Agenda
Agenda: https://ocgov.granicus.com/DocumentViewer.php?file=ocgov_d968966c235c1c8ea7ddb18fb578eb4e.pdf&view=1
Transcript
SOURCE TRANSCRIPT
This transcript is downloaded from the source you provided but we haven't reviewed it for accuracy. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record. You can also request an AI-transcription of the audio file with the button to the left.
The times in this transcript were moved to match the video, using the meeting's own audio. The text is the source's captions, unchanged; the source times are kept in the "sourced" version.
[0:00]
shortly]
[0:00]
[Orange county board of
[0:00]
supervisors-
[0:00]
meeting will begin
[0:00]
shortly]
[0:00]
[Orange county board of
[0:00]
supervisors-
[0:16]
shortly]
[0:18]
>>chair, doug chaffee: check
[0:18]
check.
[0:19]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: check
[0:19]
check.
[0:21]
>>vincente sarmiento: check
[0:21]
check.
[0:23]
>>clerk, robin stieler: check check
[0:31]
>>chair, doug chaffee: this
[0:31]
morning I'm chair doug chaffee
[0:33]
and 4th district supervisor
[0:36]
and joined this morning with
[0:37]
vice-chair katrina foley.
[0:41]
National weights and measures
[0:43]
week is observed each year in
[0:45]
the first full week of MARCH.
[0:47]
We are in advance for a change,
[0:50]
recognition of PRESIDENT John
[0:52]
addams signing the first united
[0:55]
states weights and measures law
[0:57]
on MARCH 2, 1799.
[0:58]
.
[1:01]
Every day 3.2 million residents
[1:04]
and businesses as well as 59
[1:08]
million-plus annual visitors
[1:09]
rely on accurate measurements
[1:10]
and pricing when purchasing
[1:13]
groceries, fuel, utilities,
[1:15]
consumer goods and services.
[1:17]
The orange county office of
[1:19]
weights and measures ensures
[1:21]
weighing and measuring devices
[1:23]
are accurate, protecting
[1:25]
millions of dollars in
[1:26]
transactions. With that, I'd
[1:28]
like to invite up jose air
[1:31]
yugoslav ga, the orange county
[1:32]
commissioner and also known as
[1:35]
the sealer of weights and
[1:36]
measures. Anthony lee, deputy
[1:39]
sealer of the weights measures,
[1:41]
and anna watts, our business
[1:42]
service analysts, hugo soto,
[1:46]
senior agricultural standards
[1:47]
inspector, marinda herr,
[1:50]
agricultural standards
[1:51]
inspector. Mark johnson, senior
[1:56]
agricultural standards
[1:57]
inspector, david scorski,
[1:59]
agricultural standards
[2:06]
inspector, and alicia barry, our
[2:06]
senior deputy D.A. So we do
[2:09]
have some oversight from the
[2:11]
D.A.'s office in here as well..
[2:14]
Orange county ranks third
[2:16]
statewide in the number of
[2:17]
commercial weighing and
[2:19]
measuring device under our
[2:21]
jurisdiction, reflecting the
[2:23]
scale and complexity of the
[2:24]
local economy. Through the
[2:27]
diligent work, the office of
[2:29]
weights and measures' staff,
[2:31]
consumers are protected and
[2:33]
ensured that prices are fair. I
[2:36]
want to thank staff for their
[2:37]
work that often goes
[2:38]
unrecognized. We'd now like to
[2:41]
invite vice-chair foley with any
[2:43]
remarks she'd care to make.
[2:44]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank
[2:48]
you. Great to be here. Good
[2:49]
morning. Katrina foley, county
[2:51]
supervisor representing the
[2:52]
fabulous fifth district. And as
[2:54]
mentioned by our CHAIRMAN, we
[2:56]
are today recognizing weights
[2:58]
and measures week here in orange
[2:59]
county. And this rear's theme
[3:01]
is "we measure what matters."
[3:05]
and this reflects our commitment
[3:06]
to fairness, accountability, and
[3:09]
public protection. Every time
[3:11]
residents fill up at the gas
[3:13]
pump, buy groceries or receive a
[3:15]
delivery, they trust that they
[3:17]
receive exactly what they paid
[3:19]
for. Dedicated professionals
[3:21]
like these behind me inspect,
[3:23]
test, and verify these systems
[3:25]
every single day. Our weights
[3:28]
and measures team at oc public
[3:29]
works safeguards consumer
[3:30]
dollars, ensures a level playing
[3:32]
field for businesses and quietly
[3:35]
keeps our local economy running
[3:38]
fairly and efficiently.
[3:40]
Standard measurements are so
[3:41]
important, and they help us
[3:42]
perform even simple tasks like
[3:45]
purchasing carpet, laundry
[3:47]
detergent, fabric, any number of
[3:50]
things. And I do think it's so
[3:52]
important because before I
[3:54]
became a county supervise, I
[3:56]
didn't even know that we had
[3:57]
this group. And so it's very
[4:00]
important because it's all about
[4:02]
protecting our consumers and
[4:04]
making sure, like I said, that
[4:06]
we get what we pay for. So
[4:07]
thank you for all of the work
[4:09]
that you do. And sometimes it's
[4:11]
hard because people get mad at
[4:12]
you and they don't like you in
[4:14]
their business. But you're
[4:15]
there to protect the consumers.
[4:17]
So thank you.
[4:26]
>>speaker: CHAIRMAN Chaffee,
[4:29]
vice-chair foley, thank you so
[4:30]
much for being here, and thank
[4:31]
you for the opportunity to be
[4:32]
here and highlight a little bit
[4:34]
of the work of the weights and
[4:36]
measures professionals. My name
[4:38]
is jose arriaga, also known as
[4:40]
the county sealer of weights and
[4:41]
measures. I want to share a
[4:45]
little bit of information what
[4:47]
is weights and measures. As
[4:48]
mentioned, sometimes we don't
[4:49]
even know what weights and
[4:51]
measures is, it's quietly in our
[4:52]
communities, but I assure you
[4:54]
that by the end of the day today
[4:57]
the work of the individuals will
[4:58]
touch your life and every single
[5:00]
day for the rest of our days,
[5:02]
every single resident is touched
[5:04]
by the work of these
[5:05]
individuals. When you pump fuel
[5:07]
at that gas station and you see
[5:08]
that seal that says it was
[5:10]
accurate when tested, that
[5:12]
ensures that that device -- we
[5:14]
call them a device -- it meets
[5:16]
the conform plans. It is within
[5:18]
a tolerance that ensures that
[5:19]
you get what you pay for. It's
[5:21]
not just the 20,000 gas pumps in
[5:23]
orange county, it also includes
[5:25]
the 100,000 water submeters,
[5:28]
20,000 electric watt meters, it
[5:30]
includes the thousands of scales
[5:32]
at grocery stores, and it's not
[5:35]
just devices, the work weights
[5:37]
and measures officials expands
[5:38]
beyond those devices. It also
[5:42]
applies to the price that you
[5:43]
pay. We do not set the price
[5:46]
but ensure that the price that
[5:47]
every consumer pays is the
[5:49]
lowest advertised price. We
[5:51]
have a team of secret shoppers,
[5:53]
some of them are here, where
[5:54]
they will go into thousands of
[5:56]
retail stores every year and
[5:59]
verify the accuracy of those
[6:01]
prices on the shelves against
[6:02]
the point of sales system. And
[6:04]
it's beyond pricing. When you
[6:06]
buy commodities by count,
[6:08]
weight, measure, when you pour a
[6:10]
gallon from a gallon of milk to
[6:11]
your 16 ounce box of cereal,
[6:13]
well, hopefully it's in a bowl,
[6:16]
how do you know there's a gallon
[6:17]
in there? When you buy items by
[6:20]
count, how do you know what's in
[6:23]
there by weight? The other
[6:26]
thing we do, one of the other
[6:27]
programs we play a critical role
[6:29]
here in our community is that
[6:31]
our officials respond to
[6:32]
hundreds of complaints of
[6:34]
residents where they buy canned
[6:35]
goods, packaged goods, and we're
[6:37]
verifying the accuracy of that
[6:38]
label and the content of those
[6:40]
containers.
[6:41]
We are protecting an $89 billion
[6:44]
retail economy, but more
[6:46]
importantly, we are protecting
[6:47]
an over$300 billion gdp economy
[6:52]
here in orange county. I do
[6:55]
want to thank the officials. I
[6:56]
want to thank the team here for
[6:58]
the work that they do every
[6:59]
single day. They are committed.
[7:01]
I also want to provide a
[7:02]
special thanks to our partners
[7:04]
with the district attorney's
[7:05]
office. A lot of our work
[7:07]
relies on compliance through
[7:08]
education, through awareness,
[7:10]
occasionally through
[7:11]
administrative actions, but
[7:13]
sometimes we have to go beyond
[7:14]
and do prosecutions and that is
[7:16]
where our district attorney's
[7:17]
office comes in. Alicia, thank
[7:19]
you so much for you and your
[7:20]
team for all of the help and
[7:22]
support. They help us achieve
[7:23]
our goals of protecting the
[7:24]
consumers hear in orange county.
[7:27]
With that, when we say thank
[7:28]
you. And if you ever feel that
[7:29]
anything you buy, the quantity,
[7:32]
the price, the weight is
[7:33]
inaccurate, please reach out to
[7:34]
our office. We are a very small
[7:37]
team. We do a lot of coverage,
[7:39]
but we actually need the help of
[7:40]
every single resident and every
[7:41]
single business in orange county
[7:43]
to help protect each other. So
[7:45]
please reach out to our office
[7:46]
if you have any questions, if he
[7:47]
ever want to learn about what we
[7:48]
do, if you want to come work
[7:50]
with us, it's an amazing job.
[7:52]
There's never a boring day here.
[7:53]
Thank you.
[9:21]
[Applause]
[9:22]
>>chair, doug chaffee: and that
[9:23]
concludes our presentations this
[9:24]
morning. We will begin our
[9:28]
regular meeting at 9:30. Thank
[9:59]
you.
[10:19]
[Orange county board of
[10:19]
supervisors-
[10:20]
meeting will begin
[10:24]
shortly]
[10:25]
[Orange county board of
[10:25]
supervisors-
[10:26]
meeting will begin
[10:26]
shortly]
[10:27]
[Orange county board of
[10:27]
supervisors-
[10:28]
meeting will begin
[10:30]
shortly]
[10:31]
[Orange county board of
[10:31]
supervisors-
[10:32]
meeting will begin
[10:37]
shortly]
[10:37]
[Orange county board of
[10:38]
supervisors-
[10:38]
meeting will begin
[10:39]
shortly]
[10:40]
[Orange county board of
[10:40]
supervisors-
[10:40]
meeting will begin
[10:43]
shortly]
[10:44]
[Orange county board of
[10:44]
supervisors-
[10:45]
meeting will begin
[10:49]
shortly]
[10:50]
[Orange county board of
[10:50]
supervisors-
[10:51]
meeting will begin
[10:51]
shortly]
[10:52]
[Orange county board of
[10:53]
supervisors-
[10:53]
meeting will begin
[10:56]
shortly]
[10:56]
[Orange county board of
[10:57]
supervisors-
[10:57]
meeting will begin
[11:02]
shortly]
[11:03]
[Orange county board of
[11:03]
supervisors-
[11:04]
meeting will begin
[11:04]
shortly]
[11:05]
[Orange county board of
[11:05]
supervisors-
[11:06]
meeting will begin
[11:08]
shortly]
[11:09]
[Orange county board of
[11:09]
supervisors-
[11:10]
meeting will begin
[11:15]
shortly]
[11:15]
[Orange county board of
[11:16]
supervisors-
[11:16]
meeting will begin
[11:17]
shortly]
[11:18]
[Orange county board of
[11:18]
supervisors-
[11:18]
meeting will begin
[11:22]
shortly]
[11:22]
[Orange county board of
[11:22]
supervisors-
[11:23]
meeting will begin
[11:27]
shortly]
[11:28]
[Orange county board of
[11:28]
supervisors-
[11:29]
meeting will begin
[11:29]
shortly]
[11:30]
[Orange county board of
[11:31]
supervisors-
[11:31]
meeting will begin
[11:34]
shortly]
[11:34]
[Orange county board of
[11:35]
supervisors-
[11:35]
meeting will begin
[11:41]
shortly]
[11:41]
[Orange county board of
[11:41]
supervisors-
[11:42]
meeting will begin
[11:42]
shortly]
[11:43]
[Orange county board of
[11:43]
supervisors-
[11:44]
meeting will begin
[11:46]
shortly]
[11:47]
[Orange county board of
[11:47]
supervisors-
[11:48]
meeting will begin
[11:53]
shortly]
[11:53]
[Orange county board of
[11:54]
supervisors-
[11:54]
meeting will begin
[11:55]
shortly]
[11:56]
[Orange county board of
[11:56]
supervisors-
[11:56]
meeting will begin
[12:00]
shortly]
[12:00]
[Orange county board of
[12:00]
supervisors-
[12:01]
meeting will begin
[12:05]
shortly]
[12:07]
[Orange county board of
[12:07]
supervisors-
[12:07]
meeting will begin
[12:07]
shortly]
[12:08]
[Orange county board of
[12:09]
supervisors-
[12:09]
meeting will begin
[12:12]
shortly]
[12:12]
[Orange county board of
[12:13]
supervisors-
[12:13]
meeting will begin
[12:18]
shortly]
[12:19]
[Orange county board of
[12:19]
supervisors-
[12:20]
meeting will begin
[12:20]
shortly]
[12:21]
[Orange county board of
[12:21]
supervisors-
[12:22]
meeting will begin
[12:24]
shortly]
[12:25]
[Orange county board of
[12:25]
supervisors-
[12:26]
meeting will begin
[12:31]
shortly]
[12:31]
[Orange county board of
[12:32]
supervisors-
[12:32]
meeting will begin
[12:33]
shortly]
[12:34]
[Orange county board of
[12:34]
supervisors-
[12:34]
meeting will begin
[12:37]
shortly]
[12:38]
[Orange county board of
[12:39]
supervisors-
[12:39]
meeting will begin
[12:43]
shortly]
[12:45]
[Orange county board of
[12:45]
supervisors-
[12:45]
meeting will begin
[12:45]
shortly]
[12:46]
[Orange county board of
[12:47]
supervisors-
[12:47]
meeting will begin
[12:50]
shortly]
[12:50]
[Orange county board of
[12:51]
supervisors-
[12:51]
meeting will begin
[12:56]
shortly]
[12:57]
[Orange county board of
[12:58]
supervisors-
[12:58]
meeting will begin
[12:58]
shortly]
[12:59]
[Orange county board of
[12:59]
supervisors-
[13:00]
meeting will begin
[13:02]
shortly]
[13:04]
[Orange county board of
[13:04]
supervisors-
[13:04]
meeting will begin
[13:09]
shortly]
[13:09]
[Orange county board of
[13:10]
supervisors-
[13:10]
meeting will begin
[13:11]
shortly]
[13:12]
[Orange county board of
[13:12]
supervisors-
[13:12]
meeting will begin
[13:15]
shortly]
[13:16]
[Orange county board of
[13:17]
supervisors-
[13:17]
meeting will begin
[13:21]
shortly]
[13:22]
[Orange county board of
[13:22]
supervisors-
[13:23]
meeting will begin
[13:24]
shortly]
[13:24]
[Orange county board of
[13:25]
supervisors-
[13:25]
meeting will begin
[13:28]
shortly]
[13:29]
[Orange county board of
[13:29]
supervisors-
[13:29]
meeting will begin
[13:34]
shortly]
[13:35]
[Orange county board of
[13:35]
supervisors-
[13:35]
meeting will begin
[13:37]
shortly]
[13:37]
[Orange county board of
[13:37]
supervisors-
[13:38]
meeting will begin
[13:40]
shortly]
[13:41]
[Orange county board of
[13:41]
supervisors-
[13:42]
meeting will begin
[13:47]
shortly]
[13:47]
[Orange county board of
[13:48]
supervisors-
[13:48]
meeting will begin
[13:49]
shortly]
[13:50]
[Orange county board of
[13:50]
supervisors-
[13:50]
meeting will begin
[13:53]
shortly]
[13:54]
[Orange county board of
[13:54]
supervisors-
[13:55]
meeting will begin
[13:59]
shortly]
[14:00]
[Orange county board of
[14:00]
supervisors-
[14:01]
meeting will begin
[14:01]
shortly]
[14:02]
[Orange county board of
[14:03]
supervisors-
[14:03]
meeting will begin
[14:06]
shortly]
[14:06]
[Orange county board of
[14:07]
supervisors-
[14:08]
meeting will begin
[14:12]
shortly]
[14:13]
[Orange county board of
[14:13]
supervisors-
[14:13]
meeting will begin
[14:15]
shortly]
[14:15]
[Orange county board of
[14:15]
supervisors-
[14:16]
meeting will begin
[14:18]
shortly]
[14:19]
[Orange county board of
[14:19]
supervisors-
[14:20]
meeting will begin
[14:25]
shortly]
[14:25]
[Orange county board of
[14:26]
supervisors-
[14:27]
meeting will begin
[14:27]
shortly]
[14:28]
[Orange county board of
[14:28]
supervisors-
[14:29]
meeting will begin
[14:31]
shortly]
[14:32]
[Orange county board of
[14:32]
supervisors-
[14:33]
meeting will begin
[14:37]
shortly]
[14:38]
[Orange county board of
[14:38]
supervisors-
[14:39]
meeting will begin
[14:39]
shortly]
[14:41]
[Orange county board of
[14:41]
supervisors-
[14:41]
meeting will begin
[14:44]
shortly]
[14:44]
[Orange county board of
[14:45]
supervisors-
[14:46]
meeting will begin
[14:50]
shortly]
[14:51]
[Orange county board of
[14:51]
supervisors-
[14:52]
meeting will begin
[14:52]
shortly]
[14:53]
[Orange county board of
[14:53]
supervisors-
[14:54]
meeting will begin
[14:56]
shortly]
[14:57]
[Orange county board of
[14:57]
supervisors-
[14:58]
meeting will begin
[15:03]
shortly]
[15:03]
[Orange county board of
[15:04]
supervisors-
[15:05]
meeting will begin
[15:05]
shortly]
[15:06]
[Orange county board of
[15:06]
supervisors-
[15:06]
meeting will begin
[15:09]
shortly]
[15:10]
[Orange county board of
[15:10]
supervisors-
[15:11]
meeting will begin
[15:15]
shortly]
[15:16]
[Orange county board of
[15:16]
supervisors-
[15:17]
meeting will begin
[15:17]
shortly]
[15:19]
[Orange county board of
[15:19]
supervisors-
[15:19]
meeting will begin
[15:22]
shortly]
[15:22]
[Orange county board of
[15:23]
supervisors-
[15:23]
meeting will begin
[15:28]
shortly]
[15:29]
[Orange county board of
[15:29]
supervisors-
[15:30]
meeting will begin
[15:30]
shortly]
[15:31]
[Orange county board of
[15:32]
supervisors-
[15:32]
meeting will begin
[15:34]
shortly]
[15:35]
[Orange county board of
[15:35]
supervisors-
[15:36]
meeting will begin
[15:41]
shortly]
[15:41]
[Orange county board of
[15:42]
supervisors-
[15:42]
meeting will begin
[15:43]
shortly]
[15:44]
[Orange county board of
[15:44]
supervisors-
[15:44]
meeting will begin
[15:47]
shortly]
[15:48]
[Orange county board of
[15:49]
supervisors-
[15:49]
meeting will begin
[15:53]
shortly]
[15:54]
[Orange county board of
[15:54]
supervisors-
[15:55]
meeting will begin
[15:55]
shortly]
[15:56]
[Orange county board of
[15:57]
supervisors-
[15:57]
meeting will begin
[16:00]
shortly]
[16:00]
[Orange county board of
[16:01]
supervisors-
[16:01]
meeting will begin
[16:06]
shortly]
[16:07]
[Orange county board of
[16:07]
supervisors-
[16:08]
meeting will begin
[16:08]
shortly]
[16:09]
[Orange county board of
[16:09]
supervisors-
[16:10]
meeting will begin
[16:12]
shortly]
[16:13]
[Orange county board of
[16:13]
supervisors-
[16:14]
meeting will begin
[16:19]
shortly]
[16:19]
[Orange county board of
[16:20]
supervisors-
[16:20]
meeting will begin
[16:21]
shortly]
[16:22]
[Orange county board of
[16:22]
supervisors-
[16:23]
meeting will begin
[16:25]
shortly]
[16:26]
[Orange county board of
[16:26]
supervisors-
[16:27]
meeting will begin
[16:31]
shortly]
[16:32]
[Orange county board of
[16:32]
supervisors-
[16:33]
meeting will begin
[16:33]
shortly]
[16:34]
[Orange county board of
[16:35]
supervisors-
[16:35]
meeting will begin
[16:38]
shortly]
[16:38]
[Orange county board of
[16:39]
supervisors-
[16:39]
meeting will begin
[16:44]
shortly]
[16:45]
[Orange county board of
[16:45]
supervisors-
[16:46]
meeting will begin
[16:46]
shortly]
[16:47]
[Orange county board of
[16:47]
supervisors-
[16:48]
meeting will begin
[16:50]
shortly]
[16:51]
[Orange county board of
[16:51]
supervisors-
[16:52]
meeting will begin
[16:57]
shortly]
[16:57]
[Orange county board of
[16:58]
supervisors-
[16:58]
meeting will begin
[16:59]
shortly]
[17:00]
[Orange county board of
[17:00]
supervisors-
[17:01]
meeting will begin
[17:03]
shortly]
[17:04]
[Orange county board of
[17:04]
supervisors-
[17:05]
meeting will begin
[17:09]
shortly]
[17:10]
[Orange county board of
[17:10]
supervisors-
[17:11]
meeting will begin
[17:11]
shortly]
[17:13]
[Orange county board of
[17:13]
supervisors-
[17:13]
meeting will begin
[17:16]
shortly]
[17:16]
[Orange county board of
[17:17]
supervisors-
[17:17]
meeting will begin
[17:22]
shortly]
[17:23]
[Orange county board of
[17:23]
supervisors-
[17:24]
meeting will begin
[17:24]
shortly]
[17:25]
[Orange county board of
[17:25]
supervisors-
[17:26]
meeting will begin
[17:28]
shortly]
[17:29]
[Orange county board of
[17:29]
supervisors-
[17:30]
meeting will begin
[17:35]
shortly]
[17:35]
[Orange county board of
[17:36]
supervisors-
[17:36]
meeting will begin
[17:37]
shortly]
[17:38]
[Orange county board of
[17:38]
supervisors-
[17:39]
meeting will begin
[17:41]
shortly]
[17:42]
[Orange county board of
[17:42]
supervisors-
[17:43]
meeting will begin
[17:47]
shortly]
[17:48]
[Orange county board of
[17:49]
supervisors-
[17:49]
meeting will begin
[17:49]
shortly]
[17:50]
[Orange county board of
[17:51]
supervisors-
[17:51]
meeting will begin
[17:54]
shortly]
[17:54]
[Orange county board of
[17:55]
supervisors-
[17:55]
meeting will begin
[18:00]
shortly]
[18:01]
[Orange county board of
[18:01]
supervisors-
[18:02]
meeting will begin
[18:02]
shortly]
[18:03]
[Orange county board of
[18:03]
supervisors-
[18:04]
meeting will begin
[18:07]
shortly]
[18:07]
[Orange county board of
[18:07]
supervisors-
[18:08]
meeting will begin
[18:13]
shortly]
[18:13]
[Orange county board of
[18:14]
supervisors-
[18:14]
meeting will begin
[18:15]
shortly]
[18:16]
[Orange county board of
[18:16]
supervisors-
[18:16]
meeting will begin
[18:19]
shortly]
[18:20]
[Orange county board of
[18:20]
supervisors-
[18:21]
meeting will begin
[18:26]
shortly]
[18:26]
[Orange county board of
[18:26]
supervisors-
[18:27]
meeting will begin
[18:28]
shortly]
[18:28]
[Orange county board of
[18:29]
supervisors-
[18:29]
meeting will begin
[18:32]
shortly]
[18:32]
[Orange county board of
[18:33]
supervisors-
[18:33]
meeting will begin
[18:38]
shortly]
[18:39]
[Orange county board of
[18:39]
supervisors-
[18:40]
meeting will begin
[18:40]
shortly]
[18:41]
[Orange county board of
[18:41]
supervisors-
[18:42]
meeting will begin
[18:45]
shortly]
[18:45]
[Orange county board of
[18:45]
supervisors-
[18:46]
meeting will begin
[18:51]
shortly]
[18:51]
[Orange county board of
[18:52]
supervisors-
[18:52]
meeting will begin
[18:53]
shortly]
[18:54]
[Orange county board of
[18:54]
supervisors-
[18:54]
meeting will begin
[18:57]
shortly]
[18:58]
[Orange county board of
[18:58]
supervisors-
[18:59]
meeting will begin
[19:04]
shortly]
[19:04]
[Orange county board of
[19:05]
supervisors-
[19:05]
meeting will begin
[19:06]
shortly]
[19:06]
[Orange county board of
[19:07]
supervisors-
[19:07]
meeting will begin
[19:10]
shortly]
[19:11]
[Orange county board of
[19:11]
supervisors-
[19:11]
meeting will begin
[19:16]
shortly]
[19:17]
[Orange county board of
[19:17]
supervisors-
[19:18]
meeting will begin
[19:18]
shortly]
[19:19]
[Orange county board of
[19:19]
supervisors-
[19:20]
meeting will begin
[19:23]
shortly]
[19:23]
[Orange county board of
[19:23]
supervisors-
[19:24]
meeting will begin
[19:29]
shortly]
[19:30]
[Orange county board of
[19:30]
supervisors-
[19:30]
meeting will begin
[19:31]
shortly]
[19:32]
[Orange county board of
[19:32]
supervisors-
[19:32]
meeting will begin
[19:35]
shortly]
[19:36]
[Orange county board of
[19:36]
supervisors-
[19:37]
meeting will begin
[19:42]
shortly]
[19:42]
[Orange county board of
[19:43]
supervisors-
[19:43]
meeting will begin
[19:44]
shortly]
[19:44]
[Orange county board of
[19:45]
supervisors-
[19:45]
meeting will begin
[19:48]
shortly]
[19:49]
[Orange county board of
[19:49]
supervisors-
[19:50]
meeting will begin
[19:54]
shortly]
[19:55]
[Orange county board of
[19:55]
supervisors-
[19:56]
meeting will begin
[19:56]
shortly]
[19:57]
[Orange county board of
[19:57]
supervisors-
[19:58]
meeting will begin
[20:00]
shortly]
[20:01]
[Orange county board of
[20:02]
supervisors-
[20:02]
meeting will begin
[20:07]
shortly]
[20:08]
[Orange county board of
[20:08]
supervisors-
[20:08]
meeting will begin
[20:09]
shortly]
[20:10]
[Orange county board of
[20:10]
supervisors-
[20:10]
meeting will begin
[20:13]
shortly]
[20:14]
[Orange county board of
[20:14]
supervisors-
[20:15]
meeting will begin
[20:19]
shortly]
[20:20]
[Orange county board of
[20:21]
supervisors-
[20:21]
meeting will begin
[20:22]
shortly]
[20:22]
[Orange county board of
[20:23]
supervisors-
[20:23]
meeting will begin
[20:26]
shortly]
[20:27]
[Orange county board of
[20:27]
supervisors-
[20:27]
meeting will begin
[20:32]
shortly]
[20:33]
[Orange county board of
[20:33]
supervisors-
[20:34]
meeting will begin
[20:34]
shortly]
[20:35]
[Orange county board of
[20:35]
supervisors-
[20:36]
meeting will begin
[20:38]
shortly]
[20:39]
[Orange county board of
[20:40]
supervisors-
[20:40]
meeting will begin
[20:45]
shortly]
[20:46]
[Orange county board of
[20:46]
supervisors-
[20:47]
meeting will begin
[20:47]
shortly]
[20:48]
[Orange county board of
[20:48]
supervisors-
[20:48]
meeting will begin
[20:51]
shortly]
[20:52]
[Orange county board of
[20:52]
supervisors-
[20:53]
meeting will begin
[20:57]
shortly]
[20:58]
[Orange county board of
[20:58]
supervisors-
[20:59]
meeting will begin
[21:00]
shortly]
[21:00]
[Orange county board of
[21:01]
supervisors-
[21:01]
meeting will begin
[21:04]
shortly]
[21:05]
[Orange county board of
[21:05]
supervisors-
[21:05]
meeting will begin
[21:10]
shortly]
[21:11]
[Orange county board of
[21:11]
supervisors-
[21:12]
meeting will begin
[21:12]
shortly]
[21:13]
[Orange county board of
[21:13]
supervisors-
[21:14]
meeting will begin
[21:16]
shortly]
[21:17]
[Orange county board of
[21:18]
supervisors-
[21:18]
meeting will begin
[21:23]
shortly]
[21:23]
[Orange county board of
[21:24]
supervisors-
[21:24]
meeting will begin
[21:25]
shortly]
[21:26]
[Orange county board of
[21:26]
supervisors-
[21:26]
meeting will begin
[21:29]
shortly]
[21:30]
[Orange county board of
[21:30]
supervisors-
[21:31]
meeting will begin
[21:35]
shortly]
[21:36]
[Orange county board of
[21:36]
supervisors-
[21:37]
meeting will begin
[21:38]
shortly]
[21:38]
[Orange county board of
[21:39]
supervisors-
[21:39]
meeting will begin
[21:42]
shortly]
[21:42]
[Orange county board of
[21:43]
supervisors-
[21:43]
meeting will begin
[21:48]
shortly]
[21:49]
[Orange county board of
[21:49]
supervisors-
[21:50]
meeting will begin
[21:50]
shortly]
[21:51]
[Orange county board of
[21:51]
supervisors-
[21:52]
meeting will begin
[21:54]
shortly]
[21:55]
[Orange county board of
[21:55]
supervisors-
[21:56]
meeting will begin
[22:01]
shortly]
[22:01]
[Orange county board of
[22:02]
supervisors-
[22:02]
meeting will begin
[22:03]
shortly]
[22:04]
[Orange county board of
[22:04]
supervisors-
[22:04]
meeting will begin
[22:07]
shortly]
[22:08]
[Orange county board of
[22:08]
supervisors-
[22:09]
meeting will begin
[22:13]
shortly]
[22:14]
[Orange county board of
[22:14]
supervisors-
[22:15]
meeting will begin
[22:15]
shortly]
[22:16]
[Orange county board of
[22:17]
supervisors-
[22:17]
meeting will begin
[22:20]
shortly]
[22:20]
[Orange county board of
[22:21]
supervisors-
[22:21]
meeting will begin
[22:26]
shortly]
[22:27]
[Orange county board of
[22:27]
supervisors-
[22:28]
meeting will begin
[22:28]
shortly]
[22:29]
[Orange county board of
[22:29]
supervisors-
[22:30]
meeting will begin
[22:32]
shortly]
[22:33]
[Orange county board of
[22:33]
supervisors-
[22:34]
meeting will begin
[22:39]
shortly]
[22:39]
[Orange county board of
[22:40]
supervisors-
[22:40]
meeting will begin
[22:41]
shortly]
[22:42]
[Orange county board of
[22:42]
supervisors-
[22:42]
meeting will begin
[22:45]
shortly]
[22:46]
[Orange county board of
[22:46]
supervisors-
[22:47]
meeting will begin
[22:51]
shortly]
[22:52]
[Orange county board of
[22:52]
supervisors-
[22:53]
meeting will begin
[22:53]
shortly]
[22:54]
[Orange county board of
[22:55]
supervisors-
[22:55]
meeting will begin
[22:58]
shortly]
[22:58]
[Orange county board of
[22:59]
supervisors-
[22:59]
meeting will begin
[23:04]
shortly]
[23:05]
[Orange county board of
[23:05]
supervisors-
[23:06]
meeting will begin
[23:06]
shortly]
[23:07]
[Orange county board of
[23:07]
supervisors-
[23:09]
meeting will begin
[23:10]
shortly]
[23:11]
[Orange county board of
[23:11]
supervisors-
[23:12]
meeting will begin
[23:17]
shortly]
[23:17]
[Orange county board of
[23:18]
supervisors-
[23:18]
meeting will begin
[23:19]
shortly]
[23:20]
[Orange county board of
[23:20]
supervisors-
[23:20]
meeting will begin
[23:23]
shortly]
[23:24]
[Orange county board of
[23:24]
supervisors-
[23:25]
meeting will begin
[23:29]
shortly]
[23:30]
[Orange county board of
[23:30]
supervisors-
[23:31]
meeting will begin
[23:32]
shortly]
[23:32]
[Orange county board of
[23:33]
supervisors-
[23:33]
meeting will begin
[23:36]
shortly]
[23:36]
[Orange county board of
[23:37]
supervisors-
[23:37]
meeting will begin
[23:42]
shortly]
[23:43]
[Orange county board of
[23:43]
supervisors-
[23:44]
meeting will begin
[23:44]
shortly]
[23:45]
[Orange county board of
[23:45]
supervisors-
[23:46]
meeting will begin
[23:48]
shortly]
[23:49]
[Orange county board of
[23:49]
supervisors-
[23:50]
meeting will begin
[23:55]
shortly]
[23:56]
[Orange county board of
[23:56]
supervisors-
[23:56]
meeting will begin
[23:57]
shortly]
[23:58]
[Orange county board of
[23:58]
supervisors-
[23:58]
meeting will begin
[24:01]
shortly]
[24:02]
[Orange county board of
[24:02]
supervisors-
[24:03]
meeting will begin
[24:07]
shortly]
[24:08]
[Orange county board of
[24:08]
supervisors-
[24:09]
meeting will begin
[24:10]
shortly]
[24:10]
[Orange county board of
[24:11]
supervisors-
[24:11]
meeting will begin
[24:14]
shortly]
[24:14]
[Orange county board of
[24:15]
supervisors-
[24:15]
meeting will begin
[24:20]
shortly]
[24:21]
[Orange county board of
[24:21]
supervisors-
[24:22]
meeting will begin
[24:22]
shortly]
[24:23]
[Orange county board of
[24:23]
supervisors-
[24:24]
meeting will begin
[24:26]
shortly]
[24:27]
[Orange county board of
[24:27]
supervisors-
[24:28]
meeting will begin
[24:33]
shortly]
[24:33]
[Orange county board of
[24:34]
supervisors-
[24:34]
meeting will begin
[24:35]
shortly]
[24:36]
[Orange county board of
[24:36]
supervisors-
[24:36]
meeting will begin
[24:39]
shortly]
[24:40]
[Orange county board of
[24:40]
supervisors-
[24:41]
meeting will begin
[24:45]
shortly]
[24:46]
[Orange county board of
[24:46]
supervisors-
[24:47]
meeting will begin
[24:48]
shortly]
[24:48]
[Orange county board of
[24:49]
supervisors-
[24:49]
meeting will begin
[24:52]
shortly]
[24:52]
[Orange county board of
[24:53]
supervisors-
[24:53]
meeting will begin
[24:58]
shortly]
[24:59]
[Orange county board of
[24:59]
supervisors-
[25:00]
meeting will begin
[25:00]
shortly]
[25:01]
[Orange county board of
[25:01]
supervisors-
[25:02]
meeting will begin
[25:04]
shortly]
[25:05]
[Orange county board of
[25:05]
supervisors-
[25:06]
meeting will begin
[25:12]
shortly]
[25:12]
[Orange county board of
[25:12]
supervisors-
[25:12]
meeting will begin
[25:13]
shortly]
[25:14]
[Orange county board of
[25:14]
supervisors-
[25:14]
meeting will begin
[25:17]
shortly]
[25:18]
[Orange county board of
[25:18]
supervisors-
[25:19]
meeting will begin
[25:23]
shortly]
[25:24]
[Orange county board of
[25:24]
supervisors-
[25:25]
meeting will begin
[25:26]
shortly]
[25:26]
[Orange county board of
[25:27]
supervisors-
[25:27]
meeting will begin
[25:30]
shortly]
[25:30]
[Orange county board of
[25:31]
supervisors-
[25:31]
meeting will begin
[25:36]
shortly]
[25:37]
[Orange county board of
[25:37]
supervisors-
[25:38]
meeting will begin
[25:38]
shortly]
[25:39]
[Orange county board of
[25:39]
supervisors-
[25:40]
meeting will begin
[25:42]
shortly]
[25:43]
[Orange county board of
[25:45]
supervisors-
[25:45]
meeting will begin
[25:49]
shortly]
[25:49]
[Orange county board of
[25:51]
supervisors-
[25:51]
meeting will begin
[25:51]
shortly]
[25:52]
[Orange county board of
[25:52]
supervisors-
[25:52]
meeting will begin
[25:55]
shortly]
[25:57]
[Orange county board of
[25:57]
supervisors-
[25:57]
meeting will begin
[26:01]
shortly]
[26:02]
[Orange county board of
[26:02]
supervisors-
[26:03]
meeting will begin
[26:04]
shortly]
[26:04]
[Orange county board of
[26:05]
supervisors-
[26:05]
meeting will begin
[26:08]
shortly]
[26:08]
[Orange county board of
[26:09]
supervisors-
[26:09]
meeting will begin
[26:14]
shortly]
[26:16]
[Orange county board of
[26:16]
supervisors-
[26:16]
meeting will begin
[26:16]
shortly]
[26:17]
[Orange county board of
[26:17]
supervisors-
[26:18]
meeting will begin
[26:20]
shortly]
[26:21]
[Orange county board of
[26:21]
supervisors-
[26:22]
meeting will begin
[26:27]
shortly]
[26:27]
[Orange county board of
[26:28]
supervisors-
[26:28]
meeting will begin
[26:30]
shortly]
[26:30]
[Orange county board of
[26:30]
supervisors-
[26:30]
meeting will begin
[26:33]
shortly]
[26:34]
[Orange county board of
[26:34]
supervisors-
[26:35]
meeting will begin
[26:39]
shortly]
[26:40]
[Orange county board of
[26:40]
supervisors-
[26:41]
meeting will begin
[26:42]
shortly]
[26:42]
[Orange county board of
[26:43]
supervisors-
[26:43]
meeting will begin
[26:46]
shortly]
[26:46]
[Orange county board of
[26:48]
supervisors-
[26:48]
meeting will begin
[26:52]
shortly]
[26:53]
[Orange county board of
[26:53]
supervisors-
[26:54]
meeting will begin
[26:54]
shortly]
[26:55]
[Orange county board of
[26:55]
supervisors-
[26:56]
meeting will begin
[26:58]
shortly]
[26:59]
[Orange county board of
[26:59]
supervisors-
[27:00]
meeting will begin
[27:05]
shortly]
[27:05]
[Orange county board of
[27:06]
supervisors-
[27:06]
meeting will begin
[27:07]
shortly]
[27:08]
[Orange county board of
[27:08]
supervisors-
[27:08]
meeting will begin
[27:11]
shortly]
[27:12]
[Orange county board of
[27:12]
supervisors-
[27:13]
meeting will begin
[27:17]
shortly]
[27:18]
[Orange county board of
[27:18]
supervisors-
[27:20]
meeting will begin
[27:20]
shortly]
[27:20]
[Orange county board of
[27:21]
supervisors-
[27:21]
meeting will begin
[27:24]
shortly]
[27:24]
[Orange county board of
[27:25]
supervisors-
[27:25]
meeting will begin
[27:30]
shortly]
[27:31]
[Orange county board of
[27:31]
supervisors-
[27:32]
meeting will begin
[27:32]
shortly]
[27:33]
[Orange county board of
[27:33]
supervisors-
[27:34]
meeting will begin
[27:36]
shortly]
[27:37]
[Orange county board of
[27:37]
supervisors-
[27:38]
meeting will begin
[27:43]
shortly]
[27:43]
[Orange county board of
[27:44]
supervisors-
[27:44]
meeting will begin
[27:45]
shortly]
[27:46]
[Orange county board of
[27:46]
supervisors-
[27:46]
meeting will begin
[27:49]
shortly]
[27:50]
[Orange county board of
[27:50]
supervisors-
[27:51]
meeting will begin
[27:55]
shortly]
[27:56]
[Orange county board of
[27:56]
supervisors-
[27:57]
meeting will begin
[27:58]
shortly]
[27:58]
[Orange county board of
[27:59]
supervisors-
[27:59]
meeting will begin
[28:02]
shortly]
[28:02]
[Orange county board of
[28:03]
supervisors-
[28:03]
meeting will begin
[28:08]
shortly]
[28:09]
[Orange county board of
[28:09]
supervisors-
[28:10]
meeting will begin
[28:10]
shortly]
[28:11]
[Orange county board of
[28:11]
supervisors-
[28:12]
meeting will begin
[28:14]
shortly]
[28:15]
[Orange county board of
[28:15]
supervisors-
[28:16]
meeting will begin
[28:21]
shortly]
[28:21]
[Orange county board of
[28:22]
supervisors-
[28:22]
meeting will begin
[28:23]
shortly]
[28:24]
[Orange county board of
[28:25]
supervisors-
[28:25]
meeting will begin
[28:27]
shortly]
[28:28]
[Orange county board of
[28:28]
supervisors-
[28:29]
meeting will begin
[28:33]
shortly]
[28:34]
[Orange county board of
[28:34]
supervisors-
[28:35]
meeting will begin
[28:36]
shortly]
[28:36]
[Orange county board of
[28:37]
supervisors-
[28:37]
meeting will begin
[28:40]
shortly]
[28:40]
[Orange county board of
[28:41]
supervisors-
[28:41]
meeting will begin
[28:46]
shortly]
[28:47]
[Orange county board of
[28:47]
supervisors-
[28:48]
meeting will begin
[28:48]
shortly]
[28:50]
[Orange county board of
[28:50]
supervisors-
[28:50]
meeting will begin
[28:52]
shortly]
[28:53]
[Orange county board of
[28:53]
supervisors-
[28:54]
meeting will begin
[28:59]
shortly]
[28:59]
[Orange county board of
[29:00]
supervisors-
[29:00]
meeting will begin
[29:01]
shortly]
[29:02]
[Orange county board of
[29:02]
supervisors-
[29:02]
meeting will begin
[29:05]
shortly]
[29:06]
[Orange county board of
[29:06]
supervisors-
[29:07]
meeting will begin
[29:11]
shortly]
[29:12]
[Orange county board of
[29:12]
supervisors-
[29:13]
meeting will begin
[29:14]
shortly]
[29:14]
[Orange county board of
[29:15]
supervisors-
[29:15]
meeting will begin
[29:18]
shortly]
[29:18]
[Orange county board of
[29:19]
supervisors-
[29:19]
meeting will begin
[29:24]
shortly]
[29:25]
[Orange county board of
[29:25]
supervisors-
[29:26]
meeting will begin
[29:26]
shortly]
[29:27]
[Orange county board of
[29:27]
supervisors-
[29:28]
meeting will begin
[29:30]
shortly]
[29:31]
[Orange county board of
[29:32]
supervisors-
[29:32]
meeting will begin
[29:37]
shortly]
[29:37]
[Orange county board of
[29:38]
supervisors-
[29:38]
meeting will begin
[29:39]
shortly]
[29:40]
[Orange county board of
[29:40]
supervisors-
[29:40]
meeting will begin
[29:43]
shortly]
[29:44]
[Orange county board of
[29:44]
supervisors-
[29:45]
meeting will begin
[29:49]
shortly]
[29:50]
[Orange county board of
[29:50]
supervisors-
[29:51]
meeting will begin
[29:52]
shortly]
[29:52]
[Orange county board of
[29:53]
supervisors-
[29:54]
meeting will begin
[29:56]
shortly]
[29:56]
[Orange county board of
[29:57]
supervisors-
[29:57]
meeting will begin
[30:02]
shortly]
[30:03]
[Orange county board of
[30:03]
supervisors-
[30:04]
meeting will begin
[30:04]
shortly]
[30:05]
[Orange county board of
[30:05]
supervisors-
[30:06]
meeting will begin
[30:08]
shortly]
[30:09]
[Orange county board of
[30:10]
supervisors-
[30:10]
meeting will begin
[30:15]
shortly]
[30:15]
[Orange county board of
[30:16]
supervisors-
[30:16]
meeting will begin
[30:17]
shortly]
[30:18]
[Orange county board of
[30:18]
supervisors-
[30:18]
meeting will begin
[30:21]
shortly]
[30:22]
[Orange county board of
[30:22]
supervisors-
[30:23]
meeting will begin
[30:27]
shortly]
[30:28]
[Orange county board of
[30:28]
supervisors-
[30:29]
meeting will begin
[30:30]
shortly]
[30:30]
[Orange county board of
[30:31]
supervisors-
[30:31]
meeting will begin
[30:34]
shortly]
[30:34]
[Orange county board of
[30:35]
supervisors-
[30:35]
meeting will begin
[30:40]
shortly]
[30:41]
[Orange county board of
[30:41]
supervisors-
[30:42]
meeting will begin
[30:42]
shortly]
[30:43]
[Orange county board of
[30:43]
supervisors-
[30:44]
meeting will begin
[30:46]
shortly]
[30:47]
[Orange county board of
[30:47]
supervisors-
[30:48]
meeting will begin
[30:53]
shortly]
[30:53]
[Orange county board of
[30:54]
supervisors-
[30:54]
meeting will begin
[30:55]
shortly]
[30:56]
[Orange county board of
[30:56]
supervisors-
[30:56]
meeting will begin
[30:59]
shortly]
[31:00]
[Orange county board of
[31:00]
supervisors-
[31:01]
meeting will begin
[31:05]
shortly]
[31:06]
[Orange county board of
[31:06]
supervisors-
[31:07]
meeting will begin
[31:08]
shortly]
[31:08]
[Orange county board of good morning,
[31:09]
supervisors-
[31:09]
meeting will begin everyone
[31:10]
shortly]. I'd like to welcome
[31:15]
you to this
[31:16]
>>speaker: good morning,
[31:17]
everyone. I'd like to welcome
[31:19]
you to this meeting FEBRUARY 24,
[31:22]
2026. Today the invocations
[31:25]
will be offered by vice-chair
[31:26]
foley and pledge of allegiance
[31:27]
led by supervisor nguyen. If
[31:36]
you're able, please stand.
[31:38]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: join
[31:39]
me today to pause for a moment
[31:40]
reflection before we begin the
[31:41]
work on behalf of our orange
[31:42]
county community. We join
[31:44]
together here with the shared
[31:46]
responsibility to serve every
[31:50]
constituent of our community
[31:52]
with speaking with grill and
[31:53]
purpose and moments when
[31:55]
disagreements grow MAY we
[31:56]
remember that public service
[31:57]
calls us to rise above division.
[32:00]
Let us all work harder and with
[32:02]
more intention to choose
[32:04]
collaboration over conflict and
[32:06]
solutions over spectacle. As
[32:08]
leaders we also have a duty to
[32:10]
protect and support the county
[32:11]
staff who carry out this work
[32:14]
for us every day. They look to
[32:16]
us for steadiness,
[32:17]
accountability and example. Our
[32:20]
conduct sets the tone. Ideally
[32:23]
we lead them and they help us
[32:24]
improve our county government by
[32:26]
trusting their commitment to
[32:27]
provide quality services and set
[32:30]
high standards for performance
[32:31]
and delivery of services. MAY
[32:34]
we remember that this work is
[32:36]
not about any one of us, it is
[32:38]
about all of us. We MAY not
[32:40]
always agree but we MAY disagree
[32:42]
with respect, work harder to
[32:45]
challenge ideas without
[32:47]
degrading one another and remain
[32:49]
productive rather than
[32:51]
interactive, when we falter or
[32:52]
slip up, MAY we also forgive and
[32:55]
commit to picking up another
[32:56]
plank to keep building the
[32:58]
bridges that keep us connected.
[33:01]
Our community benefits when we
[33:02]
build bridges, not barriers.
[33:04]
And when we focus on helping
[33:06]
lift up all segments of our
[33:08]
community.. As we watch bombs
[33:10]
bursting, builds blow up and
[33:13]
other chaos in other countries
[33:14]
and communities, let us
[33:15]
recognize the privilege we share
[33:18]
to live and serve here and the
[33:20]
duty to move forward together
[33:22]
for the entire county to protect
[33:24]
this paradise we call home. I
[33:27]
look forward a protective
[33:28]
meeting with you all. Thank
[33:29]
you. Please join me in the
[33:37]
pledge of allegiance.
[33:39]
I pledge allegiance to my flag
[33:40]
to the united states of america
[33:41]
and to the republic for which it
[33:42]
stands, one nation, under GOD,
[33:44]
indivisible, with liberty and
[33:52]
justice for all.
[33:54]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank you
[33:54]
supervisors foley and nguyen. A
[34:00]
couple of reminders for today's
[34:03]
meeting, please use the main
[34:04]
entrance when entering and
[34:06]
leaving the room. All the other
[34:08]
doors are alarmed and for
[34:09]
emergency exit only. Please set
[34:13]
all cell phones to "mute" or
[34:16]
vibrate at this time for the
[34:18]
duration of the meeting. A list
[34:20]
of changes to today's agenda
[34:22]
along with the agenda requests
[34:24]
to speak are locate in the lobby
[34:26]
outside the boardroom. We'll be
[34:29]
breaking for lunch around the
[34:31]
noon hour during which time
[34:32]
we'll also recess to closed
[34:33]
sessions.
[34:36]
Feed the parking validation for
[34:37]
the p4 parking lot, please see
[34:41]
the deputy clerk next to the
[34:42]
podium and you'll see a parking
[34:44]
validation card. We now will
[34:47]
proceed to the agenda for this
[34:49]
morning's meeting. This agenda
[34:52]
contains a brief description of
[34:54]
each item to be considered
[34:56]
except as provided by law, no
[34:58]
action maybe taken to any item
[35:00]
not appearing in today's agenda.
[35:03]
The agenda is divide into
[35:04]
sections, all matters on the
[35:06]
scent calendar are proved by --
[35:07]
a -- on the consent calendar are
[35:08]
approved by one motion, a board
[35:10]
member or member of the public
[35:12]
MAY have a separate action on a
[35:13]
specific item. If you wish to
[35:15]
address the board, please
[35:17]
complete a speaker request form.
[35:22]
To be heard on a consent
[35:23]
calendar item, the completed
[35:25]
form must be deposited in the
[35:27]
box next to the podium prior to
[35:29]
the beginning of the consent
[35:30]
calendar. As to all other items
[35:33]
to ensure smooth conduct in
[35:35]
meetings, speaker requests must
[35:36]
be turned in prior to the
[35:38]
reading of an individual item,
[35:39]
including public comments.
[35:43]
Speakers MAY address the board
[35:44]
up to three occasions for three
[35:46]
minutes allotted to the speaker
[35:49]
per occasion. When you're
[35:51]
called to special please step to
[35:52]
the podium, we request that you
[35:54]
state your name and city of
[35:55]
residence for the record.
[35:57]
Please note the light on the
[35:58]
podium. The green light means
[36:00]
you have three minutes. The
[36:02]
light changes to yellow when you
[36:03]
have 1 minute. The light turns
[36:04]
to red when your time has
[36:06]
expired. We ask that you
[36:08]
observe the time limit so that
[36:09]
all who wish to speak will have
[36:11]
an opportunity do so.
[36:13]
Addressing the board, we address
[36:15]
the board as a whole through the
[36:16]
chair.. We're moving to -- I'm
[36:32]
changing this around a little
[36:34]
built. Normally we have board
[36:36]
comments that the time. I'm
[36:37]
going to move that to the end of
[36:38]
the meeting instead. And so now
[36:42]
we'll move to our agenda items.
[36:44]
I ask the clerk to identify any
[36:45]
changes to the agenda, any
[36:48]
requests received from the
[36:49]
public to pull an item from the
[36:51]
consent calendar for separate
[36:53]
consideration. MADAM Clerk.
[36:56]
>>clerk, robin stieler: on
[36:56]
discussion calendar, item 22 has
[36:58]
been deleted. And closed
[37:01]
sessions cs-1 has also been
[37:03]
deleted. The public has
[37:05]
requested to pull item 4 from
[37:06]
the consent calendar.
[37:11]
>>chair, doug chaffee: I would
[37:11]
like to move item, I believe,
[37:14]
it's 28, to be heard after item
[37:17]
17 since item 18 can be directed
[37:21]
by that item. That's the board
[37:28]
procurement item.
[37:29]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: did
[37:30]
you say 22, grants committee
[37:32]
report --
[37:33]
>>chair, doug chaffee: no. I
[37:34]
meant 28.
[37:36]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 22 was
[37:37]
deleted. Excuse me. 23. 23.
[37:40]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: okay.
[37:41]
I thought so. Thank you.
[37:51]
>>chair, doug chaffee: okay.
[37:52]
I'd ask my colleague if there
[37:54]
are any items you'd like to hear
[37:56]
separately on the consent
[37:57]
calendar. We have requests from
[38:00]
the public that item 4 be heard
[38:02]
separately. Except for, that
[38:04]
MAY I have a motion --
[38:05]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: move
[38:05]
the balance.
[38:06]
>>don wagner: second.
[38:06]
>>chair, doug chaffee: any
[38:07]
objection? Seeing none,
[38:10]
carried. Item 4.
[38:11]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 4.
[38:11]
Under oc community resources,
[38:12]
Approve master agreement for oc
[38:13]
Animal Care services, 6/1/26-
[38:15]
5/31/31; authorize Director
[38:16]
or designee to execute
[38:17]
individual agreements, make
[38:18]
minor changes and renew
[38:20]
agreements under certain conditions.
[38:22]
And we have one requests to
[38:23]
speak on agenda item 4.
[38:25]
>>chair, doug chaffee: please
[38:25]
call the speaker.
[38:28]
>>clerk, robin stieler: michael
[38:29]
m.
[38:31]
>>speaker: thank you. Michael m
[38:34]
from irvine. In the last year,
[38:36]
the animal shelter has made
[38:37]
significant strides, thanks to
[38:40]
this board. I am grateful to
[38:45]
those who led these positive
[38:46]
changes and as a proud resident
[38:48]
of the third district also to
[38:50]
supervisor wagner for his
[38:51]
support. To sustain the
[38:54]
progress we need to follow up on
[38:56]
the shelter's strategic plan,
[38:58]
which defines how the board, its
[39:01]
cities and community expect the
[39:02]
shelter to operate. We as a
[39:05]
county spent thousands of hours
[39:07]
and hundreds of thousands of
[39:09]
dollars to put this plan
[39:10]
together. The board voted for
[39:13]
the strategic plan as the
[39:14]
blueprint for shelter
[39:15]
operations. I urge the board
[39:18]
and the animal shelter to follow
[39:20]
up on last year's improvements
[39:22]
and put the shelter on a good
[39:23]
path that fixes persisting
[39:26]
promise and prevents
[39:27]
backsliding. The plan there, we
[39:30]
just need work on
[39:31]
implementation. Thank you.
[39:33]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank you
[39:34]
for your comments. Back to the
[39:37]
board for consideration. Do we
[39:38]
have a motion.
[39:39]
>>janet nguyen: I'll move it
[39:40]
with comments, MR. CHAIRMAN.
[39:41]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley:
[39:41]
second.
[39:42]
>>chair, doug chaffee: please go
[39:43]
ahead, prfers nguyen.
[39:46]
>>janet nguyen: I just want to
[39:47]
first thank monica, dillon and
[39:51]
the oc animal staff for putting
[39:54]
these contracts together.
[39:56]
Really thankful that there's no
[39:59]
increase in our rates as well,
[40:01]
because, you know, it's a tough
[40:02]
time for cities and -- but, yet,
[40:05]
you know, we are still providing
[40:06]
the services and making sure
[40:08]
that these contracts -- well,
[40:11]
making sure that we don't
[40:12]
increase the rates for the
[40:13]
cities. And so I appreciate all
[40:16]
that they've done. And I agree
[40:18]
with our speakers that, you
[40:20]
know, oc animal has made
[40:21]
significant changes last year,
[40:26]
you know, so please know that we
[40:26]
appreciate you, but there is
[40:28]
still some work to be done. And
[40:31]
I -- you know, I know that
[40:32]
you're working on a strategic
[40:34]
plan. Staff has told my office
[40:37]
that you're compiling a report
[40:41]
to, you know -- on the 2018
[40:43]
strategic plan that would be
[40:45]
coming to the board. I'm hoping
[40:47]
maybe if you can give us a
[40:49]
report in the next 30 days on
[40:51]
where you're at with that and
[40:53]
when we will see it moving
[40:56]
forward, whether it's a board
[40:58]
hearing, then we will accept
[40:59]
your report or a report to the
[41:01]
board itself. So again, I'm
[41:05]
excited to support this item and
[41:08]
looking forward to more great
[41:09]
things and collaboration with oc
[41:13]
animal in the community. Thank
[41:14]
you.
[41:16]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank
[41:16]
you, supervisor nguyen.
[41:17]
Supervisor sarmiento.
[41:19]
>>vincente sarmiento: thank you,
[41:19]
MR. Chair, and thank you to the
[41:21]
speaker for his comments. I
[41:23]
certainly appreciate and agree
[41:24]
with them, and I want to
[41:26]
actually also thank the
[41:29]
community members that helped
[41:30]
influence the changes that were
[41:33]
made since, you know, I've been
[41:35]
on this board and thank the
[41:37]
staff at animal care, dillon and
[41:39]
monica and others that made
[41:42]
these changes that are very
[41:43]
reasonable. So I do think we
[41:45]
have a great outline of what we
[41:47]
need to do with the strategic
[41:48]
plan, and it was adopted in
[41:50]
2018. I simply think that we
[41:52]
need to make sure that the
[41:53]
public gets to see
[41:54]
compliance,
[41:56]
implementation, and those
[41:57]
regular reports and making sure
[42:01]
that we're meeting the metrics,
[42:02]
the goals stated in that
[42:04]
strategic plan. So to the
[42:06]
extent that something is brought
[42:08]
back, I think we need to do
[42:09]
something on a periodic basis,
[42:10]
and make sure that we're able to
[42:13]
see almost as a dashboard,
[42:14]
right, to see how we're doing on
[42:16]
these different concerns that we
[42:18]
have, that are outlined in the
[42:20]
strategic plan. So I am
[42:22]
supportive of all that's been
[42:24]
said, and obviously on this
[42:26]
underlying item, which is sort
[42:28]
of unrelated to the strategic
[42:29]
plan implementation. But I do
[42:31]
think maybe we should bring
[42:33]
something back that's a little
[42:34]
bit more formal that will give
[42:36]
some guidance on how to make
[42:38]
sure we're complying with the
[42:39]
strategic plan periodically for
[42:41]
the public to see. So I am
[42:43]
supportive these -- of the
[42:43]
underlying item, as well. Thank
[42:45]
you.
[42:46]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank
[42:47]
you. Any more comment?
[42:50]
Seeing none, we have a motion.
[42:53]
Any objection? The item is
[42:55]
approved. Thank you. Item 7.
[43:00]
Is that where we're at? Item 7,
[43:03]
yes. That would conclude our
[43:03]
consent calendar.
[43:05]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 7.
[43:06]
Under Treasurer-Tax Collector-
[43:08]
Approve transfer of funds
[43:09]
($62,669.16) From Probation Fund
[43:10]
to Probation Victim Restitution
[43:12]
Fund and transfer of escheated
[43:14]
funds ($74,056.03) From
[43:15]
Sheriff-Coroner Fund to County
[43:16]
General Fund. It does require a
[43:17]
vote.
[43:22]
>>chair, doug chaffee: an
[43:29]
all-district item.
[43:29]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: move
[43:29]
the item.
[43:30]
>>chair, doug chaffee: I'll
[43:30]
second the item.
[43:33]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: no
[43:34]
one wants to support this, I
[43:35]
guess.
[43:38]
>>chair, doug chaffee: any
[43:39]
objection? Seeing none, it
[43:41]
required a 4/5th vote. We
[43:43]
have unanimous approval of that
[43:48]
item. Item 8, please.
[43:49]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 8.
[43:50]
Under health care agency,
[43:51]
Approve amendment 2 to renew
[43:52]
contract ma-042-24010172 with
[43:53]
The Regents of the University of
[43:54]
California, on behalf of uc
[43:56]
Irvine School of Medicine,
[43:57]
Department of Psychiatry for
[43:59]
physician services, 7/1/26-
[44:00]
6/30/28 ($1,210,000; cumulative
[44:00]
total $3,025,000); And
[44:01]
authorize County Procurement
[44:03]
Officer or Deputized designee to
[44:05]
execute amendment. We have no
[44:08]
requests to speak on agenda item
[44:09]
8.
[44:09]
>>chair, doug chaffee: lgt a
[44:11]
district 2 item.
[44:12]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley:
[44:13]
second.
[44:13]
>>chair, doug chaffee: any
[44:15]
objection? Item is approved.
[44:16]
Item 9, please.
[44:16]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 9.
[44:17]
Under health care agency,
[44:19]
Approve amendment 6 to renew
[44:19]
contract ma-042-23011035 with
[44:20]
ocy Management, llc for
[44:21]
non-emergency transportation
[44:22]
services, 7/1/26-6/30/28
[44:22]
($1,000,000; cumulative total
[44:23]
$4,650,000); and authorize
[44:24]
County Procurement Officer or
[44:24]
Deputized designee to execute
[44:27]
amendment. We have no requests
[44:31]
to speak on agenda item 9.
[44:32]
>>chair, doug chaffee: it's an
[44:46]
all-district item.
[44:46]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 10.
[44:47]
Under health care agency,
[44:48]
approve amendment 6 to renew
[44:49]
contract ma-042-20011621 with
[44:49]
anaheim global medical center,
[44:50]
inc. For inpatient hospital
[44:51]
services for correctional health
[44:51]
services, 7/1/26-6/30/28
[44:52]
($12,833,874; cumulative total
[44:53]
$49,855,154); and authorize
[44:54]
county procurement officer or
[44:54]
deputized designee to execute
[44:57]
amendment. S we have no
[44:58]
requests to speak.
[44:59]
>>chair, doug chaffee: it's a
[45:00]
district 3 item.
[45:02]
>>janet nguyen: thank you. I
[45:03]
received a contribution of over
[45:06]
$1,000 for ocy management back
[45:09]
in 2025.
[45:10]
Since the contribution exceeds
[45:17]
the 500 threshold set by the
[45:19]
management, I am recusing myself
[45:22]
from participating in this
[45:22]
discussion.
[45:25]
>>leon page: and that was item 9
[45:27]
and 10, supervisor, correct?
[45:29]
Where you intend to recuse
[45:30]
yourself? If the board would
[45:32]
permit to reflect that
[45:35]
supervisor nguyen did not
[45:36]
participate in the board
[45:37]
deliberation vote on item 9,
[45:38]
which we already did, and now
[45:40]
we're on number 10.
[45:41]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: I'll
[45:47]
move to re-open item 9 for --
[45:50]
item no. 9 for a second vote.
[45:51]
>>vincente sarmiento: I'll move
[45:52]
the item.
[45:53]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley:
[45:53]
second.
[45:58]
>>chair, doug chaffee: any
[45:58]
objection?
[45:59]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: you
[46:06]
have to make the disclosure.
[46:07]
>>chair, doug chaffee: I'm not
[46:08]
sure where we are here.
[46:09]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: now
[46:10]
we have to vote on item 9.
[46:10]
>>chair, doug chaffee: all
[46:13]
right. We had a motion, and
[46:16]
supervisor sarmiento would like
[46:17]
to make a comment.
[46:19]
>>vincente sarmiento: on item 10
[46:20]
10.
[46:21]
>>chair, doug chaffee: okay.
[46:21]
We're back to 9.
[46:23]
>>vincente sarmiento: I moved
[46:24]
item 9.
[46:24]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: and I
[46:24]
seconded.
[46:25]
>>chair, doug chaffee: any
[46:29]
objection? Seeing none, item 9
[46:29]
is approved.
[46:32]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: with
[46:32]
one abstention.
[46:33]
>>chair, doug chaffee: okay.
[46:34]
With one abstention. Okay.
[46:36]
Sorry. All right. That gave us
[46:42]
a majority vote. Now we're on
[46:44]
item 10, that's a district 2 and
[46:45]
3 item.
[46:47]
>>vincente sarmiento: that,
[46:48]
MR. Chair. I'd like to have
[46:50]
DR. Kelly, if she can, maybe
[46:52]
come and share some thoughts on
[46:53]
this. I want to make sure that
[46:54]
we are clear. I know this is
[46:56]
for services for our in-custody
[47:01]
population. So medical care and
[47:04]
hospital care. So to the
[47:06]
extent, DR. Kelly, if you could
[47:07]
just walk us through.
[47:09]
>>leon page: and I think
[47:09]
supervisor nguyen has been
[47:10]
announcement on this as well.
[47:13]
>>janet nguyen: I do. I would
[47:13]
like to also recuse myself from
[47:15]
this vote, as well. I received
[47:17]
a contribution of $2500 from
[47:19]
strategic global management,
[47:20]
inc. Which is affiliated with
[47:22]
anaheim global medical center
[47:24]
back on MAY 12th, 2025 for
[47:27]
this item. I'm recushion myself
[47:28]
from participating in any
[47:29]
discussion or vote on this
[47:30]
matter. Thank you.
[47:34]
>>chair, doug chaffee: all
[47:34]
right. Any more comments?
[47:41]
>>speaker: good morning,
[47:41]
CHAIRMAN Chaffee, honorable
[47:43]
board. DR. Kelly, director of
[47:44]
the orange county healthcare
[47:48]
agency. Were there specific
[47:48]
questions you had or you just
[47:49]
want an overview.
[47:51]
>>vincente sarmiento: I know we
[47:52]
went to procurement for this.
[47:53]
We had two responses. I know
[47:55]
that anaheim global is the
[47:56]
prevailing bidder on this.
[47:59]
Number one, explain what the
[48:00]
item is, it's an important one,
[48:02]
and number 2, what are your
[48:04]
thoughts going forward? Does
[48:06]
this benefit the county? I know
[48:08]
this is trying to include
[48:11]
cal-aim to be able to maybe
[48:13]
address some of the cost
[48:15]
concerns. But if you can,
[48:16]
please --
[48:18]
>>speaker: this stem to renew
[48:19]
inpatient services for
[48:20]
correctional health. And so the
[48:22]
vendor is anaheim global medical
[48:24]
center. They provide medical
[48:26]
care for inmates who require
[48:29]
outpatient specialty care such
[48:30]
as dialysis that can't be done
[48:32]
in custody or inpatient care, if
[48:35]
someone is having a cardiac
[48:36]
issue, they're giving birth. So
[48:38]
they provide that medical care.
[48:43]
>>vincente sarmiento: who are we
[48:43]
billing for this? Who's paying
[48:44]
for this.
[48:45]
>>speaker: none of that is
[48:46]
billable to any insurance. That
[48:48]
is full net county cost. The
[48:50]
item you talked about cal-aim
[48:52]
jail in range is for a very
[48:55]
specific cost that would not
[48:55]
include these services. It
[48:57]
would include some services we
[48:59]
provide for correctional health,
[49:01]
evaluations, medical evaluations
[49:03]
of inmates, providing
[49:05]
medication. And we are going to
[49:06]
start that APRIL 1st, and we
[49:09]
can only provide that and bill
[49:10]
the state for those services,
[49:13]
for people who are eligible for
[49:14]
medi-cal, and that would be for
[49:16]
90 days prior to their release.
[49:19]
Carnals so 83% of this is born
[49:21]
by the county, that county cost
[49:23]
17% realignment dollars. Your
[49:25]
recommendation, we just went out
[49:27]
on an rfp, do you think we
[49:28]
should go out on one soon
[49:30]
after.
[49:31]
>>speaker: we are going to be
[49:31]
starting another rfp. Usually
[49:33]
they take 12 to 18 months. This
[49:36]
is harder service to find
[49:38]
appropriate vendors for because
[49:40]
of the population and the
[49:41]
custody, the hard custody
[49:43]
requirements. So change in the
[49:44]
actual building space itself.
[49:47]
So we will be shortly after --
[49:49]
if this report approves, we will
[49:51]
go out for another rfp.
[49:53]
>>vincente sarmiento: I'm
[49:53]
supportive of that. That's what
[49:54]
I wanted to get on the the
[49:56]
record make sure that that's
[49:57]
understood, giving my support
[50:00]
for this item. I'll go ahead
[50:02]
and move this item based on
[50:04]
attempt that from your team.
[50:06]
Thanks.
[50:06]
>>chair, doug chaffee: moved and
[50:08]
seconded. Was there an
[50:08]
abstention?
[50:09]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: yes.
[50:09]
>>chair, doug chaffee: noting
[50:13]
the abstention, the item is
[50:14]
approved, 4 votes. Item 11,
[50:18]
please.
[50:19]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 11.
[50:20]
Under health care agency,
[50:21]
approve amendment 2 to renew
[50:21]
contract ma-042-23011108 with
[50:23]
sdxray inc. For direct digital
[50:25]
radiology services for
[50:26]
correctional health services
[50:27]
programs, 7/1/26-6/30/28
[50:28]
($4,214,240; cumulative total
[50:28]
$10,535,600); and authorize
[50:29]
county procurement officer or
[50:30]
deputized designee to execute amendment.
[50:32]
We have no requests to speak on
[50:33]
agenda item 11.
[50:33]
>>chair, doug chaffee: it's a
[50:34]
district 2 and 3 item. Moved
[50:38]
and seconded. Any objection?
[50:39]
The item is approved. Item 12,
[50:41]
please.
[50:41]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 12.
[50:42]
Under health care agency,
[50:43]
approve amendment 2 to renew
[50:43]
contract ma-042-23011109 with
[50:44]
correctional managed care,
[50:45]
medical corporation, for
[50:47]
physician services for
[50:48]
correctional health services
[50:49]
programs, 7/1/26-6/30/28
[50:49]
($6,955,868; cumulative total
[50:50]
$16,410,125); and authorize
[50:51]
county procurement officer or
[50:52]
deputized designee to execute amendment.
[50:54]
We have no requests to speak on
[50:56]
agenda item 12.
[50:56]
>>chair, doug chaffee: it's a
[50:59]
district 2 and 3 item. Any
[51:02]
objection? Item is approved.
[51:04]
Item 13, please.
[51:05]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 13.
[51:06]
Under john wayne airport,
[51:07]
approve subordinate contract
[51:08]
ma-280-26010529 with siemens
[51:09]
industry, inc. For facility
[51:10]
security systems, equipment, and
[51:12]
software with related services,
[51:13]
4/23/26-2/18/29 ($2,800,000);
[51:14]
renewable for one additional
[51:14]
two-year term; authorize county
[51:16]
procurement officer or deputized
[51:17]
designee to execute contract;
[51:18]
and make californi environmental
[51:19]
quality act (Ceqa) Exemption
[51:19]
findings under ceqa guidelines
[51:21]
section 15378. We have no
[51:23]
requests to speak on agenda item
[51:24]
13.
[51:25]
>>chair, doug chaffee: item 13 a
[51:27]
district 5 item.
[51:28]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: move
[51:28]
the item.
[51:31]
>>chair, doug chaffee: any
[51:31]
objection? Motion carries.
[51:34]
Unanimously. Next item is 14.
[51:36]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 14.
[51:39]
Under oc community resources,
[51:40]
approve amendment 1 to contract
[51:41]
ma-012-25011237 with citiguard,
[51:42]
inc. For unarmed security guard
[51:43]
services at various county
[51:45]
library branch locations, 4/1/26
[51:45]
-3/31/30 ($2,050,000;
[51:46]
cumulative total $2,250,000);
[51:47]
and authorize county procurement
[51:47]
officer or deputized designee to
[51:50]
execute amendment and future
[51:53]
amendments under certain conditions.
[51:54]
Question have no requests to
[51:55]
speak on agenda item 14.
[51:57]
>>chair, doug chaffee: it's an
[51:57]
all-district item.
[51:58]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: move
[51:58]
the item.
[51:59]
>>chair, doug chaffee: any
[52:00]
objection? Item is approved.
[52:02]
Item 15, please.
[52:02]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 15.
[52:03]
Under oc community resources,
[52:05]
approve amendment 7 to contract
[52:06]
ma-012-23011443 with council on
[52:07]
aging-southern california,
[52:07]
inc. For senior health insurance
[52:09]
counseling and advocacy program
[52:11]
services, 4/1/26-3/31/27
[52:12]
($601,668; cumulative total
[52:12]
$1,808,627); and authorize
[52:13]
county procurement officer or
[52:14]
deputized designee to execute
[52:15]
amendment and future amendments
[52:15]
under certain conditions. We
[52:15]
have no requests to speak.
[52:15]
>>chair, doug chaffee: it's an
[52:23]
all-district item. Any
[52:23]
objection? Item is approved.
[52:26]
Item 16.
[52:30]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 16.
[52:31]
Under oc public works, adopt
[52:32]
resolution initiating 2026 weed
[52:35]
abatement program and setting
[52:36]
public hearing for 4/14/26, 9:30
[52:40]
A.M. To consider assessment to
[52:42]
private property for cost
[52:43]
removal of weeds by county or
[52:45]
contractor; and make california
[52:45]
environmental quality act (Ceqa)
[52:47]
Exemption findings under ceqa
[52:48]
guidelines section 15304. We
[52:50]
have no requests to speak on
[52:51]
agenda item 16.
[52:53]
>>chair, doug chaffee: it's an
[52:55]
all-district item. Moved and
[52:57]
seconded. Any objection?
[52:58]
Motion carries. Item 17, please
[52:59]
please.
[53:00]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 17.
[53:01]
Under oc public works, approve
[53:02]
aggregate contract
[53:04]
ma-080-26010053 with various
[53:04]
contractors for sanitation and
[53:06]
remediation removal &
[53:07]
decontamination services, 3/9/26
[53:08]
-3/8/29 (Aggregate total
[53:09]
$1,800,000); renewable for one
[53:09]
additional two-year term;
[53:10]
authorize county procurement
[53:11]
officer or deputized designee to
[53:13]
execute contract; and make
[53:13]
california environmental
[53:14]
quality act (Ceqa) Exemption
[53:15]
findings under ceqa guidelines
[53:16]
sections 15301 and 15308 we have
[53:20]
no if to speak on agenda item
[53:21]
17.
[53:22]
>>chair, doug chaffee: it's an
[53:22]
all-district item.
[53:24]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley:
[53:24]
second.
[53:25]
>>chair, doug chaffee: moved and
[53:26]
seconded, any objection? Motion
[53:27]
approved. I'd like now to move
[53:29]
to item 28.
[53:30]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 28.
[53:31]
Under county executive office-
[53:35]
acting as the orange county
[53:36]
board of supervisors and orange
[53:38]
county flood control district-
[53:39]
adopt 2026 contract policy
[53:42]
manual, effective 2/24/26
[53:45]
2/24/26; authorize county
[53:48]
executive officer or designee to
[53:48]
make changes under certain
[53:49]
conditions; and adopt amended
[53:51]
resolution authorizing director
[53:52]
of oc public works,
[53:55]
sheriff-coroner or designees to
[53:55]
advertise bids in accordance
[53:57]
with public contract code
[53:59]
sections 22037, 22032(C) And 20128.5.
[54:07]
We have no if to speak on agenda
[54:08]
item 28.
[54:08]
>>chair, doug chaffee: it's an
[54:09]
all-district item.
[54:12]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: move
[54:12]
the item.
[54:15]
>>janet nguyen: I have a
[54:15]
question, MR. CHAIRMAN
[54:15]
supervisor supervisor nguyen.
[54:17]
Go ahead.
[54:21]
>>janet nguyen: any staff here?
[54:24]
Maria, just, real quick, I
[54:27]
know -- first, thank you. You
[54:32]
did a phenomenal job in putting
[54:34]
all of our thoughts and comments
[54:37]
and questions from last week --
[54:38]
or two weeks ago now. My only
[54:40]
question is, I know that you've
[54:42]
mentioned this, but I wanted to
[54:43]
make sure that the -- under the
[54:47]
board's approval on the power
[54:48]
presentation, it says -- where
[54:51]
it describes the changes to rfp
[54:53]
and rfq comes to the board for
[54:54]
selection and then staff
[54:55]
negotiates the contract and then
[54:57]
comes back to the board for
[54:58]
final approval. But on the
[55:03]
package itself, I don't see the
[55:07]
rfp. I only see rfq. Am I
[55:11]
missing somewhere? I just want
[55:13]
to make sure that it is
[55:14]
consistent and that it's in the
[55:18]
manual.
[55:18]
>>speaker: good morning,
[55:19]
CHAIRMAN, vice-chair, members of
[55:21]
the board. Yes, the change
[55:26]
applies to all ASRs for
[55:28]
contract award.
[55:30]
>>janet nguyen: so rfp and --
[55:31]
>>speaker: any contracts coming
[55:32]
to the board. They will now
[55:34]
come one time for selection
[55:35]
earlier on in the process,
[55:38]
asking for authority to then
[55:40]
negotiate an award. But we will
[55:42]
be coming earlier in the
[55:43]
process.
[55:44]
>>janet nguyen: okay. So that's
[55:45]
not just an rfq for joc and a&e
[55:48]
contracts, but for all.
[55:51]
>>speaker: any contract coming
[55:52]
to the board for award.
[55:54]
>>janet nguyen: okay. Is it
[55:54]
somewhere here? Because I just
[55:56]
want to make sure that a year
[55:58]
from now when we're talking
[55:59]
about the manual, they're like,
[56:01]
we only did what the manual
[56:01]
says.
[56:03]
>>speaker: cpm is silent on that
[56:04]
procedural asr procedure. So
[56:08]
the change also be in the
[56:09]
procedures manual as well as the
[56:11]
asr guidance dewpoints. So cpm
[56:15]
is kind of silent on the process
[56:17]
to get board approval.
[56:18]
>>janet nguyen: why?
[56:19]
>>speaker: because we refer to
[56:21]
the asr guidance document and
[56:22]
our producers manual.
[56:24]
>>janet nguyen: when you have
[56:25]
that, can you send it up to us.
[56:26]
>>speaker: definitely.
[56:27]
>>janet nguyen: thank you.
[56:28]
>>chair, doug chaffee:
[56:29]
supervisor sarmiento.
[56:31]
>>vincente sarmiento: thank you,
[56:31]
MR. Chair, and thank you, marie
[56:33]
back for you and your team
[56:35]
making sure -- I think
[56:36]
everything that was discussed at
[56:37]
the last meeting was included.
[56:39]
Sounds like it was pretty
[56:39]
comprehensive. Just going back
[56:41]
to the question that supervisor
[56:44]
nguyen was asking, the one
[56:44]
change about having the items,
[56:47]
these contracts come to the
[56:48]
board first to give authority
[56:51]
for you and your team to
[56:54]
negotiate or for the contracts
[56:56]
to be negotiated, so we'll be
[56:57]
seeing these in advance of that.
[57:00]
Does it come back to us, or is
[57:02]
it pretty much once we give
[57:03]
authority for you to then
[57:04]
negotiate those contracts, are
[57:06]
you now delegated with that?
[57:09]
>>speaker: we will be asking for
[57:09]
that delegated authority.
[57:10]
However, the board has the
[57:12]
opportunity to ask us to come
[57:13]
back for an a -- back forward at
[57:15]
any gufn time.
[57:15]
>>vincente sarmiento: when you
[57:17]
bring back the results of, you
[57:20]
know, the rfp, rfq, it will come
[57:25]
with no staff recommendation.
[57:26]
It simply comes back with data?
[57:28]
>>speaker: he will come back
[57:29]
with the rank order of the
[57:30]
results of the evaluation.
[57:33]
>>vincente sarmiento: look, to
[57:34]
me -- and I understand, you
[57:36]
know, what we're doing. We want
[57:38]
to be more objective, maybe a
[57:39]
more open process for the board
[57:42]
to be able to make a decision.
[57:43]
I just want you to know, my
[57:45]
understanding of staff
[57:47]
recommending the way we have the
[57:49]
existing procedure now where
[57:51]
staff would come back and
[57:52]
recommend a vendor or vendors
[57:55]
based upon, you know, the
[57:57]
procurement process, I always
[57:58]
thought, was fair. That doesn't
[58:00]
mean that this board has to
[58:01]
follow staff's recommendation.
[58:03]
It could deviate for whatever
[58:04]
reason. We could just see
[58:06]
things a little differently.
[58:07]
But the guidance from an
[58:10]
unbiased, technical subject
[58:12]
matter, you know, a group of
[58:14]
people on panels, that are
[58:16]
taking a deeper dive on this has
[58:17]
always been instructive. Not
[58:20]
depositive, but, you know,
[58:20]
helpful. So, you know, I didn't
[58:24]
want that to be lost. But at
[58:26]
the same time I think maybe the
[58:30]
school board looking at having
[58:31]
an unvarnished, you know, no
[58:34]
preference from staff on this.
[58:38]
But I don't know if a hybrid
[58:41]
would be better where it comes
[58:42]
to us early and the staff gives
[58:44]
us their thoughts on, you know,
[58:47]
what they believe would be the
[58:50]
preferential vendor or the
[58:52]
vendor that, you know, seems to
[58:54]
be better suited, based on
[58:55]
costs, experience, business
[58:56]
plan, whatever criteria we have.
[58:58]
I just didn't want to dismiss
[59:00]
all our subject matter experts
[59:02]
that are able to, you know, take
[59:04]
a deeper dive than we would on
[59:06]
this. Again, just for guidance.
[59:08]
Not for any rubber stamping or
[59:12]
doing anything else. It's just
[59:13]
simply been helpful. So go
[59:17]
ahead, maria.
[59:17]
>>speaker: one suggestion is we
[59:19]
could put in the background
[59:20]
information of each asr based on
[59:23]
the information or evaluation --
[59:25]
or information contained the
[59:28]
staff -- we could provide some
[59:30]
sort of recommendation based on
[59:32]
the information collected
[59:33]
through the evaluation process.
[59:34]
>>vincente sarmiento: right.
[59:35]
And that doesn't mean that's
[59:36]
going, to again, determine where
[59:38]
this board is going to go. We
[59:39]
could certainly take that into
[59:40]
consideration or not and just
[59:42]
simply, you know, go in a
[59:43]
different direction. I do think
[59:44]
having staff give us some idea
[59:47]
and some sense of the rationale
[59:49]
of how we arrived at ranking and
[59:52]
how these different applicants
[59:55]
did, I think, is fair. So to
[59:58]
the extent that would be
[59:59]
something that could be included
[1:00:00]
in the process, again, that
[1:00:01]
would be helpful, I think, as --
[1:00:03]
you know, for the public as well
[1:00:05]
as for us.
[1:00:05]
>>speaker: there is procedural
[1:00:06]
language until background of
[1:00:08]
asr. We could put something in
[1:00:09]
there and draft it and extend to
[1:00:11]
the board's office for your
[1:00:12]
concurrence.
[1:00:15]
>>janet nguyen: MR. CHAIRMAN?
[1:00:16]
MAY I?
[1:00:17]
>>chair, doug chaffee:
[1:00:18]
supervisor foley is next.
[1:00:19]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank
[1:00:22]
you. Mine will be quick. I
[1:00:23]
just want to thank your team in
[1:00:26]
procurement as well as all of
[1:00:28]
the department procurement team
[1:00:30]
members for helping us get
[1:00:33]
through this process. It's my
[1:00:35]
understanding that you all took
[1:00:36]
another look, and the $3 million
[1:00:39]
was gonna be okay in terms of
[1:00:42]
efficiencies, and so I think
[1:00:45]
this contract policy manual
[1:00:47]
helps us to accomplish two
[1:00:48]
things. It keeps us efficient
[1:00:51]
in our progression and prevents
[1:00:54]
us from having any delays in our
[1:00:57]
projects, but also, you another
[1:00:59]
a little bit more oversight and
[1:01:01]
accountability by the board.
[1:01:04]
And I'm hoping that if at all
[1:01:07]
you think that it's starting to
[1:01:09]
bog down, that you will alert
[1:01:11]
us, because we have a lot of
[1:01:14]
projects underway. We don't
[1:01:16]
want to get bogged down. And so
[1:01:20]
please do alert us. Thank you.
[1:01:22]
>>chair, doug chaffee:
[1:01:22]
supervisor nguyen.
[1:01:23]
>>janet nguyen: thank you,
[1:01:24]
MR. CHAIRMAN. I want to follow
[1:01:26]
up on what supervisor sarmiento
[1:01:28]
mentioned. My understanding is
[1:01:30]
that staff would do your panel
[1:01:33]
interview and everything, and
[1:01:35]
then you would give us all that
[1:01:36]
data so we would know -- because
[1:01:38]
staff would usually take the
[1:01:40]
highest score. So we would know
[1:01:41]
that would be the selection of
[1:01:43]
staff, and then we would be up
[1:01:44]
here making that decision. And
[1:01:46]
the only reason is last year we
[1:01:48]
had so many of those came here
[1:01:49]
afterward, and staff was -- put
[1:01:53]
so much time in getting these
[1:01:55]
contracts and everything
[1:01:57]
negotiated, and then you had to
[1:01:58]
start over. And so that's why,
[1:02:02]
you know -- so it isn't that
[1:02:04]
we're just being handed, here,
[1:02:05]
have at it. You're going to
[1:02:07]
give us the data, the panel,
[1:02:08]
scoring, and all of that
[1:02:11]
information, and then we get to
[1:02:12]
make that -- we would then
[1:02:14]
deliberate and make that
[1:02:15]
decision.
[1:02:16]
>>speaker: correct.
[1:02:17]
>>janet nguyen: thank you.
[1:02:18]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank
[1:02:18]
you. I'd like to thank you for
[1:02:21]
the incredible line of work the
[1:02:22]
staff has put in. It's been a
[1:02:24]
long haul. And thank you for
[1:02:26]
helping us understand the
[1:02:27]
definition of "commodities" a
[1:02:29]
little better. It's more than
[1:02:32]
just gold and silver bars. And
[1:02:35]
with that, I think we have a
[1:02:37]
motion. Any objection? The
[1:02:41]
item is approved. Thank you for
[1:02:43]
your good work.
[1:02:44]
>>speaker: thank you.
[1:02:45]
>>chair, doug chaffee: and now
[1:02:45]
we come back to item 18.
[1:02:50]
18. Approve job order contracts
[1:02:51]
with various contractors for
[1:02:52]
general contracting services,
[1:02:53]
oneyear term ($5,000,000 each);
[1:02:53]
and authorize director or
[1:02:56]
designee to execute contracts.
[1:02:57]
And we have no requests to speak
[1:02:58]
on item 18.
[1:03:03]
>>chair, doug chaffee: it's an
[1:03:07]
all-district item. Supervisor
[1:03:07]
wagner.
[1:03:10]
>>don wagner: before we do that,
[1:03:11]
though, I think this is an item
[1:03:13]
that's $5 million per contract,
[1:03:16]
and we just talked about and
[1:03:19]
voted on $3 million. How is
[1:03:25]
this going to work? Kevin, can
[1:03:26]
you live with $3 million? Or do
[1:03:30]
you want to add some other
[1:03:31]
companies to make up the
[1:03:33]
difference, or how -- help me
[1:03:35]
square these two. I just didn't
[1:03:37]
want this to fly past us.
[1:03:40]
>>michelle aguirre: kevin,
[1:03:41]
before you respond, I think as
[1:03:45]
part the policy, right, the ends
[1:03:47]
something for most types of
[1:03:49]
contracts, most types of work,
[1:03:52]
the $3 million will suffice.
[1:03:54]
But there are some areas like
[1:03:56]
the one that you see before you,
[1:03:58]
the general contracting, where
[1:04:00]
at least for this upcoming year,
[1:04:02]
based on the number of projects,
[1:04:03]
the analysis that staff has
[1:04:05]
done, a higher amount is
[1:04:07]
warranted, and departments would
[1:04:11]
bring those requests based on
[1:04:13]
their analysis. You MAY
[1:04:15]
occasionally see something that
[1:04:16]
deviates from the $3 million,
[1:04:18]
about you has to be justified by
[1:04:20]
the department, and then that's
[1:04:21]
why we've got kevin here, to
[1:04:23]
explain a little bit more
[1:04:24]
related to the general
[1:04:25]
contracting.
[1:04:28]
>>speaker: CHAIRMAN Chaffee,
[1:04:29]
members of the board, kevin
[1:04:30]
aloom know, oc public works.
[1:04:32]
The reason why we're
[1:04:33]
recommending a higher dollar
[1:04:35]
amount is joc contracts are low
[1:04:38]
bid. If we went with the $3
[1:04:40]
million limit, we had 17
[1:04:43]
responsive bids, we'd be using
[1:04:46]
the contractors with the highest
[1:04:48]
prices, so we'd be paying more
[1:04:49]
for the work. That why we're
[1:04:51]
recommending fewer contracts at
[1:04:54]
a higher dollar amount so we can
[1:04:55]
keep it at more of the low
[1:04:57]
bidders.
[1:05:00]
>>don wagner: is that true of
[1:05:02]
all joc contracts?
[1:05:05]
>>speaker: well, the joc
[1:05:07]
contracts for general
[1:05:08]
contracting as michelle said
[1:05:10]
tend to be a larger dollar
[1:05:11]
amount. The other joc contracts
[1:05:13]
when it's specific to a trade,
[1:05:15]
plumbing and so on, the need for
[1:05:18]
those are the project size and
[1:05:20]
total dollar amounts tending to
[1:05:20]
smaller.
[1:05:22]
>>don wagner: so despite our
[1:05:23]
policy and putting the $3
[1:05:25]
million into the contract policy
[1:05:27]
manual you expect on general
[1:05:29]
contracting to keep coming back
[1:05:32]
to us for higher amounts? So we
[1:05:35]
should just be prepared for
[1:05:36]
that?
[1:05:37]
>>speaker: in general, yes. But
[1:05:38]
it depends on the capital
[1:05:40]
projects that are approved by
[1:05:41]
the board. If we have less,
[1:05:43]
maybe we can get by with the
[1:05:45]
smaller dollar amount.
[1:05:46]
>>don wagner: all right. Thank
[1:05:47]
you. I'll move the item.
[1:05:49]
>>chair, doug chaffee: if I MAY
[1:05:53]
comment, when we do the asr and
[1:05:56]
it exceeds the policy amount,
[1:05:59]
then we shrewed a paragraph in
[1:06:01]
there describing that and
[1:06:03]
justifying it, if we can have
[1:06:04]
that in the future ASRs,
[1:06:06]
that'd be helpful.
[1:06:07]
>>speaker: will do.
[1:06:08]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank
[1:06:08]
you. Supervisor sarmiento.
[1:06:11]
>>vincente sarmiento: and the
[1:06:11]
chair just kind of said exactly
[1:06:13]
weigh intended to say. Are we
[1:06:14]
calling this an exemption, an
[1:06:16]
exception, a justification?
[1:06:18]
What term of art are we going to
[1:06:19]
see in that additional
[1:06:20]
paragraph, just so we're clear
[1:06:22]
on the term? Maybe we should
[1:06:26]
and our county counsel, I'm not
[1:06:26]
sure if -- I've heard exemption,
[1:06:34]
i've heard exception.
[1:06:36]
>>speaker: we can develop that
[1:06:37]
language and alert the board.
[1:06:42]
>>vincente sarmiento: and I
[1:06:42]
appreciate the $3 million
[1:06:43]
because when I saw the data that
[1:06:45]
you sent our office, the bulk of
[1:06:47]
the contracts are $3 million and
[1:06:49]
below. So that's why we landed
[1:06:51]
on this amount. There are --
[1:06:52]
there obviously were other
[1:06:54]
contracts outside of that
[1:06:55]
amount, but the bell curve, I
[1:06:56]
guess if you look at it, was the
[1:06:59]
median washed $3 million and
[1:06:59]
below. I just want to make sure
[1:07:01]
we have our terms correct.
[1:07:03]
>>speaker: we will get that out
[1:07:03]
to you.
[1:07:04]
>>vincente sarmiento: thank
[1:07:04]
you.
[1:07:05]
>>chair, doug
[1:07:05]
thank you
[1:07:06]
vice-chair foley.
[1:07:07]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank
[1:07:07]
you. I'm not sure what we're
[1:07:14]
going to get because that was
[1:07:15]
the language we voted on. We
[1:07:17]
specifically added that sentence
[1:07:19]
that said for anything above $3
[1:07:21]
million we would come to the
[1:07:23]
board with a justification.
[1:07:25]
It's not an exemption. It's
[1:07:26]
just justification, for
[1:07:28]
exceeding the $3 million. So I
[1:07:31]
feel like we already have it in
[1:07:32]
there. If we're going to change
[1:07:34]
it, what do we need to change it
[1:07:36]
to? We've already said it.
[1:07:39]
>>vincente sarmiento: the only
[1:07:39]
reason why I mentioned it is
[1:07:40]
because I've heard exemption
[1:07:41]
from staff exceptions as well.
[1:07:43]
If we're not going to use
[1:07:46]
justification, I wanted to see
[1:07:46]
if there was any other language
[1:07:48]
besides that. But if it's
[1:07:50]
justification, then that's the
[1:07:52]
term.
[1:07:54]
>>michelle aguirre: departments
[1:07:55]
will be required, right, to
[1:07:57]
justify it within the background
[1:08:00]
exception of the asr. But what
[1:08:02]
the asr document does is provide
[1:08:05]
standard like template language
[1:08:07]
so that when you see, that we
[1:08:08]
have consistent language across
[1:08:10]
all ASRs for all departments
[1:08:12]
that kind of lead up to that
[1:08:13]
justification. So that's what
[1:08:15]
maria was referring to. We can
[1:08:16]
provide that standard language.
[1:08:17]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: so it
[1:08:19]
will say "justification" and
[1:08:21]
then whatever it is.
[1:08:22]
>>michelle aguirre: exactly.
[1:08:23]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: okay.
[1:08:23]
Thank you.
[1:08:24]
>>chair, doug chaffee:
[1:08:25]
supervisor nguyen.
[1:08:26]
>>janet nguyen: thank you,
[1:08:27]
MR. CHAIRMAN. So kevin...
[1:08:30]
What are these projects? What's
[1:08:34]
the $5 million each company --
[1:08:36]
what are they doing?
[1:08:39]
>>speaker: the projects are
[1:08:40]
listed in attachment m. So
[1:08:43]
they're the projects that have
[1:08:44]
been approved by the board as a
[1:08:46]
product of capital improvement
[1:08:49]
projects with the budget or with
[1:08:50]
the sfp. It includes projects
[1:08:53]
for fy25/26 and also projects
[1:08:59]
that were included in the sfp
[1:09:02]
for fy '26/27 and on.
[1:09:05]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley:
[1:09:11]
libraries, public parks, --
[1:09:13]
public works, the gas
[1:09:16]
compressors, probation, juvenile
[1:09:18]
hall, sprinkler system, it's on
[1:09:22]
page 18 of the staff report.
[1:09:26]
Orangewood children family
[1:09:28]
center rehab, the manchester
[1:09:31]
office building, several
[1:09:32]
different ada and fire panel
[1:09:34]
upgrades. A lot of parks,
[1:09:40]
libraries, town valley library
[1:09:42]
roof, hvac, westminster roof
[1:09:45]
hvac, interior refresh for the
[1:09:47]
library..
[1:09:54]
>>janet nguyen: thank you. And
[1:09:55]
I think what would be helpful,
[1:09:57]
kevin, is maybe this page should
[1:10:00]
be part of it, asr, so we see
[1:10:04]
right away what these projects
[1:10:06]
are or what you're working on
[1:10:08]
versus having it in the back.
[1:10:11]
Because I think -- you know, I
[1:10:13]
want to also make sure that the
[1:10:13]
public knows that we are giving
[1:10:16]
you the $5 million outside the
[1:10:18]
manual. I mean, basically it's
[1:10:19]
your justification.
[1:10:22]
>>speaker: so put in the body of
[1:10:22]
the asr instead of the
[1:10:23]
attachment.
[1:10:25]
>>janet nguyen: yes, thank you.
[1:10:26]
>>speaker: okay.
[1:10:27]
>>chair, doug chaffee: all
[1:10:31]
right. We have a motion. Any
[1:10:32]
objection? Item is approved.
[1:10:35]
Thank you. Item 19, please.
[1:10:38]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 19.
[1:10:41]
Under oc public works, consider
[1:10:42]
second reading and adoption of
[1:10:44]
"an ordinance of the county of
[1:10:45]
orange, state of california,
[1:10:47]
amending sections 3-14-2 through
[1:10:52]
3-14-16, 5-1-31, 5-1-33 and
[1:10:59]
7-9-103 of the codified
[1:11:00]
ordinances of the county of
[1:11:01]
orange"; and adopt resolution
[1:11:02]
adopting zoning code amendment
[1:11:06]
ca 25-02 (County of orange
[1:11:07]
commercial cannabis activities
[1:11:09]
and outdoor personal cultivation
[1:11:11]
prohibition ordinance). Woe have
[1:11:14]
no requests to speak on agenda
[1:11:15]
item 19.
[1:11:17]
>>chair, doug chaffee: it's an
[1:11:17]
all-district item.
[1:11:18]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: move
[1:11:18]
the item.
[1:11:20]
>>chair, doug chaffee: all
[1:11:21]
right. This is an interesting
[1:11:22]
item in that we catch property
[1:11:24]
owners who are profiting well
[1:11:28]
illegal cannabis trade. I think
[1:11:30]
it's a good ordinance. Any
[1:11:32]
objection? Motion carries.
[1:11:34]
thank you. Item 20 please.
[1:11:36]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 20.
[1:11:38]
Under oc waster & recycling,
[1:11:41]
approve amendment 1 to renew
[1:11:41]
contract ma-299-22011684 with
[1:11:42]
stearns, conrad and schmidt,
[1:11:44]
consulting engineers dba scs
[1:11:47]
field services for landfill gas
[1:11:49]
services, central region,
[1:11:49]
4/10/26-4/9/28 ($11,000,000;
[1:11:50]
cumulative total $27,500,000);
[1:11:51]
authorize county procurement
[1:11:51]
officer or deputized designee to
[1:11:53]
make minor changes under certain
[1:11:54]
conditions and execute
[1:11:55]
amendment; and make california
[1:11:56]
environmental quality act (Ceqa)
[1:11:57]
Exemption findings under ceqa
[1:11:58]
guidelines sections 15301,
[1:12:01]
15304, and 15308. We have no
[1:12:04]
requests to speak on agenda item
[1:12:05]
20.
[1:12:06]
>>chair, doug chaffee: this is a
[1:12:07]
district 2, 3, and 5 item.
[1:12:08]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley:
[1:12:08]
second.
[1:12:10]
>>chair, doug chaffee: moved and
[1:12:11]
seconded. Any objection? Item
[1:12:12]
is approved. Item 21, please.
[1:12:13]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 21.
[1:12:14]
Under oc waste & recycling,
[1:12:16]
adopt county of orange climate
[1:12:17]
action planning document; direct
[1:12:19]
staff to begin implementation
[1:12:21]
phase and analysis; and make
[1:12:22]
california environmental quality
[1:12:23]
act (Ceqa) Exemption findings
[1:12:24]
under ceqa guidelines section
[1:12:25]
15262 and public resources code
[1:12:29]
sections 21083 and 21150. And
[1:12:33]
MR. Chair, we very received
[1:12:34]
three requests to speak on
[1:12:36]
agenda item 21.
[1:12:37]
>>chair, doug chaffee: please
[1:12:37]
call the speakers.
[1:12:39]
>>clerk, robin stieler: paulina
[1:12:39]
alvarez, anna gromas, and jeff
[1:12:44]
weaver.
[1:12:51]
>>speaker: good morning, chair
[1:12:57]
chaffee and members of the
[1:12:57]
board. My name is paulina
[1:12:58]
alvarez, and I'm the government
[1:12:59]
affairs manager for the orange
[1:13:01]
county business council. We
[1:13:03]
support thoughtful,
[1:13:05]
cost-effective, and achievable
[1:13:06]
climate policies and appreciates
[1:13:09]
the county's efforts to address
[1:13:11]
greenhouse gas emissions and
[1:13:13]
sustainability. Our concern is
[1:13:15]
chapter 4 community climate
[1:13:17]
action introduces measures that
[1:13:19]
could create uncertainty and
[1:13:20]
unintended consequences for
[1:13:23]
house production, economic
[1:13:24]
development and private
[1:13:26]
investment in un-incorporated
[1:13:28]
areas. Measure cm2 reduce
[1:13:30]
vehicles miles travels vmt
[1:13:33]
encourages reduction of vmt
[1:13:35]
through public outreach and
[1:13:37]
incentives. Our concern is vmt
[1:13:39]
is already regulated under state
[1:13:41]
law including sb-743 and ceqa.
[1:13:44]
Additional local measures could
[1:13:45]
duplicate standards and increase
[1:13:47]
entitlement uncertainty and ce1
[1:13:51]
promotes building
[1:13:54]
decarbonization. The concern is
[1:14:00]
it could raise construction
[1:14:02]
costs, constrain housing supply
[1:14:04]
and complicate private
[1:14:05]
development particularly amid
[1:14:07]
california's housing
[1:14:08]
affordability crisis.
[1:14:10]
Incorporating the cap into the
[1:14:11]
general plan could
[1:14:13]
unintentionally turn
[1:14:14]
aspirational goals into binding
[1:14:16]
land use standards raising
[1:14:18]
secret disputes and feasibility
[1:14:19]
challenges. Ocbc recommends the
[1:14:22]
following, remove chapter 4
[1:14:24]
community climate action from
[1:14:26]
phase 2, avoid incorporating
[1:14:28]
community cap measures into the
[1:14:30]
general plan in a way that
[1:14:31]
affects private development, and
[1:14:33]
focus the cap on county
[1:14:34]
operations and facilities to
[1:14:36]
ensure clarity and legal
[1:14:38]
defensibility and
[1:14:39]
economic competitiveness. Ocbc
[1:14:42]
remains committed to
[1:14:43]
collaborating with the county on
[1:14:44]
climate strategies that are
[1:14:46]
effective, achievable and
[1:14:47]
supportive of orange county's
[1:14:49]
economy. Thank you for your
[1:14:50]
time.
[1:14:53]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank
[1:14:55]
you.
[1:14:58]
>>speaker: good morning, chair
[1:14:59]
chaffee and supervisors. Anna
[1:15:00]
gromas here representing the
[1:15:02]
building industry association in
[1:15:03]
the orange county chapter. The
[1:15:06]
first outline was OCTOBER of
[1:15:09]
2025 and the second one being in
[1:15:12]
JANUARY of 2026, we still have
[1:15:14]
concerns with the cap as it is
[1:15:16]
written in chapter 4 is still
[1:15:17]
problematic to us. There's a
[1:15:19]
lot of combyity that surrounds
[1:15:20]
the language on decarbon sayings
[1:15:26]
and vmt. We kindly ask that
[1:15:26]
that section be omitted from the
[1:15:28]
cap. In addition in the
[1:15:29]
JANUARY 2026 draft comprehensive
[1:15:32]
general plan update that is
[1:15:33]
currently out for public review,
[1:15:35]
implementation of the cap was
[1:15:37]
listed as an action item under
[1:15:38]
the resource management elements
[1:15:40]
section. The building industry
[1:15:42]
is justifiably concerned that
[1:15:43]
incorporating the climate action
[1:15:45]
plan into the general plan will
[1:15:47]
unintentionally turn advisory
[1:15:49]
climate objectives into binding
[1:15:51]
land use mandates. When goals
[1:15:53]
are elevated into the general
[1:15:54]
plan, they assume the same legal
[1:15:56]
bhait weight as other general
[1:15:57]
plan policies. That the county
[1:16:00]
must use when conditioning,
[1:16:02]
approving or denying development
[1:16:05]
complications. If the cap is
[1:16:05]
incorporated into the --
[1:16:06]
development applications. If
[1:16:07]
the cap is incorporated, there's
[1:16:08]
a significant risk that the
[1:16:10]
broad, long-term community
[1:16:11]
greenhouse gas reduction goals
[1:16:13]
could be applied rigidly to
[1:16:14]
individual projects without
[1:16:16]
consideration or proportionality
[1:16:18]
or feasibility. It would switch
[1:16:21]
the cap from a planning guide
[1:16:22]
into a binding standard of
[1:16:24]
review. Developers could be
[1:16:26]
required to prove that their
[1:16:27]
projects meet community wide
[1:16:29]
goals. This creates entitlement
[1:16:35]
risks and the potential for ceqa
[1:16:36]
disputes over targets that were
[1:16:37]
originally meant to be
[1:16:38]
aspirational and not mandatory.
[1:16:41]
From the beginning the county
[1:16:43]
indicated that the cap would not
[1:16:44]
be applied to private
[1:16:45]
development and un-incorporated
[1:16:47]
areas. The cap goals should
[1:16:49]
remove references to private
[1:16:50]
development, should not be
[1:16:51]
incorporated into the general
[1:16:53]
plan as doing so could turn
[1:16:55]
community-wide aspirations into
[1:16:57]
inflexible and enforceable
[1:16:59]
mandates on individual prisons.
[1:17:01]
We thank you for your time and
[1:17:02]
consideration, and we look
[1:17:03]
forward to continuing our work
[1:17:05]
with the county on this
[1:17:06]
mattered.
[1:17:07]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank
[1:17:07]
you. Next speaker, please.
[1:17:12]
>>speaker: good afternoon,
[1:17:12]
board. I'm jeff weaver from san
[1:17:14]
juan capistrano, the home of the
[1:17:16]
prima desay sha landfill
[1:17:19]
problem. We talked last time
[1:17:21]
about the massive amount of
[1:17:23]
toxic gas that comes out of each
[1:17:27]
landfill. The prima landfill is
[1:17:35]
located about a mile from san
[1:17:37]
juan hills high school. At the
[1:17:39]
current status before the
[1:17:40]
expansion -- and I'd like to get
[1:17:42]
some definition. Expansion, we
[1:17:44]
talked last time -- or you
[1:17:45]
talked to tom petition troll
[1:17:47]
liss last time about expansion.
[1:17:49]
I think we spent $100 million on
[1:17:51]
to so-called expansion. This is
[1:17:52]
it. This is what they're
[1:17:54]
tearing apart right now. You
[1:17:56]
see this from miles away. The
[1:18:00]
problem is it's one mile from
[1:18:01]
our high school. And the high
[1:18:02]
school kids have no choice but
[1:18:03]
to breathe this toxic gas. Oc
[1:18:07]
waste and recycling and its
[1:18:08]
climate action plan calls it
[1:18:10]
odor. Well, the way they
[1:18:12]
control the odor, they drive
[1:18:13]
around and sniff and spray
[1:18:16]
febreze type stuff to decrease
[1:18:18]
the odor. And doesn't mean
[1:18:20]
you're not smelling it. But if
[1:18:22]
you're smelling it, it's really
[1:18:23]
bad. And these kids are out
[1:18:25]
there on the track team or the
[1:18:27]
football team, running as hard
[1:18:28]
as they can, they don't know
[1:18:29]
that they're breathing these
[1:18:30]
toxic fumes that are
[1:18:32]
consistently over 1 million
[1:18:35]
cubic feet per day that gets
[1:18:37]
released, uncontrolled release
[1:18:38]
from this landfill. So that's
[1:18:42]
our big concern. And in the
[1:18:43]
climate action plan they mandate
[1:18:45]
aggressive methane management.
[1:18:50]
And all I see in the climate
[1:18:52]
action plan are drones. $25
[1:18:53]
million for drones. They have a
[1:18:55]
thing that says "drones are
[1:18:56]
tackling methane gas." I
[1:18:59]
watched the super bowl. I saw a
[1:19:00]
lot of tackling. I don't know
[1:19:01]
how it's even possible for a
[1:19:03]
drone to tackle an invisible
[1:19:05]
gas. But I like the definition
[1:19:08]
on how the drone tackles the
[1:19:09]
gas. I'd like the definition on
[1:19:12]
how older is a toxic gas and the
[1:19:14]
expansion. Is that an
[1:19:15]
expansion? It looks like an
[1:19:16]
expansion, and there's been over
[1:19:18]
$100 million on this expansion.
[1:19:20]
This be landfill will be in
[1:19:21]
operation for 75 years. It's
[1:19:23]
going to be producing this
[1:19:24]
methane for over 100 years. But
[1:19:26]
the problem is, this methane is
[1:19:28]
fuel. If we tap this methane,
[1:19:30]
our plan is to cap this
[1:19:31]
landfill, tap the landfill and
[1:19:34]
produce 20 megawatts of energy
[1:19:36]
that will power the desal plant
[1:19:38]
and the entire city of san juan
[1:19:39]
capistrano for the next 100
[1:19:41]
years. We want to put an
[1:19:43]
amendment that you at least look
[1:19:44]
at our plan. I've talked to two
[1:19:46]
of the staff of the board
[1:19:48]
members here -- or the
[1:19:49]
supervisors. I've been waiting
[1:19:51]
to talk to katrina foley for
[1:19:53]
almost two years now, and I met
[1:19:55]
with alyssa. I was supposed to
[1:19:57]
have a meeting with her. I've
[1:19:58]
been waiting two years. But
[1:19:59]
until the climate action plan
[1:20:01]
came out and environmental
[1:20:02]
impact report came out just last
[1:20:05]
month, we didn't have a whole
[1:20:06]
lot of data to go on. The funny
[1:20:07]
thing is the data they're study
[1:20:09]
something from 2018 on the gas
[1:20:11]
that's released from these
[1:20:12]
landfills. 2018. That's the
[1:20:14]
current data. I'm sorry -- I'm
[1:20:16]
running a little long.
[1:20:17]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank
[1:20:17]
you, sir.
[1:20:17]
>>speaker: please someone talk
[1:20:19]
to us about this. We have a
[1:20:20]
plan, we have engineers.
[1:20:22]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank
[1:20:22]
you, sir.
[1:20:23]
>>speaker: we can have our own
[1:20:23]
financing and won't cost a dime
[1:20:25]
and we can save the kids from
[1:20:29]
the poisonous gas at san juan
[1:20:29]
hills high school. Please help
[1:20:30]
us.
[1:20:31]
>>chair, doug chaffee:
[1:20:33]
supervisor wagner.
[1:20:36]
>>don wagner: real quick, we're
[1:20:40]
all at the octa board yesterday.
[1:20:42]
We had been in discussion about
[1:20:45]
one of these climate action
[1:20:46]
plans or a plan that carbon come
[1:20:49]
up with the ict, how it's
[1:20:51]
failing. A newspaper article
[1:20:54]
over the weekend, I want to say
[1:20:56]
wall street journal, it MAY have
[1:20:58]
been somewhere else. It
[1:21:00]
explained that the world has
[1:21:03]
spent $16 trillion with a "t" --
[1:21:06]
trillion dollars on climate
[1:21:08]
action plans this and climate
[1:21:11]
environmental worries that and
[1:21:13]
climate the other thing. And
[1:21:15]
we're still spending that money,
[1:21:16]
and we aren't really achieving
[1:21:18]
anything close to what is
[1:21:20]
promised. With we are also not
[1:21:22]
seeing the ice melt in the artic
[1:21:26]
and the polar bears drowning
[1:21:28]
that al gore worried about in
[1:21:31]
the '90s when he said we only
[1:21:32]
have about 10 more years to fix
[1:21:34]
this problem. Anyway, it's a
[1:21:35]
long way of saying we've wasted
[1:21:36]
an enormous amount of time on
[1:21:37]
this. That said, as a realist
[1:21:42]
and being in california, I
[1:21:44]
recognize we need to have a
[1:21:46]
climate action plan in order to
[1:21:48]
get the funding that is
[1:21:50]
absolutely critical to this
[1:21:53]
government doing the basic
[1:21:56]
function it is needs to do. We
[1:21:57]
will not be eligible for grants
[1:21:59]
without it. And so I am not
[1:22:02]
prepared to vote against the
[1:22:04]
entire climate action plan.
[1:22:06]
Though, I believe it is a
[1:22:07]
grotesque waste of money, it is
[1:22:09]
the game the state forces us to
[1:22:11]
play. That said, I think
[1:22:14]
there's a lot to recommend the
[1:22:17]
views of our business champions
[1:22:20]
who are here, who recognize that
[1:22:24]
business and people being able
[1:22:28]
to do business for themselves
[1:22:30]
means the government needs to do
[1:22:32]
less. We can be smaller and be
[1:22:34]
more responsive. And that said,
[1:22:37]
that is a long way of saying we
[1:22:40]
ought to take them at their
[1:22:41]
word, we ought to do the minimum
[1:22:43]
that we need to do to play the
[1:22:45]
game the state forces us to
[1:22:47]
play, and with that, I move
[1:22:50]
approval the climate action plan
[1:22:53]
with the complete removal of
[1:22:55]
chapter 4, community climate
[1:22:57]
action. That's my motion.
[1:22:58]
>>chair, doug chaffee:
[1:23:03]
supervisor nguyen.
[1:23:05]
>>janet nguyen: sorry. And I'll
[1:23:07]
second that. I agree. I mean,
[1:23:10]
we do -- I've been in
[1:23:12]
sacramento. I've heard all of
[1:23:15]
these arguments. I've been in
[1:23:16]
many, many hearings as well,
[1:23:18]
and, you know, I continue to ask
[1:23:20]
the question what has the
[1:23:22]
results been for us in
[1:23:24]
sacramento? And there's never
[1:23:26]
been an answer. The answer has
[1:23:28]
always been, well, we just gotta
[1:23:29]
set a very high bar and
[1:23:33]
hopefully we'll get there
[1:23:34]
eventually. So, I mean, but,
[1:23:37]
you know, in the end, we all
[1:23:39]
here want -- as a county, want
[1:23:41]
to reduce green house gas
[1:23:42]
emission. But the goals we
[1:23:46]
pursue needs to be in a way that
[1:23:48]
also preserves the economic
[1:23:49]
competitiveness, supports job
[1:23:51]
creation and also avoids any new
[1:23:53]
regulatory uncertainty. And so,
[1:23:56]
you know, as drafted, the
[1:23:59]
community section raise
[1:24:03]
significant concerns because it
[1:24:05]
focuses on an area where the
[1:24:06]
county has limited jurisdiction,
[1:24:08]
including private vehicles,
[1:24:11]
privately-owned buildings and
[1:24:11]
land use decisions overseen by
[1:24:13]
other agency. And I know that
[1:24:16]
it says volunteer and
[1:24:18]
non-bind -- voluntary and
[1:24:21]
non-binding, however, the
[1:24:22]
section establishes countywide
[1:24:24]
goals without clear
[1:24:26]
implementation parameters
[1:24:27]
creating risk of interpretation
[1:24:29]
beyond existing state law. And
[1:24:33]
so this action plan is intended
[1:24:36]
to outline aspirational goals,
[1:24:40]
not just create mandates. So
[1:24:42]
I'm concerned about that line
[1:24:44]
that's becoming very blurry.
[1:24:46]
And so, you know, is especially
[1:24:47]
if there's a lack of clarity, we
[1:24:51]
need -- I mean, what will end up
[1:24:53]
is that it will be duplicate, it
[1:24:55]
will be inconsistent went
[1:24:56]
requirements, increase
[1:24:57]
developmental costs, add
[1:24:59]
uncertainties for businesses and
[1:25:01]
housing providers in our
[1:25:03]
incorporated areas at a time
[1:25:05]
when we need housing to be
[1:25:06]
affordable in orange county.
[1:25:08]
And the cost of living is
[1:25:10]
unbearable. At this point for
[1:25:13]
anybody who lives in orange
[1:25:15]
county and so we as a county,
[1:25:18]
when we set our policy, when
[1:25:20]
it's countywide, yes we're
[1:25:23]
saying incorporate, but we're
[1:25:25]
also saying wink-wink,
[1:25:28]
countrywide, meaning cities and
[1:25:29]
everybody else also have to
[1:25:31]
adhere to our mandate,
[1:25:39]
countywide. So again, we can't
[1:25:41]
have duplicate, you know, areas
[1:25:44]
and unintended consequence asks
[1:25:48]
not really understanding
[1:25:49]
where -- what is mandate, what
[1:25:51]
is volunteer, as well.
[1:25:52]
>>chair, doug chaffee:
[1:25:54]
vice-chair foley.
[1:25:55]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank
[1:25:56]
you, MR. CHAIRMAN.
[1:26:01]
You know, I'm not really seeing
[1:26:03]
these sections that have been
[1:26:04]
referred to in the climate
[1:26:06]
action plan itself. So there's
[1:26:08]
nothing in the climate action
[1:26:10]
plan that mandates anything on
[1:26:11]
any private developer. We had
[1:26:15]
representatives from the bi a
[1:26:16]
and the business council on our
[1:26:19]
task force. We've talked to
[1:26:21]
them multiple times about this,
[1:26:23]
and there's no mandates included
[1:26:26]
in this climate action plan.
[1:26:29]
And then respectfully we cannot
[1:26:33]
remove this section that they're
[1:26:35]
referring to because we will not
[1:26:37]
qualify for any grants. So
[1:26:40]
that's the critical component
[1:26:42]
here. And if for no other
[1:26:45]
reason the roadmap that has been
[1:26:48]
created here is to conserve
[1:26:51]
costs for the taxpayers, if for
[1:26:54]
know other reason, even if you
[1:26:55]
don't believe climate change is
[1:26:57]
real, the measures, the roadmap,
[1:27:02]
the landfill analysis is all
[1:27:06]
intended to reduce cost and so
[1:27:08]
make us competitive for grants.
[1:27:10]
So I will not be supporting the
[1:27:12]
motion.
[1:27:14]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank
[1:27:15]
you. Supervisor wagner.
[1:27:17]
>>don wagner: I want to respond
[1:27:17]
a little bit. The fact that bi
[1:27:23]
a and/or ocbc and/or any other
[1:27:23]
business groups were in the
[1:27:26]
discussions and at the table and
[1:27:28]
on the panels and involved here
[1:27:29]
doesn't mean that they were
[1:27:32]
listened to. And the resulting
[1:27:34]
document and their positions on
[1:27:37]
it suggest that they weren't
[1:27:39]
listened to. And I think we do
[1:27:42]
a disservice to -- not just to
[1:27:44]
those organizations but to the
[1:27:46]
vast business community in
[1:27:48]
orange county, that is so
[1:27:51]
important to us, that has been
[1:27:53]
so burdened by just trying to
[1:27:56]
exist in this state, that the
[1:27:59]
unaffordability issue supervisor
[1:28:02]
nguyen raised has come to the
[1:28:03]
forefront for so many people.
[1:28:05]
We aren't doing any favors to
[1:28:07]
everyone who is struggling with
[1:28:09]
unaffordability by rushing pell
[1:28:13]
mel into this and ignoring.
[1:28:14]
witness the leerings they sent
[1:28:17]
to us. They were at the table,
[1:28:19]
but they got ignored and felt
[1:28:21]
the need to do these letters.
[1:28:23]
And that's why, slow it down,
[1:28:26]
we'll still get the grants.
[1:28:27]
We've got what we need to do,
[1:28:30]
the bare minimum in what
[1:28:32]
survives my motion, the climate
[1:28:35]
action plan, just not this
[1:28:39]
unthought-through potentially
[1:28:40]
quite damaging section 4. I
[1:28:42]
urge support for the motion.
[1:28:44]
>>chair, doug chaffee:
[1:28:45]
supervisor sarmiento.
[1:28:46]
>>vincente sarmiento: thank you,
[1:28:46]
MR. Chair. I see somebody from
[1:28:49]
waste and recycling. Is it tara
[1:28:50]
that's here? If you could come
[1:28:53]
up if you don't mind. And as
[1:28:56]
you're coming up, if you could
[1:28:57]
answer sort of the question
[1:29:01]
buffers, which is what would it
[1:29:02]
do -- what would the impact be
[1:29:04]
from removing this section from
[1:29:06]
the climate action plan.
[1:29:08]
>>speaker: good morning. I'm
[1:29:09]
tara, deputy director of
[1:29:11]
sustainability. What would it
[1:29:14]
do, to answer your question,
[1:29:17]
obviously we brought what we
[1:29:18]
thought was, you know, finished
[1:29:20]
product. I will say just to
[1:29:22]
answer some of the comments that
[1:29:24]
were raised, this is not being
[1:29:26]
included in the general plan.
[1:29:27]
There are no plans to put it in
[1:29:29]
the general plan at all. Any
[1:29:31]
document that's out on the
[1:29:33]
general plan right now through
[1:29:34]
public works I would encourage
[1:29:36]
them to comment on that, as
[1:29:38]
well, if there is a reference to
[1:29:39]
the cap. Beyond that, the part
[1:29:43]
that I would probably be worried
[1:29:44]
about losing is the references
[1:29:46]
to environmental justice. We
[1:29:48]
have a lot of mandates related
[1:29:50]
to environmental justice. I'm
[1:29:52]
so sorry. And with that said,
[1:29:56]
when we go back to tie the cap
[1:29:57]
into the ej sections, which you
[1:30:00]
know most of the prop 4, 40% of
[1:30:03]
that funding is going to ej
[1:30:04]
communities, and they literally
[1:30:06]
ask if you can tie it back into
[1:30:08]
an approved plan or motion. I'm
[1:30:10]
not saying this guarantees us
[1:30:12]
the money, but if it gives us a
[1:30:13]
leg up, I would obviously love
[1:30:16]
to keep it. With that said,
[1:30:18]
it's at your discretion.
[1:30:21]
>>vincente sarmiento: so I guess
[1:30:22]
the -- sort of the essence of
[1:30:26]
your response is that, keeping
[1:30:28]
it in will help for future
[1:30:30]
funding of projects that --
[1:30:33]
>>speaker: I'm trying to just
[1:30:34]
gives any leg up that we can
[1:30:35]
get, and if there's an ab-39
[1:30:38]
mandate that will also include
[1:30:39]
environmental justice, that I'm
[1:30:40]
hoping that when we bring this
[1:30:42]
back with the ceqa document we
[1:30:44]
will actually cover that report
[1:30:46]
that's due. I completely agree,
[1:30:48]
there are more mandates and laws
[1:30:50]
than we can keep track of at
[1:30:51]
this point. So the more we
[1:30:52]
could try to cover, like we put
[1:30:54]
the climate vulnerability
[1:30:55]
assessment in to try to cover
[1:30:57]
that state mandate. We are
[1:30:59]
trying to make this as
[1:31:00]
cost-effective as we can.
[1:31:02]
>>vincente sarmiento: is there a
[1:31:03]
net benefit from keeping this
[1:31:04]
section in for future funding.
[1:31:07]
>>speaker: I believe so.
[1:31:09]
>>vincente sarmiento: thank you.
[1:31:09]
>>chair, doug chaffee:
[1:31:09]
supervisor nguyen.
[1:31:10]
>>janet nguyen: thank you.
[1:31:14]
Tara, can I just foul? -- follow
[1:31:15]
up? So it's not -- it's certain
[1:31:21]
that we would not get any
[1:31:22]
funding.
[1:31:22]
>>speaker: no. No.
[1:31:24]
>>janet nguyen: because that's
[1:31:24]
what was stated up here. I
[1:31:26]
wanted to make sure that we're
[1:31:29]
hearing there's a possibility,
[1:31:30]
right. But that's a possibility
[1:31:31]
all of our grants and every time
[1:31:33]
we apply for any grants through
[1:31:37]
the state or the federal, that
[1:31:39]
we -- it's competitive and it's,
[1:31:41]
you know, it can and cannot --
[1:31:44]
we might or might not get it.
[1:31:46]
>>speaker: correct. There's no
[1:31:47]
guarantee. I think what we're
[1:31:49]
trying to do is be as
[1:31:50]
cost-effective as we could. But
[1:31:52]
if it has to cover ab-39 and has
[1:31:54]
to be a component of the general
[1:31:56]
plan and we could supply ands
[1:31:58]
dies and pull out of this
[1:31:59]
document -- slice and dice just
[1:32:00]
to pull out of this document to
[1:32:00]
save money on reports down the
[1:32:02]
road, that is also something we
[1:32:05]
would be trying to do. We were
[1:32:10]
not trying to mandate anything
[1:32:12]
on the community side. We
[1:32:15]
worked with bi a quite a bit,
[1:32:16]
with adam at the time. We
[1:32:19]
really just didn't want to be
[1:32:22]
preclueded from having to do
[1:32:22]
things like outreach, the mobile
[1:32:24]
home parks, projects of that
[1:32:26]
nature if an opportunity
[1:32:28]
presented itself. We're not
[1:32:30]
trying to mandate what type of
[1:32:32]
boiler, heater. And the nice
[1:32:35]
part is we do have to bring this
[1:32:36]
back to you with a ceqa document
[1:32:39]
if it's approved today so there
[1:32:40]
will be time to make adjustments
[1:32:43]
that nature, if you think that
[1:32:44]
the language implies, that I do
[1:32:47]
want to correct that.
[1:32:48]
>>janet nguyen: I just think it
[1:32:50]
makes everybody nervous when
[1:32:52]
you're not sure what is
[1:32:54]
mandated, what isn't. I mean, a
[1:32:56]
lot of times when government
[1:32:57]
says it's not mandated, but...
[1:33:00]
It is on here, and wink-wink, we
[1:33:04]
would really like to you follow
[1:33:06]
it. That's what makes everybody
[1:33:07]
nervous.
[1:33:08]
>>speaker: I agree with their
[1:33:09]
concerns on the general plan,
[1:33:10]
and the nice part of being one
[1:33:11]
of the last counties out of the
[1:33:13]
gate is that you get to see what
[1:33:14]
happened in other jurisdictions.
[1:33:16]
And san diego county, I know
[1:33:18]
and L.A. County, did have
[1:33:19]
litigation because it was part
[1:33:21]
of their general plan, which is
[1:33:23]
why I really hope that the board
[1:33:26]
does not put it in the general
[1:33:27]
plan and avoid that. And I
[1:33:29]
think that's where the concerns
[1:33:30]
are coming from, from bia. I
[1:33:33]
don't want to speak for them,
[1:33:34]
but I do not want to put it in
[1:33:36]
the general plan unless you feel
[1:33:37]
otherwise.
[1:33:39]
>>janet nguyen: and I don't want
[1:33:40]
to do anything L.A. Does.
[1:33:42]
>>speaker: I agree, but we're on
[1:33:45]
the record.
[1:33:45]
>>janet nguyen: thank you.
[1:33:46]
>>chair, doug chaffee:
[1:33:53]
supervisor wagner.
[1:33:55]
>>don wagner: you're back. All
[1:33:56]
right. So for a brief shining
[1:33:59]
moment, I served on the south
[1:34:02]
coast air quality management
[1:34:03]
district board, and you and I
[1:34:06]
had numerous conversations when
[1:34:08]
I was wearing that hat. Now
[1:34:10]
supervisor nguyen is honored and
[1:34:13]
privileged and I'm sure thrilled
[1:34:15]
to serve on that board. In
[1:34:18]
those conversations, I remember
[1:34:20]
you telling me things like,
[1:34:23]
we've got all of these group ins
[1:34:25]
out there, but they're for
[1:34:26]
specific communities, and we
[1:34:27]
don't have those communities in
[1:34:29]
our county. So when you're
[1:34:32]
talking about, well, let's just
[1:34:34]
faint towards words
[1:34:36]
environmental justice
[1:34:38]
communities, et cetera, but at
[1:34:39]
the end of the day, most of that
[1:34:42]
by design is going to other
[1:34:47]
counties because we don't fit
[1:34:48]
the criteria. Correct?
[1:34:50]
>>speaker: right. I think when
[1:34:51]
we were having those
[1:34:52]
conversations, we were talking
[1:34:53]
about ab-61 exphiefnts. We do
[1:34:56]
not. We have no ab-617, which
[1:34:59]
are considered the most dire
[1:35:02]
under environmental justice, and
[1:35:04]
there's only six, and there is
[1:35:05]
one in L.A., yes.
[1:35:09]
>>don wagner: right. So the
[1:35:09]
statutes are written by folks
[1:35:10]
from L.A. To benefit L.A.. They
[1:35:13]
don't come to orange county.
[1:35:15]
And so to stand there and say,
[1:35:16]
well, we just need to make
[1:35:17]
this -- say these things doesn't
[1:35:21]
change the reality on the
[1:35:22]
ground. They write the statutes
[1:35:24]
to benefit themselves, and we
[1:35:26]
have been fighting for funding
[1:35:28]
equity. We have been fighting
[1:35:29]
for this, that, and the other
[1:35:30]
thing and getting nowhere. I
[1:35:32]
just lay that out there as maybe
[1:35:33]
one of the reasons that we have
[1:35:35]
to play the game, but we don't
[1:35:36]
have to damage our community's
[1:35:39]
wholesale to play that game,
[1:35:41]
which is what chapter 4 does.
[1:35:44]
MS. Walsh, is she in the
[1:35:45]
audience and if I MAY...
[1:35:58]
All right. You've been
[1:35:59]
listening to all of this, and
[1:36:02]
I'm going to kind of give -- and
[1:36:05]
law school 101, never ask a
[1:36:07]
question you don't know the
[1:36:08]
answer to. I don't know the
[1:36:09]
answer to this. We haven't
[1:36:10]
talked. What is your legal view
[1:36:15]
of this document, chapter 4.
[1:36:19]
What excising chapter 4 would do
[1:36:22]
to our availability to get these
[1:36:24]
grants under all of these
[1:36:25]
different programs. I know
[1:36:27]
you've worked on it. I'm hoping
[1:36:29]
you might be, if not the expert,
[1:36:31]
the sacrificial lamb --
[1:36:36]
>>speaker: I think sacrificial
[1:36:37]
lamb helps us better at this
[1:36:39]
point. I have reviewed it.
[1:36:42]
There's a lot of things going on
[1:36:43]
here. Just so everybody knows,
[1:36:44]
with dough have a comprehensive
[1:36:45]
general plan update coming up.
[1:36:48]
It is out for public comment. I
[1:36:50]
spoke to the woman from the bia
[1:36:51]
in the back, and we do have a
[1:36:55]
mitigation measure in the
[1:36:56]
resource management chapter that
[1:36:59]
mentions the climate action
[1:37:00]
plan. That should be stricken.
[1:37:03]
Because we are not making the
[1:37:05]
climate action plan part of the
[1:37:07]
general plan. In addition our
[1:37:10]
comprehensive general plan
[1:37:11]
update has to have an
[1:37:13]
environmental justice chapter.
[1:37:15]
It is does. The chapt draft has
[1:37:17]
an environmental justice
[1:37:17]
chapter. That will be the
[1:37:19]
chapter that complies with state
[1:37:22]
law because the climate action
[1:37:24]
plan is not part of the general
[1:37:26]
plan and we are not making it
[1:37:28]
part of the general plan, any
[1:37:30]
environmental justice
[1:37:31]
conversation in the cap will not
[1:37:35]
qualify us for anything because
[1:37:37]
we are not the doing it as part
[1:37:39]
the general plan. The law
[1:37:40]
requires that an environmental
[1:37:42]
justice chapter be adopted as
[1:37:46]
part of the general plan. The
[1:37:48]
general plan requires multiple
[1:37:49]
hearings, as you all know, and
[1:37:52]
that's upcoming. Right now the
[1:37:56]
effect of today is that you
[1:37:59]
would be approving a plan. This
[1:38:02]
is just that you are approving
[1:38:03]
sort of the contents of what we
[1:38:06]
would move forward with in an
[1:38:08]
environmental document for the
[1:38:10]
cap. The cap right now as it
[1:38:13]
stands before you, even if
[1:38:14]
approved today, cannot be
[1:38:15]
implemented because there are no
[1:38:17]
ceqa findings. So we need to
[1:38:20]
move forward with an ier. It is
[1:38:25]
my understanding, and tara and I
[1:38:28]
haven't talked about this in a
[1:38:30]
while, and I was only involved
[1:38:32]
in the end just to be clear,
[1:38:33]
that the environmental document
[1:38:37]
will not cover chapter 4. Okay.
[1:38:40]
So that's correct. So what
[1:38:42]
that means is that even if you
[1:38:45]
adopt chapter 4 today,
[1:38:48]
quote/unquote, it is merely a
[1:38:51]
planning goal-oriented document.
[1:38:53]
It cannot be implemented, and
[1:38:55]
even after this when it is
[1:38:56]
brought back to you, because the
[1:38:58]
eir will not cover chapter 4.
[1:39:00]
It cannot be implemented. It
[1:39:08]
cannot be -- it's not binding.
[1:39:11]
We can't use it as a -- we can't
[1:39:11]
use it as a baseline for ceqa
[1:39:15]
documents for residential
[1:39:16]
developments. And we can't use
[1:39:22]
it to impose mitigation measures
[1:39:25]
because an eir will not have
[1:39:29]
covered that chapter.
[1:39:33]
>>don wagner: so is that a long
[1:39:35]
way of saying it won't matter if
[1:39:37]
we excise chapter 4, give us
[1:39:40]
more time then to have more
[1:39:41]
discussions with the
[1:39:43]
stakeholders and get something
[1:39:45]
that is not only agreeable to
[1:39:48]
them, but to the entire board,
[1:39:49]
and that we could then move
[1:39:50]
forward with?
[1:39:51]
>>speaker: I am not sure about
[1:39:53]
the funding on chapter 4.
[1:39:55]
That's what I'm not sure about.
[1:39:57]
In my conversations with the oc
[1:40:00]
waste and recycling, the fund
[1:40:01]
has been about municipal. So
[1:40:04]
that's not chapter 4. But there
[1:40:06]
could be funding that implicates
[1:40:09]
chapter 4. I honestly don't
[1:40:11]
know. I don't know what that
[1:40:16]
fund something, and I'm not
[1:40:16]
usually involved in that, I'll
[1:40:18]
be honest.
[1:40:21]
>>chair, doug chaffee:
[1:40:26]
vice-chair. Foals you're
[1:40:26]
getting everything mixed up
[1:40:27]
here. Sorry. But chapter 4 is
[1:40:31]
not an implementation strategy
[1:40:33]
section.
[1:40:34]
>>speaker: right.
[1:40:35]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: it
[1:40:35]
talks about promoting -- it
[1:40:43]
talks about reducing building
[1:40:45]
energy, it talks about
[1:40:47]
promoting, building
[1:40:49]
decarbonization. It talks about
[1:40:51]
promoting solar installation.
[1:40:54]
It talks about accessible ev
[1:40:59]
charge infrastructure. It's
[1:41:05]
intend as a non-mandate section
[1:41:06]
that covers areas of support.
[1:41:11]
So the language in chapter 4
[1:41:14]
says the community component of
[1:41:17]
the cap does not include binding
[1:41:20]
emissions, reductions, targets
[1:41:22]
or required implementation
[1:41:25]
measures. The community
[1:41:27]
component instead proposes
[1:41:29]
measures that could reduce
[1:41:31]
emissions if undertaken
[1:41:32]
voluntarily.
[1:41:33]
>>speaker: correct.
[1:41:35]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: and
[1:41:35]
the reason for this chapter is
[1:41:38]
intended so that we could help
[1:41:41]
support cities and nonprofits
[1:41:45]
and communities like we did
[1:41:47]
recently with our trump
[1:41:51]
administration epa grant that
[1:41:54]
was for our mobile home park
[1:41:56]
project in supervisor
[1:42:00]
sarmiento's district to install
[1:42:00]
solar. So that is what it is
[1:42:03]
intended for, is to be
[1:42:05]
supportive so that we can help
[1:42:09]
those communities to achieve
[1:42:11]
grants. And so I think that
[1:42:14]
it's getting all confused
[1:42:16]
because there's an intentional
[1:42:21]
attempt to confuse it, and so
[1:42:24]
just to be clear, what I heard
[1:42:27]
you saying, that is correct is
[1:42:30]
that chapter 4 is not a mandate
[1:42:33]
that is being channeled into the
[1:42:36]
general plan into the
[1:42:38]
environmental documentation for
[1:42:41]
purpose of development in the
[1:42:43]
county un-incorporated area. We
[1:42:45]
are not mandating what is
[1:42:47]
contained in the section related
[1:42:50]
to chapter 4. Correct.
[1:42:50]
>>speaker: that's correct.
[1:42:52]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: okay.
[1:42:53]
So the reason for chapter 4,
[1:42:55]
though is that if we don't have
[1:42:58]
chapter 4 we will not be able to
[1:43:02]
be as competitive for state
[1:43:07]
grants, especially prop 4. And
[1:43:10]
that is why we included chapter
[1:43:14]
4. And just.
[1:43:16]
Ly, we didn't ignore anyone.
[1:43:18]
We've had many, many
[1:43:19]
conversations. The concern is
[1:43:23]
understood, and that's why I've
[1:43:26]
said every single meeting over
[1:43:27]
the past year and a half these
[1:43:29]
are not mandates; these are how
[1:43:32]
the county creates a roadmap for
[1:43:33]
how we manage our own buildings,
[1:43:36]
especially our landfills. We
[1:43:37]
have three landfills that are
[1:43:38]
creating the most carbon
[1:43:39]
emissions for -- you know,
[1:43:41]
that's our main carbon emitter,
[1:43:43]
is our landfills. The priority
[1:43:45]
will be focused on reducing the
[1:43:47]
landfill emissions and our own
[1:43:49]
county building, saving taxpayer
[1:43:51]
funds by reduce energy costs.
[1:43:53]
Thank you.
[1:43:54]
>>chair, doug chaffee: all
[1:43:55]
right. One more time, I'm going
[1:43:57]
to go around and make a comment
[1:43:59]
of my own and call for a vote if
[1:44:00]
I MAY. Supervisor wagner.
[1:44:01]
>>don wagner: I'll just be real
[1:44:03]
brief. Weigh heard was chapter
[1:44:04]
4 -- what I heard was chapter 4
[1:44:06]
is not about grants, from our
[1:44:08]
lawyer. That's in municipal.
[1:44:14]
And therefore the grants
[1:44:16]
argument is sort of a red
[1:44:19]
herring as it applies to chapter
[1:44:22]
4.
[1:44:24]
>>speaker: I think I said -- I'm
[1:44:27]
not sure about all of the grants
[1:44:28]
that could result from chapter
[1:44:30]
4. So we do have -- if it's an
[1:44:32]
environmental justice grant,
[1:44:34]
because there was discussion
[1:44:35]
about environmental justice, we
[1:44:37]
have a specified chapter hear
[1:44:38]
that will meet the requirements
[1:44:40]
of the general plan in our draft
[1:44:42]
general plan. There could be
[1:44:44]
other grants. I'm not an
[1:44:44]
expert.
[1:44:46]
>>don wagner: chapter 4 intnt
[1:44:51]
grants, correct?
[1:44:53]
>>speaker: I think you're asking
[1:44:54]
me a question -- I'm -- chapter
[1:45:00]
4 is not about grants because
[1:45:03]
chapter 4 is a cap for
[1:45:05]
community, you know, ghg goals.
[1:45:09]
>>don wagner: thank you.
[1:45:10]
>>chair, doug chaffee: all
[1:45:10]
right. I'll make my own
[1:45:12]
comment. I dweebt to remove
[1:45:14]
chapter 4. The meeting is held
[1:45:18]
in my district. I saw
[1:45:19]
tremendous enthusiasm from my be
[1:45:21]
constituents. There was no
[1:45:23]
objection to these things being
[1:45:26]
objected to. I read the bia
[1:45:28]
letter. I kind of thought, how
[1:45:32]
does that even relate to the
[1:45:33]
document? It seemed like a
[1:45:34]
misfire. Because when I read
[1:45:36]
the document, there's nothing
[1:45:37]
binding that would even slightly
[1:45:39]
impact came a building trade.
[1:45:42]
So my -- I'm going to vote no on
[1:45:45]
the motion. And at this time,
[1:45:46]
I'd think I'd ask the clerk to
[1:45:48]
call the roll.
[1:45:48]
>>clerk, robin stieler:
[1:45:51]
supervisor wagner. Supervisor
[1:45:54]
nguyen.
[1:45:55]
>>janet nguyen: yes.
[1:45:57]
>>clerk, robin stieler:
[1:45:58]
supervisor sarmiento, vices
[1:45:59]
chair foley.
[1:46:00]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: no.
[1:46:01]
>>clerk, robin stieler: and
[1:46:01]
chair chaffee.
[1:46:02]
>>chair, doug chaffee: no. I
[1:46:04]
think I will make a motion that
[1:46:05]
we approve the climate action
[1:46:07]
plan including chapter 4.
[1:46:09]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: I'll
[1:46:10]
second.
[1:46:11]
>>janet nguyen: MR. CHAIRMAN,
[1:46:12]
MAY I --
[1:46:14]
>>chair, doug chaffee: we have a
[1:46:14]
motion on the floor. Now we can
[1:46:15]
discuss it. Supervisor wagner.
[1:46:17]
>>don wagner: I was just going
[1:46:19]
to ask the chair, given the
[1:46:21]
natural division in the
[1:46:22]
question, to divide chapter 4
[1:46:25]
out so that we can vote on the
[1:46:27]
bulk of the climate action plan
[1:46:28]
and chapter 4 separately.
[1:46:31]
>>chair, doug chaffee: I would
[1:46:31]
be agree tonight bifurcating if
[1:46:33]
that's agreeable -- I see a lot
[1:46:35]
of nodding. Let's -- let me
[1:46:38]
restate the motion, that we
[1:46:40]
consider the plan without
[1:46:42]
chapter 4, and we'll come back
[1:46:44]
and consider chapter 4
[1:46:47]
separately. MAY I have a
[1:46:48]
second?
[1:46:52]
>>janet nguyen: I'll second it.
[1:46:52]
>>chair, doug chaffee: the
[1:46:53]
motion is everything but chapter
[1:46:54]
4.
[1:46:56]
Is there any objection to
[1:46:57]
that. So the plan to chapter 4
[1:47:04]
is now approved. I'll make a
[1:47:06]
motion that chapter 4 be
[1:47:08]
included in the plan.
[1:47:08]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley:
[1:47:09]
second.
[1:47:09]
>>chair, doug chaffee: moved and
[1:47:11]
seconded. Now we can talk
[1:47:11]
separately about chapter 4 if
[1:47:13]
anyone cares. Supervisor
[1:47:13]
nguyen.
[1:47:15]
>>janet nguyen: thank you,
[1:47:16]
MR. CHAIRMAN. If you would
[1:47:19]
consider for chapter 4 is just
[1:47:23]
removing two sections of it.
[1:47:25]
Which is measure c, dash e-1,
[1:47:29]
which sets the building decarbon
[1:47:32]
sayings targets that while is
[1:47:35]
labor voluntary, it could be
[1:47:37]
interpreted as future policy
[1:47:39]
commitments and could contblict
[1:47:41]
state building codes and utility
[1:47:42]
programs. Building retrofit
[1:47:46]
expectation MAY increase costs
[1:47:49]
and operational challenges,
[1:47:51]
especially for small businesses
[1:47:53]
and older buildings. So
[1:47:55]
removing measure c-e1, and the
[1:47:59]
second one I'm asking you to
[1:48:01]
consider is removing measure
[1:48:06]
c-m2 which establishes the
[1:48:08]
vehicle mileage travel
[1:48:12]
reduction. That targets -- it's
[1:48:16]
largely outside the county's
[1:48:19]
direct control, and really could
[1:48:22]
negatively impact our business
[1:48:23]
access workforce mobility and
[1:48:25]
goods movement. So referencing
[1:48:27]
to come to this, it would
[1:48:31]
introduce land use policy
[1:48:32]
directions through a climate
[1:48:33]
plan rather than utilizing an
[1:48:36]
established plan in process.
[1:48:39]
Vmt has been in discussion in
[1:48:41]
sacramento since I was up there
[1:48:43]
for probably the full decade,
[1:48:46]
and so I think that we here at
[1:48:49]
county shouldn't be including
[1:48:51]
that in our section. And so if
[1:48:55]
you would consider removing
[1:48:57]
those two, I can support the
[1:49:00]
rest of chapter 4.
[1:49:08]
>>chair, doug chaffee: can I be
[1:49:08]
clear where that's in the plan.
[1:49:15]
>>janet nguyen: so c-e1, which
[1:49:16]
is --
[1:49:17]
>>chair, doug chaffee: you can
[1:49:18]
give me a page number.
[1:49:24]
>>janet nguyen: page 95.
[1:49:25]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank
[1:49:25]
you. Vice change comments.
[1:49:28]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank
[1:49:28]
you, MR. CHAIRMAN. I need
[1:49:32]
change my vote on the prior
[1:49:34]
because I want to be against the
[1:49:36]
cap. The way that the vote got
[1:49:38]
set up, I voted against the
[1:49:39]
climate action plan, which
[1:49:41]
obviously I don't want to do
[1:49:42]
that because I spent two years
[1:49:43]
of my life helping to develop
[1:49:45]
it. So I need to change my vote
[1:49:47]
to a yes on the original motion.
[1:49:50]
I just was not in favor of
[1:49:52]
removing chapter 4.
[1:49:54]
>>vincente sarmiento: I'll move
[1:49:55]
to reconsider the initial vote
[1:49:57]
on the balance of the cap plan
[1:50:00]
without chapter 4.
[1:50:02]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank
[1:50:03]
you. Second.
[1:50:04]
>>chair, doug chaffee: wait a
[1:50:04]
minute. I got lost in all that.
[1:50:08]
We're talking separately about
[1:50:10]
the -- chapter 4.
[1:50:12]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: I
[1:50:12]
understand. But the original
[1:50:14]
motion was the climate action
[1:50:17]
plan without chapter 4, which I
[1:50:19]
voted against. But now because
[1:50:21]
of how it got set up, now I'm
[1:50:24]
against the cap as a result,
[1:50:26]
because you just added the
[1:50:27]
chapter 4 into the original
[1:50:31]
motion. So it made it so that I
[1:50:34]
voted against the cap, not
[1:50:35]
intentionally.
[1:50:37]
Unintentionally.
[1:50:38]
>>chair, doug chaffee: well, I
[1:50:38]
didn't interpret it that way.
[1:50:40]
We simply voted for the plan
[1:50:43]
itself. Clearly, I thought with
[1:50:46]
the understanding that we would
[1:50:48]
consider adding chapter 4
[1:50:51]
separately. That's what we're
[1:50:52]
doing.
[1:50:53]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: so
[1:50:53]
can I just re --- I would like
[1:50:55]
to vote in favor of the original
[1:50:57]
motion because I want to be in
[1:50:58]
favor of the cap.
[1:51:00]
>>chair, doug chaffee: of
[1:51:00]
chapter 4.
[1:51:02]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: I
[1:51:02]
support chapter 4. I support
[1:51:04]
the whole cap as presented.
[1:51:07]
>>chair, doug chaffee: so you
[1:51:07]
don't support the bifurcation;
[1:51:09]
is that what it is, where we
[1:51:11]
separated chapter 4 from the
[1:51:13]
plan?
[1:51:16]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: I
[1:51:17]
support -- I did not support
[1:51:19]
removing chapter 4. And I'm
[1:51:23]
just trying to make sure my vote
[1:51:24]
is in favor of the cap. I'm not
[1:51:26]
sure what we voted that the
[1:51:26]
point.
[1:51:29]
>>chair, doug chaffee: why don't
[1:51:30]
we restate the motion, if that's
[1:51:34]
where we're at, that we simply
[1:51:38]
approve the plan as presented,
[1:51:40]
including chapter 4. Is that
[1:51:42]
where you're at.
[1:51:43]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: yes.
[1:51:44]
Second.
[1:51:44]
>>janet nguyen: we bifurcated
[1:51:45]
it.
[1:51:46]
>>chair, doug chaffee: I know.
[1:51:47]
But I think the result is the
[1:51:48]
same if we -- if you move
[1:51:51]
chapter 4 into the plan.
[1:51:55]
>>vincente sarmiento: I think
[1:51:55]
the vice-chair simply wants to
[1:51:58]
revote on the first part of the
[1:52:00]
bifurcation, which is on the
[1:52:01]
plan without chapter 4, because
[1:52:03]
she voted no and wants to vote
[1:52:05]
in favor of it.
[1:52:06]
>>janet nguyen: so in other
[1:52:08]
words, what I'm hearing, MADAM
[1:52:12]
Vice-chair, that we just need to
[1:52:13]
reconsider --
[1:52:14]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: is
[1:52:14]
there a way to clear the board?
[1:52:15]
>>chair, doug chaffee: we can
[1:52:19]
make a notion reconsider. Ask
[1:52:20]
counsel to clarify, if he can.
[1:52:22]
>>leon page: I think typically
[1:52:26]
the board is allowable of these
[1:52:28]
kinds of requests. And I think
[1:52:30]
there's just unanimous support
[1:52:31]
for the climate action plan
[1:52:32]
without chapter 4.
[1:52:34]
>>chair, doug chaffee: yes
[1:52:35]
paidgesz all of the members
[1:52:35]
support that. The controversy
[1:52:37]
concerns chapter 4, and I think
[1:52:39]
that's where the board had the
[1:52:40]
division of the vote, and now
[1:52:43]
there's been a request by
[1:52:44]
supervisor nguyen to remove two
[1:52:46]
action items in chapter 4.
[1:52:47]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley:
[1:52:48]
that's not answering the
[1:52:48]
questions.
[1:52:49]
>>leon page: I think the clerk
[1:52:51]
can record that all five members
[1:52:54]
support the climate action plan
[1:52:56]
without chapter 4. And that's
[1:52:58]
what I think supervisor foley is
[1:52:59]
trying to get to. Supervisor
[1:53:02]
foley also supports chapter 4,
[1:53:04]
and that's where we will
[1:53:05]
eventually end up.
[1:53:05]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank
[1:53:05]
you.
[1:53:08]
>>chair, doug chaffee: okay. So
[1:53:08]
I'm going to stand by the
[1:53:11]
bifurcation, and we're now
[1:53:13]
considering chapter 4 as part
[1:53:17]
the climb ate -- climate action
[1:53:18]
plan.
[1:53:19]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: yep.
[1:53:22]
>>chair, doug chaffee: all
[1:53:23]
right. Any further discussion
[1:53:24]
on that or shall we call another
[1:53:25]
roll at this point.
[1:53:27]
>>janet nguyen: I'm so confused.
[1:53:30]
I'm sorry. I'm confused. So
[1:53:32]
our original vote for 81, the
[1:53:39]
climate action plan without 4,
[1:53:42]
was 4/1.
[1:53:43]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: it's
[1:53:46]
now 5-0. And then he added back
[1:53:47]
in chapter 4, and you've asked
[1:53:49]
for changes to chapter 4, which
[1:53:51]
there isn't support in the maker
[1:53:53]
of the motion for that.
[1:53:54]
>>janet nguyen: so the new vote
[1:53:56]
is just on chapter 4 then.
[1:53:56]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley:
[1:53:58]
adding it in -- so it's page 65
[1:54:08]
in also page 100.. I'm
[1:54:12]
asking --
[1:54:13]
>>janet nguyen: also on page
[1:54:13]
100, I'm asking you to consider
[1:54:14]
moving these two items off of
[1:54:16]
chapter 4 and I will be
[1:54:29]
supporting the rest.
[1:54:29]
>>chair, doug chaffee: are there
[1:54:30]
any other comments? I see the
[1:54:32]
point that you're making on e1.
[1:54:37]
I didn't read the next page,
[1:54:37]
but...
[1:54:40]
>>janet nguyen: page 100 is the
[1:54:42]
vehicles miles travel.
[1:55:03]
>>chair, doug chaffee: that one
[1:55:04]
I would be supportive of
[1:55:08]
removing, c-e3, but not the
[1:55:13]
other one, I think that has some
[1:55:14]
advantage. It's just a planning
[1:55:16]
consideration. That one. And I
[1:55:19]
think -- bifurcation to me is an
[1:55:22]
economic consideration.
[1:55:24]
>>janet nguyen: so c-e1 is
[1:55:26]
the --
[1:55:31]
>>chair, doug chaffee: isn't
[1:55:31]
that on -- that's 97, sorry.
[1:55:34]
>>janet nguyen: 95.
[1:55:34]
>>chair, doug chaffee: I'm
[1:55:38]
sorry. E1 on page 95, I would
[1:55:39]
be agreeable that that be
[1:55:42]
removed.
[1:55:43]
>>janet nguyen: what about c-m2?
[1:55:49]
, which is page 100.
[1:55:56]
>>chair, doug chaffee: no. I
[1:55:56]
think that's okay. I would
[1:56:01]
leave that. But I think the
[1:56:02]
electrification goes with the
[1:56:04]
concept of all electric water
[1:56:06]
heaters and all that kind of
[1:56:08]
stuff that made no sense.
[1:56:11]
So I think electrification is
[1:56:14]
more of an economic concept to
[1:56:17]
me. Not necessarily a climate
[1:56:19]
one. You get there through
[1:56:20]
economics, I think.
[1:56:20]
>>janet nguyen: but remember,
[1:56:22]
MR. CHAIRMAN, the vehicles miles
[1:56:24]
travel is also economic.
[1:56:29]
Currently those who has gas car
[1:56:34]
paying gas taxes. While those
[1:56:35]
who has electric cars are not
[1:56:36]
paying the tax -- the gas tax.
[1:56:41]
And what you're going to end up
[1:56:43]
with is when we implement
[1:56:45]
statewide vehicles miles travel,
[1:56:49]
which means those whoa has gas
[1:56:50]
car would not only be paying
[1:56:52]
sales tax on the gasoline
[1:56:56]
they're pumping into their car,
[1:56:58]
but they're also now going to be
[1:56:59]
paying vehicles miles travel
[1:57:01]
while the electrical cars folks
[1:57:03]
are only paying for the vehicles
[1:57:04]
miles travel and not the gas
[1:57:07]
sales tax. So I think it's also
[1:57:10]
economic. And it does hit
[1:57:12]
individuals and families, you
[1:57:15]
know, very hard, and that's one
[1:57:17]
of my arguments in the last, you
[1:57:19]
know, several years in
[1:57:21]
sacramento when we talked about
[1:57:23]
the vehicles miles travel. And
[1:57:25]
so I think that removing both of
[1:57:26]
them would really -- I mean, it
[1:57:31]
also allows those -- I mean, for
[1:57:35]
us to continuing to watch that
[1:57:37]
sacramento is doing. They've
[1:57:39]
got hearings, talking about the
[1:57:40]
vehicle miles travel as well
[1:57:42]
this year. And watching what
[1:57:45]
they do and how it's going to be
[1:57:47]
implemented statewide would be
[1:57:48]
much more helpful to us than to
[1:57:50]
put it into our action.
[1:57:53]
>>chair, doug chaffee: I think
[1:57:53]
the vehicle miles plan can be
[1:57:56]
done different ways. Maybe a
[1:57:58]
different rate for electric cars
[1:57:59]
than gasoline cars for example.
[1:58:01]
I think that's a concept that
[1:58:03]
I'd like to see explored.
[1:58:07]
>>chair, doug chaffee: I would
[1:58:11]
demand the motion to approve by
[1:58:15]
4 by deleting that first item on
[1:58:21]
page 95 that you're referring to
[1:58:23]
if the second is agreeable to
[1:58:25]
that. If the second is not
[1:58:26]
agreeable, then we don't move
[1:58:28]
forward.
[1:58:30]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: can
[1:58:30]
someone clarify what section
[1:58:32]
we're deleting? I don't have
[1:58:33]
page numbers on mine.
[1:58:36]
>>chair, doug chaffee: page 95.
[1:58:40]
>>janet nguyen: c-e1.
[1:58:42]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: c-e1
[1:58:43]
as I understand it says provide
[1:58:45]
technical assistance to private
[1:58:47]
building owners and tenants
[1:58:49]
regarding building
[1:58:50]
decarbonization and explore
[1:58:52]
opportunities to connect
[1:58:53]
building owners with proficient
[1:58:55]
contractors. That's what you
[1:58:56]
want to remove? I don't
[1:58:59]
understand.
[1:58:59]
>>leon page: there are actually
[1:59:00]
three action items on page 95.
[1:59:02]
>>chair, doug chaffee: page 95.
[1:59:06]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: c-e1
[1:59:07]
says what I just read. Which
[1:59:11]
section are you asking to
[1:59:12]
remove?
[1:59:17]
>>janet nguyen: c-e1, e-1, dash
[1:59:17]
2, and dash 3.
[1:59:19]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: dash
[1:59:20]
2 and 3 is what you want to
[1:59:21]
remove.
[1:59:23]
>>janet nguyen: all three of
[1:59:23]
them. At this point --
[1:59:25]
MR. Chair, I appreciate --
[1:59:28]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: can I
[1:59:28]
finish? So c-e1.2, I just want
[1:59:33]
to make sure we're all on the
[1:59:33]
same page, says work with local
[1:59:36]
utilities and or the southern
[1:59:39]
california regional energy
[1:59:41]
network to promote replacement
[1:59:43]
of natural gas appliances
[1:59:45]
through education and financial
[1:59:47]
incentives. That's assuming
[1:59:49]
that those are required by the
[1:59:51]
state at some point. We're not
[1:59:53]
mandating it, we're just saying
[1:59:55]
if that's required, work with
[1:59:57]
locals to help them. So is that
[2:00:00]
what you want to remove? Is
[2:00:02]
that a yes or a no? I just want
[2:00:04]
to go through and make sure I
[2:00:05]
know what you want to remove.
[2:00:06]
>>janet nguyen: I said all of
[2:00:07]
e-1.
[2:00:08]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: so
[2:00:09]
the next part of e-1.3 is launch
[2:00:13]
educational campaigns for
[2:00:15]
residents, businesses and
[2:00:17]
building owners and managers on
[2:00:19]
decarbon sayings and/or
[2:00:21]
electrification programs and
[2:00:23]
incentives offered by the local
[2:00:25]
utilities and or so cal rye n,
[2:00:28]
which is the regional --
[2:00:29]
southern california regional
[2:00:31]
energy network. Is that what
[2:00:33]
else you want to remove.
[2:00:34]
>>janet nguyen: all of e-1.
[2:00:36]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: and
[2:00:39]
the vehicle miles traveled, the
[2:00:46]
recommendation is to evaluate
[2:00:48]
opportunities to support and
[2:00:50]
expand active transportation
[2:00:51]
infrastructure to major
[2:00:54]
destinations within
[2:00:55]
un-incorporated areas, and the
[2:00:58]
second goal is to promote and/or
[2:01:01]
incentivize transit oriented,
[2:01:03]
mixed use, compact development
[2:01:05]
through permit streamlining and
[2:01:07]
incentives. That's not really
[2:01:09]
about vehicle miles traveled as
[2:01:12]
a tax, as it's been described.
[2:01:14]
It's more about how do we create
[2:01:16]
infrastructure. So I would not
[2:01:18]
support the motion. I would not
[2:01:21]
support the request to remove
[2:01:23]
those because --
[2:01:23]
>>chair, doug chaffee: either of
[2:01:24]
them.
[2:01:25]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: well,
[2:01:25]
I don't know what -- we're going
[2:01:27]
to remove the section -- I'd
[2:01:29]
like to hear why we need to
[2:01:32]
remove the section about
[2:01:33]
providing technical assistance
[2:01:35]
and working with the utility
[2:01:37]
companies. Don't we want to do
[2:01:42]
that.
[2:01:43]
>>chair, doug chaffee: it's
[2:01:46]
today to into this
[2:01:47]
electrification issue, so...
[2:01:50]
>>janet nguyen: MR. CHAIRMAN,
[2:01:52]
MAY I --
[2:01:54]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: it's
[2:01:54]
not requiring -- look, I have a
[2:01:57]
gas stove. I know people
[2:01:59]
have -- there's like a lot of
[2:02:00]
debate about that. And that's
[2:02:04]
why we did mandate anything like
[2:02:05]
that. And so I don't think this
[2:02:09]
section does what has been
[2:02:11]
described.
[2:02:11]
>>chair, doug chaffee: well,
[2:02:11]
it's strange, connecting a
[2:02:14]
building with proficient
[2:02:16]
contractors. That's almost like
[2:02:18]
an advertisement for who is
[2:02:21]
profession.
[2:02:23]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: well,
[2:02:23]
I can understand why that would
[2:02:24]
be a concern.
[2:02:26]
>>chair, doug chaffee: yeah. I
[2:02:26]
don't want to vote a contractor
[2:02:29]
particularly.
[2:02:29]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: can
[2:02:29]
we keep the provide technical
[2:02:31]
assistance to private building
[2:02:33]
owners.
[2:02:34]
>>janet nguyen: MR. CHAIRMAN,
[2:02:35]
can I say --
[2:02:35]
>>chair, doug chaffee: well,
[2:02:35]
let's --
[2:02:36]
>>janet nguyen: it might help
[2:02:39]
you to have not --
[2:02:42]
>>chair, doug chaffee: okay.
[2:02:48]
Well, let's -- there is a
[2:02:49]
request now from removing two
[2:02:52]
items, and I don't see any
[2:02:56]
support for removing the one
[2:02:57]
concerning the vehicle miles
[2:03:01]
expiration. The first one,
[2:03:02]
though, building
[2:03:03]
decarbonization, I find that
[2:03:06]
difficult myself. All right.
[2:03:10]
Let's see if we can work through
[2:03:11]
this. Supervisor -- vice-chair,
[2:03:15]
any further comments?
[2:03:17]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: I
[2:03:17]
just would be open to hearing
[2:03:19]
how you might want to change
[2:03:20]
some of that because I think
[2:03:21]
what I hear you saying is that
[2:03:23]
you're concerned about the -- us
[2:03:26]
advertising. So I get that, and
[2:03:28]
that I can accept. But I guess
[2:03:32]
my concern is that most of the
[2:03:34]
rest of this is more sort of
[2:03:37]
educational, helping people to
[2:03:39]
find out what incentives are
[2:03:41]
offered by other utilities,
[2:03:43]
connecting residents, and
[2:03:46]
private businesses to utility
[2:03:49]
incentives. So if they have to
[2:03:52]
do something different in their
[2:03:54]
development or if they want to,
[2:03:56]
for that matter. So that would
[2:03:58]
be -- if we want to remove the
[2:04:00]
language, explore opportunities
[2:04:03]
to connect building owners with
[2:04:05]
proficient contractors, would
[2:04:08]
that satisfy your concerns?
[2:04:10]
>>chair, doug chaffee: well, I
[2:04:11]
think we're getting a little bit
[2:04:12]
into the weeds here a little too
[2:04:14]
much.
[2:04:15]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley:
[2:04:15]
okay.
[2:04:16]
>>chair, doug chaffee: I think
[2:04:17]
if you want to come back later
[2:04:18]
with some rewording of this
[2:04:21]
whole section, that's possible.
[2:04:25]
It doesn't have to be the end of
[2:04:26]
it today.
[2:04:27]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: okay.
[2:04:28]
>>chair, doug chaffee: but I
[2:04:29]
found the whole thrust of it is
[2:04:32]
leading to electrification when
[2:04:35]
there are other economic
[2:04:36]
opportunities that MAY need to
[2:04:41]
be considered. So -- and I'm
[2:04:44]
also going to try to find some
[2:04:45]
grounds to get this done. And I
[2:04:47]
find -- so, anyway...
[2:04:51]
We have a motion that so far is
[2:04:55]
just to add the section 4.
[2:05:02]
There's a suggestion for a
[2:05:04]
change from supervisor nguyen.
[2:05:06]
I'm agreeable to that. I did
[2:05:08]
not -- not to this mileage
[2:05:10]
thing, but to the other part. I
[2:05:14]
didn't hear an agreement from my
[2:05:16]
second. So I don't know where
[2:05:17]
we are. Right now we have a
[2:05:20]
motion to simply add section 4
[2:05:25]
PRESIDENT Been moved and
[2:05:25]
seconded. That's where we're at
[2:05:31]
at. I guess we'll call -- and I
[2:05:37]
think we can address this other
[2:05:38]
thing later maybe? I don't
[2:05:42]
know. I'm troubled when I read
[2:05:42]
through that thing that
[2:05:45]
supervisor nguyen was pointing
[2:05:46]
out as not a good idea.
[2:05:53]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: I'd
[2:05:53]
be happy to work with you on
[2:05:54]
some changes to the language if
[2:05:56]
we could just get it passed
[2:05:56]
today and then we could maybe
[2:05:57]
bring it back, if that's
[2:05:58]
agreeable.
[2:05:58]
>>chair, doug chaffee: the
[2:05:59]
alternative is simply to
[2:06:01]
continue consideration of
[2:06:03]
section 4 to the next meeting.
[2:06:05]
Would that be agreeable?
[2:06:06]
>>janet nguyen: I'll second
[2:06:06]
that.
[2:06:07]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: I'd
[2:06:10]
rather just condition this one
[2:06:12]
page that is at issue if we're
[2:06:14]
going to continue anything.
[2:06:16]
>>chair, doug chaffee: so you'd
[2:06:17]
be agreeable at this time for
[2:06:20]
removing that item from --
[2:06:20]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley:
[2:06:22]
continuing this one item.
[2:06:25]
>>chair, doug chaffee: okay. So
[2:06:29]
that item c-e1 through 3 will
[2:06:31]
not be part of section 4 that
[2:06:33]
we're voting on now.
[2:06:34]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: yeah.
[2:06:35]
And then we'll continue that to
[2:06:36]
the next meeting.
[2:06:36]
>>chair, doug chaffee: for
[2:06:38]
further discussion all right.
[2:06:39]
Got it. All right. Any
[2:06:42]
objection to that motion?
[2:06:46]
Clerk, please call the roll.
[2:06:52]
>>clerk, robin stieler: chair
[2:06:52]
chaffee.
[2:06:55]
>>chair, doug chaffee: aye.
[2:06:58]
>>clerk, robin stieler:
[2:06:59]
supervisor foley.
[2:07:01]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley:
[2:07:01]
isle.
[2:07:04]
>>clerk, robin stieler:
[2:07:06]
supervisor nguyen.
[2:07:08]
>>janet nguyen: abstain.
[2:07:09]
>>clerk, robin stieler:
[2:07:10]
supervisor sarmiento.
[2:07:11]
>>vincente sarmiento: yes, but
[2:07:30]
it's c hi e1, ce-.2, c dash e1.3
[2:07:31]
e1.3.
[2:07:31]
S.
[2:07:33]
>>janet nguyen: MADAM Clerk, you
[2:07:40]
can make mine no?.
[2:07:42]
>>chair, doug chaffee: so no,
[2:07:45]
three yeses and an abstention.
[2:07:47]
>>clerk, robin stieler: two
[2:07:47]
NOs.
[2:07:48]
>>chair, doug chaffee: so
[2:07:53]
section 4, absent the c-e.1, 2,
[2:07:55]
and 3 are now part of the
[2:07:56]
climate action plan and we'll
[2:07:57]
come back and further discuss
[2:07:59]
this and massage it a little bit
[2:08:00]
and see if we can make more
[2:08:01]
sense out of it.
[2:08:02]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank
[2:08:02]
you, MR. CHAIRMAN.
[2:08:04]
>>chair, doug chaffee: all
[2:08:12]
right. Now please go on to item
[2:08:14]
22.
[2:08:15]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 22.
[2:08:16]
Under county executive office-
[2:08:17]
approve grant
[2:08:18]
applications/awards submitted by
[2:08:19]
health care agency, oc community
[2:08:20]
resources and oc waste &
[2:08:24]
recycling in 2/24/26 grant
[2:08:24]
report and other actions as
[2:08:27]
recommended; and adopt
[2:08:27]
resolution authorizing oc waste
[2:08:29]
& recycling director or designee
[2:08:31]
to negotiate, execute
[2:08:33]
agreements, related documents
[2:08:34]
and amendments with california
[2:08:36]
coastal commission for whale
[2:08:38]
tail grants program ($50,000)
[2:08:39]
And MR. Chair, we received one
[2:08:41]
request to speak on agenda item
[2:08:42]
22.
[2:08:43]
>>chair, doug chaffee: please
[2:08:43]
call the speaker.
[2:08:57]
>>clerk, robin stieler: donora.
[2:08:57]
>>chair, doug chaffee:
[2:08:59]
apparently not present.
[2:09:00]
>>clerk, robin stieler: she's
[2:09:01]
right here.
[2:09:02]
>>chair, doug chaffee: come on
[2:09:02]
over then. Please come to the
[2:09:04]
podium.
[2:09:13]
>>speaker: good morning,
[2:09:14]
everyone. I guess you guys know
[2:09:16]
who I am, and I want to speak on
[2:09:20]
item 22, but I also -- since
[2:09:22]
english is my second language, I
[2:09:25]
want to stand a little bit that
[2:09:27]
I'm very disappointed that you
[2:09:29]
as federal government, who
[2:09:31]
brought me here as a kid, I was
[2:09:34]
7 years old, supposed to be
[2:09:35]
protected under federal statute
[2:09:37]
because we were brought as
[2:09:38]
refugee, not escape from cuba.
[2:09:41]
Federal government brought us
[2:09:43]
here. And I've worked 40-plus
[2:09:45]
years and paid taxes to see
[2:09:48]
illegal aliens taken over
[2:09:49]
housing in orange county. I've
[2:09:54]
never drink, done drugs, neither
[2:09:54]
smoke. My family from florida
[2:09:56]
is very disappointed including
[2:09:58]
in cuba, so they're sending my
[2:10:01]
alien number to washington D.C.
[2:10:03]
To see what the heck went wrong
[2:10:05]
here. I should not be in my
[2:10:12]
cart, and illegal aliens have
[2:10:14]
taken over housing. I've been
[2:10:15]
coming to the board since 2019
[2:10:18]
through the present, and a lot
[2:10:20]
of great officers are friends of
[2:10:23]
mine, including the chief
[2:10:27]
barnes. And it's an
[2:10:28]
embarrassment that you guys have
[2:10:31]
not done to anything about it to
[2:10:33]
tell the housing authority go
[2:10:35]
ahead and give her an emergency
[2:10:36]
voucher, run into church, taking
[2:10:36]
shower.
[2:10:40]
>>chair, doug chaffee: this has
[2:10:40]
nothing to do with that.
[2:10:41]
>>speaker: but I would like to
[2:10:42]
make an appointment with you. I
[2:10:44]
was told you are the chair.
[2:10:46]
>>chair, doug chaffee: you can
[2:10:46]
make an appointment through the
[2:10:47]
appropriate channels. But this
[2:10:50]
has nothing to do with that.
[2:10:52]
>>speaker: thank you. Very
[2:10:54]
stressed out. But on topping,
[2:10:58]
no. 22, since you say community
[2:11:02]
resource -- on topic...
[2:11:03]
Maybe the resource community
[2:11:06]
could focus on illegal immigrant
[2:11:09]
when they making housing and not
[2:11:12]
depriving me of housing
[2:11:13]
assistant, hopefully I can make
[2:11:16]
an I point with you, the chair,
[2:11:22]
because charles has refused to
[2:11:22]
make me an appointment with
[2:11:24]
supervisor janet nguyen, and I
[2:11:28]
was told that I have the right
[2:11:30]
to make an appointment with the
[2:11:31]
a supervisor because he have not
[2:11:33]
done anything for me, just ask
[2:11:40]
andrew do and chief crist.
[2:11:41]
>>chair, doug chaffee: you need
[2:11:42]
to address the item or sit down,
[2:11:44]
please.
[2:11:45]
>>speaker: thank you. This is
[2:11:46]
the item that -- like I say,
[2:11:49]
this is my first time being here
[2:11:51]
since I was a kid, and I had to
[2:11:53]
basically talk to you guys,
[2:11:57]
legislative policymakers, to see
[2:11:58]
why people that are illegal are
[2:12:00]
take over housing in orange
[2:12:01]
county.
[2:12:02]
>>chair, doug chaffee: again,
[2:12:03]
this item has nothing to do with
[2:12:04]
that.
[2:12:05]
>>speaker: so when it has
[2:12:06]
something to do, can you explain
[2:12:07]
this in english, is my second
[2:12:08]
language, community resource.
[2:12:11]
>>chair, doug chaffee: this has
[2:12:11]
to do with grant applications.
[2:12:14]
They're listed in the agenda.
[2:12:17]
>>speaker: well, I pulled out my
[2:12:18]
application for housing and
[2:12:19]
nothing happened yet.
[2:12:20]
>>chair, doug chaffee: that's
[2:12:20]
not this. Your time is up.
[2:12:22]
Thank you.
[2:12:23]
>>speaker: thank you. Have a
[2:12:24]
great day, and looking forward
[2:12:25]
to making an appointment with
[2:12:26]
you.
[2:12:28]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: move
[2:12:28]
the item.
[2:12:29]
>>chair, doug chaffee: moved and
[2:12:30]
seconded. I would note there is
[2:12:32]
grant money here possibly for
[2:12:35]
prop 36 funding, something that
[2:12:37]
the people voted in, and they --
[2:12:39]
and sacramento seems to ignore.
[2:12:41]
Here's a chance for some
[2:12:43]
funding, and we do take that
[2:12:46]
seriously. All right. It's
[2:12:52]
included PRESIDENT Been
[2:12:52]
approved. Item 23 has been
[2:12:55]
deleted. So item 24, please.
[2:12:57]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 24.
[2:13:00]
Under county executive office,
[2:13:01]
approve type 2 work order number
[2:13:03]
ncy7-009 under contract
[2:13:05]
ma-017-19010750 with science
[2:13:06]
applications international
[2:13:07]
corporation for managed services
[2:13:09]
network, voice and security
[2:13:10]
services to support firewall
[2:13:12]
system migration for john wayne
[2:13:14]
airport, 3/25/26-11/10/26
[2:13:16]
($225,200); and authorize county
[2:13:16]
chief information officer or
[2:13:18]
designee to execute work order.
[2:13:19]
We have no requests to speak on
[2:13:21]
agenda item 24.
[2:13:22]
>>chair, doug chaffee: it's an
[2:13:23]
all-district item.
[2:13:23]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: move
[2:13:24]
the item.
[2:13:26]
>>chair, doug chaffee: any
[2:13:26]
objection? Item 24 is approved.
[2:13:29]
25, please.
[2:13:29]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 25.
[2:13:30]
Under county executive office,
[2:13:31]
approve amendment 3 to renew
[2:13:32]
contract ma-017-22011093 with
[2:13:33]
southwest strategies, llc for
[2:13:35]
spent fuel solutions management
[2:13:36]
services at san onofre nuclear
[2:13:39]
generating station, 3/22/26-
[2:13:39]
3/21/27 ($100,000; cumulative
[2:13:40]
total $500,000); and authorize
[2:13:41]
county procurement officer or
[2:13:43]
deputized designee to execute amendment.
[2:13:44]
We have no requests to speak on
[2:13:49]
agenda item 25.
[2:13:49]
>>chair, doug chaffee: is
[2:13:50]
district 5.
[2:13:51]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: move
[2:13:53]
the item.
[2:13:55]
>>chair, doug chaffee: any
[2:13:56]
objection? Item 25 is approved.
[2:14:00]
26, please.
[2:14:00]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 26.
[2:14:00]
Under county executive office,
[2:14:01]
approve 2026 federal community
[2:14:03]
project funding requests. And we
[2:14:05]
have no requests to speak on
[2:14:06]
agenda item 26.
[2:14:08]
>>chair, doug chaffee: it's an
[2:14:09]
all-district item.
[2:14:10]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: move
[2:14:11]
the item.
[2:14:12]
>>chair, doug chaffee: seeing no
[2:14:13]
objection, item is approved.
[2:14:16]
27, please.
[2:14:16]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 27.
[2:14:17]
Under county executive office,
[2:14:18]
approve amendment 3 to contract
[2:14:19]
ma-017-22010907 with network
[2:14:20]
television time inc. For board
[2:14:21]
hearing room hardware, software
[2:14:22]
and professional services, term
[2:14:23]
ending 3/8/31 ($1,793,655;
[2:14:24]
cumulative total $4,676,762);
[2:14:24]
and authorize county
[2:14:25]
procurement officer or deputized
[2:14:26]
designee to execute amendment.
[2:14:27]
And we have no if to speak on
[2:14:29]
agenda item 27.
[2:14:30]
>>chair, doug chaffee: it's an
[2:14:33]
all-district item.
[2:14:34]
>>don wagner: move the item.
[2:14:36]
>>chair, doug chaffee: I'll
[2:14:37]
second it. Any objection?
[2:14:39]
Motion carries. Item 28. We
[2:14:41]
dealt with earlier. Now we come
[2:14:44]
down to item 29.
[2:14:45]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 29.
[2:14:47]
Under registrar of voters-
[2:14:47]
approve retroactive amendment 2
[2:14:48]
to contract ma-031-24010973 with
[2:14:50]
cathyjon enterprises, inc. Dba
[2:14:52]
hb staffing for temporary help
[2:14:53]
services, 1/31/25-1/30/26
[2:14:53]
($181,659; new total $500,000;
[2:14:54]
cumulative total $1,081,659);
[2:14:55]
and authorize county
[2:14:55]
procurement officer or deputized
[2:14:57]
designee to exercise cost
[2:14:57]
contingency increase not to
[2:14:59]
exceed 10% under certain
[2:15:00]
conditions and execute contract.
[2:15:02]
And we received one request to
[2:15:05]
speak on agenda item 29.
[2:15:06]
>>chair, doug chaffee: please
[2:15:06]
call the speaker.
[2:15:08]
>>clerk, robin stieler: paul
[2:15:17]
hayek.
[2:15:23]
>>speaker: I bet people -- my
[2:15:25]
question is, with this company,
[2:15:27]
are they gonna able to provide
[2:15:29]
the extra help when we have our
[2:15:31]
elections in JUNE and NOVEMBER
[2:15:37]
to staff? The facilities that
[2:15:40]
are needed. I'm very interested
[2:15:43]
in being one of those temps.
[2:15:46]
I'm a handicap.
[2:15:48]
>>clerk, robin stieler: no
[2:15:50]
further requests, MR. Chair.
[2:15:51]
>>chair, doug chaffee: all
[2:15:52]
right. This is an all-district
[2:15:52]
item.
[2:15:54]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: move
[2:15:55]
the item.
[2:15:55]
>>chair, doug chaffee: moved and
[2:15:56]
second. Objection? Motion
[2:15:58]
carries. Next item is item 30.
[2:16:01]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 30.
[2:16:03]
Under office of campaign finance
[2:16:05]
and ethics commission-receive
[2:16:06]
and file 2025 campaign finance
[2:16:09]
and ethics commission's annual report.
[2:16:12]
And MR. Chair, we see one
[2:16:13]
request to speak on agenda item
[2:16:15]
30.
[2:16:15]
>>chair, doug chaffee: please
[2:16:15]
call the speaker.
[2:16:19]
>>clerk, robin stieler: brian
[2:16:30]
kay.
[2:16:34]
>>speaker: happy day. So orange
[2:16:35]
county does have a campaign
[2:16:37]
ethics office. I've been to it.
[2:16:43]
I've been to a few of the
[2:16:44]
meetings, and it's somewhat of
[2:16:48]
an embarrassment. It's a vacant
[2:16:50]
building. There's no offices.
[2:16:54]
There's just a couple of tables.
[2:16:57]
They hold a meeting, which is
[2:16:59]
more a get-together for the four
[2:17:01]
or five board members. And poor
[2:17:04]
donna hoard isn't allowed to
[2:17:07]
actually communicate with the
[2:17:08]
public. So while our beloved
[2:17:10]
katrina foley sits there and
[2:17:12]
says that she's paying attention
[2:17:14]
to people and she wants to hear
[2:17:16]
what the public has to say, poor
[2:17:19]
donna hoard isn't capable of
[2:17:21]
listening to the public, and
[2:17:24]
then translating that to this
[2:17:26]
board of supervisors. And it is
[2:17:30]
a shame. It reminds me of james
[2:17:33]
armanderis. I'm sure that vince
[2:17:34]
remembers james. Do you not,
[2:17:36]
sir? He was a great man on the
[2:17:39]
human relations, and he met with
[2:17:42]
the members of the public, and
[2:17:43]
he communicated with members of
[2:17:45]
the public. And then he
[2:17:47]
communicated with members of the
[2:17:48]
board. And provided that
[2:17:52]
integral service of
[2:17:54]
communication between the public
[2:17:57]
and the board. And right now
[2:18:00]
donna doesn't have that ability.
[2:18:03]
She hasn't been given the
[2:18:04]
resources. She doesn't have the
[2:18:06]
office, and she's admitted to
[2:18:10]
being given orders to just
[2:18:11]
ignore the public and just keep
[2:18:14]
doing what she's doing. So you
[2:18:18]
would think that someone like
[2:18:19]
katrina foley, dressed to the
[2:18:21]
NINEs in that wonderful
[2:18:23]
bright, loud suit that she's
[2:18:26]
wearing today, matches the
[2:18:28]
lipstick, she looks sharp -- you
[2:18:30]
would think that she would want
[2:18:31]
to make sure that that board was
[2:18:34]
open to communication from the
[2:18:36]
public and able to communicate
[2:18:39]
with her. I mean, she's saying
[2:18:41]
that she doesn't want to ignore
[2:18:42]
people, yet, here she is
[2:18:45]
ordering a county employee to
[2:18:47]
ignore the public. So here I am
[2:18:52]
standing up for a county
[2:18:54]
employee, donna hoard, and even
[2:18:56]
for katrina foley, once again,
[2:18:59]
saying, katrina, this is what
[2:19:00]
you want. This is what you
[2:19:02]
believe in. This is the
[2:19:04]
standard that you are holding
[2:19:06]
out to the public as your own.
[2:19:09]
And we're not here to do
[2:19:12]
anything other than to help you,
[2:19:13]
to advise you and to warn you
[2:19:15]
that what you're doing is not
[2:19:17]
what you say you're doing. And
[2:19:19]
we're here giving you the
[2:19:21]
opportunity to live up to those
[2:19:23]
promises, live up to that bright
[2:19:25]
suit that you're wearing today
[2:19:27]
and follow the laws that you're
[2:19:29]
bragging about doing. Happy day
[2:19:29]
day.
[2:19:31]
>>clerk, robin stieler: no
[2:19:32]
further requests to speak,
[2:19:34]
MR. Chair.
[2:19:34]
>>chair, doug chaffee: all
[2:19:35]
right. This is actually a --
[2:19:40]
this is a "receive and file".
[2:19:46]
Is there any discussion? Any
[2:19:49]
objection to receiving and
[2:19:50]
filing the report? The report
[2:19:53]
shall be received and filed.
[2:19:56]
All right. Now we come to item
[2:19:57]
31.
[2:19:58]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 31.
[2:19:59]
Under vice chair foley-
[2:20:00]
consider second reading and
[2:20:01]
adoption of "an ordinance of the
[2:20:03]
county of orange, california,
[2:20:04]
adding division 22 to title 3,
[2:20:08]
sections 3-22-1 through 3-22-4,
[2:20:10]
relating to the unlawful
[2:20:12]
possession of catalytic
[2:20:13]
converters, to the codified
[2:20:14]
ordinances of the county of
[2:20:15]
orange." we have no requests to
[2:20:17]
speak on agenda item 31.
[2:20:22]
>>chair, doug chaffee: this
[2:20:23]
is -- it was continued before.
[2:20:27]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley:
[2:20:27]
MR. CHAIRMAN.
[2:20:29]
>>chair, doug chaffee:
[2:20:30]
vice-chair, it's your item.
[2:20:31]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank
[2:20:31]
you. I'll move this item. This
[2:20:34]
ordinance, our second reading
[2:20:35]
makes it unlawful in
[2:20:36]
un-incorporated orange county to
[2:20:38]
possess even one detached
[2:20:40]
catalytic converter without
[2:20:42]
proof of ownership. This close
[2:20:45]
as loophole in state law which
[2:20:47]
actually allows you to have nine
[2:20:48]
or more detached catalytic
[2:20:52]
converters without proof
[2:20:53]
ownership. So the ordinance
[2:20:54]
shifts the burden to the
[2:20:56]
possessor, allows the
[2:20:57]
presumption of unlawful
[2:20:58]
possession and treats the
[2:21:00]
converter -- each converter as a
[2:21:02]
separate offense with civil
[2:21:03]
penalties. Thank you to the
[2:21:05]
sheriff's department and
[2:21:06]
district attorney for their
[2:21:07]
support of this ordinance. With
[2:21:08]
that, I move the item.
[2:21:09]
>>chair, doug chaffee: moved and
[2:21:10]
second. Thank you for bringing
[2:21:12]
this forward. There are no
[2:21:14]
objections. The item is
[2:21:15]
approved.
[2:21:16]
>>vincente sarmiento: I was a no
[2:21:17]
during the first reading but I
[2:21:18]
will be a no on this one too.
[2:21:21]
>>chair, doug chaffee: noting
[2:21:22]
the "no" vote. And supplement
[2:21:25]
31a...
[2:21:27]
>>clerk, robin stieler: s31a.
[2:21:27]
Under health care agency-
[2:21:27]
approve amendment 1 to renew
[2:21:28]
master and individual contracts
[2:21:30]
ma042-25010884 for adult peer
[2:21:31]
support wellness and supported
[2:21:33]
employment centers with
[2:21:34]
college community services dba
[2:21:37]
clarvida, central and south, and
[2:21:38]
orange county association for
[2:21:40]
mental health dba mental health
[2:21:42]
association of orange county,
[2:21:43]
west, 7/1/26-6/30/28
[2:21:43]
(Aggregate total $8,200,000;
[2:21:43]
cumulative aggregate total
[2:21:43]
$12,300,000); renewable for one
[2:21:44]
additional two-year term; and
[2:21:44]
authorize county procurement
[2:21:45]
officer or deputized designee to
[2:21:46]
execute amendments. We have no
[2:21:48]
requests to speak on s31a.
[2:21:49]
>>chair, doug chaffee: is a
[2:21:51]
district 1, 2, and 3 item. Any
[2:21:54]
objection? Motion carries.
[2:21:55]
Supplement 31b, please.
[2:21:56]
>>clerk, robin stieler: s31b.
[2:21:57]
Under supervisor sarmiento-
[2:21:58]
orange county behavioral health
[2:22:00]
advisory board-appoint cesilia
[2:22:02]
vega-gonzalez, laguna hills, for
[2:22:07]
ending 3/9/29. And we have no
[2:22:10]
requests to speak on s31b.
[2:22:11]
>>chair, doug chaffee:
[2:22:12]
supervisor sarmiento.
[2:22:14]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley:
[2:22:14]
second.
[2:22:16]
>>chair, doug chaffee: any
[2:22:17]
objection? The point is made.
[2:22:18]
Supplement 31c.
[2:22:19]
>>clerk, robin stieler: s31c.
[2:22:20]
Under supervisor sarmiento-
[2:22:21]
animal care community outreach
[2:22:22]
committee-appoint hollis
[2:22:23]
lenore, fountain valley, for
[2:22:26]
term ending 4/14/26. We have no
[2:22:29]
requests to speak on s31c.
[2:22:29]
>>chair, doug chaffee:
[2:22:32]
supervisor sarmiento? Second.
[2:22:35]
Any objection? There is none.
[2:22:37]
Next we have a series of items
[2:22:39]
being brought forward by the
[2:22:42]
vice-chair. If we could combine
[2:22:44]
d through m and also add q, r,
[2:22:47]
and s, I believe that's all of
[2:22:48]
them. And if the clerk would
[2:23:28]
read those items.
[2:23:29]
>>clerk, robin stieler: s31d.
[2:23:31]
Under vice chair foley-approve
[2:23:32]
allocation of $10,000 from fifth
[2:23:34]
district discretionary funds to
[2:23:34]
parkinson'
[2:23:35]
s exercise program for
[2:23:40]
you; make related findings under
[2:23:42]
government code section 26227;
[2:23:43]
authorize county executive
[2:23:44]
officer or designee to negotiate
[2:23:45]
and enter into agreement as
[2:23:47]
necessary; and authorize
[2:23:48]
auditor-controller or designee
[2:23:58]
to make related payments.
[2:23:58]
>>clerk, robin stieler: s31e.
[2:23:59]
Under vice chair foley-approve
[2:24:00]
allocation of $5,000 from fifth
[2:24:01]
district discretionary funds to
[2:24:01]
san clemente village; make
[2:24:02]
related findings under
[2:24:03]
government code section 26227;
[2:24:04]
authorize county executive
[2:24:04]
officer or designee to negotiate
[2:24:05]
and enter into agreement as
[2:24:06]
necessary; and authorize
[2:24:07]
auditor-controller or designee
[2:24:09]
to make related payments. Under
[2:24:09]
vice chair foley-approve
[2:24:10]
allocation of $5,000 from fifth
[2:24:11]
district discretionary funds to
[2:24:11]
families forward, inc.; make
[2:24:12]
related findings under
[2:24:13]
government code section 26227;
[2:24:13]
authorize county executive
[2:24:14]
officer or designee to negotiate
[2:24:15]
and enter into agreement as
[2:24:16]
necessary; and authorize
[2:24:16]
auditor-controller or designee
[2:24:18]
to make related payments. Under
[2:24:19]
vice chair foley-approve
[2:24:20]
allocation of $5,400 from fifth
[2:24:21]
district discretionary funds to
[2:24:22]
capistrano unified school
[2:24:22]
district: marco forster middle
[2:24:23]
school library; make related
[2:24:23]
findings under government code
[2:24:24]
section 26227; authorize county
[2:24:25]
executive officer or designee to
[2:24:26]
negotiate and enter into
[2:24:27]
agreement as necessary; and
[2:24:27]
authorize auditor-controller
[2:24:31]
or designee to make related payments.
[2:24:31]
under vice chair foley-approve
[2:24:32]
allocation of $103,633 from
[2:24:33]
fifth district discretionary
[2:24:34]
funds to south orange county
[2:24:34]
community theatre dba camino
[2:24:35]
real playhouse; make related
[2:24:37]
findings under government code
[2:24:38]
section 26227; authorize county
[2:24:39]
executive officer or designee to
[2:24:40]
negotiate and enter into
[2:24:41]
agreement as necessary; and
[2:24:41]
authorize auditor-controller
[2:24:44]
or designee to make related payments.
[2:24:47]
And we have no requests to speak
[2:24:48]
on any of these items.
[2:24:49]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: I'll
[2:25:13]
move the items as described.?
[2:25:14]
>>clerk, robin stieler: s31n.
[2:25:14]
Under supervisor wagner-
[2:25:15]
approve sponsorship of various
[2:25:16]
nonprofit entities from third
[2:25:17]
district events funds; approve
[2:25:18]
addition or revision of events
[2:25:18]
to fy 2025-26 county events
[2:25:19]
calendar; make related findings
[2:25:20]
under government code section
[2:25:21]
26227; and authorize
[2:25:21]
auditorcontroller to make
[2:25:25]
related payments. The we have no
[2:25:26]
requests to speak.
[2:25:27]
>>chair, doug chaffee: moved and
[2:25:30]
seconded. Motion is approved.
[2:25:31]
Supplement 31o.
[2:25:32]
>>clerk, robin stieler: s31o.
[2:25:33]
Under supervisor sarmiento-
[2:25:34]
approve sponsorship of various
[2:25:35]
nonprofit entities from second
[2:25:35]
district events funds; approve
[2:25:37]
addition or revision of events
[2:25:37]
to fy 2025-26 county events
[2:25:38]
calendar; make related findings
[2:25:41]
under government code section
[2:25:42]
26227; and authorize
[2:25:42]
auditor-controller to make
[2:25:48]
related payments. And we have no
[2:25:51]
requests to speak on s31o.
[2:25:52]
>>chair, doug chaffee:
[2:25:54]
supervisor sarmiento? Moved and
[2:25:56]
seconded, any objections?
[2:25:59]
Seeing none. Approved. Now we
[2:26:00]
come to supplement 31p.
[2:26:01]
>>clerk, robin stieler: s31p.
[2:26:02]
Under chair chaffee-approve
[2:26:03]
sponsorship of nonprofit
[2:26:03]
ethiopian-american generational
[2:26:04]
bridge organization from fourth
[2:26:06]
district events funds; approve
[2:26:08]
addition or revision of events
[2:26:09]
to fy 2025-26 county events
[2:26:11]
calendar; make related findings
[2:26:13]
under government code section
[2:26:14]
26227; and authorize
[2:26:17]
auditor-controller to make
[2:26:17]
related payments. And MR. Chair,
[2:26:19]
we have received one request to
[2:26:20]
speak on s31p.
[2:26:22]
>>chair, doug chaffee: please
[2:26:22]
call speaker.
[2:26:31]
>>clerk, robin stieler: donora.
[2:26:32]
>>speaker: a lot of problems in
[2:26:45]
the government. Thank GOD I'm
[2:26:45]
still here. What was that
[2:26:49]
again? That number, please?
[2:26:52]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 31p.
[2:26:54]
>>speaker: now, I trust the
[2:26:57]
chair, MR. Chaffee, you can
[2:26:59]
explain it to me that again,
[2:27:02]
that way I can translate into
[2:27:04]
spanish and english and then I
[2:27:06]
can be respond. Thank you.
[2:27:10]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: this
[2:27:10]
item relates to support for
[2:27:13]
ethiopian american generational
[2:27:15]
bridge organization.
[2:27:16]
>>chair, doug chaffee: do you
[2:27:17]
want to speak on that.
[2:27:20]
>>speaker: well, I'm from cuba,
[2:27:25]
not ethiopia. So I pass, but I
[2:27:25]
would like to make an
[2:27:26]
appointment with the chair.
[2:27:27]
>>chair, doug chaffee: that's
[2:27:27]
not part of this item. So.
[2:27:29]
>>speaker: thank you.
[2:27:31]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank you
[2:27:35]
you. Second. Any objection?
[2:27:36]
Motion carries. Now we come to
[2:27:40]
supplement 31t.
[2:27:42]
>>clerk, robin stieler: s31t.
[2:27:43]
Under supervisor sarmiento-
[2:27:45]
approve use of $75,000 from
[2:27:48]
second district, budget control
[2:27:50]
007 to first five orange county
[2:27:52]
for childcare business incubator
[2:27:54]
program; make related findings
[2:27:55]
under government code section
[2:27:57]
26227; authorize county
[2:27:59]
executive officer or designee to
[2:28:01]
negotiate and enter into
[2:28:01]
agreement as necessary; and
[2:28:03]
authorize auditor-controller or
[2:28:04]
designee to make related payments.
[2:28:05]
And we have no if to speak on
[2:28:07]
s31t.
[2:28:11]
>>chair, doug chaffee: any
[2:28:11]
objection? Motion carries. We
[2:28:14]
come to item 32, which is a
[2:28:17]
public hearing.
[2:28:18]
>>clerk, robin stieler: 32.
[2:28:19]
Under county executive office-
[2:28:20]
public hearing to consider
[2:28:21]
adopting resolutions of
[2:28:22]
necessity acquiring by eminent
[2:28:23]
domain easements for silverado
[2:28:25]
canyon road bridge replacement
[2:28:27]
project; authorizing county
[2:28:29]
counsel to retain outside
[2:28:30]
eminent domain counsel bdg law
[2:28:32]
group inc. And initiate
[2:28:33]
condemnation proceedings; and
[2:28:35]
directing and authorizing
[2:28:36]
auditorcontroller to encumber
[2:28:38]
and transfer compensation under
[2:28:39]
certain conditions and making
[2:28:41]
related findings. This item
[2:28:42]
does require a 2/3 vote of the
[2:28:43]
monopoly.
[2:28:43]
>>chair, doug chaffee: let me --
[2:28:43]
vote of the membership.
[2:28:45]
>>chair, doug chaffee: all
[2:28:48]
right, do we have any members
[2:28:49]
who wish to speak.
[2:28:54]
>>clerk, robin stieler: no.
[2:28:55]
>>chair, doug chaffee: I'll
[2:28:57]
bring it back to the board for
[2:28:58]
consideration. This is a
[2:28:59]
district 3 item. Moved and
[2:29:03]
second. Any objection? We have
[2:29:08]
a unanimous vote, so the item is
[2:29:09]
approved. Now we could come at
[2:29:15]
this point to closed sessions.
[2:29:17]
was that -- would you like to do
[2:29:18]
that or -- do public comments?
[2:29:21]
All right. MADAM Clerk, how
[2:29:22]
many public comments do we
[2:29:23]
have.
[2:29:27]
>>clerk, robin stieler: nine.
[2:29:30]
>>chair, doug chaffee: nine. I
[2:29:30]
thought I heard "none." that
[2:29:32]
sounded intriguing, but it's
[2:29:35]
"nine." okay. Would you like
[2:29:41]
to do board comments before
[2:29:43]
closed sessions? We can do
[2:29:44]
that. Let's get to public
[2:29:47]
comments, and then we'll follow
[2:29:49]
with that, okay. Please call
[2:29:51]
the speakers.
[2:29:52]
>>clerk, robin stieler: I'll
[2:29:52]
call three names at a time.
[2:29:53]
Please line up at the center of
[2:29:54]
the room when your name is
[2:29:56]
called behind the podium, steve
[2:29:57]
rocco, paul hayek and greg
[2:30:12]
arrowsmith..
[2:30:14]
>>speaker: if you see something,
[2:30:16]
say something. If you see
[2:30:18]
something, say something. That
[2:30:22]
was a calling cry at last
[2:30:23]
meeting that I spoke out on
[2:30:25]
JANUARY the 27th. Well, I did
[2:30:28]
say something. And I talked
[2:30:30]
about the home inveighs of my
[2:30:32]
home. And at the same time, my
[2:30:36]
home was being invaded. How
[2:30:37]
about that? And by pretty much
[2:30:40]
the same people. Let's see, my
[2:30:44]
grass is too high, I got bugs.
[2:30:49]
Plus, I owe the city over
[2:30:52]
$16,000 for a water bill. What
[2:30:54]
does that sound like to you? It
[2:30:56]
sounds like persecution,
[2:30:57]
prosecution. Sounds like
[2:30:59]
special prosecution. Sounds
[2:31:01]
like a special project. You
[2:31:03]
went to the fbi to get rid of
[2:31:07]
do. Why aren't you going to the
[2:31:08]
fbi to get rid of spitzer?
[2:31:12]
who's a sexual pervert. Prove
[2:31:16]
it. Hates christians. Hates
[2:31:19]
christians. Pulled a gun on
[2:31:21]
one. And yet that's okay with
[2:31:24]
you. Because criminal
[2:31:26]
politicians are okay with ooh
[2:31:28]
guys. You know, over the united
[2:31:31]
states supreme court in
[2:31:32]
washington D.C. There's a sign
[2:31:35]
which says "equal justice under
[2:31:37]
the law." this does not mean
[2:31:40]
equality in all things. It
[2:31:42]
doesn't mean you can go to the
[2:31:44]
same bathroom as me if you're
[2:31:45]
not the same gender. It means
[2:31:48]
equality under the law. You
[2:31:50]
have the same political rights.
[2:31:53]
Political rights is something
[2:31:56]
else, okay. Diversity and
[2:32:00]
equality are not the same thing.
[2:32:04]
Diversity gives an empire.
[2:32:07]
Washington D.C. Was built to
[2:32:09]
look like rome. Marvel --
[2:32:15]
marble, columns, and the whole
[2:32:15]
shebang. And equality means
[2:32:18]
sameness. Similarity.. Nation
[2:32:25]
and empire are not the same
[2:32:27]
thing. Uncle sam loves
[2:32:31]
diversity because you're not
[2:32:33]
going to be a majority. And the
[2:32:36]
government will tell you what to
[2:32:37]
do, not vice-versa. You can't
[2:32:41]
have it both ways. You can't
[2:32:44]
have it both ways. They are
[2:32:46]
contradicter to. It's
[2:32:49]
either/or. Uncle sam's
[2:32:50]
diversity or sameness, a nation,
[2:32:54]
a real nation. And you know
[2:32:57]
what, it's people like me who
[2:32:58]
are being discriminated against
[2:33:00]
today. White christian males,
[2:33:03]
number one on the list.
[2:33:05]
Equality, take a look at the
[2:33:06]
sports. I couldn't find a white
[2:33:09]
face there for the entire last
[2:33:20]
week.S.
[2:33:22]
>>speaker: good afternoon. Good
[2:33:25]
morning, I mean. We need to
[2:33:27]
make sure these new operators
[2:33:29]
for these shelters are make them
[2:33:36]
wear they're -- where they are
[2:33:40]
walk in/walk out. Why don't we
[2:33:41]
hire those that have the trades
[2:33:42]
to help run the place? Because
[2:33:46]
they'd be glad to help run it
[2:33:48]
and make minimum wage. Let's
[2:33:52]
see them turn this place around.
[2:33:55]
Remember, back in '17 I was
[2:34:00]
advocating for the homeless
[2:34:02]
shelter in anaheim. I was there
[2:34:05]
when they dedicated it. I was
[2:34:07]
there for eight months, and
[2:34:09]
mercy house has to go. And the
[2:34:12]
one in santa ana is being run by
[2:34:15]
a foreign company. They're not
[2:34:17]
even a U.S.. And mercy house is
[2:34:20]
run by a hawaiian with hawaiian
[2:34:23]
security.
[2:34:29]
>>clerk, robin stieler: the next
[2:34:29]
three superiors are donora, l
[2:34:32]
uci daniel and nicole nguyen.
[2:34:36]
>>speaker: presentation z mailed
[2:34:42]
to the usdoj, california brown
[2:34:42]
act of 1953, forcing local
[2:34:45]
government agencies to be
[2:34:46]
transparent with the tax paying
[2:34:47]
citizens. Had an introduction
[2:34:48]
meeting with sheriff chad dee
[2:34:52]
bianco, government candidate and
[2:34:53]
michael gates, attorney general
[2:34:54]
candidate at the elks lodge in
[2:34:56]
santa ana last tuesday night.
[2:34:58]
They were both real, genuine and
[2:34:59]
approachable guys that have the
[2:35:01]
resume
[2:35:02]
and experience to make
[2:35:03]
california golden again. They
[2:35:04]
are eager to put their words
[2:35:06]
into action for the best
[2:35:08]
interest of californians.
[2:35:09]
Focus, offender recidivism and
[2:35:12]
re-entry in the united states,
[2:35:15]
crime in america net leonard
[2:35:16]
adam signs junior 2026, U.S.
[2:35:18]
Department of justice bureau of
[2:35:20]
justice statistics 68% of
[2:35:23]
prisoners were released with a
[2:35:25]
new arrest within three years
[2:35:26]
and 77% in five years.
[2:35:31]
California correctional
[2:35:32]
facilities issues from colleges
[2:35:38]
of law.Edu, overcrowding and
[2:35:39]
inadequate handling of
[2:35:41]
complaints and violence within
[2:35:43]
the system. California
[2:35:44]
correctional facilities remain
[2:35:47]
over capacity which affects
[2:35:48]
safety and rehabilitation
[2:35:49]
efforts. Overcrowding leads to
[2:35:52]
increased violence and undermine
[2:35:53]
security measures. Problem,
[2:35:56]
there are three hours of actual
[2:35:57]
work assignments and or
[2:35:58]
educational programs that an
[2:36:00]
inmate will accomplish in a
[2:36:02]
15-hour day, according to the
[2:36:03]
typical daily schedule for
[2:36:05]
inmates in the california
[2:36:06]
correctional facilities. In
[2:36:08]
other words, the typical daily
[2:36:09]
schedule focuses more on a day
[2:36:12]
camp schedule for criminal
[2:36:13]
versus a work schedule to
[2:36:15]
prepare him or her to be
[2:36:17]
productive tax paying citizens
[2:36:18]
in society. The overcrowding
[2:36:20]
and violence in these facilities
[2:36:21]
makes sense due to these inmates
[2:36:23]
have too much time on their
[2:36:25]
hands for shenanigans. It
[2:36:27]
appears that the offenders'
[2:36:29]
behavior will accept returning
[2:36:30]
back to a correctional facility
[2:36:32]
knowing that he or she has a
[2:36:33]
criminal day camp waiting for
[2:36:36]
him or her. Solution, as a tax
[2:36:38]
paying citizens I'd like to have
[2:36:39]
the opportunity to revise a
[2:36:41]
typical daily schedule for
[2:36:42]
inmates. These inmates,
[2:36:43]
prisons, jails, juvenile
[2:36:45]
detentions should be working
[2:36:46]
eight hours a day for five days
[2:36:47]
a week. They will be allowed to
[2:36:49]
have a daily 30-minute lunch and
[2:36:51]
two 15-minute breaks to be
[2:36:53]
complying with california labor
[2:36:54]
laws. The inmates will execute
[2:36:56]
a self development and
[2:36:57]
educational class during day 6
[2:37:00]
and 7 and after work. The goal
[2:37:02]
is to have the california
[2:37:03]
correctional facilities execute
[2:37:05]
a curriculum that will motivate
[2:37:06]
the inmates to not want to go
[2:37:08]
back to a correctional facility
[2:37:10]
ever again in a lifetime.
[2:37:12]
Temporary housing, dorms,
[2:37:14]
continued education and job
[2:37:15]
placement during the inmate
[2:37:17]
release program is crucial to
[2:37:19]
get him or her heading towards
[2:37:22]
the right direction for success.
[2:37:27]
>>chair, doug chaffee: MAY we
[2:37:28]
have the next speaker, please.
[2:37:34]
>>speaker: thank you, again.
[2:37:36]
Just want to say I still have
[2:37:38]
love for all you guys being a
[2:37:40]
christian pentecostal parent and
[2:37:43]
pastor be pentecostal and my
[2:37:45]
father was an architect. We
[2:37:47]
went to church seven days a week
[2:37:49]
to keep us focused from the
[2:37:51]
communists. I got sick from a
[2:37:53]
hearing, then it was government.
[2:38:01]
Not america. It was depraved
[2:38:03]
house, discriminated and I have
[2:38:05]
my alien number. This number
[2:38:09]
congress will now that they
[2:38:09]
brought me from cuba, supposed
[2:38:11]
to be protected under federal
[2:38:14]
statute and still today. So the
[2:38:20]
government has -- I'm praying
[2:38:20]
that they focus on illegal
[2:38:23]
immigrant U.S. Citizens that
[2:38:25]
work and pay taxes. Many
[2:38:28]
people, you see it in the media,
[2:38:30]
they are not legal. They are
[2:38:32]
aggressive against police
[2:38:34]
officer and I.C.E., and I'm
[2:38:36]
crying what the heck went wrong
[2:38:38]
in orange county that we grew up
[2:38:40]
in orange county, went to orange
[2:38:42]
high school where america taught
[2:38:45]
us how to speak english. There
[2:38:47]
was no one from mexico, with all
[2:38:49]
due respect, running orange
[2:38:51]
county back in 1969. So I'm
[2:38:54]
requesting our origin -- an
[2:38:55]
urgent appointment with the
[2:38:57]
chair doug chaffee as soon as
[2:39:00]
possible and, again, the chief
[2:39:03]
janet nguyen refuse to make me
[2:39:06]
an appointment. And you guys
[2:39:08]
have seen me since 2018 and 19.
[2:39:11]
And thank GOD I'm a great human
[2:39:13]
being to guiding other people
[2:39:14]
that are still standing. So
[2:39:17]
please it's urgent an
[2:39:18]
appointment with doug chaffee be
[2:39:21]
blessed in hoping to make
[2:39:22]
america great for all of us. If
[2:39:24]
you don't fix it, this will
[2:39:25]
never be the united states of
[2:39:27]
america anymore. My parents are
[2:39:31]
in heaven. They are the reason
[2:39:33]
why we are here, they prepare
[2:39:35]
possible under kennedy. We
[2:39:38]
waited, and thank GOD we here.
[2:39:40]
But this is not the country that
[2:39:41]
we grow up. But we still have
[2:39:43]
love for you guys. You.
[2:39:47]
>>chair, doug chaffee: the next
[2:39:48]
speaker, please.
[2:39:48]
>>clerk, robin stieler: l uci
[2:39:49]
daniel and nicole nguyen.
[2:39:54]
>>speaker: hello. I'm here to
[2:40:01]
explain that I am a home care
[2:40:02]
provider with ihss for 14 years.
[2:40:05]
I take care of my mom for 14
[2:40:07]
years, and I do everything for
[2:40:11]
her. She cannot live by
[2:40:12]
herself. She's 92. And her
[2:40:15]
mind strong, but she is very
[2:40:16]
weak for her age. And she needs
[2:40:21]
help with everything. I cook
[2:40:23]
for her. I clean. I bathe her,
[2:40:27]
I MAY being sure she takes her
[2:40:28]
medication. I take her to the
[2:40:31]
doctor's, sometimes I take her
[2:40:33]
out to the store. That's what
[2:40:35]
she likes to do mostly, to go
[2:40:36]
shopping. And I'm just
[2:40:40]
explaining that because we don't
[2:40:44]
get paid very much, but it helps
[2:40:46]
us to stay with the people we
[2:40:49]
take care of. Like it helps me
[2:40:50]
to stay home with my mom because
[2:40:53]
of the ihss program because I
[2:40:56]
can be -- I'm a certified
[2:40:59]
paralegal. I could have a job
[2:41:02]
like I used to work with the
[2:41:04]
lawyers, and making a lot more
[2:41:06]
money. But I chose this because
[2:41:08]
I love my mom, and I have to
[2:41:11]
take care of her, or -- I don't
[2:41:13]
want to put her in a nursing
[2:41:14]
home because she gets very
[2:41:16]
depressed when she thinks about
[2:41:17]
what if she goes to a nursing
[2:41:19]
home. And that's not a good
[2:41:22]
thing for her, but she's healthy
[2:41:25]
and her mind is strong because
[2:41:27]
of my care. And I just want to
[2:41:30]
make sure that we try to keep
[2:41:31]
the ihss program for the
[2:41:36]
disabled and the elderly.
[2:41:39]
They're better off at home than
[2:41:41]
a nurse home. That's all I'm
[2:41:42]
saying. And when my mom's had
[2:41:47]
to go for therapy to a nursing
[2:41:49]
home, she just cried almost
[2:41:51]
every day. She was so
[2:41:52]
depressed. It's better if they
[2:41:55]
stay home. So thank you for
[2:41:57]
your time.
[2:42:01]
>>clerk, robin stieler: after
[2:42:02]
nicole, the last three speakers
[2:42:04]
are katherine louie, andrew and
[2:42:06]
brian kay.
[2:42:07]
>>speaker: good morning, board.
[2:42:09]
I am nicole nguyen, and I'm an
[2:42:11]
ihss provider. I live -- I have
[2:42:17]
been a provider for five years.
[2:42:19]
I care for my cousin, my first
[2:42:21]
cousin. I'm a resident of santa
[2:42:24]
ana and district 2. What I do
[2:42:28]
for my cousin -- and what I care
[2:42:31]
for my cousin, I MAY being sure
[2:42:33]
that she take her medication on
[2:42:36]
time and make sure she has her
[2:42:39]
refill medication on time too.
[2:42:42]
She is 83 years old. She's not
[2:42:45]
healthy, not physically and not
[2:42:48]
mentally. I care for her. I
[2:42:51]
MAY being sure she can eat. She
[2:42:53]
cannot eat likely, she can have
[2:42:55]
proper food, and I gotta help
[2:42:59]
her in and out of my car for
[2:43:00]
doctors, pharmacist or anywhere
[2:43:03]
she want to go. My work, my
[2:43:06]
helping her is very important,
[2:43:09]
that allow her to stay home and
[2:43:12]
be comfortable with respect. I
[2:43:17]
really appreciate the ihss
[2:43:19]
program to allow me to take care
[2:43:23]
of my cousin. And
[2:43:39]
>>speaker: I'd like to provide a
[2:43:39]
little help. My name is
[2:43:47]
katherine louie. I'm a proud
[2:43:48]
member of udw. And I'm an ihss
[2:43:51]
provider. I live in the city of
[2:43:53]
cota decause sarc I've been a
[2:43:54]
provider for 17 years, and I
[2:43:56]
take care of my beautiful boy,
[2:43:58]
as you can see. He is 19 years
[2:44:01]
old -- he is 19 years old, and
[2:44:07]
I've cared for him since the day
[2:44:09]
he was born. I just like to
[2:44:11]
share a little bit about my
[2:44:12]
story with you. I worked prior
[2:44:15]
in the corporate world for many
[2:44:17]
years doing everything --
[2:44:19]
complete op assistant medical.
[2:44:21]
I never did anything like that.
[2:44:22]
My son was born with profound
[2:44:24]
needs requiring 24 hours care.
[2:44:26]
I knew nothing about this, so I
[2:44:29]
relied on the doctors and nurses
[2:44:31]
and therapists and everyone else
[2:44:33]
to tell me what to do and how to
[2:44:35]
take care of my son. I has
[2:44:37]
profound needs, like I said,
[2:44:39]
requiring 24 hours care. He is
[2:44:42]
blind. He's non-verbal. He is
[2:44:45]
fed through a tube. I take care
[2:44:47]
of all of his living activities
[2:44:50]
that he does. And as time went
[2:44:53]
on, I started questioning
[2:44:55]
things. And this program has
[2:44:57]
allowed me to -- was able to
[2:45:00]
allow me to stay home with him,
[2:45:02]
to do research, to find out what
[2:45:06]
I can better do. So the first
[2:45:08]
thing is -- one of the things is
[2:45:09]
my son -- they told me when he
[2:45:11]
was very young and he was in the
[2:45:13]
hospital for all of the time for
[2:45:15]
the first three years of his
[2:45:16]
life, that's all I did, was in
[2:45:19]
the hospital. He has a seizure
[2:45:20]
disorder. And he was on
[2:45:22]
multiple medications for that.
[2:45:25]
they just don't work, so they
[2:45:26]
would add another one, another
[2:45:28]
one. So I was okay with that.
[2:45:30]
He was fed through ag tube.
[2:45:31]
Every time offer stopped nursing
[2:45:34]
him, he would -- he had to
[2:45:39]
receive nutrition, medical-grade
[2:45:42]
nutrition. Every time I put it,
[2:45:44]
in he would throw it up. So one
[2:45:47]
day decided to start feeding him
[2:45:48]
with homemade food. I just
[2:45:50]
decided why don't I blend
[2:45:51]
something and put it. Heaven's
[2:45:53]
forbid, he started eating, he
[2:45:55]
was able to keep it down. Real
[2:45:56]
food kept it down. Then I said
[2:45:59]
why do you want me to keep
[2:46:01]
adding more seizure meds. They
[2:46:02]
don't work. I researched
[2:46:04]
alternative medications, seizure
[2:46:07]
medications. And they started
[2:46:10]
working. So I started taking
[2:46:11]
them away. And most of these
[2:46:13]
doctors you all know. Thomas is
[2:46:15]
a child of choc hospital and you
[2:46:17]
will of a the specialty there is
[2:46:20]
and they do great with him, but
[2:46:22]
he has thrived because I have
[2:46:24]
been allowed to stay home and
[2:46:26]
take care of him. They told me
[2:46:27]
he would never walk. After he
[2:46:29]
stopped throwing up and having
[2:46:30]
seizures, guess what, he walked.
[2:46:32]
We walked into the doctors, and
[2:46:36]
I would think they would run
[2:46:37]
down the hall going, oh, my GOD,
[2:46:40]
what did you do. He's in a much
[2:46:41]
better way because of this
[2:46:42]
program, and I'd like you to
[2:46:44]
consider doing what you can to
[2:46:46]
keep this program to allow
[2:46:48]
people to take care of their
[2:46:49]
loved ones.
[2:46:51]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank you
[2:46:52]
you.
[2:46:54]
>>clerk, robin stieler: andrew
[2:46:54]
and brian kay.
[2:47:09]
>>speaker: hello. I'm andrew,
[2:47:09]
as you know. I just want to say
[2:47:13]
I was here at beginning, and
[2:47:16]
man, I give you guys props for
[2:47:17]
what you guys do. It can be
[2:47:18]
pretty intense. This is my
[2:47:21]
first public meeting. So I am
[2:47:24]
not as experienced as many of
[2:47:27]
you in this. So it is my first.
[2:47:32]
I'll do my best. I just have
[2:47:36]
three topics that I want to
[2:47:38]
start with. First off, one of
[2:47:42]
the gentleman before me had
[2:47:45]
mentioned shelters. There's a
[2:47:50]
few agenda ago. I just want to
[2:47:53]
go off of that because a lot of
[2:47:55]
times nonprofit organization try
[2:47:57]
to do their best to get their
[2:47:58]
grants, right, and make sure
[2:48:02]
that the community and everybody
[2:48:04]
within the community is able to
[2:48:06]
help set these places up.
[2:48:13]
What's point if you don't even
[2:48:14]
know what you're putting your
[2:48:15]
money into let alone at least go
[2:48:19]
and see it for yourself, right.
[2:48:21]
I know that if I'm going to go
[2:48:22]
to a donation center or
[2:48:23]
somewhere, I walk around and
[2:48:25]
view it and look at it, and then
[2:48:27]
I put my money down, and go,
[2:48:28]
hey, this program is helping
[2:48:30]
kids, right. Many of the
[2:48:33]
programs that I've been to
[2:48:34]
personally experiencing
[2:48:36]
homelessness and going to
[2:48:38]
shelters, they do a thing with
[2:48:41]
favoritism, and it's very, very
[2:48:43]
sad because if somebody is not
[2:48:46]
to your liking or they don't
[2:48:48]
like your attitude or they don't
[2:48:49]
like something about you,
[2:48:53]
basically you're screwed, and
[2:48:54]
it's back to the streets. And I
[2:48:57]
don't know if you guys are aware
[2:48:58]
of this, but a lot of these
[2:48:59]
shelter and a lot of these
[2:49:00]
places had a really long waiting
[2:49:02]
list just to get in, so it's
[2:49:04]
very sad on seeing that. And so
[2:49:08]
even the ones that are
[2:49:15]
non-shelters such as orangewood
[2:49:16]
donation foundation in santa
[2:49:19]
ana, they do good work, but,
[2:49:21]
again, it's a lot of favoritism,
[2:49:25]
and it's very, very sad. And we
[2:49:27]
need to seriously do something
[2:49:28]
about this, you guys. It's very
[2:49:30]
serious. We're not here to put
[2:49:32]
money in and go in a work place
[2:49:35]
and take every little thing that
[2:49:38]
we see as personal aspect,
[2:49:42]
because when you're in a
[2:49:43]
workplace, it requires and
[2:49:45]
involves professionalism. Not
[2:49:48]
how you feel, not how much of a
[2:49:50]
bad day you had at home. Please
[2:49:52]
don't bring what you have at
[2:49:53]
home into your workspace,
[2:49:55]
especially as shelters when
[2:49:57]
we're trying to help people not
[2:49:59]
break them back down and push
[2:50:00]
them back in the streets. All
[2:50:02]
right. Thank you guys.
[2:50:03]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank
[2:50:04]
you.
[2:50:07]
>>clerk, robin stieler: brian
[2:50:20]
kay.
[2:50:27]
>>speaker: happy day. Earlier
[2:50:27]
in the meeting katrina foley
[2:50:29]
realized that she had made a
[2:50:30]
mistake, and she wanted to go
[2:50:32]
back and correct her mistake.
[2:50:35]
And recast her vote. That's
[2:50:38]
basically the first amendment
[2:50:39]
right there. You redress the
[2:50:42]
grievance. So you would think
[2:50:45]
that in the criminal case she'd
[2:50:47]
look at it and go, hey, brian
[2:50:48]
cark doesn't know where I live,
[2:50:50]
so even if I think he really
[2:50:51]
threatened me, it doesn't rise
[2:50:53]
to the level of a crime. You'd
[2:50:56]
that I she'd be able to ask
[2:50:57]
vincent sarmiento, a defense
[2:51:00]
attorney, if that was the truth,
[2:51:04]
and that vince would be able to
[2:51:05]
stand up for the truth. You
[2:51:07]
don't have to stand up for me,
[2:51:09]
vince. You can hate me all the
[2:51:10]
want but I think that you would
[2:51:13]
stand up for the constitution
[2:51:14]
and the raw and that you would
[2:51:18]
help katrina foley not be
[2:51:20]
afraid. It's amazing, narsisco
[2:51:25]
ber rang oh, the gentleman who
[2:51:26]
fathered three children who were
[2:51:28]
marine veterans, you went to
[2:51:30]
court to get him -- get that
[2:51:35]
whole matter resolved. There's
[2:51:37]
a picture of you in the paper
[2:51:38]
walking out the courthouse right
[2:51:40]
there next to him. You
[2:51:43]
supported him. You endorsed
[2:51:45]
him. You worked to help get him
[2:51:47]
free. And it's a shame because
[2:51:50]
we have families right here to
[2:51:53]
petition you to not be forced
[2:51:57]
into family court without having
[2:51:59]
their petitions addressed.
[2:51:59]
Please realize you had to --
[2:52:00]
their petitions redressed.
[2:52:01]
Please realize you had to stand
[2:52:02]
over julie, you had to step over
[2:52:05]
me, who's filed a petition to
[2:52:10]
help narsisco. I'm not saying
[2:52:14]
it's bad. As a matter of fact,
[2:52:15]
thank you for helping him, but
[2:52:18]
realize that you had to walk
[2:52:20]
over, you had to tread over your
[2:52:23]
own constituents.
[2:52:25]
You know, you're all complaining
[2:52:26]
about I.C.E.. You're doing the
[2:52:28]
same thing as I.C.E. You have
[2:52:30]
police who are undertrained,
[2:52:33]
overviolent, committing crimes
[2:52:34]
against the people. You ignore
[2:52:36]
the petitions from the people,
[2:52:39]
and then you allow the police to
[2:52:40]
do what they've done. Vince,
[2:52:43]
could you help me with my issue.
[2:52:46]
You have chosen not to. And
[2:52:51]
lastly, honorable spitzer, he
[2:52:52]
lost a second lawsuit. There's
[2:52:55]
about eight more. And the
[2:52:57]
really sad thing is that all of
[2:52:59]
you are implicated. You know,
[2:53:01]
probably the saddest one is,
[2:53:02]
again, katrina foley, who has a
[2:53:04]
law firm dedicated to protecting
[2:53:06]
employees from abusive employers
[2:53:07]
was found to be an abusive
[2:53:10]
employer. And rather than
[2:53:12]
stopping this abusive behavior,
[2:53:14]
she's gonna do it eight more
[2:53:16]
times. I wish better for you.
[2:53:20]
Happy day.
[2:53:21]
>>clerk, robin stieler: no
[2:53:22]
further requests to speak,
[2:53:23]
MR. Chair.
[2:53:24]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank
[2:53:24]
you. Now we'll go to board
[2:53:26]
comments. Would any board
[2:53:27]
member like to speak?
[2:53:29]
Supervisor nguyen.
[2:53:29]
>>janet nguyen: thank you. I
[2:53:31]
have a few items to make
[2:53:34]
comments on. One, I wanted to,
[2:53:37]
again, thank you, the ceo and
[2:53:41]
also doug from oc care, who
[2:53:45]
attended our hud senior
[2:53:46]
officials meeting last week.
[2:53:50]
This came about because of my
[2:53:52]
trip to washington D.C. And, you
[2:53:55]
know, it's -- we were inquiring
[2:53:57]
about receiving additional
[2:53:58]
funding for our homeless efforts
[2:54:00]
and, so last week they came out,
[2:54:03]
they originally were actually
[2:54:05]
just going to stop by L.A. And
[2:54:07]
san diego, but because of our
[2:54:09]
trip to D.C., they stopped by
[2:54:12]
orange county. I don't remember
[2:54:14]
the last time hud actually came
[2:54:16]
to orange county, at least not
[2:54:18]
at the time that I remembered,
[2:54:20]
my first two terms on this
[2:54:22]
board. And since I've been
[2:54:24]
back. So it actually was very
[2:54:26]
exciting that we were able to
[2:54:27]
get home to orange county to
[2:54:29]
visit us. We toured the oc
[2:54:32]
rescue mission, homeless shelter
[2:54:33]
in tustin. It is a private
[2:54:36]
state of the art facility with a
[2:54:37]
high successive rate of
[2:54:39]
rehabilitation. Hud was very
[2:54:43]
impressed what they saw and, you
[2:54:45]
know, what I gather and -- is
[2:54:47]
that they highly encourage us to
[2:54:51]
apply for the funding that's
[2:54:52]
coming up with the nofa, that's
[2:54:55]
coming up. You know, they're
[2:54:56]
refocusing on homeless policy on
[2:54:59]
treatment, recovery, and
[2:55:01]
self-sufficiency. And so it's
[2:55:03]
actually, you know, exciting,
[2:55:05]
and I really appreciate your
[2:55:06]
comments at the meeting,
[2:55:07]
MR. CHAIRMAN, and sharing your
[2:55:08]
prevention solutions. I think
[2:55:11]
they -- their eyes were really
[2:55:13]
wide open when they heard about
[2:55:14]
it and couldn't believe that,
[2:55:15]
you know, such a program exists.
[2:55:17]
And, you know, the ceo
[2:55:19]
mentioned about the encampment
[2:55:23]
of, you know, from -- in 2018,
[2:55:25]
the clearing of the encampment,
[2:55:27]
whether it's the santa ana river
[2:55:28]
trail or the plaza of the flags
[2:55:31]
and how the county has helped
[2:55:35]
assist hundreds of individuals.
[2:55:36]
And so we'll continue to
[2:55:38]
communicate with hud and, you
[2:55:40]
know, I want to continue to
[2:55:41]
offer that orange county can be
[2:55:43]
a statewide leader in solving
[2:55:44]
the homeless crisis unlike other
[2:55:46]
counties. And they did mention
[2:55:49]
that the nofa coming up will be
[2:55:50]
very competitive. It's not
[2:55:52]
gonna be, you know, just because
[2:55:54]
you received it in the past you
[2:55:55]
will get it, and that's why
[2:55:56]
there's a lot of angst all
[2:55:58]
across the country, because most
[2:56:00]
folks depend on these fundings.
[2:56:01]
But they want measures --
[2:56:07]
measurements to be included.
[2:56:08]
And so I'm excited. And again,
[2:56:10]
thank you, MR. CHAIRMAN, and
[2:56:11]
thank you to the ceo and also
[2:56:13]
doug. It was friday evening.
[2:56:15]
Didn't finish to a little close
[2:56:20]
to 9:00 or past 9:00 P.M.. So I
[2:56:21]
really appreciate you being part
[2:56:23]
of it. The other -- couple of
[2:56:26]
other things is I want to thank
[2:56:27]
doug and his staff and the
[2:56:31]
thousand volunteers on the point
[2:56:34]
in time count. This past --
[2:56:37]
couple of weeks ago now. This
[2:56:39]
is very important to us. So the
[2:56:41]
data is essential to access --
[2:56:43]
assess our coach homelessness
[2:56:45]
and whether we as a county has
[2:56:47]
done well or not or what each
[2:56:50]
city has done, if it has worked
[2:56:53]
or not. As we know, in 2024, we
[2:56:58]
had 7,322 homeless individuals,
[2:57:02]
which, you know, was an increase
[2:57:03]
from 2022 by 37%, and we did not
[2:57:09]
do any count in '23 or '25. And
[2:57:11]
so this count something going to
[2:57:13]
be important for us to see what
[2:57:14]
has been done since '24.
[2:57:16]
Whether our programs or the
[2:57:18]
city's programs have worked or
[2:57:20]
not worked, and whether we
[2:57:21]
continue those programs or stop
[2:57:24]
those programs, and we look at
[2:57:25]
whether, you know, it's -- what
[2:57:28]
to do going forward. And so I
[2:57:29]
really appreciate the city of
[2:57:31]
fountain valley because I joined
[2:57:32]
them, the team of the officers,
[2:57:34]
at my square park, and we drove
[2:57:36]
around in fountain valley to
[2:57:37]
look and talk to a lot of
[2:57:40]
individuals. And it's very
[2:57:42]
eye-opening to see what's
[2:57:43]
happening there, especially in
[2:57:45]
the evening. And so, again,
[2:57:48]
thank you to doug, the oc cares
[2:57:52]
staff and also the thousand of
[2:57:54]
volunteers that came out to help
[2:57:58]
at that -- to help. And last, I
[2:58:01]
just also want to thank the
[2:58:04]
board for celebrating lunar new
[2:58:06]
year with us. We had a great
[2:58:08]
time at the board meeting, and
[2:58:11]
lots of comments and
[2:58:13]
conversations of folks.
[2:58:16]
Appreciate the board for
[2:58:16]
continuing to recognize lunar
[2:58:19]
new year, particularly in our
[2:58:20]
district, would be for tet. And
[2:58:24]
I was also able to participate
[2:58:26]
in a lot of lunar new year
[2:58:28]
events in the district.
[2:58:31]
And I can say that, you know, I
[2:58:34]
want to give a shout-out to my
[2:58:34]
staff that a whole week and a
[2:58:37]
half was exhausting for us. We,
[2:58:40]
you know, when new year's eve
[2:58:42]
events, temple run, which, you
[2:58:44]
know, a lot of us got back at
[2:58:47]
probably 1:30 in the morning.
[2:58:49]
And so really appreciate my
[2:58:51]
staff for hanging in there and,
[2:58:53]
even though it was raining on
[2:58:55]
us, as well, for being out
[2:58:57]
there, for being troopers and
[2:58:58]
then into -- being a part the
[2:59:02]
tet parade this past weekend in
[2:59:03]
westminster and appreciate all
[2:59:09]
of their support and all of the
[2:59:10]
volunteers that came out to help
[2:59:11]
us in the parade as well, and
[2:59:13]
thank you to this board for the
[2:59:15]
recognition of lunar new year
[2:59:17]
and tet in orange county. Thank
[2:59:19]
you, MR. CHAIRMAN.
[2:59:20]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank
[2:59:20]
you, supervisor. Vice-chair.
[2:59:26]
>>v. Chair, katrina foley: thank
[2:59:26]
you, MR. CHAIRMAN. And, yes,
[2:59:29]
this -- I feel like this year
[2:59:30]
has been the most celebrated
[2:59:32]
lunar new year of anytime I've
[2:59:35]
ever seen in our whole county.
[2:59:36]
So it's wonderful, so many
[2:59:38]
colorful, joyful celebration,
[2:59:41]
and thanks for bringing all of
[2:59:42]
the decorations to the sixth
[2:59:43]
floor and the nice treats that
[2:59:46]
you shared with us at our lunch
[2:59:49]
meeting last time. So lots of
[2:59:51]
things to celebrate here in
[2:59:52]
orange county. One thing -- one
[2:59:55]
issue that has been percolating
[2:59:57]
in our district is the san juan
[3:00:03]
creek channels. I want to thank
[3:00:03]
orange county public works and
[3:00:06]
our agricultural commissioner
[3:00:09]
for the time expended and the
[3:00:12]
deep dive in briefing with my
[3:00:14]
time on all of the county's san
[3:00:16]
juan and trabuco creeks and
[3:00:17]
maintenance plans, the different
[3:00:18]
ways we manage our channels, the
[3:00:20]
history of managing our channels
[3:00:22]
and the use of herbicides
[3:00:24]
specifically in our flood
[3:00:26]
channels. So the community has
[3:00:30]
been communicating with us quite
[3:00:31]
a bit about the san juan and
[3:00:34]
trabuco creeks. And as our team
[3:00:37]
knows well, I'm very much
[3:00:39]
opposed to herbicides in our
[3:00:40]
public spaces and our waterways.
[3:00:43]
I share -- I've shared many of
[3:00:44]
these concerns and all of the
[3:00:47]
questions that we are receiving
[3:00:48]
with our orange county public
[3:00:49]
works team and I'll continue
[3:00:51]
engaging with our county staff
[3:00:53]
on different alternatives. We
[3:00:56]
want to assure the public that
[3:01:02]
round-up/gliff say the, has not
[3:01:02]
been applied to the tra bush oh
[3:01:04]
or san juan creek flued channels
[3:01:06]
eyewitness news since JANUARY of
[3:01:09]
2025, the reason we know that is
[3:01:14]
because we received complaints
[3:01:15]
in JANUARY of 2025. Formal
[3:01:17]
complaints were made. An
[3:01:19]
investigation ensued. And
[3:01:21]
because we take these complaints
[3:01:23]
seriously, the investigation
[3:01:25]
found that the contractor was
[3:01:27]
not in compliance, and then our
[3:01:30]
county staff acted decisively.
[3:01:34]
Gliff say the has not been used
[3:01:35]
since then and not be applied
[3:01:37]
those channels again.
[3:01:39]
Glyfhosate. The county is only
[3:01:41]
approved to apply state water
[3:01:42]
board and epa approved
[3:01:44]
herbicides to vegetation and
[3:01:48]
flood control channels. And the
[3:01:50]
reason for that is so that
[3:01:52]
people don't experience flooding
[3:01:53]
in their homes. This channel
[3:01:55]
was developed and house built
[3:01:58]
and commercial retail built all
[3:02:01]
along it, and so it's a bagging
[3:02:04]
act to protect the homes from
[3:02:07]
flooding and keep the vegetation
[3:02:09]
out in a way that is respectful
[3:02:12]
of, you know, the humans and the
[3:02:14]
natural habitat that live in the
[3:02:17]
channel like fish. So we have
[3:02:20]
been following the protocols for
[3:02:22]
diluting the application to
[3:02:24]
ensure it remains as safe as
[3:02:25]
possible for humans, and we'll
[3:02:28]
continue to try to balance the
[3:02:31]
environmental needs, including
[3:02:33]
researching cost-effective
[3:02:35]
alternatives. I had a
[3:02:38]
discussion with county staff
[3:02:40]
yesterday about some
[3:02:41]
alternatives that I'm hoping
[3:02:42]
that we can research and pursue.
[3:02:44]
But also with the thought in
[3:02:48]
neighborhood we have to protect
[3:02:49]
the property and the people from
[3:02:51]
the threat of flooding. So if
[3:02:53]
you have questions for our
[3:02:55]
office or public works or the
[3:02:57]
healthcare agency, you can come
[3:02:58]
to our town hall. The town hall
[3:03:00]
is on monday MARCH 2nd at 6:00
[3:03:03]
P.M.. Please rsvp, and you can
[3:03:07]
contact our office to do so.
[3:03:09]
And you can contact public works
[3:03:11]
for any additional inquiries at
[3:03:17]
714-667-8800. And in the
[3:03:18]
interest of time, I want to just
[3:03:20]
focus quickly on travelers who
[3:03:22]
might be stuck in puerto
[3:03:23]
vallarta. In the fifth district
[3:03:25]
we have a lot of travelers that
[3:03:26]
go to puerto vallarta. The
[3:03:29]
country is pretty much on
[3:03:31]
lock-down in some areas,
[3:03:34]
tijuana, guadalajara, puerto
[3:03:36]
vallarta and the U.S. State
[3:03:38]
department is advising americans
[3:03:41]
as well as others that are
[3:03:42]
traveling to seek shelter,
[3:03:44]
minimize unnecessary movements,
[3:03:46]
remain in hotels or residences,
[3:03:49]
be aware of your surroundings.
[3:03:51]
Anyone needing assistance can
[3:03:53]
call from U.S. Or canada,
[3:04:02]
1-888-407-4747. Or if you're in
[3:04:03]
mexico and you need call
[3:04:11]
1-202-501-4444. Southwest
[3:04:11]
airlines, which travels direct
[3:04:13]
from jwa to mexico are advising
[3:04:16]
to check with
[3:04:20]
southwest.Com/traveladvisor for
[3:04:21]
information. And then the state
[3:04:23]
department has this american
[3:04:24]
citizens services task force for
[3:04:26]
U.S. Citizens in mexico, and you
[3:04:29]
can call a number to help get
[3:04:31]
returned travel 202-501-4444.
[3:04:38]
Or 1-888407-4747.
[3:04:42]
I already gave those numbers.
[3:04:43]
So with that, thank you to my
[3:04:46]
colleagues for a very productive
[3:04:48]
meeting today. And it's only
[3:04:50]
noon.
[3:04:51]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank you
[3:04:53]
vice-chair. Supervisor
[3:04:53]
sarmiento.
[3:04:55]
>>vincente sarmiento: thank you,
[3:04:55]
MR. Chair. I have just a few
[3:04:56]
items, and if the board will
[3:04:59]
indulge me on these, I'll try go
[3:05:00]
rapid me. I -- rapidly. I want
[3:05:01]
to thank our partners who helped
[3:05:04]
us with the health and resource
[3:05:07]
fair this saturday the 21st.
[3:05:09]
We hosted at anaheim high
[3:05:11]
school. We want to thank their
[3:05:12]
board of trustees and the
[3:05:14]
principal there. Principal
[3:05:16]
rubin.
[3:05:19]
He and his team were just very
[3:05:22]
gracious and opening up the
[3:05:24]
campus. It's a beautiful
[3:05:25]
campus. It's a historic campus,
[3:05:28]
and our partners, who kind of
[3:05:32]
anchored this were social
[3:05:33]
service agency, ahn tran was
[3:05:35]
there and also caloptima. So we
[3:05:38]
want to thank our partners who
[3:05:41]
were there, notably lestinac,
[3:05:44]
cap oc, second harvest food
[3:05:46]
bank, choc, central city,
[3:05:48]
united, across borders and many,
[3:05:51]
many others. They were doing
[3:05:53]
medical screenings, reading
[3:05:55]
glasses on the spot and just a
[3:06:02]
lot of good stuff, groceries,
[3:06:05]
diapers, people who were just
[3:06:07]
trying to help their neighbors.
[3:06:08]
Unfortunately, attendance wasn't
[3:06:10]
as large as we would have
[3:06:12]
expected just because we know
[3:06:14]
there was a lot of fear, and it
[3:06:15]
was palpable in people who were
[3:06:17]
there. We saw it in their
[3:06:19]
faces, and they explained to us
[3:06:21]
that their neighbors would have
[3:06:22]
attended had conditions been
[3:06:24]
different. But they're still
[3:06:25]
fearful of immigration raids and
[3:06:28]
enforcement that has communities
[3:06:30]
really kind of closed off. So
[3:06:33]
that was one. And the other one
[3:06:35]
is our warm program. We just
[3:06:37]
wanted to update, we know it's
[3:06:39]
beautiful weather right now.
[3:06:40]
It's 80 degrees outside right
[3:06:41]
now. Last week we had a lot of
[3:06:42]
rain and previously, and I'm
[3:06:44]
sure we'll have more. The warm
[3:06:46]
program in its second year is
[3:06:49]
our effort to stand up what was
[3:06:53]
the cold weather shelter, and on
[3:06:55]
JANUARY 1st, the program
[3:06:57]
started providing motel stays to
[3:07:02]
elementary-age students and
[3:07:02]
their families during periods of
[3:07:04]
inclement weather. We partner
[3:07:06]
with all five school districts
[3:07:07]
in our area, and for families in
[3:07:10]
need. So if you know of
[3:07:11]
anybody, please have them
[3:07:12]
contact their school districts,
[3:07:14]
teachers, principals so they can
[3:07:16]
connect with their program. It
[3:07:18]
was able to support some
[3:07:18]
families through some very cold
[3:07:20]
nights and continue to activate
[3:07:22]
on nights when temperatures drop
[3:07:24]
below 45 degrees and during
[3:07:26]
rainy weather. Lastly, I wanted
[3:07:29]
to touch on the report that was
[3:07:32]
just released by caloptima, and
[3:07:34]
that is the audit on findings.
[3:07:38]
It disclosed in the expenditures
[3:07:42]
major in the period when former
[3:07:43]
supervisor andrew do served on
[3:07:45]
the caloptima board. You know,
[3:07:47]
there was an article written on
[3:07:49]
it. It's a little less than
[3:07:52]
accurate, but to the extent that
[3:07:56]
it captured what the board was
[3:07:57]
trying to do at came optima,
[3:07:59]
which was to look back and see
[3:08:01]
if there was any undue influence
[3:08:02]
by the former supervisor because
[3:08:04]
he served as chair and served on
[3:08:05]
that board as director for many
[3:08:07]
years. I know that they try to
[3:08:09]
budgets two reports. One that
[3:08:11]
was released late last year.
[3:08:13]
That was a completely separate
[3:08:15]
investigation. That was into
[3:08:16]
the proposed acquisition of a
[3:08:21]
tustin property, which
[3:08:22]
ultimately was not consummated.
[3:08:25]
That was not an investigation
[3:08:26]
into MR. Do. That was based
[3:08:29]
upon a whistle blower claim that
[3:08:31]
was made by an employee. He was
[3:08:32]
part of that. He was all over
[3:08:34]
that narrative. But it wasn't
[3:08:36]
focused in on him. This audit
[3:08:38]
in particular that was released
[3:08:39]
and done by ankura was
[3:08:41]
specifically focused in on his
[3:08:43]
possible influence on any
[3:08:46]
funding that MAY have gone
[3:08:48]
through the agency. So the
[3:08:50]
board initiated this. It was
[3:08:52]
not obligated to do this. But
[3:08:54]
it wanted to make sure that in
[3:08:56]
the effort and in the spirit of
[3:08:57]
transparency -- they wanted to
[3:08:59]
make sure that they looked back
[3:09:00]
and saw what his dealings were
[3:09:03]
there. And although it was
[3:09:05]
inclusive, that doesn't mean
[3:09:06]
that there weren't findings or
[3:09:08]
recommendations that we could
[3:09:09]
take and use going forward. And
[3:09:11]
that's where I use praise for
[3:09:14]
the report. It be wasn't really
[3:09:15]
for the findings. I know that
[3:09:17]
there was some difficulty by the
[3:09:19]
auditors to access information.
[3:09:22]
That, I'm certainly not
[3:09:24]
praising. I think there's some
[3:09:26]
work and improvements that could
[3:09:27]
be done, but to the extent that
[3:09:28]
the board took it upon itself to
[3:09:30]
initiate and complete these --
[3:09:33]
both an investigation and an
[3:09:36]
audit -- I think are good steps
[3:09:38]
for public agencies that are
[3:09:40]
trying to make sure that there
[3:09:42]
is good governance,
[3:09:43]
transparency, oversight and
[3:09:46]
there is work to be done
[3:09:47]
obviously from the
[3:09:48]
recommendations that were cited.
[3:09:49]
So that's something that I'm
[3:09:50]
sure the board will undertake.
[3:09:52]
But there have been already
[3:09:53]
action taken by the board,
[3:09:54]
strengthening the grant's
[3:09:56]
management policy,
[3:09:58]
standardsizing processes and
[3:09:59]
improving oversight on every
[3:10:01]
grant and updating the conflict
[3:10:02]
of interest policy to clarify
[3:10:04]
when conflicts must be
[3:10:05]
disclosed.
[3:10:06]
That was done here at county
[3:10:08]
because we know that was abused
[3:10:10]
by a former supervisor do. So
[3:10:13]
to the extent that there is
[3:10:14]
continuing work to be done,
[3:10:16]
obviously there was -- you know,
[3:10:18]
there's some compliance and
[3:10:19]
improvements that need to be
[3:10:20]
made. We know there is work to
[3:10:23]
be done. But to the extent that
[3:10:25]
this health plan doesn't just
[3:10:27]
necessarily do medical care. We
[3:10:30]
know that at caloptima, what we
[3:10:32]
see is good healthcare means
[3:10:35]
house, to make sure people have
[3:10:36]
a roof over their head is an
[3:10:39]
india of how people can be
[3:10:40]
either healthy or ill, access,
[3:10:43]
which is why we stood up for
[3:10:45]
programs doing street medicine,
[3:10:46]
which is basically doctors'
[3:10:49]
offices on wheels, which helps
[3:10:52]
people on the street so they can
[3:10:55]
receive medical care and
[3:10:56]
eventually get housing. Also we
[3:10:58]
know that many of our members
[3:10:59]
suffer from swo substance abuse
[3:11:05]
and we had narcan that was
[3:11:06]
distributed throughout the
[3:11:07]
county to make sure people had
[3:11:09]
that who were addicted or use
[3:11:15]
fentanyl. We know many of our
[3:11:16]
members suffer from food
[3:11:18]
insecurity, which is why 1.2
[3:11:20]
million was dedicated to second
[3:11:22]
harvest and cap oc to make sure
[3:11:24]
that we address those issues.
[3:11:26]
So the reason why I think that's
[3:11:28]
relevant is because this health
[3:11:30]
plan now, again, dispenses more
[3:11:32]
than just medical care. It does
[3:11:35]
grants. It works, community
[3:11:36]
partners and providers, and a
[3:11:39]
lot of times, you know, it is
[3:11:40]
not as familiar as maybe some of
[3:11:42]
the agencies that, you know, do
[3:11:44]
oversight compliance and
[3:11:46]
tracking of funds, you know, as
[3:11:49]
often as this health plan does.
[3:11:51]
We will certainly get into that,
[3:11:55]
you know, routine of making sure
[3:11:59]
that they track these things
[3:12:00]
better, and looking back, having
[3:12:02]
audits done, investigations
[3:12:03]
done, there are opportunities
[3:12:05]
for us to improve both here at
[3:12:07]
the county and at caloptima and
[3:12:09]
make sure that all public
[3:12:10]
dollars are accounted for,
[3:12:13]
there's responsibility and
[3:12:14]
oversight on those. So I just
[3:12:15]
wanted to make some clarity on,
[3:12:17]
that that I am very proud of our
[3:12:19]
board who undertook these things
[3:12:20]
voluntarily. Much work to be
[3:12:22]
done, and I believe a lot of
[3:12:24]
compliance training that, you
[3:12:26]
know, that plan could learn
[3:12:28]
from, you know, agencies that we
[3:12:30]
all sit on that do very good
[3:12:31]
work on track and oversight. So
[3:12:33]
with that, MR. Chair, those are
[3:12:35]
my comments for the day.
[3:12:36]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank you
[3:12:37]
supervisor. I will make a few
[3:12:39]
of my own. First, I'd like to
[3:12:40]
thank supervisor nguyen for
[3:12:43]
setting up the little seance we
[3:12:45]
had with the hud people and the
[3:12:46]
staff that attend as well, and
[3:12:49]
particularly our ceo. It was, I
[3:12:53]
thought, a good rapport that was
[3:12:56]
established, something I don't
[3:12:58]
think we've had in the past.
[3:12:59]
You can look at all of the words
[3:13:01]
in your application, but when
[3:13:02]
you put it face to face, it
[3:13:04]
really helps. I think we'll
[3:13:06]
move forward successfully when
[3:13:08]
we get to those various
[3:13:11]
applications that they were
[3:13:12]
talking about. And I had my
[3:13:16]
usual good time on valentine's
[3:13:18]
day. My eighth year in a row
[3:13:19]
that I've spent in the clerk's
[3:13:20]
office officiating weddings. I
[3:13:23]
was able to do six of them this
[3:13:26]
last valentine's day at the
[3:13:28]
anaheim office. And that for me
[3:13:30]
is always fun, to see some happy
[3:13:32]
people and participate in their
[3:13:35]
joy. We have a couple events
[3:13:40]
coming up. We have our elder
[3:13:43]
fraud prevention. There it is.
[3:13:47]
Up, there coming up this
[3:13:48]
thursday. Elderly people are
[3:13:52]
probability most often scammed
[3:13:54]
group. So we want to give them
[3:13:55]
as much information so they can
[3:13:57]
protect themselves. So that's
[3:13:59]
coming up. The information is
[3:14:00]
up there. It is thursday at
[3:14:03]
noon. We'll have a little
[3:14:05]
something to eat, as well, being
[3:14:07]
noontime. And then more fun, on
[3:14:11]
MARCH 14, coming up, assuming no
[3:14:14]
rain, we will be holding another
[3:14:17]
fishing derby for kids. On
[3:14:19]
MARCH 14, beginning at 8:00,
[3:14:23]
ending at 11:00. We do have
[3:14:24]
fish rods and bait and all that
[3:14:25]
and the lake will be stocked. I
[3:14:27]
hope you like catfish because
[3:14:28]
that's what we have available at
[3:14:31]
this time. Always fun to see a
[3:14:36]
5-year-old hold up a two-foot
[3:14:38]
catfish. Almost the same height
[3:14:40]
when they hold that up. If you
[3:14:44]
have a fishing license after 11,
[3:14:46]
there's still plenty of fish
[3:14:47]
there, you can join in, even
[3:14:50]
though you're not a kid. So
[3:14:52]
some fun things coming up for
[3:14:54]
me. We also at the end of the
[3:14:55]
day appreciate the orange county
[3:14:58]
employee association coming in
[3:14:59]
and providing lunch with their
[3:15:02]
hot dog machine that they have
[3:15:03]
there. So ceo agruye
[3:15:04]
rey, do you
[3:15:06]
have any -- ceo aguirre, do you
[3:15:06]
have any comments you'd like to
[3:15:07]
make.
[3:15:11]
>>michelle aguirre: I'll echo
[3:15:12]
the comments from yourself and
[3:15:14]
also from supervisor nguyen
[3:15:15]
related to our meeting with hud
[3:15:16]
on friday night. I think one of
[3:15:18]
the things that I found to be
[3:15:19]
most impactful was when we were
[3:15:21]
speaking about clearing the
[3:15:23]
riverbed, and a couple of the
[3:15:24]
graduates of the oc rescue
[3:15:26]
mission from actually on the
[3:15:28]
riverbed at that time. So it
[3:15:30]
was great to be able to
[3:15:31]
communicate with them and hear
[3:15:33]
their stories.
[3:15:34]
I thought it
[3:15:35]
was a great night also. So
[3:15:37]
thank you. And just one
[3:15:39]
shout-out, so this past friday,
[3:15:41]
the ceo government affairs and
[3:15:44]
communications team conducted an
[3:15:46]
oc cares photo shoot to dewpoint
[3:15:49]
the great work that our oc cares
[3:15:51]
initiative is doing. And it was
[3:15:54]
at craig regional park in
[3:15:56]
fullerton. We just want to give
[3:15:59]
kudos to the four parpght
[3:16:02]
probation officers, michael
[3:16:04]
castill, colleen burn, francisco
[3:16:07]
free was, and jorge cast none
[3:16:09]
for their time, professionalism
[3:16:11]
and their commitment to this
[3:16:12]
initiative and to our community
[3:16:14]
partner project kinship for
[3:16:16]
their participation. And then
[3:16:18]
this was right after the stormy
[3:16:21]
weather that we had last week.
[3:16:23]
And so a big thank you to the oc
[3:16:26]
parks crew who went above and
[3:16:28]
beyond to ensure that we had a
[3:16:31]
successful production at craig
[3:16:33]
park. Park ranger james kim,
[3:16:36]
supervising park ranger jason
[3:16:37]
arthur along with our
[3:16:39]
maintenance team of chavez,
[3:16:42]
caesar, alvarez and enrique
[3:16:45]
ororsco led a clean-up effort,
[3:16:50]
even repainting the hand ball
[3:16:52]
court before the photo shoot,
[3:16:55]
cleaning up debris, and just a
[3:16:59]
shout-out to you. Greatly
[3:17:00]
appreciate all of your efforts.
[3:17:02]
Thank you, chair.
[3:17:03]
>>chair, doug chaffee: thank you
[3:17:04]
MADAM Ceo. MADAM Clerk, you can
[3:17:13]
read the closed-session items.
[3:17:15]
>>clerk, robin stieler: cs-1 has
[3:17:15]
been deleted.
[3:17:16]
>>clerk, robin stieler: cs-2.
[3:17:17]
Public employee performance
[3:17:20]
evaluation-pursuant to
[3:17:20]
government code section 54957(B):
[3:17:22]
title:executive director of the
[3:17:25]
campaign finance and ethics commission.
[3:17:26]
(Continued from 2/10/26, item cs-2)
[3:17:29]
Scs3. County counsel-
[3:17:29]
conference with legal counsel-
[3:17:30]
existing litigation-pursuant
[3:17:31]
to government code section 54956.9(D)(1):
[3:17:34]
name of case: mind oc v. County
[3:17:37]
of orange, orange county
[3:17:38]
superior court case
[3:17:38]
no.: 30-2024-01442012-cu-co-cjc.
[3:17:39]
Scs4. County counsel-
[3:17:40]
conference with legal counsel-
[3:17:41]
existing litigation-pursuant
[3:17:43]
to government code section 54956.9(D)(1):
[3:17:45]
name of cases: clarisse magtoto
[3:17:48]
v. County of orange, orange
[3:18:01]
county superior court case no. 30-2022-01241335,
[3:18:02]
amy tallakson v. County of
[3:18:02]
orange, orange county superior
[3:18:03]
court case no. 30-2022-01241346,
[3:18:04]
shabnum azizi v. County of
[3:18:05]
orange, orange county superior
[3:18:06]
court case no. 30-2022-01232544,
[3:18:06]
mallory miller v. County of
[3:18:07]
orange, orange county superior
[3:18:08]
court case no. 30-2022-01252436,
[3:18:09]
bethel cope-vega v. County of
[3:18:10]
orange, orange county superior
[3:18:10]
court case no. 30-2022-01252452,
[3:18:11]
mohammad abuershaid v. County of
[3:18:12]
orange, orange county superior
[3:18:13]
court case no. 30-2022-01243989,
[3:18:14]
and tracy miller v. County of
[3:18:15]
orange et al., orange county
[3:18:18]
superior court case no. 30-2022-01262015.
[3:18:19]
>>chair, doug chaffee: we are
[3:18:24]
adjourned to closed sessions.
[3:20:29]
>>leon page: pursuant to
[3:20:33]
government code section 5 foifer
[3:20:34]
5497b and section d the board
[3:20:35]
met in closed sessions to
[3:20:37]
discuss the items referenced on
[3:20:40]
today's agenda as cs2, cs3, and
[3:20:44]
scs4. Cs1 was actually deleted.
[3:20:45]
With respect to those three
[3:20:47]
items the board took no
[3:20:48]
reportable action in closed
[3:20:49]
sessions today. Thank you.
[3:20:51]
>>clerk, robin stieler: that
[3:20:52]
concludes today'sed a. The next
[3:20:53]
meeting is scheduled for tuesday
[3:20:55]
MARCH 10th at 9:30 A.M.
[3:20:56]
Today's meeting of the orange
[3:21:00]
county board of supervisors