4:18:11] as residential, I'm reading sandwich board, signs and compliance with the following standards.
[4:18:20] Do I need to give you, can I give you it without having a specific section?
[4:18:25] I think I'll just add a sentence, striking the provision on the exact location of the amendment
[4:18:33] to amend the ordinance to include that for all new signs, the new signage must meet the
[4:18:44] construction standards, and that those standards be amended to specify that the high quality
[4:18:50] materials shall not include plastic. Is that adequate for making the amendment in the
[4:18:57] ordinance? Okay. And that change is okay to have a first reading with that change.
[4:19:03] Okay. Okay. All right, we have a motion in a second and we can vote. If I could also just
[4:19:09] because it was on the table to have a sunset close.
[4:19:13] And also that the provision shall be sunseted in 18 months.
[4:19:22] I'm seconding.
[4:19:23] Seconding the amended motion.
[4:19:29] It's fine.
[4:19:34] That was easy.
[4:19:35] That motion unanimously carries.
[4:19:37] Great.
[4:19:38] All right.
[4:19:38] We're moving on to item number 14.
[4:19:40] We're going to wave the first.
[4:19:41] This is for waving the first reading and an introduction of an ordinance
[4:19:44] increasing city council compensation and this will be a Mrs. Susan Carpenter.
[4:19:49] Thank you, City Council.
[4:19:51] I'm bringing an item forward to increase city council compensation.
[4:19:56] I do this every two years before the election when it is.
[4:20:00] As appropriate to bring it forward, I will note that the Tribune in turn has made us aware of a mathematical
[4:20:07] air, so we won't be doing a first reading today, but we're going to go ahead with this item,
[4:20:13] so I can get direction, and I will bring back a first reading November 3rd. But let's discuss
[4:20:19] the item and see what kind of compensation you'd like to give yourselves. The maximum you're allowed
[4:20:25] to give yourselves as 5% per year and you can do any other lower amount or none at all.
[4:20:33] So if you can provide me direction today, I will bring back an ordinance on November 3rd.
[4:20:40] Very good.
[4:20:41] Thank you, Mr. Carbender.
[4:20:43] Bring in this back to council for first questions if we have any questions.
[4:20:47] I'm going to open the public comment.
[4:20:47] If the ordinance is on the November 3rd agenda, and it takes two readings.
[4:20:53] and then 30 days before its adoption will, will the increase should it be allowed, which I
[4:21:04] own concerns about, be operative for the newly seated city council or not.
[4:21:10] So the provision is that this will not become effective until January 25th.
[4:21:16] I believe this will be effective January 20th.
[4:21:19] Thank you.
[4:21:19] Yes.
[4:21:20] Thank you.
[4:21:21] Thank you.
[4:21:21] Yeah, great. Any other questions from council on this item? Okay. I have questions. Oh question. Oh, I'm sorry. I'm not on that.
[4:21:29] Thank you.
[4:21:30] Hello, you go first.
[4:21:32] Yeah, so remember my experiences in healthcare. So I wrote down the numbers just just with my question.
[4:21:41] So is it customary? It seems to do 5% has been customary.
[4:21:46] That's what we have done the last two times I've brought this forward.
[4:21:50] three times it has a council ever decided not to accept a five percent. No. Okay. And is it correct that
[4:22:00] 3.3 percent would be more in alignment with what see your management staff got?
[4:22:08] Just I think they're the advice on the inflation adjustment or I'm trying to get it to look.
[4:22:18] you can go with inflation if you'd like. I just throw out 5% because that's what you're allowed to have.
[4:22:26] Yeah, but that's why I give you two other options. You can go somewhere lower. You can decide not to give yourselves a raise at all.
[4:22:33] Yeah, you can decrease it back to zero.
[4:22:37] I'm curious why we do this ahead of the election rather than after the election so that the new council can make that decision rather than us making a decision.
[4:22:46] because it's per government code, you're not allowed to do that.
[4:22:49] It's in the separate part.
[4:22:50] It has to be done before the election is sort of...
[4:22:56] Yeah, that's why it's every two years, before the election is...
[4:22:59] Yeah, and only before the election.
[4:23:00] And I think, you know, when we look at this, it's...
[4:23:02] We're really...
[4:23:03] If you look at the amount of accounts of member makes,
[4:23:06] it's...
[4:23:06] It's barely even covering our basic cost on things.
[4:23:10] I mean, it really is.
[4:23:11] And so I think you're, it's a disservice to future councils not to do.
[4:23:14] And, you know, there's a lot of talk about this around, this really is inequitable for people that want to run for council that don't have the way with all financial need to do it, and so we should be increasing this, and hopefully the state will make an effort to change this amount so that it's, you know, not just available to people that have the financial ability to give 20 to 30 to 40 hours a week to volunteer, because that's really what it takes.
[4:23:39] and if you look at the compensation for that amount of time, and many people don't recognize
[4:23:44] it isn't just City Council, it's TRPA, it's DTD, it's 7, 7 other commissions, staffs,
[4:23:50] there's not many meetings, phone calls, on and on, but wait, let's tell us questions, sorry,
[4:23:55] let me go to public comments, I don't know if you've got your questions, you don't know,
[4:23:59] I have a comment, just like you were saying, okay, so I'll open this to public comment,
[4:24:03] miss Autiston.
[4:24:08] Well, it's a saddest in South Lake Tahoe, just no.
[4:24:12] Now's not the time.
[4:24:13] We've had a shit show of a year.
[4:24:16] We do not know who the new council members are going to be.
[4:24:19] And the most of the community has very little faith in the people that are running.
[4:24:24] Scott, a lot of people are supporting you, which is great to see.
[4:24:30] I can't afford to fall into your 20 hours a week, but I do it.
[4:24:34] And I feel that people that run for City Council are doing this because they believe in performing a civic duty.
[4:24:42] And I'm sorry that if it costs too many but there are ways to figure that out.
[4:24:46] Carpooling is an option. There are plenty of ways that we can work it out.
[4:24:51] What you guys make for this is well above what people are making in this town.
[4:24:56] So I don't understand how this is not tied to some minimum wage thing.
[4:25:00] I, money needs to be taken completely out of politics. I don't understand why you're running for a city council position if you feel you need to be compensated for your time.
[4:25:11] It's pretty insulting for people who are really struggling in this town and we're not getting a lot of results from the council.
[4:25:19] it was frankly embarrassing what we had to put up with with Tamra.
[4:25:27] I don't know. We really
[4:25:28] need to rethink this. It is great to think that cola increases need to happen, but
[4:25:34] that's not happening for most people. People are struggling right now. People are
[4:25:39] broke right now.
[4:25:42] My family's fucked right now. So I don't understand how you guys
[4:25:48] all are allowed to vote on what your compensation is. That should be something that's entirely up to the
[4:25:54] community. I don't understand how that's even legal. I can't vote on what my income is. I can't vote on
[4:26:02] what I'm paid at my job and I just don't know. Most of the time I really don't have an issue with this, but
[4:26:13] Because the number goes up, that 5%, becomes a larger number every single year and that jump, that's a large jump.
[4:26:22] So, I don't know, maybe there should be some stipends coming from the community for gas, for travel.
[4:26:28] Those kind of things are much more equitable, they're much more palatable for the community.
[4:26:34] But just giving you guys a paycheck to do what I consider a civic duty, which I would have done for free, is...
[4:26:43] Yeah, I don't know. Are you here for money or are you here because you care about the community is really what it comes down to and it's fine that you get to pay check, but
[4:26:51] Just an increase every year just for the hell of it is pretty insulting when our community is struggling to feed themselves right now.
[4:27:00] Thank you.
[4:27:01] It mows
[4:27:10] our staff like Tau.
[4:27:12] I want to raise.
[4:27:16] You know, two bananas,
[4:27:21] yeah, I kind of agree with Melissa on the point of, you know, the last year and to be quite honest, you know, I've been coming to meetings for longer than I want to admit.
[4:27:38] And, you know, the previous council was the worst of that time, and in my opinion, they've
[4:27:47] all been marginal to bad,
[4:27:52] and you know, the results speak for themselves.
[4:27:56] So, you know, after having, you know, lost a lot of faith in the community, if you looked
[4:28:00] that your study there that you did and what a few citizens that did answer and respond
[4:28:08] of what their responses were, wasn't too good, wasn't too positive.
[4:28:12] I mean, you know, you got lower ratings and Donald Trump for gosh-stakes, you know,
[4:28:17] you know, a lot of categories.
[4:28:19] So I would hold off on any raise for right now.
[4:28:23] But one thing we're not addressing, which I've mentioned, just about every time this has
[4:28:27] come up is it's not just the 1400 that you get paid. You're also getting the medical plan
[4:28:33] most of you unless I don't know if you're retired and so security or something, I think
[4:28:39] you're not allowed to get that if I'm not mistaken if that's still the same. So, you know,
[4:28:46] some of those have been, you know, the 27, 28, 28,000 dollar range. You know, so actually when I
[4:28:57] $143,000 was the compensation package, full compensation package.
[4:29:04] So it's not just the $1,400 a month, so there are people that have run in the past just
[4:29:10] because they really needed that for their families and themselves needed a medical coverage.
[4:29:17] So they weren't retired and couldn't afford it for their families.
[4:29:23] So it's not just the $1,000 that you're getting.
[4:29:26] So I think that in lieu of that, when you consider everything, I would put a hold on it.
[4:29:33] You know, good message to the community that you want to earn it, and it's, you're not
[4:29:38] poppers, you're all looking well fed, well kept.
[4:29:43] So I think it'd be a good message to send to the community and wait one year, at least,
[4:29:48] until giving yourselves a raise.
[4:29:50] Thank you.
[4:29:51] Thank you, Mr. Moser.
[4:29:52] Anybody else here in the public seeing Namongo Resume?
[4:29:58] Comments on.
[4:30:00] Great. We'll bring it back, but actually before we do, because it looks like we are going to go a couple minutes past 10, hopefully only a couple, please. So if I could get a motion to the city council to move past 20 years.
[4:30:11] I'll make a motion that we extend the meeting past 10 pm.
[4:30:15] I don't know how many of you have about a dozen things for APCs.
[4:30:18] Someone's second? Second.
[4:30:19] Yes.
[4:30:20] And then we can vote.
[4:30:21] I didn't.
[4:30:23] It's roll call.
[4:30:23] All in favor? Any opposed?
[4:30:26] Yeah, motion unanimously.
[4:30:28] Okay.
[4:30:28] Okay, we're going to bring this back to Council.
[4:30:31] I will just say a couple of comments on this real quick, because I've been here through all
[4:30:35] of these every two years.
[4:30:37] I think that, again, I said it before, I think we do a service to the Council.
[4:30:40] When you look at a, you know, $1,400 for one month, it's below minimum wage by far if you put
[4:30:47] the hours together that we, that we commit to this.
[4:30:50] And it's far below on certain months when the demands are far beyond, I think, what a lot of
[4:30:56] people in the public really realized and the real thing is for me of course I don't this is not what I
[4:31:02] rely to live on by any means. But there are people that want to run for counsel and because
[4:31:08] the compensation is not anything they don't and so if we only can do this every two years at a
[4:31:14] 5% level that's really only 2.5% a year. It's not you know CPI or whatever the increase that
[4:31:21] executives get and it's also not an increase of a six digit salary it's an increase of a
[4:31:26] So it's pretty like you're talking about a very small amount and I think, you know, there has been an effort and I hope one day the state will, you know, a men state law for the general law to, of cities to allow a larger compensation.
[4:31:41] I think that that gets more people involved in the notion that only wealthy people can help these seats, hopefully goes away through time and that's why I think and support a higher salary for compensation.
[4:31:54] I'm not saying we should make a huge amount of money.
[4:31:56] I'm the same, we should be able to be reasonably compensated for our time.
[4:31:59] So that's my opinion, is that we would go to the max on this to give direction to
[4:32:03] this carpenter.
[4:32:04] But I will defer to Mr. Robbins.
[4:32:20] The point like reality is personally, I don't need
[4:32:23] the, you know, 1,500, whatever, that's not, that's not make or break for me.
[4:32:30] I think for most of us, that's not make or break, but the problem here is that if there's
[4:32:36] not compensation or reasonable compensation for the time spent on city council, the only
[4:32:42] people who will ever show up to run for city council are people with the means and assets
[4:32:53] to be able to spend between 20 and 30 hours a week for free on this activity. That will
[4:33:00] leave you with people who are independently wealthy or people who have a vested financial
[4:33:06] interest in the outcomes of decisions made on City Council, neither of which is healthy for
[4:33:12] a democracy.
[4:33:15] I have found in the last four years that on my lightest of weeks, I spend
[4:33:21] about 20 hours a week on City Council. That's half time. And at the proposed even the top 5 percent
[4:33:30] increase here. That equates to 1750 an hour, which is below California minimum wage by several
[4:33:40] bucks an hour. So this is a sub, and on most weeks, typically I'm working a lot closer
[4:33:47] to 30 hours, especially on weeks like this week, which has city council meeting, perhaps
[4:33:53] city council meeting, the transit district meeting tomorrow, constituent meetings later this
[4:33:57] week, you know, subcommittee meetings coming right up for the, for the, sorry, and review
[4:34:04] of proposals for the, for the grants. There is so much behind the scenes work, which is not visible
[4:34:12] because, you know, we're only here in the public eye for part of it. At 30 hours a week, that's
[4:34:19] $13 and 30 cents an hour, which is very sub minimum wage. It's not that I need the money,
[4:34:25] It's that I think it's wrong to say that if you want to serve here, you have to be someone who doesn't need an income.
[4:34:34] And that's very limiting.
[4:34:35] This is not a novel issue.
[4:34:37] This has been pointed out in the last election.
[4:34:40] It has been pointed out during this campaign as well that this is a challenge for a number of the candidates who have said that one of the challenges they've had is
[4:34:49] Some of the challenges they have is they have to give up time and that has to be compensated with something because the rent doesn't care
[4:34:57] So I agree that it should be something that
[4:35:00] You can do for civic responsibility, like any other volunteer opportunity, but it's a challenge
[4:35:08] because this is something that you commit to. You can't really take this on, like, say, search
[4:35:14] and rescue, and if you can't swing the time for search and rescue, it's easy enough to drop
[4:35:17] out or volunteer less. This is a four-year commitment, and if you're going to do it well, you have
[4:35:25] to do it for 20 to 30 hours a week.
[4:35:28] And there's no meaningful way around that.
[4:35:30] And that means you can't work those hours.
[4:35:33] And so I think there's an equity thing here as well.
[4:35:37] And there's no way for me to just say, OK, pay everyone,
[4:35:40] and make it means tested.
[4:35:42] That's not an option before us.
[4:35:43] Thank you.
[4:35:45] Miss, Miss, I don't, yeah, I've got Miss Morgan.
[4:35:49] All right, sorry, well, I'll come do you not to
[4:35:54] go.
[4:35:54] Miss Morgan?
[4:35:56] Yes, I did.
[4:35:57] And I think I had put my hand up for questions, so in healthcare, sometimes there's a market
[4:36:04] adjustment, sometimes if you're really good employee, you get a performance adjustment.
[4:36:11] I hear all the comments by City Council and I'm actually going to abstain from voting on
[4:36:18] this.
[4:36:19] Mr. Jenkins.
[4:36:22] First of all, I am in a new attempt, that is I'm retired.
[4:36:27] I have CalPERS pension, and I have health under Social Security, because even though I'm
[4:36:32] very young, I have Social Security, and I also have, so I have that.
[4:36:39] The compensation is not what should drive people into this office at service, and I like to
[4:36:46] think that each month I at least may be earned some of my retirement check. But I also take
[4:36:54] into account what was pointed out by other members that for people, other people who are
[4:37:03] not a new intents, and that they might be a sacrifice to run for public office because it
[4:37:11] it costs them something to do so.
[4:37:13] And we want to encourage people to run for public office.
[4:37:21] And if I, and if, so I think this ordinance really
[4:37:25] applies to peak, it's an opportunity for other people
[4:37:30] who might want to run for public office.
[4:37:34] But out of difference, it actually
[4:37:36] something that Ms. Horgan said is I, too, I'm going to abstain.
[4:37:41] Okay. Great. Mr. Roberts, did any comments?
[4:37:46] Well, I mean, for myself, I mean, the additional raises isn't really going to change my life,
[4:37:51] any. But on the other hand, I'm really enjoying this public service and my time in
[4:38:06] involved, but I know I cannot afford to do that, so I mean it is something where I mean
[4:38:13] there should be some sort of compensation and you know, it really is a small increase.
[4:38:21] So we're just looking for direction, I think, I mean for me, the 5% increase is okay, I think
[4:38:27] I hear that from Mr. Robbins, Mr. Roberts, is that okay with you? So we got the three for
[4:38:31] direction on 5% in your mouth.
[4:38:33] The new mouth, we $1,057.
[4:38:35] $7.42.
[4:38:36] And for the record, it shows that the two of you have basically
[4:38:39] abstained on the direction.
[4:38:41] With that, we're not.
[4:38:42] This is literally the lowest, the lowest legal paying job
[4:38:46] in this city at 1750 an hour.
[4:38:50] So cannot pay anyone by law.
[4:38:52] And that's for you, because only you're 20 hours.
[4:38:55] And that's what you do.
[4:38:56] And that's doing the minimum.
[4:38:58] All right, so we're going to move on to our agenda planning
[4:39:00] calendar. This is item 15. This is our agenda planning calendar. Mr. Robarud.
[4:39:07] Thank you Mayor Bass. I just really wanted to point out that we do have the special meeting scheduled for October 13th.
[4:39:14] Regular session will begin at 11 o'clock and the focus will be the discussion over the use and sale of glyphosate within the city limits that the council requested to come back.
[4:39:27] Okay. Great. All right. With that, we can do adding to a gentleman at the Councilman report.
[4:39:34] So updates and announcements.
[4:39:37] Miss Maulankov. Any announcements from the city attorney?
[4:39:44] Then the glyphosate issue, Sergio asked me to let you all know that he's been negotiating
[4:39:50] a settlement regarding the Tahoe Keys Marina and the Sierra Club. And he thinks their close
[4:39:56] and should be coming back to you with a final resolution soon.
[4:39:59] Great.
[4:40:00] Thank you, and Mrs. Robert.
[4:40:05] Thank you just a couple of the dates that the council would be interested that we did receive confirmation
[4:40:11] from El Dorado County that they are moving the senior nutrition service to the City's Recreation
[4:40:16] Center, their first meal in that new location, will be on October 13th.
[4:40:24] Also, wanted to thank the community members that came out for the Tahoe Valley Green Belt project
[4:40:29] ribbon cutting on September 25th. It was great to celebrate that project. If you haven't been in that
[4:40:35] area to check it out, I highly encourage you to do it totally transformational changing that area to
[4:40:44] a bike friendly family, friendly stormwater friendly area. So we're pretty proud of that project.
[4:40:51] Also wanted to just report out that our public works department has completed all of the road rehabilitation
[4:40:57] projects that were scheduled for the summer that includes the new paving in the
[4:41:03] Altojo neighborhood and on Johnson Boulevard Cape Seal treatment on Pioneer
[4:41:09] Trail and Altojo Boulevard and the Mastic Crack Treatment on Eloise. We do
[4:41:16] expect that the Pioneer Trail sidewalks road rebuild and lighting project
[4:41:23] there between skewer and enlarge to be wrapping up here soon, and we look forward to celebrating
[4:41:28] that completion as well as a good pedestrian improvement for our community.
[4:41:33] Great.
[4:41:34] That's all I have.
[4:41:35] Thank you so much, Ms. Robert, Mrs. Carbender.
[4:41:37] Yeah, just a really quick one and two announced again that we are soliciting for all of our
[4:41:43] boards and commissions, and I will hit the paper this Friday.
[4:41:46] I did want to urge Council to seek candidates to apply.
[4:41:54] So if you know of anybody that you think might be a good fit, please encourage them to apply and submit their application to the Assistant City Clerk.
[4:42:02] If we have Instagram content that we will share, that would make it very easy to repost.
[4:42:09] Also, Facebook content can be re-shared.
[4:42:11] Yeah. We had a meeting with our public information officer where we came up with some new strategies to try to reach some more people.
[4:42:20] Definitely going to do that. And I would be happy to have sure you share those posts with you if you don't already follow the city of South Lake Tahoe.
[4:42:30] I do follow the city. So if those show up there, hopefully I'll see them and can read.
[4:42:34] Okay.
[4:42:35] Those are probably come out in the next couple of weeks.
[4:42:37] So we just had some other top priorities first.
[4:42:40] Great.
[4:42:41] All right.
[4:42:41] Thank you, Mr. Carpenter.
[4:42:43] We are going to move on to council member reports and comments.
[4:42:46] And this is going to be Mr. Jenkins.
[4:42:49] Thank you, Mr. Mayor and council.
[4:42:51] And also, thank you for the opportunity to attend
[4:42:53] the Cal Cities event.
[4:42:54] Nanahime last seems like a week, maybe it's two weeks.
[4:42:58] I go, I have written some things up on that event.
[4:43:03] There was, I thought the networking was excellent.
[4:43:05] I was very happy to be home because I had a time-convention centers that completely different
[4:43:11] venue than this is, but I was very happy to be here.
[4:43:15] What I thought significant about it was a site from the context which I've written about
[4:43:20] and I'll write more is the small and rural cities organizing to advocacy for small and
[4:43:27] rural cities, 65% of the Cal cities are smaller or rural cities, and there's a whole
[4:43:33] organization within the league to get the league to advocate and get the state to recognize
[4:43:39] that our are of issues are very different than larger binaries.
[4:43:45] The second is that I want to say that I did attend the fire event.
[4:43:51] The fire event.
[4:43:52] What would you call it?
[4:43:55] Firefest.
[4:43:55] Firefest.
[4:43:56] That was the Caribbean.
[4:43:58] You have the other.
[4:44:00] I was an eye.
[4:44:00] And it was actually a job the fire department did, it was good to see people show up for that.
[4:44:08] And I also have heard excellent comments about a parks and recreation of our new facility.
[4:44:15] And I've also heard a very positive comments about the visible work that's been done
[4:44:21] by the Public Works Department and our roads.
[4:44:23] So I want to thank them when you come time for matters for the future agenda.
[4:44:28] I have a couple.
[4:44:29] So that's now.
[4:44:30] That's now.
[4:44:31] That's now.
[4:44:32] Yes.
[4:44:32] Okay.
[4:44:33] I have two items.
[4:44:34] One is that the City Council set for our next meeting, and our next meeting, because of
[4:44:40] the timing, that we have a resolution opposing measure S, which is Elirado County,
[4:44:48] that that item be on the agenda.
[4:44:50] It affects every taxpayer or the City of South Lake Tahoe.
[4:44:54] The other item came up tonight.
[4:44:55] Let's see real quick.
[4:44:56] I think we just want to clarify that a little bit.
[4:45:03] All the special meeting yesterday. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, for the clarification.
[4:45:07] I'm sorry, Council. But we would not have the opportunity to put that together for you for October 13.
[4:45:13] I can, I can depended more. I already have it together.
[4:45:17] Mr. Oberwood, so the 13th is too late because we got an election.
[4:45:22] It's coming up. Well, yeah, we're already putting out the agenda.
[4:45:30] I've done this before.
[4:45:31] Long as it take to add, what is the limiting issue that we can't put this on the 13th?
[4:45:37] Could you explain that?
[4:45:39] We intended to publish the agenda packet on Wednesday tomorrow so that the public would
[4:45:45] have time to take a look at all of the glyphosate materials.
[4:45:48] It is a special meeting so we aren't required to publish until Friday, I believe, but adding
[4:45:55] another item would delay till Friday, and we would need to put other work aside and take care of
[4:46:03] this for you.
[4:46:03] That's what you wish.
[4:46:05] Well, let me please.
[4:46:07] There's a lot of information that's already available about measure S. It's already, in fact,
[4:46:14] some of us have written about it.
[4:46:16] And we're not immune from professional staff experience and doing these things, and I would
[4:46:23] I mean, more than happy to share that with you tomorrow,
[4:46:27] I could do it early.
[4:46:28] It's a lot of it's already written.
[4:46:30] The question really on the council is,
[4:46:32] is the council interested in opposing a measure
[4:46:35] that unfairly taxes the people of this city
[4:46:37] for something that has to do with Marshall Hospital,
[4:46:41] has nothing to do with Barton or any of us.
[4:46:43] And so that's really the issue.
[4:46:45] And I think timing is important
[4:46:46] because November election is coming up.
[4:46:48] The city council can choose not to do it,
[4:46:51] but I think this is a second issue.
[4:46:52] So I think I looked at Mr. Roberts on whether or not you want to give direction that somewhat,
[4:46:57] you know, puts us in a, puts our staff in a time crunch, but it would be on the Friday
[4:47:01] instead of Wednesday of publishing the agenda.
[4:47:04] Since you're the second, I would ask you, both are who's given the direction it's coming
[4:47:09] from.
[4:47:10] I'm going to talk to you right now.
[4:47:14] You need two days to put together a measure or ask discussion agenda item?
[4:47:18] Yes, we can do that.
[4:47:19] It will come from the staff, however we do if you have materials that you'd like to send that would help put that together would be grateful.
[4:47:29] I did want to note that your Council protocols do state that items that are requested by Council would be brought back two meetings later.
[4:47:40] If you, it's your protocols, so you can certainly take that under consideration.
[4:47:45] And I would ask that the protocols be suspended in this case, but you know, we can get it
[4:47:52] back by Friday.
[4:47:53] So, this is direction is okay.
[4:47:56] Yes, other work will be set aside and this will be prioritized.
[4:47:59] Oh, let's thank you Mr. O'Ready.
[4:48:02] Mr. Jenkins, did you have one of those?
[4:48:03] Yes.
[4:48:04] The other thing is there were issues that were raised at the seedlings meeting that had to
[4:48:09] do with safety issues, pedestrian and road safety issues in the city of South Victoria.
[4:48:14] And I would like at the earliest time possible report back from staff that discusses those issues whether there are safety concerns and how we are going to address them in the near term.
[4:48:25] The reason I think there is an urgency is because all it takes is one incident that we should avoid.
[4:48:37] And rather than this issue that was raised, just go up and smoke somewhere that we actually
[4:48:44] bring something back and address those specific issues that were raised by members of the
[4:48:49] public regarding safety issues at intersections in the record will show what those were
[4:48:56] during public comment.
[4:49:00] Mr. Jenkins, are you referring to the road safety issues along the Eloise bike route?
[4:49:08] Okay, thank you. We do have that already on the APC to come to Council in December.
[4:49:14] Okay. All right, within that hand, Mr. Robinson. Unless there was nothing.
[4:49:19] Okay, thank you, Mr. Jenkins.
[4:49:20] On your, you mentioned the calcities, what was the outcome of the vote for zoning?
[4:49:27] And that was what we talked about prior to heading to there, I'm just curious how that came out.
[4:49:32] The people there voted to have a compromise resolution that would be a committee of the league that would be meeting with league staff and with legislators rather than going to a constitutional amendment that they would be meeting to try and find if there's a compromise with them rather than go through the initiative process.
[4:49:54] So that was the outcome.
[4:49:56] There was passed in almost unanimously.
[4:49:58] Okay, that's, I was just curious.
[4:50:02] Okay, I've got six items for APN on this, I'm good.
[4:50:09] I've got TRP, TTT meeting is tomorrow, so I don't have a report on the future, just yet.
[4:50:15] Okay, great. Thank you, Mr. Robbins. Mr. Morgan.
[4:50:19] First, I'd just like to mention its flu season, wash your hands, everybody. Also, the public communications about trash,
[4:50:29] I was going to get a report back from staff about possibly whether we have bear proof containers required for commercial properties.
[4:50:39] Is that something that you have?
[4:50:42] I second it.
[4:50:42] Mr. Robertson, did you have an opportunity to take a look at that?
[4:50:48] I did.
[4:50:52] Hold please.
[4:50:54] Well it doesn't.
[4:50:56] So there's three components in the trash in the city code.
[4:50:59] It's 4.50, 4.150, and then VHR code at 3.50.
[4:51:06] So on the commercial trash, it says it has to be equipped
[4:51:10] with a sufficient closure system as a discourage animals
[4:51:13] and insects.
[4:51:16] So while it's probably not endorsed or approved by the IGRC,
[4:51:24] in my close, it's technically compliant.
[4:51:28] But if you want to, if you want to label, we can talk about, you know, a different label for that and modify that code.
[4:51:34] I think I'd like to see a trash ordinance that more specifically requires bear proof containers and commercial properties.
[4:51:40] Second.
[4:51:41] God, I got you.
[4:51:43] I have, I have seconded you.
[4:51:45] So I looked into what, I looked into what bear proof containers cost on commercial properties and it's between 2500 and 5000 dollars per container.
[4:51:53] Yeah. I have a, well, okay, you've got your second and Mr. Robert. Excuse me, Mr. Robert.
[4:51:59] So many hours tonight.
[4:52:01] We can't have trash out for bears.
[4:52:04] Yeah, I just, I had a couple. See if there's a council.
[4:52:07] I know it's interesting.
[4:52:09] I know we have an agenda item coming addressing TID to some level reviewing their performance.
[4:52:17] Can we add to that that we request the city request and audit and a third party audit?
[4:52:25] Second.
[4:52:28] Well, yeah.
[4:52:29] It was the original second time that I agree with that very much.
[4:52:33] Can I get clarification?
[4:52:36] When we bring back the annual report for the TID, TID is required to report annually to the city council.
[4:52:44] Coming up in a few weeks, it to be the report presented and then direction by council at that time to conduct an audit.
[4:52:55] As an option for council. Yeah, either way, but you know, a third party audit that also reviews, you know, others pending with their vendors.
[4:53:05] I would only add that it should be an audit, maybe not just of the TID, because I think
[4:53:12] most of them and it just goes to the LTVA and so they may not be much to see there.
[4:53:17] It's where the money actually getting spent and like expended is at the LTVA, so maybe
[4:53:22] that's where the audit comes from and they are contracted to the TID.
[4:53:26] So what I was going to ask for was an audit of the TID, so we've got a second on that.
[4:53:30] And then if we want to come back with LTVA, that's a separate thing.
[4:53:33] I will say the LTVA is audited every year, so there is an audit to review.
[4:53:38] That is a full public audit, but anyways, that's just the way on the one.
[4:53:41] I just want to clarify that this would be added to the ABC.
[4:53:45] The request in the second is not direction to conduct that audit.
[4:53:49] We would bring that back to council for both.
[4:53:51] I mean, Mr. Mayor of the...
[4:53:53] I've always heard of all good committee director of finance.
[4:53:56] When we present annual JD reports to City Council, it usually includes the audit.
[4:54:01] That's one of the requirements.
[4:54:03] So there is a report that includes the budget.
[4:54:07] And separately, it includes the audited financial statements performed by an independent auditor.
[4:54:14] Mr. Mayor, we want a third party audit, not to internal audit like the LTVA.
[4:54:17] No, it's not an internal audit, it's an independent audit by CPA firm that they hired.
[4:54:24] Mr. Mayor.
[4:54:24] I think, as I understood what the Mayor of Pro Tem was saying, is that we would like to know
[4:54:32] where the money that is being collected in the city limits by the businesses, where that money is being spent.
[4:54:41] And so that that is clear where that money is being spent currently.
[4:54:46] And I think that's, that's the request that's not that it's being spent improper.
[4:54:49] Not a suggestion, just where is it being spent?
[4:54:51] We need something more thorough than just a company report.
[4:54:55] Yeah.
[4:54:56] Great.
[4:54:57] Anything else?
[4:54:58] Yeah.
[4:54:59] Awesome.
[4:55:00] On the grass removal, throughout town, I know Mr. O'erward, you mentioned that. It's a topic already within the department.
[4:55:10] But I think it's something that needs to come to council. We need to be involved in what the next move is and reviewing.
[4:55:19] I don't want to point fingers at anybody or blame anybody, but it's been handled. It's not very well as thus far.
[4:55:26] I think we need to make sure, you know, the next move on. It is done properly.
[4:55:32] The grass move removal, the turf removal.
[4:55:37] The state law.
[4:55:39] That's what you're kind of saying that you want to like.
[4:55:41] Well, what we're replacing, that's what being said.
[4:55:44] The question is, the question that I understand.
[4:55:47] Hold on, let's just, if you don't want to.
[4:55:49] He's got, he's got an ask for a second.
[4:55:51] Oh, okay.
[4:55:52] You have the second.
[4:55:52] You have the second.
[4:55:54] Okay.
[4:55:54] So Mr. Jenkins second.
[4:55:56] So it's about, he's basically saying he wants to review the design.
[4:56:00] It's by state law that we must remove any grass and that's a ornamental grass throughout the city unless we're using non-potable water.
[4:56:07] So that's why this is happening. What Mr. Roberts is asked for a second is that the city council would review that design.
[4:56:12] You got the second from Mr. Jenkins.
[4:56:14] That's more clear.
[4:56:15] I just need to contact.
[4:56:17] I think I thought I understood the issue to be that we are being told that state law has to be amended.
[4:56:25] in order to use that it requires us to remove that there's no options other than a
[4:56:32] many state law. And I do not believe that that's the case. And I've asked the
[4:56:37] Ben Letton with the Law and Regional Water Quality if Lake Water. So I thought it
[4:56:43] was included is that there would be a conversation at least about it because when
[4:56:47] that the 2023, I know we're getting a little deep, but let me just say, the 2023 law,
[4:56:53] Nobody said, are there any exceptions or because we're up here and there's 59 billion gallons
[4:56:57] of water, could you use lake water, which is not recycled water, it is lake water.
[4:57:03] And that question is now out and being asked, and I thought that maybe that was part of
[4:57:08] what you wanted an answer to.
[4:57:09] Well, I just, I mean, again, Ms. Wilberwood, I know you mentioned that your department is already
[4:57:13] on it and I'm talking about it, but I just think it's a big issue in the city right now,
[4:57:18] and I think the council should be involved.
[4:57:21] Yes, we can bring a report to Council on what's been done and what the plan is to move forward and receive your input.
[4:57:27] Great.
[4:57:28] Thank you.
[4:57:30] All right.
[4:57:32] I don't have too many updates.
[4:57:33] I've got LTVA coming up on Thursday.
[4:57:37] And that should be a good meeting for anybody that does want to know the budget.
[4:57:42] We presented every meeting, so I would highly encourage coming to check that out.
[4:57:47] And with that, we're adjourned.