Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
[0:00]
You don't have a
[0:04]
fish now?
[0:06]
We do.
[0:12]
Oh yeah. 14.
[0:16]
Yeah, we had a
[0:20]
really split the difference.
[0:29]
Alright, well ladies
[0:31]
and gentlemen, the hour is upon us and we have a quorum.
[0:34]
So I'd like to call this meeting to order.
[0:37]
This is the Central Vermont Career Center
[0:42]
Special Meeting of the board, Monday,
[0:44]
August 25th, 2025.
[0:51]
Do we have any special gifts
[0:55]
other than routine individuals?
[1:01]
Any comments for items
[1:03]
that are not on the agenda from the public?
[1:09]
Any comments from anyone online for anything
[1:11]
that is not on the agenda?
[1:17]
All right, we'll move forward to the consent agenda.
[1:21]
We have to approve our agenda first
[1:26]
before we move on to the consent agenda.
[1:28]
So I need a motion to approve the agenda as printed.
[1:33]
I move that we approve the agenda. Okay, Jan.
[1:37]
Alright, any discussion? Hearing none.
[1:42]
All those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.
[1:47]
A Ladies and gentlemen, on on,
[1:53]
on online, we will accept your, your eyes.
[1:58]
And now the consent agenda.
[2:02]
The consent agenda is for the approval
[2:03]
of the minutes from the August 11th, 2025 board meeting.
[2:08]
Any questions or concerns?
[2:13]
Deletions or additions?
[2:17]
Hearing none. I need a motion to approve this agenda.
[2:22]
Minutes. The minutes? Yes. I'll get there Minutes.
[2:26]
Move to approve the minutes from August 11th? Yes.
[2:30]
I need a second. I'll second. Okay. Thank you gentlemen.
[2:35]
Any further discussion? Hearing none.
[2:38]
All those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.
[2:44]
Any nays? Any abstentions? Hearing none. Motion carries.
[2:49]
Board reports, committee reports, facilities.
[2:55]
Is there a facilities report?
[2:57]
We actually have a presentation. Okay.
[3:00]
So we will move that report
[3:02]
to our presentation moving forward.
[3:07]
The board discussion
[3:08]
and action items, which is the facilities project, budget
[3:13]
and bond projection, and then the marketing updates.
[3:16]
So we'll move this committee report to facilities to 6.1
[3:20]
and include it in there.
[3:22]
So let's proceed with facilities,
[3:26]
project budget and bond projections.
[3:31]
Who would like to break the ice?
[3:34]
I will start and I'll ask Cam data to help.
[3:38]
And would you sir, please identify yourself? Sure.
[3:41]
My name is David Epstein. I'm with Trucks Collins.
[3:44]
And we're the architects, one
[3:46]
of the architects for the project.
[3:49]
Hi everybody. Good to see you in person.
[3:51]
Usually we are all floating heads.
[3:55]
The this is a, an abbreviated version.
[3:58]
Is there a possibility
[3:59]
of turning some lights off or dimming lights?
[4:02]
Yeah. Thank you. See, that might help everybody see,
[4:11]
Think up above there. I
[4:13]
Was like, these are pretty minimal.
[4:21]
Next slide, please.
[4:23]
Excuse me. I just wanna check,
[4:25]
can everybody online see these slides?
[4:30]
Yes.
[4:33]
Okay. Are
[4:39]
Jenna, Todd, or Corey can?
[4:41]
Yes. Canice says yes. Thank you. Okay, very good. Okay.
[4:44]
Yes, so it's very short, it's very abbreviated.
[4:48]
Last time we were here, we gave a very long, not long
[4:53]
but detailed presentation.
[4:55]
So we'll start with the site design
[4:57]
and the building design show a few of the renderings
[5:00]
and then really the, the meat of the presentation.
[5:03]
We'll be talking about what is the cost impacts from a tax
[5:06]
standpoint, and then talk about next steps in the,
[5:11]
the media campaign.
[5:12]
So next slide please.
[5:15]
So as everybody knows,
[5:19]
the Site 16 Baptist Road is the site we're going.
[5:22]
You can see right here, this is relative
[5:25]
to the catchment area.
[5:26]
It has a, those qualities, this is a location plan.
[5:31]
You can see the building right here. This is Rock of Ages.
[5:35]
You can see the quarries.
[5:36]
If you go to the next slide, this is one of the updates is
[5:41]
that the traffic study showed
[5:44]
that there were two section intersections of concern,
[5:49]
middle Road in Graniteville
[5:51]
and Baptist Road in Graniteville.
[5:54]
They calculated the number of trips.
[5:57]
They, you know, made some assumptions about distribution
[6:00]
and, and they're not even sure that, you know,
[6:04]
there's any improvements that need to happen.
[6:06]
But they, what happens is when there's a certain number
[6:09]
of trips, additional trips at an intersection
[6:11]
that triggers the review,
[6:16]
they didn't have any issues with the ingress
[6:18]
and egress out of the site.
[6:20]
And it's distanced from this intersection.
[6:22]
But this is something that say when the bond vote passes,
[6:27]
we will have to look at further and we've budgeted money.
[6:33]
There's an impact fee that you have to, if you have to do,
[6:36]
you don't have to, you don't literally have to pay
[6:38]
for the improvements, but you have to contribute to a fund
[6:42]
that might improve those intersections.
[6:44]
And we've budget for that in the project budget. Next slide.
[6:48]
This is just a little bit closer view
[6:51]
and go to the next slide.
[6:52]
So the site plan,
[6:55]
and I apologize, this site plan is rotated so that north is
[6:59]
to the right before we were looking north up the page,
[7:03]
we had to modify this front area here
[7:07]
because of wetlands.
[7:09]
And we, when we had the wetlands delineated, we discovered
[7:15]
wetlands up in this area here that are,
[7:18]
we did not know about.
[7:20]
We knew about the ones off to the south of the site,
[7:25]
the left on the page.
[7:26]
And so we, what, what we did was we modified
[7:32]
the site plan to get all of the parking out of the,
[7:36]
the wetlands and the buffer.
[7:38]
If you go to the next slide, there'll be kind
[7:40]
of a blow up to make it can see easier.
[7:42]
So this is the 50 foot wetland buffer here
[7:46]
and the wetlands are, are right here.
[7:49]
So we moved everything out of there.
[7:51]
We sent those to the regulators
[7:53]
and we got a positive, some positive feedback.
[7:58]
We showed the original plan
[8:00]
and we showed this plan to show that we're making, you know,
[8:04]
every effort to avoid
[8:08]
impact on the wetlands.
[8:09]
There is one class three wet. This is class two.
[8:12]
There's one class three wetland
[8:14]
that's right in the middle here that
[8:18]
we are impacting.
[8:19]
And there is a, once again, another mitigation fee,
[8:23]
which has been budgeted for.
[8:26]
But so far we've got, we've got like, I don't know,
[8:30]
would you say one and a half thumbs up or two thumbs up?
[8:34]
Tell we're waiting for the to be to be candid.
[8:37]
We're waiting, we're still waiting for feedback from the
[8:39]
US Army Corps of Engineers.
[8:40]
Although that's less nerve wracking than the,
[8:45]
and we have some other, we have some other ideas if we
[8:48]
have to go further.
[8:49]
But we like this site plan a lot.
[8:52]
So we're gonna stick with this if, if,
[8:54]
If it gets a blessing regulated.
[8:58]
Okay, so next, Jay,
[9:00]
do you wanna talk a little bit about the building?
[9:01]
Yes. Just a couple slides here.
[9:03]
So if you don't mind me presenting for the back.
[9:05]
I'm Jay Ty, I'm one
[9:07]
of the other architects that's working on the project.
[9:08]
I'm from Resinger.
[9:11]
Our specialty is the lab planning, looking at the actual
[9:15]
spaces within the building.
[9:17]
So just a quick recap
[9:18]
because I know we've, we've talked
[9:19]
to you about this at great lengths before.
[9:21]
This building has two round levels.
[9:24]
So at the, the way the, so site slopes,
[9:27]
it gives us two opportunities to get materials
[9:31]
and things in and out of the building.
[9:33]
So at this level, which is the lower
[9:35]
of the two levels is the main entry, which is
[9:37]
that red arrow you see, which comes into admin,
[9:40]
which provides a series of doors.
[9:43]
So safety and security, we can make sure students are safe.
[9:46]
And then as you move further in, there's another set
[9:49]
of doors that can be locked to keep the students
[9:51]
safe within the building and still have access to some
[9:54]
of the arts and business and hospitality spaces up front.
[9:58]
Which in this one are the, the culinary dining space
[10:01]
and the cosmetology space that can now service the public
[10:04]
and still keep the students secure.
[10:07]
In the center of the space is the heart of the building.
[10:09]
We'll see in 3D in a few minutes,
[10:11]
but that's really the stair, the meeting area,
[10:14]
the gathering area, kind of the, the, the Greek
[10:19]
agora stair that that learning takes place on.
[10:22]
So that's, that's the heart of the school.
[10:24]
Off of that, we've got some common spaces,
[10:26]
which are your gymnasium and some locker rooms
[10:29]
and some bathrooms and some service spaces.
[10:31]
And then as we move down the, the corridor,
[10:34]
you see the health and natural resource science spaces
[10:38]
there, which we have plant
[10:39]
and animal, we have natural resources, we have
[10:44]
childcare, I'm sorry, human services.
[10:48]
Yeah, human services, human service,
[10:49]
Emergency services and medical professions.
[10:52]
And they're all, they're all working together to create a,
[10:57]
a cluster that, that has a center
[10:59]
or has a space that will let natural aid in
[11:01]
that becomes their home, within their home.
[11:04]
So this would be some class cross pollination that happens
[11:07]
between these programs.
[11:10]
As we move up that stair, that main stair, that center,
[11:14]
we move up and we have design construction,
[11:16]
manufacturing down one side,
[11:18]
which has our electrical trades, our building trades, our
[11:23]
welding or HVC
[11:27]
and our advanced manufacturing, manufacturing spaces home.
[11:34]
Thanks. And, and those spaces again have a heart
[11:37]
or have a space that's around them
[11:39]
that becomes their cluster home.
[11:41]
That collaboration between these
[11:42]
types of programs would happen.
[11:44]
As I said before, they're all like, great,
[11:46]
they all have doors outside for project yards
[11:49]
and space to get materials in and out.
[11:51]
And at the very end we have transportation,
[11:53]
which is automotive
[11:54]
and our, our heavy diesel spaces
[11:57]
that are working together there at the end, as we move back
[12:00]
to the heart of the school, the center of the school,
[12:02]
we have some spaces which are our arts
[12:06]
and business spaces, which are the art is actually media.
[12:11]
So we have digital media and film media that happens there.
[12:15]
And then the business space,
[12:17]
which is the business program that happens there.
[12:21]
Also off that heart we have the library,
[12:23]
which is a important space to be part of that,
[12:26]
that central commons
[12:27]
and the support space for students to be able
[12:30]
to receive support that's right in the center of the school.
[12:34]
And further down you'll see kind of the, the reddish spaces.
[12:37]
Those are the exploratory and flex spaces.
[12:40]
So these are really trying to get younger students
[12:43]
or early students interested in really engage
[12:47]
in a bunch of programs.
[12:48]
That's the feeder programs that will happen there.
[12:51]
Hit everything Jody,
[12:54]
These are some views of the exterior and interior.
[12:58]
So this is the what as you come up the drive.
[13:02]
Next slide please. Here you can see the
[13:06]
parent drop off.
[13:07]
At this end you have the childcare area, whether,
[13:10]
whether the playground,
[13:13]
that upper large feature window is into one
[13:15]
of the exploratory laps.
[13:16]
And in the distance you can see the entry,
[13:18]
which we'll see in the next slide.
[13:21]
So this is the entry, you know, as we've mentioned
[13:26]
before, the base is this kind of rust located stone
[13:30]
buried granite, you know, we want it
[13:33]
to be evocative of the region.
[13:35]
And then up on the upper is a more lightweight
[13:40]
panel system, could be metal or, or some kind of resin.
[13:46]
So here you can see it from above.
[13:49]
Once again, you have student parking in front,
[13:51]
you've got the bus and car drop off.
[13:55]
There's the, the playground.
[13:57]
And as we go to the next slide, you'll see the back
[14:00]
and you'll see the solar panels.
[14:04]
The, the roof is being planned for the solar panels.
[14:07]
We're approaching it.
[14:09]
They're not in the project budgeted for it,
[14:11]
but it's approaching as a lease.
[14:15]
We did a, a winooski, they leased the roof
[14:18]
for a very large solar array
[14:20]
and they get the benefits of it without having
[14:22]
to put any money down the back.
[14:25]
This as, as Jay was talking about, you can see the
[14:29]
project yard and the doors directly to grade.
[14:32]
There's the loading dock and back.
[14:34]
That's the gymnasium projecting out.
[14:37]
And then we'll move to the inside.
[14:40]
So this is the injury I was talking about before.
[14:42]
You can see we have cosmetology
[14:45]
and dining that happened here
[14:46]
and there's a set of secure doors further down at your left
[14:49]
here is that admin that monitor all this.
[14:53]
As we move into the heart of the school, that's stair
[14:56]
that learning stair, it becomes the, the, the space that
[15:01]
most school can gather together.
[15:03]
That it can be all school
[15:04]
meetings, you can be groups together.
[15:06]
This also becomes the cafeteria.
[15:07]
Just really a multifunctional space that really
[15:11]
engages the whole building.
[15:12]
You see above natural light being poured in here.
[15:15]
Again, these are, this is a really deep building,
[15:17]
but when we get natural light,
[15:18]
these spaces really energized.
[15:23]
It's just another look at that, that's the top
[15:24]
of the stairs now and spin
[15:26]
around looking down at the presentation wall.
[15:29]
So this, this space will have presentation capabilities
[15:33]
and with the, the, the media department right
[15:37]
behind can now provide support for presentations
[15:40]
and things that have happened in this space.
[15:45]
And this is one of those homes, those center cluster homes
[15:49]
where you have cross pollination of these different programs
[15:53]
to be able to work together on projects or, or things.
[15:56]
So this is one of those spaces
[15:58]
with natural light coming down
[15:59]
and a variety of seeding
[16:00]
that they can work on different projects.
[16:07]
So the next part of presentation
[16:11]
talks about the project costs and impacts.
[16:13]
And I'll, I'll turn it over to Michelle for that.
[16:17]
You've all been waiting for.
[16:21]
Yeah, sure. So I just wanted to make some notes like
[16:26]
to start off, so
[16:27]
before I just show you the numbers,
[16:30]
these are all good faith estimates.
[16:32]
They're based on the most recent data, which is FY 26.
[16:37]
We assume a home value of $300,000
[16:40]
income sensitivity is not modeled here.
[16:43]
So in Vermont, most of you, if not all of you know
[16:46]
that some households qualify for property tax adjustments
[16:49]
and it reduces their tax bill based off income,
[16:54]
not just their property value.
[16:55]
So that means that some families, the actual impact
[16:58]
that we're gonna show may actually be less s
[17:03]
the tax impacts will vary depending on the future state.
[17:07]
We don't know what the overall
[17:09]
education spending's gonna look like.
[17:10]
The statewide yield, the common level of appraisal
[17:13]
with pupil counts.
[17:15]
So our goal tonight is just to give you a reasonable range
[17:18]
of the likely impacts so that voters can have a clear
[17:22]
and transparent information.
[17:24]
So the best available information
[17:26]
that I can give you at this moment
[17:32]
cut off.
[17:36]
So I think it'll take a little bit of time.
[17:38]
But brief digest this amount of information.
[17:42]
I tried to actually, I had someone else help me
[17:45]
'cause my graphs were like four pages long
[17:47]
and I was like, no, I need all this information.
[17:49]
And they're like, no, no, we're gonna show you
[17:52]
just the big numbers.
[17:53]
Again, this is based off a $300,000 house.
[17:57]
This is this year FY 26 tax estimates.
[18:01]
So if we had to pay it back this year,
[18:03]
this year right now, yep.
[18:06]
If payments started this year, if they started this year
[18:11]
tomorrow, they were kind of sort of,
[18:15]
but then we go into six semester
[18:18]
hours and that sort of thing.
[18:19]
So anyway, you could see the highest tax increases are East
[18:23]
Montpelier Cals in Berlin.
[18:24]
But the lowest being Cabot more counted in the field.
[18:28]
It ranges from about $99
[18:31]
to $420 per household tax bill.
[18:34]
So this is not per person, this is per taxable.
[18:38]
$300,000? Yes.
[18:41]
The average is about $297.
[18:48]
Yes. Do you have a number for Worcester?
[18:50]
I don't, I don't, I haven't got their appraisal yet.
[18:52]
Has it come in yet? Do you know? I don't know. Okay.
[18:56]
The last I checked last week hadn't come in yet.
[18:58]
So that's the one I'm waiting on.
[18:59]
You said 2 97 per household?
[19:02]
2 97 is the average through all
[19:05]
of our districts, all of our accounts.
[19:09]
The minimum being 99
[19:10]
and the highest being four 20 based off a 300,000 bucks x.
[19:19]
The next slide just goes into some
[19:21]
assumptions that I'm making.
[19:22]
So I can give you again, the most clearest possible answers.
[19:27]
The total bond is $149 million.
[19:32]
We said the average payment is $9.4 million over,
[19:36]
over the course of 30 years.
[19:38]
Again, that could be different.
[19:40]
We're using the level debt services,
[19:42]
meaning we're gonna pay the same amount every year.
[19:44]
That's the model that I use to estimate these numbers.
[19:48]
Sometimes you can pay back a lesser amount at the beginning
[19:51]
and higher in the end,
[19:52]
or you can do vice versa,
[19:54]
pay back a higher amount at the
[19:55]
beginning and less at the end.
[19:57]
But I chose the most, even peel one that I could.
[20:02]
So I could really just kind of keep everything level.
[20:06]
How this gets paid back is through tuition payments.
[20:08]
That's the only way that CTE that we the district are able
[20:12]
to pay for any of our expenses right now.
[20:16]
Right now. So tuition payments again is a
[20:21]
reminder for you folks or anybody listening?
[20:25]
It's based on a six semester average.
[20:27]
So what this means for me is that I can estimate what
[20:32]
the proportional value
[20:34]
of each sending school district will have.
[20:37]
So if a school district sends 50% of the total population
[20:41]
of students that we have, they'll be responsible
[20:43]
for paying about 50%
[20:45]
of the bond total cost back, if that makes sense.
[20:47]
So we use a six, six semester average.
[20:51]
The percent of students from each
[20:53]
district remains fairly constant.
[20:55]
It goes up about a percentage or two.
[20:58]
So what I did was I chose this year with my past three years
[21:03]
to make sure it was within range
[21:05]
and I estimated of that $9.4 million, what's percentage,
[21:10]
what's the allocation that each district
[21:11]
would be responsible for?
[21:15]
And then I allocated of courts to each district
[21:18]
and based off $300,000 house this year.
[21:23]
Again FY 26.
[21:26]
And that's how I came up with the numbers.
[21:29]
Is there any question on how I came up with the numbers?
[21:34]
Do you assume an equal setting population from
[21:37]
each district of the 18th?
[21:38]
I mean just 9 million divided
[21:40]
by 18 is half a million dollars.
[21:41]
No, that's not, no,
[21:43]
because each district sends a different amount of students
[21:46]
and we're only able to bill.
[21:47]
But how did you calculate
[21:48]
It based off FTEs?
[21:50]
So okay, yeah,
[21:52]
Today.
[21:53]
Today, this year. Yep.
[21:55]
And we built tuition based off a six semester average.
[21:58]
So we have two, last year we had 220 students.
[22:01]
I, I'm only able to actually go for 194 students.
[22:05]
It takes the last six semester averages.
[22:07]
That's what I'm able to bill.
[22:10]
And did you model in how it's gonna be UNE amongst the
[22:13]
Towns? I did.
[22:14]
That's the last slide. Yeah, that's,
[22:17]
that's, sorry to jump in.
[22:19]
That's why go back. It's a different amount for each town,
[22:22]
Right?
[22:23]
That's why it's not like you're gonna pay a million,
[22:25]
you're gonna pay a million, you're gonna pay a million,
[22:27]
half a million, whichever the number is.
[22:29]
It's each town has an adjusted amount of
[22:31]
that total $9.4 million that they would be responsible
[22:35]
for paid back in tuition.
[22:37]
Like in my case I live in Berlin.
[22:39]
It really comes down to the number of students
[22:41]
who originated in Berlin
[22:42]
and then up gonna the career center.
[22:44]
Correct? Yes.
[22:48]
Someone had a question.
[22:51]
Peter Anthony, Mr. Anthony, you have a question?
[22:54]
Yeah. I guess just refining the
[22:58]
preceding statement about allocation across districts,
[23:02]
I assume there'd be a lag time for those communities
[23:06]
who have not sent a great number of students
[23:11]
here to, for for whatever reason
[23:14]
and they increase their sending of students.
[23:19]
There would be obviously a lag time in terms of catch up
[23:23]
of recap, re reallocation of the proportion
[23:28]
amongst the collective members of the
[23:33]
career center catchment area.
[23:34]
Is that not logically correct?
[23:38]
That's correct. That's why we use a six semester average.
[23:41]
So if you were to spend 20 additional students
[23:44]
to me this year, I'm going off a three year,
[23:47]
six semester average.
[23:48]
So this year you're not paying
[23:50]
for an additional 20 students.
[23:52]
But over the course of three years,
[23:53]
those 20 students will be worked into our average
[23:55]
in which we're able to pay.
[23:58]
I just to observe, I mean part
[24:00]
of the reason we're doing this,
[24:01]
and I applaud it, is we're having to turn down two out
[24:05]
of every three applicants.
[24:07]
So they're obviously sending towns whose participation will
[24:11]
dramatically increase once we open.
[24:14]
And so there's, there's gonna be a shift,
[24:17]
but it will be, if you will, into the future
[24:20]
because it's lagged if it's a six semester average.
[24:25]
Correct. Yep, you're right.
[24:28]
Will, let's have the added knock on benefit of,
[24:31]
of tapering the increases because you,
[24:36]
because you're gonna have, it'll take you six semesters
[24:38]
to get up to full enrollment
[24:42]
Billings, presuming that's, that remains for CTE.
[24:45]
Oh right. With the foundation formula. We really don't know.
[24:49]
We, so that's part of why we had to go with the numbers
[24:51]
that we have this year that we know
[24:54]
and the way that we budget and tuition now
[24:56]
because that's what we know and we can't predict the future.
[25:00]
I joked to somebody just yesterday
[25:02]
or maybe it was this morning, that I don't,
[25:04]
my crystal ball's not working.
[25:06]
And so we're doing the best we can
[25:08]
with what we know right now. Yeah. Patrick,
[25:11]
Thank you.
[25:13]
This something we, we discussed a bit at the Washington show
[25:16]
meeting was what, what's the ratio of, of students
[25:21]
that apply versus students that, that attend at,
[25:25]
they were obviously consent were specifically for E 32,
[25:28]
but do you have those numbers for each school and
[25:31]
and is that appropriate to work into the estimates or
[25:34]
or do you feel like it's pretty even?
[25:41]
That's a really good question.
[25:42]
I don't, I'm trying to think of how we break it out.
[25:45]
We break it out by school district
[25:50]
when once they've been accepted,
[25:52]
but we haven't broken it out that way in who's applied
[25:57]
so that we have the data.
[25:59]
We can go into it that way this year for the first time.
[26:02]
And actually I asked them to go back to last year, I asked
[26:06]
how many actual people, single people applied
[26:10]
because we have students who if they don't get in the first
[26:12]
round, they'll reapply Right.
[26:14]
The second round for others.
[26:16]
And so there was really, I'm gonna have to dig to find that,
[26:21]
but I think we had 400
[26:24]
and I'm gonna guess wrong probably,
[26:27]
but 424 applicants for this year.
[26:30]
And 404 of them were single.
[26:35]
I only applied once, sorry, looking on it earlier.
[26:40]
Yes, I was. You go to the bottom.
[26:42]
Okay, so total applicants this year, 443,
[26:46]
but individual applicants was 414.
[26:49]
So really we did have over 400 individual students apply.
[26:53]
Right. And we have 216
[26:55]
that will be starting with us on Wednesday.
[26:58]
Yeah,
[27:00]
I guess the question is, is the proportion
[27:01]
of kids from each sending school the same for the, the 218
[27:06]
as for the 414?
[27:08]
Right. So that's, that's a really good question
[27:11]
and I don't have that information in
[27:12]
front of me, but I can ask for it.
[27:13]
Thanks.
[27:16]
One thing I'll, I'll one thing I'll note. Excuse me,
[27:18]
I'm, could you just identify
[27:19]
yourself for the record please?
[27:21]
Thank you for the request. My name's Camp Featherston.
[27:24]
I'm senior associated tr cullins.
[27:27]
So when, when I first looked at the, at the
[27:32]
impact, this comports very, very closely
[27:36]
with the initial projections of the
[27:40]
burden on the 18 towns as a whole.
[27:44]
And what that tells me, especially
[27:46]
as we talk about these things, as populations may change
[27:49]
and this town may send more in the future
[27:51]
and this one may send less, is that that range of costs
[27:54]
that we're seeing is may shift back and forth,
[27:57]
but it's, it's, it's, it's gonna be in
[27:59]
that same ballpark, right?
[28:01]
Because it's, it's the same amount
[28:03]
of money that has to be raised.
[28:06]
It's just, it's being paid for,
[28:09]
it sounds like it's being paid
[28:10]
for proportionally based on the number
[28:11]
of students from each town that are going.
[28:14]
So the proportions may shift as the popul relationships,
[28:19]
which seems fair.
[28:21]
But it, all I'm saying is that this comports very closely
[28:26]
with the overall projections in this range
[28:30]
is what we expected.
[28:37]
No,
[28:37]
You got it.
[28:40]
So Michelle, yeah, the,
[28:44]
the projections that,
[28:46]
that we're looking at the very fancy graph, I love it.
[28:50]
So that
[28:55]
we know is not going to be the case going forward. Right.
[28:59]
This is my best estimate as of right
[29:01]
Now.
[29:02]
Absolutely. And with the, the legislation that passed,
[29:05]
we don't know yet the effect of the foundation formula
[29:10]
and we don't know.
[29:14]
And the truth. So this is additional to
[29:19]
what already is being paid by the school district.
[29:22]
If the school district were to shift change
[29:27]
what they're paying that will also affect tax rates.
[29:31]
So if schools paid exactly what they're paying now
[29:35]
and I had to add $9.4 million on this is what it would be.
[29:39]
Gotcha. Presumably if we are taking double the amount
[29:43]
of students, we're increasing our enrollment from 220
[29:46]
to 500, between four
[29:48]
and 500 students, that would change
[29:51]
what sending schools are are
[29:54]
paying presumably.
[29:57]
So if theirs went down a little, even though they owed more
[30:01]
to the CTE again, that can Yeah. Decrease tax.
[30:05]
Yeah. Oh absolutely.
[30:06]
And I guess I'm, so the, the, the first students
[30:10]
that would ever make it in would be in 2029.
[30:14]
When do, when do the
[30:17]
taxpayers start paying on the bond
[30:21]
The next, it depends when we fully allocate our bond.
[30:26]
So when we take the money out,
[30:27]
but I would presume it could be
[30:29]
that first year that they're in.
[30:31]
So during construction there's no, I,
[30:35]
I need to verify that, but
[30:37]
because of the short timeline of between construction
[30:39]
and starting, I don't presume that would be much before.
[30:43]
Yeah. Okay, cool.
[30:45]
Yeah, I think, yeah, that's definitely a,
[30:49]
I'm trying if you can figure out, I'm trying
[30:50]
to figure out all of those things that we don't know
[30:53]
but we know are likely to change.
[30:54]
Right. And so the other, the other question I have, sorry,
[30:59]
is the potential for,
[31:03]
and Jody maybe this is a question for you.
[31:05]
The potential for the change in
[31:08]
CTE governance in the state.
[31:11]
So if that, if we go to one CTE district,
[31:18]
what are the potential impacts on, or even if you know
[31:22]
It, it depends what they determine about
[31:24]
what would happen with bonds, right?
[31:25]
Because does does it then get spread across the entire state
[31:29]
or do the sending schools that are originally voted
[31:32]
for it in these towns have to continue to carry it?
[31:36]
It's a really good question. I don't know
[31:40]
Right now this is assumes that the cost will be
[31:44]
amongst the 1870 towns and not the entire state. Correct?
[31:48]
Correct. And historically
[31:52]
the state paid a hundred percent for CTE centers.
[31:56]
There was no bonding No.
[32:00]
Through legislative. Yeah.
[32:01]
It was just that they didn't build a lot of 'em
[32:05]
and you know,
[32:06]
but that's to your point of a, of a single district
[32:10]
and the whole state supporting the CTE center,
[32:15]
that's essentially what was happening in the past
[32:17]
through different mechanisms.
[32:19]
Yeah. So again, the, the assumption
[32:21]
of this is we are not getting our bond our any kind
[32:25]
of our census tape through any other means
[32:27]
besides this bond.
[32:28]
Right. Which I do not know as of right now.
[32:33]
As of right now, I'm gonna assume
[32:35]
we are paying for the whole thing.
[32:37]
At some point in the future there might be other means in
[32:40]
which could pay help pay for this.
[32:42]
And I truly hope that there is
[32:44]
and we don't mind searching for those things either.
[32:47]
I will find every pot of money.
[32:55]
Any additional questions or concerns.
[33:01]
I see the, the, are we do, is it for simplicity's sake
[33:05]
or are we, or
[33:07]
or what's, what's the status of the 149 versus 140
[33:13]
price tag gymnasium?
[33:15]
No gymnasium decision.
[33:17]
I think the direction we got from the board when we last
[33:20]
talked about this was just let's move forward
[33:23]
with a full amount and just do the whole thing.
[33:28]
I think there was some discussion at that time of if we,
[33:32]
if the bond vote failed in November, then we might come back
[33:37]
later without the gym portion of it.
[33:41]
But that it made sense to go move forward with the vision
[33:44]
of the board for the full day and to have that there. Okay,
[33:48]
Thank you.
[33:51]
So kind of finalize my portion of the presentation.
[33:54]
I just wanted to emphasize transparency.
[33:56]
For the best available estimates that I have right now,
[34:00]
I am committed to providing with ongoing updates
[34:04]
as new data becomes available,
[34:05]
I'm still waiting on one town.
[34:07]
So when I get that information, I'll share that
[34:09]
I hear anything about construction cost
[34:13]
coverage or anything like that.
[34:14]
I definitely, or if you hear anything,
[34:17]
definitely share it my way
[34:20]
and I'm just really excited.
[34:23]
Really excited. And so the,
[34:28]
the last slide here is just the project schedule.
[34:31]
So tonight the board hopefully will reaffirm
[34:35]
that it wants us to move forward
[34:37]
with $149 million bond vote.
[34:40]
We will warn that vote, assuming
[34:43]
that happens on September 8th at our next board meeting.
[34:47]
And that would take place on November four.
[34:50]
The votes would be comm mingled on the November 6th.
[34:53]
So we would not know on November four what the outcome was.
[34:55]
We would know by end of day on November 6th.
[34:59]
And then if it was a positive outcome, we would move forward
[35:03]
with building design and permits, then construction
[35:05]
and then with the plan of opening in September of 2029.
[35:09]
Jody. Alright, go ahead. I saw Paul Malone and then
[35:15]
Thank you.
[35:18]
I have a little bit of history here with the career center
[35:22]
as well as the high school.
[35:24]
I was a chair of the high school board for a number
[35:27]
of years, which incorporated the CDCC.
[35:30]
I also became the chair of the new BUSD board
[35:34]
for the first two years of that.
[35:36]
That was fun with COVID and everything else.
[35:38]
So I'm, I'm really very rational with numbers
[35:42]
and data pours outta my ears.
[35:44]
It's just what I, I have some concerns and some issues.
[35:49]
The first one, I, I would ask you to indulge me
[35:52]
for about five minutes because when I was looking at the
[35:56]
news article and I was looking at the,
[35:58]
the historical framing of this
[35:59]
and also looking at the sites, I, I served on a couple
[36:01]
of the boards as its chair in the town of Perry as well.
[36:05]
So I have a little bit more of an insight,
[36:07]
a little bit more knowledge.
[36:08]
And since this is being proposed
[36:09]
to be constructed in our backyard,
[36:12]
I thought maybe I would come forward
[36:14]
and share some of my thoughts.
[36:16]
There is an affordability factor that is,
[36:19]
has risen in this state.
[36:20]
Just over a year, year and a half ago, there were dozens
[36:24]
and dozens of communities in this state
[36:26]
that defeated their school budgets.
[36:28]
Affordability became a very, very real thing
[36:31]
and it still is, hasn't gone away.
[36:34]
This led to a shakeup in our legislature, change
[36:37]
of the balances and so forth that there was just part of a,
[36:41]
a radical shift
[36:42]
because people had reached at
[36:45]
that time the end of their agenda.
[36:48]
This hasn't changed much.
[36:50]
This led to the current redistricting proposals out there.
[36:54]
We're not sure how that's gonna end up
[36:56]
and what that's going to do.
[36:58]
This may even have an, an effect on the existing buildings.
[37:02]
We may have buildings,
[37:03]
we may be closing some buildings in the state.
[37:05]
I'm talking about education from a 30,000 foot elevation,
[37:09]
something I'm used to doing
[37:11]
and looking at what does this look like for our area.
[37:15]
And a lot of the really small schools that when you go back
[37:19]
to Act 60 was kind of intended to close a lot
[37:22]
of those smaller schools 'cause they became very,
[37:24]
very expensive at that time.
[37:26]
I remember Roxbury for example,
[37:28]
the average cost per pupil under
[37:30]
that particular formula was somewhere
[37:32]
around $46,000 a year for student.
[37:35]
Which I thought was equivalent to a Harvard education.
[37:38]
I won't go into that, but the declining enrollments in
[37:42]
students across the state of Vermont
[37:43]
and the general cost of education increasing the idea
[37:48]
of tacking on another eight
[37:49]
or 9% on top of everything else for the next 30 years
[37:54]
is difficult to really fathom for a lot of the people
[37:57]
who make my phone ring off code sometimes
[37:59]
because they still think I'm still seeing on a board,
[38:01]
which I am not the, the concern that we have is
[38:06]
that over the 30 years time, even if everything was frozen,
[38:11]
there was no increase in the cost of education.
[38:13]
Which I don't think anybody's sitting on a board
[38:16]
will recognize that as being the case.
[38:17]
Costs just seem to be going up
[38:20]
and generally speaking it is gonna go up a rate
[38:22]
that's higher than nutrition.
[38:24]
It has done so for the last, oh I don't know,
[38:27]
25, 30 years since I've been gone to schools
[38:31]
building the state of the art building may be,
[38:34]
but it's not necessary as far as what most of the people
[38:38]
that talk to me about, if Randolph can accept 40 students,
[38:44]
there's probably a lot of other school systems where there
[38:48]
to declar enrollments that are affected
[38:50]
the same way Randolph is.
[38:51]
They could take in students,
[38:54]
maybe we're looking at it from a different point of view
[38:56]
that we should be looking at satellites.
[38:59]
There are a lot of school districts across the country when
[39:03]
I was in Virginia saw that there were district satellite
[39:06]
entities and they seem to work very well.
[39:09]
True enough there's gonna be ***** no matter what you do
[39:12]
as far as where you set things up, whether they be satellite
[39:15]
or you have the state of the art building.
[39:18]
The graniteville district kind of concerned me
[39:21]
because that's their water district.
[39:22]
And the water district from my understanding,
[39:24]
doesn't have the capacity for this.
[39:26]
So I have a real stranges quirky question.
[39:29]
My back of my head is,
[39:30]
where will the water come from to supply this?
[39:33]
'cause right now that needs a tremendous upgrade.
[39:36]
I don't know about the sewer capacities.
[39:38]
I know we, we are coed with Barry City for that.
[39:44]
And as was mentioned on your presentation,
[39:49]
there is some concerns about traffic.
[39:51]
Those of us who live in the town, you're gonna have
[39:54]
to come up some state hills.
[39:55]
You're gonna come to some interesting intersections to get
[39:58]
to this location.
[39:59]
Which passing understanding is in the farthest corner
[40:03]
of the district that this is a interesting place
[40:08]
and, and most of us who lived
[40:10]
around these general areas knew that there were wetlands
[40:13]
and other concerns and obviously not
[40:14]
showing up in their maps.
[40:19]
We had a response
[40:22]
after we had formed our Act 46 group
[40:26]
and we realized there were so many other acts
[40:28]
that the state was throwing at us.
[40:30]
We just couldn't keep up with it.
[40:31]
Act 1 73, which dealt with the special ed formula, caused us
[40:36]
to buy a piece of property
[40:38]
and build what we called as the sea building.
[40:41]
And that was the intent
[40:42]
to bring in our special ed kids back in
[40:45]
because we didn't want to get hammered.
[40:47]
'cause we were told at the time it might cost us a million
[40:50]
or two a year, an extra expense to the district.
[40:53]
So it made sense to maybe put a couple million
[40:55]
dollars in building, building.
[40:57]
However that project went 50% over.
[41:01]
And we also found out that
[41:04]
the way the X 2073 panned out to, we built it basically
[41:10]
on a theory and it never panned out.
[41:13]
As much as I believe in tech schools
[41:15]
and I do believe in tech technology
[41:17]
is is very, very important.
[41:18]
I believe in education or I wouldn't even be here
[41:21]
tonight to talk about it.
[41:24]
I'm aware of many of the neighbors in my community that said
[41:28]
that they've hit the maximum what they can pay.
[41:32]
So if you say an average cost of a home is around 300,000,
[41:36]
you are looking at something between oh 110
[41:40]
and $140 per house at that range.
[41:45]
That's, that's a sizeable increase when you look at it
[41:49]
in the real scale of
[41:51]
what housing in Vermont has gone since COVID came in
[41:54]
those housing numbers.
[41:55]
I'm not even sure $300,000 will get you
[41:58]
into a decent house anymore.
[42:00]
I know there's a lot of people that are in Barr Town,
[42:02]
particularly the town that I live in
[42:05]
who have properties are way more than that
[42:08]
and a lot of 'em are probably paying one to
[42:13]
one and a half thousand dollars per month.
[42:15]
That used to be a big mortgage many years ago.
[42:18]
Right now that's just the ordinary tax.
[42:21]
I would encourage you to look at, you know, the,
[42:26]
the facts that we're going
[42:27]
to have continuing education increase
[42:29]
and maybe look outside the box.
[42:32]
Whenever I was designing buildings and
[42:34]
and doing construction so forth, we looked at, you know,
[42:38]
optimum ways to stretching that dollar homeowners
[42:41]
and businesses wanted that from us and that was important.
[42:45]
I know these gentlemen have done a good job.
[42:47]
I mean when we were involved with our C building,
[42:50]
I was involved with that committee very directly
[42:52]
and talked about its expansion
[42:54]
because we thought that's exactly
[42:55]
what was going to have to happen.
[42:57]
And we allowed for an expansion
[43:00]
by planning its infrastructure
[43:01]
but that purpose we're not fully filled on
[43:05]
that building at this point.
[43:07]
That kind of concerns me too.
[43:08]
'cause that's another thing that we are concerned about.
[43:12]
It's not that I'm against technical education,
[43:14]
quite the contrary.
[43:16]
I think it's a very, very important habit.
[43:19]
But we are in a state, this is not northern Virginia,
[43:21]
we're in a state right now
[43:22]
where people are actually having a hard time, A,
[43:25]
getting housing B, being able to afford housing
[43:28]
and C are having a hard time making all ends.
[43:31]
B we are a state of older population.
[43:35]
I hear gives testimony to that.
[43:37]
And as a result of that, there are a lot of people
[43:40]
who are on fixed incomes.
[43:42]
We have a difficult time making ends meet.
[43:45]
They shouldn't have to choose between their medicines,
[43:49]
their their food, clothing and shelter.
[43:53]
And they have a tax burden on top of that.
[43:55]
'cause every one of them making that, not to mention energy,
[43:58]
energy is a real big problem right now
[44:00]
and in this state we've gone in these directions
[44:03]
and made it next to it possible.
[44:05]
I don't think the legislators really had a clue as to
[44:08]
what was gonna happen with Act 1 27.
[44:11]
But it was a big blow up. The idea change in models.
[44:14]
Once again, coming back to special ed, we don't,
[44:18]
we don't know what's gonna happen in the near future.
[44:21]
That's the problem we're talking about.
[44:24]
What happens to this school system.
[44:27]
For example, our population is drawn tremendously
[44:32]
and some days we have maybe four
[44:34]
or 500 kids in this building, which used
[44:35]
to have 13, 14, 1500 kids.
[44:38]
That's just one building
[44:39]
and we're watching our populations decline.
[44:43]
We no longer have, you know, three or 4,000 students.
[44:46]
We're now headed towards under 2200 students
[44:48]
for this entire district.
[44:50]
That's Barry and Barry down,
[44:52]
which in this circle is the largest district.
[44:56]
What is the burden?
[44:58]
I was listening to
[44:59]
how this bond might work out if students shift, does
[45:03]
that mean that the bond ratios that been put together
[45:06]
for the 18 towns also shift?
[45:08]
It sounded like it a minute ago.
[45:11]
And that's leads to another thing of uncertainty.
[45:15]
And we shouldn't go into something
[45:16]
with an uncertainty principle.
[45:19]
I hope it didn't discourage you,
[45:21]
but I just thought somebody had
[45:22]
to say it was my ears been getting bent quite a bit on it
[45:25]
and I just thought I'd share that. Thank you. Thank you.
[45:28]
Thanks.
[45:34]
This isn't clear. I thought somebody else
[45:36]
Had No I On a different issue.
[45:39]
Okay, let's roll with this one.
[45:42]
I just wanna say I am a strong support of the test school.
[45:45]
I think it's awesome what they offer
[45:47]
and I always feel bad for the students that want to go
[45:50]
that can't attend for that year.
[45:53]
'cause I know it impacts their,
[45:55]
their plans and their future.
[45:59]
Speaking about this district, Mr. Malone is,
[46:03]
is accurate when he says we just this one year we've lost
[46:06]
eight students at Swanley High School
[46:09]
and which is quite concerning
[46:13]
because it was, it used to be 1600 students here.
[46:17]
I went to school here and I remember when it was packed.
[46:20]
But anyways, and,
[46:21]
but they have a $70 million budget here that we're paying
[46:26]
for taxes and in addition to all the property taxes.
[46:31]
So I really would like to see this happen,
[46:35]
but I just have some questions before we get there.
[46:38]
Was there a cost benefit analysis done on
[46:43]
the existing building versus the new deal as far
[46:47]
as getting your needs here to,
[46:50]
do you know if that was done at all?
[46:54]
Yes, we actually had the architects design
[46:57]
what it would look like to add the spaces here
[47:00]
for us to be able to do that.
[47:02]
Okay. It doesn't fit. Okay.
[47:04]
There are some concerns about this being a floodplain.
[47:07]
As you know, we have not had this building tested for PCBs
[47:11]
yet, so there might be some mitigation there.
[47:13]
Okay. So there's, there are a lot of potential factors
[47:17]
and if we're renovating any part of the space to become
[47:21]
lab spaces, there are very different spaces than
[47:24]
classroom spaces.
[47:26]
Okay. So it's a pretty significant shift as far as heights
[47:29]
of ceilings ability to carry weight.
[47:32]
So we did look at that
[47:34]
and we did actually bring it to the very board.
[47:36]
You did? Gosh, it was a while ago, two years ago, Joe,
[47:41]
I'm not sure if it was two, but it was a while ago
[47:42]
Was, wasn't there also an issue that,
[47:44]
that we don't own this building?
[47:48]
Right. And so I can't remember
[47:50]
what it was until I thought that.
[47:52]
Right. Honestly,
[47:54]
I don't think anyone's answered the question
[47:55]
of if CT has become a single district
[47:58]
who owns the CTE spaces
[47:59]
because the, the funds were direct CTE funds
[48:04]
that pay for the spaces.
[48:06]
So that's a, that's a really good question,
[48:07]
but right now we can pay a facility to use fee for a lot
[48:11]
of the infrastructure that is part of the full building.
[48:14]
Yeah. Well and we also have the issue that we can't use
[48:18]
our grant funding for upgrades
[48:21]
because we don't own the building.
[48:22]
Right. Question.
[48:26]
So beyond the students, which I think would be great.
[48:29]
Is there any other plans
[48:30]
and you probably haven't got here yet, like for
[48:35]
adult workforce training?
[48:37]
Yes. Okay. So one of the, one of the things
[48:40]
that I've been doing a lot of research on is just
[48:44]
CTE across our country.
[48:46]
And there are a lot of benefits in just
[48:50]
training students here, high school students
[48:52]
and what they get and bring to our communities
[48:54]
because more of them tend to stay in the communities.
[48:57]
And of course I think Lyman, you were talking about this
[48:59]
before the meeting started, the average salary
[49:02]
that they get coming straight out of tech school instead
[49:05]
of straight out of high school
[49:06]
and entering in as an apprentice
[49:08]
and as an electrician for example,
[49:10]
is much higher than their peers
[49:11]
that they're sending schools.
[49:13]
So their earning potential
[49:14]
and their ability to potentially settle here
[49:16]
and be part of that tax base is also higher.
[49:21]
We are on the precipice of signing an agreement
[49:25]
with district six emergency services to do all
[49:27]
of their training and the funds that they get for the grants
[49:31]
that they get for their training.
[49:33]
And some state grants are coming to us to pilot this so
[49:36]
that we do it all here, partly
[49:38]
because we have redundant equipment
[49:41]
and so they won't have to keep investing in equipment
[49:43]
that we already have and we have the spaces
[49:45]
to do the training instead of having
[49:47]
to pull the firetrucks out of the fire station so
[49:49]
that they can do a training day.
[49:51]
So that's something that we're soon to sign off on.
[49:54]
I would say within the next two weeks
[49:58]
we have a new adult ed coordinator who's working
[50:01]
on some other pieces.
[50:02]
And so we're looking at growing not only
[50:04]
where our high school students have access,
[50:06]
but also any training for adult education.
[50:08]
So it, we're hoping
[50:10]
that this new facility will be a much better hub for all of
[50:13]
that and to support all
[50:15]
of the workforce development in our region.
[50:18]
I have one last questions to her.
[50:21]
One, if one
[50:22]
of the sunny districts will know, we won't know.
[50:27]
We won't know. Our votes are commingled,
[50:30]
so we just have the end result of yeses and nos.
[50:33]
Okay. So it's a majority.
[50:35]
And from these towns it seems like it's gonna be
[50:37]
hard for them to budget.
[50:40]
Will there be like a heads up
[50:41]
or some kind of That's a really good question
[50:46]
and we're gonna do the best we can
[50:48]
to provide all the information that we do.
[50:49]
As you've sat through a couple of my roadshows in December
[50:53]
where I go and let everybody know where's our budget at,
[50:56]
what, what's the impact on you?
[51:00]
But we're all gonna have to wait and see what happens.
[51:03]
There are so many things
[51:04]
that we just can't predict right now that we're,
[51:06]
that's why we're sitting with these FY 26 numbers
[51:09]
because that's the only thing we have that's real right now.
[51:13]
And there's nothing that we can predict.
[51:15]
So are these numbers real?
[51:17]
No, because they apply
[51:18]
as if we were paying back something this year under
[51:21]
everything that's currently happening.
[51:23]
And any change to that shifts those numbers.
[51:26]
Thank you so much.
[51:30]
I just wanted to address one
[51:32]
thing, Mr. Malone, is that right?
[51:33]
Yes. Line and gas.
[51:36]
The, the idea of Randolph that I had the same idea you did,
[51:41]
which was if Randolph could take 40 of our kids
[51:44]
and other schools could take some,
[51:46]
we'd be set and we'd be fine.
[51:48]
And Jody, I thought you responded very well to me, which was
[51:53]
now we're talking about a kid somehow getting from Cabot
[51:57]
to here, Cabot from their house to cab school to here
[52:03]
to Randolph in the middle of winter
[52:07]
is a long way away.
[52:09]
They'll, they'll spend more time on the bus than they
[52:12]
will in the building.
[52:13]
I believe it'll be right around the same.
[52:16]
And so that's not an ideal.
[52:19]
Well I I would add to that,
[52:20]
that if you've been watching North Southwest has had two
[52:24]
meetings with Pain Mountain School District
[52:27]
where they're trying to talk about should they move forward
[52:30]
with a merger idea ahead of
[52:33]
what the legislature is gonna do.
[52:34]
And some very folks, very board folks were there to listen
[52:39]
at their last meeting last week, which is the same time
[52:42]
as the Washington Central meeting.
[52:44]
And basically what I interpreted was
[52:47]
that Orange Southwest is saying Randolph school has,
[52:50]
is going to, in the near future,
[52:52]
have some pretty big failures that are gonna cost them a lot
[52:55]
of money and that they would need a new building.
[52:58]
And so they were looking for Paine Mountain
[53:01]
to potentially join 'em
[53:03]
and build a new regional high school in
[53:05]
Randolph with a tech center.
[53:09]
Our new center could potentially take care of our region
[53:14]
and the Randolph students
[53:15]
because they're 106 with our students.
[53:22]
I'd like to respond to you.
[53:24]
I'm the kind of a person that likes
[53:26]
to think outta the box.
[53:27]
In fact, I usually pretend there is no box.
[53:30]
You know, Randolph was a long ways to go.
[53:32]
My, my first commentary to that would be
[53:35]
that there are a lot of buildings in this district,
[53:37]
the overall what might be a new state district, who knows?
[53:41]
But there's an awful lot of space that is trying
[53:43]
to be created in a lot of the schools
[53:45]
to constantly closing schools
[53:47]
because there's that much space
[53:49]
and small populations kind of forces you to that.
[53:54]
So two, two ways of answering that is maybe to look,
[53:57]
look at all the schools that we have right now, which are,
[53:59]
you're sending the schools and say, is there, is there a way
[54:02]
to maybe do satellites
[54:03]
or another way to look at that is go ahead the bond go,
[54:07]
if it fails, then you come back
[54:08]
to looking at maybe some satellite programs.
[54:12]
I don't see any other route to that,
[54:14]
but that's, I I don't serve in your capacity
[54:17]
and you have a a, a way in blaming these two. But it is
[54:22]
No, I I I think these are all things
[54:24]
that we've been discussing over the past couple of years
[54:28]
and there's a lot of yes, ands, let's do this.
[54:32]
And there's also a well, but this doesn't work
[54:35]
because of this reason.
[54:38]
We've kind of been juggling all of those things for,
[54:42]
since the district was started.
[54:44]
And
[54:46]
If, if the state was building tech centers like they did
[54:50]
before, go back some time to when this meeting was put on
[54:55]
and they were gonna do that a hundred percent.
[54:57]
There's no question in my mind. I like the pretty pictures.
[55:01]
I like what, what you're trying to do.
[55:02]
I like the idea you expanded program,
[55:05]
but what's going to be the thing that holds everything up is
[55:08]
how do people who actually pay for this,
[55:12]
I'm not speaking for myself personally,
[55:16]
having put poor kids through college, I can tell you clearly
[55:20]
that it's, it's, it's an interesting path
[55:24]
and, you know, education costs.
[55:26]
But in this reality, in this day and age
[55:29]
and being in the state, Vermont
[55:31]
moneys are drying up in a lot of different quarters.
[55:33]
And you are, our economic growth is,
[55:36]
is not really like it was say cir
[55:39]
nineties, eighties and so on. That's all I say.
[55:43]
Thank you.
[55:49]
Anyone online have any questions or concerns?
[55:55]
Come on Guy.
[56:02]
Can can I ask another quick question? Michelle?
[56:05]
I was looking in your, what remains uncertain yield
[56:08]
and CLA adjustments are in there.
[56:10]
And is that only for like taking, like figuring out
[56:14]
how much a specific town would,
[56:18]
it would cost a, a 300,000?
[56:20]
It's not the actual like proportional. Right. Okay, cool.
[56:24]
Right. Yeah, it's simply like XX number
[56:28]
of students on average over the last six semesters came
[56:31]
from Montpelier.
[56:32]
So that proportion of the, the bond bill is paid
[56:36]
by Montpelier and then you divide up based on the property.
[56:39]
Yep. By grant risk, whatever. Yeah. Fantastic.
[56:42]
Now I'm ready to explain the tax system.
[56:48]
I mean at, at the end of the day it seems like it has test
[56:51]
for me because broadly speaking
[56:54]
the project is gonna add about 4.5%
[56:57]
to the total expenditures of the 18 towns.
[57:00]
And we saw that there's an average about five
[57:02]
and three quarter percent
[57:03]
or something like that, which probably accounts
[57:05]
for financing costs
[57:06]
or variability in the, in the
[57:09]
translating my rough numbers to real numbers.
[57:13]
So to me it passes the sniff test.
[57:15]
It may be a little conservative,
[57:20]
which is probably where you want to be.
[57:26]
Todd, I heard something from my, I thought so.
[57:27]
Thought so too. Did anyone try to raise a hand?
[57:33]
Alright, well that brings us to
[57:38]
conclusion of our discussion.
[57:41]
What action does our career center need from the
[57:46]
board at this time, if any?
[57:50]
I don't have that. We do, sorry to close my computer,
[57:54]
but the authorization to draft a warning to get this
[57:59]
to our taxpayers.
[58:03]
I do have the warning, I do have the language
[58:05]
for this summary, but we're just drafting,
[58:08]
we're agreeing to draft one.
[58:10]
We're not authorizing the warning at this time. No. Correct.
[58:12]
I just need you to authorize the ability to drop the warning
[58:16]
to bring it to the taxpayer.
[58:18]
Okay. So we need a motion for the board to draft a warning
[58:23]
announcing the, the bond vote
[58:27]
and allowing all those who have
[58:31]
significant input to put that together.
[58:34]
So I need a motion to draft a warning for the bond vote.
[58:38]
I'll make that motion. Alice. Thank you. All right guy.
[58:42]
Need a second? A second. Patrick, any discussion?
[58:50]
Any questions? Hearing none.
[58:54]
All those in favor, please say aye.
[58:56]
Aye. Aye. Aye.
[58:58]
Aye. Okay. We got everyone in the room.
[59:03]
Everyone online. Okay.
[59:07]
Any dissension?
[59:11]
Any abstentions?
[59:14]
Hearing none. Motion carries.
[59:22]
Now who will work on that?
[59:24]
Me, we're gonna bring it to legal counsel
[59:27]
and then we'll bring you the morning for official approval
[59:31]
next September 8th.
[59:34]
All right. So we will hear from our school administration
[59:39]
and legal counsel on September 8th.
[59:43]
Can I, for the purposes of our tenants, can I ask,
[59:47]
who is the phone number that ends in eight six?
[59:53]
This is Yara Mosquito. Oh, thank you Yara.
[59:59]
Okay, thank you. All right,
[1:00:03]
Just a process question.
[1:00:04]
Yes. So we just need to get that vetted warning
[1:00:08]
to the town clerks, like, whatever,
[1:00:10]
40 days or something like that.
[1:00:12]
30 days, whatever they're Yep. Before,
[1:00:15]
Yeah, before vote.
[1:00:17]
I had to start a Google sheet. 'cause there's a
[1:00:18]
Lot of, they all have
[1:00:20]
In all the different towns. Thank
[1:00:23]
You.
[1:00:24]
Thank you. Thank you guys.
[1:00:27]
Work my way backwards on this one.
[1:00:29]
On on that same note,
[1:00:30]
the question I was gonna ask earlier was,
[1:00:32]
we have the town clerks on to process the votes.
[1:00:38]
They're all aware. They're all aware.
[1:00:40]
They've had some conversations,
[1:00:41]
they've asked some questions.
[1:00:42]
Okay. But they know it's coming
[1:00:44]
and they've been providing me with
[1:00:46]
where the voting will take place
[1:00:48]
and the the hours they'll be open.
[1:00:50]
So we're updating that information. Awesome.
[1:00:55]
All right. Moving forward. Marketing updates.
[1:01:02]
I'll have two tomatoes and a zucchini.
[1:01:05]
Careful when asking the zucchinis
[1:01:13]
uc.
[1:01:16]
So a lot of doors around here.
[1:01:19]
Last week a small cohort of folks had the opportunity
[1:01:22]
to look at three campaigns.
[1:01:26]
I think Todd was probably the only board member there.
[1:01:31]
Options that the marketing team had put together
[1:01:35]
and to give some feedback
[1:01:36]
and we did give some pretty direct feedback that was linked
[1:01:40]
to some documents the board got.
[1:01:44]
And later the next day, August 21st, Michelle
[1:01:48]
and I received a, like the media plan
[1:01:53]
in the original agreement.
[1:01:54]
There's, I have a couple of concerns,
[1:01:58]
but one of which is that they've decided
[1:02:00]
to take away a direct mailer.
[1:02:02]
And I think that our, I wanted
[1:02:04]
to get feedback from the board
[1:02:05]
because I feel like our communities expect
[1:02:07]
our budget postcard.
[1:02:09]
And so not doing that for a bond vote worries me
[1:02:14]
that people will be expecting it and they won't get it.
[1:02:18]
I wonder if I should just present the media piece
[1:02:22]
that they asked us for feedback on
[1:02:26]
Somebody in the packet online, right?
[1:02:28]
I think I sent it today. Yeah.
[1:02:31]
Be updated. Yeah.
[1:02:33]
Strongly recommended to direct mail or to constituents.
[1:02:36]
It's the most surefire way to hit everybody. Yeah,
[1:02:39]
People like it.
[1:02:41]
We've gotten the most feedback on our direct mailers than
[1:02:45]
anything that we, so there was a recommendation
[1:02:47]
that the majority of the majority of what they were going
[1:02:50]
to do would be through social media.
[1:02:52]
So we do, we did upgrade our Facebook to a paid Facebook
[1:02:57]
and we've upgraded all of our Instagrams
[1:02:59]
for every single program so that they're all linked to it so
[1:03:02]
that we can push out information on Instagram and Facebook
[1:03:07]
and so can our marketing team, they will do lawn signs
[1:03:11]
and brochures for
[1:03:14]
print purposes.
[1:03:16]
And the lawn signs and brochures are probably what's coming.
[1:03:19]
First. They propose some 32nd radio spots
[1:03:25]
on three channels.
[1:03:28]
So they are froggy
[1:03:31]
and Frank and one other.
[1:03:35]
DEV? No,
[1:03:37]
We said no, No,
[1:03:39]
No.
[1:03:40]
The point. No, no, we said no. Sorry.
[1:03:43]
Let me hold it Up at DEV. Okay. That's,
[1:03:46]
Oh, okay.
[1:03:47]
And, and you are searches for the
[1:03:49]
Record.
[1:03:50]
Memel is my name. Meyers Rome.
[1:03:52]
Okay, say that one more time.
[1:03:55]
Memel. M-E-R-M-E-L. Okay. First name Meyers. M-Y-E-R-S.
[1:04:01]
So froggy, Frank and the penguin.
[1:04:03]
And they did note that WDEB said no
[1:04:08]
and then placing ads in the times RES basically
[1:04:12]
every other week between our, our warning decision
[1:04:16]
that happened September 8th meeting
[1:04:18]
and up until the bond vote.
[1:04:22]
I'm curious about the statement about why they
[1:04:25]
didn't include direct mail.
[1:04:27]
While we love the impact of a well-designed mailer,
[1:04:31]
we have found other channels
[1:04:32]
to be much more efficient in reaching the right people.
[1:04:37]
And yeah, I just,
[1:04:41]
So we have to provide feedback to them by the 30th
[1:04:44]
and I'm happy to do it actually by tomorrow, but,
[1:04:48]
and that's one where I feel like that was part
[1:04:51]
of our agreement with 'em, is
[1:04:52]
that there would be a direct mailing
[1:04:54]
and that we have to hold them to that.
[1:04:56]
Yeah, I would push back on that
[1:04:58]
and ask if, if they have any, like to provide some sort
[1:05:02]
of rationale evidence support for those, for that statement.
[1:05:06]
'cause
[1:05:08]
And of the three campaigns, the strongest one was honestly
[1:05:11]
based on education networks, which is our tagline
[1:05:15]
and which they actually created all of our, our tagline
[1:05:19]
and our, what am I talking about?
[1:05:23]
The images? Logo. Logo. Logo, thank you. Several years ago.
[1:05:26]
So it's not anything new that they're providing in this,
[1:05:30]
it's building off of what they had created before.
[1:05:33]
Jody, can you explain a little bit on the, the notes
[1:05:38]
that you have on that, that sheet
[1:05:41]
and this idea that a lot of this stuff That's
[1:05:46]
whether it's we're doing it, they're doing it.
[1:05:51]
Yeah. So I shared with the board
[1:05:55]
just a spreadsheet of here's what was in our contract,
[1:05:59]
here's what we've gotten so far as far as the deliverables
[1:06:02]
and the date that we received it.
[1:06:04]
And then a few concerns just,
[1:06:08]
I think this is their first bond vote.
[1:06:10]
And so helping them to realize what we can
[1:06:13]
and can't say, we can't put line on signs out to say,
[1:06:17]
vote yes, we can say please vote.
[1:06:21]
So, you know, those sort of nuances
[1:06:23]
that we've been working through.
[1:06:25]
There was at one point a time when Michelle reached out
[1:06:28]
to have a meeting with 'em 'cause we were concerned about
[1:06:30]
our timeline and we weren't seeing anything yet
[1:06:33]
and we were declined that meeting.
[1:06:37]
There's a lot of phrasing in the first, the three campaigns
[1:06:40]
that they offered us that ha have some negative statements
[1:06:43]
like education can't wait
[1:06:46]
or were, were out of capacity in the space.
[1:06:51]
Not outta Hope. Outta hope.
[1:06:52]
Which didn't land well for anyone on the committee
[1:06:54]
that heard that one, honestly.
[1:06:57]
And we're like, that's no, that's not,
[1:06:59]
that doesn't feel right for us ourselves against Hope.
[1:07:02]
Right? And so what I can say is nobody was afraid to share
[1:07:06]
that these, this did not resonate with us.
[1:07:08]
And that the education networks really was the best option
[1:07:11]
so far that they had been working with.
[1:07:13]
And they understood that and they took those notes
[1:07:15]
and they got that feedback.
[1:07:17]
So I feel like we're going to see that shift.
[1:07:20]
It was just, it, it feels like we have a short timeline
[1:07:23]
and it's not happening as fast as we would like it to.
[1:07:25]
And it's not looking as beautiful
[1:07:28]
as I would hope right away.
[1:07:31]
We have been collecting information about key stakeholders
[1:07:34]
and Yara, you're on the phone, thank you so much
[1:07:36]
for your willingness to be interviewed.
[1:07:39]
Should they reach out to some of our alumni.
[1:07:43]
And that's a hope that we have.
[1:07:44]
And we're using those stakeholders with our other consultant
[1:07:47]
for our comprehensive local needs as assessment as well.
[1:07:50]
And we're currently, you'll see in this week, we'll
[1:07:54]
that we're reaching out asking alumni
[1:07:55]
and parents, if you are willing to be interviewed for part
[1:07:58]
of this process to talk about why you might support this
[1:08:01]
or why CBCC for your kiddo, or how, how our education works.
[1:08:07]
That's, those are people who are hoping that we'll volunteer
[1:08:10]
and let us know so that they can be interviewed
[1:08:12]
by both sets of consultants.
[1:08:15]
We're wondering about the world.
[1:08:16]
A lot of people, as I think Todd wrote to me earlier today,
[1:08:19]
lots of people read it just for the obituaries.
[1:08:21]
But we might be in there
[1:08:24]
and be able to get some, we do some advertisements in there.
[1:08:27]
Why wasn't the world mentioned?
[1:08:28]
Is Vermont Digger someplace that we're gonna reach out to?
[1:08:31]
Is WCAX someplace we're gonna reach out to?
[1:08:34]
Our videography class is gonna be doing a podcasting unit.
[1:08:37]
They're wanting to do some of this work too
[1:08:40]
and see how they can share stories.
[1:08:44]
One of our teachers said, what about a lobbyist?
[1:08:47]
And I know Myers, you're here to talk about
[1:08:50]
what you're thinking we might need, which is different than
[1:08:53]
what we've been presented with.
[1:08:55]
And so I just wanted the board to have a conversation about
[1:08:58]
what are, what are our expectations for this marketing team?
[1:09:02]
And we set them and hold 'em to them.
[1:09:05]
Or at what point if we feel like they're not making those
[1:09:10]
expectations happen, what do we wanna do about that?
[1:09:14]
Jenna question?
[1:09:16]
Yeah. Yeah. I just was wondering if everybody had posted
[1:09:19]
on Front Porch Forum.
[1:09:21]
I haven't gotten any feedback from my post,
[1:09:24]
but I was just wondering if, I mean,
[1:09:26]
that seemed like a good vehicle,
[1:09:28]
but it seems like until the bond comes up
[1:09:31]
that it's a one shot thing.
[1:09:33]
Until now we have to wait.
[1:09:35]
I don't think we can keep posting the same kind of thing.
[1:09:39]
And now we have to wait and remind people to vote.
[1:09:43]
Yes, they'll be including some op-eds
[1:09:45]
that was part of their plan as well.
[1:09:48]
But as you know, that's that one
[1:09:49]
that I asked you to post I created.
[1:09:52]
Right. No, that was good.
[1:09:54]
I put my name to it so that they could see it was local.
[1:09:58]
But the other thing is,
[1:10:03]
well, since I just forgot
[1:10:05]
what I was gonna say, just forget it.
[1:10:08]
So I'll just go away.
[1:10:12]
Don't go away, guy.
[1:10:16]
Yeah, a co a couple things.
[1:10:18]
Follow up on the direct mail stuff.
[1:10:20]
I'm, I'm of two minds
[1:10:23]
and David, don't take offense to this
[1:10:25]
'cause it's not your fault, but I get my newspaper in the
[1:10:29]
mail and I still haven't gotten my weekend newspaper
[1:10:32]
and it's gonna be easy probably by the time I get it.
[1:10:36]
So, but having heard some of the
[1:10:41]
testimony tonight based on, you know, who some
[1:10:45]
of the voters are, there are not a lot of, of people
[1:10:50]
who are elderly
[1:10:51]
and on fixed incomes who necessarily follow social media.
[1:10:56]
So I've got a little bit of concern about that,
[1:11:00]
but I also know that direct mail is,
[1:11:02]
you know, can be expensive.
[1:11:04]
The other thing I wanted to second is, you know,
[1:11:07]
certainly the Washington world is,
[1:11:10]
I think a lot of people pick it up.
[1:11:12]
It's a freebie. And I also wonder about the
[1:11:15]
Waterbury Roundabout.
[1:11:17]
And I think it's an area where, you know,
[1:11:20]
perhaps doesn't get reached by, you know, some
[1:11:23]
of the other newspapers.
[1:11:25]
And quite frankly, I think they were the only ones
[1:11:28]
that appeared at, at some of the presentations that we did.
[1:11:32]
So I certainly would give them a shot.
[1:11:35]
And the last thing I would say, even though WDV has has
[1:11:40]
stand us down or you know, is not interested in advertising
[1:11:43]
or they're too expensive, they do have the Vermont Viewpoint
[1:11:48]
Show where we could, you know,
[1:11:51]
strategically get an interview on.
[1:11:54]
And I'm more than happy to, you know, to contact, you know,
[1:11:59]
certain people to, you know, to get Jody
[1:12:02]
or you know, somebody else on to, you know,
[1:12:05]
talk about the project.
[1:12:08]
I think that's a great opening. Yeah.
[1:12:10]
Let's just go to Lyman and then we'll go to
[1:12:12]
Mr.
[1:12:13]
Mayor. Just really quickly,
[1:12:13]
I'm wondering if we could put together just some very short
[1:12:17]
two or three sentence from porch forums,
[1:12:20]
because I don't read anything.
[1:12:23]
It's eight paragraphs along from anybody
[1:12:29]
I, I read because, because I should,
[1:12:33]
but I really think just some, let's hit 'em hard
[1:12:37]
with these little blurbs
[1:12:39]
that we've been talking about, I think would be great.
[1:12:42]
Alright, Mr. Burl, do you have a presentation or something
[1:12:46]
To say?
[1:12:47]
Well, just something to say actually. Okay.
[1:12:49]
I, so I'm the incoming owner at WDEV Radio Vermont.
[1:12:52]
So I'm taking over what a great man started at Ken Squire.
[1:12:57]
And we cover these 18 towns.
[1:12:58]
We were recently ranked by Nielsen as having,
[1:13:01]
as being number one across all age groups, 12 to 65
[1:13:05]
with WBB across all of central and northern Vermont.
[1:13:08]
We're 73% ahead of our next closest competitor.
[1:13:13]
So we're very, we have a very fortunate place
[1:13:16]
where we've earned the trust of Vermonters,
[1:13:18]
but we also, we hear a lot of things.
[1:13:21]
And so when I was approached by one of the,
[1:13:24]
the media brokers, I know you don't have any money to spend,
[1:13:27]
but I'm not here to ask for money.
[1:13:30]
I'm here to, I'm here to ask you to point me in a direction.
[1:13:33]
But let me tell you why. When I was first approached,
[1:13:38]
they said, well, why didn't you just do five days
[1:13:40]
of advertising for 10 days
[1:13:41]
of advertising right before the vote?
[1:13:43]
That's not enough. That's not even nearly enough.
[1:13:46]
This is gonna be the second highest bond vote
[1:13:49]
in the state of Vermont.
[1:13:50]
And your towns,
[1:13:53]
my my own eighth great grandfathers buried Perry.
[1:13:56]
I know these towns, right, they don't have a lot of money
[1:13:58]
to spend, but this is an investment to
[1:14:01]
to, to turn things around.
[1:14:02]
I wish Mr. Malone had stayed. Everything he said was right.
[1:14:06]
People don't wanna make those decisions.
[1:14:08]
But here's an, here's a chance
[1:14:10]
to make an investment in these attempts
[1:14:12]
to keep people together, to keep their families together,
[1:14:15]
to provide jobs for their own children.
[1:14:18]
That will turn the demographics around that alone.
[1:14:22]
This is probably one of the most important,
[1:14:23]
if not the most important project
[1:14:25]
that Vermont is considering today.
[1:14:27]
This is a construct of project, not a destructive project.
[1:14:31]
Look at energy, healthcare, public safety,
[1:14:35]
none of those things are working.
[1:14:36]
Here's an opportunity to actually turn something around.
[1:14:39]
So we're, we're very much in favor of this.
[1:14:41]
We, we typically don't, don't get behind public project,
[1:14:45]
but we want to get behind this one.
[1:14:46]
This is very important.
[1:14:48]
And our concern is, one of the things
[1:14:50]
that Mr. Malone mentioned is that if this project doesn't go
[1:14:53]
through November, that it's gonna be split into 15 different
[1:14:56]
pieces because the new education agenda
[1:15:00]
and that you're not gonna be able to consolidate people.
[1:15:02]
You're not gonna build a project that you want to build
[1:15:04]
that, that frankly our children deserve so
[1:15:08]
that they can stay here and work here.
[1:15:10]
AI is going to gut literally a lot, you know, 30 to 40%
[1:15:15]
of these college graduates.
[1:15:16]
But you can't, AI is not gonna replace somebody that comes
[1:15:19]
to your house to fix your plumbing or your HVAC
[1:15:23]
or drive the ambulance to come and get you.
[1:15:26]
These jobs are gonna stay.
[1:15:27]
And these are good paying jobs that, that will allow people
[1:15:31]
to build, build equity in homes and buy homes
[1:15:34]
and stay here, build families.
[1:15:35]
So in that regard, our thought was, you know,
[1:15:39]
there are 18 pounds and we were thinking of it more
[1:15:41]
as a political campaign.
[1:15:43]
John Rogers, you know, plumber hate took his first $40,000
[1:15:48]
and spent it in WDE and built up this huge grassroots base
[1:15:51]
because people listen to the radio.
[1:15:53]
We have an older population, they typically don't go
[1:15:55]
to digital, but we have a much better coverage of,
[1:15:59]
of the population than, than the small papers do.
[1:16:03]
So there's an opportunity sort of build grassroots support.
[1:16:05]
But as I, as I talked to Jody, it's not clear that
[1:16:09]
because you haven't had a lot
[1:16:10]
of public attendance at these meetings,
[1:16:12]
you don't really know what the public is thinking, right?
[1:16:14]
So I've talked to the elected representatives, they,
[1:16:16]
they're all negative, they're like, not gonna work, right?
[1:16:20]
It's too much money. We, you know, not now,
[1:16:23]
but what we thought might help would be a,
[1:16:27]
a very quick poll of these 18 pounds,
[1:16:30]
because it's not just money.
[1:16:32]
I think Vermonters are naturally fiscally conservative,
[1:16:36]
but they'll take risks, right?
[1:16:38]
And they'll do, they'll stand up
[1:16:40]
for the right And I think when they understand
[1:16:42]
how important this project is to the wellbeing
[1:16:46]
and the fiber of these towns, that they'll wanna support it.
[1:16:48]
But you need to find out where, where your votes are.
[1:16:51]
I mean, every yes vote regardless of
[1:16:52]
where it comes from helps, right?
[1:16:54]
So a poll would be able
[1:16:55]
to isolate likely voters within these 18,
[1:17:00]
within the 18 towns
[1:17:01]
and point you in a direction that with additional media,
[1:17:04]
and I mean very heavy advertising over the next two months,
[1:17:08]
that you might be in a position to overcome.
[1:17:10]
So I know that the board doesn't have the, the money
[1:17:12]
to fund this, but what I wanted to, what I'd asked Jody is,
[1:17:16]
you know, could you point in the direction
[1:17:17]
of your five biggest supporters, right?
[1:17:20]
We're willing to contribute as well.
[1:17:23]
We can't, we can't volunteer at all
[1:17:26]
and we certainly can't pay the pollsters,
[1:17:28]
but would it be possible for me to meet with your,
[1:17:32]
my biggest private company supporters?
[1:17:34]
I know private companies have want this thing to succeed
[1:17:37]
that will enjoy the, we will enjoy, like we will hire people
[1:17:40]
to come out of this, out of this project.
[1:17:43]
So would it be possible that I could talk to the,
[1:17:46]
the private companies that are supporting this project
[1:17:49]
and see if I could get support among them for something
[1:17:51]
that's a little bit more robust?
[1:17:55]
I I, I really think you need to hit it as hard as you can.
[1:17:58]
People are coming back from vacation.
[1:18:00]
I mean, they're gonna focus on, on the next 60 days.
[1:18:02]
And it may have start,
[1:18:04]
it may have should have started earlier,
[1:18:05]
but you've got 16 days.
[1:18:06]
It's not over yet. And so if you can really bear down
[1:18:09]
and I'm more than happy to help if you can point me in the
[1:18:12]
right direction for people to talk to.
[1:18:13]
I know I'm not alone. So
[1:18:15]
that's why I'm here to, to ask the board.
[1:18:20]
Mr. Coleman, you have a question.
[1:18:24]
Well, thank you very much. I see Guy had his hand up
[1:18:27]
as well, but I'll, I'll take this.
[1:18:29]
I did attend the marketing meeting with Jody and others.
[1:18:32]
Michelle was there. And so I just wanted to reinforce some
[1:18:36]
of her concerns about this marketing firm.
[1:18:39]
And I know this is public
[1:18:41]
and I'm gonna be as gentle as I can,
[1:18:43]
but I don't feel like there was an urgency on the,
[1:18:48]
from the people at the marketing firm
[1:18:50]
because as this gentleman from WDEV,
[1:18:54]
I'm sorry I didn't get your name.
[1:18:56]
I just pointed out we don't have that much time.
[1:18:58]
There's a lot of urgency
[1:19:00]
and I felt like they hadn't really even done their homework.
[1:19:04]
Of course they hadn't mentioned the world,
[1:19:06]
they hadn't mentioned some
[1:19:07]
of our local papers like the bridge, any of these sources.
[1:19:12]
I know they reached out to DEV
[1:19:13]
and they didn't feel like they got a warm reception.
[1:19:16]
But again, the creativity
[1:19:21]
that they were putting forth, as Jody pointed out,
[1:19:24]
was also very limited.
[1:19:25]
It was based on what they've done in the past.
[1:19:28]
Not much real thought, I think was put into the,
[1:19:32]
the taglines they came up with and the, the media messages
[1:19:37]
and they kept going back to the survey that they created
[1:19:41]
and presented to us.
[1:19:42]
Well I think that survey was very simplistic.
[1:19:47]
They've probably used versions of it in the past
[1:19:50]
and the sample size was very limited.
[1:19:52]
So I had some great
[1:19:56]
about this firm.
[1:19:58]
And so moving forward, I think if we do wanna continue
[1:20:01]
with it, we need to give them very specific direction.
[1:20:05]
And I think Jody mentioned many things.
[1:20:08]
This board has brainstormed some great tactics
[1:20:12]
already tonight.
[1:20:13]
And I think those specific directions need to be
[1:20:18]
given to the, to the directors there.
[1:20:21]
I also wanna reiterate the, what
[1:20:25]
I mentioned about mailers.
[1:20:29]
I reached out to my good friend, my former student
[1:20:32]
who was the director of tourism
[1:20:33]
and marketing for the state of Vermont
[1:20:35]
through three governors.
[1:20:36]
Steve Cook, he just got back to me.
[1:20:39]
Three of his children have gone through the career centers.
[1:20:42]
He's a big support of that.
[1:20:45]
And he said
[1:20:46]
that he thinks mailers are a really important tool.
[1:20:50]
I do too because I think they get to people's mailboxes.
[1:20:54]
People like to get mail, they keep it on their tables.
[1:20:56]
They might read it several times. They'll think about it.
[1:20:59]
You put a URL on there
[1:21:01]
and maybe not just one mailer, but maybe several.
[1:21:04]
I know it's expensive,
[1:21:06]
but we need to be in front of the public consistently.
[1:21:11]
I think the gentleman from DEV made a very important point.
[1:21:14]
And I was thinking about this when
[1:21:19]
the gentleman was talking about Mr. Malone was talking,
[1:21:24]
we need to invest in the future here in Vermont,
[1:21:26]
we're very stagnant.
[1:21:28]
People know that we're at a crossroads.
[1:21:31]
We know young people aren't staying.
[1:21:33]
Perhaps if we invest in our future,
[1:21:35]
like this beautiful center, it will attract more families
[1:21:40]
to come here and help our tax base.
[1:21:43]
So we can't stay still. We have to move forward with this.
[1:21:47]
And we have to look at it as very
[1:21:50]
positive about the polling.
[1:21:53]
Just just a comment about polling.
[1:21:55]
I don't know a lot about it, but I know
[1:21:56]
that it's small sample sizes
[1:21:59]
and you can't predict the outcome.
[1:22:00]
Typically with a poll we'll know who's against it,
[1:22:05]
but we have to assume that people could be sprayed.
[1:22:09]
And so with our, a good marketing campaign
[1:22:12]
and effective tactics, not efficient,
[1:22:15]
like maybe social media is efficient,
[1:22:18]
but it's not always effective
[1:22:19]
because as people have pointed out, it's difficult to reach
[1:22:25]
who live in rural areas through social media.
[1:22:28]
Sure, some of them may use Facebook marketplace
[1:22:30]
to buy their backhoes or their tractors or whatever,
[1:22:33]
but are they really gonna see something about
[1:22:37]
the career center on Facebook?
[1:22:39]
I don't, I don't know. I don't think so.
[1:22:41]
Maybe just because I'm old fashioned.
[1:22:44]
So I guess my message is,
[1:22:46]
I was concerned about this marketing team
[1:22:49]
presentations we've seen from them.
[1:22:51]
I think we need to empower Jody to be very forward with
[1:22:55]
that team and make some specific
[1:23:04]
ourselves lawn signs.
[1:23:07]
I don't know how effective they're gonna be,
[1:23:09]
but we could go to a printer and have lawn signs made.
[1:23:13]
So I just wanna throw all that out.
[1:23:14]
And that's just my, my take on this at this point.
[1:23:19]
I'm happy to answer any questions if anybody has any
[1:23:26]
Guy, do you need to add to anything?
[1:23:33]
The news guy? I just wanna say,
[1:23:35]
I just wanna say have me a hello.
[1:23:40]
I would just, I would just add
[1:23:41]
that there's no comment section for people
[1:23:44]
to argue with on a mailer.
[1:23:54]
Alright, so we're looking at
[1:23:59]
drawing up specific actions for this marketing team
[1:24:04]
and who will be responsible for delivering
[1:24:09]
that message to the, our marketing team.
[1:24:14]
Correct? Yes.
[1:24:17]
So let's start with
[1:24:21]
talking about some specific actions first.
[1:24:27]
Anyone have some? So it, it appears that we seem
[1:24:31]
to be in
[1:24:35]
acceptance of the fact that we need to have a mailer.
[1:24:41]
Anyone have any? Okay.
[1:24:42]
So we'll make sure that they, we know
[1:24:45]
that that a mailer
[1:24:48]
One point that was brought up by Mr. Malone, which,
[1:24:52]
you know, of course I don't want to,
[1:24:55]
I don't want be in a position where I'm trying
[1:24:57]
to rebut against people who are offering their opinion
[1:24:59]
and public testimony.
[1:25:00]
But I would offer that this comes up on every single job.
[1:25:04]
There's always at least one person that says,
[1:25:06]
but all the people on fixed income, they can't afford it.
[1:25:08]
And this is one reason to perhaps drill down a little bit on
[1:25:12]
the income sensitivity question.
[1:25:14]
Because people
[1:25:15]
who have on a fixed income are generally on the low end
[1:25:19]
of the income spectrum.
[1:25:21]
And they generally have a lot of relief from these kinds
[1:25:25]
of tax increases
[1:25:26]
because of tax income sensitivity in Vermont.
[1:25:29]
So it's one of these things that's kind of like,
[1:25:31]
I don't know, I don't necessarily know how to answer
[1:25:33]
that question because I can't give strict facts and figures
[1:25:36]
and I don't want to be accused of being wrong
[1:25:38]
or having rose colored glasses.
[1:25:40]
But I know in other projects they have calculated that
[1:25:44]
and that threshold is actually fairly high.
[1:25:46]
It's well above what most people are getting
[1:25:48]
for likes social security
[1:25:49]
and even if they have decent pension.
[1:25:52]
So that's, and I don't know if that's something
[1:25:54]
that can be explored in the future
[1:25:55]
or if that's just a talking point that you give,
[1:25:58]
that you have with people who have that concern.
[1:26:01]
Because without saying, oh hey, you know, if you're,
[1:26:04]
you make less than this, your tax impact is
[1:26:07]
zero Short of that.
[1:26:08]
I think you just have to sort of make them feel comfortable
[1:26:10]
that the tax impact will be mitigated
[1:26:12]
by income sensitivity for low income people.
[1:26:18]
And then how, just as a question, a follow up question.
[1:26:22]
The business people though, they certainly are going
[1:26:26]
to have some kind of a concern about this.
[1:26:33]
We would need to say something to them as well.
[1:26:36]
I landlords and,
[1:26:38]
and what, when you start talking about individuals
[1:26:41]
who are landlords, that that affects the tenants
[1:26:45]
because the rent goes up.
[1:26:48]
So that's all.
[1:26:50]
And I say this from the, the perspective
[1:26:52]
of having been on the berry board for so many years
[1:26:55]
that I have seen the ease
[1:26:57]
with which some budgets were pla passed
[1:27:00]
and the stress with, with others.
[1:27:04]
So, and, and those were our
[1:27:08]
biggest challenges was making it clear to tenants
[1:27:12]
and landlords and business people that commercial operators.
[1:27:16]
I just realized it's probably not clear why I brought
[1:27:18]
that up, but it was, I was thinking ahead about maybe it's
[1:27:21]
not even, maybe it's not just one mailer,
[1:27:23]
especially if you're thinking that a mailer is the best way
[1:27:26]
to reach people who, again, I don't know if,
[1:27:29]
if the stereotype of, you know, people
[1:27:31]
who are older aren't on social media, I find that a lot
[1:27:34]
of them are, but do, do you want
[1:27:39]
to craft mailers for specific people
[1:27:41]
or with specific information?
[1:27:42]
'cause the mailers also have to be very concise
[1:27:46]
or else they won't be reviewed.
[1:27:49]
So that's, you have to be good to be pick picky and choosey.
[1:27:53]
And of course we can help counsel on
[1:27:57]
what we've seen in other districts that has helped
[1:28:03]
It is the big cost of the mailer.
[1:28:06]
The postage or the printing.
[1:28:09]
The printing and post the printing.
[1:28:10]
And yes, for the large mailer there's a significant
[1:28:14]
reduction in postage.
[1:28:22]
Can we afford it? Double that?
[1:28:28]
Can we afford two? Can we afford two mailings,
[1:28:35]
Jenna?
[1:28:36]
It depends on how we're spending the rest of our money.
[1:28:38]
So if we may be asking them to shift
[1:28:42]
how we're, what we're funding. So,
[1:28:44]
Okay, so like we can do it in the middle and then just
[1:28:47]
before the bond vote.
[1:28:49]
Well, no, but you can't do it just before
[1:28:52]
because it won't actually get to people until after.
[1:28:55]
No, I mean before. Before. Just before.
[1:28:59]
Yep. And also I think lawn signs,
[1:29:03]
I don't think we should poo PPO lawn signs.
[1:29:05]
Do we have the capacity to print?
[1:29:10]
Yes. So we, so that doesn't cost us anything.
[1:29:18]
It doesn't cost as much as if someone else does it.
[1:29:21]
Right. I think we should print long signs too.
[1:29:25]
Okay. Patrick,
[1:29:28]
I'm concerned that we're, we're second
[1:29:30]
guessing our contractor.
[1:29:31]
Yeah. And if we're, if we're, if we're,
[1:29:34]
if we think we know better,
[1:29:36]
if we don't think they're doing a
[1:29:37]
good job, we get a new one.
[1:29:40]
Do we have time to do that? We have other bids
[1:29:43]
that we looked over.
[1:29:45]
Do we have time to switch?
[1:29:47]
I would not suggest switching.
[1:29:49]
If we choose to terminate this contract, we would continue
[1:29:53]
with what we think that we should have done it.
[1:30:00]
What they're offering right now is no different
[1:30:01]
than what we will have done.
[1:30:02]
What we were hoping for was some out of the box awesome idea
[1:30:06]
that we're like, oh duh, we never thought of that before.
[1:30:09]
We've thought about Facebook ads, we've thought about print,
[1:30:12]
we've been thinking about these, the mailers.
[1:30:14]
We've done this in the past, we know how to do it.
[1:30:17]
We were hoping for something above and beyond
[1:30:19]
and something that just hit every nail in the head.
[1:30:23]
Not that we do not have time to move on with a new company.
[1:30:28]
Okay. We could transition some
[1:30:30]
of those funds into polling if we felt
[1:30:33]
that was the right thing for more mailers.
[1:30:38]
And so transitioning, so sorry guys, just one second.
[1:30:42]
So ing a polling would tell us where
[1:30:46]
to focus more resources.
[1:30:49]
So we do polling in September,
[1:30:52]
then we get an answer in October,
[1:30:55]
you could get in two weeks.
[1:30:57]
Okay. So we waited answer in September, a sample size of 300
[1:31:01]
or the 18 towns would be likely voters would be by phone
[1:31:05]
and you could probably te probably tease out 20 questions
[1:31:08]
so you could understand what the objections are.
[1:31:10]
And it's more interactive
[1:31:12]
because you don't know the level of of objection.
[1:31:15]
Right. You'll be able to identify
[1:31:18]
and segment certain objections by size.
[1:31:21]
Okay. Right. Which you aren't gonna get in these kind
[1:31:24]
of one way communications.
[1:31:25]
Right. The digital is one way you might get some comments,
[1:31:28]
but people don't necessarily participate.
[1:31:31]
A lot of people don't like their opinion to be known
[1:31:33]
to, to their neighbors.
[1:31:35]
Right. And with a mailer, you don't see it.
[1:31:36]
Mailers are cheap either.
[1:31:38]
I mean, a mailer could be 10 grand. Yeah. Right.
[1:31:40]
Two mailers is $20,000. Right? Yeah.
[1:31:44]
I'm just trying to work the timeline. So if we, we do,
[1:31:46]
if we do the polling in September, we know in two weeks
[1:31:49]
and then we know where to put the mailers
[1:31:51]
and the other other resources.
[1:31:52]
You know what to say. Yeah.
[1:31:54]
Yeah. That that's the we're not,
[1:31:56]
What I'm saying is you know what to say
[1:31:58]
Than too much fully will get that feedback. Yeah.
[1:32:01]
You know, which points to specifically articulate Right.
[1:32:05]
Or which ones to highlight.
[1:32:07]
I mean, you may find a very
[1:32:08]
favorable block in some of these times.
[1:32:10]
You may want to accentuate that,
[1:32:11]
try to pull those people out.
[1:32:12]
Right. But you know, those people can swamp that nose.
[1:32:18]
Do we have the capacity in house to do that?
[1:32:24]
We have some folks who are interested
[1:32:26]
and we may be able to pay them a stipend for above
[1:32:29]
and beyond their contract to support the work
[1:32:35]
pay for my here to not be gray.
[1:32:40]
That's, I'm sorry.
[1:32:43]
Yeah. I mean, against time.
[1:32:45]
Michelle, I, I'm a scientist, right? I like, I like data.
[1:32:50]
My concern is, is we get that information
[1:32:55]
and then the value is what we do with it.
[1:32:58]
And do we have the capacity
[1:32:59]
to actually act on the information, right?
[1:33:02]
Yes. Polls are not precise,
[1:33:05]
but they do give you information that you can then
[1:33:08]
base your actions on.
[1:33:09]
And so that's the piece that,
[1:33:10]
and I forgot we asked the question about do
[1:33:12]
we have the capacity?
[1:33:13]
And so yeah. That, that, that is my concern.
[1:33:16]
And I, and I recognize that like time is
[1:33:18]
of the essence, right?
[1:33:20]
And so yeah, I I'm, I'm more in favor
[1:33:24]
of being very clear with the,
[1:33:29]
the contractor, like, these are the expectations,
[1:33:33]
this is what we want.
[1:33:35]
And, and not,
[1:33:38]
not just they're, they're experts, right?
[1:33:40]
Like we chose them because of their expertise
[1:33:44]
and now we're second guessing they're,
[1:33:45]
I'm not a media expert, right?
[1:33:47]
Like, right. And so I I I wanna sort of hold back that,
[1:33:53]
that, that feeling to second guess the experts who we chose
[1:33:57]
to, to help us.
[1:33:59]
Yeah. And to recognize that urgency is,
[1:34:01]
is probably playing a pretty big role
[1:34:03]
in that second guessing.
[1:34:05]
And I, I don't wanna dismiss the, the Mr.
[1:34:10]
Mur, my, my bad.
[1:34:13]
The the request that that you made.
[1:34:15]
And I just don't know, like where, I don't know
[1:34:20]
where the line is for like, us to be able to like,
[1:34:23]
make connections versus, like those connections happen
[1:34:27]
amongst the community.
[1:34:28]
I'm, I'm not a legal expert, so
[1:34:30]
I think I can reach out to advisory board members and,
[1:34:33]
and let them know of this interest
[1:34:35]
and give them your contact information so it goes that way
[1:34:39]
that they can reach out and take that step.
[1:34:41]
I think that that is a great idea.
[1:34:44]
I love that it, if that the community is is,
[1:34:47]
or there are folks within the community
[1:34:49]
that would be willing to support this.
[1:34:53]
Yeah. I think there are, when you think about the jobs
[1:34:55]
that we're gonna be creating for the next three years
[1:34:57]
and, you know, the construction companies
[1:35:00]
and just the landscape, like there's
[1:35:02]
so many big projects going be going on here
[1:35:05]
that it's going to be worth it.
[1:35:08]
And, and I've asked this question of you, Jody,
[1:35:10]
in the past, and I'll shut up after this,
[1:35:11]
but like, where's the state?
[1:35:12]
Right? Like we've heard from the state government,
[1:35:16]
we've heard from the federal government, like the importance
[1:35:18]
of CTE, right?
[1:35:19]
And so yeah, I,
[1:35:22]
Again, we did have a member of the Agency
[1:35:24]
of Education on for a little bit here.
[1:35:26]
I think she's also a very resident, so
[1:35:31]
that might be one, but they're not here anymore.
[1:35:36]
And getting the support
[1:35:37]
of the business community is powerful.
[1:35:39]
Yes. Whether it's through funding a poll,
[1:35:42]
but just their visual, you know, being interviewed,
[1:35:46]
being in the videos, whatever you can do to get them
[1:35:49]
to come out and support the project is really good.
[1:35:54]
I, a couple of thoughts, having been doing this
[1:35:57]
for a long time, I I I,
[1:36:03]
I'm not sure what a poll will tell you.
[1:36:05]
You know, what the complaint's gonna be. It's expensive.
[1:36:10]
Right? Right. I, I don't, everybody is for CTE.
[1:36:15]
It's an overwhelmingly positive addition in the community.
[1:36:20]
And the only downside to the project
[1:36:22]
that people will probably say is, wow, it's,
[1:36:25]
it's really expensive and my taxes are high.
[1:36:27]
So I, I guess, and, and then,
[1:36:31]
and then maybe a more sophisticated polling would yield more
[1:36:35]
nuanced responses so you could craft the message.
[1:36:38]
But I, given the timeline
[1:36:44]
and the urgency of getting media out there, i, I
[1:36:49]
personally question whether the poll is
[1:36:54]
a worthwhile thing
[1:36:55]
because that delays everything
[1:36:56]
for even more time. Anyway, that's just,
[1:37:01]
I think we could maybe move forward with both.
[1:37:02]
Maybe it's an and. Yeah. Yeah.
[1:37:04]
I, I agree with David.
[1:37:08]
If we had a lot of time polling would probably be
[1:37:11]
worthwhile, but since early voting starts
[1:37:15]
probably the third week of October,
[1:37:17]
and we need to get those people that are, that vote early
[1:37:20]
and then head out of town for Florida or wherever they go.
[1:37:24]
We, we really don't have time.
[1:37:26]
And I know data's great to, to gather,
[1:37:30]
but we also know that thousands
[1:37:33]
and thousands of people vote in favor of the budget
[1:37:37]
for this career center.
[1:37:39]
Every, every time there's a, there's a vote
[1:37:41]
for a budget vote.
[1:37:43]
And we went through those numbers last time
[1:37:45]
and it was overwhelmingly like 75%
[1:37:48]
of the voters were in favor.
[1:37:51]
So we know, like David says, there's a lot
[1:37:53]
of positivity around it.
[1:37:55]
It it's just about our messaging, the urgency of
[1:37:59]
getting consistent messages out there as soon as possible
[1:38:03]
and then right up to November 4th.
[1:38:07]
So I think we've got multiple tactics
[1:38:10]
to get messages out there and we have to begin using those.
[1:38:14]
And so if Jody puts together a list, some
[1:38:17]
of the things we've spoken about, some of the things me, she
[1:38:20]
and Michelle have talked about
[1:38:21]
and present that to the marketing team,
[1:38:24]
hopefully they'll say, yeah, we're ready to do that.
[1:38:26]
If they don't, then I feel like we have the resources in
[1:38:30]
house to do much of what they would be doing anyway.
[1:38:34]
What we're doing is buying time
[1:38:35]
because none of us have time to do this.
[1:38:38]
And certainly the administrators at the school
[1:38:41]
do not have a lot of time.
[1:38:42]
But if we have to, we can make that time.
[1:38:45]
So we use our 40,000 plus
[1:38:48]
dollars wise.
[1:38:55]
I think, I think what we've begun
[1:38:56]
to sketch out just from the discussion is
[1:38:59]
what the deliverables are that we're looking for from the
[1:39:04]
marketing team that we're hiring.
[1:39:08]
The question of the mailer, is that one, or is it two?
[1:39:13]
Is it one that's dedicated to citizens
[1:39:15]
and another that's dedicated to businesses?
[1:39:18]
How does that, how do we wanna break that out if we need to,
[1:39:23]
making sure that we have enough information, whether
[1:39:28]
that is through polling or advertising
[1:39:31]
and getting the businesses on board
[1:39:35]
for their support, not only financially,
[1:39:37]
but also verbally,
[1:39:42]
outspokenly what I, to have that kind of
[1:39:46]
presence from the business community saying that we are
[1:39:49]
behind this endeavor
[1:39:50]
because of what it'll bring not only for us as a business,
[1:39:54]
but also for the community and, and the, the students.
[1:39:59]
Anything else that needs to be added to that?
[1:40:01]
I like that Alice,
[1:40:05]
I agree with op-eds are free, right?
[1:40:10]
And we're talking about the value of the, of the support
[1:40:12]
of the business community.
[1:40:13]
And so if there is a coordinated like effort
[1:40:16]
of our supporters to be outspoken in
[1:40:21]
that was redundant in support of the,
[1:40:25]
we're not the ones saying go out and vote.
[1:40:27]
Yes. We're, we're getting,
[1:40:29]
we're getting people to go out and vote.
[1:40:31]
That's what we're doing, right?
[1:40:33]
Folks in the community can speak in
[1:40:35]
favor or against the vote.
[1:40:37]
And so, you know, I, I do think that those types of
[1:40:42]
efforts in Montpelier, we, we have like op-ed,
[1:40:47]
like a schedule when we come up to a, a board budget vote
[1:40:52]
of like who's writing op-eds when.
[1:40:54]
And so I think, you know,
[1:40:56]
something along those lines might, might also be helpful.
[1:41:00]
Ms. Palmer? Hi there, my name is Danielle Palmer
[1:41:05]
and I am a 1998 graduate of Spalding High School.
[1:41:10]
I participated in the career center
[1:41:12]
and I think just inviting everyone to think outside the box
[1:41:17]
in respect to telling people's stories.
[1:41:21]
So for example, maybe soliciting someone like myself
[1:41:25]
to share about how the career center benefited me
[1:41:29]
and my career path and
[1:41:31]
or seeing if there's multi-generational, I have a child
[1:41:34]
that's going to partake in the exploratory program, so nice.
[1:41:38]
Just looking outside the box sort stories sell.
[1:41:43]
So if you are aware
[1:41:45]
of people even you can approach it from the angle
[1:41:47]
of business owners, the benefit of of students,
[1:41:51]
and then eventually them becoming higher
[1:41:53]
and the benefits to that.
[1:41:55]
So you can really just really invite anybody think
[1:41:57]
outside the box and I'm happy to participate
[1:42:01]
or help generate more ideas.
[1:42:05]
Thank you for that, Danielle.
[1:42:08]
That that's something that the marketing firm did not
[1:42:12]
address and we had recommended that many times
[1:42:14]
and I think we forgot to mention that that's a,
[1:42:18]
they dropped the ball on that.
[1:42:19]
And so yes, we need to have those testimonials,
[1:42:22]
those representatives and should have been started already.
[1:42:26]
But the marketing firms still
[1:42:29]
putting together their proposal.
[1:42:32]
Well, they did ask for some stakeholder information
[1:42:34]
and I have provided them with some,
[1:42:36]
and I keep adding to that.
[1:42:37]
And I think that is where they, Todd,
[1:42:40]
when they had those social media posts
[1:42:43]
where they had pictures of,
[1:42:45]
they weren't our students in those pictures
[1:42:47]
for the examples, but that they, the intent was
[1:42:50]
to use alumni and other business partnerships and parents
[1:42:55]
and to be able to post really quickly short stories.
[1:43:00]
But I, the value of a story is really important.
[1:43:03]
And I think we, we also heard that from our co consultants
[1:43:05]
for the comprehensive of local needs assessment.
[1:43:08]
And, and that's something we're trying
[1:43:09]
to gather some of those.
[1:43:11]
So I really appreciate you saying that Danielle
[1:43:13]
and I will be adding you to the list.
[1:43:15]
So I'm glad you're up for that. And yes,
[1:43:18]
You're Welcome.
[1:43:20]
Yes. The parents can tell the story better than the,
[1:43:23]
than actually the student can
[1:43:25]
because the, the parent is watching the growth
[1:43:28]
of their child through the educational system.
[1:43:33]
Teachers. Yep.
[1:43:36]
Sorry, I'm behind you. That's
[1:43:37]
Okay.
[1:43:39]
One thing that these small papers,
[1:43:42]
people mentioning the world in roundabout the
[1:43:44]
Bread, They are desperate for content.
[1:43:48]
And if you, you can literally write the article,
[1:43:52]
give 'em the photo, and they'll clean it up and,
[1:43:55]
and you know, and post it.
[1:44:00]
We've, so anyway, I think that's an easier way
[1:44:04]
to get content out if you write like press release
[1:44:07]
or more like a more info article about maybe with,
[1:44:12]
with some of these testimonials from students to parents
[1:44:17]
and, and then, you know, talk
[1:44:21]
to the different small newspapers
[1:44:23]
and a lot of them are connected, so it's the same publisher.
[1:44:26]
We'll do three different towns or three different regions.
[1:44:29]
And so you, you can propagate an article that way.
[1:44:37]
Circling back to your question about deliverables. Yes.
[1:44:39]
I think the most important deliverable, the one
[1:44:41]
that I was most troubled by was urgency.
[1:44:46]
And I think that's come up a couple of times,
[1:44:47]
but I just wanted to, to say that to me that's the most
[1:44:51]
important thing I think that we need to see out
[1:44:55]
of them moving forward is a real sense of urgency.
[1:44:59]
And that probably comes down to giving them a, a set time
[1:45:03]
by this time really to have this.
[1:45:05]
And that's, I'm not trying to
[1:45:07]
Your business, but Michelle just did the countdown.
[1:45:09]
It's 51 days till the first person
[1:45:11]
could vote for that early.
[1:45:13]
Yeah, exactly. It's, I think urgency is the
[1:45:15]
most critical thing.
[1:45:16]
And I would, I would offer that in addition to
[1:45:19]
that was left feeling that it was, that the,
[1:45:22]
maybe the content wasn't this way,
[1:45:25]
but the presentation itself felt a little slick.
[1:45:29]
You know, like I was looking
[1:45:30]
for a little bit more authenticity
[1:45:33]
or a little bit more like it was of this place
[1:45:37]
and not, I guess I, it's,
[1:45:39]
it felt like a marketing presentation from a marketing firm.
[1:45:43]
And maybe that's to be expected.
[1:45:47]
Maybe that may be a nothing burger comment, but
[1:45:49]
Well, like to your point, when you,
[1:45:51]
you helped prepare the slide for tonight,
[1:45:53]
but it still looked like us.
[1:45:54]
It was our colors. Even though you all,
[1:45:57]
we all kind of did it together.
[1:45:58]
Like when you're preparing something for us,
[1:46:01]
whether it's internal
[1:46:02]
or to be shared, it should still look like us.
[1:46:06]
So for the, if I can build on the urgency point,
[1:46:09]
the September 7th, they have their first, their first
[1:46:12]
item on their timeline is the times, August print a
[1:46:16]
and so maybe asking to see that week beforehand
[1:46:20]
or something could be a double check on,
[1:46:26]
on, on, on the urgency.
[1:46:28]
Yep. It could have been the way they
[1:46:29]
rolled out the presentation too.
[1:46:31]
So they were kind of taking their time.
[1:46:32]
They had a plan and I could feel everybody in the room
[1:46:35]
and kind of chomping feeling get to it, get to the point so
[1:46:39]
that could play into it.
[1:46:43]
Yeah, I mean to your, to your point just there, right?
[1:46:46]
So they want approval of the strategy by the 30th, which is
[1:46:50]
a week before the first.
[1:46:52]
So it's like, all right, well where's your,
[1:46:53]
what's your ad look like?
[1:46:55]
You know, because that's a, that's a week and a day. Yeah,
[1:47:00]
Yeah.
[1:47:01]
And you don't send it on the day it's gonna be in the
[1:47:02]
Print. Exactly.
[1:47:04]
So do we have a, a list that we need
[1:47:08]
to present to them or how are we, I'm marking on one.
[1:47:12]
Okay. I also been Oh, thank you. Writing down as well.
[1:47:17]
Okay. You read it out and add Yeah.
[1:47:22]
Thank you. Knowing that at
[1:47:26]
the overarching premise of all of this is the urgency.
[1:47:29]
Yeah. That we don't have a lot of time. Okay.
[1:47:33]
Is every is everyone on board with that,
[1:47:35]
Patrick? Any suggestions?
[1:47:37]
Yes, just one more thing and then separately, we'll,
[1:47:38]
we'll provide, we'll we'll pull, we'll talk to the stake
[1:47:41]
to our, I'm sorry, advisory councils that you said to,
[1:47:44]
to give them Yes.
[1:47:46]
Miles. Great.
[1:47:51]
Any other questions or concerns? Mr. Todd?
[1:47:56]
Guy Jana? Anything? Corey? Corey.
[1:48:04]
Okay guy. I'm good. You're flashing us guy.
[1:48:11]
I'm
[1:48:13]
Not literally Okay.
[1:48:18]
Your, your, your,
[1:48:21]
Honestly I've got my, I've got my sign on.
[1:48:24]
It's covering everything. Okay.
[1:48:31]
Sandwich board again. Yeah, there
[1:48:35]
that guy is
[1:48:36]
Ready to go.
[1:48:37]
He knows urgent sign.
[1:48:40]
We haven't talked about the guy sandwich board.
[1:48:44]
We need to add that in. Add.
[1:48:46]
Alright, so we need to
[1:48:49]
One thing, Alice?
[1:48:50]
Yes. Yes.
[1:48:52]
Okay. Just one thing, Jody, I'm wondering when you come
[1:48:55]
to our schools to talk,
[1:48:59]
what can we be doing to bring people out
[1:49:04]
other than the postings that we did?
[1:49:07]
And could you give me
[1:49:10]
alarm signs when you come so I can give, distribute them
[1:49:17]
My, I will.
[1:49:19]
That sets a very firm date
[1:49:21]
for when we need those lawn signs, so yes.
[1:49:24]
Okay, great. Thank you.
[1:49:28]
I i it it appears that our next situation is
[1:49:32]
that we need a motion to
[1:49:38]
empower the administration to go ahead
[1:49:40]
with this conversation with the marketing team
[1:49:43]
and bring to them our discussion of urgency,
[1:49:48]
activities and deliverables.
[1:49:51]
So moved exactly as you said it.
[1:49:55]
Exactly. Alright. Any further discussion?
[1:50:02]
I would just like to amend that to say the administration
[1:50:05]
or their designees, so we have
[1:50:10]
that as, as clear.
[1:50:11]
Is that acceptable? Okay. To do that.
[1:50:14]
All those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.
[1:50:20]
Aye. Very good. Any any dissension?
[1:50:24]
Any abstentions? Hearing none. Motion carries. Thank you.
[1:50:30]
We have one item that was not on our agenda. Okay.
[1:50:34]
Our lovely clerk.
[1:50:36]
Oh, I was gonna say too, so I decided
[1:50:39]
to step down from taking board minutes.
[1:50:42]
It was a really difficult decision for me
[1:50:46]
as I've been doing this this year forever.
[1:50:49]
I know I three years, three years for the district
[1:50:53]
and then three years for governance and then events as well.
[1:50:57]
And I wanna focus on my curriculum this year
[1:51:00]
and continuing my education doesn't mean I'm not gonna stop
[1:51:04]
and for board meetings, but this was a really difficult
[1:51:06]
decision as I've learned so much.
[1:51:12]
Oh my God.
[1:51:20]
We do not accept your resignation. Oh my gosh. Yeah.
[1:51:23]
Write that down. Could we put something,
[1:51:26]
something on the record?
[1:51:28]
Yes. That expresses our appreciation. Yes.
[1:51:30]
We, we are, I think, I think everyone, every, each
[1:51:33]
of us really appreciates the work
[1:51:36]
and has appreciated the work that you do as well
[1:51:39]
as the contributions that you have made to our meetings.
[1:51:42]
Because without that, that's a kind of an inside view
[1:51:46]
that you have that we don't always have
[1:51:48]
as board members, you know?
[1:51:49]
And, and I've thought a lot about it
[1:51:51]
and, you know, I definitely may hop on
[1:51:54]
to board meetings for that.
[1:51:56]
'cause I do, you know, this is my 11th year at CBCC
[1:52:00]
and I really strongly believe in what tech ed does.
[1:52:04]
And, you know, I've seen my brother benefit
[1:52:06]
from going to a tech center.
[1:52:08]
I did not get the chance to go to a tech center.
[1:52:12]
But seeing our students success and,
[1:52:14]
and just seeing what this does for our community,
[1:52:17]
I'm very invested in that work.
[1:52:19]
I really am. So I'll still hop on,
[1:52:22]
but it was a really difficult decision.
[1:52:24]
It really was. Motion of appreciation.
[1:52:28]
Thank you for our recording secretary who we will miss.
[1:52:33]
I thank you. Cry sunglasses.
[1:52:38]
I, I appreciate you. I miss you already.
[1:52:41]
Oh, I'll hop on. Don't worry. All right.
[1:52:47]
Do we need to vote or just accept the fact
[1:52:50]
that we will no longer have a vibrant personality
[1:52:55]
as part of our staff?
[1:52:57]
You guys are all vibrant. Don't worry.
[1:53:00]
Well, thank you very much from all of us.
[1:53:02]
We really do appreciate your work. You're welcome.
[1:53:04]
I really enjoyed it.
[1:53:06]
It was just so cool to see the, the back ends
[1:53:09]
and not many people get to see that.
[1:53:12]
And I wish they would. You know what I mean? I really do.
[1:53:15]
And also thank you for being here
[1:53:17]
and in person to tell us that
[1:53:20]
because it would've been horrible if
[1:53:22]
we had just gotten an email.
[1:53:25]
No, no, no. I didn't wanna do that.
[1:53:26]
We wouldn't have an opportunity to have to, to fret over it
[1:53:30]
and, and miss you. All right. I'm gonna,
[1:53:35]
I'm gonna make you a gone fishing sign
[1:53:40]
Guy.
[1:53:41]
I have so many fishing signs at my house.
[1:53:44]
Well, you're getting another one
[1:53:48]
That you can wear
[1:53:51]
sandwich in my classroom.
[1:53:57]
All right, so we're set with that.
[1:53:59]
Your long side God vision, lawn side.
[1:54:02]
It's officially God vision.
[1:54:05]
So I think it's
[1:54:10]
pretty clear what we have for ahead of us for our meetings.
[1:54:16]
As always, if there's anyone who believes
[1:54:18]
that there's anything that we can do
[1:54:20]
to improve our meetings, to go ahead.
[1:54:22]
I, I think always, I really find the discussion that goes on
[1:54:26]
among this board and the interplay
[1:54:31]
among the all, not only the members, but the public
[1:54:33]
and people who are here.
[1:54:35]
I think that really adds to our efficiency.
[1:54:40]
And it also is a testament to just how well we,
[1:54:43]
from different districts not seeing each other all the time
[1:54:48]
come together in support of the career center.
[1:54:51]
So anyone else?
[1:54:54]
Comments, conclusions, all as always.
[1:54:57]
We appreciate our administration for
[1:55:00]
what you do and how you do it.
[1:55:02]
So there's no question about that.
[1:55:06]
Any other questions or concerns to come before this board?
[1:55:09]
Then I need a motion to adjourn. I will adjourn.
[1:55:15]
Jana, you wanna second it? Second.
[1:55:20]
We are officially adjourned.
[1:55:22]
Thank you very much everyone, everyone at home
[1:55:25]
and in the, in the building.
[1:55:28]
Thank you Jan. Emojis in there.