Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
Copy of a YouTube video held by the Internet Archive.
Captions were copied from the YouTube video.
Captions were copied from the YouTube video.
[0:14]
to our Williamson School Board meeting
[0:15]
. Welcome to everyone
[0:17]
present this afternoon. I'm Lee Webb,
[0:19]
current superintendent of
[0:20]
Williamson County Schools, and I'm
[0:21]
proud to welcome you. We're going
[0:23]
to start this afternoon with an
[0:26]
oath-taking process. It is a privilege for
[0:28]
us to welcome the
[0:29]
newly elected members of the
[0:31]
school board at the start of each
[0:32]
academic year in an
[0:34]
oath-taking ceremony, and we are starting this
[0:35]
ceremony at 6:30 on purpose, so that
[0:37]
all of our constituents and
[0:39]
family members who are here
[0:40]
tonight can witness this
[0:42]
momentous occasion.
[0:44]
In addition, we are broadcasting live
[0:45]
so that family members we know
[0:47]
who are at home or voters at
[0:48]
home can also watch. At this
[0:51]
time, I would like to welcome
[0:52]
to the podium our Mayor of
[0:54]
Williamson County, Andy Marshall, who
[0:56]
will introduce and swear in the
[0:59]
newly elected school board members. Therefore,
[1:01]
I would like to welcome the
[1:02]
school board members and their
[1:04]
families to the podium at this time for
[1:05]
our oath ceremony. Yes.
[1:25]
Just make a small circle.
[1:27]
Yes.
[1:28]
Fill the well.
[1:29]
Forward. So, let's
[1:39]
swear everyone in at the same time, so there's
[1:41]
a little bit of harmony. We'll
[1:44]
see. We're in Nashville, right
[1:46]
, Tony? So, we'll harmonize our
[1:47]
answers, but we're going to
[1:49]
swear everyone in at the same time. But
[1:51]
, before doing so, I first want to
[1:54]
congratulate and thank you.
[1:58]
Williamson County thanks you for your service
[2:00]
and your willingness to run, win, and
[2:03]
serve. So, thank you
[2:05]
all very much. So, let's begin the
[2:07]
ceremony. I say his name. I
[2:18]
solemnly swear that I will
[2:22]
faithfully fulfill the duties of the
[2:26]
office
[2:28]
to which I have been elected
[2:31]
and which I am about to assume. I
[2:38]
solemnly swear to
[2:39]
uphold
[2:40]
the constitutions
[2:41]
of Tennessee and the United States.
[2:47]
And to
[2:49]
faithfully fulfill the duties
[2:54]
of the office of member of the
[2:59]
Board of Education representing
[3:01]
the fourth district, performing
[3:03]
all the obligations corresponding
[3:05]
to said office.
[3:06]
Excellent. from Williamson County,
[3:09]
Tennessee.
[3:12]
Congratulations to all. Thank you.
[3:29]
If I can take your oaths so you
[3:32]
can sign them before then. Yes, I'm going to have him sign them
[3:34]
.
[3:50]
Very good, guys.
[3:52]
Randy, can everyone make some space?
[3:57]
Very good, right here in 3. 1 2 3.
[4:07]
Excellent. Thanks, guys.
[4:18]
Okay, we'll take a moment to
[4:20]
let you all sit down and then we'll
[4:21]
begin.
[4:47]
Very well, while you take your seats, we will
[4:49]
give you an official welcome and
[4:50]
congratulate you individually. From
[4:52]
District 2, Randy Allen. From District 4
[5:00]
, Tracy Anderson. From District 6,
[5:05]
Kimberly Caldicott. From District 8,
[5:11]
Donna Clements. From District 10,
[5:16]
Jennifer Canady. And from District 12,
[5:25]
Jessica Licciardello. Welcome and
[5:30]
congratulations to all of you.
[5:32]
I now call this meeting to order.
[5:34]
I request that all
[5:35]
board members register their
[5:36]
digital attendance at this time.
[5:46]
There are 12 members present.
[5:49]
Thank you. We would like to
[5:51]
welcome and thank our
[5:54]
Williamson County Sheriff's deputies who are here tonight,
[5:56]
Officer Matt Smith and Officer Jason
[5:58]
Curtis. Thank you for your service to
[5:59]
our district and thank you for being
[6:01]
here tonight. We would also
[6:02]
like to welcome
[6:04]
Boy Scout Troop 86. Could you please stand
[6:05]
, gentlemen? Troop 86 is
[6:12]
here tonight from Brentwood and
[6:14]
they are working on their
[6:15]
communication badge. So, welcome.
[6:17]
Thank you for being here with us
[6:18]
tonight. And I believe we also have
[6:20]
some Summit High graduates who
[6:22]
are enrolled at Columbia State.
[6:23]
Future teachers, could you please stand
[6:25]
to be recognized? Thank you for
[6:27]
being here tonight. Thank you and
[6:33]
welcome. They are here as part of
[6:35]
their class project which they are
[6:36]
working on at Columbia State University
[6:37]
. Alright, to start off
[6:39]
tonight, we'll stand for the Pledge of Allegiance
[6:41]
led by
[6:43]
Summit High School students
[6:44]
Lyric Hudson and Owen Stratton.
[6:46]
We will stand firm tonight.
[6:49]
We will welcome the singing of
[6:50]
our national anthem by the
[6:52]
Summit High choir, and when they conclude
[6:54]
, we will pause for a moment of
[6:56]
silence. So, come closer, Lyric and
[6:59]
Owen.
[7:05]
Pledge allegiance
[7:06]
to the flag
[7:07]
of the United States of America
[7:09]
and to the republic for which it stands,
[7:12]
one nation
[7:14]
under God,
[7:15]
indivisible,
[7:16]
with liberty and justice for all.
[7:49]
Oh, can they see in the early light of
[7:56]
dawn what we so proudly acclaimed in
[8:04]
the last glimmer of twilight?
[8:08]
Whose broad stripes and
[8:11]
bright stars, through the perilous
[8:14]
struggle, waved so gallantly over the walls we observed
[8:21]
. And the
[8:27]
red glow of the rockets, the
[8:29]
bombs exploding in the air,
[8:35]
proved throughout the night that
[8:41]
our flag was still there. Oh,
[8:44]
tell me, does that star-studded flag still fly
[8:48]
for the land of
[8:57]
the free and the home of the brave?
[9:17]
Thank you. Please remain standing
[9:19]
for a brief moment of silence.
[9:31]
They can sit down. First on our
[9:38]
agenda tonight is an annual item,
[9:39]
the election of the president and
[9:41]
vice president of our board of
[9:42]
directors. So, to begin this
[9:45]
process, I'm going to ask for nominations
[9:47]
verbally. All nominations will be
[9:49]
heard until we close the
[9:51]
nominations. So, at this moment
[9:54]
, I will ask you to open the
[9:56]
nominations. Once I close the
[9:58]
nominations, I will ask for your vote for
[10:00]
president by voice call in a
[10:02]
roll-call voting system that will be
[10:03]
run by Lydia Glenn. We will begin
[10:07]
that roll-call vote first by the
[10:08]
first district and then proceed
[10:10]
numerically until we have
[10:11]
reached seven votes for our
[10:13]
new chairman of the board.
[10:16]
At this time, I would like to open the
[10:17]
nomination process for the position of
[10:19]
president of our board of directors
[10:21]
for this academic year. Very good.
[10:28]
Dr. Driggers?
[10:29]
I would like to nominate Dr. Claire
[10:31]
Reeves.
[10:32]
We have a nomination for Dr.
[10:33]
Claire Reeves, nominated by Dr.
[10:35]
Driggers. Mr. Bostick? Does he have any
[10:42]
nominations? No? Very good. The
[10:44]
nomination period is still open. Any
[10:46]
additional nominations? At this time,
[10:51]
I will close the nominations and we will vote
[10:53]
by district. Mrs. Glenn?
[10:56]
Tony Bostick?
[10:57]
Yes.
[10:58]
Randy Allen?
[10:59]
Yes.
[11:00]
Dennis Driggers?
[11:01]
Yes.
[11:02]
Tracy Anderson?
[11:04]
Yes.
[11:04]
Margie Johnson?
[11:06]
Yes.
[11:07]
Kimberly Calcoat? Yes.
[11:09]
Melissa Wyatt? Yes.
[11:11]
Donna Clements? Yes.
[11:13]
Claire Reeves?
[11:14]
Yes.
[11:15]
Jennifer Conine?
[11:17]
Yes. Yes. Yes.
[11:22]
We have 12 yes votes, zero no votes.
[11:25]
Congratulations, Dr. Reeves. Come on.
[11:28]
Let's take a moment. Let's give a round of
[11:29]
applause to Dr. Reeves. We'll take a
[11:37]
moment to have the chairs changed. The
[11:39]
next item on the agenda
[11:40]
will be the election of our
[11:42]
vice president, for which we will let
[11:43]
our new president lead the
[11:45]
process. The process will work in the
[11:47]
same way as the nominations and
[11:49]
voting for the chairman of the
[11:50]
board. In a moment, Dr. Reeves
[11:53]
will open the floor for
[11:54]
nominations for vice president.
[11:56]
We will leave the floor open and
[11:58]
then begin the voting.
[12:26]
First, I would like to begin by
[12:28]
thanking my fellow
[12:30]
voting board members for that vote
[12:31]
of confidence. I feel I had great
[12:36]
respect for our outgoing chairman
[12:39]
, Mr. Josh Brown, and I believe he provided
[12:41]
strong leadership to this board and I
[12:44]
look forward to following in his footsteps. Whenever
[12:48]
there is a transition, five
[12:51]
board members leave, and tonight we just
[12:53]
installed five new members.
[12:55]
I believe that change brings
[12:58]
opportunity, and I know that each of
[13:00]
the five new board members
[13:03]
has unique backgrounds and experience
[13:05]
, and I welcome the fresh
[13:07]
perspective they will bring to this board
[13:09]
. Therefore, what I hope to offer
[13:13]
are efficient and respectful meetings.
[13:17]
My goal is to keep this board
[13:20]
focused on policy and
[13:22]
governance, and to give everyone the
[13:24]
opportunity to be heard.
[13:27]
Thank you very much, and now we will return to the agenda
[13:29]
. OK. The next
[13:33]
item on the agenda is the
[13:35]
election of the vice president of the
[13:36]
school board. We will follow the same
[13:39]
process that we just used for
[13:41]
the position of president. Then,
[13:44]
I will open the floor for
[13:46]
nominations and we will hear the
[13:48]
nominations until no
[13:51]
more names are presented, and then we will hold an
[13:55]
oral vote starting with
[13:57]
district one and moving around the room.
[14:02]
The floor is now open for
[14:03]
nominating the vice president.
[14:06]
I would like to nominate Margie Johnson,
[14:09]
Dr. Johnson.
[14:17]
Mrs. Calcote, you have the honor of being
[14:18]
recognized.
[14:18]
I would like to nominate Tonya Hickman. Are
[14:24]
there more nominations? Well, since we don't see
[14:28]
any, we'll close the nominations and
[14:30]
proceed to the voting. Mrs. Glenn
[14:33]
.
[14:34]
Tony Bostick.
[14:37]
And this is the person we'll be voting for
[14:38]
, Margie, right? For this or...
[14:41]
Please indicate the name of the person you would
[14:43]
like to support.
[14:44]
How will we do it? Very good, Margie
[14:45]
Johnson.
[14:47]
Randy Allen.
[14:49]
Tanya Hibma.
[14:50]
Dennis Triggers.
[14:51]
Tanya Hibma.
[14:53]
Tracy Anderson. Tanya
[14:54]
Hibma.
[14:56]
Margie Paget.
[14:59]
Kimberly Calcoat.
[15:00]
Tanya Hibma.
[15:01]
Melissa Wyatt.
[15:03]
Tanya Hibma.
[15:04]
Donna Clements.
[15:05]
Margie Paget.
[15:08]
Claire Reeves.
[15:10]
Tanya Hibma.
[15:12]
Jennifer Cannine.
[15:13]
Tanya Hibma.
[15:18]
Jessica Lucian.
[15:20]
Tanya Hibma.
[15:25]
Nine votes for Mrs. Hibma and three
[15:28]
for Dr. Paget.
[15:29]
Very good. Congratulations to Ms.
[15:32]
Hibma on being elected vice president.
[15:36]
Now we will move on to topics of special
[15:39]
public interest. This is our
[15:45]
afternoon public commentary segment and I believe we have eight speakers
[15:47]
registered. So I'll say we have
[15:51]
30 minutes allotted. Each person will have
[15:54]
3 minutes to speak. I will announce the
[15:56]
names of the first three, and
[15:58]
please come forward to the podium when they
[16:01]
have finished speaking. If the
[16:03]
first person has finished speaking,
[16:05]
ask the second person to do so
[16:07]
immediately to save time. The
[16:11]
first three are Lily Graver, Ed
[16:15]
Wagner and, oh, Lisa Schraufnagel.
[16:29]
Should I start?
[16:30]
Begin and pay attention to the time
[16:32]
displayed on the screen. Thank you.
[16:36]
I propose that
[16:37]
Winston County and District schools ban
[16:39]
books from school libraries
[16:41]
and impose two censorships on
[16:43]
newspaper articles and publications. Therefore,
[16:46]
policy 4.43 states that
[16:48]
Winston County supports the principles of
[16:49]
intellectual freedom and recognizes the
[16:51]
right of students to access
[16:53]
different types of material, and that
[16:55]
censorship of instructional material will be discouraged
[16:57]
. However, his own
[16:59]
track record proves otherwise. A
[17:01]
couple of examples I mentioned were
[17:03]
The Perks of Being a Wallflower, whose
[17:05]
themes represented in this book are
[17:07]
trauma, friendship, identity, and
[17:09]
growth. In The Catcher in
[17:11]
the Rye, isolation,
[17:13]
survival, relationships,
[17:14]
truth, and justice are shown. And Extremely
[17:16]
Loud and Incredibly Close, it
[17:17]
shows the pain, 9/11,
[17:19]
war, and trauma. Thus, in 2023,
[17:22]
it was decided to keep them in the
[17:23]
school library, but in 2024 the decision was made to
[17:25]
prohibit access to
[17:27]
students in Williamston County schools
[17:29]
. But I believe the
[17:33]
purpose of having a library is
[17:35]
that everyone can read books according to their
[17:37]
own preferences, not according to what
[17:39]
someone else censors, because everyone
[17:40]
has a different idea of what is
[17:42]
comfortable and appropriate for
[17:44]
students. And another thing I want to
[17:47]
mention is that the Supreme Court
[17:49]
addressed the removal of books from
[17:53]
public school libraries in the case Board of Education
[17:55]
versus Pico in 1982 and recognizes that
[17:57]
students have
[17:59]
First Amendment rights to receive
[18:00]
information. And that removing books
[18:03]
because officials disagree goes
[18:05]
against
[18:06]
constitutional concerns. And some of them
[18:08]
would be Sarah J. Maas, The Hate U Give.
[18:11]
All have been challenged for
[18:13]
sexual content, and yet all were allowed to
[18:14]
remain in libraries. And if
[18:17]
you start framing them in terms of
[18:18]
an adult audience, there would be nothing left
[18:20]
to read. It's the story, not the
[18:22]
activation warning. And then the
[18:25]
other issue I want to mention was the
[18:27]
ban on censorship of
[18:28]
journalistic publications, which dates back
[18:30]
to 2025. This shows that
[18:31]
Tennessee already has situations where
[18:33]
schools have restricted
[18:34]
access because administrators
[18:36]
deemed the topics
[18:37]
inappropriate. The topics covered
[18:40]
were birth control and the
[18:42]
LGBTQ+ field, both fundamental to
[18:44]
providing students with access to information
[18:45]
. And not only are they prevented from
[18:47]
reading a newspaper, but they are also
[18:49]
prevented from accessing information on
[18:51]
issues that directly affect them.
[18:53]
It meant that they lost the ability
[18:55]
to listen to different perspectives and
[18:57]
form their own opinions.
[18:58]
He conveyed the message that certain
[19:00]
topics were not appropriate because they were
[19:02]
controversial. And that has a
[19:04]
greater effect on student journalists
[19:05]
because it basically discourages them from
[19:07]
reporting on issues in the future.
[19:08]
Thank you.
[19:09]
Next up is Ed
[19:17]
Wagner.
[19:20]
Good night. I didn't realize I
[19:23]
only had 3 minutes, but I understand
[19:24]
everyone has the same amount,
[19:26]
so it's fair. To begin with, my
[19:29]
experience was that I was a
[19:31]
primary school teacher and school psychologist for
[19:32]
more than 30 years. I am very
[19:35]
familiar with
[19:36]
public education. I really want to propose not
[19:40]
just for this school district, but
[19:42]
a regional vocational high school
[19:44]
that covers
[19:46]
Williamson County, Davidson County, and
[19:49]
Maury County. In this way,
[19:53]
we lose many gifted children
[19:57]
who do not have the opportunity and are
[19:59]
forced to go to university. I
[20:01]
love university, it did a lot for
[20:04]
me, but I'm not a very
[20:06]
handy person. I lift the hood of a car and
[20:08]
I could point to the engine, and that's about it
[20:09]
in terms of my skill level.
[20:12]
But I think it's very important and that there will
[20:15]
potentially be a million
[20:17]
jobs a year looking for people
[20:20]
with those skills. Now, I know there is
[20:22]
some vocational training
[20:25]
in schools, but I mean
[20:27]
licensed plumbers,
[20:29]
licensed electricians, licensed welders,
[20:31]
sheet metal workers, HVAC technicians,
[20:33]
not just technology, but I do think
[20:35]
technology is important in school
[20:38]
. I hope I can convince some of
[20:41]
you to meet with me and
[20:43]
talk and explore how we could
[20:45]
talk to the other districts. I don't
[20:48]
mind doing a lot of grassroots work,
[20:50]
but I truly believe, as a former
[20:52]
educator and in the importance of
[20:55]
education, that there are 132,000 children in these
[20:57]
three districts. If you took 20%, you
[21:00]
would be looking at more than 13,000 children whose
[21:06]
needs we may not be meeting, and
[21:09]
we could. Well, right now
[21:14]
I'm hoping that Mark Zuckerberg from Facebook—
[21:17]
I'm not a big fan of his, but he has the
[21:20]
Workforce Academy, which tries to train
[21:24]
people to work and create the
[21:27]
new technological systems they
[21:30]
want, or the A1, etc. AI, I should
[21:33]
say. The president is starting
[21:37]
one where they look to do internships,
[21:39]
etc. But those programs could
[21:41]
appear and disappear. They are not
[21:43]
guaranteed. A vocational high school
[21:45]
would be a constant.
[21:47]
I would be there every year, every
[21:49]
year, for the children who
[21:51]
need it. I don't know how much time I have
[21:53]
left. So I'll leave it here. I had a
[21:56]
lot of information, but I couldn't give it to you right
[21:58]
now. But I hope some of
[22:01]
you are willing to sit down
[22:02]
with me and talk about doing this. I think it would be a
[22:05]
wonderful thing for the
[22:07]
region and I think it would meet many
[22:08]
needs of the children who are left
[22:10]
behind. I'm going to tell you a
[22:12]
quick story. I met a guy who was a
[22:13]
plumber. He is 27 years old. He graduated
[22:16]
from high school,
[22:17]
unsure of what he wanted to do.
[22:19]
After talking to her parents, she went
[22:20]
to university. I'm
[22:21]
sorry, Mr. Wagner. It's time. It's
[22:23]
over. I'm sorry
[22:23]
. Okay, thank you very much
[22:25]
for your time.
[22:30]
Next up is Lisa Schrouth
[22:32]
Schrouthnegel. I regret having ruined
[22:34]
his name. And after her we have
[22:36]
Beverly Purvis followed by Emma Graw.
[22:38]
Good night. Thank you all. My
[22:40]
name is Lisa Schrouthnegel. I have two
[22:42]
students who attend
[22:43]
Thompson Station Elementary School. First,
[22:45]
I want to thank you all for your work.
[22:46]
We love Williamson County and
[22:48]
the Thompson Station community. We
[22:50]
moved here specifically because of the
[22:51]
schools and their excellence. That's why
[22:53]
I'm here to talk about what
[22:55]
a reasonable expectation of
[22:57]
bus transportation is. We have
[22:59]
ongoing challenges specifically at Thompson
[23:00]
Station. For the last 4 years,
[23:03]
transportation was predictable. Whether it was their
[23:05]
first or second trip in our
[23:07]
area, students usually got back
[23:08]
home by 4:20 p.m. m.
[23:10]
Parents could plan their
[23:12]
work days, childcare, appointments, and
[23:14]
activities around a schedule they
[23:15]
could rely on. However, since
[23:18]
the first day of classes this year,
[23:20]
that predictability has been
[23:21]
completely diminished.
[23:24]
My children's school is 1.4 miles from our
[23:26]
house. Our original delivery time
[23:28]
was 4:17 p.m. m. Then it changed to
[23:30]
4:42 p.m. m. Without explanation, we are
[23:32]
simply supposed to
[23:33]
accept it. It set us back 25
[23:36]
minutes, almost half an hour. We were never
[23:38]
notified of this new standard time. It
[23:40]
is not unreasonable for a family to expect to
[23:43]
know when their child will return home
[23:45]
. I say this with privilege because I work
[23:48]
from home. I can't imagine being a
[23:50]
single mother who might work outside the
[23:51]
home and trying to guess every day
[23:53]
when her child will arrive, especially
[23:54]
if he is a minor. The impact is real
[23:57]
. Those young children wait at
[23:59]
school long after
[24:01]
dismissal time, as do the staff who
[24:02]
look after them. Working parents can't
[24:05]
just quit their jobs,
[24:06]
join a line of cars at
[24:08]
3:30, and do this every time
[24:09]
changes occur. It has been a continuous challenge and I
[24:11]
cannot emphasize enough how
[24:13]
difficult it has been. I imagine they
[24:15]
have much more important things to
[24:16]
do than this. That's why being here at
[24:18]
the county board to address this
[24:19]
issue is like making a mountain out of
[24:21]
a molehill. Last Friday, a
[24:23]
driver became ill and
[24:25]
my children had to be picked up 4
[24:26]
minutes before
[24:27]
school started. Like many others, I decided to
[24:29]
take them to school that day. But
[24:32]
I went to the bus stop just to
[24:33]
see what was happening, and the bus passed by
[24:35]
without any students. So,
[24:36]
many parents, again, simply
[24:38]
made arrangements to take them to
[24:39]
school themselves. It is a reflection of
[24:41]
how families have
[24:43]
completely abandoned a transport service that is
[24:45]
owed to us as taxpayers in this
[24:46]
area. After school that day,
[24:49]
my children stayed in the cafeteria
[24:51]
for almost an hour waiting for
[24:52]
the bus to arrive. Illnesses
[24:54]
happen, I understand. I have three
[24:56]
deceased children who had been in
[24:58]
daycare services. I understand. But that doesn't
[25:00]
explain the unpredictability and the
[25:01]
ongoing challenges and delays that
[25:03]
I and many other families
[25:04]
have faced since
[25:05]
classes started 8 weeks ago. I have requested
[25:08]
changes to our program. I have asked
[25:10]
that we have different loads. They've given me
[25:12]
excuses. There is a shortage of
[25:13]
buses. There is a shortage of drivers.
[25:15]
Again, I understand. What I'm asking is
[25:17]
that they be held accountable for what they're
[25:18]
doing about it. I haven't seen
[25:20]
any information explaining that my
[25:22]
bus is full, therefore, my
[25:24]
route cannot be changed. I haven't given any
[25:27]
data on how many drivers
[25:29]
they need. Again, what's the plan
[25:31]
for hiring them? When are
[25:32]
our children expected to
[25:34]
get home from school on time? They have not once
[25:35]
arrived home on time.
[25:37]
Thank you for your time. Thank you.
[25:48]
Good night. I am Beverly Purvis and I
[25:49]
have the privilege of serving as
[25:51]
president of the
[25:52]
Williamson County Education Association.
[25:54]
Tonight, I want to ask you to
[25:55]
carefully consider the vote
[25:56]
before you regarding the
[25:58]
superintendent search process. As you weigh up whether to
[26:00]
spend district resources on
[26:02]
hiring an outside search firm
[26:03]
, I encourage you to consider a
[26:05]
simple but important question. If we already have
[26:07]
a qualified,
[26:08]
reliable, and proven leader performing this
[26:10]
role, why spend
[26:11]
additional taxpayer money
[26:12]
looking outside the district for someone
[26:14]
who may be highly qualified
[26:15]
but lacks the deep
[26:17]
institutional knowledge that has
[26:18]
helped make Williamson County Schools
[26:20]
one of the
[26:21]
top districts in Tennessee and across
[26:22]
the country? Dr. Lee Webb is not
[26:25]
an unknown candidate. It's not
[26:26]
someone we would have to spend
[26:28]
months getting to know, nor
[26:29]
our schools, our staff,
[26:30]
our students, our culture, or
[26:32]
our community. She has been an
[26:34]
integral part of the leadership team that has
[26:36]
guided this district through years of
[26:37]
growth and success. He understands what
[26:39]
makes Williamson County schools
[26:41]
exceptional because he has
[26:42]
helped build that success. The
[26:44]
reality is that leadership matters.
[26:47]
The direction set by a
[26:48]
superintendent ultimately influences
[26:50]
every school, every
[26:51]
educator, and every student in this
[26:52]
district. Decisions made at the
[26:55]
district level have a
[26:56]
domino effect that eventually reaches every
[26:58]
classroom. These priorities set by
[27:00]
the district leadership affect the
[27:02]
working conditions of
[27:03]
educators, the
[27:04]
learning conditions of our students, and
[27:06]
the overall trajectory of our
[27:07]
schools. And that is why the WCA has
[27:10]
encouraged teachers and
[27:11]
educational support professionals across the district
[27:13]
to contact their
[27:14]
representatives on the school board and
[27:16]
share their perspectives on those
[27:17]
decisions. Regardless of whether they
[27:20]
support Dr. Webb as
[27:22]
permanent superintendent or believe an
[27:23]
outside search is necessary, we believe
[27:25]
educators deserve to have a voice in this
[27:27]
process. These are the people who
[27:28]
experience the impact of
[27:30]
leadership decisions every day
[27:31]
. The decision is much more important
[27:34]
than filling a position. This is about
[27:35]
determining the future direction of
[27:37]
schools in Williamson County. It's about
[27:39]
deciding whether we continue
[27:40]
building on the foundations that
[27:42]
have made this district successful
[27:44]
or whether we look for leadership and vision
[27:46]
elsewhere. As board members,
[27:48]
you have a tremendous responsibility
[27:50]
tonight and we appreciate it. My
[27:52]
request is simply that you listen
[27:53]
carefully to the educators,
[27:55]
staff, parents, and
[27:57]
community members who have invested their
[27:58]
lives in these schools. Don't
[28:01]
just consider the qualifications on a
[28:02]
resume, but also the value of
[28:04]
experience, trust,
[28:06]
relationships, and proven commitment to
[28:08]
Williamson students. Thank you for
[28:10]
your service, your careful consideration
[28:12]
of this matter, and your continued commitment
[28:13]
to the students and employees of
[28:15]
Williamson County schools. We
[28:17]
appreciate you guys.
[28:19]
Thank you, Mrs. Burgess. Next up is
[28:25]
Anne McGraw, followed by
[28:27]
Tony Caudill and then
[28:29]
Robin Baldry.
[28:30]
Thank you. My name is Anne McGraw and
[28:33]
first of all, I want to point out, just at random,
[28:35]
how nice it is to see so many
[28:36]
women sitting here. Brilliant! I am
[28:40]
the mother of a former high school student
[28:41]
and I'm only saying this part because it's
[28:43]
incredibly relevant. I am a
[28:44]
former member of the
[28:45]
Williamson County School Board. It's been 8
[28:47]
years since I sat here in
[28:49]
Tracy's seat and I'm here to
[28:50]
speak for the first time since then
[28:52]
because this district is about to
[28:54]
make a colossal mistake by not voting
[28:55]
Dr. Webb for a permanent position.
[28:58]
As someone who has been in
[28:59]
Dr. Webb's professional orbit in
[29:01]
one way or another since I first
[29:03]
showed up at one of these
[29:04]
meetings in 2014, here's what I know
[29:06]
about her. He is excellent at his job. She
[29:09]
is professional, fair, kind but
[29:11]
firm, cares deeply about
[29:13]
student outcomes, and is
[29:14]
incredibly respected and loved by
[29:16]
staff and parents. I also know
[29:19]
that it scares me a little, in the best way
[29:21]
. She always has the answers,
[29:23]
is determined to find solutions, and
[29:24]
, which is especially helpful for
[29:26]
all new board members, will
[29:27]
never make them feel remotely
[29:29]
like idiots for asking a
[29:30]
dumb question. But this is the most important thing
[29:32]
tonight. I wouldn't even
[29:34]
venture to guess about
[29:36]
his political affiliation. I have no
[29:38]
idea. Even better, it had never occurred to me to
[29:40]
ask until now.
[29:43]
It would be hard to find many
[29:44]
people more in tune with the
[29:46]
last decade of headwinds in politics
[29:48]
than me, sad to say, and I don't even
[29:50]
have any idea how I vote
[29:52]
as a citizen. And that's what
[29:54]
a professional looks like. Dr. Webb has been
[29:56]
doing on-the-job training
[29:58]
for this position for decades, which is what
[29:59]
every organization dreams of when
[30:01]
appointing a new leader. We don't
[30:03]
need to spend a single dollar of
[30:04]
taxpayer money to rewrite
[30:06]
a succession plan that has been
[30:07]
in the works for decades under the pretext that
[30:09]
she is proving she has
[30:10]
earned it. In fact, it has been crazy to
[30:13]
even hear anyone mention the
[30:14]
search for a superintendent who
[30:16]
might lean in a
[30:18]
political direction. I hope I misheard and that this isn't
[30:20]
a factor in wanting to conduct an
[30:22]
external search using
[30:23]
taxpayer funds that are scarce at the
[30:25]
moment. I don't know how many of you
[30:27]
know this, but parents have to
[30:28]
pay out of their own pockets for things like
[30:30]
mowing the school lawn and
[30:31]
buying blackboards and even
[30:33]
new equipment for the teachers. I don't know how
[30:35]
anyone could seriously justify
[30:37]
spending money on private consultants
[30:38]
when we have a very clear
[30:40]
and qualified candidate, willing and able to
[30:41]
dedicate even more years of her
[30:42]
career to steering the ship. And to
[30:44]
be clear, this is not a
[30:46]
sinking ship. We are at the
[30:51]
top of the rankings in every
[30:52]
aspect of the state, and Dr. Webb has
[30:54]
played a vital role in getting us
[30:55]
here. And if there's one thing I
[30:57]
know about her, it's that she's ready
[30:58]
to exceed expectations as the
[31:00]
leader of
[31:01]
our county's crown jewel. Ask some
[31:04]
teachers what needs fixing here and
[31:05]
what they could dedicate all their
[31:06]
attention and energy to this year. Or to the
[31:09]
parents, the bus idea is a
[31:10]
great idea. I agree with that. I would have
[31:12]
loved
[31:13]
reliable bus transport. But I can promise you
[31:16]
that the one thing that doesn't need fixing
[31:17]
is replacing Dr. Webb. Thank you.
[31:30]
Very well, good night. My name is
[31:32]
Tony Cardile. Both of my children
[31:34]
graduated from Williamson County schools
[31:35]
. I have followed the
[31:37]
district closely for years. And two
[31:39]
years ago I applied for a position on
[31:41]
this board. Tonight I ask you to
[31:44]
vote against spending up to
[31:45]
approximately $100,000 to
[31:46]
hire a company to conduct
[31:48]
the search for a superintendent
[31:50]
. I understand the argument in favor of the
[31:52]
search. They have the important
[31:54]
responsibility of ensuring that we
[31:56]
have the right person in
[31:57]
charge of our schools. But we already
[31:59]
have a highly
[32:01]
qualified leader acting as
[32:02]
interim superintendent. I don't know
[32:05]
Dr. Webb personally, but I've
[32:07]
seen her work for years. She is a
[32:10]
very well-informed person, always
[32:12]
prepared, understands this district
[32:14]
and this community, and has demonstrated the
[32:15]
qualities we should desire in
[32:17]
our superintendent. When WCS
[32:20]
needed an interim superintendent,
[32:22]
the previous board of directors elected her
[32:24]
unanimously. Therefore, I would like to
[32:26]
ask you a very simple question.
[32:29]
Before spending up to $100,000 of
[32:31]
taxpayer money and months of
[32:33]
your time and the administration's time
[32:34]
looking for someone else
[32:36]
, why not first determine if
[32:38]
the highly qualified person who
[32:40]
is already doing the job is the
[32:42]
right person to continue doing it?
[32:45]
Every year, this district fights for the
[32:47]
funding needed to support
[32:49]
our schools. Finding $100,000
[32:52]
in the budget doesn't mean
[32:53]
we have to spend it. Evaluate
[32:57]
Dr. Webb, decide what you expect from your
[32:59]
next superintendent, and determine
[33:02]
if she meets those expectations. If
[33:05]
they conclude that they don't, then consider
[33:07]
conducting a
[33:08]
search. But please, answer
[33:10]
that question first. I urge you to
[33:13]
vote against hiring
[33:14]
a search firm tonight.
[33:15]
Thank you.
[33:18]
Next is Robin
[33:21]
Baldridge, and after Robin Baldridge
[33:23]
is Becca Ripley.
[33:35]
Thank you. My name is Robin Baldridge.
[33:37]
I live on Arno Road in Franklin. I have been a
[33:40]
resident of Williamson County
[33:41]
for almost 26 years and all three of my children
[33:43]
are proud graduates of
[33:44]
Williamson County schools.
[33:46]
I wish to thank each member of
[33:48]
our school board for their service and
[33:50]
welcome those who have
[33:51]
joined us to serve our county. I
[33:54]
also believe that Dr. Webb has done
[33:56]
a wonderful job stepping up
[33:57]
during this time of
[33:58]
transition following Jason Golden's departure
[34:00]
as superintendent. I
[34:02]
sincerely appreciate your many years of
[34:03]
service to Webster County.
[34:05]
Really. That said, I support
[34:07]
conducting a
[34:08]
thorough search for our next
[34:10]
superintendent. At the end of that
[34:12]
process, Dr. Webb could very well
[34:14]
be the person selected. But I think it would be
[34:17]
a disservice to conduct an
[34:19]
open and thoughtful search, and
[34:21]
frankly, I think it would be a
[34:23]
disservice to Dr. Webb herself. Because
[34:26]
for many years Jason Golden
[34:28]
faced criticism because
[34:30]
a formal search was not conducted before
[34:32]
the board appointed him to the position
[34:34]
. Out of an abundance of caution and with respect for everyone
[34:38]
involved, including Dr. Webb,
[34:41]
I believe it is important that we follow a
[34:43]
careful and transparent process
[34:45]
during this time. And again,
[34:48]
Dr. Webb may ultimately be chosen
[34:50]
as our next superintendent,
[34:52]
but conducting a search will give
[34:54]
the community a chance to have confidence
[34:56]
in the process. Thank you very much for your
[34:59]
time.
[35:11]
Hi, I'm Becca Ripley and I have a
[35:12]
middle school student in Grassland and
[35:14]
a high school student in
[35:16]
Franklin. Hello. Well, let's
[35:19]
welcome all the new members.
[35:21]
Thank you so much for serving our
[35:23]
community and our students. We
[35:25]
all appreciate it very much.
[35:28]
We currently have an outstanding interim superintendent
[35:29]
, Dr. Webb. Dr. Webb's 22 years of
[35:32]
advancement within the WCS educational and
[35:34]
administrative system have
[35:36]
provided her with
[35:40]
unique and vital institutional and historical knowledge that would benefit us if she
[35:42]
were to take up this position
[35:44]
permanently. While it is quite possible that there is
[35:46]
no more qualified candidate
[35:48]
than our Dr. Webb, and we have her
[35:50]
track record right in front of us,
[35:52]
and we have this fortuitous opportunity to
[35:54]
generate leadership from within,
[35:56]
we could still have a
[35:58]
competitive and hopefully
[35:59]
transparent search process without spending our hard-
[36:01]
earned WCS funds
[36:03]
on an unnecessary external search firm
[36:05]
. For example,
[36:08]
Wilson County hired a new
[36:10]
superintendent this year, and they received
[36:12]
applications from all over the country without
[36:14]
paying a recruiter. As a parent of
[36:18]
Williamson County schools
[36:20]
and a
[36:21]
county property and sales tax payer,
[36:23]
I find this superfluous expenditure
[36:24]
disappointing, discouraging, and
[36:26]
frankly frustrating. That
[36:29]
search team money could and should be
[36:31]
spent on our underfunded schools
[36:32]
instead of
[36:34]
redundantly lining the pockets of an
[36:36]
Illinois corporation whose
[36:37]
closest partner to Williamson County
[36:39]
is southeast of Huntsville.
[36:41]
People all over Tennessee know about this
[36:43]
vacancy right here in our county,
[36:45]
and there will be no shortage of applicants. Even
[36:48]
without the delightful possibility
[36:50]
of Dr. Webb's interest in making
[36:52]
her temporary position permanent, an
[36:54]
exhaustive and expensive search is
[36:56]
simply unnecessary. Thank you.
[37:00]
so much. Thank you all
[37:06]
again for taking the time to be
[37:08]
here with us this afternoon and
[37:09]
share your feedback. Right now, we will
[37:12]
move on to the approval of the
[37:14]
agenda. Board members, we will do it
[37:16]
by oral vote.
[37:21]
Basically, they've reviewed the
[37:23]
agenda. Everyone in favor, say yes.
[37:26]
Anyone against it? Very good. With that,
[37:29]
we have approved the agenda. Next,
[37:32]
approve the
[37:34]
consent agenda. On the
[37:37]
consent agenda, we approved the minutes of the
[37:39]
August 17, 2026 school board meeting
[37:41]
, the
[37:43]
Fairview High building modification request, the
[37:45]
band shed, field trip fees,
[37:47]
and board policy on second
[37:49]
reading 6.415 regarding
[37:51]
applied behavior analysis with
[37:53]
private payment within
[37:55]
school institutions. We will also hold an
[37:58]
oral vote to approve the
[38:00]
common agenda. Does anyone have any questions
[38:02]
about the
[38:03]
consent agenda? OK. Very well,
[38:07]
since there is no discussion, all those who
[38:09]
are in favor of approving the
[38:11]
consent agenda, say yes.
[38:14]
Anyone against it? Very well, we have
[38:17]
approved the
[38:18]
consent agenda. Now, we move on to
[38:22]
communications with the board with the
[38:23]
report from the superintendent, Dr.
[38:25]
Webb.
[38:26]
Thank you, Madam President. First,
[38:27]
I want to thank those who came
[38:29]
this afternoon and spoke about the
[38:30]
audience's comments. In case you didn't
[38:32]
know, at the top of the well,
[38:34]
around the center, are
[38:36]
all our
[38:37]
assistant superintendents from all the
[38:39]
Williamson County Schools departments.
[38:41]
As public comments come in
[38:43]
, they take into careful consideration the topics
[38:45]
presented for discussion and the
[38:47]
concerns raised.
[38:48]
Therefore, in addition to contacting
[38:50]
you individually after
[38:51]
this meeting, we will also analyze
[38:53]
the issues you have raised and
[38:54]
ensure we follow up
[38:56]
with the board regarding them. A
[38:58]
perfect example is our
[39:00]
bus and transport department. We continue
[39:02]
working on our routes and on the
[39:03]
recruitment and retention of our
[39:04]
bus drivers. It's something we're
[39:06]
constantly working on, so we'll keep
[39:09]
you updated on it as well. I also want to
[39:10]
thank the students who come to
[39:12]
speak. It's very stressful. I can speak
[39:15]
from my own seat. Sometimes it's
[39:16]
stressful sitting in these
[39:17]
seats. But to be a student and
[39:19]
step forward and get up on the podium to
[39:21]
share something you're passionate about, I just
[39:23]
want to congratulate you on your leadership and
[39:24]
thank you for being here tonight
[39:26]
. And while we continue with
[39:30]
our superintendent's report, I just want to
[39:32]
share with you my vision for
[39:33]
this year regarding our
[39:35]
school visits. And, obviously, one
[39:38]
of the things I do as
[39:39]
superintendent is go in and out of
[39:40]
school buildings and classrooms. And
[39:42]
this academic year, I made the
[39:44]
decision to visit classrooms and
[39:45]
schools based on the groups. And
[39:48]
for the past 6 weeks, I've
[39:49]
been in the Spring Hill group at
[39:51]
Thompson's Station and at the schools
[39:52]
that feed into Summit High School. And
[39:55]
those have been
[39:56]
phenomenal conversations and a great
[39:58]
learning experience about each group, from
[40:00]
kindergarten through 12th grade. On
[40:02]
those visits, I have the opportunity to
[40:03]
talk with bus drivers,
[40:05]
students, staff, teachers, and
[40:06]
leaders. They've been pretty phenomenal
[40:09]
. Therefore, each month we will highlight the
[40:12]
group I have just visited. And this month,
[40:16]
in our working session,
[40:18]
we celebrated and recognized
[40:20]
Thompson Station Elementary,
[40:23]
Allendale, Bethesda, and Chapman's Retreat schools
[40:26]
. They came to our work session
[40:27]
and our students became
[40:29]
teachers and taught us a few
[40:30]
things. Some of the things they
[40:32]
taught us on Thursday night
[40:34]
were the mission statement.
[40:35]
Our board members have
[40:37]
a copy of
[40:38]
Bethesda's mission statement. They wanted them to make sure they
[40:40]
remembered what they had been
[40:41]
taught. We won't have an exam, don't
[40:43]
worry, but they showed us their
[40:44]
mission statement. We had
[40:46]
groups of students who
[40:47]
showed us art projects and
[40:49]
replicated the process that their teachers
[40:51]
had followed to teach them about
[40:53]
art and create art. We learned about the
[40:55]
books the students were
[40:56]
reading as they prepared for the
[40:58]
Elementary School Book Battle. It was
[41:00]
a wonderful evening and we want to
[41:02]
thank the directors, especially
[41:04]
Tiffany Dukes from Thompson Station,
[41:06]
Anthony Johnson from Allendale, Karen
[41:08]
Caldwell from Bethesda and Michelle
[41:10]
Hummel from Chapman's Retreat. It was a
[41:11]
great experience and the students
[41:13]
did a fantastic job. It was
[41:16]
great to celebrate them. As part of that
[41:19]
group, we celebrated a great practice we
[41:21]
saw there, which was the Golden
[41:23]
Mentors. We would like to highlight a program that takes
[41:26]
place in our
[41:28]
primary schools, where grandparents and
[41:29]
retirees return to our schools
[41:31]
as volunteers and participate in
[41:32]
our reading program and
[41:34]
volunteer with our
[41:35]
students. It was great to hear about
[41:38]
that great program that's going on
[41:39]
. And of course, tonight,
[41:41]
before this meeting, we highlight
[41:43]
our high schools. Spring
[41:45]
Station was here and we heard a
[41:47]
great broadcast from our
[41:48]
student broadcasters, the
[41:50]
Thompson Station Middle Orchestra, the
[41:51]
Summit High School Corrale, and of
[41:53]
course, they joined us tonight
[41:55]
with some beautiful music. So
[41:57]
we want to thank those students
[41:59]
for being here and their principal Sarah
[42:00]
Lamb, Paula Waits and Jason Loudon
[42:02]
for their respectful support of those schools
[42:04]
. One of the questions I ask when
[42:06]
I'm in the building, no matter
[42:08]
who I'm talking to, is, "What do you
[42:10]
love about this school? What makes
[42:12]
your school community unique as a
[42:14]
student, as a teacher, as a
[42:15]
bus driver?" Therefore,
[42:17]
I want to share with you some of
[42:19]
the words that were
[42:20]
constantly repeated to me in this group. What
[42:23]
students, teachers,
[42:25]
staff, and leaders love is the sense
[42:27]
of community, the people, the pride, the
[42:30]
relationships, the hearts of the
[42:31]
people who lead in those buildings.
[42:34]
And it was a great experience to feel the
[42:37]
culture alive and well in that
[42:39]
kindergarten up to grade 12 within
[42:41]
that group. Therefore, I want to
[42:43]
especially thank our
[42:45]
leaders from those schools who are in
[42:46]
the room tonight. Thank you for your
[42:48]
leadership. Thank you for the culture you
[42:50]
build. I would like to ask you to stand
[42:52]
to receive
[42:53]
recognition if you are here as
[42:54]
directors in that group tonight.
[43:05]
Thank you for your leadership. I see that
[43:07]
we have many principals and teachers
[43:08]
here. If you are a teacher or leader in
[43:10]
Williamson County, could you
[43:11]
also stand up? Thank you for
[43:22]
being here. As I continue with my
[43:25]
report, I want to remind our
[43:27]
community that we are beginning the
[43:29]
process of adopting our
[43:30]
social studies textbooks, as well as
[43:32]
adopting some
[43:33]
select courses for career
[43:35]
and technical education. And that process begins
[43:38]
tonight. We will sign and finalize the
[43:40]
committee that will begin that process in
[43:43]
the coming weeks. In the coming
[43:47]
months, from December to February,
[43:48]
we will have approximately 99 hours of
[43:50]
community time where
[43:52]
community members can come and review
[43:54]
those materials. You can see those dates
[43:57]
and the timeline for the
[43:58]
full adoption of the
[44:00]
social studies textbooks. You can see it in
[44:02]
our board package, which is
[44:03]
on our website. Next year
[44:06]
, for 2027-28, we will have the
[44:08]
fine arts adoption process and some
[44:10]
additional CTE courses, but this
[44:11]
year is for social studies and some
[44:13]
additional courses there. I would like to
[44:16]
give special thanks to
[44:18]
our entire Careers and
[44:19]
Technology Department. As Mr.
[44:21]
Wagner shared in his public comment, you
[44:23]
know, we prepare our
[44:24]
students for Careers and Technology
[44:26]
and opportunity for all
[44:28]
walks of life when they cross
[44:29]
our stage, whether they go
[44:31]
directly into the job market, to a
[44:33]
specialized trade, to a
[44:34]
community college, to a 4-
[44:36]
year university, it is important that we have
[44:37]
pathways for every student. And
[44:40]
we highlighted those pathways
[44:42]
last week in the State
[44:43]
of the Schools address we did in
[44:45]
partnership with Williamson Inc. And
[44:47]
our CTE leaders, Jeremy Qualls
[44:49]
, Paula Chilton, and Chris Snyder,
[44:50]
led that in our Center for
[44:52]
Innovation and Entrepreneurship, and
[44:53]
our students did a
[44:55]
fantastic job telling the
[44:57]
story of what
[44:58]
that education is like inside our classrooms
[45:00]
as we prepare for
[45:02]
those pathways. Well, we want to give
[45:05]
special thanks to those leaders.
[45:07]
And since tonight we're highlighting
[45:09]
Summit High School, one of the
[45:10]
student presenters was Adler
[45:12]
Smith, a junior at
[45:13]
Summit High School, who is an
[45:15]
entrepreneur in her own right and runs
[45:16]
her own sportswear business, and
[45:18]
has been part of our
[45:20]
entrepreneurship program since she was in
[45:21]
middle school at Thompson Station.
[45:23]
So, we also want to say hello to her. I'd
[45:26]
also like to introduce
[45:28]
everyone to Sam Jackson, who is here.
[45:30]
He is our new board lawyer and
[45:31]
this is his first school board meeting
[45:33]
. So we want to
[45:34]
officially welcome Sam.
[45:36]
Thank you.
[45:36]
Yes, welcome. And now, I'd like to
[45:39]
hand the floor to the fabulous Corey
[45:41]
Mason from our
[45:43]
Communications Department. Welcome, good sir
[45:45]
.
[45:46]
Thank you, Dr. Webb, and good night
[45:48]
everyone. We have a great group of
[45:50]
Spotlight Award winners
[45:52]
tonight, including four
[45:54]
national champions. We'll start with three of the
[45:58]
students who won gold medals
[46:00]
at the National Special Olympics
[46:02]
last summer, including Delaney
[46:05]
Heflin from Franklin High School
[46:07]
. You see her here, she's on the
[46:09]
right with the gold medal hanging around her
[46:11]
neck and a big smile. She won the
[46:13]
gold medal in the
[46:15]
unified women's doubles
[46:17]
pickleball competition. I am very proud of her
[46:20]
. And pickleball must be a
[46:22]
regular thing at Franklin High School
[46:23]
because Rogan Rivers, a
[46:26]
Franklin High School student, also competed there. He
[46:27]
is on the right and won the
[46:29]
traditional doubles
[46:31]
pickleball competition, earning the
[46:33]
gold medal. Congratulations to him. And then there's
[46:36]
Kimley Wood, from
[46:38]
Ravenwood High School, whose
[46:39]
favorite sport is swimming. He won a
[46:41]
gold medal in the
[46:44]
4 x 25 yard freestyle relay. Congratulations
[46:47]
to them. And continuing with the topic of
[46:49]
athletics, at Page High School
[46:51]
, their athletic department
[46:53]
is doing great things. In fact, they just
[46:56]
received the
[46:58]
Quality Program Evaluation Designation
[47:00]
from the National Association of
[47:04]
Interscholastic Sports Administrators. Guys, this is
[47:07]
very important. They are one of
[47:10]
only two schools in the state of
[47:12]
Tennessee to have earned this
[47:14]
designation, which is awarded to programs
[47:16]
that have exceptionally
[47:18]
high standards in the areas of operations,
[47:20]
leadership, and safety. The
[47:23]
athletic director at Page High School
[47:25]
is Benji Gray, and he's doing a great
[47:27]
job. Next, we have
[47:30]
some state championships that we would
[47:32]
like to acknowledge. At
[47:34]
Page High School, the Future
[47:36]
Farmers of America program is doing
[47:38]
extremely well. The students you
[47:40]
see here, Grace Snyder, Sam Hatch,
[47:42]
Ben Delvin, and Scarlett Hendrickson,
[47:44]
won first place in the
[47:48]
high school dairy judges competition
[47:50]
during the summer at the Tennessee State Fair
[47:52]
. In fact, this is the
[47:54]
second year in a row that they have won this
[47:55]
competition. So they're right
[47:57]
at Page High School,
[47:59]
where their teacher is Tommy Green.
[48:02]
Not to be outdone, Page High School
[48:03]
also has an
[48:05]
exceptional FFA program. In fact, they have just
[48:07]
received the
[48:09]
national designation of three-star chapter
[48:11]
, which is the highest rating
[48:14]
a chapter can achieve in the
[48:16]
world of FFA. In fact, this is the
[48:18]
third consecutive year they have received
[48:19]
this designation. The teacher is
[48:22]
Shanna Botella. We talked a little while ago
[48:25]
about Page and the great work they are
[48:27]
doing in the world of athletics.
[48:29]
Well, this is proof of that.
[48:31]
We would like to share with you some
[48:32]
highlights of our staff. James
[48:34]
Ickoff, from Page High School, has just been
[48:36]
named the TSSAA Coach of the Year
[48:39]
in girls' golf. Congratulations
[48:41]
to him. And then Dana Fassano is the
[48:45]
girls' lacrosse coach of the year at Page High School. At
[48:49]
Independence High School, Luke Finley is
[48:52]
seen there wearing the gray t-shirt.
[48:54]
He received the
[48:56]
TSSAA Men's Cross Country Coach of the Year award
[48:58]
. And then Indy's rival,
[49:03]
Summit High School, Warren Reiker, who
[49:05]
did a great job at Summit, was
[49:06]
named volleyball coach of the year
[49:08]
, where he worked and helped the
[49:09]
team win a state championship
[49:11]
last year. And then our last
[49:15]
highlight of the night, guys,
[49:17]
is really special. We went to the
[49:19]
archives and found a new photo
[49:21]
of Harriet Medlin. If they know her, they
[49:23]
adore her. Harriet retired
[49:25]
last year after 57 years in the world
[49:28]
of education. She continues to be a
[49:30]
coach, continues to change lives, and continues to
[49:32]
do great work in the world of
[49:34]
public speaking and debate. Well, the
[49:37]
Tennessee High School Speech and Drama
[49:40]
League, the THSSDL, let me
[49:42]
double-check the name, presented her with
[49:44]
a lifetime achievement award this
[49:46]
summer for all the work she has
[49:49]
done over the years. And
[49:52]
not only that, they also went a step
[49:54]
further. They gave him the award and,
[49:56]
later, decided to name it after him
[49:58]
. So, from now on
[50:00]
, it will be known as the
[50:02]
Harriet Medlin Lifetime Achievement Award.
[50:05]
Congratulations to Harriet and congratulations
[50:07]
to all our outstanding winners
[50:09]
this month.
[50:12]
Thank you, Mr. Mason. And Madam
[50:14]
President, with this my
[50:15]
report concludes.
[50:16]
Thank you so much. Okay, the next item on the
[50:19]
agenda is the president's report
[50:20]
. There is no report from the
[50:22]
chairman of the board tonight, so we will
[50:24]
move on to new business. The
[50:26]
first item on the new agenda is the
[50:29]
textbook adoption committee's approval for the adoption of
[50:31]
social studies in March. I was going to say
[50:34]
Mr. Dr. Webb.
[50:36]
Thank you, Madam President. Okay,
[50:38]
our first memorandum for your
[50:40]
approval here is a point of
[50:41]
contention regarding the textbook committee
[50:43]
. And again, you will see here that it is
[50:45]
for social studies and in the areas
[50:47]
of professional and technical education,
[50:49]
human services, and administration and
[50:51]
entrepreneurship. This includes our
[50:53]
teachers, parents, and
[50:54]
our school board members who will act
[50:56]
as our representatives on this
[50:57]
committee. As a reminder, all
[50:59]
board members are ad
[51:01]
hoc members of the committee, but are not
[51:02]
voting members, including Ms.
[51:04]
Tanya Hibner, who will act on the
[51:06]
committee because you, as the board,
[51:07]
have the final vote. Therefore, they are
[51:09]
voting members in the end with
[51:11]
regard to the materials and their
[51:13]
adoption. This is the committee I
[51:15]
recommend and I recommend its approval.
[51:18]
Very good. Thank you so much. Do we have a
[51:22]
motion? Yes, okay. I see a
[51:24]
motion by Ms. Calcoat and one
[51:26]
seconded by Donna Clements. Now, the
[51:29]
floor is open for discussion on
[51:31]
this point. Very good. Since there is no
[51:37]
debate, we will proceed to the vote.
[51:49]
12 in favor, zero against.
[51:53]
And with this, the
[51:54]
textbook adoption committee for the
[51:56]
adoption of social studies in March is approved
[51:58]
. Moving on to the next point, the
[52:01]
approval of the collaborative conference team
[52:03]
, Dr. Webb.
[52:04]
Thank you, Madam President. WCS is
[52:07]
in the second year of a
[52:09]
three-year memorandum of understanding with WCEA, and TCA
[52:11]
stipulates that we must conduct an
[52:13]
annual review of pay,
[52:14]
grievance procedures, benefits, and
[52:17]
working conditions. So, this
[52:19]
is your chance to vote to approve
[52:22]
this committee. We have asked Ashley
[52:24]
Slaughter to chair this committee this
[52:26]
year in our
[52:27]
Human Resources Department. As many of
[52:29]
you know, this is a committee I
[52:30]
have chaired before, so
[52:31]
we are grateful to Ashley for
[52:33]
stepping up to lead it.
[52:34]
I recommend its approval.
[52:37]
Thank you, Dr. Webb. I see we have a
[52:39]
motion from Ms. Wyatt and one
[52:41]
seconded by Ms. Kenneine. And now
[52:43]
the floor is open for
[52:45]
debate. Very well, since there is no debate,
[52:51]
we will proceed to the vote.
[52:59]
is 12 in favor and
[53:00]
zero against.
[53:02]
And with that, we have approved the
[53:05]
collaborative conference team's approval. The next
[53:08]
item on the agenda is the
[53:10]
approval of the board's parameters
[53:12]
for the 2027-28 school calendar
[53:13]
. Dr. Webb.
[53:15]
Thank you, Madam President. This is an
[53:16]
annual voting point. The
[53:18]
school board has the opportunity, before
[53:20]
we begin the
[53:22]
calendar process for the next
[53:23]
school year, to set the
[53:25]
calendar parameters if they so wish. In
[53:29]
recent years we have not voted on
[53:31]
any parameters and have simply
[53:33]
allowed our
[53:34]
calendar committee to listen to our comments
[53:36]
through debate and take them into
[53:38]
account as they do their work
[53:40]
and report on those
[53:41]
feedback points rather than going
[53:43]
ahead with the parameters. I noted
[53:46]
in our working session that
[53:48]
we had three talking points
[53:50]
from the board that we requested the
[53:52]
committee to consider. The first is
[53:55]
the commemoration of September 11th
[53:56]
so that this day is added to the
[53:58]
calendar. The second was the
[54:00]
consideration of early dismissal days
[54:01]
for the primary to
[54:03]
discuss them with respect to a
[54:04]
transition to Fridays. And the third
[54:07]
was a consideration of the dates on
[54:09]
which we have elections and how we conduct
[54:11]
school, whether we should be
[54:12]
open or closed, taking
[54:14]
careful consideration with regard to
[54:15]
election days. Those are the
[54:18]
three points of discussion that,
[54:20]
beyond any parameters, they will take
[54:22]
and move forward with. As you know, this
[54:25]
is a committee that I have chaired for
[54:27]
the past 8 years, and some of the
[54:29]
things I want you to know that this
[54:30]
committee does annually,
[54:32]
regardless of its parameters,
[54:33]
is that its number one goal is to
[54:35]
ensure that we have the best
[54:36]
possible educational calendar. And that's why
[54:40]
they rely, of course, on all the
[54:41]
policies of the state and local board,
[54:44]
but that's the first objective they
[54:45]
discuss. They aim for a balance of days
[54:48]
in each quarter. They review the
[54:50]
start and end dates,
[54:51]
breaks, and attendance data as they
[54:53]
pertain to them. They review
[54:55]
local and national election days and holidays
[54:57]
, and they review feedback
[54:59]
from the board and our
[55:01]
school community. I don't have a recommendation
[55:04]
for them to proceed with the
[55:05]
parameters, but of course, that's
[55:07]
a decision and a motion they can
[55:09]
make this afternoon.
[55:11]
Thank you, Dr. Webb. I see a motion
[55:14]
by Mrs. Hidema and one seconded
[55:16]
by Mrs. Kelso. Any
[55:19]
discussion? Yes, Mrs. Wyatt.
[55:24]
Thank you, Madam President. I believe
[55:26]
we also discussed in the
[55:27]
working session, I think Dr. Padgett
[55:29]
mentioned the continuation of the two
[55:31]
years we would have with the
[55:33]
school calendar. If we could continue with
[55:34]
that, I think our families would
[55:36]
really appreciate it. Thank you.
[55:42]
Very well, since there are no further discussions,
[55:44]
we will proceed to the vote. Well, what
[55:55]
we will vote on is that there are no parameters
[55:58]
for the 2027-28 calendar, just to
[56:01]
make that clear.
[56:08]
There are 12 votes in favor, zero against.
[56:11]
Very well, we have approved that there will be no
[56:14]
parameters for the 2027-28 school calendar
[56:16]
. Moving on to the approval of the
[56:19]
calendar committee composition
[56:21]
, Dr. Webb.
[56:22]
Thank you, Madam President. As
[56:23]
you will see here, we have our
[56:24]
calendar committee that is ready to
[56:26]
begin its work without parameters. And
[56:28]
I recommend its approval. Jenny Lopez
[56:30]
will chair this committee.
[56:35]
Very well, I see a motion from Dr.
[56:36]
Driggers and one seconded by Ms.
[56:38]
Wyatt. Does anyone have any points to
[56:41]
discuss? Okay, since we didn't see any,
[56:46]
we voted to approve the composition
[56:47]
of the calendar committee.
[56:56]
The vote is 12 in favor and
[56:57]
zero against.
[56:59]
Thank you, and we have approved the
[57:01]
calendar committee. Moving on to the
[57:03]
approval to renew the
[57:05]
interim superintendent's contract. Oh,
[57:08]
I'll lead the discussion on this.
[57:10]
So, we had our
[57:12]
district general counsel, Seth Wilson,
[57:14]
amend the contract based on
[57:17]
our conversation at the
[57:19]
work session. Well, you'll see that it now
[57:22]
includes, uh, specifies that
[57:24]
Dr. Webb's tenure will not be
[57:27]
affected if she returns to her position as
[57:29]
assistant superintendent of
[57:32]
high schools, and we will also pay
[57:34]
her entire cell phone bill
[57:36]
that will be reimbursed to her as
[57:38]
regards work use. So,
[57:40]
those two changes have been made.
[57:43]
We have a motion in Dr. Driggers' room
[57:45]
, seconded by Mr.
[57:46]
Bostick. Are there any other discussions
[57:48]
related to that? Well, since we didn't see
[57:53]
any, we were going to vote to approve
[57:55]
her interim superintendent contract
[57:58]
.
[58:04]
Vote: 12 in favor, zero against.
[58:08]
And with that vote, we have approved the
[58:10]
interim superintendent's contract.
[58:13]
Now, we move on to the approval of the
[58:14]
superintendent search firm
[58:16]
. So, we discussed this too;
[58:19]
we had an intense discussion in the
[58:21]
working session. And where we left off
[58:24]
is that you are all welcome to
[58:26]
make a motion to discuss
[58:28]
anything you wish to discuss
[58:30]
related to the search process
[58:32]
. Well, I see we have a motion
[58:36]
from Mr. Allen and one seconded by
[58:38]
Ms. Calcoat. The floor is yours, Mr.
[58:41]
Allen. I
[58:42]
suppose I would like to recommend that
[58:44]
a motion be put forward to
[58:46]
hire the search firm
[58:48]
Zeal Education to search for a
[58:50]
superintendent for next year. I'm
[58:54]
going to repeat the motion to make it
[58:56]
clear. Therefore, it proposes hiring
[58:59]
Zeal Education Group as a
[59:01]
search firm.
[59:03]
Correct.
[59:03]
For the search for the superintendent.
[59:05]
Correct.
[59:06]
Okay. Mrs. Kennan Kennard.
[59:12]
Yes, I want to start a conversation
[59:15]
about that. Obviously, I wasn't sure
[59:18]
what Mr. Allen was going to propose,
[59:23]
but I personally would be
[59:25]
interested in proposing that the board not
[59:28]
hire any of the
[59:30]
private companies. However, if we are going to have
[59:35]
that conversation, I suppose what
[59:38]
I would like to request, before voting,
[59:41]
is that each board member disclose
[59:44]
for the public record whether they have
[59:46]
any personal, professional,
[59:49]
financial, employment, or any other
[59:52]
type of relationship, current or past, with HYA
[59:54]
Associates or Zeal Education Group. I would
[59:59]
also ask members to
[1:00:01]
disclose any such relationship
[1:00:02]
with an owner, employee,
[1:00:03]
consultant, associate, or any other
[1:00:05]
representative acting on behalf of
[1:00:06]
any of the companies. And the reason I
[1:00:10]
ask that is because I know
[1:00:12]
that one of these proposals,
[1:00:13]
specifically Zeal's, came
[1:00:14]
before this board was appointed. And I
[1:00:17]
'm not sure how it got to
[1:00:18]
us. I'm not sure how
[1:00:19]
any of the
[1:00:20]
proposals from the private company reached us.
[1:00:22]
Therefore, I would love to have a
[1:00:23]
conversation about how
[1:00:25]
these proposals came to the board before
[1:00:27]
the board casts any vote,
[1:00:29]
as well as about the disclosure of any
[1:00:31]
possible relationships that may exist.
[1:00:34]
OK.
[1:00:36]
Well, I'll talk about how Zeal, Zeal, the
[1:00:40]
Jeff Melendez guy, proactively submitted the proposal
[1:00:43]
. I believe it was
[1:00:47]
originally sent to Mr. Galbraith.
[1:00:50]
knew he was going to leave
[1:00:52]
the board. So he asked Mr.
[1:00:54]
Melendez to send it to me. At that
[1:00:57]
time I shared it with Mrs. Farmer
[1:01:01]
and Mr. Jackson. And I asked them
[1:01:05]
both if we needed a request
[1:01:07]
for quotation or a request for
[1:01:10]
proposals or a request for
[1:01:12]
qualifications, to which they both
[1:01:14]
replied no because it was
[1:01:17]
professional services that the board was
[1:01:19]
seeking. So that's how
[1:01:23]
Zeal came about. I would like to ask the
[1:01:27]
other board members present
[1:01:29]
if they wish to consider
[1:01:32]
disclosing any conflicts of
[1:01:34]
interest; I suppose that's how
[1:01:36]
I would phrase it. So I'll open a
[1:01:38]
debate about that. I mean, I
[1:01:41]
have no conflict of interest. I did
[1:01:42]
not know Mr. Melendez. So,
[1:02:02]
wait.
[1:02:03]
Say it again. I
[1:02:04]
just want to make sure we have
[1:02:07]
a second motion from Mr. Allen. No,
[1:02:10]
I saw that you seconded the motion, but it was
[1:02:12]
before he made the motion
[1:02:14]
. So I wanted to make sure. I've got you
[1:02:16]
You ended up being second.
[1:02:18]
Ah, okay. There you have it.
[1:02:20]
But, but fine. Well,
[1:02:21]
there's a second one in the room.
[1:02:22]
Yes, now that I know what it is, of course.
[1:02:24]
Thank you. That's all I had. I'm sorry
[1:02:28]
. Okay. Okay. I'm sorry, I did
[1:02:29]
n't mean to...
[1:02:31]
we had one.
[1:02:31]
Yes. Well, what we're discussing
[1:02:34]
is that Ms. Cannine has asked if
[1:02:37]
any other board members
[1:02:38]
wish to disclose whether they have any
[1:02:40]
conflicts of interest with any of the
[1:02:42]
search options that are on the table. I'll make it
[1:02:46]
clear that I won't. Mrs. Anderson.
[1:02:55]
Yes, first of all, I would like to
[1:02:56]
thank Ms. Cannine for that
[1:02:58]
excellent idea. I think it's a great
[1:03:01]
idea. And if I say that I wasn't aware
[1:03:05]
of this company before it was
[1:03:07]
presented to the entire board. I have no
[1:03:11]
connection with any of these
[1:03:13]
people. Yes, but it's good to know.
[1:03:20]
Who's next? Miss
[1:03:22]
Lucian.
[1:03:25]
Similarly, I think it's a good point
[1:03:26]
to mention, but I had never heard
[1:03:28]
of any of the
[1:03:30]
private companies before receiving these
[1:03:31]
proposals.
[1:03:32]
Miss Wyatt. Or, sorry,
[1:03:34]
Miss Kelcode.
[1:03:36]
I'm in the same situation. I have no
[1:03:37]
personal or professional relationship
[1:03:39]
with them. My first introduction to
[1:03:42]
Zeal Education Group was when it was
[1:03:44]
presented to the board of directors.
[1:03:46]
Miss Wyatt.
[1:03:47]
I don't have a
[1:03:49]
professional or personal relationship with them either. Can we
[1:03:51]
also know how we received
[1:03:54]
proposals from HYA and TSBA?
[1:03:57]
Clear. The previous board of directors
[1:03:59]
had discussed TSBA as an option
[1:04:01]
. And we know very well that TSBA
[1:04:03]
provides those services and we are
[1:04:05]
members of TSBA. So I
[1:04:08]
contacted TSBA as well because I
[1:04:10]
realized they were going to be a
[1:04:12]
lower-priced option. So, they sent us
[1:04:15]
an application and then I asked Mr.
[1:04:17]
Meléndez to name a
[1:04:20]
major competitor of his company, and he said HYA and
[1:04:23]
that he used to work for them, so he
[1:04:25]
knew them. So, when I did
[1:04:29]
a search, they were always one of the
[1:04:30]
top companies mentioned
[1:04:32]
for superintendent searches. And I
[1:04:35]
also knew they would be at the
[1:04:37]
top end. So, the goal
[1:04:40]
was to have a lower-priced option
[1:04:41]
, a mid-priced option, which
[1:04:43]
was Yeager, and a higher-priced option
[1:04:45]
. And as we all know, there are
[1:04:49]
many different options, but I felt
[1:04:53]
that three was kind of a
[1:04:56]
standard number and yes, asking for more proposals
[1:04:59]
could sometimes make
[1:05:02]
decision-making more difficult. So.
[1:05:10]
Miss Padgett or Dr. Padgett,
[1:05:12]
sorry. You
[1:05:14]
can call me Margie. I
[1:05:17]
'm getting used to Padgett too. Thank you
[1:05:20]
for asking that question. I hadn't heard
[1:05:23]
of any of the companies
[1:05:25]
except TSBA, and that's because we
[1:05:26]
were members before
[1:05:28]
the proposals came to us.
[1:05:32]
And Mrs. Clements?
[1:05:33]
Thank you, Madam President. I just
[1:05:35]
want to point out that I hadn't heard
[1:05:37]
of Zeal or HYA until they
[1:05:40]
arrived in our package, and of
[1:05:42]
course I did know about TSBA.
[1:05:47]
Mrs. Hima?
[1:05:50]
Yes, I haven't heard of HYA or
[1:05:52]
Zeal, but I also reflected a bit
[1:05:55]
on why we're doing this
[1:05:57]
nationwide search, so I wrote
[1:06:00]
some comments that I'd like to
[1:06:02]
share before making that proposal.
[1:06:07]
I think it's important to ask
[1:06:08]
why we are requesting this
[1:06:09]
national search. I believe our
[1:06:12]
interim leadership preserves the stability of
[1:06:14]
our district this year,
[1:06:15]
but also gives our community
[1:06:17]
a real voice in setting the
[1:06:18]
future direction of
[1:06:20]
Williamson County schools. The election of
[1:06:23]
a chief executive officer is arguably
[1:06:26]
the most consequential vote that
[1:06:28]
a school board casts. And it's not a place
[1:06:31]
for convenience or taking shortcuts
[1:06:33]
. Our job is
[1:06:36]
fiduciary oversight. To demonstrate to our
[1:06:38]
contributors and our families
[1:06:40]
that our next superintendent
[1:06:42]
survived the toughest,
[1:06:44]
broadest, and most validated market possible. And this
[1:06:47]
process is not just about collecting
[1:06:48]
resumes. Williamson County schools
[1:06:51]
are at the top
[1:06:53]
of the state rankings, which means that
[1:06:55]
status quo thinking is our
[1:06:58]
biggest enemy. A
[1:07:01]
real national search partner provides us with
[1:07:03]
structured community insights to
[1:07:05]
manage rapid growth and
[1:07:07]
budgets. Oh I'm sorry.
[1:07:10]
Structured
[1:07:12]
community information to define the
[1:07:14]
exact leadership profile we need right now
[1:07:16]
. And Zeal offers this profile of
[1:07:19]
people, and some of those examples
[1:07:20]
would be someone who could manage
[1:07:23]
growth and budgets or
[1:07:24]
someone who connects
[1:07:27]
district operations to run smoothly
[1:07:28]
or who plans
[1:07:30]
ahead for the future needs
[1:07:32]
of the community. Those are just three of
[1:07:35]
the different people who share
[1:07:39]
with the community. And there are also many
[1:07:41]
opinions from the community that I know
[1:07:44]
our community wants. We need
[1:07:47]
someone who will not only maintain a
[1:07:49]
top ranking in the state,
[1:07:50]
but also compare us to
[1:07:52]
national excellence, while keeping
[1:07:54]
daily operations stable for
[1:07:56]
our students and faculty. That
[1:07:59]
is the diagnostic rigor we
[1:08:00]
need. And while I
[1:08:03]
deeply appreciate the vital advocacy and
[1:08:06]
multifaceted support that TSBA
[1:08:08]
provides to our district year
[1:08:10]
after year, a mandate of this magnitude
[1:08:13]
requires a partner with a singular
[1:08:15]
and absolute focus on executing our
[1:08:18]
search. And of the three companies we
[1:08:21]
interviewed in our
[1:08:23]
working session on Thursday, I also recommend
[1:08:24]
partnering with Zeal Education Group to
[1:08:26]
help us achieve this. Thank you.
[1:08:30]
Mr. Bostick. Yes, I've never heard
[1:08:33]
of any of the
[1:08:33]
search companies either, so I have no
[1:08:34]
conflict of interest. I assume this
[1:08:39]
is also covered by our official conflict of
[1:08:40]
interest disclosure, correct? Well, I
[1:08:43]
'm not sure about this
[1:08:44]
additional audience. Dr. Triggers.
[1:08:50]
Like everyone else, I didn't know about
[1:08:51]
the other two companies until a few
[1:08:53]
days ago, when we received the package. HYA
[1:08:55]
conducted an exhaustive search on
[1:08:57]
them. HYA faces serious
[1:09:00]
legal challenges over some of its
[1:09:02]
hiring practices. The only
[1:09:06]
superintendent they've hired in
[1:09:09]
Tennessee was Shelby Memphis a few
[1:09:12]
years ago, a couple of years ago. Okay.
[1:09:17]
That's all for me. The other is Zeal, a
[1:09:20]
small company that they can
[1:09:23]
adapt to. Okay. But they have never
[1:09:27]
hired a superintendent in
[1:09:29]
Tennessee. So, what it leaves me with is
[1:09:34]
the TSBA. The day after Jason
[1:09:38]
announced his resignation, I called the
[1:09:41]
TSBA and said, "What the hell do we
[1:09:43]
have here? They've dumped this on us." And
[1:09:48]
I spoke with Ben Torres, the deputy director,
[1:09:50]
and with his legal advisor. OK
[1:09:53]
? We talked about the new statute that
[1:09:58]
Tennessee has. Nobody has mentioned the
[1:10:01]
hot topic here. The
[1:10:05]
Tennessee legislature has given
[1:10:07]
school districts a new way to specifically search for a
[1:10:09]
superintendent. It's never been
[1:10:14]
tried, not in Tennessee, as far as
[1:10:17]
Sam is concerned, help me with this. I
[1:10:21]
don't think any other state is
[1:10:23]
using
[1:10:24]
Tennessee's new superintendent search, although
[1:10:26]
the idea might be floating around
[1:10:28]
. So it's never been done before. If we
[1:10:33]
do that, the TSBA has already drafted the
[1:10:36]
template. They've already figured out how we would do it
[1:10:39]
. We would be the first district in the
[1:10:42]
state of Tennessee to use the
[1:10:45]
new law to find a
[1:10:46]
superintendent. I mentioned in the
[1:10:50]
work session that if we are the
[1:10:52]
spearhead and the first
[1:10:54]
district to use the first
[1:10:57]
new law that the legislature gave us, yes,
[1:11:01]
there will be problems to solve because
[1:11:04]
we will be the first. And no matter what we
[1:11:07]
do, someone isn't going to be
[1:11:09]
happy. I don't mind. Let's go
[1:11:13]
back. Sam, I'm putting you in a
[1:11:16]
tight spot again. You have collaborated in the
[1:11:18]
searches for superintendents in the
[1:11:20]
state of Tennessee.
[1:11:21]
Yes sir.
[1:11:22]
And you've worked with the TSBA on some
[1:11:25]
of those searches.
[1:11:26]
Yes sir.
[1:11:27]
Okay. The TSBA would do it faster and
[1:11:32]
for much less money, and it's the only
[1:11:36]
firm that knows how to hire a
[1:11:40]
superintendent if the board accepts
[1:11:44]
Tennessee's new law. Nobody else knows
[1:11:48]
how to do it. OK? And the TSBA
[1:11:53]
has hired 30 superintendents in
[1:11:55]
the state of Tennessee in the last
[1:11:57]
5 years. I haven't heard any
[1:12:00]
problems with those 30 new registrations. So,
[1:12:04]
for those reasons and maybe some others
[1:12:06]
, if you asked me, I would support the
[1:12:11]
TSBA for those reasons. Now, we can
[1:12:15]
discard this second part. Nobody
[1:12:19]
knows Williamson County better
[1:12:22]
than the TSBA. Nobody knows the
[1:12:26]
school district better than Dr. Webb. Spot. They do
[1:12:30]
n't exist. You're not going to go anywhere
[1:12:32]
in the other 49 states and find
[1:12:34]
someone who's better or
[1:12:36]
smarter than what we already have. And
[1:12:39]
we pay our TSBA membership fee, which was
[1:12:41]
established by the legislature to
[1:12:42]
help school districts. And they
[1:12:46]
are there to help us. So I
[1:12:49]
say let's give them a chance. That
[1:12:52]
's all. I don't know where that leaves us with
[1:12:55]
the motions, but
[1:12:56]
hey, we're still debating.
[1:12:58]
OK. OK.
[1:12:59]
Mrs. Cannine. Well, I
[1:13:01]
just wanted to echo
[1:13:03]
Dr. Driggers' statements
[1:13:06]
regarding the TSBA. As I mentioned
[1:13:09]
before, I personally would be inclined
[1:13:10]
not to vote for either of the two
[1:13:12]
private firms. So, if that's what we
[1:13:16]
're putting to a vote, my
[1:13:18]
vote would be no. I have no objection to
[1:13:21]
considering the TSBA, and I have no objection
[1:13:23]
to considering Dr. Webb's appointment
[1:13:24]
, but I just wanted to put that on
[1:13:25]
record during our discussion.
[1:13:30]
Dr. Padgett.
[1:13:33]
In the working session, one of
[1:13:36]
our concerns with the TSBA was
[1:13:38]
whether they could conduct a
[1:13:39]
nationwide search. So, I contacted
[1:13:42]
Ben Torres on Saturday, and they are indeed conducting
[1:13:45]
a nationwide search. He
[1:13:48]
shared with us that they have networks where
[1:13:50]
they can post
[1:13:52]
job offers. He mentioned some
[1:13:56]
states: Alaska, Georgia, Idaho,
[1:13:58]
Illinois, Indiana, etc. They also
[1:14:00]
partner with consultants in 38 other
[1:14:03]
states. And then another question I
[1:14:06]
asked them was, well, in how many counties
[1:14:12]
in Tennessee have you conducted searches
[1:14:14]
comparable to ours or
[1:14:16]
larger? Well, they did searches in
[1:14:18]
Sumner County, they had 15
[1:14:20]
applicants, eight of them from out
[1:14:21]
of state. In Rutherford, seven
[1:14:23]
applicants, one from out of state.
[1:14:25]
In Clarksville-Montgomery, they had
[1:14:26]
some applicants from out of
[1:14:28]
state. In Knox County, they had
[1:14:29]
some out-of-
[1:14:30]
state applicants. And one thing that really
[1:14:33]
impressed me about the TSBA was their
[1:14:34]
two-year warranty. So, if the
[1:14:36]
superintendent were to leave within
[1:14:39]
two years, they would conduct the
[1:14:40]
search again free of charge. And so far
[1:14:43]
, in those four large counties I
[1:14:45]
mentioned, the superintendents
[1:14:47]
are there. My other concerns
[1:14:50]
with search companies, you know
[1:14:52]
, I have 30 years of experience in
[1:14:55]
education. I have worked in three
[1:14:57]
different states, and each state has
[1:14:59]
a very different education law. And when we
[1:15:03]
conducted a nationwide search, we still
[1:15:05]
wanted someone who was well-
[1:15:08]
versed in Tennessee state law.
[1:15:11]
Because, as I said, every time I went to
[1:15:15]
a new state, I had to figure out,
[1:15:16]
"Okay, what are the laws here and
[1:15:18]
how do I operate?" And the last thing I want to
[1:15:22]
warn you about regarding
[1:15:24]
educational consulting firms is that they have their
[1:15:27]
network, but often people have to
[1:15:30]
attend their events or pay their
[1:15:32]
fees to be part of that network. And
[1:15:36]
one of my concerns is that
[1:15:38]
we'll get someone who keeps
[1:15:40]
rising through the ranks in different
[1:15:43]
districts and that with that process... So I'm
[1:15:46]
going to vote against Zeal. Very
[1:15:51]
well, Mrs. Anderson. I
[1:15:56]
just wanted people to know that,
[1:15:58]
at first, when I was looking for
[1:15:59]
search companies, I had
[1:16:00]
different doubts. They had an
[1:16:06]
extraordinarily expensive company. Um, where uh, not only was its base level high, uh,
[1:16:12]
but also the additional cost you
[1:16:15]
could incur was also
[1:16:17]
high. And that made it seem like, uh, I
[1:16:21]
couldn't say for sure if it would be worth it
[1:16:24]
. Now, I had some
[1:16:27]
doubts about Zeal until I was
[1:16:29]
advised to get in touch and
[1:16:32]
talk to Mr. Malendez myself
[1:16:35]
. And these are the things that
[1:16:38]
stood out to me if we decided to do
[1:16:41]
that. The people in charge of
[1:16:45]
the search and who are in charge of
[1:16:48]
our account have been
[1:16:50]
superintendents. So, for every
[1:16:54]
candidate they analyze and send to us,
[1:16:57]
these are analyzed by four or five
[1:17:00]
actual school district superintendents
[1:17:03]
. So, while I'm very
[1:17:06]
good in my experience, I couldn't
[1:17:08]
tell you who the best person in
[1:17:10]
this particular group is without a certain
[1:17:13]
amount of reasonable guidance.
[1:17:16]
Some other things he mentioned, and
[1:17:19]
this is something I think is very
[1:17:22]
important, is that part of this
[1:17:24]
consultancy involves engaging
[1:17:27]
the community to provide their
[1:17:30]
opinions on what the
[1:17:32]
priorities are for a superintendent. The
[1:17:38]
previous superintendent was appointed
[1:17:40]
without much input from the community
[1:17:43]
. I have no complaints against the
[1:17:47]
previous superintendent, but something I
[1:17:49]
've heard time and time again is that there were
[1:17:51]
some people who probably would have
[1:17:53]
preferred someone with an
[1:17:55]
academic background. Those people
[1:17:58]
should be able to make their voices heard.
[1:18:01]
People in
[1:18:04]
special education departments and parents who
[1:18:06]
have such children should be able to make
[1:18:08]
their interests and concerns heard.
[1:18:14]
Bus drivers should be
[1:18:16]
able to... If we don't have a system in
[1:18:18]
place where we can take
[1:18:21]
community opinions into account,
[1:18:23]
then I personally believe we
[1:18:26]
're not serving the community in the
[1:18:28]
best way. The other thing, and I appreciate
[1:18:32]
all the information you sent us, I
[1:18:35]
wanted to say that it is the
[1:18:38]
stakeholders who make me tip
[1:18:41]
the scales in favor of hiring a
[1:18:45]
medium-sized search firm
[1:18:48]
. In fact, I also
[1:18:51]
contacted one of the references
[1:18:53]
after speaking with him and said, "
[1:18:55]
Well, I'm not sure about this." He said to
[1:18:58]
speak with the superintendent
[1:19:00]
about the search we had conducted
[1:19:02]
in South Carolina. And she...Here's
[1:19:07]
something interesting about that
[1:19:09]
particular community: they're south of Charlotte,
[1:19:11]
so even though they're in
[1:19:13]
North Carolina, they have middle-class people, they
[1:19:17]
actually have a lot of
[1:19:18]
students from the local Indian reservations
[1:19:20]
. They had many students from
[1:19:26]
other communities who are more...
[1:19:28]
what's the best way to put it? These were
[1:19:30]
disproportionately lower-income communities
[1:19:34]
, and they used to have
[1:19:37]
school board meetings with 500 people in which they
[1:19:39]
very clearly expressed the
[1:19:41]
concerns they had about what had
[1:19:43]
been a bankrupt district. In the
[1:19:47]
end, they managed to unite the entire community
[1:19:49]
because the community felt
[1:19:51]
that they were being heard. According to what
[1:19:55]
this lady said, they got the
[1:19:58]
Tribal Leadership Group Council,
[1:20:01]
the council, the NAACP, and Moms for Liberty to
[1:20:05]
agree, and I was
[1:20:08]
speechless. And the reason he
[1:20:12]
said that is because of the expert who came
[1:20:14]
during the entire week in which they
[1:20:16]
have community meetings. I can
[1:20:19]
tell you that I don't feel qualified
[1:20:21]
to have these community meetings
[1:20:24]
with this opinion from the community, and
[1:20:26]
for me, the opinion of the community
[1:20:28]
is very important. Finally, I want to
[1:20:31]
thank the community for the feedback we
[1:20:33]
've received, the email support
[1:20:35]
, the calls for
[1:20:37]
fiscal responsibility, and I want to
[1:20:38]
highlight the excellent
[1:20:40]
interim superintendent and candidate, Dr. Webb.
[1:20:44]
I want to ensure that this search
[1:20:45]
includes a process in which Dr.
[1:20:47]
Webb is considered within the pool
[1:20:49]
of candidates and fairly evaluated
[1:20:51]
alongside them. When
[1:20:53]
the final candidate is selected, this
[1:20:55]
process will validate that they are absolutely
[1:20:58]
the best person for the job and
[1:21:00]
will create a foundation of legitimacy. A
[1:21:02]
search can fail in two ways.
[1:21:04]
You can hire the
[1:21:06]
wrong candidate and that becomes obvious quickly, or you
[1:21:08]
can fail to clearly define the
[1:21:09]
job parameters within the
[1:21:11]
community, and that's also a failure, just a
[1:21:13]
more subtle one. Finally,
[1:21:17]
regarding cost, the minimum cost of the
[1:21:21]
TSBA is $15,000. Therefore, it
[1:21:23]
is not zero. They don't do the
[1:21:26]
community outreach work we
[1:21:27]
're talking about here. They don't have
[1:21:31]
staff whose job is to find
[1:21:33]
candidates. The other company says it
[1:21:37]
will conduct criminal,
[1:21:39]
financial, DMV, and
[1:21:41]
media checks on the candidates they
[1:21:43]
screen for us. The TSBA doesn't do
[1:21:47]
that. And this other company is at around
[1:21:53]
50,000 plus maybe a small
[1:21:55]
amount for travel expenses. An
[1:21:58]
excellent superintendent will make up for
[1:22:01]
that difference in no time. Out of a
[1:22:05]
budget of $500 million, this
[1:22:08]
cost is 1/10,000 of one percent
[1:22:13]
of the budget. So that's what I
[1:22:16]
wanted to say about it, and
[1:22:18]
I'll vote for Zeal.
[1:22:21]
Thank you, Mrs. Padgett, Dr. Padgett.
[1:22:24]
Well, I'm glad you
[1:22:25]
mentioned that TSBA does engage with
[1:22:28]
voters because they hold meetings with
[1:22:30]
them. They also conduct surveys and
[1:22:32]
said they would give us a few
[1:22:33]
more days if we felt it was
[1:22:35]
necessary. For me, the big difference
[1:22:40]
between TSBA and Zeal is that Zeal has
[1:22:42]
some advantages. They have the people
[1:22:45]
and they have a control panel. TSBA
[1:22:49]
has committed to holding meetings and
[1:22:55]
surveys with voters and then
[1:22:57]
providing us with the data. And now, with
[1:23:00]
survey data or
[1:23:02]
survey tools, it's not
[1:23:03]
difficult to take that data and
[1:23:05]
turn it into a kind of
[1:23:07]
dashboard. Zeal costs $48,000,
[1:23:13]
plus travel expenses. None
[1:23:15]
of them live here. So if
[1:23:17]
they come here for a week,
[1:23:19]
how many people do they send each night, including
[1:23:24]
food, flights, and hours? Yes, it's now
[1:23:29]
$48,000. However, what
[1:23:32]
will the final bill be? Well, and you
[1:23:35]
know, I'm very conservative when it comes to taxes,
[1:23:38]
so I'm always worried about money.
[1:23:42]
That's all I have for now.
[1:23:43]
Okay, Dr. Triggers. Once
[1:23:45]
again, I'm back with Mr. Jackson.
[1:23:49]
Given their personal and
[1:23:51]
professional knowledge, having worked with the
[1:23:54]
TSBA on so many searches, they have bought
[1:23:57]
at three levels: $5,000, $10,000 and
[1:24:00]
$15,000. The $15,000 fee
[1:24:03]
is the platinum level, and I believe that
[1:24:06]
includes community meetings and
[1:24:08]
outreach. Someone said they don't do
[1:24:11]
that. Yes, they do. So, uh, that's
[1:24:14]
true. The
[1:24:15]
understanding is that
[1:24:19]
they will put on the website whatever we
[1:24:21]
tell them to put on the website, which is what
[1:24:23]
we are looking for. And if we choose
[1:24:27]
the 15,000 program, then they
[1:24:29]
will come to Williamson County and
[1:24:32]
help establish it. We haven't really
[1:24:36]
gotten that far. I think everyone
[1:24:38]
wants the community's opinion,
[1:24:40]
okay? Everyone wants the
[1:24:42]
community's opinion. I don't know if Dr. Webb would
[1:24:45]
apply for the position or not. Don't
[1:24:48]
answer that. But if he does,
[1:24:51]
he would be on equal footing with
[1:24:53]
other applicants, and would then either
[1:24:55]
succeed or fail based on his track
[1:24:57]
record. And I think that's all we
[1:25:02]
can ask for.
[1:25:06]
End of my comment.
[1:25:08]
Thank you. Mrs. Anderson.
[1:25:11]
Just one last thing. I just wanted to
[1:25:14]
point out that
[1:25:20]
Zeal's primary business model is to take
[1:25:22]
superintendents and find them, and their
[1:25:25]
primary business model is to
[1:25:28]
engage the community. And they're also
[1:25:33]
doing
[1:25:35]
leadership profile development training and
[1:25:37]
bias training
[1:25:40]
for the board, and other things like that. This
[1:25:43]
is a very important decision. And
[1:25:45]
I want to make sure that people
[1:25:48]
whose primary job is not
[1:25:54]
interpreting the law in Tennessee,
[1:25:55]
which is very, very important, but who
[1:25:57]
are not recruiters, who are not
[1:25:59]
superintendents, and that's the only thing
[1:26:01]
that makes me a little nervous about the
[1:26:02]
TSBA. I'll be happy with whatever
[1:26:06]
the board chooses, but since I've done these
[1:26:08]
additional interviews, I wanted
[1:26:10]
people to know.
[1:26:13]
Mrs. Clements.
[1:26:14]
Thank you, Madam President. First
[1:26:17]
I had a question for Sam. Could you
[1:26:23]
help and guide us with this new
[1:26:27]
Tennessee state law? Because that was
[1:26:30]
one of the attractive things about TSBI,
[1:26:32]
that they know the law, but can they
[1:26:34]
make sure we stay in
[1:26:36]
our lane? I
[1:26:38]
can try, but here's what I'll
[1:26:40]
tell you, which I think everyone has
[1:26:42]
pointed out, the new law, we'll be the
[1:26:44]
first to... So let's walk
[1:26:46]
together on the ice. But yes,
[1:26:49]
ma'am, I'd be happy to help you
[1:26:51]
overcome it and give you my best idea of
[1:26:53]
how it would work.
[1:26:54]
Good. Thank you. Secondly
[1:26:56]
, I think that was the only thing we saw
[1:26:58]
when we analyzed the TSBA model, they
[1:27:00]
only had one day to communicate. I know they
[1:27:03]
said they'd be back for more,
[1:27:04]
but for me, what makes Zeal
[1:27:06]
more appealing is that it offers a
[1:27:08]
much greater amount of
[1:27:10]
community interaction. I think that's very
[1:27:13]
valuable in this situation. I
[1:27:17]
was also doing some research today, I went into a
[1:27:20]
little bit of a topic and a little bit about how we
[1:27:22]
've done
[1:27:24]
superintendent searches in
[1:27:27]
Wilmington County in the past, and I saw that
[1:27:29]
we put a limit on a firm that we
[1:27:31]
put in place years ago, like a couple of
[1:27:34]
decades ago, but we did limit travel
[1:27:37]
and assignment. So I think
[1:27:40]
we could have some framework for that,
[1:27:42]
especially with video and Zoom, to be
[1:27:44]
able to have some meetings where we do
[1:27:45]
n't have to incur a lot of
[1:27:47]
travel expenses. It's just an idea. And
[1:27:50]
finally, I just want to say that,
[1:27:53]
although I know we're thinking about
[1:27:56]
making it a public or
[1:27:58]
search company, that doesn't disqualify, what
[1:28:01]
great work, Dr. Webb. I mean,
[1:28:03]
Dr. Webb is currently doing
[1:28:05]
an interim job, and it's been fun
[1:28:07]
having a front-row seat to watch
[1:28:09]
you in this role. And I know you'll be a
[1:28:11]
strong contender. So I just
[1:28:13]
want to assure the community that I
[1:28:15]
know you will shine in this position, and we
[1:28:17]
look forward to working alongside
[1:28:18]
you and seeing you perform in this
[1:28:20]
new role throughout this year,
[1:28:22]
sir.
[1:28:24]
Mrs. Calcote. I
[1:28:27]
just wanted to second
[1:28:29]
Mrs. Clements' comments. One of the things I
[1:28:31]
deliberately asked TSBA on
[1:28:33]
Thursday afternoon was how much time they
[1:28:35]
give us to receive feedback from the
[1:28:38]
community. And in the plan, there's only one
[1:28:40]
day, whereas with Zeal, we have
[1:28:42]
a whole week of
[1:28:44]
solid community feedback, including
[1:28:47]
public assemblies, Zoom calls,
[1:28:49]
the ability to survey our
[1:28:51]
community, and, you know,
[1:28:53]
community forums. It's simply a
[1:28:56]
more robust approach to ensuring that all
[1:28:58]
stakeholders in our community—
[1:29:01]
parents, teachers,
[1:29:03]
community leaders, and any
[1:29:05]
contributors—can have a say. And then,
[1:29:08]
the other thing that... That's why I think
[1:29:10]
Zeal is the best option, because I don't
[1:29:13]
think that by choosing HYA we'll get
[1:29:15]
stronger
[1:29:17]
community feedback or more services that
[1:29:19]
justify the extra money. Another
[1:29:23]
thing I know is
[1:29:24]
constantly mentioned is the fact that it is
[1:29:25]
a new law. This is the first
[1:29:28]
time a school district has used the
[1:29:30]
new law. For Zeal and HYA, and
[1:29:34]
obviously my vote is for Zeal, but
[1:29:37]
one could argue that Zeal has
[1:29:40]
more experience than TSBA or us
[1:29:43]
because they have conducted
[1:29:46]
confidential and public searches. So,
[1:29:49]
whether it's Tennessee law or another
[1:29:51]
state law, because they travel all over the US,
[1:29:53]
they have more experience than any
[1:29:55]
of us in these kinds of searches.
[1:29:58]
I believe their guidance will be
[1:29:59]
crucial to ensuring that
[1:30:01]
we comply with the law and that this process
[1:30:08]
is transparent. We are receiving the
[1:30:10]
most feedback from the
[1:30:12]
community and are accountable to
[1:30:13]
our internal candidate to
[1:30:15]
ensure that everything is
[1:30:16]
transparent. Therefore, I believe that
[1:30:18]
in order for us to conduct our
[1:30:20]
due diligence as a board, it is
[1:30:22]
really important that we hire
[1:30:24]
a firm that has experience in
[1:30:25]
this area, especially if
[1:30:27]
we decide to use this new approach
[1:30:29]
under the new law.
[1:30:32]
Mr. Bostick.
[1:30:35]
Yes, regarding the cost
[1:30:38]
, I understand that Rachel
[1:30:39]
was discussing that topic
[1:30:41]
last Thursday. It might put you in a
[1:30:45]
difficult position, Rachel. I'm sorry. But you
[1:30:48]
had given us a rough estimate of
[1:30:50]
how far we were going to get there. Because I think there's
[1:30:53]
a misconception that we're
[1:30:55]
asking for additional funding or
[1:30:57]
taking money from other
[1:30:59]
resources to pay for it, or whatever. And
[1:31:02]
that's not the case, right?
[1:31:07]
Correct. So, there were funds for
[1:31:09]
the superintendent position, funds
[1:31:11]
for the assistant
[1:31:12]
high school superintendent that were in the
[1:31:13]
budget that you all voted for.
[1:31:16]
The agreed-upon salary for the
[1:31:18]
interim superintendent was less than
[1:31:20]
the superintendent's budget. And
[1:31:23]
then there's also money left in that
[1:31:25]
assistant superintendent line.
[1:31:28]
So, that's where the
[1:31:29]
money to cover it will come from.
[1:31:32]
Whoever they end up voting for
[1:31:34]
next month, we will introduce a
[1:31:35]
resolution to move the money from a
[1:31:37]
payroll line to a
[1:31:39]
contracted service line. But we weren't going to
[1:31:42]
do that until we knew how much
[1:31:44]
money, or how much estimated money,
[1:31:46]
needed to be moved. So, if the
[1:31:48]
money is not spent, if it is moved, every
[1:31:50]
time money is not spent, and this is
[1:31:51]
true for any
[1:31:52]
budget line, it will be transferred to the
[1:31:54]
balance of funds at the end of the year. We can't
[1:31:56]
just move or spend
[1:31:58]
money on anything else. It will
[1:32:00]
always depend on you how
[1:32:02]
the funds can be spent if
[1:32:04]
a change is made.
[1:32:05]
OK.
[1:32:06]
Can you give us a rough estimate of
[1:32:08]
what that is?
[1:32:09]
It was one hundred thousand dollars, Thank you. Yes,
[1:32:15]
I believe it is important to make it
[1:32:16]
clear to everyone the
[1:32:18]
exact origin of that money in
[1:32:20]
question. Also, I'm undecided
[1:32:26]
between TSBA and Zeal. I'm leaning towards Zeal.
[1:32:30]
I think everyone has given very
[1:32:32]
good arguments about this. But I know I'm
[1:32:34]
totally in favor of
[1:32:36]
doing a real search. And that's
[1:32:40]
because I think it's the fairest thing for
[1:32:44]
Lee. Lee is amazing. I have
[1:32:49]
thoroughly enjoyed my time on the board
[1:32:51]
getting to know Lee, and especially
[1:32:53]
since he took on this new role, he has
[1:32:55]
impressed me greatly so far. But
[1:32:59]
I want you to know that if you receive this
[1:33:01]
position, you have received it on your own
[1:33:04]
merits and it was not given to you because it was
[1:33:06]
the easiest and cheapest thing to do.
[1:33:10]
I believe we also owe him that
[1:33:12]
confidence in his work. It's incredible. I
[1:33:15]
fully believe that. Never, but if
[1:33:17]
everyone else believes it too,
[1:33:19]
we should allow her to continue the
[1:33:21]
process and defend herself. And that's all I have to
[1:33:23]
say about it
[1:33:26]
Thank you. Mrs. Connine, you have all the
[1:33:28]
recognition. I
[1:33:29]
just wanted to thank Ms.
[1:33:33]
Anderson for mentioning the fact that
[1:33:35]
Zeal uses current
[1:33:37]
or former superintendents as part of its
[1:33:39]
search process. I'm not sure if
[1:33:44]
anyone investigated the people
[1:33:45]
appointed to our
[1:33:47]
search team. I sought out the people on
[1:33:50]
our search team because that's just the way I
[1:33:52]
am as a person. And I think it's worth
[1:33:57]
noting that none of the
[1:33:59]
senior associates who would be part
[1:34:01]
of our search had trouble-
[1:34:02]
free superintendent careers
[1:34:04]
. In fact, one was
[1:34:06]
sued by his state for not
[1:34:07]
implementing the curriculum
[1:34:08]
correctly. That was Dr. David
[1:34:10]
Myerschough, who is one of the
[1:34:11]
main associates of our
[1:34:13]
Zeal search team. And Dr. John
[1:34:16]
Barrile or Briel, whichever is his
[1:34:18]
correct name. He faced a
[1:34:22]
vote of no confidence from his district
[1:34:23]
during his term, two years after
[1:34:25]
deciding to resign and dedicate himself to
[1:34:27]
higher education and work at a
[1:34:29]
university. I think that's something
[1:34:32]
worth mentioning. I respect their choice to
[1:34:35]
use
[1:34:36]
superintendents. I recognize that it's a
[1:34:38]
job that can only be understood if it's
[1:34:40]
actually been done, right? But I
[1:34:42]
also think it's worth
[1:34:43]
asking who these
[1:34:45]
superintendents are. I don't believe that the fact
[1:34:48]
that they have superintendents on their
[1:34:49]
teams automatically implies that they
[1:34:51]
are more qualified than the TSBA. I
[1:34:54]
also wanted to state that I think it's
[1:34:55]
absurd to imply that the
[1:34:57]
TSBA has no experience in these
[1:34:58]
searches. They have literally performed
[1:35:00]
30 in the state in the last 5 years
[1:35:01]
. Well, and not just the
[1:35:03]
small districts, as they pointed out with the
[1:35:05]
information sent today. Therefore, I
[1:35:06]
just want to make sure we all
[1:35:07]
keep that in mind. I believe that
[1:35:09]
implying that the TSBA does not have this
[1:35:11]
experience is simply a fallacy.
[1:35:14]
But I would like to highlight the
[1:35:15]
superintendent's concerns
[1:35:16]
regarding the particular search team
[1:35:17]
that was assigned to us.
[1:35:20]
Dr. Driggers.
[1:35:22]
Yes, I wanted to go back and be clear.
[1:35:26]
The board has not yet decided which
[1:35:28]
search methodology we will
[1:35:31]
use. The thing is, the
[1:35:34]
newest thing in Tennessee is the
[1:35:36]
executive session, but there hasn't been a vote on it yet
[1:35:39]
. Well, I mean, we're still
[1:35:42]
trying to decide which way
[1:35:44]
we're going to go.
[1:35:46]
We discussed it in the working session, and
[1:35:49]
I would
[1:35:49]
say it's the board's opinion. We did
[1:35:51]
n't vote. I do
[1:35:52]
n't think it requires a vote.
[1:35:54]
OK.
[1:35:55]
So, we went and reached a
[1:35:57]
consensus on the use of the
[1:36:00]
closed session, and the next step is
[1:36:02]
that we have to approve a policy
[1:36:05]
related to that. And then, Seth
[1:36:08]
is going to draft a policy for us to
[1:36:10]
review at our
[1:36:12]
October policy meeting regarding
[1:36:14]
that.
[1:36:18]
Therefore, the way the board
[1:36:20]
chooses a new superintendent does not
[1:36:22]
require a board vote. There are no
[1:36:28]
yeses or nos.
[1:36:30]
I think they're going to have to vote on
[1:36:31]
that policy.
[1:36:32]
Yes, we will vote on policy.
[1:36:34]
When we return to politics, that's
[1:36:36]
fine.
[1:36:38]
Yes, yes, yes. I'm sorry
[1:36:40]
, I didn't mean to interrupt.
[1:36:41]
No, it's fine. That's how it is. Mrs. Anderson,
[1:36:45]
you have the honor of speaking. I
[1:36:47]
just wanted to thank everyone for the
[1:36:49]
excellent contribution and I appreciate
[1:36:52]
everyone reviewing it and also, if we are
[1:36:54]
concerned about some of the people in the
[1:36:56]
search, we could ask other
[1:36:59]
people, but I really appreciate it.
[1:37:01]
That's an excellent point.
[1:37:04]
Mrs. Calcote.
[1:37:06]
Well, I just wanted to put on record
[1:37:08]
that I wasn't implying that the TSBA
[1:37:11]
lacks experience, but I think
[1:37:13]
even Sam mentioned that no one has
[1:37:15]
conducted a search with the
[1:37:18]
executive group. Therefore, taking
[1:37:22]
this into account, they have no experience
[1:37:24]
in conducting this type of research that
[1:37:26]
we expect to be... I believe Dr. Dryger
[1:37:28]
used the word guinea pig
[1:37:30]
to refer to this in the
[1:37:31]
working session. Therefore,
[1:37:35]
we will be the first to embark on
[1:37:36]
this type of search, and I believe that, for this reason
[1:37:38]
, it is helpful to have someone, a
[1:37:39]
search firm that has
[1:37:41]
experience in this, to guide us
[1:37:42]
through that process. While this is
[1:37:45]
the first time Tennessee has had this
[1:37:46]
law, many other states have this
[1:37:48]
option as a choice for
[1:37:49]
superintendent searches.
[1:37:54]
Mr. Allen.
[1:37:56]
Yes, thank you for tonight's discussion
[1:37:57]
, my fellow board members
[1:37:59]
. Well, the reason I'm not
[1:38:03]
voting for TSBA is because we have some
[1:38:05]
history with
[1:38:07]
Williamson County and TSBA, and it didn't go well for us,
[1:38:08]
so I don't want to get involved in that again
[1:38:10]
while I can represent
[1:38:12]
my district. So, obviously, I've
[1:38:15]
made the motion, so I'll be voting
[1:38:17]
for Zeal.
[1:38:19]
And I don't see any more applications for...Okay,
[1:38:23]
Miss Wyatt.
[1:38:25]
Thank you, Madam President, for
[1:38:27]
keeping her alert. I just wanted to
[1:38:29]
address the teachers and
[1:38:31]
community members who contacted us.
[1:38:33]
Thank you so much. Thank you for being in
[1:38:35]
touch. We listen to you. I support them. We
[1:38:39]
have heard many of you
[1:38:40]
supporting Dr. Webb and I have been very
[1:38:43]
outspoken in my tremendous support and respect
[1:38:46]
for her. So thank you, thank you, for being in touch with
[1:38:50]
us about this. I join Miss
[1:38:53]
Canine in considering
[1:38:55]
offering the position to Dr. Webb and not
[1:38:58]
considering a search. But I understand
[1:39:01]
that if the majority of the board wants to
[1:39:03]
hire a firm, I return to my
[1:39:05]
comment from Thursday night
[1:39:07]
that a nationwide search
[1:39:09]
can confirm a strong internal candidate
[1:39:11]
. And I see that in Dr. Webb, so
[1:39:14]
I can move forward with faith using
[1:39:16]
that information. Thank you.
[1:39:19]
Mr. Bostick.
[1:39:23]
I request that the question be approved.
[1:39:25]
Very good. So, we will proceed to the
[1:39:28]
vote, and just to be clear,
[1:39:31]
what is on the floor that we
[1:39:33]
are voting on is a motion to
[1:39:35]
use Zeal Education Group as the
[1:39:39]
superintendent search service. Please proceed to
[1:39:42]
the vote.
[1:39:56]
is eight yes, four no.
[1:40:00]
And with that, we have approved the
[1:40:02]
use of Zeal Education Group
[1:40:04]
for our
[1:40:06]
superintendent search. Okay, let's move on to the
[1:40:09]
next point, the adoption and
[1:40:10]
approval of the board's objectives
[1:40:12]
and the affirmation of the
[1:40:14]
strategic plan. So, this is another
[1:40:18]
point we discussed in the
[1:40:20]
work session, and for our
[1:40:23]
board goals this year, we are simply going to
[1:40:26]
support our
[1:40:28]
interim superintendent in each of the goals we
[1:40:30]
set for her as a board in June
[1:40:33]
. Would you like to discuss the
[1:40:35]
strategic plan, Dr. Webb?
[1:40:38]
Of course. We are in the fourth year
[1:40:40]
of the five-year strategic plan. I
[1:40:42]
will update you each week in our
[1:40:44]
regular communications on where
[1:40:45]
we stand in those steps, just
[1:40:47]
to keep you, especially
[1:40:48]
the new board members, up to date on
[1:40:50]
where we've been. We have worked
[1:40:52]
hard in several departments and have
[1:40:54]
brought that strategic plan to life. Please pay
[1:40:56]
attention to that communication and I
[1:40:58]
recommend that we continue to ratify
[1:40:59]
the strategic plan as it is
[1:41:01]
written. OK.
[1:41:03]
Thank you. We have a motion from Ms.
[1:41:06]
Hidma and one seconded by Ms.
[1:41:08]
Cannain. Has anyone mentioned that?
[1:41:13]
Since we don't see any, we will proceed to the
[1:41:15]
vote.
[1:41:27]
12 in favor, zero against.
[1:41:30]
We have approved the board's objectives
[1:41:32]
and ratified the strategic plan
[1:41:34]
. We move on to the next item, the
[1:41:37]
review of policy 1.2021 on
[1:41:39]
the school board's code of conduct
[1:41:41]
. Everyone signed the code of
[1:41:45]
conduct at the work session.
[1:41:47]
We review this code of conduct every
[1:41:49]
2 years when new
[1:41:51]
school board members are sworn in.
[1:41:53]
So, thank you all for signing
[1:41:56]
that document, and let's work to
[1:41:58]
make sure we comply with it.
[1:42:01]
We have a motion in Mr.
[1:42:04]
Bostick's chamber, seconded by Ms. Kelcoat.
[1:42:06]
Any further discussion? Since we don't see
[1:42:11]
any, we will proceed to the vote.
[1:42:18]
is 12 in favor and
[1:42:19]
zero against.
[1:42:21]
And we have approved the code of conduct
[1:42:22]
for school board members.
[1:42:25]
The next item, the next series
[1:42:27]
of items, is related to the
[1:42:29]
school board budget 26 27.
[1:42:31]
So, the first item is the
[1:42:33]
approval of amendment 09.26 of the
[1:42:35]
general purpose school fund, the
[1:42:37]
United Way grant in the amount
[1:42:39]
of $52,080. Dr. Webb?
[1:42:42]
Yes, thank you, Madam President. For the
[1:42:44]
fifteenth year, United Way is
[1:42:46]
providing funding to the district for
[1:42:48]
tutoring for grades 1-5 in
[1:42:49]
our elementary schools, and
[1:42:51]
I recommend its approval.
[1:42:53]
Thank you. We have a motion from Mr.
[1:42:55]
Bostick, seconded by Mr. Allen.
[1:42:57]
Any other discussion? Questions? Since we do
[1:43:01]
n't see any, we will proceed to the
[1:43:03]
vote.
[1:43:09]
was 12 in favor and
[1:43:10]
zero against.
[1:43:12]
We have approved the
[1:43:14]
general purpose school fund in the amount of $
[1:43:17]
52,080. The next item on the
[1:43:20]
agenda is the approval of the
[1:43:22]
amendment to the general purpose school fund
[1:43:24]
09.26 regarding
[1:43:27]
sports donations in the amount of $45,223.50.
[1:43:29]
Dr. Webb.
[1:43:30]
Thank you, Madam President. Our
[1:43:32]
Wilco sports event, which we organize
[1:43:34]
every year to celebrate our
[1:43:36]
athletes from across the district, is
[1:43:37]
funded by donations like this one.
[1:43:39]
Therefore, tonight's approval
[1:43:41]
is made possible with donations from Play
[1:43:43]
On and Teal Property Groups. They have been
[1:43:45]
supporting this event and
[1:43:47]
I recommend approving the acceptance of
[1:43:48]
those donations. Thank you.
[1:43:50]
So, we have a motion from Ms.
[1:43:52]
Clements, seconded by Mr.
[1:43:54]
Bostick. Any further discussion? Since we do
[1:43:57]
n't see any, let's proceed to the
[1:43:58]
vote.
[1:44:06]
12 in favor, zero against.
[1:44:10]
Very well, we have approved those
[1:44:11]
sports donations. The next
[1:44:14]
item on the agenda is the
[1:44:16]
approval of resolution 10.26 of the
[1:44:18]
general purpose school
[1:44:20]
bus fund in the amount of
[1:44:22]
$3,367,130. Dr. Webb.
[1:44:25]
Thank you, Madam President. It is at this
[1:44:26]
time of year that we begin to
[1:44:28]
project how many school buses
[1:44:29]
we will need to replace for the
[1:44:31]
next school year. We need to
[1:44:33]
replace 15 general education buses
[1:44:35]
and four
[1:44:36]
special education buses. We will finance this
[1:44:39]
through the balance of funds, as this will be
[1:44:40]
funded, and I recommend
[1:44:41]
approval so that we can order
[1:44:43]
those buses and have them headed
[1:44:44]
here.
[1:44:46]
We have a motion from Mr. Bostick and it is
[1:44:48]
seconded by Ms. Wyatt. Any
[1:44:50]
questions for the discussion about
[1:44:51]
buses? Since none are seen, a
[1:44:54]
vote will be taken.
[1:45:00]
The vote is 12 yes, zero no.
[1:45:05]
With that, we have approved the
[1:45:07]
funding for the buses and the
[1:45:09]
last item is the approval of the
[1:45:11]
schedule for preparing the
[1:45:13]
2027-2028 budget. Dr. Bob.
[1:45:15]
Thank you, Madam President. It's
[1:45:16]
budget time. Are you excited,
[1:45:18]
good people? I think we're all
[1:45:19]
excited. It's time to talk about the
[1:45:21]
budget, and this is our
[1:45:23]
budget timeline prepared
[1:45:24]
for you in response to your
[1:45:26]
feedback in the working session.
[1:45:28]
On page two you will see some
[1:45:30]
highlighted areas where we will ask at
[1:45:32]
four strategic moments if you would
[1:45:34]
like to have additional sessions
[1:45:36]
outside of the scheduled meetings.
[1:45:38]
We will continue to offer them, but if
[1:45:40]
you have individual questions, those
[1:45:42]
one-on-one sessions with Rachel Farmer will
[1:45:44]
give you answers and the
[1:45:46]
knowledge you need to
[1:45:49]
succeed in how we move forward with the
[1:45:50]
budget. Therefore, I recommend
[1:45:53]
the approval of this timeline.
[1:45:54]
Very good. We have a motion from Ms.
[1:45:56]
Anderson, seconded by Mrs.
[1:45:58]
Clements. Any discussion
[1:46:00]
related to that? Just a
[1:46:02]
reminder that everyone can
[1:46:04]
schedule a meeting with Rachel anytime
[1:46:07]
until March, I guess,
[1:46:10]
right? She loves it. Yes. Very
[1:46:13]
good. Since there is no discussion, we will take
[1:46:15]
our final vote of the afternoon.
[1:46:23]
Vote: 12 in favor, zero against.
[1:46:26]
And we have approved the timetable for
[1:46:28]
preparing the 2027-28 budget, and
[1:46:30]
with this the session is adjourned.