Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
The times in this transcript were moved to match the video, using the meeting's own audio. The text is the source's captions, unchanged; the source times are kept in the "sourced" version.
[3:04]
the.
[3:04]
>> All right.
[3:05]
Good morning And I will now
[3:05]
call the city council meeting
[3:06]
on Monday, JUNE 29th, 2026 to
[3:09]
order Clerk please call
[3:10]
the roll.
[3:10]
Thank you.
[3:11]
Council PRESIDENT Council
[3:12]
member Campbell Council Member
[3:14]
Whitburn Council Member Foster
[3:17]
Council Member Von Wilpert
[3:20]
Council PRESIDENT Pro Timely I
[3:27]
Apologies Council Member
[3:27]
Campion here Council Member
[3:28]
Moreno Council Member Ellen
[3:31]
Rivera and Council PRESIDENT
[3:32]
LaCava present also attending
[3:36]
the meeting our city Attorney
[3:37]
Heather Ferber, independent
[3:38]
budget analyst Charles Monaco
[3:40]
and myself your city Clerk
[3:41]
Diana Fuentes.
[3:42]
Thank you Council PRESIDENT All
[3:43]
right, thank you.
[3:44]
A quorum is now present.
[3:45]
We will begin this morning with
[3:46]
an invocation by Clark Winters
[3:48]
followed with
[3:49]
the acknowledgment and
[3:50]
the Pledge of Allegiance led by
[3:51]
Council PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee
[3:57]
Grant.
[3:57]
Those who hold office in this
[3:59]
city, the spirit of wisdom,
[4:01]
charity and justice that was
[4:03]
steadfast purpose.
[4:04]
They MAY faithfully serve in
[4:05]
their offices to promote
[4:06]
the well-being of all people.
[4:09]
>> We respectfully acknowledge
[4:11]
the nation or the original
[4:12]
inhabitants of the Unceded land
[4:14]
Now known as San Diego.
[4:15]
Despite enduring the horrors of
[4:17]
genocide and colonization,
[4:17]
the community spirit remains
[4:18]
and broken.
[4:20]
We honor the resilience of
[4:21]
their ancestors who fought to
[4:22]
protect their culture and land.
[4:24]
Today they carry their legacy
[4:25]
forward ensuring that their
[4:27]
traditions continue to thrive
[4:28]
in gratitude and strength.
[4:30]
We stand with committed nation
[4:31]
connected to our past and
[4:33]
committed to a thriving future.
[4:35]
Please raise a flag and join me
[4:37]
in the Pledge of Allegiance But
[4:38]
begin I pledge allegiance to
[4:41]
the flag of the United States
[4:43]
of America and to the Republic
[4:45]
for which it stands one nation
[4:47]
under GOD, indivisible with
[4:56]
liberty and justice for all.
[4:56]
>> And with that, Clark, please
[4:58]
go over how the public can
[4:59]
offer their testimony.
[5:00]
Thank you.
[5:00]
Council PRESIDENT I'd like to
[5:01]
highlight the slide on
[5:02]
the screen that reviews how
[5:03]
the public can offer their
[5:04]
public testimony during today's
[5:05]
meeting.
[5:06]
If you are located in person
[5:07]
please complete the speaker
[5:08]
slip.
[5:09]
Please note that no further
[5:11]
in-person testimony will be
[5:11]
taken once the Council begins
[5:12]
virtual testimony for a better
[5:14]
meeting management purposes
[5:15]
each speaker will have one
[5:16]
minute per item per person.
[5:18]
If you're joining us remotely
[5:19]
please be sure to raise your
[5:20]
hand now for closed session
[5:21]
items by pressing Star nine or
[5:23]
the raise your hand icon.
[5:24]
>> Thank you Council PRESIDENT.
[5:25]
All right.
[5:26]
Thank you.
[5:26]
With that please read
[5:27]
the closed session item into
[5:28]
the record.
[5:29]
Conference with Labor
[5:30]
Negotiators pursuant to
[5:31]
California Government Code
[5:32]
Section 54957.661 City
[5:36]
Designated Management Team
[5:37]
representatives.
[5:39]
>> All right.
[5:40]
And with that please proceed
[5:41]
with public comment.
[5:42]
There is no public comment here
[5:45]
in council chambers going to
[5:45]
those participating remotely.
[5:47]
Blair Beckman, if you can
[5:48]
please limit.
[5:49]
There is one item in the closed
[5:53]
session so you'll have one
[5:54]
minute.
[5:54]
>> Please proceed.
[5:56]
Hi.
[5:56]
Thank you.
[5:57]
Blair Bateman.
[5:58]
At the end of JUNE everyone I
[6:03]
speak to is a JUNE.
[6:04]
I wanted to comment with this
[6:05]
kind of item and the many Union
[6:08]
City government union worker
[6:10]
groups involved with this item
[6:10]
.
[6:12]
It usually signifies some sort
[6:14]
of labor talk but I mean I
[6:16]
guess for this item you're
[6:17]
going to speak specifically to
[6:18]
police actions working with
[6:20]
the police review Commission.
[6:23]
Thanks and good luck.
[6:24]
What You can be decided
[6:25]
together.
[6:25]
We are really trying to build a
[6:27]
future of the police review
[6:30]
body as cold and we keep
[6:34]
sputtering a bit.
[6:35]
I keep praying that the powers
[6:38]
that be in San Diego can be of
[6:42]
some help that you know, I
[6:43]
think we're trying to reach out
[6:44]
and develop a relationship with
[6:47]
esdp.
[6:48]
Good luck with that can mean
[6:49]
and what you talk about and how
[6:51]
it can be an accountable
[6:52]
process for all of us and that
[6:54]
we want to trust each other and
[6:56]
what we talk and work on and
[6:57]
work towards in the street.
[7:01]
That does conclude your time.
[7:03]
8700 If you can please unmute.
[7:06]
There's one item on the agenda
[7:07]
You'll have a minute.
[7:08]
Please proceed.
[7:11]
Oh excuse me Joy.
[7:12]
It's an item.
[7:14]
This is my opinion.
[7:16]
I find it interesting that
[7:19]
the sd pd wants less
[7:21]
surveillance use of
[7:23]
miscellaneous and the public c
[7:26]
p p wants more surveillance use
[7:29]
of investigations.
[7:31]
Therefore in labor negotiations
[7:34]
on proposed operating
[7:36]
procedures the balance
[7:39]
the sweet spot will be what is
[7:42]
enough Investigating and more
[7:45]
is enough Miscellaneous This
[7:47]
will build more trust on
[7:50]
the public officer definition I
[7:53]
am guided by Article b of
[7:56]
the Charter Section 41.2 So
[8:00]
I'll say this It's City Council
[8:03]
call.
[8:04]
Thank you for listening.
[8:05]
It's going to be a beautiful
[8:06]
day and a beautiful week.
[8:07]
Love you all.
[8:08]
>> Thank you.
[8:09]
That does conclude public
[8:10]
comment on this closed session
[8:12]
agenda.
[8:13]
>> All right.
[8:13]
Thank you, city Clerk.
[8:14]
And with that we will now
[8:15]
recess in the closed session
[8:16]
and reconvene council today at
[14:43]
the.
[14:43]
>> All right.
[14:43]
Good afternoon.
[14:44]
I will now reconvene the city
[14:45]
council meeting on Monday, JUNE
[14:46]
29th, 2026.
[14:48]
Clerk Please call the roll.
[14:50]
Thank you.
[14:50]
Council PRESIDENT Council
[14:51]
Member Campbell Council Member
[14:54]
Whitburn Council Member Foster
[14:59]
Council Member Von Millburn
[15:01]
Council PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee.
[15:02]
Council Member Can you hear
[15:07]
Council Member present Council
[15:08]
Member Ella Rivera and Council
[15:11]
PRESIDENT Look I also thank
[15:14]
the meeting our Assistant City
[15:14]
Attorney Leslie Fitzgerald,
[15:16]
independent budget analyst
[15:17]
Charles Monica and myself your
[15:19]
city Clerk Diana Fuentes.
[15:20]
Thank you Council PRESIDENT All
[15:22]
right, thank you.
[15:22]
A quorum is now present.
[15:24]
So let's start off by asking is
[15:26]
there any comments from
[15:27]
the mayor's office?
[15:30]
Council members So the attorney
[15:30]
independent journalist or city
[15:31]
clerk I don't see anything.
[15:33]
We'll move right along.
[15:34]
So please go over how
[15:35]
the public can offer their
[15:37]
testimony.
[15:38]
Thank you.
[15:38]
Council PRESIDENT I'd like to
[15:39]
highlight the slide on
[15:40]
the screen that reviews how
[15:41]
the public can offer their
[15:41]
public testimony during this
[15:43]
afternoon's meeting.
[15:45]
The order can be found on
[15:46]
the agenda summary found online
[15:47]
or at the table in the back of
[15:49]
the room.
[15:49]
If you are in person please
[15:50]
complete the speaker slip
[15:51]
located at the entrance of
[15:52]
chambers and bring it to
[15:54]
the front of the room into
[15:55]
the clear box.
[15:56]
Council ambassadors are
[15:57]
available near the entrance of
[15:59]
chambers and can assist with
[16:00]
questions and speakers Lips No
[16:02]
for the person No further
[16:04]
in-person testimony will be
[16:05]
taken once the council begins
[16:07]
Virtual testimony.
[16:08]
Thank you Council PRESIDENT All
[16:09]
right.
[16:10]
Thank you for that.
[16:10]
And as you slowly make your way
[16:13]
down we'll have our deputy
[16:15]
clerk Please introduce item or
[16:17]
one item As for one.
[16:20]
Information guide on group
[16:21]
participation updates and
[16:23]
council determination of
[16:24]
community engagement efforts.
[16:27]
>> All right.
[16:30]
So it looks like you're settled
[16:30]
in.
[16:31]
Please enter your yourself for
[16:32]
the record and let us know what
[16:33]
time you need for your
[16:34]
presentation.
[16:35]
Thank you.
[16:35]
Council PRESIDENT.
[16:36]
Good afternoon Council
[16:37]
PRESIDENT And members of
[16:38]
the city council as well as
[16:40]
those joining me here in-person
[16:42]
and online.
[16:43]
My name is Deanna Fuentes and I
[16:44]
am your city clerk.
[16:46]
I will need ten minutes for my
[16:48]
presentation.
[16:49]
All right.
[16:49]
When you're ready.
[16:50]
I'm pleased to present an
[16:52]
overview of the recent
[16:53]
initiatives aimed at expanding
[16:54]
access to local government and
[16:56]
compliance with sb 7o7 which
[16:59]
we've all heard a lot about
[17:01]
today We are reviewing ongoing
[17:02]
proactive efforts to engage
[17:04]
communities that do not
[17:06]
traditionally participate in
[17:07]
our public meetings.
[17:08]
And our core goal is to remove
[17:11]
barriers so that every San
[17:13]
Diego feels empowered to have
[17:14]
their voice heard in this
[17:16]
chamber.
[17:17]
At the heart of this initiative
[17:19]
is our department's mission to
[17:21]
provide accurate information
[17:22]
and maximize public access to
[17:24]
municipal government.
[17:26]
But we know traditional
[17:27]
notification methods don't work
[17:29]
for everyone, especially
[17:30]
historically underserved
[17:32]
populations.
[17:33]
To break those barriers down we
[17:35]
didn't just push information
[17:36]
out.
[17:36]
We went out into the community
[17:38]
to listen.
[17:39]
We conducted four public
[17:40]
listening sessions across
[17:42]
districts one, seven and eight
[17:44]
alongside a citywide survey
[17:45]
that ran from OCTOBER 2025
[17:47]
through MARCH 2026.
[17:50]
We also engage with residents
[17:51]
at community events and
[17:53]
meetings in districts three,
[17:54]
four, eight and nine.
[17:56]
Now what did our residents tell
[17:57]
us?
[17:58]
Their feedback fell into clear
[18:00]
themes They want simpler
[18:01]
website navigation more visible
[18:03]
public comment links plain
[18:06]
language summaries of our
[18:07]
complex agendas and expanded
[18:09]
translation services.
[18:12]
They also noted that a simple
[18:13]
lack of awareness and
[18:14]
scheduling conflicts often
[18:16]
stand in their way.
[18:18]
The direct community feedback
[18:19]
is what helped shape some of
[18:21]
the operational improvements we
[18:22]
are presenting today.
[18:25]
So we took that feedback and
[18:27]
immediately translated it into
[18:29]
action on the language and
[18:30]
digital access front.
[18:32]
Thanks to Panda's web team we
[18:34]
have updated our website to be
[18:37]
week 2.1 compliant for better
[18:38]
ada accessibility.
[18:40]
We also revamped our How to
[18:42]
Participate web page making
[18:43]
critical information available
[18:46]
and not just our primary
[18:47]
alternative languages but
[18:49]
thanks to our city's new auto
[18:52]
translation 22 languages
[18:53]
overall.
[18:54]
You will now see the English
[18:56]
and Spanish language agendas
[18:57]
featured prominently on the San
[18:59]
Diego Doc website as well.
[19:01]
Near the top we have
[19:03]
streamlined our agenda
[19:05]
formatting using plain language
[19:07]
principles and even added a
[19:08]
dedicated legislative glossary
[19:10]
directly onto the council
[19:12]
agenda.
[19:12]
So government jargon isn't a
[19:14]
barrier to participation.
[19:16]
Physically we've distributed
[19:18]
education materials to nearly
[19:20]
200 neighborhood locations over
[19:23]
200 neighborhood locations
[19:25]
including libraries or
[19:27]
recreation centers, cultural
[19:29]
markets and faith based
[19:30]
organizations and other
[19:32]
community hubs such as
[19:33]
laundromats and latrines across
[19:35]
all nine districts.
[19:38]
And looking ahead to JULY or
[19:39]
just next week's agenda,
[19:41]
the council PRESIDENT Is
[19:42]
launching anticipated time
[19:43]
allotments on the agenda to
[19:45]
help residents better plan
[19:47]
their participated around their
[19:47]
participation around busy
[19:50]
schedules.
[19:51]
And we are officially launching
[19:53]
our new organized presentation
[19:55]
process on JULY 1st as adopted
[19:57]
by the city Council.
[20:00]
So what is an organized
[20:01]
presentation?
[20:02]
Let's dive into that new tool.
[20:04]
This is an equity improvement
[20:06]
adopted by the City Council to
[20:08]
empower community groups to be
[20:10]
income and to be in compliance
[20:11]
with sb 707.
[20:13]
Essentially an organized
[20:14]
presentation allows a
[20:16]
coordinated group of two or
[20:17]
more individuals to share a
[20:19]
unified position to speak
[20:21]
collectively or choose a lead
[20:23]
speaker for an allocated block
[20:25]
of time during a meeting.
[20:26]
This applies especially
[20:28]
specifically to discussion or
[20:30]
informational items listed on
[20:33]
our agenda.
[20:34]
This replaces the old
[20:35]
traditional practice of seating
[20:37]
time which was restricted
[20:39]
exclusively to those who could
[20:41]
show up in person.
[20:42]
This new format equitably
[20:46]
extends the exact same
[20:47]
collective presentation
[20:49]
opportunity and the ability to
[20:51]
share PowerPoint presentations
[20:52]
or other ab two hour online and
[20:56]
virtual participants.
[20:57]
Leveling the playing field for
[20:59]
working families or homebound
[21:01]
residents.
[21:03]
We've designed the digital
[21:05]
submission framework to be as
[21:06]
intuitive and streamlined as
[21:08]
possible.
[21:08]
It breaks down into three
[21:10]
simple steps for the community.
[21:12]
Step one is to review
[21:14]
the agenda.
[21:14]
Groups must identify
[21:16]
the specific item number or
[21:17]
numbers that matter to them and
[21:19]
look over the accompanying
[21:20]
staff reports and allocated
[21:22]
time per person for that item
[21:25]
that is listed on the agenda.
[21:26]
Step two is to submit
[21:28]
the online sign up web form.
[21:30]
The group's designated lead
[21:32]
presenter can fill out the form
[21:34]
at San diego.Gov/presentation.
[21:37]
This must be done at least 24
[21:39]
hours in advance of
[21:40]
the scheduled meeting so our
[21:42]
staff can verify the details.
[21:44]
Step three is to submit
[21:46]
materials if the group wants to
[21:48]
use visual or audio aids like a
[21:50]
PowerPoint presentation.
[21:51]
They can upload them right
[21:52]
along with the sign up form or
[21:54]
use a follow up link emailed to
[21:56]
them at sign up.
[21:57]
They must submit them no later
[21:59]
than two hours before
[22:01]
the meeting starts.
[22:02]
So for city council meetings
[22:03]
that would be Monday and
[22:06]
Tuesday depending on when
[22:08]
the item is scheduled for.
[22:11]
To ensure that a seamless user
[22:15]
experience there is a seamless
[22:17]
user experience we've
[22:18]
integrated these tools right
[22:20]
into the active areas of
[22:22]
the city's existing web portal.
[22:23]
When residents visit the main
[22:25]
page San diego.Gov the Council
[22:28]
Agenda portal or the City
[22:30]
Clerk's Web page such as are
[22:32]
main San Diego slash City Clerk
[22:34]
or San Diego slash L.A. Or
[22:37]
the legislative calendar you'll
[22:39]
be able to see it prominently
[22:40]
displayed and updated headers
[22:42]
with direct links to public
[22:45]
comment and organize
[22:46]
presentations.
[22:47]
We have also placed comment
[22:48]
button public comment buttons
[22:51]
and clear links to
[22:52]
the dedicated group
[22:53]
presentations portal.
[22:54]
Right alongside the standard
[22:56]
individual comment options this
[22:58]
means the community member
[22:59]
doesn't have to hunt their
[23:00]
pages of text just to figure
[23:02]
out how to participate.
[23:04]
The link is also going to be on
[23:06]
the agenda just as public
[23:07]
comment is today when the lead
[23:11]
presenter clicks through to San
[23:13]
Diego Taco presentation.
[23:14]
They are brought to this
[23:16]
dedicated sign up interface.
[23:17]
The system prompts them to
[23:20]
select the meet the specific
[23:22]
meeting body which can be
[23:24]
the city council meeting or any
[23:26]
of the committee agendas.
[23:28]
The system then prompts them to
[23:30]
select the specific meeting
[23:33]
date which I'll just give Kevin
[23:36]
a moment to bring up the actual
[23:38]
website.
[23:39]
Here it is.
[23:39]
So you would see meeting body
[23:43]
then click the calendar date
[23:45]
and then input the exact agenda
[23:49]
item number.
[23:49]
You can also input the agenda
[23:52]
item name so that they can give
[23:54]
us a clue as to what item you
[23:56]
are.
[23:56]
If sometimes the item number
[23:58]
gets missed input and it
[24:01]
further has them read and check
[24:03]
the acknowledgments to ensure
[24:05]
everyone understands the rules
[24:06]
of the road and we are managing
[24:09]
expectations.
[24:10]
Most importantly this is where
[24:12]
they enter their participant
[24:13]
roster and upload their slides
[24:16]
behind the scenes.
[24:17]
The entire web interface
[24:18]
features full in translations
[24:21]
appear to match our city's
[24:22]
language access goal ensuring
[24:24]
that language is never a
[24:26]
barrier to organizing a group
[24:27]
presentation.
[24:30]
If you can go up to the top up
[24:31]
Kevin and then just show
[24:33]
the language in the language
[24:42]
translation I can choose any
[24:43]
language and it will change
[24:45]
the form to be in any of the 22
[24:47]
languages there.
[24:48]
Thank you.
[24:50]
We'll go back to our PowerPoint
[24:52]
presentation to keep our
[24:57]
council meetings moving
[24:58]
efficiently.
[24:59]
The program relies on the lead
[25:01]
presenter.
[25:01]
This individual serves as
[25:03]
the primary operational link
[25:05]
between the community group or
[25:07]
a group that wishes to present
[25:08]
and the clerk's office.
[25:09]
The lead presenter handles
[25:11]
the logistics.
[25:12]
They make sure everyone in
[25:13]
their group understands
[25:14]
the rules and they sign off on
[25:16]
the formal ignore
[25:17]
acknowledgments during
[25:18]
registration.
[25:18]
When the agenda item is finally
[25:21]
called in the council chambers
[25:22]
it's the lead presenters job to
[25:24]
verify that all listed members
[25:27]
are present and know how to
[25:29]
raise their hands either
[25:30]
physically here in the room or
[25:32]
digitally on the virtual
[25:33]
meeting platform so that
[25:35]
the clerk can accurately verify
[25:37]
attendance just as we do today
[25:39]
with seating time.
[25:40]
Now to ensure fairness and
[25:42]
transparency for all speakers.
[25:43]
There are established clear
[25:45]
structure time rules.
[25:47]
First a group must have a
[25:49]
minimum of two individuals and
[25:51]
the total speaking time for any
[25:52]
single organized presentation
[25:54]
is capped at 15 minutes to
[25:56]
ensure proper meeting
[25:57]
management.
[25:58]
How do we calculate the time?
[26:00]
We multiply the number of
[26:02]
verified present group speakers
[26:04]
by the standard time allocated
[26:06]
per person for that specific
[26:08]
item on the agenda.
[26:09]
For example, if the item allows
[26:12]
two minutes per person and a
[26:14]
group has four members present
[26:15]
they get an eight minute block
[26:18]
to present.
[26:20]
However there is an attendance
[26:21]
rule Every person listed on
[26:24]
the roster must all be present
[26:25]
either physically or virtually
[26:26]
.
[26:27]
When the item is called if a
[26:29]
registered member is missing
[26:31]
that portion of the time is
[26:32]
forfeited and the group's total
[26:34]
speaking block is reduced
[26:36]
accordingly.
[26:37]
Currently all members of a
[26:39]
group must be present in one
[26:40]
attendance format.
[26:41]
If they are present in a mix
[26:43]
format, the way that the lead
[26:45]
presenter is attending is how
[26:47]
the group's time will be
[26:48]
calculated.
[26:49]
For example if there is a group
[26:51]
before but only two are present
[26:53]
in chambers with the lead
[26:54]
presenter the group will only
[26:56]
get three minutes.
[26:57]
The virtual attendee will not
[26:59]
count towards that time
[27:01]
allocation vice versa if
[27:03]
the lead presenter is virtual
[27:04]
and everyone else is present in
[27:06]
chambers none of their time
[27:08]
will go to them unless they
[27:10]
attend virtually.
[27:13]
We do hope to continue to work
[27:15]
through our rfp process for a
[27:16]
new agenda system and zoom to
[27:18]
find a technology solution to
[27:20]
allow for mixed attendance
[27:22]
without meeting disruption in
[27:23]
the future.
[27:25]
Now equity means meeting our
[27:27]
residents in the language they
[27:29]
are most comfortable using as
[27:30]
well.
[27:31]
In strict alignment our equity
[27:32]
objectives all in structures
[27:34]
and win forms from
[27:35]
the organized presentation
[27:36]
process.
[27:36]
Are fully available in
[27:38]
the cities.
[27:39]
Eight Primary Alternative
[27:40]
Languages of Spanish Chinese
[27:42]
Tagalog Vietnamese Arabic,
[27:43]
Korean, Japanese and Laotian.
[27:46]
I will note that the only
[27:47]
required language per sb 707 is
[27:50]
Spanish Such a bad card.
[27:52]
>> We provide full language
[27:54]
support and if anyone
[27:55]
experiences technical glitches
[27:57]
or has a question while
[27:59]
navigating the portal they can
[28:00]
call or email our staff
[28:01]
directly for real time
[28:03]
assistance.
[28:04]
A new program is only effective
[28:07]
if people actually know it
[28:08]
exists.
[28:08]
To get the word out ahead of
[28:11]
the JULY roll out we are
[28:12]
executing a multichannel
[28:13]
outreach campaign.
[28:14]
This includes distributing
[28:16]
physical fliers to community
[28:18]
homes, pushing targeted notices
[28:19]
through diversity email
[28:21]
listservs and launching a
[28:22]
dedicated social media campaign
[28:24]
across all of the city
[28:25]
channels.
[28:26]
We want to ensure that
[28:27]
the community organization
[28:29]
planning groups and grassroot
[28:30]
coalitions is fully informed
[28:32]
and ready to leverage this
[28:34]
tool.
[28:34]
In conclusion, these actions
[28:38]
represent a sustained,
[28:39]
proactive and good faith
[28:41]
commitment to lowering barriers
[28:42]
and ensuring equitable civic
[28:44]
access.
[28:46]
Perfectly aligning with our
[28:47]
city's strategic core principle
[28:49]
of equity and inclusion based
[28:51]
on the extensive community
[28:52]
listening, the technological
[28:54]
and language upgrades and
[28:55]
the deployment of the new
[28:56]
organized presentation tool
[28:58]
staff confidently believe that
[29:01]
city that the city has made
[29:02]
reasonable efforts to efforts
[29:04]
to invite public participation.
[29:06]
Therefore we respectfully
[29:07]
request that the Council adopt
[29:08]
a resolution finding that
[29:10]
the city of San Diego has made
[29:11]
reasonable efforts to encourage
[29:12]
participation from communities
[29:14]
that do not traditionally
[29:15]
engage in public meetings and
[29:17]
direct our office to continue
[29:19]
implementing these vital
[29:21]
outreach initiatives.
[29:22]
I thank you for your time, your
[29:24]
leadership and your partnership
[29:26]
in making local government more
[29:28]
accessible to all San Diegans.
[29:29]
And a special thank you to
[29:31]
the Panda Web team to the Park
[29:33]
and Rec services director Andy
[29:35]
Field and Misty Jones as well
[29:37]
as Christina Beyeler from adb
[29:39]
who have all been engaging with
[29:41]
me to ensure that we get
[29:42]
the word out as well as each
[29:44]
one of your offices as much as
[29:46]
possible.
[29:46]
I'm happy to answer any
[29:47]
questions you MAY have
[29:48]
regarding the report or
[29:50]
the upcoming rollout of
[29:51]
the organized presentation
[29:52]
process.
[29:52]
Thank you Counsel PRESIDENT And
[29:54]
apologies for the overrun.
[29:55]
All right.
[29:56]
Thank you.
[29:57]
City Clerk 20th for
[29:59]
the presentation.
[30:00]
Deputy Clerk Please proceed
[30:01]
with public comment.
[30:02]
Thank you.
[30:03]
Council PRESIDENT We received
[30:04]
one request to speak from an
[30:06]
individual in chambers.
[30:08]
Paul Kruger please come
[30:10]
forward.
[30:11]
You'll have two minutes.
[30:19]
I want to thank you And I had
[30:19]
the time seated by Yvonne
[30:22]
Jones.
[30:23]
>> Yvonne Jones Okay.
[30:25]
You'll have four minutes.
[30:29]
Which one?
[30:30]
>> Uh, thank you.
[30:34]
Um, first let me express my and
[30:36]
other people's appreciation for
[30:39]
all the work that the city
[30:40]
clerk did in making sure that
[30:42]
the council is compliant with
[30:43]
seven seven.
[30:47]
I can tell it was a lot of work
[30:49]
And those of us who participate
[30:52]
in this project appreciate it.
[30:56]
Um, but I wanted to use an
[30:58]
opportunity here to focus again
[31:01]
your attention on
[31:02]
the importance of community
[31:03]
planning groups.
[31:05]
And I do understand why we're
[31:09]
moving forward with this But
[31:11]
you'll hear today on the phone
[31:13]
from Victoria Lou Brousseau
[31:16]
who's chair of the cpc and
[31:17]
she's going to speak with you
[31:19]
again about how crucial a role
[31:23]
community planning groups can
[31:25]
play in this process.
[31:26]
Because one thing we know for
[31:29]
sure is that these new rules
[31:30]
are going to be very
[31:31]
complicated for people to
[31:33]
follow.
[31:33]
And that we have already or you
[31:37]
have already at hand a time
[31:40]
tested five decade old process
[31:42]
of community planning groups
[31:44]
that are prepared, shared and
[31:47]
more than able to give you
[31:50]
information about how members
[31:52]
of that community who you don't
[31:54]
hear from often because
[31:56]
unfortunately they don't have
[31:58]
access to a lot of counsel
[32:00]
offices and are not connected
[32:02]
financially and politically.
[32:05]
I have to say about important
[32:07]
things that are happening in
[32:08]
their neighborhoods.
[32:11]
I know that there has been for
[32:13]
the last five years criticism
[32:15]
of community planning groups
[32:17]
and I would like to just urge
[32:19]
you what I think planning group
[32:22]
members urged from
[32:23]
the beginning which is that way
[32:27]
to improve the process is not
[32:29]
to silence or minimize
[32:30]
community planning groups but
[32:33]
to continue to expand their
[32:35]
representation within
[32:37]
communities by making each
[32:40]
council office responsible or
[32:44]
encouraged to work with
[32:47]
community planning groups to
[32:48]
expand notification of
[32:51]
vacancies, to expand
[32:54]
notification of elections so
[32:56]
that more people participate
[32:59]
and to ensure as we have done
[33:02]
and in several planning groups
[33:04]
that these planning groups
[33:06]
represent the community.
[33:09]
The biggest split of course
[33:10]
would be from those who want to
[33:13]
see pretty much unbridled
[33:15]
development in our in our
[33:17]
residential areas and how they
[33:21]
are contrasted with those who
[33:24]
want to take a more measured
[33:26]
and realistic approach.
[33:28]
And we can encourage those who
[33:32]
are underrepresented if they
[33:34]
are to run for election, to win
[33:37]
election and to give a very
[33:40]
Democratic voice to these
[33:42]
meetings.
[33:44]
So in closing, I would just
[33:45]
urge you to please not forgo
[33:48]
the opportunity to embrace
[33:51]
the constructive work that
[33:53]
community planning groups can
[33:54]
do.
[33:56]
And excuse me to listen to
[33:59]
Victoria when she calls in.
[34:01]
She couldn't be here in person
[34:03]
and I know that coming here in
[34:06]
person and speaking to you and
[34:08]
looking at you does have a bit
[34:10]
more of an impact than a
[34:12]
telephone call.
[34:13]
But hers will only be two
[34:15]
minutes and I appreciate your
[34:18]
attention.
[34:18]
Thank you very much.
[34:20]
>> Thank you.
[34:21]
That does conclude the public
[34:22]
comment hearing Council chamber
[34:23]
is going to those participating
[34:24]
remotely currently have seven
[34:26]
people in the queue.
[34:27]
Kate Callaghan If you can
[34:30]
please unmute.
[34:33]
>> Good afternoon.
[34:35]
When this item came before
[34:37]
the rules Committee several of
[34:38]
us urged that community
[34:39]
planning groups be given a seat
[34:41]
at the table.
[34:42]
Council PRESIDENT LaCava
[34:43]
responded that we were
[34:45]
misunderstood.
[34:45]
Why the council was discussing
[34:48]
community outreach.
[34:49]
There was no misunderstanding.
[34:51]
We rarely have the chance to
[34:53]
point out publicly that
[34:55]
the city has failed a genuine
[34:56]
community engagement.
[34:58]
That's where planning groups
[35:00]
come in.
[35:01]
There are members who are
[35:01]
elected to serve the public
[35:03]
just as all of you were.
[35:05]
For 50 years they have carried
[35:07]
out their mandate to speak for
[35:08]
their communities.
[35:10]
They survived an ugly campaign
[35:12]
by special interest that
[35:14]
questioned their integrity and
[35:15]
their competence.
[35:16]
They emerged stronger.
[35:19]
They continue to represent San
[35:20]
Diegans who are too often
[35:22]
ignored.
[35:23]
If you care about community
[35:25]
engagement please adopt a seat
[35:27]
at the table proposal that
[35:29]
Victoria Brousseau has put
[35:30]
before you.
[35:32]
It is the best way to make sure
[35:33]
that people and communities are
[35:35]
represented and heard and
[35:38]
respected.
[35:39]
Thank you.
[35:41]
Thank you.
[35:41]
Next is 8700 If you can please
[35:43]
unmute.
[35:50]
>> Thank you so much.
[35:52]
I support this resolution on
[35:55]
group participation and
[35:56]
community engagement efforts.
[35:58]
Well there were 15 items in
[36:00]
the backup and the staff report
[36:02]
itself was 12 pages.
[36:04]
What does that tell you?
[36:05]
Great job.
[36:07]
I especially appreciate
[36:09]
the office of the city clerk
[36:11]
Fuentes and the rest of
[36:13]
the team for encouraging
[36:15]
participative participation of
[36:18]
individuals and groups that do
[36:21]
not traditionally participate
[36:23]
in public meetings.
[36:26]
Please speak up and let us hear
[36:29]
your voice.
[36:30]
Is that for me?
[36:31]
I enjoyed hearing your
[36:33]
presentation.
[36:34]
City Clerk 20 For the second
[36:36]
time This is a stellar
[36:38]
initiative and so is your
[36:40]
implementation of it.
[36:42]
I'm so excited about it being
[36:45]
rolled out by the rolling out
[36:47]
on JULY 1st, 2026 with
[36:51]
the first real City Council
[36:54]
meeting on JULY 6th, 2026.
[36:58]
I love the inclusion Inclusion
[37:01]
Public Engagement Guide.
[37:05]
That was a great idea.
[37:07]
Now this is kind of a finishing
[37:09]
paragraph with something else
[37:11]
came up just a few minutes ago
[37:12]
that I want to add to it So
[37:13]
I'll say this first.
[37:15]
Please keep on top of any
[37:17]
additional funding that is
[37:19]
needed over the 2027 budget.
[37:24]
Let's keep this fire burning.
[37:26]
So on the community planning
[37:29]
groups I really haven't looked
[37:32]
at that but I can tell there's
[37:34]
an issue in this passion around
[37:35]
the item including them.
[37:38]
What I just wanted to say is
[37:40]
that I know there's been some
[37:43]
bumpy moments with
[37:44]
the community planning groups
[37:46]
yet I really respect PRESIDENT
[37:51]
Carver's participation you
[37:51]
know, leadership.
[37:52]
He's been very involved with
[37:54]
those groups and he really is
[37:56]
on top of of kind of what's
[37:58]
going on in the future and all
[38:00]
of that.
[38:00]
>> So what I just want your
[38:02]
time has concluded.
[38:03]
John, if you can please unmute
[38:03]
.
[38:10]
>> Hi.
[38:10]
Good afternoon.
[38:11]
Council members.
[38:13]
MISS Congratulations.
[38:14]
This is really amazing work.
[38:16]
It shows a lot of thought.
[38:18]
A lot of the changes that we've
[38:20]
been hoping might be included
[38:21]
in this are really love
[38:24]
the ability to have a group
[38:25]
participate particularly for
[38:27]
those with disabilities who
[38:29]
cannot show up in person.
[38:32]
>> And speaking of which, I was
[38:33]
wondering if there was any
[38:35]
accommodation provided.
[38:36]
I know we give extra time for
[38:38]
folks that have language
[38:40]
barriers or need translation.
[38:43]
I feel that the same courtesy
[38:44]
might want to be extended to
[38:46]
those who have challenges with
[38:48]
speech or speech impediments
[38:50]
that cause them to not be able
[38:53]
to articulate effectively or as
[38:56]
quickly as others.
[38:59]
The other thing I do I'm not
[39:00]
sure if I heard but I would be
[39:02]
nice to read to be able to read
[39:04]
this during neutral position as
[39:05]
opposed to for or against as we
[39:08]
sign in for these things.
[39:10]
I do have one other suggestion
[39:12]
for you but that will take more
[39:14]
time so I'll reach out to you
[39:15]
independently but really great
[39:16]
work.
[39:17]
They're very supportive of
[39:18]
this.
[39:20]
I agree that Thank you Francine
[39:21]
Maxwell if you can please
[39:22]
unmute.
[39:23]
>> There was also the five
[39:24]
minute time where we have five
[39:25]
speakers in the queue.
[39:25]
No additional speakers will be
[39:27]
taken.
[39:28]
>> Francine Maxwell if you can
[39:29]
please.
[39:31]
>> Francine Maxwell
[39:33]
Southeastern San Diego resident
[39:34]
Thank you so much for
[39:35]
the presentation and for
[39:37]
support.
[39:38]
Really want the Council to pay
[39:40]
attention to what the clerk's
[39:41]
office staff does.
[39:43]
You get a glimpse of it but
[39:45]
literally they're not supposed
[39:46]
to work on the weekends with
[39:48]
some of them, do their due
[39:49]
diligence and go ahead and
[39:50]
answer a quick question on
[39:52]
the weekend unlike many of your
[39:53]
offices.
[39:54]
So want to make sure that you
[39:56]
look at the diversity of when
[39:59]
the meetings were very
[40:01]
inclusive.
[40:03]
You did not have to send for
[40:06]
council for someone to consult
[40:07]
from Colorado.
[40:09]
I think we were doing a parking
[40:11]
rack or we were doing something
[40:12]
in water area and we had a
[40:14]
consultant from Colorado.
[40:16]
So I mean literally you have
[40:18]
stars right there in
[40:19]
the building.
[40:20]
I mean some stars are getting
[40:22]
stuck in elevators but they're
[40:23]
still a star.
[40:25]
And again, we want to make sure
[40:27]
that everyone is educated in
[40:30]
and if hopefully the council
[40:32]
people that have newsletters
[40:35]
maybe you'll put a corner
[40:37]
clerk's corner in your
[40:38]
newsletter so that while you're
[40:40]
showing the wonderful events
[40:41]
that you go to the handouts of
[40:44]
resolution and certificates
[40:46]
proclamations that you can help
[40:48]
educate.
[40:49]
Again, education is the key to
[40:52]
everything.
[40:53]
And a Clerks Corner and
[40:55]
everybody's newsletter could
[40:57]
give people insight on how to
[40:59]
work the system, how to
[41:01]
participate more in their city
[41:03]
government because they know
[41:05]
that their voice really counts
[41:07]
and it counts more than just
[41:09]
election season.
[41:10]
So again, thanks to every
[41:12]
person in that works for
[41:14]
the clerk's office.
[41:16]
You are absolutely seen we are
[41:19]
listening to you and we
[41:20]
appreciate your time and your
[41:22]
talent.
[41:23]
Thank you for allowing me to
[41:24]
speak.
[41:25]
Thank you.
[41:26]
Blair Beckman if you can please
[41:27]
unmute.
[41:30]
>> Hi.
[41:32]
Where Beckman are San Diego
[41:33]
Civic Center.
[41:33]
Elevators are starting to
[41:35]
become infamous.
[41:36]
Good luck.
[41:37]
We can fix them elevators soon.
[41:40]
Thanks a lot for this item.
[41:41]
i'm in full agreement with
[41:42]
the public comment.
[41:44]
Stellar was used as a word.
[41:47]
The concept that you are
[41:48]
allowing over 20 plus languages
[41:51]
so people can attend city
[41:53]
council meetings now I was
[41:56]
living in San Diego in 1986
[41:58]
when they created English only
[42:00]
laws that I feel were just
[42:02]
learning to work through San
[42:02]
Diego.
[42:04]
San Jose made really
[42:06]
significant strides in these
[42:08]
sort of efforts in the mid and
[42:09]
the 2015.
[42:11]
You guys are coming through now
[42:13]
San Diego San Jose's practicing
[42:15]
what you're offering now and
[42:16]
thank you immensely.
[42:18]
That means everyone can
[42:19]
participate.
[42:20]
That's an amazing concept we
[42:22]
haven't grasped fully yet.
[42:23]
Good luck.
[42:24]
We can continue to do that.
[42:25]
Thank you for the idea of a
[42:27]
neutral voice to vote to to put
[42:31]
in your speaker card on issues.
[42:32]
I'm totally in favor of that
[42:33]
idea.
[42:35]
I was a bit surprised that, you
[42:37]
know, in working with community
[42:38]
groups a very nice speech
[42:40]
earlier that upon the beginning
[42:42]
public speaker that really
[42:44]
described the importance of
[42:45]
community groups and what our
[42:46]
current community groups are
[42:48]
working towards.
[42:49]
I mean it's a really
[42:50]
participatory process.
[42:52]
It's in our decency while
[42:53]
others have money to accomplish
[42:55]
things, a group of community is
[42:58]
trying to offer ways that
[42:59]
people who don't have
[43:00]
advantages can be a part of
[43:02]
the process and help create our
[43:04]
process.
[43:05]
>> I really hope that can be
[43:06]
better expressed.
[43:08]
It seems like you cut things
[43:09]
short a bit on the Zoom
[43:11]
comments on how to do that Even
[43:12]
better.
[43:13]
Good luck.
[43:14]
You can continue that work and
[43:15]
effort on that on those issues
[43:17]
and San Diego County government
[43:20]
is working on a subcommittee
[43:22]
process They've taken notes
[43:24]
from 707 like the close agenda
[43:26]
item things but they need a bit
[43:29]
of help in how to better
[43:30]
understand its future that
[43:32]
respects privacy.
[43:33]
>> Good luck on those efforts
[43:34]
too.
[43:35]
Thank you Victoria Lorenzo Hey
[43:46]
good afternoon.
[43:46]
Council members Victoria
[43:48]
Brousseau, Chair of the cpc.
[43:49]
First I want to thank Paul for
[43:51]
showing up and giving this
[43:52]
comment since afternoon.
[43:53]
I also want to thank the city
[43:54]
Clerk office for all the great
[43:57]
advancements with
[43:57]
the distributing distributing
[44:00]
information but continue to
[44:01]
encourage the city clerk and
[44:02]
the City council to continue
[44:04]
refining public participation
[44:05]
allowing time to be seated
[44:07]
virtually is a great step
[44:08]
forward.
[44:09]
However, I remain concerned
[44:10]
about the organized
[44:11]
presentation process.
[44:13]
Under the new rules volunteers
[44:14]
must identify speakers gather
[44:16]
commitments to cede time,
[44:18]
collect names and submit those
[44:19]
names in advance.
[44:20]
That adds another level of
[44:22]
coordination for volunteers
[44:23]
that already donate time to
[44:25]
participate.
[44:26]
As for robust public
[44:28]
engagement, I continue to
[44:29]
advocate that the city already
[44:31]
has an established network of
[44:33]
community planning groups made
[44:34]
up of more than 600 elected
[44:36]
volunteers serving San Diego.
[44:38]
If you truly want to strengthen
[44:40]
public engagement, the answer
[44:42]
is to provide with the cpses a
[44:44]
seat at the table and
[44:45]
empowering and promoting
[44:47]
the community elected voices.
[44:48]
This would complement public
[44:50]
comment, not replace it and
[44:53]
provide a predictable way for
[44:54]
organized community voices to
[44:56]
be heard.
[44:57]
As the Planning Department
[44:58]
continues to reduce the role of
[45:01]
CPGs, I urge the City Council
[45:02]
to move in the opposite
[45:03]
direction, strengthen not
[45:06]
diminish the role by formally
[45:08]
providing CPGs and cpc a seat
[45:10]
at the table.
[45:12]
If the city wants stronger
[45:13]
public engagement it should
[45:15]
actively promote community
[45:16]
planning groups as the local
[45:18]
connection between residents
[45:20]
and City Hall.
[45:21]
Not leave each cpg to create
[45:23]
its own public awareness Bpg
[45:26]
and the cpc should be
[45:28]
the city's front door to civic
[45:30]
participation.
[45:32]
Thank you again and I
[45:33]
appreciate the time to speak
[45:35]
with you guys and wish I could
[45:36]
have come down there.
[45:37]
But Scripps Ranches is further
[45:39]
out and takes a lot more time
[45:41]
and a lot more money.
[45:42]
So I speak when I can and I
[45:44]
appreciate you all giving
[45:45]
attention to this matter.
[45:46]
Thanks.
[45:47]
Thank you.
[45:49]
Next is Peggy Walker and then
[45:50]
our final speaker is Natalie
[45:51]
asking Peggy please.
[45:51]
And you.
[45:53]
Thank you.
[45:54]
Good afternoon And thank you
[45:56]
for explaining this process.
[45:58]
All efforts to increase public
[45:59]
participation in the governing
[46:01]
process are good and in
[46:02]
particular allowance for
[46:05]
seeding time for virtual
[46:06]
participants as well as
[46:10]
in-person events.
[46:11]
Solid equity improve allowing
[46:11]
organized virtual presentations
[46:13]
levels the playing field for
[46:15]
all constituents especially
[46:17]
those like myself who observe
[46:19]
and participate in these
[46:21]
meetings from an office finding
[46:23]
it hard to make regular trips
[46:25]
to council chambers and our
[46:27]
mobile society.
[46:28]
Virtual participation deserves
[46:30]
to be recognized as important
[46:32]
as in-person participation.
[46:35]
It has enabled me, for example
[46:37]
and I'm sure others to speak to
[46:39]
issues when I'm not in town or
[46:41]
able to drive downtown.
[46:43]
And finally I attend my
[46:45]
planning group and strongly
[46:46]
support the suggestions earlier
[46:49]
of giving planning groups a
[46:50]
greater seat at the table
[46:52]
including expanding council
[46:54]
member or staff communication
[46:57]
with pages in their districts.
[47:00]
Planning groups are the best
[47:02]
way to strengthen a community
[47:03]
link to the council and they
[47:06]
should be recognized for their
[47:07]
importance.
[47:08]
Thank you.
[47:10]
Thank you.
[47:11]
And our final speaker is
[47:12]
Natalie Raskin.
[47:12]
If you can please unmute and
[47:13]
thank you.
[47:19]
Another thing that I think is
[47:20]
an amazing idea having more
[47:24]
involved and having the ability
[47:24]
.
[47:29]
I think that you're a little
[47:29]
jumbled up here.
[47:30]
You sound a little bit Can you
[47:33]
hear me now?
[47:34]
Yes, that's better.
[47:35]
>> Please proceed.
[47:36]
I'm multitasking.
[47:39]
I think it's it's amazing.
[47:40]
I think having the opportunity
[47:41]
for the community support
[47:45]
involved is the best thing
[47:47]
moving forward in this case.
[47:51]
Feel a little sympathy stomach
[47:51]
for what?
[47:56]
That's what I'm on.
[47:59]
We have to curb that and help
[48:02]
People are also a part of how
[48:05]
we best when we go.
[48:06]
People that forget they are
[48:09]
part of it.
[48:14]
You're cutting out again Not
[48:20]
hear me?
[48:21]
>> You are cutting out again
[48:23]
and we no longer hear you.
[48:31]
I'm sorry.
[48:34]
You can definitely submit
[48:35]
comments to City clerk at San
[48:37]
diego.Gov and those will be
[48:38]
distributed to the council.
[48:40]
But we have lost you.
[48:43]
That does include public
[48:44]
comment here in council
[48:46]
chambers And regarding this
[48:47]
item.
[48:48]
>> All right.
[48:50]
Thank you City Clerk.
[48:52]
This now goes back to
[48:53]
the Council to ratify
[48:55]
the community engagement
[48:56]
process and whether it met
[48:57]
the standards of the 707 In
[49:01]
addition to the extraordinary
[49:03]
training session that the city
[49:04]
clerk gave us on how this new
[49:07]
process will move forward.
[49:09]
So I'll kick things off.
[49:11]
So again, thank you to Clark
[49:13]
Francis and your team for
[49:14]
the work and as well as
[49:15]
the office of the City Attorney
[49:16]
and everybody else that engaged
[49:18]
in this process.
[49:20]
And as a reminder sb 707
[49:21]
requires us to put this in
[49:23]
place by JULY 1st and our very
[49:26]
first council meeting where
[49:27]
we'll be using this new system
[49:28]
will be Monday, JULY sixth.
[49:33]
Sb 7 or 7 has many elements but
[49:34]
for the public the most obvious
[49:35]
will be the changes to
[49:36]
the agenda to comply with
[49:38]
translation requirements and
[49:41]
changes to the public comment
[49:42]
procedures to ensure equal
[49:43]
treatment of in-person and
[49:45]
virtual public commenters.
[49:47]
Virtual public commerce will
[49:48]
now allow seeding of time a
[49:51]
first for the City of San Diego
[49:53]
Sacramento path sb 707 with
[49:56]
good intentions but provided a
[49:58]
very short timeline for
[49:59]
implementation and no
[50:00]
additional resources.
[50:02]
Nevertheless, the City clerk
[50:03]
remain undaunted and was ready
[50:05]
to take up the charge.
[50:07]
And with our current staffing
[50:08]
levels and with technology
[50:09]
currently available in
[50:10]
the marketplace it became clear
[50:12]
that we could not fully
[50:13]
replicate our existing
[50:15]
in-person processes for virtual
[50:17]
participation.
[50:19]
So council had a choice either
[50:20]
eliminate long standing option
[50:22]
of city time during in-person
[50:24]
public comment or reimagine
[50:25]
the process And some
[50:26]
jurisdictions like Encinitas
[50:28]
opted to discontinue seeding
[50:30]
time.
[50:31]
Everyone has limited their own
[50:32]
time and own presentation.
[50:34]
Under my work as Council
[50:36]
PRESIDENT And with
[50:37]
collaboration from City Clerk,
[50:38]
council administration and City
[50:39]
Attorney's Office, we proposed
[50:41]
changes to protect public
[50:42]
participation by reimagining
[50:44]
the process of seeding time.
[50:47]
The changes were tested and
[50:48]
revisited numerous times.
[50:50]
I first brought in Information
[50:52]
Item two Rules Committee in
[50:53]
FEBRUARY with a framework for
[50:54]
these changes.
[50:55]
We listened to feedback from
[50:56]
the public and committee
[50:57]
members and adjusted.
[50:59]
We had originally had different
[51:01]
ideas.
[51:01]
We proposed process only
[51:03]
applying to groups of 5 to 10.
[51:05]
Due to the administrative
[51:06]
burden on the clerk's team
[51:08]
however, with feedback from
[51:09]
Rules Committee and the public
[51:11]
I propose and Council adopted
[51:13]
organize presentation groups
[51:14]
for just two or more people.
[51:17]
Additionally we reduced
[51:18]
the signup time based on public
[51:20]
feedback and I really have to
[51:21]
give thanks to the city clerk
[51:22]
and her team for willingness to
[51:24]
do that.
[51:24]
As you heard in
[51:25]
the presentation, groups can
[51:27]
now sign up 24 hours in advance
[51:29]
of the meeting and provide
[51:30]
their slides or presentation
[51:31]
material if any as late as two
[51:34]
hours before the meeting.
[51:36]
That's a lot of scrambling by
[51:37]
the city clerk's office to
[51:38]
accommodate this further.
[51:41]
Again, based on public feedback
[51:43]
we are keeping the virtual
[51:44]
comment period open for up to
[51:46]
five minutes.
[51:47]
Once in-person comment has
[51:49]
ended in MARCH, Rules Committee
[51:52]
unanimously voted on
[51:53]
the revised proposal and
[51:54]
forwarded to Council
[51:56]
unanimously voted in forwarded
[51:58]
to the Council in APRIL.
[51:59]
Council heard this item on
[52:00]
discussion and also voted
[52:02]
unanimously to support
[52:03]
the changes modifications to
[52:05]
our publicic comment procedures
[52:07]
were done out of a requirement
[52:08]
to comply with state law and
[52:10]
our commitment to preserving
[52:12]
public participation.
[52:14]
This proposal strikes a good
[52:15]
balance between what was
[52:17]
possible with our current
[52:18]
resources and expanding this to
[52:20]
virtual participants.
[52:22]
Under these new procedures
[52:24]
virtual participants can can
[52:25]
now give presentations and as I
[52:29]
mentioned at the onset we will
[52:31]
now put this into practice
[52:32]
after a lot of talk and a lot
[52:34]
of discussion.
[52:35]
Council's JULY 6th hearing will
[52:37]
be the first time we will roll
[52:38]
this out.
[52:40]
>> It MAY all sound a bit
[52:41]
complicated and as you saw
[52:42]
the clerk has put out
[52:43]
information guides and their
[52:44]
office stands ready to help
[52:46]
the public navigate the new
[52:47]
processes.
[52:49]
In closing the council and city
[52:49]
clerk has been a statewide
[52:51]
leader in hosting public
[52:53]
comment both in-person and
[52:55]
virtually And now we're
[52:56]
stepping up to meet the intent
[52:58]
of sb 77 with the resources.
[53:01]
Bottom line we're expanding
[53:02]
opportunities for public
[53:03]
comment and input at our public
[53:06]
hearings.
[53:07]
There MAY be some bumps in
[53:08]
the road but I have no doubt
[53:09]
the clerk's team and council
[53:10]
administration will be up to
[53:12]
the challenge to help us all
[53:13]
through it.
[53:14]
Note They often do as they
[53:16]
always do I should say in every
[53:18]
council and committee hearing.
[53:20]
And so to the comments of a
[53:22]
members of the public, I
[53:23]
certainly appreciate that And
[53:25]
it's important to know that a
[53:27]
seat at the table was not about
[53:28]
public comment.
[53:29]
It was a proposal to have
[53:31]
dedicated time during a council
[53:33]
action.
[53:34]
I think that's a big change
[53:36]
from what our past practices
[53:39]
have been and I wonder about
[53:41]
who we actually limited to.
[53:43]
I was a big believer in
[53:45]
community planning groups.
[53:46]
I'm still a big, big believer
[53:48]
and planning groups as well as
[53:49]
the Community Planners
[53:50]
committee.
[53:51]
But there are so many other
[53:52]
voices that we need to hear
[53:55]
from when we make a decision
[53:57]
and the variety of things that
[53:58]
come across our diocese.
[54:01]
And so we can continue
[54:02]
the conversation about how we
[54:03]
do that.
[54:04]
But I think this is an
[54:05]
important step because I used
[54:07]
to be on the other side of
[54:08]
the dice and I remember how
[54:10]
much time was and how tricky it
[54:12]
was to get people to cede time.
[54:13]
But we see it time and time
[54:15]
again about how it is possible
[54:18]
we're going to roll this out on
[54:20]
JULY 1st for an experience in
[54:22]
JULY 6th and the four meetings
[54:24]
we have in JULY and then we'll
[54:27]
react and possibly pivot.
[54:29]
This is brand new and we know
[54:31]
there MAY be bumps as I said
[54:33]
going forward.
[54:34]
We do appreciate the planning
[54:36]
groups.
[54:36]
I know my colleagues appreciate
[54:38]
the planning groups.
[54:39]
I think we all appreciate
[54:41]
the community planners
[54:41]
committee as well.
[54:43]
Going forward And we want to
[54:45]
hear from them and we want to
[54:46]
hear from every organized group
[54:49]
whether it's neighbors for a
[54:49]
better San Diego live
[54:50]
experience advisors Alliance,
[54:53]
Summit City can you name it
[54:54]
They all have important voices
[54:56]
to contribute to our decision
[54:57]
making process.
[54:59]
And with that I will move
[55:00]
the staff recommendation and
[55:02]
turn it over to my colleagues
[55:05]
for either a second or a
[55:05]
permit.
[55:10]
Councilmember Marino have
[55:12]
second and not seen any other
[55:14]
councilmember mpo.
[55:14]
>> Thank you Council PRESIDENT
[55:15]
Just briefly appreciate
[55:16]
the members of the public who
[55:17]
came in and spoke as they did
[55:18]
in Rules Committee a couple of
[55:19]
days ago and just reiterate my
[55:20]
comments from rules out
[55:22]
continually looking for ways to
[55:24]
improve and increase public
[55:25]
participation.
[55:26]
There's no better person in our
[55:27]
city government who does that
[55:28]
than our city clerk.
[55:28]
They want this.
[55:30]
And I just want to say hearing
[55:32]
them loud and clear and
[55:34]
appreciating the role that
[55:36]
species play and finding a
[55:37]
bigger role for them moving
[55:38]
forward continued Well I'm
[55:41]
committed to doing that further
[55:42]
into the future but I am in
[55:43]
support today of the motion.
[55:45]
>> Thank you.
[55:45]
All right.
[55:46]
Thank you, sir.
[55:47]
And I forgot to mention with
[55:48]
handy field in the background
[55:49]
the councils are also another
[55:50]
voice in a lot of these
[55:52]
conversations.
[55:53]
So see no one else on
[55:54]
the lights a motion by myself
[55:56]
and a second by COUNCILMAN
[55:57]
Marino to move the staff
[55:58]
recommendation Call the roll
[56:01]
I'm sorry the voting system
[56:02]
Please cast your vote and that
[56:06]
passes unanimously 7 to 0 with
[56:06]
Councilmember Foster and
[56:07]
Councilmember Yvonne Wilbert
[56:11]
Absent.
[56:11]
Thank you, council PRESIDENT
[56:12]
And thank you again.
[56:14]
Thank you city Clerk, for all
[56:15]
the good work you and your
[56:16]
entire team and everyone who
[56:17]
participated in that process.
[56:19]
>> So with that please
[56:20]
introduce item 400 items 400 as
[56:24]
the proposed fiscal year 2027
[56:26]
Recreation Center Fund Budget
[56:28]
Opportunity Fund budget and
[56:30]
2025 complete outside report If
[56:33]
you're here in council chambers
[56:34]
I would like to speak on this
[56:35]
item.
[56:35]
Please be sure to submit your
[56:37]
speakers live to the front of
[56:38]
the room in the clear box And
[56:39]
if you're participating online
[56:41]
or via phone now's the time to
[56:43]
raise your hand by pressing
[56:44]
Star nine or the Raise your
[56:46]
hand I can't thank you Council
[56:47]
for that.
[56:48]
>> All right.
[56:48]
Thank you.
[56:48]
I see a staff is settling in
[56:51]
When you're ready, introduce
[56:54]
yourselves for the record and
[56:56]
let us know how much time you
[56:57]
need.
[57:03]
>> Good afternoon.
[57:05]
Sara Erato, deputy director for
[57:05]
the Parks and Recreation
[57:06]
Department.
[57:07]
With me today is Salome
[57:08]
Martinez, program equity
[57:10]
manager as well as Andy Field
[57:12]
Department director.
[57:13]
Today we have returned to
[57:14]
present updates to the proposed
[57:16]
fiscal year 2027 Recreation
[57:18]
Center Fund and Opportunity
[57:19]
Fund Budget.
[57:20]
We are requesting eight minutes
[57:21]
for the presentation.
[57:22]
All right.
[57:23]
When you're ready.
[57:26]
On JUNE 16th the department
[57:27]
presented the proposed fiscal
[57:29]
year 2027 Recreation Center
[57:31]
Fund an opportunity fund
[57:32]
budgets to council resulting in
[57:34]
concerns raised over how
[57:36]
the Opportunity fund was being
[57:37]
allocated and unspent
[57:39]
Recreation Center fund dances
[57:41]
without the Recreation Council.
[57:43]
The Council returned this item
[57:44]
to staff requesting that
[57:45]
the opportunity fund allocation
[57:46]
for Council District eight
[57:48]
recreation centers be increased
[57:48]
.
[57:50]
The Allocation for Opportunity
[57:52]
Fund be reevaluated using
[57:53]
the assumption that fiscal year
[57:55]
26 budgets were fully expended
[57:57]
to develop a plan for
[57:59]
the expenditure of fund
[58:00]
balances and to evaluate
[58:02]
improvements to the Recreation
[58:03]
Center Fund Budget and
[58:04]
Opportunity Fund allocation
[58:06]
process in the future.
[58:08]
The next few slides we will
[58:09]
review each of these
[58:10]
recommendations.
[58:13]
Recreation centers are
[58:14]
supported through a combination
[58:16]
of funding sources beginning
[58:17]
with the general fund which
[58:18]
provides core operating support
[58:20]
needed to maintain services and
[58:22]
facilities.
[58:23]
In addition to general fund
[58:24]
support we have recreation
[58:26]
center funds that capture
[58:27]
revenues generated through
[58:29]
recreation center operations
[58:30]
and reinvest those funds back
[58:31]
into recreation services.
[58:33]
Opportunity funds provide
[58:35]
additional resources that are
[58:36]
allocated to recreation centers
[58:38]
and underserved communities for
[58:39]
local priorities programs,
[58:41]
equipment and minor maintenance
[58:42]
projects.
[58:43]
We also have actively we
[58:44]
actively pursue grants from
[58:46]
state, federal and private
[58:47]
organizations to support
[58:49]
specific projects, expand
[58:51]
programing and improve
[58:52]
facilities.
[58:53]
Finally, donations from
[58:54]
community members,
[58:55]
organizations and partners help
[58:57]
support programs and projects
[58:58]
beyond what traditional funding
[58:59]
sources MAY provide.
[59:01]
Taking a closer look at
[59:03]
recreation Center funds, there
[59:04]
are several revenue sources
[59:06]
that make up fund balance
[59:07]
program registration fees from
[59:09]
classes, camps, sports leagues
[59:11]
and other recreational
[59:12]
activities.
[59:13]
Our primary source of revenue
[59:14]
for the Recreation Center Fund
[59:17]
revenue is also generated
[59:18]
through permits for use of
[59:19]
recreation buildings, athletic
[59:21]
fields and park facilities for
[59:22]
community events, leagues and
[59:24]
private rentals.
[59:25]
Annually Opportunity Fund
[59:27]
allocations are deposited into
[59:28]
recreation center funds to
[59:30]
support underserved communities
[59:30]
.
[59:32]
Expanding programs, events and
[59:34]
projects identified at
[59:35]
the local level.
[59:37]
Donations made specifically to
[59:38]
a recreation center can also be
[59:40]
deposited into a fund and used
[59:42]
in accordance with the donor
[59:43]
intent.
[59:44]
Together these funding sources
[59:45]
create a diversified funding
[59:47]
model that allows recreation
[59:48]
centers to maintain daily
[59:50]
operations while also investing
[59:52]
in programs, equipment and
[59:53]
facility improvements.
[59:56]
After running the analysis
[59:58]
recommended in item two,
[1:00:00]
the results remained similar in
[1:00:01]
the original allocation
[1:00:02]
disbursement resulting in even
[1:00:04]
less item Council District
[1:00:05]
eight receiving an allocation.
[1:00:07]
With that the Department makes
[1:00:09]
the following recommendation to
[1:00:10]
move the budgets forward for f
[1:00:12]
y 27 expenditure maintain
[1:00:14]
the previously proposed
[1:00:15]
opportunity Fund allocations of
[1:00:19]
555,000 to the 14 recreation
[1:00:20]
centers originally identified
[1:00:22]
in the staff report and
[1:00:23]
Attachment b.
[1:00:25]
In addition, utilize $100,000
[1:00:27]
of Future Opportunity Fund
[1:00:29]
revenue to support expanding
[1:00:31]
opportunity fund allocations in
[1:00:33]
the fiscal year 27 budget to
[1:00:35]
all eight recreation centers in
[1:00:36]
Council District eight.
[1:00:38]
This would provide each site an
[1:00:39]
additional $12,500 for
[1:00:41]
the fiscal year 27 Recreation
[1:00:43]
Center Fund budget.
[1:00:45]
This would be a one time
[1:00:46]
allocation of future revenues.
[1:00:48]
Future allocations will follow
[1:00:50]
a policy methodology at
[1:00:52]
the time as it existed at
[1:00:54]
the time of that year's
[1:00:55]
allocation.
[1:00:57]
As previously mentioned, staff
[1:00:59]
assessed the Opportunity Fund
[1:01:01]
scoring methodology assuming
[1:01:02]
fiscal year 26 recreation
[1:01:03]
center fund budgets had been
[1:01:05]
fully expended.
[1:01:07]
The analysis found similar
[1:01:08]
results to the original scores
[1:01:10]
with Council District eight
[1:01:11]
allocations changing from two
[1:01:12]
eligible sites to one.
[1:01:14]
The findings suggest that
[1:01:15]
broader elements of
[1:01:16]
the Opportunity Fund scoring
[1:01:17]
matrix and methodology work
[1:01:20]
further evaluation to ensure
[1:01:22]
the program effectively
[1:01:23]
advances equity objectives
[1:01:25]
which the Department is
[1:01:26]
committed to evaluating prior
[1:01:27]
to the fy 28 budget cycle.
[1:01:31]
The third request of a plan to
[1:01:34]
expend recreation center fund
[1:01:35]
balances requires a broader
[1:01:36]
discussion on why fund balance
[1:01:38]
does exist for the immediate
[1:01:40]
fiscal year 27 budget proposal.
[1:01:42]
The Department updated all
[1:01:43]
eight recreation center fund
[1:01:44]
budgets in Council District
[1:01:47]
eight to fully expend fund
[1:01:48]
balances less $5,000 to support
[1:01:50]
expanding programs and
[1:01:52]
maintenance projects.
[1:01:53]
As for the history of
[1:01:54]
Recreation Center fund
[1:01:56]
balances, these were created in
[1:01:57]
2018 with many balances
[1:02:00]
starting with funds turned over
[1:02:01]
by recreation councils who had
[1:02:03]
been generating balances since
[1:02:05]
their inception.
[1:02:07]
To date community recreation
[1:02:08]
groups continue to provide
[1:02:10]
recommendations for recreation
[1:02:11]
center fund expenditures and
[1:02:13]
often include a reserve of
[1:02:15]
funds over multiple years to
[1:02:16]
support larger projects.
[1:02:18]
In addition, recreation centers
[1:02:19]
require sufficient fund
[1:02:21]
balances at the start of
[1:02:22]
the fiscal year to continue
[1:02:23]
operating busy summer month
[1:02:25]
programing and events.
[1:02:27]
Also being annual revenues and
[1:02:28]
expenditures can fluctuate
[1:02:30]
throughout the year.
[1:02:31]
Having fund balance does
[1:02:32]
provide a safeguard against
[1:02:33]
revenue shortfalls preventing
[1:02:35]
spending and program freezes.
[1:02:38]
In addition, fund balances MAY
[1:02:40]
exist as a result of changes to
[1:02:42]
procurement processes.
[1:02:43]
Specifically the implementation
[1:02:44]
of 8339 which requires a more
[1:02:47]
robust contracting out review
[1:02:49]
process for example contracting
[1:02:51]
out review process previously
[1:02:52]
took 14 to 45 days to process
[1:02:55]
or as currently underway since
[1:02:58]
FEBRUARY.
[1:02:59]
The process takes 90 or more
[1:03:00]
days depending on
[1:03:01]
the procurement type.
[1:03:03]
Also the department continues
[1:03:04]
to face ongoing challenges
[1:03:05]
primarily due to staffing
[1:03:07]
capacity as it relates to
[1:03:08]
navigating public works and
[1:03:10]
maintenance contract process
[1:03:11]
for facility repairs and
[1:03:12]
improvements as well as
[1:03:14]
recreation program contracts.
[1:03:16]
While we have experienced
[1:03:17]
delays in getting contracts in
[1:03:18]
place in a timely manner to
[1:03:20]
support these activities,
[1:03:21]
the Department continues to
[1:03:23]
work closely with various city
[1:03:24]
departments to ensure
[1:03:25]
compliance with these
[1:03:26]
requirements and processes.
[1:03:30]
Lastly, fund balances continue
[1:03:31]
to grow as the department
[1:03:32]
continues to leverage nonprofit
[1:03:34]
partners and grants to fund
[1:03:36]
specific programs events and
[1:03:37]
projects.
[1:03:39]
The supplemental funding
[1:03:40]
sources have reduced our
[1:03:41]
reliance on recreation center
[1:03:42]
funds which allows fund
[1:03:44]
balances to be preserved for
[1:03:45]
future community priorities
[1:03:46]
programs and investments.
[1:03:48]
A couple of examples include
[1:03:50]
the Padres Foundation donating
[1:03:54]
$40,000 to Montgomery Lawler to
[1:03:54]
cover field renovations that
[1:03:55]
were previously budgeted for
[1:03:57]
recreation center fund
[1:03:58]
expenditure as well as
[1:04:00]
the ongoing collaboration with
[1:04:01]
Saanich Parks Foundation,
[1:04:02]
the County Press Philanthropies
[1:04:04]
and the private foundation to
[1:04:06]
support the Parks After Dark
[1:04:07]
program.
[1:04:10]
Moving on to the last
[1:04:11]
recommendation a possible
[1:04:12]
recreation center Fund and
[1:04:14]
Opportunity Fund reforms.
[1:04:15]
The Department is committed
[1:04:17]
over the upcoming year to work
[1:04:18]
with eBay office of Race and
[1:04:20]
Equity to analyze the policy
[1:04:22]
and allocation process for
[1:04:23]
improvements and to participate
[1:04:25]
in the Allocation Process
[1:04:26]
Committee to achieve a more
[1:04:28]
equitable distribution of
[1:04:30]
funding.
[1:04:31]
We will meet with
[1:04:31]
the Department of Finance to
[1:04:33]
evaluate if the funds and both
[1:04:35]
funds can be folded into
[1:04:36]
the annual budget development
[1:04:38]
and monitoring process.
[1:04:40]
We will improve our
[1:04:41]
communication efforts with
[1:04:42]
the Council on the process for
[1:04:43]
developing Budgets for
[1:04:45]
Recreation Center Funds and
[1:04:46]
Opportunity Fund.
[1:04:48]
And lastly we will boost our
[1:04:49]
efforts to work closely with
[1:04:50]
operational staff and
[1:04:52]
the Council to ensure unspent
[1:04:54]
fund balances are prioritized
[1:04:55]
and spent on community
[1:04:57]
priorities.
[1:04:59]
The Department updated
[1:05:00]
attachments to the Recreation
[1:05:02]
Center Fund budget proposals as
[1:05:03]
well as Attachment b
[1:05:05]
Opportunity Fund allocations to
[1:05:07]
reflect the Increase
[1:05:08]
Opportunity fund allocations as
[1:05:10]
increased and increased budgets
[1:05:12]
for Council District eight.
[1:05:14]
Without the only changes to
[1:05:15]
the proposed actions includes
[1:05:16]
the addition of action for
[1:05:18]
which authorizes
[1:05:19]
the appropriation and
[1:05:20]
expenditure of future revenue
[1:05:21]
which was intended for fiscal
[1:05:23]
year 28 allocations as part of
[1:05:25]
the fiscal year 27 budget and
[1:05:27]
expenditures specifically
[1:05:28]
across all eight recreation
[1:05:30]
center funds in Council
[1:05:31]
District eight.
[1:05:32]
The Department recommends
[1:05:33]
approval of all actions as
[1:05:35]
proposed to ensure
[1:05:35]
the Recreation Center Fund
[1:05:37]
budgets are approved in a
[1:05:38]
timely manner and are available
[1:05:40]
for use beginning JULY 1st to
[1:05:43]
ensure constant continuity of
[1:05:43]
summer programing.
[1:05:45]
That concludes my presentation
[1:05:47]
>> Happy to take questions.
[1:05:48]
All right.
[1:05:48]
Thanks for the work and thank
[1:05:49]
you for the presentation.
[1:05:50]
Clerk Please go to Excuse me
[1:05:53]
Officer The idea to have some
[1:05:53]
comments.
[1:05:54]
>> Thank you.
[1:05:54]
Council PRESIDENT Kim Desmond
[1:05:56]
from our Division of Race and
[1:05:57]
Equitable provide our comments
[1:05:59]
Good afternoon to your local
[1:06:01]
members of council.
[1:06:02]
Our team wanted to outline some
[1:06:05]
equity implications for this
[1:06:07]
item including the upcoming
[1:06:08]
fund budget.
[1:06:10]
So our team has identified a
[1:06:12]
couple of equity implications
[1:06:14]
in the following categories.
[1:06:16]
One some that were mentioned by
[1:06:18]
Parks and Rec but one I want to
[1:06:19]
highlight is the Opportunity
[1:06:21]
Fund evaluation Committee
[1:06:23]
scoring matrix process.
[1:06:25]
We've had several conversations
[1:06:26]
with Sara and team around this
[1:06:28]
process in our team is
[1:06:31]
committed to looking at
[1:06:32]
the process in ways that we can
[1:06:33]
make sure that it's more
[1:06:34]
equitable.
[1:06:35]
And we plan to work with staff
[1:06:37]
to look at those improvements
[1:06:38]
in the 2020 budget cycle.
[1:06:41]
Some of the preliminary things
[1:06:42]
that we saw regarding this item
[1:06:44]
is improvement include
[1:06:46]
increasing transparency so that
[1:06:50]
we the recreation fund we can
[1:06:51]
make sure that the money is
[1:06:53]
being set aside in retained in
[1:06:55]
the fund balance for
[1:06:56]
the improve to other areas is
[1:07:00]
that it's clear that those
[1:07:01]
items are being used for and
[1:07:03]
why it's set aside.
[1:07:05]
Other opportunities includes
[1:07:06]
looking at the actual
[1:07:07]
opportunity fund scoring matrix
[1:07:09]
to explore ways in which
[1:07:12]
the matrix can be changed and
[1:07:14]
we can examine and critique
[1:07:15]
those factors.
[1:07:17]
Factors of 21 include if
[1:07:20]
the location is in a community
[1:07:21]
concern and or it is adjacent
[1:07:23]
to a pool.
[1:07:24]
So our team is committed to
[1:07:26]
looking at those factors in
[1:07:27]
partnership with Parks and Rec.
[1:07:30]
Last but not least in this
[1:07:31]
particular category we
[1:07:33]
recommended the department
[1:07:34]
determine which individuals to
[1:07:37]
be present to evaluate
[1:07:38]
the Allocation of Opportunity
[1:07:40]
Fund which is also charged with
[1:07:42]
providing recommendations.
[1:07:44]
Parks and Rec have invited our
[1:07:46]
team to sit on this committee
[1:07:47]
and so we wanted to just
[1:07:49]
highlight that part as looking
[1:07:50]
at who should be on
[1:07:51]
the committee and we accept
[1:07:53]
the invite from Parks and Rec
[1:07:57]
to the consideration of them.
[1:07:57]
I'll say this really quickly is
[1:07:58]
that we know that not all rec
[1:07:59]
centers are created equally so
[1:08:02]
council MAY want to consider
[1:08:03]
how facility limitations
[1:08:06]
including side and upper upper
[1:08:07]
recent offers of operational
[1:08:07]
hours impact access to activity
[1:08:13]
for stakeholders.
[1:08:15]
So we recommend that Parks and
[1:08:16]
Rec could identify a process to
[1:08:18]
provide stakeholders with
[1:08:20]
access information if their
[1:08:22]
service is not provided at
[1:08:23]
their location.
[1:08:25]
So essentially if it's not
[1:08:26]
provided there where else can
[1:08:27]
they go?
[1:08:28]
Last but not least regarding
[1:08:29]
the subsidized contracts
[1:08:31]
council MAY want to consider
[1:08:32]
and monitor the increase in
[1:08:35]
programs and activities in
[1:08:38]
septa as it pertains to working
[1:08:40]
with those provider to offer
[1:08:41]
more activity and services.
[1:08:43]
This includes the number of
[1:08:44]
clear tangible programs and
[1:08:46]
activities.
[1:08:48]
The call from our team is
[1:08:49]
aligned to address any
[1:08:50]
questions as well as Celina is
[1:08:51]
behind me.
[1:08:52]
We look forward to answering
[1:08:54]
any other questions regarding
[1:08:55]
our suggestions for this fund.
[1:08:59]
>> All right.
[1:09:00]
Thank you for those comments.
[1:09:02]
Always helpful in
[1:09:03]
the conversation.
[1:09:04]
>> Now let's go to public
[1:09:06]
comment.
[1:09:06]
Thank you.
[1:09:07]
Council PRESIDENT Evelyn Smith
[1:09:10]
if you can please come forward
[1:09:11]
after that is allegedly under.
[1:09:17]
>> You will have two minutes
[1:09:25]
and Smith representative day
[1:09:26]
four on the City Parks and Rec
[1:09:28]
board and I'm just here
[1:09:31]
requesting that these funds
[1:09:33]
remain in the hands of
[1:09:36]
the parks and Rec department
[1:09:37]
because the parks and rec
[1:09:40]
groups and the owners are
[1:09:43]
committed to do really need
[1:09:44]
these funds.
[1:09:46]
Thank you.
[1:09:48]
Thank you for the comments
[1:09:49]
Allegedly Audra, you you guys
[1:09:58]
thought I wasn't going to show
[1:09:59]
up today.
[1:10:00]
I bet would have been good.
[1:10:03]
I think you are right.
[1:10:03]
Yes.
[1:10:04]
So my concern is what's
[1:10:06]
happening at these rec centers
[1:10:07]
and the parks and the safety of
[1:10:10]
the children and really anybody
[1:10:13]
that participates in engaging
[1:10:16]
in those activities.
[1:10:18]
>> And as you're talking about
[1:10:20]
Parks after Dark program like
[1:10:22]
that's a little scary.
[1:10:23]
We don't have lights at parks
[1:10:23]
rubble.
[1:10:25]
People have been dying in your
[1:10:27]
parks.
[1:10:29]
I mean murdered it you know
[1:10:29]
Linda Vista skate park or being
[1:10:31]
brutally assaulted by officers
[1:10:33]
I mean you don't really care
[1:10:35]
because it doesn't really
[1:10:37]
affect you but it's very
[1:10:39]
detrimental what's happening at
[1:10:42]
these places And these funds
[1:10:43]
should be spent for safety and
[1:10:45]
things like that to make sure
[1:10:47]
there's lighting because people
[1:10:48]
are getting raped.
[1:10:49]
These are like perfect places
[1:10:51]
when you're a rapist or
[1:10:53]
something like that.
[1:10:54]
If they're dark and there's
[1:10:56]
secluded areas to go and take
[1:10:58]
advantage of somebody and it's
[1:11:00]
like you know we can sit here
[1:11:02]
and virtue signal like what
[1:11:03]
we're really doing is bringing
[1:11:05]
forward something in
[1:11:06]
the community which you are But
[1:11:08]
if you're not ensuring that
[1:11:09]
it's a safe place to go to then
[1:11:11]
it's like where's our money
[1:11:12]
really being spent?
[1:11:13]
I mean you could sit there and
[1:11:14]
have swings all day long but if
[1:11:16]
children are being raped under
[1:11:17]
the swings I mean how does that
[1:11:20]
help?
[1:11:20]
So I just feel like you guys
[1:11:22]
need to be more you know,
[1:11:26]
concerned about people's public
[1:11:28]
safety and you know, the fact
[1:11:30]
that, you know, you can just be
[1:11:32]
going and enjoying the park and
[1:11:34]
you know, an officer from
[1:11:36]
the San Diego Police Department
[1:11:37]
can just come up and like
[1:11:39]
basically slam your face into
[1:11:41]
the ground.
[1:11:42]
You know, and brutally assault
[1:11:45]
you and then you get charged
[1:11:47]
with something.
[1:11:48]
So it's just interesting
[1:11:49]
the things that take place that
[1:11:51]
isn't really of concern to
[1:11:53]
people who you know, those are
[1:11:55]
your constituents like Raul
[1:11:57]
Campo.
[1:11:58]
But you know, that's just
[1:11:58]
the way the business goes.
[1:12:05]
Good job involved Suzy or
[1:12:05]
Gonzalez Walden people you
[1:12:09]
can't read the person Sage
[1:12:12]
Thank you.
[1:12:13]
You'll have two minutes.
[1:12:14]
Please proceed.
[1:12:15]
Hi, my name is Sage Consultant.
[1:12:17]
Well, I am the chair of Choice
[1:12:20]
Valley Community Planning
[1:12:21]
Group.
[1:12:22]
I'm speaking to this in favor
[1:12:24]
because obviously we all need
[1:12:26]
more money for Parks and Rec.
[1:12:29]
One of the issues that our
[1:12:31]
community has is that finding
[1:12:33]
what the metric is for each
[1:12:36]
district for parks has been
[1:12:39]
difficult to figure out.
[1:12:41]
So I have brought you each
[1:12:44]
something to look at.
[1:12:45]
This is called the Trust for
[1:12:47]
Public Land.
[1:12:49]
This is a nationwide
[1:12:50]
organization that that really
[1:12:53]
just does a metric And in San
[1:12:55]
Diego we rate pretty low for
[1:12:57]
equity.
[1:12:58]
So you know, the other piece is
[1:13:02]
next week we're speaking over
[1:13:03]
radio towers and this is a 31
[1:13:05]
acre park.
[1:13:06]
I know this is not on
[1:13:07]
the agenda but I am And I
[1:13:09]
really all the things that are
[1:13:12]
happening with the presentation
[1:13:15]
is this is going to be a really
[1:13:15]
big deal for our community.
[1:13:17]
So I would like you all to look
[1:13:19]
at this Public safety is
[1:13:24]
imperative in our community And
[1:13:26]
if you consider public safety
[1:13:27]
being clean air places to play,
[1:13:31]
things for children to do and
[1:13:34]
ways to invest in our children
[1:13:35]
in our community this is this
[1:13:39]
is for for our community really
[1:13:41]
important.
[1:13:42]
I find it interesting my
[1:13:43]
council member isn't here today
[1:13:45]
and this is what we're talking
[1:13:46]
about.
[1:13:47]
>> So thank you.
[1:13:50]
>> Shut up here.
[1:13:52]
Thank you.
[1:13:52]
We'll pick that up.
[1:13:54]
Paul, are you speaking to this
[1:13:55]
item?
[1:13:57]
Paul Kruger Are you speaking to
[1:13:58]
this item?
[1:13:59]
Okay.
[1:13:59]
Just wanted to make sure before
[1:14:00]
I went to virtual public
[1:14:02]
comment I'm sorry the five
[1:14:03]
minute timer going to those
[1:14:04]
participating virtually we have
[1:14:06]
six speakers in the queue 9885
[1:14:09]
If you can please unmute line
[1:14:17]
85I can't imagine for you.
[1:14:18]
>> There you go.
[1:14:18]
Hi.
[1:14:19]
Hi there I am.
[1:14:20]
My name is Joanne Paquette.
[1:14:22]
I am the secretary and you
[1:14:24]
officer for Lucky Waller our
[1:14:25]
Little League that is located
[1:14:27]
at Montgomery Water Park.
[1:14:29]
I have to just say that we're
[1:14:30]
really sad to hear that our
[1:14:34]
district is being passed up
[1:14:34]
again this year for the second
[1:14:36]
time And it's really important
[1:14:37]
for us not to leave money on
[1:14:39]
the table especially when a
[1:14:40]
park with McMurry Waller has so
[1:14:42]
many things that it needs fix
[1:14:44]
and we have a playground that
[1:14:45]
is not ada compliant.
[1:14:46]
We have parking lots that have
[1:14:48]
no lights to them or people
[1:14:49]
can't get broken into them.
[1:14:50]
We had the Padres come out last
[1:14:52]
year and yes they donated
[1:14:54]
$40,000 to have our fields
[1:14:55]
flattened and modeled so that
[1:14:57]
our kids could play on this
[1:14:57]
field.
[1:14:58]
And this is the first time
[1:14:59]
since 1969 that these bills are
[1:15:01]
fixed and we cannot depend on
[1:15:04]
the charity of organizations to
[1:15:06]
come in and step in to take
[1:15:07]
care of what being neglected.
[1:15:09]
And on top of that, yes, they
[1:15:10]
came in and they fix those
[1:15:11]
fields for us but then Parks
[1:15:13]
and Rec allowed football and
[1:15:15]
soccer to play on those fields
[1:15:16]
and so we had to spend
[1:15:17]
thousands of dollars this year
[1:15:18]
to fix them again so that they
[1:15:20]
can be playable for our players
[1:15:21]
this spring And the season is
[1:15:23]
almost over and we're going to
[1:15:24]
have to hand it back over to
[1:15:25]
football and soccer again.
[1:15:27]
It is just going to happen
[1:15:27]
again.
[1:15:30]
The community has been stepping
[1:15:31]
up to make sure that our parks
[1:15:32]
look good but it's not enough
[1:15:34]
and our kids deserve better and
[1:15:36]
we deserve the funding and
[1:15:37]
the funding that's left over
[1:15:39]
the 300,000 is not even enough
[1:15:41]
to start working to bring
[1:15:43]
Montgomery Waller into
[1:15:44]
compliance.
[1:15:45]
The playgrounds need to be
[1:15:46]
fixed.
[1:15:47]
The lights need to be fixed.
[1:15:48]
We don't have a scoreboard for
[1:15:50]
our kids.
[1:15:50]
We don't have a dog park.
[1:15:52]
It's not safe.
[1:15:53]
Our bathrooms are not great.
[1:15:55]
It's just it's not okay that
[1:15:56]
every year we get passed up and
[1:15:58]
our families deserve better.
[1:16:00]
This is something that I live
[1:16:01]
in the community, something I
[1:16:02]
was born there and this is
[1:16:04]
something that we've been
[1:16:04]
fighting for every year that I
[1:16:06]
can remember.
[1:16:06]
My parents fought for life in
[1:16:08]
the parking lot.
[1:16:08]
I'm almost 40 years old and we
[1:16:10]
still don't have them.
[1:16:11]
We cannot leave money on
[1:16:12]
the table anymore and we need
[1:16:13]
to look at these parks and
[1:16:15]
these organized actions and
[1:16:17]
these would be places that kids
[1:16:18]
can go and have fun in a safe
[1:16:20]
manner and give them
[1:16:22]
the opportunity to improve and
[1:16:23]
to grow because your time has
[1:16:25]
concluded Becky Rapp is
[1:16:27]
the next speaker.
[1:16:28]
>> If you can please unmute.
[1:16:31]
>> Yes, good afternoon.
[1:16:33]
My name is Becky Rapp and it's
[1:16:35]
unfortunate that we are to
[1:16:37]
the point that we have to
[1:16:38]
utilize opportunity funds to
[1:16:40]
help fund parks and rec
[1:16:41]
centers.
[1:16:42]
Our communities are being asked
[1:16:43]
to do more with limited
[1:16:44]
resources while families
[1:16:46]
continue to rely on these types
[1:16:49]
of recreation programs
[1:16:50]
especially now I do appreciate
[1:16:53]
the city's commitment to
[1:16:54]
expanding the recreational
[1:16:55]
opportunities but we also need
[1:16:57]
to look at opportunities to
[1:16:59]
generate additional revenue
[1:17:01]
without asking taxpayers to pay
[1:17:03]
more.
[1:17:04]
One opportunity is stronger
[1:17:05]
enforcement of laws that
[1:17:07]
already exist across San Diego
[1:17:10]
illegal flavored tobacco
[1:17:11]
products, intoxicating hemp
[1:17:12]
products and other prohibited
[1:17:13]
items continue to be sold
[1:17:15]
openly, often and often in
[1:17:19]
storefront windows near
[1:17:20]
neighborhoods and recreation
[1:17:22]
centers.
[1:17:23]
These illegal sales undermine
[1:17:24]
public health, increase youth
[1:17:26]
exposure and create unnecessary
[1:17:28]
burdens on our communities.
[1:17:30]
Stronger enforcement will not
[1:17:32]
only protect children and
[1:17:33]
families, it could also
[1:17:34]
generate substantial revenue
[1:17:36]
through penalties, fines and
[1:17:37]
enforcement actions.
[1:17:39]
>> Those funds could be
[1:17:40]
reinvested directly into our
[1:17:42]
recreation system.
[1:17:44]
Imagine what that could mean.
[1:17:47]
Recreation centers could expand
[1:17:49]
afterschool and summer programs
[1:17:50]
parks that currently lack
[1:17:52]
adequate lighting could finally
[1:17:53]
be lit up making them safer and
[1:17:56]
more accessible during
[1:17:57]
the evening hours.
[1:17:58]
Facilities could receive long
[1:18:00]
overdue maintenance and
[1:18:02]
neighborhoods with the greatest
[1:18:03]
needs could benefit from
[1:18:05]
additional recreational
[1:18:06]
activities without relying
[1:18:08]
solely on limited general fund
[1:18:11]
dollars.
[1:18:13]
I just encourage the city to
[1:18:15]
make stronger enforcement of
[1:18:17]
existing laws as part of its
[1:18:19]
long term funding strategy for
[1:18:21]
parks and Rec.
[1:18:23]
>> Let's put it back into
[1:18:24]
the community.
[1:18:25]
Thank you.
[1:18:26]
Thank you Blair Beakman If you
[1:18:27]
can please unmute.
[1:18:28]
>> All right.
[1:18:29]
Thank you.
[1:18:29]
We're Beakman.
[1:18:34]
I think this is about the third
[1:18:35]
time this item has been here at
[1:18:37]
Council in committee in
[1:18:38]
the past month and a half.
[1:18:40]
Thank you.
[1:18:41]
It's interesting for items to
[1:18:43]
come back.
[1:18:44]
I thought additional funding it
[1:18:46]
was described today that
[1:18:47]
additional funding is going to
[1:18:48]
be going to District eight.
[1:18:50]
So good luck how that can go to
[1:18:51]
the park that was described as
[1:18:54]
needing help.
[1:18:57]
>> And you know as this is
[1:18:58]
the third time with this item,
[1:19:00]
I hope my ideas can be very
[1:19:03]
much a part of this process in
[1:19:04]
how we talk about the future of
[1:19:06]
our tech accountability for
[1:19:08]
the future of these rec centers
[1:19:09]
and park systems in San Diego.
[1:19:14]
It sounds like there's going to
[1:19:15]
be a lot of new aspects of
[1:19:16]
surveillance tech coming up and
[1:19:19]
I think we should be well
[1:19:20]
prepared that we not only ask
[1:19:21]
for good surveillance tech but
[1:19:23]
that we ask for good policies
[1:19:24]
with the tech.
[1:19:26]
I think I think we have to
[1:19:28]
start moving past
[1:19:29]
the euphemisms of sports
[1:19:31]
utility lighting and learn to
[1:19:33]
speak directly to the concept
[1:19:35]
of biometric technology as an
[1:19:37]
example and that we're not
[1:19:39]
afraid to have that subject be
[1:19:40]
a regular talking point in our
[1:19:42]
community dialog.
[1:19:44]
We don't know how to do that
[1:19:45]
yet but yet biometric tech was
[1:19:46]
all around us during the era of
[1:19:48]
covid and in our post-covid era
[1:19:51]
and yet we don't know how to
[1:19:52]
practice having that
[1:19:53]
conversation openly yet.
[1:19:55]
It's really important to say
[1:19:57]
that instead of sports utility
[1:19:58]
lighting and I hope we make
[1:19:59]
the efforts to do that.
[1:20:01]
And for all the clamor to
[1:20:03]
create new tech we have to have
[1:20:06]
we have that has to be equally
[1:20:08]
balanced with the concepts of
[1:20:09]
good policy practices.
[1:20:11]
And that's all I ask for.
[1:20:12]
You know, in this sort of
[1:20:14]
instance, you know how we can
[1:20:16]
limit our tech is important and
[1:20:18]
it can do that serve the same
[1:20:19]
purposes.
[1:20:20]
But having the good policies in
[1:20:22]
place just adds that we're
[1:20:24]
doing things well.
[1:20:25]
We're doing it responsibly and
[1:20:27]
holistically.
[1:20:29]
I mean that's how you build
[1:20:30]
the park community future and I
[1:20:32]
hope you take to heart.
[1:20:34]
Creating good tech policies
[1:20:35]
with our future tech in our
[1:20:37]
parks Your time has concluded
[1:20:39]
and so has the five minute
[1:20:40]
timer.
[1:20:40]
We have three speakers in
[1:20:41]
the queue with their hands
[1:20:42]
raised.
[1:20:43]
No additional speakers will be
[1:20:44]
taken at 700 If you can please
[1:20:46]
unmute.
[1:20:46]
Thank you Joy.
[1:20:54]
Assume that I support this
[1:20:56]
movement of funds to see
[1:20:57]
the eight Councilmember Moreno
[1:21:01]
Ward I think it was just a week
[1:21:03]
or two ago and I listened so I
[1:21:07]
strongly support it.
[1:21:09]
I really liked under the in
[1:21:11]
the staff report under equal
[1:21:14]
opportunity contracting info
[1:21:17]
the way they spelled it out
[1:21:20]
the whole the steps in
[1:21:21]
the unfoldment of the process
[1:21:23]
it just got me to a big yes
[1:21:26]
real fast.
[1:21:27]
So if you haven't read that
[1:21:29]
section I highly recommend send
[1:21:30]
it.
[1:21:33]
So and then my next comment is
[1:21:35]
on the c r g the community
[1:21:38]
recreation groups Do we know
[1:21:42]
this is not a judgment?
[1:21:43]
I'm a little bit in the past
[1:21:45]
with the recreation councils It
[1:21:47]
was very bumpy the way it ended
[1:21:50]
up but do we have enough
[1:21:52]
transparency monitoring and
[1:21:56]
oversight of the influence on
[1:21:59]
funds and so forth The movement
[1:22:02]
to influence
[1:22:02]
the recommendations from the c
[1:22:05]
r g groups and how that is all
[1:22:07]
handled.
[1:22:08]
Thank you Kim Desmond because
[1:22:12]
I'm really excited about you
[1:22:14]
being called to do work on
[1:22:17]
the spend down and the scoring
[1:22:19]
metrics.
[1:22:21]
Recent Equity Department is
[1:22:23]
really really needed on that
[1:22:26]
and you're just going to come
[1:22:28]
forward with your greatness and
[1:22:29]
you're going to make it happen.
[1:22:31]
So I love the Race and Equity
[1:22:33]
Department.
[1:22:34]
I was against it sort of it
[1:22:36]
first being part of the idea.
[1:22:39]
But you began beginning to be
[1:22:40]
even better and better and
[1:22:41]
greater and greater heroes for
[1:22:43]
me on this important item.
[1:22:46]
And then of course you MAY have
[1:22:47]
to cut me off, sweetie.
[1:22:49]
No grants in a nine, no grants
[1:22:55]
and your time is concluded.
[1:22:56]
Francine Maxwell if you can
[1:22:58]
please unmute Francine Maxwell
[1:23:01]
Southeastern San Diego resident
[1:23:03]
Thank you so much for
[1:23:04]
the presentation and full
[1:23:06]
support of their request
[1:23:09]
wanting to make sure that
[1:23:11]
people go and make sure that
[1:23:13]
the studies that were done in
[1:23:16]
earlier years are pulled off
[1:23:18]
the shelf before we decide to
[1:23:19]
do another one because
[1:23:21]
the things that were found
[1:23:22]
remain the same.
[1:23:24]
So before we spend more money
[1:23:25]
on disparities steady let's
[1:23:27]
make sure that we go to
[1:23:28]
the shelves and pull off
[1:23:29]
the programing equity study
[1:23:31]
within the parking rec desist
[1:23:36]
system and we MAY need to
[1:23:37]
expand his board another seat
[1:23:41]
at the table where it comes
[1:23:42]
from the community Voice Not
[1:23:45]
people that are paid where
[1:23:47]
they're going to check a box
[1:23:48]
and pretty much be able to pull
[1:23:50]
out what the community has been
[1:23:52]
knowing for years.
[1:23:54]
We knew that there were issues
[1:23:55]
with the hiring that our panels
[1:23:58]
had relatives on it and so
[1:24:01]
given that the department knows
[1:24:03]
it we don't need to sit and
[1:24:05]
continue to put committees
[1:24:07]
together and put people that
[1:24:08]
are going to sit there and talk
[1:24:09]
about it and not change
[1:24:11]
the narrative.
[1:24:12]
So again, looking forward to
[1:24:15]
more transparency and oversight
[1:24:17]
within our parking rec.
[1:24:19]
The system making sure that
[1:24:21]
when people are turned out they
[1:24:22]
are thoughtfully removed so
[1:24:25]
that things can grow.
[1:24:27]
Also remember that it's
[1:24:28]
the council office that directs
[1:24:29]
things that they want to as
[1:24:31]
well and people that are in
[1:24:33]
the areas of concern sometimes
[1:24:34]
you remain the areas of concern
[1:24:36]
because you need to look at
[1:24:38]
what's going on behind
[1:24:39]
the doors in the council office
[1:24:40]
because our park was stacked to
[1:24:43]
get a a plaza when we could
[1:24:46]
have pushed harder and got a
[1:24:48]
whole skate park across
[1:24:49]
the street on some land that we
[1:24:51]
own, all those people are gone.
[1:24:53]
They attended the meeting and
[1:24:55]
the park system knew that they
[1:24:56]
were going to do it and so did
[1:24:57]
the council office and that
[1:24:59]
doesn't bode well.
[1:25:03]
That concludes your time and
[1:25:05]
our final speakers Peggy Walker
[1:25:08]
Thank you again As a youth
[1:25:10]
mentor I support this with a
[1:25:12]
focus on safety and oversight.
[1:25:15]
It's important to provide
[1:25:16]
greater availability of healthy
[1:25:18]
recreational choices in a safe
[1:25:21]
place for children, especially
[1:25:22]
in underserved communities.
[1:25:24]
This is important at a time
[1:25:26]
when youth are bombarded with
[1:25:28]
so many diverse and not always
[1:25:30]
healthy way to spend their time
[1:25:32]
when case in point
[1:25:34]
the overwhelming draft So some
[1:25:35]
media another scores of studies
[1:25:38]
have shown that when kids live
[1:25:39]
near dispensaries for example
[1:25:41]
they are more likely to use
[1:25:42]
marijuana and as a result have
[1:25:45]
higher rates of psychosis.
[1:25:47]
There is a greater prevalence
[1:25:48]
of dispensary dispensaries and
[1:25:51]
higher rates of underage use
[1:25:53]
marijuana use in underserved
[1:25:54]
communities.
[1:25:55]
So we need to counterbalance
[1:25:57]
that with safe and equitable
[1:25:59]
year round recreational
[1:26:00]
opportunities for healthy youth
[1:26:00]
activities.
[1:26:04]
The interaction and engagement
[1:26:07]
Thank you again.
[1:26:08]
Thank you.
[1:26:09]
And that concludes public
[1:26:10]
comment on this item.
[1:26:11]
>> All right.
[1:26:12]
Thank you.
[1:26:12]
City Clerk.
[1:26:13]
An item like this I would
[1:26:14]
normally go to the chair of
[1:26:15]
the Community Neighborhood
[1:26:16]
services but we're here a
[1:26:17]
second time because of issues
[1:26:19]
raised by District eight So I'm
[1:26:20]
going to start out with council
[1:26:21]
member Moreno.
[1:26:22]
>> Thank you.
[1:26:24]
I want to thank our Parks and
[1:26:26]
Rec staff and
[1:26:27]
the administration for your
[1:26:29]
work on this revision and also
[1:26:31]
to my colleagues for
[1:26:32]
understanding my concerns on
[1:26:34]
this item.
[1:26:35]
When it was heard last week at
[1:26:36]
Council the opportunity Fund is
[1:26:39]
a special revenue fund created
[1:26:41]
by the Parks and Rec Department
[1:26:43]
to reduce historical
[1:26:44]
disparities in recreation
[1:26:47]
programing a goal that I
[1:26:48]
strongly support In 2021
[1:26:50]
the City of San Diego released
[1:26:53]
their Park Master Plan and
[1:26:55]
the Performance Audit of Equity
[1:26:59]
and Recreation programing both
[1:26:59]
identified inequities related
[1:27:01]
to park access and recreation
[1:27:04]
programing across the city.
[1:27:06]
The performance audit
[1:27:10]
recommendation recommendations
[1:27:11]
six states that the Park and
[1:27:12]
Rec Department should a
[1:27:15]
developed document and
[1:27:16]
implement a plan for directing
[1:27:18]
resources including any equity
[1:27:21]
based funding towards specific
[1:27:23]
steps to eliminate identified
[1:27:25]
disparities.
[1:27:28]
The Opportunity Fund was
[1:27:29]
created in direct response to
[1:27:33]
that recommendation and it's
[1:27:35]
deeply troubling that the fund
[1:27:36]
itself is now reproducing
[1:27:39]
the disparities it was designed
[1:27:40]
to fix sit Since its inception
[1:27:44]
in fiscal year 24, District
[1:27:46]
eight has consistently received
[1:27:48]
a disproportionately low share
[1:27:50]
of opportunity fund allocations
[1:27:53]
compared to other historically
[1:27:55]
underserved districts.
[1:27:57]
The numbers speak for
[1:27:58]
themselves in fiscal year 24,
[1:28:01]
District eight received 9% of
[1:28:03]
the total opportunity Fund
[1:28:05]
allocation In fiscal year 25,
[1:28:08]
District eight got 24% in
[1:28:10]
fiscal year 26 District eight
[1:28:13]
got 12% Fiscal year 27 we're
[1:28:18]
getting 26% and this is only
[1:28:20]
after this revision and only
[1:28:23]
with additional funds Over four
[1:28:26]
years District eight has
[1:28:28]
averaged roughly 18% of a fund
[1:28:32]
explicitly designed to address
[1:28:34]
underserved communities.
[1:28:37]
To me that's a continuation of
[1:28:39]
the same neglect these funds
[1:28:41]
were created for and it's
[1:28:44]
unacceptable.
[1:28:47]
>> I also want to address
[1:28:48]
the issue of unspent rec center
[1:28:51]
funds.
[1:28:52]
When this item was first
[1:28:53]
brought forward, District eight
[1:28:57]
had $1.2 million in funds and
[1:29:00]
it was these exact funds that
[1:29:02]
are obstructing my park and
[1:29:04]
RECs from being considered for
[1:29:06]
the opportunity fund Yet
[1:29:08]
the money has not been spent.
[1:29:11]
It was those unspent funds that
[1:29:13]
disqualified our parks from
[1:29:15]
being considered for
[1:29:16]
opportunity fund dollars.
[1:29:19]
I stated last time and I still
[1:29:21]
have it I have an invoice for
[1:29:23]
$34,000 for a scoreboard that
[1:29:26]
Little League families have
[1:29:27]
advocated for years.
[1:29:29]
Montgomery Waller Park has
[1:29:33]
$302,000 in identified needs
[1:29:35]
with funds that have not been
[1:29:38]
spent.
[1:29:39]
The San Diego American Memorial
[1:29:41]
Park Little League plays on
[1:29:43]
baseball fields that need laser
[1:29:45]
leveling clay for the bases
[1:29:48]
proper fencing to allow for
[1:29:49]
landscape maintenance and
[1:29:51]
additional shading In this
[1:29:53]
revision memorial park will not
[1:29:55]
will now receive some funds but
[1:29:58]
absolutely not enough to
[1:30:00]
address the full scope of what
[1:30:02]
the fields need.
[1:30:04]
My residents deserve the same
[1:30:05]
quality of parks and recreation
[1:30:07]
programs that other that other
[1:30:11]
communities across this city
[1:30:12]
take for granted.
[1:30:13]
The opportunity funds exist
[1:30:15]
precisely to close the gap and
[1:30:18]
right now it's falling short of
[1:30:19]
that promise for District
[1:30:20]
eight.
[1:30:22]
I disagree with the historical
[1:30:24]
trajectory of priority
[1:30:25]
prioritization that has been
[1:30:28]
presented because District
[1:30:30]
eight deserves more.
[1:30:33]
I do want to thank our Chief of
[1:30:36]
race and equity Can Kim Desmond
[1:30:38]
and I look forward I look
[1:30:38]
forward to looking into
[1:30:42]
the process that these
[1:30:44]
opportunity funds get allocated
[1:30:47]
The committee members that are
[1:30:49]
sitting on the committee that
[1:30:52]
gets to decide how these funds
[1:30:54]
are being spent which were to
[1:30:56]
items that I brought up at
[1:30:58]
the last meeting.
[1:30:59]
When are you proposing to come
[1:31:01]
back to this Council with your
[1:31:03]
findings?
[1:31:06]
>> So I think we can sketch out
[1:31:07]
a timeline what Parks and Rec
[1:31:09]
for f y 28 as looking at some
[1:31:12]
of these factors I think it
[1:31:13]
deserves some critique to make
[1:31:15]
sure we're getting it right so
[1:31:17]
we can come back with a
[1:31:18]
timeline when we get with Parks
[1:31:19]
and Rec If that suffices.
[1:31:21]
Okay so we don't know yet.
[1:31:22]
It could be a month.
[1:31:24]
It could be seven months.
[1:31:25]
That's right.
[1:31:28]
It's up to the administration.
[1:31:32]
>> Councilmember I think that's
[1:31:33]
fair.
[1:31:34]
The timeline is somewhat
[1:31:34]
indeterminate right now.
[1:31:35]
However, we anticipate that an
[1:31:38]
updated process including
[1:31:39]
members of the Opportunity Fund
[1:31:42]
kind of committee would be in
[1:31:44]
place in time for development
[1:31:45]
of the fy 28 budget.
[1:31:47]
So I know that you will not be
[1:31:49]
sitting here next year but
[1:31:50]
whoever succeeds you should
[1:31:52]
have the benefit of having some
[1:31:55]
folks from the draft team
[1:31:56]
sitting on that committee when
[1:31:58]
they see their fy 28 numbers
[1:31:59]
presented to you.
[1:32:00]
>> Wonderful.
[1:32:00]
And so I would just like to
[1:32:01]
read into the record
[1:32:02]
the committee member titles We
[1:32:05]
and these are all city of San
[1:32:06]
Diego associate manager analyst
[1:32:09]
a district manager, an area
[1:32:11]
manager, a senior management
[1:32:12]
analyst supervising rec
[1:32:15]
specialist, a senior park
[1:32:17]
ranger and I think recently
[1:32:18]
added a philanthropic public
[1:32:21]
partner into that.
[1:32:23]
These are the folks that get to
[1:32:25]
decide how much funding is
[1:32:26]
being disbursed And obviously
[1:32:28]
the city council puts
[1:32:30]
the parameters as to what is
[1:32:33]
puts the approves
[1:32:35]
the parameters So definitely
[1:32:37]
something that needs to be
[1:32:38]
looked at with a finer lens.
[1:32:42]
Also Council Councilmember
[1:32:44]
Foster at the last meeting
[1:32:46]
brought up the fact that he
[1:32:47]
would wanted to see a funding
[1:32:50]
allocations for these park and
[1:32:52]
RECs at during the budget
[1:32:54]
process which I very much
[1:32:56]
welcome.
[1:32:58]
So with that I would like to
[1:33:03]
make an amendment to
[1:33:04]
the staff's recommendation if I
[1:33:07]
could find it here.
[1:33:09]
So in section four and I'll
[1:33:12]
read this authorize the chief
[1:33:14]
financial Officer to
[1:33:15]
appropriate and expend 100,000
[1:33:18]
from the surf cubs Ports llc
[1:33:20]
percentage ground lease
[1:33:22]
payments scheduled for delivery
[1:33:24]
into the Opportunity Fund for
[1:33:26]
fiscal year 2028 Disbursement
[1:33:28]
and redirect it to the fiscal
[1:33:31]
year 2027 opportunity budget to
[1:33:34]
be allocated to Montgomery
[1:33:37]
Waller Little League for their
[1:33:39]
scoreboard at $34,000 and
[1:33:42]
allocate the remainder all
[1:33:47]
across District eight.
[1:33:52]
>> Let me see Scuse me Sorry
[1:33:58]
once again to allocate to
[1:33:59]
Montgomery Waller Little League
[1:34:03]
for their scoreboard at $34,000
[1:34:08]
and allocate evenly.
[1:34:17]
>> Sorry can't even read my own
[1:34:19]
notes to allocate evenly across
[1:34:21]
all eight city rec centers and
[1:34:25]
Council District eight at
[1:34:26]
the amount of 8250 each and
[1:34:29]
that will be my modification to
[1:34:32]
the motion And I was I and I
[1:34:34]
apologize I do want to thank my
[1:34:37]
colleague Council member Shani
[1:34:40]
Leo Rivera for proposing
[1:34:40]
the $100,000 from the Surf Club
[1:34:44]
Boards llc percentage ground
[1:34:46]
lease payment.
[1:34:47]
Thank you for that
[1:34:48]
recommendation.
[1:34:49]
I will note that District four
[1:34:52]
and District nine are receiving
[1:34:56]
$250,000 of opportunity funds
[1:34:58]
which they 1,000% deserve.
[1:35:01]
District eight is only getting
[1:35:04]
$150,000 this year and that's
[1:35:05]
because of the $100,000 that my
[1:35:08]
colleague was able to identify.
[1:35:10]
If not, we would only be
[1:35:12]
getting $54,000.
[1:35:15]
It's my district, my community,
[1:35:17]
very underserved community and
[1:35:18]
I will always fight tooth and
[1:35:20]
nail to make sure that we get
[1:35:22]
our fair share.
[1:35:22]
So I hope to see if I I'll
[1:35:25]
finish up next year as a member
[1:35:28]
of the public I hope to see
[1:35:30]
the opportunity funds being
[1:35:31]
dispersed across all very much
[1:35:34]
needed communities evenly and
[1:35:38]
proportionately as well
[1:35:39]
including Linda Vista.
[1:35:42]
I will out of that one So thank
[1:35:43]
you all right.
[1:35:46]
Thank you, Councilmember
[1:35:46]
Moreno.
[1:35:47]
So we have a motion as amended
[1:35:49]
and we'll get that up on
[1:35:50]
the screen.
[1:35:51]
>> I don't maybe hard copies We
[1:35:54]
didn't get an email so yeah
[1:35:55]
we'll get through All council
[1:35:57]
members know what the amended
[1:35:58]
motion is.
[1:36:01]
>> So with that we'll go to
[1:36:02]
Council Member Campbell.
[1:36:03]
The Chair Thank you so much.
[1:36:05]
Thank you so much.
[1:36:06]
Council PRESIDENT There's
[1:36:10]
34,000 for the scoreboard.
[1:36:11]
Is that part of the 12,500 each
[1:36:15]
for the eight rec center areas
[1:36:18]
in District eight or is that an
[1:36:21]
additional funding from
[1:36:23]
somewhere else?
[1:36:26]
Thank you for the question.
[1:36:27]
I do want to clarify since you
[1:36:28]
made the motion that as part of
[1:36:30]
the budget revision that we did
[1:36:32]
for Montgomery Waller we did
[1:36:33]
incorporate the repairs to
[1:36:36]
the scoreboard as part of their
[1:36:38]
budget So it has already
[1:36:38]
included utilize in their
[1:36:40]
recreation center fund budgets
[1:36:41]
just in case that helps with
[1:36:43]
your amendment.
[1:36:45]
But the 34,000 is separate than
[1:36:48]
the 12,500 that we originally
[1:36:50]
recommended for each of the rec
[1:36:52]
centers and Council District
[1:36:54]
eight That is incorrect.
[1:36:57]
Councilmember Campbell our
[1:36:58]
colleague Shani Lowe Rivera
[1:36:59]
discovered that we could
[1:37:01]
potentially put $100,000 of
[1:37:03]
surf club funding So out of
[1:37:05]
those $100,000 the staff is
[1:37:07]
proposing to divide up evenly
[1:37:09]
into eight council into eight
[1:37:12]
Council District eight parking
[1:37:15]
Rex Right for a total of about
[1:37:15]
12,500.
[1:37:17]
What I'm proposing is we take
[1:37:19]
that 100,000 we fund the 34,000
[1:37:20]
for that.
[1:37:24]
So I'm not taking money out of
[1:37:26]
anywhere else than what is
[1:37:28]
already being proposed Out of
[1:37:30]
the 100,000 we take 34 and we
[1:37:33]
put it towards the scoreboard
[1:37:35]
at Montgomery Waller and
[1:37:36]
the remainder which is roughly
[1:37:39]
64,000 which equates to about
[1:37:42]
8250 divided up to the eight.
[1:37:44]
So nothing there's no extra
[1:37:45]
money coming out of anywhere.
[1:37:46]
It's the 100,000 that clarifies
[1:37:51]
it for me.
[1:37:52]
Is that your understanding?
[1:37:54]
Good afternoon Andy Field Parks
[1:37:55]
and Recreation Director Yes, we
[1:37:57]
understand we take the first
[1:37:59]
portion of 100,000 towards
[1:38:01]
the scoreboard then divide
[1:38:02]
the remainder across the eight
[1:38:04]
sites We got you.
[1:38:05]
No problem.
[1:38:06]
Thank you.
[1:38:07]
Okay, Thanks you guys.
[1:38:08]
I understand completely and I'm
[1:38:09]
happy to second the motion.
[1:38:11]
>> All right.
[1:38:12]
We have a motion by council
[1:38:13]
member Moreno Marina which was
[1:38:15]
an amendment amended to
[1:38:17]
the staff recommendation and a
[1:38:18]
second by Councilmember
[1:38:19]
Campbell.
[1:38:20]
We'll go next to council member
[1:38:21]
Eli Rivera.
[1:38:22]
All right.
[1:38:23]
Thank you, Council PRESIDENT
[1:38:25]
Vic Sayre for the presentation
[1:38:26]
and all that work for Parks and
[1:38:28]
Rec.
[1:38:28]
I appreciate the work that
[1:38:30]
Councilmember Moreno did
[1:38:32]
between last evening and this
[1:38:33]
meeting in partnership with
[1:38:35]
Parks and Rec and the Mayor's
[1:38:36]
office to get to where we are
[1:38:39]
today.
[1:38:41]
I think this is an important
[1:38:42]
conversation about the way that
[1:38:44]
the Opportunity Fund is working
[1:38:45]
in practice Now the idea behind
[1:38:47]
it is incredibly important and
[1:38:49]
that it starts with recognizing
[1:38:51]
that there are rec centers in
[1:38:53]
San Diego that have not been
[1:38:55]
given the opportunity to
[1:38:57]
succeed and that we have a
[1:38:59]
system in place that made it
[1:39:00]
more and more difficult for
[1:39:01]
them to ever catch up.
[1:39:04]
It's that that is reminiscent
[1:39:06]
of the way many things work in
[1:39:08]
our city and opportunity And i
[1:39:11]
think is it is a really smart
[1:39:13]
idea And now it's about making
[1:39:15]
sure that the idea aligns with
[1:39:17]
the vision that we have for our
[1:39:19]
our rec centers and the goals
[1:39:22]
of this specific program.
[1:39:26]
So if I really do believe that
[1:39:30]
if we properly frame
[1:39:31]
the opportunity fund we can
[1:39:32]
figure out the ways to to
[1:39:34]
modify it in a way that
[1:39:36]
achieves those goals.
[1:39:38]
There's going to need to be
[1:39:39]
some rightsizing and some
[1:39:40]
improvements, some recognition
[1:39:41]
that the way that things are
[1:39:44]
being operationalized on
[1:39:45]
the ground impacts ability for
[1:39:49]
this fund to up to to work as
[1:39:52]
intended.
[1:39:54]
But all of that doesn't mean
[1:39:57]
that the opportunity in itself
[1:40:00]
it isn't important.
[1:40:00]
I think it's important for
[1:40:01]
members of the public to
[1:40:02]
recognize I also did want to
[1:40:03]
just make note that
[1:40:06]
Councilmember Foster is on
[1:40:07]
official business right now.
[1:40:09]
He is not shy about ensuring
[1:40:12]
that District four gets its
[1:40:14]
fair share and was an important
[1:40:19]
part of the conversation to
[1:40:20]
ensure that District four
[1:40:21]
wasn't left out of
[1:40:24]
the conversation as this
[1:40:25]
opportunity fund as
[1:40:26]
the decisions were being made
[1:40:28]
and that they didn't get any
[1:40:30]
less than what they were
[1:40:30]
deserving of just because we
[1:40:33]
heard some some comments and I
[1:40:34]
want to make sure that was on
[1:40:35]
the record as well.
[1:40:36]
The last thing I wanted to say
[1:40:38]
is that I think the $100,000
[1:40:40]
that we were able to to deploy
[1:40:42]
here to address some of
[1:40:45]
Councilmember Moreno's concerns
[1:40:46]
and the direct result of this
[1:40:47]
this council demanding more and
[1:40:50]
demanding better from those who
[1:40:51]
have the ability to pay more
[1:40:53]
and treat the city better.
[1:40:55]
It's an example of us leaning
[1:40:57]
into that and then deploying
[1:41:00]
that additional revenue in a
[1:41:02]
way that serves a part of
[1:41:03]
the city that's been the most
[1:41:05]
left behind over the years.
[1:41:07]
And you know in this case it's
[1:41:09]
just $100,000.
[1:41:11]
So not transformational from a
[1:41:13]
city budget perspective but it
[1:41:15]
also demonstrates that every
[1:41:16]
single dollar that we get in
[1:41:17]
that sort of way matters that
[1:41:21]
the $34,000 that'll be deployed
[1:41:21]
for the scoreboard is going to
[1:41:23]
make a margin.
[1:41:24]
A very big difference for
[1:41:25]
the families who are at
[1:41:28]
Montgomery Waller and we can't
[1:41:32]
lose sight of that.
[1:41:32]
That's just my way of saying
[1:41:34]
that when we are entering into
[1:41:35]
negotiations with any party
[1:41:38]
with the city we need to
[1:41:39]
squeeze as much out as possible
[1:41:43]
because on the other end of
[1:41:44]
that equation are families who
[1:41:46]
will benefit from that And in
[1:41:49]
this case it's $100,000 It'll
[1:41:50]
feed into the opportunity fund
[1:41:51]
and those hundred thousand
[1:41:52]
dollars are being deployed to
[1:41:53]
benefit the residents of
[1:41:54]
District eight And in other
[1:41:56]
circumstances there are similar
[1:41:59]
positive outcomes that can be
[1:42:02]
derived from us simply
[1:42:03]
demanding more when we are in
[1:42:06]
negotiations especially with
[1:42:08]
very wealthy entities that are
[1:42:10]
making a lot of money from
[1:42:11]
their from from the agreements
[1:42:14]
that they have from the city.
[1:42:15]
So I'm glad that this is being
[1:42:18]
this is being able to be
[1:42:19]
deployed in this way But we're
[1:42:21]
in a better place than we were
[1:42:22]
a couple of weeks ago.
[1:42:22]
I appreciate the work that was
[1:42:24]
done to get to this place and
[1:42:26]
look forward to more
[1:42:27]
opportunities to make sure that
[1:42:29]
we're that we're doing right by
[1:42:30]
residents who were not done
[1:42:32]
right by in the past.
[1:42:36]
>> And that will conclude my
[1:42:37]
comments.
[1:42:38]
Council PRESIDENT Thank you.
[1:42:39]
All right.
[1:42:40]
Thank you, Councilmember Rivera
[1:42:42]
I'll just out of course be
[1:42:44]
supportive of this and I
[1:42:45]
appreciate Park and Rec in
[1:42:48]
everyone who pivoted after
[1:42:50]
the input from the first
[1:42:53]
meeting of this.
[1:42:55]
You did an awful lot of work on
[1:42:57]
that and have reevaluated a lot
[1:42:59]
of your processes.
[1:43:00]
There's more work to be done as
[1:43:02]
you gain this And what I want
[1:43:05]
to focus on something that I
[1:43:06]
think Councilmember Foster
[1:43:07]
pointed out about having this
[1:43:11]
information not as a separate
[1:43:12]
item after the budget is
[1:43:14]
already approved but part and
[1:43:16]
parcel of the budget because
[1:43:18]
today we have very little room.
[1:43:20]
The opportunity fund is x
[1:43:21]
dollars and the question is how
[1:43:22]
are you going to divvy up those
[1:43:23]
x dollars if count if
[1:43:24]
Councilmember El Overhead
[1:43:29]
secured that hundred thousand
[1:43:29]
it would have been a much
[1:43:30]
different very painful
[1:43:31]
conversation today.
[1:43:33]
So having that information
[1:43:34]
about even if it's only draft
[1:43:36]
in terms of the rec center fund
[1:43:39]
the opportunity fund during
[1:43:41]
the budget conversations
[1:43:42]
because a few dollars every
[1:43:45]
dollar is painful that we don't
[1:43:47]
give to Parks and Rec given how
[1:43:48]
much you have to do and how
[1:43:49]
much is on your plate but a few
[1:43:51]
dollars taken from that
[1:43:52]
operating budget for dedicated
[1:43:54]
funds for individual rec
[1:43:56]
centers and under resourced
[1:43:57]
communities could have made a
[1:43:59]
heck of a lot of difference.
[1:44:00]
But we didn't know we didn't
[1:44:02]
have those tools available to
[1:44:03]
us.
[1:44:03]
So one more thing to add to
[1:44:06]
your list of how we do f y 28
[1:44:08]
differently and maybe have you
[1:44:10]
at least give us
[1:44:11]
the opportunity or council
[1:44:13]
the opportunity that more
[1:44:14]
flexibility and weigh the pros
[1:44:17]
and cons to benefits and
[1:44:19]
the cost of any of those
[1:44:21]
decisions going forward.
[1:44:23]
So thank you for your good work
[1:44:24]
Thank you for that And again
[1:44:26]
I'll throw in a to rec centers
[1:44:29]
rec councils in district one
[1:44:31]
through in money towards that
[1:44:32]
opportunity fund beyond
[1:44:33]
the regular process and oh that
[1:44:39]
you created the opportunity to
[1:44:40]
find out of scratch and maybe
[1:44:42]
this is a good chance to kind
[1:44:43]
of revisit the thinking that
[1:44:45]
went into the opportunity funds
[1:44:46]
now that we've got a few years
[1:44:49]
under our belt.
[1:44:50]
So anyway, thank you.
[1:44:52]
Thank you to COUNCILMAN Moreno
[1:44:53]
and everybody who weighed in
[1:44:55]
last time and weighed in this
[1:44:57]
afternoon and so that we do
[1:44:59]
have the motion that is now up
[1:45:01]
on the screen I think you heard
[1:45:03]
it said out loud a couple of
[1:45:04]
times.
[1:45:07]
So the key being directing
[1:45:11]
34,000 directly to
[1:45:12]
the Montgomery Recreation
[1:45:13]
Center for the scoreboard and
[1:45:15]
spreading the remainder of that
[1:45:17]
100,000 evenly across all eight
[1:45:19]
recreation centers and council
[1:45:21]
district in the $8,250 each.
[1:45:25]
So with that not to anybody
[1:45:27]
else in life, please call
[1:45:28]
the roll.
[1:45:29]
>> That's right the voting
[1:45:30]
system Please cast your vote
[1:45:34]
That passes unanimously 7 to 0
[1:45:36]
with Councilmember Foster and
[1:45:36]
Councilmember a little bit
[1:45:38]
absent.
[1:45:39]
>> Thank you, Council
[1:45:39]
PRESIDENT.
[1:45:40]
All right.
[1:45:41]
Thank you, Clerk.
[1:45:43]
So with that for the next two
[1:45:44]
items we're going to update
[1:45:46]
the order.
[1:45:47]
We will first hear the item two
[1:45:50]
establish the Affordable
[1:45:51]
Housing Preservation Fund which
[1:45:53]
is item one as the housing
[1:45:56]
authority.
[1:45:56]
Then we will hear item 402 from
[1:46:01]
the city Planning Department as
[1:46:03]
the City Council upon inclusion
[1:46:05]
of those two items we will
[1:46:07]
Return of Housing Authority to
[1:46:09]
continue with today's business
[1:46:11]
So with that we will now
[1:46:12]
adjourn as the City Council and
[1:46:14]
convene as a special housing
[1:46:16]
Authority meeting Clerk Please
[1:46:18]
introduce Housing Authority
[1:46:19]
Item ha1 of you council
[1:46:22]
PRESIDENT Item one is to
[1:46:25]
establish an affordable housing
[1:46:26]
preservation Fund and amend
[1:46:28]
the San Diego Housing
[1:46:29]
Commission and Fiscal Year 2026
[1:46:31]
budget to accept City of San
[1:46:33]
Diego Neighborhood Enhancement
[1:46:34]
fee funds for affordable
[1:46:36]
housing preservation.
[1:46:37]
If you'd like to speak on this
[1:46:38]
item please be sure to submit
[1:46:40]
the speaker up to the front of
[1:46:41]
the room in the clear box Or if
[1:46:42]
you're participating remotely
[1:46:44]
please be sure to raise your
[1:46:45]
hand by pressing Star nine or
[1:46:46]
the raise your hand icon.
[1:46:48]
Thank you.
[1:46:49]
All right.
[1:46:50]
Thank you so staff, please
[1:46:51]
introduce yourself for
[1:46:52]
the record and let us know how
[1:46:54]
much time you need.
[1:46:55]
>> Good afternoon, Councilor
[1:46:56]
Senior Vice PRESIDENT, Real
[1:46:57]
estate for Senior Housing
[1:46:59]
Commission minutes, please.
[1:47:00]
>> All right, When you're ready
[1:47:05]
you staff is recommending that
[1:47:06]
the housing authority of
[1:47:07]
the city of San Diego authorize
[1:47:08]
a senior housing commission to
[1:47:09]
establish an affordable housing
[1:47:10]
preservation fund and amend
[1:47:12]
the Housing Commission's fiscal
[1:47:13]
year 2026 budget to accept
[1:47:21]
$5,913,554 instead of sending
[1:47:21]
only renouncing funds that will
[1:47:21]
be transferred from the city of
[1:47:22]
San Diego to the Housing
[1:47:23]
Commission to be deposited into
[1:47:25]
the Housing Commission's
[1:47:25]
Affordable Housing Preservation
[1:47:27]
Fund.
[1:47:28]
These are crucial, crucial next
[1:47:29]
steps to help preserve
[1:47:30]
the affordable rental homes
[1:47:31]
citywide.
[1:47:33]
We also support the City
[1:47:34]
Council approved Affordable
[1:47:34]
housing preservation strategy
[1:47:39]
that was a commission study
[1:47:39]
preserving affordable housing
[1:47:40]
in the city of San Diego
[1:47:41]
released MAY 2020 estimated
[1:47:43]
that more than 13,000 units
[1:47:45]
could become unaffordable by
[1:47:49]
2040 4200 restricted units MAY
[1:47:49]
lose protections and up to
[1:47:50]
9250.
[1:47:52]
Naturally, affordable homes
[1:47:54]
will become unaffordable due to
[1:47:56]
market pressures without
[1:48:00]
without intervention 35% of all
[1:48:01]
new production or simply
[1:48:03]
replacing have lost
[1:48:03]
affordability.
[1:48:06]
On FEBRUARY 3rd, 2025 City
[1:48:07]
Council approved a deed
[1:48:08]
restricted Affordable Housing
[1:48:10]
Preservation Ordinance
[1:48:10]
spearheaded by Councilmember
[1:48:12]
Fabian Moreno.
[1:48:13]
Then on APRIL 10th 2025 at
[1:48:15]
the request of City Council
[1:48:17]
PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee, chair of
[1:48:20]
the Land Use and Housing
[1:48:20]
Committee staff presented an
[1:48:22]
informational report about
[1:48:23]
the potential for the creation
[1:48:24]
of an Affordable Housing
[1:48:25]
Preservation fund Along with
[1:48:27]
the options for its
[1:48:28]
implementation, the committee
[1:48:30]
asked us to return with
[1:48:31]
recommendations and funding
[1:48:32]
models going forward On
[1:48:34]
SEPTEMBER 4th, 2025 staff
[1:48:36]
returned to eliminate with a
[1:48:37]
range of preservation
[1:48:38]
strategies to create and
[1:48:39]
implement an affordable housing
[1:48:40]
preservation fund.
[1:48:42]
The committee unanimously
[1:48:43]
unanimously approved
[1:48:44]
recommending that the City
[1:48:45]
Council take the staff
[1:48:46]
recommended actions to
[1:48:47]
establish an affordable housing
[1:48:48]
preservation fund.
[1:48:51]
The committee requested
[1:48:52]
the staff take the actions
[1:48:53]
shown on the slide start of
[1:48:56]
research to various funding
[1:48:57]
models available to create and
[1:48:58]
preserve affordable housing and
[1:48:59]
naturally occurring housing In
[1:49:01]
San Diego we spoke with
[1:49:03]
industry professionals and
[1:49:04]
consulted with other localities
[1:49:05]
Determine the best options for
[1:49:06]
the city of San Diego.
[1:49:08]
We return to City Council to
[1:49:09]
request the approvals needed to
[1:49:10]
establish the fund and transfer
[1:49:12]
the neighborhood enhancement
[1:49:13]
funds to the Housing Commission
[1:49:18]
in its approval of the City of
[1:49:19]
San Diego's fiscal year 2026
[1:49:21]
budget, the City Council
[1:49:22]
allocated $5 million for
[1:49:24]
the Neighborhood Enhancement
[1:49:25]
Fund to the Affordable Housing
[1:49:26]
Preservation Fund since that
[1:49:29]
council action,
[1:49:30]
the Neighborhood announcement
[1:49:31]
Fund has grown to $5,913,544 as
[1:49:35]
new as additional new
[1:49:36]
developers paid for the Bond
[1:49:38]
Housing Commission staff have
[1:49:39]
worked with City of San Diego
[1:49:40]
staff to bring a companion item
[1:49:41]
to the city council to approve
[1:49:43]
a transfer of funds from
[1:49:44]
the city of San Diego Fund 2000
[1:49:48]
Commission for the fiscal year
[1:49:48]
2026 Sources and uses of funds
[1:49:50]
proposed for approval were not
[1:49:52]
included in the Housing
[1:49:53]
Commission's housing.
[1:49:53]
The Housing Commission's
[1:49:54]
Housing authority approved
[1:49:57]
fiscal year 2026 budget.
[1:50:00]
The Housing Commission is
[1:50:00]
requesting approval from
[1:50:01]
the Housing Authority to amend
[1:50:02]
the Housing Commission's fiscal
[1:50:04]
Year 2026 budget to authorize
[1:50:06]
the Housing Commission to
[1:50:07]
accept 5,000,913 $1,154 from
[1:50:11]
any fund for Affordable Housing
[1:50:12]
Preservation Fund activities to
[1:50:14]
acquire and preserve both deed
[1:50:15]
restricted and naturally
[1:50:16]
occurring affordable housing
[1:50:17]
properties.
[1:50:21]
The Housing Commission's
[1:50:23]
proposal for 26 Budget
[1:50:23]
Amendment does not commit any
[1:50:25]
funds to any specific strategy
[1:50:28]
program or acquisition or
[1:50:30]
individual property
[1:50:31]
acquisitions, Bond
[1:50:32]
authorizations and Preservation
[1:50:34]
Fund program approvals will be
[1:50:36]
brought back to the housing
[1:50:37]
Commission Board of
[1:50:38]
Commissioners, the Housing
[1:50:39]
Authority and or City Council
[1:50:41]
for separate approval before
[1:50:42]
any funds are expended on a
[1:50:44]
specific project.
[1:50:46]
The Housing Authority and or
[1:50:47]
City Council will set the final
[1:50:48]
policy strategies for
[1:50:50]
the Preservation Fund at a
[1:50:51]
later date as the fund grows
[1:50:53]
and additional types of
[1:50:54]
investments are sought, Those
[1:50:56]
proposals and any changes to
[1:50:58]
preservation fund activities
[1:50:59]
will be brought to the Housing
[1:51:00]
Authority or City Council for
[1:51:02]
approval.
[1:51:04]
Staff recommend that
[1:51:05]
the Housing authority of
[1:51:06]
the City of San Diego take
[1:51:07]
the actions detailed in staff
[1:51:08]
report and shown on the slide.
[1:51:14]
Thank you for your time.
[1:51:15]
Francis Barros and I are able
[1:51:16]
to answer any questions and
[1:51:18]
that concludes our
[1:51:19]
presentation.
[1:51:20]
All right.
[1:51:20]
Thank you for the work and
[1:51:21]
thank you for the presentation.
[1:51:22]
Please proceed with public
[1:51:23]
comment.
[1:51:25]
Thank you.
[1:51:25]
Council PRESIDENT If I can have
[1:51:26]
Paul Krueger please come
[1:51:27]
forward after that as allegedly
[1:51:30]
Adrienne and then Anthony Ross
[1:51:32]
you can please come forward to
[1:51:33]
the other reserved seats at
[1:51:34]
the front.
[1:51:34]
Anthony That would be greatly
[1:51:35]
appreciated as well as Agenda
[1:51:38]
You will have two minutes.
[1:51:40]
>> Please proceed.
[1:51:41]
I put in a slip for this and a
[1:51:43]
slip for the next one that i
[1:51:44]
would like almost the same.
[1:51:46]
Would it be easier if I just
[1:51:47]
made one presentation for four
[1:51:50]
minutes and not on the next?
[1:51:51]
The items are being taken
[1:51:52]
separately so then your
[1:51:54]
comments on Disappear.
[1:51:55]
Thank you.
[1:51:55]
Thank you.
[1:51:56]
I just wanted to call your
[1:51:58]
attention to how significant
[1:52:00]
this is in terms of unintended
[1:52:02]
consequences of programs.
[1:52:04]
The city council has approved
[1:52:06]
and refused to modify over
[1:52:10]
years of concern.
[1:52:11]
The bonus idea program
[1:52:13]
specifically removed from our
[1:52:15]
housing stock Affordable
[1:52:17]
starter housing at 750,000 or
[1:52:21]
more.
[1:52:22]
These homes are considered very
[1:52:25]
affordable and they're in
[1:52:26]
neighborhoods where housing is
[1:52:28]
affordable.
[1:52:29]
This policy allowed developers
[1:52:32]
to turn these homes into rental
[1:52:35]
units and build multiple units
[1:52:37]
in the backyards where these
[1:52:38]
bonus adu units affordable.
[1:52:41]
No they were not.
[1:52:43]
For every market rate unit
[1:52:45]
the developer got they were
[1:52:47]
allowed or required to build a
[1:52:52]
quote unquote affordable unit.
[1:52:54]
Those affordable units include
[1:52:56]
moderate rate housing that
[1:52:58]
rents for up to people who make
[1:53:01]
more than 110% of the average
[1:53:05]
median income for five years.
[1:53:08]
We urge this council to revisit
[1:53:10]
these rules and require
[1:53:12]
developers to build truly low
[1:53:14]
income housing and this council
[1:53:16]
did not do that.
[1:53:18]
The other issue here is what
[1:53:20]
could lead communities has done
[1:53:22]
to existing apartment buildings
[1:53:25]
that because they're older or
[1:53:29]
more affordable those those
[1:53:30]
units examples in utc and
[1:53:34]
Golden Hill were demolished to
[1:53:36]
make room for developments that
[1:53:38]
charge $2,700 for a one bedroom
[1:53:43]
unit with quote unquote
[1:53:44]
affordable units costing more
[1:53:47]
than $2,500.
[1:53:49]
We wouldn't be here if you
[1:53:51]
would Please take time to
[1:53:53]
review the consequences of
[1:53:55]
these programs They are pointed
[1:53:57]
out to you.
[1:53:58]
>> Thank you.
[1:54:00]
Thank you.
[1:54:01]
Allegedly under course they
[1:54:08]
didn't do it.
[1:54:08]
They need to squeeze out as
[1:54:10]
much as possible.
[1:54:11]
Right.
[1:54:11]
Sean, it's so interesting
[1:54:13]
because you guys sit here and
[1:54:15]
you do bring forward items like
[1:54:17]
this like you're really going
[1:54:18]
to preserve affordability.
[1:54:19]
You can't preserve something
[1:54:20]
that doesn't exist.
[1:54:22]
So you guys sit here and act
[1:54:24]
like we're providing affordable
[1:54:25]
housing.
[1:54:27]
Is it I mean is it really
[1:54:28]
affordable even if you need
[1:54:29]
some kind of voucher, does that
[1:54:31]
mean it's still affordable?
[1:54:33]
I mean would that mean it's not
[1:54:35]
that you make more money to go
[1:54:36]
in there?
[1:54:37]
I mean it's like the way you
[1:54:39]
guys pull wool over people's
[1:54:40]
eyes to make it seem like what
[1:54:41]
you're doing is beneficial to
[1:54:43]
them.
[1:54:43]
It's so sad because it's like
[1:54:44]
this $5 million.
[1:54:45]
>> I mean really what's going
[1:54:46]
to do your time on acquiring
[1:54:47]
and preserving like I mean you
[1:54:51]
guys sit up there with a
[1:54:52]
straight face.
[1:54:53]
>> It's so sad because people
[1:54:56]
are suffering.
[1:54:56]
You sit up on your dais and you
[1:55:00]
guys act like you know what
[1:55:01]
that's like to try and figure
[1:55:03]
out how you're going to pay
[1:55:04]
your rent and what's actually
[1:55:06]
affordable Like when you have
[1:55:08]
people that are making hundreds
[1:55:10]
of thousands of dollars and
[1:55:12]
talking about affordability
[1:55:13]
until you guys get paid 20
[1:55:15]
bucks an hour and you're trying
[1:55:17]
to make ends meet, I don't
[1:55:18]
think that you have a right to
[1:55:19]
talk about that because you
[1:55:21]
don't have that kind of lived
[1:55:22]
experience where you would
[1:55:23]
understand what it's like to
[1:55:25]
stretch a dollar Instead you
[1:55:27]
guys come out to the people
[1:55:28]
time and talk know Sean Do you
[1:55:30]
know what that's like?
[1:55:31]
Have you been homeless?
[1:55:32]
You have for how long?
[1:55:36]
Right?
[1:55:36]
And look at you now right?
[1:55:39]
Do you care about the people
[1:55:40]
you walk over at night?
[1:55:42]
You don't.
[1:55:43]
So I mean you want to sit here
[1:55:44]
and act like you've been
[1:55:45]
homeless?
[1:55:45]
I've been homeless too, but I
[1:55:47]
actually give a about
[1:55:48]
the people.
[1:55:48]
I don't just walk over them and
[1:55:50]
like Oh my gosh you're such an
[1:55:51]
eyesore.
[1:55:52]
Let's move you down the road.
[1:55:53]
That's what's so sad.
[1:55:54]
Yes, that's what you guys do.
[1:55:57]
You don't go in and personally
[1:55:59]
like encounter these people but
[1:56:03]
yet you sit up here and decide
[1:56:05]
what they can and what they
[1:56:07]
can't afford and that is so
[1:56:09]
egregious.
[1:56:10]
>> Anthony please confirm.
[1:56:16]
Well good afternoon City
[1:56:17]
Council.
[1:56:17]
I thought that this I mean it
[1:56:22]
appeared to be cut and dry to
[1:56:23]
me but after hearing some of
[1:56:25]
the testimonies, some of
[1:56:26]
the members of the public I'm
[1:56:28]
not exactly sure.
[1:56:29]
And I think that with regard to
[1:56:31]
what one of the gentlemen said
[1:56:33]
earlier with regard to
[1:56:34]
the unintended consequences, I
[1:56:36]
think that we should look into
[1:56:37]
that.
[1:56:37]
I think that I'm in support of
[1:56:40]
this item on the contingency
[1:56:42]
that we look into some of
[1:56:44]
the unintended consequences
[1:56:46]
that could happen as a result
[1:56:48]
of this proposal.
[1:56:50]
Thank you.
[1:56:52]
Sorry I'm going to time are
[1:56:54]
going to those participating
[1:56:55]
remotely starting with Francine
[1:56:57]
Maxwell If you can please
[1:56:58]
unmute Francine that's all
[1:57:02]
southeastern San Diego any of
[1:57:04]
these required paragraph two in
[1:57:06]
our dash 2021 dash 22 to be
[1:57:08]
used solely to fund recreation
[1:57:10]
amenities, active
[1:57:11]
transportation and transit
[1:57:13]
infrastructure projects.
[1:57:15]
So 100% no amenities were or
[1:57:19]
ever will be constructed with
[1:57:21]
any benefit.
[1:57:22]
Any money was not spent in any
[1:57:24]
amenity in communities of
[1:57:26]
concern or any infrastructure.
[1:57:29]
100% of money is now being
[1:57:30]
proposed to be transferred into
[1:57:32]
preserving the concentration of
[1:57:34]
poverty in communities of
[1:57:36]
concern without needed
[1:57:37]
infrastructure.
[1:57:38]
I could have sworn that my
[1:57:40]
neighbors won their lawsuit
[1:57:42]
against the city of San Diego
[1:57:44]
in reference to
[1:57:45]
the concentration of poverty.
[1:57:48]
So again we're going to have to
[1:57:51]
revisit this because it seems
[1:57:53]
like people have forgotten
[1:57:55]
about the win that my neighbors
[1:57:58]
received building projects
[1:58:00]
without amenities then using
[1:58:02]
the money meant to improve
[1:58:03]
the lives of the most
[1:58:04]
vulnerable but instead ensuring
[1:58:07]
they are without amenities.
[1:58:10]
I think that there's something
[1:58:11]
wrong unless I have just
[1:58:14]
completely misread this.
[1:58:16]
So I look forward to
[1:58:18]
the education that I MAY
[1:58:20]
receive from the diocese today
[1:58:22]
>> And again let's not forget
[1:58:27]
about 100% is now being
[1:58:28]
transferred preserving
[1:58:30]
the concentration of poverty
[1:58:31]
because District four is an
[1:58:35]
area of concern and their
[1:58:37]
neighbors get together and they
[1:58:39]
win lawsuits.
[1:58:41]
>> Thank you for allowing me to
[1:58:42]
speak.
[1:58:43]
Thank you.
[1:58:44]
Next is 8700 If you can please
[1:58:46]
unmute a joyful two Oh gosh I
[1:58:57]
thought I was preparing for
[1:59:00]
this in an unexpected items but
[1:59:00]
that's not what I need to whine
[1:59:03]
about or even cry.
[1:59:05]
Thank you Paul Krueger Thank
[1:59:08]
you Allegedly Audra Thank you.
[1:59:10]
Francine Maxwell They all are
[1:59:13]
telling us things You need to
[1:59:15]
listen to those statistics
[1:59:18]
about what's going to happen to
[1:59:21]
you know, these covenants these
[1:59:23]
these homes that are a year ago
[1:59:27]
we looked at this We have a
[1:59:29]
list of these things, these
[1:59:31]
restrictive covenant properties
[1:59:32]
that really didn't go under.
[1:59:34]
I don't think we've really done
[1:59:36]
anything dramatically to stop
[1:59:37]
that.
[1:59:42]
I really don't But I don't have
[1:59:42]
the time So I'm just worried.
[1:59:47]
I was very I love the word
[1:59:48]
preservation.
[1:59:49]
You all know that And I really
[1:59:53]
was all for this whole new I
[1:59:54]
still am.
[1:59:56]
But are we missing something?
[1:59:59]
I think we are and I don't know
[2:00:01]
what it is so please help me
[2:00:04]
with that, will you?
[2:00:05]
So we can do better.
[2:00:06]
>> Thank you for listening to.
[2:00:10]
Next is John If you can play
[2:00:16]
some you Good afternoon City
[2:00:17]
council It's interesting
[2:00:18]
the direction it's taken It's
[2:00:20]
the same direction that I was
[2:00:22]
going to go which is the most
[2:00:24]
underserved community and most
[2:00:27]
struggling is those that are
[2:00:28]
living on our streets right now
[2:00:30]
And we have decided to close
[2:00:35]
the facility that represents
[2:00:37]
over half of the bathrooms
[2:00:39]
the only place where you can
[2:00:41]
wash your personal items and
[2:00:44]
get your clothes done and
[2:00:46]
the only place where you can
[2:00:47]
take a break even a park for
[2:00:50]
homeless people to go to.
[2:00:52]
So if this funding is for that
[2:00:55]
for the purpose of meeting
[2:00:56]
the needs of underserved
[2:00:57]
communities I suggest we start
[2:00:59]
there and then we should go
[2:01:01]
over to the lot and talk about
[2:01:03]
what's going on there because
[2:01:05]
when we envision that we did
[2:01:06]
not envision it at the density
[2:01:08]
that it currently is operating
[2:01:09]
at, we did not envision it
[2:01:11]
without any ground cover to
[2:01:13]
relieve you of just any point
[2:01:16]
or when it rains.
[2:01:17]
We do not agree to a place that
[2:01:19]
has no shade and no community
[2:01:21]
gathering places to relax.
[2:01:23]
There is and it is divisible
[2:01:26]
and dense beyond what we ever
[2:01:29]
imagined were 2 to 300 tents in
[2:01:32]
one location.
[2:01:34]
We have zero adult shelters
[2:01:37]
that are built for purpose or
[2:01:39]
for that matter that are in
[2:01:40]
place for anyone who is a
[2:01:43]
single adult On our streets
[2:01:44]
right now we've got four
[2:01:46]
specialty groups.
[2:01:46]
We've got it for families.
[2:01:48]
We've got for people with
[2:01:49]
disabilities people gay,
[2:01:50]
lesbian.
[2:01:51]
But if you're a single adult
[2:01:52]
you get to live in a tent
[2:01:54]
whether it's a group tent on
[2:01:55]
asphalt or a tent and then a
[2:02:00]
lot So I think we need to
[2:02:02]
rethink our priorities here
[2:02:04]
because honestly we're kind of
[2:02:06]
make it some break up ranch
[2:02:07]
look like a good idea and you
[2:02:10]
know how I feel about that.
[2:02:13]
Thank you.
[2:02:15]
Thank you.
[2:02:16]
The five minute timer has been
[2:02:16]
clear.
[2:02:17]
We have two speakers in
[2:02:18]
the can.
[2:02:18]
No additional speakers will be
[2:02:19]
taken.
[2:02:20]
That was Blair Beekman and
[2:02:21]
Natalie Raasch.
[2:02:22]
Gabler if you can please unmute
[2:02:23]
I thank you for Beakman Thank
[2:02:28]
you Public comment today
[2:02:29]
the previous public comment or
[2:02:32]
as a lot of words and ideas on
[2:02:34]
the concept of the future of
[2:02:35]
the New York Day Center and he
[2:02:38]
is just the best strongest
[2:02:40]
voice to really talk about any
[2:02:42]
possible future for the day
[2:02:43]
center.
[2:02:44]
I hope his voice is really
[2:02:46]
listened to and realize what
[2:02:49]
we're losing and giving that
[2:02:49]
up.
[2:02:51]
I think we understand its
[2:02:52]
efficiency in giving it up.
[2:02:55]
He's stating the practicalities
[2:02:57]
why we need to keep it and work
[2:02:59]
on concepts like it If we if it
[2:03:02]
is depended where else are we
[2:03:02]
going to go All Kruger also
[2:03:06]
offered really interesting
[2:03:07]
comments that was seconded by
[2:03:10]
Anthony Thank you very much I
[2:03:13]
would like to third that
[2:03:14]
concept and and the idea that
[2:03:17]
you're hearing good public
[2:03:19]
voices on this matter and that
[2:03:21]
help and I guess to thank our
[2:03:23]
council persons you know I've
[2:03:25]
been learning important lessons
[2:03:27]
from our council person
[2:03:28]
the Carver that I understand
[2:03:30]
you guys do care about
[2:03:32]
affordable housing at this time
[2:03:34]
I'm better understanding that
[2:03:35]
what you can be doing towards
[2:03:37]
that subject towards truly
[2:03:39]
affordable housing and with
[2:03:41]
what the groups like path can
[2:03:43]
do the work that they do has
[2:03:46]
been nothing short of
[2:03:48]
miraculous And we really have
[2:03:50]
to be I hope those
[2:03:52]
conversations become more and
[2:03:54]
more clear.
[2:03:54]
I mean it's more than just
[2:03:55]
shelters that they offer and
[2:03:58]
how we build that future is
[2:03:59]
important from that how do we
[2:04:02]
again talk about the future of
[2:04:03]
places like New graduate center
[2:04:05]
and services for people who
[2:04:07]
really need it And look how
[2:04:10]
this funding can be used to for
[2:04:14]
a truly affordable end and that
[2:04:14]
you guys have conversations
[2:04:15]
here on the dsa in those good
[2:04:18]
terms and good luck in
[2:04:19]
listening to the public to all
[2:04:21]
of us who've offered really
[2:04:22]
interesting comment here today.
[2:04:24]
>> Thank you.
[2:04:25]
Thank you, Natalie Rush here
[2:04:26]
last speaker please on media Hi
[2:04:31]
Natalie Rashi a lot a lot of
[2:04:33]
this is kind of confusing
[2:04:34]
understanding the language
[2:04:37]
that's being used as a
[2:04:40]
stakeholder elder And I was you
[2:04:43]
know, looking at the definition
[2:04:44]
I consider myself a stakeholder
[2:04:46]
and I don't know that we are
[2:04:49]
considered a stakeholder.
[2:04:51]
Some of us the voices that we
[2:04:52]
have I think that moving
[2:04:56]
forward we have to really be
[2:04:58]
intentional and conscious of
[2:05:00]
what we choose and how we
[2:05:02]
choose to build buildings or
[2:05:05]
build anything that we're
[2:05:06]
doing.
[2:05:07]
I was offered a apartment at
[2:05:12]
Quattro for City Heights.
[2:05:13]
I drove by there that whoever
[2:05:16]
designed that that building it
[2:05:19]
looks like a jail cell.
[2:05:20]
The side window would be
[2:05:23]
the freeway of the 15 I
[2:05:26]
understood in that when we have
[2:05:26]
to build affordable housing in
[2:05:28]
areas where there's transits
[2:05:31]
and such things but I don't
[2:05:34]
know of anybody who's looked at
[2:05:35]
that building or some of
[2:05:37]
the other buildings that are
[2:05:38]
built.
[2:05:38]
It really stands out as you're
[2:05:42]
in affordable housing.
[2:05:43]
So if we're creating these I
[2:05:47]
don't know it almost puts a tag
[2:05:49]
on you again and I don't know
[2:05:52]
whose intentions are or what
[2:05:54]
they are when they're building
[2:05:55]
these places that are supposed
[2:05:57]
to include or be inclusive to
[2:06:01]
our community.
[2:06:03]
And I think that there is there
[2:06:09]
is definitely we need to re
[2:06:11]
approach how we move forward in
[2:06:15]
this new day and age.
[2:06:17]
Thank you.
[2:06:18]
>> Thank you.
[2:06:19]
That does conclude public
[2:06:20]
comment on this item.
[2:06:21]
All right.
[2:06:22]
Thank you City Clerk.
[2:06:22]
With that we'll turn over to
[2:06:24]
council members questions,
[2:06:25]
comments entertain a motion.
[2:06:26]
We'll start with the chair of
[2:06:28]
Land Use and Housing Council
[2:06:29]
PRESIDENT Pro tem I think I was
[2:06:31]
PRESIDENT And I want to start
[2:06:33]
off by thanking my colleague
[2:06:35]
Councilmember Renaud for her
[2:06:35]
years of leadership and
[2:06:36]
advocacy as the former chair of
[2:06:38]
Planning and Housing Committee
[2:06:39]
in bringing forward
[2:06:40]
the Preservation Ordinance that
[2:06:42]
was passed by this council
[2:06:44]
earlier last year.
[2:06:45]
This item came before the Land
[2:06:48]
Use and Housing Committee in
[2:06:49]
the fall and where we are doing
[2:06:52]
is taking the next step in
[2:06:54]
actually putting together a
[2:06:55]
fund that supports our
[2:06:57]
affordable housing preservation
[2:06:59]
ordinance as we acknowledge at
[2:07:01]
the time the ordinance was
[2:07:02]
really just one initial step to
[2:07:05]
move the city's affordable
[2:07:06]
housing preservation strategy
[2:07:07]
forward allowing for
[2:07:09]
opportunities so that as
[2:07:10]
affordable housing covenants
[2:07:11]
expired, the city whether
[2:07:14]
through the Housing Commission
[2:07:15]
or through partners within
[2:07:16]
the community who could
[2:07:18]
participate in this fund could
[2:07:20]
help and have the opportunity
[2:07:22]
to preserve existing affordable
[2:07:24]
housing and to renew their
[2:07:26]
covenants in the years ahead.
[2:07:28]
As you've heard from
[2:07:29]
the presentation, there's been
[2:07:30]
over 13,000 units that have
[2:07:32]
been identified with covenants
[2:07:34]
that would be expiring other
[2:07:36]
nationally affordable housing
[2:07:37]
occurring affordable housing
[2:07:38]
that has been at risk And for
[2:07:41]
much time the city has focused
[2:07:43]
heavily primarily on producing
[2:07:46]
new housing units.
[2:07:47]
But at the same time we
[2:07:48]
recognize that just producing
[2:07:50]
new units doesn't necessarily
[2:07:51]
ensure that the existing units
[2:07:53]
with expirations on their
[2:07:55]
covenants would actually be
[2:07:57]
protected.
[2:07:57]
And that's why we're here today
[2:07:59]
working with the Housing
[2:08:00]
Commission and Planning
[2:08:01]
Department, the Neighborhood
[2:08:03]
Enhancement fee was established
[2:08:05]
specifically with housing
[2:08:07]
preservation as one of its
[2:08:09]
primary areas of emphasis And
[2:08:12]
today we're looking not just at
[2:08:13]
allocating the $5.9 million to
[2:08:17]
start this fund but recognizing
[2:08:18]
that the funds that were
[2:08:20]
collected in that now have
[2:08:21]
the opportunity actually be
[2:08:22]
utilized for the purpose they
[2:08:23]
were intended which is to
[2:08:25]
provide for additional
[2:08:26]
affordable housing
[2:08:27]
opportunities specifically by
[2:08:29]
protecting the ones that
[2:08:30]
already exist.
[2:08:32]
I do want to ask both Colin and
[2:08:35]
Francis something that has been
[2:08:37]
identified is that the staff
[2:08:39]
report and the materials here
[2:08:40]
talk about the $5.9 million as
[2:08:42]
a part of f by 26.
[2:08:45]
We're of course headed into
[2:08:46]
that for 27 budget as well.
[2:08:46]
And so we've been talking about
[2:08:48]
a higher number of what's
[2:08:49]
anticipated to ultimately go
[2:08:50]
into this fund.
[2:08:51]
>> Can you share about that?
[2:08:52]
Yeah.
[2:08:52]
Thank you for the question.
[2:08:53]
So yes, this is strictly for
[2:08:56]
fiscal year 2026 for the 5.9
[2:08:58]
million in fiscal year 27
[2:09:00]
there's an additional 2.7
[2:09:02]
million to get bring us to a
[2:09:03]
total of $8.5 million.
[2:09:05]
That budget was already
[2:09:07]
approved by city council.
[2:09:08]
>> That's why we did not
[2:09:08]
mention it in this report.
[2:09:09]
Thank you.
[2:09:11]
And let me just note that as
[2:09:13]
much as we talked about
[2:09:14]
the ordinance being a first
[2:09:15]
step and the establishment of
[2:09:17]
this fund being another step,
[2:09:19]
there's a lot of work to do
[2:09:21]
still $8.5 million is not a lot
[2:09:24]
at the end of the day in terms
[2:09:25]
of the number of housing units
[2:09:26]
that can be impacted.
[2:09:28]
We look at some of
[2:09:28]
the developments that we've or
[2:09:31]
some of the properties in
[2:09:32]
the past where on the national
[2:09:34]
affordable naturally occurring
[2:09:35]
affordable side we've seen
[2:09:37]
thousands of units shift hands
[2:09:39]
to become market rate and we've
[2:09:41]
lost that affordability to
[2:09:43]
those who had the ability to
[2:09:45]
act upon that.
[2:09:46]
What this establishing this
[2:09:48]
fund allows the city to do is
[2:09:49]
to also look at other resources
[2:09:52]
whether it's philanthropic
[2:09:53]
partners, whether it's
[2:09:55]
corporate and workforce
[2:09:56]
partners within the region to
[2:09:58]
think about how we can work
[2:10:00]
collectively to have funding
[2:10:01]
available so that as housing
[2:10:03]
units either lose their
[2:10:05]
covenants or naturally
[2:10:06]
affordable occurring affordable
[2:10:07]
units are identified where
[2:10:10]
there's an opportunity for us
[2:10:11]
to step in and preserve their
[2:10:13]
existing cost so that
[2:10:15]
homeowners renters etc. Can
[2:10:18]
stay within the housing units
[2:10:19]
that they're in.
[2:10:21]
This fund is just the first
[2:10:22]
step in allowing us to better
[2:10:24]
be prepared to act upon that
[2:10:25]
front.
[2:10:26]
So again, we're just taking one
[2:10:29]
step today We're opening a door
[2:10:30]
inviting the opportunity to
[2:10:32]
partner with others to expand
[2:10:34]
upon our ability as a city to
[2:10:37]
preserve affordable housing.
[2:10:38]
Again, where this really
[2:10:39]
focuses just as a starting
[2:10:41]
point are the thousands of
[2:10:42]
units that we have identified
[2:10:43]
that are 55 year covenants for
[2:10:46]
affordable housing that are
[2:10:47]
expiring and the decade ahead.
[2:10:49]
There's nothing else we can do
[2:10:52]
for those units if we're not
[2:10:54]
ready to act upon them and to
[2:10:56]
encourage others to do so.
[2:10:58]
The ordinance that was
[2:10:59]
established that Councilmember
[2:11:01]
Moreno helped to champion help
[2:11:02]
provide the first right of
[2:11:03]
refusal so that affordable
[2:11:04]
housing developers and others
[2:11:06]
could act before someone could
[2:11:07]
come in.
[2:11:08]
From a market rate standpoint
[2:11:10]
this is a next step that allows
[2:11:11]
the city to partner with folks
[2:11:13]
to actually put funding and
[2:11:14]
capital into doing just that.
[2:11:15]
So with that I'm proud to move
[2:11:18]
the staff recommendation on
[2:11:19]
this item and look forward to
[2:11:21]
the comments from my
[2:11:21]
colleagues.
[2:11:22]
Thank you.
[2:11:22]
All right.
[2:11:22]
Thank you.
[2:11:23]
So we have a motion by Council
[2:11:24]
PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee to move
[2:11:25]
the staff recommendation and
[2:11:26]
we'll go next to council member
[2:11:28]
Moreno.
[2:11:30]
Thank you to the San Diego
[2:11:31]
Housing Commission and city
[2:11:32]
staff for bringing this item
[2:11:34]
forward.
[2:11:35]
I am pleased to support
[2:11:36]
the final establishment of
[2:11:38]
the Affordable Housing
[2:11:39]
Preservation Fund and
[2:11:41]
the transfer of
[2:11:42]
the Neighborhood Enhancement
[2:11:43]
Funds to build this important
[2:11:45]
resource for San Diego.
[2:11:49]
The reality is simple San Diego
[2:11:52]
doesn't have enough affordable
[2:11:53]
housing and while we must
[2:11:55]
continue building more
[2:11:57]
construction, it alone is not
[2:11:58]
keeping up with the need.
[2:12:01]
This is why preserving
[2:12:02]
the Affordable homes we already
[2:12:04]
have is just as important as
[2:12:07]
building new ones.
[2:12:09]
When an affordable housing
[2:12:10]
property is put up for sale
[2:12:13]
after the 55 year covenant it
[2:12:16]
simply could be before it could
[2:12:18]
be sold from an affordable
[2:12:21]
housing developer to a private
[2:12:22]
developer without the city ever
[2:12:25]
having the opportunity to step
[2:12:26]
in and preserve its
[2:12:28]
affordability.
[2:12:30]
To be clear, these are
[2:12:31]
affordable homes that were
[2:12:32]
built using public subsidies
[2:12:34]
and it's critical that we keep
[2:12:37]
them affordable.
[2:12:38]
The Affordable Housing
[2:12:40]
Preservation Ordinance that was
[2:12:42]
mentioned by our pro tem is an
[2:12:45]
ordinance that I worked very
[2:12:47]
closely with with the San Diego
[2:12:48]
Housing Commission in 2023 As a
[2:12:52]
former chair of the Land Use
[2:12:53]
and Housing Committee, I
[2:12:55]
requested that the San Diego
[2:12:56]
Housing Commission bring
[2:12:58]
the committee information on
[2:13:00]
what we could do to preserve
[2:13:01]
affordable homes in San Diego
[2:13:04]
in NOVEMBER 2024, the Land Use
[2:13:06]
and Housing Committee
[2:13:07]
unanimously recommended that
[2:13:09]
the City Council adopt this or
[2:13:11]
the order the previous
[2:13:12]
ordinance which provides a
[2:13:14]
right of first offer and right
[2:13:17]
of first refusal to qualified
[2:13:19]
entities including nonprofits
[2:13:21]
and for profit organization or
[2:13:26]
for profit organizations.
[2:13:27]
And I do want to take this
[2:13:28]
opportunity to thank the San
[2:13:29]
Diego Housing Commission for
[2:13:31]
how many meetings did you guys
[2:13:33]
have during that?
[2:13:34]
>> I know we're not talking
[2:13:35]
about this but it's good to to
[2:13:36]
put on record how many meetings
[2:13:38]
you had.
[2:13:39]
>> I've lost count.
[2:13:41]
>> It was a lot was a lot.
[2:13:42]
It was a lot of meetings But in
[2:13:45]
20 in 20 in FEBRUARY of 2025
[2:13:49]
the Affordable Housing
[2:13:50]
Preservation Ordinance was
[2:13:52]
unanimously approved by
[2:13:54]
the city council.
[2:13:56]
This ordinance applies when
[2:13:58]
the owner of an assisted
[2:13:59]
housing development intends to
[2:14:01]
sell the property.
[2:14:03]
It requires the property owner
[2:14:05]
to provide a notice of intent
[2:14:07]
to sell to government and
[2:14:09]
affordable housing entities
[2:14:10]
three months before any
[2:14:12]
offering to sell or listing
[2:14:14]
with any real estate agent
[2:14:17]
the Affordable Housing
[2:14:17]
Preservation Ordinance prevents
[2:14:20]
deed restricted affordable
[2:14:22]
homes from being redeveloped
[2:14:25]
into market rate or luxury
[2:14:27]
housing.
[2:14:29]
Now when a building with deed
[2:14:31]
restricted affordable housing
[2:14:32]
goes on the market we will have
[2:14:34]
the opportunity to preserve
[2:14:36]
that The those houses that pass
[2:14:40]
ordinance I thought was very
[2:14:41]
reasonable and it was an
[2:14:43]
effective tool to keep deed
[2:14:44]
restricted affordable units in
[2:14:46]
place across San Diego
[2:14:49]
basically keeping San Diego
[2:14:51]
from losing affordable homes
[2:14:53]
that they live in today We are
[2:14:56]
now we're taking the next
[2:14:58]
critical step the neighborhood
[2:15:00]
enhancement for dollars JANUARY
[2:15:02]
aided by new development are
[2:15:04]
now being reinvested to
[2:15:06]
preserve affordable housing and
[2:15:09]
establishing the Affordable
[2:15:10]
Housing Preservation Ordinance
[2:15:12]
Fund which we are doing today
[2:15:14]
will ensure we have
[2:15:16]
the resources also known as
[2:15:18]
money needed to act when these
[2:15:21]
opportunities arise.
[2:15:23]
So the first ordinance gave us
[2:15:24]
the right to do it.
[2:15:26]
Now this is providing us
[2:15:27]
the money to do it.
[2:15:29]
So having the Affordable
[2:15:30]
Housing Preservation Ordinance
[2:15:32]
Fund in place is an essential
[2:15:34]
tool to ensure that we continue
[2:15:37]
preserving exist existing
[2:15:39]
affordable homes in San Diego.
[2:15:42]
>> Do we need more housing?
[2:15:43]
Yes.
[2:15:44]
Do we need more parks?
[2:15:45]
Yes.
[2:15:46]
Do we need to make our parks
[2:15:48]
and keep them up to speed?
[2:15:49]
Absolutely yes.
[2:15:51]
But we absolutely need need
[2:15:52]
these funds And I want to take
[2:15:54]
this opportunity to thank
[2:15:56]
Council Pro Tem Lee and his
[2:15:58]
staff for your continuous work
[2:15:59]
on this very important effort.
[2:16:02]
Could have just left it sitting
[2:16:04]
on the shelf and we would have
[2:16:05]
never had money to actually put
[2:16:07]
our money where our mouth is.
[2:16:09]
And I also want to take an
[2:16:11]
opportunity to thank our I'm
[2:16:14]
going to call you guys housing
[2:16:15]
heroes to call in to Frances to
[2:16:18]
Lisa.
[2:16:19]
You guys are absolutely our
[2:16:20]
housing heroes.
[2:16:22]
We could have had that
[2:16:23]
informational item and you
[2:16:24]
could have, you know, told me
[2:16:26]
everything I wanted to hear and
[2:16:28]
we could have walked away and
[2:16:29]
not had I want to say it was
[2:16:31]
like it was a crazy amount of
[2:16:33]
meeting like 15 or 33 meetings
[2:16:35]
You could have never you didn't
[2:16:36]
have you you didn't have to do
[2:16:38]
it and you did it.
[2:16:39]
>> And now we are seeing
[2:16:40]
the fruits of your hard labor
[2:16:42]
And I want to thank you for
[2:16:43]
that And second the motion.
[2:16:44]
>> Thank you.
[2:16:45]
All right.
[2:16:46]
Thank you.
[2:16:46]
Council member Moreno So we do
[2:16:48]
have a motion by Council
[2:16:49]
PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee and
[2:16:50]
second by council member Marina
[2:16:51]
on move the staff
[2:16:52]
recommendation will go next to
[2:16:54]
council member Eli Rivera.
[2:16:55]
Thank you Council PRESIDENT
[2:16:58]
Thank you Colin and Frances and
[2:17:01]
Lisa and the whole Housing
[2:17:03]
Commission team.
[2:17:07]
>> Sometimes things are good.
[2:17:10]
That's it.
[2:17:11]
They're just good.
[2:17:13]
This is good If we care about
[2:17:16]
people being able to live in
[2:17:18]
this city and stay in
[2:17:20]
the communities that they live
[2:17:21]
in they love and they're
[2:17:22]
pouring their hearts into this
[2:17:24]
is good period.
[2:17:28]
>> This is making it easier for
[2:17:32]
the city to actually do
[2:17:35]
the things we say we want to
[2:17:36]
do.
[2:17:38]
So I think some of
[2:17:39]
the confusion is coming from a
[2:17:42]
a genuine place of not
[2:17:44]
understanding exactly what
[2:17:46]
the action is here in front of
[2:17:47]
us.
[2:17:48]
But I also think there's some
[2:17:49]
folks who just will always find
[2:17:55]
an opportunity to criticize
[2:17:59]
everything that happens here to
[2:18:02]
relitigate completely separate
[2:18:05]
issues And what's in front of
[2:18:08]
us right now is the result of
[2:18:11]
one council member working hand
[2:18:15]
in hand with the housing
[2:18:16]
Commission to put a law on
[2:18:20]
the books to to ensure that
[2:18:22]
every single affordable housing
[2:18:25]
naturally occurring affordable
[2:18:26]
housing complex in San Diego
[2:18:31]
isn't seen as fresh meat from
[2:18:35]
Wall Street investors and
[2:18:38]
people who want to flip homes
[2:18:41]
regardless of what the impact
[2:18:42]
is on community gives San Diego
[2:18:45]
an actual chance to to compete
[2:18:47]
and then council PRESIDENT Pro
[2:18:49]
Tem Lee in partnership with
[2:18:50]
the Housing Commission is
[2:18:51]
making sure that the city has a
[2:18:52]
vehicle to have the funding
[2:18:54]
necessary to actually act on
[2:18:56]
that law.
[2:18:57]
>> This is good.
[2:19:01]
>> So I'm appreciative of
[2:19:02]
the effort that's gone into
[2:19:03]
this.
[2:19:04]
I am glad to see that we are
[2:19:07]
taking actions to ensure that
[2:19:09]
we can do the things that we
[2:19:10]
say we want to do And there are
[2:19:16]
plenty of reasons to be
[2:19:20]
dissatisfied with the state of
[2:19:21]
housing in San Diego.
[2:19:22]
There are plenty of reasons to
[2:19:23]
be dissatisfied with
[2:19:25]
the progress we've made to make
[2:19:27]
San Diego more affordable and
[2:19:31]
this is good.
[2:19:33]
So the last thing I will add
[2:19:37]
and I had a chance to talk
[2:19:38]
about this a little bit earlier
[2:19:40]
alongside my colleagues
[2:19:43]
Councilmember Moreno and
[2:19:43]
Council PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee.
[2:19:44]
But communities like City
[2:19:47]
Heights and other parts of
[2:19:48]
the city that were naturally
[2:19:49]
occurring affordable housing
[2:19:50]
exists and just to make sure
[2:19:52]
that's a technical term so we
[2:19:54]
can like define what we're
[2:19:55]
talking about there Those are
[2:19:56]
typically older homes that have
[2:20:00]
have become more affordable
[2:20:04]
over time or there's a deed
[2:20:06]
restricted affordable housing
[2:20:08]
that is about to where the deed
[2:20:12]
restrictions are about to
[2:20:12]
expire And that is the reason
[2:20:15]
why investors are seeing it as
[2:20:18]
chum in the water.
[2:20:18]
And if we don't do this, what
[2:20:23]
happens is a Wall Street
[2:20:27]
investor or local developer who
[2:20:30]
doesn't care about people comes
[2:20:32]
in, buys a property, kicks
[2:20:33]
the people out who are
[2:20:34]
currently there, flips those
[2:20:36]
units into air quote luxury
[2:20:38]
apartments cause they're not
[2:20:39]
really luxury and that
[2:20:43]
the cycle continues.
[2:20:46]
So some of the folks who've
[2:20:48]
spoken kind of in opposition to
[2:20:51]
this are the same people who
[2:20:53]
talk about caring about
[2:20:54]
community character and
[2:20:55]
the community character that I
[2:20:56]
care about comes from
[2:20:57]
the people who live in those
[2:20:58]
homes And this helps us protect
[2:21:01]
those people.
[2:21:02]
So thank you again everyone who
[2:21:03]
worked on this who put effort
[2:21:05]
in I'm glad we're doing this.
[2:21:07]
This is good.
[2:21:07]
That's why I'm supporting it
[2:21:09]
And we'll vote yes.
[2:21:09]
Thank you.
[2:21:10]
Council PRESIDENT.
[2:21:10]
All right.
[2:21:11]
Thank you.
[2:21:11]
Got Somerville or Rivera We'll
[2:21:12]
go next to council member
[2:21:13]
Whitburn Thank you.
[2:21:14]
Council PRESIDENT Yes this is a
[2:21:15]
great step forward.
[2:21:16]
Thank you to the Housing
[2:21:17]
commission, the planning
[2:21:18]
department for all the work
[2:21:19]
that's gone into it.
[2:21:20]
So many people are struggling
[2:21:21]
with the cost of living in San
[2:21:22]
Diego.
[2:21:23]
The biggest part of that is
[2:21:24]
the cost of housing.
[2:21:25]
We need more housing that is
[2:21:28]
truly affordable And obviously
[2:21:30]
one way to address that is to
[2:21:31]
build more affordable housing.
[2:21:33]
We're doing that.
[2:21:35]
We're doing quite a bit of that
[2:21:36]
in the district I represent
[2:21:38]
here downtown Harrington
[2:21:39]
Heights and the East Village
[2:21:41]
opened up late last year.
[2:21:43]
Jacaranda died in Cortez Hill
[2:21:46]
opened up last month.
[2:21:47]
We got another deed restricted
[2:21:49]
affordable housing project
[2:21:50]
going in up here on six between
[2:21:53]
Cedar and Beach That will be
[2:21:55]
opening before too long.
[2:21:56]
All of those have or will have
[2:21:58]
rents that are restricted based
[2:22:00]
on the renter's income.
[2:22:02]
But as we produce that new
[2:22:04]
affordable housing we can't
[2:22:05]
afford to lose the affordable
[2:22:07]
housing that we already have
[2:22:10]
Lose it because
[2:22:11]
the department's rent
[2:22:12]
restriction expires or because
[2:22:16]
that apartment that simply has
[2:22:17]
a low rent because of
[2:22:18]
the market goes away or is
[2:22:20]
replaced by something more
[2:22:21]
expensive.
[2:22:22]
Otherwise we're just spinning
[2:22:23]
our wheels and we're not
[2:22:25]
actually adding to the overall
[2:22:27]
supply of affordable housing
[2:22:29]
that we so desperately need.
[2:22:30]
That is why this fund is such a
[2:22:32]
big deal.
[2:22:32]
The city dedicating funding
[2:22:35]
specifically for preserving
[2:22:36]
affordable housing is not
[2:22:37]
something that very many cities
[2:22:38]
are doing.
[2:22:39]
This fund as has been
[2:22:41]
discussed, could be used to
[2:22:42]
acquire naturally occurring
[2:22:44]
affordable housing before a
[2:22:46]
private investor snaps it up
[2:22:47]
could be used to preserve deed
[2:22:49]
restricted affordable housing
[2:22:51]
and with the city committing
[2:22:53]
neighborhood enhancement for
[2:22:55]
dollars year over year this is
[2:22:57]
a sustained investment in
[2:22:59]
keeping San Diego affordable.
[2:23:00]
It's not just a one time
[2:23:01]
effort.
[2:23:02]
That's part of the beauty of
[2:23:04]
this.
[2:23:04]
This is going to help renters
[2:23:05]
in my district who currently
[2:23:07]
live in affordable housing and
[2:23:09]
depend on their apartment to
[2:23:12]
remain affordable.
[2:23:14]
It means that when a landlord
[2:23:15]
decides to sell that apartment
[2:23:17]
building in North Park or
[2:23:19]
Hillcrest or Golden Hill a
[2:23:21]
building where people have
[2:23:22]
lived for years and where rents
[2:23:24]
are still affordable,
[2:23:24]
the Housing Commission could
[2:23:26]
have an opportunity to step in
[2:23:27]
and buy it before a private
[2:23:29]
investor does Before Redd's go
[2:23:31]
up, before people get pushed
[2:23:32]
out of their homes and out of
[2:23:34]
their neighborhoods, it'll
[2:23:36]
protect the affordable rents
[2:23:38]
that exist right now and keep
[2:23:39]
them affordable going forward.
[2:23:41]
Every unit that we preserve is
[2:23:43]
a family that doesn't have to
[2:23:45]
move, a family that could stay
[2:23:47]
in the neighborhood.
[2:23:47]
A senior at fixed income who
[2:23:50]
gets to stay in
[2:23:50]
the neighborhood that they have
[2:23:51]
called home for decades a
[2:23:53]
worker who could still afford
[2:23:55]
to live close to where they
[2:23:57]
work.
[2:23:57]
>> We lose thousands thousands
[2:24:00]
of affordable units in this
[2:24:02]
city every year that because
[2:24:04]
they're necessarily tore down
[2:24:06]
but because they're sold and
[2:24:07]
the rents are raised this fund
[2:24:09]
is how we start to fight back
[2:24:10]
against that.
[2:24:11]
So San Diego is doing something
[2:24:13]
genuinely innovative here.
[2:24:14]
I am proud to support it and I
[2:24:16]
will join my colleagues
[2:24:17]
colleagues in thanking all of
[2:24:20]
you who have been involved in
[2:24:21]
this incredibly important work.
[2:24:23]
Thank you.
[2:24:23]
Thank you.
[2:24:23]
Council PRESIDENT All right.
[2:24:24]
>> Thank you Council member
[2:24:26]
Whitburn.
[2:24:26]
And we'll go next to Council
[2:24:27]
member Campbell.
[2:24:28]
Thank you so much for all
[2:24:31]
the comments from all my
[2:24:32]
colleagues that are absolutely
[2:24:33]
correct.
[2:24:34]
I remember gosh back just
[2:24:37]
before I ran for council we
[2:24:39]
lost a large affordable housing
[2:24:44]
complex because the 55 years
[2:24:47]
had run out and it was really
[2:24:50]
difficult to get them to agree
[2:24:53]
with the fact that please help
[2:24:55]
us figure out a way to help
[2:24:56]
these folks who are now elderly
[2:24:58]
and can't move And they got
[2:25:00]
they've been in this thing for
[2:25:01]
55 years So at any rate those
[2:25:06]
times that's the history that
[2:25:07]
led to ideas like this.
[2:25:10]
This is an excellent idea and
[2:25:12]
I'm definitely in favor and I
[2:25:14]
want to thank all my colleagues
[2:25:15]
for this as well as the Housing
[2:25:17]
Commission.
[2:25:18]
Again for your brilliance in
[2:25:20]
trying to help us with our
[2:25:21]
housing situation.
[2:25:22]
Thank you.
[2:25:23]
Thank you, Councilmember
[2:25:24]
Campbell.
[2:25:26]
Not anybody else on the lights
[2:25:28]
I'll add my thank you to member
[2:25:32]
Maureen out Council PRESIDENT
[2:25:32]
Pro Tom Lee the Housing
[2:25:34]
commission excuse me city staff
[2:25:37]
that has done the very good
[2:25:38]
work here going forward and
[2:25:42]
the one thing I want to really
[2:25:43]
emphasize is that nobody is
[2:25:45]
standing up and cheering and
[2:25:46]
saying mission accomplished.
[2:25:47]
This is a huge step towards
[2:25:51]
solving a huge problem and we
[2:25:54]
can't build fast enough.
[2:25:56]
And as my colleagues have said
[2:25:57]
,this is an opportunity to
[2:25:58]
preserve what we have and there
[2:26:01]
is nothing more efficient, more
[2:26:02]
green, more climate action plan
[2:26:04]
friendly than simply preserving
[2:26:06]
the development and buildings
[2:26:08]
that we have already.
[2:26:09]
So this is a huge step.
[2:26:11]
I appreciate the emphasis in
[2:26:14]
getting this place locked into
[2:26:16]
place and then begin to think
[2:26:18]
about what do we do next?
[2:26:19]
Can we leverage this together
[2:26:22]
and are funding other grants
[2:26:24]
philanthropic philanthropy.
[2:26:26]
As council PRESIDENT Pro Tem we
[2:26:29]
talked about so we look forward
[2:26:32]
to once you start getting into
[2:26:34]
the weeds and where you go and
[2:26:38]
this is a good day.
[2:26:40]
It is a a step in the right
[2:26:42]
direction So I'll be supporting
[2:26:44]
as well.
[2:26:44]
So we have a motion by Council
[2:26:46]
PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee and a
[2:26:48]
second by Councilmember Moreno.
[2:26:49]
Clerk Please call the roll I'm
[2:26:54]
sorry the voting system Please
[2:26:55]
cast your vote That passes
[2:27:00]
unanimously unanimously 6 to 0
[2:27:03]
with Council Member Campo,
[2:27:04]
Councilmember Yvonne Wolpert
[2:27:07]
and Councilmember Foster
[2:27:07]
absent.
[2:27:08]
>> Thank you Council PRESIDENT.
[2:27:09]
All right.
[2:27:09]
Thank you And again thank you
[2:27:10]
to staff for the good work.
[2:27:11]
We will now adjourn as
[2:27:13]
the housing authority and
[2:27:14]
reconvene as the City council
[2:27:15]
clerk please introduce item 402
[2:27:19]
items for a Tuesday agreement
[2:27:19]
between the city of San Diego
[2:27:21]
and the San Diego Housing
[2:27:22]
Commission as the agency for
[2:27:24]
the Transfer of Neighborhood
[2:27:25]
Enhancement Fund fees to chc to
[2:27:27]
support the Affordable Housing
[2:27:29]
Preservation Fund.
[2:27:30]
Thank you Council PRESIDENT All
[2:27:32]
right.
[2:27:32]
And staff as you're settling in
[2:27:34]
when you're ready please
[2:27:36]
introduce yourselves for
[2:27:37]
the record and let us know how
[2:27:38]
much time you need.
[2:27:41]
We should only need five
[2:27:42]
minutes.
[2:27:42]
All right.
[2:27:43]
When you're ready.
[2:27:43]
All right.
[2:27:44]
>> Good afternoon, council
[2:27:46]
members.
[2:27:47]
My name is Melissa Garcia and
[2:27:48]
I'm a senior planner with
[2:27:49]
the city planning Department.
[2:27:50]
Today I'm joined by Marlin
[2:27:52]
Pangilinan, program manager
[2:27:54]
with the City Planning
[2:27:54]
Department.
[2:27:55]
We are here to present
[2:27:56]
the agreement between the city
[2:27:58]
of San Diego and the San Diego
[2:27:59]
Housing Commission for
[2:28:00]
the Transfer of Neighborhood
[2:28:01]
Enhancement Fund fees to
[2:28:04]
the San Diego Housing
[2:28:05]
Commission to support
[2:28:06]
the Affordable Housing
[2:28:07]
Preservation Fund.
[2:28:09]
The item proposes the following
[2:28:11]
actions Authorize the mayor or
[2:28:13]
designee to enter an agreement
[2:28:15]
between the city of San Diego
[2:28:16]
and the San Diego Housing
[2:28:18]
Commission to transfer City
[2:28:20]
Neighborhood Enhancement Fund
[2:28:21]
fees to support the Affordable
[2:28:23]
Housing Preservation Fund.
[2:28:25]
And authorize the Chief
[2:28:27]
Financial Officer or designee
[2:28:29]
to appropriate and expend an
[2:28:31]
amount not to exceed 8.5
[2:28:33]
million from the city's
[2:28:34]
Neighborhood Enhancement Fund
[2:28:36]
to the San Diego Housing
[2:28:37]
Commission for the purpose of
[2:28:39]
supporting the Affordable
[2:28:40]
Housing Preservation Fund.
[2:28:43]
The Neighborhood Enhancement
[2:28:45]
Fund consists of fees collected
[2:28:47]
from developers participating
[2:28:48]
in the Complete Community's
[2:28:50]
Housing Solutions program which
[2:28:52]
was adopted in 2020 and is a
[2:28:54]
program that incentivizes
[2:28:56]
housing production here transit
[2:28:58]
while funding neighborhood
[2:28:59]
amenities to be eligible to
[2:29:01]
receive benefits under
[2:29:02]
the Complete Community's
[2:29:03]
Housing Solutions regulations.
[2:29:05]
Applicants must either
[2:29:07]
construct on site public
[2:29:08]
amenities or pay a neighborhood
[2:29:11]
enhancement in lieu fee.
[2:29:12]
50% of the net funds collected
[2:29:16]
are to be used to fund
[2:29:17]
recreation amenities, active
[2:29:19]
transportation and transit
[2:29:21]
infrastructure projects and
[2:29:23]
the remaining 50% of the nef is
[2:29:25]
to be used for affordable
[2:29:26]
housing preservation.
[2:29:30]
>> This action proposes to
[2:29:32]
transfer a neighborhood
[2:29:32]
enhancement fees to the San
[2:29:34]
Diego Housing Commission's
[2:29:35]
Affordable Housing Preservation
[2:29:37]
Fund which is being established
[2:29:39]
under a separate action by
[2:29:40]
the Housing Authority.
[2:29:42]
The Affordable Housing
[2:29:43]
Preservation Fund will acquire
[2:29:45]
and preserve deed restriction
[2:29:46]
deed restricted, restricted and
[2:29:48]
naturally occurring affordable
[2:29:49]
housing for households earning
[2:29:51]
between 30% and 150% of area
[2:29:55]
median income.
[2:29:56]
The fund will also preserve at
[2:29:58]
risk deed restricted affordable
[2:30:00]
housing that is nearing the end
[2:30:02]
of its affordability term.
[2:30:04]
It will also prevent
[2:30:05]
displacement and leverage
[2:30:07]
public and private investment.
[2:30:11]
The staff recommendation is to
[2:30:12]
authorize the mayor or designee
[2:30:14]
to enter into an agreement
[2:30:15]
between the city of San Diego
[2:30:17]
and the San Diego Housing
[2:30:18]
Commission to transfer a city
[2:30:20]
neighborhood Enhancement Fund
[2:30:21]
fees to support the Affordable
[2:30:23]
Housing Preservation Fund and
[2:30:25]
authorize the Chief financial
[2:30:27]
officer or designee to
[2:30:28]
appropriate and expend an
[2:30:30]
amount not to exceed 8.5
[2:30:32]
million from the city's
[2:30:34]
Neighborhood Enhancement Fund
[2:30:35]
to the San Diego Housing
[2:30:36]
Commission for the purpose of
[2:30:38]
supporting the Affordable
[2:30:39]
Housing Preservation Fund.
[2:30:41]
>> That concludes staff
[2:30:42]
presentation.
[2:30:43]
We're available for questions.
[2:30:44]
All right.
[2:30:45]
Thank you for the presentation
[2:30:47]
,Clark Please proceed with
[2:30:48]
public comment.
[2:30:49]
>> Paul Krueger if you can
[2:30:50]
please come forward after that
[2:30:50]
will be allegedly older than
[2:30:57]
Anthony Ramos If you can please
[2:30:57]
come to the front of the room.
[2:31:02]
>> Oh, thank you.
[2:31:03]
First I'd like to clarify that
[2:31:04]
I don't oppose this nor
[2:31:06]
the prior motion I spoke
[2:31:08]
neutrally about them.
[2:31:10]
Secondly, I want to stress that
[2:31:12]
our concerns are as you
[2:31:15]
yourselves have pointed out,
[2:31:17]
the loss of quote unquote
[2:31:19]
naturally occurring affordable
[2:31:21]
housing could be and could have
[2:31:24]
been prevented.
[2:31:25]
I'm not here to relitigate
[2:31:27]
anything.
[2:31:27]
I'm here to stress to you and
[2:31:31]
ask you to please moving
[2:31:33]
forward listen to those who
[2:31:35]
bring a wealth of knowledge and
[2:31:38]
research.
[2:31:39]
Six years ago we told you that
[2:31:42]
commune complete communities
[2:31:43]
and more than that the bonus
[2:31:46]
edu program were destroying
[2:31:48]
naturally occurring affordable
[2:31:50]
housing They were destroying.
[2:31:52]
Market level entry purchase
[2:31:56]
housing by turning those homes
[2:31:58]
into rentals and they were
[2:32:00]
destroying opportunities for
[2:32:02]
truly affordable housing by
[2:32:04]
allowing developers to always
[2:32:07]
choose the moderate income
[2:32:09]
option for their bonus.
[2:32:12]
The moderate income option was
[2:32:14]
100 and is 110% of the area
[2:32:18]
Median income or more than
[2:32:21]
$100,000 a year and resulted in
[2:32:23]
rents of $2,500 for a 417
[2:32:27]
square foot apartment.
[2:32:30]
If you had only listened to us
[2:32:32]
six years ago and simply took a
[2:32:35]
critical look at these two
[2:32:37]
programs, you would have saved
[2:32:39]
a significant number of
[2:32:42]
affordable homes moving
[2:32:44]
forward.
[2:32:45]
You have the opportunity to
[2:32:47]
look critically at with our
[2:32:51]
upcoming neighborhood homes for
[2:32:53]
All of Us program to ask
[2:32:56]
yourself for a viewpoint that
[2:32:58]
do not reflect those with money
[2:33:01]
and lobbying connections who
[2:33:04]
speak with your.
[2:33:06]
>> Thank you for including
[2:33:12]
sentence at the allegedly ultra
[2:33:17]
>> Do you guys smell that It
[2:33:18]
smells like gas all
[2:33:20]
the gaslighting that you guys
[2:33:21]
have done hopefully nobody
[2:33:24]
likes imaginative plays will go
[2:33:24]
up in flames It's so sad
[2:33:26]
because it's like I still
[2:33:27]
understand how you're literally
[2:33:29]
pretending to preserve anything
[2:33:30]
when $8.5 million even if you
[2:33:33]
wanted to preserve those 13,000
[2:33:35]
units it's like 650 bucks.
[2:33:38]
I mean and then you're talking
[2:33:39]
about buying these these
[2:33:40]
affordable housing units that
[2:33:42]
the deed restrictions have gone
[2:33:44]
and how you can afford that And
[2:33:45]
then who's going to take care
[2:33:46]
of it?
[2:33:46]
Dreams for change And then
[2:33:48]
people will die just like they
[2:33:50]
have a tent city to 17 in your
[2:33:51]
district Stephen to last week
[2:33:54]
How cool is that?
[2:33:55]
Thursday and Friday.
[2:33:55]
That's so exciting that it's
[2:33:58]
just 17 and six months.
[2:33:59]
Goodness good thing they're
[2:34:00]
open But yeah they would be a
[2:34:01]
good people to you know go in
[2:34:03]
and take over one of these deed
[2:34:05]
restricted units.
[2:34:06]
I mean how about you guys
[2:34:07]
What's with the 55 years?
[2:34:09]
>> Why do we only do it 55
[2:34:09]
years?
[2:34:10]
So we come to a place like this
[2:34:11]
and like oh my gosh, what are
[2:34:12]
we going to do?
[2:34:13]
Oh dang it, these people are
[2:34:14]
going to sell this unit but
[2:34:16]
we're going to put in an
[2:34:17]
ordinance, We're going to get
[2:34:18]
this money and tell people that
[2:34:19]
if you pay a fee you don't have
[2:34:20]
to create affordable housing
[2:34:22]
even when we need it and there
[2:34:24]
isn't anything affordable Like
[2:34:26]
again you guys sit here and you
[2:34:27]
say it's affordable.
[2:34:28]
How can it be affordable if you
[2:34:30]
have to have a subsidy for it?
[2:34:34]
>> Just wondering are we
[2:34:36]
redefining this just like we
[2:34:37]
did with a woman?
[2:34:38]
So now affordable means that as
[2:34:40]
long as you have to get all of
[2:34:42]
these things to help you pay
[2:34:43]
for that means it's affordable
[2:34:45]
to you.
[2:34:46]
Like you literally get in
[2:34:48]
the way of people being able to
[2:34:50]
thrive in life.
[2:34:51]
It's disgusting because you
[2:34:53]
gaslight the people sitting
[2:34:54]
here saying like This is good.
[2:34:57]
Trust us.
[2:34:57]
This is good right?
[2:34:58]
This is this is so good.
[2:35:01]
So good.
[2:35:02]
It's good.
[2:35:02]
That's all I can say is that
[2:35:04]
it's good.
[2:35:04]
Just trust us.
[2:35:09]
It's bad for real.
[2:35:11]
People are dying at 1030 and
[2:35:13]
you guys won't even shut it
[2:35:14]
down.
[2:35:15]
>> You won't even do anything.
[2:35:16]
But yet you're in litigation
[2:35:17]
with Anthony Robles.
[2:35:25]
Good afternoon, City Council.
[2:35:26]
I wanted to start by thinking
[2:35:29]
Vivian Moreno for explaining
[2:35:31]
exactly what the ordinance does
[2:35:33]
and how one of them establishes
[2:35:35]
the procedure and one of them
[2:35:36]
helps fund the procedure.
[2:35:39]
I want to thank Kent Lee for
[2:35:41]
explaining that as well to add
[2:35:42]
that both of your explanations
[2:35:44]
made a really what was what it
[2:35:45]
was a complicated issue that I
[2:35:49]
didn't understand really helped
[2:35:50]
It really helps break it down
[2:35:52]
so that I could understand it
[2:35:54]
in terms that were more
[2:35:55]
palpable And now it is
[2:35:57]
something that I fully support
[2:35:59]
I am thankful, MISS Campbell
[2:36:01]
for your input, your historical
[2:36:03]
input.
[2:36:04]
I really appreciate you sharing
[2:36:05]
that expertise with regard to
[2:36:08]
the context of the governance
[2:36:10]
of the 55 year lease and how
[2:36:12]
any expire We have to renew
[2:36:13]
them and we have to have
[2:36:14]
the funds to renew them.
[2:36:16]
Every time I come to city
[2:36:17]
council it's always humbling.
[2:36:19]
There's always stuff that I
[2:36:20]
learn.
[2:36:21]
I show up wanting to oppose
[2:36:23]
block and then I learn about
[2:36:24]
tons more issues that I had no
[2:36:27]
idea existed and had no idea
[2:36:29]
how to even interpret.
[2:36:31]
So I'm grateful for the work
[2:36:33]
that's done here.
[2:36:34]
And I also want to acknowledge
[2:36:38]
the cynicism and the lack of
[2:36:44]
trust that comes from repeated
[2:36:48]
public engagement and feeling
[2:36:50]
like there is a what's the word
[2:36:56]
I'm looking for It was in
[2:37:00]
packet It was left behind
[2:37:00]
somebody they were talking
[2:37:02]
about a planning group and they
[2:37:03]
were talking about how
[2:37:03]
the planning groups don't feel
[2:37:04]
like they have an adequate seat
[2:37:05]
at the table.
[2:37:06]
It was the first agenda item
[2:37:08]
unfortunately I was not here
[2:37:10]
for it for that discussion But
[2:37:11]
the point that was raised they
[2:37:14]
mentioned it in the letter that
[2:37:15]
was left behind I feel like it
[2:37:17]
probably got a copy of it but
[2:37:18]
it was mentioning how sometimes
[2:37:20]
it feels like we don't have
[2:37:22]
enough of a seat at the table
[2:37:24]
to really have the input
[2:37:25]
necessary to be qualified.
[2:37:29]
>> Honestly thank you for
[2:37:30]
completing that either by going
[2:37:32]
to time or going to those
[2:37:32]
participating remotely Starting
[2:37:34]
with Hector If you can please
[2:37:35]
unmute.
[2:37:38]
All right.
[2:37:39]
This one is probably going to
[2:37:42]
be the Supreme Court Supreme
[2:37:43]
Court ruling just came down
[2:37:46]
with temporary legal status has
[2:37:48]
been revoked for a million
[2:37:50]
people.
[2:37:51]
So anybody that's got their
[2:37:54]
legal status revoked and send
[2:37:56]
your county has got to leave.
[2:37:58]
So make sure that the roles
[2:38:02]
the roles of the buildings
[2:38:03]
don't have any illegals in them
[2:38:05]
to have to leave.
[2:38:06]
So that would that would clear
[2:38:08]
up housing problem but that
[2:38:10]
would put in more spaces for
[2:38:12]
rent like even 100,000 people
[2:38:15]
are living here illegally work
[2:38:17]
on that problem to deport them
[2:38:20]
That will open up a lot of
[2:38:21]
housing, affordable housing and
[2:38:23]
even some millionaire guys who
[2:38:25]
are here illegally.
[2:38:26]
So that'd be a good reason to
[2:38:28]
do.
[2:38:29]
And then about I'm all for
[2:38:32]
the mayor of Barrio Logan for
[2:38:35]
the new mayor to get some Tesla
[2:38:38]
charging stations down there by
[2:38:41]
the railroad tracks and get
[2:38:43]
the banana company to get those
[2:38:45]
Tesla trucks, the electric
[2:38:48]
trucks are flying off
[2:38:49]
the shelves the time companies
[2:38:52]
are buying them And the Dow guy
[2:38:54]
could set up a thing down there
[2:38:56]
to charge these trucks and give
[2:38:57]
the revenue to Barrio
[2:38:59]
the Barrio Logan Don't let
[2:39:01]
the city get the revenue Have
[2:39:03]
the barrio get that revenue
[2:39:05]
Like maybe it'd be like 500,000
[2:39:08]
a month doing the charging
[2:39:10]
station down there in battery
[2:39:12]
thing that would be and guys
[2:39:15]
could live there and watch it
[2:39:17]
The barrio could I mention it
[2:39:18]
doesn't get tagged They could
[2:39:20]
provide security but no one
[2:39:23]
ever tags the girls under
[2:39:26]
the bridge right where they're
[2:39:28]
tagging their neighborhood in
[2:39:30]
District four but not in
[2:39:32]
the barrio.
[2:39:32]
Logan Nobody tags the murals
[2:39:35]
because they provide security
[2:39:37]
for their own stuff so that
[2:39:39]
would be cool.
[2:39:40]
Okay But thank you.
[2:39:43]
Next is Jonathan please on you
[2:39:45]
Hi.
[2:39:49]
I just wanted to make sure that
[2:39:50]
it was understood with my prior
[2:39:52]
comments that we do support
[2:39:54]
the effort to retain affordable
[2:39:56]
housing.
[2:39:57]
The frustration that we're
[2:39:58]
having is whether or not you
[2:40:01]
know, there's 320 households
[2:40:03]
that were on a used that are
[2:40:05]
going to see those vouchers go
[2:40:07]
away and they will not at this
[2:40:09]
point as we understand it, have
[2:40:11]
a place for them or their
[2:40:13]
families to go.
[2:40:14]
So that's almost 2000 people I
[2:40:19]
you've got that You've got
[2:40:20]
the loss of food stamps where
[2:40:22]
people who are living on
[2:40:23]
the streets there's some sort
[2:40:24]
of insanity that people are
[2:40:26]
going to be believe that those
[2:40:27]
folks are going to be able to
[2:40:28]
get a job or are volunteer for
[2:40:31]
20 hours a week.
[2:40:33]
Clearly this is something
[2:40:34]
designed by people that have no
[2:40:35]
idea and now on top of it in
[2:40:39]
the city where we've had
[2:40:39]
multiple outbreaks amongst this
[2:40:41]
population because of a lack of
[2:40:43]
sanitation, we're taking half
[2:40:46]
or more of the toilets offline
[2:40:48]
that are available to them at a
[2:40:51]
time where they're needed most
[2:40:52]
on top of a place to clean
[2:40:55]
their stuff, to relax and not
[2:40:58]
be harassed.
[2:40:58]
>> Remember we just talked
[2:41:00]
about people investing in
[2:41:01]
parks.
[2:41:03]
People who are experiencing
[2:41:04]
homelessness can't even go to a
[2:41:05]
park without being harassed
[2:41:07]
here And I'll say that And now
[2:41:09]
that I've experienced it I will
[2:41:11]
never again allow to stand up
[2:41:13]
and help somebody who the city
[2:41:15]
cannot help when they've been
[2:41:16]
evicted because now my rv has
[2:41:20]
been targeted and I got one
[2:41:23]
morning and now I have $175
[2:41:25]
ticket and I have left that rv
[2:41:27]
as needed out on the overpass
[2:41:29]
nearby my home for years But
[2:41:33]
since it got tagged now we're
[2:41:35]
targeting So why don't we take
[2:41:36]
some of those resources and
[2:41:38]
target people that are oh I
[2:41:40]
don't know in illegally renting
[2:41:41]
vacation homes so we can free
[2:41:43]
up some housing.
[2:41:44]
>> Thank you.
[2:41:44]
Next is 8700 and then our final
[2:41:49]
speaker is Blair Beekman.
[2:41:58]
Joy Senator, first of all,
[2:42:00]
Councilmember Rivera and
[2:42:01]
Councilmember Moreno, I'm
[2:42:03]
really I can't believe the two
[2:42:06]
of you are just chatting.
[2:42:10]
Councilmember Moreno, this is
[2:42:11]
your big baby.
[2:42:14]
You did get it rolling yet
[2:42:16]
You're sitting there with
[2:42:19]
Councilmember Rivera and you're
[2:42:23]
talking while people are
[2:42:24]
talking and telling you how
[2:42:26]
they feel and what they care
[2:42:28]
about What what you I it's
[2:42:29]
beyond it's beyond me.
[2:42:31]
It's beyond me What I need to
[2:42:41]
believe you are the one thing
[2:42:49]
to which you're my hero You're
[2:42:51]
the one of those 20 or 30
[2:42:53]
meetings You were just here
[2:42:57]
beyond beyond your five star
[2:42:59]
plus into the universe And
[2:43:02]
the presentation tax
[2:43:03]
exemptions.
[2:43:04]
And I wish I could talk to you
[2:43:07]
about which projects are exempt
[2:43:08]
from those we don't qualify
[2:43:11]
for.
[2:43:11]
The ordinance said that it's
[2:43:14]
brilliant These financial
[2:43:15]
solutions are brilliant and why
[2:43:17]
can't I understand the movement
[2:43:19]
of the funds on both of these
[2:43:23]
items?
[2:43:23]
Why can't I?
[2:43:27]
I look at I look at I look at
[2:43:28]
it I'm not good at it.
[2:43:28]
I'll say that.
[2:43:29]
But why can't we understand
[2:43:31]
what you're doing with these
[2:43:33]
funds in the past and now And
[2:43:36]
what was the companion item?
[2:43:38]
I thought they were called a
[2:43:40]
companion item.
[2:43:41]
I'm just lost in the shuffle
[2:43:43]
and I'm doing the best I can.
[2:43:45]
>> Please listen to us.
[2:43:48]
Love to all our next because
[2:43:53]
Blair between please I mean
[2:44:01]
what are we going academy for
[2:44:01]
you I will need to move on If
[2:44:03]
you are having technical
[2:44:04]
difficulties there could be
[2:44:07]
between.
[2:44:08]
Yes, we can hear you.
[2:44:09]
Please proceed.
[2:44:11]
I just got a new phone, so
[2:44:12]
thank you.
[2:44:13]
It's working now.
[2:44:14]
Yeah.
[2:44:15]
I wanted to comment that I
[2:44:17]
enjoyed watching Councilperson
[2:44:20]
Moreno and and their
[2:44:22]
conversations over the past few
[2:44:24]
months Now it's been really
[2:44:26]
engaging I think what they're
[2:44:28]
talking about it seems like But
[2:44:30]
hopefully they can make
[2:44:31]
the arrangements to to listen
[2:44:32]
more to public comment during
[2:44:33]
public comment time as well.
[2:44:36]
I wanted to comment that yeah
[2:44:42]
this item as it can work with
[2:44:44]
the baby asylum I thought of
[2:44:47]
ideas I thought of a community
[2:44:50]
land trust ideas and how well
[2:44:51]
that can be working these items
[2:44:53]
and what the future of that can
[2:44:55]
be.
[2:44:57]
I've always been a really
[2:44:59]
important point that within
[2:45:02]
this if we have a consistent
[2:45:03]
pattern in how we fund our in
[2:45:08]
movies developers then know
[2:45:09]
what to expect and we can be
[2:45:11]
very very clear in the concepts
[2:45:13]
of what truly affordable
[2:45:14]
housing can be about and they
[2:45:17]
can be clear as well And they
[2:45:18]
all understand the rules of
[2:45:19]
the road a lot easier and be
[2:45:22]
more giving I think to be more
[2:45:24]
understanding of what is good
[2:45:26]
policy and good practices
[2:45:27]
instead of the continual casino
[2:45:30]
that we usually practice that I
[2:45:32]
agree work sometimes but other
[2:45:34]
times we just get really really
[2:45:36]
confused and everybody gets
[2:45:37]
lost and hate each other from
[2:45:39]
it, you know And then they say
[2:45:40]
I don't want to ever support
[2:45:41]
for affordable housing again,
[2:45:44]
you know And when you go
[2:45:44]
through that whole pattern and
[2:45:45]
trip instead of just having a
[2:45:47]
nice steady way or just
[2:45:51]
consistently, you know, doing
[2:45:51]
the best practices and I hope
[2:45:53]
you can be working towards that
[2:45:55]
To conclude.
[2:45:56]
Thank you a lot for the words
[2:45:57]
of John Again you mentioned
[2:45:58]
affordable housing.
[2:46:00]
It's really it's importance And
[2:46:01]
can I mention mixed income
[2:46:03]
ideas and ideas?
[2:46:04]
How can we work towards new
[2:46:05]
ideas of mixed income that
[2:46:08]
offers a lot of flexibility and
[2:46:09]
choices in our efforts?
[2:46:11]
>> Thank you.
[2:46:12]
That doesn't appear to comment
[2:46:13]
on this item.
[2:46:16]
>> All right.
[2:46:17]
Thank you.
[2:46:17]
City Clerk Without turning over
[2:46:19]
to colleagues for questions
[2:46:21]
Comments entertain a motion
[2:46:22]
We'll start with the chair of
[2:46:23]
the Land and Housing Committee
[2:46:24]
council PRESIDENT Pro tem we
[2:46:27]
think as a PRESIDENT Whereas
[2:46:28]
the last item helped to
[2:46:29]
establish the Affordable
[2:46:29]
Housing Preservation Fund
[2:46:31]
Outstanding Housing Commission.
[2:46:32]
This item helps to allocate
[2:46:34]
the funding from
[2:46:35]
the Neighborhood Advancement
[2:46:36]
Fund fees to the Housing
[2:46:38]
Commission to complete
[2:46:39]
the other side of it.
[2:46:40]
>> So with that I will move
[2:46:41]
the staff's recommendation.
[2:46:43]
All right.
[2:46:44]
Thank you.
[2:46:44]
So we do have that motion
[2:46:46]
Council PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee
[2:46:47]
and with the staff
[2:46:47]
recommendation I'll go next to
[2:46:49]
Councilmember Moreno.
[2:46:50]
Happy to second item.
[2:46:52]
All right.
[2:46:53]
So we have motion by Council
[2:46:54]
PRESIDENT Pro Tem Lee, a second
[2:46:55]
by Councilmember Moreno to move
[2:46:57]
the staff recommendation.
[2:46:58]
We'll go to my way to say thank
[2:47:02]
you.
[2:47:03]
How did we get dropped?
[2:47:05]
Do you want okay I'll just add
[2:47:09]
my thanks for the good work to
[2:47:11]
do this and I appreciate that
[2:47:13]
brief explanation.
[2:47:14]
Council PRESIDENT Pro Tem Maybe
[2:47:15]
that helps one of the public
[2:47:16]
commenters with that clerk
[2:47:19]
Please call the roll So
[2:47:23]
the voting system please cast
[2:47:24]
your vote That passes
[2:47:29]
unanimously 6 to 0 with
[2:47:30]
Councilmember Campo
[2:47:32]
Councilmember Opening
[2:47:33]
Councilmember Foster Absent.
[2:47:34]
Thank you.
[2:47:35]
Council PRESIDENT All right
[2:47:36]
Again thank you to staff for
[2:47:37]
the item.
[2:47:38]
We will now adjourn as the city
[2:47:39]
council and reconvene
[2:47:41]
the special Housing Authority
[2:47:42]
meeting Clerk Please introduce
[2:47:44]
Housing Authority Item two
[2:47:48]
Authority Item two is
[2:47:49]
the Federal Housing Commission
[2:47:51]
Semiannual Grant Report JULY
[2:47:52]
1st, 2025 through DECEMBER 31st
[2:47:55]
2025.
[2:47:56]
If you'd like to speak to this
[2:47:57]
item please be sure to raise
[2:47:58]
your hand by pressing Star nine
[2:48:00]
or the raise your hand icon Or
[2:48:02]
if you are hearing council
[2:48:03]
chambers please be sure to
[2:48:04]
submit your speakers to the box
[2:48:07]
in the front of the room.
[2:48:08]
Thank you.
[2:48:10]
All right.
[2:48:11]
As you said all yourself in
[2:48:12]
please indicate or scuse me
[2:48:12]
please state your name for
[2:48:15]
the record and let us know how
[2:48:16]
much time you need.
[2:48:19]
Okay?
[2:48:20]
There we go.
[2:48:21]
Good afternoon.
[2:48:21]
I'm Deborah Fishel for
[2:48:23]
the senior vice PRESIDENT Of
[2:48:24]
Community and Strategic
[2:48:25]
Initiatives for the Housing
[2:48:26]
Commission.
[2:48:27]
With me is Polly Toledo,
[2:48:29]
the housing programs manager
[2:48:31]
Are presentation will be six
[2:48:34]
minutes or less.
[2:48:36]
All right.
[2:48:36]
Well hang on the left.
[2:48:38]
All right.
[2:48:39]
We're getting ready.
[2:48:40]
Okay.
[2:48:41]
Let's go to the folks.
[2:48:44]
That's all I did here But I'm
[2:48:45]
going to stop there.
[2:48:47]
I'm going to go there.
[2:48:48]
There we go.
[2:48:51]
So this informational report is
[2:48:53]
being provided in accordance
[2:48:54]
with the resolution number
[2:48:56]
eight 1569 which granted
[2:48:59]
the Housing Commission
[2:49:00]
authority for a number of grant
[2:49:02]
related activities.
[2:49:04]
The report provides information
[2:49:06]
on grant activities for
[2:49:08]
the period of JULY 1st 2025
[2:49:10]
through DECEMBER 31st, 2025.
[2:49:14]
It covers competitive grants,
[2:49:17]
noncompetitive grants and
[2:49:17]
allocations grant funds passed
[2:49:19]
through to the Housing
[2:49:20]
Commission and agreements and
[2:49:22]
contracts executed as a result
[2:49:24]
of these sources of funds.
[2:49:27]
During this reporting period
[2:49:29]
there was activity on 13
[2:49:31]
competitive funding
[2:49:32]
opportunities.
[2:49:33]
This included nine new and four
[2:49:36]
renewal applications.
[2:49:38]
We were notified of seven
[2:49:40]
awards totaling more than $40
[2:49:42]
million.
[2:49:44]
There was one grant request for
[2:49:46]
more than 490,000 that didn't
[2:49:49]
unfortunately didn't advance to
[2:49:50]
the next step in
[2:49:51]
the application process.
[2:49:53]
Finally, five applications for
[2:49:55]
approximately $6.5 million were
[2:49:58]
pending decisions as of
[2:50:00]
DECEMBER 31st 2025.
[2:50:03]
I will now provide you with
[2:50:04]
the remaining grant activity
[2:50:05]
details for this report.
[2:50:10]
The nearly 40.1 million in
[2:50:13]
grant awards came from three
[2:50:14]
sources The California Housing
[2:50:16]
and Community Development
[2:50:17]
Department, the us Department
[2:50:19]
of Housing and Urban
[2:50:20]
Development and the County of
[2:50:22]
San Diego.
[2:50:24]
Please note that this total
[2:50:25]
does not reflect the value of a
[2:50:27]
grant that was awarded but for
[2:50:28]
which the dollar amount was
[2:50:29]
unknown as of DECEMBER 31st,
[2:50:32]
2025 and this total includes
[2:50:35]
only the first year award
[2:50:37]
amount for a grant that has two
[2:50:39]
more one year options
[2:50:44]
approximately 39.2 million in
[2:50:47]
grant awards came from three
[2:50:49]
separate programs administered
[2:50:51]
by the California Housing and
[2:50:53]
Community Development
[2:50:54]
Department, also known as hpd.
[2:50:57]
The programs include Hongqi
[2:50:59]
plus Cal Home and the Local
[2:51:01]
Housing Trust Fund.
[2:51:03]
These awards will help create
[2:51:04]
205 affordable rental
[2:51:06]
apartments including permanent
[2:51:08]
supportive housing units for
[2:51:10]
households experiencing
[2:51:11]
homelessness.
[2:51:13]
Additionally, they will support
[2:51:14]
up to 19 households to be
[2:51:16]
assisted through the housing
[2:51:17]
commissions for first time
[2:51:19]
homebuyer low income program
[2:51:21]
and up to five households
[2:51:23]
through the Accessory Dwelling
[2:51:24]
Unit Finance program.
[2:51:28]
The Commission received more
[2:51:30]
than 727,000 in renewal funding
[2:51:34]
from the federal family
[2:51:36]
Self-sufficiency Program.
[2:51:37]
This money pays for staff to
[2:51:38]
provide families receiving
[2:51:40]
federal rental assistance with
[2:51:42]
financial literacy, employment
[2:51:44]
and similar services to help
[2:51:46]
them become more self-reliant.
[2:51:48]
The Commission also was
[2:51:49]
selected to continue its
[2:51:51]
administration of the county of
[2:51:52]
San Diego's as needed
[2:51:53]
Downpayment and Closing Costs
[2:51:56]
Assistance program.
[2:51:58]
The program offers low interest
[2:52:00]
deferred payment loans for
[2:52:01]
first time homebuyers with low
[2:52:03]
income and makes funds
[2:52:04]
available to moderate income
[2:52:06]
first time homebuyers in
[2:52:07]
designated areas.
[2:52:12]
The final two awards during
[2:52:13]
this reporting period include a
[2:52:16]
$10,000 from the banking
[2:52:17]
institution City Community
[2:52:19]
Investing and Development to
[2:52:20]
support programs of the San
[2:52:22]
Diego City County Reinvestment
[2:52:23]
Task Force.
[2:52:25]
Additionally, we were notified
[2:52:26]
about a first time award of a
[2:52:28]
federal youth homeless
[2:52:30]
demonstration program funds
[2:52:32]
which was granted to
[2:52:33]
the Housing Commission by
[2:52:34]
the San Diego Regional Task
[2:52:36]
Force on Homelessness.
[2:52:38]
The exact amount of the award
[2:52:39]
was unknown at the end of this
[2:52:41]
reporting period but we have
[2:52:42]
since been notified that it is
[2:52:44]
for more than 1.5 million.
[2:52:50]
>> The Commission submitted a
[2:52:52]
letter of interest to
[2:52:53]
the California Wellness
[2:52:54]
Foundation's Economic Safety
[2:52:56]
Net program which unfortunately
[2:52:59]
did not advance to the next
[2:53:01]
stage though our request for
[2:53:03]
approximately 490,000 to
[2:53:06]
provide homelessness prevention
[2:53:07]
assistance did fit within
[2:53:10]
the foundation's strategies.
[2:53:12]
There were limited funds to
[2:53:13]
accommodate all the submissions
[2:53:17]
as the Housing Commission had
[2:53:18]
five submissions to three
[2:53:20]
separate funding opportunities
[2:53:21]
that were pending decision as
[2:53:23]
of DECEMBER 31st 2025.
[2:53:26]
Requests for funding for three
[2:53:27]
separate projects were
[2:53:29]
submitted to
[2:53:29]
the congressionally directed
[2:53:30]
economic development Initiative
[2:53:32]
Community Project Funding
[2:53:34]
through hud.
[2:53:36]
Two of the project requests
[2:53:37]
totaling approximately 4.4
[2:53:39]
million were submitted via
[2:53:40]
the Office of Congressman Scott
[2:53:42]
Peters to support an affordable
[2:53:44]
housing prevention program as
[2:53:46]
well as an integrated recovery
[2:53:48]
support program.
[2:53:50]
Another request for 2 million
[2:53:52]
to support the Velasco
[2:53:53]
redevelopment project was
[2:53:55]
submitted via the Office of
[2:53:57]
Congresswoman Sara Jacobs and
[2:54:00]
application was submitted to
[2:54:01]
the County of San Diego's
[2:54:03]
Community Development Block
[2:54:04]
Grant requesting annual support
[2:54:06]
for the Reinvestment Task Force
[2:54:08]
for more than $121,000.
[2:54:11]
The last pending request at
[2:54:13]
the end of this reporting
[2:54:14]
period was to head for Veterans
[2:54:16]
Affairs supportive housing
[2:54:17]
vouchers not including
[2:54:20]
the budget authority for
[2:54:21]
the rental housing vouchers
[2:54:23]
which is unknown until
[2:54:24]
the vouchers are awarded.
[2:54:26]
The total for these pending
[2:54:27]
grant request was more than 6.5
[2:54:29]
million.
[2:54:34]
The Housing Commission
[2:54:35]
submitted six eligible renewal
[2:54:37]
projects worth a combined total
[2:54:39]
of more than 11.7 million That
[2:54:42]
provided rapid rehousing and
[2:54:43]
permanent supportive housing
[2:54:45]
surface services through
[2:54:47]
the continuum of care.
[2:54:53]
No formal application for
[2:54:57]
the Housing Commission also
[2:54:58]
received two awards of grant
[2:55:00]
funding totaling more than 18.5
[2:55:02]
million.
[2:55:03]
That was passed through from
[2:55:04]
other entities.
[2:55:06]
These awards will be leveraged
[2:55:07]
with the housing Commission's
[2:55:08]
Grant Award from the Homekey
[2:55:10]
Plus program for Starline Place
[2:55:12]
Affordable housing development.
[2:55:14]
>> The funding includes more
[2:55:16]
than 11.5 million in federal
[2:55:20]
community development block
[2:55:22]
grant fundraising passed
[2:55:23]
the pass through by the city of
[2:55:25]
San Diego and 7 million and
[2:55:27]
Federal American Rescue Plan
[2:55:28]
Act general purpose revenue
[2:55:30]
passed through by the county of
[2:55:32]
San Diego.
[2:55:37]
Next up grant funding to
[2:55:38]
the Housing Commission also is
[2:55:39]
reinvested into the community
[2:55:40]
and positively impact the local
[2:55:42]
economy.
[2:55:43]
During the first half of f y 20
[2:55:47]
2623 sub recipient agreements
[2:55:48]
utilized approximately 28.7
[2:55:51]
million in whole or in part
[2:55:53]
from grant funding were
[2:55:55]
executed.
[2:55:56]
Additionally three contracts
[2:55:58]
totaling approximately $122,000
[2:56:02]
and hud Capital Fund program
[2:56:03]
funding were also executed.
[2:56:06]
That concludes our
[2:56:08]
informational report and we're
[2:56:09]
happy to answer any questions
[2:56:10]
you MAY have.
[2:56:11]
All right.
[2:56:11]
Thank you for the work.
[2:56:12]
Thank you for the presentation.
[2:56:15]
Clark, please proceed with
[2:56:16]
public comment.
[2:56:17]
>> If you can please come
[2:56:18]
forward to the microphone And
[2:56:19]
after that is Anthony Ralphs.
[2:56:34]
>> Just because I wish that you
[2:56:34]
guys did all these things that
[2:56:37]
you talk about like you do good
[2:56:39]
presentations and whatnot But I
[2:56:43]
mean it's scary to think about
[2:56:44]
where this youth homeless
[2:56:45]
funding is going to go When you
[2:56:50]
give out money you you don't
[2:56:51]
ensure that it's being used
[2:56:53]
properly, that people aren't
[2:56:54]
being abused.
[2:56:55]
I mean, again, I'm going to
[2:56:56]
bring up Tent City and Lot and
[2:56:59]
the fact that like I don't know
[2:57:04]
the exact number but it's close
[2:57:06]
to 40 people have died at Tent
[2:57:08]
City since it's in session.
[2:57:11]
And Sean, you said you were
[2:57:14]
even going to look into it.
[2:57:15]
You said you care about
[2:57:16]
homeless, that you've been
[2:57:17]
homeless.
[2:57:19]
Why doesn't it matter that
[2:57:20]
those people are dying?
[2:57:21]
Why does it matter that Ciara
[2:57:23]
died on Friday?
[2:57:26]
Why does it matter that people
[2:57:27]
are being raped there?
[2:57:29]
They're like there's rats and
[2:57:30]
infestations but people are
[2:57:32]
losing their lives there.
[2:57:33]
And I just I really don't
[2:57:35]
understand why someone like
[2:57:37]
Steven will I get why he would
[2:57:39]
Because he's an arrogant son of
[2:57:40]
a And that's why he laughed in
[2:57:42]
my face when Tammy died and why
[2:57:46]
he doesn't give a that this
[2:57:48]
older woman died on Thursday
[2:57:50]
and a woman named Sierra died
[2:57:52]
on Friday.
[2:57:54]
How many more?
[2:57:55]
I've asked you guys this for
[2:57:57]
years now.
[2:57:57]
How many people is enough that
[2:58:01]
you will do something about
[2:58:03]
tent City Bro What's the number
[2:58:06]
Is 100 Is it You know like what
[2:58:09]
What is is that threshold where
[2:58:11]
it's like oh that death really
[2:58:12]
matters Where we really should
[2:58:14]
do something about that.
[2:58:16]
I mean you're in litigation
[2:58:17]
federal court for it and you
[2:58:20]
guys were supposed to bring a
[2:58:21]
response today and we'll see
[2:58:23]
what what you've said.
[2:58:24]
But how many is enough I guess
[2:58:32]
if it's not your child it
[2:58:34]
doesn't matter.
[2:58:36]
>> Anthony Robles.
[2:58:43]
>> Afternoon City Council I
[2:58:46]
like to think our city
[2:58:49]
employees for the presentation
[2:58:51]
was a good presentation.
[2:58:54]
Thankful for all
[2:58:54]
the information that's been
[2:58:55]
brought forth today.
[2:58:58]
Um I do have concerns as a
[2:58:59]
member of the public with some
[2:59:01]
of the oversight with regard to
[2:59:03]
some of these facilities has as
[2:59:05]
has been mentioned by Audra.
[2:59:07]
I would hope that we could look
[2:59:08]
into that.
[2:59:09]
I'd hope that we could be more
[2:59:11]
accountable with the funds, how
[2:59:13]
these funds are spent and
[2:59:14]
ultimately how these services
[2:59:16]
are delivered to the people.
[2:59:17]
I have no problem with these
[2:59:18]
funds going to these programs
[2:59:21]
and helping people that need
[2:59:22]
help.
[2:59:23]
I would just hope that we could
[2:59:24]
follow up on the oversight and
[2:59:27]
the supervision and make sure
[2:59:28]
that these programs are as
[2:59:30]
effective in helping people as
[2:59:32]
possible.
[2:59:33]
With regard to the point that I
[2:59:34]
was trying to make earlier,
[2:59:35]
there's a San Diego community
[2:59:37]
planner's committee letter
[2:59:39]
probably was left for all of
[2:59:39]
y'all.
[2:59:40]
And it says these organization
[2:59:42]
organizations exist and provide
[2:59:45]
a meaningful pathway into local
[2:59:46]
government talking about
[2:59:47]
the importance of having
[2:59:48]
members of planning groups
[2:59:50]
participate in the discussions
[2:59:52]
and how we serve as liaison
[2:59:54]
between some of the policies
[2:59:55]
that are implemented here and
[2:59:57]
members of the general public
[2:59:58]
understanding some of
[2:59:59]
the policies that you all
[3:00:00]
implement.
[3:00:01]
I know that this was already
[3:00:02]
discussed in Item se for a one
[3:00:04]
but I just wanted to address it
[3:00:06]
now within the context of
[3:00:07]
saying we can provide that
[3:00:11]
opportunity to help some of
[3:00:12]
these issues become more better
[3:00:14]
known to the public especially
[3:00:15]
with regard to the Housing
[3:00:17]
Commission.
[3:00:17]
The grants, the agreements that
[3:00:19]
are made.
[3:00:20]
But it's in our best interest
[3:00:22]
to have you all support with
[3:00:25]
regard to the human rights
[3:00:29]
issues, the privacy issues,
[3:00:30]
the constitutional amendment
[3:00:32]
issues this morning the Supreme
[3:00:33]
Court handed down a decision
[3:00:37]
with regard to all of our
[3:00:38]
privacy concerns with regard to
[3:00:40]
our location database tracking.
[3:00:43]
I will mention that and non
[3:00:44]
agenda public comment thank you
[3:00:47]
started the five minute time
[3:00:48]
are going to those
[3:00:49]
participating remotely Hector
[3:00:51]
if you can please unmute after
[3:00:53]
that is 8700 and then Blair
[3:00:55]
Beekman.
[3:00:56]
>> It's great for you guys
[3:00:57]
pursue all the grants it's
[3:00:59]
great man Just get on some more
[3:01:01]
grants It also throughout
[3:01:02]
the city but there's also like
[3:01:05]
been talk about taxing the rich
[3:01:08]
so if you want to tax I'm all
[3:01:09]
for taxing the rich politicians
[3:01:12]
like Scott Peters has got $600
[3:01:14]
Million on Google and Sarah
[3:01:17]
Jacobs got 60 million But she's
[3:01:20]
related to MR. Jacobs who's got
[3:01:23]
like a trillion I wouldn't tax
[3:01:26]
him.
[3:01:27]
Let's just put a tax on
[3:01:28]
the wealthy politicians that
[3:01:31]
are in our purview.
[3:01:32]
You and maybe just that million
[3:01:34]
dollars a year to go to
[3:01:36]
the housing fund and see how
[3:01:38]
they like it will set the rich
[3:01:41]
politician as $10 Million So if
[3:01:45]
you got 10 million you should
[3:01:47]
be able to afford not counting
[3:01:49]
your house like you other house
[3:01:53]
and the lawyer that is down But
[3:01:53]
if you got 10 million somewhere
[3:01:55]
that's called rich and we'll
[3:01:57]
just put $1 million a year tax
[3:01:59]
on the politicians and even
[3:02:02]
some of your cronies below you,
[3:02:04]
they might be sitting there
[3:02:06]
talking to people.
[3:02:08]
They might be loaded no kind of
[3:02:10]
trust fund kids or something.
[3:02:12]
But anyway that's what
[3:02:16]
the Housing Commission just one
[3:02:17]
house set a time target one
[3:02:19]
house and try to make it work.
[3:02:21]
However the grants flow or
[3:02:24]
the people that live there see
[3:02:26]
what happens and just one house
[3:02:29]
at a time.
[3:02:29]
It's it's going to be hard to
[3:02:31]
compete with guys with billions
[3:02:33]
of dollars and to them it's
[3:02:35]
just a candy store.
[3:02:36]
They're looking at that
[3:02:37]
property and it's going to be
[3:02:39]
hard for the city to match
[3:02:41]
the funds or it's going to be a
[3:02:43]
kind of it's going to be hard
[3:02:47]
to do.
[3:02:47]
The guys are paying them double
[3:02:48]
What you guys are paying
[3:02:50]
Anyway, good luck.
[3:02:53]
>> 8700 If you can please
[3:02:55]
unmute Joy Senator thank you.
[3:03:05]
San Diego Housing Commission I
[3:03:08]
love grants and I have been
[3:03:10]
concerned about grants due to
[3:03:13]
the way things have been
[3:03:14]
unfolding the last few years So
[3:03:18]
it looks like you're doing
[3:03:19]
better with the competitive
[3:03:21]
grants because at one point I
[3:03:24]
thought we were going to form a
[3:03:25]
working group and analyze what
[3:03:28]
was happening on our not
[3:03:30]
getting competitive grants and
[3:03:32]
that never did happen.
[3:03:33]
I don't know what happened to
[3:03:34]
that working group But anyway
[3:03:37]
it looks like things are really
[3:03:40]
so that applied in a very good
[3:03:41]
way.
[3:03:42]
So thank you very much San
[3:03:44]
Diego Housing Commission for
[3:03:45]
that and keep up the work when
[3:03:49]
we have that other item today
[3:03:51]
on on the Opportunity Fund I
[3:03:54]
was surprised to see that list
[3:03:57]
Nine of the people on that list
[3:04:01]
had zero grant money come in.
[3:04:05]
So you know, I think it is it's
[3:04:09]
much less and that's sad.
[3:04:11]
So hopefully that will change
[3:04:13]
and philanthropists to me are
[3:04:16]
definitely invited to the table
[3:04:18]
as all income levels are
[3:04:20]
invited to our table and we can
[3:04:23]
have a conversation of working
[3:04:24]
together.
[3:04:25]
So thank you Congressman Scott
[3:04:29]
Peters so very much for your
[3:04:31]
work for California and for San
[3:04:33]
Diego And thank you
[3:04:35]
Congresswoman Sarah Jacobs also
[3:04:38]
for your help with the grants.
[3:04:40]
You are very appreciated as are
[3:04:42]
all people that work together
[3:04:44]
to to make our city work and to
[3:04:48]
make all levels of people work
[3:04:51]
together.
[3:04:51]
That is so appreciated.
[3:04:53]
I love to all of you That
[3:04:58]
completes your comments.
[3:05:00]
Yes.
[3:05:00]
Thank you.
[3:05:01]
>> Thank you.
[3:05:02]
Blair Bateman If you can please
[3:05:03]
unmute.
[3:05:04]
>> All right.
[3:05:06]
Thank you Big Ben.
[3:05:08]
Really nice to have a comment
[3:05:09]
from Joy.
[3:05:10]
Thank you.
[3:05:10]
>> I learned a lot from what
[3:05:12]
you just said Grants is a is a
[3:05:15]
new process to me.
[3:05:16]
>> I find it an interesting
[3:05:17]
process to be learning about
[3:05:19]
how our government can function
[3:05:20]
and find ways of funding and so
[3:05:25]
thank you for this item and
[3:05:27]
good luck how this can develop
[3:05:30]
>> Thank you.
[3:05:31]
Thank you John If you can
[3:05:34]
please on you.
[3:05:39]
Yes Thank you for all Thank you
[3:05:41]
again.
[3:05:42]
Hello.
[3:05:42]
Hello John Brady with
[3:05:44]
Experience Advisors Thank you
[3:05:44]
again for this update.
[3:05:47]
I you know I think as we are
[3:05:49]
looking forward to another
[3:05:52]
three years we need to be
[3:05:54]
planning for even more cuts and
[3:06:02]
and and really I guess where my
[3:06:04]
frustrations are as I see
[3:06:05]
the country and therefore our
[3:06:09]
own city heading in a very dark
[3:06:11]
direction when it comes to our
[3:06:13]
support for people in need, our
[3:06:16]
compassion and for people that
[3:06:17]
have been impacted by any
[3:06:19]
number of life struggles and a
[3:06:22]
seemingly comfortable I guess
[3:06:27]
they comfortable way that they
[3:06:28]
society at large wants to
[3:06:30]
accept that it's okay to blame
[3:06:34]
the victim And I don't know how
[3:06:38]
we reverse that but I do know
[3:06:40]
that it does need a unified
[3:06:42]
political voice locally here
[3:06:46]
that is clearly saying we can't
[3:06:48]
do this to our own people.
[3:06:50]
We can't do this to our
[3:06:51]
neighbors, we can't do this to
[3:06:53]
our grandparents.
[3:06:54]
We can't do this to our family
[3:06:55]
members.
[3:06:56]
We can't do this to even those
[3:06:57]
strangers.
[3:06:57]
We don't have.
[3:07:01]
But we've got more belt
[3:07:03]
tightening folks And these
[3:07:05]
decisions are going to get even
[3:07:07]
harder as we move forward.
[3:07:08]
>> Thank you.
[3:07:10]
That does include public
[3:07:12]
comment for this item.
[3:07:13]
All right.
[3:07:13]
Thank you, city clerk.
[3:07:14]
And with that I'll turn it over
[3:07:15]
to my colleagues.
[3:07:17]
This is an information item so
[3:07:18]
no motion is required.
[3:07:19]
>> I'll go to Council member
[3:07:21]
Whitburn.
[3:07:22]
Thank you.
[3:07:23]
Council PRESIDENT Thank you for
[3:07:24]
this report.
[3:07:25]
Applying for these grants is
[3:07:27]
critical work.
[3:07:28]
It's a lot of work and
[3:07:29]
the effort that you put into it
[3:07:31]
is very much appreciated.
[3:07:33]
Understanding that this report
[3:07:34]
gives us the status as of
[3:07:36]
the end of last year DECEMBER
[3:07:37]
31st that there were six
[3:07:39]
pending grants at that time.
[3:07:42]
Do you know if we've heard of
[3:07:44]
any of those pending six grants
[3:07:45]
since then?
[3:07:46]
I fear that at your fingertips
[3:07:48]
if you don't we can follow up.
[3:07:49]
But I'm curious if you've heard
[3:07:51]
one way or the other.
[3:07:53]
>> Yeah, I don't have that
[3:07:54]
information in my fingertips
[3:07:55]
right now but we have heard
[3:07:56]
back on probably most of them.
[3:07:58]
Yeah.
[3:07:58]
And we can certainly provide
[3:08:00]
you with that information.
[3:08:01]
Thank you.
[3:08:02]
We did get some good news late
[3:08:04]
on Friday.
[3:08:05]
Not part of this program but
[3:08:07]
that the state's hap program is
[3:08:10]
going to be fully funded during
[3:08:13]
the last budget And this MAY be
[3:08:16]
a question for Lisa.
[3:08:18]
We were forced to cut 50 beds
[3:08:21]
at the 60 Newton shelter
[3:08:24]
because there wasn't enough
[3:08:26]
money to fund them all.
[3:08:27]
Understanding that we got this
[3:08:29]
news late Friday and you know
[3:08:30]
it's the middle of the day on
[3:08:32]
Monday.
[3:08:33]
Do you have any idea yet
[3:08:35]
whether the full funding will
[3:08:37]
enable us to keep those 50
[3:08:38]
beds?
[3:08:40]
>> No, I don't.
[3:08:41]
It's wonderful to see
[3:08:42]
the amount of funding that has
[3:08:43]
come through and for the state
[3:08:44]
to really step up And I think a
[3:08:46]
lot of the advocacy that
[3:08:47]
happened with this council and
[3:08:48]
with this mayor MAY have to
[3:08:50]
make that happen.
[3:08:52]
And shelter is definitely an
[3:08:53]
eligible use for those funds.
[3:08:55]
But we'll need to meet with
[3:08:57]
the city's Homeless Strategies
[3:08:59]
and Solutions department
[3:09:00]
obviously have conversations
[3:09:01]
with Council and the mayor
[3:09:02]
about where that funding can
[3:09:05]
go.
[3:09:05]
>> Okay.
[3:09:06]
Thank you very much.
[3:09:07]
Appreciate that And thank you
[3:09:09]
again for all the work to bring
[3:09:10]
in funding and thank you
[3:09:12]
Council PRESIDENT.
[3:09:13]
All right.
[3:09:14]
Thank you Council member
[3:09:14]
whitburn.
[3:09:16]
I don't see anybody else lights
[3:09:17]
I'll just have my thank you for
[3:09:18]
the good work and clearly you
[3:09:20]
have the secret sauce of going
[3:09:22]
after grants and securing
[3:09:23]
the wins on that.
[3:09:25]
So when there's too little
[3:09:26]
resources it's incredibly
[3:09:28]
important to do that.
[3:09:29]
Good work.
[3:09:30]
So thank you.
[3:09:32]
>> Thank you.
[3:09:33]
With that we will now proceed
[3:09:34]
with the approval of
[3:09:35]
the Housing Authority minutes.
[3:09:37]
>> clerk Please proceed with
[3:09:39]
public comment.
[3:09:40]
>> Thank you.
[3:09:41]
The public comment period for
[3:09:42]
the housing authority minutes
[3:09:43]
is now open and please note
[3:09:44]
each speaker will have three
[3:09:46]
will have one minute per item
[3:09:47]
per person up to a maximum of 3
[3:09:50]
minutes or 3 minutes on
[3:09:51]
the agenda.
[3:09:51]
Tuesday, MAY 12th, 2026 Regular
[3:09:54]
Meeting Tuesday, JUNE 9th, 2026
[3:09:56]
Regular meeting and Monday,
[3:09:57]
JUNE 15th, 2026 Special meeting
[3:10:01]
and allegedly order if you can
[3:10:03]
please come forward.
[3:10:10]
>> You'll have three minutes to
[3:10:12]
speak on all three dates.
[3:10:17]
>> So you're talking about
[3:10:18]
bonds for housing homeless
[3:10:19]
programs, litigation and these
[3:10:22]
three meetings and you know
[3:10:23]
we're getting in debt to
[3:10:27]
pretend to provide housing.
[3:10:32]
I just find it extremely
[3:10:33]
difficult to like proceed when
[3:10:39]
you guys hear people have died
[3:10:42]
in your programs and it doesn't
[3:10:44]
bother you enough to go, We
[3:10:47]
should really look into that.
[3:10:48]
>> We should figure out why
[3:10:52]
this is happening.
[3:10:52]
>> I mean, Steven why why
[3:10:53]
aren't you doing that?
[3:10:54]
Why is it funny to you?
[3:11:03]
>> Everything done in the dark
[3:11:05]
will come to the light And it
[3:11:07]
does And it's sad because it's
[3:11:09]
like I mean these people are
[3:11:14]
put in like a prison there.
[3:11:15]
You guys spend money at Tent
[3:11:17]
City to put up a fence that is
[3:11:20]
a wired like the ones that
[3:11:22]
usually have the spikes going
[3:11:23]
out.
[3:11:24]
Like you go to a hotel and you
[3:11:25]
see it because you don't want
[3:11:26]
someone coming in But it tent
[3:11:29]
city they're facing in like
[3:11:30]
these people can't get out and
[3:11:32]
you put them in fire danger by
[3:11:34]
continuing to add tents and
[3:11:37]
it's like you can't even see
[3:11:38]
your way out of there and
[3:11:40]
there's no fireworks Seeing
[3:11:41]
wishers if there was a fire in
[3:11:44]
Fenton, all is being dealt
[3:11:44]
there and people are dying on
[3:11:48]
it on a regular basis And yet
[3:11:51]
Dreams for Change continues to
[3:11:53]
get more funding because that's
[3:11:57]
your friend Stephen and that's
[3:12:00]
why you don't give a that
[3:12:03]
these people are dying.
[3:12:04]
That's like three people a
[3:12:05]
month so far this year and
[3:12:13]
everybody just sits there like
[3:12:15]
who cares?
[3:12:21]
And you wonder why people don't
[3:12:23]
trust you.
[3:12:25]
I'm not talking about someone
[3:12:27]
taking a out on the sidewalk
[3:12:29]
which happens all the time to
[3:12:31]
allow people to come and clean
[3:12:32]
it up.
[3:12:32]
I'm talking about a life lost
[3:12:36]
and you guys sit up here and
[3:12:38]
act like you care about people
[3:12:39]
But this falls upon deaf ears
[3:12:42]
and we just keep giving them
[3:12:44]
more money.
[3:12:47]
Make it make sense.
[3:12:50]
Why don't their lives matter
[3:12:52]
enough to like question what's
[3:12:57]
going on to go?
[3:12:59]
Maybe we should look into this
[3:13:00]
funding, make sure it's really
[3:13:02]
going somewhere that is
[3:13:04]
beneficial to people.
[3:13:05]
I mean if Theresa Smiths wants
[3:13:07]
people to stay there as long as
[3:13:09]
possible I mean that's
[3:13:12]
terrifying and literally they
[3:13:14]
die before they'll ever get
[3:13:15]
into housing.
[3:13:16]
>> How sad going to those
[3:13:20]
participating online.
[3:13:21]
John Stump if you can please
[3:13:23]
unmute and let me know which
[3:13:25]
item or items of minutes you
[3:13:27]
wish to speak to.
[3:13:29]
Oh excuse me.
[3:13:30]
I thought this was public
[3:13:31]
comment.
[3:13:32]
They'll be next.
[3:13:33]
I'll come back to you John
[3:13:36]
Please let me know which item
[3:13:38]
or items you wish to speak to
[3:13:39]
on the minutes.
[3:13:44]
I'm sorry at that.
[3:13:44]
This public comment goes well.
[3:13:47]
I have you We'll come back to
[3:13:48]
you right now Blair Beekman on
[3:13:50]
the minutes Well where do you
[3:13:53]
know where Big Ben I'm going to
[3:13:55]
wait to for public comment
[3:13:57]
Sorry about sorry.
[3:14:00]
>> Okay.
[3:14:00]
That does conclude the public
[3:14:01]
comment on the minutes or I
[3:14:06]
think you said sorry or I think
[3:14:07]
you city Clerk And with that
[3:14:08]
I'm going to make a motion to
[3:14:09]
approve the minutes.
[3:14:09]
Can I get a second
[3:14:11]
Councilmember Marina Beach out
[3:14:13]
Not anybody else seeking to
[3:14:15]
speak So motion by myself and
[3:14:15]
the second by Councilmember
[3:14:19]
Moreno.
[3:14:20]
Clerk please call the roll.
[3:14:22]
>> I'm sorry The voting system
[3:14:23]
Please cast your vote That
[3:14:32]
passes unanimously 6 to 0 with
[3:14:34]
Council member Campo,
[3:14:35]
Councilmember Yvonne Wolpert
[3:14:37]
and Councilmember Foster
[3:14:37]
absent.
[3:14:37]
Thank you Council PRESIDENT.
[3:14:39]
All right.
[3:14:39]
We will now adjourn as a
[3:14:40]
housing authority and reconvene
[3:14:41]
as the City council and take up
[3:14:44]
non agenda public comment.
[3:14:45]
Council members respect and
[3:14:46]
appreciate the public's input.
[3:14:48]
I fully committed to protecting
[3:14:49]
every participant's free speech
[3:14:50]
rights at council and committee
[3:14:51]
meetings.
[3:14:52]
>> Clerk Please proceed with
[3:14:53]
public comment.
[3:14:55]
>> Thank you.
[3:14:55]
Council PRESIDENT Per rule 2.7
[3:14:57]
on agenda Public comment is an
[3:14:58]
opportunity for members of
[3:14:59]
the public to comment on items
[3:15:00]
that are not on the agenda but
[3:15:02]
within the subject matter
[3:15:03]
jurisdiction of the City
[3:15:04]
Council.
[3:15:04]
Each speaker will have two
[3:15:05]
minutes.
[3:15:06]
Please note if there are eight
[3:15:07]
or more speakers on a single
[3:15:08]
topic the maximum time for
[3:15:09]
the topic will be 16 minutes.
[3:15:11]
If you're in chambers please
[3:15:12]
submit your speaker slip If
[3:15:13]
you're joining us virtually
[3:15:14]
please raise your hand to speak
[3:15:15]
by tapping the raise your hand
[3:15:16]
icon or if you are calling on
[3:15:18]
Participant Star nine allegedly
[3:15:22]
Audrey if you can please come
[3:15:22]
forward And then Anthony Ralph
[3:15:25]
so he can please come to
[3:15:26]
the yellow reserved seats at
[3:15:27]
the front of the room.
[3:15:31]
It's interesting I wasn't here
[3:15:32]
earlier because I was in care
[3:15:34]
court now for myself.
[3:15:36]
But hearing what they're going
[3:15:37]
to do with Andrea being and
[3:15:39]
it's such an educational
[3:15:41]
experience just observing
[3:15:44]
things like a board like this
[3:15:46]
being in court and seeing how
[3:15:48]
they use competency And then I
[3:15:51]
think about how I'm telling you
[3:15:52]
guys about people dying that
[3:15:54]
are part of your community and
[3:15:56]
that involve really people
[3:15:59]
don't care.
[3:15:59]
So I would think I mean you
[3:16:01]
guys should be evaluated for
[3:16:02]
competency to see I mean are
[3:16:05]
you you you know if you don't
[3:16:07]
really care about human life
[3:16:08]
but you're saying that you do I
[3:16:09]
mean perhaps you're incompetent
[3:16:11]
and perhaps you guys should be
[3:16:13]
sent to one of the psychiatric
[3:16:15]
facilities and medicated until
[3:16:17]
you can be deemed competent.
[3:16:19]
Right.
[3:16:19]
And somebody like me because
[3:16:21]
this is how it goes Like
[3:16:22]
someone like you guys would
[3:16:23]
deem me incompetent because I
[3:16:25]
don't go along with your
[3:16:26]
ideologies.
[3:16:27]
So imagine someone like me
[3:16:29]
doing that to you and saying
[3:16:31]
that the way that you feel is
[3:16:34]
means that you are incompetent
[3:16:37]
It's interesting the way
[3:16:38]
the world works and if you
[3:16:39]
don't just kind of capitulate
[3:16:41]
and go along and conform then
[3:16:44]
you're seen as somebody who
[3:16:46]
needs their behavior changed
[3:16:48]
And it's like I literally could
[3:16:49]
say that about you guys seeing
[3:16:51]
that you don't care that people
[3:16:52]
are dying all while professing
[3:16:55]
that you do.
[3:16:57]
>> But it's interesting the way
[3:16:59]
that it's used to silence
[3:17:00]
people And sure there's people
[3:17:03]
that are incompetent
[3:17:04]
potentially and need help and
[3:17:06]
wouldn't be able to, you know,
[3:17:07]
go through trial.
[3:17:09]
>> But when it's literally
[3:17:10]
being used to silence the truth
[3:17:12]
about the people that are
[3:17:13]
actually engaged in this care
[3:17:15]
court and whatnot, what a smart
[3:17:19]
weapon to use.
[3:17:20]
You know what I'm saying?
[3:17:22]
But imagine being that person.
[3:17:23]
Thank GOD it's not you guys.
[3:17:25]
Right?
[3:17:26]
Right.
[3:17:28]
Maybe it'll be one of your
[3:17:29]
children.
[3:17:29]
>> Who knows?
[3:17:30]
We'll see who's in charge.
[3:17:35]
Anthony Rose Yes, I will read
[3:17:41]
today's reading from
[3:17:42]
the Supreme Court.
[3:17:44]
But first I just want to
[3:17:44]
acknowledge that there is an
[3:17:46]
inherent conflict of interest
[3:17:47]
between those that want to
[3:17:48]
leave work early and can do so
[3:17:50]
with a short workday with which
[3:17:53]
is facilitated by minimal
[3:17:55]
public engagement and those
[3:17:57]
members of the public that wish
[3:17:58]
to have a robust, engaged,
[3:18:00]
fully informed discussion that
[3:18:02]
often requires extended hours
[3:18:03]
of additional city council
[3:18:04]
participation.
[3:18:06]
So when the vast majority of
[3:18:07]
your constituents demand you
[3:18:09]
respect our concept of our
[3:18:11]
constitutional protected
[3:18:11]
privacy rights over your own
[3:18:14]
esdp sponsored perception of
[3:18:16]
public safety, it sends us
[3:18:18]
the message that you prioritize
[3:18:20]
getting off work early over
[3:18:22]
doing your job.
[3:18:25]
So here's the article You've
[3:18:27]
probably had a chance to read
[3:18:28]
it But this morning the Supreme
[3:18:29]
Court ruled that when law
[3:18:30]
enforcement officials used a
[3:18:32]
geofence warrant a warrant that
[3:18:33]
instructed Google to provide
[3:18:34]
location data for cell phone
[3:18:36]
users who were near a
[3:18:37]
particular place during a
[3:18:39]
specified time period to obtain
[3:18:41]
evidence used to convict a
[3:18:42]
Virginia man of a 2019 bank
[3:18:44]
robbery.
[3:18:44]
They conducted a quote search
[3:18:46]
for the purposes of the Fourth
[3:18:47]
Amendment By a vote of 6 to 3
[3:18:50]
the justices sent Okello
[3:18:53]
Patrice's case back to
[3:18:53]
the lower court for it to
[3:18:54]
consider whether his Fourth
[3:18:55]
Amendment requires the search
[3:18:57]
was quote reasonable.
[3:18:58]
Writing for the majority,
[3:19:00]
Justice Elena Kagan emphasized
[3:19:01]
that quote An individual has a
[3:19:03]
reasonable expectation of
[3:19:05]
privacy in records about his
[3:19:07]
cell phone's location and
[3:19:08]
police intrude on that
[3:19:10]
constitutionally protected
[3:19:12]
interest when they demand
[3:19:13]
the information even though for
[3:19:14]
only a limited time and from a
[3:19:16]
third party tech company there
[3:19:22]
we have it the Supreme Court
[3:19:23]
decided this morning that our
[3:19:26]
location data on our on our
[3:19:28]
cell phones is not fair game
[3:19:30]
for third party applications to
[3:19:33]
be utilized to track us.
[3:19:36]
That should be a clear cut case
[3:19:39]
>> There are lawsuits all over
[3:19:40]
the state of California against
[3:19:43]
Floc Thank you for that
[3:19:44]
concluding remark Five minute
[3:19:45]
time We're going to those
[3:19:46]
participating online.
[3:19:48]
We currently have nine speakers
[3:19:49]
in the queue starting with
[3:19:50]
John.
[3:19:50]
>> If you can please unmute.
[3:19:54]
>> Good evening City Council.
[3:19:55]
My first comment is that public
[3:20:00]
comment should be at
[3:20:01]
the beginning of the meeting or
[3:20:02]
you should at least provide
[3:20:03]
the opportunity for a number of
[3:20:05]
people to speak at
[3:20:06]
the beginning of the meeting.
[3:20:07]
Because in part public comment
[3:20:08]
is so that our voices are heard
[3:20:10]
not only by us, not only by you
[3:20:12]
but other members of
[3:20:13]
the community.
[3:20:16]
Secondly, I want to explain to
[3:20:17]
you what it's like to be a
[3:20:18]
target.
[3:20:19]
I have had my rb now for two
[3:20:22]
years.
[3:20:23]
I have regularly parked it on
[3:20:24]
the nearby overpass where semi
[3:20:27]
tractor trailers parked
[3:20:28]
limousines, other commercial
[3:20:30]
businesses, vehicles got junk
[3:20:34]
trailers.
[3:20:35]
>> But for the moment until
[3:20:38]
the moment somebody was
[3:20:39]
identified as living in there
[3:20:41]
And then I became a marked
[3:20:43]
vehicle.
[3:20:45]
So now 17 members of
[3:20:47]
the community policing
[3:20:48]
department are out and actively
[3:20:51]
aware of where my vehicle is
[3:20:53]
And now I've got 275 to $75
[3:20:57]
ticket with no warning for
[3:20:59]
trying to help.
[3:21:00]
That's my office.
[3:21:01]
That's the place we used to do
[3:21:03]
surveys.
[3:21:04]
That's the place I've never
[3:21:05]
allowed anybody to live on it
[3:21:07]
at least while I was out in a
[3:21:08]
public space.
[3:21:09]
So I'm a little in shock here
[3:21:11]
how quickly we're able to act
[3:21:12]
on that.
[3:21:13]
>> But we can't pick up a911
[3:21:14]
call.
[3:21:17]
We've got to figure out where
[3:21:18]
our priorities are.
[3:21:20]
And right now going into this
[3:21:22]
whole budget negotiation, I
[3:21:24]
thought homelessness was off
[3:21:26]
the table.
[3:21:27]
And then I thought well, we're
[3:21:29]
going to cut the new center not
[3:21:30]
one member of the Community
[3:21:32]
Budget Alliance or any of
[3:21:33]
the other people that I know
[3:21:34]
that advocate for homeless
[3:21:36]
individuals had any clue when
[3:21:38]
that went through that it was
[3:21:39]
going to permanently close
[3:21:40]
the neon good day center.
[3:21:42]
We've been your close partner
[3:21:44]
on this and I'll tell you I
[3:21:45]
feel violated.
[3:21:48]
Our trust is gone.
[3:21:51]
And that's a sad place to be.
[3:21:54]
>> Thank you, Blair Beckman If
[3:21:57]
you can place on you.
[3:22:00]
All right.
[3:22:01]
Thank you.
[3:22:02]
Plan b friends?
[3:22:02]
Yeah.
[3:22:02]
I thought we were working on a
[3:22:04]
six day plan for the future of
[3:22:07]
New York State Center.
[3:22:07]
I was pretty shocked in what
[3:22:08]
you've decided.
[3:22:09]
I understand your decision and
[3:22:11]
how it can be working.
[3:22:13]
But the previous speaker is
[3:22:15]
offering a lot of good public
[3:22:17]
comment What we actually need
[3:22:20]
within the data center and we
[3:22:20]
have to be having that
[3:22:21]
conversation more openly and
[3:22:24]
regularly.
[3:22:25]
As I've been mentioning myself
[3:22:26]
I've been trying to mention
[3:22:27]
John is up in the actual words
[3:22:29]
Good luck in that effort.
[3:22:31]
So what we can be talking about
[3:22:32]
openly and I also wanted to
[3:22:35]
mention there's been a lot of
[3:22:37]
talk about encampment issues
[3:22:40]
You know, or the government
[3:22:41]
sponsored camp I heard before
[3:22:44]
here you know that instead of
[3:22:47]
you know, the 2 to 300 person
[3:22:49]
site in San Diego, San Jose's
[3:22:52]
model, they work, you know, in
[3:22:54]
a much smaller frame you know,
[3:22:56]
35 to 50, 25 to 35 spaces for
[3:23:00]
people.
[3:23:00]
We can have one space in San
[3:23:02]
Diego to say 100 people and
[3:23:04]
then you know, create 3 or 4
[3:23:06]
little smaller spaces that I
[3:23:09]
think we can much better manage
[3:23:10]
people and people will just be
[3:23:12]
dying the way they currently
[3:23:14]
are.
[3:23:15]
This large encampment is
[3:23:16]
creating a lot of again and we
[3:23:19]
got to really consider our
[3:23:20]
different options from that.
[3:23:22]
So good luck on those efforts.
[3:23:23]
Good luck that we can be
[3:23:25]
listening to Andrea Evans case
[3:23:26]
what she can be doing, what we
[3:23:29]
can be doing for her so she can
[3:23:30]
be free and regular She
[3:23:33]
deserves it.
[3:23:35]
I thank you for the words of
[3:23:36]
Anthony.
[3:23:38]
She actually mentioned concepts
[3:23:39]
that we're working on in 2018
[3:23:41]
We stopped something in 2018.
[3:23:44]
Good work.
[3:23:45]
We can continue what he's
[3:23:46]
talking about and from that
[3:23:47]
really address your issues in
[3:23:49]
real time.
[3:23:50]
There's a lot of subtlety in
[3:23:52]
what he said and how he can and
[3:23:55]
can't work that we need to more
[3:23:57]
openly address And I'll talk
[3:23:58]
about more tomorrow a lot more
[3:24:02]
I need to say good luck with
[3:24:04]
our public process right now,
[3:24:05]
concluded Francine Maxwell.
[3:24:07]
>> If you can please on your
[3:24:13]
Nancy Maxwell Southeastern San
[3:24:14]
Diego resident I want to thank
[3:24:16]
the council for the education
[3:24:18]
that came when I was
[3:24:20]
misdirected.
[3:24:22]
Really appreciate that.
[3:24:24]
Now let's parlay that since
[3:24:26]
there are so many upcoming
[3:24:28]
legislative breaks, let's do it
[3:24:30]
Educational series.
[3:24:31]
Let's go to some parking risks
[3:24:33]
and let's make sure that we try
[3:24:36]
to educate the community all
[3:24:38]
year long.
[3:24:39]
I would like your first thing
[3:24:40]
to be educational wise How can
[3:24:44]
Steve Cushman be an advisor to
[3:24:47]
the city, to the mayor's office
[3:24:48]
and be on the Housing
[3:24:50]
Commission?
[3:24:52]
So it would seem like that
[3:24:53]
would be a conflict to me.
[3:24:55]
I completely understand that
[3:24:56]
everybody is looking for their
[3:24:58]
next gig and so Steve Cushman
[3:25:01]
is not looking for his next gig
[3:25:02]
because he's pretty much
[3:25:03]
running our city.
[3:25:04]
But the mayor is absolutely
[3:25:07]
parlaying his dc trips and so
[3:25:10]
maybe he's looking to get a
[3:25:11]
position in hud or something.
[3:25:14]
>> We don't have all
[3:25:15]
the receipts but it seems like
[3:25:17]
elected officials continue to
[3:25:20]
hold things close to the vest
[3:25:22]
And when somebody needs a good
[3:25:24]
piece of press things come out
[3:25:27]
very appreciative of District
[3:25:29]
nine sharing with my neighbors
[3:25:30]
that our elected official is on
[3:25:33]
official business Love our
[3:25:35]
neighbor National City Council
[3:25:36]
member markets took a picture
[3:25:38]
of our council member on a bus
[3:25:41]
with our Board of Supervisors
[3:25:43]
vice chair just wonderful
[3:25:46]
communication through social
[3:25:47]
media.
[3:25:48]
So we're hoping that in
[3:25:50]
the newsletter there will be a
[3:25:51]
report in reference to
[3:25:53]
the Baltimore official trip.
[3:25:55]
>> Again, all city officials
[3:25:57]
take all of these official
[3:25:59]
trips.
[3:26:00]
You sit on other boards and
[3:26:02]
commissions, some of them are
[3:26:04]
paid, some of them are not.
[3:26:05]
But there never an educational
[3:26:08]
component or a component to
[3:26:09]
the constituents.
[3:26:11]
So let's do better.
[3:26:12]
Let's begin to educate the next
[3:26:14]
generation.
[3:26:15]
Thank you.
[3:26:16]
Thank you.
[3:26:16]
8700 If you can please unmute
[3:26:18]
8700 city for committees so I
[3:26:27]
can shape my comments is this
[3:26:31]
each day this is not agenda
[3:26:32]
public comment for the whole
[3:26:36]
meeting for the for the city
[3:26:38]
council meeting yes but there
[3:26:41]
was no agenda Public comment No
[3:26:44]
because it was a special
[3:26:45]
meeting for you.
[3:26:51]
Okay Thank you.
[3:26:52]
We just catch my breath here a
[3:26:54]
minute.
[3:26:56]
Had two plans so we will need
[3:26:59]
to start your time out.
[3:27:05]
I think you I need to finish on
[3:27:06]
this because I.
[3:27:07]
I don't know.
[3:27:09]
I'm coming strictly from
[3:27:11]
extemporaneous and then I think
[3:27:14]
I need to begin to get it out
[3:27:20]
of joy to I voted yes for this
[3:27:22]
week since we think
[3:27:29]
the ordinance a small minority
[3:27:32]
voted yes I'm never forget that
[3:27:33]
day and here we are That's what
[3:27:38]
we to where we are now And let
[3:27:40]
me tell you that I still
[3:27:42]
believe in our case.
[3:27:50]
We think of and pivot away from
[3:27:52]
that.
[3:27:54]
I'm using a lens to look at
[3:27:57]
the world.
[3:27:59]
It's different for each of us
[3:28:01]
that's proven scientifically
[3:28:03]
and to my lens I can't see all
[3:28:07]
the ugliness I'm hearing.
[3:28:10]
I don't I've never witnessed it
[3:28:12]
yet.
[3:28:13]
I respect the people that are
[3:28:15]
sharing their truth So I'm I to
[3:28:18]
become sort of a rock and a
[3:28:19]
hard place.
[3:28:21]
I worked with the homeless for
[3:28:23]
20 years.
[3:28:24]
David lost both my hair
[3:28:28]
the water man He lived in
[3:28:30]
the trenches Not really that he
[3:28:32]
lived there as a hero and he
[3:28:34]
told me a lot And these people
[3:28:42]
they have stories that are
[3:28:43]
beyond belief So we transition
[3:28:46]
them from the streets into an
[3:28:49]
enclosed space.
[3:28:50]
He could save sleeping sight,
[3:28:55]
make it safe and comfortable
[3:28:56]
and take care of them.
[3:28:58]
I don't know.
[3:29:00]
It's a big transition.
[3:29:01]
Let's talk more later with Joel
[3:29:04]
Thank you, Kathleen Lippert.
[3:29:10]
Thank you.
[3:29:11]
Good afternoon.
[3:29:12]
Council and the public drug
[3:29:14]
policy researcher.
[3:29:16]
I follow drug research and best
[3:29:18]
practices for decades.
[3:29:20]
The year to year data is
[3:29:21]
important but it is the long
[3:29:24]
term trend of drug use that are
[3:29:27]
that are the best indicators of
[3:29:30]
a city's policies Whether or
[3:29:32]
not they're preventing harms or
[3:29:34]
contributing to collateral
[3:29:36]
damage.
[3:29:37]
The report I want to share
[3:29:39]
today with Council is from
[3:29:41]
the American Society of
[3:29:43]
Addiction Medicine, which
[3:29:44]
followed cannabis policy
[3:29:46]
changes from 2009 to 2018.
[3:29:50]
The researchers studied
[3:29:51]
pediatric exposures of children
[3:29:55]
under six years old to
[3:29:57]
marijuana which were stable
[3:29:59]
between 2000 and 2009.
[3:30:02]
But beginning in 2010
[3:30:05]
the increase of more than
[3:30:08]
6,000% in pediatric exposures
[3:30:10]
to marijuana it was found oral
[3:30:13]
ingestion was found to be
[3:30:15]
responsible for the majority of
[3:30:18]
exposures in young children.
[3:30:21]
A concurrent prospective cohort
[3:30:23]
found that virtually all of
[3:30:26]
the of the effects were from
[3:30:29]
hospital admissions in the U.S.
[3:30:34]
And Canada For those under ten
[3:30:35]
years old for severe toxicity
[3:30:38]
from marijuana was from
[3:30:40]
ingestions of edible
[3:30:42]
preparations.
[3:30:45]
The negative effects on
[3:30:47]
children's health public health
[3:30:48]
policy adjustments are
[3:30:50]
warranted.
[3:30:52]
Please the city should consider
[3:30:55]
the manufacturers that it
[3:30:57]
allows the small shops that
[3:30:59]
continue to sell such broad
[3:31:01]
edible products without any
[3:31:04]
oversight or regulations And
[3:31:07]
these are the products that are
[3:31:08]
getting into the hands of
[3:31:10]
children They need to be
[3:31:13]
protected.
[3:31:13]
>> I hope you will do that.
[3:31:15]
Thank you.
[3:31:15]
Your time has concluded.
[3:31:17]
The five minute time are also
[3:31:18]
concluded and there are eight
[3:31:19]
speakers in the queue.
[3:31:21]
No additional speakers will be
[3:31:22]
taken.
[3:31:23]
>> Barbara Gordon If you can
[3:31:24]
please unmute Thank you.
[3:31:28]
As a public health educator
[3:31:30]
concerned about the lack of
[3:31:32]
Smokefree policies, I wanted to
[3:31:33]
share with you a peer review
[3:31:36]
study regarding comprehensive
[3:31:39]
Smokefree laws and
[3:31:40]
cardiovascular disease
[3:31:41]
mortality in U.S. Counties.
[3:31:44]
This was published in
[3:31:46]
the Journal of American Medical
[3:31:48]
Association just JUNE of 2026.
[3:31:52]
The research examined
[3:31:53]
comprehensive Smokefree Laws
[3:31:56]
Associate it with long term
[3:31:58]
changes in cardiovascular
[3:32:00]
disease mortality at the county
[3:32:03]
level in the us.
[3:32:04]
The 2026 county level study
[3:32:07]
found that counties adopting
[3:32:09]
comprehensive smokefree laws
[3:32:11]
were associated with lower
[3:32:13]
cardiovascular mortality over
[3:32:15]
roughly a decade compared to
[3:32:17]
similar counties that did not
[3:32:19]
adopt such law.
[3:32:21]
These findings are consistent
[3:32:22]
with decades of research
[3:32:24]
showing that comprehensive
[3:32:26]
Smokefree policies reduce
[3:32:27]
exposure to secondhand smoke
[3:32:30]
and are associated with
[3:32:32]
improvement of cardiovascular
[3:32:34]
health.
[3:32:35]
The strongest evidence supports
[3:32:38]
Smokefree laws of any kind
[3:32:40]
tobacco or marijuana indoors or
[3:32:42]
outdoor public places without
[3:32:44]
exception showed an average
[3:32:46]
reduction of about 12
[3:32:47]
cardiovascular death per 100
[3:32:50]
people in this year.
[3:32:52]
I think for city councils and
[3:32:53]
local health departments that
[3:32:56]
we can reduce exposure tobacco
[3:32:58]
and marijuana secondhand smoke
[3:33:00]
by enacting comprehensive well
[3:33:03]
enforced smokefree ordinances
[3:33:05]
along with it doing public
[3:33:08]
health education and it will
[3:33:10]
improve the lives of all San
[3:33:10]
Diego.
[3:33:13]
Thank you for letting me speak
[3:33:16]
Ernie Casco If you can please
[3:33:18]
unmute Brant Colorado Ernie
[3:33:26]
Casco Lawyer Resident Attention
[3:33:28]
District Attorney The end
[3:33:31]
concern of Torrey Pines Dog
[3:33:34]
Park Ongoing dispute The Dear
[3:33:35]
Ernie email I received from cp
[3:33:37]
p is completely unacceptable
[3:33:40]
unacceptable It fails to
[3:33:43]
address serious allegations
[3:33:44]
made to City Council John
[3:33:47]
LaCava and San Diego Police
[3:33:48]
Department itself.
[3:33:50]
It it completely ignores
[3:33:51]
the victims and witnesses and
[3:33:53]
the ongoing criminal activity
[3:33:54]
and public safety concerns that
[3:33:57]
tweet my slide report My first
[3:33:58]
question is is where are
[3:34:00]
the police reports addressing
[3:34:02]
the victim and witnesses?
[3:34:03]
Residents should not be forced
[3:34:06]
to sign an access pass waiver
[3:34:08]
under the threat of violence.
[3:34:10]
I receive unanimous letters of
[3:34:12]
support from the town council,
[3:34:15]
the Hoyt Shores Association and
[3:34:16]
the University Community
[3:34:17]
Planning Group to stop this
[3:34:20]
crime.
[3:34:20]
Yet the court issues remain
[3:34:22]
ignored while problems continue
[3:34:25]
I have experienced retaliation
[3:34:27]
myself Serious injuries and
[3:34:32]
assaults devastating personal
[3:34:33]
loss to me and my family
[3:34:35]
poisoned with a biohazard over
[3:34:37]
the commercialization of Torrey
[3:34:41]
Pines Glider part died with
[3:34:41]
stage four cancer.
[3:34:43]
I want to see this public park
[3:34:45]
returned to the people and
[3:34:46]
protected from future abuse.
[3:34:49]
I'm asking City Council for
[3:34:50]
three things.
[3:34:51]
First, where are the police
[3:34:53]
reports involving victim and
[3:34:55]
witnesses?
[3:34:56]
Let's see them.
[3:34:57]
Second stop the illegal
[3:34:59]
collection of public funding in
[3:35:01]
the private accounts with a
[3:35:03]
full city audit Until we find
[3:35:05]
Sly report Where is the money
[3:35:06]
going?
[3:35:07]
Third, restore lawful public
[3:35:09]
access and ensure that no one
[3:35:12]
is forced into signing waivers.
[3:35:14]
Time to address the victim and
[3:35:16]
witnesses and force American
[3:35:18]
law not administrative law and
[3:35:20]
stand up for a constitutional
[3:35:22]
recreational rights and
[3:35:24]
freedoms.
[3:35:25]
Thank you.
[3:35:28]
Ready Casco You kid.
[3:35:28]
My apologies, Ernie.
[3:35:31]
Did you want to make any final
[3:35:34]
comment?
[3:35:37]
I didn't mean you.
[3:35:39]
I thought you were dead.
[3:35:40]
My apologies.
[3:35:44]
Okay.
[3:35:45]
You're not a meeting so we will
[3:35:46]
proceed.
[3:35:48]
Madison, if you can please.
[3:35:52]
On.
[3:35:53]
>> Hello.
[3:35:53]
Good evening.
[3:35:54]
City council members with
[3:35:56]
the 4th of JULY holiday
[3:35:57]
approaching, I want to briefly
[3:35:59]
highlight an important public
[3:36:00]
safety concern drug impaired
[3:36:02]
driving especially when it
[3:36:04]
comes to marijuana because
[3:36:06]
while many people think of
[3:36:07]
impaired driving primarily in
[3:36:08]
terms of alcohol, marijuana can
[3:36:10]
also significantly affect a
[3:36:12]
person's ability to drive
[3:36:13]
safely.
[3:36:14]
It can slow down reaction time
[3:36:16]
,impair coordination, distort
[3:36:18]
perception of distance and
[3:36:20]
speed and reduce overall
[3:36:22]
attention.
[3:36:23]
These effects can make it much
[3:36:25]
more difficult to respond
[3:36:26]
quickly to changing road
[3:36:27]
conditions, pedestrians or
[3:36:29]
other drivers.
[3:36:31]
One of the challenges with
[3:36:32]
marijuana impairment is that
[3:36:33]
people often underestimate it
[3:36:36]
Unlike alcohol where there are
[3:36:38]
well-known guidelines and
[3:36:39]
widespread public messaging,
[3:36:41]
many individuals do not fully
[3:36:42]
recognize how long marijuana
[3:36:44]
can impair judgment or how it
[3:36:46]
can affect driving even hours
[3:36:48]
after use.
[3:36:49]
This can lead to risky
[3:36:51]
decisions such as driving too
[3:36:53]
soon after consumption or
[3:36:55]
assuming they are fine to drive
[3:36:56]
when they are not during
[3:36:58]
holiday periods like the 4th of
[3:37:00]
JULY when there is increased
[3:37:01]
travel, social gatherings and
[3:37:03]
celebrations the risks become
[3:37:05]
even more significant.
[3:37:07]
More cars on the road combined
[3:37:08]
with impaired driving increased
[3:37:10]
the higher potential for
[3:37:11]
preventable accidents and
[3:37:12]
injuries.
[3:37:14]
I encourage our community to
[3:37:15]
prioritize planning ahead this
[3:37:17]
holiday using designated
[3:37:19]
drivers, rancher services or
[3:37:21]
other safe transportation
[3:37:22]
options If substances are being
[3:37:24]
used, public awareness and
[3:37:26]
personal responsibility can go
[3:37:28]
a long way in preventing
[3:37:29]
tragedies.
[3:37:30]
Thank you and I wish everyone a
[3:37:31]
safe and happy holiday.
[3:37:33]
Thank you.
[3:37:34]
John Stump Oh John Stump Want
[3:37:45]
to talk about three things
[3:37:48]
the recent election I don't
[3:37:51]
think the results in District
[3:37:55]
four or in the controversial
[3:37:59]
districts in New York City is a
[3:38:03]
reflection that people want
[3:38:04]
socialism.
[3:38:06]
I think it's more reflection.
[3:38:08]
They want change and they're
[3:38:10]
not They're dissatisfied with
[3:38:13]
the return they're getting in
[3:38:15]
response are getting from
[3:38:15]
elected officials They want
[3:38:18]
change.
[3:38:20]
Secondly, in today's newspaper
[3:38:22]
there was a report about
[3:38:24]
the separation or retirement of
[3:38:30]
the ceo of Community Power.
[3:38:36]
Community power is very fat.
[3:38:40]
There's 150 employees who make
[3:38:43]
salaries much greater than
[3:38:45]
the city of San Diego and
[3:38:48]
community power doesn't do
[3:38:50]
anything.
[3:38:51]
It's just an aggregator.
[3:38:52]
It doesn't generate or
[3:38:54]
distribute the council members
[3:38:57]
that are in community power
[3:38:59]
should be looking at the wages
[3:39:01]
paid.
[3:39:02]
Their third I need the city
[3:39:05]
clerk to call me concerning
[3:39:06]
the notice of appeals there's
[3:39:10]
an appeal scheduled for next
[3:39:12]
week the seventh and completely
[3:39:18]
misunderstands what is being
[3:39:21]
done in an appeal.
[3:39:23]
The City Council is acting as a
[3:39:26]
hearing body as judges and yet
[3:39:29]
the mayor and the staff who are
[3:39:32]
the group being appealed
[3:39:35]
against are being given status
[3:39:39]
in that appeal different than
[3:39:41]
the appellant So that process
[3:39:44]
either needs to be re noticed
[3:39:49]
or changed and concluded Hector
[3:39:50]
he complains on you.
[3:39:54]
>> All right thanks.
[3:39:55]
I'm just so disappointed and
[3:39:58]
I'm not surprised at
[3:40:00]
the outcome of the California
[3:40:03]
budget how we didn't get
[3:40:05]
millions of dollars to fix our
[3:40:07]
sewer plant.
[3:40:09]
Where's our 3 or 400 million to
[3:40:11]
have a state of the art sewer
[3:40:13]
plant at the border?
[3:40:15]
It's a joke.
[3:40:16]
It's the blind leading
[3:40:17]
the blind.
[3:40:19]
You end up smelling Mexican
[3:40:21]
for another decade.
[3:40:23]
Come on, man.
[3:40:25]
We need we need a railroad high
[3:40:27]
speed from Fresno to
[3:40:29]
Bakersfield funded another
[3:40:31]
couple billion.
[3:40:33]
Where's our money?
[3:40:35]
But come on, you guys, you got
[3:40:36]
to be embarrassed.
[3:40:38]
How could you have your kids
[3:40:39]
that sewer gas growing up?
[3:40:43]
You know?
[3:40:43]
Come on.
[3:40:44]
What are you going to tell
[3:40:44]
them?
[3:40:45]
Why don't they ask the dad?
[3:40:48]
How do you smell that?
[3:40:49]
How come we live here?
[3:40:51]
How What's going on?
[3:40:51]
Blame.
[3:40:53]
Blame the Democratic Party.
[3:40:56]
You can't blame Mexico.
[3:40:58]
They don't got their together
[3:41:00]
They're only like building $1
[3:41:02]
billion highway above Tijuana.
[3:41:06]
Yeah, which is if you live
[3:41:07]
below that today, you better be
[3:41:09]
heavily into the Catholic
[3:41:11]
Church with their rosary beads
[3:41:13]
at night when they earthquake
[3:41:15]
comes, that thing's going down
[3:41:19]
bad And then there's going to
[3:41:20]
be a flood, a sewer gas even
[3:41:21]
more when that sewer breaks
[3:41:24]
again over there it's it's
[3:41:26]
frankly it's embarrassing And
[3:41:29]
don't use the expression
[3:41:30]
America's finest city until we
[3:41:33]
have it all areas of the city
[3:41:35]
and county until we have a
[3:41:37]
sewer plant that can handle
[3:41:39]
Tijuana's sewage.
[3:41:42]
It's just disgusting that it's
[3:41:45]
just it's totally disgusting.
[3:41:48]
So anyway, the next time I'm
[3:41:50]
I'm looking forward to next
[3:41:52]
year when everyone gets
[3:41:53]
deported is that'd be great.
[3:41:57]
Round them up, man.
[3:41:58]
Your time is concluded.
[3:42:00]
Jodi Strang, if you can please
[3:42:00]
unmute.
[3:42:05]
>> Good afternoon City Council
[3:42:07]
Thank you for this opportunity
[3:42:08]
to share some thoughts.
[3:42:10]
Perhaps you saw as I did
[3:42:12]
the press conference on Friday
[3:42:15]
regarding legislation that's
[3:42:17]
been supported by our Senator
[3:42:20]
Catherine Blake or as well as
[3:42:23]
assembly person Lori Davis.
[3:42:24]
It's sb 936 that would prohibit
[3:42:27]
the sale of natural nitrous
[3:42:29]
oxide canisters that are larger
[3:42:31]
than eight grams.
[3:42:35]
Noxious oxide joins a group of
[3:42:36]
other products being sold at
[3:42:38]
gas stations, Vape stores smoke
[3:42:41]
shops across our city that are
[3:42:45]
being purchased by our young
[3:42:46]
people in particular they join
[3:42:49]
Create Them which is another
[3:42:49]
product that's illegal to sell
[3:42:51]
that we're selling it in our
[3:42:53]
city Nevertheless as well as
[3:42:55]
magic mushrooms and hemp
[3:42:57]
products that contain over
[3:43:00]
limit And thus we get these
[3:43:03]
high concentrated thc products
[3:43:06]
hiding under hemp products.
[3:43:10]
Sb 936 nitrogen oxide can cause
[3:43:12]
serious damage to people who
[3:43:14]
are inhaling them which tend to
[3:43:16]
be our young people
[3:43:17]
particularly brain damage.
[3:43:18]
It seems to have its main
[3:43:20]
effect neurologically and in
[3:43:22]
many instances it has caused
[3:43:24]
death.
[3:43:25]
If you have an opportunity as a
[3:43:27]
city council to support
[3:43:28]
legislation and I know that you
[3:43:30]
do and you have a lobbyist I
[3:43:32]
would suggest you add sb 936 to
[3:43:35]
your list Be a wonderful thing
[3:43:37]
for our city council to
[3:43:38]
recognize the role of these
[3:43:40]
drugs primarily sold in our
[3:43:44]
city at gas stations,
[3:43:45]
convenience stores, vape stores
[3:43:48]
and change the course of
[3:43:49]
the young people's lives who
[3:43:51]
are using them.
[3:43:52]
Thank you.
[3:43:54]
Thank you.
[3:43:55]
Natalie Raskin If you can
[3:43:56]
please unmute them after that
[3:43:59]
is backing up.
[3:44:04]
>> Hi Natalie Rush key here I
[3:44:05]
agree with I think her name was
[3:44:07]
Maxine There should be more
[3:44:10]
education within the public in
[3:44:12]
educating on how the system
[3:44:15]
works and how the items work
[3:44:18]
and being informed so that when
[3:44:20]
they do have the opportunity to
[3:44:21]
come speak they understand what
[3:44:23]
they're speaking on and about
[3:44:27]
and not just calling in and
[3:44:29]
making random random
[3:44:30]
statements.
[3:44:33]
>> I'm also concerned with this
[3:44:36]
possibility of a sun break
[3:44:40]
ranch with all the things that
[3:44:42]
are going on and these cuts no
[3:44:45]
backup plan.
[3:44:46]
>> I'm really doing some
[3:44:47]
research as Maxine stated with
[3:44:50]
Steve Cushman Now I'm starting
[3:44:52]
to go down a rabbit hole
[3:44:56]
because if it's not Sun Break
[3:44:58]
ranch then what is it?
[3:45:01]
Transparency I think is
[3:45:03]
necessary for me and my family.
[3:45:06]
>> And it also seems that
[3:45:08]
the county is starting to go
[3:45:11]
this direction as in now
[3:45:14]
reframing homelessness as
[3:45:15]
mental illness and addiction
[3:45:18]
which I have neither of those
[3:45:20]
but yet I will still be in this
[3:45:23]
possible homeless category.
[3:45:27]
Also what's concerning to me is
[3:45:30]
that I was reading our tfa
[3:45:34]
teachers data and how many
[3:45:36]
people have entered
[3:45:36]
homelessness and how many
[3:45:37]
people exited.
[3:45:38]
I have came to learn that they
[3:45:40]
do not do statistics past 18
[3:45:44]
months of a person staying
[3:45:46]
housed or unhoused And these
[3:45:49]
are certain things that I think
[3:45:51]
we should be keeping track of
[3:45:53]
because if we're not keeping
[3:45:55]
people housed then we're just
[3:45:57]
doing this vicious cycle and
[3:46:00]
it's causing distrust amongst
[3:46:02]
our community and the unhoused
[3:46:04]
people and they don't want to
[3:46:05]
have any.
[3:46:07]
Sir, your time has come.
[3:46:07]
Thank you.
[3:46:09]
Becky Rapp, if you can please
[3:46:11]
unmute.
[3:46:15]
>> Good evening.
[3:46:16]
My name is Becky Rapp and
[3:46:17]
tonight I would like to share
[3:46:19]
with the council what I shared
[3:46:21]
with the active transportation
[3:46:23]
and Infrastructure Committee
[3:46:24]
last week.
[3:46:25]
As I am concerned for road
[3:46:26]
safety and the real
[3:46:28]
consequences of reducing
[3:46:29]
staffing in program that
[3:46:31]
support Vision Zero.
[3:46:33]
>> Traffic deaths continue to
[3:46:35]
be a serious public safety
[3:46:36]
issue and nationally about one
[3:46:39]
third of fatal crashes involved
[3:46:41]
in per driver.
[3:46:43]
That includes not only alcohol
[3:46:45]
but also drugs including
[3:46:48]
marijuana.
[3:46:49]
Federal data proves that many
[3:46:51]
drivers involved in fatal
[3:46:52]
crashes test positive for
[3:46:54]
marijuana.
[3:46:55]
When we reduce staffing for say
[3:46:56]
for traffic safety, we're not
[3:46:58]
simply cutting back on
[3:46:59]
positions, we're weakening
[3:47:00]
education planning and
[3:47:02]
enforcement efforts that help
[3:47:04]
prevent crashes before they
[3:47:05]
happen.
[3:47:06]
At the same time, California is
[3:47:09]
advancing assembly Bill 2697
[3:47:12]
which would allow local
[3:47:13]
governments to authorize drive
[3:47:15]
thru marijuana sales at
[3:47:17]
licensed pot shops.
[3:47:19]
The bill has already passed
[3:47:20]
the Assembly and continues to
[3:47:22]
move through the Senate.
[3:47:23]
This proposal moves us in
[3:47:25]
the opposite direction of
[3:47:26]
Vision Zero.
[3:47:27]
It's also important to know
[3:47:29]
that there's nothing in
[3:47:30]
the bill prohibiting adults
[3:47:31]
from purchasing pot products
[3:47:32]
while children are sitting in
[3:47:34]
the back seat of the car.
[3:47:35]
That sends the wrong message to
[3:47:37]
families and undermines our
[3:47:39]
efforts to protect public
[3:47:41]
the young people.
[3:47:43]
If we're serious about
[3:47:44]
eliminating traffic deaths, we
[3:47:47]
should not be reducing vision
[3:47:48]
zero resources Why Policies are
[3:47:51]
being advanced that could
[3:47:52]
increase the convene instead of
[3:47:54]
purchasing intoxicating
[3:47:55]
products.
[3:47:56]
So I urge this council to
[3:47:58]
consider the importance of
[3:47:59]
transportation, transportation
[3:48:00]
safety.
[3:48:02]
Continue investing and Vision
[3:48:04]
zero and publicly oppose ab
[3:48:06]
2697.
[3:48:09]
>> Thank you.
[3:48:09]
Thank you.
[3:48:10]
That does conclude public
[3:48:11]
knowledge and a public comment
[3:48:12]
on today's meeting.
[3:48:13]
All right.
[3:48:14]
Thank you, City Clerk.
[3:48:15]
And with that does the office
[3:48:16]
of the city attorney have
[3:48:17]
anything to report out from
[3:48:18]
closed session?
[3:48:19]
Thank you, Council PRESIDENT.
[3:48:20]
There's no report out from
[3:48:21]
closed session.
[3:48:22]
>> All right.
[3:48:23]
Thank you.
[3:48:24]
We have one adjournment in
[3:48:26]
memory by council member
[3:48:27]
Moreno.
[3:48:28]
>> I respectfully request that
[3:48:31]
the council adjourn today's
[3:48:33]
meeting in memory of MISS
[3:48:34]
Veronica Medina, a committed
[3:48:37]
and influential member of
[3:48:39]
the San Isidro community.
[3:48:41]
MISS Medina peacefully passed
[3:48:43]
away on JUNE 19th, 2026.
[3:48:46]
MISS Benita was a natural
[3:48:48]
leader with a kind heart.
[3:48:50]
Her dedication, compassion and
[3:48:52]
humility were evident in her
[3:48:54]
work with the San Isidro Youth
[3:48:56]
and Families.
[3:48:57]
As the coordinator of Pupil
[3:48:59]
Services ses at the San Ysidro
[3:49:01]
School District during the many
[3:49:04]
years I had the privilege of
[3:49:05]
knowing her through her
[3:49:07]
community work and our time
[3:49:08]
together in the San Isidro
[3:49:10]
Women's Club.
[3:49:11]
MISS Medina's presence was
[3:49:12]
unfair unforgettable.
[3:49:15]
Her laughter alone would have
[3:49:16]
let you know she was in
[3:49:17]
the room.
[3:49:19]
The same warmth, grace and joy
[3:49:21]
guided the way she served
[3:49:22]
others and reflected the hope
[3:49:24]
she carried for the San Isidro
[3:49:26]
community.
[3:49:27]
She made it her mission to
[3:49:29]
improve the lives of students
[3:49:30]
outside of the classroom.
[3:49:32]
In doing this she provided
[3:49:33]
students with the external
[3:49:35]
foundation needed to be able to
[3:49:37]
learn.
[3:49:38]
This commitment was reflected
[3:49:40]
in her development of
[3:49:41]
the Primero homeless program
[3:49:43]
which aimed to eliminate
[3:49:45]
barriers to education for
[3:49:47]
students and families
[3:49:48]
experiencing homelessness.
[3:49:51]
Through her work, MS. Medina
[3:49:52]
built a strong network of
[3:49:55]
community partnerships that
[3:49:56]
connected students families to
[3:50:00]
mental health services, housing
[3:50:01]
assistance, food resources and
[3:50:04]
other essential support for
[3:50:06]
daily life.
[3:50:08]
MS. Medina cultivated a safe
[3:50:09]
and welcoming environment where
[3:50:11]
she was known as a trusted
[3:50:13]
colleague, advocate, mentor and
[3:50:15]
friend.
[3:50:16]
Throughout her life MS. Medina
[3:50:18]
was recognized many times for
[3:50:20]
her service and dedication And
[3:50:23]
today we honor her
[3:50:24]
contributions and ensure that
[3:50:26]
her impact on the San Isidro
[3:50:28]
youth families and the broader
[3:50:29]
community will never be
[3:50:31]
forgotten.
[3:50:32]
My deepest condolences to her
[3:50:34]
son Nathaniel, whom she loved.
[3:50:36]
Dearly and MAY she rest in
[3:50:38]
peace.
[3:50:39]
>> Thank you, Councilmember
[3:50:40]
Moreno.
[3:50:42]
And with that we will now
[3:50:43]
adjourn Council to
[3:50:44]
the regularly scheduled council
[3:50:45]
meeting on Tuesday, JUNE 30th,