Planning Commission on 2025-05-22 7:00 PM

Hayward, CA · · More Hayward, CA meetings · More California meetings

Transcript

Download: Text · SRT
AI TRANSCRIPT

This transcript was generated automatically from audio using AI and hasn't been reviewed by a person — it can contain mistakes, including plausible-sounding sentences that were never actually said. Treat it as a starting point, not a verbatim record.

[0:00] And welcome to the City of Hayward Planning Commission meeting for May 22, 2025. We're holding a hybrid meeting with some participants in the council chambers and others who have joined virtually via Zoom.
[0:12] This meeting is being webcast on Comcast TV, Channel 15, and live streamed on the city's YouTube channel and on the city's website. This meeting is called to order at 704PM. Please rise for the pledge of allegiance.
[0:47] Ms. Allen, could you please call roll?
[0:51] Good afternoon.
[0:54] Commissioner Franco Cawson absent.
[0:56] Commissioner Goodbody.
[0:58] Here.
[0:58] Commissioner Hammond.
[1:00] Here.
[1:01] Commissioner Low.
[1:02] Here.
[1:02] Commissioner Myers.
[1:04] Here.
[1:05] Commissioner Stevens.
[1:06] Here.
[1:06] Chair Hardy.
[1:08] Present.
[1:10] We will now open public comments on non agenda items.
[1:14] The public comment section provides an opportunity to address the planning commission on items not listed on the agenda.
[1:20] The Commission welcomes comments and requests that speakers present their remarks in a respectful manner with in-established time limits and focused on issues which directly affect the city or within the jurisdiction of the city.
[1:34] As the Commission is prohibited by state law from discussing items not listed on the agenda, your item will be taken into consideration and may be referred to staff for further action.
[1:44] Speaker, shall not use threatening profane, abusive or abusive language, which disrupts, disturbs
[1:50] or otherwise impedes the orderly conduct of a commission meeting.
[1:54] The city is committed to maintaining a workplace free of unlawful harassment, and is mindful
[1:59] that city staff regularly attend commission meetings.
[2:03] Discriminatory statements are conduct that is hostile, intimidating, oppressive, or abusive,
[2:08] or per se, disruptive to a meeting will not be tolerated.
[2:12] Ms. Allen, do we have any public comments at this time?
[2:20] There are not online.
[2:22] Thank you.
[2:23] I will now close public comments and we will move on to our action items.
[2:30] The Commission will permit comments on each item that is called for public hearing.
[2:36] Please submit a speaker card if you haven't already.
[2:39] If you wish to speak on a public hearing item.
[2:41] For agenda item number one, the decision of the Planning Commission is final unless appealed.
[2:47] The appeal period is 10 days from the date of the decision.
[2:51] If appealed, a public hearing will be scheduled before the City Council for final decision.
[2:57] Item number one, P-H-2502 is a public hearing for the Stack Data Center,
[3:04] a major site plan review and administrative use permit application
[3:07] to construct a three-story data center, generator yard,
[3:11] substation, switching yard, and related accessory structures,
[3:16] in-site improvements on an approximately 11 acre site,
[3:20] located at 26062, Eden Landing Road,
[3:24] and review and certify the project's initial study,
[3:28] mitigated negative declaration, and mitigation monitoring,
[3:31] and reporting program, prepared by the California Energy Commission.
[3:36] staff have a presentation for this item.
[3:40] Yes, we do.
[3:41] I'm joining online so first just want to make sure that you are seeing the title slide before
[3:45] you and that you can hear me okay.
[3:49] We can hear you, but we do not see the slides yet.
[3:52] Oh, okay.
[3:53] Let's try sharing again.
[3:54] Hang on one second.
[3:55] And Jeremy, please stand by.
[3:56] I might have you share instead.
[3:59] Let's see.
[3:59] I try again.
[4:09] Okay.
[4:09] And my screen.
[4:09] It looks like it's sharing.
[4:10] How does it look on everybody else?
[4:12] It's green.
[4:12] It looks great if you see it on Monday.
[4:16] Well, a good evening commissioner is Elizabeth Lantin, senior planner.
[4:21] I'm joining you all virtually this evening because I'm actually currently on vacation in Pennsylvania, visiting my sisters family.
[4:28] So from afar, I'm here to present the Stacked Data Center project, which is requesting approval of a major site plan review and administrative use permit application.
[4:38] You may recall that this project was previously brought before the commission at a work session back in November.
[4:45] Since then, the project application has been deemed complete by staff and the environmental analysis process has concluded.
[4:52] So as a result, tonight, we'll be asking the commission to make a decision on this application.
[5:05] There we go. The project site is located just south of Highway 92 on Eden Landing Road in the middle of the city's industrial area, and as you can see on this map, it's fairly close to the shoreline interpretive center, which is indicated by the yellow dot, as well as sections of the Bay Trail, which are indicated by the dotted line green lines.
[5:28] As zooming in on our map, the site itself is approximately 11 acres and has frontages on
[5:34] Eden Landing Road, Production Avenue, and Investment Boulevard.
[5:39] It has a general plan land use designation of industrial corridor and is zoned in industrial
[5:44] park, which allows for data centers by right along with a range of other industrial and office
[5:50] uses.
[5:51] Currently, there's a vacant, light industrial office park with nine single-story buildings on
[5:57] site, which would be demolished in order to accommodate the proposed project. Staff has heard
[6:03] from one of the now former tenants of this office park that they were concerned that they
[6:07] would be unable to find affordable office space elsewhere in the area. But in response to the
[6:12] applicant team provided some financial relief to support this tenant's relocation efforts.
[6:18] I'll also note here while we're looking at this map that staff has also heard from a couple of
[6:27] landing road, who are concerned about the potential impacts that the construction of the project
[6:31] and that the limited number of future employees would have on their businesses and we'll address
[6:37] that more in just a bit. So this site plan rotates our orientation slightly so that north and highway
[6:45] 92 are now toward the left of this image. The main building on site here shown in orange would
[6:51] a three-story 310 square foot data center that is about 100 feet tall. To support the project
[6:58] significant power needs there would also be an on-site substation and switching station
[7:03] along inlanding road and a large generator yard with 28 emergency diesel generators facing
[7:10] production avenue. Additional site improvements would include a guard station, security fencing,
[7:16] new landscaping and buyer retention basins and outdoor seating for employees.
[7:24] The design of the primary building includes a mix of concrete, metal, and textured elements.
[7:29] This rendering is a view from the corner of investment, boulevard, and production avenue,
[7:35] and as you can see the building incorporates a number of elements from the city's industrial design
[7:40] guidelines, including varied wallplanes and projections that help to visually break up the overall
[7:46] of the building. In this render, you can also see some of the screening that will help
[7:51] mask the view of that large generator yard facing production avenue. And in addition,
[7:58] the on-site substation, which will be visible from Eden Landing Road in Highway 92, will also be
[8:03] screened. As shown in this rendering, the screening design has evolved since the last time you saw
[8:09] in November, but the curved blue slats remain. And again, there meant to be a bucket of of the
[8:14] by Hayward Shoreline.
[8:19] Now, while this project is proposed, meets most of the requirements
[8:22] of the industrial park zoning district, as you might recall, there are two exceptions
[8:26] that the applicant is requesting. The first is a reduction in parking. Data centers are defined
[8:32] as an office use in our zoning ordinance, which means that they're required to provide one parking space
[8:37] for every 250 square feet of building. Given the square footage of the proposed project,
[8:43] this would require over 1200 parking spaces.
[8:47] Now, however, the city's parking regulations
[8:49] do allow for exceptions in cases when a uses parking demand
[8:53] would be significantly lower
[8:55] than the required number of spaces.
[8:57] So it's illustrated in the parking memo
[8:59] that's attached to the staff report.
[9:01] The proposed data center would have a maximum of 33 employees
[9:05] and up to 12 visitors per day.
[9:08] So that's the 68 parking spaces
[9:10] that the application proposals would be more than enough to accommodate the project's
[9:15] daily parking demand.
[9:18] The applicant team is also requesting a second exception related to
[9:22] building height. The building's main building, I should say, is proposed 100 foot height is taller
[9:29] than the 75 foot maximum height allowed by the industrial part zoning district. Now that said,
[9:35] the city's code does allow decision makers to approve taller buildings in the zoning district
[9:40] if the project includes significant and sufficient public benefits or amenities to warrant that increase in height.
[9:51] So the applicant team has met with staff, the Council Economic Development Committee, the HASPA Board of Directors,
[9:56] and this commission over the past two years, she just got...
[10:00] What should be included in the project's public benefit package to justify that requested height increase?
[10:07] As a result of these discussions, the public benefits package has increased from $900,000 in the initial application
[10:14] to the $2 million that you see today. Now, this is an increase from the $1.5 million public benefits package
[10:22] that was described in the staff report as just this week, the applicant team elected to increase
[10:28] their proposed contributions further in response to a letter from the HASPA Board of Trustees,
[10:33] which was also included as an attachment to the staff report. So this latest proposed $2 million
[10:40] public benefits package would be divided among various city and regional projects and funds,
[10:46] including $500,000 to HASPA, $300,000 each to the city's gateway marker project and a small business grant program,
[10:57] $200,000 each to Levista Park, the school district, and a CIP solar project at the city's water resource recovery facility,
[11:06] $150,000 for nearby bike and pedestrian projects, $100,000 for the CIP Stack Community Center
[11:15] project, and $50,000 for new signage for that adjacent Eden Landing shopping center
[11:22] that I was mentioning earlier.
[11:25] The revised conditions of approval that were distributed earlier this afternoon in the
[11:36] Again, this proposed public benefits package is based on feedback that the applicant team has received to date.
[11:44] At their June meeting last year, the Council Economic Development Committee recommended that the public benefits package include hosting an ongoing food truck court nearby,
[11:53] a contribution for the staff community center and support for small businesses.
[11:58] All of these are included in the latest public benefits package, with the exception of the food truck court as staff from the East Bay Regional Park District,
[12:05] recommended against that idea of based on where we are talking about putting it.
[12:10] In addition to CDC, we wanted to see further enhancement of the project's architectural
[12:16] elements and artistic screening, especially where they would be visible from Highway 92.
[12:23] On the behalf of Board of Trustees meetings in February and October of last year,
[12:28] the Board recommended a significant increase to the public benefits budget to cover a wider variety
[12:33] of green and sustainable projects, including contributions toward the renovation of the nearby shoreline
[12:39] interpretive center and towards bike and pedestrian infrastructure, city parks, tree plantings,
[12:45] and educational programs. Again, contributions for all of these items are included in the latest
[12:51] public benefits package and in direct response to a recent letter by the House of the Board,
[12:56] the applicant team increased the overall package to the low from $1.5 million to $2 million,
[13:01] which now includes a half million dollar contribution directly to HASPA to be used at their
[13:06] discretion towards their projects aimed at shoreline resiliency and education.
[13:13] And a work session with this body last year, the Commission again was generally supportive of
[13:17] the project, but recommended increased funding for the shoreline interpreted center,
[13:22] even landing ecological reserve, Hayward Unified School District,
[13:26] Russell City Art Project, and the Hayward Fire Department. In addition, the Commission recommended
[13:31] ongoing funding for the small business grant program to ensure its long-term success.
[13:37] And then finally, the Commission asked the applicant to incorporate more public art and EV charging
[13:42] stations. So again, many of these items are represented in the applicant's final proposal
[13:48] for the public benefits package and in the project design itself in the case of public art and EV charging
[13:53] stations.
[13:57] Now, this project is subject to the California Environmental Quality Act or CWA and
[14:01] initial study in mitigated negative declaration with the mitigation monitoring and reporting
[14:06] program was prepared. Per State requirements for projects that qualify as a small thermal power
[14:13] plant, as this one does, the California Energy Commission served as the lead agency in
[14:19] charge of preparing the ISM and D. The city, on the other hand, served as a responsible agency
[14:25] under SIGWA, assisting in the review of draft chapters.
[14:30] The ISM&D was available for public review from March 21st through April 21st, and the
[14:35] final document was certified by the CEC earlier this month on May 8th.
[14:41] Tonight, if the Planning Commission decides to approve this project, you will also be required
[14:45] to certify and accept the ISM&D that the CEC prepared, which is attached to the staff report.
[14:53] So, in conclusion, staff finds a project is consistent with all applicable city-cosm requirements.
[15:00] Including the general plan, zoning ordinance and industrial district design guidelines. We further find that by increasing the overall public benefits package from $900,000 to $2 million, and adjusting the contributions contained within, the proposal has adequately responded to the feedback provided to date, including from this body.
[15:21] While there were some comments received an opposition to the project, citing general concerns about the environment related to a data center and concern about impacts to nearby small businesses, the proposed project includes a number of sustainability measures and public benefits aimed at addressing these concerns.
[15:43] Moreover, staff also received several letters and correspondence in support of the project.
[15:47] On staff supports the requested parking reduction given the uniquely low staffing needs of a data center.
[15:56] And finally, staff appreciates the unique architectural design of this structure, especially the creative artistic screening of the substation facing Highway 92 and Eglanting Road.
[16:08] So as a result, staff recommends that the Planning Commission approves the proposed major site plan review and administrative use permit application
[16:15] and certify the project's Secret Document.
[16:19] This concludes staff's presentation,
[16:21] but if the chair will allow the applicant
[16:23] team has also prepared a short presentation
[16:26] that they'd like to share before we open it
[16:28] for questions and discussion.
[16:32] Thank you, senior planner,
[16:33] Blanson.
[16:34] Yes, if the developer would like to go ahead
[16:36] and make their presentation that would be great.
[17:33] Thank you so much.
[17:34] Great to be here this evening.
[17:35] Thank you so much for having us.
[17:36] Very exciting night for us and all of our partners.
[17:38] I have a lot of stakeholders, partners, consultants with us and some on the phone, so questions come up, I may be phoning a friend later.
[17:45] Thank you so much.
[17:46] Stack infrastructure.
[17:48] To review a bit, we are a data center developer.
[17:51] We specialize in building data centers globally.
[17:54] And data centers really help to power the internet, you know, the brick and mortar of the cloud.
[17:59] This is the nice to have, like the virtual presentation,
[18:02] Retreat even the documents from the internet that we're all using.
[18:05] It's also the need to have such as air control, such as police dispatch,
[18:08] such as our medical records in the event of emergency.
[18:11] Next slide, please.
[18:14] Stack is a global data center group.
[18:17] We focus here today in the Bay Area in Hayward,
[18:21] but we have a presence across the globe.
[18:25] This is where the internet crisscrosses the world
[18:27] and creates the cloud.
[18:29] Next slide, please.
[18:32] As I mentioned, Stack has a significant Bay Area presence here.
[18:36] We intend to grow in Hayward.
[18:38] We're also in Santa Clara in San Jose
[18:40] with two sister projects as well.
[18:42] Next slide, please.
[18:46] As Elizabeth was mentioning, and with great partnership, very proud working with Elizabeth staff
[18:50] who has been tremendous to the process as much as all of you have in continuing to refine
[18:53] the project.
[18:54] We really found ourselves a great home and 10-day grow here in the industrial technology
[18:59] corridor to really help to bring a healthy blend of information and technology jobs to the manufacturing
[19:05] jobs that are there.
[19:06] This is to really move an alignment with Hayward's 2040 general plan and really help to bring
[19:12] that healthy blend and to continue to attract additional corporate development in the area.
[19:17] Next slide, please.
[19:19] Here we see an updated rendering that you may be seeing for the first time, but this is just
[19:23] a visual to see how we really integrate into the neighborhood.
[19:27] You can see right in the middle, this is our SBY03A project.
[19:30] Thank you so much.
[19:32] It's hard to see too, because it blends in.
[19:34] You know, although we are asking for a height modification, we are relative to some of the other buildings,
[19:38] especially across the highway, and it really looked to integrate into the neighborhood.
[19:42] I think the biggest part that helps us to stand out is our enhanced architectural and science that we're really proud of.
[19:48] I'd also like to call out here.
[19:51] It's hard to see, you might be able to see it easier on your visuals.
[19:54] But we will be building a switching station in this sub-station on site.
[19:58] This is really to help enhance.
[20:00] The electrical infrastructure of the network, as well as help to provide our facility with electricity.
[20:06] This switching station will also enhance the robustness of the already PG&E network switching station network to help provide another breaker point.
[20:14] To help in case of an outage upstream or downstream, this allows other networks inside of this distribution and transmission network to stay online in the event of an emergency.
[20:25] see this provides that additional breaker position.
[20:28] What you can't see here is additional infrastructure that's underground.
[20:31] Some upgrades to the water infrastructure that we'll be making as part of our project.
[20:36] In collaboration with our civil engineering team, we're actually going to be doing some
[20:40] ride-along trenching for our water improvements to not disrupt any of the neighbors and make
[20:47] sure that this is actually an up-sized, you know, our upgrade actually calls for a 10-inch
[20:51] and this will be a 12 inch main to provide for future expansion in the area as well for future
[20:55] businesses or for future water usage.
[20:59] Next slide, please.
[21:01] Just to hit on a few of the benefits that we bring to the table, really excited to be creating
[21:07] approximately 380 union jobs for our construction site.
[21:12] We also anticipate having around 41 on-site jobs throughout the project and we have a job
[21:17] to apply here with about 200 indirect jobs that will be supporting in the data center.
[21:22] To go down some of the conformance and consistency that Elizabeth mentioned, this is truly
[21:26] in the line with a 2040 general plan as well as some of the green building ordinances and revenue
[21:31] creation that Hayward has really outlined. Some of our off-site improvements include pedestrian network
[21:37] improvements, traffic calming measures, and we also do work with alternative work schedules.
[21:41] This is a 24 hour facility, so not everyone is coming all at one time to reduce the amount of traffic
[21:46] that we bring to the area.
[21:48] With our mitigative negative declaration that was led by the CEC,
[21:52] we were able to complete our secret process
[21:54] and also be granted our small part planning exemption.
[21:57] This also includes our mitigation,
[21:59] monitoring and reporting program to help establish
[22:02] best practices through the course of development,
[22:04] what to do in each scenario,
[22:06] and really mitigate all concerns there.
[22:09] We will be 100% renewable and this goes towards
[22:12] stacks global and net zero program.
[22:14] for landscaping will be replanting 55 of the trees will be starting off with our 18EV
[22:20] chargers right off the bat and will be reducing our parking stalls to about 71 or less.
[22:25] Just to hit on some of the infrastructure that I was talking about that switching station,
[22:30] the water infrastructure upgrades, approximately you know $70 million worth of infrastructure
[22:35] upgrades that will be coming here to the city of Hatewood.
[22:38] Next slide please.
[22:41] Additionally, just a chat on some of the additional public benefits here.
[22:44] This is a letter from Dustin to the City Council identifying some of the key areas to help
[22:49] city close some of the funding gaps that we have in the general plan.
[22:53] The areas that we highlighted here with property tax sales tax and utility user tax.
[22:57] Next slide, please.
[22:59] When we look at the property taxes, for example, each one dollar that goes into property taxes,
[23:06] Hayward gets 16 cents on that dollar.
[23:08] Last time we were here, we were discussing how we believe Hayward has a pretty significant
[23:12] and deal relative to some of the neighboring jurisdictions.
[23:15] And we'd like to do a little comparison.
[23:17] So next slide, please.
[23:19] This is just some help on kind of by the numbers.
[23:22] And what we did here was try to bring through one of the questions
[23:26] that we had during our work session of,
[23:28] what if this project was in San Jose?
[23:30] Do we really have a better deal than other jurisdictions?
[23:33] And what we did here with one of our consultants
[23:35] and I'm going to really showcase that.
[23:37] If this project was dropped down in the exact same acreage,
[23:40] the exact same project, the difference is quite significant.
[23:44] And we'll just walk through some of these
[23:46] the tax revenue streams that we're looking at here
[23:47] from left to right.
[23:49] From left to right, we have the secured real estate property taxes.
[23:52] This is the traditional property tax that we all think of.
[23:55] As we go to the right here, the next one is the unsecured property taxes.
[24:00] Not as typical for a lot of projects,
[24:02] but these are the computers.
[24:04] The mechanical equipment to help cool the facility.
[24:07] These are also taxes as well.
[24:08] These are, this is equipment that is inside the building and consider personal property or unsecured property.
[24:15] As we continue to the right, all of that equipment that we're buying is coming to Hayward.
[24:19] And Hayward gets a piece of that sales tax.
[24:22] The computers that are in the facility are also refreshed.
[24:25] Just like the computers here, just like the computers that we had at home or in our work lives.
[24:28] You know, every one to five years will need to refresh these computers.
[24:31] So the sales tax revenue continues to regenerate.
[24:34] About 20% of the facility will be replaced every year on a rolling base.
[24:37] So it's just as we continue to update and refresh,
[24:40] and that produces a huge tax revenue center
[24:43] for hayward for sales tax.
[24:45] The last one, which is one that we don't always think about,
[24:48] but this is for the utility usage tax.
[24:50] This is the tax on electricity.
[24:53] And so again, as we go across all of these brackets here,
[24:57] we can see how if this project was in San Jose.
[24:59] Okay.
[25:00] Hayward does have a significant higher figure across the board to where we look at. When the project is fully stabilized, we can anticipate Hayward to anticipate about $9 million per year in direct revenue.
[25:15] And by the numbers, that's about an increase of 2% on the total revenue for the city of Hayward.
[25:20] as we look down at San Jose, it's about $7 million.
[25:25] So significantly about a million and a half higher per year
[25:27] that Hayward can anticipate to receive instead
[25:30] of if this project was in San Jose.
[25:32] Next slide, please.
[25:35] You've seen this one.
[25:35] This is again, we're just showing off how beautiful this project is.
[25:38] I'm really proud of our architectural team.
[25:40] And again, challenge for Mayor Mark Solene
[25:41] is during the Cdc meeting and from you all
[25:43] to continue to improve the design.
[25:46] I can say without a doubt, this is the most attractive data
[25:48] that I personally entitled, and that we've stood up here
[25:51] on the West Coast, or in the Americas.
[25:54] Very impressive.
[25:54] This is breaking up the facade using different architectural features.
[25:59] Some tricks that our architects have implemented,
[26:01] so not only at Louvers, but fake windows
[26:03] to help disguise the building, not as a data center,
[26:06] but as a office building next slide, please.
[26:10] And then the screening.
[26:11] Again, from you all continuing to iterate,
[26:13] this is the concept design that you all saw
[26:15] during the working session and really
[26:17] providing some feedback. We continue to enhance that and to great on the wave in next
[26:21] slide, please. And brought us to reality of what we anticipate to build and what we anticipate
[26:26] to submit a building permit on. Again, this is the integration of a wave into the screen.
[26:32] And as we see here, it does have a straight line at the top, but as we continue our designs
[26:35] with PG&E, we hope to be able to create some more undulation on the top of that to make the
[26:40] interpretation of a wave more evocative. We wanted to show, you know, no pun intended
[26:44] with the high water mark of how it could be,
[26:46] what it could look like, but we continue to work
[26:48] to improve our design even after this meeting tonight.
[26:51] In this screen, it's something that we're really proud of
[26:54] in an area for us to really bring our artistic expression to.
[26:57] This could have been corrugated metal paneling.
[27:00] We wanted this to be something that we could all be proud of
[27:02] every time we look by.
[27:03] This is a project that we all worked on together.
[27:06] Next slide, please.
[27:08] And then again, we'll continue on looking at this screen.
[27:10] This is a different screen this time,
[27:12] as Elizabeth was mentioning.
[27:13] this is for our generators. So not only are our generators, these are the cleanest generators
[27:19] that exist, these are tier 4 generators using biodiesel, reduced emissions, and scrubbers,
[27:25] basically Catholic inverters on these diesel generators. These have enclosures. So each of these
[27:31] generators are within their own little room. So even before we put the screen on, if you're walking
[27:36] along that fence line, if you hear testing or anything like that, it's going to be like a vacuum,
[27:40] You know less than 70 decibels less than noisy less than on the noise or conversation
[27:45] You know someone in the next room over having a loud conversation. That's what it's going to sound like
[27:49] Good driving by in a car. You're not going to hear it
[27:52] And to enhance that we also hide these so that someone driving by wouldn't even know that they were there
[27:56] We have we have these screenings all the way up to the top of the stack so you can't even tell you're going to see the screen
[28:02] And we went in to also make this just not a standard screen, but again
[28:06] different colors to break up these facades, you know, these were longer areas.
[28:09] So we use the checker, we use different colors to help to break this up, to help distract the eye.
[28:13] So it's not just one monolith of the color.
[28:15] Next slide, please.
[28:17] And here's just a view of the entrances control facility.
[28:20] 24, 7, only people that are supposed to be there will be there to make sure that we have that.
[28:25] We have a controlled access to access control building.
[28:29] And again, just another view from another perspective to show that, you know,
[28:32] So there's really no kind of backside of the building.
[28:34] A lot of buildings nowadays will have the front facade that's enhanced,
[28:37] but the backside, the side neighbors, they don't get a pretty view.
[28:40] We want to make sure that from every angle,
[28:42] this is truly the gorgeous building.
[28:45] Next slide, please.
[28:47] Coming back to the public benefits.
[28:48] As Elizabeth was mentioning, I won't go through them all again,
[28:51] but really an iterative process that we're really proud to be a part of.
[28:55] Stack is always active in our communities.
[28:58] down in San Jose, we just helped out with the Buries are festival down there, and so we are proud to be members of the communities that we operate in across the Americas and across the globe.
[29:08] This provided us with really a unique opportunity where earlier we were kind of talking about some of the apples, you know, the infrastructure, the taxes.
[29:19] We didn't talk about the impact fees, the schedules that we all have as each city does that will be contributing to, but that's really the apples that we look to other cities at.
[29:26] This is the orange. This is where we have the opportunity to create an enhanced package for
[29:32] Hayward and really bring something that no other city has. Santa Santa Santa's A doesn't
[29:37] have the opportunity to receive these type of public benefits. They have a different
[29:41] system. They have higher height limits which don't provide the opportunity for us to engage
[29:45] with the community for all of these causes. The way that we look at this is this is really
[29:49] the start of the conversation for us to get together with these organizations, begin the
[29:54] discussions and then as the years go on and as we continue to work with our neighborhoods and work with our state.
[30:10] Thank you all for helping us along the way, from the project that we started with to the project that we are today. Truly an interim process that we're so proud of and excited to be a member of this community. Thank you so much.
[30:33] So, now we will move on to a commissioner questions.
[30:38] This is a time for us to ask staff and the developer and any questions and we'll
[30:42] reserve our comments for later.
[30:44] Do any of my fellow commissioners have any questions?
[30:51] Commissioner.
[30:52] Good body.
[30:55] Thank you, Chair.
[30:55] I have a question for the applicant.
[30:59] So, there were comments about the concern about making it a little more sustainable.
[31:07] And I was wondering if it was possible to phase in or do a hybrid with battery storage
[31:15] or if, because I understand that it's all diesel.
[31:18] Correct.
[31:18] Yeah, these are all tier four diesel generators using renewable fuel.
[31:23] Batteries are something that we did explore.
[31:26] Unfortunately, we do not have a lot of space on site and to ride our redundancy for power.
[31:33] This is the only time the generators come on is when we test them, just like an old car
[31:38] to make sure they work when it turns on or if the grade goes out.
[31:42] So again, the only time those generators are coming on is in the event of the grid going out.
[31:46] Talking with our printers about PG&E or adjacent substations have had zero downtime in the past decade.
[31:51] So these are only just in case, unfortunately, we're not able to integrate batteries into our
[31:57] building program here, just given the site constraints, the batteries that would be required
[32:02] to provide this amount of electricity would take up significantly more space than we're afforded
[32:07] on this site.
[32:15] Commissioner Stevens?
[32:19] Thank you.
[32:20] I just have a quick question.
[32:23] Why three floors and not four?
[32:25] Why not make a taller?
[32:26] Is there like an economic sweet spot between size and height?
[32:32] Great question.
[32:32] Yeah, for us, as we were working through this project,
[32:36] a two-story project was not economically feasible.
[32:39] And so we came forth with the plan to go with the three-story project,
[32:44] looking at the incremental increase from 75 feet to 100 feet.
[32:47] We felt like that was an area that we could be approachable with this public benefit package
[32:51] and with precedent from the project across the street, across Highway 92,
[32:56] at about 91 feet, we felt the relative height would be achievable.
[33:00] We actually have built projects that we have won in Santa Clara.
[33:03] That's a four-story project.
[33:05] And so we, at the time, came forth with a three-story project,
[33:09] but given the relative size to some of the other projects in the neighborhood,
[33:12] I felt like a three-story project was more appropriate,
[33:15] and that's where we came forth with our project.
[33:16] But if you looked at market forces, something much taller would be a reasonable thing for your firm to tackle.
[33:25] And then just can you summarize the benefits this project makes?
[33:30] I understand it has a huge tax benefit to the city.
[33:35] There's impact fees paid, which are standard.
[33:39] You are also making a lot of infrastructure improvements that go beyond the value of what your project is.
[33:46] is that correct?
[33:47] That's correct.
[33:48] Can you estimate what that value is?
[33:49] Yeah.
[33:50] We think about $70 million for the infrastructure improvements.
[33:53] That's between the electrical grid infrastructure improvements for the switching station
[33:57] as well as the water infrastructure that I was mentioning earlier, and really upsizing that beyond
[34:02] our project itself.
[34:04] And then finally, I think you mentioned this last time you were here in the event of a power issue in California.
[34:12] Does data centers like this and the one across the highway provide auxiliary power to the grid?
[34:20] Our company has never participated in it.
[34:23] But a few years ago Gavin knew some during a major power shortage did call around to data centers in the area to ask them to shed load off of the grid.
[34:34] Santa Clara has also done this itself again.
[34:36] Our company has never participated in that.
[34:38] That's something that has happened historically to help prevent issues.
[34:42] Our project is actually on what's considered the transmission network as opposed to the distribution network.
[34:50] So our electricity isn't necessarily competing with local businesses or local homes.
[34:55] And so that program is a little bit separate.
[34:57] And we actually help to enhance the transmission network through our switch.
[35:00] We also provide for enhanced grid reliability down at the distribution level.
[35:05] But conceivably, that could be another benefit, should it ever come to pass? We can't promise it today, but it potentially could be in the future.
[35:11] If Governor Newsom wants to call in us and need us to help out, that's something that we would of course consider.
[35:17] So finally, you own the data center, you least space in the data center, so many, many users are going to come in and develop many different resources and applications that are going to serve us as we occupy the area that could be AI, it could be everything, correct?
[35:37] That's correct. The abstract infrastructure purchases property actually back in 2020, and we'll continue to be a long-term owner of this facility in landlord.
[35:46] We are ourselves a developer of the building itself, just like an office building would have a developer that builds the shell itself.
[35:53] And then meets us, leases out different space inside for for users. Very similar.
[35:58] And then just to confirm, when these type of resources,
[36:04] these availability centers are located near the centroid
[36:07] of populations, it improves the reliability of our digital experience.
[36:12] Yes, this helps to reduce latency.
[36:14] That's one of the biggest things that we'll experience
[36:16] is faster internet, as well as reliant internet
[36:20] to other areas within our community,
[36:23] faster ability to reach that, as well as having that locally
[36:27] in the event of a course of a natural disaster.
[36:32] Thank you.
[36:32] Commissioner Low?
[36:35] Hi.
[36:35] Thank you very much for your presentation.
[36:38] And also for the presentation of staff.
[36:41] I said a couple of questions.
[36:42] I wanted to find out.
[36:46] The diesel generators is natural gas.
[36:50] Would that be less pollutant and was that explored as an option?
[36:56] We did look at different options for this specifically.
[37:00] We do not have natural gas transmission nearby, and natural gas is also used for a lot of
[37:07] facilities to help bridge the gap to the grid when grid electricity is not available.
[37:14] So people will have a natural gas essentially power plant in their backyard.
[37:18] We wanted to lead, and of course start with electrical power from the grid to reduce our
[37:24] emissions.
[37:24] And again, these generators are only there for an emergency, and also do help to provide that
[37:31] resiliency in the event of an emergency.
[37:34] So we're not using any natural gas on site for power generation or redundancy and our generators
[37:40] are state of the art as clean as it gets and using renewable fuel.
[37:47] And I know there's a red a little bit about the issue that I'm going to bring up, but I
[37:52] see if you could talk a little bit more about it. I was just wondering about the generators again
[38:00] they're tested several times a month. Is that correct? And then my question to that is
[38:09] how much noise pollution would there be with those? I might actually phone a friend on this one.
[38:16] I have Scott Deloddy, my RCEC consultant.
[38:22] Scott, are you available to answer that one?
[38:25] Yes, I am.
[38:28] Can you hear me?
[38:31] Yes, we can hear you.
[38:32] OK, thank you very much.
[38:34] Thanks for the opportunity to speak in front of you.
[38:36] A couple of things, a typical testing schedule
[38:39] for these kinds of generators are to our,
[38:44] we test them at no load, meaning they're tested
[38:47] very low load, usually 15 minutes a month for each generator. We also don't really test them
[38:55] that more than one at a time. So as as Miles said, it is presentation, these generators are inside
[39:03] an enclosure already. So all of the noise is already mitigated by the enclosure to make sure
[39:09] that we meet the standards as well as the additional screening that's provided.
[39:15] Towards the end of the year, sometimes you run the machine from instead of 15 minutes, you run it for an hour to four hours, and again, we do those at one at a time.
[39:29] The last thing I'd like to say is, as far as the diesel is concerned when it comes to emissions, again, we're talking about the possibility of maybe 10, 12 times a year for about 15 minutes each.
[39:46] And it's our intention is to never have to run them.
[39:50] And so far, the data from PG&E shows that in the last 10 years, we would have never had to run them
[39:55] except for this testing protocol.
[39:58] So the commission looked at the testing protocol.
[40:00] And look at what the noise would be, and look at what the emissions would be, and we're below every threshold, the thresholds that the Bay Area sets and the Bay Area Quality Management District, excuse me, sets, and we're also below below the city standards.
[40:16] Thank you very much for that answer. I appreciate that. You committed to 100% renewable but it wasn't clear.
[40:30] It said you could either go with PG&E or Ava and Hayward has chosen Ava as our renewable energy source.
[40:39] What is preventing you from just committing to Ava?
[40:44] We did have a great discussion with Eva about three, four months ago just learning about the program.
[40:51] Very looking much forward to continuing the discussion with Eva.
[40:56] But what is preventing you from just committing to Eva?
[41:00] What is holding you back?
[41:01] What are your thoughts about it?
[41:03] I was looking for a little bit more of an in-depth answer.
[41:10] Just learning about Eva very much so in the last couple of months and working with our energy procurement team
[41:15] and our potential clients to learn more about Ava.
[41:19] Ava sounds like a great community partner
[41:20] that I know has been a partner with Hayward,
[41:24] I believe since 2001.
[41:25] And so a great community partner
[41:27] and one that I know a lot of the profits from Ava
[41:30] do stay within the community.
[41:31] So a great partner here in the community.
[41:34] Something that we're just learning about
[41:35] and just beginning to discussions with Ava.
[41:37] So very much again, looking forward
[41:39] to continuing discussions with Ava
[41:40] and learning more from Ava.
[41:44] I'll also jump in here quickly, Commissioner Low, to add as conditioned and as is reflected in the mitigation monitoring and reporting program for the project.
[41:53] The project is required to use an 100% renewable option.
[41:57] Eva is kind of the typical option that we see here in Hayward, but PG&E, if you buy power from them directly, they also have a 100% renewable option.
[42:06] So from a sustainability standpoint, from an environmental standpoint, the project will be using 100% energy from 100% renewable sources in either case, whether they go with Eva or with PG&E.
[42:23] Thank you.
[42:24] Thank you very much, Ms. Blanton.
[42:25] And then, lastly,
[42:29] I wanted to ask, I believe, and now I don't have it exactly in my notes
[42:35] where, but I believe initially when the project was brought to one of the committees I
[42:43] don't remember, Phil, as Hesper or who, but the discussion was around a $3 million that
[42:50] public benefits package and I'm wondering why did you settle on 2 million instead of 3 million?
[43:01] Yeah, we originally started at about $900,000 looking at the data center project across
[43:07] the highway at exchange at 92. That project was about $730,000 equivalent. Through discussions
[43:16] with you all and through community discussions with stakeholders, we had I've been able to identify
[43:21] areas of most impact and continuously improve that package.
[43:25] With our package coming out of the study session, we're about $1.3 million and increase that
[43:31] up to $1.5 and then in discussions with other community stakeholders as well as the request
[43:37] from Hasbud to increase their specifically to $500,000.
[43:40] We're able to revisit our budget, really dig deep, and bring that up to the $2 million figure.
[43:46] That's where we started digging deep and cutting into bone a little bit.
[43:50] and really the public benefit packages the one time these really gave us an opportunity
[43:57] to help with some of these really key opportunities and we ended up leveling out at about
[44:03] $2 million.
[44:06] Thank you and I did also want to ask the jobs that you are generating specifically like
[44:15] I think you said 41 jobs,
[44:19] 41 employees, and then all of the other jobs that you listed.
[44:25] Will there, is there a preference for a Haywood residence?
[44:29] For those jobs?
[44:30] We don't set any restrictions on any of our employment.
[44:35] We welcome all and encourage everyone from Haywood to come down and apply.
[44:40] We don't set any preference.
[44:41] We want to turn any one away from a great job and excited to work with everyone, but of course
[44:46] encourage, especially people nearby, especially people in Hayward, to minimize commute
[44:50] times, to work in their own communities, to come work on a great data center.
[44:56] Thank you very much.
[44:56] Again, thank you to staff as well.
[45:00] Commissioner Myers? Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Miles.
[45:05] Excuse me. So, one of my, my, my two questions for you. The first one is kind of been touched upon briefly, regarding kind of the decision to opt into a hundred percent renewable energies.
[45:19] Is it true that a lot of those will come from renewable credits?
[45:25] That's correct, we're afraid of fortunate here in California to have a very clean electrical grid.
[45:31] However, some of that power is still imported, and to reach a 100% renewable level,
[45:37] especially with 24-7 power. The sun isn't always shining at night time, and the wind isn't always blowing.
[45:44] We do use carbon credit offsets to achieve a 100% renewable level. These credits are typically used to help
[45:53] subsidize some of those new solar projects, some of those new wind projects, and to help
[45:58] by large acreages of trees to help deforestation prevent deforestation and to also replant
[46:04] trees and areas that have been logged and to help subsidize that. And so a lot of these
[46:08] credits in our national programs and a lot of our clients, national programs, helped to
[46:13] focus a lot of those credits on a national level and focus those as local as possible.
[46:17] Okay, and one of the things I've heard over the past decade pushed back against the carbon credit program.
[46:25] If is there a possibility that it may be expire and if so, what would be your recourse?
[46:35] That's a great question.
[46:37] That's one that I'm not personally able to answer.
[46:41] I think Sharon, are you available to answer that?
[46:45] We have one of our sustainability consultants that was able to
[46:48] participate in the program?
[46:50] Yes, hello.
[46:52] Thank you again for giving me the opportunity to present to the committee today.
[46:57] So for the carbon program, if it was canceled, then we will focus more on the energy part
[47:05] of the, so usually, again, these things are not guaranteed, but with carbon credits and things
[47:13] like that, since the building also look into embodied carbon and other stuff.
[47:20] So these are things that will be explored.
[47:23] So one of the things, majorly the things that we looked into was the energy aspect of
[47:29] the project and the water consumption of the project cool things that will resume and continue
[47:34] to be a factor into continuing the project.
[47:38] While the carbon credit part is more concerned of, so carbon is the embodied carbon can be
[47:46] operational carbon, which is also related to energy.
[47:49] So this also consolidates the idea that if we continue with the carbon, even if the carbon
[47:55] is cancelled, then looking into the energy and operating energy of the building, that will
[48:01] help us also to consolidate and confirm that the energy efficiency of the building is going
[48:07] who was all the resonating of all the ideas that we can put into making sure that the building
[48:14] is energy efficient. And again, all of this also goes with the enmanagement, with the Calgary
[48:22] requirements, and all of the California Energy Commission requirements as well.
[48:27] Okay, thank you. I don't anticipate it growing away except with the new administration
[48:33] and stuff, a lot of things are happening that we don't anticipate, or haven't anticipated.
[48:38] And if we had to, based on the footprint, I know we're limited on space, but would any,
[48:45] do you know of any size megawatt system, or a proportion of that, would fit on the footprint of the property,
[48:51] that maybe you could charge during non-rush hour, let's say, at night and then use harness in the day?
[48:58] So, right now, on the open space that we have, we are on the non-building space for really
[49:03] prohibited, given our open space requirements to provide green space about 15 percent
[49:08] of our site plan is required and we're excited to comply with that.
[49:13] For open space requirements and green space, this provides break areas for our employees
[49:17] as well as areas for wildlife to come.
[49:21] We are solar ready on the roof.
[49:23] We are a little bit prohibited with the space that we have on our roof given the equipment.
[49:27] However, as that space and that equipment continues to reduce in footprint, it's an opportunity for us to perhaps install
[49:34] scale solar arrays.
[49:36] Right now we're a little bit prevented on space.
[49:38] However, the building is solar ready.
[49:42] Yeah, and hopefully the efficiencies will grow up on those solar as well.
[49:46] And then my second question for you is, I see a few of the restaurant owners that are in the area.
[49:54] I asked about this in November, but I was wondering if maybe you could talk a little bit more about the
[50:00] The construction limitations that you're going to impose or not impose on the company, the local restaurants, it's a tough location to have any kind of food service.
[50:12] So any impact that I know over the last few weeks, PG&E was just redoing wires and it really, really affected the business there.
[50:18] Yeah, so you already, you know, have a tough situation with the location and now we're building this, can you talk about how to mitigate those disruptions?
[50:30] Absolutely. Yeah, we're blessed to have three street frontages on our project with Eden Landing production and investment.
[50:36] And with our general contractor hit, we've really been able to focus that logistics plan to leverage investment and production to stay away from Eden Landing.
[50:44] There's a, there's a bike lane there. We have our restaurant to cross the street. And so for all of our site logistics, we're really focused on not using e-dolanding to limit that interaction between some of our larger vehicles, some of our, some of our, some of our other trucks, some of our dump trucks from bicycles from pedestrians from other cars. And this will also help with reducing any street closures. So that those retailers are not interrupted. In the event that there's any time that we do need to interrupt any type of traffic on e-dolanding.
[51:14] It would be done with the help of traffic control measures such as flaggers to make sure that we keep the street open so that people are able to access all the commercial tenants across the street and again really focusing on leveraging production and investment.
[51:30] Okay, yeah, that's appreciated because I mean just one day of everybody driving by saying,
[51:34] It's too much trouble. I'll go somewhere else. That's really painful for the restaurant owners.
[51:40] So if there's anything you can do to really minimize that, that's appreciate it.
[51:44] Okay, that's all I had. I have one for staff, one question for staff.
[51:49] So I was reading today and I know we've all had our comments about the food court, food truck court.
[51:55] And is it my understanding that that will not be part of this situation now?
[52:01] Correct. When this idea originally came up at the CDC, we were envisioning where that might be in the nearby area.
[52:10] We talked about the inlanding ecological reserve parking lot, which is a couple blocks away.
[52:16] Where all the shoreline trails are without that might be a good spot for it.
[52:20] When talking though to East Bay Regional Park staff directly, they thought that that would be a more difficult thing to accommodate.
[52:31] especially because we're so close to the shoreline and there's sensitive species, sensitive habitat.
[52:37] So having an event that comes in and trash and all of that sort of stuff, they were concerned about that.
[52:44] So in response to that feedback from them, that's when some of the contributions shifted towards other things in the area.
[52:51] by pedestrian improvements, additional trees, additional improvements to signage and things like
[52:59] that instead.
[53:01] Okay, thank you.
[53:02] Evan, I've worked a lot of job sites, and I never thought about it, but it must be just
[53:08] an organic thing where food trucks appear.
[53:11] Is there a process where food trucks show up, do they have to get permits, or is it just organically
[53:17] showing up?
[53:18] Good question for any food truck operators listening. We do have a process and hey, word
[53:24] You have to get an annual permit to operate your food trucks so we can make sure that you're
[53:29] Operating in a legal way you have all of your trash pick up and everything contained and but we do allow food trucks to operate in the
[53:38] Industrial area in parking lots and things like that. So if there were food trucks that wanted to come and operate nearby
[53:46] They would just have to fill out an application with the city and then renew that every year.
[53:53] Is there a way to kind of make our restaurant owners a priority over the food trucks?
[54:02] Because if we're flooded with a bunch of food trucks and all of a sudden our restaurant owners are struggling,
[54:07] and we lose that business, I think that would be a total negative.
[54:11] Yeah, honestly, like our food truck permitting program has been in effect since I've worked for the city, so I started working here in 2018 and it was revamped a little bit when we updated our industrial regulations in 2019.
[54:23] We do have some folks in different places around town that every year get their food truck permit.
[54:29] However, it has not been a pervasive program where we would be having significant competition
[54:36] for this brick and mortar businesses, like we have in that inlanding shopping center.
[54:40] So to date, it hasn't really been much of an issue, but I'll say another long-range planning
[54:45] project I'm working on is a business-friendly update where we're looking at some of our commercial
[54:49] code updates, so this could certainly be something that we revisit and discuss as part
[54:53] of that project moving forward.
[54:55] Okay, and is there anything we should say to the restaurant owners if all of a sudden
[55:01] We are inundated with trucks, and it should affect them negatively. Is there a recourse or somebody they could talk to?
[55:09] They can always come to planning again that this is friendly. It's called Business Friendly Hate Word. It's the name of the project.
[55:16] It's aimed at making sure that our regulations, our processes, our permitting, our fairer to businesses. They are supporting businesses in Hate Word.
[55:26] So that's a project that's going on right now.
[55:29] Anyone that has concerns about this and he businesses please reach out to me.
[55:33] I'm the head planner on that project and we can certainly address your concerns as part
[55:37] of that effort.
[55:38] Excellent.
[55:39] Thank you.
[55:40] Planner.
[55:40] And that's all.
[55:41] Thank you.
[55:45] Mr. Hammond.
[55:48] Hello.
[55:50] First, I want to thank everyone for the hard work and putting together the staff report, it's
[55:53] attachments.
[55:54] and to the staff team for bringing us this project,
[55:58] your presentation was very informative and encouraging.
[56:02] I have a few questions.
[56:04] My full commissioners have already answered quite a few of them.
[56:09] What was the most significant concern in the mitigated negative declaration
[56:15] that you had to mitigate and that we should be aware of?
[56:22] Scott, are you able to feel that one?
[56:27] Yes, Mr. Nice to meet you. Thank you for letting me answer that question. Surprisingly, not much. We were not surprised.
[56:39] We proposed many of those mitigation measures. This applicant is the one that proposed to do 100% renewable and proposed to use renewable diesel.
[56:48] and proposed to do the mitigation that you see there.
[56:53] So there were certainly tweaks to the language
[56:56] that the Energy Commission in consultation with the city worked on.
[57:01] And none of that was unacceptable to us.
[57:04] We didn't make a single comment.
[57:05] We accepted the ISM&D because we weren't surprised.
[57:09] And I must tell you, I represent a lot of applicants.
[57:12] This applicant came to the table to work in such a way
[57:15] as to prepare in their application two years ago
[57:18] to the Energy Commission, a hired all of the technical consultants to do the studies, necessary
[57:25] to develop a full mitigation package with their application.
[57:30] I think that that should be acknowledged, that's why we weren't surprised because most of
[57:35] the mitigation was the things we were committing to do because we're good neighbors.
[57:39] I can also add to that as the city is a, we weren't the lead agency, but we're a responsible
[57:44] agency. So within a mitigated negative declaration, basically that means that you've reduced
[57:51] any identified potential impact to less than significant level. So Sequa has specific thresholds
[57:58] that says, you know, for example, for greenhouse gases, you have to be under these various
[58:01] specific thresholds that the city has adopted and that backman has adopted. And then the project
[58:08] test I would identify ways to get below those thresholds.
[58:11] Some of the things were, as Scott was saying, from the design of the project itself,
[58:16] and other things are those items that are listed in the mitigation monitoring and reporting
[58:20] program to ensure that on every topic that's equal to covers, if the project will be below those thresholds.
[58:27] So, sequence and end of itself doesn't weigh.
[58:29] It's a one topic more than others are all equally important.
[58:32] You have to get below levels of significance in all of them in order to use mitigated
[58:36] I get a declaration rather than an EIR, but for myself, when I've reviewed data center projects,
[58:44] the things that you tend to look at are air quality impacts, greenhouse gas impacts.
[58:50] Those are the types of things that rice is service, but again, this project mitigated them
[58:54] below the identified threshold, so there are no significant impacts identified with the mitigation
[58:59] that are incorporated.
[59:02] All right, thank you.
[59:04] Next question in the conditions of approval numbers 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, cover everything from Native American artifacts to fossils.
[59:13] Is anything of this sort ever been found in the general vicinity?
[59:16] And what do you think the likelihood of us finding something there would be?
[59:21] I think Scott, if you could address that one as well.
[59:29] I think when it comes to those things, we don't think it's a high likelihood,
[59:32] But because it could happen, we want to be prepared and again, as Elizabeth said, to meet
[59:40] the thresholds to ensure that there would not be no significant impacts, we proposed the monitoring.
[59:46] We proposed those things.
[59:47] They did turn into mitigation measures so that they would be enforceable.
[59:51] But we proposed those in our application for the sole purpose of just making sure.
[59:56] So I don't think it's going to happen, but we're prepared in case.
[1:00:02] And that's what those mitigation measures I think prevent. Correct. And I'll add here that this project did have an ISM&D, so you saw those in the form of mitigation measures in the conditions of approval.
[1:00:14] But even for projects that don't require the city has standard conditions of approval. They get it that same thing. Basically, if you find anything, they could be an artifact, or something of cultural significance, there's a process that you need to follow to make sure that we're not destroying any of that.
[1:00:28] So that's that's something that you would see in any project in the city.
[1:00:31] Sure, but historically there have ever been anything found in that vicinity.
[1:00:35] I know that the coastline was popular by the Lonees and the ISM&D has some more detail about
[1:00:43] that in the cultural resources chapter it talks about it, not a ton in the exact immediate
[1:00:49] vicinity.
[1:00:50] There is stuff culturally that's been found in our area and we do have tribes that requested
[1:00:55] consultation as a result. No tribe requests a consultation as part of this project. So again,
[1:01:01] I agree with Scott, it's probably unlikely, but it's not impossible that something would be found.
[1:01:08] All right, thank you very much. The last, at the last meeting, you stated that you'd be using
[1:01:13] local union labor and local suppliers to help construct the data center. It appears from the audience
[1:01:21] that's still in the plan.
[1:01:23] Have you reached out to any other local unions besides
[1:01:26] the Carpenter's Union, which quite a few letters
[1:01:30] in the presentation this evening?
[1:01:32] That's correct.
[1:01:32] We're excited to be proceeding forward
[1:01:34] with 100% Union for our construction project.
[1:01:37] So across all the trades.
[1:01:39] OK, very good.
[1:01:41] What is your contingency in your site plan
[1:01:44] for rising sea levels?
[1:01:45] I didn't see anything in that.
[1:01:48] and the report about sea level. Right now, I believe our site plan is built up, I believe,
[1:01:58] maybe Bernie, if you can address this one, or I believe we have our civil engineer. If you said
[1:02:02] you had a lower level, if I saw it. I can actually jump in here. So HASPA has a shoreline mitigation plan
[1:02:09] that anticipates different levels of sea level rise depending on the severity of what happens in
[1:02:16] future. So they have actual maps that identify which properties in our largely for us in
[1:02:21] a word. It's in our industrial area that might be subject to inundation, depending on what
[1:02:26] the levels of sea level rise are. This property is just outside of that. So the base elevations
[1:02:33] of the property are high enough that it's not anticipated even if there was a sea level rise event
[1:02:40] that it would be impacted at this property. Some of the properties to the west closer to the shoreline,
[1:02:45] certainly would face impacts, but not this property based on our latest data.
[1:02:51] Okay, thank you.
[1:02:53] In the staff report, it was said that EV stations were mentioned for use by the public.
[1:02:59] How are the EV stations incorporated in this new plan?
[1:03:04] Where are they?
[1:03:05] We have eight.
[1:03:06] There are EV charging stations that are incorporated for the workers and for visitors to the site itself.
[1:03:13] but since it's a secure site, those would not be available to the public.
[1:03:17] It would just be available to visitors or employees of the site.
[1:03:20] Okay, so there wouldn't be any room for any destination, maybe, chargers?
[1:03:25] No, one of the reasons that the public benefits package included all financial contributions
[1:03:29] was because this site was so constrained at 11 acres that there was just was not space
[1:03:34] for any sort of public amenity to be built on site.
[1:03:38] We'll still accommodate all of the needs of the project itself.
[1:03:42] Okay, thank you. And then in the conditions approval, number 46, and in the public benefit package,
[1:03:50] I'll just be clear are the funds for the LaVista Park and the in-lu fees for the treatment mitigation separate?
[1:03:57] Good question. So yeah, this project will have park impact fee requirements as all industrial projects in the city do.
[1:04:06] that's based on what the building permit issuance date is and we have a fee that goes up with an
[1:04:12] annual inflator every year. So that the project is subject to that in addition because there were
[1:04:19] trees that were removed on site that couldn't the value of those trees could not be fully mitigated
[1:04:23] on site. There is an obligation to pay the city into a tree fund for those additional trees that
[1:04:30] to be planted elsewhere, likely to live as to park.
[1:04:33] So this contribution in the public benefits package
[1:04:36] is in addition to both of those things.
[1:04:38] So it's an extra thing that they would not
[1:04:41] be required to do otherwise.
[1:04:42] The park impact fee, they're required to do.
[1:04:45] The inluffee for the tree medication,
[1:04:46] they're required to do.
[1:04:48] The public benefits package, that is something
[1:04:50] that they're proposing.
[1:04:51] It's above and beyond what is required of them.
[1:04:54] OK, very good.
[1:04:55] And so can some of that money be used to plant trees
[1:04:57] in those neighborhoods where
[1:04:59] They're most needed.
[1:05:00] For to reduce carbon like the Jackson corridor and our neighborhoods that are under planted with trees, in lieu of or in addition to love this to park?
[1:05:12] Yeah, I think my, in my husband correct me if I'm wrong. The applicant team has been very clear with staff to say that they want to make these contributions as general is possible and really trust staff to know where best to spend these funds.
[1:05:28] that's why, for example, the HASPA contributions says HASPA and then HASPA could elect us, you
[1:05:33] know, spend it on the shoreline, Interimative Center upgrade, or on other projects that
[1:05:38] they're pursuing. I'm so similarly with the tree donation to live this department, they
[1:05:44] heard that from city staff, they heard that city staff thinks that's where it would most be needed,
[1:05:50] but that could certainly be direction that the planning commission gives staff that they want that
[1:05:53] we use more generally towards trees and different locations around the city.
[1:05:59] Okay, thank you very much.
[1:06:00] And for my last question, besides your generous public benefits package, have you considered
[1:06:05] community involvement such as volunteering for a adoptive block program or joining in on community
[1:06:11] cleanup events or tabling a Hayward event to show the public with the stack centers all
[1:06:19] Absolutely. Yeah, we are very involved in the communities that we are members of as I was mentioning earlier just a recent example in San Jose
[1:06:28] But we had participated in cleanups in San Jose and looked to participate in ongoing activities here in Hayward as well
[1:06:36] One of the examples of the school district contribution was potentially to help out with the scholarship for the steam competition
[1:06:44] That's held each year to help grow the minds of the future of tomorrow children
[1:06:48] And so just another example of one of the areas that we are really excited to help contribute in.
[1:06:54] And again, that's a starting place.
[1:06:56] We are continued members of our community.
[1:06:59] And that's one of the fun parts of our job.
[1:07:01] We get to engage with the community.
[1:07:02] We get to help out.
[1:07:04] And all of our employees, our future employees,
[1:07:06] we're always excited to help out as well.
[1:07:08] It's very good to hear.
[1:07:09] Thank you very much.
[1:07:10] That's my questions.
[1:07:12] Thank you.
[1:07:13] I have just a few questions.
[1:07:16] The first one is what is the expected lifespan of the generators and how will they be disposed of or replaced at the end of their life cycle?
[1:07:26] Scott, can you address that one?
[1:07:33] Yeah, I'll do my best here. This is more of a commercial and more of an environmental guy.
[1:07:37] But I can tell you that most of the warranties that I've seen, they go for many years.
[1:07:43] I have worked on projects where I know that the generators are still operating and functioning
[1:07:51] appropriately 15 years into their life.
[1:07:57] These generators are modules, so they're easy to pick up and send back to the manufacturer
[1:08:02] and get a new one.
[1:08:04] So I think the disposal would be to the manufacturer.
[1:08:08] What the manufacturer does at that point, I don't know.
[1:08:11] So that's, I'm not really sure on being able to answer your full question, sorry about that.
[1:08:19] Okay, thank you.
[1:08:23] So, is there any scenario where a diesel spill from a generator could actually present a hazard to the public?
[1:08:34] We do have, go ahead Scott, yep.
[1:08:36] Sorry, that you're going to call on me and I was going to say maybe the time, but you want to answer it.
[1:08:41] we're probably going to say the same thing,
[1:08:43] go ahead and head Scott.
[1:08:44] Yeah, we have still prevention and protection.
[1:08:46] We have a hazard and materials plan that we prepare.
[1:08:52] We only use licensed delivers.
[1:08:56] And so they're not filling this very often.
[1:09:00] As you know, we only test them about 15 minutes a month.
[1:09:05] So we have thought about that
[1:09:07] and we have the appropriate catch basins
[1:09:09] and the appropriate materials that have to be on site during filling, and I think that's
[1:09:17] all required in one of the proposed conditions that we had proposed to the Energy Commission
[1:09:23] showing that exactly how we prepared those plans and what we do.
[1:09:27] So it is always possible to have a spill that it's not going to be a spill that isn't more
[1:09:32] like ounces rather than gallons.
[1:09:34] I can also add to this just to clarify and process.
[1:09:39] So in addition to this entitlement application that the applicant is required to get
[1:09:44] for this project, they're also required to apply for a separate fire permit, where they submit
[1:09:50] a fire protection engineer report and what's called an alternate means of protection or
[1:09:55] related to exactly the decil that's on site.
[1:09:59] that that's actually why this
[1:10:00] This project is not just a major site plan review, but it's a major site plan review and a administrative
[1:10:05] use permit. It's because of the amount of diesel on site. So basically, it means that they have
[1:10:10] fire technical experts and engineers submit all this documentation to show how things will be stored
[1:10:17] on site, how the diesel will be handled when being brought to the site to make sure that there's
[1:10:23] adequate fire access and then our team of technical experts reviews that make sure that it meets
[1:10:29] fire code or meets the intent to fire code in the sense of an AMP and our fire marshal
[1:10:35] signs off on that before anything is installed. So we're through the conditions of approval
[1:10:41] of this project. We're kind of enforcing that that is double triple check to make sure that
[1:10:47] it's safe and meets the intent to fire code and it's something we're to happen that our teams
[1:10:51] could safely access the site. Thank you. So as a part of that fire protection report,
[1:10:59] community warning system at all? Is there any plan right now for if there were, I hear
[1:11:06] that there's a lot being done to prevent it from happening? But if something were to happen,
[1:11:09] is there a plan for how, just yeah, it would be communicated?
[1:11:15] That wouldn't be in the technical fire report, but that would be something that we as a city,
[1:11:19] our PIO and in coordination with the fire chief would handle. As we've seen that first, there's
[1:11:25] some like refineries and different projects around the Bay Area that have had
[1:11:31] emergency events. We're that's coordinated that communication about that is
[1:11:35] coordinated through the cities official channel so it would be similar here in
[1:11:38] Hayward.
[1:11:41] So then just for my understanding so it wouldn't be a part of this
[1:11:45] actual plan but it's something separate that the city would exactly
[1:11:50] rather and it's more like rather than having like a thousand different plans about
[1:11:55] how that would be communicated to the community in event of a disaster, our fire chief would
[1:12:01] just be coordinating with our public information team to get that information out as quickly
[1:12:06] as possible.
[1:12:07] So when it be specific to this site, that's just what would happen in the event of any major
[1:12:11] emergency that the community need to be made aware of immediately.
[1:12:16] Thank you.
[1:12:18] So, I saw that the diesel fuel would be delivered as needed and you already spoke to how
[1:12:24] infrequently you would even run the generators really, they're only there for an emergency,
[1:12:30] but is there an estimate of how often like as needed could be like with some of the other
[1:12:35] stack centers that you've developed, like how often does diesel actually have to be brought in?
[1:12:43] It's infrequent. Scott, if you could provide any specifics from our maintenance program
[1:12:47] that we have.
[1:12:56] Sorry about that. Yeah, I'm trying to look it up here and I think that when we
[1:13:00] evaluated the number of trips, I think we thought we were going to have maybe two trucks a quarter
[1:13:08] at most.
[1:13:13] So is that typically because you just need to replace the diesel or is it really being
[1:13:19] used in the testing and it's getting empty and has to be refilled? What we like to do is keep
[1:13:25] the tank all the way full, so we don't use a full tank and then so we top off the tank.
[1:13:32] In case there is emergency we want to have 24 hours of run time available to us.
[1:13:40] So we generally do a schedule and if I remember correctly I think it's once a quarter we top up the tank.
[1:13:46] So it's not filling it from the bottom of the tank.
[1:13:49] And when I say tank, each generator has its own tank, that is enclosed and it is double walled.
[1:13:57] And so, yeah, I think that's the best I can find right now. I'm happy to keep looking and see if I can find the exact number.
[1:14:06] But my memory fits good. I think it was a couple of trucks in a quarter, once a quarter we usually do that.
[1:14:14] Great. Thank you. That's sufficient for what I wanted to know. Thank you.
[1:14:18] Thank you. Sorry. So I had a question about the Gateway Market Project, so this might be more for staff.
[1:14:26] It says with community, can you speak to what that project is and does it potentially include anything
[1:14:32] have to do with a Russell City Art Project?
[1:14:36] That's a good question. I don't know if Jeremy LeCurgo or Planning Manager knows more than I do,
[1:14:41] but my understanding is the Gateway Market Project has been something that's been on the city's road map for quite some time now.
[1:14:47] It's about incorporating signage or public art components,
[1:14:52] specifically that welcome people into the city,
[1:14:55] for example, on Highway 92, coming into the city,
[1:14:58] to kind of announce, hey, word.
[1:15:00] I'm in all the great new things that we have here. There has been talks about including like artists from our community into helping to develop some of the schemes of this.
[1:15:13] But I don't know the particulars of the project well enough to know if that also includes a connection to the Russell City Art Project.
[1:15:20] Jeremy Sardy put you on the spot, but do you happen to know more about this than I do?
[1:15:23] I actually don't know much more than you just mentioned, although I do understand that one of the reasons why it hasn't happened
[1:15:31] Seniors because there hasn't been enough sufficient funding available to be able to provide that.
[1:15:37] But certainly, I mean, obviously community input is going to be hugely valuable as we're entering a gateway to the community.
[1:15:44] And so obviously, you would want to make sure that that does reflect a word in a positive way.
[1:15:50] But in terms of timeline or when that actually happens, I think I'm not quite sure on that yet.
[1:15:56] And I can ask that.
[1:15:57] You can, sorry, just to interject here. Again, if the commission wanted to make recommendations to, you know, shift some of the conditions of approval to maybe make sure that incorporates the rest of the city art project.
[1:16:09] It would certainly be within your purview to do that.
[1:16:12] And originally, this was a program commissioned by the CEDC and so when we visited the CEDC almost a year ago now this was one of the programs that we were very excited to present to the CEDC.
[1:16:26] Originally it was commissioned for a budget of about $250,000 and just given that was back in 2017 when originally envisioned.
[1:16:33] We wanted to bring that forward to hopefully today's dollars bringing that up to $300,000.
[1:16:38] And based on feedback from the CDC, we thought this would be a great opportunity to involve the community,
[1:16:44] or deploy the program that staff had already helped to develop.
[1:16:47] And so we wanted to again leave that up to the discretion of decision makers like you,
[1:16:51] that could best integrate that into the community.
[1:16:56] Thank you.
[1:16:57] So my last question is, if this were approved tonight,
[1:17:01] When do you think you might break ground on this project?
[1:17:06] It's a great question.
[1:17:08] We hope it's possible.
[1:17:09] But we likely anticipate around October, November.
[1:17:13] We would be submitting our building permits.
[1:17:16] We're submitting them as we speak.
[1:17:18] And so planning to commence as soon as possible.
[1:17:22] We are, you know, of course, facing economic pressures over the last year and
[1:17:26] have two years since we began this planning process, we've been facing inflation, which directly
[1:17:30] hits all of the equipment and construction that we're facing, as well as increase
[1:17:34] tariff risk for all of the steel and other equipment that we're purchasing.
[1:17:38] And so, no time to waste, we're very excited to start construction.
[1:17:44] Thank you.
[1:17:45] Commissioner Myers.
[1:17:47] Thank you.
[1:17:47] I just have a couple of quick ones I hope.
[1:17:50] My first one was going to be that same one.
[1:17:52] From start to finish, what do you expect the construction duration to be and what is the overall
[1:17:58] build package price of this?
[1:18:02] It's about 20 months, 20 months from start to finish involving all of the site and horizontal
[1:18:07] work. The development costs have been evolving, and so I don't want to anchor 20
[1:18:13] figure or any number. But again, that day by day is continuing to grow, unfortunately.
[1:18:18] But so I don't want to presume to anchor on any number as that figure is continuing to evolve.
[1:18:24] Okay, fair enough.
[1:18:25] And then my other one is, I think for staff, just for due diligence purposes, not that I don't believe the numbers, but do we, are we finding the same numbers approximately 8.8 million that revenue that we'll receive?
[1:18:39] Yeah, I can start to speak to this and Jeremy can jump in if there's anything that I'm missing.
[1:18:44] We received a question from you.
[1:18:47] We spoke with Eric Pearson, who's on our sustainability team.
[1:18:51] He vetted that the utility tax number seem about right,
[1:18:55] if anything, they seem a little bit conservative,
[1:18:57] because they assume a flat rate for the utility tax
[1:19:00] when often that will increase slightly over time.
[1:19:03] And that's over half, I believe,
[1:19:06] if I'm remembering correctly,
[1:19:06] from the table of the tax benefit to the city.
[1:19:10] For the other numbers,
[1:19:11] we weren't able to verify with our finance team specifically to do the same
[1:19:18] sorts of calculations that generally speaking the information that's conveyed
[1:19:23] in those reports is accurate. Super. Okay, my last thing is senior planner
[1:19:30] Blanton is on vacation. I want to nominate her for a huge raise this year.
[1:19:35] Thank you.
[1:19:35] Thank you.
[1:19:39] There are any other commissioner questions?
[1:19:43] Not seeing any.
[1:19:44] I will close this section of our agenda.
[1:19:47] Thank you.
[1:19:48] And we will now move on to public comment.
[1:19:51] So I know I have I believe 11 speaker cards for this item.
[1:19:55] Are there any public comments on Zoom?
[1:20:01] Yes, we have rainjada.
[1:20:04] Just one, okay. Let's do the online comment first. Each person will have three minutes for comments.
[1:20:13] So, I'm sorry if you could please set a timer for our public speakers.
[1:20:29] Hello, you can go ahead.
[1:20:31] Hi, so I'm one of the owners in that blog that the gentleman announced earlier.
[1:20:38] And our concern is that we have been suffering for the past year, year and a half.
[1:20:45] What is the city of Hayward besides the 50,000 that you guys are going to honor for everyone at the Plaza?
[1:20:54] But what else are you guys willing to do to help us as business owners?
[1:21:00] Because the landlord for that Plaza, he's not willing to help us with anything.
[1:21:05] In fact, he actually raised the rent on us rather than lowering it, knowing that we've been
[1:21:13] suffering.
[1:21:15] So, and the city of Hayward, I have to mention, has been such a big help.
[1:21:20] We just opened a place in San Francisco.
[1:21:22] I have never met a city that is actually on top of it.
[1:21:28] I want to thank Paul and Miles for always being so consistent with us.
[1:21:33] but now our concern is that we're barely making it. I'm hearing that if there's going to be
[1:21:40] a food truck, you guys are going to be okay with it. You know, we want to get as much benefit
[1:21:47] out of the construction you guys are doing and I'm speaking upon all the owners in that
[1:21:53] club.
[1:22:00] Thank you. Okay, we will move on to our in-person comments. So again, if anyone would like to
[1:22:06] Coming on this item who didn't already, please submit a speaker card, but I'll begin by calling
[1:22:12] from the script.
[1:22:14] So, Luis and Draude.
[1:22:22] Thank you.
[1:22:24] Commissioner, my name is Luis Andrade.
[1:22:27] I'm President of the Hayward Integration and Park District, but tonight I come to you as
[1:22:32] Trustee for the Haspa, and we are satisfied with the increased,
[1:22:42] how do you want
[1:22:43] call it the increased amount that they're offering as mitigation.
[1:22:48] I do want to say that the purpose of the haspah is to mitigate climate change.
[1:22:55] And even though this project is slightly out of their boundaries, it will benefit eventually
[1:23:00] or all the projects in the area will benefit from our mitigation efforts.
[1:23:05] So, I think it's an appropriate nexus between this project and what's happening and what
[1:23:15] has been doing.
[1:23:17] We plan to improve the offshore line center.
[1:23:21] It'll be not just for help and space and natural values there, but also for we're going
[1:23:32] to repurpose it or refogus it on sea level rise,
[1:23:38] which is will affect the area.
[1:23:40] It definitely will affect the area.
[1:23:43] So it'll, and we should know that that center,
[1:23:46] you know, pose several thousand school children
[1:23:49] every year in field trips,
[1:23:51] and we'll probably get,
[1:23:53] including from this local area,
[1:23:55] but also the entire area.
[1:23:56] And I believe that we'll be able to accommodate more
[1:23:59] have a program that will be a great interest to not only school children with a general public.
[1:24:07] So, just when I say we approve the mitigation that's been offered and that's full of good
[1:24:14] say right now. So thank you. Thank you, Lewis. I apologize for mispronouncing your name and
[1:24:20] anyone else who's named my mispronouns. Next is Oligario, Guzman.
[1:24:34] Good evening members of this committee.
[1:24:35] my names when they got to use them and I'm a member of Lionel Labor's Local 304 right here in
[1:24:39] Hayward and I've been a member for two years. I'm here to express support for this project.
[1:24:44] A project like this offers this community, the chances start and or further a union construction
[1:24:49] career in their local area. Much like I have and like my brother's decisions behind me have.
[1:24:54] And since I joined the Zine, my life has improved dramatically because I'm certified.
[1:25:00] I train and working. I once felt like I had no options for employment, but the labor's and local 304 were there when I needed a career to start providing for my family. There are hundreds of thousands more in my position. As a resident of this area, this project allows me to work within the community where I live, where my family attends school and attends church, and when we spend our money. All while I contribute towards my pension and provide health care benefits from my immediate family.
[1:25:31] Projects like these show that the labor in our community are proven and trusted partners.
[1:25:35] It's a project built by this community for the same community.
[1:25:38] The exact partnership we need to move Hayward and its residents forward.
[1:25:43] I urge you all to approve this project, grant the permits and break ground so that this community
[1:25:47] are our members and your constituents can begin working.
[1:25:51] Thank you.
[1:25:53] Thank you.
[1:25:55] Next is Alejandro Martinez.
[1:26:01] Good afternoon, chair and commissioners. My name is Alejandro Martinez and I've been a member
[1:26:06] of the labor's union for the past 10 years. I'm here tonight on behalf of the 4,363 members
[1:26:13] in Elamita County and the 1,058 members that live here in Hayward. I'm here tonight to voice my strong
[1:26:20] support for the proposed stack data center and ask you to grant the permits to get construction
[1:26:26] started as soon as possible. This project will bring more jobs and better opportunities to our
[1:26:31] community. It will provide great jobs and opportunities especially for young adults.
[1:26:37] And anyone looking for a fresh start, it also allows skill training through our apprenticeship
[1:26:41] program. When I was younger I had big dreams we're going to college starting a career and have a family.
[1:26:47] Unfortunately it didn't go as planned. I found myself struggling making ends meet while trying to
[1:26:57] Ohio. One of the largest cause next to housing is the expense of owning a vehicle associated
[1:27:04] with the fuel and computing. After years of hardship, the labor's union gave me an opportunity
[1:27:09] for a second chance and I was able to start a career as a skill labor. This general contractor
[1:27:15] has been a proven partner in the past and believes in equitable benefits to all workers in their
[1:27:20] under projects. This long-term project, so close to home, we'll create opportunities for others
[1:27:26] like me who are looking for a way to build a better future for themselves and their families
[1:27:30] providing a livable wages, health benefits, an entire family and a pension so they can
[1:27:36] retire with dignity. We will also appreciate the opportunity to work here close to home and
[1:27:43] maybe I can catch a soccer game for my daughter. It will be my honor and privilege to work with
[1:27:48] my brothers and sisters in this project. I urge you to please support and grant the permits
[1:27:52] So we can get to work. Thank you for your time.
[1:27:56] Thank you.
[1:27:57] Next is Jason Guematato.
[1:28:12] All right, greetings chair and commissioners.
[1:28:14] Thank you for allowing me to speak.
[1:28:17] My name is Jason Guematato.
[1:28:19] I'm a member and organizer with IBW Local 595.
[1:28:24] I'm also a delegate with the Alameda County Building and Construction Trade Council.
[1:28:28] Speaking on behalf of our local as well as the BTC and a number of the other affiliated locals in the room.
[1:28:36] We are here to urge you to approve the staff recommendation of the proposed major site plan review.
[1:28:45] You know, some of the things that we talked about tonight, I was going to try and address,
[1:28:49] but it sounded like there was one thing that was really important to the committee.
[1:28:54] The public, the benefits, the community benefits portion.
[1:28:58] And so while the developer and the team maybe didn't hit the three million as, as it probably could have been viewed,
[1:29:06] what I would offer is that a project like this, maybe there's 400 construction workers,
[1:29:10] you know, the state requires about 20% be performed by apprentices.
[1:29:15] That's about 40 apprentices on this job over the duration of the 20 months.
[1:29:20] If those 40 apprentices works for approximately six months, about 1000 hours,
[1:29:26] They're hovering around $30 an hour when you look at entry level apprentices, that's over, that's north of a million dollars.
[1:29:32] That's a million dollars for apprentices that are from Hayward that can spend it at these restaurants.
[1:29:37] They can spend it at Buffalo Bills, they can go down to Costco, they go down to Target or whoever, you know, they're, however they're spending their money.
[1:29:45] And so while it wasn't sort of explicitly listed, if you would, if you would consider that part, that part of it, as it relates to the workforce in Hayward that
[1:29:55] that will be working on this project. Maybe Miles was unable to sort of communicate it.
[1:30:12] Thank you, thank you. Next is Victor de la Torre,
[1:30:24] and thank you all for allowing me to
[1:30:29] didn't speak this this evening. I am a third generation Lyona that is the labor
[1:30:33] International Union of North America and I've been a resident of this area
[1:30:37] for over 20 years. Thanks to the construction traits and the opportunity that
[1:30:41] they have to offer, I will say what to start a career off as a friend when I was
[1:30:45] 18 years old. Learning the skill says that will help me build a career. This is why I'm
[1:30:51] here this evening in support of the Stack Data Center. Projects that will bring
[1:30:57] much needed, good paying jobs that benefits our brothers and sisters, where careers opportunities
[1:31:03] will be offered to the youth and those facing hardships in this difficult times we are facing
[1:31:09] due to inflation. I am a single father of four and I can't stress enough the importance of being
[1:31:15] able to work close to home instead of driving multiple hours committing. Projects like this will
[1:31:21] bring will allow us to balance home and work. I am extremely grateful to be able to provide
[1:31:27] of a roof over my family's head,
[1:31:29] and fortunate to be able to send my kids off to college
[1:31:31] and watching grow up in the community that I grew up in.
[1:31:35] I will not have been able to do this
[1:31:37] if it wasn't for the construction
[1:31:38] or opportunities provided to me through projects like this one.
[1:31:42] No, I know many believe that this construction jobs
[1:31:46] are only temporary, but I'm here to tell you,
[1:31:49] this jobs are not temporary.
[1:31:51] Construction jobs build America
[1:31:52] and maintain the communities that we live in.
[1:31:54] It's not just a job. It's a career. I am in full support of this project. You have a decision
[1:32:01] to make. And I trust that you will make the right one and get us working once again. Thank you
[1:32:06] for your time. Thank you. Oscar Masari Eagles.
[1:32:20] Good evening. Steve members of the Planet Commission.
[1:32:22] My name is Oscar Masari Eagles. I am here before you, not only as a field representative for the
[1:32:31] but also as a Hayward resident myself in the last 15-plus years.
[1:32:36] The developer, stacking infrastructure,
[1:32:37] has shows a responsible contractor
[1:32:39] in Hayth Constructing,
[1:32:41] which is signatory to the Carpenter's Union.
[1:32:44] Currently, construction in general has been very slow.
[1:32:47] So residents and all members from the surrounding areas
[1:32:50] could benefit from a work opportunity
[1:32:51] that a project of this size can offer.
[1:32:55] Not only during construction,
[1:32:57] but opportunities after as well.
[1:32:58] Also, by contracting being signatory to the carpenters,
[1:33:02] they are part of a state-approved apprenticeship program,
[1:33:05] though bringing many new next generation carpenters
[1:33:09] to start a new career and many to finish their apprenticeship
[1:33:11] by becoming a gentleman with a career that they could be proud of.
[1:33:16] In conclusion, I want to thank you for the time to talk tonight.
[1:33:20] And also, myself and the rest of our carpenters over here,
[1:33:24] we urge you to please support this project and continue
[1:33:26] investing on a workforce, our future, and local economy.
[1:33:30] Thank you.
[1:33:31] Thank you.
[1:33:34] Michelle Swin.
[1:33:45] Commissioner Sincere.
[1:33:46] My name is Michelle.
[1:33:48] I'm here today as a third-year apprentice in the local
[1:33:51] Carpenter's Union here at 713 as well as being a
[1:33:54] Hebrew resident.
[1:33:55] I'm here today in support of this
[1:33:56] Data Center project.
[1:33:58] My union has done a lot more than a
[1:34:00] specific variety job.
[1:34:02] It's built a foundation for a stable and
[1:34:04] to fight life, not only for me, but my family, but for hundreds of
[1:34:08] apprentices across Alameda County in Northern California.
[1:34:11] As a union apprentice, I've had the privilege of working alongside
[1:34:14] highly skilled professionals, learning trade specific skills and
[1:34:17] contributing to the growth of my community and those around me.
[1:34:20] The benefits of large-scale projects like this go beyond just the
[1:34:24] workers that are directly involved, they extend to the local business
[1:34:28] businesses, families, and the entire region.
[1:34:31] So once again I ask you to please support this project. Thank you.
[1:34:36] Thank you.
[1:34:39] Rosalie Aheda.
[1:35:05] Hello, good afternoon. Members of the Planning Commission.
[1:35:11] Thank you for allowing me to speak today.
[1:35:15] My name is Rosalio Heda. I have been a carpenter at North Cal Carpenter's Local 713 in Alameda County for 20 years, and a Hayward resident for 40 plus years.
[1:35:31] I am here today to ask for the approve of the Stack Center General Projects.
[1:35:40] I'm very excited about it.
[1:35:44] I already asked my nephew to join the union. He's a welder.
[1:35:49] The HITT contracting has made a commitment to pay area standard wages, benefits, and retirement
[1:35:57] to all construction workers working on their job site.
[1:36:03] This job will also create opportunities for many residents from Hayward
[1:36:11] and surrounding areas.
[1:36:14] Thank you for your time.
[1:36:18] Thank you.
[1:36:20] Is Hedardo Rios?
[1:36:29] Good evening.
[1:36:33] Good evening.
[1:36:35] I'm a member of Dr. Wal-Local 968 for the last 10 years.
[1:36:41] I'm also a Hayward resident for the last year.
[1:36:45] I'm here today to ask for the opportunity for a stack status center project.
[1:36:49] This project will create a lot of necessary jobs for the residents of Hayward
[1:36:53] and surrounding area, help a lot, and keep a lot of people working during these critical times
[1:36:59] where jobs are scarce.
[1:37:00] These workers can also benefit not only from liable wages, but benefits for ourselves and our families
[1:37:08] So once again, I ask you to please approve this project. Thank you
[1:37:13] Thank you
[1:37:16] David Calderon.
[1:37:28] Good evening planning commission. My name's David Calderon
[1:37:31] I'm a field representative for brick layers now like craft workers local three of Northern California
[1:37:36] I was born and raised in Hayward
[1:37:39] Hayward is close to my heart.
[1:37:44] I look forward to having the opportunity to give a local resident an opportunity to have an apprenticeship program and a middle-class career.
[1:37:54] Thank you.
[1:37:55] Thank you.
[1:37:59] Julian Dodge.
[1:38:06] Good evening, Commissioner.
[1:38:08] Commissioner.
[1:38:09] I am Julian Dodge.
[1:38:10] Project Manager with Revital Electric Group.
[1:38:13] signatory with I.B.W. Local 595, I've been planning on working on this project for a while now,
[1:38:21] and I'm very excited to get some, get some guys hired and get out there and get after it.
[1:38:26] So I just urge you guys to please support this project and improve it tonight. Thank you so much.
[1:38:32] Thank you. Robert Downs.
[1:38:44] Thanks, commissioners. Good evening. My name is Robert Downs. I'm a
[1:38:48] decision with local 342, the Pummers and Pifters, I just want to say you guys had some amazing
[1:38:53] questions tonight with the project. Just address a couple of with some of the issues about fuel
[1:39:00] spills, 25 years in the heavy industrial industry, my self working refineries. All fuel containment
[1:39:07] systems are double contained. So if there is a spill within side generating system in the fuel
[1:39:13] management, it leaks into the first containment system that is the outer
[1:39:19] containment. There's moisture sensors that would trigger all on-site alarm. That
[1:39:24] basically the on-site maintenance guys that are working the buildings, it
[1:39:29] triggers them to obviously respond in those scenarios. So I just wanted to
[1:39:33] kind of point that out, that is something that's a valuable system that's, you know,
[1:39:37] obviously moving fuel oil around a facility like that. So hopefully that kind of
[1:39:43] is that question with the fire code prevention to with that stuff. Looking at their generator
[1:39:48] run times that they were proposing only 15 minutes a month was that correct? Okay. So if you
[1:39:54] look at that, that's only three hours a year. The average commercial generator runs about 40,000.
[1:40:00] On its lifetime span. So if you do the math there, I mean, that three hours a year, that thing will last a long time. So you're probably looking to probably make missing it from not using it enough, more so than having to replace it. I would think in that scenario.
[1:40:15] And then to all the business owners around, I promise you guys, we are tired of eating on the same food trucks all the time. Every job site we go to the food truck is always the same. It doesn't matter who owns the food truck.
[1:40:28] I promise you, we will be eating at your businesses during this project.
[1:40:34] Just, you know, it's refreshing to see that there's businesses right across the street from the project.
[1:40:38] Not including all of the business that you're going to see in the future from the data center itself.
[1:40:45] So the UA, we cover spring critters, plumbers, pipe critters, welders.
[1:40:50] So we will bring a lot of business to this with the job site itself.
[1:40:53] And we urge you to move forward with the project, also along with my constituents and the unions.
[1:40:57] Thank you.
[1:41:00] Thank you.
[1:41:02] And that was our last public comment.
[1:41:04] So I will close public comments and we will move on to Commissioner comments.
[1:41:10] Commissioner low.
[1:41:15] Thank you, Chair.
[1:41:24] So I definitely hope that the applicant will consider using Ava.
[1:41:32] And I hope that you will continue with the talks with them and getting to know them so that you will be comfortable doing this.
[1:41:38] that. But I am grateful that you are committing to 100% renewable. I still hold out hope
[1:41:47] and would love to see the 3 million. However, I definitely feel better about it after hearing
[1:41:54] from Mr. Guamatautel. So I feel a lot better about that. And also, I just want to say, it's
[1:42:03] very, very refreshing to see so many people here passionate about a topic, usually we don't have
[1:42:09] anyone here, and it's great to see you not only here, but the fact that you were brave enough
[1:42:15] to come up and speak, you didn't just say words that were persuasive which you did, but you also
[1:42:24] educated us in ways that all these experts hadn't educated us. So I just really appreciated and
[1:42:31] and encourage you to do that for topics like this
[1:42:34] that you are very concerned about.
[1:42:37] And I would encourage other groups to do the same.
[1:42:40] What I like most about this project
[1:42:47] is that our residents will have jobs.
[1:42:52] That it's jobs, it's revenue, generating,
[1:42:56] and also my favorite thing besides the jobs, which is huge,
[1:43:00] is the design.
[1:43:02] I really like the design.
[1:43:03] I like the fact that the applicant takes pride in the architecture, and didn't just give
[1:43:10] us a square box or a rectangle that is especially with it being something that people will
[1:43:18] see when they come off of the bridge.
[1:43:20] I really like that design that water sort of design that they have on the, I think that's
[1:43:28] third, three story building. So thank you for that. When this project, when we had a
[1:43:35] work session back in November, I supported the project. I just wanted to get more money
[1:43:40] for Hayward. And I think Hayward deserves the best. I think Hayward deserves to have all
[1:43:46] the public benefits that we could possibly get. And so that's why I've been pushing for that.
[1:43:52] But I was in support of the project in November. I'm supportive of the project today. And you guys
[1:43:58] being here just as made me even more excited about it.
[1:44:02] Thank you.
[1:44:04] Thank you, Commissioner Lowe.
[1:44:05] Commissioner Stephens.
[1:44:09] Thank you.
[1:44:10] So first off, thank you, Stacks, for being here.
[1:44:13] Again, this is an awesome project.
[1:44:15] I'm so glad you chose Hayward to make this your home.
[1:44:19] And I feel a little bad that all you folks
[1:44:23] have to be here to advocate for this project.
[1:44:26] I agree.
[1:44:27] It's nice to have people here, but this shouldn't be
[1:44:30] you should be your advocating. This should be a no brain or this should be stamped approved,
[1:44:35] right, there should be, there shouldn't be even an issue with this. I don't think the policy
[1:44:39] makers are understand that there is like an AI race right now and it's really about the economic
[1:44:45] interest of the country and us as individuals. And hyper scale data centers like this make this
[1:44:53] like realistically possible. Hyper scale data center needs two things, cheap power, or really cheap
[1:44:59] hour.
[1:45:00] And space. I don't know why they chose Hayward. I can think of a lot of other places the United States. It make a heck of a lot better space, but thank you for being here.
[1:45:09] I feel frustrated that there is any payment made for a special benefit. I think that sets a really bad precedent.
[1:45:19] I mean, we want the best, the highest quality data center equipment located in the San Francisco Bay Area that provides us the interest to support our future.
[1:45:30] And $2 million is too much to spend given all the other benefits that are coming here, and I think there needs to be a realistic discussion at the state level about how much power is actually consumed by a 50-megawatt data center.
[1:45:44] It's laughable to think that this is going to be supported by any type of renewable energy.
[1:45:50] I mean, that's not realistic unless the state and the country get on the ball and come up with a plan here really quickly because there's a lot of other places in the world that are surpassing this country.
[1:46:00] So thank you for being here. I fully support this. I'd like to make a motion to approve this this item.
[1:46:10] Second.
[1:46:13] So we have a motion and a second. Do we have other commissioner comments?
[1:46:17] Mr. Goodbody.
[1:46:19] Thank you chair. I also want to thank the staff center for coming out and working with our staff on on this very innovative project. I think it's going to be a wonderful gateway.
[1:46:28] way. You know, as you come off the 92 to welcome people into, into Hayward Residence and Visitors,
[1:46:37] alike to the development services. I also want to thank you for the robust work session
[1:46:44] and everything that has gone into planning this to our citizens and our workers. You have shared
[1:46:55] a journey about, that's common here in the Hayward and Common in California, and what struck
[1:47:02] me is that while I am appreciative of the increase in the community benefit program, it struck
[1:47:09] me that, you know, there is perhaps a missed opportunity in that I felt the, it wasn't an open
[1:47:18] process, it wasn't necessarily, there was definitely some partners that were missing here,
[1:47:24] I didn't see St. Rose, I didn't see Cal State Hayward, I didn't see Shabou, Fesco, some of the
[1:47:31] organizations of our very city that provide lifelines to our community. And I, through
[1:47:40] your conversations and through your public comments this evening, workforce development is very
[1:47:45] much a part of our fabric here in Hayward. And I think the missed opportunity is a way that we
[1:47:52] could work the city of Hayward and perhaps St. Rose or Cal State Hayward to some of our
[1:47:59] education institutions to work with some of the future clients and snacks center on AI technology,
[1:48:07] on getting our, you know, working with teachers and educators on AI curriculum or at St. Rose
[1:48:16] with our medical professionals on how to use AI in medicine.
[1:48:22] And so I am supportive of this project,
[1:48:26] but I would like to see our policymakers take another look,
[1:48:30] and maybe perhaps invite some of our other stakeholders
[1:48:35] here in Hayward to build something that's sustainable
[1:48:39] and can grow year after year after year, instead
[1:48:43] of just a one-time funding opportunity.
[1:48:45] I know that we have leverage with leverage funds from other sources and that's what I would
[1:48:53] like to see with this community benefit program. I would like to see it grow. I would like
[1:48:58] to see it expand and include more people to really grow our economy, not just for one budget
[1:49:03] cycle or two budget cycles, but for many budget cycles.
[1:49:09] Thank you Commissioner Myers.
[1:49:13] Thank you, Chair.
[1:49:14] Okay, a few comments.
[1:49:16] First off, to all the brothers out there, one of my biggest fears is public speaking.
[1:49:22] They probably have paid me to come up and do what you guys did.
[1:49:25] And I really appreciate it.
[1:49:26] I know it's not comfortable for a lot of you.
[1:49:29] And you guys really rocked it.
[1:49:31] So thank you for coming out, do that.
[1:49:32] Apologize for the long meeting.
[1:49:34] It doesn't happen all the time, but it's very nice of you guys to come out.
[1:49:37] I'm a card-caring I.B.W. Most of my friends are 595 and I even work for Redwood City Electric
[1:49:44] before it was Redwood Group. It's a very cool. Also, primarily wanted to thank Miles and Dave
[1:49:51] and the whole stack center team for your collaboration with staff and with us and the neighbors.
[1:50:01] I just think it's a phenomenal precedent to set for maybe future builds. So thank you for that. That's really excellent. And staff, obviously, amazing. Amazing work. I'm really excited about this project.
[1:50:15] for the work it's bringing and also for what you guys will provide.
[1:50:19] I appreciate the benefits package and the increased package that recently came out means a lot.
[1:50:28] And also, putting the EV charges, I think that's really, really appreciated from my standpoint.
[1:50:37] I will definitely be supporting this and I still believe that senior Blanton should get a race.
[1:50:44] Thank you.
[1:50:46] Thank you, Mr. Hammond.
[1:50:50] Yes, I like this project and I'm excited to see all the benefits little bring to this community.
[1:51:00] The benefits package is generous and will go a long way to help different aspects of the city.
[1:51:08] The project will replace a property in the industrial park that's struggling with lease vacancies.
[1:51:16] With a project will be a future benefit to the city of Hayward, technology, revenue, and community commitment.
[1:51:24] In general, I'm pleased with the design and I appreciate the different architectural elements incorporated in the design as seen from every side.
[1:51:32] I maybe I'm not 100% on board with the screening and I'd like to see potential mural opportunities for local artists in combination with the proposed screen wall as a condition of approval.
[1:51:44] Being this, this will be the tallest building in the industrial park and that will be viewed from a distance from all directions.
[1:51:51] I hope that every effort has been made in developing the final design that would create a building that the city of Haywood can be proud of.
[1:51:58] It will serve as an example for future similar developments.
[1:52:03] I'm very excited about this project.
[1:52:06] Thank you.
[1:52:09] Thank you.
[1:52:11] So I just also wanted to echo Commissioner Lowe's comments,
[1:52:15] thanking everyone who made a public comment.
[1:52:19] Just the amount of information that we all got from you,
[1:52:22] that was not the same information that we already received.
[1:52:24] It's just very appreciate it.
[1:52:26] Thank you all for being here.
[1:52:27] It is so exciting to see people involved and engaged.
[1:52:33] So yes, hope that we do see more of that.
[1:52:36] And then, one is to thank the applicant.
[1:52:39] I really do think that the amount of engagement
[1:52:43] that I feel like we had with you and just
[1:52:45] seeing the responsiveness that you had.
[1:52:48] So the community and even the way that you answer
[1:52:50] our questions, I just really appreciate that.
[1:52:52] I do appreciate what I thought
[1:52:54] was a significant increase in the public benefits package, even though I may have been one of
[1:52:59] the people who suggested it even higher amount previously with that negotiation, right?
[1:53:04] So I appreciate where you ended up with it and all the things that you added.
[1:53:08] I appreciate your investment in Union Labor and then here in that's going to be 100% Union
[1:53:13] Labor is really exciting.
[1:53:15] I appreciate that you like name that the design will be on all sides of the building, not just
[1:53:19] front facing portion. That's really great too. And then finally appreciation to staff
[1:53:25] and senior planner. Senior planner, Blanton, especially for being here. And so I do
[1:53:32] want to see if there could be maybe a friendly amendment to the motion. I do really want
[1:53:37] to make sure that the Russell City Art Project is a part of that Gateway Marker project.
[1:53:43] And so just adding in some language around that is a condition is that something that we
[1:53:48] potentially do and so I'm asking you commissioner Stevens if that's something that you would be
[1:53:53] I'm in a little too. I am with the caveat that I don't accept and appreciate the use of funds,
[1:54:01] which is always clear that on the record I do not believe that staff should have to pay any special
[1:54:06] benefit that I recognize your comment. Thank you. I appreciate that. Do we can we have a second on the
[1:54:21] And then just to check, Commissioner Hammond, you actually mentioned something about a mural, were you suggesting that as a friendly amendment, as well, or you just, I'm saying that something that you usually want on the record.
[1:54:34] So then that would be directed to.
[1:54:37] Mr. Stephens, as well.
[1:54:40] So I appreciate the intent of that.
[1:54:43] I do not agree with that, because as I previously
[1:54:46] said in November, that a data center
[1:54:49] is part of the base infrastructure of our society
[1:54:53] and the electrical generation is a key component of that.
[1:54:56] I don't think it should be screened.
[1:54:59] I understand.
[1:55:00] I understand the benefit of any aesthetic quality of what you've created, but I fundamentally disagree
[1:55:07] that it should be screened. I don't know how you handle that. I appreciate what your comment is,
[1:55:11] but for this purpose and what we're trying to achieve and the fundamental basis that our society
[1:55:21] and the economic success of all of us thrive on the future of AI. I think we have to get real about things
[1:55:28] and we can't cover things up.
[1:55:31] Thank you.
[1:55:31] So I think how we've received from that
[1:55:33] is that we do have a motion on the floor
[1:55:34] with a second, so it stands as you have stated it
[1:55:38] and we can vote and if the vote doesn't pass
[1:55:40] and you could propose a new motion
[1:55:42] that includes your piece.
[1:55:44] So with that, Ms. Allen, could we have a vote on the motion?
[1:55:50] Commissioner Franco Cawson, absent.
[1:55:53] Commissioner's good.
[1:55:53] Can we have more discussion?
[1:55:59] What is the motion?
[1:56:02] So the motion and amendment.
[1:56:05] So commissioner Stevens originally just motion for approval.
[1:56:09] The amendment that I gave was that I would like to see Russell city art project
[1:56:13] included in the gateway marker funding specifically.
[1:56:18] It's because it's something that I actually talked about in the last meeting
[1:56:20] and so staff was unclear whether that is a part of it or not.
[1:56:23] So I would definitely like to see it there.
[1:56:25] So that is the motion on the floor.
[1:56:31] Are we okay to vote or do?
[1:56:33] Okay, sorry.
[1:56:33] It's a commissioner.
[1:56:34] I'm sorry.
[1:56:35] Ms. Allen.
[1:56:36] Could you please call roll.
[1:56:38] Commissioner Franco Cawson, absent.
[1:56:41] Commissioner Goodbody.
[1:56:42] Yes.
[1:56:43] Commissioner Hammond?
[1:56:45] Yes.
[1:56:46] Commissioner Low.
[1:56:48] Yes.
[1:56:49] Commissioner Myers.
[1:56:51] Yes.
[1:56:51] And one quick thing.
[1:56:52] When I said brothers, I met brothers and sisters
[1:56:54] because I remember there was a couple out there.
[1:56:56] So thank you.
[1:56:58] Commissioner Stevens?
[1:57:00] Yes.
[1:57:01] Chair Hardy.
[1:57:02] Yes.
[1:57:03] The motion passes.
[1:57:05] Thank you all.
[1:57:11] All right.
[1:57:24] We would like to take like a one-minute break if that's okay before we move on.
[1:57:29] Two minutes.
[1:57:31] The break.
[1:57:32] And we are moving on to agenda item number two.
[1:57:37] For this item, the planning commission may make a recommendation to city council.
[1:57:42] Item number 2, PH-25-020, it's a public hearing for a proposed zoning text amendment, conditional
[1:57:50] use permit and site plan review, so allow drive-thru's and the air terminal commercial
[1:57:56] district, and construction of a Starbucks coffee shop with drive-thru as part of a new
[1:58:02] two-story mixed use development on a vacant portion of the property located at 22101,
[1:58:09] This very embole of art adjacent to the home to sweets by Hilton Hotel and the finding that
[1:58:15] the proposed zoning text amendment and mixed use development are exempt from the California
[1:58:20] Environmental Quality Act or Sequa.
[1:58:23] The staff have a presentation for this item.
[1:58:26] I do, yes.
[1:58:26] Thank you, Chair Hardy.
[1:58:29] Steve Koalski, senior planner.
[1:58:31] And this is an application for a small number of amendments to the zoning ordinance along with
[1:58:38] a company and conditional use permit, which I'm going to say I'm going to refer to as a
[1:58:43] CUP from here on out, and site plan review application for a new mixed use development
[1:58:48] featuring a Starbucks drive-through coffee shop on a vacant portion of the property at
[1:58:54] 221-01 has barium boulevard.
[1:58:58] All zoning ordinance text amendments require review by the Planning Commission and final
[1:59:04] approval or denial by the city council.
[1:59:07] The CUP and Site Plan review hinge upon the approval of the zoning text amendments, so if the amendments are not ultimately approved by the council, then the Starbucks drive through would not be allowed to be built.
[1:59:23] In January 2019, the applicants who are here in the audience site obtained Site Plan review approval to construct the home to suites by Hilton Hotel on the subject property.
[1:59:35] Along with a small multi-tenant commercial building where the mixed use development is now being proposed.
[1:59:42] In early 2022, while getting ready to build the hotel project, the applicant informed staff
[1:59:48] that the multi-tenant building was no longer economically viable at the site,
[1:59:53] and asked if it could be replaced with a new Starbucks drive-through.
[1:59:57] staff presented this idea to the council.
[2:00:00] Economic Development Committee in April 2022, at which time the committee expressed support for the idea, but with the caveat that it'd be part of a mixed use development to make better, more efficient use of the site.
[2:00:14] So, in March of 2024, the applicant submitted the application to amend the zoning ordinance, and obtain approval of a CUP and site plan review for a mixed use project with the Starbucks on the ground floor, and for small office suites on the site.
[2:00:33] This is an aerial photo of the site as you can see the subject property is the part that is kind of highlighted in a yellow color outlined in red.
[2:00:43] As you can see, when the applicant completed the construction of the hotel, he constructed all the necessary parking landscaping and utility connection improvements for the site in anticipation of its eventual development.
[2:00:56] And this was all just done a couple of years, a couple of years ago.
[2:00:59] The site is 1.76 acres in size and has the vehicular access via existing driveways along
[2:01:07] hasperian Boulevard and SkyWest Drive.
[2:01:11] It shares parking with both the hotel to the south, and this large rectangular white building
[2:01:17] is the hotel that we're talking about, and the adjacent business park to the north via reciprocal
[2:01:24] access and parking easements, and this kind of saw-toothed building to the north is the office
[2:01:31] business park that we're talking about. The site is zoned air terminal commercial or ATC for
[2:01:39] short and is designated retail and office commercial in the general plan.
[2:01:46] The proposed mixed use project
[2:01:48] features a 2,345 square foot Starbucks on the ground floor and a 1,912 square foot
[2:01:57] second floor that would contain four small east office suites ranging in size from a little
[2:02:04] less than 400 square feet to a little more than 400 square feet. 16 new additional parking spaces
[2:02:11] would be built directly outside of this building. But as I said before the site also has access to
[2:02:17] the other existing parking spaces around the hotel and the adjacent hotel and business
[2:02:22] park.
[2:02:23] Two outdoor patios will also be provided and furnished with Starbucks standard cafe tables,
[2:02:30] chairs and sunshades for use by the cafe's customers and the building's office tenants.
[2:02:39] This slide shows the proposed site plan layout.
[2:02:43] Hesperium Boulevard is the street at the top of the graphic, while Sky West is the street at the bottom.
[2:02:50] The entrance to the drive through Lane, rather is directly inside of the Sky West driveway.
[2:02:57] You can see it here.
[2:03:00] And this is to make sure that in a worst case scenario, if there were overflow,
[2:03:06] So, cueing of vehicles, those vehicles would not spill out into the much, obviously, much
[2:03:12] busier, hasperium, boulevard ride away and pose a traffic safety hazard.
[2:03:20] This slide lists the small number of amendments to the zoning ordinance that need be made
[2:03:25] to enable the proposed mixed use project with the Starbucks drive through to move forward.
[2:03:32] There's five sections of the code that need to be amended.
[2:03:36] The first one is just kind of a clean up item here.
[2:03:39] I don't need to go into that.
[2:03:41] But the second one is that is one of the key ones.
[2:03:44] It's an amendment to the list of permitted uses
[2:03:47] in the ATC zoning district
[2:03:50] to amend that the list to allow drive-through restaurants
[2:03:53] and coffee shops like Starbucks and Peats.
[2:03:59] With a drive-through subject to approval of a conditional use permit,
[2:04:03] which would be an approval that would require planned commission review.
[2:04:08] And then the other three are amendments to the general regulations governing all drive through restaurants throughout the city.
[2:04:15] And I don't need to go and these are all described in detail in your staff reports.
[2:04:22] Staff reviewed the proposal for conformance to the general plan and for compliance with the applicable standards for a new mixed use project with the drive through
[2:04:31] and found that it complies with the standards of the zoning ordinance and is consistent with a number of goals and policies of the land use and economic development elements of the general plan.
[2:04:43] Again, I won't read each of these verbatim here on the slide, but here are four goals and policies which the proposal does conform to.
[2:04:53] So, finally, if the Planning Commission agrees with staff and supports the project, then staff
[2:04:59] wrecked.
[2:05:00] Commence it forward the proposed text amendments and accompanying CUP and site plan review to the city council with a recommendation for approval, based on the findings in attachment to your staff reports and subject to the conditions in attachment three.
[2:05:16] If the commission does not wish to support this project, which is an option available to you, then it can forward the matter to the council with a recommendation for denial instead and direct staff to prepare recommended findings.
[2:05:30] for that denial. And that concludes staff's presentation. Thank you.
[2:05:35] Thank you senior planner Kowalski. So at this time we will actually, is there a presentation from the developer the applicant for this project?
[2:05:46] I believe the developer is just here to answer any questions that the commission may have.
[2:05:52] I don't think has a presentation prepared.
[2:05:54] Okay. Thank you for being here.
[2:05:56] Okay, so at this time we'll open it up for our commissioner questions, do any commissioners have questions?
[2:06:07] Commissioner Hammond?
[2:06:11] Yes.
[2:06:14] Can this building be used for another type of business that needs to drive through in the future?
[2:06:19] And will they also need to apply for a conditionally use permit?
[2:06:23] That's an easy one.
[2:06:24] Once the conditional use permit is approved for a drive-through, whether it's a Starbucks or a McDonald's or a Taco Bell,
[2:06:32] if the Starbucks were to close down after a year later after it's constructed, and a McDonald's asked to move in, they would be able to move in.
[2:06:42] There is a sunset period of six months for another drive-through operator to move into the space.
[2:06:49] If more than six months elapsed, then that McDonald's or that Taco Bell would have to re-apply for a new conditional use permit.
[2:06:57] Well, you thank you.
[2:06:58] On the zoning map attachment five, how many of the nine ATC parcels are considering a drive through at this time?
[2:07:07] No.
[2:07:08] And some of those parcels are probably two that would be capable of accommodating a new drive through that's built from the ground up.
[2:07:18] but they're all occupied by existing buildings so something would have to be demolished,
[2:07:23] some parking spaces would have to be removed and replaced. So there's not,
[2:07:28] none of those lots are vacant and ready for a corporation like McDonald's or a talk about
[2:07:34] them to move on to them. Okay, and then would each one of those parcels be required to
[2:07:39] attend its own conditionly use permit for a drive-through or would this be, if approval tonight
[2:07:45] would this be a blanket approval for all future ATC parcels?
[2:07:50] No. This approval is changing the rules for those parcels. It's only approving. It would only
[2:07:56] approve a drive through at this property next to the home to sweet hotel. If any other corporations
[2:08:02] wanted to try to build a drive through on those other parcels that are zoned ATC, they would have
[2:08:07] to come back. We would have to take them back before you further own conditional use permits.
[2:08:15] of the 10% plus tax at the city charges, what does the tax revenue percentage going directly
[2:08:21] the city of Hayward? Economic development director Paul Nguyen, it's probably best suited to
[2:08:29] you. I think I'm kind of quoting you for the previous. Hi. Good evening. Commissioner Paul Nguyen,
[2:08:35] Chief Economic Development Officer. So I understand the question is of the sales tax that a consumer
[2:08:40] pays at a business in here or this use what percent of that goes to the Hayward General Fund?
[2:08:46] Yes. About 1 percent of the sales tax that you pay as a consumer when purchasing a good
[2:08:51] or having a transaction in Hayward goes to the General Fund. So who's the big beneficiary?
[2:08:57] Well, it's a pretty complicated formula, but the majority of it is state sales tax, so the states get
[2:09:02] their cut and then there's an apartment portion of a formula where that dollar, where that 10 percent
[2:09:07] 10.75% tax gets dvd up from the state to the counties and then to the cities.
[2:09:14] Thank you.
[2:09:18] Then what is the maximum I can see for the office spaces on the second floor and with this
[2:09:24] impact parking or pedestrian traffic for employees or visitors visiting the office spaces?
[2:09:32] I don't know the answer to the question, is the maximum occupancy of an office space?
[2:09:38] But we did do a parking analysis to make sure that there is sufficient parking for the parking requirement for an office is one for every 200 square feet.
[2:09:49] And so each of those offices is about 400 square feet.
[2:09:52] So if you do the math they need a little less than 10 parking spaces for the office.
[2:09:57] But there's a sea of parking around the hotel.
[2:10:00] And the business park that is largely available nearly all the time. And this property would have the rights to use that parking.
[2:10:11] Okay. Are any of these office spaces exclusive to Starbucks activities? Are there going to be Starbucks offices? Or are these going to be these to?
[2:10:19] No, I perhaps the developer is better equipped to answer that question, but I don't believe so.
[2:10:25] These are just going to be leaseable, small spaces, probably flex spaces, I'm not sure.
[2:10:30] Jay, do you want to address the commissioner's question about the office spaces?
[2:10:45] Jay push the green button, yes please.
[2:10:46] Thank you.
[2:10:47] Good afternoon.
[2:10:49] All the members of the Blowing Commission.
[2:10:51] I made me Javansai and we are the part of the developer ownership of this site development with the Hilton Hotel.
[2:10:59] And as you know that this is a complimentary to my hotel also, we can have the more gas service.
[2:11:10] We can bring more people from the San Mateo side or these by adding the coffee in our parcel.
[2:11:18] And regarding the parking, I think that is the question, right?
[2:11:24] Well, I guess the question is the office faces up above are these going to be used for star
[2:11:31] buck?
[2:11:32] Oh no, obviously for the other tenant, we have already negotiating the lease with them,
[2:11:39] but once in the report we will sign the lease on that, so it is not for the Starbucks.
[2:11:46] Okay, so another question, another question on the condition of approval number 11 for a separate
[2:11:52] building permit should be required for all signage.
[2:11:55] Well, these spaces will they get their own signage?
[2:11:59] I didn't see anything on the drawings that would advertise their business
[2:12:05] or...
[2:12:05] No, we will not allow them to put the signage on our... on this person.
[2:12:11] So they wouldn't be able to advertise their business.
[2:12:14] Okay.
[2:12:18] And then the condition of approval number 28, the trash and closers, they were required to
[2:12:25] be self-contained with a sanitary sewer connection, but the approved clean-up method includes
[2:12:32] a dry clean-up method with no hose bib, I'm guessing that's so you can't wash the trash.
[2:12:40] that's correct. That's more of a question for us over here in staff. And that is correct.
[2:12:45] That's a clean water regulation nowadays. And back in the old days people were just washed
[2:12:51] and then the leechate from the dumpsters would seat down into that and then it ends up in,
[2:12:57] you know, also in the internet. Yeah, I think we all kind of know. Inclosure is getting kind of
[2:13:01] gritty and grimy. How is it? I'm just curious how you're going to clean that without
[2:13:07] but given some mental extra washing, I don't actually know that condition is a standard condition
[2:13:15] from our environmental services division, but it's, everybody has to do it nowadays,
[2:13:20] not just here in Hayward, but all throughout the Bay Area, probably throughout the state of
[2:13:24] California.
[2:13:26] Okay, just say that we can reach out to an inspector for inquiries, just curious how you might
[2:13:31] to clean that. And then it's said in the conditional approval number 36 all businesses are required
[2:13:38] to arrange for separate collection of recyclables in organics. Does this mean that each business
[2:13:45] will need to secure their own trash service? Or does this mean that each business must comply
[2:13:49] with the three-way separation? The latter. So each little office will have to have its own
[2:13:57] garbage can recycling bin and green waste bin. And then of course Starbucks which generates
[2:14:01] a great deal of organic waste and, but they all use on the same trash enclosure.
[2:14:08] Yeah, they'll still, they'll share the same trash enclosure, so they'll have to be some
[2:14:11] large dumpsters, but each business has to have its own three-can stream like you see here
[2:14:16] in City Hall at the common areas.
[2:14:18] And then, for the conditional proof, for the hours of operation, it says that the hours of operation
[2:14:25] can be between 6.30 a.m. in 11 p.m. a weekdays and 7 to 1 a.m. on weekends. What are the proposed
[2:14:33] hours for this establishment?
[2:14:38] Jay, would you like to answer that? I'm not sure what the
[2:14:40] Starbucks is saying.
[2:14:42] So, requirement of the tenant and the leases, we proposed these timings on that and the other
[2:14:52] mainly business working time to be accommodated them.
[2:14:59] So if I want to...
[2:15:00] We're going to get a drive-through cup of coffee at 11 o'clock at night, would I be able to?
[2:15:04] Mr. Speaker.
[2:15:05] And how late would I be able to get a cup of coffee?
[2:15:11] I think when Jay is saying here is that I'm sorry. I'm our key to be an architect.
[2:15:18] Lieutenant themselves, Starbucks will probably dictate, you know, the hours of operation.
[2:15:23] You know, it's going to be least to Starbucks, right?
[2:15:27] I just was wondering if it's going to be open later tonight or early in the morning.
[2:15:32] I think that's really up to the franchise e Starbucks, what they're going to actually the
[2:15:39] hours of operation, but I can't see Starbucks open.
[2:15:42] There aren't too many of them open.
[2:15:43] There's a little bit of a clock at night.
[2:15:45] It's a drive through.
[2:15:48] It might serve those people.
[2:15:50] Possibly.
[2:15:51] Yeah, there is the hotel there, the hotel, the good thing about the hotel is that it has the
[2:15:56] extra reserve parking, so during the daytime where Starbucks is popular, the hotel has a
[2:16:04] sea of empty parking spaces, so there's plenty of parking, same thing for the office spaces on
[2:16:10] the second floor, I think Jay has one tenant, even though it's divided up into four spaces,
[2:16:16] it's my understanding, but there's excess parking during the daytime office spaces used,
[2:16:22] parking in the parking lot when the most hotel guests are gone. So there shouldn't be an issue
[2:16:27] with parking and as far as the hours of operation for the office space usually even those are
[2:16:33] based on the tenant that's occupying the space of what they may occupy there to meet the office
[2:16:39] spaces open 24 hours, but maybe this might be, I don't know. Sure, no, I realize that for the office
[2:16:44] I guess I'm more concerned about with hours I can get a cup of coffee.
[2:16:49] Being in a main corridor, people are going to be wanting their coffee early in the morning.
[2:16:57] And this certainly offers that opportunity for people to get a cup of coffee early in the morning or late at night.
[2:17:04] If they close up at five o'clock, it seems like it would be.
[2:17:12] I believe if it's profitable for them, they'll be open, you know, and that's really the key here.
[2:17:17] And if the demographics dictate to be open and five in the morning, for instance,
[2:17:21] they'll probably be open and five in the morning.
[2:17:24] Okay, but because, again, with the condition of approval, it does say that the hours should be considered between 630 and 11.
[2:17:33] So we make that's what's already written in there.
[2:17:37] That's what we're going to comply by.
[2:17:38] Okay.
[2:17:40] Anyway, that's my questions.
[2:17:43] Thank you.
[2:17:45] Thank you.
[2:17:46] Are there other commissioner?
[2:17:47] Commissioner Myers.
[2:17:49] Thank you, chair.
[2:17:50] Thank you.
[2:17:51] Staff.
[2:17:54] So, a few questions.
[2:17:57] Maybe for staff first.
[2:17:59] I think I read that the adjacent street.
[2:18:02] I believe Southwest.
[2:18:03] We were going to change that with no parking signs.
[2:18:06] Am I correct in that?
[2:18:08] Yes.
[2:18:09] And that was a mitigation measure that came out of the traffic study.
[2:18:14] As you know, Starbucks drives you can get pretty crowded at morning rush hour, typically
[2:18:19] when everybody wants to get their coffee on the way to work.
[2:18:22] And what the traffic study recommended was to prevent people from just backing out on the
[2:18:29] sky west drive to red curb, like something like 100, I forget what it is exactly, but maybe
[2:18:35] But a big segment of curb right before the entrance driveway from SkyWest into the drive-through site.
[2:18:43] So that people won't just wait on SkyWest drive for their turn to enter the queue.
[2:18:48] Now that means that the queueing is going to have to occur within the site.
[2:18:52] But there's a lot of drive-iles here there everywhere kind of around the back of the hotel.
[2:18:56] There's like a fire lane separating the hotel from the Starbucks.
[2:18:59] If worst case scenario, there's, you know, dozens of cars waiting to, their turn to get in
[2:19:05] that drive, they're going to have to negotiate it within the property.
[2:19:10] That's the reason for that no parking signage and red curving along that segment of Skyways
[2:19:18] drive right before the driveway.
[2:19:21] Thank you.
[2:19:22] It appears like there's not a heck of a lot of traffic there, there's a lot of space there.
[2:19:26] I was concerned maybe the worry was having a long term parking people with RVs maybe that wasn't it at all
[2:19:34] I was just to make sure that people don't wait on Sky West drive and block traffic. Okay, and I think even with the sign
[2:19:41] They're probably not going to listen, but at least it's the sign, right. Okay, and then the other thing is so I use Google
[2:19:48] Let me let me back up. So I am I've flown with friends for years and recently started flying
[2:19:55] for my own license out of the Hayward Airport, and there's a thing called, you may have heard of it.
[2:20:00] The $100 hamburger, which means it's just that's how much it costs to fly to a fun airport and get a burger.
[2:20:06] I think nowadays, it's like a $300 burger. So it's kind of fun to think that we would have something for a destination, for our pilots to come to Hayward, and I don't foresee them coming for a Starbucks.
[2:20:23] So what I did was I did Google Maps and this is a question.
[2:20:29] I used Google Maps and I used their measuring tool and it's a little over I think 10,000 square feet that property.
[2:20:36] Is it possible and does the code allow for a restaurant possibly to take up that space in the future if this was not approved?
[2:20:48] Yes.
[2:20:48] But a restaurant is a permitted use in the ATC district.
[2:20:52] Full service sit down style restaurant would not require a CUB.
[2:20:58] I was thinking the same thing.
[2:20:59] And it appears that the parking would accommodate
[2:21:01] that are ready based on the hotels pre-planning.
[2:21:03] Is that right?
[2:21:05] Okay.
[2:21:06] Yes, sir.
[2:21:08] Can I ask, what is of the Indian cuisine at the Winton corridor?
[2:21:15] Is there a plan for a restaurant there?
[2:21:18] What's happening there?
[2:21:21] Director Nguyen, do you know that?
[2:21:24] It's been shuddered for a while, hasn't it?
[2:21:26] I haven't heard anything.
[2:21:27] I don't know if planning director Lekirko has heard anything.
[2:21:30] Paul would probably, Mr. Nguyen would be the one who would know, best.
[2:21:36] I hadn't heard anything either, but so that's one site where this could, another drive
[2:21:40] through could get built, but they'd probably have to tear down that building or do I
[2:21:44] significant remodel of it.
[2:21:45] Okay, that makes sense.
[2:21:47] And then,
[2:21:51] so do we know how many Starbucks we have in Hayward already?
[2:21:55] I think you figured that question was going to come up?
[2:22:00] I said I don't know.
[2:22:03] So, I went on their website and I counted this would be the 16th.
[2:22:07] Sound about right?
[2:22:11] That sounds a little high, but that might be right.
[2:22:13] They were the answer I don't know if Paul.
[2:22:14] They were the ones with the Hayward address.
[2:22:17] And then I went to the site and I did a map from my truck
[2:22:21] And it showed, this would be the six, I mean, the ninth one within a two mile radius.
[2:22:29] I'm just wondering, is there's a number of sounds about right, because that was my question.
[2:22:34] I know there's like three or four within like a mile, in either direction on his
[2:22:40] barium, boulevard. But just so the commission knows, staff is in the one going out and
[2:22:45] trying to attract a Starbucks, right? Mr. Shaw is, he was approached by the Starbucks
[2:22:51] corporation. It's his idea so to speak, but we're not going to discriminate against the Starbucks
[2:22:58] versus McDonald's versus an in and out or something like that. Okay, very good. That was all my
[2:23:04] question. Thank you.
[2:23:07] Thank you for that presentation. Steve, I have a question for the applicant
[2:23:15] following up on Commissioner Myers. So if a proof this would be the fourth drive through Starbucks
[2:23:22] in Hayward, and at this location there are two Starbucks, two blocks to the north, so it
[2:23:33] would be in the target, there's one target, and then there's one next to the Duggetia.
[2:23:41] And then three blocks to the south of this location, there is one at the Walgreens, right
[2:23:50] next to the Walgreens.
[2:23:51] And so I wanted to ask the applicant what was the, what drove the decision to put a, a Starbucks, a Starbucks drive through rather than just a free standing restaurant.
[2:24:06] Yeah, we went through this visibility and we are the owner of another five-quartered by
[2:24:17] myriad and we have Starbucks inside the bistro and that helps helping the guest service
[2:24:27] in good ways.
[2:24:29] So we were thinking to put some coffee shop near the Hilton and we discussed with the Hilton
[2:24:36] franchise and they have the support of our ideas, yeah, just go ahead with the Starbucks
[2:24:43] and it will be the complementary supplementary to the to the Hilton hotel nearby.
[2:24:50] So the parcel available right next to the Hilton and we approached the Starbucks and they
[2:24:58] really accepted idea.
[2:25:08] Thank
[2:25:11] you. Thank you. Thank you. Commissioner Obama. Thank you chair.
[2:25:18] I could have a moment.
[2:25:31] So at one point,
[2:25:36] we talked earlier about the parking issue.
[2:25:42] The parking spaces and you were saying staff, this is to staff that there are plenty of parking.
[2:25:47] I'm wondering though, I assume, just like the owner or applicant want to have lots of people
[2:25:56] going to Starbucks and that business to thrive, they expect their hotels to also fill
[2:26:03] up.
[2:26:04] If the hotel is full, and the Starbucks is full, will there actually be the extra 40 parking
[2:26:14] spaces at the hotel and business park if they're if the hotel is in use and the business
[2:26:20] park is also in use.
[2:26:26] I'm the architect you want me to answer that
[2:26:31] if you'd like to. I'm looking
[2:26:33] yeah I guess I can jump in there you know because I I design hotels across the United States
[2:26:38] and we we always talk about parking you know from the 70s and 80s and you know when hotels
[2:26:45] you have to look at the Drogaster leave it in the morning and during the daytime they're fairly
[2:26:50] empty parking lots. So the idea is not to actually create more paved surface area in the world,
[2:26:57] but actually to have a little less of it, right? So during the daytime, you look at your typical
[2:27:03] office user. They're going to be there for me in the morning to five o'clock if you can get people
[2:27:07] to come to an office nowadays right during that time period. And the Starbucks user, I would say from
[2:27:14] earlier in the morning until the evening. But, you know, I think the key attribute to this particular
[2:27:20] Starbucks that's different than, you know, the other Starbucks is that are down around the corner.
[2:27:24] The one you had mentioned that was in the target. Not a lot of people want to stop to actually go
[2:27:30] inside Target to grab a Starbucks as you probably know. The convenience of driving through with your
[2:27:35] car is a huge convenience. So if you look at how many people are actually going to park to go into
[2:27:43] Starbucks, you know, for a meeting space, it's probably not going to equate out to, I can't
[2:27:48] see more than the parking that's already provided for the Starbucks by itself. That's in
[2:27:54] addition to the hotel parking. So, because this is what they call a convenience Starbucks,
[2:28:01] it's kind of a third portion or third type of Starbucks that they talk about where you have the
[2:28:12] So, if the line is extra long, people will park and then leave, of course, right?
[2:28:19] But, you know, when you look at the majority of traffic, time periods, and there was a
[2:28:25] traffic state done, I believe, on this anyways.
[2:28:28] But the parking that's already available in the parking lot will be absorbing amount of extra
[2:28:33] parking during those hours.
[2:28:36] So, thank you very much, transferring my question, I appreciate it.
[2:28:41] In the CD draft minutes on page three, Mayor Salinas expressed concerns that changing the zoning
[2:28:53] here would open the floodgates to too many drive-thrues where we do not want them in our city.
[2:29:00] And my question to staff is, is there any reason why this should no longer be a concern for us?
[2:29:09] So, as I mentioned in the staff report there, I think there are nine parcels total that have this zoning that we're talking about tonight, and they're all developed none of them are vacant right now.
[2:29:24] So if somebody like McDonald's wanted to come in, they would have to tear down an existing building and start from scratch.
[2:29:32] And we're well aware that a lot of the city leaders have expressed.
[2:29:40] Concerning about the number of drive-thru's, we're just processing Mr. Shaw's application.
[2:29:45] It seems...
[2:29:49] What am I trying to say?
[2:29:52] I guess it's kind of up to you guys if you feel that the community benefit is there to recommend
[2:29:58] to prove all of these zoning text amendments are in.
[2:30:00] Not all in the name of, you know, supporting another, another construction, another drive through and relaxing some zoning standards that might enable one or two more drive through sometime in the distant future to get built around the airport.
[2:30:15] If I could just add onto that, I would just say, you know, that was a discussion that we had internally about the potential of maybe just creating a pathway more broadly with commercial districts, but that was not the direction that we received from CEDC.
[2:30:28] We were trying to really tailor this request to this specific zoning district, which is very small.
[2:30:36] So that way to your point, Commissioner, we're not proposing to broaden it.
[2:30:42] And, you know, obviously if we're going to change that city wide, we will need some additional direction from city council on how they would like to approach that.
[2:30:50] And I know we did make a couple of minor amendments to that several years ago when it was really intended to encourage
[2:30:56] what you would typically find along auto thoroughfares, like 880, that's auto oriented, and so
[2:31:03] a drive-through was completely appropriate, but a drive-through may not be appropriate in
[2:31:08] downtown where we're trying to create more pedestrian environment. So again, it's trying
[2:31:13] to take not only look at the policy, but also trying to understand why was the policy invented
[2:31:18] in the first place or why were those prohibitions established in the first place. And
[2:31:22] location off of his sparian. Obviously you have the airport there. You have a very number of very
[2:31:27] low number of parcels that would be even, that would even qualify to do this. And even those
[2:31:33] if one became available as Steve had pointed out, they would be subject to the same discretionary
[2:31:39] of reprocess that this applicant would be going through in front of coming front of the commission.
[2:31:43] And so you would have, ultimately, you would continue to have that discretion on a case by case
[2:31:48] But we did have that conversation, and we thought that this was the best way to accommodate his
[2:31:54] sparian, which also is a major thoroughfare through the community, as well as catering to some of the businesses and the air traffic that come in from the airport.
[2:32:09] Thank you.
[2:32:11] And then I noticed in the same report, the mayor said he would consider his position if the applicant built a second story with offices,
[2:32:19] which the applicant has done and provide a rooftop seating and I didn't see that in the
[2:32:26] plans. Is that in the plan somewhere? I don't believe that is there does need to be room for
[2:32:33] solar panels on the rooftop and I think the building frankly is probably too small to accommodate
[2:32:37] a rooftop deck but we do have the two nice and it's a nicely landscaped project if you look
[2:32:43] at the landscape plans. There are going to be those two outdoor patio areas that are furnished
[2:32:48] with cafe table and chair, but I don't think the roof top deck made it into the
[2:32:52] plans.
[2:32:52] Just wondering, because I didn't see it, I just wanted to know.
[2:32:55] It's a good cop.
[2:32:56] Just wanted to know.
[2:32:58] And then does the planning commission have any BTO power, say so, or suggestability power
[2:33:10] as it relates to the architecture of the Starbucks, wondering that, because I'm trying to
[2:33:20] make sure I don't make a comment because I'm supposed to just ask questions.
[2:33:26] But I guess that's my question because when I look at it and as I'm trying to evaluate
[2:33:32] whether or not it creates a benefit to the city, that is one of the things that we generally
[2:33:39] look at and there's no buddy here from Starbucks to talk about that.
[2:33:44] I assume there's a reason for that and I just want to hear what that is.
[2:33:47] I would just say is a recommendation to Council if you want to recommend further architectural enhancements that the Council consider those when they're reviewing the text amendment and the use permit which ultimately would be now pushed to them.
[2:34:03] That could be something that would be made as part of your part of your recommendation.
[2:34:07] Yeah,
[2:34:10] this is a housing project, you guys are probably accustomed to not being able to say very much about the design of housing projects anymore, but this is different, you can definitely request our, our, our, our, our, our, our, our, our, our, our, our cultural improvements if you if you deem that.
[2:34:24] That's very great. I will.
[2:34:27] Um, I think it's the last thing I wanted to ask about was security.
[2:34:32] Um, I wanted to find out from the applicant.
[2:34:36] But if you know or staff, if you know what the security measures will be at this particular
[2:34:45] Starbucks.
[2:34:52] is present also, we have a hundred and thirty-one room hotel and we have twenty-four
[2:34:58] why so and security?
[2:35:00] In the parking area. So we have the full our in-house security people for all days and all hours.
[2:35:13] Will Starbucks have their own security in addition, that's patrolling Starbucks as well, or will this be relying on your security?
[2:35:20] Starbucks, actually.
[2:35:22] And do you know anything more about their security?
[2:35:24] Oh no, we don't require it, because our, for the hotel for the Hilton requirement, we are putting the, and we are also thinking to put the friends around and we are just discussing with their port authority and everybody to how much height we can do for the friends and that also we are thinking on that and planning to put the friends at around whole hotel and the Starbucks whole whole bus.
[2:35:54] So the fence would go around the Starbucks and the hotel
[2:35:57] And the Starbucks should be the part of that person
[2:36:00] Where we will put the fence
[2:36:03] So the fence would just go around your hotel
[2:36:06] No, no, it would be a whole parcel parcel contained the hotel and the Starbucks vote. Oh, that's what I was asked. Okay, so the fence will go around
[2:36:14] And what does the fence look like?
[2:36:18] We are just planning and thinking to put the fence
[2:36:22] with the dancers from the start of the box.
[2:36:25] Oh, okay, thank you.
[2:36:29] If I could just interject, a fence would have to be.
[2:36:33] This is the first we've heard of any such fence.
[2:36:35] So the plane would have to, in the building,
[2:36:38] the vision would have to review that, the design of that fence.
[2:36:41] So this is news to us.
[2:36:43] But Mr. Shaw, did you understand, you,
[2:36:46] you have your own private security around the hotel property?
[2:36:49] Do they also extend their service to the Starbucks?
[2:36:54] Yes.
[2:36:54] We have our private security.
[2:36:57] We will take care of the Starbucks also.
[2:36:59] It's a one parcel.
[2:37:02] Yeah.
[2:37:07] Make sure I got all my questions.
[2:37:09] I'm done.
[2:37:11] Thank you again.
[2:37:11] Thank you again for your presentation.
[2:37:16] Yeah, there are commissioner questions.
[2:37:19] I have just three.
[2:37:23] Has Starbucks indicated that they're thinking about opening this location and closing one of those other ones that is very close by that is not a drive through?
[2:37:34] I have not had any discussions with Starbucks representatives. I don't know if Mr. Shaw has or Paul.
[2:37:41] Mr. Nguyen.
[2:37:42] Thank you.
[2:37:47] Good evening, Paul Cohen, Chief Economic Development Officer.
[2:37:50] No, in fact, we've received a number of inquiries.
[2:37:54] Starbucks is in a pretty aggressive growth mode,
[2:37:56] and they're looking to open more and more given consumer demand.
[2:38:01] Thank you.
[2:38:04] Will the Starbucks have a say in what tenants are permitted
[2:38:09] in the upstairs offices?
[2:38:11] Is that totally going to be at the discretion of the applicant?
[2:38:15] That would be the discretion of the, the lessy of the building.
[2:38:20] The city owns the property, but the developer, whoever the landlord is, of those tenent office tenent spaces would, I don't think Starbucks would have, that's just between them. Sorry, we're not a party to that.
[2:38:35] It does seem that this is a unique design, which was, I'm not aware of any other, like at least standalone Starbucks that have a drive through like this.
[2:38:45] I think, of course, there's some that are just commercial storefronts that have something
[2:38:49] above.
[2:38:50] Are you all aware of a model like this, and just the types of tenants that may even want
[2:38:56] to be above a drive through?
[2:38:57] I imagine that could be an annoying thing, or just, is there been any research into that yet?
[2:39:04] There hasn't, perhaps, the architect could attempt anything.
[2:39:07] I think Mr. Shaw has a potential tenant already that wants to be in the above location
[2:39:12] of all the Starbucks.
[2:39:12] And I think it's really, when you really look at the square footage of it, it's a very
[2:39:17] small, 1912 square feet, that's a very small tenant space, even as a single tenant.
[2:39:24] To the best of my knowledge, I believe that the lease for that tenant space has nothing to do
[2:39:30] with the Starbucks, the other individual tenants, right?
[2:39:34] But I don't really see any multiple tenants going in there, because it would be too small,
[2:39:41] the office we'd so, and I think Mr. Shaw had conveyed tonight even that he has a tenant
[2:39:48] that he's in negotiations with with a full space home.
[2:39:53] Yeah, Mr. Shaw would use mind-speaking to maybe that tenant, is it look like they're going to be
[2:39:59] leasing that end.
[2:40:00] Tire space, potentially, and then what kind of business it is?
[2:40:03] No, he's all he sees, and they're separate in, and non-one, one-dominant.
[2:40:11] Okay, and so it's just someone's personal use office space that they're considering.
[2:40:16] Okay, thank you.
[2:40:19] Not seeing any other commissioner questions.
[2:40:22] Do we have any public comments on this item?
[2:40:26] There are none.
[2:40:27] Thank you.
[2:40:29] We will close public comments, do any commissioners have comments?
[2:40:35] Commissioner Goodbody.
[2:40:37] Thank you, Chief.
[2:40:37] This is actually a question for staff.
[2:40:42] I'm concerned about the over the proximity of all these Starbucks near each other.
[2:40:50] Does the commission have any way to recommend if it's going to be a coffee shop?
[2:40:55] can we make a room recommendation that the applicant look at other coffee establishments like
[2:41:06] peats or blue bottle or Dutch bros, which is popular with the younger crowd?
[2:41:14] We don't really have the ability to select particular tenants, I think, as the applicant,
[2:41:23] and I think is the architect pointed out.
[2:41:26] The clarification I thought that he made was pretty accurate
[2:41:30] in that there are other Starbucks nearby,
[2:41:33] but they cater to different users.
[2:41:35] And so if you're going into Target,
[2:41:36] you would typically pick that up as you're going there.
[2:41:38] But Starbucks like this with a drive-thru is mainly catering
[2:41:42] to those that are in their car and passing by,
[2:41:44] or maybe potentially that are staying at the hotel
[2:41:46] and just want to walk a couple steps without having to get
[2:41:49] in their car to drive down the street to get that cup of coffee.
[2:41:53] So, you know, similar to a lot of businesses, obviously, but, yeah, I'd love to see Blue
[2:42:01] Bottles, but I don't know that we have an option to pick and choose what tenants are.
[2:42:06] I would also say to that what we're really evaluating, even though it's a coffee shop,
[2:42:10] as we're looking at an individual use.
[2:42:13] So, just as we're looking at a restaurant use, we don't, the planning commission and the
[2:42:18] the ability to select what kind of restaurant, if it just falls into that category, it would
[2:42:25] qualify.
[2:42:25] In this case, it's a drive through, and so as Steve had pointed out, this could be specific
[2:42:30] to drive through for a coffee shop, but if there's a, if this happened to close, and there
[2:42:36] was another operator that wanted to go in there, an operator either a coffee shop or another
[2:42:40] restaurant within six months, they could easily do that without having to come back, or
[2:42:43] they would need to come back to the commission if it would be on that six month period.
[2:42:47] My family has stayed at the home two suites and I will say that we had to get in a car
[2:42:53] to go either to restaurant at Southland or a restaurant further down towards the San Lorenzo
[2:42:59] area and it seems that a standalone restaurant would be a better use of the space next
[2:43:05] to a next hotel and you have people coming from out of town. It's nice to just be able
[2:43:12] for hotel room and go have dinner rather than getting your car and drive somewhere and go
[2:43:18] to dinner.
[2:43:22] Commissioner Myers.
[2:43:24] Thank you, Chair.
[2:43:25] Thank you for your presentation and for staff's work on this.
[2:43:29] She's been able to apologize for my coughing.
[2:43:32] So right now there's nothing there and what's proposed is mixed juice.
[2:43:38] I think mixed juice is wonderful.
[2:43:40] I'm a big advocate for mixed juice projects.
[2:43:43] There's currently no real trees there, so we're gonna be adding trees. I think that's a positive and
[2:43:48] Looking at the architectural
[2:43:50] Layout and the design. I have to say I'm pretty impressed with the way it looks. I particularly like the layout and I know the city needs
[2:44:01] Revenue or I know that this would help the city with revenue
[2:44:05] with all that said I
[2:44:08] look at it as
[2:44:10] And analogous, if you're a single person in a home, a small home, and you're looking for a roommate,
[2:44:17] you need that money to pay your rent. It would be great to have a tenant there for the income.
[2:44:23] But what you do as a roommate is you really find the best use or the best person that would fit the characteristics of who you are, your environment,
[2:44:32] and the same which should be said with the city as well.
[2:44:40] With it's possibly being maybe the 16th Starbucks, I know that Starbucks in the past has had mass closings.
[2:44:49] I would hate to have all of our eggs, that many eggs in one basket.
[2:44:53] If they should have some mass closings, you know, who knows what's going to happen, then I foresee a potential.
[2:45:00] I'm sure for boarded up buildings here and there. As I mentioned, the $300 hamburger, I think a restaurant
[2:45:07] would better suit the airport, would also better suit the hotel. And based on the dimensions, it appears
[2:45:18] that there's enough space. I know we don't have anybody wanting it right now, but that's like a roommate thing.
[2:45:24] You know, I wouldn't jump at the first person offering to pay half my rent if they weren't a good fit.
[2:45:31] I know, Starbucks has kind of a business plan of having a lot of Starbucks, and they claim
[2:45:37] it's probably partially true that it helps with climate because you're not parking
[2:45:41] in a bunch of places, you're in and out faster.
[2:45:44] But I also think that they have a overall plan to stifle competition, and I know that for
[2:45:50] our local businesses, I don't want to see that.
[2:45:53] I do appreciate the design in the space, just I will not be supporting this today.
[2:45:59] Thank you.
[2:46:01] Commissioner Lowe.
[2:46:06] 16 Starbucks is a lot of Starbucks.
[2:46:08] It's a lot of Starbucks and to have so many in such a short space, I know that one of our neighboring cities,
[2:46:17] my daughter is saying the other day, a good lord that holds cities just one gigantic Starbucks.
[2:46:22] And I would prefer that Hayward not become one gigantic Starbucks, that's just my personal
[2:46:29] preferences.
[2:46:30] Somebody who lives here and who pays taxes here, I prefer not to just be in a giant Starbucks.
[2:46:39] And so when I look at the public benefit, I see I understand that people would prefer not
[2:46:46] to get out of their cars and have that benefit of being able to drive up and I think that
[2:46:50] a benefit for sure to be able to not get out of your car and just pull up and get your coffee
[2:46:58] and go. I'm concerned though if it's enough of a value add to the city overall because to
[2:47:07] me a value add to the city should be something fresh, new, different, exciting, something that
[2:47:16] draws people. I don't see it as a draw. I just see it as anybody going to work. We'll
[2:47:21] just stop there because it's convenient, which is very different than a draw to the city
[2:47:26] or a value add to the city. I'm really not overwhelmingly excited about it, but I also don't hate
[2:47:35] it. I get the point that people, some people will benefit from it. I just, I'm struggling with
[2:47:42] whether or not there's enough value add to the city.
[2:47:46] In addition,
[2:47:48] I, unlike my colleague,
[2:47:49] I actually do not like the design.
[2:47:51] I think it looks like all the others.
[2:47:53] There's nothing new about this one.
[2:47:56] Like if there's so, I understand the newness
[2:47:58] is that it's a drive through, but there's nothing new unique
[2:48:01] about this one in this company has so much money.
[2:48:05] They can bring something really new, unique,
[2:48:08] and exciting to the city if they really want it to.
[2:48:12] There's the Starbucks Reserve in Chicago that is gorgeous.
[2:48:16] And I'm not talking about, I know we wouldn't build it on that scale here.
[2:48:22] But gosh, it shows how, if a city really, let's say,
[2:48:30] gently encourages Starbucks to make something unique, different,
[2:48:34] something that's attractive, they will do it because they've done it.
[2:48:39] And it worries me or kind of upsets me a little that I am more impressed with the architecture of a data center than I am with the architecture of the Starbucks.
[2:48:52] So from my standpoint, I'm just not 100% convinced of the value add to the city.
[2:49:04] Commissioner Stevens.
[2:49:08] Thank you. So when when we started this exercise because there were some questions, I thought I would run a little AI test and I thought I'd ask my friends and AI about
[2:49:21] about Starbucks in Hayward, and this is not the free version, this is the paid version,
[2:49:28] and this is the deep research version. So it took about 15 minutes to come up with this
[2:49:33] market research analysis. So there are 10 Starbucks that are company owned, and there are
[2:49:40] four that are part of a grocery store or something else. There's 14 Starbucks in Hayward.
[2:49:48] And if you look at the national averages, right now, if another Starbucks goes in, they'll probably be a higher concentrate.
[2:50:04] I think this makes a really good point about Starbucks's strategy about concentrating in high traffic areas of high commute areas.
[2:50:15] And if we think about how this site is in the city, and we think about his very mobile part as a principal commute corridor, and it is near the Hayward Airport, to me, the concentration of Starbucks in this location makes reasonable business sense.
[2:50:29] This is a free economy that we live in, if Starbucks wants to make the investment here, I think it makes perfect sense, so I complete support of this initiative.
[2:50:43] Thank you.
[2:50:45] Commissioner Hammond?
[2:50:48] Yes.
[2:50:49] So it's a very interesting conversation.
[2:50:50] And so in general, I am all for approving changes in the tax amendments and in the
[2:51:01] conditionally use permit and changing for the zoning.
[2:51:07] Maybe I'm a little bit concerned about having a star buck, but again, it is a free market
[2:51:14] economy and if Starbucks, things that they can make and go at it in another location, I guess
[2:51:23] that's all they're right, if I can tell, nobody else has come up forward to do something
[2:51:30] with that piece of property. I do like that piece of property or the fact that they would
[2:51:35] be putting something like this on that piece of property. I like that it's a mixed use. It's
[2:51:42] good use for the site. Even though there are already two other Starbucks in the vicinity,
[2:51:48] I believe that this location probably serves the community a little bit better than the one
[2:51:54] that's located at Target or the one on, close to it on Winton, in that it would have a better
[2:52:03] seating capacity, maybe a little bit more of an atmosphere, to have your coffee and also I think that
[2:52:11] drive through is, is a good idea for that, for the corridor.
[2:52:18] So I would have to say that I'm probably in favor of it, even though I would maybe
[2:52:26] like to see perhaps some other competition come in and make a go at it.
[2:52:33] But nobody that I've talked you so far has given me any reason to think that they wouldn't
[2:52:41] want another Starbucks.
[2:52:43] So anyway, those are my comments.
[2:52:48] Thank you.
[2:52:49] And I will just add my comments as well.
[2:52:53] So I want to see the hotel be successful.
[2:52:57] This is something that the hotel owner feels is going to keep that business thriving.
[2:53:04] and we won't see that shut down. I feel like that is a consideration also for public benefit.
[2:53:10] I see this as a model similar to the Fairfield and in sweet Starbucks drive through that's down
[2:53:15] on industrial boulevard seems to always be busy. It's near a hotel, it's near the freeway.
[2:53:22] So I could see how these would work being next to each other, not just a necessarily a sit-down
[2:53:28] restaurant. I also just want to point out that there are two vacant restaurants really close by.
[2:53:33] we talked about the Raja Indian cuisine on Witten,
[2:53:38] which seems that it's not open anymore.
[2:53:40] It says it's temporarily closed,
[2:53:41] but I haven't seen it open in a very long time.
[2:53:44] And then the elephant bar at Southland Mall,
[2:53:45] that building has been there vacant for,
[2:53:47] I believe, years now.
[2:53:50] So I'm concerned that if we don't do this
[2:53:52] because we're holding out for a sit-down restaurant
[2:53:54] that we may just end up having nothing there with the hotel
[2:53:58] and that could impact the hotel.
[2:54:01] And we want to keep the hotel
[2:54:02] have that be thriving as well. I do agree that that's a lot of Starbucks. I actually do
[2:54:07] think that this is a better location. Also, Mr. Hammond said, then definitely, I mean,
[2:54:14] the one in the target, that serves a different purpose with the standalone one next to the
[2:54:18] Walgreens. I suspect many people who currently go to that one maybe going to this one if it's
[2:54:22] approved. And then we would have to see if Starbucks actually keeps that open as well. So that
[2:54:27] maybe something more to think about, like, the potential of, even though they're in a growth
[2:54:32] model, like, is there really supply in the man that necessitates another one?
[2:54:37] If there is, then it'll be fine, but that's yet to be seen.
[2:54:42] So, the one other point I mean, I wanted to make was that I really did like the signage that
[2:54:47] they were going to add, even though I don't necessarily think the architectural design is anything
[2:54:51] special, but I did think that the sign that was specific to Hayward was a nice touch.
[2:54:57] And those are my comments.
[2:55:00] Are there any other commissioner comments?
[2:55:03] Commissioner Myers?
[2:55:04] Well, thank you.
[2:55:05] The only things I hadn't mentioned earlier were, I'm concerned with a small square footage of the four units on top if it's not taken by one person.
[2:55:15] You're probably looking at somebody with little capital, maybe start up starting the wrong little business.
[2:55:19] And there's probably going to be a lot of turnaround, I fear, and maybe possibly some boarded up windows.
[2:55:24] And if it does overtake this Starbucks, if it does overtake one of the other Walgreens, now we have that vacancy there.
[2:55:30] So that was the other trepidations that I had.
[2:55:33] Thank you.
[2:55:35] Commissioner Hammond?
[2:55:37] Yes.
[2:55:37] Just a couple more comments.
[2:55:39] I did want to say that I appreciate the thought given to the landscaping and the trees and to the separation of the trash.
[2:55:46] But to echo the concerns of previous meetings, I'm concerned about the traffic and the litter generated around a drive-through restaurant.
[2:55:53] And that means any of them, although they're included in the condition of approval, I hope that
[2:56:00] after the certificate of occupancy has been issued, that it won't become a forgotten item.
[2:56:09] Thank you.
[2:56:11] Are there any other commissioner comments?
[2:56:13] Do we have a motion on this item?
[2:56:18] I would make a motion to approve this item, and I guess I'm struggling, when I look at
[2:56:27] architecture of it. I think it's well balanced. I think it's integrated with this side, I guess.
[2:56:34] I don't understand. I mean, I'd love to hear what the concerns are with the architecture of it.
[2:56:39] I mean, it seems, it almost seems natural. I mean, maybe I'm totally missing something.
[2:56:44] And I'm usually the critic. So I'd love to hear more feedback about it.
[2:56:52] I think you're directing that at me.
[2:56:54] I've heard two folks say that they had concerns about the architectural feel of the building
[2:57:01] and I just thought that we should put it on the record what our issue is.
[2:57:05] Yeah, I just said what I think I said what I believe which is there are when I looked at the
[2:57:12] for example, just as an example, the one in Chicago, it is unique, it is different, it is
[2:57:18] interesting and it brings some sort of, it's just, it's different and interesting. And I feel
[2:57:28] like this, it looks like it's just trying to look like the hotel to me. And I understand
[2:57:33] maybe that is the goal because it's next to the hotel and it's a part of the whole hotel,
[2:57:38] maybe that is the goal. I'm just saying for me, I don't really think it's the sort of thing
[2:57:43] that you can quantify because it's a personal preference
[2:57:47] based upon what I think would add value.
[2:57:52] So that's just my personal opinion.
[2:57:55] Can I make a suggestion?
[2:57:56] When I look at
[2:58:00] the, I think it's the south facade,
[2:58:03] there's a funny little sign on it.
[2:58:09] And the sign scale seems incorrect.
[2:58:18] says Hayward Aviation on it, is that really, I'm sorry, is that a logo that is
[2:58:24] readily used?
[2:58:30] If the architect could answer that question, I was wondering this thing.
[2:58:32] Yeah, it just says Hayward on it.
[2:58:34] I think there's an airplane flying through it, but I don't know if that's your logo or
[2:58:39] how that came about.
[2:58:41] But, you know, the massing on this is much more proportion to scale to human scale,
[2:58:47] unlike the call center or whatever you got going there.
[2:58:50] of the other good building.
[2:58:54] I mean, this scale on this is only 20-something tall.
[2:58:56] It's almost like a couple ADA residential units put together.
[2:59:01] I think the architecture, too, is not like any other Starbucks that the facade's broken
[2:59:06] up.
[2:59:07] The two-story section, which makes it more of a mixed use look, is broken up.
[2:59:11] The color scheme, these are the ink colors.
[2:59:14] I do a lot of work with Miran Hotels.
[2:59:16] They spend, you know, I don't think three or four million dollars a year in color schemes.
[2:59:20] these are the primary colors that people like and enjoy and they're very long lasting.
[2:59:26] So I think just looking at this as a Starbucks like a one in the mill versus the one in Chicago,
[2:59:31] which I've been to too. This has this has outdoor seating area with, you know,
[2:59:37] umbrellas and things like that. So it's, I think, you know, I appeal with the landscaping,
[2:59:42] the facade broken off so much. I don't think you get any developer to actually
[2:59:48] You invest so much in such a small little building here, and it's basically, you know,
[2:59:54] a 2,000-square footprint, and I think the second floor is 2,000, roughly 2.
[2:59:58] So it's such a small footprint.
[3:00:00] It's a blink of an eye as you drive by, right? So say at the end of the day, you know, between the color schemes and the architectural facade, it's not anything like, well, the color schemes are probably very close to other Starbucks stores, but ideally here, I think the architecture went above and beyond what your typical developer would do. And the cost per square foot is probably, you know, higher than your call center, you're doing down the road.
[3:00:28] because the amount of small scale that this is at the cost for construction is very high.
[3:00:34] So I think, you know, Mr. Shaw, of course, put in a lot of extra effort here and money into this design to get it to be appealing.
[3:00:44] So I kind of disagree with the architecture thoughts here, but everybody does have their own opinions which is good.
[3:00:52] So I would continue to make my motion.
[3:00:54] And I'm still unclear about this sign that's on the side of this building.
[3:00:59] I think this sign and architect can correct me if I'm wrong.
[3:01:02] I think it was just a gesture.
[3:01:05] They are required to do a sign on the building.
[3:01:08] And if this is not what the logo of the Hayward Executive Airport, if this is not the airports logo,
[3:01:13] then our airport staff will inform the architect what the proper logo is.
[3:01:18] And they'll have to put that sign on the exterior.
[3:01:23] sort of clarify that the building is to be branded with the Hayward Air Force logo.
[3:01:29] That's correct. Okay. Then I would continue my motion to recommend this.
[3:01:38] Do we have the second?
[3:01:41] Mr. Hammond. All second.
[3:01:44] Thank you. So we have a motion on the floor in the second. Ms. Allen, can you please call roll?
[3:01:52] Commissioner Franco Clauston, absent. Commissioner Goodbody? No.
[3:01:58] Commissioner Hammond?
[3:02:00] Yes.
[3:02:01] Commissioner low?
[3:02:04] Commissioner Myers?
[3:02:05] No.
[3:02:06] Commissioner Stevens?
[3:02:08] Yes.
[3:02:08] Chair Hardy.
[3:02:10] Yes.
[3:02:13] So I am going to look to our city staff to see what we do with the tie.
[3:02:20] So if it's a tie then it would just be a neutral recommendation to council.
[3:02:26] Great.
[3:02:26] No recommendation actually.
[3:02:29] No recommendation.
[3:02:31] Okay.
[3:02:32] So thank you to staff.
[3:02:34] Thank you, applicant for being here.
[3:02:36] Thank you very much.
[3:02:42] Right.
[3:02:45] So we will move on to approval of the Planning Commission meeting minutes from November 14th,
[3:02:51] 2020-4.
[3:02:55] I'm moved to approve the minutes.
[3:02:58] All second.
[3:03:01] Can we have a vote?
[3:03:04] Commissioner Franco Kwasen, Absent, Commissioner Goodbody.
[3:03:08] Yes.
[3:03:08] Commissioner Hammond.
[3:03:10] Commissioner Low.
[3:03:12] Commissioner Myers.
[3:03:13] Yes.
[3:03:14] Commissioner Stevens.
[3:03:15] Yes.
[3:03:16] Chair Hardy.
[3:03:19] We will now move on to our commission reports.
[3:03:22] Mr. LeCairfolk.
[3:03:24] Do you have a report for us?
[3:03:25] Just one quick announcement, which is that we do have one item scheduled for the June
[3:03:29] 12 planning commission meeting, and it is consideration on a recommendation to council on the
[3:03:35] preservation ordinance update that staff has been working on right now. We don't currently have
[3:03:41] anything scheduled for the June 26 meeting but I will update the commission on the meeting
[3:03:46] on the 12th whether or not that meeting will actually happen so you can plan your summer.
[3:03:51] Thank you. Are there any commissioner reports? Commissioner Myers. Thank you chair.
[3:03:58] So starting tomorrow night for I believe two weekends, Mount Eden High School is doing their
[3:04:04] version of the Lion King. It's at the new Performing Arts Center, right next to Mani and
[3:04:09] High. So just tickets are cheap and I think we should support our students and we're
[3:04:15] going to be there and just recommend everybody to go. Thanks.
[3:04:19] Thank you for that. My granddaughter would love to see it. Are there any other commissioner
[3:04:23] reports? Not seeing any. So with that, our next meeting can is scheduled for June 12th and
[3:04:30] me as adjourned at 10-16 p.m.
[3:04:36] Recording Stop.