Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
[7:26]
>> all right, good evening, everyone.
[7:27]
I'm going to call the regular council meeting to order for
[7:31]
september 1st, 2026, at 7:00 p.m.
[7:33]
at this time we have no disclosures pursuant to
[7:36]
government code section 54953.8.3.
[7:41]
roll call and declaration of conflicts, please.
[7:46]
>> council member bedolla. >> council member evans.
[7:53]
>> present, no conflicts. >> council member nygard.
[7:59]
>> present, no conflicts. >> mayor pro tem abercrombie.
[8:03]
>> present, no conflicts. >> mayor arriola.
[8:08]
>> present, no conflicts. >> present, no conflicts.
[8:22]
>> madam clerk, is that sufficient?
[8:29]
>> sorry, 7:03. The clock is off there.
[8:48]
>> mayor, we are having a tech issue on ur end ere.
[8:53]
okay. Result?
[8:57]
>> are we ready to proceed? All right, thank you.
[9:00]
please stand and join me for the pledge of allegiance.
[9:03]
> I pledge allegiance to the flg of the united states of america
[9:06]
and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under god,
[9:10]
indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[9:18]
>> please remain tanding for our invocation from pastor kevin
[9:21]
james is a new creation bible fellowship.
[9:24]
>> let us bow our heads for a word of prayer.
[9:26]
lord god, first, giving you all the glory, honor, and praise,
[9:32]
because only you are truly worthy.
[9:34]
thank you for remaining faithful to us even though, at times, we
[9:38]
are not faithful to you. Search our hearts and our minds
[9:43]
ight now for offensive waysn us.
[9:47]
lead us into ways verlasting, oh, god.
[9:48]
we invite your presence throughout this entire council
[9:52]
meeting. We pray, counc god, that you wil
[9:58]
guide our city council this meeting.
[9:59]
bless our mayor, city council members, and city staff with
[10:02]
wisdom as they preside over tonight's agenda items.
[10:06]
father, we pray that every decision made this evening will
[10:09]
be what is best for the residents of our great city, and
[10:13]
we pray that everything this evening is done decently and in
[10:18]
order. We thank you, lord god come in
[10:23]
advance for the answered prayer. It is in your name that we pray
[10:26]
and give thanks and say amen. >> thank you, pastor.
[10:31]
you may be seated. Members of the public may
[10:39]
participate remotely by visiting the following link and using the
[10:47]
information provided on the screen.
[10:49]
this is also available online on the city website as well as in
[10:53]
paper format here at city hall. That brings us to the
[10:55]
presentations. I will go ahead and turn it over
[10:58]
to our tracy police chief. >> do you mind if I
[11:09]
just -- thank you very much. Good evening, mayor and council
[11:14]
and to our community members. Thank you so much.
[11:17]
if you would indulge me just for a moment, this is a great honor
[11:20]
for me. We generally get to recognize
[11:24]
our officers for all the good work they do, and they are the
[11:28]
face of the police department, but today e get to celebrate
[11:31]
one of our dispatchers, one of our very own who is the voice
[11:34]
behind the face. They are the first to make
[11:37]
contact with our community in need, so we are very proud of
[11:44]
nicolle's accomplishment today. I'm going to celebrate her a bit
[11:46]
and talk about why she has been chosen as an employee of the
[11:51]
month. Nicolle has proudly served as a
[11:55]
dispatcher for our police departments in 2016, bringing a
[11:59]
decade of experience and dedication and commitment to the
[12:02]
department and the community she serves.
[12:05]
nicolle recently joined our dispatch training team, formerly
[12:07]
known as cto connolly she has demonstrated developing the next
[12:13]
generation of dispatchers. She has time to ensure new
[12:16]
employees understand not only what to do, but why it is
[12:18]
important to do the things they do.
[12:21]
when a trainee is struggling with the concept, nicolle's
[12:25]
patient and willing to explain in a different way until the
[12:28]
trainee has a clear understanding of the material.
[12:31]
her commitment to her trainees combined with her knowledge and
[12:34]
experience makes her an invaluable -- excuse my
[12:39]
stutter -- addition to the training team.
[12:40]
beyond her role as a trainer, nicolle is a dedicated and
[12:44]
dependable dispatcher who consistently goes above and
[12:46]
beyond for both her coworkers and for the community.
[12:51]
she regularly volunteers for overtime shifts to support her
[12:53]
teams, to help ensure the department is adequately
[12:59]
staffed. Your coworkers know she can be
[13:01]
counted on. She's a eliable partner,
[13:04]
particularly during challenging and demanding shifts.
[13:07]
nicolle takes great pride in providing exceptional service to
[13:10]
the officers and citizens she assists.
[13:12]
she has a strong ability to anticipate what officers may
[13:16]
need and often has information ready before it is requested.
[13:19]
she makes full use of the systems and resources available
[13:23]
to her to gather accurate, timely information helping
[13:27]
officers in the field ake informed decisions and keep
[13:30]
communities safe. Her professionalism, initiative,
[13:33]
and willingness to help others example has the qualities of an
[13:36]
outstanding police dispatcher. Nicolle shares that she enjoys
[13:42]
the challenges that come with dispatching and most importantly
[13:46]
genuinely enjoys helping people. I know this for a fact.
[13:49]
my last set-along with his with nicolle and she was able to
[13:53]
really enlighten me about the challenges of the work that her
[13:55]
and the rest of the team does. She speaks highly of her
[14:01]
coworkers and values teamwork within the unit.
[14:03]
she recognizes the hard work her fellow dispatchers put in every
[14:07]
day and appreciates the way they support one another.
[14:10]
nicolle grew up in fremont, california.
[14:13]
outside of work she also enjoys photography.
[14:15]
I have seen her work. She has got a really good eye
[14:23]
and is an accomplished photographer.
[14:25]
she enjoys gardening and raising chickens.
[14:26]
that, I did not know about her. She's married to her high school
[14:29]
sweetheart and together they have three children ages 18, 15,
[14:34]
and 12, and I believe they are all here.
[14:37]
2 out of 3. And I see the hubby taking the
[14:39]
photograph. Otstanding.
[14:40]
nicolle is also committed to their personal growth and
[14:43]
education. She recently earned three
[14:47]
associate degrees and is currently pursuing her
[14:50]
bachelor's degree in psychology. Nicolle's dedication to her
[14:52]
profession, commitment to her coworkers, passion for helping
[14:56]
others, and continued his pursuit of personal and
[14:58]
professional growth makes are truly deserving of this
[15:01]
recognition here today. I want to congratulate you
[15:04]
personally. I do appreciate all that you do.
[15:05]
you are a shining star, and I look forward to having more of
[15:11]
the employee of the months be much like you, dispatchers
[15:14]
deserving of it. Forward for your check and yourg
[15:18]
certificate, and if we could give nicolle a round of
[15:21]
applause. [applause]
[15:32]
[inaudible] thank you all.
[15:43]
that's the end of my presentation.
[15:44]
I also want to thank the rest of the dispatchers who came down to
[15:48]
support nicolle, and the officers in the back.
[15:51]
thank you all. At the end of my presentation.
[15:54]
>> thank you, chief. Council will join me for the
[15:59]
presentations. All right, good evening,
[16:20]
everyone. It's an honor to have this type
[16:22]
of presentation. It's new to the city council but
[16:25]
now we have our military enlistments, so we are going to
[16:27]
go ahead and invite all of them to come up individually.
[16:30]
you'll have an opportunity to speak if you'd like, shake hands
[16:33]
with council, and a group photo at the end.
[16:37]
first and foremost -- [reading name]
[16:44]
[applause] we have a certificate of
[16:47]
recognition on the occasion of your enlistment in the
[16:50]
united states army. [applause]
[17:00]
next up we have -- [reading name]
[17:07]
we have a certificate of recognition presented on the
[17:11]
occasion of your enlistment in the united states army.
[17:15]
[applause] next up --
[17:27]
[reading name] a certificate of recognition is
[17:35]
presented on the occasion of your enlistment in the
[17:37]
united states army. [applause]
[17:47]
next up -- [reading name]
[17:55]
we have a certificate of recognition presented on the
[17:58]
occasion of your enlistment in the united states army.
[18:02]
[applause] next --
[18:15]
[reading name] we have a certificate of
[18:18]
recognition presented on the occasion of your enlistment in
[18:21]
the united states army. [applause]
[18:32]
all right, and last but not least --
[18:35]
[reading name] we have a certificate of
[18:42]
recognition presented on the occasion of your enlistment in
[18:45]
the united states army. [applause]
[18:57]
all right, can we have a round of applause for all our military
[19:02]
enlistments tonight? [applause]
[19:16]
[inaudible] all right, congratulations and
[19:42]
thank you all for your service. Next up we have a proclamation.
[19:49]
we have tracy connect's day, so I'd like to invite former
[19:57]
mayor nancy young, if she'd li like.
[20:25]
tracy connects day. Whereas tracy connects is an
[20:28]
annual community event founded by former tracy mayor nancy
[20:31]
young that highlights the many wonderful opportunities tracy
[20:33]
has to offer, and whereas the purpose and vision of tracy
[20:36]
connect is to connect members of the tracy community with local
[20:41]
non-profit organizations, service organizations,
[20:43]
faith-based groups, and churches, school rograms, city
[20:46]
services, and more, bringing awareness and opportunity to
[20:49]
inspire synergy and connection between local businesses,
[20:53]
associations, organizations, and individuals in the tracy
[20:57]
community. And whereas tracy connects is
[20:59]
celebrating its sixth annual community event inviting members
[21:02]
of the community with various resources to bring awareness of
[21:05]
all the local services available at no cost to them.
[21:08]
it also allows our tracy community to connect and network
[21:11]
with one another, whereas the theme for this year's event is
[21:15]
"living your best life in tracy, bridging the digital divide,
[21:18]
youth and seniors." a portion of the proceeds
[21:21]
generated will benefit local organizations that provide help
[21:23]
and support for foster youth. Therefore be it resolved that I,
[21:28]
dan arriola, mayor of the city of tracy, and on behalf of the
[21:33]
city council proclaim september 19th, 2026, as tracy
[21:36]
connects day and encourage the tracy community to participate
[21:39]
in this annual event and get connected with the numerous
[21:42]
opportunities tracy has to off offer.
[21:52]
>> thank you, mayor arriola and council.
[21:54]
so thankful for this continuation of such a great
[21:56]
event that we have going on here in the city of tracy, in
[22:00]
partnership with the city of tracy, as well as the other
[22:05]
partners we have. As our tra mayor just read and t
[22:11]
you know, on the 19th, all you are invited.
[22:13]
I left some cards out front in the lobby.
[22:15]
you are able to pick them up as you go out.
[22:18]
this year's theme, as was said, "bridging the digital ivide for
[22:24]
youth and seniors." we are grateful that over the
[22:26]
last five previous years they have been able to get out over
[22:31]
$55,000 for beneficiaries for filling the different needs and
[22:35]
we've highlighted throughout the past.
[22:40]
it's not just a free event to come to bet everything will be
[22:46]
free. Everything we have to offer is
[22:49]
free. We have one more day for
[22:52]
sponsors and one more week for vendors.
[22:54]
if you want to sign up, non-profit, it's very
[22:59]
inexpensive and so are other vendors if they would like to
[23:01]
sign up. You can go to
[23:09]
tracyconnects.com. Thanks to my partial team, all
[23:10]
the way down to my youngest, my ganddaughter is here with us
[23:14]
today, so we are glad for all the communities that continue to
[23:17]
come together. S it will be a great event.
[23:19]
I would love to see all they are.
[23:21]
god bless you. Thank you.
[23:45]
[inaudible] >> we are taller than y'all.
[24:01]
>> just squeeze. >> we don't want the podium
[24:05]
blocking. >> okay, you guys.
[24:23]
one, two, three. [applause]
[24:31]
>> all right, that's it for our presentations today.
[24:33]
thank you, everyone. >> mayor, city manager.
[24:39]
I want to report that we've been advised that our youtube feed is
[24:42]
not currently working. We are ttempting to
[24:44]
troubleshoot it. We are asking that anyone who is
[24:47]
attempting to view this online to switch to facebook or zoom.
[24:51]
we ill also put out a notice via social media until the issue
[24:55]
is fixed, but for sb707 we have to make the announcement but we
[25:01]
can continue the meeting. >> thank you.
[25:05]
we will give folks a minute to go ahead and exit if they'd li
[25:10]
like. That brings us to the consent
[25:37]
calendar. Council, re there any items you
[25:39]
would like to pull for consent? >> I'm going to recuse myself
[25:41]
from lett 3s. >> understood.
[25:47]
>> I would like to pull 3a. >> staff, do you have any items
[25:55]
to pull? >> staff has no items to pull.
[25:59]
thank you. >> would members of the audience
[26:00]
please raise your hand if there any consent calendar items you
[26:04]
would like to pull other than lett 3kor 3s?
[26:12]
with that will entertain a motion.
[26:18]
>> motion. >> second.
[26:20]
>> we have a first and a second. Roll call, please.
[26:23]
>> yes. >> yes.
[26:29]
>> council member bedolla. >> yes.
[26:31]
>> council member nygard. >> mayor arriola.
[26:34]
>> yes. >> all right, that takes us to
[26:42]
item 3a, related to the art installations at the track.
[26:48]
staff report or a comment? >> I would like to make a quick
[26:50]
comment, mayor. Thank you.
[26:52]
I wanted noted I'm supporting all the consent items except for
[26:55]
this one. I do support the arts.
[26:57]
I love the arts and I wanted to support this.
[27:00]
we did a discussion when this item came before council some
[27:04]
months back and I requested some value engineering on this.
[27:07]
being the price tag is $600,000 for this art project, for my own
[27:11]
personal feelings it's a little too high of an expenditure for
[27:15]
an art project, so I won't be supporting at this time and
[27:18]
that's my only comment. Thank you.
[27:20]
>> understood. Do you have any preliminary
[27:24]
questions from council? Seeing none, we will go for
[27:27]
public comment. You have any members of the
[27:30]
public to speak on item 3 letter a?
[27:32]
seeing none in chambers, do they have any online?
[27:36]
>> no, mayor. >> we will close the public
[27:39]
comment for item 3a. >> I was also opposed to this
[27:44]
when it came before. Same concerns that councilmember
[27:47]
evans just voiced, and I also do not support moving forward at
[27:50]
this. >> understood.
[27:54]
thank you, mayor pro tem. At this time I will entertain a
[27:57]
motion. >> I entertain a motion to
[27:59]
approve the consent calendar, minus 3a.
[28:06]
sorry, excuse me. 3a.
[28:09]
>> I will go ahead and second that motion.
[28:12]
roll call, please. >> council member nygard.
[28:15]
>> yes. >> mayor arriola.
[28:16]
>> yes. >> council member bedolla.
[28:21]
>> no. >> council member evans.
[28:25]
>> no. >> mayor pro tem abercrombie.
[28:28]
>> no. >> at this time item 3a fails.
[28:34]
do you have any alternate motions?
[28:36]
>> I guess I can make an alternate motion that staff take
[28:39]
another look at this and bring back some value engineering for
[28:41]
this item. >> I would second that motion.
[28:46]
>> we have a first and a second. Roll call, please.
[28:49]
>> council member evans. >> yes.
[28:52]
>> mayor pro tem abercrombie. >> yes.
[28:54]
>> council member bedolla. >> yes.
[28:56]
>> council member nygard. >> yes.
[28:58]
>> mayor arriola. >> yes.
[29:03]
>> all right, this will come back for further discussion for
[29:08]
item 3a. Next up, that brings us to item
[29:13]
3f. Councilmember, I believe you
[29:16]
need to leave the dais to recuse yourself.
[29:22]
>> thank you. >> this is item 3f regarding
[29:28]
awards for the mayor's community youth support network use
[29:33]
grants. Did council need a staff report?
[29:35]
no? To be have any preliminary
[29:38]
questions? No?
[29:39]
will go out for public comment on item 3f related to the
[29:43]
mayor's community youth support network grants.
[29:47]
seeing none in hamber -- excuse me, please go ahead.
[29:50]
ith one comment we . >> thank you.
[29:56]
good evening, chamber. I just wanted to speak on behalf
[30:01]
of the youth program -- >> please speak into the
[30:03]
microphone a little bit more. >> I apologize.
[30:06]
I wanted to speak on behalf of of the tracy youth program and
[30:10]
my involvement there, because I believe it is such an important
[30:13]
part of our community. We just graduated our 30th
[30:16]
cohort today and it was a really great ceremony for five lucky
[30:22]
local youth to learn all about bike mechanics and lifelong
[30:24]
skills that I hope they take with them for decades to come.
[30:29]
so I appreciate you recognizing it as a legitimate opportunity
[30:34]
for our youth, and that we continue to invest in our youth
[30:38]
in a nontraditional program such as this.
[30:41]
that is all from me. Again, I appreciate you, and
[30:45]
have a good night. >> tank you.
[30:49]
>> next speaker, please. >> I am also one of the
[30:55]
nonprofits -- >> please pull the microphone
[30:57]
down. Can't hear you very well.
[30:59]
>> sorry about that. I am also here on behalf of one
[31:03]
of the nonprofits serving tracy for the past 25 years.
[31:07]
we were awarded some sons, we have a soccer club for the kids
[31:13]
on fridays and sundays for about four hours on fridays.
[31:17]
that includes practices, games, and also on sundays.
[31:19]
we get them uniforms and we just want to thank everybody for
[31:26]
looking into this, for looking at the youths, and we have a
[31:45]
very good experience with kids graduating and going to
[31:46]
universities and different events to keep them out of
[31:47]
trouble. Thank you.
[31:53]
>> thank you, sir. Do you have any additional
[32:01]
>> yes. Il member bedolla. >> council member nygard.
[32:06]
>> mayor arriola. >> yes.
[32:13]
item 3f passes. Can someone please ask
[32:16]
councilmember nygard to return? All right, that concludes our
[32:36]
consent calendar. At this time we have items from
[32:39]
the audience. As a reminder, this is for any
[32:42]
item that is not on tonight's agenda, and the city council is
[32:45]
limited in how we can respond pursuant to the california
[32:48]
government code. Can I please see hans raise for
[32:50]
anyone who would like to speak on an item not on tonight's
[32:55]
agenda? I counted 16, and per our public
[33:03]
comment guidelines, with 16-25 requests each speaker will get .
[33:08]
do you have any speaker cards for items from the audience?
[33:12]
>> yes, mayor. I received six speaker cards.
[33:16]
>> let's please proceed with speaker cards.
[33:19]
>> mr. Bob tanner? >> they're stopping me in the
[33:39]
streets talking about fireworks. They hear it almost every week,
[33:43]
even though it's illegal now, but for the fourth.
[33:50]
the city council needs to stop selling safe and sane, only have
[33:55]
the one fireworks you do for the city itself, and no more.
[34:02]
drones should be up almost every weekend.
[34:06]
this past weekend in my neighborhood we heard fireworks
[34:11]
from south tracy. You could tell it was in that
[34:16]
area, but you couldn't say where it was.
[34:18]
you could just hear it coming up from south tracy.
[34:23]
we just need to stop having these fireworks.
[34:27]
people are saying that this council is not listening,
[34:30]
they're not doing their job, they should be doing something
[34:32]
about it, but they are. You raised the fees, that's
[34:38]
great, but fees aren't everything.
[34:42]
you need to stop selling, as well.
[34:46]
thank you. >> thank you, mr. Tanner.
[34:47]
next speaker card, please. [reading name]
[34:59]
>> good evening, mayor and members of the council.
[35:01]
I am here on behalf of the greater stockton chamber of
[35:06]
commerce start program, standing together against all regional
[35:09]
theft. First I would like to start by
[35:11]
thanking councilmember nygard for speaking at our green team
[35:15]
of san joaquin event. Over the past two years, we have
[35:18]
grown from an innovative approach to combating retail
[35:20]
theft into an award-winning community engagement, economic
[35:23]
element, and public safety initiatives built around a
[35:25]
simple but powerful principal: businesses and residents taking
[35:30]
ownership of their community and becoming part of that solution.
[35:32]
as s.t.a.r.t. Has continued to grow throughout the region, I
[35:34]
usinesses are aware of two cy resources available and provided
[35:41]
to them at no cost. The first is our small business
[35:44]
can ead grant. We have fewer than 90 grants
[35:47]
remaining, so funding is limited and running out for that aspect.
[35:52]
qualifying businesses must be independently owned, franchises
[35:56]
qualify, a retail or commercial business having been open since
[36:00]
2020 with a storefront located here in san joaquin county.
[36:04]
the second resource is our free merchant account.
[36:07]
here businesses can create a secure account to receive any
[36:10]
reports of retail theft that might be made by their shoppers
[36:13]
on the s.t.a.r.t. App, review and organize instant information
[36:16]
as well as compiling the reports into a singular pdf document to
[36:20]
attach to their online police reports.
[36:23]
these resources are about giving businesses the tools they need
[36:26]
to take an active role in community safety and
[36:28]
strengthening the connection between businesses, residents,
[36:33]
and law enforcement. For two years s.t.a.r.t. Has
[36:35]
demonstrated what can happen when the private sector,
[36:38]
residents, law enforcement, local government, and non-profit
[36:42]
organizations all come to work together.
[36:43]
as we move into the next phase of s.t.a.r.t. When you want to
[36:46]
continue building this partnership here in tracy.
[36:49]
I strongly encourage tracy businesses to visit to create
[36:52]
their account and see if they qualify to receive th the free
[36:57]
camera grant. With fewer than 90 remaining, I
[36:59]
encourage businesses to apply while funding lasts.
[37:03]
thank you. >> next speaker card, please.
[37:06]
>> nancy rush. >> good evening.
[37:12]
I wanted to once again talk about climate change.
[37:15]
we need to update our climate change plan in the city of
[37:22]
tracy. This year we are
[37:24]
expected -- they have projected a 500-year el nino, warmer and
[37:31]
wetter, very wet. I haven't heard anything from
[37:35]
this city nor the county. The county of marin is dredging
[37:40]
creeks and advising other residents to pack their go bags
[37:43]
and make arrangements for what they will do in the event of a
[37:48]
flood. I haven't seen anything from he
[37:50]
city or the county. The county, on the 19th, the
[37:53]
same day as tracy connects, is having a "please help clean up
[37:58]
our stormwater ways." and I will be doing that while
[38:02]
you guys are having fun in the park.
[38:04]
I will clean up the trash. But it doesn't look to me like
[38:07]
it is ready. There are weeds, there's a lot
[38:11]
of stuff growing, and I have seen in past years where those
[38:14]
waterways are full. So if this is a 500-year event,
[38:20]
they might overfill. I know in the past they have had
[38:23]
floods on the outskirts of the city limits, and we have had
[38:26]
very large trees keel over on houses because the roots are so
[38:34]
soaked and the soil will no longer hold them.
[38:37]
so I would like for us to prepare and maybe have something
[38:41]
in a plan. That's it.
[38:43]
thanks. >> thank you, ms. Rush.
[38:47]
next speaker card, please. >> pat howell.
[38:59]
>> good evening, council. Pat howell.
[39:04]
I understand that we are updating our 20-year plan.
[39:07]
instead of just reviewing and tweaking this document as the
[39:11]
state requires, let's make a real commitment to a climate
[39:17]
action plan. I understand that the elements
[39:21]
of this 20-year plan includes safety policies to protect our
[39:25]
population from climate events, fire, flood, drought, water,
[39:31]
soil contamination, air quality, et cetera.
[39:32]
it is the perfect time to develop a climate action plan
[39:36]
that provides yearly goals so that budgets can be adopted to
[39:43]
support these goals. Climate action plans with the
[39:46]
purpose of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and other
[39:51]
environment or problems are recommended by the california
[39:53]
air quality board. Millions of california citizens
[39:58]
are living in towns and cities with voluntary climate action
[40:02]
plans. We live in a very dangerous
[40:05]
environment with nitrates and other contaminants used by
[40:08]
agriculture, which can be found in our water and our soil.
[40:12]
air pollution is an extremely serious problem that causes many
[40:15]
asthma emergencies a year. Our wind patterns coming through
[40:21]
ultima pass increase the dangers for wildfires.
[40:24]
also our neighbor, the lawrence -- the livermore
[40:29]
national lab, 15 miles from us, has increased their nuclear
[40:33]
weapon production and design tip ability.
[40:36]
they will meta-plutonium now available by our national
[40:40]
government and that means that plutonium and highly
[40:45]
radioactive waste will be transported over our major
[40:48]
highways that surround us. We must do better and
[40:57]
immediately do a climate action plan and improve our all-ctizen
[41:03]
disaster response plan. Thank you.
[41:05]
>> thank you, ms. Howell. Next speaker card, please.
[41:09]
>> larkin fleckner. >> good evening, mayor and
[41:25]
council members. It is nice to see you all again.
[41:28]
I recently spoke at a city council meeting asking that the
[41:31]
city move forward with an updated omprehensive climate
[41:33]
action plan. At the time it was insinuated by
[41:36]
another resident in attendance that I not be part of some
[41:40]
nefarious out of town climate organization traveling from city
[41:42]
to city to spread my insidious pro-tree messaging.
[41:45]
as intriguing as that may sound, for the record, I am not.
[41:55]
I am a proud resident of tracy. I live here with my husband and
[41:56]
two children. My parents and my little brother
[41:57]
are also longtime residents. They care deeply about our city.
[41:59]
I assure you that I would not bring something to council if I
[42:01]
did not feel it were important. With that I will move to my ask.
[42:05]
I am appreciative of you taking time to listen to the recent
[42:08]
requests for an updated climate action plan.
[42:11]
I believe that council is amiable to the idea, which is
[42:14]
awesome. However, I don't see it as a
[42:16]
topic for today's agenda. I am respectfully asking
[42:19]
city council to request that this item be agen agendized fore
[42:27]
next meeting in accordance with the protocols and rules of
[42:33]
procedure, which states that the motion maker may include a
[42:36]
specific meeting date on which the item must be brought to the
[42:39]
cty council for consideration, and such date shall prevail
[42:44]
unless the city manager provides information to explain that such
[42:47]
date is not possible either due to current workloads, staffing,
[42:51]
and/or anticipated research. Thank you for your time and
[42:54]
consideration and thank you for what you do.
[42:58]
>> thank you. Next speaker card, please.
[43:01]
>> veronica vargas. >> good afternoon, mayor,
[43:11]
city council, staff members. I has been asked, or three
[43:18]
bullet point items, for you all to consider, and I would love if
[43:22]
this council decides to bring my ask to the future discussion
[43:27]
for future consideration in a futur.
[43:31]
this is three points. First, the activation of the
[43:37]
nature park. We asked the city council direct
[43:40]
staff to bring a design and construction workflow to phase
[43:43]
one of the nature park. This should and could utilize
[43:49]
the voter approved measure b fundings, ensuring zero impact
[43:53]
to the city general fund. To ensure fiscal responsibility,
[43:59]
council should establish a firm target budget ap for phase one.
[44:06]
furthermore, the community requests that phase one design
[44:09]
prioritize immediate integration of youth structure for
[44:13]
agricultural learning opportunities, like a greenh
[44:16]
greenhouse, outdoor nature education, and an education
[44:21]
center alongside trails and utilities infrastructure for the
[44:23]
nature park. Number two, the urban forestry
[44:30]
management plan and ordinance update.
[44:31]
to protect and enhance the tracy existing green canopy, we
[44:36]
request that the city council formally adopt this plan, to
[44:43]
update the tracy tree ordinance to ensure the robust heritage
[44:47]
tree policy and enforce higher tree replacement ratios of 1:3
[44:54]
o greater for private and commercial development.
[44:57]
I'm going to leave the third item to one of the board members
[45:01]
to finish, and it is a pleasure being here this evening.
[45:04]
thank you. >> thank you, ms. Vargas.
[45:08]
next speaker card, please. >> mayor, we have no additional
[45:11]
speaker cards but I do have a speaker on line.
[45:14]
>> let's proceed with who is in chambers right now.
[45:17]
who would like to speak next? >> good evening.
[45:32]
my name is ellen mcrae. I am a lifelong resident of
[45:37]
tracy, and I would like to add my voice to veronica's in hopes
[45:40]
that you will implement -- >> ms. Mccray, could you speak
[45:45]
a little closer to the microphone?
[45:47]
thank you. >> in hope that you will
[45:50]
implement the urban forest management plan, that you will
[45:52]
begin work on the nature park, and that you can implement some
[45:58]
kind of city department to protect and expand tracy's
[46:03]
trees. Thank you.
[46:03]
>> thank you, ms. Mcrae. Next speaker, please.
[46:14]
>> good evening. My ame is cynthia eese, and I
[46:18]
am a tracy resident. I'm here today to support an
[46:20]
updated climate action plan. Residents have been asking for
[46:24]
this update dating back to 2021, and as recently as the last
[46:28]
meeting on august 18th. The lack of follow-through is
[46:33]
concerning. That is why I am asking in this
[46:35]
item be agendized for the next council meeting on septem
[46:43]
september 15th in accordance with item four dot three dot one
[46:46]
dot three of the protocols and rules of procedure.
[46:50]
that section indicates a council member can request a specific
[46:52]
gendized and the date should prevail unless the city manager
[46:59]
provides information explain why it is not possible.
[47:03]
as I have stated previously, we are contending with extreme
[47:07]
weather. There is rising heat.
[47:10]
tracy faces rising heat, more frequent triple digit summer
[47:14]
days, and updating plans protect vulnerable residents.
[47:17]
central valley water supplies are shrinking.
[47:22]
smarter water management secures future growth.
[47:25]
wildfire smoke and traffic pollution harm health.
[47:27]
better plans reduce local air risks.
[47:31]
also there is a state compliance.
[47:36]
ew laws. Plans must align with there's also grant money that
[47:39]
could be accessed, updated plans unlock these funds.
[47:44]
it also lowers utility bills, green building codes save
[47:49]
residents money. Energy efficiency drops monthly
[47:52]
costs. So I and asking you, please put
[47:56]
this on the agenda. Thank you.
[48:00]
>> thank you, ms. Reese. Next speaker, please.
[48:16]
>> good evening, mayor and council members, staff.
[48:18]
it looks like I'm part of the conspiracy here, to improve the
[48:22]
environment here in the community.
[48:23]
let me read bullet .3. I think you have a copy of it.
[48:31]
the tracy tree foundation is asking for stability for tree
[48:33]
development and wellness, to guarantee the long-term survival
[48:39]
of our urban forest. We request that the council
[48:41]
direct staff to evaluate the feasibility of establishing a
[48:46]
dedicated department or division for tree development and
[48:49]
wellness. This entity would be tasked with
[48:54]
cross-departmental coordination, working alongside public works
[48:58]
engineering and water utilities to establish strict, sustainable
[49:02]
irrigation standards. The city trees manage route and
[49:04]
sidewalk mitigation and protect public safety.
[49:12]
currently trees are taken care of by public works and the
[49:15]
recreation department, and I think it would be better if we
[49:18]
had sort of a unified central department, group, that deals
[49:26]
with that. I think we would be better
[49:30]
served as a community. That said, we are looking to
[49:34]
plant around 200 trees on october 3rd, and we are looking
[49:36]
for cooperation from the city to do that.
[49:39]
so any help would be appreciated.
[49:41]
thank you. >> thank you.
[49:43]
next speaker, please. Whoever would like to speak ne
[49:49]
next. >> good evening, mayor and
[49:56]
council, staff, ladies and gentlemen.
[49:58]
I'm just here with a request, in other ask, I guess you could
[50:04]
say. As you know september we have
[50:06]
9/11, the 25th anniversary this year.
[50:09]
I want to say on the record that I'm not asking anyone to stop
[50:13]
living or stop celebrating whatever they are, but just out
[50:15]
of respect, especially the 25th anniversary, no disrespect to
[50:19]
the staff at all, I love you guys, you worked really hard,
[50:24]
graham mcdonald is a great guy.
[50:27]
how did the city and at putting a block party on 9/11?
[50:30]
many other fridays. It could have been on any other
[50:34]
friday. It is the 25th anniversary.
[50:37]
again, I'm not saying everybody should stop living their life
[50:40]
and be sad. We are a strong and resilient
[50:42]
nation. We do get up and go.
[50:47]
but this s close to many people's heart.
[50:49]
I might be the lone wolf here when I say this, but I have been
[50:53]
hosting a 9/11 memorial event since 2002 and this is my 25th
[50:58]
year of doing it. Mayor, you have attended it.
[51:03]
mr. Evans, steve. M. Abercrombie.
[51:05]
and a couple people here have attended it.
[51:08]
veronica has attended it. So it is very
[51:11]
important -- again, please don't get me wrong, I'm not telling
[51:13]
you guys to do something from the city, but at least don't do
[51:17]
something that doesn't sound right.
[51:18]
just because you can do it doesn't mean you should do it.
[51:21]
hs many other fridays. Please, if you can, move that
[51:25]
9/11 block party on that day. I'm posting this, I have been
[51:28]
hosting it, and I never keep a penny of this money.
[51:31]
this is a self-funded event. All the money raised has been
[51:35]
given back to the tracy firefighters association and the
[51:38]
police officers association. You can ask them any time how
[51:39]
much has been given to them because I don't want to brag
[51:42]
about it. It's been over hundreds of
[51:44]
thousands. This is something close to not
[51:46]
only my heart but to a lot of people who know what this means.
[51:49]
a lot of people do know what this means.
[51:52]
I'm not saying they don't know. Would it carry something,
[51:55]
because if we forget about history, I don't want to go that
[51:58]
route, that I just want to say thank you so much for the time,
[52:01]
appreciate it. God bless you and god bless the
[52:04]
united states of america. Thank you.
[52:06]
>> thank you. Next speaker, please.
[52:10]
>> can anybody hear me? >> yes, thank you.
[52:13]
>> my name is anthony villal villalobos.
[52:17]
I wrote on this paper because I get nervous.
[52:18]
I like to blabber a lot. All right.
[52:23]
[clears throat] what independent oversight does
[52:25]
the city have to ensure that the ntm is providing the services
[52:29]
taxpayers are paying for, that the city personnel are
[52:35]
maintaining appropriate boundaries -- sorry -- with ntmd
[52:45]
that the safety and discipline of investigations and employment
[52:47]
are being applied constantly? If there's no -- you know, just
[52:55]
wondering what's going on. Just checking for the bus
[52:58]
services. That's what I'm talking about.
[53:01]
so yeah. Pretty much that's -- that's
[53:04]
what I'm talking about. >> thank you, mr. Villalobos.
[53:09]
>> you're welcome. Have a nice night.
[53:12]
>> you, too. Next speaker, please.
[53:19]
>> good evening, mr. Mayor, city council.
[53:23]
>> good evening. >> I am here to request the same
[53:26]
request that my colleague did, regarding the implementation of
[53:35]
forest management, and the nature park.
[53:43]
that's it. Very short.
[53:46]
>> thank you. Next speaker, please.
[53:52]
>> good evening, mr. Mayor. Todd lee berg.
[53:55]
two topics tonight. First one is halloween.
[53:59]
a year ago, halloween, two children were hit outside the
[54:03]
fairhaven neighborhood. To your credit, you authorized
[54:07]
construction of the streetlight. That streetlight is not yet
[54:10]
installed. There are temporary signs out
[54:11]
there, which is a positive first step.
[54:14]
that being said, you have less than eight weeks to get a
[54:17]
streetlight installed, which is probably not going to happen.
[54:19]
I'm hoping you guys can have an option b to direct traffic out
[54:24]
there if the light is not installed.
[54:28]
second topic, mr. Mayor, last week or two weeks ago you
[54:31]
announced the settlement agreement.
[54:35]
I'm cautiously optimistic that this will lead to positive
[54:40]
results, hat they eventually turn over the land without issue
[54:45]
and finally pay the $8 million. Those are long-standing and
[54:51]
overdue issues. At the same time, you announced
[54:53]
that the city will be playing some money, approximately
[54:55]
$5 million is what I'm hearing. Sutherland has a long history of
[55:03]
not honoring their legal obligations, paying the bills on
[55:07]
time. I strongly urge the city, before
[55:09]
you pay any money, make sure you have the land completely deeded
[55:15]
and you have the full $8 million.
[55:17]
don't pay before then, please. Thank you.
[55:21]
>> thank you. Next speaker, please.
[55:34]
>> good evening. Kevin toback, on the board of
[55:40]
the district and on behalf of the cemetery I would like to
[55:43]
thank the council for approving the item at the last meeting.
[55:45]
the cemetery is such a special place in this community was so
[55:50]
many of our loved ones there. It was so helpful to see that
[55:55]
the city will provide some policing to the cemetery
[55:58]
district after hours. It's unfortunate that some folks
[56:00]
just can't follow the rules and regulations of the cemetery
[56:04]
district, which are pretty standard.
[56:06]
so I just wanted let you know we are very thankful for what the
[56:09]
city is doing for the cemetery. I want to thank the police
[56:12]
department in particular, anna contrasts, and the city
[56:19]
attorney's office for working with our staff and our egal
[56:22]
counsel, and thank you very much.
[56:23]
I don't think a lot of people know this, the cemetery is 145
[56:26]
years old. There's a lot of history there.
[56:29]
it's a special place. So I wanted to thank you very
[56:31]
much for providing the assistance at the cemetery.
[56:37]
>> thank you. Next speaker, please.
[56:46]
>> good evening, city council. I'm going to talk about the
[56:53]
nature park. There is $8.5 million that has
[56:56]
been set aside. We have been waiting patiently,
[57:01]
patiently, for years, to have a beginning on the nature park.
[57:04]
now that all the money has been collected, we are asking that
[57:08]
you direct staff to start to put out bids, and that we can
[57:14]
actually begin, we can go. I also would like to see the
[57:21]
urban forestry management plan, which was accepted by the
[57:26]
council but has not yet been implemented, I would like to see
[57:32]
that began, as well. I do have to note that, if those
[57:36]
of these things are done, you are like halfway to compliance
[57:46]
on the of environmental action plan.
[57:48]
so everything ere tonight is kind of dovetailing.
[57:54]
I do appreciate your service, and thank you.
[57:57]
>> thank you. Next speaker, please.
[58:02]
seeing none -- l. Oh.
[58:14]
>> I wrote it down this week. Good evening, council.
[58:19]
I have got a rave, a ranch, and a question for you.
[58:23]
first the rave. A city staff member listened at
[58:27]
the last meeting when I brought up the pothole on grant line.
[58:29]
my wife and I have been trying to get it fixed for over a year.
[58:32]
less than a week after mentioning it here, it was
[58:38]
repaired. That is what responsiveness
[58:41]
looks like. Whoever handled this deserves
[58:44]
employee of the month. When the system works, I would
[58:47]
like to say so. Now the rant.
[58:56]
we just didn't move the homeless person out of one part to let
[59:01]
them settle in another. I reported the same woman living
[59:04]
in lincoln park for about a year.
[59:06]
I've been told they have new codes in the parks, that the
[59:08]
staff knows her, familiar faces, and that the police might police
[59:14]
need to catch her sleeping overnight, but every morning she
[59:18]
is still there. Now it looks like we are up to
[59:20]
three people living in that park.
[59:22]
I ask you, are we actually addressing homelessness in our
[59:26]
parks or are we just trying to make residents feel like
[59:28]
something is happening? Because from ground level it
[59:34]
doesn't look like progress, it looks like we are spending a lot
[59:37]
of money shuffling people around without solving anything.
[59:41]
with no homeless commission any longer, the only place that you
[59:45]
can bring this up is before you. And finally, the question.
[59:50]
the flashing light for the fire station on 11th street had a
[59:57]
burned-out lower left bulb. I noticed it weeks ago, but kept
[1:00:00]
forgetting to report it. My wife reported it late last
[1:00:09]
week, and it was fixed the next day.
[1:00:14]
that's the part that really bothers me.
[1:00:20]
why did it take a resident to report something that the city
[1:00:25]
employees -- >> your time is up.
[1:00:25]
>> I'll finish it later. >> thank you.
[1:00:31]
next speaker, please. >> I was going to rebut
[1:00:45]
everything chuck said, but it didn't take too long.
[1:00:50]
s my representative to request nd at the end of the meeting to
[1:00:54]
have the staff provide you with a report that says how
[1:01:04]
public-private partnership's work, and what are the benefits
[1:01:06]
and the advantages. I think now is a really great
[1:01:09]
opportunity, that urban forest can be about $0.30 on the dollar
[1:01:14]
with public-private, but I would like to hear their take on it.
[1:01:18]
they can't do anything if I ask them, but if you ask them that
[1:01:21]
would be helpful. The other thing is they had that
[1:01:28]
fiasco that we didn't collect enough money and we had to raise
[1:01:30]
the rates and everybody in town is upset, so to avoid that
[1:01:34]
happening to the people ho are going to replace you in ten
[1:01:38]
years when the measure b money stops, I would like to suggest
[1:01:42]
to you that you request from the city what the operational costs
[1:01:47]
are going to be of all of the new capital improvements from
[1:01:56]
measure b, how it's going to be at year 20 when there is no
[1:01:59]
revenue to support it. It will be a big number.
[1:02:02]
you won't have the budget for it.
[1:02:04]
you might be shocked, but you should ask that question ahead
[1:02:08]
of time so you can take some sort of action.
[1:02:11]
the other is, in ancient history I was on the city council one
[1:02:19]
time, and they actually presented a budget that had a
[1:02:23]
per unit cost and it. You do not have such a budget,
[1:02:28]
and unless you ask for one, you will never get one.
[1:02:31]
it is very hard to parse what is the value of the art compared to
[1:02:36]
the value of anything else if you don't know what it costs per
[1:02:43]
unit. You need to ask for that.
[1:02:44]
thank you very much. >> any additional speakers?
[1:02:52]
seeing none in chambers, do we have any online?
[1:02:58]
>> yes, mayor. We have one speaker online.
[1:03:03]
>> let's proceed. >> can you hear me?
[1:03:06]
>> yes, thank you. >> excellent, I'll just get
[1:03:09]
started. Good evening, my name is andrew.
[1:03:10]
I am accessing my opposition to the widespread use of flock
[1:03:14]
cameras in the city of tracy. I'm calling on city council to
[1:03:18]
cancel the city contract with flock it neatly and not seek an
[1:03:22]
alternative vendor. These cameras are a great threat
[1:03:23]
to our citizens' privacy and safety.
[1:03:25]
due to the nature of how the system works, I as a member of
[1:03:30]
the public have no idea whether searches are for legitimate
[1:03:32]
purposes. Just this year there was a
[1:03:35]
public records request that revealed federal agents
[1:03:39]
including I.c.e. Have been using these in violation of california
[1:03:42]
law. As it so happens, tracy pd has
[1:03:46]
no way of knowing if searches are for legitimate purposes
[1:03:49]
since they share data with 363 other police departments in
[1:03:53]
california according to their disclosure.
[1:03:55]
excuse me. This allows all those agencies
[1:04:01]
to search tracy's network of cameras th at will.
[1:04:05]
if we make it estimate that mean 360ish other agencies, let's say
[1:04:10]
a dozen officers have search credentials that each
[1:04:12]
department. The math works out to about 4300
[1:04:15]
people who can search tracy's network and track whoever they
[1:04:19]
want without a warrant. It would be really difficult to
[1:04:24]
phish and use it for criminal purposes but I digress.
[1:04:30]
I've only got 2 minutes, so much ais made about china and the
[1:04:39]
government who uses surveillance to surveilled their citizens.
[1:04:40]
let me remind you that these systems were designed by
[1:04:43]
american companies such as oracle and cisco solely for the
[1:04:48]
same systems are used in the u.s. And it is growing one city
[1:04:52]
at a time. More invasive surveillance
[1:04:55]
technology at a time. I ask everyone present, do we
[1:04:59]
truly value our freedoms or will we yield them for some perceived
[1:05:01]
short-term benefit? Visit deflocktracy.com for
[1:05:10]
more. I yield my time.
[1:05:13]
>> thank you. Next speaker, please.
[1:05:17]
no additional speakers? >> no additional speakers
[1:05:20]
online. >> thank you.
[1:05:20]
with that we will close out items from the audience.
[1:05:23]
that brings us to public hearings.
[1:05:27]
first up we have item 5a related to the development impact fee
[1:05:32]
nexus studies. Staff report, please.
[1:05:41]
>> thank you. Good evening.
[1:05:43]
my name is veronica child, from the community and economic
[1:05:46]
develop a department. This evening I'm going to give
[1:05:49]
you a presentation about our nexus studies and how they
[1:05:51]
relate to our master plans, and you're asking the city council
[1:05:55]
adopt the new nexus studies and associated development impact
[1:06:00]
fees. The city of tracy currently has
[1:06:06]
seven infrastructure master plans.
[1:06:09]
transportation, water, sewer, storm, public safety, public
[1:06:14]
facilities, and parks. This identifies the long-term
[1:06:17]
intersection needs and costs associated with the
[1:06:19]
infrastructure to support future growth.
[1:06:23]
these studies take he master plan cost data and determine new
[1:06:28]
developments fair share and establish development impact
[1:06:30]
fees to fund the future infrastructure.
[1:06:34]
development impact fees are a one-time fee under the
[1:06:37]
mitigation fee act, assembly bill 1600.
[1:06:40]
they must fund capital imprudence only.
[1:06:42]
they cannot send any maintenance, salaries, or
[1:06:46]
existing deficiencies, and this requires that we show a clear
[1:06:49]
link between the fee and the improvement, and we track those
[1:06:52]
separately by category in separate funds.
[1:06:55]
development impact fees are calculated by taking the project
[1:06:58]
costs attributed to new development and divide that by
[1:07:03]
the units of new development. The fees vary by residential or
[1:07:08]
nonresidential, and by specific infrastructure categories
[1:07:11]
associated with the seven master plan as I before.
[1:07:21]
this map of the city shows the 3c areas in the city.
[1:07:22]
the light blue is the core fee area, in the dark blue is the
[1:07:25]
master plan fee area. The nexus studies we are talking
[1:07:28]
about this evening or in the dark blue areas on that map.
[1:07:37]
in 2022 we did adopt an update to the recreation and trails
[1:07:41]
master plan and in 2024 we adopted the water and public
[1:07:46]
safety and public master plans. Since then we have been working
[1:07:49]
on these nexus studies. We have had key updates in this
[1:07:53]
time period. One of these is in line,
[1:07:56]
shifting the residential fees from the fee per nit two fee
[1:08:01]
per square foot. We have decreased our rogram
[1:08:03]
management fee from 5% to 2.5%. We have seen some increases due
[1:08:09]
to higher construction costs, updated facilities plans, and
[1:08:16]
employees per square foot. Related to parks, we have broken
[1:08:18]
up the fees into a separate fee and then they are now based on
[1:08:31]
the previous 4 acres per 1000 residents.
[1:08:34]
we have seen decreases in the water fee due to lower water
[1:08:37]
demand and the $20 million recycled water branch, nd the
[1:08:43]
capacity fee is now being charged based on usage and meter
[1:08:45]
size as opposed to acreage. In addition, we have multiple
[1:08:50]
meetings with the building industry association and various
[1:08:54]
developers to go over these fees and work with our outside
[1:08:58]
counsel to make sure we have the most fair fees to present to you
[1:09:03]
tonight. Our water fees are changing
[1:09:07]
slightly. They are actually reducing,
[1:09:09]
going from about $17,000 down to about $12,000.
[1:09:15]
they are increasing, single-family residential per
[1:09:22]
square now a little over $7 per square foot.
[1:09:27]
for public safety facilities, these are all the facilities
[1:09:31]
included in the master and being funded through the nexus study.
[1:09:39]
these total out to about $98 million in costs and the
[1:09:47]
cost is about $62 million. The safety fee is going up from
[1:09:55]
about $0.86 per square foot to $1.31 per square foot for single
[1:09:59]
family residential, and for commercial about $670 per 1000
[1:10:03]
suare feet to about $920 per 1000 square feet.
[1:10:12]
the public facilities included in the master plan are listed
[1:10:14]
here in this table. They total to about
[1:10:19]
$241 million. The maximum attributable is
[1:10:23]
about $128 million, but we are only funding about $101 million
[1:10:27]
to the impact fee program because we do have some funding
[1:10:30]
already identified. How that affects the public
[1:10:35]
facilities fee, about $1.64 per square foot and increasing to
[1:10:42]
$1.82 per square-foot. For commercial they were about
[1:10:47]
$110 going up to about $358 per thousand square feet.
[1:10:54]
these tables show comparison to other agencies, so we used a
[1:11:00]
2600 square-foot prototype for single family residential.
[1:11:03]
as you see by this chart, the tracy existing fees are in
[1:11:07]
orange, the proposed fees are in green, and neighboring cities
[1:11:11]
are in blue. So ou will see that the
[1:11:14]
proposed fees are slightly increasing overall for
[1:11:16]
single-family residential unit, and below the median line.
[1:11:21]
and then for multifamily residential you're using a 995
[1:11:25]
square foot unit as a prototype. You will see that we are just
[1:11:27]
over the median, and there is a slight decrease overall to the
[1:11:32]
impact fees from the existing to the proposed.
[1:11:40]
and then for commercial we do have our office, we are using
[1:11:47]
per 1000 square feet. The feasibility median line, and
[1:11:54]
for commercial you can see the tracy proposed fees are actually
[1:11:57]
less overall than the existing fees, and for industrial, same
[1:12:03]
situation that the tracy existing fees are higher than
[1:12:06]
what our new proposed fees are. I'm happy to answer any
[1:12:11]
questions you may have. I also have atomized it in the
[1:12:15]
audience, one of the consultants that's been working on this, and
[1:12:18]
he'll be here to help answer any questions you might have.
[1:12:22]
thank you. >> thank you.
[1:12:24]
does council have any peeling merry questions?
[1:12:27]
mayor pro tem? > thank you very much.
[1:12:29]
great report. It was one outstanding issue
[1:12:33]
that you said you had, got that resolves?
[1:12:37]
>> we did get that resolved. We had another conversation with
[1:12:41]
them and they agree with the fees as they are presented
[1:12:45]
tonight. >> thank you very much.
[1:12:46]
>> thank you. Councilmember victoria?
[1:12:56]
>> I see a presentation that the proposed fee for a single family
[1:12:57]
for 2026, it says $7.04 per square foot.
[1:12:59]
I think in the actual nexus study -- I forget the publisher,
[1:13:04]
sorry. I think it says it is $7.27.
[1:13:08]
can I ask why it's different? Which one are we adopting today?
[1:13:13]
>> we are adopting the $7.04 per square foot.
[1:13:16]
we came to an agreement with the bia to o a slight reduction to
[1:13:20]
the contingency related to the park.
[1:13:23]
>> that clarifies, thank you. Sorry, I have one more question.
[1:13:31]
for an average -- average doesn't matter, and for a new
[1:13:37]
single-family home, what is the net change in impact fees after
[1:13:40]
the water fee reductions we are seeing?
[1:13:46]
the increases and the reduct reductions?
[1:13:50]
out of all the increases and reductions they are seeing, what
[1:13:52]
is the net change for a single family home?
[1:13:56]
are fees going up? >> for a single-family home the
[1:13:59]
fees are increasing slightly. The 2600 square-foot single
[1:14:01]
family residential unit was at about $59,680 and it's going up
[1:14:08]
slightly to be $63,354. >> thank you.
[1:14:18]
>> thank you, councilmember. >> staff answered all my
[1:14:20]
questions, so thank you. >> all right, we will go out for
[1:14:26]
public comment. Would any members of the public
[1:14:27]
like to speak on item 5a related to the impact fee nexus studies?
[1:14:33]
seeing one hand, we will allow for minutes.
[1:14:39]
please proceed. >> mayor, it's a public hearing
[1:14:40]
so we should -- >> my apologies, they are going
[1:14:44]
to open the public hearing at 8:07.
[1:14:56]
>> I don't understand, do we have $20 million coming in for
[1:15:00]
the library? Because I on't need that much
[1:15:04]
to do what I need t the library, and I might not have to
[1:15:07]
beg and borrow from you guys. Is that what I'm seeing here?
[1:15:13]
that's my question. And if I could get that answered
[1:15:16]
by staff, that would be nice. Thank you.
[1:15:21]
>> thank you. Next speaker please.
[1:15:34]
>> I just have one question. When your public safety fees
[1:15:41]
comparison shows everyone going up except industrial, why is
[1:15:43]
industrial going down? They take as much ublic safety
[1:15:49]
as anywhere else. You would think that either they
[1:15:54]
stay even or they go up just like everyone else.
[1:15:58]
and that is under the public safety fee comparison sheet.
[1:16:04]
it's only a minor drop, but it is dropping, and they take as
[1:16:11]
much safety as everything else. So if you could answer that
[1:16:16]
question, that would be great. >> thank you, mr. Tanner.
[1:16:18]
do they have any additional speakers on this item?
[1:16:23]
okay, do we have any speakers on line?
[1:16:26]
>> no, mayor. No speakers online.
[1:16:28]
>> with that we will close at public comment and close the
[1:16:31]
public hearing for item 5a. Staff, I would like to get
[1:16:34]
responses to the questions related to the library fees and
[1:16:38]
public safety fees in the industrial category.
[1:16:44]
>> yes, that is correct. The cost estimate for the tracy
[1:16:47]
library is $27 million. The costs attributable to the
[1:16:52]
fee program is $20 million. So we would be collecting from
[1:16:56]
new development about $20 million to fund the library.
[1:17:01]
and for industrial, I believe the fees are going down because
[1:17:03]
the assumptions of the number of people per thousand square feet
[1:17:08]
in industrial building has gone down.
[1:17:11]
>> thank you. Do you have any additional
[1:17:14]
questions, discussion, or entertain a motion?
[1:17:17]
>> I make a motion to adopt a resolution adopting the public
[1:17:22]
facilities nexus study and associated public facilities
[1:17:25]
project list, and adopting an updated charge for the public
[1:17:30]
facility fees, adopting water capacity nexus study, adopting
[1:17:33]
updated charges for water capacity fees, adopting public
[1:17:38]
safety nexus study and associated public safety project
[1:17:42]
lists, adopting updated charges for public safety fees, adopting
[1:17:47]
park edication, and park acquisition and improvement see,
[1:17:54]
nexus study and associated park acquisition and improvement fee
[1:17:57]
project list, adopting charges and dedication requirements for
[1:18:03]
park dedication and charges for park acquisition and improvement
[1:18:09]
fee. >> second.
[1:18:10]
>> we have a first and a second. Councilmember bedolla, did you
[1:18:14]
have a comment? >> quick question, I wanted to
[1:18:16]
check in with staff. The lowering of the parks fee,
[1:18:22]
that happened kind of recently. If we improve, with staff still
[1:18:28]
say that new development is paying for their fair share of
[1:18:32]
infrastructure? >> yes, absolutely.
[1:18:36]
>> thank you. >> we have a first and a second.
[1:18:38]
roll call, please. >> mayor pro tem abercrombie.
[1:18:41]
>> yes. >> councilmember evans.
[1:18:43]
>> yes. >> councilmember bedolla.
[1:18:44]
>> yes. >> councilmember nygard.
[1:18:45]
>> yes. >> mayor arriola.
[1:18:47]
>> yes. Madam clerk, will you please
[1:18:51]
read the title of the proposed ordinance?
[1:18:58]
>> amending the tracy municipal code title 13 by amending
[1:19:04]
chapters 13.04, 13.08, and 13.12, repealing chapters 13.16
[1:19:12]
and 13.20, and adding chapters 13.37 and 13.38, updating the
[1:19:18]
development impact fees. >> motion to waive the first
[1:19:24]
reading by substitution of title and introduce the ordinance.
[1:19:28]
>> second. >> we have a first and a second.
[1:19:29]
roll call, please. >> mayor pro tem abercrombie.
[1:19:30]
>> yes. >> councilmember evans.
[1:19:32]
>> yes. >> councilmember bedolla.
[1:19:33]
>> yes. >> councilmember nygard.
[1:19:35]
>> yes. >> mayor arriola.
[1:19:36]
>> yes. All right, the impact fees past.
[1:19:42]
thank you, staff, and we look forward to new develop and
[1:19:46]
paying their share. That brings us to regular agenda
[1:19:49]
items. Item 6 letter a is related to
[1:19:52]
the cal city's annual conference.
[1:19:54]
staff report, please. >> did evening, both
[1:20:01]
city council and staff. My name is elva esquivel, the
[1:20:09]
acting city clerk. This is about the annual
[1:20:13]
conference and expo general assembly meeting.
[1:20:14]
it is scheduled for september 23rd through septembe.
[1:20:19]
as you know, cal cities advocates on important issues.
[1:20:26]
their advocacy teams work with regional field staff and
[1:20:29]
lawmakers to sponsor, draft, and support legislative and
[1:20:34]
regulatory measures that promote local decision-making and lobby
[1:20:38]
against policies that erode local control.
[1:20:42]
an important part of the annual conference and expo is the
[1:20:46]
general assembly meeting to be held on friday, september 25th.
[1:20:52]
a this meeting, cal cities membership considers and acts on
[1:20:56]
resolutions that establish cal cities policy.
[1:20:59]
in order to expedite the conduct of business at this policymaking
[1:21:03]
meeting, each city council is required to designate a voting
[1:21:07]
delegate and up to two alternates who are registered
[1:21:11]
for and attend the annual conference and general assembly
[1:21:15]
meeting. A voting card will be given to
[1:21:17]
the city official designated on the voting delegate form.
[1:21:22]
cal cities has requested to receive the names of the
[1:21:25]
delegates prior to attendance at the conference.
[1:21:30]
as council is aware, the cal cities annual conference
[1:21:35]
resolutions process is one way that the city officials can
[1:21:37]
directly participate in the development of cal cities
[1:21:39]
policy. The deadline to submit
[1:21:42]
resolutions this year was july 25th.
[1:21:47]
this year cal cities has reported receiving one
[1:21:49]
resolution to be considered at the general assembly meeting in
[1:21:53]
advance. Attachment b of the staff report
[1:21:55]
contained the general resolution submitted by the city of
[1:22:01]
marietta and eight letters of concurrence for the city of
[1:22:05]
murrietta submission, and the general resolution text and its
[1:22:10]
implications. The general resolution and cal
[1:22:14]
cities analysis site multiple laws passed by the state
[1:22:18]
legislature, mandating various restrictions or reporting
[1:22:22]
requirements upon local agencies and elected officials.
[1:22:27]
however, these laws included exclusions for the state
[1:22:29]
legislature and for state agencies.
[1:22:33]
he city supports policit promote local authority and
[1:22:35]
flexibility for local governments to be responsive and
[1:22:40]
transparent to their constituencies.
[1:22:43]
the city policies also do not support unfunded mandates which
[1:22:45]
are often imposed on the cities not on the state.
[1:22:50]
however, it is not clear what impact this resolution would
[1:22:54]
have on influencing the state legislature.
[1:22:57]
there is no anticipated fiscal impact associated with this
[1:23:01]
action and this agenda item supports governance strategic
[1:23:05]
goal number one to model good government, governance,
[1:23:10]
teamwork, and transparency. Staff recommends that the
[1:23:12]
city council take the following actions this evening with regard
[1:23:15]
to the league of california cities 2026 annual conference
[1:23:19]
and expo general assembly meeting.
[1:23:24]
first, by motion, designate a voting delegate and up to two
[1:23:27]
alternate voting delegates for the league of california cities
[1:23:29]
2026 annual conference. Second, discuss general
[1:23:35]
resolution number 1 and determined by motion how to
[1:23:38]
authorize the appointed delegate to.
[1:23:43]
third, to adopt a resolution designating the voting delegate
[1:23:45]
and up to two alternate voting delegates selected in the prior
[1:23:51]
action for the 2026 annual conference and expo
[1:23:54]
general assembly meeting. This concludes my report and
[1:23:56]
staff is available for questi questions.
[1:24:01]
>> quick question, who from council will be attending the
[1:24:04]
conference? >> you are the only
[1:24:06]
myself, sara castro, arturo sanchez, our legislative anal
[1:24:20]
analyst, and the city attorney and daniel green, the assistant
[1:24:24]
city ttorney. >> thank you.
[1:24:29]
do you have any preliminary questions?
[1:24:34]
>> thank you. Is it possible for council
[1:24:36]
embers to sign up to go or is it closed off?
[1:24:40]
>> I would have to check. But it usually does -- we can
[1:24:43]
check for you. >> are you interested if it's
[1:24:49]
available? >> I have something to change.
[1:24:51]
>> anybody else? Okay.
[1:24:58]
just for my questions, with regard to the general resolu
[1:25:02]
resolution, I just want to confirm that our city policy is
[1:25:04]
such that we would be supporting local control, opposing unfunded
[1:25:10]
mandates and anything in which the legislature has excluded
[1:25:14]
from requirements placed upon local governments.
[1:25:18]
his head in with our olicies? >> arturo sanchez, city manager.
[1:25:25]
those three items as described by the mayor ended the
[1:25:27]
resolution would be consistent wth our local policies, yes,
[1:25:31]
sir. >> thank you, mr. Sanchez.
[1:25:32]
that is also what I would be proposing that we support.
[1:25:37]
will got to the public for this item, 6a related to the
[1:25:41]
cal cities annual conference. Are there any members of the
[1:25:43]
public would like to speak on item 6a?
[1:25:47]
seeing that in chambers, do you have any on the line?
[1:25:50]
>> no speakers online. >> with that will close out
[1:25:54]
public comment for item 6a. You're welcome to join, as well.
[1:26:05]
my only concern is that I have a 2:00 p.m. Flight and sometimes
[1:26:11]
these resolutions begin around noon.
[1:26:13]
sometimes they run late. Can staff to have been if become
[1:26:22]
unavailable? >> we have later flights so if
[1:26:25]
you would like to designate us as an alternate.
[1:26:32]
>> I moved to designate myself as a voting delegate, and if
[1:26:39]
councilmember bedolla has a delegate or her designee is a
[1:26:43]
second delegate for the annual conference.
[1:26:51]
>> I have a second from councilmember evans.
[1:26:54]
is that okay with you? >> I believe we can resolve the
[1:26:57]
issue whether or not there is space for councilmember bedolla
[1:27:01]
probably by tomorrow. To be can turn in the
[1:27:02]
appropriate names in that. >> we have a first and a second
[1:27:08]
roll call, please. >> mayor arriola.
[1:27:12]
>> yes. >> councilmember evans.
[1:27:13]
>> yes. >> councilmember bedolla.
[1:27:15]
>> yes. >> councilmember nygard.
[1:27:16]
>> yes. >> mayor pro tem abercrombie.
[1:27:18]
>> yes. >> thank you.
[1:27:23]
was there any council opposition to the policies I briefly
[1:27:26]
discussed with staff earlier? With that I would move my motion
[1:27:30]
to authorize whichever appointed delegate to vote under the
[1:27:35]
conditions of supporting local control opposing unfunded
[1:27:39]
mandates, opposing anything in which state legislature is
[1:27:42]
excluded from the authority of local government.
[1:27:45]
>> second. >> we have a first and a second
[1:27:46]
roll call, please. >> mayor arriola.
[1:27:48]
>> yes. >> mayor pro tem abercrombie.
[1:27:50]
>> yes. >> councilmember bedolla.
[1:27:51]
>> yes. >> councilmember evans.
[1:27:53]
>> yes. >> councilmember nygard.
[1:27:56]
>> yes. >> thank you.
[1:28:04]
and is the third motion separate than the first motion?
[1:28:09]
I would move to adopt a resolution, with the previously
[1:28:15]
designated voting delegates as the alternate voting delegates
[1:28:18]
to the league of california cities annual conference.
[1:28:21]
>> second. >> we have a first and a second
[1:28:22]
roll call, please. >> mayor arriola.
[1:28:24]
>> yes. >> mayor pro tem abercrombie.
[1:28:26]
>> yes. >> councilmember bedolla.
[1:28:27]
>> yes. >> councilmember evans.
[1:28:28]
>> yes. >> councilmember nygard.
[1:28:30]
>> yes. >> all right, the item passes.
[1:28:36]
thank you to everyone. I look forward to seeing you all
[1:28:38]
at the annual conference. That brings us to item 6b
[1:28:44]
regarding council compensation. Staff report, please.
[1:28:49]
>> thank you, mayor and council. May I have the powerpoint,
[1:28:53]
please? Thank you.
[1:29:07]
sara castro, assistant city manager presenting this item for
[1:29:11]
you tonight. The item before you is a routine
[1:29:12]
item that we bring every other year.
[1:29:16]
a little bit of background on the city council and treasurers
[1:29:20]
compensation, the city council code of conduct states that the
[1:29:24]
mayor and council salaries should be reviewed every two
[1:29:28]
years, and the treasury salary is at the same time.
[1:29:35]
we follow the approved compensation increases to go
[1:29:38]
into effect for our next mayor and council.
[1:29:41]
in this case, any approved compensation increase would go
[1:29:45]
into effect january 1 of 2027. Current salaries are set by
[1:29:52]
ordinance 1351 on october the 15th of 2024.
[1:30:02]
all of those became effective january 1, 2025.
[1:30:07]
the chart below shows the current salaries for mayor,
[1:30:11]
council members, and treasurer. >> I'm going to briefly go over
[1:30:17]
some rules around council compensation.
[1:30:19]
this is set by ordinance. There were some amendments to
[1:30:26]
the government code 36516 around the compensation.
[1:30:32]
it's based upon population size. The city of tracy falls into the
[1:30:36]
range of over 75 but up to and including 150,000 in population,
[1:30:41]
which allows for a maximum compensation of $1900 per
[1:30:46]
month. That same government code
[1:30:48]
section also allows for an additional maximum of $150 per
[1:30:52]
month for each commission, committee, board, or similar
[1:30:57]
authority. It also authorizes compensation
[1:30:58]
in addition to the base for the mayor also approved by ordinance
[1:31:04]
and that is currently set at $200.
[1:31:06]
further increases to compensation can be allowed by
[1:31:12]
either one of the following, 5%, up to 5% for each calendar year
[1:31:16]
from the date of the last increase, or an amount that is
[1:31:21]
equal to cumulative inflation since january 1 of 2024, based
[1:31:26]
on the consumer price index for california.
[1:31:30]
it cannot exceed 10% for each calendar year.
[1:31:31]
we have done the calculation on this and the cumulative increase
[1:31:38]
would be 7.75%. Some other quick rules around
[1:31:42]
the city treasurers compensa compensation, this is set up
[1:31:46]
differently. This is set by council
[1:31:49]
resolution and the government code does not set a maximum
[1:31:52]
monthly compensation for elected city treasurers.
[1:31:55]
this allows the city council the discussion on the amount of
[1:31:59]
salary for treasurer. Although the salary has
[1:32:01]
historically been set to align the city council.
[1:32:05]
taking a quick look at the maximum allowable salary
[1:32:11]
increase, the left side hows the current salaries it became
[1:32:15]
effective january 1, 2025. $1900 for the city council,
[1:32:20]
$2100 for the ayor, in $1900 for the city treasurer.
[1:32:25]
using the maximum allowable increase from the information I
[1:32:28]
shared on the slide before would allow up to 5% per calendar
[1:32:35]
year, showing the amount for each year would take that
[1:32:41]
maximum allowable increase of salary up to $2090 for
[1:32:47]
city council and $2290 for the mayor.
[1:32:50]
and there's no percentage applicable to the city
[1:32:52]
treasurer. When we look at the total
[1:32:56]
increase, that would ake city council up to 25,080
[1:33:02]
annually and the married $27,480 annually if council were to
[1:33:07]
choose to amend the salaries to the maximum.
[1:33:12]
so with this item I am requesting some direction from
[1:33:17]
the council. Should we amend the mayor and
[1:33:19]
city council monthly salary? If so, by what amount up to the
[1:33:26]
maximum allowable of 10%? And also should the city
[1:33:29]
treasurer monthly salary be increased, and if so, what
[1:33:35]
amount? And if council provides
[1:33:37]
direction on that salary increase, staff will return with
[1:33:40]
the ordinance and the resolutions appropriate at a
[1:33:42]
future meeting date, and again any salary increase would become
[1:33:47]
effective january 12027. This concludes my staff report.
[1:33:53]
thank you. >> did he have any preliminary
[1:33:56]
questions? >> just to confirm, although we
[1:34:00]
are allowed, we do not get any eight -- I just want to make it
[1:34:08]
clear, we don't get compensation for the commissions we serve on?
[1:34:12]
>> that is correct. It's just a monthly salary.
[1:34:15]
>> right. Secondly, if we don't do
[1:34:18]
anything, we can vote tonight to say we just want to stay where
[1:34:22]
we're at and next time you don't have to bring anything back.
[1:34:25]
>> you are correct. >> thank you.
[1:34:30]
>> any questions on the side? I wanted to confirm, have we
[1:34:38]
calculated with the total annual salary would be for the second
[1:34:44]
compensation category for cumulative inflation?
[1:34:51]
>> on the cumulative inflation, that would be 7.75%.
[1:34:57]
>> do you have umbers or based on the percentage?
[1:35:02]
>> I did the calculation probably last month.
[1:35:07]
>> understood. That answers our questions.
[1:35:09]
I'm going to go out for public comment on this item.
[1:35:12]
would anyone like to speak on item 6b?
[1:35:17]
I see three hands. We will allow 4 minutes for
[1:35:19]
whoever would like to start. >> I want to take this time to
[1:35:33]
thank all of you for the job that you do.
[1:35:37]
I'm very impressed with the fact that you always make sure that
[1:35:40]
we are on budget, and I believe in budgets, and I believed in
[1:35:46]
responsibility. But I also believe in paying for
[1:35:48]
what you get, and that I personally would prefer that you
[1:35:55]
take the maximum increase. I think you deserve it, nd I
[1:35:58]
think that's what we should do. Thank you.
[1:36:03]
>> thank you. Next speaker, please.
[1:36:16]
>> I'm not sure what you're getting paid for now as it is.
[1:36:21]
in '24, when I asked the question what city council does,
[1:36:26]
where's the grants, nancy young came unglued and was going all
[1:36:28]
over the place. They finally provided, after
[1:36:32]
several meetings, a list of all grants that the city receives,
[1:36:39]
both the city, fire, and police. Both fire and police have their
[1:36:43]
own grant writers. I don't know what the city has,
[1:36:47]
I assume they do. But if the city council is
[1:36:50]
earning their money, they would find where the grants are and
[1:36:53]
start suggesting that the city apply for them.
[1:36:56]
but I haven't heard of anything of what you guys are doing.
[1:37:00]
so I would think that salary should be flat and you can't
[1:37:09]
touch it until after the elections.
[1:37:13]
so whatever is in '26 is really going to help.
[1:37:17]
but some of you are going to be gone one way or another.
[1:37:23]
what are you guys doing? What grants are you providing
[1:37:27]
the city to try and get? I would like to see a list of
[1:37:34]
any and all grants that the city has obtained or is in the
[1:37:40]
process of obtaining. That would show what the worth
[1:37:45]
is of the city council along with everything else going on.
[1:37:48]
but we haven't seen it since '24.
[1:37:54]
no one is telling us what's going on.
[1:37:57]
every once in while the police get a grant for flock or
[1:38:00]
something else and we know that's happening, or the fire
[1:38:03]
department get something that their ambulance, we know that's
[1:38:07]
happening. But what's happening with the
[1:38:10]
city? What kind of grants are they
[1:38:11]
trying to get a hold of and what have they obtained?
[1:38:15]
haven't heard. Start earning your money.
[1:38:22]
>> thank you, mr. Tanner. Next speaker, please.
[1:38:39]
>> I think everybody deserves a raise, but the government's
[1:38:47]
stepped forward and said that the senior citizens that are on
[1:38:53]
social security get this little raise and then everybody else is
[1:38:58]
entitled to this big raise. Let's start a movement right
[1:39:03]
here and let's lock the city council rate into the exact
[1:39:10]
same saying that social security gets.
[1:39:13]
I think that would be fair. And maybe if you start that,
[1:39:18]
then another city would do it, and we have this big movement
[1:39:24]
and government will actually perform better because they need
[1:39:30]
to make the economics work so they can get there bigger
[1:39:38]
raises. If we lock it to something that
[1:39:40]
is already there, it might work. So I'm telling you, lock your
[1:39:45]
raise to 3% for this year. That's where mine was locked.
[1:39:50]
thank you. >> thank you.
[1:39:52]
next speaker. >> hello again.
[1:40:07]
I'm not great at winging it, but this -- this sounds like an
[1:40:13]
awkward one for you guys to vote on.
[1:40:16]
sorry. I just want to make an
[1:40:18]
observation, which is I am a longtime worker, I just started
[1:40:21]
coming in person, but I've watched a lot of city council
[1:40:24]
meetings over the years and I feel like you all had been doing
[1:40:27]
a better job working together. When I walk downtown ic change
[1:40:31]
and I see you in the community, and I'm sure there's things
[1:40:34]
behind the scenes that you guys could be working more
[1:40:38]
collaboratively on. So I guess if you do vote this
[1:40:42]
in, just use it as your incentive to make sure you are
[1:40:48]
getting those potholes filled, take care of them feral cats,
[1:40:52]
what are the people bring to you, climate action plan.
[1:40:54]
keep up the good work. Do more and do what you feel is
[1:41:00]
right. Thanks.
[1:41:03]
>> thank you. Do you have any additional
[1:41:04]
speakers on this item? Seeing nine in chambers, do you
[1:41:08]
have any online? >> no speakers online.
[1:41:11]
speak a little close public comment for item 6b and return
[1:41:16]
to council for discussion or entertain a motion.
[1:41:24]
council member evans? >> thank you, mayor.
[1:41:25]
I posed a raise two years ago and I'm going to oppose this
[1:41:29]
one. I like the idea of public
[1:41:31]
service being to represent the best interest of the community,
[1:41:34]
and I understand the arguments against that, but in the end I
[1:41:37]
don't want our constituents thinking that is why we are
[1:41:42]
here. I also really don't like the
[1:41:44]
idea of anybody being able to give themselves a raise.
[1:41:48]
it seems inherently wrong. In addition, money is finite,
[1:41:51]
the city only has so much, is only so much to go around.
[1:41:54]
whatever we take doesn't go into the roads, it doesn't go into
[1:41:57]
fixing the potholes or the parks, it doesn't go into public
[1:42:02]
safety. I'm just going to say I'm
[1:42:04]
opposed to any pay raises. Thank you.
[1:42:09]
>> thank you. Councilmember nygard?
[1:42:11]
>> thank you, mayor. I'm kind of neutral on this.
[1:42:13]
I didn't run for this position for money, either, but I will go
[1:42:17]
with the consensus of the dais because I do want to make sure
[1:42:23]
that we all feel we do hold some value up here.
[1:42:30]
I commend all of us this last 18 months, the collaboration we
[1:42:36]
have been able to have on this dais and the work you've been
[1:42:41]
able to accomplish, and I look forward to many more months
[1:42:45]
ahead. Thank you.
[1:42:48]
>> thank you, councilmember nygard.
[1:42:50]
>> thank you. I've supported what I call
[1:42:53]
correcting compensation two years ago.
[1:42:54]
I think it's currently fair. But going forward I think it'll
[1:42:57]
be a good idea to think about tying t to something objectives
[1:43:02]
like social security. Thank you.
[1:43:07]
>> mayor pro tem? >> as I previously stated, I
[1:43:10]
don't support -- I didn't sign up to et paid and I'm fine with
[1:43:12]
what I'm getting compensated with.
[1:43:15]
thank you. >> thank you.
[1:43:17]
as for my comments, I would be consistent with what I've said
[1:43:20]
in the past. I want to make sure we are
[1:43:23]
reducing barriers to articipate in local governance and I would
[1:43:35]
council, not for this one. We don't know who will be
[1:43:36]
sitting in the seats, so I would generally support some moderate
[1:43:42]
raise. I want to confirm, with regards
[1:43:44]
to the compensation category for cumulative inflation,
[1:43:50]
essentially the cola adjustm adjustments, ms. Castro, do you
[1:43:53]
have an answer for that? >> I believe the intent behind
[1:43:58]
this is to keep inflation at more of an inflationary
[1:44:02]
increase. But when you look cumulatively,
[1:44:08]
for two years, typically a lot of the cost-of-living increases,
[1:44:11]
as was entioned, are usually in the 3-4% range, that we are
[1:44:15]
looking cumulatively over that time, not just one 3% increase,
[1:44:21]
if that makes sense. It's a cumulative amount of
[1:44:25]
cost-of-living increase for two years.
[1:44:28]
>> just to confirm, 7.75% over two years?
[1:44:33]
>> that's right. >> okay.
[1:44:35]
with that, and similar to what councilmember bedolla was
[1:44:39]
saying, I would be comfortable attaching it with something, I
[1:44:41]
think would be fair to attach it to cola.
[1:44:45]
so I will go with the consensus as well, that I would be
[1:44:49]
supporting attaching it to a cumulative inflation basis.
[1:44:56]
any additional comment? Council member evans?
[1:44:59]
>> just thinking it through. I'm not opposed to the idea.
[1:45:02]
I'm opposed to an increase at this time.
[1:45:05]
the last increase percentagewise was very high.
[1:45:11]
I can't remember, somewhere in the neighborhood of 79-80%,
[1:45:14]
something like that. I don't mind that idea of
[1:45:20]
attaching it to something like cpi, because theoretically that
[1:45:24]
takes it out of ur hands, and that is one thing I stated that
[1:45:28]
I've never been comfortable with that idea of us giving ourselves
[1:45:33]
raises. So I guess if we attach it to
[1:45:35]
cpi, that would be -- is there a way to lock it in and keep that?
[1:45:44]
>> unfortunately no. It'll come back every two years
[1:45:46]
to have a discussion. >> for me, I think in the future
[1:45:55]
that would make sense. I think it's a good idea.
[1:45:59]
for me the salary is a little high for my taste.
[1:46:01]
I would say maybe in the future at some point I could support
[1:46:06]
it. >> this is for an informational
[1:46:10]
update, asking for a motion for direction today.
[1:46:13]
>> I'm seeking direction. If action were to be taken, it
[1:46:16]
would need to be taken with this council with the intent of
[1:46:21]
taking effect for the next council.
[1:46:22]
>> so you eed a specific motion team asked.
[1:46:26]
>> if possible, yes. >> if I made a motion to not be
[1:46:30]
one, that's what I would do right now.
[1:46:32]
would make a motion that we maintain the current salary as
[1:46:36]
they are. >> I would second that.
[1:46:41]
>> we have a irst and second. Roll call, please.
[1:46:46]
>> mayor pro tem abercrombie. >> yes.
[1:46:48]
>> councilmember bedolla. >> yes.
[1:46:49]
>> councilmember evans. >> yes.
[1:46:50]
>> councilmember nygard. >> yes.
[1:46:51]
>> mayor arriola. >> yes.
[1:46:57]
>> so that takes care of council compensation and that takes care
[1:47:01]
of our regular items. At this point we have items from
[1:47:04]
the audience. Would any members of the public
[1:47:06]
like to speak on an item not on tonight's agenda?
[1:47:15]
the time is yours. We will allow 4 minutes.
[1:47:31]
>> and finally I have the question.
[1:47:34]
the flashing warning light at the fire station on 11th street
[1:47:37]
had burned out, the lower left bulb.
[1:47:42]
I noticed it several weeks ago. My wife reported it and it was
[1:47:48]
fixed the next day. So obviously somebody thought
[1:47:52]
that it was something that needed to be fixed right away.
[1:47:54]
but the part that bothers me, why did it take a resident to
[1:48:03]
report his? Doesn't city employees and
[1:48:06]
police officers drive past it every day?
[1:48:09]
so here's my question: are they not allowed to use 11th street?
[1:48:13]
because every vehicle has a radio and it.
[1:48:16]
it will be a very simple thing to call up and say, hey, I
[1:48:22]
noticed this light is out, and it would've been taken care of
[1:48:25]
right away. No employee of the month for
[1:48:27]
this group of people. I would like to celebrate the
[1:48:32]
staff that responds quickly, and let's be honest, it's not
[1:48:37]
working in our parks, so let's empower where required the city
[1:48:47]
employees to look for safety issues while they are working
[1:48:50]
and report them. Tracy city residents shouldn't
[1:48:54]
be the only ones reporting things.
[1:49:00]
and I would just like to say, as a city council, I think you guys
[1:49:07]
are great. I have watched some other
[1:49:11]
meetings online for other city councils and stuff, and there's
[1:49:16]
bickering, and we had bickering before, but you guys generally
[1:49:22]
take care of your business and listen to what people say, and
[1:49:27]
you should be appreciated by this town.
[1:49:32]
in my little blogs and stuff, I hope I haven't offended any of
[1:49:36]
you, but I try to put it out to where we actually see what's
[1:49:46]
happening, and that the city council does get credit for
[1:49:48]
what they're doing. So I thank you for your jobs.
[1:49:52]
>> thank you. Next speaker.
[1:50:04]
seeing none in chambers, do you have any online?
[1:50:05]
>> no speakers on line. >> with that I will close out
[1:50:07]
items from the audience. That brings us to staff items.
[1:50:11]
>> good evening, city manager. I just have a couple of
[1:50:14]
announcements that went out over these last few weeks.
[1:50:16]
you may have seen sara castro has been selected to sell our
[1:50:21]
second assistant city manager role.
[1:50:26]
while she is new to the position, he is not new to the
[1:50:29]
ity. She's been in a couple of other
[1:50:32]
roles. Primarily senior and finance,
[1:50:34]
and she's in the finance director since 2022, and the
[1:50:38]
finance budget officer? Accounting manager prior to
[1:50:42]
that. She's got over 20 years of
[1:50:46]
experience in california local governments and we are excited
[1:50:50]
to welcome her upstairs to be part of our team.
[1:51:03]
timely, mr. Tanner, I'm glad he still here.
[1:51:04]
yesterday the text for assembly bill 113, the budget committee
[1:51:05]
bill, was released and it includes $5 million in proposed
[1:51:07]
funding for the city of tracy, this is for the state.
[1:51:10]
this includes $2 million for climate adapter tree planting,
[1:51:14]
$1 million for improved expansion of animal shelter and
[1:51:16]
for the police department to update its communication
[1:51:18]
systems. Some of these things were
[1:51:20]
projects that you also saw at our legislative -- during our
[1:51:25]
legislative trip to washington, d.c., as also we
[1:51:28]
were stomping behind the scenes. The state budget has not yet
[1:51:35]
been awarded, but these would be a significant investment in our
[1:51:37]
community and we are very pleased to see tracy included in
[1:51:41]
these proposals. That's $5 million that we are
[1:51:44]
looking to hopefully be awarded in the coming months.
[1:51:46]
also I wanted to announce that we do currently has recruitment
[1:51:51]
open for our environmental sustainability community.
[1:51:54]
have a couple of vacant positions we are trying to for
[1:51:57]
that. If you know anybody wants to get
[1:51:59]
involved and be a part of it, please go to our website and you
[1:52:03]
will see the application and the process they are.
[1:52:09]
some updates at gretchen talley park, I don't know if you seen
[1:52:13]
the social media updates, it is pretty impressive, the phase
[1:52:17]
that is getting ready to come oline.
[1:52:19]
we completed some light testing at the park and excited to share
[1:52:22]
we are still on track for a fall opening.
[1:52:26]
it will feature four lighted pickleball courts, tennis
[1:52:30]
courts, and basketball courts giving our communities even more
[1:52:32]
opportunities to get outside and play.
[1:52:34]
it should come online as daylight savings time is going
[1:52:37]
into effect, and it will be getting darker earlier so we are
[1:52:42]
excited to announce it is opening in the fall.
[1:52:44]
sprouts farmers' market is having its grand opening this
[1:52:48]
friday at 6:45 a.m., so good to see a lot of you bright and
[1:52:53]
early. This is a great addition and we
[1:52:56]
know that many residents is whas wellare looking forward tom
[1:53:02]
opening their doors. That's all the announcements I
[1:53:05]
have for this evening. >> thank you.
[1:53:07]
that brings us to council items. You have any council items on
[1:53:11]
the side? Mayor pro tem?
[1:53:14]
>> I would like to get support for bringing back the nature
[1:53:17]
park just to get a better understanding of how many phases
[1:53:22]
we are talking about, the bandwidth available to move
[1:53:26]
forward with that, what the overall costs are, just some
[1:53:34]
more -- I was unfortunately -- I thought when I saw it,
[1:53:38]
$8 million, I thought that covered the whole nature park.
[1:53:40]
I later found out that was just phase one.
[1:53:44]
sophie could get something done that clarification on
[1:53:49]
so if wecould get clarification, and if we have the track going e
[1:53:55]
staffing available to do that?
[1:53:57]
>> I will support that. >> and I will take a third on
[1:54:00]
that. >> so you want an update on the
[1:54:04]
nature park project? >> right.
[1:54:08]
how many phases we are talking about, the cost, do we have the
[1:54:12]
availability to move forward with essays one right now
[1:54:14]
because of staffing, all the other things they are doing,
[1:54:18]
more of an update, yes. Thank you.
[1:54:22]
>> councilmember bedolla? >> I want to add that the
[1:54:29]
climate adaptive treeplanting request is really good news for
[1:54:32]
tracy. I work directly with the ffice
[1:54:36]
on the city's two million-dollar requests I'm very glad to see
[1:54:38]
the full request included in the state budget bill.
[1:54:41]
there is still a process to finish, but this is exactly the
[1:54:44]
kind of outside funding we should be working with.
[1:54:48]
thank you. >> councilmember evans?
[1:54:51]
>> I wanted to bring it to staff and make a request.
[1:54:58]
mr. Dobie mentioned multiple people living in lincoln park
[1:55:00]
and that he's been requesting us to look at that for over a year.
[1:55:04]
given the amount of progress and effort that we have put into
[1:55:10]
ensuring that our parks are clean and safe, I want to
[1:55:13]
understand the full extent of what's going on.
[1:55:15]
I can take some time and walk out there with tracy pdf that's
[1:55:20]
what it takes. But I want to really understand,
[1:55:23]
we put a lot of effort into the park ordinance, spent a lot of
[1:55:27]
money and a lot of the public's money on a shelter, so I need to
[1:55:32]
understand, if that's happening, why it's appening, and what our
[1:55:35]
next steps are. I want to solution.
[1:55:43]
want a solution. It could be a staff report
[1:55:47]
brought to the council, or I would like to request time with
[1:55:50]
pd on site. >> I'm good with whatever
[1:55:53]
version it takes. >> I will support that.
[1:55:56]
>> thank you. Was that clear or does staff
[1:55:58]
need more? Under the constituent mentioned
[1:56:07]
halloween approaching and the intersection where the accident
[1:56:10]
occurred at val pico and tracy boulevard.
[1:56:16]
do we have something temporary coming for the halloween crowds
[1:56:18]
we are going to see out there? If this needs to be taken to a
[1:56:26]
report off-line, that's fine, too.
[1:56:28]
but I would like some comfort level.
[1:56:31]
>> councilmember evans, I would like to say there is an event
[1:56:35]
being planned, but I don't know if we have anybody from parks or
[1:56:40]
pd that is here. If not, I can provide an update
[1:56:43]
before halloween to make sure we know -- but I know that the
[1:56:48]
single light will not be installed before this october.
[1:56:53]
but I believe the light pole has been ordered, the design has
[1:56:55]
been done and the funding has been provided.
[1:56:59]
it's just the timing. >> I think the concern is what's
[1:57:01]
going to be done on a temporary basis for halloween.
[1:57:02]
I'm sure my colleagues would like that update as well.
[1:57:06]
if you could make that for all of us, I appreciate that.
[1:57:09]
other than that, had a great time at the veterans breakfast
[1:57:12]
on saturday. Lots of great events around the
[1:57:14]
city. There was a car show, so
[1:57:17]
hopefully folks are getting out there and enjoying all the great
[1:57:23]
things, concerts in the park, a lot of great things happening.
[1:57:25]
thanks, everybody. Have a great night.
[1:57:30]
>> councilmember nygard? >> thank you, mayor.
[1:57:32]
I would like to address the urban forest management plan.
[1:57:37]
I was on the environmental commission back in october of
[1:57:43]
2023 and this was actually approved at the commission.
[1:57:46]
I do not believe it has come back to staff, so I would like
[1:57:52]
to see if we could have it returned, support to have that
[1:58:00]
bought back, and to have the presentation so this council
[1:58:04]
will know what the urban forest management plan actually
[1:58:09]
curtails. >> I'll second that.
[1:58:13]
>> I will third. >> thank you very much.
[1:58:15]
also I just wanted to -- I attended this weekend the car
[1:58:21]
show. Congratulations to the
[1:58:21]
organizers of that event. Great attendance.
[1:58:26]
it was just packed. It was exciting to see the
[1:58:34]
festival flair come back. Everybody downtown, beautiful
[1:58:41]
weather, lots of families. Congratulations and kudos to the
[1:58:43]
organizers who put in for that. I want to bring an important
[1:58:48]
issue that is still prominent in our downtown streets as well as
[1:58:52]
I the city of tracy. I would really like to have a
[1:58:55]
consensus to have it brought back for discussion about our
[1:59:00]
electric bikes and scooters on our city streets.
[1:59:02]
I think it is time to just have a presentation maybe from pd and
[1:59:09]
what exactly are some of the dnv traffic rules in regards to the
[1:59:16]
evolving state of these electric cycles, because they are going
[1:59:18]
from bikes now to mopeds to even more powerful electric bikes.
[1:59:26]
actually, motorcycles. But a very continued use f our
[1:59:35]
sidewalks, and I feel that is an incredibly unsafe use of our
[1:59:40]
streets. So I would like to see if I
[1:59:42]
could have consensus to have this brought back as a
[1:59:45]
discussion item for street safety.
[1:59:50]
>> I'll second. >> third.
[1:59:52]
>> also, one of the items that we had in our consent calendar
[1:59:55]
was about stormwater basins, and I would really love to see if we
[2:00:00]
could bring this item back for discussion on how we could
[2:00:04]
actually have a discussion on, one, more multi-use of our storm
[2:00:13]
basins, possibly recreation areas, but more importantly how
[2:00:16]
we can capture that stormwater, possibly for maybe our purple
[2:00:22]
pipe. I think it would be a good
[2:00:27]
discussion to see what we could do to improve the use of our
[2:00:29]
storm basins. >> second.
[2:00:34]
>> third. >> thank you very much.
[2:00:39]
last, I loves interfaith and the diligent work they do to help
[2:00:46]
meet the food need in our community.
[2:00:52]
because of the track construction, they used ritter
[2:00:56]
park as they are receiving spa space, I think there are
[2:01:01]
hundreds of clients to go through on a daily basis.
[2:01:06]
they utilize the residential area to go across and to go to
[2:01:12]
parker. I live on that street and I've
[2:01:13]
had many of my neighbors come to say how cars are speeding.
[2:01:21]
we did have pd has a -- the traffic, where they easure your
[2:01:32]
speed. It was on there for quite a few
[2:01:34]
weeks and it did help curtail the speed, but I would really
[2:01:37]
like to get an update on how much longer we are going to
[2:01:41]
be -- it has been over a year. How much longer we are going to
[2:01:44]
be using that ritter park as the designated space, and then going
[2:01:51]
to parker and over to the interfaith facility.
[2:01:59]
I watch my elderly neighbor trying to back out of her
[2:02:03]
driveway the every day, and they just went around her and it
[2:02:06]
was really sad to watch. So it has gotten to be a little
[2:02:16]
unsafe and a little frustrating, because they do speed on that
[2:02:19]
small section. Like I said, it's a couple
[2:02:22]
hundred every single day, monday through thursday.
[2:02:25]
I just want to say, yes, I really enjoyed this weekend,
[2:02:31]
really great to see the rowds that have really enjoyed our
[2:02:34]
downtown. All I can say is fall is here.
[2:02:38]
we got the cool weather and the wind back, and I just really
[2:02:45]
thank the city for all they are doing and welcome back, midori,
[2:02:52]
from your vacation, and welcome, sara, into your new position.
[2:02:57]
>> thank you, councilmember. I will keep it brief.
[2:02:59]
thank you for all your work. Back from our vacations, let's
[2:03:01]
get back to work. I want to wish everyone a happy
[2:03:04]
labor day. I hope you have a long and safe
[2:03:06]
weekend and we will see you all at the next meeting.
[2:03:11]
>> moved to adjourn. >> second.
[2:03:13]
>> I heard a second from councilmember evans.
[2:03:16]
roll call, please. >> mayor pro tem abercrombie.
[2:03:18]
>> yes. >> councilmember evans.
[2:03:19]
>> yes. >> councilmember bedolla.
[2:03:20]
>> yes. >> councilmember nygard.
[2:03:22]
>> yes. >> mayor arriola.
[2:03:23]
>> yes. We are adjourned at 8:56 p.m.
[2:03:31]
good night, everyone. >> I forgot the whole reason I
[2:03:33]
came up here.