Transcript
AI TRANSCRIPT
This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.
[0:00]
It is now two minutes past our start time, so test. We're ready. Welcome to the September 22, 2021,
[0:11]
special call meeting of the Tennessee Public Charter School Commission. We're holding this special
[0:16]
call meeting to take up issues that are important to the commission. I'd like to recognize Ashley
[0:25]
To be Thomas, to provide us with the statement of necessity, Ashlyn.
[0:30]
Thank you, Chairman.
[0:32]
This commission meeting is being conducted pursuant to TCAA 8-44-108, allowing for a governing
[0:39]
body to allow participation by electronic means of communication, where a physical form
[0:43]
is not possible.
[0:45]
As commission business requires a decision prior to the regularly scheduled October meeting,
[0:50]
the necessity of this special call meeting is for the commission's deliberation and action
[0:54]
on item set forth in the September 22, 2021 agenda.
[0:59]
This meeting is being recorded
[1:00]
and will be available after its conclusion,
[1:02]
via link on the commission's website.
[1:05]
A calling number was provided on the commission's website
[1:07]
for the public to participate.
[1:09]
A statement of necessity shall be filed
[1:11]
with the Secretary of State,
[1:13]
pursuant to TCAA 8-44-108
[1:16]
and just as a friendly reminder,
[1:17]
because I know it's been a minute
[1:19]
if you could just introduce yourself for speaking.
[1:21]
Thank you.
[1:23]
Thank you, Ashley. This is Tom Griske, a member of all votes of the commission are conducted via taking a roll call.
[1:32]
Please identify yourself prior to speaking, making a motion or voting.
[1:39]
So I believe we're now ready to take a roll call and proceed with our business today. Chase, I ask you to take the roll, please.
[1:46]
Mr.
[1:49]
Hanson.
[1:50]
I think it's President Commissioner Levine.
[1:56]
Present here.
[1:58]
Is President Commissioner Patterson?
[2:00]
Here.
[2:01]
Is President Commissioner Richards?
[2:04]
Here.
[2:05]
Is President Commissioner Sissnick?
[2:07]
Here.
[2:08]
Is President Commissioner Smith?
[2:11]
Commissioner Tucker?
[2:14]
Commissioner Woodson?
[2:17]
And Chairman Gris.
[2:18]
here is President. Mr. Chairman, you have a corner.
[2:23]
Thank you. This is Tom Grissom again.
[2:31]
So we're going to adopt our agenda for
[2:35]
day. We're going to be handling some issues that are instructional for us as
[2:40]
commissioners prior to October meeting. The staff is also going to give us some
[2:46]
updates on key work streams and and part of this today's session is some
[2:53]
scarlet charter, charter school appeals training for us as commissioners. Does
[3:00]
anyone have any comments regarding the agenda before we vote to approve?
[3:06]
Seeing none, do I have a motion to approve the agenda for today? So move this
[3:13]
Thank you. Do I have a second?
[3:16]
Levine, second.
[3:17]
Thank you. Chase, would you call a row, please?
[3:21]
Mr. Hansen.
[3:23]
Aye.
[3:24]
votes aye.
[3:25]
Commissioner Levine.
[3:26]
Aye.
[3:28]
votes aye.
[3:28]
Commissioner Patterson.
[3:30]
Aye.
[3:31]
votes aye.
[3:32]
Commissioner Richards.
[3:33]
Aye.
[3:34]
votes aye.
[3:35]
Commissioner Sissnett.
[3:36]
Aye.
[3:38]
votes aye.
[3:38]
Aye, Commissioner Smith, Commissioner Tucker,
[3:43]
Mr. Woodson and Chairman Grissin.
[3:46]
Aye.
[3:48]
But the agenda is approved.
[3:50]
Thank you, Ms. Tom.
[3:51]
Grissin, minutes of the meeting held on July 13, 2021
[3:56]
have been provided.
[3:57]
Does anyone have any edits to make regarding the prior minutes
[4:00]
before we proceed?
[4:03]
Motion to approve, thank you.
[4:05]
Thank you to have a second.
[4:06]
Second.
[4:11]
Second. Levine. Thank you. Is it any further discussion? Seeing none, Chase, would you call the role, please?
[4:21]
Commissioner Hanson.
[4:23]
Bowtie.
[4:24]
Bowtie.
[4:25]
Commissioner Levine.
[4:27]
Aye.
[4:28]
Bowtie.
[4:28]
Commissioner Patterson.
[4:30]
Aye.
[4:32]
Bowtie.
[4:33]
Commissioner Richards.
[4:34]
Aye.
[4:34]
I.
[4:39]
Commissioner Smith.
[4:41]
Commissioner Tucker.
[4:44]
Commissioner Woodson and chairman.
[4:46]
I.
[4:47]
Mr chairman the minutes from July 13th are approved.
[4:51]
Thank you.
[4:52]
Tom Griscombe.
[4:53]
In accordance with commission policy one dot two zero zero.
[4:59]
We reserve time for up to 30 minutes.
[5:02]
Public comment.
[5:03]
for public comment.
[5:05]
Chase, can you please introduce any individuals
[5:07]
who registered for public comment?
[5:09]
And please share the protocols that we use for comments.
[5:16]
Thank you, Chairman.
[5:17]
Chase, single here.
[5:19]
So we have one individual signed up
[5:20]
to make a public comment.
[5:22]
That's Mr. Bob Nardo.
[5:23]
And pursuant to commission policy 1.200.
[5:27]
Each individual will be given three minutes
[5:29]
to provide that public comment.
[5:35]
Thank you so much for having me. I got to meet most of you a couple of months ago. I'm Bob
[5:39]
Narada. I'm the executive director of Libertas Charter School in Memphis. Tennessee is first
[5:43]
Montessori Charter School and School and Achievement School District. We're also the host
[5:49]
of a recently state board approved educator preparation program. We're now preparing teachers
[5:55]
at several schools around Tennessee Charter and District to teach them on a story education
[6:00]
and method. And I'm addressing you today as a forthcoming applicant under the new procedure
[6:06]
that you all of you adopting later today. I just wanted to share a couple things for us a
[6:10]
little bit of news about our school. We were delighted that despite all the challenges of the
[6:16]
pandemic and what a serious academic threat that is to kids in our state, our school really had a
[6:22]
lot of success last year. We were once again a level five school, the highest designation for academic
[6:27]
growth in the state. Our school is the highest performing school in the achievement school district
[6:32]
in every grade and every subject. We have surged over 25 percentile in state rankings
[6:40]
over all schools and most importantly to me at risk children in our school are doing particularly
[6:46]
well. African American students who are the vast majority of our kids are now in the top half of the
[6:51]
state and our special education students of which we have the largest population the AAC are in the
[6:57]
top 15% of the state. So we're incredibly thankful for the support of the Department
[7:02]
of Education and the governor for everything we've been able to do as an AAC school, and
[7:06]
we're excited to move forward in your process to continue this work. Really, Chairman,
[7:11]
the main thing I wanted to say today was gratitude. Over the last couple of months, your team,
[7:16]
Tess, Kelly, Melanie, Chase, Dragan and others have been incredibly engaging to us. They've
[7:23]
given us a lot of useful information.
[7:26]
They've been open to our perspective,
[7:27]
the materials they're presenting you today,
[7:29]
they've incorporated some of our feedback,
[7:31]
and that means a lot to us as school operators,
[7:32]
that the LEA is hearing our view.
[7:35]
But another thing I want to thank them for is
[7:37]
even when they were not willing to take our input,
[7:40]
they explained why, and they educated us
[7:42]
about other issues you're dealing with us
[7:44]
that helped us to figure out how to engage with you better.
[7:48]
So I'm really grateful for the team
[7:49]
that you all have assembled,
[7:50]
and we're really looking forward to working with you.
[7:53]
I'll just mention two other things very briefly if I might.
[7:56]
There's some work, one of the really important things that's going to have to be figured out,
[8:00]
if some ASD schools will be joining your portfolio, is the issue around federal funding allocations.
[8:06]
I think your team has informed you that these dollars, which are a big part of what supports schools
[8:10]
that serve children in poverty, are allocated on a lag basis.
[8:15]
And with the growth of your district, this would be a challenge for schools like ours,
[8:19]
if we're not able to access some of those federal funds because we're only funded a year later,
[8:23]
rather than on the current year. I want to thank your team for what they're already doing,
[8:27]
strategically to address that issue in advance. We've also approached the state about it,
[8:31]
and we're hoping that there'll be some creative ways for them to ensure that schools don't have
[8:36]
destruction in their federal funding. Similarly, I've spoken with your staff. They've been very
[8:41]
receptive around this question of special education, and how the charter commission as an LEA
[8:47]
can be strategic about ensuring that the right amount of money follows the child.
[8:54]
And knowing that a school choice is not meaningful, if you have a disability,
[8:58]
and the school funding doesn't reflect what is needed to serve that disability.
[9:02]
So I want to thank your team again for being open to those conversations and being very strategic
[9:06]
for how that can be addressed moving forward, likewise with issues of the performance framework.
[9:11]
So all that to say, we're really excited about the opportunity in the coming months to move forward
[9:16]
with our application and I couldn't be more excited about working with the team that
[9:20]
you have put together so that we can continue to give meaningful opportunities and
[9:25]
full choices to kids in our community and others across the state. Thank you so much for
[9:29]
your time. Thank you Bob. This time, risk and chase, do we have any other people who have
[9:36]
signed up to provide a comment with the commission today? No, Chairman, we do not have any other
[9:44]
public comment. Thank you. This is Tom Grisson. Before we continue, I'd like to share a couple
[9:50]
things with commissioners. Number one, self-evaluation. We've got a few other men. Let me encourage you all
[9:58]
please to get a man. I think it's important for us as a commissioner, as a commission,
[10:03]
to be able to have for the record. Anybody who asks, do we do a self-evaluation? I think that's
[10:11]
important thing that any board ought to do, but we also are able if we're asked by our
[10:18]
legislative oversight committees whether we have done that, so I would hope you will
[10:23]
take time to fill out your self-evaluation and send it in and possibly test. We might
[10:31]
think about we still got some left of using a little bit of time at the retreat to get those
[10:37]
evaluation is completed. Second thing, we are in the process. It's hard to believe.
[10:46]
Tessna will be talking tomorrow to do a cycle of her evaluation. I appreciate the
[10:54]
commissioners who did provide input. I have put that together so that we will have a
[11:00]
document that gets forwarded after Tessna have a conversation tomorrow.
[11:05]
And the last thing I have is a reminder everybody, and let me thank Durwin again publicly for the work that you're doing as we put the strategic plan together.
[11:16]
You saw in the test evaluation was the work on a strategic plan.
[11:23]
As a commission, we decided that we should do a few other things like having executive director for one before we put a strategic plan together.
[11:34]
And to sort of get our hands around a little bit more and more understanding of exactly the focus we want to have as a commission
[11:41]
I think we have spent a lot of good time together. We've got us team a great team has been assembled by test.
[11:49]
I enjoy working with them and the input that I get and I know many of you all also receive from them.
[11:57]
But the strategic plan will be part of our December retreat.
[12:02]
We are sharing information if we go forward so that when we get to the meeting in December,
[12:09]
we should have a pretty good overview of what we're doing.
[12:13]
I know that Darwin is looking at everything that's working through here.
[12:18]
So let me just remind you all of that when you see pieces related to strategic plan,
[12:24]
please find a little bit of time to provide feedback so that our session in December is quite productive.
[12:31]
So those are the points that I wanted to make before we move with the rest of the agenda.
[12:39]
So we'll now have Ashley Thomas present a charter school agreement for our consideration.
[12:46]
This charter agreement is for Kip, Antioch, College Prep High School.
[12:51]
Ashley, would you walk us through this item, please?
[12:55]
Absolutely. Thank you, Chairman. This is Ashley Thomas.
[12:57]
As you stated, I do want to present a proposed charter agreement for Kip Antioch College Prep High School.
[13:03]
The waivers for the school were approved by the commission at our July meeting.
[13:08]
Throughout the negotiation process, I made sure that all statutory mandated requirements were met,
[13:13]
and were noted within the agreement material sections of this agreement,
[13:17]
which would require commission approval for modification.
[13:20]
They mirror those of the previously approved charter agreements.
[13:23]
as you all know, Kip Antioch, Middle and Elementary have already been approved by the Commission,
[13:28]
and so those material sections are noted they mirror the language of the previous agreements.
[13:35]
All exhibits accompanying this charter agreement have been provided to the Commission members,
[13:39]
and all the documentation is available on the website. The Executive Director and I completed
[13:44]
a due diligence review of any proposed language to ensure that an approval will be supported by
[13:49]
school and organizational records. We also engaged in multiple conversations with the operators.
[13:55]
With that, I'll answer any questions, but my recommendation is to have commission
[13:59]
approve this agreement, pursuant to TCA 49-13-110.
[14:05]
This is Tom Griskem. Do any commissioners have
[14:07]
questions or comments for Ashley?
[14:12]
Seeing none, Ashley, thank you for that review of the proposed
[14:15]
charter school agreement. Do I have a motion to approve the kick? Yep.
[14:22]
Any hot college prep high school charter agreement.
[14:30]
Hello, can I have a commissioner?
[14:32]
Nice to meet you, thank you.
[14:35]
Chase, did you get the motion and the second?
[14:40]
Yes, sir Chairman, I've got it.
[14:42]
Thank you.
[14:47]
Mr. McCullough me.
[14:48]
Yes, aye.
[14:49]
Yes, sir.
[14:50]
Boat's aye.
[14:51]
Commissioner Levine.
[14:52]
Aye.
[14:53]
Boat's aye.
[14:54]
Commissioner Patterson.
[14:55]
Aye.
[14:57]
Boat's aye.
[14:58]
Commissioner Richards.
[14:59]
Aye.
[15:00]
votes, aye, Mr. Assistant, aye, votes, aye, and Chairman Griske. Aye.
[15:07]
votes, aye. Mr. Chairman, the motion is approved. Thank you. This is Tom Griske. Our next item on the agenda consists of two LEA policies that require attention.
[15:19]
We'll be considering these items on first and final reading.
[15:24]
Ashley, can you discuss LEA policies 4206 and 4212 for the commission?
[15:32]
Absolutely.
[15:33]
Thank you, Chair Mendez.
[15:34]
This is Ashley Thomas.
[15:35]
I'm presenting, for first and final reading, two LEA policies, the first being an update
[15:40]
and the second will establish a new policy for the commission.
[15:43]
Of course, with many changing considerations surrounding the global pandemic, I wanted to
[15:47]
to make sure that the commission remains in a posture
[15:50]
to lead and serve the schools in our portfolio.
[15:53]
So the first LEA policy is 4206,
[15:55]
that contains some new language,
[15:57]
which indicates that the charter schools homebound policy
[16:01]
should permit students temporarily quarantine
[16:03]
due to a positive COVID-19 test
[16:06]
or possible exposure to COVID-19.
[16:08]
It allows them to participate in remote instruction
[16:11]
during the period of quarantine only.
[16:13]
and then secondly, I'm introducing LEA policy 42-12, which is regarding
[16:19]
virtual programs within charter schools. This requires authorized charter schools
[16:23]
to develop a policy regarding virtual education on a temporary basis for
[16:28]
academic remediation, home-bound students, and quarantine students. LEA policy 42-12
[16:34]
indicates the parameters of the charter schools' virtual education program
[16:38]
including attendance and removal from the program.
[16:42]
These policies are being presented to the commission during this meeting as our charter schools did need guidance on the subject as soon as possible.
[16:49]
Both policies were sent to members of the rules policy and governance committee for feedback ahead of this meeting.
[16:54]
And I'll pause here for any questions or address any edits that the commission may have.
[17:03]
Mr. Chair.
[17:05]
Yes, commissioner Levy.
[17:07]
I don't know if you want to, I don't know if this is time for question for both policies
[17:13]
or do you want to do one at a time?
[17:17]
I think we're going to be able to vote on them both together.
[17:20]
That's my understanding.
[17:21]
Is that correct, Ashley?
[17:23]
This is Ashley Thomas, yes, sir.
[17:25]
So Commissioner Levine, yes sir, please, please go ahead.
[17:28]
Okay.
[17:28]
You know, I don't know if this is the right place to raise this or not.
[17:31]
I remember reading the virtual instruction policy, and it may not be the right sandbox here, but
[17:41]
AP online, we have the state funds, the Nice Longer Foundation, to provide AP online programs
[17:50]
throughout the state, and primarily rural communities or schools that don't have enough students
[17:56]
to support a faculty member to do online AP courses.
[18:02]
And I just want to make sure that we're encouraging the use of online or virtual instruction
[18:08]
for AP.
[18:11]
And I don't know if this is, when I read this, I think these policies relate to temporary
[18:17]
virtual instruction, but is there anything precluding or preventing our charter schools from being
[18:25]
being able to utilize virtual courses for AP credits.
[18:33]
Commissioner Levine's question.
[18:34]
Are you able to answer Commissioner Levine's question?
[18:40]
I can offer an answer. I'm not sure if it's the answer that Commissioner Levine was looking for.
[18:45]
What I would say is there's nothing in the two policies that I'm proposing that prohibits
[18:49]
virtual instruction for AP courses.
[18:52]
Um, I have not seen where that is prohibited as as an option for the charter schools. I know that, uh, of course we cannot have complete virtual charter schools, but I'm happy to look into that.
[19:04]
I don't know that these policies, particularly address that, but I'm happy to look into that.
[19:08]
I just sort of prompted me to ask the question about access for AP courses and I definitely
[19:21]
think even if there's no prohibition, I definitely think we ought to encourage our charter
[19:27]
school somehow to, if they can't provide a full spectrum of AP courses because of limitations
[19:34]
and size, or faculty, we should be encouraging the use of virtual instruction for AP credit just so they're not denied that opportunity because they're in charter school.
[19:44]
So anyway, so this may not be the right place to time to raise it, but we can we can have that conversation later.
[19:53]
Absolutely, and like I said, I'm happy to look into that. I will try to get you, you know, more definitive answers.
[19:57]
I think to your point, these particular policies address virtual instructions on a temporary basis and it sounds like what what you're referring to would be more on an ongoing basis for the charter schools.
[20:09]
So this time, risk and commissioner Patterson as the chair of this committee, is there anything you would like to add before I call for a motion to prove.
[20:20]
This is Terence Paterson. Thank you Mr. Chair. No, I don't have anything substantive to add, but I did just want to affirm that this policy is an alignment with all of the state laws and it does not. It's not in contravention or in conflict in any way. It is on a temporary basis.
[20:40]
Thank you commissioner.
[20:42]
Are there other questions from commissioners?
[20:45]
Seeing none do I have a motion to approve?
[20:48]
This is Commissioner Patterson, so moved.
[20:51]
No, a deference to the chair, I'll second it.
[20:54]
Thank you.
[20:56]
Is there any other discussion?
[20:59]
Seeing none, Chase, would you call the wrong, please?
[21:02]
This is Chase, single Commissioner Hanson.
[21:05]
Aye.
[21:06]
Boats, aye, Commissioner Levine.
[21:08]
Aye.
[21:09]
Boats, aye, Commissioner Patterson.
[21:11]
Aye.
[21:12]
Boats, aye, Commissioner Richards.
[21:14]
Aye.
[21:14]
Aye.
[21:15]
Opposed?
[21:16]
Aye.
[21:16]
Commissioner Assistant.
[21:17]
Aye.
[21:18]
Opposed?
[21:19]
Aye.
[21:21]
Opposed?
[21:22]
Aye.
[21:22]
Mr. Chairman, the policies are approved on final reading.
[21:25]
Thank you.
[21:26]
Mr. Tom Griscombe.
[21:28]
We're now moving on to consider the achievement school district authorization emergency rule.
[21:34]
Ashley, can you describe the emergency rule governing the charter commission's application process
[21:39]
for ASD operators before the commission takes a vote?
[21:43]
Absolutely. This is actually Thomas. Thank you chairman. I am presenting these emergency rules to the commission for both so that we're in the correct posture for receipt of any application for schools exiting the achievements full district.
[21:57]
The language of these rules mirror the rules that were presented and approved on first reading at our July meeting.
[22:03]
If approved, these rules will become effective upon filing and they remain so for 180 days or until approximately February of 2022.
[22:12]
These rules are running concurrently with the permanent version
[22:15]
for which a rule making hearing is scheduled for September 30th of this year.
[22:21]
It is my intention that these rules expire at or near the effective date of the permanent rules
[22:26]
for the record just to reiterate the language of these rules,
[22:30]
set forth the standards for our application process,
[22:32]
which includes an October 15 letter of intent date,
[22:36]
followed by November 15th application date. It includes information about the application fee and the review process for that application.
[22:45]
I'll pause here for any questions that the Commission may have, but my recommendation will be approval of these rules for emergency filing.
[22:55]
Don, don, risk of other commissioners with questions.
[22:59]
Mr. Chairman, this is Commissioner Richards.
[23:02]
Yes.
[23:02]
Yes, I don't have any question about the process outlined and it seems quite appropriate, but I am quite concerned at the lack of a standard that is apparent as to how many schools we might be asked to address.
[23:20]
And if we have adequate resources to follow through that process depending on that number and this may be kind of outside the scope of this rule.
[23:30]
But I would like to have some sense of where we are on that particular problem.
[23:35]
Mr. Richard, this time, Griscum, I think Tess will be addressing this because she and I've
[23:41]
had conversations for the last several weeks so if you're comfortable, can we go ahead
[23:46]
and act on this rule and then Tess, I know it's going to talk about the issue you raised.
[23:52]
I'm very comfortable, thank you.
[23:54]
Thank you.
[23:55]
Commissioner Patterson, once more, let me ask you as the chair of this committee.
[23:59]
Is there any comments you would like to make?
[24:00]
No, no, no, no further. This is Commissioner Patterson. No further comment. This is as our general council
[24:08]
point out similar in an alignment with what we presented on first rate. So they haven't been any modifications.
[24:15]
Thank you. Any other questions? Do I have a motion to approve?
[24:21]
Some move. This is Commissioner Patterson. Thank you. Do I have a second?
[24:23]
We'll be in second. Thank you. Any other discussion? Chase, would you call the wrong
[24:31]
please? This is Chase, and you'll Commissioner Hanson.
[24:35]
I. Boat's I. Commissioner Levine. I. Boat's I. Commissioner Patterson. I. Boat's I. Commissioner
[24:44]
Richards. I. Boat's I. Commissioner Sisson. I. Boat's I. Chairman Giscombe. I. Boat's I. Mr.
[24:54]
Chairman, the motion is approved. Thank you. This is Tom.
[24:57]
Risk of the next item on our agenda is the Charter School Amendment
[25:00]
Application in Roober. I'd like to recognize our Executive Director,
[25:05]
Tess Stovall, presented as item. Tess. Thank you, Chairman. Tess Stovall,
[25:11]
Executive Director. So this item is presented to the
[25:14]
Commission today on first and final reading because an
[25:17]
accordance with the Commission's emergency rules governing the
[25:22]
charter school agreement amendment process, it requires the application that is used by
[25:29]
all operators and authorizers in the state, a round charter school amendment to be approved
[25:36]
by the commission. So when this rule was first established by the State Board of Education,
[25:42]
the original application that was developed by the Tennessee Department of Education was approved
[25:47]
by the State Board since the rule making authority in this particular area of law has shifted
[25:54]
from the State Board of Education to the Charter Commission as of July 1st of this year.
[25:59]
I ask the Department to submit the application to the Commission for approval.
[26:05]
On a go-forward basis, we are going to be including the application as a part of our meeting timeline.
[26:13]
So the we are ensuring that any changes that the department makes on this application comes before the commission for approval in accordance with the rule.
[26:23]
And I'm happy to take any questions on this application.
[26:30]
It's Tom Griskem. Do commissioners have any questions for tests?
[26:37]
Seeing none, do I have a motion to approve?
[26:40]
Mr. Smith, the motion is approved.
[26:43]
Commissioner Ciccinet, some move.
[26:45]
Thank you.
[26:45]
Do you have a second?
[26:46]
Second, Commissioner Patterson.
[26:48]
Thank you.
[26:49]
Any other discussion?
[26:51]
Chase, would you call the wrong please?
[26:53]
Chase, single.
[26:55]
Commissioner Hanson.
[26:56]
Which aye.
[26:58]
Votes aye.
[26:58]
Commissioner Levine.
[27:00]
Aye.
[27:01]
Votes aye.
[27:02]
Commissioner Patterson.
[27:03]
Aye.
[27:04]
Votes aye.
[27:05]
Commissioner Richards.
[27:06]
Aye.
[27:07]
Votes aye.
[27:08]
Commissioner Ciccinet.
[27:10]
Aye.
[27:11]
both I and Chairman Griscoff, both I and Mr. Chairman, the motion is approved.
[27:19]
Thank you. This is Tom Griscoff. This next one is an item that we have talked about on
[27:24]
number of occasions and that is an interagency agreement between the Charter Commission and the
[27:31]
State Department of Education. So I'd like to call on Tess Stovall and our Director of Finance and
[27:39]
operations, who are going to present this information to the commission.
[27:44]
Yes?
[27:45]
Thank you, Chairman.
[27:46]
Test, Stovall.
[27:47]
I would like to ask Melanie Harrell, who's our Director of Finance and Operations, to
[27:51]
the high-level review of the Interagency Agreement, and then Melanie and I are happy to take
[27:57]
any questions that you all may have.
[27:59]
Melanie?
[28:01]
Thank you, Taz.
[28:02]
This is Melanie Harrell, Director of Finance and Operations.
[28:04]
So, as was mentioned, as part of the legislation that authorized the
[28:10]
potential transition process for certain ASD schools to the charter commission,
[28:16]
the TDOE allocated funds from the governor's emergency education relief fund or gear funding to support our work on this transition.
[28:26]
So, when HB 74 was being discussed in the legislature, this funding was outlined in the presentation of the bill as intended to
[28:33]
to offset our need for funding across FY 2223 and 24.
[28:41]
So we've budgeted or included in this interagency agreement
[28:45]
about $300,000 for FY 22.
[28:48]
Since this revenue is meant to essentially replace
[28:52]
our need for to access that amount of state funding,
[28:56]
we do not anticipate that this will change
[28:58]
or currently approve budget by the commission.
[29:00]
It is just intended to be kind of an offset
[29:03]
of our need for state funds. So expenditures that we allocate to gear funding will be aligned
[29:09]
to each fiscal year's approved budget, and we've worked with TDOE staff closely
[29:14]
to finalize this interagency agreement and the allocation of these funds. So we've outlined
[29:21]
pretty broad categories that you'll see in the IAA, things like salaries and benefits for staff
[29:27]
members working on the transition. I think this also supports, as we know, our need for
[29:32]
additional capacity, both to prepare for new schools potentially coming into our portfolio,
[29:39]
but also to support them once they're here in those first critical couple of years. We've also
[29:44]
budgeted some funding for transition application reviewers and potentially some additional supports
[29:50]
around the transition process, we've also allocated funds to certain systems and
[29:58]
non-professional service contracts that could
[30:00]
These support ASD schools, things like software, student information system transfers. Those can be a little bit leading. And we want to make sure that we have the supports necessary to facilitate those processes. And then some costs associated with, we anticipate additional travel, additional meetings, more school site visits, and things of that nature. So with this, the flexibility with this agreement is pretty broad. And we do recommend this inter agency agreement for
[30:29]
approval, and we are happy to answer any questions anybody may have about this.
[30:35]
So this is Tom Griskem. Do commissioners have any questions for Melanie or Tess?
[30:44]
Seeing none,
[30:45]
do I have a motion to approve? Moving motion. Thank you, second.
[30:56]
Richard, second. Thank you,
[30:59]
commissioners. Any other discussion? Chase, would you call the role, please?
[31:04]
Please.
[31:05]
Jason Engel here.
[31:06]
Commissioner Hanson.
[31:08]
Aye.
[31:09]
Vote aye.
[31:10]
Commissioner Levine.
[31:12]
Aye.
[31:13]
Vote aye.
[31:13]
Commissioner Patterson.
[31:15]
Aye.
[31:16]
Vote aye.
[31:17]
Commissioner Richards.
[31:18]
Aye.
[31:19]
Vote aye.
[31:20]
Vote aye.
[31:20]
Commissioner Susanna.
[31:22]
Aye.
[31:23]
Vote aye.
[31:24]
Chairman Griscombe.
[31:25]
Aye.
[31:26]
Vote aye.
[31:27]
Mr. Chairman, the motion is approved.
[31:28]
Thank you.
[31:29]
Again, let me thank you, Melanie, for I know you're continued working very much.
[31:32]
Thank you.
[31:33]
So, Commissioner Richards, I think our next item is going to provide a lot more information
[31:38]
to the question you asked a few minutes ago.
[31:42]
So I want to call on Tess, who's going to give us an update on the implementation of
[31:50]
public chapter 490, which governs the AESD operator exit process.
[31:57]
Tess, it is all yours.
[31:59]
Thank you.
[31:59]
Thank
[32:02]
you.
[32:03]
Test still, Val.
[32:04]
I am sharing a short PowerPoint presentation with you all that's going to guide this conversation.
[32:09]
So with this update today, I want to give you a high level update about the progress that
[32:15]
the commission has made as a relate to preparing for the implementation of public chapter 490.
[32:22]
At the October meeting in a few short weeks, we will have a committee of the whole on Monday
[32:27]
before any of our commission meetings or committee meetings begin. And Dr.
[32:33]
Eve Carney and myself will have a fuller update for you on ASD
[32:38]
implementation. So you will be able to hear directly from the department on
[32:42]
their piece of this implementation process. But since we were here today, I wanted
[32:47]
to take this opportunity to update you on a few key pieces.
[32:53]
So as a refresher, public
[32:55]
chapter 490 that was passed by the General Assembly this past spring allows for high performing
[33:03]
ASD charter school operators to exit the ASD via two pathways. That first pathway is by
[33:11]
Commissioner Authority, so the Commissioner is able to designate a school as high performing and
[33:17]
who allow that school to apply to the charter commission. The second is by a school earning priority
[33:23]
exit status. As of today, I can share with you that there are three current ASD charter schools that
[33:29]
have earned priority exit status. Those schools are Libertas, as you heard earlier, cornerstone prep,
[33:37]
Denver, and Leicester prep. So these three schools are in known quantity in terms of schools that
[33:44]
either have to apply to the charter commission this fall or apply to their district for authorization.
[33:51]
I know that the Commissioner and the Achievement School District are currently working on the rubric for the Commissioner Authority pathway.
[34:03]
And I expect that at the October meeting that Dr. Eve Carney will be able to go into much further detail about that specific pathway.
[34:16]
So since July the staff has been hard at work in preparing for as much as possible the work ahead.
[34:26]
First and foremost, it was the priority for us was to establish an application in a rubric that the commission would use to evaluate any applications that it would receive this fall.
[34:39]
So we developed that application in the rubric based on the department's current application
[34:46]
in rubric that's used for new search applicants.
[34:50]
We then adjusted those documents to fit the context.
[34:55]
We presented this application in rubric at our July meeting and received feedback from commissioners.
[35:01]
We also circulated those drafts with stakeholders, with operators within the ASD, and
[35:09]
other external individuals and we received feedback from three operators in the Achievement
[35:15]
School District, external stakeholders as well as the Tennessee Department of Education.
[35:21]
We revised the application and the rubric based on that feedback and that information the final
[35:27]
application was published on the commission's website on September the 1st. We also circulated
[35:34]
the final version of the application in rubric with all ASD operators.
[35:40]
Rolling out of that process, we wanted to conduct webinars and make it available to all
[35:48]
charter school operators within the ASD, both to solicit feedback on the application, but also
[35:54]
just to introduce the charter commission, the staff. There are some operators that we work with
[35:59]
currently based on our current portfolio. And there are other operators that we don't. And so we
[36:04]
conducted three webinars open to all ASD operators. We have representatives from eight operators who
[36:11]
participated in those webinars. And we reviewed application process and timeline basics about being
[36:19]
authorized by the commission and key things for them to and key differences for them to be aware of
[36:25]
should they want to apply and be authorized by the Charter Commission. And we accepted additional
[36:30]
feedback on the application in the rubric before it was finalized as a part of those webinars.
[36:38]
We've also been doing a lot of internal preparation for the possibility of accepting additional
[36:45]
schools within our portfolio. And I think it's really important that the commissioners understand that
[36:52]
we have two dynamics that we're trying to work within and kind of figure out what is our long-term plan.
[36:59]
First, that we have schools in the pipeline that have already been authorized via the New
[37:05]
Starter Field process. So, we have two schools that have been authorized to open in the 2022-23
[37:12]
school year. We also are anticipating, at a minimum right now, the potential of three schools being
[37:19]
able to apply from the AST this fall with the possibility of additional ones coming from
[37:25]
the Commissioner Authority pathway. And so we're we've been really strategic about the places within
[37:33]
our staff that we need to add immediate capacity knowing that it is very likely that our portfolio
[37:39]
will be expanding significantly and potentially doubling in the next year, as well as the areas
[37:45]
that maybe in two or three years is where we need to add additional capacity.
[37:50]
So first and foremost, we're adding additional capacity to our school district LEA team
[37:55]
in the area of special populations and data and operations. So these are the two key roles that
[38:01]
work almost exclusively with our charter schools and really help them into ensure that they're
[38:08]
a compliance with all regulations around special populations, as well as have really great and
[38:15]
clean data on their student information systems. These are two areas where I think from a staff
[38:21]
capacity standpoint, we'll see the most exponential growth in their workload as we add more schools.
[38:29]
And so it was critical in our planning process to go ahead and start using two of the five positions
[38:36]
that we were granted from the general assembly to start really trying to build capacity in these two areas.
[38:44]
The additionally, we are really focused on hiring and building capacity in our authorizing team area.
[38:51]
So we have hired a director of authorizing who is beginning with the commission in early October.
[38:57]
That individual will oversee both our appeal process as well as our application review process.
[39:04]
build out our performance management as well as we're really thinking critically about what additional supports that team needs as the portfolio of schools grow.
[39:17]
We are also preparing a transition checklist that we will be utilizing for achievement school district schools that are transitioning from one district to another.
[39:27]
So in a traditional new start school, we have a pre-opening checklist that we go through and that we monitor in the months leading up to that school opening to make sure that we are setting them up first success.
[39:40]
We recognize that that is going to have to happen with any school transitioning from the achievement school district, but that work is going to look slightly different.
[39:48]
And so we are building out based on our own knowledge and experience, a transition checklist
[39:54]
that we're going to be utilizing with any operator that would be transitioning from the
[39:58]
achievement school district.
[40:00]
And as Melanie shared earlier, you all just approved.
[40:03]
We're thinking about the use of our gear funding to provide strategic support to this transition
[40:09]
process.
[40:12]
This is a high level timeline that we have shared with our charter with ASC operators as
[40:19]
a part of the webinars.
[40:20]
It is also available on our website so that anyone in the public can understand both where we have been and where we are going as it relates to our part of the ASD exit process.
[40:33]
So key upcoming dates that we are looking forward to is first that we have a rulemaking hearing next week on the permanent ASD rule as well as a vote by the full commission on that rule in October.
[40:47]
As was shared earlier, letters of intent are due October 15th to the commission.
[40:53]
And so that is the point where we will really have a firm number of what potential schools may be,
[40:59]
maybe authorized by the charter commission.
[41:02]
And we will be both be able to prepare for the application review cycle as well as for the authorization cycle.
[41:08]
We plan to run a pretty traditional application review process similar to the ones we've used for new start appeals, so we will have a review committee, we will host public hearings,
[41:21]
we will compile a recommendation to the commission and we will have you all vote on any applications from the ASD at your January 2022 meeting.
[41:31]
And then moving on from that, any schools that are authorized by the commission, we would be bringing those charter agreements to you all at the April meeting so that we can make sure that we have an agreement in place in advance of a transfer for the upcoming school year.
[41:49]
And with that, I will stop sharing my screen and would happy to take any questions or conversation from the commissioners.
[41:57]
So this is Tom Briscoll. Let me share one thing with commissioners while test mentioned
[42:02]
that eight operators actually participate in the webinars. What what tests in the team
[42:08]
also put together was for those who may not have been able to attend. They have the ability
[42:14]
to come in and see the same presentation so that they had the benefit of the same information
[42:22]
for those that did actually attend.
[42:24]
So I wanted to sort of highlight that test for the commissioners,
[42:27]
so they were aware that that step was taken as well for those
[42:30]
who might not have been able to be at the time that you conducted them.
[42:35]
Commissioner Richards, let me come back to you now,
[42:37]
because you had a question earlier.
[42:41]
Are there any other questions you have that you'd like to address to test at this point?
[42:45]
Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman.
[42:48]
One thing right off the bat, these two ways that schools can be authorized to apply for
[43:02]
operation under the Charter Commission as the LEA indicate that there's to be a new charter agreement
[43:10]
not to with the term, not to exceed the term of the initial ASD charter agreement.
[43:18]
Now, for the schools that are on a priority exit, it seems to me that they may have a year
[43:24]
or two or three or four that are still available under their original charter agreement.
[43:30]
But one of the things that has bothered me is that we have a significant number of schools
[43:35]
I think 10 across the state that they're in the AST and their charter agreements run out
[43:41]
in the very near term.
[43:43]
So to, I don't understand how to go through this process simply to enter a new chart or agreement
[43:49]
with them that's going to be running out in a very short period of time, has this been discussed
[43:56]
and what is the plan to address this? I realize it's statutory language, but it doesn't seem to make
[44:02]
much sense.
[44:07]
Chairman Grisske, I'm happy to respond there. This is test of all. So if a operator is at
[44:14]
the ends of their agreement with the ASD,
[44:19]
then if the commission or a local school district
[44:24]
were to approve the authorization of that school,
[44:27]
they would enter into a new 10-year agreement.
[44:31]
For anyone who has years remaining,
[44:34]
so if you have four years remaining,
[44:37]
then the agreement would only be for the remaining
[44:40]
three or four years,
[44:42]
And then the entity that authorizes that school would be responsible for the renewal process of the school.
[44:49]
I think one of the questions that we received from one of the operators within the ASD, which is a valid question.
[44:57]
And, you know, if I had to take white board, it's on the...
[45:00]
The list of the whiteboard is to your point, Commissioner Richards, how does the commission want to handle a renewal of a school that we have only been an authorization for maybe two or three years? And what does that? How do we handle the renewal of a school that we have seen for 10 years versus a school we have seen for two or three years? And so that is something that we, as when I think about the authorization team that we are building
[45:29]
That is going to be on the list of how do we build criteria that both acknowledges the experience of operators in their charter agreement, but also it doesn't set up multiple standards of expectations across our portfolio.
[45:47]
So I hope that answers the question of yes, and we have more work to do, particularly in the things that we own over the next couple of years.
[45:56]
Thank you. That addresses my question on the term. Now, an additional question that I have is, I see where we have the staffing approved, the Fox positions for the additional support as we go through this authorization process, but I don't understand where is the operational support once they are authorized.
[46:22]
because while many of these schools are wonderful schools, I mean,
[46:27]
Bob Nardo's school obviously is, you know, top of the ranking.
[46:33]
Many of these schools are not being as successful perhaps as they would like,
[46:39]
and certainly not being as successful as we will need to expect of them going forward.
[46:46]
And I am very curious, especially since this looks like it could be happening
[46:50]
this as soon as next year, the 22th school year, where are the resources to support this from an
[46:58]
operating point of view, because I'm very concerned that we need to be able to aggressively work with
[47:05]
the operators to make sure they're doing what they're supposed to be so they start establishing a
[47:10]
track record of success since their track record may have been far less than that in the past.
[47:17]
So, can you help me with those resources?
[47:21]
Absolutely.
[47:22]
Test of all.
[47:22]
So, the fiscal note that was attached to the bill allowed for recurring state dollars
[47:30]
to support the work of the charter commission on a go-forward basis.
[47:35]
And so, we, there have been lots of conversations at the General Assembly that the expectation
[47:40]
is that the charter commission be self-sustaining via authorizer fee funds in the long term.
[47:48]
So we, those five positions will be able to be continued in the work of the charter commission,
[47:56]
you know, beyond the transition. It will then be an expectation of us in terms of working
[48:02]
with our schools to be collecting those authorizer fee dollars, using them to the best kind of the
[48:07]
transparent best way to support our overall operations, but also to be
[48:12]
ensuring that we are advocating for additional dollars as we as we
[48:16]
need it. I think we're in a very good posture for the next two or three
[48:20]
fiscal years given the additional positions we've been given the gear
[48:24]
funding the support from the general assembly to do this work. And so I feel
[48:29]
confident over the next, you know, in terms of working with the schools
[48:33]
transitioning them, getting them to where they they need to be over the next two
[48:36]
three years. I think that the ongoing question for the charter commission and the general assembly
[48:41]
will be as we continue to grow schools and authorize new schools either through the ASD or through
[48:47]
other avenues, we will probably need to increase our staff support. And so we are going to have to be
[48:54]
thinking further out than one expects to be asking for those additional reasons for the general
[49:02]
Assembly. And so just as an example, we had to turn in a preliminary FY 23 budget to finance
[49:09]
an administration basically this week. So that means that we need to be thinking about 18 months
[49:15]
in advance to make sure that we are appropriately supported both operationally and from a staff
[49:22]
capacity standpoint. And I don't want to put Mellie on the spot, but I think her team in particular,
[49:28]
are these are conversations we have daily about what is that capacity need?
[49:33]
Is there anything that I may have missed that would be helpful? Melanie, please
[49:36]
vote for her to share. Yeah, absolutely, this is Melanie
[49:40]
Harrell. I think absolutely everything that
[49:44]
tests that is right. I think something that my team is also
[49:46]
trying to be very intentional about as we do our work now is looking at
[49:52]
outside of staffing. What are the things that we need to make our work
[49:57]
more efficient, more streamlined, make sure that we are thinking through any systems that we need to adapt or look into as we know that the work will very possibly grow exponentially.
[50:09]
So I think that's something that we are thinking about certainly as we budgeted some gear dollars, thinking about different systems that could support the transition and then would hopefully be able to be captured by grow an authorizer fee revenue in the long term.
[50:23]
But I think we are being very intentional about not just thinking about staffing needs which
[50:30]
we will absolutely need to echo Tess's point, but also what are other processes or systems
[50:36]
that we could think about to also support that work.
[50:40]
I also think we acknowledge and are certainly acknowledging as we were thinking about this
[50:45]
transition checklist for the ASD that there are certain things that will just be different
[50:50]
about being authorized by the commission and different levels of supports and things that we're thinking strategically around to make sure that authorizers are prepared for any adjustments that that may need to be made, but also that we were setting up systems again to support their transition and not, you know, leave anybody in a lurch for an unexpected reason.
[51:11]
So, those are things that, you know, outside of just staffing, we're also thinking about other processes and systems that we may need to scale or modify and improve to make sure that those are kind of as as efficient but still high quality is possible.
[51:33]
So, the commissioners have other questions, the commissioners.
[51:38]
I just, I don't have another question because I don't think this is something that people
[51:42]
can answer at this point in time, but I would just ask that we try to do our best to try
[51:48]
to get an understanding of what is really going to happen under this first provision where
[51:54]
the commissioner appears to be able to designate schools to be exiting the ASD in a fairly
[52:03]
unconstrained fashion and what is the potential ramifications for us as to the number of schools
[52:11]
that we are going to be potentially seeing and I think that's probably not anything that anyone
[52:17]
knows at this point in time but as we move into December and certainly in the October time frame
[52:24]
perhaps we can cover that because I'm very concerned that a significant number of these schools
[52:31]
are going to be designated by the Commissioner to come over, and we have to be prepared to deal
[52:38]
with the problems. And I'm very worried about the staff's ability given everything already on its
[52:46]
plate to undertake that additional responsibility without some help. So I'll just leave it at that.
[52:53]
Thank you for the patience.
[52:56]
This time, Chris, I think, Commissioner Richards, you will find that Dr. Carney, when she comes in October, is well aware of this issue and well aware of the point that you're making so that we have a better sense of exactly what we're looking at and I know while you will not be able to be with us in October about want you to know we will do everything that we can to try to get that answer.
[53:22]
because I think what you're expressing
[53:24]
is on the minds of most of us on this call.
[53:26]
So I appreciate your help and I will check in
[53:29]
with tests after the October meeting.
[53:31]
I wish I could be there.
[53:32]
Thank you.
[53:33]
Do commissioners have other questions?
[53:38]
So seeing none, tests, thank you very much.
[53:42]
We're now going to move to the start appeals training
[53:48]
that was really what this whole meeting
[53:51]
was set up for us to have.
[53:55]
So, tests and Ashley are going to lead the training.
[53:59]
They'll help us better understand the new start-up pills process and the basis for the two
[54:04]
appeals that we will consider in October.
[54:08]
So now, let me recognize tests and Ashley to visit the end of the presentation, and thank
[54:14]
you all for doing this today.
[54:16]
Thank you, Chairman.
[54:17]
Test Stovall.
[54:18]
I'm going to share my presentation.
[54:21]
and we will dive in to New Start Appeals trainings.
[54:26]
We have not only in preparing for the ASD application process,
[54:31]
the staff has been hard at work on our two New Start Appeals,
[54:35]
which will be the first appeals of,
[54:38]
I can imagine, many cycles of appeals
[54:41]
that the commission will hear.
[54:43]
And so to ground you all in this work
[54:46]
in advance of these first two appeals,
[54:48]
we wanted to talk about the process, talk about what you're going to see, so that when you get the
[54:55]
materials you're better oriented to the process. And I know happy to take questions, we'll have some
[55:01]
spaces in this presentation to pause for questions. And then also at the end of presentation we can
[55:07]
talk in detail about anything else that you all might have questions about. So first and foremost,
[55:13]
I wanted to start high level with the commissioners about the general appeal process and we will talk in depth about these pieces as we go through this training but at a high level.
[55:28]
There are three key components to a charter school appeal that the commission staff undertakes when we receive that appeal.
[55:37]
And it's important to note as you all start digging into the records when you all receive it, is that for an applicant, this process in terms of applying for a charter student actually started back December of 2020.
[55:54]
So they have to submit a letter of intent to a local district saying that they intend to apply in December by December 1st of 2020.
[56:04]
They then submit an initial application to their local school district.
[56:10]
That school district has denied that application.
[56:13]
They have had an opportunity to amend their charter agreement.
[56:17]
And then that local board of education has denied the amended application.
[56:22]
And then it is only at that point that a school may appeal that decision to the charter
[56:28]
commission.
[56:28]
And as kind of a, you know, for your knowledge base, there've actually been three schools
[56:35]
that have been approved through this process at the local level.
[56:39]
There are two charter schools in Hamilton County that were approved and one charter school
[56:44]
in Metro National that were approved at this point.
[56:47]
So the charter commission that has received two appeals and when it receives an appeal,
[56:53]
the staff then collects information from the local school district.
[56:57]
So we want to know from a local school district, give us all of your information about analyzing
[57:03]
this application, who participated in the review of the application, what did your board
[57:09]
consider, what were the reasons for denial.
[57:12]
So we go to an LEA and collect all of that information.
[57:16]
We also conduct a review of the amended application and we host a capacity interview and we will
[57:22]
talk in more depth about what that means in just a few minutes.
[57:25]
And then finally, we hold a public hearing and collect public comments.
[57:31]
This is a critical part of our process.
[57:33]
It's so important for both the public to be able to share information with us,
[57:38]
but also for the parties to be heard publicly.
[57:41]
And you will see that we mirrored this process in the ASD application rule,
[57:46]
rule because we feel it's so important.
[57:49]
So all three of these components will roll up into a recommendation from myself
[57:54]
to the commission and that recommendation will either be to approve the school or it will be to
[58:01]
affirm the LEA's decision to deny the application. All of this process has to occur within 75 calendar days.
[58:10]
That is a statutory requirement and so we map out all of the processes in this work regularly to make sure that
[58:20]
we're staying in
[58:27]
and why it's important to our process.
[58:31]
So in accordance with the Commission Policy 2.100 application review,
[58:37]
the commission is required to form a review committee
[58:40]
with a variety of backgrounds and expertise
[58:43]
to conduct a review of the application.
[58:47]
Using a review committee is a best practice.
[58:49]
You will see it referenced in the state's best practices
[58:53]
on authorizing as well as national best practices
[58:56]
and authorizing. And when you begin to review LEA's documentation, you will see that they form
[59:03]
review committees similar to the way that the commission does. How do we, who sits on a review
[59:10]
committee, and how is this process made up? So we conduct a screening process to recruit
[59:20]
screen and train individuals who want to serve as an extra reviewer on a review committee.
[59:27]
So we ask for individuals to complete a short application and to submit their resume.
[59:33]
This is for us to gauge their expertise in a particular area. We want to make sure that we are
[59:41]
having a variety of individuals with expertise in academics, in operations, and in finance,
[59:46]
such that when they are reviewing an application that they are bringing
[59:51]
necessary invaluable perspective to the Review Committee work. We then
[59:57]
conduct a phone interview with those individuals.
[1:00:00]
Individuals to ensure that they are an adequate candidate to serve as a review committee member. Review
[1:00:07]
committee members do receive a small stipend. They receive $600 per application review. This
[1:00:15]
is both important to acknowledge the amount of work that goes into reviewing an application,
[1:00:20]
which is pretty extensive, as well as to ensure that we get a high-quality review process. So, I want
[1:00:28]
you to think about external reviewers as short-term contractors. And this is very common across all
[1:00:34]
authorizers nationally to be recruiting and having a kind of a pool of external reviewers to
[1:00:42]
serve on review committees. The pool is important because, if you can imagine, people's availability
[1:00:48]
changes, people's the needs change in terms of if we have a high school application, it's important for
[1:00:54]
to have a review committee that has high school experience, we also have to manage conflicts
[1:00:59]
and make sure that someone who's reviewing an application doesn't have a conflict with that
[1:01:03]
application. So, we are constantly making sure that we have a pool of candidates to serve on
[1:01:09]
that external review committee.
[1:01:14]
So, this cycle, our reviewers consist of a variety of different
[1:01:19]
individuals. We have current and former charter school leaders. We have current and former
[1:01:25]
authorizing staff from both within Tennessee and outside of Tennessee. We have legal and finance
[1:01:31]
experts. We have curriculum and instruction experts. We have special populations and federal
[1:01:36]
programs experts. We also make sure that we have geographic representation, so both within Tennessee
[1:01:42]
as well as nationally. We work to ensure we have demographic representation and we also include
[1:01:50]
internal commission staff. We internally as staff deeply understand our
[1:01:56]
authorization and operations and so it's incredibly important not only to have
[1:02:01]
that external voice to make sure that we are checking our bias in terms of
[1:02:06]
you authorizing the best schools, but it's important to have that internal
[1:02:10]
perspective as well as we know our authorization contacts better than anyone
[1:02:15]
else.
[1:02:19]
So, once we have identified review committee members, both external and internal, everyone has
[1:02:25]
to participate in a training to prepare them to review applications. This is an annual training.
[1:02:32]
We will not place anyone on a review committee if they have not participated in the training.
[1:02:37]
This training involves both orientation to the application in the rubric. We do practice scoring,
[1:02:44]
so they are given a sample application that we have used in a previous cycle. They are asked to
[1:02:50]
review and at parts of that application, score it against the scoring rubric, have conversations
[1:02:56]
about writing objective language. How would you rate that part of the application so that we can
[1:03:02]
really begin to build capacity within those reviewers to conduct a high-quality review?
[1:03:08]
We talk about what to expect in a capacity interview. So a capacity interview is a
[1:03:14]
time when the review committee and the leadership of the proposed school come together and that
[1:03:20]
leadership answers questions from the review committee about the application. So we discuss how do
[1:03:27]
you pose questions in the review, in the capacity interview, how do we get to the best information,
[1:03:32]
what's really important to ask versus not as important to ask. We also have to talk a lot about
[1:03:38]
the rating and consensus building in an application. So it's incredibly important for review committee
[1:03:45]
members to understand that it is not based on one person's voice in the evaluation of the
[1:03:52]
application. Everyone has a variety of experiences and a variety of expertise and so it is truly those
[1:03:58]
conversations and consensus building throughout the review committee process that gets us to the final
[1:04:05]
recommendation. So when staff is building out a review committee, we make sure that as
[1:04:12]
we have shared, there's a balance of expertise. You know, an application is going to cover
[1:04:17]
academics, operations and finance. There are very few people who are experts in all three.
[1:04:23]
So we make sure that we are balancing a review committee that has expertise across those
[1:04:28]
areas that we have no real or perceived conflict. So every individual, both external
[1:04:34]
and internal has to complete a conflict of interest form,
[1:04:37]
and we save that to make sure that we are identifying any conflicts.
[1:04:41]
And we do try to make sure that we have geographical
[1:04:44]
or community considerations.
[1:04:46]
So when all possible, making sure that we have individual serving
[1:04:50]
on that review committee who understand both the community
[1:04:53]
and the geographic location of the school,
[1:04:56]
either they are from that community
[1:04:58]
or they have worked in that community or have contacts within that community.
[1:05:05]
So, the review committee is charged with conducting that
[1:05:09]
denovo review of the amended application.
[1:05:12]
So, they are reviewing the amended application,
[1:05:14]
scoring it against the department scoring rubric.
[1:05:18]
They are not given information about why the LEA denied the application
[1:05:22]
or any kind of what I would say periphery information.
[1:05:25]
We say your charge is to give us a fresh look at that application
[1:05:29]
and against the scoring rubric.
[1:05:31]
They are conducting a capacity interview and they are completing a final
[1:05:36]
rubric based on the totality of the evidence and coming to that consensus
[1:05:41]
recommendation and what you all will see as commissioners is a review committee
[1:05:47]
report that is an exhibit to the executive director's recommendation which is
[1:05:52]
that summarizes the review committee's perspectives on that amended
[1:05:56]
application.
[1:06:00]
So as a high level I wanted to share with you the timeline that
[1:06:04]
we share with reviewers, and this is the timeline we shared with them as a part of their training
[1:06:08]
and expectations for their work. As you can see, there are many touch points in our process
[1:06:15]
to prepare them throughout and to conduct their work. We're hosting trainings. They're doing
[1:06:22]
their internal individual scoring of an application. We're hosting capacity interviews. We're hosting
[1:06:28]
and debrief conversations.
[1:06:30]
So there is a significant amount of work
[1:06:32]
that happens for reviewers in that six-week or so process
[1:06:36]
that they are reviewing applications.
[1:06:41]
So I will pause there to see if there are any questions
[1:06:44]
about the review committee process
[1:06:47]
before we move on to the next part of the string.
[1:06:53]
Test, this is Tom Griskin.
[1:06:55]
One quick question.
[1:06:56]
The review committees, are they meeting us individuals
[1:07:00]
do they ever meet as a group? Thank you for that question, Test-Dovall. They do meet as a group,
[1:07:08]
both to prepare for the capacity interview and to conduct the capacity interview and then to
[1:07:14]
be as part of the debrief conversation. So we do value both independent review at the beginning
[1:07:23]
so that they are really focused on what they evaluate and see in the application,
[1:07:29]
but then to begin to bring in the voices of the review committee so that they are building out that consensus as a group.
[1:07:38]
So can I follow real quick? So does that mean that let's say you've got a review committee of 12 people all 12 are then going to be sort of talking as a group.
[1:07:48]
And are you're trying to get to one recommendation rather than 12 different pieces of the puzzle they got put together, is that right?
[1:07:58]
And would we see all 12 pieces that came together, or would we just see the consensus that they reach?
[1:08:06]
Thank you, Testoval. You would only see the consensus report.
[1:08:11]
And the reason is, is that if I'm an academic expert, then my part of the of the process is to really provide my evaluation of the academic part. Now, I will have rated and reviewed the other sections, but I really need to share from my expertise.
[1:08:29]
And so then the operations expert share from their expertise.
[1:08:34]
The size of review committees, I didn't mention this but this is important, we do try to keep it around like five to seven people.
[1:08:43]
I think we can all appreciate trying to get 12 people or 10 people on the same page can be very difficult.
[1:08:49]
And so we do try to keep it both diverse in terms of experience but also not too large.
[1:08:55]
And I think the thing that we talk about even from the beginning of the training process is that we are
[1:09:02]
the process that we go through in terms of review of application, preparing for capacity interview,
[1:09:08]
capacity interview, debrief is really a funneling process to get folks in alignment with what the
[1:09:15]
recommendation is so that we're starting to build that funnel in terms of where we're netting out
[1:09:22]
even before the capacity interview.
[1:09:25]
I got one last question, commissioners, you don't mind.
[1:09:27]
Is this a noticed session when they come together with consensus review that you have?
[1:09:35]
So is there is a public participation at least public review of what is occurring?
[1:09:42]
So it is not publicly noticed that we have in our policies that the public is not as a part of the review committee process.
[1:09:49]
But any information that is a part of the record is a public record and it would be available in terms of a public records were classed.
[1:09:56]
Thank you.
[1:09:57]
Do other commissioners have questions at this point for test. Thank you all for letting me, you know, pose those three anybody else has a question.
[1:10:05]
Yes, this is commissioner assistant. I have a couple of questions.
[1:10:09]
One, it actually speaks to the last one around just.
[1:10:12]
just public access. I know this is a political process. You know, folks who would want to get their schools approved. I could see lobbying. What have you?
[1:10:22]
How are we ensuring just that this process is a straight forward and not politically driven process, but that it's by merit and it's objective and not subjective.
[1:10:35]
are the reviewers, are they confidential,
[1:10:39]
or are we keeping their names confidential,
[1:10:41]
or do they have, in addition to the conflict of interest,
[1:10:45]
do they have confidentiality clauses,
[1:10:48]
just wanting to think through that,
[1:10:50]
or wondering if that's been bought through?
[1:10:53]
Yes, test so well.
[1:10:55]
So first and foremost, we do publicize at the very end,
[1:10:59]
the review committee.
[1:11:00]
As a part of the report,
[1:11:01]
there will be an exhibit that will have
[1:11:03]
their bio information. We believe it's important for you as commissioners as well as the public
[1:11:10]
to know who participated in the review committee. They will include a short bio so that you can
[1:11:16]
see their expertise. That will be included both for external and internal reviewers.
[1:11:24]
We do ask them to sign a terms and conditions about both conflicts and then expectations that they
[1:11:31]
keep the process that we lead to the consensus building internal and into
[1:11:38]
themselves and that they're not kind of talking about the process until after the
[1:11:43]
commission has voted. Obviously post the commission vote they are they are free
[1:11:47]
and welcome to discuss the process. I think in the past based on my
[1:11:53]
experience, we do have from time to time applicants who are reaching out to
[1:12:00]
reviewers, both in advance of an after-the-capacity interview. And what we ask is that reviewers
[1:12:06]
funnel any communications as that regard to the staff so that we are able to communicate
[1:12:12]
with those individuals. Because we, you know, as we will talk about, it's really important
[1:12:18]
for both the review committee to kind of put their guard rails up as it relates to kind of what
[1:12:24]
they are considering in their review and that really it's the information provided in the application
[1:12:30]
of the capacity review and not external information that they would be receiving. But we, you know,
[1:12:37]
a part of the training and the use of the rubric and these debrief conversations that are all staff
[1:12:42]
as a part of is that we're really pushing to make sure that any recommendation is based on the
[1:12:47]
evidence heard in the cast interview and in the in the application as opposed to a feeling or I think, you know, that's really external to what the review committee's recommendation is.
[1:13:03]
Okay. Thank you. That's really helpful. I had another question. I think, well, I'll still ask it just to get you a thoughts on you mentioned earlier that there will be different folks on the committee that have different areas of expertise, I academics or finance.
[1:13:18]
And so given that how are you thinking about waiting their respective sort of scores in those areas which they're experts in versus those that are not or is that really what the roll up score or the consensus building would do.
[1:13:36]
So that's really a part of the consensus building process and I will say we don't put everyone
[1:13:43]
scores together and average them out because it really the consensus building process is
[1:13:48]
really about hearing a committee members perspective on the evidence that they fall and then saying,
[1:13:56]
okay, what evidence did you see that may have rated this application as partially neat?
[1:14:01]
So we can have because there are always things that maybe I miss in the application that you saw or vice versa
[1:14:07]
And so we do ask that all reviewers read and read great every section of the application
[1:14:14]
Regardless of their expertise because everything really ties together and so what we don't want is to have a reviewer
[1:14:23]
Who's an expert in finance only to review the budget because they might say wow this budget looks great
[1:14:28]
everything you know lots of cash flow but what they may have missed if they didn't read the academic
[1:14:33]
section is they're mentioning all these staff that are not included in the budget and so we
[1:14:38]
require everyone to read and rate every section but we also acknowledge as a part of the consensus
[1:14:46]
building process that people are going to come in with different strengths but that it's a really an
[1:14:51]
even keel process and I would also say it's a part of the staff to really make sure that everyone's
[1:14:56]
voices are heard and that we're balancing out, you know, there's not just like
[1:15:00]
One dominating talker that everyone is able to hear and see the evidence that everyone saw as a part of those conversations.
[1:15:10]
Thank you.
[1:15:21]
We may have lost our chairman.
[1:15:25]
Chase.
[1:15:28]
This is chasing. Oh, that's correct. I'm about to give them a call. So you can easily help. Okay. I will pod.
[1:15:38]
Hey, test since we're sitting here. Can I can ask the quick question? Of course. This is Alan Levine. So we go through surveys in hospitals all the time.
[1:15:49]
and I'm curious about the process when they go through the review.
[1:15:55]
Like I know when the surveyors come survey our hospitals if we're not in compliance with something.
[1:16:02]
We typically are told during the process and we have an opportunity to correct it before the process is concluded.
[1:16:11]
Is that how you envision this being or is it more of a whatever it is it is, we score it and that's it.
[1:16:17]
You know, I mean, I mean, is it is it sort of partially advisory while also measuring or thank you for that question.
[1:16:27]
Testo all and I think this that's actually hits on a uniqueness of the the appeal process because the commission is charged with a
[1:16:38]
to NOVO on the record review of in essence what the local district considered.
[1:16:48]
So most cases, we are not allowing amendments to the application, once it is submitted
[1:16:57]
to us because the charge is really, we're looking at what the district considered.
[1:17:03]
Now that we do allow some, as our policies allow some level of due diligence in a situation
[1:17:10]
where we as a commission could ask for additional information, but we are not allowing a whole
[1:17:17]
rewrite of the amended application.
[1:17:20]
Now, if we're thinking about future, like let's say the ASD application cycle as an example,
[1:17:27]
We are actually running that process so we actually can build in some places where we could do a preliminary review ask for some additional information because it's not it's a different legal standard.
[1:17:43]
And I will ask Ashley to weigh in because I just like to rely on Ashley's legal expertise of anything I may have missed as it relates to that question, but I actually think that's a really it's a good distinction of kind of what the charges on an appeal versus to a certain extent running our own application process.
[1:18:01]
This is actually Thomas test is exactly right I think because this is statutorily charged as a
[1:18:06]
denovo on the record review we're sort of limited into what we can ask for I think as part of our
[1:18:12]
due diligence if we need just some clarification on something that was in the amended application
[1:18:18]
I think it's fine to ask for that clarification but to do essentially a preliminary review and then
[1:18:24]
and allow them to correct or edit that in any way,
[1:18:28]
I think goes beyond the charge of the statute.
[1:18:38]
I said, okay, and thank you.
[1:18:40]
I'm just muted, sorry.
[1:18:42]
I have this time written.
[1:18:43]
So I think, Tess, I think this is my day.
[1:18:45]
First of all, I couldn't get off mute.
[1:18:47]
And then, I don't know about you all,
[1:18:49]
but we've had storms again.
[1:18:51]
I just, I lost EPB, the gig city.
[1:18:55]
I lost my whole internet.
[1:18:57]
So I had to reboot everything.
[1:18:59]
So I apologize. I had a question if I may.
[1:19:04]
You and I talked some time ago about, for those of us like me,
[1:19:08]
to provide us sort of an inexemptive summary.
[1:19:13]
So we sort of, we know what we ought to be looking at.
[1:19:16]
We've sort of got the highlights.
[1:19:17]
All the other information is there that we can look into.
[1:19:20]
Is it still your thought that you would provide for us as commissioners,
[1:19:25]
at least that type of an overview to help us sort of get focused?
[1:19:28]
on the reviews? Absolutely. I can dive into my next part of the presentation which is going to get into kind of some high level things that works for the group. Sorry, I got a hand of your apologize.
[1:19:43]
No, you're absolutely fine. Okay, let me reach.
[1:19:45]
All right,
[1:19:56]
so that before we get into the summary and kind of what our key look for is I didn't want to touch on the public hearing as we talked about this is an incredibly important part of our process.
[1:20:07]
And I think if I think about what we hear regularly is that parties feel most valuable as a part of this process, it is the public hearing.
[1:20:18]
So it is first it's statutorily required. We have to host a public hearing in the district in which the school proposes to locate.
[1:20:27]
I serve as the hearing officer.
[1:20:30]
We allow both the sponsor of the application and the local board of education to have an opportunity to be heard on the record.
[1:20:37]
This is notice publicly noticed on our website.
[1:20:40]
We are also required to publish it in a newspaper of record in that community.
[1:20:46]
So, you know, for example, our appeals this time around.
[1:20:50]
We publish it in the Tennessee and then the Falcon.
[1:20:53]
We also share this information about this public hearing widely with anyone who's interested in it.
[1:21:00]
At the hearing, we also allow for public comment.
[1:21:04]
So both individuals who want to speak publicly in the meeting as well as we collect public
[1:21:09]
comment as a part of this process.
[1:21:12]
As the executive director, I do ask questions of both the sponsor and the local board of education
[1:21:18]
based on initial review of the record so that we have a little bit of an opportunity to have
[1:21:23]
a dialogue with both parties to discuss some questions that we have and to gather some additional
[1:21:29]
information as we need it.
[1:21:32]
The third piece of the part, the leading up to a recommendation for the commission is the staff review of the record.
[1:21:41]
So this is led by the general council and the executive director.
[1:21:45]
As we build out our authorizing team, those individuals will support in this review as well.
[1:21:51]
but we are reviewing every single document that is submitted as a part of the appeal.
[1:21:57]
So we review everything that has been submitted by the local board of education.
[1:22:02]
We review everything by the sponsor.
[1:22:04]
We are looking at anything that the review committee has submitted
[1:22:09]
and any public comment or information collected at the public hearing.
[1:22:14]
Based on that, review of the record and the other parts that we've talked about
[1:22:19]
a recommendation is then provided to the commission
[1:22:23]
based on the following statutory charge.
[1:22:26]
So does the application meet or exceed the metrics
[1:22:28]
outlined in the scoring rubric
[1:22:30]
that is produced by the Department of Education
[1:22:33]
and is the approval of the application
[1:22:35]
and the best interest of the students,
[1:22:37]
the LEA or community?
[1:22:39]
If the answer is yes,
[1:22:41]
then the commission may authorize and approve that school.
[1:22:45]
I will say that there is a provision in statute
[1:22:48]
that if the commission authorizes the school, there is a 30-day window that allows a local
[1:22:53]
board of education and an operator to mutually agree that that school actually would be authorized
[1:23:00]
by the local district. In my previous time at the State Board of Education, that did happen
[1:23:06]
on a couple of occasions, so although we would be thrilled and excited if we were to approve a school,
[1:23:13]
We also recognize that there is a 30 day window in which that school and that district may come to an immutual agreement and that school would no longer be the commission's responsibility.
[1:23:27]
So let's talk about how you are going to approach the record, what your legal charge is and into your question chairman this we will get into some high level things that you would want to consider.
[1:23:40]
So first I'm actually going to ask Ashley, our general counsel to step in here and talk about what is that legal charge we talked a little bit about that already, but I want to clarify kind of what information you will be considering as a part of that record review and an appeal.
[1:23:56]
So Ashley, would you be able to hop in here?
[1:24:00]
Sure, thanks, Tess. This is Ashley Thomas. I want to highlight that the charges of the
[1:24:09]
NOVO review on the record, you will receive the information that the original LEA had, so
[1:24:16]
that would be the initial application, the amended application, and any documentation that
[1:24:20]
they had in response to that. So you will look at everything that they had, but your decision
[1:24:26]
does not have to match that. So that's the denouable part. You're looking at it a new, you're looking at it
[1:24:31]
as those, of course, it's your first time. I do want to say this includes information from the,
[1:24:37]
like I said, the original LEA's decision, the Commission's public hearing and, of course, the
[1:24:41]
recommendation from Tess during the public process. I may ask parties to supplement information
[1:24:47]
as I stated to Commissioner Levine just a bit earlier and that, of course, would be considered as a part
[1:24:53]
the record. As we know, these operators, as Tess mentioned, have been in this process for
[1:24:59]
almost a year by the point it gets to the commission. For that reason, you may find that they
[1:25:04]
want to reach out to you. They may have additional information. They may want to just give you
[1:25:10]
information on their school. What I would say to that is it's important that they understand that
[1:25:16]
any of that information that you may receive from them cannot be considered in your decision as to
[1:25:20]
whether or not the denial was correct.
[1:25:24]
So I would advise you to let those operators know
[1:25:27]
that that information needs to be funneled to me or test
[1:25:29]
if we can figure out if that's something
[1:25:31]
that needs to be a part of the record
[1:25:33]
or explain to them while that cannot be considered.
[1:25:38]
I do, I want to ensure the commission
[1:25:40]
that the appeal process does provide ample opportunity
[1:25:43]
for the operators to be heard.
[1:25:44]
It is through the public hearing.
[1:25:47]
Additionally, we have been in contact with them
[1:25:50]
as we build out the record, as we work towards a recommendation for you.
[1:25:55]
And Tess, if there was anything else you want to get highlighted, let me know.
[1:26:02]
No, I think I appreciate that. Actually, this is test of all.
[1:26:05]
I would also say that throughout our process and communication with both parties, we also articulate this.
[1:26:11]
That you all are limited to what's on the record. And so we have a lot of conversations with them about making sure that the reason that we have deadlines for.
[1:26:20]
or submission of materials and public comments
[1:26:24]
is that we have to be very thoughtful
[1:26:25]
about what is considered a part of the record,
[1:26:27]
both in your review, but if there were any litigation
[1:26:31]
that may come out of any appeal process
[1:26:34]
that we have a clean documentation
[1:26:37]
of what was on the record.
[1:26:39]
So as the, you know, kind of flowing into that,
[1:26:42]
what will be a part of your record
[1:26:44]
when you receive that from the staff?
[1:26:46]
So the record in an appeal will include first correspondence from the Commission staff to parties.
[1:26:54]
You'll see the request for information letters, any additional letters that we may sent requesting further due diligence.
[1:27:02]
You will see that you will receive the notice of appeal from a sponsor.
[1:27:07]
So what that's going to include is the initial and amended application.
[1:27:11]
you will see a timeline from the sponsor, you will also see a statement that the sponsor
[1:27:18]
submits when they complete their notice of appeal about why they think their application
[1:27:23]
should be approved.
[1:27:25]
You will see documentation from the LEA about their application review process.
[1:27:30]
So who reviewed the application?
[1:27:33]
Minutes from their local board meetings.
[1:27:36]
What's the local board of information received?
[1:27:38]
What were their reasons for this now?
[1:27:41]
You will see information about the public hearing that we host.
[1:27:45]
Both agendas, scripts, and questions that I ask, as well as a recording of that public
[1:27:50]
hearing, as well as any public comment that we received in writing.
[1:27:55]
And then finally, you will receive an executive director's recommendation.
[1:28:00]
That is going to include the review committee report that we talked about.
[1:28:04]
And it's also a summary of the record.
[1:28:08]
So how would we recommend that you approach a record?
[1:28:12]
First and foremost, I want you to know that there is going to be a lot of documentation that you are going to receive as a part of the record.
[1:28:21]
We have probably close to 100 files that we have reviewed and looked at that's the totality of the record.
[1:28:30]
Certainly you don't feel like to be prepared to discuss the appeal that you need to look through all 100 documents.
[1:28:37]
That is the responsibility of the staff and as a part of the executive director's recommendation we will summarize the material parts of the record for your review.
[1:28:48]
So when the executive director's recommendation is available would suggest that you start there. That is going to give you a high level summary of what are the key issues.
[1:28:59]
What are the merits of the application from the review committee?
[1:29:04]
What were the key issues discussed at the public hearing?
[1:29:09]
And what is the staff's recommendation on the appeal?
[1:29:13]
If there's any information that you then are interested in kind of digging into further,
[1:29:19]
based on the recommendation, that's when you can go deeper into the record.
[1:29:23]
I would also highly recommend that you review that review committee report that's going
[1:29:29]
to be an exhibit to the executive directors recommendation.
[1:29:32]
It is going to give you both a summary of the application and it's going to give you
[1:29:38]
a one-page summary of the contents of the key parts of the application and the review
[1:29:45]
committee's rating.
[1:29:46]
So, it's going to summarize for you, does the school have a strong quality academic program?
[1:29:53]
Can it serve all students with particular focus to special education and English learners?
[1:30:00]
Is the school likely to meet its enrollment projections? This is incredibly important, as we all know, because enrollment drives budgets and staffing. And so we have to know if a school has a likelihood of success in terms of enrollment. Does the school have an effective governance structure? Is it going to be able to govern itself and run its operations successfully? Can it recruit and staff its program?
[1:30:26]
are does it have reasonable revenue projections both in terms of what is
[1:30:31]
confirmed and what is projected? And if a school or a network is already in
[1:30:37]
in existence is the performance successful? Does it merit an additional school?
[1:30:46]
We
[1:30:46]
also recommend that you listen or watch the public hearing. This is a great
[1:30:52]
summary of the key argument on those sides of this appeal. The public hearing's
[1:30:58]
typically last about an hour to 90 minutes in total.
[1:31:04]
And it's really good for you to hear kind of what
[1:31:06]
the sponsor's perspective is on their application,
[1:31:09]
the local boards reasons for denial,
[1:31:12]
the key questions that we as a staff ask,
[1:31:15]
as well as what members of the public had to say.
[1:31:18]
We would also encourage you to review the public comments.
[1:31:22]
Again, the summary or high level of the public comments
[1:31:26]
is going to be an executive director's report.
[1:31:29]
But I think it's a good idea for you
[1:31:32]
to just get a general sense of what are folks
[1:31:36]
in the public have to say.
[1:31:39]
As always, you would caution kind of counting
[1:31:42]
of public comments, because I think as we know,
[1:31:45]
sometimes a link to submit a public comment
[1:31:48]
can be circulated amongst one group
[1:31:50]
and not circulated amongst the other.
[1:31:52]
But I do think it's an important piece
[1:31:55]
of the information that you're going to be considering in an appeal.
[1:32:02]
So I will pause there before I talk about the timeline and expectations for these upcoming
[1:32:07]
two appeals and to see if there are any questions overall about the record that we can discuss
[1:32:13]
at this point.
[1:32:17]
So tests this time risk are the files going to be electronic or are you sending out paper
[1:32:25]
versions?
[1:32:28]
So the files will be electronic.
[1:32:29]
Thank you.
[1:32:30]
And actually, I'll just go ahead and go through those slides and then we'll because we're going to answer those questions.
[1:32:37]
So let me do that really quick.
[1:32:41]
So what on Monday, you will get an email from me where I will say the record is available in SharePoint.
[1:32:50]
It is important and we will have staff being following up with you after this meeting this week to make sure that you are able to access SharePoint.
[1:32:57]
because as I mentioned, there are a lot of files and so we are not going to be linking everything to the website just for my sheer capacity standpoint.
[1:33:10]
So in order to see the full record, you are going to need to be able to have access to T and share.
[1:33:16]
So on Monday, you are going to have access to the following information in the record.
[1:33:21]
The sponsors notice of appeal, all LEA documentation, the public hearing
[1:33:27]
information, so the recording, public comment, etc. We are still in the process
[1:33:34]
of finalizing review committee reports and the executive director's
[1:33:38]
recommendation on both of those appeals. That will be prepared and ready for you
[1:33:42]
while on October the 4th. That will be posted both on our website as well as in
[1:33:47]
and share, so we will be notifying you all via email when that information is ready.
[1:33:53]
So if you want to get a jumpstart on reviewing the entirety of the record, you are welcome
[1:33:57]
to do that beginning next week.
[1:33:59]
You are also welcome to wait until those executive director's recommendations are ready and then
[1:34:04]
to dive into the information.
[1:34:06]
We also are happy to, as you all are beginning to look through the rubric and the record,
[1:34:14]
If you want to schedule a call to orient yourself since this is your first appeal process,
[1:34:19]
we'd be more than happy to schedule a call with you to discuss any questions about access information,
[1:34:26]
how you should look at that information.
[1:34:36]
And with that, I am happy to take any questions.
[1:34:39]
This is Tom Briskam.
[1:34:43]
Tess, let me thank you and Ashley for the presentation very much.
[1:34:50]
Very well done, very concise, but for me, for one, very helpful
[1:34:56]
and understanding exactly how this process works.
[1:35:00]
It helps me to recall when I had the opportunity to sit in one of the legislative hearing rooms
[1:35:07]
as I've watched you up there on repeal when we were yet candidates for this.
[1:35:13]
So, Commissioner, does anybody have a question that you would like to ask,
[1:35:18]
Tess or Ashley, at this point? Let me open it up.
[1:35:28]
There must be a great sign that you all did extremely well.
[1:35:33]
Mr. Chair, this is Alan. I would just make comment, this has been an extraordinary amount of work
[1:35:39]
in a very condensed period of time.
[1:35:43]
So, test congratulations on what I don't know how you did it,
[1:35:49]
but you and your staff have just done a great job.
[1:35:54]
Thank you.
[1:35:55]
I appreciate that, Chairman Levina.
[1:35:58]
I also, I want to note to you for the commissioners
[1:36:01]
is that I think we, all of us are in a learning process.
[1:36:05]
And so, we both value feedback from review committee members.
[1:36:10]
we value feedback from our participants in the process, and we value feedback from you all.
[1:36:15]
And so we want to, you know, complete this process, and then once we get on the other side,
[1:36:21]
hear from you all, what are things that we could do better in the future, knowing that we're
[1:36:26]
going to be doing this on a regular basis. So we look forward to hearing from you all about ways
[1:36:31]
that we can improve. So thank you.
[1:36:36]
Tom Griskum, saying no other questions or comments,
[1:36:39]
we're at the end of the meeting day. Let me make some quick last minute notes. On the 4th of October,
[1:36:47]
the School Performance and Accountability Committee will meet. And then on October 11th,
[1:36:54]
and October 12th is our regular schedule meeting. We do have a committee of the whole on the 11th,
[1:37:01]
and we've got two other committee meetings that afternoon, and then our regular commission session is on the 12th.
[1:37:08]
We are in Nashville, and we're in the legislative building, correct tests.
[1:37:19]
Yes, that is correct.
[1:37:20]
Okay, and I know that there's been a note that's going out about reservation, room reservations to make sure Mary did.
[1:37:27]
I did that today, so I make sure she knew when I was coming.
[1:37:32]
So, commissioners, if you haven't done that, please do so.
[1:37:35]
So, does any commission have something else to add today before we get to the end of the meeting?
[1:37:44]
Seeing none, do I have a motion to adjourn?
[1:37:53]
Commissioner Levine, I saw your hand.
[1:37:54]
Thank you.
[1:37:55]
Do I have a second?
[1:37:57]
Hi, second.
[1:37:58]
Commission Assistant.
[1:37:58]
Thank you, Commissioner Assistant.
[1:38:00]
Is there any discussion?
[1:38:01]
Yes.
[1:38:02]
Mr. Chair, this meeting was agenda until 4 o'clock, central 5 o'clock, Eastern.
[1:38:07]
and I propose that we continue to meet until then.
[1:38:12]
Chief, I promise to the public, right?
[1:38:14]
Commissioner, I would be happy to do that.
[1:38:17]
As a matter of fact, I might like for you
[1:38:19]
to share with us a lot of the things you've been sharing publicly.
[1:38:26]
I'll call the question.
[1:38:31]
Chase, may I ask you to call the role, please?
[1:38:33]
Chair, single commissioner Hanson, which aye votes aye commissioner Levine, aye votes aye commissioner Patterson, aye
[1:38:44]
votes aye commissioner Richards, aye votes aye commissioner assistant, aye
[1:38:52]
votes aye and chairman Griscombe, aye votes aye Mr Chairman the motion is approved, thank you thank you all
[1:38:59]
and we'll see you in a couple of weeks.