Common Council Committee of the Whole Meeting September 28th, 2026

Utica, NY · · More Utica, NY meetings · More New York meetings

Transcript

Download: Text · SRT ·
AI TRANSCRIPT

This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.

[11:52] We're meeting to order the committee of the whole meeting at September 28, Monday, 2020. Today, we're going to be talking about
[12:01] Rose Dorn in September 5 from September 16th of 2020, entitled an ordinance amending city of
[12:08] Utica Code ordinances by adding section 1-15-6 entitled prohibitive camping. Today, we have chief Williams here as well as deputy chief
[12:18] very beautiful police department. Thank you both for coming. I think a good way to start here is to
[12:24] maybe summarize your your thoughts or your reading on the proposal and then maybe we can open it up to questions after that.
[12:30] Joe, I do have to make one comment though. The one thing that I'm going to ask about the chief is kind of explain the difference between what's on the book now and what this does
[12:38] because people are out there saying it's repetitive and things like that and I just I need to have you clarify that because it's a very important component to this
[12:45] the legislation, and what we've worked on, so that's all I wanted such a base on.
[12:50] So, we do have a orders, right now, to exist about sleeping in the parks, and basically law
[12:57] reads, that's the recollection of my members from Donald Dast, basically. What this can be
[13:04] a much, that she does, that this is nearly two or two bucks, to address people who are actually
[13:09] setting up living arrangements in various different spaces to include sidewalks and whatnot.
[13:17] So I think it does give us another tool to address this.
[13:20] My main concern when I saw you proposed legislation, I want to make sure that it was
[13:24] legally silent.
[13:26] So one of the Supreme Court cases that I reviewed, which means it's way the highest court
[13:33] that city of Grant's past in Oregon versus Johnson in,
[13:39] it was very interesting because in that cork case,
[13:41] they actually talked about it in a dress,
[13:44] ate the men that are concerned with any of this failure,
[13:49] passes the take-a-laws in what the enforcement looks like.
[13:53] And some of the things they made clear,
[13:54] they did not want to make homelessness itself
[13:57] to be an offense against people.
[13:59] And he also wanted to make it clear that this could be
[14:03] to equally apply to everybody through due process,
[14:07] so that whether the policy or on-house,
[14:09] it applies to everybody, but what they didn't really address
[14:13] is that, accordingly, it was the method
[14:15] for clearing a lot of these game sites
[14:18] in the practical collection that went down.
[14:22] So I looked at it from two different sponges,
[14:27] from the original address.
[14:28] One is though all itself about camping legal,
[14:32] And I believe it is, and then the property concern is that that's huge.
[14:38] I mean, I think that's a big undertaking that we have to be managed, and we just don't
[14:43] have to keep the ability to do it.
[14:44] I'll give you an example.
[14:46] In agreement of state, there was a cleanup that we had a homeless accountant about two years
[14:52] ago.
[14:53] And we got to help it to state it took five dump trucks to give rid of all that stuff.
[14:58] We wouldn't have the roof.
[15:00] For all that property. And just because someone leaves behind, you can't necessarily be able to talk to the same, get your stuff out of here. It doesn't mean it's abandoned either. So there's some final lines there. But I think if we just stick with the cabinet portion of the legislation and go from that, I think we'll be good. Yeah, I think it really helped us having Stephanie, Georgia, that's really a conversation with us today.
[15:28] I think she also agreed that the campus portion of it is legal, and again, she highly
[15:34] that concerns what it comes to the property assessment of it as well.
[15:38] Since she's wouldn't the clean green and the states, can you just touch on the fact
[15:41] of how many needles at that point in time were cleaned up as well?
[15:44] Because at the pictures, I know that you guys went through and I had contacted Senator
[15:47] Griffo's office and Marianne Boughton's office to come help us because it was an undertaking
[15:52] that the city couldn't take on, obviously, it costed a $2,500, $10,000 at the end of
[15:56] the cleanup.
[15:57] But there was probably what would you say as far as needles went.
[16:01] I don't remember the exact number, but I know there was two of those organizations to their credit.
[16:05] They were going out there and getting really discontinued needles and I gave them as well for 1,000.
[16:11] 1,000 needles.
[16:13] And that's part of the problem with when you do leave these encampments.
[16:17] You know, one ends up happening is that it doesn't accumulate not only garbage, but it accumulates, you know,
[16:24] And that was one of the things when we went in there and looked at that is you couldn't have the city
[16:29] DPW cleaned that up on their own.
[16:30] So that was something that, you know, again, that was two years ago and hence the reason why
[16:35] this legislation was introduced back in 2024 because we kind of had to protect ourselves
[16:40] in doing that.
[16:42] I will say this, so the most of it, I do have to make this clear.
[16:45] When we deal with the homeless population, I still believe the best role is services.
[16:49] We should be only using the situations where it affects quality life and we have to address those quality life issues.
[16:56] But I believe the first approach always should be a service approach.
[17:00] It's very difficult to get these people to take services. There's no question about it.
[17:03] But I will tell you this much, where they are having some success.
[17:07] I've got a good friend of mine who has to have the port authority in New York City.
[17:11] What they do, they have all their teams, they can kill and go out there.
[17:14] Maybe it may take 10, 15 times before they can build a report
[17:18] for trusting the community, almost to me,
[17:20] or do they actually get to take services,
[17:22] but it has to be repetitive.
[17:24] Can I follow that up?
[17:26] Sure.
[17:28] So you're saying, let's see, you find a campsite.
[17:33] You're not immediately, you feel that you're not immediately
[17:39] going to kick them out, you're going to try to get services in there
[17:42] before you go through the activation clear in the camp.
[17:46] So what you want to do is we're going to do outreach first
[17:48] with those people.
[17:49] See if we can get them connected to services.
[17:52] Also, a town that they have specific time period
[17:54] and move their items out of it.
[17:57] And to get me out of tune to move those items with them.
[18:01] Now, what's a good, I mean, is there a pretty much,
[18:05] okay, we're giving it two days?
[18:07] How do you figure out how long it's going to take them?
[18:09] And it would be the legal time that you could get a little bit clearer.
[18:15] I see every circumstance is different.
[18:17] Based on if there's a disability involved, if they need maybe some help, maybe we're
[18:22] waiting for some help.
[18:23] So it's going to have to be done in a case-by-case basis.
[18:26] I will tell you this much, when we do come across the homeless population, you're also
[18:31] going to run into the people that have wants for their rest.
[18:33] You're also going to have people that have no identification on them.
[18:36] And if we have to do set up an enforcement action,
[18:39] they'll have to be brought down to the police department,
[18:41] at least to verify their identification.
[18:45] Now, if they're arrested and won't,
[18:47] one of the problems we face again was property
[18:50] is usually they bring a back pack with them.
[18:52] And there's a lot of concerns with the back pack
[18:54] that they have with them.
[18:56] It's filled with contaminants.
[18:57] You have needles that my officers can definitely be stuck by.
[19:02] There's going to be bodily fluids on these back packs,
[19:05] as well as there's insects and festations on these and their properties as well, and that's why this
[19:12] comes very problematic for police as well, and I know the few times we've taken some of these
[19:18] backpacks in, we actually got to a point we had to leave them outside because we had it bring in
[19:25] the passport control that controlled the insects that were coming out of the station.
[19:30] Now, when you walk out on a, honestly, in, and you see multiple needles on the ground, is that considered
[19:41] hazardous waste on the ground?
[19:44] It's considered, it has, has material in the situation where it needs to be addressed.
[19:48] But you don't have to address it at that time, it feels that, and I'm not going to work
[19:53] it wrong.
[19:54] So, if you see that there's needles all over the place, you don't feel that you have to
[19:59] to put them up right now, you wait for services to get in there and then try to get them out before you pick it up.
[20:05] It depends on the circumstances.
[20:07] Could I give you an example?
[20:09] Part of the problem we had during the States, there also been their exposed needles and the dugouts.
[20:15] And our officers who are trained in collecting those needles and collecting them and exposing them,
[20:23] So we had the officers at that point, carefully, we treat those need to get them out of those
[20:28] areas where we knew what other people were going to use that publicly.
[20:31] So we didn't want to see anybody get her.
[20:33] And I'm enduring the fact that you've done the impacts to those along with the end of the
[20:37] And if not, what we do is we'll call on the organizations, I can, or another organization to come
[20:41] out of us.
[20:43] Especially if we find a lot.
[20:45] But just a few, we just don't want to take the chance that someone's going to stuck, I mean,
[20:50] And another example was a couple years ago when we were getting complaints from the Head
[20:53] Start School on the South Street, the nearby park there at M.L.K., we had the edicts
[20:59] or three hundred news into the playground of the kids.
[21:03] So we had our officers go in there and retreat those news so that they wouldn't give
[21:08] me kids that kind of kicked them out.
[21:10] No, we're part of it, it was part of it when you're saying, you have some mislegislation
[21:15] and some of the reasoning states.
[21:16] State of Oregon.
[21:17] And what part of that is that they do that is in here in the state of Oregon?
[21:23] It's the Supreme Court case.
[21:24] And we just said it's the 8th Amendment.
[21:27] What's the highest court?
[21:28] What happened was, this was an issue this.
[21:30] Well, the reason I've seen it, if Oregon approved it, we should have hit Pope Propon,
[21:35] because they get a bigger mess than we do over there.
[21:37] Oh my God.
[21:38] But I tell you, I just didn't Supreme Court actually address this issue.
[21:44] And it was important.
[21:44] because now you talk to the highest court
[21:46] and make it a ruling on this.
[21:47] But you know, I know that we all hear
[21:49] from your constituents, the citizens I serve,
[21:53] about while the homeless probably used to go,
[21:55] let me tell you something.
[21:56] It's not you to go.
[21:57] If you look around and you reach some of the stories elsewhere,
[22:01] big and thin.
[22:01] They actually have in Kansas City Hall
[22:03] in your county building.
[22:05] Sir Tolga now is doing with a serious homeless situation,
[22:08] especially when it comes to the begging situation
[22:10] in the streets, and why do you use the public restaurants
[22:12] and what that?
[22:13] So this is all over the place, right?
[22:16] So everybody's sort of going along with this particular report.
[22:20] I think that it has to be kind of explained that this court of ordinance is was written by me,
[22:27] okay, and it kind of made it so that it wasn't.
[22:30] In conjunction with I actually write better legislation than I think everybody here combined. Okay, what they had said, it was in conjunction with the Supreme Court case and also in conjunction with state and federal law.
[22:45] So there, it is curtailed to the city of Utica in specific issues and I think we went back and forth on several amendments, you know, what you felt comfortable, what I felt comfortable in regards to that.
[22:57] And this actual piece of legislation is most likely going to be changed.
[23:01] I have several strikeouts, some of the things obviously we can't do regarding, but I'm
[23:07] getting there.
[23:09] So I have to, I just have to, I mean, I, in listen, and I'm very sensitive to this, I get very
[23:15] sensitive to any legislation that they write.
[23:17] And it is very problematic when publicly I have felt my fellow colleagues saying that my
[23:22] legislation's done.
[23:23] And I don't think that that's fair to to by any means and anybody that shares it is actually
[23:29] Wrong to but I just wanted to say that this wasn't just done up yesterday in the morning hours. You know what I mean?
[23:37] But you had mentioned the only issue with it on this was the key about the kid
[23:43] I think the can't be legislation is proposed especially talking to Stephanie DiGiorgio
[23:49] Who I value her opinion. I think she's very astute
[23:52] She saw it the same way I do, we think that the legislation for the campaign is good.
[23:56] It's just the provisions about the cluster of property.
[24:00] Well, I just think we treated some issues with this.
[24:06] So I just want to say in a perfect world, like we could have a $100,000 for each encampment.
[24:11] Like the state does and give us that money so that we can store items and things like that.
[24:16] We don't have a budget that could sustain cleaning up encampments.
[24:19] And that's why I started this off kind of stronger in the verbiage of,
[24:23] of doing a waiver and stuff like that because if there was a possibility that we do come into
[24:27] some funding from the state, that that's something that's the proper way to do it.
[24:31] And I think that that's what we're kind of stuck in.
[24:34] We need the camp and camp and legislation, but we also can't afford to do it the way that we need to.
[24:40] And I think that that's the problem.
[24:41] I think it's
[24:48] about meetings and they're about where I can't or see the family at this point.
[24:52] They've been here, God.
[24:53] How many times has the county been here in a meeting with us?
[24:55] I don't think that's inside of the council.
[24:56] So since we're bringing this up, I'm just curious.
[24:58] Yeah, I've had plenty of discussion with the county.
[25:01] What they're saying?
[25:02] I mean, but this is a city of Utica problem they do
[25:05] when they offer the social services,
[25:06] that's their department.
[25:08] And when we do call somebody to come pick it up,
[25:10] that's the county services that are offering that.
[25:12] But this is our responsibility as a city
[25:15] into protect our police department and those that go there.
[25:18] The only important point we get from the county
[25:20] is the fact that they created their own county law
[25:22] as a guardian freedom, and another one
[25:25] you already sent that a substance system.
[25:28] The only thing I see this week that I have a conversation
[25:30] with the undershift I had is that they didn't talk about
[25:34] how they're going to test, they're not requiring
[25:36] the test yet for a substance system.
[25:38] I don't know if you can rely just on the packaging
[25:40] or sometimes we're finding an distributors to our stores.
[25:43] It's coming at another day.
[25:45] So unless you test, you don't know where it is.
[25:51] So the one question I have, so I'm kind of puzzled by,
[25:55] and I know it's something that happened two years ago.
[25:58] So you talk about the green menace states.
[26:01] And you talk about, you had five dump trucks to clean it out.
[26:06] So will this legislation help eliminate that?
[26:10] Obviously, if we had a campment that had five dump trucks
[26:13] full of materials, it was a huge encampment.
[26:17] And I'm sure that we had to know they were there.
[26:21] But at that time, we couldn't go after it
[26:23] and get rid of it before it got that big.
[26:25] or were, you'd be able to create a question
[26:28] that the problem when you hit that guy,
[26:30] that earlier, whether it kept was, it was like,
[26:32] and it's in different responsibilities,
[26:35] some of these properties owned by the city,
[26:37] some was owned by the city,
[26:38] some was owned by the telephone company.
[26:40] So we had collectively had to get everybody on board
[26:42] to agree, who's unclean is up to our ability
[26:45] and we were forcing it to kind of see sentences
[26:48] because that was basically statement back there.
[26:51] And that's because most of it was on state.
[26:53] here that's in a different way. It's part of the city part of the state part of the state part of the state part of the state.
[26:59] But so going forward, if they're on the city of Udaka property, this legislation will help.
[27:05] Get rent will be able to get in there and get rid of them.
[27:08] So we don't have an example like the encampment you had a couple weeks ago at check price.
[27:15] I think it would be a tool to help us.
[27:16] I think again, if that's a approach, is one go with a service or a approach, but when it starts
[27:21] with come an issue, we're talking about public health, public safety issues, and call
[27:27] you life, and that's when the pieces will be going to set it up.
[27:30] And so this legislation that we've been talking about, you're good with it.
[27:35] You're in a favor, you're good with it.
[27:37] Thank you.
[27:39] I just, if you guys don't mind, she since we touched on that, as far as the county offering and
[27:44] their local, what their law actually does, another dumb piece of legislation that I proposed
[27:48] was actually submitting the synthetic marijuana legislation and can you kind of explain the
[27:54] meeting that you had with MMI and how that ties into that legislation and what could
[27:59] possibly come out of it and how that could strengthen the city's position when not only
[28:03] going after people, I think from the county as a public health concern, right? They go in,
[28:07] they go to the corner stores, that's the public health component of it. We have an obligation
[28:12] through a new sense of treatment to actually have a law and a tool that could be referred
[28:17] to corporation counsel and so on and so forth for them to go after.
[28:20] So can you kind of explain why they look a law for synthetic marijuana or the amendment
[28:24] to the original existing law for synthetic marijuana actually helps you in mending it into
[28:30] addressing the newer components of synthetic marijuana and testing?
[28:34] Sure, synthetic marijuana, that's the issue we have in the city, these are the updated.
[28:39] In the reasons because they're constantly changing the chemical compounds and I read their basics, but
[28:45] What's nice about NMRI is the fact that
[28:51] We used to be able to send our
[28:53] Life submissions to the state police lab and they do a remarkable job. They do but they're overwhelmed
[28:59] They're taking evidence from all of the state and when they do you talk about major felony cases to
[29:05] city ordinance is like this and no good to prioritize what they're going to task and what they're not going to test and in many cases
[29:13] You know when we think it's a result ceiling task is very small my new portion of the substance and usually comes back and conclusion
[29:21] so
[29:22] recently we hit our
[29:24] crime scene
[29:24] desk is reach out to the state police lab about
[29:27] expression interesting again using their lab and they told us that they will not test for any
[29:33] Kind of a noise there are based on either a county or city or city or city ordinance
[29:39] So that leaves just only one other option, and it's a private lab
[29:43] So we looked in the private lab in Pennsylvania, and you're talking about a cost of six hundred and twenty dollars per sample is what we were quoted
[29:52] So
[29:53] Apparently what I found out is that I think councilman
[29:56] The medical is at a meeting
[29:59] for the
[30:00] The United Square Association and they brought up the effect and our eye can do this.
[30:07] And through your help, you've got us the connection to get an actual meeting with the organization.
[30:12] We toured both their lives, they had one there and had one in broad street.
[30:16] And we were impressed with their potential and their capabilities to do this.
[30:21] But there's still a lot of work to be done in their part. They have to get the certifications from the DEA to be able to...
[30:30] Yeah, there's a lot to work out, but there are many certain certifications, and then we
[30:35] went to the second meeting, we wanted to bring in the legal people, they would actually
[30:38] either prosecute these cases, so we brought in the attorney, he brought in the county attorney,
[30:43] brought in the corporation council, they had them gather and put it as well, so that was
[30:50] that what the meeting was about there, and they had their questions about chain of custody
[30:54] and things like that, but they want to make sure that if they do this testing, isn't it
[30:59] to be admitted and it's going to have judicial notice in court. So there's a lot of things to work out,
[31:05] but I'm impressed with their capabilities. Obviously, we need some follow-up meetings to go,
[31:10] but that's certainly has great potential for us, especially being able to do it locally.
[31:15] We should have turned around times.
[31:16] And if you have one other thing on there, when they were also saying that,
[31:21] okay, we could test for what's existing. But as we're testing, we could see new drugs that are
[31:26] into the system that we could stay ahead. So if we have to legislate for them, we could stay ahead
[31:33] of the legislation. Because right now, all they're getting from the state or whoever, it's
[31:39] what's out, what it's a lot of times, it's like six months, eight months old. And they changed
[31:43] that right away. And now they're bringing in some news, some new chemicals in it. And they'll have
[31:49] the ability if they get some type of idea of what might be coming in so they could test for it.
[31:54] So we could stay ahead of the ball game and legislate for those new chemicals coming in before they hit the streets here.
[32:01] And which is very, very important.
[32:03] Because you know why?
[32:05] It also would help us give out public notices.
[32:07] Find something that's truly dangerous out there.
[32:10] That's mixed with this.
[32:11] We give out a public warning that potential users that, you know,
[32:14] that's one of the one that's been found.
[32:16] Right.
[32:16] And finally on the meeting too, and I think we brought it up today.
[32:19] We're discussing this is that they could start doing DNA testing,
[32:22] which would help to police out immensely down the road once they get that up and right
[32:28] in too, because what's typically a DNA turnaround for you?
[32:32] Sometimes we see there's really three months, sometimes it's taken a year.
[32:36] On cases that are pending, wait on the way down long?
[32:40] Good, because I'll give you an example.
[32:41] We need DNA at every time a potential shooting or a homicide.
[32:47] Now if we need those DNA results in order to charge someone, now I'll bet shooters out in the street
[32:52] they have much longer, especially community more grants.
[32:55] So by getting those results back quicker,
[32:57] obviously, it helps us hold that person responsible
[33:00] and these stop is right at here in our city.
[33:04] Well, thank you.
[33:06] That's big.
[33:06] Chiefs, let me ask you a question, too.
[33:09] And I'll go right back to this.
[33:11] So I actually have this legislation
[33:13] for the synthetic cannabois that I updated for us.
[33:16] Would you prefer to hold off on that until we can find out
[33:19] anything through our MRI?
[33:21] Or would you like this updated with the current substances?
[33:25] There's a whole nother component in there before you go with the mandatory nuisance referral.
[33:29] So I want you to hold off the synthetic marijuana.
[33:31] Here's a reason for it.
[33:33] Because they recently identified recently some new compounds that are in these cannibalids.
[33:41] And then these be updated.
[33:42] And in fact, I suddenly emailed today with,
[33:45] to MRI with the latest substances that we know about.
[33:49] But right now, in the public outlaw, that's another law we used to our advantage.
[33:54] But there's over 390 different compounds that are identified in the New York State public
[34:02] outlaw.
[34:02] And that's like, we actually passed it on in 2012, those bad cells.
[34:08] And that's why, you know, that was, I easy to identify if somebody was on bad cells or not.
[34:13] And why we updated that legislation in 2012, but as of now, unless it's bad cells,
[34:18] or something like that, that legislation is kind of,
[34:21] that's outdated.
[34:22] So I just want to say, I'm not wasting anybody's time
[34:24] by having these meetings and presenting this legislation.
[34:28] Thank you.
[34:29] OK, so back to the actual ordinance.
[34:32] Is the amended the city code adding section 1,
[34:35] dash 1, 5, dash 1, 6.
[34:37] Now, I will go through and I'll, I'll, dash 6.
[34:41] So I have to do two things.
[34:42] I have to actually amend the section,
[34:44] because it's actually in the local law.
[34:46] I'm going to move it to the park section.
[34:50] I got to look up the actual code.
[34:52] Because this, if I amend this, this is a
[34:54] Mending a local law.
[34:55] And I actually can do the same thing that
[34:57] I need to do under a different section of the code,
[34:59] so that it's under a code of ordinance.
[35:00] So I have to do that.
[35:02] So you'll see a modified component of that actual section.
[35:06] Once I get, once I actually, we all did this today.
[35:09] So I really haven't had time to go through and
[35:11] figure out what section that I actually need.
[35:13] So just the sections parts will be amended.
[35:16] And the other components of it, if you want to go through, I'll take a page by page.
[35:21] The second page.
[35:23] Hold on, can we continue around here?
[35:25] I just want to make sure on that first wave.
[35:27] We don't have questions.
[35:28] Then we could dig in a little detail.
[35:29] Sorry.
[35:29] We left off for Councilman Beatrice.
[35:31] All set with Councilman Irvin?
[35:33] No.
[35:34] Okay.
[35:36] All right.
[35:37] She's something I did have.
[35:38] First, I'll comment.
[35:39] I do think this is drafted well.
[35:41] It's constitutionally cautious where it needs to be.
[35:44] It looks to maybe unintended consequences that may.
[35:47] may occur because of it, so I do agree that it's strong from that perspective. Now, the property
[35:53] issue that keeps coming up, and Chief, I think you mentioned you're okay with the camping side,
[35:59] the language on the prohibited camping. Yes. Now, when it comes to the property portion, and I mean
[36:06] this seriously, where are we, where that property portion won't be enforced, and we only have
[36:16] prohibited camping site, where does that really leave us if someone who violates this provision
[36:23] the dragged off of a campsite and what happens to their property at that point because I'm
[36:30] just looking and I fully appreciate the issue here of it's a huge undertaking. The storage
[36:38] of all this property, if you come across a campsite with mattresses, tents, bicycles, carts,
[36:43] You know, what do we do with with all of that put what's left of this ordinance if the property provision won't be enforced or can't be enforced?
[36:52] What teeth does it have at that point with the campaign for camping provisions left?
[36:57] So in most cases we've heard it fortunately beginning in voluntary compliance.
[37:00] Once we tell them they have to leave if they've been doing it.
[37:03] But you're going to have your cases where people are not going to leave.
[37:06] And what we find is in those cases used is because someone used this mental health issues.
[37:10] And that's why we've been using our crisis response team quite a bit to try to address it and get them to help they need.
[37:17] And maybe there's been time to send this, we recognized that they may fall in the high gym of 941 or 945.
[37:25] And that's the advantage of having a crisis.
[37:30] We have a license clinician with this as well. So if there need to be an involuntarily commit someone, we have those who's available.
[37:38] But our goal is to get a compliance. We're looking at not to be cast on your rest with us. We're looking to, and most, given the parents to get, but even before that, we want to offer services, and we aren't voluntary compliance before we take any enforcement action.
[37:53] because I think you bring up a great point.
[37:56] What we don't want to be viewed at,
[37:58] and one in sending your officers to deliver services
[38:02] and the other, and being out there with the hammer,
[38:06] saying enforcement is law.
[38:08] So it's a fine balance.
[38:11] There's no question about it, but again,
[38:13] I believe that homelessness is truly a social issue.
[38:16] Yeah.
[38:17] And it needs to be addressed through services.
[38:19] And I appreciate that you've come to meetings
[38:22] in the past and highlighted that. I think maybe last year or two years ago, we had county officials
[38:27] come in as we discussed the services offer, not only in this county but Perkamer County,
[38:32] that might want might come here in Madison County and what might come to a night of county
[38:35] just because their services are lacking. And with this piece of legislation, I mean, what can we
[38:44] revise? So there's not questions about property storage and retention that doesn't put the police
[38:51] department in a situation of still having on the books more, more of an undertaking
[38:59] and staffing allows.
[39:00] You know, we don't want to leave anything in there that leads open the question of
[39:04] a good word department.
[39:05] If you let me get through the amendments, that's what we talked about today.
[39:07] No, I'm just asking this over now.
[39:09] I appreciate it.
[39:10] I'm just asking the chief what he recommends that would prevent a negative situation from
[39:17] occurring, where is something still on the books where we wouldn't want on the books
[39:21] to put the department in the situation.
[39:25] So, Stephanie's the Georgia was a great resource today.
[39:27] I mean, I think that she validated my research that I did,
[39:31] and we also talked about the logistical problems
[39:34] with property collection, and we thought
[39:37] that they had to be removed from the original proposed orders
[39:40] because we don't have the resources.
[39:43] We don't have the storage space,
[39:46] and more importantly, we're hoping
[39:47] through voluntary compliance that we can get them
[39:50] to review the rights or say, listen, I don't want to stuff, this is abandoned.
[39:58] York.
[40:02] Did the answer your question at home?
[40:04] No, yeah, I appreciate it, Kim.
[40:07] All the services around here are better than her, you know, we got more food ventures,
[40:13] you got more free food, so we're trying a lot more people from those areas.
[40:20] The more you offer, the more you get a drop.
[40:22] So they got a fine line, yes, we want to help.
[40:26] We want to bring more people in because we're given the help.
[40:31] And we got, we got so many places where they can move
[40:33] if people that are in need to go get free food.
[40:37] And now I'm seeing that people from work and women,
[40:40] and people from fires can.
[40:42] They're coming here because they know they can get more stuff.
[40:45] I mean, so to fine line how much you want to give
[40:48] and how much you're going to track.
[40:50] So we're later than I can be able to get that much.
[40:54] So about a year and a half ago, two years ago,
[40:56] I went out with our crisis trust team,
[40:57] just to interact and talk to some of the homeless people out there.
[41:01] And to your point, it is true.
[41:03] I mean, they're being told by other municipalities
[41:06] that go to your country, they have the service.
[41:09] So why do you see quite a bit of the homeless population
[41:12] that they can grow here?
[41:13] We don't, we don't think we've got 20 of the people
[41:17] that volunteer for food pantry, we're giving out food like crazy,
[41:20] which is great, but who draw people from areas, just get more and more to the world.
[41:29] I don't know how to answer that. I'm just bringing up the fact that I don't know the solution.
[41:35] That's a fact.
[41:37] The problem is that there's no presolutions out there.
[41:39] I don't have any suggestions.
[41:41] The city of the state has configured out.
[41:44] In municipalities that try to figure out, you're seeing my today.
[41:47] We're trying to pass local legislation now, at least controlling it.
[41:50] All right.
[41:51] The city unit does a lot.
[41:53] The food pantry, free food, lunches, everything.
[41:57] I mean, we're not getting that.
[41:59] These other areas.
[42:02] That's chasing them away from the other areas.
[42:05] But there's no, I'm just bringing that up as a fact.
[42:07] I'm not an exclusion for it.
[42:09] Most of the issues are right now.
[42:11] You go anywhere.
[42:12] It's almost all over the place.
[42:14] I'm terrible.
[42:14] I'll tell you this much, what reason why I think the United States of Albus is you alone
[42:19] since we made.
[42:21] We've already crossed two people that died in these encambles.
[42:25] One, and then there's so long, all we found was bones in the clothe of trees.
[42:28] You saw the cave.
[42:30] Yeah.
[42:30] So we found two people on the, I think it was a two, it was a two and a half month period.
[42:35] In cabins, I think it was.
[42:38] So I think it would help us, no, maybe address in the constraints to keep them healthy.
[42:44] They don't approve of it, and to your point, the county has the services, they come and put them in programs.
[42:53] They want to follow rules of services, and they don't go back to where they came from.
[42:59] That's where they don't you say that over 75% of homeless in the people on the streets, I come to Syria, direct.
[43:07] I think that's what David Chievelle knew in the second half of the year.
[43:11] Yes.
[43:11] Dennis is fine but...
[43:14] No.
[43:14] No.
[43:14] They came here for a program.
[43:15] They got out of program and they don't like to rule the program.
[43:18] And they leave.
[43:19] But you know, the Councilman beaters at point.
[43:22] I mean, we're not going to give a rest of our way out of this situation all.
[43:25] And that's why we need services at our country.
[43:27] And that was today.
[43:29] And we're going to go to the last of the year.
[43:30] Yeah, we're going to go to the last year.
[43:31] No, we're going to go to the last year.
[43:31] This is all got to be done by service.
[43:34] And we're not evil.
[43:51] You know what, I have not heard that there's been any of, any of it denied or, and I know how, um, sheltered for individuals. So I am heard of it.
[44:03] Thank you.
[44:04] Yeah, and the other thing about this law that they've taken, Supreme Court case, law that
[44:09] the research cities under no obligation before the enforce this law to make sure there's
[44:16] housing or shelter available as well.
[44:21] All right, so if we don't have any other questions, we could turn it over to Councilman
[44:26] Tester go through each proposed amendment, I don't know.
[44:29] I don't know.
[44:30] Yeah,
[44:33] sure.
[44:33] thing before we move forward with this.
[44:36] So I can briefly, I did have a phone call with Sam.
[44:41] We did go over a bunch of things to amend the cancellation.
[44:45] I apologize.
[44:46] I just finished it and dropped off to me while I was in my other meeting.
[44:50] So I did attract changes so I can circulate that around.
[44:54] But if she wants to go over kind of the broad strokes, but I can give her my copy, I only
[44:59] have one copy.
[45:05] Okay, so I already talked about the mistake that we have to amend the section. Put it to a different part of the code. That was something that it shouldn't take us. That's not going to take me long enough to do. I just have to amend that. I'm in that section.
[45:19] That was, was he where it says section one, dash one five, dash six. I just have to, yeah, I just have to change that section.
[45:25] are we able to make copies of that track change document I want to keep this we'll just
[45:30] we have in front of us so we can follow right now I mean if possible I was just
[45:37] going through it so that you could accidentally I mean I don't want anybody else
[45:41] circulating any other information I don't want any else anything else anybody else
[45:46] circulating information that that's all I'm saying is that any amendment that's made
[45:51] I would like to make the amendments.
[45:53] That's fair, just so we could follow along with what we're talking about.
[45:58] So the other part was, and you can just keep going, because these are just languages in the actual definitions.
[46:07] So obstruction means you could just gotta take out a person.
[46:11] So it's really kind of just some of its verbiage, some of its taking out whole section.
[46:16] So the other part is taking out reasonable accommodation in the actual definition section.
[46:23] So I'll take an order ready and stop and she'll make it.
[46:26] Yeah.
[46:27] So then you'll see no person shall knowingly sit, lie your stand, you just got to
[46:30] take out, sit, lie your stand.
[46:35] And then like schedule E was removed, schedule Apple's removed, schedule G was removed.
[46:43] And that really kind of went back to the property component of it.
[46:47] I'll wait for it to make that.
[46:48] I'm not going to waste my time.
[46:51] So while we're waiting, do you have a question, Councilwoman?
[46:56] So skipping ahead a bit here to Section 3, the implementation pre-rex,
[47:05] do we want to
[47:07] add languages that give some kind of associated timeline with that?
[47:12] So we're, you know, there's a lot going on with the city.
[47:15] So that's actually gone.
[47:16] So that's pulled.
[47:17] Yeah.
[47:17] So, what does the effective date stay the same 60 days after it opt in though?
[47:22] Nope, that actually is going to be amended to effective immediately on under the mayor's page.
[47:26] It's the same way we pass the normal ordinance.
[47:28] Okay, so we're pulling that section.
[47:31] Nope, section three is removed.
[47:34] And then section five is going to be amended to say effective immediately.
[47:38] Or, or normal.
[47:41] Um,
[47:41] So I'm going to get two pages on.
[47:46] No, it's still pretty, it's still pretty worthy.
[47:53] Are we keeping the voluntary property release form for those who do wish?
[47:57] That's gone, Paul.
[47:59] And like I said, Joe, I kind of went high and then figured out what we can and cannot do.
[48:05] I mean, again, I would pull this legislation out if we got money from the state.
[48:09] And that's obviously part of the other resolution,
[48:11] and urgent in the government in New York City
[48:13] to legislate or to provide additional resources
[48:15] policy reform, so on and so forth.
[48:18] And I think it's important to add.
[48:19] I mean, I don't think the concerns here
[48:21] are constitutional or legal.
[48:23] It's practical concerns of implementation.
[48:26] I mean, again, I think again,
[48:27] constitutionally, it's cautious where it needs to be.
[48:30] It keeps in mind the Supreme Court cases.
[48:33] It's just logistics.
[48:34] I mean, there's a lot of things to do before implementation
[48:37] of the property aspect.
[48:39] Well, and that's the thing, we don't, unless we get a next year of, you know,
[48:44] 50,000 dollars out of our budget, a storage component is the natural problem.
[48:48] And I also think that even after that fact, even if you do get a storage, you're still going
[48:52] to have to outsource it to a different company.
[48:54] Because it's really not fair for the Police Department Parks Department,
[48:57] D.P.W., that really don't have the storage facilities on site to have to take that on.
[49:18] Okay, so now the first copy was in RAD.
[49:20] You'll see your straightouts are in black.
[49:24] So again, we'll go through, so page one is really just the sections on that the other one was obstruction and the definitions on page two, you remove person.
[49:36] You also remove reasonable accommodations scheduled removal. Once you go to obstruction bill hit prohibited, you go to sit, lie stand, that's going to be removed.
[49:48] Section 2 of that will be removed and then you just change section 2, section 3, the section 2.
[49:53] Camping on city property prohibited, no person shall knowingly establish maintain or occupy a campsite on city property.
[50:00] And that right there, remove that section, remove section 2, and then section 2, 3 becomes 2.
[50:07] So nothing in the section so lawful.
[50:09] And for us, I'm going to park our stress pass by your sanitation traffic, so I'm going to so far.
[50:15] And then again, warning of our opportunity to comply, except as otherwise provided,
[50:19] you'll see that those two sections are the first, first sentence and last sentence are taken out,
[50:25] section two, and then three goes to two.
[50:28] And then you're changing that from shell to mate.
[50:32] If they have any opportunity that they need to take a photograph or record before removal.
[50:38] going to the next page, section four is removed.
[50:42] Go to section E, that whole section is removed.
[50:46] Go to section F, personal property from a campsite.
[50:51] Go to section two of that.
[50:53] Removal Shelby no broader than reasonably necessary.
[50:55] Take out sections two, three, four, and five.
[51:02] Take out section G.
[51:04] And again, this was because the city needs a broader aspect when it comes to removing stuff
[51:10] if we don't have that storage facility with that.
[51:15] Garbage has this material, so garbage can be removed and lawfully dispose without storage.
[51:21] Take out that last sentence.
[51:24] Number two, material representing an immediate health or safety hazard.
[51:28] Maybe isolated removed or disposed.
[51:29] Take out that last sentence.
[51:32] Weapons, illegal drugs, contraband property known for those that stay the same.
[51:37] Then you take out reasonable combinations as needed and social service outreach when
[51:42] warranted and or reasonably practical the city shall offer that before we remove or
[51:47] citation.
[51:48] So you just put a scheduled one.
[51:50] Then take out those last two sections and force mobility and limitations.
[51:55] It personally violate subsection B and C after receiving an opportunity by required of the
[52:00] that's actually commits a punishable, but I find it's not exceeding $50.
[52:04] One of the things that we did talk about up there, what's the chief, and Chief, can you
[52:08] kind of explain how we talked about earlier, as far as you guys keeping a running record
[52:13] on, who you take in and so on and so forth, so that that will be accessible if needed in a
[52:20] database that you collect.
[52:21] So, one of the things you want to be careful is you don't want to be known for tracking
[52:24] And homeless people, that's going to be the job of my peak aid belief in the city hall.
[52:30] We do it now. However, whenever we have contacts with the homeless people, obviously, our officers are required to do a entry into our records management system, which are named the reason why we have the encounter with the person.
[52:45] And again, like any street encounter has to be legal under the board doctrine under stock question or frisk. So we have to make sure, you know, again, our officers will train it in there.
[52:55] We, you know, has traditionally approached these people and they have the reason to do so.
[53:00] Thank you.
[53:02] I'm sorry.
[53:06] If you missed that information, I see the reason why we couldn't share it with them.
[53:10] You just might have to redact some information.
[53:12] I mean, I mean, I should get, shouldn't it?
[53:17] Would you thoughts on that?
[53:19] Yeah, I mean, I don't, if that's what he's been doing.
[53:22] And I don't know that this is information for me,
[53:24] But if that's what he's been doing, that she was right, whatever we can share, we will share.
[53:28] And then if there's anything that is sensitive, that has to be redacted, we'll be, you know,
[53:32] we're active.
[53:36] And that's from a long course when Stan Point II, whoever is in that position, to take that information.
[53:42] All right, take out section two, that goes to one, all condo, that you take out section three, four, and five.
[53:50] I run a private property that's these the same administration records and reporting and this is kind of
[53:56] to kind of skip to that. This is what I was going to do to the City of Shomning Team record
[53:58] sufficient to audit enforcement including warnings, citations, and then you'll see there
[54:03] a couple of other strikeouts, at least annually the administration provided the Comaconcil,
[54:07] would report that protects personal privacy and identifies implementation issues of the
[54:11] chapter. severe weather and emergencies that was a strikeout rules of construction was a strikeout
[54:19] So, it's a very ability that stays in there, section three implementation, that was a strike out.
[54:26] Section four, the ordinance does not supersede any state, or federal law, and any city form policy or practice,
[54:34] and consistent with the ordinance that supersede state, and then section five, that was amended to be effective immediately.
[54:41] Chief, I just got a follow-up on that.
[54:47] Mike, Mike, hand, Chief, I'm talking about it.
[54:52] The corporation has a question.
[54:54] Go ahead.
[54:57] So, I'm going to ask you a question.
[54:59] The question that the administration is offering for review.
[55:06] It's what I have reviewed with Councilwoman Tessa and the Chief.
[55:13] I don't want to say that it's put forth by the administration, but it's something that we are good with.
[55:20] I ask you a question.
[55:23] I review these bad.
[55:29] I don't see anything and I could
[55:35] accept an explanation that some of the media won't look something.
[55:42] That requires worse justice, that shouldn't be canning people, squatting, that's what really is.
[55:55] That's the integration of our fundamental governance.
[55:58] They need to be notified because many of the people who are there may be subject to their jurisdiction.
[56:06] But areas in this country do not want to accept that responsibility for the coalition.
[56:19] Could it be a kind of state of Congress that has made a very clear debate?
[56:24] What has been determined by someone who came across side of the country?
[56:30] And it was not a fair investigation.
[56:33] So if you find somebody in the park, who has a tent from one of them is, and they cannot
[56:42] identify a pool of what they can or where they're from, why is it the art of what they're
[56:50] saying?
[56:51] Because it's not ever a responsibility to determine the kind of function you should now be a
[56:57] of the president, but the name should be in this country that that's probably greater
[57:03] authority than us, but I think that those authorities should be notified and the police
[57:11] department of the city, the county, and the state, I think, are required to notify them
[57:19] that because they have the facility for removal of people, for and not supposed to be
[57:27] here at all. And otherwise, you're saying that anybody who's here has some work, has
[57:37] some authority to be here. And I love them, they say, with constitutional rights, you can't
[57:43] But I can't do the first instructions unless you are a citizen, and you can't go too much while I'm sitting.
[57:51] And then you can't do any of it. You are not a citizen except when you exist.
[57:55] If you are here or being being lawfully, you do not have to become a citizen.
[58:01] Back on the West Coast in the United States, in 1941, many of the people will live there.
[58:07] and that, it's citizens, and it's not, and that states in order to give up their citizens,
[58:14] it's just enough.
[58:15] It's right there.
[58:16] They should have been passing a result of this, isn't it, right?
[58:19] So, but they were there, which I know would be legal status.
[58:25] So, I look at all of that, I see that the problem with all this legislation, it is that,
[58:36] There's so little cooperation, or the assistance of state of federal governments about
[58:46] how a handle is brought.
[58:48] I mean, what you'd do with this, and it had to be very careful that there are human beings
[58:58] who cannot, you know, that they're not like a piece of,
[59:05] but non-personal property there
[59:07] people. What do you do with them? What do you cut up? If you think about the park, what
[59:13] you do it up? Who do you know if I, who is responsible for this? You're being the money
[59:21] is really the responsibility of the county. We're not allowed to make suits any of you.
[59:27] We need to have the budget of the airport. You do that. So the government has, and the federal government
[59:34] that is supposed to determine whether you're in this country and you're really not you.
[59:41] So what I'm saying to you is I'm not the typical of everything until saying to you there is so much
[59:50] So let's take a bath in this bed.
[59:53] It's like the paragraphs that are about people who are camping.
[1:00:02] We have to do so. And so I'll just be popular as a group. There's can't be under roll property.
[1:00:11] I'll just do whatever you have to do. That's the post.
[1:00:15] They're not promises. How could that ever be legal? I just can't say that.
[1:00:21] I know it's your restrictions. I know that people are trying to remove people from the personal document.
[1:00:27] If you are trying, this already said, thank you to you to protect the squad, as opposed to the proper version, and the driver problem.
[1:00:38] So, what I'm saying to you is that I think of what you're doing, and everything I've read is very interesting, and I think it's something that is needs a lot of things.
[1:00:57] examination, and I agree with the council of people who are proposing this legislation, because
[1:01:05] something the righty should be there to give people like the chief of police, some sort of
[1:01:13] authority, and what they're supposed to do in this situation. I am sure that the chief of police
[1:01:19] city here again. It is very concerned about shots,
[1:01:24] fighter shootings and all the other things that will happen
[1:01:29] because the number of people who are here will
[1:01:32] are going to comment for at home.
[1:01:37] So if they're carrying the guns on them and then you give them
[1:01:41] this thing about the park. Parts have a clear signage
[1:01:46] I'm all of the bucks, but very clear of scientists that, you know, there's no camping.
[1:01:53] Those squatting, no overnights.
[1:01:56] You know, that's like the worship of the closing dollars will be strictly enforced.
[1:02:02] It should be very clear that you can't go in there, and if you can read English, you will know you can't go in there and stay after a certain period of time.
[1:02:12] which you set the time when the part is closed after what you do.
[1:02:20] So, I am not criticized anything here.
[1:02:24] I am just laying out thoughts, and that's why I came to this being today.
[1:02:31] I don't claim to be any more stew than this second.
[1:02:36] That anyone else in this world, I see there's a big pile of this country that is very
[1:02:44] aware of its borders, Ukraine, unguarded, unknown, and unclosed for walker to try and
[1:02:53] millions of people came across those borders, and they're starting to show up in a lot of
[1:03:00] Please, because a lot of the problems, so it's not something that you cost, but something
[1:03:08] here we have to handle or provide some answers to, so I know the purpose of saying this
[1:03:19] is that I'm not critical of anything.
[1:03:22] What you question I have been doing for the official question that I have asked, I think I had
[1:03:27] that.
[1:03:28] This is also one of my best tests that you will find a model that you were crafted or
[1:03:39] looked at to assist you to encourage something for this body to consider.
[1:03:46] I mean this particular piece now, it's kind of just been a combination of what we've worked
[1:03:50] for the past couple years. I think this one specifically has kind of been an amendment between
[1:03:58] me and the chief and now Stephanie. I said that no, I think that it's been a combination of
[1:04:06] all of us working together which best fits the city of Utica and that's, you know, we've kind of just
[1:04:12] put all our brains together and we're able to come up with this.
[1:04:19] Yeah, I mean the only thing that I did
[1:04:21] Was it I looked at, you know, obviously the Supreme Court case versus Johnson and that had to kind of be amended because we did have this legislation in back in 2024 and nobody was really comfortable with that
[1:04:48] I've heard this legislation comes home and tested it.
[1:04:50] I only made modifications of what was put in front of me.
[1:04:54] I used the framework that we were aimed at.
[1:04:56] Correct.
[1:04:57] Okay.
[1:04:58] It's all about it.
[1:05:00] It's all my questions.
[1:05:01] I have not, I want to think it was very perfectly clear.
[1:05:05] And I have not been critical to our criticizing anything.
[1:05:11] I just think that five or two ways, I would want some clear direction about
[1:05:18] I'm supposed to do and how I'm supposed to do it, because I am in every piece of legislation
[1:05:25] and the premise that some court may be reading it someday, and whether this would not
[1:05:34] the unfortunate amount of money that's mine, that's mine, that's mine, that's mine, what I've
[1:05:46] thought to look for, and I'm just saying to one of you, just to quote, which you can't
[1:05:54] Our job is to assist you at the need of one of us out of the curve.
[1:06:01] I know a lot of people will receive or send superior positions to us.
[1:06:10] And we are knowing that the courts look at all of this things.
[1:06:17] They say things that I know that agreement and they say things that I do agree with.
[1:06:23] So everything is subject to review and determination by the person who is thinking to sit down.
[1:06:30] I said it, but it's a really cheap piece of legislation.
[1:06:36] And I think there are certain things that have to be very clear.
[1:06:41] Think there's the close either of the parts that the hours of all that has to be very clearly
[1:06:49] the money that the ventilator said because that's the starting point.
[1:06:55] You get the right to go in there to remove everybody from the car.
[1:07:00] By a rare argument, it says that the park is closed.
[1:07:05] You have also the authority to remove something.
[1:07:08] If there's a clear sign that says, no, can't be no squatting is allowed on these city properties.
[1:07:17] and any nature or any form, and we shall be removed, if possible.
[1:07:24] The responsibility of wearing a yellow collar is something.
[1:07:30] It has to be coordinated with county and the city and the government, as somebody's people are subject to some federal government review and how do we do that, and should we do that.
[1:07:45] And so, all of that I think is, and it has to be considered when you're looking at anything
[1:07:53] as serious as a document, like this, that by the fact of a lot of people, and I'm just
[1:08:02] recently, somebody was saying to me, knowing the position I hold here, how come people are
[1:08:11] We've been endorsed steps in Europe, people will go in a lot, or in a place on the way to the top.
[1:08:19] I said, let me tell you something.
[1:08:22] People have been speaking in gorge steps.
[1:08:25] For it's to talk with this idea of development in this country.
[1:08:30] And it had nothing to do with our president's situation.
[1:08:33] It's just a fact of why I think the chief believes in the same thing.
[1:08:39] He's been looking at that problem since he was a patrolman.
[1:08:44] So, and there were no easy answers then, and I know easy answers not to be a good midge.
[1:08:51] I do, sir.
[1:08:53] That's all I have to ask why I'm here tonight, not to criticize or just review, and that's why I
[1:09:10] And it provides it to an all-day subject, and eventually,
[1:09:19] in any piece of legislation
[1:09:20] I do review, and in any way, it gets your guidance from a much different source.
[1:09:28] So, and I do not claim to be the best for that very much worth of law in the U.S.
[1:09:35] Actually, one of the things that I would like to
[1:09:37] come in an end is section five, the effect of immediately,
[1:09:41] just add in that the proper signage to be erected.
[1:09:50] The judge did make a good point that we probably should.
[1:09:53] Yeah, to answer that, I think that's a good recommendation
[1:09:56] of post that.
[1:09:57] I was thinking about this as the judge is making a comment on here.
[1:10:00] So we have it currently drafted as city property.
[1:10:03] I mean, for parks that's easy, right?
[1:10:05] You just posted it each entrance of the park.
[1:10:08] So what do we do about other city property that's not technically a park but it's, it would be applicable here.
[1:10:14] I mean that would be very difficult to implement.
[1:10:17] So I just food for thought because the city parks sure.
[1:10:21] But other areas that are big enough for someone to technically camp at.
[1:10:26] But it doesn't matter.
[1:10:27] I mean it's a city or it's the same thing with anything else.
[1:10:29] So containers.
[1:10:30] We don't have that posted across the city.
[1:10:32] So. Sure. This one specifically. I think that that is a good point about posting though at the at least at the entrance of each at least each entrance of a city park with respect to the parks. There's no problem with that. I believe there's already a sign with all of the park.
[1:10:45] Rules.
[1:10:46] Yes.
[1:10:47] Listen, well, no, there's there's some other I think.
[1:10:51] Stuff that has stuff, but that's not a problem to add to the park rules or whatever signages within the parks or additional signage for that.
[1:10:59] But with respect to other areas that you can't post it, I mean, it's city ordinance, it'll be created as it's like saying no smoking signs, but they shouldn't have no heroin, no needles, no, I mean for example that's a place you're talking about is the island in north, okay?
[1:11:14] So they put a couple of years ago they were camping in between the trees and they were using the power there, we had to cut that out.
[1:11:21] So that's I mean it's saying this would apply to that even though it's not basically it's sort of hard.
[1:11:27] Yeah, it applies in a place in city property. I just not like being you don't need a post
[1:11:31] You know everything because it's a city ordinance, so it's
[1:11:35] Chief is gonna make a point anything to your point. What issues we've been deal it for example the
[1:11:40] See this monument
[1:11:42] You know
[1:11:44] I'll actually authorize be able to
[1:11:46] I bet people sleep in overnight
[1:11:47] But because it wasn't posted you wanted to get fair warning
[1:11:51] So we did was we went and talked those people getting fair warning
[1:11:54] We talked about it, so we could prove that they were warned previously to us do many
[1:11:58] enforcement.
[1:12:00] Yeah.
[1:12:01] And I, I, so corporation council's point, I, I see exactly what you're saying.
[1:12:05] And, you know, I think about this often with the name of the game with a lot of this is
[1:12:09] notice.
[1:12:10] It's, you know, due process did they have the proper notice.
[1:12:13] So, I mean, I think something like this would lend itself a while to having opposed to
[1:12:17] notice just because I mean, I guess I'll ask, what, what percentage of campsites are we seeing
[1:12:23] that are in city parks.
[1:12:25] I mean, what percent will we capture with just posting the notice
[1:12:28] at city parks as if a decent percentage to begin with there?
[1:12:32] Well, I was telling this much.
[1:12:33] We had three in campus.
[1:12:35] We were usually working on throughout the Dalton
[1:12:37] and I'll be with a plan we put forth in the mayor's office.
[1:12:41] And the three were concerned about was the sales movement,
[1:12:45] the climate, the economic impact, and the nurses part.
[1:12:50] Our strategy to begin is trying to get these people's services.
[1:12:52] When they weren't in something services, we went in there and I think they didn't share a warning.
[1:12:57] Whether it's posted or not.
[1:12:58] And then, basically, we saw some clients.
[1:13:01] We didn't have to make it at your arrest.
[1:13:03] And he rushed, we didn't make, as it was with people who wanted for once.
[1:13:08] I'm going to guess it should clarify just from my read at this.
[1:13:10] There is some language in here that allows for a warning to move it.
[1:13:14] So I would think that that would constitute at least enough that your advice,
[1:13:18] if there's no signage, you have one warning if we catch it here again.
[1:13:22] And we do that the same way with the public project property, two, for example, we had a
[1:13:27] problem for a while, and it walks through Plaza there, where business could play with the
[1:13:34] homeless camp, they wanted them out.
[1:13:36] So we gave them sure notice, and when they didn't move, then there would be, they would
[1:13:40] be arrested for trespassing.
[1:13:42] Yeah, no.
[1:13:43] And either way, I think that proposals are good one for the city parks.
[1:13:54] I was going to follow up on Mike Pete, Mike's Pete thing, I mean.
[1:13:57] So he's keeping track of just
[1:14:00] I don't think that they have the answer to what these don't I think you got to have like like peeking here at the girl
[1:14:05] What he's just a method did they tell you what he was doing what is done?
[1:14:08] So my mistake of talking about it might be because actually I've been tracking the obvious population with your cabinets are
[1:14:15] If they do something individuals are I don't have access to the information, but that's Ralph's told
[1:14:19] I just think it would be important if you have contact with the multiple contacts that
[1:14:26] But I think the one point we have to be clear, we can enact all these defenses that we want.
[1:14:32] The one that I would make it clear is that a lot of times that we're seeing this placement.
[1:14:37] There's just going to one another area that we have to address.
[1:14:40] And I guess one thing I will just point out from a legal standpoint is,
[1:14:44] That's why services is important.
[1:14:45] You know, the legislation is prohibiting camping.
[1:14:48] There is a lot of first amendment,
[1:14:53] eight-minute rights that individuals are allowed.
[1:15:02] Targeting, you know, and addressing it in the homeless sense, it has to be looked at across the board. We're prohibiting camping in the parks. This is, you know, equal enforcement.
[1:15:09] Equal enforcement. I get it that we are trying to address the situation that is going on, but the more we start narrowing these things down, the more it's going to look like we're, you know.
[1:15:18] So,
[1:15:24] again, so if you go off-leadland to have, you get the trail that's right there, that runs
[1:15:30] to the new trail that runs parallel to the canal, I walked in the morning or night.
[1:15:38] But on the other side, don't, okay, there, and the other end, by the state garage, if you
[1:15:43] go that way.
[1:15:44] Now, is that considered city property, is that all of them are state properties, even though
[1:15:50] So there's, I mean, there's a large quantity of almost them and right down in there.
[1:15:58] I know for a fact because I see it a lot of mornings I was scared by it, but I'm not scared,
[1:16:03] but I'll have a son you're walking at 7.30 in a morning and
[1:16:06] guy jumps is coming out of there.
[1:16:08] So I know that it's there.
[1:16:09] This really wasn't pertain to that because it's state property.
[1:16:12] Same thing like I just wanted to know if that's city or state.
[1:16:18] That's my question if that was city or state property.
[1:16:31] We want to go around again.
[1:16:32] We have any other follow-up questions based on any
[1:16:45] other business, any one wants to address?
[1:17:10] don't need to stress it. I would put it up to the top and so forth and next time you might think this is you.
[1:17:15] I just ended up in that post-ground buildings, but it's coming up a way more frequently.
[1:17:20] Some of the same days, some of the similar days across the city and just that was very close.
[1:17:27] I think that we used to take a approach that you've been in the comments area or anything like that.
[1:17:32] I mean, I would just say it's very tough crime to enforce.
[1:17:36] I mean, because it's being done during the night hours when no one's around, and then even
[1:17:43] if we stop at the individual, it's just because they have a backpack on, we don't have
[1:17:47] the legal right to actually search that backpack without a reasonable cost.
[1:17:53] So we've been successful in some areas where we've actually, you know, the officer was able
[1:17:58] to visually see someone actually doing, but it's fewer of our between, it's difficult.
[1:18:02] I mean, I've been seeing the sciences
[1:18:05] that I've been even fostered over.
[1:18:08] South here to get a North here to get a downtown,
[1:18:10] I mean, with it put his tags and it's frustrating.
[1:18:14] Because it's not only a public safety issue,
[1:18:17] but it's also a big cleanup issue for the parts
[1:18:19] that part of the DPRW has to do.
[1:18:22] But I would tell you this much.
[1:18:24] It's a very difficult part of the force.
[1:18:26] We can make a sense that's been in the point that I was saying is hiring, if we do find some of you that you know obviously this part of the other job, you know there's there's several tags,
[1:18:36] and several different kinds of people respond to buildings and all more.
[1:18:39] I would just hope that I'll be explaining to you if you've seen a team plan if you need plenty of fun about that.
[1:18:44] I think you can utilize some of the ones that I mean not.
[1:18:46] Well, we have had some successes.
[1:18:48] We put out on the cover car out there, we're playing the other, with the officers and play clothes.
[1:18:54] It's a time to worry had to be able to catch up with hate.
[1:18:57] I mean, I don't know.
[1:18:57] I'll know, but I need to know its meaning is just, it's, it's necessarily a different
[1:19:01] button.
[1:19:02] I mean, that, that's why i don't have, because legislation, as I know, I don't, and I'm
[1:19:06] a little bit introduce again, and the narrative gives me anything of why people would
[1:19:11] want to do other than something more about their law was big, but I mean, I just can't see
[1:19:18] it's the same thing.
[1:19:18] Does that do you know the line?
[1:19:22] Um, I don't recall off the top of my head, but there was a bunch of issues as it related to the funding.
[1:19:29] And then I've never got anything with that.
[1:19:30] So I have the IPv1 and just literally I don't know if you know what I think.
[1:19:34] I will tell you this far.
[1:19:35] So there are penal offenses for possessing graffiti tools and graffiti.
[1:19:39] And so they does exist in the New York City people long.
[1:19:42] No, and that's usually we do charge.
[1:19:44] Yeah, I believe just so I don't know if she does aware.
[1:19:47] So, the legislation is more for payment and cleanup.
[1:19:52] I haven't seen that.
[1:19:52] Yeah. So, I don't, I just don't recall off the top of my head, but I believe, at least
[1:19:57] my notes, I had that there was issues with funding that we're not going to be, like, you
[1:20:02] couldn't do with that way. So, I can look and try to find my notes on that, and I can
[1:20:06] check to see what's up there.
[1:20:08] Thank you.
[1:20:08] You know, if you're going to be needing next time, thanks a lot.
[1:20:16] So, if you agreed with it, if you liked it, we were doing it, but it doesn't help
[1:20:19] we could pay for it.
[1:20:22] I don't know about any of that, I'm just saying when I recall from my notes, I had issues with that.
[1:20:35] So I'm not sure his rationale for the video or what he specifically had issues with.
[1:20:40] I just don't recall it's been a while.
[1:20:44] Okay, that's all in the minutes, right there.
[1:20:47] The last thing is, it's sorry, it's never almost October.
[1:20:52] Nobody is, it's up to that new legislation for the weathering.
[1:20:56] So, I mean, go up, the badering, sort of silly.
[1:20:59] I mean, the only people that have complaints, never should have been anything.
[1:21:02] To us as a council, and we got like 15 days of course, just like it's not.
[1:21:08] So, if it doesn't exist in the day, if it expires again,
[1:21:11] You really put the second up in a position where, because you've wasted your opinion of
[1:21:16] the opposition to the legislation that was opposed to not the post-banking health, it's
[1:21:19] kind of you only, because of the legislation that we have left.
[1:21:25] So I think that if nobody else is in the interjections event, they've got to submit it by next
[1:21:30] month to repeat this month to repeat it.
[1:21:33] And that was over a month ago, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you.
[1:21:56] Are you going to resubmit the ordinance or amend?
[1:22:04] I got you, I got you, I don't know what to read to each amendment and then do that.
[1:22:11] Do you have anything else?
[1:22:13] Thank you.
[1:22:14] Thank you.
[1:22:15] Motion to adjourn.
[1:22:17] Any object?
[1:22:18] Okay.
[1:22:19] adjourn.