City Council Meetings — Monday Agenda

San Diego, CA · · More San Diego, CA meetings · More California meetings

Transcript

Download: Text · SRT ·
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT

This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.

The times in this transcript were moved to match the video, using the meeting's own audio. The text is the source's captions, unchanged; the source times are kept in the "sourced" version.
[13:25] 888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888
[15:16] and
[16:24] and and I will answer.
[16:25] All right.
[16:25] Good morning.
[16:26] I will now call the City
[16:27] council meeting of Monday, JUNE
[16:29] 22nd 2026 to order that
[16:32] the clerk please call the Roll
[16:34] Council member Campbell your
[16:40] government Council member
[16:40] Whitburn here Council Member
[16:42] Foster Council Member Von
[16:46] Wilpert Council Member Council
[16:49] PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee here
[16:51] Council Member Can't be out
[16:53] here Council Member Moreno
[16:57] Council Member Julio Rivera and
[16:59] Council PRESIDENT LaCava
[17:01] present.
[17:02] Also attending the meeting are
[17:03] City Attorney Heather Ferber,
[17:05] independent budget analyst
[17:09] Jillian and Elina of Council
[17:10] Affairs advisor in the mayor's
[17:11] office.
[17:12] But as I learned myself here
[17:13] Deputy City Clerk Kevin Smith
[17:16] All right, thank you Deputy
[17:18] Clerk a quorum is now present.
[17:20] We will begin this morning with
[17:21] the invocation by Deputy Clerk
[17:23] Smith followed with an
[17:25] acknowledgment and the Pledge
[17:26] of Allegiance let by council
[17:27] member Campbell Brandt.
[17:33] Those who hold office in
[17:35] the city a spirit of wisdom,
[17:37] charity and justice that were
[17:38] steadfast purpose They MAY
[17:40] faithfully serve in their
[17:41] offices to promote
[17:42] the well-being of all people.
[17:48] We respectfully acknowledge
[17:50] that the communication or
[17:52] the original inhabitants of
[17:54] the Unceded land now known as
[17:57] San Diego Despite enduring
[17:59] the horrors of genocide and
[18:00] colonization, the community
[18:02] spirit remains unbroken.
[18:05] We honor the resilience of
[18:06] their ancestors who fought to
[18:08] protect their culture and land
[18:10] and today they carry their
[18:11] legacy forward ensuring that
[18:14] their traditions continue to
[18:16] thrive and gratitude and
[18:17] strength We stand with Cooma,
[18:20] our nation connected to our
[18:22] past and committed to a
[18:24] thriving future.
[18:26] We place the flag, place your
[18:28] hand over your heart and let's
[18:30] begin by going to the flag
[18:34] United States of America and to
[18:36] the Republic for which it
[18:37] stands one nation under GOD,
[18:40] indivisible with liberty and
[18:47] justice for all.
[18:48] >> All right With that Deputy
[18:49] clerk, please go over how
[18:50] the public can offer their
[18:51] testimony.
[18:53] >> Thank you, Council
[18:53] PRESIDENT.
[18:54] I will now now highlight
[18:55] the slide on the screen that
[18:57] reviews how the public can
[18:58] offer their public testimony
[18:59] during today's meeting.
[19:01] If you are in person please
[19:03] complete a speaker slip located
[19:05] at the entrance of chambers and
[19:06] bring it to the front of
[19:07] the room No further in-person
[19:09] testimony will be taken once
[19:11] the Council begins Virtual
[19:13] testimony for better meeting
[19:15] management purposes each
[19:16] speaker will have one minute
[19:17] per item per person.
[19:19] If you would like to speak on
[19:20] three or more items you will
[19:22] have a maximum of three
[19:23] minutes.
[19:26] All right.
[19:26] Thank you Deputy Clerk And as a
[19:27] reminder non agenda public
[19:29] comment which will be taken at
[19:30] the end of the session with
[19:31] the opportunity to speak freely
[19:32] on items within city
[19:34] jurisdiction items on
[19:35] the docket we encourage
[19:37] the public to offer their
[19:38] testimony to inform the Council
[19:40] members of their consideration
[19:42] or deliberations on that docket
[19:44] item.
[19:45] So with that Deputy Clerk
[19:47] please read the closed session
[19:48] items into the record.
[19:51] Conference with Legal Counsel
[19:53] Existing litigation pursuant to
[19:55] California Government Code
[19:56] Section 5495 6.91 c.
[20:00] S one Sandra Silva versus City
[20:01] of San Diego at all the to
[20:04] repeat versus city of San Diego
[20:05] c.
[20:09] S three Maria del Rosario Nunez
[20:10] Munoz versus City of San Diego
[20:10] c.
[20:13] S four Jesse Torres versus
[20:14] Civil Service Commission of
[20:16] the city of San Diego c.
[20:18] S five Denise Wadsworth at all
[20:20] versus City of San Diego at
[20:21] all.
[20:23] All right.
[20:24] >> With that please proceed
[20:25] with public comment.
[20:29] >> Thank you.
[20:30] We will begin with in-person
[20:31] public comment.
[20:34] Jacob Lewis Edwards please come
[20:36] forward.
[20:38] You are requested to speak on c
[20:40] us one c us two and see us
[20:42] three.
[20:42] >> You'll have three minutes to
[20:43] speak.
[20:49] Thank you members of our city
[20:50] council and allow me to speak
[20:52] in front of you.
[20:54] I've spoken from you about many
[20:56] things and these items include
[20:59] lawsuits to the city of reading
[21:01] slips and falls and such.
[21:05] i'm going to speak upon myself
[21:07] now.
[21:08] I usually speak upon for what
[21:09] is going on in a general sense.
[21:13] I spoke to you about how our
[21:14] cyber networks were hijacked
[21:16] going around eight years ago.
[21:19] My uncle his possession of
[21:20] the dhs over our country
[21:23] cybersecurity networks
[21:23] hijacked.
[21:24] I'm sorry to interrupt.
[21:25] Can you speak to the closed
[21:26] session items that you
[21:27] identified as opposed to a now?
[21:29] Yes, I am getting to that, sir.
[21:31] I'm getting to that And that
[21:33] handful of federal field agents
[21:35] assisted the mob in hijacking
[21:37] our federal government agencies
[21:41] flooding terrorized along
[21:41] the way by them pestered,
[21:42] tormented, harassed, harassed
[21:45] any trace of anything I've gone
[21:46] through wiped out and it
[21:50] continues to this day now is
[21:53] prevented that until I get into
[21:54] a shelter if I am able to get
[21:57] into a shelter and that is here
[21:59] in the city.
[22:00] It's set up there on customer
[22:02] tormented, harassed, terrorized
[22:05] people, given assignments
[22:06] within the shelter to hurt me.
[22:08] And it all comes from federal
[22:10] activity currently and
[22:13] prevented from getting into a
[22:14] shelter.
[22:15] I sleep at the front door here
[22:17] at the Civic Center to stay
[22:18] safe under a camera.
[22:21] But I go through even here I
[22:23] wouldn't sue the city of San
[22:25] Diego.
[22:25] I love this city but I I'd like
[22:26] to bring to your attention I
[22:29] mean I could file a lawsuit but
[22:32] I'm not but I'm going to bring
[22:33] it to your attention.
[22:34] Just two nights ago sleeping
[22:36] right here at the front door.
[22:38] Three guys nice designer jeans,
[22:41] nice shoes And it was overnight
[22:42] standing right over me loudly
[22:45] conversating being rude.
[22:47] It was very unruly over
[22:49] somebody trying to sleep.
[22:52] I mentioned that to them so
[22:54] please have some consideration.
[22:55] And I mentioned how federal
[22:56] field agents who terrorize me
[22:58] will set people up to do this.
[23:00] I'm not saying that's the case
[23:01] but it sure seems so.
[23:04] They got very angry at me.
[23:05] One of them pulls his belt off,
[23:08] stands over me and says
[23:09] Threaten to beat me in a very
[23:12] aggressive threatening manner.
[23:14] I said Now you're going to
[23:15] threaten to beat a homeless guy
[23:16] that you were standing over.
[23:19] I said Really?
[23:21] He got more abrasive cop bag
[23:23] that he So I walked off and
[23:24] called 911911 dispatchers will
[23:28] not take a report from any of
[23:30] the activity that I've gone
[23:32] through in the past It struck
[23:34] me from reporting anything
[23:37] The dispatcher wanted me to
[23:39] confirm my telephone number
[23:40] before he would dispatch
[23:42] anybody in an emergency call.
[23:45] >> That's not normal protocol
[23:47] in any city.
[23:48] Usually it's a dispatch
[23:49] immediately.
[23:51] That's what I got.
[23:51] Thank you for your comment that
[23:51] that concludes the witness who
[23:52] died.
[23:55] And for the record you did not
[23:56] speak to any of the closed
[23:57] session items so thank you.
[23:58] I'm a human being.
[24:02] That does conclude in-person
[24:03] public comment.
[24:04] I've started the five minute
[24:05] timer in council chambers.
[24:07] We will now turn to the virtual
[24:08] care in which there are
[24:09] currently three participants
[24:11] wishing to speak.
[24:14] We will first go to original
[24:14] draft.
[24:18] Could you please indicate which
[24:21] closed session item or items
[24:22] you wish to speak to me?
[24:26] I'm going to touch on all of
[24:28] them.
[24:28] Okay.
[24:29] You have three minutes.
[24:30] >> Please proceed.
[24:30] Okay.
[24:31] So with these continued trips
[24:33] and fall incidents I mean it's
[24:36] quite ridiculous how much money
[24:38] we wind up spending to in
[24:41] settlements when you know just
[24:44] these problems can be fixed and
[24:47] you know, knowing that someone
[24:49] has tripped and fall fell in
[24:51] these areas or had an incident
[24:54] there, you know, have you gone
[24:57] and mitigated that?
[24:58] Is that something that you
[25:00] know, was instantly put on
[25:02] the list of things to do to
[25:04] make sure that there won't be
[25:06] other incidents that arise?
[25:08] And I find it interesting as
[25:10] well that some of you say this
[25:12] case arises from a slip and
[25:14] fall.
[25:14] This case arises from a slip
[25:15] and fall and then it's like
[25:17] this matter arises from an
[25:19] alleged trip and fall on
[25:21] the sidewalk.
[25:22] So I mean what leads you to
[25:25] treat the case in that manner
[25:27] And then for you you know
[25:33] the case five in the Wadsworth
[25:34] case, you know this one also it
[25:36] says this case arises out of an
[25:38] alleged scooter incident But
[25:39] this is an actual death.
[25:41] Somebody died and due to
[25:45] dangerous condition.
[25:46] So I feel like when you guys
[25:48] want to, you know, go under
[25:50] the Brown Act and say that
[25:51] you're like providing just
[25:53] enough information for a
[25:55] summary I mean you're leaving
[25:57] out some pretty significant
[25:58] information and you know, for
[26:01] the people to know and you know
[26:04] to for someone to have died due
[26:07] to this incident you know, and
[26:09] you to to consider it alleged
[26:11] in the other ones you know are
[26:12] obviously true or whatever you
[26:16] know it just kind of discredits
[26:17] the person dying it feels like
[26:20] And then with this Jesse Taurus
[26:22] case and the Civil Service
[26:24] Commission, you know, this
[26:26] officer was engaged in
[26:29] misconduct off duty.
[26:31] And so, you know, officer
[26:32] should be held to a, you know,
[26:36] standard much like the people.
[26:38] And I find that the people are
[26:40] held to a higher standard than
[26:41] law enforcement and or any kind
[26:43] of public official.
[26:44] And you know, when the people
[26:46] engage in crimes, you know you
[26:48] want to hold them accountable.
[26:48] But then we have, you know,
[26:50] officers whether it's on duty
[26:52] or off duty and they're engaged
[26:55] in misconduct abuse, you know,
[27:00] abuse of power or different
[27:01] things like that.
[27:02] I mean.
[27:02] Andrea Ebbing you know, within
[27:04] Anthony Warner I mean he
[27:06] brutally assaulted her and
[27:07] she's sitting in jail right now
[27:09] and they made her do a
[27:10] competency evaluation and they
[27:13] have deemed her incompetent
[27:14] which is absolutely ridiculous
[27:16] which means that stalls of
[27:17] proceedings and all of this And
[27:19] so it's like you guys wind up
[27:22] criminal izing the people when
[27:23] they've been abused by law
[27:25] enforcement.
[27:26] So I mean this man needs to be
[27:29] held to a standard much like
[27:31] the people and even higher I
[27:33] would say thank you very
[27:35] comment.
[27:35] The caller did speak to all
[27:37] the closed session items So
[27:38] thank you very much.
[27:41] Our next virtual commenter is
[27:44] with the caller with the last
[27:46] four digits 8700 please tell us
[27:50] which items you wish to speak
[27:51] to and begin your comments.
[28:01] Excuse me.
[28:02] Thank you.
[28:03] Deputy Clerk Joy is Senator and
[28:08] I would speak on all of them.
[28:09] Okay.
[28:10] Please proceed.
[28:12] And number one which is a trip
[28:14] and fall accident again I'm
[28:18] going to speak to the public
[28:20] deer public I really encourage
[28:22] you to claim your own self
[28:25] safety and be your own advocate
[28:28] when you're out walking as I
[28:30] try to do because it's
[28:32] dangerous out there on
[28:34] the sidewalks and we need to
[28:36] watch out for ourselves.
[28:37] So please consider that I'm
[28:41] number two which is a slip and
[28:45] fall incident and well I'll say
[28:48] on that is incident versus an
[28:50] accident doesn't seem as solid
[28:53] a case for the plaintiff here.
[28:55] I am not sure on that.
[28:57] So on number three alleged trip
[29:00] and fall on sidewalk so with
[29:03] alleged I'm not clear again yet
[29:07] what I'm not clear is what
[29:10] happened and it doesn't seem
[29:11] like you are either in what's
[29:13] being presented and that
[29:14] the evidence will need to be
[29:16] presented so that you really
[29:17] can move forward on it.
[29:19] But best of luck on that.
[29:21] So item number four which is
[29:23] the Civil Service Commission
[29:26] item a writ of mandamus which
[29:31] in MARCH and it means we
[29:33] command and also this really
[29:36] struck me when I looked it up
[29:38] it is an extraordinary remedy.
[29:41] So I'm not clear what that
[29:42] means but I did Google a civil
[29:46] service commission and they
[29:48] have a very positive
[29:50] reputation.
[29:50] So that was really wonderful to
[29:53] read, You know, on
[29:54] the settlements and judgments
[29:55] which we looked at recently
[29:57] mostly regarding speedy equal
[30:01] rights within number one item
[30:02] of the number of cases that
[30:04] occur to I And they talked
[30:08] about speeding up the process
[30:09] because the costs are
[30:11] escalating.
[30:12] So please I don't know when
[30:15] this termination in
[30:16] the original added some
[30:18] information which I didn't know
[30:20] about so it sounds like a
[30:21] pretty serious thing and then a
[30:24] termination is involved So I'll
[30:25] just send you blessings on that
[30:27] and best of luck for all
[30:29] parties In the Scooter incident
[30:33] which was alleged excuse me
[30:35] Same incident.
[30:36] Alleged.
[30:37] Oh yes.
[30:38] So there is an incident alleged
[30:40] e-scooter incident I learned a
[30:42] lot during our e-scooter time
[30:45] and when they were present in
[30:47] San Diego mostly I learned that
[30:49] we have many levels, many
[30:52] layers of codes and regular
[30:54] ations that can tie our hands
[30:57] in litigation.
[30:59] I think we learned a lot from
[31:01] our e-scooter period and it's
[31:06] it's just a learning lesson for
[31:08] us and I certainly learned a
[31:10] lot.
[31:10] So we move forward and I thank
[31:14] you very much for listening and
[31:16] love to all have a beautiful
[31:17] day and a beautiful week.
[31:18] Thank you to the caller for
[31:20] staying on topic.
[31:21] Thank you for those comments.
[31:23] Please note that the five
[31:25] minute timer did conclude with
[31:26] no additional speakers left in
[31:27] the queue That does conclude
[31:29] closed session Public comment
[31:33] All right.
[31:34] >> Thank you Deputy Clerk With
[31:35] that we will now recess into
[31:36] closed session and reconvene
[31:38] council today at 2 P.M. Or
[44:58] shortly thereafter
[46:43] and then
[46:49] All right started.
[46:50] >> Good afternoon.
[46:50] I will now reconvene the city
[46:52] council meeting on Monday, JUNE
[46:54] 22nd 2026 that the clerk please
[46:57] call the Roll Council member
[46:59] Campbell Council Member
[47:01] Whitburn Council Member Foster
[47:06] Council Member Von Wilpert
[47:10] Council PRESIDENT Pro Tem
[47:10] The Council Member Campo
[47:15] Council Member Moreno Council
[47:18] Member Eli Rivera and Council
[47:21] PRESIDENT LaCava Present.
[47:23] Also attending the meeting are
[47:25] Assistant City Attorney
[47:26] Michelle Garland Jordan more
[47:29] fiscal and policy analyst with
[47:31] the Office of the Independent
[47:32] Budget Analyst and myself here
[47:36] Deputy City Clerk Kevin Smith.
[47:40] All right, a quorum is now
[47:41] present.
[47:42] So first of all start off
[47:43] whether there's any comments
[47:44] from the mayor's office,
[47:45] council members, city attorney,
[47:47] independent budget analyst, our
[47:49] city clerk and not seeing any
[47:53] We'll go on Deputy Clerk Please
[47:55] go over how the public can
[47:56] offer their testimony.
[47:59] I will not I don't know how I
[48:00] like to slide on the screen
[48:01] their reviews how the public
[48:02] can offer their public
[48:03] testimony during this
[48:04] afternoon's meeting.
[48:06] The order can be found on
[48:07] the agenda Summary found online
[48:08] or at the table in the back of
[48:10] the room.
[48:11] If you are in person please
[48:12] complete the speaker slip
[48:13] located at the entrance of
[48:14] chambers and bring it to
[48:15] the front of the room.
[48:17] Council ambassadors are
[48:18] available near the entrance of
[48:20] chambers and can assist with
[48:21] questions and speaker slips.
[48:23] No further in-person testimony
[48:25] will be taken once the council
[48:26] begins Virtual testimony.
[48:30] >> All right.
[48:31] And as a friendly reminder non
[48:34] agenda public comment which
[48:35] will be taken at the end of
[48:36] the day it's an opportunity to
[48:37] speak on anything that's within
[48:38] the broader city of San Diego
[48:40] Purview docketed items We
[48:43] request that you speak to
[48:45] the item itself Inform
[48:47] the Council about whether you
[48:48] support an item or reject an
[48:51] item and your reasons why So
[48:53] focusing on the docket item
[48:55] will be appreciated So with
[48:57] that Deputy Clerk please
[49:00] introduce item 200 item 200
[49:07] Public hour Feasibility study
[49:09] Phase two report.
[49:10] All right.
[49:11] Thank you, sir.
[49:12] And a reminder to everyone this
[49:14] is an information item.
[49:16] No motion will be taken And now
[49:23] settle then please introduce
[49:25] yourselves for the record and
[49:26] let us know how much time
[49:27] you'll need.
[49:37] >> There we go.
[49:37] Try again.
[49:38] There we.
[49:42] Keep on Heather Rider, deputy
[49:42] director for energy in
[49:44] the Department of General
[49:45] Services.
[49:45] We need about 15 minutes.
[49:47] All right, Begin when you're
[49:48] ready.
[49:48] All right.
[49:49] Thank you very much.
[49:49] Thank you.
[49:50] Council PRESIDENT, members of
[49:51] council as many of you are
[49:53] aware and as a corollary to
[49:56] the award of the Genie
[49:57] franchise, the city started
[50:01] studying alternatives to a
[50:03] franchise agreement for
[50:05] the delivery of electricity
[50:06] within the city boundary and as
[50:08] public power feasibility that
[50:10] study was split into two parts.
[50:12] The Phase one report was
[50:13] brought to council in
[50:14] the summer of 2023.
[50:17] It did find basic economic and
[50:19] technical feasibility so we
[50:21] moved into phase two which was
[50:24] a much deeper dive into
[50:26] the economic and technical
[50:28] feasibility as well as
[50:29] incorporating changes in
[50:31] the regulatory space that have
[50:33] happened between those periods.
[50:35] We brought on new gen
[50:37] strategies to act as our
[50:41] subject matter expert and
[50:42] technical consultant in
[50:43] executing that study And so I'm
[50:44] going to pass it over to Scott
[50:46] to go over the findings.
[50:48] Great.
[50:49] Thank you Heather.
[50:50] Good afternoon.
[50:51] Council PRESIDENT Council
[50:52] members Staff As I mentioned my
[50:54] name is Scott Burnham.
[50:55] I'm a partner and project
[50:57] manager with New Data Strategy
[50:59] Solutions.
[51:00] I'm joined here today with DR.
[51:02] Nelson Beck along with Siemens
[51:04] Engineering, Andrew Atwater
[51:05] with Beebe and a consultant
[51:08] that assisted us with the study
[51:14] Excellent.
[51:15] >> All right.
[51:15] The bottom line in terms of
[51:17] the phase two study is that we
[51:19] found that the analysis for
[51:21] developing and creating an mcu
[51:24] and municipal electric utility
[51:25] from the San Diego Gas Electric
[51:28] Genie assets was both
[51:30] economically and technically
[51:31] feasible.
[51:33] The results depend on the value
[51:35] of the assets that the city
[51:37] pays to acquire them.
[51:39] We conducted analysis using two
[51:42] approaches to cost approaches
[51:43] to value.
[51:44] We'll talk more about that
[51:45] The Oakland original costs less
[51:47] depreciation at the low end and
[51:49] replacement costs new less
[51:51] depreciation on the high end.
[51:53] This analysis focuses on
[51:55] the delivery assets only
[51:58] There's no generation assets to
[51:59] be acquired from Genie
[52:02] The generation power supply
[52:04] portion of the mcu was assumed
[52:07] to be supplied by sdp.
[52:10] >> This data currently serves
[52:10] the majority of the city Load
[52:14] results suggest a range of
[52:15] savings between 6 and 6% to 16%
[52:20] depending on the assets paid to
[52:22] be acquired between 7 billion
[52:24] and $19 billion At the 30 year
[52:27] conclusion of the 30 year study
[52:31] More broadly, the analysis that
[52:32] we conducted was what we call
[52:34] an overnight analysis.
[52:36] It's assuming that
[52:39] the municipal utility would
[52:40] essentially start within
[52:43] the year.
[52:44] That's not feasible.
[52:45] We know that We realize that
[52:47] will take at least 10 or 15
[52:48] years to establish a municipal
[52:51] utility.
[52:52] But the approach uses an
[52:54] overnight analysis as a prudent
[52:56] approach to understand the cost
[52:58] and determine the feasibility.
[53:05] We came before you
[53:06] approximately three years ago
[53:07] with the results of the Phase
[53:08] one study.
[53:09] >> There's been significant
[53:10] changes since then.
[53:12] The relative to the study we
[53:15] had additional information and
[53:17] detailed data provided by Jenny
[53:20] and that informed a lot of
[53:22] the results of the study.
[53:23] We also recognize there have
[53:25] been significant changes in
[53:27] policy and the regulatory
[53:28] environment that also impact
[53:29] the study and the Phase two
[53:31] report Phase two report In
[53:35] terms of the changes in
[53:36] the utility environment,
[53:38] certainly a change in
[53:39] the landscape relative to
[53:40] the assets themselves.
[53:42] Again, the information we got
[53:43] from Jenny that information
[53:46] helped improve the cost
[53:48] analysis relative to
[53:50] the physical separation of
[53:52] the two systems.
[53:53] If the mou is to be formed it
[53:55] would be electrically isolated
[53:56] from Jenny who have the ability
[53:58] to do so and that would require
[54:02] investment on behalf of
[54:03] the city.
[54:06] In terms of the regulatory
[54:07] environment, the process
[54:08] continues to evolve relative to
[54:10] how the cpc would develop or
[54:13] what would determine the cost
[54:16] for the mcu to acquire these
[54:18] assets.
[54:19] As you're aware, the city of
[54:20] San Francisco is going through
[54:21] a similar exercise.
[54:22] They're a little further ahead.
[54:24] They've been to the cpc.
[54:26] They have some preliminary
[54:27] results relative to how the cpc
[54:31] would then then look at
[54:32] the acquisition costs.
[54:34] But there are other policy and
[54:36] risks to be considered in terms
[54:38] of climate change, commodity
[54:39] cost, wildfire mitigation as
[54:41] you know that's a big ticket
[54:43] item relative to costs and cost
[54:46] recovery.
[54:50] The Phase two approach focuses
[54:52] on a 30 year cash needs.
[54:54] It develops what we call a
[54:56] revenue requirement for
[54:57] the mcu.
[54:58] That's the total dollars to
[54:59] operate the mcu in comparison
[55:01] to the total dollars paid to us
[55:04] based on existing rates and
[55:06] assumptions about future rates.
[55:08] For Jenny, as I mentioned, it's
[55:11] only acquiring assets within
[55:13] the city primarily distribution
[55:16] assets but some limited
[55:17] transmission assets as dcp as
[55:23] dcp sorry the cta will continue
[55:23] to provide power supply to
[55:24] everyone And it's this buildup
[55:27] of the revenue requirement that
[55:28] is the crux of the analysis.
[55:30] So we're looking at the that
[55:31] the system as mcu compared does
[55:36] cost on an all in basis
[55:38] compared to the system as I see
[55:41] each unit continue and
[55:42] the status quo the analysis
[55:45] suggests the that there is
[55:46] indeed savings it shows
[55:48] the benefit of public power
[55:50] there are but current
[55:52] opportunity for efficiency
[55:54] local control and cost savings.
[55:57] Again this is done on what we
[55:59] call an overnight analysis
[56:01] recognizing that there would
[56:02] still be a different time
[56:04] component to this in terms of
[56:09] the assets to be acquired.
[56:11] As I mentioned, almost all
[56:12] the assets almost all
[56:14] the assets in the city would be
[56:15] acquired approximately 800
[56:17] miles of secondary conductor
[56:18] conductor line wires,
[56:22] transformers meters and other
[56:23] equipment.
[56:24] The city would be responsible
[56:26] for serving approximately six
[56:29] 660,000 customers.
[56:30] The city would also acquire 42
[56:33] electrical substations within
[56:34] the municipal boundary and
[56:36] the sub transmission conductor
[56:37] between those substations
[56:40] the city would not acquire
[56:42] the high voltage system
[56:44] the bulk transmission system or
[56:45] any generation assets from a
[56:52] genie.
[56:53] As I mentioned, we conducted
[56:54] what we call a cost based
[56:55] purchase price analysis.
[56:57] This cost based analysis begins
[56:59] on a low end and with the only
[57:03] older original cost less
[57:03] depreciation and the high end
[57:04] replacement cost new less
[57:05] appreciation In reality
[57:07] the cost would likely come in
[57:09] between those two values.
[57:10] But we developed these bookend
[57:12] values at $2.4 billion for
[57:15] original cost of depreciation
[57:19] and $7.6 billion replacement
[57:19] cost new less depreciation In a
[57:23] transaction a prudent seller
[57:24] likely would likely not accept
[57:29] our original cost appreciation
[57:29] That's a book value essentially
[57:31] and a prudent buyer is unlikely
[57:32] to accept replacement cost new
[57:34] less depreciation which is why
[57:36] would in all likelihood that
[57:38] costs would come in between
[57:39] those two values somewhere
[57:41] The difference of that $5.2
[57:44] billion is significant and it
[57:46] does in the age of the assets
[57:48] certainly has an impact on that
[57:49] valuation.
[57:51] We also assumed that there
[57:52] would be additional costs
[57:53] upfront approximately $912
[57:55] million of upfront cost to fund
[57:58] that separation analysis again
[58:00] creating to electrically
[58:02] ability to have two
[58:03] electrically isolated systems
[58:05] startup costs as well and as
[58:07] well as $470 million in working
[58:10] capital.
[58:11] Startup costs include
[58:12] the development of the utility
[58:14] to create an operating utility
[58:16] ,financial reserves, liquidity
[58:18] measurements and the like.
[58:22] This next slide shows a summary
[58:23] of the key assumptions.
[58:26] As I mentioned, the purchase
[58:26] price is probably the most
[58:28] dramatic key in terms of
[58:30] the analysis that range between
[58:34] 2.4 billion and 7.6 billion but
[58:35] also the assumptions around
[58:37] long term rate growth for ge we
[58:40] assume 4% per year going
[58:43] forward That was based on
[58:44] information available at
[58:45] the time From the general rate
[58:46] case it's probably a little bit
[58:49] lower than historic but we
[58:52] believe there was a
[58:52] conservative assumption other
[58:55] elements include the payment in
[58:56] lieu of franchise fees and
[58:58] public benefits.
[58:59] As I mentioned, the separation
[59:00] costs, startup costs upfront
[59:02] working and of course staffing
[59:05] one of the critical elements
[59:05] relative to difference between
[59:07] the phase one and the phase two
[59:07] analysis was there's a more
[59:10] detailed analysis around
[59:12] staffing.
[59:13] The intent would be to to
[59:15] address the concerns of ibew
[59:17] and others and acquire
[59:19] the workforce from any.
[59:24] In summary of the results.
[59:27] We've got two graphics here on
[59:28] the left.
[59:28] You can see there's selected
[59:29] years between the oclc and
[59:31] again on the low end the rca
[59:33] and on the high end.
[59:35] So you can see we're showing
[59:37] your ten, your 20 and your 30
[59:38] for the ocd.
[59:40] So significant savings of $19
[59:41] billion at the end of
[59:43] cumulative savings in your 30
[59:45] the replacement costs new less
[59:46] appreciation is slightly lower
[59:48] at $7 billion There is a
[59:51] crossover in the ocd case It's
[59:54] year one in which mean you
[59:55] would show cash positive for
[59:58] the replacement cost you looked
[59:59] at less depreciation the old
[1:00:01] either higher asset that
[1:00:02] crossover occurs and estimated
[1:00:04] in year 12 so the city would
[1:00:06] not recognize savings upfront
[1:00:08] if indeed they purchased a
[1:00:14] price at at rc an oldie
[1:00:15] The next slide shows on an
[1:00:17] annual basis looking out over
[1:00:19] the 30 year forecast the period
[1:00:21] of the study on the left we saw
[1:00:23] the ocr and all the numbers You
[1:00:24] can see showing cash positive
[1:00:25] there in year one and
[1:00:27] continuing to grow over time On
[1:00:29] the right we show our you know
[1:00:31] you can see that the blue bars
[1:00:32] there are the city of San Diego
[1:00:34] costs the mcu costs that would
[1:00:37] be higher than any costs for
[1:00:39] the first 12, 11, 12 years in
[1:00:41] the study we did conduct a
[1:00:48] sensitivity on the relative to
[1:00:51] the assumptions about
[1:00:53] the growth rate of the retail
[1:00:55] rates.
[1:00:56] As I mentioned, we use the 4%
[1:00:57] approach annual approach for
[1:01:00] city Jeanie retail rates We
[1:01:02] believe that that was
[1:01:03] reasonable based on recent rate
[1:01:05] case information.
[1:01:07] Historically that number is
[1:01:08] probably closer to about 6% as
[1:01:11] you can see in this analysis
[1:01:12] here.
[1:01:13] What we're trying to show in
[1:01:14] this analysis I should say is
[1:01:16] that at 3% at the lower end of
[1:01:19] the range of growth rates,
[1:01:22] the savings is significantly
[1:01:23] less at 6% that that range goes
[1:01:27] up to significant and
[1:01:27] significant savings, a
[1:01:31] difference of about $60 billion
[1:01:32] between those.
[1:01:33] Now this is based on the ocr
[1:01:35] acquisition cost case but you
[1:01:38] can see the sensitivity to
[1:01:40] the results relative to
[1:01:41] the assumption made for
[1:01:42] the genie rates.
[1:01:46] There are certainly several key
[1:01:47] assumptions moving forward that
[1:01:49] would impact future
[1:01:50] feasibility.
[1:01:52] Certainly policy direction
[1:01:53] around climate change, consumer
[1:01:55] preference, electrification and
[1:01:56] the like relative to projected
[1:01:58] low growth How it will impact
[1:02:00] this analysis certainly
[1:02:03] direction at the state level
[1:02:05] looking at affordability,
[1:02:07] looking at reliability in terms
[1:02:09] of investment requirements for
[1:02:11] systems such as energy needs
[1:02:13] and the sensitivity to retail
[1:02:15] rates is an important
[1:02:16] consideration as well.
[1:02:19] Looking out over what's
[1:02:20] happening at the state at
[1:02:22] the cpi you see relative to San
[1:02:23] Francisco felt that
[1:02:26] the precedents there in terms
[1:02:26] of that court decision,
[1:02:28] the preliminary court decision
[1:02:30] looking at legislation, Senate
[1:02:32] bill 875 looking at municipal
[1:02:36] ization efforts across
[1:02:37] the state as well as at the cpi
[1:02:40] you see regarding wildfire
[1:02:41] investments and the past in
[1:02:43] the future is a major unknown
[1:02:49] conclusion.
[1:02:50] >> The Phase two analysis is
[1:02:52] conducted has significantly
[1:02:53] refined the financial
[1:02:55] projections.
[1:02:55] We have a lot more detailed
[1:02:57] data relative to the asset
[1:02:58] inventory relative to
[1:03:00] the estimated costs.
[1:03:02] The certainly the age of
[1:03:03] the assets are materially older
[1:03:04] than originally assumed
[1:03:07] creating a different difference
[1:03:08] disparity between the ocr and
[1:03:11] replacement costs new less
[1:03:12] depreciation values.
[1:03:15] The Phase two does find
[1:03:16] financial and technical
[1:03:17] feasibility and the opportunity
[1:03:19] to save dollars for the rate
[1:03:20] over time for rate payers.
[1:03:23] But the biggest drivers I
[1:03:25] mentioned is the assumption
[1:03:26] around sd g long term growth
[1:03:28] rates and of course
[1:03:30] the potential savings and
[1:03:31] financial benefits are an
[1:03:32] estimate At this point there's
[1:03:34] no guarantees that these that
[1:03:36] these savings would would would
[1:03:36] come to fruition.
[1:03:40] The legislative and regulatory
[1:03:41] environment is indeed evolving
[1:03:43] and fluid.
[1:03:45] There are certainly costs
[1:03:47] issues around costs recovery
[1:03:48] cost reimbursement valuation
[1:03:49] approaches as well as
[1:03:51] the potential process all of
[1:03:53] which could impact
[1:03:53] the financial feasibility.
[1:03:56] However, overall the results
[1:03:57] are more refined and more more
[1:04:00] defined than significant
[1:04:00] unknowns and variables remain.
[1:04:03] That's the conclusion of our
[1:04:04] presentation.
[1:04:05] I'd be happy to answer any
[1:04:06] questions.
[1:04:09] >> All right.
[1:04:10] Thank you for the presentation.
[1:04:11] The fire marshal has asked for
[1:04:12] Those that are standing
[1:04:14] the back are actually empty
[1:04:15] seats out there.
[1:04:16] So if you could take a seat
[1:04:17] with make the fire marshal
[1:04:19] happy which makes me feel more
[1:04:21] comfortable.
[1:04:22] So thank you.
[1:04:24] So think again for
[1:04:26] the presentation.
[1:04:28] With that let's go to public
[1:04:31] comment.
[1:04:32] Thank you counsel Thank you.
[1:04:35] Council PRESIDENT This item
[1:04:35] received 15 comments in favor
[1:04:37] and two comments in opposition
[1:04:38] via our e comment form which
[1:04:41] has been distributed to
[1:04:42] the Council.
[1:04:43] We will begin with in-person
[1:04:44] public comment.
[1:04:49] Anthony Stackhouse Please come
[1:04:51] forward and and each speaker
[1:04:55] will receive one minute after
[1:04:59] Anthony Kevin Carroll, Matthew
[1:05:02] Fish and Christina marquez
[1:05:05] Please come sit in the front
[1:05:06] row.
[1:05:10] >> Please begin.
[1:05:13] My name is Anthony Stackhouse.
[1:05:15] I serve on the executive board
[1:05:16] for ibew for 65.
[1:05:19] I spent 14 years in the Army
[1:05:22] with combat deployments
[1:05:23] overseas and if you knew the I
[1:05:25] went through to get to where
[1:05:26] I'm at today you would not be
[1:05:28] so steadfast to put my job and
[1:05:30] my family's quality of life at
[1:05:32] risk.
[1:05:33] The people in this city don't
[1:05:35] trust you Don't give them more
[1:05:36] reasons.
[1:05:37] Be honest with themselves.
[1:05:39] You do not have the resources
[1:05:40] or knowledge to do this.
[1:05:43] Don't gamble with my job or
[1:05:44] the job of my union brothers
[1:05:46] and sisters because I promise
[1:05:47] you one thing we will not go
[1:05:49] down without a fight.
[1:05:51] I urge this Cancel this council
[1:05:52] to end this now Municipal
[1:05:55] association is union busting.
[1:06:01] Thank you for those comments.
[1:06:02] Kevin Carroll Good afternoon
[1:06:10] Council members My name is
[1:06:11] Kevin Caroline, executive
[1:06:12] Director of Tech San Diego
[1:06:13] representing technology
[1:06:14] companies across our region.
[1:06:16] Our members care about reliable
[1:06:17] service competitive rate and
[1:06:19] the infrastructure needed to
[1:06:20] support innovation,
[1:06:21] manufacturing and economic
[1:06:23] growth.
[1:06:24] Based on this presentation we
[1:06:25] have some concerns.
[1:06:27] The question is not whether
[1:06:28] minutes position is possible.
[1:06:30] The question is whether
[1:06:31] the risk caused are
[1:06:33] sufficiently understood before
[1:06:34] making a multibillion dollar
[1:06:35] decision that could impact
[1:06:36] businesses and residents for
[1:06:38] decades before moving forward.
[1:06:40] The city should have a high
[1:06:41] degree of confidence that all
[1:06:42] major cost liabilities,
[1:06:44] regulatory requirements and
[1:06:45] operational challenges are
[1:06:47] fully understood and reflected
[1:06:49] in the analysis.
[1:06:51] If manipulation ultimately
[1:06:52] proves to be the best path,
[1:06:54] the business case could
[1:06:55] withstand rigorous scrutiny if
[1:06:56] significant uncertainties
[1:06:57] remain as I think we saw in
[1:06:59] the presentation, those
[1:07:00] questions should be resolved
[1:07:01] before ratepayers and
[1:07:03] businesses assume the risk for
[1:07:04] San Diego's innovation economy.
[1:07:06] The goal is a reliable,
[1:07:07] resilient and affordable energy
[1:07:09] energy system that supports
[1:07:09] job.
[1:07:10] Thank you.
[1:07:11] Thank you for your comment and
[1:07:12] that does conclude your time.
[1:07:15] Matthew Fish Good afternoon
[1:07:21] Council members.
[1:07:22] My name is Matthew Fish and I'm
[1:07:23] the system business manager at
[1:07:25] ibew Local 465.
[1:07:27] I represent the workers
[1:07:28] industry Jeannie speaking
[1:07:32] against the Phase two study
[1:07:32] because it offers no job
[1:07:33] protections for my 700 gas
[1:07:35] construction work members
[1:07:37] workers will lose their jobs
[1:07:39] and the retiree medical and
[1:07:41] pensions will be affected.
[1:07:43] Please in this once and for all
[1:07:45] please invest the $9 million
[1:07:46] Billion elsewhere such as
[1:07:48] infrastructure backlog or
[1:07:50] housing for the homeless.
[1:07:51] Please do not gamble with our
[1:07:53] union jobs and if the city has
[1:07:55] bigger priorities like thank
[1:08:03] you and Christina marquez and
[1:08:05] while Christina speak incurred
[1:08:08] Mark Fuentes, Krystal Gomez,
[1:08:09] Monica Valdez and Cecilia
[1:08:11] marquez please approach
[1:08:12] the front row.
[1:08:14] Hi good afternoon.
[1:08:16] Christina marquez speaking on
[1:08:18] behalf of ibew Local 569 San
[1:08:21] Diego and Imperial County where
[1:08:24] the inside wireman We're here
[1:08:25] in solidarity with our union
[1:08:27] sisters and brothers of 465.
[1:08:30] The ibew stands against any
[1:08:32] effort to municipalities
[1:08:34] the power company the Nugent
[1:08:37] study says nothing about worker
[1:08:39] protections or job guarantee
[1:08:42] Leaving our ibew five 569
[1:08:45] members in limbo ibew members
[1:08:49] could lose jobs and benefits
[1:08:53] and the city is already
[1:08:54] billions behind in
[1:08:55] infrastructure spending
[1:08:57] infrastructure spending That
[1:08:59] puts our building trades
[1:09:00] members to work.
[1:09:01] >> Please do not wage or gamble
[1:09:05] with our jobs and our
[1:09:07] livelihood.
[1:09:08] Please end these efforts once
[1:09:10] for all.
[1:09:11] Thank you.
[1:09:12] Thank you.
[1:09:13] Mark wants Yeah Good afternoon.
[1:09:20] Council members.
[1:09:21] My name is Mark Fuentes.
[1:09:23] I'm a gas working foreman for
[1:09:23] our city.
[1:09:26] Jeannie a shop steward Would I
[1:09:28] be w Local 465 a proud U.S.
[1:09:30] Army veteran and a San Diego
[1:09:32] native.
[1:09:33] I served this country because I
[1:09:35] believe in protecting American
[1:09:37] families, American workers and
[1:09:39] communities.
[1:09:40] But when I look at this
[1:09:41] proposal I don't see any
[1:09:42] protections for me, my
[1:09:44] coworkers or our families.
[1:09:45] I don't see a future for my
[1:09:47] skilled gas workers who have
[1:09:49] dedicated their entire careers
[1:09:51] to serving this community.
[1:09:53] I also don't see protection for
[1:09:55] our communities especially when
[1:09:56] the cost of living is at an all
[1:09:58] time high.
[1:10:00] This proposal will create
[1:10:01] additional expenses for
[1:10:03] citizens and taxpayers who are
[1:10:04] already struggling to make ends
[1:10:05] meet.
[1:10:06] Please don't gamble with good
[1:10:08] union jobs without clear worker
[1:10:10] protections.
[1:10:11] I urge you not to move forward
[1:10:12] with this effort.
[1:10:13] Thank you Cristo Gomez.
[1:10:20] >> Good afternoon, Council
[1:10:21] members.
[1:10:22] My name is Cristo Gomez.
[1:10:25] I am shop steward of ibew 465
[1:10:26] and equipment operator c
[1:10:28] Jeannie I'm also a veteran of
[1:10:29] the United States Marine Corps.
[1:10:31] I operate equipment for gas and
[1:10:32] electric emergency And this
[1:10:34] feasibility study you only want
[1:10:36] to take over electric.
[1:10:37] What about gas jobs?
[1:10:39] What about equipment operators
[1:10:41] like myself and their families
[1:10:44] when we lose our jobs?
[1:10:46] What about our retirements?
[1:10:48] There are over 700 gas workers
[1:10:50] in our union.
[1:10:51] What about them?
[1:10:53] Where's our just transition And
[1:10:55] what about job mobility?
[1:10:57] Because in this proposal I
[1:10:59] don't see a future for us in
[1:11:01] our jobs Don't gamble with good
[1:11:03] union jobs And I see Jeannie
[1:11:05] with the city takeover I urge
[1:11:06] the City Council not to proceed
[1:11:08] any further with this effort
[1:11:10] forcing the city to take on
[1:11:11] billions in debt is wrong.
[1:11:13] We have bigger priorities.
[1:11:15] Thank you.
[1:11:16] Thank you.
[1:11:17] Monica Valdez Hello my name is
[1:11:25] Monica Relative.
[1:11:26] >> I'm a third generation ibew
[1:11:28] member and emergency dispatcher
[1:11:30] for sd Jeannie I'm a proud
[1:11:32] resident of District four.
[1:11:36] >> I am a very active and very
[1:11:37] active in my union and my
[1:11:39] community as part of local
[1:11:41] social service clubs.
[1:11:43] I'm here to express my absolute
[1:11:45] opposition to the Phase two
[1:11:46] study The proposal is costly,
[1:11:49] will gamble what puts our union
[1:11:51] contracts in the crosshairs?
[1:11:53] There are zero protections and
[1:11:55] zero guarantees for my members
[1:11:57] There was zero current
[1:12:00] consideration for my gas
[1:12:00] members.
[1:12:01] Our gas people They are left
[1:12:03] behind in this proposal.
[1:12:05] Where is the just the just
[1:12:06] transition Please vote against
[1:12:08] this risky measure.
[1:12:10] Please don't gamble with our
[1:12:11] livelihoods.
[1:12:12] >> Please stop this once and
[1:12:13] for all.
[1:12:17] Thank you.
[1:12:18] Cecilia marquez Well Cecilia
[1:12:21] comes to the microphone could
[1:12:21] Laurie Lips?
[1:12:26] Lipson Noelia Carolyn Jason
[1:12:28] Poggio, Chris Kate and Amy
[1:12:30] Fossett please come to
[1:12:30] the front row.
[1:12:32] >> Please begin.
[1:12:34] Thank you.
[1:12:35] My name is Cecilia marquez.
[1:12:37] I'm born and raised in San
[1:12:38] Diego.
[1:12:39] I'm a single mother, a
[1:12:40] homeowner and a 24 year
[1:12:42] employee at San Diego Gas and
[1:12:43] Electric.
[1:12:44] I'm also a proud union officer
[1:12:46] and organizer at ibew Local
[1:12:48] 465.
[1:12:50] The city has been studying this
[1:12:52] for decades and it's time to
[1:12:53] stop.
[1:12:53] San Diego is a beautiful city
[1:12:56] but when I look around I see
[1:12:57] bigger priorities that we
[1:12:58] should be focusing on
[1:13:00] the homelessness, affordable
[1:13:02] housing, fixing our storm
[1:13:03] drains, infrastructure, public
[1:13:05] transit And in this study
[1:13:08] there's no guarantee that our
[1:13:09] jobs will carry over to a city
[1:13:11] ran utility.
[1:13:12] And even if they do, wages,
[1:13:14] salaries and benefits could
[1:13:16] change considerably.
[1:13:17] So I urge the city council to
[1:13:19] not proceed any further with
[1:13:20] this effort.
[1:13:21] Let's stop wasting our tax
[1:13:22] dollars.
[1:13:23] This is wrong and the city has
[1:13:25] much bigger priorities.
[1:13:28] Municipal association It is
[1:13:28] union busting.
[1:13:29] >> Thank you.
[1:13:31] Thank you.
[1:13:38] Laurie Lipman Hello Council
[1:13:38] members.
[1:13:39] I'm Laurie Litzman, a
[1:13:40] constituent of District three
[1:13:43] sd Jean e continues to put
[1:13:45] profits before people.
[1:13:46] For decades we've been we've
[1:13:49] built an energy system that
[1:13:51] transports power long distances
[1:13:53] ,losing power along the way
[1:13:55] while increasing costs and
[1:13:57] vulnerability.
[1:13:58] The Sunrise Powerlink destroyed
[1:13:58] habitat impact and cultural
[1:14:02] significance in significant
[1:14:03] lands and disrupt its disrupted
[1:14:05] communities.
[1:14:08] Today those transmission
[1:14:09] corridors are part of a system
[1:14:11] that routinely shuts down power
[1:14:13] to reduce wildfire risk.
[1:14:15] This is not smart energy.
[1:14:19] Sd g e customers pay among
[1:14:21] the highest rates in California
[1:14:23] while utility executives and
[1:14:25] shareholders continue to profit
[1:14:27] ,many residents are being
[1:14:28] forced to choose between
[1:14:29] necessities and keeping
[1:14:31] the lights on.
[1:14:32] Energy is an essential public
[1:14:34] service.
[1:14:35] It should be accountable to
[1:14:36] the people not corporate
[1:14:36] profit.
[1:14:37] Basically that does conclude
[1:14:37] your time.
[1:14:38] Thank you.
[1:14:43] Next speaker Noelia Collin Good
[1:14:51] afternoon.
[1:14:52] My name is Noelia Colon and I'm
[1:14:53] a welder.
[1:14:56] Jeannie I'm four and a proud
[1:14:56] member of ibew for six five.
[1:14:58] I'm proud to be the first woman
[1:15:00] welder in our union's history
[1:15:01] of over 100 years.
[1:15:02] This career has changed My life
[1:15:04] gave me opportunities financial
[1:15:06] independence and a future I
[1:15:08] never imagined for myself.
[1:15:09] I understand that people are
[1:15:10] frustrated with utility costs.
[1:15:12] Those concerns are valid and do
[1:15:14] deserve to be heard and
[1:15:15] discussed.
[1:15:15] We pay those too and we live
[1:15:17] here as well.
[1:15:18] But when I read the study I
[1:15:19] didn't see enough discussion
[1:15:21] about the workers who operate
[1:15:22] maintain and respond to
[1:15:23] emergencies on the system every
[1:15:24] day.
[1:15:25] I didn't see myself I didn't
[1:15:26] see my union brothers and
[1:15:27] sisters.
[1:15:28] I didn't see the young women
[1:15:29] who MAY 1st day follow the path
[1:15:30] that I did part that I did.
[1:15:32] I ask that you consider not
[1:15:33] only the infrastructure but
[1:15:34] the people behind it
[1:15:35] the workforce, the training,
[1:15:36] the experience, the careers,
[1:15:38] the culture, all the hustlers
[1:15:39] that serve that community for
[1:15:41] generations.
[1:15:41] I was born and raised here in
[1:15:43] San Diego.
[1:15:44] I love the city and that's
[1:15:45] exactly why I'm asking you to
[1:15:47] think carefully about
[1:15:47] the people who serve and
[1:15:48] sacrifice for it every day.
[1:15:50] >> Thank you.
[1:15:53] >> Jason Paglia, Jason Paglia.
[1:15:59] Okay.
[1:16:00] Moving on Chris Kate Good
[1:16:06] afternoon.
[1:16:06] Council PRESIDENT Members of
[1:16:07] the council Chris Kate on
[1:16:08] behalf of the San Diego
[1:16:09] Regional Chamber of Commerce.
[1:16:11] The Phase two study claims I
[1:16:13] mean just what utility would
[1:16:13] save San Diegans $130 billion?
[1:16:16] Let's be direct When something
[1:16:18] sounds too good to be true, it
[1:16:19] usually is giving false hope to
[1:16:22] San Diegans at a time when
[1:16:23] affordability is top of mind.
[1:16:25] The reality is that municipal
[1:16:26] ization is a dangerous, costly
[1:16:27] gamble.
[1:16:29] Startup costs alone could reach
[1:16:30] $9 billion a year or more.
[1:16:32] Money the city simply does not
[1:16:33] have nor residents can afford
[1:16:35] to take on as debt.
[1:16:36] This doesn't even account for
[1:16:38] massive annual operating costs
[1:16:40] wildfire insurance cost
[1:16:41] overruns or litigation that
[1:16:42] residents and businesses would
[1:16:43] be forced to bankroll.
[1:16:47] >> Pursuing a takeover of our
[1:16:48] energy infrastructure is a
[1:16:49] costly distraction that
[1:16:50] undermines our economic
[1:16:51] stability and risk our electric
[1:16:53] reliability.
[1:16:55] Past city councils have rightly
[1:16:56] rejected this path time and
[1:16:57] again because the risks
[1:16:58] continue to far outweigh any
[1:17:01] speculative benefits.
[1:17:02] We urge you to reject this
[1:17:03] proposal once and for all.
[1:17:05] Thank you.
[1:17:07] Amy Fossett.
[1:17:12] >> Good afternoon.
[1:17:13] Amy Fossett with the Building
[1:17:14] Industry Association of San
[1:17:16] Diego.
[1:17:16] I'm here today to talk more
[1:17:18] about from my personal and
[1:17:19] professional experience working
[1:17:21] here at the city.
[1:17:22] I was had the honor of working
[1:17:23] here over for over 20 years in
[1:17:25] almost every branch of
[1:17:27] government.
[1:17:28] The city is not structured
[1:17:29] organizationally nor does it
[1:17:31] have the expertise or
[1:17:32] the financial resources to take
[1:17:34] on such an endeavor.
[1:17:35] I too am concerned about energy
[1:17:37] rates.
[1:17:38] But the city of San Diego is
[1:17:39] not the solution to that
[1:17:40] problem.
[1:17:41] So I ask you to please move on
[1:17:43] from this endeavor and focus on
[1:17:45] the priorities and issues that
[1:17:46] you already have on your plate.
[1:17:47] Thank you.
[1:17:51] >> Thank you.
[1:17:52] Our next speaker is Marcy
[1:17:53] Weaver.
[1:17:54] While Marcy approaches
[1:17:55] the microphone, could Mark
[1:17:58] Kersey.
[1:18:01] Gene Wilder, Al Sanchez and
[1:18:06] Matt Kaczynski Please come sit
[1:18:08] in the front row.
[1:18:10] Good afternoon, Council members
[1:18:12] and city staff.
[1:18:13] My name is Marcy Weaver, ceo
[1:18:15] Controller MR. Chamber of
[1:18:16] Commerce.
[1:18:17] I'm here today on behalf of
[1:18:18] the businesses we represent to
[1:18:19] the throughout South County.
[1:18:22] Our business community depends
[1:18:23] on a reliable, affordable and
[1:18:25] predictable energy to operate,
[1:18:28] grow and create jobs in our
[1:18:29] region.
[1:18:30] While we appreciate the effort
[1:18:32] that has gone into
[1:18:33] the feasibility study, we are
[1:18:34] concerned that there is still
[1:18:36] not enough information
[1:18:37] available to fully understand
[1:18:39] financial, operational and long
[1:18:42] term impacts of the municipal
[1:18:42] politician accounts.
[1:18:46] We also want to acknowledge
[1:18:48] the significant wildfire
[1:18:51] mitigation work and ongoing
[1:18:53] investment that sgmd has made
[1:18:56] across the region.
[1:18:58] Chula Vista has had close calls
[1:19:00] with five wildfires.
[1:19:03] And this is critically
[1:19:04] important issue for our
[1:19:05] community.
[1:19:05] We have seen firsthand the work
[1:19:08] that fda has done to straighten
[1:19:12] grid build reliability and
[1:19:14] reduce fire risk being Thank
[1:19:17] you for your comments.
[1:19:17] That does conclude your time.
[1:19:19] Next speaker is Mark Kersey.
[1:19:24] Good afternoon council
[1:19:25] PRESIDENT And members of
[1:19:26] the council Mark Kersey
[1:19:27] representing San Diego
[1:19:27] Taxpayers.
[1:19:29] Having said on your side of
[1:19:30] the dais for eight years I'm
[1:19:32] going to ask you a question Is
[1:19:34] this really a headache that you
[1:19:35] guys want to take on?
[1:19:36] You guys already have a lot of
[1:19:38] headaches and several of them
[1:19:39] concern utilities.
[1:19:41] You get thousands of complaints
[1:19:42] about water rate increases.
[1:19:45] You get browbeat over the cost
[1:19:46] of pure water.
[1:19:48] You get criticized for failed
[1:19:49] stormwater channels and you
[1:19:51] take errors over trash fees
[1:19:52] particularly when third party
[1:19:53] estimates don't match reality
[1:19:56] Exactly like what could happen
[1:19:57] with this issue.
[1:19:59] Make no mistake running
[1:20:00] the power grid will only make
[1:20:02] these other headaches seem
[1:20:03] minor by comparison.
[1:20:05] The minute this ill fated
[1:20:06] eminent domain takeover closes
[1:20:08] ,people will expect you to
[1:20:10] immediately lower their
[1:20:11] electric rates.
[1:20:12] But you won't be able to
[1:20:13] because you have spent billions
[1:20:15] to buy the system and might
[1:20:16] actually need those rates to
[1:20:17] increase to pay off the massive
[1:20:19] bond debt and associated
[1:20:20] integration costs.
[1:20:23] You all have a tough job.
[1:20:24] You have enough headaches.
[1:20:25] Save yourself this one.
[1:20:27] Thank you.
[1:20:28] Thank you for your comments.
[1:20:30] Next speaker is Jay Wilder.
[1:20:33] If you're holding a sign,
[1:20:34] remember there are people
[1:20:35] behind you that might want to
[1:20:36] see our smiling faces up here.
[1:20:38] So use the back row if you want
[1:20:40] to hold the signs up so we can
[1:20:42] read them because you big fonts
[1:20:43] but have a courtesy to
[1:20:45] the people behind you.
[1:20:46] Thank you.
[1:20:47] Hello.
[1:20:48] Thank you for your time.
[1:20:48] My name is Jay Walder.
[1:20:49] I'm PRESIDENT Of ibew Local 465
[1:20:52] and alignment during
[1:20:52] the alignment.
[1:20:54] I'm also a marine Corps veteran
[1:20:56] husband father to two kids and
[1:20:58] I'm and I've defended
[1:21:00] the nation and our freedom.
[1:21:02] Today I am speaking to defend
[1:21:03] my union members and protect
[1:21:05] their jobs.
[1:21:06] Don't do this like I've trained
[1:21:08] for 20 plus years under ibew
[1:21:10] desk to learn this complex and
[1:21:11] ever changing system and I'm
[1:21:13] learning more every day.
[1:21:15] This is not something you can
[1:21:16] just learn overnight.
[1:21:17] It will take you decades and
[1:21:19] all the while my vw brothers
[1:21:21] and sisters and I will fight
[1:21:22] you every step of the way to
[1:21:23] protect union jobs.
[1:21:26] Let's not go to war.
[1:21:27] Let's find a way to work
[1:21:28] together to address real
[1:21:29] priorities in San Diego like
[1:21:31] homelessness especially veteran
[1:21:33] homelessness, mental health and
[1:21:37] addiction.
[1:21:38] This is where we should be
[1:21:39] spending valuable city
[1:21:39] resources.
[1:21:40] Thank you for your time.
[1:21:42] >> Thank you.
[1:21:44] Our next speaker is Al Sanchez
[1:21:48] >> Thank you, council members.
[1:21:49] My name's Al Sanchez and I'm
[1:21:51] here on behalf of Local 89 and
[1:21:54] my business manager Bella
[1:21:54] Marcelo.
[1:21:56] We're here today to communicate
[1:21:58] our opposition to the efforts
[1:22:00] of bringing the work union
[1:22:02] contractors currently do
[1:22:02] in-house.
[1:22:05] We do not mean we do not
[1:22:06] benefit the city taxpayers or
[1:22:10] our employees.
[1:22:11] The studies have shown
[1:22:11] the studies have not proven you
[1:22:15] with real opportunities costs
[1:22:16] for what is needed to actually
[1:22:20] manage this reliably utility
[1:22:21] and keep it keep the lights on
[1:22:23] 24 hours.
[1:22:25] Nor does it address the costs
[1:22:27] needed for worker safety
[1:22:29] working in highly highly
[1:22:30] skilled working workforce,
[1:22:31] skilled workforce and
[1:22:33] competitive wages and benefits
[1:22:34] and construction expertise in
[1:22:37] building and maintaining
[1:22:38] the grid and pipelines in San
[1:22:40] Diego.
[1:22:41] We don't believe this business
[1:22:42] is served in the cities.
[1:22:46] >> Good interest of doing this
[1:22:50] >> We asked the council to
[1:22:51] direct their time and resources
[1:22:53] in delivering the city
[1:22:53] services.
[1:22:55] >> Thank you Mayor Because
[1:22:58] Greensky while Matt approaches
[1:22:59] the microphone could make a
[1:23:02] erroneous Britney says Rihanna
[1:23:06] barrel Bill Powers and
[1:23:08] allegedly Audra please come to
[1:23:10] the front row.
[1:23:11] Please begin.
[1:23:13] Good afternoon council members.
[1:23:15] My name is Max Stransky I'm
[1:23:17] speaking We have today of acp
[1:23:18] Local 127 the dedicated city
[1:23:20] workers who keeps an you
[1:23:22] running as you know local 127
[1:23:24] represents the hardworking
[1:23:25] employees of our maintenance
[1:23:27] labor skilled trades and
[1:23:29] equipment operators and so
[1:23:30] forth.
[1:23:31] Our members are on the front
[1:23:32] frontlines serving the city
[1:23:33] every single day and their
[1:23:35] stability is our top priority.
[1:23:37] It is our concern that that's
[1:23:39] stability and the fiscal health
[1:23:41] of our city that local 127 must
[1:23:43] express its continued objection
[1:23:46] regarding public power.
[1:23:47] We have met with the proponents
[1:23:49] to express the same concerns to
[1:23:51] them.
[1:23:52] While we understand the desire
[1:23:53] to explore alternative models,
[1:23:54] we believe this current
[1:23:55] proposal presents too many
[1:23:57] unresolved risks.
[1:23:58] One lack of consensus This
[1:24:00] initiative has come before
[1:24:01] the council multiple times and
[1:24:04] has struggled to find viable
[1:24:04] path forward Demonstrating
[1:24:06] the community and leadership
[1:24:07] remained deeply divided on this
[1:24:09] issue.
[1:24:11] Workforce uncertainty The Phase
[1:24:12] two report does not provide
[1:24:14] the concrete assurances.
[1:24:15] >> Thank you.
[1:24:16] That does conclude your time.
[1:24:21] Mark o'Brien is Good afternoon
[1:24:21] Council My name is Mark o'Brien
[1:24:23] is political director of
[1:24:24] the San Diego and Imperial
[1:24:25] County Labor Council.
[1:24:26] We're proud to represent over
[1:24:26] 100 unions and 200,000 working
[1:24:28] families including our brothers
[1:24:30] and sisters in ibew 46 five and
[1:24:32] we're here standing with them
[1:24:34] in efforts to oppose them in
[1:24:35] its opposition to this power
[1:24:36] company.
[1:24:36] We know the struggles of our
[1:24:38] members to make it in San Diego
[1:24:39] right now and we know that
[1:24:40] consumers are paying the same
[1:24:41] thing.
[1:24:42] But we also know that right now
[1:24:43] our city resources are
[1:24:44] stretched very, very thin and
[1:24:46] now is not the time to risk
[1:24:47] those limited resources on
[1:24:50] the utility take.
[1:24:50] Workers could lose their
[1:24:51] pensions and retirement and
[1:24:52] the hard fought benefits.
[1:24:54] We stand with the hundreds of
[1:24:55] workers that could lose these
[1:24:56] benefits.
[1:24:56] Please don't gamble with their
[1:24:57] jobs.
[1:24:58] We have bigger priorities and
[1:24:59] we thank you for your support.
[1:25:03] >> Thank you.
[1:25:03] Thank you.
[1:25:07] Britney says hi.
[1:25:07] Good afternoon council members.
[1:25:08] Thank you so much for the time
[1:25:09] to comment on this today.
[1:25:11] Like many others here, we have
[1:25:13] serious concerns with this
[1:25:14] study in particular it doesn't
[1:25:17] answer the critical question of
[1:25:19] how much will it actually cost
[1:25:21] to purchase the assets of
[1:25:23] the utility.
[1:25:24] First off, the report gives you
[1:25:26] a range of between 2 and 2 and
[1:25:27] a half and $7.5 billion a huge
[1:25:30] range.
[1:25:31] The cost to just purchase
[1:25:33] the assets is $9.3 billion.
[1:25:36] The study also omits some key
[1:25:38] costs including the cost to
[1:25:41] make our remaining customers
[1:25:42] whole.
[1:25:43] If the city were to leave
[1:25:45] the surrounding cities and
[1:25:46] unincorporated county would see
[1:25:48] an increase in their rates.
[1:25:50] There is precedent that says
[1:25:52] that the city would need to
[1:25:53] make sure that that does not
[1:25:54] happen so there would be an
[1:25:55] exit fee of billions of dollars
[1:25:58] Finally the city this study
[1:26:00] also isn't including
[1:26:01] the significant wildfire risk
[1:26:03] that is part of San Diego.
[1:26:05] It doesn't include
[1:26:06] the insurance costs or
[1:26:07] mitigation.
[1:26:08] Thank you very much.
[1:26:10] Thank you.
[1:26:12] Next speaker is Brianna Barrow.
[1:26:13] >> Good afternoon, council
[1:26:13] members.
[1:26:16] My name is Brianna Berman and
[1:26:18] local business owner and I also
[1:26:19] run a local nonprofit.
[1:26:20] So public power MAY be a good
[1:26:22] idea and it MAY also be a
[1:26:24] costly idea.
[1:26:24] Both things can be true.
[1:26:26] My concern is not about
[1:26:27] protecting one institution over
[1:26:28] the other.
[1:26:29] My concern is about
[1:26:29] workability, accountability and
[1:26:31] integrity.
[1:26:32] If the city is going to pursue
[1:26:33] a public power model,
[1:26:34] the process must be
[1:26:34] transparent.
[1:26:36] The numbers must be complete
[1:26:37] and the public must understand
[1:26:39] exactly what they're being
[1:26:40] asked to carry as a ratepayer I
[1:26:42] want relief as a taxpayer.
[1:26:44] I want responsibility as a
[1:26:45] contractor.
[1:26:45] I want fair opportunity as a
[1:26:47] community centered business
[1:26:48] owner.
[1:26:48] I want solutions that did not
[1:26:50] leave the people with the least
[1:26:52] margin carrying the most risk
[1:26:54] at this time without a clear
[1:26:55] and definitive understanding of
[1:26:56] the full cost, the risk and
[1:26:58] the impact on city communities
[1:27:00] I cannot support moving forward
[1:27:01] with the municipal ization and
[1:27:02] I ask that you do not either.
[1:27:04] Thank you.
[1:27:05] Thank you.
[1:27:07] Bill Powers While Bill
[1:27:09] approaches the microphone could
[1:27:11] I have Mike Miller okay all
[1:27:15] the Monday Neil Winter John
[1:27:18] Mattis and Barbara Pinto
[1:27:21] approach the front row please
[1:27:23] begin Bill Powers Board Member,
[1:27:26] Public Power San Diego I'll
[1:27:28] start with Labor.
[1:27:29] The veteran utility workers
[1:27:31] will be key to the new
[1:27:32] utility's credibility Labor
[1:27:34] does need to have a seat on
[1:27:35] the utilities governing board.
[1:27:37] Labor also needs to be a part
[1:27:39] of the blue ribbon panel that
[1:27:40] selects the critical initial
[1:27:41] governing board with the die
[1:27:43] gets cast.
[1:27:45] New Jersey's first public power
[1:27:47] study for the city was in 2020.
[1:27:49] That study only looked at
[1:27:50] distribution a distribution
[1:27:51] only utility low voltage.
[1:27:53] It did not look at transmission
[1:27:54] and distribution phase one and
[1:27:57] phase two that only at&t at&t
[1:28:00] utility would be completely
[1:28:01] contained within the city's
[1:28:02] boundaries.
[1:28:04] Crossing jurisdictional
[1:28:05] boundaries would trigger Lasko
[1:28:06] review that would occur six
[1:28:08] years to the implementation
[1:28:09] schedule That would be a
[1:28:11] momentum killer for public
[1:28:13] power.
[1:28:13] In San Diego we obtained a
[1:28:16] Phase two financial model
[1:28:17] through a Public Records Act
[1:28:18] request New Dennis set
[1:28:20] the model up so you can click a
[1:28:22] button and look at a
[1:28:22] distribution only structure.
[1:28:24] >> There is no more work to do
[1:28:25] to assess distribution.
[1:28:27] >> That is the way to go.
[1:28:28] Thank you.
[1:28:29] Thank you.
[1:28:31] Next speakers allegedly Audra
[1:28:42] Yeah so I mean as dg any roms
[1:28:45] Peter to pay Paul but so do you
[1:28:47] guys and so that's what's
[1:28:49] concerning about this going
[1:28:50] into your hands especially when
[1:28:52] you talk about savings and that
[1:28:54] not really being feasible of
[1:28:55] course not because sd g and e
[1:28:58] is aggressively opposed to you
[1:29:01] guys doing this So this will
[1:29:02] end up in litigation So it will
[1:29:05] cost the people more than
[1:29:07] the billions of dollars that
[1:29:08] you are you know, talking about
[1:29:10] here And I mean with the storm
[1:29:12] infrastructure needing $5
[1:29:13] billion, it's like how many
[1:29:15] billions of dollars do you guys
[1:29:17] need in order to provide
[1:29:19] the things?
[1:29:19] But again, you can't be trusted
[1:29:21] with this type of thing when
[1:29:22] you are not good stewards of
[1:29:25] our money and when this is
[1:29:26] going to be something that is
[1:29:28] San Diego community power is
[1:29:30] engaged with when they're
[1:29:31] talking about keeping data
[1:29:33] centers on and having
[1:29:34] the public in the community not
[1:29:37] have power during that time
[1:29:38] that is extremely egregious and
[1:29:40] people need to pay attention to
[1:29:41] that because there's meetings
[1:29:42] that are talking about it.
[1:29:43] >> Thank you.
[1:29:46] Next speaker is Mike Miller.
[1:29:52] >> Good afternoon counsel.
[1:29:55] The more we learn about Jionni
[1:29:57] the more appalled I am at
[1:29:57] the amount of corporate greed
[1:29:58] that goes on that organization.
[1:30:00] Their average profit for
[1:30:02] the last four years is over
[1:30:04] $800 million and their parent
[1:30:06] company also spends nearly $300
[1:30:08] million annually in campaign
[1:30:10] donations and lobbying and
[1:30:12] counting on $2,000 to Donald
[1:30:13] Trump's inauguration last year
[1:30:17] Obviously there are a lot of
[1:30:19] questions and things that need
[1:30:20] to be figured out before this
[1:30:21] goes into place and it's
[1:30:24] obviously an informational item
[1:30:25] and I'm grateful you're taking
[1:30:27] the time to consider it and I
[1:30:28] hope that you consider to look
[1:30:30] at it more because personally I
[1:30:33] just can't imagine what I would
[1:30:34] do with an excess amount of
[1:30:37] even $1 million every year And
[1:30:38] I'm sure there's a better way
[1:30:39] that we can find to use that
[1:30:42] money to help the people of San
[1:30:43] Diego.
[1:30:43] >> Thank you.
[1:30:47] Thank you.
[1:30:48] Gail via Marty Well Gail comes
[1:30:50] to the microphone.
[1:30:52] You do have time ceded to you
[1:30:54] by Neil Winter.
[1:30:56] Neil can you raise your hand?
[1:30:57] Okay.
[1:30:57] Thank you.
[1:30:58] You will have two minutes.
[1:30:59] Thank you.
[1:31:00] My name is Gail b one time a
[1:31:02] proud resident of District nine
[1:31:03] and I'm also the chair of
[1:31:05] the board of directors of
[1:31:06] Public Power San Diego.
[1:31:07] And I'd like to make an
[1:31:09] important distinction here.
[1:31:11] There's a difference between a
[1:31:14] nonprofit public utility versus
[1:31:16] a for profit investor owned
[1:31:18] utility.
[1:31:18] And the definition of municipal
[1:31:23] as a nonprofit public utility
[1:31:24] does not have to be quote run
[1:31:26] by the city.
[1:31:27] So you can all kind of public
[1:31:29] thank GOD because there are
[1:31:33] challenges but there are cities
[1:31:36] this has been something that
[1:31:37] has been done for 100 years.
[1:31:39] All right.
[1:31:40] And it's been done in over 40
[1:31:43] cities in California including
[1:31:46] Sacramento, by the way they do
[1:31:49] it And on the average they have
[1:31:51] half the rates we do And better
[1:31:54] reliability.
[1:31:55] So I think that's one key
[1:31:57] point.
[1:31:57] I just like to leave you with
[1:31:59] the other point is our union
[1:32:01] brothers and sisters, they
[1:32:03] deserve to have certainly their
[1:32:05] benefits, their compensation,
[1:32:07] their seniority, all of that
[1:32:09] protected.
[1:32:09] I don't think that was really
[1:32:11] part of the study.
[1:32:12] I mean I don't think it was
[1:32:15] meant to be part of the study
[1:32:16] but that's certainly part of
[1:32:18] any conversation I have
[1:32:20] personally been involved with.
[1:32:22] They talked about the possible
[1:32:24] future of a nonprofit utility.
[1:32:26] In fact, public utilities have
[1:32:28] 80 to 90% unionization rate
[1:32:31] whereas private utilities have
[1:32:34] I guess what, a 30%
[1:32:37] unionization rate.
[1:32:38] All right.
[1:32:40] So there's a really big
[1:32:41] difference.
[1:32:41] So the unions would benefit And
[1:32:43] I know that you know you have a
[1:32:45] contract with sd g and that
[1:32:47] precludes certain conversations
[1:32:49] but you would benefit union
[1:32:53] members would benefit both in
[1:32:55] terms of their families and
[1:32:56] their immediate costs and in
[1:32:58] terms of their status.
[1:32:59] No one is looking to change any
[1:33:02] of that.
[1:33:02] Thank you very much.
[1:33:03] Thank you.
[1:33:05] John Madison.
[1:33:07] Next, while John approaches
[1:33:09] the microphone, I would ask
[1:33:10] that Patricia Mendoza
[1:33:19] the ferryman, Adriana Cizik and
[1:33:21] Kevin Machado please approach
[1:33:23] the front row please me.
[1:33:27] >> John matters here.
[1:33:27] I'm here on the reality of
[1:33:30] the crisis facing the city of
[1:33:33] San Diego.
[1:33:33] Proudly you took the first step
[1:33:36] in a path forward.
[1:33:38] The crisis is one quarter of
[1:33:41] the people here in this city
[1:33:43] can't afford their bills.
[1:33:45] Wants to month they can't pay.
[1:33:50] If you ask the question why
[1:33:51] can't they?
[1:33:52] Is it because they have
[1:33:53] the highest rates in the state?
[1:33:55] Is it because they want another
[1:33:57] 8% rate increase?
[1:34:00] That's the reality.
[1:34:02] We have a powerful quote.
[1:34:04] We have a plan.
[1:34:06] We have a plan that saves your
[1:34:09] constituents tens of thousands
[1:34:11] of dollars.
[1:34:13] Help us get out of this crisis
[1:34:16] of unaffordability of a key
[1:34:19] component of our life here in
[1:34:21] San Diego.
[1:34:21] And that is our outrageous g&a
[1:34:23] rate.
[1:34:25] >> Thank you.
[1:34:26] Thank you.
[1:34:28] >> Barbara Pinto.
[1:34:31] Barbara, you do have time ceded
[1:34:36] to you by Isidora Lopez Magali.
[1:34:38] Can you raise your hand please?
[1:34:39] Thank you.
[1:34:40] And an okay.
[1:34:44] Ana Thank you.
[1:34:44] You have three minutes.
[1:34:45] Thank you.
[1:34:46] Good afternoon.
[1:34:48] My name is Barbara Pinto and
[1:34:50] I'm a resident of San Diego,
[1:34:51] the District 11 Loganathan and
[1:34:54] a member of eighth.
[1:34:55] I have been a resident since
[1:34:58] the 40s in San Diego and
[1:35:01] selling gas and electric has
[1:35:03] been our only utility company
[1:35:04] So it is a monopoly on
[1:35:07] utilities provided since then
[1:35:09] and before Sandy Again we are
[1:35:11] paying the highest prices for
[1:35:14] homes rent, gas, food and
[1:35:18] utilities more almost than
[1:35:20] anyone in the nation.
[1:35:21] Our utility provider dictates
[1:35:24] cost increases services and
[1:35:27] sets no limit on their profits.
[1:35:29] Last year they made a whopping
[1:35:35] $563 million in profits and
[1:35:37] that figure was roughly one
[1:35:39] third lower than it was
[1:35:40] the previous year.
[1:35:41] I'm a senior citizen living on
[1:35:44] a fixed income of Social
[1:35:46] Security and a modest
[1:35:47] retirement.
[1:35:48] I went back to work around 2018
[1:35:51] to keep up with the cost of
[1:35:54] living and inflation.
[1:35:55] i lost my job due to covid.
[1:36:02] In 2021 I prioritize my rent
[1:36:02] and I got behind in my water my
[1:36:04] utility.
[1:36:05] My current utility bill is over
[1:36:06] $3,500.
[1:36:09] I enlisted in a debt
[1:36:11] forgiveness program and said
[1:36:14] they would work with me to
[1:36:15] forgive part of my debt.
[1:36:16] I agreed to pay $111 a month
[1:36:19] for 12 consecutive months but
[1:36:23] that cost changes according to
[1:36:26] my everyday usage.
[1:36:28] I wasn't told that the average
[1:36:31] monthly cost now is about $140
[1:36:33] a month.
[1:36:33] This is difficult when you're
[1:36:35] on a fixed income and you're
[1:36:37] trying to do a budget.
[1:36:38] Why is there no limit on what
[1:36:41] these companies can make in
[1:36:43] profits?
[1:36:43] Even with my return to work I
[1:36:47] am struggling.
[1:36:48] We need services offered at
[1:36:51] more affordable rates.
[1:36:53] We need more competitive
[1:36:55] companies putting people before
[1:36:58] profits.
[1:36:58] Thank you.
[1:36:59] >> Thank you.
[1:37:03] Next speaker is Patricia
[1:37:04] Mendoza.
[1:37:05] >> Hi, my name is Patrick and
[1:37:12] I'm a member of Ace Energy as a
[1:37:15] basic necessity that every
[1:37:16] family depends on.
[1:37:17] We need it to cook continue to
[1:37:20] cut meals, keep the lights on
[1:37:21] after dark, wash close to our
[1:37:23] children and have clean clothes
[1:37:24] to wear.
[1:37:25] Yet these high utility rates
[1:37:27] make everyday activities a
[1:37:29] source of stress, often forcing
[1:37:31] families to make difficult
[1:37:32] choices about the bills to pay
[1:37:34] and which bills to put off.
[1:37:36] It is especially troubling now
[1:37:37] that summer's here it's going
[1:37:39] to be more hot.
[1:37:40] People can't afford air
[1:37:41] conditioner.
[1:37:41] It's going to get colder
[1:37:43] weather outside.
[1:37:44] People can't afford adequate
[1:37:47] heating.
[1:37:48] But right now I also want to
[1:37:50] acknowledge all our brothers
[1:37:51] and sisters here in our union
[1:37:54] brothers and sisters here I
[1:37:55] heard it and I had another
[1:37:56] speech written But I want to
[1:37:58] hear you guys to I want to put
[1:38:00] their voice out there too
[1:38:01] because we need public power.
[1:38:03] We really do.
[1:38:04] But it concerns on your
[1:38:07] concerns about job security.
[1:38:08] We do need public power and we
[1:38:11] need it not at the expense of
[1:38:12] other working class people,
[1:38:13] other working class jobs.
[1:38:15] Thank you.
[1:38:15] That does conclude your time.
[1:38:16] >> We can work together.
[1:38:19] We can Women I'm working.
[1:38:21] We can work together.
[1:38:22] We can work together.
[1:38:22] We're still talking about So
[1:38:25] they make their man work
[1:38:26] together to make this
[1:38:26] transition good.
[1:38:26] Okay.
[1:38:29] All all right.
[1:38:38] >> She set the tone.
[1:38:39] We're not going to do that
[1:38:40] again.
[1:38:40] Okay?
[1:38:41] We're going to keep this
[1:38:41] simple.
[1:38:42] You guys have been fantastic.
[1:38:43] So I'm passionate on both
[1:38:45] sides.
[1:38:46] I've been clear and unambiguous
[1:38:48] but let's have a good civil
[1:38:52] dialog Now you have three
[1:38:53] people sitting your time When I
[1:38:55] call your name please raise
[1:38:56] your hand to confirm your year
[1:39:01] And above all is honor.
[1:39:07] Thank you Gary Carter.
[1:39:08] Gary Clark.
[1:39:08] Corey of Corey.
[1:39:09] Sorry.
[1:39:09] Thank you.
[1:39:10] Oscar Gomez Junior.
[1:39:11] Thank you.
[1:39:14] Your four minutes please begin.
[1:39:15] Good afternoon, Council members
[1:39:17] and city staff.
[1:39:18] My name is Nate Berryman,
[1:39:19] business manager of
[1:39:20] the International Brotherhood
[1:39:21] of Electrical Workers Local
[1:39:22] Union for 65 I represent 2900
[1:39:26] union utility workers here in
[1:39:27] San Diego and several counties.
[1:39:28] And look, I know why we're
[1:39:31] really here.
[1:39:31] People are not happy with
[1:39:34] energy.
[1:39:34] They're not happy with their
[1:39:35] rates or their skyrocketing
[1:39:37] profits.
[1:39:38] People are mad at the never
[1:39:39] ending corporate profits that
[1:39:40] are pulled from our pockets and
[1:39:42] funneled to separate
[1:39:43] shareholders And to be 100%
[1:39:45] honest my members are meant to
[1:39:47] Our members have more in common
[1:39:49] with you in this room than
[1:39:50] utility CEOs or executives.
[1:39:52] Working class people are
[1:39:54] struggling.
[1:39:54] They're struggling to get by
[1:39:56] and something needs to be done
[1:39:57] to provide support.
[1:39:58] But I promise you brothers and
[1:40:00] sisters, this ain't it.
[1:40:02] Our union and our members share
[1:40:03] a mutual interest in the city's
[1:40:05] success and the success of our
[1:40:06] communities success of our
[1:40:08] mayor, our council and
[1:40:10] the utility who's delivering
[1:40:11] these essential services to San
[1:40:14] Diego's municipal division is
[1:40:15] bad for everyone.
[1:40:16] It will not solve for
[1:40:18] affordability.
[1:40:19] It will destroy our union
[1:40:20] contracts and force layoffs of
[1:40:22] union workers.
[1:40:23] Each phase of the new study
[1:40:24] continues to diminish or ignore
[1:40:26] addressing worker protections
[1:40:27] and safety the fire risk and
[1:40:29] liability the city would assume
[1:40:31] under urban exploitation and
[1:40:33] the occurred that the city
[1:40:34] would force to be take on with
[1:40:36] this effort High voltage
[1:40:37] infrastructure demand
[1:40:38] significant investment and
[1:40:40] the operating continue
[1:40:42] The operating costs continue to
[1:40:43] be significantly
[1:40:43] underestimated.
[1:40:45] There's no guarantee that
[1:40:46] the infrastructure the city
[1:40:47] purchases will be maintained
[1:40:48] sufficiently To keep my members
[1:40:50] safe I was in these chambers
[1:40:52] just weeks ago when you were
[1:40:53] debating closing public
[1:40:54] bathrooms in order to close a
[1:40:56] $175 million budget deficit.
[1:40:59] What happens when you have a
[1:41:01] budget deficit but now you run
[1:41:02] the power company.
[1:41:03] You can't just shut down a
[1:41:05] substation.
[1:41:05] You can't just turn the lights
[1:41:06] off to save money or limit
[1:41:08] the hours that you provide.
[1:41:09] Electric service like the grid
[1:41:11] is a public library You can't
[1:41:13] balance the budget by robbing
[1:41:14] resources from grid maintenance
[1:41:16] or pole replacement.
[1:41:17] If you do that you might have
[1:41:18] mass outages, blackouts and
[1:41:20] wildfires.
[1:41:21] So where's the real cost
[1:41:22] associated with the fire risk
[1:41:24] and liability?
[1:41:25] Where's the real numbers on
[1:41:26] the billions dollars of debt
[1:41:27] the city and our taxpayers will
[1:41:29] carry for decades?
[1:41:31] Each phase of the Nugent study
[1:41:32] has not provided you or our
[1:41:34] taxpayers with an accurate
[1:41:36] picture of that risk of
[1:41:38] the cost of the liability and
[1:41:40] the risk the city will be
[1:41:41] undertaking to municipal lies.
[1:41:44] It's a lot It's $9 billion, $9
[1:41:47] billion at a time where
[1:41:48] the city is laying off workers
[1:41:51] when the city is closing
[1:41:52] bathrooms, the city is
[1:41:54] defunding the bomb squad and
[1:41:56] relying on donations to keep
[1:41:57] your arts programs alive.
[1:41:59] You just cut $7 million from
[1:42:01] your own Climate Action Fund.
[1:42:03] You don't have the money You
[1:42:05] don't have the resources and
[1:42:07] you don't have the expertise.
[1:42:08] So we're asking you to please
[1:42:10] not do this.
[1:42:12] But I will end with this If
[1:42:15] city genie doesn't offer
[1:42:16] immediate rate relief to our
[1:42:18] communities most at need, we
[1:42:22] will be back here having
[1:42:23] the same presentation with
[1:42:25] the same advocacy and the same
[1:42:26] level of frustration
[1:42:28] The utility affordability
[1:42:29] crisis isn't going away until
[1:42:32] we sit down with honesty and
[1:42:33] empathy for our communities
[1:42:35] that are struggling.
[1:42:36] I fear the cycle will continue
[1:42:39] and the ibew stands ready and
[1:42:40] willing to have that
[1:42:41] conversation.
[1:42:43] >> Thank you very much.
[1:42:47] Thank you and Speaker lady And
[1:42:51] if you think you could approach
[1:42:51] the microphone, you have
[1:42:54] several speakers seating time
[1:42:55] to you.
[1:42:56] Matthew Pendergrast, thank you
[1:43:00] Randall and Driver thank you.
[1:43:10] As an uncommon husband no, no.
[1:43:10] Okay.
[1:43:11] You will have a total of three
[1:43:13] minutes then.
[1:43:15] Okay.
[1:43:16] Thank you so much for having
[1:43:17] me.
[1:43:17] I'm DR. Adrian Cusick.
[1:43:19] I live in District three.
[1:43:20] I served in the us Peace Corps
[1:43:21] and I'm a member of cfa which
[1:43:23] is a California faculty
[1:43:24] association.
[1:43:26] I teach environmental science
[1:43:27] and sustainability sdsu My
[1:43:29] students are bright, they're
[1:43:31] motivated, they're innovative.
[1:43:33] They get out there and gain
[1:43:34] work experience.
[1:43:35] Unfortunately they're learning
[1:43:37] about the injustices that are
[1:43:39] deeply embedded in our systems
[1:43:41] and structures.
[1:43:42] The sad reality that a utility
[1:43:44] company is a monopoly
[1:43:45] extracting wealth from
[1:43:47] the community to transfer it to
[1:43:49] its already wealthy CEOs and
[1:43:51] shareholders is an example of
[1:43:53] environmental and social
[1:43:55] injustices that we've been
[1:43:56] forced to live with This system
[1:43:59] under the investor owned
[1:44:00] utility makes life harder for
[1:44:01] the average than Diegan and it
[1:44:03] stifles innovation and
[1:44:05] progress.
[1:44:06] But there's a better way.
[1:44:08] The Phase two public power
[1:44:09] study clearly demonstrates that
[1:44:11] it's financially, technically
[1:44:12] and operationally feasible to
[1:44:14] transition to a nonprofit
[1:44:16] publicly owned utility.
[1:44:18] The study focused on different
[1:44:19] variations on one specific
[1:44:22] scenario for acquiring
[1:44:23] the grid.
[1:44:24] It demonstrated that public
[1:44:25] power will work in San Diego.
[1:44:27] And it also demonstrated that
[1:44:29] public power will be good for
[1:44:31] San Diegans not only
[1:44:32] financially but public power
[1:44:34] would turn decision making over
[1:44:35] to us the people who live here
[1:44:37] and are impacted by local
[1:44:39] energy decisions not
[1:44:40] shareholders who probably
[1:44:42] couldn't care less about
[1:44:43] the struggles of everyday San
[1:44:47] Diego's public power have been
[1:44:47] successful in other cities So
[1:44:48] it makes sense It would be
[1:44:50] successful here where we pay
[1:44:51] the highest electricity rates
[1:44:53] in the continental United
[1:44:54] States.
[1:44:55] It's important to remember that
[1:44:56] the phase two study is a
[1:44:58] baseline and it shows that it's
[1:45:00] possible We don't need to have
[1:45:02] every single technical detail
[1:45:03] worked out right now.
[1:45:04] But what we do need to do is
[1:45:06] commit to making action to
[1:45:08] making it happen.
[1:45:10] As local owners of the grid we
[1:45:11] can determine what works best
[1:45:13] for us.
[1:45:14] We can ensure that Labor
[1:45:15] remains whole and has agreement
[1:45:17] agreements to ensure that
[1:45:19] people operating the system are
[1:45:21] involved in the decisions that
[1:45:22] impact them.
[1:45:23] We can tailor the scale of
[1:45:24] the infrastructure and we can
[1:45:26] explore different different
[1:45:27] governance models.
[1:45:29] We can trade the status quo for
[1:45:31] low energy costs and local
[1:45:33] control.
[1:45:33] Imagine what that would do for
[1:45:35] our city.
[1:45:36] Lower energy costs are key to
[1:45:37] economic growth Cutting
[1:45:38] emissions, reducing
[1:45:40] inequalities and spurring
[1:45:41] innovation.
[1:45:43] So once we're out from under
[1:45:45] the thumb of Sempra we could be
[1:45:46] a model of community
[1:45:47] resilience.
[1:45:48] We could have virtual power
[1:45:50] plants bi directional charging,
[1:45:52] microgrids, agile and proactive
[1:45:54] technology to mitigate growing
[1:45:56] climate risks.
[1:45:57] We could decide if and where
[1:45:59] data centers enter our city.
[1:46:01] Ultimately we have the power
[1:46:03] now to commit to transitioning
[1:46:05] to public power.
[1:46:06] And when we do, every aspect of
[1:46:08] that transition will be under
[1:46:10] our local control.
[1:46:11] And like my students, we have
[1:46:13] the imagination, the creativity
[1:46:16] to create something really
[1:46:18] wonderful that can serve us
[1:46:19] all.
[1:46:24] >> Thank you for your comments.
[1:46:25] That does conclude your time.
[1:46:25] Next speaker is Kevin Machado
[1:46:25] or Kevin approaches
[1:46:26] the microphone.
[1:46:27] I would ask Will Smith, Kevin
[1:46:30] Zavala Rachel Kiss Lane Range
[1:46:31] shot Sharon.
[1:46:40] Sorry if I said that in part
[1:46:42] Troutman too.
[1:46:42] Please come to the front row.
[1:46:44] Kevin please begin.
[1:46:45] Hello, my name is Kevin and I'm
[1:46:47] a worker here in San Diego.
[1:46:49] Working family The San Diego
[1:46:50] are tired of the cost of living
[1:46:51] going up as the union has
[1:46:53] consistently raised rates in
[1:46:54] the past decade as the union
[1:46:56] has raised rates on average 7%
[1:46:58] per year.
[1:46:59] They're taking $1 billion from
[1:47:00] us every year and doing nothing
[1:47:02] for our communities.
[1:47:03] That money could go to San
[1:47:04] Diego schools and the library
[1:47:05] San Diego workers and San Diego
[1:47:07] infrastructure as the union
[1:47:10] wants more more money for their
[1:47:10] owners And Wall Street at
[1:47:13] the city's profits this quarter
[1:47:14] is $290 million and they're
[1:47:17] likely to break a million in
[1:47:18] profit this year.
[1:47:18] And regardless of that, they
[1:47:20] still are proposing another
[1:47:21] $280 million more every year.
[1:47:24] If we don't act now, another
[1:47:26] decade will pass and San Diego
[1:47:27] will still be struggling with
[1:47:29] the cost of living.
[1:47:30] We have the opportunity to
[1:47:31] change that now la Power will
[1:47:33] lower the cost of electricity
[1:47:34] for generations.
[1:47:35] The feasibility study will will
[1:47:37] save money.
[1:47:38] It will work here.
[1:47:39] It's worked everywhere else
[1:47:40] They've tried it.
[1:47:43] The minimum the minimum
[1:47:43] position in Sacramento has been
[1:47:44] complete success.
[1:47:45] They pay half of what we're
[1:47:46] paying the council to be brave
[1:47:48] and act And I thank you for
[1:47:49] your time.
[1:47:50] Thank you.
[1:47:52] Well Smith you do have indoor
[1:47:56] seating your time.
[1:47:57] Andrew, could you raise your
[1:47:58] hand, please?
[1:47:59] Thank you.
[1:48:00] You'll have two minutes.
[1:48:01] Good afternoon, Council.
[1:48:03] My name is Will and I live in
[1:48:04] District five.
[1:48:05] Over the last few years I have
[1:48:07] moved around San Diego several
[1:48:08] times.
[1:48:09] Every neighborhood has been
[1:48:10] different but in each one of
[1:48:12] them life keeps getting more
[1:48:13] expensive.
[1:48:14] Like many people in my
[1:48:15] generation I already worry
[1:48:16] about the cost of rent,
[1:48:18] groceries, gas and health care.
[1:48:21] But when bills used to go up no
[1:48:22] matter what I do.
[1:48:23] Electricity.
[1:48:24] Recently I was fortunate enough
[1:48:26] to move somewhere with solar
[1:48:27] panels.
[1:48:28] I thought I would finally get
[1:48:29] some relief.
[1:48:30] Instead I watched as Jeannie
[1:48:32] continued to make decisions
[1:48:33] that made it harder for
[1:48:34] ordinary people to lower their
[1:48:36] bills.
[1:48:37] It feels like no matter what we
[1:48:38] do the system is designed so
[1:48:40] that the shareholders win.
[1:48:41] And working families pay
[1:48:43] the price.
[1:48:44] We don't want to keep having to
[1:48:45] choose between keeping our
[1:48:46] lights on and putting food on
[1:48:48] the table.
[1:48:50] Beyond affordability, I've also
[1:48:51] seen the consequences of
[1:48:53] failure to properly maintain
[1:48:54] its infrastructure.
[1:48:55] Wildfires fueled by neglected
[1:48:57] infrastructure threaten our
[1:48:58] communities, our environment
[1:48:59] and the places that make San
[1:49:00] Diego special.
[1:49:02] I want future generations to be
[1:49:03] able to enjoy our parks, open
[1:49:05] spaces and beaches without
[1:49:06] being under the constant threat
[1:49:08] of very preventable disasters.
[1:49:10] That is why I am here today in
[1:49:11] support of public power.
[1:49:13] I want a utility that answers
[1:49:14] to the people of San Diego not
[1:49:15] investors.
[1:49:16] I want money we spend on
[1:49:18] electricity to stay in our
[1:49:19] community and be invested in
[1:49:20] reliability, clean energy and
[1:49:22] affordability.
[1:49:23] Most of all, I want future
[1:49:24] generations of San Diego owners
[1:49:25] to be able to afford to live in
[1:49:26] the city they call home.
[1:49:28] Council These issues affect
[1:49:30] real people, real families and
[1:49:32] real voters.
[1:49:33] Today you have a choice Stand
[1:49:35] with San Diego and struggling
[1:49:36] to afford an essential service
[1:49:38] or stand with a monopoly that
[1:49:40] continues to raise rates while
[1:49:41] posting record profits off
[1:49:43] the backs of working class
[1:49:44] families.
[1:49:45] The voters of the city will
[1:49:46] remember that choice.
[1:49:48] I urge you to move forward with
[1:49:49] sd Public Power.
[1:49:50] >> Thank you.
[1:49:52] Thank you.
[1:49:52] Kevin Zavala.
[1:49:56] >> You have time ceded to you
[1:49:57] by Robert Freedman Could you
[1:49:59] raise your hand please?
[1:49:59] >> Thank you.
[1:50:00] You'll have two minutes.
[1:50:02] Good afternoon.
[1:50:03] My name is Kevin Zavala, Marine
[1:50:05] Corps veteran and a District
[1:50:06] four constituent.
[1:50:07] Over the last decade, genius
[1:50:09] driven electricity rates up by
[1:50:11] more than 80% far outpacing
[1:50:13] inflation and leaving San Diego
[1:50:14] residents with the same with
[1:50:16] some of the highest utility
[1:50:17] bills in the nation.
[1:50:18] We're told these increases are
[1:50:19] unavoidable but what are
[1:50:20] the facts?
[1:50:21] After the devastating 2007 San
[1:50:23] Diego wildfires, the us Supreme
[1:50:25] Court ruled that the genie
[1:50:27] could not pass $379 million in
[1:50:29] fire related litigation costs
[1:50:31] to ratepayers because
[1:50:32] the damage was caused by
[1:50:33] the utility's poor maintained
[1:50:34] equipment.
[1:50:35] Shareholders, not customers
[1:50:36] were required to bear those
[1:50:38] costs.
[1:50:38] However, Genie later exploited
[1:50:40] a legal loophole while barred
[1:50:42] from charging customers for
[1:50:43] past damages.
[1:50:44] The company successfully
[1:50:45] shifted 100% of its ongoing
[1:50:47] wildfire mitigation and
[1:50:48] infrastructure hardening costs
[1:50:49] onto ratepayers.
[1:50:50] As a result, customers are
[1:50:52] paying billions to repair and
[1:50:54] upgrade infrastructure that
[1:50:55] the utility neglected for
[1:50:56] years.
[1:50:57] This is the consequence of a
[1:50:58] private monopoly accountable to
[1:51:00] investors rather than
[1:51:01] the public it serves.
[1:51:02] In response, public power San
[1:51:04] Diego is working to establish a
[1:51:05] publicly owned utility that
[1:51:07] will prioritize affordability,
[1:51:08] transparency and local control.
[1:51:10] Public records show sgi has
[1:51:12] spent millions on lobbying and
[1:51:14] political influence efforts to
[1:51:15] block public power proposals
[1:51:17] and protect its monopoly.
[1:51:18] The choice is clear continue
[1:51:20] accepting more rate hikes or
[1:51:22] support a public power future
[1:51:23] that puts the people first.
[1:51:24] >> Thank you Rachel Kiss.
[1:51:29] You have time ceded to you by
[1:51:32] Dale Holmberg.
[1:51:32] Thank you.
[1:51:34] Good afternoon.
[1:51:35] My name is Rachel Kiss.
[1:51:36] I'm a San Diego resident, a
[1:51:38] mother of three young children,
[1:51:39] a homeowner and a small
[1:51:41] business owner.
[1:51:41] Like many families, we've made
[1:51:43] sacrifices over the last few
[1:51:44] years as the cost of living
[1:51:46] continues to rise.
[1:51:47] We budget carefully.
[1:51:48] We compare prices.
[1:51:50] We make difficult decisions
[1:51:51] about where our money goes.
[1:51:52] What's frustrating is that
[1:51:54] while families are expected to
[1:51:55] tighten their belts as Jeannie
[1:51:57] continues to come back asking
[1:51:59] for more, how much is enough?
[1:52:02] Electricity is not a luxury.
[1:52:04] It's a necessity.
[1:52:05] Families need to keep food cold
[1:52:07] home safe and children
[1:52:08] comfortable.
[1:52:09] Small businesses need to
[1:52:10] survive.
[1:52:11] Yet we're paying some of
[1:52:12] the highest energy rates in
[1:52:13] the country with especially
[1:52:15] concerning is that more and
[1:52:17] more of these costs are being
[1:52:18] shifted into fixed charges.
[1:52:19] Whether someone lives in a
[1:52:20] small apartment and edu or a
[1:52:23] large home whether they can
[1:52:24] serve energy or not, they're
[1:52:26] being asked to pay more.
[1:52:27] Families are being told to use
[1:52:29] less energy while
[1:52:30] simultaneously being charged
[1:52:32] speeds that they cannot
[1:52:32] control.
[1:52:33] That undermines both
[1:52:34] affordability and conservation.
[1:52:36] Today isn't just about a
[1:52:38] feasibility study.
[1:52:39] It's about accountability.
[1:52:41] It's about exploring whether
[1:52:42] there's a better path forward
[1:52:43] that puts residents before
[1:52:44] profits.
[1:52:46] I'm not here because I have all
[1:52:47] the answers.
[1:52:47] I'm here because I believe
[1:52:48] the people of San Diego deserve
[1:52:50] leaders who are willing to ask
[1:52:52] hard questions and seriously
[1:52:53] explore alternatives.
[1:52:55] When sd Jenny asks for another
[1:52:57] increase it's a line item on a
[1:52:59] spreadsheet.
[1:52:59] For families it's groceries,
[1:53:01] kids activities, savings and a
[1:53:04] peace of mind.
[1:53:05] Those costs are real and we're
[1:53:06] feeling them.
[1:53:07] Please seriously evaluate every
[1:53:09] option available to bring
[1:53:11] affordability, transparency and
[1:53:13] accountability back to our
[1:53:14] energy system.
[1:53:14] And please remember that behind
[1:53:16] every rate increase is a family
[1:53:18] trying to make their budget
[1:53:19] work.
[1:53:19] Thank you for your time.
[1:53:21] Thank you.
[1:53:22] Lane Sharman.
[1:53:25] When you have time ceded to you
[1:53:28] by Katherine Harrison and
[1:53:29] Katherine, raise your hand.
[1:53:30] Thank you.
[1:53:30] You'll have two minutes.
[1:53:38] Good afternoon, counsel.
[1:53:39] My name is Lane Sharman.
[1:53:41] I'm a fifth generation
[1:53:43] Californian and I'm also
[1:53:44] the proud founder and initiator
[1:53:46] of community choice aggregation
[1:53:48] in San Diego along with Bill
[1:53:50] Powers.
[1:53:51] We have public power in San
[1:53:53] Diego, don't we?
[1:53:55] We've had it since the Smart
[1:53:57] Energy Alliance was founded by
[1:53:59] Lisa hepner, your colleague.
[1:54:00] She did that because it was
[1:54:03] good for the city of Solana
[1:54:05] Beach.
[1:54:06] That tiny little city up north
[1:54:09] >> And why was it good for it?
[1:54:11] Because San Diego gas and
[1:54:13] electric then as now was taking
[1:54:16] advantage of every single
[1:54:19] ratepayer then and now.
[1:54:21] And I am asking you to please
[1:54:24] look at the big picture here.
[1:54:26] Your legacy, your future, your
[1:54:30] ability to lead and do what's
[1:54:33] good for this city is before
[1:54:36] you.
[1:54:36] And even though there is so
[1:54:39] much opposition, much of it is
[1:54:43] just fear.
[1:54:44] It is.
[1:54:45] And we all fear is the only
[1:54:48] thing that we have to fear
[1:54:50] right now.
[1:54:50] This is going to be great for
[1:54:53] unions.
[1:54:53] It's going to be great for
[1:54:55] the people of San Diego.
[1:54:56] It's going to be good for our
[1:54:59] future.
[1:55:00] So I just beg you to do what
[1:55:04] Lisa Huebner did in 2016.
[1:55:07] She wrote why it was good and
[1:55:11] she published it.
[1:55:12] Each one of you could do that
[1:55:14] and it would be an amazing way
[1:55:17] of clearly stating why this is
[1:55:20] good for San Diego because you
[1:55:22] will work through all of
[1:55:23] the issues including the fears
[1:55:25] and I just want to thank each
[1:55:28] and every one of you who takes
[1:55:29] that action and and dedicates
[1:55:33] themselves to the future of San
[1:55:35] Diego.
[1:55:35] Thank you.
[1:55:37] >> Thank you.
[1:55:39] Next speaker is Pak Troutman.
[1:55:42] While you approach
[1:55:43] the microphone I would ask that
[1:55:44] James Ferguson Diego Sandoval,
[1:55:47] Tyler Andre, Isaiah Glass and
[1:55:51] Allison Miller please approach
[1:55:53] the front row park.
[1:55:55] You have five people sitting
[1:55:57] time to you.
[1:56:00] Angela Haynes Thank you.
[1:56:01] Doris Wynn.
[1:56:03] Thank you.
[1:56:05] Michael Brack Me.
[1:56:07] Thank you.
[1:56:09] Janet o'Dea Thank you.
[1:56:12] Five minutes please.
[1:56:13] Please begin.
[1:56:14] Thank you.
[1:56:15] Good afternoon, Council members
[1:56:17] and Council PRESIDENT My name
[1:56:19] is Park Troutman.
[1:56:20] I am with San Diego 350 Well, I
[1:56:23] want to talk about is San Diego
[1:56:25] Gas Electric general rate case
[1:56:27] that was filed last week.
[1:56:29] The general rate case is a huge
[1:56:31] filing in which investor owned
[1:56:33] utility tries to convince
[1:56:35] the California Public Utilities
[1:56:37] Commission that they should be
[1:56:39] allowed to raise their rates
[1:56:40] over a four year block for 2028
[1:56:43] the first year of the 40 years
[1:56:46] of the rate increase request.
[1:56:51] As the genie asked permission
[1:56:52] to raise the residential
[1:56:54] electricity rates by about $14
[1:56:56] per month which is a little bit
[1:56:58] more than 7% and
[1:57:00] the residential gas rates by a
[1:57:03] little bit less than 850 per
[1:57:05] month which is about a 13%
[1:57:07] increase.
[1:57:08] The California Public Advocacy
[1:57:14] Office tracks acg genies rates
[1:57:15] versus inflation.
[1:57:16] They've done this since 2014.
[1:57:17] The cumulative impact of their
[1:57:21] increase in their rates more
[1:57:22] than inflation is that they
[1:57:23] have increased about triple
[1:57:25] inflation.
[1:57:28] This request for the general
[1:57:30] rate increase or the general
[1:57:32] rate case which is really
[1:57:33] the window into how they're
[1:57:34] thinking about the future is
[1:57:37] actually a little bit more than
[1:57:39] their average request for
[1:57:40] the since 2014 and they make a
[1:57:44] similar request in 2029 and in
[1:57:47] 2030 and 2031 they only request
[1:57:51] an increase of 5.5%.
[1:57:54] And keep in mind that these
[1:57:56] rate increases that are in
[1:58:00] the general rate case are
[1:58:03] merely the baseline of what
[1:58:05] they're asking for.
[1:58:07] Increasingly investor owned
[1:58:08] utilities are asking for rate
[1:58:10] increases outside of
[1:58:12] the general rate case so we can
[1:58:16] expect that they will keep
[1:58:18] continue to ask for more And
[1:58:19] these are through their
[1:58:20] balancing in memorandum
[1:58:22] accounts where they spend money
[1:58:23] and then say oh we already
[1:58:24] spent this money, could you get
[1:58:27] reimbursed by paying or
[1:58:29] charging rate payers more?
[1:58:31] So this let the audacity and
[1:58:34] compulsiveness of this sink in
[1:58:36] public anger at investor owned
[1:58:39] utilities has begun to affect
[1:58:40] the outcomes of elections
[1:58:43] nationwide and sd Genie which
[1:58:46] in a J.D. Power study excuse me
[1:58:50] a brand appeal of utilities in
[1:58:52] the Western us that they did
[1:58:53] last year sc Genie was 28 out
[1:58:57] of 30th near the absolute
[1:59:00] bottom because of their high
[1:59:01] rates They are so out of touch
[1:59:05] they are going to continue They
[1:59:06] are continuing to ask for more.
[1:59:10] The general rate case request
[1:59:13] is higher than the 4% that was
[1:59:15] the basis for the consultant's
[1:59:19] study and that was the main
[1:59:21] assumption for the phase two
[1:59:23] feasibility study There are
[1:59:23] consultants are constrained by
[1:59:25] the need to be reasonable as
[1:59:28] the genie apparently does not
[1:59:29] feel the same.
[1:59:31] This means that when we look at
[1:59:34] the impacts of the cumulative
[1:59:36] benefits I believe that Slide
[1:59:38] 11 we should be concentrating
[1:59:40] on the highest bar showing
[1:59:42] the highest possible savings
[1:59:48] because that is the most
[1:59:50] likely.
[1:59:50] We know this because Star Genie
[1:59:52] is telling us so they are going
[1:59:54] to continue to ask So what does
[1:59:57] this mean going forward?
[2:00:02] I was we are not going to if we
[2:00:03] know they're going to continue
[2:00:04] to ask for more rate increases.
[2:00:06] We're not going to be having
[2:00:06] the same conversation.
[2:00:08] We're not always coming back
[2:00:10] having the exact encounter.
[2:00:11] It's going to be worse.
[2:00:12] People will be more frustrated,
[2:00:13] Rates are going to be higher.
[2:00:15] We cannot sit our hands We
[2:00:17] cannot say wait to see what
[2:00:20] happens in San Francisco And
[2:00:22] these are not options.
[2:00:23] We need to keep moving forward.
[2:00:28] Star Genie The company will not
[2:00:29] stop itself.
[2:00:30] >> Thank you.
[2:00:33] Thank you.
[2:00:34] Our next speaker is James
[2:00:35] Ferguson.
[2:00:37] James, you have Deborah
[2:00:39] Winthrop or any time to you
[2:00:41] Deborah, can you raise your
[2:00:42] hand?
[2:00:43] >> Thank you.
[2:00:44] Two minutes.
[2:00:46] Thank you.
[2:00:48] My name is James and I live in
[2:00:50] North Park and I have been an
[2:00:54] advocate for climate issues and
[2:00:55] our energy systems for my
[2:00:57] entire adult life which is
[2:00:58] actually pretty long.
[2:00:59] I went to college in 1975 and
[2:01:02] that's where I took
[2:01:02] environmental science.
[2:01:04] I'm a retired naval officer and
[2:01:07] anesthesia provider and this
[2:01:09] has been a passion of mine for
[2:01:11] that long.
[2:01:12] I'm now Senate liaison for
[2:01:14] Citizens Climate Lobby and I
[2:01:16] must tell you that we're
[2:01:17] working on transmission issues
[2:01:19] this year with the federal
[2:01:21] government And I tell you that
[2:01:23] dependency model of early
[2:01:25] monopoly electronic electrical
[2:01:26] systems no longer serves as
[2:01:28] well as electrical demand will
[2:01:31] double or triple in the next 20
[2:01:32] years because of data centers
[2:01:34] electrification, reshoring of
[2:01:36] business etc. Favoring big
[2:01:40] distant production and long
[2:01:42] wires with cpu c guaranteeing
[2:01:45] double digit profits over
[2:01:47] whatever costs are incurred And
[2:01:52] it doesn't even have to try to
[2:01:53] economize.
[2:01:56] So they are incentivized to
[2:01:58] spend as much as possible
[2:01:59] because that's a percent above
[2:02:01] the cost that they incur while
[2:02:05] lack of profit incentives for
[2:02:08] upgrades and maintenance of
[2:02:09] the not very lucrative
[2:02:10] capacities of the local
[2:02:12] distribution grid is a failure
[2:02:14] to accommodate local generation
[2:02:16] and storage which we could do.
[2:02:18] We have a lot of available
[2:02:20] storage opportunities and in
[2:02:22] solar opportunities.
[2:02:23] But an sd Genie technician came
[2:02:26] to my house to explain to me
[2:02:27] why my 200 hour panel is crying
[2:02:30] and it's because he just said
[2:02:33] Well there's a lot of solar
[2:02:34] systems around here These old
[2:02:35] circuits just can't handle it.
[2:02:38] So we pay the highest rates in
[2:02:40] America in the continental
[2:02:42] states two times California
[2:02:44] average with three times
[2:02:45] the national average.
[2:02:47] Thank you.
[2:02:48] Thank you.
[2:02:50] Next speaker is D.A. Diego
[2:02:54] Sandoval.
[2:02:55] Do you have time to buy Ben
[2:02:56] Owens?
[2:02:58] Ben, could you raise your hand?
[2:02:59] Thank you.
[2:02:59] And Pamela Isaacs, thank you.
[2:03:02] You have three minutes.
[2:03:03] Please begin.
[2:03:04] Thank you.
[2:03:05] Good afternoon, City Council.
[2:03:07] My name is Diego Sandoval.
[2:03:08] I live in District eight and
[2:03:09] I'm here today to ask you to
[2:03:11] choose public power over
[2:03:12] the greed and power hungry
[2:03:16] genie as De Genie wants you to
[2:03:16] think that there is serious
[2:03:17] about what's doing best for our
[2:03:19] environment and people when in
[2:03:20] reality they're just doing
[2:03:22] what's best for their pockets
[2:03:23] so much so that they change
[2:03:25] the g in their logo to Green.
[2:03:28] Now it's green.
[2:03:29] How nice is that?
[2:03:32] And truth as the genie supports
[2:03:32] fighting climate change insofar
[2:03:34] as they can profit from it and
[2:03:35] households across San Diego are
[2:03:37] feeling that every month for a
[2:03:39] company committed to net zero
[2:03:41] they're still incredibly
[2:03:41] enthusiastic about fossil
[2:03:43] fuels.
[2:03:44] Ac Genie is owned by Sempra
[2:03:46] which has invested heavily in
[2:03:47] the transportation of what they
[2:03:49] euphemistically call natural
[2:03:50] gas.
[2:03:51] Natural gas is the most highly
[2:03:53] potent greenhouse gas methane.
[2:03:55] To quote the CHAIRMAN And ceo
[2:03:56] of Sempra from last month, they
[2:03:59] are very bullish on
[2:04:01] the liquefied natural gas trade
[2:04:02] long term This is not what you
[2:04:05] say when you're serious about
[2:04:06] net zero or what's doing best
[2:04:08] for the people or the climate
[2:04:10] that they depend on for a
[2:04:11] livable future.
[2:04:12] This corporations mentality of
[2:04:14] grasping what every book they
[2:04:16] can be seen is can be seen in
[2:04:20] their filing for their general
[2:04:21] rate case.
[2:04:22] They claim that they need to
[2:04:23] raise their rates for wildfire
[2:04:25] mitigation in the case of
[2:04:27] ongoing climate changes.
[2:04:29] Yet on the very same page they
[2:04:30] also say they want to raise
[2:04:31] rates to support
[2:04:33] the construction of new gas
[2:04:34] facilities.
[2:04:35] Does that make sense?
[2:04:36] They want us to pay more so
[2:04:38] that they can continue
[2:04:39] contributing to climate change
[2:04:41] then use climate change as
[2:04:43] justification for us paying
[2:04:45] more as the genie does not care
[2:04:47] about people or the environment
[2:04:49] they only care about profit not
[2:04:51] progress.
[2:04:52] San Diego can do better.
[2:04:54] This is why I asked for you to
[2:04:56] choose public power today but
[2:04:57] also to work with our union
[2:04:58] brothers and sisters to ensure
[2:05:00] that they are considered during
[2:05:01] this transition.
[2:05:02] To echo the opinions of a
[2:05:03] previous speaker we can do this
[2:05:05] together.
[2:05:05] >> Thank you.
[2:05:05] Yeah.
[2:05:08] Thank you.
[2:05:09] Next speaker is Tyler Andre.
[2:05:12] Tyler, you have several
[2:05:13] individuals setting your time.
[2:05:14] Cory Quite Lander.
[2:05:20] Thank you, Jackie Smith.
[2:05:21] Thank you, Fred And here.
[2:05:26] Thank you.
[2:05:28] Rhea Coleman.
[2:05:30] Thank you.
[2:05:31] You will have five minutes.
[2:05:32] Please begin.
[2:05:33] >> Good afternoon, Counsel.
[2:05:34] My name is Dre.
[2:05:35] I am a resident of District
[2:05:37] one, a Navy veteran and a small
[2:05:39] business owner as well as a
[2:05:40] proud volunteer with San Diego
[2:05:42] 350 and Public Power San Diego.
[2:05:45] >> Now why are so many people
[2:05:47] motivated to be here on a
[2:05:48] Monday afternoon?
[2:05:49] >> And why does Jeannie solicit
[2:05:51] curses from every San Diego who
[2:05:53] hears that name?
[2:05:55] It's because every single one
[2:05:56] of us has had that moment.
[2:05:58] The one where you open
[2:05:59] the billing up or the bill
[2:06:00] lands on the counter and you
[2:06:02] just stare at it.
[2:06:03] Maybe you reread the number
[2:06:05] like it'll change.
[2:06:06] It won't.
[2:06:07] In case you're wondering in
[2:06:08] fact don't look at it too many
[2:06:10] times because I'm going to
[2:06:10] charge you extra for that.
[2:06:12] >> And what's maddening is that
[2:06:14] we live in one of the sunniest
[2:06:15] city in the country.
[2:06:16] Solar is now the cheapest
[2:06:18] electricity on earth and we are
[2:06:20] still paying some of
[2:06:21] the highest electric rates in
[2:06:22] the continental United States.
[2:06:24] This is a broken arrangement
[2:06:26] created by an investor owned
[2:06:27] corporation.
[2:06:29] In fact here are the numbers.
[2:06:30] >> Straight from the cpu See?
[2:06:32] Since 2014 sd genius
[2:06:35] residential rates have gone up
[2:06:36] about 117% Inflation over that
[2:06:40] same period 39%.
[2:06:43] Sd Genius rates have grown
[2:06:44] three times faster than
[2:06:46] the cost of everything three
[2:06:48] times.
[2:06:50] Right now nearly one in five sd
[2:06:53] Genie households are behind on
[2:06:55] their bill.
[2:06:56] >> Owning an average owing an
[2:06:56] average of over $500.
[2:07:00] Those are our neighbors.
[2:07:02] That's multiple people in this
[2:07:03] room right now.
[2:07:05] >> And this doesn't stop at our
[2:07:06] electric bill.
[2:07:08] Local businesses pay these same
[2:07:09] rates and that cost gets built
[2:07:11] into the price of your coffee,
[2:07:13] your haircut, your kid's
[2:07:14] daycare.
[2:07:15] High electric rates are a
[2:07:17] hidden cost on every
[2:07:18] transaction in the city.
[2:07:19] >> Our water rates mtf also
[2:07:22] facing a deficit has to pay
[2:07:23] them too.
[2:07:24] So that's why we're here
[2:07:26] because we're tired of
[2:07:27] subsidizing a system that costs
[2:07:29] us three times more than it
[2:07:30] should in the one city in
[2:07:32] America with the least excuse
[2:07:34] for it.
[2:07:35] But here's what I'd like you to
[2:07:36] think about.
[2:07:37] >> This is the business model
[2:07:39] working exactly as designed.
[2:07:42] Sd Jeannie is a government
[2:07:43] granted monopoly.
[2:07:44] You can't shop around for your
[2:07:46] power and under California's
[2:07:48] regulatory system it doesn't
[2:07:49] make money by giving you
[2:07:51] cheaper or better power.
[2:07:52] It makes money by spending more
[2:07:54] on infrastructure because
[2:07:56] the state guarantees its
[2:07:57] shareholders a return of nearly
[2:07:59] 10% on every dollar that it
[2:08:01] spends.
[2:08:02] Not on outcomes but on
[2:08:04] spending.
[2:08:06] Sd Jeannie boasts up to $1
[2:08:07] billion in annual profits and
[2:08:09] that money comes from
[2:08:10] somewhere.
[2:08:11] It came from us.
[2:08:12] Yet they'll shut your power
[2:08:14] off.
[2:08:15] It is also why sd Jeannie
[2:08:18] doesn't celebrate when your
[2:08:18] neighbor puts solar panels on
[2:08:19] the roof.
[2:08:20] Solar that we the ratepayers
[2:08:22] pay for Personally under this
[2:08:25] business model your rooftop
[2:08:26] solar is a loss of revenue to
[2:08:28] them not a win for the grid.
[2:08:30] >> And sd Genies parent company
[2:08:32] Sempra is one of the largest
[2:08:34] builders of fossil fuel export
[2:08:35] infrastructure in the country.
[2:08:37] >> So while we MAY be doing our
[2:08:39] best to go green, the company
[2:08:40] taking our power bill is in
[2:08:43] other corners of its empire
[2:08:45] building out more fossil fuel
[2:08:46] infrastructure.
[2:08:47] And they protect this
[2:08:49] arrangement the same way every
[2:08:50] entrenched monopoly does with
[2:08:52] money in politics.
[2:08:55] Sempra spendnds over $1 million a
[2:08:56] year lobbying Sacramento and
[2:08:58] the very commission that sets
[2:08:59] its profit margin.
[2:09:01] >> Take a look at where Sempra
[2:09:03] Nest is.
[2:09:03] You need to donate their money.
[2:09:04] Our money.
[2:09:06] This isn't just about a high
[2:09:07] bill.
[2:09:08] It's about a monopoly that
[2:09:09] profits by spending more
[2:09:12] vitally clean energy on our
[2:09:13] roofs and spends our money
[2:09:15] lobbying the people meant to
[2:09:17] hold them accountable.
[2:09:19] This is unacceptable.
[2:09:20] This is nonpartisan and this is
[2:09:22] wrong.
[2:09:24] >> I want to end with a
[2:09:25] question to the room and I
[2:09:26] think you will actually might
[2:09:27] know the answer.
[2:09:28] How do you spell corporate
[2:09:29] greed?
[2:09:32] Sd Jeannie, thank you Counsel.
[2:09:36] >> Thank you for your comments
[2:09:40] Our next speaker is Isaiah
[2:09:43] Glass of Isaiah.
[2:09:43] You have several people sending
[2:09:44] you time so I just need to
[2:09:46] confirm they're here.
[2:09:47] Robin Gill Burt thank you.
[2:09:51] Mary Fifield Thank you.
[2:09:54] Andrew Lund Steve Thank you.
[2:09:57] So today Lopez Eugenio thank
[2:09:58] you And Mike meaning All right,
[2:10:02] Thank you.
[2:10:03] You will have six minutes.
[2:10:04] >> Please begin.
[2:10:05] Good afternoon, Council
[2:10:06] members.
[2:10:07] My name is Isaiah Glasser and
[2:10:08] I'm the program director for
[2:10:10] Public Power San Diego.
[2:10:12] I want to take a moment to
[2:10:12] thank all the volunteers who
[2:10:13] came out to support the Phase
[2:10:15] two public power study and
[2:10:16] public power in general.
[2:10:17] I really do appreciate it from
[2:10:18] the bottom of my heart.
[2:10:20] This new gen study shows even
[2:10:22] in the most conservative
[2:10:23] modeling that public power is
[2:10:26] good for San Diego and it's
[2:10:27] good for San Diego is the key
[2:10:29] number that determines this
[2:10:30] amount of savings is
[2:10:31] the revenue growth rate.
[2:10:33] New Gen assumed 4% and admits
[2:10:35] that 6% is more realistic and
[2:10:38] it's a total slap in the face
[2:10:39] that just a couple of days ago
[2:10:41] you filed for an 8% increase in
[2:10:42] 2028.
[2:10:44] The second you take this model
[2:10:46] it's the same You take this
[2:10:47] model and use a revenue growth
[2:10:48] rate that's anywhere near
[2:10:49] reality.
[2:10:50] The savings are absolutely mind
[2:10:51] blowing and it seems to me that
[2:10:53] we're actually pretty close to
[2:10:54] consensus on that which makes
[2:10:56] common sense because when you
[2:10:58] cut Wall Street profit out of
[2:10:59] our electricity bills you will
[2:11:01] see savings.
[2:11:02] Many of us here today knew this
[2:11:04] back in 2020 during
[2:11:05] the franchise agreement fight
[2:11:06] and again in 2024 during
[2:11:08] the power San Diego campaign.
[2:11:10] Public power was the right
[2:11:11] choice in 2020.
[2:11:12] It was the right choice in
[2:11:13] 2024.
[2:11:15] It's the right choice in 2026
[2:11:17] and it will be the right choice
[2:11:18] in 2023.
[2:11:19] The question is not if public
[2:11:21] power saves money.
[2:11:23] The question is when will we
[2:11:24] have a council that is brave
[2:11:26] enough to take on the corporate
[2:11:27] oligarchs that any all of us
[2:11:30] here today are being ripped off
[2:11:32] by our stage name including
[2:11:34] the city of San Diego.
[2:11:36] The city pays an sd Jeanie Bill
[2:11:38] the water department pays
[2:11:40] the nasty G.I. Bill.
[2:11:41] The sewer department pays a
[2:11:42] nasty G.I. Bill Electric rates
[2:11:44] are a cost inflator on
[2:11:46] the entire city budget.
[2:11:48] Public power would help
[2:11:49] the city's structural deficit,
[2:11:51] t harm it.
[2:11:52] We really truly are the council
[2:11:54] and the people of San Diego on
[2:11:56] the same side against sd Jenny
[2:11:59] And moving forward we
[2:12:00] absolutely must protect ibew
[2:12:02] guarantee their fought hard,
[2:12:04] hard fought labor contracts and
[2:12:06] hard earned pension funds.
[2:12:08] And that is absolutely doable
[2:12:09] with public power.
[2:12:11] Now I've got a message for
[2:12:13] the bosses at e!
[2:12:17] >> The public power movement is
[2:12:19] only growing.
[2:12:20] Your days are numbered.
[2:12:21] Of pillaging our community.
[2:12:23] Your for profit monopoly will
[2:12:25] end.
[2:12:26] >> Thank you.
[2:12:30] >> Thank you.
[2:12:31] Alison Miller Well Alison comes
[2:12:33] to the microphone I will ask
[2:12:35] Blaire Beekman, Jessica
[2:12:36] Anderson Nicole Lilly Yeah and
[2:12:40] Dori Bruggeman to please come
[2:12:42] to the front room.
[2:12:44] >> Alison, please begin.
[2:12:45] Hello Council I am a resident
[2:12:47] of District three and I am here
[2:12:48] today because a quarter of your
[2:12:50] voters and my neighbors are in
[2:12:52] debt to corporate greed as any
[2:12:56] at any given time.
[2:12:58] >> They're on track to make $1
[2:13:00] billion in profits this year
[2:13:01] yet they continue to ask for
[2:13:02] more during the same time
[2:13:04] period they've been
[2:13:04] participating in union busting.
[2:13:06] They've been turning to private
[2:13:08] contractors that hurt our union
[2:13:09] neighbors.
[2:13:12] We the supporters of the public
[2:13:14] power movement are committed to
[2:13:15] working with our union
[2:13:15] neighbors as we implement
[2:13:17] public power And I ask you to
[2:13:18] commit to the same.
[2:13:19] Opponents today have argued
[2:13:20] that there isn't enough
[2:13:21] information to take the next
[2:13:22] step.
[2:13:23] But you have before you data
[2:13:25] that is founded on good
[2:13:27] information.
[2:13:29] It's time today is the time to
[2:13:32] take the next step.
[2:13:33] There will never be enough
[2:13:34] information for some people.
[2:13:35] Today San Diego pays and see
[2:13:37] Jeannie profits.
[2:13:38] But San Diegans deserve to own
[2:13:40] the goods and services that we
[2:13:41] pay for.
[2:13:42] So today I'm asking you to
[2:13:43] reject corporate greed and act
[2:13:45] in support of San Diegans by
[2:13:47] supporting public good.
[2:13:49] >> That doesn't include your
[2:13:49] time.
[2:13:50] Blair Beekman.
[2:13:59] Hi.
[2:14:00] I'm already here.
[2:14:00] Shoot.
[2:14:01] It's my time.
[2:14:02] Thank you.
[2:14:03] I'm not very knowledgeable
[2:14:04] about these things, but I come
[2:14:07] from the Bay Area.
[2:14:08] They have a great tradition of
[2:14:09] community energy and working
[2:14:11] with unions I feel I have to
[2:14:14] refresh myself on such
[2:14:15] subjects.
[2:14:16] I hope you guys are learning
[2:14:17] that too that the municipal
[2:14:20] things weren't offered here.
[2:14:21] For union things I hope there
[2:14:24] can be dialog between everyone
[2:14:26] It sounds like people want to
[2:14:27] have the dialog and we
[2:14:29] definitely want to believe in
[2:14:30] the future of what community
[2:14:31] energy can offer.
[2:14:34] Where you minister a municipal
[2:14:36] system MAY not work.
[2:14:37] We do have little small
[2:14:39] programs you know like
[2:14:41] the funding of neighborhood
[2:14:42] infrastructure that can be
[2:14:44] called a municipal program
[2:14:46] possibly and work in those kind
[2:14:48] of avenues.
[2:14:49] But working towards the overall
[2:14:51] goal of community energy I hope
[2:14:53] we're all on board on that
[2:14:54] subject matter and want to be
[2:14:56] building such good things for
[2:14:58] all of us in our future.
[2:14:59] >> Thank you.
[2:15:00] Thank you, Jessica Anderson.
[2:15:05] >> Hello, Council.
[2:15:07] Month after month over the past
[2:15:08] year my utility bill has
[2:15:09] continued to climb, reaching
[2:15:11] nearly over $300 every single
[2:15:13] month in my first apartment out
[2:15:15] of college.
[2:15:16] This is unaffordable.
[2:15:17] It is ridiculous that City
[2:15:17] Jionni profits nearly $1
[2:15:20] billion a year yet 1 in 5 San
[2:15:22] Diegans cannot afford their
[2:15:23] utility bills.
[2:15:25] It is ridiculous that in that
[2:15:28] stage you need claim that this
[2:15:28] is not feasible when they are
[2:15:29] asking for an 8.6% increase at
[2:15:32] the cpu.
[2:15:33] See it is absolutely ridiculous
[2:15:35] when San Diegans are forced to
[2:15:37] choose between food on their
[2:15:38] table paying their rent and
[2:15:40] paying their utility bills it
[2:15:41] is clear the system is broken.
[2:15:43] Public power is a real
[2:15:44] opportunity to address this
[2:15:45] crisis.
[2:15:46] Public power presents us with
[2:15:48] the opportunity for clean
[2:15:50] affordable energy.
[2:15:50] Public power presents us with
[2:15:52] the opportunity for clean air
[2:15:53] public health, the opportunity
[2:15:55] to protect strong unions and to
[2:15:58] protect people In San Diego who
[2:15:59] cannot afford to live here any
[2:16:00] longer.
[2:16:01] Public power is a real viable
[2:16:03] opportunity to build a more
[2:16:05] affordable and thriving San
[2:16:07] Diego.
[2:16:07] >> Thank you.
[2:16:08] That does conclude your time.
[2:16:09] Nicole Lilly.
[2:16:14] Nicole Lilly.
[2:16:17] Okay.
[2:16:17] Uh oh.
[2:16:19] Here she comes.
[2:16:20] All right.
[2:16:32] >> Sorry.
[2:16:34] Hello.
[2:16:35] My name is Nicole Lilly.
[2:16:36] I'm a 23 year old run turned
[2:16:38] Golden Heel and the executive
[2:16:39] director of our Time to Act a
[2:16:41] youth led 523 nonprofit
[2:16:42] organizing powerful youth for
[2:16:44] an inclusive, equitable and
[2:16:45] sustainable future.
[2:16:47] As youth organizers we have
[2:16:48] become all too familiar
[2:16:49] tackling complicated and
[2:16:51] nuanced issues and creating new
[2:16:52] and innovative solutions
[2:16:53] because it is what is necessary
[2:16:56] I support the implementation of
[2:16:58] public power without denying
[2:17:00] the necessity of labor
[2:17:01] considerations.
[2:17:02] We need not be divided.
[2:17:04] Dismantling monopolies like
[2:17:06] Jeannie is an effort that we
[2:17:07] must join together to pursue.
[2:17:09] Utilities like housing and
[2:17:10] health care are basic needs and
[2:17:12] allowing it to be maintained as
[2:17:13] a tool for profit because it is
[2:17:15] complicated is unacceptable.
[2:17:17] Every day San Diegans young
[2:17:19] organizers like myself demand a
[2:17:21] commitment from this council to
[2:17:22] do what is complicated because
[2:17:23] it is necessary.
[2:17:25] My roommate and I figure out
[2:17:26] how to make do with less and
[2:17:27] less every month to survive in
[2:17:29] San Diego.
[2:17:30] I urge the city to do more to
[2:17:31] make San Diego work for all
[2:17:32] the people in this room not
[2:17:33] the corporations that we
[2:17:34] destroy.
[2:17:35] >> Thank you.
[2:17:36] Lori Saldana.
[2:17:42] >> Good afternoon And I want to
[2:17:44] just acknowledge and thank all
[2:17:45] the people who have spoken
[2:17:46] today because the perspectives
[2:17:48] are important and I think
[2:17:49] they've all raised some really
[2:17:51] excellent points on both sides
[2:17:53] for and against us.
[2:17:54] There are a few certainties in
[2:17:56] life We know a couple of them
[2:17:58] death taxes and I'll add a
[2:18:02] third sdg in asking to raise
[2:18:03] their rates.
[2:18:06] 300,000 people at least cannot
[2:18:07] afford to pay their higher
[2:18:08] rates here in San Diego.
[2:18:10] We pay the highest rates in
[2:18:12] the country.
[2:18:13] So with certainty when I heard
[2:18:14] the report on my way in today
[2:18:15] and listen to the report saying
[2:18:17] an estimated 3% rate increase
[2:18:19] would even out over time i
[2:18:22] think you're way
[2:18:22] underestimating what us intends
[2:18:25] to do.
[2:18:26] So in the interest of time I
[2:18:28] will just point out one more
[2:18:29] thing.
[2:18:29] Working against us is one
[2:18:30] culprit.
[2:18:31] You have received $5,000 as of
[2:18:33] MARCH 31st from ibew for your
[2:18:37] run for Congress.
[2:18:38] I would ask that you please
[2:18:39] recuse yourself from voting on
[2:18:40] this.
[2:18:41] >> I think you have a conflict
[2:18:42] of interest and thank you for
[2:18:46] your time.
[2:18:46] >> Okay, take it easy.
[2:18:47] This is an information item.
[2:18:49] There is no voting.
[2:18:54] Dori Brueggemann You do have
[2:18:55] time ceded to you by Barbara I
[2:19:00] have a rose Okay you have two
[2:19:00] minutes.
[2:19:00] Please begin.
[2:19:02] >> Good afternoon Council I'm
[2:19:04] Dory.
[2:19:05] I'm an executive board member
[2:19:06] of Public Power San Diego and
[2:19:09] some of the points I had
[2:19:10] written down here today have
[2:19:11] already been said so I'll skip
[2:19:12] those.
[2:19:13] But I wanted to read a couple
[2:19:15] of quotes from the feasibility
[2:19:17] study phase two The first quote
[2:19:20] that I have here is
[2:19:22] the financial risks while real
[2:19:24] are manageable through careful
[2:19:25] planning and execution.
[2:19:27] The municipal electric utility
[2:19:29] remains viable even under
[2:19:31] adverse scenarios.
[2:19:33] The bottom line is that this
[2:19:34] report shows that this is
[2:19:35] feasible.
[2:19:37] This quote also tells us that
[2:19:38] when we build a public utility
[2:19:40] we are building a domain where
[2:19:42] success lies in our hands.
[2:19:44] And I want to say there's been
[2:19:45] a lot of fear mongering here
[2:19:46] today.
[2:19:48] I also just want to shout out
[2:19:49] thank you.
[2:19:52] Britney says for
[2:19:52] the fearmongering directly from
[2:19:53] sd Janey She did not identify
[2:19:53] herself but she does work for
[2:19:57] any.
[2:19:58] I want to talk about the risk
[2:20:00] of not making the choice to
[2:20:02] switch to public power instead
[2:20:03] making the choice to stay
[2:20:05] the course where we are hoping
[2:20:09] that legislative reform or cpc
[2:20:11] reform will somehow fix this
[2:20:12] problem.
[2:20:13] The cbc is not going to save
[2:20:16] us.
[2:20:18] That's not our turf.
[2:20:19] That's Sdrinis turf.
[2:20:23] One of our allies over here had
[2:20:26] a great example of the way that
[2:20:27] they exploit loopholes.
[2:20:28] Any any roadblock we put in
[2:20:31] their way they will exploit.
[2:20:33] We are not winning as much as
[2:20:34] we need to be to fix
[2:20:35] the problem at the state level.
[2:20:39] But the point is that public
[2:20:40] power is not uniquely risky And
[2:20:42] also we're lucky that we have
[2:20:44] this option that we are a city
[2:20:45] and we can actually do
[2:20:47] something significant to make a
[2:20:49] change and get out under
[2:20:51] the thumb of Jeannie.
[2:20:52] So I want to echo what my ally
[2:20:54] Patricia and Diego said.
[2:20:56] We can do this.
[2:20:57] >> We can work together.
[2:20:59] This is a growing movement.
[2:21:00] And don't let the fear
[2:21:04] mongering get to you.
[2:21:04] That does conclude your time.
[2:21:06] Omar Walter Nadji.
[2:21:25] One minute.
[2:21:26] One minute.
[2:21:26] Yes.
[2:21:26] So you said you uniquely
[2:21:27] positioned to chart a different
[2:21:28] course with national
[2:21:30] consequences.
[2:21:31] Climate is one of the greatest
[2:21:32] natural resources anywhere in
[2:21:34] the world.
[2:21:35] We have an abundant sunshine
[2:21:36] growing clean energy sector,
[2:21:38] world class research
[2:21:39] institutions and the population
[2:21:41] has consistently embraced
[2:21:43] innovations.
[2:21:44] We're not simply capable of
[2:21:46] generating enough clean energy
[2:21:48] to power our homes and
[2:21:49] businesses.
[2:21:50] We have potential to become a
[2:21:52] net producer of energy creating
[2:21:54] economic value that remains in
[2:21:57] our region rather than leaving
[2:21:58] it.
[2:22:00] Decisions being made right now
[2:22:01] will determine who benefits
[2:22:03] from this growth.
[2:22:05] This opportunity will the value
[2:22:08] created by this transformation
[2:22:09] of our system remain here in
[2:22:13] San Diego reinvested in
[2:22:15] affordability, reliability,
[2:22:16] infrastructure and local
[2:22:16] priorities?
[2:22:19] Or will it continue to flow
[2:22:20] primarily towards a system
[2:22:21] designed around shareholder
[2:22:23] returns?
[2:22:25] We have every incentive to
[2:22:27] preserve this model.
[2:22:30] If we were part of this study
[2:22:36] well we that's an investor
[2:22:36] owned utility understand that.
[2:22:37] But as you guys represent us
[2:22:42] the citizens your
[2:22:44] responsibility is about what
[2:22:48] serves San Diego is best.
[2:22:50] Sorry I'm not professional
[2:22:51] speech.
[2:22:53] Is my first speech in years.
[2:22:54] But anyway I think this is a
[2:22:56] test.
[2:22:57] The biggest question is ask
[2:22:59] whether the generation of
[2:23:01] wealth created by the energy
[2:23:03] economy should be captured
[2:23:05] locally and used to benefit
[2:23:07] communities that created it.
[2:23:09] Or are we to continue to give
[2:23:11] it to us to Junior?
[2:23:15] This isn't their decision.
[2:23:16] >> Thank you.
[2:23:17] That does conclude
[2:23:17] the development session but
[2:23:26] please keep.
[2:23:32] >> I just walk to the parking
[2:23:33] structure with former
[2:23:34] Councilmember Mark Kersey.
[2:23:36] >> He was kind enough to listen
[2:23:38] to my questions about why
[2:23:41] the city can't do the simplest
[2:23:42] things to oversee the many
[2:23:46] businesses that operate
[2:23:47] throughout this city.
[2:23:50] Do you know what he said to me?
[2:23:53] He said there was too much
[2:23:54] going on in this city for
[2:23:57] the council members to deal
[2:23:58] with all the details in
[2:24:00] the city.
[2:24:02] Too much going on for you to
[2:24:04] deal with.
[2:24:06] Now I'm not an expert on energy
[2:24:08] but I have become an expert on
[2:24:11] business interests hijacking
[2:24:13] the city government for their
[2:24:15] own purposes.
[2:24:17] If you have any doubt, look
[2:24:19] into how the city That's you.
[2:24:22] Joe Lacob and Todd Lauria have
[2:24:24] mismanaged the Torrey Pines
[2:24:24] Gloria port.
[2:24:26] Thank you.
[2:24:27] Thank you.
[2:24:29] Our final in-person speaker
[2:24:30] will be Anthony Ralphs.
[2:24:39] >> Good afternoon City Council.
[2:24:40] I want to remind everybody in
[2:24:42] this room that we all share one
[2:24:43] thing in common We're all
[2:24:45] getting ripped off by Jionni
[2:24:47] and it continues every day year
[2:24:49] after year.
[2:24:52] $1 billion in profits last year
[2:24:54] Almost a billion the year
[2:24:55] before.
[2:24:56] I'm sick to my stomach.
[2:24:57] I'm tired of not being able to
[2:24:59] pay my energy bills.
[2:25:00] I'm tired of the people in my
[2:25:01] city not being able to pay
[2:25:02] their energy bills.
[2:25:03] I'm tired of one quarter to a
[2:25:05] fifth of the people in this
[2:25:06] city not being able to afford
[2:25:08] meeting their energy bills at
[2:25:10] the end of the month.
[2:25:11] I'm tired of seeing a corporate
[2:25:13] monopoly and its greed
[2:25:15] prioritized over the people
[2:25:17] that live in the city.
[2:25:18] I am a union member.
[2:25:20] I'm a member of iww,
[2:25:21] the Industrial Workers of
[2:25:22] the World so I understand
[2:25:24] the priority that labor places
[2:25:26] in our lives.
[2:25:27] But I also understand that only
[2:25:29] half of the people in this room
[2:25:31] are getting paid handsomely to
[2:25:32] be here And it's not those of
[2:25:34] us who hate sd Jeanie for free.
[2:25:36] >> Thank you.
[2:25:41] >> Thank you.
[2:25:42] We also received two speaker
[2:25:44] slips from individuals wishing
[2:25:46] to register their position in
[2:25:48] favor but not speak from
[2:25:49] Brandon Reynolds and Korina
[2:25:51] Vega.
[2:25:54] That concludes in-person public
[2:25:55] comment.
[2:25:56] I've started the five minute
[2:25:57] timer and council chambers.
[2:25:58] We will now turn to the virtual
[2:26:00] queue in which there are
[2:26:02] currently ten speakers
[2:26:03] requesting to speak.
[2:26:05] We will begin with Eric Revolt
[2:26:09] Zachary.
[2:26:20] Imagine every single family
[2:26:23] house and duplex in San Diego
[2:26:25] covered with twice the solar
[2:26:28] panels there are now and
[2:26:30] they're going to get paid three
[2:26:31] times more for the energy.
[2:26:33] Imagine Fashion Valley covered
[2:26:36] in solar panels.
[2:26:37] Mission Valley covered in solar
[2:26:39] panels.
[2:26:41] The parking drives all their
[2:26:42] green power.
[2:26:44] And imagine every trolley
[2:26:46] station covered in providing
[2:26:49] shade and solar energy to feed
[2:26:52] the dc motors on the trolley
[2:26:55] instead of using ac dropping
[2:26:57] down to dc for them directly
[2:27:00] with solar panels on
[2:27:02] the trolley system Even
[2:27:04] the tracks elevator from
[2:27:05] the tracks.
[2:27:06] We're now doing ac power and
[2:27:09] turning that ac power into dc
[2:27:12] causing energy when we can
[2:27:15] generate it from solar panels
[2:27:17] right there on the trolley
[2:27:18] stations.
[2:27:19] >> No all involved is solar.
[2:27:23] Thank you.
[2:27:24] That does conclude your time.
[2:27:25] We will go next to Eric Proval,
[2:27:28] Paul Jones Eric.
[2:27:32] >> Perfect.
[2:27:33] Thank you so much counsel.
[2:27:34] My name is Eric Proval and I am
[2:27:36] the ceo of the San Diego North
[2:27:38] Economic Development Council
[2:27:39] representing an area North of
[2:27:42] that sa 56 with more than 1
[2:27:43] million residents and 500,000
[2:27:45] jobs.
[2:27:46] I urge caution and ask that
[2:27:48] the city pause this effort
[2:27:49] until the regional implications
[2:27:51] are better understood.
[2:27:52] The reported self acknowledges
[2:27:54] that the electric system was
[2:27:55] not built around city
[2:27:57] boundaries.
[2:27:58] Numerous substations and other
[2:27:59] assets serve customers both
[2:28:01] inside and outside the city.
[2:28:03] Yet the report appears to
[2:28:05] assume that separating and
[2:28:06] operating these assets can
[2:28:08] occur smoothly and
[2:28:09] cooperatively.
[2:28:11] That is a significant
[2:28:12] assumption with major
[2:28:13] implications for reliability
[2:28:14] costs in neighboring
[2:28:15] communities.
[2:28:16] But most importantly the report
[2:28:18] does not adequately explain how
[2:28:20] a municipal utility would
[2:28:21] participate in regional
[2:28:23] wildfire prevention, weather
[2:28:25] monitoring and emergency
[2:28:26] operations before moving
[2:28:27] forward.
[2:28:28] North County communities
[2:28:29] deserve a clear understanding
[2:28:31] of how municipal this action
[2:28:32] would affect them.
[2:28:36] Thank you for your comments.
[2:28:40] Kathleen Levitt Thank you.
[2:28:45] Good afternoon and thank you to
[2:28:46] everybody who spoke.
[2:28:48] Governor Newsom allowed
[2:28:49] California companies to tax
[2:28:51] taxpayer dollars from the state
[2:28:53] $21 billion while fund wildfire
[2:28:57] fund to pay for their damages,
[2:28:59] fines and liabilities for fires
[2:29:01] that were directly tied to it.
[2:29:04] For every dollar the utility
[2:29:06] spent building infrastructure
[2:29:08] they were allowed to charge
[2:29:09] customers an additional 10% in
[2:29:12] profits for their shareholders.
[2:29:14] They routinely their priority
[2:29:16] is profit for their executives
[2:29:18] and shareholders and they
[2:29:19] routinely disregard public
[2:29:21] priorities They disregard while
[2:29:23] diverse habitats that support
[2:29:25] migratory birds, reptiles,
[2:29:28] pollinators and they're ignored
[2:29:30] On behalf of permitting if
[2:29:33] figure you need to put their
[2:29:35] power lines they now want to
[2:29:37] put their power lines directly
[2:29:40] through the anza-borrego Park
[2:29:43] that is a designated park in
[2:29:45] perpetuity to protect Thank
[2:29:48] you.
[2:29:48] That does conclude your time.
[2:29:56] Francis Yasmeen Matlala Hello.
[2:29:57] So first it's I think it's
[2:30:01] important for everyone to
[2:30:02] realize that like the entire
[2:30:04] state of Nebraska has municipal
[2:30:06] run power is is not impossible
[2:30:08] task any government can do it
[2:30:10] if they just create the public
[2:30:11] the political will to do it.
[2:30:13] I think that every one of
[2:30:16] the council members should
[2:30:17] attend The American Public
[2:30:20] Power Association's annual
[2:30:21] conference and you can learn
[2:30:23] about and meet cities of people
[2:30:27] from cities all over
[2:30:28] the country that enjoy
[2:30:29] the benefits of public power
[2:30:30] that we are only dreaming of.
[2:30:33] I want to state that the sdg
[2:30:35] business model it's not about
[2:30:38] security or affordability.
[2:30:42] It's about profit And even
[2:30:43] the way they're designing
[2:30:44] the future with long
[2:30:45] transmission lines out to
[2:30:47] the desert is the wrong way to
[2:30:48] go.
[2:30:49] It's not sensible unless you
[2:30:51] try and exploit people for
[2:30:52] money as he takes $1 million a
[2:30:55] day out of the city and 3
[2:30:56] million a day out of
[2:30:57] the county, it's got to stop
[2:30:58] now.
[2:30:59] >> Thank you, John Stump by
[2:31:13] John Stone And DECEMBER 15th
[2:31:15] 2025 I sent the council a nine
[2:31:19] point program to get out of
[2:31:23] this mess with me.
[2:31:25] And the key thing in this nine
[2:31:28] point program which I'm sending
[2:31:29] you again today is that
[2:31:32] the city should create its own
[2:31:34] municipal utility for its own
[2:31:36] use.
[2:31:37] The city currently now
[2:31:39] generates its own power and
[2:31:41] spends a lot of money paying
[2:31:45] Genny.
[2:31:45] The city could easily set up
[2:31:47] its own department and that
[2:31:50] would be the initial step
[2:31:51] the transitional step toward
[2:31:54] public power.
[2:31:56] City Council Start exploring
[2:31:59] where you spend money and where
[2:32:02] you generate electricity now
[2:32:04] and set up a separate
[2:32:06] department To watch that please
[2:32:09] follow the direction of my
[2:32:10] mother at DECEMBER 15th 2025.
[2:32:13] >> Thank you very much.
[2:32:17] Thank you.
[2:32:18] And I please know that the five
[2:32:19] minute timer has concluded with
[2:32:21] eight speakers left in
[2:32:23] the queue and the other
[2:32:23] speakers will be taken after
[2:32:27] this time The voices please
[2:32:29] begin.
[2:32:33] >> Hi my name is We try and set
[2:32:34] the director for businesses.
[2:32:37] I'm calling to support you know
[2:32:39] public power.
[2:32:40] I know that I also think it's
[2:32:44] ironic that we need a study to
[2:32:46] figure out where we should put
[2:32:48] the power.
[2:32:50] We all talk about the rising
[2:32:53] costs of standing so much now I
[2:32:57] you know, if you can find a
[2:32:59] little will to make it happen,
[2:33:02] it will really help a lot of us
[2:33:03] reduce the cost of living here
[2:33:05] and stay here And then I go it
[2:33:07] is the no getting there now we
[2:33:10] don't really need a study to do
[2:33:11] it But now you have a study Can
[2:33:13] you please move forward with
[2:33:15] it?
[2:33:15] That would be great.
[2:33:16] Thank you.
[2:33:22] Color with the last word Digits
[2:33:22] 88213.
[2:33:24] Please begin.
[2:33:33] Okay so the goal here is
[2:33:34] unbelievable to get people to
[2:33:36] have confidence that this board
[2:33:38] will do the right thing when
[2:33:40] the record of ignoring
[2:33:42] the people's wishes and needs
[2:33:44] are like it's been proven in
[2:33:47] putting people honestly to
[2:33:49] the people who are awake to any
[2:33:53] and all we have We have so much
[2:33:53] of our money and keep asking
[2:33:55] for more But you realize that
[2:33:57] this board you're addressing
[2:33:58] does the same exact thing
[2:34:02] honestly from sandag to
[2:34:03] the county to this board.
[2:34:06] I mean all these corrupt
[2:34:08] government agencies they'll
[2:34:10] take for it They will take from
[2:34:12] us and you know, whatever
[2:34:15] benefits them.
[2:34:16] But I just wish, you know, more
[2:34:17] people were awake to that And
[2:34:20] it's it's amazing You can't
[2:34:22] address us without also
[2:34:24] addressing the corruption of
[2:34:24] the very board.
[2:34:27] Well, I got to say that.
[2:34:33] Thank you, Evan Burke, please
[2:34:35] begin.
[2:34:39] >> Hello.
[2:34:39] I want to speak in favor of
[2:34:41] public power first.
[2:34:43] There is no benefit to a
[2:34:44] private monopoly like Genie.
[2:34:46] There's no need to even pretend
[2:34:47] to little cost with no
[2:34:49] competition.
[2:34:50] Meanwhile, their insanely high
[2:34:51] power costs make our cost of
[2:34:52] living more expensive and
[2:34:54] contribute to issues like
[2:34:55] homelessness.
[2:34:56] I found the fear mongering that
[2:34:58] I've heard outrageous.
[2:35:00] We hear that we don't have
[2:35:01] enough data but what more data
[2:35:02] do we need when dozens of other
[2:35:04] cities have already done this
[2:35:05] and succeeded, we were warned
[2:35:08] that San Diego will have to pay
[2:35:09] new costs like insurance
[2:35:11] premiums.
[2:35:12] But San Diegans are already
[2:35:13] paying those costs and more
[2:35:15] Whenever Janey turns a profit
[2:35:18] the definition of madness is
[2:35:19] doing the same thing over and
[2:35:21] over again and expecting a
[2:35:22] different result.
[2:35:23] We've seen what I see Genie can
[2:35:24] do and will do and now's
[2:35:27] the time to try something
[2:35:28] different or just a new form of
[2:35:30] pop pop power.
[2:35:31] >> Thank you.
[2:35:33] Thank you.
[2:35:34] Natalie Rashid, please begin.
[2:35:42] Hi.
[2:35:48] Natalie Rushdie Here I am
[2:35:48] District seven.
[2:35:48] I want to bring couple
[2:35:50] attention to one number that
[2:35:51] explains a lot of what's
[2:35:52] happening with our electric
[2:35:54] bills.
[2:35:58] You see just authorized a
[2:35:58] return on equity of nearly 10%
[2:36:01] for 2026 to 2028.
[2:36:03] That's the profit percentage
[2:36:06] Sempra's shareholders earn not
[2:36:07] on selling us electricity but
[2:36:08] on infrastructure spending
[2:36:10] itself.
[2:36:11] The more he spends on poles
[2:36:13] wires and upgrades the more
[2:36:15] profit profit it earns because
[2:36:17] that return is applied to
[2:36:19] the entire faith based
[2:36:21] independent economics at
[2:36:23] the American Economic Liberties
[2:36:25] Project testified that their
[2:36:26] fair return based on current
[2:36:27] market conditions would be
[2:36:29] closer to 6% and the gap
[2:36:30] between that and what was
[2:36:32] actually authorized comes out
[2:36:33] to 4.4 billion in overcharges
[2:36:37] in 2026 alone across
[2:36:39] California's immediate
[2:36:40] utilities.
[2:36:40] This is exactly why the cities
[2:36:42] on Public Power study found
[2:36:45] that most Thank you that does
[2:36:48] conclude your tired electric
[2:36:49] grid.
[2:36:52] Next speaker is Jordan Lewis.
[2:36:54] Please begin.
[2:36:58] >> Hi, my name is Katherine
[2:37:02] Mock.
[2:37:02] I'm a resident of San San Diego
[2:37:04] County in North County and I'm
[2:37:06] an sd g and customer and I
[2:37:08] support acquiring sd Janney
[2:37:09] Infrastructure and could bring
[2:37:11] it to a publicly owned power
[2:37:12] utility particularly for
[2:37:14] concerns like affordability and
[2:37:16] transitioning to zero emission
[2:37:18] utilities.
[2:37:19] Well it's expensive to acquire
[2:37:20] a managed utility and that cost
[2:37:22] will be footed by us rate
[2:37:22] payers.
[2:37:23] We're already footing the bill
[2:37:25] for sd duty and on top of that,
[2:37:27] as others have pointed out,
[2:37:29] we're paying the additional
[2:37:29] cost of a for profit entity
[2:37:32] including the hundreds of
[2:37:33] millions of profits each year
[2:37:35] that sd only makes as well as
[2:37:36] the 22.2 million total
[2:37:39] compensation for Jeffrey
[2:37:40] Martin, Sempra ceo That was
[2:37:42] last year's number.
[2:37:44] So for these reasons I fully
[2:37:45] support advancing a publicly
[2:37:46] owned utility for San Diego.
[2:37:48] Please continue this effort.
[2:37:49] Do what you can to reduce
[2:37:50] the uncertainty.
[2:37:51] Incorporate the concerns of
[2:37:53] some of the folks who spoken
[2:37:53] opposition today and complete
[2:37:55] the transition to public power.
[2:37:57] >> Thank you.
[2:37:57] Thank you.
[2:38:00] Next speaker is a caller with
[2:38:02] last four digits 8700.
[2:38:06] Please begin.
[2:38:13] Thank you.
[2:38:14] Yes, I support public power
[2:38:18] also known as Power of
[2:38:20] the People.
[2:38:21] Here are my reasons.
[2:38:23] Number one, all of you using
[2:38:26] the power of your voice today.
[2:38:29] Number two, trusting that all
[2:38:32] of us will do a full analysis
[2:38:34] of this of its ability.
[2:38:37] Number three keeping an eye on
[2:38:40] San Francisco as a public power
[2:38:42] model.
[2:38:44] This is a golden opportunity
[2:38:46] for creative action outside
[2:38:49] the box of sd g and e!
[2:38:53] It's been a great item.
[2:38:55] Thank you everybody and love to
[2:38:57] all.
[2:39:00] Thank you.
[2:39:00] Our next speaker is a caller
[2:39:02] with the last four digits to
[2:39:02] 265.
[2:39:16] Please begin.
[2:39:16] I am Diego.
[2:39:17] I live in Kensington.
[2:39:18] Over the last five years San
[2:39:20] Diego Gas Electric has
[2:39:22] appropriated an average more
[2:39:23] than $800 million per year.
[2:39:26] At the same time, nearly 1 in 5
[2:39:29] Centurions cannot afford to pay
[2:39:30] their utility bills.
[2:39:33] And greed knows no end.
[2:39:35] And just last week they
[2:39:36] requested the rate increase of
[2:39:41] 8.6% at the puc.
[2:39:43] This would mean an increase of
[2:39:44] over $22,000,022 a month on top
[2:39:47] of the already high utility
[2:39:49] rates we are paying above
[2:39:51] the public power Feasibility
[2:39:53] study shows public power is
[2:39:55] possible feasible and cheaper
[2:39:57] for San Diego and the time for
[2:39:59] public power is now.
[2:40:01] My utility bill is like we live
[2:40:04] in a 2000 square foot apartment
[2:40:07] in utility bills like $250.
[2:40:09] It's just ridiculous.
[2:40:11] >> We need to do public art
[2:40:11] now.
[2:40:13] You.
[2:40:16] >> Thank you.
[2:40:17] Our final speakers and all of
[2:40:17] Alaska.
[2:40:19] Please begin.
[2:40:23] Hi.
[2:40:24] So I'm a resident of District
[2:40:25] two.
[2:40:27] Natural monopolies like
[2:40:29] utilities should not be owned
[2:40:30] by for profit entities because
[2:40:32] without competition and
[2:40:33] swimmers will always be
[2:40:35] squeezed for profit.
[2:40:36] It was a mistake to have ever
[2:40:37] allowed power to be privately
[2:40:38] owned.
[2:40:39] If the power had been publicly
[2:40:41] owned, the electrical expertise
[2:40:43] and the good union jobs would
[2:40:44] have always been available
[2:40:45] through a public entity.
[2:40:47] It will never be a good time to
[2:40:48] unwind this mistake but it
[2:40:50] needs to be done.
[2:40:51] We understand the fear of
[2:40:53] uncertainty facing union
[2:40:54] members but there is no better
[2:40:56] union employer than public
[2:40:57] agencies.
[2:40:58] As you have pointed out, your
[2:40:59] expertise and skill will still
[2:41:01] be needed.
[2:41:02] And yes, there will be a
[2:41:03] reshuffling of jobs but
[2:41:04] the jobs would not go away.
[2:41:06] We hear the argument we don't
[2:41:07] have enough information But
[2:41:08] isn't this what the council is
[2:41:09] considering a feasibility study
[2:41:12] to gather more information.
[2:41:14] We want the council to have all
[2:41:15] the information possible to
[2:41:17] make a decision on this issue.
[2:41:18] >> We cannot be afraid of this
[2:41:20] knowledge.
[2:41:20] Thank you.
[2:41:22] Thank you.
[2:41:23] That does conclude public
[2:41:25] comment on item 200.
[2:41:28] >> Thank you.
[2:41:29] All right.
[2:41:29] Thank you, Deputy Clerk.
[2:41:30] Let's take a moment and thank
[2:41:31] Kevin.
[2:41:32] This is his first big meeting
[2:41:33] sitting there in the chair.
[2:41:35] So well done, sir.
[2:41:38] And to your entire team because
[2:41:40] the way that you organized all
[2:41:42] the flips truly, truly
[2:41:43] impressive.
[2:41:44] I'll just give a personal
[2:41:46] thanks to everybody that showed
[2:41:47] up and the special shout out to
[2:41:48] those who showed up just to
[2:41:49] give time to somebody else to
[2:41:51] speak.
[2:41:52] Greatly appreciate that.
[2:41:53] So with that we will turn it
[2:41:55] over to the council members for
[2:41:56] questions and comments.
[2:41:58] And we'll start with the chair
[2:41:59] of the Environment Committee.
[2:42:01] >> Council member Ella Rivera.
[2:42:03] All right.
[2:42:04] Thank you.
[2:42:04] Council PRESIDENT.
[2:42:05] Thanks for the report.
[2:42:07] Obviously we had this
[2:42:09] conversation at Environment
[2:42:10] Committee.
[2:42:11] This is a continuation of that
[2:42:15] And I think the additional
[2:42:18] public participation is useful
[2:42:20] because it highlighted to me
[2:42:21] what I think is probably
[2:42:23] the most important component of
[2:42:25] this And with very few
[2:42:28] exceptions almost every comment
[2:42:30] we heard today came from one of
[2:42:31] two groups either the blue
[2:42:34] collar workers who who keep
[2:42:35] the grid running or residents
[2:42:37] who are breaking under
[2:42:38] the weight of their bills.
[2:42:41] It's working People fighting to
[2:42:42] make rent, fighting to keep
[2:42:44] the lights on and fighting each
[2:42:46] other over scraps because
[2:42:48] that's exactly what a rigged
[2:42:50] economy does.
[2:42:51] It doesn't just take people's
[2:42:52] money.
[2:42:53] It turns neighbors against each
[2:42:55] other, workers against
[2:42:56] ratepayers in a fight over who
[2:43:00] absorbs the pain while
[2:43:02] the people who actually rig
[2:43:03] the game keep their feet up and
[2:43:05] enjoy the show from the other
[2:43:06] side of the table.
[2:43:08] So who's doing that?
[2:43:10] As Jeanie in Sempra the set of
[2:43:13] millionaire executives who will
[2:43:14] go home tonight to a financial
[2:43:15] reality that no one who
[2:43:17] testified here today can even
[2:43:19] imagine let alone enjoy.
[2:43:23] So our San Diego boys are
[2:43:24] fighting each other over
[2:43:25] scraps.
[2:43:26] Executives sit fat and happy
[2:43:29] enjoying the fruits of their
[2:43:30] victories.
[2:43:31] We should put some numbers to
[2:43:32] that because I think that's
[2:43:33] important.
[2:43:34] Sempra ceo Jeff Martin took
[2:43:36] home a compensation package
[2:43:38] worth $22.2 million in 2025
[2:43:44] That made him the fourth
[2:43:44] highest paid energy executive
[2:43:46] in the country.
[2:43:48] An average California worker
[2:43:50] would have to work for 236
[2:43:52] years to earn what Martin made
[2:43:55] in a single year 236 years.
[2:44:00] That's not poor people.
[2:44:02] That's the average California
[2:44:03] worker.
[2:44:05] And that's the gap between
[2:44:07] the people who keep the grid
[2:44:08] running and the man at the top
[2:44:12] of the company who owns it.
[2:44:15] And I think there's something
[2:44:17] really important about why it's
[2:44:19] so important to continue this
[2:44:21] conversation.
[2:44:21] I understand the anxiety that
[2:44:24] it creates for the workers who
[2:44:25] who are impacted by
[2:44:27] the conversation.
[2:44:28] But I want to explain why it's
[2:44:30] been important to keep this
[2:44:31] conversation going.
[2:44:31] Because despite this
[2:44:33] conversation going despite a
[2:44:36] visibility report that says
[2:44:38] that this is feasible despite a
[2:44:41] growing movement of San Diegans
[2:44:43] who are organizing to fire
[2:44:47] Jeanie as Jeanie still filed
[2:44:48] for another rate increase 8.6%
[2:44:51] on the average monthly bill
[2:44:53] That's an extra 20 to 50 a
[2:44:54] month.
[2:44:55] While all of that scrutiny is
[2:44:57] happening, not pausing to read
[2:44:59] the room, they're not
[2:45:01] questioning whether or not they
[2:45:02] should slow down.
[2:45:04] They're just they just keep at
[2:45:05] it.
[2:45:06] Increase after increase after
[2:45:08] increase.
[2:45:09] And the message that that sends
[2:45:11] to us is that they don't think
[2:45:13] we have the nerve to have an
[2:45:14] honest conversation about
[2:45:15] alternatives.
[2:45:16] So I think we have a
[2:45:17] responsibility to know what our
[2:45:19] options are and ensure
[2:45:21] the public knows the pros and
[2:45:22] cons of those options.
[2:45:26] According to the most recent
[2:45:28] electric rates report by
[2:45:28] the California Public
[2:45:30] Advocate's Office over the past
[2:45:32] ten years as residential rates
[2:45:33] have risen 98% and every single
[2:45:39] cent that ibew Local 465
[2:45:42] members have earned in that
[2:45:43] same period they've had to
[2:45:45] fight for every contract
[2:45:47] grievance after grievance.
[2:45:48] Nothing handed to you earlier
[2:45:52] this year or at the end of last
[2:45:55] year as de went after a small
[2:45:56] group of workers right to even
[2:45:58] hold a union election.
[2:46:00] Hiring the most notorious union
[2:46:02] busting law firm in America and
[2:46:06] tried to take advantage of a
[2:46:08] paralyzed federal labor board
[2:46:10] to run out the clock on that
[2:46:11] vote.
[2:46:12] And if it wasn't for the work
[2:46:13] of the union they would have
[2:46:16] been successful.
[2:46:19] >> So when ratepayers see a 90%
[2:46:21] or 98% rate increase and ask
[2:46:23] for that money went I know it
[2:46:26] didn't go to the workers.
[2:46:29] It went to a company that will
[2:46:30] spend resources fighting just a
[2:46:33] handful of its own employees
[2:46:34] rights to organize or asking
[2:46:36] the rest of us for another 8.6%
[2:46:39] So I want to make sure we're
[2:46:43] really clear about what we're
[2:46:44] up against and who we're
[2:46:45] standing with.
[2:46:47] MS. Mendoza I appreciated what
[2:46:49] you said.
[2:46:50] We can work together.
[2:46:52] Nobody wants to fire
[2:46:53] the workers who built the grid
[2:46:54] and keep it running.
[2:46:57] The conversation is about what
[2:46:58] our options are instead of
[2:47:00] the status quo Because
[2:47:01] the status quo does not work.
[2:47:02] The status quo allows a ceo to
[2:47:05] earn 236 years worth an average
[2:47:08] worker salary in a single year
[2:47:09] ,fights its union over a
[2:47:11] handful of jobs and squeezes
[2:47:13] rate payers for a 98% rate
[2:47:14] increase.
[2:47:17] All while there's a
[2:47:18] conversation happening about
[2:47:19] what our options are.
[2:47:25] So that context is incredibly
[2:47:28] important.
[2:47:29] I appreciate the conversation
[2:47:30] here today and I again just
[2:47:32] want to reiterate why I think
[2:47:33] it's so important for us to
[2:47:34] keep having it.
[2:47:36] >> There were a lot of
[2:47:38] important points made in
[2:47:39] today's conversation about
[2:47:41] the way that everyone feels
[2:47:43] these impacts about the way
[2:47:45] the city feels, the rising
[2:47:47] costs, the way it has a a
[2:47:52] domino effect in terms of cost
[2:47:53] of living.
[2:47:55] And we have this responsibility
[2:47:59] I did have one one question
[2:48:03] that I brought up last time and
[2:48:05] I'm curious if there's any
[2:48:06] updates.
[2:48:06] Last time I asked about Long
[2:48:08] Island and the hybrid model
[2:48:11] that they pursued.
[2:48:14] Have you done any additional
[2:48:15] research on that?
[2:48:18] Any additional analysis?
[2:48:20] We did look into it generally.
[2:48:24] Councilmember I think
[2:48:24] the important thing to remember
[2:48:25] about Long Island so you are
[2:48:27] right that the Long Island
[2:48:28] Power Authority lpa then has a
[2:48:32] relationship with Shute I don't
[2:48:35] remember actual utility
[2:48:37] operator.
[2:48:38] The issue is is that because
[2:48:40] Long Island and New England and
[2:48:42] most of the East Coast frankly
[2:48:43] is in a deregulated
[2:48:44] environment.
[2:48:46] So it automatically splits kind
[2:48:47] of commodity And then you've
[2:48:48] got a lot of competing
[2:48:50] distributors.
[2:48:51] >> They are overseen still by
[2:48:53] the state Department of Energy
[2:48:55] and Electricity Resources.
[2:48:57] And so you still have a state
[2:48:59] level regulatory body that
[2:49:01] oversees that specific contract
[2:49:04] And there are conversations
[2:49:05] going on on updates on that
[2:49:07] contract that are coming up in
[2:49:08] the next several years.
[2:49:09] If there is continued interest
[2:49:11] in deep diving in here we can
[2:49:13] but there's no equivalent model
[2:49:16] in a in what was a bundled or a
[2:49:18] semi unregulated environment
[2:49:20] like Calif in some of the other
[2:49:22] larger states have got it.
[2:49:24] >> Appreciate that.
[2:49:26] General idea though is
[2:49:29] the workers don't have to be
[2:49:30] displaced from their current
[2:49:32] place of work.
[2:49:33] They continue to do the work
[2:49:34] that they do for who they do
[2:49:36] it.
[2:49:37] What changes is that company is
[2:49:39] now working for the city or
[2:49:41] the municipality instead If I
[2:49:44] understand the model correctly.
[2:49:48] Yes.
[2:49:48] Generally what I did not what
[2:49:50] we did not necessarily have
[2:49:51] time or resources to do was to
[2:49:52] dig into the actual contracts
[2:49:54] and compare what Long Island
[2:49:57] Power Authority has negotiated
[2:49:58] with the in this case.
[2:50:00] And in that instance you're
[2:50:01] talking about us contracting
[2:50:02] out to sd Jenny so that that
[2:50:05] and how different that is from
[2:50:07] say either the workers contract
[2:50:11] under that with that system
[2:50:13] versus another and how
[2:50:15] different say the revenue or
[2:50:17] model is versus other areas
[2:50:20] where that utility operates
[2:50:22] separately?
[2:50:24] Okay.
[2:50:25] Again, just in terms of us
[2:50:29] understanding options, the pros
[2:50:30] and cons of those options
[2:50:32] hearing what are the main
[2:50:33] sources of anxiety that matter
[2:50:34] to me here which is hardworking
[2:50:37] people not being displaced in
[2:50:38] their jobs, not having their
[2:50:39] jobs place at risk And that's
[2:50:43] seeming to be a thing that was
[2:50:45] worked through in that model
[2:50:47] While also significantly
[2:50:49] reducing management costs.
[2:50:51] It just seems like a thing that
[2:50:54] we should know as a potential
[2:50:55] tool in the tool belt.
[2:50:57] I'll just end with this council
[2:50:59] PRESIDENT.
[2:51:00] I'm glad we're having this
[2:51:01] conversation.
[2:51:02] I think it's important and I
[2:51:05] appreciate Nate your comments.
[2:51:09] The reality is is that this is
[2:51:11] I don't know that there's a
[2:51:13] single issue where I heard have
[2:51:14] heard more agreement amongst
[2:51:18] folks from different sides of
[2:51:19] the political spectrum.
[2:51:20] We had some of the most
[2:51:20] conservative folks who engage
[2:51:22] with the council and some of
[2:51:23] the furthest to the left who
[2:51:25] are in complete agreement that
[2:51:27] what is what we are currently
[2:51:28] operating under is
[2:51:29] unsustainable and unacceptable.
[2:51:32] And if that doesn't show that
[2:51:34] the dam is starting to break,
[2:51:36] that San Diegans are sick and
[2:51:37] tired of paying so much for
[2:51:39] their utility bills I don't
[2:51:41] know what will.
[2:51:42] And it's that's why it's
[2:51:43] incumbent upon us to continue
[2:51:44] this conversation, continue to
[2:51:45] work so that we know what
[2:51:46] options we have to both protect
[2:51:48] workers and protect ratepayers.
[2:51:50] Thank you, Council PRESIDENT.
[2:51:51] All right.
[2:51:52] Well, thank you Council member
[2:51:53] Eli Rivera.
[2:51:54] And as a reminder this is an
[2:51:55] information item and no motion
[2:51:57] is required And I'm going to
[2:52:00] jump in at this point.
[2:52:02] So I want to start out by
[2:52:02] thanking Heather General
[2:52:04] Services Team Randy Wilde and
[2:52:06] the mayor's office and
[2:52:07] the teams that knew Jen and and
[2:52:09] for this work And of course
[2:52:11] thank you to every member of
[2:52:12] the public who showed up
[2:52:13] speaking on all sides of
[2:52:15] the issue And those who called
[2:52:17] in Phase two report was an
[2:52:19] equally impressive undertaking
[2:52:21] as phase one and provided
[2:52:22] greater detail and clarity on a
[2:52:24] proposal that is massive in
[2:52:26] scale and as complex as
[2:52:27] anything we would undertake at
[2:52:28] the city.
[2:52:29] That does not mean we should
[2:52:31] shy away.
[2:52:32] We can and will do big things
[2:52:34] and win Financial impacts on
[2:52:36] residents and businesses is on
[2:52:37] the table.
[2:52:38] We must be bold.
[2:52:40] I will start by highlighting
[2:52:41] the opening slide.
[2:52:43] I mean it's simple Energy
[2:52:44] utility is both economically
[2:52:45] feasible and technically
[2:52:47] feasible.
[2:52:48] That is what the city set out
[2:52:49] to determine and should we
[2:52:51] decide to proceed there is a
[2:52:52] path forward.
[2:52:54] Of course that comes with risks
[2:52:55] that must be weighed and
[2:52:57] assumptions that must be tested
[2:52:59] and we will have to find
[2:53:01] the right balance.
[2:53:02] And whether you feel the study
[2:53:03] has been too conservative in
[2:53:05] its projections or it MAY take
[2:53:07] longer than initially
[2:53:08] anticipated.
[2:53:09] A municipal energy utility
[2:53:10] remains feasible and since
[2:53:12] the outset onset of exploring
[2:53:14] public power and when I voted
[2:53:16] against the current electric
[2:53:18] and gas franchises in 2021 I
[2:53:21] have talked about the limited
[2:53:22] options we have as a city.
[2:53:25] But just as we fought for in
[2:53:27] the creation of the San Diego
[2:53:28] community power in giving
[2:53:30] customers options it would be
[2:53:33] irresponsible of us not to
[2:53:34] pursue pursue alternatives to
[2:53:36] our energy distribution system
[2:53:40] Today's presentation as we've
[2:53:41] heard coincidentally perhaps
[2:53:43] prophetically comes just days
[2:53:45] after sd genius latest general
[2:53:47] rate case submitted to the cpc.
[2:53:50] And as we've heard from members
[2:53:50] of the public sd Janey's own
[2:53:53] projections are substantially
[2:53:54] higher than the average annual
[2:53:56] increase assumed by
[2:53:57] the consultants in the study.
[2:53:59] >> As an engineer I appreciate
[2:54:00] that conservatism moving
[2:54:03] forward with this process
[2:54:04] demonstrates our commitment to
[2:54:06] not sitting back not accepting
[2:54:08] the status quo nor remaining
[2:54:10] vulnerable to a monopoly but
[2:54:12] rather exploring all options to
[2:54:14] provide more affordable rates
[2:54:17] keeping our options open and
[2:54:19] continuing to pursue a
[2:54:21] municipal energy utility is in
[2:54:23] everyone's best interest.
[2:54:25] So for those of you who opposed
[2:54:28] this conversation, look into
[2:54:31] the faces who can't afford but
[2:54:34] don't qualify for subsidies on
[2:54:35] their electric bill.
[2:54:38] And for those of you who
[2:54:39] support, look into the faces of
[2:54:41] the workers who are wondering
[2:54:43] whether they will still have a
[2:54:46] long term career in their
[2:54:48] chosen profession.
[2:54:49] And a promise today is not
[2:54:52] necessarily a promise that will
[2:54:53] be kept.
[2:54:55] The two sides of a conversation
[2:54:58] And for those who oppose
[2:55:01] municipal tell me the question
[2:55:01] I ask you is what are you doing
[2:55:03] to join the city in our efforts
[2:55:06] to control rates, to control
[2:55:09] the impact or reduce the impact
[2:55:11] that is hitting so many San
[2:55:13] Diegans?
[2:55:15] And if those who spoke that
[2:55:18] were prior here at City Hall
[2:55:21] let me remind you you let a 50
[2:55:23] year franchise expire with no
[2:55:26] game plan to give our city
[2:55:28] options or help control rates.
[2:55:31] We missed a golden opportunity
[2:55:33] and 2021 became a very awkward
[2:55:36] year to realize we had no place
[2:55:39] to go and a franchise had to be
[2:55:42] signed to keep the wheels
[2:55:45] turning so to speak.
[2:55:47] So this is a difficult
[2:55:48] conversation.
[2:55:49] I agree with Councilmember Eloy
[2:55:50] Rivera.
[2:55:51] We should keep our options
[2:55:53] open.
[2:55:53] We should continue to pursue a
[2:55:55] municipal energy utility
[2:55:56] because it's in everyone's best
[2:55:58] interest.
[2:55:59] And until we have sd Jeannie
[2:56:01] come to the table, pull that
[2:56:04] general rate increase and have
[2:56:06] the conversation as one member
[2:56:07] of the public I'm not going to
[2:56:08] name.
[2:56:09] He knows who he is and he
[2:56:10] pleasantly surprised me today
[2:56:12] and have a real conversation
[2:56:14] about how we relook at rates
[2:56:17] knowing as some of you have
[2:56:19] said that the cpp is not going
[2:56:21] to save us.
[2:56:22] And as a reminder cpc doesn't
[2:56:25] guarantee profits.
[2:56:27] They set a profit rate to set
[2:56:29] the rates.
[2:56:30] And when I won and the investor
[2:56:33] owned utility exceeds those
[2:56:34] profit rates year after year
[2:56:36] after year.
[2:56:37] Something has to change.
[2:56:39] We have to protect our most
[2:56:41] vulnerable individuals who
[2:56:42] can't afford what should be a
[2:56:45] right of affordable electricity
[2:56:47] going forward.
[2:56:49] >> So that's where we stand
[2:56:50] today.
[2:56:51] I agree that we have to keep
[2:56:53] this on the table going forward
[2:56:55] And again, thank you for
[2:56:56] the good work in this phase two
[2:56:58] study.
[2:56:59] With that again this is an
[2:57:01] information item no motions
[2:57:02] required.
[2:57:03] We'll turn to council member
[2:57:04] Campbell, the third member of
[2:57:06] the Environment Committee.
[2:57:08] >> Thank you so much.
[2:57:09] Council PRESIDENT When first
[2:57:12] elected and thank you for
[2:57:15] the presentation and thanks to
[2:57:16] the public for all of your
[2:57:18] input.
[2:57:19] It's a.
[2:57:20] Agreed with and appreciated on
[2:57:23] all sides.
[2:57:24] This is a really complicated
[2:57:25] issue and I want to say that
[2:57:29] when I was first elected to
[2:57:30] council I was appointed chair
[2:57:31] of the Environment Committee
[2:57:33] That was JANUARY 2019.
[2:57:36] First thing I did was lead
[2:57:37] the effort to create community
[2:57:39] choice aggregation.
[2:57:40] In other words, what became San
[2:57:43] Diego community power does now
[2:57:46] include six cities and our
[2:57:48] county government which means
[2:57:50] our unincorporated areas.
[2:57:52] One of the goals was to provide
[2:57:53] cleaner energy options to
[2:57:55] reduce the effects of climate
[2:57:56] change.
[2:57:58] It also gave our communities
[2:58:00] more local control over how we
[2:58:02] purchase energy And at that
[2:58:04] time the city commissioned
[2:58:05] the first feasibility study on
[2:58:09] municipal izing our energy
[2:58:10] utilities, gas and electric.
[2:58:13] And since then we have
[2:58:14] completed two more studies and
[2:58:16] spent millions of dollars on
[2:58:19] consultants to tell us about
[2:58:24] municipal ization millions of
[2:58:25] dollars we could use this year
[2:58:26] in our budget or in a year in
[2:58:29] our budget.
[2:58:31] The findings have always been
[2:58:33] clear The estimated cost is at
[2:58:37] least 8 billion.
[2:58:38] That was the first study that
[2:58:40] was seven years ago is probably
[2:58:42] 16 billion now and that was
[2:58:45] just for the infrastructure
[2:58:46] needed.
[2:58:47] The city cannot afford this.
[2:58:51] That estimate does not include
[2:58:53] additional cafs costs staffing
[2:58:57] operations and onboarding.
[2:58:59] The impact of exit fees on
[2:59:01] the other 17 cities that rely
[2:59:04] on sd Jeannie system and would
[2:59:07] expect us to pay them
[2:59:09] the difference or the fact that
[2:59:13] we still would need to use sd g
[2:59:16] and e for the gas component.
[2:59:19] So this study was only about
[2:59:21] electricity not the g.
[2:59:23] Part of sd g After three
[2:59:28] studies we do not need more
[2:59:30] analysis.
[2:59:31] We already have the information
[2:59:33] we need to decide at this point
[2:59:35] it is too expensive to continue
[2:59:39] to spend billions of dollars on
[2:59:41] consultants.
[2:59:42] It is way too expensive for
[2:59:45] the billions that the city
[2:59:46] would have to spend to try to.
[2:59:50] To provide this utility.
[2:59:53] It is important to know that
[2:59:56] the state of California public
[2:59:58] utilities Commission, the puc
[3:00:01] it says right there in the law
[3:00:04] is main responsibility is to
[3:00:06] protect ratepayers and also
[3:00:10] decide utility rates In so
[3:00:13] doing to protect ratepayers.
[3:00:16] They're supposed to protect us
[3:00:19] They don't.
[3:00:20] It's supposed to decide utility
[3:00:22] rates within mind us consumers
[3:00:27] The puc needs to be reformed.
[3:00:31] It needs to be held accountable
[3:00:34] and I ask you to please
[3:00:35] inundate them with emails and
[3:00:38] phone calls and letters that
[3:00:40] they need to lower sd any rates
[3:00:43] not raise them.
[3:00:47] Forming San Diego community
[3:00:49] power was a good idea and sd
[3:00:53] Jeannie was in favor and you
[3:00:55] MAY be wondering why Why would
[3:00:57] they have been in favor?
[3:00:58] Because commercial utilities
[3:01:01] are not allowed to make a
[3:01:02] profit on what it costs them to
[3:01:05] buy the power to make
[3:01:06] electricity And so they handed
[3:01:09] this off gladly to the San
[3:01:12] Diego community power.
[3:01:14] Do you know that 95% of
[3:01:16] electric customers have signed
[3:01:18] up for San Diego community
[3:01:19] power?
[3:01:21] It's a good thing It's been
[3:01:24] very successful.
[3:01:25] It has millions of dollars in
[3:01:28] its reserve.
[3:01:29] The question is why have they
[3:01:32] not lowered their rates?
[3:01:35] We need to have them come in
[3:01:36] and answer that for us.
[3:01:39] Meantime, we need to stop
[3:01:41] spending on consultant reports
[3:01:44] I think this last one was $3
[3:01:45] million.
[3:01:47] It's ridiculous.
[3:01:48] Is going to come out the same
[3:01:49] every time.
[3:01:50] It's very, very expensive And
[3:01:53] the city has 100 and $100
[3:01:56] million deficit It can't even
[3:01:57] meet And we're supposed to
[3:02:01] spend 8,000,000,008 billion 60
[3:02:02] billion to become an electric
[3:02:04] company?
[3:02:05] No, no, no.
[3:02:06] That doesn't make any sense at
[3:02:08] all.
[3:02:09] We cannot afford to be a power
[3:02:11] company In the meantime, as dg
[3:02:15] and his top executives and
[3:02:16] those of many other
[3:02:17] corporations in this nation
[3:02:20] need to decide how many
[3:02:22] millions of dollars a year do
[3:02:24] they need to live on?
[3:02:25] This is ridiculous.
[3:02:27] Just as my my colleague
[3:02:30] Councilmember Ella Rivera said,
[3:02:32] the guy in 2025 made $25
[3:02:35] million a year.
[3:02:37] It's ridiculous.
[3:02:39] Think if you only made a couple
[3:02:40] of million dollars a year how
[3:02:42] many rates could be lowered?
[3:02:45] Quite a few.
[3:02:46] Quite a few.
[3:02:47] And so I say to all the top
[3:02:49] executives of the corporations
[3:02:51] in this nation how much money
[3:02:54] do you really need at the cost
[3:02:59] of making your consumers poor?
[3:03:03] Greed is evil.
[3:03:05] Stop practicing it.
[3:03:07] >> Thank you.
[3:03:08] Council PRESIDENT All right.
[3:03:10] Thank you, Council member
[3:03:11] Campbell.
[3:03:12] We'll go next to council member
[3:03:13] Von Walbert.
[3:03:14] Thank you very much for your
[3:03:16] work today and for
[3:03:17] the presentation.
[3:03:17] Thank you for everyone who's
[3:03:19] come in today to express a very
[3:03:22] justified frustration over
[3:03:24] the fact that effigy enables
[3:03:25] continue to go up including our
[3:03:27] own workers who also don't want
[3:03:29] to pay that.
[3:03:30] And I want to thank the workers
[3:03:31] who came in, especially our
[3:03:33] veterans who served in Iraq and
[3:03:35] Afghanistan.
[3:03:36] I can't imagine what you've
[3:03:37] seen.
[3:03:38] You know, this past Memorial
[3:03:40] Day we just did a memorial
[3:03:42] commemorations only for folks
[3:03:44] who died in the Afghanistan and
[3:03:46] Iraqi wars because they were
[3:03:47] our generation.
[3:03:50] And so just know that you have
[3:03:51] sacrificed a lot in coming in
[3:03:53] and getting training from ibew
[3:03:54] which is one of the most
[3:03:55] incredible veterans transition
[3:03:57] employers in this country is
[3:03:59] fantastic And I want to thank
[3:04:01] you for continuing to do that
[3:04:01] work.
[3:04:02] So I know that we up here care
[3:04:03] about you.
[3:04:04] We care about union workers And
[3:04:05] I'm going to show you why what
[3:04:06] we're going to do.
[3:04:08] I also want to thank
[3:04:09] the environmentalist who came
[3:04:10] in San Diego 350 and everyone
[3:04:11] who's been trying to take away
[3:04:13] the monopoly power of this
[3:04:15] company as we should our our
[3:04:18] public power should not be a
[3:04:19] monopoly.
[3:04:20] We should not be paying $22
[3:04:22] million alone To the ceo
[3:04:25] Jeffrey Martin of Sempra last
[3:04:27] year.
[3:04:28] We just should none of us have
[3:04:30] a choice about whether or not
[3:04:31] we pay a fee.
[3:04:32] You need to keep our power on
[3:04:34] but I want everyone who's in
[3:04:36] the room all the union workers
[3:04:37] especially or anyone who works
[3:04:38] at a job to pay attention to
[3:04:39] this.
[3:04:40] This is a public website from
[3:04:42] the Office of Labor Management
[3:04:43] Standards.
[3:04:43] It's under the Department of
[3:04:45] Labor.
[3:04:46] You can check this website to
[3:04:47] see if your employer is paying
[3:04:49] union busters for the most
[3:04:51] part.
[3:04:52] We'll get to Jackson Lewis go
[3:04:53] to the next slide please.
[3:04:54] We did check this website when
[3:04:56] we had to renew the franchise
[3:04:58] agreement as council PRESIDENT
[3:04:59] LaCava said and we all got
[3:05:00] elected up here.
[3:05:02] We were forced with this
[3:05:04] renewal for stg and our
[3:05:05] predecessors didn't do anything
[3:05:06] about it and left it in our
[3:05:08] laps This is a formal Clinton
[3:05:09] report.
[3:05:10] You can see it highlighted.
[3:05:11] It's from c, g and e Studio gas
[3:05:13] and electric from 2019.
[3:05:14] Please go to the next slide.
[3:05:16] This is a public report.
[3:05:17] They have two to show if
[3:05:19] they're going to hire union
[3:05:19] busters they are public facing
[3:05:22] in 2019 as you paid tens of
[3:05:25] thousands of dollars of our
[3:05:26] rate payer money to hire crews
[3:05:28] and associates to be their
[3:05:29] independent labor consultant
[3:05:30] who is known nationwide to be
[3:05:32] one of the biggest union
[3:05:33] busters in the nation.
[3:05:35] They were trying to rent steel
[3:05:37] you need from hiring from
[3:05:37] unionizing the coal center
[3:05:39] workers And I know ibew came to
[3:05:41] the call center Workers Aid and
[3:05:42] made sure this didn't happen
[3:05:43] before the next slide please.
[3:05:45] This is the one from 2018 which
[3:05:48] you can see Crews Associates
[3:05:49] was paid This one I think was
[3:05:50] signed by Scott Crider who is
[3:05:52] now I believe the ceo of cgt.
[3:05:55] They paid them $33,000 to hire
[3:05:57] union busters to fight
[3:05:59] The unionized work to cgt had
[3:06:00] been hiring union busters And
[3:06:02] when they came to this Dyess to
[3:06:03] get a renewal I required cgt
[3:06:06] their ceo to say they would not
[3:06:08] hire union busters again with
[3:06:09] our money And you agreed?
[3:06:13] I think at the end of
[3:06:13] the slides you do down And so
[3:06:17] I'm really upset to see that
[3:06:19] when ibew tried to get some of
[3:06:21] their supervisor employees who
[3:06:23] don't actually supervise anyone
[3:06:24] into the union which is a
[3:06:25] common union busting tactic for
[3:06:26] an employer to say they have
[3:06:29] supervisory responsibilities
[3:06:30] which they don't You hired
[3:06:32] Jackson Lewis but guess what?
[3:06:34] You don't have to report that
[3:06:35] because there's a loophole in
[3:06:37] federal law that says if you
[3:06:38] hire a lawyer to you your union
[3:06:39] busting you can call it legal
[3:06:41] services.
[3:06:43] Congress can change this law
[3:06:44] and I hope they do.
[3:06:45] They haven't anyway, I am sick
[3:06:47] and tired of seeing cgt crush
[3:06:49] its workers at our expense and
[3:06:51] I want you to know that
[3:06:52] everyone on this diet is going
[3:06:53] to work hard to make sure
[3:06:54] whatever transition happens
[3:06:56] union jobs are protected.
[3:06:58] You do incredibly hard work at
[3:07:00] a high voltage and none of us
[3:07:01] are trying to do and we
[3:07:02] respected value for that.
[3:07:04] If you need me on a strike line
[3:07:05] call me.
[3:07:05] I'll be there.
[3:07:07] That said, I'm questions First
[3:07:13] of all what would taking over
[3:07:16] the power structure look
[3:07:19] the power infrastructure look
[3:07:20] like Obviously you need is not
[3:07:22] willing to sell their assets.
[3:07:23] So legally what would the city
[3:07:24] do if we were to do that?
[3:07:28] >> So if we use the San
[3:07:29] Francisco model as the current
[3:07:32] Calif fornia template San
[3:07:35] Francisco City County they're
[3:07:36] all one thing did make an offer
[3:07:39] to pge to purchase the wires in
[3:07:42] their system and you kind of
[3:07:44] didn't pick up the phone So San
[3:07:45] Francisco petitioned to
[3:07:46] the cpsc which regulates pge to
[3:07:51] require pge to to establish a
[3:07:54] purchase price.
[3:07:55] >> So that is as Scott
[3:07:57] mentioned, the biggest variable
[3:07:58] about how all of this modeling
[3:08:00] and economics really works
[3:08:01] where feasible, where your cash
[3:08:02] flow is, etc. That is now a
[3:08:05] process that is ongoing.
[3:08:06] The first decision came out in
[3:08:08] the fall and that set
[3:08:10] the framework of what has to
[3:08:12] happen afterwards which
[3:08:14] includes prey's appraisals of
[3:08:16] the system by both parties,
[3:08:17] multiple different valuations
[3:08:19] and a basic set of principles
[3:08:21] regarding things like just
[3:08:23] compensation etc. So we know
[3:08:26] that that step is in there.
[3:08:30] >> There is our current
[3:08:32] understanding and I will I am
[3:08:33] not a lawyer so a grain of salt
[3:08:36] a high probability that at some
[3:08:38] point an action like this would
[3:08:40] probably need to go to
[3:08:41] the ballot.
[3:08:43] And so one of the I would say
[3:08:45] the next step that moves this
[3:08:46] past feasibility if there is
[3:08:48] interest in continuing this
[3:08:49] effort is moves it into
[3:08:52] the kind of political
[3:08:54] regulatory legal area.
[3:08:59] >> What that looks like really
[3:09:01] frankly is a discussion and
[3:09:03] guidance that will be given to
[3:09:04] staff from discussions between
[3:09:07] the mayor's office and council
[3:09:09] Randi, I don't know if you have
[3:09:09] anything to add.
[3:09:14] I would say that there is not
[3:09:16] currently allocated resources
[3:09:17] to go hire more consultants or
[3:09:20] staff resources to go do a lot
[3:09:23] of that work in this current
[3:09:24] fiscal year.
[3:09:25] So our intention is to watch
[3:09:26] closely what happens with
[3:09:28] the San Francisco case.
[3:09:29] Well not exactly the same
[3:09:30] scenario as what would be
[3:09:33] the case in San Diego for a
[3:09:34] number of different reasons
[3:09:35] would certainly set a lot of
[3:09:37] precedents in terms of
[3:09:38] the valuation methodology and
[3:09:40] the process that the city of
[3:09:42] San Diego would go through.
[3:09:43] I think there's other decisions
[3:09:44] that would need to be made if
[3:09:46] the city were to move forward,
[3:09:47] what would be the structure of
[3:09:48] the new entity?
[3:09:50] Would that be a special
[3:09:51] district as recommended in
[3:09:52] the report?
[3:09:53] What type of a special district
[3:09:54] would that be?
[3:09:56] That MAY or MAY not require a
[3:09:57] ballot measure or a vote of
[3:09:59] the people depending on how
[3:10:00] that structured MAY or MAY not
[3:10:01] require less co component.
[3:10:04] Again, I'm also not an attorney
[3:10:05] so I would defer to them on
[3:10:06] that.
[3:10:07] But there's a number of
[3:10:07] different decisions that need
[3:10:08] to be made about the structure
[3:10:10] and the process.
[3:10:11] But I think that the highest
[3:10:12] priority for us since this is
[3:10:14] kind of the new process
[3:10:16] established by the state is
[3:10:17] through this cpc is to really
[3:10:19] monitor closely what happens in
[3:10:20] the San Francisco pge case.
[3:10:23] Okay.
[3:10:24] i have a question for a
[3:10:24] question about the district.
[3:10:25] So I, I, I do believe that
[3:10:29] the power system should be
[3:10:30] governed by a nonprofit.
[3:10:32] I do not believe the city of
[3:10:34] San Diego as a beautiful
[3:10:35] corporation is ready to take
[3:10:36] this on.
[3:10:38] We can barely operate a water
[3:10:39] department.
[3:10:41] We are struggling to figure out
[3:10:42] if we can deploy our own
[3:10:43] ambulance system if we have to
[3:10:44] bring that in-house.
[3:10:45] But I do believe there's
[3:10:47] another opportunity and that is
[3:10:48] what Sacramento did with
[3:10:50] the Sacramento Municipal
[3:10:51] Utility District And this is
[3:10:52] what I hope the advocates
[3:10:53] listen to the city ceo you you
[3:10:56] get a sales tax passed last
[3:10:57] year because voters didn't
[3:10:58] trust us.
[3:10:59] I think the better option is
[3:11:01] not to saddle this on the city
[3:11:02] the better option is to create
[3:11:04] a public utility district which
[3:11:06] is run by experts And but
[3:11:08] the only way anyone would vote
[3:11:10] for this and I would vote for
[3:11:11] this is if there was concrete
[3:11:13] new protections for union
[3:11:14] workers and they should have a
[3:11:15] role in the ballot measure if
[3:11:16] we're ever to get to that point
[3:11:18] because there's no way I would
[3:11:20] You're working with us and we
[3:11:20] need our workers to provide
[3:11:21] the power we need anyway.
[3:11:24] So how would that process look
[3:11:25] like?
[3:11:27] >> As Randy mentioned,
[3:11:29] the special district process
[3:11:30] looks different depending on
[3:11:32] one or multiple parties going
[3:11:34] after it.
[3:11:35] This is all kind of outlined in
[3:11:37] California Public utilities
[3:11:38] code so various structures
[3:11:42] require votes by council and
[3:11:47] then going to the ballot Some
[3:11:48] of them it can be go to
[3:11:49] the ballot directly.
[3:11:50] So a lot of it is the structure
[3:11:52] that is put in place and
[3:11:53] therefore the special district
[3:11:54] is defined by public utility
[3:11:56] code.
[3:11:56] I'm happy to follow up with you
[3:11:58] with those specific areas of
[3:11:59] law.
[3:11:59] I do not want to even attempt
[3:12:00] to quote them off the cuff yet.
[3:12:03] >> Sounds like a lack of
[3:12:03] question.
[3:12:07] Understood that a question
[3:12:07] about this valuation I have a
[3:12:09] feeling it's going to be much
[3:12:10] higher than what's even the $7
[3:12:11] billion just because you know I
[3:12:14] don't think you do You wouldn't
[3:12:16] willingly sell its assets which
[3:12:18] means it would go to some kind
[3:12:19] of eminent domain for closure.
[3:12:22] I don't know.
[3:12:22] And that would be litigated
[3:12:23] every step of the way which
[3:12:25] would increase the cost
[3:12:26] exponentially.
[3:12:26] So just I have a feeling that
[3:12:29] what's going to happen in San
[3:12:29] Francisco a wealthy the one
[3:12:33] thing I do give you credit for
[3:12:35] every time we're here is
[3:12:37] the wildfire work they are
[3:12:38] doing which the Witch Creek
[3:12:40] Fire didn't have to happen to
[3:12:41] have that led down that path by
[3:12:43] the emergency operation center
[3:12:45] to see if you need to start up
[3:12:46] is state of the art.
[3:12:47] It's incredible.
[3:12:49] It's catching fires left and
[3:12:50] right And I appreciate the fact
[3:12:51] that they've also invested in
[3:12:52] wildfire attack helicopters.
[3:12:54] So does this study also
[3:12:56] encapsulate the cost of taking
[3:12:58] over the emergency operations
[3:12:59] center Because we cannot take
[3:13:01] over utility if we're not going
[3:13:02] to protect us from wildfires.
[3:13:05] It doesn't because the vast
[3:13:06] majority of the area that
[3:13:09] the eoc monitors is not within
[3:13:13] the city of San Diego.
[3:13:14] It does imagine a portion of
[3:13:16] the costs that currently are
[3:13:17] expended within wildfire
[3:13:18] mitigation as a part of
[3:13:20] the overall operating costs and
[3:13:22] thus a revenue requirement for
[3:13:24] the utility as well as pieces
[3:13:27] of you know there's someone
[3:13:29] mentioned liability so there's
[3:13:30] liability insurance etc. So
[3:13:32] that would need to be carried
[3:13:33] for those areas that are
[3:13:34] subject to it.
[3:13:35] But again I think it's
[3:13:37] remembering that if you're
[3:13:38] separating out the system, what
[3:13:40] now there also then would need
[3:13:42] to be coordination between
[3:13:43] the two and that kind of goes
[3:13:45] to about just compensation
[3:13:47] piece of how much has already
[3:13:50] been paid for by San Diego
[3:13:53] ratepayers how much would
[3:13:55] therefore need to be And some
[3:13:56] of that is also subject to you
[3:14:00] know the cpc as was mentioned
[3:14:01] as dgt makes a revenue request
[3:14:02] specifically within
[3:14:03] the wildfire mitigation fund
[3:14:05] that includes the cost of
[3:14:06] operation of the that's the cpc
[3:14:07] then decides how much of that
[3:14:08] can and cannot be rate based or
[3:14:10] should or should not be
[3:14:11] expended.
[3:14:13] And so what role for
[3:14:15] the municipal utility in an
[3:14:19] area that is definitely at risk
[3:14:22] because of fires in not its
[3:14:23] territory pays and plays in
[3:14:26] the operations to ensure that
[3:14:28] those fires don't get anywhere
[3:14:30] near the territory would all be
[3:14:32] part of the negotiations
[3:14:33] between the parties.
[3:14:34] So the feasibility study
[3:14:35] incorporates modeled costs for
[3:14:39] that but it doesn't outline for
[3:14:41] a whole bunch of reasons how
[3:14:42] specifically those negotiations
[3:14:44] would go because simply we
[3:14:45] can't speak for the other side
[3:14:46] of the table.
[3:14:48] Okay, got it.
[3:14:50] But that would be something
[3:14:50] that's incredibly important
[3:14:52] that needs to be thought about.
[3:14:54] Absolutely.
[3:14:56] Yeah, I was I suppose you would
[3:14:58] require utility to do something
[3:14:59] similar So we satellite involve
[3:15:02] ours of another state but there
[3:15:03] are many things I wish the cbc
[3:15:04] would do.
[3:15:06] Okay.
[3:15:06] Okay.
[3:15:07] My last my colleagues have
[3:15:11] covered a lot of this.
[3:15:12] I mean what about the fact that
[3:15:14] there's an 8.6% request for a
[3:15:16] rate hike and the feasibility
[3:15:17] study had anticipated four per
[3:15:19] year?
[3:15:19] You know what is this large
[3:15:20] hike that I see Judy want to
[3:15:22] add to our bills once again due
[3:15:24] to the feasibility study?
[3:15:26] Sure.
[3:15:26] So I think some of the thing to
[3:15:28] remember is over a 30 year
[3:15:29] horizon we specifically picked
[3:15:30] 4% one because historically in
[3:15:32] the past two grc that's
[3:15:34] approximately been the end
[3:15:36] decision.
[3:15:37] So cgu usually asks for more
[3:15:39] money and then it gets cut down
[3:15:41] through the grc process.
[3:15:44] So fundamentally if you look at
[3:15:46] that sensitivity graph,
[3:15:48] the higher the rate increase
[3:15:50] annually for us, Jenny,
[3:15:52] the more cumulative benefit
[3:15:53] there would be for utility that
[3:15:56] is only replacing its revenue
[3:15:58] requirements, right?
[3:16:00] And so you can kind of say if
[3:16:02] their rates are significantly
[3:16:03] higher than they're saying
[3:16:04] their revenue requirement is
[3:16:06] significantly higher than
[3:16:07] the That's what that
[3:16:08] distinction is because this is
[3:16:12] just their proposal.
[3:16:12] We don't know what the cpc is
[3:16:14] going to decide And because it
[3:16:15] is frankly only a four year
[3:16:17] picture and we're trying to do
[3:16:18] a 30 year model providing a
[3:16:22] conservative estimate is gives
[3:16:25] us and it's still feasible at
[3:16:27] 4% then at 6% it is also
[3:16:29] feasible from an economic
[3:16:31] perspective at 8% it is still
[3:16:33] feasible from an economic
[3:16:34] perspective.
[3:16:34] So it's 8% increase in 20 I'm
[3:16:38] sorry it's overall in
[3:16:40] the system it's actually a 5%
[3:16:42] increase in f y 28 sorry in
[3:16:44] 2028 from 2027 rates So we
[3:16:47] haven't seen those yet.
[3:16:49] 2028 is 8.5% and then 20 sorry
[3:16:53] 2029 is 8.5% and then 2030 and
[3:16:54] 2031 about 5.5%.
[3:16:56] So again we're trying to blend
[3:16:57] out a 30 year annual rate
[3:17:00] increase in order to make those
[3:17:02] numbers line up accurately and
[3:17:05] ensure when we say it's
[3:17:06] economically feasible you're
[3:17:08] doing that with a responsibly
[3:17:12] conservative number on
[3:17:14] the Jenny side so you're not
[3:17:17] overpromising savings that MAY
[3:17:18] or MAY not manifest.
[3:17:20] Okay.
[3:17:21] Understood.
[3:17:21] Thank you.
[3:17:22] Thank you for the update.
[3:17:24] Thank you for going down this
[3:17:25] incredibly complex study and
[3:17:28] what we're trying to do to at
[3:17:29] least give the city and
[3:17:31] the residents who live here
[3:17:32] some kind of negotiating power
[3:17:33] over city.
[3:17:36] You know, it's very hard to do
[3:17:38] that when did the monopoly but
[3:17:40] it has to include protections
[3:17:41] for our workers who work very
[3:17:43] hard to make sure the lights
[3:17:44] and the gas are literally
[3:17:45] turned on every day And it
[3:17:47] needs to account for
[3:17:48] the catastrophic litigation
[3:17:51] costs that are going to come
[3:17:52] with trying to separate from
[3:17:53] this.
[3:17:54] But again, that's why I think
[3:17:55] the utility district would be
[3:17:56] better to take this on to
[3:17:57] the city of San Diego itself
[3:17:59] because that could be a fight
[3:18:01] the good fight the city and I
[3:18:02] don't think we can do this on
[3:18:03] our own in a city needs to
[3:18:08] charge lower rates.
[3:18:10] We have no ability to handle
[3:18:13] that here at the city of San
[3:18:14] Diego We did Under California
[3:18:15] state law it is Sacramento to
[3:18:18] decide how and when a city
[3:18:19] charges its rates.
[3:18:20] However, in the next few years
[3:18:22] in 20 2030 our franchise
[3:18:25] agreement could be opened up
[3:18:26] again by the future City
[3:18:27] Council who sits here.
[3:18:28] I will be termed out.
[3:18:29] Many of us will be turned out
[3:18:30] but we are trying to do is make
[3:18:31] sure that 2030 if the future
[3:18:33] Council wants to put
[3:18:34] the pressure on cgt to lower
[3:18:36] rates they will now be able to
[3:18:37] do that because of the work
[3:18:38] we're doing going down this
[3:18:40] road with the public
[3:18:41] marketability study and we need
[3:18:42] to continue to strengthen our
[3:18:43] hand to lower rates for our
[3:18:44] state.
[3:18:45] You need to they charge too
[3:18:46] much.
[3:18:47] Thank you.
[3:18:48] All right.
[3:18:49] Thank you, gentlemen.
[3:18:50] Bonneville We'll go next to
[3:18:50] Councilmember Flippen.
[3:18:52] Thank you, Council PRESIDENT.
[3:18:54] First of all, thank you to
[3:18:55] everybody who provided public
[3:18:58] comment this afternoon.
[3:18:59] I took a lot of notes, very
[3:19:00] interesting comments from
[3:19:03] everybody here appreciated that
[3:19:04] I have a few questions for our
[3:19:06] consultant There is it says
[3:19:09] the potential for average
[3:19:11] customer savings of $500 a year
[3:19:14] or which would equate to about
[3:19:16] $42 about the end of the 30
[3:19:19] year study period is that in
[3:19:22] today's dollars 30 years from
[3:19:25] now $42 MAY not seem like that
[3:19:29] much.
[3:19:30] So if you say the potential
[3:19:30] savings then would be
[3:19:32] the equivalent of what $42
[3:19:34] about this today or would it be
[3:19:37] $42.30 years from now to
[3:19:39] the extent the analysis is
[3:19:40] looking at a sort of average
[3:19:41] bill, it would be in today's
[3:19:42] dollars We're looking at
[3:19:43] the percentage that were
[3:19:45] proposed or was projected to be
[3:19:47] relative to the savings.
[3:19:50] And looking at the flip side,
[3:19:52] you talk about the risk What
[3:19:55] would be the worst case
[3:19:56] scenario if things went south
[3:20:00] in term in real terms what bad
[3:20:02] things could happen to the city
[3:20:07] in terms of what bad things I
[3:20:09] mean, you know, who knows,
[3:20:10] right?
[3:20:11] I mean you could say that that
[3:20:13] I mean I don't really know that
[3:20:16] to tell you the truth.
[3:20:17] But what bad things could
[3:20:18] happen is that is that the you
[3:20:20] know, the utility could incur
[3:20:22] you know, costs like any other
[3:20:24] utility incurred costs and have
[3:20:26] to pass those costs on to a
[3:20:27] ratepayer right Just in terms
[3:20:29] of commodity cost, in terms of
[3:20:33] all the costs that it takes
[3:20:36] operating ability there's
[3:20:37] there's always a potential
[3:20:38] those costs could exceed beyond
[3:20:40] what anybody could imagine and
[3:20:43] then in which case those costs
[3:20:44] would have to be recovered by
[3:20:46] ratepayers.
[3:20:46] Okay.
[3:20:47] So essentially you're not
[3:20:49] seeing a lot of financial risk
[3:20:52] for the city as I mean it's a
[3:20:55] poor entity in of itself.
[3:20:56] You would see the financial
[3:20:57] risk as being contained within
[3:20:59] the utility structure.
[3:21:02] Okay.
[3:21:05] You've prepared a 200 page
[3:21:07] report and analysis on
[3:21:10] the feasibility Based on what
[3:21:12] you know in your expertise, do
[3:21:14] you think that San Diego should
[3:21:15] go to a minimal utility?
[3:21:17] I believe the report suggests
[3:21:18] that it's financially feasible
[3:21:20] to do so.
[3:21:22] Okay.
[3:21:24] I will turn now to the Office
[3:21:26] of the Independent Budget
[3:21:27] Analyst MR. Boer, your thoughts
[3:21:31] on this?
[3:21:35] My thoughts on this are many So
[3:21:40] I will tell you what I've been
[3:21:42] telling sort of leading up to
[3:21:43] this meeting.
[3:21:43] >> I've had many meetings I've
[3:21:45] met with general Services, I've
[3:21:46] met with Public power San
[3:21:47] Diego, I've met with San Diego
[3:21:49] Gas and Electric all three
[3:21:51] entities the same thing.
[3:21:52] We've had three studies.
[3:21:54] They're all directionally
[3:21:55] pointing the same direction
[3:21:57] which is yeah, it's most likely
[3:21:58] economically feasible.
[3:22:00] The questions that are still
[3:22:02] being raised how much is it
[3:22:04] going to cost?
[3:22:04] What's the revenue projections
[3:22:06] going to look like?
[3:22:07] Those types of things Another
[3:22:09] study is not going to tell you
[3:22:10] because there are things that
[3:22:12] need to be worked out either
[3:22:13] through the cpc proceeding or
[3:22:16] somebody writing down on a
[3:22:18] ballot measure What is this
[3:22:20] thing going to look like?
[3:22:21] What is structure going to be
[3:22:22] and how is it going to operate
[3:22:24] And then sending that ballot
[3:22:25] measure to the people for a
[3:22:26] decision.
[3:22:27] So at this point I think
[3:22:29] the study is sound.
[3:22:31] It's a sound of the committee.
[3:22:32] It's showing a path that could
[3:22:34] be taken with known risks At
[3:22:37] this point as Heather kind of
[3:22:39] alluded to earlier, it's now a
[3:22:41] policy decision on what
[3:22:43] the people want to do.
[3:22:44] How would you want to frame it
[3:22:45] and how would you want to craft
[3:22:46] If you want to craft a ballot
[3:22:48] measure, how is that going to
[3:22:49] look That will start answering
[3:22:51] a lot of the questions that are
[3:22:53] here today but it's kind of
[3:22:56] going above the staff paper of
[3:22:58] you know what they can answer
[3:23:00] for you.
[3:23:02] Okay.
[3:23:05] Thank you, Council PRESIDENT.
[3:23:06] All right.
[3:23:07] Thank you, gentlemen.
[3:23:08] Whitburn we'll go next to
[3:23:09] Council member Campion Thank
[3:23:11] you very much, Council
[3:23:12] PRESIDENT And thank you to
[3:23:13] the public for your
[3:23:14] participation today.
[3:23:18] Obviously a very big
[3:23:19] conversation for our city
[3:23:20] talking about over $10 billion
[3:23:23] in one way or another in cost
[3:23:26] and potentially more than that
[3:23:27] in savings.
[3:23:29] I want to get to the heart of
[3:23:31] some key questions that keep
[3:23:34] coming up in this is it's not
[3:23:36] very often we have both sides
[3:23:37] of the debate here to be able
[3:23:39] to answer them.
[3:23:40] I think the first thing I want
[3:23:41] to point out is that we're not
[3:23:42] going to get anywhere without
[3:23:44] our workers who repair
[3:23:47] the lines and make sure our
[3:23:48] energy gets to our hospitals.
[3:23:50] Schools and homes are taken
[3:23:51] care of and that their jobs are
[3:23:54] protected because they're just
[3:23:55] too many livelihoods at risk to
[3:23:57] make sure that they don't don't
[3:24:00] get to continue their careers,
[3:24:02] have their retirements
[3:24:03] protected and their families
[3:24:05] cared for.
[3:24:08] The representative from sd
[3:24:10] Eugenie would come to that
[3:24:12] answer a few questions just
[3:24:13] very directly.
[3:24:20] Thank you.
[3:24:20] MRS..
[3:24:22] Thank you for being here.
[3:24:24] Given the report that's in
[3:24:25] front of us very explicitly and
[3:24:28] directly, what is the issue
[3:24:30] that you believe makes whether
[3:24:34] it's municipal ization or a
[3:24:37] nonprofit utility which are
[3:24:39] very close to the same in this
[3:24:41] debate?
[3:24:42] What's what do you think is
[3:24:44] the most risky part of that
[3:24:47] plan?
[3:24:47] Sure.
[3:24:48] I think the riskiest part of
[3:24:49] the plan is the cost.
[3:24:50] I don't think this report
[3:24:52] captures the full cost to
[3:24:54] acquire our assets And as I was
[3:24:57] talking about the exit fee to
[3:24:58] make other customers whole.
[3:25:00] So if you even take the 9
[3:25:04] billion just to acquire
[3:25:05] the assets, separate
[3:25:06] the separate the system and
[3:25:09] then ensure that the other
[3:25:11] cities in our territory.
[3:25:13] Chula Vista Imperial Beach
[3:25:16] Alcohol and Carlsbad don't see
[3:25:18] a significant rate increase
[3:25:19] when the city leaves The city
[3:25:21] of San Diego would have to pay
[3:25:23] a significant fee to ensure
[3:25:25] that that that doesn't happen.
[3:25:26] That would be billions of
[3:25:28] dollars.
[3:25:28] So you're taking an asset to
[3:25:31] purchase the assets of $9.3
[3:25:34] billion and then several
[3:25:35] billion dollars on top of that.
[3:25:37] The feasibility study itself
[3:25:38] says that it's $7.5 billion.
[3:25:41] There will be a rate increase
[3:25:43] for the first 12 years.
[3:25:44] Then at some point rates going
[3:25:46] to flatten out And in 30 years
[3:25:48] there's a very de minimus
[3:25:50] decrease in rates.
[3:25:51] I can just things that we can
[3:25:53] be doing right now to reduce
[3:25:54] rates that we'd love to work
[3:25:56] with the City council on.
[3:25:57] I think I've talked to many of
[3:25:58] your officers about this Almost
[3:26:00] 30% of our bills are made up of
[3:26:03] state mandates and we would
[3:26:04] love to work with the city
[3:26:05] the city council.
[3:26:06] We're happy to come in to talk
[3:26:08] to you.
[3:26:08] Let's work at this at
[3:26:09] Sacramento and take these cost
[3:26:12] ineffective things out of our
[3:26:13] bills would immediately reduce
[3:26:15] bills JANUARY first.
[3:26:18] Okay.
[3:26:18] Thank you.
[3:26:18] Okay.
[3:26:20] From public power San Diego
[3:26:23] the issue of the cost.
[3:26:26] But when I looked at
[3:26:28] the spreadsheet realizing that
[3:26:30] 4% was the 4%, was it assumed
[3:26:34] increase in electrical rates
[3:26:36] annually?
[3:26:37] Right.
[3:26:38] I think far higher than that in
[3:26:39] the last ten years.
[3:26:40] Right.
[3:26:40] Almost a doubling in 13 years.
[3:26:43] 14 years, something like that.
[3:26:44] Correct?
[3:26:45] Generally speaking, yes.
[3:26:46] Okay.
[3:26:47] So the cost of the system
[3:26:49] relative to the cost to
[3:26:51] the ratepayers that we're
[3:26:53] seeing someone from San Diego,
[3:26:56] what would you address that
[3:26:57] issue related to
[3:26:58] the disassociation cost that
[3:27:00] we're going to have to pay to
[3:27:02] the other municipalities
[3:27:04] Because I know that one model
[3:27:06] of this is to not take over
[3:27:07] the transmission.
[3:27:08] It's only to take over
[3:27:10] the distribution.
[3:27:12] What's your response to what
[3:27:13] MRS. Just said about that fee
[3:27:16] We'd have to pay other cities.
[3:27:18] Well there is no fee yet that
[3:27:21] we might pay.
[3:27:21] I think I would side with I
[3:27:24] think Heather's comment that
[3:27:26] all of this would be a
[3:27:27] negotiation.
[3:27:29] We don't know where that's
[3:27:30] going to land.
[3:27:31] We talked about how much fire
[3:27:34] exposure we have as a city That
[3:27:36] would be it's partly in
[3:27:37] the model already but this idea
[3:27:40] that there are billions pending
[3:27:43] that we would have to pay is
[3:27:45] based on nothing at this point
[3:27:48] That would be something we
[3:27:50] would discuss.
[3:27:50] But keep in mind the electrical
[3:27:53] workers would stay.
[3:27:55] They would be maintaining
[3:27:56] the system.
[3:27:56] I just wanted you to focus on
[3:27:58] that part portion that she
[3:27:59] brought up.
[3:28:00] I know there's lots of
[3:28:01] components that have been
[3:28:01] brought up to date but you're
[3:28:02] telling me we just don't know
[3:28:04] what that true cost to
[3:28:05] the associate would be here?
[3:28:06] Would there be no cost if we
[3:28:07] just did distribution instead
[3:28:09] of taking over transmission
[3:28:10] lines or the beauty of doing
[3:28:12] distribution?
[3:28:13] Not only is we would have no
[3:28:16] lack of exposure so we have
[3:28:18] years of delay to to look at
[3:28:20] this but it's important to know
[3:28:23] that those electrical workers
[3:28:25] would be maintaining and
[3:28:26] operating the system in San
[3:28:28] Diego.
[3:28:29] Those costs wouldn't be costs
[3:28:31] that other cities would bear.
[3:28:33] We would bear our own cost So
[3:28:35] it's very much to be negotiated
[3:28:37] what additional costs we might
[3:28:39] have to bear as well.
[3:28:40] Okay.
[3:28:41] One second.
[3:28:42] Given that our business manager
[3:28:43] for these workers here in
[3:28:45] the room, MR. Ferryman, can I
[3:28:46] ask you a quick question
[3:28:47] related to that component of
[3:28:49] this potential model?
[3:28:51] What impact on workers could
[3:28:51] you guys work on all
[3:28:52] the electrical lines We're
[3:28:57] going to get some I'm here with
[3:28:57] Nate.
[3:28:58] Okay.
[3:28:58] Thank you for being here.
[3:29:02] The transmission versus
[3:29:03] distribution concept here
[3:29:06] the transmission lines cross
[3:29:07] municipal boundaries that I
[3:29:09] understand could open us up to
[3:29:11] a price We have to pay other
[3:29:13] municipalities but just a
[3:29:13] distribution.
[3:29:14] How many workers of that would
[3:29:16] it impact that you represent?
[3:29:20] I would say anywhere from 100
[3:29:22] to 200 directly but then you're
[3:29:24] reducing the size of
[3:29:26] the primary group at as many as
[3:29:28] your lowering their bargaining
[3:29:29] strength indirectly about 1800
[3:29:32] directly about 1 to 200.
[3:29:34] Okay, understood.
[3:29:35] So MRS. If we did a
[3:29:39] distribution model as opposed
[3:29:41] to taking over any transmission
[3:29:43] lines, would we still be
[3:29:45] exposed to those cut off fees
[3:29:48] or or exit fees please?
[3:29:51] Absolutely.
[3:29:52] If you're taking out a portion
[3:29:54] of our system and a portion of
[3:29:55] our customers, those costs that
[3:29:58] are fixed costs are still going
[3:29:59] to need to be spread across
[3:30:00] the remaining customers And now
[3:30:02] you no longer have the city of
[3:30:04] San Diego as part of that as
[3:30:07] part of those customers paying
[3:30:08] for those other costs.
[3:30:09] So absolutely if you separate
[3:30:11] the distribution cost out,
[3:30:12] the remaining customers will
[3:30:14] still see an increased cost.
[3:30:16] Okay.
[3:30:17] Transmission is where sd Genie
[3:30:19] makes its profit.
[3:30:20] Correct?
[3:30:23] I don't understand.
[3:30:24] So generation of the energy you
[3:30:26] have to sell it at the value it
[3:30:28] costs you to do it So there's
[3:30:29] no profit on the actual
[3:30:30] creation of it.
[3:30:31] The profit margin comes from
[3:30:33] the transmission cost from
[3:30:35] where it's generated out to
[3:30:36] the customers, correct?
[3:30:38] Well, the profit comes from
[3:30:39] both the distribute and
[3:30:41] the transmission.
[3:30:41] Okay.
[3:30:42] So it's from our infrastructure
[3:30:44] that we build everything from
[3:30:46] that batteries, transmission
[3:30:47] lines, distribution lines It's
[3:30:49] the entire infrastructure
[3:30:50] system.
[3:30:51] Okay.
[3:30:52] I guess a question as it
[3:30:53] relates to the economics of
[3:30:54] this is the transmission
[3:31:00] crosses multiple cities, maybe
[3:31:02] even multiple counties, right?
[3:31:03] Absolutely.
[3:31:03] Okay.
[3:31:04] So there's a profit that's
[3:31:05] built into that component that
[3:31:07] goes to the entire system.
[3:31:09] But after it gets to a
[3:31:10] distribution hub say in Sierra
[3:31:12] mesa in my district and down to
[3:31:13] the homes, then there's a
[3:31:15] different profit component
[3:31:16] that's part of that correct?
[3:31:20] Yes.
[3:31:20] Okay.
[3:31:20] It's the same concept though.
[3:31:22] Okay.
[3:31:22] When the infrastructure is
[3:31:24] built we are making the profit
[3:31:26] on building the infrastructure
[3:31:27] whether it's transmission or
[3:31:29] distribution.
[3:31:29] Okay.
[3:31:30] I guess I'm wondering is why
[3:31:31] would why would we have to pay
[3:31:34] an exit fee after the energy
[3:31:36] already crosses into the city
[3:31:38] of San Diego to a distribution
[3:31:39] center And and then so we'd
[3:31:43] have to pay to la Masons and
[3:31:46] people from Poway and other
[3:31:49] cities when it's crossed over
[3:31:51] the line it's now in the city
[3:31:52] And then the utility
[3:31:53] the nonprofit utility would
[3:31:55] ostensibly take control of it
[3:31:56] at that point.
[3:31:58] So Genie would still be making
[3:31:59] a profit from the transmission
[3:32:02] And at that point it's not
[3:32:03] really affecting the Masons and
[3:32:06] folks from power would it?
[3:32:08] Right.
[3:32:08] But there's fixed costs what
[3:32:09] you just said.
[3:32:09] Right.
[3:32:10] Well I'm sorry.
[3:32:12] Don't catch me.
[3:32:14] I'll explain it.
[3:32:16] There are fixed costs across
[3:32:17] the entire system.
[3:32:18] Don't build our system
[3:32:19] including the distribution
[3:32:20] system.
[3:32:21] City boundaries only.
[3:32:21] Okay?
[3:32:23] You don't say We're building it
[3:32:25] out for La mesa.
[3:32:26] Done Now to do another foot in
[3:32:28] San Diego.
[3:32:29] So the distribution system also
[3:32:31] crosses the borders So just
[3:32:32] cutting it off there's still
[3:32:34] fixed costs that go both ways
[3:32:36] And so to serve the system as a
[3:32:38] whole So you're taking our
[3:32:40] customers out of the city of
[3:32:42] San Diego out of the system and
[3:32:44] there are still fixed costs
[3:32:45] that will be part of
[3:32:46] the distribution and
[3:32:47] transmission system that would
[3:32:49] then be shouldered by
[3:32:50] the remaining customers no
[3:32:52] longer the customers from
[3:32:53] the city of San Diego.
[3:32:55] But if a transmission line
[3:32:56] crosses from some other county
[3:32:58] or part of the part of
[3:32:59] the county into our city and
[3:33:02] we've disassociated from
[3:33:03] the ecosystem as you're
[3:33:05] pointing out, it doesn't seem
[3:33:07] to me that la Masons would pay
[3:33:10] for any component of it getting
[3:33:12] to the distribution center and
[3:33:14] on and we'd be buying
[3:33:14] the distribution center from
[3:33:16] you at that point.
[3:33:18] So are we paying for la Masons
[3:33:20] and people in power is I see
[3:33:24] this one here You're nodding
[3:33:25] your head clear this up for me
[3:33:26] because it seems to me that
[3:33:27] once it crosses into our city
[3:33:29] gets to a place that the public
[3:33:31] utility would have purchased it
[3:33:34] I understand the fixed cost
[3:33:35] component but if we bought it
[3:33:37] from MR. Genie and it's being
[3:33:39] owned publicly, why would there
[3:33:40] be a further fixed cost to it?
[3:33:42] Okay, so let me come at this
[3:33:43] slightly differently in
[3:33:45] the math so that it might be a
[3:33:46] little clearer.
[3:33:47] So the first thing to
[3:33:48] understand is when we talk
[3:33:49] about distribution assets in
[3:33:50] the report, those include
[3:33:52] specifically the vast majority
[3:33:53] of the distribution sorry
[3:33:56] the transmission assets that we
[3:33:56] speak about are the substations
[3:33:58] and that's the point of step
[3:33:59] down.
[3:34:00] Those are often and you want
[3:34:02] those The reason they're
[3:34:04] included in the study is
[3:34:05] because you want them both for
[3:34:07] the ability to manage
[3:34:09] the system and then plan for
[3:34:11] future growth so that
[3:34:14] the oversimplified solute
[3:34:14] example I can give here is
[3:34:15] buying just the distribution
[3:34:16] system is like buying the pipes
[3:34:18] but not the pump station for
[3:34:20] water.
[3:34:21] So that's kind of the I just
[3:34:23] want to address kind of
[3:34:24] the there's a reason that we
[3:34:25] didn't do a distribution only
[3:34:26] kind of presentation in
[3:34:28] the report from the just
[3:34:30] compensation standpoint.
[3:34:31] Yes.
[3:34:32] So we know from the information
[3:34:34] that's in the report that about
[3:34:38] 10% give or take of
[3:34:42] the physical assets of any
[3:34:44] within the city of San Diego
[3:34:45] are fully depreciated.
[3:34:47] One of the reasons those cost
[3:34:49] boundary is are so large
[3:34:50] compared to phase one is
[3:34:52] because there's a significantly
[3:34:53] larger component of the assets
[3:34:55] that are old And a lot of that
[3:34:58] is because the vast majority of
[3:35:01] ratepayer funds in the last 5
[3:35:04] to 10 years of all of city
[3:35:07] genius territory have been
[3:35:09] toward wildfire mitigation
[3:35:10] that's been approved at the cpc
[3:35:13] And to Councilmember Von
[3:35:15] Wilpert point, we have
[3:35:16] benefited from that as a city
[3:35:18] but we're also paying for it.
[3:35:20] >> We are ten and in every
[3:35:23] other municipalities paying for
[3:35:23] it.
[3:35:23] So ten years ago the city of
[3:35:26] San Diego ratepayers made up
[3:35:28] approximately 40% of city
[3:35:31] genies Total revenue Since
[3:35:32] we've now seen growth in houses
[3:35:34] and industry etc. In
[3:35:35] the greater San Diego region
[3:35:36] we're now down to about 35% of
[3:35:40] their revenue.
[3:35:42] So the issue of just
[3:35:44] compensation in a hypothetical
[3:35:46] simply says okay you are going
[3:35:48] to remove 35% of revenue,
[3:35:54] 660,000 customers from
[3:35:55] the overall territory.
[3:35:59] >> If you do that that means
[3:36:01] that and again we don't put
[3:36:04] this number in the feasibility
[3:36:05] study because you can kind of
[3:36:06] pick any number to put in that
[3:36:09] whatever investments sdg any
[3:36:11] continues to make from that
[3:36:14] division from the point of that
[3:36:16] division are only going to be
[3:36:18] applied to the rest of excuse
[3:36:21] me the rest of the system.
[3:36:22] So right now yes, depending on
[3:36:23] which year we're talking about
[3:36:25] City of San Diego ratepayers
[3:36:26] most of the urban ratepayers
[3:36:28] frankly not just within
[3:36:29] the city are subsidizing
[3:36:31] investment in the physical
[3:36:32] system outside the city If
[3:36:37] those physical investments
[3:36:38] continue to and are seen to be
[3:36:41] beneficial to the whole area
[3:36:44] including a new city I mean you
[3:36:47] then there is a just
[3:36:48] compensation problem that all
[3:36:50] of those costs should not be
[3:36:53] borne by the remaining sdg any
[3:36:57] ratepayers If there is still
[3:36:58] benefit out to the new city of
[3:37:00] San Diego ratepayers And that's
[3:37:02] the just compensation
[3:37:03] conversation one and part of
[3:37:05] the ongoing kind of proceeding
[3:37:07] with San Francisco and ppg and
[3:37:09] they have a very different
[3:37:10] calculation both because of
[3:37:12] Janie's lack of investment into
[3:37:13] wildfire and the size of San
[3:37:15] Francisco as it relates to
[3:37:17] the larger any system but
[3:37:18] the exit fee fees is kind of
[3:37:21] like the cia when the ccr was
[3:37:24] set up.
[3:37:25] There are contracts and fixed
[3:37:26] costs that Guinea pays or has
[3:37:28] historically paid that the city
[3:37:32] of San Diego ratepayers still
[3:37:34] need to cover.
[3:37:36] If you look back and say Well
[3:37:37] we've done a whole bunch
[3:37:38] outside the city you could
[3:37:40] argue just compensation one way
[3:37:42] If you say hey all this load
[3:37:43] growth means that we're going
[3:37:44] to have to do a whole bunch of
[3:37:45] investment outside the city
[3:37:47] boundaries but it benefits
[3:37:48] the city than just compensation
[3:37:50] is going to look another way
[3:37:52] what that range looks like and
[3:37:54] how the puc even determines
[3:37:55] the correct way to calculate
[3:37:57] that is a vastly open question.
[3:37:59] Okay, So let me just go back to
[3:38:02] one last material component of
[3:38:04] this problem.
[3:38:07] My understanding is if we did a
[3:38:09] distribution only model that
[3:38:11] would be the utility, the local
[3:38:13] public utility that we'd pay a
[3:38:16] portion of the bill too but we
[3:38:17] wouldn't stop paying as genie
[3:38:20] for the transmission component
[3:38:22] would we Correct.
[3:38:23] It would be like some type of
[3:38:25] you would still have to use
[3:38:26] the transmission system.
[3:38:27] Yeah, okay.
[3:38:28] We'd still have to use
[3:38:28] the transmission system so we'd
[3:38:31] still be bearing the cost of
[3:38:34] the entire air transmission
[3:38:35] system through that portion of
[3:38:38] a potential hypothetical bill.
[3:38:41] So why would there be an exit
[3:38:42] fee if we'd still be paying
[3:38:44] the transmission bill Because
[3:38:46] of the fixed cost for
[3:38:47] the entire distribution system
[3:38:49] which again doesn't it wasn't
[3:38:51] built city by city.
[3:38:53] So even as you disconnect it,
[3:38:55] our system is built as a
[3:38:57] unified territory wide south
[3:38:59] Orange County to the border and
[3:39:01] there are fixed costs that run
[3:39:03] through that that would still
[3:39:05] need to be that are still being
[3:39:07] paid by our customers.
[3:39:08] And so if the city was to walk
[3:39:10] away, those customers are still
[3:39:12] paying those fixed costs that
[3:39:13] have already been spent And so
[3:39:15] the city can't just walk away
[3:39:16] from those fixed costs across
[3:39:18] the system.
[3:39:19] They would still be
[3:39:20] responsible.
[3:39:21] That's what the case up in San
[3:39:23] Francisco said is you have to
[3:39:24] make the other customers whole
[3:39:26] And what do you think the fixed
[3:39:27] costs are We think it's in
[3:39:28] the billions surely two $7
[3:39:32] billion That's a huge range
[3:39:32] somewhere between 4 and $7
[3:39:33] billion for being very
[3:39:37] concerned As I say, surely as
[3:39:37] the investors in that
[3:39:38] infrastructure you wouldn't
[3:39:39] know the exact dollar amount
[3:39:41] that it would cost, right?
[3:39:42] Yeah.
[3:39:43] Okay.
[3:39:44] Can you not give me better than
[3:39:45] 427 six 6 to $8 billion?
[3:39:49] >> Okay But it's negotiable,
[3:39:51] right?
[3:39:52] >> We don't think so.
[3:39:54] And the cpc did say that it's
[3:39:56] absolutely part of the court
[3:40:00] case as Heather just explained
[3:40:00] ,the court will actually
[3:40:01] determine it.
[3:40:02] So you know, I don't know
[3:40:04] exactly what that's going to
[3:40:05] look like.
[3:40:07] Yes, it could be some type of
[3:40:08] settlement but ultimately
[3:40:09] the court determines what
[3:40:11] the just compensation would be
[3:40:13] to the remaining customers So
[3:40:14] they don't see a 20 to 30% rate
[3:40:17] increase.
[3:40:17] Okay.
[3:40:18] Really quickly, you mentioned
[3:40:20] that you didn't do an analysis
[3:40:21] of distribution only model.
[3:40:23] You said that right just a
[3:40:24] minute ago.
[3:40:25] This study doesn't provide its
[3:40:28] kind of recommendations and
[3:40:29] determination of feasibility
[3:40:31] looking at just distribution
[3:40:32] because it's not recommended
[3:40:34] for the actual long term health
[3:40:36] purpose and a capability of any
[3:40:39] municipal utility.
[3:40:41] But the other thing but there
[3:40:42] is that distinction that's got
[3:40:43] made of you're not talking high
[3:40:45] voltage crossing line
[3:40:46] transmissions.
[3:40:47] We have transmission line is
[3:40:48] just how big the line is.
[3:40:50] There's a break point of what's
[3:40:51] considered a distribution line
[3:40:52] versus a transmission line.
[3:40:53] We have transmission lines that
[3:40:55] run between substations, both
[3:40:56] of which are within the city.
[3:40:57] You effectively want to own all
[3:40:59] of the assets within the city
[3:41:01] boundary in order to run
[3:41:03] the system efficiently.
[3:41:05] Sometimes you got to move power
[3:41:06] really far and sometimes you
[3:41:08] you know you can just run it
[3:41:09] along the distribution lines.
[3:41:11] That's an excellent point.
[3:41:12] Power San Diego That's a
[3:41:13] component that wasn't brought
[3:41:14] up that I've heard before
[3:41:16] The fact that within the city
[3:41:17] you have the transmission lines
[3:41:19] and if you're looking at if
[3:41:20] you're suggesting just a
[3:41:21] distribution only utility, a
[3:41:23] public utility, how do you get
[3:41:25] around that internal
[3:41:26] transmission line?
[3:41:30] What do you get around that is
[3:41:30] those transmission and
[3:41:32] distribution substations become
[3:41:33] tollbooths.
[3:41:35] You monitor how much power is
[3:41:38] flowing off the transmission
[3:41:39] system You pay for that.
[3:41:41] We pay it through
[3:41:42] the transmission access charges
[3:41:44] and that is how the system
[3:41:46] works.
[3:41:47] Again, the first study that new
[3:41:49] Gen did with distribution only
[3:41:51] and so it's a choice.
[3:41:56] Okay, understood.
[3:41:59] Thank you, MR. CHAIRMAN, Quick
[3:42:08] question for you.
[3:42:09] I noticed you mentioned
[3:42:10] leverage your workers would
[3:42:13] have in negotiating a deal if a
[3:42:14] significant proportion were
[3:42:16] segregated off from the broader
[3:42:19] body that you represent.
[3:42:22] How would it materially change
[3:42:24] the day to day work to have
[3:42:28] Genie essentially handling
[3:42:29] certain components that run
[3:42:31] into the city of San Diego
[3:42:32] versus a public utility
[3:42:35] controlling inside the city?
[3:42:37] I would say it's going to be a
[3:42:39] substantial impact especially
[3:42:41] when you start talking about
[3:42:42] breaking out the transmission
[3:42:43] and distribution infrastructure
[3:42:45] As a lineman who worked on
[3:42:46] these power lines in the city
[3:42:47] of San Diego for ten years
[3:42:48] before taking this job, a lot
[3:42:50] of our transmission
[3:42:51] infrastructure has distribution
[3:42:53] under build so it's the same
[3:42:55] exact pole, right?
[3:42:57] So if a transmission pole has
[3:43:00] 16 kbps on top 12 gave you
[3:43:01] under build and then 120 to 40
[3:43:03] on the bottom and a drunk
[3:43:04] driver runs into that pole and
[3:43:06] everything's on the ground.
[3:43:07] We struggle today having to put
[3:43:09] up telecommunications lines,
[3:43:11] having to rely on spectrum
[3:43:14] at&t, Cox Communications to
[3:43:15] come out and then we are
[3:43:16] putting stuff up here Now
[3:43:18] you're just adding another
[3:43:19] layer of bureaucracy on who's
[3:43:20] going to take the transmission.
[3:43:22] We're going to do
[3:43:22] the transmission, you're going
[3:43:23] to do the distribution And then
[3:43:25] three different telecom
[3:43:25] telecommunications companies
[3:43:27] are going to do these other
[3:43:28] wires As a lineman I'm just
[3:43:30] trying to get everything off
[3:43:31] the ground and up safe and
[3:43:33] power restored.
[3:43:34] So you're going to add to
[3:43:35] competing power companies
[3:43:37] trying to restore service in an
[3:43:38] emergency?
[3:43:39] I think it would make it very
[3:43:40] complicated.
[3:43:41] Okay.
[3:43:42] Appreciate that.
[3:43:43] I'll wrap up my comments.
[3:43:44] Council PRESIDENT I thank
[3:43:45] the members of the public for
[3:43:47] getting into the deep details
[3:43:49] of just why this is so
[3:43:50] complicated and being able to
[3:43:52] stand side by side at
[3:43:54] the microphone to answer
[3:43:55] the questions very directly as
[3:43:57] kind of transparent in fact
[3:43:59] driven comparison I think
[3:44:00] the public expects when we're
[3:44:03] dealing with multibillion
[3:44:04] dollar decisions and being able
[3:44:07] to hear immediately what one
[3:44:09] organization says and being
[3:44:11] able to rebut it or supplement
[3:44:13] it and ultimately hearing from
[3:44:15] the workers about how that
[3:44:16] impacts their lives.
[3:44:17] I know we have another item
[3:44:19] into a one where I'll have some
[3:44:20] further comments but at the end
[3:44:23] of the day I think that
[3:44:25] the well I'll say my comments
[3:44:27] about the 8% profit coming up
[3:44:30] in a second.
[3:44:30] Thank you Council PRESIDENT And
[3:44:31] thank you to members of
[3:44:32] the public for caring so much
[3:44:33] about driving rates down for
[3:44:35] electricity in San Diego.
[3:44:36] All right.
[3:44:37] Thank you.
[3:44:39] And to member Campo, this is an
[3:44:39] information item.
[3:44:40] We have a lot more work to do
[3:44:41] today but nevertheless
[3:44:43] Councilmember Bond, welcome
[3:44:44] one.
[3:44:45] One more point.
[3:44:48] First of all, the way that we
[3:44:49] can lower bills today is by
[3:44:50] making less profit for
[3:44:51] shareholders.
[3:44:53] Today any argument that we need
[3:44:56] to get rid of the public
[3:44:57] purpose programs in the state
[3:44:59] but the mandates in our bills
[3:45:01] is ridiculous.
[3:45:01] You want us to take away
[3:45:02] the low income assistance
[3:45:03] program and state bills.
[3:45:05] You want to take away
[3:45:06] the wildfire safety mandates?
[3:45:08] These are the state
[3:45:08] requirements in the bills that
[3:45:10] we pay.
[3:45:11] That is ridiculous.
[3:45:12] It should be said you need
[3:45:14] shareholder profits that are
[3:45:15] lower today to lower our bills,
[3:45:16] not lowering help for low
[3:45:17] income people And it shouldn't
[3:45:18] be on the backs of cities to do
[3:45:20] that.
[3:45:20] Second, we already pay We
[3:45:23] the city of San Diego already
[3:45:24] pay for infrastructure we don't
[3:45:25] use for city And I'm now
[3:45:27] reading about the Golden
[3:45:29] Pacific Power Line project that
[3:45:30] could go entirely around
[3:45:31] the city of San Diego.
[3:45:32] Yet our ratepayers might have
[3:45:34] to pay for it.
[3:45:35] So I'm glad you're having a lot
[3:45:37] of stakeholder engagement but
[3:45:38] you need to engage the citizens
[3:45:40] of City of San Diego who could
[3:45:41] be paying for this.
[3:45:42] And second of all you should be
[3:45:43] doing more than just virtual
[3:45:44] open houses.
[3:45:46] If you're going to run this
[3:45:47] through an unnatural state park
[3:45:48] like Rego Springs, go to
[3:45:50] Brigham Springs, talk to
[3:45:51] the people in the communities
[3:45:52] in in person about this before
[3:45:54] you go to a natural preserve.
[3:45:56] Thank you.
[3:45:56] Council PRESIDENT.
[3:45:57] All right.
[3:45:58] Thank you.
[3:45:59] So not seeing anybody else on
[3:46:01] the lights.
[3:46:01] This is an information item.
[3:46:03] No motions required.
[3:46:05] Thank you to Brittany, Nate
[3:46:08] Bell and whoever else got in
[3:46:10] the hot seat And we're willing
[3:46:11] to take the questions from
[3:46:12] the council members going
[3:46:14] forward.
[3:46:15] There was a lot of ground
[3:46:16] covered.
[3:46:16] There was a lot of ground not
[3:46:17] covered for this discussion
[3:46:19] because we weren't setting this
[3:46:21] up for an action today because
[3:46:23] there are still so many things.
[3:46:25] But I'll reiterate what
[3:46:27] the report said that it is
[3:46:28] feasibly feasible from an
[3:46:30] economic point of view and it's
[3:46:31] feasible from a technical point
[3:46:33] of view.
[3:46:33] A lot more work would have to
[3:46:35] be done And so you kind of
[3:46:36] tried to summarize Heather and
[3:46:37] I appreciate that.
[3:46:39] So with that we will close item
[3:46:41] 200.
[3:46:42] Again, thank you to everyone
[3:46:44] and Deputy Clerk please
[3:46:46] introduce item 201 Thank you
[3:46:50] Council PRESIDENT Item 2a1 sdg
[3:46:52] any franchise independent audit
[3:46:54] report and Franchise Compliance
[3:46:55] Review Committee report 2023
[3:46:59] through 2025 Thank you for All
[3:47:26] right As you start to settle in
[3:47:28] introduce yourselves for
[3:47:29] the record and let us know how
[3:47:30] much time we need.
[3:47:32] >> Hello.
[3:47:32] Thank you.
[3:47:33] Council PRESIDENT My name is
[3:47:33] Matt.
[3:47:35] We are We'll try to keep under
[3:47:35] 20 minutes for That's for both
[3:47:37] for the entire reading.
[3:47:39] Okay.
[3:47:39] Thank you.
[3:47:41] >> Thank you.
[3:47:42] My name is Megan Long, program
[3:47:43] manager and department of
[3:47:44] General Services.
[3:47:45] I'm joined today by Eric Cohen,
[3:47:46] Aaron Cohen and Eric Niland
[3:47:49] from Crow Cody Human And to
[3:47:50] tell me about Marshall Zeigler
[3:47:52] from our franchise Compliance
[3:47:53] Review committee today we'll be
[3:47:54] presenting to you the results
[3:47:55] of our second two year
[3:47:56] compliance period of the Genie
[3:48:00] franchise which will include a
[3:48:00] presentation from our
[3:48:01] independent auditor as well as
[3:48:02] our presentation from
[3:48:03] the Franchise Compliance Review
[3:48:04] Committee.
[3:48:06] By way of background in JULY of
[3:48:08] 2021 the Council passed two
[3:48:10] ordinances that awarded the gas
[3:48:12] and electric franchises to San
[3:48:14] Diego Gas and Electric
[3:48:16] the franchise with a ten year
[3:48:16] term with an automatic renewal
[3:48:17] for a second ten years unless
[3:48:19] there's action taken by council
[3:48:21] as additional level of
[3:48:22] oversight.
[3:48:22] The franchise required two
[3:48:23] things First, the city is
[3:48:25] required to retain a third
[3:48:26] party independent auditor every
[3:48:27] two years to perform an audit
[3:48:29] of each unit compliance with
[3:48:30] the franchise.
[3:48:31] And second, the franchise
[3:48:32] requires the city to establish
[3:48:33] the Franchise Compliance Review
[3:48:34] Committee also known as the f
[3:48:37] crc, a citizens committee
[3:48:38] comprised of two mayoral
[3:48:39] appointments and three council
[3:48:40] appointments.
[3:48:41] The icrc is charged with
[3:48:42] receiving the independent
[3:48:43] Auditors report and providing
[3:48:44] its own report to Council with
[3:48:46] a recommendation on
[3:48:47] the automatic renewal on
[3:48:48] the second ten year term.
[3:48:49] Both of those reports will be
[3:48:50] presented today in JULY of 2024
[3:48:53] we presented a similar item for
[3:48:55] the first two year review
[3:48:56] period and at the same meeting
[3:48:58] council passed a resolution to
[3:48:59] establish the second frc to
[3:49:01] review the second compliance
[3:49:02] period which covers JULY 8th
[3:49:04] 2023 to JULY 7th of 2025.
[3:49:07] I would like to take a moment
[3:49:08] to thank the volunteer
[3:49:09] committee members Matt Brennan,
[3:49:10] Lydia Latimore, Cody Human So
[3:49:14] tell me about Flagler and Corey
[3:49:14] All right.
[3:49:15] For their time and dedication
[3:49:16] to this committee in regards to
[3:49:20] the independent auditor in
[3:49:21] OCTOBER of 2022 city staff
[3:49:23] released an rfp for
[3:49:24] the independent auditor and
[3:49:25] after a competitive process
[3:49:28] Crowell lp was elected as
[3:49:28] the vendor cro will present
[3:49:30] their audit findings for
[3:49:31] the first two three for
[3:49:32] the second two year Crowe
[3:49:34] presented their audit findings
[3:49:35] for the first two year
[3:49:36] franchise period as part of
[3:49:38] the hearing in JULY of 2024 and
[3:49:40] the city chose to exercise its
[3:49:42] option to extend Crowe's
[3:49:43] contract for the second two
[3:49:44] year compliance period.
[3:49:46] I have with me today
[3:49:47] representatives from the Crowe
[3:49:48] team who will go into more
[3:49:49] detail about their audit
[3:49:50] procedures and findings in a
[3:49:51] few minutes.
[3:49:52] But at a high level the audit
[3:49:53] covers the second two year of
[3:49:55] the franchise scuse me
[3:49:57] the second two years of
[3:49:58] the franchise and includes
[3:49:59] the financial, operational and
[3:50:00] cooperative requirements under
[3:50:02] the franchise ordinances and
[3:50:03] their supporting documents
[3:50:04] which include
[3:50:05] the administrative mou,
[3:50:06] the undergrounding mou and
[3:50:07] the Energy Cooperation
[3:50:08] Agreement.
[3:50:09] At this point I will pass it
[3:50:10] over to our independent under
[3:50:12] Crowe who will provide an
[3:50:12] overview of the audit findings
[3:50:13] and recommendations.
[3:50:17] Thank you Megan.
[3:50:18] Next slide we'll go through
[3:50:20] some brief introductions.
[3:50:21] We'll talk about audit scope
[3:50:22] and procedure and then our
[3:50:24] findings and recommendations.
[3:50:26] So next slide My name is Eric
[3:50:27] Niland.
[3:50:29] I'm a director with Crowe and
[3:50:30] with me I have Erin Cohen who's
[3:50:32] a senior manager with Crowe.
[3:50:33] We don't have Burt with us but
[3:50:35] he was the engagement partner
[3:50:36] on this project.
[3:50:40] >> I'll turn to Aaron to talk
[3:50:41] about the scope here.
[3:50:42] Thank you Eric So scope of
[3:50:46] the audit was an independent
[3:50:47] audit of Genie's gas and
[3:50:49] electric franchise agreements
[3:50:50] And as Megan mentioned the two
[3:50:52] year period was JULY 8th, 2023
[3:50:54] through JULY 7th, 2025.
[3:50:57] The audit covered Genie's
[3:50:59] performance and complying with
[3:51:00] the franchise agreements
[3:51:02] Administrative mou, the utility
[3:51:04] underwriting mou and the Energy
[3:51:05] Cooperation agreement
[3:51:06] associated with the franchises
[3:51:09] Now our audit procedures
[3:51:10] included conducting interviews
[3:51:12] with Jenny and city staff.
[3:51:14] We spoke with city staff
[3:51:16] including finance, operational
[3:51:17] and oversight personnel and
[3:51:19] spoke with many city
[3:51:20] departments the Development
[3:51:21] Services Department and an
[3:51:23] engineering and capital
[3:51:24] projects utilities
[3:51:25] undergrounding program and city
[3:51:26] management.
[3:51:28] We reviewed and documented
[3:51:29] requirements of each agreement.
[3:51:31] We submitted multiple data
[3:51:32] requests to City Jenny and
[3:51:34] the city.
[3:51:35] These data requests were
[3:51:36] requested for relevant
[3:51:37] requirements for each of
[3:51:38] the agreements for franchise
[3:51:40] fees We obtained and reviewed
[3:51:42] Genie Annual franchise fee
[3:51:43] calculation documents,
[3:51:45] quarterly franchise fee
[3:51:46] statements, processed
[3:51:47] documentation controls
[3:51:49] information They are aging
[3:51:51] reports, bad debt expense
[3:51:52] support and collection
[3:51:53] procedures and documentation of
[3:51:55] payment to the city Exide For
[3:52:01] the administrative mou we
[3:52:03] selected a sample of 13
[3:52:05] projects to audit project
[3:52:07] specific requirements things
[3:52:08] like permitting inspections or
[3:52:10] collaboration.
[3:52:11] We also reviewed supporting
[3:52:12] documentation for what we're
[3:52:14] calling non project specific
[3:52:15] requirements.
[3:52:16] This is information sharing
[3:52:17] protocols or communication
[3:52:18] between Genie and the city.
[3:52:21] Similarly for the utility
[3:52:23] undergrounding mou we selected
[3:52:24] eight in-process projects to
[3:52:26] audit requirements that were
[3:52:27] project specific and then
[3:52:29] review review supporting
[3:52:30] documentation for non project
[3:52:31] specific requirements for
[3:52:34] the Energy Cooperation
[3:52:35] Agreement We reviewed
[3:52:36] supporting documentation for
[3:52:38] each requirement.
[3:52:41] >> Now the results of these
[3:52:42] tests indicated that we met
[3:52:43] the four audit objectives in
[3:52:45] all significant respects for
[3:52:46] the audit period.
[3:52:47] However we did include two
[3:52:49] audit findings that were deemed
[3:52:50] not to be significant
[3:52:53] significant to the objectives
[3:52:54] but warranted inclusion in
[3:52:55] the report.
[3:52:57] >> And now I'm going to turn it
[3:52:58] to Eric to walk through
[3:52:59] the findings.
[3:53:01] You know, so the first of these
[3:53:02] findings has to do with
[3:53:03] compliance with
[3:53:04] the undergrounding mou And
[3:53:05] there were several sections of
[3:53:07] the mou that we found
[3:53:10] noncompliance and and they're
[3:53:10] listed here on this slide and
[3:53:12] I'll review those with you for
[3:53:14] the first of those are six 11.2
[3:53:17] for a project titled block b r
[3:53:24] a r c g You do not complete
[3:53:24] internal processes on time
[3:53:26] which caused a delay in
[3:53:27] assigning and inspector to
[3:53:29] the project and that's Palm
[3:53:29] City.
[3:53:32] Edgar Highlands project.
[3:53:34] Secondly, sd g did not provide
[3:53:36] a written schedule of days and
[3:53:38] hours in which the c an
[3:53:41] inspector would be available to
[3:53:43] a project titled Blockade r sd
[3:53:47] g ultimately was not able to
[3:53:48] provide an inspector at
[3:53:49] the time of that construction
[3:53:51] as a consequence.
[3:53:53] So in section 743g did not
[3:53:56] comply by providing a
[3:53:59] construction baseline which
[3:54:00] includes both an estimate of
[3:54:02] cost and a schedule for
[3:54:05] trenching conduit work for
[3:54:06] the project titled 2bb job two
[3:54:06] That's a crown point one.
[3:54:10] And finally in section 834cg
[3:54:14] has not submitted detailed 90%
[3:54:16] design estimates in
[3:54:17] the supporting documentation
[3:54:19] for invoices Did not clearly
[3:54:20] differentiate projects that
[3:54:22] have reached the 90% completion
[3:54:24] threshold as required by
[3:54:26] the franchise.
[3:54:27] So we have a number of
[3:54:28] recommendations to address
[3:54:29] these these misses so to speak.
[3:54:32] The first is to establish
[3:54:33] stronger project management
[3:54:35] controls by developing
[3:54:37] standardized timelines and
[3:54:38] checklists.
[3:54:39] Secondly, to assign a dedicated
[3:54:41] compliance liaison or project
[3:54:43] coordinator within cdg and to
[3:54:45] limit these misses.
[3:54:47] Third, to revise invoicing
[3:54:49] backup materials to more
[3:54:52] clearly distinguish that 90%
[3:54:53] design estimate.
[3:54:55] Fourth to establish regular
[3:54:56] joint review meetings with city
[3:54:58] staff They've started doing
[3:55:00] those and are doing more of
[3:55:01] them As a consequence of this
[3:55:06] trained personnel and mou
[3:55:06] requirements by reinforcing
[3:55:08] compliance standards And
[3:55:09] finally link compliance to
[3:55:11] performance metrics or
[3:55:13] oversight reviews.
[3:55:15] So those are recommendations
[3:55:15] that are addressed first.
[3:55:17] The first findings second
[3:55:18] finding on the next slide has
[3:55:20] to do with the admin mou
[3:55:24] section ten point b of that mou
[3:55:27] as you need to not schedule
[3:55:30] pre-construction meeting with
[3:55:30] the city as required as
[3:55:33] Eugenie's Field crews
[3:55:33] incorrectly assumed that was a
[3:55:35] classic Category one project
[3:55:37] winner which would not have
[3:55:39] required this pre-construction
[3:55:40] meeting and the project was
[3:55:41] actually a Category two
[3:55:43] project.
[3:55:43] So there's a couple of things
[3:55:44] that I can do to strengthen and
[3:55:46] you know, respond accordingly.
[3:55:49] First by just project project
[3:55:52] classification work and review
[3:55:54] processes so that this doesn't
[3:55:56] happen again.
[3:55:57] Developing a project checklist
[3:55:58] to be reviewed by
[3:55:59] the supervisor before
[3:56:00] construction begins.
[3:56:01] And perhaps most important to
[3:56:03] train field crews and project
[3:56:04] managers to clearly
[3:56:05] differentiate between these two
[3:56:07] category types.
[3:56:09] So those are the two findings
[3:56:11] the status of findings from
[3:56:13] the first phase of the audit
[3:56:14] and I'll go through those
[3:56:15] briefly here.
[3:56:16] There were four findings last
[3:56:18] Two of these have been
[3:56:19] remediating remediated.
[3:56:21] Those are three and four.
[3:56:23] Number three was remediated
[3:56:25] because it's no longer a
[3:56:27] compliance requirement And
[3:56:27] the new admin mou number four
[3:56:30] was remediated because
[3:56:31] the finding related to a paint
[3:56:32] plant completion timing which
[3:56:34] they met although they delayed
[3:56:37] in meeting and getting that
[3:56:38] done both the city and in
[3:56:40] the study ultimately got
[3:56:41] the plan completed So it wasn't
[3:56:43] a compliance matter in this
[3:56:45] phase.
[3:56:46] The other two relate to number
[3:56:48] one they're inconsistent
[3:56:49] undergrounding project cost
[3:56:51] estimates.
[3:56:51] And so this is sort of a to be
[3:56:54] determined going forward.
[3:56:55] In the past there were some
[3:56:58] inconsistencies in the overhead
[3:57:00] allocations to the cost
[3:57:02] estimates and they've cleaned
[3:57:03] those up to some degree.
[3:57:04] But going forward I think
[3:57:06] there's still as they get into
[3:57:08] more construction projects
[3:57:10] there's still a need to
[3:57:11] reinforce consistent project
[3:57:13] cost estimates There.
[3:57:15] The second one is just in terms
[3:57:17] of collaborating between
[3:57:18] the city and sd Junior on
[3:57:19] the mou for certain contracted
[3:57:23] services, the Mhsaa hasn't been
[3:57:25] solicited again So to
[3:57:27] the degree that when that
[3:57:28] happens there more coordination
[3:57:30] between the city and sga and on
[3:57:33] that is merited So we didn't
[3:57:34] say that's remediated but it's
[3:57:36] pending the next cycle of
[3:57:37] the mhsaa.
[3:57:39] So with that I will turn it
[3:57:40] back to the Council for
[3:57:43] questions.
[3:57:44] At this time I would have to
[3:57:45] revert to our franchise
[3:57:46] compliance review committee.
[3:57:50] Hi everybody.
[3:57:50] Thank you.
[3:57:50] My name is Cody Hoven.
[3:57:52] I'm the chair of your franchise
[3:57:54] Compliance Review committee.
[3:57:55] Nice to be back in the seat I
[3:57:56] think.
[3:57:57] And here with the Tell me about
[3:57:59] Siegler the vice chair of
[3:58:00] the committee.
[3:58:00] We're going to split up this
[3:58:01] portion of the presentation.
[3:58:05] Thanks.
[3:58:06] So just to remind you
[3:58:07] the purpose of Franchise
[3:58:09] Compliance Review Committee was
[3:58:12] it was assigned a very narrow
[3:58:13] scope per the franchise
[3:58:14] agreement and it's formed as
[3:58:16] you see here every two years to
[3:58:19] review franchise compliance and
[3:58:21] recommend to the city council
[3:58:22] whether the franchise should be
[3:58:23] renewed for a secondary term.
[3:58:24] So we're a function of
[3:58:27] the Brown Act compliant
[3:58:28] Committee and comply with all
[3:58:30] of the rules of the Brown Act
[3:58:31] in our meetings.
[3:58:35] Additionally, our
[3:58:36] responsibilities include
[3:58:37] reviewing and discuss
[3:58:38] discussing the franchise audit
[3:58:41] what you just heard in
[3:58:42] collaboration with the auditor
[3:58:44] and preparing a comprehensive
[3:58:46] written report for you all
[3:58:48] which we provided And I quickly
[3:58:52] went quickly through these and
[3:58:54] then making a formal
[3:58:55] recommendation to City Council
[3:58:57] regarding whether to approve
[3:58:58] automatic renewal of
[3:59:00] the franchise for a secondary
[3:59:06] ten year term.
[3:59:12] Next on the committee found
[3:59:13] that Junior demonstrated
[3:59:15] overall compliance with all
[3:59:16] four agreements The electric
[3:59:17] and gas franchise agreements,
[3:59:19] the administrative mou or
[3:59:21] the utility utility
[3:59:22] undergrounding mou and
[3:59:23] the energy Cooperation
[3:59:24] Agreement.
[3:59:25] The audit identified only a few
[3:59:27] minor issues mostly related to
[3:59:28] documentation scheduling or
[3:59:30] classification.
[3:59:30] These were isolated and
[3:59:33] technically and with no
[3:59:35] evidence of systemic problems
[3:59:37] financial harm or governance
[3:59:38] breakdowns.
[3:59:39] The committee recommends that
[3:59:41] routine monitoring or franchise
[3:59:42] compliance continue with a
[3:59:44] focus on clarifying
[3:59:45] expectations, standardizing
[3:59:47] documentation and reinforcing
[3:59:48] early coordination between
[3:59:51] F.D.A. And city departments for
[3:59:52] the administrative mou This
[3:59:54] means strengthening internal
[3:59:55] controls and aligning
[3:59:57] renegotiate renegotiation
[3:59:58] timelines with the committees
[4:00:00] review cycle.
[4:00:01] Right now there's a timing
[4:00:03] mismatch mismatch between when
[4:00:05] the agreements can be
[4:00:06] renegotiated and when
[4:00:07] the committee is actually doing
[4:00:09] its review.
[4:00:10] That means the committee's
[4:00:11] input MAY come too late to
[4:00:13] meaningful meaningfully
[4:00:14] influence the process.
[4:00:16] What we're proposing is to
[4:00:17] better align those timelines so
[4:00:19] when the renegotiation
[4:00:20] opportunities arise they
[4:00:22] coincide with the committee's
[4:00:23] review cycle allowing their
[4:00:25] work to directly inform city
[4:00:26] decisions for
[4:00:28] the undergrounding mou.
[4:00:29] The committee recommends
[4:00:30] providing detailed cost
[4:00:31] breakdowns and establishing a
[4:00:32] regular review mechanism.
[4:00:34] Those costs are often shown as
[4:00:36] big lump sums and not broken
[4:00:38] into enough detail.
[4:00:39] So you know x is for labor wise
[4:00:42] for overhead, for construction.
[4:00:43] Right now it's like getting a
[4:00:44] restaurant bill that just says
[4:00:46] a total of $200 with no
[4:00:48] itemized itemization.
[4:00:49] The committee is recommending
[4:00:50] an itemized receipt and regular
[4:00:52] check ins to make sure
[4:00:53] everything looks reasonable for
[4:00:55] the Energy Cooperation
[4:00:56] Agreement.
[4:00:56] The committee suggests setting
[4:00:58] realistic timelines,
[4:00:59] maintaining energy efficient
[4:01:00] program commitments, improving
[4:01:02] reporting and expanding public
[4:01:04] engagement opportunities.
[4:01:05] Next slide please.
[4:01:07] While complaints are strong,
[4:01:08] the committee noted several
[4:01:09] areas where the processes could
[4:01:11] be improved.
[4:01:12] These include ensuring
[4:01:13] pre-construction meetings are
[4:01:14] consistently held clarifying
[4:01:16] documentation practices,
[4:01:17] increasing transparency and
[4:01:19] project cost enhancing tracking
[4:01:21] and reporting under the Energy
[4:01:23] Cooperation Agreement and
[4:01:24] creating additional
[4:01:25] opportunities for public
[4:01:26] engagement before agreements or
[4:01:28] modifications are executed.
[4:01:30] Next slide please.
[4:01:32] The committee recommends
[4:01:33] continuing to monitor prior
[4:01:35] audit needs to ensure progress
[4:01:36] is sustained.
[4:01:37] Recognizing that some issues
[4:01:38] require ongoing management
[4:01:40] rather than one time fixes, it
[4:01:42] also suggest creating plain
[4:01:44] language summaries of all
[4:01:45] agreements to help both
[4:01:47] the committee and the public
[4:01:48] understand the purpose process
[4:01:51] and the timelines.
[4:01:52] Renegotiation timelines once
[4:01:54] again should be aligned should
[4:01:55] align with biennial review
[4:01:57] cycle to improve public
[4:01:59] engagement and the Committee
[4:02:00] should have access to draft
[4:02:02] audit findings for early
[4:02:03] review.
[4:02:04] Oversight shouldn't just focus
[4:02:05] on compliance though We also
[4:02:07] need to look at financial
[4:02:08] impacts and how these
[4:02:09] agreements affect the community
[4:02:11] creating structured
[4:02:11] opportunities for Republican
[4:02:13] input along with more
[4:02:14] standardized reporting across
[4:02:16] all franchise agreements would
[4:02:17] improve transparency and make
[4:02:19] it easier for the council and
[4:02:20] the public to review and
[4:02:21] understand what's happening
[4:02:24] next Like this.
[4:02:26] The committee observed that not
[4:02:28] all franchise activities carry
[4:02:30] the same level of risk or
[4:02:31] public concern.
[4:02:32] So oversight should focus on
[4:02:33] areas of greatest impact For
[4:02:35] example routine administrative
[4:02:37] updates like minor contract
[4:02:38] amendments or reporting changes
[4:02:40] don't typically have major
[4:02:42] community impacts and can be
[4:02:43] reviewed more quickly.
[4:02:45] But decisions involving
[4:02:46] undergrounding projects rate
[4:02:48] impacts or long term renewal
[4:02:50] terms have significant
[4:02:51] financial and public
[4:02:53] implications So those should be
[4:02:55] should receive deeper scrutiny
[4:02:57] and more detailed oversight.
[4:02:59] Some prior audit findings like
[4:03:01] undergrounding cost variability
[4:03:02] have improved while others
[4:03:04] require ongoing management.
[4:03:06] In this case continuous
[4:03:07] improvement rather than
[4:03:09] the complete absence of issues
[4:03:10] is is a reasonable but
[4:03:11] reasonable benchmark.
[4:03:14] To strengthen oversight,
[4:03:15] the committee recommends
[4:03:16] establishing successful
[4:03:17] criteria beyond compliance for
[4:03:19] example instead of only
[4:03:20] confirming compliance.
[4:03:22] We would also look at look at
[4:03:24] outcomes like whether
[4:03:26] the project stayed on budget or
[4:03:27] were delivered on schedule.
[4:03:29] Sharing all public comments So
[4:03:32] feedback from residents is
[4:03:33] fully visible throughout
[4:03:34] the process not just summarized
[4:03:37] Expanding structured public
[4:03:39] input early in the agreement
[4:03:41] process for instance holding
[4:03:42] engagement sessions before key
[4:03:44] terms are finalized not after
[4:03:46] decision decisions are largely
[4:03:48] set.
[4:03:49] Enhancing audit scope for cost
[4:03:51] drivers.
[4:03:51] So instead of just seeing total
[4:03:54] project costs we can clearly
[4:03:55] see the breakdowns you know
[4:03:56] like earlier and itemized
[4:04:00] receipt and standardizing
[4:04:00] reporting across all franchise
[4:04:01] agreements to improve
[4:04:02] transparency, consistency and
[4:04:04] accessibility for the committee
[4:04:06] ,city council and the public
[4:04:08] in general.
[4:04:12] And so consider our
[4:04:14] recommendations a bigger
[4:04:15] picture.
[4:04:16] We based on the information we
[4:04:18] had in front of us and barring
[4:04:19] any other decisions you all
[4:04:20] might make.
[4:04:21] The committee recommended
[4:04:22] allowing the franchise to renew
[4:04:24] with conditions.
[4:04:29] So this Conditional Renewal
[4:04:32] Council decision per our
[4:04:33] recommendation should consider
[4:04:34] both individual agreements and
[4:04:36] among others as well as
[4:04:36] the overall structure and long
[4:04:38] term impact of the franchise.
[4:04:40] So our recommendation for
[4:04:41] renewals conditioned on
[4:04:42] aligning renegotiation
[4:04:43] timelines to ensure meaningful
[4:04:45] public and council input before
[4:04:46] agreements are finalized.
[4:04:48] So we talked about some of our
[4:04:50] key compliance.
[4:04:52] i think the key findings as a
[4:04:54] student is generally compliant
[4:04:55] based on the scope of the audit
[4:04:56] question posed with only minor
[4:04:58] issues noted in the audit.
[4:05:00] Underground costs are high and
[4:05:01] overhead transparency could
[4:05:02] improve.
[4:05:04] And previous concerns have been
[4:05:05] mostly addressed But climate
[4:05:07] action progress has been
[4:05:08] limited and public input was
[4:05:10] considered in our meetings as
[4:05:13] well.
[4:05:14] And the three new one would
[4:05:15] preserve flexibility for future
[4:05:17] options like mineralization.
[4:05:23] This conditional renewal is
[4:05:25] the approach our committee
[4:05:26] recommended because it supports
[4:05:28] both San Diego ratepayers and
[4:05:29] the city's broader policy
[4:05:31] objectives.
[4:05:32] But I would like to underscore
[4:05:33] that it is important to
[4:05:35] recognize that simply meeting
[4:05:36] the terms of these agreements
[4:05:38] the compliance alone doesn't
[4:05:40] fully address the bigger
[4:05:41] concerns of how you define
[4:05:43] success As a lot of discussion
[4:05:45] you've heard today.
[4:05:46] Things like affordability,
[4:05:47] potential rate impacts or how
[4:05:48] these agreements align with
[4:05:49] the city's long term energy and
[4:05:51] climate goals.
[4:05:52] This is why renewal is
[4:05:53] ultimately a policy decision to
[4:05:55] city council balancing
[4:05:56] compliance with public value
[4:05:57] and long term priorities.
[4:06:01] >> Thank you.
[4:06:02] We're happy to take any
[4:06:03] questions I think.
[4:06:04] All right.
[4:06:04] Thank you for
[4:06:05] the presentations.
[4:06:06] Special shout out to Cody Soto
[4:06:08] me and everybody on
[4:06:09] the franchise compliance
[4:06:10] agreement the volunteers.
[4:06:13] You've got some fans out there
[4:06:16] and all the work to do that.
[4:06:18] So with that please proceed
[4:06:21] with public comment.
[4:06:23] Thank you.
[4:06:24] Council PRESIDENT.
[4:06:25] This item received one comment
[4:06:26] in favor and one comment in
[4:06:27] opposition via our e comment
[4:06:29] form which had been distributed
[4:06:31] to the Council.
[4:06:32] We will begin with in-person
[4:06:33] comment allegedly Audra please
[4:06:35] come forward You'll have one
[4:06:36] minute to speak or serve.
[4:06:46] Feels like we're as de genies
[4:06:49] really And it's just
[4:06:51] interesting to have them here
[4:06:52] and talking about like how much
[4:06:55] is it really going to cost and
[4:06:56] it's like 4 to 7 billion and
[4:06:58] then it's like be honest and
[4:07:00] it's like okay, 6 to 8.
[4:07:03] So interesting how we just let
[4:07:05] this go on and as long as we
[4:07:06] make sure they're compliant
[4:07:08] with these agreements But no
[4:07:11] wonder why the cost is high for
[4:07:13] undergrounding because they
[4:07:14] make profit off of this
[4:07:15] infrastructure.
[4:07:17] And so I'm wondering if you're
[4:07:18] conditional renewal can be like
[4:07:21] any kind of profit you make you
[4:07:23] give it to us or half of it so
[4:07:25] that the people can start
[4:07:26] getting their money back.
[4:07:27] It's like I don't understand
[4:07:29] why we just kind of bend over
[4:07:31] and allow them to do these
[4:07:32] things.
[4:07:33] It's like you know it's
[4:07:34] happening.
[4:07:34] You know why their cost is high
[4:07:36] and why they're profiting.
[4:07:39] But yeah, we just continue to
[4:07:40] let it happen.
[4:07:41] How about you guys take some of
[4:07:42] that back?
[4:07:43] I mean you're the ones with
[4:07:43] the agreements that should get
[4:07:47] off the top.
[4:07:48] >> Thank you, Blair Beckman And
[4:07:52] while Blair comes to
[4:07:53] the microphone, could we have
[4:07:54] Anthony Ralphs or Seldon?
[4:07:56] Yeah and Bob because these Can
[4:07:57] you please come to the front
[4:07:58] row?
[4:08:03] Hi, we're Beekman.
[4:08:04] Thanks for the report.
[4:08:05] Thanks for the words on working
[4:08:07] on undergrounding issues that
[4:08:09] needs to be better specified.
[4:08:12] I was trying to specify
[4:08:14] previously that if we're going
[4:08:15] to do undergrounding things
[4:08:17] there is little neighborhoods
[4:08:19] that have undergrounding you
[4:08:21] know, funding sources and we
[4:08:24] can consider that as a
[4:08:25] municipality process.
[4:08:26] I want to make that more clear.
[4:08:29] Thank you for the ideas of
[4:08:31] oversight.
[4:08:34] Um yeah.
[4:08:34] Basically what I was saying was
[4:08:35] that we don't have to fully
[4:08:36] rely on municipality.
[4:08:38] We can rely on San Diego
[4:08:39] community energy itself and
[4:08:43] nothing in this capacity Those
[4:08:43] are options.
[4:08:44] Thank you for the oversight
[4:08:45] process that you've offered
[4:08:48] overall to do The big items on
[4:08:52] public projects is good also to
[4:08:54] offer you know what are
[4:08:56] the little administrative
[4:08:57] signatures Where's a little
[4:08:59] space for that that can be
[4:09:00] available to the public as
[4:09:01] well?
[4:09:02] I think that can be helpful and
[4:09:03] important.
[4:09:03] Thank you.
[4:09:04] Thank you.
[4:09:05] Thank you.
[4:09:06] >> Anthony Ralphs followed by
[4:09:08] Laurie Saldana City Council.
[4:09:12] >> Thank you for
[4:09:12] the presentation by the Audit
[4:09:17] group.
[4:09:18] I took a couple of notes on
[4:09:19] the things that I heard.
[4:09:20] I heard number one that they
[4:09:21] didn't finished undergrounding
[4:09:23] on time, that they didn't have
[4:09:24] standardized timelines and that
[4:09:26] the construction baseline for
[4:09:28] cost and schedule are rather
[4:09:29] that they didn't schedule
[4:09:31] pre-construction meetings.
[4:09:32] These are just the ways in
[4:09:32] which you need $1 billion
[4:09:35] profit in company every year
[4:09:36] has been out of compliance just
[4:09:38] some of the ways in which
[4:09:40] they've been out of compliance
[4:09:40] that I heard that I got to take
[4:09:42] notes on which it was hard to
[4:09:43] do because the representatives
[4:09:44] from sd g are so loud and
[4:09:47] they're talking right now when
[4:09:48] I'm trying to give
[4:09:49] the presentation and one of
[4:09:50] them is eating your popcorn so
[4:09:52] incredibly loudly that it's
[4:09:53] really difficult for me and
[4:09:55] it's really difficult for
[4:09:56] the public to have trust in me
[4:09:58] when they're talking in
[4:09:59] the middle of someone giving a
[4:10:00] presentation on how they're out
[4:10:01] of compliance and eating so
[4:10:03] loud that I can't even write
[4:10:04] down the notes as to all
[4:10:06] the ways in which they're out
[4:10:07] of compliance yet they're
[4:10:08] making $1 billion a year and
[4:10:10] they're asking for their
[4:10:11] franchise board renewal.
[4:10:13] >> Thank you does conclude your
[4:10:14] time.
[4:10:15] Lori Saldana followed by Vikas
[4:10:21] Whiskey Thank you.
[4:10:22] So ultimately I think we need
[4:10:23] to say is this meeting
[4:10:24] the needs of utility rate
[4:10:28] payers And there are many
[4:10:29] things here that if you're
[4:10:31] committed to improve customer
[4:10:32] service they were delays.
[4:10:34] We have a domino effect of
[4:10:36] missed deadlines and other
[4:10:37] things that delay the outcomes
[4:10:39] So what are the consequences
[4:10:41] for this?
[4:10:42] That's my question When if you
[4:10:44] do a customer service survey
[4:10:46] and you find out that they're
[4:10:48] not meeting the needs of your
[4:10:49] customers, what are
[4:10:50] the consequences?
[4:10:51] What do you change?
[4:10:52] And I think that's been missing
[4:10:54] from these reports for the last
[4:10:55] few cycles Are the meeting
[4:10:58] formats available for people to
[4:10:59] participate are accessible to
[4:11:01] the public The ones that I
[4:11:03] happen to have in the middle of
[4:11:03] the day when most people are
[4:11:05] not able to participate I think
[4:11:06] that's problematic.
[4:11:08] So in general talking about
[4:11:10] undergrounding my family has
[4:11:13] had the same house for 60 years
[4:11:16] we've been paying into
[4:11:16] undergrounding is delay, delay,
[4:11:17] delay.
[4:11:19] So what are the consequences
[4:11:21] for delaying basic customer
[4:11:23] service?
[4:11:24] You know, there appeared to be
[4:11:25] nothing but because it's been
[4:11:35] followed by promises I'm not
[4:11:36] deeply informed on this issue
[4:11:38] and I'm mostly sympathetic to
[4:11:40] ratepayers But it's my
[4:11:42] understanding from city and
[4:11:43] union representatives that they
[4:11:45] are operating on their own land
[4:11:47] or land that they have leased
[4:11:50] or from their own funds over
[4:11:53] many years Now that doesn't
[4:11:55] mean that the city shouldn't
[4:11:57] take a role in ensuring that
[4:11:58] citizens are treated fairly.
[4:12:01] You should but I find it
[4:12:04] inexplicable that here you are
[4:12:07] investigating and reporting and
[4:12:09] auditing what sd, g and e does
[4:12:12] as a private business on mostly
[4:12:15] their own land.
[4:12:17] While you have refused to do
[4:12:18] any investigation or auditing
[4:12:22] of a private business or
[4:12:25] operating on our public
[4:12:28] parkland at the Torrey Pines
[4:12:30] Glider port, can any of you
[4:12:32] explain that inconsistency?
[4:12:36] >> Thank you.
[4:12:36] That does conclude your time.
[4:12:47] Says I thank you so much both
[4:12:48] to the auditors and
[4:12:49] the Franchise Compliance Review
[4:12:50] Committee for spending the time
[4:12:52] to evaluate our work Under
[4:12:53] the franchise agreements we
[4:12:55] knowledge of the independent
[4:12:56] auditor for the second year or
[4:12:58] the second time found no
[4:13:00] significant findings or
[4:13:01] deficiencies relating to
[4:13:03] performance on the franchise
[4:13:04] and related agreements.
[4:13:06] This reflects our commitment to
[4:13:07] meetings and to meeting
[4:13:08] the several hundred
[4:13:09] requirements under each of
[4:13:11] these ancillary franchise
[4:13:12] agreements.
[4:13:13] Of course we know we always
[4:13:14] have to improve.
[4:13:16] We'll continue to work on our
[4:13:17] processes and we take that
[4:13:18] responsibility seriously.
[4:13:20] We'd also like to recognize
[4:13:21] the Franchise Compliance Review
[4:13:22] Committee for the time and care
[4:13:24] they dedicated to this process
[4:13:26] After their extensive review
[4:13:27] including presentations from
[4:13:29] subject matter experts
[4:13:31] including the cpa and other
[4:13:33] stakeholders in the community.
[4:13:35] Your evaluation of our
[4:13:37] performance and your
[4:13:38] consideration of all the public
[4:13:39] input.
[4:13:40] Importantly, the committee
[4:13:41] found that we demonstrated
[4:13:42] overall compliance with
[4:13:44] the electric and gas franchise
[4:13:45] agreements as well as an mou.
[4:13:48] Thank you very much.
[4:13:48] All of you.
[4:13:49] Thank you.
[4:13:50] That concludes in-person public
[4:13:52] comment.
[4:13:54] We will now go to virtual
[4:13:55] public comment.
[4:13:56] I've started the five minute
[4:13:57] timer in council chambers and
[4:14:00] we will turn to the virtual
[4:14:01] queue in which there are
[4:14:02] currently three participants
[4:14:04] requesting to speak.
[4:14:05] We'll begin with John Stott.
[4:14:08] Please begin.
[4:14:14] >> Wow.
[4:14:15] Did they get it a a p a c, a d
[4:14:20] or an f?
[4:14:21] Can't tell you No.
[4:14:24] For $1 billion company you'd
[4:14:25] expect an a-plus.
[4:14:27] Second thing that's missing
[4:14:29] here is how much did the city
[4:14:34] or residents of the city of San
[4:14:37] Diego have to pay in litigation
[4:14:41] with f, c, g and e?
[4:14:43] How much damages did they do on
[4:14:47] the undergrounding You know, in
[4:14:52] the valuation that we had
[4:14:53] before the undergrounding Seems
[4:14:55] like we have to pay three times
[4:14:58] for the same undergrounding.
[4:15:00] And for the lawyers there
[4:15:01] amongst you the law fixtures
[4:15:04] should apply.
[4:15:06] This is not like San Francisco
[4:15:08] in any way.
[4:15:10] San Francisco is a takeover.
[4:15:12] Ours would be an end of a
[4:15:14] franchise or at least that we
[4:15:16] get the law for next year.
[4:15:17] >> Thank you.
[4:15:18] Thank you.
[4:15:19] All right.
[4:15:20] Our next speaker is John Lear.
[4:15:27] Please begin.
[4:15:28] >> Good afternoon.
[4:15:28] This has been a long one.
[4:15:29] I just really wish I could get
[4:15:32] a contract where when I screw
[4:15:34] up with a major installation
[4:15:36] like a nuclear power plant I
[4:15:38] get to build the customers for
[4:15:39] it.
[4:15:40] I don't even begin to
[4:15:41] understand this cost plus
[4:15:43] billing that we live under.
[4:15:44] I will tell you this Six months
[4:15:45] ago I had solar installed on
[4:15:47] the on the unit that I live in.
[4:15:50] Unfortunately I've not been
[4:15:51] able to take advantage of it
[4:15:52] until the last two months.
[4:15:54] But I will say this I generate
[4:15:56] twice as about twice the amount
[4:15:58] of power that I need in this
[4:16:02] household on that solar.
[4:16:04] So the rest of it goes back to
[4:16:05] my neighbors and the people
[4:16:06] around me.
[4:16:07] Unfortunately I'm not able to
[4:16:09] take advantage of the benefit
[4:16:10] of the reduced billing because
[4:16:12] for 3 or 4 months as the genie
[4:16:16] could get people out to inspect
[4:16:18] and approve and turn it on
[4:16:20] which is just outrageous.
[4:16:22] Anyway, get solar, get away
[4:16:24] from the grid and get rid as
[4:16:24] the genie.
[4:16:27] >> Thank you.
[4:16:29] Thank you.
[4:16:30] Our next speaker is caller with
[4:16:33] the last four digits 8700.
[4:16:36] Please begin.
[4:16:41] >> Thank you, Joy.
[4:16:41] It's turn.
[4:16:44] I don't support the renewal of
[4:16:48] the fda and the franchise
[4:16:52] agreement.
[4:16:53] My reasons are mostly in
[4:16:57] the last paragraph of
[4:16:59] the PowerPoint entitled
[4:17:00] Conclusion and I quote
[4:17:03] Conditional renewal supports
[4:17:05] rate payers in the city's
[4:17:08] objectives.
[4:17:10] At the same time, complaints
[4:17:12] alone doesn't solve concerns
[4:17:14] about affordability rates or
[4:17:16] long term value.
[4:17:18] Ultimately the Council must
[4:17:21] weigh both technical
[4:17:22] performance in broader public
[4:17:25] benefit in deciding whether to
[4:17:27] renew Dear Council.
[4:17:30] Dear Mayor do not renew It does
[4:17:33] not support repairs.
[4:17:35] It does not support the city
[4:17:37] objectives.
[4:17:38] We all know that.
[4:17:40] So let's be bold.
[4:17:42] Let's have the courage to say
[4:17:45] no.
[4:17:45] Thank you.
[4:17:46] That concludes your time This
[4:17:47] morning.
[4:17:48] Thank you.
[4:17:49] Thank you.
[4:17:50] That concludes public testimony
[4:17:52] on item 201.
[4:17:55] >> All right.
[4:17:55] Thank you, Deputy Clerk.
[4:17:57] With that this is an
[4:17:58] information item and no motions
[4:18:00] required.
[4:18:01] I'll turn it over to council
[4:18:02] members and jump in if nobody
[4:18:04] else wants to.
[4:18:07] So I will jump in.
[4:18:09] Again, thank you to the members
[4:18:11] of the franchise compliance
[4:18:12] agreement.
[4:18:12] I mean it's committee excuse
[4:18:14] me.
[4:18:14] It's an interesting animal that
[4:18:16] we've created and we appreciate
[4:18:17] your two year stint.
[4:18:19] You know, if I can make a pitch
[4:18:20] for you to come back and do
[4:18:21] another two years.
[4:18:22] i would be remiss if I did not
[4:18:24] do that.
[4:18:26] I want to speak to some of
[4:18:28] the things that were raised by
[4:18:30] the public.
[4:18:31] We have new faces doing utility
[4:18:34] undergrounding and our
[4:18:35] transportation department and
[4:18:37] they've done some serious
[4:18:39] changes to that that when we do
[4:18:43] the next two year review I
[4:18:44] don't think we're going to see
[4:18:45] those same problems because
[4:18:47] they've gotten much more
[4:18:48] aggressive not only with Genie
[4:18:50] but also with at&t and
[4:18:51] Spectrum,
[4:18:53] the telecommunications that
[4:18:55] also have aboveground lines.
[4:18:58] So I'm it didn't surprise me
[4:19:00] that there were some instances
[4:19:02] where there were problems going
[4:19:04] forward But new crew internally
[4:19:08] the city is doing a fantastic
[4:19:09] job.
[4:19:10] So I don't think we'll see it
[4:19:11] in the next audit We go
[4:19:13] forward.
[4:19:14] And to MR. Kozinski or Bob
[4:19:18] because I always pronounce your
[4:19:19] name wrong I did reach out to
[4:19:21] the city auditor to actually
[4:19:22] look into the latter part.
[4:19:24] You think I don't do anything?
[4:19:26] And the city auditor reported
[4:19:28] that they have heard these
[4:19:30] allegations multiple times and
[4:19:32] quote Our investigations
[4:19:34] determined that the allegations
[4:19:35] of fraud, waste and abuse were
[4:19:38] unsubstantiated and that
[4:19:39] the qualification requirements
[4:19:40] for him claiming that the clerk
[4:19:41] report were reasonable.
[4:19:43] That comes from our independent
[4:19:44] city auditor.
[4:19:46] Take that for what it's worth.
[4:19:48] But again thank you to
[4:19:49] the auditors for the good work
[4:19:51] that you do under the franchise
[4:19:54] agreement.
[4:19:55] Thank you again for the good
[4:19:56] work that you do.
[4:19:57] And then again the volunteers
[4:19:58] who stepped up for
[4:19:59] the committee very much
[4:20:00] appreciate it.
[4:20:01] With that we will go to council
[4:20:03] member Eli Rivera.
[4:20:06] >> All right.
[4:20:07] Thank you.
[4:20:07] Council PRESIDENT I just wanna
[4:20:08] say thank you.
[4:20:09] It's a ton of time and effort
[4:20:11] that goes into this volunteer
[4:20:13] work that you do and it is
[4:20:15] important and is one of
[4:20:17] the things that distinguishes
[4:20:19] the way that we've approached
[4:20:21] our our relationship ship with
[4:20:26] Jeannie um and with this
[4:20:26] franchise agreement in
[4:20:27] comparison to what had been
[4:20:29] done in the past.
[4:20:30] I think that that positions us
[4:20:31] better for the future and I'm
[4:20:33] very grateful for the work that
[4:20:34] you do to help us do that.
[4:20:35] >> Thank you.
[4:20:36] Council PRESIDENT.
[4:20:37] All right.
[4:20:38] Thank you.
[4:20:38] Council Yellow Rivera Not
[4:20:40] seeing anybody else in
[4:20:41] the lights.
[4:20:42] I will close this item up And
[4:20:44] again thank you for the good
[4:20:45] work and your patience on a
[4:20:47] long afternoon.
[4:20:54] Okay.
[4:20:56] And with that deputy clerk
[4:20:58] please introduce item 203 Thank
[4:21:02] you, Council PRESIDENT Item 2
[4:21:03] or 3 approval of a Fifth
[4:21:04] Amendment to the agreement with
[4:21:05] Path of San Diego for
[4:21:07] the Coordinated Street Outreach
[4:21:09] Program.
[4:21:11] >> All right.
[4:21:11] Thank you for that.
[4:21:12] This is a Fifth Amendment to an
[4:21:14] agreement.
[4:21:14] It's a little bit of a holdover
[4:21:17] Would you guys be okay with
[4:21:19] waiving the presentation given
[4:21:21] that this is the Fifth
[4:21:22] Amendment?
[4:21:24] All right, So settle yourselves
[4:21:27] in and Deputy clerk proceed
[4:21:30] with public comment on item 203
[4:21:35] Thank you.
[4:21:35] Council PRESIDENT We will begin
[4:21:37] with an in-person comment
[4:21:41] allegedly Order a please come
[4:21:42] forward.
[4:21:42] You'll have one minute to speak
[4:21:54] And again you guys want to get
[4:21:54] out of here.
[4:21:54] But again the presentations
[4:21:55] aren't for you guys.
[4:21:57] It's also for the people.
[4:21:59] All right.
[4:22:00] So this is interesting because
[4:22:02] you know, homelessness is
[4:22:05] running rampant though It's
[4:22:08] good for business when it is
[4:22:10] it's fantastic.
[4:22:11] There's so much money to be
[4:22:12] made off of these people And
[4:22:15] I'm wondering how good are they
[4:22:16] doing if just right outside
[4:22:19] the doors here there's homeless
[4:22:20] people sleeping every night.
[4:22:23] So I mean is that money well
[4:22:24] spent And when there is no, you
[4:22:26] know, path to another shelter
[4:22:30] or you know, some kind of home
[4:22:33] for like a hamster wheel and we
[4:22:35] just keep going around.
[4:22:36] It's like let's give more money
[4:22:37] and maybe that will help fix
[4:22:39] it.
[4:22:39] No, we don't have anywhere for
[4:22:40] them to go But we have these
[4:22:42] people out there just telling
[4:22:43] people, you know, that there's
[4:22:46] nowhere for them to go but then
[4:22:47] we're going to arrest them or
[4:22:49] take their stuff, you know,
[4:22:51] because they're out there.
[4:22:52] So it seems like it's working
[4:22:52] out.
[4:22:54] Maybe you guys could get some
[4:22:55] more money and throw it at it.
[4:22:57] >> Thank you.
[4:22:58] That concludes your time.
[4:23:01] Our next speaker is Blair
[4:23:02] Beekman followed by Anthony
[4:23:04] Ralphs.
[4:23:07] Hi, we're Beekman.
[4:23:09] I'm filling improving today I
[4:23:10] guess my my knowledge and depth
[4:23:13] of community issues is pretty
[4:23:16] feeble but gosh darn it this is
[4:23:19] an item that I think really
[4:23:21] needs a public presentation.
[4:23:24] I'm the work that does for our
[4:23:27] unhoused has been incredible
[4:23:28] especially in the past few
[4:23:29] years.
[4:23:30] They've proven how much they
[4:23:31] can house people and we don't
[4:23:33] just talk about shelters we can
[4:23:35] actually be talking about
[4:23:36] housing issues.
[4:23:38] I really ask the council to if
[4:23:40] they can you know, be asking
[4:23:42] questions after public
[4:23:43] presentation and that they can
[4:23:45] still make their presentation
[4:23:47] that would be great too.
[4:23:49] It's really important to be
[4:23:51] hearing this item and I'm
[4:23:52] really surprised we're avoiding
[4:23:55] it out of efficiency and to get
[4:23:58] home early.
[4:24:00] This is an important step.
[4:24:03] I hope we make this step more
[4:24:05] open and clear in our public
[4:24:06] future.
[4:24:07] >> Thank you.
[4:24:09] Anthony Ralphs Good afternoon
[4:24:14] City Council Excuse me I
[4:24:17] support the approval of
[4:24:20] the Fifth Amendment to
[4:24:21] the agreement with the path San
[4:24:22] Diego Program for
[4:24:23] the Coordinated Street Outreach
[4:24:24] Program.
[4:24:26] At a time when we've seen so
[4:24:28] many of our homeless programs
[4:24:29] and outreach programs cut
[4:24:31] particularly the Alpha project
[4:24:33] particularly I believe it was I
[4:24:38] forget the good the good center
[4:24:40] I'm blanking on the full name
[4:24:41] of it.
[4:24:42] But anyway we've had so many
[4:24:43] homeless programs cut and this
[4:24:46] is a matter of public safety
[4:24:47] and I know how quick all are to
[4:24:49] defend public safety.
[4:24:51] So I would expect that we could
[4:24:53] have that same approach with
[4:24:56] our homeless, that same
[4:24:57] compassion and empathy and that
[4:24:59] these programs can pan out and
[4:25:01] help the people that they are
[4:25:02] intended to serve.
[4:25:03] Thank you.
[4:25:07] Thank you.
[4:25:08] That concludes in-person public
[4:25:09] comment.
[4:25:10] I've started the five minute
[4:25:11] timer and council chambers.
[4:25:13] We will now turn to the virtual
[4:25:14] queue in which there are
[4:25:16] currently three participants
[4:25:17] requesting to speak.
[4:25:20] We will begin with color with
[4:25:23] the last four digits 8700
[4:25:26] Please begin and thank you Joy
[4:25:34] Senator Yes I support this item
[4:25:37] passed.
[4:25:38] It is absolutely fabulous.
[4:25:40] I don't have personal
[4:25:41] experience with them but I had
[4:25:44] a wonderful experience with
[4:25:45] the homeless couple years ago
[4:25:47] when I moved here and I
[4:25:49] followed their experience with
[4:25:52] past and how they helped them
[4:25:54] and it was very beautiful.
[4:25:55] The only concern I have for
[4:25:57] Path it seems like a few years
[4:25:59] ago they were having trouble
[4:26:01] with really paying their people
[4:26:02] enough to work and perhaps they
[4:26:06] were having trouble filling
[4:26:07] positions that could have been
[4:26:09] corrected And I MAY be way off
[4:26:10] base on that but that just
[4:26:12] popped up when I thought about
[4:26:13] what I was going to say.
[4:26:15] So love path just support them
[4:26:18] wherever we can and love you
[4:26:20] Path for what you do for
[4:26:21] the homeless and that affects
[4:26:23] all of San Diego Love to all
[4:26:26] Thank you.
[4:26:28] Next is Natalie Roski.
[4:26:30] Please begin.
[4:26:34] >> Hi Natalie.
[4:26:36] Rush here District seven.
[4:26:36] So I've been doing some
[4:26:37] research and I'm really getting
[4:26:39] good at my research I think so
[4:26:41] I'm kind of confused on what
[4:26:43] I'm researching and what this
[4:26:45] path San Diego Fifth Amendment
[4:26:47] means because it's telling me
[4:26:51] that the resolution before it
[4:26:54] describes this routine one year
[4:26:55] extension flat funding at 13.6
[4:26:57] million and change.
[4:27:00] But there's an underlining
[4:27:02] amendment does something that
[4:27:04] the resolution never mentions
[4:27:05] It adds a new clause
[4:27:10] acknowledge is that h m c.
[4:27:11] S and c I e the data systems
[4:27:12] used to track and house
[4:27:15] residents are some surveillance
[4:27:16] technology under the trust
[4:27:18] ordinance.
[4:27:20] So moving forward and improving
[4:27:23] are these systems being used
[4:27:25] currently?
[4:27:28] Is there understanding
[4:27:30] the grace period and is this
[4:27:33] being acknowledged or is this
[4:27:35] was known about is it
[4:27:38] the question?
[4:27:38] Thank you.
[4:27:39] That does conclude your time.
[4:27:42] Next speaker is John Leah.
[4:27:44] Please begin.
[4:27:49] Good afternoon.
[4:27:50] Council members.
[4:27:51] It's been a long one but I did
[4:27:52] want to make time to update you
[4:27:54] that I actually that
[4:27:57] the individual that came out
[4:27:58] front of city Council in my rv
[4:28:00] for a period of time I'm not
[4:28:04] sure where ultimately that
[4:28:05] situation is resolved but I
[4:28:07] will tell you that we've run
[4:28:08] into these cases all the time.
[4:28:11] I love that they're an amazing
[4:28:12] provider.
[4:28:13] We have had nothing but a high
[4:28:15] regard for much of their
[4:28:16] service.
[4:28:17] So this is not necessarily
[4:28:18] related to path but we do not
[4:28:20] have a mechanism for people who
[4:28:22] are struggling and falling
[4:28:24] through the cracks to raise
[4:28:26] their hand and go Hey, what's
[4:28:28] going on?
[4:28:29] And I don't think that we are
[4:28:31] capturing the number of people
[4:28:33] that are returning to our
[4:28:35] system effectively because
[4:28:36] after two years if you come
[4:28:39] back into the system are hmas
[4:28:42] recognize here is a brand new
[4:28:43] person anyway we need to be
[4:28:45] listening to our customers.
[4:28:47] We're still not and I would
[4:28:48] hope that we could take that
[4:28:49] seriously.
[4:28:50] Thank you.
[4:28:52] Thank you.
[4:28:53] That does conclude public
[4:28:55] comment on item 203.
[4:28:57] All right.
[4:28:57] Thank you, Deputy Clerk.
[4:28:59] This is an item for discussion
[4:29:02] and we will need a motion.
[4:29:04] So we'll turn over first to
[4:29:05] Council member Whipper Thank
[4:29:07] you Council PRESIDENT I will
[4:29:09] make the motion to approve
[4:29:11] the staff recommendation.
[4:29:13] This presentation is online.
[4:29:15] Both the PowerPoint and
[4:29:17] the staff report are on line
[4:29:20] for everybody to access and
[4:29:22] they've been online for
[4:29:23] everybody to access for several
[4:29:24] days now.
[4:29:26] This does not add more money to
[4:29:30] the contract.
[4:29:32] It extends the term of
[4:29:34] the contract.
[4:29:35] These response teams that I
[4:29:38] have has out there assess
[4:29:39] people who are experiencing
[4:29:41] homelessness and have helped
[4:29:44] hundreds of people not just get
[4:29:46] into emergency shelters but
[4:29:49] also into housing both
[4:29:53] temporary and permanent
[4:29:53] housing.
[4:29:54] And that's very important
[4:29:55] because I am deeply concerned
[4:29:57] about the unavailability of
[4:30:02] emergency shelter.
[4:30:03] We need more shelter beds to be
[4:30:05] available to people.
[4:30:10] But the good news is that path
[4:30:12] is also directing people to
[4:30:13] housing And as long as we're
[4:30:17] getting people off the streets
[4:30:17] and directly into housing,
[4:30:19] that's a good thing.
[4:30:19] One of the most important
[4:30:20] things we could be doing and I
[4:30:22] will approve move the staff
[4:30:25] recommendation.
[4:30:26] All right.
[4:30:27] Thank you, sir.
[4:30:27] So we have a motion by council
[4:30:28] member Whipper and we'll go
[4:30:29] next to Council PRESIDENT Pro
[4:30:31] Tem Lee.
[4:30:32] Thank you Council PRESIDENT And
[4:30:33] thank you to path for their
[4:30:34] continued work as well.
[4:30:35] I'll second this motion.
[4:30:37] >> All right so we have a
[4:30:38] motion by Councilmember Whipper
[4:30:39] and a second by Council
[4:30:40] PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee to move
[4:30:41] the staff recommendation.
[4:30:43] I see Council member John
[4:30:46] Wolpert sup Thank you very much
[4:30:47] and thank you for all the work
[4:30:49] that path does as well.
[4:30:50] I appreciate it.
[4:30:51] I know that does increase
[4:30:53] the amount of the contract but
[4:30:54] it is the Fifth Amendment.
[4:30:55] So are we thinking about doing
[4:30:56] another rfp at some point or a
[4:30:58] new scope of services or what's
[4:31:00] the plan?
[4:31:00] We released the rfp in APRIL of
[4:31:02] this year so we intend to
[4:31:04] fulfill the awardees of the rfp
[4:31:07] in this next fiscal year and
[4:31:10] that will then supersede this
[4:31:11] contract.
[4:31:12] Okay.
[4:31:12] All right.
[4:31:12] Thank you very much.
[4:31:14] And Sara, could you introduce
[4:31:15] yourself for the record since
[4:31:16] you did a response?
[4:31:16] Sorry.
[4:31:17] Third Dorman, director of
[4:31:18] Homelessness Strategies and
[4:31:19] Solutions Deanna would be very
[4:31:21] mad at me if I didn't get that
[4:31:22] done All right, I I don't see
[4:31:24] anybody else in the light.
[4:31:25] I'll just add my Thank you for
[4:31:27] managing that And to the folks
[4:31:30] at path we have a motion by
[4:31:32] Councilmember Lipper and a
[4:31:32] second by Council PRESIDENT Pro
[4:31:34] Tem Lee to move the staff
[4:31:35] recommendation please call
[4:31:37] the roll Deputy Clerk I have
[4:31:39] set up the voting system.
[4:31:40] Please cast your vote.
[4:31:53] The item passes unanimously
[4:31:54] with District two and District
[4:31:56] eight absent.
[4:31:57] >> All right.
[4:31:59] And for meeting management
[4:32:00] the reason we did that was to
[4:32:02] make sure that we have a quorum
[4:32:03] when it comes to not agenda
[4:32:05] public comment at the end.
[4:32:07] So for those that might
[4:32:08] participate remotely stay
[4:32:11] tuned.
[4:32:11] We MAY or MAY not have a quorum
[4:32:13] to have remote not a agenda
[4:32:15] public comment We will
[4:32:16] definitely do it for in-person
[4:32:18] non agenda Public comment
[4:32:20] meeting Management All right
[4:32:23] Deputy Clerk please introduce
[4:32:24] item 202 Thank you Council
[4:32:27] PRESIDENT Item 2o2
[4:32:29] Establishment of a cannabis
[4:32:30] Delivery Services business
[4:32:32] permit and enhanced commercial
[4:32:34] cannabis enforcement mechanisms
[4:32:38] All right.
[4:32:38] I believe this is coming from
[4:32:40] district seven.
[4:32:41] So Councilmember Camp here do
[4:32:42] you want to have some opening
[4:32:42] remarks?
[4:32:43] Thank you.
[4:32:44] Counsel turn it over to your
[4:32:44] staff.
[4:32:45] Yes.
[4:32:45] Council PRESIDENT, thank you
[4:32:46] very much for that.
[4:32:46] And before we begin with
[4:32:47] the staff presentation, I'd
[4:32:49] like to take a moment to
[4:32:50] recognize the amount of work
[4:32:51] that's gone in today's action
[4:32:52] over the past two years not
[4:32:54] only from my office but from
[4:32:55] the mayor's office and cannabis
[4:32:57] workers and businesses, members
[4:32:59] of the public who've engaged
[4:33:00] with us throughout this
[4:33:01] process.
[4:33:02] Cannabis delivery is a complex
[4:33:03] policy issue and the item we
[4:33:05] are putting forward for
[4:33:06] consideration today is one that
[4:33:08] puts accountability, safety and
[4:33:09] workers first.
[4:33:11] So with that I'll turn over to
[4:33:12] Summer Patten, Deputy director
[4:33:13] of policy for my office for
[4:33:15] the presentation.
[4:33:16] >> Thank you.
[4:33:17] i need ten minutes for
[4:33:18] the presentation when you're
[4:33:20] ready.
[4:33:21] >> Good afternoon.
[4:33:22] Council PRESIDENT Lacob and
[4:33:23] council members I'm presenting
[4:33:25] here today on behalf of
[4:33:26] Councilmember Campo
[4:33:27] the establishment of a cannabis
[4:33:28] delivery services business
[4:33:30] permit and enhanced commercial
[4:33:31] cannabis enforcement mechanisms
[4:33:37] >> The proposed actions today
[4:33:38] are to establish a cannabis
[4:33:39] delivery business permit
[4:33:41] category for commercial
[4:33:42] cannabis operators entering
[4:33:43] the city of San Diego to
[4:33:45] conduct cannabis delivery.
[4:33:46] I'm sorry, can you hold on?
[4:33:48] We're not displaying.
[4:33:49] There we go.
[4:33:50] Okay.
[4:33:50] Very nice.
[4:33:50] My apologies for
[4:33:52] the interruption.
[4:33:53] Go ahead.
[4:33:53] Good.
[4:33:55] So that's the first action.
[4:33:57] The second is to establish a
[4:33:58] private right of action to
[4:33:59] allow eligible entities to
[4:34:01] pursue step one enforcement
[4:34:02] against operators that violate
[4:34:04] local commercial cannabis
[4:34:05] regulations.
[4:34:06] And third is to revise
[4:34:08] penalties for noncompliance to
[4:34:10] a maximum of $20,000 per day
[4:34:12] for court imposed civil
[4:34:13] penalties and $20,000 per
[4:34:16] violation for administratively
[4:34:17] imposed civil penalties not to
[4:34:20] exceed $500,000 per parcel or
[4:34:22] business and up to 10,000 per
[4:34:25] violation for administrative
[4:34:26] abatement penalties not to
[4:34:28] exceed 500,000 per parcel or
[4:34:30] structure.
[4:34:32] And before we discuss
[4:34:34] the proposed changes, it's
[4:34:35] helpful to review the licensing
[4:34:36] system around commercial
[4:34:37] cannabis.
[4:34:38] Cannabis in California is
[4:34:40] regulated on a dual track
[4:34:41] system meaning that cannabis is
[4:34:43] regulated both by the state and
[4:34:45] by a businesses, city or county
[4:34:48] And at the state level there
[4:34:49] are two types of retail
[4:34:50] licenses.
[4:34:51] There is a non storefront
[4:34:53] retailer or delivery only
[4:34:54] business which is what we're
[4:34:55] talking about today.
[4:34:57] And there are storefront
[4:34:58] retailers or brick and mortar
[4:34:59] businesses.
[4:35:00] And while state law allows
[4:35:04] cannabis delivery on public
[4:35:05] roads, state law also
[4:35:06] explicitly states that local
[4:35:08] jurisdictions have authority to
[4:35:09] regulate cannabis businesses
[4:35:11] including through business
[4:35:12] license requirements.
[4:35:14] Cities and counties can
[4:35:15] prohibit cannabis of all
[4:35:18] business types some or
[4:35:19] implement their own regulations
[4:35:21] And as shown on the map, this
[4:35:23] creates a patchwork of local
[4:35:24] regulations throughout
[4:35:25] the state.
[4:35:29] >> So if a customer in San
[4:35:30] Diego is ordering cannabis for
[4:35:32] delivery, it can either come
[4:35:34] from a permitted retailer in
[4:35:35] the city a state licensed
[4:35:37] business entering the city to
[4:35:38] deliver or a business operating
[4:35:41] outside of legal requirements.
[4:35:43] Currently the city only permits
[4:35:45] storefront or brick and mortar
[4:35:46] cannabis retailers.
[4:35:48] These are the ones that are
[4:35:49] limited to four per council
[4:35:50] district and they're required
[4:35:51] to obtain a conditional use
[4:35:52] permit.
[4:35:54] They are allowed to deliver
[4:35:55] direct to consumer as part of
[4:35:56] that conditional use permit.
[4:35:58] The city allows state licensed
[4:36:00] delivery from outside of
[4:36:01] the city If that business
[4:36:02] registers for a business tax
[4:36:04] certificate with
[4:36:05] the Treasurer's office and
[4:36:06] remits monthly business taxes.
[4:36:08] The city's land use code does
[4:36:10] not allow delivery only
[4:36:11] non-food storefront retail
[4:36:13] establishments within city
[4:36:14] limits.
[4:36:15] And this ordinance does not
[4:36:16] change that.
[4:36:16] And it does not propose any new
[4:36:18] land uses.
[4:36:21] Cannabis delivery is extremely
[4:36:23] difficult to regulate because
[4:36:24] the operations are mobile.
[4:36:26] And cities can only regulate
[4:36:27] what occurs within their
[4:36:28] jurisdiction.
[4:36:29] And cannabis businesses can
[4:36:30] easily avoid those regulations.
[4:36:32] And on the screen is an example
[4:36:34] of a listing on weed maps for a
[4:36:36] business advertising in North
[4:36:37] Park.
[4:36:39] That's based in Alameda County
[4:36:40] and I'm looking at the license
[4:36:43] on the Department of Cannabis
[4:36:44] Control website.
[4:36:45] It's expired but they currently
[4:36:48] advertise 30 to 60 minute
[4:36:49] deliveries in San Diego.
[4:36:52] So here we can see
[4:36:54] the difference between what's
[4:36:55] advertised to consumers and
[4:36:56] where the current the city
[4:36:58] currently permits cannabis
[4:36:59] retail.
[4:37:00] The image on the left are
[4:37:02] delivery only offerings listed
[4:37:04] on weed maps in San Diego.
[4:37:06] And some of these businesses
[4:37:07] are advertising is based in San
[4:37:09] Diego and are licensed to
[4:37:10] the state.
[4:37:11] Some are not licensed through
[4:37:12] the state or operate on expired
[4:37:14] permits or are not following
[4:37:15] all state and local
[4:37:16] requirements.
[4:37:18] State licensing a strict and
[4:37:19] requires those businesses to
[4:37:21] return to a licensed premise
[4:37:23] after a delivery route.
[4:37:24] To use license facilities to
[4:37:26] restock their product.
[4:37:27] To dispatch deliveries only
[4:37:29] after orders are received and
[4:37:30] logged.
[4:37:31] And it also requires delivery
[4:37:32] of cannabis goods to be
[4:37:33] performed by a driver employed
[4:37:35] by that retailer.
[4:37:37] >> For the retailers to
[4:37:38] maintain an accurate list of
[4:37:39] their delivery employees to
[4:37:40] confirm ages and identities of
[4:37:42] customers.
[4:37:43] And for a delivery drivers to
[4:37:44] carry copies of the retailers
[4:37:46] license id and an employee
[4:37:48] badge.
[4:37:49] Which are just a few examples
[4:37:50] of the numerous other state
[4:37:51] requirements as part of
[4:37:54] commercial cannabis delivery.
[4:37:57] So with that the goals for this
[4:37:59] ordinance are to create a
[4:38:00] centralized regulatory check
[4:38:02] point for cannabis delivery
[4:38:03] services entering the city of
[4:38:04] San Diego.
[4:38:07] It's to increase the cost of
[4:38:07] noncompliance through raise
[4:38:10] penalties.
[4:38:11] And third, it's to allow
[4:38:12] private civil action where
[4:38:14] the city currently lacks staff
[4:38:15] capacity.
[4:38:17] Next slide.
[4:38:19] So with stronger civil
[4:38:20] enforcement the goal is to
[4:38:21] incentivize registration for a
[4:38:23] cannabis delivery services
[4:38:25] business permit and encourage
[4:38:26] local compliance.
[4:38:28] This requirement would be in
[4:38:30] addition to the business tax
[4:38:31] certificate and cannabis
[4:38:32] business tax currently required
[4:38:34] and administered through
[4:38:35] the City Treasurer's office.
[4:38:36] So all three of those processes
[4:38:38] will be administered by
[4:38:39] the city Treasurer's office.
[4:38:42] Cannabis delivery businesses
[4:38:44] entering into the city of San
[4:38:45] Diego would be required to
[4:38:46] obtain the permit.
[4:38:48] This does not include current
[4:38:49] cup holders as delivery
[4:38:51] services are already permitted
[4:38:53] and regulated through their
[4:38:54] conditional use permit and they
[4:38:56] are subject to an annual
[4:38:57] cannabis fee at around $15,000
[4:38:59] a year.
[4:39:00] The application requirements
[4:39:02] are modeled off of the City of
[4:39:03] Ventura which has a similar
[4:39:04] license and would require a
[4:39:06] copy of the business's state
[4:39:07] retail license a copy of their
[4:39:10] business tax certificate
[4:39:11] information of all owners and
[4:39:14] employees.
[4:39:15] Proof that employees are direct
[4:39:17] employees of the delivery
[4:39:18] service as required by state
[4:39:20] law.
[4:39:21] And the fee amount would be
[4:39:22] determined in a future action
[4:39:24] to determine the exact costs
[4:39:26] recoverable amounts related to
[4:39:28] the registration or permit
[4:39:28] expense.
[4:39:36] So the proposed enforcement
[4:39:37] changes are to increase civil
[4:39:38] penalties in three categories
[4:39:40] in the code regulating
[4:39:41] commercial cannabis operations.
[4:39:43] The first is to increase court
[4:39:45] awarded civil penalties for
[4:39:46] commercial cannabis violations
[4:39:47] up to $20,000 per day for
[4:39:50] cannabis business.
[4:39:51] The second is to increase
[4:39:52] administrative civil penalties
[4:39:54] for violations up to $20,000
[4:39:55] per day not to exceed 500,000
[4:39:56] per business.
[4:40:00] And third, this ordinance
[4:40:01] defines cannabis violations as
[4:40:03] a public nuisance which would
[4:40:04] then allow the city to abate
[4:40:05] violations if there's capacity.
[4:40:08] The penalty amounts are aligned
[4:40:09] with recent updates to land
[4:40:10] development code which was
[4:40:12] updated at $10,000 provi lation
[4:40:14] not to exceed 500,000 per
[4:40:16] parcel.
[4:40:18] But the significant enforcement
[4:40:19] change is to introduce a
[4:40:21] private right of action for
[4:40:22] cannabis related code
[4:40:23] violations.
[4:40:25] Private right of action are
[4:40:26] more commonly used in labor law
[4:40:27] but was implemented to allow
[4:40:29] civil enforcement against
[4:40:30] cannabis violations most
[4:40:31] recently through ab 1171 which
[4:40:34] was implemented in 2024.
[4:40:36] The ordinance proposes
[4:40:37] establishing the private right
[4:40:39] of action to allow legal
[4:40:40] cannabis businesses or labor
[4:40:42] organizations representing
[4:40:43] cannabis workers to file civil
[4:40:45] actions to enforce compliance.
[4:40:47] This means that a licensed
[4:40:48] cannabis business could sue a
[4:40:50] business if they can establish
[4:40:51] that a violation of this
[4:40:53] ordinance occurred within city
[4:40:54] limits and any penalties
[4:40:56] recovered would be distributed
[4:40:58] between the city for
[4:40:59] enforcement and the entity
[4:41:00] bringing the civil action 65%
[4:41:02] to 35%.
[4:41:04] And this distribution was
[4:41:05] modeled after the private
[4:41:07] Attorney General's act or paga
[4:41:08] which was updated in 2020 for.
[4:41:12] So with that the recommended
[4:41:14] action today is to approve
[4:41:15] amendments to Chapter four
[4:41:18] Article two Division 15 of
[4:41:19] the San Diego Municipal Code to
[4:41:21] establish a cannabis delivery
[4:41:22] permit business permit category
[4:41:24] for commercial cannabis
[4:41:25] operators entering the city of
[4:41:26] San Diego to conduct delivery
[4:41:29] to create a private right of
[4:41:30] action allowing eligible
[4:41:31] entities including state
[4:41:32] certified cannabis retailers
[4:41:33] and labor unions representing
[4:41:35] cannabis workers to pursue
[4:41:37] civil enforcement against
[4:41:38] operators that violate local
[4:41:39] commercial cannabis regulations
[4:41:42] and to revise penalties for
[4:41:44] noncompliance to a maximum of
[4:41:45] $20,000 per day for court
[4:41:47] imposed civil penalties.
[4:41:49] 20,000 per violation for
[4:41:49] administratively imposed
[4:41:50] penalties and up to $10,000 per
[4:41:53] violation for administrative
[4:41:55] abatement penalties.
[4:41:58] And that concludes my
[4:41:59] presentation.
[4:42:00] Thank you.
[4:42:01] All right.
[4:42:01] Thank you very much for
[4:42:02] the work and the presentation.
[4:42:04] Now I'll turn it over to
[4:42:04] the office of the rba for
[4:42:07] comment.
[4:42:07] >> Thank you.
[4:42:07] Council PRESIDENT Sergio
[4:42:08] Leclaire from the iab his
[4:42:09] office as presented by staff
[4:42:12] The this proposal would make
[4:42:13] four main changes to
[4:42:15] the municipal code.
[4:42:16] First they would create a new
[4:42:17] permit category specifically
[4:42:19] for cannabis businesses that
[4:42:20] are based outside the city but
[4:42:23] deliver cannabis products to
[4:42:24] customers within city limits.
[4:42:26] Consistent with the status quo.
[4:42:29] This proposal will not permit
[4:42:30] delivery only businesses based
[4:42:32] within the city.
[4:42:34] Second, it would establish a
[4:42:35] private right of action
[4:42:36] allowing compliant cannabis
[4:42:38] businesses and representative
[4:42:41] labor organizations to pursue
[4:42:42] civil action against operators
[4:42:44] without a civil city permit
[4:42:46] without a valid city permit.
[4:42:48] Civil penalties recoverable in
[4:42:50] this manner would be shared
[4:42:51] with the city.
[4:42:53] Third, it will classify
[4:42:54] cannabis businesses without a
[4:42:56] city permit as a public
[4:42:57] nuisance.
[4:42:58] And lastly it would separate.
[4:42:59] It would update fines for those
[4:43:01] that fail to comply with
[4:43:03] the city's cannabis permitting
[4:43:04] requirements.
[4:43:06] Based on our conversations with
[4:43:07] relevant departments.
[4:43:08] The fiscal impact of this
[4:43:10] proposal is uncertain but MAY
[4:43:12] not be substantial.
[4:43:13] There are three noteworthy
[4:43:15] sources of potential revenue
[4:43:17] outlined in the proposal.
[4:43:18] First is permitting fees.
[4:43:20] Second is city imposed fines.
[4:43:22] And then third is the city's
[4:43:24] share of civil penalties
[4:43:25] recovered through private right
[4:43:26] of action which would be one
[4:43:28] time in nature.
[4:43:30] Regarding permitting fees,
[4:43:32] the number of businesses likely
[4:43:33] to seek a new delivery permit
[4:43:35] is limited currently to conduct
[4:43:37] business including deliveries
[4:43:39] within the city.
[4:43:40] Cannabis businesses outside
[4:43:41] city limits must obtain a
[4:43:43] business tax certificate and
[4:43:44] remit cannabis business tax.
[4:43:47] The city Treasurer's office
[4:43:48] indicated that there are five
[4:43:49] of these compliant businesses.
[4:43:51] Staff noted that if a new
[4:43:53] permit is established these
[4:43:54] five businesses are expected to
[4:43:56] obtain the new permit in
[4:43:58] addition to the business tax to
[4:44:01] cannabis delivery services that
[4:44:03] do not currently have business
[4:44:05] Business tax ratification,
[4:44:07] however, would likely not
[4:44:08] comply with additional
[4:44:10] permitting requirement given
[4:44:12] the small number of affected
[4:44:13] businesses Any permit fee
[4:44:15] revenue as well as cannabis
[4:44:16] business tax revenue would
[4:44:17] likely be limited unless
[4:44:19] private rights of action compel
[4:44:21] enforcement.
[4:44:23] Regarding fines we found that
[4:44:25] the city currently does not
[4:44:26] receive currently receives
[4:44:27] minimal city issued penalty
[4:44:29] revenue from delivery operators
[4:44:31] that do not comply with
[4:44:32] the city's current regulations.
[4:44:34] Therefore, even with
[4:44:35] adjustments to the fines city
[4:44:37] issued penalty revenue would
[4:44:39] likely remain minimal.
[4:44:42] The private Right of action
[4:44:43] provision offers an additional
[4:44:44] enforcement tool for private
[4:44:46] entities.
[4:44:48] Though state law allows
[4:44:49] licensed cannabis businesses
[4:44:51] including those permitted by by
[4:44:53] the city to pursue civil action
[4:44:56] against operators without a
[4:44:58] state license, cannabis
[4:44:59] license.
[4:45:00] The city's city attorney's
[4:45:02] office has not found any
[4:45:03] reported cases of such
[4:45:04] lawsuits.
[4:45:05] So it's unclear whether
[4:45:06] eligible parties would choose
[4:45:08] to pursue civil action under
[4:45:10] this proposal.
[4:45:12] As noted by the presentation,
[4:45:13] however, the state's provision
[4:45:14] has a higher burden of proof
[4:45:16] and a more limited financial
[4:45:17] incentive Compared to this
[4:45:19] proposal.
[4:45:20] Additionally, this proposal
[4:45:21] would also allow compliant city
[4:45:23] businesses to pursue civil
[4:45:24] action against operators
[4:45:25] without a city permit work
[4:45:26] orders regardless of whether
[4:45:29] they have a state issued
[4:45:31] cannabis license or not or
[4:45:34] the intent of this proposal is
[4:45:35] to regulate state licensed
[4:45:37] cannabis businesses not
[4:45:38] complying with city regulations
[4:45:40] or unregulated operators.
[4:45:42] We note that the greater
[4:45:43] compliance challenge lies
[4:45:44] within with cannabis delivery
[4:45:46] businesses that operate
[4:45:48] illicitly without state issued
[4:45:49] licenses or illicit operators
[4:45:52] since again they're unlikely to
[4:45:53] comply with the new additional
[4:45:55] local permit requirement.
[4:45:57] Additionally, since this
[4:45:58] proposal doesn't increase
[4:45:59] the city's enforcement levels,
[4:46:02] the permit and fines provision
[4:46:03] of this proposal MAY not
[4:46:05] significantly improve
[4:46:06] compliance among illicit or
[4:46:08] unregulated operators and
[4:46:09] materially increase the city's
[4:46:11] revenues.
[4:46:12] Unless a private right of
[4:46:13] action compels enforcement
[4:46:16] During our discussions with
[4:46:18] the Development Services
[4:46:20] Department and the Treasurer
[4:46:22] they raise concerns regarding
[4:46:23] implementation.
[4:46:24] These operational concerns
[4:46:25] include uncertainty over
[4:46:26] whether which new which
[4:46:28] department would enforce
[4:46:30] the new perimeter permit or
[4:46:32] what enforcement of the new
[4:46:33] permit would look like from
[4:46:34] the city's perspective.
[4:46:36] Questions about the city's
[4:46:37] authority to find businesses
[4:46:39] located outside city boundaries
[4:46:40] and whether additional
[4:46:42] resources would be needed to
[4:46:43] administer and enforce
[4:46:44] the program.
[4:46:46] We recommend that council
[4:46:48] inquire further with
[4:46:48] departments including the city
[4:46:50] Attorney's office, city
[4:46:51] treasurers, dsd and police
[4:46:53] the police department regarding
[4:46:55] the practical challenges of
[4:46:56] implementing and enforcing
[4:46:57] these provisions and whether
[4:46:59] they are there are any
[4:47:00] outstanding issues.
[4:47:02] This concludes my comments and
[4:47:04] are available for any
[4:47:05] questions.
[4:47:06] Then comes Council PRESIDENT.
[4:47:06] All right, Thank you for your
[4:47:07] always appreciate the input at
[4:47:09] the office.
[4:47:09] With that Deputy clerk please
[4:47:11] proceed with public comment.
[4:47:13] >> This item received five
[4:47:15] comments in Opposition via our
[4:47:17] economic forum which has been
[4:47:18] distributed to the Council.
[4:47:19] We'll begin with in-person
[4:47:21] comment.
[4:47:23] DeAndre Brooks please come
[4:47:25] forward.
[4:47:25] You'll have one minute to speak
[4:47:27] while DeAndre walks to
[4:47:28] the microphone I would ask Matt
[4:47:28] Stransky.
[4:47:32] Mark o'Brien as our man king
[4:47:33] And Terry best to please come
[4:47:35] to the front row Council
[4:47:39] members My name is DeAndre
[4:47:40] Brooks and I'm here tonight as
[4:47:43] a concerned citizen with strong
[4:47:45] opposition to this ordinance
[4:47:47] for several reasons.
[4:47:49] In a sense it creates a
[4:47:51] monopoly on the delivery
[4:47:52] services and that's also
[4:47:54] counterproductive to
[4:47:55] the county's cannabis equity
[4:47:57] program that's been spearheaded
[4:48:00] So for individuals who have
[4:48:01] been harmed by the war on drugs
[4:48:03] and then living out over
[4:48:05] criminalized communities an
[4:48:06] opportunity to get into
[4:48:07] the cannabis industry so we end
[4:48:10] up voting yes to things like
[4:48:12] that.
[4:48:13] It is super counterproductive
[4:48:14] to what we're trying to do as a
[4:48:16] county.
[4:48:17] And if you recall this same
[4:48:19] issue came before this city
[4:48:20] council and you guys kind of
[4:48:23] shut it down basically sort of
[4:48:24] county had to come in to give
[4:48:26] that demographic an opportunity
[4:48:27] to thrive in this industry.
[4:48:29] So again, I'm a strong
[4:48:31] opposition to this and I urge
[4:48:32] you to consider everything I
[4:48:34] just said Thank you, MR. Ski.
[4:48:40] I don't see you.
[4:48:42] Okay.
[4:48:42] We'll move on to Marco Briones
[4:48:45] Thank you, council members.
[4:48:46] But again we stand in
[4:48:47] solidarity with the brothers
[4:48:48] and sisters of 135 you if cw
[4:48:51] and ask you to support this
[4:48:52] ordinance today at a time
[4:48:54] cannabis delivery businesses
[4:48:55] are avoiding paying the city's
[4:48:56] cannabis retail tax and harming
[4:48:58] our local permitted cannabis
[4:48:59] retailers like the ones I've
[4:49:00] known since childhood that are
[4:49:03] here today.
[4:49:03] So our local cannabis workers
[4:49:04] are really feeling these
[4:49:05] effects of the unregulated
[4:49:07] activity, seeing their hours of
[4:49:09] layoffs and wages reduced
[4:49:11] workers and taxpayers are
[4:49:12] better.
[4:49:13] >> We support this and we ask
[4:49:14] you to do the same.
[4:49:15] Thank you.
[4:49:19] Thank you.
[4:49:20] Our next speaker is Armand
[4:49:21] King.
[4:49:21] All right.
[4:49:23] Do you have several speakers
[4:49:25] reading time to you?
[4:49:26] When I call your name please
[4:49:27] raise your hand to confirm
[4:49:29] you're here.
[4:49:29] Justin Lewis going on.
[4:49:30] Okay.
[4:49:32] Anthony Hawkins.
[4:49:34] Okay, Louis The waste business
[4:49:38] gone.
[4:49:38] Okay.
[4:49:40] And tis one Let us Okay.
[4:49:44] >> So that you'll have three
[4:49:44] minutes.
[4:49:45] Okay.
[4:49:45] Sounds good.
[4:49:47] Thank you.
[4:49:48] So what was pointed out was
[4:49:49] Alameda, right?
[4:49:51] Alameda problem There are there
[4:49:52] is a problem with dispensary
[4:49:54] deliveries happening from
[4:49:55] outside of San Diego County.
[4:49:57] Very much so that should be
[4:49:59] regulated.
[4:50:00] What's not mentioned is our
[4:50:01] neighbors La mesa, National
[4:50:02] City, Chula Vista.
[4:50:04] Let me grow now They cannot
[4:50:05] deliver across the street
[4:50:06] without going through this and
[4:50:08] I'm not here to fight for them.
[4:50:09] I doubt has been reach out to
[4:50:11] these cities to let them know
[4:50:12] that this is about to happen.
[4:50:13] There has not been adequate
[4:50:14] reach out to communities We
[4:50:17] there hasn't been a time limit
[4:50:20] right now The problem is and
[4:50:21] what I'm here representing
[4:50:22] those social equity applicants
[4:50:25] I'm the program manager for
[4:50:26] the County of San Diego Social
[4:50:28] Equity Program.
[4:50:29] The majority of our
[4:50:31] participants are San Diego City
[4:50:33] residents from your district,
[4:50:34] your district or district in
[4:50:36] your district the majority of
[4:50:37] them.
[4:50:38] Why are they in a county
[4:50:39] program?
[4:50:40] Because we all know I thought
[4:50:42] we know we had it here and
[4:50:44] the same entities that are
[4:50:46] coming bringing that brought
[4:50:47] this law because it didn't come
[4:50:48] from your office, it came from
[4:50:49] the same people, the same evil
[4:50:51] people that stripped us from
[4:50:55] having a social equity program
[4:50:56] here are now back in this.
[4:50:59] So what's behind the scenes
[4:51:00] That private right to action
[4:51:02] private right to action is
[4:51:03] saying there now you all by
[4:51:05] voting yes or giving them a
[4:51:07] loaded gun to now attack
[4:51:09] the very people that should be
[4:51:11] in the city program right now
[4:51:13] These people live in your city.
[4:51:14] They live in Linda Vista.
[4:51:16] They live in North Park.
[4:51:17] They live in southeast San
[4:51:18] Diego.
[4:51:19] They live here.
[4:51:20] And even if now they have to
[4:51:21] locate because to have a
[4:51:23] delivery service you have to
[4:51:24] have a building somewhere to
[4:51:26] deliver.
[4:51:26] Forget outside.
[4:51:28] Forget Oakland, forget L.A. San
[4:51:29] Diego residents that you're
[4:51:31] attacking here are people so
[4:51:33] they have to have a break not a
[4:51:35] brick and mortar but a building
[4:51:36] where they store their their
[4:51:39] stories that they live in San
[4:51:39] Diego.
[4:51:40] They pay rent in Central City.
[4:51:42] They shop in San Diego City.
[4:51:43] Where's the revenue coming back
[4:51:45] to here?
[4:51:46] So my only ask is is there a
[4:51:48] way for us if we want to
[4:51:50] register them because they're
[4:51:51] going to be legal operators,
[4:51:53] Can we set up a process to
[4:51:56] where the city of San Diego
[4:51:57] knows who they are but to add
[4:51:59] an extra barrier to people who
[4:52:00] have been buried and we stand
[4:52:03] here marching on the ashes of a
[4:52:05] program that we should have had
[4:52:07] right Because certain people
[4:52:09] are afraid to feel the wrath of
[4:52:12] high paid lobbyists that are
[4:52:14] pushing this forward.
[4:52:16] >> I have represented
[4:52:17] the people from your city.
[4:52:19] Clean this up.
[4:52:21] Yes, we need to regulate
[4:52:22] outside people.
[4:52:23] Yes, we do.
[4:52:23] But this ain't it.
[4:52:25] Let's do this right Because
[4:52:26] once you sign this once you say
[4:52:28] yes and this is put into place
[4:52:29] you're giving You heard of a
[4:52:30] Trojan horse, right?
[4:52:32] It looks nice and shiny.
[4:52:33] The way to deliver to your is
[4:52:35] we're keeping out all these
[4:52:36] outside folks But meanwhile
[4:52:37] inside that Trojan horse is an
[4:52:39] army ready to attack.
[4:52:40] They can't wait to see all
[4:52:41] these people out of business.
[4:52:43] They couldn't stop the county
[4:52:44] the same way they stopped
[4:52:45] the city They couldn't And
[4:52:47] we're about to have unlimited
[4:52:48] delivery services.
[4:52:51] Thank you for your time.
[4:52:51] Thank you.
[4:52:53] Next up Terry Bass.
[4:52:54] Well, Terry walks to
[4:52:54] the microphone.
[4:52:56] I would like to ask Daniela
[4:52:57] Nelson, Victoria Bush, James
[4:53:00] Case, Nate Ferryman and
[4:53:03] allegedly Otto to please come
[4:53:03] to the front row please Again,
[4:53:06] Terry.
[4:53:06] Thank you.
[4:53:07] I'm Terry Best, a voter in
[4:53:08] District three.
[4:53:10] This appears to be an
[4:53:11] unnecessary law aimed at
[4:53:13] the Social at the county social
[4:53:15] equity program.
[4:53:17] My suggestion would be to
[4:53:18] please remove the private right
[4:53:20] of action portion from
[4:53:22] the proposal.
[4:53:23] It is just wrong and shame on
[4:53:26] you.
[4:53:27] >> Shame on you too.
[4:53:31] Please also modify the proposal
[4:53:33] to only cover out of county
[4:53:35] delivery services.
[4:53:37] Please exclude all three within
[4:53:39] San Diego County and San Diego
[4:53:42] County itself from this law.
[4:53:44] Each of our cities has a robust
[4:53:46] cannabis permitting process.
[4:53:48] It is not necessary to be
[4:53:50] hostile to other cities
[4:53:52] delivery operations.
[4:53:54] Please do this so that at
[4:53:56] the very least the one licensed
[4:53:58] type where we struggling
[4:54:01] entrepreneur could hope to get
[4:54:02] into the industry is not
[4:54:03] blocked by special interests.
[4:54:10] Thank you that those who do not
[4:54:11] want the competition
[4:54:12] the current city operators
[4:54:13] behind this proposal have
[4:54:14] enjoyed additional
[4:54:15] consideration.
[4:54:15] Thank you.
[4:54:17] No other industry enjoys.
[4:54:19] Now the city is considering
[4:54:20] whether that does conclude your
[4:54:21] time on the board.
[4:54:22] What would you do if you took
[4:54:25] special interest along with a
[4:54:26] rabbit for a profit and any
[4:54:28] other.
[4:54:34] >> Thank you.
[4:54:35] Next speaker is Don Ellen
[4:54:36] Nelson.
[4:54:40] Hello, everybody.
[4:54:41] Good evening.
[4:54:42] My name is Donald Nelson.
[4:54:43] I am a proud resident of San
[4:54:45] Diego and live out to just
[4:54:46] outside of City Heights.
[4:54:47] I am actually here in support
[4:54:50] of this measure.
[4:54:51] Having worked on the license
[4:54:52] cannabis delivery in San Diego.
[4:54:54] I have firsthand seen
[4:54:55] the impact of an illegal market
[4:54:58] Continuing to have legitimate
[4:54:58] business licenses are
[4:54:59] legitimate businesses,
[4:55:02] employees and consumers while
[4:55:04] license operators invest
[4:55:05] significant resources into
[4:55:07] complying with state and local
[4:55:08] regulations regulations.
[4:55:10] Many unlicensed operators
[4:55:11] continue to conduct business
[4:55:13] without oversight
[4:55:14] accountability and
[4:55:16] consequences.
[4:55:17] Licensed cannabis Licensed
[4:55:18] cannabis is required to test
[4:55:21] the products, verify customer
[4:55:23] rage, maintain strict inventory
[4:55:24] controls and pay taxes to
[4:55:26] support our local community.
[4:55:28] Illegal operators do not do
[4:55:29] none of those things.
[4:55:31] They undermine public safety,
[4:55:32] avoid paying taxes and create
[4:55:34] unfair competition for
[4:55:35] businesses that are trying to
[4:55:36] do things right.
[4:55:38] I myself has been a part of
[4:55:39] the cannabis industry for five
[4:55:40] years and over the time I've
[4:55:42] watched them do that does
[4:55:43] conclude your time.
[4:55:44] >> Thank you.
[4:55:44] Thank you.
[4:55:46] Next speaker is Victoria Bush.
[4:55:48] Victoria.
[4:55:48] Here.
[4:55:51] Okay.
[4:55:52] James Case Thank you Counsel My
[4:55:56] time.
[4:55:57] Thank you, Council members.
[4:55:58] My name is James Case.
[4:55:59] I'm a resident of District two
[4:56:01] and I've lived and worked in
[4:56:03] San Diego, the city of San
[4:56:04] Diego for over 30 years since
[4:56:06] SEPTEMBER of 2021.
[4:56:08] I've been a proud member of
[4:56:09] the United Food and Commercial
[4:56:10] Workers Union as a delivery
[4:56:12] driver for legal registered
[4:56:14] cannabis dispensaries San
[4:56:15] Diego.
[4:56:16] I'm not evil.
[4:56:17] I'm a 63 year old grandpa.
[4:56:19] I do my job.
[4:56:20] I love my job And that's four
[4:56:23] and a half years I've been
[4:56:24] doing this.
[4:56:24] I've delivered I've driven over
[4:56:27] 100,000 miles on the streets of
[4:56:28] San Diego delivering cannabis.
[4:56:30] And one thing I've learned to
[4:56:32] be here today is it's about
[4:56:33] the money The city needs
[4:56:34] the money.
[4:56:36] Unlicensed operators have no
[4:56:38] incentive to pay business
[4:56:39] taxes.
[4:56:40] Those business taxes not only
[4:56:41] fund the works of the city,
[4:56:44] those operators also provide
[4:56:46] good jobs like my union job
[4:56:48] where the people who have those
[4:56:50] jobs spend that money in
[4:56:52] the county in the city.
[4:56:54] So those dollars not only thank
[4:56:59] that does the county help
[4:57:00] the community?
[4:57:01] Next speaker is Nate Furman.
[4:57:03] Don't see Nate here.
[4:57:06] I will go to allegedly order
[4:57:08] next please smile.
[4:57:09] Just coming to the microphone
[4:57:11] Todd Walters grant Tom, Robert
[4:57:14] Wood, Larry Beekman and Eduardo
[4:57:17] Battista Please come to talk
[4:57:20] about a war on drugs.
[4:57:21] Did you guys ever think you'd
[4:57:22] be micromanaging drug turf
[4:57:24] competition and stuff like
[4:57:26] that?
[4:57:26] How cool is that?
[4:57:27] Right?
[4:57:27] It used to be illegal.
[4:57:29] Now it's not.
[4:57:30] I mean one day it could be
[4:57:31] again.
[4:57:31] Who knows?
[4:57:32] It's like on the edge of your
[4:57:34] seat which is so interesting
[4:57:36] because people think it's still
[4:57:37] profitable.
[4:57:37] The government has taken like
[4:57:39] $60 billion industry and it's
[4:57:43] like governance.
[4:57:45] >> We heard your daddy I mean
[4:57:46] talk about being able to make
[4:57:47] all the money and not have to
[4:57:48] pay taxes.
[4:57:49] Then you come here like listen,
[4:57:50] we need you to regulate it and
[4:57:52] I do not want these people
[4:57:53] coming into my territory.
[4:57:54] So you guys are going to need
[4:57:55] to regulate that know But this
[4:58:02] is what is so interesting New
[4:58:04] permits you know what I mean?
[4:58:06] It's like I'm sorry.
[4:58:07] I just I don't understand why
[4:58:09] people think it's cool for you
[4:58:10] to come to the government and
[4:58:12] be like what's going to take
[4:58:14] billions of dollars out of my
[4:58:17] pocket like I did?
[4:58:19] >> But good for you guys,
[4:58:20] right?
[4:58:21] And it's supposed to go to city
[4:58:22] services.
[4:58:23] >> Looks like it's working.
[4:58:26] Thank you.
[4:58:26] That does conclude your time.
[4:58:28] Our next speaker is Todd
[4:58:29] Walters.
[4:58:33] Good evening City council and
[4:58:34] city staff and thank you very
[4:58:35] much for your time.
[4:58:36] It's very valuable and I
[4:58:37] respect it.
[4:58:39] Most people aren't aware of it.
[4:58:42] The cannabis legal cannabis
[4:58:42] industry is in trouble.
[4:58:44] It's not doing well.
[4:58:46] The unpermitted cannabis
[4:58:47] delivery services are taking
[4:58:48] business away from those
[4:58:49] licensed retailers who are
[4:58:51] paying taxes.
[4:58:52] The illicit cannabis market can
[4:58:53] treat contributes to a shadow
[4:58:55] economy where wage theft,
[4:58:57] unsafe working conditions and
[4:58:59] labor exploitation are more
[4:59:00] likely to occur.
[4:59:01] Workers in legal cannabis
[4:59:03] industry should not have to
[4:59:04] compete against businesses that
[4:59:05] ignore regulations and avoid
[4:59:06] paying their fair share.
[4:59:09] Stronger licensing requirements
[4:59:10] help ensure that cannabis
[4:59:11] businesses operating in San
[4:59:13] Diego follow the same rules.
[4:59:15] Ensuring operators contribute
[4:59:16] to the cannabis business tax
[4:59:18] helps generate revenue for our
[4:59:20] city essential services which
[4:59:21] we know we need.
[4:59:23] Supporting this ordinance means
[4:59:25] protecting workers responsible
[4:59:27] business and the integrity of
[4:59:29] Senegal's regulated cannabis
[4:59:30] industry.
[4:59:31] In conclusion I just ask you to
[4:59:33] support this ordinance and
[4:59:34] support the workers.
[4:59:36] Thank you.
[4:59:36] Thank you.
[4:59:37] Our next speaker is Grant Tom.
[4:59:44] >> Good evening.
[4:59:45] I'm Grant Tom Secretary
[4:59:48] Treasurer Jacobi Look at 135 I
[4:59:48] represent about 12,000 members
[4:59:50] throughout the county
[4:59:52] everywhere including retail,
[4:59:53] cannabis, medical, kiser
[4:59:56] everything I know the out of
[4:59:57] town companies and listed
[5:00:00] operators of unpermitted
[5:00:00] cannabis businesses that are
[5:00:02] currently operating or harming
[5:00:03] or illegal local cannabis
[5:00:05] industry and operators and
[5:00:07] they're undercutting taxpayers
[5:00:08] but not paying their fair share
[5:00:10] of the cannabis retail tax just
[5:00:13] hurts the workers who are
[5:00:15] causing reduce hours and we've
[5:00:16] had tons of layoffs.
[5:00:17] It's really sad.
[5:00:19] It's important to maintain
[5:00:20] the integrity of your San
[5:00:22] Diego's regulated your cannabis
[5:00:24] industry.
[5:00:25] It's also important to protect
[5:00:27] the workers and the taxpayer.
[5:00:31] This ordinance creates enhanced
[5:00:32] enforcement to protect those
[5:00:34] workers and their families
[5:00:37] including other local high road
[5:00:38] cannabis businesses.
[5:00:39] Please support this ordinance.
[5:00:41] Thank you guys very much.
[5:00:43] Thank you.
[5:00:44] Robert Wood.
[5:00:47] While Robert walks to
[5:00:49] the microphone, I will ask for
[5:00:51] the folks as needed in time to
[5:00:53] please raise my hand when
[5:00:54] called Eduardo Camacho Eduardo
[5:01:02] Livio Marquez No.
[5:01:06] Okay.
[5:01:08] Ada Castaneda okay, So Ada is
[5:01:11] here so you'll have to answer.
[5:01:19] >> Okay?
[5:01:20] >> Doug Okay.
[5:01:21] Thank you.
[5:01:21] First of all, my name is Robert
[5:01:23] Wood.
[5:01:23] I am a citizen of San Diego
[5:01:26] County.
[5:01:27] I was born and raised in
[5:01:28] the city of San Diego.
[5:01:30] I did prison time for selling
[5:01:32] marijuana.
[5:01:33] Now I go throughout
[5:01:35] the community, try to improve
[5:01:37] it in various ways and I'm a
[5:01:40] social equity cannabis
[5:01:40] advocate.
[5:01:44] Would that be I'm one of
[5:01:44] the people he helped build
[5:01:45] the cannabis industry in
[5:01:47] the county of San Diego at one
[5:01:49] point and one of the people who
[5:01:51] went to prison behind it And
[5:01:53] now I'm out.
[5:01:54] I'm ready to do things legally.
[5:01:55] I told five different greens
[5:01:55] one the nba.
[5:01:58] I understand barriers to entry,
[5:02:00] barriers to entry be it dealt
[5:02:03] with Businesses want to keep
[5:02:04] people out of something they
[5:02:06] come up with ridiculous like
[5:02:07] this ridiculousness like this.
[5:02:09] They come up with things where
[5:02:11] they say Oh you're probably
[5:02:13] right too soon so you can just
[5:02:15] personally sue me into oblivion
[5:02:16] yourself.
[5:02:17] You don't need anybody else to
[5:02:19] do it for you.
[5:02:20] This is this is this is
[5:02:21] incredible to me.
[5:02:23] The people in the San Diego
[5:02:25] Social Equity Cannabis program
[5:02:27] are people from San Diego.
[5:02:29] We all arrested in San Diego
[5:02:32] for cannabis at some point
[5:02:35] Social equity cannabis.
[5:02:38] It's just that is social
[5:02:38] equity.
[5:02:39] Do you think that any of these
[5:02:41] businesses that got together it
[5:02:44] concocted this that one time
[5:02:45] about such work I can't see one
[5:02:48] facing one of these owners in
[5:02:49] here that came down to
[5:02:50] the social equity program and
[5:02:52] took the time to talk to us and
[5:02:54] try in equities you would think
[5:02:56] that they would be embracing
[5:02:57] this, trying to work at it and
[5:03:00] saying you got to try to get
[5:03:00] into this Cool.
[5:03:02] Let us see what we can do to
[5:03:04] help you guys If they take
[5:03:06] tooth and nail the whole time,
[5:03:09] it's time that the game stop is
[5:03:12] time that this gets torn up,
[5:03:14] that the barriers to entry stop
[5:03:16] and social equity is treated
[5:03:17] like we're just supposed to be
[5:03:20] sociable and equitable.
[5:03:21] >> Thank you.
[5:03:36] >> Thank you.
[5:03:37] Blair Beekman.
[5:03:37] All right.
[5:03:37] Thank you.
[5:03:37] Where we going?
[5:03:38] I have not known much about
[5:03:39] this item.
[5:03:41] It was a learning process for
[5:03:42] myself.
[5:03:43] I really like hearing public
[5:03:44] comment on it about the social
[5:03:48] equity lack that seems to be a
[5:03:50] part of this.
[5:03:51] We try to make up rules and
[5:03:53] laws sometimes that we feel is
[5:03:55] just gosh darn good, you know
[5:03:58] and we're doing a good thing.
[5:03:59] It has a logic to it is a good
[5:04:03] logic but that logic doesn't
[5:04:05] take into account what maybe is
[5:04:08] going on underneath.
[5:04:10] This is a group that seems to
[5:04:11] have some sort of real thing
[5:04:13] going on in wanting to nail
[5:04:15] social equity with marijuana
[5:04:20] purchases and how that process
[5:04:23] can work.
[5:04:24] I mean Oakland has always
[5:04:25] created really good examples of
[5:04:27] social equity.
[5:04:28] Perhaps you can talk to them at
[5:04:30] this time at this needs a bit
[5:04:33] of more review and work it
[5:04:35] sounds like Thank you.
[5:04:36] >> Thank you Eduardo Batista
[5:04:40] followed by Anthony Ralphs and
[5:04:45] more so Daniel.
[5:04:46] Good evening Council members My
[5:04:48] name is Eduardo Batista and I
[5:04:49] respectfully oppose this
[5:04:51] cannabis delivery proposal.
[5:04:52] I support legal cannabis
[5:04:53] businesses paying taxes
[5:04:55] following the rules and
[5:04:56] operating responsibly.
[5:04:58] But this proposal goes beyond
[5:04:59] fair regulation.
[5:05:00] It creates new barriers for
[5:05:02] licensed delivery operators and
[5:05:03] gives existing cannabis
[5:05:04] retailers the ability to use
[5:05:06] private lawsuits against
[5:05:08] competitors.
[5:05:09] So weaponizing it This is
[5:05:11] dangerous for small businesses,
[5:05:12] county operators and future
[5:05:14] social equity businesses that
[5:05:15] MAY not have the resources to
[5:05:17] fight expensive litigation.
[5:05:19] Even a threat of lawsuit can
[5:05:21] discourage competition and
[5:05:22] limit access.
[5:05:23] You can also look California
[5:05:25] Motor Transport Company where
[5:05:28] trucking Unlimited and I think
[5:05:29] that covers kind of that If
[5:05:31] the concern is tax compliance,
[5:05:33] create a simple registration
[5:05:34] and tax process.
[5:05:36] If concern is illegal operators
[5:05:37] focus enforcement on unlicensed
[5:05:39] activity but do not create a
[5:05:41] system that allows established
[5:05:42] businesses to weaponize
[5:05:43] enforcement against licensed
[5:05:46] competitors.
[5:05:46] I urge the Council to reject
[5:05:48] this proposal.
[5:05:49] >> Thank you.
[5:05:50] That does conclude your time.
[5:05:51] Anthony Ralphs Yes I had
[5:05:56] submitted want to speak in
[5:05:58] favor but after hearing
[5:05:59] the deliberation I think I'm
[5:06:00] going to change to speak in
[5:06:02] opposition.
[5:06:08] >> The reason why I am changing
[5:06:10] my position from going in favor
[5:06:12] to in opposition is because I
[5:06:14] do think that regulation has
[5:06:18] good intentions.
[5:06:18] I do want to see delivery
[5:06:20] drivers have the ability to
[5:06:22] have some type of guidelines by
[5:06:23] the city as to what they can do
[5:06:25] and what they can't do.
[5:06:26] However, I was really concerned
[5:06:27] about the amount of
[5:06:29] the penalties that would be
[5:06:30] imposed The $20,000 a day just
[5:06:33] like none of us are made out of
[5:06:34] gold and we all make mistakes
[5:06:35] and $20,000 to be out of
[5:06:39] compliance or to have made a
[5:06:42] mistake with the regulations
[5:06:43] just seems really excessive to
[5:06:47] me.
[5:06:48] And also I think that if there
[5:06:50] is a confliction a conflict
[5:06:53] between the socially equitable
[5:06:54] cannabis program and this one I
[5:06:56] think I would rather go with
[5:06:57] the socially equitable
[5:06:58] community program.
[5:06:58] Thank you.
[5:06:58] Thank you.
[5:07:03] Lori Saldana you actually cut
[5:07:05] off some of his time but let me
[5:07:06] just start out by saying what
[5:07:08] Terry Bell said.
[5:07:10] MR. Campos shame on you and
[5:07:12] your committee members.
[5:07:13] You were putting a loaded gun
[5:07:14] in the hands of people to go
[5:07:16] after folks who have been
[5:07:17] historically disadvantaged in
[5:07:19] this industry.
[5:07:19] When I served the legislature I
[5:07:21] wrote bills to do the exact
[5:07:23] opposite to try and prevent
[5:07:25] this kind of cherry picking and
[5:07:27] I'm going to stick around for a
[5:07:28] non agenda comment so I can
[5:07:30] speak a little bit more about
[5:07:31] what if other industries took
[5:07:32] this approach What if other
[5:07:35] indices were given a gun and
[5:07:36] said you can do private action
[5:07:37] and go after these opponents?
[5:07:40] Are these competitors It would
[5:07:42] be mayhem.
[5:07:43] Shame on you.
[5:07:45] Shame on you MR. Foster.
[5:07:46] You know how this community has
[5:07:48] been hurt so I just don't
[5:07:51] understand why you're picking
[5:07:51] winners and losers.
[5:07:52] I wait.
[5:07:53] I do.
[5:07:53] Who has money?
[5:07:54] Who gives money to
[5:07:55] the Democratic Party?
[5:07:56] Who gives money to the party
[5:07:58] and then passes it on to
[5:07:59] candidates?
[5:08:00] >> The people that you are
[5:08:02] favoring on this Shame on you.
[5:08:05] >> Thank you.
[5:08:06] That does conclude your time.
[5:08:08] That concludes in-person public
[5:08:10] comment.
[5:08:11] We have started the five minute
[5:08:13] timer and council chambers will
[5:08:15] now turn to the virtual queue
[5:08:17] in which there are ten
[5:08:20] participants requesting to
[5:08:21] speak.
[5:08:21] We'll begin with Terry and
[5:08:23] Skelly.
[5:08:24] Please begin.
[5:08:28] >> Good afternoon San Diego
[5:08:29] City Council Chair LaCava My
[5:08:31] name is Terrance Fili and I
[5:08:33] work with my planning group on
[5:08:35] good public health and safety
[5:08:36] policies and land use
[5:08:38] decisions.
[5:08:39] I support this policy.
[5:08:40] I appreciate the city's effort
[5:08:42] to know who is selling pot in
[5:08:43] our city and where the pot is
[5:08:46] coming from since it doesn't
[5:08:47] seem to have a physical
[5:08:48] location within the city, this
[5:08:50] is a very good thing We should
[5:08:52] be aware of actual actually
[5:08:54] being successful collecting
[5:08:56] cannabis business tax and
[5:08:58] perhaps also remember that
[5:09:00] the comment by a physician
[5:09:01] trained in emergency medicine
[5:09:03] pediatrics and family practice
[5:09:05] and I quote It's ridiculous to
[5:09:07] think that any city or county
[5:09:08] will make it will make excess
[5:09:11] funds in tax revenue from
[5:09:13] the selling of addictive
[5:09:14] products.
[5:09:15] The money being brought in does
[5:09:17] not cover the costs of
[5:09:18] addiction of addiction
[5:09:20] treatment let alone any any
[5:09:21] other harm psychosis, cannabis
[5:09:25] hyperemesis pediatric exposures
[5:09:27] and injuries while intoxicated.
[5:09:29] Thank you for hearing my
[5:09:31] concern.
[5:09:32] Thank you.
[5:09:33] Our next speakers and Albania's
[5:09:35] please begin.
[5:09:48] >> Andrew Ibanez I cannot
[5:09:54] unmute for you must press on
[5:09:54] Hear me?
[5:09:57] Yup Go ahead please.
[5:09:59] >> Thank you.
[5:09:59] Good evening.
[5:10:00] Presenter and council members.
[5:10:02] My name is Andrew Ibanez.
[5:10:03] I lived in District four for 39
[5:10:04] years and I'm a cannabis social
[5:10:06] equity applicant.
[5:10:07] I oppose the proposal.
[5:10:08] I support maintaining expanded
[5:10:10] access to cannabis delivery
[5:10:12] services in the city of San
[5:10:13] Diego.
[5:10:14] Cannabis delivery provides a
[5:10:16] safe, convenient and legal
[5:10:17] option for adults, seniors,
[5:10:18] people with disabilities,
[5:10:20] veterans and patients and
[5:10:22] residents who have difficulty
[5:10:23] traveling to a dispensary or a
[5:10:25] storefront.
[5:10:26] Delivery services allows
[5:10:28] consumers to receive product at
[5:10:29] home rather than driving to a
[5:10:31] retail location.
[5:10:33] Licensed delivery operators are
[5:10:34] regulated subject to testing
[5:10:36] and tracking requirements and
[5:10:37] contribute tax revenue to
[5:10:39] the city.
[5:10:39] Policy should encourage
[5:10:41] consumers to the to use
[5:10:42] the regulated market rather
[5:10:44] than care or create barriers
[5:10:46] that MAY unintentionally push
[5:10:47] customers toward unlicensed
[5:10:49] operators.
[5:10:50] As the city considers new
[5:10:51] regulations, I encourage you to
[5:10:53] support a framework that
[5:10:54] protects public safety while
[5:10:56] preserving reasonable access to
[5:10:58] legal cannabis delivery
[5:10:59] services.
[5:11:01] Regulation should be fair,
[5:11:01] practical and designed to
[5:11:02] promote compliance.
[5:11:03] Thank you.
[5:11:04] >> That does conclude your
[5:11:05] time.
[5:11:07] Madison please begin.
[5:11:13] Hi.
[5:11:14] Good evening.
[5:11:15] Thank you for the chance to
[5:11:15] speak.
[5:11:16] I support this ordinance
[5:11:18] because strong enforcement of
[5:11:20] cannabis regulations is
[5:11:21] essential to protecting young
[5:11:22] people in our city.
[5:11:24] We are not talking about
[5:11:25] delivery of ice cream here.
[5:11:27] When delivery of a drug like
[5:11:29] cannabis is allowed it means
[5:11:30] products are spreading
[5:11:31] throughout our community that
[5:11:33] contain extremely high levels
[5:11:34] of thc and have been linked to
[5:11:37] increased risks of psychosis
[5:11:38] cannabis use disorder, cyclic
[5:11:40] vomiting syndrome, impaired
[5:11:42] driving and other serious
[5:11:44] health concerns particularly
[5:11:45] for adolescents.
[5:11:47] That is why enforcement matters
[5:11:50] Creating a local permit
[5:11:51] requirement for cannabis
[5:11:52] delivery businesses gives
[5:11:54] the city a tool to identify
[5:11:56] operators, monitor compliance
[5:11:58] and take action When violation
[5:12:00] occurs.
[5:12:01] Strong penalties are also
[5:12:02] important because regulations
[5:12:04] without meaningful enforcement
[5:12:05] are simply suggestions.
[5:12:07] Every gap in enforcement
[5:12:09] creates opportunities for
[5:12:10] unlawful activity and increases
[5:12:13] the risk that harmful cannabis
[5:12:14] products will reach our youth.
[5:12:16] >> Thank you.
[5:12:17] Thank you.
[5:12:19] Next is Becky Wrap.
[5:12:20] Please begin.
[5:12:35] My name is back.
[5:12:40] You up and I'm very concerned.
[5:12:40] The city is considering
[5:12:41] expanding delivery regulations
[5:12:44] before providing or proving
[5:12:47] that existing regulations have
[5:12:49] been effectively enforced.
[5:12:50] For years residents have been
[5:12:52] requesting a comprehensive
[5:12:54] audit of San Diego's marijuana
[5:12:56] program including the number of
[5:12:57] businesses operating,
[5:12:58] the amount of tax revenue being
[5:12:59] collected and whether
[5:13:01] businesses are complying with
[5:13:02] local regulations.
[5:13:04] This report repeatedly
[5:13:05] references noncompliance but
[5:13:07] does not include important
[5:13:08] enforcement data to support
[5:13:10] the need that this new permit
[5:13:12] program is needed.
[5:13:13] How many violations have been
[5:13:15] identified?
[5:13:15] How much unpaid tax has been
[5:13:17] recovered?
[5:13:18] And the delivery operators have
[5:13:19] been investigating.
[5:13:21] A report doesn't tell us that
[5:13:23] before creating new permits and
[5:13:25] expanding the city's marijuana
[5:13:26] framework.
[5:13:28] The city should first provide a
[5:13:29] full accounting of the current
[5:13:31] system.
[5:13:32] If we don't know whether
[5:13:33] existing businesses are
[5:13:34] complying with the rules or
[5:13:35] paying the taxes they owe.
[5:13:37] >> How can we justify
[5:13:38] expanding?
[5:13:39] Thank you.
[5:13:40] That is include your time.
[5:13:41] >> Please note that the five
[5:13:46] minute timer has concluded with
[5:13:48] six speakers left in the queue.
[5:13:50] No other speakers will be taken
[5:13:54] Next up is Peggy Walker.
[5:13:56] Please begin.
[5:14:00] Oh, good evening, COUNCILMAN
[5:14:01] Campo.
[5:14:03] I represent parents and thank
[5:14:04] you and support this.
[5:14:06] Strict controls are needed
[5:14:07] because bad players on both
[5:14:09] the seller and consumer sides
[5:14:11] ignore illegal delivery
[5:14:13] requirements.
[5:14:14] Delivery services Too often
[5:14:16] cheat the city of taxes put
[5:14:18] youth in jeopardy of harmful
[5:14:20] underage use, fail to make I.D.
[5:14:22] Checks and deliver quantities
[5:14:24] not allowed by state
[5:14:25] regulations.
[5:14:26] A Bay Area delivery company was
[5:14:29] recently exposed for leaking
[5:14:31] their delivery databases
[5:14:33] containing customer names, home
[5:14:36] addresses, even medical data.
[5:14:39] Consumers should be made aware
[5:14:40] of these risks.
[5:14:42] An official list posted online
[5:14:44] of all future San Diego license
[5:14:46] delivery services would be
[5:14:48] helpful so that consumers can
[5:14:50] know that their deliveries are
[5:14:52] from permitted vendors.
[5:14:54] Thank you.
[5:14:58] >> Thank you.
[5:15:04] Next up is Peggy Walker.
[5:15:05] Please begin.
[5:15:09] >> Hi.
[5:15:10] That was me.
[5:15:10] I just spoke.
[5:15:11] Sorry.
[5:15:12] I apologize.
[5:15:16] Next up is Kathleen Leavitt.
[5:15:18] Please begin.
[5:15:22] >> Thank you.
[5:15:22] Thank you.
[5:15:23] To counsel Patrick Campo for
[5:15:25] his good intentions a proactive
[5:15:28] step that should be taken
[5:15:29] before proposing any additional
[5:15:32] programs like this would be to
[5:15:34] do an analysis of
[5:15:36] the businesses already
[5:15:36] permitted.
[5:15:37] Are they compliant?
[5:15:39] Are they paying their taxes?
[5:15:41] Many businesses already see
[5:15:43] city codes and suggestions
[5:15:44] rather than requirements.
[5:15:47] They do not see meaningful
[5:15:48] consequences to businesses
[5:15:50] found to be out of compliance.
[5:15:52] It is no surprise many
[5:15:54] marijuana businesses have gone
[5:15:56] out of business because
[5:15:57] unpermitted marijuana
[5:15:58] businesses always have and
[5:16:01] always will take business from
[5:16:03] permitted business.
[5:16:04] This permanent undermines
[5:16:06] the city's regulatory framework
[5:16:08] and disadvantages compliant
[5:16:10] businesses.
[5:16:12] That being said, there is
[5:16:13] nothing good about compliant or
[5:16:16] permitted businesses any more
[5:16:17] than unpermitted businesses.
[5:16:19] The rent seeking revenues over
[5:16:22] public safety is never going to
[5:16:24] end well for the city.
[5:16:26] >> That does conclude your
[5:16:27] time.
[5:16:27] Thank you.
[5:16:28] Next up J.D. String Please
[5:16:30] begin.
[5:16:30] >> Good afternoon, San Diego
[5:16:34] City Council.
[5:16:36] Thank you to City Council
[5:16:39] person Carpio for considering
[5:16:39] this at his NOVEMBER adr
[5:16:43] meeting.
[5:16:44] I'm sorry Some of us maybe who
[5:16:46] spoke didn't have an
[5:16:47] opportunity to hear
[5:16:48] the discussion then I think we
[5:16:50] would have a better
[5:16:51] understanding of what the goal
[5:16:52] was behind this policy.
[5:16:57] Some intent to level
[5:16:58] the playing field for those who
[5:17:01] actually have permits in
[5:17:02] the city of San Diego to
[5:17:03] deliver and those who do not
[5:17:05] and are coming in and we don't
[5:17:06] know who they are, where
[5:17:08] they're from, what
[5:17:09] the condition of the products
[5:17:10] are And it looks like and
[5:17:12] the example on the PowerPoint,
[5:17:14] the one given it's not even
[5:17:15] registered by the city, by
[5:17:17] the state, by dcc.
[5:17:20] So we need to really understand
[5:17:22] who it is just driving around
[5:17:24] our neighborhoods, dropping off
[5:17:25] pot.
[5:17:26] I must say, however, in doing a
[5:17:28] search I found the city of
[5:17:30] Oceanside tried to do the same
[5:17:31] thing and get a registry of
[5:17:34] deliveries and then when signed
[5:17:35] out.
[5:17:37] >> Thank you.
[5:17:37] That does conclude your time.
[5:17:39] Next is Cannabis Education
[5:17:41] Project.
[5:17:42] Please begin Cannabis Education
[5:17:57] Project.
[5:17:58] Please begin.
[5:17:58] I see you're unmuted.
[5:18:00] One more time Cannabis
[5:18:12] Education Project.
[5:18:17] Okay, we'll have to move on.
[5:18:22] Next up Shelby Huffaker.
[5:18:24] Please begin that evening.
[5:18:29] My name is Shelby and I'm a
[5:18:30] board member of the San Diego
[5:18:31] chapter of Americans for Safe
[5:18:33] Access, a national nonprofit
[5:18:35] advancing Safe Access to
[5:18:36] cannabis for therapeutic use
[5:18:38] and research.
[5:18:39] I urge you to reject this
[5:18:40] proposed cannabis delivery
[5:18:41] permit and enforcement
[5:18:43] enforcement ordinance.
[5:18:44] It is redundant with state law
[5:18:46] and appearance designed to let
[5:18:47] San Diego's existing cannabis
[5:18:48] monopoly block competition from
[5:18:51] the county social equity
[5:18:52] program which is just weeks
[5:18:53] away from an anticipated vote
[5:18:55] on the code's needed to
[5:18:56] implement it.
[5:18:57] If you move forward please make
[5:18:59] two changes.
[5:19:01] First, eliminate the private
[5:19:02] right of action which would let
[5:19:03] anyone including monopoly
[5:19:05] members and opponent opponents
[5:19:06] of cannabis legalization sue
[5:19:09] compliant operators and clog
[5:19:11] our courts.
[5:19:12] Second, please exempt operators
[5:19:13] already licensed by the county
[5:19:15] from this duplicative permitted
[5:19:16] system.
[5:19:18] Please reject this ordinance or
[5:19:19] adopt these fixes.
[5:19:20] >> Thank you.
[5:19:21] Thank you.
[5:19:23] >> Kelly Hayes.
[5:19:24] Please begin.
[5:19:24] >> Hi.
[5:19:28] Good evening, Council members.
[5:19:30] My name is Kelly Hayes.
[5:19:31] i'm a resident of District two
[5:19:33] and an attorney who specializes
[5:19:35] in working with the cannabis
[5:19:36] businesses.
[5:19:37] I've been working with this
[5:19:39] industry since 2014.
[5:19:40] And I've seen a lot of issues
[5:19:43] with this ordinance and I
[5:19:45] strongly oppose it.
[5:19:46] First requiring delivery
[5:19:48] businesses to obtain a separate
[5:19:50] San Diego permit is unworkable
[5:19:53] in the city.
[5:19:54] The city is going to have no
[5:19:55] way to police and enforce this
[5:19:57] requirement.
[5:19:58] State regulations require
[5:19:59] delivery vehicles to be in
[5:20:01] unmarked and indistinguishable
[5:20:03] from any other type of vehicle
[5:20:06] The effect that this is going
[5:20:07] to have on staff is going to be
[5:20:09] burdensome and it's going to
[5:20:10] accomplish absolutely nothing
[5:20:11] nothing that you're trying to
[5:20:13] achieve.
[5:20:14] Additionally, the private right
[5:20:15] to action is duplicative.
[5:20:17] There's already state law that
[5:20:18] allows for this type of private
[5:20:21] action And what you're
[5:20:23] proposing is going to create
[5:20:25] meritless cases and clog our
[5:20:28] court system.
[5:20:29] >> So I strongly ask you to
[5:20:31] oppose this.
[5:20:32] Thank you.
[5:20:32] That does conclude your time.
[5:20:34] And that concludes the public
[5:20:36] testimony on item 2o2.
[5:20:38] All right.
[5:20:39] Thank you, Deputy Clerk.
[5:20:40] Thank you.
[5:20:41] Everybody that spoke or called
[5:20:42] in will now turn it over to
[5:20:44] council members for questions,
[5:20:46] comments and entertain a motion
[5:20:47] and we'll start with
[5:20:48] the proponent.
[5:20:49] Council Member Campo Thank you
[5:20:51] Council PRESIDENT And thank you
[5:20:52] to my staff for the good work
[5:20:53] on this.
[5:20:53] Thank you to all the members of
[5:20:54] the public for their
[5:20:55] participation today.
[5:20:56] I want to specifically thank
[5:20:57] the cw workers who came to
[5:20:59] speak directly.
[5:21:00] Members of the Public Labor
[5:21:01] Council and members of sounds
[5:21:04] like almost every district for
[5:21:06] explaining why today's action
[5:21:07] is so important.
[5:21:08] It's abundantly clear that
[5:21:10] illicit cannabis delivery is a
[5:21:12] problem in the city.
[5:21:13] It's a problem that we haven't
[5:21:15] had a solution to address
[5:21:17] because it's difficult to
[5:21:18] address.
[5:21:19] It's layered with state and
[5:21:21] local laws and enforcement
[5:21:23] Actions span from the state to
[5:21:24] city attorneys, local law
[5:21:26] enforcement, the city
[5:21:28] administrators and city
[5:21:28] administrators involved.
[5:21:30] Land use enforcement in some
[5:21:31] cases.
[5:21:32] So from a regulatory
[5:21:33] perspective it is very
[5:21:34] difficult to get this right.
[5:21:36] But we're here.
[5:21:39] The city regulates cannabis
[5:21:40] delivery from businesses inside
[5:21:41] city limits.
[5:21:42] And if they don't follow
[5:21:43] the rules, they don't get to
[5:21:44] operate in the city.
[5:21:46] They have a physical building
[5:21:47] and a permit to operate it.
[5:21:49] But what about the businesses
[5:21:50] that come in, drive in, deliver
[5:21:53] legally by state or local laws
[5:21:55] and then leave?
[5:21:56] To test if this is actually
[5:21:58] happening you could right now
[5:21:59] order cannabis to be delivered
[5:22:01] to city hall particularly out
[5:22:04] of city company is advertising
[5:22:07] on Weed Maps an online platform
[5:22:09] for marketing cannabis products
[5:22:10] and has their location listed
[5:22:12] as the Gaslamp District right
[5:22:15] here in downtown Shouldn't
[5:22:17] surprise anybody.
[5:22:19] We don't have any licensed
[5:22:20] cannabis outlets in
[5:22:21] the Gaslamp.
[5:22:23] This business is listed on
[5:22:24] the state's Department of
[5:22:25] Cannabis Control website as a
[5:22:27] state licensed delivery
[5:22:28] business but their licensed
[5:22:30] operations is in Kern County.
[5:22:34] That means in order to abide by
[5:22:35] state law they would have to
[5:22:36] wait until an order is made
[5:22:38] before they dispatch to deliver
[5:22:40] with a driver that delivery
[5:22:42] driver has to be a direct
[5:22:44] employee of that company.
[5:22:46] They have to provide specific
[5:22:47] details on every receipt with
[5:22:49] information about that company
[5:22:51] and they have to pay all
[5:22:52] applicable taxes.
[5:22:54] And they're definitely not
[5:22:55] allowed to deliver to
[5:22:56] government property.
[5:22:57] You can place an order and have
[5:22:59] a delivery within two hours
[5:23:00] from this company.
[5:23:01] No local taxes are applied on
[5:23:03] their receipt.
[5:23:05] No state license number is
[5:23:06] listed on that receipt.
[5:23:08] That means that someone is
[5:23:10] either driving very fast from
[5:23:11] Kern County, the nearest city
[5:23:13] of which is 191 miles away or
[5:23:16] they're storing cannabis
[5:23:17] products illegally within our
[5:23:19] city limits and that business
[5:23:21] is clearly not abiding by
[5:23:22] worker and consumer safety
[5:23:24] protections.
[5:23:24] So I understand we have a
[5:23:26] current process for cannabis
[5:23:27] delivery services entering city
[5:23:29] limits.
[5:23:30] They are required to register
[5:23:31] for a business tax certificate
[5:23:32] and pay applicable taxes but
[5:23:34] they're not required to provide
[5:23:35] any proof of their state
[5:23:36] license.
[5:23:36] So if we know that a business
[5:23:38] is violating their state
[5:23:39] license requirements, we can't
[5:23:41] really do anything about it
[5:23:42] yet.
[5:23:43] And in this scenario let's say
[5:23:45] we suspect that a facility is
[5:23:46] within city limits is being
[5:23:47] used to store cannabis products
[5:23:49] for delivery.
[5:23:50] It's not allowed under current
[5:23:51] code.
[5:23:52] We can provide notice and send
[5:23:53] in code enforcement cpd to
[5:23:55] investigate.
[5:23:55] Apply penalties If they have
[5:23:57] information on that business we
[5:23:58] could file a complaint with
[5:24:00] Department of Cannabis Control
[5:24:01] to apply penalties or revoke a
[5:24:03] permit if the business has one.
[5:24:05] But we know that revoking a
[5:24:06] permit or having an expired
[5:24:07] permit does not stop that
[5:24:09] business entity from continuing
[5:24:10] to advertise and deliver
[5:24:11] cannabis in the city of San
[5:24:13] Diego.
[5:24:14] So it's safe to say our current
[5:24:15] resources are at capacity at
[5:24:17] addressing this kind of illegal
[5:24:18] commercial activity.
[5:24:20] And when we've exhausted our
[5:24:21] administrative options,
[5:24:22] the city attorney's office can
[5:24:23] still file a civil action in
[5:24:24] court against the business.
[5:24:26] But it would be a matter of
[5:24:27] prioritizing this this issue
[5:24:29] over others because our staff
[5:24:31] capacity is limited.
[5:24:33] And from what I've heard from
[5:24:34] the workers and businesses and
[5:24:35] members of the public is that
[5:24:36] this activity goes on and on
[5:24:38] and on.
[5:24:39] >> While the government
[5:24:41] agencies tasked with regulation
[5:24:42] they're unable to enforce
[5:24:43] the law.
[5:24:44] My experience as a litigator
[5:24:46] and prosecutor the private
[5:24:47] right of action is a very
[5:24:48] commonly used enforcement
[5:24:49] mechanism.
[5:24:50] It's primarily used in other
[5:24:52] areas of law labor law for
[5:24:53] example.
[5:24:54] But the concept is very simple.
[5:24:56] When a party is harmed by
[5:24:58] the violation of a law they can
[5:25:00] ask the court to enforce it.
[5:25:01] This is not a unique remedy.
[5:25:03] It's not a unique tool.
[5:25:05] It's not just any member of
[5:25:07] the public, by the way, a party
[5:25:09] that's harmed by the violation
[5:25:10] and in this case a legal
[5:25:11] business.
[5:25:12] Unions representing those
[5:25:13] workers and those businesses
[5:25:14] right here in San Diego.
[5:25:16] So a court can evaluate that
[5:25:18] evidence, determine penalties
[5:25:20] if they determine the law was
[5:25:22] not followed.
[5:25:24] So what does this accomplish
[5:25:24] and what does success look like
[5:25:26] if we implement this?
[5:25:27] First we incentivize legal
[5:25:29] commercial activity by raising
[5:25:31] the cost of noncompliance.
[5:25:34] Registering for a business
[5:25:36] permit means filling out a form
[5:25:38] or you run The risk of high
[5:25:42] penalties is not a high bar
[5:25:43] that we are setting here
[5:25:45] penalties that can actually
[5:25:46] outweigh the financial benefit
[5:25:47] to skip On hiring employees and
[5:25:49] obtaining and renewing required
[5:25:50] permits.
[5:25:51] That's what we're looking at.
[5:25:52] With this we intend to be clear
[5:25:54] that any cannabis business
[5:25:55] operating within our
[5:25:56] jurisdiction must make
[5:25:58] themselves known.
[5:26:00] They must follow the laws.
[5:26:02] As I pointed out earlier, a
[5:26:04] receipt from a cannabis company
[5:26:05] and current registered in Kern
[5:26:07] County and delivering in
[5:26:08] Gaslamp advertising Gaslamp as
[5:26:09] violating multiple laws.
[5:26:12] And if the business continues
[5:26:13] to ignore local and state laws
[5:26:15] they can then be held
[5:26:16] accountable.
[5:26:17] But I think we ought not reward
[5:26:21] multimillion dollar companies
[5:26:22] that decide it's more
[5:26:23] profitable to ignore the law
[5:26:25] which means ignoring worker
[5:26:26] protections.
[5:26:28] I think we should protect
[5:26:29] workers.
[5:26:32] These companies are ignoring
[5:26:33] community protections where
[5:26:34] around where cannabis can be
[5:26:35] sold.
[5:26:36] I think we should maintain
[5:26:37] the system that we've put up in
[5:26:39] San Diego that allow outside
[5:26:40] entities to bring it down.
[5:26:45] >> The public who voted to
[5:26:46] allow commercial cannabis under
[5:26:47] the expectation that tax
[5:26:49] revenue would return back to
[5:26:50] them.
[5:26:51] That's what they wanted.
[5:26:53] Right now it's not working.
[5:26:55] So this proposal helps us
[5:26:56] collect that as well.
[5:26:59] So with that I understand that
[5:27:01] to make this mechanism
[5:27:01] successful we also need to
[5:27:03] properly implement a permit or
[5:27:06] a business registration
[5:27:07] whichever way you want to
[5:27:08] describe it.
[5:27:09] We need to bring a fee study in
[5:27:11] order to determine the cost
[5:27:13] recoverable amount for
[5:27:14] administering the permit.
[5:27:16] And if we're asking businesses
[5:27:17] to submit a copy of their state
[5:27:18] license or business certificate
[5:27:20] and information on their owners
[5:27:21] employees I would imagine that
[5:27:23] would align with the amount for
[5:27:24] the business tax certificate
[5:27:25] which is around $34 right now
[5:27:27] for small businesses or $125
[5:27:29] for larger businesses.
[5:27:31] I see Good is here from
[5:27:32] the mayor's office.
[5:27:34] I need the mayor's commitment
[5:27:37] via you that we will that you
[5:27:37] will work to bring back bring
[5:27:41] forward the appropriate fee
[5:27:42] study to determine the exact
[5:27:43] amount of what this business
[5:27:45] permit will cost.
[5:27:46] Yes, Councilmember, thank you
[5:27:47] for that.
[5:27:48] You do have our commitment to
[5:27:49] bring that forward post second
[5:27:51] reading at this House is today.
[5:27:53] City Treasurer's office will
[5:27:54] initiate the process to conduct
[5:27:56] the fee study and then bring
[5:27:57] that forward for council
[5:27:58] consideration later this fall.
[5:27:59] >> Okay, very good.
[5:28:01] Also with along those same
[5:28:03] lines working with staff to
[5:28:05] ensure that neighboring
[5:28:06] jurisdictions and
[5:28:07] the Department of Cannabis
[5:28:08] Control are properly notified
[5:28:09] of those changes to our
[5:28:11] cannabis regulations and
[5:28:12] understand how to register
[5:28:13] through the mechanism that will
[5:28:15] be created by our departments.
[5:28:17] Yes and I think that be an all
[5:28:18] hands effort for parties that
[5:28:19] touch this including dsd, cpd,
[5:28:21] our government affairs team.
[5:28:22] So you have our full support
[5:28:23] there as well.
[5:28:24] Okay.
[5:28:25] With that council PRESIDENT,
[5:28:26] I'm happy to move approval of
[5:28:28] staff's recommendation on this.
[5:28:29] Thank you.
[5:28:29] All right.
[5:28:30] So we have a motion by Council
[5:28:31] member Campo to move the staff
[5:28:32] recommendation and we'll go
[5:28:33] next to council member Von
[5:28:34] Wolpert.
[5:28:34] >> Thank you.
[5:28:36] And thank you very much to
[5:28:38] staff for bringing this forward
[5:28:39] today and thank you for
[5:28:40] the hard work you've done it
[5:28:42] and thank you to the public for
[5:28:43] commenting and thank you to our
[5:28:43] hard working folks that you
[5:28:44] have.
[5:28:47] C.W. Who have negotiated some
[5:28:49] of the very first labor
[5:28:50] contracts in the cannabis
[5:28:51] industry.
[5:28:52] I mean things like a paid day
[5:28:54] off to go to the doctor and
[5:28:57] fair wages And if you're
[5:28:58] injured at the job that your
[5:29:00] employer actually has to pay
[5:29:03] worker's comp these are
[5:29:03] the things that these workers
[5:29:04] are asking for.
[5:29:05] And I think that that should be
[5:29:06] the bare minimum And it really
[5:29:09] is very hard for cannabis
[5:29:11] businesses who are lawfully
[5:29:13] operating including the new
[5:29:14] cannabis businesses who will be
[5:29:16] permitted under the county's
[5:29:18] equity program.
[5:29:19] You too can be undercut by
[5:29:21] the folks who operate down
[5:29:22] the gas gaslamp from Kern
[5:29:23] County by folks operating
[5:29:25] outside of our state.
[5:29:27] Even once you're licensed by
[5:29:29] the cannabis equity program in
[5:29:30] the county you too can use this
[5:29:32] law If you locate in San Diego
[5:29:34] and with the private right of
[5:29:35] action it grants attorney's
[5:29:38] fees and costs to
[5:29:40] the prevailing party So you
[5:29:41] don't need to hire an attorney.
[5:29:43] You can get one to do it On
[5:29:44] contingency.
[5:29:45] It will be available to any
[5:29:46] licensed business provider here
[5:29:48] and you all can take on these
[5:29:49] guys here or girls whoever who
[5:29:52] are clearly coming from outside
[5:29:53] the city and the county to come
[5:29:55] undercut our local businesses.
[5:29:58] That said, anyone who delivers
[5:30:01] a product for sale in the city
[5:30:03] of San Diego needs to be paying
[5:30:04] sales tax and in this case
[5:30:07] cannabis tax in the city.
[5:30:08] You know we have folks who
[5:30:10] deliver for Amazon or Target or
[5:30:12] Walmart And if the point of
[5:30:13] sale is here in the city of San
[5:30:14] Diego, they have to pay their
[5:30:15] taxes here even if their
[5:30:17] business is located outside of
[5:30:18] it.
[5:30:18] This is a basic tax revenue
[5:30:21] requirement.
[5:30:21] It's a licensure requirement
[5:30:23] and we require all businesses
[5:30:24] to do this.
[5:30:25] So I will second the motion.
[5:30:27] >> Thank you.
[5:30:27] All right.
[5:30:28] Thank you.
[5:30:29] Council member Von Wilpert.
[5:30:30] So we have a motion by
[5:30:31] Councilmember Campos, second by
[5:30:34] Council member Von Wolpert to
[5:30:35] move the staff recommendation
[5:30:36] and we'll go next to Council
[5:30:39] member Foster and thank you
[5:30:40] Council PRESIDENT And I guess I
[5:30:48] just need to reiterate and just
[5:30:52] state for the record that I
[5:30:57] think the discourse that you
[5:30:59] are hearing stems from one
[5:31:03] problem and that is we move
[5:31:06] forward with cannabis without
[5:31:09] being inclusive on its onset
[5:31:11] And I think that was the worst
[5:31:14] thing that we could have done.
[5:31:16] I appreciate the $20 million in
[5:31:19] revenue or roughly thereof that
[5:31:21] we have been receiving.
[5:31:23] I appreciate the good jobs as
[5:31:28] our partners have been working
[5:31:30] to make sure that we have good
[5:31:34] employee benefits and and
[5:31:37] workers rights But we did a
[5:31:40] disservice.
[5:31:41] We excluded a community that
[5:31:46] has and still to this day is
[5:31:56] continuing to have challenges
[5:31:57] as we look at um how folks can
[5:32:08] have what we call a life in
[5:32:10] this United States of America
[5:32:13] and this is something that we
[5:32:17] have to stop.
[5:32:19] It sounds like just from
[5:32:22] the line of I guess from my
[5:32:24] colleague MR. Campo
[5:32:27] Councilmember Campo that there
[5:32:28] is work that needs to come back
[5:32:29] as we talk about establishing
[5:32:31] permit fees.
[5:32:33] It sounds like it should not
[5:32:35] exceed $125.
[5:32:37] Is that what I'm understand on
[5:32:40] the onset of this conversation?
[5:32:41] That's correct.
[5:32:44] Okay.
[5:32:45] Um and I guess if you can help
[5:32:49] me to understand what does this
[5:32:52] mean as I hear the public
[5:32:54] comment, what does this mean
[5:32:55] for folks that are part of this
[5:32:59] county's program?
[5:33:01] Is this excluding those
[5:33:03] individuals from being able to
[5:33:06] participate in the cannabis
[5:33:08] industry that would like to do
[5:33:10] delivery?
[5:33:12] Yeah.
[5:33:13] Thank you for the question.
[5:33:15] Um, as the ordinance is written
[5:33:16] now the county social equity
[5:33:18] operators or any operator
[5:33:21] that's delivering from outside
[5:33:22] the city would be required to
[5:33:24] fill out the permit form which
[5:33:26] would be an online
[5:33:27] registration.
[5:33:28] And I think the thing that
[5:33:29] we're hearing and discussion is
[5:33:31] the fee amount and does that
[5:33:33] fee represent a barrier?
[5:33:34] And so like you said,
[5:33:36] the second part of this is to
[5:33:38] bring that fee study forward
[5:33:39] and to determine the cost of
[5:33:42] service and also explore
[5:33:44] options for whether that be
[5:33:48] waivers, discounted rates and
[5:33:53] explore the possibilities
[5:33:54] there.
[5:33:55] But we can't determine that
[5:33:58] feasibility without
[5:33:59] understanding the cost to begin
[5:34:01] with.
[5:34:01] So we benchmark it against
[5:34:03] the current business tax
[5:34:06] certificate because it's a
[5:34:07] similar mechanism of
[5:34:08] registering providing
[5:34:09] the information online.
[5:34:11] It's not a land use permit
[5:34:12] where it's going to be
[5:34:13] intensive.
[5:34:14] So we're thinking ballpark
[5:34:16] can't be more than 50 to $100
[5:34:18] but we have to be sure before
[5:34:19] we present that information to
[5:34:21] any other jurisdiction And also
[5:34:23] to that we have met with
[5:34:26] the county of San Diego over
[5:34:28] this question and concern which
[5:34:30] is how will the county social
[5:34:33] equity businesses understand
[5:34:35] the requirements when they're
[5:34:37] navigating all of these hoops
[5:34:39] through the county's program?
[5:34:41] And we received their
[5:34:43] commitment that they have a
[5:34:44] list of the delivery operators
[5:34:46] those Type nine licenses or
[5:34:48] microbusinesses that will be
[5:34:49] entering into the city and they
[5:34:51] have a staff person ready to
[5:34:52] assist filling out that form.
[5:34:54] They're waiting on us to get
[5:34:55] that information to them So we
[5:34:58] will work extensively to make
[5:35:00] sure that this ordinance
[5:35:02] targets who is intended and is
[5:35:05] not hurt, who it's not intended
[5:35:06] to hurt.
[5:35:10] Okay.
[5:35:10] I appreciate that clarification
[5:35:14] I mean I guess I will turn to
[5:35:18] the city attorney as I am as my
[5:35:22] office is working on a cannabis
[5:35:25] equity policy as we speak.
[5:35:30] And I will say that we have had
[5:35:32] conversations with other
[5:35:34] agencies and in one being Long
[5:35:38] Beach on that we've had some
[5:35:39] extensive conversations with as
[5:35:41] we talk about the cannabis
[5:35:43] industry and impacted folks and
[5:35:45] barriers.
[5:35:46] And one thing that did come
[5:35:50] about that conversation as we
[5:35:52] talk about cannabis equity is
[5:35:54] the importance of delivery and
[5:35:59] delivery services.
[5:36:01] Um it is a lot different than
[5:36:04] trying to enter the market just
[5:36:08] establishing a brick and mortar
[5:36:11] type process.
[5:36:13] Um just evening I'm going to
[5:36:15] take out what the cost of of of
[5:36:18] building a building or some of
[5:36:22] that but just the cost of what
[5:36:24] we go through from a
[5:36:26] development services position
[5:36:28] and that added cost and time
[5:36:31] frame and what it does to
[5:36:33] someone that's trying to move
[5:36:35] forward in this industry it is
[5:36:37] daunting and it is a a
[5:36:44] financial burden um the way
[5:36:45] this process is moving right
[5:36:48] now.
[5:36:49] And so with that MADAM City
[5:36:51] Attorney I will say um that um
[5:36:57] I will my office will be
[5:36:59] contacting you as I think as we
[5:37:01] continue to move forward with
[5:37:02] the cannabis equity policy that
[5:37:05] we will have to potentially at
[5:37:08] some point um relook at this
[5:37:11] policy that we are discussing
[5:37:12] today and to make some
[5:37:14] provisions based on what we are
[5:37:16] going to be bringing forward
[5:37:18] because I cannot bring in a
[5:37:22] cannabis equity policy without
[5:37:24] a delivery provision and that
[5:37:28] was directly a result of my
[5:37:30] conversations with Long Beach
[5:37:32] and what was brought to my
[5:37:34] attention.
[5:37:34] So it is a very, very important
[5:37:37] and critical component of a of
[5:37:39] an equity program.
[5:37:40] So thank you Council member
[5:37:45] We'll be happy to discuss those
[5:37:46] issues with Office.
[5:37:47] All right.
[5:37:48] Thank you With that One last
[5:37:50] question and just going to
[5:37:52] the eBay's comments on that
[5:37:56] they provided it seems like
[5:37:58] there are as we as the main
[5:38:00] purpose that we are doing this
[5:38:02] is trying to get our arms
[5:38:04] around the illicit market and
[5:38:07] especially and I'm just going
[5:38:08] to say out of town folks, right
[5:38:10] I'm going to isolate those mean
[5:38:12] those bad actors.
[5:38:13] But clearly it looks like
[5:38:14] there's concerns on just what
[5:38:17] that enforcement entails, what
[5:38:21] it looks like.
[5:38:21] Can you fill us in on just what
[5:38:25] those at least immediate
[5:38:28] challenges have been or what is
[5:38:31] police referring to?
[5:38:33] As you know, we can pass a
[5:38:35] policy but if we can't go out
[5:38:36] and enforce then what are we
[5:38:41] accomplishing?
[5:38:41] Definitely I'll I'll start and
[5:38:43] then I can pass it over to
[5:38:45] the departments to get their
[5:38:46] response.
[5:38:47] But the concerns that were
[5:38:49] mentioned on how to enforce
[5:38:53] delivery is essentially
[5:38:55] the reason why we're proposing
[5:38:56] this with the private right of
[5:38:58] action.
[5:38:58] Our current enforcement
[5:39:00] capacity is exhausted.
[5:39:03] The fda has the authority to
[5:39:04] issue notices and I'll let them
[5:39:06] finish on their department of
[5:39:08] their expertise.
[5:39:09] But their staff is limited.
[5:39:12] The information that they have
[5:39:13] is limited So as is they're
[5:39:16] unable to enforce against known
[5:39:20] delivery services especially
[5:39:21] because they don't have a
[5:39:23] physical place in San Diego.
[5:39:25] So how can dsd enforce
[5:39:27] something that's not within
[5:39:28] their limits?
[5:39:29] And so that's where the city
[5:39:31] treasurer's office comes in and
[5:39:32] they're responsible for
[5:39:35] administering the business tax
[5:39:36] certificate and they would be
[5:39:38] the entity that's responsible
[5:39:39] for enforcing this so to speak
[5:39:41] from an administrative
[5:39:42] perspective they would be
[5:39:43] administering the permit.
[5:39:45] But the question then becomes
[5:39:46] what happens if a business
[5:39:48] decides not to register?
[5:39:49] They only have five registrants
[5:39:51] so far and like you heard in
[5:39:54] comment Oceanside set up a
[5:39:54] registry No one registered
[5:39:56] because they don't have an
[5:39:57] incentive to and so that's
[5:40:01] where the private right of
[5:40:02] action comes into play where
[5:40:05] the current enforcement
[5:40:07] mechanisms aren't working.
[5:40:08] So there wouldn't be
[5:40:10] necessarily additional
[5:40:11] enforcement capacity to address
[5:40:13] that even though it repeat some
[5:40:16] of the available improvement
[5:40:19] mechanisms.
[5:40:19] I would say So with that I can
[5:40:23] turn it over to coda if you
[5:40:24] have anything else to add.
[5:40:24] >> Yeah.
[5:40:25] Thanks so much.
[5:40:26] I think that captures it pretty
[5:40:28] accurately.
[5:40:28] It's really to supplement and
[5:40:30] support the current enforcement
[5:40:33] landscape they're adding in
[5:40:35] the Treasurer piece of it and
[5:40:36] having essentially a checkpoint
[5:40:37] for what we know is out there
[5:40:40] not out there That's helpful to
[5:40:41] support these efforts
[5:40:43] separately from that.
[5:40:44] But really the private right of
[5:40:46] action is is that in the big
[5:40:47] shiny thing through this new
[5:40:49] proposed policy But staff is
[5:40:51] ready to enforce this to
[5:40:53] implement this I do have at
[5:40:57] least open to as well as
[5:40:57] Ricardo Ramos from city
[5:41:00] treasurer all mine if have
[5:41:00] really any specific questions
[5:41:01] there But we are all on
[5:41:03] the same page and ready to
[5:41:04] enforce.
[5:41:04] Okay.
[5:41:07] Is there any I guess anything
[5:41:09] covered in the current statutes
[5:41:11] in regards to reporting or how
[5:41:13] are we going to monitor Is
[5:41:15] there any monitoring associated
[5:41:16] with this?
[5:41:16] How are we going to determine
[5:41:18] how this is progressing?
[5:41:20] There's no monitoring
[5:41:22] requirements that are explicit
[5:41:23] in the ordinance but because of
[5:41:26] that it's flexible to determine
[5:41:28] that administratively our goal
[5:41:30] would be to have something like
[5:41:32] the Department of Cannabis
[5:41:33] Control They have a registry
[5:41:37] that's available for public
[5:41:38] viewing so you're not
[5:41:39] contacting that staff person
[5:41:41] and asking for that
[5:41:42] information.
[5:41:42] It's a readily available list
[5:41:45] and active registry.
[5:41:46] So in terms of records
[5:41:48] maintenance and managing of
[5:41:50] that we would envision an
[5:41:53] annual updated process.
[5:41:54] But again it's up to
[5:41:55] the administration and
[5:41:57] department to determine what
[5:41:58] makes the most sense and what
[5:42:00] would be feasible on their end.
[5:42:03] Okay.
[5:42:05] All right.
[5:42:06] Thank you for that.
[5:42:07] I guess I will fall back coda
[5:42:10] and have some additional
[5:42:12] conversation so I can make sure
[5:42:13] I just understand just from a
[5:42:15] practical perspective what this
[5:42:17] enforcement process looks like.
[5:42:19] It sounds like we are going to
[5:42:21] leave it in the hands of
[5:42:22] the public to come in and try
[5:42:24] and do some things which is a
[5:42:30] little concerning based on how
[5:42:33] the commentary and the feedback
[5:42:35] you get within the industry as
[5:42:38] competitive as it is and
[5:42:40] the issues that that everyone's
[5:42:42] encountering I will support
[5:42:47] this today as we continue to
[5:42:50] move forward.
[5:42:51] But again and that's what
[5:42:55] the understanding the intent
[5:42:55] that I will be bringing forward
[5:42:57] the cannabis equity program
[5:42:58] I'll be it will have a delivery
[5:43:01] component to it And so we'll be
[5:43:04] looking to make sure that any
[5:43:06] necessary provisions to make
[5:43:07] sure we are as inclusive as we
[5:43:09] can be as we continue to move
[5:43:11] forward and further progress
[5:43:14] with the cannabis or cannabis
[5:43:18] program.
[5:43:20] And again I'm just going to
[5:43:21] close with I am still very
[5:43:24] disappointed that we move
[5:43:26] forward without the cannabis
[5:43:27] equity program.
[5:43:28] I hate that we gave almost $1
[5:43:31] million back which I think was
[5:43:32] a horrible decision and really
[5:43:35] an injustice to those folks who
[5:43:37] have been impacted.
[5:43:38] And just to turn this over to
[5:43:42] what I guess I would call
[5:43:43] corporate type folks to take
[5:43:47] over this industry I think was
[5:43:48] just a horrific and horrible
[5:43:51] move by the by the city
[5:43:52] council.
[5:43:53] And so I'll conclude there.
[5:43:56] Council PRESIDENT And me for
[5:44:02] your comments.
[5:44:02] All right.
[5:44:03] Thank you Council my boss for
[5:44:04] not seeing anybody Council
[5:44:06] member Yellow River Thank you
[5:44:09] Council PRESIDENT Thank you so
[5:44:11] much for the presentation and
[5:44:12] for your help Customer come to
[5:44:14] you for bringing us forward
[5:44:15] kind of at a high level you
[5:44:22] know groups and businesses that
[5:44:25] are taking advantage of San
[5:44:28] Diego that are operating here
[5:44:31] benefiting from the city but
[5:44:33] not paying their fair share.
[5:44:35] I always have a problem with
[5:44:36] that And so I appreciate
[5:44:39] the part of this that that aims
[5:44:41] to address that.
[5:44:42] I'm certainly sympathetic to
[5:44:44] the concerns that the high
[5:44:49] standard that you C.W., has
[5:44:53] helped establish for what work
[5:44:55] place conditions and wages look
[5:44:57] like for those folks who work
[5:44:59] in the industry that operate
[5:45:02] outside the city.
[5:45:04] There's operators who work or
[5:45:06] not not only not meeting that
[5:45:07] standard that employers
[5:45:09] generally and we certainly do
[5:45:11] want to reward that All of
[5:45:13] those concerns I am very
[5:45:15] sympathetic to I appreciate
[5:45:17] the questions and comments from
[5:45:17] Councilmember Foster.
[5:45:22] I could I'm not sure I fully
[5:45:25] understood the answer to
[5:45:26] the question raised about input
[5:45:28] raised about implementation
[5:45:29] because in terms I appreciate
[5:45:34] your your response but I will
[5:45:38] note that dsd and Treasurer
[5:45:40] raise concerns regarding
[5:45:41] implementation of Proposal co
[5:45:42] two.
[5:45:43] You said you guys are ready to
[5:45:45] enforce.
[5:45:47] What's the gap there between
[5:45:48] what the department's told
[5:45:50] the ipa and the readiness to
[5:45:53] enforce?
[5:45:53] And I think there's been an
[5:45:54] acknowledgment by the length
[5:45:56] within the language of
[5:45:57] the ordinance that there's a
[5:46:00] gap between what the city can
[5:46:03] do and what the expectation is
[5:46:05] as far as what needs to be
[5:46:06] done.
[5:46:08] I think and certainly I'm not
[5:46:11] tried to speak on your behalf I
[5:46:12] think there was a
[5:46:14] misunderstanding that MAY be
[5:46:14] played out last week during one
[5:46:16] of the public briefings that
[5:46:18] has since been resolved where
[5:46:20] dsd does know their role here
[5:46:22] within this proposed ordinance
[5:46:23] as does the city treasurer.
[5:46:24] I think maybe there was an
[5:46:26] assumption that more was going
[5:46:27] to be added to their plate in
[5:46:28] terms of something that would
[5:46:29] require additional staff time
[5:46:30] or budget which again wouldn't
[5:46:33] be maybe wasn't something that
[5:46:36] was going to be ready for
[5:46:36] consideration today that then
[5:46:38] resolved We do have a path
[5:46:40] forward here that we can do
[5:46:41] within our current capacity.
[5:46:43] We do have a game plan moving
[5:46:45] forward on returning with
[5:46:47] the fee study and so we do feel
[5:46:48] confident that our timeline and
[5:46:52] path forward is solidified and
[5:46:54] agreed upon by all parties and
[5:46:56] city departments.
[5:46:58] So if you can I ask you I mean
[5:46:59] you put this here for a reason
[5:47:02] Are there specific concerns
[5:47:04] that you continue to have just
[5:47:09] not have the information that
[5:47:11] code is referencing here?
[5:47:13] I'm trying to reconcile what I
[5:47:16] know what's put here in good
[5:47:18] faith and what we're hearing on
[5:47:20] the dais.
[5:47:23] I think Yes.
[5:47:24] So so while we're discussing
[5:47:24] with the departments both dsd
[5:47:28] and seato just have questions
[5:47:30] on how to enforce once we have
[5:47:33] this registered or some
[5:47:35] information that they might
[5:47:36] require that it's not provided
[5:47:38] and I defer back to the city or
[5:47:40] what specific those are For
[5:47:41] example type nine licenses
[5:47:43] information that is collected
[5:47:46] in the state That's not
[5:47:47] something they're able to
[5:47:48] receive as of my understanding
[5:47:51] now But I would defer back to
[5:47:53] the cto for specifics.
[5:48:01] I don't have anyone we do
[5:48:03] believe we had a deputy
[5:48:04] director Ricardo Ramos from
[5:48:06] city treasurer only this
[5:48:08] recording of the see that's
[5:48:10] what concern was just
[5:48:11] the enforcement as referenced
[5:48:14] earlier this is basically just
[5:48:16] a registry So we're collecting
[5:48:17] the data and we can actually do
[5:48:20] that piece.
[5:48:20] But it's the question is just
[5:48:22] the enforcement.
[5:48:27] So that's what the answer if
[5:48:33] that's the question as well as
[5:48:34] what was presented today, there
[5:48:35] is no enforcement enforcement
[5:48:38] that would be performed by
[5:48:38] the city just because we have a
[5:48:40] lack of resources to The answer
[5:48:43] is a private right of action.
[5:48:45] Correct.
[5:48:46] Okay.
[5:48:52] So okay So concerns about
[5:48:59] the city's ability to enforce
[5:49:02] or I should say implement
[5:49:04] through enforcement those
[5:49:06] remain what is solved through
[5:49:10] salt Fourth through
[5:49:10] the ordinance is
[5:49:12] the expectation that that gap
[5:49:14] will be closed through private
[5:49:16] right of action.
[5:49:18] That's okay.
[5:49:22] There's like I like a consensus
[5:49:23] of had nothing going on okay I
[5:49:29] recognize that type of action
[5:49:30] are a common tool and an
[5:49:34] important tool And I just from
[5:49:36] a general public policy
[5:49:37] perspective I have concerns and
[5:49:41] don't like the idea that we've
[5:49:43] basically written off
[5:49:44] the city's ability to to
[5:49:46] perform a function that we
[5:49:47] think is worth writing the law
[5:49:48] for to the to private industry.
[5:49:54] But that's just as a general
[5:49:57] sense of public policy that
[5:49:59] doesn't seem like the direction
[5:50:02] we should head but that's a
[5:50:03] resource issue and that will
[5:50:05] continue to be a resource issue
[5:50:06] until the city is properly is
[5:50:08] properly resourced which is a
[5:50:17] little bit of a separate issue
[5:50:18] but not completely because as
[5:50:20] we like we are adding things to
[5:50:22] the city's plate while we're
[5:50:23] also removing resources at
[5:50:25] times and I will continue to be
[5:50:27] frustrated by that But that's
[5:50:29] not the decision that's in
[5:50:30] front of us.
[5:50:34] One other question and
[5:50:36] COUNCILMAN Foster was going to
[5:50:37] get to this There's four cities
[5:50:39] referenced in the ordinance
[5:50:41] L.A., Oakland, Long Beach and
[5:50:42] Ventura.
[5:50:46] Three of those four, as I
[5:50:47] understand it have equity
[5:50:48] programs and as I think either
[5:50:50] of us were saying, the delivery
[5:50:53] piece is the onramp to
[5:50:55] the equity program in Long
[5:50:56] Beach.
[5:51:00] So what are and I trust
[5:51:02] COUNCILMAN Foster to do
[5:51:03] the work here But what what are
[5:51:04] we kind of doing more broadly
[5:51:08] to include the equity piece
[5:51:10] since we're using their
[5:51:11] regulatory framework that you
[5:51:17] you'll have you don't have to
[5:51:19] That's all right if you want it
[5:51:20] by all means.
[5:51:20] But it's also a question for
[5:51:23] COUNCILMAN Foster and our
[5:51:24] office has been working on
[5:51:25] the cannabis social equity
[5:51:26] program and proposed policy for
[5:51:29] you know been working closely
[5:51:30] together on that.
[5:51:31] That was one of the first
[5:51:31] questions asked when this
[5:51:33] initial proposal came forward
[5:51:34] was how it MAY incorporate an
[5:51:34] impact Councilmember Foster's
[5:51:35] effort.
[5:51:38] And so as we get closer to
[5:51:39] the finish line with that
[5:51:40] proposed policy as this one
[5:51:42] gets legs under it and starts
[5:51:43] to be implemented, those are
[5:51:44] two conversations that
[5:51:45] absolutely have to happen
[5:51:46] concurrently to ensure that
[5:51:48] both are essentially feeding
[5:51:49] into each other.
[5:51:51] >> So okay, I appreciate that.
[5:51:55] The last thing I will say is I
[5:51:57] just will echo the comments
[5:51:59] from Catherine Foster that
[5:52:01] the further we allow those who
[5:52:08] got their foot in the door for
[5:52:10] the regulated industry to to to
[5:52:17] sprint ahead, the more
[5:52:19] difficult it is to make it
[5:52:21] equity to eventually have an
[5:52:23] equity program that will
[5:52:24] actually be meaningful and we
[5:52:29] have folks who were shut out
[5:52:32] who were targeted just as much
[5:52:36] for who they are and where they
[5:52:38] were as as to what they were
[5:52:41] actually doing.
[5:52:43] We know the disproportionality
[5:52:45] of the war on drugs and what
[5:52:47] that has meant for generational
[5:52:49] poverty, the disruption of
[5:52:51] families and long term harm
[5:52:53] that will take generations to
[5:52:57] undo And it the cities the city
[5:53:01] has made it a intentional
[5:53:05] decision to start a race and
[5:53:07] not even allow those folks to
[5:53:10] not only not have their shoes
[5:53:11] on yet they're not even at
[5:53:12] the track yet And I think that
[5:53:14] continues to be a concern And
[5:53:16] my trust in Councilmember
[5:53:19] Foster's commitment to making
[5:53:22] sure that we get that piece up
[5:53:25] and running in a meaningful way
[5:53:28] is is significant.
[5:53:30] But I understand
[5:53:33] the frustration And so again,
[5:53:35] the intent here I think is
[5:53:38] there's a lot that we are
[5:53:39] aiming to curb that I think
[5:53:40] needs to be curbed.
[5:53:41] I will never support the idea
[5:53:43] of businesses operating in
[5:53:44] the city without contributing
[5:53:47] back to the city.
[5:53:48] I'll never support the idea of
[5:53:50] businesses operating in
[5:53:51] the city and selling their
[5:53:53] workers short and I want to
[5:53:56] make sure that we do right by
[5:53:57] those who were most harmed by a
[5:54:01] war on drugs that has been
[5:54:04] proven in every way imaginable
[5:54:08] to have been extremely,
[5:54:10] extremely harmful in a very
[5:54:13] disproportionate way.
[5:54:14] So with that I say thank you
[5:54:16] again to Catherine Pompeo and
[5:54:18] his team for bringing this
[5:54:20] forward and look forward to
[5:54:21] having the questions answered
[5:54:22] that have been raised today.
[5:54:24] Thank you.
[5:54:25] >> All right.
[5:54:26] Thank you.
[5:54:26] Council member Eli Rivera.
[5:54:27] We'll go back to Councilmember
[5:54:28] Foster.
[5:54:29] Thank you.
[5:54:30] Just one last question
[5:54:33] Hopefully I guess just process
[5:54:36] wise as there is more work to
[5:54:40] do Right.
[5:54:42] We have this passes today I'm
[5:54:44] assuming that's the first read
[5:54:46] comes back for the second read.
[5:54:49] I guess my question is timeline
[5:54:53] wise and as we talk about cost
[5:54:59] of service right our fee study
[5:55:02] those types of things So what
[5:55:05] happens when we are still going
[5:55:07] through that process and
[5:55:08] understanding just how this
[5:55:09] will be operationalized?
[5:55:11] I guess I will say And what
[5:55:13] does that leave to
[5:55:14] the individuals who MAY be
[5:55:16] going through whatever they are
[5:55:18] going through?
[5:55:19] Let's say there is a county
[5:55:22] equity individual who wants to
[5:55:29] come in and sign up or do
[5:55:32] something.
[5:55:32] What does that do to their
[5:55:33] business and their ability to
[5:55:35] engage as we are trying to
[5:55:38] figure out the operational side
[5:55:39] of this and to where we are
[5:55:41] able to function and understand
[5:55:45] who you know because I'm
[5:55:45] assuming if they go to court
[5:55:46] who would be the legal not
[5:55:48] legal not legal business entity
[5:55:51] or what comes first, how does
[5:55:54] that play out in terms of
[5:55:56] the process of the ordinance
[5:55:57] and its implementation?
[5:55:59] Well, first this would be first
[5:56:01] reading second reading 30 days
[5:56:04] pass that implementation date
[5:56:06] and we're asking for commitment
[5:56:07] from the mayor's office to be
[5:56:08] able to bring that fee study in
[5:56:11] alignment with that timeline so
[5:56:13] that we have certainty before
[5:56:15] this ordinance becomes
[5:56:16] effective because you can't
[5:56:20] have an effective ordinance
[5:56:21] with this tool without
[5:56:22] the implementation and it can't
[5:56:26] work.
[5:56:28] So correct And I think it would
[5:56:29] if that did happen it would
[5:56:31] just become chaos.
[5:56:33] So what I guess how are you
[5:56:35] going to manage that?
[5:56:36] What's the plan for that?
[5:56:37] So as we go through the second
[5:56:39] reading and if that passes
[5:56:41] through council city treasurer
[5:56:43] initiates the fee study item We
[5:56:46] are up against legislative
[5:56:47] recess at that time as well
[5:56:48] too.
[5:56:48] So there's a little bit of time
[5:56:50] here after initial passage and
[5:56:51] actual implementation.
[5:56:53] I think during that portion as
[5:56:54] you do have the commitment from
[5:56:55] our office that this does not
[5:56:57] go live until that fee is
[5:56:58] obviously there.
[5:57:00] And so it's a it's a
[5:57:01] communication piece really.
[5:57:03] And so I think the second part
[5:57:04] of the request from
[5:57:06] Councilmember Campo was for our
[5:57:07] assistance in coordinating with
[5:57:08] other regional entities as
[5:57:10] Summer mentioned earlier
[5:57:11] incorporating equity pieces
[5:57:13] that the county already has in
[5:57:14] place into that fee study I
[5:57:16] think is is a good step forward
[5:57:18] And so there's quite a bit of
[5:57:20] work here after initial passage
[5:57:22] but we got to get this passed
[5:57:24] to initiate that work And so
[5:57:26] it's really going to be a
[5:57:27] communication piece from both
[5:57:28] of our offices on this council
[5:57:30] to educate folks on what to
[5:57:32] expect and then have a clear
[5:57:34] runway as the fee actually gets
[5:57:35] adopted by this council.
[5:57:37] We have a firm implementation
[5:57:38] date in mind.
[5:57:39] Okay.
[5:57:40] So what I'm hearing is if for
[5:57:42] some reason that commitment in
[5:57:45] regards to operationalizing
[5:57:47] this is not stood up in time as
[5:57:52] we go through this second read
[5:57:53] then are we going to pause or
[5:57:58] timeline that correctly so that
[5:58:00] we are not so we don't have an
[5:58:02] ordinance that has passed and
[5:58:03] made it through and then we are
[5:58:07] in trouble trying to scramble
[5:58:09] and you have this clause in
[5:58:13] here where folks can just start
[5:58:15] filing.
[5:58:18] So how are we managing that?
[5:58:21] >> You understand what I'm
[5:58:22] asking?
[5:58:23] I totally get what you're
[5:58:24] saying.
[5:58:24] So I think I think there need
[5:58:27] to be a discussion maybe with
[5:58:28] city attorney's office here on
[5:58:30] if we push out a second reading
[5:58:31] and initiate to basically take
[5:58:33] this as the direction of
[5:58:34] the council saying yes, proceed
[5:58:35] with establishing the fee and
[5:58:37] then going through that process
[5:58:38] to conduct the study and have
[5:58:41] the conversations I described
[5:58:42] earlier before returning for
[5:58:43] the second reading Similar to
[5:58:45] how we do things if it's a
[5:58:46] meeting confer approach or
[5:58:47] anything like that that way we
[5:58:49] can have a clear and clean
[5:58:50] implementation date.
[5:58:52] I think both options work here
[5:58:54] but I completely understand
[5:58:55] where your concerns are of
[5:58:56] basically creating a
[5:58:57] opportunity for predatory
[5:58:59] litigation to come through and
[5:58:59] in place.
[5:59:01] So get that.
[5:59:02] Okay.
[5:59:03] Well I think that's something
[5:59:04] that we need to make sure we
[5:59:06] have a clear understanding and
[5:59:10] don't get ahead of ourselves
[5:59:14] and create other issues And
[5:59:17] then I'm sure creating more
[5:59:20] barriers for folks who have
[5:59:21] already been impacted from
[5:59:23] the war on drugs right.
[5:59:26] So so MADAM City Attorney, I
[5:59:28] guess I will in the city
[5:59:31] attorney's office We'll add
[5:59:32] that to our conversation.
[5:59:35] Um, as we are preparing and
[5:59:37] continuing to move this item
[5:59:39] forward I just want to make
[5:59:40] sure that we are not getting
[5:59:41] ahead of ourselves and doing
[5:59:43] more of a disservice and that
[5:59:44] what we are trying to
[5:59:46] accomplish with this.
[5:59:48] Okay.
[5:59:49] Thank you.
[5:59:49] Council PRESIDENT All right.
[5:59:51] Thank you Councilmember Foster
[5:59:54] Not see anybody else and light
[5:59:56] I'll ask a few questions of my
[5:59:58] own one Thank you Councilmember
[6:00:03] Camp you and your d seven team
[6:00:03] on This is something we've
[6:00:05] talked about.
[6:00:06] We have acknowledged it and it
[6:00:07] never went anywhere even though
[6:00:09] we recognize the delivery
[6:00:11] services were happening there
[6:00:13] And as I think we've all kind
[6:00:15] of landed on the inability to
[6:00:18] enforce by city staff was
[6:00:21] probably one of the reasons
[6:00:22] that we were just kind of stuck
[6:00:25] and acknowledging there was a
[6:00:26] problem without any kind of
[6:00:27] solution And the private right
[6:00:28] of action is that missing piece
[6:00:30] that allows us to actually that
[6:00:34] will be brought forward.
[6:00:35] So thank you for working
[6:00:36] through it.
[6:00:38] So the questions that go
[6:00:39] through my mind are unlike most
[6:00:42] ordinances and implementations
[6:00:45] that follow afterwards, it's
[6:00:48] the city that's doing
[6:00:49] the enforcement.
[6:00:50] This ordinance actually has a
[6:00:52] private right of action.
[6:00:53] Is there language in today's
[6:00:56] motion that says this does not
[6:00:59] go into effect until we
[6:01:01] actually have a permit process
[6:01:03] in place That's not in
[6:01:07] the motion language but if
[6:01:09] the maker would like to we go
[6:01:11] to the first reading, we go to
[6:01:12] the second reading we have an
[6:01:13] ordinance and somebody named
[6:01:16] Lady Named says I just found
[6:01:18] somebody who doesn't have a
[6:01:19] permit and compliance.
[6:01:21] I'm going to initiate a private
[6:01:22] right of action Go to my be
[6:01:25] bound with operations side.
[6:01:28] Is it a crazy idea?
[6:01:29] I know there's some big money
[6:01:31] there that council PRESIDENT
[6:01:39] Are you are you asking if
[6:01:41] the private right of action can
[6:01:43] be a force enforced if the city
[6:01:45] hasn't City Treasurer's office
[6:01:46] hasn't created the license
[6:01:48] structure or the permit
[6:01:49] structure for an outside of
[6:01:52] the city cannabis delivery
[6:01:53] program or a business to
[6:01:55] actually get and therefore
[6:01:58] follow the law.
[6:01:59] >> I guess that's that's
[6:02:01] the question.
[6:02:02] I think that it would Okay Well
[6:02:05] first to even prove it you'd
[6:02:05] have to prove harm or you'd
[6:02:08] have to show that you're, you
[6:02:08] know, harmed economically But I
[6:02:13] guess strictly speaking it
[6:02:14] doesn't elucidate that exactly
[6:02:20] I mean code is committed to
[6:02:22] the operation cited dft or city
[6:02:25] treasurers would enforce that.
[6:02:26] We actually had it in place
[6:02:28] certainly Well to be very to be
[6:02:29] very clear, there is an
[6:02:31] enforcement mechanism for
[6:02:32] the city that says a city
[6:02:33] manager shall promulgate rules
[6:02:34] and regulations to do that.
[6:02:36] So it's not as if we're not
[6:02:39] able to create a system for
[6:02:41] internal administrative
[6:02:42] enforcement.
[6:02:47] So I would say it's almost
[6:02:49] nonsensical to think that a
[6:02:51] private right of action could
[6:02:51] come forward if the city
[6:02:55] manager, the mayor's office
[6:02:57] through the departments hasn't
[6:02:58] created an actual license to
[6:02:59] apply for because how could you
[6:03:01] possibly go forward and try to
[6:03:02] follow the law as an outside
[6:03:04] delivery company if it doesn't
[6:03:06] exist?
[6:03:08] Yeah but the city attorney
[6:03:10] agree with him Either one of
[6:03:12] you And as Deputy City attorney
[6:03:16] David Carlin to respond to
[6:03:17] that?
[6:03:18] >> Yes, I would agree with that
[6:03:19] proposition that's been
[6:03:21] discussed by Councilmember You
[6:03:24] It's a private right of action
[6:03:25] could not be initiated until
[6:03:26] there actually is a permit
[6:03:27] process in place That I guess
[6:03:30] to answer that question
[6:03:31] specifically, there's nothing
[6:03:32] ever to stop somebody from
[6:03:34] filing a lawsuit as I think we
[6:03:35] all know.
[6:03:35] But to succeed in that lawsuit
[6:03:38] is you'd have to have a permit
[6:03:40] process in place to show that
[6:03:42] somebody is in violation of it
[6:03:43] >> That's right.
[6:03:45] Okay.
[6:03:45] I got three lawyers saying yes
[6:03:50] so I'm going to back off at
[6:03:51] the engineer the for those of
[6:03:57] us that are not steeped in this
[6:03:58] whole ordinance, there's no
[6:04:02] limit on the number of permits
[6:04:03] that can be issued.
[6:04:04] Is that correct?
[6:04:06] >> That's correct.
[6:04:06] As long as it's state licensed
[6:04:09] there was an assumption made
[6:04:11] that you have to have both a I
[6:04:14] think a business tax
[6:04:15] certificate and the permit and
[6:04:19] that the expectation is that
[6:04:22] that permit we know what
[6:04:23] the business tax certificate
[6:04:24] amounts are.
[6:04:25] It's kind of a throwaway It's
[6:04:27] probably the cheapest fee that
[6:04:29] we have on the books.
[6:04:30] But if what if survey the fee
[6:04:37] analysis comes back and said
[6:04:39] well yeah, we're not going to
[6:04:40] do anything for 75 bucks or 150
[6:04:42] bucks.
[6:04:42] I don't even know what permit
[6:04:43] you could get for that.
[6:04:44] And it comes back of 300 bucks
[6:04:46] and 500 bucks.
[6:04:48] We're just going to we could
[6:04:50] subsidize it.
[6:04:51] We don't have to have full cost
[6:04:52] recovery but I just want to set
[6:04:56] expectations that in fact it
[6:04:58] MAY not come in that an
[6:05:00] expensive so and then we can
[6:05:02] deal with it because we can
[6:05:03] subsidize it.
[6:05:04] We don't have to charge full
[6:05:05] cost recovery and we can do as
[6:05:07] I think it was suggested
[6:05:08] waivers or carve out I've done
[6:05:12] some of those and some of
[6:05:13] the fees.
[6:05:14] The other question is I think
[6:05:16] every time that we've gone and
[6:05:18] done update our fees and
[6:05:20] penalties, a lot of us have
[6:05:23] grumbled that we don't think
[6:05:24] those rates are high enough to
[6:05:26] actually be a disincentive to
[6:05:28] someone breaking the law.
[6:05:30] I can think lots and lots of
[6:05:31] examples of that.
[6:05:33] This sets a whole new bar of
[6:05:35] jacking up 10,000 per violation
[6:05:39] for abatement $20,000 a day for
[6:05:41] a civil penalty That opens up
[6:05:44] the universe in terms of what
[6:05:46] those can be.
[6:05:47] Why is this okay?
[6:05:48] And when we don't do that with
[6:05:49] any other fee and penalty, was
[6:05:52] that just a policy call or was
[6:05:55] there actually something that
[6:05:56] limited how much we could
[6:05:57] charge?
[6:05:58] I don't know Who wants to
[6:05:59] answer that.
[6:06:00] I can start with the policy
[6:06:02] direction the fee establishment
[6:06:04] amount at $20,000 was a policy
[6:06:07] decision based off of the city
[6:06:08] of L.A. Is a penalty structure.
[6:06:12] The $10,000 value comes from
[6:06:15] what is existing in the land
[6:06:17] development code that was
[6:06:19] recently updated as part of
[6:06:20] the JUNE 8th action.
[6:06:22] So that is the baseline figure
[6:06:24] that we were operating off of.
[6:06:29] I'll leave it there.
[6:06:29] MR..
[6:06:32] So legally again this literally
[6:06:35] goes to the United States
[6:06:36] Constitution and the Eighth
[6:06:38] Amendment and the excessive
[6:06:38] fine clause It would have to be
[6:06:40] to be unlawful to be grossly
[6:06:43] disproportionate to the actual
[6:06:43] fence.
[6:06:45] Again, this is a fee that's up
[6:06:47] to $20,000 per day that a
[6:06:50] violation exists.
[6:06:51] And this would be I guess I
[6:06:55] should say this is the judicial
[6:06:56] civil penalty portion of this.
[6:06:58] So a judge would have to factor
[6:07:01] in what he or she would decide
[6:07:03] would be judicially imposed.
[6:07:04] Right.
[6:07:09] I mean so it's not it's not a
[6:07:10] guarantee $20,000 if we put a
[6:07:13] ceiling on it.
[6:07:15] Okay.
[6:07:15] Fair enough Because again, we
[6:07:18] have private right of action.
[6:07:21] The city's policy generally has
[6:07:22] a ban.
[6:07:23] We're not looking for revenue.
[6:07:25] We're looking for compliance by
[6:07:27] private right of action
[6:07:28] probably assume has no such
[6:07:30] strings.
[6:07:32] They don't have to say Did you
[6:07:34] not know that there was a new
[6:07:35] law that you have to comply
[6:07:37] with that they can just drag
[6:07:39] them into court, is that
[6:07:41] correct?
[6:07:43] Again, once the permit process
[6:07:44] is up and running, yes, that
[6:07:46] that is correct.
[6:07:47] Okay.
[6:07:49] And as I think others said,
[6:07:52] communications are going to be
[6:07:52] a big part of this to try to
[6:07:53] spread the word that not only
[6:07:56] is there a requirement but it
[6:07:57] could be enforced immediately
[6:07:58] unlike how the city typically
[6:08:00] acts.
[6:08:03] I think the one question that I
[6:08:04] didn't hear from my colleagues
[6:08:07] was we got a number of folks
[6:08:10] who apparently operate under
[6:08:12] the county cannabis equity
[6:08:15] program.
[6:08:18] I'm not familiar what are
[6:08:20] the requirements that they had
[6:08:21] to go through to qualify or get
[6:08:24] a permit or whatever the county
[6:08:25] does versus what this ordinance
[6:08:27] will require?
[6:08:29] Is there any differences or any
[6:08:31] added obligations or
[6:08:33] differences between
[6:08:35] the county's permit and this
[6:08:36] proposed permit The counties
[6:08:38] permit?
[6:08:38] From our conversations they
[6:08:40] have four categories and
[6:08:42] they're all land use based So
[6:08:44] their delivery permit also
[6:08:46] include is the facility itself
[6:08:49] and they have a flat fee
[6:08:50] assessed And I know we have
[6:08:52] some county operators here they
[6:08:54] can give the specifics on fees
[6:08:55] but it's in the thousands of
[6:08:56] dollars That's for the license
[6:09:00] for the counties program.
[6:09:01] An operator that's operating
[6:09:04] social equity or not still has
[6:09:06] to obtain their state license
[6:09:07] both at the same time.
[6:09:09] So they would have to obtain
[6:09:11] their state license their
[6:09:13] license to the county as a
[6:09:14] separate licensing process
[6:09:16] application fee And that's
[6:09:20] the county what the city is
[6:09:22] proposing in this ordinance is
[6:09:25] the registration,
[6:09:26] the commercial business
[6:09:28] registration to do business and
[6:09:30] conduct business in the city.
[6:09:31] So it's not a land use permit
[6:09:33] in that sense It's a business
[6:09:35] registration that it's intended
[6:09:36] to complement the existing
[6:09:38] cannabis non cannabis business
[6:09:41] tax certificate.
[6:09:43] So if I understand correctly
[6:09:45] the only new requirement for
[6:09:47] anybody who has a permit or
[6:09:49] license through the county is
[6:09:51] to fill out an online form.
[6:09:54] That's correct.
[6:09:55] That's it.
[6:09:56] So and the tax certificate and
[6:10:00] then the permit fee which we
[6:10:01] hope is $150 range.
[6:10:08] >> Okay.
[6:10:08] And I think that answers all
[6:10:11] the questions.
[6:10:12] So thank you very much for
[6:10:13] answering the questions.
[6:10:15] Thank you for working through
[6:10:17] this.
[6:10:17] I know some of the folks that
[6:10:19] were in opposition to this are
[6:10:20] not going to be satisfied with
[6:10:22] the dialog here going forward
[6:10:26] but I will be in support of
[6:10:30] this.
[6:10:31] So Councilmember Hemphill Thank
[6:10:31] you, counselors.
[6:10:33] I'll just be very brief.
[6:10:34] MR. Carlin mentioned
[6:10:34] constitutional protections that
[6:10:36] clicked in my mind The Doctor
[6:10:38] There would be a due process
[6:10:40] problem for the city to create
[6:10:42] a law but not create the permit
[6:10:44] to enforce the law and then go
[6:10:46] someone from a private reaction
[6:10:47] go to a court to say this
[6:10:48] person doesn't have the permit
[6:10:50] that is required by law.
[6:10:51] So I think it's a I think we
[6:10:54] can say with a high degree of
[6:10:56] certainty that no court would
[6:10:57] allow a private private right
[6:10:59] of action lawsuit if we haven't
[6:11:01] taken the steps.
[6:11:02] There's also equitable remedies
[6:11:04] under the law to save.
[6:11:05] How could I know I was
[6:11:07] violating the law if I never
[6:11:08] had the ability to follow
[6:11:10] the law itself?
[6:11:11] So I appreciate MR. Carlin
[6:11:13] bringing up that phrase so it
[6:11:15] would trigger that history
[6:11:16] lesson.
[6:11:17] Well, we all learned a little
[6:11:18] bit about the Constitution.
[6:11:21] Okay.
[6:11:22] I think I've gotten all my
[6:11:24] questions answered about again
[6:11:27] thank you, Councilmember Campo,
[6:11:29] for finally solving the missing
[6:11:31] piece to regulate something
[6:11:32] that we've talked about for a
[6:11:33] very long time.
[6:11:35] I look forward to Councilmember
[6:11:36] Foster and his work at the city
[6:11:39] level.
[6:11:40] Thank you to staff for
[6:11:41] navigating this and
[6:11:42] the research that you did to
[6:11:44] bring bring this forward.
[6:11:46] So with that I don't see
[6:11:48] anybody else on the lights.
[6:11:49] We have a motion by
[6:11:49] Councilmember Campo and
[6:11:52] the second by council member
[6:11:53] Von Wilbert that we can't
[6:11:55] please call the roll.
[6:11:57] I have set up the voting
[6:11:58] system.
[6:11:59] Please cast your vote.
[6:12:10] The motion passes unanimously
[6:12:11] with District two and district
[6:12:13] date absent.
[6:12:15] All right.
[6:12:16] Thank you again.
[6:12:18] Okay.
[6:12:18] I need to do a little bit of a
[6:12:19] time check.
[6:12:20] This is the point in
[6:12:21] the afternoon session where we
[6:12:23] do not agenda public comment
[6:12:25] Everybody willing to stick
[6:12:26] around for both in-person and
[6:12:29] remote because I hope we got
[6:12:33] six So we're in good shape.
[6:12:36] Thank you because I know I
[6:12:37] don't want to roll over till
[6:12:38] tomorrow.
[6:12:38] It can be done so we will now
[6:12:42] take up non agenda public
[6:12:43] comment We'll take both
[6:12:45] in-person and those
[6:12:46] participating remotely.
[6:12:48] Council members respect and
[6:12:49] appreciate the public input and
[6:12:50] are fully committed to
[6:12:51] protecting every participant's
[6:12:53] free speech rights at council
[6:12:54] and committee meetings.
[6:12:55] Deputy Clerk Please proceed
[6:12:57] with public comment Pearl 2.7
[6:13:00] Known Agenda Public comment is
[6:13:01] an opportunity for members of
[6:13:02] the public to comment on items
[6:13:03] that are not on the agenda but
[6:13:05] within the subject matter
[6:13:06] jurisdiction of the City
[6:13:08] Council.
[6:13:08] Each speaker will have two
[6:13:10] minutes.
[6:13:10] Please note if there are eight
[6:13:12] or more speakers on a single
[6:13:13] topic the maximum time for
[6:13:14] the topic will be 16 minutes.
[6:13:16] If you are in chambers please
[6:13:18] submit your speaker slip If you
[6:13:19] are joining us virtually please
[6:13:20] raise your hand to speak by
[6:13:22] tapping the raise your hand
[6:13:23] icon or if you are a call in
[6:13:25] participant start nine We will
[6:13:27] begin with in-person knowledge
[6:13:30] and public comment.
[6:13:34] Jacob Lewis Edwards I don't
[6:13:36] think he's still here so I'll
[6:13:39] go to the next person allegedly
[6:13:44] Order Please come forward.
[6:13:45] You have two minutes to speak.
[6:13:45] Okay.
[6:13:58] We we go.
[6:14:01] Can you start my time over?
[6:14:03] Thanks.
[6:14:04] Yeah.
[6:14:04] You guys are funny with this
[6:14:05] drug stuff.
[6:14:06] You're like we're going to
[6:14:07] fight the war on drugs by
[6:14:08] heavily regulating the drugs
[6:14:12] make an extremely difficult for
[6:14:13] all those people.
[6:14:14] Who were you know wrongly
[6:14:17] charged any who And it's funny
[6:14:18] to be talking about drugs while
[6:14:19] we have people who are
[6:14:22] whistleblowing against
[6:14:23] the government like some are
[6:14:26] Stephan And the things that are
[6:14:27] going on in the jails at Las
[6:14:31] Colinas and their brutal
[6:14:33] assault from that Andrea Ebbing
[6:14:35] with Anthony Warner totally
[6:14:37] slammed her face into
[6:14:38] the ground and he's playing
[6:14:40] the victim.
[6:14:40] He's like six, six three and
[6:14:44] 260 pounds said she was really
[6:14:46] posturing any who So they have
[6:14:49] done a competency evaluation
[6:14:52] because you know in order to
[6:14:53] silence somebody you got to
[6:14:54] really question their
[6:14:56] competency.
[6:14:57] So then as long as you ask them
[6:14:59] some political questions and
[6:15:00] the person doing the evaluation
[6:15:02] things that you're I don't know
[6:15:05] maybe a conspiracy theorist
[6:15:06] then they'll say that your
[6:15:07] incompetent So how cool is
[6:15:10] that?
[6:15:10] I mean she's got felony charges
[6:15:12] from you know, supposedly
[6:15:14] barring Anthony Warner who you
[6:15:15] know, can still shoot his
[6:15:16] firearm but has to take time
[6:15:19] off of work because his hand is
[6:15:20] so injured.
[6:15:22] But it's just interesting to
[6:15:24] see the lengths that people
[6:15:25] will go to silence people.
[6:15:27] So I mean imagine she might go
[6:15:29] into a mental hospital for like
[6:15:31] two years.
[6:15:32] Who knows?
[6:15:33] And then eventually, you know,
[6:15:34] if somebody deems her competent
[6:15:35] she might be able to face these
[6:15:37] charges.
[6:15:39] Right.
[6:15:39] And right now she's in on two
[6:15:41] misdemeanors.
[6:15:42] She's out on a felony.
[6:15:43] You know, she had her brain
[6:15:44] aneurysm.
[6:15:45] No worries there.
[6:15:47] She might need some more
[6:15:48] surgery while she's in there.
[6:15:49] She already had to go to
[6:15:50] the hospital because they can't
[6:15:52] take care of her.
[6:15:53] >> But good job isn't that cool
[6:15:55] when you're exposing stuff and
[6:15:57] they say you're incompetent
[6:15:58] should be really exciting.
[6:16:01] >> The job.
[6:16:02] Thank you.
[6:16:03] Blair Beekman followed by Bob
[6:16:05] Kozinski, Anthony Ralphs, Lori
[6:16:11] Saldana, Marco Espinosa and
[6:16:11] Terry Best High by Beekman
[6:16:14] Thanks.
[6:16:20] A report back on Andrea's which
[6:16:23] is that where she's at?
[6:16:24] I think she's passing her
[6:16:25] competency test so Oh I'm not
[6:16:29] hearing the story right If
[6:16:30] she's going down again she was
[6:16:31] up before and now it's down and
[6:16:33] it's just amazing she has to go
[6:16:35] through all of this.
[6:16:37] I mean I really hope that can
[6:16:38] be a real effort to be working
[6:16:41] on this issue And overall
[6:16:44] issues of how our police work,
[6:16:45] how our immune systems are
[6:16:47] working.
[6:16:48] Good luck in those efforts.
[6:16:49] I wanted to ask also how
[6:16:52] the just I made a point You
[6:16:57] know, I was I was late to learn
[6:16:59] that the new Good Day Centers
[6:17:01] is probably going to be closing
[6:17:02] in six months time And I think
[6:17:05] we have to make a concerted
[6:17:06] effort to talk about our
[6:17:09] homeless issues more in
[6:17:10] the coming year, how we do that
[6:17:12] and a more sensitivity in that
[6:17:14] department.
[6:17:15] And so I was really hurt in
[6:17:17] the presentation being
[6:17:19] dismissed today.
[6:17:20] I think we have to make that
[6:17:22] extra effort at this time and I
[6:17:24] hope we can.
[6:17:25] So good luck how we can.
[6:17:27] I also wanted to offer at this
[6:17:30] time I'm giving my tech academy
[6:17:33] a bit of a break tonight and
[6:17:35] just consider you know
[6:17:36] the ideas I brought up before
[6:17:39] about budget issues that we can
[6:17:41] still work on budget issues at
[6:17:43] this time And the idea of as a
[6:17:47] very small cut in pay to our
[6:17:49] city government staff if that's
[6:17:53] 3000 people at least if they
[6:17:56] take a cut of say $600 a year
[6:18:00] that's 50 bucks a month.
[6:18:01] I think that's over almost $2
[6:18:03] million in savings that can go
[6:18:06] to the budget and that's not
[6:18:07] including our city council And
[6:18:09] Mayor, what they can take on
[6:18:12] that's a lot of money and I
[6:18:14] hope we want to consider such
[6:18:16] things.
[6:18:17] >> Good luck You can Thank you.
[6:18:19] Thank you.
[6:18:20] Bob Kozinski So video okay.
[6:18:43] Okay Bob because there's a week
[6:18:43] ago today I was hang gliding at
[6:18:45] Dockweiler State Beach in Los
[6:18:46] Angeles under the Dockweiler
[6:18:48] waiver that has been in place
[6:18:49] since 2017 the public has been
[6:18:52] able to hang glider at
[6:18:53] Dockweiler Beach for nearly ten
[6:18:54] years under that waiver a
[6:18:56] decade ago.
[6:18:57] However, hang gliding at
[6:18:58] Dockweiler was not allowed by
[6:18:59] the county of Los Angeles
[6:19:01] without use of a membership.
[6:19:03] Fortunately that all changed
[6:19:04] due to a sequence of events
[6:19:06] that started right here in San
[6:19:08] Diego On JULY 24th, 2011.
[6:19:11] A female student named Shannon
[6:19:12] Hamby was taking lessons at
[6:19:14] Tori through the city where she
[6:19:19] was under radio supervision
[6:19:21] when she was flown directly
[6:19:22] into the path of another
[6:19:23] student.
[6:19:24] She crashed and was badly
[6:19:26] injured.
[6:19:26] I was contacted by Shannon's
[6:19:28] lawyer and asked to testify as
[6:19:30] an expert witness and I did.
[6:19:32] My testimony in SEPTEMBER of
[6:19:33] 2014 was solid and the case was
[6:19:36] quickly settled in Shannon's
[6:19:37] favor for an undisclosed
[6:19:39] amount.
[6:19:40] Yeshivah ended up losing their
[6:19:41] insurance coverage by NOVEMBER
[6:19:43] of 2014.
[6:19:44] I was retaliated against by
[6:19:46] your concessionaire who
[6:19:48] conspired with you spend
[6:19:49] the spring of 2015 to have me
[6:19:51] expelled for my testimony which
[6:19:53] ended my ability to fly at all
[6:19:55] use for sites including Torrey
[6:19:57] Pines and Dockweiler In early
[6:19:59] 2017 we met with newly elected
[6:20:01] Barbara Bree for help.
[6:20:03] Barbara Bree suggested a flight
[6:20:04] waiver to solve the problem but
[6:20:06] she never followed through.
[6:20:09] Joe Foust and I also spoke to
[6:20:10] the Los Angeles County Board of
[6:20:12] Supervisors while Barbara Bree
[6:20:14] did nothing here in San Diego,
[6:20:16] Los Angeles Supervisor Janice
[6:20:18] Hahn stepped up and actually
[6:20:20] instituted a waiver.
[6:20:21] The first DR. Weiler waivers
[6:20:23] were issued to Joe Foust, Frank
[6:20:25] Culver and myself on JULY 26th,
[6:20:28] 2017 and we have flown under
[6:20:31] those waivers without incident
[6:20:32] ever since Barbara Bree dodged
[6:20:34] the issue for the rest of her
[6:20:35] term until her failed mayoral
[6:20:37] bid in 2020.
[6:20:38] Joe LaCava has followed her
[6:20:40] lead throughout his entire term
[6:20:42] reactivate the Torrey Pines
[6:20:44] City Park Advisory Board and
[6:20:45] Institute a Torrey Pines flight
[6:20:47] waiver now Thank you.
[6:20:49] >> Thank you.
[6:20:49] >> Our next speaker is Anthony
[6:20:57] Ralphs.
[6:21:05] Good afternoon City Council.
[6:21:07] I just wanted to speak about
[6:21:09] the concern that I have and
[6:21:10] hearing the expressed financial
[6:21:12] concerns earlier today.
[6:21:14] Miss Campbell who is no longer
[6:21:15] here expressed the $3 million
[6:21:17] concern that she had with
[6:21:19] the study that was done for
[6:21:21] the Phase two project for sdi
[6:21:25] And she thought that the $3
[6:21:26] million was too much, that
[6:21:27] these studies are costing
[6:21:28] the city too much.
[6:21:31] I have a real difficulty in
[6:21:33] understanding how she can on
[6:21:35] one hand have fine problems
[6:21:37] with the costs of the studies
[6:21:39] that cost $3 million to help us
[6:21:42] potentially get off of a
[6:21:43] monopoly that's making $1
[6:21:46] billion of profit every year.
[6:21:47] But she doesn't raise a single
[6:21:49] point with the fact that
[6:21:52] the police budget the public
[6:21:54] liability fund has exceeded
[6:21:56] over $116 million in the last
[6:22:00] ten years or that this year
[6:22:02] alone it's already exceeded $42
[6:22:04] million and we're not even
[6:22:06] finished with all
[6:22:07] the settlements.
[6:22:07] I have not heard the side of
[6:22:11] the city that does not address
[6:22:12] these issues as as Henry Foster
[6:22:14] has expressed before and
[6:22:16] multiple times in this chambers
[6:22:17] he said this is the tale of two
[6:22:19] cities And he's right.
[6:22:20] We do have one half of this
[6:22:22] city council that understands
[6:22:24] and respects our privacy
[6:22:25] concerns, that understands and
[6:22:27] respects that we are not
[6:22:30] property of the state to be
[6:22:32] tracked in our whereabouts of
[6:22:34] where we go that understands in
[6:22:37] the Supreme Court's recent
[6:22:38] ruling that we have freedom in
[6:22:42] the whole totality of our
[6:22:43] movement Although the roads are
[6:22:46] owned yes by the city and
[6:22:49] therefore yes y'all do have
[6:22:51] jurisdiction over the city's
[6:22:53] roads.
[6:22:54] We own our own personal
[6:22:56] sovereignty over our own bodies
[6:22:58] And there are cities that are
[6:23:01] being sued including I believe
[6:23:05] it is Santa Monica No Santa
[6:23:05] Clara.
[6:23:07] >> Thank you for your time.
[6:23:09] Thank you.
[6:23:10] We're next.
[6:23:10] Lori Saldana.
[6:23:19] >> Good evening and thank you
[6:23:20] to those of you who are
[6:23:22] actually still here and some of
[6:23:23] you are maybe even paying
[6:23:25] attention.
[6:23:25] I just got off of a Zoom
[6:23:28] meeting with the Democratic
[6:23:29] Club and one of the council
[6:23:31] members who's not here tonight
[6:23:33] was in that meeting.
[6:23:34] So I'm not sure where
[6:23:35] the priorities are but it's a
[6:23:37] little concerning to me when
[6:23:38] you have discussions on issues
[6:23:40] that are important to this body
[6:23:42] and people leave early and then
[6:23:44] end up at another engagement
[6:23:45] elsewhere.
[6:23:46] You're you're concerned about
[6:23:48] the impacts on public health
[6:23:50] and safety and giving
[6:23:51] the private right of action to
[6:23:52] others in certain industry.
[6:23:55] And I just want to suggest that
[6:23:56] there's another industry in
[6:23:57] town that has serious impacts
[6:23:59] on public health and safety.
[6:24:02] Is it just me or is there
[6:24:03] feedback on this tonight?
[6:24:05] There's feedback.
[6:24:07] >> And if you were to give a
[6:24:09] private right of action to
[6:24:10] people I think you would go a
[6:24:12] long way to closing of several
[6:24:14] problems in our city budget and
[6:24:16] also our housing.
[6:24:17] And of course I'm talking about
[6:24:18] short term vacation rentals.
[6:24:20] They also lack enforcement.
[6:24:22] They also have people operating
[6:24:24] without permits.
[6:24:25] They also have people putting
[6:24:26] lives and safety at risk.
[6:24:28] Around the corner from my
[6:24:30] house.
[6:24:30] There's a short term rental
[6:24:32] that has caught on fire that
[6:24:34] has flooded raw sewage into
[6:24:35] the streets.
[6:24:36] And it took me over a year to
[6:24:38] get someone to respond.
[6:24:40] If I had a private right of
[6:24:41] action I could have gone at
[6:24:42] them as a property owner
[6:24:44] nearby.
[6:24:45] Also they don't pay commercial
[6:24:46] trash hauling fees.
[6:24:48] They pay residential fees and
[6:24:49] they're businesses operating in
[6:24:51] our neighborhoods.
[6:24:52] If you are serious about
[6:24:53] private right of action, give
[6:24:56] residents who are next door to
[6:24:58] short term rentals that are
[6:24:59] violating the permitting,
[6:25:01] violating health and safety.
[6:25:03] And let us go after them
[6:25:04] because I promise you they are
[6:25:06] not disadvantaged.
[6:25:08] They have people that owned
[6:25:09] multiple properties that form
[6:25:10] consortiums that buy our
[6:25:12] properties in Ocean Beach and
[6:25:14] elsewhere and push out full
[6:25:15] time residential rent renters
[6:25:18] and homeowners.
[6:25:19] If you want a right of action
[6:25:21] apply it to short term rent.
[6:25:22] Thank you.
[6:25:23] That does conclude your time.
[6:25:25] >> Marco Espinosa.
[6:25:32] >> Good evening.
[6:25:35] My question goes a Boston
[6:25:35] Avenue park ideas.
[6:25:42] Um the it's not helpful if I
[6:25:43] don't have a map for you.
[6:25:46] Sorry.
[6:25:47] Um, I know we already iterated
[6:25:47] the coming onto the freeway
[6:25:50] The bollards that first section
[6:25:53] of park between the freeway
[6:25:55] onramp and the bridge that goes
[6:25:57] over the freeway.
[6:25:58] I think that could be
[6:25:58] the section in the diagram
[6:26:03] shows how it's owned.
[6:26:05] It doesn't include actually
[6:26:07] the walkway.
[6:26:08] Um, and the bridge.
[6:26:11] Um, so when I got to the park I
[6:26:12] was like oh that's something to
[6:26:13] consider on Google Maps.
[6:26:15] The park actually looks really
[6:26:16] small.
[6:26:18] Doesn't seem like there's a lot
[6:26:18] space but once you get there
[6:26:20] quite a lot of space for a park
[6:26:22] If it does end up being the um
[6:26:23] tennis courts or soccer fields
[6:26:27] um in the portion that's like a
[6:26:33] longer portion Nothing could
[6:26:33] fit there.
[6:26:34] That doesn't need to be like a
[6:26:35] net or something that goes
[6:26:37] along that nice new barrier
[6:26:38] wall for the freeway so
[6:26:40] eyeballs don't go into
[6:26:41] the freeway as cars are going.
[6:26:43] And then the second portion of
[6:26:47] land use available for park
[6:26:52] Right now it's a cycle center.
[6:26:54] I remember I heard that
[6:26:55] possibly So we chose one second
[6:26:59] over which then we left like a
[6:27:00] little strip on the side along
[6:27:03] Charles Creek and at the creek
[6:27:04] was a lot cleaner, a lot nicer.
[6:27:05] I mean you can make that into
[6:27:06] some kind of little beach kind
[6:27:08] of thing but it's a really
[6:27:10] dirty water so.
[6:27:10] And if the recycle center does
[6:27:13] move out and the so be chosen
[6:27:16] to move in, that's a huge whole
[6:27:19] plot of land for a park that
[6:27:21] had a nice and everything.
[6:27:22] That would be a lot of fun.
[6:27:24] And couple of more that you
[6:27:27] measured did not pass but I saw
[6:27:29] advertised as 5000 to 5000 but
[6:27:31] on the values 8000.
[6:27:34] Thank you.
[6:27:34] That does conclude your time.
[6:27:37] Terry Best Terry Best District
[6:27:37] three.
[6:27:44] Please stop allowing special
[6:27:47] interest to write laws that
[6:27:49] create and strengthen
[6:27:50] monopolies.
[6:27:52] Stop doing the bidding of rich
[6:27:54] white men to fund your future
[6:27:56] political endeavors.
[6:27:58] Stop allowing special interests
[6:28:00] using labor to attack those
[6:28:03] less fortunate.
[6:28:04] This nonsense theme here is
[6:28:07] precursory support for your
[6:28:09] 2028 mayor campaign and it
[6:28:12] looks ugly.
[6:28:13] Is that the look you want
[6:28:14] further marginalize vulnerable
[6:28:16] people?
[6:28:18] Again, shame on you MR. Trump.
[6:28:23] You.
[6:28:24] >> Thank you.
[6:28:25] That does conclude in-person
[6:28:28] public comment.
[6:28:28] I have started the five minute
[6:28:29] timer in council chambers.
[6:28:31] We will now turn to the virtual
[6:28:33] queue in which there are seven
[6:28:35] participants requesting to
[6:28:37] speak.
[6:28:37] We'll begin with Tyrion Skelly.
[6:28:39] Please begin.
[6:28:44] Good evening San Diego City
[6:28:45] Council Chair.
[6:28:46] My name is Scully and I work
[6:28:49] with my planning group on good
[6:28:50] public health and safety
[6:28:51] policies and land use
[6:28:53] decisions.
[6:28:53] Where I live has windy
[6:28:56] sometimes rocky roads,
[6:28:57] overgrown foliage and some
[6:28:59] roads reported that at times
[6:29:01] and dangerous when it rains or
[6:29:03] is windy as it's been in
[6:29:05] the last couple of days.
[6:29:07] JUNE is Brain Awareness Month
[6:29:09] and I'd like to talk about
[6:29:10] the dangers of marijuana and
[6:29:12] alcohol impaired drivers.
[6:29:14] This is a situation we know
[6:29:15] well in our family oriented
[6:29:17] neighborhoods with our perilous
[6:29:18] roadways.
[6:29:19] Recently the Journal of
[6:29:21] Adolescent Health article wrote
[6:29:23] that marijuana policies
[6:29:25] decisions must acknowledge that
[6:29:28] access access to an
[6:29:29] intoxicating substance that
[6:29:31] appeals to young people will
[6:29:33] end up causing harm No more.
[6:29:35] So then when we drive
[6:29:37] the tribute again describe
[6:29:38] the conditions of our roadways
[6:29:40] and the delays to fix them.
[6:29:42] I would like to respectfully
[6:29:44] suggest that damaged roadways
[6:29:46] combined with drug impaired
[6:29:48] driving is one more lawsuit
[6:29:51] about to happen?
[6:29:53] At least there is one thing you
[6:29:55] could do to mitigate that has
[6:29:56] been contributing to
[6:29:57] the dangerous the dangerous use
[6:30:00] of can and cannabis removing
[6:30:02] enticing and distracting
[6:30:04] marijuana billboards from our
[6:30:06] roadways.
[6:30:07] Summer 26 would be the perfect
[6:30:10] time for policies to happen
[6:30:11] that would ban marijuana from
[6:30:13] our neighborhood roadways.
[6:30:15] Thank you for hearing my
[6:30:16] concerns this evening.
[6:30:19] Thank you.
[6:30:20] Next up Peggy Walker.
[6:30:21] Please begin.
[6:30:25] Thank you.
[6:30:26] Council members Food and gas
[6:30:29] prices MAY be high today but
[6:30:32] drugs like high potency
[6:30:33] marijuana have never been more
[6:30:35] affordable or available And
[6:30:37] that's reflected in today's
[6:30:39] marijuana delivery item
[6:30:40] addressed earlier.
[6:30:43] In a society seeking
[6:30:44] the convenience of home
[6:30:46] delivery for just about
[6:30:47] everything that item shows
[6:30:50] psychotropic drug consumers are
[6:30:52] no exception.
[6:30:52] And the upshot of that is that
[6:30:55] a society where people can get
[6:30:57] high so easily it's also less
[6:31:00] healthy and that's reasonable.
[6:31:02] That truth was put forth in a
[6:31:04] recent New York Times article
[6:31:06] headlined It Shouldn't Be This
[6:31:08] Easy to Get High And so many of
[6:31:11] us parents agree.
[6:31:13] Citing the fact that 48 million
[6:31:14] Americans are addicted to an
[6:31:16] intoxicant like marijuana,
[6:31:18] the Times suggests we should be
[6:31:20] making it easier for people to
[6:31:22] get help rather than get high.
[6:31:25] A straightforward way to curb a
[6:31:29] particularly uptick in use and
[6:31:30] its outcomes of poor physical
[6:31:32] and mental health and
[6:31:33] addiction.
[6:31:36] The proposals it's higher
[6:31:37] taxation on marijuana reasoning
[6:31:40] that people sicker less when
[6:31:41] something's more costly.
[6:31:44] With that in mind I ask your
[6:31:46] consideration of increased
[6:31:48] taxes for all marijuana
[6:31:49] products.
[6:31:50] However results are delivered
[6:31:53] and more transparent reporting
[6:31:55] of how much in taxes for
[6:31:58] marijuana is being collected
[6:32:01] and transfer nc and how they're
[6:32:02] being used by the city.
[6:32:04] Thank you for that
[6:32:05] consideration.
[6:32:09] Thank you.
[6:32:10] Next up is Judith Strain.
[6:32:12] Please begin.
[6:32:15] >> Good evening San Diego City
[6:32:16] Council.
[6:32:17] I appreciate that you've stated
[6:32:18] that doesn't go unnoticed by
[6:32:20] the public when you make those
[6:32:21] sorts of sacrifices.
[6:32:23] I want to speak to a
[6:32:24] terminology that we're seeing
[6:32:25] in public health more and more
[6:32:27] and that is called gas station
[6:32:30] heroin.
[6:32:31] It's kind of used as a catchall
[6:32:32] terminology for gas station
[6:32:35] intoxicants but we now see
[6:32:36] those products still available
[6:32:38] to our young people.
[6:32:40] They include in their often
[6:32:42] sort of spotlight kratom.
[6:32:44] They're also including what's
[6:32:46] called magic mushrooms not I'm
[6:32:48] sorry nitrous oxide and other
[6:32:52] products that contain high thc
[6:32:56] in hiding under cbd products.
[6:32:58] I just mention it because
[6:33:00] the terminology is getting used
[6:33:03] more and more about where our
[6:33:05] children buy these items at gas
[6:33:08] stations which right at the top
[6:33:08] of the list and the number of
[6:33:10] gas stations in the city of San
[6:33:12] Diego.
[6:33:12] One can only guess And if we
[6:33:14] were to enforce the laws
[6:33:16] against these products here in
[6:33:18] our city, just think of
[6:33:19] the amount of money that we
[6:33:20] could bring in.
[6:33:22] So as you hear the terminology
[6:33:23] gas station heroin and realize
[6:33:26] that they're talking about all
[6:33:27] the intoxicants that are now
[6:33:29] portable at gas stations, I
[6:33:31] think what we could do to at
[6:33:33] least stop it by enforcement
[6:33:35] and gather up from them they
[6:33:39] find that come with it.
[6:33:40] Boy, it could be a double win
[6:33:42] for everybody.
[6:33:43] >> Thank you.
[6:33:46] >> Please note that the five
[6:33:47] minute timer has concluded with
[6:33:49] four speakers left in
[6:33:51] the queue.
[6:33:51] No other speakers will be taken
[6:33:52] at this time.
[6:33:55] Next up Phyllis.
[6:33:57] Please begin.
[6:34:04] Phyllis, please On the air.
[6:34:14] I can assure you Phyllis I can
[6:34:26] on mute for you.
[6:34:26] We're going to move on.
[6:34:32] Okay.
[6:34:33] Next up, Becky Wrap.
[6:34:45] Please begin.
[6:34:45] Good evening.
[6:34:46] I need a second rapid increase
[6:34:50] in my concerns about
[6:34:51] transparency and
[6:34:52] accountability.
[6:34:53] In San Diego, the marijuana
[6:34:54] marijuana permitting program
[6:34:57] almost seven years ago,
[6:34:58] the rich Bernardo community
[6:35:00] engaged extensively in
[6:35:02] the public process for
[6:35:03] the original marijuana
[6:35:05] application.
[6:35:06] Residents attended hearings,
[6:35:07] submitted written comments and
[6:35:09] with strong concern about this
[6:35:11] being a pot shop in their
[6:35:13] neighborhood.
[6:35:14] But what has happened since
[6:35:15] that approval is basically
[6:35:17] invisible to the public.
[6:35:19] That original permit has now
[6:35:21] changed hands multiple times.
[6:35:22] The operator that the community
[6:35:24] initially evaluated is no
[6:35:26] longer the operator today.
[6:35:28] Ownership has shifted through
[6:35:29] acquisitions and corporate
[6:35:30] transactions and now
[6:35:32] the business is associated with
[6:35:33] a brand called Lake House.
[6:35:36] Residents were never notified
[6:35:37] of these changes.
[6:35:38] There were no public hearings,
[6:35:39] no neighborhood notices and no
[6:35:41] requirement for the city to
[6:35:42] explain who ultimately controls
[6:35:43] these permits.
[6:35:45] The community was fully engaged
[6:35:46] in the original decision but it
[6:35:49] has been in the dark for years
[6:35:51] since.
[6:35:51] That raises a transparency
[6:35:53] question.
[6:35:54] If public input is required to
[6:35:56] approve a pot shop, why is
[6:35:58] there no transparency when that
[6:36:00] same permit is sold or
[6:36:01] transferred to an entirely
[6:36:03] different company multiple
[6:36:05] times?
[6:36:06] The operator behind the permit
[6:36:08] is not a minor detail.
[6:36:10] It speaks to accountability,
[6:36:12] business practices and
[6:36:13] the enforcement history.
[6:36:14] It also raises concerns about
[6:36:16] branding and public perception
[6:36:19] and the like.
[6:36:20] The House does not communicate
[6:36:22] to the public that this
[6:36:23] business will be selling highly
[6:36:25] intoxicating products.
[6:36:27] Rather the message it sends is
[6:36:29] that our being now has a new
[6:36:30] bakery in town.
[6:36:32] This is unacceptable and
[6:36:33] communities deserve to know who
[6:36:35] is operating in their
[6:36:36] neighborhoods not just at
[6:36:38] the moment of approval but
[6:36:39] throughout the entire life of a
[6:36:41] permit.
[6:36:42] Thank you.
[6:36:44] Thank you.
[6:36:46] Next, John Elway.
[6:36:48] Please begin.
[6:36:53] Hi John.
[6:36:54] You have lived experience
[6:36:55] advisors so my team and I went
[6:36:57] through all the press articles
[6:36:59] and were in attendance or
[6:37:02] listening to the majority of
[6:37:04] the budget meetings and we
[6:37:08] started to find out that
[6:37:09] the city is not only funding
[6:37:12] the partial operation over at
[6:37:15] the new Good data center but
[6:37:18] that you are licensing it
[6:37:20] meaning that nobody could go
[6:37:21] ahead and or and fill in
[6:37:23] the money or or move in and
[6:37:27] operate that separately from
[6:37:29] the existing provider.
[6:37:31] I can't believe after all
[6:37:34] the work we've done building
[6:37:35] relationships that nobody had
[6:37:36] the courtesy to say that Well
[6:37:39] actually I probably should
[6:37:40] believe it because obviously it
[6:37:43] was hidden from the public.
[6:37:45] The fact that you were taking
[6:37:46] away the only place that
[6:37:48] homeless people could go in
[6:37:50] the entire city and not be
[6:37:53] addressed at least from 9 to 5
[6:37:55] for a few days a week.
[6:37:57] I'd like to understand how this
[6:38:00] decision occurred and was that
[6:38:02] included in the budget
[6:38:03] resolution?
[6:38:05] >> Thank you.
[6:38:08] Thank you.
[6:38:09] Next our last caller is caller
[6:38:12] with the last four digits 8700
[6:38:15] please begin.
[6:38:20] Thank you.
[6:38:22] First of all, Joy Senator a
[6:38:24] first of all, a big thank you
[6:38:26] and five stars for
[6:38:28] the performance by our deputy
[6:38:31] city clerk.
[6:38:33] Thank you so much And the next
[6:38:39] PRESIDENT For your humor was
[6:38:40] present today.
[6:38:42] Thank you.
[6:38:43] Thank you.
[6:38:43] I really enjoyed that.
[6:38:45] And then a request from MR.
[6:38:48] Stump.
[6:38:49] I'm wondering if you could
[6:38:51] during the public comment give
[6:38:53] the public his nine step plan
[6:38:56] for fda and that sounds
[6:38:59] interesting.
[6:39:01] Next I want to speak to
[6:39:03] the gentleman who used the word
[6:39:07] union bust and I felt his anger
[6:39:10] in those words.
[6:39:14] I respect that anger.
[6:39:18] Next, I love the boldness and
[6:39:21] the fight that was present in
[6:39:23] the chamber today.
[6:39:24] Did you feel the beautiful
[6:39:27] tapestry of all the people to
[6:39:31] be There was a little bit like
[6:39:36] what we feel when we say one
[6:39:38] people, one family, one San
[6:39:41] Diego I'm going to get to this
[6:39:42] tomorrow.
[6:39:43] Look forward to that.
[6:39:45] But to all.
[6:39:48] Thank you.
[6:39:48] This concludes lunch and
[6:39:49] the public comment.
[6:39:51] All right.
[6:39:51] You can catch me at The Late
[6:39:53] Show at the Comedy Club later
[6:39:54] tonight.
[6:39:54] With that, does the city
[6:39:56] attorney have anything to
[6:39:58] report out in closed session?
[6:40:02] There is nothing to report.
[6:40:03] All right.
[6:40:03] Thank you.
[6:40:05] With that we will now turn
[6:40:05] counsel to the regularly
[6:40:07] scheduled council meeting
[6:40:07] tomorrow, Tuesday, JUNE 23rd,
[6:40:08] 2026 at 10 A.M. Or shortly
[6:40:08] thereafter.